DRAFT A- I CONSTJTLITION PUBLISHED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF A COMMITTEE OF CITIZENS OF COLORADO, FOR SIDER$TI(]N AD DISUSI[) BY THE CITIZENS OF THE CENTENNIAL STATE. DENVER, COLO.: CHAIN & HARDY, 414 LARIMER STREET, -I875. -OF A . i.. I t I >i,\ i ,4 I. DVERTISEMENT. The draft of a Constitution submitted to the public in this pamphlet, is the production of a gentleman who, during the whole of the past twenty-five years, and while engaged in the active practice of the law, devoted himself to the investigation of legal and educational sciences, and to the work of legal and educational reform. It is his desire to publish his draft anonymously, because it will thus be impossible for even the most envious "poli tician" to imagine in the author a possible rival for office. The undersigned citizens of Colorado, believing that many of the principles advanced in this draft are of great value, and that the whole document well deserves the serious consideration of, and discussion bythe people, have formed themselves into a committee for its publication. + ~ None of the undersigned are responsible for a single principle or opinion maintained or advocated in any part of the work; the only responsibility they accept, and this they do earnestly and gladly, is the expression of the opinion that some of the principles advanced by the author are of great value, that the whole scheme deserves the fullest discussion, and of earnestly urging upon their fel low citizens to give it their serious consideration. PETER GOTTESLEBEN. WM. DINGLE. WM. C. KINGSLEY. THOS. F. NICHOLL. A. F. OVERHOLT. ALONZO C. MCCOY.' F. M. F. CAZIN. E. F. BOOK. W. C. SPRAGUE. A. G. BOONE. E. J. MALLET, JR. GEO. B. ALLEN. JOHN WILLIAMSON. JULIUS LONDONER. JOHN S. JONES. LYMAN C. BLOOD. JOHN WHITLEY. THOMAS GEORGE. i 'k I NTRODUCTION,. The draft of a State Constitution now submitted to the public for consideration and discussion is not presented as a perfect scheme. To give time for its discussion before the meeting of the convention, its preparation has been somewhat hurried, for it is believed that theprinciples which it presents are important and true, and will, if adopted into the Constitution of the Centennial State, form a marked step in social progress. The writings of the greatest legist that ever lived, Jeremy Bentham-to whom, more or less directly, the world is indebted for every advance in morals and legislation made during this century, have formed the groundwork on which the present draft is constructed. Modifications to 4 adapt it to our conditions, and to avail ourselves of the latest discoveries in governmental science, have been intro duced. The universal favor with which the idea of the Ref erendem has been received, emboldened the author to introduce it into this draft, whereby the instrument itself could be greatly simplified without detriment to the princi ple of the maximization of aptitude and minimization of ex pense. Should the Referendum fail to be introduced into the Constitution, stringent limitations on the legislative powers of the legislature will have to be imposed to prevent the happening of frauds such as those so frequent in the legislatures of the States, by which the people have been so shamelessly plundered. Should the proxy system fail to find acceptance, a well digested electoral law, including a provision for a new elec tion whenever the fact that fraudulent practices have been resorted to in the interest of the successful party shall be proved, will be necessary. -vi Should the principles of this draft be adopted, the chief officer of the State will be —niot a Governor,-but a Minister of Justice. This one feature serves as a key-note to the whole instrument, and places the State which adopts it in the vanguard of civilization. It announces to the world, that justice and not force, is the leading feature of the State, and therefore it may well be hoped the leading idea of its people. Little hope is entertained that the professional politician, or with some noble exceptions, the lawyers will fail to give this draft of a Constitution a bitter opposition. Nor can it well be otherwise. The end in view in this draft is, and at the outset is declared to be, the promotion of the happiness of all the inhabitants of Colorado. Never has the professional politician, never (taken as a class), have the professors of the immoral and demoralizing English and English derived systems of law procedure had any other end in view than their own aggrandizement. Never has the interest of these classes been other than a sinister one. It depends on the people of Colorado to determine whether they Will continue like their predecessors in other States, to be the prey of these classes, or whether the Centenial State shall become a beacon of light, in whose rays the people of all other States may learn how corruption may be prevented and justice-real justice,-administered; exhibiting in the utmost perfection our condition of civilization will permit us to receive them, the latest developments of the science and art of government. After the first few years of experiment, it is hoped and expected that the appointment of the Minister of Yustice will be confided to the legislature, and that his tenure of office will be for life, or at least for a long term of years, unless removed for cause. In deference to the popular desire to elect officers, and of that most unhappy principle of "rotation in office," so favored by the community, the election of or -vii the Minister of Justice is in this constitution left to the Constitutive authority (the people), and the term of office made far too short. A small number of persons, such as the committee of the people formed by a proxy-seated legislature, will be far better qualified to select suitable persons to fill important offices, than the multitude can by any possibility be. The really good men are rarely known to the people; their choice is generally restricted among noisy demagogues between whom there is in reality little to choose. This is still more glaringly the case in the now prevailing method of nominating candidates. In the electoral code, which it will be the business of the Legislation minister to prepare, a system for nominating candidates may be provided, by which most, if not all, of the evils of primary and nominating conventions would be avoided. An outline of the system is here suggested. An election is to come off for any office. To a pre-appointed election officer, a member of the Constitutive authority sends a written nomination of some person whom he desires to see elected to the office in question. If within a given time that nomination receives the endorsement of a certain number of citizens, the nominee becomes a candidate. In all cases the nominator would be bound to give with his nomination-paper his reasons for nominating the person in question. The nomination with these reasons would be properly advertised, so that those so inclined might forward their endorsements of the nominee with any additional reasons they may have for so doing. Reference is made in Art. X, Chap. II., ~ 7, note 2, to rules for the maximization of efficiency and minimization of expense in the public service. Steps being taken to secure the necessary qualifications,-first by examinations, afterwards by service inan inferior office,-among those equally qualified competition will take place as to who will accept the office at the lowest remuneration. -viii How far the "politicians" may be expected to resist the adoption of such a system of appointment to office may be judged from the following facts: The office of County Clerk and Recorder of Arapahoe County is currently believed to yield to its incumbent an income, (legitimate but scandalous,) of 15 to 20,000 dollars per annum. Hundreds of competent persons would gladly accept the office and perform all its duties for $4,OO000 per annum. Prior to the last election, Captain H. L. Thayer, of Denver, offered to take the office at half the legal fees, and on this very account was refused even a nomination by the politicians. He was told his offer had killed his chance for the nomination, because as this office was so'fat" the means which it plundered from the people furnished a fund to the politicians for electioneering! There are various necessary offices, sometimes provided for in constitutions, but which the author of this draft has intentionally left to be provided for by law, seeing that the Referendum will tend to prevent any objectionable measure with regard to them from being even proposed, and will pretty effectually prevent the adoption of any such measure, should such be presented by the legislature to the people. The offices in question relate to the armed force of the state, its police, public lands, finances and education, each of which would in a state with a large population require a special administration. Here, many of these offices may be filled by one person, who may be appointed by the chief executive. Important and valuable as the proxy system of locating legislators is believed to be, the adoption of the Referendum will be so valuable a safeguard against evil legislation that even the adoption or rejection of the proxy system becomes of comparatively little importance. It is to the Referendum and to Art. XIV., relating to the Judiciary, that the attention of the public is most earnestly invited and which they are urged above all other points to 0 i I -ix insist upon. It is against Art. XIV. that the main spite of politicians and of the lawyer class will be directed, and, as it is the most important of all the articles of this constitu tion, as it is the one on the adoption or rejection of which depends the continuance in, or emancipation of, the people from an abject slavery of body, purse and mind, a few words will be now given to a ratiocinative exposition of the system of procedure indicated by and dependent upon the provi sions of this article. Suppose one man to have occasion to complain of an other; he goes to the nearest Primary judge and makes his statement. His statement is to be true, under the like pen alties for mendacity as now exist in the case of perjury. In a small per centage of cases the Primary judge will decide that, on his own statement, the complainant has no ground for suit. The complainant, if dissatisfied, will at once appeal from this decision to the Appellate judge. In the majority of cases, and in case the Appellate judge shall reverse the judgment of the Primary judge, this latter sends to the per son complained of to come before him at a certain time, or, if he live in a different judicial district, will send a transcript of the complainant's statement by mail to the judge of that district, in order that he may summon the person com plained of. The statement of the latter being received, either party cross-examines the other to the fullest extent, either to establish his own case or to disprove his oppo nent's. In a vast majority of cases the cause will now be ripe for decision; in a few, further evidence will be required. Each party is called upon to admit, deny, or require evidence of those points which are necessary to establish his 9pponent's case. The denial by a party of a fact which he knows to be true will subject him to the penalties of mendacity; the requiring proof of a fact which he ought to have known to be true will be visited by requiring him to pay the costs of proving the same in any event. By this means the necessity for being prepared with evidence to prove technical facts which no man with any sense of decency, if put on his honor before the public gaze, would dare to deny,-a necessity which now adds so greatly to the expense of litigation, and often defeats the party who ought to succeed,-would be completely obviated. By the means above indicated, simple cases in the course of a few days, the most complicated (except where witnesses are absent from the state,) in the course of about a month or six weeks, would be brought to a conclusion in the Primary court. Either party being dissatisfied appeals, and the appeal is heard and decided within from one week to thirty days from the taking of the appeal. Procedure similar to the foregoing has place also in penal cases, but as in these the accused is generally in custody, the suit is determined even more expeditiously, with the right to the accused at any time to apply for a rehearing or new trial, on the ground of fresh evidence, or any other sufficient cause. No pardoning power, that constant source of corruption, is anywhere vested beyond the extent provided in Art. XIII, Chap. II, Sec. II, clause I8; but if any sentence be found to be excessive, or any conviction complained of as erroneous, the wrong may be redressed by a rehearing before the same or some other judge. Let the citizens of Colorado contrast this system with the agony long drawn out, which now tortures every litigant, and the chance, nay, the almost certainty of escape at present offered to every delinquent who can purchase the needful delay, and ask themselves why a system so natural and so obvious has not centuries ago been substituted for the complicated monstrosity which now prevails. Under the system here suggested, justice would sleep only when injustice did;-under the existing system, while injustice is ever rampant, the sham justice offered to us by the law wakes up at most twice, and in many counties but once a year! And then after this monstrous delay, every -X 0 I -Xi thing is done in so much hurry that it has generally to be done over again! In short, so great is the expense, vexation and delay, and so frequently the wrongfulness of the ultimate decision, under all English derived systems of law procedure (political causes excepted,) that it is generally far wiser to submit to any wrong rather than pursue the Will o' the wisp offered as redress in the name of the law! It may reasonably be asked: "If our laws are so defective as here insisted, how comes it that they have been so greatly prized, how is it that we have preserved so much freedom?" Two grand features have existed in the English system from time immemorial, which contrasted so brilliantly with the system of Roman procedure which formerly prevailed on the continent of Europe, that they more than counterbalanced the evils of the English procedure as compared with the Roman. Centuries elapsed before it occurred to any legist, that those features of English law might be adopted into the Roman, or the Roman system substituted for the English, with those features preserved. These two grand features were, the publicity of the courts, and trial by jury in political causes. In none other ought jury trial to have place. Other features, such as the penal responsibility of judges for violations of personal liberty laws, and the personal re sponsibility of all for participation in tortuous acts, although committed by subordinates in obedience to superior orders, have grown out of the two great principles of publicity and politico-jury trial, and presented a noble contrast to the systems elsewhere prevailing. These features of the English system, which our Ameri can jurisprudence has for the past seventy years been grad ually frittering away, are in this draft restored and preserved. It is not improbable that the politicians will raise the cry of expense for the purpose of prejudicing the people against -xii the judicial system here advocated. The cry. will be a false pretense, as the proposed system will be more economical than the present. Even were it otherwise, it must be conceded that a system which justifies injustice, as does that now existing, must be abandoned, and if no system for securing justice could be devised except at an intolerable expense, the only proper alternative would be-no law at all. But, as above stated, the expense of the system here proposed would be actually less than that now existing. True on the one side there will be a number of Primary and Appellate judges, and government and eleemosynary advocates,-but against these there have to be set the present staff of supreme court judges, the clerks of the different courts and their deputies, the probate judges, justices of the peace, and last, but most onerous of all, the grand and petit juries and witnesses, more than two-thirds of the expenses of these last being saved under the system here proposed. Cast up the expense of all these against those of the proposed astablishment, and the balance will be found greatly in favor of the system framed to administer justice, as against that which exists to sanctify evil and evil doers. Fellow Citizens of Colorado! He who adresses to you these words and has labored to lay before you the following draft of a constitution, is one whose life has been devoted to the effecting of reforms in the law, which, while still in his pupillage, he saw to be needed. For himself he has never sought anything and he seeks now nothing at your hands. Some among you have already appreciated the fact that he is laboring only for the cause and for the people. But his present labor is most probably his last in this direction. If he can see the main principles advanced in this work accepted by the people of Colorado, -if he can but see one single community adopting justice as the foundation of its political fabric, he will feel his task on earth completed and be ready to say: "Now permitteth thou thy servant to depart in peace." I i -xiii. If, people of Colorado, we would release ourselves from a slavery none the less abject that so many of us do not feel our chains; if we would save ourselves, our children, our country, from the ruin which threatens the Republic from the demoralization of its people; a demoralization, a festering corruption, fostered and engendered by the defects, the avoidable defects, of our existing political systems, while our schools and our churches do nothing to correct or prevent it, we must arouse from our supineness and take the reins into our own hands. He who has labored to produce this work to-day, has sought in so doing to perform his duty; fellow citizens, do you now do yours! THE AUTHOR. I 4 I f i pray If a aonstltlut'ton - FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. The people of Colorado do hereby ordain and establish for themselves a Constitutional Government as expressed in the following articles: ARTICLE I. The name of the state is COLORADO. ARTICLE II. The constitution of the United States, and the laws and treaties made and to be made in pursuance thereof, are the Supreme law of Colorado. ARTICLE III. I. The territory of the State of Colorado is comprised within the boundary lines following: Commencing on the thirty-seventh parallel of north latitude where the twentyfifth meridian of longitude west from Washington crosses the same; thence north, on said meridian, to the forty-first parallel of north latitude; thence along said parallel west to the thirty-second meridian of longitude west from Wash 4 -4 I DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION ington; thence south on said meridian to the thirty-seventh parallel of north latitude, to the place of beginning. 2. The whole territory of the state is divided into districts. 3. Each district is an election district and a primary judicial district. 4. The names and boundaries of the districts are as follows: ,* *, *: * * * ARTICLE IV. ENDS AND MEANS. CHAP. I. The end in view in this Constitution, is the promotion of the greatest sum of happiness for all the inhabitants of Colorado. CHAP. II. I. The means sought to be employed are: a) the maximization of official aptitude, and b) the minimization of expense. 2. Included in the mass of expense are rewards and punishments. 3. Punishment is evil applied to a particular purpose. 4. All punishment is an evil. It may therefore only be employed as a means of producing more than equivalent good, of excluding more than equivalent evil, or of both combined. 5. Rewards can only be given by government out of matter of good taken from others. They must therefore never be bestowed except in exchange for services which confer greater good upon those from whom the matter of reward is taken, than the amount of the matter so taken would otherwise have secured them. 6. Rewards, charges or punishment imposed by law in violation of the foregoing principles will be declared void by the Judiciary on all appropriate occasions. 2 t, FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. ARTICLE V. DECLARATION OF RIGHTS.' I. No person may be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law, after time and opportunity shall have been afforded him to be heard in his defence. 2. Any judicial officer who shall attempt to give effect to any law violating the right secured by the Ist Section of this Article, shall, on conviction thereof, be forever incapable of holding any judicial office in the State. He shall also be responsible to the party aggrieved, for all damages sustained and for $I,OOo in addition thereto. 3. Any executive officer who shall attempt to carry into operation any law violating the rights secured by the Ist Section of this Article, shall, on conviction thereof, be forever incapable of holding any executive office in the State. He shall also be responsible to the party aggrieved for all damages sustained, and for $I,OOO in addition thereto. 4. No warrant for the arrest ot any person or for the searching of any place shall issue, except upon the testimony of some person shewing that some crime has probably been committed, and setting forth the nature of the supposed crime, the person to be arrested and the place to be searched. 5. All persons shall be bailable by sufficient sureties, except on a charge of murder, or of highway robbery with violence, burglary, or arson, where the accuscd has been taken in the act. (I) A declaration of rights is embodied in the Constitution of most of the States, but their provisions have but too frequently become a dead letter, and the dearest rights intended to be secured by them have been frequently and outrageously violated by legislatures, by state and by federal courts, for want of some "sanctions" to enforce them. Such "sanctions" are supplied in this draft. The personal liberty laws of England were all of them fruitless until the habeas corpus act imposed penalties on the judge who should dare to refuse the writ. To maintain and preserve some of the rights asserted in the declaration of rights contained in this draft, penalties are imposed on judges and executive officers who should dare to violate them. (2) 3 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 6. An order to bring into court the body of any person held in confinement, shall never be refused, unless on the application for such order it shall appear from the evidence brought before the judge that the person in confinement is lawfully so held. 7. The office of any judge so refusing such order, shall, on his being convicted thereof, be vacated, and he shall be forever incapable of holding any judicial office in the State, and he shall be liable to payto the party aggrieved the sum of $I,OOO, besides all damages. 8. Any person who shall refuse or neglect to obey, or shall evade service of any such order as mentioned in the 8th Section of this Article, or shall cause or permit any person in his custody or under his control, to be removed in anticipation of the service of any such order, shall be forever incapable of holding any office in the State, or of being a member of the Constitutive Authority. Fle shall also be responsible to the party aggrieved for all damages sustained, and the sum of $5,00ooo, in addition thereto. 9. All trials shall be in public. Parties in all causes shall be entitled to meet the witnesses face to face, except where they are out of the State, in which case their testimony may be taken by rogatory commission. IO. All persons accused of any offence shall have the right to demand the nature and cause of the accusation, and, if in writing, to have a copy thereof free of charge; to have process to compel the attendance of witnesses at the cost of the people, and a speedy public trial. I I. No conviction shall work corruption of blood or render the convict infamous. I2. No person shall be deprived of life under process of law.2 (2) Clauses I I and 12 will render it unnecessary ever to summon a grand jury. (See the Constitution of the United States, Art. V. of the Amendments.) The worse than uselessness of the grand jury, the injustice of the 4 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. I3. No person shall be imprisoned for debt. 14. No law shall be passed recognizing any form of religion or religious worship. Every inhabitant of Colorado may freely pursue what form of worship he pleases, provided that in so doing he infringe not the rights of life, liberty, person, or property, secured to others. I5. 3All oaths are abolished. Evidence shall be given on solemn declaration or exhortation, to tell the truth The giving of false testimony shall be punished as has heretofore been the crime of perjury, until provided for in the penal code. I6. Every person may freely speak, write and publish what he pleases on all subjects, but shall be responsible to the party aggrieved, for speaking, writing or publishing what is false; also for speaking, writing or publishing injurious statements of any party, although such statements may be true, unless it be for the public interest that such statements should be made or published. In the penal code provision shall be made for the punishment of persons who may thereafter speak, write, or publish false statements respecting any person or class of persons. system to the accused, the expense to thie community, not merely the money loss to each county, but the interruption caused to the industrial pursuits of the members, and of the witnesses so uselessly dragged before it, will be appreciated by all who have ever been on a grand jury. As a grand inquest of the county, the institution was formerly, and might to-day be of some use, but unfortunately, in the lapse of ages, its only useful function has fallen into disuse, and it remains simply a nuisance to be abated whenever common sense enters into legislation. (3) No Christian can take an oath without violating the express command of the author of his religion. Oaths are nets in which tender consciences may be caught, while the less sensitive pass through the meshes. They enable falsehood to receive the faith due to the truth. Their administration is a logical absurdity as assuming power over the Almighty in the hand of his creature. Their use lowers the moral tone of the community by leading to the inference that it is not Truth which is right, or Mendacity which is wrong, but Perjury. 5 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 17. No law shall have any retroactive effect4 except such as may be passed under the provisions of this Constitution on the recommendation of a judge or of the Minister of Justice. I8. Private property shall not be taken for public use without just compensation. 19. The military shall be in strict subordination to the civil power. 20. No act committed by any official, civil or military, shall, (if otherwise tortuous,) be excusable on the ground of its having been committed in obedience to the orders of a lawful superior. Every individual concerned in the committal of a tortuous act shall be responsible, civilly and criminally, for all the consequence thereof.5 2I. No soldier shall, in time of peace, be quartered in any house without consent of the owner and of the occupier, nor in time of war, except as prescribed by law. 22. The right of the people to assemble in a peaceable manner to consult for the common good; to make known their opinions, and to apply for redress of grievances, shall not be lessened or infringed. 23. Elections shall be free and equal. 24. All charters of Incorporation granted by the State, whether made pursuant to general laws or to any special law, shall be subject to whatever alteration any future legislature may think fit to make in such laws or charter of incorporation. (4) In many States retroactive laws have been passed in times of excitement, which have worked great injustice to individuals. The present clause (I 7) is therefore introduced instead of the usual prohibition of ex post facto laws, which judicial construction, i.e. judge-made law, has restricted to penal laws. (5) This provision restores the old law which had been frittered away by modern judicial decisions. The maintenance of this provision is of the last ijmportance for the preservation of liberty. English and Anglo-American liberty owe more perhaps to this old law than to any other single provision. 6 I FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 25. Whenever any corporation shall be unwilling to accept any such alteration they shall be at liberty to dissolve, in which case all the property and estate of such corporation shall be administered according to law as follows, viz: Ist. To defray the expenses of the dissolution and winding up of the corporation. 2d. To pay and provide for all debts and liabilities, absolute and contingent, of the corporation. 3d. The residue shall be divided among the parties beneficially interested in the corporation, ac cording to their respective interests. 26. Whenever the parties beneficially interested shall be the people of Colorado, or any particular portion of such people, the funds shall go to the the department of the State, to whose function the object of the fund has the nearest relation, and shall be administered by that department so as best to fulfil the object of the fund.6 27. The official records ofthe State and of each department of its government, and the judgments of its courts, shall be evidence of the facts stated or found therein suffieient to throw the burthen of proof on any party disputing the same, but shall never be deemed conclusive evidence thereof, and the truth may, notwithstanding, be shewn. 28. Foreign judgments and records shall receive the same faith and credence as though they were judgments or records of a court or department of this State.7 (6) These provisions, ~ 24-5-6, while preventing many of the abuses and providing means for the correction of the misconduct of corporations avoid the character of spoliation which attaches to some of the recent Constitutional and Legislative provisions of many States. Charters of Incorporation create a legal existence or entity-if the owners thereof do not like the new conditions imposed, they retain all their property, but abandon the existence which the law created, and instead of a number of persons merged into a single imaginary entity, the entity is resolved back into the individual existences out of which the law created it. (7) Borrowed from England has been the pernicious principle of looking upon the judgment of a court of record as conclusive of the facts found. 7 — I -i 0 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 29. The State of Colorado desires to render justice to all, to enforce justice, and to give an example of rendering it. Therefore the State or any and every branch or department of its government, may be sued in its courts of justice the same as any private person or body corporate.8 ARTICLE VI. SOVEREIGNTY. Subject only to the duties of Colorado as a State of the Union, the sovereignty of the State is in the people. It is exercised by the CONSTITUTIVE AUTHORITY. ARTICLE VII. AUTHORITIES. I. The authorities in the State are: a) Original, b) Delegated. When it is considered that in civil causes, by reason of its infamous procedure, a large proportion of cases litigated under English and English-derived procedure, are adjudged in favor of the evil-doer; that in France a person accused of crime is almost certain to be adjudged guilty; that in Russia a Record, complete to the very seal of the court and signature of its official recording officer, can be bought where there has never been a suit instituted at all, and the transcript of the supposed record is consequently wholly fictitious, the monstrous character of such a rule of law will be apparent. The true principle, clearly, is that established in this draft. (8) This is not only a new provision, but it absolutely reverses the law as hertofore adjudged, and is in direct opposition to express provisions of the Constitutions of many States. Yet, can anything be more flagrantly unjust than that the pretended fountain of justice should refuse to render justice, refuse to be even amenable to justice as administered in the courts it has itself established! This refusal-of-justice principle is a blind and servile adoption of the old English law which, as one of the prerogatives of the Crown, forbad suit to be brought against the sovereign. Will the people of Colorado be the first to give the bright example of daring to do right, and permit their State to be sued in her own courts by anyone who has reason to complain of her? To prevent this permission being made use of by "politicians" and "statesmen" of the Tweed class to defraud the people, the various checks adopted in this Constitution for securing upright judges and for preventing their being purchased, are essential. 8 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 2. Original authority lies only in the Constitutive. 3. The Constitutive authority delegates such portions of its powers as are expressly delegated by this constitution to a) Legislative authorities, b) Judicial authorities, c) Administrative or Executive authorities. 4. The powers delegated by this Constitution are grants from the Constitutive authority, and are to be construed in favor of the grantor. They are not a limitation on powers which but for this Constitution would be absolute or inherent in any of the delegated authorities., 5. No powers may be implied as delegated to any authority except such as are absolutely necessary for the exercise of powers expressly delegated by this Constitution. ARTICLE VIII. THE CONSTITUTIVE AUTHORITY. CHAP. 1. The Constitutive authority is in the whole body of the inhabitants of the State, who, on the several days which may be appointed by law for the exercise of their powers and the operations thereunto preparatory, are resident within the territory of the State, except as follows: (I) Judicial decisions have shewn the necessity of {{ 4 and 5 of this ar ticle. A distinction has been drawn by the courts between the powers o Congress and those of the Legislatures of the States. Of the former, no like ness was to be found in British precedents, hence it was, (and justly,) declared to be the creature of the law and of the Constitution of the United States, and that that Constitution was a grant of powers which otherwise would not have existed. But when the courts came to consider the Constitutions of the States, they had before them the British theory of the omnipotence of parlia ment, and the Legislatures of the sovereign States were deemed to be absolute and omnipotent except where their powers were limited by the State Consti tutions in consequence of the incapacity of the Judicial mind to escape from the grooves in which it had been trained, so long as any trace of the old ruts could be perceived. In this draft the absolute authority is declared to be in the people, constituting the Constitutive authority; all other authorities are delegated merely, and the Constitution therefore contains grants of powers to delegated authorities instead of limitations on powers otherwise absolute The distinction is important. 9 4 0 .1II., I I DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION I st. Persons under the age of twenty years. 2d. Persons lawfully confined or lawfully ordered to be confined in any lunatic asylum or prison on such day. 3d. Persons who may have received relief from any public fund for the relief of the poor within three months prior to such day. 4th. Persons unable to read intelligently and intelli gibly, and to write with moderate accuracy. 5th. Persons who may have failed to comply with the provisions of the electoral law. 6th. Persons who may have been deprived of the right to be members of the Constitutive Au thority by any competent tribunal. CHAP. II. THE FUNCTIONS OF THE CONSTITUTIVE AUTHORITY ARE: I. Enactive. Exercised by adopting or rejecting this Constitution and of amendments thereto, and by adopting or rejecting such bills passed by the Legislature with or without amendments thereto, as provided by this Constitution. 2. Elective., Exercised by electing the several members of the Legislature, the Minister of Justice,2 district and school commissioners and trustees, and district constables. (I) The terms locative and dislocative would be far more appropriate than the terms elective and removing, but in deference to the opinions of many who consider the use of words so unusual as locative and dislocative would add to the difficulties in the way of the adoption of the principles of this draft, the comparatively inappropriate terms in the text are employed. (2) Under this Constitution the Minister of Justice is the most important officer of the State. His election is left to the Constitutive authority in deference to the prevailing sentiment on the subject of the chief officer of the State. It is nevertheless believed that his election ought to be by the Legislature. After a few years experience it is expected that this will be seen to be the best, as also that he should hold office for a long term of years. The functions 10 -i FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 3. Removing., Exercised by removing the officials elected by them, also the Chief Executive3 and Judicial officers. 4. Punitive. Exercised by remitting for trial and punishment by the authority provided by this Constitution, or of laws passed pursuant thereto, any of the functionaries removed in the exercise of the removing function. CHAP. III. POWERS OF THE CONSTITUTIVE AUTHORITY. HOW EXERCISED. SECTION I. Enactive. I. Bills passed by the Legislature shall be referred to the Constitutive Authority for ratification. This reference to the Constitutive Authority is termed the Referendum. Bills affecting a special District or Districts only, shall be referred to the Constitutive Authority of such District or Districts only. Each bill will be voted upon by each member of the Constitutive Authority as a whole, in groups of clauses, each clause separately, or partly in groups of clauses, and partly separately, as each individual member may think fit. 2. Amendments proposed by any convention for the re-vision of this Constitution will be subjected to the Referendum, and be voted upon as provided in Clause I of this Section, in relation to bills passed by the Legislature. of District, or County and School Commissioners and Trustees, ought to be performed by officials appointed by and responsible to the ministers of the departments to which their functions respectively belong. It is hoped that the exercise of the Legislative function by the Constitutive authority, as provided in this draft, will soon reconcile the people to abandon the right to elect these officials. (3) The term Chief Executive is preferred to that of Governor or President. The Chief Executive neither governs nor presides, he is the servant of the Legislature, to carry out their will, and the fittest term for him would be Chief Minister, for Minister means servant. 4 I I -4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 3. Excepted from the Referendum are: Ist. Laws merely repealing existing laws. 2d. Laws passed under the provisions of this Con stitution on the recommendation of a judge, or of the Minister of Justice, with reference to some cause pending in one of the courts of the State. 8. May go into operation pending the Referendum: laws declared urgent by a majority of three-fifths of the votes of the Legislature. SECTION II. Elective. I. At the time and places at which the vote upon this Constitution shall be taken, each voter will cast his ballot for the person whom he desires to elect to the office of MINISTER OF JUSTICE. He will also give his proxy4 to any member of the Constitutive Authority to act as his delegate in the next Legislature. 2. If the person receiving the plurality of the votes cast for Minister of Justice shall receive a majority of threefifths of the total vote, he may hold his office for the term of five years from the day of.1876, and until his successor shall be elected and shall qualify. If no person receive a majority of three-fifths of the votes cast, the pereon receiving the plurality of the votes cast may hold - (4) The system of proxies here suggested, in a country such as ours, where there is no class needing the protection of secret voting, is so beautifulily simple and gives to everyone so exactly his proper representation and weight in legislation, that it is hoped no difficulty will be found in getting the people to insist upon its adoption. The ease with which, under this system, the people can express their confidence in their delegate, or warn him of their dissatisfaction, is not the least of its advantages. By no other simple means can it be prevented, that the minority, and often a small one at that, may sometimes dictate to the majority; or at other times, that the minority shall not be wholly unrepresented. No complicated electoral machinery is needed to prevent fraud-for as the profit from any fraudulent practices would be certain to be almost immediately lost by the revocation of the fraudulently obtained proxy, no fraud is likely to be committed. 12 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO.. the office of Minister of Justice for two years from the said day of I876, and until his successor shall in like manner, be elected and shall qualify; and such successor may hold the said office for the unexpired part of the said term of five years from said day of I 876. 3. Every person receiving the proxies of not less than I,ooo members of the Constitutive Authority to act as their delegate, may be a member of the Legislature for the period of two years from the day of, in the year in which the election takes place. 4. No person shall hold more than 5,ooo proxies in the Legislature. 5. Any person receiving more than 5,00oo0 proxies may transfer and distribute the excess to such respective persons as he may think will be most acceptable as the respective delegates of the persons whose proxies he respectively transfers; provided, that each such transferee shall, (such transferred proxies included,) be the holder of not less than I,OOO proxies. 6. Persons receiving less than I,ooo proxies may trans fer them to such persons, respectively, as they may think will be most acceptable as delegates of the persons whose proxies they respectively transfer; provided, that each such transferee shall, (such transferred proxies included,) be the holder of not less than I,OOO proxies. 7. Proxies may be revoked at the pleasure of the grantor, and may be granted to any delegate or to any member of the Constitutive Authority, but no person holding less than 1,000ooo proxies shall be a delegate. 8. At the expiration of each successive period of two years a new Legislature shall be elected in like manner, and shall hold office for a like period of two years. 9. At the expiration of each successive period of five I3 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION years from the confirmation of this Constitution, another Convention shall be elected to revise the same.5 IO. The election of each such convention shall be in the same manner as the election of the Legislature. II. The Constitutive Authority shall at the same time proceed to the election of a Minister of Justice for the next quinquennial period. I2. If no person shall receive a majority of the votes cast for Minister of Justice, the Legislature shall elect the Minister of Justice from the two persons having the largest number of votes. I3. The election of District and School Commissioners and Trustees, and of Constables, by the Constitutive Authorities in each District and Precinct, will be regulated by appropriate legislation.6 I4. Vacancies in the office of delegate, occurring more than six months prior to the time provided for a general election, shall be supplied by a new election. 15. A vacancy in the office of Minister of Justice occuring more than one year prior to the appointed time for a new election, shall be supplied by a new election, and the person elected shall hold office during the residue of the term during which the vacancy occurred. If less than one (5) The means provided in most of the Constitutions for their revision, are both complicated and difficult to put into operation. By providing for the periodical assembling of a Convention whose business shall be expressly to overhaul the Constitution, the errors and omissions which experience will suggest can be readily supplied. A main cause for the placing of so many difficulties in the way of revision has been the proneness of man to think his own work perfect, and the consequent desire to prevent "innovation." It is the part alike of philosophy and of practical statesmanship, to recognize the fact of human imperfection. In recognition of this fact, the provision for the periodical revision, or, rather, the periodical opportunity to revise the Constitution, has been above adopted. Probably after one or two quinquennial periods it will be found desirable to extend the periods between the meeting of each Constitutional Convention. (6) L. E., In the Constitutional Code. 14 t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. year of such term shall remain unexpired when the vacancy occurs, the Legislature shall elect a Minister of Justice to hold office during the residue of such term. I6. The first in the month of October shall be the day on which general elections shall be held throughout the State after the first. 1 7. The Referendum and special elections shall take place on such days as may be appointed by the Legislature or by the Election Minister. SECTION III. Removing Function. 7 DIVISION I. I. In the case of any delegate to the Legislature or to a Constitutional Convention, the removing function may be exercised by any member of the Constitutive Authority by withdrawing his proxy, or transferring it to some one else, and sending or giving notice thereof to the Election Minister. 2. Whenever the proxies so withdrawn or transferred shall leave the delegate the holder of less than I,ooo proxies, the Minister of Elections shall inform the President of the Legislature thereof, who shall announce the same to the Legislature. (7) The methods provided in this draft for getting rid of the Minister of Justice and Chief Executive, should either become obnoxious to their employers, will be specially appreciated by those who remember the case of President Johnson. Could he have been got rid of by any of the methods here provided, all the trouble, excitement and disturbance of his trial would have been avoided. If a servant, even though so highly placed as the Minister of Justice or Chief Executive become obnoxious to a considerable majority of his employers, surely the latter ought to have power to remove their servant, even though he be not guity of "high crimes and misdemeanors." The reason for making it necessary that the Constitutive Authority, instead of the Legislature, should alone have power to remove the Minister of Justice is, that he, as a judicial officer, may have to stand between the Constitutive Authority and usurpations attempted by the Legislature. 15, -1 4 i DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 3. Unless such delegate shall, within three days thereafter, file a sufficient number of proxies to make up I,ooo, he shall cease to be a delegate. 4. Proxies may be transferred to him by any other delegate to enable him to maintain his qualification. 5. On ceasing to be a delegate he may, at any time within seven days thereafter, transfer or distribute the proxies held by him to, or among, other delegates or a delegate. DIVISION II. In the case of the Minister of Justice: I. On receipt of a requisition for the removal of the Minister of Justice, signed by members of the Constitutive Authority, the Election Minister, or, if that office be vacant, the Chief Executive or the President of the Legislature, shall appoint a day on which the vote of the Constitutive Authority shall be taken. 2. If the removal of the Minister of Justice shall be voted by three-fifths of the votes cast, his office shall be vacated. 3. If the removal of the Minister of Justice shall be voted by three-fifths of the votes cast on a Referendum, ordered by a vote of not less than three-fifths of the votes of the Legislature, his office shall be vacated. DIVISION III. The removal of other officers elected by the Constitutive Authority will be provided for by appropriate legislation.8 DIVISION IV. In the case of the Chief Executive: I. On receipt of a requisition for the removal of the Chief Executive, signed by members, of the Constitutive Authority, the President of the Legislature shall put the question of his removal to the Legislature. If his removal be voted by a majority of three-fifths of the votes of the delegates, his office shall thereupon be vacated. It (8) i.e., in the Constitutional Code. i6 - f FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. his removal be voted by a less majority, the Referendum shall be had upon it, and if the vote of the Legislature be confirmed his office shall be vacated. 2. If there be a majority against the removal of the Chief Executive of three-fifths of the votes of the delegates, no further action shall be taken; but if the majority to retain him shall be less than three-fifths, the President of the Legislature shall put the question: "Shall the removal or retention of the Chief Executive be referred to the Consti tutive Authority?" If the affirmative be carried, the Ref erendum shall have place, and if there be a majority on the Referendum to remove the Chief Executive, his office shall be vacated. 3. When the office of Election Minister shall be filled by the Chief Executive, or be vacant, the Legislation Minister shall superintend the election, and perform the duties of Election Minister on the occasion of every election or Refendurn in which the question of removing the Chief Executive shall be voted upon.9 A DIVISION V. In the case of any judicial officer:o (9) The Legislation Minister, and no other, should under such circumstances perform the functions of Election Minister; i. e., one officer dependent on the Legislature shall perform the duties of another equally dependent, but, under the circumstances, incapacitated. If the power were given to the Minister of Justice simply, he and the Chief Executive might conspire to overturn the government by a fraudulent election. This danger does not exist when the duty is placed in the hands of the Legislation Minister, even though that office happen to be filled -by the Minister of Justice, for the Legislature can, under this draft, by a simply majority vote, appoint some one else to be Legislation Minister. (IO) It is earnestly hoped that the people of Colorado will consent to see their judges appointed for life or during good behaviour. It is the only way to secure an independent and upright judiciary, while their partial dependence on the Constitutive Authority and the Minister of Justice, as provided by this draft, will prevent their independence from becoming arrogance. Above all, the principle of appointment by a single responsible officer, instead of election, is earnestly insisted upon. 1 7 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION I. On the receipt of a requisition for the removal of any judicial officer, signed by members of the Constitutive Authority, or by one-fifth of all the registered members thereof resident in the District, appellat or primary, which forms the local field of service of the judicial officer whose removal is demanded, the Minister of Justice shall institute an enquiry, and if it shall appear that such judicial officer is incompetent, corrupt, inattentive, arrogant or otherwise inefficient, or has violated any provisions of the law, the Minister of Justice shall remove him and appoint some competent person to his office. 2. If there shall appear no sufficient cause for the removal of such officer, but that by reason of his having lost or failed to acquire the respect of the inhabitants, his usefulness in his office is impaired, the Minister of Justice may transfer such judicial officer to some other District. 3. The Minister of Justice may refer final action on the case to the Constitutive Authority where there does not appear sufficient cause to remove the judicial officer. A simple majority shall be sufficient to require the Minister of Justice to transfer such officer to another District. SEcTION IV. Pnuitive. On the removal of any official by the Constitutive Authority, each voter may at the same time vote whether the official to be removed shall be prosecuted for any alleged violation by him of the penal code. The people can not know and never can learn enough of the character of individuals to enable them to make a good selection of judges. The best men are rarely the men whose names are most before the people. Noisy demagogues who "know the ropes" and how to run the primaries and nominating conventions, and who, to procure a nomination, kow-tow to and hobnob with the dangerous classes, and wink at their crimes, these are the men who will generally be placed in judicial positions by popular election. 18 A I I FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. ARTICLE IX. THE LEGISLATURE.' CHAP. I. HOW CONSTITUTED. I. All members of the Constitutive Authority are eligible as delegates to the Legislature, as also all persons who have failed to be members thereof only by reason of a failure to comply with the provisions of the electoral law. 2. The Legislature is elected in the manner provided in Art. VIII, Chap. II, ~ 2, and Art. VIII, Chap. III, ~ 2, Clauses I, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, I3 and I5. -4 (I) The principle of a single Legislature will be readily acquiesced in, if the Referendum be adopted, as in such case the Constitutive Authority is more a great deal than any second chamber can be. But lest this principle should fail of adoption, a few words on the question whether the Legislature should consist of two Houses or one, will be useful: The principal reason assigned for the adoption of a divided Legislature, i. e., of two Houses, is that they are a check upon hasty legislation. Argument from experience and a priori alike show the contrary to be the fact. To take the apriori argument first: Evidently increased delay must take place between the passing of a project by one House and the definite passing of it by both, and as the time of the session is limited, either by law or in fact, much less consideration can be given to each measure by either House than would be able to be given to it if there were but one. Again, members of each House will reconcile themselves to giving little consideration to a measure originating there, by the reflection that it will be reconsidered in the other Honse, while members of the other House will reconcile their consciences to giving little consideration to a bill brought up from one House, by the reflection that it has already been considered there. Experience of all Legislatures proves this to be true, an illustration drawn from the proceedings of the last Legislature of Colorado will be specially in point. A House bill was on its third reading in the Council, the question was put, "Shall this bill pass?" The ayes and noes were called. Room for further deliberation there was none. On the name 6f Mr. Hugh Butler being called he answered from his seat, "Aye,-I don't know anything at all about it." On the clerk calling the name of Mr. Fitzpatrick, that gentleman rose and said, "Aye, but it is understood we are not responsible for this bill." A further objection to the system of two Houses, is the expense, both as regards the remuneration of the members of the second House and the expenses of their proceedings and election. Further, by its means the will of the minority frequently prevails over that of the majority. (3) Ig DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 3. The Judges of Election will canvass all votes and proxies at the first election under this Constitution, and will certify the same and transmit said votes and proxies to the Governor of the Territory, who, together with the Chief Justice and the United States Attorney, or any two of them, shall canvass the same, and shall, if this Constitution be adopted, forward to each delegate who shall have received not less than I,ooo proxies, a certificate of his election and of the number of proxies held by him.2 Again, the division of responsibility renders corruption more easy, and, on the supposition that one House is more numerous than the other, it will be both easier and more effectual to corrupt the members of the less numerous House than those of the more numerous. The proper precautions against hasty legislation are to be found in the character of the members of the Legislature, and in rules of order for the conduct of business, some of which should be inflexible, others open to suspension. It does not seem necessary to discuss here, what those rules of order should be. Again, if two Houses are to be constituted, how are their members to be elected? If, by election, they must be elected in the same way or in different ways. No one proposes the former, and as for the latter, one mode must be better than the other. Solve the difficulty then by adopting the best mode only, and save the expense of the worse. A circumstance connected with the progress and development of governamental science will furnish an interesting confirmation of the above views: The author of this Draft, some years ago, conducted a class in the study of legal and governmental science, at the Cooper Institute, New York. The method of instruction adopted was the Socratic, the most powerful for the detection of error and discovery of truth in abstract science ever invented. He gave no indication of his own views. By the Socratic method of enquiry the student discovers every truth for himself, the direction only of his studies being shaped by the questions addressed to him by the Instructor. The students, one and all, were so prepossessed in favor of two Houses that the single system seemed to them out of all question; nevertheless, they all came round, unwillingly but unavoidably, to the conviction that the single chamber system was the only fit one. (2) A difficulty might possibly, but not probably, arise under this section. The Governor, Chief Justice, and United States Attorney, being Federal, and not State officials, may refuse to canvass the proxies. Before incorporating this clause in the Constitution it will be desirable to ascertain from them their willingness to act in the premises. 20 -1 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 4. They shall also forward to each person who has received less than I,OOO proxies, a certificate of the fact and of the number granted to him. 5. Within thirty days after such certificate shall be so sent, any such person may file with the Governor sufficient proxies to make up I,OOO, and shall, thereupon, be entitled to a certificate of election as delegate. 6. Within the like period of thirty days such person may transfer his proxies, or some of them, to such person or persons respectively, as he may think will be most acceptable as their delegate, to the persons whose proxies he transfers. 7. Each delegate shall cast in the Legislature a vote equal to the number of proxies held by him of the recall whereof no notice has been received by the Election Minister, or, if that office be vacant, by the President or Clerk of the Legislature. 8. All future elections shall be under the direction of the Election Minister and of officers appointed by him. Each local officer shall canvass the votes and transmit one copy of his certificate thereof, together with all ballots and proxies to the Election Minister. 9. The Election Minister shall furnish to delegates and other elected officers, certificates of their election and of the number of proxies held by delegates under his official seal. Io. He shall also furnish a certificate such as mentioned in Section 4 of this Chapter to all persons receiving less than I,ooo proxies. I I. Sections 5, 6 and 7 of this Chapter shall ap,ply to future elections and Legislatures as well as to the first to be elected under this Constitution, except that the words Election Minister shall be read in place of the word Governor in sec. 5. I2. Each delegate shall, at the commencement of his term, file with the Election Minister and with the Clerk of 21 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION the Legislature, duplicate certificates of the appointment of a deputy to take his place in the Legislature, in the absence of the delegate.3 (3) This, which Bentham terms the self-suppletive function, is a feature of great importance. A very few words will suffice to make its value apparent. Whatsoever need or use there is for a delegate, or any other official, to act in his office on any one day, the same there may be, for anything that can be known to the contrary, on every other, and as the days of unavoidable absence cannot be forseen, by this provision the need or use is supplied. Further, for want of it, a mode of corruption can and at all times has been carried on to an indefinite extent; - corruption which can in no way be guarded against, neither by penal provision nor by Public opinion. A man Mwho, had he been in attendance, the apprehension of censure from Public-opinion would have engaged to vote or act rightly, absents himself, and thereby, though he does not give to the wrong side the benefit of his vote or act, deprives the right of it. Instances out of number of this method of corruption might be given from the annals of all Legislative bodies. Instances of the like method of corruption in the case of officials other than delegates, have occurred recently in our country, so glaring that they may well serve as a warning. When the fraudulent bills and vouchers were to be passed by the New York Board of Audit, during the mayorality of Oakey Hall, he always absented himself from the place where it was his duty to be, and the fraudulent acts were performed in his pre-arranged absence. When the infamous Sanborn and Jayne contracts were to be entered into, Mr. Secretary Boutwell was always conveniently absent, and Mr. Richardson did the dirty work which Mr. Boutwell was willing to have done, but desired to be able to say that he was not there at the doing of it. If, now, Mr. Hall and Mr. Boutwell had had to provide deputies for whose acts they would themselves have been held strictly accountable, there would have been no use in either of them getting out of the way while the frauds were being consummated, and it is therefore probable that they would not have been perpetrated. It is obvious that both the appointment and removal of the deputy must be in the absolute discretion of the man who is responsible for his acts. A different rule will be found to apply to Judges' deputies. As the reason for the rule does not exist, so also the rule will be different. For the general ,conduct of the Judge's deputy, the Minister of Justice who appoints him is responsible to the Public-opinion-tribunal. The Judge will review_and may reverse the judicial acts he may depute to his deputy, and will be responsible for those judicial acts so deputed which he adopts, and no further. In the appointment of the Judge's deputy, the Minister of Justice will so far consult the wishes of the Judge as not to appoint any one to his court who may be personally objectionable to him,-to no further extend is it expected that the Judge will influence the appointment of his deputy after this Constitution has been in operation for a few years. 22 -1 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. I3. The delegate is responsible for all the acts of his deputy, and may revoke his appointment and substitute another at his pleasure. CHAP. II. ITS POWERS. The'powers of the Legislature are: I. Legislative. I. Exercised by drawing up, considering and passing, projects of laws, or bills, for confirmation by the Constitutive Authority. 2. By repealing existing laws with or without the Referendum, and by declaring urgent, and to have immediate operation, new laws, pending the Referendum. 3. By directing the mode in which it shall conduct its business, the mode in which shall be published the various returns of property, income and expenditure made to it or to any official by the delegates and by the different officers of the official establishment of the State, as provided by this Constitution or by laws passed pursuant thereto, and such other matters as the Legislature may judge expedient to be published. 4. By prescribing the remuneration of the President and other officers of the Legislature, and of extra allowances for expenses incurred or to be incurred on special occasions by any of the ministers or delegates. 5. By appointing the times and occasions on which the Referendum and special elections shall have place pursuant to this Constitution, and making provision for the expense thereof. 6. No special law, no law pledging the credit of the State, binding the State to any contract, or contracting any debt or obligation, can be declared urgent except for the purpose mentioned in the next section of this chapter. 7. The first Legislature which shall be elected under this 23 I 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION Constitution shall make provision for the preparation of a civil code, a penal code, a procedure code, a constitutional code, and an election code. 8. Until otherwise provided the laws heretofore enacted by the Legislature of the Territory of Colorado shall have operation except as follows:4 (4) Although no great mischief could result from allowing all laws to die out until the passing of the codes ordered by this Constitution to be prepared, it has been thought on the whole, in the present state of public opinion, desirable to re-enact existing laws, with some few exceptions of ill-judged laws, to be included in a schedule which, for sufficient reasons, the author has not prepared, but hopes to see wisely done by the Convention. But the author of this draft is unhesitatingly of the opinion that it would be infinitely to be preferred that all existing laws should cease to operate, than to tolerate in the State, even for a day, the infamous system of legal procedure and of evidence, which at present prevail. The existing practice and procedure were framed centuries ago in England, almost avowedly to encourage dishonest litigation, fraud and perjury, yet this system was adopted here! Under this system of procedure there has ever been one law for the rich and a very different law for the poor, while the courts of law have ever been sanctuaries for the crimes of the wealthy and powerful. Society has been held together not by means of but in spite of, the courts, miscalled of justice, and because the people were better than their laws. The true principle of procedure, discovered by the master mind of Bentham, is that of which the model has been before us constantly since the existence of a family. It is that which every sensible head of a household adopts in the event of a dispute arising among the members of his household. But let us imagine him, instead of listening to the complaint and sending for the person complained of, to refuse to listen to it unless brought written out in a nonsensical jargon, of which one statement being true, others, without limit as to number, are necessarily false. Imagine him, after the lapse of several months, to require the party complained of to bring in an equally nonsensical jargon of lies in reply, this to be continued backwards and forwards for an indefinite time, and then the parties to come before him, and when they attempt to give their statements, to be rigorously shut out from telling what, or being asked questions the answers to which might, conclusively establish the truth; in addition, under penalty of losing their cause, to be obliged to prove the most nonsensical facts which the opponent, if put upon his honor under the sanction of public opinion alone, would not dare to contest!-what now would become of a family so conducted? Citizens of Colorado! the picture here drawn of the legal practice and procedure now prevailing is only too favorable. It does -not put before you a 24 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. I. Such laws and parts of laws as are mentioned in the schedule to this article, which are hereby repealed. 2. Such as are inconsistent with this Constitution. 3. The entire law of evidence as heretofore in force. In place of the laws of evidence heretofore in force, the principles laid down in the "Ra tionale of Judicial Evidence," by Jeremy Bentham, are adopted as the only rules of judicial evidence in force within the State of Colorado. 4. So soon as the Minister of Justice, to be elected pursuant to this Constitution, shall have ap pointed Priniary and Appellate judges in any district, the practice and procedure in all causes shall be summary: Provided, that tithe of the iniquities, nor a ten-thousandth part of the misery, the present system inflicts. And this is the system which will be attempted to be continued upon you, this or some palty modification of it called "a code!" All the code systems heretofore adopted have been but palliatives of this monstrous wickedness. The New York code, on which most of the codes of the States are modelled, enabled David Dudley Field and "Brother Shearman" to concoct their infamous plots by which Jay Gould and Jim Fisk stole railroads from their owners, while not one cent has been able to be recovered in all these years of the millions stolen by "Boss Tweed" from the people of New York. The only true system, the only system the people should permit to be adopted, is that of Nature, discovered by the grand genius of Bentham. As to the laws of evidence, these laws as laid down by Greenleaf and adopted by our courts, are carefully framed to shut out the truth, and for the increase of expense, vexation and delay. Happily this part of the field of legal science was completely, exhaustively explored by Bentham, whose work, "The Rationale of Judicial Evidence," is a finished and perfect system. So perfect is it, that its principles have been adopted in all scientific investigations; only in law it has not yet been suffered to prevail, owing to the sinister interest of the professors of the law and of professional politicians, and the supineness of thepeole. Citizens of Colorado! will you, like the citizens of other states, permit yourselves to be the shuttlecocks of the lawyers and of politicians, or will you take hold of the opportunity you now have of emancipating yourselves from thraldom, and become a lodestar and a guide to all the other states of the Union! 25 .4 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION every person shall be entitled, on his de manding the same, to trial by jury to the ex tent guaranteed to him by the Constitution of the United States, or whenever the act complained of shall be of a political char acter. 5. The maxim that Sunday, or the first day of the week, is a dies non, is abrogated. No law shall recognize any distinction of days except days set apart as National or State holidays. 6. No district, body politic, or political corporation, shall have power to contract any debt or ob ligation in excess of the amount of taxes estimated to be collected within such district, body politic, or political corporation, during the then current fiscal year, without the con sent of every tax-payer within the same vot ing upon the question. 2. Elective.5 I. Exercised by electing: I. Two Senators to the United States Senate. 2. The President of the Legislature and other offi cers thereof 3. The Chief Executive. 4. The Legislation Minister. 5. The Election Minister. (5) The number of offices in a State ought to be such that their duties will employ the whole time of the incumbents. The duties of Legislation Minister in a State with so small a population as ours would occupy but a small part of the time of one man, and as his duties require a similar talent to that of the Minister of Justice-the two offices may be fitly held by one person. Similar considerations suggested the permission for the Chief Executive to be also elected Election Minister. In neither case should the two offices respectively be merged into one, because the Legislation Minister and the Election Minister ought to be removable at the simple will of the Legislature, while more difficulty should, as has been seen, be placed in the way of the removal of the Minister of Justice and of the Chief Executive. 26 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 2. The person holding the office of Minister of Justice may be elected Legislation Minister. 3. The Chief Executive may be elected Election Minister. 4. The President of the Legislature, the Chief Executive, the Legislation Minister and the Election Minister will each be elected for the period of two years. 3. Removing. I. Exercised by suspending any delegate for misconduct, in which case his deputy shall act in his place until a new election be ordered by the Legislature, or the suspension be removed. 2. By suspending the Minister of Justice by a majority of three-fifths of the votes of the delegates, until the decision of the Constitutive Authority can be obtained as to his removal. 3. By removing the President of the Legislature or any other officer thereof. 4. By removing the Chief Executive. 5. By removing the Legislation Minister. 6. By removing the Election Minister. 7. A vote of three-fifths of the votes of the delegates shall be required to remove the Chief Executive. 8. The other officers named in this Chapter may be suspended or removed by a majority of the votes of the delegates. CHAP. III. REMUNERATION. I. Each delegate shall be entitled to a remuneration of $ per diem for each day's actual attendance during the session of the Legislature. If any delegate shall be absent during part of the day's sitting of the Legislature, a rateable proportion shall be deducted from his per diem. 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 2. No sitting shall continue for more than eight hours in any one day, except by vote of a majority of three-fourths of the members of the Legislature, each member casting a single vote. 3. Whenever a deputy shall take the place of the delegate (his principal) such deputy shall receive the per diem, or the rateable part thereof, for his attendance during the sitting, or part thereof, of the Legislature, in the place of the delegate. 4. Any contract, bargain, or understanding, by which the delegate should receive the whole or any part of the remuneration payable to the deputy, shall be void, and the entering into the same shall vacate the office of the delegate from the day of the date thereof. 5. Mileage amounting to per mile, one way, for the entire distance from his home to the place of sitting of the Legislature, shall be allowed to each delegate each session of the Legislature. CHAP. IV. DUTIES AND LIABILITIES. I. It is duty of every delegate to attend every sitting of the Legislature throughout its entire duration. 2. It is the duty of each delegate to see that his deputy supplies his place in case of his own necessary or unavoidable absence. 3. Every delegate shall make and deliver to the Clerk of the Legislature, within sixty days after the receipt by him of his certificate of election, a full and complete statement in writing, signed by him, of all his property, -real, personal, and mixed, possessed or enjoyed by him, or by any person for his use; and. thereafter, once in every two months, so long as he shall continue such delegate, shall make and deliver to the said clerk, a true and complete statement and account in writing, signed by him, of all moneys and prop 28 'I 'I FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. erty or effects, received disbursed or parted with by him, or by any person for his use, during the preceding two months. At the end of each year he shall make a full and complete statement, in writing, signed by him, of all his property, real, personal, and mixed, possessed or enjoyed by him, or by any person for his use.6 4. Neglect to make such returns or any of them for the period of thirty days, shall vacate his office and the Election Minister shall immediately, on being notified thereof, order a new election whenever such neglect shall take place more than six months prior to the time provided for a general election. 5. Any error or omission in any such return, to the amount of $5.oo in one sum or of $Ioo in the aggregate, (6) The provisions contained in this Draft requiring officials to make, and for the publication of, returns of their property and income, though novel, will be readily seen to be just and expedient. If a private individual evades payment of a tax, the loss to the government is small; nevertheless the government claims, and has conceded to it, the power to make the most rigorous investigation into the private affairs of every citizen, lest one out of thousands should evade payment of its claims npon him. The private citizen does not place himself in any position to have thrust upon him the duty of paying the tax, the government comes to him and insits on his paying it. If then, this investigation into the private affair; of private citizens is justifiable, how much clearer the justice, nay how necessary, must be the like investigation into the affairs of every official. An official does not have his office thrust upon him, he accepts, and generally he has sought it. Accepting it, he does so with all its conditions, and there can be no shadow of injustice in requiring him to give to the public a faithful and periodical return of all his sources of income and expenditure. Peculation or corruption by an official inflicts a loss many times more severe upon the government than does the evasion of a tax by an ordinary citizen, besides tending to demoralize the entire community. Apply then, on this so much more important occasion, and to the functionary, the preservation of whose honesty is of so much greater necessity, the rule adopted on the less important occasion and to less important individuals. Require of each official an account of all the moneys and property that pass through his hands, and an enormous obstacle is placed in the way of all kinds of corruption by the matter of wealth. 29 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION shall also vacate the office of the delegate making such error or omission, and a new election shall be ordered, as provided in Section 4 of this Chapter. 6. Any such neglect, error, or omission, as described in Sections 4 and 5 of this Chapter, shall, if made intentionally, render the delegate, when convicted thereof, forever incapable of holding office in the State, and shall also subject him to a fine of not less than $5oo; and not exceeding ten times the amount of the error or omission so intentionally made, or of the amount intentionally neglected to be returned. 7. All statements and accounts rendered pursuant to the provisions of this Chapter, shall be published by the Clerk of the Legislature within forty days after the receipt thereof by him. CHAP. V. CONTINUATION COMMITTEE. I. Each Legislature shall'appoint persons, being either members of the existing Legislature or of the preceding one, as a Continuation Committee, who shall continutre to sit after the adjournment of the Legislature. 2. Such committee shall labor with the Legislation Minister in the preparation of the codes ordered to be prepared by this Constitution, and in the preparation of bills to be submitted to the Legislature. 3. They shall, not less than twenty days prior to the assembling of the Legislature, transmit to the Minister of Justice all bills prepared by them, and report progress made upon the Codes. 4. The Continuation Committee, or a majority thereof, shall have power to summon the Legislature to meet at any time and place, on giving thirty days' notice thereof in some newspaper published in the place where the last sitting of the Legislature was held, and to suspend any of the Ministers, except the Minister of Justice, from his office, 30 ,f FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. until the next meeting of the Legislature and ten days thereafter. 5. The members of the Continuation Committee shall have the same remuneration as members of the Legislature. CHAP. VI. REMOVAL OF DELEGATES TO THE LEGISLATURE OR TO A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION AND OF MEMBERS OF THE CONTINUATION COMMITTEE. I. Dele Constituti ticle VIII 2. The Committe I. 2. By resignation. By acceptance of any office belonging to the of ficial establishment of this or any other State or of the United States, other than that of Election Minister of this State. 3. By acceptance of any factitious honor or dignity, or of any gift or reward from any foreign government or authority. Excepted from the foregoing is the acceptance of any title, honorary or otherwise, denoting merely intellectual position or acquirement. mental derangement. 5. By the exercise of the removing function by the Legislature, as per Article IX, Chap. II, Sec tion 3, Clause I. 6. By failure to make within the times prescribed the returns prescribed by this Constitution, Article IX, Chap. IV, Sections 3 and 4, or by making any incorrect return to the amounts, or either of them, as provided in Section 5 of the same Chapter. 31 — 4 'O 4. By 5. By DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 7. By criminal delinquency pronounced by the sen tence of a competent tribunal within the State. 8. A delegate may be suspended by a vote of three fifths of the votes of the Legislature. CHAP. VII. DELEGATES INAUGURAL DECLARATION.7 (7) No Inaugural Declaration is presented in this Draft. The short forms of oaths of office prescribed in existing Constitutions are useless. Oaths are logical absurdities; a solemn declaration is not obnoxious to the same objections which exist against oaths. But for an inaugural declaration to be of any value it should recite the main duties of the office upon which the officer-elect is about to enter. The main function of such a declaration is to bring the moral sanction of the community, i. e., Public Opinion, to bear with more force upon the incumbent, by means of the prominence with which his several duties are brought before him and them, and by him engaged to be performed, and the several temptations to which he will be subjected, reviewed and abjured. In the present state of the public mind, the presentation of an inaugural declaration framed to this end, would not be acceptable, it would be deemed too long, —" impractical," and unfortunately there exists no adequate means for the discussion of this and other important points. Should the convention contain the right sort of men, the proper inaugural declaration will most probably be adopted. For an excellent model see "The Constitutional Code," by Jeremy Bentham, Book II, Chap. VII, Vol. IX, pp. I98, 204 of the Bowring edition of his works. CHAP. VIII. SITTINGS OF THE LEGISLATURE. I. The first Legislature elected under this Constitution shall hold its first session on the first in the month of October, I876, at ten o'clock in the forenoon. " 2. The subsequent sessions of the first Legislature and the sessions of future Legislatures shall commence at nine o'clock in the forenoon on the second Monday in January in each year, unless specially convened as provided by this Constitution. 3:2 -1t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 3. A majority of the members elected shall constitute a quorum. 4. The Minister of Elections will report all cases of disputed elections to the President of the Legislature and to the Minister of Justice.8 (8) Under the proxy system a contest with regard to the result of an election will be scarcely possible. But in case one should happen, it should be referred to the judiciary to decide upon it like any other cause. For the Legislature to adjudicate thereon is to mix up legislative with judicial functions, and, (so long as government by party exists,) to make a party to the cause judge in it. The maxim that every Legislature is the sole judge of its own elections, so dear to precedent lawyers has been already abandoned in England whence we derived it. 5. The Minister of Justice will cause the same to be en quired into by the judge of such District as he shall deem most convenient for the enquiry. All persons claiming to be interested in the result shall, on application, be made parties to the enquiry and, unless the judge shall deem they have no interest therein, shall have a right to be heard in person or by attorney and to produce such testimony relavent to the issue as they may think fit. 6. By consent of all parties claiming the delegation the cause may be heard and determined by a committee of the Legislature presided over by the Election Minister. 7. The proceedings of the Legislature and of all Consti tutional Conventions shall be public; but the Legislature or Convention may vote a secret session not to exceed two hours in any one day. 7. Laws shall run as follows: I. When the referendum has place "It is enactedby "the Constitutive Authority of the State of "Colorado on the recommendation of their "Legislature as following:" 2 When the law merely repeals existing laws "It is enacted by the people of Colorado rep 33 .1 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION "resented in their Legislature that "be and the same is (or are) hereby repeal ed " 3. When the law is passed under the provisions of this Constitution on the recommendation of a judge or of the Minister of Justice "It is enacted by the people of Colorado "represented in their Legislature on the re "commendation of "judge of [or] on the recommendation of the Minister of Justice "evidenced by said recommenda "tion under the hand and seal of said ~~" ~ presented to the President "of the Legislature and recorded on the "journal of the Legislature at pages "thereof as follows": ARTICLE X. THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE. CHAP. I. HOW ELECTED AND REMOVED.' (I) As in this draft, the Minister of Justice and not the Chief Executive is the principal officer of the State, and his election is reserved to the Constitutive authority, it is probable that the election of the Chief Executive by the Legislature may excite but faint opposition. It is the will of the Legislature to which he is to give execution and it is they who are to prescribe his duties and provide the means for their execution; evidently then, the Legislature is the proper authority to elect and remove him. I. The Chief Executive is elected by the Legislature for the term of two years. 2. His office may be vacated I. By removal as per Article VIII, Chap. III, Sec tion 3, Division IV, ante p. I6. 2. By removal as per Art. IX, Chap. II, Sec. 3, Clause 4, ante p. 27. 34 I FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 3. By any of the means numbered I, 2, 3, 4 or 7 of Art. IX, Chap. VI, Sec. 2, of this constitu tion, ante p. 3I. 4. By failure to make within the time prescribed by this constitution the returns provided in Chap. II of this article, Sec. IO, post 36. 5. By acceptance of any gift present or benefit con trary to the provisions of Sec. 4, Chap. III, of this article, post 37. CHAP. II. DUTIES AND POWERS. The duties and powers of the Chief Executive are: I. To see that the laws are executed. 2. To convene the Legislature in special session when he thinks necessary or desirable so to do. 3. To communicate with the Legislature by message on all matters necessary or proper for them to know or to con fer upon. 4. To report to them at each session upon the finances of the State; upon the expenditures necessary for the current and next succeeding years; upon the best mode of making provision for those expenses; on the condition of peace and order of the State; upon Federal relations; upon the various industries of the State, and upon the condition of education. 5. To attend the Legislature whenever required by them so to do. 6. He will appoint and remove, pursuant to the provisions of the Constitutional Code, all Ministers except the Minister of Justice, the Legislation Minister, and the Election Minister. 7. He will appoint all officers in the various Executive establishments of the State, and it is his duty to exercise (4) 35 -I DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION constant supervision over the manner in which they perform their several duties, to take note of their conduct, and, whenever necessary, to reprimand, suspend, or remove them; provided, that after the promulgation of the Constitutional Code, by this Constitntion ordered to be prepared, the appointment, transfer, and removal of all such officials, shall be in accordance with the rules to be established in and by said Code.2 8. The Chief Executive is Commander-in-Chief of the armed force of the State. 9. He will appoint a deputy to act in his stead in case of his absence, sickness, or other disability. He is responsible for the acts of his deputy, and may, at his pleasure, remove him and appoint another in his place. IO. Within sixty days after his acceptance of the office he will file with the Clerk of the Legislature a statement like to that required from each delegate as per Art. IX, Chap. IV, Sec. 3, and shall, once in every two months thereafter, and once in every year, file accounts and statements like to those respectively required from each delegate, as by the same Sec. 3, Art. IX, Chap. IV, ante p. 28. I I. Such statements, and two monthly accounts shall be made and published within thirty days after the expiration of each period of two months and one year respectively. I2. Any neglect to make, and any error or omission in, such statements and accounts, shall subject the Chief Executive to the same pains and penalties as provided in the case of delegates, as per Art. IX, Chap. IV. Secs. 4, 5 and 6, ante pp. 29-30. (2) This provision refers to what has been termed "civil service reform," and will apply equally to military officers. The objects of the rules to be provided by the Constitutional Code, are the maximization of efficiency and the minimization of expense. Of course the politicians will resist them and will get the aid of a certain class of minds by denouncing them as "impractical." Their "impracticability" consisting in the fact that they would be a pretty severe check on plundering the people! 36 t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. CHAP. III. REMUNERATION. I. The salary of the Chief Executive is per year, paid quarterly, in advance. 2. He shall be allowed expenses actually incurred on all journeys made on the business of the State. 3. The Legislature may make extra allowances for expenses actually incurred by the Chief Executive on particular occasions in the business of the State. 4. No gift, present, or benefice of any kind may be received by the Chief Executive during the time that he holds his office, other than provided by this Constitution or any law passed pursuant thereto, except such as may come to him by inheritance, or bequest, or from a natural or adopted parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, brother or sister. ARTICLE XI. ELECTION MINISTER. CHAP. I. HOWN ELECTED AND REMOVED. I. The Election Minister is elected by the Legislature for the term of two years. 2. His office is vacated I. By removal, as per Article IX, Chap. II, Sec. 3, Clause 6, ante p. 27. 2. By any of the means numbered I, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7, of Art. IX, Chap. VI, in the case of dele gates, ante pp. 3 I-2. 3. By acceptance of any office belonging to the of ficial establishment of this or of any other State, or of the United States, other than that of delegate to the Legislature or Chief Exe cutive of this State. 37 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 4. By accepting any gift, present or benefice, con trary to the provisions of Chap. III of this Article, post p. 39. 5. By failure to make, within the times prescribed, the returns provided by Chap. II, Sec. 6 of this Article. CHAP. II. DUTIES AND POWERS. The duties and powers of the Election Minister are: I. Subject to the directions of the Legislature, to give execution to the Election Code. 2. To communicate thereon to the Legislature and to the Chief Executive, as occasion may require. 3. To receive and canvass the returns of every election; to give certificates as provided by this Constitution, and as may be provided by law, under his hand and seal of office, to all persons entitled to the same and to report all disputed cases to the Legislature and to the Minister of Justice. 4. To appoint and remove all officers of elections, temporary and permanent, subject to the provisions of the Constitutional Code, when the same shall be promulgated, and to exercise as regards election officers, the same duties, powers and authority, as provided to be exercised by the Chief Executive in the case of executive officers, as per Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. 7, pp. 35-6. 5. He will appoint a deputy, as provided in the case of the Chief Executive, Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. 9, p. 36. 6. He will make the like statements and returns as are provided by Art. X, Chap. II. Sec. Io, of this Constitution, in the case of the Chief Executive. 7. Said statements and returns will be published as provided by Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. I I. 8. Neglect, error, or omission, will subject him to like pains and penalties, as provided in the case of delegates, as per Art. IX, Chap. IV, Secs.'4, 5, and 6, ante p. 29. 38 FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. CHAP. III. REMUNERATION. I. The salary of the Election Minister is. -per year, paid quarterly, in advance, unless the Chief Executive shall hold the office, in which case the joint salary shall be that of the Chief Executive added to one-third that of the Election Minister. 2. He shall be allowed expenses actually incurred on journeys made on the business of the State. 3. The Legislature may make extra allowances for ex penses actually incurred by the Election Minister on par ticular occasions. 4. No gift, present or benefice of any kind may be received by the Election Minister, other than provided by this Constitution during the time that he holds the office, except such as may come to him by inheritance or bequest, or from natural or adopted parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, brother or sister. 4 ARTICLE XII. LEGISLATION MINISTER." CHAP. 1. HOW ELECTED AND REMOVED. As in the case of Election Minister, as per Art. XI, Chap. I, except that he may hold no other office in the official establishment of the State than that of Minister of Justice. (i) The necessity for such an officer as a Legislation Minister will be evident to all who know the slipshod manner in which laws now are generally framed. Even when a bill has been carefully prepared, it is so cut up by amendments as to be constantly self-contradictory and nonsensical, while laws violating the Constitutions of the United States and of the States, are fre. quently passed. 39 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION CHAP. II. DUTIES AND POWERS. The duties and powers of the Legislation Minister are: I. To prepare all such bills and projects of law as may be ordered by.the Legislature. 2. To review all bills and projects of law when passed by the Legislature, and to communicate thereon to them with a view to their reconsideration when necessary. 3. To report from time to time all bills prepared by him as well as all bills passed by the Legislature to the Minister of Justice, with such remarks thereon as he may think fit; to point out errors, inconsistencies or inaccuracies, whenever they occur therein; also to point out inconsistencies between such bills and existing laws; to suggest remedies, and to take the instructions of the Minister of Justice thereon. 4. To appoint and remove officers in his department in the same manner as provided by Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. 7, in the case of the Chief Executive with regard to executive officers, ante pp. 35-6. 5. He will appoint a deputy as provided by Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. 9, p. 36, in the case of the Chief Executive. 6. He will make the like statements and returns as are As will be seen from Chap. II of this Article it will be the duty of the Legislation Minister to obviate these mischiefs. The similarity of some of the talent required for an efficient Minister of Justice with that required for the performance of the duties of Legislation Minister, suggests the propriety of allowing the two offices to be held by one person in a State so little populous as Colorado. But the Legislation Minister needs obviously to be so dependant upon the Legislature that the latter may readily remove him with or without cause, and there seems no reason why a simple majority vote of the Legislature should not be sufficient for that purpose. Similar observations apply to the Election Minister, except that as his office is executive and rarely, and only by consent of parties, judicial, it may be appropriately given to the Chief Executive and not to the Minister of Justice. 40 i -t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. provided by Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. Io, in the case of the Chief Executive, ante p. 36. 7. Such statements and returns will be published as provided by Art. X, Chap. II, Sec. I I, ante p. 36. 8. Neglect, error, or omission, will subject him to the like pains and penalties as provided in the case of delegates as per Art. IX, Chap, IV, Secs. 4, 5, and 6, ante p. 29. CHAP. III. REMUNERATION. I. The salary of the Legislation Minister is per year, paid quarterly, in advance, unless the Minister of Justice shall hold the office, in which case the joint salary shall be that of the Minister of Justice added to one-third that of the Legislation Minister. 2. He shall be allowed expenses as provided in the case of the Election Minister, as per Art. X, Chap. III, Secs. 2 and 3, ante p. 37. 4+ ~ 3. Sec. 4 of Art. XI., Chap. III., applies also to the Legis lation Minister, ante p. 38. ARTICLE XIII. OFFICIALS GENERALLY. I. No officer of the official establishment may retain in his hands any public moneys longer than for the period of one week from the day on which he shall have received the same.' (I) It has been so much the custom for public officers, of late years, to make a profit of the public moneys, that this article, which merely glives a new sanction to the old law, will strike many persons as novel. Its importance and justice none will fail to recognize. The fact that no honest man-a trustee of public funds, would ever appropriate to himself the profit he might make on their use, coupled with the too notorious fact that in this county nearly all public officials do so, shows the extent to which the demoralizing effects of the present system have extended. 41 0 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 2. He shall deposit all such moneys in such depositary as shall be directed by law, and in the absence of such direction, it shall be his duty to apply to the officer to whom by the Constitutional Code, shall be entrusted the care of the State Finances for instructions, and shall deposit the same wherever such officer may direct. 3. If he shall doubt the expediency of the instructions given him by such officer, he shall report the same to the Chief Executive and to the Minister of Justice, together with his reasons for, and suggestions concerning, the same. 4. Any officer who shall hold in his hands any public moneys, contrary to the provisions of this Article, shall be charged compound interest thereon, after the rate of three per cent. per month, with quarterly rests.. He shall also be subject to the pains and penalties provided by the penal code. 5. Any officer of the official establishment who shall be concerned or interested in, or shall make any profit out of any contract which, in the course of his official duty, he shall have occasion to enter into, recommend, advise, supervise, or influence, shall forfeit to the State three times the total amount of such contract, or of the money paid, or agreed to be paid, thereunder, shall be forever incapable of holding any office in the State, or of being a member of the Constitutive Authority, and shall be subject to the pains and penalties provided by the penal code.2 6. Whenever the same person shall hold two or more offices in the official establishment of the State, his remu (2) This provision may put some check on the deplorable peculation now common among officials. The compelling them to give returns of their property, income and expenditure, are fitly supplemented by these provisions, and will, it is believed, do much to raise the tone of official morality. The author is acquainted with instances of peculation and corruption on the part of County Commissioners and of others, past and present, which he may use, if necessary, to enforce the provisions-of this Chapter against the " politicians." 42 f FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. neration (except in the case of the Minister of Justice or Chief Executive holding the offices of Legislation Minister or Election Minister, respectively) shall be as follows: The salary or pay of the highest paid office added to one-half the salary or pay established by law for the next highest, added to one-third the salary or pay of the next, and one-fourth of the salary or pay of the fourth.3 7. No' person may hold more than four offices in the official establishment at any one time. 8. All salaries provided by this Constitution may be changed by law passed with the Referendum. ARTICLE XIV. THE JUDICIARY. CHAP. I. The Judicial powers of the State are vested in a Minister of Justice, a Supreme Court Appellate Judges and Primary Judges. CHAP. II. THE MINISTER OF JUSTICE. SECTION I. How Elected and Removed. I. The Minister of Justice is elected by the Constitutive Authority, as provided by Art. VIII, Chap. III, Secs. 2 and I I, ante pp. I2 and I4. 2. He is removed in manner provided by Art. VIII, Chap. III, Sec. 3, Div. 2, ante p. I6. (3) When the population of the State shall be five or six millions in place of ioo,OOO, it will be proper to prohibit the holding of more thai one office by any person at one and the same time. 43 I A 7 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION 3. He may be suspended as provided by Art. IX, Chap. II, Sec. 3, Clause 2, ante p. 27. 4. His office is vacated by I. Resignation. 2. Acceptance of any other office belonging to the official establishment of this or of any other State, other than that of Legislation.Minister of this State. 3. Acceptance of any factitious honor or dignity from any foreign government other than titles denoting intellectual position or acquirement. 4. Mental derangement. 5. Criminal delinquency pronounced by the sentence of a competent tribunal. 6. Failure to make within the times prescribed the returns provided by Chap. II, Sec. 2, Clause 15, of this Article, post p.46. 7. Acceptance of any gift, present or benefice (other than may come to him by inheritance or be quest) contrary to the provisions of Chap. II, Sec. 3, of this Article, post p. 47. SECTION II. Duties and Powers. The duties and powers of the Minister of Justice are: I. To watch over the administration of Justice in all the Courts of the State. 2. To attend to and take such action as may seem expedient upon any and every complaint which may come to him from or against any officer belonging to the_judicial establishment of the State. 3. To attend to and take such action as may seem expedient upon any and every complaint which may come to him from or against any officer belonging to any branch other than the judicial, of the official establishment of the 44 -i I FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. State, after referring the same to, and conferring thereon, with the official superior of such officer. 4. To direct the institution of such proceedings as may seem to him right, against or in defence of any officer belonging to the official establishment of the State. 5. To direct the defense of proceedings instituted against the State, the treasury of the State, any branch of the government of the State, or any body politic or political corporation within the State, as he may think fit. 6. To receive and examine the reports of all Primary and Appellate judges. 7. To summon the Supreme Court to meet whenever he shall deem it necessary, and to summon such of the Primary judges as he may think fit to form part of such Court. 8. To watch over the rights declared in Article V of this Constitution, and to cause steps to be taken to prevent or punish their violation. 9. To communicate to the Legislature by message on all matters necessary or desirable for them to know or to confer with him upon. Io. To report to the Legislature at each session upon the Legislative measures he may think necessary or desirable. I I. In conjunction with the Legislation Minister to settle the drafts of bills, and review them when passed by the Legislature, and to communicate with the Legislature thereon. I2. To review the codes which shall be prepared by the Legislation Minister under the direction of the Legislature, and to communicate with the Legislature thereon. - I 3. To attend the Legislature whenever required by them so to do. - I4. To appoint all judges-Primary and Appellate, and their deputies, and all other officers of the judicial estab 45 I 4 t DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION lishment, except Constables. To transfer such officers from time to time from one district or place to another; to direct enquiry into the conduct, or the prosecution of, any of such officials. I15. He will make the like. returns, and will be subject to the like penalties for default in making such returns of his property and income, as are provided in the case of the Chief Executive, by Art. X, Chap. II, Secs. Io, and I2, ante p. 36. I6. He will appoint a deputy to act in his stead in case of his absence, sickness, or inability. He is responsible for the acts and conduct of such deputy, and may, at his pleasure, remove him and appoint another in his place. I7. He will visit every Appellate and Primary judicatory once, at least, in every year. I8: He may, in consideration of any service rendered to the State, and after public enquiry in open Court into such service, remit the whole or any part of the sentence of any person convicted of any crime., I9. He may direct a rehearing of the case of any person convicted of crime before the same as, or before any judge other than him by whom the case was tried, whenever, from the production of new evidence, or from any other cause, he may think justice has not been done.2 20. He shall reportto the Legislature all judicial recommendations for the alteration of the law received by him from any judge, and shall give his advice thereon by message to the Legislature. (I) No further pardoning power than is here given should be rested in the breast of the highest official. In all States in which a pardoning power has been vested in the governor it has proved a constant source of corruption or what is almost as pernicious -a constant source of supposed corruption. (2) Whenever an innocent man is convicted, the State owes him redress. At present his only remedy is "a pardon," adding insult to injury. Under this draft a rehearing is provided, so that justice may be done. Justice, not pardon, is what is due to an innocent man. 46 i t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. SECTION III. REMUNERATION. I. The salary of the Minister of Justice is per year, paid quarterly, in advance. 2. The provisions of Chap. III, of Art. X, Secs. 2, 3 and 4, apply also to the Minister of Justice, ante p. 37. 3. The Minister of Justice may hold conjointly with his own the office of Legislation Minister and no other. CHAP. III. PRIMARY COURTS. I. In each of the Districts mentioned in Art. III, Sec. 4, of this Constitution, a Primary Judge and a Judge-deputy, a government advocate and an eleemosynary advocate, and their several deputies, will be appointed by the Minister of Justice. 2. The Primary Judges have jurisdiction in all cases and causes of what nature, kind, or amount, soever. Every cause must be commenced in the Primary court. 3. The Primary court shall be always open. 4. Either or any party to any cause may require a jury. In the absence of such requirement the Judge will proceed to hear and determine every cause. 5, He may summon experts to sit as assessors, but shall not be bound by their opinions. The judgment to be rendered is to be rendered by him, and will be his judgment. 6. The Judge-deputy will act as Registrar of theCourt, and as Judge in the absence of the Primary Judge. The Primary Judge may depute him to go to any place to receive testimony or prepare a report on real evidence, or the evidence of things, there to be found. Any party to a cause may decline to have it adjudicated by the Judge-deputy. 47 I 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION CHAP. IV. APPELLATE COURTS. I. There are...I Appellate Districts in the State. 2. The First Appellate District comprises, and its court is the Appellate Court from, the following Primary Districts and Courts: * * * * * * 3. The Second Appellate District comprises, and its court is the Appellate Court from the following Primary Districts and Courts- * * * * * 4. The Third Appellate District comprises and its court is the Appellate Court from the following Primary Districts and Courts- * * * * * * * 5. The Fourth Appellate District 6. The number of, and the Primary and Appellate Districts may be changed by law from time to time. 7. An Appellate Judge and Judge-deputy, a government advocate, and an eleemosynary advocate, and their respective deputies, will be appointed in each Appellate District by the Minister of Justice. 8. From every final judgment of a Primary Judge an appeal lies to the Appellate Court in whose District the Primary Court is contained. 9. The Appellate Courts will be always open. IO. The Judge-Appellate-deputy will act as Registrar of the Court, and as Judge in the absence of the Appellate Judge. Any party to a cause may, however, refuse to have it adjudicated by the Judge-deputy. The deputy will attend to such judicial business as may be deputed-to him by the Appellate Judge, and will report all his proceedings therein to such Appellate Judge, who will confirm, reverse or vary the same, as he may think right. (I) Four or five, as discussion may determine to be desirable. 48 t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. I I. After the period of three years, no person will be appointed to the office of a Primary Judge who shall not have completed two full service years of not less than three hundred days each, of actual service in court, or on judicial business without the court, as deputy to the Minister of Justice or Legislation Minister, or as a deputy Primary or Appellate Judge; nor to the office of Government Advocate or Eleemosynary Advocate, unless he shall have served, in like manner and for the like period, as deputy to one of the said Ministers, or to a government or eleemos3nary Advocate. i2. After the like period of three years no person will be appointed an Appellate Judge who has not filled the office of Primary Judge. I3. Whenever it shall appear to any judge that the law, as it exists, would, if put in force in a case before him, work an injustice, he shall be at liberty to make a decree suspending judgment until the will of the Legislature is expressed or ascertained. From any such decree by a Primary Judge, either party, or the government or eleemosynary Advocate, though not before engaged in the case, may enter an appeal on behalf of the people or of any party to the cause authorizing the same, to the proper Appellate Judge. If no such appeal be taken, or if taken, if the decree suspensory be confirmed, or if such decree be made in the first instance on the hearing of an appeal by an Appellate Judge, the judge making such decree shall make a report thereof to the Minister of Justice and another to the Clerk of the Legislature, with a recommendation of such legislation as he may think fit. If the Legislature shall at its then present, or, if not then in session, at its next succeeding session, pass a law in ac — cordance with the recommendation of such judge, or in accordance with the advice of the Minister of Justice, the judge shall make a decree in accordance with such new 49 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION law. If no action shall be taken by the Legislature in the session then present, or if not then in session, at its session next succeeding the date of the suspensory decree, the judge shall give judgment in accordance with the law; Provided, That no new law shall render criminal an act which was not a violation of the penal code at the time it was committed. I4. Justice shall be administered gratuitously. No fees shall be asked or received from any litigant; but as part of his judgment the judge may assess against either party a sum to be paid by him by way of penalty for having improperly or unnecessarily instituted or defended a cause, or improperly or unnecessarily denied or required his opponent to prove a fact within, or which ought to have been within the knowledge of such party. All sums so assessed shall, when collected, form part of the "Judicial fund," and shall be paid over to the proper financial officer of the State by the officer who may collect the same. I 5. Every person convicted of a violation of the Penal code shall be sentenced to pay such sum as to the judge shall seem a proper proportion of the expenses of the judicial establishment, appropriate to the case. 16. In all cases of prosecution for a violation of the Penal code, the party believed, or alleged to be aggrieved, shall, unless he object thereto, be made a civil party against the accused, and may recover a civil judgment in the same proceeding. I7. In cases of homicide, the widow or widower, child or children, and any or every person dependent upon the deceased may be made a civil party complainant, and may recover damages against the person or persons guilty of the homicide. I8. In all cases of violations of the Penal code, reparation to the party injured shall be the main object of all judicial proceedings. 50 0 -t t FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. CHAP. V. JUDICIAL OFFICERS-HOW REMOVED. I. The offices of Primary Judge and deputy, of Appellate Judge and deputy, of government and eleemosynary Advocates, and of their deputies, may be vacated: I. By resignation. '2. By acceptance of any other office belonging to the official establishment of this or of any other State. 3. By any of the means numbered 3, 4, or 5, of Art. XIV, Chap. II, Sec. I, Clause 4, of this Con stitution. 4. By failure to make to the Minister of Justice statements and returns of property and in come like to those, and within the like periods as are provided to be made to the Clerk of the Legislature by delegates, as per Art. IX, Chap. 4, Secs. 3, 4, 5, ante pp. 28-9. 5. By failure to make to the Minister of Justice the returns provided to be made by Chap. VII of this Article. 6. By acceptance by any judge or deputyjudge of any gift, present or benefice (other than may come to him by inheritance, bequest, or by gift from natural or adopted parent, grand parent, child, grandchild, brother or sister) beyond his salary and allowances, as provided by Chap. VI of this Article. 7. By removal for cause, after enquiry had by the Minister of Justice. 8. By transfer or promotion to some other judicial office. CHAP. VI, REMUNERATION OF JUDICIAL OFFICERS. I. The salary of each Primary Judge is ten dollars per diem, payable monthly, for each day's actual attendance in (5) - } .51 4 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION court, or on the business of his office outside of the court house. 2. The deputy has no salary for the first two complete service years of not less than three hundred days each of actual service in court, or on judicial business without the court-house. Thereafter his salary will be per diem for each day's actual attendance in court, or on judicial business without the court-house. 3. The salary of the Primary Government Advocate is per diem, payable monthly, for each day's actual attendance on the judicial business of the government. 4. His deputy receives no salary unless the people's advocate elect to pay him. 5. The salary of the Eleemosynary Advocate is for each day's actual attendance in court. It is his duty to attend the court each day and to watch every case in the interests of justice; to act as the advocate of every person who desires his assistance, and is unable to hire assistance elsewhere. Instead of receiving the per diem above provided, he may elect to be remunerated by the person desiring his assistance, with the consent and by contract with such person and with the approval of the Judge. 6. The deputy of the Eleemosynary Advocate receives no salary unless the Eleemosynary Advocate elect to pay him. 7. The salary of each Appellate Judge is $4,00ooo per an'num, payable monthly, in advance. It is subject to a deduction of $20 for each day's delay in the hearing and determining of any cause on appeal, occasioned-by the absence of the Appellate Judge from the Appellate courthouse, unless occasioned by sickness or by attendance upon judicial business without the court-house, or unless the appeal so delayed was taken during the absence of the Appellate Judge during any of the periods not exceeding 52. i FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. six weeks in the aggregate in any one year that said Appellate Judge may be absent, by leave of the Minister of Justice, for a vacation, and no opportunity shall have since happened for its being heard and decided. 8. The Appellate-Judge-deputy has no salary for the first two complete service years of not less than three hundred days each of actual service in court, or on judicial business without the court-house. Thereafter he will receive a salary of per diem for each day's actual attendance in court or on judicial business without the courthouse. 9. Every judge, judge-deputy, government and eleemosynary advocate, and their respective deputies, may be allowed by the Minister of Justice such expenses as are mentioned in the case of the Election Minister, Art. XI, Chap. III, Sec. 2, ante p. 41. Io. No judge or judge-deputy may receive any gift, present, or benefice of any kind (other than may come to him by inheritanae or bequest, or from a natural or adopted parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, brother or sister) during the time that he holds his office. CHAP. VII. JUDGES' JUDICIAL REPORTS. I. Once in every month each judge shall transmit to the Minister of Justice a true abstract of all the business done in his court, shewing the nature of each litigation, and of the evidence therein, its condition at the date of making the return the disposition made of it, and if appealed, the result of the appeal when known. Also, the attendance given in court or on judicial business without the courthouse, of such judge and judge-deputy and of the attendance in court, and of attendance alleged to have been given on government judicial business without the court-house of each government and eleemosynary advocate and of their respective deputies. 53 4 54 DRAFT OF A CONSTITUTION FOR THE STATE OF COLORADO. 2. The report above provided to be made shall be drawn up by the judge-deputy from the records kept by him, and shall be subscribed both by the judge and by the judgedeputy, each of whom shall be responsible for its accuracy. CHAP. VIII. THE SUPREME COURT. I. The Supreme Court shall consist of the Minister of Justice who will be its President, of the Appellate Judges, and of such of the Primary Judges as the Minister of Justice may from time to time summon to sit as Justices thereof. 2. Four of its members will constitute a court. 3. It will take original cognizance of all enquiries into the conduct of any official belonging to the official establishment of the State, that may be referred to it by the Minister of Justice, by the Chief Executive, or by the Legislature, and will give such judgment of acquittal, reprimand, suspension or removal, with such disabilities as may be provided by law, as to said court may seem just. 4. It will convene whenever summoned by the Minister of Justice or by the Legislature. 5. It will consider all questions submitted to it by the Minister of Justice or by any Judge, but it has no power to give judgment in any cause except as provided in Sec. 3 of this Chapter. 6. The judgments of all Appellate and Primary Judges will be conformed to the opinions of the Supreme Court on questions submitted to it, in all then pending an. future causes. i ,i ' "t,II ;,'I, "I, Page 3, Advertisement, strike out name of E. J. Mallet, Jr.; insert names of James F. WVi]bur and Geo. H. Church. " 4, line 13, for "8th" read 6th. " 6, line I4, for "consequence" read consequences. 6, last line but one, for "charter" read charters. ' IS, line 4, for "appellat" read appellate. " 9, line II, for " 13 an(l 15" read I4 and I6. 22, last line but two, for " extend " read extent. 33, last line but two, for "following" read follows. 34, last line, for "clause 4" read clauses 4 and 7. v. Ia i I I GALENA ORES. THE VIRGINIA SMELTING AND REFINING COMPANY, OF ST. LOUIS, Mo., -PAYS THE IIGEEST PRICE IN CAS: HIGH GRADE LEAD ORES Contaihing the least quantity of Silver; but will allow for Silver, if rich in Lead. Represented by HENRY BROOKS, C. E. Address, P.O. Box 22io, DENVER. SILVER GALENA ORES. THE HIGHEST PRICE IN CASH WILL BE PAID FOR GALENA ORES. None desired with less than 30 per cent. Lead and 20 oZs. of Silver, or, if of higher grade in Silver, not less than 20 per cent. Lead. WILLIAM LAWSON, 2~pi~t0o 3J -$=?ilin Wlork,-s DENVER, COLORADO. Io I PHOTOGRAPH ERS! The Finest Stereoscopic Views ever taken in Colorado, "The Switzerland of America," PORTRAITS IN EVERY STYLE. 440 LARIMER ST., (bet. I7th and I8th Sts.) DENVER, COL. Country Home and Board! AT GLEN PLYM, ONE OF THE MOST ROMANTICALLY LOCATED AND COMFORT ABLE FARMS IN COLORADO. J. WI LIAlSON, LITTLETON P. O., Arapahoe County, Col. ED'WAR D:PISKO, DEALER IN WINES LIQUORS, 391 LARIfER ST'REET, DBYNVR, COLOR4DO. .Bourdeaux and Rye Whiskies. Imported and Domestic Wines at Eastern prices. CHICAGO LAW BOOK HOUSE. IF,. B. M'V ]Y-EIIIS, CLAW BOOK-SELLER AND PUBLISHER, 93 WASHINGTON STREET, CHICAGO. 1Send for Catalogue. HENSE & COTTESLEBEN, MANUFACTURERS OF lXT.A_-T I'V JE'- El:E T,t:Y, 388 Larimer Street, J. H. HENSE, P. GOTTESLEBEN, I DENVER, COL. F. NICHOLL, -CIVIL, MINING, AND HYDRAULIC ENGINEER AND T.Land Surveyor. U. S. Deputy Mining Surveyor. Denver, Col. OHN WHITLEY, - ATTORNEY AND COUNSELLOR AT LAW, MINING J Agent, Denver, Colorado. Office-No. 2, Ruter Block, s6th (G) Street. X3H1E: 13R3S., Alddress, ESTABLISHED A. D. i86o. THE DAILY AND WEEKLY NEW DEMOCRATIC JOURNAL. NEW DEMOORATIC JOURNAL. rUBLISHED IN p)ENVER, BY THE SENTINEL PUBLISHING COMPANY. .... ~. _. w-Ir I, ii S. -" THE DAILY SENTINEL, published every morning, except Sun days. 28 columns, is furnished to mail subscribers. postage paid, for $io.oo a year in advance. THE WEEKLY SENTINEL. 36 columns, is sent by mail, post age paid, for $2.50 a year, invariably in advance. .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ JOB OFFICE. 4A large and firsl-class _ob Printing Office in connection with the SENTINEL office, and on all wVork satisfaction piaranteed. DAVID KLINE, Jobber and Retail Dealer in BOOTS J SHOES 343 LtA%IIEE STEEET, DENVER, COL. '.. I- LL & EBROS. SDEALERS IN Staple and Fancy Groceries, AND RANCH PRODU0CE, 253 15TH STEET, NEAR {ARIMER, JEN.VER. 53 1_ WGOODS DELIVERED FREE. I SPORTMEN'S DEPOTL BLAKE STREET JoHNae & Rl ER Wholesale & Retail Dealer in all kinds of itgat m,apvel tl'rEso tca,'lg UA.OT~ itiloAl PISTOLS. COLT'S a&d SMITH & WESSON'$ RBVO.IL VERS, SHARP'S,WESSON'S, WINCHESTER AND REMINGTON RIFLES, AND CARTRIDGES FOR SAME. AGENT FOR PARKER'S BREECH-LOADING DOUBLE CUN. i~ISXI-IIC TAC KLE3, Sporting Goods, Field and Spy Glasses, Microscopes, Hunting Knives, Pocket Cutlery, In dian Beads and Ornaments, AT LOWEST MARKET RATES. SEND FOR CATALOGUE CIRCULAR. DENVER, COL. WM. DINGLE, I..PHAR1MA( CEUT][ST 0 V~CMI][ST9 I 350 Larimer St., between 14th and 15th Sts., DENVER, COL. PRESCRIPTIONS ACCURATELY COMPOUNDED AT ALL HOURS OP THE DAY OR NIGHT. S. B. HARDY. PARLOR BOOK STORE. J. A. CHAIN. CHAIN & HARDY, BOOKSELLERS o STATIO ENBS, A FULL LINE Rocky Mounlltain Scenery Constantly in Stock. MOULDINGS AND FANCY GOODS. 414 Larimer Street, - ------ DENVER, COL. t f