3 1822 01221 0787 3 1822 01221 0787 PR. 35/6 1 8 A v,/ 'A XHK WORKS OF JOHN HOME, ESQ. from ail original Picture in rtu- posst-asion of SirO Wa Av A- r,-n.tt>iMr I f "T I U >J O^k") rT i THE WORKS OF JOHN HOME, ESQ. NOW FIRST COLLECTED. TO WHICH IS PREFIXED, AN ACCOUNT OP HIS LIFE AND WRITINGS. BY HENRY MACKENZIE, ESQ. F. R. S. E. &c. &c. &c. IN THREE VOLUMES. VOL. I. EDINBURGH : PRINTED FOR ARCHIBALD CONSTABLE AND CO. EDINBURGH ; AND HURST, ROBINSON, AND CO. LONDON. 1822. 11 O W Printed by James BullaiUync and Co. Edinburgh, TO THE READER. THE reader of this Biographical Account may perhaps be surprised to find it now given to the public in the same form as it was originally read to the Royal Society of Edinburgh. In truth, there was at that time no intention of publishing it, as I con- ceived the life of Mr Home, the situation of the friends with whom he was connect- ed, and the circumstances of the time in which he lived, to be so locally peculiar to Scotland, that they would not interest read- ers of the sister kingdom. It was afterwards, VOL. i. a vi TO THE HEADER. however, strongly urged by some friends, for whose opinion I have great respect, that the literature of this country had now be- come so much an object of attention to our southern neighbours, that any details rela- ting to it, given by one who had known it almost from its first dawning to the present time, would interest the English nearly, if not quite, as much as the Scots reader. Still, however, diffident af its value in the more formal shape of a book, I chose to give it to the world, under the protection, as it were, of the Society to which it had been read, in the less assuming form in which itwas pre- sented to that learned body. I have now another motive for this, which is still more egotistical, and for which, therefore, I am not sure if I can claim the sympathy of the reader. In reviewing these sheets, as they were read to the Eoyal Society, I feel the melancholy indulgence (natural to my period of life,) of recalling the times and occasions TO THE READER. Vll when they were originally produced; times and occasions which live in my recollection, associated with the tender remembrance of those literary friends whom I have, alas ! survived, but who remain, and, while I live, will remain, hallowed in my sense of their talents and their worth. ll I :.Hi! CONTENTS. VOLUME I. PAGE. ACCOUNT or THE LIFE OF Ma JOHN HOME 1 Appendix to Biographical Account of Mr John Home, consist- ing of Letters to and from ,his Friends 123 DRAMATIC WORKS. Dedication 185 AGIS ........ 189 DOUGLAS 287 VOLUME II. SIEGE OF AQUILEIA 1 THE FATAL DISCOVERY 89 ALONZO 179 ALFRED 27 A HISTORY OF THE REBELLION, 1745. Dedication 375 Preface 377 CHAPTER I. The Subject. Introduction. Extent and Limits of the High- lands of Scotland. Manners of the Highlanders. Clanship. The Highlanders inferior to the Lowlanders in Arms. When and how they became superior. Their Attachment to the Family of Stuart. They take Arms at every Crisis of Pub- lic Affairs. Measure suggested to reconcile them to Govern- ment. Approved by Sir Robert Walpole. Recommended by him to the Cabinet Council. Rejected by the Cabinet Council. Britain declares War against Spain 384 VI CONTENTS. PAGE. CHAPTER II. Conspiracy to restore the Family of Stuart Engagement to take Arms Sent to the Old Pretender Transmitted by him to Cardinal Fleury. War at the Death of Charles VI. Emperor of Germany. The House of Austria attacked Assisted by Great Britain. Cardinal Fleury sends an Agent to Edinburgh. Plan of Invasion. Death of Cardinal Fleury. Succeeded by Cardinal de Tencin. Charles Stuart arrives at Paris Goes to Dunkirk. The Troops begin to embark. Design of Invasion frustrated by a Storm. Charles embarks for Scotland Lands in the Highlands 409 VOLUME III. CHAPTER III. Charles at Boradale His Interview with Lochiel Resolves to erect his Standard. Commencement of Hostilities. Sir John Cope His Correspondence with the Secretary of State Marches towards Fort Augustus. The Rebels take post on his way to the Fort. Sir John changes his Route. The Rebels advance to the Southward. Alarm at Edinburgh Condition of the City. The Rebels take possession of Perth. Petition of the Citizens of Edinburgh for Leave to take Arms The Petition granted. Observations 3 CHAPTER IV. Preparations to defend the City. Transports sent for General Cope's Army. Notice that the Rebels had left Perth Their March. Conduct of the Volunteers. The Highland- ers advance towards Edinburgh. Retreat of the Dragoons. Consternation in the City. Meeting of the Magistrates and Citizens Proceedings of the Meeting. Deputation sent to Charles. Notice that the Transports are off Dunbar. Re- turn of the Deputies. Another Deputation sent out. The Deputies ordered to be gone. The Rebels get Possession of the City 38 CONTENTS. Vll PAGE. CHAPTER V. Charles comes to Holyrood House. His Father proclaimed. The Dragoons join Sir John Cope His march towards Edinburgh Receives Information of the Rebels advancing to meet him Forms his Army to receive the Enemy The Rebels come in sight. A Morass between the Armies. Va- rious Movements till Night. The Rebels pass the Morass. The Battle of Preston TO CHAPTER VI. Charles at Holyrood House Resolutions of his Council. Con- test with General Guest in the Castle. The Rebels reinfor- ced. Some Ships arrive from France. Correspondence of Charles with the Chiefs. Of the Chiefs with one another. Their Engagements to join the Rebel Army. Message by Lord Lovat's Secretary. Embarrassment of Charles and his Council. Resolution and Preparations to March into Eng- land. Number of the Rebels when they left Edinburgh . 98 CHAPTER VII. March of the Rebels towards Carlisle. Carlisle invested. Ge- neral Wade at Newcastle. Charles marches to Brampton. The Duke of Perth sent back to' besiege Carlisle. The Mayor capitulates. The Rebels take possession of the City. Dissension in their Army. Cause of Dissension. The Cause removed. A Council of War. Order sent to Lord Strath- allan. March of the Rebels from Carlisle. They arrive at Derby. Council held at Derby. Resolution of the Council to march back. The Retreat begins. The Duke of Cum- berland pursues. Skirmish, at Clifton. The Rebels con- tinue their march. Cross the Esk, and return to Scotland 117 CHAPTER VIII. State of Scotland while the Rebel Army was in England. Preparations for War. Head-Quarters of both Armies Skirmish at Inverury. Number of the Rebels Contention and Animosity amongst them. Charles marches to Stirling The Town surrenders. The Rebels besiege the Castle. General Hawley marches to raise the Siege. The two Annies Vlll CONTENTS. FA 01. meet at Falkirk. The King's Array defeated. The Rebels take possession of Falkirk Tumult and Mutiny in their Army. The Duke of Cumberland arrives at Edinburgh Marches to attack the Rebels They retreat to the High- lands. Escape, from the Castle of Downe, of the Volunteers taken Prisoners after the Battle of Falkirk 132 CHAPTER IX. The Duke of Cumberland pursues the Rebels Halts at Perth Sends several Detachments of his Army to different Places. The Prince of Hesse, with a Body of his Troops, escorted by Ships of War, arrives in the Frith of Forth. The Duke of Cumberland comes from Perth to visit the Prince of Hesse. A Council of War at Edinburgh. The Duke of Cumberland returns to Perth Sends several Regi- ments to Dundee Marches himself with the main Body of his Army to Aberdeen Halts there some time. Charles with a few Men at Moy, near Inverness. An attempt made by Lord London to seize him. The attempt defeated. Charles assembles his Men Marches to Inverness. Lord Loudon retreats to Ross-shire. Charles besieges the Castle of Inverness. The Castle surrenders. Various Expeditions of the Rebels while the Duke's Army lay at Aberdeen. Ac- count of these Expeditions. An Order from Charles to the Commanding Officers to desist from them, and join him at Inverness 176 CHAPTER X. The Duke of Cumberland at Aberdeen. His Army leaves Aberdeen Proceeds towards Inverness. Skirmish at the Bridge of Nairne. The Rear-guard of the Rebels retreats The Van-guard of the Duke's Army pursues. Charles comes up with a Body of his Troops. The Van-guard of the Duke's Army retreats Joins their main Body. Design of a Night Attack. Night March of the Rebels. The De- sign frustrated. The Rebels retreat to Culloden. March of the Duke of Cumberland to attack them. Defeat and Dispersion of the Rebel Army. . . 187 CONTENTS. IX PA.OS. CHAPTER XI. Circumstances and Incidents at the Battle of Culloden. Num- ber of the Slain in both Armies. Fate of the Chiefs who commanded the Highland Regiments that attacked the King's Army. Route of Charles when he left the Field Crosses the River of Nairn Halts there some time Goes to Gorthleek Sees Lord Lovat Travels through the High- lands to Boradale Embarks for the Long Island His Danger and Distress there Returns to the Main-land His Distress does not abate Joins Lochiel and Cluny Lives with them in the Great Mountain Senalder. Notice comes that two French Frigates are arrived at Boradale. He travels to Boradale Embarks, and lands in France 222 APPENDIX. I. Letter from the Old Pretender, addressed to Mr Johnstone, 'junior, that is, Young Lochiel. April llth, 1727 . . . 253 II. Letter from Allan Cameron to his Nephew, Young Lochiel. Albano, October 3d, 1729 . 254 III. Letter from the Old Pretender to one of his Adherents in Scotland. March llth, 1743 259 IV. Answers to some Queries sent to a Person in Scotland, by the Pretender, or some of the people about him. Edinburgh, January 8th, 1736 262 Correspondence between the Marquis of Tweedale, Secretary of State, and Lord Milton, Justice Clerk, from the first surmise of a Rebellion. V. Letter from the Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton, Whitehall, July 30th, 1745 265 VI. Lord Milton's Answer. Roseneath, August 4th, 1745 .269 VII. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale. Rose- neath, August 7th, 1745 269 VIII. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale. Roseneath, August 10th, 1745 270 IX. Letter Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. White- hall, August 13th, 1745 272 X CONTENTS. PAGE. X. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale Brun- stane, August 20th, 1745 274 XI. Letter from the Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. Whitehall, August 22d, 1745 275 XII. Letter Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. Whitehall, 24th August, 1745 276 XIII. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale. Brun- stane, 29th August, 1745 278 XIV. Letter Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. White- hall, 29th August, 1745 280 XV. Letter from the Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. Whitehall, 3d September, 1745 1 281 XVI. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale. Edin- burgh, 6th September, 1745 282 XVII. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale. Edinburgh, 7th September, 1745 284 XVIII. Letter Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. White- hall, 12th September, 1745 286 XIX. Letter Lord Milton to the Marquis of Tweedale. Edinburgh, 16th September, 1745 289 XX. Letter from the Marquis of Tweedale to Lord Milton. Whitehall, 21st September, 1745 296 XXI. Letter from the Lord President to Sir Alexander Mac- donald. Culloden, 19th August, 19th August, 1745 . . . 298 XXII. Letter from the Lord President to Sir John Cope. Cul- loden, 20th August, 1745 301 XXIII. Letter Sir John Cope to Lord Milton. From the Camp at Inverness, 31st August, 1745 305 XXIV. Letter Lord Milton to Mr Maule, afterwards Baron Maule. Edinburgh, Sept. 6th, 1745 308 XXV. Letter General Guest to Lord Milton. Thursday Morning 307 XXVI. Letter Lord Milton to Sir John Cope. Edinburgh, 5th September, 1745 '307 XXVII. Letter concerning the Arms of the Highlanders, dated Kilmuir, in the Isle of Skye 309 XXVIII. Instructions for Mr Alexander Macleod, Advocate . 310 XXIX. Letter from Eraser of Foyers to the Duke of Athole. October 9th, 1745 313 CONTENTS. XI PAGE. XXX. Queries sent to Mr Patullo, with his Answers. Patullo had been Muster-master of the Rebel army, in the Year 1745, and had lived in Exile at Paris many years . . . 314 XXXI. Letter from Lord Milton to the Duke of Argyll, at London. Edinburgh, 21st November, 1745 318 XXXII. John Hay's Account of the Retreat of the Rebels from Derby , 321 XXXIII. Queries sent to Charles at Rome, called there the Count of Albany, with his Answer 228 XXXIV. Letter from Macpherson of Cluny to one of his Friends in Scotland. Carlisle, 20th December, 1745 . . 325 XXXV. Letter Lord John Drummond to Lord Fortrose. Perth, 6th December, 1745 327 XXXVI. Letter from the Duke of Newcastle to Lord Milton. Whitehall, 14th December, 1745 829 XXXVII. Letter from the Duke of Newcastle to the Lord President. Whitehall, llth January, 1746 ...... .332 XXXVIII. Letter Lord Milton to General Hawley. Edin- burgh, Jan. eeth, 1746 334 XXXIX. Address from the Chiefs to Charles, after the Bat- tle of Falkirk, advising a Retreat to the North. Falkirk, 29th January, 1746 335 XL. John Hay's Account of the Retreat from Stirling . . 338 XLI. Letter Secretary Murray to Cameron of Lochiel. Fort Augustus, 14th March, 1746 839 XLII. Copy Letter Lord George Murray, calling himself De Vallignie, to Mr William Hamilton, Esq. of Bangour. Em- merick, 5th August, 1749 342 XLI 1 1. John Hay's Account of the Retreat after the Night March to attack the Duke's Army at Nairn 355 XLIV. Answer by Charles, called the Count of Albany, at Rome 357 XLV. Narrative of Flora Macdonald, giving an Account of her Interviews with Charles, in the Long Island, and the Manner in which she conducted him to the Isle of Skye . 358 XLVI. Cluny's Account of Lochiel and himself, after the Battle of Culloden ; of their meeting with Charles ; and the extraordinary Habitation called the Cage, where Charles XII CONTKNT8. PACK. lived with them, till he received notice that two French Fri- gates were arrived at Lochnanuagh $62 XLVII. Resolutions by the Rebel Chiefs, after the Battle of Culloden. Muirlaggan, 8th May, 1746 869 X LVIII. Letter from Lochiel to Cluny. Locharkaik, 13th May, 1746 . . 373 XLIX. Letter Secretary Murray to Macpherson of Cluny. Invermeley, 19th May, 1746 374 L. Letter from Lochiel to some of the Chiefs, who had agreed to take arms. 25th May, 1746 876 LI. Extracts from his Majesty's State Papers, relative to Scot- land, in the Year 1745-6 377 ACCOUNT OF THE LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME * THE biography of literary men is generally little more than a chronological account of their works, with a few private anecdotes, which, except being connected with, and, as it were, ennobled by their works, it could not be an object to record. But with that connection in their favour, the else un- valued circumstances of their lives acquire an in- terest with the reader proportionate to that which the writings of the author have excited ; and we are anxious to know every little occurrence which befel him who was giving, at the period when these occurrences took place, the product of his mind to the public. We are anxious to know how the world treated the man who was labouring for its instruction or amusement, as well as the effect * Read at the Royal Society, on Monday, 22d June 1812. VOL. I. A 2 ACCOUNT OF THE which his private circumstances had on his literary productions, or the complexion, as one may term it, which those productions borrowed from the inci- dents of his life. The above considerations afford an apology for the narratives of the comparatively unimportant occupations which the world peruses with so much attention and interest ; they help that personifica- tion of an author which the reader of his work so naturally indulges ; and if they sometimes put that reader right in his estimate of the influence of genius or feeling upon conduct, they serve at the same time as a moral lesson on the subject, and mark, as it were, one of the unexpected shores or islands, sometimes it may be rocks or quicksands, on the chart of life. The subject of the Memoir which I now take the liberty of laying before the Society, is some- what more entitled to notice than the common bio- graphy of mere literary men, from the peculiar cir- cumstances in which the person of whom it treats was placed ; and more particularly as he began to write in the dawn of that period of literary emi- nence which our countrymen have so much illus- trated, and was extremely intimate with most of those men to whom Scotland owes so much of its reputation in the world of letters. It is on this ground chiefly that I venture to submit it to the Society, not as a thing of any va- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 3 lue in itself, but as borrowing some estimation from the era of which it speaks, and the names which that era introduces to their notice. It is only with reference to this sort of chronicle that it pretends to claim your attention, and that he who reads it could now pretend to make it worthy of your hearing. That waning age, and often inter- rupted health, which have so long delayed its pro- duction, even in a very imperfect state, have blunt- ed, he is well aware, those powers which the world were kindly disposed to estimate, more from their application and tendency than from their intrinsic worth. The first favoured lot of age is to retain its powers undecayed ; the next is his who is sensible of their decay, and diffident of their exertions. The Society will pardon this little digression of egotism in one who will never probably be heard by it again in the first person, and who scarce pre- sumes to expect that any partial friends will deem him of importance enough to recal him to its re- membrance in the third. JOHN HOME, of whose life I am to read the fol- lowing sketch, was born at Leith, on the 22d day of September, 1722, O. S. He was the son of Mr Alexander Home, town-clerk of Leith, and Mrs Christian Hay, daughter of Mr John Hay, writer in Edinburgh, of a respectable family in the north 4 ACCOUNT OF THE of Scotland. His father was a son of Mr Home of Flass, in the county of Berwick, a lineal descend- ant of Sir James Home of Cowdenknows, ancestor of the present Earl of Home. Mr Home (according to the narrative, for which I am indebted to an intimate friend and relation of his) was educated at the Grammar School of Leith, and the University of Edinburgh. In both these seminaries he prosecuted his studies with re- markable diligence and success. While he attend- ed the University, his talents, his progress in lite- rature, and his peculiarly agreeable manners, soon excited the attention, and procured him in no small degree the favour, both of the professors and of his fellow students. At this early period of life he en- tered into strict bonds of friendship with the late Drs Robertson, Blair, Drysdale, and several others, of whom I shall, in a subsequent part of this Me- moir, give a more particular account. As he was educated with a view to obtain a si- tuation as a minister of the Church of Scotland, his studies were, of course, for some time principal- ly calculated to qualify him for the performance of the several duties incumbent on a clergyman. His character as a zealous and accomplished student, became in a few years very conspicuous. After passing, with much approbation, through the va- rious trials, which candidates for acquiring the sta- tion of probationers for the ministry are required LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 5 to undergo, he was licensed to preach the gospel by the Presbytery of Edinburgh on the 4th day of April 1745, O. S. His sincere attachment to the ecclesiastical and civil constitution of his country was, with his usual warmth and openness of mind, displayed in some of his early appearances in the pulpit. The progress of his professional studies and oc- cupations was interrupted by the breaking out of the Rebellion in 1745. This furnished an occa- sion for that military ardour, that chivalrous spirit, which his natural temperament and favourite course of reading had produced and fostered. He took the side of whiggism, as whiggism was then under- stood, and freedom, as British freedom was then conceived, and became a volunteer in a loyal corps, which was formed in Edinburgh with the original purpose of defending that city from the attack of the rebels, of which he has given a full account in his History of that Rebellion. In this corps he served at the unfortunate battle of Falkirk, and, after the defeat, was taken prisoner along with some others of his fellow volunteers, and commit- ted to the Castle of Doune in Perthshire, from which the party contrived to escape by cutting their bed-clothes into ropes, and letting themselves down from the window of the room in which they were confined. One of their number (Mr Bar- O ACCOUNT OF THE row,* a young English student, then in Edinburgh, an early and intimate acquaintance of Mr Home's) broke his leg in the descent; but Mr Home es- caped unhurt, and, eluding the vigilance of the Ja- cobite party, who, in truth, were neither very ac- tive nor rigid in their measures of precaution or of resentment, took up his residence for some time with his relations at Leith, and applied himself to that sort of study which his intended clerical pro- fession required, but always mixed, if not interrupt- ed, by the kind of reading to which his inclination led, that of the historians and classics of Greece and Rome. His temper was of that warm susceptible kind which is caught with the heroic and the tender, and which is more fitted to delight in the world of senti- ment than to succeed in the bustle of ordinary life. This is a disposition of mind well suited to the poeti- cal character, and, accordingly, all his earliest com- panions agree that Mr Home was from his child- hood delighted with the lofty and heroic ideas which embody themselves in the description or nar- rative of poetry. One of them, nearly a coeval of Mr Home's, our respected and venerable colleague Dr. A. Ferguson, says, in a letter to me, that Mr Home's * Mr Barrow was the " Genial youth" mentioned in Col- lins's Ode on the Superstitions of the Highlands. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 7 favourite model of a character, on which, indeed, his own was formed, was that of Young Norval, in his tragedy of Douglas, one endowed with chivalrous valour and romantic generosity, eager for glory be- yond every other object, and, in the contemplation of future fame, entirely regardless of the present objects of interest or ambition. It was upon this ideal model of excellence that Mr Home's own character was formed, and the same glowing com- plexion of mind which gave it birth, coloured the sentiments and descriptions of his ordinary dis- course ; he had a very retentive memory, and was fond of recalling the incidents of past times, and of dramatizing his stories by introducing the names and characters of the persons concerned in them. The same turn of mind threw a certain degree of elevation into his language, and heightened the narrative in which that language was employed ; he spoke of himself with a frankness which a man of that disposition is apt to indulge, but with which he sometimes forgot that his audience was not al- ways inclined to sympathize, and thence he was accused of more vanity than in truth belonged to his character. The same warm colouring was em- ployed in the delineation of his friends, to whom, in his estimation, he assigned a rank which others did not always allow. So far did he carry this propensity, that, as Dr Robertson used jokingly to say, he invested them with a sort of supernatural 8 ACCOUNT OF THE privilege above the ordinary humiliating circum- stances of mortality. " He never (said the Doc- tor) would allow that a friend was sick till he heard of his death." To the same source might be tra- ced the warm eulogium which he was accustomed to bestow on them. " He delighted in bestowing as well as in receiving what is generally termed flattery, (says another of his intimates,) but with him it had all the openness and warmth of truth. He flatter- ed all of us from whom his flattery could gain no favour, fully as much, or, indeed, more willingly, than he did those men of the first consequence and rank with whom the circumstances of his future life associated him, and he received any praise from us with the same genuine feelings of friendship and attachment." There was no false coinage in this currency which he used in his friendly intercourse ; whether given or received, it had with him the stamp of perfect candour and sincerity. Those companions at this early period of his youth were chiefly found among young men employed in the same studies, and destined for the same^profes- sion with himself, that of the Church of Scotland. The clergy of Scotland were at that time one of the most respectable as well as happy orders of the people. With the advantages always of a classical, and sometimes of a polite education, their know- ledge was equal or superior to that of any man in their parish. Their influence in those times, be- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 9 fore a number of different sectaries had withdrawn themselves from the established church, was great and universal, and their incomes, taken with refer- ence to the value of money, the state of manners, and style of living at that period, were much more adequate to all the purposes of comfort and decent appearance than their stipends of the present day, after all the augmentations which have been grant- ed them. At that period, when the value of land was low, when the proprietors of a parish lived more at home, when there were fewer outlets for their younger sons, and when those younger sons did not so often as they now do bring back great wealth, its attendant pretensions and its attendant luxuries, to their native districts, the clergyman of the parish stood high in the scale of rank among his parishioners, and, as I well remember, was able to maintain a certain style of plain and cordial hos- pitality, which gave him all the advantages of ra- tional gentleman-like society. The General As- sembly of the Church of Scotland gave its clergy an opportunity of occasional visits to the metropo- lis, and of a situation in that truly popular assem- bly which brought them to a level, and mixed them for a time, with gentlemen of the first rank and re- spectability in the country. In point of weight and consideration, and, indeed, in the exertion of ta- lent, particularly in that of oratory, they had this obvious advantage over the lay members of that 10 ACCOUNT OF THE assembly, that the subjects were chiefly clerical^ ly- ing more within the range of their accustomed studies, as well as more within the reach of their particular information, than could be the case with the laymen who sat there along with them. The clergy of Edinburgh, coming thither thus prepared by education and habit, for filling a respectable place in society, found in that city a circle well adapt- ed to perfect their knowledge, to enlarge their minds, and to foster their genius. They mixed more than, I think, they have done at any subse- quent period, with the first and most distinguished persons of the place, distinguished, whether for science, literature, or polite manners, and even, as far as the clerical character might innocently allow, with the men of fashion conspicuous for wit and gaiety. In the inexpensive style of the Edinburgh society, at the period to which I allude, when tea was the meal of ceremony for general acquaintance, and a supper of a very moderate number that of more intimate society, there was much more in- tercourse of mind than in the large parties of mo- dern times, which form, in truth, a sort of public place in a private house. In such places of nu- merous resort, even if other circumstances allowed, the clergy cannot so easily mix with those who are styled people of fashion. I regret the want of mixture of clerical and lay society for the sake of both parties. To the one it tended to add the LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 11 graces of manner to the solid talents which at all times so many of them possess. To the other it tended to give that very solidity, soberness, and modesty of demeanour, so useful and so amiable in the young of either sex. It tended to give to wealth and rank, instead of the insolence and fri- volity which often accompany them, the urbanity, the condescension, the chastened wit, the decent deportment, which are the great sweeteners, as well as ennoblers, of social life. It added respect and dignity to both parties, and mixed into a closer and more advantageous union, the different classes of men. It checked the petulance of the young, and smoothed the severity of the old ; it added senti- ment to the gaieties, and gave more winning fea- tures to the serious duties, of life. There was, indeed, a high Calvinistic party in the church, whose rigid ideas of the clerical func- tion were somewhat unfriendly to social inter- course, or the ease of social enjoyment. But they were often men of great learning and talents, and they had their reward in the authority and popu- lar weight which they obtained among the bulk of their parishioners. The party opposite to them, who were less rigid and severe in their ideas of cle- rical manners and character, owed, perhaps, to that very distinction a politeness and suavity of deport- ment, and an attention to accomplishment and ele- gance in their studies, to which otherwise their si- 12 ACCOUNT OF THE tuation might not have led. They cultivated clas- sical literature, and began that study of refined composition which some of them afterwards carried to such a degree of excellence in this country. Of this party was Mr John Home, who was ear- ly associated with his coevals destined for the church, of similar inclinations and dispositions. Besides the eminent persons above-mentioned, Robertson, Hugh Blair, and Drysdale, he became intimately associated with others of his fellow-churchmen, whose disposition, as well as talents, were calcula- ted to combine with and to foster his own. Among these were Drs Cleghorn, Carlyle, Adam Fergu- son, Ballantyne, and Logan.* The last of these was peculiarly distinguished for learning and acute- ness, and was generally allowed to be the first me- taphysician of his time. This quality tended to draw upon him a certain suspicion of heterodoxy ; and Dr Carlyle used to mention, that once having lent Dr Logan a sermon, when he was unexpect- edly called to preach before the Presbytery of Dalkeith, that reverend body believing it to be Logan's own, found, or conceived themselves to find, so much sceptical metaphysics in it, as to be * Not the clergyman of that name, the poet of a later time, but another clergyman, coeval with Mr Home, who died be- fore the younger Logan was known as an author. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 13 with difficulty prevented from instituting a prose- cution against the preacher. I have prepared the Society for this paper being a paper of parentheses a sort of literary gossip's story. Will they indulge me in a somewhat long, and, perhaps, it may be thought still more tedious than long, parenthesis on the situation and cha- racter of some of Mr Home's early companions, whose names and memories they may not be un- willing, however, to recal, as the fathers and fos- terers of that literary and philosophical spirit to which this Society owes its origin and station ? It were impertinent in me to do any more than merely to name those illustrious men whose bio- graphy has been already in much abler hands, Drs Robertson and Blair, and David Hume, nor need I speak of our venerable colleague, Dr A. Fergu- son, whose life, as well as his works, are so well known to the world. Others there were of less note, who have not been handed down by their li- terary labours to posterity, but who were, perhaps, little inferior either in genius or learning to their more celebrated companions, and to whom those companions were indebted, not only for a great part of the happiness of their lives, but more, per- haps, than can ever be known, for many sugges- tions, for the original germ of many ideas, which they afterwards expanded or adorned in the vo- lumes which they gave to the world. At that 14 ACCOUNT OF THE time the press was a vehicle not so immediately re- sorted to for the communication of opinion or of theory as it now is. Men were then shyer of coming forth to public notice as authors, and were apt to content themselves with the conscious pos- session of talents or of learning, or the participa- tion of those endowments with the circle of such of their friends as were qualified to appreciate them. Among these were the clergymen Ballantyne, Logan, Carlyle, and Drysdale, whom I have men- tioned ahove; and, at a later period, General Fletcher, who was one of Mr Home's most inti- mate and constant companions, a man of a very elegant appearance, and a scholar more deeply read than men in his situation commonly are. Mr John Jardine, one of the ministers of Edin- burgh, was another of that circle, the coeval and intimate companion of Mr Home, a man of infi- nite pleasantry as well as great talents, whose con- versation, perhaps, beyond that of any other of the set, possessed the charm of easy natural attractive humour. His playful vivacity often amused itself in a sort of mock contest with the infantile (if I may use such a phrase when speaking of such a man) simplicity of David Hume, who himself enjoy- ed the discovery of the joke which had before excited the laugh of his companions around him. Another member of that society, while he lived in LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 15 the neighbourhood of Edinburgh, was Wilkie, author of the Epigoniad, a poem now but little read or known, yet certainly of great merit, not only as possessing much of the spirit and manner of Homer, of whom its author was an enthusiastic admirer, but also a manly and vigorous style of poetry, rarely found in modern compositions of the kind. Of Wilkie all the party spoke as superior in original genius to any man of his time, but rough and unpolished in his manners, and still less accommodating to the decorum of society in the ordinary habits of his life. Charles Townsend, a very competent judge of men, and who, both as a politician and a man of the world, was fond of judging them, said, after being introduced to Wilkie, and spending a day with him at Dr Car- lyle's, that he had never met with a man who ap- proached so near to the two extremes of a god and a brute as Dr Wilkie. It might surprise us to find how much Wilkie, with all his vigour of mind, his powers of expression, and shrewdness of observation, has failed in the Moral Fables which he published some time after his Epigoniad, did we not know how much poetry requires feeling, as well as knowledge and fancy, a quality which Wilkie did not much possess. To poetical excellence, perhaps, even a degree of ner- vous sensibility, bordering on weakness, is often favourable ; the poetical talent is favoured, at 16 ACCOUNT OF THE least, by that pliability of imagination which iden- tifies itself with the character, with the passion, with the scene, which it delineates ; it goes out of the man's self, as it were, to assume such character and passion, to lose its own actual situation in such a scene. Hence, too, one can easily account for what has appeared strange to some, (and the won- der is, perhaps, a compliment to those who think it strange,) namely, the highly virtuous poetry, or works of imagination akin to poetry, of men whose conduct was so little actuated by virtue. It is, perhaps, to a want of this poetical sensibi- lity that we may chiefly impute the inferior degree of interest excited by Wilkie's Epigoniad, to that which its merits in other respects might excite. Perhaps it suffers also from its author having the Homeric imitation constantly in view, in which, however, he must be allowed, I think, to have been very successful, so successful that a person, igno- rant of Greek, will, I believe, better conceive what Homer is in the original by perusing the Epigo- niad, than by reading even the excellent transla- tion of Pope. Of this groupe of men, with whom, as I have said, Mr John Home was associated, was Dr Wallace, another minister of Edinburgh, known as an author by his Treatise on the Numbers of Mankind, who cultivated the science of political economy before it had begun to be studied here under those great 10 LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 17 masters, David Hume, and his friend, Adam Smith. Dr Wallace, with the most perfect correctness of clerical character, was a man of the world in that better sense of the term, which implies a know- ledge of whatever human science or learning has done to enlighten mankind ; and he even extend- ed his reading to its innocent though lighter accom- plishments. He wrote Notes, as his son informs us, on " Gallini's Treatise on Dancing." I sat with my father's family in the Little Church, (called Haddo's Hold, from its having been once used as a prison for Lord Haddo, in the days of civil con- tention in Scotland,) where Dr Wallace was mi- nister ; and I perfectly remember his introducing in a sermon, comparing modern morals, manners, and attainments, with those of the ancients, a high encomium on " Gray's Elegy on a Country Church Yard," which had been published a short while be- fore, which he said he would venture to compare with the most celebrated specimens of ancient classic poetry. * * " An anecdote, told by the late Professor Robison, (as mentioned in his Life, read by the late Professor Playfair to this Society,) deserves well to be remembered. Professor Robison, then employed as an engineer in the army com- manded by General Wolfe, happened to be on duty in the boat in which the General went to visit some of his posts, the night before the battle, which was expected to be decisive of the fate of the campaign. The evening was fine, and the scene, considering the work they were engaged in, and the VOL. I. B 18 ACCOUNT OF THE The opposite party in church politics had also their economist and arithmetician, Dr Alexander Webster, who, from his talents in those depart- ments, arranged, if not originated, the Corpora- tion of the Widows' Fund, destined to support the widows and orphans of the Scots clergy, an insti- tution the most useful as well as prosperous of any of the kind in Europe. Drs Dick and Peter Gum- ming were likewise very eminent among that par- ty for talents and learning. Dick was of that high unbending mind, which was better fitted for pub- lic exhibitions of eloquence than for the level of ordinary conversation ; but Dr Webster and P. Gumming possessed a degree of natural humour and pleasantry equal to those of any men with whom my youthful days had the pleasure of being associated. Of George Wishart, minister of Edinburgh, and another of what was termed the moderate party, the figure is before me at this moment* It is pos- sible some of the Society who hear me may remem- ber him. Without the advantage of that circum- morning to which they were looking forward, sufficiently im- pressive. As they rowed along, the General, with much feel- ing, repeated nearly the whole of Gray's Elegy (which had appeared not long before, and was yet but little known) to an officer who sat with him in the stern of the boat ; adding, as he concluded, that ' he would prefer being the author of that poem to the glory of beating the French to-morrow.' " Playfair's Works, Life of Robison, vol. IV. p. 126-7- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 19 stance, 1 can faintly describe his sainted counte- nance that physiognomy so truly expressive of Christian meekness, yet, in the pulpit, often light- ed up with the warmest devotional feeling. In the midst of his family society a numerous and ami- able one it beamed with so much patriarchal af- fection and benignity, so much of native politeness, graced with those manners which improve its form, without weakening its substance, that I think a painter of the *Apostolic School couldhave nowhere found a more perfect model. The lay members of this circle, with whom Mr Home spent much of his time, were not less emi- nent for talents than amiable in manners ; Lord Elibank, Sir Gilbert Elliot, Mr Wedderburn, af- terwards Lord Loughborough, Mr Baron Mure, and Mr Johnston, afterwards Sir William Pulteney. Lord Elibank was, in conversation, much beyond any of those his companions. His wit was of the most brilliant, yet, at the same time, of the most natural kind. His knowledge of books was various and extensive, and his memory of what he read surprisingly accurate as well as retentive. His re- marks both on books and men were not less con- spicuous for originality than discernment. * I am aware that there is no such school technically so called ; but I shall be easily understood to mean that class of painters whose subjects led them so often to exhibit the saint- ed countenances of our Saviour and his disciples. 20 ACCOUNT OF THE But the most illustrious of that circle was David Hume, who had a sincere affection for his poetical namesake, an affection which was never ahated during the life of that celebrated man. The un- fortunate nature of his opinions with regard to the theoretical principles of moral and religious 'truth, never influenced his regard for men who held very opposite sentiments on those subjects subjects which he never, like some vain and shallow scep- tics, introduced into social discourse ; on the con- trary, when at any time the conversation tended that way, he was desirous rather of avoiding any serious discussion on matters which he wished to confine to the graver and less dangerous consider- ation of cool philosophy. He had, it might be said, in the language which the Grecian historian applies to an illustrious Roman, two minds ; one which indulged in the metaphysical scepticism which his genius could invent, but which it could not always disentangle ; another, simple, natural, and playful, which made his conversation delight- ful to his friends, and even frequently conciliated men whose principles of belief his philosophical doubts, if they had not power to shake, had grie- ved and offended. During the latter period of his life I was frequently in his company amidst per- sons of genuine piety, and I never heard him ven- ture a remark at which such men, or ladies still more susceptible than men could take offence. LIFE OF ME JOHN HOME. 21 His good nature and benevolence prevented such an injury to his hearers ; it was unfortunate that he often forgot what injury some of his writings might do to his readers. The sentiments which such good nature and benevolence might suggest, I ventured to embody, in a sort of dramatic form, in the story of La Roche in the Mirror, in which Mr Hume is made to say, " That there were times when, recollecting that venerable pastor and his lovely daughter, he forgot the pride of literary fame, and wished that he had never doubted." It will not, I hope, be an offensive egotism, if I in- form the Society, that, when I wrote that story, being anxious there should not be a single expres- sion in it that could give offence or uneasiness to any friend of Mr Hume's, I read it to Dr Adam Smith, and begged that he would tell me if any thing should be left out or altered. He heard it attentively, and declared he did not find a syllable to object to; but added, with his characteristic absence of mind, that he was surprised he had never heard of the anecdote before. In the same bonkommie, Mr Hume bore with perfect good nature the pleasantries which hu- morous deductions from his theoretical scepticism sometimes produced. Once, I have been told, he was in a small degree ruffled by a witticism of Mr John Home's, who, though always pleasant, and often lively, seldom produced what might be term- 22 ACCOUNT OF THE ed or repeated as wit. The clerk of an eminent banker in Edinburgh, a young man of irreproach- able conduct, and much in the confidence of his master, eloped with a considerable sum with which he had been entrusted. The circumstance was mentioned at a dinner where the two Humes, the historian and the poet, and several of their usual friendly circle, were present. David Hume spoke of it as a kind of moral problem, and wondered what could induce a man of such character and habits as this clerk was said to possess, thus to in- cur, for an inconsiderable sum, the guilt and the infamy of such a transaction. " I can easily ac- count for it," said his friend John Home, " from the nature of his studies, and the kind of books which he was in the habit of reading." " What were they ?" said the philosopher. " Boston's Four- fold State," rejoined the poet, " and Hume's Es- says." David was more hurt by the joke than was usual with him, probably from the singular con- junction of the two works, which formed, according to his friend's account, the library of the unfortu- nate young man. Such was the free and cordial communication of sentiments, the natural play of fancy and good humour, which prevailed among the circle of men whom I have described. It was very different from that display of learning that prize-fighting of wit, which distinguished a literary circle of our LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 23 sister country, of which we have some authentic and curious records. There all ease of intercourse was changed for the pride of victory ; and the victors, like some savage combatants, gave no quarter to the vanquished This may, perhaps, be accounted for more from the situation than the dispositions of the principal members of that society. The lite- rary circle of London was a sort of sect, a caste separate from the ordinary professions and habits of common life. They were traders in talent and learning, and brought, like other traders, samples of their goods into company, with a jealousy of com- petition which prevented their enjoying, as much as otherwise they might, any excellence in their competitors. The learned and ingenious men whom I have just mentioned, were the principal founders of the society established in Edinburgh under the deno- mination of the Select Society., of which Mr Stewart has given a list in his Life of Dr Robertson. That list, according to the information of a member, is not quite complete. Among other names omitted, may be mentioned those of the Duke of Hamil- ton, a man, not only of elegant manners, but of classical acquirements ; but careless and dissipated in the highest degree ; Lord Dalmeny, cut off, like the duke, in the prime of life, though very differ- ent in the temperance of its habits. Mr Robert Alexander was also a zealous member of that so- 24 ACCOUNT OF THE ciety ; a very worthy, intelligent, and accomplished man, but plain and awkward in his person, and de- void of that readiness of thought and command of expression which might qualify him for a speaker. " But his suppers," says my authority, " were de- lightful, formed on the model of Paris, where Mr A. had occasion frequently to be ; they were ele- gant and enj cue's, frequented by all the literary, and most of the fashionable, persons of the time. By those meetings (continued he) some of the most distinguished members of the Select Society were more improved than by the debates at its sittings. Those meetings of easy but improving sociality rubbed off the corners of mere learning and science, and thus made the literati of Edinburgh less cap- tious and less pedantic than those of any other place." About this time (1755) was produced a periodi- cal publication, which attracted less notice at the time than it has since excited, when its principal authors had attained such celebrity as to make the world anxious to know the smallest of their pro- ductions, I mean the Original Edinburgh Re- view, of which only two numbers were published ; the article by Adam Smith, a Criticism on John- son's Dictionary, was very conspicuous. David Hume was not among the number of the writers of the Review, though we should have thought he would have been the first person whose LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 25 co-operation they would have sought. But I think I have heard that they were afraid both of his ex- treme good nature, and his extreme artlessness ; that, from the one, their criticisms would have been weakened, or suppressed, and, from the other, their secret discovered. The merits of the work strong- ly attracted his attention, and he expressed his sur- prise, to some of the gentlemen concerned in it, with whom he was daily in the habit of meeting, at the excellence of a performance written, as he presumed, from his ignorance on the subject, by some persons out of their own literary circle. It was agreed to communicate the secret to him at a dinner, which was shortly after given by one of their number. At that dinner he repeated his won- der on the subject of the Edinburgh Review. One of the company said he knew the authors, and would tell them to Mr Hume upon his giving an oath of secrecy. " How is the oath to be taken," said Da- vid, with his usual pleasantry, " of a man accused of so much scepticism as I am ? You would not trust my Bible Oath ; but I will swear by the TO xaAoi/ and the TO TC^TFOV never to reveal your secret." He was then told the names of the authors and the plan of the work, but it was not continued long enough to allow of his contributing any articles. Of another work, and one of much humour, written by Adam Ferguson, in ridicule of the opposers of a Scots militia, " The History of Sister Peg," Da- 26 ACCOUNT OF THE vid Hume was also kept in ignorance, from similar motives, by his literary friends. By way of a plea- sant revenge for their want of confidence, David Hume wrote a letter to the publisher, assuming the work to himself, and accounting for his having till that time declined avowing it. I have seen this let- ter, and it is written in such a style, as, to a man not informed of the real circumstances of the case, would leave no doubt of Mr Hume's being the au- thor of the book. I could not read this letter with- out being confirmed in an observation which I have often ventured to make, on the uncertainty of the evidence arising from letters., when the writers are dead, and the motives of their correspondence can- not be known. The mention of Sister Peg leads me to take no- tice of another literary association, considerably later than the Select Society, established under the auspices of some of Mr Home's above-mentioned companions, and in conformity to his own sanguine ideas of national pride and heroism ; this was the Poker Club, instituted in 1762, at a time when Scotland was refused a militia, and thought herself affronted by the refusal ; a refusal which many sen- sible and moderate men thought for her advantage, as she was just then beginning that course of im- provement in industry, and particularly in agricul- ture, which she has since so successfully prosecuted ; but, perhaps, chiefly caused by that jealousy, which LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 27 fifteen years had not yet extinguished, of a disaf- fected spirit of Jacobitism, which made it unsafe to trust the people of Scotland, or at least a great part of them, with arms. The name of this club, the Poker ', was chosen from a quaint sort of allusion to the principles it was originally meant to excite, as a club to stir up the fire and spirit of the coun- try. It was afterwards extended as to members, though less definite in its objects, by the admission of a number of gentlemen of this country, and chiefly resident in Edinburgh, considerable either in rank and station, or eminent for talents. At its first institution, Mr Johnston, afterwards Sir Wil- liam Pulteney, was chosen Secretary, with two as- sistants, for the revisal of any publications that might be thought necessary ; and, in a playful moment, Mr Andrew Crosbie, the celebrated bar- rister, (one of the most zealous advocates for the people, and one of the warmest asserters of their freedom, but the best-natured and gentlest man possible in private life,) was chosen Assassin, in case that office should be found necessary, with another more celebrated man, equally remarkable for the mildness of his disposition, Mr David Hume, for his assistant. I see among these care- less scraps of his earlier writings, which Mr Hume had preserved, the beginning of a warm paper ad- dressed to the landed gentlemen of Scotland, on the subject of the militia, ascribing to the want of it 28 ACCOUNT OF THE the early misfortunes of the Seven Years' War, to which the subsequent successes, unparalleled in British history, afforded a sufficient answer. The club flourished till 1784, when its members, accord- ing to a list I have seen, were in number sixty- six, consisting, among other literary men, of several whom I have mentioned above, of Patrick Lord Elibank, Sir John Dalrymple, Sir James Stewart, Dr Adam Smith, Drs Cullen, Black, and Gregory, and Professor James Russel. Of men that were af- terwards eminent in public life, were Lord Melville, Sir Gilbert Elliot, his brother Admiral Elliot, and Sir Robert Murray Keith. Of men of fashion, who, in those days, were proud of connection and ac- quaintance with men of letters, were the Duke of Buccleuch, the Marquis of Grahame, afterwards Duke of Montrose, Lord Mountstewart, after- wards Earl of Bute, the Earls of Haddington, Glencairn, and Glasgow, Lord Binning, Sir Adam Ferguson, and Sir John Halkett. Excellent as, from the above enumeration, the Society of Edinburgh will be allowed, at that pe- riod, to have been, yet old Ambassador Keith, who returned to his native city after an absence of twen- ty-two years, complained (perhaps with an old man's partiality) that it had lost some of that high po- lish and general information of which he remem- bered it possessed. In his younger days, he said, LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 29 every Scots gentleman, of L.300 a-year, made it a necessary part of education to travel for two or three years abroad, when, having previously acqui- red sufficient learning and information to point out their objects of inquiry, and to lay the foundation for future acquirements, and not being rich enough for the indulgence of the idleness, the follies, or the profligacy which are often produced or fostered by wealth, the gentlemen of Scotland improved in manners and in fashion, and gained that knowledge of the world and enlargement of mind, which made their society afterwards so delightful at home. " They were qualified," says my authority, " for conversation and study, while they cultivated their paternal fields. Sportsmen and farmers, without being able to talk of nothing else than the pedi- gree of horses, the breed of bullocks, or the quali- ties of manure." The elder Keith, whose opinion I have just quoted, became, at that advanced age, a member of the Poker Club, with which he fre- quently associated. Lord Elliock was a constant attendant ; an excellent scholar, of the most singu- larly retentive memory, particularly for anecdotes, with a great store of which his long residence abroad had furnished him. When in Holland, he had the good fortune to be intimately known, and often in the society of Frederick the Great, whom the jea- lousy of his father, then King of Prussia, had ba- nished at that time from his native country. 30 ACCOUNT OF THE I hope I have not trespassed too far on the pa- tience of the Society, in this account of Mr Home's companions and associates. Young men speak from feeling, old men from memory. I am aware that the memory of old men is apt to be tiresome, from the length and minuteness of its details ; it is only interesting to others, in proportion as it tra- vels over important events, or among eminent men. I know also, that the narrator is often deceived as to the interest of his narrative. The sun-set of life, like that of the natural day, throws a golden gleam on the objects of our recollection, which brightens them to our view much beyond the ap- pearance which they wear when clothed in soberer colours; but the narrative, like the landscape, draws some advantage, with susceptible minds, from the tint which is thus thrown upon it, though they may be aware that it is illumined somewhat be- yond the colouring of truth. Such companions and associates as I have men- tioned naturally encouraged Mr Home's love of letters, and his ardour for poetry. But, besides this excitement, he had from nature, or a very early education, received a turn of mind, or imbibed sen- timents and habits, very favourable to the poetical spirit. Notice has been already taken of that ad- miration of the chivalrous character, of ardent va- lour, and of military fame, which Mr Ferguson states as one of his marked early propensities, per- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 31 sonified in his character of Young Douglas. His favourite reading was of a kind to inflame the ima- gination, and to dramatize, as it were, the passions. Plutarch was the author constantly in his hands. The spirit with which he read this historian may be judged by the opening of an Essay he had be- gun to write on the character of the Gracchi. " I hope," says he, in detailing his motives for writing it, " that the freemen of Great Britain will read Plutarch, and my reflections upon his narrative, with the same passion and pleasure that I think and write ; and while they contemplate and admire the actions of those great men, be inspired with that spirit of liberty which was so strong in them." Mr Home's favourite amusement was angling one that seems to me peculiarly adapted to nourish poetical feeling, and to inspire poetical enthusiasm. The romantic scenery which surrounds the angler the quiet and solitude to which his art neces- sarily leads the pauses which the contemplative angler (as Walton calls him) frequently indulges that repose of the soul which Rousseau has so en- chantingly described, which lets sleep the severer faculties and powers, but wakes the fancy and the heart ; all these concomitants of this amusement are the natural food of poetry. From the usual scenes of this diversion Mr Home has borrowed an expression, which, though somewhat bold, and therefore made a subject of ridicule to the soberer 32 ACCOUNT OF THE critic, any man who has listened to the rippling of a brook, in the stillness of noon, or in the silence of a summer evening, will immediately acknow- ledge to be just : " The river, coursing o'er its pebbly bed, Imposes silence with a stilly sound." Mr Home's classical reading was such as to bend his mind to that heroic sentiment of which I have taken notice above, the swell of which is one of the nurses of poetry. He had written an Essay, of which I have seen considerable detached pieces, on the Character of Cornelius and Sempronius Gracchus, of Cleomenes and Agis, and the Repub- lican Form of Government, of which, like most young men of ardent minds, he was at that time a great admirer. From the perusal of Plutarch, he had early conceived the idea of writing a tragedy on the subject of the death of Agis, as related by that biographer, and had completed the first copy of it soon after he was settled as minister of Athel- staneford, in East Lothian, which was in the year 1746. To that church he was presented by the patron, Mr Kinloch, afterwards Sir David Kin- loch of Gilmerton, and was the immediate succes- sor of another poetical incumbent, author of a very popular poem,* The Grave. Mr Kinloch did him This gentleman may be mentioned with another dis- 3 LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 33 another favour, which had a material influence on his future life ; he introduced him to his relation, Lord Milton, then Sous-Ministre for Scotland, under Archibald Duke of Argyle, who conceived a very great kindness for him. In a conversation soon after this introduction, the Duke said, " Mr Home, I am now too old to hope for an opportunity of doing you any material service myself; but I will do you the greatest favour in my power, by presenting you to my nephew, the Earl of Bute." Amidst his classical and poetical reading, however, Mr Home occupied himself not only in the studies of Ethics and Divinity, but also in the composi- tion of Sermons. But even at these moments, it would seem as if his mind was constrained, not changed, from its favourite bent ; for, on the backs, or blank interstices of the papers containing some of his earliest composed sermons, there are passages of poetry, written in a more or less perfect state, as the inspiration or leisure of the moment prompted or allowed. But his clerical duties, of every kind, were always attended to, and so great a favourite was he with the parishioners of Athelstaneford, tinction, though he did not live to reap the pleasure it must have conferred ; he was the Father of the late Robert Blair, President of the Court of Session, a name which will be long remembered with reverence and admiration by the Bar of Scotland. VOL. I. C 34 ACCOUNT OF THE that, as Dr Carlyle was informed by a gentleman who heard him preach his farewell sermon at that church, there was not a dry eye among his audience ; and, at a subsequent period, when he retired from active life, and built a house in East-Lothian, near the parish where he had once been minister, his for- mer parishioners, as Lord Haddington informed me, insisted on leading the stones for the building, and would not yield' to his earnest importunity to pay them any compensation for their labour. 1 have in my possession part of a scroll of an- swers to the observations of some friendly critic, on the play of Agis, the first production of Mr Home's tragic muse, but it is so mutilated, that it is impos- sible to trace its date, or the person to whom it is addressed ; but, from the fragment which remains, Mr Home seems to have availed himself of the re- marks of his friend, in several particulars. The ori- ginal plan of the tragedy, I have understood, was to have constructed the fable solely on the distress- es and death of Agis; as a patriot king ; but fear- ing that this subject was too barren of incident and passion, to suit the prevailing dramatic taste, he af- terwards added the love part of the plot, by the in- troduction of the Athenian maid Euanthe, betro- thed to the hero of the piece, Lysander, the friend and avenger of Agis. Conceiving that, thus improved in its interest, the play was now fit for the stage, he went to Lon- LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 35 don about the end of the year 1749, and offered it to Mr Garrick, for representation at Drury-Lane, of which that great actor had recently become ma- nager. But that gentleman did not think it well adapted to the stage, and declined bringing it on, much to the mortification of its author, who, with the feeling natural to such a situation, wrote the following verses on the tomb of Shakespeare, in Westminster- Abbey : Verses written ly Mr Home, with a Pencil, on Shakespeare's Monument in Westminster Abbey. Image of Shakespeare ! To this place I come To ease my bursting bosom at thy tomb ; For neither Greek nor Roman poet fired My fancy first, thee chiefly I admired ; And day and night revolving still thy page, I hoped, like thee, to shake the British stage ; But cold neglect is now my only mead, And heavy falls it on so proud a head. If powers above now listen to thy lyre, Charm them to grant, indulgent, my desire ; Let petrefaction stop this falling tear, And fix my form for ever marble here. After this unsuccessful expedition to London, he turned his mind to the composition of the tra- gedy of Douglas, of which he had, as his friends believed, sketched the plan some time before. From certain notes and hints, relating to this tragedy, in my possession, it appears to have un- 36 ACCOUNT OF THE dergone material alteration from the original de- sign, or rather, indeed, composition *, for the plot, which was suggested to the author by the old po- pular hallad of Gil Morice, seems not to have been materially altered. The names of the persons of the drama appear to have been changed during the time in which the author perfected his piece. That of Norval in those fragments is Norman. Even after the first representations, the name Randolph was substituted for Barnet, the name in the old ballad, which had struck some of the English part of the audience as producing a bad effect, from its being the same with that of the village near Lon- don. With the tragedy of Douglas in his pocket, Mr Home set off on horseback for London, from his house in East-Lothian, in February 1755. The ideas of his friends as to its excellence and success were very sanguine indeed, as appears from the warm expressions used by Dr Carlyle in describing some incidents at the beginning of the author's jour- ney, who was accompanied, to a certain distance on his way, by some of his most intimate friends, of whom Dr Carlyle was one. The habitual care- lessness of Mr Home (another quality, I am afraid I must say failing, which I might, perhaps, have enumerated among those allied to the poetical cha- racter,) was strongly shewn by his having thought of no better conveyance for this MS., by which he LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 37 was to acquire all that fame and future success of which his friends were so confident, than the pocket of the great-coat in which he rode. Dr Carlyle and his other friends trembled for the safety of this drama, their admiration of which he describes as approaching to idolatry, and turned a little out of their road to procure from a clergyman of their ac- quaintance the loan of a pair of saddle-bags, in which to deposit the MS. Having thus, by the provident care of his friends, secured it from the accidents of the weather, he rode on to London, full of those sanguine hopes which every man in his situation indulges, and presented his play to Gar- rick, to whom he had procured an introduction ; but Garrick did not see those merits which have since rendered Douglas so popular, and returned it to the author, with the mortifying declaration, that it was totally unfit for the stage. Neither Mi- Home nor his friends were at all satisfied with this decision, and immediately conceived the plan of bringing it out at the Edinburgh Theatre, then under the management of Digges, an actor of very great powers, (though with many defects,) and of great popularity in Scotland. Its rehearsals were attended by that literary party who were the con- stant companions of the author, and then the chief arbiters of taste and literature in Edinburgh Lord Elibank, David Hume, Mr Wedderbura, 38 ACCOUNT OF THE Dr Adam Ferguson, and others. Dr Carlyle, who sometimes witnessed those rehearsals, expresses, in his Memoirs, his surprise and admiration at the acting of Mrs Ward, who performed Lady Ran- dolph. Digges was the Douglas of the piece, his supposed father was played by Hayman, and Glen- alvon, hy Love ; actors of very considerable merit, and afterwards of established reputation on the London stage. But Mrs Ward's beauty (for she was very beautiful,) and feeling, tutored with the most zealous anxiety by the author and his friends, charmed and affected the audience as much, per- haps, as has ever been accomplished by the very su- perior actresses of after times. I was then a boy, but of an age to be sometimes admitted as a sort of page to the tea-drinking parties of Edinburgh. I have a perfect recollection of the strong sensation which Douglas excited among its inhabitants. The men talked of the rehearsals ; the ladies repeated what they had heard of the story ; some had pro- cured, as a great favour, copies of the most striking passages, which they recited at the earnest request of the company. I was present at the representa- tion ; the applause was enthusiastic ; but a better criterion of its merits was the tears of the audience, which the tender part of the drama drew forth un- sparingly. " The town," says Dr Carlyle, (and I can vouch how truly,) " was in an uproar of exulta- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 39 tion, that a Scotsman should write a tragedy of the first rate, and that its merits were first submitted to them." But the most remarkable circumstance attend- ing its representation, was the clerical contest which it excited, and the proceedings of the Church of Scotland with regard to it. Religious zeal, and a jealousy of any infringement on the established doctrines of the Presbyterian Kirk, seem to have been more than usually predominant at the time of the appearance of Douglas. About this time was published, " England's Alarm," a complaint of the gross impiety and atheism of the times, appli- cable to Great Britain in general, but particularly referring to the corruptions of religion in Scotland ; among which were specified the breach of the Na- tional Covenant, the subsistence of Episcopacy, and the adoption of Episcopal forms of worship, which the author severely condemns, such as kneeling at receiving the sacrament, ecclesiastical habits, (not moral habits, but the dress and costume of the church,) the Liturgy, &c. On the other hand, Lord Kames had just published a small metaphy- sical treatise, entitled, " Essays on the Principles of Morality and Natural Religion." This was sup- posed by some of the clergy to contain principles and positions derogatory to the Christain faith, and the rules of morality contained in the Gospel. A zealous clergyman, Mr George Anderson, minister 40 ACCOUNT OF THE of Chirnside, gave in a complaint against the book, (its author was then unknown,) and the bookseller by whom it was published, to the Presbytery of Edinburgh, praying that reverend judicature to call before them the bookseller, in order to his gi- ving up the author, that the Presbytery might pro- nounce against him such censure as the writing and publishing so wicked a book might seem to deserve. Very able legal answers were given in to this com- plaint by the counsel for the bookseller, Mr, after- wards Sir John, Dalrymple, and Mr Ferguson of Pitfour ; and a pamphlet was written in the au- thor's defence, and in his name, but generally sup- posed to be the production of Dr Hugh Blair. In both, the natural tendency of Lord Kames's work was contended to be altogether the reverse of what the complaint supposed ; and for the particular doc- trines laid down in the tract, the counsel for the bookseller, and the writer of the pamphlet in be- half of the author, produced very high authority, in numberless quotations from the fathers of the church, and the most eminent as well as orthodox divines. To these defences, Mr Anderson gave in a reply, under the title of " The Complaint Veri- fied." On the 28th January, 1757, the Presbytery pronounced its sentence in the following terms : " The Presbytery, having resumed the considera- tion of Mr Anderson's complaint, the majority came to the resolution of dismissing it, on the LIFE OF MU JOHN HOME. 41 ground of the author's having, in his explanatory pamphlet, explained and accounted for the un- guarded expressions in his Essays, and expressed his regard for religion ; and to prevent the Presbytery's entering into so abstruse and metaphysical a ques- tion." It is a singular enough coincidence with some church proceedings, about fifty years after, that Dr Blair, in defence of his friend's Essays, expressly states, that one purpose of those Essays was to con- trovert what appeared to him to be a very danger- ous doctrine, held by the author of certain other Essays, then recently published, (Mr David Hume,) that, by no principle in human nature, can we dis- cover any real connexion between cause and effect* According to Dr Blair, the object of one of Lord Kames's Essays is to shew, that though such con- nexion is not discoverable by reason, and by a pro- cess of argumentative induction, there is, neverthe- less, a real and obvious connexion which every one intuitively perceives between an effect and its cause. We feel and acknowledge, that every effect implies a cause ; that nothing can begin to exist without a cause of its existence. " We are not left," says the author of the Vindication, *' to gather our belief of a Deity, from inferences and conclusions deduced through intermediate steps, many or few. How unhappy would it be, for the great bulk of man- kind, if this were necessary ! The Deity has dis- 42 ACCOUNT OF THE played himself to all men by an internal sense common to all, the ignorant as well as the learned ; we have the same intuitive perception of Him that we have of our own existence." In such a temper of the public mind, it was not wonderful if the appearance of a tragedy, written by a Presbyterian clergyman, should scandalize and provoke the Church of Scotland. That party, op- posed to Mr Home and his friends, were excited to the severity of their proceedings on this occasion, not only by the conscientious objections which they entertained to such compositions, but perhaps a little by the opposition which then prevailed so keenly between the different parties in the church, and in the supreme judicature of the church, the General Assembly. The Presbytery of Edinburgh published a so- lemn admonition on the subject, beginning with expressions of deep regret at the growing irreligion of the times, particularly the neglect of the Sab- bath ;* but calculated chiefly to warn all persons * Yet at that time in Edinburgh there was much more regard to the sacredness of Sunday than now. I was then a boy, and I well remember the reverential silence of the streets, and the tip-toe kind of fear with which, when any accident prevented my attendance on church, I used to pass through them. What would the Presbytery have said now, when, in the time of public worship on a Sunday, not only are the public walks crowded, but idle and blackguard boys LIFE OF MU JOHN HOME. 43 within their bounds, especially the young, and those who had the charge of youth, against the danger of frequenting stage-plays and theatrical enter- tainments, of which the Presbytery set forth the immoral and pernicious tendency, at considerable length. This step of the Presbytery, like all other over- strained proceedings of that nature, provoked re- sistance and ridicule on the part of the public. The wags poured forth parodies, epigrams, and songs. These were, in general, not remarkable for their wit or pleasantry, though some of them were the productions of young men, afterwards eminent in letters or in station. While the Church was taking public general measures on this occasion, it did not neglect to notice what it conceived to be an outrage against its purity and dignity, by instituting proceedings against the individuals of its own body, who had witnessed or countenanced the representation of Douglas. Mr Home himself escaped the censure and punishment, which would certainly have reach- ed him, by an abdication of the ministerial func- tion, having resigned his living at Athelstaneford, bawl through the streets, and splash us with their games there? an indecency of which, though no friend to purita- nical preciseness, and still less to religious persecution, I ra- ther think the police ought to take cognizance. 44 ACCOUNT OF THE in June, 1757. Mr Home's intimate friends and acquaintance, who had been present at the repre- sentation of his tragedy, were censured or punished, according to the degree of their supposed miscon- duct. Mr White, the minister of Libberton, was suspended for a month, a mitigated sentence, in consideration of his apology for a conduct into which he had been unwarily led ; " that he attend- ed the representation only once, and endeavoured to conceal himself in a corner, to avoid giving of- fence." Messrs Carlyle, Home of Polwarth, Scott at Westruther, Cupples at Swinton, and Steel at Stairs, underwent different degrees of censure ; and several other Presbyteries adopted and enforced the language of that of Edinburgh, with regard to the baneful and immoral effects of stage-plays, perni- cious at all times, but doubly improper and sinful at a period of great dearth and distress among the poor, and of national degradation and calamity. This was at the commencement of the Seven Years' War, when Byng had failed of relieving Minorca, and Braddock had been defeated in America. Such was then the prevailing opinion of the Church of Scotland, with regard to the improprie- ty and immorality of attending theatrical represen- tations, especially by clergymen, though, indeed, the overture of one Synod, and the language of most of them, expressed that opinion with regard to all persons whatsoever. The difference between LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 45 the opinions of the two Churches of England and Scotland, in this matter, was strongly set forth in some of the writings on the subject ; and the Pres- bytery of Dunse, in answer to a representation made to them by that of Edinburgh, used the fol- lowing expression : " We cannot allow ourselves to think that a thing, really criminal in itself, can be innocent or indifferent on the other side of the Tweed." Something, however, must be allowed to custom, in considering the lesser moralities of man- ners and deportment. The nakedness of an Ame- rican, or a, Hindoo, is no breach of modesty or de- corum ; but that of an inhabitant of London or Edinburgh, would be a flagrant offence against both. In the question about theatrical exhibitions, as far as concerned the tragedy of Douglas, and the propriety or impropriety of the ecclesiastical opinions and proceedings to which it gave rise, it can only be fairly said, even by the advocates for the moral or innocent effects of dramatic enter- tainments, that Scotland, at the period of these proceedings, had not attained the refinement or li- berality of the church of her sister kingdom. To the many excellent persons, of different ranks and persuasions, who have held, or still hold, dramatic entertainments to be of such baneful effect on the moral and religious principles of a people, I can only reply, that viewing their scruples with that indulgence and respect to which the purity of their 46 ACCOUNT OF THE intentions, and the respectability of their charac- ters are entitled, I should, were I to allow the jus- tice of their fears* be obliged to regret that a de- partment of literary composition, which affords the amplest field to the talents of the writer, and the feelings of the reader of poetry, should be liable to the imputation of such hurtful consequences ; I should remind them how much of life is spent, and must be spent, in amusements ; and that, to draw the young and the gay into innocent fields of amuse- ment, is to gain or to save a great deal of their time from hurtful dissipation. But, in truth, the plea on behalf of theatrical exhibitions rests on higher and more certain grounds ; for it is proved by re- peated experience, marked in the accurate and im- partial registers of officers of police, that in several great cities, when, from any accident, such exhibi- tions are suspended, every kind of wickedness and crime, even those which trench on the public safe- ty, (without taking into account any advantage of improvement in manners,) has always increased in a very great degree. " The truth seems to be," as our venerable colleague Dr Adam Ferguson ex- presses it, in a letter to me on the subject of Mr Home's dramatic writings, " that theatrical com- positions, like every other human production, are, in the abstract, not more laudable or censurable than any other species of composition, but are either good or bad, moral or immoral, according to the LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 47 management or the effect of the individual tragedy or comedy we are to see represented, or to peruse." On this ground, certainly the tragedy of Douglas may confidently put itself on its trial ; both the sentiments and the feelings expressed in it being of the most laudable and virtuous kind, parental tenderness, and aspiring virtue. The elder Sheridan, then manager of the Thea- tre at Dublin, sent Mr Home a gold medal, in tes- timony of his admiration of Douglas ; and his wife, a woman not less respectable for her virtues than for genius and accomplishments, drew the idea of her admired novel of Sydney Biddulph, (as her in- troduction bears,) from the genuine moral effect of that excellent tragedy. Amidst the censures of the Church, the public suffrage was strong in its favour, and the houses were crowded every night of its representation. Perhaps the success of the play excited the envy of some as much as the nature and species of its com- position, and the situation of its author, produced the censure of others ; for, among \hejeux d'esprit produced on the occasion, were some written by men themselves poets, and not at all remarkable for religious strictness or severe morality. Its defend- ers were found among all ranks and professions. Mr Wedderburn, afterwards Lord Loughborough, wrote some of its lighter defences. Mr Adam Fer- guson published a serious pamphlet, in defence of 48 ACCOUNT OF THE the morality of dramatic composition, deduced from Scripture, particularly exemplified in the story of Joseph and his Brethren ; Dr Carlyle, an ironical pamphlet, under the title of, " Reasons why the Tragedy of Douglas should be Burnt by the hands of the Common Hangman ;" and afterwards he wrote a paper, calculated for the lower ranks, which was hawked about the streets, " History of the Bloody Tragedy of Douglas, as it is now performing at the Theatre in the Canongate." This paper had such an effect as to add two more nights to the al- ready unprecedented run of the play. Against Dr Carlyle, the prosecution of the Presbytery was carried on for a considerable time, till at last it terminated in the brutumfulmen of a censure and admonition. The learned Dr Wal- lace, of whom I have made mention in a former part of this Memoir, wrote an anonymous letter to Dr Carlyle, full of the soundest advice, and assuring him of his support in the proceedings before the Presbytery. The Synod of Mid-Lothian and Tweeddale, a body free from the partialities and prejudices of the Presbytery of Edinburgh, pronounced a much more moderate sentence than this last-mentioned judica- ture had done on the matter of Douglas, and of Mr Home's conduct as a dramatic author ; and the sentence of the Synod was affirmed in the General Assembly, by 117 votes to 34. Yet next day, on 9 LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 49 the motion of a gentleman, whom one would not have supposed likely to be the advocate of severe or illiberal proceedings, Mr George Dempster, the Assembly passed a declaratory act, prohibiting the clergy from being concerned in, or countenancing, theatrical representations. But the manners over- came the law of the Church ; and country clergy- men, when in Edinburgh, frequented the theatre when any eminent actor or actress performed there. During the first visit of Mrs Siddons to this city, in 1784, while the General Assembly was sitting, there was, I have been told, great difficulty in pro- curing a full attendance of its members, on those evenings when she was to perform. A distinction was justly allowed between exhibitions, in which that great actress gave new force and impression to the noblest tragic sentiments, and those more ex- ceptionable representations, which our comic stage, even in its present reformed state, sometimes ex- hibits. The persecution, however, which Mr Home and his tragedy endured, was of use to both. Lord Bute, to whom I have mentioned his introduction by the Duke of Argyle, now warmly patronized an author, whose sufferings, as well as genius, recom- mended him to his benevolence and favour. Mr Home went to London, soon after the publication of his tragedy, in March 1757, when it was brought out at Covent-Garden, with much success. Gar- rick at that time maintained his resolution of not VOL. I. D 50 LIFE OF MK JOHN HOME. bringing it out at Drury-Lane, but afterwards made up for his former neglect, by the warmest pa- tronage of Mr Home's subsequent tragedies ; which I am sorry to be obliged to impute to that respect for great men for which that celebrated actor was remarkable, Lord Bute's fayour being a surer pass- port to his theatre than the merit even of Douglas. Mr Home now lived very much with that noble- man, and was in such habits of intimacy with his young pupil, the Prince of Wales, as seldom falls to the share of any individual of his rank and si- tuation in life. Lord Bute was a man of some learning, and considerable science, and of not less virtue than either ; but his virtue was of an austere unbending sort, and his natural shyness and reserve did not, any more than his better qualities, accom- modate themselves to the circle around him, which a minister of England must necessarily cultivate, if he does not happen to possess those splendid and commanding talents which make some men, but those very rare, independent of any other support. From this disposition, which his original station of preceptor to the Prince did not tend to over- come, Lord Bute was, more than any other mini- ster, inclined to relax from the constraints of form, and the severity of business, in the society of a few familiar friends, with whom he found himself at perfect ease. This is natural to the situation, be- cause the mind, like the body, feels a relief in the LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 51 change of posture ; to Lord Bute it was more than usually grateful, both from that monkish sort of austerity and reserve of which I have just taken notice, and from a tincture of family pride, which inclines a man to lean upon inferiors, rather than to hold himself in the attitude of equality. His original patronage of Mr Home was meritorious, from its benevolence and attention to the encou- ragement of letters. He was then the patron of the poet ; it was afterwards somewhat of a more selfish cast, from the indulgence which he found in the society of the man an indulgence which he sometimes gratified at the expence of persons of high rank., and great political influence, who saw, with indignation, those private interviews which were refused to them, granted to this obscure man of letters. There was, I have been informed, the same sort of imprudence in the private life of the great Earl of Chatham, who, in the intervals of those paroxysms of the gout to which he was subject, was frequent- ly peevish and inaccessible to men of high rank and high office, but indulged himself in the familiar society of very inferior dependents, much less re- commended by talent or agreeable conversation than Mr Home ; but, in Lord Chatham, these little in- fringements of politeness or etiquette were not felt nor resented. Amidst the splendour of his tri- 53 ACCOUNT OF THE umphant administration, those specks of a private kind were unnoticed or forgotten. Mr Home has sometimes been accused of al- lowing his vanity of Lord Bute's friendship and fa- miliarity to get the better of his prudence, or of the reserve which he ought to have maintained on account of his patron ; and that he increased the unpopularity of the minister by displaying his dis- proportionate favour and familiarity to himself. If he shewed a certain degree of weakness and want of discretion in the vanity which he indulged from the favour and intimacy of the first Lord of the Treasury, he exhibited a degree of purity of mind and disinterestedness, much less common, in never turning this favour and intimacy to his own pri- vate advantage. He never asked, (and I cannot mention it without feeling equal surprise and dis- pleasure,) he was never offered, any office or ap- pointment, so many of which Lord Bute had in his power to bestow. It was solely at the sug- gestion of some of his friends, without the most distant hint from himself, that Lord Bute at last bestowed on him the office of Conservator of Scots Privileges at Campvere, which Mr Home enjoyed for several years, till he resigned it in 1770, (re- taining, I believe, the salary,) to Mr Crawford, of Rotterdam ; to whom, as a merchant in Holland, it was important, from that sort of rank and station which in that country it conferred. LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 53 But though his self-love never took advantage of this intimacy to benefit himself, the warmth of his friendship sometimes exerted itself in recommend- ing others to favourable situations, which, how- ever, I believe were what their merits might have fairly claimed, though such, as without his com- mendation, they might have failed to obtain. Had he been selfishly disposed, he had a golden opportunity of enriching himself. At the peace of Paris, in 1763, Mr Home was then living with Lord Bute in London, and in the intimate know- ledge of the diplomatic proceedings which were car- ried on by our Ambassador in France. I believe there were not wanting men who were willing to suggest to him, as well as to share, the obvious ad- vantage which such opportunities of intelligence, or even conjecture, might afford in the then fluc- tuating state of public expectation, and the conse- quent variations in the state of the funds. But Mr Home had a sense of honour and delicacy much above even the harbouring of any such thoughts of private emolument. His mind, indeed, had that heroic cast which I have formerly mentioned, as far removed as possible from avarice, or the love of gain. His inattention to money-matters went perhaps a blameable length, or at least was carried to a de- gree which his friends allowed to be imprudent. I well remember a saying of the witty Lord Elibank, when he was told that Dr Adam Ferguson had got 54 ACCOUNT OF THE a pension. " It is a very laudable grant," said he, " and I rejoice at it ; but it is no more in the power of the King to make Adam Ferguson, or John Home rich, than to make me poor," alluding to the well-known economy, or parsimony, as it might fairly be termed, of his own disposition. I am aware that I have trespassed both in point of diffuseness, and somewhat also against chrono- logical arrangement, in thus giving alt the parti- culars of Mr Home's life which stand in connex- ion with Lord Bute, instead of exactly following the order of events. But I was induced to give the above sketch of Mr Home's connexion with Lord Bute, and its results, as it marked the lead- ing features of both their minds, and was much more honourable to Mr Home, than those who sometimes heard him talk of their familiarity were led to suppose. Among his weaknesses, (and it is one of that unpopular sort which men are apt to remark and to remember,) was a desire of egotism, which he was apt to indulge in recounting anec- dotes of past times, and of eminent men. He had lived in a society of an excellence, and also of a rank, with which, from peculiar circumstances, he had been associated beyond what men in his situ- ation of life commonly are. This (as is altogether in nature,) made that society a more leading object in his mind and his discourse, than in that of men whose original rank or situation entitles them to LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 55 enjoy it. I have mentioned above, his remarkable memory for anecdotes, and his happy manner of re- lating them ; those little narratives became natu- rally the chief materials of his conversation, and the openness and warmth of his temper never kept back his own share in the occurrences he was rela- ting. In truth, a man never actually forgets him- self in recounting such anecdotes ; it is the reserve of politeness only that makes him forbear talking in the first person ; and reserve was a quality which, of all men, Mr Home possessed the least. This style of conversation is, however, very unpopular, except when sparingly introduced : Its hearers, who have not participated in such scenes or adven- tures, feel the details of them a sort of foreign lan- guage, by which they are cut off from a share in the conversation. Proud men feel resentment, humble ones an awkwardness, in being mere auditors on such occasions, and are apt to impute altogether to vanity or conceit, what the speaker is often in truth telling for their entertainment. On this ground, there was a most intimate friend of our author's, who might have been a pattern for his imitation. I never knew a man of such plea- sing talents for conversation as Dr Robertson: He spoke, as became him, a good deal ; but there was nothing assuming or authoritative either in the manner or the matter of his discourse. He took 56 ACCOUNT OF THE every opportunity of calling on his heaters for their share of the dialogue, of asking their opinion or information on the subject of it, and introduced such topics as gave opportunities for his asking such information or opinions. I had often occasion to be with him along with strangers at their first introduction, not unfrequently to introduce them myself. When we left his house, they always ex- pressed their admiration of his general knowledge, as well as of his politeness. The Doctor's gene- ral knowledge enabled him to transport himself, as it were, into the country of the stranger ; and to speak of that country with the deference of an in- quirer a manner which is always flattering to the person we address, because it seems to call for the favour of his information. The agreeableness of Mr Home's manners and conversation, as much as the notice of Lord Bute, introduced him into a society in London of the most respectable and pleasing kind. Lord Lough- borough, (then Mr Wedderbum,) his brother-in- law, Sir Harry Erskine, Mr Robert Adams, Mr Garrick, Mr Douglas, afterwards Bishop of Salis- bury, Sir Gilbert Elliot, Mr Ross Mackie, Drs Armstrong, Smollett, Pitcairn, and William Hunt- er, were his daily companions. They formed a club at the British Coffee-house, of which the then mis- tress was a woman of uncommon talents, and the 5 LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 57 most agreeable conversation, Mrs Anderson, sister of Dr Douglas. Garrick, at whose theatre Douglas was now oc- casionally performed, and always with the greatest applause, brought out Mr Home's tragedy of Agis, (the second in order of representation, though the first in order of composition,) in 1758, and played himself Lysander to Mrs Gibber's Euanthe. I have in my possession an original note of Garrick's, written on the morning after the first representa- tion, which is conceived in the following terms : " MY DEAR FRIEND, " Joy, joy, joy to you ! " My anxiety yesterday gave me a small touch of the gravel,* which, with a purging, weakened me prodigiously ; but our success has stopped the one and cured the other. I am very happy, because I think you are so. The Ode, as I foretold, is cer- tainly too long. There were other little mistakes, but all shall be set right to-morrow. Ever most affectionately, " My Genius, " D. GARRICK. " Pray, let me see you at twelve to-morrow." * A complaint which he laboured under all his life, which was often occasioned by the violent exertions of his acting, and of which he died at last. 58 ACCOUNT OF THE In London, or at Lord Bute's house, at Luton, in Bedfordshire, Mr Home passed much of his time from this period, for several years. He was in Scotland, however, when his Siege of Aquileia was brought out at Drury-Lane, in 1760, Garrick playing, as usual, the principal part, Emilius, to Mrs Gibber's Cornelia. I remember to have heard from Dr Robertson, that in a letter written by Garrick to Mr Home, after reading this tragedy to Mrs Garrick, and a young lady then living with them, of whose taste he had a high opinion, he ex- pressed the greatest admiration of the play, and pre- dicted the most brilliant success in its representa- tion. But his prediction was not fulfilled ; not- withstanding all his skill in scenic effect, he had not been aware of one objection to the conduct of this drama, namely, that most, or indeed almost all the incidents, are told to, not witnessed by, the specta- tors, who in England, beyond any other country, are swayed by the Horatian maxim, and feel very im- perfectly those incidents which are not " oculis sub- jectajidelibus" It rather languished, therefore, in the representation, though supported by such ad- mirable acting, and did not run so many nights as the manager confidently expected. In this year, 1 760, he published those three tra- gedies of Douglas, Agis, and the Siege of Aqui- leia, in one volume, dedicated to the Prince of Wales, who in that very year having succeeded to LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 59 the crown, showed an immediate additional mark of favour to Mr Home, by settling on him a pen- sion of L.300 per annum, from his privy purse. In 1763, he had obtained, as I have mentioned above, the office of Conservator of Scots Privileges at Campvere. The salary of this office was L.300 per annum, which, with his former pension from the crown, gave him independence, to him it might be called wealth. This wealth he used as he did every thing else ; he made it an offering to friend- ship. " His house," said Dr Adam Ferguson, " was always as full of his friends as it could hold, fuller than, in modern manners, it could be made to hold." David Hume told Mr Ferguson he should lecture his friend on his want of attention to money-matters. " I am afraid I should do so with little effect," answered Dr Ferguson ; " and, to tell you the truth, I am not sure if I don't like him the better for this foible." One instance of such inattention Mr Ferguson relates in a letter to me, received but a few days ago. " I happened once to have occasion for L.200. John Home told me he had L.200 more than he had immediate use for, and he lent it me upon my note of hand. Soon after, having received some money, I remitted to my agent at London this L.200, with the interest due upon it, with direc- tions to pay it to Mr Home, in discharge of my debt. My agent paid him the money, and begged 60 ACCOUNT OF THE to have up my note. He said he could not recol- lect any thing of a note, but he would look for it when he went to Scotland. The circumstance was forgotten by us both for several years, when at last, having married and got a family, I began to think that it was possible the note might appear against my children after both our deaths ; and I wrote to Mr Home, requesting, that if he had not found the note, he would write a letter to me, acknowledging that the debt had been paid, and that the note, if it appeared, should be of no avail against me or my heirs. I had a letter from my friend in reply, say- ing, that to talk of finding any such note among his papers, was like talking of finding the lost Books of Livy ; but he gave the acknowledgment in the letter, in what he conceived the most proper terms, though, perhaps," said Mr Ferguson, " in terms too poetical to be good in law. ' If ever the note appears,' said his letter, * it will be of no use, ex- cept to shew what a foolish, thoughtless, inatten- tive fellow I am.' " He represented the Dutch ecclesiastical esta- blishment at Campvere, in the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, to which that establish- ment had long had the privilege of sending a mem- ' ber. He was in use to come from London to at- tend in his place in the Assembly, and took a share occasionally in the debates in support of his friend Dr Robertson, and his party. His speeches were LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 61 not remarkable either for force of argument or dis- play of eloquence, but were delivered in an easy and gentlemanlike style and manner ; though, from his particular situation, an ex- churchman of the Presbyterian establishment, they were not popular with one side of the house, and sometimes called forth severe and sarcastic replies from some of the leading members sitting there. The General Assembly had then to boast of some of the best public speaking that was to be heard in Britain, the House of Commons scarcely excepted. The great question which divided the speakers was that of patronage, (the right of no- minating the minister by the proprietor of that right,) the exercise of which had separated a con- siderable number of the people from the Establish- ed Church, under the denomination of Seceders, and was not less productive of warm debates in this kind of ecclesiastical parliament. On one side were ranged Dr Robertson and his associates. Dr Ro- bertson had a power of speaking in a manner ad- mirably calculated for his situation as a leader of what was called the Moderate Party of the Church, temperate, conciliating, and candid ; he generally wound up the debate with a concise and impartial view of the opposite arguments, and frequently brought the opposite parties to an amicable settle- ment, by proposing some resolution which allowed to both a portion of what they had contended for, 62 ACCOUNT OF THE and did not trench on any of the principles which they considered as fixed, and not to be departed from. On the other side was Dr Dick, one of the most powerful speakers, in point of eloquence and impression, that had ever appeared in that, or any other -popular assembly ; and another man, a plain country clergyman, but of infinite native humour, Fairbairn, the minister of Dumbarton, whose talent for enlivening a debate by pleasantry, or turning the laugh against his adversary by sar- casm, not rude, though keen, I have seldom heard equalled by any debater whomsoever. In 1767j Mr Home got a long lease, on very favourable terms, of the farm of Kilduff, in East- Lothian, from his former patron and friend, Sir David Kinloch. On this farm he built a house, where he lived, with only occasional interruptions, for the succeeding ten or 12 years of his life. In 1769, his tragedy of The Fatal Discovery was brought out at Drury-Lane. Its original title, was Rivine, from the name of the heroine of the story, which was taken from one of the fragments of Ossian. But Garrick, afraid of the prejudices then prevalent in London against Scotsmen, and Scots subjects, changed its name to that of The Fa- tal Discovery ; and, in order more effectually to disguise its origin, procured a young English gen- tleman, a student from Oxford, to attend the re- hearsals, and personate the author. But the sue- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 63 cess of the play drew its real author from his covert ; and, after some nights' representation, Mr Home declared himself the writer of the tragedy. The event verified the fears of Garrick ; the succeeding representations were but indifferently attended, and the piece languished only for a few nights longer. The natural vanity of an author came in aid of this disappointment ; Mr Home imputed the thin- ness of those houses to the circumstance of the pub- lic attention being entirely engrossed by the deci- sion of the celebrated Douglas cause, which hap- pened at that time. In 1770, Mr Home was married to the daugh- ter of his friend and relation, Mr Home, the mi- nister of Foggo, formerly of Polwarth, who, not- withstanding her delicate frame, and constantly in- terrupted health, has outlived her husband, who watched her with a tenderness suitable to those amiable dispositions which formed so prominent a part of his character. In the year 1773, his tragedy of Alonzo was performed at Drury-Lane, to which his friend Gar- rick contributed a justly celebrated epilogue, cer- tainly one of the best which his genius, so prolific in that species of composition, ever produced. This play was the most popular of all Mr Home's tra- gedies, Douglas excepted, and met with great suc- cess in the representation. Mrs Barry's Ormisin- da was one of the parts in which that celebrated 4 ACCOUNT OF THE actress exerted her powers, in displaying the vio- lence and energy of feeling, with striking effect. In 1776, he was called suddenly from London, by accounts he received from Mr Ferguson, of the dangerous state of his celebrated friend, David Hume. He set off with all that warmth of affec- tion which was natural to him, met his friend on the road, and accompanied him in his journey to London and Bath, which he took by medical ad- vice, cm account of his health. I am possessed of a journal of this expedition, which, as it contains some interesting particulars of the great philoso- pher's closing life, as well as of his confidential opi- nions, I may, perhaps, if the Society inclines, read, by way of appendix to this paper ; meantime, I cannot resist submitting to its perusal one letter of Mr Hume's, to which, I am persuaded, it will lis- ten with a considerable degree of interest ; it is da- ted 6th August, 1776, not many weeks before that celebrated man's death : " Edinburgh, Qth August, 1776. " MY DEAR JOHN, " I shall begin with telling you the only piece of good news of the family, which is, that my nephew, in no more than two days that he has staid here, has recovered so surprisingly, that he is scarcely knowable, or rather is perfectly knowable, for he was not so on his first arrival. [This relates to Mr LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. (>5 Hume's eldest nephew, Joseph, at that time just returned from abroad, in very bad health.] Such are the advantages of youth ! His uncle declines, if not with so great rapidity, yet pretty sensibly. Sunday, ill ; half of yesterday the same ; easy at present ; prepared to suffer a little to-morrow ; perhaps less the day after. Dr Black says I shall not die of a dropsy, as I imagined, but of inanition and weakness. He cannot, however, fix, with any probability, the time, otherwise he would frankly tell me. " Poor Edmonstone, [Col. Edmonstone of New- ton] and I parted to-day, with a plentiful effusion of tears ; all those Behebubians * have not hearts of iron. I hope you met with every thing well at Foggo, and receive nothing but good news from Buxton. In spite of Dr Black's caution, I venture to foretel that I shall be yours cordially and sin- cerely till the month of October next. (Signed) " DAVID HUME." In the beginning of the year 1778, the tragedy of Alfred was performed at Drury-Lane, but did not succeed. I do not mean in this place to enter * Colonel Edmonstone was a member of what was called the Ruffian Club ; men whose hearts were milder than their manners, and their principles more correct than their habits of life. 66 ACCOUNT OF THE into any critical discussion of Mr Home's works ; but I may just say, that this tragedy is undoubt- edly the weakest of his productions, and it was not surprising that it did not please the public. In- deed, had it possessed more merit than it did, an English audience could have hardly been pleased to see their Alfred, the pride of their country in its earliest age, the patriot and the lawgiver, melt- ed down to the weakness of love, like the common- place hero of an ordinary drama. In the year 1778, he had another opportunity of indulging his passion for the military character, by accepting a commission in the newly-embodied re- giment of Mid-Lothian Fencibles, of which the Duke of Buccleuch was colonel. In this appoint- ment he possessed the advantage of having for the captain of the company of which he was lieutenant, his particular friend Lord Binning, and for his bro- ther lieutenant, Mr W. Adam, the son of that fa- mily with whom he had been so long on terms of the strictest intimacy. Of this corps, he attended the duties with all the ardour of a young soldier, till they were interrupted by an unfortunate acci- dent which had a material influence on his future life, a fall from his horse, by which he suffered so violent a contusion on his head, as for some days deprived him of sense, and nearly extinguished his life. Though he recovered the accident so far as his bodily health was concerned, his mind was never 13 LIFE OF MU JOHN HOME. 67 restored to its former vigour, nor regained its for- mer vivacity. It did not, however, abate his military ardour ; and after being for a short while at home, he thought himself so much re-established, as to join the regiment at Aberdeen, but he found him- self not strong enough to go through the duties of his station, nor even to attend the mess, which he was anxious to do. The friendship of Lord and Lady Binning, then at Aberdeen, did every thing for him that kindness or assiduous care could ac- complish ; but though his health seemed sufficient- ly restored, his head was not able for numerous so- ciety, and he was obliged, though with great re- luctance, and not without the most urgent requests of his friends, to resign his commission and return to Edinburgh, whence he some time after repaired to Bath, at which place, a residence of some months, with attention to regimen and quiet, appeared per- fectly to re-establish his health, but his intellectual powers were never restored to their original state. He had very early projected a History of the Rebellion 1745. Indeed, I can perceive from some notes on his earliest papers, that he had thought of such a work immediately after the conclusion of the rebellion, in 1746, or 47- During his inter- vals of leisure, and more particularly after the un- successful performance of Alfred, when he seemed to cease writing for the stage, he resumed the plan of this history, and had been in use to collect mate- 68 ACCOUNT OF THE rials for it by correspondence and communication with such persons as could afford them, and even by journies or tours to the Highlands of Scotland. In one of these journies, I happened to travel for two or three days along with him, and had occasion to hear his ideas on the subject. They were such as a man of his character and tone of mind would entertain, full of the mistaken zeal and ill-fated gallantry of the Highlanders, the self-devoted he- roism of some of their chiefs, and the ill-judged se- verity, carried (by some subordinate officers,) the length of great inhumanity, of the conquering par- ty. A specimen of this original style of his com- position, still remains in his Account of the Gal- lant Lochiel. But the complexion of his history was materially changed before its publication, which, at one time, he had very frequently and positively de- termined should not be made till after his death, but which he was tempted, by that fondness for our literary offspring which the weakness of age produces, while it leaves less power of appreciating their merits, to hasten ; and accordingly published the work at London in 1802. It was dedicated to the King, as a mark of his gratitude for his majes- ty's former gracious attention to him; a circum- stance which perhaps contributes to weaken and soften down the original composition, in compliment to the monarch whose uncle's memory was some- what implicated in the impolitic, as well as unge- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 69 nerous use which Mr Home conceived had been made of the victory of Culloden. I need not give any further account of the book, which is fresh in the recollection of the Society ; but I may inform them, that it was read in its native state before it was emasculated by his later alterations, by a very competent judge, Mr Ferguson, who was interest- ed and pleased with it. He said to me, however, with his usual frankness, in the recent communica- tion which I have mentioned above, that he him- self had contributed to spoil his friend's History of the Rebellion. " I had often laid down to him those principles of historical composition on which I afterwards wrote my Roman History ; first, that the narrative should be plain and simple, without embellishment ; and, secondly, that it should re- late only great public events, and trace only the characters of individuals connected with them, with- out descending into the minuter details of biogra- phy. Now these," said Dr Ferguson, " were per- fectly applicable to my subject, but not at all to that of my friend. The Rebellion 1745 was too unimportant in itself to make a history, without borrowing such ornament from style, and such in- terest from anecdote, as Voltaire has given to what may be called his Historical Romance of the Ex- pedition of Charles Edward Stuart." In the year 1779, Mr Home left Kilduff, and fixed his residence in Edinburgh, where, with the 70 ACCOUNT OF THE exception of some joumies to London, and particu- larly that made for the unfortunate purpose of pub- lishing his History of the Rebellion, he resided till his death, which happened on the 5th September, 1 808, in the 86th year of his age. For some time before that event, he had gradu- ally sunk into a state of bodily and mental weak- ness, which makes death a desirable event, both for a man's own sake and that of his friends ; yet the warmth of his heart remained unextinguished amidst the feebleness of his frame. Lord Had- dington, (whose kindness as Lord Binning had been so useful to him when an officer in the Lo- thian Fencible Regiment,) saw him among the last times any person, beyond those of his own family, were admitted to his room. He looked at his lord- ship for some time with an uncertainty as to his person, but shortly after, recovering the recollection of his old friend, his features assumed the smile of satisfaction, and he pressed his hand with a silent assurance of his tender remembrance. It was gra- tifying to his friends thus to see him pass through his last moments with a decay of body undisturbed by pain, and a serenity of mind, the effect of good- ness and virtue exercised in this world, and the forerunner of their reward in a better. The Society must have been sensible of a defect in this paper, the want of any critical account or examination of Mr Home's works ; but I was aware LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 71 that I must exhaust its patience by what it was ne- cessary for me to read of the principal events of his life, and the characters of his friends. I could not think of tiring it with listening to my remarks on his works, or with another usual accompaniment, perhaps at least as material, of such memoirs as this, the most interesting letters of such of his friends and correspondents as were conspicuous in public or literary life. These I therefore reserve to a future meeting, if the Society shall think they are likely to deserve being read ; and with regard to the letters, I shall derive great advantage from the delay, because it is only this very day that I have received from a near relation of Mr Home's, a very large collection of those which he received from Mr D. Hume, Mr Garrick, Dr Blair, Lord Elibank, and others, strongly characteristic both of the writers themselves, of the persons to whom they were addressed, and not unfrequently of the times when they were written. SECOND PART. SOME ACCOUNT OF HIS WORKS, AND THE LETTERS OF HIS CORRESPONDENTS. I HAD intended, previously to giving any account of Mr Home's Works, to have prefaced it with a short notice of the state of the literature of this part of the kingdom at the time when he began to write ; but I found this statement likely to grow, under my hands, to a size rather disproportionate to what might be called the text of my biographi- cal sketch of the poet. I will content myself, at present, with mention- ing the general state of the public taste and opi- nion with regard to the drama, at the period when Mr Home first began to cultivate dramatic poetry. It was not long after Mr Garrick had opened the new theatre of Drury Lane, with that idolatry of Shakespeare, which his admirable acting, in some of the principal characters of that inimitable poet, tended so strongly to confirm. The heroics of the LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 73 former age had gone into that oblivion from which fashion only had rescued them at their first produc- tion. Such was the power of that fashion, that Ot- way's admirable tragedies of the Orphan, and Ve- nice Preserved, had received only a moderate de- gree of public approbation ; while his play of Don Carlos, every way inferior to these, and possessing, indeed, very little merit of any kind, received the unbounded applause which the Duke of Bucking- ham has recorded in his satyrieal poem of the Ses- sion oftlie Poets. Among the candidates for the laureateship, Otway is introduced, not as founding his claim on the excellent dramas first above men- tioned, but as " Tom Shadwell's dear Zany, Who swears, for heroics, he writes best of any, Don Carlos his pockets so amply had filled" the other line of the couplet is so gross and dis- gusting, that the Society will excuse my repeating it. At the time of Mr Home's beginning to turn his thoughts to the composition of tragedy, this author, Otway, had attained that true rank in dra- matic poetry to which his power over the passions, and the exquisite tenderness of his pathetic scenes, so justly entitled him. His name was always cou- pled with that of Shakespeare, by the friends of the drama in this country. Next in rank were 74 ACCOUNT OF THE placed Howe and Southern ; the first for the rich- ness and melody of his verse, the last for that na- tural pathos with which he invested dramatic dis- tress. Congreve's single tragedy of the Mourning Bride had been received with great applause ; cer- tainly there was something very impressive in one of the characters, (that of Zara,} and the incidents, if not very probable, were striking and theatrical. Dr Young had, with a very successful boldness, produced a play on the same subject as that of Othello, which owed, perhaps, great part of its suc- cess to that semi-bombastic dignity with which his Zanga was invested, a character to which Young's florid and swelling diction was well suited, and which gave to some actors, who were celebrated for their performance of that part, (the Irish Mossop in particular,) an opportunity of displaying strong powers, better adapted to the savage and relentless energy of the Moor, than to the expression of more natural feelings. A few months before the first re- presentation of Douglas, Moore brought out his tragedy of the Gamester, a dramatic story, sketch- ed with somewhat a finer pencil than the plays of Lillo, whose family tragedies (as they may be call- ed) had been favourably received by the public, and were on a plan that might be considered original, as they preceded, by a considerable period, the dromes of the French stage, which, for some time, were so popular in France. The Gamester, how- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 75 ever, with all its merits, rather languished on the London theatre, till the reflected reputation which it borrowed from the success of a French imitation of it, which Garrick found in high favour at Paris, brought it into equal favour on the London stage ; and the Society knows the celebrity it has since ac- quired from the exquisite representation of its do- mestic distress in the acting of Mrs Siddons. I may speak of Mrs Siddons, now that she has quit- ted the stage, as an actress of former times ; it would not, perhaps, be altogether delicate to speak of performers who continue to hold a high place there. Mr Home does not seem to have written with any of the above-named authors in his view. Shakespeare, of whose excellence he was an enthu- siastic admirer, he did not think of imitating in manner or in style ; and the later poets he does not appear, from any of his private notes or letters which I have seen, to have either studied or follow- ed. He had, I presume, very early conceived the idea of dramatic composition, and indeed I have not been able to find traces of any poetical attempts of his early life, when he wrote poetry independ- ently of this idea. In his admiration of ancient re- publicanism, which the warm and enthusiastic turn of mind which 1 have before mentioned, as natural to him, readily excited, he had written a prose essay of considerable length, (already noticed 76 ACCOUNT OF THE in the first part of this paper,) somewhat after the manner of Plutarch, on the comparative merits of the Grecian characters ofAgis and deomenes, and the Roman ones of the two Gracchi. In the course of this historical dissertation, he seems to have caught the idea of dramatizing that portion of Spartan history which it led him to study, and he produced his first tragedy otAgis. The plan of this tragedy, as it first rose in his mind, appears to have been conceived without the agency of any other passion than that of patriotism on the one side, and ambition on the other ; but after proceeding a cer- tain length, he was convinced, (as Addison had been in writing Cato,} that his play would not suc- ceed in representation without somewhat more of interest and tenderness being woven into the story, and therefore he introduced the love of Lysander and Eudnthe. This, certainly, whatever objection might be made to it with regard to unity of action, improved the theatrical effect of the plot and in- cidents of the piece, and gave an opportunity, in particular, for one incident in the scene where Ly- sander, disguised in the dress of a helot, attempts to kill Amphares, but is checked by the threat of the Spartan chief, to stab Euanthe, if her lover makes any further resistance, which the author set a particular value on, as he expressed strongly to me on a subsequent occasion, and which Garrick, whose attention to stage effect sometimes, very na- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 77 turally, overcame his literary or critical judgment, perused, (as will appear from a letter which I shall read by and by,) with the highest approbation. The tragedy of Agis remained several years in its author's possession, without his being able to pro- cure its admission to the stage. It was read by se- veral of his literary friends, among whom was a gen- tleman of great ability, but whose abilities were better known as a politician than as a critic, the late Mr Oswald of Dunnikeir, from whom I beg leave, in this place, to read a letter to Mr Home on the subject. The general remarks of this let- ter are more distinguished by their good sense than by their novelty ; and I should perhaps think it too long for the Society to hear, were it not for one interesting circumstance, namely,, that it contains the opinion of the great Lord Chatham on the tra- gedy of Agis, Mr Oswald having left the MS. with that illustrious statesman, for the purpose of obtaining his remarks on it. It is pleasant thus to attend, into the walks of literature and private life, the great public characters who have ruled the fate of nations ; to mark the current of their minds in its purer state, unsoiled and unperturbed amidst the mazes of politics, or the stormy regions of am- bition. I am, however, extremely sorry to say, that Lord Chatham's (then Mr Pitt's) own letter has been lost or mislaid by Mr Home, the most care- less man on earth with regard to papers, so that we 78 ACCOUNT OF THE can only judge of the criticism which it contained, from the representation of Mr Oswald in the letter with which it was accompanied, and in which it was amplified and enlarged. " DEAR SIR, " I received last night a letter from Mr Pitt, which, as it contains a judgment on your play, I have enclosed for your consideration. Since recei- ving it, I have considered your piece, with a parti- cular view to the objections contained in the letter ; which, though not quite enough opened, nor suffi- ciently accompanied with reasons, yet, as they are said to proceed from sentiment, and come from peo- ple of taste, deserve the most serious consideration, taste and sentiment being the ultimate tests of all poetical composition ; though it is possible, by reasoning, to discover the foundations on which such judgments proceed. " The first objection seems directed singly against the manner in which the love affair betwixt Lysan- der and Euanthe is executed, and condemnation is past on the expression of that passion, in both these personages. This criticism is founded entirely on sentiment. But, upon the best reflection I am able to make, if it is a just one, it is more deeply found- ed, and lies against the love intrigue itself, which is not, perhaps from its nature cannot be, sufficient- ly made a part of the main action, so as to mingle LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 79 with, or be transfused into it, and contribute to the general distress or catastrophe. If that is the case, not only any imperfections in this part will be more visible, but at the same time less excusable, than if in those incidents or characters which are more pecu- liarly parts of the main design. The reason of this seems to be, that the attention of the mind being chiefly fixed to the main object, easily passes over whatever is immediately connected with, or contri- butes to it ; and, consequently, easily escapes and forgives such small slips and faults as occur in the hurry which this attention creates, providing they do not intercept the view of the main object, or di- vert the attention any other way. Besides, while the attention remains fixed in general, such slips and faults are not so soon discovered. No ques- tions are asked while the attention is carried on ; and in the progress new lights arise, to clear up what would otherwise be obscure. The mind rests satisfied on the whole, and only critics perhaps demand greater exactness ; but it is quite the re- verse in episodes, or double plots ; for, as these in- fallibly divert the attention of the mind from the main object, they as infallibly give occasion to a thousand questions ; whilst unluckily the poet is not at liberty to answer or explain them, without diverting the attention and distracting the mind still farther. To do it in a full degree, the main object might be wholly eclipsed and lost. To ap- 80 ACCOUNT OF THE ply this general doctrine to the present case, what I apprehend shocks in the episode of Lysander and Euanthe, is, that their situation is not sufficiently explained to justify the impatient passion of the one, and the distressful tenderness of the other ; their sentiments, neither improper in themselves, nor improperly expressed, may become so from the si- tuation not being properly explained ; and, conse- quently, the reader or spectator left at liberty to form such ideas of that situation, as his own force of mind suggests to him, which is not always di- rected by good nature the very reverse of which is always indulged in subjects where aversion is professedly expected. Another inconveniency at- tending episodes, is, that the distress they produce seldom coincides or mingles perfectly with the ge- neral distress or catastrophe of the piece ; and if it does not, it plainly diminishes it in just the same proportion. This inconveniency is hard to be avoided in any episode, unless a very fortunate one indeed ; and I am afraid takes place in this of Ly- sander and Euanthe, which, in some measure, gives occasion to the other objections ; viz. that the catas- trophe consists not of one general distress, but of various distresses, each occasioning a different sen- timent from each other for this I apprehend the objection to be. The distress of Lysander and Euanthe is a different one from that of Agis and Sparta, through the whole play ; and the senti- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 81 ment of compassion different which the mind gives to each. If this is so, they may, perhaps, instead of heightening the sum total of the catastrophe, by taking from each other, rather serve to diminish it. One other cause could possibly be assigned why the catastrophe strikes in this manner, and that is, that Agis's imprisonment, from which period the conspirators might, if they would, have put him to death, may possibly, with some minds, finish the main action in the fourth act ; and if this should be so, the deaths ofAgis, Lysander, and Euanthe, in the fifth act, may not mark the general catas- trophe, or sum total of distress, but appear as so many relations of so many various events, each of which is attended with a different, and not one uniform sentiment. Thus, if the fate of Sparta is supposed to be determined in the fourth act, we are left in the fifth to do no more than survey the different ends of those who followed it. We may pity Euanthe pity and applaud Lysander for his generosity approve of Agis for his benevolence and stoicism, and detest the others. But the mind is not absorbed in one general passion or sentiment, of which all the particular ones are only so many parts which easily mix and blend together ; and such is, and ought to be, the tragic catastrophe. Those reflections which I have thrown loosely to- gether since I received Mr Pitt's letter, did not, I VOL. I. F 83 ACCOUNT OF THE own, occur to me before ; both as being no critic in such performances, and for being charmed, as I still am, with every detached scene of your piece, which I look upon as far the best of the kind I have read. But, on finding objections from a quarter for which I have so great deference, I was tempted to try if I could discover where the real strength of them lay; not only as success is scarce to be expected when objections from such people remain ; but, as I know your genius and ability to be such as can easily free this play from them, or compose another as good, where none such shall exist. I will not pretend to answer for the pertness of any of the observations I have made, being quite a novice in those matters ; But, as I write you with great freedom, I not only submit them to you, but at same time what occurs to me ; if you shall be of opinion that either those objections, or what I have said on them, is mate- rial. What occurs to me then is this ; that I ap- prehend, with your genius and facility of composi- tion, you will find it perhaps both an easier, a more agreeable, and a more successful task, to set about composing an entire new piece, where you will be master of the whole, and thereby enabled, with ease, to avoid every objection which has been made; while at the same time you can transfuse the whole of that poetical spirit, truth of character and inte- rest, and beauty of diction, which has been, I will take upon me to say, so justly admired in LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME, 83 this. Should this be your own opinion, I dare say you cannot fail of success ; and may, perhaps, ob- tain as quick a representation for the one, as you could have had for the other ; which, meantime, may be laid by to wait a more solemn decision, when critics perhaps may change their rninds, as I shall always at least be willing to do mine. One thing you will certainly obtain ; that is, a more fa- vourable hearing both from critics and others. What inclines me to this opinion is, that I verily believe, to one of your genius, it is infinitely easier to com- pose a play, free from such faults as are objected to in Agis, than to amend and alter those objected to. Whatever your opinion is, I beg you will write me with freedom ; and, above all, without being dis- couraged ; for I think I can answer for your suc- cess if you are not. I have got both copies, which I shall dispose of as you direct. All this family is well, and send compliments. " I am, " DEAR SIR, " Yours, with great esteem, " JAMES OSWALD." " Wandsworth, 15tk June, 1750." The suggestion of Mr Pitt was obeyed, and the play materially corrected ; but neither the correc- tions of the author, nor the patronage of those friends, prevailed on Garrick to bring it on the 84 ACCOUNT OF THE stage. Afterwards, when the success of Douglas had given Mr Home considerable reputation, and principally, I believe, when he had become a favou- rite and companion of Lord Bute, and through him was patronised by the Prince of Wales, Gar- rick made no difficulty of bringing out this tragedy, in which he played the part of Lysander himself; and though he criticised, in the following letter, parts of the plan of the tragedy, and some of the scenes in detail, his indulgence for the author got the better of his judgment, and he brought out the tragedy without any of the alterations which he had suggested. It is amusing, when one recollects his absolute refusal of this play at a prior period, to peruse this letter, as well as the short note which I read along with the first part of this paper, from that celebrated actor and manager, whom the mu- ses, I am afraid, interested somewhat in proportion as they were in favour at Court. " Nov. 5, 1757. " MY DEAR SIR, " I sit down to write you in the midst of drums, trumpets, and, above all, the roarings of the mighty Bajazet ; we are celebrating the glorious and im- mortal memory as loudly as we can, but I have stole away to say a word to you upon Agis. I have read the three acts over and over again ; the language and characters in general please me. The subject LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 85 itself is of the least dramatic kind, (viz. political and sentimental,) not but there are some affecting scenes in these three acts ; and if your two last are gloriously poetical, I will insure you both fame and profit. I could wish, if you have rough-written the whole, that you would immediately repair to this place, that we might confer upon these matters, for it will be impossible to say every foolish thing I have to say to you by letter. Some of the scenes are rather heavy, particularly that between Rhesus and Euanthe, and that between Agisaud Lysander, in the second act. I likewise think that Lysander comes too suddenly upon the stage, for Agis has but just quitted it ; Euanthe speaks a soliloquy, then enters Rhesus, giving an account of Lysan- der's arrival and victory, and that he was with Agis. Now, is it possible to conceive that Agis could get to the Senate, meet Lysander there, and that the necessary matters between them could be dispatched in the time so short a scene can be per- formed ? The first scene of the lovers is not, in my opinion, so interesting and affecting as that in the third act, and indeed you'll say that it ought not to be so ; but all I mean is this, that their first scene in the first act is not in proportion so well written and magical as their last, or that in the third act. If you and your friends should think me in this a little too hypercritical, I shall very readily submit to better judgments. 13ut now for something of 86 ACCOUNT OF THE more consequence ; surely the reason that Lysan- der gives to Euanthe, (but I, Euanthe, partial to thy willy SOUGHT THEE IN VAIN,) for being shut up in the city, is a very weak one, and almost amounts to the ridiculous. What ! not find a lady of her quality, who is under the protection of the king, and lives in the palace ? This certainly must be altered.* I was thinking whether the scene be- tween them in the third act might not pass before the gates are shut, and that upon leaving her he finds his going to the camp obstructed by the sud- den order of Amphares,, that then he may return to her in the helofs dress, which would very na- turally and forcibly bring on the fine capital scene in the third act, between him, her, and Amphares. I am speaking at random, and therefore you must make what use you please of these my loose thoughts. Is not there too little matter in the second act ? the whole consists of that very long scene between Agis and Lysander, the entrance of a Senator, the procession, and the soliloquy, (which is a very fine one) of Amphares. I cannot as yet see what use we can make of Sandane ; she is very insignificant hitherto, and unless she has sometnlfTg to do in the two last acts, she will appear to have no business in the tragedy. I am called away, and can only say, * It was, however, not altered. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 87 that the more I read of Agis, the more I like it ; and if the pathos rises to a proper height in the two last acts, I" affair est/aite. It will be a most unspeak- able pleasure to me to convince you how much I regard and esteem you. " I am, dear Sir, " Most sincerely, " Your friend and very humble servant, " D. GARIUCK. " Mrs Garrick presents her best compliments to you ; she has cry'd at you already. You have writ- ten some passages in these three acts, more like Shakespeare than any other author ever did." Yet the objections of Garrick to this tragedy as a play to be acted, seem to me to be well founded. The two first acts lag so much, and have so much of mere languid declamation, that it would be hard- ly possible for any performer to keep up the atten- tion of the audience during this pause of the main action, and the barrenness of incident which attends it. The poetry, however, is in general smooth and flowing, and the sentiments striking and well ex- pressed. There is much of the favourite spirit of the author, the admirer of martial glory, in the short speech of Rhesus t characterising his brother, the second in command in that Thracian army, 88 ACCOUNT OF THE which was to awe the Spartans, and destroy their king: " Next in command my brother Euxus stands, A youth to Mars devoted ; for he loves Danger itself, not danger's rich reward*" And the sentiment of Lysancler, when his prince wishes him to leave him in Sparta, and provide for their future safety by repairing to the army, is hap- pily expressed, without being overloaded, like those of many other dramas, with unnecessary words : " Things past belong to memory alone, Things future are the property of hope ; The narrow line, the isthmus of these seas, The instant scarce divisible, is all That mortals have to stand on." Nor is the reflection of the calm and philosophic Agis without its peculiar merit, and is sufficiently appropriate both to the character and the situation. " In times like these, of a declining state, Baseness infects the general race of man ; But yet these trying times rear up a few More excellent, refined, and conscious spirits, More principled, and fit for all events, Than any in the good, but equal mass, Of a far better age." The following may be thought too bold, and the LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 89 figure is somewhat open to ridicule, in respect of the picture which it presents : " On the insect wing Of a snlall moment, ride th' eternal fates." Yet I have heard it admired at the time ; and even now, in that vague extravagant sort of sublimity, begotten by Genius upon Nonsense, which has dis- tinguished some recent productions, it would, I doubt not, excite admiratibn and applause. In the third act occurs the incident of which, as I have formerly mentioned, the author was so proud, and which Garrick foresaw would strike the audi- ence so much, that in which the villain Ampliares disarms Lysander., by the threat of stabbing his much-loved Euanthe, if he continues to resist. Mr Home has repeated it, with scarce any variation, in one of the closing scenes of his Fatal Discovery. The fourth act does not ill sustain, in the im- portance of its events, and the spirit of its dialogue, the interest which was excited in the third. The Athenian Lysander, bred in the academic school, may be excused, when, amidst the perils of his si- tuation, he utters the following philosophical, but generous exclamation : . " If man is like the leaf, Which, falling from the tree, revives no more, I shall be shortly dust, that will not hear Euanthe's grief, nor see the shame of Sparta ! 90 ACCOUNT OF THE Now I am a living man, my mind is free ; And whilst I live and breathe, by Heaven, I'll act As if I were immortal !" One line, uttered by the same person in this scene, attracted the particular applause of the au- dience, from a circumstance in the conduct of the Seven Years' War, which had then recently hap- pened. Our troops had been foiled in an attempt on the French coast, and the dispatch, if I recol- lect right, of the commander of that detachment, had mentioned the danger which had deterred him from landing, or longer maintaining his position on the coast. In the play, Euxus proposes to Ly- sander immediately to leave Sparta, and depart for the army. " Your stay," says he, " Your stay is full of danger, risk it not." Lysander replies, " All necessary dangers must be risk'd." Some one in the pit exclaimed, " Bellisle" and there was a loud and continued plaudit. The fifth act but ill supports the spirit of the two former, though there is some interest excited by the uncertainty which hangs over the fate of Lysander, till the scene in which he kills Am- phares, and rescues Euanthe. But the audience, when I saw this piece represented, felt the languor LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 91 of its conclusion, and went away not much affected by the death of Agis, and with somewhat of indif- ference ahout the future fate of the lovers, or of Sparta. To this is probably owing the neglect which it has experienced since its original repre- sentation, though certainly superior, in every kind of merit, to many tragedies that have since kept possession of the stage. I think it probable that the suggestion contain- ed in the criticism of Mr Oswald, which I read a little while ago, was the prompter of our author's idea in writing the tragedy of Douglas ; for there are among his papers some hints and scraps that seem to have been germs of that tragedy, which bear the appearance of having been set down very near the time when that letter was written. In conformity, perhaps, with the criticism of that let- ter, he now discarded love from the plan of his dra- ma, and founded it on maternal tenderness a sub- ject which had employed the ablest dramatic poets, from the earliest times, and which was naturally indeed, from the earliest times, entitled to posses- sion of the stage. He wove it into a story, found- ed, I believe, on the old Scots ballad of Gil Mor- rice, which had been recited to him by a lady, and which happily suited the bent of his imagination, that loved to dwell amidst the heroic times of chi- valry and romantic valour, particularly amidst those in which the great names of our ancient Scottish 92 ACCOUNT OF THE Worthies were distinguished. The story, in all its circumstances, was calculated to inflame this sort of imagination, and the incidents which it presented were of an appropriate kind, familiarized to the fancy of a poet of this country, and congenial to its traditional history as well as manners. This seems to me to have been the peculiar felicity which gave Mr Home so great an advantage in the composition of Douglas, and raised that drama so much above all his other works. Of this piece there are extant, among those papers which Mr Home's nephew has been so obliging as to put into my hands, more frag- ments and original sketches, or, as a painter would call them, studies, than of any other of Mr Home's productions ; and it is curious to observe, how much the after corrections of the poet, probably suggest- ed by the remarks of that very able set of friends and companions to whom he early communicated his piece, have improved it.* Yet the chief scene, * These corrections, it is probable, occasioned the belief, which I remember very current at one time, that the supe- rior excellence of Douglas, was owing to the assistance which he received in its composition, from his literary friends. There is a disposition, (whether from envy or a love of de- traction, or merely a sort of pleasure in the discovering of things not commonly known) in the public to impute works to others, instead of their real authors. The same disposition leads to the accusations of plagiarism, so often made on very slight foundations. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 93 one, indeed, which has no equal in modern, and scarcely a superior in ancient drama, that between Lady Randolph and Old JVorval, I have found, on comparing the original sketch with the finished scene in the printed play, to differ scarcely in a word. Thus it is that the fervid creation of genius and fancy strikes out what is so excellent as well as vivid, as not to admit of amendment, and which, indeed, correction would spoil instead of improving. This is the true inspiration of the poet, which gives to criticism instead of borrowing from it, its model and its rule, and which it is possible, in some dif- fident authors, the terrors of criticism may have weakened or extinguished. The only part of any great poetical composition, whether in the dramatic or narrative form, which no genius can produce in a hurry, is the plan and progress of the fable. On that the poet, gifted how much soever he may be, must often pause must consider it in its general effect, as well as in its va- rious parts in detail, in the relation which those parts bear to one another, as well as to nature and probability. He must often look back from the end to the beginning must measure, as it were, the growth of his characters, from their earliest intro- duction into the piece, and trace the connexion of the incidents or scenes, from the opening of his story to its final catastrophe. It was this that made 94 ACCOUNT OF THE Racine say that his piece was written when he had written out its plan ; yet I am rather of the opinion which I had once occasion to hear Garrick declare, that there is a power in exquisite writing to abate the faults, and to supply the wants of a defective plan ; just as an excellent colourist can soften the errors of his drawing, by the lights and shadows of his painting. In Douglas, there are some defects in the plan and construction of the story ; and one which is a sort of merit in the poet to have produced, is the falling off in the interest in the two last acts ; for I think, on an impartial examination, it will be found, that the incidents, and more particularly the dialogue, in these last acts, go off somewhat coldly, chiefly from the high excitement of the spectator's mind in the scene of the discovery ; and it is also to be attended to, that in a play so often represent- ed, the reader always raises up, even in his study, the picture of the representation and in the repre- sentation, the acting ; especially of that admirable actress who has electrified so many audiences in Lady Randolph ; and who, in her interview with the Old Shepherd, has so called forth and exhaust- ed the feelings, as to leave only their languid re- mains to the future scenes of the play. I think that if allowance be made for those disadvantages, the reader will find, in the dialogue between the LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 95 mother and her son, in the fifth act, a degree of tenderness and nature, that in an ordinary tragedy would have been considered excellent. The dic- tion, as well as the delineation of feeling in Dou- glas, seems to me of a very superior kind suffi- ciently beautiful, without losing the proper drama- tic simplicity, and in a high degree poetical, with- out any of that obscurity which in many, especial- ly of modern poems, has been mistaken for poetry. Mrs Siddons told me she never found any study (which, in the technical language of the stage, means the getting verses by heart) so easy as that of Douglas, which is one of the best criterions of excellence in dramatic style. The same great acr tresv however, complained, that in the opening scenes, even with the retrenchments which she was obliged to make, there was a monotony which she found it extremely difficult to support in the deli- very. I apprehend that this remark, which I am persuaded was well founded, was rather a compli- ment than an objection to the style of the piece ; because that sort of level tone which is so difficult to support in scenic representations, is the very voice of nature in those situations of long-nourish- ed settled sorrow, which had been for so many years the constant and cherished companion of Lady Randolph. With such excellence as is now universally al- lowed to the tragedy of Douglas, it was not to be 96 ACCOUNT OF THE wondered at that it should produce a strong sensa- tion in Scotland ; though I will allow, at the same time, that the public curiosity and expectation were considerably heightened by the peculiar situation of its author, the minister of a church, which, in those times particularly, held stage plays in repro- bation. It created a sort of party, as a religious rather than a critical question, and the proceedings, as I have detailed in a former part of this paper, were carried on with a violence which perhaps may surprise us in these more moderate times. This party keenness, however, was favourable, as far as notice and interest are favourable, to the success of the play. But its success did not rest on this ground alone its poetical merit captivated all who had the good fortune to hear any parts of it recited. I have already mentioned that some of the striking pas- sages, among which I particularly recollect the open- ing soliloquy, had been got by heart, and were re- peated by fair lips, for the admiration of their tea- tables. I may observe in passing, that few open- ing speeches are more beautiful in poetry, or more interesting in matter ; though, perhaps, there is a mistake, not uncommon (observable indeed in other soliloquys of this very tragedy) in its dramatic cha- racter, that it tells a great part of Lady Randolph's story. Now, one never, I think, strictly speaking, tells a story to one's-self in soliloquy, though one 13 LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 97 may reflect on its past, and anticipate its future, consequences. No part of dramatic composition, however, has been so little regulated either by nature or proba- bility, as that of the Monologue. On the French stage, till the time of Voltaire, the soliloquys were not indeed narrative ; but they consisted of a string of high-flown sentiments, artificially expressed, equally unnatural and tiresome. I may be allowed to add, that no part of dramatic language is more difficult to the actor. Garrick appeared to me un- rivalled in this department of acting. In speaking soliloquy, in holding those secret and searching dia- logues with himself, he not only forgot the audience, but seemed to hold no communion with any thing external. He put off even the ordinary attributes of the character which he represented ; he wrapt in the dark recesses of his soul, the half-conceived thought, the stifled passion, the secret vengeance, the repressed consciousness of crime. In a low and broken tone, in a language almost independent of words, he expressed the abrupt and scarcely con- nected movements of his mind. In some of those " horrible imaginings," as Shakespeare calls them, which are first developed in soliloquy, from his fix- ed eye, his contracted and furrowed brow, the silent quivering of his lips, with the low stifled tones they breathed, which, by an art almost peculiar to him- VOL. j. G 98 ACCOUNT OF THE self, he made audible to the ear, but still more au- dible to the mind, the impression was powerful be- yond measure. 'Twas like the muttering of a vol- cano, before its fires are seen ; and the audience lis- tened to it with the same deep and silent awe. The Society will scarcely make allowance for this enthu- siastic eulogium ; but any of its members who have seen Garrick will understand it. The episode of the Hermit, in the tragedy of Douglas, is extremely beautiful, and may be even considered natural in the place where it is intro- duced. It was one which had probably risen to the poet's mind in his solitary walks on the shores of his parish ; and of which he was so particularly fond, that he has introduced the idea in more than one of his subsequent productions, with the addition, in one of them, of a picturesque image, which would naturally occur to him amidst the scenes of those walks I have mentioned. " Here I sit in sorrow, Silent and motionless, from morn to eve, Till the sea-fowls that skim along the shore, Fearless alight, and settling at my feet, Scream their wild notes, as if I were a stone, A senseless trunk, that could not do them harm." I have been more full in my remarks on this tra- gedy, because it was that which gave his celebrity to the author, and continues to be distinguished as LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 99 one of the most interesting and pathetic dramas of the modern stage. It is not easy to conceive what could have induced Garrick to reject it when offer- ed to him for representation ; nor did his confidence in his own superior judgment yield even to the ex- perience of its effect in representation at Edin- burgh ; it was brought out at Covent-Garden only, the year after it had been acted in Scotland. Mr David Hume's high opinion of this tragedy, he has told the world in the dedication of a volume of his Essays, published soon after the appearance of Douglas, to his friend the author. His remarks when it was first communicated to him in MS. are contained in a letter, part of which has been torn off, of which the residue is as follows :* * In reading this letter, it is necessary to know, that, as the tragedy was first acted, the names of several of the prin- cipal characters were different from what they were made in the later representations. Lord Randolph was then Lord Barnet, Lady Randolph, of course, Lady Barnet, and Norval was Forman. The author's friends soon discovered the want of dignity in the name Barnet, from its being the name of the well-known village near London ; and Forman was a com- mon sirname of no high rank in Berwickshire. 100 ACCOUNT OF THE Mr DAVID HUME'S Remarks on Douglas. " 1755, a 1756. " DEAR SIR, WITH great pleasure I have more than once perused your tragedy. It is interesting, affecting, pathetic. The story is simple and natural ; but what chiefly delights me, is to find the language so pure, correct, and moderate. For God's sake, read Shakespeare, but get Racine and Sophocles by heart. It is reserved to you, and you alone, to redeem our stage from the reproach of barbarism. '* I have not forgot your request to find fault, but as you had neither numbered the pages nor the lines in your copy, I cannot point out particular ex- pressions. I have marked the margin, and shall tell you my opinion when I shall have the pleasure of seeing you. The more considerable objections seem to be these : Glenalvorfs character is too abandoned. Such a man is scarce in nature ; at least, it is inartificial in a poet to suppose such a one, as if he could not conduct his fable by the or- dinary passions, infirmities, and vices of human na- ture. Lord JBarnefs* character is not enough de- cided ; he hovers betwixt vice and virtue, which, * This name changed to Randolph, after the first repre- sentation. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 101 though it be not unnatural, is not sufficiently theatrical nor tragic. After Anna had lived 18 years with Lady Barnet, and yet had been kept out of the secret, there seems to be no sufficient reason why, at that very time, she should have been let into it. The spectator is apt to suspect that it was in order to instruct him ; a very good end indeed, but which might have been attained by a careful and artificial conduct of the dialogue. " There seem to be too many casual rencoun- ters. Young Forman* passing by chance, saves Lord JSarnet; Old For man, passing that way by chance, is arrested. Why might not Young For- man be supposed to be coming to the Castle, in or- der to serve under Lord Barnet, and OldForman, having had some hint of his intention, to have fol- lowed him that way ? [Some lines torn off and lost.] Might not Anna be supposed to have returned to her mistress after long absence ? This might ac- count for a greater flow of confidence." If the Society will not think me tedious, I shall be tempted to read in this place two other letters from Mr Hume, the first of which mentions his * Changed to Norval, before the tragedy was brought on the stage. 102 ACCOUNT OF THE high opinion of Douglas, but the second has no re- lation either to that or any other production of his friend. But it seems to me so delightful in itself, and is so genuine a specimen of the writer's admi- rable talent for epistolary composition, that I own I reckoned myself fortunate in being permitted to allow the society a perusal of it. It will not be va- lued the less for being altogether on a private sub- ject, evidently written without the most distant view to publication, or even to general perusal. To Mrs D YSART, at Eccles, (a much valued rela- tion o/*Mr D. HUME,) with a book the first part of his History of England. " Qth October, [1754.] " DEAR MADAM, "As I send you along book, you will allow me to write you a short letter, with this fruit of near two years very constant application, my youngest and dearest child. You should have read it sooner, but during the fine weather, I foresaw that it would produce some inconvenience ; either you would at- tach yourself so much to the perusal of me as to ne- glect walking, riding, and field diversions, which are much more beneficial than any history ; or if this beautiful season tempted you, I must lie in a cor- ner, neglected and forgotten. I assure you I would LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 103 take the pet if so treated. Now, that the weather has at last hroke, and long nights are joined to wind and rain, and that a fire-side has become the most agreeable object, a new book, especially if wrote by a friend, may not be unwelcome. In ex- pectation then, that you are to peruse me first with pleasure, then with ease, I expect to hear your re- marks, and Mr Dysart's, and the Solicitor's.* Whe- ther am I Whig or Tory ? Protestant or Papist ? Scotch or English ? I hope you do not all agree on this head, and that there are disputes among you about my principles. We never see you in town, and I never can get to the country ; but I hope I preserve a place in your memory. " I am, " DEAR MADAM, " Your affectionate friend and servant, " DAVID HUME. " P.S. I have seen John Hume's new unbap- tized play,t and it is a very fine thing. He now discovers a great genius for the theatre. * Mr Home, a relation of the Historian, then Solicitor- General for Scotland. t I presume this was Douglas ; and the expression, " he now discovers a great genius for the theatre," I suppose was meant to imply Mr D. Hume's opinion of its being better fit- ted for the stage than Agis. 301) ACCOUNT OF THE [ Written at the top.'] " I must beg of you not to lend the book out of your house, on any account, till the middle of November ;* any body may read it in the house." To Mrs DYSART. " Nmewells, March 19th, 1751. " DEAR MADAM, " Our friend at last plucked up a resolution, and has ventured on that dangerous encounter. He went off on Monday morning, and this is the first action of his life wherein he has engaged himself without being able to compute exactly the conse- quences. But what arithmetic will serve to fix the proportion between good and bad wives, and rate the different classes of each ? Sir Isaac Newton himself, who could measure the courses of the pla- nets, and weigh the earth as in a pair of scales, even he had not algebra enough to reduce that amiable part of our species to a just equation ; and they are the only heavenly bodies whose orbits are as yet uncertain. " If you think yourself too grave a matron to I suppose the time of its publication in London. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 105 have this florid part of the speech addressed to you, pray lend it to the collector, and he will send it to Miss Nancy. " Since my brother's departure, Katty and I have been computing in our turn, and the result of our deliberation is, that we are to take up house in Berwick ; where, if arithmetic and frugality don't deceive us, (and they are pretty certain arts) we shall be able, after providing for hunger, warmth, and cleanliness, to keep a stock in reserve, which we may afterwards turn either to the purposes of hoard- ing, luxury, or charity. But I have declared be- forehand against the first. I can easily guess which of the other two you and Mr Dysart will be most favourable to. But we reject your judgment ; for nothing blinds one so much as inveterate habits. " My compliments to his Solicitorship. Unfor- tunately I have not a horse at present to carry my fat carcase, to pay its respects to his superior obe- sity. But if he finds travelling requisite either for his health or the Captain's, we shall be glad to en- tertain him here as long as we can do it at an- other's expence ; in hopes we shall soon be able to do it at our own. Pray tell the Solicitor that I have been reading lately, in an old author called Strabo, that in some cities of ancient Gaul, there was a fixed legal stand- ard, established for corpulency, and that the senate kept a measure, beyond which, if any belly presu- 106 ACCOUNT OF THE med to increase, the proprietor of that belly was obliged to pay a fine to the public, proportionable to its rotundity. Ill would it fare with his worship and I, [me] if such a law should pass our parlia- ment ; for I am afraid we are already got beyond the statute. " I wonder, indeed, no harpy of the treasury has ever thought of this method of raising money. Taxes on luxury are always most approved of ; and no one will say, that the carrying about a portly belly is of any use or necessity. 'Tis a mere superfluous or- nament, and is a proof too, that its proprietor enjoys greater plenty than he puts to a good use ; and* therefore, 'tis fit to reduce him to a level with his fellow subjects, by taxes and impositions. "As the lean people are the most active, unquiet, and ambitious, they every where govern the world, and may certainly oppress their antagonists when- ever they please. Heaven forbid that Whig and Tory should ever be abolished, for then the nation might be split into fat and lean, and our faction, I am afraid, would be in piteous taking. The only comfort is, if they oppressed us very much, we should at last change sides with them. " Besides, who knows if a tax were imposed on fatness, but some jealous divine might pretend, that the church was in danger. " I cannot but bless the memory of Julius Cag- sar, for the great esteem he expressed for fat men, LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 107 and his aversion to lean ones. All the world allows, that that emperor was the greatest genius that ever was, and the greatest judge of mankind. " But I should ask your pardon, dear Madam, for this long dissertation on fatness and leanness, in which you are no way concerned ; for you are nei- ther fat nor lean, and may indeed he denominated an arrant trimmer. But this letter may all he read to the Solicitor ; for it contains nothing that need be a secret to him. On the contrary, I hope he will profit by the example ; and, were I near him, I should endeavour to prove as good an encourager as In this other instance. What can the man be afraid of? The Mayor of London had more cou- rage who defied the hare. " But I am resolved sometime to conclude, by putting a grave epilogue to a farce, and telling you a real serious truth, that I am, with great esteem, " DEAR MADAM, " Your most obedient humble servant, (Signed) DAVID HUME." "P.*?. Pray let the Solicitor tell Frank,* that he is a bad correspondent the only way in which he can be a bad one, by his silence." The next tragedy which Mr Home composed was that of the Siege of Aquileia, of which Mr * The late Dr Francis Home of Edinburgh. 108 ACCOUNT OF THE Garrick (as I have mentioned in the chronological account of the representations of the author's plays,) entertained the most favourable opinion, and anticipated the most brilliant success. In that ex- pectation he was disappointed, from the circum- stance formerly noticed, of the distress being chief- ly produced by narrative, instead of the livelier means of representation. But, even exclusive of that circumstance, it seems to me that this tragedy, neither as a drama or a poem, is calculated to af- fect or to please nearly so much as either Douglas or some of his other pieces. There are not those bursts of real and overpowering passion with which the audience sympathises and is moved. The words in some degree overwhelm the feeling, and we read verses which indeed contain beautiful and sublime sentiments, but which speak rather than exhibit those contending emotions of the soul, of which the genuine expression in such situations marks the in- spired mind, and the deep conscious skill of the tragic poet. Emilius reminds us of Cato, but it is Cato the orator, rather than Cato the patriot and the father ; yet the contrast between the firmness of Roman virtue in Emilius, and the yearnings of a mother's heart in Cornelia, might, I think, in the hands of such an actress as Mrs Gibber was, have had a powerful effect on the stage, if there had been more of compression in the words, and of picture in the scene. In its present state, it would exhaust the powers of the most unwearied actress, to sup- LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 109 port the part of Cornelia as it ought to be support- ed ; and this is probably the reason why it has never been acted (as far as I know,) since its first representation in London, in 1760. The Fatal Discovery was the next production of his muse, which, though indifferently received at the time of its appearance, and now almost forgot- ten, I am inclined to think, in point of poetry, and indeed of pathos, the next to his Douglas. The subject had probably dwelt on his mind ever since his meeting at Moffat with James M'Pherson, whom, as is well known, he encouraged to make a tour in the Highlands and Islands, to collect the ancient Gaelic poetry, of which M'Pherson had translated fragments to Mr Home, when at that watering-place. From one of those fragments, the subject of this tragedy was taken, and the names of the persons in the poem are preserved in the play. Garrick was of my mind as to its merit, as appears from the following letter : " Hampstead, June 6, 1768. " MY DEAR FRIEND, " I NEVER sat down to write to you with more pleasure than I do at present. I have read Rimne again and again, and every time with greater plea- sure. I could not send it to you so soon as I pro- mised, because I was resolved to get rid of all my theatrical cares, which I did not, on account of the 110 ACCOUNT OF THE Princess's death, till last Tuesday, when I finished the season with Hamlet, and never played that character so well in all my life. But to return to our precious Rivine. How happy am I that I did not give you the copy till I had considered it with all my wits about me ! It is a most interesting, original, noble performance ; and whenever it is exhibited, will do the author great, very great ho- nour. " If your fifth act (as a fifth act,) is equal to the rest, sublimiferies, &c. The construction of your fable is excellent ; you leave the audience, at the end of every act, with a certain glow, and in the most eager expectation of knowing what is to fol- low. I drew the tears last night in great plenty from my wife, and a very intimate friend of ours, who is now with us at Hampstead. I read it with all my powers, and produced that effect which I would always wish to do in reading a work of genius, and more particularly a work of yours. " I shall give the copy to Dr Blair to-morrow morning, for he and Dr Robertson do me the ho- nour to breakfast with me. The literary world, notwithstanding our present unaccountable confu- sion, are in the highest expectation of Dr Robert- son's Charles the Fifth. " I will not descend from my present exaltation about you, to point out some little trifling objec- tions I have here and there in your tragedy ; they LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. Ill are of very little consequence, and if just, can be altered in a morning. I find your friend Dr Blair knows of it, and though I have not yet opened my lips to him upon it, I will talk it over with him to- morrow, by ourselves. I have filled my paper, and my heart and mind are full about you. I shall ever love and esteem you, though I were never to see you again ; for * friendship never dies.' Act 4 Scene 1. " Yours, " Ever and most affectionately, " D. GARRICK. " Pray let me have the fifth act soon, and a com- plete copy, that I may give it another reading. What are your designs about it ? Pray tell me, and tell it me in a hand that does not gallop quite so fast as your imagination." Mr Home's next succeeding performance was the tragedy of Alonzo, brought out at Drury-Lane in 1773. This tragedy, though written at a consider- able distance of time, has more both of the style and story of Doug-las, than any other of the poet's dra- mas, but both are much inferior to those of that ex- cellent tragedy. There are a great many passages in Alonzo so closely resembling those of its sister- play, that the author could hardly have ventured to set them down, if his memory had served him to 112 ACCOUNT OF THE recal those which he had formerly written. Thus the young ^Alberto, the unacknowleged son of the heroine Ormisitida, begins the story of his life : " Alberto is my name, I drew my breath From Catalonia ; in the mountains there My father dwells, and for his own domains Pays tribute to the Moor. He was a soldier. Oft have I heard him of your battles speak, Of Cavadonga's and Olalla's fields ; But ever since I can remember aught, His chief employment and delight have been To train me to the use and love of arms. et Meanwhile, my bosom beat for nobler game ; I long'd in arms to meet the foes of Spain. Oft I implored my father to permit me, Before the truce was made, to join the host." And the King's reply is nearly in the words of Lord Randolph to his young deliverer : " Thou art a prodigy, and fill'st my mind With thoughts profound, and expectations high." And in another place, the King, in words exactly like those of Lady Randolph, says, " Rise, Alberto, To me no thanks are due ; a greater king, The King of Kings I deem, hath chosen thee To be the champion of his law divine." Qrmisindtis admiration of her son, and compari- 15 LIFE Or MR JOHN HOME. 113 son of him with his father, are expressed exactly as ILady Randolph expresses the same feelings : tc Is he not like him ? mark his coming forth Behold Alonzo in his daring son, Full of the spirit of his warlike sire; His birth unknown, he felt his princely mind, Advanced undaunted on the edge of war, And claimed the post of danger for his own." And, in the next act, " Then tell him of his son to wring his heart ! Truly describe the boy, how brave he was ! How beautiful ! How, from the cloud obscure In which his careful mother had involved him, He burst, the champion of his native land." There is likewise, though the author had long cea- sed to exercise any of his clerical functions, the same imitation of the Bible. " Oft," says the stripling Alberto, almost in the very words of David, when speaking of Goliah, " Oft have I kill'd The wolf, the boar, and the wild mountain-bull, For sport and pastime. Shall this Moorish dog Resist me fighting in my country's cause ? And again, " The God of Battles, whom Abdallah serves, Has overthrown the infidel, whose trust Was in his own right arm." VOL. I. H 114 ACCOUNT OF THE There is in many passages of this play the same animated poetry which is found in Douglas ; but there are many more blemishes in the language to balance these. The following is an image of much grandeur, comparing to a sublime natural pheno- menon the mysterious progress of the hero of the piece : " I judge it is Alonzo. Shrouded in anger, and in deep disdain, Like some prime planet in eclipse he moves, Gazed at and fear'd." And in the next scene, the simile, illustrative of a mind uncertain of its future destiny, is natural and beautiful. " But hope and fear alternate sway my soul, Like light and shade upon a waving field, Coursing each other, when the flying clouds Now hide, and now reveal the sun of heaven." It is difficult to conceive the same author, but a few pages after, writing such prosaic lines as the following i " There never was, Nor will there ever, while the world endures, Be found a parallel to my distress." " His eyes, his ears are shut. Oft have I sent Jitters that would have pierced a heart of stone." LIFE OF 3FR JOHN HOME. 115 " A mace he wields, Whose sway resistless breaks both shield and arm, And crushes head and helmet." " Has this youth no name ? Hast thou not heard How he is called ?" " You start and shudder like a man Struck with a heavy blow." " He did not deign to look upon the present, But stretch'd his sun-burnt hands straight out before him, Like a blind man, and would have stood so still, Had I not made his fingers feel the pearls." " Why should I fear to see a grave-clad ghost, Who may so soon be number'd with the dead, And be a ghost myself."* " Then forward sprung, and on the mighty shield Discharged a mighty blow, enough to crush A wall, or split a rock." " The years, the months, the weeks> the very days, Are reckon'd, register'd, recorded there. And of that period I could cite such times, So dolorous, distressful, melancholy, That the bare mention of them would excite Amazement how I live to tell the tale." * Our national vanity must confess the same wretched quibble in one of the most interesting scenes of Shakespeare's Hamlet : " Unhand me, gentlemen ! By heaven, I'll make a ghost of him who lets me !" Lines which (with reverence to Shakespeare be it said) I think it might be judicious to leave out in the acting. 116 ACCOUNT OF THE And in that well known defiance of Alonzo, con- ceived in the very slang of a bruiser. " I'll fight you both,* Father and son at once." Nor is there less a want of propriety and good- taste in the allusion to the hackneyed story in Ovid, in the midst of a mother's anguish : " You know not what you do, unhappy both ! This combat must not, nor it shall not be ; The sun in heaven would backward turn his course, And shrink from such a spectacle as this, More horrid than the banquet of Thyestes." With all its imperfections, however, this tragedy had much greater success in the representation than any of Mr Home's other plays, Douglas excepted. It owed, perhaps, great part of that success to the exertions of Mrs Barry, then in the very zenith of her theatrical fame, for whom Mr Home, in a pre- face which sufficiently speaks his exultation at the applause which his play received, says he wrote the * When Mr Woods, a favourite actor on our Edinburgh stage, brought out this tragedy for his benefit, I suggested a slight transposition of thewords, that took off something from the vulgarity of expression " Both will I fight, Father and son at once." LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 117 part of Ormisinda, a confession which speaks more of policy than dignity in the poet. Of his latest tragedy, Alfred, I am unwilling to speak. His friend, our venerable associate, Df Adam Ferguson, thus accounts for its failure : " Edinburgh, February 7, 1778. " MY DEAR JOHN, " DAMN the actors that have damned the play, and think no more of it till you have time to do what may be necessary for the press, and then con- sider what is to be done with it. Besides the ac- cidents you mention, I can conceive that the sub- stitution of a love-interest for an interest of state, which the audience expected from the name of Al- fred, may have baulked them ; when they appeared to languish, you certainly did right to withdraw it. ****** " I am, " Dear JOHN, " Most affectionately yours, " ADAM FERGUSON." But in truth, its own want of interest in the plot, and of poetry in the dialogue, are quite sufficient, without any other cause, to account for the unfa- vourable reception it met with. There was an uni- form mediocrity in the language, an uniform tame- ness and want of discrimination in the characters, 118 ACCOUNT OF THE sufficient, without the national feeling of the de- basement of the great Alfred into the hero of a love-plot, to tire, if not to disgust an audience. Another tragedy I find among his papers, of the composition of which I am unable to fix the date, but I presume it was at a later period than that of Alfred ; its title is Alina, or the Maid of Yar- row, and it is founded on a fabulous story, of which the time is supposed to be that of the Crusade of St Louis ; but the persons are Scots, and the scene is laid on the Borders of Scotland. This story, being of a sort adapted to kindle those national and he- roic feelings of which Mr Home was so susceptible, one would have thought might have roused his ge- nius to something of the same excellence which his Douglas possesses ; but it is very deficient in all the qualities which give force or interest to drama- tic composition, and the principal female character, Alina, marked with nothing to distinguish or to adorn it, and not placed in any situation in which the ablest actress could make it attractive. Yet the author seems to have been fond of it, for he has made a number of corrections and alterations. An anonymous friend, to whose judgment he appears to have submitted this play, has written an elaborate criticism (as far as can be judged by the fragment of that criticism which exists among Mr Home's papers,) upon every scene of it. But no amend- ment which criticism could suggest, could possibly LIFE OF MU JOHN HOME. 119 give it interest with the reader or with an audience ; it has the most irremediable of all faults, a want of that vigour and creative force of genius for which a number of faults is easily forgiven. By the au- thor's partiality, two fair copies of it were made by two different amanuenses ; but it was never acted, and will probably never be published. 1 found, in a more imperfect form, two acts of an unfinished play, to which the author has affix- ed no title, but which is founded on an East-Indian story, and turns on the invasion of Hindoostan, by a Tartar Prince, who is in love with the daugh- ter of a Rajah, whose hand her father, as well as her own affections, had bestowed upon another. From the two acts which were written, it does not seem to promise any excellence that should make one regret its not being finished. It is probable the story was suggested by Mr Home's intimacy with the author of Zingis, for which tragedy Mr Home wrote the prologue. Zingis was brought out, I think, about the year 1780. If I am right in supposing the time of writing these two tragedies to have been as late as that year, it was after Mr Home had met with the very serious accident of a fall from his horse, which had: nearly cost him his life, and which certainly, though it did not affect his intellect, impaired both the power of his genius and the discrimination of his taste; and this circumstance may easily account 120 ACCOUNT OF THE for their inferiority to his earlier productions. An- other dramatic work, written however at a much earlier period of his life, (for I see mention made of it in a letter from Mr James M'Pherson, in 1774,) is indeed of so inferior a kind, and so utterly un- worthy of Mr Home, that I should not have men- tioned it at all, but for that obligation which biogra- phical truth imposes on me. This is a comedy call- ed the Surprise ; or, W^ho would have ThoiigJit it % It is a tame and spiritless dialogue, without any wit, or even sentiment, to give pleasure to the reader, or any incident in the scenes to give amuse- ment on the stage. It might have fairly been doubted indeed, even without this proof, if Mr Home, even in his most vigorous days, or in his happiest moods of composition, could have produ- ced a good comedy. Though his conversation was always pleasing, and frequently amusing, from the anecdotes with which his memory was furnished ; yet he appeared to me not endowed with that vi- vacity or creative humour fitted to inspire comedy. His very epilogues are always grave and serious, even with a cast of melancholy ; and 1 have rarely found in any of the fragments of his composition, or in his letters, any sparks of humour or of gaiety. I have taken up so much of the Society's time, that I cannot encroach upon it more at present by reading some of the correspondence which passed LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 121 between Mr Home and his friends, among whom were some men whose letters the Society would hear with considerable interest. If they think it worth while to afford me another evening, or part of an- other evening, I may accomplish that purpose, or attempt another, which I conceived on comparing Mr Home's poetry with that of his immediate pre- decessors and contemporaries. This comparison in- duced me to take a short review of the older dra- matists of England, who wrote before the poets of the era immediately preceding Mr Home ; I was thence imperceptibly led to a consideration of the general state of poetry in this country, and that change which it has undergone in recent times ; but several interruptions, both of leisure and of health, have hitherto prevented my finishing those remarks. If I can render them any way deserving the attention of the Society, I will take the liberty of reading them at some subsequent meeting. APPENDIX BIOGRAPHICAL ACCOUNT MR HOME, CONSISTING OF LETTERS TO AND FROM HIS FRIENDS. I AM sorry to find myself considerably disappoint- ed in the Letters which I hoped to lay before the Society, as an Appendix to the Account of Mr Home's Life. In looking carefully over those with which his nephew, Mr John Home, was so kind as to furnish me, I found much fewer than I had ex- pected of sufficient consequence to induce me to read them in this place. This was owing, I believe, to the circumstance which I mentioned formerly, of Mr Home's careless habit with regard to papers, parti- cularly during the concluding years of his life, 124 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF There are still, however, some letters which 1 think will interest the Society, hoth from the cha- racters of the writers, and the subjects to which they relate. These I will read in the order of their dates, as far as that order allows of dividing them into the subjects of the narrative which I for- merly submitted to the Society, taking first those which relate to the early period of Mr Home's life, the openings of his genius, and its subsequent de- velopement in the productions of his muse ; next, those which have reference to the patronage, I might rather say the warm attachment, of Lord Bute, his connexion with whom had the most im- portant effects on his circumstances and situation ; and, if the Society's time or patience will allow, I shall conclude by submitting to it some letters from, and relating to, his illustrious friend Mr David Hume, chiefly written towards the close of that celebrated author's life. One thing I may fairly say, and with the most perfect sincerity, that there is not one sentence of all that correspondence which I have perused, how- ever private or confidential, that does not afford the strongest proof of those amiable dispositions, that warmth of heart, that cordiality of friendship, that perfect disinterestedness with regard to himself, and generosity with regard to others, which I have formerly mentioned as belonging particularly to the character of Mr Home. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 125 The first letter that I shall read is one address- ed to me by our venerable colleague, Dr Adam Ferguson, giving some account of his early ac- quaintance with Mr Home, and of their respec- tive occupations. He apologises for its defects in point of information, from a circumstance, which, however, will increase its interest with us, the very advanced age, and peculiar situation of the writer. " St Andrews, June 3, 1812. " MY DEAR Sm, " I AM sorry to feel that I can do but little to supply the defects of your materials, in framing the intended Memoir relating to the life of my very particular friend John Home. My intimacy with him began at College, about the year 1743, or 44. I left Scotland in the summer 1745, did not re- turn till the year 1751, and had no fixed residence in Scotland till near 1760, and my recollection of transactions, or rather of dates, within this whole period, is very imperfect, and even perplexed. " As to Mr Home's early visits to London, I heard of one in company with some of Mr Adams' family, and believe it was then he met with his re- pulse from Garrick, and made his address to Shake- speare's monument. I know not whether he was then presented to Lord Bute, but have heard of his interviews with Mr Pitt, afterwards Earl of Chatham. His openness, ardour, and warmth of 126 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF heart, recommended him equally to Mr Pitt and Lord Bute ; but the political difference which arose and increased betwixt these personages, lost him the one in the same degree as he acquired the other. " It was, I think, in his first visit to London, he fell in with Collins the poet, perhaps introduced by Mr Barrow, who, as you suppose, was his fellow ad- venturer in the Castle of Doune, and continued through life his warm and affectionate friend, as I too experienced by Home's recommendation. Home's access to Lord Bute procured Barrow the office of pay-master to the army, during the Ame- rican war, where scores of millions passed through his hands, and left him returning to England, I believe, nearly as poor as he went. " I lived, as you suppose, with Mr Home, at Braid, a farm-house two miles south of Edinburgh ; but as to the date, I can say nothing, but suppose it may have been after the first representation of Douglas at Edinburgh, and after he was far gone in the favour of Lord Bute. " I remember he was then much engaged in ver- sifying, but cannot say what. I think, but may be mistaken, it was in some changes or amendments wished by Lord Bute, in the tragedy of Agis ; and even in concert with Garrick, who was beginning to regard the influence of Lord Bute more than he had formerly regarded the applications of Home. I LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 127 am by no means qualified to mention what differ- ent subjects, or works, Mr Home attempted or executed, as I myself, during the busiest time of his life, was much engaged abroad, sometimes in the Low Countries, in Germany, Switzerland, and even in America. As to any attempt of his in co- medy, I never heard of any such thing ; and, if the public are not much interested to know the failures as well as successes of literary men, I should be willing to have the attempt in comedy you men- tion entirely suppressed, as one of the mistakes we commit in moments of dulness or error. " As to what you call the party at MofFat, I can- not pretend to recollect the date to which it may be referred. I believe it was not any concerted par- ty. John Home was there by himself lived at the Ordinary and met with James M'Pherson at the Bowling-Green. M'Pherson was there with his pupil, young Graham of Balgoun, [now Lord Lynedoch,] living with his mother, Lady Christian Graham, at her brother, Lord Hopetoun's house, in that village. What passed between John Home and James M'Pherson, I soon after heard of; and had no doubt it was a continuation of what had pass- ed frequently betwixt Home and myself, on the sub- ject of reported traditionary poetry in the Highlands. There was another Highlander there, who, as well as Mr Home, I understood, obtruded on M'Pher- 128 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF son with inquiries on that subject. M'Pherson con- firmed the reports ; and being asked whether he could exhibit any specimens, said he was possessed of several ; and on Home's wishing to have some translation, M'Pherson agreed, and furnished him with some of \hosefragments which were afterwards printed in a pamphlet, and drew that public atten- tion which gave rise to the further proceeding on the subject. " David Hume was not at Moffat when these in- terviews with M'Pherson took place ; he was, you know, a professed sceptic, and cannot properly be said to have ever formally affirmed or denied the authenticity or imposture of the poetry in question. He began, and continued to call for evidence per- haps for more evidence than the circumstances of the case could admit ; but this, you know, is the essence of scepticism ; to most men, day-light is sufficient evidence that the sun is rising or risen ; but the sceptic would always have more, even if the rays were vertical. " As to the project and subscription which after- wards took place, to dispatch M'Pherson to collect more poetry in the Highlands, I was not then in Scotland, nor heard of it till some time afterwards. " Mr Home certainly never entertained any doubt that the original of Mr M'Pherson's tran- slations was traditionary in the Highlands. 13 LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 129 " As to the society he mostly frequented at Lon- don, you seem to be sufficiently informed. Lord Bute generally treated him with an uncommon de- gree of affection ; their minds were much at uni- son in all the sentiments of admiration or contempt. The sphere of attentions paid to Mr Home at Lon- don, no doubt extended after the representation of Douglas ; but I have ever since been too little in London to be apprised of particulars for your infor- mation ; and as to the defects of what you might expect from me on the subject of this letter in ge- neral, I trust you will forgive it, being now for many years declining, while you and many other younger men are advancing in knowledge and power. " I am visited sometimes by Dempster, who is possibly too old for your acquaintance, but I call him a younker, being myself about to enter on my ninetieth year. " I am, " My DEAR SIR, " With great esteem, " Your most obedient, and most " Humble servant, " ADAM FERGUSON." VOL. I. 130 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF Part of a Letter from Mr HOME, to a friend, giving a humorous Account of himself, after re- covering from a severe Jit of the Toothache ; con- cluding with a Description of BLACK LOCK, the blind poet. " DEAR SIR, " I FANCY my letter last week would puzzle you strangely, and make it hard for you to divine the fate of the china and the wig, (for a wig was got by George's care ;) but by the inexcusable neglect of the china merchant, who undertook to send them with some other boxes that were going for Dunse, they have both lain in his shop all this week. I should be extremely sorry if I thought that this disappointment had given as much pain to Mrs Home or you, as it has done to me. " Yesterday I was out for the first time, having been obliged, after a number of tormenting success- less remedies, to draw the tooth where the pain was seated, which has relieved me for this bout. I am now what one, at first sight, would call a polite fel- low, being much thinner and paler than usual ; and when I am dressed in my folio coat, I very much resemble those petit maitres that are pictured on the frontispieces of Moliere's plays. My spirits were so low for some time, that the taste for read- ing, and even for arguing with my companions, was LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 131 sunk to a degree that alarmed me with fears of its never rising more ; for, in my severest intervals, I could not attend to the most easy deductions of reason, but I am now in a more hopeful way, and soon Shall wonted ardour in my bosom burn, And the fierce spirit of dispute return. \ "As soon as I went to town, I called at your car- rier, and though I repeated my visit, found he had nothing for me ; after which, I went to a compa- nion's, and sent for the blind poet,* who is really a strange creature to look at ; a small, weakly, under thing a chilly, bloodless animal, that shivers at every breeze. But if nature has cheated him in one respect, by assigning to his share, forceless sinews, and a ragged form, she has made him ample com- pensation on the other, by giving him a mind en- dued with the most exquisite feelings the most ardent kindled up affections ; a soul (to use a poet's phrase) that's tremblingly alive all over ; in short, he is the most flagrant enthusiast I ever saw ; when he repeats verses, he is not able to keep his seat, but springs to his feet, and shews his rage by the most animated motions. He has promised to let me have copies of his best poems, which I'll trans- mit to you whenever he is as good as his word. In * Dr BUcklock. 132 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF the meantime, as small fish are better than none, you will accept of the inclosed Ode on Mercenary Love, which was shewn to Blacklock by an ac- quaintance of mine, along with some others, and by him preferred to the rest. Receive with this, Par- nell, Gaff, and Virtot's Revolutions of Portugal, which Mrs Home will accept instead of a com- pliment written especially to her. Pray let me hear from you next week. Three Letters from Mr Home to Dr Carlyle; writ- ten from London, when smarting under his dis- appointment of not getting his Tragedy ofAgis brought on the Stage. It were trite to say, after its being concentrated into the adage "genus irritabile vatum" that the same sensibility which inspires excellence in poetry, gives proportional acuteness to the pains of neglect and disappointment ; but it may be fair to remark, on the other hand, that this irritability (which I cannot bring myself to call unfortunate) frequently aggravates the neglect much beyond what it would appear to soberer minds, who give themselves lei- sure to consider all the circumstances of the case. I wish this qualifying remark to accompany our author's account of the reception of his play by one person, at least, of most respectable character, whom LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 133 other muses acknowledged as their most benevolent patron and supporter. The same kind of feeling which I have ventured to ascribe to poets, makes per- sons of genius contemptuous of ordinary men, espe- cially when their youth and inexperience, " fresh from the classic walks of Greece and Rome," pre- vent their justly appreciating the use of such cha- racters. Poets, beyond all other men, live amidst a creation of their own, where the castle-building of their fancy smooths every thing around them, without ever supposing any of those obstructions which they must infallibly meet with when they come to jostle amidst the realities of the world. They are catched, if I may be allowed the expres- sion, with the polished part of the fabric of human life ; they forget how indispensible are the less showy materials that compose the rubble work of the building. With these prefatory observations, I may venture to read the two following letters, without detracting from that philanthropy and milk of hu- man kindness, for which, in truth, Mr Home was so remarkable : " London, 6th November, " DEAR CARLISLE, " I DID not write to you upon the road, because I was in no spirits, having travelled about one half of the road alone ; besides, I had nothing very ma- terial to report of Marchmont's criticisms ; he ex- 134 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF tolled the spirit and characters of the piece, but ob- jected to the bloodiness of the catastrophe, and to the want of regularity and sequence of the scenes. As to the first of these objections, I know that the most applauded plays on earth are as bloody, and ought not to be less so. As to the suite of the scenes, the strictness of it would spoil almost every fable, and I think that I have enough of it. Blair and Maghie are to read it this night and to-mor- row, after whose judgment I shall shew it to Lit- tleton. I have seen nobody yet but Smollett, whom I like very well. " I am a good deal disappointed at the mien of the English, which I think but poor. I observed it to Smollett, after having walked at High-Mall, who agreed with me. " Westminster Abbey is the only object to my content. I believe that I shall be very much there at my leisure hours. I contemn all the buildings that I have seen, except a chapel called the Ban- quetting-house, which is admirable. I shall write Logan as soon as I have seen the lions and other pagans that reside in this city. The people here LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 135 are incredibly surprised to see a raw Scotchman so little surprised, and so well acquainted with all that he sees. " JOHN HOME." " MY DEAR CARLISLE, " I HAVE long delayed writing to you, in expec- tation of writing what might be agreeable with re- gard to myself, or interesting as to others. I can- not say that I will at this present time do either of these, but I do not think it is fit I should be long- er silent. Know, then, that as to myself, I have met with one disappointment. After having made some alterations in my play, and turned out some Scotticisms, or vulgarities as they were termed, Mr Littleton refused to read it, because if he did not approve it, he would be pained in saying so, and if he did, he would be put to as much trouble in supporting it, as he was last winter in carrying through Coriolanus, which, with all his interest, he hardly could make run for nine nights, for which reason he would not read a tragedy as a judge, nor engage in it as a patron, if it was writt by his own brother. I was also told, that it was not to be ex- pected that any young man could write a tragedy better than Mr Thomson, who was the greatest poet of the age, (a brother of Littleton's, a dignified clergyman, told me all this pleasing matter,) I bowed, and answered, ' that Mr Thomson was a 136 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF descriptive poet.' I thanked the gentleman for his civilities, and walked off with less appearance of chagrin than you will think possible. I thought at first that Littleton had read the play, and took this gentle way of dismissing me ; hut upon putting that, and desiring to know the worst, this parson, who I believe fears God, (though perhaps he may be a little Arminian,) assured me most solemnly, ' that Mr Littleton had not read it, and that he himself did not pretend to be a judge in these mat- ters, having addicted himself to the study of na- tural history ; however, that he would have read it for all that, if it had not been his extraordinary business in attending upon the King as chaplain.' You see what people I have to deal with ; I am only vexed that I applied to them. I could divide my body into two, and go to buffets with myself, for having solicited a dish of skimmed milk, (as Hot- spur says,) in such an honourable action. I believe I need hardly tell you, that Maghie, Blair, and Barrow, judged of j4gis as Logan, Blair, and you have done. I cannot help telling 'you that one Englishman, after extolling the genius of the piece, added, * that the author had formed himself too much upon Thomson's Seasons, and Lee's plays/ I could not have been more surprised if he had said that I had formed myself upon Euclid's Elements, and M'Laurin's Fluxions. The genius of this na- tion is really a little gross ; by what I can see of LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 137 their public buildings, their entertainments, and their conversations, the plumb-pudding, and but- ter-sauce, makes their intellectuals boggy. How- ever, I have met with some charming fellows amongst them, Oxonians that were republicans, and citizens that were patterns of taste. * ****** Your friend Smollett, who has a thousand good, nay, the best qualities, and whom I love much more than he thinks I do, has got on Sunday last three hundred pounds for his Mask. * * * # * * # * " JOHN HOME." ** My DEAR CARLISLE, " I ADDRESS this to you with pleasure, as it will certify you of the more favourable state of my af- fairs, and that I hope to set out in a few days with assurance, if not certainty, of my plays being acted next winter. Kay, to whose cousin, Oswald, 1 am infinitely obliged, will tell you the particulars. I know your good sense and affection for me to be both so great, as that you will easily excuse the ne- glects in writing from a man like me, whose mind was torn with anxiety, shame, and indignation. I have now recovered my spirits and begun to write to my friends, the moment that it is not painful for me to write, and for them to receive my letters. Before I go any further, I desire you to make my 138 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF compliments, (but that's a cursed word,) to pre- sent my most respectful and affectionate remem- brance to your father and mother, who I doubt not have often wondered at my silence. I delayed from post to post, because every day I expected to be the harbinger of better tidings. * * * * * * # * * I can't write to you about London as I do to other people to whom every thing is news. You know it better than I do, and we shall compare notes plentifully. I must acquaint you, that I found [torn off.] which is a most excellent place, neither are the chop-houses to be despised ; only the people here in general are so execrably stupid, that there is no conversing with them, and their men of learning such shallow monsters, that I am always obliged to be upon my guard, lest I should really shock, or seem to insult them. I sometimes heark- en to the coffee-house conversations upon poetry and politics, where there are such fellows authors, whose wigs are worth three pounds sterling, that it is ready to make a man of moderate patience * Curse his better angel from his side, and fall to reprobation.' " JOHN HOME." LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 139 I am now to read three letters from Mr James M'Pherson, who at that time, I believe, was a sort of editor or manager of some newspapers in the in- terest of government, because they relate to an event which the national pride of this country sets down as a very extraordinary one, the combined fleets of France and Spain cruizing in the British Channel, and threatening to cover an invasion, and exhibit the feeling of the country on that event. One cannot help comparing that with the alarm af- terwards felt from the preparations for a French in- vasion, and contrasting therewith a prouder nation- al feeling, when the embodying and discipline of a militia, and other native force, had rendered the fears of an invasion a bugbear, with which no man, scarce a woman or child, condescended to be fright- ened. " MY DEAII Sm, '* I HAVE news to tell you. The French and Spanish fleets are in the mouth of the Channel. An express arrived this morning, a lieutenant of the Marlborough, of 64 guns, which ship was cha- ced by the enemy to within a few leagues of the Lizard. Sir Charles Hardy was, by the last ac- counts, off Ushant. I reckon it likely that he has 140 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF them between him and the land. The lieutenant says that an action must have happened ; a general anxiety prevails, but less than you could have sup- posed. Our friends look a little blue. The times are big with events. I have no doubt of our beat- ing them, unless the same devil who turmoiled the 27th of July, 1778, has still his black hand at our admiral's helm. The express counted sixty-three sail, 'tis said of the line ; I hope sixty- three was the number of the whole. Should any new lights come ere the post sets out, you may be put to the ex- pence of another ninepence. We may probably demand the swords of the S. Fencibles, in this part of the world. " Yours, very affectionately, " JAMES MACPHERSON. Tuesday, two 6 'Clock, Aug. 17, 1779." " Tuesday, two o' Clock, Aug. 31. " NOTHING new of the fleets. By the last of- ficial accounts, the C. d'Orvilliers, with fifty of the line, had advanced to where Sir Charles Hardy had been left, on the 19th. Our fleet had been driven further west. 'Twas thought Sir Charles was on another tack, and about twelve leagues off. There are thirty-two French, and eighteen Spaniards of the line, with D'Orvilliers, sixteen of the line with D. Lewis de Cordova, in sight. The fifty under D'Orvilliers are in this order : Forty- five divided UFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 141 into three squadrons ; these subdivided into nine lesser squadrons, each consisting of three French and two Spaniards ; five ships of the line, under the Che- valier de la Touche-Treville, destined to conduct the transports, should our fleet suffer itself to be beat or blocked up in a port. Official information says, that the embarkation at St Male's was to have begun on Friday last, the 27th. Some reports came to-day, that 32,000 were at sea. The wind is truly an invasion wind two points to the west of south. We think here that Hardy ought to beat 'em ; others say, he will miss them and gain the Chan- nel. I am not under great apprehensions ; and John Bull keeps up his spirits wonderfully. All is calm, tranquil, and easy here. The stocks don't fall ; and all the animal functions, and even plea- sures, go on as usual. We shall hear some news soon. 'Tis a time of anxious suspense to specula- tive men." " September 3d, 1779. " This morning an express from Sir C. Hardy. He was coming up Channel the combined fleet be- hind, it is said, under a press of sail, in pursuit. The fogs which prevailed at the mouth of the Chan- nel during the east wind, prevented their meeting. All was involved in night. They mutually heard the signal guns, but could not see each other. We expect a decisive action. I am not of that opinion. ] 42 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF John Bull is perfectly indifferent. Stocks rise ; yet the fate of the kingdom may depend on the turning up of the dye. One is disgusted with the white lies of the day. I believe the Bourbons are serious. Johnston's fifty gun Romney is thrown out of the line. Hardy is in great spirits so is the whole fleet. But, if we look back, through time, we never had a sea-advantage over France, but with superiority of numbers. I hope to announce a victory in my next. The times are critical. A defeat would involve us in confusion. I don't think that drilling business ought to be your province in these times. The battle will happen, perhaps, at Spithead. Though I ought to know many things, they communicate nothing. The bell-man is at the door." The next class of letters, from Lord Bute, I think may be considered historical, in so far as they seem to me decisively to contradict an idea very generally entertained afr the time, and frequently repeated since, that there was a certain secret in- fluence possessed by that nobleman, which regula- ted the choice of ministers, if not the adoption of measures ; and placed between the people and the sovereign, a sort of intermediate and invisible agen- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 143 cy, possessed of power without responsibility, which therefore, the constitutional authority of parliament could not directly controul, nor the voice of the public its applause or its censure easily reach. From the letters I am now to read, on the contrary, it ap- pears that Lord Bute, when he did retire from offi- cial situation, retired in good earnest, and was hap- py to be relieved from all concern whatever with public matters. In such retirement, he felt him- self, as he conceived, neglected and forgotten, much beyond the degree of neglect and oblivion which commonly follows the relinquishment of power. The first letter, dated 20th September, 1755, may serve as an answer to the accusation brought against him by Lord Chatham, when boasting of having called forth the valour of Scotsmen and Highlanders in the service of their country. " It was not the country I objected to, but the man of that country ; because he wanted wisdom, and held principles incompatible with freedom." London, September 20, 1755. " DEAR HUME, " I HAVE been living a most unsettled life ever since I received your first. Real business should plead for my silence, and yet I am loath to make that excuse, because it sounds like an affected one. I know you so well, that I flatter myself you will be satisfied with assurances, that it no way proceeded 13 144 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF from any want of regard or real esteem. I long much to know how Douglas goes on. Garrick and I have never met since I saw you. I don't much like that scheme of shewing your play to Mallet ; for I own I have not that great opinion of his taste ; but prudential reasons with regard to Garrick may make it necessary. Since Lady Dalkeith's intend- ed marriage has been owned, I, from being an ut- ter stranger to Mr Townshend, have little interest with her ; but I have imparted to my brother your request, who will, I am certain, do what he can. " I once thought of sending a beautiful ode of Voltaire's on the lake of Geneva, but I see they have printed it, so that you will certainly see it ; and yet I must give you here a few lines out of It: " Ce Loi est le premier ; c'est sur ces bords heureux, Qu' habite des humains La Deesse eternelle, L'ame des grands Travaux, 1'objet des nobles voeux, Que tout mortel embrasse, ou desire, ou rapelle, Qui vit dans touts les cceurs et dont le nom sacre, Dans la Cour des Tyrans est tout bas adore, La Liberte, &c." "Again, talking of the people's success in defend- ing Geneva against the sovereign, he says, " Leurs fronts sont Couronnez, de ces fleurs Que la Grecc, aux Champs de Marathon, prodiguoit aux vainquers. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 145 C'est la leurs diademe, ils en font plus cle compte Que d'un cercle a fleurons de Marquis ou de Comte. On ne voit point ici la grandeur insultante Portant de I'epaule au cote Un niban que la vanite A tissu de sa main brillante. Ni la fortune insolente Repoussant avec fierte La priere humble et tremblante De la triste pauvrete. On n'y rneprise point les travaux necessaires, Les etats sont egaux et les hommes sont freres." " Excellent truth, with which I will end this scrawll, desiring you to believe me, " DEAR HOME, " Your's, most humbly, " BUTE." On the subject of a Tutor to his Son. " DEAR HOME, " I am very much obliged to you for the friend- ly endeavours you have used for me, in a point of the greatest consequence. A person acting up to the character you draw of Mr Ferguson would be a treasure to me, and deserve my warmest protec- tion. I spoke to Elliot upon the subject, and de- sired him to write my thoughts, as I had it not then in my power to do it myself. You would find by VOL. I. K 146 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF him, that I want to change the plan of my chil- dren's education. You have often heard me talk of schools with horror. Before I received yours, I had been on the search of a person in whom I might repose the greatest trust I shall ever have in my power to place in any man ; for it is not Greek and Latin that I am most anxious about, 'tis the for- mation of the heart the instilling into the tender ductile plant, noble generous sentiments, real reli- gion, moral virtue, enthusiasm for our country, its laws and liberties ; in short, ideas fit for the situa- tions my children, especially my eldest boy, will, in all probability, be in ; the man who does this, or indeed attempts it honestly, (for who can answer for the success of the wisest education) must be my friend, and will most certainly find me extremely his. A person fit to take this great line, cannot, must not, be embarrassed with teaching the first ru- diments of education. I should therefore provide some other person for that, under his eye. I have now opened my heart to you, and have given you, dear Home, more data to go upon. You will now be a better judge of the important commission you kindly take in hand. I expect every post to hear of Agls you know I am to be feasted with the acts as they are completed. " I am this minute come from Harrowgate, where I found Mountstuart proud of having made his first essay for the silver arrow ; and not far off a victory. He enquires after his friend, as well as Frederick ; LIFE OF Mil JOHN HOME. 147 and hopes Agis will make him amends for the loss of Douglas. All are well here, and all your warm wishers. Adieu, " DEAR HOME, " Believe me ever " Most sincerely yours, &c. " BUTE. "Kew, August 1th, 1757." " DEAR HOME, " 1 observe in your last letter that you make no mention of the length you are got in your play. Though I long to see you, yet it is so impossible for you to do any business here, that I own I should, (though against myself,) advise remaining in Scot- land to finish it, unless you propose putting it off to another winter, which may be perhaps the most prudent measure. I have now read again and again your friend's* history, and cannot express how much it pleases me ; the opening and winding up are magnificent ; the characters equal to any thing I ever read ; and the style noble, animated, and pure. I protest, in my opinion, it stands the first history in the English tongue. I hope he will hear as much from others ; and that, encouraged by the jUst re- ward of superior merit, he will procure new laurels * Dr Robertson's, 148 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF by some other masterpiece. I hope he has got some good hand to do it justice in a French translation ; for I should be grieved to hear of its appearing mu- tilated in a foreign dress. Adieu, " DEAR HOME, " Yours, most entirely, " BUTE. "London, February 20th, 1759." " DEAR HOME, " As I may probably continue the next winter abroad, I send this letter by George Johnson, to be delivered into your own hand. I assure you I am sorry to go without you ; and yet, for the reason I mentioned in my last, you will see with me, the ne- cessity of it ; besides, if you are here next winter, I know your warm heart so well, that I am certain you will not suffer me to be calumniated and abu- sed in my absence, without taking proper methods of answering these infamous wretches, where it is necessary or expedient ; and I shall also expect to know the state of things' from you, with more free- dom than from others ; in short, if you are here, I know I have a warm and zealous friend in this pan- demonium, who will not leave me in ignorance of any thing material that comes to his knowledge. When once I know your motions and your time, I will apprize you how to direct to me, as I shall LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 149 leave my name behind me, for these vipers to spread their venom on ; for, believe me, whatever advan- tage to my health this odious journey may be of, I know too well the turn of faction to suppose my absence is to diminish the violence I have for so many years experienced a violence and abuse that no fear has made me too sensible to ; and perhaps the more, that I may think I merit a distinguish- ed treatment, of a very opposite nature, from a peo- ple I have served at the risk of my head. I have tried philosophy in vain, my dear Home. I can- not acquire callosity ; and were it not for something still nearer to me still more deeply interesting I would prefer common necessaries in Bute, France, Italy, nay, Holland, to 50,000 a-year, within the atmosphere of this vile place. But see it I must ; so fate decrees ; and I am doomed, therefore, to ex- perience, to my last minute, all the consequences Adieu, dear Home, and depend upon it, if I live to return, you will have restored to you, in my pre- sence, a very cordial and affectionate friend, " BUTE. " London, July W]th, 1763." " Venice, October 5tk, 1770. " I have just received your letter, my worthy bard, and wish you every happiness your heart can desire in your new situation. It is, of all others, 150 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF that in which there exists no medium. Felicity or misery must attend it , may the first be your con- stant lot ; for I know you well enough to be cer- tain that was your whole aim ; and that you are in- capable of those sordid interested views, that form the basis of modern alliance, where the heart never has any share, and even desire is often wanting ; which passion, common to all animals, is, however* the only thing this age christens by the name of Love void of tender feelings, and real delicacy. Where the half-crown does not make the match, brutal desire is alone substituted for those exquisite sensations those raptures in which the soul and body have an equal share ; and which, with me, makes the essence of that universal passion I call love ; this enjoyment cannot pall, nor age or sick- ness weaken. May you both experience this supe- rior bliss, to the last hour of life. I have but a poor account to give of myself. Near three months of this envenomed Sirocco has lain heavy on me ; and I am grown such a stripling, or rather a wither- ed old man, that I now appear thin in white clothes that I looked Herculean in when I was 20. I hope I may get better, if permitted to enjoy that peace, that liberty, which is the birth-right of the mean- est Briton, but which has been long denied me. Adieu, DEAR HOME, " Yours, most affectionately, " BUTE." LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 151 " London, March 25t/i, 1773. " DEAR HOME, " I DON'T wonder you are surprised at not hear- ing from me ; it would appear to any one else most unkind, but you know me enough not to measure my friendship by my letters. Alas ! my friend, For- tune has been determined to empty every enve- nomed arrow out of her quiver against me, which, joined to so long a state of bad health, will bring matters to a quicker issue ; which, far from a pain- ful, is rather a comfortable reflection at my time of life. Few men have ever suffered more, in the short space I have gone through of political war- fare, and yet the violence of open enemies has least affected me. Think, my friend, of my son Charles being refused every thing I asked. I have not had interest to get him a company, while every alder- man of a petty corporation meets with certain suc- cess. I am now in treaty, under Lord Townshend's wing, for dragoons in Ireland ; if I don't succeed, I will certainly offer him to the Emperor. A thou- sand thanks for the boxes and snuff; before I re- ceived it, I had got a provision from Prestonpans, that will, I believe, last my life. You say nothing of moving southward, though my motions and re- sidence are too uncertain to make me wish for it. If I am in being, and in this part of the world, I need not tell you that I shall rejoice to see you. 152 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF Adieu, my good friend. Health, quiet, and hap- piness attend you many years. " Yours, most affectionately, " BUTE." " London, June Zltk, 1780. " DEAR JOHN, " How are matters going on with you in the world, while we here have hoth lives and property at stake ? This mad Scotchman* has lighted up a flame that will not be so easily extinguished, though at present, surrounded by fifteen thousand men, it remains dormant. You will easily perceive, that under the colour of religious zeal, three different purposes were pursued by three very different sets of people ; the breaking open the prisons and plun- dering houses, were the natural operations of the abandoned populace. Lord Mansfield's house, and many others, they have found marked for destruc- tion, (of which both mine in town and country had the foremost rank,) belong to counsels you cannot be at a loss to guess ; but the attack on the Bank, of the New River water-pipes, and the particular fire-balls made use of, came from those who really wished the total destruction of this once-great * Lord George Gordon* LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 153 country. Fanaticism in burning Romish chapels, with a formidable list found of thirty-five thousand Roman Catholic houses, all destined to the flames, may be deemed to proceed from a fourth junto. You will see printed, by authority, lists of three or four hundred killed and wounded ; but Charles tells me the first don't exceed thirty. The troops had very cautious orders, and acted accordingly : Never was an hour where spirit was so necessary to save a country at the gates of destruction ; but that is fled from this island, and exists only in the first person amongst us. The extempore speech he made at Council, drew tears from several there, ' I lament the conduct of the magistrates, but I can only answer for one one (putting his hand on his breast,) will do his duty' The language of is, at this hour, ' Poor creatures ! they did not mean mischief, a mere frolic, &c. and now all over, so that keeping the troops has very sinister purposes.' I fear, indeed, those in power think it over ; but the troops once gone, I look on the fate of my house as determined ; indeed, nothing but my son Charles, with forty of the Royals, saved it on the Thursday ; and as to this place, I fear they may destroy it when they please. Twenty men left at Luton would have secured me, for a mob can't come from London without its being known, but eight or ten villains may do here what they please. Charles is to send me arms, but his account of the 154 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF servants left in town renders them useless, for he says, except Peter, they were all sneaking cowards. O ! my friend, how does this demonstrate the folly I have been guilty of in all done here ? One-fourth as much at Bute would have made that the first seat in Britain, and given me a comfortable and se- cure asylum in the decline of life ; but repentance comes too late, and now, ' come what come may, time and the tide wear out the roughest day.' " The last division of the correspondence, which I have selected from other letters, less interesting to the Society, consists of some from Mr Home's celebrated friend, to whom I have had occasion so often to allude, David Hume ; many of whose letters, I regret to say, our poet, with his charac- teristic inattention to such matters, appears to have destroyed, or rather probably neglected to keep, as his nephew, to whose kindness I am indebted for a communication of his uncle's papers and correspond- ence, has been able to find but a very few. In the first part of this paper, I mentioned ajeu d 1 esprit of Mr Hume's ; who, being kept out of the secret of a humorous pamphlet, written by his inti- mate friend, Mr Ferguson, took his revenge by wri- ting to Dr Carlyle a letter, claiming the work as LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 155 his own ; and I took occasion to observe how much this anecdote tended to confirm an observation which had frequently occurred to me, of the uncer- tainty of the evidence arising from letters, when the writers are dead, and the motives of the corre- spondence cannot be known. I have now been fa- voured with a copy of that letter, which I will read to the Society, who, I think, will perceive, that though plainly ironical to us, who know the pre- vious circumstances, there is an air of sober reality about it, that would have made it appear perfectly serious to one who should have found it at some distance of time, without being possessed of such previous knowledge. "Edinburgh, 3d February, 1761. " DEAR SIR, " I AM informed that you have received a let- ter from London, by which you learn that the ma- nuscript of sister Peg has been traced to the print- er's, and has been found to be, in many places, inter- lined and corrected in my hand-writing. I could have wished that you had not published this piece of intelligence before you told me of it. The truth is, after I had composed that trifling performance, and thought I had made it as correct as I could, I gave it to a sure hand to be transcribed ; that in case any of the London printers had known my 156 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OP hand, they might not be able to discover me. But as it lay by me for some weeks afterwards, I could not. forbear reviewing it ; and not having my ama- nuensis at hand, I was obliged, in several places, to correct it myself, rather than allow it to go to the press with inaccuracies of which I was sensible. I little dreamed that this small want of precaution would have betrayed me so soon ; but as you know that I am very indifferent about princes or presi- dents, ministers of the gospel or ministers of state, kings or keysars, and set at defiance all powers, hu- man or infernal, I had no other reason for conceal- ing myself, but in order to try the taste of the pub- lic ; whom, though I also set in some degree at de- fiance, I cannot sometimes forbear paying a little regard to. 1 find that frivolous composition has been better received than I had any reason to expect, and therefore cannot much complain of the injury you .have done me by revealing my secret, and obliging me to acknowledge it more early than I intended. The only reason of my writing to you is, to know the printer's name, who has so far broke his engage- ments as to shew the manuscript ; for the bookseller assured my friend to whom I entrusted it, that we might depend upon an absolute secrecy. I beg my compliments to Mrs Carlyle, and am, " Dear Sir, " Your most obedient humble servant, " DAVID HUME." LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 157 Copy of passage in a Letter from Mr DAVID HUME to Dr BLAIR, dated Park Place, Lon- don, 28th March, 1769. ." DEAR DOCTOR, " THE Fatal Discovery succeeded, and deser- ved it. It has feeling, though not equal to Dou- glas, in my opinion. The versification of it is not enough finished. Our friend escaped by lying con- cealed ; but the success of all plays in this age is very feeble ; and people now heed the theatre al- most as little as the pulpit. History now is the fa- vourite reading, and our other friend,* the favourite historian. Nothing can be more successful than his last production, nor more deservedly. I agree with you ; it is beyond his first performance, as was in- deed natural to expect. I hope, for a certain rea- son which I keep to myself, that he does not in- tend, in his third work, to go beyond his second, though I am damnably afraid he will, for the sub- ject is much more interesting. Neither the cha- racter of Charles V., nor the incidents of his life, are very interesting ; and, were it not for the first volume, the success of this work, though perfectly well writ, would not have been so shining." * Dr Robertson. 158 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF To Mr HOME. " St Andrew's Square, September 20th, 1775. " DEAR JOHN, "Or all the vices of language, the least excusa- ble is the want of perspicuity ; for, as words were instituted by men, merely for conveying their ideas to each other, the employing of words without meaning is a palpable abuse, which departs from the very original purpose and intention of language. It is also to be observed, that any ambiguity in ex- pression is next to the having no meaning at all ; and is indeed a species of it ; for while the hearer or reader is perplexed between different meanings, he can assign no determinate idea to the speaker or writer ; and may, on that account, say with Ovid, " Inopem me copia fecit" For this reason, all emi- nent rhetoricians and grammarians,, both ancient and modern, have insisted on perspicuity of lan- guage as an essential quality ; without which, all ornaments of diction are vain and fruitless. Quinc- tilian carries the matter so far, as to condemn this expression, vidi hominem librum legentem i be- cause, says he, legentem may construe as well with librum as hominem ; though one would think, that the sense were here sufficient to prevent all ambi- guity. In conformity to this way of thinking, Van- LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 159 gelas, the first great grammarian of France, will not permit, that any one have recourse to the sense, in order to explain the meaning of the words ; because, says he, it is the business of the words to explain the sense not of the sense to give a deter- minate meaning to the words ; and this practice is reversing the order of nature ; like the custom of the Romans (he might have added, the Greeks) in their saturnalia, who made the slaves the masters ; for you may learn from Lucian, that the Greeks practised the same frolic during the Festival of Sa- turn, whom they called Xgovaq. " Now, to apply, and to come to the use of this principle, I must observe to you, that your last letter, besides a continued want of distinctness in the form of the literal characters, has plainly transgressed the essential rule above-mentioned, of grammar and rhetoric. You say, that Coutts has complained to you of not hearing from me ; had you said either James or Thomas, I could have understood your meaning. About two months ago, I heard that James complained of me in this respect, and I wrote to him, though then abroad, making an apology for my being one of the subscribers of a paper which gave him some offence. I was afraid he had not received mine. The letter of Thomas, I concei- ved to be only a circular letter, informing me of a change in the firm of the house ; and have answer- ed it a few days ago, by giving him some directions 160 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF about disposing of my money, which proved that I intended to remain a customer to the shop. It hap- pens, therefore, luckily, that I had obviated all ob- jections to my conduct, on both sides. " In turning over my papers, I find a manuscript journal of the last rebellion, which is at your ser- vice. 1 hope Mrs Home is better, and will be able to execute her journey. Are you to be in town soon ? Yours, without ambiguity, circumlocution, or mental reservation, " DAVID HUME." To Mr HOME. " Edinburgh, 8th February, 1 776. " DEAII TVRT^EUS, " IT is a remark of Dr Swift's, that no man in London ever complained of his being neglected by his friends in the country. Your complaint of me is the more flattering. " Two posts ago, I received, under a frank of General Fraser's, a pamphlet, entitled A Letter from an Officer retired. It is a very good pam- phlet ; and I conjecture you to be the author. Sal- lust makes it a question, whether the writer or the performer of good things has the preference ? and he ascribes the greater praise to the latter. It is happy for you, that you may rest your fame on 13 LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 161 either. I here allude to what you have done for Ferguson. " But, pray, why do you say, that the post of Boston is like the Camp of Pirna ? I fancy our troops can be withdrawn thence without any diffi- culty. " 1 make no doubt, since you sound the trumpet for war against the Americans, that you have a plan ready for governing them, after they are subdued ; but you will not subdue them, unless they break in pieces among themselves an event very probable. It is a wonder it has not happened sooner. But no man can foretell how far these frenzies of the peo- ple may be carried. Yours, " DAVID HUME." Copy of a Card from Mr DAVID HUME to Dr BLAIR. It was written when he> along with Mr JOHN HOME, was on the way down from Bath to Edinburgh. "Doncaster, With of June. MR JOHN HUME, alias Home, alias the Home, alias the late Lord Conservator, alias the late Mi- nister of the Gospel at Athelstaneford, has calcula- ted matters so as to arrive infallibly with his friend VOL. I. L 162 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF in St David's Street,* on Wednesday evening. He has asked several of Dr Blair's friends to dine with him there on Thursday, being the 4th of July, and begs the favour of the Doctor to make one of the number." Subjoined to the card, there is this Note, in Dr Blair's hand writing : " Mem. This the last note received from Mr David Hume. He died on the 25th of August, 1776." Copy of passage in a Letter from Mr DAVID HUME to Dr BLAIK, dated Bath, 13th May, 1776. It relates to his meeting with Mr JOHN HOME, when on the way to jBatJi,for recovery of his health. " You must have heard of the agreeable surprise which John Home put upon me. We travelled up to London very cheerfully together, and thence to this place, where we found Mrs Home almost quite recovered. Never was there a more friendly action, nor better placed ; for what between conver- * Mr Hume's house. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 163 sation and gaming,* (not to mention sometimes squabbling) I did not pass a languid moment ; and his company I am certain was the chief cause why my journey had so good an effect ; of which, how- ever, I suppose he has given too sanguine accounts, as is usual with him." Excerpt from a Codicil to Mr DAVID HUME'S Will, written in kis own hand, and dated 1th August, 1776. " I LEAVE to my friend Mr John Home of Kil- duff, ten dozen of my old claret, at his choice ; and one single bottle of that other liquor called port. I also leave to him six dozen of port, provided that he attests under his hand, signed John Hume, that he has himself alone finished that bottle at two sittings. By this concession, he will at once ter- minate the only two differences that ever arose be- tween us concerning temporal matters." * Both were fond of picquel, and they played every even- ing on the road. 164 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF Note by DAVID HUME, Esq. Nephew to the His- torian. JOHN HOME was very strenuous in support of the o in preference to the u, in the spelling of his name, and held the point to he so clear in his own favour, as to admit of no debate. David Hume, at one time, jocularly proposed that they should de- termine the controversy by casting lots. " Nay," says John, " that is a most extraordinary proposal indeed, Mr Philosopher for if you lose, you take your own name, and if I lose, I take another man's name." This he often told me with great glee, and nearly in these words. Wote by the Editor. As to the port-wine, it is well known that Mr Home held it in abhorrence. In his younger days, claret was the only wine drank by gentlemen in Scotland. His epigram on the enforcement of the high duty on French wine in this country, is in most people's hands : " Firm and erect the Caledonian stood, Old was his mutton, and his claret good ; ' Let him drink port,' an English statesman cried He drank the poison, and his spirit died." LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 165 Among the papers which have been preserved, is one of a remarkable kind, a journal of that phi- losopher and historian's conversation and opinions delivered during the progress of a journey, which those two friends made in company to Bath, a very short while before Mr David Hume's death. That journey was highly honourable to Mr John Home, from the cordial and disinterested attachment which it shewed him to entertain for his illustrious friend. He was at London with his wife, when he re- ceived accounts of the dangerous situation of Mr David Hume's health, and that he proposed a journey to Bath, as one of the possible means for restoring it. Mr Home instantly set off for Scot- land, with the design of attending him in that journey, and ministering to him whatever ease or comfort the society of so intimate and long-tried a friend could afford. Mr Hume felt very sensibly the kindness of this measure, and it seemed to have answered, in no inconsiderable degree, the good pur- pose which it was intended to serve. They travel- led by easy stages, they discoursed by the road with an easy unconstrained familiarity, which a sick man, in his moments of ease, can indulge without fa- tigue ; and, in the evening, when they came early to their resting-place for the night, they played at picquet, a game of which they were both fond enough, as well as skilful in, to find an interest- 166 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF ing amusement. When Mr Hume went to bed, naturally from his situation, at an earlier hour than his friend, Mr John Home used to put down notes of the conversation which the preceding day had afforded. Its value, in his estimation, was such, that he got it fairly copied out, with an intention of ha- ving it published ; hut the historian's nephew, our excellent colleague Mr Professor Hume, whose leave he asked previously to carrying this design into execution, conceived, that at that time it would not have been proper for publication \ and that in his own very significant words (addressed to Mr John Home, in answer to a letter asking his leave to make this publication), it was one which he thought his uncle, had he been alive, would have objected to. The same reasons, how- ever, not subsisting now, he has given me leave to insert it in this place. The Society will perceive in those unreserved effusions, the general turn and complexion of Mr Hume's historical notions. Such familiar sketches give the bent and contour of a person's mind, per- haps more truly than his elaborate compositions, as portraits drawn in a night-gown and slippers, shew the figure more freely and more naturally, than when they are finished in the costume of rank or ceremony. LIFE OF MB JOHN HOME. 167 The letters from Mr Hume, which are subjoin- ed to the journal the notes to Dr Blair, and the Codicil to Mr Hume's Will, must interest, from the peculiar situation in which they were written. The Codicil was of his own hand-writing, and da- ted 7th August, 1776. He died on the 25th of that month. Copy Letter Mr ADAM FERGUSSON to Mr JOHN HOME, dated at Edinburgh, the \\th day of April, 1776. " I AM much such a correspondent as usual ; and for some little time have heen in doubt where a letter might find you. But David shewed me a line from you to-day, by which you desire to have your letters sent to London, and after such a pre- amble, you may guess that my silence proceeded in part from want of matter here. The loss of one friend, and the danger of another, are not subjects that make people in haste to write. David, I am afraid, loses ground. He is chearful, and in good spirits as usual, but I confess that my hopes, from the effects of the turn of the season towards spring, have very much abated. A journey to the south, particularly to Bath, has been mentioned to him ; but the thoughts of being from home, hurried at inns, and exposed to irregular meals, are very dis- 168 APPENDIX TO ACCOUNT OF agreeable to him. Black is of opinion that he ought not to expose himself to any thing that is so ; and that for his complaints, the tranquillity and usual amusement of his own fire-side, with proper diet, is his hest regimen ; so that I think the thoughts of any journey are at present laid aside. I hope we shall see you here soon, and that your attentions will contribute to preserve what we can so ill spare. " I am, dear John, " Most affectionately yours, " ADAM FERGUSSON." Note by Mr JOHN HOME. " Soon after Mr Home received the letter from Dr Ferguson, he left London, and set out for Scot- land with Mr Adam Smith. They came to Mor- peth on the 23d of April, 1776, and would have passed Mr David Hume, if they had not seen his servant, Colin, standing at the gate of an inn. Mr Home thinks that his friend, Mr David Hume, is much better than he expected to find him. His spirits are astonishing : He talks of his illness, of his death, as matters of no moment, and gives an account of >Yhat passed between him and his phy- sicians since his illness began, with his usual wit, or with more wit than usual. LIFE OF MR JOHN HOME. 169 " He acquainted Mr Adam Smith and me, that Dr Black had not concealed the opinion he had of the desperateness of his condition, and was rather averse to his setting out. " Have you no reason against it," said David, " hut an apprehension that it may make me die sooner ? that is no reason at all." I never saw him more chearful, or in more perfect possession of all his faculties, his memory, his understanding, his wit. It is agreed that Smith shall go on to Scotland, and that I should proceed to Bath with David. We are to travel one stage before dinner, and one after dinner. Colin tells me that he thinks Mr Hume better than when he left Edinburgh. We had a fine evening as we went from Morpeth to Newcastle. David seeing a pair of pistols in the chaise, said, that as he had very little at stake, he would indulge me in my humour, of fighting the highwaymen. Whilst sup- per was getting ready at the inn, Mr Hume and I played an hour at picquet. Mr David was very keen about his card playing." " Newcastle., Wednesday, 24; b^,k>Tcf '/>/ > ef^i/f*O r/i : Kwf.it >^/l- -zi'v-iM Irjflt'w t -rvj;Hrir M 'uf,iii r-;< r;rS i'fMjM-. ;;:! PEOLOGUE, ;.! ,'- .>''* 'j'.- 'i/f! Oyirf ( }efmu f'- SPOKEN AT LONDON. IN ancient times, when Britain's trade was arms, And the loved music of her youth, alarms ; A god-like race sustain'd fair England's fame : Who has not heard of gallant Percy's name ? Ay, and of Douglas ? Such illustrious foes In rival Rome and Carthage never rose ! From age to age bright shone the British fire, And every hero was a hero's sire. When powerful fate decreed one warrior's doom, Up sprung the phoenix from his parent's tomb. But whilst these generous rivals fought and fell, These generous rivals loved each other well : Though many a bloody field was lost and won, Nothing in hate, in honour all was done. When Percy, wrong'd, defied his prince or peers, First came the Douglas with his Scottish spears ; And, when proud Douglas made his king his foe, For Douglas, Percy bent his English bow. Expell'd their native homes by adverse fate, They knock'd alternate at each other's gate : Then blazed the castle, at the midnight hour, For him whose arms had shook its firmest tower. VOL. I. T - 290 PROLOGUE. This night a Douglas your protection claims ; A wife ! a mother ! Pity's softest names : The story of her woes indulgent hear, And grant your suppliant all she begs, a tear. In confidence she begs ; and hopes to find Each English breast, like noble Percy's, kind. [ 291 ] PROLOGUE, SPOKEN AT EDINBURGH. IN days of classic fame, when Persia's Lord Opposed his millions to the Grecian sword, Flourish'd the state of Athens, small her store, Rugged her soil, and rocky was her shore, Like Caledonia's ; yet she gain'd a name That stands unrival'd in the rolls of fame. Such proud pre-eminence not valour gave, (For who than Sparta's dauntless sons more brave ?) But learning, and the love of every art, That Virgin Pallas and the Muse impart. Above the rest the Tragic Muse admired Each Attic breast with noblest passions fired. In peace their poets with their heroes shared Glory, the hero's and the bard's reward. The Tragic Muse each glorious record kept, And, o'er the kings she conquer'd, Athens wept.* Here let me cease, impatient for the scene ; To you I need not praise the Tragic Queen : Oft has this audience soft compassion shown To woes of heroes, heroes not their own. * Sec the Perai of JEschylus. 292 PROLOGUE. This night our scenes no common tear demand, He comes, the hero of your native land ! Douglas, a name through all the world renown'd, A name that rouses like the trumpet's sound ! Oft have your fathers, prodigal of life, A Douglas follow 'd through the bloody strife ; Hosts have been known at that dread time to yield And, Douglas dead, his name hath won the field. Listen attentive to the various tale, Mark if the author's kindred feelings fail ; Sway'd by alternate hopes, alternate fears, He waits the test of your congenial tears. If they shall flow, back to the Muse he flies, And bids your heroes in succession rise ; Collects the wand'ring warriors as they roam, Douglas assures them of a welcome home. DRAMATIS PERSONS. LORD RANDOLPH. GLENALVON. OLD NORVAL. DOUGLAS. LADY RANDOLPH. ANNA. Servants, fyc. DOUGLAS. ACT I. SCENE, The Court of a Castle surrounded with Woods. Enter Lady RANDOLPH. Lady Rand. YE woods and wilds, whose me- lancholy gloom Accords with my soul's sadness, and draws forth The voice of sorrow from my bursting heart, Farewell a while : I will not leave you long ; For in your shades I deem some spirit dwells, Who from the chiding stream, or groaning oak, Still hears and answers to Matilda's moan. O, Douglas, Douglas ! if departed ghosts Are e'er permitted to review this world, 296 DOUGLAS, ACT I. Within the circle of o bu$I>i{ .^'.xrhiifto -thili Jjfiu .>.'i-;>,'[v(M;r -^mWifroTJ oiH ACT IV SCENE, ^* Cowr#, ^c. * lef ore. Flourish of Trumpets. '. CxCf 1 iHf'R JSw/^r Z/orrf RANDOLPH, attended. Lord Rand. Summon a hundred horse, by break of day, To wait our pleasure at the castle-gate. Lady RANDOLPH. Lady Rand. Alas ! my lord ! I've heard un- welcome news : The Danes are landed. Lord Rand. Ay, no inroad this Of the Northumbrian, bent to take a spoil : No sportive war, no tournament essay Of some young knight resolved to break a spear, And stain with hostile blood his maiden arms. The Danes are landed : we must beat them back, Or live the slaves of Denmark. 346 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Lady Rand. Dreadful times ! Lord Rand. The fenceless villages are all for- saken ; The trembling mothers, and their children, lodged In wall-girt towers and castles ; whilst the men Retire indignant. Yet, like broken waves, They but retire more awful to return. Lady Rand. Immense, as fame reports, the Da- nish host ! Lord Rand. Were it as numerous as loud fame reports, An army knit like ours would pierce it through: Brothers, that shrink not from each other's side, And fond companions, fill our warlike files : For his dear offspring, and the wife he loves, The husband and the fearless father arm. In vulgar breasts heroic ardour burns, And the poor peasant mates his daring lord. Lady Rand. Men's minds are temper'd, like their swords, for war ; Lovers of danger, on destruction's brink They joy to rear erect their daring forms. Hence, early graves ; hence, the lone widow's Life ; And the sad mother's grief-embitter'd age. Where is our gallant guest ? ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 347 Lord Rand. Down in the vale I left him, managing a fiery steed, Whose stubbornness had foil'd the strength and skill Of every rider. But behold he comes, In earnest conversation with Glenalvon. Enter NORVAL and GLENALVON. Glenalvon ! with the lark arise ; go forth, And lead my troops that lie in yonder vale : Private I travel to the royal camp : Norval, thou goest with me. But say, young man ! Where didst thou learn so to discourse of war, And in such terms, as I o'erheard to-day ? War is no village science, nor its phrase A language taught amongst the shepherd swains. Norv. Small is the skill my lord delights to praise In him he favours. Hear from whence it came : Beneath a mountain's brow, the most remote And inaccessible by shepherds trod, In a deep cave, dug by no mortal hand, A hermit lived ; a melancholy man, Who was the wonder of our wand'ring swains : Austere 'and lonely, cruel to himself, 348 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Did they report him ; the cold earth his bed, Water his drink, his food the shepherd's alms. I went to see him, and my heart was touch'd With rev'rence and with pity. Mild he spake, And, entering on discourse, such stories told As made me oft revisit his sad cell ; For he had been a soldier in his youth, And fought in famous battles, when the peers Of Europe, by the bold Godfredo led, Against the usurping infidel display'd The blessed cross, and won the Holy Land. Pleased with my admiration, and the fire His speech struck from me, the old man would shake His years away, and act his young encounters ; Then, having shew'd his wounds, he'd sit him dawn, And all the live long day discourse of war. To help my fancy, in the smooth green turf He cut the figures of the marshall'd hosts ; Described the motion, and explain'd the use Of the deep column, and the lengthen'd line, The square, the crescent, and the phalanx firm. For all that Saracen or Christian knew Of war's vast art, was to this hermit known. ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 349 Lord Hand. Why did this soldier in a desert hide Those qualities that should have graced a camp ? Non\ That too at last I learn'd. Unhappy man ! Returning homeward by Messina's port^ Loaded with wealth and honours bravely won, A rude and boist'rous captain of the sea Fasten'd a quarrel on him. Fierce they fought : The stranger fell, and with his dying breath Declared his name and lineage. Mighty power \ The soldier cried, my brother ! Oh my brother ! Lady Rand, His brother ! Norv. Yes ; of the same parents born ; His only brother. They exchanged forgiveness : And happy, in my mind, was he that died ; For many deaths has the survivor suffer'd. In the wild desart on a rock he sits, Or on some nameless stream's untrodden banks, And ruminates all day his dreadful fate. At times, alas ! not in his perfect mind, Holds dialogues with his loved brother's ghost : And oft each night forsakes his sullen couch, To make sad orisons for him he slew. 350 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Lady Rand. To what mysterious woes are mor- tals born ! In this dire tragedy, were there no more Unhappy persons ? Did the parents live ? Norv. No ; they were dead : kind Heaven had closed their eyes Before their son had shed his brother's blood. Lord Hand. Hard is his fate ; for he was not to blame ! There is a destiny in this strange world, Which oft decrees an undeserved doom : Let schoolmen tell us why. From whence these sounds ? [ Trumpets at a distance. Enter an Officer. Off. My lord, the trumpets of the troops of Lorn : The valiant leader hails the noble Randolph. Lord Rand. Mine ancient guest ? does he the warriors lead ? Has Denmark roused the brave old knight to arms? Off. No ; worn with warfare, he resigns the sword. His eldest hope, the valiant John of Lom, Now leads his kindred bands. ACT IV. DOUGLAS, 351 Lord Rand. Glenalvon, go, With hospitality's most strong request Entreat the chief. \Exlt GLENALVON. Off. My lord, requests are vain. He urges on impatient of delay, Stung with the tidings of the foe's approach. Lord Hand. May victory sit on the warrior's plume ! Bravest of men ! his flocks and herds are safe ; Remote from war's alarms his pastures lie, By mountains inaccessible secured : Yet foremost he into the plain descends, Eager to bleed in battles not his own. Such were the heroes of the ancient world ; Contemners they of indolence and gain ; But still, for love of glory and of arms, Prone to encounter peril, and to lift Against each strong antagonist the spear. I'll go and press the hero to my breast. {Exit RANDOLPH. Manent Lady RANDOLPH and NORVAL. Lady Rand. The soldier's loftiness, the pride and pomp DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Investing awful war, Norval, I see, Transport thy youthful mind. Norv. Ah ! should they not ? Blest be the hour I left my father's house ! I might have heen a shepherd all my days, And stole obscurely to a peasant's grave. Now, if I live, with mighty chiefs I stand ; , And, if I fall, with noble dust I lie. Lady Rand. There is a gen'rous spirit in thy breast, That could have well sustain'd a prouder fortune. This way with me ; under yon spreading beech, Unseen, unheard, by human eye or ear, I will amaze thee with a wondrous tale. Norv. Let there be danger, lady, with the se- cret, That I may hug it to my grateftd heart, And prove my faith. Command my sword, my life; These are the sole possessions of poor Norval. Lady Rand. Know'st thou these gems ? Norv. Durst I believe mine eyes, I'd say I knew them, and they were my father's. Lady Rand. Thy father's, say'st thou ? Ah ! they were thy father's ! 12 ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 353 Norv. I saw them once, and curiously inquired Of both my parents, whence such splendour came ; But I was check'd, and more could never learn. Lady Rand. Then learn of me, thou art not Norval's son. Norv. Not Norval's son ! Lady Rand. Nor of a shepherd sprung. Norv. Lady, who am I then ? Lady Rand. Noble thou art ; For noble was thy sire ! Norv. I will believe O, tell me farther ! Say, who was my father ? Lady Rand. Douglas ! Norv. Lord Douglas, whom to-day I saw ? Lady Rand. His younger brother. Norv. And in yonder camp Lady Rand. Alas ! Norv. Youmakemetremble Sighs and tears ! Lives my brave father ? Lady Rand. Ah ! too brave indeed ! He fell in battle ere thyself was born. Norv. Ah me, unhappy ! ere I saw the light ? But does my mother live ? I may conclude, From my own fate, her portion has been sorrow. VOL. I. 7, 354 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Lady Rand. She lives ; but wastes her life in constant woe, Weeping her husband slain, her infant lost. Norv. You that are skill'd so well in the sad story Of my unhappy parents, and with tears Bewail their destiny, now have compassion Upon the offspring of the friends you loved. O ! tell me who, and where my mother is ? Oppress'd by a base world, perhaps she bends Beneath the weight of other ills than grief; And, desolate, implores of heaven the aid Her son should give. It is, it must be so Your countenance confesses that she's wretched. O, tell me her condition ! Can the sword Who shall resist me in a parent's cause ? Lady Rand. Thy virtue ends her woes. My son ! my son ! I am thy mother, and the wife of Douglas ! \Fatts upon his necJf. Norv. O heaven and earth, how wondrous is my fate! Art thou my mother ? Ever let me kneel ! Lady Rand. Image of Douglas ! Fruit of fatal love ! All that I owe thy sire, I pay to thee. ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 355 Norv. Respect and admiration still possess me, Checking the love and fondness of a son : Yet I was filial to my humble parents. But did my sire surpass the rest of men, As thou excellest all of womankind ? Lady Rand. Arise, my son ? In me thou dost behold The poor remains of beauty once admired : The autumn of my days is come already ; For sorrow made my summer haste away. Yet in my prime I equall'd not thy father : His eyes were like the eagle's, yet sometimes Liker the dove's ; and, as he pleased, he won All hearts with softness, or with spirit awed. Norv. How did he fall ? Sure 'twas a bloody field When Douglas died. O ! I have much to ask. Lady Rand. Hereafter thou shalt hear the lengthen'd tale Of all thy father's and thy mother's woes. At present this : Thou art the rightful heir Of yonder castle, and the wide domains Which now Lord Randolph, as my husband, holds. But thou shalt not be wrong'd ; I have the power 356 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. * To right thee still : before the king 111 kneel, And call Lord Douglas to protect his blood. Norv. The blood of Douglas will protect itself. Lady Rand. But we shall need both friends and favour, boy, To wrest the lands and lordship from the gripe Of Randolph and his kinsman. Yet I think My tale will move each gentle heart to pity ; My life incline the virtuous to believe. Norv. To be the son of Douglas is to me Inheritance enough. Declare my birth, And in the field I'll seek for fame and fortune. Lady Rand. Thou dost not know what perils and injustice Await the poor man's valour. O, my son ! The noblest blood of all the land's abash'd, Having no lackey but pale poverty. Too long hast thou been thus attended, Douglas ! Too long hast thou been deem'd a peasant's child. The wanton heir of some inglorious chief Perhaps has scorn'd thee, in the youthful sports, Whilst thy indignant spirit swell'd in vain ! Such contumely thou no more shalt bear : But how I purpose to redress thy wrongs ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 357 Must be hereafter told. Prudence directs That we should part before yon chiefs return. Retire, and from thy rustic follower's hand Receive a billet, which thy mother's care, Anxious to see thee, dictated before :I m This casual opportunity arose Of private conference. Its purport mark ; For, as I there appoint, we meet again. Leave me, my son ! and frame thy manners still To Norval's, not to noble Douglas' state. Norv. I will remember. Where is Norval now, That good old man ? Lady Rand. At hand conceal'd he lies, An useful witness. But beware, my son, Of yon Glenalvon ; in his guilty breast Resides a villain's shrewdness, ever prone To false conjecture. He hath grieved my heart. Norv. Has he, indeed? Then let yon false Glenalvon Beware of me. [Exit DOUGLAS. Manet Lady RANDOLPH. Lady Rand. There burst the smother'd flame ! O ! thou all righteous and eternal King ! 358 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Who father of the fatherless art call'd, Protect my son ! Thy inspiration, Lord ! Hath fill'd his bosom with that sacred fire, Which in the breast of his forefathers burn'd : Set him on high, like them, that he may shine The star and glory of his native land ! Then let the minister of death descend, And bear my willing spirit to its place. Yonder they come. How do bad women find Unchanging aspects to conceal their guilt ? When I, by reason and by justice urged, Full hardly can dissemble with these men In nature's pious cause ? Enter Lord RANDOLPH and GLENALVON. Lord Rand. Yon gallant chief, Of arms enamour'd, all repose disclaims. Lady Hand. Be not, my lord, by his example sway'd ; Arrange the business of to-morrow now, And, when you enter, speak of war no more. [Exit Lady RANDOLPH. ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 359 L-ii-1 ;>.,{ . i -fl. ! Manent Lord RANDOLPH awe? GLENALVON. Lord Rand. 'Tis so, by heaven ! her mien, her voice, her eye, And her impatience to be gone, confirm it. Glen. He parted from her now : behind the mount, Amongst the trees, I saw him glide along. Lord Rand. For sad sequester'd virtue she's renown'd. Glen. Most true, my lord. Lord Rand. Yet, this distinguish'd dame Invites a youth, the acquaintance of a day, Alone to meet her at the midnight hour. This assignation, [Shews a Letter,] the assassin freed, Her manifest affection for the youth, Might breed suspicion in a husband's brain, Whose gentle consort all for love had wedded ; Much more in mine. Matilda never loved me. Let no man, after me, a woman wed, Whose heart he knows he has not ; though she brings A mine of gold, a kingdom for her dowry. 360 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. For let her seem, like the night's shadowy queen, Cold and contemplative he cannot trust her : She may, she will, bring shame and sorrow on him ; The worst of sorrows, and the worst of shames ! Glen. Yield not, my lord, to such afflicting thoughts ; But let the spirit of a hushand sleep, Till your own senses make a sure conclusion. This billet must to blooming Norval go : At the next turn awaits my trusty spy ; I'll give it him refitted for his master. In the close thicket take your secret stand ; The moon shines bright, and your own eyes may judge Of their behaviour. Lord Rand. Thou dost counsel well. Glen. Permit me now to make one slight essay. Of all the trophies which vain mortals boast, By wit, by valour, or by wisdom won, The first and fairest, in a young man's eye, Is woman's captive heart. Successful love With glorious fumes intoxicates the mind ! And the proud conqueror in triumph moves, Air-borne, exalted above- vulgar men. ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 361 Lord Rand. And what avails this maxim ? Glen. Much, my lord. Withdraw a little : I'll accost young Norval, And with ironical derisive counsel Explore his spirit. If he is no more Than humble Norval, by thy favour raised, Brave as he is, he'll shrink astonish'd from me : But if he be the fav'rite of the fair, Loved by the first of Caledonia's dames, He'll turn upon me, as the lion turns Upon the hunter's spear. Lord Rand. 'Tis shrewdly thought. Glen. When we grow loud, draw near. But let my lord His rising wrath restrain. [Exit RANDOLPH. Manet GLENALVON. Glen. 'Tis strange, by heaven ! That she should run full tilt her fond career, To one so little known. She too that seem'd Pure as the winter stream, when ice emboss'd Whitens its course. Even I did think her chaste, Whose charity exceeds not. Precious sex ! Whose deeds lascivious pass Glenalvon's thoughts ! 362 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. .. / : Enter NORVAL. His port I love ; he's in a proper mood To chide the thunder, if at him it roar'd. [Aside. Has Norval seen the troops ? Norv. The setting sun With yellow radiance lighten'd all the vale ; And as the warriors moved, each polish'd helm, % Corslet or spear, glanced back his gilded heams. The hill they climbed, and halting at its top, Of more than mortal size, towering, they seem'd A host angelic, clad in burning arms. Glen. Thou talk'st it well ; no leader of our host In sounds more lofty speaks of glorious war. Norv. If I shall e'er acquire a leader's name, My speech will be less ardent. Novelty Now prompts my tongue, and youthful admiration Vents itself freely ; since no part is mine Of praise pertaining to the great in arms. Glen. You wrong yourself, brave sir ; your mar- tial deeds Have rank'd you with the great : But mark me, Norval ; Lord Randolph's favour now exalts your youth Above his veterans of famous service : ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 363 Let me, who know these soldiers, counsel you : Give them all honour ; seem not to command ; Else they will scarcely brook your late-sprung power, Which nor alliance props, nor birth adorns. Norv. Sir, I have been accustom'd all my days To hear and speak the plain and simple truth : And though I have been told that there are men Who borrow friendship's tongue to speak their scorn, Yet in such language I am little skill'd. Therefore I thank Glenalvon for his counsel, Although it sounded harshly. Why remind Me of my birth obscure ? Why slur my power With such contemptuous terms? Glen. I did not mean To gall your pride, which now I see is great. Norv. My pride ! Glen. Suppress it as you wish to prosper : Your pride's excessive. Yet, for Randolph's sake, I will not leave you to its rash direction : If thus you swell, and frown at high-born men, Will high-born men endure a shepherd's scorn ? Norv. A shepherd's scorn ! Glen. Yes. If you presume To bend on soldiers these disdainful eyes, 364 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. As if you took the measure of their minds, And said in secret, you're no match for me ! What will become of you ? Norv. If this were told ! [Aside. Hast thou no fears for thy presumptuous self? Glen. Ha ! Dost thou threaten me ? Norv. Didst thou not hear ? Glen. Unwillingly I did ; a nobler foe Had not been question'd thus. But such as thee Norv. Whom dost thou think me ? Glen. Norval. Norv. So I am And who is Norval in Glenalvon's eyes ? Glen. A peasant's son, a wand'ring beggar-boy ; At best no more, even if he speaks the truth. Norv. False as thou art, dost thou suspect my truth ? Glen. Thy truth ! Thou'rt all a lie ; and false as hell .'>a'' Is the vain-glorious tale thou told'st to Randolph. Norv. If I were chain'd, unarm'd, and bed-rid old, Perhaps I should revile : But as I am, I have no tongue to rail. The humble Norval Is of a race who strive not but with deeds. ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 365 r Did I not fear to freeze thy shallow valour, And make thee sink too soon beneath my sword, I'd tell thee what thou art. I know thee well. Glen. Dost thou know Glenalvon, born to com- mand Ten thousand slaves like thee ! - Norv. Villain, no more : Draw and defend thy life. I did design To have defy'd thee in another cause : But heaven accelerates its vengeance on thee. Now for my own and Lady Randolph's wrongs. IUK;,", olc.'. -;r;ofi;>!T Enter LORD RANDOLPH. Lord Rand. Hold, I command you both. The man that stirs Makes me his foe. Norv. Another voice than thine That threat had vainly sounded, noble Randolph. Glen. Hear him, my lord ; he's wond'rous con- descending ! Mark the humility of shepherd Norval ! Norv. Now you may scoff in safety. [Sheaths his sword. Lord Rand. Speak not thus, 366 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. Taunting each other ; but unfold to me The cause of quarrel, then I judge betwixt you. Norv. Nay, my good lord, though I revere you much, My cause I plead not, nor demand your judgment. I blush to speak ; I will not, cannot speak Th' opprobrious words that I from him have borne. To the liege-lord of my dear native land I owe a subject's homage ; but even him And his high arbitration I'd reject. Within my bosom reigns another lord ; Honour, sole judge and umpire of itself. If my free speech offend you, noble Randolph, Revoke your favours, and let Norval go Hence as he came, alone but not dishonour'd. Lord Rand. Thus far I'll mediate with impar- tial voice : The ancient foe of Caledonia's land Now waves his banners o'er her frighted fields ; Suspend your purpose, till your country's arms Repel the bold invader : then decide The private quarrel. Glen. I agree to this. Norv. And I. ACT IV. DOUGLAS. 367 Enter Servant. Serv. The banquet waits. Lord Rand. We come. [Exit with Servant. Glen. Norval, Let not our variance mar the social hour, Nor wrong the hospitality of Randolph. Nor frowning anger, nor yet wrinkled hate, Shall stain my countenance. Smooth thou thy brow; Nor let our strife disturb the gentle dame. Norv. Think not so lightly, sir, of my resent- ment. When we contend again, our strife is mortal. [Exeunt. 368 DOUGLAS. ACT IV. ACT V. ,t//cr! In.^h- -"i 7 ?- -r-* i SCENE, T f ')is.' , ._. ? 0!f Enter DOUGLAS. Doug. This is the place, the centre of the grove; Here stands the oak, the monarch of the wood. How sweet and solemn is this mid-night scene ! The silver moon, unclouded, holds her way Through skies where I could count each little star. The fanning west wind scarcely stirs the leaves ; The river rushing o'er it's pehhled bed, Imposes silence with a stilly sound. In such a place as this, at such an hour, If ancestry can be in aught believed, Descending spirits have conversed with man, And told the secrets of the world unknown. Enter OLD NOBVAL. . Old Norv. 'Tis he. But what if he should chide me hence ? ACT V. DOUGLAS. 369 i His just reproach I fear. [DOUGLAS turns and sees him. Forgive, forgive ! Can'st thou forgive the man, the selfish man, Who bred Sir Malcolm's heir a shepherd's son ? Doug. Kneel not to me ; thou art my father still : Thy wish'd-for presence now completes my joy. Welcome to me, my fortunes thou shalt share, And ever hononr'd with thy Douglas live. Old Norv. And dost thou call me father ? O my son ! I think that I could die to make amends For the great wrong I did thee. 'Twas my crime Which in the wilderness so long conceal'd The blossom of thy youth. Doug. Not worse the fruit, That in the wilderness the blossom blow'd. Amongst the shepherds, in the humble cot, I learn'd some lessons, which I'll not forget When I inhabit yonder lofty towers. I, who was once a swain, will ever prove The poor man's friend ; and, when my vassals bow, Norval shall smooth the crested pride of Douglas. VOL. i. 2 A 370 DOUGLAS. ACT V. Old Norv. Let me but live to see thine exalta- tion ! Yet grievous are my fears. O leave this place, And those unfriendly towers. Doug. Why should I leave them ? Old Norv. Lord Randolph and his kinsman seek your life. Doug. How know'st thou that ? Old Norv. I will inform you how. When evening came, I left the secret place Appointed for me hy your mother's care, And fondly trod in each accustom'd path That to the castle leads. Whilst thus I ranged, I was alarm'd with unexpected sounds Of earnest voices. On the persons came ; Unseen I lurk'd, and overheard them name Each other as they talk'd, Lord Randolph this, And that Glenalvon : still of you they spoke, And of the lady ; threatening was their speech, Though but imperfectly my ear could hear it. 'Twas strange, they said, a wonderful discovery ; And ever and anon they vow'd revenge. Doug. Revenge ! for what ? Old Norv. For being what you are, Sir Malcolm's heir : how else have you offended ? ACT V. DOUGLAS. 371 When they were gone, I hied me to my cottage, And there sat musing how I best might find Means to inform you of their wicked purpose. But I could think of none : at last perplex'd, I issued forth, encompassing the tower With many a weary step and wishful look. Now Providence hath brought you to my sight, Let not your too courageous spirit scorn The caution which I give. Doug. I scorn it not. My mother warn'd me of Glenalvon's baseness ; But I will not suspect the noble Randolph. In our encounter with the vile assassins, I mark'd his brave demeanour : him I'll trust. Old Norv. I fear you will, too far. Doug. Here in this place, I wait my mother's coming : she shall know What thou hast told : her counsel I will follow ; And cautious ever are a mother's counsels. You must depart ; your presence may prevent Our interview. Old JVbrv. My blessing rest upon thee ! O may heaven's hand, which saved thee from the wave, And from the sword of foes, be near thee still ; 372 DOUGLAS. ACT V. Turning mischance, if aught hangs o'er thy head, All upon mine ! [Exit OLD NORVAL. Doug. He loves me like a parent ; And must not, shall not, lose the son he loves, Although his son has found a nohler father. Eventful day ! how hast thou changed my state ! Once on the cold and winter-shaded side Of a bleak hill mischance had rooted me, Never to thrive, child of another soil : Transplanted now to the gay sunny vale, Like the green thorn of May my fortune flowers. Ye glorious stars ! high heaven's resplendent host ! To whom I oft have of my lot complain'd, Hear and record my soul's unalter'd wish ! Dead or alive, let me but be renown'd ! May heaven inspire some fierce gigantic Dane, To give a bold defiance to our host ! Before he speaks it out I will accept ; Like Douglas conquer, or like Douglas die. Enter LADY RANDOLPH. Lady Rand. My son ! I heard a voice Doug. The voice was mine. Lady Rand. Didst thou complain aloud to Nature's ear, ACT V. DOUGLAS. 373 That thus in dusky shades, at midnight hours, By stealth the mother and the son should meet ? [Embracing him. Doug. No ; on this happy day, this better birth- day, My thoughts and words are all of hope and joy. Lady Rand. Sad fear and melancholy still di- vide The empire of my breast with hope and joy* Now hear what I advise. Doug. First, let me tell What may the tenor of your counsel change. Lady Rand. My heart forebodes some evil ! Doug. 'Tis not good. At eve, unseen by Randolph and Glenalvon, The good old Norval in the grove o'erheard Their conversation ; oft they mention'd me With dreadful threat'nings ; you they sometimes named. 'Twas strange, they said, a wonderful discovery ; And ever and anon they vow'd revenge. Lady Rand. Defend us, gracious God ! we are betray'd : They have found out the secret of thy birth ; It must be so. That is the great discovery. 374 DOUGLAS. ACT V. Sir Malcolm's heir is come to claim his own ; And they will be revenged. Perhaps even now, Arm'd and prepared for murder, they but wait A darker and more silent hour, to break Into the chamber where they think thou sleep'st. This moment, this, heaven hath ordain'd to save thee! Fly to the camp, my son ! Doug. And leave you here ? No : to the castle let us go together, Call up the ancient servants of your house, Who in their youth did eat your father's bread ; Then tell them loudly that I am your son. If in the breasts of men one spark remains Of sacred love, fidelity, or pity, Some in your cause will arm. I ask but few To drive those spoilers from my father's house. Lady Rand. O Nature, Nature! what can check thy force ? Thou genuine offspring of the daring Douglas ! But rush not on destruction : save thyself, And I am safe. To me they mean no harm. Thy stay but risks thy precious life in vain. That winding path conducts thee to the river. ACT V. DOUGLAS. 375 Cross where thou seest a broad and beaten way, Which running eastward leads thee to the camp. Instant demand admittance to Lord Douglas. Shew him these jewels which his brother wore. Thy look, thy voice, will make him feel the truth, Which I by certain proof will soon confirm. Doug. I yield me, and obey : but yet my heart Bleeds at this parting. Something bids me stay, And guard a mother's life. Oft have I read Of wond'rous deeds by one bold arm achieved. Our foes are two ; no more : let me go forth, And see if any shield can guard Glenalvon. Lady Rand. If thou regard'st thy mother, or reverest Thy father's mem'ry, think of this no more. One thing I have to say before we part ; Long wert thou lost ; and thou art found, my child, In a most fearful season. War and battle I have great cause to dread. Too well I see Which way the current of thy temper sets : To-day I've found thee. Oh ! my long-lost hope ! If thou to giddy valour givest the rein, To-morrow I may lose my son for ever. The love of thee, before thou saw'st the light, 376 DOUGLAS. ACT T. Sustain 'd my life when thy brave father fell. If thou shalt fall, I have nor love nor hope In this waste world ! My son, remember me ! Doug. What shall I say ? how can I give you comfort ? The God of battles of my life dispose As may be best for you ; for whose dear sake I will not bear myself as I resolved. But yet consider, as no vulgar name That which I boast sounds amongst martial men, How will inglorious caution suit my claim ? The post of fate unshrinking I maintain : My country's foes must witness who I am. On the invaders' heads I'll prove my birth, Till friends and foes confess the genuine strain. If in this strife I fall, blame not your son, Who, if he lives not honour'd, must not live. Lady Rand. I will not utter what my bosom feels. Too well I love that valour which I warn. Farewell, my son ! my counsels are but vain ; [Embracing. And as high Heaven hath will'd it, all must be. [ They are about to separate. ACT V. DOUGLAS. 377 Gaze not on me, thou wilt mistake the path ; I'll point it out again. [Just as they are separating., enter from the Wood Lord RANDOLPH and GLENALVON. Lord Hand. Not in her presence. [Exeunt, at different sides, DOUGLAS and Lady RANDOLPH. Glen. I'm prepared. Lord Rand. No ; I command thee stay. I go alone : it never shall be said That I took odds to combat mortal man. The noblest vengeance is the most complete. [Exit Lord RANDOLPH. [GLENALVON makes some steps to the same side of the stage, listens and speaks. Glen. Demons of death, come, settle on my sword, And to a double slaughter guide it home ! The lover and the husband both must die. [Lord RANDOLPH behind the scenes. Lord Rand. Draw, villain ! draw. Doug. Assail me not, Lord Randolph ! Not, as thou lovest thyself. [Clashing of swords. 378 DOUGLAS. ACT V. Glen. Now is the time. [Running out. Enter Lady RANDOLPH at the opposite side of the stage, faint and breathless. Lady Rand. Lord Randolph, hear me ; all shall be thine own : But spare ! Oh spare my son ! Enter DOUGLAS, with a sword in each hand. Doug. My mother's voice ! I can protect thee still. Lady Rand. He lives, he lives ! For this, for this to Heaven eternal praise ! But sure I saw thee fall. Doug. It was Glenalvon. Just as my arm had master'd Randolph's sword, The villain came behind me ; but I slew him. Lady Rand. Behind thee ! Ah, thou'rt wound- ed ! O my child, How pale thou look'st ! And shall I lose thee now ? Doug. Do not despair : I feel a little faint- ness ; I hope it will not last. \Leans upon his sword. Lady Rand. There is no hope ! ACT V. DOUGLAS. 379 And we must part ! the hand of death is on thee ! O my beloved child ! O Douglas, Douglas ! [DOUGLAS growing more and more faint. Doug. Too soon we part ; I have not long heen Douglas. O destiny ! hardly thou deal'st with me : Clouded and hid, a stranger to myself, In low and poor obscurity I lived. Lady Rand. Has heaven preserved thee for an end like this ? Doug. O had I fall'n as my brave fathers fell, Turning with effort great the tide of battle ! Like them I should have smiled and welcom'd death. But thus to perish by a villain's hand ! Cut off from nature's and from glory's course, Which never mortal was so fond to run. Lady Rand. Hear, justice ! hear ! stretch thine avenging arm. [DouGLAS^/w/fo. Doug. Unknown I die ; no tongue shall speak of me. Some noble spirits, judging by themselves, May yet conjecture what I might have proved, And think life only wanting to my fame : But who shall comfort thee ? 380 DOUGLAS, ACT V. Lady Hand. Despair ! despair ! Doug. O, had it pleased high Heaven to let me live A little while ! My eyes that gaze on thee Grow dim apace ! my mother ! O, my mother ! [Dies. Enter Lord RANDOLPH and ANNA. Lord Eand. Thy words, the words of truth, have pierced my heart. I am the stain of knighthood and of arms. Oh ! if my hrave deliverer survives The traitor's sword Anna. Alas ! look there, my lord. Lord Rand. The mother and her son ! How curst I am ! Was I the cause ? No : I was not the cause. Yon matchless villain did seduce my soul To frantic jealousy. Anna. My lady lives : The agony of grief hath hut supprest A while her powers. Lord Rand. But my deliverer's dead ! The world did once esteem Lord Randolph well ; Sincere of heart, for spotless honour famed : ACT V. DOUGLAS. 381 And in my early days, glory I gain'd Beneath the holy banner of the cross. Now past the noon of life, shame comes upon me ; Reproach, and infamy, and public hate, Are near at hand ; for all mankind will think That Randolph basely stabb'd Sir Malcolm's heir. \Lady RANDOLPH recovering. Lady Rand. Where am I now ? still in this wretched world ! Grief cannot break a heart so hard as mine. My youth was worn in anguish ; but youth's strength, With hope's assistance, bore the brunt of sorrow, And train'd me on to be the object, now, On which Omnipotence displays itself, Making a spectacle, a tale of me, To awe its vassal, man. Lord Rand. O misery ! Amidst thy raging grief I must proclaim My innocence. Lady Rand. Thy innocence ! Lord Rand. My guilt Is innocence, compared with what thou think'st it. Lady Rand. Of thee I think not : what have I to do 382 DOUGLAS. ACT T. With thee, or any thing ? My son ! my son ! My beautiful ! my brave ! how proud was I Of thee, and of thy valour ! My fond heart O'erflow'd this day with transport, when I thought Of growing old amidst a race of thine, Who might make up to me their father's child- hood, And bear my brother's and my husband's name : Now all my hopes are dead ! A little while Was I a wife ! a mother not so long ! WTiat am I now ? I know But I shall be That only whilst I please ; for such a sou And such a husband drive me to my fate. [Runs out. Lord Rand. Follow her, Anna : I myself would follow, But in this rage she must abhor my presence. [Exit ANNA. Enter Old NORVAL. Old Norv. I hear the voice of woe ; heaven guard my child ! Lord Rand. Already is the idle gaping crowd, The spiteful vulgar, come to gaze on Randolph ? Begone ! ACT V. DOUGLAS. 383 Old Norv. I fear thee not. I will not go. Here I'll remain. I'm an accomplice, lord, With thee in murder. Yes, my sins did help To crush down to the ground this lovely plant. nohlest youth that ever yet was horn ! Sweetest and best, gentlest and hravest spirit, That ever bless'd the world ! Wretch that I am, Who saw that noble spirit swell and rise Above the narrow limits that confined it, Yet never was by all thy virtues won To do thee justice, and reveal the secret, Which, timely known, had raised thee far above The villain's snare ! Oh ! I am punish'd now ! These are the hairs that should have strew'd the ground, And not the locks of Douglas. [Tears his hair, and throws himself upon the body of DOUGLAS. Lord Rand. I know thee now : thy boldness I forgive ; My crest is fall'n. For thee I will appoint A place of rest, if grief will let thee rest. 1 will reward, although I cannot punish. Curst, curst Glenalvon, he escaped too well, Though slain and baffled by the hand he hated. 384- DOUGLAS. ACT V. Foaming with rage and ftrfy to the last, Cursing his conqueror the felon died. Enter ANNA. Anna. My lord ! my lord ! Lord Rand. Speak : I can hear of horror. Anna. Horror indeed ! Lord Rand. Matilda? Anna. Is no more. She ran, she flew like lightning up the hill, Nor halted till the precipice she gain'd, Beneath whose low'ring top the river falls, Ingulph'd in rifted rocks : thither she came, As fearless as the eagle lights upon it, And headlong down Lord Rand. 'Twas I ! alas ! 'twas I That fill'd her breast with fury ; drove her down The precipice of death ! Wretch that I am ! Anna. O had you seen her last despairing look ! Upon the brink she stood, and cast her eyes Down on the deep : then lifting up her head And her white hands to heaven, seeming to say, Why am I forced to this ? she plunged herself Into the empty air. ACT V. DOUGLAS. 385 Lord Rand. I will not vent, In vain complaints, the passion of my soul. Peace in this world I never can enjoy. These wounds the gratitude of Randolph gave. They speak aloud, and with the voice of fate Denounce my doom. I am resolved. I'll go Straight to the battle, where the man that makes Me turn aside, must threaten worse than death. Thou, faithful to thy mistress, take this ring, Full warrant of my power. Let every rite With cost and pomp upon their funerals wait : For Randolph hopes he never shall return. [Exeunt. VOL. j. tii/ ill lo jtisiXRW .ffw'i { (> ioo tfJiV/ rf' Ajfobirfill lo'f EPILOGUE. AN epilogue I ask'd ; but not one word Our bard will write. He vows 'tis most absurd With comic wit to contradict the strain Of tragedy, and make your sorrows vain. Sadly he says, that pity is the best, The noblest passion of the human breast : For when its sacred streams the heart o'erflow, In gushes pleasure with the tide of woe; And when its waves retire, like those of Nile, They leave behind them such a golden soil, That there the virtues without culture grow, There the sweet blossoms of affection blow. These were his words : void of delusive art I felt them ; for he spoke them from his heart. Nor will I now attempt, with witty folly, To chase away celestial melancholy. END OF VOLUME FIRST. at t v/of)Ki> Jufc/ft yd,t f obit sjb liliv; Jioa nsbfoij R J'jrr moth j/ok! rroilooBft J< anK s 3 /;!iiaf> 1 EDINBURGH : Printed by James BaUantyne and Co. UC SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBBARYFACIUTY CENTRAL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY University of California, San Diego DATE DUE FEB 1 8 1984 a 39 UCSD Libr. r