k THE MONKS OF THE WEST VOLUME THE SECOND THE MONKS OF THE WEST FROM ST. BENEDICT TO ST. BERNARD BY THE COUNT DE MONTALEMBERT MEMBER OF THE FRENCH ACADEMY WITH AN INTRODUCTION BY THE REV. F. A. GASQUET, D.D., O.S.B. AUTHOR OF "HENRY VIII. AND THE ENGLISH MONASTERIES" FIDE ET VERITATE IN SIX VOLUMES ; , . .VOLUME TliE .SECOND LONDON JOHN C. NIMMO 14 KING WILLIAM STREET, STRAND MDCCCXCVI - Printed by Ballantyne, Hanson & Co. At the Ballantyne Press PAOK CONTENTS BOOK V St. Gregory the Great. — Monastic Italy and Spain in the Sixth and Seventh Centuries i BOOK VI The Monks under the First Merovingians . . 1 1 1 BOOK VII St. Columbanus. — The Irish in Gaul and the Colonies of Luxeuil 239 BOOK VIII CHRISTIAN ORIGIN OF THE BRITISH ISLES I. GREAT BRITAIN BEFORE THE CONVERSION OF THE SAXONS 365 II. THE SAINTS AND MONKS OF WALES 387 III. MONASTIC IRELAND AFTER ST. PATRICK . . . . 42 1 BOOK V ST. GREGORY THE GREAT. — MONASTIC ITALY AND SPAIN IN THE SIXTH AND SEVENTH CENTURIES SUMMARY Cassiodorus : his monastic retreat and his Christian academy at Viviers in Calabria. — The disciples of Benedict in Sicily : martyrdom of St. Placidus.— Benedictine Mission and Martyr Monks in Italy. — Kavages of the Lombards : they overthrow Farfa and Novalese. — First destruction of Monte Cassino. St. Gregory the Great : his birth, his conversion ; he becomes a monk at the monastery of St. Andrea ; his alms and fasts. — He is nuncio at Constantinople, afterwards abbot of his monastery ; his severity against individual property. — His desire to go to convert the Angles : the Romans detain him. — He is elected Pope, to his very great grief : his plaintive letters on leaving the cloister. — State of the world and of the Church at his accession. — Italy at once abandoned and ground down by the Byzantine emperors.— Relations op Gregory with the Lombards : he defends Rome against them. —Homilies on Ezekiel interrupted. — Mediation be- tween Byzantium and the Lombards : Agilulf and Theodelinda. — Conver- sion of the Lombards. — Dialogues on the ancient monks. — His struggles against the Greeks. — Conflict with John the Faster, Patriarch of Con- stantinople, with reference to the title of universal bishop : he desires for himself only the title of servant of the servants of God. — Conflict with the Emperor Maurice : law against the admission of soldiers to monasteries ; celebrated letter to Maurice. — Maurice dethroned and slain by Phocas : congratulations of Gregory to the new emperor ; contrast to his courage and habitual rectitude. — He turns towards the new races, becomes their ally and instructor, and thus begins to emancipate the Church and the West from the Byzantine yoke. — His relations with the Franks and THE BURGUNDIANS : Virgilius of Aries ; Brunehaut ; letter to the young king Childebert. — Celebrated charter of Autun, in which the temporal supremacy of the Papacy over royalty is proclaimed. — Relations with the bishops of Neustria. — His respect for the episcopate and for the freedom of episcopal elections. — His vast correspondence : universal vigilance. — VOL. II. A 2 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT Order re-established in St. Peter's patrimony. — He protects peasants, free- men, slaves, Jews. — His conduct towards the pagans and the Donatists. — Services rendered to the Liturgy and religious art : Gregorian Chants ; musical education. — Ridiculous slander respecting his antipathy to classical literature. — His WRITINGS : The Sacramentary , The Pastoral, The Morals : letters and homilies.— He is the fourth great doctor of the Church. — His extreme humility. — He remains always a monk, and renders the most signal services to the monastic order : he confirms the rule of St. Benedict at the Council of Rome, and shields the liberty and property of the monks. — Exemptions. — Rigorous distinction between monastic life and the eccle- siastical state. — Monastic discipline is reformed and enforced. — History of Venantius, the married monk. — Nunneries. — Gregory watches over the freedom and sincerity of vocations. — Catella, the young slave. — The Abbey of Classe, at Ravenna, protected against the metropolitan ; monastic foun- dations in Isauria and Jerusalem. — He always regrets the cloistral life, and habitually surrounds himself with monks ; he makes them bishops and legates. — Charities and monastic hospitality. — His cruel sufferings; his last letters. — He dies. — Ingratitude of the Romans. — He is avenged by posterity. — His true greatness. The Monks in Spain : origin of the order in Spain conquered by the Arian Visigoths. — St. Donatus, St. Emilian, St. Martin of Dumes.— St. Leander, monk and bishop of Seville. — School of Seville. — Martyrdom of Hermenegild ; exile of Leander : he meets St. Gregory at Constantinople ; their mutual tenderness. — Conversion of King Recarede and of the Vi.sigoth nation, under the auspices of Leander : their relations with Gregory. — The family of Leander : his sister Florentine. — His brother Isadore : action of the latter on the monastic order and Spain ; his writings.— St. Braulius. — Visigothic formula of monastic foundations. — School of Toledo : Abbey of Agali. — Ildefonso of Toledo, monk and bishop, the most popular saint of that period. — Councils of Toledo : part played by the bishops ; inter- vention of the laity : decrees and doctrines upon royalty. — Harshness against the Jews. — The Fuero Juezgo, issued by the Councils of Toledo. — King Wamba made monk in spite of himself. — Monastic extension in Lusi- tania. — St. Fructuosus and his hind. — The monks dwell on the shores of the Ocean waiting for the conquest and invasion of the New World. BOOK V ST. GREGORY THE GREAT Quemadmodum radii solis contingunt quidem terrain, sed ibi sunt unde mittuntur, sic animus magnus et sacer, et in hoc demissus ut pro- pius divina nossemus, conversatur quidem nobiscum, sed hseret ori- gini suae ; illinc pendet, illinc spectat ac nititur. — Seneca, Epist. 41. I. — Monastic Italy in the Sixth Century. Even before the death of Benedict, the most illustrious of his contemporaries had sought in monastic life an interval of repose and freedom between his public career and his grave. Cassiodorus, who had been for thirty years the honour and light of the Gothic monarchy, the minister and the friend of five kings, abandoned the court of Ravenna and all his offices and dignities, 1 towards the year 538, to found, at the extremity of Italy, a monastery called Viviers ( Vivaria), which at one time seemed destined to rival Monte Cassino itself in importance. Cassiodorus belonged to the high Roman nobility : his ancestors had seats at once in the senates of Rome and Constantinople. His fortune was immense. Successively a senator, a quaestor, and prefect of the pretorium, he was the last of the great men who held the office of consul, which Justinian abolished. He obtained, finally, that title of patrician which Clovis and Charlemagne considered them- 1 "Repulsis in Ravennati urbe sollicitudinibus dignitatum et curis S33cularibus." — CASSIOD., Prcef. in Psalm. 3 4 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT selves honoured in receiving. His credit survived all the revolutions of that terrible age. He was successively the minister of Odoacer, of Theodoric, of his daughter Amala- sontha, and of his grandson Athalaric, who made him prefect of the pretorium. He retained that office under the kings Theodatus and Vitiges. He allied in his own person the virtues of the old Romans to those of the new Christians, as in his titles the dignities of the republic were conjoined to those of the empire. Full of respect for the popes and bishops, he was also full of solicitude for the people. An intelligent and courageous mediator between the Barbarian conquerors and the conquered population, he was able to give to the Ostrogoth royalty that protecting and civilising character which it retained for some time. To him must be attributed the finest portion of the great reign of Theodoric, who would have deserved to be the fore- runner of Charlemagne, if he had contracted with the Church that alliance which alone could guarantee and fertilise the future. But, although an Arian, this great prince long pro- tected the religious liberty of the Catholics ; and during the greater part of his reign, the Church gained more by his benevolent indifference than by the oppressive and trifling intervention of the crowned theologians who reigned in By- zantium. Influenced by his pious and orthodox minister, he said, nobly and wisely, that to him, as king, nothiug beyond reverence with regard to ecclesiastical affairs pertained. 1 Cassiodorus, who filled the office of chancellor under him, showed in his official acts the great principles he held, and which most Christian doctors up to that time had appealed to. We cannot," said he, in the name of Theodoric, " com- mand religion, for no man can be forced to believe against his will ; " 2 and to one of his successors, " Since God suffers 1 " Nee aliquid ad se praeter reverentiam de ecclesiasticis negotiis pertinere." 2 " Religionem imperare non possumus, quia nemo cogitur ut credat invitus. ''—Letter of Theodoric to the Jews, ap. Cassiod., lib. ii. ep. 27. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 5 several religions, we dare not impose one alone. We re- member to have read, that a sacrifice to God must be made voluntarily, and not in obedience to a master. A man who attempts to act otherwise evidently opposes himself to the Divine commands." l Two centuries after the peace of the Church, he continued thus faithful to the great apologists of the time of the imperial persecutions : to Tertullian, who said, " Religion forbids us to constrain any one to be re- ligious ; she would have consent, and not constraint ; " " and to Lactantius, according to whom, " To defend religion, one must know how to die, and not how to kill." ' Afterwards, when, unfaithful to his earliest policy, Theo- doric arrogated to himself the right of interfering in the election of the Roman pontiffs — when he had dishonoured the end of his career by cruelties of which Boethius, Sym- machus, and the holy pope, John I., were victims — when his daughter Amalasontha, whose reign was so happy for Italy, had perished by assassination — Oassiodorus, who, amongst all those crimes, had devoted all his energies and perseverance to preserve authority from its own excesses, to soften the manners of the Goths, and guarantee the rights of the Romans, grew weary of that superhuman task. No danger nor disgrace threatened him, for all the sovereigns who, after Theodoric, succeeded each other on the bloody throne of Ravenna, seem to have vied in seeking or conciliat- ing him ; but he had experienced enough of it. He was nearly seventy years old ; fifty years had been passed in the most elevated employments ; he had wielded a power almost 1 "Cum Divinitas patiatur diversas religiones esse, nos unam non aude- mus imponere. Retenimus enim legisse nos voluntarie sacrificandum esse Domino, non cujusquam cogentis imperio. Quod qui aliter facere tentaverit, evidenter coelestibus jussionibus obviavit." — Letter of Theodatus to Justinian, ap. CASSIOD., lib. x. ep. 26. 2 "Non est religionis cogere religionem, quas sponte suscipi debet, non vi." — Ad Scapulam, in fin. s " Defendenda religio est non occidendo, sed moriendo ; non sasvitia, sed patientia ; non scelere, sed fide." 6 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT sovereign, but always tempered by reason and faith. He resolved to end his life in monastic solitude. With him disappeared the glory and prosperity of the kingdom of the Goths in Italy. This was the first, after the downfall of the Roman empire, of these striking conversions, an innumerable series of which will pass before our eyes, which, even in the highest ranks of the new society, sought out the great ones of the world, to teach them how to expiate their grandeur, to rest from their power, and to put an interval between the agita- tions of the world and the judgment of God. But in assuming the monastic frock, Cassiodorus seems to have recommenced to live. This religious profession offered as many attractions to his soul as employments to his activity. The monastery of Viviers, which he had built on the patrimonial estate where he was born, at the ex- tremity of Calabria, on the shores of the Gulf of Squillace, took its name from numerous vivaria, or fish-ponds, which had been hollowed in the rock. It was a delightful dwell- ing, which he has described affectionately in terms worthy of that delicious region, where the azure sea bathes a shore clad with incomparable and perpetual verdure. The build- ing was vast and magnificent ; at a distance it appeared like an entire town. There were two monasteries for the numerous disciples who collected round the illustrious old man. Besides these, some who believed themselves called to a life more austere than that of the cenobites whose dwelling extended along the smiling shores of the sea, found, by ascending the mountain which overlooked them, isolated cells where they could taste in all its purity the delight of absolute solitude. 1 Cassiodorus himself, successively a monk and abbot, passed nearly thirty years in that retreat, occupied in 1 " Habetis Montis Castelli secreta suavia, ubi, velut anachoretae, prse- stante Domino, feliciter esse possitis, ... si prius in corde vestro praepa- ratus sit adscensus." — Cassiod., De Instit. Divin. Litter., c. 19. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 7 governing his community, and uniting the study of litera- ture and science with the pursuit of spiritual life. During his political career, he had made use of his power, with energy and solicitude, to maintain public education and intellectual life in that poor Italy, which was periodically overrun by floods of ignorant and rude conquerors. He has been declared, not without reason, the hero and restorer of knowledge in the sixth century. 1 As soon as he became a monk, he made his monastery a kind of Christian academy, and the principal centre of the literary activity of his time. He had there collected an immense library ; he imposed upon his monks a complete and severe plan of study. His own example enforced his precepts ; he instructed them with unwearied zeal in the Holy Scriptures, for the study of which he, in concert with Pope Agapetus, had attempted in vain to establish public professors in Rome. He added to this the study of the seven liberal arts, and profane litera- ture in general. It was at Viviers that he composed most of his works, and especially his famous Treatise wpon the Teaching of Sacred Literature? a kind of elementary ency- clopaedia, which was the code of monastic education, and served long as a programme to the intellectual education of the new nations. At eighty-three he had the courage to commence a treatise upon orthography, in order to assist in the correction of ancient copies of the holy books. Cassiodorus thus gave, amid his numerous community, one of the first and most illustrious models of that alliance of monastic and intellectual life which has distinguished the monastic order. The literary enthusiasm which inspired the noble old man served only to redouble his zeal for the strict observance of monastic regularity. " God grant to us grace," he wrote, " to be like the untiring oxen to cultivate 1 F. DE Sainte-Marthe, Vie de Cassiodore, 1684. Compare MABILLON, Annal. Bened., lib. v. c. 24, 27. 2 De Institutione Divinarum Litterarum. " Quern monachi omnes accurate legere deberent." — Mabillon, I. c. 8 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT the field of our Lord with the plough of observance and regular exercises." l It is scarcely known what rule he adopted. Some have believed that it was that of St. Bene- dict ; but he has made no special mention of it in recom- mending his monks to follow the rules of the Fathers generally, along with the orders of their own superior, and to consult the institutes of Cassianus. 2 However, a strong analogy may at least be recognised between the usages practised at Viviers and the great example of St. Benedict, in the directions given by Cassiodorus on the subject of manual labour. He desires that those who are not capable of study, or of transcribing manuscript, should apply them- selves to agriculture and gardening, especially for the relief of guests and of the infirm. 3 Like Benedict, he recom- mended them to bestow an affectionate solicitude upon travellers, and upon the poor and sick in the neighbourhood. Like Benedict, he desired that the cultivators of monastic lands should share in the temporal and spiritual wellbeing of monastic life. " Instruct your peasants in good morals ; oppress them not with heavy or new burdens ; call them often to your festivals, that they may not blush, if there is occasion for it, for belonging to you, and yet resembling you so little." 4 In short, he seems to follow the rule of Bene- dict, even in its least details, in that which concerns the nocturnal and almost perpetual psalms which characterised monastic worship, and which he explains as follows to his numerous disciples : " During the silence of night, the voices of men bursting forth in chants and in words sung by art and measure brings us back to Him from whom the divine word came to us, for the salvation of the human race. . . . All who sing form but a single voice, and we mingle our music with the praises of God, chanted by angels, although we cannot hear them." 5 i In Prcef. Explic. Psalm. 2 De Div. Litt., c. 32 and 29. 3 Ibid., c. 28. 4 Ibid., c. 32. Prcef at. in Psalter. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 9 Into the same region where the Roman minister of the Gothic kingdom completed his glorious career, but beyond these Straits of Faro, which doubtless exhibited then, as now, an enchanting scene of nature, other monks had like- wise penetrated. The cherished disciple of St. Benedict, the son of the rich senator who had so generously endowed the new-born community of Subiaco, the young Placidus, had brought to Sicily the name and rule of his master. He had been sent there to recover the eighteen estates situated in that island, which his father had given to the abbot of Monte Cassino, and the profits of which had been lost by unfaithful stewardship. He remained there, and established towards the year 534, at Messina, the first Benedictine monastery which was formed out of Italy. Placidus col- lected there thirty monks, but was too soon interrupted in his work of religious colonisation. 1 He perished with two of his brethren and his young sister Flavia, tortured and slain by a band of Moorish pirates, still pagans, and who, like so many other ruffians, made the monks the principal victims of their fury. The children of St. Benedict inaugu- rated thus the long series of their struggles and victories. The blood of Placidus watered the seeds of the order in Sicily, where its harvest, even up to our own days, has been so abundant. 2 We have said that the monks came to replace the martyrs, but that often also they imitated and joined their band. It was thus during the rise of the Benedictine order in Italy. Its extension was rapid during the last years of Benedict's life, and especially after his death. The tomb where the holy 1 We do not venture to relate here many very interesting features in the life of the first disciple of St. Benedict, because his Acts, attributed to one of his companions, the monk Gordian, have undergone very numerous interpolations, according to the unanimous opinion of Baronius, Mabillon, and the Bollandists. 2 There were at that time, and subsequently, many monasteries in Sicily inhabited by Greek monks, who followed the rule of St. Basil. — Yepes, Chronica General., ii. 2. IO ST. GREGORY THE GREAT remains of the great legislator rested, under the guardian- ship of a line of fervent disciples constantly renewed, became the spring from which a new life flowed forth upon the penin- sula. 1 Most of the ancient monasteries adopted the rule which flourished at Monte Cassino. It spread through Latium in the environs of Lake Fucino, where the holy abbot Equitius, shod with nailed shoes, made hay with his monks, and returned, after the hot and laborious day, with his scythe on his shoulder like any other labourer. 2 It was carried to the summit of Mount Soracte, where more than one brave solitary, well worthy of practising it, waited its coming, and where the gentle prior Nonnosus laboured .on the rocky sides of the mountain celebrated by Virgil and Horace, to make gardens and olive orchards for the use of his brethren. 3 It prevailed in several of the twenty-two re- ligious houses which already existed at Rome. 4 It soon extended into the isles of the Mediterranean and Adriatic, which we have seen to be already occupied by monks, and especially into those which lay near the coast of Naples, whither, under the hideous tyranny of the first Caesars, men accused of high treason had been banished, and where the love of heavenly things and spiritual freedom retained many voluntary exiles. Thus, throughout the whole peninsula, numerous companies of monks laboriously struggled, amidst the general confusion, against the depravity of Roman man- ners, against the violence of the Barbarians. Their lives afforded these lessons of austere virtue and miraculous power, the memory of which St. Gregory the Great has associated in his Dialogues with that of their holy patri- 1 " Te monachorum turbas diu noctuque concelebrant, corpus tuum in medio positum servantes, quod largos miraculorum fluvios effudit." — Menkes de VEglise Grccque, ap. Dom GUERANGER, Careme, p. 581. 2 " Clavatis calceatus caligis, falcem ferrariam in collo deferens venie- bat."— S. Greg., Dial, lib. 4. 3 V. S. Gregor., Dial., lib. i. c. 7, on Nonnosus and Anastasius. 4 Baronius, Martyrol. , 5 Dec. Amongst these the monasteries of St. Sabas and St. Erasmus held the first rank. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT I I arch. They died as they had lived, and braved martyrdom in public places as well as in the depth of woods. Upon the faith of that great doctor, the faithful have related from generation to generation, how the monk Herculanus, Bishop of Perugia, when that city was besieged and destroyed by the Goths under Totila, was sacrificed amid tortures, as the principal author of the resistance ; how, in the Roman Cam- pagna, the abbot Suranus was slain by the Lombards, who found him hidden in the hollow of an oak ; and how, else- where, the same Lombards hung the monks, two by two, to the same tree. 1 For the Lombards were already there. Scarcely had the Goths, who fell into their premature decay after Theodoric and Cassiodorus, disappeared, when a new race of Barbarians crossed the Alps and descended upon Italy. They were proud, intelligent, and warlike, Arian by name, but still, in fact, half-pagan, and a thousand times more cruel and dreaded than the Goths. 2 Under Alboin and his succes- sors they ravaged the peninsula without pity, trampling under foot Greeks and Romans, Catholics and Arians, priests and laymen. Ruined cities, desecrated churches, murdered bishops and clergy, and exterminated nations, were everywhere seen in their track. 3 These ferocious con- querors reaped everything, and left only a desert behind them. The end of the world was supposed to have come. 4 They were especially furious against monks and monasteries. They burned and destroyed, among others, two considerable abbeys, the origin of which is unknown : Novalese, situated upon a plateau on the south side of the Piedmontese Alps ; 1 S. Greg., Dial., iv. 21. 2 Their first invasion took place in 568, at the solicitation of Narses. 3 ANASTASIUS, Liber Pontif., c. 32. 4 " Mox effera gens Longobardorum de vagina suae habitationis educta in nostram cervicem grassata est, atque humanum genus . . . succisum aruit. . . . Depopulatse urbes, . . . destructa monasteria virorum ac femi- narum, . . . occupaverunt bestiae loca quas prius multitudo hominum tenebat."— S. Gregor. Magn., Dial, iii. 38, Epist., iii. 29. 12 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT and Farfa, which imagined itself secure, hid among the fresh foliage of the Sabine woods, sung by Ovid — " Et amoense Farfaris umbrae." These names, destined to be so celebrated in religious history, yet the first appearance of which is marked by disaster, must be noted. A great number of monks received martyrdom from the hands of these new persecutors ; others, hunted from their first asylum, and wandering through the different parts of Italy, carried with them the seeds of monastic life into countries which, without that storm, they might never have reached. Finally, the Lombards ascended Monte Cassino, and pil- laged and burned that already famous sanctuary, according to the prediction of Benedict, forty years before; but, as he had also predicted, 1 they could destroy nothing which had life, and did not take a single monk. Although the attack of the Lombards took place by night, and while the monks were asleep, they were all able to flee, bearing with them, as their entire fortune, the rule written by their founder, with the measure of wine and the pound of bread which he had prescribed. 2 They took refuge at Rome ; Pope Pelagius II. 3 gave them a paternal reception, and permitted them to build, near the Lateran palace, a monastery in which the children of Benedict were to await for a century and a half the happy day which was to witness their return to their holy mountain. 4 1 " Res, non animas." — Epist., iv. 17. 2 In 580, under Bonitus, fourth abbot after St. Benedict. 3 According to Yepes and some other authors, this pope, like his prede- cessor, Benedict I., was a monk ; but we find no proof of this assertion. 4 They only returned to Monte Cassino about 730, under the abbot Petronatius. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 1 3 II. — Gregory the Great, Monk and Pope. But ere long a monk ascended for the first time the apostolical See. This monk, the most illustrious of all those who have been reckoned among the sovereign pontiffs, was to shine there with a splendour which none of his prede- cessors had equalled, and which flowed back, like a supreme sanction, upon the institute from which he came. Gregory, who alone among men has received, by universal consent, the double surname of Saint and Great, will be an everlasting honour to the Benedictine order as to the papacy. By his genius, but especially by the charm and ascendancy of his virtue, he was destined to organise the temporal power of the popes, to develop and regulate their spiritual sovereignty, to found their paternal supremacy over the new-born crowns and races which were to become the great nations of the future, and to be called France, Spain, and England. It was he, indeed, who inaugurated the middle ages, modern society, and Christian civilisation. Issued, like St. Benedict, from one of the most illustrious races of ancient Rome, the son of a rich senator, and descen- dant of Pope Felix III., of the Anicia family, 2 Gregory was early called to filled a dignified place, which, in the midst of modern Rome, the vassal of Byzantium, and subject to the ceaseless insults of the Barbarians, retained some shadow of ancient Roman grandeur. He was praetor of Rome during the first invasions of the Lombards and the religious troubles stirred up by the fifth general council. In the exercise of this office he gained the hearts of the Romans, while habitu- ating himself to the management of public business, and while acquiring a taste for luxury and display of earthly grandeur, in which he still believed he might serve God 1 Compare Don PlTRA, Histoire de St. Legcr, Introduction. 2 " Ex noblissima et antiquissima Aniciorum familia." — Joan. DlAC in Vit. S. Greg. Magn. He was born probably in 540, and died in 604. 14 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT without reproach. But God required him elsewhere. Gregory hesitated long, inspired by the divine breath, but retained, led back and fascinated to the world, by the attrac- tions and habits of secular life. At last he yielded to the influence of his intimate and close relations with the refugees of Monte Cassino, the successors and disciples of Benedict ; l and then, obeying the grace which enlightened him, he abruptly broke every tie, devoted his wealth to the en- dowment of six new monasteries in Sicily, and established in his own palace in Rome, upon the Coelian hill, a seventh, dedicated to St. Andrew, into which he introduced the Benedictine rule, and where he himself became a monk. 2 He sold all that remained of his patrimony to distribute it to the poor; and Rome, which had seen the young and wealthy patrician traverse its streets in robes of silk covered with jewels, now saw him, with admiration, clothed like a beggar, serving, in his own person, the beggars lodged in the hospital which he had built at the gate of his paternal house, now changed into a monastery. 3 Once a monk, he would be nothing less than a model of 1 " Diu longeque conversionis gratiam distuli, et postquam ccelesti sum desiderio afflatus, sseculari habitu contegi melius putavi. Apparebatur enim mihi jam de asternitatis amore quid quaererem : sed inolita me con- suetudo devinxerat, ne exteriorem cultum mutarem. Cumque adhuc me cogeret animus . . . cceperunt multa me ex ejusdem mundi cura succres- cere, ut in eo jam non specie, sed, quod est gravius, mente retinerer." — Prccfat. ad Job. The Benedictines who brought about his conversion were Constantine, disciple and successor of St. Benedict at Monte Cassino ; Simplicius, third abbot of Monte Cassino ; and Valentinian, abbot of Latran. 2 "Mutato repente sseculi habitu."— Paul. Diac, Vit. S. Greg., c. 3. Yepes and Mabillon have proved beyond question, against Baronius, that St. Gregory professed the rule of St. Benedict.— Act. SS. 0. S. B. Prozf. in i. sac. § vii. See also his life by his Benedictine editors, lib. i. c. 3. This monastery of St. Andrew, which now bears the name of St. Gregory, has been since given to the Camaldules, and from it, thirteen centuries after, issued another Gregory, pope and monk, Gregory XVI. 3 " Qui ante serico contextu ac gemmis micantibus solitus erat per urbem procedere trabeatus, post vili contectus tegmine ministrabat pauper ipse pauperibus." — Paul. Diac, c. 2. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT I 5 monks, and practised with the utmost rigour all the austeri- ties sanctioned by the rule, applying himself specially at the same time to the study of the Holy Scriptures. He ate only pulse which his mother, who had become a nun since her widowhood, sent him to his convent, already soaked, in a silver porringer. This porringer was the only remnant of his ancient splendour, and did not remain long in his hands, for one day a shipwrecked sailor came several times to beg from him while he was writing in his cell, and finding no money in his purse, he gave him that relic of his former wealth. Long after, Gregory saw the shipwrecked man, who appeared to him under the form of his guardian angel, and instructed him that from that day God had destined him to govern His Church, and to be the successor of Peter, whose charity he had imitated. 1 Continually engaged in prayer, reading, writing, or dic- tation, he persisted in pushing the severity of his fasts to such an extent that his health succumbed, and his life itself was in danger. He fell so often into fainting fits, that more than once, as he himself relates, he should have sunk under them, had not his brethren supported him with more substantial food." In consequence of having attempted to do more than others, he was soon obliged to relinquish even the most ordinary fasts, which everybody observed. He was in despair at not being able to fast even upon Easter eve, a day on which even the little children fast, says his biographer : and aided by the prayers of a holy abbot of Spoleto who had become a monk with him at St. Andrea, he obtained from God the grace of strength to observe that fast at least. But he remained weak and 1 " Crudis leguminibus pascebatur. . . . Matris argenteam quaa cum infusis leguminibus mitti solita erat. . . . Ego sum naufragus ille qui quondam veni ad te, quando scribebas in cella. . . . Ab illo destinavit te Dominus fieri prassulem S. suae Ecclesise." — Joan. Diacon., Vit. S. Greg., i. 10, and ii. 23. 2 " Nisi me frequenter fratres cibo reficerent, vitalis mihi spiritus fundi- tus intercidi videretur." — Dial., iii. 33. 1 6 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT sickly all his life, and when he left his monastery, it was with health irreparably ruined. Pope Benedict I. drew him first from the cloister in 577, to raise him to the dignity of one of the seven cardinal- deacons or regionaries, who presided over the seven principal divisions of Borne. He yielded, against his own will, to the authority of the pontiff. " When a ship," said he, " is not well moored in port, the storm seizes it, even on the most secure coast. Thus I am plunged again into the ocean of the world, under an ecclesiastical pretext. I learn to appreciate the peace of the monastery by losing it, though I have not been sufficiently careful of defending while I possessed it." 1 It was still worse when Pope Pelagius II. sent him, as Apocrisiarius or Nuncio, to the Emperor Tiberius. During this involuntary absence he was accom- panied by several monks of the community, devoting him- self with them to study and reading, and following, as much as possible, all the observances of the rule. " By their example," he wrote, " I attach myself to the coast of prayer, as with the cable of an anchor, while my soul is tossed upon the waves of public life." 2 He discharged the duties of his office, nevertheless, with reputation and success, re-established between the Holy See and the Byzantine court the friendly relations which had been interrupted by the Lombard invasion, and neglected no means to obtain from Tiberius and his successor, Maurice, the help demanded by Rome and Italy against the terrible invasions, and the more and more oppressive domination, of the Lombards. He also learnt to know the shifts and sub- terfuges which the Byzantine spirit already employed against 1 "Navem incaute religatam . . . tempestas excutit ; repent e me sub prsetextu ecclesiastici ordinis in causarum saecularium pelago referi, et quietem monasterii, quia habendo non fortiter tenui, quam stricte tenenda fuerit, perdendo cognovi." — Pra>fat. ad Job. 2 "Ad orationis placidum littus, quasi ancborae fune. . . . Dum cau- sarum ssecularium vertiginibus fluctuaret."— Prcef. Moralium. Compare Dial, iii. 36 ; Joan. DiAC, i. 26; Bede, Hist. Eccl, ii. I. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT I 7 Roman unity and authority. He brought the patriarch Eutychus, who denied the actual resurrection of the body, to an edifying retractation. After six years of this honourable and laborious exile, he returned to Rome, and regained the peaceful shelter of his monastery of St. Andrea, the monks of which elected him abbot soon after his return. 1 He enjoyed there for some time longer the delights of the life which he had chosen. Tenderly cherished by his brethren, he took a paternal share in their trials and spiritual crosses, provided for their temporal and spiritual necessities, and specially rejoiced in the holy death of several among them. He has related the details of these in his Dialogues, and seems to breathe in them the perfume of heaven. But the affectionate kind- ness which always inspired him did not prevent him from maintaining with scrupulous severity the requirements of the rule. He threw into a ditch the body of a monk, who had been a skilful physician, and in whose possession three pieces of gold were found, in contempt of the article of the rule which interdicted all individual property. The three pieces of gold were thrown upon the body, in presence of all the monks, whilst they repeated aloud the words of the verse, " Pecunia tua tecum sit in perditionem." When this act of justice was accomplished, mercy took its sway once more in the heart of the abbot, who caused mass to be celebrated for thirty days successively to deliver this poor soul from purgatory. 2 This tender solicitude for souls was on the point of separating him from his dear monastery and from Rome. 1 The chronological order of these first events in the public life of St. Gregory has been finally established, in the work of the Mecklenburg pastor, Lau, Gregor der Grosse, nach seinem Leben und seiner Lehre geschildert, Leipzig, 1845. T Be history of the great pontiff is there written with eru- dition and as much impartiality as can be looked for from a Protestant minister. Compare S. Gregorii Vita ex ejus Scriptis Adornata, lib. i. c. 5, in the large edition of his works by the Benedictines. 2 Dial., vi. 55. VOL. II. B 1 8 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT Everybody knows how he saw exhibited in the market some poor pagan children, of extraordinary beauty and fairness, who were said to be of the country of the Angles, to which he answered, that they were made to become angels. 1 On which occasion, hastening to the pope, he begged him to send missionaries into that great island of Britain, where the pagans sold such slaves ; failing others, offered himself for this work ; surprised the pontiff into consent, and pre- pared instantly for his departure. But when they under- stood his intention, the love with which the Romans had formerly regarded him was re-awakened. They surrounded the pope as he went to St. Peter's; they cried to him, " You have offended St. Peter ; you have ruined Rome in allowing Gregory to leave us." The astonished pope yielded to the popular voice. He sent messengers after Gregory, who overtook him at three days' journey from Rome ; they led him back forcibly to his monastery. It was not as a missionary, but as a pope, that he was to win England to the Church. In 590, Pelagius II. died of the plague, which then depopulated Rome. Gregory was immediately elected pope by the unanimous voice of the senate, the people, and the clergy. It was in vain that he refused, and appealed to the Emperor Maurice not to confirm his election. The Romans intercepted his letter ; the imperial confirmation arrived. Then he disguised himself, and, fleeing from Rome to seek some unknown retreat, wandered three days in the woods. He was followed, discovered, and a second time led back to Rome, but this time to reign there. He bowed his head, weeping, under the yoke imposed upon him by the divine will, and the unanimity of his fellow- citizens. 2 1 "Bene Angli quasi angeli, quia angelicos vultus habent et tales in coelis angelorum decet esse concives." — Joan. Diac, i. 21. 2 "Infirmitatis meas conscius secretiora loca petere decreveram. . . . Jugo conditoris subdidi cervicem." — Epist., vii. 4, edit. Benedict. In refer- ring to the epistles, we have almost always followed the order established ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 19 It was during the interval between his election and the imperial confirmation that, in the hope of turning back the scourge of the plague, he caused the famous procession of three days (in which, for the first time, all the abbots of the Koman monasteries appeared with their monks, and all the abbesses with their nuns) to be celebrated. Whilst these communities defiled before Gregory, he saw an angel appear upon the summit of the Hadrian Mole, putting back his sword into its sheath, the image of which, standing upon the colossal mausoleum, has given its name to the Castle of St. Angelo, and perpetuated to our own day the recollection of St. Gregory's vision. 1 The supreme pontificate, perhaps, never fell upon a soul more disturbed and afflicted than that of the monk who saw himself thus condemned to exchange the peace of the cloister for the cares of the government of the universal Church, and the special defence of the interests of Italy. Not only then, but during all his life, he did not cease to lament his fate. His sadness displayed itself first in his answers to the con- gratulations which reached him from all quarters : " I have lost," he wrote to the sister of the emperor, " the profound joys of repose. I seem to have been elevated in external things, but in spiritual I have fallen. ... I endeavour daily to withdraw from the world and from the flesh, to see heavenly joys in the spirit. . . . Neither desiring nor fear- ing anything in this world, I felt myself above everything. But the storm of temptation has cast me all at once among alarms and terrors ; lor, though still I fear nothing for myself, I fear much for those of whom I have the charge." ' To the patrician Narses : " I am so overcome with melan- in the edition of the Benedictines, which differs considerably from the ancient classification, quoted by Mabillon, Fleurs, &c. " Decretum generalitatis evadere nequivit. . . . Capitur, trahitur, consecratur." — Joan. Diac, Vit. Greg., i. 41. 1 Compare Greg. Turonens., Hist. Franc, x. i. ; Paul. Diac, Be Gcst. Longob., iii. 25 ; JOAN. DlAC, Vit. Greg., i. 41. 2 " Alta quietis mea? gaudia perdidi." — Epist., i. 5. 20 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT choly, that I can scarcely speak; the darkness of grief assails the eyes of my soul ; I see nothing that is not sad, and everything which is supposed to please me appears to me lamentable. For I cannot cease to see from what a height of tranquillity I have fallen, and to what a height of embarrassment I have ascended." l To Andrew, of the rank called Illustrious : " When you hear of my promotion to the episcopate, weep, if you love me ; for there are so many temporal occupations here, that I find myself by this dignity almost separated from the love of God." 2 To the patrician John, who had contributed to his election : " I complain of your love, which has drawn me from the repose which you know I sought. God reward you with eternal gifts for your good intention, but I pray Him deliver me, as He shall please, from so many perils; for, as my sins deserve, I have become bishop, not only of the Romans, but of these Lombards who acknowledge only the right of the sword, and whose favour is torture. See how much your patronage has brought me." 3 Then, taking up once more these images which he loved to borrow from maritime life, he said to his intimate friend Leander, Bishop of Toledo, whom he had met at Constantinople : " I am here so beaten by the waves of this world, that I despair of being able to guide to port this rotten old vessel with which God has charged me. . . . I must hold the helm amid a thousand difficulties. ... I already hear the bell of shipwreck ringing. ... I weep when I recall the peaceful shore which I have left, and sigh in perceiving afar that which I cannot attain." One day, long after, when, more than ever overwhelmed by the burden of secular affairs, he had withdrawn into a secret place, to give himself up to silence and sadness, he was joined there by the deacon Peter, his pupil, the friend of 1 Epist., i. 6. " "Si me diligitis, plangite." — Ibid., i. 30. 3 " Quorum synthicae spathas sunt, et gratia poena. Ecce ubi patrocinia vestra me perduxerunt." — Ibid., i. 31. 4 " Vetustam ac putrescentem navim. . . . Flens reminiscor quod per- didi mese placidum littus quietis." — Ibid., i. 43. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 2 1 his youth and companion of his beloved studies. " Has some new trouble happened to you," said the young man, " that you are thus sadder thau usual ? " " My grief," an- swered the pontiff, " is that of all my days, always old by custom, and always new by its daily increase. 1 My poor soul recalls what it was of old in our monastery, when it soared over everything changeable and transitory ; when it dreamt only of heaven ; when by contemplation it escaped from the cloister of this body which enclosed it ; when it loved death as the entrance of life. And now, because of my pastoral charge, it must bear the burdens of the men of the world, and soil itself in this dust. And when, after having exhausted itself without, it comes back to its internal retreat, it returns with diminished forces. I meditate on all I have suffered and lost. I see myself tossed by the ocean and broken by the tempest. When I think of my former life, I seem to look back towards the shore. And what is still more sad, when thus shaken by the storm, I can scarcely perceive the port which I have left." " These exclamations of profound grief tell us all that we re- quire to know of the influence of this cloistral life, which swayed to such an extent the holy soul of the greatest man of his age. It is true that the condition of the world and the Church, at the advent of Gregory, exhibited only causes of grief and 1 " Quadam die . . . secretum locum petii amicum mceroris . . . dilec- tissimus filius meus Petrus . . . mihi a primsevo juventutis flore amicitiis familiariter obstrictus. . . . Num quidquam novi. . . . Moeror, Petre, quem quotidie patior, et semper mihi per usum vetus est, et semper per augmentum novus." — Prcefat. ad Dialog. 2 "Infelix animus meus occupationis sua3 pulsatus vulnere meminit qualis aliquando in monasterio fuit, quomodo ei labentia cuncta subter erant. . . . Quod etiam retentus corpore ipsa jam carnis claustra con- templationem transibat, quod mortem quoque, qua? pene cunctis poena est, videlicet ut ingressum vita? et laboris prasmium amabat. At nunc . . . et post tarn pulchram quietis suae speciem terreni actus pulvere fcedatur. . . . Ecce etenim nunc magni maris fluctibus quatior, atque in navi multis tempestatis validae procellis inlidor : et cum prioris vita? recolo, quasi post tergum reductis oculis viso littore suspiro . . . vix jam portem valeo videre quem reliqui." — Procem. ad Dicdoy. 2 2 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT alarm. An obstinate, although restrained schism, which dated from the fifth general council, 1 and which had lasted forty years, consumed the powers of the clergy. The papacy, always dependent on the Byzantine emperors, and unceasingly humiliated by them, did not even find, in the arm of these distrustful and incapable masters, the support which it needed against its enemies from within and with- out. Within the shadow of their throne flourished those patriarchs of Constantinople, whose ambition already aspired to the title of universal, and who were to end by rending the Church in twain. Africa was a prey to the Donatists ; Spain was entirely Arian ; England had fallen back into idolatry ; in Gaul, despite the Catholic faith professed by the successors of Clovis, simony polluted the Church, and the struggles of Fredegond and Brunehaut distressed all Chris- tians ; in the East, the Avars and Persians threatened or ravaged the empire. But nothing was more lamentable than the state of Italy. As if the scourge of God, floods, plague, and famine, were not enough, men rent each other with contentions, and disorders of all kind invaded the Church, following in the steps of persecution and war. The Lombards, who from being pagans had become Arians, believed that by persecuting furiously the Roman Church they would secure their power against the Greeks ; they regarded the papacy as the servant of the Byzantine court, and consequently as their own habitual enemy. The Greek emperors, on their side, accused the popes of treason, be- cause they did not sacrifice everything to the necessities of imperial policy, or of usurpation, because they took upon themselves the task of providing for the public necessities when the inaction or powerlessness of the lieutenants of Caesar became too evident. In reality, the successors of Constantine, with an instinctive perception of the future, perceived already, in the successors of St. Peter, the power which God had destined to replace their decrepid 1 The second of Constantinople, in 553. ST. GKEGORY THE GREAT 23 sovereignty, in Italy and over that city in which the imagination of Christendom still placed the centre of the empire and the cause of its existence. Thence came their tortuous, oppressive, and inconsistent policy. They would be obeyed as masters, by nations whom they knew not how to defend ; and as, amid the ruins which despot- ism had everywhere accumulated, the papacy alone was seen standing, they willingly made the popes responsible for the consequences of their own weakness. The poor monk who showed so much despair when he was thrown into that whirlpool by the unanimous voice of the Romans, could yet perceive with a bold and clear glance the dangers of the situation, and adopt a line of conduct which was a manifest realisation of the infallible promises of Jesus Christ. He founded the temporal greatness of the Holy See, and the progress of its spiritual authority, upon the basis, long immovable, of the gratitude and admiration of nations. First of all, and especially, he concerned himself with the Lombards. Although he has perhaps judged too severely in his writings this proud and intelligent race, whose courage and legislative powers have attracted the attention of pos- terity, and who were a hundred times more worthy than the degenerate Greco-Romans, whose authority he loyally endeavoured to re-establish in Italy, Gregory used in his intercourse with them no means that were not legitimate and honourable. He had a right, after long and laborious negotiations with them, to bear this testimony to himself, " Had I been willing to lend myself to the destruction of the Lombards, that nation would have had to-day neither kings, dukes, nor counts, and would have been a prey to irremediable confusion ; but because I fear God I would not assist in the ruin of any." * He doubtless alluded to the treacheries planned by the exarchs of Ravenna, who were the emperor's viceroys in Italy, by which they at- tempted to make up for their military inferiority before the 1 Epist., iv. 47, 5. — He wrote this in 598. 24 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT Lombards. The Roman exarch was, by his animosity and cowardice, one of the principal afflictions of Gregory's life. After having broken the peace with the Lombards, and thus justified the renewed hostilities of their dukes Ariulf x and Arigis 2 in Central and Southern Italy, he abandoned Rome and Naples without defence, and notwithstanding interdicted the pope from treating with the invaders. It was then that Gregory displayed all the resolution of a valiant captain, with all the authority of a sovereign. He did not content himself with complaining bitterly to the Emperor Maurice of the desertion of Italy, and that, in order to guard Perugia, Rome had been left defenceless. " I was obliged," he wrote to him, " to see with my own eyes the Romans led into France with ropes round their necks, like dogs, to be sold in the market." 3 But he himself provided what was most urgent, wrote to the military leaders to encourage them in resistance, pointed out to the soldiers assembled at Naples the leader whom they should follow, fed the people, paid the troops their wages and the Barbarians their contributions of war, all at the expense of the ecclesiastical treasury. " The emperor," he wrote to the empress, " has a treasurer for his troops at Ravenna, but as for me, I am the treasurer of the Lombards at Rome." 4 At a later period, the king of the Lombards, Agilulf, dis- gusted by the renewed treachery of the imperial exarch, laid siege to Rome itself. Gregory, who was, above every- thing else, a bishop, and watched over the spiritual interests of the Romans with still more care than he exerted for their material defence, was then expounding the prophet Ezekiel in his sermons. He interrupted his discourses more than once to breathe out his grief, and to deplore the misfortunes of the eternal city. " Two things specially trouble me," he 1 Duke of Spoleto. 2 Duke of Benevento. 3 "Quodoculis meis cernerem Romanos more canum in collis funibus ligatos. . . . Qui ad Franciam ducebantur venales." — Epist., v. 40. 4 Ibid,, v. 21. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 25 said, when he was asked at least to explain the last chapters of the prophet upon the re-establishment of the temple : " the obscurity of the text, and the news that King Agi- lulf has passed the Po on his way to besiege us. Judge, my brethren, how a poor soul, thus troubled and distracted, can penetrate into such mysteries." l And again, " What does the world contain which can please us ? . . . We see nothing but sadness, we hear only groans. . . . Rome, once mistress of the world, how do we see her fallen ! Where is the senate ? where is the people ? But why speak I of men ? The very buildings are destroyed and the walls crumble down. . . . Once her princes and chiefs spread themselves over all the earth to possess it. The sons of worldly men hastened hither to advance themselves in the world. Now that she is deserted and ruined, no man comes here to seek his fortune : there is no power remaining to oppress the poor." After a time he announced that he should stop his preaching : " Let no one blame me if I put an end to this discourse. You all perceive how our tribu- lations increase. The sword and death are everywhere. Some return to us with their hands cut off, with the news that others are taken or killed. I must be silent, because my soul is weary of life." 2 Agilulf, however, for some unknown reason, did not suc- ceed in taking Rome. All the surrounding country was once more devastated, and the incurable desolation and un- wholesome barrenness of the Roman Campagna dates from this period ; but the city was spared. Gregory could verify the prophecy of St. Benedict, who had predicted that Rome, condemned to the most cruel trials, should sink back upon herself, but should not be destroyed. 3 He could still con- 1 Homil. 18. 2 " Undique gladiis, . . . undique mortis periculum. . . . Alii detrun- catis manibus. . . . Taedet animam meam vitas mese." — Homil. ult. in Ezechid. 3 " Roma a gentilibus non exterminabitur, sed ... in semetipsa mar- cescet. " — Dial., ii. 15. 26 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT tinue to watch over these crumbling walls, these overthrown palaces, these buildings worn out with extreme old age. 1 But, as a reward for his generous and useful efforts, he received only new denunciations from the exarch, and a reprimand from the emperor, who reproached him in insult- ing terms with his simplicity. " I understand," the pope replied to him, "what the language of your serene missives means : you find that I have acted like a fool, and you are right. If I had not acted like a fool I should not have borne all that I have borne for you among the swords of the Lombards." 2 He succeeded at last, after nine years' exer- tions, in overcoming the Byzantine repugnance to acknow- ledge any right whatever on the side of the Lombards, and concluded a peace between the two powers which made Italy, exhausted by thirty years of war and brigandage, thrill with joy. It was of short duration ; but when hos- tilities recommenced, he entered into direct negotiation with King Agilulf, and obtained from that prince a special truce for Rome and its surrounding territory. He had besides found a powerful advocate with the Lombard king in the person of the illustrious Queen Theodelinda, who was the Clotilde of these last conquerors of Italy. This princess, a Bavarian and Catholic by birth, the widow of King Autharis by her first marriage, had so gained the heart of the Lom- bards, that they conferred upon her the right of designating his successor by marrying whomsoever she thought most worthy of reigning with her. In this way she had given her hand and crown to Duke Agilulf, in the same year as that in which Gregory ascended the Holy See. These two noble hearts soon understood each other. The queen was always the faithful friend of the pope ; she served as a i " Dissoluta moenia, eversas domos, . . . sedificia longo senio lassata." — Dial., ii. 15. 2 " In serenissimis jussionibus dominorum pietas . . . urbanse simplici- tatis vocabulo me fatuum appellat. . . . Simplex denuncior : constat procul dubio quia fatuus appellor . . . quod ita esse ego quoque confiteor." — Epist., v. 40. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 27 medium of communication between him and her husband. It is not certain whether she succeeded in converting the latter, 1 but her gentle influence led the entire Lombard nation, little by little, from Arianism to the Catholic faith. Gregory, from the very beginning of his pontificate, had ex- horted the Italian bishops to make special exertions for the conversion of these formidable enemies of orthodoxy. It is believed that the queen was powerfully aided in this work by the Dialogues which Gregory had compiled from the narratives of the first disciples and successors of St. Bene- dict, and in which he related the life of that patriarch of the monastic order, and the marvels of fervour and penitence exhibited by the monks who were imbued with his spirit. This work was dedicated to the Lombard queen, as if to enable her to show to the devastators of Italy proofs of the sanctity and moral greatness with which the orthodox faith alone could endow the vanquished. It was thus that Gregory snatched Rome from the yoke of conquest. He not only preserved her from the Lom- bards, but sheltered her from the violence of all the petty tyrants of the neighbourhood, who rose amidst the universal confusion. But his soul was consumed, says one of his his- torians, by the fire of perpetual alarms concerning the fate of his children, and that consecrated soil which he regarded as their inheritance. 3 We can understand now how the patriotism of popes, such as Gregory, created their temporal power, and how, " sole guardians of Rome, they remained its masters." 4 However, he required still more constancy and courage to contend with the Greeks, with that Eastern Empire which was represented by functionaries whose odious exactions had 1 St. Columba, in a letter written in 607, speaks of him as still an Arian. 2 Epist., i. 29. 3 " Urebant incessanter ejus animum filiorum hinc inde discrimina nun- tiata." — Paul. Diac, c. 13. 4 OzANAM, Unpublished Fragment on St. Gregory. 28 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT quite as great a share in the despair of the people as the ravages of the Barbarians, and whose malice was more dreadful, as he wrote, than the sword of the Lombards : " They can only kill our bodies, while the imperial judges devour our souls by their rapine and fraud." l Elsewhere he denounces to the empress the officers who, in Sardinia, sold to the pagans for money the permission to sacrifice to their idols, and continued to collect that impost from those who had been baptized, and who, in Corsica, overwhelmed the inhabitants with such burdens that they were reduced to selling their children and fleeing to seek refuge among the Lombards. 2 It was the same in Sicily, and the re- venues provided by their extortions were to be employed in the defence of Italy. But, said Gregory to the empress, " it might be suggested to the emperor that it would be better to give up some expenses in Italy, in order to dry the tears of the oppressed in Sicily. 3 I say this briefly, and only that the supreme Judge may not impute my silence to me as a crime." The entire life of Gregory was then a struggle with the Byzantine spirit, with the patriarch of Constantinople, who aimed at supplanting the Boman pontiff, as well as with the emperor, who would have dominated Italy without defending her, and ruled the Church as if she had been only a province of his empire. God had sent him, before his pontificate, to Constantinople, that he might the better understand that field of battle 4 in which he won for the Church more than one difficult victory. Among so many conflicts — through which Gregory always maintained the rights and dignities of the Holy See, con- 1 "Ejus in nos malitia gladios Longobardoruni vicit, ita ut benigniores videantur hostes, quia nos interiniunt, quam Reipublicse judices, qui nos . . . rapinis atque fallaciis in cogitatione consumunt." — Epist., v. 42. 2 Ibid., v. 41. 3 " Sed ego suggero ad hoc, ut, etsi minus expense in Italia tribuantur, a suo tamen imperio oppressorum lacrymas compescat." — Ibid., v. 41. 4 Dom Pitra., Hist, de S. Leger, Introduction. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 29 ciliating, at the same time, with extraordinary precautions, the arrogance of the Byzantine court — we shall dwell only on that one which arose between him and the patriarch of Constantinople, John, surnamed the Faster. Relying on the support of most of the Eastern bishops, faithful to the proud pretensions which for two centuries past had been entertained by the bishops of the imperial residence, and preluding thus the disastrous ambition of his successors, this monk, who had begun by a pretence of refusing the episco- pate, took in his acts the title of oecumenical or universal patriarch. Gregory stood up with as much vigour as autho- rity against this strange pretension. He did not draw back before the emperor, who openly sided with the bishop of his new capital, and although deserted in the struggle by the two other patriarchs of Antioch and Alexandria, who would have been equally wounded by the usurpation of him of Constantinople, Gregory persevered, during all his pontifi- cate, 1 in his resistance to that wretched assumption, in which he perceived less an attempt upon the unity and authority of the universal Church, than an excess of pride on one side and adulation on the other, which disgusted his humble and generous soul. 2 " What ! " he wrote to the emperor, " St. Peter, who re- ceived the keys of heaven and earth, the power of binding and loosing, the charge and primacy of the whole Church, was never called universal apostle ; and yet my pious brother 1 The contest was renewed under Phocas. Neither the emperor nor the patriarch would yield. If Gregory did not obtain the victory, he at least paved the way for that of his successor Boniface III., under whom the emperor Phocas forbade the patriarch the use of the contested title ; but during the following reign, under Heraclius, it was resumed by the patri- arch Sergius. In return, the popes then resumed the right to confirm the patriarchs of Constantinople — a right from which the latter had been emancipated for a century, and which Photius did not succeed in over- throwing until three centuries later.— Baeonius, AnnaL, ad 606. Latj., p. 165. 2 " Quousque pestem universalis nominis ab ipsis etiam subdolis adula- torum labiis penitus abstulisset." — Joan. Diac, Vit., iii. c. 59. 30 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT John would name himself universal bishop. I must needs exclaim, O tempora ! mores ! All Europe is in the power of the Barbarians. The cities are overthrown, the castles are in ruins, the provinces are depopulated, the soil has no longer hands to cultivate it ; idolaters pursue the faithful even to death. And priests who should prostrate them- selves in the courts of the temple in dust and ashes, seek after titles of vanity ! " He took care to explain to the emperor that he did not defend his own cause, but that of the whole Church, which was scandalised by such an unheard-of pretension. He reminded him that Nestorius and Macedo- nius, both bishops of Constantinople, had both been heretics and heresiarchs. He added : " For me, I am the ser- vant of all the priests as long as they live in a manner becoming the priesthood : but if any one raises his head against God and against the laws of our fathers, I am con- fident that he shall not make me bow mine, even with the sword." x Gregory was so much the more bold in combating the dangerous vanity of the Byzantine patriarch, that he him- self had displayed on all occasions a sincere and practical humility. His vast correspondence and all the acts of his life furnish a thousand touching proofs of it. He had im- pressed the seal of this humility upon the papacy itself, by adopting, first of all the popes, in the preamble of his official documents, the fine title of Servant of the servants of God, which has become the distinctive title of his successors. He had expressly refused the same name of universal bishop or pope, which had been given him by the patriarch of Alex- andria. His magnanimous humility displays itself fully in 1 " Et vir sanctissimus consacerdos meus Joannes. . . . Exclamare com- pellor ac dicere : tempora ! O mores ! Ecce cuncta in Europae partibus. . . . Et tamen sacerdotes qui in pavimento et cinere flentes jacere debue- runt. . . . Numquid ego hac in re . . . propriam causam defendo. . . . Ego cunctorum sacerdotum servus sum. . . . Nam qui contra Dominum . . . suam cervicem erigit, . . . confido quia meam sibi nee cum gladiis flectet." — EpisL, v. 20. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 31 these noble words of his letter to this patriarch. " I desire to increase in virtue and not in words. I do not consider myself honoured in that which dishonours my brethren. It is the honour of the universal Church which honours me. It is the strength and greatness of my brethren in the epis- copate which does me honour. I feel myself truly honoured only when I see that no man refuses to another the honour due to him. Away with those words which inflate vanity and wound charity ! . . . The holy Council of Chalcedon and other Fathers have offered this title to my predecessors, but none of them has ever used it, that they might guard their own honour in the sight of God, by seeking here below the honour of all the priesthood." This weighty difference, another of which we shall speak regarding the prohibition addressed to soldiers to their be- coming monks, and especially that which arose between the pope and the emperor touching the irregular election of the metropolitan of Salona, contributed to render almost perma- nent the misunderstanding between them. That Eastern world which was so soon to become the prey of Islam, was obstinate in ignoring its best chance of salvation, in alienat- ing the nations and Churches of the West, and in weakening by a minute and vexatious despotism the Christian life which had blossomed with so much promise in its bosom. Gregory had to exercise an incessant vigilance, to prevent the immense army of lay officials, from the emperor down to the meanest agent of the treasury, from encroaching upon the rights and liberties of the Church, and especially from relaxing or attempting to break the ties of subordination which con- nected individual churches with the Holy See. And he had also to reconcile this permanent and universal resistance 1 " Ego non verbis quaere- prosperari, sed moribus ; nee honorem meum esse deputo in quo fratres meos honorem suum perdere cognosco. Meus namque honor est honor universalis Ecclesice. Meus honor est fratrum meorum solidus vigor. Turn ergo vere honoratus sum, cum singulis quibusque honor debitus non negatur. . . . Recedant verba quas vanitatem inflant, caritatem vulnerant." — Epist., viii. c. 30. 3 2 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT with the submission which he professed and practised, to the best of his power, towards the empire in temporal affairs. In claiming for the Church an almost absolute liberty and sovereignty in spiritual matters, he did not hesitate to declare himself the humble subject of Caesar. From thence came that singular medley of immovable resolution and humble protestations which appears in his correspondence with the Caesars. However, though he always spoke and often acted as a docile subject of the successors of Augustus and Con- stantino, they were not slow to understand that they had something else to deal with in this bishop, who was at once the direct successor of Peter, the patriarch of the entire West, and the greatest proprietor in Italy, and who had already occupied the place of mediator between the Barbarians and the Empire. We find this mixture of extreme humility and energetic resistance in another struggle, which the constant and natural concern of Gregory for the rights and interests of monastic life had led him into, in the beginning of his pontificate. The Emperor Maurice had published an edict which interdicted public functionaries and soldiers from entering either into the ranks of the clergy or into a monas- tery. Gregory approved the first clause of this law, which interdicted public functionaries from holding ecclesiastical offices : " for," said he, " these people prefer rather to change their occupation, than to leave the world." * But, always a monk in his heart, he protested against the measure rela- tive to monastic life, in a letter celebrated for its eloquence and ability, and which must not be omitted here. He begins by declaring that he speaks not as pope, but as an individual, the obliged friend of the emperor, which explains the humble character of certain passages ; but he soon rises to all the loftiness of spiritual power and the freedom of souls. " The man who fails to be sincere in what he says or 1 "Mutare saeculum, non relinquere." — Epist., iii. 65. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 33 does to the serene emperors 1 is responsible towards God. For myself, the unworthy servant of your piety, I speak neither as bishop nor as subject, but by the right which I find in my heart. 2 For, serene lord, you were my master before you became master of all. ... I confess to my masters that this law has filled me with terror, for it closes the way of heaven to many. . . . There are many who can lead a Christian life in the world. But there are also many who cannot be saved, but by forsaking all things. . . . " And who am I but dust, and a worm of the earth, who venture to speak thus to my masters ? 3 However, when I see this law interfere with God, the Master of the world, I cannot keep silence. For this power over the human race has been bestowed from on high upon my masters, that they might help those who would do well to open up the way to heaven, and make the earthly kingdom serve the heavenly. Yet here it is forbidden to him who has once been enrolled in the terrestrial army to enter, unless when an invalid or in retirement, into the service of our Lord. ... It is thus that Christ answers by me, the last of His servants and yours : 1 I have made thee, from a secretary, count of the guards ; from count, Cassar ; from Csesar, emperor ; if that was not enough, I have made thee also father of an emperor. I have put My priests under thy power, and thou withdrawest thy soldiers from My service ! ' 4 Sire, say to your servant what you can answer to Him who, at the day of judgment, shall speak to you thus. 5 " Perhaps it is supposed that none of these men are truly 1 He speaks in the plural, because Maurice had associated his son Theo- dosius in the imperial power in 591. s " Neque ut episcopus, neque ut servus jure reipublica?, sed jure privato loquor." 3 "Ego autem hasc dominis meis loquens, quid sum, nisi pulvis et vermis ? " 4 " Ego te de notario comitem excubitorum. . . . Sacerdotes meos tuas manui commisi." 5 " Responde, rogo, piissime domine, servo tuo, quid venienti e haac dicenti responsurus es ? " VOL. II. C 34 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT converted ; but I, your unworthy servant, have known many soldiers converted in my lifetime, who have, in the monas- teries, given an example of every virtue, and even worked miracles. Yet this law interdicts every similar conversion. Inquire, I beseech you, what emperor it was who made a similar law, and see whether it becomes you to imitate him. 1 And consider besides that men would be prevented from leaving the world at a time when the end of the world approaches. For the time is not distant when, amidst the burning of heaven and earth, in the universal conflagra- tion of the elements, surrounded by angels and archangels, thrones, dominions, and powers, the terrible Judge shall appear. When He would pardon all your sins, if He did not find this single law directed against Himself, what, I pray you, will be your excuse ? I conjure you by that terrible Judge, not to make your tears, your fasts, your many prayers, useless before God, but to soften or abrogate this law, for the army of my masters shall increase so much the more against the army of the enemy, as the army of God shall increase in prayer. " In submission, however, to your command, I have for- warded this same law into the different provinces, and be- cause it is not in accordance with the will of God Almighty, I warn you of it by this supplication. I have thus fulfilled my duty on both sides — have rendered obedience to the emperor, and have not been silent concerning that which seemed to me in opposition to God." Modest and humble as this letter was, he did not venture to send it to the emperor by his resident representative, but confided it to one of Maurice's physicians, who was a private friend of his own, that it might be presented privately, and at a favourable moment. The immediate effect of this pro- test is not known, but it was listened to, for a subsequent letter of the pope to the metropolitans of Italy and Illyria 1 He says in a subsequent letter that this was Julian the Apostate. 2 Epist. , hi. 65. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 3 5 enjoins them not to receive soldiers into monasteries till after a three years' novitiate, and adds, that the emperor consented to these conditions. 1 These perpetual contests with the Byzantine court may explain, without excusing, the conduct of Gregory at the death of the Emperor Maurice. This prince, infected, like all his predecessors, with a mania for interfering in ecclesi- astical affairs, and interfering with all the weight of absolute power, was very superior to most of them. Gregory him- self has more than once done justice to his faith and piety, to his zeal for the Church and respect for her canons. 2 He acknowledged that in his reign no heretic dared open his mouth. 3 Almost the only thing with which the emperor could be reproached, was his avarice. After twenty years of an undistinguished reign, he unfortunately abandoned twelve thousand captives of his army to the sword of the Avars, who massacred the whole on his refusal to ransom them. From this circumstance arose a military revolt, which placed Phocas upon the throne. This wretch not only murdered the Emperor Maurice, gouty, and incapable of defending himself, but also his six sons, whom he caused to be put to death under the eyes of their father, without even sparing the youngest, who was still at the breast, and whom his nurse would have saved by putting her own child in his place ; but Maurice, who would not have his child preserved at such a cost, disclosed that pious deception to the murderers. He died like a Christian hero, repeating the words of the psalm, " Thou art just, Lord, and Thy judgment is right." He had before entreated God to expiate his sins by a violent death in this world, that he might be spared from suffering in the other. This massacre did not satisfy Phocas, who sacrificed the empress and her three daughters, the brother of Maurice, and a multitude of others in his train. The monster then sent his own image and 1 Epist., viii. 5. 2 Ibid., v. 43, and xi. 25. 3 Ibid., x. 46. 36 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT that of his wife to Rome, where the senate and people re- ceived them with acclamation. Gregory unfortunately joined in these mean acclamations. He carried these images of his new masters, bathed in inno- cent blood, into the oratory of the Lateran palace. 1 After- wards he addressed extraordinary congratulations to Phocas, not in the surprise of the first moment, but seven months after the crime. 2 " God," said he, " the sovereign arbiter of the life of man, sometimes raises up one to punish the crimes of many, as we have experienced in our long affliction ; and sometimes to console the afflicted hearts of many, He raises another whose mercy fills them with joy, as we hope from your piety. Therefore we feel strengthened by the abun- dance of our joy, congratulating ourselves that your goodness has attained the imperial dignity. Let heaven and earth rejoice with us ! " 3 He also wrote to the new empress : " No tongue can express, nor mind conceive, the gratitude which we owe to God, that your Serenity has attained the empire, and that we are delivered from the hard burden we have so long endured, and to which has succeeded a gentle yoke which we can bear. Let choirs of angels and voices of men unite with us to thank the Creator ! " 4 It is true, that in this same letter to Phocas, and in a subsequent one, he points out to him the duties of his charge, exhorts him to amend the errors of past reigns, and supplicates him so to rule, that under him all may enjoy their possessions and his freedom in peace. " For," says he, " there is this difference between the barbarous kings and the emperors of the republic, that the former rule over slaves, and the latter over free 1 Joan. Diac, iv. 20. 2 JEpisL, xiii. 31. Data mense Junii, indictione vi. 3 "De qua exultationis abundantia roborari nos citius credimns, qui benignitatem vestrse pietatis ad imperiale fastigium pervenisse gaudemus. Lastentur coeli et exultet terra," &c. — Ibid. 4 " Qua? lingua loqui, quis animus cogitare sufScit quantas de serenitate vestri imperii omnipotent! Deo gratias debemus. . . . Reddatur ergo Creatori ab hymnodicis angelorum choris gloria in coelo." — Ibid., xiii. 39. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 37 men." l This was precisely the reverse of the truth : it was, besides, a melancholy and guilty homage rendered to a man who was to become one of the most odious tyrants of his age, and who had gained the empire by a crime without parallel even in the annals of that infamous history. This is the only stain upon the life of Gregory. We do not attempt either to conceal or excuse it. It can scarcely be explained by recalling all the vexations he had suffered from Maurice and his agents, annoyances of which he always complained energetically, though he did not fail to do justice to the undeniable piety of the old emperor, 2 who, like all his predecessors, imagined himself entitled to judge and direct the affairs of the Church, but was in no respect a persecutor. Perhaps, too, Gregory adopted this means to secure the help which he implored from Phocas against the new incursions of the Lombards, 3 or to mollify beforehand the already threatening intentions of the tyrant. 4 We have seen that he mingled advice and indirect lessons with his congratu- lations. It must also be remembered that these flatteries, which we find so repugnant from the pen of our holy and great pope, were in some sort the official language of those times ; they resulted from the general debasement of public manners, and from the tone of the language invariably used then at each change of reign. His motives were undoubtedly pure. Notwithstanding, a stain remains upon his memory, and a shadow upon the history of the Church, which is so consoling and full of light in this age of storms and dark- 1 " Reformetur jam singulis sub jugo imperii pii libertas sua. Hoc namque inter reges gentium et imperatores reipublicse distat, quod reges gentium domini servorum sunt, imperatores vero reipublicas domini libe- rorum." — Epist., xii. 31. 2 Compare Epist., v. 43, to the patriarchs of Alexandria and Antioch, and xi. 25, to Maximus of Salona, where he says expressly of Maurice, " Omnibus notum est piissimos dominos disciplinam servare, et in causis sacerdotalibus non miscere." 3 Compare Epist., xiii. 38. 4 "His laudibus novos principes demulcebat, . . . quia non eos ad tyrannidem venturos esse putabat." — Joan. Diac, iv. 23. - - 38 ST. GREGORY THE GREAT uess. But among the greatest and holiest of mortals, virtue, like human wisdom, always falls short in some respect. Gregory, who died sixteen months after the advent of Phocas, had no time either to expiate or repair that weak- ness. No doubt he would have done it, if occasion had been given him. His life demonstrated nothing more clearly than his boldness in presence of danger, and his immovable per- severance in the pursuit of right and truth, whenever he perceived them. All his career justifies the noble words which he wrote to his apocrisarius or nuncio at Constanti- nople : " You ought to know how I feel, I who have resolved to die rather than see the chair of St. Peter degenerate in my lifetime. You know my disposition ; I bear long, but when I have once resolved to endure no longer, I face all dangers with joy." 1 Save in the deplorable instance which we have pointed out, he always showed himself faithful to the instructions which he gave to an Illyrian bishop who lamented over the iniquity of the imperial judges : " Your duty is to assist for the cause of the poor and oppressed. If you do not succeed, God will remember the intention ; seek above all things to gain Him who reads hearts. As for human terrors and favours, they are but a smoke which vanishes before the lightest breath. Be assured that it is impossible to please God and the wicked at the same time ; consider yourself most agreeable to God when you perceive yourself odious to perverse men. However, even in defending the poor, be grave and moderate." But to perceive in all their purity the greatness of his 1 " Mores meos bene cognitos habes, quia dm porto. Sed, si semel deliberavero non portare, contra pericula lastus vado." — Epist., iv. 47. Tbe point in question was the affair of Maximus of Salona : the letter is addressed to Sabinian, who was afterwards his successor. 2 " Fraternitas tua opponere se pro pauperibus, pro oppressis debet. In omni quod agis inspectorem cordis appete habere placatum. . . . Nam humani terrores et gratia fumo sunt similes, qui leni aura raptus evanescit. Hoc certissime scito quod placere Deo sine pravis hominibus displicere nullus potest. . . . Ipsa tamen defensio pauperum moderata et gravis sit." — Epist., x. 35. ST. GREGORY THE GREAT 39 soul and the influence of his genius upon the doctrines of the Church, it is necessary to turn from that Lower Empire which was condemned to irremediable decay, and where the seeds of schism budded in the bosom of abject ser- vitude. Life and honour were elsewhere. Gregory was aware of it. He did not content himself with the imposing position of defender of Rome, protector of Italy, and mediator between the Greeks and Lombards. He did more. In turning towards the Germanic nations, he showed the way by which the Eoman Church, and with her the mind and future fate of the West, could be emancipated from the dishonouring yoke of Byzantium. The Roman empire existed no longer in its first form. That climax of disgrace had come to an end. The civilised world was escaping from that absolute dominion exercised by monsters or adventurers, which has been admired in our own days by some base souls worthy of having lived under Caracalla or Arcadius. The human race had at last perceived its own shame. The yoke of a free nation, how- ever cruel and iniquitous, may be borne without blushing ; but to obey a nation itself enslaved by the most repellent despotism, is to ask too much of human baseness. The whole world was then in insurrection against Rome, and the insurrection had everywhere triumphed. It was necessary that the victorious Barbarians, and those countries which had been revivified by the rude experience of conquest, should be kept from identifying in a common reprobation the odious phantom of old imperial Rome, and that young Church, the sovereign see of which God, by a secret miracle of His providence, had established in the very centre of the empire which had persecuted her so cruelly, which she had in vain attempted to regenerate after having converted it, but which she was shortly to eclipse and replace in the world. It was necessary to keep Constantinople from imagining itself the 4