75/m 581 MCrNRLF *B 2TD 55t STEIN'S SUMMARY OF TM MAllOT HERODOTUS, BOSTON: PUBLISH p:i) by ginn, heath, & CO. 188 2. Copyright, 1880. By JOHN WILLIAMS WHITE IN MEMORfAM t^V\< Ginn <& Heath. J. /S. Cushing, Printer, Boston. STEIN'S SUMMAUY DIALECT OF HERODOTUS. ryiHE euphonic and inflexional peculiarities which distin- 1 -^ guish the language of Herodotus from Attic Greek are often briefl}^ called his "dialect." Both in these and in his vocabulary and syntax he generally agrees with the language of the Ionic historians and philosophers, so far as we can judge from the fragments of their works, which are both scanty and corrupt. His history, therefore, has alwa3's been reckoned among the models of Ionic prose. The ancients, however, gave it this rank rather on account of its excellent stj'le than because of its pure Ionic form. Exact grammarians, indeed, like ApoUonius Dyscolus, avoided nam- ing him with writers like Pherecjxles, Hecataeus, or Democri- tus, as an authority for Ionic forms ; and even the rhetoricians, who paid more regard to vocabulary and expression, regarded his language as "mixed Ionic." And it is true not only that he has avoided certain clearl}' established lonicisms, but also that he has admitted here and there no inconsiderable n um- ^ b er of forms peculiar to ot her dialects. The ^relation of the Ionic dialect in its earlier and purer 2 form to the other dialects is to us as obscure and uncertain a matter as the earher history of the Ionic race. In earlier times 930619 2 HERODOTUS. the Greek grammarians distinguished between an older Ionic of Homey and a luew ijdnic hf the writers of the fifth and sixth centuries .B-C. ..lU^t. this , cannot be historicallj- attested or estkblist^ied'';' it -q(riv VIII. 49 (on account of the play on 'A4>sTai), verbs (see 80): e.g. lQv\s.ir\(ri, Qv[in\T^piov, Oerjo-ofxcu 0TjTTJs Ge'T]Tpov, dirc'SpTi. C. for d of the stem : -qifp, KKpT)fj.a(, aKprjTos KpTj-rrfp, KaTT]7dTa vavT]-ycs, VcTivitjs, vtjo's, irpTJo-a-o), TrpT]vs, ptlX^^I' P^XOS cr4>pTi'yis, Tprjxvs, ^pT]rpr\, Eu4)pT|- TT\s, pTJilj 2upT]Kov(rai SvpTiKoVios, ^"A^r^v, *AKap- vi]V (still 'AKapvaviT]), 'Evi-^yss (but rivSdvs), Owpul, tpt]| (= U'pa|), oii]Kitiv, dvi-qpo's, ircpTjOe, 6 HEI^ODOTUS. TpiKdpT]vos (but Kapa8cKeft)), <}>\vr]peiv, 8it[kovos 8lT]K0VelV, 5LT]K0'cn.Ol, Tplr^KOVTtt Tpn]KOCriOl rplT^KOlS. yiver]koyi(>), cripT]opos, o-KiT]Tpo(j5, Ti|jiT]'yvi5Tis (but IGa-yevrls), XoxiTyo's- d. in suffixes : 'lo-Tpit^vo's 2ap8iT]vo's, 'AXiKapvqo-o-o's Ilapviioro-o's, KpT](rT<)viTJTT]s 2TrapTirjTT]s etc. (but the Doric Avixavdrai 'Ovedrai 'Ydrai Xoipcdrai). 13 r\ for a : irpv'iJLVT], irpwpTi, 2|xvpvT], o-|xvpvT], in substantives in -cia (from adjectives in -tjs), sucli as oXtjOcitj, da-Qivdt], do-a- XcCt], v^uiTj, and those in -oia (from adjectives in -oos), such as uvoiT] iTpovoit] crvvvoir\ (but 8idvoia), aarXoit], dfjioxpoti], iraXippoiT], finally in tpeirj (from ipev's, but Pao-iXeia) and the four proper names 'la-rialt] MT]8eii] for ao and aco : Xcws, MeveXcws (still Mcvc'Xaos IV. 169, VII. 169) etc., Aetov8r,s etc. (but also Aao8a;xa9, cf. 6), 'AXkuc'wv, 'A[jk(}>idp6cos, IIoo-i8a)v, oircW. In the present and imperfect, Giiconai occurs in place of OcoCofxai. 16 for r\ : ia-a-oj} (-- i]TTaa>, but alwaj^s t|o-o-v), |1'v for jiTi'v in the combinations -^ [jic'v, y (xe'v, ov }jlv ovSe (see Stein on II. 29, 1). ^ 17 for o : TrcvniKo'vTcpos. 18 for 61 : KvTTgpos, KpeVo-wv }i(t,icrPaT'a) d;i.i for and a : ir\ww (but much ofteuer irXeo)), ta) (but also 27 (I) for av: 8ia{j>ci>av(ris) , Tpwjjia. 28 0) for ot] : o^SwKovTa. On the contrary, it is more accurate to refer 29 dXXo-yvwcras evvwras evvcvwKacrt eve'vwTo to the simple stem vo- ("yvo-) than to vo-; in like manner cpoxra i^wrQr\v pePoDlxc'vos should be referred to the stem Po- and not to poa-. (ePwGcov epweiio-av etc. from ^or\Q4(o, which formerly occurred in certain places, have now been proved to be corrupt.) v)i,d^a), ({accdvtov XKvcrTiKdv does not occur. Final v is wanting also in cvcpOc 36 ireptiOe dirio-0 irpoVOc efjiirpoo-Oe virp0 KarvircpGc, in which the suffix has almost wholly lost its sense of place ; elsewhere always -0v (ttpXTi^sv evOev O-o)0v etc.). Final or is wanting in dxpt K-cxP'- ovtw, but occurs in drpcjias, Terpd- 37 Kis, iroXXaKis etc. Hiatus also in the middle of a word is much less avoided than in 38 Attic Greek. Therefore, both in inflexion (see below) and in the formation of words, two successive vowels or a vowel and a diph- thong which in Attic Greek would be united often remain uncon- tracted. 8 HERODOTUS. 39 The following cases of this occur : ac : dcKwv (but dpYo's) , dcGXos deOXew etc. aei : diKTJs, dcCSo) deicrfjia, deipd). 6a: cap, eircdv (but always t|V aud eTri8dv). : p'0pov. 61 : Bopuo-0ViTai. o : in substantives and adjectives of the second declension in -cos -60V, such as xpv'o-os 00-T0V. 06: Trpoe'xw etc., dYaOoep-yo's dYaOoepYiT) 8i]|xiop7o's XuKiocpYt^s (but ipovpyit] KaKOvp-yos KpOup"yT]8o'v ^uXovp-ye'eiv vTroupYc'civ AuKovp- yos, kXtipovxos irarpoilxos iroXiovxos) , in substantives and adjectives in -o'cis -o'eo-o-a, such as (leXiro'cis Al-yipo'eco-a (but Olvovo-o-ai) . oi : ois (but oteos) , oioto's, KaTaTrpoL|o-0ai. oo: in substantives and adjectives of the second declension in -oos, such as irXo'os 6vvoos SnrXo'os (but SmtXti). 40 In like manner : di: *A8tjs, dicnroi. Tji: 8T]io'a), -qiGcoi, Xtiio-tt]S, 'M.r]io)v, \pfi]ll'8iov, wo'v). 41 In like manner, but with the first vowel lengthened : Til (from di) : pTji^, priiKt], IIpovTiiT] (I. 92, elsewhere and oftener npovaiTi), irpovrjiov, piiiSios, pao-vSrjios. r]i (from ei) : kXtiiw KXiii8s, \t\ir\, Xtjitov, in substantives in -da derived from verbs in -cvw, such as pao-iXT]iii 0paTrTjiT] oTpaTTiiT], in adjectives in -ctos, such as dv8pT]ios dxpTJios PopTJios SovXtJios (but also 8ovXios) etc. (but 0eios Xcios), 4>oiviKT]ios Ktjios (from Kc'ws like Tifios from Tews) Ka8Hniios (in KaSurjia ypdfip.aTa V. 59, but Ka8(jLeioi and the proverbial Ka8}iCT] vIkh] like Ap-yctos *HXios) etc., in neuters in -eiov, such as dvYTJiov dpt- orrrjiov ep-yoX-rjiov ipiiiov (lavTrjiov etc. (but Sevrcpeia). iroXiTJTTis for ttoXCttis also belongs here (but this form does not occur in compounds, such as 'HXioiroXiTai KoXXiiroXiTai) . Inflexion. 42 The dual number is entirely want ing. Successive vowels that in Attic"^reeF would be unite(L.generally remain uncontracted. SUMMAKY OF DIALECT. First Declension. In the terminations of the singular a becomes r\ : tro^iry, i(r\vpr[, 43 [jLiTls. (For exceptions, see 6 above.) Nominatives in -tjs form the genitive singular in : vTjviT]s 44 vfrjvUw, but those in -c'tis not in -eew but in e'w : popcTjs popew, 'EpntTjs 'p)ji(a. In the accusative singular the two substantives oKivaKi]? Seo-iroTTis 45 and many proper names in -t]s end sometimes in -t]v and sometimes in -ca, as, e.g. Fv'yiiv and Fvyca. The genitive plural ends in -eW : yy(a^n\ yya^iav, iroXiTfrrjs ttoXitj- 46 Ta)v. This is true also of the feminine of all adjectives (with the exception of those of two terminations in -os -ov), numerals, pro- nouns, and participles, whether they have the same form as tlie masculine or not : KcXaivcW, v\|;t]XW, ctrxare'tov, dvxicwv, 8it]koo-ic'(ov, iroXXcwv, dXXc'wv, d\\T]Xe'v, v}iTpECdv, avre'cov, tovtc'cdv, okoo-c'wv, ov(r6(uv, apirao-Gcwrc'wv, irpoKcificvewv, Tcurcrop.6Vv. Barytones shorten -66'wv into -wv: O-qXewv, xpvo-c'wv, 'HpaKXc'cov, MoXe'wv, crvKc'tov, ^vieW. The dative plural ends in -tjo-u 47 Second Declension. The dative plural ends in -own. 48 Proper names like M6veXws *Aji<|)idp6cos and Xcws 8i}jiviS, but also Tv4>v, accusative Tuwva. Kptvea (from Kptvos), but also Kptva (from Kptvov). Similarly Se'vSpos Se'vSpeos, but also Se'vSpcov SevSpe'ou and Sc'vSpov 8e'v8pou. vXc| vXaKOs 4>vXdKou. The adjective o-ws has in the neuter c-o'ov, and in the plural os has the superlative d(Jiop(|)VTaTcs; SUMMARY OF DIALECT 11 raxv's has both rax^Tcpov and Gdtro-ov. To iroXXo's (= Attic iroXvs) belong the following comparative forms : irXeW, neuter irXe'ov and irXcvv, irXcvvos, irXe'ovt, irXeova irXew irXcvva, irXcvvcs (irXe'ovs II. 8), irXeovcov irXevvwv, irXeocri, irXevvas, and the adverb irXeo'vws. Numerals. 8vo : gen. 8uo and 8uc3v, dat. 8v'o and 8uoi8ei (= avroiwi) A. i^fJieas vjie'as o-e'as cr4>6'a " (ras o-<|>a. Reflexives. p.wi>Tov, o-vtov, cwvtov etc. (see 33 above). 62 Demonstratives. oSe i^'Sc in the dat. plur. has Toti and dvd are not included in the list just given because they do not occur before rela- tives in Herodotus. The forms of the relative that begin with a 12 HERODOTUS. vowel occur also in the temporal phrases ev w 'while', e's 6' (i ('anchor') dpiii'tw dprdtw ot|>Xov dvoi^w (but aviioyis I- 187) and all the rest that begin with oi. Besides these, some that occur but once each : dXv- KTa^ov djxavptoGt] dvcdYe Karap-yupwiie'vovs TrpoaiSearo (?) c^cto \ivvov ^p.iroXii|iVCi)V 6 eXevOepoo} lirci-yojiai eiritrrafiai ep'Y'^' ^^^ dvexcjiat (T^V, aiveat ^T]{jLt(da-eai, eSe'^ao, el'peo e-ye'veo, ireiOeo (but -ev sometimes occurs in place of -eo, especially in the imperative : etXev -irpoo-Se'Kev irvOev); -e'co and -e'a)|xev -e'oxrt in the aor. subj. pass. : diratpeOe'co eVtrw- fle'cojiev (}>ave'a)aTat KaTerTpd'vJ)aTo, dva}i,ep.ixaTat eTerdxaTo. The aspiration is wanting only in tlie forms belonging to iKveofjiat, such as diriKarat diriKaro. There are even three denominative verbs in -il -dw -dw. 82 Verbs in -e'o) generally remain uncontracted : Troic'to irou'eis iroUs iroieT). But iQr\iiTo, riOei (see 87) are exceptions, and Sei eSei Sciv and 8i e'Sec Se'eiv vary. Besides this, the diphthong v often occurs here also in place of o: iroicvtri vocvvres Xuirevo-a irowtJo-i (partic.) irroUvv cKoXciJvTo irpoOujievfie'vov etc. The imperat. ending e'co (v) is short- ened to -o: alreo, <|>oPo (cf. 46). The pres. of the optat. act. has the ending -oi|ii: iroicoiixi. The only exception is iroioiriv VI. 35 (?). 83 Polysyllabic verbs in -dw can, in the Ionic as in the Doric dialect, assume the inflexion of verbs in -e'w, and have cw cou co in place of aco aov ao. The extent of this interchange, which may have been greater at an earlier period of the language (cf. the Homeric t|vtov, Hvoivov), has become very uncertain in the course of the transmis- sion of the text. The principle is exemplified now in only a few verbs : clpwrdv, Kojidv, |XTixa.vdo-6ai (but imperf. e|XT]xavw and imperat. (jiT)xavt3), dpdv (but imperf. poiTdv; and even in these the change is not made in the dat. plur. of the partic. (cipwTtSo-i). Add to these the isolated forms ciriTip-eW, roXjitw, KaTaixap-yc'tov, o-Ta0(jLo'(ivoi, TeXevTcovras. co and iov sometimes be- come iv : dpfoTivv dvievvTai. But xpdo-0ai has everywhere cw for co : Xpewfxai cxpcwvTo xP^^JJ-^^os (except imperat. xpio I. 155, and cf. Xpcdv). Similarly xpra from xpdv VII, 111. 84 Verbs in -dw retain everywhere, as in Attic Greek, the long a arising from contraction, which elsewhere in the Ionic dialect be- comes Tj : oiTdv. Besides this, the following cases, which are exceptions to the practice even in Attic Greek: xpdv Xpdo-Gai Kvdv trp-dTai (but 8ii|/t)v tiiv). The pres. optat. ends in -w'tjv (pass. -w'|jn]v) : evopwT), vikwev, tijicoto. SUMMARY OF DIALECT. 15 Verbs in -ow suffer contraction throughout, as in Attic Greek. 85 But except in the influ. tv often occurs in place of ov: tSiKaiou eXEvOepovvTO IkevQ^povv, eSiKaiev dvSpevffcevw. Verbs in |ii. Besides the inflexional forms peculiar to these verbs, there are 86 others, mainly from presents in -tot -ctw -o'w, some of which occur oftener than the -fii forms. Ti0t]jj.t: Ti0i (Ti0r]pai 0'VTai, orTewpcv, ^Ewpcv. lpi, ts (irepi'eis), elpe'v, subj. ew gs "n wo-t, optat. tT]