Qia \ Sketct)esg/^ E a r lyAme r ican Arcl)itecture O.I^Eggers Witn a Series of descriptive monograpns by WILLIAM H. CROCKER Editor or The American Architect THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT 243 W. 39 Street. New York 1922 Copyright ig22 by The Architectural and Building Press, Inc. 101 Foreword IN presenting- the series of original sketches and tlie accompanying descriptive monographs, wliich at reguhir intervals appeared in Thk American Architect, it will not be necessarj^ to comment further on their artistic excellence or tlie high reputation of the artist who sketched these many exam])les of early American architecture. Heretofore there have never been adequately shown or grouped in one volume, the many buildings and details, historically interesting and architectui-ally good, that ai-e to be found in the Colonial towns adjacent to the Eastern cities in the United States. A rather indif- ferent and poorly executed lot of postcards, illustrating some of tliese buildings, but lacking any description, issued by various communities, represents all that has been jniblished of many of the subjects shown. It was with the two-fold ])uri)ose of dignifying the work of the early builder-architects and furnishing the best possible examples of pencil rendering, that the jniblishers of The American Architect set about the preparation of the present series. Since the advent of the hand camera too little attention has been given by architects and draftsmen to sketching in the field. It is believed the sketches shown in this collection constitute an eloquent appeal for a revival of interest in this phase of architectural education. MONOGRAPHS DESCRIPTIVE OF A SERIES OF SKETCHES BY OTTO R. EGGERS OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE ST. PAUL'S CHAPEL, NEW YOKK McBean, Architect WllEjST, in 17(34, this venerable chapel of Ti'iuity Parish was begun, it was placed to face the river whose banks at that time were many hundred feet nearer to the church than they are today. Its eastern end was close to what is now known as Bruadway and owing to the pedi- mented portico that adorns it, is often mistakenly believed to be the front of the church. One McBean was the architect. It is gleaned from the records of the church that, owing to slow means of transportation of material and a scarcity of competent labor, this chapel was three years under construction. It has been claimed that Mc- Bean was at one time a pupil of Giibbs of London and this claim is bolstered by the fact that this church strongly resembles St. Martin's-in-the-Field in London, which was designed by Gibbs. The fact remains that "old St. Paul's," as it is affectionately called by New Yorkers, is one of the most satis- factory examples of our extant Coloilial ecclesias- tical architecture. It stands in the center of its churchyard on the block bounded by Vesey, Fulton, Broadway and Church streets and is today, as for more than a centviry past, a spot hallowed by every association, religious and civic, that is part of the heritage of every New Yorker. Its interior pre- serves all of the aspects of its English origin even to the three ostrich plumes (the crest of the Prince of Wales) that surmount the canopy over the altar. Here Washington came after his inaugin-atiou as President of the United States to attend the solemn service that formed a part of his inaugura- tion ceremony. The pew in which he sat has been kept exactly as it was at that time. One may judge the intluence of the (piiet digni- ty of this church if on any noonday he will visit it. Either within the dimly lighted interior, or the steps of its front or western entrance, or along the pleasant paths of the graveyard, there will be seen many office workers in tiie neighbor- hood. Here they daily seek for an all too brief spell the quietness and rest that such a sanctuary will afford. On the wall of the eastern or Broadway end of the church there is a wall monument placed there as a record to the memory of General Richard Montgomery who lies buried in the churchyard. DOORWAY OF A HOUSE ON WASHING- TON SQUARE NORTH, NEW YORK /^NE of the most interesting periods of the ^^ ai'chitectural development of New York City is that called by architectural writers as of the Greek Revival. Men of large means and of much culture who located their homes in the then aris- tocratic Washington Square section, which in- cluded lower Fifth avenue, readily availed of the suggestion that their houses be designed after these classic and retined motives. The portico illus- trated is of the house standing on the northwest corner of Fifth avenue and Washington Square North and is typical of the majority of the houses in its neighborhood. Mr. Eggers has with charac- teristic skill retained in his sketch all the beauty of proportion and classical adaptation of this en- trance detail. Of the various well known archi- tects that lived and worked during the early thirties, Robert Mills is on good authority be- lieved to be the man who first designed in the style now known as "the Greek Revival." The late Montgomery Schuyler, in a series of articles contrilnited to The American Architect in 1910 expressed the conviction that it was largely through the examples of Robert Mills that this dignified method of architectural expression found favor not only in the domestic architecture of all of our then large cities, but was also plainly shown in all of the important work on which ]\Iills was engaged. Undoubtedly good architecture is influential in retting a good example wherever it is successfully grouped. In spite of the many vicissitudes through which the Washington Square section has passed, the northern boundary of the "Square" yet presents a quiet dignity, a staid respectability, even though its neighboring boundaries on the south and east and west have long since lost all architectural colierence. The well appointed phaeton with two liveried men on the box no longer waits in front of these houses. Where once the future aristocrats played in the Square under the watchful eye of nurses and grooms, the "Vil- lagers" (M)ngrcgate under the shadows of the Wash- ington Arch or overspread the walks and lawns to listen to the miisic of the city band. And these stately old houses, closely shuttered, sit in all their isolation of a past splendor ealmly awaiting SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE tlie (lay wheii the wreckers tor speculative builil iiij; interests will fall nimn tlieiii and raze tlieiii to the frri'Uiiil. KAKLV IlKMK t)F COLON K I, VAX VUKDKMMlCtill. NO. 7 SI'ATK STKKKT. M:\V V(iKI\ THIS tine exanijile nt' areliitccturc in New Viirk was erit-teil about tlie year IMio. It was then considered one of the bi'st mansions of the bwalitv. It fronts ou Bowling CJreen, and stands today as it did then, an example of the tjuiet dignity of well considered design. And, while the rai)id niareh of timi' has served entirely to change the character of the buildings which sur- round this house, there are yet unspoiled those elements of architectural excellence that are so well accented by Air. Kggers' pencil. Today the hon.i H>.'5!>, iIk' frwiiuii of Xcwtowii, Conn., now rallril lliiitt'iinl, met uml inl«>iitcreserved ti> lis so many splendid examples of our Colonial hnilding. The old towni hall at Hartford was built as a stat(> house in ITOti. Its classic lines and correct pro- portions are the pritle of the citizens of Hartford and the dclifrht of those who have heeu so for- tunate as to visit that city. So carefully have all the various details of this tiiu- old huildiiifr hcen preserved, so reverentially have its restorers j)roceeded with their work, thai the building may today be viewed almost exactly as it stood 12.t years ago. Who designed this tine old building we d»ew York as a historical museum and park. STHKKT KKIIMJK. HARTFORD, C'ON.X. TJIK master builders, during the Colonial period, were a conscientious lot of men. Evervthing they did received the same careful stiulv. the same painstaking care in the working- out of every essential thing to create a proper result. This statement finds imiof in tiie design of the bridges thev erected, and the one chosen as the subject of Mr. Eggers' .sketch is a fine example. ilany of the.-c early bridges are models of good masonry design. Their rugged surfaces after centuries of exposure have taken on a very fine "patina" that delights the eye of the artist. To add to the picturesque effect there is often a back- ground of foliage that at jjlaces trail.-- on the water's stirface in the summer days or in winter gives a delicate framing for the trac<'rv of trees aiul shrubs. When carefully designed, an old bridge will have to architects the same artistic appeal as old houses. Their study, and the setting forth of their well considered outliiu's as a means of grai>li ic ]preservation is therefore very much worth while. T HOUSE IN LTTOHFIELI), CONN., BFILT m 1771 HE history of Litchfiel.l is interwoven in the most interesting way with the early period of New E^ngland. It has been the home of many illustrious men and women and presei-ves today all the traditions that are so dear to the dwellers in these rural communities. Settled in 1720, it was duriiig the Revolutionary War used a- a base of supplies l>y the Continental Army. It was to Litchfield in 177fi that the statue of George III. which, on Ttdy 0. was thrown from its pedestal on the Rowling Green in Xew ^^ork. was sent. There i' was cast into bullets by the women. Jurists, statesmen and writers of nati(mal fame have made their homes in this quaint New England village. All the traditions of good arcliilecture and those elements of retinenu'ut that marked our (Jolonial [leriod have Ix'en carefully preservetl. The house that Mr. Eggei's has chosen as the .-.idijeci of his sketch is exactly typical of many othei's that face the elm embowered roadways. Sit- ting close to the sidewalk these houses present a n<'igliborly and a most human aspect. Their snow white walls are relieved by the green shutters while the noonday sun casts the shadows of the branching boughs and the leaves of the trees that stand as sentinels. Isverv aspect of this old bouse is one of refine- ment, of the highe. t develo])ment of domesticity. One ceases to wonder that the New Knglaml states have from their very beginning sent to the service of the country in every imi)oi-tant station sturdy men and women who, with sound minds in sound bodies, have labored to build up this country's greatness. Nor will an\' one be able successfully to disprove that long residence in a home so archi- te<-turally good will do naught iiut add to mental and moral development. Such restoration as found necessary to kee|) tlii- hou.se in good repair and fit for occu])ancy has been skilfully and reverently c(uiclucted under the sn]>ervision of .\yniar Endiuvv 11. architect. MOUNT VERNON, VA., THE HOME AND BURIAL PLACE OF GEORGE WASH- INGTON. DETAIL OF ENTRANCE AN 1) COLONN A I)E C( )N NECT- TNG KITCHEN ON the right bank of the Pofoinac, in Fair- fax County. Va., fifteen miles from Wash- iiiiiton. I). C.. is ^[onnt Vernon, the one time home and final Imrial i)lace of George Washing- lui. This stately house, with the ground that -nrronnds it. is typically an estate of a well-to-do geutlenutn id' our early colonial period. The house, beautifully situated on an eminence, com- nnmds a long view of the river. It was built in 174?) by Lawrence Washington, an older brother of (ieorge. and was called .Mount Vernon after .Vdiniral Vernon, under whom Lawrence Wash- iniitiin served in the British Navy. .\ house so well known and so reverently re garded liy all ]iatriotic Americans will need no fui'ther description. The motive selectecl by ^Ir. Elggers for the present sketch shows the entrance front as the visitor approaches the house from the public highway. The culinMiade ciiniu-:-ts the main luiilding with tb(> kitchen, a detached building, a portion of which is shown on the extreme right 10 SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE of the sketch. Pashiiug through the coh)Uuade ami kitchen, the visitor emerges on a short lane, bordered on eitlicr side bv the many dependent buihlings that were necessary in the domestic ad- ministration of so large an estate. There are coach houses, spinning houses, harness shops, a bakery and all of the many rooms and detached buildings that mach; Iiousekeeping in early colonial times an earnestly studied occujjation. Further removed were grouped the cabins, in which were lodged the slaves. Every aspect of Mount Vernon siiggests culture. The architec- ture of the house and all the buildings that sur- nmnd it accents the refinement of style that char- acterized the Georgian Period. THE OLD DANIEL LAKE TIOUSE, STATEiV ISLAND, NEW YORK WHEN in the early part of tlie seventeenth century, the Dutch settled on Manhattan Island, they soon began the preparation for the colonization of the valley of the Hudson River. It is in this district which also includes Staten Island in New York Harbor, that there are to be found lUiiny examples of gambrel roofed houses, the ju'csent illustration being typical. The heavy walls of these houses were construct- ed of stone and were Usually pointed up with white mortar. The roofs were low and ()f moder- ate 2)itch for about ten feet both ways from the ridge. From this point the angle was sharper to near the caves, where it ciirved gracefully out- ward, extending from fmir to six feet. This broad expanse of roof surface nmde the u]>per stories of the house imcomfortably hot in summer and eijual- ly uncomfortable during the rigorous winters. To overcome these \uulesirable conditions, liny was often placed between the rafters, wliicli im doubt acted in a measure as a non-conductor. It is in- teresting to note the gradual development of the overhanging roof in the architecture of modern suburban houses, where porches are ]daiined be- neath it. The gambrel roof as a rule is the dominatini;' feature in correctly assigning the Dutch Colonial. In tracing the origin of the name, iiand)rel, we have for anthoritv Oliver Wendell Holmes, who in his "The Autocrat of the Breakfa^^t Table," writes : "Know old Camliridge. Hope you do. "Born there? Dnn't say so? I was, too. "Bnni ill a house with a gambrel roof — "Standing still, if you must have proof. "Gambrel? Gambrel? Let me beg "You'll look at a horse's hinder leg. "First great angle above the hoof — "That's the gambrel, hence gambrel-roof." ON THE GRKKX, PLYMOUTH, CONN. RURAL New England abounds in jiicturescpie small towns, all laid out with orderly care. Each has its spacious common, or city park bordered on four sides by stately elms, through the dense foliage of which may be seen well de- signed white houses with green shutters. In these white houses, in many instances, there have lived, from the time of earliest settlement, families whose members have tigaired in all the towm's ac- tivities. As a rule one side of the Commons was set apart as location for the meeting house, the town hall, the school and other village buildings. Mr. Eggers has sketched with his usual tine jierception of the architectural essentials, that sec- tion of the village green at Plymouth set apart for the church, with its stately colonnade and the adjacent school house. ^lore and more each year do these tine old New England villages attract a class of people who best appreciate the (|uiet rest- fulness that residence in them affords. And it is good to know that these new residents soon im- bibe the same reverential attitude toward the traditions of the place that form a religious part of the evciyday life of the older inhaliitants. The commercialism of a period that until re- cently menaced the safety of these old towns and their locallv historic buildings is now giving place to a feeling of deep respect. The evidence is to be found in the solicitoiis care of these old structures and a correct ^jrotective attitude toward them. DETAIL OF A HOUSE IN LUrCHFIELD, CONN. Till*', c-arjicnter-architects of the late eight- eenth and early nineteenth centuries woyp very often men of ninch refinement of mind and undoubtedly the most skilful of craftsmen. "While the dominating infiuences which controlled their work were those gained through knowledge of earlier English exam]iles, they, it would appear, combined with such knowledge a cleverness of adaptation that stamped a certain originality on their own work. The present illustration is a good exam])le in point. Mr. Eggers has sketched this most interest- ing "bit" with his usual keen perception of archi- tectural significance. It is a most interesting variation of an often-seen motive of design. The sense of domestic seclusion conveyed by this sketch is perfect. It siiggests the type of house affected by the upper middle class during the early part of the nineteenth century. There can be no doubt but that houses of this character 11 SKLICHKS OF liARLV AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE stiiiiulati'd lii'ttt-r ways ni' liviiif; aiul liifrliiT iilcals of cMtiziiisliip. At'tiT tlio Civil War lluTt- was iiiuliiulitiillv a iltvadciwc of our tloinestii- types of ari'lntoctuit' wliicli contiimcd for many years. IJiit today Wf may take comfort in llie fat-t tlnit tlie d<'v<'lo]>mciit of ilic <'onntry house. h\ arclii- tivts in iIh' I Hired States, is reaeliinjr the highest dignity ami ex( rtin^ tlie same, influence as iii(l tliose of tile perioil rrjiresciitod in the |iresciit sketch. (..MKW.W TO THOMAS (X)\V1,KS llOlSiO, i-ar.mix(;ton, coxn. Till-! Thciiiias ("owJes place at l-"aiiiiinjrl"ii, Connecticut, was ])rol)alily huilt liy .Imlah Woodruff, wlio in his day was the leadinii Iniilder in western Connecticut. (ieorge Clarence Gardner, in an article in Thi> Georfrian Period, on "The .Men Who Designed the Old Colonial P.uildings," states: "Strictly .'ijeakinf;-. up to the be}iiiiiiinlaiis and elevations of liiiildiiii;s wire ])rep:iicd and drawn for the distinct ])iirpose of either iiiiitatiuf; or improvinji' on Miiiilish inndcls and the men who did this may be divided into two types, the car- penter-architect and the amateur architect." It is to the former class that W^oodruff undoubt- edly belonirecl, and tbat he worked with skill and huilt hone, ily is shown in his excellent works tiiroufrhout the theatre of his well directed activi ties. The irate to the riicinia> ( 'owlcs house in Farm- in^rton, reveals in all its feattires the same ele- ments of good design as i]<:c< the liciuse to which it is the point of main ap|ircia<'li. Fortunately. its excellence is apparent tn the preent owners, for it remains in a state of good repair, and serves to arre.t the trained eye of the passer-by, as a .■■•ilent witness of a period when our forefatbers led the most cultured lives, surrounded li\ cvi r\- attainable expression of their refinement. OLD siior. 1.1 r(iiFii:i.i). co.w. T ITCIIFIKI.D'S lii>t.iry dates from its set- L/ tleinent in 172<1. It grew as all New Fng- land town;- of earlier settlement grew with wind ing streets and shaded lanes which tndy typified the simple character of the early iidiabitants. Its builders built as did all the early Xew Eng- landers with a fine regard for the basic elements of god architecture and even the humble sh(i|i was not too insignificant to receive the careful thinight of its designer. There is a most satis- factory imlication of good design anil honest hiiilding in tlie present Niilijcct sti well ])resentcil by .Mr. Kggers, who fouiiil many eijually satis- factory stdijects for his book of sketches during a visit to old Fitchtield. I.itehtield ])re-crves its traditions, which te(!in in liisttnMc association, and it is equally proud n( its record as the liirtli[ilaee of many illustrious men. 'The first law school tuiinded in the I'liited States was at J^itchfield, as was alsu the lirst "woman's seminary," the forertiiiner of the wo- man's college. Lyman J:5eecher, the father of Henry Ward Beecher and Harriet Heecher Stowe, was a much res])ected pastor of a Litchfield clnirch, and it was in Litchfield that Henry Ward IJeeeher and Harriett lieecher Stow(> were born. Flthan Allen was also born in Litehfield. When the miirmiirings that marked the days before "the shot heard nnind the world" was fired at Lexington, and the Kevdhitidiiary struggle was begun, Litchfield had rnmuled out a half century of growth, ifany old buildings stanil today that stood then as silent witnesses to the jiarf this (plaint New Kngland town played when it sent its manhood forth to jeiii the Continental armies. L\ TllF KlTCllKX GAKDEJS', MOUNT VEliNON, VA., THE HOME OF G FORGE WASHINGTON I '" 1 1 h] sulijeet of (he present sketch is a view -'■ of the gardens, which with their walks ami terraces and essential buildings remain today as lilaiiiie(| hy Wa.shington. These lawns ami gaivleiis are on the West side of the house, where was the ai)proacli from the pnlilie lilglnvay. They comprised about twenty acres anil were enclosed hy lirick walls. One of the two small octagon garden houses erected by Washington is shown in the sketch. These were built to store seeds ami tools. They have brick liases ami are boarded in imitation of stone t'oiins, aftei- llie manner of the dwelling house. .hisl what are these elements of greatness that make Washington the central figure of bis age ami have with each succeeding year caused his memory to be held in ever increasing respect, it wotild he (liHiciilt to define. Yet, the spirit of the man ])ervades today these historic localities. The visitor will note the absence of noisy bilar- ionsness that nsually marks the tourists to historic shrines. Perhaps it is because in a small tomb, but a few steps away rest the bones of Washing- ton. If the visitor fails to sense the nearness of the illustrious dead, he will liavc a solemn re- 12 SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE minder in the tolling of the bell of some passing- ship of war on the Potomae river, whose otHcers and men stand at silent sahitc From 1743 to 1859 Mount Vernon was held in possession of members of the Washington family. In 1859 it was pnrehased by the Jiount Vernon Ladies' Association. Since then the re- storation of the place has been eifected, mnch of the original Inrnitnre reclaimed and installed. Today Mount Vernon stands as nearly as it did when Washington lived there as human endeavor can make possible. DOOE OF A DUTCH FARM HOUSE, NORTH PATERSON, N. J. IoST another plate there was illustrated a gam- brel-roof house, located on Staten Island in New York Harbor. While, as stated, this type of house was typical of the earlier form built by the Dutch wdien they settled along the Hudson River Valley, the later coming of the English and the intermingling of settlers from two countries so widely ditfering in their architectural traditions undoubtedly e.xerted certain intluences, one on the other. While the doorway which Mr. Eggers has ilrawn for the present illustration is strongly intluenced by the later Georgian motives as developed in this country, it appears to be an original part of an otherwise typically Dutch house. The door is divided after the Dutch fashion into two separate- ly movable leaves and the stone door sill un- doid)tedly has its placement as part of the Dutch custom. But the general detail of the frame of the door is equally and unmistakably a relic of our early English Colonial architecture. The paneling at the sides of this entranc(^ is apparently hinged so as to close and form an outer door, a wise precaution in a section where the winters were often extremely rigorous. It be- comes interesting in stmlying a detail of this character to note the effect of social conditions on the development of architectural details. TRINITY CHURCH, NEWPORT, R. 1. "^^EWPORT, Rhode Island, sometimes called ■^ ^ the "social capital of the United States," was even before the outbreak of the Revolution socially and industrially important. During the occupation of Newport by the British, a fire de- stroyed a large part of the town. Among the few structures to escape the flames was Trinity Church, the subject of this sketch. As a result of military operations Newport became almost de- fiopidated, but through all the vicissitudes of the Revolutionary struggle, "old Trinity" passed safely. In its architecture Trinity resend)les many other churches built in New England during the early history of the Colonies, and while preserv- ing the dignity and quiet refinement that charac- terized the early meeting houses, its chief claim is its association with stirring scenes of earl)' wars and the reverential aspect of the people who stoutly guarded this sacred building from every threatened danger. Old Newport presents a picturesque contrast to the newer section, where now the mansions of the newly rich flaunt their pride of wealth before the observer. In the old town the hoiises are small, wooden structures, the streets are quaint and nar- row and there is a restfxd feeling ab.mt the en- tire section. In earlier days the waterfront was the scene of bustling activity. Newport is an ideal harbor for ships of even the largest draft. From this port there cleared to sail the waters of the seven seas tall sparrcil ships whose cargoes formed a con- siderable ])art of our American commei'ce. At that time the spire of Trinity dominated the town raid it served as a laiulmark for incoming ships and a beacon of hope to the home-coming sailor. DOORAV.VY, 'I'RI.XITV CHURCH, .XKWPORT, R. 1. I HIS doorway indicates the conscientioiis at- -'- tention with which the Colonial builder- architect worked. Its moldings and fluted pilas- ters show the handnnule wcu'k that makes a Colo- nial detail a thing of art and beauty as opposed to the nnichine cut nmldiugs of the present. The two-stoi'v mtcting hiiu:es in New England arc of unusual interest, and while many of them architecturally i)resent a better result, we (hndU if any of our early churches have received more solicitous care or have been more reverently re- garded than Trinity at New^Dort. OUI) STATE HOUSE, NEWPORT I ""HE public buildings designed during our -'■ early Colonial period are, in general, ex- cellent in design. While simple in style they have a certain eleg- ance that may properly furnish inspiration to njodern designers. It is in its disciplined and al- most universal refinement and dignity that lies the chief beauty of this work. Even wdien the earlv builders sought to venture on display they seem- ed to possess an innate senje of good breeding which taught them to avoid the vvdgar and the eccentric. 13 SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE This ni;r;i<'il n-liiu'irieiil is slmwii in the fin-t (liiit classic (Iftiiii was a cmiiinuii laiifiiiafjc, ami even the liuiulilcst carpenter was al)le to use it with iiitellip'iice and appropriatenivs to express tlie jov lie evitliMitlv I'onntI in his work. The State lionse at Newport was linilt in \~ \'.\. ai'd Hiehard .Munday was its arciiileci. OhilT ('. Kevin, writiiij; in the Cieorjiian I'eriod <<( Miiudav and his work, states: "This huilding is sym- metrical, well proportioned and quiet. For sug- •restion Muinlay dejtended on the type then in vogue. * * * Xhe dimensions are forty tent by eighty. Honestly constructed of Krick and stone, it hravely promises to weather lln' seasons for many generations to come." Some critics of the architecture of onr Colonial ])eriod have contended that, while its purity and classic lieauty cannot be (piestioned, it was never- theless based purely on domestic types. This State House at .Newport is cited as a case to prove this contention. riiK i;ii.i,( IP HOUSE. sT.vrKx isi..\ni) Till'] IJillop House is one of llie eai'liest e\- am])les if .\nierican arcliilecinre. From it : tirst beginnings it li:i^ been liid'ieil with events in .\merican history iliat \\:wr eiiileiired it as t!ie iiackgrouml for many legem^. At a time back in the Kidti's the Dnke of York claimed Staten Island as part of the colony of Xew York. Xew .lersey also wanted ])ossession. In or tain Chri; toj)lu r IJillop, in connnand of a small vessel, who succeeded, and this act won from the Dnke of ^'ork a trai-t of land containing l.lti-'l acres. The hoiise here illustrated, located at Totten- ville, is the oldest structure in Staten Islaiul and was built by Billop soon after the land was ])re- :ented to him in HitiS. It stands a little way be- yonnce of the Revolu- tion, wliich tor)k ](lace on September fi, ]T7<1. Benjamin Franklin, John Adams and Edward liiitleilge had been a]>pointed by the Continental Congress to confer with the English on the issues of the war. The In use was nsed as a barracks during the K(\i>huion and in ili(> cellar there is a brick vault and dungeon, large and linely arritish troops, stationed in Richmond, :iii(l ]inrsue(l them to the church to which they retreated. The .\mericans stormed the building, shooting until every window jiane was shattered ami then threw stones to con- ■serve ammunition. At this, a soldier came to the door and stated that the troojis within were ready to surrender, offering the explanation that the elnirch was being used as a British hos])ital, and that wounded and snfFei'ing men lav within. 14 SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE During the Kevohition, when the British were iu possession of the island, services were suspend- ed in all its churches except this. St. Andrew's was twice partly destroyed hy fire, but portions have withstood the ravages of two centuries. Tn the Metropolitan Museum, New York, there is treasured a silver communion service which Queen Anne gave the church when the charter was granted. T A STREET IN NEWPORT HERE is nothing iu the view of this quaint, winding street, su picturestjuely shown by Mr. Eggers, to suggest that it is a close neighbor to a section renowned all over the world for its palatial residences and the iiomcs of multi-mil- lionaires. The native population of Newport, with com- mendable regard for the traditions which sur- round this town, have kept as far as possible free from incursions of modernism. The artist in drawing this picture has presented a street in the old town of Newport as it probably looked a century ago. One may almost with accuracy trace the suc- cessive stages of building, rndoubtedly the hous- es, with their gambroled gables facing on to the street, were the earliest types. In the distance rises the spire of Trinity Church, shown in an- other illustration. There are nuiny well designed historic buildings in Ne\v])ort. The neighborhood has long been a favorite sketching ground. The State House, in which is hung the original portrait of Washington by Gilbert Stuart, the old market house, dating from 17G3, the Redwood Library and the Jewish Synagogue are among those best known. OLD TAVERN, ROSSVILLE, STATEN ISLAND STAGE coach and tavern days were picturesque ones during our Colonial period. With our present facilities for safe and quick journeys over long distances it is difficult to realize with what trepidation and great preparation our forefathers set about the trip from Philadelphia to Boston. Now a matter of hours, then a journey of weeks, the venturesome traveller, we learn, was wont to make his will, set his house in order and bid his family a tearful good-bye. It was only the rich and important who could afford the ex- pense of these long stage coach trips and it is for this i-eason that these taverns are in a sense his- torical landmarks. At one time or another they have sheltered the great men who were active during our Colonial period. The tavern at Rossville on State Island, pic- turesquely presented by Mr. Eggers' skillful pen- cil, is on the one time direct route between the southern and northern colonies. It was along this route that Washington journeyed when he set out for New York to take the oath of office as first President of the United States. In its architecture the tavern at Rossville fol- lows traditions of Dutch Colonial types. In fact it may be regarded as an excellent example of that period. Much of the picturesqueness of Staten Island has now disappeared and this old tavern is but a suggestion of what it was when all the village turned out to greet the arrival of "The Coach" and stare openmouthed at the pas- sengers alighting to stretch their legs after the long run from Trenton and to find in the low- ceilinged tap room the refreshment that would ease their fatigue and fortify them to continue their journey. OLD DUTCH FARM HOUSE, STATEN ISLAND ' I ""HE sturdy qualities of the Dutch who settled -'- Manhattan Island and spread out across the Hudson to New Jersey and seaward toward Staten Island are well typified in the house selected by Mr. Eggers for the present illustration. Low in iieight and broatl in expanse, this colonial farm liouse solidly sits its site. One may imagine the iitolid burgher taking his ease on the wide spread- ing porch, sheltered from the oppressive heat of the summer sun, or during inclement days in winter equally snug and comfortable before the stone fireplace of the low beamed kitchen ceiling. Few of these oldtinie farm houses remain, and when he who tramjis the unfrequented highway conies upon one, the charm of its picturesqueness is appealing. The wide clapboarcns to have suceeeded reasonably well. It is a pleasure to recall tiie reverential attitude of the people of I'hiladelpliia for these old Colo- nial landmarks and it is thnnif;h this atfectioiiati- eare that Christ ("liurch is today preserved as nciir as possible as orifcinally designed and built. ST. I'KTKirs nu'Rcn. rilll..M)KI.PlllA, PA. ST. PKTPIirs ClirKClI was imilt in 1T5S and is very similar in its treatment id Christ Chureh. It is one of the few early Colonial ehnrches in Philadelphia which does not follow the Wrenii type. In the eiul of this church there is a ])alladian window similar in design to that .shown in Christ Church and there are a number of similaritic-s in the tWM structures. The tipper part of the square tower of this church, with its slender octagonal spire, telescop- ing behind the battlemented roof, was addcil to the original church in 1742 by William Strickland. The detail showni in ilr. Eggers' sketch is a part of tlic original structure. It is interesting to learn that in order to pro- vide a means of raising the money to erect the stee])le it was decided to hold a lottery. This lottery was advertised in the Philadel])hia jour- nals. Thirteen men were appointed nuinagers, of whom Benjamin Franklin was one. DOORWAY TO FAIEFAX IIOISE, AI.K.XAJs^DRIA, VA. A I the o](cning of tlie Revolutionary War, the -^ *- "Virginia Fairfaxes" were the best known of the American Colonial pioneers of English birth. Thomas, sixth Baron P'airfax, had acquir- ed an immense estate in Virginia, which compris- eil about one-quarter of the entire colony. Thougli ardent loyalist during the Revolution, the Fairfaxes were permitted to dwell in peace in their manor house near Winchester. The sketch ])resented by ^fr. Eggers shows the Fairfax house in Alexandria. Va. Tt is tyi)ical of the hest work of this period, and undoubtedly was the product of one of those now unknown carpenter-architects who so efficiently built along our Kastern seaboard during the close of the eigh- teenth century. This house stands today but little changed from its tiriginal design, and the porch sclwled by Mr. Eggers as the subject of the pres- ent sketch is one of the iminy that have given in- spiration to architects as among the best details of our Colonial period. These carpenter-archi- let'ts unquestionably worked, as did our great modern i>ainlers. to achieve simplicity with full- ness. Jt is the outstanding characteristic of all of our best early Colonial work, and the result is a purity of classic beauty that is unsurpassed. KITCIIKX WL\(}, MOIWT VKKNoX. VA. THE kitchen wing of ilnnm X'eruon shown in the present sketch is reached by the ar- catled passage which projecrts above the boxwood hedge. The low building at the left is the kitchen. Its large expanse was necessary in the preparation of the food for the Washingtcm family and the many dependents that were required in the con- duct of so large an estate. The wide, o])en kitch- en fireplace stands as it did in Washington's time, and is ecjuipjicd with the many and ingenious utensils that contributed to produce the sumptuous banquets that nuirked the hospitality of a Vir- ginia gentleman. Owing to the well directetl work of a patriotic society of WT)men, ilount Vernon and :ill of its dependent buililings have been restored. It was here that the lordly Fairfaxes, who own- ed much of the surrounding country, were ac- customed to visit, and it will not re(|uire a wide stretch of imagination by those familiar with Colonial customs to imagine the great deeds of cookery that were performed in this kitchen when these and other illustrious people were guests at Mount Vernon. PORTICO. LEE MANSION. ARLINGTON. VA. THIS mansion and the lands emliracecl in the Arlington National Cemetery surrounding it, marks one of the most important locations in American history. It will always remain closely as.sociated with the name of General Robert E. Lee. the commander of the armies of the South- ern Confederacy, for it was here that he made his home during thirty years. He left it to join the armies of the South, never to return to it. In the early days of the Civil War this man- sion was taken over by the authorities and after much litigation, finally became legally the pro- perty of the Government and tlie grounds which surrounded it were acquired for purposes of a national cemetery. 16 SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE This historic buikling receives the utmost care and has been preserved so as to retain all the as- pects of the day when it was the central feature of the estate of one of the most representative Vir- ginia families. DETAIL OF A CHURCH ON CHARLES STREET, BALTIMORE, MD. THE First Presbyterian Church of Baltimore was erected about 1817, from plans by M. Godcfroy, Architect. Baltimore abounds in notable ecclesiastical structures, and those dating during the early years of the nineteenth century have the attributes of good architecture that marked the period. The artist who has drawn this notable series of early American architecture, and the writer who has added these brief notes of description, have by intimate association with the work of these clever designers and builders, acquired a deep re- spect for it. If the publication of these sketches serves to impress on those who scan them, the gTeat merit of the early architectural work in this country and the necessity for its careful preserva- tion, the object sought has been attained. CHRIST CHURCH AND GRAVEYARD, PHILADELPHIA, PA. IN a previous plate there was illustrated a view of Christ Church and this is now supplement- ed by J\[r. Eggers' .sketch of the wall surrounding the old churchyard wherein lie the remains of many men and women who actively participated in affairs during the early period of the forma- tion of the United States. In the present sketch Mr. Eggers has shown the iron railing set into the wall through which the passer-by may view the grave of iienjamin Franklin and stop to do him the homage of a pas- sing thouglit. The tomb, a slab of stone set flat, for Franklin was an unpretentious man, bears the inscription "Benjamin and Deborah Franklin, 1790." CENTRAL :\[OTIVE, OLD STATK HOUSE PHILADELPHIA nr^ilE central motive and tower of the Old A State House in Philadelphia provides the subject of Mr. Eggers' sketch. While the build- ing was started in 1729, the tower was not added until about I7.'il. In the belfry of this tower there was hung the bell that "proclaimed liberty throughout all the land to all the inhabitants thereof." To the great disappointment of all the people, this bell was cracked at its first trial by a stroke of its own clapper. The Declaration of Independence while draft- ed, passed and signed in Independence Hall, was not, as many mistakenly infer, proclaimed from that rostrum. It was read from the platform of a small observatory to a vast concourse assembled in Independence Scpiare, as it is now called. PENNSYLVANIA HOSPITAL, PHILADELPHIA, PA. THE Pennsylvania Hospital, is one of the most venerated and venerable structures in Philadelphia. Founded in 1751, largely through the efforts of Benjamin Franklin, it is maintained entirely by private subscription. It is the oldest institution of its kind in America. In its architecture it follows closely the lines of the important liuildings erected during our Colo- nial period. OLD STATE HOUSE, PHILADELPHIA npHE Old State House in Philadelphia, the ■*■ birthplace of our national life, was begun in 1729. Its progress toward completion Avas slow, and when the Assembly met for the first time in this building in 1735 it was far from finished. The historic chamber, known as In- dependence Hall, was not completed until 1742. The graceful lines of this historic structure present a fine example of our Colonial architec- ture. The building is one of dignity and has a fine sense of fitness and proportion. In its original setting it was embowered by tall trees and formed a ]iart of the mighty woods that gained for Pennsylvania its sylvan name. \VASHINGTON JMONUMENT, BALTHIORE "DALTIMORE'S title as "The Monumental •'-' Oity" is derived less from the number of its monuments than from the early date at which the Washington Monument in Mount Vernon Place, Baltimore, was erected. This stately shaft rises 164 feet and is sur- mounted by a heroic figure of General Washing- ton. The monument was built in 1815. Of the many monuments of Washington erected all over the United States none is more dignified or has a finer setting than this one. The citizens of Baltimore, with a true sense of the artistic, have completed a scheme for the de- velopment of the Mount Vernon Place section, and in this scheme the Washington Monument 17 SKnTCHFS OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE will IkVOHIO tht« (li'lllllUlIlM^ IcMlmr. riif |llullS fi>r this tlifiiiifuMl I'itv (li'vrl.>|iiiii'iil Wfir wuiki-d out li.v Tliiiiiins Hastings, lUfliitirt. nCIMI'V ••(H.I) SWKDKS" (IHIM 11, WIl.M l.\(i|(>\. DKl.. TUINITV. ill.- "1)1.1 S\v,mI.-.s" C'liiinli at Wil- iiiiii;;ti.n. Di'l.. was Imilt in ItillS, aiul is still in a.hnii'altlc ro|>air an. I rcfrnlar nsi'. It is in- ti ri->lin;r n.it al.iiic liccansc it .itTcrs a |ii.-lnrt's.[n.' I'tr.ft, lint alsii fur tlii' reason that the numy re- storations an. I a.l'liti.ins have heen s.i ear.'fully anil skilfully a.ljuste.l that it is .mlv th.)se fami liar with this eliureh wli.) d.i n.tt iniafrine that the entire strn.-tnre ili.l not .iri^inate at the sain.' ■ late. The tower was not a.l.le.l until 1802, ainI it was .)nly fifty years afr.> that the south porch wiili its h\altim.>re in 1S()4, he had f.ir an archi- tect one of the carpenter-architects wli.) so clever- ly built along the Atlantic seaboard during the close of the eighteenth and the oiiciiing years of the nineteenth centuries. Unfortunately the names, with few exce])tions, of these men are un- known, anil ei|Ually unfortunately in the present instance. The subject of ifr. Eggers' sketch has long been regar.led as one of the most valued architectural heirl.i.nns. It is a satisfaction t.) know that it will be carefully pre.-erved. Now the prop.^'ty of Johns-Hopkins University, it is safe to assume that by no chance will this architectural relic lie permitted to fall to decay. OLD CUSTOM nOT'SE, I'Hll.ADELl'UlA, I'A. I.VCOKRECTI.Y TiTI.Elj OlD CoiTRT HoiT.SE I 'HTS fine old building was built in 1810 for *■ the T'nited States 1)ank. Tn 184.") it })ecanie the C\istoni House. Designed by William Strickland, it represents his work at the early period .d' his activititrs as an ari'liitc'i. William Strickland and Robert .Mills, ontem- poraiicoiis, .lominale.i the public buil. lings in this cumtiy. They dictated the public taste in aiclii tecture for a full generation. The .dassi.' or Creek K.'vival was the doiuiual ing motive of all their buildings and ii is safe to assnmi' llial the slnn-tnres erect. '.I by tli.' gov- erniiienl frnm aboiit 1 N^n weri' either iloigiied or largely intlii.'iiced by either Sirickhind (17S7- 1^,'>) I or .Mills ( IT.SI-ISS")). CHRIST ClirncH. AT.EXAXmilA, VA. CHRIST ClU'RCll in .Me.Naii.lria, Va.. wa.s, ii.'fon- till- adiliiioii of its jiruscnt tower, iv])ical of a class of rliurch buildings erecte.l iliiring our Colonial |i( riod. It was a ])lain, four- sipiare building, wiili ;i liip roof, and its main architectural features were the cornice anil tlie liiiish of doors and windows. These reccivc.l the considerable attention that was characteristic of the work of the skilled Colonial builder. (ieorgc Washington was on.' of ilic tirst vi'strv men of this church, and the ]i.'W he occupied re mains today as it was in Washington's time. General Robert E. I.ce, who comnuindcil tli.' Confederate forces during the Civil War, was also a member of this church, coming from his stately I'.onie in .\rlin"toii. A STREET SCENE TN PROVIDENCE W/ IIE.V, in Kiot), Roger Williams was expel- ' '^ Icil from Massachu.'-.etts, he journeyed along the sh.ncs of what is now known as Narragansctt Bay. He bought a trac-t of land from the In.lians aii.l founded the town of Provideiuv in Rhode Island. A cijinpli'te and ilistinct se])aration was made between spiritual anil temporal affairs. The re- ligious intolerati.m that existed in Massachusetts was here set aside and freedom of action in re- ligious matters unecpiivocally giiaranteed. From the days of its founding up to the present, Proviilence has been typically New England in its growth and development. Thi.s niay be noted in the older part of the city where the thoroughfares are narrow an.l cr.ioked, and where may be found many interesting early American houses similar to tlu- one that has been so ailmirably sketched by M r. Eggers. The high box stoops shown in the illustration are common to New England, and many are to be found in Providence. They mark a certain period of domestic architecture. It is satisfactory to 18 SKETCHES OF EARLY AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE know that the patriotic spirit of the people of Providence is the reason for the conservation of many of these valnable architectural details. A PEO^aDENCE DOORYAED THERE is a certain quiet refinement about domestic life in New England seldom found elsewhere. This refinement is shown in the pride of birth that New England people so in- sistently proclaim, and this very attitude towards their ancestors is responsible for the mainte- nance, as nearly in the original as possible, of many of the landmarks to be found in Providence. This picturesque dooryard, with its well pro- portioned gateway, is of a house located on a hilly street. It is one that would attract the at- tention of the artist, and it has been very well handled by ^Ir. Eggers in the accompanying sketch. EIRST BAPTIST CHURCH, PROVIDENCE PROVIDENCE, Rhode Island, may be said to be the first home of the Baptist (.'hureh in America. The congregation which now worships in this church comprises among its members many of the descendants of that first congregation which, in 1638, organized this church, under the ministry of Roger Williams. The church is similar in design to many of the so-called two-story meeting houses that adorn New England villages and cities and which sug- gest, in every line, the devout spirit that has for so long a time maintained this church and zeal- ously guarded its traditions. CHRIST CHURCH, PHILADELPHIA I HIS fine church, one of the oldest now stand- -*- ing in Philadelphia, was built in 1727. Its history is linked with that of other and perhaps better known historical buildings in that city. It has been maintained with the most zealous care, as near as possible, in its original state, and is affectionately regarded by every citizen as one of the many revolutionary landmarks in which the people take a very proper ])ride. It ia an important addition to the already large number of Colonial churches included in this series. It also presents further evidence of the skill and refinement of design of the builder- architects of the period who constructed the build- ings which constitute such a valuable heritage to e\ery citizen of the L^nited States. DOORWAY IN BRISTOL, RHODE ISLAND BRISTOL, R. I., in the opinion of many an- ti(juarians, is located on or near the site where the Northmen in the year 1,000 and later, built the dwellings mentioned in the Icelandic Saga. This picturesque town on Narragansett Bay was first settled by the whites in 1680 and was in- 'corjjorated as a town in 17-t6. It is, therefore, among the oldest of our New England settlements. The boat building industiy has for many years flourished in Bristol, and the inhabitants, many of whom can trace their ancestry to the early set- tlers, have maintained, as far as possible, all the earlier characteristics of this interesting town. The doorway sketched by Mr. Eggers and pre- sented in this portfolio, is typical of the large amount of good architectural detail in Bristol that has survived the many changes that have there been made. OLD STOCK EXCHANGE, PHILADELPHIA, PA. IxcoRRECTLv Titled as Old Custom House THIS fine old building, designed by William Strickland, has seen many vicissitudes. It was built in ls;31 and represents in a most digni- fied way that period of our architectural develop- ment known as the ''Greek Revival." A drawing by llr. Eggers of a house at 7 State Street, New York, is included in the portfolio. In the monograph it is stated that the architect of that building was unknown. Comparison with the present illustration would suggest that it might be safe to hazard an attribution to Strickland. Strickland was born in 1787 and died in 1854. The house on State Street in New York was Iniilt in 18.30, a year earlier than the present subject, or when Strickland was about 43 years old. 19 f .-^rf*" '',".0(y_ ST. PAUL'S CHAPEL. NEW YORK, THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Archiletliire >OORWAY, WASHINGTON SQUARE NORTH, NEW YORK UF. AMERICAS ARCHITECT Utrit, >— —-^.SSJSJrj CHRIST CHURCH AND GRAVE YARD, PHILADELPHIA, PA. TBE AMERICAS ARCHITECT $in,, of Earh Amtruan Architiiiu,: OLD STATE HOUSE, PHILADELPHIA, PA. EE AMERICAS' ARCHITECT Seriej of Early American Architectur, I .•^:'' Vmc OF PENNSYLVANIA HOSPITAL, PHILADELPHIA, PA. THE AMERICAS ARCHITECT Si'its of Early Amiricat Arihiucturt OLD STATE HOUSE. PHILADELPHIA, PA. £ AMERlCA^■ ARCHITECT Series of Early Arne'uan Architecture HE WASHINGTON MONUMENT/BALTIMORE, MD. AMERICAS ARCHITECT Serit, af Earl, Amtntar, Ar^h'tKlur, OLD SWEDES.CHURCH, WILMINGTON,:dEL. TBE AMERICAS ARCHITECT Striet of Earl, Amirican ArcHticltir, 9/i S"> trm^i PORTICO OF HOMEWOOD, BALTIMORE, MD. at. AMERICAN ARCHITECT Stri,, <,f Earl, Amtruan Archi:„i OLD COURT HOUSE, PHILADELPHIA, PA. THE AMERICAS ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architeriure CHRIST CHURCH, ALEXANDRIA, VA. IIHE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Siriit af Earl, Amtrican Arthiltctur, DETAIL OF A HOUSE IN PROVIDENCE, R. I. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early Ameikati ArchUeclure . -fro-) I At.riCt. • ^- ^ ■ I T 5. A PROVIDENCE DOOR-YARD 'HE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecture KT I * FIRST BAPTIST MEETING HOUSE, PROVIDENCE, R. I. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecture ^ ■ K. "E- CHRIST CHURCH, PHILADELPHIA, PA. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecturt ?3»- .;.. D «. c ^ T o J_ . R- . I A DOORWAY IN BRISTOL, R. I. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecture I OLD CUSTOM HOUSE, PHILADELPHIA, PA. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Sent, ot Earl, Amsruur Ar,h, ltiJ t;:^.^^, S%•cit'^■'-■■ .^1 OLD PROVIDENCE NATIONAL BANK THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecture a"*s*- ^i^~^^:r- (. DOOR WAY TO A HOUSE ON BENEFIT STREET, PROVIDENCE, R. I. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecture THE CATHEDRAL, BALTIMORE, MD. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT Series of Early American Architecture University of CalKomia SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY 40S Hiigard Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90024-1388 Return tills materlai to the library from which II was borrowed. D 000 263 566 2