731 L56 r B o CO o ^= ID O o 3> 55 3> -XI J> o ^e^TC THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES LETTERS O N LOVE, MARRIAGE, AND ADULTERY. i PRICE TWO SHILLINGS AND SIX-PEN . LETTERS O N LOVE, MARRIAGE, AND ADULTERY; ADDRESSED TO THE RIGHT HONORABLE THE EARL OF EXETER, LONDON: printed for j. r1dgway, no. i, york street, st. james's square. -- MDCCtXXXIX. 7 S > L5& LETTERS. LETTER L My Lord, THE name of CficiL, is refpe&able in . the political and civil hiftory of Britain : and you derive your honours and wealth from fources which fhould produce the no- bleft ambition ; that of improving the laws and political conftitution of your country. The private character of your lord (hip-, I have often found a fubjecl of praife : and in your tafte for the arts ; particularly in your paflion for mufic, you difplay the qua- lities of a munificent patron. B The 2 INTRODUCTION. The objects of patronage in a nobis houfe, determine the principles of education through all its branches. r// c I will not wound your lordfhip's mind by minute and public references to a late event in your family ; which I could trace to its general caufes . I would only avail my- felf of it, to turn your lordfhip's attention to thofe caufes, and engage your efforts to remove them. .., k ri Compare the pofllble confequences of fuch efforts, with thofe of your prefent purfuits. To diflipate the corroding reflections of royalty, by the commemoration of Handel ; or to render mufic the means of fupportino* its profefTors what objects for the ambi- tion of a Cecil ! while the constitution is mouldering nto ruins ; while the itatute- books hold laws, which contaminate at the fpring, all the happinefs of domefti elite! The glorious revolution in France, hath ftunned the Englilh adminiftration : for, in providing againfl: the abufes of a free con- ftitution, the patriots of France minutely delineate the actual government of England. This is fullenly, but fecretly refented : for the INTRODUCTION. 3 . the national fympathy, with Gallic pa- triotifm, is at this time fo ftrong, that the minifter, who would intimate an obftru6tion, or (hew a difpoation to take advantage of its diftrefs, would be fuipended at the treafury lamp, with the cordial approba- tion of the kingdom. I do not call on you, my lord, to antici- pate the neceffity which I fee approaching, a venal and perfidious adminiftration. I urge you not, on the ftate of parliamen- tary reprefentation ; on the corrupt influ- ence of the India Company ; on the accu- mulation of taxes to ferve the purpofes of jobbers ; on the dreadful condition of the magiftracy, the police, and the poor. It is hoped, the people of England will foon be inftructed, in a mode of directing their re- prefentatives and their legiflature on thefe fubjeas. I folicit your lordftlip to an un- dertaking lefs arduous ; to remove thofe evils which have affected your peace, and clouded your hopes. The common and ftatute laws, reflect- ing love, marriage, and adultery, I will not fpecify at this time. Perhaps the fol- B 2 lowing 4 INTRODUCTION. lowing con federations may induce your lordfhip to examine, and to lay them be-' fore parliament for revifal and amend- ment. I have the honor to be, My lord, Your lordfhip's moft obedient And moft humble fervant, The AUTHOR. LETTER LOVE. LETTER 'II. My Lord, THE principle of union between the fexes, has been varioufly denominated, and has been in efteem or dififteem, as it has appeared in a natural ftate, or perverted by cufioms and inftitutions. The ancients deified every confiderabie principle in hu- man nature ; and finding love to be highly powerful, they affigned it high diftinclions, and prudently peribnified it by a feminine deity. Venus was not only a daughter of Jupiter, but a favourite, whofe fmiles over- ruled all things but the decrees of fate; who held in pleafing, becaufe voluntary, thraldom all the inhabitants of heaven and earth. When we confider the reafon or philofophy of this allegory, we wonder love became not the general principle of devo- tion. As the fource of pleafures the moft pure and extenfive, what principle can bear its 6 LOVE. its competition? Through what medium could men look up to nature, or the God of Nature, with gratitude fo ardent, as that fuggefted by the numerous affections pro- duced by love? But curfes not blefllngs have been the general principles of religion. In rude and favage conditions, evils are fo prevalent, that the birth of piety is gene- rally under the dominion of a malignant fiend ; and abafe, abject fpirit of devotion is generated, which improved knowledge or information cannot always expel. In the enlightened periods of Greece and Rome, the qualities, commonly deified were mif- chievous. I Jupiter, Neptune, Mars and Apollo, were formed from heroic or popu- lar,, not from virtuous or natural characters. Men having no view of becoming wife, no jalan of becoming happy, have been con- veniently furnifhed with deities whofe qua- litiesare alloyed, whofe virtues are mingled with vices. Thus the father of gods and men, while he held the balance of the uni- verfe, animated or terrified all nature with ethereal fire; while all power, dominion, and virtue, were attributed to him, was transformed LOVE. 7 transformed into a bull or a fwan, for the conduct of a wretched intrigue. Pains have been taken by the advocates of antw quity to elevate thefe abfurdities into pro- bability and conftftency. All the fources of parable, allegory and fable have been traced, to furnifh favorable interpretations ; and maxims of wifdom, or principles of virtue have been fought, where no ideas of them had been entertained. This is owing to a common error in our eftimate and opinion of individuals or of nations. When we have obtained incidents and facts, we infer moral qualities and difpohtions, on the idea of confiftency. But the minds of men, and the conftitutions of kingdoms, generally receive their principles from the hands of barbarifm and folly. They afterwards ac- quire knowledge and virtue ; but their habits being formed, they exhibit wife the- ories, and foolifh or barbarous conduct ; they are virtuous in avowed principles, and vicious in manners. We are thus perpe- tually embarafled, with mingled qualities in morals, which would be unaccountable in (peculation : and we fee the lame foun- tain 8 LOVE. tain bring forth fweet waters and bitter. While we difcern evident marks of poetical and even rational defign in fouie parts of the heathen mythology; others may have been produced by grofs fuperftition or vicious policy Communities as well as in^ dividuals are formed on prejudices ; they acquire portions of knowledge and virtue, which do not harmonize with their habits ; we look in vain to them for confiftency, and it is generally impracticable to argue from principles to actions, or from actions to principles. The heathen mythology, in many of its parts, is not only abfurd, unpoetical, and incapable of being rendered into fenfe, even by the licence of allegory and fable, but its effects muft be vicious. The character of Jupiter, being the fupreme "religious model, the ambition of youth could not have been directed higher than to copy it ; and they mingled acts of power and heroifm w 7 ith bad paffions and mlfchievous actions. Hardly any view of the political inftitu- tions-of mankind can reflect; greater dif- honof on them, than that of their- origin in LOVE. 9 In vices of the moft depraved charafter. When they have arilen from errors on the firft principles of human nature, we find their firft deities have been modifications of love ; as it is the paflion which holds the firft rank in the human mind, or the blefl- ing through which man muft be moft dif- pofed to look up to nature with enthufiaftic gratitude. The abufes of devotion, on this principle, generated voluptuoufnefs, and mifchiefs of various kinds enfucd ; but they were obvious and immediate corruptions of natural paffions. In the mythologies of the world we are further removed from nature. Jehovah, Jupiter, or Jove, is arbi- trary power; Mars, cruelty; Mercury, de- ceit. Thefe are peribnifications of compli- cated ideas : they are corruptions of cor- ruptions ; and they were generated, not by miftakes in a ftate of fimplicity, but by evil intentions and vices, in a condition ot mature deliberation and malignity. How- ever we may determine on thefe fubje&s, we are fure the interefts of mankind have not been promoted when the principles which naturally and affcakmately unite C th0 10 LOVE. the fexes, are made to yield precedence to thofe which, raife us into lieroes, enable ns to lay wafte the earth, or to deluge it with blood. Venus and Cupid, though admitted among the gods, or allowed to feduce them, are marked with circum- itances of ridicule and reproach ; they feem not to -be genuine or legitimate divini- ties ; and their influence is connived at or excufed, not avowed as natural, neceflary, r reafonable. It has ever appeared as a rule, if natural difpofitions be reftrained and reproached, they become vicious ; as a man whofe cha- racter is unjuftly deftroyed, becomes a vil- lain, to affimilate himfelf with the order into which he is protruded. The difrepute of love, and its humiliating condition of fub- fervience to pafiions of inferior utility and rank, fufficiently account for the inconve- niences or evils it may have occafioned. The elementary parts of the globe ap- pear to have been difpofed in regular la- mina? or ftrat2T* Convulfions and eruptions have, in many places, deftroyed this order. The wretched flave, who feeks the precious metals love. n metals in apparent ruins, would Tmile with incredulity, if an interval of ferenity fhould allow him to fmile, at being informed, that the riches he feeks for are not matters of hazard, but produced in a regular difpoii- tion of things ; that fuch difpofition is to be traced by perfons of enlarged views and comprehenfive knowledge. To fuch perfons the order of nature is difcernible, where it is inverted or confounded ; where the heavier matters are brought to the furface, and the lighter funk into the depth ; where the laws of gravitation feem to have been rendered ineffectual, and things having no relation in weight, quality, or difpofition, are brought together and intimately mingled. He refers every thing to its place ; every particle to the bed wherein it was produced ; and every deviation from general law to its caufe. It is thus in morality. Certain eflential principles, like the conftituent parts of the natural world, form its general utility; and thefe are the foundations of private and public virtue. But thefe, like the earth, are broken, distorted, or confufed by cuftoms is LOVE, or mftitutions ; and the fubjects of our wretched governments, contemplate virtue under fimilar difadvantage, or feek happi- *iefs in the fame random manner, as nature is viewed, or wealth fought, by the refer- able flaves who pick up the fragments of disjointed rocks, or collect gold among the lands of a torrent. It is the philofopher who difcovers the principles of nature through partial diitortions, or aniidft the confufion of human inftitutions : who, while cuftoms or manners may make virtue vice, and vice virtue ; or mingle difpofitions and qualities \'o as to confound ordinary under- standings, will point out the precife line between good and evil, and refer every prin- ciple to its proper origin. This is my meaning, when I allude to the principles and truths of nature, as diftinguiihed from the facts furnifhed by fociety. The diitinc- tion is of importance to thofe, who would form a criterion of virtue and vice. We may obierve thofe reafoners or philofophers who do not rife to the general tendencies or dif- pofitions of nature, which, under the forms of permanent happinefs or extenfive utilit actually LOVE. *3 actually govern the moral world ; who are confined to incidents in ill formed inftitu- tions, confound their underftandings and thofe of their readers by multitudes of con- tradictory facts : and they conclude there are no truths or principles in nature, with as much fagacity or wifdom as men among rocks and precipices affirm that the ge- neral difpofition of the globe is without order or beauty. When you attend to my reafon for ex- plaining myfelf on this fubje6t, your lord- fhip will not imagine I detain you on uncer- tain or unimportant fpeculations. I refer to the only truths which are permanent ; and of utility as extenfive as the combined interefts of mankind. Nothing can be more uncer- tain, contradictory, or delufive than the events or facts produced by ill contrived* vicious, and fleeting focieties. Every wife man, every philofophic moraliff, acquires the faculty of looking through local in- ftitutions and cultoms, into the general principles which actuate mankind. The genuine principle of love, produ- cing genuine and permanent happinefs is not 14, LOVE. not an idea merely fpeculative ; it is not a poetic fancy conceived to amufe or delude the multitude. It is an indisputable prin- ciple of nature, as obvious in its utility as any truth of natural philofophy. It may be faid, principles are of no ufe if not reduced to practice. If the real and obvious tendency of nature, in the union of man and woman, has not its ef- fe6t, or cannot have it in the pr-efent con- dition of Societies of what confequence can it be, to defcribe or to think of fuch tendency ? While we remain under the influence of vicious religions and bad laws, this objec- tion may be urged againft every principle of morality. It may be faid, why talk of honefty, when it is not in the power of any man, in the prefent ftate of things, to be ftriclly or perfectly honeft? In every office, occupation, or bufinefis, where the power or artifice of others, is to be mana- ged ; it is as difficult, as dirc6tly againft a man's immediate intereft, to adhere invaria^ bly to that integrity which nature has con- ftituted the cement cf all advantageous in- tercourfe LOVE. 15 tercourfe or union, as it would be to pro- ceed in love, on the maxims, to which alone God has annexed real and perma- nent happinefs. But, as in every condition of trade or commerce, the admiffion of certain portions and of a general appear- ance of honefty, difcovers a latent and fix- ed conviction of its neceflity ; fo in depra- ved conditions of fociety, the expedience of fome degrees of tender inclination and the general affectation of it, difcover the latent principles or operations of nature; and lead us to conclude that, in a better Hate of things, under better governments, religions and cuftoms, the difficulties in our way to happinefs would be removed, mere- ly by the poffibility of forming our deter- minations on the principles of reafon. When therefore, I attempt to delineate a ftate of nature, I do not feek the privilege of poetic licence. I confider myfelf, as more ftri<5tly and facredly bound to truth, than in demonltrating mathematical propofiti- ons. Every thing that ought to be, may be, and will be; for all the truths of reafon. muft have their effects. I will 16* LOVE. I will not deny, there may be fpecies of facts againft the probability of regulating the union of men and women, on natural or virtuous principles ; but 1 may allege other fpecies of fa&s as numerous and re- fpe&able to prove fuch regulation pra&ica- ble and neceflary. If the end of living be happinefs if the provifions of the deity, in the powers and principles of man, may and ought to make him ufeful the faas producible to prove him always unhappy, when deviating from the path traced by reafon, are better argu- ments for the poffibility of following it, than any which may be deduced from vici- ous cuftoms or manners, to prove the im- poffibility. But in this as in other cafes, we are feldom fo circumftanced, as to dif- cern in their order, fucceflion,and com- bination, thofe properties of the human frame ; the effeas of which are as indifpu- table as thofe of gravitation. Man and woman, are made for each other; as evidently as one part of the globe, or as one part of the human body is made for the other. Either confidered fin- gtor LOVE. * 7 gly, does not conftitute a perfect moral be- ing; and in a Rate of feparation, could not exift in circumftances of utility or enjoyment. The forms and difpofitions of their bodies and minds, are proofs of this truth : for their chara&eriftic qualities are different; and their defe&s are made up by their union. , Man and woman, in the plan of the univerfe, are divifions of a focial being. Ancient poets borrowed the idea, proba- bly from philofophical moralifts ; but they converted it, as poets ulually convert a philofophical idea, into abfurdity. They conceived Jupiter to have made man and woman one body ; feparated them, in fome caprice, by a random precipitation into this world; and that wrong aflbciations of feparated parts, are the occafions of un- happy marriages. But the principle is falfe. Men and wo- men cannot be fo effectually united ; be- come virtually one, and mutually pro- mote happinefs, on any conceivable plan, where they are not formed and born fe- parately, with diflimilar bodies and dif- fiimilar minds. It is the firfi proviiion of D wiidom, i$ LOVE. wifdom, in the road of happinefs, to give connections the charm of choice: evert where propenfities are irrefiftible, it gives an idea of power or liberty, without which they would mortify, inftead of de- lighting us. I can only open the fubjecl, in the pre- fent letter. I confider it as the moll im- portant in the province of morality or of legiflation, and the moft difficult of difcuf- fion in a perfpicuous and ufeful manner. It has not been properly confidered by philofo- phers ; it has been mifreprefented or abufed by enthufiafts and fanatics ; and rendered lu- dicrous or injurious by fabulifts and poets. I mean to avoid thefe deviations and er- rors ; and to fubmit to your Lordlhip, fuch thoughts or obfervations as may be ufe- ful to you, if you mould attempt to in- duce the Wiflature to deliberate on the laws that effecT: love and marriage. I have the honor to be, My Lord, Your lordfhip's mod obedient, And mod humble fervant, The AUTHOR. LETTER. love. *g LETT ER I My Lord, THE fagacity and wifdom of Lord Ba- con, have miftaken the fubjecl: under confideration ; and the error of fuch a man, on a fubjecl; fo important, fhould not be unnoticed, though treated with candor and refpect. Undertakings of great extent and and hazard, either in fcience or patriotifm, are, in his opinion, fuited to fmgle men; not to thofe, whofe time and affe6tions are engrofled by the connections or duties of domeftic life. Lord Bacon repeats the opinion, as a fixed or evident propofition ; and in the language of advice to thofe who would be tranf mitted to pofterity by the fame of their talents or actions. This is laying the axe at the root of a tree, which may be called moft properly " the tree of " life." If the firft order of men is to be detached, to acquire immortality, love will D 2 fuffe r o LOVE. fuffer in its credit ; and be appropriated to the rank and merit of inferior beings. I have profited fo much by the wifdom and learning of Lord Bacon, that my mind retains an impreflion of his works, fimilar to early prepofleffions in favor of the fcrip- tures ; and, I have fuperftitious feelings, like the confcioufnefs cf irreligious prefumption, when I difpute his maxims. But his. errors are fatal, as thofe of the oracles of re- ligion ; and, in the prefent cafe, they en- danger important principles of focial virtue. If his great and penetrating mind had con- fidered the iubject with attention, he would have perceived, that aftoniming appearances and immortal characters are not the objecls of genuine philofophy ; never the pro- duce of well formed or happy focieties. They are " lights ihining in dark places " they are meteors in dreary or unhappy fituations; they are monflers, giving ex- amples of importance in bad focieties; where the mo ft ufeful members may fe- clude themfelves with advantage, or be obliged to produce good out of evil. In focieties wifely formed and honorably con- LOVE. 21 conducted, no wonderful characters arife ; as in cultivated or enlightened periods, no miracles are ever performed. Such com- munities might be wonderful, compared with others; but the members would be loft to general view, each being aptly fixed to a particular ftation. This would be dis- advantageous only in appearance; for a man who contributes his utmoft proportion to the general prolperity, multiplies his enjoyments by general Sympathies with every part of the community, and his gra- tifications are greatly fuperior to thofe of vanity in fcience or in war. In the fame manner, men in affectionate union with women, becoming focial beings, fulfilling their duties in the community, and feeK ing the profperity and happinefs diffufed through all its parts, have fatisfactions of much greater value and permanence, than any which can be enjoyed by detached or diftinguifhed beings, however brilliant their fortune or fame. Socrates owes his immortality to a bad wife, to a corrupt community, to unequal laws, to the def* potii'm of ufurpers, and to an unjuft or violent 22 LOVE, violent death. No man formed for his duties, and underftandmg their effects, would wifh to purchafe the immortality at the price. His fate is a leflbn to focieties, rather than to individuals. If Athens had been virtuous, Socrates would not have been immortal : but inftead of the fame, of which he had no enjoyment, he might have fpent every hour of a long life, in the pleafing confcioufnefs of virtuous utility ; inftead of amufing himfelf with fhadows, he would have felt and enjoyed fnbitantial fatisfaction. Lord Bacon, in his own life, illuftrates the truth under confederation ; and fur- nifhes means to deftroy his maxim. His talents and progrefs had been checked, as a member of fociety ; he had tarnilhed his character, before he quitted his public fta- tion ; and he fought immortality in fcience, as a compenfation for difappointment in .life. His opinion, therefore, can have but little weight in the prefent cafe : it is not ground- ed on a juft view of the principles of fo- ciety LOVE. 23 ciety ; and is owing to mifapprehenfions of the nature and happinefs of man. That fociety and not folitude is the ftate of nature, appears from the general pro- vifion, that all beings, capable of enjoy- ment or happinefs, fhould be male and fe- male; each fex feparately imperfect, and under a fpecies of neceflity of being united. I call it a fpecies of neceffity ; becaufe the idea of choice ; and that undefinable fa- culty of nature, by which fhe renders her indirect operations our own acts and our own pleafures ; give us the firft privilege of being, and are the firft procefles by which fhe converts into bleflings, neceffary or unavoidable effects. Though men and women muft unite to form focial beings ; they are brought together, as if they might unite, or live feparately. This gives the idea of choice or liberty; it diftinguifhes the impulfes or actions of men from the motions of trees or ftones; it throws a charm over ftrong and abfolute tenden- cies ; and forms an intereft, where we implicitly or paflively obey. This power of determination, combines the ideas of liberty 2* LOVE. liberty and necefiity, which polemic phi- lofophers have attempted to difunite: ideas affociated in nature ; though fometimes in a manner, which may be better felt than defer ibed. Poetry has ever abounded with mifappre- henfions or errors ; and it is among the principal misfortunes of mankind, that its early leffons are furnifhed by poetry. The utmoft licence has been taken in imagining the original ftate of man. Jupiter has been fuppofed to prevent the poflibility of error by pairing and uniting the parties, to ren- der them infeparable. Such an act of di- vine power, would have infured their mifery. This is rendered probable, by the effects of every fpecies of interpofition in negociations of love. We perceive certain mifchiefs or injuries arifmg, in proportion as liberty is violated. And if we could fuppofe a Deity to be employed in {electing and uniting fuitable perfons through all the world, we may be aflured, not one pair would have a chance for happinefs. It is the idea of choice ; it is the power of LOVE. ' 25 of rendering an event our own act, while our concurrence may be inevitable : thefe are the circumftances which conftitute us agents, give us the opinion of being rati- onal, and beftow all our bleffings. In the bufinefs before us, as in all moral fituations, it is puerile, to recur in imagination to a former and better ftate of human nature* producing happinefs by direct or abfolute neceffity. No fuch effect could have been produced by fuch a caufe. The ftate of the world may never have been better, on the whole, than at this time ; it was never, pro- bably, very different : and the quantity of good and evil in it, though fluctuating in human fancies, may poflibly be invariable. The determinations of nature are always effectual, but events in the moral world do not appear to be. produced with the precifion or accuracy we obferve in the arrangement of inanimate objects. To in- troduce intellectual happinefs, a certain la- titude is dmitted, and rational beings are fo formed, as to afTume the appearance of voluntary or independent agency. Hence the wonderfuLproperty of the human mind, E called $6 LOVE. called confcience, the left of its operations, the legal reprefentative of its power,- and the final judge of its punifhments and re- wards. The reafon that perfect happinefs does not take place* by a proper union of men and women, or by a proper conduct to each other, is fimilar to the reafons prevent- ing moral happinefs, in all cafes depending on the will or conduct of moral agents. Having a choice, and acquiring judgment by errors, the confequence muft be a con- dition of mingled happinefs and mifery. The union of man and woman, though it be the neceffary effect of their formation ; though infured by affectionate tendencies or affinities ; the neceflity admits of confider- ation or choice, and it is made the deter- mination or act of the parties. The fuit- ablenefs or unfuitablenefs of one to the other, and the various circumftances form- ing inclination or paflion, muft depend ul- timately on their judgment or underltand- ing. If we fuppofe a ftate of things, in which young perfons are judicioufly edu- cated, and profeffedly prepared by their parents LOVE. *7 parents for this important event of focial life, hardly any improper connections can be made, and more than poets have ima- gined of conjugal happinefs muft be enjoy- ed ; for I am afraid, no man has had it in his power to conceive, the degree of happi- nefs it is r:oflible to enjoy in virtuous foci- eties by means of virtuous education, and by the union of fenfible and affectionate youth, educated for their principal duties. In this cafe, the object of the fociety would be the ha pinefs of its members ; and infti- tutions of that tendency would be few, im- portant, and obvioufly beneficial. Parents would be und-r a fpecies of neceflity in ac- commodating themfelves to the general ob- je6t ; and education would be leiTons of in- telligence, truth, honor, fidelity, and good- nefs : they would perceive the inutility of interpofing their power in the firlt con- nections of youth, where that of a Deity would be injurious defpotifm. The union of man and woman, having nothing to dil- tinguifh it from the union of ftones and rub- bifh but choice ; and marriage being the firft and moll important occafion of reducing E a into e8 LOVE: into pra&ice the leflbns of reafon and virtue received in education, parents (hould be cenfured and fubje6l to public reftraint, in attempting to extend their authority where it cannot be ufefully exercifed. But it is the misfortune of ignorant or vicious parents, to neglect their duty in its proper place, and to commit injuries or outrages in attempting to atone for their errors. They who have given their children, or procured for them, trifling, oftentatious, or bad in ftr ucfions, have reafons for fufpect- ing their judgments or their hearts, in the choice of connections for life. But at fuch a period, it mull' be too late to remedy the evils of education, if fuch parents were fuf- ceptible of the intention. They interpofe their authority, and having been unnatural or cruel in negteaing the feaibn of cherifh- ing the tendencies to reafon and virtue, they think themf elves juftified in outraging na- ture, by denying their chi ftfen privileges, which indeed they are not qualified to ufe 3 but which cannot be fubftituted by parental defpotiim, prudence, or avarice. A man, who, by negligence, continues the LOVE. o 9 the infancy of his offspring beyond its na- tural period; or by vicious meafures, con- taminates and injures their minds, fhould be gratified with that exercife of defpotifm ; and not relentlefsly purfue them, where they mud produce either good or evil for them- ielves, where their chance of recovery mull be, by getting clear of the original author of their misfortunes. In moral life, as in every part of nature with which we are acquainted, there are feafons. Ages elapfed in the progrefs of focieties, before men difcerned thofe of the year, and precifely diitinguifhed feed-time from harveft. Great confufion and mifery niuft have arifen : the feafon of cultiva- ting the earth and depofiting the feed being neglected, they endeavored to remedy their miiconduct by induftry mifapplied in the period when the fruits fhould have been growing, and the harveft commenced. Whole tribe^rprovinces, and nations, either led wretched lives, uncertain of fcanty fup- port, rendered calamitous by difeafes from unwholfome food, or they were ftarved. Ages of misfortunes fixed their attention to the So LOVE. the leflbns of experience, and gave them probability of fubfiftence, by teaching them to difcern the* laws of nature, to diftinguiih the feafons of the year, or to employ in every period the fpecies of induftry parti- cularly fuited to it. The duties or obligations of focial life are, in a fimilar manner, ftrictly and abso- lutely confined to their feafons. Infancy is the fpiing, the feafon for giving impref- fions or forming difpofitions. Y nth the fummer, in which they fend out fhoots, buds, and flowers. Manhood, the autumn. Old age, the winter. If, in common life, a fucceuion of ages muft have taken place, before mifery iniiructed men in the import- ance of diftinguifhing the common feafons,' though their fupport or exiftence depend- ed on them are we to wonder that, in moral life, the region of reflection and reafon, the fufTerings of the mind and heart have not yet inftrucled them to difcern its periods or feafons ? This knowledge re- quires the art of attending to a feries of cir- cumftances, and of reafoning on them ; an art which is not eafily taught even by mi- fery.. LOVE. S i fery. If Ceres and Triptolemus have been recorded and worfhiped, for refcuing na- tions from the condition of brutes in refpet to fubfiflence or fupport ; what would he deferve who could fix the attention of man- kind on the moral feafons, by the obferv- ance of which alone genuine happinefs can be procured? As thofe who neglect the timely cultivation of the earth, and fow in fummer or in autumn, will be difap- pointed, poor, and ftarved; thofe who neg- lecl: or corrupt their children, depending on future opportunities of correcting or improving them, will afluredly be difap- pointed and wretched. This ignorance of the nature of infancy or youth, or of the fpecies of care to be employed on them, renders men incapable of forming the moft important connections of fociety with any probability of happinefs. The fir ft remove from barbarifm and brutal negligence, is into indifcriminate injudicious care, fuch as may be evident at this time in the anxieties of domeftic education. Prudence is over- ftrained ; children are prepared for enter- prifes or duties merely poffible, and left to 3 2 LOVE. to act at random, or wholly under the di- re&ion of others, on their entrance into fociety, and on afltiming the characters they are to fuftain. The loweft itate of barba- rifm, is indicated by unfeeling negligence, fimilar to that of brutes, from whom bar- barians are barely removed. The common transition is into the extreme of exceflive care, by which all duties, all arts, all fci- ences are precipitated into the mind. The induftry of parents and tutors mould be employed to form habits of enquiry, difcern- ment, and firm integrity; to cultivate a natural and exquifite fenfibility ; to form out of it an upright confcience ; and to clear the fprings of virtuous and happy difpofi- tions. Youth thus educated would not furprize the ignorant by premature acqui- fitions ; but placed in any fituations, their errors would not be material ; their minds and hearts, being in a right direction, they would anfwer the purpofes of life in their proper feafons, and their progrefs in know- ledge and virtue would be gradual and fure. It is owing either to negligence or to ex- ceijive LOVE. H ceftive care in the education of children, and to defpotifm in the difpofal of them, that fo many unhappy marriages take place ; and that youth are introduced in fociety or af- fume the rank of citizens, with no rational and focial profpect, or with that of mifery. Previous to any reafonable expectation, that men and women may be generally united for happinefs, the revolutions of the world muft form focieties for the advantage of all their members , morality muft defcend from fpeculation into life, and confift in duties, not in docirines ; education muft be an ex- ercife for thofe duties, or an apprentice-* (hip for the bufinefs of living : then we may fee youth felecl each other with warm, live- ly, intelligent pafiions ; and fo happily aflb- ciated, as to refcue Nature from blame* oit the fubject of marriage. I have the honor to be, My Lord, Your moft obedient And moft humble fervant, The AUTHOR. LettfR 34 L0FEt 113OT s>bin lo .11/ oi boonfcim 9 Lffo I LETTER IV. My Lord, bi i T has not been my intention, to confider the unreafonable exercife of parental authority, as the firft occafion of unhappy marriages in point of time. My fenti- ments arofe, from the liberty or choice, effentially neceffary to the happy union of man and woman. The improper autho- rity of relations or parents, might not bo the iirft caufe, in point of time, if any pro- bable origin could be affigned to mankind. Societies have rifen to civilization and rea- fon, by flow gradations, and from conditions bordering on brutality. The vice of brutes, or of men refembling them, is not tyranny but negligence, reflecting their children. Their power is exercifed over the females ; and from caufcs, obvious in nature, though adapted to other effects. In LOVE. 35 In focieties of rude conftruction, men and women are induced to unite, by a combination of phyfical and moral caufes, which are not eafily defer ibed, becaufe not eafily comprehended. The effect of this combination is called inftinct, paflion, or af- fection ; according to the rank or excel- lence of the animal, in which it appears: and not being underftood in its principles, it is confidered as an occult quality, or a myfterious gift of heaven. This may fuit poetic, or fuperilitious ignorance ; and fur- nidi that enthufiafm in poems or religi- ons, of which ignorance is generally the parent : but it will not anfwer the ends of real philofophy ; or of thofe men, who find happinefs, when they have inveftigated truth. We mud be fatisfied with the beft ufe to which we can apply the myftic terms adopted by credulity ; and fay, that youth, abandoned by their parents in rude and wandering focieties, were induced to unite by that degree of intelligence, called in- ftincl ; and the confequences of fuch union, are obvious. When the principles, obligations, and F a ends V ends of facial connections, are not under* Rood ; the provifions of nature may be peiv verted in their effects. Men and women are differently formed, that by moral neceffity, or indfpenfib'e convenience, or the view of mutual happinefs, they might be united, In conditions, little above brutality, this is not under ftood, Mechanic tendencies, and detached thoughts, produce brutal inftincf ; and they are united by its impulfe. The bo- dily ftrength, vigor, and activity of the man ; uninterrupted health; fortitude; courage; and force of intellect inftead of being, as in nature, advantageoufly contrafted to the foft and delicate conftruction of the woman, the frequent interruptions of her health ; her timidity, tendernefs, fenfibility, and the exquifite nature of her intellect : this beauty or utility in the formation of male and female is loft. In all cafes, extenfive and clear knowledge, feem neceffary to perfect virtue. Ignorance produces mifery ; mifery obliges us to attend and obferve ; expe* rience produces knowledge; and know- ledge virtue. This is the order of nature; and attempts to love: &r to violate, or anticipate its arrangements, are not attended with real or lading advan- tages. The fir ft ftate, is that of ignorance ; which becomes that of error and mifery. In the various nations difcovered by cu- riofity or avarice, we have various fpecimens of the virtues and vices of human nature ; for we find men, in gradations from bru- tality to confiderable knowledge and civi- lization. I know no circumftance by which this gradation may be marked with fo much accuracy and juftice, as the treatment of women. It may be denominated the moral thermometer ; and applied to focieties with the certainty of important information. In fome parts of America, nations are pointed out, whofe bonds of focial union are flight and fcarcely perceptible; they have no fixed fettlements; they move in herds, like brutes ; and nearly for the fame reafons. This ftate of ignorance, exhibits hardly any thing but errors and miferies. The man, finding himfelf in pofleflion of fuperior ftrength, and not having habits of refle6tion, he confiders it as a title to do- minion ; and inftead of protecting or fuc- couring 3S LOVE. couring female weaknefs ; inftead of pro- ducing happinefs by the affection, tender- nefs, and domeftic attention of the woman, he enflaves, or fets her juft above a beaft of burthen. This error is common to the firit efforts of uncultivated minds. If we attend to the morals of public fchools, which thole who prefide in them treat as of lefs importance than the acquifition of languages, we (hall perceive the dawn of fociety, as it opens among favages. All diilindtions in fchools., as focieties, are created by bodily ftrength, courage, and cunning: the boy who has the misfortune to be weak, carrries bur- thens ; performs offices of labor ; and is an oppr.effed, abject (lave. It is thus in the allocations of favages. The men endowed with ftrength ; and defigned for offices re- quiring labor ; . by uiing that ftrength to terrify the women, transfer to them the la- borious duties, and referve themfelves for exercifes, which gratify or amufe. The life of a favage is divided by indolent re-, pole, hunting, and war ; while the culti- vation of the ground, procuring fuel, and pre-. LOVE. 39 preparing provifions, are forced on the wo- man, and added to the nccsiTary and bur- thenibme duties of bearing and nurfing chil- dren. It is difficult to imagine that right and wrong, virtue and vice, are convertible terms, and depend on the caprice, folly, or vices which ufually fabricate the conftitutions of ftates. Writers aflltming philofophcal diftinclionSj have adopted the opinion ; and becaufe good is put for evil and evil for good, they deny their difference, unlefs it be formed by the laws or cuftoms of nations, If there were H not jj} LOVE. not principles and difpqfitions in nature, generally determining the boundaries of right and wrong, advantageous or difad- vantageous ; as they do thofe of pleafure and pain, light and fhadow: if they de- pend wholly on the pafTions and interefts of particular focieties nothing analogous to jujrice could take place in the reciprocal traniactions of communities ; for nothing like a llandard could be inftituted by intel- lectual calculations ; and the world inuft be a fcene of licenfed rapine and iniquity. There is a rude fimilitude in the original conftruc- tion of focieties, which indicates uniformity in the firft fuggeftions of nature concerning- right and wrong ; and notwithstanding the variations of partial interefts, or of advan- tages mifunderftood, mens' ideas of virtue and vice in all great or eflential matters, are umverfally fimilar . When we enquire into the effects of par-* ticular principles, it may be ufeful to look into its hiftory ; to coniider the appearances it affumed under various circumftances ; and to eftimate the influence of opinions, preju- dices, and vicious inftitutions, in checking the LOVE. ffl the tendencies of nature to produce wifdom and happinefs. It is in tliis manner, we difcover truth ; feparate the operations of nature from the fophiftications of art ; and obtain permanent rules of duty. In this way we gradually rife above fervility to prepofTefTions, remove emb'arafling error, and clear the road to happinefs. In this manner, we have treated the fub- je6f. of love ; the moft important principle in human nature, and attended with diffi- culties in proportion to that importance. Nothing marks the fentiments of modern nations, or the doctrines of modern mora- lity, with ftronger characters of barbarifm, than the prevailing apprehenfions of love. Inftead of afllgriihg it, in our fyftems, the firft rank, as it really holds in nature ; we confider it as the occafion of reftraint or prohibition ; and convert into vice, into a fource of poignant mifery, the firfl virtue and blefling of man. We may perceive fome of the reafons, in the fhort hiftory of this principle, given in the laft letter. Its ex- travagance in the periods of chivalry, was a pretence for moralifts to pronounce it H 2 repre- /; LOVE. rcprehenfible. But the fource of the evil is higher. An order of men aroie, in the dark ages immediately fucceeding the dif-* folution of the Roman empire, which, though not unknown, had never been fuf- peeled of aiming at the dominion of the world. Pricfts, of all mythologies, had been the inftruments of power. The oracles of Greece, and the auguries of Rome, had been directedby the ruling adminiitration, party, or individual ; and it had been invariably the obje6l of prudent ambition, to poflefs the prieftefs with proper infpirations, to direct the omens of the augur, t much acquainted with the principle itfelf, is the higheft and mod en- gaging accomplishment. We eafily trace this oppofition into the remains of that ro- mantic fpirit cherifhed by chivalry, and the feverity or reftraint impofed by intereft- ed fuperftition: and it has been attended with various effects, as chearful or gloomy influences have occafionally prevailed . The appearance of order or diforder, in public manners, have generally depended on that occafional prevalence. ( When fuperftition or fanaticifm can frighten profligacy into- confirained 5* LOVE. conftrained order or affected decency, &ri apparent difpoiition to virtue is.aihuned. But the operations of pailions are not lair- ing. Libertinifm rallies its powers ; laughs fuperftition out of credit ; and reilores the triumph of debauchery. Modern nations^ in this refpecl, are marked with fluctuating characters,, according to the fluctuation of thefe cauies. The conititution of a parti- cular government may render its people of- tentatious ; ftimulate their ambition, or re- gulate their manners, by a falie fentiment of honor. Here fuperftition will be confi- ned to the ignorant, the poor and the op- preffed ; and the prevailing manners will be attractive and orientations. Gallantry ^'ill be the character, of inch a nation, lb far as it relates to love. Another government may, in its forms, approach nearer to nature, or to thofe prin- ciples which are the reiult of fcientific in- veitigation. Such an inftitution will profeis to excite ambition and regulate manners, partly by a fimilar fpecies of honor, partly by fuperftition under the name of religion, and partly by virtuous principles. Com- pared LOVE. 57 pared with the effects of the former govern- ment, the general manners may be lefs inclined to gallantry, and infliiencad by principles of moxpermanent utility. The former would provide the region for youth- ful diffipation ; the latter might afford a better chance to thofe who would render their firft and ftrongeft paffions, the means of happinefs for life. To judge of thefe opinions, we fhould recollect, that nations retaining the milita- ry fpirit which diftinguifhed the times of chivalry, retain fome things fimilar to the manners in romances, and are diftinguifh- ed by, what we call, gallantry. Other nations, who had originally taken more popular forms, as they gradually become monarchical, military and fuperftitious, lofe the firfl: portions of rough fincerity, and affume, in the treatment of the fair fex,- the language and manners of gallantry. In modern nations, gallantry is the fubftitute of love ; for it is the general agent which effects voluntary connections; Marriages, by authority, intereft, avarice, or the grofier paffions, have hardly any I thing S3 LOVE. L thing to diftinguifh them from thofe effected by the fame means in all nges ; and having no relation to love, we mult not refer to it, any of the connexions they occafion. The tendencies or inclinations of nature, when retrained by the inftitutions of men, are to be found in their cuftoms, or their vices. Modern governments having employed their utmoft art, in preventing marriage from choice and affection, or in difcredit- ing the paffion of love as the bond of do- meftic union ; like a torrent violently im- peded, it lias biirft its way in other direc- tions : being denied its influence in bring- ing men and women together for happinefs, it puts on the mafque of gallantry, and brings them together for pleafure. In modern language, there is an import- ant difference betv/een pleafure and happi- nefs. Happinefs is generally referred to Utopia, or the Mileenium : and pleafure is not, as in nature, an ingredient or portion of happinefs; but a detached fenfation, either bodily or mental ; without attention to its caufes or confequences. This deferves the ferious attention of your Lordfhip ; as modern LOVE. S9 dern manners are influenced by the error ; and it is fupported by the abilities of p'hila.- fophers, who are popular, becanfe they de- nominate the principle of morality either fentiment or common-fenfe. Feeling is the inftrument of experience : reafon is the guide of life. For the fenfi* bility being exercifed by error as well as by truth, it. may lead us to vices as well as to virtues ; and it cannot afford a rule to be depended on, like the voice of reafon, fug- gefted by circumftances relating to the whole of life, or to the general intereft of man. Sentiment, however, is the principle of gallantry: reafon is the principle of love. I mean, that perfons difKnguimed by gallan- try, are influenced merely by fentiment - they feek pleafure in any of its forms,- and their object is immediate gratification: while thofe who are united by affection, feek the direction of reafon, to guard, multiply, and perpetuate their fatisfaction. The diftinc- tion of brutes and men, is that of fentiment and reafon. Brutes are all fentimental.. I 2 they 6c LOVE. they are governed by feeling, or the fimple recollection of feeling. Their fyftem is that of gallantry, feeking the repetition of pleafurable fentiment, without provifion for the intervals of ftrong impreffions. That fentiment is not the rule of life in the commerce of men and women, we may prefume from obferving thofe who adopt it among the mod wretched of mankind. A life confuting of fmall portions occupied by lively fenfations, and great portions occu- pied by difguft, regret, wearinefs and ap- prehenfion, is extremely miferable. Men and women of gallantry, have never pretended to be happy. The intervals of their plea- furable fenfations ; folitude, reflection and reafon ; torture them even in apprehenfion : yet they neceiTarily occupy the greater por- tions of their lives. Their ftudy therefore, is to Ihorten the intervals of fentiment ; and to vary and multiply the moft poignant emotions. The moft confummate ikill in this matter, will not anfwer the purpofe: for pleafures cloy by frequent repetition ; and flrong emotions debilitate conftitutions moil: LOVE. 61 moft fufceptible of them : they hafrcn de- crepitude and death ; objefts of perpetual terror to men of fentiment and pleafure. I have the honor to be, My Lord, > */ Your moft obedient, And very humble fervant, The AUTHOR. . gnorrrs iiuitoi : nolii LETTER 6* MARRIAGE. LETTER VI. My Lord, E have confidered the union of man and woman, as intended to be brought on by inclination and choice. In- clination, and the power of chufmg, give fife to the affection of love ; which is the beft and moft ufeful affection in the human mind. But it is with affections, as with the productions of the earth ; they cannot be cherifhed in improper foils. Conftitu- tions of government, and fyftems of reli- o-ion, are to principles of morality, what climates are to trees or herbs or flowers ; and in the moral as well as the natural world, things alter and even change by a change of circumftances or fituations. This we have feen in the kind of hiftory which we have given of the paffion of love ; or the principle which has united men and women. At one time, it has been, a brutal ap- petite, MARRIAGE. H petite, confident with brutal and fava?e cruelty. At another, it has mounted Into the fublimity and madnefs of romantic adoration ; from which it has again fallen into a civilized kind of brutality called gal- lantry, intrigue, and debauchery. Fcr the difference between a Mate of favage bruta- lity, and civilized gallantry, is not fo great in fa& as in appearance. Women are the mere inftntments of low and temporary fen- iuality ; they are in common, pofleffed by as many perfons as will flatter or purchafe them ; and they are Haves nearly alike in both cafes : for they hold their influence, their pleafures, and even their fupport, by the precarious tenure of the caprice of men. The brutes who are not formed into com- munities, are incapable of all thofe fuperior and exquifite pleafures which we denomi- nate refilled ; live in that ftate of promif- cuous conneaion, which may be called a ftate of gallantry ; a juft, though a rude re- prefentation of a life of pleafure. Where laws, prejudices, and cuftoms are in oppofition to nature, it will feek a kind d'f indemnification in gallantry, libertinifm, or 6* MARRIAGE. or debauchery. Indeed the vices arifing in modern governments from the effe6ts of love, feem to be all owing to unnatural or iniquitous cuftoms and laws ; and gallantry and intrigue are the indemnities which men and women refer ve to themfelves for the injuftice or injuries they have received. - Though the idea of being property, or parts of our goods and chattels, be exploded from our philofophy and from fome of our laws, it ftill remains in our prepofleffions or cus- toms, counteracted by a little fenfelefs and romantic gallantry. It does not offend a man's confcience ; it is not reprehenfible by his parents ; it is not difhonorable ; it is not punifhable by law that he fhould feduce an unfufpicious, artlefs, or affectionate girl ; that he fhould deprive her of that cha- pter, without which even he would difef- teem or diflike her ; that he fhould involve her in difhonor and infamy, which no re- pentance, no good behaviour can remove : while he would be executed, if he forcibly entered her habitation, or took away fom.3 paltry parts of her drefs or property. The crime is always contrived and committed by the MARRIAGE. % the man ; the punifhment and the infamy are borne by the woman. Thefe are the principles of Europe ; on thefe all the na- tions of it act in refpea to women ; what- ever may be their laws or their religions. We fay, truth, juftice, and honor, are ne- ceflary to the exiftence of focieties, and to the various connections which form them ; and we totally banilh thofe virtues, from the firft, the raoft important, and mod facred intercourfe of life. Are we to wonder men brought up with fuch ideas of privi- lege or licenfe, and fecure of impunity, Ihould commit daily outrages on the happi- nefs of the world ? Are we to wonder, wo- men degraded from their juft or natural equality ; deprived of their rights ; betray- ed by artifice to be configned to infamy; ihould, on their part, forget or difcard the virtues which they would rejoice to practice in better fituations ? In vain do we call the art of falfe reafon- ing to our aid, in a warfare againft na- ture. We gravely fay, what is called virtue in this cafe is of much greater import- ance to women than to men. This is K faHc : 66 MARRIAGE. falfe : for no poftible injury can arife from the vices of women, which do not arife from thofe of men ; nay are occafioned or produced by them. Indeed, fmce I have attentively and impartially confidered the matter, I have felt the warmed indignation, at the abandoned afiurance of a man, who pretended to refent the infidelity of his wife, when I have known his conduct to be a feries of infamous injuries to her. That has been the cafe in every inftance under my obfervation. It has been the cafe in thofe numerous procefles, which have afto- nifhed or amufed the public ; and which have been purfued with the fame barbarous iniquitous fpirit that pervades the prin- ciples of our morals and laws. But I muft not go' too far on this branch of the fubjecl. I would have your Lord- ihip obferve, I do not intend thefe general obfervations as an apology for conjugal in- fidelity. I account for it ; in order to fix your attention on a real and effectual reme- dy. I know no offence fo great againft na- ture, againft God i no crime which indi- cates a heart fo infenfible to the ftrongeft and MARRIAGE. 7 and mod pleafmg affeclions ; no difpofition fo unworthy of all the efteem and confidence which bind us to each other ; or fo direct- ly leading to total depravity and wretched- nefs, as conjugal infidelity. But it mud be obvious to every one who is not ftrangely perverted by vicious cuftoms and laws, that when all truth, honor and juftice are aban- doned by one party, they muft fbon be abandoned by the other. It is time we mould turn our views from the errors and vices occafioned by hu- man inftitutions, to the pleafmg and bene- ficient difpoiitions of nature. Indeed in this, as in many other cafes, the profpe&s of wade or wretched nefs are numerous, thofe of real beauty or happinefs are few, and . perceived or relifhed only by uncor- rupted and cultivated minds. Social vir- tues do not arife immediately from iimple fenfations or fimple ideas ; or there would be no difficulty in afcertaining their princi- ples and pointing out their neceffity. If a life of focial virtue were only a feries of detached fenfations, the moil ftupid and wretched mind ; fo trifling a thing as a K 2 man 6& MARRIAGE. man of pleafure ; nay, a brute might per- ceive its advantages. But when we enter fociety, our morality becomes a com p ex, fcience ; and our pleafures if we have any, are multiplied by reflection. The difficulty in becoming virtuous and happy as iocial beings, is exactly the difficulty of riling from the ftate of brutes to that of men ; the difficulty of bj'.ieving that the pleafures of fenfe are infinitely enhanced, when uni- ted to thofe of reafon. I know this is aiming too high, for the prefent morality, or the preient philofophy ; which is content to fnatch its pleafures, becaufe nature will be obeyed ; or to abftain from them, becaufe the law, or the devil hold before men the profpecl: of fhame or (Jeftruclion. Their hearts are therefore alternately occupied by defire and appre- henfion ; by temporary pleafure, which is ever fucceeded by terror and remorfe. It would be folly to talk to thefe perfons of pleafures they have never tafted ; which they confider as ideal ; and of which it is hardly poffible they ffrould be induced to make trial, A man acccuftomed to fimple fenfations ; marriage: 63 fenfations ; governed wholly by fentimentV or what is called common-fenfe hears of reflected pleafures, of the happinefs to be procured by reafon and the uniform prac- tice of virtue, with the fame effecl that a brute attends to mufic, or a bigot to a benevolent defcription of heaven. All morality is founded on pleafure. Thfe is a principle, which no fpecies of fuperiU- tion ; no philofophic chicane, has been able to difcredit. All men in all puriuits feek pleafure ; this is an invariable and eternal law of nature. On this law varioufly inter- preted, all men, in their lenfes, are agreed. This pleafure confifts either of fimple detached fenfations, feelings, or fenii- ments ; without intention, without plan, and without relation to each other: or it confifts of fenfations, multiplied by defign, by a plan which gives them reciprocal rela- tions ; by the conftant guidance or direc- tion of reafon. Here men are divided. The common votaries of pleafure fay, things are to be taken as they may occur ; prefent pleafure is not to be foregone ; that happi- nefs depends on the quantity and variety of thofe 70 MARRIAGE, thofe pleafures, we have the good fortune to feize as their occafions arife ; that the inter- pofition of reafon is a prejudicial reilraint ; and that views or confederations extending to the whole of lite, or to its moral relations and duties, are inconfiftent with enthuiiafm, the foul of pleafure, and are never united to that feniibility, without which it can have no exigence. This is the creed of tiie mul- titude. It is the principle of all the infaicr animals : and of that great majority of man- kind, who occupy the borders of brutal and rational life. So far it may. be faii to be natural ; as it neceffarily arifes from the firft and general fituations of favage or wandering nations. Brutes live promif- cuoufly ; becaufe they have not acquired talents and reafon to render domeilic fo- ciety, or domeftic virtue, the lource of pleafure. Savages act in a fimilar manner for a fhnilar reafon. Men and women of gallantry, in all the variations of what is called a itate of civilization, adopt theufages of favages and brutes, becaufe they have not fufficient experience and reafon to dif- cern, that by adopting the genuine princi- ples MARRIAGE. 71 pies and rational regulations of domeftic fo- ciety, they heighten and multiply their' pleafures. They who have ftudied the laws of na- ture, not only in the fimple propenfities by which fhe firft acts, but in thofe combina- tions which form focial principles ; who have felt their pleafures heighten, become more interefting and more numerous as they advanced in paths of virtue; who have found themfelves becoming more free by obferving the regulations of reafon, and more happy by facrificing prefent and fingle pleafures to thofe which may be at fome dif- tance, but of great importance, complica- ted with gratifications of the mod intereft- ing nature : thefe perfons have ever held the promifcuous commerce of favage bru- tality, or of civilized gallantry, in abhor- rence; and have fought the virtues, as the inftruments of pleafure. But their num- bers are fmall ; too inconfiderable to fur- nifh examples for general imitation; nay, too inconfiderable to give their experience and principles an air of probability, or a chance of obtaining refpecl: and influ- ence. 72 MARRIAGE. ence. Habits formed in ignorant or xW cious focieties are io prevalent ; and exam- ples of men a6ting on rational and focial views are fo few, that libertinifm triumphs, and reafon or virtue put in claims with modefty and referve. Thefe claims, however, have been always well fupported ; they have influenced the principles of the barbarous, as well as li- centious forms of governments ; they have had the fan6fions of all religions ; they have checked the profligacy of public manners ; they have been avowed and acted upon by the wifeft and moft excellent perfons who have ever appeared in the world. We need not therefore be afraid of the farcafms of licentious wit ;' we need not ap- prehend being ridiculed as fuperftitious, if we after t, that love is not defigned to be a temporary paftime ; or the inftrument of gratification merely fenfual ; but a princi- ple of union in man and woman to continue during life. Religious legiflators have imagined ihtip perceived this truth ; and they have en* joined, under, the ianclion of penalties in this MARRIAGE. 73 this world and of damnation in another, that when man and woman are united, they fnall never be ieparated but by one offence. Nothing could have been imagined more effectually to coi interact the intentions of mir/a >;e, fhaa nidi a law. Nature plainly inn pate*) Eke, only method to fecure domef- tic ao \ ^ NppSnefe, is to form our con-. nc.t ; c^ pp auction or principle; which, in prouu .: g c< Y 2*1 love, the mntfincere and mo--' bite J e Ing friend-lip, the recipro- cal and t n.^r attachments of parents and ch'ldren, b others and fitters heigthen and muhi^y all cur pleafures. If we obey this direction, we are fure to be happy ; if we difobey, we have no reafon to expeel hap- pinefs. But nature is not fufficiently wife or prudent, according to the church or the law. They have enjoined, that men and women muft continue together ; notbecaufe they love each other, or are likely to be happy ; but becaufe they are united ; becaufe myftical words have been pronounced over them ; and heaven has been fuppofed to witnefs their contract. L The 74 MARRIAGE. The very breath of a priefl: has ever Teemed malignant to the happinefs of man. This is the triumph of fuperftitious artifice over reafon and the affe6tions of the heart. Nothing has ever been contrived fo effec- tually to oppofe the intentions of reafon ; to deftroy the beft affections of men ; to warp them by authority and intereft ; or to drive them by defpair into all the excefles of" proftitution or debauchery as the im- politic, the barbarous cuftom of forcing thofe whofe folly has made them wretched, to continue wretched to the end of life. It is a common effe6t of ignorance or im- pofture to endeavor or pretend to obtain the ends of nature, by different means from thofe pointed out by her evident laws. God has ordered or difpofed that man and woman mould be united by mutual affection ; that the affection fhould give a charm to all the pleafurable circumftances arifing from their union. Here the Almigh- ty hath left us to render ourfelves happy ; here men fhould have left us : but avarice and ambition profit by mifleading and tor- menting us. The MARRIAGE. 73 The Almighty hath provided, when the firft tranfports from having found another part of ourfelves; when the firft joys from the diicovery of a mind and heart fit to be blcn lecj with our own, and worthy of the tendered love ; when thefe lively but na- tural emotions are meliorated into that ferene and namelefs delight which fubfifts in minds perfectly fatisiied with their union new relations arife, new affections are produced, and new ties are formed in our hearts, by the birth and education of children. Brutes have not this privilege ; nor have lavages, or men of pleafure, who live like brutes. They come together by mere appetite ; and the fruits- of temporary or promifcuous commerce, are regarded without delight ; perhaps with corroding doubts, fufpicions, or hatred ; and are either neglected, or con- figned to infamy and vice. But all connec- tions, without that affection, which may be truly and properly called love; whether effe6ted by the authority of parents, by views of intereft, or by luff, however fanc- tified by fu perditions or legal forms, are vrostitutions; offences againlt nature ; and L 2 therefore 7 6 MARBIAGE. therefore neceFarily productive of mifery. The, Deity hath provided, when the firft enchanting links o. mu ual aiTeclion -and pa- rental love have u liied us ; we fuould be more endeared to each other, by every inftance of care and afte61ion in the edu- cation of our children. Nothii.g [o errec- tually charms the mind into a fettled ef- teem, as concurrence in an employment, fo beneficent, fo delightful, as the care or education of our own offspring. This is a work of fo much importance, and requir- ing fo much time, that it contributes more than any thing towards perpetuating our union. The neceflary duties to one child are fucceeded by the neceflary duties to an- other ; until we have transferred, as it were, our whole fouls into our offspring ; paf- fionately love each other again in our feveral images or representatives ; and live only to make ourfelves happy through the hap- pinefs of our children. It is thus we may be faid to be renewed ; or to be made young again. We view the progrefs of an infant mind, the fources and growth of its affec- tions, with more pleafure than is expert enced MARRIAGE. 77 enced by itfelf. We intereil ourfelves in thofe great paffions which determine. the events of life ; we forget our infirmities, we imagine ourfelves in love again becaufe our children are enamoured ; and we be- come fathers and mothers a fecond time, when they afliime thofe happy denomi- nations. Compare, if you can, the events of what is called a life of pleafure, with fuch as thefe. And when nature is decompos- ing ; when infirmities or diforders menace diflblution you may fee the man who has a6ted on the felfifh and brutal principle of gratifying himfelf at the expence of truth, honour, and the happinefs of others, curfing a world which detefts or defpifes him ; deferted by all, by the very inftru- ments of his pleafures, becaufe univerfally difefteemed ; and finking into the grave in ignominy or frantic wretchednefs : while thofe men and women who have gone hand in hand in the pleafing duties of life, will not only have a firm fupport in honorable re- collections ; but will be led down its rugged declivity, by the tenderer!: care of an af- fectionate offspring ; and will confign them- felves 78 MARRIAGE, felves to reft, like iifeful labourers, a little weary, but iatisfied with the work of the day. I have the honor to be, My Lord, Your Lordfhip's, -Moft obedient, And moft humble fervant, The AUTHOR, > io J i LETTER JDULTERT. 79 LETTER VII. My Lord, ON the fubjec~t of love, we have re- garded principally the abufes or corruptions of that paffion introduced by human religions and laws. It is ufual, on the fubjecl, to attempt defcriptions, of fuch a flate as might take place, if the difpo- fitions of nature were to have their effect. But as the moft beautiful and pleafmg de- fcriptions of that kind have ever been at- tended with little or no moral influence, I thought it might have better effects to point out to your Lordfhip the origin or caufes of the vices and miferies I wifh to have re- moved, than to amufe the fancy with ideal fcenes, on which men have no difpofitions or capacities to enter. For I look on a perfon, whofe heart has been vitiated, or whofe affections have been depraved in his- 8c; ADULTERY.. his intercourfe with women, to be as inca- pable of conceiving any idea of that pleafing principle, which unites and keeps toge- ther, during life, affectionate and deferving minds ; as a brute is to conceive the fatis- faction arifing from the truths of mathema- tics and aftronomy, or what is juftly deno- minated fcientiflc pleafure. Give the brute his wretched lubfiftence, and he thinks of nothing higher : give the fenfualift the immediate gratification of the loweft or coarfefi appetites, and he will affect to def- pife fatisfactions of the mind, which he has never comprehended, or pleafures of the heart, which he never could have felt. The difference between the ftates of men governed by their firft fenfations, and when governed by combined and reflected fenti- timents, is fo great, that it has given proba- bility and influence to the idea, that man* confifls of two Jlrrerent beings, a foul and a body. When he is governed by fimple or and grofs fenfations, he is faid to confnlt on- ly the pleafure of the body, or to be directed by that body ; when his attention is to more complicated, more exquifite, and internal fenfations, he is faid to be under the govern- ment ADULTERS 81 merit of the foul. This doctrine has its apparent conveniences and inconveniencies, which may be very proper fubjecls of con- fideration. Our bufinefs at prefent is only to give weight or credit to the diftinction w r e make between fimpie and complex fen- fations ; between the immediate or grofs impreflions made on the outward fenfes* and thofe made through them on the finer organs of reflection (whatever their names) and thence returned, multiplied, or dif- fused through the whole human frame. This conftitutes precifely the difference be- tween a mere animal, a mere fenfualift, and a rational or virtuous man. They are both actuated by fenfations. Thofe of the former are fimpie, grofs, confined to out- ward fenfes ; they are indulged at random, and have happy or miferable confequences, as may happen : thofe of the latter are firft fimpie, but natural and juft ; they are coveted, partly on their own account, but principally on account of thofe efte6ts pro- duced by combinations of them, or by that power acting on and directing them* which is called reflection. They have, there- M fore, 83 ADULTERT. fore, been among the greateft enemies of mankind, who not only diftinguifhed be- tween the body and the mind, but fet them at variance; made the pleafures of fenfe, and the duties of reafon inconfiftent. Virtue cannot be better defined, than as the economy of our pleafures ; the art of improving them ; the fcience of refining, perfecting, and rendering permanent the moft voluptuous fenfuality. But it is an art ; it is a fcience ; and none but adepts poffefs it. The reafon, that men in general grovel in low pleafures, or are ftrangers to virtue, is ignorance ; fuch as prevents an Indian from failing in a fhip, or meafuring his time by a watch. To thofe who have had fome experience on this fubjecl; who have underftanding to make experience furnilh data for reafon ; it will feem probable, the union of man and woman, formed, regulated, and preferved by this voluptuous art, this pleafurable fcience, which alone deferves the name of virtue is the beft foundation for that focial and perfect happinefs which all wifti for, though but few enjoy. Mutual ADULTERY. 83 Mutual wants, which may be called mu- tual defects, produce warm and tender de- fires : thefe fixed by tafte, imagination and reaion, produce paffion ; which produces friendfhip ; which re-produces or re-ani- mates paffion to the end of life. This Is the marriage of nature ; ib wifely provided for ; arranged in caufes and effects of fo exquifite and delicate a kind, that the in- terpofitions of human art or policy, the interference of law or of religion, have generally had the effects of rude violence and injury. Indeed they mull appear to a true philofopher, like the attempts of lions or bears to re-adjuft the parts, or to improve the difpofition of the human brain . A declaration of love anfwered by a de- claration or confeffion of love, is the moft folemn, the moft facred, the moft binding engagement into which it is poffible for a man and woman to enter. It muft be under ftood, the perfons making it, pledge their truth and honor, that they are mutu- ally poffeffed of thofe defires, or that paf- on whic h is the proper principle of lading M 2 attachment ; 8.i ADULTERY. attachment ; that they have each found a counterpart for the other ; and mean to enter into that tender and affectionate friendfhip, which is to constitute the great bleffing of their lives. Compare the terms and importance of ihis engagement, with thofe civil obligations, a failure which fub- jects a man to puniihment, ignominy or death ; compare them with t e confidera- tions which determine us to acknowledge moral obligations and you will perceive that nature holds adultery among the blackeft and moil enormous crimes. If we think a man an enemy to fociety, or to be cut off from it, who violates juitice in de- frauding us of our property, or violently feizing it what mutt he deferve who fails in obligations much more facred, much more important ; into which he has openly and deliberately entered : or by artifice deprives another of a blcfllng, with which the poffeffion of all the riches in the world, can bear no. co:nparifon. But thefe are imaginary cafes. We fel- dom or never fee real happinefs forfeited by tjie. parties themfelves, or broken in upon by ADULTERT. 8 5 by others. Marriages are generally made by the influence or authority of parents; and their children are only actors who have parts given them, fometimes very difficult to ftudy, to digeft, or to perform. The common opinions and laws therefore in regard to adultery, are in a high degree favage and tyrannical. For they fuppofe thole guilty of violating truth honor and juftice, who were not at liberty to make engagements ; and treat them as worthlefs , or abandoned, for having extinguifhed af- fections they were not allowed to cherifh, and forfeited happinefs they could never have expereienced, or of which they had no hope. As it would be unjuft to make a performer, who recites a bad part on the theatre, wholly anfwerable for the faults of the author ; fo it is favage and cruel to make thofe young perfons who are forced into unhappy marriages, anfwerable for the con- fequences of crimes, they would have been very glad not to have committed. In (lead therefore of devifing laws to render more infamous and wretched the victims of ava^ rice or ambition, wife legiflators fhould have 8<5 ADULTERT. have had thofe parents punifhed, and pu- nifhed exemplarily, for the incontiner.cy or profligacy of children they had meanly or inhumanly proftituted How can it be expected, a fon or a daughter who is in- tru6ted by its family, that all inclinations and all principles muft give way to autho- rity or intereft, and who is forced or de- ceived into a difagreeable connection for life ; fhould on a hidden afliime all the virtues of a moral character ; all the fenfi- bility which is the ground of affection and friendfhip ; or all the truth, fidelity and goodnefs necelfary to a6l up to its obliga- tions ? Indeed young people are feldom brought into this fituation without previous opportunities to refill: the exercife of fuch authority ; and the common crime of incon- tinency is not fo much in eloping as in mar- rying. In proportion therefore as they have aflented or feemed to aflent to the mean or abominable facriflce ; they ought to (hare in its miferable and infamous confequences. But under the management of bad pa- rents or avaricious relations, the crimes of incontinency and adultery become probable and ADULTERT. 87 and necefiary confequences, not only when young perfons are forced to unite them- ielves contrary to their inclinations ; but when to avoid fuch violence, they are obliged to have recourfe to fecret correfpondences or clandeftine marriages. Stolen matches are feldom happy ; for very good reafons. The parties have not opportunities to be- come lufficiently acquainted with each other ; their connections are perhaps owing to the dread of being forced into fituations they deteft, and cemented by refiftance or ill ulage. There is a charm to young and generous minds in being fellow-fufferers, which forms an attachment or affection, very eafily miftaken for love. All their correfpondence and commerce are car- ried on in that kind of hurry or obfcu- rity, which is ever unfavourable to judg- ment or choice. We accordingly fee men and women hazarding every thing for each other, on a flight fecret or ftolen acquaint- ance; and when marriage gives them lei- fure to behold what they have done; to con- sider or know each other ; they are aftoniflied at 88 ADULTERT. at their folly, and driven by defpair into the excefles of profligacy. Yet the imprudence itfelf would not be fo fatal, if an indifference or difregard to truth, a habit of infincerity, artifice, and intrigue, were not formed by the necelTity of fecret correfpondence. A woman, who will be prevailed upon to deceive her pa- rents, may be prevailed upon to deceive her hulband ; and a man who takes pains to teach her that art, is deftitute of the eflen- tial requifites to conjugal happinefs : he never can have her confidence ; he has under- mined the foundation of her fidelity, and he has mrnifhed the fecret and the inclination to betray him. They who marry by intrigue, often fix the habits of infincerity or artifice fo deeply in their minds, that intrigues be- came neceflliry ; they lofe all talte for plea- fures, which are the refult of natural or honourable affections ; and relifh none but fuch as are purchafed by fome wretched ar- tifice, or matched from fome hazardous and alarming fituation. The art of conducting intrigues, or of hazarding and efcaping the dangers attend- ing ADULTERS %9 ingthem, is very fimilar to the art of war. Both are unnatural in their principles or obje&s ; both confift of ftratagems or ha- zards, which create quick fucceffions of lively fenfations ; and both have charms to iimilar minds. Indeed it is remarkable, the fame vitiated tafte, and the fame mediocrity of genius, which lead to the profeffion of a foldier, generally leek happinefs in the little arti- fices or perils of intrigue. Women of lively imaginations ; with fufficient talents to be vain of them, and unfurnifhed by educa- tion with the eflential principles of good- nefs are dazzled or enamoured of thefe artificial but brilliant characters ; and eafily adopt the fpirit and artifice, which render them proper counterparts to them. Here we fee vice become an art ; and we know there is a kind of gratification in practifing any art of which we are in pof- felhon. Hence many of thofe deviations; thofe adventures apparently capricious, for which it is fo difficult to account. It is not uncommon for a man or woman, to hazard N reputa- &> ADULTERT. reputation, peace, or life, for a connection, which is no fooner made, than it lofes its charm ; and the parties fly to new hazards in purfuit of new obje&s. We are not to wonder fuch perfons are enraptured during their moments of fondnefs, at one time with one kind of beauty, at another time with another; at one time fmelling to a rofe, at another delighted with a poppy : making no diftinction between wit and folly ; or even between youth and age ; but con- templating with equal tendernefs and the fame temporary fufpicious paffion, luft lurking in furrows, and the loves or graces fporting in dimples. The pleafure is in the art, in the conduct of the intrigue : not in the object: which, if an angel, muftfoon be changed for the pleafure of purfuing another. 'Such perfons foon become inca- pable of love, friendfhip, or any attachment requiring true or genuine feniibility, na- tural and lafting affections, fincerity, truth, or fidelity : for the principles of their art,, tfre cunning, falfehood, an infenfibility to the fufierings of others, and a difregard to- the ADULTERY. 91 the moft pleafing and facred ties which unite the hearts of mankind. It is extremely unhappy, when intereft, ambition, or any other improper motive, induces fuch perfons to marry ; unlefs they fhould afibciate like with like : for then they may agree on mutual licence and libertinifm* or they may plague and punifh each other as they deferve, by mutual fufpicion, mutual recrimination, and mutual difhonor. Pride, vanity, prodigality, and avarice, are common fources of various iniquities; and the common caufes of adultery. Thefe, however, are obvious ; have been often in- fixed upon ; and we are aware of their dan- ger : but there exifts a caufe, the danger of which is feldom apprehended; it has the greater! influence in tender and excellent minds ; and it promifes happinefs in all cafes with fo much plaufibility, that it fecurely leads men in the paths of vice, of hope, of difappointment, and of mifery, to the end of life. This is an exquifite extreme ienfibility to the minute attentions or in- attentions of thofe we love; and an ex- N 2 peclation c,s ADULTERT. peculation of the continuance of thofe ami-* able arts wh ; ch were firft made life of to gain our affections. The difference be- tween lovers and hufbands ; between mif- trefles, who are' candidates for our .hearts, and wives who have gained them is the occafion of great unhappinefs in marriage, and often leads to the violation of its en- gagements. Nothing can more effectually mortify a mind of real fenfibility, and con- fcious of its merit, than to perceive itfelf neglected, becaufe it is pouched ; to lofe either at once, or gradually, all that tender folicitude, thofe paffionate attentions, which had been ufed to get pofleffion of it. Indeed it fhews a fhameful, though comr mon weaknefs, to difregard an object we have taken great pains, and been extremely defirous to obtain, merely becaufe we have obtained it. When pofleffion is not, as it femetimes may be, the occafion of diffipating an illufion, or of unmafking artful and bad minds, the natural confequence is fatisfac- tion, not indifference or difguft. In nature ; in reafon ; and in all pleafures regulated ADULTERS C) S regulated by nature and reafon, the means are inferior to the end. In the intercourfes of men and women, whofe paflions are na> tural, or difpofed to be the inftruments of happinefs, the end is more delightful than the means ; and the happinefs of pofleffion is diverted of anxious doubts, is more pure, more fatisfa61ory, than any pleafures which preceded it. Little minds are incapable of any but lit- tle pleafures ; and not being able to furnifli or to enjoy happinefs, they endeavour to fubftitute a variety of fhort delights ; and, knowing none higher than thofe of court- fhip, they feek a repetition of them in in- trigue. Hence the deviation and fall of many, who feemed deftined for better things. It muft be owned, the failure in this cafe, is generally on the fide of men. Women, who are not firft proftituted by their pa- rents in what is called the holy ftate of ma- trimony, are generally difpofed to be affec- tionate, faithful, and happy: but the com- mon licentioufnefs of men, deftroys all fuch difpofitions, and renders poffeffion the grave of 94 ADULTERY. of love. It is much to the honour of wo- men, that while men are univerfally aban- doned, many oi them are virtuous. I fpeak in the behalf of women ; becaufe it is juft to be on the fide of the opprefled. They generally ftruggle hard to extend the atten- tions and tendernefs of courtfhip through the whole of life ; and feldom become un- faithful, till after repeated injuries. But when totally difappointed ; when outraged in every pleafmg hope ; and gradually giv- ing way to grief and defpair what an af- fecting object is an amiable woman- thus circumftanced ! Kow very likely to engage the love of a generous man ! And if he dif- covers it, how very likely to give him up a heart which has been cruelly diftrefled or caft away ! What confiderations are there to prevent this crime ; and who mould have the blame of it? Our wanton licentioufnefs and tyranny mould have all its infamy and all its mifery. Hence the ridicule of thofe men who are thus difhonoured ; and the iheer at the name of cuckold: this is juft ; for men are the caufes ; and women well treated, would hardly ever go aftray. However ADULTERT. 95 However this may be, men and women, when incapable of happinefs, or difappoint- ed in their hopes of it, fubftitute the little temporary pleafures of repeated courtfhipSj and neceffarily facrifice their honor to enter into intrigues. This is the very region of delufion, to fuch minds as have more ima- gination than judgment, or more fenfibi- lity than underftanding. The objects of intrigue, are like fairy forms and unfub- ftantial fhadows. They place themfelves always in the mod advantageous light, be- caufe they have only a temporary appear- ance to make. They ferve to reanimate the hopes of thofe who have been difappointec! in better things ; they engage them in the activity of purfuit ; they furnifh them with the delights of flattery and courtfhip ; and they are no fooner grafped, than they dif-* appear or difguft; while other objects flart tip, create other hopes, other pleafures, and other difappointments ; until the fenfibility be worn out, the whole frame exhibit haggard and cadaverous appearance ; until the mind be foured into an ill opinion or hatred B G ADULTERT. hatred of the world, the moil favorable td Iniquity, and the moft unhappy to it's pof- feffor ; until the heart become wholly aban- doned and profligate. What a (long contraft between this, the moft favorable, defcription of what is called a ftate of pleafure, and that affeaionate love, that fincere and tender friendfhip, to be found only in the connexions of fincere and excellent minds ; and rendered perma- nent as our exiftence by thofe qualities which occafioned them. What a difference between the filly or artful flatteries of a fpecious libertine, who may amufe, and daz- zle and deceive for awhile, but who will not bear infpeclion; who avoids attachments; and means to faerifice every thing to his prefent convenience and gratification, or to the affeaed carefles of a proftitute, which have been repeated on every dupe who had no difcernment and tafte to be difgufted with them what a difference betwen thefe and the well-grounded afFe6tion r the de- ferved approbation, and heart-felt attach- ment of the beft and tendered friends? What ADULTERY. gy What facrifices therefore are made, what follies committed, by the common purfuits of infidelity and adultery ? I need not point out to your Lordfhip the confequences of thefe crimes. At this time, it would be like defcribing mnfhine, or fhewing what conftitutes day. They all prove the expediency of my application to your Lordfhip, to exert your inter eft and influence in the revifion and correction of the Englifh laws, reflecting the authority of parents, their power of difpofing their property, and the various modes by which they may controul or direct the marriages of their children. At this time, the abufe of parental autho- rity, and of the laws reflecting marriage, are the general caufes of infidelity to the marriage vow. How that authority may be regulated : or what laws may be fub- flituted for ftatutes which now dishonour our national character, and banifh virtue and happinefs from our dwellings, I will not fuggeft. When your Lordfhip has in- duced, what is called the Wifdom of Par- O liament, 8 ADULTERT. J - lianient, to deliberate on thefe fubje6ts I may exercife the privilege of a Briton ; and again obtrude fome of my opinions on your Lordfhip. I am, my Lord, Your Lordfhip's moil obedient, And very humble lervant, The AUTHOR. FINIS. 3 1158 00486 0168