MEDICI POPES HERBERT M. VAUGHAN UCSB LIBRARY 7 /3 /(jto fl-V 6? THE MEDICI POPES Alinari LEO X, CARDINAL G1ULIO DE' MEDICI (CLEMENT VII) AND CARDINAL DE' ROSSI THE MEDICI POPES (LEO X. AND CLEMENT VII.) BY HERBERT M. VAUGHAN, B.A. AUTHOR OF " THE LAST OF THE ROYAL STUARTS," ETC. WITH TWENTY ILLUSTRATIONS METHUEN & CO. 36 ESSEX STREET W.C. LONDON First Published in 1908 3n dfcemoriam PIAM ET SEMPER VIRENTEM FRATRIS CARISSIMI J. P. V. QUI AD ALTERAM VITAM NUPER TRANSIVIT HUNC DEDICAT LIBRUM AUCTOR MOESTISSIMUS MCMVIII PREFACE A' THOUGH the names of the two great Popes of the House of Medici loom large in the annals of the Italian Renaissance, yet the private side of their lives and conduct has naturally been dwelt upon with less insistence by the papal historian than the leading part they took in the development of Italian politics or in the course of the Reformation throughout Europe. Even in William Roscoe's elaborate biography of Leo X., the figure of that famous pontiff is largely overshadowed by the momentous episodes of his reign both within and without Italy; "one cannot see the wood for the intervening trees ! " In the present volume, therefore, I have made the attempt of presenting to the reader a purely personal study, from which I have excluded, so far as was practicable, all reference to the burning theological questions of the Refor- mation, and have also avoided any undue amount of dissertation on the tortuous and complicated policy pursued by these Popes of the House of Medici. For I hope that a simple account of the personal career and character of Leo X. (with whom of neces- vii viii THE MEDICI POPES sity my work chiefly deals) will prove of some value to the historical student of the Renaissance, who may thereby become better able to comprehend the varying part played by the former of the two Medicean pontiffs in the political and religious struggles during the opening decades of the sixteenth century. The earliest, and indeed only contemporary life of any importance of Giovanni de' Medici, Pope Leo X., is the Vita Leonis X. of Paolo Giovio, Bishop of Nocera, himself a member of Leo's own brilliant court in Rome, and therefore a person well qualified to undertake such a task. The work of Giovio, or Jovius, which was first published at Florence in 1549, is written in Latin, and though it has been rendered into Italian and French, it has never, so far as I am aware, been translated into English. Giovio's Life, which is divided into four books, is a most meagre and disappointing narrative, scarcely a biography at all in the modern sense of the term, for it principally consists of a long rambling account of contemporary politics, albeit the Fourth Book contains a large num- ber of intimate details concerning the Pope, which have often been utilised by succeeding writers. Poor and unsatisfactory as was Giovio's Life, this work remained for over 250 years the sole biography of the great Medicean pontiff until 1797, when there appeared an enlarged Leonis X. Vita from the pen of the learned Monsignore Angelo Fabroni of Pisa. This biography, which was published in Latin and has never been translated, contains a fuller account, together with a PREFACE ix copious Appendix of original Documents discovered and given to the world by Fabroni himself. His work was followed eight years later by the justly celebrated biography from the pen of William Roscoe of Liver- pool, who based his study on Fabroni's researches. Roscoe's The Life and Pontificate of Leo X. was soon translated into Italian, and published in 1817 by Count Luigi Bossi of Milan, whose splendid edition in twelve volumes constitutes the best and fullest Life of this Pope in existence. Amongst more recent volumes on the same subject, the carefully compiled Leo X. of Professor Ludwig Pastor, published in 1906, may be mentioned. Free use has been made in the ensuing work of these various biographies, together with their voluminous Appendices. I have treated of Giulio de' Medici, Pope Clement VII., in a less detailed manner, for two reasons : first, because his life before obtaining the tiara is closely bound up with, and consequently covered by, the career of his more distinguished cousin, Leo X. ; and second, because his private biography offers far less of general interest. Special attention has been drawn throughout the book to the various existing works of art in Florence and Rome which are connected with the personal history, or are due to the bountiful patron- age of these two Medicean pontiffs. In accordance with the title chosen for this work, I have also added a brief account of the later Popes, Pius IV. and Leo XL, both of whom bore the historic name of Medici, x THE MEDICI POPES although their connection with the senior branch of the great Florentine House was exceedingly remote. In case it may be remarked that an undue propor- tion of space has been bestowed on the early years ot Leo X. (and thereby also on those of his near kinsman and contemporary, Clement VII.), I would reply that far less is generally known of the youthful struggles and adventures of Cardinal Giovanni de' Medici than of the pomp and power of his pontificate ; and that some acquaintance with the story of Leo X.'s early poverty and insignificance is essential to a clearer understanding of his subsequent conduct as Supreme Pontiff. The vast and ever-increasing mass of material reflecting on the life, public and private, of the Medici Popes has rendered my task of selection and rejection peculiarly difficult ; indeed, an adequate and compre- hensive account of the reign of Leo X. alone would afford occupation for a lifetime, as every historian is well aware. Yet I think that from the pages of this book the reader will contrive to obtain a tolerably accurate glimpse into the personality of those two great Popes, whose deeds and influence for good or evil did so much to shape the course of the political, religious, intellectual and artistic development of Europe during the early stages of the Reformation. CONTENTS CHAPTER I PAGE CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE i Aspect of Florence under the Medici Birth of Giovanni de' Medici His parents His childhood and education He is destined for the Church Quarrel between Politian and Clarice de' Medici Giovanni de' Medici receives the tonsure He is given preferment in the Church Lorenzo de' Medici is anxious to obtain a Cardinal's hat for Giovanni His efforts in Rome Condition of Italian politics Accession of Pope Innocent VIII. Giovanni is nominated a Cardinal Deacon He is sent to the University of Pisa Bernardo Dovizi of Bibbiena Giovanni receives the scarlet hat in public Rejoicings in Florence Giovanni sets out for Rome His reception by Innocent VIII. Letter of Lorenzo de' Medici to his son Giovanni Death of Lorenzo. CHAPTER II MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 28 Effects of Lorenzo's death upon the politics of Florence and of Italy Piero de' Medici succeeds his father Lorenzo's three sons and their respective characters Arrival of the Cardinal in Florence State of Europe in the year 1492 Death of Innocent VIII. and election of Roderigo Borgia as Alexander VI. Giovanni returns to Florence Sermons and influence of Savonarola in Florence Critical condition of Italian politics Ludovico Sforza invites Charles VIII. of France into Italy Attitude of the Medici Piero's foolish conduct The Medici are expelled from Florence Bravery of the Cardinal His flight to Bologna Entry of King Charles VIII. into Florence Position of the Cardinal and his brothers Giulio de' Medici joins his cousin, the Cardinal Together they travel in Germany and France Meeting at Savona of Giovanni and Giulio de' Medici with Cardinal Delia Rovere, afterwards Pope Julius II. Death of Alexander VI. and election of Pius III. Early xii THE MEDICI POPES PAGE death of Pius III. and election of Julius II. Piero de' Medici is drowned in the river Garigliano His wife and family His monu- ment at Monte Cassino. CHAPTER III RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 52 Improved position of the House of Medici Friendship of the Cardinal with the Papal nephew The Cardinal's mode of life in Rome Character and policy of Julius II. Contrast between the Pope and the Cardinal Campaigns of Julius He is accompanied by Giovanni and Giulio de' Medici Surrender of Perugia and Bologna to the Pope The League of Cambrai Loss of Bologna and murder of Cardinal Alidosi of Pavia Giovanni de' Medici is appointed Papal Legate of Bologna Gaston de Foix The battle of Ravenna The Cardinal-Legate a prisoner of the French He sends his cousin Giulio de' Medici to Rome The Cardinal and Giulio de' Medici at Milan Retreat of the French army Escape of the Cardinal and his subsequent adventures Importance of this episode in the Cardinal's career. CHAPTER IV RETURN OF THE MEDICI TO FLORENCE 79 The conference at Mantua Julius wishes to restore the Medici to Florence Efforts of the Cardinal and opposition of the Duke of Urbino to them The Cardinal with the Spanish army of Cardona prepares to cross the Apennines into Tuscany Public feeling in Florence The Gonfalionere Soderini and Niccolo Machiavelli urge the citizens to defend their city against the Medici Advance of the Cardinal towards Barberino The Florentine Republic rejects Cardona's offers Siege and Sack of Prato Conduct of the Cardinal thereat Giuliano de' Medici re-enters Florence Flight of Soderini The Cardinal returns to the city He is practically master of Florence Formation of the societies of the Diamond and the Bough Death of Pope Julius II. The Cardinal sets out for the conclave in Rome. CHAPTER V LEO DECIMUS PONTIFEX MAXIMUS too Last days of Julius II. The judgment of history upon him His portrait by Raphael The Conclave of March, 1513 Illness of Giovanni de' Medici He is elected Pope under the title of Leo X. CONTENTS xiii Rejoicings in Rome and Florence The personal appearance of the new Pope He is crowned in St. Peter's High hopes for his reign Description of Rome in the year 1513 The ceremony of the Sacro Possesso, or formal occupation of the Lateran by a new Pontiff Elaborate preparations for the procession Description- of the pageant Decorations and laudatory verses in the city Agostino Chigi Progress of Leo X. across the city Return of the procession Letter of Gian-Giacomo Penni Opening of the Leonine Age in Rome. CHAPTER VI MEDICEAN AMBITION 129 Count Alberto Pio's opinion of the new Pope The private aims and ambitious character of Leo X. Condition of European politics in 1513 Giuliano de' Medici is made Gonfalionere of the Church Festival at the Roman Capitol Leo X. poses as the peacemaker of Europe Accession of Francis I. to the throne of France He invades Italy with a vast army He is opposed by Leo X. The battle of Marignano and its results Alarm of Leo X. He decides to appeal in person to Francis Leo sets out to meet the French King at Bologna His reception in Florence The meeting of Leo and Francis at Bologna Its unsatisfactory and indecisive results Leo returns to Florence Illness and death of Giuliano de' Medici Character of Giuliano The war of Urbino Lorenzo de' Medici, the Pope's nephew, is declared Duke of Urbino. CHAPTER VII THE COURT OF LEO X 160 Rome the intellectual and artistic centre of the Christian world under Leo X. Patronage of literature by the Pope His neglect of Ariosto, Guicciardini, Machiavelli and Erasmus Rise of Bembo and Sadoleto Musicians, buffoons and Improvvisatori at the Vatican The Pope's love of music Camillo Querno, the arch- poet Practical joke played upon Baraballo Unseemly conduct at Leo's court Influence of Fra Mariano Fetti Beginnings of the Drama Performances at the Vatican The Calandria of Cardinal Bibbiena The Suppositi of Ariosto Other dramatic performances at the Papal court Leo's extravagance Condition of the papal finances Visit of Isabella d' Este, Marchioness of Mantua, to Rome Banquets and concerts of the Italian Renaissance Festi- vities in Rome during the Carnival of 1515 Departure of Isabella d' Este from Rome. xiv THE MEDICI POPES CHAPTER VIII PAGE LEO'S HUNTING 192 Leo's devotion to sport in his youth He continues to hunt after his election The Papal villa of La Magliana The preserved zones for the Pope's hunting Methods of contemporary sport in Italy The Pope's head keeper, Boccamazzo Leo's chamberlain, Serapica The Pope hunts with Cardinal Farnese The hunting poems of Molosso and Postumo Description of a day's sport under Leo X. Criticism of Leo's conduct His actual participation in sport His neglect of business Sums paid for hawks for the papal mews before the Pope's death. CHAPTER IX LEO X. AND RAPHAEL 215 Leo X. the chief patron of Raphael of Urbino The Pope's neglect of Michelangelo Reasons for this neglect Comparison of the chances for the papal favour of Michelangelo and Raphael Michelangelo is set to design a fagade for the church of San Lorenzo in Florence Early acquaintance of the Pope with Raphael The artist beautifies the basilica of Santa Maria in Domenica Raphael is employed by Julius II. to decorate the official apartments of the Vatican Death of Julius and election of Leo X. Leo commands Raphael to complete the painting of the Stanze Portraits of Julius II., Leo X. and other famous personages in the frescoes of the Vatican Completion of the Halls of the Segnatura, the Eliodoro and the Incendio Wood carving and heraldic ornamentation in the Stanze di Raffaelo Decoration of the Loggie by Raphael and Giovanni da Udine The bathroom of the Cardinal Bibbiena The cartoons for the tapestries of the Sistine Chapel Raphael at Leo's suggestion writes a treatise upon ancient Rome and prepares a plan of the city Sudden illness and early death of the artist Grief in Rome Letters of Michiel and Castiglione Raphael's portrait of LeoX. CHAPTER X CONSPIRACY OF THE CARDINALS 244 Dissatisfaction felt at Leo's policy in the Sacred College His early nominations to the Cardinalate Giulio de' Medici is made Arch- bishop of Florence, and later a Cardinal His unpopularity Anger of Alfonso Petrucci against Leo Petrucci is supported by the Cardinals Riario, Sauli, Soderini and Adrian of Corneto Petrucci conspires against the Pope's life The plot discovered Arrest and CONTENTS imprisonment of Petrucci and Sauli Leo calls the consistory, and accuses Adrian and Soderini of complicity in the plot Arrest of Riario The Cardinals heavily fined and punished Execution of Petrucci in prison Criticism of Leo's conduct Leo creates over thirty cardinals in one batch Important results of this step General distrust of the Pope's policy Betrothal of Lorenzo de' Medici to Madeleine de la Tour d'Auvergne Lorenzo's mission to the French Court Lorenzo and his bride return to Florence Birth of their daughter, Caterina de' Medici Death of Lorenzo and his wife Tombs of the Medici in San Lorenzo Cardinal Giulio takes over the government of Florence His all-powerful influence with the Pope Indecision of Leo He allies himself with the Emperor Charles V. Opening of the war between Charles V. and Francis of France. CHAPTER XI DEATH AND CHARACTER OF LEO X 268 Giulio de' Medici sends news to Rome of the recapture of Parma and Piacenza Leo is overjoyed at the news He is seized with a sudden chill at his villa of La Magliana He returns to the Vatican, where he expires on ist December, 1513 Conflicting accounts of his last hours Suspicion of poison Reception of the news of the Pope's death in Rome He is buried in St. Peter's His monument in the Dominican Church of Santa Maria sopra Minerva Analysis of Leo's personal character Opinion of Guicciardini Unfounded charges of immorality and impiety His inordinate craving for pleasure and amusement The real failings of Leo X. Conclusion. CHAPTER XII CLEMENT SEPTIMUS PONTIFEX MAXIMUS 285 The Conclave of December, 1521 Election and Pontificate of Adrian VI. Cardinal Giulio de' Medici retires to Florence He returns to Rome later at Adrian's request Death of Adrian VI. The Con- clave of October, 1523 Its delays and scandals Election of Giulio de' Medici, who assumes the title of Clement VII. The choice approved by the European sovereigns Appearance and character of Clement VII. Renewed activity in the artistic world The Hall of Constantine in the Vatican completed by Giulio Romano and Penni Emblem of Clement VII. Clement's former patronage of Raphael The Villa Medici on Monte Mario The painting of the Transfiguration Clement gives numerous commissions to Benvenuto Cellini The master-jeweller's account of the Pope xvi THE MEDICI POPES PAGE Cellini serves the Pope faithfully during the sack of Rome Clement's appreciation of Michelangelo The master is com- missioned by Clement to erect the New Sacristy and the Laurentian Library at San Lorenzo in Florence Progress of this work inter- rupted by the siege of Florence Michelangelo is forgiven by Clement for his behaviour at the time of the siege The work at San Lorenzo left incomplete at Clement's death and never re- sumed. CHAPTER XIII THE SACK OF ROME 307 Clement VII. pursues a fatal policy of vacillation between the Emperor and the French King The battle of Pavia Clement persists in his political folly and defies the Emperor Cardinal Colonna's raid upon Rome The united army of German landsknechts under Frundsberg and of Spanish veterans under the Constable of Bourbon advances towards Rome The Spanish fleet under the viceroy Lannoy reaches Gaeta Terrible position of Clement The battle of Frosinone Truce between the Pope and Lannoy The army of Bourbon continues to move southward It turns aside from Florence It proceeds by way of Viterbo upon Rome Un- prepared state of the city Abject folly of Clement Bourbon attacks the walls of Rome and is killed The foreign forces enter the city Clement and most of the members of the Roman Court seek refuge in the Castle of Sant' Angelo Massacre and sack of the city Frightful horrors committed The return of the Cardinal Colonna Position of the Pope in Sant' Angelo Defence of the castle under Santacroce and Benvenuto Cellini News of the revolt in Florence and of the expulsion of the Medicean bastards brought to the Pope Miserable plight of the Pope He surrenders unconditionally to the representative of Charles V. Flight of Clement to Orvieto The English Embassy at Orvieto Clement is reconciled to the Emperor, whom he crowns at Bologna Siege and capitulation of Florence. CHAPTER XIV THE LAST YEARS OF CLEMENT VII. 329 The Pope's relatives, Alessandro and Ippolito de' Medici Preference of Clement VII. for the former, who is created Duke of Florence Ippolito is made a Cardinal against his wish Memorials of Clement VII. in Florence Caterina de' Medici and Clement's anxiety to arrange an important marriage for her The Emperor CONTENTS xvii and Pope again meet at Bologna Catherine is betrothed to Henry, Duke of Orleans Meeting of Francis I. and Clement at Marseilles Marriage of Catherine in the Pope's presence Return of Clement to Rome His last months spent in sickness and misery The Pope and Benvenuto Cellini Clement's death a cause of popular rejoicing Estimate of Clement VII.'s character. PAGE CHAPTER XV THE LATER MEDICI POPES Gian-Angelo Medici of Milan, Pius IV. Alessandro de' Medici of Florence, Leo XI. Leo's election and brief reign of one month His monument in St. Peter's. APPENDIX ............ INDEX 353 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS LEO X. ATTENDED BY THE CARDINALS GlU-LIO DE* MEDICI (AFTER- WARDS CLEMENT VII.) AND LUIGI DE' Rossi . . . Frontispiece From the painting by Raphael in the Pitti Palace, Florence. FACING PAGE GIOVANNI DE' MEDICI KNEELING BEFORE HIS FATHER, LORENZO IL MAGNIFICO 18 Fresco by Vasari in the Palazzo Vecchio, Florence. GlULIANO DELLA RoVERE (JULIUS II.) WITH GlOVANNI DE 1 MEDICI AND OTHER MEMBERS OF HIS COURT 56 From the Stanze di Raffaello in the Vatican. FLORENCE IN THE YEAR 1529 82 Fresco in the Palazzo Vecchio, Florence. JULIUS II 103 From the cartoon by Raphael in the Corsini Palace, Florence. LEO X. RIDING IN STATE 125 Detail from the Flight of Attila in the Stanze di Raffaello. LEO X.'s PROCESSION IN FLORENCE 144 Fresco in the Palazzo Vecchio, Florence. TOMB AND STATUE OF GIULIANO DE' MEDICI 157 By Michelangelo in the New Sacristy of Sun Lorenzo, Florence. EMBLEMS OF LEO X. AND THE MEDICI 172 Wood carving in the Stanze di Raffaello. CARDINAL BERNARDO DOVIZI DA BIBBIENA 185 From the painting by Raphael in the Pitti Palace, Florence. PAPAL ACHIEVEMENT OF LEO X 190 By Giovanni da Udine, in the Borgia Apartments of the Vatican. ALESSANDRO FARNESE (PAUL III.) 200 From the paiitiing by Paris Bordone in the Pitti Palace, Florence. LA SALA DI ELIODORO 223 Stanse di Raffaello. xx THE MEDICI POPES FACING PAGE LOGGIA DI RAFFAELLO 233 In the Vatican. LEO X.'s CREATION OF CARDINALS 257 Fresco by Vasari in the Palazzo Vecchio, Florence. LORENZO DE' MEDICI, DUKE OF URBINO 263 Staftie by Michelangelo in the New Sacristy of San Lorenzo, Florence. GIULIO DE' MEDICI (CLEMENT VII.) 289 From the painting by Bronzino in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence. CLEMENT VII. AND THE EMPEROR CHARLES V 308 Fresco by Vasari in the Palazzo Vecchio, Florence. CLEMENT VII. AND FRANCIS I. 326 Fresco by Vasari in the Palazzo Vecchio, Florence. CATERINA DE' MEDICI, QUEEN OF FRANCE 339 From a painting in the Uffizi Gallery, Florence. The illustrations are from photographs by Messrs. Alinari, Florence. BIBLIOGRAPHY Amongst the printed works that have been consulted during the preparation of this volume, some of the more important and useful are enumerated below : Paulus Jovius [Paolo Giovio, Bishop of Nocera]. Vita Leonis X. Florentine, Z 549- (Quoted as Jovius.) Angelo Fabroni. Leonis X. Vita. Pisa, 1807. (Quoted as Fabroni.) William Roscoe. The Life and Pontificate of Leo X. Bohn's edition, London, 1846. (Quoted as Roscoe.) Count Luigi Bossi. Vita e Pontificate di Leone X. di Guglielmo Roscoe. Milano, 1816. (Quoted as Bossi- Roscoe.) Francesco Nitti. Leone X. e la sua Politica. G. Barbera, Firenze, 1892. Professor Ludwig Pastor. Leo X. Geschichte der Pdpste seit dem Ausgang des Mittelalters. Freiburg im Breisgau, 1906. (Quoted as Pastor.) Dr. M. Creighton, Bishop of London. A History of the Papacy from the Great Schism to the Sack of Rome (vols. v. and vi.). Longmans, Green and Co., London, 1904. (Quoted as Creighton.) Ferdinand Gregorovius. History of Rome in the Middle Ages. Trans- lated by Annie Hamilton. George Bell, London, 1902. (Quoted as Gregorovius.) Jacob Burckhardt. The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy. Translated by S. G. C. Middlemore. Swan Sonnenschein & Co., London, 1892. M. Sanudo. / Diarii (1496-1533). Venezia, 1879-1902. Francesco Guicciardini. Storia d' Italia. Edited by Gio. Rosini. Capolago, 1836. Lorenzo Pignotti. Storia della Toscana. Pisa, 1813. H. E. Napier. Florentine History (vol. iv.). Moxon, London, 1846. J. Michelet. La Renaissance. Le'vy, Paris, 1898. G. Del Badia. Diario Florentine di Luca Landucci. Sansoni, Firenze, 1883. (Quoted as Landucci.) E, Bacciotti. Firenze Illustrata. Firenze, 1879. C. Yriarte. Florence. Sampson Lowe, London, 1882. W. Roscoe. Life of Lorenzo de' Medici. London, 1796. Professor E. Armstrong. Lorenzo de' Medici. Putnams, New York and London, 1896. zzi xxil THE MEDICI, POPES C. Belviglieri. Tavole Sincrone e Genealogiche di Storia Italiana. Firenze, 1885. E. Grifi. Saunterings in Florence. Bemporad e Figlio, Firenze, 1899. Professor Pasquale Villari. Life and Times of Niccolb Machiavelli. Translated by Madame Linda Villari. (Third Edition.) Fisher Unwin, London, N.D. (Quoted as Villari.) J. C. L. Sismondi. Histoire des Republiques Italiennes. Bruxelles, 1839. Professor R. Lanciani. The Golden Days of the Renaissance in Rome. Hough- ton, Mifflin and Co., Boston and New York, 1906. (Quoted as Lanciani.) B. Platina. Le Vite de' Pontefici. In Venetia, 1685. Raynaldus. Diario di Paridc Grasso. Leopold Ranke. History of the Popes. Translated by E. Foster. Bohn's edition, London, 1889. Count Domenico Gnoli. Le Caccie di Leone X. La Nuova Antologia, vol. cxxvii. Signor Alessandro Luzio. Isabella d" Este ne 1 primordi del Papato di Leone X. Cogliati, Milano, 1907. Adolphus Trollope. The Girlhood of Catherine de Medici. Chapman & Hall, London, 1856. Scipione Ammirato. Ritratti d' huomini illustri di Casa Medici. (Opuscoli, vol. iii.) Firenze, 1640. Cesare Guasti. II Sacco di Prato e il Ritorno dei Medici in Firenze nel 1512. Bologna, 1880. G. Milanesi. // Sacco di Roma del 1527. G. Barbara, Firenze, 1867. J. A. Symonds. Renaissance in Italy. Holt & Co., New York, 1887. J. A. Symonds. Life of Michelangelo Buonarotti. Macmillan, London. 1901. Benvenuto Cellini. Vita di scritta da lui medesimo. Firenze, 1842. Giorgio Vasari. Lives of the Painters, Sculptors and Architects. Bohn's edition, London, 1850. Eugene Muntz, Raphael, His Life, Works and Times. Translated by Walter Armstrong. Chapman & Hall, London, 1896. (Quoted as Muntz.) Baldassare Castiglione. // Cortigiano. Vinegia, 1556. A. Braschet. Les Archives de la Serenissime Republique de Venise. Venise, 1857. r> ^. CO J 1 ? oS C 1 13 O OS "* ^T-w rt . T ^ ja * c - 't/3 CL ^ S j^j O o t4 O || !5 13 -a li W s CO g 'H II Q<*-t 05 ^-T OS ^^ c II * *"* H HM at O . ID ^ -C H O II . . "o o ^^ II z -^- M o< fe .^ _ ^^ r S/< C*4 _S* M O ^ rt P-H 8 < JJ* ** "3 in *rt o O eg S >r> Q M . |1 'c ^> u C3 "-"'' ^ HH ^"^ W "n< "t^ W W tf o as S N ' M O N .S ' '33 G fi a v2 ** 1 U K o -oo- M Q C I t> er, Maria S; arentage, b 5 I 5 fl .SO 3 Sa w ,3 E u JS . O-i ^ S P 1 o sl O JJ ITi So THE MEDICI POPES CHAPTER I CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE From the frightful spectacle of poverty, barbarity and ignorance, from the oppression of illiterate masters, and the sufferings of a degraded peasantry, which the annals of England and France present to us, it is delightful to turn to the opulent and enlightened states of Italy, to the vast and magnificent cities, the ports, the arsenals, the villas, the museums, the libraries, the marts filled with every article of comfort or luxury, the factories swarming with artisans. . . . With peculiar pleasure every cultivated mind must repose on the fair, the happy, the glorious Florence, the halls which rang with the mirth of Pulci, the cell where twinkled the midnight lamp of Politian, the statues on which the young eye of Michelangelo glared with the frenzy of a kindred inspiration, the gardens in which Lorenzo meditated some sparkling song for the May- Day dance of the Etrurian virgins (Lord Macaulay, Essay on Machiavellt). IN our efforts to realise the leading events of our own history we experience no small difficulty from the fact that so much of the face of England has com- pletely altered its outward appearance under the stress of modern development, so that we find it particularly hard to picture to ourselves their original setting. Our over- grown yet ever-spreading capital owns scarcely a feature to-day in common with the London of the Tudors or Plan- tagenets ; the relentless pushing of industrial enterprise has turned whole shires from green to black, from verdant countryside to smoke-grimed scenes of commerce. It is therefore well-nigh impossible for us in many cases to con- 2 THE MEDICI POPES jure up the old-world conditions of Merrie England. But in writing of Italian annals we are confronted by no such problem ; altered to a certain extent no doubt is the pres- ent aspect of Italy, yet in Florence, Venice, Siena and most of her cities we still possess the empty stages of the pageants and deeds of long ago, all ready prepared for us to people with the famous figures of the historic past. Standing on the airy heights of San Miniato, where the golden mosaics of its venerable church have cauhgt the passing glories of the sunset for nigh upon a thousand years, or strolling amongst the ilex alleys of " Boboli's ducal bowers," we can still gaze below upon the Florence of the Medici, the Florence of Lorenzo the Magnificent and of Savonarola, the Florence of Popes Leo and Clement, of Michelangelo and Machiavelli. For beneath us swift Arno still shoots under the arches of Taddeo Gaddi's ancient bridge piled high with its load of tiny shops that Florentine goldsmiths have inhabited for the past six cen- turies. There still dominates the red-roofed city Brunel- leschi's huge cupola, and beside it still springs aloft "into blue aether that no clouds o'ercast" the delicate parti- coloured campanile of the Shepherd- Painter. Nearer to us the graceful yet sturdy belfry of the old civic palace soars majestically into the clear atmosphere, and hard by we note the fantastic spire of the Badia, and alongside it the severe outline of the turret that adjoins the grim castle of the Podesta. Westward the slender pinnacle of Santa Maria Novella greets our eyes, whilst amidst this varied group of towers there obtrudes on our sight the square mass of Or San Michele, that sacred citadel of the Flor- entine guilds. Oltr' Arno nestling at our feet remains wholly unchanged, and of a truth the only conspicuous objects that can interrupt our mental retrospect of the city of Lorenzo and Leo are the mean tower of Santa CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 3 Croce, the long colonnades of the Uffizi, and the clumsy dome that surmounts the gorgeous charnel-house of the Medicean Grand- Dukes. To make the picture perfect, we must blind our eyes to these excrescences of a later age, and by another slight effect of the imagination we must behold the modern raw suburbs and their smoke-belching factories sink into the soil of the Florentine plain to give place to tracts of garden and orchard, to shady groves and smiling vineyards, that lie outside the broad coronal of towered walls, wherewith Arnolfo di Cambio endowed his native city for her protection. We must next conceive the steep hillside of Fiesole less populous than at the present day, less marred by quarries and mean houses, yet freely besprinkled with ample villas. Amidst this radiant scenery the practised eye can easily detect the chief Medicean residences ; that sheltered pleasaunce with its long terraces below the crest of ancient Faesulae ; the favourite retreat of the sickly Piero and the Magnifi- cent Lorenzo, with its broad roof peeping forth from bosky thickets of elm and cypress at sunny Careggi ; and again by directing our glance across the fertile plain towards Prato, we seem to discover the whereabouts of Sangallo's stately palace at low-lying Cajano, where the luckless Clement VII. spent much of his childhood. No stretch of the imagination is however required on our part to realise the eternal hills which form the northern background to the City of the Lily ; for ever unchanged and unchange- able remain the stony stretches of familiar Monte Morello, the green and russet slopes of the heights that rise in end- less succession eastward of Fiesole, and the barren violet- tinted mountains bounding the plain above Prato and Pistoja. How exquisite, and also how unaltered even to-day, is the distant aspect of Florence, "la bellissima e famosissima figlia di Roma," as one of her most famous 4 THE MEDICI POPES sons thus addressed his ancient mother ! With so superb a setting, amid such glorious surroundings, the past history of Florence becomes a living thing, which it needs no striving to quicken, for the true Medicean city of the Italian Renaissance stands before us to-day sharply defined in the crystal-clear air of Tuscany Dove "1 humano spirito si purga E di salir al Ciel' diventa degno. 1 In the heart of the town itself, almost beneath the shadow of the vast dome, out of sight of which no true-born son of Florence is said ever to feel happy, rises that group of buildings which is so closely associated with the origin and fortunes of the House of Medici. Here lies the great basilica of San Lorenzo with its pitiful naked fagade, that Medicean popes and princes were always intending to convert into a costly thing of beauty ; at its transepts up- rear the rival sacristies of Brunelleschi and Michelangelo, above which looms the red cupola of the Grand- Ducal mausoleum. Beside the church extends the long window- pierced form of the Laurentian Library, overlooking the quiet cloister in a dark angle of which sits eternally the robed and mitred figure of the grim-visaged Paolo Giovio, the venal Plutarch of his age and the earliest bio- grapher of Pope Leo X. Upon the little piazza before the church, nowadays the busy scene of a daily market of cheap or tawdry goods, abuts the massive palace which was the cradle of the Medicean race. Much changed in outward aspect is the mansion that Michelozzi con- structed for Cosimo il Vecchio, for the Riccardi, who bought this historic building in after years, must needs spoil its original proportions by adding largely to the structure. The statue-set garden wherein Cosimo and 1 // Purgatorio, canto i. CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 5 Lorenzo were wont to stroll has wholly disappeared, but the central courtyard with its antique friezes and its stone medallions remains intact. A most precious relic of its former owners it still retains in the exquisite little chapel covered with Benozzo Gozzoli's renowned frescoes, where- in are portrayed in glowing colours and in gleaming gold Cosimo the Elder, his son Piero, his grandchildren, and his Imperial guests from distant Byzantium, all riding with their trains of richly-clad attendants, with hawk and hound, and even with trained leopard, amidst a landscape of marvellous but fantastic beauty. The old Medicean mansion, lying between Piazza San Lorenzo and the broad curve of Via Larga, cannot perhaps aspire to the symmetry and rich decoration of Palazzo Strozzi hard by, nor can it vie in bulk and majesty with Messer Pitti's vast palace on the slopes of Oltr' Arno ; nevertheless it is a goodly building, well-proportioned and imposing, and withal suitably contrived for defence. It was in a chamber of this historic house that Giovanni de' Medici, afterwards Pope Leo X., first saw the light on nth December, 1475. Of his sire, the Magnificent Lorenzo uncrowned king of Florence, genial tyrant of an adoring populace, statesman, diplo- matist, banker, scholar, poet it will be superfluous to speak ; his mother, Clarice Orsini, a member of the haughty feudal Roman house, was the first "foreign" bride to enter the portals of the Medicean palace. She was a good woman and a faithful wife, but in intellect the inferior of her brilliant consort, whose versatile nature and marvellous powers often puzzled or alarmed her. But she had at least the merit of bestowing on her second son the pontifical name by which all the world speaks and thinks of Giovanni di Lorenzo de' Medici. For on the night before her infant was born the good 6 THE MEDICI POPES Clarice had a dream, wherein she imagined herself seized with pangs of childbirth in the Florentine Duomo, and delivered of a huge but most docile lion instead of the expected infant. 1 Man has always been a superstitious animal, and in the year 1475 dreams such as Clarice's were taken very seriously indeed as intentional warn- ings or compliments from the Unseen, so that there can be no reasonable doubt that Giovanni de' Medici on being elected to fill the papal throne in after years chose his official title of Leo X. out of deference to his mother's nightmare, over the mystical meaning of which he had probably often pondered. Of the little Giovanni's brothers and sisters we must speak one word. First, there was Piero, the heir, who was four years old at Giovanni's birth, and last there was Giuliano, born in the year of the Pazzi conspiracy and so named after his ill-fated uncle. Then there were the four sisters Lucrezia, Maddalena, Contessina and Luisa of whom the three first-named were married re- spectively to a Cybo, a Salviati, and a Ridolfi ; whilst Luisa died prematurely on the eve of her nuptials with Giovanni, son of Pier-Francesco de' Medici, head of the younger branch of the Medicean House. To his chil- dren, Lorenzo always showed himself an affectionate and indulgent father, even condescending on occasions to take part in their noisy games of the nursery : a circum- stance that the merciless Machiavelli records with a sneer in the pages of his Florentine history " he would for- get the dignity of his office in romping with his children, for he would oftentimes indulge in any idle or childish amusement they might put him to". Nevertheless, most persons will agree with a modern French critic, who de- 1 Jovius, lib. i. CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 7 clares that never could the great Lorenzo have shown "himself more human or more lovable than when playing at soldiers with Piero and Giuliano, or rolling on the floor with the future Leo X. Giovanni must have been far too young to remember the conspiracy of the Pazzi with its terrible scenes, when the mangled corpse of his uncle Giuliano was borne from the cathedral to the palace that was surrounded by angry crowds calling for summary vengeance on the murderers, and professing boundless devotion towards their surviving ruler, who had escaped the assassin's knife as though by a miracle. Later, perhaps, he may have recalled an addition to the Medicean nursery in a little dark-eyed boy with the name of Giulio, the bastard son of the murdered Giuliano, who was sometimes brought to share the lessons and amusements of Lorenzo's own children. In any case he must have been conscious of the change of scene from busy crowded Florence to the quiet and solitude of the family estate of Caffagiolo, whither the Magnificent despatched his household for safety after the Conjuration of the Pazzi. The dark forests of pine and fir, the fleecy flocks, the rough but kindly shepherds of the hills, the keen air of the wind- grieved Apennines, must have had their early influence on any son of Lorenzo the Poet, who loved dearly the life and people of the Tuscan country-side. But in strange contrast with the rural surroundings of airy Caffagiolo on its distant mountain-top must have seemed the conversa- tions overheard by the sharp ears of the children between their tutor, Angelo Poliziano, and the handsome young Pico della Mirandola, or the abstruse arguments indulged in by their father with the learned Marsilio Ficino on the chance occasions when Lorenzo was able to join his family in their country retreat. But more often Politian 8 THE MEDICI POPES was left alone with his charges and their mother, whose views by no means coincided with those of their chosen preceptor. Fiercely did the anxious Clarice wrangle with Politian over the methods of education, which she wanted to be conducted on her old-fashioned lines, the tutor complaining meanwhile to Madonna Lucrezia, Lorenzo's mother, a Tornabuoni by birth, to whom in an amusing letter he sends a comically dismal account of the daily life at Caffagiolo, which was by no means a residence to the taste of the fastidious scholar. " The only news I can send you is that we have here such continual rains that it is impossible to quit the house, and the exercises of the country are exchanged for childish sports within doors. Here I stand by the fire- side in my great coat and slippers, so that you might take me for the very figure of Melancholy. . . . Were we in Florence, we should have some consolation, were it only for that of seeing Lorenzo, when he returned home ; but here we are in continual anxiety, and I for my part am half-dead with solitude and weariness. The plague and the war are incessantly in my mind. I lament past evils, and I have no longer at my side my dear Madonna Lucrezia, to whom I might unbosom my cares." 1 But besides complaining thus to Madonna Lucrezia, the spoiled Humanist does not scruple to upbraid Clarice to her own husband for wasting the time of his most promising pupil, the precocious little Giovanni, by forcing him to squander his newly-acquired power of reading in spelling through the Psalms of David instead of the masterpieces of antiquity. That the mother and tutor of Lorenzo's children were on the worst possible terms 1 Roscoe, Life of Lorenzo de" Medici t Appendix LIX. CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 9 at lonely Caffagiolo is evident from one of Clarice's letters, wherein she relates her side of the case with re- gard to the thorny question of education, nor does she shrink from abusing Lorenzo's favourite poet and com- panion to her husband. "... I do not like Messer Angelo Poliziano threaten- ing to remain in the house in spite of me. You re- member I told you, that if it was your wzY/he should stay, I was perfectly contented ; and although I have suffered infinite abuse from him, yet if it be with your consent, I am satisfied. But I cannot believe this to be the case." 1 At length Lorenzo, growing weary of these appeals and bickerings, advised Politian to withdraw to the villa below Fiesole, where he quickly recovered his equanimity and spent a profitable time in composing his Rusticus, a charming Latin poem that his contemporaries did not hesitate to compare with the Georgics of Vergil. With unerring instinct Lorenzo had already perceived his second son's talents, and had decided to turn them to the advantage of his House and his policy, so that the little Giovanni was accordingly marked out for an ecclesi- astical career almost from his infancy. Before reaching his seventh birthday the child received the tonsure the solemn shaving of the scalp which notified his entry into the Church, and he was at the same time declared capable of preferment, whereupon Louis XI. of France, to whom Lorenzo had communicated his intention, at once presented the boy with the abbey of Fonte Dolce, and even promised him the see of Aix, until it was un- expectedly realised that its archbishop was still living. A canonry in each cathedral-church of Tuscany was 1 Roscoe, Appendix LXI. 10 THE MEDICI POPES promptly bestowed on this infantile pluralist, and even Pope Sixtus IV., that implacable foe of the House of Medici, granted him a little later the rich convent of Passignano. A detailed list of this child's benefices would prove wearisome, but we may mention that he held twenty -seven separate offices, of which the abbeys of Fonte Dolce, Passignano and Monte Cassino were the most lucrative. No wonder then that the learned Fabroni, Leo's first modern biographer, exclaims in horrified amazement, " Dear Lord, what a mass of benefices concentrated in one single youth ! " Yet it is difficult to dissent from Roscoe's shrewd criticism on such a scandal, that it is of small consequence whether such preferment be bestowed upon an infant who is unable, or upon an adult who is unwilling, to perform the re- quisite duties. 1 In the following year, 1483, this young ecclesiastic was confirmed by the bishop of Arezzo in the beautiful Medicean chapel with its Gozzoli frescoes ; a circumstance which Lorenzo naively mentions in his Ricordi: " On the nineteenth day of May, 1483, we received in- telligence that the King of France had of his own motion presented to my son Giovanni the abbey of Fonte Dolce. On the thirty -first we heard from Rome that the Pope had confirmed the grant, and had rendered him capable of holding benefices, he being now seven years of age. On the first day of June, Giovanni accompanied me from Poggio a Cajano to Florence, where he was confirmed by the bishop of Arezzo, and received the tonsure, and from henceforth was called Messire Giovanni. This ceremony took place in the chapel of our family." But it is needless to add that Lorenzo had far more 1 Roscoe, chap, i., pp. 10, n. CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE n ambitious ends in view than the mere obtaining of rich sees and abbeys for his second, who was perhaps his favourite, son. His many experiences of the Protean changes in Italian politics, of which he was now be- coming the acknowledged moderator " the beam of the Italian scales" had already impressed upon his marvel- lous mind the paramount importance of a close connec- tion between his own House and the Papacy. The preponderance of Italian influence in Lorenzo's days was divided between the duchy of Milan and the republic of Venice in Northern Italy, and the kingdom of Naples and the Papacy in the south, whilst in the centre the wealthy commercial state of Florence under the judicious sway of Lorenzo himself had for some time past managed to keep the balance of power between the jarring ele- ments of North and South, and to prevent any dangerous combinations amongst the four leading states, whose in- trigues also shaped the policy of the smaller Italian cities such as Mantua, Ferrara, Siena, Bologna and the like. But dangerous and tangled as was the skein of political threads held in Milan, Naples, Venice and the minor capitals, it was the uncertain action of the Papacy which the ruler of Florence had most cause to dread. For it had been the unconcealed hostility of Sixtus IV. that had made the Pazzi conspiracy possible, and it was also the same Pope's aggression that had later forced Lorenzo to risk his life at the court of the treacherous Ferdinand of Naples on his famous diplomatic mission of 1480. From a repetition of past dangers at the hands of the Pope, Lorenzo had fully determined to guard himself by obtaining the admission of his younger son into the College of Cardinals, whenever a favourable opportunity might present itself. This attempt to obtain the scarlet hat for Giovanni de' Medici was therefore as much an 12 THE MEDICI POPES act of political foresight as an object of mere family ag- grandisement, since a Medicean Cardinal would not only help to raise the prestige of the burgher House, already allied with a proud Roman family, but he would also be able to influence the policy of the Sacred College and the shifting aims of successive Popes. So long as Sixtus IV. sat in St. Peter's chair, such an ambition could remain only a day-dream, but on 1 3th August, 1484, the Delia Rovere Pope, so dreaded by Lorenzo, expired unloved and unlamented. The sub- sequent election of Giambattista Cybo with the title of Innocent VIII. now placed a personal as well as a political friend on the pontifical throne, so that a rare chance pre- sented itself to Lorenzo to push his intentions at the Roman court. Two serious obstacles lay in the way of his cherished scheme ; the feeble health of the aged Pontiff, whose tenure of the dignity did not promise to be of long duration, and the extreme youth of Lorenzo's own little Cardinal in petto. Yet nothing daunted, the Magnificent at once began eagerly to press his request upon the new Pope, although the latter was naturally, in spite of his regard for the father, extremely loth to no- minate his infant son a prince of the Church. In fact, at his election Innocent had in the conclave not only promised never to admit any candidate to the Sacred College who was under thirty years of age, but also not to create any more members of the College itself until its numbers were in the course of nature reduced to twenty-four. These restrictions, absurd and illegal as they undoubtedly were, the new-made Pope could hardly have been expected to comply with strictly, yet certainly Giovanni's proposed elevation constituted an extreme case. To raise a mere child to the highest rank in the Church, even in that age of universal corruption, would CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 13 have caused a grave scandal ; nevertheless, Innocent wavered between the fear of offending the Sacred College and a warm desire to serve his true friend, Lorenzo, who kept on demanding this boon from the Pontiff "with no less fervency than he would have asked of God the salvation of his soul ".* So eager and intimate an appeal the scruples or fears of Innocent were unable to with- stand, especially since in the previous year the existing ties between the Houses of Medici and Cybo had been drawn closer by the union of the Pope's son, Francesco Cybo, with Lorenzo's daughter Maddalena. Besides arranging this marriage between the two families, Lorenzo had left no stone unturned to obtain his desired end. By means of his envoy Lanfredini at the Roman court, the two leading cardinals, Roderigo Borgia, whose name was soon to become notorious throughout Christendom, and Ascanio Sforza, brother of the usurper of Milan, were approached on this delicate matter. Both cardinals worked diligently on little Giovanni's behalf, especially the cardinal of Milan, until the Pope, wearied out by this judicious policy of alternate teasing and flattery, finally complied with Lorenzo's wishes, so ardently expressed. On 8th March, 1489, therefore, Giovanni de' Medici was formally nominated a Cardinal Deacon by the title of Santa Maria in Domenica, the small antique church that stands to-day half-hidden amidst the vineyards and acacia groves of the deserted Coelian Hill. The Cardinal de Balue, Louis XL's minister, writing after the con- sistory to Lorenzo in Florence, thus announces the joyful news: "O happy man, what a blessing and what an honour for your most reverend son, for your own Magni- ficence, and for the city of Florence ! " 2 But supreme as 1 Fabroni, Appendix II. 2 Ibid. i 4 THE MEDICI POPES was Lorenzo's satisfaction on receipt of this news, his transports of joy were not a little tempered by certain re- strictions which accompanied his son's admission into the College. In the first place, Innocent very reasonably and properly it will be admitted refused to allow the new-made thirteen-year-old Cardinal to wear the vest- ments or exercise any of the privileges of his rank for the space of at least three years. Lorenzo's irritation was ex- treme at this command, but in spite of shrewd arguments and persistent entreaties the Pope, to his credit, remained unshaken in his resolve. Another stipulation made by the Pope, who evidently did not consider the education of a Humanist as altogether sufficient for a cardinal, was that Giovanni should quit Florence immediately in order to study canon law at Pisa during his three years of pro- bation. Accordingly the boy was sent to Pisa, that magnificent failure amongst the historic cities of mediaeval Italy, which had lately been endowed with an university by Lorenzo himself. For the brooding quiet of the famous but derelict old city, the cheapness of lodging within its walls, and its central position near the coast- line midway between Rome and Genoa, had already made Pisa a flourishing seat of learning. Here then the future Pontiff studied diligently under Decio, Soz- zini and other learned professors, recently nominated to the various chairs of Pisa by his father, whilst his household was managed for him by a young scholar of great promise, whose career was from this time onward bound up closely with that of his brilliant pupil, who was but five years his junior. This was no less a person than Bernardo Dovizi of Bibbiena, whose shrewd face is so familiar to us from Raphael's splendid portrait in the Pitti Gallery at Florence, and whose attain- ments will ever shed reflected glory on the humble CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 15 village amongst the Tuscan uplands that gave him birth : Fk nota per costui, dicea, Bibbiena, Quanto Fiorenza, sua vicina, e Siena. 1 Meanwhile Lorenzo himself, already ailing in the prime of life, was kept in a perpetual fever of suspense for fear the Pope might die before the close of this probationary period, and there can be little doubt that this continual anxiety contributed not a little to the Magnificent's pre- mature decease. Nor was he idle in urging Innocent, by means of his ambassadors in Rome, to withdraw the odious conditions, so as to allow his son the full enjoy- ment of his rank. But the Pope continued to shut his ears to all appeals and arguments, so that Lorenzo had to rest content with vague assurances of the Pontiff's good-will. " Leave the fortunes of Messire Giovanni to me," replied Innocent to Piero Alamanni's entreaties on his master's behalf; "for I look upon him as my own son and shall perhaps make his promotion public when you least expect it, for it is my intention to do much more for his interests than I shall now express." 5 Such promises proved cold comfort to Lorenzo, ever intriguing to shake Innocent's fixed resolve, and ever dreading each post from Rome lest it might bring tidings of the old Pope's death, in the event of which he foresaw only too clearly the certain collapse of all his secret schemes. For it was highly probable that a new Pontiff, if a virtuous reformer like Pius II., would postpone for many years the desired consummation ; whilst a bad Pope of the type of his old enemy Sixtus would either extort an immense sum for bestowing the hat or else try to repudiate altogether the promises made by 1 Ariosto, Orlando Furioso, canto xxvi., st. 48. 2 Fabroni, Jn vita Laurentii Medicei, p. 301. 1 6 THE MEDICI POPES Innocent with regard to a child of thirteen. Nor were o Lorenzo's fears of failure unfounded, for, as we shall see, the papal permission arrived only a few weeks before his own decease ; in short, but for the frantic efforts of Lorenzo, Giovanni de' Medici would never have received the scarlet hat, and the world's history would have lacked the pontificate of Leo X. At length the day so anxiously expected by Lorenzo arrived, and on the evening of 8th March, 1492, the young Cardinal, now aged sixteen years and three months, left Florence with a small train to ascend to the ancient abbey that stands on the fertile slopes below Fiesole. This church, commonly known as the Badia Fiesolana, adorns the left ridge of the vine- and willow- clad valley of the Mugnone, and lies within a few hundred yards of the better-known convent of San Domenico with its cherished memories of Fra Angelico. The Badia itself, with its tall tower and its picturesque fa9ade of black and white marble, had long been associated with the name and bounty of the Medici, so that it made a suitable spot for the intended ceremony of investiture, which, probably owing to Lorenzo's ill-health, it had been decided to make as simple and brief as possible. Within the walls, therefore, of this church distinguished by the gifts and emblems of his ancestors, Giovanni spent a long night's vigil in solitary prayer, until with the dawn appeared on the scene Pico della Mirandola and Jacopo Salviati, together with Messer Simone Stanza, the public notary. The young Cardinal now received the Sacra- ment "with the greatest devotion and humility," after which High Mass was sung. During the performance of the service the Superior of the Abbey pronounced a blessing on the insignia of Giovanni's rank \hepallium or mantle, the biretum or scarlet cap, and the galerus, CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 17 the broad-brimmed hat with the long depending tassels and these were exposed before the high altar. In its proper place the papal brief of 1489 was read aloud, and attention was openly drawn to the circumstance that the probationary term of three years had at last expired. Then the Cardinal was solemnly vested with mantle, cap and hat of scarlet, and also with the sapphire ring (emblematic of the Church's celestial foundation) at the hands of Canon Matteo Bosso, from whose personal narrative this account is largely drawn. 1 The choir having sung the hymn Veni Creator Spiritus, the youth- ful Cardinal stood up to pronounce an indulgence upon all who had attended the ceremony that day, and also upon all such as should repair to the altar of the Badia Fiesolana on succeeding anniversaries of the event. Returning to the refectory, the assembled company was now joined by Piero de' Medici, who had ridden up from the city on a charger of remarkable size and spirit." Meanwhile an immense crowd of friends and sympathisers was beginning to ascend the old Fiesole road in order to witness the ceremony, which was already finished at so early an hour ; but this eager throng's progress was arrested at the bridge over the Mugnone, where all persons were compelled to await the return of the two brothers and their chosen suite. At the Ponte di Mugnone therefore the cavalcade coming from Fiesole was duly welcomed by deputations of the leading citizens, by the whole body of the Florentine clergy, and by the general mass of the people, who with cheers and demands for a blessing from the newly-vested Cardinal, accompanied Piero and Giovanni to the church of the Anunziata, where the latter alighted from his mule to perform his 1 Narrative of 'Canon Matteo Bosso of Verona, Fabroni, Appendix V. 2 Ibid., " Equus mirae ferocitatis et magnitudinis ". 1 8 THE MEDICI POPES orisons at the Madonna's famous shrine ; thence to the Duomo, where more prayers were offered up ; and finally to the Medicean palace, where Lorenzo, sickening with his mortal illness, was impatiently awaiting his younger son's return. Here the Cardinal was presented with a costly service of plate, said to be valued at 20,000 florins, by order of the Signory. Shows and banquets, that occasioned much grumbling amongst the political oppo- nents of the Medici, were given at the public expense in honour of the event, which in the words of the republican chemist, Luca Landucci, "ennobled the city as well as the House of Medici". 1 The meeting between Giovanni and his father on this occasion has been commemorated for us in one of Giorgio Vasari's frescoes in the Sala di Lorenzo it Magnifico in the civic palace of Florence. Although not of contemporary date, this composition is of ex- ceptional interest, because it affords us one of the very few extant portraits of Leo X. in his boyhood. Lorenzo in a long violet robe appears seated on a throne in a garden ; languid and suffering, he can yet regard with proud satisfaction the son who kneels at his feet dressed in the gorgeous robes of a cardinal, and offering his scarlet hat to the parent whose indefatigable efforts had obtained for him so high an honour. Beside the form of Lorenzo are introduced Politian, Ficino and other members of his court, whilst a warrior waves aloft a white banner emblazoned with the Magnificent's chosen device of three ostrich plumes, red, white and black, clasped by a diamond ring. Above this group towers the strange head of the giraffe which the Grand Turk presented to Lorenzo, and the like of which, so Jovius 1 Landucci, pp. 62, 63. CARDINAL DE' MEDICI AND HIS FATHER, LORENZO THE MAGNIFICENT CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 19 informs us, neither the Portuguese could discover in the Indies nor the Spaniards in the New World. 1 True it is that the spotted ungainly creature, which for some months had been the pet of the Florentine populace, succumbed to the sharp Tuscan climate many years before the event thus commemorated, yet Vasari deemed it not beneath his dignity as a painter to introduce this departed favourite of the people into the scheme of his historical picture. Giovanni himself appears as a tall stripling with light brown hair and a fair complexion, whilst a medallion portrait in the same hall likewise presents him as a youth with a pale heavy face, with flabby cheeks and light hazel eyes. From the peculiar angle at which every portrait of the future Pope has been drawn, it is evident that Giovanni must have possessed a blemish of some sort in the right eye : in any case it is certain that even in these early years he did not share the good looks of his brothers, although his countenance must have been singularly attractive from its marked expression of intelligence and humour. But already at sixteen Giovanni de' Medici gave only too evident promise of that corpulence of body which was destined to become in after-life so great a hin- drance to the health and comfort of the Pope. Three days later Giovanni bade farewell to his father and brothers, and with a well-equipped train of followers took the road towards Rome. Travelling by easy stages, which included halts at his own abbey of Passignano, at Siena and Viterbo, he finally arrived at the Flaminian Gate of the Eternal City on 22nd March. Here he took up his temporary abode in the Augustinian convent of Santa Maria del Popolo famous in after 1 Jovius, lib. i. 20 THE MEDICI POPES years as the residence of Luther during his visit to Rome and made his preparations for his approaching audi- ence of the Pope. Amongst the Italian cardinals then residing in Rome during that momentous year 1492, Giovanni de' Medici was likely to find some friends, notably in the powerful Roderigo Borgia, papal vice-chancellor, and in Ascanio Sforza, both of whom had helped considerably in the matter of his own promotion. He could scarcely expect much sympathy from the two nephews of the late Pope, Giuliano Delia Rovere and Raffaele Riario, the latter of whom had been Sixtus' envoy at the time of the Pazzi conspiracy, and had actually been present at that historic service in the Florentine Cathedral, whereat Giuliano de' Medici had been stabbed to death by in- numerable dagger thrusts. According to vulgar report, Riario had not yet fully recovered from the alarm and horror of that terrible scene, whilst his nervous pallid face bore lasting witness to that abominable act of mingled sacrilege and treachery. Lorenzo Cybo, Innocent's own son, would of course be well-disposed to the new-comer, whilst out of the all-too-few members of the College who were conspicuous for genuine piety or learning, the Cardinal Piccolomini, nephew of Pius II., and Oliviero Caraffa. of Naples, were naturally in- clined to take an interest in the proper development of Giovanni's still unformed character. And though some O members of the diminished College were ' disposed to regard their new brother with disfavour, such persons with easy Italian duplicity concealed their private feelings, and openly at least appeared ready to extend a warm welcome to their young Florentine colleague. Thus did Giovanni de' Medici, Cardinal Deacon of Santa Maria in Domenica, make his first appearance CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 21 at the age of sixteen in the midst of "that sink of ini- quity," as Lorenzo did not scruple in private to describe the seat of Western Christendom ; and his first letter telling of his arrival and early experiences in Rome to his anxious father in Florence, although couched in simple s rather childish terms, is not without human interest. " To LORENZO THE MAGNIFICENT, BEST OF FATHERS IN FLORENCE "... On Friday morning I was received in state, being accompanied from Santa Maria del Poplo as far as the palace, and from the palace back to the Campo de' Fiori by all the Cardinals, and by nearly the whole court, although it was raining heavily. I was warmly welcomed by Our Lord ; he spoke scarcely a word, but the following day our envoys visited him, and they had a most gracious audience of him. The Pope set aside the next day for my own reception, that is to-day. Thither I went, and His Holiness addressed me in as loving a manner as possible. He has reminded me, and also exhorted me to return the Cardinals' visits, and this I have begun to do in the case of all who have visited me. I shall write another day to tell you who they all are ; they profess themselves to be very well disposed towards yourself. Of all matters that passed, I know you are fully informed. I shall write nothing more concerning myself, except that I shall ever strive to do you credit. De me proloqui ulterius, nefas. The news of your much improved state of health has given me great joy. I have no further desire for myself except to hear such good tidings often, and for this recent information I beg to thank my 22 THE MEDICI POPES brother, Ser Piero. I recommend myself to you. No more. " JOHN, YOUR SON "Ax ROME, 25/^5 March, 1492 J>1 It was probably on receipt of this simple missive from his second-born in Rome that Lorenzo indited that famous letter of advice, which the good Fabroni eloquently calls the Magnificent's swan -song ("vox cycnea"), seeing that it was composed within a very few days of his premature death at the age of forty-two ; and indeed, apart from the intrinsic value of this epistle, such a circumstance would naturally lend it a pathetic interest. However early in life Lorenzo's physical powers may have sunk beneath the fearful strain of his public and private cares, this letter provides the fullest proof that his marvellous and versatile intellect continued unim- paired to the last. It was indeed a swan-song of peculiar strength and sweetness, wherein excellent spiritual advice, not unworthy of a Fenelon, was so blended with worldly maxims that a Chesterfield might have penned, that it is well-nigh impossible to separate its component elements of an exhortation to a Churchman's strict morality and of a subtle suggestion to turn an ecclesiastical career to the private interests of the House of Medici. That a careful perusal of this remarkable letter is essential to the student of Leo X.'s career, it is needless to state ; whilst it is of special interest to note the extent to which the young Cardinal, for whose future guidance this unique piece of admonition was composed, either followed or deviated from the path thus carefully pointed out beforehand for him by his illustrious father. 1 Fabroni, Appendix VI. CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 23 " LORENZO THE MAGNIFICENT IN FLORENCE TO THE CARDINAL DE' MEDICI IN ROME "... You and all of us who are interested in your welfare ought to esteem ourselves highly favoured by Providence, not only for the many honours and benefits bestowed on our House, but more particularly for having conferred upon us in your person the greatest dignity we have ever enjoyed. This favour, in itself so important, is rendered still more so by the circumstances by which it is accompanied, and especially by the consideration of your youth, and of our situation in the world. The first thing that I would therefore suggest to you is, that you ought to be grateful to God, and continually to recollect that it is not through your prudence, or your solicitude, that this event has taken place, but through His favour which you can only repay by a pious, chaste, and exemplary life, and that your obligations to the per- formance of these duties are so much the greater, as in your early years you have given some reasonable ex- pectation that your riper age may produce such fruits. It would be indeed highly disgraceful, and as contrary to your duty as to my hopes, if at a time when others display a greater share of reason and adopt a better mode of life, you should forget the precepts of your youth, and forsake the path in which you have hitherto trodden. Endeavour therefore to alleviate the burden of your early dignity by the regularity of your life and by your perseverance in those studies which are suitable to your profession. It gave me great satisfaction to learn that in the course of the past year, you had frequently of your own accord gone to Confession and Communion ; nor do I conceive that there is any better way of ob- taining the favour of Heaven than by habituating your- 24 THE MEDICI POPES self to a performance of these and similar duties. This appears to me to be the most suitable and most useful advice, which in the first instance I can possibly give you. 41 1 well know that as you are now to reside in Rome, that sink of all iniquity, che e sentina dituttii mali, the difficulty of conducting yourself by these admonitions will be increased. The influence of example is itself prevalent, but you will probably meet with those who will particularly endeavour to corrupt and incite you to vice, because, as you may yourself perceive, your early attainment to so great a dignity is not observed without envy ; and those who could not prevent your receiving that honour will secretly endeavour to diminish it, by inducing you to forfeit the good estimation of the public, thereby precipitating you into that gulf wherein they have themselves fallen, in which attempt the consideration of your youth will give them a confidence. To these difficulties you ought to oppose yourself with the greater firmness, as there is at present less virtue amongst your brethren of the College. I acknowledge indeed that several of them are good and learned men, whose lives are exemplary, and whom I would recom- mend to you as patterns for your conduct. By emulating them you will be so much the more known and esteemed, in proportion as your age and the peculiarity of your situation will distinguish you from your colleagues. Avoid, however, as you would Scylla or Charybdis the imputation of hypocrisy. Guard against all ostentation either in your conduct or your discourse. Affect not austerity, nor even appear too serious. This advice you will in time, I hope, understand and practise better than I can express it. 44 You are not unacquainted with the great importance CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 25 of the character you have to sustain, for you well know- that all the Christian world would prosper, if the Cardinals were what they ought to be, because in such a case there would always be a good Pope, upon which the tranquillity of Christendom so materially depends. Endeavour then to render yourself such, that, if all the rest resembled you, we might expect this universal blessing. . . . "You are now devoted to God and the Church, on which account you ought to aim at being a good ecclesi- astic, and to show that you prefer the honour and state of the Church and of the Apostolic See to every other consideration. Nor, while you keep this in view, will it be difficult for you to favour your family and your native place. On the contrary, you should be the link to bind this city of Florence closer to the Church, and our family with the city, and although it be impossible to foresee what accidents may happen, yet I doubt not but this may be done with equal advantage to all, observing that you always prefer the interests of the Church. " You are not only the youngest Cardinal in the College, but the youngest person that was ever raised to that rank, and you ought, therefore, to be the more vigilant and unassuming, not giving others occasion to wait for you either in the chapel, the consistory, or upon deputations. You will soon get a sufficient insight into the manners of your brethren. With those of less respectable char- acter converse not with too much intimacy, not merely on account of the circumstance in itself, but for the sake of public opinion. Converse on general topics with all. On public occasions let your equipage and dress be rather below than above mediocrity. A handsome house and a well-ordered household will be preferable to a great retinue and a splendid palace. Endeavour to live with regularity, and gradually to bring your expenses 26 THE MEDICI POPES within those bounds which in a new establishment can- not perhaps be expected. Silks and jewels are not suit- able for persons in your station. 1 Your taste will be better shown in the acquisition of a few elegant remains of antiquity, or in the collecting of handsome books, and by your attendants being learned and well-bred rather than numerous. Invite others to your house oftener than you yourself receive invitations. Practise neither too frequently. Let your own food be plain, and take sufficient exercise, for those who wear your habit are soon liable, without great caution, to contract infirmities. The situation of a Cardinal is not less secure than ele- vated, on which account those who arrive at it too frequently become negligent, conceiving that their object is attained and that they can preserve it with little trouble. This idea is often injurious to the life and character of those who entertain it. Be attentive there- fore to your conduct and confide in others too little rather than too much. There is one rule which I would re- commend to your attention in preference to all others : Rise early in the morning. This will not only contribute to your health, but will enable you to arrange and ex- pedite the business of the day, and as there are various duties incident to your station, such as the performance of Divine service, studying, giving audience, etc., you will find the observance of this admonition productive of the greatest utility. Another very necessary pre- caution, particularly on your entrance into public life, is to deliberate every evening on what you have to per- form the following day, that you may not be unpre- pared for whatever may happen. With respect to your 1 Compare with this Lord Chesterfield's advice to his son, a fashionable layman : " Let your lodging be equal to your means ; your living below your means, and your dress above your means ". CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH IN FLORENCE 27 speaking in the consistory, it will be most becoming for you at present to refer the matters in debate to the judgment of His Holiness, alleging as a reason your own youth and inexperience. You will probably be desired to intercede for the favours of the Pope on particular occasions. Be cautious, however, that you trouble him not too often, for his temper leads him to be most liberal to those who weary him least with their solicitations. This you must observe, lest you should give him offence, remembering also at times to converse with him on more agreeable topics ; and if you should be obliged to request some kindness from him, let it be done with the modesty and humility which are so pleas- ing to his disposition. Farewell." Scarcely had the young Cardinal received this extra- ordinary proof of a father's devotion and wisdom, than there was brought to Rome news of the Magnificent's fatal illness and death at the Careggi villa on 8th April. And thus at the very outset of his career in the Church was the youthful Giovanni de' Medici deprived of a loving parent and a judicious guide, who perhaps whilst he was inditing his final letter to his absent son realised only too well the impending disaster of his own death. 1 Fabroni, Appendix VII. Roscoe, Life of Lorenzo the Magnificent, vol. ii., pp. 146-151. CHAPTER II MISFORTUNE AND EXILE Italy ! O Rome ! I am going to deliver you into the hands of a people that will wipe you out from amongst the nations. I behold them descending upon you like famished lions. Hand in hand with War stalks Pestilence. And the mortality will be so great that the grave-diggers will pass through your streets calling aloud for the dead bodies. And then will one bear a father to the charnel-house, and another his son. O Rome ! again I warn you to repent. Repent, O Venice ! Repent, O Milan ! . . . Florence, what have you done ? Shall I tell you ? The cup of your iniquities is full, therefore stand prepared for some great vengeance (Sermons of Savonarola). R)MANCE and mystery have ever brooded over the death-bed of the Magnificent Lorenzo from contemporary times to the present day. His- torians still disagree concerning the real facts of Savona- rola's undoubted visit to the dying prince at Careggi, 1 whilst his end was accompanied by strange portents or coincidences in Florence itself, which at the moment excited the alarm alike of the learned and the vulgar. Not many hours before he expired, there fell from the cupola of the Cathedral a huge fragment of stone- work with a fearful crash in the dead of night, striking the pavement on the side towards the Medicean palace, whereat it was commonly reported that Lorenzo himself recognised his 1 The reader is referred to Professor Pasquale Villari, Life and Times of Savonarola (book i., chap, ix., Appendix), and to Professor Armstrong, Lorenzo de* Medici (chap, viii.) for accounts of this famous incident. 28 MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 29 coming dissolution in this mysterious accident. Men told each other also how a fine lion kept at the public expense had sickened and died, and again certain of the more credulous spoke of comets trailing their light over Careggi and of a fire-breathing monster which had been seen in Santa Maria Novella. There was an universal feeling of restlessness and expectancy in the air ; a vague presentiment of coming peril, as men began dimly to realise that the loss of their beloved Lorenzo, "the most glorious man that could be found," 1 must of necessity cause far-reaching changes not only in Florence, but through- out all Italy. Yet Piero Piero the Second, as he is sometimes called was straightway confirmed in the ex- alted position held by his late father, and in particular the French King's envoy was instructed to recognise the transfer of the dignity from parent to heir, so that out- wardly at least, the state of Florence pursued its normal course, as though it had been guided for generations under an hereditary monarchy. As soon as the fatal news reached Rome, it was at once suggested that the young Cardinal should return to Florence, in reality for the purpose of strengthening his brother's hands, but ostensibly on account of the coming heats, which the Florentine envoy in Rome affected to consider injurious to the health of young persons. 2 During the short space of his residence in the Eternal City it is evident that Giovanni de' Medici had gained golden opinions from the Pope, who had been favourably im- pressed both by the Cardinal's modesty and by his ap- plication to business. How far the papal satisfaction was shared by the Sacred College at large, it is difficult 1 Landucci. 2 Fabroni, Appendix V. : " Questa aria a giovani maxime non suol esser buona ". 30 THE MEDICI POPES to determine ; yet everyone expressed pleasure when Innocent announced his intention of investing this fortun- ate youth with legatine authority in Tuscany, so that these additional powers might prove of service to his elder brother, thus suddenly called upon to fill the difficult post of an uncrowned and officially unrecognised monarch. The legatine authority was formally bestowed on Giovanni de' Medici in the Sistine Chapel during the ceremony of the blessing of the palms on Palm Sunday, and the news of this honour, according to the young Cardinal's tutor, Stefano di Castrocaro, made a profound sensation at the Roman court, so that we cannot help reflecting on the gratification which this early mark of favour would have afforded to the ambitious Lorenzo, had he been still living. Yet Castrocaro's report also contains a curious postscript addressed to the Florentine envoy, whom he exhorts to speak seriously to the young Cardinal concerning his present mode of life, which differs much from that pursued by his colleagues, so the writer avers. He will not rise betimes of a morning, and will sit up too late at night, whereat the tutor is much con- cerned, since such irregular habits are likely to injure his general health. 1 On this vital point, therefore, upon which his father had laid such stress, Giovanni evidently did not intend to follow the excellent advice bequeathed him, and, as we know, his lazy habits in later life are severely commented on by those candid critics, the Venetian ambassadors in Rome. The Cardinal, who did not return to his native city till 2Oth May, had early written to his brother, bewailing their irreparable loss and also expressing a subject's deep devotion towards one who was now both an elder brother 1 Fabroni, Appendix V. MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 31 and a sovereign, although Giovanni's profession of un- questioning loyalty is tempered by a delicate hint as to future conduct on Piero's side : "JOHANNES FRANCISCUS, CARDINAL DE' MEDICI, TO HIS MAGNIFICENCE, PIERO DE' MEDICI " DEAREST BROTHER AND SOLE PILLAR OF OUR HOUSE! "What am I to write, brother mine, for there is nought save tears to tell of, and of a truth in dwelling upon the pious memory of our father, mourning seems better than language? And what a father he was to us ! That no parent was ever more indulgent to his sons, there needs no witness save his own conduct. No wonder therefore that I lament with tears and find no repose ; yet sometimes, dear brother, I obtain consolation in the thought that I have yourself to regard ever in the light of our lost parent. Yours it will now be to com- mand, and mine to obey cheerfully, for it will give me the highest pleasure possible to perform your orders. Despatch me into dangers ; command me ; for there is nothing wherein I would not assist your ends. Never- theless, I implore you, Piero mine, for my sake to con- trive to show yourself generous, courteous, friendly and open towards all, but especially towards our ow r n followers, for by such qualities there is nothing one cannot achieve or keep. But I do not remind you of this for lack of confidence in your powers, but because I feel it my duty to mention it. Many things go to strengthen and con- sole me the crowds of mourners at our gates, the grief- stricken aspect of the city, the public lamentations in Florence, and all those other details which help to allevi- ate sorrow like ours but what solaces me more than aught else is my having yourself, since I trust in you to 32 THE MEDICI POPES a degree I cannot easily express. . . . Fare you well ! As for myself, I am in such health as my grief permits. " From the City " \2th April, 1492 M1 Of his three sons, Lorenzo had long ago predicted that Piero would grow up headstrong (unpazzo), Giovanni a scholar (un savio], and Giuliano good (un buono), and as usual the Magnificent's shrewd judgment was proved by time to be correct. The new ruler of Florence, though not wholly destitute of virtues, for he was generous, cultured and accounted brave, was far too hot- headed and fond of pleasure to carry out adequately the exalted but delicate duties which his father had performed with such marked ability and success for the last twenty years. Addicted to street brawling and to nocturnal amours, Piero was quite unfit to set an example to the Florentine people. His love of costly tournaments, wherein his undoubted skill often bore away the palm ; his excellence at that rough species of Florentine foot-ball, the calcio ; and his acknowledged prowess at pallone, the popular Tuscan game at ball which requires both an un- erring eye and brute strength of arm, served to endear their new ruler to the idle and rich young men ; but such accomplishments scarcely commended themselves to the graver citizens, whilst they excited the contemptuous dislike of the old-fashioned adherents of the Republic. Piero's mother had been an Orsini, and in her eldest son's character the feudal pride of the Roman house dominated the more crafty qualities derived from the burgher blood ; his wife, Alfonsina Orsini, came of the same turbulent stock, and her injudicious advice went far towards increasing her husband's natural arrogance. 1 Fabroni, Appendix VII. MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 33 Tactless and violent, inordinately fond of sports and im- patient of the routine of business, Piero could never have held the mastery of Florence for any great length of time, and on the whole it seems rather remarkable that more than two years were allowed to elapse before the offended citizens expelled with ignominy this incapable young ruler from their midst. As to Giovanni and his possible restrain- ing influence over his elder brother, we must bear in mind that he had not yet attained his nineteenth year, when the final catastrophe of 1494 overwhelmed the Medicean family, and even assuming that he tendered good advice, it does not appear probable that the rash and conceited Piero would have consented to listen to a younger brother's solemn warnings. On the other hand, had Giovanni possessed Piero 's splendid opportunities and additional years of experience ; had he been educated by Lorenzo as his political heir rather than as a future Churchman, we agree with a modern critic in believing that the forcible expulsion of the Medici in the autumn of 1494 might certainly have been averted. Of a truth, the times were too fateful to allow of medio- crity, far less of downright incompetence, for the year 1492, that annus mirabilis, may be described as definitely marking the boundary line between the world of the middle ages and that of modern thought and civilisation. Europe was passing through a series of changes moral, social and political with appalling rapidity. That memorable year saw the expulsion of the Moslem from Granada, and with it the first blow to the overweening o power of the Turk and the early rise of the vast but short-lived Spanish empire ; it saw too the voyage of Columbus into the New World, that prelude to the dis- coveries of Vasco da Gama and of Sebastian Cabot, which were destined to stultify the whole system of 3 34 THE MEDICI POPES mediaeval geography and astronomy, and to prepare the way for the theories of Copernicus and Galileo. To Italy itself that year was doomed to be climacteric, for the death of Lorenzo de' Medici, that typical product of the earlier Renaissance, broke up for ever the artificial system of balance of power within the peninsula, of which the late ruler of Florence had been the main director ; whilst fresh and unheard-of complications were about to arise on the decease of the aged Pope. Poor Piero's abilities were of course quite unequal to cope with this universal upheaval ; indeed, it is very doubtful if all the skill of his father could have saved Italy from the terrible wrath to come. Scarcely had Piero been three months at the head of the Florentine state, than news was brought of the fatal illness of Innocent VIII., "the constant guardian of the peace of Italy," the firm friend of the Medici and the patron of Andrea Mantegna. The Cardinal now hastened to Rome where a conclave of twenty-three members (for to such meagre proportions had the selfish attitude of the Cardinals reduced the Sacred College in Italy) met to select a successor to Innocent. The conclave was of brief duration, for of the two likely candidates for the tiara Roderigo Borgia and Ascanio Sforza the former by un- scrupulous methods soon induced his possible rival to waive his claims. Five asses laden with bags of gold were seen to enter the courtyard of Sforza's palace, and even this was but an earnest of what the Spanish Cardinal promised to his Milanese opponent in return for his support. Smaller largesse was sufficient for the other members of the conclave, all of whom save five are said to have re- ceived pay or promises from Borgia in return for their votes. The opposition of the pious Piccolomini and Caraffa, of Giovanni Colonna and of the young Medici, MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 35 and the fierce diatribes of Cardinal Giuliano Delia Rovere proved of no avail; on nth August, within three weeks of Innocent's death, Roderigo Borgia was elected Pope under the name of the invincible Alexander at his own request. The elevation of the Borgia was in short almost an exact historical repetition of that disgraceful incident during the decadence of the Roman Empire, when the Pretorian Guard put up the sovereignty of the Roman world for sale to the highest bidder, the merchant Julius Didianus. The evil reputation of the new Pope and the open bribery he had used to accomplish his aims sent a thrill of horror throughout the courts of Italy. The hard- hearted Ferdinand of Naples, who had never been known to weep, even at the death of his own child, burst into tears of rage and fright at the receipt of this news, whilst the intrepid Cardinal Delia Rovere hurried from the city to the castle of Ostia, whence he denounced the late elec- tion as null and void, loudly appealing to the princes of Christendom to call a general council to depose this false Pontiff, this betrayer of the Church. Nevertheless, Alexander held his own despite the outcry, and at least in Rome itself his accession was far from being considered altogether a calamity. For if the new Pontiff had many acknowledged vices (which Italian historians and gossips have perhaps unduly blackened in the case of a foreign Pope) he certainly owned qualities which might have rendered him an able and even a beneficent administrator. With justice but without mercy the disgraceful state of crime and brigandage, which had prevailed in the Roman States under Innocent's feeble sway, was promptly sup- pressed, and for this and similar measures on behalf of the public safety the Roman people felt not a little grateful. " Vive diu, Bos! O Borgia, live for ever!" cried the admiring throngs in allusion to the heraldic bull on the 36 THE MEDICI POPES Borgian shield, whilst during the coronation festivities one of the many laudatory inscriptions bore the fulsome and almost blasphemous legend In Alexander, Caesar is surpast, The former is a God, a man the last ! l But however much the populace of Rome may have ap- plauded on this occasion, such of the cardinals as had opposed Alexander's election at once perceived the ad- visability of withdrawing quickly from the city. Amongst these was the Cardinal de' Medici, who has been credited, on the authority of Burchard, the papal master of cere- monies, with a remark addressed to his neighbour in the conclave, Lorenzo Cybo : "We are in the jaws of a rapacious wolf! If we neglect to flee, he will devour us." Whether or no Giovanni actually expressed himself thus, it is certain that he deemed it prudent to retire to Florence, where he resided until the expulsion of his House in 1494, inhabiting during this period a palace in the quarter of Sant' Antonio near the Faenza Gate. 2 The many snares in the existing situation at home must have been soon perceived by the sharp eye of the young Cardinal, who did what he could to render the tenure of the city by his family less insecure. With the political world without ready to fall into confusion, Florence itself was seething with discontent and with a general desire for reform, a desire which found voice in the impassioned sermons of the prior of San Marco, Fra Girolamo Savonarola. His Advent and Lenten addresses, given within the spacious nave of the Duomo, were attracting vast crowds of citizens, bent equally on bewailing their 1 " Caesare magna fuit, nunc Roma est maxima : Sextus Regnat Alexander; ille vir, iste deus." Creighton, vol. iv., p. 189, note 2. 2 This quarter of the city was dismantled during the siege of Flor- ence in 1529, and its site is now occupied by the Citadel of the Grand- Dukes of Tuscany. N. Richa, Chiese Florentine. MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 37 own sins and deploring the wickedness of those in high places. The recent election of Alexander VI. had caused the deepest indignation to the prior, who was already expounding his predictions of impending disaster to his overflowing audiences, ending each discourse with his three famous " Conclusions," on which all his exhortations were based ; namely, that the Church would be chastised for her present state of corruption ; that she would be regenerated ; and that these measures of punishment and reformation were close at hand. From his conclusions the preacher advanced to attack in scathing language the lives and practices of the prelates of the day, who cared only for the outward adornments of Holy Church for the ceremonies and vestments, the jewelled mitres and golden chalices, the notes of sweet-toned organs and the chaunting of choristers and who only tickled men's ears with pagan arguments from Plato or Aristotle, instead of attending to the true salvation of the soul. From the princes of the Church Savonarola passed to the condem- nation of the secular rulers of Italy, and here his burning indignation knew no bounds ; " these wicked princes are sent to chastise the sins of their subjects ; they are truly a sad snare for souls ; their courts and palaces are the refuge of all the beasts and monsters of the earth, for they give shelter to ribalds and malefactors ". From princes, Savonarola proceeded to "flattering philosophers and poets, who by force of a thousand lies and fables trace the genealogy of these evil princes back to the gods ". And in connection with this last piece of fulmination, we can imagine with what degree of disgust the prior of St. Mark's must have heard of the canonry in the Duomo conferred by the Cardinal de' Medici upon his old tutor, the humanist and reputed pagan, Politian. Names were invariably omitted by the preacher, yet 3 8 THE MEDICI POPES for this general indictment of secular and ecclesiastical corruption in Italy, it was no difficult matter for the vast congregation, much of it already hostile to the Medicean rule, to apply the prior's statements and warnings directly to the sins of the prince and prelate in their midst : the supposed tyranny of Piero and the worldliness of the Cardinal. Nevertheless, Piero was unable or unwilling to take any decided step for the arrest or silencing of this uncompromising monkish agitator. For a short time, it is true, during the summer of 1493, the nominal ruler of Florence, probably at the suggestion and cer- tainly with the help of his younger brother, had contrived by means of the superiors of the Dominican Order in Rome to obtain Savonarola's peaceful transference to Bologna ; yet by an unaccountable act of folly Piero had later allowed the all-powerful preacher to return to Florence, thereby proving beyond the shadow of a doubt that the great Lorenzo's heir was indeed a positive fool, wholly unable to read aright the manifest signs of his times. The evil effects of Lorenzo's loss and of Alexander's election soon became apparent, for the three states of Florence, Milan and Naples were already falling into political entanglements, which the constant intrigues of three ambitious women Alfonsina Orsini in Florence, Beatrice d'Este in Milan and the Duchess Isabella at Pavia made yet more complicated. Almost immedi- ately after his father's death, Piero had begun to exhibit a certain degree of coolness towards the usurper of Milan (whom Lorenzo had always done his best to con- ciliate) and to coquet politically with Ludovico Sforza's deadly enemy, King Ferdinand of Naples ; an attitude which eventually drove the exasperated and nervous Duke of Milan to take a step fraught with the utmost MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 39 importance for the future of Italy. Dreading a combina- tion of the Florentine state with his arch-enemy, Ferdin- and of Naples, the Sforza now determined to save himself from impending ruin by no less a measure than the total banishment of the dynasty of Aragon from Naples, by inciting the young Charles VIII. of France to take forcible possession of that kingdom, which he claimed as heir of the former monarchs of the House of Anjou. The devil, says the proverb, is at all times easier to raise than to lay ; and in this instance Ludovico Sforza of Milan has gained an unenviable notoriety as the original promoter of that detestable policy of foreign in- vasion, from the evil effects of which Italy has been suffering almost until our own days. But at this period the aims of every government and ruler throughout Italy were mean, selfish and provincial to a degree which we find it hard at this distance of time to realise ; the very notion of Italian patriotism, of Italian unity, was practically non-existent in the year 1492. Even the shrewd Lorenzo had always regarded his native land as a mere conglomerate mass of hostile and disunited states, which it required a master-hand like his own to manipu- late, so as to preserve peace throughout the whole peninsula. Nevertheless, it was reserved for a Floren- tine thinker, an obscure and needy citizen, who was twenty-three years of age at Lorenzo's death, to propound to an unheeding Italy the tenets of true patriotism and their surest means of attainment. 1 After much hesitation and in opposition to public opinion in France itself, the young French monarch finally accepted the Sforza's selfish invitation, and at last the vast army of Charles VIII., 60,000 men strong and supported by the finest artillery of that age, crossed the 1 Niccol6 Machiavelli in // Principe, Gli Discorsi, etc. 40 THE MEDICI POPES snowy barrier of the protecting Alps, which, in the words of Michelet, were now levelled henceforth and for ever- more. After a long period spent partly in feasting and dallying at Asti and Turin, and partly in recovering from the ill-effects of his excesses at these entertainments, Charles was again able to proceed, and his splendid army with its fine French cavalry, its sturdy German Lands- knechts, its Swiss mountaineers and its Scottish archers, once more continued on its course towards Naples, where the aged Ferdinand was making feverish but belated efforts in defence of his coveted kingdom. The king's son, the Duke of Calabria, was meanwhile preparing to oppose the French advance by way of the Adriatic coast-line, but it lay with Piero de' Medici to decide whether or no the invaders were to be allowed to pass unmolested through Tuscan territory on the western side of the Apennines. Intense was the excitement pre- vailing in Florence at the news of Charles' progress, and the general concern was further increased, when it be- came known that Piero, anxious to imitate his father's diplomatic methods, had at his own initiative set out for the French camp to treat in person with the king. Both Medicean and popular parties awaited in tense anxiety the result of this mission, and loud were the execrations of the latter party and dire the dismay of the Palleschi, the adherents of the Medici, when authentic details of Piero's bungling diplomacy were brought to the city. For the foolish and incompetent prince " II Gran Lom- bardo," as he was styled by the French court for want of a recognised official title had actually ceded the Tuscan fortresses of Sarzana and Sarzanella, the keys of the road to Rome and Naples, to the King of France. Yet so blind was Piero to the inglorious nature of his late pact with Charles, that he ventured to return to the MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 41 city on 8th November, and throwing open the doors of his palace gave cakes and wine to a number of the popu- lace, whom he assured with a cheerful countenance that now both he himself and the state of Florence were safe from danger owing to his judicious treaty with the in- vincible invader of Italy. But Piero's self-satisfaction, as- suming it to have been genuine, was not of long duration, for on the following day he attempted to force his way into the palace of the Signory in order to explain his late unpopular action, with the result that he was ig- nominiously forced to return to his house amidst the ringing of alarm bells and shouts of contemptuous hatred. Terrified at the hostile aspect of the city, Piero after a short period of wavering finally decided upon flight, thereby committing the last of the many follies which had characterised his brief rule of Florence ; indeed, this final action proved Lorenzo's heir to be not only in- capable but also cowardly. Together with his youngest brother, Giuliano, then sixteen years old, the self-exiled prince hurried to the Porta San Gallo, where horses were waiting in readiness to carry them over the passes of the Apennines to Bologna. Even his voluntary choice of an objective in his flight proves Piero's hopeless incompetence, for his natural bourne under the circum- stances should have been the camp of the French King, with whom he had so recently made a treaty in the name of the state he was supposed to represent. As it so fell, the unlucky prince richly deserved the taunts, however ungenerous, of Giovanni Bentivoglio, tyrant of Bologna, who did not hesitate to twit the head of the once-powerful Medicean House with his late surrender of Florence practically without a protest, certainly with- out a struggle. During this acute crisis produced by threats of ex- 42 THE MEDICI POPES ternal invasion and by dissensions within the city, what had been the conduct of the Cardinal ? Shortly before the approach of Charles towards Sarzana, Giovanni de' Medici had, it seems, been summoned specially to Rome by the Pope. Not daring to disobey Alexander's ex- plicit message, although the Pontiff's request was gener- ally interpreted as a device to obtain Giovanni's person as a hostage for Piero's future obedience to the Holy See, the Cardinal set out for Rome. He had proceeded as far as his own abbey of Passignano, when he was hastily informed of Piero's mission to the French King, where- upon he quickly returned to Florence, now filled with tumult and with the mass of its citizens avowedly hostile to the House of Medici. On that memorable Sunday of 9th November, 1494, the Cardinal, in order to assist his brother's efforts to force an entrance into the palace of the Signory, issued from his house at Sant' Antonio clad in his robes and attended by a number of armed servants. Riding by way of the narrow Corso and shouting Palle ! Palle / the young Churchman contrived to reach the chapel of Or San Michele despite the threatening attitude of the mob and the repeated cries of Popolo e Liberia / Muoiano i tiranni / with which the air resounded. Although the Cardinal kept bitterly reproaching the Florentine crowd for its ingratitude to his House, the red robe was for a while respected ; but in front of Or San Michele, Giovanni was compelled to retire at the risk of his life. An attempt to rouse the poor quarter round San Gallo, hitherto notable as a stronghold of the Palleschi, ended in like failure. The Cardinal now made his way to the convent of San Marco, whereupon the monks ungraciously refused to unbar their doors to a prince of the Church, the son of their former benefactor, Lorenzo de' Medici. Thus repulsed MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 43 at San Marco, Giovanni retired to his own house, where, later, information was sent to him of Piero's unmanly flight. Angry crowds were now gathering round the doors of the palace in Sant' Antonio, where Luca Landucci, no friend to the Medici, declared that he saw the Cardinal's form through the open casement, kneeling in prayer with clasped hands, at which, remarks the good Landucci, " I felt very sorry for him, for I reckoned him to be a worthy young man with excellent intentions "- 1 The beleaguered Cardinal now hastily exchanged his rich vestments for the coarse brown habit of a Franciscan friar, and quitting his palace unnoticed in this garb and mingling with the crowd bent on his own destruction he escaped under cover of the shades of evening to the Porta San Gallo, whence, following in the tracks of his brothers across the Apennines, he arrived a few hours after them at the gates of Bologna. On hearing of the departure of the three Medici, the Florentine populace grew fiercer and more uproarious, so that the proposal to sack the deserted palaces of their late rulers was greeted with shouts of approval. The Casino of San Marco, with its adjacent gardens and academy provided by the Magnificent for the public study of sculpture, was speedily denuded of its treasures, the ignorant rabble hacking to bits the masterpieces of art, which were too bulky for removal. The Cardinal's re- sidence at Sant' Antonio was next destroyed, and its valuable collections all stolen or scattered ; so violent was the behaviour of the mob here that the very fabric of the house was threatened with collapse, and the Cardinal's servants were scarcely permitted to escape with their lives. The great palace in Via Larga was 1 Landucci, p. 75. 44 THE MEDICI POPES however protected by express order of the Signory, not out of any motive of compassion for its luckless owner, but because it had been proposed to lodge the King of France under its roof on his expected arrival. Quantities of works of art and pieces of plate were, however, pilfered, and whatsoever the Florentines spared the retinue of Charles removed a little later, so that it is no exaggeration to say that all the Medicean palaces were sacked and their possessors absolutely despoiled of all their private wealth. Nor was this all, for the Signory, after decreeing the con- fiscation of their goods, next set a price upon the heads of the two elder brothers, now declared outlaws, pro- mising by open proclamation 2000 ducats to the slayer of Piero and half that sum to the lucky assassin of the Cardinal. 1 But before pursuing further the fortunes of the exiled Cardinal, it is impossible to avoid making reference, although such may naturally be accounted a digression, to the coming " Restorer and Protector of the liberties of Florence," as the name of Charles of France was enrolled officially in the archives of the revived Republic. Exactly a week from the violent expulsion of the Medici, late in the evening of I7th November, appeared Charles VIII. as a conqueror with couched lance at the open gate of San Frediano. Mounted on a magnificent charger and clad in black velvet with flowing mantle of cloth-of-gold, surrounded by the flower of French chivalry, Charles made an imposing figure at his entry into Florence. But on his alighting at the portals of the cathedral and thus giving a nearer view of his person to the applauding citizens, general surprise and disappoint- 1 Landucci, p. 75 : "E in questo tempo mandorono un bando in piazza, che chi amazzava Piero de' Medici guadagniassi 2000 ducati, e chi amazzava el Cardinale n' avesse 1000 ". MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 45 ment were expressed at the deformed little monster of a man with the inane face, the staring expressionless eyes, the long nose, the tiny trunk and the spindling legs ending in feet so enormous that vulgar tradition credited their owner with the possession of a sixth toe. "He was in- deed a mannikin ! " l sighs the aggrieved Landucci, who however adds that all the Florentine women were in love with him, old and young, small and great. But perhaps it might be thought that Nature, who in a malignant sportive mood had bestowed so mean a pre- sence upon a great monarch, had presented him by way of compensation w r ith surpassing gifts of intellect. The King's mind, however, was fully as mis-shapen as his diminutive body, for according to all contemporary chroniclers, Charles of France was weak, vacillating, timid, cunning and appallingly ignorant ; indeed, his sole distinguishing quality, which w r as not a vice, seems to have been a vague but insatiable craving for military glory. His lust and gluttony were patent to all, whilst his vaunted virtues were imperceptible ; he had the brain of an idiot and the tastes of a satyr. Such was the sovereign whom Ludovico Sforza had called upon to cross the Alps and act as the arbiter of the fortunes of Italy ; such was the creature whom Savonarola now pre- sented to the people of Florence as the scourge of tyrants and the champion of popular rights, as God's own des- tined instrument to chastise and purge His Church. It was not long before the three brothers were joined at Bologna by another fugitive member of their House, Giulio, the bastard son of Giuliano the Elder, who had managed to escape from Pisa, where he was then study- ing. Nearly of an age with his cousin Giuliano the 1 Landucci, p. 80 : "In vero era molto piccolo uomo ! " 46 THE MEDICI POPES Younger, Giulio had originally been brought up as a soldier by his uncle Lorenzo, who had acknowledged him for a nephew and had contrived to get him enrolled one of the Knights of Rhodes ; but later, on the boy's expressing a desire for an ecclesiastical career, he had been nominated prior of Capua and despatched, like his cousin Giovanni before him, to study canon law at Pisa. As a recognised bastard of a great house, Giulio took an unbounded pride in his family, and manifested an intense desire to serve it in every way, so that early in life he began to attach himself to his cousin Giovanni, following and waiting on the latter alike in good and evil fortune till the day of his death. The three brothers quickly dispersed to different parts of Italy ; Piero following the camps, Giuliano chiefly remaining at the courts of Urbino and Mantua, where his accomplishments no less than his buoyant good nature made him a special favourite with the reigning families of Gonzaga and Montefeltre ; whilst the Cardinal, always accompanied by the faithful Giulio, spent much of his time in Rome, although the Eternal City under the rule of the Borgias was scarcely reckoned either a safe or a respectable residence for a young prince of the Church. During the years succeeding the events of November, 1494, no fewer than five attempts were made by the expelled Medici to regain the city of Flor- ence with the assistance of their political friends, but all failed miserably, partly owing to the unforeseen chances of an adverse fate, but largely on account of Piero's un- rivalled incapacity. It is wholly beyond the scope of this work to follow in detail the course of these fruitless efforts or their accompanying intrigues, except to state that ere long both Giovanni and Giuliano relinquished all chance of success for the time being. At length, wearied out with the hopeless task of attempting to re- MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 47 cover that which seemed for the nonce irretrievably lost, and living in constant dread of Alexander's suspected enmity, the young Cardinal applied to the Pope for per- mission to leave Italy in order to travel in foreign lands. As Giovanni de' Medici was not rich nor his family any longer of importance in Italian politics, so that he pos- sessed little value as a hostage, the Pontiff consented to this request, whereupon the future Leo X. and the future Clement VII., with ten chosen friends of congenial habits and ideas, departed from Rome on their intended ex- pedition. Having reached Venice, the Cardinal laid aside the signs of his rank, so that the whole party might appear dressed alike, and in this manner the twelve travellers crossed the Alps to seek consolation for the fallen fortunes of the House of Medici in the novel ex- citement of beholding strange nations and of visiting the famous towns of Northern Europe. Their first country to sojourn in was Bavaria, where they expressed their delight at the beautiful buildings of Nuremberg and Ratisbon, nor was their pleasure lessened by the terms of perfect equality on which all existed. For every night it was customary amongst them to choose by lot a leader for the ensuing day, whose commands all were obliged to obey without question. And in thus manfully setting at defiance the blows of ill-fortune, the Medici was wont to declare in after years that neither before nor since had he en- joyed so much true freedom of thought and action. At Ulm, however, the identity of this distinguished traveller became recognised, on which the Emperor Maximilian, who had always kept the warmest regard for the memory of the Magnificent Lorenzo, at once summoned his old friend's son to his presence. On hearing from Giovanni's own lips the reason of this pilgrimage, Maximilian's 48 THE MEDICI POPES admiration was raised, and after prophesying a brighter future for the Medici, he immediately congratulated his visitor upon his recent decision thus to turn his evil fate to such good account ; far better it was, said he, for a man, however highly placed, to enlarge his mind by the study of men and manners abroad, than to sulk in luxuri- ous idleness at home. 1 Wending their way up the rich valley of the Rhine with its thriving towns, this band of Italian exiles reached Brussels, where they were hospitably entertained by Don Philip, the Emperor's son, on the strength of his father's warm recommendation. From Brussels Giovanni and his companions proceeded westward till they found themselves at Terouenne near the Flemish coast, at which point a difference of opinion arose as to the advis- ability of crossing the sea so as to visit England, a pro- ject on which the future Leo X. it seems had set his heart. It would indeed have been interesting to be able to record a visit of the Medici to our island, and still more so to learn his impressions of London and its in- habitants, but unfortunately the Cardinal's plan was over-ruled by the majority of the party, who positively refused to embark. Their course was accordingly directed into France, in which country a curious mis- adventure befel the whole party, for at Rouen the magistrates of that town made them all prisoners in spite of Giovanni's protestations and open disclosure of his rank ; nor was it until letters from King Louis had been received that the innocent wanderers were released by the obstinate Frenchmen, whom Giovio consequently describes as hasty and suspicious as a nation. On be- ing at last set at liberty, the Cardinal and his friends 1 Jovius, lib. i. MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 49 were allowed to travel unmolested across France, until they reached Marseilles, where they chartered a ship for their conveyance to Italy, for apparently the aspect of the sunny Mediterranean did not appear so alarming to the less adventurous members of the party as the grey waters of the English Channel. But scarcely had they embarked than a succession of inopportune squalls com- pelled the captain to keep under lee of the Genoese coast, until worn and weakened by the discomforts of their protracted voyage, by an unanimous vote they decided to land at Savona. Here, in the native town of his own humble ancestors, they unexpectedly found Cardinal Giuliano Delia Rovere, an exile from Alexander's wrath, who gave a warm welcome to Giovanni and Giulio de' Medici, and at this point Leo's first biographer mentions with proud satisfaction a certain historic meal, whereat there sat down to table the three famous Churchmen, each of them at that moment in evil plight, but each destined later to wear the tiara successively as Julius II., Leo X. and Clement VII. Bidding fare- well to Delia Rovere, Giovanni de' Medici continued his journey to Genoa, where he remained for some time as the guest of his sister Maddalena, the wife of the peace-loving Francesco Cybo. 1 With the opening of the new century the political situation in Italy underwent a complete transformation. In the summer of 1503, Alexander expired suddenly at the Vatican, and, as Caesar Borgia lay helpless on a sick-bed at this critical moment, the conclave was en- abled to hold its proceedings without fear of any disturb- ing influence from that dreaded quarter. On this occasion the most exemplary member of the Sacred College was 1 Jovius, lib. ii. elected to the vacant throne in the person of Francesco Piccolomini, who out of compliment to his famous uncle l assumed the title of Pius III. But the new Pontiff was already fast sinking to the grave at the very time of the conclave a circumstance that perhaps in some degree prompted the choice of the cardinals. To the disappoint- ment of all Italy, but scarcely to the surprise of the Roman court, the new Pope only survived his elevation twenty -six days, dying on i8th October "What boots it to be pious, when an evil Alexander is permitted to reign for years, and a Pius for scarce a month ? " de- manded an indignant epigrammatist, when the fatal in- telligence was spread abroad. Once more the conclave assembled, and as on this occasion Giuliano Delia Rovere, by means of a secret compact with the now partially recovered Caesar Borgia, obtained the votes of the Spanish cardinals, he was finally chosen Pope on ist November by the name of Julius II. Nor did this fateful year draw to its close without producing one more event of importance to the House of Medici, for on 28th December, during the rout of the French by the Spaniards under the celebrated "Gran Capitan," Gonsalvo da Cordova, poor Piero de' Medici, who as usual was serving with the losing army, terminated his useless existence. For on trying to cross the swollen stream of the Garigliano after the battle, the vessel bear- ing Piero and his cousin Paolo Orsini, together with a number of refugees and four pieces of artillery, foundered and sank in deep water. Piero's body, recovered many days later in the shallows near the river's mouth, w r as conveyed to the great Benedictine abbey of Monte Cassino hard by, of which his brother the Cardinal was Sylvius Piccolomini of Siena, Pope Pius II. MISFORTUNE AND EXILE 51 titular abbot, and here it was buried with due display of military honours. Yet nearly fifty years were allowed to elapse before a monument was erected to the deceased prince, whose memory was perhaps not held very dear by his surviving brothers. In 1552, however, the first Grand-Duke of Tuscany caused a splendid tomb from the chisel of Francesco Sangallo 1 to be raised in the abbey church, although it is significant to note that in its ac- companying epitaph no mention is made of the unhappy prince's career save to state the cause of his early death, and to tell the chance visitor that he was the son of the Magnificent Lorenzo, the brother of Leo X., and the cousin-german of Clement VII. By his wife, Alfonsina Orsini, Piero de' Medici left two children : a daughter Clarice, who was later married to the Florentine merchant-prince, Filipppo Strozzi ; and a son and heir, Lorenzo, afterwards Duke of Urbino, who had been born two years prior to his father's head- long flight from his capital in 1494. It is a striking but hardly an inexplicable circumstance that with the pre- mature end of Piero il Pazzo, the fortunes of the depressed House of Medici began steadily to improve, as the old Emperor Maximilian had predicted to the despondent Cardinal during his visit to Germany. 1 Vasari, Life of Fr. Sangallo. CHAPTER III RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II Julius Secundus loqiiitur. " I raised the revenue. I invented new offices and sold them. I invented a way to sell bishoprics without simony. ... I recoined the currency and made a great sum that way. Then I annexed Bologna to the Holy See. I beat the Venetians. I jockeyed the Duke of Ferrara. I defeated the schis- matical Council by a sham Council of my own. I drove the French out of Italy, and I would have driven out the Spaniards too, if the Fates had not brought me to death. I have set all the princes of Europe by the ears. I have torn up treaties, and kept large armies in the field. I have covered Rome with palaces, and I have left five million ducats in the treasury behind me. ... I have done it all myself too. I owe nothing to my birth, for I don't know who my father was ; nothing to learning, for I have none ; nothing to youth, for I was old when I began ; nothing to popularity, for I was hated all round " {Julius Secundus Exclusus). CARDINAL Giovanni de' Medici had tasted enough of the bitter of adversity to appre- ciate his improved position due to the death of Alexander VI. and the election of Julius II. For the last nine years he had experienced what was practically double exile, being forcibly kept out of his native Florence and at the same time rendered chary of settling permanently in Rome, which was in reality also his rightful abode. Although as a nephew of Sixtus IV. the new Pope looked with no favourable eye upon the political pretensions of the House of Medici, yet Julius was personally at least well-disposed towards the young Cardinal. In any case, through the untimely, or timely, death of Piero, Giovanni de' Medici 52 RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 53 had become a personage of increased consequence in the world of Italian politics. Piero's only son, Lorenzo, was but eleven years old when his parent was drowned in the Gariglianq, so that Giovanni now came to be regarded as the real head of his family, and it was to the Cardinal that the Medicean party, crushed but still capable of future action, now turned with renewed hopes of success. Living with Giovanni in his Roman palace (later known as the Palazzo Madama), not far from the venerable Pantheon in the heart of the mediaeval city, were the cunning Bernardo Dovizi and the ever-faithful Giulio ; whilst often residing with his elder brother in Rome was Giuliano de' Medici, one of the most esteemed princes and most charming personalities of the Italian Renaissance, "pre-eminent above all other men," quaintly observes Giovio, "by reason of the perfect harmony of virtues abiding in his nature and conduct". 1 This im- proved position Giovanni was astute enough to strengthen yet further by trying to obtain the good graces of the youthful Cardinal Galeotto Franciotto, the Pope's favourite nephew and papal vice-chancellor. Although Giovio states explicitly that this newly formed intimacy between the Medici and Franciotto had its origin in the diplomatic aims of the former rather than in any mutual inclination of the two young men, yet it is certain that ere long Giovanni grew deeply attached to Galeotto, and that the sorrow expressed by him at the papal nephew's sudden and premature death was both genuine and abiding, for on the testimony of Tommaso Inghirami, we learn that in after years, when the Cardinal de' Medici had been transformed into the Pontiff Leo X., he could not endure to hear Galeotto's name men- 1 Jovius, lib. i. 54 THE MEDICI POPES tioned in his presence, and if anyone were so care- less as to allude to his passed friend, the Pope would invariably turn aside his face to hide the tears he was unable to repress. And in the Medici's case this instance of real affection, is of peculiar interest, for with the excep- tion of his brother Giuliano, there exists no record of Leo showing any strong affection towards any one of his contemporaries save this nephew of Julius II. With the renewal of public confidence in Rome, Giovanni prepared to enjoy the pleasant existence of a prince of the Church, whose personal tastes, derived from his illustrious father, had early marked him out as a leading patron of the literature and fine arts of his day, so that the hospitable Palazzo Medici soon became known as a prominent literary and artistic centre. Painters, sculptors, jewellers, poets and scholars all found a hearty welcome in the saloons of the Medici, whose natural delight in music also induced him to encourage singers and players of instruments, who were engaged to perform at the many sumptuous banquets that he gave, notwith- standing the dying Lorenzo's earnest counsel to be moderate in all things. For in spite of numerous bene- fices the Cardinal was not nearly so opulent as many of the colleagues with whom he endeavoured to vie, nor was his extravagant style of living compensated for by any aptitude for household management on his part. Even the prudent Giulio's economy was unable to pre- vent his cousin from running continually into debt, an inconvenience which seemed however to sit very lightly on the easy-going Cardinal, although oftentimes the well- spread table stood depleted of its choicest silver vases and goblets, owing to the fact that the plate had been deposited temporarily with the Roman butchers and fish- mongers for lack of ready money. As the Cardinal RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 55 preferred to risk his credit rather than to retrench, debts rapidly accumulated, yet he only declared cheerfully that men of mark like himself were specially provided for by Heaven, so that they need never lack long for all that was necessary, if only they kept a lively faith in their predestined good fortune. 1 When the daily audiences were finished, and the last scholar with his poem in manuscript or goldsmith with some graceful design for a ring or chalice had been dismissed, the Cardinal usually rode out into the Campagna to amuse himself with hawk- ing or hunting, for he had inherited his father's love of outdoor sport. This period of daily exercise in the fresh air was of peculiar value in helping to reduce the already bulky frame, which threatened its owner with excessive stoutness at no distant date, unless he made abundant use of the remedies which Lorenzo had suggested long ago in his famous letter. But this pleasant existence, wherein business, sport and culture were so agreeably blended, this daily life of entertaining and of being enter- tained, of encouraging obsequious scholars who hung intent on his shrewd criticisms, and of examining or buy- ing works of art, could not long continue undisturbed under such a Pontiff as the vigorous old man who had lately ascended the throne of St. Peter. Julius II. undoubtedly shone as a great states- man, but he was in reality a greater warrior, for much as he busied himself in the finer arts of diplomacy, in his heart he preferred the rough life of the camp to the deliberations of the council-chamber. At the date of his election all Italy was at peace, with the exception of the endless war between Florence and her revolted colony of Pisa. Yet this state of quiescence was but the 1 Jovius, lib. ii. 56 THE MEDICI POPES ominous lull before the approaching storm, for the ponti- ficate of Julius was fated to be remembered as the most turbulent and bloody in the annals of the Papacy, a cir- cumstance for which the ambitious policy of Julius him- self was mainly responsible. At his accession the French were firmly established in the Milanese ; the Spaniards were masters of Naples ; Venice was busily engaged in annexing one by one the various towns of the Romagna, which had recently formed part of Csesar Borgia's short-lived duchy, whilst she was also strengthening her position along the seaboard of the Adriatic. Such a situation was bound to lead to mischief in the near future, and although the presence of two sets of invaders con- stituted at once a menace and a disgrace to Italy as a whole, yet it was the growing predominance of Venice amongst the Italian states that most of all excited the alarm of Julius, whose aim was now directed to prevent the Venetian Republic from becoming the dictator of Italy, in reality her only possible means of salvation from the designs of these foreigners. In the first place to humble and cripple Venice, and in so doing to extend the boundaries of the Holy See ; then to rouse the whole Italian nation and by one united effort to free Italian soil from the polluting presence of the " Barbarians" j 1 - such was the ardent desire of Julius, which like many another grandiose conception was entirely local and self- ish in its main object, and patriotic only in a secondary sense. In the military expeditions and deep-laid schemes of 1 The contemptuous epithet of " Barbarian " is fiercely repudiated by the author of the Julius Exclusus, who lays stress on the mongrel pedigree of the Italian people, " who are but a conglomerate of all the barbarous nations in the world, a mere heap of dirt, yet they are absurd enough to call everyone not born in Italy a barbarian ! " JULIUS II. CARDINAL DK MKDICI AND OTHKKS 57 this Pope, the Cardinal de' Medici had for the first time an opportunity to display his inherent diplomatic ability both in humouring the irascible Julius and in silently building up the collapsed fortunes of his own House. That the utmost caution and dissimulation had always to be practised by the young Cardinal will appear obvious at once to those who care to study the characters of the two men, for it would be well-nigh impossible to name two great historical types more diverse from every point of view than the reigning Pontiff and the future Leo X. Thus the Medici was a young man barely thirty years of age, just beginning to creep warily into that treacherous sea of Italian statecraft ; Julius, on the other hand, had many years behind him of varied political ex- perience, whilst he was considered venerable in having passed his sixtieth year in an age wherein medical at- tentions often proved more disastrous than disease itself. Julius was violent, arrogant and ill-tempered ; the Cardinal was always calm, suave and credited with a remarkable mildness of disposition, upon which all con- temporary writers emphatically dwell. The Pope, sprung from a plebeian stock, the grandson of a Genoese fisher- man, with a peasant's coarseness and garrulity ; Medici, a cultured Florentine scholar with a Roman princess for his mother, ever scrupulously courteous even under severe provocation and with a complete mastery over that un- ruly member, the tongue. The Pope was fond of an active military life, loving camps and sieges, not refusing to partake of the coarse fare of his soldiers nor even objecting to use their oaths under stress of excitement ; whilst the fastidious Cardinal had a perfect horror of martial savagery and bloodshed, and undoubtedly held opinions, which were none the less strong because they had to be kept secret, concerning the propriety of a Roman 58 THE MEDICI POPES Pontiff taking the field in person like a general. Julius, although he gave commissions to Raphael and Michel- angelo, had no real sympathy with art, which he regarded solely as an useful means of recording his own prowess ; he was notoriously unlearned, and at times did not hesi- tate to express his contempt for the classical literature wherewith his own court was so deeply engrossed : " Put a sword in my hand, not a book, for I am no schoolman ! " had replied the plain-spoken Pontiff to Michelangelo, when the sculptor asked him to suggest a fit emblem for the Pope's bronze statue to be erected in Bologna. Of the Medici's true understanding of art and letters, it is needless to speak here. In outward appearance, as in age, the two Churchmen offered the strongest contrast ; Julius spare, bearded he was the first Pontiff to wear hair on his chin alert in defiance of his years ; the Cardinal, corpulent despite his youth, slow in his move- ments and constantly requiring spectacles or spy-glass to aid his feeble vision. Nevertheless, although the two men differed in appearance, aims, ideas, age, learning, manners and morals, it was now the manifest duty of the younger man to pay court to the reigning Pope, in order to obtain the full amount of sympathy and con- fidence necessary for the intended restoration of the Medici to Florence, which at this period of his career formed without doubt the overwhelming desire of the future Leo X. In the height of the summer of 1507, Cardinal de' Medici received a foretaste of Julius' methods of cam- paigning, when he accompanied his master on the expedi- tion to reduce Perugia and Bologna, both cities being nominally fiefs of the Church. Twenty-four cardinals in all swelled the papal train, yet only 500 men-at-arms were engaged for their protection, so that it speaks elo- RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 59 quently for the intense terror which the name of Julius had already inspired throughout Italy, that on the Pope reaching Orvieto, Gian-Paolo Baglioni, tyrant of Perugia, should have hastened to come in person to make his sub- mission. Julius received this treacherous vassal of the Church with lofty condescension, and without waiting to collect an adequate army, pressed forward to seize the surrendered city : a piece of wilful rashness, which aroused the wonder, or rather the deep disappointment of Machiavelli, who has criticised this hasty action of the Pope and the cowardly complaisance of Baglioni in one of the most famous passages of the Discorsi. There could be no question that Julius ran the gravest risk in thus placing himself and all his court at the mercy of one who was in reality an aristocratic brigand with a small but well-trained army. The defenceless condition of the Pontiffand his cardinals, together with the vast amount of treasure in their luxurious trains, must have been apparent to the greedy eyes of the Umbrian tyrant ; nevertheless, he shrank from committing a sacrilegious crime on so grand a scale, and for his omission thus to purchase an undying reputation for good or ill, Machiavelli has cen- sured the hesitating Baglioni in the bitter language of which he was an acknowledged master, and in terms clearly expressive of his own detestation of the methods of the warrior Pope : " Men know not either how to be splendidly wicked or wholly good, and they shrink in consequence from such crimes as are stamped with an inherent greatness or disclose a nobility of nature. For which reason Giovanpagolo, who thought nothing of incurring the guilt of incest or of murdering his kinsmen, could not, or more truly durst not avail himself of a fair occasion to do a deed which all would have admired ; which would have 60 THE MEDICI POPES won for him a deathless fame as the first to teach the prelates how little those who live and reign as they do are to be esteemed, and which would have displayed a greatness far transcending any infamy or danger that could attach to it" 1 From Perugia the papal army and its followers crossed the Apennines by way of Gubbio to the plains of the Romagna, not resting till they reached Cesena, at which place the Pope had arranged to meet with the Cardinal d' Amboise, the all-powerful minister of Louis XII., who in return for sundry favours to himself and his nephews, was prepared to withhold French aid from threatened Bologna. Having thus bribed France to complaisance, Julius now launched one of his bulls of excommunication against Giovanni Bentivoglio, who promptly fled from the city to the French camp, all ignorant of the shameless bargain lately concluded between the Pope and the French cardinal. This open display of rank cowardice on the part of the old tyrant of Bologna must have afforded some measure of satisfaction to Giovanni de' Medici, who had certainly not forgotten Bentivoglio's ill-timed merry-making over the misfortunes of Piero and himself some thirteen years before, when the Medici had been forcibly driven from Florence. On nth November, Julius entered the city of Bologna in state, where, as befel every Italian conqueror in that era of perpetual change of masters, the indifferent populace greeted the victorious Pope as a liberator and benefactor, as a second and a more glorious Julius Caesar. Amidst waving of kerchiefs and showers of late-blooming roses, the self-satisfied Pontiff proceeded towards the vast church of San Petronio, nor was he aware that in the midst of the l Discorsi, booki., chap, xxvii. RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 61 applauding crowds stood a sharp-eyed observant traveller from the north with fur collar well tucked up to his ears, who was watching narrowly the passing procession. For by a curious chance Erasmus of Rotterdam happened to be visiting Bologna at the very moment of Benti- voglio's flight and the Pope's triumphal entry into the city, so that to feelings outraged by such a spectacle of worldliness may have been due the production of that striking satire called t\\& Julius Exclusus Pope Julius excluded from Paradise which has ever been attributed to the pen of the great Humanist in spite of his repeated denials. " Would that you could have seen me carried in state at Bologna, and afterwards in Rome ! " the boast- ful Pontiff is made to exclaim to the indignant Apostle at the gate of Heaven. " Carriages and horses, troops under arms, generals prancing and galloping, handsome pages, torches flaming, dishes steaming, pomp of bishops, glory of cardinals, trophies, spoils, shouts that rent the heavens, trumpets blaring, cannon thundering, largesse scattered among the mob, and I borne aloft, the head and author of it all ! Scipio and Csesar were nothing in comparison with me ! " In any case it is certain that Erasmus was an interested eye-witness of the strange scene which is described so vividly in the Pope's apology for his life to the Janitor of Heaven. So far the cardinals, whom their militant master had turned into lieutenants of his warlike enterprise, had not suffered greatly during this autumn campaign. True, they had endured some degree of misery from the bites of the rapacious mosquitoes infesting the marshes of the Romagna, to which their disfigured faces bore ample ^Julius Exclusus. A Dialogue in the form of a drama performed in Paris in 1514. A translation of this amusing work is included in Froude's Life and Letters of Erasmus, Appendix to Lecture VIII. 62 THE MEDICI POPES testimony, 1 but the ease with which an almost unarmed Pope could reduce in so short a space of time and practically without carnage two of the most important towns in central Italy must have given intense satisfac- tion to those members of the Sacred College who shared their Pontiff's views. But this opening campaign, which seemed little short of a triumphal procession with none of the horrors and scarcely any of the hardships of war, was destined to be succeeded by many stern experiences. Towards the close of December, 1508, the celebrated League of Cambrai, the most cherished object of the papal diplomacy, was concluded between France, Spain, the Empire and the Papacy, for the admitted purpose of stripping Venice of all her dominions on the mainland : a political combination against which the Republic of St. Mark made a most feeble show of resistance. Defeated by the French troops at Vaila and despoiled of her colonies, the humiliated state was ere long only too thankful to implore for the Pope's mercy and the bless- ing of an alliance with the Holy See. Having thus reduced to impotence the sole Italian state which seemed capable of resisting the foreign invasion, and having got the towns of the Romagna into his own hands, Julius realised that the primary object of his detestable and unpatriotic policy had been secured, and now that the might of Venice was hopelessly broken for the sake of a few miserable fortresses, he was anxious to obtain Venetian co-operation in striking a severe blow at French influence in Lombardy. A reconciliation was easily effected, whereupon the Pope promptly seceded from the League of Cambrai, even boasting that by such a piece of perfidy " he was thrusting a dagger into the 1 Adriano da Castello, Creighton, vol. v., p. 102, note i. RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 63 side of the French King ". At the same time he made arrangements for a number of Swiss mercenaries to descend upon Milan under the direction of his devoted agent, the Cardinal Matthew Schinner of Sion in the o Valais, who had lately supplied Julius with that historic bodyguard of picked mountaineers, the Swiss Guard, who in their quaint parti-coloured livery have continued for nearly four centuries to keep watch and ward at the portals of the Vatican. Of Julius' endless troubles, secular and ecclesiastical, of his wars and sieges, of his marches and counter- marches, of his massacres and excommunications, we have no space to speak in a work which is wholly con- cerned with the career and character of his successors. But on 1 3th May, 1511, Bologna, "the Jewel of the Pope's crown," was retaken with French assistance by Alfonso d' Este, Duke of Ferrara, who signalised his contempt for the spiritual fulminations of Julius by re- moving from the facade of San Petronio the fine bronze statue of the militant Pontiff, a justly admired work of the divine Michelangelo. Reserving the head of the figure to add to his stock of curiosities in the ducal museum at Ferrara, the dauntless prince had a large piece of artillery cast from the component bronze, which in mockery he christened " Giulio," and concerning which he w r as wont to indulge in many a coarse jest. But a far more serious incident than this open insult to the Pope succeeded the fall of Bologna : an incident which, there is good reason to believe, made an indelible impression on the mind of Cardinal de' Medici, now held in the highest favour by Julius and recently invested with the important see of Amalfi. The late capitulation of Bologna had not taken place without manifest signs of treachery on the part of its Cardinal- Legate, the 64 THE MEDICI POPES worthless Francesco Alidosi, Bishop of Pavia, detested by all decent men but adored for some mysterious reason by the Pontiff, who placed absolute confidence in Alidosi's good faith and personal devotion towards him- self. After the recapture of the city, which was on all sides attributed to the venal aims of this papal minion, the Cardinal- Legate proceeded to Ravenna, where on entering into the Pope's apartment, he threw himself at his indulgent master's feet and openly accused Julius' own nephew, Francesco- Maria Delia Rovere, Duke of Urbino, of having been the cause of the late catastrophe. So deep-rooted was the Pope's infatuation for Alidosi, that he at once turned upon the duke, who was standing beside his throne, and with threats and curses and Julius was ever an adept at foul invective drove the young man, his own nephew and heir, from his presence on the mere word of one who was commonly reported a liar and a villain. Successful in his mission and more confident than ever of the papal protection, Alidosi quitted the palace in high spirits to return to his castle of Rivo, when at an evil moment in one of the streets of Ravenna he chanced to meet with the retiring Duke of Urbino. With ill-timed levity the triumphant Legate must needs jeer at the crestfallen prince, whereupon, infuriated beyond all control by this last insult, Delia Rovere leaped from his horse and with naked sword rushed upon his traducer, flinging him off his mule and raining blow after blow upon the defenceless Churchman as he lay writhing and screaming in the mire of the street. " Take that, you traitor ! and that, and that, and that for your deserts ! " cried the duke, until having dealt his prostrate foe some half-dozen strokes on the head and body, he left the corpse to be hacked to pieces by some of his attendants. " A favourite has no friends," 65 particularly a favourite of the type of Alidosi so that many persons, including the Legate's own servants, looked on unconcernedly upon this murder of an un- popular Churchman in broad daylight. Having com- pleted the foul deed, the living secular tyrant fled with his train towards the lofty citadel of Urbino, leaving the dead ecclesiastical tyrant a shapeless blood-stained mass in the mean lane of Ravenna. Even in those days of universal violence and crime such an act of combined sacrilege and brutal revenge stands without parallel, so that it is highly probable that Leo's subsequent hatred of Alidosi's murderer arose originally from his feelings of horror at this assassination of one who, however vile and unscrupulous, was yet a Cardinal- Legate and a bishop. But of this matter we intend to speak more fully in a later chapter. It is enough to state here that the sympathies of the common people lay as usual with the aggressor, and that the cry was raised on all sides, " Blessed be the Duke of Urbino ! Blessed is the death of his victim ! Blessed be the name of God, from Whom all good things do proceed ! " In fact, Julius alone of all men expressed grief at the news of the wretched Alidosi's fate ; he beat his breast, he refused food, and as he was being conveyed that night towards Rimini from Ravenna a place now grown hateful to him in his bereavement his attendants could hear loud cries of impotent rage and deep groans of sorrow issuing from the curtained litter of this extraordinary old man. When the violence of his grief had somewhat spent itself, Julius appointed a committee of four cardinals, amongst them being Giovanni de' Medici, to make a full inquiry into the conduct of the Duke of Urbino ; nor was it until 1 Diary of Paris de Grassis, Creighton, vol. v., Appendix, pp. 309-311. 5 66 THE MEDICI POPES many months had elapsed that the Pope, at last con- vinced of Alidosi's acts of treachery in the past, finally consented to receive his heir back into favour. At the close of this same year 1511, the Holy League between Spain, Venice, England and the Holy See, an- other political creation of the Pope's fertile brain, was in- augurated with the expressed object of driving the French out of Italy. A new papal army, composed chiefly of Spanish infantry under Raymond de Cardona, viceroy of Naples, and of Italian cavalry under Fabrizio Colonna, was now formed to re-conquer the lost cities of the Romagna, and of this mixed force Cardinal de' Medici was named Legate : an appointment clearly showing how successful had been Lorenzo's son in his supreme efforts to win the complete confidence of a Pope who was originally chary of trusting a Medici. Early in the new year the papal forces advanced to the siege of Bologna, now held by the re-instated Bentivogli with the aid of French troops under Lautrec and Yves d'Allegre. In order to effect a breach in the walls, the Spanish engineer, Pedro Navarro, laid his mines at a certain point of the rampart which was dominated by a chapel of the Virgin, consequently known as La Madonna del Barbacane. The attempt was suc- cessful in its initial stage, for on the fuse being ignited, the Cardinal and the besieging army saw the fragment of wall blown high into the air, and then to their amazement and terror (so Jovius gravely informs his readers) they beheld wall and chapel descend uninjured and fit them- selves again into the breach made by Navarro' s explosion. 1 The spectacle of this military miracle caused a profound impression both amongst the soldiers of the papal army and the defenders of the city ; and whatsoever phenomenon 1 Jovius, lib. ii. RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 67 may have happened on this occasion, it is evident that some curious incident, ascribed by all present to Divine interposition, raised the spirits of the besieged and de- pressed those of their assailants at a most critical moment. In any case, the delivery of the beleaguered town was close at hand, for the famous Gaston de Foix, a prince of the royal House of Navarre, who flashes for a brief moment like some brilliant meteor across the troubled sky of the Italian wars, suddenly appeared within sight of the towers of Bologna. The timely arrival of Gaston and his vic- torious troops, fresh from the sack of unhappy Brescia, was the signal for the immediate retirement of the army of the Holy League. Having relieved Bologna, Gaston next pressed on to Ravenna, which was stubbornly held against his attack by the Colonnas and their Roman followers. Meanwhile the Cardinal- Legate, in duty bound to succour Ravenna, decided to advance, and to encamp about three miles from the town, at a spot in the neighbourhood of the famous basilica of Sant' Apollinare in Classe. The united forces of France and of Ferrara had already taken up a strong position midway between the streams of the Montone and the Ronco, which join at Ponte dell' Asse, about a mile and a half to the south of Ravenna. The numbers on both sides were fairly equal, but the advantage of generalship lay obviously with the French, who possessed Gaston himself, Alfonso of Ferrara, Yves d'Allegre, La Pallice and a host of other accom- plished leaders. On the part of the League, Fabrizio Colonna, the cavalry commander, was reputed to be head- strong, whilst Raymond de Cardona, in the elegant words of Jovius, "shone more in civil life than on the battle- field". 1 Blood-red uprose the sun upon that memorable 1 Jovius, lib. ii. 68 THE MEDICI POPES Easter morning, which fell on nth April, 1512, and the superstitious soldiers in either camp declared that the flushed skies denoted the coming death of a generalissimo, although whether of Gaston or of Cardona remained to be seen. Each army possessed its cardinal in attendance, for with the French was Federigo Sanseverino, one of Julius' most bitter opponents and a leading supporter of the schismatic Council of Pisa, whose gigantic form encased in mail was prominent on a huge charger, as he rode about the French camp performing the regular duties of an officer. Very different were the aspect and behaviour of the orthodox legate. Habited in his flow- ing robes of scarlet and wearing the broad-brimmed tas- selled hat, the full panoply of his exalted office, Giovanni de' Medici made a conspicuous figure, as bestriding a white palfrey and with silver cross borne before him, 1 he passed along the ranks of the Italians and Spaniards, ex- horting the soldiers to acts of valour and offering up prayers for victory. His naturally peaceful disposition made the prospect of a bloody and confused engagement singularly distasteful to him, yet the position of legate in his master's army forbade him to retire from the scene of expected massacre, although in any case his defective eyesight rendered his presence on the battlefield useless in victory and a cause of anxiety in the event of defeat. The fight opened with a duel of artillery, for which the level nature of the battlefield gave full scope, and which proved all to the advantage of the French, since Alfonso of Ferrara had long been paying special attention to this branch of warfare, so that his guns were the best constructed and most ably served in all Italy. Colonna's cavalry suffered severely from this heavy and well- 1 He is so represented in the famous Tapestries of Raphael, see chapter ix. RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 69 directed cannonade, but the Spanish infantry, reputed the best foot-soldiers in Europe, escaped almost un- scathed owing to the foresight of the capable Navarro, who bade his men lie prone upon the flat surface of the plain, so long as the murderous hail of bullets from across the intervening Ronco continued. Colonna, however, maddened by the havoc wrought by Duke Alfonso's artillery and disgusted with what he deemed the cowardice of the Spaniards, now charged headlong towards the river, compelling the Spanish infantry to follow his lead. Along the banks of the Ronco raged the battle with almost unparalleled ferocity, for in this case hatred and jealousy of race were added to the ordinary lust of fighting. Richly clad in a mantle distinguished by the heraldic devices of the royal House of Navarre and with right arm left bare for the fleshing, rode hither and thither that splendid youth, Gaston de Foix, swearing he would never quit the field save as victor and urging the troops of France to pursue the hard-pressed Spaniards, who were slowly retiring in good order long after Colonna's cavalry had been scattered to the four winds. But at the very moment when the battle of Ravenna was actually won, and the enemy's camp already cap- tured, Gaston de Foix, forgetting in the supreme hour of triumph that it is the first duty of every capable general to safeguard his own life, must needs lose everything by a piece of boyish folly. Streaming with sweat and bespattered with human brains and blood, the young leader, flushed with victory and already beholding visions of the coveted Neapolitan crown before his dazzled eyes, spurred in person after Cardona's retreating battalions. In mid-career a stray bullet knocked the prince headlong from his charger to the ground, whence mortally wounded he rolled down the steep bank into 7 o THE MEDICI POPES the turbid waters of the Ronco. In vain did the un- happy youth cry aloud for quarter, shouting to the savage Spanish soldiery above him that he was the brother of their own queen ; little did they reck at such a moment of their victim's birth and honours. Pierced with a hundred wounds in every portion of his body, Gaston de Foix lost at once the hard-won fruits of his victory and also his young life at the precise moment when he seemed to hold all Italy in his eager and ambitious grasp. Death was busy amongst the leaders in both armies, but especially in that of the French, during this historic engagement, wherein at least 20,000 men are said to have perished. Amidst the universal din and confusion, which in this case were not a little increased by the slaughter of so many generals on either side, young Giulio de' Medici, as usual in attendance upon his illustrious cousin, was enabled to escape in the mass of terror-stricken fugitives to Cesena ; but the Cardinal- Legate, impeded by his blindness yet showing commend- able pluck and coolness in a situation of extreme peril, remained on the battlefield, deeply absorbed in performing the last sad offices for the dead and dying. He was engaged in this truly Christian task, when he was per- ceived by some common soldiers of the victorious army, who, recking nothing of the sanctity of a cardinal's robe and person, hastened to lay violent hands upon so glorious a prize as the papal legate. The would-be assailants of the Medici, however, were opportunely struck down by a gentleman of Bologna, named Piatese, who for his better protection handed the Legate over to Federigo Gonzaga, of the noble House of Mantua. Gonzaga immediately led the captive Cardinal into the presence of Sanseverino, by whom his Florentine col- RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 71 league was received with every mark of respect. On the strength of his old friend's kindness, the cunning Medici now ventured to ask as a special favour that his cousin Giulio might be allowed to proceed under a safe- conduct to the French camp. To this seemingly in- nocent request Sanseverino, too much engrossed in quarrelling with the new French commander, La Pallice, to reflect upon any possible ill consequences of his complaisance, at once consented, so that Giulio was able to reach Ravenna before many hours were past. By means of his cousin the shrewd Cardinal- Legate obtained the desired opportunity of sending to Rome an authentic report of the late battle, and also an exact appreciation of the present strength of the French army. For the Cardinal had already perceived clearly that, although the forces of King Louis had indeed gained a stupendous victory, yet the consequences of such a success had been greatly impaired, if not altogether destroyed by the loss of Gaston de Foix, on whose able strategy and far- reaching aims all future policy depended. Hurrying from Ravenna with the Legate's minute instructions, Giulio arrived in Rome at a most critical juncture. Already stragglers from the defeated army had reached the Eternal City, where by the exaggerated language which all bearers of evil tidings are so prone to employ, they had spread consternation amongst Julius and his cardinals attendant, whilst Pompeo Colonna and the Roman barons were already preparing to rouse the populace in favour of an expected French army. The fortunes of Julius had now sunk to their lowest ebb, and so intense was his alarm that an escape by sea from Ostia had even been seriously suggested. To the scared Pontiff and his court Giulio truly brought most welcome relief, for he was able to explain by means of his cousin's 72 THE MEDICI POPES careful instructions that the dreaded Gaston was no more ; that the Duke of Ferrara had returned to his capital ; that La Pallice and Sanseverino were on terms of open rivalry ; and that, in short, there was little fear of the conquerors now descending upon Rome. Time was all that was needed for repairing the shattered fortunes of the League, since the delays and quarrels of the new French leaders were likely to continue indefinitely, so that in contriving to despatch so able a messenger to Rome with such speed, the captive Cardinal- Legate had indeed performed a signal service to the Pope and the Holy See. Thus reassured, Julius recovered his wonted presence of mind and again began to treat with the French King. A master-stroke, also suited to the exi- gencies of the moment, was the Pope's decision to summon a general Council to meet with all convenient despatch at the Lateran, an action almost certain to counteract the dreaded influence of the schismatic Council, or conciliabulo, which had recently transferred its sittings from Pisa to Milan. Possibly this ingenious idea of calling a Council in Rome itself as an antidote may have originated with the Cardinal- Legate, for the very notion of holding such an assembly had always been highly repugnant to the arrogant Julius ; at any rate, it is remarkable that this announcement followed close upon Medici's lucid explanation of the general situation in Italy after the battle of Ravenna. In the meantime the Legate had been escorted in honourable durance to Bologna, where the unfeeling citi- zens came in crowds to gibe at the captive prince of the Church and at his fellow-prisoner, Pedro Navarro. The Bentivogli, however, treated Giovanni with consideration, as did likewise Bianca Rangone at Modena, whither he was next transferred. This lady, a daughter of the RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 73 House of Bentivoglio, actually stripped herself of all her jewels in order to provide properly for the Cardinal's immediate necessities, and it is pleasant to be able to re- cord that this act of kindness shown him in an hour of distress was not allowed to pass unnoticed in the days of prosperity and power that were now so close at hand, for Leo X. granted many favours to the fortunate children of the Lady Bianca. From Modena the Cardinal was taken to Milan, where he was honourably lodged in the house of Sanseverino, whilst many of the leading Milan- ese citizens came to pay him court in spite of his being a French prisoner of war. In fact, the situation in Milan was most extraordinary, seeing that here was the schismatic Council under the presidency of Carvajal and Sanseverino holding its sittings and anathematising the Roman Pontiff, whose captive legate meanwhile was being treated with marked deference by the Milanese themselves, who scarcely tried to hide their contempt for the Council in their midst ; indeed, the ambitious Carvajal was con- tinually assailed in the streets and mocked by the children as "Pope Carvajal". Hither a little later arrived the indefatigable Giulio, armed with letters from the Pope, granting to his legate plenary powers to give absolution to all and sundry at his discretion ; whereupon so many applications were made to the orthodox legate that the Medici's secretaries were kept busily employed day and night in preparing the necessary forms. Numbers of the French officers even openly asked for letters of absolu- tion for their late crime in opposing the arms of His Holiness at Ravenna and Bologna; nor was any atten- tion paid by the governor of Milan to the indignant pro- tests of Carvajal and his colleagues, who complained bitterly of Medici's honourable treatment and his manifest influence. The final withdrawal of the French troops 74 THE MEDICI POPES from Milan before the advancing Swiss at the close of May, 1512, at last compelled the Council, now utterly dis- credited in the eyes of all men, to retire with the French forces, intending, so it was declared, to select some safe spot in France for its further proceedings. As a hostage the Cardinal- Legate of Bologna undoubtedly possessed no small value in the estimation of King Louis, and ac- cordingly Medici was constrained to follow in the retreat- ing army under a strong escort. Ideas of escape had already suggested themselves to the Cardinal, who was firmly resolved not to be carried a prisoner beyond the Alps without making a desperate effort to regain his liberty. The attempt, carefully matured beforehand, was arranged to take place at the village of Cairo on the banks of the Po, at which spot the French army had decided to cross the river. Closely guarded and watched, the Cardinal by feigning illness was yet allowed to spend the night at the humble house of the parish-priest of Cairo, whilst the French ecclesiastics of the Council were embarking in the barges that were ready to bear them- selves and their attendants to Bassignano across the stream. That night a certain priest named Bengallo, who was in Medici's train and was the guiding spirit of the whole plan, went secretly to implore a country gentleman of the neighbourhood, one Rinaldo Zazzi, to act as his assistant in the matter of the Cardinal's escape. Zazzi was at first unwilling to join in so hazardous a scheme, even though the good priest begged him with tears in his eyes to rescue the Pope's legate out of the hands of the discomfited barbarians, yet a last appeal to the ever-potent memory of Lorenzo the Magnificent was successful in inducing the hesitating Piedmontese squire to give a reluctant promise of aid, but only on the con- dition that a local nobleman, by name Ottaviano Isim- RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 75 bardi, should likewise be admitted into their confidence. The disappointed priest had perforce to agree, whereupon Isimbardi was sought and after additional promises and pleadings was gained over to the cause. Zazzi and Isimbardi now arranged to collect a number of peasants from off their estates to compass the rescue of the Cardinal, whose person was to be seized on the following morning at the river's bank, at the precise moment when he was preparing to step into the barge. The whole scheme, concocted with such care and at such risk by Bengallo and his new accomplices, was however nearly frustrated by an error of Zazzi's messenger, who addressed himself to the French priest in charge of Medici by mistake for Bengallo ; and although the servant had the wit to invent a reasonable explanation of his strange blunder, the Frenchman's suspicions were aroused, so that he gave the order of embarkation sooner than was anticipated. By a series of pretended delays, however, some little time was gained, with the result that as the Cardinal, who managed to be almost the last person left on the river- bank, was about to step into the boat prepared for him, Zazzi and Isimbardi suddenly appeared on the scene with a band of armed men, who quickly drove back the startled Frenchmen and conveyed Medici to a temporary hiding-place. But the Legate's troubles were as yet by no means finished, in spite of this successful beginning, for the French, furious at losing a valuable hostage by so simple a device, set to work to scour the surrounding country, though happily not before the Cardinal had been able to don military attire a most unsuitable disguise, it would seem, for one of his bulky figure and elegant manners and to flee in an opposite direction. Under the circumstances Isimbardi, who accompanied the il- lustrious fugitive, thought it best to seek the protection 76 THE MEDICI POPES of a relative, one Bernardo Malespina, although he was known to sympathise with the French faction. To the dismay of the poor Cardinal and to the genuine surprise of Isimbardi, Malespina however not only declined to assist the refugee's flight, but insisted on keeping Medici a close prisoner, until he had communicated with the French general, the celebrated Gian-Giorgio Trivulzi. Shut up under lock and key in a dark and dirty pigeon- house, the Legate had ample time to bewail his evil fate, for there was every reason to suppose that Trivulzi, though an Italian by birth, would insist on his being handed over to the French. But to the unbounded joy and relief both of the Cardinal and of Isimbardi, the general's reply was all in favour of the fugitive ; for Trivulzi informed Malespina that he might liberate the Cardinal, if he were so minded, seeing that fortune had so far helped him to elude his late captors. Malespina had sworn to his kinsman to abide by Trivulzi's decision, and although refusing actively to help in the matter of escape, he had no objection to leaving ajar the door of the dove-cote, as though by accident. Issuing thus from his undignified place of restraint in Malespina's castle, the Cardinal hastened in disguise to Voghiera and thence to Mantua, where he was hospitably enter- tained by the Marquis and his consort, the famous Isabella d' Este of Ferrara. Such are the bare outlines of the story of Leo's escape, and for its sequel we must add that according to his usual, if not invariable custom, on succeeding to the Papacy he did not fail to remember and reward all those devoted friends who had assisted in his rescue. The brave and resourceful Bengallo was nominated bishop of Nepi ; titles and estates were be- stowed on Zazzi and Isimbardi ; whilst the over-cautious Malespina must have lived to regret bitterly his harsh RISE TO POWER UNDER JULIUS II 77 treatment of the poor wanderer imprisoned in his fowl- house. As a memorial of this interesting and by no means unimportant episode in the career of the first Medicean Pope, the Marchese Isimbardi caused the walls of the chief saloon of his villa at Cairo to be adorned with a series of frescoes illustrating the story of the Pon- tiffs flight, beneath which he added a personal inscription, containing the words : "O Ottaviano Isimbardi! to thy efforts of a truth doth Florence owe a Medicean Prince, Italy a Hero, and the world a Leo the Tenth!" Modesty was not a common attribute of the noblemen of the Italian Renaissance, nor self-glorification a rare one. The real political importance of the Medici's escape from the French army at this exact moment must not be overlooked. Had he not attempted, and with success, to break away from his captors, he would undoubtedly have been borne away to France and been kept there as a hostage, at least until the death of Julius II. In that case the restoration of the Medici in Florence an event of which we intend to speak presently would certainly never have occurred, whilst without this increased in- fluence in Italian politics, which the recovery of Florence gave to him, would he ever have been elected Pope, particularly if he were remaining a prisoner honourably treated, no doubt, but a prisoner none the less- on alien soil. Nor, seeing how this extraordinary piece of good fortune befel the Cardinal within a few weeks of his triumphal entry into Florence and within a few months of his ascending the pontifical throne, can we wonder that both Jovius and Egidius of Viterbo should allude to this event as miraculous in an age which attributed all good or evil to the direct intervention of a watch- ful Providence. "It was the act of God," says the 78 THE MEDICI POPES latter chronicler, "and before all other things that have been done in past ages, is it marvellous in our i i eyes ! 1 Cavaliere Rosmini, Istoria del Magno Trivulzio ; Jovius, lib. ii. ; Roscoe, vol. i., pp. 322-324, and p. 324, note 10. CHAPTER IV RETURN OF THE MEDICI TO FLORENCE Let no man scheme to make himself supreme in Florence who is not of the line of the Medici, and backed besides by the power of the Church. None else, be he who he may, has such influence or follow- ing that he can hope to reach this height, unless indeed he be carried to it by the free voice of the people in search of a constitutional chief, as happened to Piero Soderini. If any therefore aspire to such honours, not being of the House of Medici, let him affect the popular cause (F. Guicciardini, Counsels and Reflections), THE discomfiture of the French had been so complete, that soon after the evacuation of Milan there were remaining to them scarcely half a dozen fortresses of all their late conquests in Lombardy. Once more the expelled Sforza were in- stalled in Milan ; Bologna was again in the hands of Julius II., whose fury against the unfortunate Bentivogli burned so fierce that he threatened to raze the whole city and transplant its fickle inhabitants to the town of Cento ; Parma and Piacenza were likewise seized by the ambitious but not self-seeking Pontiff, who claimed these important towns for the Church as forming outlying portions of the ancient exarchate of Ravenna ; Venice, now supported by her new friend and former foe, the Pope, was preparing to annex Brescia and Cremona, which were still held by French garrisons ; whilst the vacillating Emperor and the shrewd Ferdinand of Spain were silently working to obtain some substantial advant- age out of the recent failure of the French arms. To 79 8o THE MEDICI POPES settle the affairs of Italy and to apportion the spoils amongst the component members of the League, a con- ference had been called at Mantua in the summer of 1512. But a more important matter than the pacifica- tion of Northern Italy to be discussed at this meeting was the question of dealing with the only independent state of consequence which had been openly hostile to the victorious League, for throughout the late campaign Florence had remained an acknowledged, if not a very active ally of the French King. The collapse of the late invasion had indeed imperilled the actual existence of the Florentine Republic, now guided by Piero Soderini, who in 1 503 had been duly elected Gonfalionere for life and endowed with powers somewhat akin to those en- joyed by a Venetian doge. Soderini, who was an eminently honest but not very able public magistrate, had for some time past regarded this French alliance with serious misgiving, but partly from a natural in- decision of character and partly from a high-minded sense of loyalty to the pact made with King Louis, he had taken no definite step to dissociate the Republic from an union which was singularly distasteful to the Pope, whose hatred of the French amounted to a verit- able passion. To pursue a middle course under these circumstances proved a fatal mistake, and Soderini's recent conduct in affording shelter to the refugees of both armies after the battle of Ravenna had only ex- asperated the French without winning the gratitude of the League. Now, with the invaders practically swept out of the country, Soderini found himself and the Florentine Republic completely isolated, so that it is not difficult to understand the feelings of grave alarm where- with the Gonfalionere and his adherents were regarding this coming conference at Mantua. In order to propitiate RETURN OF THE MEDICI TO FLORENCE 81 the heads of the League, therefore, the perplexed ruler of Florence despatched to Mantua his brother, Gian- Vittorio Soderini, a person "more learned in the laws than in the higher arts of diplomacy," to treat on behalf of the recalcitrant Republic. Conspicuous amongst the representatives of the various powers convened at Mantua was the Emperor's plenipotentiary, the haughty Matthew Lang, bishop of Gurck, who was ready to offer his master's good-will to the highest bidder. The Medicean interests were in the hands of Giuliano de' Medici in the absence of the Cardinal, who was engaged in restoring order in Bologna. Giuliano, acting under the advice of his elder brother, was naturally lavish of his promises both to Lang and to Cardona, the leader of Ferdinand's army ; but all such promises, however tempting they might seem, were necessarily contingent on the restoration of the Medici, who were still exiles. Had Piero Soderini invested his brother with fuller powers to pledge the credit of the Florentine state to an unlimited extent, he might possibly have succeeded in buying off the representatives of both King and Emperor, for without the Spanish army of Cardona, Julius would in all probability have been unable to carry out his open project to overthrow the existing government of Soderini and to replace it by the rule of the Medici. For, thanks to the years of loyal service and his recent misfortunes in his master's cause, the Cardinal had completely succeeded in winning the papal confidence and favour, and had been actually marked out by Julius as a proper instrument for the chastisement of obstinate Florence, which had not only made an un- holy alliance with the detested French, but had also granted hospitality to the late schismatical Council at Pisa. But although the anxious Soderini must have been fully 6 82 THE MEDICI POPES aware that, in order to avert the papal vengeance and to placate the enmity of the League, there was absolute necessity for other and more subtle methods than mere appeals to fair-play and common-sense, he shrank from bribery on the required scale, allowing the promises of Giuliano de' Medici to transcend in value his own more frugal offers. Meanwhile, the Cardinal, his brother Giuliano, their cousin Giulio and Bernardo Dovizi da Bibbiena, with all their friends, were busily employed in furthering the restoration of the Medicean family in Florence, whether as acknowledged rulers or as private citizens ; the actual form of their re-entry seemed of little consequence at the moment. Julius now willingly invested the Cardinal with legatine authority in Tuscany, whilst there was placed at his disposal the Spanish army under Cardona, which was encamped near Bologna. Yet Giovanni, who fully realised that the precise moment for a vigorous effort to regain Florence had in very truth arrived, still met with many difficulties in his path, in spite too of the warm support of the Pope and the League. Cardona himself regarded with indifference, if not with dislike, this proposed descent upon Tuscany, and the Spanish general's aversion had to be overcome by such sums of money as the impoverished Cardinal could scrape to- gether. Even more serious and exasperating than Cardona's reluctance was the strong opposition of the papal nephew, Francesco Delia Rovere, Duke of Urbino, who stoutly refused to second his uncle's scheme against Florence in this emergency ; denied artillery to the Spanish army ; and even forbade the Vitelli and Orsini, cousins of the Medici and eager upholders of their cause, to quit the force, which as Captain-General of the Church he himself was then commanding. Whether the duke RETURN OF THE MEDICI TO FLORENCE 83 had been secretly bribed, or was acting thus out of a personal dislike of the Cardinal, who had sat as one of his judges in the late enquiry concerning Alidosi's murder, it is impossible to say ; but certain it is that his unseason- able attitude of sharp hostility to the Medici was one which he had every reason ere long to deplore under the Medicean pontificate, which he little dreamed was so near at hand. But the energy and tact of the Cardinal were sufficient to surmount all initial difficulties. It was he who contrived to purchase two pieces of the much- needed artillery, and during the passage of the Apennines it was his personal influence with the mountaineers that secured pack-horses and food for the ill-equipped army. At the village of Barberino, on the confines of the Re- public's territory, arrived an embassy from the city of Florence, offering terms to which Cardona might have been tempted to accede, had it not been for the presence of the Cardinal, who insisted before all things upon the acceptance of the League's late resolution a resolution naturally of the first importance to the struggling Medici that the exiled members of the family should be per- mitted to return to Florence as private citizens. Upon this vital question the negotiating parties were quite unable to agree, the Gonfalionere boldly stating his preference for an appeal to arms rather than for any arrangement which might include a restoration of the Medici ; and to this grave determination Soderini had been urged not a little by the arguments of Niccolo Machiavelli, his secretary-of-state, who had now served the Florentine Republic with devoted skill for the past fourteen years. Acting under Machiavelli's advice, Soderini now permitted the enrolment of a force of local militia, and also gave orders for the strengthening of all fortresses, whilst he boldly thrust into prison some twenty- 84 THE MEDICI POPES five prominent supporters of the Medicean faction, who were already agitating noisily for the return of their patrons. Having taken measures so decided and alert, the Gonfalionere, convoking the Grand Council of the city, amidst breathless silence addressed his fellow-citizens in a speech, which for pure patriotism, sound reasoning and personal unselfishness must ever confer honour upon the speaker, and to some extent redeem his fixed reputa- tion for incompetence and sloth. After expressing his readiness to resign the office of Gonfalionere, Soderini warned all loyal upholders of the Republic against re- admitting the Medici within their walls, even in the guise of private citizens. For true citizens they could no longer be, he clearly explained, since after so many years of absence from civic life and of residence in foreign courts, they had been transformed into princes, even assuming they had been private persons at the time of their expulsion nearly twenty years before. And this remark would apply with special force to the young- Lorenzo de' Medici, the heir of the family, who, having been an infant at that date, could not therefore possibly remember any of the traditions of his House, but would of necessity behave like a tyrant of the type of a Benti- voglio or a Gonzaga, relying not upon the public love and acquiescence in his rule, but upon force of arms and the support of the Papacy, which his uncle the Cardinal coulcl be trusted to obtain. The Gonfalionere ended his oration by solemnly warning his hearers that the times and government of Lorenzo il Magnifico, " who was ever anxious to cover his real prerogative with a mantle of private equality rather than to make an ostentatious display of his power," would be reckoned as a golden age compared with the open tyranny which his sons and grandsons would inaugurate, were they admitted into the city. "It therefore becomes your duty," were his last words, "now to decide, whether I am to resign my office (which I shall cheerfully do at your bidding), or whether I am to attend vigorously to the defence of our fatherland, if you desire me to remain." 1 The patriotic and sensible arguments used by Soderini were received with enthusiasm by his audience, and even by the mass of the citizens, who were distinctly averse to a Medicean restoration. For a time the united determination of the Florentines to resist any attempt at invasion was manifest and genuine, whilst the work of defence, already begun in the early summer, was being pushed forward with feverish alacrity, chiefly under the supervision of Machiavelli. But although Machiavelli was perhaps the greatest genius of his age and whole- hearted in his endeavours to defend his fatherland, yet his talents shone rather in the theoretical than in the practical art of warfare. He could give excellent advice on paper as to strategy and training, but as a civilian pure and simple he was scarcely competent to undertake those more laborious tasks, which necessarily belong to the peculiar province of skilled generals and engineers. Unlike his great fellow-citizen Michelangelo, who was destined seventeen years later to erect the fortifications of San Miniato during the siege of Florence, Machiavelli was neither architect nor mechanician ; yet it is of interest to recall the plain circumstance that on two momentous occasions Florence was prepared for defence by the devoted efforts of this pair of her most illustrious sons. The town of Prato with its crumbling brown walls 1 Guicciardini, Storia d* Italia, lib. xi. 86 THE MEDICI POPES and its black and white striped cathedral-tower, which rises so prominent a feature of the fertile and populous Val d' Arno, stands on the right bank of the rushing Bisenzio, and at no great distance from the western slopes of Monte Morello. Even to-day Prato retains much of its mediaeval appearance, whilst its works of art by Donatello and the Robbias, and also Lippo Lippi's glorious frescoes in the cathedral-choir, attract yearly many visitors to the prosperous little city that stands in the midst of a fruitful Tuscan landscape. Situated within eight miles of Florence, this place had long shared the political fortunes of its more important neighbour, and it was familiar to Giovanni de' Medici, who in the past had been itsproposto, or nominal protector, although his first visit hither, undertaken nearly twenty years ago, had been attended by a melancholy accident of a type common enough in those days of elaborate pageants. A triumphal arch, placed above the Florence gate of the town and intended to represent some allegorical scene, had suddenly collapsed on the young Cardinal's approach, so that two pretty children, dressed as welcoming angels, fell to the ground and perished miserably in the wreck- age : an unforeseen catastrophe which quickly changed the festal aspect of the town into one of universal mourn- ing. 1 The Pratesi now, on hearing of the advance of Cardona's army bearing in its ranks their late protector, their " Dolce Pastore," as certain poets had designated him, recalled to mind this long-passed event, and drew an evil augury from the near presence of the Cardinal. Nor were the good people deceived in their dismal prognostications, although the Florentine Signory had hastened to pour thousands of troops within their walls, 1 Nardi, Islorie Florentine, lib. v. RETURN OF THE MEDICI TO FLORENCE 87 since it was openly known that Cardona, deeming his artillery too weak and his men too exhausted to attack Florence itself, was meditating an assault upon Prato, where he could at least obtain the means of victualling o his famished troops. The first effort of the Spaniards resulted in complete failure, due rather to a lack of cannon than to any skill on the part of Luca Savelli, the Florentine commander ; but the second assault, made from the direction of Campi on the afternoon of 29th August, succeeded with an ease which astonished all who witnessed the operations. Battering down with the Cardinal's two pieces of cannon a portion of the wall near the Mercatale gate, the Spaniards rushed into the breach almost unopposed ; the Tuscan militia bands, a mere rabble of armed peasants that Machiavelli had levied for the defence, flying like frightened sheep before the onslaught of Cardona's veterans. Thereupon followed an indescribable scene of confusion, plunder and massacre, the awful effects of which have not been forgotten to this day in unhappy Prato, "where, rightly or wrongly, the name and memory of Giovanni de' Medici, Pope Leo X. will for ever be associated with the blood and tears of its citizens "- 1 For nearly two days the Sack of Prato of impious recollection raged unchecked. Neither age nor sex was spared by the ferocious soldiery, who were said, though probably without truth, to have included a large number of Moslem mercenaries. No quarter was granted either to peaceful merchant or to fleeing peasant ; priests were struck down at the altar ; the crucifix, and even the Host were insulted ; the churches were plundered ; and the famous shrine of the Cintola, the Madonna's girdle, which is the historic 1 Baldanzi, Storia della Chiesa Cattedrale di Prato. 88 THE MEDICI POPES relic of Prato, is said to have escaped depredation only by means of a timely miracle that terrified its would-be devastators. 1 Monasteries were set on fire, and their inmates stabbed or beaten ; the very convents were invaded by the licentious soldiery. "It was not a struggle, but sheer butchery," comments the historian Nardi ; "it was an appalling spectacle of horrors," de- clares the unemotional Machiavelli, whose hastily-levied militia had in no small degree contributed by cowardice and inexperience to the disaster itself. To add to the terrors of the scene, a fearful thunderstorm with torrents of rain raged all night over the town, so that the fiendish work of destruction and outrage was rendered yet more easy, and any attempt at keeping order was thereby rendered impossible. " The place was a verit- able pool of blood," writes a contemporary chronicler ; and indeed, when we take into account the small area of the town and the mass of soldiery suddenly admitted within the narrow compass of its walls, it becomes easy to understand so terrible, if exaggerated a description, especially on hearing that the number of those who perished in the sack of Prato has been estimated at so high a figure as 5000 persons. With the dawn of 3