8 "*!*"* LETTER TO ADAM SMITH, LLD. Printed by Bye and Law, St. John's Square, Clcrkenwell. LETTER TO ADAM SMITH, LL.D. ON THE LIFE, DEATH, and PHILOSOPHY OF HIS FRIEND DAVID HUME, Esq. By one of the People called CHRISTIANS. Ibant olfcuri, fold fab noBe, per umbram, Perque domos Ditis vacuas, et inania regna. • VlRG. A NEW EDITION, PUBLISHED EY DESIRE Of THE SOCIETY FOR PROMOTING CHRISTIAN KNOWLEDGE Hontron : PRINTED FOR F. AND C. RIVINGTON, BOOKSELLERS TO THE SAID SOQJETY, NO. 62, ST. PAUL'S CHURCH-YARD, 1799. N, B. TJie Author of this Tract was GEORGE HORNE, D. ZX Xate Lord Bifhop of Norwich. SRLF ADVERTISEMENT. n ^ T is of no confequence, gentle Reader,. to you, any more than it is to Dr. Smith, that you mould know the name of the perfon, who now addrefTeth you.. Your mind cannot be piaffed, either way, by that, of which you remain ignorant. The remarks in the following pages are not therefore true, or falfe, becaufe I made them j but I made them, becaufe I thought them to be true. Read, confider, and deter- mine for yourfelf. If you find no fatis- faclion, throw the book into the fire ; regret (but with moderation, as becometh a philofopher) the lofs of your fixpence*; The price of the firft edition. a 3 and -9 OQO VI ADVERTISEMENT. and take care not to lofe another, in the fame manner. If, on the contrary, you Jhould find fatisfaction (and, it is humbly hoped, you will find a great deal) neglect not to communicate toothers, what has thus been communicated to you. Speak hand- fomely of me, wherever you go, and in- troduce me to your kinsfolk and acquaint- ance. The enemies of Religion are awake; let not her friends fleep. I intended a much longer work ; but, like the learned editor of Mr. Hume's Life, am neceffitated to " gratify," with all poffible expedition, *' the impatience " of the public curiofity;" fo eager is it to hear, what they, who believe in God, can poflibly have to fay for themfelves. And if this will do the bufinefs, why mould ADVERTISEMENT. Vll mould you be troubled with more ? I am far from agreeing with Mr. Voltaire, in all his obfervations. But there is one, in which it is impoffible to diiagree with him. " I have faid, and I abide by it," cries the little hero, " that the fault of '* molt books is, their being too large." On reviewing what I have written, I really cannot fee there is occafion to add another fentence. Had I not chofen, for reafons belt known to myfelf, thus to make my ap- pearance incog, I would certainly have fate for my piclure, and have tried to caft a look at my title page, as lively and good humoured, as that of Mr. Hume himfelf. My bookfeller, indeed, told me, it would have been a much more credit- a 4 able Vlll ADVERTISEMENT. able way of doing the thing; " and then, " you know, Sir," faid he, " we could " have charged the other Sixpence," A LET- LETTER, &c. SIR, VOU have been lately employed in em— -■- balming a philoibpher; his body, I be- lieve I mull fay; for concerning the other part of him, neither you nor he feem to have entertained an idea, fleeping or waking,. Elfe, . it furely might have claimed a little of your, care and attention; and one would think, the belief of the foul's exiftence and immortality • could do no harm, if it did no good, in ai Theory of Moral Sentiments. But every pen-- tleman underftands his own bufinefs belt. Will, you do an unknown correspondent- the honour, .Sir, to accept a \(m ry}:drt re- marks, in a free and eafy way, upon thee cu- rious letter to Mr. St rah an,, in which; this . a 5 ever;- lO A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITH. ever memorable operation of embalming is performed ? Our Philofopher's account of his own life will likewife be confidered, as we go along. Truft me, good Doctor, I am no bigot, enthufiaft, or enemy to human learning — Et ego in Arcadia — I have made many a hearty meal, in private, upon Cicero and Virgil, as well as Mr. Hume *. Few perfons (though, perhaps, as Mr. Hume fays, upon a like oc- cafion, " I ought not to judge on that fub- Cf ject") have a quicker relifh for the pro- du6tions of genius, and the beauties of com- pofition. It is therefore as little in my in- tention, as it is in my power, to prejudice the literary character of your friend. From fome of his writings I have received great pleafure, and have ever efteemed his Hiftory of England to have been a noble effort of matter and motion. But when a man takes it into his head to do mifchief, you muft be fenfible, Sir, the Public has always reafon to lament his oeing a clever fellow. * Life, p. 5, I hope A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITH. II I hope it will not be deemed vanity in me likewife to fay, that I have in my compofition a large proportion of that, which our inimi- table Shakespeare ftyles, the milk of human kindnejs. I never knew what envy or hatred was; and am ready, at all times, to praife, wherever I can do it, in honour and confid- ence. David, I doubt not, was, as you affirm, a focial agreeable perfon, of a convi- vial turn, told a good ftory, and played well at " his favourite game of whift*." I know not that John the Painter did the fame. But there is no abfurdity in the fuppofition. If he did not, he might have done it — Doctor, be not offended — I mean no harm. I would only infer. thus much, that I could not, on that account, bring myfelf abfulutely to ap- prove his odd fancy of firing all the dock- yards in the kingdom. Concerning the philofophical opinions of Mr. Hume you obferve f, that " men will, no " doubt, judge varioufly." They are cer- tainly at liberty fo to, do, becaufe the author • Life, &c. p. 43. f Life, &c> p. 59. a 6. him id f 12 - A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITH. himfelf did the fame. Sometimes, to be fure, he efteemed them ingenious, deep, fubtile, elegant, and calculated to diffufe his literary fame to the ends of the world. But, at other times, he judged very differently; very much fo, indeed. " I dine," fays he, '-* I play a game at back-gammon, I converfe, little clofer to you, Doctor, if you pleafe, upon this fubject — Don't be under any apprehenfions — my name does not begin with a B — ) Arc ysu fure, and can you make us fure, that there really exift no 14 A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITH. no fuch things as a God, and a future ftate of rewards and punifhments ? If fo, all is well. Let us then, in our laft hours, read Lucian, and play at whist, and droll upon Charon and his boat * ■, let us die as foolifh and in- lcnfible, as much like our brother philofo- phers, the calves of the field, and the afifes of the defart, as we can, for the life of us. But —-if fuch things be — as they moll certainly are— Is it right in you, Sir, to hold up to our view, as " perfectly wife and virtuous f," the character and conduct of one who feems to have been poneffed with an incurable antipathy to all that is called religion ; and who {trained every nerve to explode, fupprefs, and extirpate the fpirit of it among men, that it's very name, if he could effect it, might no more be had in remembrance ? Are we, do you imagine, to be reconciled to a character of this fort, and fall in love with it, becaufe it's owner was good company, and knew how to manage his. cards? Low as the age is fallen, I wiil venture to hope, it has grace enough yet left, to refent fuch ufage as this. * Life, &c. p. 47, et fe.|. f Life, &c)r. 62. You A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITH. 1$ You endeavour to entertain us with Tome •pleajant conceits that were fuppofed by Mr, Hume to pafs between himfelf and old Cha- ron. The philofopher tells the old gentle- man, that, cc he had been endeavouring to " open the eyes of the Public ■," that he was cc correcting his works for a new edition," from which great things were to be expected ; in fhort, " if he could but live a few years " longer (and that was the only reafon why " he would wifh to do fo) he might have the tf fatisfadlion of feeing the downfal of fome " of the prevailing fyftems of Jwperji ition *." We all know, Sir, what the word super- stition denotes, in Mr. Hume's vocabulary, and again!! what Religion his fhafts are level- led, under that name. But, Doctor Smith, do you believe, or would you have compaJJion y generofity y charity. Alas, Sir, whither were they all fled, when he fo often fate down calmly and deliberately to obliterate from the hearts of the human fpecies every trace of the knowledge of God and his difpenfations ; all faith in his kind providence, and fatherly protection;, all hope of enjoying his grace and favour, here, or hereafter; all love of him, and of their brethren for his fake ; all the patience under tribulation, all the com- forts, in time of forrow, derived from thefe fruitful and perennial fources ? Did a good man think himfclf able, by the force of me- taphyiic incantation, in a moment, to blot the fun out of heaven, and dry up every * Life, &c. p. 59. fountain l8 A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITH. fountain upon earth, would he attempt to do it? — Tully had but a faint glimpfe of the country to which we are all travelling ; yet, fo pleafing was any the mod imperfect and fhadowy profpeft into futurity, that Tully declared, no man fhould ravifh it from him*. And furely, Tully was a philofopher, as well as Hume. O had he feen the light which {hone upon Hume, he would not have clofed his eyes againft it -, had the fame cup been offered to him, he would not have darned it untafted from him ! " Perhaps our modern fceptics are igno- " rant, that without the belief of a God, and " the hope of immortality, the miferies of " human life would often be infupportable. " But can I fuppofe them in a Hate of total " and invincible ftupidity, utter flrangers to " the human heart, and to human affairs? " Sure, they would not thank me for fuch " a fuppofition. Yet this I muft fuppofe, * Quod fi in hoc erro* quod animos hominum im- mortales eiFe credam, libenter erro ; nee mihi hunc errorem, quo deleclor, dum vivo, extorqueri volo. DsSenectute, ad Fin. or (C A LETTER TO DR. ADAM SMITK. I 9 Cf or I mull believe them to be the moft cruel, the moft perfidious, and the moft profligate of men. CarefTed by thofe who (c call themfelves the great, ingrofled by the l every thing in the univerfe proceeds from fomfc caufe ; yet it would be unreafonable for him to believe, that the univerfe itfelf pro- ceeds from a caufe. OF HUMAN KNOWLEDGE. That the perfection of human knowledge is to doubt. That we ought to doubt of every thing, yea, of our doubts themfelves, and there- fore, the utmoft that philofophy can do, is to give us a doubtful folution of doubtful doubts *. That the human understanding, acting alone, does entirely fubvert itfelf, and prove by ar- gument, that by argument nothing can be proved. That man, in all his perceptions, actions, and volitions, is a mere pafTive machine, and has no feparate exiftence of his own, being entirely made up of other things, of the exift- * The fourth fedion of Mr. Hume's EJJ'ays on the Human Uiiderjianding, is called Sceptical doubts concerning the operations of the human underjlanding ; and the fifth fe&ion bears chis title, Sceptical Solution of thofe doubts. ence 3 2 POSTSCRIPT. ence of which he is by no means certain y and yet, that the nature of all things depends fb much upon man, that two and two could not be equal to four, nor fire produce heat, nor the fun light, without an act of the human, understanding. OF GOD. That it is unreafonable to believe God to be infinitely wife and good, while there is any evil or diforder in the univerfe. That we have no good reafcn to think the univerfe proceeds from a caufe.. That as the existence of the external world is queftionable,. we are at a lofs to find argu- ments by which we may prove the exiftence of the Supreme Being, or any of his attri- butes. That when we fpeak of Power, as an attri- bute of any being, God himfelf not excepted, we life words without meaning:. That we can form no idea of power, nor of any being endued with power, much lefs of one endued with infinite power ; and that we can POSTSCRIPT*. J ? Fan never have reafon to believe, that any object, or quality of any objed exifts, of which we can form an idea *. OF THE MORALITY OF HUMAN ACTIONS. That every human action is neceffary, and could not have been different from what it is. That moral, intellectual, and corporeal vir- tues are nearly of the fame kind — In other words, that to want honeily, and to want un- derstanding, and to want a kg, are equally the objects- of moral difapprobation. That adultery muft be pradifed, if men would obtain all the advantages of life ; that, if geirerally practifed, it would in time ceafe to be fcandalous ; and that, if pradifed fe- en j tly and frequently, it would by degrees come to be thought no crime at all. Laftly, as the foul of man, according to Mr. Flu me, becomes every moment a diffe- The poor prodigal Gentile, in the parable, was hardly reduced to feed upon fuch husks as thefe. How good and how joyful a thing muft it be, for one, that has been fo reduced, to return to the houfe of his hea- venly Father, where there is bread enough and to /pare — to knew the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom • f rent 34 POSTSCRIPT. rent being, the confequence mult be, that the crimes committed by him at one time, cannot be imputable to him at another *. I believe, Doctor Smith, the reader is now fully prepared to enter into the fpirit of your concluding fentence, which therefore lhall be mine. " I have always confidered Mr. Hume, i( both in his life-time, and'fince his death, as " approaching as nearly to the idea of a per- " FECTLY WISE AND VIRTUOUS MAN, aS per- " haps the nature of human frailty will li permit." * " My Enquiry concerning the Principles of Met als is of '* all my writings, hiftorical, philofophical, or literary* " incomparably the best." Life, p. 16. THE END, Frinted by Bye and Law, St. JohnVStpare. Lately publified, By Ddire of the Society for Promoting Christian- Knowledge, New Editions of tbe following; Tracts : r. A SHORT and EASY METHOD with the DEISTS ; wherein the Certainty of the Christian Reli- gion is demonftrated by infallible Proof, from Four Rules, which are incompatible to any Impofture that ever yet lias been, or can poffibly be. In a Letter to a Friend. To which is added, Trie Truth of Chriitianity demonftra'ed, in a Dialogue between a Chriftian and a Deift; wherein the Cafe of the Jews is like wife considered. By the late Rev. Charles Leslie, m.a. With a Letter from the Author to a Deift, upon hi s Converfion by reading his Book. To which is prefixed, A Preface, by the Rev. W, Jones, m.a. Author of the Catholic Doctrine of the Trinity, &c. Price zs. 6d. fevved. 2. OBSERVATIONS on the CONVERSION and APOSTLESHIP of St. PAUL. In a Letter to Gilbert Weft, Efq. By the late Right Hon. George, Lord Lyttelton. Price is. 6d. fevved. 3. A TREATISE on the NATURE and CONSTI- TUTION of the CHRISTIAN CHURCH; wherein. are fet forth the Form of its Government, the Extent ■of its Powers, and the Limits of our Obedience. By William Stevens, Efq. Price Four-pence. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY O r Los Angeles This book is DUE on the last date stamped below. §gj?08 p |665 7 .4 A-3 1 J0V V NIAV2 ftPR3 0l98i L9-75m-7,'61(Cl437s4)444 UC SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY A A 000 206 768