AIAAXH TON AHAEKA AnOSTOAHN. of tbe twelve Hpostles. RECENTLY DISCOVERED A\D PUBLISHED BY ffflLOTHEOS BRTENXfOS, METROPOLITAN OF NICOMEDIA. EDITED WITH A TRANSLATION, INTRODUCTION AND NOTES, BY ROSWELL D. HITCHCOCK AND FRANCIS BROWN, PROFESSORS IN" UNION THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY, NEW YORK. X . ,7 J ft L AIAAXH TUN AHAEKA TEACHING THE TWELVE APOSTLES. RECENTLY DISCOVERED AND PUBLISHED BY PHILOTHEOS BRYENNIOS, METROPOLITAN OF NICOMEDIA. EDITED WITH A TRANSLATION, INTRODUCTION AND NOTES, BT ROSWELL D. HITCHCOCK AND FRANCIS BROWN, PROFESSOUS IN UNION THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY, NEW YORK. NEW YORK: CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS. 1884. 5 COPYKIGHT, 1884, BT CHARLES SCEIBNER'S SONS. INTRODUCTION. IN 1875 Philotheos Bryennios, then Metro- politan of Serrae (now Serres), in ancient Mace- donia, published the two Epistles of Clement of Rome, from a manuscript discovered by him in the Library of the Most Holy Sepulchre in Fanar of Constantinople. The last six chapters (60-65) of the First Epistle, and the last eight sections (13-20) of the so-called Second Epistle, had never been published before. The date of the manuscript is 1056 A.D. As desciibed by the finder, " it is an octavo volume, written on 2054143 INTRODUCTION. parchment, in cursive characters, and consists of 120 leaves." First conies Chrysostom's Synop- sis of the Books of the Old and New Testa- ment ; then the Epistle of Barnabas ; then the two Epistles of Clement ; then the Teaching of the Twelve Apostles ; then the Epistle of Mary of Cassobelae to Ignatius ; followed by twelve Epistles of Ignatius (the current seven, besides one to the Virgin Mary, and four others). The "Teaching of the Twelve Apostles," Ai&x,>7 r&v SuSexa 3 Anoaro^v, occupies leaves 76-80 of the manuscript. It now seems strange to us that the document thus announced at- tracted so little attention. This same Bryen- nios, now Metropolitan of Nicomedia, in Asia Minor, has again surprised the literary world by publishing, with an abundance of learned illus- tration, this long-lost document. It is printed in Constantinople, and the date of publication is 1883. The genuineness of the document can hardly be doubted. It is cited by Clement of Alexandria in -his First Stroma; by Eusebius, INTRODUCTION. who speaks of it (Hist. iii. 25) as . a. 'OBol Bvo elcri, fj,ta r^9 &fj<> KOI /u'a rov Savd- TOV, Biacf)opd Be TroXX?) fiera^v rwv Bvo 6Bwv. 5 'H fiev ovv 6809 T?;9 ^w^9 ecrrtv avrrj rrpwrov, dyaTnjcreis rov &ebv rov Troitjcravrd ere ' Bevre- pov, rov rr\i]criov crov 0)9 creavrov rrdvra Be ocra eav &e\.r)crr)<3 firj paTTicrfUt et9 rrjv Be^iav arpe-^rov aurco Kal rrjv a\\r)v, Kal ea-rj eav dyyapeva-y ere rts piXiov ev, vTraye /ier' av- 20 TOV &vo ' eav aprj rt? TO ifidnov al- TOVVTI ere St'Sou Kal fir) aTra/ret iraai yap 3e\ei StSotr^at o iraTrjp eK TWV ibtajv 25 Ma/fapt09 6 SiSovs Kara TIJV evTO\r]V yap e&Tiv oval TW \afjLfBdvoini' el /j,ev yap 'Xpeiav c^av \afj,/3dvei rt9, a^a3o9 Icrrat o Be M XP ^ av %'X. WV Boixrei SiKyv, IvaTi eXa^Se Kal els TI, ev o'vvo'xfj oe yevofievos e%eTao~Qij(rTai 30 u>v eTrpa^e, Kal OVK ej;e\evcrTai, ov d7ro&a> TOV eo-^aTov KoSpdvrijv. 'A\\d Kal irepl TOVTOV STJ eiprjTai 'ISpcaa-aTO) r, eXefj/jLoav- civ 1/9 TIVI 35 Ke0. yS*. Aevrepa Be evTo\rj r^9 BiBa^ij^ Ov (povevo-eis, , ov TEACHING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES. love them that love you ? Do not the nations also the same ? But love ye them that hate you and ye shall have no enemy. Abstain from the fleshly and worldly lusts. If any one give thee a blow on the right cheek, turn to him the other also, and thou shalt be perfect ; if any one compel thee to go one mile, go with him t\vo ; if any one take thy cloak, give him thy tunic also ; if any one take from thee what is thine, ask it not back; for indeed thou canst not. To every one that asketh thee give, and ask not back; for to all the Father desires to give of his own gracious gifts. Blessed is he that giveth according to the commandment ; for he is guiltless ; wo to him that taketh ; for if, indeed, one taketh who hath need, he shall be guiltless ; but he who hath no need shall give account, why he took, and for what purpose, and coming under arrest shall be ex- amined concerning what he did, and shall not go out thence until he pay the last farthing. But it hath been also said concerning this matter : Let thine alms sweat in thy hands, until thou knowest to whom thou shouldst give. CHAP. II. Now the second commandment of the teaching is : Thou shalt not kill, thou shalt not commit adultery, thou shalt not corrupt boys, thou shalt not AIAAXH TON AQAEKA AHO2TOAQN. ov /cXei/ret9, ov fiayevcret,^, ov apfjuitcev(rei<;, ov reKVOv ev \7^et9, rrepl Se wv rrpocr- evgrj, ou9 Be aryarrrjcreis vrrep rr]v ^v^fjv aov. 50 Keep. y. TGKVOV /xou, favye drco Travrb? irovypov /cat OTTO 77CMT09 0/MMOV avrov ' Mr) yivov 6^71X09 * oSijyei yap 17 0/37^ 77^09 TOJ^ 6vov firjSe %r)\(0- rrjs /JLTjBe ept,o~riKb<$ //.i^Se ^u//.t/co9 e: yap rov- Ttov drcdvrav fybvou yevvwvrai. TCKVOV /^of, (JLVJ 55 yivov 7riQv[j,r)rrj<$ oBrjyei yap rj 7riQv/j,ia 77/309 rrjv iropveiav /i^Se alo"%pd\6yoov, fir) yivov olcovocrKOTros ' 7ret,Br) oBijyet et9 rrjv eloo)\o\arpeiav ' /i^Se eTra- 60 04809 p?8 6 TEACHING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES. commit fornication, thou shalt not steal, tliou shalt not practise magic, thou shalt not use sorcery, thou shalt not slay a child by abortion, nor what is begotten shalt thou destroy. Thou shalt not lust after the things of thy neighbor, thou shalt not forswear thyself, thou shalt not bear false witness, thou shalt not re- vile, thou shalt not bear malice. Thou shalt not be doubled-minded nor doubled-tongued ; for a snare of death is the double tongue. Thy speech shall not be false, nor empty, but filled with doing. Thou shalt not be covetous, nor rapacious, nor a hypocrite, nor malicious, nor arrogant. Thou shalt not take evil counsel against thy neighbor. Thou shalt hate no man, but some thou shalt reprove, and for some thou shalt pray, and some thou shalt love above thy life. CHAP. III. My child, flee from every evil thing, and from everything like it. Be not inclined to anger, for anger leadeth to murder ; nor jealous, nor contentious, nor passionate ; for of all these murders are begotten. My child, become not lustful ; for lust leadeth to for- nication ; nor foul-mouthed, nor lofty-eyed ; for of all these things adulteries are begotten. My child, become not an omen-watcher ; since it leadeth into idolatry ; nor an enchanter, nor an astrologer, nor a purifier, nor 7 AIAAXH TON AQAEKA AHO2TOAQN. &e\e avrd J3\e7retv K yap rovrwv d-rrdv- Ttav eiBa)7(.o\aTpeia yevvdrai. TCKVOV /AOV, p,i] yivov 'fyevcrTris CTreiBrj oBrjyei TO ijrevo'/jia 619 65 e/c yap TOVTWV airdvrwv K\O7ral yevvwvrai. Tere- vov fiov, fj,rj yivov 7677^0*09 * eVetS^ 6877764 et9 rr)v IK yap rovrcav airdvrwv ^Kaa-^fJiiai, yevvwvrai. "Icr^t Be Trpavs, eirel ol Trpaei? /c\,r)povo/j,ij Sia iravrbs, ovf ij/covcras. OVK v- treavrov ot>8e Sc69 dya&a Trpoa- j, eta>9 ori drep 0eov ov&ev yiverai. Ke(j>. B'. Te/cvov fiov, rov \a\ovvr6s croi TOV \6yov rov Qeov /J,vr)(r$ij(rr) VVKTOS Kal rjfiepas, TLprfcreis Be 80 avrbv a>9 Kvpiov o&ev yap r) Kvptor-rjf \a\eiTai, exel Kvpios ea-riv. 'EK&Tijcreis Be KO$ rjfiepav TO, irpotrtoTTa TWV dyiojv, '(va eTravaTravrj rot9 \6yoi<> avTcov. Ov Tro&ij cr^Lcrfia, elpijvev- &) crou KOL OVK epet? l'8ta elvai, el yap ev TO> aSavdrw icoivavoi eVre, 77oo-eij 95 fia\\ov ev Tot5 ^i^TOi9 ; OVK apet? rrjv X ^P a OT/Dot9 @eoy ou 70/3 ep^erai Kara TrpoawTrov Ka\eo-at, a\V e^>' 01/9 TO 'T/z6t9 Se 01 SovXoi V7rorayj)o-ea-&e rot5 v/j>wv a>9 Tj/77a> 0eoO eV alcr^vvr} /cat 105 Mio-rfcre^ irda-av vTroKpicrw /cat 77ay o ^77 a/aea-- roi' TOO Kvply. Ov HT) eyKarahiTrys evro\as Kvpiov, aip&v. 'Ev ra Trapa7rr(i)fj,ard cov, /cat ou 7rpoo-e\evo-r) eVt 10 TEACHING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES. slialt judge justly, thou shalt not respect persons in con- victing for transgressions. Thou shalt not hesitate whether it shall be or not. Become not one who for tak- ing stretches out the hands, but for giving draws them in ; if thou hast anything, by thy hands thou shalt give a ransom for thy sins. Thou shalt not hesitate to give, nor when giving shalt thou murmur, for thou shalt know who is the good dispenser of the recompense. Thou shalt not turn away the needy, but shalt share all things with thy brother, and shalt not say they are thine own ; for if ye are partners in that which is imperishable, how much more in the perishable things ? Thou slialt not take off thy hand from thy son and from thy daughter, but from youth thou shalt teach them the fear of God. Thou shalt not lay commands in thy bitterness upon thy slave or handmaid, who hope in the same God, lest they perchance shall not fear the God who is over you both ; for he cometh not to call men according to the ap- pearance, but to those whom the Spirit hath made ready. And ye, slaves, ye shall be subject to your lords, as to God's image, in modesty and fear. Thou shalt hate every hypocrisy, and whatever is not pleasing to the Lord. Thou shalt by no means forsake the Lord's commandments, but shalt guard what thou hast received, neither adding to it nor taking from it. In the church AIAAXH TON AQAEKA AOOSTOAQN. 110 Trpoaevxyv (TOV eV avla, Katcia, av&dSeia, 7r\eovej;ia, alcr')(pd\o- yia, fyj\oTV7ria, SpavvTrjs, /-|ro9, aXa^oveia- Siw/crat dyaSwv, fJUGOvvTe? d\ijQetav, dycnrayV' 120 re9 i/rei)8o9, ov ryivaxTKovres p.i ovbe Kpitrei dt- Kcua, asypvirvovvTes OVK els TO dyaBov, a\A,' 649 TO 7TOVT)p6v WV fJiaKpdv 7T paVTr)<$ KOl V7TO- fjiovT], fjidraia dryaTrwvres, SicoKovres avrcnro- 125 Sofia, OVK e\eovvTe$ TTTW^OV, ov TTOVOVVTCS eVl KarcnrovovfJievq), ov yivcacrtcovTes rbv Troirjaavra aurou9, (j)ovei$ Te/cvcov, r jr\dafj.a'ro^ &eov, a7roaTpe^>6fj,evoi TOV evSeofievov, TOV 3\i/3d/j,vov, irKovffiwv TrapafcXyToi, 130 T0)v avo/jLOi Kpirai, diro TOVTCOV Ke(f). . "Opa fjij T(9 o"e TrXavrfa"}) diro TavTijs r)9 o8oO r^9 8t8a^7}9. eVet Trape/cro? &eov ere 12 TEACHING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES. thou shalt confess thy transgressions, and shalt not come forward for thy prayer with an evil conscience. This is the way of life. CHAP. Y. Now the way of death is this : first of all it is evil, and full of curse ; murders, adulteries, lusts, fornications, thefts, idolatries, magic arts, sorceries, rob- beries, false testimonies, hypocrisies, duplicity, craft, arrogance, vice, presumptuousness, greed, foul speech, jealousy, over-boldness, loftiness, pretence ; persecutors of the good, hating truth, loving falsehood, knowing not the reward of righteousness, not cleaving to that which is good nor to righteous judgment, on the watch not for good but for evil ; far from whom are meekness and patience, loving vanities, pursuing revenge, not pitying a poor man, not laboring for the distressed, not knowing him that made them, murderers of children, destroyers of the image of God, turning away the needy, oppressing the afflicted, advocates of the rich, lawless judges of the poor, universal sinners : may ye be delivered, children, from all these. CHAP. VI. See thr.t no one lead thee astray from this way of the teaching, because apart from God does AIAAXH TON AQAEKA AIIO2TOAQN. El fj,ev yap Buvao~ai ySacrratrat o\ov rbv vybv 135 TOV Kvpiov, re\eio9 eo~y el S' ov Bvvao~ai, o Bvvrj TOVTO iroiei. Ilepl Be 7-7)9 /3/9a>o-ea>9, o Svvaaai cnro Se TOV el&aiko&vTOV \iav \arpeta yap earl Qewv Ke9 ot vTTOKpiTai, aXA,' rj fiaaikeia a~ov, ^T^TW TO ^eXvj/jid (7ov to? ev ovpava) /cal eVt 160 rbv dprov rj^wv rbv 7riora-iov 809 r)p.lv pov Kal a0e? rjfuv rrjv 6(f)i\rjV rj/Auv &>? KOI rot? o^etXeTat? rj/j.(av, Kal pr) et? Treipaa-^ov, aXX^ pvaai ^a? ttTTO rov Trovrjpov OTI (rov . ^'. He-pi Se TrpwTOV jrepl rov iroTypiov ' Ev^apiarovnev croi, IlaTep rjfiwv, VTrep rrjs ayias a/A7reXou ^da/StS 170 TOU 7rat8o9 crou, 175 eyixapicras rjfj.iv Sta 'Iijcrov TOV 7ratfio9 o~oi . i. Mera 8e TO efj,7r\r) crot, Ildrep ayte, VTrep rov ayiov Ofd^uaTO? o-of, ou KaTeaKJ)vwaas ev Tat? real v-rrep TT)? yvfaaeca^ KOI Tria- 17? eyvwptaas r)iMV &ia 190 'Iij&ov TOV TratoV? trou via> AaftiB. Ei ris ayios CGTIV, e/ - ei TI avrov a>? Kvpiov. Ilepl Se rtov arroa- 215 ToXo>y /ca) irpofyrirwv Kara rb S6y/J.a rov evay- yeXtou, ovrca Troirjcrare. Ua? Be arrocrro\os GKK 7T/305 v/ua? Sejfinjra) a>9 Kvpios ' ov Be rjfjtepav p.iav ' eav Be y ^pet'a, /cal rrjv 220 eo-riv. 'Egepftopevos Be o aTroo-ToXo? ^T/Sey Xa/i- ftaverw el/^rj aprov ea)9 ou av\io'^fj eav 6e ap- yvptov alrf), tyev8oTrpoiJTr)<;. Kal ?ra? Trpo^T?;? bpitpv rpd- 230 iretav ev Trvevpan, ov dyerai cnf avrrjs, eloe /u.ijye TJrevBoTrpo^iJTrjs eo~ri' iras Be TrpoffrrjTTjs BiBdffKwv rrjv a\rf$eiav, el a SiSda-tcet ov Trotec, TfrevSoTrpoiJTr)<; ecrrt. Ua? Be TrpcxpiJTrjs SeSoKi- Haa-/j.evo<;, a\^ 41/69, iroiuv et? fivaTijpiov xooyu- 235 KOV eKK\7). iff. ITa? Be 6 epx6/j,evo<; ev 6vo/j.art Kvpiov $%- ), evretra Se 8o/ctyLta. ij' 1 JTa? Be Trpo^rr}^ aX^tpo?, SeXwv 7rpo9 tyia9, at09 ecru r?}? rpo(f)f)<> avrov. 'flcrav- 255 T&>9 Si8acr/caXo9 aXrjQivds ecrnv afyos Kal av- T09, co97rep 6 e/?7aT?79, r^9 rpoffis avrov. Ha- a-av ovv cnrap-^v yewrjficcTwv \i)vov Kal a\wvo$, ftowv re /cal Trpo/Bdrtav \a(3(av Swaeis rot9 i/ 809 Kara TT)V eino\rjv. 'flvavrws Kepdfuov ol'vov 17 e\aiov dvoigas, TTJV atrap-^v \aftwv 809 rot9 Trpofaj dpyvpiov Se Kal If^aricrfJiov KOI 7ra^T09 265 Xa/3a)i; T^I/ dirap^v W9 at/ crot Sof?;, 809 T^y VTO\r)V. tS'. Kara KVpiaxrjv Be Kvptov (ruva'x&evTes K\d- aprov Kal ey^aptcrr^cra rd TrapaTrroiifjbara u/ncoy, O7r&)9 270 ?5 QvGia vfiwv 37. JT9 Se fytov TTJV dp(f)i/3o\iav fierd rov eraipov avrov p,r) o"vve\6erco vfj.iv, ea)9 ov Bia\\ay&aiv, JW /x^ KOivuQf) f) Ovaia vfiatv avrrj yap e' 280 vfuv yap \eirovpy overt, KOI avrol rr)v \eirovpyi- av TWP Trpo(f>T)TQ)v Kal SiSaafcaXwv. Mr) ovv VTreplBrjre avrovs avrol yap elcriv ol vot vficov fJLera rwv irpo^yrjrwv Kal 'E\9 e^ere ev TW evayye- 290 X/^i) TOV Kvptov r^ vtrep ) d\\a yiveade eroifjioi ov yap OiBare rrjv &pav, ev y 6 Kvpios rjuwv ep^erai. 295 IIvKvws Be a-vva^drja-ecBe fyTOvvre? ra avrjKov- ra rat9 xjru^afc vuwv ov yap ftx^eX^crei u/ta9 6 7Ttt9 ^301/09 T?79 7Tt / (TTe(9 VfjLWV, IttV /JiT) V T&5 ecr^arm Kaipfi T\eia)0rJT. 'Ev yap rat9 ec 300 /eat ot fyOopels Kal arpa^rjaovraL ra Trpo/Sara 26 TEACHING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES. CHAP. XY. Now appoint for yourselves bishops and deacons worthy of the Lord, men meek and not ava- ricious, and upright and proved ; for they, too, render you the service of the prophets and teachers. Despise them not, therefore; for they are the ones who are honored of you, together with the prophets and teachers. And reprove one another, not in anger, but in peace, as ye have it in the gospel ; and to every one who erreth against another, let no one speak, nor let him hear any- thing from you, until he repent. But your prayers and your alms and all your deeds so do ye, as ye have it in the gospel of our Lord. CHAP. XVI. Watch for your life's sake ; let your lamps not go out, and your loins not be relaxed, but be ready ; for ye know not the hour in which our Lord com- eth. But ye shall come together often, and seek the things which befit your souls ; for the whole time of your faith thus far will not profit you, if ye do not be- come perfect in the last time. For in the last days the false prophets and the corruptors shall be multiplied, and the sheep shall be turned into wolves, and love AIAAXH TON AGAEKA AII02TOAQN. ei? \VKOVS Kal rj dyaTnj (TTpa^)ij(TTai et? av^avovcrijs avija'Tai ra GrjfjLeia T?}? dX^^e^a?' O"r]fjLiov e/CTrerao-ew? ev ovpavaj, elra 0a)i^5 ? eppeOij "Hget, 6 Kvpio? Kal Trai/re? ot' aytot /xer' avrov. Tore 6 /cotr/io? ro^ Kvpiov ep^o^evov TOV ovpavov. TEACHING OF THE TWELVE APOSTLES. shall be turned into hate; for when lawlessness in- creaseth they shall hate one another, and shall persecute and shall deliver up, and then shall appear the world- deceiver as the Son of God, and shall do signs and won- ders, and the earth shall be given into his hands, and he shall commit iniquities which have never yet been done since the beginning. Then all created men shall come into the fire of trial, and many shall be made to stumble and shall perish. But they that endure in their faith shall be saved from this curse. And then shall appear the signs of the truth ; first the sign of an opening in heaven, then the sign of the trumpet's sound, and thirdly, the resurrection of the dead ; yet not of all, but as it hath been said : The Lord will come and all the saints with him. Then shall the world see the Lord coming upon the clouds of heaven. USE OF THE HOLY SCRIPTURES IN THE "TEACHING." 1 OLD TESTAMENT. U:NK. I LINE. *Deut. 5:17-19 35 f. *Sirach 4 : 31 86 f. Tobit 4 : 15. . . 7 f . Zech. 14 : 5 ... . . 315 f. *Sirach2:4 *Sirach 4:5.. 75 f. 91 f. Mai. 1:11,14 273 f. NEW TESTAMENT. "Matt. 5:5... . 69 f. *Matt. 5:22.., 284 f. *Matt. 5:26 30 f. *Matt. 5 : 39-48 16 f. Matt. 6 : 5-13 155 f. *Matt. 6 and 7 289 Matt. 7:6 183 f. *Matt. 7 : 15-23 215 f. *Matt. 10:5-12 215 f. *Matt. 10 : 10 256 *Matt. 12:31 224f. *Matt. 18: 15-17 284 *Matt. 18:21-35 284 Matt. 21:9 205 Matt. 22:27-39... 5f. *Matt. 24:3-4 298 f. *Matt. 24:24-31 313 f. *Matt. 24:31 200f. *Matt. 24 : 42, 44 291 f. Matt 28: 19 140 f. "Luke 6 : 27-35 10 "Luke 9:1-6 215 f. "Luke 10: 4-21 215 f. Luke 11: 2-4 1551 "Luke 11 and 12 289 f. "Luke 12 : 35 291 f. *Acts 4 : 32 92 f. *Eph. 6:5,9 103 f. *1 Thess. 5 :22 50 f. *1 Pet. 2:11... . 15 f. 1 This table is that of Bryennios, who adds: "By this sign [*] are distinguished the passages which are not verbally cited in the ' Teaching,' and those to which the ' Teaching ' simply refers, with the words, ' As the Lord commanded in the gospel.' " EDS. NOTES. TITI/R, Another title is At8oj^ Kvplov 8ia rS>v 8a>8fKa 'AiroordXaw, " Teaching of the Lord through the Twelve Apostles." Atha- nasius also calls it SiSa^i?. But Eusebius (Hist. iii. 25) uses the plural, 8i8axai And Clement of Alexandria cites it as ypa(f>fj. CHAP. I. P. 2, 1. 8." do not to another "] The Golden Eule occurs both here and in the Apostolic Constitutions (vii. 2), in a nega- tive form, as in the teachings of Confucius. P. 2, 1. 11. " fast for them that persecute you "] The em- phasis put upon fasting, here and elsewhere in this document, is no sign of Montanism, since fasting was much emphasized in the early Church, and Montanism itself was, in this respect, only an exaggeration of common usage. P. 4, 1. 15. "ye shall have no enemy "] Suggested, appar- ently, by 1 Pet. iii. 13, " And who is he that will harm you, if ye be zealous of that which is good ? " P. 4, 1. 22." for indeed thou canst not "] Because Chris- tians were forbidden to "go to law before the unrighteous," 1 Cor. viL NOTES. P. 4, 1. 32. "Let thine alms sweat in thy hands, until thou knowest to whom thou shouldst give "] A very graphic injunc- tion of carefulness in giving. CHAP. IL P. 4, 1. 36. "thou shalt not corrupt boys"] The ircufcpao-Tia of Classic writers, referred to by Paul in Rom. i. 27. P. 6, 1. 38. "by abortion"] Another heathen abomination. P. 6, 1. 42, 43. SfyAoxrcr/a] This noun does not occur in Classic Greek, nor in the New Testament, but is found, to- gether with the entire sentence in which it here stands, in the Epistle of Barnabas, Chap. xix. There are many other corre- spondences between that epistle and the present document. P. 6, 1. 44. "filled with doing"] i.e., works, deeds, as in Matt. xvi. 27. CHAP. m. P. 6, 1. 60. "nor a purifier"] Referring to some kind of su- perstitious lustration, perhaps by fire, as in Lev. xviii. 21 ; Deut. xviii. 10. CHAP. IV. P. 10, 1. 87. "for taking stretches out the hands, but for giving draws them in "] Graphic description of taking and giving. P. 10, 1. 88. "by thy hands thou shalt give a ransom for thy sins "] Beneficence is better than sacrifice. See Prov. xvi. 6, *' By mercy and truth iniquity is purged." P. 10, 1. 98." thy slave "] As in the New Testament, so here, the relation of master and slave is not denounced, but regulated. 33 X NOTES. CHAP. V. This catalogue of evil things pertaining to the "way of death," reflects only too faithfully the dreadful corruption of the ancient civilization. CHAP. VI. P. 14, 1. 136. "And concerning food, what thou art able, bear "] Nothing is unclean of itself, as Paul says in Bom. xiv. 14. And again in 1 Tim. iv. 4, "For every creature of God is good, and nothing is to be rejected, if it be received with thanksgiving." CHAP. vn. P. 14, 1. 139. "Now, concerning baptism ... in running water"] v8an favri, literally "in living water," water in mo- tion, either as in a fountain, or as in a stream. A picture in the Catacomb of St. Callixtus, dating from about the year 200 A.D., represents a youth standing ankle-deep in water, and receiving baptism by the pouring of water upon his head. [See Northcote and Brownlow's "Koma Sotteranea," Part II., Plate XV.] The passage before us apparently recommends just this mode of per- forming the rite. If this should be impracticable, then fresh cold water might be similarly used [in a font]. If cold water could not be had, warm water would answer. If neither cold nor warm water in sufficient quantity (ankle-deep) could be had, then pouring only (the feet resting on the floor or ground) would suffice. This last is now the Syrian mode of baptism, and probably always has been. This fact, ascertained by the Crusaders (in the third Crusade, 1189-92), and made known through them in Europe, would help to account for Aquinas's definition of baptism, so different from that of Peter Lombard NOTES. about a century before. Lombard's definition requires immer- sion ; Aquinas's definition permits either immersion, pouring, or sprinkling. The Seventh Book of the Apostolic Constitu- tions, at this point (Section xxii.), says nothing about the mode, but prescribes anointing with oil, both before and after bap- tism. Fasting is enjoined in both documents. CHAP. VHI. P. 14, 1. 154. Trapao-icevTjv] Cf. John xix. 14. Wednesday and Friday are named as days of fasting, instead of Monday and Thursday, as observed by "the hypocrites." The Lord's Prayer ends with the Doxology, as in Matthew, in- stead of its being omitted, as in Luke. CHAPS. IX., X. These two chapters contain a brief eucharistic liturgy. CHAP. XI. Apostles and Prophets are described as mere evangelists, or itinerant preachers, who were not expected to remain in one place more than a single day. P. 20, 1. 218. fl fjiTj has been inserted in the translation before fiptpav. So Harnack, Theol. Lit. Zelt., Feb. 9, 1884. Cf. p. 22, 1. 246. CHAP. XII. P. 22, 1. 244." Ye shall have understanding right and left "] That is, a complete understanding. See 2 Cor. vi. 7. NOTES. CHAP. XHI. Prophets and teachers are here spoken of as resident minis- ters, entitled to maintenance. They were to have the first- fruits of everytliing. SITU/, in Classic Greek, is the plural of uiriov, meaning "food" in general. Here, as in the Byzantine Greek, it is a singular noun, and means "batch," or "baking of bread." CHAP. XIV. The Lord's Day is the day for worship and for the Eucharist. No mention is made of the seventh day of the week. CHAP. XV. P. 26, 1.277. "Now appoint for yourselves," x ft P TOV *l< TaTf ovv favrols] Xfiporoveo) occurs only twice in the New Testament (Acts xiv. 23 ; 2 Cor. viii. 19), and, in both places, means sim- ply to "appoint." Josephus uses the word in the same sense in Ant. xiii. 2, 2, where Alexander Balas, the pretended son of Antiochus Epiphanes, " appoints " Jonathan High Priest. The same meaning appears in Ant. vii. 9, 3 ; vii. 11, 1. In Ant. vi. 5, 4, however, the noun ^ftporovia is used of the coronation of Saul. In Josephus, accordingly, the prevailing sense of x ft P* roi/e'co is to "appoint." This is the meaning of the word also in the Epistles of Ignatius (about 115 A.D.). See Philadelphians, Chap. 10 ; Smyrnseans, Chap. 11 ; Poly carp, Chap. 7. But in the " Apostolic Canons," I. and H., and in the "Apos- tolic Constitutions," viii. 4, 5, x ft P nrov * (0 means to " ordain." This represents the usage of the third century, as the New Tes- tament, Josephus, and Ignatius represent the usage of the first and second centuries. NOTES. Now, it is noteworthy, that in the "Apostolic Constitutions," vii. 31 (the section corresponding to the passage before us), the word employed is not x fl P OTOV * u >> which then meant " ordain," but rrpoxeipi'fo/ixai, a new usage having obtained. In this fif- teenth chapter of the "Teaching," ^ttporovew is employed, evi- dently, in its original sense of "appoint." This indicates the high antiquity of the document, antedating by decades, if not by a whole century, the "Apostolic Canons" and the "Apos- tolic Constitutions." As for the officers to be "appointed," only Bishops and Dea- cons are mentioned. By Bishops must, of course, be meant Presbyters, or Elders. There is no sign of a Bishop as distin- guished from a Presbyter ; nor of a Ruling Elder as distin- guished from a Teaching Elder ; and, apparently, there was in each congregation a plurality both of Bishops (or Elders) and Deacons. CHAP. XVI. The document concludes with a vision of the Lord coming upon the clouds of heaven, and all the saints with him. The resurrection is of the dead, vexpuv, though "not of all the dead." Not a word is said of any second resurrection. If there is to be a second resurrection, it is only implied. Of course, no interval is indicated. Premillennarianism, accordingly, is not directly, perhaps not even indirectly, taught. Following the lead of the New Testament, as in Matt. xxiv. 31, and in 1 Thess. iv. 13-18, our document may, after all, only be em- phasizing the resurrection of the righteous. EEEOES IN THE CODEX COEEECTED BY BEYENNIOS. CODEX. BBYENNIOS. LINE. 32. 8^ ..................................... Si 32. ISpandru 51. op7Xoy 59. elSwA.oAarpfaj' ........................... fl5w\o\arpfia,v- 62. eiSaiAoAarpfa ............................ fi$w\o\a.Tpfla. 91. r, ..................................... 6. 103. Sov\oi[SicJ See Bryenn., p. 22, N. 19]..5o5Ao. 104. ^/twi/ .................................. fyiwi/. 114, 115. flS