THE JAMES D. PHELAN CELTIC COLLECTION TAKING MY CLUE "WITH ME, I DIVED" (p. 198). LOST ON DUHQQBBIO OK TWIXT EARTH AND OOEAN S T A N D I S II O ' G K A D Y If AUTHOR OF " FINN AND HIS COMPANIONS," " THE BOG OF STARS, "THE STORY OF IRELAND," ETC. CASSELL AND COMPANY LIMITED LONDON PARIS $ MELBOURNE 1894 All Rights Reserved PHEtAN m PBEFACE. I HAD at first intended to tell this story my- self. With that intention I wrote to each of the four brothers who separately or together figured in the singular events hereafter de- scribed, requesting of them more exact informa- tion than I already possessed. They replied not only at such length, but with such un- expectedly vivid realism, that their various narratives, in spite of some literary shortcomings, seemed to me to need only a little editorial re- vision to fit them for publication. I perceived that I would more prudently play the part of editor than of original author. Accordingly, I decided to let the brothers Freeman tell their own story. When their narratives over- lapped I simply used the scissors. When too minute or too wandering I struck- my pen through the redundancies, or what appeared to me to be such, endeavouring to secure a little more brevity and conciseness. Some 810306 iv PREFACE. slight discrepancies, chiefly in the matter of dates, I was enabled to correct from an old volume of the Saunders Newsletter. It was there that I first became acquainted with the details of the singular disappearance of John Freeman, though long before the story was familiar to me in its more general features. By the kindness of the Authorities of Dublin Castle I was permitted to inspect and take copies of the official reports sent in by the Police Sub-Inspector of the district. Along with these reports I found tied up in the same bundle a number of letters of a more private character written by the same Police Officer and addressed to the same superior to whom were forwarded the official reports. These two persons viz., the local Sub-Inspector of Constabulary, who wrote the reports and letters, and the permanent official in the Castle to whom they were ad- dressed seem to have been intimate friends. On the top of the bundle I found a single sheet with the following endorsement : "It has occurred to me that sooner or later PREFACE. v some person will undertake to write out and publish in all its details the whole story of the mysterious and unaccountable disappearance of John Freeman, a story which illustrates again for the thousandth time the old adage that truth is stranger than fiction. I have, there- fore, decided to deposit here, along with the official reports forwarded to me by Mr. Samuel Watkins, the private letters which, simultane- ously with the official, or from time to time, he may have written to me dealing with the catastrophe. In these private letters the in- quirer, whoever he may be, and whenever he comes along this way making his searches, will meet with a large variety of local and personal details very suitable for his purpose, but for obvious reasons unfit to form part of Mr. Watkins' official reports. " HENRY VIGORS." Mr. Watkins, of whose letters I have made a copious use, is dead ; so is Mr. Vigors. These letters are very interesting not only as exhibit- ing the attitude of an intelligent Constabulary vi PREFACE. officer towards the main incident and its develop- ments, but also on account of the light which they throw upon the Freeman family. Then the letters of a person, written at the time of the occurrence of the tragedy, or whatever it may be called, will, I think, help the reader to picture the events and characters with more vividness. The letters of Mr. Watkins I have treated in the same manner as the narratives of the brothers. In fact, I have done little more than cross the t's and pip the i's of the various persons whom I allow here to relate the history of the singular disappearance and singular adventures of John Freeman. I beg publicly to thank the brothers not only for responding so promptly to my appeal, but for their permission to publish, with such alterations as I might see fit to make, what they never intended should come before the public eye in the form in which it left their pens. I may add that the warm mutual affection of the brothers, the primitive character of the neighbourhood, and the simplicity of the home PREFACE. vii life of the Freeman family, which are pleasantly and naturally suggested rather than elaborately described in their various communications, are such as I . myself, though a seasoned litterateur, felt convinced that I could not re- produce with anything like the freshness and vividness of their unlaboured composition. Of the four brothers who were concerned in the events described, Samuel, the third, hereinafter spoken of invariably as Sam, is the only one whose narrative I have not used, but for no other reason than that it is quite overlapped by those of the rest. John Freeman, the hero of the story, is the lad who was lost ; Edward Freeman is the discoverer of the lost one. The part played by Charles, the youngest, and also some singular experiences of the hero, are very curious, and suggest interesting questions in psychology. I am happy to state that all four, though now scattered far and wide over the earth's surface, are doing well, and all, except the youngest, are married men and fathers of families. EDITOR. CONTENTS. CHAPTER PAGE I. CHARLES FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE. MY BROTHER GOES TO Du-CoRRia . . 1 IT. AND DOES NOT RETURN . . . .10 III. SAMUEL W ATKINS ON THE DISAPPEARANCE. OFFICIAL REPORT . W. . .19 IV. CHARLEY FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (con- tinued). His VISION . . . .24 V. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE. THE AR- REST OF MELODY . , . . . 3'2 VI. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (con- tinued). JACK'S CARRIER PIGEON. . 43 VII. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (con- tinued). MYSTERIOUS DISAPPEARANCE OF EDWARD FREEMAN . . . .54 VIII. CROHOOR-BEG. SAMUEL WATKINS TO HENRY VIGORS ...... 54 IX. MR. WATKINS' NARRATIVE (continued). THE PIAST . ', " 63 X. MR. WATKINS' NARRATIVE (continued). MR. WATKINS RECEIVES A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS . . . .76 XI. MR. WATKINS' NARRATIVE (continued). RECEIVES A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER 87 XII. SURPRISING EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR 98 x CONTENTS. CHAP 1 ER PAGE XIII. MR. W ATKINS' NARRATIVE (concluded). FOUND! 116 XIV. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued). - EDWARD FREEMAN LOSES HIMSELF, BUT FINDS HIS BROTHER . . .119 XV. JOHN FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued). How JOHN FREEMAN CAME TO CURRY'S WINDOW' , m . . * . .125 XVI. TRAPPED . . . . . . .132 XVII. NOT TO GET OUT 139 XVIII. FIRE 146 XIX. NOT A DOG, SPITE ITS BARKING . . .154 XX. FRIENDS MULTIPLY 159 XXI. FURTHER EXPLORATIONS . . . .166 XXII. ANOTHER ATTEMPTED ESCALADE. . .171 XXIII. A PSYCHOLOGICAL EXPERIMENT . . .177 XXIV ATTEMPTED ESCAPE vid THE SEAL'S TUNNEL 183 . XXV. A DESPERATE ATTEMPT UPON THE TUNNEL . 195 XXVI. AT CURRY'S WINDOW. / . ;. ' . .211 XXVII. THE GHOST . .< . . ' . .217 XXVIII. THE GHOST TAKES AN UNEXPECTED SHAPE . 226 XXIX. ALL ABOUT MUTTON . . . . . . .241 XXX. MY LAST ATTEMPT UPON THE SEALS' TUNNEL 248 XXXI. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (con- tinued). LIFE OF THE Two BROTHERS IN THE CAVERN ..... 257 XXXII. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued). HOME AGAIN 267 XXXIII. JOHN FREEMAN CONCLUDES THE STORY. A GOOD TREASURE-TROVE AND A MORAL . 277 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. "TAKING MY CLUE WITH ME, I ... DIVED . . /' Frontispiece. PLAN OF THE CAVERX p. xii. " SOON I WAS IN DENSE DARKNESS " . . To face p. 46 " IT SENT OUT A GREAT BLAZE" ,, 106 " IT GAVE WAY BEFORE MY DESCENDING WEIGHT" 132 " I SAW FOUR ROUND EYES APPARENTLY WATCHING ME " To face p. 160 "I WAS OFTEN SURROUNDED BY THE WHOLE NINE" To face p. 182 " I FOUND A FAT SHEEP LYING MOTIONLESS ON THE GROUND" . . . . 4 . To face p. 241 " WE STOOD IN CURRY'S WINDOW " 274 PitofBoiling Water. Ancient Tomb? GREAT CENTRAL CAVERN & ^Seals' 'Pool. XSccond Fire. First Blow flo * Pocket of ft K^ Woo t Fire. A *+ Curry's PL AX OF THE CAYEEN. LOST ON CHAPTER I. CHARLES FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE. MY BROTHER GOES TO DU-CORRIG. IN the month of July, 1854, my eldest brother, John Freeman, suddenly and most unaccount- ably was taken from us. One fine afternoon, being in good health and spirits, he went fishing and never returned. At lunch he was very pleasant and even jocose, making us youngsters laugh so immoderately that my father was at last obliged to interfere, and one of my brothers was sent out of the room in disgrace. All the events of that terrible day are im- printed on my mind with the clearness of visuality. I can still see the funny faces with which, when my father was not looking, he threw us into uncontrollable laughing fits. He 2 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. had but just returned from Trinity College for the summer, vacation, and was full of all sorts of joyous plans : arvd projects for spending a good me;^tr,li(Mm^- Tp^r fellow ! he little knew what this vacation had in store for him. For a boy like my brother, and, indeed, for all of us, few rural neighbourhoods could have been more delightful than ours. There were mountain streams abounding with trout, streams which needed only a night's rain, sometimes merely a heavy shower, to supply good fishing. When the streams were not flooded he often brought home a good basket of brown trout and white, taken in the pools and holes with a mere shrimping-net which he made himself. It was something like a large and long-handled landing-net. There were good trout lakes, too, in the mountains. Of sea-fishing, both from boats and from the rock, he was very fond ; he was at the latter sport, viz., fishing for conor* from * A dull-yellow fish, very scaly, not welcome to epicures, and affording poor sport. ED. MY BROTHER GOES TO DU-CORRIG. 3 a rock, when he so mysteriously disappeared. The Atlantic, beating against a very wild and almost iron-bound coast, lay less than a mile from our home. My father, a clergyman of the Church of Ireland, before the world suspected it to be a " upas tree," was incumbent of a very large parish, in fact three parishes rolled into one, which extended many miles along the sea- coast and far into the interior. There were no resident gentry, and there was no preservation of game. No one but my brother had a gun in all the country -side, so that the shooting was all ours, and there was shooting in summer as well as in winter, for in summer we shot curlews, cave- pigeons, rabbits, and hares. Puss abounded in this region, and as there were no harriers and no greyhounds, Jack was, in fact, not only a great sportsman, but the only sportsman in the county. Enemies he had none, so that his mys- terious disappearance could not be ascribed to any personal malignity. All the country people were fond of him, and, I think, proud of B 2 4 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. him. They were always bringing him news of the " whereabouts " of otters, badgers, coveys of partridge, and so forth, and would run across the fields, leaving their work, to learn the contents of his bag, or would shout from afar, when they saw him returning with rod or gun, "Well, Master John, what luck ? " No, we never suspected for a moment, not until months after his disappearance, that he had been made away with by an enemy or had met with any foul play. And yet, in broad daylight, less than a mile from the Eectory, my brother suddenly disappeared, vanished as utterly as if he had been sucked down into the bowels of the earth, or drawn up into the sky. The day was the 10th of July, a singularly fine day even for that time of the year. It was the day after his return from college, and he was quite running over with spirits. When I awoke early that morning I heard him whistling outside the windows on the lawn. The air was " Vilikins and his Dinah," a song much in vogue MY BROTHER GOES TO DU-CORRIG. 5 at the time. He always came home with a new tune, and never seemed to tire of it till he got another. When I looked out he was walking to and fro on the lawn, taking the twist oat of a new fishing-line. He had fastened one end of it to a little holly-tree on the lawn, and was diligently engaged in taking out the twist, which, indeed, is a tedious process. During the forenoon and on till dinner-time he seemed keenly and happily absorbed in similar avocations, viz., getting his fishing-gear into order. We youngsters were confined to the schoolroom all that time, which we considered unfair, inasmuch as it was Jack's first day at home, but we could hear him bustling about the place and everlastingly whistling " Yilikins and his Dinah." Once we heard an awful screaming of geese in the rear regions. We knew perfectly well the cause of it. Jack was pursuing them and plucking out their wing feathers in order to tie pollock-flies. A little after noon he came into the school- room and asked the tutor, Mr. Humphreys, to 6 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. let me go to the village to buy him some wire. He gave me a penny for the wire and a penny for myself. In those days I considered a penny a handsome tip. He wanted the wire to make line-eyes for his big rod, that which he used for sea-fishing. He also bade me call at the shoe- maker's to get a piece of wax. I mention all this because on his disappearance some foolish people said that he had " run away," a suppos- ition which no member of the family harboured for a single instant. He was, in fact, brimful of sporting intentions. At three we dined, when, as I have described, he made those funny faces and set us all on the roar. When dinner was over and we ran out of the room, there was a boy at the hall door with a box of bait in his hand, consisting partly of cockles and partly of what we used to call lug- worms. They are dug up in the mud of the sea-shore when the tide is out. This boy had been digging bait for Jack all the morning. He asked Jack to let him go with him to Du-Corrig, and Jack refused. MY BROTHER GOES TO DU-OORRIG. 7 " Where are you going, Jack ? " said my second brother, Ned. " To Du-Corrig for conor," he said ; " and let none of you follow me as you value your lives." Young as I was, by a certain sympathy, or I know not what, I saw why he wished to be alone. It was to indulge in his transports and talk and sing, and do what he pleased, and so let off his animal spirits and delight at being home agaiii, without witnesses. I generally knew and felt what was passing in his mind. Indeed, I was very much attached to him, though he took hardly any notice of me. I was greatly pleased this day because he had selected me to go for the wire and wax. " I shall slay the wily conor, Ned," he went on, " till the sun is just that high above the western main. Sing tooral-al-ooral-al-ooral-al-lee, and then, up with the white feather ! and in with pollock and crohogues ! till Apollo is half- 8 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. way to the North in his silver boat, and black night invests the sea. For a cup of cold pison it lay by her side, And the billet-doux said 'twas by pison she died. Sing tooral-al-ooral-al-ooral-al-lee." etc., etc. Off he marched down the avenue with his little box of bait in his left hand, and his rod on his right shoulder, crunching the gravel noisily, for he was a large and stout lad. The two dogs followed close at his heels with their tails down, for they feared that they would be turned back. So they were, at the gate, and when they still showed signs of following he stooped down and flung stones towards them. Shortly afterwards I heard him shout " Ter." " Sir ? " answered a voice from a neighbour- ing field. " Come to Du-Corrig an hour after sunset to bring home the fish." "I will, sir," answered the voice. Then I heard more faintly in the distance the plaintive notes of " Vilikins and his Dinah " MY BROTHER GOES TO DU-GORRIG. 9 an odious song, by the way. So my brother Jack left home that 10th of July, 1854, and was not seen again. As will be quite evident, he could have no intention whatever of " running awa}V and yet that was the explanation of his disappearance which was favoured by all the Solomons. 10 CHAPTEE II. AND DOES NOT RETURN. I KNOW not why, but I had an uneasy feeling about Jack all that day, and it increased after he had left the Eectory for Du-Corrig. For some time this uneasy feeling took no precise shape, but later on I began to picture to myself a " tidal wave " sweeping him off the rock, and, having a lively imagination, saw the imaginary scene clearly, and Jack struggling for his life in the water. In the previous summer three tenants of ours in a different part of the coun- try, all fathers of families, had been so swept off the rocks while fishing conor and drowned. Though I reminded myself that Jack was a splendid swimmer and diver, and could do any- thing in the water, I failed to get rid of the vague sense of coming calamity of which I was conscious all day, and which became greater and greater as the sun set and darkness came on. AND DOES NOT RETURN. 11 " Might not Jack be attacked by cramp," I thought, " when in the water ? " True he never had had a cramp, nor did I know of anyone who was ever assailed in that way, but I had heard a great deal about the cramp. I was sent to bed early, for I was only eight years old, but I could not sleep. I kept listen- ing for the barking of the dogs. In the pre- vious summer that was to me the usual sign that Jack had returned safe from fishing. It was now long after dark. My two elder brothers, Ned and Sam, came into the room with a lamp. We three slept in the same room, Ned and Sam in one large bed, I in a little timber bedstead with high sides, over which I had to climb when getting in and out. Ned put the lamp on the table opposite the looking-glass and leaned over it. He took a pin from his coat and began to push up the wick. It was a primitive little lamp : I have not seen such since I was a boy. There was usually a fat red head on the top of the wick, 12 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. which, had to be snuffed just as we used to snuff the candles. " Jack is out late to-night," he said ; " I hope nothing has happened him." " What could happen him ? " said Sam, who was of a more stolid character. While saying this he undid the serpent-fastened belt which confined his waggoner. In those days boys wore loose white blouses gathered round the waist by a belt ; we used to call them " wag- goners." "I don't know," replied Ned, "but 'tis very late. There's papa opening the hall door and listening. How still the night is ! " " He's drowned," I cried from my truckle bed. " The tidal wave has caught him as it caught Cody, Phillips, and Moroney last year." " Hold your tongue, you little ass, and go to sleep," answered Ned angrily, but he threw down the window, leaned out, and listened. There was a corn-crake craking somewhere outside. The moon was shining ; I could hear AND DOES NOT RETURN. 13 the distant roar of the sea, where it rolled up the white strand which we called Tramore. "This is getting bad, Sam," he said. " He's long after his time." Sam was now in bed, but sitting up and listening with bright eyes. I heard my father moving about below stairs ceaselessly from the hall door to the parlour and back again, and talking with my mother. " There's someone coming," said Ned. The dogs were indeed barking, but not for Jack ; that I knew well. " Pooh 1 'tis only old Ter." "Well, Ter," he cried cheerfully from the window, " where are the fish ? Why isn't Master John with you ? " To these questions there was no audible reply. Ter was one of my father's labourers who worked, or rather elaborately idled, upon the extensive glebe farm which was attached to the Eectory. It will be remembered that it was Ter whom my brother told to come to Du-Corrig after sunset. Ter made no reply to Ned's 14 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. questions. I heard him crunching the gravel as he walked slowly to the hall door. " What is he saying ? " I cried. "Sh " said Ned, with his head on one side, listening. The man was Baying something to my father at the hall door. " He says he found the bait-box on the rock, but no rod, and that Jack is not there, and that he shouted for him everywhere and got no answer. Get up, Sam ; we must go search/' Sam sprang at once with a bound upon the floor and dressed in haste. " Perhaps he left Du-Corrig," he said, " in one of the boats going out for night-fishing." *' Then why did he leave the box of bait behind him ? " retorted Ned. " Forgot it," answered Sam, dressing furiously. The house was by this time in confusion, with servants rushing to and fro, exclamations, interrogations, and my father's voice raised. Then I heard somewhere the sound of a horn. The country-side was being called out to AND DOES NOT RETURN. 15 search. I was alone now ; Ned and Sam were far away in the night. From the window I could see many torches moving swiftly south- westwards in the direction of Du-Corrig. I heard the faintest and most distant noises, owing to the extreme stillness of the night. Fear, I suppose, too, made my hearing preter- naturally acute. I remained at the open window a long time, till I was discovered there by my mother, shiver- ing and coughing, and was by her put back into my bed. She was in tears, though perhaps to comfort me she said, "Go to sleep, darling. Jack will be here when you wake in the morn- ing. Of course he has gone out in one of the deep-sea fishing-boats." It was discovered, however, ere long that none of the boats which used to go out far from land, fishing haak and ling, had gone out that night, owing to stress of haymaking. At last I fell asleep. When I woke in the morning and sat up, I found my two brothers lying on their bed, outside the bed-clothes, fast asleep, but not 16 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. undressed. I knew from this that Jack had not been found. I dressed and went into Jack's room. It was empty ! I then went downstairs. There were voices in my father's study. The door was open ; I saw my father standing and my mother sitting down, both very pale, and my mother weeping. It was still the grey dawn of the day. My parents not having noticed me, I set out for Du-Corrig and ran all the way. The place was crowded with fishermen and country people, amongst whom were several policemen and coast- guards, in their bluejackets and white trousers. There were boats off the rock, which were being rowed slowly along. The men in them were dragging the sea-bottom here with grappling- irons. Just then a police orderly rode up on a foaming horse. He received some fresh directions from Mr. Watkins, the constabulary officer of the district, and galloped off again. Everyone, indeed, was at his wits' ends, for it was quite impossible to frame any theory of the disappear- ance which would square with known facts. One AND DOES NOT RETURN. 17 boat had gone bream -fishing the previous after- noon. The people in it said that they had seen my brother on the rock, and that he had hailed them as they rowed past in a cheerful and friendly manner. That was the last seen or heard of him. That he had been drowned no one in the neigh- bourhood could believe, though the coastguards, for want of anything else to do/ were dragging the sea-bottom. There were other boats out too fishermen who went miles to the east and miles to the west, searching and at intervals crying out, hoping against hope that there might be some response. Presently my elder brothers Ned and Sam came down to the rock, and roughly bade me go home. They joined Mr. Watkins, who questioned them for a long time. The last hope was that in obedience to a sudden impulse he had walked off to visit some of our distant friends, for' a twenty or thirty mile walk was nothing to him. But no tidings of any kind reached us as day followed day. No one had heard of him 18 LOST ON DU-CORRIQ. or seen him anywhere since the bream -fishers passed him on the rock, when he hailed them as I have already described. The series of extraordinary and marvellous experiences which had really befallen my brother will be found to re -illustrate for the thousandth time the old saying that " truth is stranger than fiction/' 19 CHAPTER III. SAMUEL WATKINS ON THE DISAPPEARANCE. OFFICIAL REPORT. " I HAVE to report a very mysterious disappear- ance which took place in this neighbourhood last Wednesday, the 10th instant. The eldest son of our rector, the Rev. Mr. Freeman, left home in the afternoon to go fishing, and never returned. He was seen by a boat's crew shortly afterwards, fishing from the rock to which he had announced that he would go for that purpose. Its local name is Du-Corrig. For reasons which I need not set down, I am abso- lutely certain that he did not run away. That he slipped from the rock and was drowned is also well-nigh incredible, for he was a splendid swimmer and a remarkably athletic and spirited young man ; nor is it credible that he met with foul play in such a spot and at such a time, for he had nothing with him to excite cupidity. c 2 20 LOST OjV DU-CORRIG. " He was very popular, too, in the neigh- bourhood, and after making many secret in- quiries, I do not believe that he had an enemy in the whole country-side. It is possible, no doubt, that from some other part of the country an enemy may have followed him hither, killed him unawares on the rock, and flung his body into the sea. The ground, however, has been carefully dragged, under my directions, by the coastguards of the adjoining station. They found nothing not even his rod, which dis- appeared along with him. " Subsequently I secured the services of the diver who is at work on the construction of the Coosdarig pier for the Board of Works. He came next day, with his diving apparatus and assistants, and made a careful submarine exam- ination without discovering anything. If young Freeman was drowned here, his rod, weighted as it was by a heavy brass reel, should have been found. Altogether the case is mysterious, nor can I frame any theory which would rationally account for it. I have caused advertisements to SAMUEL WATKINS ON THE DISAPPEARANCE. 21 be inserted in all the Connaught papers, giving a description of young Freeman." SAMUEL WATKINS. [Private Letter.] July 18th. MY DEAR HARRY, You cannot imagine how much I have been upset about this affair. John Freeman, the lost boy I find it hard to picture him as anything but a boy has been known to me intimately since he was thirteen years of age. I can honestly say that I have never known a finer, braver, more honourable, and more affectionate lad. He is not exactly handsome, though he has the fiercest and brightest eyes of glowing hazel that I ever saw, and a very beautiful mouth ; nor clever, yet, at the same time, not deficient in intelligence. He is absolutely without vice, though I hear that during the last college term he has begun to smoke a little. He is the strongest and almost the most athletic youth whom it has ever been my good fortune to meet, large-limbed, muscular, and brimful of health and of spirits. As a swimmer and diver I never saw his equal. I have often seen him strip on a wild day in December or January, and swim long distances to recover some curlew or pigeon which he had shot. But enough of this. Suffice it to say that not only as the constabulary officer of this district, but as his own personal friend, the astonishing and mysterious disappearance of poor Freeman, under the circumstances detailed in the official report, has been to me a most severe blow. I have done, and am doing, my best. But every night finds me here in my den cogitating aimlessly over this tragedy 22 LOST ON DU-OORRIG. for the worst of it is that I am unable even to imagine a theory which will in the least square with the facts. It is unfortunate that the Rev. Mr. Freeman and myself are not on the best of terms. I once flung out the suggestion that the days mentioned in the first chapter of Genesis were ages or long intervals of time. Some meddler told him of this, since when he has regarded me coldly and askance as a dangerous Freethinker. Moreover, I am not a very regular attendant at church. In short, our relations are cold and strained, though I like and respect him very much. John, the lost boy, is the eldest son. The next brother is Edward a tall, loose-jointed, black- eyed and merry stripling, far more popular than John, owing to his pleasant ways and ready speech, greatly devoted to flute-playing and performances on the cornet- a-piston, 3, magnificent leaper and swimmer, though by no means as powerful and athletic as his brother John, who but I think I have sufficiently described him already. There is no girl. Next comes Sam, who is somewhat of a nondescript a staid, self-contained, stubborn sort of boy. The fourth son is a little boy called Charley, a weird- looking child, all eyes, like a young crow, and who never laughs. Mrs. Freeman is as quiet and unassuming as her husband at least, where his pastoral authority and sense of theological duty are concerned is not. She is kind, gentle, most hospitable, a truly Christian lady. Write at length, and fully, weighing and considering all the facts. Was John Freeman drowned, or murdered, SAMUEL W ATKINS ON THE DISAPPEARANCE. 23 or spirited away and hidden ; or did he run away, or was he swept off by the tide and picked up by a passing ship 1 Consider all the possibilities, and write. When we were at the depot together I remember you used to guess out the mystery of a novel from the first few chapters. This disappearance is curiously like the first chapter of a novel. Bring your guessing and solving powers to bear upon it, and oblige yours truly, SAMUEL W ATKINS. 24 CHAPTER IV. CHARLEY FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued}. HIS VISION. EVERYONE had given up all hope of ever seeing my brother again, when one person, if a child of eight may be called a person, strongly and continually began to assert that he was alive. How I became possessed of this conviction I now proceed to relate. It happened in this manner. On the night of the 31st of July, exactly three weeks and a day after the dis- appearance, I had a very singular experience, which, in spite of all absurd theories of brain- waves, telepathy, and I know not what, I still firmly believe to have been an instance of Divine interposition. It was upon a Wednesday night, as I par- ticularly remember, because my father always had service on Wednesday nights, and I had been to church and returned with the rest of CHARLEY FREEMAN'S VISION. 25 the family. I went to bed as usual at half-past seven in good health, if not in good spirits. Truly, during those weeks we were all terribly afflicted and cast down. Between eight and nine o'clock, as I lay wide awake, I saw, not a dream, but a clear waking vision ! At the time I was not thinking of Jack at all. I had just got into bed, and was lying on my back and looking upwards into the dark. I became aware of a light not far from me on the left, and thought at first that someone had come into the room with a lamp. Turning a little to one side, I saw a fire burning red and smoky, from which went up a good many sparks. This was all I saw at first, but presently I became aware that someone was sitting near it with his back towards me, bare-headed, and perfectly still. It was Jack ! I sat up and called him by his name, but he made no answer and did not move. Then I asked him a succession of short, quick questions as to what he was doing, why he did not answer me, etc. There was darkness 26 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. all round the place, darkness which was faintly illuminated by the fire, but afterwards I re- membered having seen rough, shiny points of ragged rock on which the firelight faintly played and flickered. I did see clearly a large fish which lay beside him on a flagstone close to the fire. To judge by his attitude he ap- peared to be gazing intently into the heart of the blaze. Once he stooped forward a little as if to feed the fire. Still shouting questions I sprang from my bed and rushed towards him, intending to lay my hand on his shoulder. Then I came violently into collision with something solid ; it was a wardrobe which stood against the wall on the other side of the room in front of my bed. Eecovering myself, I could see the vision still before me as clear and distinct as if I saw it with my eyes ; indeed, I have not the least doubt that I did see it with my eyes. Then soft arms were laid round me and I was raised up. It was my mother, who had run upstairs hearing my cries. CHARLEY FREEMAN'S VISION. 27 She put me back in my bed. The whole family had rushed to the room, greatly fright- ened by my screamings and loud excited talk. Though there were candles in the room I still saw the apparition, vision, or whatever it might be called, and, still urging my mother and brothers to see it too, was deposited in bed, and even forcibly held down there. When I was again able to look in the same direction the vision was gone ! Of course, my mother concluded at once that I was ill, labouring perhaps under an acute gastric attack, the commencement of a gastric fever, and I was treated on the assumption that I was suffering from that common child's malady, and dosed with the usual medicines. My mother was surprised in the morning to find no sign of illness upon me, and still more so when the doctor declared that I was perfectly well. Though I was kept in bed my brothers were permitted to see. me. Of course I told and told over and over again the whole story of the vision. 28 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. " Jack is alive somewhere," I kept saying, " and must be searched for." "Why do you go on like that, Charley?" they said. " Don't you know he's dead ? It was a dream." " It was no dream," I answered ; " I was as broad awake as you are. I saw him, and how could I see him if he wasn't alive ? " " But how could he be in the room ? There's no trace of fire here. How can you be so foolish ? " " No," I replied, " he wasn't in the room, of course. When I struck the press which stands against the wall here, I could see him still beyond me. So, of course, he wasn't in the room. But he was somewhere else, and I saw him, and he's alive." On the following night, shortly after the big mahogany clock in the lobby had struck eight, I continued to watch intently for the reappearance of the vision. Nothing came, however, though I heard the clock strike nine. But on the following night I had an experience CHARLEY FREEMAN'S VISION. 29 quite as surprising to myself, though not to others, as that vision of the fire and of my brother sitting between me and it. A few minutes after the clock struck, I seemed to grow suddenly and curiously cold, and while still staring out into the darkness, I was aware of the words " The Devil's Parlour" coming into my mind. I did not hear the words at all with my ears. It was as if my mind had ears, and that I heard the words in that way, very clear and distinct, but not at all as if spoken by any audible voice. I did not cry out or make any noise on this occasion, but resolved to stay awake and tell my brothers when they came to bed. I fell asleep, however, before they came up. In the morning I awoke them and told what had happened. They treated me as little Joseph was treated by his brothers ; nevertheless I saw them look significantly at one another. After breakfast and before school hours they went off together, Ned taking his cornopean with him. The Devil's Parlour was an awe- 30 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. inspiring cleft, the opening to some deep and mysterious subterranean hollow, in the side of a long hill which lay about a mile westward from the Rectory. As I afterwards learned, my two brothers went to the cleft, shouted down into it both together, and Ned blew his cornet-a-piston, mouth downwards, awaking huge echoes and reverberations there. Then they listened but heard no reply. They hardly spoke to me at all after this, and never about my mysterious visions and experiences. The same day I took from the sideboard in the dining-room a great home-made brown cake, and going off by myself rolled it down the Devil's Parlour. Two days afterwards I took and rolled down another, and continued to tell everyone that Jack was alive and in the Devil's Parlour. I had rolled down some half a dozen cakes in this manner when my mother, who was aware of the rapid disappearance of her cakes, dis- covered me in the act of making off with one. That night she and my father had a con- CHARLEY FREEMAN'S VISION. 31 sultation on my case, and the following day I was sent off to an uncle and aunt who lived in an adjoining county. Of course my parents thought that my mind was affected, and my mother attributed it to excessively long school hours and too much brain-work. At my uncle's, I had nothing to do but amuse myself, and gradually I began to think that perhaps what my uncle and aunt said was true, and that these experiences were only dreams and " lively imaginations," which was the expression used. I was to come home at Christmas, but early in November a messenger arrived with a letter from Ned addressed to my uncle, telling him to send me home at once. Something very strange had occurred in the meantime, something that caused my visions and voice to be regarded at home in quite a new light. 32 CHAPTEE V. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE. THE ARREST OV MELODY. IN the month of October, long after the public excitement caused by the disappearance of my brother John had subsided, and even after the local interest caused by Charley's curious be- haviour and conversation had died away, the suspicion, indeed the conviction, that John had met with foul play, while it renewed the general excitement, made our own grief only the deeper and more bitter. Everyone believed now that my brother had been murdered. Du-Corrig, where Jack was last seen, was not within sight of any house in the neighbour- hood, but there was a house and farm close by, occupied by a returned Irish-American called Melody, a very big, noisy, and quarrelsome man, given to drink. He was poor now, though when he came home he had money. His wife was THE ARREST OF MELODY. 33 dead. He lived here with his mother, who was bed-ridden, and three children, the eldest of them called Dannie, who was a pupil in my father's parochial school. No one liked Melody ; nor am I surprised his ways were so different from those of the rest of the people. One day I overheard a labourer on the Glebe say to another, " Melody is drinking again, wherever he got the money." I noticed the remark, for on the previous even- ing I had seen him staggering home from the adjoining village. He endeavoured to get into conversation with me, but I stepped out, and could hear him bawling some impertinence after me. Melody had money and was drinking. The fact caused a good deal of interest and curiosity in the neighbourhood. A few evenings later the schoolmaster called at the Glebe and inquired for me. I went into the kitchen and noticed that his face was fixed and pale ; I brought him into the dining-room and asked him whether he was ill. He said " No," and was silent. I too was silent and D 34 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. only looked at him. He had a piece of paper in his hand which he kept twirling between his fingers in a nervous manner. At last he said suddenly " I came about Master John. I fear, sir, there has been foul play. You know I taught him mathematics for his Michaelmas examin- ation last year, and was a good deal with him in the evenings. He then showed me his ring. It had a Latin inscription on the inside. Not knowing Latin, I do not rightly recollect the words, though I read them at the time and he translated them for me. Master Edward ! Master Edward ! " he cried in great agitation, and laying the paper on the table, " are those they ? " " They are ! " said I. We stood trembling and looked at each other. Written on the paper in a large schoolboy hand were the words "Nee sperne duritiam" Those were the words engraved on the inside of my brother's ring. "This is terrible, Mr. Grloster," I said at last; "tell me all." He did so, and to the following effect : THE ARREST OF MELODY. 35 Dannie Melody, it seems, came to school one day looking very big and important, and behaved so badly that he had to be punished. The boy's singular behaviour arose from the fact that he was the possessor of a sixpenny- bit, which he said his father had given to him. As Dannie was never known to have even a halfpenny, his bright sixpence excited a great deal of curiosity, and all the boys were very eager to find out the cause of his father's un- expected munificence. Dannie, however, refused to tell ; but, it seems, after having pledged him to fidelity, communicated the secret to a little friend of his. One day Mr. Gloster surprised these two friends idling at their desk, or, rather, examin- ing together a piece of strange paper. Before Dannie could conceal it Mr. Gloster had snatched it up and demanded of Dannie where he had got the characters with which it was inscribed. They recalled to him the legend in the ring. The boy began to cry, and said that he could not tell, that his father would beat him if he D 2 36 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. did. When school was dismissed Mr. Gloster kept Dannie back, and at length got the secret from him. Dannie, it seems, coming home one day found his father sitting by the fire and ex- amining a gold ring. The moment the boy appeared he put it hastily into his pocket. He came back drunk from the village that night, and slept long the next morning. Dannie, with a child's inquisitiveness, searched his father's pockets till he found the ring, and after examining it curiously for a long time, finally the whim seized him of copying out the strange words which he found on the inside. He kept the copy and put the ring back in the pocket from which he had taken it. When his father awoke and got up, he called him outside of the house and said to him, " Dannie, you saw a ring with me last night. Well, you're to tell no one about it. If you do, I'll break every bone in your body." Then he gave Dannie the sixpence as a bribe and made him give a solemn promise of secrecy. THE ARREST OF MELODY. 37 That was all Dannie had to tell, except that his father the same day went to our nearest market town, Ballymohur, and sold the ring there, as Dannie believed, for he came back with money, but without the ring. Mr. Gloster wished to know from me whether he should tell all this to my parents. Terrible as was the news, and great as would be the shock to them, especially to my poor mother, I thought so. Of the effect upon them I shall say nothing. Later on in the evening, Mr. Gloster and I set out for the house of Mr. Watkins, the sub -inspector of police. When Mr. Watkins heard this strange story he re- solved to arrest at once Melody and his son. A warrant was procured from the nearest magistrate, and about nightfall we came to Melody's cabin. The cabin was absurdly small to be the abode of such a big man. The thatch was secured by hay ropes, held in their place by stones attached to their ends, a row of which hung all round the cabin under the eaves like a necklace. The tenant's huge conor rod reposed against 38 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. the roof and stretched away into the sky. Everything about the place was as untidy and unkempt as possible. Melody had learned nothing good, but much bad, during his sojourn in the great Eepublic. The cabin stood a little distance in from the boreen which led from the high road down the steep valley and ended near Du-Corrig. As we approached, the big Irish-American issued in a stooping attitude from the little dark doorway, and came along the causeway which crossed the bawn, that is to say the small yard lying in front of the cabin. When he saw us a visible change of expression passed over his face. One of the constables, showing him the warrant, laid his hand on his shoulder, saying at the same time, " I arrest you in the name of the Queen ! " "What for? " said he, looking very angry. " For the murder of John Freeman," was the reply. Melody turned pale and staggered. " Gentle- men," he said, " I am not guilty ; I never did it." THE ARREST OF MELODY. 39 "Melody," said the sub-inspector, "Mr. Freeman's ring was seen in your possession. You may make any statement or explanation that you please, but I warn you that what you say will be used against you hereafter at your trial." " Gentlemen," said Melody, " I'll tell you all I know about that ring. One morning I sees a flock of pigeons in the black field beyant there that has the heap of white stones in the middle of it. I crept under the fence, and when I got near threw a stone or two at them. They fled away, but wan of them flew so bad and sat down again so soon that I followed after and killed her. The ring was fastened to her leg with a bit of cord, and I was afeard that some- one would claim it on me, so I tould Dannie not to tell." " And the ring, where is it ? " said Mr. Watkins sternly. Melody hesitated for a moment or two ; then he said boldly " Sir, I losht it." 40 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. I perceived at once, and everyone there perceived too, that he lied. The pigeon story, too, though told so circumstantially, we of course disbelieved. Dannie was arrested too, and led away crying bitterly. Melody was lodged in the county gaol, and the boy taken in charge by the police lest his evidence should be in any way tampered with pending the trial. Melody's cabin was searched by the police, but without discovering there any further evidence of his guilt. It was, however, now recalled that something like a fracas had occurred between my brother and the Irish- American on the evening before the dis- appearance. That was the evening of my brother's return from Dublin. He arrived unexpectedly by the post-car from Ballymohur and walked home from the village, i.e., Dun- beacon, which was only some three-quarters of a mile from the Rectory. As he was leaving the village, Melody was seen to join him, he being then in a tipsy condition. What occurred between them in the THE ARREST OF MELODY. 41 way of conversation was not heard, but after a while my brother was seen to give him a strong push, not a blow, which sent him staggering across the road so that he fell into the gripe. Jack walked on then, taking no further notice of him. Jack said nothing of this affair to any of us. I suppose he considered it a trifle. Of the subsequent investigations and in- quiries of the police I shall say little. Their theory of course was that Melody on the evening of the disappearance had joined my brother in the dusk of the evening, had struck and stunned him there on Du-Corrig, rifled the body and flung it into the water. Melody's arrest took place on the 15th of October, and of course created a great deal of excitement over the whole country. A detective came down from Dublin, but no further evidence was discovered against Melody save indeed the ring itself. This was found with a jeweller in Ballymohur, and at once surrendered to the police. The jeweller, Mr. Campion, admitted that he had bought it from Melody, 42 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. who had previously sold him a watch and other trinkets which he said he had brought home with him from America. I drove into town with Mr. Watkins and at once identified the ring. The constabulary were still searching for further evidences of Melody's guilt when something happened which in all probability was the means of saving an innocent man's life, namely, complete corroboration of Melody's incredible story about the pigeon and the ring. CHAPTER VI. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued}. JACK'S CARRIER PIGEON. ONE morning in the middle of October, as I looked from my bedroom window while dressing, I saw a flock of pigeons, of the slate-coloured variety common on this coast, fly over the lawn, and swooping a little, as if they would alight in an adjoining field, which had been tilled that summer. I felt a strong desire to have a shot at them, though I had not once taken out a gun since Jack's disappearance. Our only gun, by the way, was Jack's, a long single- barrelled muzzle-loader. I charged it quickly, passed through the wood, and surveying the field from a distance, saw the flock moving about and feeding in the dark-coloured tillage. I crept round the fence of the field till I came within shot of them as I judged. Waiting 44 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. till I had three in a line, I fired and killed all three. As I was bringing them home in triumph, I noticed a piece of linen wrapped round the leg of one of the birds, and fastened by a cord. I cut the cord, and unwinding the linen rag found it was the corner of a handkerchief, and bore certain initials. They were Jack's, viz., J.F. For a moment I stood rooted to the spot, then in a frenzy of joy ran to the house and rushed into the breakfast-room, where the whole family was already assembled at prayers, crying, or I dare say screaming, " Jack is alive." Again I pass over the agitation of our family circle, for such things are not easy to write about. We now saw that Melody's story of the ring was true. It was evident that Jack, imprisoned somewhere, and without other means of communicating with us, had hit upon this plan. That Jack was alive when he sent out these carriers was plain, but was he alive now? Perhaps the messengers had been despatched by JACK'S CARRIER PIGEON. 45 him shortly after his disappearance, and before hunger had made an end of him. My little brother Charley's vision then was true. My parents bitterly reproached them- selves for not having given heed to that strange vision which they now regarded as a special and miraculous interposition of Providence. I advised that Charley should be sent for at once, in order that we might examine him more carefully about what he had seen. The coachman saddling one of the horses galloped off straight, taking with him a note to my uncle hastily scribbled, and just caught the mail car which was on the point of starting from the village of Dunbeacon. He returned the next day, bringing Charley with him. Meantime the police and coastguards were communicated with, and the whole country-side was in motion. I and my next brother Sam, attended by some workmen, went off at once to the hill in which was the Devil's Parlour. We had with us a candle and matches and a very long rope. When we arrived there I knotted 46 LOST ON DU-COREIG. the end of the rope round my chest, first padding it with a blanket lest it should hurt me, and bade them lower me into the cleft. Soon I was in dense darkness. The flue, if I may call it so, was at first crooked and ragged, then descended sheer, so that I was in mid-air and could touch nothing with my hands. At another time I might have been afraid, but the hope of rescuing Jack drove out fear. At length I felt my feet touch ground, gravel as I knew by the feel and the noise. I shouted, but there was no response. I struck a match and lit my candle. Almost the first thing I saw was Charley's cakes lying about. I did not count them ; had I done so the discovery and rescue of Jack might have come sooner and by a different way. The place in which I now found myself was not what I expected. It was like a great round room, walled with rock, and paved with stones and gravel. There were bones of animals here, and the cakes which poor Charley fancied had been eaten by Jack. I gave the pre-arranged "SOON I WAS IN DENSE DARKNESS " (p. 46). s JACK'S CARRIER PIGEON. 47 signal, viz., a strong jerk at the rope, and was slowly drawn up out of this dark den. Till now we all believed that the Devil's Parlour was a huge subterranean cavern. Five miles further on towards the west there was a similar cleft leading into another cavern of unknown depth. We went thither, and I descended that too. Here I went near to being drowned. It com- municated with the sea, and was filled at the bottom with salt water. Without seeing it, I was lowered into it, and in fact fell in with a souse. By the slackness of the rope those above concluded that I had reached the bottom. Though I tugged vigorously at the rope they Avere not aware of it. I could not tug strongly while I was swimming, and then the great length of rope rendered it, I suppose, less sens- itive. Here, too, all the way down and up again I shouted at intervals and heard no re- sponse. It was night when we returned home. No sign of Jack had been discovered by any- one that day. The coastguards had been out 48 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. since morning visiting the rocks and islands, of which there were several in the neighbourhood, but had been as unsuccessful as myself. When I awoke next day, it seemed to me that I had caught a very bad cold. I got up nevertheless, but the moment my mother saw me she ordered me to my room. I refused to go, and my father had to exert his parental authority in a very stern manner before I could be got to obey. In the afternoon Charley arrived. I was aware of the fact, but of little more, for by this time the fever had so grown upon me that I was beginning to be unconscious. After this I remember no more till I began to be convalescent after an attack of brain- fever. The searching for Jack had gone on without me during the remainder of October and the begin- ning of November while I lay at death's door. But the searchers had found no sign or trace of my brother. The police were utterly nonplussed. I heard that a very clever detective had been sent down from Dublin, but after wasting a fort- night had returned, saying that we were all mad. JACK'S CARRIER PIGEON. 49 I heard, too, that during all these weeks little Charley regularly every second day, wet or fine, used to go to the Devil's Parlour, and roll down his brown cake. My mother made no objection. He still continued to do it even after I began to move about, and after I had declared to him that there was nothing at the bottom of the cavern but gravel, bones, and the bread which he was wasting. I began to think of forcibly re- straining him from this practice, for it was killing my mother, who used to weep for a long time after she had given him his cake and seen him off. The neighbours watched him with the utmost compassion, and indeed I have never seen anything so pathetic. "Was it said in your dream that Jack was in the Devil's Parlour ? " I asked him. "No," he said, "but I believe that he is there without being told ; I told myself." When I was sufficiently convalescent to be able to move about again, I organised a search- party of my own. I believe we visited every E 50 LOST ON DU-GORRIO. cave and nook along the coast for fifteen miles on either side of Du-Corrig. We searched also the islands and isolated rocks out in the sea, though they had been already searched by the coastguards. 51 CHAPTER VII. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued). MYSTERIOUS DISAPPEARANCE OF EDWARD FREEMAN. THAT Jack was or had been in some cavern I knew. These slate-coloured pigeons blue rocks, as they are called roost in caves. Indeed, we never called them anything but cave-pigeons. But where was the cave ? It now occurred to me that Jack, having hooked some unusually large fish (the sun-fish, for example, could do it), had been drawn into and under the sea. I knew that under such circumstances he would not let go his rod, and thought it possible that while under the water he had been sucked through a submarine tunnel into some unknown and otherwise unapproachable interior cavern, and had been unable to re- discover or retrace the passage by which he had entered. E 2 52 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. This cavern, I thought, might communicate with the open air, or with one of the many ordinary caves or fissures along the coast by some narrow outlet, through which his carrier pigeons might have escaped. Improbable as was this theory, it was the most probable that I could frame, and was, in fact, rather near truth. All the theories and surmises of the police contained one or more incredible assumptions. I procured the services of the same diver who had been formerly employed by Mr. Watkins. For more than three weeks under my superin- tendence he made submarine searchings, of the kind indicated, on either side of Du-Corrig, and to a considerable distance each way. All was, however, in vain. The diver gave up first. He said it was a sin to waste any more of my father's money in such an attempt. With my father's sanction I now wrote to the Board of Works in Dublin, asking them to send me another. Harris, the man whom I employed, obstinately refused to go on with the search. This diver DISAPPEARANCE OF EDWARD FREEMAN. 53 was actually on his way down from Dublin, when " [When, in fact, Edward Freeman himself dis- appeared just as suddenly and unaccountably as his brother. EDITOR.] 54 CHAPTER VIII. CROHOOR-BEG. SAMUEL W ATKINS TO HENRY VIGORS. You will no doubt have already read the official report in which I have informed the authorities of the disappearance of the Eev. Mr. Freeman's second son under circumstances somewhat similar to those which attended the disappearance of the eldest, Mr. John Freeman. This extraordinary event has caused a degree of consternation and alarm over the whole countryside which it would be impossible to describe. On the morning of Friday last, about ten o'clock, Edward Freeman whose exertions for the discovery of his brother's place of conceal- ment, voluntary or enforced, have been so inde- fatigable was seen walking in the direction of Du-Corrig, and no doubt on his way to that fatal and ill-omened rock. Two children coming along the main road saw him turn aside and step briskly down the little lane or boreen leading to CROHOOR-BEG. 55 Du-Corrig He had a fishing-rod on his shoulder and a box of bait in his hand. He has not been seen since. , The mystery is infinitely more than doubled by this second disappearance, for with it our hypothesis regarding the first, viz., that Melody murdered John Freeman, vanishes too. I declare I begin to think there is something supernatural and uncanny in the whole of this Freeman affair. All other theories having failed, I can assure you, though I may earn nothing but your contempt by the avowal, that I find my thoughts straying perpetually in the direction of supernaturalism as that which may supply us with the key to this astounding mystery. A singular superstition of old standing, but which was believed to have died out, has been revived amongst the people to account for this disappearance of the brothers. It is said that the coast is haunted by what the English-speaking fishermen call a worm, and the Irish-speaking a piast. Even before the disappearance of Edward Freeman, I overheard talk of this piast in 56 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. connection with John Freeman's disappearance, but when I laughingly desired more definite in- formation on the subject I was refused. As you are aware, when I was first stationed in this district I determined, for professional reasons, to learn the language in which the people express their most intimate thoughts, that is to say, the old Gaelic tongue. It has been very useful to me. I have always found that the people are much more communicative and con- fiding with a person who can speak to them in this ancient language. Concerning the piast, however, on this occasion referred to I found the men, whom I had overheard speaking, sullenly and obstinately uncommunicative. I am certain, however, that the notion of a supernatural and man-devouring monster now haunting these shores is universal amongst the island and coast population. Since John Freeman was lost, not a man has been seen fishing upon any of the rocks along the coast, and since Edward disappeared in the same equally amazing manner, no fishing boat CROHOOR-BEG. 57 from our little basin has ever remained out after dark. For myself I must say that, although of course I do not believe in any such nonsense, yet for some days I have found my imagination most disagreeably haunted by the thought of this reptile prowling round the shore and seeking whom he may devour. I have dreamed of the brute, and that he had plucked me too not from off a rock, but out of my flower-garden, as I was watering my flowers. The beast seemed to be a monstrous serpent with wings and a hairy mane. He raised him- self out of the sea, and, looking all around with his basilisk eyes, suddenly swooped down upon me and seized me. I screamed so loud that the whole household came running to my room. You can imagine what a fool I seemed to myself and others. On Friday, in the forenoon, I say, the second young Freeman was lost. Of what we have done and attempted in the meantime you will find enough in the official report. The following is for your private eye, for I know you take an interest in these queer 58 LOST ON DU-OORRIG. superstitions which still linger amongst the peasantry and fisher people, and which are, I suppose, a remnant of paganism. On Sunday afternoon I saw a four-oared hoat endeavouring to gain the long island where you and I made such a bag of rabbits last summer, and which the people call Lan-wohr. Curious to see whether the rowers could accomplish their purpose against the head-wind which blew strongly from the west, I kept watching them. The boat had started early that morning from the little fishing village of Coos-beg, which lies to the east of our own village, Dunbeacon, and some ten miles distant from my place. Suddenly the boat's head was turned towards land, a sail hoisted, and the boat came driving straight towards my own private little harbour, Coos-an-Dorcha, which of course you remember. The boat seemed to me as if fleeing from the pursuit of an enemy, so furiously she came plunging along with the water leaping and boiling at her bows. I went down to the strand to meet the crew. When they were landed CROHOOR-BEG. 59 and had drawn up their boat, I bade the men step up to my house and have refreshment before going to the village. They intended to sleep there that night and go on next morning to Lan-wohr should the wind come down or change its direction. They were in all six Lan-wohr men, very wild and rough in appearance, but, like all the remote islanders along this coast, by no means so wild as they looked. Indeed, these islanders are almost invariably a simple -minded, peaceable, hospitable, and kindly people. I gave them a comforting draught of undiluted whisky as they sat and dried themselves around a big fire in my kitchen, and afterwards regaled them with plenty of home-made cake and butter and big bowls of steaming hot tea. They were much exhausted from rowing, and the poor fellows looked so happy and pleased as they ate and drank, that it was a delight only to see the look of satisfaction in their simple countenances. Then at my suggestion they took out their pipes and smoked, I, too, smoking 60 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. with them and asking many questions in Gaelic. They were at first very friendly and com- municative ; then I spoke of the disappearance of Mr. Freeman's sons, of the fruitlessness of all our searchings, and observed, with as serious arid awe-struck a face and manner as I could assume, that they might have been snatched from Du- Corrig by a worm. A sudden silence thereupon fell on the Lan- wohr men. One of them made some answer which I forget, but the subject was not pursued. I felt at once that the Lan-wohr men knew a great deal more about the piast than they thought good to communicate to me, who, though I could speak their tongue, was yet a gentleman, a Sassenagh, and, in short, not one of themselves. As you are aware, these people consider it " unlucky " to talk more than is necessary about the supernatural things and personages in whom they believe, and will never speak about them with those who are not quite in accord and sympathy with themselves upon CROHOOR-BEG. 61 sucli subjects. The peasantry who are communi- cative on such subjects will be found, almost invariably, to be persons who have to some extent become emancipated from these forms of superstition. When the men rose to leave for the village, which they offered to do, not too soon and also not too long after they had partaken of my hospitality, I bade the oldest of them, a gigantic old fisherman called Crohoor-beg, to stay with me for the night, for I could spare him a bed. He consented, and remained when the rest took their leave. He was called Crohoor-beg, or Crohoor the Little, no doubt ironically on account of his great size. I had noticed that when I alluded to the plant Crohoor 's face became unusually rigid and impassive, and that he closed his mouth as if resolved not to speak again that evening. I now led Crohoor into my office, stirred up the fire, made a good blaze, and after some allusion to the hardship which he had endured that day, brewed for him a stiff tumbler of punch. 62 LOST ON DU-GOEEIG. Though he was now in my own private room, and surrounded by pictures and many strange things savouring of "quality life," Crohoor's behaviour was almost gentlemanlike ; at least, it was characterised by ease, simplicity, and dignity. Later on I spoke again of the disappearance of Mr. Freeman's sons, of the great affliction of the family, and of the exertions of myself and my man to solve the mystery. Eventually Crohoor- beg broke through his reserve, and before he lay down that night told me all he knew or believed about ihe piast. 63 CHAPTEE IX. MR. WATKINS' NARRATIVE (continued}. THE PIAST. CROHOOR-BEG commenced by iDforming me, somewhat in the manner of a professional story- teller or historian about to deliver a lecture, that Ireland was at one time filled with monstrous reptiles, ugly and horrible, which preyed upon the people. So much I knew, and also that St. Patrick had banished them, all but a few which lingered on after his time in remote mountain lakes ; but Crohoor said that though this might be true of other parts of the country, it was not St. Patrick who had banished the great piast of this region, but a man called Cuhoolin. The name of the piast, he said, was Cooree, and that after a terrible battle Cuhoolin had conquered her, driven her into the sea, and put her under spells to remain there till the Day of Judgment, when, according to Crohoor, she will be cast for ever into Hell, and the door shut. Also 64 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. Cuhoolin put spells upon her that she should not have power to eat men, only once and again and between times. Crohoor went on to inform me that when his father was a little boy some men had been lost while fishing off this coast, and it was believed they had been eaten by ihepiast. A panic took possession of the whole country, so that fishing ceased. There was at the time in this country a very good and holy priest, who had unusual influence over the minds of the people. He held a sea- service and celebrated mass upon the water, in the midst of a great flotilla of boats, for the banishment of the monster. After that he forbade the people even to speak of the piast, not even to mention her as a thing of the past, an old-time plague upon the coast ; and such was his influence, according to Crohoor, that, for two generations, only the vaguest ideas circulated amongst the people concerning the reptile. Since the taking away of Mr. John Freeman from Du-Corrig, " the old people had been talking " ; " and why shouldn't they," he added, THE PIAST. 65 " when 'tis plain that the pia&t is alive and strong and at her old bloody work again ? " "What is the appearance of \hspiast? }< I asked ; " and where does she live ? " " I'll tell you about that, sir/' he said; and proceeded to relate the following story, with regard to which I may add that I am very conscious that my English does not adequately express the power and picturesqueness of Cro- hoor's Gaelic. " These things happened before my father's time and before my grandfather's, but they are as true as that you are sitting in that chair. Two men and a gossoon went in a boat from Lan-beg, which lies a little westward from Lan- wohr (but your honour knows the island), to buy flour in Dunbeacon, for little is the grain grown there on Lan-beg by reason of the stony floor of the island. The wind was from the south' ard, so they hoisted sail, and it wasn't long before they made the Basin and grounded their boat there. When they bought the flour and put the bags in the boat, it was the F 66 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. judgment of one of the men that they should run down the boat, hoist sail, and return to Lan-beg immediately, so that the daylight might be with them in their returning. " c None of your nonsense,' says the other. ' It isn't once in six months I come to the city, and I won't leave it till I warm myself well with water of life.' "' Water of death,' says the other. ' 'Tis unlucky to be passing the square hole after dark at any time, and in especial on this night.' " The night, your honour, was All Hallows' Eve, and 'tis a night when all the infernal things in the world, from the Devil down, have great power, be the reason what it may. " ' Tbepiast be hauged,' says the other. ' I hold by no such foolishness.' "The man who said this word was called Teigue Eue. He had red hair, and was the biggest and strongest man on the little island, and a terror to the peaceably inclined. By the same token, too, he had gone away to be a sailor THE PIAST. 67 when he was a slip, and he went to many out- landish parts before he came home and settled himself down with his kin, for good and all, in Lan-beg. And though he used to pretend to laugh at the old stories of the people, he himself had a custom of talking of some sea-devil orpiast that he called Ould Davy, and sometimes Davy with another name that the old people did not remember. " And so now all that his comrade could say was no use, but back he would go to the public- house, taking his comrade with him, who was a weak man, and there they were diverting themselves till the going-down of the sun. The comrade's name was Shaun. He was an O'Flaherty by nation. Well, Teigue Eue, though he laughed at the notion of ibejriafit, had too much sense to get drunk and he about to go out on the salt water in a sail-boat, or to allow Shaun O'Flaherty to get drunk either, though the people said afterwards that Shaun, in spite of his desire for an early return, was then all for more drink and another song. F 2 68 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. " They pushed the boat down after that, and stepped the mast and hoisted the sail, with the night upon them, and the moon rising three- quarter over the Ballyhourahan hills there in the east. Teigue Eue took the bailing-can and dipped it in the tide and poured the salt water on his head to cool himself after the liquor, and make his intellect more steady and considerate, and he made Shaun do the same. The gossoon also was warm and pleasant in himself, for he was with them in the public-house and all through. The stars came out, but though the night was bright and fine the wind blew strong still from the southward. " Well, sir, the boat was just opposite your own coos, called Coos-an-Dorcha by reason of the high black rocks around it and the shadow that is there always, when the wind scanted of a sudden, in an unreasonable manner, and the sail began to flap. " ' It would be better to go back/ says Shaun. "'It would be better to do no such thing,' THE PIAST. 69 says Teigue Eue, ' Handle your oar, man, and Jet the gossoon take the helm, and we won't be long in making Lan-beg, for the sea is like a goose-pond. The tide is against us here, but it won't be against us a mile farther on, and we can get home from that without inconvenience.' " Well, they rowed on in that manner till they came opposite the square hole in the big straight cliff." " What hole is that ? " said I. " I'm surprised your honour has not noticed it," replied Crohoor ; " but, indeed, unless it was pointed out to him a person might not see it." " I never saw or heard of it," I said. " Your honour knows the big straight cliff between your coos and Du-Corrig ? " "Certainly," I said; "but I am a little short-sighted, and never noticed that hole." " Well, sir, up high in that cliff there is a square hole, and big enough too, though it looks small from the water. They were nearing this 70 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. place when Shaun O'Flaherty stopped rowing and crossed himself and said " 'Teigue Eue, I'm greatly afraid.' " ' Afraid of what ? ' says Teigue Eue. " ' Of the pia&ta-wokr? he says ; ' sure, this is her favourite locality, between Du-Corrig and the Coos-an-Dorcha (that is to say, the Black Hock and the Coos of Darkness), and sure, they say that it is through Cooree's Window she comes out, and goes in again through the same, and has her nest there/ " Then Teigue Eue spoke words about the piast, and, though I well remember them, I won't say them in your honour's presence ; and he fell to beating Shaun O'Flaherty to make him quit his nonsense and be rowing the same as formerly. Then the gossoon screamed, with an awful and terrible cry that was heard by all the people of the valley that runs up back from Du- Corrig, and the men stopped their fighting and looked where the boy was looking, and that was up at the big white cliff. " Then they saw something that was enough THE PIAST. 71 to kill them all at once with the fright. From Cooree's Window the piast was coming out. And first she raised her head up along the cliff- side, stretching herself like a serpent or a huge black eel, and the head continued going up till it passed beyond the cliff-top, so that they could see the head of the piast against the sky and the stars, and her body all the time working slowly out of the hole. She was maned like a horse and had ears like a horse, and her eyes were like two red fires in her head. '" In that manner she raised her head up among the stars, and then, making an arch with her neck, turned her eyes downward, and at first she did not see them, but stretched her head along the cliff shore to Du-Corrig, and then backwards along the coast as far as Coos-an- Dorcha, and into the coos, winding her head and neck round the rock at the mouth of the coos. After that she raises her head again, but not so high as before, and in the bright water she sees the black boat, and without hurry, comes down upon it, the two men sitting there without a word, as 72 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. silent and as steady as stones, with faces like white paper. Then with her long tongue she reaps them into her mouth they still without a word or noise and chews them very deliber- ately. " The cracking of their bones in the mouth of the piast, that boy used to say afterwards, was like the crackling of ' brusna ' in a fire, and that the shower of blood that fell from her jaws along the hairs of her mouth every hair as long as an oar was like the sound of hail upon water. And after that she raised up her head to swallow them more conveniently, after the manner of birds when they drink." " Then the boy escaped ? " I said. " Yes, sir, the boy escaped. When the piast raised her head to swallow the two men, God gave him courage so that he slipped over the gunwale of the boat upon the seaward side, and sheltered himself so. It was not long before the piast came down again. The boy did not see her on account of the place where he was, but he heard her breathing and smelt the breath THE PIAST. 73 of her, like sea-weed, only very strong, and it is astonishing how he contrived to keep himself afloat considering the great fear that was upon him. She returned to the boat twice after that, for no doubt she smelt him, and he knew her coming on each occasion by reason of the breath- ing and of the very strong smell. In the end he heard a loud noise, and he said to himself that it was the noise of the hinder parts of the piast falling into the water, and that he would be safer in the boat now than in the sea. Accordingly, though with very great difficulty, owing to the fear that was upon him, he climbed over the gunwale and gathered the sail around him and lay down in the bottom of the boat. " The boat was picked up next morning by the Coos-beg men, for she was carried eastward by the tide, and when they unrolled the sail the boy was an idiot, and he continued in that state, and languishing besides, till the eve of St. John's Day in the next year, when he died, saving only that for nine days before his death 74 LOST ON DU-GORUIG. his understanding returned to him, and he told the siory many times to different people." " Is it your opinion then," I said, " that the piast has taken the two young gentlemen, my neighbours ? " " God alone," said Crohoor, " knows that, with Whom is the knowledge of all things. But if it be so, and the piast has them, Heaven be our defence, for the power of man and the mind of man furnish no protection against the like of her." " Crohoor, you said a short time ago that a man beat that reptile in battle, and banished her into the rocks and the sea ? " " So I said, sir, but it is thought that the man who did it was more than a man, and that though he lived before the coming of St. Patrick, yet the power of the Almighty was in him." Such, my friend, is the explanation of the disappearance of the two brothers offered by Crohoor-beg, O'Brien "by nation," who stands six feet three and a half in his stockings, and is of a size and bulk corresponding, a poor THE PIAST. 75 fisherman and cottier of the island called Lan- wohr, who can't speak English and never read a line in any printed book, but who, I verily be- lieve, is not only a nobler and better, but a wiser man, too, than most of the professional men with whom I am acquainted. And though his theory, being grounded on an incredible superstition, is to be rejected, it is not at all more irrational than several which I have heard soberly advanced by educated persons. SAMUEL WATKINS. 76 CHAPTER X. MR. WATKINS* NARRATIVE (continued). MR. WATKINS RECEIVES A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS MY DEAR HENRY, This astounding and mys- terious tragedy of the disappearance of the brothers Freeman has entered on a phase literally calculated to strike one dumb. In short, we have had a letter from the brothers, and yet we cannot find them. What I now proceed to relate is incredible, yet it is true. After the disappearance of Edward, and after all our renewed searchings and explorations had come to nothing, I argued with myself in the following manner : Wherever the brothers are, they are doubtless together, and have been spirited away and concealed by the same person and in the same way. From his place of con- cealment John Freeman was able to send out messenger pigeons with tokens attached. These tokens, though they proved that he was alive, A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS. 77 gave us no inkling as to his place of concealment or abode. He may have sent out others to which are attached definite written information. He could have written, in blood, characters on a strip torn from his handkerchief, and by some device protected the characters from the weather. Now that the two brothers are together, the chances are that they have sent out some pigeon so equipped. At once I wrote off to my two nephews, Harry and Joseph Battersby, whom you must have met last summer, to come without delay to me, bringing their guns with them. I had now determined to shoot every cave-pigeon in this neighbourhood, and I knew that my nephews, being boys, and accustomed to stealing upon and shooting from behind hedges at curlews, starlings, cave -pigeons, and such like, would do far more execution than I could. Having posted the letter, I went forth instanter, and also distributed small shot to my four men at this barrack, bidding them be off and shoot as many cave-pigeons as they could that day. I 78 LOST ON DU-COREIG. recalled their privileges the same evening, for they only succeeded in frightening the birds and making them very shy. They did not bring home a single pigeon, though they were firing about the country all day. I myself, though I kept stealing and dodging behind fences and furze-brakes from ten o'clock to dusk, only shot two. They bore no token of any kind. I knew that with the arrival of Harry and Joseph there would be a different tale to tell. So there was. Every day for a week they brought in from five to twelve pigeons, till a pigeon began to be a rara avis in our country, for those that were not killed were frightened away. The boys knew my purpose. One day, about nine days after their arrival, Harry came rushing into my office, shouting and exclaiming and holding a pigeon in his hand, round whose leg something was tightly wrapped. I saw that it was linen laced with cord very tightly along the shank between the bird's claw and its knee. My hands so trembled with A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS. 79 excitement that I cut myself, and badly, before I cut that cord. When I unwound the linen and laid it out upon the table I found upon it various stains of red. The linen had certainly been written upon originally, but the rain had penetrated, and melting the red ink blood no doubt con- verted the characters into mere blotches and stains. I remained alone a long time studying the red daubs and splashes you can imagine in what a state of mind. This rag of linen held the secret which I verily believe I would have given all my worldly goods to master. I turned it this way and that, for there was nothing to indicate which side should be held uppermost. Then, at last, it seemed to me that in one place I saw a W, after which a mere blotch of red colour representing, apparently, the rest of a word, and at the end of it another W. I called my wife to my assistance. She was sure of the first W but not of the second. Curiously enough, both the bovs were sure of the second but not of the 80 LOST ON DU-OORRIG. first. I was sure of both myself. As you know, I am always sure of everything that jumps with my expectations and hopes. You are a phleg- matic fellow yourself, Harry, a man of sheer intellect ; but I think that even you, if you had been through these Freeman experiences, lasting now for more than five months, with the eyes of the whole country upon you, might have been, perhaps, as much excited as I was this evening. I ran to the shelf for my Webster's dictionary. Do you remember how when we were sitting here together last summer after dinner, smoking and thinking of nothing, a little girl appeared at the door and said "Mrs. Horan's compliments, sir, and would you lend her the loan of your dictionary, for she's writing a letter," and how you replied " Mr. Watkins' compliments to Mrs. Horan, and tell her that he has not read it himself yet"? Well, it was the same dictionary, and a great deal of trouble I had to get it out of Mrs. Horan's clutches. A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS. 81 I turned to the letter W and ran my eye down all the words beginning with that letter in quest of those which ended with the same. Willow would suit, so would window. There were others, such as wallow, etc., but I neglected them. I rang for my orderly and bade him make inquiries amongst the people and learn whether there was any place in this neighbour- hood called by a name in which willow or window occurred. Now, I had not the least reason for suppos- ing that, even if my assumption was correct, the word which began and ended with W was the name of a place. It might be a verb, it might be anything ; but nevertheless, I at once jumped to the conclusion that it was the name of the place where I was to find the brothers. I had hardly uttered my directions when both my nephews cried out at once "Why, Uncle Sam, there's Curry's Window." And Harry, who takes more liberties with me than the other, gave me to understand that we G 82 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. were all " duffers " not to have searched Curry's Window before. As I had not the least notion of what Curry's Window was, they proceed to enlighten me. Curry's Window, they said, was a little black square hole high up in the face of the smooth sheer cliff which extended from Du-Corrig to my coos. In short, Curry's Window was the hole out of which the piast in Crohoor-beg's story had appeared when she had devoured the two fisher- men. This was a curious coincidence, and indeed, as Harry suggested, it was a singular thing that we should have explored the caves in distant islands, yet not have explored this hole which was near Du-Corrig. But then, how could the boys have got thither ? for there is no climbing on that cliff, which starts sheer out of the sea, and is accessible neither by land nor sea. I brooded over this all night, and the more I thought about it the more absurd did it seem that the brothers should be immured there. It A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS. 83 was just possible, of course, that the brothers having fallen into the sea, might have been sucked under by a current and whirled into some cavern of which Curry's Window was another aperture. The theory was just imaginable, but no more. However, as we had tried to work out so many absurd theories, I thought I might as well work out this absurd theory too as do nothing. Accordingly I laid my plans that night, and next day had one of my men lowered from the top of the cliff by a rope. In order to signal to those who held the rope I went out in a boat, rowed by the coastguards, who have been extremely helpful to me in all this business. Lieutenant Crumps indeed, that steadiest of church-goers, who never once to my knowledge missed even the Wednesday evening service, has taken the matter very coolly. Whenever I refer to the disappearance of the boys or of the affliction of the Freeman family, he says in a formal manner, as if he were answering the responses, " It is indeed a thousand pities." I o 2 84 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. blazed out on him on the last occasion, which had the effect of waking him up a little. How- ever, I need not complain, for though not actively helpful, he lets me direct the movements of his people, who are extremely sympathetic arid active in the matter. From the water then I signalled to the men, who on the edge of the cliff lowered the explorer to Curry's Window, motioning them to the right or to the left so as to drop their man exactly to the correct point. He was the most active and intelligent of the sub-constables, and went down provided with the means of striking a light and exploring the cavity. We saw him stand in the aperture and signal to us that he should be again lowered. This we did, and he descended into the interior, where he remained for more than an hour. However, to make a long story short, my sub-constable reported to me in the evening that Curry's Window was the small opening of an enormous underground hollow, with three huge galleries branching off from a vast central space, A LETTER FROM THE BROTHERS. 5 and that he had traversed the whole of it, shout- ing as he went and brandishing his torch. His description of the vast cavern was so interesting that my nephews were very anxious to make the descent themselves, and I promised that next summer, when you are with me, we should make up a party and go down with torches, but said that I was in no mood at present for agreeable explorations. I am now again alone in my office writing this while all the world is wrapped in slumber. Here nightly I sit cogitating and reflecting like some stupid old owl on his barn-perch, thinking and thinking till my mind becomes a perfect blank. I would consider myself a sheer fool but for the fact that we had a very sharp "Dublin detective down here for a fortnight, who, after having sent us on several wild-goose chases, went away at last declaring that we were all mad. What reporfc he sent in to the office I don't know, but he and my men had words before parting, and they gave him plainly to understand 86 LOST ON DU-COPRIG. that they regarded him as no better than a pre- tentious ass or " bosthoon." I fancy that his report is that John Freeman certainly "ran away " ; and that, let me observe, is what no one who lives here believes. CHAPTEE XI. MR. W ATKINS' NARRATIVE (continued). HE RECEIVES A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER. I WAS much cast down by these events my hopes had been raised so high. At one moment we seemed to be on the verge of the solution of this mystery, and now we were as far away from it as ever. The last pigeon shot, I may observe, was the sixty-fourth. For some days the boys had shot none. The pigeons were virtually extir- minated or banished, and I had deprived the brothers Freeman of what was apparently their sole means of communicating with the world out of their mysterious prison and that was not a pleasant reflection. One evening I and my nephews (they had just come in empty- handed, as usual of late) sat here in my office dumb and stupid for a long time. At last Harry said 88 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. " It's no use, uncle, going after these pigeons for a good while now. We must give them time to come back. Lend us your rifle : I'd like to have a shot at a seal. There are three or four of them always moving about between your cove and Du-Corrig. I used to see an odd one there last summer, but there seems to be quite a colony of them there now." "All right, lads/' I said; "take the rifle. You will find the boat in the cove. She's small, remember, and easily capsized, so take care of yourselves." I was anxious to be by myself. The high spirits of the boys, who naturally could not be expected to feel about these matters as I did, were beginning to oppress me. The fact was that my mind now for so many months absorbed by, and concentrated upon, this extra- ordinary and increasing and expanding mystery was beginning to be somewhat unhinged. I thought of the lost lads all day, and dreamed of them, perhaps, all night ; for certainly I never awoke without being conscious that I had been A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER. 89 dreaming about them. I am haunted, too, by poor Mrs. Freeman's wan, sorrow-stricken face. Mr. Freeman, when last I saw him, was bowed in the shoulders he who used to be as straight as a drilled soldier and his look was that of an aged man. I, as head of the police in this district, have, of course, been blamed for not doing more ; though I confess no word of censure has reached my ears. But, to resume, I now come to something that will startle and amaze even your philosophic soul. The boys returned that evening in the dusk. They had seen several seals, and had got a shot at one without doing any execution. I was rather surprised at the number of seals seen by the boys, for, though seals were not uncommon on this coast, such a number as my nephews had seen in the same place was something quite unusual. As we sat at the tea-table, while the boys were talking in an animated manner about the events of the afternoon, and while I could hardly for a single instant keep my thoughts SO LOST ON DU-CORRIG. off the lost brothers, I heard Harry say to my wife "And there was one seal, Aunt Mary, and every time he came up there was a ball bobbing in the water behind him, and when he went down it disappeared." Instantaneously the thought sprang into my mind, " Could it be that John Freeman, or John and Edward, were signalling to us by means of that seal ? " The supposition was, of course, absurd and far-fetched. How could they catch a seal, in the first instance? Nevertheless, the appear- ance of a seal swimming about with some- thing attached to it was in itself startling enough. " I will go out with you in the morning," I said. " That seal we must shoot." Early next day, though the wind had risen and the sea was rough, my nephews and I took boat together at the Shady Coos and rowed out. Between the coos and Du-Corrig we saw some half-dozen seals. Several times I had a good A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER. 91 opportunity of shooting one of them, but did not shoot. The seal I wanted was not visible. We came home for early dinner and went out again immediately after. The boys, who now knew what I wanted, and who were not short- sighted like myself, kept a sharp look-out for the seal of which I was in quest. As we moved slowly along, Joseph said " There is a seal lying on the Corrig-a- skame rock ; that may be it, for I remember it was a small one. Do you see anything behind him, Harry ? " "No," said Harry, "but it is hard to see anything in the place where he is lying. When he begins to move we can see the ball better, for it will hop and jump somewhere behind him." " Eow on very slowly, lads," said I. We were coming from the east, and the seal was lying on the rock with its head to the west. The wind, too, was blowing from that direc- tion. Corrig-a-skame was a long black rock covered 92 LOST ON DU-CORBIG. literally all over with little mussels growing as thick as grass. It was invisible at high water, but at low tide stood out pretty well, and resem- bled the back of a small whale. The name means " The Eock of the Leap." Some active wight in old times had sprung from the corrig to the cliff, or from the cliff to the corrig. It is a common name for such rocks on the west coast. Almost every league of the coast exhibits somewhere a Corrig-a-skame, or a rock called after somebody's leap Lem-Con, or Lem-Cathal, i.e., Con's Leap, Cathal's Leap, etc. I bade the boys wrap their handkerchiefs round the leather of the oars to deaden the sound of the rowing, and went to the bow with my rifle. The boys sitting stern ward of their oars so as to keep their eyes on the seal, rowed gently forward. " I am sure it's the same," whispered Harry, who was just behind me ; " and I think I see the ball too. Yes, it is ! " he added, " and I see the ball. Fire at him now, uncle ! " A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER. 93 While I was trying to get a steady aim, which was difficult owing to the rocking of the boat, the creature suddenly turned its head, saw us, and commenced bounding and flapping for- wards along the length of the rock, while behind it, as it moved swiftly along, a round ball jumped too. I fired and missed. The creature sent forth a loud mewing sort of cry and splashed into the water on the further side. " It has left the ball behind ! " cried the two boys together in great excitement. The truth was that the ball had been caught in some cleft so that the string which connected it with the animal had been broken. None of us saw exactly how it happened, but the creature was gone and the ball remained behind. I could not see it now myself, as it was no longer in motion, but the boys did. We rowed up to the rock, but the surf all around it was so great that we could not land. The wind was steadily rising and the sea beginning to run unpleasantly high. My boat, too, was small and light, not intended to stand rough weather. The tide, 94 L08T ON DU-COERIG. however, was flowing, and in a short time I knew that some wave would sweep the ball off the rock. We kept the boat's head to the wind for about three-quarters of an hour, and at last had the pleasure of seeing one large wave cany the ball clear back off the rock, and a little later the ball had disengaged itself from the surf. You can imagine with what delight I took this waif into my hands. Though there was little rational ground for such a belief, I felt an assurance amounting to conviction that I had in my hands the explanation of the mysterious tragedy. The ball was a small bladder apparently a sheep's bladder and was very tightly fastened at the mouth with whip-cord, or strong fishing-line. When the boys looked to see me open it I did nothing of the kind. I bade the boys row, went myself to the tiller, and turned the boat's head home. I had stayed in the vicinity of Corrig-a- skame too long, and I knew it. I knew thai- good steering and good luck too were now A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER. 95 required in order to enable us to make my coos. I did not open the bladder, partly because I did not desire to remain in this jeopardy a moment longer than was necessary ; and partly because I wished in the event of an accident befalling us, that the unopened bladder and its contents should still be left swimming. The situation, indeed, was momentarily becoming more serious. The wind increased to a gale, and the huge waves lifted the little boat and propelled her forward like a chip. I feared to bring her broadside to the wind and waves, yet that was necessary in order to get into the Shady Coos. So I steered past it and let her drive forward to the Basin, a mile further on, the entrance to which was wide, and did nofc offer such a sharp angle to be turned as did my own little cove. However, not to be tedious, when I have so many infinitely more important things to relate, we made the Basin in safety and drew up our boat on the coastguard's slip. Bidding the boys say nothing to anyone about our waif, we three 96 LOST ON DU-GORRIG. started for home. The bladder was in my top- coat pocket, and I kept my hand upon it during the walk. I was in a fever of excitement and expectation. When I got home I went straight into my office by myself, locked the door, cut open the cord which bound the mouth of the bladder, ripped the skin up carefully, or as carefully as I could, with my penknife, and from the interior took out half a sheet of note-paper. On one side was writing in ink. It was the conclusion of a letter of no importance ; indeed, it was a tradesman's letter, and signed " John Costello," a musical-instrument merchant in our county town. On the other side were characters in red, written with some blunt instrument, like the pointed end of a match or bit of timber, and at foot of the writing in larger letters were two names : JOHN FREEMAN. EDWARD FREEMAN. each name in different hand- writing and repre- senting the signatures of the lads, which I knew. A SECOND AND BETTER LETTER. 97 The body of the red writing was Edward Free- man's. It was to the following effect : " We are here at the bottom of the Devil's Parlour. There is a way right down to us. Most of Charley's loaves have come down. We came in by the square hole high up in the sea-cliff. Both well. JOHN FREEMAN. EDWARD FREEMAN." By the " square hole ! " the piast's hole ! who could have thought it? The little black spot far away up in the face of the cliff. And yet it was through this aperture when he had been lowered by ropes from the cliff's top that I despatched my sub- cons table, Mulvaney. Mul- vaney had then explored with torchlights and shouting the whole interior of the big cavern, of which this was the entrance. Were the boys asleep in some unexplored cavity ? Well, as a fact, they were not ; but I must not anticipate. H 93 CHAPTEE XII. SURPRISING EMPTINESS OF THE DKVII/S PARLOUR. THE murder was out. All was known. Thrust- ing the letter into my pocket, I rushed at the door like a madman, and, forgetting that I had locked it myself, thundered upon it with my fists, roaring, " Saddle Grey Franey ! " It was the name of my fastest horse. " Saddle Grey Franey ! " I continued to roar. The boys, who were all the time in the passage outside my door, clamoured in reply. One of them seemed to run off into the yard shrieking out my mes- sage. My wife and the servants came to the door of the office. In short, it seemed as if the whole household had gone suddenly mad. Of course, what I describe here only took a few seconds to pass. I opened the door and rushed along the pas- sage, not caring whom I threw down, through the kitchen, out into the yard, and straight to EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR. 99 the stable I ran. There already my orderly and Joseph, working as for life and death, were saddling and bridling Grey Franey. In another moment I was on his back, without my hat, tearing down the avenue, and then along the road which led to the Rectory. I was aware of people standing here and there with scared faces, but little I cared for that. Since I was born, I was never so mad as that day, nor if I live for a thousand years could I be so again. I took Franey at a leap over the avenue gate of the Eectory, and galloped up to the house, shouting as I did so, " They are found ! " The avenue is a short one. My voice could have been heard from the gate in every room of the house, and was. No com- mander in the hottest moment of battle ever roared to his men as I did that day, as I galloped up to Mr. Freeman's hall door. Everyone there knew the significance of my wild shoutings. " They are found ! " could refer only to the two lost ones. Mrs. Freeman rushed from the hall door before I reached it. She raised her H 2 100 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. hands to the sky, as if in prayer, then sank on her knees and fell forward. The boy Charley came after and then the servants. After all came Mr. Freeman, his face as white as paper, but his manner calm and collected. Through the wood and shrubbery several men came rush- ing and tumbling, and behind me up the avenue others who had followed me along the road. In a few words I told Mr. Freeman all. " Have you the letter ? " he said. When I showed it to him he looked down first at the signatures, then read the letter, and handed it back to me without a word ; but the look that was in his face what pen could interpret ? Cer- tainly not mine. 1 did not wait an instant longer, but galloped back straight to my own house. I had recovered my self-possession. On the way I met the boys and the orderly, and after that three of my men wearing their usual cast iron expression, and striding quietly in the direction taken by their insane officer. Indeed I am much too excitable to command a force whose gravity would put the Spaniard to shame. EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR. 101 As it was now drawing towards dusk, and various preparations and arrangements had to be made, I postponed the descent 4}li', next morning. I procured ropes that, night, ( f Torn the village. I sent for a man/-no%v' 'a'fariai-' labourer in the neighbourhood, but who I knew had formerly worked in mines in Cornwall, and consulted him about the best means of descent. He went from me to the forge of the village blacksmith, who under his directions made that night a sort of iron stirrup to be attached to the rope's end. I set the boys to make torches of splintered bog-wood. Harry, however, who was ingenious, provided besides sods of turf soaked in paraffin oil. These stuck on the ends of spits, he assured me, would make a grand blaze. We tried one and found it excellent. The news flew like wild-fire over the country, and those who held by ihepiast theory were put to shame. Crowds of people came about the house, till the nuisance reached such dimensions that I ordered my men to clear them away, which they did with difficulty. 102 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. The public-houses in Dunbeacon were full that night, and the publicans did a roaring trade. *% I nominated .the men who were to proceed with me in the morning to the Devil's Parlour, ordered item ito :be ic. readiness an hour before dawn, and strictly commanded them to tell no one. I did not go to bed at all that night, though I may have dozed a little by the office fire. At five I woke up the boys. At six my party and none but my party being assembled, we started, well provided with strong ropes, candles, torches, paraffin-steeped turves, lucifer matches, etc. I had with me, too, a flask of brandy and sandwiches. I did not know in what exhausted condition I might find the lost ones. It was quite plain now that from the cleft called the Devil's Parlour there were two ways leading down -one a blind alley ending in the small chamber, the same that had been explored by Edward Freeman, the other, which was the true entrance, conducting into some great sub- terranean cavern, to which there were two openings one here on the hillside, the other the EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR. 103 square opening in the sea-cliff, viz., the hole out of which Crohoor-beg's imaginary piast had pro- jected itself in that very remarkable and terrible manner, when she devoured the Lan-beg men. Arrived at the spot we finished our prepara- tions and waited for the light, for it was still dark. It was not raining, but the weather was wild, and a strong gale blew from the west. I bade a man who had been with Edward Free- man show me the place where he had made the descent. Avoiding this, I put my foot in the stirrup and bade them lower away. I had round my neck, fastened by a strap, a bag con- taining half a dozen of Harry's peculiar torches, and in my hands, which clasped both it and the rope, a long spit to serve as a handle for those torches. or a short time I had to keep myself away from the rock with my second foot, that which was not in the stirrup. Presently I felt myself swinging in mid-air and in black dark- ness, and certainly in some vast hollow. In a few minutes more I should be clasping the hands of the poor lost lads. 104 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. Then I shouted. Vast hollow echoes and reverberations, travelling through what seemed interminable spaces of endless galleries, re- sponded to my shout echoes and reverberations, and nothing else. That surprised me, but did not much surprise me. The cavern was plainly enormous, and there were far-away winding corridors into which my voice might not travel. Moreover, the boys might be, and probably were, asleep. "We will soon find them and wake them up," I said. I continued at intervals to shout " Jack ! '' " Ned ! " and as loudly as I could roar. Still there came no response but the huge echoes, which now sounded in my ears like the laughter and mockery of subterranean giants. Whether I was descending or not I could not tell. Above me it was as dark as below, and of course I had long since ceased to hear the voices of those at the cave's mouth, and the running of the rope over, the block of timber which my miner had laid on the edge of the precipice. No doubt I EMPTINESS OF THE DEVWS PARLOUR. 105 was descending, but for all I could feel or per- ceive I might be fixed and stationary in the darkness or even ascending. The minutes now began to seem like hours. Should I ever reach the bottom of this awful abyss ? And to think that those pleasant young friends of mine, so gay, bright, and good- natured, so full of life, vigour, and activity, should be immured here one of them for many months ! Again and again I shouted : " Jack ! Ned ! Ned ! Jack ! Are you there ? Hullo ! hullo ! " and still no sound reached my ears but the mocking laughter of the huge, gaunt, and supernatural echoes, which seemed to grow greater as I descended, and rolled like thunder round the cavern. At last I heard a sharp click under my feet and experienced a soft shock. I was on the bottom. The click was the noise of my iron stirrup striking on rock or stone. Still keeping my foot in the stirrup, I threw off my bag of turves, opened it, stuck one on the point of my spit, struck a match, and ignited the 106 LOST ON DTJ-G011RIG. torch. It sent out a great blaze, but revealed, where I stood, nothing but great boulders, and on one side the walls of the cavern, rising sheer and black. I gave the preconcerted signal two strong jerks at the rope which was at once drawn up. The rope and stirrup looked very curious dangling there above my head as they disap- peared into the thick and black darkness. I continued to shout at intervals, but eventually desisted until the coming of my assistants. Either the Freemans were sound asleep, or were in some far gallery of the cavern beyond the reach of my voice ; or they were now terrible thought ! beyond the reach of human help, and we were too late perhaps only a few hours too late. The next to descend was my head constable ; then, in succession, the two boys, Harry and Joseph, then my orderly, and last, a sub-con- stable named Mulvaney, the same who formerly went down into Curry's Window. These and no more I had permitted to descend. I bade "IT SENT OUT A GREAT BLAZE" (p. 106). *' 5 '' - ' . . . 'i-::rl!JA.' EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR. 107 the orderly remain with the rope and keep his torch burning there. All together now we raised our voices and shouted as loud as we could bawl, and did so again and again. Save the echoes, now grown more vast and appalling, there was no response. I was be- coming more and more alarmed. If the boys were alive they must have heard that shout. The part of the cavern in which we found our- selves seemed to be a long and not very wide galley. We explored this to the end, and, as we had plenty of torches, the whole floor of the gallery was brilliantly illuminated. Not a thing out of the common could escape our notice here. Strewn on the floor were several of poor Charley's cakes. We came to the end of this gallery, turned back, passed the orderly where he stood beside the rope with his torch burning in his hand, and after a. while found ourselves in a much vaster space, the roof of which even the combined light of our torches did not reveal at all. On one side of this space there was a pool of 108 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. agitated water, to which the floor of the cavern sloped rapidly. In its vicinity, and running somewhat in the same direction as that which we had already explored, ran another great gallery, the roof of which we could see. This also we now explored yard by yard, scrutinising the floor carefully as we went. Unlike the other, which ended in a mere wall of rock, this gallery ended in a great pool or pit of madly- hoiling water. We returned to that great central space from which these galleries branched, and explored it foot by foot. Here we made the first discovery. It was my nephew, Harry, who made it viz., traces of a fire. On a level rock, not only were there all the signs of a hearth, but in its vicinity an enormous heap of ashes. It was plain that this fire had been burning many months. After the excitement which attended this discovery, and the consultation which succeeded it, we moved forward. In short, we explored step by step and foot by foot every portion of the cave up to the entrance in EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PAELOUR. 109 the sea-cliff, by which they had come in, without finding the lost ones. We discovered many traces of them bones of the sheep from which the bladder had been extracted, crumbs of bread near that hearth-place, and other signs and tokens, but alive or dead the Freemans were not there. We learned, too, how they had been trapped how, having got in, they were unable to get out again ; and also indications of their pathetic efforts to climb out of their trap. Many signs and tokens of the recent presence of the brothers, and especially of the long-continued residence there of poor John Freeman, we found there, but not what we wanted to find themselves. Again and again we searched the vast cavern through and through, expecting now only to find their bodies sunk in some cleft of the great boulders with which the cavern seemed filled, but our search was vain. As our investigations became closer and more minute, we discovered various other relics and signs of the presence of the brothers, but 110 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. neither their bodies nor any opening into which they might have fallen. True, they might have died on the edge of that pool, which evidently communicated with the sea by some passage, for the water there ebbed and flowed ; they might have died on its verge, and their bodies might afterwards have been floated away on the rising tide and borne through that passage. Again, they might have committed suicide by throwing themselves into that boiling chasm in which the second of those galleries I have referred to terminated a chasm like a huge cauldron of madly -seething waters. Yet there was something incredible and quite absurd in both theories. When they wrote that letter and signed it, they were in good health and had plenty of food. That they had plenty of food we knew as well from their letter as from its presence in the cavern, for, besides Charley's cakes, we discovered their storehouse a cranny between two boulders in which were bread and pieces of salted mutton. It was easy to see, too, EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PAULOUR. Ill how that mutton had been procured. Hard by were the bones of a sheep, from which the flesh had been stripped. The sheep had evidently been " clifted,'' to use a local expression that is to say, had fallen from above through the opening into the cavern. We did not disturb that little magazine. In- deed, we added to it, leaving there the whole supply of sandwiches which I had brought with me for the use of my party. The flask of brandy I laid there too. The whole affair of the dis- appearance of the brothers was so extraordinary and surprising, I believed it might eventuate in new and still more extraordinary developments. In presence of this mystery I could now believe in anything. I will not trouble you with an account of our consultations, theories, and guesses. Enough to say that after having spent six or seven hours in that cavern we came up again into daylight, not wiser but sadder men. By this time a huge crowd of people was assembled on the hill-side Mr. and Mrs. Free- man, Sam, and the little boy Charley amongst 112 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. them. I was the last to ascend. I hoped that they might have taken their departure before my arrival, but they had not, and I had the misery and intense misery it was to explain to them the nature and extent of our explor- ations and our vain discoveries. I shall never forget the faces of the bereaved parents as I communicated the melancholy tidings. Mr. Freeman, myself, and the orderly now made the descent. Little Charley, whose narrative stands at the head of this story, and his elder brother Sam, were not permitted to go down. I took Mr. Freeman through the vast cavern and showed him everything. His self- command was extraordinary. His face was pale and rigid, but not another sign of grief was apparent. When he spoke the tones of his voice were low and quiet. There was nothing new to be seen or inferred. At length we all returned to the upper air. As I was parting from the Freeman party the little boy Charley tugged me by the coat. " What is it, Charley ? " I said. EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR. 113 "I am glad you left those things in their storehouse," he answered. " Something told you they are there still, and alive. Something tells me the same/' I started and looked at him, but turned again at once and walked away. Something had not told me they were there ; yet, in- deed, if I had not deposited the basket of sandwiches in that cranny to be eaten by the lost brothers, and that flask of brandy to be drunk by them, why did I leave those things ? The little boy was right before. He knew that his brother John was at the bottom of the Devil's Parlour. Might he not be right now ? I turned round once more. He was standing . in the same place looking after me. His parents were now at some distance Mrs. Freeman leaning heavily on the arm of her husband, and apparently weeping. " I shall try again, Charley," I called out. He nodded approvingly, and darted away after his parents with an animation and cheerfulness which surprised me. " Out of the mouth of i 114 LOST ON DU-COnniG. babes and sucklings," I murmured to myself as I walked home. Later on the same evening I had a singular interview with the singular boy called Sam. I was strolling along a boreen near the Eectory in the dusk, smoking and meditating, when I saw Sam coming towards me. He had a bundle of rabbits slung over one shoulder, and in his hand carried a string of blackbirds, redwings, field- fares, and such-like small deer, for he is a most industrious and successful trapper and maker and setter of the engines which we call "cribs." He was going past me, when I stopped him. " Why don't you speak to me, Sam ? " I said. " You brought a lot of fellows down this morning, and you never asked me," he answered. " Well, I am sorry for that, Sam ; but you shall go down the next time." This seemed to mollify him, but he answered, to my surprise, " I don't think I shall go." " Why ? " said I. " Because I think we're all making a great deal too much fuss about those fellows. When EMPTINESS OF THE DEVIL'S PARLOUR. 115 they're tired of being away they'll come home. You don't know them as well as I do. They're both a little cracked." This was a long speech for Sam. "And Charley?" said I. He stopped and looked at me, but said nothing. I guessed what his thoughts were. He plainly regarded Charley as a prophet, seer, or something of that sort. " Send me word when you are going down," he said, after a short delay, and so stepped through the hedge and took a short way home. I sat up all that night strictly by myself, pondering the extraordinary events of the day. It is now daylight. I have spent the last four hours in writing the official account and this private one. Farewell. i 2 116 CHAPTEE XIII. MR. W ATKINS* NARRATIVE (cO)ldudcd). FOUND ! " December 23. " I HAVE just returned from a second explora- tion of this mysterious cavern, as close and as minute as the first. The loaves which Charley Freeman threw down recently have not been touched, nor the articles which I placed in the cranny. Saw a seal in one of the pools. Per- ceive now how they contrived to send out their letter. I am almost mad with excitement. "SAMUEL WATKINS." (Same to same written in pencil.) "December 24. " Have explored the cave for the third time. The flask is gone ; the sandwich basket opened ; some of the contents eaten or taken away. No sign of the brothers. I am confounded. I have left men in the cavern, and shall keep them there in permanence. The suspense is FOUND! 117 terrible. I am returning to the cave myself. Send this after post-car by orderly. " SAMUEL WATKINS." (Same to same, also in pencil marks.) "December 24. " FOUND ! ! ! " Harry has just run in to say so, and I hear the people shouting. S. W." 118 CHAPTER XIV. EDWARD FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE (continued). EDWARD FREEMAN LOSES HIMSELF, BUT FINDS HIS BROTHER. THE preservation of my brother's life, in the first instance, and his final escape from his place of imprisonment, were both due as I often heard my father assert, and as both Jack and myself also believe to the grace of God, and not the wisdom of man. The police and the coast- guards were quite at a loss all through, and could do nothing. Even the clever detective who came from Dublin and spent a fortnight here observing and considering, went away again in a sort of passion. It was the extraordinary vision seen by my little brother Charley that led him to roll loaves into the place where Jack was really imprisoned, and so perhaps saved his life. Finally I myself found out the secret of his EDWARD FREEMAN LOSES HIMSELF. 119 imprisonment not by any wise calculation, but from a sort of inspiration which came to me quite unsolicited. One day shall I ever forget it ? a whimsical thought, but really a prompting of Providence, came into my mind. It was just before breakfast, and as I sat balancing a spoon on the edge of a tea- cup and thinking about Jack. Might not something happen, or some idea strike me, if I were to go to Du- Corrig fishing, just as my brother did ? When I lost an arrow I used to come back to the spot whence I shot it and shoot another in the same direction and with equal force in order to find the first. It was this that put me in mind of the plan I was now about to execute. I said nothing about it to anyone, but tak- ing my rod set off for Du-Corrig. I fished care- lessly, or pretended to fish, for some time. Then I got tired. " This," I said, " is perhaps how Jack felt six months ago. Fish not taking, nothing to do ; I will try another rock ; but 120 LOST ON DU-OORRIG. there are none here on the right, only the sheer wall of cliff try leftwards then." I clambered along here till I came to a deep fissure in the cliff-side. It ran sheer down to the sea really a rather horrible chasm, or long and profound cleft, at the bottom of which, the sullen waters seemed talking to themselves. I had already explored this cavern by sea in my far- extended searches for Jack, having sculled a boat through it from end to end, for it was too narrow for rowing. I was on the point of turn- ing back, for it never occurred to me that any one would be so mad as to try and cross it. Where I now stood it was too wide to leap across, but as I looked up and down, I saw a place where an active leaper, gifted with a good deal of nerve, or rather afflicted with a sudden attack of lunacy, might leap over it. The cleft was not indeed so very wide at this point, but the narrowness of the foot-hold at the other side, and the darkness and depth of the abyss below, brought the consequences of failure before the imagination in a somewhat appalling EDWARD FREEMAN LOSES HIMSELF. 121 manner. Moreover, beyond that little foot-hold there seemed nothing but the sheer cliff. Still keeping my rod in my hand I leaped it, right glad to find that my foot did not slip on the narrow, sloping ledge at the other side. Just then the conviction started suddenly into my mind that I was on Jack's traces. My heart beat so that I could hear it, and I had to stand still for a considerable time before its beatings and my general agitation would allow me to go on. I was now on the side of an almost sheer cliff, one which when seen from the water seemed quite sheer and untraversable ; but I found a little ragged ledge leading onward and upward. One part of it was very dangerous, but after passing this I came upon rough craggy ground, quite easy to get over. This rough way led steadily upwards along the face of the cliff; by it alone was the rock traversable, and it was not wide. If Jack came along this cliff at all I should now find him or his body. I went on and on for nearly a mile the little ledge being always traversable and at last, quite 122 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. suddenly, arrived at a black opening in the face of the cliff, which I had never noticed before. I may add that, unlike Jack, I did not care for sea- fishing, was seldom on the water, and had never scanned our cliffs with his hawk's eye and inquiring mind. As I stood in the mouth of this cave I was too filled with hope and fear to cry out. I stood there on the flat sill for a long time. Then I heard the sound of feet, as if someone was stepping briskly over rocks, and even springing actively from one to another, though all was dark within. Then a cheery whistle sounded in the interior. The air was " Yilikins and His Dinah." Well I knew who whistled. It was either Jack or his ghost. There was a smooth incline of rock sloping inwards just in front of me. Crying out I know not what, I slid, or even cast myself, down this incline. I heard Jack roar at me to stay back, but I could not, for the incline rapidly grew steeper, till at last it was nearly sheer. So I came EDWARD FREEMAN LOSES HIMSELF. 123 tumbling down, and fell and rolled over something soft. In a moment I was on my feet again, and found myself in my brother's arms. I think we must have both cried aloud, weeping for joy. Certainly neither of us could speak for a long time. As soon as we recovered ourselves Jack brought me round his vast domain, relating all his history as we went, while I told him all that had happened in the outer world. Though I too was now trapped and a prisoner, I did not mind it in the least. I was surprised and delighted with all I saw : Jack's tame seals ; his fire burning so mysteriously in the huge darkness ; the- re- flections on the rock- walls of the prison and on the Seals' Pool ; the enormous echoing corridors of the cavern ; the great central space where he had taken up his abode ; two galleries [Here I must cut short Edward Freeman's narrative and invite the reader's attention to John Freeman's account of all his adventures 124 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. and of what he had endured and dared in this great underground prison. We must, of course, to fully unravel the details, go back to the beginning, that is, to the day of John Freeman's mysterious disappearance. EDITOR.] 125 CHAPTER XV. JOHN FREEMAN'S NARRATIVE. now HE CAME TO CURRY'S WINDOW. [So far as the reader is concerned there is an end now of the mystery. Henceforth for a good while we shall be concerned only with John Freeman's account of the extraordinary shifts and lucky accidents by which he contrived not only to remain alive in this cave for so many months, but to retain his health and spirits to such a degree that when his brother Edward at last hit upon him, in the manner just described, he was whistling lustily, and was plainly in no way discouraged or cast down. For myself, I can say that I have been far more deeply interested in Mr. John Freeman's account of his life in the cavern than in any other portion of the whole story. EDITOR.] It was half-past three when I reached Du- (Jorrig. I fished for a good while without even 126 LOST ON DU-COR11IG. a bite. A boat, which was locally known as " the old rake," rowed past me. The men in it were going to a noted " bream-rough " some miles further up the coast. I hailed them as they passed. I continued fishing for about half an hour after this without success. Then I wearied of the task, and began to cast about for something to do till sunset, at which time the pollock would begin to take a fish that gives good sport. I thought of exploring the cliffs which lay eastward from Du-Corrig. When last I had clambered along these cliffs I was stopped by a gap across which I feared to spring lest I should not be able to return. That was two summers since, and I wished to see whether it looked as formidable to me now as it did then. The only real object of interest in these cliffs was a small square aperture at a great height from the water. I had often noticed this aperture, which from the sea looked only a little square black spot. No one in the neighbour- hood knew anything about it. But once, while out with an ancient fisherman from an adjoining JOHN FREEMAN AT CURRY'S WINDOW. 127 island, I was told by him that it was the mouth of a haunted cave, and that it was unlucky to have anything to do with it. Indeed, it was difficult to see how a person could come at it at all, for it was quite unattainable from the sea or from any other side, so sheer and smooth seemed the cliff in which it was situated. This old fisherman called it " Curry's Window," and spoke of Curry as a great smuggler. Curry, he said, was so active that he would take a barrel of rum under one arm and a barrel of rum under the other, and, though weighted so, spring from the deck of his schooner and fly clean through the aperture into the cave. When I made some chaffing remark about the old smuggler's extraordinary activity, he only said that Curry was known to be " a clever man," and no more would he say. I asked about Curry on another occasion, but he not only refused to add anything, but rather angrily denied that he had ever spoken to me about Curry at all. All this naturally excited my curiosity. Knowing that I was much bigger 128 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. and stronger than when I last made the attempt, I resolved to try again. I easily reached the gap to which I refer. Here there was a split in the cliff reaching down to the sea. Far below in the darkness the sullen waters were murmuring. At the other side there was a good foothold, but it was decidedly lower than the point from which one would have to spring in order to reach it ; consequently the return leap would be more difficult, and it was this as well as the horrible depths below and the gulping and gurgling of the dark waters which had daunted me before. I perceived now that it was really no such wonderful leap after all, and surprised at my poltroonery on the former occasion, I sprang over, and then sprang back again with com- parative ease. After this proof of my prowess I resolved to forego the rest of the exploration till next day, intending to bring my brother Ned with me. Though two years younger he was a better leaper than myself, being slight and long-legged, whereas I was made rather for strength than activity. My evil genius, JOHN FREEMAN AT CURRTS WINDOW. 129 however led me on, and the thought of the two hours yet wanting till sunset and the time when pollock would begin to rise. The exploration did not indeed promise much, for the cliff as seen from Du-Corrig, as well as from the sea, seemed one sheer unbroken wall of rock, apparently offering no foothold to any creature less prehensile than a fly, yet immediately before me there was a very narrow traversable ledge. In traversing this I saw it would be an advantage to have my rod with me in order to steady my footsteps. I returned for it to Du-Corrig, and a third time cleared the chasm, and presently en- countered a piece of cliff-walking which could not possibly have been managed without such aid. There was a ledge, indeed, but the cliff above it was so sheer, or rather inclined forward so much, that some slight support for the climber on the seaward side was necessary in order to get along here. The iron spike at the end of the rod supplied a good rest for me as I went. 130 LOST ON DU-CORRIG. Passing this dangerous point I was delighted to find that the cliff was still traversable, though with difficulty, and I had frequently to crawL Yet I continued to get forwards and also up- wards. In this manner I progressed about a mile, not knowing whither that traversable ragged ledge led me, but hoping it might be to Curry's Window. As my progress was slow I should upon ordinary evenings have been per- ceived by some passing boat, but the people were at this time very busy about hay, and " the old rake " was the only one which, on this unlucky evening, had put forth from our little harbour, " the Basin," as we used to call it. Eventually I found myself all of a sudden looking into a considerable cave in the cliff side Curry's Window, as I plainly perceived. I was surprised to find it so large, and also that it was not square, but irregularly arched. I used to think that the famous smuggler would have found a difficulty in rolling even one barrel at a time through the aperture. The delusive appearance of perfect squareness JOHN FREEMAN AT CURRTS WINDOW. 131 had, of course, been caused by distance, for the aperture was very high up in the cliff. It, however, resembled a window in this respect, that the sill, so to speak, was perfectly smooth, flat, and horizontal, as if the work of man's hands. The rest of the aperture was very jagged and ragged. I also saw that the rock on the inside was smooth, and sloped away from the sill, gently at first, but afterwards at an angle of forty-five degrees, or thereabouts. The sun had now got round the shoulder of the hill, whose base was supplied by these cliffs ; consequently I could see little or nothing of the interior of the cave, but thought that I could perceive the bottom at a short distance. . I pushed the butt end of the fishing rod before me, and found that this was so. There, about six feet below me, was the bottom of the incline, and apparently the floor of the cave. j 2 132 CHAPTER XVI. TRAPPED. I SAT on the edge of the sill and slid down, expecting to land safely on the spot which I had poled and probed with the butt end of my rod, but it proved to be a false bottom, or not the bottom at all. Whatever was the obstruction at this point, it gave way before my descending weight. It was, in fact, an accumulation of debris gathered around certain rotten branches that had stuck here in the entrance, lying trans- versely along the incline. I broke through all this with a loud crackling of broken timber, and continued to slide or, indeed, rush down a still steeper incline descending into the darkness; and when I believed that I was being precipi- tated into eternity, fell into a soft mass of what seemed dry sea-weed, without sustaining any injury. " Facilis descensus" I cried, as I landed on "IT GAVE WAY BEFORE MY DESCENDING WEIGHT" (p. I