EXCHANGE HISTORY OF THE HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY DURING THE PERIOD 1840-1890. BY DANIEL WJ BAKER. Reprinted from the Boston Evening Traveller. CAMBRIDGE. 1890. w HISTORY OF THE HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY DURING THE PERIOD 1840-1890. BY DANIEL W. BAKER. Reprinted from the Boston Evening Traveller. . U'HIVBJ f/r? CAMBRIDGE. 1890. PREFACE. A CAREFUL study of the early history of the Harvard College Observatory has been made by Mr. DANIEL W. BAKER, Many facts were thus brought to light which had not appeared in print. A series of newspaper articles was accordingly prepared, which were published in the Boston "Evening Traveller" on six successive Saturdays, be- ginning August 2, 1890. Much of this material appearing to be of sufficient value for preservation in a more permanent form, it has been reprinted in the present pamphlet, with slight alterations, and with the addition of the illustrations given on page 25. The parts numbered IV. and V. originally appeared together as a single article. Reproductions have been made of some of the illustrations. The articles were originally addressed, not to professional astronomers, but to the general public, and are to be regarded as a popular description of the work accomplished at the Harvard College Observatory during the first fifty years of its existence. EDWARD C. PICKERING. HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY, September 13, 1890. r Q nn ci T> v 1 1 b 1 U Jx I u 1, where a medal was awarded for it. It had the highest award of the Massachusetts Mechanic Associ- ation, a gold medal. It was adopted at the Greenwich observatory soon after Mr. Bond's exhibition of his model, and speedily throughout Europe. Soon after the electrical experiments ol 1848 at the observatory the wire was put into use to transmit to Boston and different railway points, signals giving the true local time, these signals being electrically responsive to the movement of an astronomical clock in the observa- tory, the method of transmission being that of the "circuit interrupter." This system was at once adopted in England, wire connections being made with a clock in Greenwich Observatory. This time service of the Harvard Observatory, though continued during the interme- diate period, was not organized as at present until 1872. In 1852 the officers of Harvard Obser- vatory co-operated with Captain Charles Wilkes in experiments for ascertaining the velocity of sound under different atmospheric conditions. In these tests cannon were fired near the observatory, at the arsenal in Watertown, at the navy HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 19 yard in Charlestown and at Fort Inde- pendence in the harbor, the central ob- serving point being the cupola of the State House in Boston, where Captain Wilkes took his station. These experi- ments had immediate reference to a re- duction into proper form of data obtained by the exploring expedition, wherein Captain Wilkes had caused surveys of islands and groups in remote seas to be made by sound. In these surveys, dis- tancas between points whence angles were projected were determined by the firing of cannon at those points. In 1855 an endowment of $10,000 was made by ex-President Quincy as a me- morial of his father, Josiah Quincy, a patriot of the revolution. This fund was specifically applied to the publication of annals of the observatory. The first voiume was issued in 1856 and comprised a review of the work of the preceding years, so that the series of which it is the initial number makes a continuous record from the beginning. The series now numbers nearly 25 volumes. The decease of Prof. W. C. Bond occurred Jan. 29, 1G59. IV. George Phillips Bond was the second director of Harvard College observatory, being the successor of his father, Prof. W. C. Bond. The date of his appoint- ment was 1859. He was born in Dor- chester, Mass., May 20, 1825, and gradu- ated at Harvard in 1845. Thenceforth until his decease Feb. 17, 1865, he was in the constant service of the observatory. Prior to his taking the chief office his labors as assistant had gained for him a professional reputation ; he had shared with his father the heavy task of organ- izing the observatory and carrying it on with slender means; he was familiar with its routine, and both by academical and practical training was peculiarly qualified for the position. His professional record therefore is not to be limited to his own term as director. The computations required in the prepar- ation of the three early volumes of the annals were to a great extent his work, and those pertaining to the chronometric expeditions between Boston and Liver- pool, were wholly Dy him. He was the discoverer of the da.k interior ring of Saturn, one of tlie first revelations of the great telescope, and discoverer also, as already stated, of ten comets within a brief period of years. In this cometary work it was his practice to sweep the whole visible heavens once every month. His observations of Saturn led to the adoption of a new theory as to the con- stitution of the rings. During his term systematic observations were made of certain nebula?, particularly that in Orion. He conducted a series of zone observations of faint stars near the equa- tor, prepared a plan of observation and reduction, and with his own hand gradu- ated the mica scales used in the work. In 1860 he made an investigation of the brightness of certain celestial objects, including the moon and the planets, the results of which have a special value but are not identified with the Harvard pho- tometrioal series of later years, which relates to fixed stars only. During his term the formation of a star catalogue was begun, the observations being made with the meridian circle and in right as- cension only, and much progress was made in picturing celestial objects by the camera, the process having, with the dis- use of Daguerre's particular mtthod, gained the generic name of photography. The prestige of the beginning and early successes of astronomical photogra- phy attaches to the administration of the senior Bond ; but his son shared fully in the labors of thought, contrivance and manipulation by which the original ex- periments were conducted, and in appre- ciation of the future possibilities to sci- ence in this new method of observation. One evidence of this appears in a paper read by the younger Mr. Bond before the American Academy on May 12, 1857, the immediate occasion for its presentation being a most significant discovery made at the observatory a few days earlier. The paper says: "Daguerreotype images of the star Vega were obtained at the observatory of Harvard College on July 17, 1850, and subsequently impres- sions were taken from the double star Castor, exhibiting an elongated disc, but no separation of its two components." "These were the first, and until very recently, the only known instances of the application of photography to the delineation of fixed stars. A serious diffi- culty was interposed to further progress by the want of suitable apparatus for HISTORY OF THE communicating uniform sidereal motion to the telescope. "This has been supplied by replacing the original clock of tiie great equatorial of the observatory by a new one, oper- ating on the principle of the soring gov- ernor. Immediately upon its comple- tion, a new series of experiments was commenced. These have been success- ful in transferring to the plate by the collodian process, images of fixed stars and eleventh magnitudes as has already been done for those between the first and fifth, the extension given to our present means of observation would be an ad- vanco in the science of stellar astron- omy of which it would scarcely be possi- ble to exaggerate the importance/' Mr. Bond made important contribu- tions to the literature of the science both in its mathematical and practical depart- ments. Among the more notable THE GOLD MEDAL; REVERSE SHOWING SIR WILLIAM HERSCHEL'S 40-FOOT TELESCOPE. to the fifth magnitude, inclusive, with singular and unexpected precision. The most remarkable instances of success are the simultaneous impressions of the group of stars composed of Mizar of the second magnitude, its companion of the fourth and Alcor of the fifth magnitude. The following measurements of the an- gular distance of the companion from Mizar were taken from the plates." A tabulated statement follows in the paper, giving dates from April 27 to May 8, with measurements from 13 photographic negatives produced on the respective dates. The mean for dis- tance is 14.49 seconds, and for angle of position, 147. 80. For the same stars ob- served in the usual way, Struve's mean of six observations is, for distance, 14.40 seconds; for positions, 147. 40. Mr. Bond's comments are : "The pho- tographic method has thus in its first efforts attained the limit of accuracy, be- yond which it is not expected the other can ever be sensibly advanced. "Should photographic impressions be obtained from stars between the sixth of the former was a paper on cometary calculations and the method of mechanical quadratures, valuable in vari- ous respects, and notable in having an- ticipated an important improvement afterward given independently by Encke ; also a paper on the use of equivalent factors in the method of least squares. He wrote a monograph covering observa- tions of Donati's comet of 1858, for which he was awarded the gold medal of the Eoyal Astronomical Society and was the first of his countrymen to obtain that dis- tinction. He began a paper on the nebula in Orion, which he did not live to complete, though during his prolonged last illness he continued his labors upon it, and dictated to an amanuensis long after strength to write had gone from him. This paper was afterwards finished by Prof. T. H. Safford, then of Harvard, now of Williams College observatory. A biographer says of Mr. Bond: '"Science to him was not a pastime but a serious calling, to be pursued with the utmost conscientiousness and singleness of pur- HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 21 pose. That he did so much and aid it so well, during the few years allotted to him, must have been partly owing to an PRESIDENT JOSIAH QUINCY. extreme reluctance to dissipate his pow- ers by beginning new works while the old were still unfinished." He received the honorary degree of A. M. from Har- vard in 1853. V. Joseph Winlock was the third director of Harvard College observatory, being appointed in 1866. He was born in Shelby county, Ky., Feb. 6, 1826; he graduated at Shelby College in 1845, and was professor of mathematics and as- tronomy there until 1852. He was subse- quently in the service of the Naval Observatory at Washington, and, still later, instructor in mathematics at the Naval A cademy at Annapolis. At differ- ent dates, he was superintendent of the work of preparation of the Nautical Al- manac. He continued in office as director of the observatory until his decease, June 11, 1875. His administration appears by the record to have been one of various ac- tivity. A large amount of improved ap- paratus was added to the resources of the observatory, partly by purchase and partly by invention and making on the spot. He kept up the reputation of the observatory, which has never failed from the start, for originality and ingenuity in mechanical devices. It was during his term that the transmission by electricity of the true solar time to railroad centres and business points in all parts of New England became a regular part of the observatory work, and, by the system which he organized, compensation was made by corporations and individuals whose clocks were put into electrical connection with 'that at the observatory. A considerable revenue has thus an- nually been derived. Other electrical ap- paratus of the observatory was modified and improved. A "switch-board," tne device of his predecessor was much elaborated in its mechanism, whereby the electrical current was made more available and all the principal instru- ments were connected at will with the chronographs. In 1868 when he visited Europe he pro- cured the apparatus of a meridian circle of the latest device, the lenses being made in Cambridge. In setting up the instrument he saw opportunity to in- troduce various improvements in me- chanism. These were approved by experience and went into general use elsewhere. Another of his devices was "for the de- termination of absolute personal equa- tion by mechanical means." Other con- trivances, either wholly original or inge- nious modifications of known apparatus, were an attachment to the spectroscope for automatic recording, being a modi- fication of the chronograph : a combina- tion of a stationary plane mirror with a fixed lens of great focal length from 30 to 40 feet for photographing the sun; a later im- provement of this, by which the tele- scope was reduced to a single fixed lens of long focus and small aperture, chro- matic aberration was avoided and the image on the plate could be made as large as was convenient for measuring ; and a change of method by which the sun's image could be taken at the principal focus of the object glass and not beyond an eye-piece used to enlarge the image. In February, 1866, when he took charge of the observatory, the great equatorial was applied to a series of observations of 22 HISTORY OF THE double, arid especially binary stars. This investigation was continued as steadily as circumstances would permit till 1872, and the results appear in the annals. In 1867 the first spectroscope owned by the observatory was imported, and in 1869 another. Two small direct-vision spectro- scopes were also procured during Prof. Winlock's term. In 1870 the new meridian circle, a su- perior instrument, was set up, and on Xov. 10 of that year was begun the series of observations for position of stars in the "Cambridge zone," so called, or that between 50 north and 55 north and over- lapping 10' upon each contiguous zone. The standard in using this instrument was an artificial star produced by lamp- light. During this terra two expeditions were made with apparatus for observing total eclipses of the sun, and in both satisfac- tory results were obtained. On the first occasion, of date Aug. 7, 1869, the station was at Shelbyville, Ky., and on the sec- ond, of date Dec. 22, 1870, at Jerez de la Frontera, in Spain. In 1867 daily obser- vations in terrestrial magnetism were made at the observatory for the purposes of the coast survey. In March, 1869, experiments for determination of longi- tudes were conducted on a continental HARVARD OBSERVATORY STATION IN SPAIN. This survey was a joint enterprise con- ducted by certain of the great observa- tories of the world, that of Harvard being one of the two in this country having a share in the work. On July 4, 1870, was begun a series of photographs of the sun, and the work was continued nearly or quite to the end of Prof. Winlock's term, many hundred photographs being com- prised in the list. In September, 1871, was begun an elab- orate investigation of lunar phenomena, which continued a year. ID 1871 an ar- rangement was made with the coast sur- vey by which a series of photometric ob- servations was carried through, and for this a Zbllner astro-photometer was im- ported. The work wa^ continued three years, though not all o f it at Cambridge. The results are in the annals in 1878. scale, wire connection by relays being made with San Francisco. In these ex- periments apparatus which had been modified by Prof. Winlock was used and by this method, and also by another which was applied, it proved that the time of passage of a signal from Cam- bridge to San Francisco through the wire and six relays was very nearly three- quarters of a second. Between Dec. 13, 1869, and the summer of 1872, electric sig- nals were sent by the Atlantic cable to and from Brest in France, via Duxbury, Mass. The purpose of these tests was to es- tablish with precision the difference of longitude between America and Europe. Prof. Winlock supervised the work of preparing and engraving a series of plates illustrating remarkable celestial HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 23 objects. These gave special value to the volume of annals in which they ap- peared, causing an unprecedented de- mand for copies, so that it is now a rare book. His publications were not numer- ous, but there is no doubt that his scholar- ship, versatility and wide experience would have yielded valuable additions to the literature of science had his life been prolonged. The means at command during his term did not warrant the publication of many volumes of annals. Though for nearly 10 years in office he did not live to PROF. JOSEPH WINLOCK. see any of his own observations pub- lished or even to complete the work of his predecessors. During the term the permanent funds of the observatory were increased by the bequest of James Hay ward $20,000, and that of James Savage $20,000. In 1870 a subscription of $12,450 was completed for purchase of a new meridian circle. In the preceding term a gift of $10,000 was made by William Sturgis for the publication fund. Prof. Winlock had the honorary degree of A.M. from Har- vard in 1868. VI. Edward Charles Pickering, the pres- ent director of the observatory, was ap- pointed in 1876. He was born in Boston and is of the Essex family of the name, Colonel Timothy Pickering being his great-grandfather. He is a graduate of the Lawrence Scientific School of the class of 18ii5. During the next two years he was a teacher of mathematics in that department of Harvard University. Later and up to the time of his appoint- ment as director, he was professor of physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. A system of teaching physics called the "laboratory method" was introduced by him there, and his text-book illustra- tive of the method has to a great extent been adopted by like institutes. Astron- omy, as a department of physics, came into the general course, and the atten- tion necessarily given, for the purposes of instruction in the institute, to the technics of that subject, and to demon- stration, served as preparation and dis- cipline for the official responsibilities which he afterwards assumed. He was a member of the Nautical Al- manac party for observing in Iowa the total solar eclipse of 1869, and was in like service in the following year as a mem- ber of the United States Coast Survey party which observed in Spain a recur- rence of that event. When he came to the directorship he found the observatory to be well equipped as to instruments and its small working force efficiently employed. Their num- ber was but five or six, which was all the means of the institution permitted of. Like pecuniary restrictions continued until 1879, when a subscription was com- pleted providing for the institution, $5000 annually for five years. Since then much larger gifts have been bestowed and the instrumental equipment, in recent years especially, has been what- ever the latest demands or suggestions of science called for ; the observatory staff has been augmented from time to time, till it now numbers about 40 persons, and the field of observation has been extended to include the southern hemisphere of stars. Upon the premises at Cambridge where in 1876 stood only the main observatory and a lesser adjunct structure are now eight or ten others, a cluster of small wooden buildings, domed or otherwise adapted for astronomical uses, eacfi con- taining a costly instrument of the most approved device; and besides these a dwelling house has been transformed into a hall, or rather a workshop of photography, and makes the northern- most structure of the little city of science 24 HISTORY OF THE which has been set upon Summer House hill. Upon Mt. Wilson, in California, in north latitude, and Mt. Harvard, in Peru, in south latitude, stand other un- pretentious buildings, from within which observers of the Harvard corps nightly search through the translucent upper atmosphere of those regions to the re- spective poles. This aggregation of means has yielded ample returns ; to say which is to signify that during the period under consideration the institution has made a noteworthy record, and that its affairs have been guided with befitting skill and judgment. The total permanent funds at the be- ginning of the present term amounted to about $170,000. The subscription for five years was intended for immediate expenditure. At the end of that period a permanent fund of $50,000 was ob- tained in like manner. In 1885 was added to the permanent funds the bequest of Robert Treat Paine of his whole estate, of which $164,198 became at once availa- ble. In 1886 was made the first of a series of annual gifts of large sums of money by Mrs. Anna P. Draper of New York as a memorial of her hus- band, the late Prof. Henry Draper. These gifts have constantly been ap- plied in furtherance of photographical observation, especially in that line of in- vestigation which Dr. Draper himself began in his lifetime. In 3887 the bequest of Uriah A. Boyden, amounting to $238,- 000, became available. This bequest has conditions providing for astronomical work at considerable elevations as free as possible from disturbing or obstruct- ing conditions of atmosphere. The in- come of the Paine fund may be applied generally. In pursuing the inquiries thus sug- gested, and others, the observatory has adhered to its traditions, wherein origi- nal investigation has been directed to the physical rather than the mathematical side of astronomical science. In his first annual report the present director outlined the immediate policy, in the then restricted state of the finances, to be to keep employed chiefly the two most costly and effective instru- ments, the great equatorial and the meridian circle. The latter was already in constant use in the work of the Cam- bridge zone. With reference to the former, the re- port having named the several special- ties which the great observatories of this country had taken, each to itself, said : "Photometry offers a field almost wholly unexplored with large telescopes either in this country or abroad. It has there- fore been selected as that to which the greater portion of the time of our tele- scope will be devoted." The investigation thus entered upon, together with the zone observations just mentioned, and the continuation by ampler and in some particulars radically different methods of investigations in spectroscopy and photography, have given the institution a wide renown. But hardly less conspicuous are certain other achievements in the Ions list which makes the complete record. With- out attempting to give any of these rank, still less to repeat the list, a few may here be mentioned upon the ground of their presumed popular interest. In 1878 the utility of the time signal service was increased by causing a time ball to be dropped every day at exact noon from a conspicuous point in Boston within view of the shipping of the harbor. The time was that of the meri- dian of the State House in Boston. When the standard or 75th meridian time went into general use the practice was con- formed thereto. Indeed, the terms of the proposition might be reversed so as to indicate that, in the final determination, the responsibility was put upon the ob- servatory to lead off in the matter. There had been some discussion in the public prints and elsewhere of the advisa- bility of adopting a common meridian time for large areas. In the report of the observatory for 1878 the theoretical presentation of the case which had been made by those advocating the change was sanctioned, and the new time was recommended as sure to be of public con- venience if generally accepted. General consent was somewhat slow in its mani- festation, but eventually the managers of all the principal railroads of New Eng- land agreed to adopt the plan if the time- signalling system of the observatory should be made to correspond in respect to clock connections, time ball, etc. This was instantly agreed to, and with due prior public notice the new time went into use Nov. 18, 1883, and the Boston noon ball was first dropped on that day at exactly five hours later than the noon of Greenwich. HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 25 HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. HARVARD STATION IN CALIFORNIA. 26 HISTORY OF THE In 1880 the full routine of meteorologi- cal observation was abandoned, as sev- eral institutions were doing like work. The record of the observatory in meteor- ology, which had continuously been kept up for 40 years, was reduced to proper form for printing, and was published in 1889. Certain observations of this kind have, however, been continued in the rec- ord to the present date. In 1888 a plan of co-operation was agreed upon with the X. E. Meteorologi- cal Society and Mr. A. L. Rotch of the Blue Hill, Mass., Observatory, by which their results, which are of a comprehen- sive character, have since been published in the annals of the Harvard Observa- tory. In 1877, in co-operation with Miss Mitchell of Yassar College Observatory and her assistants, observations were made at Cambridge for determining the longitude of the Yassar Observatory. Between Feb. 15, 1879, and Jan. 3, 1880, like observations were made in co-opera- tion with officers of the Winchester Ob- servatory of Yale College to ascertain the longitude of that institution. Be- tween June 2 and June 23, 1883, similar work was done to fix the longitude of McGill Observatory in Montreal. In the summer of 1888 ten evenings were given for observations for the longitude of Smith College in Northampton. The observers were Miss Byrd, teacher of astronomy at that college, and Miss Whitney, professor of astronomy at Yas- sar College. Harvard's contribution in the affair consisted in providing facilities on the spot, including the use of a tran- sit instrument. These are instances, which among others go to show that be cause of infinite painstaking at Harvard in the earlier years it has become the Mecca to which all on this continent who wish to be perfectly assured in the mat- ter of longitude may prudently make a pilgrimage. In 1881 an arrangement was entered into for prompt communication as to unusual celestial phenomena, discoveries, etc., among astronomers in this country and in Europe. A cipher code, the invention of Messrs. S. C. Chandler and John Ritchie, Jr., of the observatory staff, was put into use. It is known as the "Science Observer Code," and as it is superior in accuracy to former codes has been widely recognized. In 1883 Harvard observatory was made the official dis- tributing centre for this class of news, by consent of the Smithsonian Institute, which had previously performed the ser- vice. Upon the occasion of the transit of Mercury across the sun's disk in May, 1878, all the available telescopes of the observatory were put to use. The re- sults, which included many photographs, were satisfactory, considering the un- favorable weather. During the like tran- sit of Yenus, on Dec. 6, 1882, six tele- scopes being in use, large additions were, made to the important data which plane- tory events of this kind may supply. In August, 1886, a small party pro- vided with instruments belonging to the observatory made an expedition to Gren- nada, near the northern coast of South America, for observation of the total solar eclipse of that year. The expedi- tion was in charge of Mr. W. H. Picker- ing, who afterwards became a member of the observatory corps. On Jan. 1. 1889, a large party, under the same direction, observed a recurrence of the event in California. The observa- tions were mainly photographical. Ex- cellent results were obtained in both cases, though less in amount in the former, because of unfavorable weather. Much has been done during the term in comecary investigation, but latterly comets have been observed, as a rule, only immediately upon discovery and towards the end of their visible period, or after they had got beyond the reach of any but the most powerful teles- copes. In the summer of 1883 the director journeyed in Europe and visited the principal observatories there. In the following annual report he names as an important result of his journey the ob- taining of copies of unpublished manu- scripts of Argelander and Sir William Herschel. The former are memoranda of observations of variable stars and the latter of observations made more than 100 years ago of the light of all stars of Flamsteed's catalogue. The work on the Cambridge zone of stars was completed, as respects the pri- mary plan of observation, on Jan. 26, 1879, and at that stage was regarded as one of the largest astronomical under- takings ever carried through in this country. The reduction of the data was accom- plished in 1883, but as was expected, a HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 27 necessity for reobservation appeared in certain cases. This work was done be- tween Oct. 9, 1883 and Aug. 9, 1884. The observer from the beginning had been Prof. William A. Rogers. He resigned his position as assistant professor in the observatory in 1886, but continued to serve as editor of the published results. The whole series makes half a dozen or more volumes ot the annals. The Eu- ropean supervisors of the general under- taking, well pleased, apparently, with the early instalments of manuscript re- turns, assigned to Harvard the work of reobservation of another zone, that be- tween 9 50' south and 14 10' south. This work is still in progress. Each zone comprises about 8000 stars or nearly 17,000 in all. The publications of the observatory during the present term in the form of annals, and as contributions by members of the corps to various journals of sci- ence, have been numerous and extensive. At the beginning of the term but four volumes of annals had been issued, though about an equal number were in some stage of progress in the printers' hands, publication having gone on slow- ly from lack of means. At the pres- ent time the continuous series of 22 vol- umes has been issued, excepting the sec- ond or supplementary parts in two or three instances. These parts are nearly ready, and the manuscript for about half a dozen more volumes in regular succes- sion has, in part or whole, been given to the printer. A review of what has been done during the present term in the departments of photometry, spectroscopy and photogra- phy will be comprised in the next and closing number of this series. VII. Agreeably to the announcement of the annual report of Harvard College Ob- servatory for 1877, as to photometry, a beginning was made by constructing a photometer suitable to be attached to the great telescope. Other photometers have been devised at different times for use independently. One of the earliest was applied during the year beginning Oct. 12, 1877, in measuring the light of all known satellites excepting the two inner ones of Uranus, which are too faint to be discerned, even by the great telecope. The first prolonged observa- tion entered upon was of the eclipses of of Jupiter's satellites. As there are four satellites and as the plane of their orbits is nearly the same as that of the planet itself, eclipses are frequent. The plan proposed the obser- vation of all these eclipses visible during a revolution of Jupiter around the sun, a period of about 12 years. The work was begun June 23, 1878, and has been regularly pursued. The final result will be of the highest value in that, among its utilities it will permit a new and inde- pendent computation to be made of the earth's distance from the sun, which dis- tance is a prime factor in theoretical as- tronomy. Computations hitherto made, based upon data derived from these eclipses, are not authoritative, because of disagree- ments among different observers using different telescopes, and because of de- fects in the method of observation. The director's report for 1878 says: "Errors of this kind are much lessened by photometric observations of the satel- lites as they gradually enter or emerge from the shadow of Jupiter, using the planet itself or another satellite as a stan- dard. Each comparison thus obtained gives an independent determination of the time of the eclipse, free from the errors due to the condition of the air or the power of the telescope employed and less likely to be affected by personal equation than the observation of a disappearance or a reappearance. By the ordinary method an observation during twilight can have little value, while good pho- tometric observations may be made as well then as at any other time. It is even possible to make them before sun- set." In 1879 a work of magnitude was be- gunthe photometric observation of all stars down to those of the sixth masrni- tude visible in this latitude. For greater facility, and particularly to avoid loss of time in identifying stars of small magni- tude, it was decided to make a new de- parture in method and in construction of an instrument. The new instrument was called the meridian photometer, and stars were observed by it only when near the meridian. The position of any star being well known, the time of its ap- pearance in the field of the telescope could be foreseen. 28 HISTORY OF THE Each that was desired for a particular night had, therefore, only to be waited for, not sought for. The original instru- ment consisted of a fixed horizontal tele- scope pointed west and having two ob- jectives. The light of the pole star, which was taken for the standard or unit of meas- urement, was reflected by a prism into one object glass, and that of the star to be measured into the other. The light of the brighter star was then reduced to exactly that of the fainter by the turning sive, between 30 south and the southern pole, was begun. Thus the facts relating to all the stars in the sky of these classi- fications will be embodied in the final re- sult. The record, whicli will comprise sev- eral volumes, one or more of which have already been published, will have an identity throughout as respects the method, the instrument, and the unit of measurement. It will be authoritative as a text book or series of text books, and will enhance the value for reference, HAKVARD OBSERVING STATION AT WILLOWS, CAL., JANUARY 1, 1889. of a screw having a register attached. The indication of the register gave the measure, which was confirmed by repeat- ed observations. Telescopes mounted in the ordinary way continued to be used in other branches of photometric work. The photometric survey of the sixth magnitude and brighter stars was com- pleted Aug. 25, 1881. In 1882 a new and more powerful meridian instrument was constructed and a photometric survey of a list of about 21,000 stars, from the sixth to the ninth magnitude, was entered upon. This work was finished Sept. 29, 1888, and soon afterwards the instrument, with others, was sent to Peru in charge of Mr. S. 1. Bailey of the observatory corps, where, May 11, 1889, a corresponding survey of the stars, from the first to the ninth magnitude, inclu- and comparison of various records of the light of stars, both those of modern and ancient date. The successful working of the two meridian photometers led to the con- struction of one still more powerful, hav- ing an aperture of 12 inches. The first was of 1| inch aperture, and the second of four inches. The three differ somewhat in mechan- ism, but are the same in principle. The 12-inch is called by distinction the "hor- izontal telescope." It will be available in case a photometric survey of stars of fainter magnitudes shall be undertaken, but its use is not limited to photometry. In 1879, a photometer was devised for measuring the light of nebulae, thus ap- plying to these objects and to stars the same unit and scale. In 1881, photo- HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 29 metric observations of certain bright parts of the moon, were mafle for the Selenographical Society of England, the particular parts being selected by that society. It thus was shown that the lunar scale of light in common use may be closely expressed in terms of stellar magnitude, each degree of the lunar scale answering to six-tenths of a mag- nitude. Photometry has been very ex- tensively applied at Harvard in study of variable stars. A history of any department of practi- cal astronomy, written from the point of one of the satellites as thus seen. Five or six different mechanics were employed to drill in a piece of metal a hole, making a true circle, and small enough to pro- duce the equality sought for by suffi- ciently diminishing the light of the planet. It may be remarked that one of those who succeeded best had already, for his own purposes, managed to drill a hole, lengthwise, through a fine cambric needle, making a steel tube of it. What he made for Prof. Pickering was a hole in a steel plate, the diameter of which was one eighteen hundredth HARVARD OBSERVING STATION IN PERU. view of a mechanician, could hardly fail to be of interest. Among the curious ex- periences at Harvard in the line of pho- tometry is one which illustrates this point, and, at the same time, indicates the refinements in observation which are resorted to, and demonstrates one of the utilities of the photometric method. In 1877 announcement was made of the discovery at Washington of two satellites of the planet Mars. The Harvard telescope being applied they were after a little effort descried as two faint points of light, showing no visible disks. To ascertain the diameter of each satellite might therefore seem impossible: but it was done, approxi- mately, by the photometric method. The mechanical problem was to reduce the light of the planet as seen in the telescope to an equality with the light of (1-1800) of an inch. It was so nearly cir- cular that the various diameters, in- cluding errors of measurement, onlv dif- fered one one hundred thousandth (1-100,000) of an inch. Other mechanical devices were resort ed to for corroboration, and the results reached were that the diameter of one of the satellites is about six miles, and that of the other about seven miles. They are the smallest known in the solar system. The availability of the spectroscope in astronomy had early been appreciated by the profession. In experiments in this line it had bsen found that a classifica- tion of the nebulae might be made upon the basis of their spectra. In 1880 the study was carried a stage further at Harvard in ascertaining by the spectro- scope that certain faint objects, which. V^:H~. OV THR rr T- c-tr TV, iJvi 30 HISTORY OF THE by direct vision, had been judged to be stars, are in fact nebulae. In 1881, it was found that the spectroscope is ser- viceable in the discovery of variable stars. Thus incited, a new instrument was imported from London, but it did not prove satisfactory. Nothing of importance appears to have been done in this department thereafter until 1886, when the proposition of Mrs. Draper opened the way to investigation of spectra by aid of photography. For this the 11-inch photographic telescope, which had been used by Dr. Draper, was loaned by Mrs. Draper, who also met the expense of a new mounting and a special observatory, building. 'A begin- ning was made with an eight-inch in- strument, known as the Bache telescope. It is of the pattern described as the "doublet," and offers the advantage of a large field of view. With it the spectra of about 10,500 stars of the sixth magni- tude and brighter, between the pole and 25 south, were photographed before the close of the year 1888. The instrument was then sent to Peru, where a like survey of the Southern sky is in progress. Spectroscopic observa- tions of the brighter stars have been continued at Cambridge with the 11-inch Draper telescope and of fainter stars with an 8-inch doublet similar to the Bache instrument. In this work it was found that by giving a certain chemical stain to the photographic plate the yellow and green portions of the spectrum of even the fainter stars can profitably be studied. Furthermore, what seems incredible at first thought, it appears to be demon- strated that the components of binary stars whose juxtaposition does not per- mit them to be separated in any tele- scope, may, by spectroscopic photo- graphy, be shown to be in revolution about each other. Two or more such objects have been found in which the changes regularly succeeding in the lines of the spectrum not only prove that the components are in motion, but permit the period of revolution to be determined. Prior to 1883 photography is mentioned in the annual reports of the present di- rector only as incidental to other work. In that year a systematic investigation was undertaken, having among other objects in view, the construction of a photographic map of tbe whole heavens. An early application of photography in this investigation was in the direction of determining the color of stars, measuring their brightness by an independent method, picturing their spectra, exhibit- ing the effect of atmospheric absorption of light in a series of plates covering the period of a year, and ascertaining by im- ages of stars trailed upon the plate, the clearness and steadiness of the atmos- phere. In 1887 the Boyden fund being avail- able, the first step was taken in the im- portant enterprise of giving a conti- nental expansion to the work of the ob- servatory. The aim of the testator in making his bequest could well be fur- thered in conducting observations simul- taneously in photometry, spectroscopy and photography. In following up the project, the Draper memorial funds ap- pear also to have been available to a considerable extent in the two latter methods of observation. Experimental stations were established in Colorado in the summer of 1887 on mountain peaks of 14,000, 11,000 and 6000 feet in height, respectively, and the meteorological con- ditions, including the transparency and steadiness of the upper atmosphere, were duly tested. This investigation was continued at the expense of the Boyden fund during the following winter by local observers whose stations were at considerable height. In 1889 the movement was further ex- tended by establishing an observatory on a peak about 6500 feet high in Peru, 25 or 30 miles distant from the sea coast and the city of Lima. Local official sanction was given to naming the peak, "Monte Harvard." About the same time other observers of the Harvard corps set up an experimental observa- tory on Mt. Wilson, 6000 feet high, in Southern California. The station is about 30 miles from the sea coast and somewhat less from the city of Los An- geles. The experimental purpose is the same as in Colorado, and looks to the ultimate establishment of a permanent observa- tory as a branch of the Harvard institu- tion at some favorable point where the superior atmospheric conditions of the Pacific mountain regions can be had. In the special direction of picturing celes- tial objects at Mt. Wilson remarkable photographic results are already pos- sessed at Cambridge in plates showing HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. 31 lunar surfaces, Saturn's rings, Jupiter's belts and the most brilliant of the nebu- lae. That among them which is of the greatest scientific interest, as being a novelty, is the picture on a negative plate of the great spiral nebula of Orion. It is a Harvard discovery by the photo- graphic method, and is quite other than that heretofore known as the great nebula in Orion. That is an object having a span of about, half a degree. The new great nebula has a span of nearly 17 degrees ; its outline includes all the stars of the constellation, and it is too faint an object to be discerned by the naked eye. It is one of the principal advantages of the photographic method in astronomical work that the sensitive plate will denote objects which the eye reinforced by a telescope of any power cannot detect. The great nebula thus discovered is within reach of the telescope, but its dimensions are so much larger than the field of the telescope, and its outline so faint, that its true character would not thus originally be apprehended. Photography at Cambridge has already produced several series of plates, each plate covering a section of the northern sky, the whole of which when perfected and collated will be a self- recorded, and so, indisputable atlas, showing the posi- tion of all stars down to those of the llth magnitude. It will be an , atlas in sheets of glass, and frailer in some re- spects than if composed of sheets of pa- per. But for study of the science the glass is better than any product of the engraver's art, and better than any sun picture printed by the plate itself. In- deed, it is one of the triumphs of the pho- tographic method that a perfect photo- graphic negative discloses more to the student than does a telescopic view of that area of the sky of which the photo- graph is a copy. Astronomical research is now constantly made at the observa- tory in this manner, and with results equal to or better than those reached by former methods. Celestial objects are thus originally discovered and the positions of familiar objects remeasured or otherwise com- pared, and this work might be continued throughout the whole 24 hours were it so desired, regardless of the glare of the sun by day or of impenetrable clouds by night. The work in progress in Peru will give other series of plates offering equal facil- ities for the study at Cambridge of that part of the sky which is beyond our southern horizon. Some of the results which these extensive investigations of the light, the spectra and the positions of the stars will yield will anticipate the doings of other great observatories of the world. But there is no necessary limit at stars of the magnitudes named ; there will remain other worlds to con- quer A special encouragement to new enter- prises at Harvard is in the munificent gift of $50,000, made within the year past by Miss Catherine W. Bruce of New York for the construction of a telescooe of 2i inches aperture, to be used in pho- tography. A contract for this instrument has been made. It is intended that its first use shall be to photograph maps of the fainter stars, and it is hoped that those as faint as the 16th magnitude can thus be represented. The basis of this sanguine forecast is the fact that with an eight-inch telescope of the pattern of the proposed 24-inch, and an exposure of the plate for one hour, twice as many stars are photographed as are visible with a telescope of 15 inches aperture. Prof. Pickering received the honorary degree of A.M. from Harvard in 1880, and that of LL.D. from the University of Califor- nia in 1886, and from the University of Michigan in 1887. Like his predecessor, Prof. G. P. Bond, he has been honored by the Koyal Astronomical Society in the bestowal of its gold medal. The several investigations of chief importance which are now in progress at Harvard College Observatory have already been mentioned as part of the record of the half-century past. They also go into the record with which the second half-century now begins. As such they may be briefly recapitulated, viz. : The survey, for the purposes of the great European standard catalogue known as the ''Astronomische Gessell- schaft," of the zone between 9 50' south and 14 10' south ; the photometric, spec- troscopic, and photographic special sur- veys making in south latitude to com- plete like surveys hitherto made at Cam- bridge, extending to about 30 south ; the systematic work in photography, which includes much classifiable as spectro- scopy, carried on both at Cambridge and in Peru as the Draper Memorial work ; other systematic work of like importance done under the special restrictions of 32 HARVARD COLLEGE OBSERVATORY. the Boyden fund; and what perhaps may be called the orbital observations of eclipses of Jupiter's satellites. That planet has now nearly completed its circuit around the sun, and the last of its satellite eclipses te be observed will occur on Dec. 17 ensuing. During the period of 12 years about 450 of these eclipses nave been observed and recorded. Perhaps as many others for which preparations were made at the observa- tory, passed unseen, because of interpos- ing clouds. Except to an expert these figures give no hint of the magnitude of the work. All that need here be said is that in its completed form it will be one of the great achievements of the observa- tory. The enumeration of these unfinished works and those completed, which has now been made, will have fulfilled its purpose if it shall have impressed upon the mind of the general reader the fact , with which it is presumable everybody is somewhat familiar, that a great oak has grown from the little acorn planted on Harvard College campus 50 years ago. RETURN TO the circulation desk of any University of California Library or to the NORTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY Bldg. 400, Richmond Field Station University of California Richmond, CA 94804-4698 ALL BOOKS MAY BE RECALLED AFTER 7 DAYS 2- month loans may be renewed by calling (510)642-6753 1-year loans may be recharged by bringing books to NRLF Renewals and recharges may be made 4 days prior to due date DUE AS STAMPED BELOW FE8 3 - 1896 i 20,000 (4/94) THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY