ra&ffiHN&vHW 4 ' 1 '-'-" MH , LUCRETIUS. LUCRETIUS ON THE NATURE OF THINGS LITERALLY TRANSLATED BY THE REV. JOHN SELBY WATSON, M.A. WITH THE POETICAL VERSION OF JOHN MASON GOOD. LONDON: GEORGE BELL & SONS, YORK ST., COVENT GARDEN, AND NEW YORK. 1893. LONDON : REPRINTED FIK'H THE STEREOTYPE PLATES BY WM. CLOWES & SONS, LTD., STAMFORD STREET AND CHARING CROSS. REMA LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. OF the life of Lucretius but little information has reached us. Ad nos vix tenuis famae perlabitur aura. That he was a Roman by birth, is inferred from the pas- sages in his poem in which he speaks of the Roman world as his country, 1 and of the Roman language as his native tongue. 1 As to the time of his birth, it is stated by Eusebius in his Chronicon, that he was born in the second year of the hundred and seventy-first Olympiad, or ninety-five years before Christ. At this period, Ennius had been dead about seventy years ; Cicero was in his twelfth year ; twenty-five years wereijjjo elapse before the birth of Virgil, and four before that of Julius Caesar. His style, indeed, would make him seem older, but its antiquated character may be partly affected, in imitation, perhaps, of Ennius, for whom he expresses great veneration. 3 Concerning his family nothing is known. The name of Lucretius, from the time of Lucretia downwards, occurs fre- quently in the history of Rome, with the surnames Tricipiti- nus, Cinna, Ofella, and others, attached to it ; but with whom the poet was connected, or from whom descended, it is impossi- ble to discover. There was a Lucretius Vespillo contemporary with him, a senator, mentioned by Cicero 4 and Caesar, 5 of whom Lambinus conjectures that he may have been the brother; suggesting that the one brother, by engaging in public life, might have attained senatorial dignity, while the other, devoting himself to literature and retirement, might have 1 Nam neque nos agere hoc patriai tempo^e in'quo, etc. i. 42. 1 I. 31; iii. 259. I. 118. 4 Cic. Brut. c. 48. * u. c. i. 18; iv 7- VI REMARKS ON THB continued in the equestrian or even plebeian rank, in whicl he was born. But all this is mere empty conjecture. Equally groundless is the supposition, started also by Lam- binus, that in his youth he went to Athens to study, and there, under the instruction of Zeno, who was then at the head of the Epicureans, became imbued with the doctrines of Epi- curus. That he attached himself to the tenets of Epicurus is certain, but when or where he studied them is not now to be ascertained. Dunlop, however, asserts that "Lucretius teas sent, with other young Romans of rank, to study at Athens." l Thus it is that errors creep into biography and history ; the learned conjecture, and the less learned affirm. Lambinus suggests that Lucretius might have gone to Athens, Dunlop states that he did go ; Lambinus says that it is probable, Dunlop says it is fact. He wrote his poem, or part of it, as appears from a passage near the beginning of the first book, 2 at a time when the Roman commonwealth was in a disturbed state ; but whether the disorders to which he alludes were, as is generally supposed, those excited by Catiline, or, as Forbiger suggests, those which were raised by Clodius eight years afterwards, there is no means of deciding. His poem and his life, if we may trust Eusebius, were ended in the manner following. " Having been driven to madness by an amatory potion, and having composed several books in the intervals of his insanity, which Cicero afterwards cor- rected, he died by his own hand in the forty-fourth year of his age." By whom the potion was administered, is conjec- tured only from a passage in St. Jerome, who says that a cer- tain Lucilia killed her husband or her lover, by giving him a philtre which was intended to secure his love, but of which the effect was to render him insane. 3 This Lucilia is supposed to have been the wife or mistress of Lucretius, but by whom the supposition was first made, I am not able to discover. He is said by Donatus, or whoever wrote the old Life of Virgil, to have died on the day on which Virgil assumed the toga virilis. 1 Hist, of Rom. Lit. vol. i. p. 417. 2 I. 42. 1 Epist. Dissuas. ad Rufinum, c. 22, toir.. xi. p. 245 ed. Veron. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. Tli That Cicero corrected what he wrote, there is, except from the passage in Eusebius, no indication. From a passage in Varro, 1 it has been concluded that he wrote many more books than have reached us ; for " Lucre- tius," says he, "suorum unius et viginti librorum initium fecit hoc : ^Etheris et terras genitabile quaerere tempus." But Lambinus has very plausibly conjectured that for Lu- cretius should be substituted Lucilius, or the name of some other writer unknown to us. This is the more probable, observes Eichstadt, as Varro was older than Lucretius, and was not accustomed to draw examples and testimonies from younger writers. From the six books, as they now stand, there is no infer- ence to be drawn that more were written. That something more was intended is perhaps true ; for when we consider how the sixth book breaks off, we must either suppose that he designed to write a conclusion to it, or that he meant an- other book to follow. He signifies, however, 2 that he was drawing to the conclusion of his undertaking ; and, indeed, the doctrines of Epicurus are so fully set forth in the six books, that little more could have been added respecting them. It is true that there are two or three allusions among the grammarians to passages and verses which are not now found in the six books ; allusions which have led to the belief that there were more books, but which, with other considerations, led Spalding, the editor of Quintilian, 3 to the suspicion that there were two editions given by the author himself, and that, though the second was generally followed, the first was not quite forgotten. Thus the 937th verse of the first book, which is now read, " Contingunt mellis dulci flavoque liquore," is cited by Quintilian, " Aspirant mellis dulci flavoque liquore." And Servius, on those lines in the Georgics, 4 " Non ego cuncta meis amplecti versibus opto; Non mihi si linguae centum sint oraque centum, Ferrea vox," 1 De L. L. v. p. 27, ed. Spengel. * vi. 45, 91, 3 Inst. Or. iii. 1, 4. 4 II. 42. Viii REMARKS ON THE says, " The verses are Lucretius's ; but he has cenea vox, not ferrea;" verses which are not now to be found in Lucretius. This notion of two editions Eichstadt has noticed at some length in his dissertation, De Lucretii Vita et Carmine ; and Forbiger has written a long essay to show that Lucretius's verses have been much altered. " Fateor enim," says For- biger, 1 " ex quo primum Lucretii carmen, studiosius perlege- rim operamque meam ei navaverim, plures mihi oblatas esse causas suspicandi, nobis in his sex de rerum natura libris non unius Lucretii, sed duorum scriptorum long& diversorum inanum agnoscendam, ideoque hunc etiam auctorem iis annu- merandum esse, quorum scripta a serioribus multis in locis mutata, aucta vel contracta, emendata vel corrupta, denique longe alia ab ea, quam auctor ipsis dederit, forma induta, ad nostra tempora pervenerint." " I confess, that since I first read the poem of Lucretius with attention, and bestowed serious labour upon it, many reasons occurred to me for sus- pecting that, in these six books concerning the nature of things, we have to recognise, not the hand of Lucretius alone, but those of two writers of far different characters ; and that this author is therefore to be numbered with those, whose works have come down to us altered in many places by later writers ; having been augmented or diminished in bulk, amended or corrupted, and invested with a different form from that which the author himself gave them." But per- haps, in the case of Lucretius, the variations which we find in the verses which are cited from him, are to be attributed, not to any regular revision or emendation of his writings, but to the casual mistakes of transcribers, and the lapse of memory in grammarians. Perhaps also passages, containing verses cited by Servi us and others, have been lost. Lach- mann, the last editor, finds, or imagines that he finds, defi- ciencies in several pages. The Memmius to whom the poem is addressed, was, as Lnmbinus and others think, Caius Memmius Gemellus, a Roman knight, who is described by Cicero 2 as "a learned man, well-read in Greek, but disdainful of Latin literature ; a clever orator, and of an agreeable style ; but shrinking from the labour, not only of speaking, but even of thinking ; and 1 De Lucretii Carmine, p. 6, * Brut. 70. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. IX doing injustice to his ability by hi? want of industry." He became prastor, and after his praetorship had the province of Bithynia, to which he was accompanied by Catullus the poet. Being supported by Caasar, he stood for the consulship, but was unsuccessful, and, after being accused and condemned of bribery, went into exile at Patrae, where he died. Cicero defended him on his trial, and addressed to him some letters which may be found in the thirteenth book of his Epistles to his friends. 1 The general voice of criticism has awarded to Lucretius high praise as a poet. The earliest notice which we find of his works, is that of Cicero in a letter to his brother Quintus, 2 in which he says, as the passage stands in Ernesti, Lucretii poemata, ut scribis, ita sunt; non multis luminibus ingenii, multce tarnen artis. " The poetry of Lucretius is such as you say ; having not much splendour of genius, but a great deal of art." Wakefield would omit the non, but is opposed by Eichstadt and Schutz, and by general opinion. 3 Cicero, how- ever, if we read his words rightly, seems hardly to do justice to the poet, 4 or to hit the general character of his work. To us, of the present day, he appears to be chiefly distinguished by a rough vigour, and to have been anxious rather to express his thoughts strongly, than to clothe them in elegance or niceties of language. Not that he disdained poetical beauties, for Virgil and others have found in him many worthy of adop- tion ; but vigour and animation seemed to have been his chief aim. Statius did him more justice, when he spoke of the docti furor arduus Lucrett? " the lofty rage of the learned Lucretius." 6 Ovid thoroughly understood his merit, and pre- dicted that his poem was destined to be immortal : Carmina sublimis tune sunt peritura Lucreti, Exitio terras cum dabit una dies. 7 1 See Lambinus in Prolegom. * Ad Quint. Frat. ii. 11. 3 Tanaquil Faber proposed to read, omitting the non, "lita sunt multis luminibus," $c., which Ernesti, as Eichstadt remarks, justly condemns. Who indeed could endure the expression luminibus lineret * See Warton's Essay on Pope, vol. ii. p. 328. 5 Stat. Sylv. ii. 7, 76. This expression Gray seems to have had in his thoughts, when he wrote, Chill penury repress'd their noble rage. i Ainor. i. 15, 23. b X REMARKS ON THE Cornelius Nepos l ranks him in elegance with Catullus ; foi speaking of a certain Julius Calidus, who was rescued from proscription by Pomponius Atticus, he calls him " the most elegant poet since the death of Catullus and Lucretius." Quintilian 2 gives him similar praise, saying that he is elegans in sud materid, elegant in his peculiar department, though he thinks him "difficult" for the student. Aulus Gellius 3 calls him a poet " excelling ingenio etfacundia, in genius and force of language;" Serenus Sammonicus 4 styles him "the great Lucretius;" and Velleius Paterculus, 5 Vitruvius, 6 Seneca, 7 Macrobius, 8 and Pliny the younger, 9 notice him as ranked among the most eminent poets, though without bestowing on him any specific commendation. He is recognised in a simi- lar way by Propertius 10 and Tacitus. 11 There was therefore little cause for Dunlop to complain of "the slight mention that is made of Lucretius by succeeding Latin authors," and of "the coldness with which he is spoken of by all Roman critics and poets, with the exception of Ovid." Horace, indeed, who makes abundant mention of Ennius and Lucilius, has, it must be acknowledged, not named Lucretius. Dunlop, to account for this silence of Horace, and the sup- posed intended silence of others, suggests that " the spirit of free-thinking which pervaded his writings, may have rendered it unsuitable or unsafe to extol his poetical talents. There was a time," he adds, " when, in this country, it was thought scarcely decorous or becoming to express high admiration of the genius of Rousseau and Voltaire." With reference to Horace, and his times, there may have been some ground for this supposition. Cicero, in his De Amicitia introduces L- lius saying that " he does not agree with those who have lately begun to assert that souls perish together with their bodies, and that death makes an end of all." " I rather sub- mit myself," he continues, " to the authority of the ancients, or of our own forefathers, who appointed religious rites for the dead ; rites which they would not have instituted, had they thought that the dead could not be affected by them, * * * or to the authority of him who was pronounced by the oracle 1 Vit. Att. xii. 4. * Instit. Or. x. 1. 3 Noct. Alt. i. 21. 4 De Medic, ver. 614. s Hist. Rom. ii. 36. Lib. ix. 3. 7 De Tranq. An. sect. 2; Ep. xcv. ex. * Sat. vi. '2. Ep. iv. 18. Eleg. ii. 25, 29. Dial, dc Or. 23. Cap. *. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. XI of Apollo the wisest of men ; and who did not on this, as on most subjects, assert sometimes one thing and sometimes an- other, but maintained invariably the same opinion, that the souls of men are divine, and that, when they are released from the body, a return to heaven is open to them, and first of all to the best and most worthy. But," he concludes, as if un- willing to side too closely with either party, " should the opinion of those be true, who think that the soul and the body perish together, and that all sense is terminated by their separation, death will then be attended with neither good nor evil." The moderns have certainly not been less willing to praise Lucretius than the ancients. Barthius ' and Turnehus 2 com- mend the attractive simplicity of his antique Latinity; Cri- nitus and Casaubon 3 speak of his style in a similar manner ; and Julius Scaliger 4 calls him "a divine man, and incompar- able poet." The eulogies bestowed upon him by Lambinus, Faber, and his other commentators, I omit, as they might be regarded as the offspring of partiality. Our own countrymen have not been behind others in offer- ing their tribute of admiration, as exhibited in editions, trans- lations, remarks, and quotations. Dr. Warton, in his Essay on Pope, 5 calls the Nature of Things "the noblest descriptive poem extant," and has most happily illustrated the poet's vigour of conception and execution : " The Persians," says he, " distinguish the different degrees of the strength of fancy in different poets, by calling them painters or sculptors. Lu- cretius, from the force of his images, should be ranked among the latter. He is, in truth, a sculptor-poet. His images have n bold relief." " If Lucretius had not been spoiled by the Epicurean system," says Lord Byron, 6 " we should have had a far superior poem to any now in existence. As mere poetry, it is the first of Latin poems." But the most discriminating and ample praise, that has been given him by any English author, is that of Dryden : 7 " If I am not mistaken," says he, " the distinguishing cha- Advers xxiii. 1. 2 Advers. xviii. 6. Not. in Johan. c. 5, cited in the Life prefixed to Creech's version. In Aristot. Hist. Anim. x. 53. Vol. i. p. 50, and vol. ii. p. 105, note. ' Letter on Bovrles. Preface to his second Miscellany of Translations, b * lii BFMARK9 ON THE racter of Lucretius, I mean of his soul and genius, is a certain kind of noble pride, and positive assertion of his own opinions. He is every where confident of his own reason, and assuming an absolute command, not only over his vulgar readers, but even his patron Memmius ; for he is always bidding him at- tend, as if he had the rod over him, and using a magisterial authority, while he instructs him. * * * He seems to disdain all manner of replies, and is so confident of his cause, that he is beforehand with his antagonists ; urging for them whatever he imagined they could say, and leaving them, as he supposes, without an objection for the future. All this too with so much scorn and indignation, as if he were assured of the tri- umph before he entered into the lists. " From this sublime and daring genius of his, it must of necessity come to pass, that his thoughts must be masculine, full of argumentation, and that sufficiently warm. From the same fiery temper proceeds the loftiness of his expressions, and the perpetual torrent of his verse, when the barrenness of his subject does not too much restrain the quickness of his fancy. For there is no doubt to be made, but that he could have been every where as poetical as he is in his descriptions, and in the moral part of his philosophy, if he had not aimed more to instruct in his system of nature, than to delight." With regard to the subject of his poem, Lucretius is to be contemplated as a natural and moral philosopher. The physical part of his philosophy, and most, indeed, of the moral part, he took from Epicurus, who, as Cicero 1 observes, had previously adopted his physics from Democritus. Of this, the great principle is, that nothing can proceed from nothing," 1 and th.it, consequently, this world, in which we live, and every other object in the universe, was formed from matter that previously existed. How this matter came to exist, we need not inquire ; we are to suppose that it existed always. In its original state it was an infinitude of detached atoms, mo\ ing or falling through unlimited space ; for that space is unlimited is by Lucretius elaborately proved. 3 These atoms are infrangible and indestructible; for mattei is not infinitely divisible ; there must be a point at which di- 1 De Fin. i. 6. * I. 156, 544. * I. 967. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. xiii vision ends. They are hard and solid, or they would l>e un- . able to endure agitation and attrition throughout an infinity of ages. 1 They are of different shapes, suited for the forma- tion of various substances by combination. 2 The number of their forms, however, is limited ; but the number of each form is infinite. 3 The atoms were moving ; but whence had they the begin- ning of motion ? From their own gravity ; for all bodies move downwards by their own weight. 4 This is the com- mencement of absurdity in the system ; for, if space be infi- nite, one direction in it cannot be called downwards more than another ; as Lucretius himself indeed acknowledges, observing that nil est funditus imum; 5 nor can any reason be assigned why an atom should move from one part of infinite space to another. This commencement of motion, however, being assumed, it is next to be shown how atoms combined. Had they all moved, as might have been supposed, in straight lines, as they fell or proceeded through space, there could have been no coalition among them, unless the heavier had overtaken the lighter. But Lucretius, or Epicurus, had sufficient conception of the motion of bodies in empty space, to understand that light bodies must move through it as speedily as heavy ones, and that, consequently, one atom could not overtake another. 6 It was necessary, therefore, to make some of them deviate from the straight or perpendicular line, and it is accordingly as- sumed that some do deviate from it. " This supposition," says Cicero, 7 " is mere puerility ; for he introduces the devia- tion arbitrarily; he makes some atoms decline from the straight course without cause ; and to say that any thing takes place without a cause is to a natural philosopher the most disgrace- ful of all things. To assert, too, that some decline, and some go straight onwards, is, as it were, to give properties and duties to atoms despotically, determining which is to go in a right line, and which obliquely." But when, from partial deviations, some had come in con- tact with others, they began to form combinations. They strove, as it were, for a long time ineffectually, 8 but at length 1 I 484635. * II. 94107. II. 426580. * II. 7987. I. 992. II. 225, seq. ' De Fin. i. . I. 1023, seq.; V. 188195. EEMARKS ON THE larger and heavier atoms coalesced into the denser sub- stances, as earth and water ; the smaller and lighter, into more subtle matters, as air and fire. From combinations of such substances arose plants and animals ; as trees and worms still spring from the earth when it is moistened and warmed. Of the rise of animals in general, and of man especially, the reader will find an ample account, according to the notions of Epi- curus, in the fifth book. 1 Nature does not abhor a vacuum. On the contrary, it is necessary that there should be, throughout the whole of mat- ter, certain portions of empty space, or the movement of par- ticles would be utterly impeded. Water, for instance, could not be a liquid, unless there were vacuities among its atoms to allow them to yield to pressure. 2 Man consists of a body and a soul. The body is constituted of coarser, and the soul of finer matter. Both are produced together, and grow up and decay together ; at death, the con- nexion between them is dissolved ; the soul takes its departure, to be decomposed, and mingled with other matter; and the body begins to decay, that it may undergo a similar fate. The mind is intimately connected with the soul ; so inti- mately that they must be said to form one substance. Both are composed of heat, vapour, air, and a certain fourth sub- stance, which has no name, but which is the most important of the four, as being the origin of motion in the whole man. That both are wholly corporeal is indisputable, from their power to act on the body : Tangere enim et tangi, nisi corpus, nulla potest res. s Ideas of objects in the mind are produced by the mysteri- ous action of images of things on the soul and intellect ; images of a light vapoury substance, which are perpetually passing off from the surface of all bodies whatsoever, and exhibiting the exact resemblance of the objects from which they are de- tached. Other images, too, are formed spontaneously in the atmosphere, as we see clouds, at times, form themselves into likenesses of things on the face of the sky. Of images, ac- cordingly, the number is infinite, so that, whenever a man wishes to think on any thing, the image of it is generally ready 1 Ver. 780, seq. z I. 347383, et seq. 1 On the Soul, see book iii. passim. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. XV to present itself for his contemplation. If he cannot recollect what he wishes to think on, he may consider that an image of it is not at hand. Dreams are excited by images, which, as they pass through the air, penetrating the coverings of the body, come in contact with such atoms of the soul as are at the surface of the body, and thus communicate their impres- sions to the whole of the soul and mind. Vision is produced by the same images flying off from the surface of the objects at which we look, and striking on the eye. Reflection from mirrors, and other smooth surfaces, is produced by the image first striking the reflecting plane, and then being reverberated to the eye. Voice, like all sounds, is a corporeal substance, because it frequently, as it passes forth, causes abrasion of the throat, and because much speaking ex- hausts the corporeal frame by detraction of atoms. 1 The members and organs of the body were not formed with a design that they might be used ; for there could have been no design in the offspring of fortuitously meeting atoms ; but, as they have been formed, and we find them capable of being used, we apply them, accordingly, to the uses for which they seem adapted. The feet were not formed for walking, but, as we find they enable us to walk, we employ them in walking. 2 Of all our knowledge the foundation must rest on the per- ceptions of our senses. To our senses we can assuredly trust, for what shall refute them ? Will any thing distinct from them refute them, or will they refute one another? That which shall convict them of falsehood must be more trust- worthy than they ; but what can be more trust-worthy ? What shall convince us that those bodies which appear to the senses square, or hot, or black, are not possessed of those qualities? 3 The motions and combinations of atoms being established, all natural phenomena, as thunder, lightning, rain, earth- quakes, are easily shown to arise from their changes of place and effects on one another. 4 Even were it not demonstrable that the world was for- tuitously formed by the coalescence of atoms, it might yet be I safely affirmed, from the numerous faults apparent in it, and , from the various causes of suffering to animal life which it ) 1 Of images, &c. see book iv. passim. a IV. 825. 3 IV. 380523. * See book v. xn REMARKS ON THE l^ontuins, that it was not made by divine wisdom as an abode for living creatures. 1 It sprung into being casually ; and nimals, that casually sprung from it, make the best of that bode to which they are confined, and from which there is no release but death. This world, which we inhabit, is not the only one in the universe. 8 The number of atoms being infinite, it is naturally to be supposed that they must have produced more worlds than one. It is therefore probable that there are many worlds of many kinds. And as these worlds have been gener- ated, we may fairly argue that they also decay. Men, other animals, and the trees of the forest, are born but to die ; and why should not a world be subject to the same fate as the tilings which grow in it? We see, indeed, the symptoms of decadence in the world which we inhabit ; for the present pro- ductions of the earth are not of the same vigour as those of its earlier days. All, then, around us, we may conclude is making progress towards dissolution ; the great globe will continue to sink and grow infirm, until at last, mouldering and disrupturcd, it scatters its atoms through surrounding space, to contribute to the formation of other worlds like or unlike itself. Star after star from heaven's bright arch shall rush, Suns sink on suns, and systems systems crush ; Headlong, extinct, to one dark centre fall, And Death, and Night, and Chaos, mingle all. Till, o'er the wreck, emerging from the storm, Immortal Nature lifts her changeful form, Mounts from her funeral pyre on wings of flame, And soars and shines another and the same. Darwin. Such were the general tenets of Lucretius as a natural philosopher ; tenets on which the reader will find him amply enlarging in the following pages. His doctrines as a moral philosopher may be noticed with greater brevity. His great boast as a moralist was, that he freed men from the terrors of death, and of suffering after death. The soul, ays he, when it is separated from the body, is dispersed among the matter from which it was collected, and the man ceases to be. His atoms continue to exist, for they are indestructible, but lus own existence, as an individual being, is no more. He 1 V. 196, M*. * II. 1075. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. XV11 is separated into his parts, and his consciousness that he ever existed as a whole is at an end. Of what has been, he will have no recollection; of what shall be, he will have no knowledge. Why then should he dread to die, when after death no suffering can ensue? He that is about to die young, may felicitate himself that he shall escape that trouble and affliction of which some falls to the lot of every man ; he that dies at an advanced age, may be satisfied that he has had so long opportunity for those enjoyments of which no man fails toobtain some. After a certain period life offers nothing new, and why should we seek to prolong it? 1 The greatest enjoyment of life consists in tranquil plea- v sure. To labour for honour and dignities, which are unsatis- factory when attained, is mere folly. Nature has supplied every thing necessary to satisfy our wants, and to enable us to spend our existence in ease, contentment, and pleasure ; if we only study the best method of making the most of what"- 1 is set before us. A wise man can live on a little ; and to live contentedly on a little is to be equal in enjoyment to him who has more than ourselves, and who, however much he may have, can have no solid satisfaction unless he is contented with' that which he possesses. 2 The highest degree of wisdom that we can attain, is to be able to look down from the serene elevations of philosophy, on the unreasoning crowds wander- ing beneath us, seeking for the path of happiness, and vainly homing to find it in the pursuit of ,the splendours and distinc- tions of the world. 3 Whether he really believed in the existence of gods, that is, of beings of a similar but superior nature to ourselves, it is' not easy, from the perusal of his works, to decide. He at times speaks of gods, like Epicu-us, as certainly existing, 4 and enjoying a state of tranquil f ;licity, unconcerned about the affairs of the world, and unaffected by human good or human evil. 5 At other times, he seems to consider them as mere creatures of the imagination, to which men have attributed, in the operations of nature, those effects of which they cannot discover the causes. 6 ' Book iii., sub Jin. II. 20-60. II. 1-18. 4 VI. 76. In ii. 599, he notices that the earth is called magna deum Mater, Materque ferarum, as if gods and beasts had alike sprung from her. * 644651. V. 1 168, **. REMARKS ON THE The first edition of Lucretius was primed at Brescia, by Fer- andus, without date, but, as Wakefield and others think, about the year 1470. It is of all editiones principes the most rare. The second edition appeared at Verona, printed by Freiden- perger, in 1486, and the third at Venice, by T. de Ragazoni- busT in 1495. From Venice, too, in 1500, came forth the first edition of Aldus ; and fifteen years afterwards the second, superintended by Naugerius, who did more to make his author intelligible than had been done in the former edition. In the mean time, however, (loll,) had appeared at Bononia the edition of Baptists Pius, who brought much learning and ability to bear upon his author, and many of whose notes are still worthy of preservation. The second edition of Aldus is said by Lacl.mann l to have been greatly improved from the revised text of Michael Ma- rullus, which was published from his manuscripts after his death, by Petrus Candidas, whose' name the edition bears, at Florence, in 1512; of which text succeeding editors have overlooked the merits, or have been unwilling to do justice to them. But all other editions were thrown into the shade by those of Lambinus, of which the first appeared in 1563, the second in 1565, and the third in 1570. Of all editors and expound- ers of Lucretius, Lambinus still deserves to stand at the head. He is accused by Wakefield of inconsulta temeritas, injudici- ous rashness, in intruding" his own conjectures into the text ; and by Eichstadt, of having had too high an opinion of his own judgment and ability; but though there be some grounds for such accusations, his character as an editor is still of the highest order. He brought to his work a powerful mind, and, knowing that Lucretius always intended to write sense, he took upon himself to put sense, perhaps at times too arbi- trarily, into verses which had been left meaningless by tran- scribers. And it is surely no dishonour to him to have shown his contempt for such a man as Gifanius, who, in 1565, printed an edition at Antwerp, and whose annotations have little other claim to notice than that of attacking Lambinus with the meanness with which a low mind Always attacks a higher. 1 Prolegom. in Notas, p. 11. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. X1JS There were some other editions, but of not much account, between Gifanius's and that of Tanaquil Faber, which wag published in 1662, containing notes, brief indeed, but evincing the great learning and acuteness of the editor. To Faber, in 1695, succeeded Creech. His text is Lambi- nus's with scarcely any variation, and though he never fails to expose a mistakeof Lambinus when he findsone in hiscomment- ary, he is very ready to profit by all Lambinus's instructions. His interpretatio, after the manner of the Delphin editions, is of little use, for, wherever there is any difficulty of construction, he invariably abbreviates. Yet, if we may credit the last editor, Lachmann, " multa rectius interpretatus est quam scripsit, in philosophia explicandA sane diligens, sed linguae Latinae imperitissimus." This is too strong ; but there are in his notes inelegances and inaccuracies. In 1725 appeared the splendid edition of Havercamp, which is extremely useful, as containing all the notes of Lambinus, Gifanius, Creech, and Faber, with a selection from those of Pius, and with a few, of considerable value, from Abrahamus Preigerus, a friend of Havercamp. Of Havercamp's own there is comparatively little. At length, in 1796, came out, with a dedication to Fox, the well-known edition of Wakefield. Wakefield had discovered, by the inspection of a manuscript or two, that Lambinus had taken, as he thought, unjustifiable liberties with the text of Lucretius, and conceived that he should be enabled to re- store it to something like its original integrity. Had he been content to reinstate only those words or phrases which Lambinus or others had unreasonably ejected, he might have done greater service, but he replaced also such readings as any editor would have been blamed for suffering to remain. I will give one instance. In Lambinus and Creech the 863rd verse of the third book stands thus : Interrupta semel quum sit repetentia nostra ; " repetentia nostra," our memory or recollection. This is in- telligible ; but Wakefield finding in manuscripts nostris, re- placed it as a crux to his reader, who, as soon as he comes to it, is stuck fast. What, he inquires, is to be understood with nostris? It is in vain to seek for any thing in what precedes, and he must consult Wakefield's notes to find that, according M REMARKS ON THE to Wakefield's notion, rebus must be supplied. How nuch the difficulties in an author may be increased by such changes^ is easily conceivable ; but he who has only read Lambinus or Creech's edition of Lucretius, can have no conception how much the difficulties in Lucretius have been increased by Wakefield's arbitrary alterations. Whether Wakefield ever "construed through a brick wall," I do not know ; but that he has raised abundance of brick walls through which others are left to construe, is manifest. There is in his notes, besides other unnecessary matter, a vast quantity of super- fluous railing at the inscitia and inverecundia of Lambinus, and the inscitia and stupor of Creech, of which the reader may see an average specimen on vi. 582, and in various other places. A man worthy to edit Lucretius should have for- borne to apply the term inscitia to such a predecessor as Lambinus. In 1801, Wakefield's text was reprinted at Leipsic by Eichstadt, who had previously obtained repute by his edition of Diodorus Siculus. The first volume, containing the text of the six books, judicious prolegomena, and an excellent in- dex, is the only one that has appeared. In 1828 came forth the edition of Forbiger, which, chiefly perhaps from the convenience of its size, has been much used. His text is Wakefield's, with but very few alterations, and all his explanations of passages are Wakefield's. His work, says Lachmann, was mercenary; and it would be doing him great injustice to suppose him capable of seeing any thing by the light of his own intellect. In 1850, at Berlin, appeared Lachmann's edition, in two thin volumes octavo. He is a little too fond of transposing verses, and discovering deficiencies in the text, but deserves great commendation for restoring many readings that Wake- field had ejected. His notes are not at all explanatory, but are wholly occupied about changes in the text. With regard to versions of Lucretius, the earliest attempt to render him into English was made by John Evelyn the author of" Sylva,"who, in 1656, published the first book in verse, with a commentary. His lady designed the frontispiece, LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. xxi and Waller prefixed a copy of verses. The translation is faithful, but tame. In 1682 was published the translation by Creech, which, as the first complete version of the poet, was cordially welcomed. Evelyn furnished some laudatory couplets, saying how much he was pleased that the entire work had fallen to more vigor- ous hands than his own. Duke, Tate, and Otway gave also their tribute of verse, and Creech was every where known as the English Lucretius. But posterity have had time to dis- covei the faults in his performance. Many of his lines are vigorous, but many are stiff and awkward ; and the licences which he has taken with the original are almost beyond be- lief. Whoever will look at the commencement of his first book, will find that between the tenth and sixteenth verses he inserts five lines of his own. Similar interpolations may be found in other places ; and he likewise curtails with equal freedom whenever it suits his purpose. About the same time Dryden produced some translations, or rather paraphrases, of particular passages, executed with his usual vigour. In 1743 there appeared, in two volumes octavo, a proso translation, which Good calls Guernier's, but which was the work of an unknown hand. Guernier, with others, furnished the plates. The version is but indifferent. Some parts of it, though printed as prose, run into blank verse. In 1799 the first book was translated in rhyme by an anonymous author; and in 1808, also in rhyme, by the Rev. W. Hamilton Drummond. Both versions have merit, but the greater share of praise belongs to Mr. Drummond. In 1805 Dr. Good laid befoi'e the public his two quarto volumes, containing a version of the whole poem in blank verse, with copious notes. This translation is in general pleasing and animated, but some parts are rather stiff. Taken as a whole it is by far the best extant, and is deemed, by my publisher, a desirable addition to the present volume. In 1813 was published by subscription, in two pompous volumes quarto, the rhymed version of Thomas Busby, Mus. D. He is, to do him justice, tolerably faithful to the sense, but his couplets are far inferior to those of Mr. Drummond's First Book. His notes are heavy and tedious ; and all his learning iecond-hand. The whole book reminds the reader of the com- REMARKS ON THE menceineut of his well-known prologue, which Lord Byron, says Moore, unnecessarily travestied : When energizing objects men pursue, What are the prodigies they cannot do ! In French, Lucretius has been translated several times. The earliest version is that of the Abbe de Marolles, in prose, published in 1650, which has not obtained more esteem than his other translations of classical authors. In 1685 another prose translation was published by the Baron de Coutures, which is paraphrastic, but seems tolerably faithful to the sense. In 1768 La Grange published a third, which gives the thoughts of the poet with exactness, but wants vigour and animation ; and in 1794 Le Blanc de Guillet brought out a fourth, in verse, which I have not minutely examined, but on which his coun- trymen set no very high value. The last, in 1825, was that of Pongerville, in prose, rather a paraphrase than a transla- tion, and preserving nothing of the sententiousness of Lu- cretius. The Italian version of Marchetti, in blank verse, published in London 1717, and since several times reprinted, has always been highly esteemed. The Germans have three translations; one by Mayr, 1784, in prose, which Degen, cited by Moss, calls " pretty accurate ;" another by Meineke, 1795, in hexameter verse, which is ge- nerally considered faithful to the sense ; and the last by Kne- bel, 1821, which is also in hexameter verse, and which is the most highly valued of the three. The Dutch have a prose translation by De Wit, printed in 1701, which Good says that he had seen, "but without being induced to imitate it." I beg leave to observe, that, in the notes attached to the following translation, I have not taken upon me to refute any of the doctrines of Lucretius or Epicurus. To have offered formal refutations of them would have occupied more space than could be afforded in the present volume; and many of them, in these days, require no refutation. I have there- fore restricted myself to discharging that which Dryden ad- monishes me to be the duty of a translator, to do my author all the riaht I can, and to translate him. to the best advantage. LIFE AND POEM OF LUCRETIUS. Those who seek for arguments against his tenets, physical or moral, may find them in Lactantius ; in Arnobius ; in the Anti-Lucretius of Cardinal Polignac ; in the Bridgewater Treatises ; and in abundance of other English books. The famous refutation by Cardinal Polignac, called Anti- Lucretius, I might have quoted in every page ; and the reader will perhaps wonder that I have not done so. But I for- bore to quote him, as I forbore to quote others. He assailed Lucretius with great determination ; his versification, though deficient in Lucretian ardour, is always respectable, and some- times elevated ; and he would perhaps be more read, had h<> not unluckily, as Voltaire observes, when he atiacted Lucre- { tins attacked Newton. LUCEETIUS. BOOK I. ARGUMENT. Lucretius invokes Venus as the great cause of production, ver. 1 44. He then dedicates his work to Memmius ; praises Epicurus, whose doctrine he follows ; vindicates his subject from the charge of impiety ; exposes the emptiness of the religious system of his day, and the fictions of -the poets ; and introduces, not without allusion to the difficulties to be over- come, the great arguments of which he proposes to treat, ver. 45 1.59. Entering upon his subject, he shows, first, that nothing can proceed from nothing, and that nothing can return to nothing, ver. 160 265. Secondly, that there are certain minute corpuscles, which, though imperceptible to our senses, are conceivable in our minds, and from which all things origin- ate, ver. 266 329. Thirdly, that there is vacuum or empty space, ver. 330430. Fourthly, that there is nothing in the universe but body and space, and that all other things which are said TO BE, are only adjuncts or events, properties or accidents of body and space, ver. 431 483. He then proceeds to demonstrate that the primary corpuscles, or elements of things, are perfectly solid, indivisible, and eternal, ver. 484 635. He re- futes those who had held other opinions, as Heraclitus, who said that fire was the origin of things ; and others, who had maintained the same of air, water, and earth, ver. 636 712. He attacks Empedocles, who said that the universe was compounded of the four elements, and Anaxagoras, who advocated the homaeomeria, ver. 713 919. He then contends that the universe is boundless, that atoms are infinite in number, and that space must be unlimited, ver. 920 1050. Lastly, he refutes those who think that there is a centre of things, to which heavy bodies tend downwanls, and light bodies upwards ; and concludes with a praise of philosophy, which assists mankind to penetrate the mysteries of nature. LUCRETIUS. i. 1- BOC N riFUL Venus, ' mother of the race of JEneas,' 2 delight of gods and men, who, beneath the gliding constellations of heaven, 3 fillest with life 4 the ship-bearing sea and the fruit-producing earth; 6 since by thy influence every kind of O bountiful Venus.] Ver. 2. Alma Venua. The word means kind, bountiful, benignant, nourishing, from alo, to nourish. " It is said of the gods,'" says Forcellini, " particularly such as are thought to give life or food to men." Thus we have alma Ceres, Virg. Geo. i. 7, alme No/, Hor. Carm. Szsc. 9, besides alma Tellus, and many other similar applications of the epithet. Horace has also alma Venus, Od. iv. 15, 31. And Ausonius has the same expression in many places, besides this inscription for a statue of Venus, which he has borrowed from Lucretius : Orta salo, suscepta solo, patre edita ccelo, jEneadum genetrix, hie habito alma Venus. "Others," says Creech, "interpret Ma, fa-cunda, grata; I prefel beniyna, a word which expresses all the other virtues of Venus, to which Lucretushas regard not less than to her fecundity." 2 Mother of the race of jEneas.] Ver. 1. ^Eneadam genetrix. He thus names the Romans, as being descended from ./Eneas. Virgil and Ovid give them the same appellation. 1 Gliding constellations of heaven.] Ver. 2. Cceli labentia signa. The same as tigna labentia ceelo, or in ccelo ; the form of expression which Virgil uses, ^En- iii. 515, Sidera cuncta notattacito labentia caelo. 4 Fillest with life.] Ver. 4. Concelebras. The onlv question as to the translation of this word is, whether it is to be rendered risitest fre- quently, or renderest populous, that is, fittest with animal life. The latter signification is, in my opinion, infinitely better adapted to what fol- lows, than the former ; and I have the oest of the commentators on my side. Thus Pius : Auges tuo dulci initu, ut ita multiplicata celebria tint tt populosa. Lambinus : Celebres [terras] reddis. Creech : Reples et exornat. These commentators notice, indeed, the other acceptation, but give the preference to this. Wakefield interprets " frequentas permeas incolis agitas," all which he gets from Nonius Marcel- lus, who has " commoves." The word occurs twice in other places of Lucretius, but not in any sense that illustrates this passage. It is to be observed that the preposition con, with, is not to be considered useless ; looking to the subject of the poem, we may regard it as signifying that Venus (herself material) co-operates with mitter in yenerai to render the earth and sea fruitful. ' The ship-bearing sea and the fruit-producing earth.] Ver. 3. Qutf mars navigentm, qua terras frugiferentes Conceltbras. The words are rendered literally, except that for the relative pronoun is substi- tuted the copulative conjunction. Evelyn gives it with eoval exact- ness: \Tomfort bring and mirth To the ship-bearing seas, corn-bearing earth. Fyget, however, means fruits of the earth in general. B. i. 525. LUCRETIUS. living creature is conceived, and, springing forth, hails the light of the sun. 1 Thee, goddess, thee the winds flee ; ie- fore thee, and thy approach, the clouds of heaven disperse; for thee the variegated earth 2 puts forth 3 her fragrant flowers; on thee the waters of ocean smile, and the calmed heaven beams with effulgent 4 light. For, as soon as the vernal face of day 5 is unveiled, and the genial gale of Favonius exerts its power unconfined, the birds of the air first, O goddess, testify of thee and thy coming, smitten in heart by thy influ* ence. Next, the wild herds bound over the joyous pastures, and swim across the rapid streams. So all kinds of living creatures, captivated by thy charms and thy allurements, eagerly follow thee whithersoever thou proceedest to lead them. In fine, throughout seas, and mountains, and whelming rivers, 6 and the leafy abodes of birds, and verdant plains, thou, infusing balmy love into the breasts of all, causest them eagerly to propagate their races after their kind. Since thou alone dost govern 7 all things in nature, neither does any thing without thee spring into the ethereal realms of light, nor any thing become gladsome or lovely ; I desire thee to be my associate 8 in this my song, which I am essaying 1 Hails the light of the suru] Ver. 5. Visitque lumina solis. " Ex- oritur, prodit in lucem, hac lucis usurS frui incipit." Lambinus. 2 Variegated earth.] Ver. 7- Deedala tellus. This is the exact sig- nification of the word. " Why the earth is called Deedala hy Lu- cretius, as well as Minerva by Ennius, and Circe by Virgil, from variety of objects and contrivances, it is easy to understand, since $aia\\tiv, in Greek, signifies to vary." Festvt. s Puts forth.] Ver. 7- Submittit. " Submittere " is "de sub mit- tere," says Faber, and so says Creech, whom Wakefield follows; interpreting " sends from her lap, causes to spring de sub solo, from underneath the ground." 4 Effulgent.] Ver. 9. Diffiiso. We have the same phrase, iii. 22, JEther Integer et large diffiiso famine ridet. Vernal face of day.] Ver. 10. Species verna diet. The same as the face of vernal day ; i. e. when the spring has arrived. Species for mifais, or aspect. Comp. iv. 243. Whelming rivers.] Ver. 18. Flu'dosoue rapaces. Able to carry away rocks, trees, and other substances; of resistless strength. Virgil borrows the expression, Geo. iii. 142, " Fluviosque innare rapaces." ' Since thou alone dost govern.] Ver. 22- Qua quoniam sola yubernas. Literally, who. since thou alone governest. To avoid stiffness, I have often rendered the relative pronoun in this way. J desire thee to be my associate.] Ver. 25. Te sociam studeo es$. B 2 4 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 26-38. to compose on the NATURE OF THINGS,' for the instruction of my friend Memmius, 2 whom thou, O goddess, hast willed at all times to excel, graced with every gift. The more therefore do thou, O goddess, bestow on my words an immortal charm. Cause the fierce pursuits of war meanwhile to cease, being lulled to rest throughout all seas and lands. For thou alone canst bless mortals with tranquil peace ; since Mars, the lord of arms, who controls the cruel tasks of war, often flings 3 himself upon thy lap, vanquished by the eternal wound of love;* and thus looking up, his graceful neck 5 thrown back, he feasts his eager eyes with love, gazing intently on thee, O goddess, and his breath, as he reclines, hangs on thy It may seem absurd that divine assistance should be invoked by an Epicurean, who thinks that the gods take no interest in human af- fairs; but it is to be considered that Lucretius here writes in the character of a poet, not of a philosopher. Faber. 1 NATURE OF THINGS.] Ver. 26. Rerum natur&. By this expression Lucretius intends not merely the objects of what we call the ma- terial universe, but all that concerns man and the world in which he dwells. His full meaning is shown in iii. 1085, where, speaking of the anxieties of mankind, and their ignorance of the cause of them, he says, that if this cause were at all surmised, each, in preference to all other pursuits, would study naturam cognoscere rerum ; that he might by that means understand how little is to be feared after death, and might become one who, as Virgil expresses it, metus omnes et inexorabile fatum Subjecit pedibus, strepitumque Acherontis avari. 1 Memmius.] Ver. 27. Memmiadee nostro. Properly the son of Memmius ; or one of the Memmtada, or family of Memmius. Lam- binus thinks him the C. Memmius Gemellus, to whom Cicero ad- dresses some letters in the thirteenth book of his Epist. ad Fam. Seethe Life of Lucretius prefixed to this translation. * Since Mars who controls often flings, on herv knees, sank to the earth ; nor could it, at such a time, avail the hapless maiden that she had been the first to bless the king with the name of father. For, raised by the hands of men, and trembling, she was led to the altar; not that, the solemn service of sacrifice being performed, she might be accompanied with the loud bridal hymn ; but spotless, 1 though stained, she might, even in her wedding prime, fall a sad victim by her father's immolating hand, that a successful and fortunate voyage might be granted to the fleet. To such evils could Religion persuade mankind .' Wilt thou too, overcome by the frightful tales of bards, ever seek to turn away from me? Surely not; for doubt- less I, even now, could invent 1 for thee many dreams, which might disturb the tenor of thy life, and confound all thy enjoyments with terror. And with reason too under the present system of belief; for did men but know that there was a fixed limit to their woes, they would be able, in some measure, to defy the religious fictions and menaces of the poets; but now, since we must fear eternal pun- ishment at death, there is no mode, no means, of resisting them. For men know not what the nature of the soul is ; whether it is engendered with us, or whether, on the con- trary, it is infused into us at our birth, 2 whether it perishes with us, dissolved by death, or whether it haunts the gloomy shades and vast pools of Orcus, or whether, by divine in- fluence, it infuses itself into other animals, as our Ennius 1 1 I, even now, could invent] Ver. 105. I, as a poet, could, like other poets, invent abundance of tales, magnifying the wrath of the gods, and inculcating the probability of Tartarean punishments for errors committed in this world ; tales that would haunt thy imagin- ation, disturb thy peace of mind, and contribute to make thee the slave of anxiety and perplexity. * Is infused into us at our birth.] Ver. 114. Nascentibus insinu- etur. The same questions have been asked by other philoso- phers since Lucretius. " Relying on our acquired knowledge," says Voltaire, " we venture to discuss the question whether the soul is created before us? whether it comes from nothing into our boilirs? At what age it placed itself within us? .... Whe- ther, after animating us for a few moments, its essence is to live after us in eternity? . . These questions have an appearance of sublimity ; what are they but the questions of men born blind, disclosing the nature of light?" See more on this subject, iii. 670,. 0*9 Enuius.l Ver. 118. He was a Pythagorean, and thought that the B. I. 119-144. LUCRETIUS. 9 sung, who first brought from pleasant Helicon a crown of never-fading leaf, which should be distinguished in fame throughout the Italian tribes of men ; though in addition, how- ever, Ennius, setting it forth in deathless song, declares that there are temples of Acheron, whither neither our souls nor our bodies penetrate, but only phantoms, strangely pale, from amongst whom he relates that the apparition of undying Ho- mer, rising up before him, began to pour forth briny tears, and to expound in words the nature of things. Wherefore with reason then, not only an inquiry concerning celestial affairs is to be accurately made by us, (as by what means the courses of the sun and moon are effected, and by what influence all things individually are directed upon the earth,) but especially also we must consider, with scrutinizing examination, 1 of what the soul and the nature of the mind consist, and what it is, which, haunting us, sometimes when awake, and sometimes when overcome by disease or buried in sleep, terrifies the mind ; so that we seem to behold and to hear speaking before us, those whose bones, after death is passed, the earth embraces. Nor does it escape my consideration, that it is difficult to explain in Latin verse the profound discoveries of the Greeks, especially since we must treat of much in novel words, on account of the poverty of our language, and the novelty of the subjects. But yet thy virtues, and the expected pleasure of thy sweet friendship, prompt me to endure any labour whatsoever, and induce me to out-watch the clear cold nights, 2 weighing with what words, with what possible soul of Homer had passed into himself. Pers. Sat. vi. 10. Cicero al- ludes to the appearance of the shade of Horpar to him, Quaest. Acad. iv. 16. 1 Scrutinizing examination.] Ver. 131. Ratione sagaci. Lucretius is fond of this word. " Sagaces proprife canes dicuntur, quia inest in eis vis odorandi eximia." Lambinus. The derivation is from taffire, to perceive acutely. 2 Clear cold nights.] Ver. 143. The original is only nodes serenas. The critics are all in doubt what sort of nights to understand. Mu- retus (Var. Lect. xviii. 13) thinks they are summer nights. Wake- field, with Creech, supposes that they are merely tranquil nights, free from noise, and suitable for study. But serenus must surely have relation to the state of the atmosphere, and I think that Evelya had a right notion of the word when he gave the passage thus : But yet thy worth, and the felicity 10 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 145160 verse, 1 I may succeed in displaying to thy mind those cleat lights, by which thou mayest be able to gain a thorough in- sight into these abstruse subjects. This terror and darkness of the mind, therefore, it is not the rays of the sun, or the bright shafts of day, 2 that must dispel, but reason and the contemplation of nature; 3 of which our first princip'e shall hence take its commence- ment, THAT NOTHING 18 EVER DIVINELY 4 GENERATED FROM NOTHING. For thus it is that fear restrains all men, because they observe many things effected on the earth and in heaven, of which effects they can by no means see the causes, and therefore think that they are wrought by a divine power. For which reasons, when we shall have clearly seen that NOTHING CAN BE PRODUCED FROM NOTHING, 5 we shall then have a more accurate perception of that of which we are in search, and shall understand whence each individual thing is generated, and how all things are done without the agency of the gods. For if things came forth from nothing, 6 every kind of thing I find in thy sweet friendship, me persuade Cold nights to watch I have therefore added Evelyn's cold to Lucretius's clear. 1 With what possible verse.] Ver. 144. Quo carmine demttm. With what verse at length. 2 Bright shafts of day.] Ver. 148. Lucida tela diet. " Rays of the sun. Thus the Greeks, /3tXij ijtXtoio." Faber. Ausonius has bor- rowed the phrase, Luciferique pavent letalia tela diei. Mosell. 260. Mason, also, in his English Garden, ii. 151, " Bright darts of day." * Contemplation of nature.] Ver. 149. Naturae species. " Species, 1} Sfwpia. i) &a, that is, contemplation." Lambinus. So Faber. Wake- field would rather make it form or image ; but who will second him? 4 Divinely.] Ver. 151. Divinitus. That is, divino numine, as he has it in ver. 155. He is anxious to show, that however things are produced, the gods have nothing to do with their production. * Nothing can be produced from nothing.] Ver. 156. Nil posse creari de nihUo. It is ta be observed that the word creo was never used among the Latin writers of the better ages in the sense in which we use the word create, that is, to make out of nothing. In all but Christian theological writers it means to produce one thing from another. Gibbon has a remark to this effect in one of his notes. * If things came forth from nothing, Ac.] Ver. 160. Nam ti at nihilo Jierent, &c. If things could come from nothing, then, wher- ^ver, in the midst of things, there might be nothing existent, some- hina misht Uwnce arise; wherever there might be u vacuum (for B.I. 161 186. LUCRETIUS. H might be produced from all things ; nothing would require seed. In the first place, men might spring from the sea ; the scaly tribe, and birds, might spring from the earth ; herds, and other cattle, might burst from the sky ; the culti- vated fields, as well as the deserts, might contain every kind of wild animal, without any settled law of production : nor would the same fruits be constant to the same trees, but would be changed ; and all trees might bear all kinds of fruit. Since, when there should not be generative elements for each pro- duction, how could a certain parent-producer remain invariable for all individual things ? But now, because all things are severally produced from certain seeds, each is produced, and comes forth into the regions of light, from that spot in which the matter, and first elements of each, subsist. And for thia cause all things cannot be produced from all, inasmuch as there are distinct and peculiar faculties in certain substances. Besides, why do we see the rose put forth in spring, 1 corn in summer heat, and vines under the influence of autumn, if it be not because, when the determinate seeds of things have united together at their proper time, whatever is produced appears while the seasons are favourable, and while the vigorous earth securely brings forth her tender productions into the regions of light. But if these were generated from nothing, they might arise suddenly at indefinite periods, and at unsuitable seasons of the year, inasmuch as there would be no original elements, which might be restrained from a generative combination at any season, however inconvenient. Nor, moreover, would there be need of time for the coming together of seed 2 for the growth of things, if they could grow which he afterwards argues,) something might spring up from that vacuum. Should there be a vacuum in the sea, a man might spring from it ; should there be a vacuum in the air, a tree might flourish out of it. Seed, or originating particles, would be quite superfluous ; simple vacant space, the abode of non-entity, would suffice to pro- duce abundance of entities. The rest of the paragraph follows of course. This is his first argument on this head. I have translated fierent " came forth," as being more suitable to what follows. 1 The rose put forth in spring.] Ver. 175. This is his second argument from time. If things may spring up in any place from nothing, why should they not also spring up at any time from no- thing? * For the coming together of seed.] Ver. 185. His third aryu- 12 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 187210. out of nothing. For young men might on a sudden be formed from puny infants, and groves, springing up unexpectedly, might dart forth from the earth ; of which things it is plain that none happen, since all things grow gradually, as is fitting, from unvarying atoms, and, as they grow, preserve their kind, so that you may understand that all things individually are enlarged and nourished from their own specific matter. Add to this, that the earth cannot furnish her cheering fruits without certain rains 1 in the year; nor, moreover, can the nature of animals, if kept from food, propagate their kind, and sustain life; so that you may rather deem that many elements are common to many things, (as we see letters common to many words,) than that any thing can exist with- out its proper elements. Still further, why could not nature produce men of such 2 a size that they might ford the sea on foot, 3 and rend great moun- tains with their hands, and outlast in existence many ages of human life, if it be not because certain matter has been assigned tor producing certain things, from which matter it is fixed what can or cannot arise ? It must be admitted therefore, that no- thing can be made from nothing, since things have need of seed, from which all individually being produced, may be brought forth into the gentle air of heaven. Lastly, since we observe that cultivated places excel 4 the Uncultivated, and yield to our hands better fruits, we may see ment from natural growth. If things might grow up from nothing, why might they not be enlarged, and enlarged suddenly, from nothing? 1 Without certain rains, *rc.] Ver. 193. His fourth argument from the necessity of certain bodies for the nutriment of others. If things can- not even grow, after they had arisen, without the presence of cer- tain other matter, who, he asks, can be so foolish as to believe that they arose at first from no matter at all? 1 Produce men of such, rc.] Ver. 200. His fifth, argumetit from the definite size of animals, and other natural productions. If, for instance, men might spring from nothing, why should they not spring of a larger size from nothing ? If they could grow at all from nothing, why should they not grow to any extent whatever from nothing? 3 Ford the sea on foot.] Ver. 201. Per vada. " Like Polyphemus, Virg. jEn. iii. 665, Graditurque per aequor jam medium, nee dum fluctuslatera ardua tinxit." Lambinus. Cultivated places excel, $c.] Ver. 209. His sixth argument from the improvement of natural productions. If things sprung frc m no- . I. 211-232. LUCRETIUS. 13 that there are in the ground the primitive elements of things, which we, in turning the fertile glebe with the ploughshare, and subjugating the soil of the earth, force into birth. But were there no such seeds, you might see things severally grow up and become much better of their own accord with- out our labour. Add, too, 1 that nature resolves each thing into its own constituent elements, and DOES NOT REDUCE ANY THING TO NOTHING. lor if any thing were perishable in all its parts, every thing might then dissolve, being snatched suddenly from be- fore our eyes ; for there would be no need of force to pro- luce a separation of its parts, and break their connexion. Whereas now, since all things individually consist of eternal seed, nature does not suffer the destruction of any thing to be seen, until such power assail them as to sever them with a blow, or penetrate inwardly through the vacant spaces, and dissolve the parts. Besides, if time utterly destroys 2 whatever things it removes through length of age, consuming all their constituent matter, whence does Venus restore to the light of life the race of animals according to their kinds ? Whence does the varie- gated earth nourish and develope them, when restored, af- fording them sustenance according to their kinds ? Whence do pure fountains, and eternal rivers flowing from afar, supply the sea? 3 Whence does the aether feed the stars? For infinite thing, why might they not improve themselves from nothing, and why might we not leave them to do so ? 1 Add, too, $c.] Ver. 214. Having proved that nothing is generated from nothing, he now proceeds to prove that nothing is reduced to nothing. To this end his first argument is, that if things could be reduced or resolved into nothing, there would probably be instances seen of things falling away and vanishing suddenly into annihilation, instead of all things decaying gradually into their ele- ments as they do at present. 2 Besides, if time utterly destroys, 4rc.] Ver. 226. The second argu- ment. Things decay and are renovated ; but how could this reno- vation take place, unless there were imperishable material atoma from which they might be recruited ? * Supply the sea?] Ver. 232. Mare suppeditant. " Lambinus and Pareus take suppeditant absolutely, in the sense of suppetunt or parata tunt ; but it is better to take it actively, in the sense of supplent or subministrant." Creech. Creech's interpretation is doubtless right: the other is not in accordance with the drift of the paragraph. 14 LUCRETIUS. H. i 233256. time already past, and length of days, ought to have con- sumed all things which are of mortal consistence : but if those elements, of which this sum of things consists and is renewed, have existed through that long space, and that past duration of time, they are assuredly endowed with an immortal nature. Things' therefore cannot return to nothing. Further, the same force 1 and cause might destroy all things indiscriminately, unless an eternal matter held them more or less bound by mutual connexion. For a mere touch, indeed, would be a sufficient cause of destruction, supposing that there were no parts of eternal consistence, but all perishable, the union of which any force might dissolve. 2 But now, because various counexions of elements unite together, and matter is eternal, things continue of unimpaired consistence, until some force of sufficient strength be found to assail them, proportioned to the texture of each. No thing, therefore, relapses into non- existence, but all things at dissolution return to the first principles of matter. Lastly, you may say, perhaps, the showers of rain perish, 8 when Father ^Ether has poured them down into the lap of Mother Earth. But it is not so ; for hence the smiling fruits arise, and the branches become verdant on the trees ; the trees themselves increase, and are weighed down with produce. Hence, moreover, is nourished the race of man, and that of beasts ; hence we see joyous cities abound with youth, 4 and 1 Further, the same force, 4rc.] Ver. 239. The third argument. Why does not any one force destroy all substances, unless because they consist of different elementary atoms, intimately interwoven, and those atoms severally indestructible? Were not the atoms imperish- able, the same force that dissolves their combination might utterlj destroy them. * Might dissolve.] Ver. 244. Deberet dissolve. Would necessarily have the power of dissolving. * The showers of rain perish, $<;.] Ver. 251. Thefoitrth argument. Perhaps you incline to think that things which vanish, as showers of rain, from the face of the earth, are annihilated ; but to think thus would be folly ; for the moisture of these showers, dispersed through the ground, assists to produce corn, and all manner of fruits. So it is with other things ; the atoms of that which is dis- solved increase the substance and promote the growth of that which is rising into being. 4 Joyous cities abound with youth.] Ver. 256. Leetas urbes puerum fortre cufemtu. ' Florere is abundare ; with which acceptation of the word the genitive case suits extremely well." Waltefield. I. 257282. . LUCRETIUS. 15 the leafy woods resound on every side with newly -fledged birds; hence the weary cattle, sleek in the rich pastures, re- pose their bodies, and the white milky liquor flows from their distended udders ; hence the new offspring gambol sportive, with tottering limbs, over the tender grass, their youthful hearts exhilarated with pure milk. 1 Things, therefore, do not utterly perish, which seem to do so, since Nature recruits one thing from another, nor suffers any thing to be produced, unless its production be furthered by the death of another. Attend, now, further : 2 since i have shown that things can- not be produced from nothing, and also that, when produced, they cannot return to nothing, yet, lest haply thou shouldst begin to distrust my words, because the primary particles of things cannot be discerned by the eye, hear, in addition, what substances thou thyself must necessarily confess to exist, al- though impossible to be seen. In the first place, the force of the wind, when excited, lashes the sea, agitates the tall ships, and scatters the clouds ; at times, sweeping over the earth with an impetuous hurricane, it strews the plains with huge trees, and harasses the moun- tain-tops with forest-rending blasts ; so violently does the deep chafe with fierce roar and rage with menacing murmur. The winds, then, are invisible bodies, which sweep the sea, the land, the clouds of heaven, and, agitating them, carry them along with a sudden tornado. Not otherwise do they rush forth, and spread destruction, than as when a body of liquid water 3 is 1 Their youthful hearts exhilarated with pure milk.] Ver. 262. Lacte novo teneras percussa novellas. " Versus plank admirabilis," says Faber. So thinks Good, and translates it thus : Each little heart Quivering beneath the genuine nectar quaff* d. Why he chose to say beneath the nectar, I do not understand. The anonymous translator has it better: From their dams as the rich draughts they drain, Gladness and health flow fast through every vein. * Attend, now, further : $c.] He now proceeds to show that there are atoms, the primary particles of all things, so small as to be im- perceptible to our senses; and lest this should be doubted, he asks why such invisible particles should not exist as well as the sub- stance of the wind, and of odours, and of other matters, which, though we cannot see them, we must yet acknowledge to have ex- \stonce? This argument extends to Ver. 329. 1 A body of liquid water.] Vur. 282. Mollu aqua natura. Molr 16 LUCRETIUS. * i. 283-311 borne along in an overwhelming stream, which a vast tor- rent ' from the lofty mountains swells with large rain-floods, dashing together fragments of woods and entire groves ; nor can the strong bridges sustain the sudden force of the sweep- ing water, with such overwhelming violence does the river, turbid with copious rain, rush against the opposing mounds ; it scatters ruin with a mighty uproar, and rolls huge rocks under its waters ; it rushes on triumphant wheresoever any thing opposes its waves. Thus, therefore, must the blasts of the wind also be borne along ; which (when, like a mighty flood, they have bent their force in any direction) drive al< things before them, and overthrow them witli repeated as- saults, and sometimes catch them up in a writhing vortex rind rapidly bear them off in a whirling hurricane. Where- fore, I repeat, the winds are substances, though invisible, since in their effects, and modes of operation? they are found to rival mighty rivers, which are of manifest bodily -substance. Moreover we perceive various odours of objects, and yet never see them approaching our nostrils. Nor do we behold violent heat, or distinguish cold with our eyes ; nor are we in the habit of viewing sounds ; all which things, however, must of necessity consist of a corporeal nature, since they have the power of striking the senses: FOR NOTHING, EXCEPT BODILY SUBSTANCE, CAN TOUCH OR BE TOUCHED. Further, garments, when suspended upon a shore on which waves are broken, grow moist ; the same, when spread out in the sun, become dry ; yet neither has it been observed how the moisture of the water settled in them, nor, on the other hand, how it escaped under the influence of the heat. The lit fpr liquid or fluid, as the Delphin editor justly observes. Comp. ii. 375. Virg. JEn. v. 817- 1 Which a vast torrent, kc.~\ Ver. 283. Flumine abundanti, quern magnut decursus aquai. The quern is the reading from certain codicet of Wakefield, who says that Lucretius, in using the mascu- line gender, had in his mind the more general word ./&?*. By such methods any thing apparently inexplicable may be explained. The quern should either be quod, as Lambinus and Havercamp have it, or we must suppose Lucretius to have used/uwew in the masculine gender. 1 Modes of operation.} Ver. 297. Moribut. Metaphorically, as if they were human beings. B. i. 312-33-5. LUCRETIUS. 17 moisture, therefore, is dispersed into minute particles, which our eyes can by no means perceive. Besides, in the course of many revolutions of the sun, 1 a ring upon the finger is made somewhat thinner by wearing V; the fall of the drop from the eaves hollows a stone ; the crooked share of the plough, though made of iron, impercep- tibly decreases in the fields ; even the stone pavements of the streets we see worn by the feet of the multitude ; and the brazen statues, which stand near the gates, show their right hands made smaller by the touch of people frequently saluting them, and passing by. These objects, therefore, after they have been worn, we observe to become diminished ; but what particles take their departure on each particular occasion, jealous nature has withheld from us the faculty of seeing. 2 Lastly, whatever substances time and nature add little by little to objects, obliging them to increase gradually, those substances no acuteness of vision, however earnestly exerted, can perceive ; nor, moreover, whatever substances waste away through age and decay ; nor can you discern what the rocks, which overhang the sea, and are eaten by the corroding salt 3 of the ocean, lose every time that they are washed by the waves. Nature, therefore, carries on her operations by imperceptible particles. Nor, however, 4 5 are all things held enclosed by corporeal substance ; for there is a VOID in things ; a truth which it will be useful for you, in reference to many points, to know ; and which will prevent you from wandering in doubt, and from perpetually inquiring about the ENTIRE OF THINGS, and from being distrustful of my words. Wherefore, I say, there is space INTANGIBLE, EMPTY, and VACANT. If this were not the case, 1 Many revolutions of the sun.] Ver. 312. Multis solis redeuntibut annis. " Solis anni are anni solares, solar years." Havercamp, 3 Faculty of seeing.] Ver. 322. Speciem videndi. " Facultatem." Creech. 3 Corroding salt.] Ver. 327. Vesco sale. " Lucretius has used vesr.us for edax or consuming, when he says, nee, mare qua impendent, vesco sale saxa peresa." Festus. 4 Nor, however.] Ver. 330. By an error of the press, these words are not made to commence a new paragraph in Forbiger's edition ; which they do in Wakefield's, and all other editions. 5 Ib. He now proceeds to demonstrate that there is a VACUUM in things ; space empty and intangible. His arguments seem suffi- ciently intelligible to require no exposition. c 18 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 336365. things could by no means be moved ; for that which is th* quality of body, namely, to obstruct and to oppose, would be present at all times, and would be exerted against all bodies; no- thing, therefore, would be able to move forward, since nothing would begin to give way. But now, throughout the sea and land and heights of heaven, we see many things moved before our eyes in various ways and by various means, which, if there were no void, would not so much want their active motion, as being deprived of it, as they would, properly speaking, never by any means have been produced at all; 1 since matter, crowded together on all sides, would have remained at rest and have been unable to act. Besides, although some things may be regarded as solid, yet you may, for the following reasons, perceive them to be of a porous consistence. In rocks and caves, the liquid mois- ture of the waters penetrates their substance, and all parts weep, a* it were, with abundant drops ; food distributes itself through the whole of the body in animals ; the groves in- crease, and yield their fruits in their season, because nourish- ment is diffused through the whole of the trees, even from the lowest roots, over all the trunks and branches ; voices pass through the walls, and fly across the closed apartments of houses ; keen frost 2 penetrates to the very marrow of our bones ; which kind of effects, unless there were void spaces in bodies, where the several particles might pass, you would never by any means observe to take place. Lastly, why do we see some things exceed other things in weight, though of no greater shape and bulk? For, if there is just as much substance in a ball of wool as there is in a ball of lead, it is natural that they should weigh the same, since it is the property of all bodily substance to press every thing downwards ; but the nature of a VOID, on the contrary, continues without weight. That body, therefore, which is equally 1 Would not so much want their active motion, (as being deprived y it,) as they would, properly speaking, never by any means hava been produced at all.] Ver. 344. Non tarn spllicito motu privata carerent, Quam genita omnino nulla ratione fuissent. The construction of the English appears awkward, but answers ex- actly to the Latin. Frot.} Ver. 356 He considered cold and heat as material and active substances. Comp. ver. 495. s. i. 366-398. LUCRETIUS. 19 large with another, and is evidently lighter, shows plainly that it contains a greater portion of VACUITY. But the heavier body, on the other hand, indicates that there is in it more material substance, and that it comprises much less empty space. That, therefore, which we are now, by the aid of searching argument, investigating, that, namely, which we call VOID ; is doubtless mixed among material substances. In considering these matters, I am obliged to anticipate that objection which some imagine, lest it should seduce you from the truth. They say, for instance, that water yields to fishes pushing forwards, and opens liquid passages, since the fish leave spaces behind them, into which the yielding waters may make a conflux ; so also that other things may be moved among themselves, and change their place, although all parts of space be full. But this notion, it is evident, has been wholly conceived from false reasoning. For in what direc- tion, I pray, will fish be able to go forward, if the water shall not give them room ? Or in what direction, moreover, will the water have power to yield, supposing the fish shall have no power to go forward to divide it? Either, therefore, we must deny motion to all bodies whatsoever, or we must admit that vacuity is more or less inherent in all material substances, whence every thing that moves derives the first commence- ment of its motion. Lastly, if two broad and flat bodies, after having come in- to collision, suddenly start asunder, it is clear that air must necessarily take possession of all the vacuum which is then formed between the bodies. And further, although that air may quickly unite to flow into the vacancy, with blasts blowing rapidly from all sides, yet the whole space will not be able to be filled at once ; for the air must of necessity occupy some part first, then another, till in succession all parts be occupied. But if any person perchance, when the bodies have started asunder, thinks that that separation is thus effected by reason that the air condenses itself, he is in error ; for a vacuum is then formed between the bodies, which was not there before, and the part likewise behind the bodies, which was vacant be- fore, is filled ; nor can air be condensed in such a way ; nor, even if it could, would it have the power, I think, to draw /- self into itself, 1 and unite its particles together without the aid 1 To draw itself into itself.] Ver. 398. Ipse in se trahere. Lam- c 2 20 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 3S*9 421. of a void. For which reason, although you may long hesitate, alleging many objections, you must nevertheless at last con- fess that there is vacuum in bodies. I have the ability, moreover, to collect credit for my doc- trines, 1 by adducing many additional arguments. But these small traces which I have indicated will be sufficient for a sa- gacious mind ; traces by which, indeed, you yourself may dis- cover others. For as dogs, when they have once lighted upon certain tracks on the path, very frequently find by their scent the lair of a wild beast that ranges over the mountains, though covered over with leaves ; so you yourself will be able, in such matters as these, to note, of your own sagacity, one principle after another, and to penetrate every dark obscurity, and thence to elicit truth. But if you shall be slow to assent, Memmius, or if you shall at all shrink back from the subject, I can still certainly give you the following assurance. My tongue, so agreeable to you, will have the power of pouring forth from my well- stored breast such copious draughts 2 from mighty sources, that 1 fear lest slow old ags may creep over our limbs, and break down the gates of life within us, before all the abundance of arguments in my verses, concerning any one subject, can have been poured into your ears. But now, that I may re- sume my efforts to complete in verse the weaving of the web which I have begun, give me a little more of your attention. As it is, therefore, all nature of itself has consisted, and consists, of two parts ; for there are bodily substances, and binus, Creech, and others, give Se ipse in se trahere. Wakefield pronounces the Se before ipse to be sitffarcinatwm, reclamantibia et renitentibiu multis libris et codicibus. So the readers of Wakefield and Forbiger (whom Lachmann follows) must understand se, or suppose trahere to be used absolutely. 1 Collect credit for my doctrines.] Ver. 402. Multaque praeterea tibi possum commemorando Argumenta fidem dictis conadere nostris. Porbiger and Wakefield leave these lines without any point ; Ha- vercamp puts a comma after argumenta, as is necessary, to prevent misconstruction. ' Such Copious draughts.] Ver. 413. "He signifies that he will rth, it necessary, such a profusion of arguments drawn from doctrine of Epicurus, that it is to be feared lest Memmius and ilf should grow old and die, before Memmius has understood uj one subject or heard it to an end." Lambimw B.i. 422-432. LUCRETIUS. 21 vacant space, in which these substances are situate, and in which they are moved in different directions. For the com- mon perception of all men shows that there is corporeal con- sistence ; l of the existence of which, unless the belief shall be first firmly established, there will be no principle by reference to which we may succeed, by any means whatever, in settling the mind with argument concerning matters not obvious to sense. To proceed then, if there were no place, 2 and no space which we call vacant, bodies could not be situated any where, nor could at all move any whither in different directions ; a fact which we have shown to you a little before. Besides, there is nothing 3 which you can say is separate from all bodily substance, and distinct from empty space ; 1 The common perception of all men shows that there is corpo- real consistence.] Ver. 423. Corpus enim per se communis dedicat esse Sensus. The common perception of all men, in all parts of the world, in all ages. " This especially Epicurus resolutely maintains, that the senses are to be trusted, and never deceive us ; and that from the senses all knowledge and understanding of all things com- mences. So in ver. 694 of this book, Lucretius says it is the senses unde omnia credita pendent. " Faber. Epicurus establishes the exist- ence of corporeal substance in the manner in which Johnson said that he refuted the doctrine of Berkeley, by striking his foot against a post. This was also the "common sense" method of Reid and his disciples ; and which of us all, however we may reason, does not act upon it? To Berkeley has been imputed a thousand and a thousand times that which he never believed or imagined. Lucretius adds, that unless the existence of corporeal substance be acknowledged, there will be no principle from which to reason on things in general. 2 To proceed then, if there were no place, #] Ver. 427. This paragraph is to be understood thus : Unless there be space, where can bodies be situated ? and unless there be somewhere vacuity, how can they move? He says he has shown that bodies could not move without a vacuum " a little before." See ver. 371, seq. 3 Besides, there is nothing, #e.j Ver. 431, seq. On this para- Iraph I have to make these observations. In ver. 433, tertia numero, have omitted the latter word. Ever so diminutive is given for parvo denique. Shall be sensible to the touch, is in the original tactus erit, Faber explaining tactus to mean tactilitas in a passive sease. See ver. 455. Increase the number of bodies, is Corporis augebit numerum, which might be rendered, increase the quantity of body. Lambinus and Cinpch, however, read corporum; and I have accordingly pre- ferred to put bodies in the plural, and to render the succeeding words, summamque sequetur, " will be ranked in the multitude <>/ them." f 22 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 433462. which would, indeed, be as it were a third kind of nature. For whatsoever shall exist, must in itself be something, either of large bulk, or ever so diminutive, provided it be at all : when, if it shall be sensible to the touch, however light and delicate, it will increase the number of bodies, and be ranked in the multitude of them ; but if it shall be intangible, inas- much as it cannot hinder in any part any object proceeding to pass through it, it then, you may be sure, will be the empty space which we call a vacuum. Moreover, whatsoever shall exist of itself, will either do something, or will be obliged TO SUFFER other things acting upon it, or will simply BE, so that other things may exist and be done in it. But nothing can DO or SUFFER without being possessed of bodily substance, nor, moreover, afford place for acting and suffering, unless it be empty and vacant space. No third nature, therefore, distinct in itself, besides vacant space and material substance, can possibly be left undiscovered in the sum of things; no third kind of being, which can at any time fall under the notice of our senses, or which any one can find out by the exercise of his reason. For whatsoever other things are said to be, 1 you will find them to be either necessary ADJUNCTS of these two things, or accidents of them. A necessary ADJUNCT is that which can never be separated and disjoined from its body without a dis- union attended with destruction to that body ; as the weight of a stone, the heat of fire, the fluidity of water ; sensibility to touch in all bodies, insensibility to touch in empty space. On the other hand, such things as slavery, poverty, riches, liberty, war, concord, and other things, by the coming or going of which the nature of the subject affected remains uninjured, these we are accustomed (as is proper) to call ACCIDENTS. Time, likewise, is not an existence in itself, but it is merely our understanding that collects from things themselves what HAS BEEN DONE in the past age ; what also is PRESENT ; what, moreover, MAY FOLLOW afterwards. And it must be owned 1 For whatsoever other things are said to be, $c.~\ Ver. 450. These observations about adjuncts, and events or accidents, are sufficiently clear to require no comment. The observations about Helen being carried off, &., are, says Creech, nugae dialectical, which Lucretius would not have inserted, but that to oppose the Stoics made it necessary. B. i. 463-488. LUCRETIUS. 23 that no one has conceived of time existing by itself apart from progressive motion and quiet rest. Moreover, when writers say that Helen WAS carried off, and that the Trojan people WERE subdued in war, we must take care lest, perchance, those writers induce us to admit that those events, viz. the abduction of Helen and the subjugation of the Trojans, WERE of themselves ; when time, irrevocably past, has carried away those generations of men, of whom these transactions were the events or accidents. For what- ever shall have been done, will properly be called an event or accident, whether occurring to lands, or to legions 1 (that is, men] themselves. Furthermore, if there were not this bodily substance in things, nor this room and space in which all things severally are done, the flame lighted up by the love of Helen's beauty, spreading through the breast of the Phrygian Paris, would never have kindled the famous contests of cruel warfare ; nor would the wooden horse have secretly set fire to the citadel of the Trojans by a nocturnal delivery of Greeks. So that you may plainly see that all transactions whatsoever do not CONSIST or EXIST of themselves, as body does, nor are spoken of as existing in the same way as a vacuum exists ; but rather that you may justly call them events or accidents of body, or of space in which all transactions are brought to pass. Bodies, besides, are partly original elements 2 of things, and partly those which are formed of a combination of those ele- ments. But those which are elements of things, no force can break ; for they successfully resist all force by solidity of sub- stance; although, perhaps, it seems difficult to believe that 1 To lands, or to legions.] Ver. 470. Namque aliud terris, aliud legionibus ipsis Eventum dici poterit, quodquomque erit actum. " Whatever things have occurred, you may justly say have happened to certain men or to certain lands (for there is no third, besides men and things); but you cannot rightly say that those events were; time, therefore, to which they belonged, is not; nor t there any thing in rerum natura besides body and space." Wakefield. * Bodies, besides, are partly original elements, (Src.] Ver. 486. Hav- ing proved that there is nothing that can be said to exist absolutely, except body and space ; he proceeds to distinguish body into two kinds, simple and compound, and to prove that simple body, of the simple primary particles of all substance, must be solid. 24 LfC'RETIUS. B. i. 489-^513. any thing of so solid a substance can be found in nature ; for the lightning of heaven passes through the walls of houses, as also noise and voices pass; iron glows, being penetrated by heat, in the fire ; rocks often burst with fervent heat ; the hardness of gold, losing its firmness, is dissolved by heat ; the icy coldness of brass, overcome by flame, melts ; heat, and penetrable cold, enter into the substance of silver, for we have felt both with the hand, when, as we held silver cups after our fashion, 1 water was poured into them from above ; so that, as far as these instances go, there seems to be nothing solid in nature. But because, however, right reason, and the nature of things, compel me to hold a contrary opinion, grant me your attention a while, until I make it plain, in a few- verses, that there really exist such bodies as are of a solid and eternal corporeal substance ; which bodies we prove to be seeds and primary particles of things, of which the whole genoroted universe now consists. In the first place, since a two-fold nature 2 of two things, a two-fold nature, or rather two natures extremely dissimilar, has been found to exist, namely, matter, and space in which every thing is done, it must necessarily be that each exists by itself for itself, independently of the other, and pure from ad- mixture; for wheresoever there is empty space, which we call a vacuum, there there is no matter, and, likewise, wheresoever matter maintains itself, there by no means exists empty space. Original substances are therefore solid and without vacuity. Furthermore, since in things which are produced, 3 or com' 1 As we held silver cups after our fashion.] Ver. 496. Manu reti- nentes pocula rite. I have added the word silver from Creech's in- terpretation. Lucretius seems to have had in his imagination a guest at a feast, holding up his cup partly filled with wine, for an attendant to pour hot or cold water into it. They mixed cold water with their wine in summer, and hot in winter. * In the first place, since a two-fold nature, $c.] Ver. 504. Solid body and vacant space must exist distinct from each other ; for where there is space that is not vacant, it must be filled with solid body ; and in space which is filled with solid body there can be no vacuity. 3 Furthermore, since in things which are produced, *c.l Ver. 512. He has proved that vacuum exists; and it must accordingly exist among compound bodies ; but that which bounds it must be solid, or vacuum would bound vacuum ; and this solid may he a B i. 513- 636. LUCRETIUS. 25 Bounded oj 'matter ', there is foundevapty space, solid matter must exist around it; nor can any thing be proved by just argu- ment to conceal vacuity, and to contain it within its body, unless you admit that that which contains it is a solid. But that solid can be nothing but a combination of matter, such as may have the power of keeping a vacuity enclosed. That matter, therefore, which consists of solid body, may be eternal, while other substances, which are only compounds of this mat- ter, may be dissolved. In addition, too, 1 if there were no space to be vacant and unoccupied, all space would be solid. On the other hand, unless there were certain bodies to fill up completely the places which they occupy, all space, which any where exists, would be an empty void. Body, therefore, is evidently distinct from empty space, though each has its place alternately ; since all space neither exists entirely full, nor, again, entirely empty. There exist, therefore, certain bodies which can completely Jill the places which they occupy, and distinguish empty space from full. These bodies, which thus completely Jill space, can neither be broken 2 in pieces by being struck with blows externally, nor, again, can be decomposed by being penetrated internally ; nor can they be made to yield if attempted by any other method ; a principle which we have demonstrated to you a little above ; for neither does it seem possible for any thing to be dashed in pieces without a vacuum, nor to be broken, nor to be divided into two by cutting ; nor to admit moisture, nor, moreover, subtle cold, nor penetrating fire, by which operations and combination of solid original particles ; and, though this compound solid may be dissolved, yet the original solid atoms of whicn it is composed remain imperishable. This 1 consider to be the drift of the argument in the text, which, perhaps from some corruption. seems not very clear. Lambinus has this comment : " Generated 4hings have vacuity within them ; otherwise they would not peristt> or be dissolved. But if they perish because they have vacuity how infinitely gJeate? a va- 8 "" f rm > bein * so incalfulaWy mor, Mark, as my easy verse spontaneous flows, How common letters various words compose, T^diffe/Sl vT E - Se ' and W r / from word > be found ;r widely, both in sense and sound- Arid hence convicted, let thy reason own Wl it wondrous change position forms alone. In , Xlrt^Tff ""A' more 1 nu m'rous far, unite In all the different forms that greet the light. Dmmmond. B. I. 838872. LUCRETIUS. 4t from many drops of blood meeting together ; he is of opinion, moreover, that gold may consist of crumbs of gold, and that earth may be a concrete of little earths ; that fire may be from fires, and moisture from moistures. Other things he ima- gines and supposes to be produced in a similar way. Yet he does not allow that there is any where a void in things, or that there is any limit to the division of bodies. Wherefore in both these respects he seems to me to err equally with those of whom we have before spoken. Add to this, that he supposes principles which are too frail, if, indeed, they are principles which are made to be endowed with like nature as the things themselves that are produced from them, and equally suffer and decay ; nor does any thing withhold them from destruction. For what portion of them will endure under violent oppression, so as to escape dissolu- tion under the very teeth of death ? Will it be fire, or moisture, or air ? which of these ? Or will it be blood, or bone ? Not one of all those substances, as I conceive ; since every thing uni- versally will be equally perishable as those things which we see manifestly perish from before our eyes, when overcome by any violence. But I call to witness the positions which I have before proved, that neither can things be reduced to no- thing, nor again grow up from nothing. Moreover, since food augments and nourishes the body, we may understand that veins, and blood, and bones, and nerves, consist of heterogeneous parts. Or, if these philosophers shall say that all food is of a mixed substance, and contains in itself small elements of nerves and bones, and also veins and par- ticles of blood, it will follow, that Vnth all solid food, and liquid itself, must be thought to consist of such heterogeneous matters, and to be mixed up of bones, and nerves, and veins, and blood. Besides, if whatever bodies grow from the earth are previously latent in the earth, earth must consist of all those heterogeneous matters which spring from earth. Transfer this reasoning to other objects, and you may likewise use the same phraseology : in wood, for instance, if there is ossa et cutem est." Servius ad Virg. JEn. vii 253. The text might be rendered, "flesh is generated irom small and minute fleshes." Evelyn took it in the sense of entrails: " That entrailt do of little entrials breed." 42 LUCRETIUS. B i 873889. concealed flame, and smoke, and ashes, wood must necessarily consist of the heterogeneous particles of those substances. Here some slight opportunity is left to this sect of philoso- phers for eluding the arguments of their adversaries; an oppor- tunity of which Anaxagoras avails himself, by alleging that although he thinks all things lie-secretly mixed witli all things,yet that that alone appears on the surface of each, of which there are most particles mixed in the composition of each, and placed more as it were in readiness and in front ; which, however, is far removed from just reasoning. For, if this hypothesis were correct, it might-naturally-be-expected also that corn, when it is broken by the overwhelming force of the mill-stone, 1 would exhibit some token of blood, 2 or some- thing of those substances which are nourished in our bodies ; (that when we rub stone against stone, blood should flow;) in like manner, also, it would be probable that herbs would send forth drops of a sweet liquid, and of similar taste, such as are the drops of milk, that issue from the udder of the sheep. And, without doubt, we might also suppose that fre- quently, when clods of earth are broken, rudiments of the several kinds of herbs, and corn, and leaves of trees would ap- pear scattered about, and be proved to lie hid in the earth in 1 Overwhelming force of the mill-stone.] Ver. 880. Minaci robore taxi. "Minaci, poetically for terrible and formidable, and therefore great and heavy." Wakefield. 2 Exhibit some token of blood.] Ver. 881. Mittere signum sangui- nit. If blood, according to Anaxagoras, comes from drops of blood, and blood is produced in our bodies by the medium of corn, surely we should, says Lucretius, on crushing corn, sometimes find drops of blood in it. What follows, " that when we rub stone against stone blood should flow," Qunm lapidem in lapidem terimus manare cniorem, is a verse which Faber, Preiger, Havercamp, and Bentley concur in condemning as spurious, and which, though preserved and de- fended by Wakefield, even Forbiger himself, following Eichstadt, has, ventured to include in brackets. It evidently encumbers the text uselessly. " It seems to have been written in the margin," ays Forbiger, " by some one who thought that the words fruget robore taxi franguntur required a more accurate explanation, and who had in his mind the passage of Plautus, Asin. i. 1, 16, num. me \lluc ducit, ubi lapis lapidem ferit t " There seems to be much plausi- bility in this conjecture. Whoever made the verse, the upper and nether mill-stone, which crush the corn between them, are plainlf intended Lachmann, to my surprise, preserves the verse. B. i. 890-917. LUCRETIUS. 43 minute particles ; moreover that in wood, when it is broken, ashes, and smoke, and small particles of fire would be found to lie concealed. Of which occurrences, since manifest expe- rience shows that none take place, we may understand that substances are not so mixed with substances ; but, if Anax- agoras were right, the common seeds of many things must lie secretly mixed, in many ways, among other things. But, you will say, it often happens that on the high moun- tains, the extreme tops of tall trees, when near to one another, are rubbed together, the strong south winds compelling them to act thus, until they shine with a flash of flame bursting forth. It is so. And yet the fire is not inherent in the wood, but there are in it many seeds of heat, which, when they have become confluent by friction, produce a conflagration in the woods. But if positive flame 1 were hidden in the woods, the fire could not be concealed for any length of time, but would openly consume the forests, and burn up the groves. Do you now see, therefore, (what we remarked a little be- fore,) that it is frequently of great consequence with what other elements and in what position the same elements are combined, and what motions they reciprocally impart and re- ceive? And that the same elements a little altered 2 in respect to each other, produce fire from wood, ignes e lignis, just as also the words themselves consist of elements or letters a lit- tle changed, when we denote wood and fire, ligna atque ignes, by distinct appellations. Finally, if you think that whatever things you see in the visible world, could not be conceived to have been formed without supposing the primary particles of matter to be en- dowed with a nature similar to the things formed from them, your original elements of things, by this hypothesis, become 1 But if positive flame.] Ver. 903. Quod si facto flamma. " Facta fiamma is flame already formed, and collected into a vivid body, its seeds having combined; and, if this flame lay hid in the woods, it might suddenly burst forth, and destroy all surrounding objects with fire." Wakefield. So also Preiger. See Thucydides. ii. 77. 2 And that the same elements a little altered, $c.] Ver. 910. At* que eadem, paulo inter se mutata creare Ignes & lignis. As we denote dissimilar things by different words, lignum et ignem, (wood and fire,) by changing a little the letters of the alphabet, some being added, and some token away." Lambinus. 44 LUCRETIUS. B. I. 918-937 mere absurdities, and fall to the ground. 1 For the consequence of such a supposition will be, that you must have primary particles which, as the origin of laughter, are themselves con- vulsed with tremulous fits of laughter, and others which, as the originals of weeping, bedew their own faces and cheeks with salt tears. And now give me your attention as to what remai learn and hear more fully and plainly. Nor does it escape my knowledge how obscure these matters are; but the great hope of praise has struck my heart with her powerful thyrsus, and has at the same time infused into my breast a pleasing love of the Muses, with which inspired I now wander, in vigorous thought, over the trackless regions of the Pierides, trodden before by the foot of no poet. It delights me to ap- proach the untasted fountains, and to drink ; and it transports me to pluck the fresh flowers, and to obtain a distinguished chaplet for my head from those groves whence the Muses have hitherto veiled the temples of no one. In the first place, be- cause I give instruction concerning mighty subjects, and pro- ceed to free the mind from the closely-confining shackles of Religion ; in the next place, because I compose such lucid verses concerning so obscure a subject; touching every thing with the grace of poetry. Since such ornament also seems not unjustifiable or without reason. But as physicians, when they attempt to give bitter wormwood to children, first tinge the rim round the cup with the sweet and yellow liquid of 1 Your original elements fall to the ground.] Ver. 917. Hac ratione tibi pereunt primordia rerum. Fiet uti risu tremulo concussa cachinnent, Et lacrymis salsis humectent ora genasque. " If any one shall suppose that none of those things which are seen by our eyes, can be produced otherwise than from similar elements, his elements, by this very supposition, will be done away with, for they will be no longer elements, but concrete, and even animated and rational, substances. For, since men are produced from ele- ments, and since men sometimes laugh and sometimes weep, it will follow that the elements of which men themselves consist, have the faculties of laughing and weeping; which will be most absurd." Lambinus. Some have thought that there must be verses lost between the first and second of these three lines ; and there certainly is an abruptness in the passage which greatly justifies such a supposition. B. L 938-961. LUCRETIUS. 45 honey, that the age of childhood, as yet unsuspicious, 1 may find its lips deluded, and may in the mean time drink up the bitter juice of the wormwood, and, though deceived, may not be injured, but rather, recruited by such a process, may ac- quire strength : so now I, since this argument seems ge- nerally too severe and forbidding to those by whom it has not been handled, and since the multitude shrink back from it, was desirous to set forth my chain-of-reasoning to thee, Mem.' ntius, in sweetly-speaking Pierian verse, and, as it were, to tinge it with the honey of the Muses ; if perchance, by such a method, I might detain thy attention upon my strains, until thou lookest through the whole NATURE OF THINGS, and vnderstandest with what shape and beauty it is adorned. But since I have taught that atoms of matter, entirely solid, pass-to-and-lro perpetually, unwasted through all time ; come now, and let us unravel whether there be any limit 2 to their aggregate, or not ; also, let us look into that which has been found to be vacancy, or the room and space in which things severally are done, and learn whether the whole is entirely limited, or extends unbounded and unfathomably profound. All that exists, therefore, / affirm? is bounded in no di- rection ; for, if it were bounded, it must have some extremity ; but it appears that there cannot be an extremity of any thing, unless there be something beyond, which may limit it ; so that there may appear to be some line farther than which 4 this faculty of our sense (i. e. our vision) cannot extend. Now, 1 Age of childhood, as yet unsuspicious.] Ver. 938. Puerorum tetas improvida. Find its lips deluded.] Ludificetur labrorum temis, may be deceived as far as the lips (are concerned). Though de- ceived, may not be injured.] Deceptaque non capiatur. " Decepti non damnum aliquod patiantur." Creech. * Whether there be any limit, $e.] Ver. 950, seq. He now pro- ceeds to consider whether matter and space be infinite or not. 8 All that exists, therefore, / affirm, i$c.~\ Ver. 957. He asserts that all tbat exists, both matter and the space which contains it, is bounded in no direction, (nulla regione Monmt,) inasmuch as it is possible to find no extremity of it. 4 So that there may appear to be some line farther than which, $c.] Ver. 960. ut videatur, Qw3 non longius hcec sentus natura sequatur. 1 have followed Lambhius, who interprets thus : ut videatur, that 46 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 962 since it must be confessed that there is nothing beyond the WHOLE, the whole has no extremity ; nor does it matter at what part of it you stand, 1 with a view to being distant from its boundary; inasmuch as, whatever place any one occupies, he leaves the WHOLE just as much boundless in every direction. B3sides, if all space which is, be supposed to be bounded, and if any one should go forward as far as possible, even to what he thinks its extreme limits, and should throw, or attempt to throw, a flying dart, 2 whether would yon have that dart, hurled with vigorous strength, go on in the direction in which it may have been propelled, and fly far forwards, or do you rather prefer to think that something would have power to hinder and stop it ? For one of the two alternatives you must there may be seen, namely, somelimiting extremity, quolongius, i. e. ultra quod, beyond which, htec natura tensvs, this faculty of vision or sight, non sequatur, cannot extend and exert its power. Evelyn translates, in like manner, So that one may discern the utmost space, Than which no farther it our sense can trace. I shall not spend time upon Creech's ex quo videri possit, except so far as to observe, that he seems to have led astray the author of the old prose version, who gives this wonderful note : " Whatever has an extreme may be seen by what is without or beyond it. Now the Universe, or the All, is not seen by any thing that is beyond it ; therefore the Universe has no extreme." 1 Nor does it matter at what part of it you stand.] Ver. 964. Nee refert quibus assistas regionibus ejus. " In quibus partibus con- sistas." Creech. Locke, showing that our idea of space is boundless, says, (Essay, book i. ch. 17, 4,) " Wherever the mind places itself by any thought, either amongst or remote from all bodies, it can, in this uniform idea of space, no where find any bounds or ends, and so must necessarily conclude it, by the very nature and idea of each part of it, to be actually infinite." 2 Throw a flying dart.] Ver. 969. Jaciatque volatile telum. If you suppose that there is a boundary to the universe, fix on the place where you think it lies, and try to throw a dart beyond it; the dart will either pass beyond it, or will be stopped by some opposing body : if it passes beyond it, you have not fixed the boundary of the universe ; if it is stopped by any body, there is something be- yond your supposed boundary. Ultimus, ver. 969, I have rendered as jar as possible. As to finique locet se, ver. 977, I have taken Creech's interpretation, who exp'.ains the whole passage thus : Quo minus earn partem, in quam destination fuit, attingat, ibique tanquam in ternnno se tistat. " Whither it were sent, it could not tend." Evelyn B. i. 9741002. LUCRETIUS. 4? of necessity admit and adopt ; of which alternatives either cuts off escape from you, and compels you to grant that the WHOLE extends without limit. Since whether there is any thing to stop the javelin, and to cause that it may not go on in the direction in which it was aimed, and fix itself.at the destined termination of its flight, or whether it is borne onwards be- yond the supposed limit, it evidently did not began-its-flight from a boundary of the WHOLE. In this manner I will go on with you, and wheresoever you shall fix the extreme margin of space, I will ask you what then would be the case with the javelin. The case will be, that a limit can no where exist ; and that room for the flight of the javelin will still extend its flight. Further, if all the space of the entire WHOLE were shut-in and bounded on all sides by certain limits, the quantity of matter in the universe would before this time have flowed together to the bottom, by reason of its solid weight ; nor could any thing be carried on beneath the canopy of heaven ; nor, indeed, would there be a heaven at all, or light of the sun ; for all matter, from sinking down for an infinite space of time, would be accumulated at the bottom of the WHOLE. But now, it is evident, no rest is given to the atoms of the primary-elements ; because no part of the universe is com- pletely and fundamentally lowest, whither the atoms might, as it were, flow together, and where they might fix their seat ; and therefore all things are always carried on in all parts in perpetual motion, and the lowest atoms of matter, or those which we may conceive to be the lowest, stirred up from the infinite of space, are supplied for the generation of things. Moreover, in things before our eyes, object seems to bound object ; the air sets-a-boundary-to the hills, and the hills to the air ; the land limits the sea, and the sea, on the other hand, limits the entire land ; but, as to the WHOLE, there is nothing beyond it that can bound it. The nature, therefore, of space, and the extent of the profound whole, is such a vast, which neither famous rivers, 1 in their course, can run through, 1 Famous rivers.] Ver. 1002. Clara flumina. " Celebres fluvii," says Creech; and"nobiles fluvii," says the Delphin editor, who adds, renowned " for their rapidity, as the Rhone, Danube, tfc." Be it so. Faber advocated fulmina, thinking that it suited belter with clara, and Lachmann has adopted it. Flumina, however, if more in accordance with labentia in the next verse. 48 LUCRETIUS. B. i. 1003-1022 though flowing for an eternal length of time, nor, by passing on, can at all cause that less distance should remain for them to go. To such a degree, on every side, vast abundance of room lies open for all things, all limit being set aside every where and in .every direction. Besides, Nature herself prevents the WHOLE OF THINGS from being able to provide bounds for itself, inasmuch as she compels body to be bounded by that which is vacuum, and that which is vacuum to be bounded by body ; that so, by this alternate bounding rf one by the other, she may render ALL infinite. 1 Else, moreover, if one or other of these did not bound the other by its simple nature, so that one of them, the vacuum for instance, should extend unlimited, neither the sea, nor the land, nor the bright temples of heaven, 2 nor the race of mortals, nor the sacred persons of the gods, could subsist for the small space of an hour. For the body of matter, driven abroad from its union, would be borne dispersed through the mighty void, or rather, in such a case, never having been united, would never have produced any thing, since, when originally scattered, it could not have been brought together. For certainly neither the primary elements of things dis- posed themselves severally in their own order, by their own counsel or sagacious understanding ; nor, assuredly, did they agree among themselves what motions each should produce ; 1 Render all infinite.] Ver. 1010. Infinite omnia reddat. " Uni- versum reddat interminatum." Creech. Perhaps I should rather have translated it, may render all things infinite, that is, produce an infinite variety of things by the alternate mixture of matter and vacuum. So that with one and other She renders all things infinite together. Evelyn. 9 Bright temples of heaven.] Ver. 1013. Cceli lucida templa. I have rendered it literally temples, but I should perhaps say that it means spaces, quarters, divisions, regions, the derivation generally adopted being from rifivia, r^ti5, to cut; temulutn, temlum. templum, as," says Mr. Valpy, " Eximo, Exemulum, Exemlum, Exemplum." Ci- cero quotes cceli ccerula templa from Ennius. The augurs, when about to take omens, divided the heaven into templa, as the astrologers of later days divided it into houses. At the beginning of the second Book occurs templa serena, in reference to learning and wisdom, which 1 have rendered terene heights. And ver. 1063, I have trans lated -ctli templa, "upper parts of heaven." H. I. 10231049. LUCRETIUS. 49 but because, being many, and changed in many ways, they are for an infinite space of time agitated, being acted upon by forces, throughout the WHOLE, they thus, by experiencing movements and combinations of every kind, at length settle into such positions, by which means, (i. e. positions,} 1 this SUM of things, being produced, exists. And this sum of things, when it was once thrown into suitable motions, being also maintained in that state through many long years^ causes that the rivers recruit the greedy sea with large floods of water, and that the earth, cherished by the heat of the sun, renews its productions; also that the race of living creatures flour- ishes undecayed, 2 and that the gliding fires of beaten live. Which effects atoms could by no means produce, unless an abundant supply of matter could arise from the infinite of space, whence every thing that is produced is accustomed to repair in time the parts lost. For as the nature of animals, when deprived of food, wastes and decays, losing its substance, so must all things fall away, as soon as matter, turned by any means from its course, 3 has failed to supply itself. Nor can impacts, 4 as some may imagine, produced externally on all sides, keep together the entire WHOLE, or whatever of matter has been combined into a ivhole. For though some external impacts may strike frequently, and thus may sustain here and there a part, until others succeed, and the requisite number of impacts for securing any particular portion may be completed ; yet at times the bodies producing the impacts are compelled to rebound, and at the same moment to give the pri- mary-atoms of things space and time for flight, so that they may be carried away free from the aggregate. It is neces- sary therefore for such compression by impact, that many atoms should again and again rise up into action from the surrounding parts ; and besides, in order that the impacts may be given 1 By which means, (i. e. positions).'] Ver. 1027. Qualibus h 2 and nothing external retards them ; and when, moreover, they themselves, being one and uncompounded in all their parts, are to that one place borne onwards, by their own tendency, 3 to which they have begun to proceed, must be thought, it is evident, to excel in swiftness, and to be carried forwards much more rapidly than the light of the sun, and to run through a much greater region of space 4 in the same time as the beams of the sun traverse the heaven. For neither have they to delay, being retarded by deliberation how they shall proceed, nor have they to pursue the neighbouring atoms one after the other, that they may learn by what method every thing is to be done. But some ignorant persons, in opposition to these opinions, think that the nature of matter cannot, without the will and providence of the gods, be ordered so suitably to human plans and conveniences, as to change the seasons of the year, and to produce the fruits of the earth, and to effect also other things in which the directress of life, divine Pleasure, prompts mor- tals, and herself leads them, to engage ; so that they may pro- pagate their kind through the allurement of gratification, lest the race of men should perish. For whose sake, when they imagine that the gods settled all things, they seem in all respects to have departed far from just reasoning. For though I were ignorant what the primary-elements of things were, yet this I could venture to assert from a contemplation o/'the 1 Of pure solidity.] Ver. 156. Solida simplicitate. " Of solid sim- plicity." The same expression is used, i. 549, 575, 610. 2 Pass through empty space.] Ver. 157. Per inane meant vacuum. That is, each being surrounded with vacuum ; not coming in con- tact with other atoms. 3 By their own tendency.] Ver. 159. Connixa. * A much greater region of space.] Ver. 162. Multiplex loci spatium. The same phrase occurs, iv. 208. Scheller, in his Lexicon, inter- prets multiplex, in this passage, " extensive, large, great." But ag Livy, vii. 8, uses multiplex comparatively, multiplex numerus quam , I think Creech right in explaining multiplex spatiitm by multo wo- Jvt sr-ilium. . ti. ^tf 210. LUCRETIUS. 61 mature of heaven itself, and to demonstrate from many other tilings, that the world was by no means made for us by divine power ; although these opinions incur reprehension among the generality of mankind. Which matters, O Memmius, I will make clear to you hereafter ; we will now explain what remains to be said concerning the motions of atoms. This is now the place, as I think, in discussing these sub- jects, to make plain to you, that no corporeal substance can, of its own proper force, be borne and advance upwards ; lest the particles of flame should deceive you in this matter. For though they are produced upwards, and take increase upwards, yet also the smiling corn, and groves, have their growth up- wards ; though all weights, as far as is in them, are borne down- wards. Nor, when fire springs up to the roofs of houses, and consumes the beams and rafters with a swift flame, is it to be thought that it does so without a compelling force ; as is the case, for example, when blood, sent forth from our body, spouts out, springing up on high, and sprinkling abroad a purple stream. Do you not see, also, with how strong a force the liquid substance of water repels beams and logs of wood ? Do you not observe how, the more we have, on any occasion, urged them straight downwards, and have powerfully pressed them down with great force and with difficulty, so the more eagerly the water casts them back and sends them upwards, so that they rise up and leap forth with a larger portion of their substance f l And yet we do not doubt, I suppose, that these bodies, as far as is in them, are all borne downwards through empty space. Thus, accordingly, flames must also have the power to rise, when driven up, through the air of heaven, al- though their own weights, as far as is in them, strive to draw them downwards. Do you not, moreover, see that meteors in the night, flying through the height of heaven, draw long tracks of flame in whatever directions nature has given them a passage ? Do you not see shooting stars fall to the earth ? The sun, also, from the highest point of the sky, spreads abroad his heat on 1 Leap forth with a larger portion of their substance.'] Ver. 200. Plus lit parte foras emergant exsiliantque. " They naturally rose above the Avater at first with a certain portion of their bulk ; but, after being pressed down, they start up above it with a still greater por- tion." Wakefield. 62 LUCRETIUS. B. n. 211238 all sides, and covers the fields with his light ? The heat of the sun, therefore, also tends downwards to the earth. And you observe likewise the lightnings fly through the oblique showers ; the fires, bursting from the clouds, rush sometimes in one way, sometimes in another ; and the body of flame falls very frequently to the earth. 1 In reference to these subjects, also, we wish you to under- stand this ; that the particles-of-matter, when they are borne downwards straight through the void of space, do for the most part, by their own weights, at some time, though at no fixed and determinate time, and at some points, though at no fixed and determinate points, turn aside 2 from the right line, but only so far as you can call the least possible deviation. But unless the atoms were accustomed to decline from the right line, they would all fall straight down, through the void profound, like drops of rain through the air; nor would there have been any contact produced, or any collision generated among the primary-elements ; and thus nature would never havejproduced any thing. But if, perchance, any one believes that the heavier bodies, as being borne, more swiftly, straight through the void of space, might fall from above on the lighter ones, and thus produce concussions, which might give rise to generative movements, he deviates and departs far from just reasoning. For whatsoever bodies fall downwards through the water and the air, they, of necessity, must quicken their motions accord- ing to their weights, inasmuch as the dense consistence of water, and the subtle substance of the air, cannot equally re- tard every body, but yield sooner to the heavier bodies, being overcome by them. But, on the contrary, a pure vacuum can afford no resistance to any thing, in any place, or at any time, but must constantly allow it they're pass age which its nature requires. For which reason all bodies, when put into motion, 1 Falls very frequently to the earth.] Ver. 215. Cadit in terras tolffb. For volgo Creech givespassim ; Wakefield seems to take it in the sense of non raro, which I prefer. 2 Particles-of-matter turn aside.] Ver. 216, seq. Had all atoms descended through space in straight lines, like drops in a shower of rain, falling perpendicularly, there could have been no collisions, and no generative motions. Epicurus, therefore, found it necessary to make them, or some of them, deviate from the straight course. B. ii. 239-1W9. LUCRETIUS. 63 must be equally borne onwards, though not of equal weights, through the unresisting void. The heavier atoms will, there- fore, never be able to fall from above on the lighter, nor, of themselves, produce concussions which may vary the motions by which nature performs her operations. For which cause, it must again and again be acknowledged that atoms decline a littl'j from the straight course, though it need not be admitted that they decline more than the least possible space ; lest we should seem to imagine oblique motions, and truth should refute that supposition. For thia we see to be obvious and manifest, that heavy bodies, as far as depends on themselves, cannot, when they fall from above, advance obliquely ; a fact which you may yourself see. But who is there that can see 1 that atoms do not at all turn them- selves aside, even in the least, from the straight direction of their course ? Further, if all motion is connected and dependent, and a new movement perpetually arises from a former one in a cer- tain order, and, if the primary-elements do not produce any commencement of motion by deviating from the straight line to break the laws of fate, so that cause may not follow cause in infinite succession, whence comes this freedom of will to all animals in the world ? - whence, I say, is this liberty of action wrested from the fates, by means of which we go whereso- ever inclination leads each of us? whence is it that we ourselves turn aside and alter our motions, not at any fixed time, nor 1 But who is there that can see, Z$c. ] Ver. 249. Bed nihil omnino recta regione via'i declinare, quis est, qui possit cernere, sese ? You must admit this declination from the straight line, says Epicurus, for who can see that there is no such declination? See Lambinus. Many other admissions Epicurus calls upon his disciples to make on si- milar grounds. Yet that no bodies in the least are turn'd, What searching sight hath ever yet discern'd ? Busby. 2 Whence comes this freedom of will to all animals in the world?] Ver. 256. Libera per terras uncle hac animantibus extat voluntas ? I' Whence is our liberty of action? Ask of the atoms themselves : if their motion be invariably direct, there arises from this motion a chain of fate and necessity ; if there be collision, (supposing collision to take place with perfectly direct motion,) there arises from it the same necessity. To declension from the right line only, therefore, can liberty of action be attributable." Creech. See Cicero de Fato, and de Nat. Deor. book i. 64 LUCRETIUS. B. ii. 260-291 in any fixed part of space, but just as our mind has prompted us. For doubtless, in such matters, his own will gives a com- mencement of action to every man ; and hence motions are diffused through the limbs. Do you not see also, that when the barriers on the race-course are set open at a certain in- stant, yet the eager strength of the horses cannot spring for- ward so suddenly as the inclination itself desires ? For the whole mass of matter throughout the whole body, excited in all the members, must be collected, 1 and roused simul- taneously into action, that it may second the desire of the mind in connexion with it- ; so that you may see that the commencement of motion is produced from the heart, and that the tendency to act proceeds in the first place from the in- clination of the mind, and is thence spread onwards through the whole body and its members. Nor is this similar to the case in which we go forwards, when impelled by a blow, from the great strength and violent compulsion of another person, for then it is evident that the whole matter of the entire body moves, and is hurried on- wards, against our consent, until the will, acting throughout the members, has reined it back. Do you now see, therefore, that although external force drives along many men, (that is, often drives men along,) and compels them frequently to go forwards against their will, and to be hurried away headlong, yet that there is something in our breast which can struggle against and oppose it ; according to the direction of which, also, the aggregate of matter ivithin us is at times obliged tc be guided throughout our several limbs and members, and. when driven forward, is curbed, and sinks down into rest? Wherefore you must necessarily confess that the sftme is the case in the seeds of matter, and that there is some other cause for motion besides strokes and weight, from Avhich this power i is innate in them, since we see that nothing can be produced ; from nothing. For weight forbids that all effects should be produced by strokes, and as if by external force ; but the cir- cumstance that our mind itself is not influenced merely by in- ternal necessity in performing every action, and is not, as if under subjection, compelled only to bear and suffer, this cir- 1 Mass of matter must be collected.] Ver. 266. Omnis enim totum per corput material Copia conquiri debet. Some manuscript* have conciri. - B. ii. 292. 319. LUCRETIUS. 65 eumstance the slight declination of the primordial-atoms causes, though it takes place neither in any determinate part of space, nor at any determinate time. Nor was the general body of matter ever more condensed l together, or, on the other hand, distributed in parts at greater intervals, than it is at present. For to that body neither does any increase ever take place, nor is any diminution made /row it through decay. For which reason, in whatever motion the atoms of primordial seeds are now, in the same motion they were in past time, and hereafter will always be moved in a similar manner ; and whatever things have been wont to be produced, will still be produced under like circumstances, and will exist, and grow, and acquire strength, as far as has been granted to each by the laws of nature ; nor can any influence change the sum of things. For neither is there any part of space to which any kind of matter can fly off from the WHOLE, nor, again, is there any part from which any new force, hav- ing arisen there, can burst in upon the WHOLE, and thus change the entire order of things and alter its movements. In these matters, it is not at all to be regarded as wonder- ful, why, when all the primordial-elements of things are in motion, yet the WHOLE of things seems to stand in perfect rest, except whatever individual thing exhibits motion in its own body. 2 For the entire nature of original-principles lies far removed from our senses, and beneath them; for which cause, when you cannot see the thing itself, its motions must also hide themselves from your eyes ; especially when even many things that we can see, nevertheless often conceal their motions from us, as being separated from us by a great dis- tance. For frequently, upon a hill, we mruj observe a flock of woolly sheep spread about, cropping the rich pasture, where- soever the grass, gemmed with fresh dew, calls and invites 1 Nor was the general body of matter ever more condensed, -c.l V 7 er- 294. Nee stipata magisfuit unquam, Sfc. " That the primary par- ticles cannot be changed, he has already shown ; he now asserts that matter, considered generally, was never distributed at less or greater intervals than at present; for not an atom perishes to cause a hiatus in matter and no new atom is generated to increase the density of matter." Creech. 8 Except whatc ver individual thing exhibits motion in its own body.] Ver. 311. Prcpterqitam si quid proprio dot corpore motus. il \a the air, the water, the heaven, the stars, &e." Faber. T 63 LUCRETIUS. B. n. 320-344. each ; while the full-fed lambs sport and frisk about with de- light: all which objects, from a distance, appear to us con- fused, and only a whiteness, as it were, seems to rest upon the green hill. Also, when vast legions fill all the parts of a plain, stirring up the image of war, the gleam of arms then raises itself to the sky, and all the land around glitters with brass, while a sound is excited by the force, beneath the feet of the men, and the neighbouring hills, struck with the noise, re-echo the shouts of the troops to the stars of heaven ; and the cavalry, at the same time, swiftly-wheel about, and suddenly charge across the plains in the centre, shaking them with their violent onset ; all these are distinct objects, and yet there is a certain spot on the high hills, whence, if you look down, they seem to rest on the ground as one body, and only a con- tinuous brightness to settle over the field. Attend now, Memmius, 1 and learn, in the next place, of what nature the primordial-elements of things are, and how very different they are in their forms ; how they are varied by manifold shapes. Not that a few only are endowed with (,ike form, for those alike are innumerable, but because, through- Out the whole, 2 all are not similar to all, but are varied with great differences. Nor is this wonderful ; for since the abund- ance of them is such, that, as I have shown, there is neither any limit nor sum of them, they must not, and cannot, assured- ly, be all universally endowed with a like figure and like shape to all others. 3 Besides, consider the human race, and the mute swarms of fishes swimming in the sea, and the abundant herds of cattle and wild beasts, and the various birds, which frequent the 1 Attend now, O Memmius, Sfc.] Ver. 333. " He first shows thjit atoms differ in shape ; next, that their differences of shape are finite ; and then that atoms of each shape are infinite." Lambinus. 1 Throughout the whole.] Ver. 337- Volga. 1 Like figure and like shape to all others.] Ver. 311. Debent nimirum non omnibus omnia prorsum Esse pari filo, similique affectu figurft. Lambinus interprets/^ by textura, and Scheller, in his Lexicon, citing this passage, makes it kind, nature." But as Lucretius is here speaking merely of the forms of atoms, it is evidently to be rendered outline or figure, as in v. 573 : Forma quoque hinc solis debet filumque videri. fcfte also v. 587, atque alibi. a. u. 345375. LUCRETIUS 67 pleasant places about the waters, upon the banks of rivers, fountains, and lakes, and which, flitting through the trees, traverse the pathless groves ; of which select any one you please, in the several kinds, for contemplation, and you will still find that they differ from one another in their forms. Nor, indeed, could the progeny, by any other means, know its mother, or the mother her progeny ; whereas we see that m ferior animals, not less than men, are known to each other. For, on many occasions, a calf, sacrificed at the frankin- cense-burning altars, falls before the beauteous temples of the gods, pouring forth a warm stream of blood from its breast ; but the mother, meanwhile, deprived of her young, wandering through the green forests, leaves traces imprinted on the ground with her cloven feet, surveying all places with her eyes, if any where she may discern her lost offspring, and then, standing still, fills the leafy grove with her complaints ; she also frequently goes back to look at the stall, peneti-ated with regret for her calf ; nor are the tender willows, or the grass fresh with dew, or any streams, gliding level with the top of their banks, able to soothe her feelings, and drive away her sudden affliction ; nor can any other forms of calves, over the fertile pastures, divert her attention or lighten her of her care; so perseveringly does she require some shape that is familiar and known to her. Moreover, the tender kids, with their tremulous voices, know, as they plainly indicate, their horned dams, and sheep distinguish the bleating of the butting lamb ; and thus, as nature requires, each hastens invariably to its own milky udder. 1 Lastly, contemplate any sorts of corn, 2 and still you will not find the whole of each in its own kind, or all the grains of each, to have such a mutual resemblance, but that some difference will run between their forms. And in like manner we see the various sorts of shells paint the lap of the earth, where the sea, 1 Each hastens invariably, to.] Ver. 370. Ad sua quisque fere de- currunt ubera lactis. For " fere," generally, or, as I have rendered it, invariably, Wakefield reads "feri," beasts. 2 Lastly, contemplate any sorts of corn, e.] Ver. 371. Postremo quodvis frumentum, non ramen pmne, Quidque sno genere, inter se simile esse videbis. '' With yuodcis frumentum understand surnere perge from ver. S*7." Cieech. r 2 68 LUCEETIUS. B. n. 376-404. with gentle waves, strews the bibulous sand on the winding shore. 1 Again and again, therefore, I repeat, the primordial atoms of things, since they exist in their own nature, and are not fashioned to a certain shape by the hand of one artificer, must likewise circulate through the universe in certain shapes dissimilar one from another. It is very easy for us, then, by the char guidance of rea- son, to explain why the flame of lightning passes through the air with much more penetration than our fire, which arises from fuel of the earth. For you may justly argue that the celestial fire of lightning, as being more subtle, consists of smaller atoms, and therefore flies through diminutive passages, which this fire of ours, taking its rise from wood, and pro- duced by torches, cannot enter. Besides, light passes through horn, but water is repelled by it. Why? unless that the atoms of light are less than those of which the genial liquid of water consists. Wine, also, we observe to flow as quickly as possible through a strainer, but thick oil, on the contrary, moves through it slowly ; because, as it appears, the latter either consists of larger atoms, or of such as are more hooked and involved with one another. And thus it happens, that the individual atoms, not being so quickly detached from their coherence with each other, cannot so easily pass through the individual pores of any body. To this is added, that the liquids of honey and milk are moved about in the mouth with a pleasant sensation to the tongue ; but, on the contrary, the bitter substance of worm- wood, and acrid ctntaury, 2 torment the palate with a disa- greeable taste ; so that you may easily infer that those things which can affect the senses with pleasure, consist of smooth and round particles ; but that, on the other hand, whatever things seem bitter and rough, are held united together of par- 1 Strews the bibulous sand, Faber. 70 LUCRETIUS. B. 11. 437459. delights it in issuing forth, as in the genial exercises of Venus ; or when the seeds, from striking against each other, raise a tumult in the body itself, and, by mutual agitation, confound the sense ; as if, for example, you yourself should strike any part of your own body, and make trial of this sensation. For which reason forms of substance, which can excite various feelings, must necessarily be far different in their elementary-principles. Further, those bodies that seem to us hard and dense, must necessarily consist of particles more locked with one another, and be held closely compacted, 1 as it were, by branching atoms. Among which kind of bodies, adamantine rocks, naturally- adapted to despise blows, stand pre-eminently in the first rank : as well as stout flints, and the strength of hard iron, and brazen hinges, which, as they support the weight of their gates, make a loud grating sound. 2 Those bodies, indeed, which are liquid and of a fluid sub- stance, must consist, more than harder bodies, of smooth and round atoms ; (for a draught of poppy -juice 3 is even as yield- ing, and as much of a liquid, as a draught of water ;) since their several collections-of-particles are not held together rigidly among themselves, and their progress along a descent is voluble and easy. All things, moreover, which you see scatter themselves in a short space of time, as smoke, clouds, and flames, must neces- sarily, if they do not wholly consist of smooth and round par- ticles, yet not be bound together with complex ones ; so that, 1 Compacted.] Ver. 446. Compacta. " Compacted " is not a word iu general use, but is found in Hooker, and quoted by Johnson. * Brazen hinges, which make a loud grating sound.] Ver. 450. jEraqw, qua claustris restantia vociferantur. Claustra here means gates or doors. " Kestantia quasi sustinentia." Faber. " JEra, brass, that is, hinget of brass, which creak with the weight of the gates." Creech. * For a draught of poppy juice, Sfc.] Ver. 453. Natnqite papaterit haustus item est facilis quod aquarum. Lambinus thought this verse spurious, and ejected it; nor did any editor offer to restore it till Wakefield. Lachmann retains it, but alters quod into quasi. Lucre- tius, if it be genuine, meant to say in it that one body which is fairly fluid is as much a fluid as any other that is fairly fluid. Good, who professes to adhere to Wakefield's text, passes the verse in silence. Glomeramina, in the next line, is evidently collections of particles, as Lambinus understood it ; not round particles, as Creech will have it B II. 460479. LUCRETIUS. 71 being as they aie, they may have a pungent effect upon the body, 1 and penetrate roc ks, but cannot cohere together ; a power which we all see to be granted to 'thorns. You may easily understand, therefore, that they do mot consist of hooked and complicated, but of acute atoms. But that you should observe the same bodies, which are fluid, to be bitter, as is the liquid of the sea, is by no means to be wondered at by any one. For that which is fluid, con- sists of smooth and round particles; and with these smooth and round particles are mixed pungent particles causing pain. Nor yet is it necessary that these atoms should hold themselves together by being hooked ; for you may be certain that though the particles are rough, they are yet globose, so that they may flow among those of the fluid, though at the same time they may hurt the sense. And that you may the more cer- tainly believe that rough are mixijd with smooth particles, of both of which, for instance, the mass of the waters of the ocean consists, there is, I may mention, a method of separating them and considering them apart. The same water of the sea, for example, becomes sweet, 2 when it is often filtered through the earth, so that it may flow, as you may sometimes see, into a trench, and thus lose its saltness. For it leaves above, or near the surface of the earth, the particles of bitter salt, which are rough and jagged; so that they more easily inhere in the earth. Which point since I have now demonstrated, I shall proceed to join with it another proposition, which, depending on this, 1 May have a pungent effect upon the body.] Ver. 460. Pun- gere uti posslnt coi-pus. " As they are easily dissipated, they do not consist of atoms that link together, but as they can stimulate the senses, (as mist and smoke affect the eyes,) and can penetrate hard bodies, (as fire enters iron and stone,) they cannot consist wholly of atoms that are smooth and round." Creech. * The same water of the sea becomes sweet, &c.] Ver 17k On Jhis passage Good happily refers to Thomson's Autumn, ver. 741. Some sages say, that where the numerous wave For ever lashes the resounding shore, Drill'd through the sandy stratum, every way, The waters with the sandy stratum rise ; Amid whose angles infinitely strain'd, They joyful leave tiieirjaygy salts behind, And clear and sweeten as they soak along. 72 LUCRETIUS. B. ii. 480501 derives its credit/row it ; that the primary-atoms of things vary in figure, but only with a limited number of shapes. 1 If this were not so, some seminal-principles would, moreover, necessa- rily Ve of an immense bulk of body. For this is evident, be- cause within the same individual minute-frame of any one seminal-principle, the figures or arrangements of its parts cannot vary much among themselves. Since, suppose that the primary-principles consist of a certain definite number of very small parts ; say three, or increase them, if you please, by a few more ; assuredly when, after arranging all those parts, and altering the place of the highest and lowest parts of that one body, and changing the right for the left, you shall have tried in every way what representation of forms each arrange- ment of the whole of that body offers, if perchance you shall wish still further to vary its forms, you will have to add other parts ; and from thence will follow, in like manner, that a third arrangement will require still more, if you shall wish by a third arrangement still to vary its forms. An increase of bulk, therefore, follows upon the variation of shapes ; for which reason you cannot believe that seminal-principles differ from one another by an infinite variety of shapes ; lest, by such a supposition, you should make some to be of immense bulk ; which I have already shown that it is not possible to prove. And if such were the case, if the figures of a terms were in- finite, barbaric garments, and shining Meliboean purple, 2 tinged with the dye of shell-fish from Thessaly, as well as the golden brood of peacocks, painted with smiling beauty, would-lose- tb.eir-estimation in your eyes, being thrown-into-the-shade by the new beauty of fresh objects ; the perfume of myrrh and the taste of honey would be despised ; and the melodies of 1 That the primary-atoms of things vary in figure, but only with a limited number of shapes.] Ver. 480. Primordia rerum FinitA V'iriare figurarum ratione. Epicurus taught, that the shapes of atoms could not be infinite, as it is impossible to imagine an infinity of figures in a finite body. Plutarch de Placit. Phil. i. 3. * Barbaric garments, and shining Melibcean purple, %c.] Ver. ?01. " If the shapes of atoms varied to infinity, there could be no ertain and determinate extreme qualities of things in nature; for, ly new configurations, objects might be so altered, that something better than whatever was best, and worse than whatever was worst, might still arise into being. Creech I ii. 505-528. LUCRETIUS. 73 swans, and the tunes of Phoebus, varied on the chords of the lyre, would, in like manner, be silenced, as being outdone by something new; for, in every class of things, some new thing might arise more excellent than others which are now thought the best. Or all things might also fall back into a worse state, as we have said that they might possibly rise to a better. For, in a retrograde order, one thing might arise, time after time, more disagreeable than others preceding it, to the nostrils, ears, and eyes, and taste of the palate. Since this, hoivever, is not so, but a certain limit set to things in both directions, as to what is bad and what is good, confines the whole, you must of necessity admit that the particles of matter also vary from one another only by shapes that are finite in number. Lastly, a distance, so to speak, has been defined from the heat of summer 1 to the freezing cold of winter, and has been measured back from cold to heat in like manner. For the whole year is, or consists of, heat and cold ; 2 and the moderate warmths of spring and autumn lie between both the other two seasons, filling up the whole in succession. The seasons of spring and autumn, therefore, as made and appointed, are kept-distinct by a limited portion to each ; since they are marked on each side by two points, and shut in on the one hand by heats, and on the other side by rigid frosts. Since I have now proved this, I shall proceed to join with it another observation, which, depending on this, derives its credit from it; that the primordial-atoms of things, which are formed of a like figure one to the other, are infinite in number ; for since the diversity of their forms is finite, it ne- cessarily follows that those which are alike are infinite ; or it would appear that the sum of matter must be finite ; which I have proved to be impossible. 1 Lastly, a distance has been defined from the heat of summer, $c. ] Ver. 515. He introduces this observation to show that things in nature are limited ; that there are extreme bounds beyond which it is not possible to pass, but within which there are many interme- diate degrees of variation. 2 For the whole year in heat and cold.] Ver. 517. Omnis enim caior ac frigus. Wakefield understands annus, " tamque ridiculum snterpretem," says Lachmann, "nostrates venerabundi sequuntur." Lachmann himself reads, from conjecture, Ambit enim, &c. 74 LUCRETIUS. B. n. 529552 Since I have shown this, I will now (give me your atten- tion) demonstrate in a few sweetly-sounding verses, that the atoms of matter support the WHOLE OF THINGS, from all eter- nity, 1 by a succession 2 of movements on every side. For though you see in any particular region certain ani- mals to be more rare than others, and observe Nature, in those less rare, to be more productive, 3 yet in another region and dis- trict, and in distant lands, it is possible that there may be many animals of that kind, and that the deficiency of their numbers in one place may be compensated in another ; just as we see, in the race of quadrupeds, to be especially the case with the snake-handed elephants, with many thousands of which India is defended as with an ivory rampart, so that it cannot be at all penetrated ; so great is the multitude of those beasts in that country, but of which we see very few specimens among us. But yet, that I may, if you wish, grant this also, 4 let there be, in your imagination, any single creature you please, existing alone with its own natural body, and to which there may be no creature similar in the whole round of the earth ; yet, un- less the quantity of the seeds of matter, from which that crea- ture may be formed and generated, shall be infinite in number, jt will neither be possible for it to be produced, nor moreover, $ it could be produced, to grow up and be nourished. For let your eyes conceive (i. e. imagine that you see) the generative atoms of any single thing, being limited in num- ber, tossed about through the whole of space ; whence, / ash, where, by what force, and by what means, will they, meeting together, unite, amid so vast an ocean of matter, and so mighty a confusion of dissimilar particles f They have, as I think, 1 From all eternity.] Ver. 531. Ex infinite. " Abaeterno." Creech. " Ab seternp tempore." Lambimis. 2 Succession.] Ver. 532. Protelo. See iv. 191. * And observe Nature, in those less rare, to be more productive.] Ver. 534. Fecundamque magis naturam cernis in ollis. This is Wake- field's rending, and Forbiger's interpretation, if interpretation it can be called ; for in truth the magiy makes the passage sheer nonsense. Lambinus, and all other editors, except Wakefield, Forbiger, and Eichstadt, read Fecundamque minus, which Lachmann has rein- stated. 4 But yet, that I may grant this also.] Ver. 542. Sed tamen, id yuoyue w/t concedam. This, namely, which follows. Another argu- ment to prove the infinity of material atoms, and " a more ingeni- ous one, says Faber, " than it may at first appear," B. ii. 552581. LUCRETIUS. 75 no method of combining themselves. But, as when gr?nt and numerous shipwrecks have arisen, the vast sea is wont to scat- ter abroad floating benches, hollow fragments ' of vessels, sail- yards, prows, masts, and oars ; so that the ornaments of sterns 2 may be seen swimming on all the coasts of the earth, and may give admonition to mortals, to resolve to avoid the treachery, and violence, and deceit of the faithless sea ; nor, on any oc- casion, to be too credulous, when the insidious flattery of the calm deep smiles ; so if you, in this case, shall once settle for yourself that certain primordial atoms are finite in number, you must then allow that the different agitations of matter will necessarily toss them about, scattered, as they will be, for ever ; so that they can at no time, being driven together, unite in Combination, or, if they should unite, remain in combination, cr swell with increase ; both of which effects manifest proof shows to occur before our eyes, namely, that things are produced, and that, when produced, they have the power to increase. It is therefore evident, that, in every cla?s of beings, the primordial- elements of things, from which all are supplied, are infinite in number. Nor, therefore, inasmuch as original-elements are infinite, can the movements of things, which are destructive to vital existence, always prevail, or bury its safety for ever ; though neither, on the other hand, can motions productive of gener- ation and increase, always preserve things ivhich have been formed. Thus a war of principles, grown up from the infi- nite space of the past, is carried on with equal strife ; the vital principles of things prevail sometimes in one place, sometimes in another, and are prevailed over in their turn. The wail which infants raise, when they come forth to view the regions of light, is mixed with funeral lamentations ; nor has any night followed a day, or any morning followed a night, which has not heard groans, the attendants of death and gloomy obsequies, mixed with the weak cries of infants coming into the world. 1 Hollow fragments.] Ver. 554. Cavernas. " This word it is easy *o understand of any fragment of the interior of a ship." Wakefield. Other editors read guberna. 2 Ornaments of sterns.] Ver. 556. Aplustra. " In Greek u\anra. They were ornaments, not on the prow, but on the stern ; for the ornaments on the prow were called atcpooToXia." Faber. 76 LUCRETIUS. B. ii. 582-619 In considering these points, it is proper for you, also, to have it impressed, as with a seal, upon your mind, and to keep itfailhftilly intrusted to your memory, that there is nothing, among all objects of which the nature is apparent before us, which consists only of one kind of elements ; nor any thing, which does not consist of mixed seminal-principles. And whatever possesses in itself more numerous powers and ener- gies than other things, thus demonstrates that it contains more numerous kinds of primary-particles and various configura- tions of them. In the first place, the earth has in itself primary atoms, from which springs, rolling forth cool waters, incessantly recruit the immense sea ; it has also in itself atoms from which fires arise. For in many places, the soil of the earth, when set on fire, burns ; and the violence of ^Etna rages with mighty flames. Moreover, the earth contains atoms from which it can raise up rich corn and cheerful groves for the tribes of men ; and from which also it can afford waving leaves and abundant pasturage for the brood of wild beasts ranging over the mountains. For which reasons the earth alone is called the great mother of the gods, and mother of beasts, and parent of the human race. The old and learned poets of the Gieeks sung that she, in her seat on her chariot, drives two lions yoked together ; sig- nifying that the vast earth hangs in the open space of the air, and that one earth cannot stand upon another earth. They added the lions, because any offspring, however wild, ought to be softened, when influenced by the good offices of parents. And they surrounded the top of her head with a mural crown, because the earth, fortified in lofty places, sustains cities ; dis- tinguished with which decoration the image of the divine mother is borne, spreading terror, through the wide world. Her various nations, according to the ancient practice of their worship, call the Idaean mother, and assign her bands of Phrygians as attendants, because they say that from those parts corn first began to be produced, and thence ivas diffused over the globe of the earth. They assign to her also the Galli ; because they wish to intimate that those, who have violated the sacred-respect due to their mother, and have been found ungrateful to their fathers, are to be thought unworthy to bring living offspring into the realms of light. Distended drums, and hollow cymbal*, resound in their hands around the >. II. 620650. LUCRETIUS. 77 goddess ; and their horns threaten with a hoarse noine, while the hollow pipe excites their minds with Phrygian notes. And they carry weapons outstretched before them, as signs of violent rage, which may alarm with terror the undutiful minds and impious hearts of the crowd, struck with the power of the goddess. As soon, therefore, as, riding through great cities, she, being dumb, bestows a silent blessing on mortals, thoy strew the whole course of the road with brass and silver, enriching her with munificent contributions ; while they diffuse a shower of roses, overshadowing the mother and her troop of attend- ants. Here the armed band, whom the Greeks call by the name of Phrygian Curetes, dance round vigorously with ropes, 1 and leap about to their tune, streaming with blood. Shaking the terrible crests on their heads as they nod, they represent the Dictaean Curetes, who are formerly said, in Crete, to have concealed that famous infant-cry of Jupiter, when the armed youths, in a swift dance around the child, struck, in tune, their brazen shields with their brazen spears, lest Saturn, having got possession of him, should devour him, and cause an eternal wound in the heart of his mother. Either for this reason, therefore, armed men accompany the great mother ; or else because the priests thus signify that the goddess ad- monishes men to be willing to defend the land of their country with arms and valour, and to prepare themselves to be a pro- tection and honour to their parents. These pageants, though celebrated as being fitly and excel- lently contrived, are yet far removed from sound reason. For the whole race of the gods must necessarily, of itself, enjoy its immortal existence in the most profound tranquillity, far removed and separated from our affairs; since, being free from all pain, exempt from all dangers, powerful itself in its own resources, and wanting nothing of us, it is neither propitiated 1 Dance round vigorously with ropes.] Ver. 631. Inter se forte catenas Ludunt. That a rope was used in dancing both by Greeks and Romans is known from Aristoph. Nub. 510; Ter. Adelph. iv. 7, 34; Liv. xxvii. 37, and other authorities. But catenas, in this pas- sage, is merely from a conjecture of Turnebus, which Lambmus adopted. Wakefield read sorte catervis, which even Forbiger did not venture to retain Lachmann reads fuitt yiiod armit. Forte is for fort>'ter. 78 LUCRETIUS. B. n. tol-.Sl by services from the good, nor affected with /anger against the bad. The earth, indeed, is at all times void of sense, but. because it contains the primary elements of many things, it brings forth many productions, in many ways, into the light of the sun. If any one, then, shall resolve to call the sea Neptune, and corn Ceres, and chooses rather to abuse the name of Bac- chus, than to utter the proper appellation of wine ; let us concede that such a one may pronounce the orb of the earth to be the mother of the gods, provided that it still be allowed to remain its real self. But to return, then, to the infinite variety of atoms, the woolly sheep. 1 we often see, cropping the grass from the same plain, and the warlike brood of horses, and the horned herds, living under the same part of the canopy of heaven, and quenching their thirst from the same stream of water, grow up of dissimilar species, retaining the parent nature ; and all follow habits according to their kinds ; so various is the nature of the matter in each kind of herb ; so great is the variety of particles in each river. Hence, moreover, though the same parts, bones, blood, veins, heat, moisture, viscera, and nerves, make up any one you please of all animals, still these, being very different in themselves, are formed of pri- mary-particles of an entirely different figure. Further, whatever bodies, being set on fire, burn, show that there are cherished in their mass, if nothing else, those various seminal-atoms, from which they are enabled to throw forth fire and cast up light, and also to put sparks in motion, and scatter abroad embers. Surveying other things with like reasoning, you will ac- cordingly find that they conceal in their consistence the seeds of many things, and contain various conformations of atoms. Again, you observe many objects to which both colour ;.nd taste have been assigned, together with smell ; especially most of the gifts which you offer to the gods, when you feel your inind affected, in a debasing manner, 2 with religion. These 1 But to return, the woolly sheep, $e.] Ver. 660. Since different 'rts of animals feed on the same herbs, and drink the same water, the herbs and water, which nourish every kind equally, must con- tain various sorts of seminal principles. In a debasing manner.] Ver. 681. Turpi pacto This is Wake- B. ii. 682707. LUCRETIUS. 79 tilings must therefore consist of various conformations of atoms; for scent penetrates where juices ^chich excite the taste do not make a way to the corporeal organs ; also juices by their particular method, and flavour by its particular method, win their way to the senses ; so that you may know that they arise from different conformations of atoms. Dis- similar forms of particles, therefore, combine in one mass, and things consist of mixed seminal-principles. Besides, even in my own verses l you see every where many elements common to many words ; though you must neverthe- less necessarily acknowledge that the verses and words con- sist part of some elements and part of others, differing among themselves ; not because only a few common letters run through the words, or because no two words, out of all, are alike in having any letter in common ; 2 but because, taking the words throughout, all the letters are not common to all. So likewise in other matters, many common elements, as they are the pri- mary-principles of many things, may yet exist in dissimilar combinations among themselves ; so that the human race, and the fruits of the earth, and the rich groves, may justly be considered to consist each of distinct original-particles. Nor yet is it to be thought that all particles can be com- bined in all ways ; for, if this were the case, you would every where see monsters arise ; you icould behold shapes produced half-man half-beast, and sometimes tall boughs of trees grow out of an animated body ; you ivould observe many members of terrestrial animals united to those of marine animals, and nature breeding, throughout the all-producing earth, Chimai- ras breathing flame from horrid mouths. Of which irregu- field's reading ; other editions have parto. Wakefield also conjec- ture s facto. 1 Besides, even in my own verses, <5rc.] Ver. 688. He uses the same illustration, i. 823. * Or because no two words, out of all, are alike in having any letter in common.] Ver. 693. Aut nulla inter se duo sint ex omnibus eadem. This is Forbiger's verse, which he calls paulo impeditiorem, and thus illustrates, " Non quo duo (verba) ex omnibus nullft (litera) inter se eadem sint: i. e. non quasi litera non in duobus verbis di- yersis occurrere possit." Lambinus reads, aut nulla (verba sc.) inter se duo sint ex omnibus isdem (literis sc.). Wakefield for isdfn substituted cidem, versui sc. And Lachmann gives, Aut nulli (versus *c.) inter se duo sint ex omnibus idem. Any one of these is better th*a Forbiger's monster. 80 LUCRETIUS. B. ii. 708- 734. larities it is evident that none occur, since we see that all things, being produced from certain seeds, by an unerring generative nature, can, as they grow up, preserve their kind pure and unmixed. And it is plain that this must necessarily be the case ac- cording to strict method and laws. For, from the several sorts of food that are eaten, the particles, suitable to each animal, pass internally into its limbs and other parts, and, being there combined, produce motions fitted to that animal. But, on the other hand, we see that nature throws back upon the earth those particles which are unsuitable to the animal; and many, existing in imperceptible substances, escape out of the body, being wrought upon by the impulses and agitations of other particles ; which effluent particles could neither be combined in any part, nor consent, and be animated, to par- ticipate in the vital movements. But lest you should think that animals only are bound by these laws, a certain order and regularity, let me observe, keeps all tilings distinct. For as, throughout the whole of nature, things dissimilar from one another are individually produced, so it is necessary that each should consist of a differ- ent form of elements. Not that only a few elements are endowed with like forms, but because all, throughout all bodies, are not similar to all. Since, moreover, seminal particles differ, their intervals, passages, connexions, weights, impulses, collisions, motions, must necessarily differ ; variations which not only keep dis- tinct the bodies of animals, but give peculiarity to the land and the whole sea, and cause the heaven to differ in nature from the earth. And now attend further,^ and receive into your mind my pre- cepts which I, with pleasing toil, have collected together. Do not, by any chance, imagine that those things which you see be fore your eyes of a white colour consist, because they are whita, of white elemental-atoms ; or that those which are black, are produced from black seminal-particles ; nor suppose that any objects, which are tinged with any other colour whatsoever, 1 And now attend further, h into the light. " He reasons thus," says Lambinus; B ii 798-817. LUCRETIUS. 83 no colours at all. For what sort of colour will there possiblv exist in thick darkness, when colour is a thing which is changed in and by mere light, because it appears different, as it is struck by direct or oblique light ? As the plumage of doves which is situate round the back of the head, and encir- cles the neck, appears of a different colour as it is seen differ- ently in the sun. For in one position it is affected so as to be red with the hue of the bright carbuncle ; at another time, in a certain aspect, 1 it is so changed that it seems to mix the colour of green emeralds with blue. The tail of the peacock, also, when it is covered with a flood of light, changes its co- lours, as it is presented in different ways, in like manner. And since all these colours are produced by a certain effect of the light, it must be considered that colour cannot be produced at all, without that light. Since, too, the pupil of the eye 2 receives upon itself one kind of impulse when it is said to perceive a white colour, and another again, when it perceives black and other colours; and since it is of no moment, a* to the feeling, with what colour those things, which you touch, are distinguished, but rather of what shape they are formed, you may conclude that primary-particles have no need of colours, but have only to affect the touch differently through the different forms in which they are combined. Besides, since there is no certain kind of colours peculiar 3 to " Without light colours are not seen ; primary-atoms are not seen ; therefore primary-atoms are without colour : a syllogism which is unsound, though all its parts are true." Lambinus was too indul- gent ; he should have disputed the minor. The atoms of things are not seen individually, but they meet the light on surfaces collectively. 1 In a certain aspect ] Ver. 804. Quodam sensu. "As the French say, speaking of vision, en un certain sens; or, as in ver. 808, quodam luminis ictu." Faber. 2 Since, too, the pupil of the eye, Sfc.] Ver. 810. The sense of the paragraph is this : The eye is affected in one way when it per- ceives a white colour, and in another way when it perceives a black ; but such affections are produced by touch or impact on the eye, (by means, namely, of the images thrown off from the surface of bodies ); and to the sense of touch colour is not requisite; therefore primary- atoms, which act on the eye by touch, have no need of colour to produce their effects, and may be considered to be without it. 3 Besides, since there is no certain kind of colours peculiar, frc.] Ver. 817. "The force of the argument is this: Suppose that the primary-atoms of things have colour, those who maintain this opin- ion will surely not say that certain coloirs of atoms are peculiar t a 2 84 LUCRETIUS. s. ". 818845. certain shapes, and since all shapes of seminal-atoms may exist with any colour whatsoever, why, if we suppose that seminal- atoms, which are of manifold shapes, have colour, are not those creatures which consist of those seminal-atoms, sprinkled over accordingly with all sorts of colours, each in its several kind, whatsoever it may be ? For, under this supposition, it might be expected that crows, as they fly, would often shed forth a white colour from white feathers, and that swans, if spring- ing perchance from black atoms, would be born black, or, if from atoms of any other colour, might be of any other hue whatsoever, uniform or varied. Moreover, the more any body is divided into small parts, the more you can see its colour by degrees die away and be- come extinct, as happens when gold is broken into small frag- ments. So purple and scarlet, (by far the brightest of colours,) when they have been divided thread by thread, are utterly deprived of lustre. So that you may from this infer, that the small parts of bodies throw off all colour, before they are re- duced to their ultimate-atoms. Further, since you grant that all bodies do not emit sound or smell, it consequently happens that you do not attribute to all bodies sounds or smells. So, since we cannot see all bodies with our eyes, we may conceive that certain bodies exist, which we do not see, as much destitute of colour as others are free from smell, and void of sound ; and that an intelligent mind can form a notion of these colourless bodies, no less than of others which are destitute of other qualities and distinctions. But that you may not perchance imagine that primary atoms remain void of colour only, they are also, you may understand, altogether destitute of heat and cold ; 1 and are understood to be barren of sound, and dry of all moisture ; nor do they certain shapes of atoms ; for example, that all triangular atoms are black, all quadrangular atoms blue, Stc., but will allow that in each shape there must be atoms of different colours ; for instance, that among triangular atoms some must be white, some black, some of intermediate colours. Let us suppose, then, that crows consist chiefly of triangular atoms; it would hence follow that crows might be born not black, but white, or green, or blue, or variegated. But this never happens ; atoms are therefore without colour." Lambinus. Altogether destitute of heat and cold.] Ver. 844. Secreta teporit ac frigoris omnino calidique vaporis. I have not thought it necen- miry to give more than one word for heat; and have made a similar abbreviation in ver. 858 . ii. 846867 LUCRETIUS. 85 send out any odour of their own from their substance. Thus when you proceed to compound a sweet ointment of amaracus,' and myrrh, and the flower of nard, which breathes nectar to the nostrils, it is, in the first place, proper to seek, as far aa is convenient, and as far as you may be able to find, the sub- stance of inodorous olive oil, which emits no scent to the nostrils, that it may, as little as possible, by the infection of any strong smell of its own, corrupt the odours mixed and digested in its body as a vehicle for them. Finally, therefore, it must be granted thai the primary-atoms of things communicate no odour or sound of their own, to the things to be produced/rom them, since they can emit from them- selves none of these qualities; nor, in like manner, do they emit any savour at all, or cold or heat. Other qualities, moreover? which are such that they are themselves, and in the bodies with which they are connected, perishable, as pliancy from soft- ness, brittleness from decay, hollowness from tenuity of sub- stance, must all, of necessity, be separated from primary-ele- ments, if we wish to lay an everlasting foundation for things, on which their entire security may rest, that the whole universe may not be resolved into nothing. And now let me observe that those creatures, whatsoever they are that we perceive to have sense, you must necessarily acknowledge to consist wholly of senseless atoms. 3 Nor do manifest appearances,* which are readily observed, refute this 1 Sweet ointment of amaracus, %c.~\ Ver. 847. Sicut amaracini blandum stacteeque liquorem Et nardi florem, nectar qui naribus halat. Amaracus is generally understood to be sweet-marjoram. Stacta is liquid myrrh. Nardus is what we call spikenard. " Nectar, the sweetest of odours ; metaphorically transferred from the taste to the smell." Lambinus. But the simile of the inodorous oil is but an imperfect illustration of the position that ultimate particles are without smell; for the oil is but the vehicle of the perfumes ; ultimate particles are themselves the substance of the perfumes. 2 Other qualities, moreover, $c.J Ver. 859. He signifies that the primary atoms of things must be destitute of all qualities that would render them perishable ; they must be hard, solid, and unyielding, as he shows, i. 501, seq., and elsewhere. * And now let me observe wholly of senseless atoms.] Ver. 865. He now proceeds to show that living creatures are formed from senseless atoms. * Nor do manifest appearances refute this petition.] Ver. 867. Xeque ul manifesta refutant. " A common argument of Epicurus. role atvouivoi." Faber. gg LUCRETIUS. B. n. 868894 position, or in the least oppose it, but rather themselves lead us by the hand, as it were, and compel us to believe that ani- mals, though possessed of sense, are generated, as I say, from atoms without sense. For you may observe living worms proceed from foul dung, when the earth, moistened with immoderate showers, has contracted a kind of putrescence ; and you may see all other things besides change themselves, similarly, into other things, The rivers turn themselves into leaves of trees ; and the rich pastures into cattle; the cattle change their substance into that of our bodies ; and from our bodies the strength of wild beasts, and the frames of birds, are often augmented. Nature, therefore, changes all kinds of food into living bodies, and hence produces all senses of animals in a method not very far different from that by which she resolves dry wood into flames, and turns all combustible bodies into fire. Do you now understand, therefore, that it is of great im- portance in what order the primordial elements of things are severally placed, and with what other elements being mingled, they give and receive impulses ? Besides, what is it that acts upon your mind, what moves you, and induces you to express a different opinion, preventing you from believing that what is possessed of sense is produced from atoms without sense? It is, evidently, this: that stones, and wood, and earth, 1 however mixed together, are neverthe- less unable to produce vital sense. On these subjects, then, it will be proper for you to remem- ber this principle, 2 that I do not say that what has sense, or that senses themselves, are of course 3 produced from all atoms in general, whatsoever generate things ; but that it is of great im- portance, in the first place, of what size those atoms are which 1 Stones, and wood, and earth, $0."] Ver. 889. You say that be- cause a mixture of such lifeless substances as stones, wood, &c., cannot produce sensible beings, therefore insensible atoms cannot give rise to sensible beings. 2 It will be proper for you to remember this principle.] Ver. 891. Illud in his igitur fcedus meminisse decebit. I have translated fcedus "principle," but the reading ought doubtless to be Illud in his igitur rebus, which Lambinus suggested, and which Lachmann haa adopted. 1 Of course.] Ver. 893. Extemplo. Forthwith, readily, without difficulty. B. ii. 895911. LUCRETIUS 87 are to produce a being of sense, and with what shape they are distinguished ; and, in the next place, what they are in their movements, arrangements, and positions ; of which par- ticulars, we, from our imperfect perceptions, see nothing take place in wood and clods ; and yet these, when they are as it were rendered putrescent by rain, produce worms, and for this reason, because the atoms of matter, being driven from their former arrangements by some new impulse, are combined in such a manner as makes it indispensable for animals to be produced. Besides, when philosophers determine that a being which has sense can be produced only from atoms endowed with sense, they forthwith, accustomed to adopt opinions from others, make those atoms soft ; for all sense is connected with viscera, nerves, veins, and whatever soft substances we see exist and grow in a mortal body. But let it be supposed, for a moment, that these atoms, oj which animals consist, may, though sensible and soft, remain eternal. They must then, however, either have sense as parts of animals,^ or be thought similar to whole animals. But it cannot be that as parts they have sense of themselves, for every part and member, if separated from the body, breaks off con- nexion with the other senses of the other members ; 2 nor can 1 Must either have sense as parts of animals, t$c.] Ver. 908. Sen- gum partis habere. " Talem sensum habebunt, qtialem habent par- tes." Lambinus. Or be thought similar to whole animals.] Aut similes totis animalibus esse putari. What similes is to agree with, is not very clear; Wakefield, whose reading it is, says venas et nervos; but it ought to agree with primordia, (comp. ver. 916,) or to refer to the primordia in some way. Lambinus and Creech read similia. Lachmann has given, Aut simili totis animalibus (scilicet sensu) esse putari. 2 For every part and member, if separated from the body, breaks off connexion with the other senses of the other members.] Ver. 911. Namque alias sensus membrorum respuit omnis. I have translated this line according to the interpretation of Lambinus : omnis " pars a toto separata, aliarum omnium partium siiarum sensus rejicit ac re- spuit." But the reading can hardly be sound. Gifanius proposed namque alitim sensus tnembrorum res petit omnis, which Havercamp admitted into the text. Lachmann gives something different: "Quid poeta voluerit," says he, " dubiuin esse non potest; negat enim membra singula scorsum sentiri posse, quippe qxis> ad aliud referantur, hoc est, ad animam : neque hoc difficile est ex verbis leviter corruptis extundere: namque alio se>isus memb-forum respicit omnis." This is not very satisfactory. 88 LUCRETIUS. s. n. 912935. the hand, when dissevered from us, nor any part of the body whatsoever, retain alone the sense of the whole body. It re- mains, therefore, that they must resemble whole animals, so that they may be animated with vital sense throughout. But how, then, will it be possible for them to be called the elements of things, and avoid the paths to death, when they are of an animal nature, and, existing themselves in perishable animals, are one and the same with them? Yet if we allow that primordial atoms, though imperishable, may nevertheless be endowed with iense t they will necessarily in that case produce nothing but a cr-Mvd and multitude of animals ; just as men, cattle, and wild beasts, would be un- able to produce by combination severally among themselves, any thing but men, cattle, and wild beasts. How then could things inanimate, as trees and metals, be produced? It is only on this supposition, accordingly, 1 (viz. that they can ge- nerate nothing but sentient beings,) that we should be obliged, as far as we see, to allow primordial-atoms to be sentient. But if, perhaps, you say that the primordial-atoms, being, as you think, sentient, lay aside, in combination, their own proper sense, and take another, what need was there, in that case, that that should be assigned to them, which is afterwards taken away ? And besides, to recur to an illustration to which we had recourse before, inasmuch as we see eggs of animals changed into birds, and worms spring forth when a kind of putrescence, from immoderate rains, has affected the ground, we know that animals having senses may be produced from objects without senses. But if any one, perchance, shall say that sentient-beings may certainly 2 arise from senseless atoms, but that this must be effected by some CHANGE which takes place in those atoms, as from some new BIRTH, before the sentient being which they con- stitute is brought forth into existence, it will be sufficient to explain and prove to him, that no BIRTH ever takes place, un- less from some combination previously formed, and that no 1 It is only on this supposition, accordingly, 4f c -] Ver. 923. Sie itidem, qua sentirmis, sentire necesse est. This verse appeared so inex- plicable to Lambinus, that he struck it out ; and Lachmann ha done the same. The sense which I have given to it, is taken from Wakefield. * Certainly.] Ver. 931. Duataxat. See Scheller's Lexicon. And comp. ii. 122. B. ii 936962. LUCRETIUS. 89 CHANGE is effected without a combination of primordial -atoms ; for no senses of any animal body can exist before the substance itself of the animal is formed ; and this is evident, inasmuch as senseless matter is kept dispersed throughout the air, rivers, earth, and things produced from the earth ; nor, though it may have united, 1 has it so united as to engender in itself those con- cordant vital motions, by which the all-observing senses of ani- mals being generated, direct and preserve every living creature. Besides, a blow inflicted, if heavier 2 than nature can endure, strikes down any animal at once, and has the effect of con- founding all sense of the body and of the mind ; for the posi- tions and connexions of the atoms are dissolved, and the vital motions are utterly impeded ; until at last the matter of the body, suffering concussion in every member, unlooses from the body the vital ties of the soul, and drives it forth, scat- tered abroad, through every outlet. For what more can we suppose that an inflicted blow can do, than shake to pieces and dissolve the several elements that were previously united ? It also happens, that when a blow is inflicted with less vio- lence, the remains of vital motion often prevail ; prevail, 1 say, over the effects of it, and calm the violent disorders occa- sioned b** the stroke, and recall every thing again into its proper cilinnel ; and thus dispel, as it were, the movement of death, when asserting-its-power in the body, and revive the senses when almost lost and overcome. For under what in- fluence, if not under this revival of the sentient motions, can bodies return to life, the mind being re-established, 3 even from the very threshold of dissolution, rather than depart and pass away to the bourne to which they had almost accomplished their course ? 1 Nor, though it may have united, #c.] Ver. 942. Nee congressa modo. " That is, si modo sit co:igressa ; si hoc etiam eveniat." Wake- field. Lucretius means to sa\ that there is abundance of matter for producing animals dispersed throughout the earth, $c., but which has not yet combined to produce vital motions. 2 Besides, a blow inflicted, if heavier, ! she supplies them food, by means of which they all support their bodies, and lead a pleasant life, and propagate offspring ; on which account she has justly obtained the name of Mother. That, also, which first arose from the earth, returns back into the earth ; and that which was sent down from the regions of the sky, the regions of the sky again receive when carried back to them ; nor does death so put an end to things as to destroy the atoms of matter, but only disunites their combinations, and produces new unions of particles, and is the cause that all things so change their forms, and vary their colours, and receive perception, and in a moment of time yield it up again. So that you may understand it to be of the greatest import- ance with what elements, and in what position and connexion, the same primordial-atoms of things are combined, and what impulses they mutually give and receive ; (nor suppose that the primary particles of things cannot remain eternal, because we see them fluctuate upon the suri\ice of things, and some- times apparently born and suddenly perish ;) as even in these very verses of mine it is of great consequence with what letters, and in what order, other letters are severally placed ; for the same letters, variously selected and combined, signify heaven, sea, earth, rivers, sun ; the same signify corn, groves, animals ; if the words are not all, yet by far the greater part are, alike, 1 at least so far as to have some letter or letters in common; but the subjects which they express are distinguished by the different arrangements of the letters to form the words. So likewise even in things themselves, when the intervals, passages, connexions, weights, impulses, collisions, move- ments, order, position, and configurations of the atoms of matter are interchanged, the things which are formed from them must also be changed. 1 If the wm-ds are not all, yet by far the greater part are, alike, S;c.~] Ver. 1017. Si non omnia sint, at tnulto maxima pars est Consimilis. I have translated this according to Wakefield's exposition : " liters eaedem, plures paucioresve, in verbis lonije pluribus inveniuntur." But I am not quite sure that this sense can fairly be extracted from it. Creech's interpretation is, " Si non oinnes sunt eaedem literae, at multo maxima pars eadem est," which can scarcely be thought intended to throw light on the subject. Lachmann seems to refei omnia to verba, but gives no further illustration. Other commenta- tors and translators afford no help whatsoever. 52 LUCRETIUS. B. ii. 10231050 Give your attention now, closely, 1 to the conclusions of juat reasoning, from what we have previously stated. For a new doctrine presses earnestly to approach your ear, and a new scene of things to display itself. But neither is any thing so easy, or credible, as that it may not seem rather difficult of be- lief at first ; nor, likewise, is there any thing so great, or any thing so admirable at first, at which all men alike do not by degrees less and less wonder. In the first place, consider the bright and pure colour of the sky, and that which the stars, wandering in all directions, contain in themselves, and the resplendency, from brilliancy of light, of the moon and the sun ; all which objects, if they were now first apparent to mortal eyes ; if they were, / say, now first presented to them unexpectedly and suddenly, what could be mentioned, which would be more wonderful than these phenomena, or which the nations of the world could less presume, beforehand, to believe would exist? Nothing, as I conceive; so wonderful to men would this scene of things have been, for the sake of which no man, you may observe, now deigns to look up to the bright regions of the sky, every one being listless from satiety of viewing it. Wherefore for- bear, through being alarmed at mere novelty, to reject any argument or opinion from your mind, but rather weigh it with severe judgment, and, if it seem to you to be just, yield your assent to it ; or, if it be false, gird up your loins to op- pose it. For, since the sum of space, abroad beyond these walls of our world, is, as I have proved, infinite, my mind proceeds to make inquiry what there exists farther onwards, in those parts into which the mind perpetually longs to look, and into which the free effort of thought itself earnestly- desires to penetrate. The first point which I advance is, that in every direction around us, and on all sides, above and below, there is no limit through the whole of space, as / myself have demonstrated, and as truth itself spontaneously proclaims, and the nature of 1 Give your attention now, closely, $ c -] Ver. 1023. Nunc animum nobis adhibe, &c. Being now about to assert that there are many worlds, and that they are born and perish ; a doctrine which many might be slow to believe ; he does not think fit to advance it without gravely demanding the attention of the reader. B. ii. 1051-1080. LUCRETIUS. 93 the profound itself makes clear as light. But by no means can it be thought probable, when infinite space lies open in every quarter, and when seminal-atoms, of incomputable number and unfathomable sum, driven about by everlasting motion, fly through the void in infinite ways, that this one globe of the earth, and this one heaven, have been alone pro- duced ; and that those innumerable particles of matter do nothing beyond our sphere ; especially when this world was made by merely natural-causes, and the atoms of things jost- ling about ' of their own accord in infinite modes, often brought together confusedly, ineffectually, and to no purpose, at length successfully coalesced ; at least such of them as, thrown to- gether suddenly, became in succession 2 the beginnings of great things, of the earth, the sea, the heaven, and the race of ani- mals. For which reason, it is irresistibly incumbent on you to admit, that there are other combinations of matter in other places, such as is this world, which the ether holds in its vast embrace. Further, when abundance of matter is ready, and space is at hand, and when no object or cause hinders or delays, things must necessarily be generated 3 and brought into being. And now, if there is such a vast multitude of seminal-atoms as the whole age of all living creatures would not suffice to number, and if there remains the same force and nature, that can throw together the atoms of things into every part in the same manner as they have been thrown together into this, you must necessarily suppose that there are other orbs of earth in other regions of space, and various races of men and gener- ations of beasts. To this is to be added, that in the WHOLE of our world there is no one thing which is produced single, and grows up alone and by itself, but that every thing is of some class, and that there are many individuals in the same kind. Thus, among animals especially, you will, by your own observation, 4 see this 1 Jostling about.] Ver. 1059. Forte offensando. 2 Became in succession.] Ver. 1062. Fierent semper. From time to time. 3 Generated.] Ver. 1069. Geri. Properly, carried on. Lambinus read geni. 4 By your own observatior, ] Ver. 1080. Indice mente. " By the observation of your mind ; i " you attend to the suggestions and ad monitions of reason." Wakefield. 94 LUCRETIUS. B. n 10811110. to be the case as to the brood of wild beasts thatl'ange over the mountains ; you will find the same as to the race of men, male and female ; ' the same, moreover, as to the mute swarms of fishes, and all the kinds of birds. Wherefore it is to be admitted, that, in like manner, the heaven, and the earth, and the sun, the moon, the sea, and other things which exist, are not single, but rather of infinite number ; since these follow | the same general law* as other things that arise and decay; the limit of existence, deeply and unalterably fixed, awaits these parts of nature as well as others, and they consist as much of a natural body, generated but to die, as the whole race of animals which abound, in their several kinds, in this state of things. Which points if, being well understood, you keep in mind, and reason from them, the system of nature immediately ap- pears, as a free agent, released from tyrant masters, to do V every thing itself of itself spontaneously, without the help of the gods. For (0 ye sacred bosoms of the deities, that pass in tranquil peace a calm and most serene existence !) who is able to rule the whole of this immense universe? Who can hold in his hand, with power to guide them, the strong reins of this vast combination of things ? What god can, at the same time, turn round all the heavens, and warm all the earth with ethereal fires ? Or what god can be, at the same moment, present in all places, to produce darkness with clouds, and shake the calm regions of heaven with thunder, and then to hurl bolts, and overturn, as often happens, his own temples ; or afterwards, retiring to the desert and uninhabited parts of the earth, to rage there, exercising that weapon with which he often misses the guilty, and kills the innocent and undeserving ? And after the time when the world was produced, and the natal day of the sea, and the rise of the earth and the sun, atoms were added from without ; seeds, which the vast WHOLE, by agitation, contributed, were conjoined ; whence the sea and the earth had the means of increase, and whence the mansion of the sky amplified its vastness, and raised its lofty vaults far above the earth, and the air rose higher and higher. For to 1 Race of men, male and female.] Ver. 1082. Hominum geminam proicm. " Utrumque sexum." Creech, \\.genitamprolem. * Since these follow the same general law, $c.] Ver. 1087. In intro- ducing these words, I follow Lambinus's elucidation. .ii.llll-1138. LUCRETIUS. 95 every body in nature, from all regions of space, are con- tributed, by the agitation of particles, its own proper atoms, and they betake themselves severally to their own kinds of mat- tfr; (he particles oj moisture pass to water ; the earth is in- creased with atoms of earth; and the fiery-principles produce fire, and the aerial air ; until, a* stick operations proceeded, nature, the perfectress and parent of the world, brought all things to the utmost limit of growth ; as happens when that which is received into the vital passages, is no more in quan- tity than that which flows away and passes off. In these cir- cumstances, the age and growth of all beings l must be at a stand ; here nature, by her own influence, restrains further increase. For whatsoever creatures you see enlarge themselves to a full and lively buii^, and climb, by degrees, the steps to a mature age, receive into themselves more atoms than they emit ; whilst the nourishment is readily distributed through the veins, and whilst their bodies are not so widely dilated 2 as to expel many, that is, a disproportionate number of particles, and to cause the waste to be greater than the food on which their life sustains itself. For certainly we must admit that many atoms flow off and pass away from bodies ; but, till they have reached the highest point of growth, more ought to accrue to them. From that point, age reduces by degrees their mature force and strength, and melts away and sinks down to its decline. Since the larger any creature is, at the time when its increase is stopped, and th-:- greater is its extent of surface, the more atoms it disperses, 3 and emits from itself, in all directions around ; nor is the whole of its food readily distributed through its veins ; nor is there sufficient nourish- ment generated from the food, in proportion to theeffluvia which the body discharges, 4 whence as much support as is necessary 1 In these circumstances, the age and growth of all beings, c.J Ver. 1120. Omnibus his (etas debet consistere rebus. I do not consider that omnibus agrees with rebus, but that it is in the daiive case, and his rebus in the ablative. In four MSS. Lambinus found Omnibus hie, (See., which will give the same sense, though omnibus be then re- garded as agreeing with rebus. 2 Dilated/] Ver. 1126. Dispersa. " Dilatata." Creech. 3 The greater is its extent of surface, the more atoms it dis-^ perses.] Ver. 1134. Quo latior est, Plura modo dispergit. " Quo modo latior est, M modo plura dispergit." Wakefield. 4 In proportion to the effluvia vr\iich~?ke body discharges.j \ er. 96 LUCRETIUS. B. ". 1139 1161 can arise and be supplied to it, 1 and whence nature can recruit what is requisite. Bodies, therefore, naturally decay, as they are wasted by their substance passing off, and as all things yield to external attacks ; for food at last fails to support ad- vanced age ; and hostile atoms, striking externally, cease not to exhaust every creature, and subdue it with assaults. So likewise the walls of the great world, being assailed around, shall suffer decay, and fall into mouldering ruins. For, if things are kept in vigour, it is nourishment that must recruit them all by renewal ; and it is nourishment that must support, nourishment that must sustain all. But it is in vain to expect that this frame of the world will last for ever ; for neither do its veins, so to speak, submit to receive what is suf- ficient for its maintenance, nor does nature minister as much aliment as is needed. And thus, even now, the age of the world is debilitated, and the earth, which produced all races of creatures, and gave forth, at a birth, vast forms of wild animals, now, being ex- hausted, scarcely rears a small and degenerate offspring. The earth, I say, which produced all creatures; for it was not, as I conceive, a golden chain from above 2 that let down the tribes of mortals from heaven into the fields ; nor did the sea, or the waves that beat the rocks, produce them ; but the same earth, which now nourishes them from her own substance, generated them at first. Moreover the earth herself, of her own accord, first pro- duced for mortals rich crops and joyous vineyards ; she her- self supplied sweet herbs over the abundant pastures, which now scarcely reach-a-full-growth, 3 though assisted and aug- 1137. Pro quam largos exastuat eestus. Proquam is rare. It occurs again iii. 200. 1 Whence as much suftjort as is necessary, $e.] Ver. 1138. Unde queant tantum suboriri ac suppeditare. " Queant, sc. corpora," say Wakefield. Others read queat. which is more satisfactory. Vnde, whence, i. e. from the food. * Golden chain from above.] Ver. 1155. "All creatures, I say, sprung from the earth ; for living things were not, as the assertoirs of a providence affirm, let down from heaven by that golden chain which none but Homer ever saw (II. ix. 18) ; nor were they generated from the sea and its waves; but the earth, which now nourishes all things, originally produced all things." Faber. 1 Scarcely reach-a-full-growth.] Ver. 1161. Vix grandescunt. This eomplamt of the decay and degeneracy of things has been common a. it. 11621175. LUCRETIUS. 97 merited by our toil. We both wear out our oxen and exhaust the strength of our husbandmen, being scarcely supplied with fruits from our slowly-yielding fields. To such a degree do the productions of the earth decline, and increase only with human labour. And in these days the sturdy ploughman, shaking his head, sighs that his great toil has too often fallen out in vain ; and, when he compares the present times to the times past, frequently praises the good-fortune of his fore- father. The planter of the degenerate vine, also, sad and fatigued, accuses the progress of time, and wearies heaven with prayers for better seasons; and often remarks how the an- cient race of men, full of piety, spent their lives happily 1 within narrow limits, when the portion of land, cultivated formerly by each individual, was much less than at present; nor does his untaught mind understand that all things, exhausted by a long course of time, gradually waste away and pass to their grave. to poets from Homer downwards. Johnson ridicules it in his Lift; of Milton. 1 Spent their lives happily.] Ver. 1172. Perfacilttolerartt avom, " Beati viverent ; as in Terence, Quam vos facile vivitis ! and in .Homer II. vii. 138, psta ^uovrtf is applied to the gods," Faber. BOOK IIL ARGUMENT. Having, in the first two books, treated of the nature and qualities of atoms, Lucretius proceeds, in the four following books, to speak of what is formed from those atoms. He occupies the third book with a description of the na- ture of the mind and the soul, commencing (ver. 1 13) with a eulogy on Epicurus, who taught that the world was formed, not by any divine power, but from a fortuitous concourse of atoms, and who succeeded, beyond any other philosopher, in relieving the minds of men from the fear of the gods, of death, and of torments after death, ver. 14 40. Many who pretend to be free from this fear, are still disquieted with it ; and it is often the source of crimes, ver. 41 93. He then shows that the mind and soul are a part of man, not less than the hand or foot, and not a mere harmony of the parts of the body, as some philosophers taught, ver. 94 106. Reasons ou the separate affections of the body and mind, on sleep, on corporeal mutila- tions, and on the cessation of breathing, ver. 107 137. Uses the terms mind and soul indiscriminately, yet shows that the mind (animus) is the chief part, residing in the middle of the breast, the soul (anima) being diffused throughout the body, and under the direction of the mind, ver. 138 161. That this mind, and soul, are corporeal, acting on the body by material impact, and consisting of minute atoms, imperceptible to the senses, ver. 161 231. That the substance of the soul and mind is not simple, but composed of four subtle consistences, heat, air, aura, and a fourth, to which no name is given, ver. 232 323. That the soul and body cannot be separated without destruction to both ; and that the sentient power is not confined to the soul, ver. 324 370. He then refutes the opinion of Democritus, who thought that the soul and body had corre- spondent parts, ver. 371 396. Shows that the preservation of life depends more on the mind than on the soul, yer. 397 417. Afterwards he demon- strates, by twenty strict arguments, and six additional observations, thiit the soul perishes with the body, ridiculing, by the way, the Pythagorean transmigration, ver. 418 841. Hence he observes, that, as death is the end of man, nothing is to be feared after it ; that it cannot be in itself an evil, because the dead can regret nothing that they have left ; and that prolongation of life is not to be desired, as it would furnish nothing but what has been already enjoyed, ver. 842 988. Says that all the Tarta- rean sufferings which are dreaded after death, are witnessed and endured in life, ver. 989 1036. Consoles mankind, by observing that the best men have died as well as the worst, and exhorts them to contemplate death with reason and calmness, ver. 1037 1088. Concludes with a few more moral reflections to the same purpose, ver. 1089 1107. 100 LUCRETIUS. B m. 1-24 O thou, who, from so great darkness, wast first able to raise so effulgent a light, shedding-a-lustre-on the blessings of life, thee, O glory of the Greek nation, I follow, and now place the steps of my feet formed upon thy impressed traces, 1 yet not because I am so eager to rival, as because, from the love which I feel for thee, I desire to imitate thee. For why should the swallow contend with swans ? Or what, that is all similar, can kids, with trembling limbs, and the strong vigour of the horse, perform in the race? Thou, O father, art the dis- coverer of truths; 2 thou suppliest to us paternal precepts, and from thy writings, O illustrious teacher, as bees gather 3 from all blossoms in the flowery glades, so we feed upon thy golden words ; golden, / say, and most worthy of perpetual existence. For as soon as thy system of philosophy began to proclaim aloud the NATURE OF THINGS, as it arose in thy divine intel- lect, 4 the terrors of the mind disperse ; the walls of the world open ; I see things conducted throughout the mighty void of space ; the calm divinity of the gods 5 appears, and their tran- quil abodes, which neither winds disturb, nor clouds sprinkle with showers, nor snow falling white, congealed with sharp frost, inconveniences; 6 but the pure air is always cloudless, and smiles with widely effulgent light. 7 To them, moreover, nature supplies all things, nor does any cause, at any time, diminish the tranquillity of their minds. But the regions of 1 Steps of my feet formed upon thy impressed traces.] Ver. 4. Ficta pedum pono pressis vestigia signis. " Ponoque vestigia pedum (i. e. sola pedum) ficta (i. e. se fingentia,) effigiata, deformata, in tuis signis, vel signis tuorum pedum." Wakefield. 2 Discoverer of truths.] Ver. 9. Rerum inventor. "Philosophise auctor, founder of true philosophy." Creech. 3 As bees gather.] Ver. 11. Limant. This is adopted by Wake- field in the sense of decerpunt, delibant, " cull, gather." Others, with Lachmann, read libant. 4 Thy divine intellect.] Ver. 15. Divinu mente coortam. This is the reading of Wakefield, referring to the mind of Epicurus ; Lambinus and his followers read haud divinu mente, that is, not from the mind of the gods. * Calm divinity of the gods.] See i. 646651. ' Inconveniences.] Ver. 21. Violat. I hesitated what word to choose for this, and took one of the mildest that I could find. Creech has invades, but this is no proper sense of the word. 1 Effulgent light.] Yer. 22. Diffuse lumiiie. See i. 9. B in. 2553. LUCRETIUS. 101 Acheron., on the other hand, are no where apparent ; nor does the dark earth hinder but tl at all things, whatever are done beneath our feet throughout the void, may be seen and con- templated. Under the influence of these wonders disclosed there, a certain divine pleasure and dread penetrates me ; amazed that nature, thus manifestly displayed by thy power, has been in all parts revealed to us. And since I have shown ' of what kind the primordial atoms of all things are, and how, differing in their various forms, and actuated by motion from all eternity, they fly through the void of space of their own accord ; 2 and since I have also de- monstrated by what means all individual things may be pro- duced from them ; the nature of the MIND and of the SOUL now seems, next to these subjects, proper to be illustrated in my verses ; and there must be driven utterly from our minds 3 that fear of Acheron, which disturbs human life from its very foundation, suffusing all things with the blackness of death, nor allows any pleasure to be pure and uncontaminated. For as to what men often say, that diseases, and a life of infamy, are more to be feared than Tartarus, the successor of death ; and that they know the consistence of the soul to be of the nature of blood, or even of breath, (if their inclination happen to lead them to such an opinion,) and have no need at all of our reasoning and instruction; you may perceive, for the reasons that follow, 4 that all these observations are thrown out more for the sake of praise and vain-i/lory, than because the belief itself is settled in their minds ; for the very same boasters, exiled from their country, and driven far from the sight of men, disgraced with foul guilt, and afflicted with all calamities, yet still continue to live ; and whithersoever, notwithstanding, the unhappy men have come, they offer sa- crifices to the dead, as if their souls were still in existence, and immolate black cattle, and send oblations to the Dii Manes, 1 And since I have shown, $e.] Ver. 31. " Having, in the first and second books, stated many particulars concerning atoms, and their figures and motions, he now proposes an exact discussion concern- ing the soul, with a view to deliver men from the fear of death and of panishment after death." Creech. * Of their own accord.] Ver 33. i. e. By their own weight. * Driven utterly from our minds.] Ver. 37. Prceceps agwidut, " Elliptically for in praceps, as if in prcecipitium." Waktifield. * For the reasons that follow.] Ver. 46. Hittc. 102 LUCRETIUS. B. in. 54 S2. and, in their calamitous circumstances, apply their minds much more zealously to religion than before. For which rea- son, it is more satisfactory to contemplate a person, in order to judge of his character, in doubtful dangers, and to learn what he is in adverse circumstances ; since words of truth .ire then at last elicited from the bottom of the heart, and the mask is taken away, while the reality of the man remains. Furthermore, avarice, and the blind desire of honours, which drive men to transgress the bounds of right, and some- times, as the accomplices and ministers of crimes, to strive night and day, with excessive labour, to rise to the height of power ; these passions, I say, which are the wounds and plagues of life, are nourished for the most part by the dread of death. For, in general, infamous contempt, and sharp po- verty, seem removed from a pleasing and secure state of life, and seem to dwell, as it were, before the very gates of de- struction. From which cause, while men, not submitting to die to avoid those evils, but restrained by a false terror of death and its consequences, wish that they may escape far, and re- move themselves to a distance, from disgrace and want, they increase their property with civil bloodshed, and greedily double their riches, heaping slaughter on slaughter ; they cruelly re- joice at the sad end of a brother, and hate and dread the tables 1 of their relations. From the same terror, 2 in like manner, envy often wastes men away ; they grieve that he who walks before them in shining honour, should be powerful, should be looked upon with respect; they complain that they themselves are tossed about in obscurity and dishonour. 3 Some pine to death for the sake of statues and a name, and often to such a degree from the fear of death, does the hatred of life, and of seeing the light, affect men, that with a despairing mind, they com- mit self-murder; 4 forgetting that this fear is the source of all 1 Dread the tables, #c.] Ver. 73. Through fear of poison. * From the same terror.] Ver. 74. If men were not afraid of suicide, they might escape from the sight of all that disquiets them. 3 Tossed about in obscurity and dishonour.] Ver. 77. In teiiebris volvi canoque. In darkness and in dirt. 4 To such a degree, commit self-murder.] Ver. 79, seq. "This strange and inconsistent effect of fear is wtll commented upon in the following verses of Butler ; who tells us that it will often Do things not contrary alone To th' force of nature, but its own ; B.III. 83 98. LUCRETIUS. 103 cares ; l that this violates modesty, that this bursts the bonds of friendship ; this, in fine, prompts mortals to overthrow piety and virtue. For men have often betrayed their country, and their dear parents, while seeking to avoid the regions of Acheron. Since as children tremble, 2 and fear every thing in thick darkness, so we, in the light, fear sometimes things which are not more to be feared than those which children dread, and imagine about to happen, in the dark. This terror of the mind, therefore, it is not the rays of the sun, or the bright ai-rows of day, that must dispel, but the contemplation of nature, and the exercise of reason. First, then, I say, that the mind, 3 which we often call the^ intellect, in which is placed the conduct and government of life, is not less an integral part of man himself, than the hand, and foot, and eyes, are portions of the whole animal. Although, indeed, a great number of philosophers have For men as resolute appear With too much as too little fear ; And when they're out of hopes of flying, Will run away from death, by dying." Good. Men, rather than live perpetually in fear of the worst, dare the worst. 1 Forgetting that this fear is the source, * substance."] Ver. 242. Quarto, qu&dam tiatura The reader now understands Lucretiu's composition of the soul. See note on ver. 121. B. in. 267-297. LUCKETIUS. Ill they are, as it were, the power of a single body. As, in the herd of animals, whichsoever you would inspect, 1 there is a certain odour, and heat, and taste ; and still from all these is composed one mass and combination of body. So heat, and air, and the secret power of aura, and that other active force, (which communicates the beginning of motion from itself to the other three, whence a sensible movement first arises through the viscera, 2 ) being mixed, produce one nature or sub- stance. For this fourth principle lies entirely hid, and re- mains in secret, within ; nor is any thing more deeply seated within our body ; and it is itself, moreover, the soul of the whole soul. As the force of the mind, and the power of the soul, mixed up with our limbs and entire body, remains latent, because it is composed of small and few atoms, so this name- less force, compounded of small particles, lies concealed, and is besides, as it were, the very soul of the whole soul, and rules throughout the whole body. In like manner, it must be the case that the aura, and air, and heat, mixed throughout the limbs, possess-their-vigour one with another ; and that one may possibly subside at times, or become prominent, more than the rest ; but so that they may still seem to be one prin- ciple compounded of them all ; and that the heat and aura by themselves, or the power of air by itself, may not, being se- parated from the whole, destroy and dissipate the sense. There is also that heat in the mind, which it assumes in anger, when it burns, and ardour gleams vividly from the eyes. There is also much cold aura, the attendant of fear, with which it produces shivering throughout the various mem- bers, and agitates the limbs. There is also that state of the air when at rest, which happens in concurrence with a tranquil breast and serene countenance. But in those animals, whose fierce hearts, and angry feelings, easily burn in wrath, there is more heat ; in which class especially is the violent fury of 1 As, in the herd of animals, whichsoever you would inspect.] Ver. 267. Quod genus, in quo vis animantum visere vulgo. Quod genus is the same as quemadmodum; on which point the reader may con- sult Wakefield on this verse, and on iv. 739. The same words occur a little below, ver. 277 and 328. " In quo vis animantum visere yulgo," says Wakefield, "is in vulgo animantum, quo vis visere, i. e. quemcunque animantem veils intueri. " The editions before Wakefield read in quovis viscere, which Lachmann has recalled. * Viscera.] Ver. 273. Viscera meant all parts under the skin, except bone. See on i. 833. 112 LUCRETIUS B. in. 298-323. lions, which, raging, often burst, as it were, their hearts with roaring, nor can contain within their breasts their torrents of ire. But the cold temperament of deer has more of the aura in it, and sooner excites a chill influence through the viscera, which cause a tremulous motion to arise in the limbs. But the nature of the ox subsists more on calm air, nor does the smoky torch of wrath, applied to him, 1 ever irritate him to fury like that of the lion, suffusing him with a shade of thick darkness ; 2 nor is he torpid, transfixed with the cold darts of aura; but is situate between the two natures, those of deer and fiercer lions. Thus is the race of men. Each has a certain temperament; K and though instruction may in a manner render some in- dividuals polished, it still leaves the first traces of the nature of every mind ; nor is k to be thought that vices can be so plucked out by the root, but that one man will run more readily than another into violent anger ; a second will be af- fected somewhat sooner than another by fear ; while a third will regard certain things more indulgently than is right. And in many other respects the various natures, and yielding man- ners of men, must necessarily differ ; of which differences I cannot now explain the secret causes, nor find so many names for figures as there are diversities of shape in the atoms from which this variety in things arises. But, with reference to these subjects, I think myself compe- tent to affirm this ; that so small are the traces left of the natural ' principles, which reason cannot remove 3 by her dictates, that nothing hinders men from leading a life worthy of the gods. 1 Nor does the smoky torch of wrath, applied to him, $e.] Ver. 3(M. Nee minus ira'i fax nunq-uam subdita percit Fwnida. There seems scarcely any possibility of extracting satisfactory sense from this line, unless by considering minus nunquam equal to unquam ; and this construction I have adopted. Lambinus read, nee nimis ira'i fax unquam; and had Lachmann. who follows Lambinus, and who in other places animadverts severely on Wakefield and Forbiger, paid that nobody but they could think this verse in a right state, most readers would surely have agreed with him. The meaning is evident; that the ox may be excited, but not to the same degree as the lion. 2 Suffusing darkness.] Ver. 305. Suffundens cac~utui, I have grown dull and stupid. * And as the mind is one single part, -c.] Ver. 547. The eighth argument. Since the mind is part of a man, like any other member or organ, as already shown (ver. 94) ; and since any other member or organ cannot exercise its functions, or even preserve its existence, if separated from the body, how can we suppose that the mind dif- fers from them in this respect? 3 Further, the animated powers of the body and mind, $c.] Ver. 657. The ninth argument. The mind and body united together, enjoy life, but when they are disjoined, the body dies, and are we not to suppose that the soul dies also? Can we imagine that it pre- serves its existence in the air? At the commencement of the par^ graph I have altered potestas into "powers." B. iii. 659579. LUCRETIUS. 123 for neither can the nature or substance of the mind, without tLe body, alone, and of itself, produce vital motions ; nor again, can the body, deprived of the soul, continue its state of txistence, and use its faculties. Just, for example, 1 as the eye itself, torn from its roots, can discern no object apart from the whole body, so the mind or soul seems to have no power in itself; evidently because when mingled throughout the veins and viscera, throughout the nerves and bones, they are held-in-close-confinement by the whole body, and their primary-particles, not being free, cannot fly asunder to great distances ; consequently, being thus confined, they move with sensitive motions, with which, after death, when cast forth beyond the body into the air of heaven, they cannot move ; for this very reason, that they are not held-confined in a si- milar manner. For surely the air forms body and soul, 2 if the soul shall be able to keep itself together in the air, and to contain itself for exerting those motions, which it before exercised amidst the nerves, and in the body itself. On which account, 1 say again and again, you must necessarily admit that when the whole enclosure of the body is dissolved, and the vital breath cast forth, the sentient-existence of the mind and the soul is dissolved ; since there is common cause and like fate to both. Besides, when the body cannot bear the dissociation 3 of the 1 Just, for example, $c.] Ver. 562. Scilicet. Ver. 564. " Mind or so\il seems:" anima atque animus videtur. Ver. 565. "when mingled:" mixtim. 2 For surely the air forms body and soul, $e.] Ver. 572. Corpus atque animam serit aer, si cohibere sese anima, atque in eos poterit concludere motus, &c. The serit is Wakefield's; Lambinus and his followers have corpus enim atque animans erit aer ; on which Lambinus very judiciously comments thus: " If the atoms of the soul, when in the open air, can keep themselves together, and pro- duce the same motions as when they were in the body, the air will then be both a body and a living creature ; but this is absurd, there- fore, &c." But this did not satisfy Wakefield, who, finding in cer- tain manuscripts serit, transferred it to his text, with an exposition which I shall leave in his own Latin. " Aer est, qui serit (vel gig- nit * * * ) corpus et animam, (i. e. animantem ex utroque compo- situm) si in acre se continere possit (anima) atque ab acre cohiberi: nib.il simpliciuset luculentius." Forbiger of course dutifully followed. But Lachmann has very wisely reinstated the reading of Lambinus. * Besides, when the body cannot bear the dissociation. 6 er. 116. Ut horum Tertia pars mdlA possit ratione rideri. "That is, any considerable part, as in Rev. viii. 7, The third part o* th trees, the sea, &c." Preigerus. to. IT. 126148. LUCRETIUS. 151 then the better understand that numerous images of bodies, composed of still smaller atoms, may flit about in various ways, without force or weight, and without impression on the senses. 1 [Of which bodies how fine a part the image is, there is no one can express, or give the due estimation of it in words.] But lest perchance you should think, that those images of objects alone wander abroad, which fly off from the objects themselves, there are others, also, which are produced spon- taneously, and are combined of themselves in this sky which is called the air ; those images, namely, which, fashioned in various shapes, are borne along on high, and, being soft in their contexture, never cease to change their figure, and to metamorphose themselves into the outlines of forms of every sort. This we sometimes see the clouds do, when we observe them thicken on high, and dim the serene face of the firma- ment, yet soothing the air, as it were, with their motion ; 2 as, frequently, the faces of giants seem to fly over the heaven, and to spread their shadows far and wide ; sometimes huge mountains, and rocks apparently torn from those mountains, seem now to go before the sun, now to follow close behind him; then some monster seems to drag forward, and to ob- trude, other stormy clouds. Understand, now, with how easy and expeditious a process these images are formed, and perpetually flow off, and pass away from objects. For there is always on the surface of bodies something redundant, which they may throw off; and this redundancy, or outside form, when it comes in contact with certain objects, as, for example, a thin garment, 3 passes 1 Without force and without impression on the senses.] Ver. 127. Nulla vi, cassaque sensu. " Which move with so small a force that they cannot affect the organs or senses." Creech. Between ver. 125 (ending with debts, which is Lambinus's conjecture for dttobus) and ver. 126, Lachmann very reasonably considers that there is a hiatus. The passage in crotchets is thought spurious by Wakefield. * Soothing the air with their motion.] Ver. 139. Aera mukentet motu. " By the variety of their shapes exhilarating the air, as it were, and diffusing over it a certain pleasantness." Wakefield. The reader will remember the passage in Hamlet, " Very like a whale," &c. 3 As, for example, a thin garment.] Ver. 148. Ut in primis vetiem. " As fiSri, dvTiica, jam, $ c . This is worthy of notice, for it means exempli gratia." Faber. A little below (ver. 152) in primis oc- curs again ; where, however, I have taken it, with Creech, in the ense of pracipue. 152 LUCRETIUS. u. IT. 149 ISO. through it ; but, when it strikes against rough rocks, or the substance of wood, is at once broken into fragments, so that it can present no image. But when objects which are bright and dense have stood in its way, as, above all, a looking-glass, neither of these effects happens ; for neither can images pass through it like a garment, nor be divided into parts before the smooth surface has succeeded in securing its entireness. 1 From this cause it happens that images abound among us; and, however suddenly, at any time whatsoever, you may place a mirror opposite an object, the image of it appears ; so that you may conclude that filmy textures of objects, and subtle shapes, are perpetually flying off from the superficies of every body. Many images are therefore carried off in a short space, so that the production of these forms must naturally be thought rapid. 2 And as the sun must send forth many rays in a short time, that all places may be constantly full of light, so, by a like process, many different images of bodies must necessarily be carried off from those bodies in a moment of time in all direc- tions round about ; since, whatsoever way we turn the mirror to the figures of objects, the objects are represented in it of a correspondent form and colour. Besides, at times when the state of the sky has just before been clear as possible, it becomes, with extreme suddenness, so frightfully overclouded on all sides, that you might think that all the darkness had left Acheron, and filled the immense vault of heaven ; so formidably, when such a gloomy night of clouds has arisen, does the face of black terror hang over the earth from above. Of which clouds, thin as they are, how thin a portion their image must be, as viewed in a reflecting surface, there is no man that can express, or give in words such an estimation a-s would be conceivable. And now attend further, and with how swift a motion images are borne along, and what activity is given to them as they swim across the air, so that, to whatever part they move, each with its several tendency, a short time only is spent in a 1 Has succeeded in securing its entireness.] Ver. 154. Meminit kevor prcestare salittem. More literally, has remembered to secure its safety. As to prcestare, comp. iii. 215, 221. 2 So that the production of these forms must naturally be thought rapid.] Ver. 161. Ut merit!) celer his rebus dicatur origo. " May justly be called rapid." This, like the lines on the activity of thought, (iii 183,) seems very tame. B, iv. 181-202. LUCRETIUS. 153 long distance, I will proceed to explain, though rather, if pos- sible, in agreeably-sounding verses than in many ;' as the short melody of the swan is better than the croak of cranes swept- afar among the ethereal clouds driven by the south-wind. In the first place, we have constant means of observing how swift in their motion those bodies which are light, and which consist of minute particles, are. Of which kind is the sun's light, and his heat ; for this reason, that they are com- posed of minute primary-atoms, which are, as it were, struck out, and make no difficulty to pass through the interval of air, driven on by a succeeding stroke ; for the place of light passing on is instantly supplied by other light, and brightness is, as it were, propelled by successive brightness. 2 Wherefore images must, in like manner, be able to pass through an inex- pressible space in a moment of time ; in the first place, because there is always some slight impulse 3 at a distance behind them, which may carry them forward and urge them on ; and se- condly, because they are sent forth formed with so subtle a texture, that they can easily penetrate any substances what- soever, and, as it were, flow through the intervening-body of air. Besides, if those atoms of bodies which are sent forth from within, 4 and from the central portion of them, as the light and heat of the sun, are seen, gliding over the whole space of the 1 In agreeably-sounding verses than in many.] Ver. 181. Snavi* dicis potius qitam multis. "Having regard to the nature of the sub- ject," says Wakefield, "which has been so treated in prose as to offend and weary the reader." The croak of cranes among the clouds seems to have been a proverbial expression : see Lambinus, who quotes a Greek epigram of Antipater Sidonius in Erinnam, containing a similar observation on the chattering of daws. The lines occur again, ver. 910, seq. 2 Successive brightness.] Ver. 191. Frotelo fulgure. " Protelum " is here used as an adjective; in the only other place where Lucre- tius has it, (ii. 532,) it is a substantive. It is of uncertain deriva- tion ; Vossius makes it from pro and telum, indicating a succession like that of a number of darts thrown forward one after another. 3 Some slight impulse, $c.] Ver. 194. Parvola causa Est procul 6 tergo. Creech interprets causa by sttfficiens vis, but would have par- vola in the ace. case, agreeing with simulacra understood. In this notion I do not think him right. Faber would read plurima causa. What cause or force impels images, or how it is produced, Lucre tiui does not explain. 4 Forth from within.] Ver. 200. Penitus ex &>. Comp. ver. 71. 1,34 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 203-227. air, to diffuse themselves abroad in a moment of time, and to fly' through sea and land, and to flood the heaven which is above, where they are borne along with such rapid lightness, what 'shall we say of those particles, then, which lie ready on the outmost surface of bodies ? Do you not conceive how much quicker and farther they ought to go, when they are once thrown off, and when nothing delays their progress ? And do you not feel certain that they should fly over a much greater distance of space in the same time in which the light of the gun traverses the heaven ? This also seems to be an eminently fitting example to show with how swift a motion the images of things are borne along, namely, that as soon as a bright-surface of water is placed in the open air, when the clear heaven is shining with stars, the radiant constellations of the sky immediately correspond in the water. Do you now understand, then, in what a moment of time this image descends from the regions of the air to the regions of the earth ? From which cause, however wonderful, 1 you must necessarily admit, again and again, the existence of bodies which strike the eyes and excite our vision, and flow with a perpetual issue from certain substances ; as cold from rivers, heat from the sun, spray from the waves of the sea, which is the consumer of walls round the shore ; nor do various voices cease to fly through the air ; 2 moreover the moisture, so to speak, of a salt taste, comes often into the mouth, when we are walking near the sea ; and, again, when we look at diluted wormwood being mixed, a bitterness af- fects our palate. So evidently a certain substance is borne rapidly away from all bodies, and is dispersed in all directions 1 From which cause, however wonderful, l$c.~] Ver. 217. Qua re etiam atque etiam mir& fateare necesse est Corpora, quae feriant oculos visumque lacessant, Perpetuoque fluant certis ab rebus obortu This is Wakefield's reading, which Forbiger retains. Lambinits and Creech, instead of mird, have mitti; which verb, or one similar, is sadly wanted. But Wakefield had the hardihood to t ay that it might well be dispensed with, and that we may sayfateri corpora as fateri peccata ! * Voices cease to fly through the air.] Ver. 222. Nee varice cessant voces volitare per auras. Faber observes that this is said in reference to the cases of those who have thought they heard words spoken when nobody was near them. B. iv. 228255. LUCRETIUS. 153 Around ; nor is there any delay or interruption allowed to the efflux ; since we perpetually perceive it with our senses, and may see all objects at all times, and smell them, and hear them sound. Further, since any figure felt with the hands in the dark is known to be the same which is seen by day and in clear light, it necessarily follows that touch and sight are excited by a like cause. If, therefore, we handle a square object, and that object affects us as a square in the dark, what object, in the light, will be able to answer to the shape of it, except its quadrangular image ? For which reason the faculty of dis- cerning forms is found to depend upon images, and it seems that no object can be distinguished by the eye without them. Now those images of objects, of which I am speaking, are carried in every direction, and are thrown off so as to be dis- tributed on all sides ; but, because we can see only with our eyes, it therefore happens, that whatsoever way we turn our sight, all objects on that quarter strike on it with their shape and colour. And the image causes us to see, and gives-us- means to distinguish, how far each object is distant from us. For when it is sent forth from the object, it immediately strikes and drives forward that portion of air, which is situated be- tween itself and our eyes ; and the whole of that air thus glides through our eyes, 1 and, as it were, brushes the pupils gently, and so passes on. Hence it comes to pass that we see how far distant each object is ; and the more air is driven before the image, and the longer the stream of it that brushes through our eyes, the farther each object seems to be removed from us. These effects, you may be sure, are produced with an ex- 1 The whole of that air thus glides through our eyes.J Ver. 249. Isque ita per nostras acies, perlabitur omnis, Et quasi pertergit pupillas, atque ita transit. " Per oculos nostros perlabitur." Creech. " Permanat per nostras pupillas oculorum." Ed. Delph. " Se faisant passage le long des prunelles." Coutures. This is very well, but what shall we maice of atque ita transit f If it enters the pupils of the eyes, to what part does it pass off? Good makes it very conveniently, " Strikes on the sen- tient pupil, and retires." But this was suggested. I suppose, by Wakefield's note, who, folding a difficulty, proposed to read sub in- stead of per. This notion about the stream of air making known th distance, is repeated in vtr. 280, seq. 136 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 256-284. quisitely rapid process, go that we see what the object is, and, at the same time, how far it is distant. In these matters it is by no means to be accounted wonderful, why, when those images which strike the eyes cannot b3 severally discerned, the objects themselves, from which they proceed, are perceived. For, in like manner, when the wind strikes upon us by degrees, and when sharp cold spreads over us, we are not wont to perceive each first and successive par- ticle of that wind and cold, but rather the whole together ; and we then perceive, as it were, blows inflicted upon our body, as if some substance were striking us, and producing in our frame a sense of its force which is without us. Besides, when we strike a stone with our finger, we touch the very ex- treme superficies of the stone, and the outside colour ; and yet we do not feel that colour with our touch, but rather perceive the hardness of the stone deeply seated within its substance. And now learn in addition to this, why the image of an object in a mirror is seen beyond the mirror ; for certainly it seems extremely remote from us. The case is the same as with those objects which are plainly seen out of doors, when a door, standing open, affords an unobstructed prospect through it, and allows many objects out of the house to be contem- plated. For this view, also, as well as that in the mirror, takes place, if I may so express it, with a double and twofold tide of air. For first is perceived the air on this side of the door-posts ; then follow the door-posts themselves on the right hand and on the left ; next the external light strikes the eyes, and the second portion o/*air, and all those objects which are clearly seen abroad. So, when the image from the glass has first thrown itself forward, and whilst it is coming to our sight, it strikes and drives forward the air which is situate between itself and the eyes, and causes us to per- ceive all this air before we see the mirror ; but when we have looked on the mirror itself, ' the image which is thrown 1 But when we have looked on the mirror itself, $c.] Ver. 28 r. Sedj ubi in speculum quoque sensimus ipsum, Continue a nobis in eum, quae fertur, imago Pervenit. Thus stands the passage in Wakefield and Forbiger. Wakefield rould join MMMMMK, and this is perhaps the best thing that can be done. As for the eum in the next line, he makes it agree with aero. LUCRETIUS. 157 off from us, reaches it, and, being reflected, returns to our eyes, and so, propelling another portion of air before it, rolls it on, and causes us to perceive this air before we see itself; and on that account seems to be distant, and to be so much removed from or behind the mirror. For which reason, again and again 1 say, it is by no means right for those who study these matters, to wonder at the effects which attribute vision from the surface of mirrors to the influence of two portions of air ; since the appearance is produced by means of both. Now that which is in reality the right side J of our bodies, is made to appear on the left side in mirrors, for this reason, that when the image, which proceeds from our person, strikes upon the plane of the mirror, it is not reflected without a change, but, being turned back, it is so struck out of its former state, as would be the case with a mask of plaster, if, before it were dry, any one should dash its face against a pillar or a beam ; when, if it should preserve, at that instant, its true figure as in front, or as when its front was presented to you, and should exhibit itself, or its exact features, driven back through the hinder part of the head, it will happen that the eye which before was the right, is now become the left, and that which was on the left, correspondently, is made the right. It is contrived, also, that an image may be transmitted from mirror to mirror ; so that five, and even six images, have been often produced. For whatsoever object in a house shall be hid, as lying back in the interior part of it, it will yet be pos- sible that every such object, however removed out of sight by crooked turnings and recesses, may, (being drawn out, by First comes to us the imago speculi, propelling a certain portion of air ; then comes our own image from the speculum, striking upon that same air. But Lachmann judiciously changes in eum into ite- rum, and omits the in in the preceding verse. At the end of the para- graph "by means of both" answers ioutraque, which Wakefield, from Non. Marc. ii. 882, says is for utrinque or utroque; other editions have utroque. It is well for us, as Wakefield observes, that we are only the interpreters of Lucretius's language, and not the patrona of his philosophy. 1 Now that which is in reality the right side, S$c.] Ver. 293. The reader of this paragraph in Forbiger, will observe that lcev&, ver. 294, is for in Uevd ; other editions have in. Recta, ver. 296, is the participle ofrego, Oculos, ver. 301, is for oculus. 158 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 307-324. means of several glasses, through the winding passages,) b" seen to be in the building. So exactly is an image reflected from glass to glass ; and, when it has been presented to us 011- the-left-hand, it happens afterwards that it is produced on-the- right ; and thence it returns again, and changes to the same position as before. Moreover, whatever small sides or plates there are of glasses, formed with a round flexure similar to that of our own side, they, on that account, reflect to us images in the right posi- tion; 1 either because the image is transferred from glass to glass, and thence, being twice reflected, flies forward to us ; or, again, because the image, when it comes forth, is turned about, inasmuch as the curved shape of the glass causes it to wheel itself round to us. Further, you would suppose that our images in a mirror advance together with us, and place their foot with ours, and imitate our gesture ; which appearance happens from this cause, that from whatever part of the mirror you recede, the images, after that moment, cannot be reflected from that part, since nature obliges all images to be reflected from mirrors, (as well as to fly off from objects,) according to the corresponding ges- tures of the person whom they represent. 2 1 They, on that account, reflect to us images in the right position.] Ver. 314. Dextera ed propter nobis simulacra remittunt. I have trans- lated dextera according to the notion of Lambinus : quorum dextrce paries nostris dextris respondent. But what sort of glasses are intend- ed, or in what position we must conceive them placed, is very far from clear. I was inclined at one time to think that the columnar- concave mirror was meant, so that de specula in speculum, ver. 315, might signify from side to side of the glass ; and there is nothing in the text to contradict this supposition, unless it be said that de spe- culo in speculum will not bear this signification ; but this I may be allowed to doubt. Lambinus, however, explains it, teres speculifigura instar columna, evidently thinking the shape convex. Other com- mentators say nothing to the purpose. The notion of concavity seems rather to be favoured by ver. 318. Flexa figura docet speculi convortier ad nos : sc. imaginem. And Gassendi, De Physiologia Epicuri, vol. ii. p. 260, thinks that concave mirrors wern meant. 2 According to the corresponding gestures oj the person whom they represent.] Ver. 324. Ad tequos reddita flexus. Creech foolishly in- terprets ad aquas flexus by " ad aequales angulos." Lucretius had no thought of equal angles. Good rightly understands the passage to signify that the reflected image " must bear each variance of the parent form ; " and Coutures, that the reflexion must be made 1( per 1 egale opposition des surfaces." B. iv. 325354. LUCRETIUS. 159 Bright objects, also, the eyes avoid, and shrink from behold- ing. The sun even blinds you, if you persist to direct your eyes against it; inasmuch as the power of it is great; and images from it are borne down impetuously from on high through the clear air, and strike the eyes forcibly, disturbing and causing pain in their sockets. 1 Moreover, whatever splen- dour is strong, often burns the eyes, because it contains many seeds of fire, which produce pain in the organs-of-sight by penetrating into them. Besides, whatever objects jaundiced persons 2 look upon, be- come in their sight yellow like themselves ; because many atoms of yellow colour flow off from their bodies, meeting and tinging the images of objects ; and many of the same atoms are moreover mixed in their eyes, which, by their contagion, paint all things with lurid hues. But when we are in the dark, we see, from the darkness, objects that are in the light, because when the black air of the darkness, being nearer to us, has entered the open eyes first, and taken possession of them, the bright white air immediately follows, which, as it were, clears them, and dispels the black shades of the other air ; for this lucid air is by many degrees more active, and far more subtle and powerful : which, as soon as it has filled with light, and laid open, the passages of the eyes, which the dark air had previously stopped, plain images of objects immediately follow and strike upon the eyes, so that we see those objects which are situated in the light. This, on the other hand, we cannot do, when we look from the light to- wards objects in the dark, because the thicker air of darkness follows behind the light air; which thicker air fills the pores, and stops up the passages of sight, so that the images of any things whatsoever, being involved in it, cannot be moved forward into the eyes. 3 And when we behold the square towers of a city a long 1 Their sockets.] Ver. 329. Composituras. " Tdf ap/ioyae." Lam- binus. The settings of the eyes. 2 Besides, whatever objects jaundiced persons, $.] Ver. 334. Qiuecunque tuentur Arquati. " The explanation is extremely apposite, and, upon the Epicurean system of effluvia, highly ingenious." Good. 3 Images cannot be moved forward into the eyes.] Ver. 353. Ne simulacra Possint ullarum rerum contecta moveri. My translation 13 based upon Wakefield's interpretation. 160 LUCRETIUS. B. IT. way off, it happens, on account of the distance, that they often seem round, because every angle, being afar off, is seen a* ob- tuse, or rather is not seen at all; the impulse of its image dies away, and the force of it does not reach to our eyes ; since, while the images of it are borne through a large body of air, the air, by frequent percussions upon them, obliges that force to become-ineffective. Hence it comes to pass, that when every angle has escaped our vision at the same time, the constructed stones are seen as if fashioned to a round ; l not, however, like round objects which are immediately before us, and which are exactly circular, but they appear, as it were, nearly, after a shadowy fashion, resembling them. Our shadow likewise seems to us to move in the sun, and to follow our footsteps, and to imitate our gesture ; (if you can fancy air, devoid of light, to go forwards, following the move- ments and gesture of men ; for that which we are accustomed to call shadow can be nothing else but air deprived of light ;) evi- dently because the ground, in certain spots successively, is excluded from the radiance, wherever we, as we go, obstruct it; and that part of it, which we have left, is again covered with light. From this cause it happens, that what was the shadow of our body, seems to be still the same, and to have followed exactly-opposite us. For fresh illuminations of rays are perpetually pouring themselves forth ; and the first dis- appear as quickly as wool vanishes, if applied to a flame. 2 By this means the ground is both easily deprived of light, and again covered with it, and discharges from itself the black shadows. Nor yet in this case do we allow that the eyes are at all de- ceived ; fj: it is their business only to observe in whatever place there may be light or shade ; but whether the light is the same or not, and whether the same shadow, which was 1 As if fashioned to around.] Ver. 362. Quasi ut ad tornum. Tornus is generally considered to mean a turner's wheel, or lathe, or turning iron, but seems here to signify the figure formed by such instru- ment. Lambinus reads quasi tornata ut , and considers that ad tor- m came into the text from a gloss. * As wool vanishes, if applied to a flame.] Ver. 377. Quasi in ignem lana trahatur. " Nothing could be imagined more applicable and ex- pressive than this simile ; for what is consumed quicker than the fine filaments of wool, when they are set on fire ? " Wakefield. Good re- fers to Isaiah, xlii. 17, "They are consumed as tow; " and to Cow- per s Task, ii. 9, " As *be flax That falls asunder at the touch of fire.' B. iv. 384419. LUCRETIUS. 161 here, passes thither, or rather, as we said before, a new one is constantly produced, this the judgment of the mind only must determine ; for the eyes cannot know the nature of things ; and therefore you must not impute to the eyes that which may be the fault of the understanding. A ship, in which we sail, is carried forward, when it seems to stand still ; and that which remains stationary, is imagined to go by us ; and the hills and plains, past which we row our vessel, or fly with sails, seem to flee away astern. All the stars seem to be at rest, as being fixed to the vaults of the sky ; and yet all are in perpetual motion ; for when, after rising, they have traversed the heaven with their shining orbs, they return to their distant places-of-setting. And the sun and the moon, in like manner, seem to remain stationary ; bodies which observation itself shows to be carried forwards. And mountains rising up, at a distance, from the middle of the sea, between which a free passage for ships is open, yet appear without separation, so that one vast island seems to be formed from the two united. It likewise happens that to children, after ceasing to whirl themselves about, the rooms seem to turn, and the pillars to run round, so that they can hardly believe that the whole building is not threatening to fall upon them. And when nature begins to raise on high the beams of the sun, red with tremulous fires, and to exalt them above the hills, the hills over which the sun then appears to be, himself apparently touching them close, (glowing with his own beams,) are scarcely distant from us two thousand flights of an arrow, often even scarcely five hundred casts of a dart ; yet between them and the sun, which seems in contact with them, lie broad expanses of sea, stretched out under vast regions of sky ; and many thousand miles of land also intervene, which various nations of men, and tribes of wild beasts, occupy and overrun. And, to mention another ocular delusion, a puddle of water, not deeper than a finger, which settles among the stones in the paved streets, affords, apparently, a prospect downwards under the earth, to a depth as great l as the height to which the lofty arch of heaven extends above the earth ; so that you seem to look down upon the clouds and to see a heaven be- 1 To a depth as great.] Ver. 417. Impete tanto. " Id est tanta at- titudine." Lambinus. 162 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 420447. neath, and to behold, by a surprising effect, the celestial bodies buried in the sky under ground. Moreover, when a spirited courser sticks fast with us in the middle of a river, and we look down into the swiftly-flowing water of the stream, a force seems to be carrying the body of the horse, though standing still, in a contrary direction to the current, and to drive it rapidly up the river ; and, whitherso- ever we turn our eyes, all objects appear to us to be carried along, and to flow, in a similar manner. A portico, too, although it be of equal dimensions through- out, and standing supported with equal columns from-end-to- end, yet, when it is viewed from the extremity through its whole length, contracts gradually, as it were, to the apex of a tapering cone, joining the roof to the floor, and all the right- hand parts to the left, until it has narrowed-itself to the in- distinct point of the cone. To sailors at sea it occurs that the sun, having risen from the waves, seems also to set, and bury its light, in the waves ; as, in their situation, they behold nothing else but water and sky ; a remark which I make, that you may not lightly sup- pose that the senses are altogether deceived. But to those ignorant of the sea, 2 ships in the harbour often appear to strive, disabled in their equipments, against the broken waves ; for though whatever part of the oars is raised above the water of the sea, is straight, and the part of the helm above the water is straight, the parts which go down, and are sunk in the water, seem all, as if broken, to be turned and in- verted, sloping upwards, and, thus bent back, to float almost up to the surface of the water. And when the winds, in the night time, carry light vapours athwart the sky, the bright constellations seem then to glide against the clouds, and to pass along on high in a far different direction than that in which they are really borne. 3 1 Altogether deceived.] Ver. 436. Labefactari undique. * But to those ignorant of the sea, &c.] Ver. 437. At maris ignaris in portu clauda videntur Navigia aplustris, fractas obnitier undas. " Aplustria are ornaments of ships ; but the word, in this passage, signifies all parts of the vessel that rise above the water, as is shown by what follows." Creech. See ii. 555. The lines are not very satisfac- tory. Lambinus reads aphtstris fractis, which makes better sense. 3 Really borne.] Ver. 147. Raiione fentntur. ' \\n$Z>g, bvru. Fabet B. iv. 448-474. LUCRETIUS. 163 But if by chance the hand, applied to one eye, presses it underneath, it happens, by some impression on the sense, tha all things, at which we look, seem to become double as we gaze on them ; two lights in the lamps appear blossoming with flames ; the twin furnit jre seems to be doubled throughout the house ; and the faces of the people seem double, and their persons double. Moreover, when sleep has bound our limbs in agreeable re- pose, and the whole body lies in profound rest ; yet, at that very time, our limbs appear to be awake and to move them- selves, and we imagine that, in the thick darkness of night, we see the sun, and the light of day ; and, though in a con- fined place, we seem to change our position with respect to the heaven, the sea, rivers, awe? mountains, and to cross over plains on foot, and to hear sounds, though the unbroken silence of night reigns around us, and to utter words, though our tongues remain still. Other things of this class, exciting our wonder, we see in great numbers ; all which seek, as it were, to destroy the credit of our senses : but they strive in vain ; since the greatest part of these appearances deceive us only because of the fancies which we allow to bear upon them ; so that those things which have not been seen by our senses, are to us as if seen. For nothing is more difficult than to separate certain from doubtful things ; things which the mind, when their fallaciousness is discovered, straightway rejects from itself. 1 Moreover, if any one believes that nothing is known, 2 he himself, also, knows not whether that can be known from which he, forming a judgment, confesses that he knows nothing. Against him, therefore, I shall forbear to urge argument, who, of his own will, has placed himself with his face towards his footsteps. 3 And although I should even grant that he knows 1 Things which the mind straightway rejects from itself.] Ver. 469. Animus quas ab se protimis abdit. '* Abdit," says Wakefiela, " repettit, ryicit, rejects the doubtful, that it may admit the certain." Lach- mann, with Lambinus and Creech, reads ab se addit, that is, " adopts from its own fancy." 2 Moreover, if any one believes that nothing is known, -c.] Ver. 470. " These observations are directed against the Academics, who contend that nothing can be known and that the senses are falla- cious and deceitful." Lambiniu. 1 Who, of his own will, has placed himself with his face toward* M 2 lfu LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 475-489. this, I should still put to him the following question : when he lias seen no truth in things previously, how he knows what it is to know and not to know, in contradistinction to one another ? What cause, / shall ask him, produced his know- ledge of truth and falsehood, and what power has proved to him that what is doubtful differs from what is certain ? The knowledge of truth, you will find, is derived from the senses as-its-origin, 1 and you will own that the senses cannot be refuted. For that which, of its own power, 2 can refute false notions by real facts, must be found of greater credit than to be liable to confutation. What, then, must be esteemed of greater credit than the senses ? Shall reasoning, arising from erring sense, 3 reasoning, 1 say, which has arisen wholly from the senses, and which can depend on nothing else, be of suffi- cient force to refute those senses? For unless these, our tenses, are true and trust-worthy, all reasoning consequently becomes false and unfounded ? But what, that is external to the senses, shall confute the senses, or will they disagree among themselves, and refute one another? Will the ears be able to refute the eyes ? Or will the touch refute the ears ? Or will the taste of the mouth, moreover, refute the touch ? Will the his footsteps.] Ver. 473. Qui capite ipse suo in statuit vestigia sese. ' The order is, Qui ipse statuit sese suo capite in vestigia : i. e. who has turned his head towards the footsteps which he has left behind him, as if about to go over the same track, and has made no progress." Wakefield. 1 The knowledge of truth, you will find, is derived from the senses as its origin, %c.] Ver. 479. Invenies primis ab sensibus esse creatam Notitiam veri. See i. 424. "I think nobody can in earnest," says Locke, "be so sceptical as to be uncertain of the existence of those things whch he sees and feels. At least, he that can doubt so far will never have any controversy with me, since he can never be sure I say any thing contrary to his opinion." Essay, book iv. 11, 3, 8. 2 For that which, of its own power, ptoaentilna alia. " His wings disturbing and driving away the night with sound and flapping." Lambinw. B iv. 741763. LUCRETIUS. 173 compose. 1 Foi assuredly the image of a Centaur is not formed from a living Centaur, since there has been no such figure in life ; but when the images of a horse and a man have come together by chance, they easily and quickly cohere, (as we said before,) because of their subtle nature and filmy texture. Other images of this sort are produced in the same manner ; and since these, from their extreme lightness, are, as I have shown above, swiftly carried about, any one thin image of them all easily stimulates our mind with a single impression ; for the mind is itself subtle and eminently excitable. That these things take place, as I state, you may easily learn from hence ; that inasmuch as this impression on the mind 2 is similar to that on the bodily senses, it necessarily follows that that which we see with the mind, and that which we see with the eye, are effected by similar means. As I have shown, accordingly, that I perceive lions, for example, 3 by means of images of lions, which excite the eyes ; we may un- derstand that the mind is moved by images of lions in like manner, and by other images of other things,* which it sees and discerns equally and not less than the eyes ; only we must observe that it sees more subtle images. Nor for any other reason does this sense of the mind be- come awake when sleep has spread itself over the limbs, than because these same images excite our minds, which affect our senses when we are corporeally awake ; to such a degree that we seem plainly to behold him, of whom, his life having 1 Partly, those which images, formed of figures of these two kinds, compose.] Ver. 740. Et qua conficiunt ex horum facta figuris. " Et quas imagines simulacra, ex horum duorum figuris facta, confici- unt." Wakefield. * Inasmuch as this impression on the mind, Sfc.~] Ver. 752. Quatenus hoc simile est illi, quod mente videmus Atque oculis, simili fieri ratione necesse est. " Hoc simile est illi; this is like to that; namely, the image in the mind to the image which strikes the eyes ; and therefore quad mente videmus et quod oculis videmus, what we see with the mind, and what we see with the eye, must be similarly produced." Wakefield. 3 For example.] Ver. 754. Forte. "Quasi ita dicat: finge me aliquo casu leones videre." Lambinus. " Verbi gratia." Creech. 4 By images of lions, and by other images of other things.'] Ver. 7.57. Per simulacra leonum, cetera, qua; videt ague, Nee minus, atque oculi. " Per simulacra leonum et cetera simulacra, (i. e. aliarum rcrum simu- *acia,) quae videt aeque atque oculi." Forbiger. 174 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 764794 been yielded up, death and the earth h.ive already taken pos- session. This Nature of necessity brings to pass ; and from this cause, that all the senses of the body, being obstructed and bound up by sleep, are at rest throughout the set-eral mem- bers, and are unable to refute any false appearance by real facts. Besides, the memory lies inactive and torpid in sleep ; and shows no disbelief in appearances, or intimates that he, whom the mind imagines that it sees alive, has long ago par- taken of death and forgetful ness. As to what remains for consideration, it is not surprising that images should move, and agitate their arms, and other membersrwith regularity ; for it happens that many an image seems to do this in our sleep. This is to be explained in the fol- lowing way ; that when the first image passes off, and a second is afterwards produced in another position, the former then seems to have changed its gesture. This, doubtless, we must conceive to be done by a very rapid process ; so great is the activity of images, and so great the number of things from which they proceed; and so great too is the abundance of atoms, that it may suffice for that which is to be perceived by the senses, at any time whatsoever. And many other ques- tions are raised on these matters, and many points must be made clear by us, if we wish to explain these subjects dis- tinctly. In the first place, it is inquired why the mind immediately thinks of that very thing of which any one has desired to think. 1 Do images watch our pleasure, and, as soon as we wish, does an image present itself to us ? If it is our desire to think of the sea, of the earth, or of the heaven, of assem- blies of men, of a procession, of banquets, of battles, does nature create and prepare images of all these things at our word ? Especially when the minds of different men in the same country and place, think of things entirely different ? What shall we say, moreover, when we perceive images in our sleep advance before us in order, and move their pliant limbs ; when, as we observe them, they wave with ease their bending arms alternately, and repeat gesture after gesture with the foot corresponding to the look? Are images, forsooth, inspired with the art of dancing, and do they, skilled in ges- 1 Of which any one has desired to think.] Ver. 781. Quod cuiyue libido Venerit. That is, quod cuique libuerit (cogitare). *. iv. 795 813. LUCRETIUS. 175 ticulation, wander about, in order that they may make sport for its in the night time ? Or will this rather be the truth, that we perceive that variety of motions in one and the same por- tion of time ; as in that time in which one word is uttered, 1 many smaller portions of time, (which reason discovers to be in it,) are contained ? From this cause it happens, that at any time whatsoever, any images are ready at hand, pre- pared for all places ; so great is their activity, and so great the abundance of objects from which they proceed. By this means, when the first image passes away, and a second is afterwards produced in another position, the first then seems to have changed its gesture. And because images are subtle, the mind cannot acutely discern any but those which it earnestly endeavours to discern; all, therefore, which exist besides these, pass away unnoticed^ unless the mind has thus prepared itself and endeavoured to distinguish them. The mind, accordingly, does prepare itself and expects that that will occur which is consequent 2 on that which has preceded; so that it observes each particular oc- currence. Thus, therefore, the effect is produced. Do you not see, also, that the eyes, when they have begun to look at things which are small, exert and prepare them- selves ; and that we could not, without this exertion, clearly diicern them? And even in respect, also, to objects easily dis- tinguishable, you may observe, that if you do not apply your mind to remark any one of them, it is just the same as if it 1 As in that time in which one word is uttered, 8;c.] Ver. 797. Consentimus id, ut, quum vox emittitur ima, Tempora multa latent, ratio quae comperit esse. Does one time comprehend the motions of several times, as the pro- nunciation of one word comprehends the times of pronouncing each syllable ? See Wakefield. Lachmann ejects the first of these two verses. It had previously been condemned by Lambinus and Fa- ber. " On bien ne sera-t-il pas plus veritable, que dans le terns que nous exprimons notre pensee par quelque voix, il y a plusieurs instans cachez dans 1' espace de ce terns, par le moyen desquels 1' agilite" des images aussi bien que leur ecoulement universel, fournit en quelque terns que ce soit, de quoi remplir la variete' de la pensee." Coutures. 2 Expects that that will occur which is consequent, $c.] Ver. 807- Speratque futurum, Ut videat, quod consequitur, rem quamque. I have translated this according to the notion of Forbiger, as it is his text. ifperatque futurum quod conseqiiitur, ut videat rem quamque. Other editions (except Wakefield's) put no stop after consequitur. 176 LUCRETIUS. B. rr. 814-30. were all the time removed and far distant from youf How is it therefore surprising, if the mind loses sight of att other images, except those concerning matters to which it is itself directed? Besides, we form opinions of great things from small indications, and thus lead ourselves into the delusion of deceit. It happens, also, that sometimes a second image is not pre- sented of the same kind as the first, but that that which was before a woman under our hands, seems to be before us changed into a man ; or that one face, and one age follows after another ; but at this, sleep and oblivion prevent us from wondering. In these matters, remember that it is necessary diligently to shun this fault, 1 and to avoid it cautiously, as a most griet- ous error ; the fault, namely, of supposing that att the parts of animals were formed with a view to the uses to which they have been adapted; lest yon should suppose that the bright luminaries of the eyes were produced that we may be able to see with them; and that the pillars of the legs and thighs, built upon the feet, were united for this purpose, that we might 1 In these matters, remember that it is necessary diligently to shun this fault, ft.] Ver. 824. Illud in his rebus vitium vehementer inesse Effugere errorem, vitareque praemetuenter, Lumina ne facias oculorum clara creata, Prospicere ut possimus. It would occupy too much space to cite all the- different readings of this passage, and the emendations which have been proposed. All commentators have seen that there is no satisfactory sense to be ex- tracted from it as it stands. I have understood memento : (memento) inesse in his rebus vehementer effngere illud vitium (quasi) errorem, *e. The only successful correction is Lachmann's, who alters the first line to JBud M kit ritium veJkematier reb*\necesse at ,- a conjec- ture which the shades of Lambinns and Faber may wonder that they missed. ** Lucretius maintains that the eye was not made for seeing, nor the ear for hearing. But die terms in which he recommends this doctrine show how hard he knew it to be for men to entertain such an opinion. * * * Undoubtedly the poet is so far right, that a most 'vehement caution and vigilant premeditation' are necessary to avoid the vice and error of such a persuasion. The study of the adaptations of die human frame is so convincing, that it carries the mind with it, in spite of die resistance suggested by speculative systems." WJteweJTs Bridyewater Treatise, p. 351. B. IT. 830-865. LUCRETIUS. 177 take long steps on the road ; and, moreover, that the fore-arms fitted to the stout upper arms, and the hands ministering on either side, were given us that we might perform those offices which would be necessary for the support of life. Other suppositions of this sort whatever explanations men give are all preposterous, reasoning being thus perverted. For nothing was produced in the body to the end that we might use it ; but that which has been produced, being found serviceable for certain ends, begets use. Neither was the fa- culty of seeing in existence before the light of the eyes was made, nor that of speaking with words before the tongue was formed ; but rather the origin of the tongue long preceded speech, and the ears were made long before any sound was heard ; and, in fine, all members, as I think, existed before there was any use of them discovered. They could not, there- fore, have been produced for the sake of being used. But, on the contrary, to engage in battle with the hand, and to tear the limbs, and to pollute the body with gore, was prac- tised long before bright darts were hurled ; and nature com- pelled us to avoid a wound, before the left hand, by the help of art, presented the defence of a shield. And, certainly, to commit the wearied body to rest is of much more antiquity than the soft cushions of the couch ; and to quench the thirst was practised before cups were invented. Such things as these, then, which were found out from expe- rience and the objects o/life, may be believed to have oeen in- vented for the purpose of using them; those things, however, which were all first produced independently, gave a knowledge of their utility afterwards. Of which kind, especially, we see that the senses and members of the body are. Wherefore again and again 1 say, it is impossible for you to believe 1 that they could have been produced for the sake of use. This, also, is not to be wondered at, that the very nature of the body of every animal requires food. For I have shown that many atoms pass off and recede from substances in many ways; but the most numerous must pass ojf from animals; because they are exercised by motion, and many particles are carried forth, urged from the interior of the body, by perspir- ation ; many, also, are exhaled through the mouth, when they 1 It is impossible for you to believe.] Ver. 857. Procvl e* vt credere pottit. m 178 LUCRETIUS. 6. iv. 863 898. pant from weariness. By these means, therefore, the body wastes, and all its nature is undermined ; a state on which pain is attendant. On this account food is taken, that it may support the limbs, and, being given at intervals, may recruit the strength, and repress the eager desire of eating through- out the organs and veins. Liquid also descends into all parts of the body, whatsoever require liquid ; and the moisture, coming into the frame, dis- sipates the many collected atoms of heat, which cause a burn- ing in our stomach, and extinguishes them like fire, so that arid heat may no longer dry up our limbs. Thus, therefore, you see, panting thirst is expelled from our bodies ; thus the pining desire of food is satisfied. I will now state how it comes to pass that we can advance our steps when we please, and hmo it is given us to move our limbs out-of-the-direct-line ; l and what cause is wont to push forward this great weight of our body. Do thou, my friend, attentively-receive my instructions. I affirm, then, that IMAGES OF GOING first approach to the mind, and impinge on the mind, as we observed before re- specting images in general. Thence arises will, for no man begins to do any thing, before his mind has discerned what it will do. And according to what it discerns, is the image of his action. 2 When, therefore, the mind so stirs itself, that it desires to proceed and move forward, it immedi- ately acts on the substance of the soul, which is distributed in the whole body, and through the limbs and joints ; and this is easily done, since the substance of the soul is held united with the mind. That substance of the soul forthwith acts upon the body ; and thus, by degrees, the whole mass of the man is protruded and moved forwards. The body at that time, moreover, opens its pores, and the air, which is always easily excited to motion, enters, as it na- turally must indeed, through the open spaces, and penetrates 1 Out-of-the-direct-line.] Ver. 879. Fare. Wakefield's reading for the varie of other editors. 2 And according to what it discerns is the image of his action, j Ver. 86 Id, quad providet, Hints rei constat imago. " Id, nempe secundum, Karcl." Wakefield. So likewise Forbiger. Larabinui reads At quod, $c., and interprets the passage thus : " That which the mind foresees is the image of that thing which the man wills to do." B. iv. 896930. LUCRETIUS. ITS* the passages abundantly, and is thus dispersed through every minute portion of the body ; thus, therefore, the body, by two several powers, 1 is made to move along as a ship with sails and wind. Nor yet is it wonderful, in these matters, that atoms so small can wield so great a body, and turn about all our weight. For the wind, though but light and of thin substance, drives forward a large ship with vast power ; and one hand rules the vessel, with whatever speed it may be going ; while one helm turns it in any direction. And a machine, by the help of wheels and pulleys, lifts many bodies of great weight, and raises them on high with but a slight force. And now I shall explain by what means sleep spreads rest through our limbs, and dispels the cares of the mind from our breast; but I shall do this rather in agreeably-sounding than in numerous verses, as the short melody of the swan 2 is better than the croak of cranes, dispersed among the clouds of hea- ven, driven by the south wind. Do you only, Memmius, devote to me your attentive ears and discerning mind, that you may not deny what I say to be possible, and depart from me with a breast repelling true precepts, when you yourself are in fault, and yet cannot perceive that such is the case. In the first place, sleep occurs when the substance of the soul has been disturbed throughout the several members, and has partly seceded from the body, (as being driven forth abroad,) and has partly, as being more concentrated, retreated into the interior of the body; for then, at length, when the frame is in this state, the limbs are relaxed and lose their power. Since there is no doubt but that this our vital sense exists in us by means of the soul, which sense when sleep hinders from be- ing exerted, we must then suppose that our soul is disturbed, and expelled from the body; but not wholly, for if it were all withdrawn, the body would lie steeped in the eternal cold of death, as, in that case, no part of the soul would remain latent in the members, (concealed as fire lies hidden under thick ashes,) whence the sense might be suddenly rekindled through- out the limbs, and flame, as it were, rise from secret heat. But by what means this change from wakefulness to sleep 1 By two several powers.] Ver. 897. Rebus utrwque duabus. Vi* by the soul and the air. J Short melody of the swan, e.] See on ver. 181. if 2 180 LUCRETIUS. a. iv. 931 962. is produced, and how the soul may be disturbed, and the body languish, I will explain. Do you, my friend, take care that I may not pour out my words to the winds. In the first place, it necessarily happens that the body since it is touched by the breezes of the air to which it is ex- posed, must be externally assailed and harassed by the frequent impulse of that air ; and, for this reason, almost all animated bodies are covered with hide, or even with shells, or with hard skin, or bark. This same air, likewise, impinges on the in- terior part of the body of animals, when, as they breathe, it is drawn in and respired. For which reason, when the body is affected from both causes, 1 and when assaults penetrate through the small pores of our frame to its primary parts and first elements, a labefactation, as it were, takes place by de- grees throughout our members ; for the positions of the ele- ments of the body and mind are disturbed, so that part of the soul is drawn forth from them, and part retires hidden into the interior ; part also, dispersed throughout the limbs, cannot remain united together, nor perform its ordinary motions mu- tually with other parts ; for nature obstructs the communica- tions and passages, and therefore, the motions of the atoms being changed, sense wholly fails. 2 And since there remains nothing that can, as it were, prop up the limbs, the body becomes weak, and all its members languish ; the arms and the eye-lids fall, and the hams often subside with a sinking lassitude, 3 and relax their strength. Sleep, too, follows upon taking food, because food, while it- is being distributed through all the veins, produces the same effects which the air produces ; and that sleep is far the most heavy which you take when full or weary ; because most of the atoms of the frame are then disturbed, being shaken with much effort. By the same means, a deeper concussion in the substance of the soul takes place, as well as a larger ejection of it without, and it becomes more divided in itself and dis- tracted within. 1 Affected from both causes.] Ver. 940. Utrinque secus vapulet. " Utrinque secus, that is, ex utrdyue parte, internally and externally." Wakefield. 1 Wholly fails.] Ver. 950. Abit altt, i. e. penitus, omnino. * Sinking lassitude.] Ver. 954. Cubanti tamd. " By tama is meant excessive fatigue from walking, when the blood settles in the leps, and causes a swelling." Fetlut. a. IT . 963 1001. LUCRETIUS. 181 And in general, as 3ach of us, having pursued any study, is devoted to it in his thoughts, or in whatever occupation we have been muc.i engaged previously, and the mind has been more exerted in that pursuit, we seem, for the most part, to go through the same employments in sleep. Lawyers seem to plead causes and to make laws ; generals to fight and en- gage in battles ; sailors to wage settled war with the winds : and myself to pursue this work, and investigate perpetually the nature of things, and to explain it, when discovered, in the language of my country. Thus other studies and arts seem generally, in sleep, to occupy the minds of men with delusions. And whatsoever per- sons have given continual attention to games and spectacles for many days in succession, we generally see that, in those persons, when they have ceased to observe those objects with their bodily senses, there are yet passages remaining open in the mind, where the same images of the same objects may enter. For very many days, therefore, those same images are presented before their eyes, so that they seem, even when awake, to see figures dancing, and moving their pliant limbs, and to listen with their ears to the liquid music and speaking chords of the lyre ; and, likewise, to perceive the same assem- bly, and to contemplate, at the same time, the various decora- tions of the scene shining before them. Of so great influence is study and inclination, and so much difference does it make in what pursuits, not only men, but indeed all animals, have been accustomed to be engaged. For you will see stout horses, when their limbs shall be stretched in sleep, yet perpetually perspiring and panting, and apparently exerting their utmost strength for the palm of victory, or often starting in their sleep as if the barriers were just set open. And the dogs of huntsmen, when stretched in gentle repose, often throw out their legs on a sudden, and hurriedly utter cries, and frequently draw in the air with their nostrils, as if they were pursuing the new/y-discovered traces of wild-beasts; and oftentimes, after they are awakened, they follow in ima- gination the empty images of stags, as if they saw them turned to flight, until, their delusions being dispelled, they return to their senses. And the fawning breed of dogs that are accus- tomed to the house, begin at times to rouse themselves and Start up from the ground, just as if they saw strange faces 182 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. 10021028 and looks. And the more fierce any breeds are, the more must the same breeds show fierceness in their sleep. But various birds, likewise, take flight, and suddenly disturb with their wings the groves of the gods during the night, if, in their quiet sleep, hawks have appeared, pursuing and flying after them, to offer battle and threaten hostilities. Moreover the minds of men, whatever great things they effect with vsst efforts in the day, frequently perform and carry on the *ame things also during their sleep. Kings storm cities, 1 ve taken prisoners, join battle, raise a cry as if they were beir. * stabbed on the spot. Many struggle-desper- ately, and utter groans as if in pain, and fill all parts around with loud shrieks, as if they were torn by the bite of a panther or savage lion. Many in sleep speak of important matters ; and men have very often made in dreams a revelation of their own guilt. Many, apparently, die ; many show terror through their whole frame, like persons who are casting them- selves to the ground from high mountains, and, as if deprived of their senses, (so disturbed are they by the agitation of their body,) scarcely, after sleep, recover themselves. A thirsty man, also, in his dream, often sits near a river or pleasant fountain, and almost swallows up the whole stream with his mouth. Boys, too, bound fast in sleep, fancy that, being near a tank or broken vessel, they are raising up their garment, and pour forth the bottled liquid 2 of the whole body, when the Babylonian coverlets, of magnificent splendour, are saturated. Or when, at length, 3 the full ripe hour is reach'd Of vigorous manhood, and the genial stores 1 Kings storm cities.] Ver. 1010 Eeges expugnant. " Kings, whose minds are agitated with mighty thoughts in the day, are naturally occupied with similar thoughts during the night, and accordingly storm, e. g towers, fortresses. Thus reges will be the nominative case, which I think proper to mention, because some commentators have injudiciouslv taken it for the accusative." Wa&eJUU. 1 Bottled liquid.] Ver. 1025. Humorem saccatum. Or when, at length, *c.] Ver. 1027- The remainder of this book t is thought advisable to give in the version of Dr. Good. In tran- scribing it for the press, six or seven words, at most, have been ered, partly to make nearer approaches to the text, and partly other reasons What Lucrems here presents to his reader, is a of philosophical and moral c nervations and precepts. They t ;v. 10291041. LUCRETIUS. 183 Crowd through the members, ceaseless then, at night, Forms of the fair, of look and hue divine, Rush on the spirit, and the ducts of love So stimulate, where throngs the new-born tide, That, as the tender toil were all achiev'd, Full flows the stream, and drowns the snowy vest. For, as we erst have sung, the seeds of life First spring when manhood first the frame confirms. And as on various functions various powers Alone can act propulsive, human seeds By nought but human beauty can be rous'd. These, when once gender'd from their cells minute O'er every limb, o'er every organ spread, Crowd in full concourse tow'rds the nervous fount By nature rear'd appropriate ; whence abrupt Excite they oft, as forms of beauty rise, The scenes at hand, the regions ruled by love. are subjects, says Good, "that naturally fall within the scope of a poem written expressly upon the Nature of Things," and "our poet \a entitled," he adds, to the joint thanks of naturalists and ana- tomical philosophers for irradiating their dark and thorny paths with the light and fire of the Muses. * * * Lucretius is a lecturer upon natural philosophy ; he admits us to his theatre, and gravely and scientifically developes the principles of this important subject. * * * A serious and attentive reader of this truly learned, as well as poetical discourse, whether male or female, cannot possibly, I think, peruse it without the acquisition of some degree of useful knowledge ; and even the medical professor himself cannot but be astonished at the copiousness of his research, and the accuracy that accompanies much of its reasoning." " There is here no impurity of language, nothing that may not be mentioned with propriety. If any thing shall appear objectionable, such appearance is to be attributed, not to the fault of the poet, but to that of the reader." Fober. " De amore, sterilitate, foecunditate, et aliis omnibus hanc ma- teriam attingentibus, liberius forsan et apertius, quam nonnulli vel- lent, disputat ; sed philosophis saltern, vel in his tractandis, videtur esse indulgendum." Wakefield. Let us also, for once, transcribe a note from Busby. " I have observed," says the Doctor, " that my author addresses himself only to high and cultivated intellect. The remark applies here with pe- culiar force. Lucretius was too much of a man of sense, too much of a philosopher, too well acquainted with human feelings, not to know that the higher order of minds are little liable to seduction from the gross exposures of nature ; and only to such minds is hit poem addressed." 184 LUCRETIUS. B. iv. KM2--107& Ther| springs the tender tumour, the warm wish Full o'er the foe, the luscious wound who deals, With dext'rous aim to pour the high-wrought charge, And full contending in the genial fight. So falls the victim on the part assail'd : With the red blood the glist'ning bruise so swells ; And o'er th' assassin flows the tide he draws. So he who feels the shaft of love propell'd From the dear form that charms him, tow'rds the spot Aims, whence the wound proceeds; supreme he pants To join the congest, and from frame to frame Pour the rich h-nnour ; for the fierce desire, Now felt, assures how vast the bliss to come. This, this is Venus : this he deems true love ; Hence flow the drops delicious that the heart Erode hereafter, and its train of cares. For, though the form adored be absent, still Her phantoms haunt the lover, and his ear Rings with her name, whate'er the path pursued. Yet fly such phantoms, from the food of love Abstain, libidinous ; to worthier themes Turn, turn thy spirit ; let the race at large Thy liberal heart divide, nor lavish, gross, O'er one fond object thy exhausted strength, Gend'ring long cares, and certain grief at last. For love's deep ulcer fed, grows deeper still, Eank, and more pois'nous ; and each coming day Augments the madness, if the wretch, perchance, Heal not old wounds by those of newer date, From fair to fair wide-wand'ring, or his mind Turn from such subjects to pursuits unlike. Nor are the joys of love from those shut out Who brutal lust avoid ; the pure of heart Far surer pleasures, and of nobler kind, Reap, than the wretch of lewd and low desires, Who, in the moment of enjoyment's self, Still fluctuates with a thousand fears subdued ; O'er the fair wanton, dubious, long who hangs, What charm his eyes, his hands shall first devour: Till fixt, at length, with furious force the spot Painful he presses, through his luscious lips . iv. 10761107 LUCRETIUS. 1$5 Drives his keen teeth, and every kiss indents ; Striving in vain for joys unmix'd, and urg'd By latent stimulus the part to wound, Where'er its seat, that frenzies thus his soul. But Venus softly smooths the wrongs endur'd, And mutual pleasures check the lover's rage. Then hopes he, too, in the same form to quench The madd'ning fires where first the flame arose. Vain hope, by every fact disproved ; for this, The more the soul possesses, still the more Craves she with keenest ardour. Foods and drinks As through the frame they pass, by toil worn out, Fill many a huge interstice ; obvious whence Dies the dread sense of hunger and of thirst ; But human beauty, and the rosy cheek, With nought the panting lover can endow But fruitless hopes, but images unsound, Scatter'd by every wind. As, oft, the man, Parch'd up with thirst, amid his dreams to drink Strives, 1 but in vain, since nought around him flows But void, unreal semblances of floods ; So with her votaries sports the power of love, False phantoms sole presenting, nor can sight, Where'er it rove, be sated with the gaze, Nor can the lover's lawless fingers tear Aught from his idol, o'er her as he hangs, And the full power of every charm explores. E'en when, in youth's prime flower, his panting frame Enclasps her frame that pants, when all his soul Expects the coming bliss, and Venus waits To sow the fertile field, though then amain In amorous fold he press her, lip to lip Join, and drink deep the dulcet breath she heaves, 'Tis useless all ; for still his utmost rage Can nought subtract ; nor through the fair one force 1 Parch'd up with thirst, amid his dreams to drink Strives, $c.] Ver. 10QO. Ut bibere in somnis sitiens quum qucerit, et humor Non da- tur. Isaiah xxix. 8, " It shall even be as when a hungry man dreameth, and, behold, he eateth ; but he awaketh, and his soul is empty : or as when a thirsty man dreameth, and, behold, he drink- eth ; but he awaketh, and, behold, he is faint, and his soul hath ap- petite." 186 LUCRETIUS. B. IT. 1108 112S His total frame, commingled with herself. Yet oft thus strives he, or thus seems to strive ; So strong the toils that bind him ; so complete Melt all his members in the sea of love. And though, when now the full-collected shock Pours from the nerves, some transient pause ensue, Yet short its period ; the fond fever soon, The frenzy quick returns, and the mad wretch Still pants to press that which he press'd before ; Nor aught of antidote exists, so deep Pines he, perplext, beneath the latent ill. Then, too, his form consumes, the toils of love Waste all his vigour, and his days roll on In vilest bondage. Amply though endow'd, His wealth decays, his debts with speed augment, The post of duty never fills he more, And all his sick'ning reputation dies. Meanwhile rich unguents from his mistress laagh, Laugh from her feet soft Sicyon's shoes superb ; l The green-ray'd emerald o'er her, dropt in gold, Gleams large and numerous ; and the sea-blue silk, Deep-worn, enclasps her, with the moisture drunk Of love illicit. What his sires amass'd Now flaunts in ribands, in tiaras flames Full o'er her front, and now to robes converts Of Chian loose, or Alidonian mould ; 2 While feasts and festivals of boundless pomp, And costliest viands, garlands, odours, wines, 1 Unguents from his mistress laugh, Laugh from her feet soft Si- cyen's shoes superb.] Ver. 1121. Unguenta et pulchra in pedibia Sicyonia rident. Shoes from Sicyon were worn only by the showy and luxurious. " If you were to offer me apair of Sicyonian shoes," says Cicero, (De Orat. i. 54,) " I should not wear them, because, although they might be easy, and fit my foot well, they would ap- pear effeminate." 1 Robes Of Chian loose, or Alidonian 'mould.] Ver. 1126. In paUam atque Alidensia Chiaque. Wakefield thinks that Alidensia is for Alindensia, from Alinda, a city of Caria, referring to Plin. N. H. v. 29. Chia, also, he derives, not from the island Chios, but from Chios, another town of Caria, mentioned by Steph. Byzant. ; so that one epithet, he says, supports and illustrates the other. Lambinus and others read Melitensia Ceaque, from Melita, or Malta, (Meli- ttniiu vestis, Cic. Ver. ii. 74,) and Ceos, an island in the ^Egean. B. iv. 1129116.'. LUCRETIUS. 187 And scatter'd roses ceaseless are renew'd. But fruitless every art ; some bitter still Wells forth perpetual from his fount of bliss, And poisons every flow'ret. Keen remorse Goads him, perchance, for dissipated time, And months on months destroy'd ; or from the fair Haply some phrase of doubtful import darts, That, like a living coal, his heart corrodes ; Or oft her eyes wide wander, as he deems, And seek some happier rival, while the smile Of smother'd love half-dimples o'er her cheeks. Such are the ills that on amoui's attend Most blest and prosp'rous ; but on those adverse Throng myriads daily, obvious and more keen. Hence, by the muse forewarn'd, with studious heed Shun thou the toils that wait ; for easier far Those toils to shun, than, when thy foot once slides, To break th' entangling meshes and be free. Yet though insnar'd, and in the silly net Led captive, thou may'st still, if firm of mind, And by these numbers sway'd, thy foot release. First the defects, then, of the form ador'd, Of mind, of body, let thy memory ne'er One hour forget ; for these full oft mankind See not, by passion blinded ; while, revers'd, Charms they bestow which never were the fair's. Hence frequent view we those, each grace denied, The coarse, the crooked, held in high esteem. And lovers laugh o'er lovers, and exhort Offerings to Venus since so vilely sway'd, While yet themselves are sway'd more vilely still. To such the black assume a lovely brown ; The rank and filthy, negligence and ease ; The red-eyed is a Pallas ; the firm-limb'd, All bone, a bounding roe ; the pigmy dwarf, A sprightly grace, all energy and wit ; The huge and bulky, dignified and grand ; The stammerer lisps ; the silent is sedate ; The pert virago, spirit all and fire ; The hectic, fine and delicate of frame : The victim worn with pulmonary cough, 188 LUCRETIUS. B. IT. 1134 USA On life's last verge, a maid of matchless waist ; The broad, big-bosom'd, Ceres full display'd, As from the bed of Bacchus ; the flat-nos'd Of monkey shape, a Satyr from the woods ; And the broad-lipp'd, a Nymph for kisses form'd. But countless such conceits, and to narrate Idle ; yet grant the frame ador'd possess'd Of face divine, that all the power of love Plays o'er each limb symphonious, others still Exist of equal beauty ; still ourselves Once Hv'd without her ; and full well we know She, too, each art essays the baser need, And so with scents bedaubs her that her maids Far fly oppress'd, and vent their smother'd laugh. Then, too, the wretched lover oft abroad Bars she, who at her gate loud weeping stands, Kissing the walls that clasp her ; with perfumes Bathing the splendid portals, and around Scattering rich wreaths and odoriferous flowers. Yet when at length admitted, the first breath So deep offends him, he some motive seeks Instant to quit her ; his long-labour'd speech Of suffering drops, and owns himself a fool, That for one moment he could deem her crown'd With charms the race of mortals ne'er can boast. This know full well the Paphian nymphs, and, deep Behind the scenes of action, each defect Strive they to hide from him they fain would sway. But vain th' attempt ; for oft the mind will guesa The latent blemish, and the laugh unfold. Whence those of soul ingenuous frankly own, Frequent, those faults which none can all escape. Yet not for ever do the softer sex Feign joys they feel not, as with close embrace, Breast join'd to breast, their paramours they clasp, And print their humid kisses on their lips. Oft from their hearts engage they, urg'd amuin By mutual hopes to run the race of love. Thus nature prompts ; by mutual hopes alone, By bliss assur'd, birds, beasts, and grazing herda, The task essay ; nor would the female else B. iv. 11971230. LUCRETIUS. E'er bear the burden of the vigorous male, By mutual joys propell'd. Hast thou not seen, Hence tempted, how in mutual bonds they strive Work'd oft to madness ? how the race canine Stain with their vagrant loves the public streets, Diversely dragging, and the chain obscene Tugging to loose, while yet each effort fails ? Toils they would ne'er essay if unassur'd Of mutual bliss, and cheated to the yoke. Whence o'er and o'er the bliss must mutual prove. If when the male his genial energy Imparts, the female deep her breath retract Transported most, the race produc'd will, then, From female store prove female ; if revers'd, From store paternal, male. But when the form Blends both its parents' features, it ascends From equal powers of each ; the impulse warm Rousing alike, through each conflicting frame, The seeds of latent life in scale so nice That neither conquers, nor to conquest yields. Oft view we, too, the living lines portray'd j Of ancestors remote ; for various seeds, Commingled various, through the parent frame Lurk, which from race to race preserve entire j The form, the features of the anterior stock. ' Diversely such the power creative blends ; Whence oft the voice revives, the hair, the hue, The full complexion of the race deceas'd ; For these as sure from seeds defin'd ascend As e'en the face, the body, or the limbs. Then, too, though male the fetus, female stores Aid the production ; while, if female form'd, The tide paternal mixes 'in the make ; For both must join, or nought can e'er ensue. But obvious this, that when the semblance more Inclines to either, the prevailing sex Chief lent the seeds of life, and rear'd complete The virgin embryo, or incipient man. Nor ever interfere the gods above In scenes like these, the genial soil lock up, Or curse with barren love the man unblcat, 190 LUCRETIUS. a. iv 1231-1264 No lovely race who I oasts to hail him sire,- As deem the many, who, in sadness drown'd, Oft offer victims, and, with fragrant gums, Kindle the blazing altar, wearying heav'n Vainly, tc Sll the void reluctant womb. For blank 3teri lity from seeds ascends Too gross, or too attenuate ; if the last, Ne'er to the regions that generic spread Cleave they, rejected instant as propell'd. But if too gross the genial atoms, dull Move they, and spiritless, or never urg'd With force sufficient, or of power devoid The puny ducts to pierce, or, pierc'd, to blend Harmonious with the vital fluid found. For Jove harmonious, whence increase alone CaniDfing, oft differs largely; easier far Some filling some, and others easier fill'd And gravid made by others ; whence, at times. Those, many a Hymen who have erst essayM Vainly, at length th' appropriate stores acquire, And feel the lovely load their wombs enrich. While he, perchance, whose prior banns forbade All the fond hope of offspring, happier now A mate has found of more concordant powers. And boasts a race to prop his crumbling age. So much imports it that the seeds of life With seeds should mix symphonious, that the gross Condense the rare, the rare the gross dilute, And man with woman duly pair'd unite. Much, too, concerns it what the foods employ'd ; For some augment the genial stores, and some Dissolve their crasis, and all power destroy. Nor small the moment in what mode is dealt The bland delight. The sage who views minute Herds, and the savage tribes by nature led, Holds that the virtuous matron chief conceives, When, with subsiding chest, and loins erect, Her dulcet charms she offers, fittest then The luscious tide t' absorb ; for nought avail Exerted motions, the perpetual heave Of frame high-strainM and ever-labouring lungs iv. 12651283. LUCRETIUS. 191 These, rather, urg'd beneath the tender fray, All fruit prohibit ; since the genial share Oft turn they from the furrow as it holds Its course direct, and break th' impinging shock. And hence the wanton mistress acts like these Frequent indulges, to preclude increase, And more transport the lawless form she clasps: Arts the chaste matron never needs essay. Nor from the darts of Venus, nor the smile Of gods above, is she of homelier make Frequent belov'd ; the praise is all her own. By her own deeds, by cleanliness most chaste, And sweet consenting manners, the delight Lives she of him who blends his lot with hers. Such virtues must prevail, and day o'er day Perfect their power ; for, though of gentlest kind, Yet urg'd perpetual, such the sternest heart Must gradual soften, and at length subdue. Hast thou not seen the fountain's falling drops Scoop in long time the most obdurate stone? BOOK V. ARGUMENT. Lucretius commences with the praise of Epicurus, and shows that he do- serves to be called a deity more than any other benefactor of mankind, ver. 1 55. He then states the subject of the present book, ver. 56 91, .and proceeds to show that the world is not eternal, ver. 92 110, and that the heavenly bodies are not, as the Stoics thought, portions of the divine nature, nor, as the vulgar suppose, the abode of the gods, ver. Ill 156. That the world was, not made by the gods for the sake of man, or for their own pleasure, may be concluded from the evils existing in it, and from other arguments, ver. 156 235. As the four elements are changeable and perishable, we must consider that the world which they constitute is of a similar nature, ver. 236 324. That the world had a beginning, appears from the recent commencement of its history, and the present imperfection of many arts among its inhabitants, ver. 325 351; that it will have an end, all reasoning respecting it conspires to render probable, ver. 352 416. The formation of the different parts of the world accord- ing to the cosmogony of Epicurus, ver. 417 509. Causes of the motions of the heavens, and of the earth's remaining at rest, ver. 510 564. The magnitudes of the heavenly bodies, ver. 565 612. Their phsenomena, and the causes of day and night, ver. 613 702. Of the phases of the moon, and the eclipses of the moon and sun, ver. 703 777- The produc- tion of plants, animals, and man, ver. 778 834. Nature, in her early efforts at production, may have generated monsters, but not such as Chi- maeras or Centaurs, ver. 835 922. The rudeness of the early life of man, the commencement of culture, and the invention of speech, ver. 923 1089. The discovery of fire, and its effects ; the progress of society anu government, ver. 1090 1159. The rise of religion from ignorance of na- tural causes, ver. 1160 1239. The discovery of metals, and the origin and progress of the arts, both useful and elegant, ver. 1240 1456. 194 LUCRETIUS. B.v. 131. WHO is able, with mighty genius, to compose a strain worthy of the majesty of THINGS, and of these discoveries of Epicurus? Or who has such power over words, that he can compose eulogies proportionate to the merits of him, who has left to us such blessings obtained and acquired by his own intellect ? No one, as I think, formed of a mortal body, will ever be able. For if we ought to speak as the known dignity of the subjects which he expounded requires, he was a god, a god, 1 say, illustrious Memmius, who first discovered that discipline of life 1 which is now called WISDOM ; and who, by the science of philosophy, placed human existence, from amid so great waves of trouble, and so great darkness of the mind, in so tranquil a condition and so clear a light. For compare with his investigations the ancient discoveries of others which are called divine ; as Ceres is said to have pointed out corn to mortals, and Bacchus the liquid of wine produced from the grape ; though life, nevertheless, might have continued without these gifts, as it is reported that some nations even now live without them; but men could not have lived well and happily without a pure and undisturbed breast. For which reason he, from whom the sweet consolations of existence, now spread abroad through mighty nations, calm the minds of men, seems to us the more justly to be accounted a god. But if you shall imagine that the deeds of Hercules excel his, you will be carried far away from sound reasoning. For what harm would those vast jaws of the Nemsean lion, and the bristly Arcadian boar, do to us at present ? Or what injury could the bull of Crete, and the Hydra, the pest of Lerna, de- fended with poisoned snakes, inflict on us at this time? Or how could the triple-breasted strength of the three-fold Geryon hurt us? And how could the horses of Diomede, breathing tire from their nostrils, dwelling near Thrace, and the Bisto- nian regions, and Ismarus ; or how could the Arcadian birds, 1 Discovered that discipline of life, $c.] Ver. 9. Vitce rationem in- venit earn qufielA B. v. 83105. LUCHETIUS. 197 pose that they are guided by any plan of the gods. For if those who have fairly understood that the gods pass a life free from care, nevertheless wonder, meanwhile, how things can severally be carried on, especially in those matters which are seen in the ethereal regions over our heads, they are carried N back again to their old notions of religion, and set over them- selves cruel tyrants, whom they unhappily believe able to do all things ; being themselves ignorant what can, and what can- not, be done, and by what means limited power, and a deeply fixed boundary, are assigned to every thing. To proceed, then, and to delay you no longer with pro- mises, contemplate, in the first place, the sea, and the earth, and the heaven ; the triple nature of which, dear Memmius, (three bodies, three forms so dissimilar, three substances of such a different consistence,) one day will consign to destruc- tion ; and the mass and fabric of the world, sustained through so many years, shall sink into total dissolution. 1 Nor does it escape ray consideration, how new and wonder- ful a subject it is for your reflection, that there will be an end to the heaven and the earth ; and how difficult it is for me to convince you of this with arguments ; as it generally happens, indeed, when you offer to the ear a subject hitherto strange to it, and yet cannot submit it to the sight of the eye, or put it into the hand ; the avenues through which the nearest main road 2 of belief leads into the human breast and the regions of the mind. But yet I will express my thoughts; fact itself, perhaps, will bring credit to my words, and you will see, per- 1 The mass and fabric of the world shall sink into total dissolution."} Ver. 97. Ruet moles et machina mundi. Flowers of the sky ! ye, too, to age must yield, Frail as your silken sisters of the field! Star after star from heaven's high arch shall rush, Suns sink on suns, and systems systems crush ; Headlong, extinct, to one dark centre fall, And Death, and Night, and Chaos, mingle all ! Darwin's Botanic Garden, iv. 371. * The avenues through which the nearest main road, & c -3 Ver. J03. Via qu& munita fidei Proxima fert humanum in pectus templaque MMfjt. " Via proxima is the nearest or shortest way; for we most readily believe what we discover by sight and touch." Lambinus. Ti.s common people, in many parts of England, have a saying, that 4 Seeing is believing, and feeling is truth." 198 LUCRETIUS. n. v. 106-1*1 chance all things violently shaken, in a brief space of time, with rising convulsions of the earth ; which time may Fortune, with commanding power, avert far from us ; and may reason, father than reality, convince us that all things, overcome by the influence of time, may sink with a direfully-sounding rrash into destruction. On this subject, before I begin to utter oracles, (expressed with more sincerity, and with much more true reason, than those o/"the Pythian priestess, who speaks from the tripod and laurel of Apollo,) I will set forth to you many consolations in learned and philosophic arguments, lest, perchance, being re- strained by religion, you should suppose that the earth, the sun, the heaven, the stars, and the moon, being endowed with a divine nature, must pursue their courses eternally ; and lest you should conceive, in consequence, that it is just for all those, (after the manner of the giants,) to suffer punishment for their monstrous wickedness, who, by their reasoning, would shake the walls of the world, and seek to quench the radiant sun in the heavens ; animadverting, in mortal speech, on bodies which are called immortal, but which, in reality, are so far distant from divine power, and are so unworthy to appear in the number of gods, that they may rather be thought adapted to give us a notion of that which is altogether re- moved from vital motion and sense. For it is not possible that the nature and rationality of in- tellect should be thought capable of existing in all kinds of bodies whatsoever. As a tree cannot exist in the sky, 1 nor clouds in the salt sea ; nor can fish live in the fields, nor blood be in wood, nor liquid in stones ; so it is fixed and appointed where every thing may grow and subsist. Thus the nature of the mind cannot spring up alone without the body, or exist apart from the nerves and the blood. Whereas if this could happen, the faculty of the human soul might rather arise in the head, or shoulders, or in the bottom of the heels, and might rather indeed be accustomed to grow in any place, than to remain in the same man and the same receptacle of the man. But since it seems certain and fixed even in our own body, in what part the soul and the mind may subsist and grow up by themselves, it is so much the rather to be denied that they can 1 As a tree cannot exist in the sky, &<.] Ver. 129. Sieut in atkert rbor, &o. See this passage in book iii. 785, seq. B. v. 142-171. LUCRETIUS. 199 exist out of the entire body, and without an animal form, whether in the soft clods of earth, or in the fire of the sun, or in the Avater, or in the lofty regions of the air. The heaven- ly bodies, therefore, since they cannot be animated with life, are not endowed with a divine sense. It is not possible, moreover, that you should believe there are sacred seats of the gods in any quarters of our world. For the nature and substance of the gods, being subtle and far removed from our senses, is scarcely apprehended by the power of our mind. And since it has hitherto escaped the touch and impact of our hands, it can assuredly touch nothing that is tangible by us ; for nothing can touch another body, if it is not possible for itself to be touched. For which reason the abodes of the gods, also, must be dissimilar to our abodes, as being subtle, and correspondent to their own nature. 1 These points I shall hereafter prove to you with abundance of argument. To say, moreover, that the gods designed to arrange all this noble fabric of the world for the sake of men, and therefore that we ought to extol it as an honourable achievement of the deities, and to believe that it will certainly be eternal and imperishable ; and to affirm that it is unlawful ever to disturb from its seat, by any force of argument, that which was established for the human race by ancient contrivance and for perpetual duration, or to shake and displace, though only in words, the sum of things from their basis ; 2 and to feign and add other conceits of this sort, dear Memmius, is to be guilty of the utmost folly ; for what profit can our gratitude afford to those who are immortal and blessed in themselves, that they should labour to effect any thing for our sake ? Or what new incitement could induce those, who were before tranquil, to desire, so long afterwards, to change their former mode o/*life? 3 For it would seem that he only, whom old 1 Subtle, and correspondent to their own nature.] Ver. 155. Temws, dr. corpore eorum. " The abodes of the gods must be subtle, as con- sisting of the same sort of atoms of which the gods themselves con- sist. " Faber. 2 Displace the sum of things from their basis.] Ver. 164. Ab into evortere xumma. Lambinus has summam. If we read summa, in the ace. pi. with Forbiger, it must be considered as equivalent to om~ nia, cuncta. Lucretius elsewhere uses summus for totus, as in i. 49, de tnmmii cocli ratione. * To chrmge their former mode of life.] Ver. 1 70 Vitam midare pn- orem. If the life of the gods was happy from the first, why did they 200 LUCRETIUS. u. v. 172199. things offend, ought to delight in things that are new ; but in him to whom no trouble has happened in past time, when he spent life happily, what could excite the desire of novelty ? 1 Or, forsooth, the life of the gods was oppressed with gloom and sorrow, until the genial birth of terrestrial things shone forth ? Or, again, what evil would it have been to us never to have been born ? For whoever is born must certainly wish to re- main in life, as long as any alluring pleasure shall engage him ; but to him who never tasted the love of life, nor was ever in the number of living beings? what affliction is it not to have been born ? Moreover, whence was a model or idea for making things, and whence was the notion of men themselves, implanted in the gods at first, that they should know, and conceive in their mind, what they should seek to do ? Or by what means was the power of primary-particles known, and what they could effect by their change of order and place, if Nature herself did not give \\\Q first specimens of production? For the primordial atoms of things were driven in so many ways by so many impulses, through an infinite duration of time, and were accustomed so to be borne and carried forward by their own weight, and to meet in all modes, and to try all endeavours, as if to ascertain what their combinations might generate, that it is not surprising if they fell at last into such positions, and acquired such motions, as those by which this universe of things, through perpetual renovation is now car- ried on. But if I were even ignorant 3 what the primary-elements of things are, yet this I could venture to assert, from the scheme of the heaven itself, and to support it from many other rea- sons, that the system of things was by no means prepared for produce a world, or worlds, for the sake of making a change in it? Was it merely that they might have a new subject on which to bestow their attention? But what motive, asks Lucretius, could they have for taking such trouble, when they had previously all that they wanted for enjoyment ? 1 But in him what could excite the desire of novelty?] Ver. 174. Quid potuit nocitatis amorem accendere tali? "Tali OVTI, in such a being, whether god or man." Faber. * Nor was ever in the number of living beings.] Ver. 181. NecfuA in nuntero. " Rerum creatarum." Faber. 1 But if I were even ignorant, &c.] Ver. 196. Quod si jam rerum tgiorem, &c. This sentiment he had already advanced, ii. 177, scq. . v. 200-229. LUCRETIUS. 201 us by divine power , so great is the faultmess with which it stands affected. In the first place, of all that space which the rapid circum- volution of the heaven covers, mountains and woods, the abodes of wild beasts, have occupied a vast portion j 1 rocks, and great marshes, and the sea, which widely separates the coasts of countries, cover another vast portion. Moreover, burning heat, and the constant descent of frost, deprive mor- tals of almost two-thirds of what is left. And as to the land which yet remains, nature would still, by her own operation, cover it with thorns, if human strength did not prevent; which, for the sake of a living, is accustomed to groan under the stout mattock, and to cut the earth with ploughs urged through if. For unless we, turning up the fertile clods with the plough- share, and forcing the soil, excite it to send forth its pro- ductions, they would be unable of themselves to rise into the liquid air. And yet at times, when all things, procured with so great labour, are green and flourish over the earth, either the sun in the heavens burns them up with violent heat, or sudden showers and cold frosts destroy them, or blasts of winds, with violent hurricanes, tear them to pieces. Besides, why does nature cherish and increase, by land, and by sea, a terrible brood of wild beasts and monsters, hostile to the human race ? Why do the seasons of the year bring dis- eases ? Why does untimely death wander abroad ? Moreover, an infant, as soon as nature, with great efforts, has sent it forth from the womb of its mother into the regions of light, lies, like a sailor cast out from the waves, in want of every kind of vital support ; and fills the parts around with mournful wailings, as is natural for one by whom so much evil in life remains to be undergone. But the various sorts of cattle, herds, and wild beasts, grow up with ease; they have 1 Vast portion.] Ver. 202. Avidam partem. " Avidus for vast; since what is greedy requires what is vast." Gifaniits. The readei may take this for an explanation if he pleases. The soundness of the reading is doubtful. Lachmann gives, from conjecture, aliquant partem. " A part how small of the terraqueous globe Is tenanted by man ! The rest a waste, Rocks, deserts, frozen seas, and burning sands, Wild haunts of monsters, poisons, stings, and death! Such is earth's melancholy map!" Young' NigJU Thcuyhla, i. 202 LPCRETIU8. B. v. 230-258. no need of rattles cr other toys; nor is the fond and broken voice of the nurse l necessary to be used to one of them. Nor do they require different dresses according to the season of the year ; nor, besides, have they any need of arms, or high walls, with which they may defend their property, since the earth herself, and Nature, the artificer of things, produce all supplies for all in abundance. Above all, since the body of the earth, and the water, and the light breezes of the winds, and the warm heat, of which this Sum of Things seems to be constituted, consist wholly of generated and dissoluble substance, the whole frame of the world must be considered to be of a similar nature. 2 For of whatever creatures, in mortal shapes, we see the parts and members to be of a generated consistence, we observe, in general, these same creatures to be themselves both generated and mortal. For which reason, when I see the four elements^ the vast members and divisions of the world, wasted and re- produced, I may conclude that there was also a time when the heaven and earth had a beginning, and that there will be a time for their destruction. On these points, do not imagine, my Memmius, that I have assumed any thing too hastily, in supposing earth and fire to be perishable; in not doubting that water and air waste away ; and in saying that the same elements are again pro- duced and augmented. In the first place, some part of the earth, parched with the constant heat of the sun, and tram- pled with the perpetual action of feet, exhales mists and fly- ing clouds of dust, which strong winds disperse through the whole air; part also of the clods is washed off by showers, 3 while rivers, as they strike against their banks, wear them away. Besides, whatever body increases another, is, on its 1 Fond and broken voice of the nurse.] Ver. 231. Blandaatque infracta loquela. " Broken, because parents and nurses are accus- tomed to use half words, not whole ones, to children." Lambimu. 2 The whole frame of the world must be considered to be of a similar nature.] Ver. 240. Debet eAdem omnis mundi natura pitta ri. Eadem via," says Wakefield, that is, in the same way, or by the same rule. Lambinus reads Debet tota eadem mundi natura putari, which is easier to be understood. A little below, in "both gener- ated and mortal," (mortalia et nativa simul.) I have transposed the epithets. 1 Is washed offhy showers.] Ver. 256. Ad diluviem revocatur /m. " I s turned into water." Creech. B. v. 259280. LUCRETIUS. 203 own part, diminished ; and since the earth, which is the parent of all things, seems, without doubt, to be the common sepulchre of all things ; the earth, therefore, you may be as- sured, is wasted, and is recruited and grows again. Further, there is no need of words to show that the sea, rivers, and fountains abound with new liquid, and that waters flow incessantly into the ocean; for the vast deflux of streams from all sides declares it ; but we must observe, above all things, that a certain portion of the water is carried off, and that it happens at last that there is no superabundance l of water ; for first that part is removed which the strong winds, Bweeping the ocean, and the ethereal sun, dispelling it with his rays, subtract from its surface; and next that part which is distributed through all the earth underneath. For the salt is strained off in its passage through the ground, and the sub- stance of the water flows back, and all meets, here and there, at the sources of rivers ; whence it flows, in a fresh stream, over the earth, wherever a passage, once cut, has borne along the waters in their liquid course. 2 I shall now, therefore, observe concerning the air, that it is changed, 3 every hour, in innumerable ways. For whatever is perpetually passing off from bodies, is all carried into the vast ocean of air ; and unless it were to restore particles back to those bodies, and to recruit them as their substance passes away, all things would by this time have been dissolved and converted into air. It accordingly does not cease to be per- 1 That a certain portion of the water is carried off, and that it happens, at last, that there is no superabundance, #c.] Ver. 265. Quicquid aquai Tollitur, in summaque fit ut nihil humor abundet. Quicquid is for quidque, as Lambinus and Creech expound it. In summit, says Wakefield, is " tandem, denique, post eventus omnes." 2 Wherever a passage, once cut, has borne along the waters in their liquid course.] Ver. 273. Qua via secta semel liquido pede detulit undas. Lambinus notices the easy flow of this verse, and observes how well it is adapted to the subject. Lucretius repeats it, vi. 639. We may compare with it a line of Cowley, called by Johnson an " example of representative versification which perhaps no other English line can equal." Which runs, and as it runs, for ever shall run on. 1 That it is changed.] Ver. 274. Quid mutatur " Qualiter, how." 204 LUCRETIUS. u. v. 281311 petually generated from bodies, and perpetually to return back to bodies ; since it is agreed that all things are in con- stant flux. The ethereal sun, too, the great fountain of liquid light, floods the heaven perpetually with new brightness, and in- stantly supplies with a new ray the place of the ray that has passed off". For whatever brightness it first sends forth, is, wherever it falls, lost to it. This you may collect from hence, that as soon as clouds have begun to come over the sun. and, as it were, to break through the rays of light, all the lower part of these rays is immediately lost, and the earth, wherever the clouds pass, is overshadowed ; so that you may understand that things constantly require a fresh supply of light, and that every first emission of radiance is dispersed ; nor could objects otherwise be seen in the sunshine, unless the fountain of light itself furnished a perpetual supply. Even your nocturnal torches, which are things of earth, your hanging lamps, and tapers, brilliant with waving flames, and showing themselves fat with abundance of smoke, are im- pelled, 1 in a similar manner, by the agency of heat, to emit new radiance ; they incessantly discharge their tremulous rays; 2 they never cease; nor does the light, as if broken off, leave the place dark. So swiftly is the destruction of that flame hastened from all its rays, through the rapid origination and emission of new particles. Thus, too, we must suppose that the sun, and moon, and stars throw off their light through successive generations of beams, 3 and perpetually lose what- ever rays are first to pass from them; so that you must not by any means suppose that these bodies maintain imperishable vigour. Do you not see, moreover, that even stones are overcome by time ? Do you not observe that lofty towers fall, and that rocks decay ? Do you not notice that the temples and images of the gods, overcome with age, open in fissures; and that the sacred deities themselves cannot extend the limits of fate, or struggle against the laws of nature ? 1 Are impelled.] Ver. 298. Properant. * They incessantly discharge their tremulous rays.] Ver. 299. Tremere ignibus instant. " Tremulos radios spargunt." Creech. 1 Through successive generations of beams.] Ver. 304. Ex alia styue alto subortu. The sense is evident. B. V. 312331 LUCRETIUS. 205 Besides, do we not see that the monuments of heroes fall ? You might even believe that they desire for themselves a time to grow old. 1 Do we not observe that flints crumble from the lofty mountains, and cannot endure and withstand the powerful force of even a finite age ? For if they were bodies which, through infinite ages, had sustained all the assaults of time, and continued exempt from dissolution, they would not now sud- denly be broken away and fall to pieces. Further, contemplate this heaven around and above us, which contains all the earth in its embrace ; it produces, as some say, all things from itself, and receives all things, when dissolved, into itself. But it was a generated body, and con- sists wholly of perishable substance. For whatever increases and nourishes other things from itself, must by that means be diminished, and must be recruited by receiving 2 into itself fresh substances. In addition, if there was no origin of the heavens and earth from generation, and if they existed from all eternity, how is it that other poets, before the time of the Theban war, and the destruction of Troy, have not also sung of other exploits of the inhabitants of earth - How have the actions of so many men thus from time to time fallen into oblivion f How is it that they no where survive in remembrance, and are no where stamped on everlasting monuments of fame ? But, as I am of opinion, the whole of the world is of com- paratively modern date, and recent in its origin ; and had its 1 You might even believe that they desire for themselves a time to grow old.] Ver. 314. Qu&rere proporro sibi quomque senescere credos. Senescere, " to grow old," quomque, " at some time or other." Cunque, as in Horace, (Od. i. 32, 15,) Mihi cunque salve Rite precanti. Wakefield interprets it quocunque modo : " Credas dato quasi studio ad senectutem properanter contendere, quocunque tandem modo." But it seems better to understand it of time than of manner; for the mode in which buildings decay has been expressed four lines above. Proporro I join with credas, in the sense of porro, preeterea, etiam. Lambinus read, from conjecture, Cedere proporro, subitoque senescere casu. Lachmann, also from conjecture, gives Qua fore proporro veti- tumque se?iescere credas, and alters the passage in Horace to medicum- que salve Rite vocanti. The verse of Horace is probably faulty, (for, as Bentley observes, there is no example to support it,) but whether Lachmann has found the right method of amending it, may be doubted. 8 By receiving, "Atpt tiroxilffSai af ffvyyfvJ}." Creech. 2 Become evanescent and imperceptible.] Ver- 530- Evanescere tt dfcrescere. 214 LUCRETIUS . v. 655-581 heaven ; for they cohere by common connexions one with the other, conjoined, and coalescing in union, from the earliest period. Do you not observe, also, how exquisitely subtle a sub- stance of the soul sustains the body, which is of great weight, simply because it is so closely united and combined with it ? What power, too, but that of the soul, which governs the limbs, can raise the body with a vigorous leap from the ground? Do you now understand how much force a subtle sub- stance may have, when it is united with a heavy body, as the air is joined with the earth, and the power of the soul with ourselves ? Nor can the circumference of the sun be much greater, or its fire less, 1 than it appears to our senses. For from what- ever distances fires can throw their rays, and cast a warm heat upon our bodies, the ejection of the heat from those dis- tances detracts nothing from the bulk of the igneous matter, and the fire is not at all more contracted to the view. Since, therefore, the heat of the sun, and its effused light, reach to our senses, and the parts about us shine with its rays, the form and outline of the sun must, on this account, appear as it really is, so that you can add nothing more to it, or make it less. And the moon, whether, as she glides through the shy, she illu- minates its regions with a borrowed light, or whether she sends forth radiance from her own body ; whichsoever is the case, she is, as she pursues her course, of no larger a dimension 2 than she appears to our eyes as we observe her. For all objects which, being far remote from us, we view through a large body of air, look confused in their appearance, before their out- line seems at all diminished. For which reason the moon, since it presents a clear shape and defined outline, (as it does 1 Nor can the circumference of the sun be much greater, or its fire less, <5fc.] Ver. 567. Aee nimio soils major rota, nee minor ardor esse potest. All that is meant is, that the sun cannot be much greater or much less than it appears to us. " An irrational and ab- surd opinion of Epicurus," says Lambinus. 1 She is of no larger a dimension, Jrc.l Ver. 578. Nihilofertur majore figura, Quant nostris oculis, qua cernimus, esse videtur. The or- der and construction, says Wakefield, is this ;' " Fertur figura nihilo majore, quam ea Jigura, qua earn cernimus Jigurd, videtur esse nos- tns oculis." v. 531-611. LUC'llKTIUS. 215 whenever its outmost edges ' are observed,) must hence appear to us in the sky just as large as it is. 2 Further, whatsoever stars in the heavens you view from hence, can, assuredly, be only very little less, or only very little larger, 3 than they appear ; since of whatsoever fires we see on the earth, even whilst the motion of their light is plain, and their glow is clearly perceived, the outline seems at times to vary in one way or other, contracting or expanding, according as it is more or less distant. It is not, moreover, a matter of wonder, how so small a body as the sun can emit so large a quantity of light, as to cover with its flood the seas, the whole earth, and the heavens, and to pervade all things with its quickening heat. Since it is possible that one fountain of the light of the whole world, opened from hence, may flow forth abundantly, and scatter its radiance abroad ; 4 because the atoms of heat, we may suppose, so meet together here from all parts of the world, and their assemblage forms such a flood, that all this heat may flow from one source. For do you not observe, too, how small a spring of water sometimes irrigates the meadows far and wide, and flows exuberantly over the fields ? It is also possible that heat may pervade the air with a strong glow from no very great fire in the sun, if, perchance, the air be so tempered and disposed as to be excited to warmth, though affected with but gentle fervour ; as we sometimes see fire, from one spark, spread in all directions among corn-fields and straw. And, perhaps, the sun, shining on high with its rosy light, contains about it much heat in secret stores-of-fire, which, though it be distinguished by no brightness, yet, retaining a 1 As it does whenever its outmost edges, i fama est e montibus, Sfc. This phenomenon is mentioned by Diod. Sic. xvii. 7, and by Pomponius Mela, de Situ Orbis, v. 6. It was probably some atmospheric illusion. Quod genus is for quemadmodun, as in several other places. 218 LUCRETIUS, B v. 669702. in all departments of nature; the groves flourish at a certain time, and at a certain time drop their verdure. At a certain time, also, age directs the teeth to be shed ; and causes the immature youth to bloom with soft down, and to let the flexible beard, too, descend from his cheeks. Lightnings, moreover, snow, rain, cloudy weather, and winds, take place at seasons of the year by no means uncertain. For since the first com- mencement of causes thus arose, and the affairs of the world thus proceeded, a? at present, from their earliest origin, every event is a consequence in the unvarying course of things. That the days also increase while the nights grow shorter, and that the days are diminished in length when the nights become augmented, may possibly happen, either because the same sun, revolving below and above the earth, divides the regions of the air with unequal curves, and distinguishes the orb of heaven into dissimilar parts, while, whatever it has taken from one part of it, it adds, as it revolves, just so much to the opposite part, until it has come to that sign in the heavens where the node of the year 1 makes the darkness of night equal to the light of day : (for the heaven has two sepa- rate points, at equal distances, where the courses of the north wind and the south meet ; 2 owing to the position of the whole circle of the zodiac, in which the revolving sun consumes the pe- riod of the year, illumining the earth and the sky with oblique light, as the system of those declares who have observed that whole region of the heaven which is distinguished by the array of the twelve signs :) or, because the air is denser in certain parts, the tremulous rays of light are therefore retarded, and cannot easily penetrate it arrd emerge to the dawn ; for which reason the nights in the winter delay long, until the bright herald of day 3 returns : or, again, because, at alternate seasons of the year, the atoms of flame, which cause the sun to rise 4 in 1 Node of the year.] Ver. 687. Nodus anni. " He means the equinoxes." Faber. 2 Where the courses meet.] Ver. 688. Media cursu Jlatiis Aquilonis. et Aiistri. 1 Herald of day.] Ver. 699. Insigne diei. " The sun." Faber. * Cause the sun to rise, #e.] Ver. 702. Faciunt salem certa desur- fffre parte. Or, as Lambinus and others have it, certii de surgere. I wonder that none of the critics have suspected Lucretius to have wvitten/w/yere rather than surgere. B. v. 703-727. LUCRETIUS. 219 a particular part of the heavens at a particular time, are ac- customed to congregate slower or faster. As for the moon, she may shine because she is struck with the rays of the sun, and may turn towards us every day a larger portion of light in her aspect, as she recedes farther from the sun's orb, until, being opposite to him, she has shone forth with fullest splendour, and, rising on high in the east, has beheld his setting in the west; thence, also, retiring back- wards, she may, as it were, hide her light gradually, as she approaches from the opposite side, along the circle of the zodiac, nearer to the sun's radiance ; as those philosophers suppose, who make the moon to be in shape like a ball, and to pursue her path of revolution beneath the sun ; [and hence it happens that they seem to say what is true.] 1 There is also a hypothesis by which the moon may revolve and present various phases of brightness, with her own light. For it is possible that there may be another body, which moves and advances 2 together with her, and which in every way ob- structs and hinders her light, but nevertheless cannot be seen, as it passes along in total darkness. And the moon may possibly revolve upon her axis, like a ball 3 tinged with shining light only on one side, and may, by turning her orb, present to us her various phases. Thus, pro- gressively, she turns that part which is illuminated, so as to behold us with full aspect and open eye ; 4 then, by degrees, she turns away and removes from us the brilliant side of her orb; 5 as, indeed, the Babylonish doctrine of the Chaldaeans taught, which, refuting the method of the Greek astrologers, 1 And hence it happens that they seem to say what is true.] Ver. 713. Protereafit uti videantur dicere ventm. This verse, which is regarded by Forbiger as suspicious, and enclosed in brackets, might very well be spared. 2 Another body, which moves and advances, $] Ver. 716. This, says Lambinus, was the opinion of Anaximander ; but Creech ob- serves that there is no proof of his having held such an opinion. 3 And the moon may revolve like a ball.] Ver. 719. This was the doctrine of Berosus, as is observed by Vitruvius, ix. 4. 4 So as to behold us with full aspect and open eye.] Ver. 723. Ad speciem nobis oculosque patentes. This is translated according to Wakefield's interpretation, who says that previous commentators had thought that the face and eyes of the spectator were meant. s Of her orb.] Ver. 725. Glomeraminis atque pilai. As both words have the same meaning, 1 have thought it sufficient to translate one. 220 LUCRETIUS. B. T. 728753. labours to support this hypothesis in opposition to it; just as if that, for which eacli contends, might not be true, or as if there were any reason why you should choose to embrace one opinion less than the other. Further, when you see so many things produced in a cer- tain order, it is difficult to demonstrate by reason, and to evince by argument, why a new moon may not be generated every day, with a certain succession of phases and figures, and each moon, as it diurnally arises, diurnally decay, and another be reproduced in its place and station. For the Spring and Venus begin their course, and the wing- ed zephyr, the harbinger of spring, walks before, near whose footsteps maternal Flora, preparing the way, covers the whole path with richest flowers and perfumes ; next follows scorch- ing Summer, and dusty Ceres closely attendant on her, and the Etesian breezes of the northern winds ; l then succeeds Autumn, together with whom advances Bacchus ; then follow other weather and other winds, the loud-resounding south-east and the south fraught with thunder ; at length cold brings on snows, and spreads abroad benumbing chillness, and Winter comes after, and frost chattering with his teeth. Since, there- fore, so many things may occur at a certain time, it is the less surprising if the moon is at a certain time produced, and at a certain time decays. As for the eclipses of the sun, and occultations of the moon. 2 you must suppose that they may arise from various causes. For, (as you perhaps ask,) why should the moon only be thought able to shut out the world from light, and to oppose her high head to it on the side of the earth, 3 (obtending her dark orb to 1 Etesian breezes of the northern winds.] Ver. 741. Etesia fabra Aquilonum. Etesian winds mean yearly winds ; but the term was often applied by the Greeks to the north winds, which were said to blow annually at the rising of the dog-star. See the commentators on Demosthenes, Phil. i. 11. 1 Occultations of the moon.] Ver. 750. Lunceque latebras. Latebras signifies obscurations or eclipses, as Creech rightly interprets. " He now begins to speak of the eclipses of the sun and moon : and first of those of the sun." Lambimis. * And to oppose her high head to it on the side of the earth.] Ver. 753. Et c, terris altum caput obstruere ei. " Objicere corpus g'.ium supra terras elatum," says Creech ; but a terris surely means yn the side of the earth. With ei Lambinus and Creech understand tuli; I prefer lumini. B. y. 754777. L.UCRBTTTT8. 221 the sun's glowing rays,'/ and not some other body, l which may always revolve devoid of light, be considered able to produce such an effect at the same time ? And why, also, may not the sun, at a certain time, send forth his radiance languidly, and again renew his splendour, when, in his passage through the air, he has passed by certain places which, we may suppose, are hurtful to his beams, and which cause his fires to be suppressed and extinguished ? And why should the earth have power, 2 in its turn, to de- prive the moon of light, and, passing itself above, to keep the sun shut out from her, (while she passes monthly through the dense coniform shadow,) and why should not some other body be able, at that time, to pass bener.th the moon, or to glide over the orb of the sun, which body may intercept from her his effulgent rays and spreading light ? And still, if the moon shines herself by her own brightness, why may she not grow dim in a certain part of the world, while she passes through regions noxious to her light ? For what remains, since I have shown how every thing may occur in the blue sky of our vast world, in order that we might understand what power and causes might produce the varied course of the sun and the wanderings of the moon, and by what means they are accustomed to have their light ob- structed and eclipsed, 3 and to spread sudden darkness over the earth, (when they shut their eyes, as it were, for a time, and then, having opened them again, cover every fair region witk 1 Some other body devoid of light] Ver. 755. Aliud corpus cassum lumine. Compare what he says in reference to the phases o/ the moon, ver. 716, se/j. Comp. also ver. 764 766. 2 And why should the earth have power, $e.] Ver. 761. Et quur terra queat lunam spoliare vicissim Lumine, et oppressum solem super ipsa tenere, Menstrua dum rigidas coni perlabitur undas. " Ipsa is to be referred to the earth, as the sense of the following verses proves." Faber. By coni umbras, says Lambinus, is meant " the extreme part of the earth's shadow ; though some by the cone understand the earth itself; which Aristotle (Mtrttip. lib. ii.) affirms to be shaped like a drum, and says that lines drawn from its centre form two cones." Creech interprets, "rigidam terrse umbram, quae est conicae figurae ; " to which interpretation I have adapted my ver- sion. * To have their light obstructed and eclipsed.] Ver. 774. Offecto lumine obire. LUCRETIUS. B. v. 778 &04 shining light,) I now return to the early age of the world, and the tender fields of earth, to consider what kind of productions they first ventured, 1 with their new power of generation, to raise into the regions of light, and to commit to uncertain winds. In the beginning, then, the earth spread over the hills the growth of herbs, and the beauty of verdure, and the flowery fields, throughout all regions, shone with a green hue ; and then was given, to the various kinds of trees, full power of shooting upwards through the air. 2 For as feathers, and hairs, and bristles, are first produced over the limbs of quadrupeds and the bodies of the winged tribes, so the new earth then first put forth herbs and trees ; and afterwards generated the numerous races of animals, 8 which arose in various forms and by various modes. For animals, that were to live on the earth, could assuredly neither have fallen from the sky, 4 nor have come forth from the salt depths of the sea. It remains, there- fore, to believe that the earth must justly have obtained the name of MOTHER, since from the earth all living creatures were born. And even now many animals spring forth from the earth, which are generated by means of moisture and the quickening heat of the sun. It is accordingly less wonderful, if, at that time, creatures more numerous and of larger size arose, and came to maturity while the earth and the air were yet fresh and vigorous. First of all, the race of winged animals, and variegated birds, left their eggs, being excluded in the season of spring ; as grasshoppers, in these days, spontaneously leave their thin coats 5 in the summer, proceeding to seek sustenance and life. Next, be assured, the earth produced, for the first time, the tribes of men and beasts ; for much heat and moisture abound- 1 Ventured.] Ver. 780. Creduint. '. " Creduint for crediderint, \. e. confisa, ausafuerint arva." Forbiger. Sed alii aliter. * Full power of shooting upwards through the air.] Ver. 785. Crescwidi magnum immissis certamen habenis. Virg. Georg. ii. 363. Dum se laetus ad auras Palmes agit, laxis per purum immissus habenis. * Numerous races of animals.] Ver. 789. Mortalia corda multa. Al. tcecla. Fallen from the sky, 3-c.] Ver. 791. See ii. 11541157. s Thin coats.] Ver. 801. Folliculos tersUs. Comp. iv. 56 " Ro- tundas gracilesque tunicas." Creech. B. v. 805837- LUCRETIUS. 223 ed through the plains, and hence, where any suitable region offered itself, a kind of wombs sprung up. 1 adhering to the earth by fibres. These, when the age of the infants within them, at the season of maturity, had opened, (escaping from their moist-enclosure, and seeking for air,) nature, in those places, prepared the pores of the earth, and forced it to pour from its open veins a liquid like milk ; just as every woman at present, when she has brought forth, is stored with sweet milk, because all the strength of the food is directed to the breasts. Thus the earth afforded nourishment to the infants ; the warmth rendered a garment unnecessary ; and the grass supplied a couch abounding with luxuriant and tender down. But the early age of the world gave forth neither severe cold nor extraordinary heat, nor winds of impetuous violence. For all these alike increase and acquire strength by time. For which cause, / say again and again, the earth has justly acquired, and justly retains, the name of MOTHER, sinc she herself brought forth the race of men, and produced, at this certain time, almost every kind of animal which exults over the vast mountains, and the birds of the air, at the same period, with all their varied forms. But because she must necessarily have some termination to bearing, she ceased, like a woman, exhausted by length of time. For lapse of time changes the nature of the whole world, and one condition after another must succeed to all things, nor does any being con- tinue always like itself. All is unsettled ; nature alters and impels every thing to change. For one thing decays, and, grown weak through age, languishes ; another, again, grows up, and bursts forth from contempt. 2 Thus age changes the nature of the whole world, and one condition after another falls upon the earth ; so that what she could once bear she can bear no longer while she can bear what she did not bear of old. The earth, also, in that age, made efforts to produce va- rious monsters, that sprung up with wonderful faces and limbs ; the hermaphrodite, between both sexes, and not either, 1 Wombs sprung up, r drawing. Quasi veheterinus, from veho. Comp. ver. 888- a T. 869897. LUCRETIUS. 225 return for their service. But of those to whom nature has given no such qualities, that they should either be able to live of themselves, or to afford us any service, why should we suffer the races to be maintained and protected by our sup- port ? Indeed all these, rendered helpless by their own fatal bonds, were exposed as a prey and a prize to other animals, until nature brought their whole species to destruction. But Centaurs, and such creatures, there neither were, nor ever can be ; for there can never exist an animal formed of a double nature and of two bodies ; an animal made up of such heterogeneous members that the power in the opposite por- tions of the frame cannot possibly be equal. This you may learn, with however dull an understanding, 1 from the follow- ing observations. First, the horse, when three years of his age have passed, is flourishing in full vigour ; the boy, at this time of life, is by no means so, but will even often seek in his sleep the milky teats of his mother s breast. Afterwards, when, in old age, his lusty vigour and stout limbs are failing the horse, (growing tor- pid as life is departing,) behold, at that very period, the young man's age being in its flower, youth prevails in him, 2 and clothes his cheeks with soft down ; so that you cannot pos- sibly imagine that Centaurs can be composed or consist of a man and the servile seed of a horse; 3 or that there can be Scyllas, of half-marine bodies, cinctured with fierce dogs ; or other monsters of this sort, whose parts we observe to be incompatible with each other ; parts which neither grow up together in their bodies, nor acquire vigour together, nor lose their strength 4 together in old age ; and which are neither excited by the same objects of affection, nor agree with the same tempers, nor find that the same kinds of food are nu- tritious to their bodies. 5 For you may observe that bearded 1 With however dull an understanding.] Ver. 880. Quamvis he~ beti corde. 2 Youth prevails in him.] Ver. 887. JuventasOJjicit. " Intervenit." Wakefield. Al. Occipit. 3 Servile seed of a horse.] Ver. 888. Veterino semine equorum Comp. ver. 863. 4 Lose their strength.] Ver. 894. Perficiunt. '' That is, bring ( their strength) to an end." Wakefield. * Nutritious to their bodies.] Ver. 896. Joconda per artus. from juvo, to help or sustain. Q 226 LUCRETIUS. B. v. 898931. goats often grow fat on hemlock, which to men is rank poison. Since, too, the flame of fire is accustomed to scorch and burn up the tawny bodies of lions, as well as every kind of creature on earth that consists of flesh and blood, how was it possible that a Chimaera, one animal compounded of three bodies, the fore part a lion, the hinder a dragon, the middle a goat, 1 could blow abroad at its mouth a fierce flame out of its body? For which reason, he who supposes that such animals might have been produced, even when the earth was new and the air fresh, (leaning for argument only on this empty term of newness,) may babble, with equal reason, many other hypo- theses of a like nature. He may say that rivers of gold then flowed every where over the earth, and that the groves were accustomed to blossom with jewels ; or that men were formed with such power and bulk of limbs, that they could ex- tend their steps over the deep seas, and turn the whole heaven around them with their hands. For though, at the time when the earth first produced animal life, there were in- numerable seeds of things in the ground, this is yet no procf that creatures could have been generated of mixed natures, and that heterogeneous members of animals could have been blended together. Since the various kinds of herbs, and fruits, and rich groves, which even now spring-up-exuberantly from the earth, can nevertheless not be produced with a union of different kinds. But they can readily be produced, if each proceeds in its own order, and all preserve their distinctions according to the fixed law of nature. And that early race of men upon the earth was much more hardy ; as it was natural that they should be, for the hard earth herself bore them. They were internally sustained with bones both larger and more solid, and furnished with strong nerves throughout their bodies ; nor were they a race that could easily be injured by heat or cold, or by change of food, or by any corporeal malady. And during many lustres of the sun, revolving through the heaven, they prolonged their lives after the roving manm-r of wild beasts. No one was either a driver of the crooked ' The middle a goat.] Ver. 903. Media ipsa. Chimera (\ifiaipa) signifies a goat. B v, 932-956. LUCRETIUS. 227 plough, or knew how to turn up the fields with the spade, or to plant young seedlings in the earth, or to cut, with pruning- hooks, the old boughs from the lofty trees. That supply which the sun and rain had afforded, or which the earth had yielded of its own accord, sufficiently gratified their desires. They refreshed themselves, for the most part, among the acorn-laden oaks. The earth, too, then furnished abundance of whortle- berries, 1 even larger than at present, which you now see ripen in winter, and become of a purple colour. And many rude kinds of nourishment besides, ample for hapless mortals, the florid freshness of the world in those days produced. The rivers and fountains then invited them to quench their thirst, as the echoing fall of waters from the high hills now calls, far and wide, the thirsty tribes of wild beasts. After- wards they occupied the sylvan temples of the nymphs, well known to the wanderers ; from which the goddesses sent forth flowing rills of water, 2 to lave with a copious flood the humid rocks, trickling over the green moss, and to swell and burst forth, with a portion of their streams, over the level plain. Nor as yet did they understand how to improve their con- dition by the aid of fire, or to use skins, and to clothe their bodies with the spoils of wild beasts. But they dwelt in groves, and hollow mountains, and woods ; and, when com- pelled to flee from the violence of the wind and rain, sheltered their rude limbs amid the thickets. Nor could they have regard to any common interest, or 1 Whortle-berries.] Ver. 939. Arbuta. Good translates this, " The wild wood-whortle," observing that commentators have uniformly understood that " the arborescent and garden strawberry-tree " is here signified, which bears " a crimson fruit about the size of an Orleans plum ;" but that this fruit is " extremely sour and unpleas- ant to the taste," and is never employed " for purposes of food." He therefore thinks that Lucretius means that species of arbutus called by Caspar Bauhine " Vitit Idtea, the common whortle or cran- berry," which " has an agreeable sub-acid flavour when tasted alone," but " is more generally eaten with cream or milk sweetened with sugar, or else in the form of preserves ; in which latter state it is very largely made use of in Russia, and, indeed, among all the northern nations." 2 Flowing rills of water.] Ver. 948. Humore Jfventa Lubrica. " Id est, flnenta humida et hquida." Lambinus. The words Humida scuca, "humid rocks," are elegantly repeated in the original, but could not be repeated to any purpose in a prose translation. 3 2 228 LUCRETIUS. K. v. 957-987. understand how to observe any customs or laws among them- selves. Whatever prize fortune had thrown in the way of any one, on that he seized ; each knowing only to profit by his own instinct, and to live for himself. And Venus united the persons of lovers in the woods ; for either mutual desire reconciled each female to the intercourse, or the impetuous force and vehement lust of the man over- came her ; or acorns and whortle-berries, or choice crabs, 1 were the purchase of her favours. And, relying on the extraordinary vigour of their hands and feet, they pursued the sylvan tribes of wild beasts with missile stones and ponderous clubs ; and many they overcame, while a few escaped them in their dens ; and, when surprised by night, they threw their savage limbs, like bristly boar.*, unprotected on the earth, covering themselves over with leaves and branches. Nor did they, trembling and wandering in the shades of night, seek to recall the day 2 and the sun with loud cries throughout the fields, but, silent and buried in sleep, they waited till Phoebus, with his roseate beams, should again spread light over the heavens. For since they had always been accustomed, from their infancy, to see darkness and light produced at alternate seasons, it was impossible that they should ever wonder at the change, or feel apprehension lest, the beams of the sun being withdrawn for ever, eternal night should keep possession of the earth. But what rather gave them trouble, was, that the tribes of wild beasts often disturbed the rest of hapless sleepers; while, driven from their cell at the approach of a foaming boar or stout lion, they fled from their rocky shelter, and yielded up with trembling, at the dead of night, their couches of leaves to the savage intruders. Nor yet did the race of men, in those days, leave with la- mentations the sweet light of life in much greater numbers 1 Choice crabs.] Ver. 963. Pira lecta. " Pears," says Good, " are a cultivated fruit, introduced, indeed, by grafting or inocula- tion alone, from the wild crab, which is the common origin of the pear, the apple, and the quince." He therefore translates pita *' crabs," and I have followed him. Nor did they seek to recall the day, $c.] Ver. 971. Nee plan- gore diem, &c. Some philosophers had attributed such surprise and Despair to the earliest race of men ; to which Manilius alludes, wok i. 6, teq. B. v. 988- -1007. LUCRETIUS. 229 than at present. For though more frequently at that period, one individual of their number, being caught by wild beasts, and consumed by their teeth, afforded them living food, and filled, meanwhile, the groves, and mountains, and forests, with his shrieks, as he felt his bowels buried in a living tomb;' while those whom flight had saved, with their bodies torn, and pressing their trembling hands over their grievous wounds, called on death with horrid cries, until, destitute of relief, and ignorant what their hurts required, cruel tortures 2 deprived them of life. Yet, in those times, one day did not consign to destruction many thousands of men under military banners ; nor did the boisterous floods of the sea dash ships and men upon rocks. But the ocean, though often rising and swelling, raged in vain and to no purpose, 3 and laid aside its empty threats without effect ; nor could the deceitful allurement of its calm water entice, with its smiling waves, any one into danger ; for the daring art of navigation was then un- known. Want of food then consigned languishing bodies to death ; now, on the contrary, abundance of luxuries causes destruction. The men of those times often poured out poison 1 As he felt his bowels buried in a living tomb.] Ver. 991. Viva videns vivo sepeliri viscera busto. Gorgias the rhetorician is censured by Longinus (Sect. 3) for calling vultures ip-^vxai rcufioi, but Lu- cretius, says Faber, being a poet, may be allowed to use such an expression. There is a similar conceit in Milton, Sams. Ag. ver. 102, Myself my sepulchre, a moving grave. And another in Pope, Essay on Man, iii. 162, Man Of half that live the butcher and the tomb. 2 Cruel tortures.] Ver. 995. Vermina steva. " Vermina is a dis- ease of the body, with a slight motion in it, as if the patient were afflicted with worms. It is called by the Greeks arpofbc." Festitt. " Vermina sunt tormina, unde verminari, pati tormina." Vossius De Anal. i. p. 150. Creech interprets vermina simply vermes, and Good gives " vile worms," which may, indeed, be the right sense. 3 But the ocean, though often rising and swelling, raged in vain and to no purpose.] Ver. 1002. This is the only passage in which I have departed from the text of Forbiger, in whose edition it stands thus : Nee temere incassum frustra mare seepe coortum scevibat. He attempts to make sense of it by referring the conjunction nee "not only, to the verb stevibat, but to all the sentence, as if Lucretius had said, nee scepe temere mare cdoriebatur et seevibat." But whom will this satisfy? Wakefield supplies in naves from the preceding verse, as if Lucretius would have said that the ocean did irt c/wn rage 230 LUCRETIUS. B. v. .005 lu:0. for themselves unawares ; now persons of their own accord give it craftily to others. Afterwards, when they procured huts, and skins, and fire, and the woman, united to the man, came to dwell in the same place with him; and when the pure and pleasing con- nexions of undivided love were known, and they saw a pro- geny sprung from themselves ; then first the human race be^an to be softened and civilized. For fire now rendered their shivering bodies less able to endure the cold under the canopy of heaven ; and love diminished their strength ; and children with their blandishments easily subdued the ferocious tempers of their parents. Then, also, neighbours, feeling a mutual friendship, began to form agreements not to hurt or injure one another; and they commended, with sounds and gestures, their children, and the female sex. to each other's protection ; while they signified, with imperfect speech, that it is right for every one to have compassion on the weak. Such concord, however, could not be established universally ; but the better and greater part kept their faith inviolate, or the human race would then have been wholly destroyed, and the species could not have continued its generations to the present period. But nature prompted men to utter the various sounds of the tongue, and convenience drew from them the names of things, almost in the same manner as inability to use the tongue seems to excite children to gesture, when it causes them to point with the finger at objects which are present before them. For every creature is sensible that it can use its own faculty. Even before horns are produced on the forehead of a calf, it butts and pushes fiercely with it when enraged ; and the young of panthers, and whelps of lions, contend with their talons, and feet, and teeth, when their teeth and talons are yet scarcely grown. We see, moreover, that the whole race of birds trust to their wings, and seek a fluttering support from their pinions. To suppose, therefore, that anj: one man ' then assigned names against ships when there were no ships. Try what mode of explan- ation you please, "nee," as Lachmann says, "perverts the sense." Lambinus reads sed, and him I have followed. Lachmann himself gives hie. The meaning of the passage evidently is, that there were then no ships for the ocean to wreck. 1 To suppose, therefore, that any one man, to.] Ver. 1040. Proindt B. v. 10111070. LUCRETIUS. 231 to things, and that men thence learned their first words, is to \ think absurdly ; for why should this one man be able to dis- tinguish all things with names, and to utter the varied accents of the voice, and others not be deemed able to do this at the same time ? Besides, if others had not also used words among themselves, whence was the knowledge of them ingrafted in him ? Whence was power first given to him, that he should under- stand, and discern in his mind, what expediency would wish to effect ? One, likewise, would not be able to compel many, and oblige them, by force, to submit to learn his names of things ; nor could he by any means teach, or persuade men unfitted to listen, what was necessary to be done ; for neither would they at all bear with patience, or long suffer him to din into their ears, to no purpose, the strange and unintelligible sounds of his voice. Lastly, what is there so wonderful in this matter, if the human race, whose voice and tongue were in full vigour, dis- tinguished various objects by sounds, according to their various feelings ; when dumb cattle, and even the tribes of wild beasts, are wont to utter different and distinct cries when terror or pair, affects their hearts, and when joy prevails in them? For this you may observe by manifest instances. When the large flabby jaws of the Molossian dogs begin to growl, as they are irritated, exposing their hard teeth, their violent fury ' threatens with a far different sound from that which they utter when they merely bark, and fill all the neigh- bourhood with yelping. And when they begin to lick their whelps tenderly with their tongue, or when they fondle them with their paws, and, snapping at them, affect gently to swallow them up with teeth suspended over them, they soothe them with a sort of whining, using their voice far otherwise than when they howl, deserted in lonely buildings, or when, putare aliquem turn nomina distributee, &c. " This is directed against Pythagoras, to whom it seemed 10 have been the office of the high- est wisdom to give names to all tilings ; and against Plato, who, in his Cratylus, says that names were given to things, not by chance, but by regular plan and contrivance ; and that he who first invented the names was called 6vofiaTovpy6g, and 6j>o/iaro0erjjc." Lambinut. 1 Violent fury.] Ver. 1064. Rabies districta. Fury drawn like a word, as Wakefield interprets it ; equivalent to rabioti dentet du- 232 LUCRETIUS. B. v. 10711091 with crouching body, they slink whimpering from beneath a blow. Again, does not the volte of the horse seem also to differ, when, as a vigorous steed in the flower of his age, and pierced with the goads of winged love, he rages-wildly among the mares ; and when he utters a snorting for war from his ex- panded nostrils, and thus, with his limbs trembling, neighs in quite other tones ? l Further, the winged tribes, and various birds, hawks, and eagles, 2 and gulls, which, amid the waves of the sea, seek their food and living in the salt water, utter far other cries at other times, than when they contend for sustenance and fight about prey. Occasionally, also, the long-lived generations of crows, and the flocks of ravens, change their hoarse notes with the weather, when they are said sometimes to call for rain and showers, and sometimes to cry for gales of wind. If various feelings, therefore, impel the inferior animals, though they are destitute of speech, to utter various sounds, how much more consonant is it to reason, that men, even in those early days, should have been able to distinguish different objects by different names ! And lest, perchance, in reference to these subjects, you should meditate with yourself as to the following point, and be anxious to know the origin ofjire, I will inform you that light- ning first brought flame down upon the earth for mortals, and 1 Thus neighs in quite other tones.] Ver. 1075, 1076. Et fremitum patulis sub naribus edit ad arma, Et quom sic alias, concussis artibus, hinnit ? This is Forbiger's reading. Wakefield injudiciously transposed the two verses. Lambinus (whom Creech follows) reads Et quom sis, for *MM, justly observing that the sic is " idle and unmeaning." He also asks the question, " Quaenam arma ? Martiane, an Venerea ? " but does not decide for either ; Lachmann understands the latter. Creech paraphrases tbe lines thus : " vel cum in pugnam initurus fe patulis naribus hinnitum edit, et cum alias propter causas artibus concussis hinnit;" understanding, apparently, the first verse de ar~ mit Martiis, and the second de armis Venereis. I have referred them both to tbe anr.s c f Mars, believing that Virgil had this passage in his mind when he wrote the vigorous lines, Stare loco nencit, micat auribus, et tremit artus, &c. * Eagles.] Ver. 1078. Ouifraga. "A kind of eagle; see Pliny, X. 2." Lambitiut. B. v. 10921121. LUCRETIUS. 233 that from thence all the fire in the world 1 is spread abroad. For we even now see many substances, struck with fire from heaven, ignite, when the ethereal region has sent down its flames. Though it is not to be forgotten, indeed, that when a branching tree, 2 struck by the winds, is shaken and agitated, moving to and fro, and pressing against the boughs of another tree, fire, excited by the violent friction, is elicited ; so that sometimes, while the branches and stems are rubbed together, a fervid glow of flame bursts forth ; of which causes, accord- ingly, either might have supplied fire to mankind. The sun next instructed them to dress their food, and soften it with the heat of flame ; for they saw many things, through- out the fields, mollified by the force of his beams and subdued by his warmth. Hence those who excelled in sense, and had power of understanding, taught the others, every day more and more, to change their rude diet, 3 and former mode of life, for new practices and improvements by means of fire. At length the leaders began to build cities, and to found fortresses, as a protection and refuge for themselves. They also divided the cattle and the fields, and allotted them accord- ing to the beauty, and strength, and understanding of each in- dividual ; for beauty was then much esteemed, and strength had great influence. Afterwards wealth was introduced, and gold brought to light, which easily robbed the strong and beautiful of their honour; for men, however strong, or en-/ dowed with however beautiful a person, generally follow the party of the richer. But to man, whoever governs his life according to true rea- son, it is great wealth to live on a little with a contented mind; for of a little there is no want. Yet men wished themselves to be honoured and powerful, that their fortune might rest on a steady foundation, and that themselves, being 1 All the fire in the world. ] Ver. 1092. Omnis flammarum ardor. * When a branching tree, $c.] Ver. 1095. See i. 896. 3 Every day more and more to change their rude diet.] Ver. ]10t. Inque dies magis invictum commutare. Invictus is a word intro- duced from three AlSS. by Forbiger, in the sense of /3ioc d/3ioc. Lam- binus and Wakefield read in victim ; and Wakefield explains com- mutare in victum to be the same as commutare victum, or mutaticnet importare in victum. But Creech adopted hi victum, from a conjec- ture of Naugerius, which Lachmann has retained, lu Forbiger there is a misprint of Inde for Inque. 234 LUCRETIUS. B v. 112211-50, strong, might pass an undisturbed life. But this they desired in vain; for, as they strove to reach the hignest honours, they rendered the course of their steps full of trouble. And still, though they attain their object, envy, like a thunderbolt, hurls them at times from their pre-eminence, and sinks them with scorn as into the gloom of Tartarus ; so that it is far better to obey in quiet, than to seek to hold states under our sway, and to manage kingdoms. Let men, therefore, if they will, sweat out their life's blood, 1 wearying themselves to no purpose, and struggling along the narrow road of ambition ; (for the highest objects, and whatever are more exposed on eminences, 2 are generally sooner scorched with envy as well as with lightning ;) since they gather knowledge only from the mouths of others, and pursue things rather from what they hear than from their own judgments. Nor does this folly prevail more now, or will it prevail more hereafter, than it has already prevailed in past time. Kings, therefore, 3 being deposed and slain, the ancient ma- jesty of their thrones, and their proud sceptres, lay overthrown in the dust ; and the illustrious ornament of the royal head, stained with blood beneath the feet of the rabble, mourned the loss of its supreme honour ; for that which has been too much feared before, is eagerly trodden down. Power, accordingly, returned to the lowest dregs and rabble of mankind, whilst each sought dominion and eminence for himself. But at length the wiser part taught them to establish I a government, and made laws^/br them, that they might consent 1 to observe order ; for mankind, weary of passing their lives in a state of violence, were worn out with contentions ; on which account they fell more submissively under the power of laws and strict ordinances. For because every one, in his resent- ment, prepared to take revenge for himself more severely than is now allowed by equitable laws, men, for this reason, be- came disgusted with living in strife. Since, from this source, 1 Sweat out their life's blood.] Ver. 1128. Sanguine sudent. I am indebted to Good for the translation of those words. 2 Whatever are more exposed on eminences.] Ver. 1131. Qua tunt altis magis edita quomque. " Exposed on high places, or promi- nent." Wakefield. * Kings, therefore, Ac.] Ver. 1135. Ergo rcgibiis oecisis. The eryo, therefore, refers to what is said, in the preceding paragraph, about the lofty being humbled ; unless, indeed, some lines have been lost. B. v. 1151-1176. LUCRETIUS. 235 the fear of punishment poisons the enjoyments of life ; for violence and injury involve every one, and generally recoil upon the head of him from whom they arose ; nor is it possible for any one to live a quiet and peaceable life, who violates by his actions the common bonds of peace. For though his guilt escape, for a time, the knowledge of both gods and men, yet he cannot feel sure that it will always be hidden ; since many, speaking frequently in dreams, or being delirious in sickness, are said to have revealed their secrets, and to have published to the world long-concealed crimes. In the next place, what cause spread abroad, throughout the wide nations of the earth, the notion of the existence and power of the gods, and filled cities with altars, and led solemn sacred rites to be instituted ; (which sacred rites now flourish and are performed on all important occasions and in all distinguished places ;) whence also terror pervades mortals; a terror which raises new temples of the deities throughout the whole globe of the earth, and impels men to celebrate their worship on feast days ; it is not so difficult, as it may seem, to explain. 1 For, in those early times of which we speak, the tribes of mortals beheld in their minds, even when awake, glorious images as of gods, 2 and saw them, in their sleep, still more dis- tinctly, and of a wondrous magnitude of figure. To these, therefore, they attributed vitality, because they seemed to move their limbs, and to utter majestic words, suitable to their dis- tinguished appearance and mighty strength. And they as- signed to them an immortal existence, because their appear- ances came-in-constant-succession, and their form remained the same ; although they might certainly have deemed them immortal on another account, 3 as they would consider that 1 To explain.] Ver. 1167- Rationem reddere verbis. 2 Glorious images as of gods.] Ver. 1168. Div&m egregias fades. This is a most unsatisfactory way of accounting for the first con- ception of supernatural beings. " Consistently with his common doctrine," says Good, "Lucretius imputes the more frequent ap- pearance of those heavenly semblances, or rather their being more frequently perceived by mankind, in those early ages of the world, to tne greater degree of solitude and tranquillity in which life was then passed." This is, however, not to be found in the passage before us. Other commentators are silent. 3 Although they might certainly have deemed them immortal on another account.'] Ver. 1176. Et tamen omnino. The words supplied are 236 LUCHETIUS. B. v. 11771207 beings, endowed with such apparent strength, could not easily be subdued by any destructive force. And they thought them pre-eminent in happiness, because the fear of death could thus trouble none of them, and because, at the same time, they saw them, in their dreams, do many and wonderful actions, and ex- perience, as it seemed, no difficulty in the performance of them. Besides, they observed the revolutions of the heavens, and the various seasons of the year, go round in a certain order, and yet could not understand by what causes these effects were produced. They had, then, this resource for themselves, to ascribe all things to gods, and to make all things be guided by their will. And the seats and abodes 1 of these gods they placed in the sky, because through the sky the night and the moon are seen to revolve; the moon, I say, the day, and the night, and the august constellations 2 of night, and the nocturnal luminaries of the heavens, and the flying meteors, as well as the clouds, the sun, rain, snow, winds, lightnings, hail, and the vehement noises and loud threatening murmurs of the thunder. O unhappy race of men ! as they attributed such acts, be- sides ascribing bitter wrath, to the gods ! What lamentations did they then prepare for themselves, and what sufferings for us ! what fears have they entailed upon our posterity ! Nor is it any piety for a man to be seen, with his head veiled, turning towards a stone, and drawing near to every altar ; or to fall prostrate on the ground, and to stretch out his hands before the shrines of the gods ; or to sprinkle the altars with copious blood of four-footed beasts, and to add vows to vows ; but it is rather piety to be able to contemplate all things with a serene mind. For when we look up to the celestial regions of the vast world above, and contemplate the firmament studded with glittering stars, and reflect upon the revolutions of the sun and moon, the apprehension lest there should, perchance, be an almighty power of the gods above us, which guides the stars in their various motions, begins then to raise its head, as if awaking, within our breast ; an from the suggestion of Wakefield. Other editions have Et manet omnino, which is not very intelligible. 1 Abodes.] Ver. 1187. Templa. " Domos." Creech. * August constellations.] Ver. 1189. Signa severa. " Veneranda, dia, sacra." Lambinus. B. v. 12081240. LUCRETIUS. 237 apprehension which, perhaps, before lay dormant under th( weight of other cares. Since poverty of reason, and ignor- ance of natural causes, disquiet the mind, while it doubt' whether there was any birth or commencement of the world, or whether there is any limit of time, until which the walls of the world, 1 and the silent movements of the heavenly bodies, can endure this incessant labour ; or whether the heavens, di- vinely endowed with an imperishable nature, can, as they roll along time's eternal course, defy the mighty power of endless age. Besides, whose heart does not shrink at the terrors of the gods ? Whose limbs do not shudder with dread, when the scorched earth trembles with the awful stroke of lightning, and ichen the roars of thunder pervade the vast heaven ? Do not people and nations tremble ? And do not proud monarchs, penetrated with fear of the deities, recoil in every nerve, lest, for some foul deed, or arrogant word, the dread time of pay- ing penalty be come ? When, likewise, the mighty force of a tempestuous wind, raging over the sea, sweeps athwart the deep the commander of a fleet with all his powerful legions and elephants, 2 does he not solicit peace of the gods with vows, and timidly im- plore them with prayers, for a lull of the winds and a pros- perous gale ? But, alas ! he implores them to no purpose ; for, frequently, seized by a violent hurricane, he is neverthe- less borne away to the shoals of death. Thus some unseen power, apparently, bears upon human things, and seems to trample down proud fasces and cruel axes, and make them merely a sport for itself. Further, when the whole earth totters under our feet, and cities, shaken to their base, fall or threaten to fall, what wonder is it, that the nations of the world despise and humble them- selves, and admit the vast influence of the gods over the world, and their stupendous power to govern all things ? Moreover, brass, and gold, 3 and iron were discovered, as 1 Walls of the world.] Ver. 1212. Mcenia mundi. That is, the heavens. Men cannot but suspect that the heavens may at length be worn out by perpetual revolutions. - Elephants.] Ver. 1227. Which he is transporting, to make war in a foreign country. :i Moreover, brass, and gold, ffc.~\ Ver. 1240. Quod superest as aty* turum, &c. He now proceeds to tell how metals were discoveio/(- 23b LUCRETIUS. B. v. 12411272. well as heavy silver, and the substance of lead, 1 at a time when fire had consumed mighty forests upon the high mountains, either from lightning having been hurled upon them, or because men, warring among themselves in the woods, had set fire to them for a terror to their enemies ; or else because, moved by the goodness of the soil, they wished to lay open fertile fields, and to render the country fit for pasturage ; or because they sought to kill the wild beasts, and to enrich themselves with their spoils. For to catch the game by means of pitfalls and fire, became a practice before men surrounded the forest with nets, or roused the animals with dogs. However this may be, or from whatever cause the rage of the fire, with frightful noise, had consumed the woods from their deepest roots, and had melted the earth with heat, there flowed from the boiling veins, uniting in the hollow places of the soil, a stream of silver and gold, as well as of brass and lead ; which, when they afterwards saw it congealed, and shining with a bright colour on the ground, they took up, being attracted by its glittering and smooth lustre ; and they observed that the masses were formed of the same shape as the figure of the receptacle of each had been. It then occur- red to them, that these metals, being melted with heat, might settle into any form or figure of things, and might also be fashioned, by beating out, into the sharpest and finest points of instruments, so that they might make tools for themselves, and be able both to cut down the woods, and hew timber, and smooth and polish boards, as well as to pierce, excavate, and bore. These instruments they at first attempted to make of silver and gold, no less than of the strong substance of hard brass ; but in vain ; for the consistence of those metals yielded and gave way, and both were alike unable to bear severe usage Accordingly brass was tlier. more in esteem, and gold was Similar extractions of metals from the earth, casual or otherwise, are mentioned by Aristotle, De Mirab. p. 102, ed. Sylb. ; Athenzeus yi. 4, sub fin. ^ Strabo, lib. iii. p. 14-7; Diodorus Siculus, Ant. lib. iv., haud longt ab init. JEs I have rendered brass, (not copper, as Good translates it,) for Servius, (ad Mn. xii. 87,) alluding to this very passage of Lucretius, makes it equivalent to orichalcum, which is generally understood to be brass. 1 Substance of lead.] Ver. 1241. Plumbi potestas. The same as plumbi vis, or plumbum ipsum. B- v 12731302. LUCRETIUS. 239 neglected on account of its uselssness, as taking only a dull edge and blunt point ; now brass is despised, and gold has succeeded to the highest honours. For thus revolving time changes the seasons of things ; that which was once in estimation, becomes of no repute at all ; while another thing succeeds, and bursts forth from contempt ; l something which is daily more and more sought, and which, when found, flour- ishes among mankind with special praise and wonderful honour. It is now easy for thee to understand of thyself, my Mem- mius, how the nature and use of iron were discovered. The first weapons of mankind were the hands, nails, and teeth ; also stones, and branches of trees, the fragments of the woods ; then flame and fire were used, as soon as they were known ; and lastly was discovered the strength of iron and brass. But the use of brass was known earlier than that of iron ; inasmuch as its substance is more easy to work, and its abundance greater. 2 With brass they turned up the soil of the earth ; and with brass they excited the tumults of war, and inflicted deep wounds, and took away the cattle and lands of their neighbours; for every thing unarmed and defenceless easily surrendered to those that were armed. Then gradu- ally came forth the sword of steel, and the form of the brazen pruning-hook was turned into contempt. With iron they began to cleave the ground, and the contests of doubtful war- fare were made equal. And it appears that man mounted armed upon the back of a horse, and guided it with reins, and exerted his right hand to Jight, before he tried the hazards of war in a two-horsed chariot. It also doubtless occurred earlier to yoke two horses than four, or than to mount in full armour on chariots equipped with scythes. In process of time the Carthaginians taught fierce elephants, 3 with towers on their backs, and with snake- like proboscis, to endure the wounds of war, and to throw vast 1 Bursts forth from contempt.] Ver. 1277. See ver. 831. * Its abundance greater.] Ver. 1283. Copia major. Viz. in those early times. XaXiwjJ fipyao>ro, /isXa; ' OVK toft aiSripof. Hes. Op. et D. 150. 1 Elephants.] Ver. 1301. Boves Lucas. Elephants were so called by the Romans because they first saw them in Lucania, in the war with Pyrrhus. Plin. H. N. via. C, 6. With snake-like proboscis.] Atiguimanos. See ii. 538. 240 LUCRETIUS. B. v. 1303-134-5 martial battalions into confusion. Thus sad discord produced one invention after another, to spread terror in battle among the tribes of men, and added daily increase to the horrors of contention. They tried bulls, also, in the business of war, and endea- voured to impel fierce boars against the enemy. The Parthi- ans, too, sent strong lions before them, with armed keepers and daring guides, to govern them and hold them in chains, But such attempts were in vain ; for the savage beasts, heated with tumultuous slaughter, and shaking their terrible manes on every side, disordered all troops without distinction. Nor could the riders soothe the spirits of their horses, which were alarmed at the roaring of the lions, and turn them with the reins against the enemy. The lions, in their rage, threw themselves with leaps among the soldiers in every part ; they flew at the faces of those who came against them, and seized on others from behind unawares, and, clasping them round about, threw them to the earth sinking under wounds, clinging to them with their strong teeth and hooked talons. The bulls tossed their own people, and trampled them under foot ; they gored with their horns the sides of the horses, and their bellies underneath, and tore up the earth with alarming fury. But the boars killed their own friends with strong tusks, staining, in their rage, the broken darts with their blood, and spread promiscuous destruction among cavalry and infantry. For though the horses, leaping aside, shunned the fierce attacks of their teeth, or, rearing up, pawed the air with their feet, yet they struggled to no purpose ;. since you might have seen them sink down hamstrung, and cover the earth with a heavy fall. Whatever beasts they thought suffi- ciently tame at home, they saw, in the heat of action, mad- dened with wounds, cries, flight, terror, and tumult. Nor could they recall any portion of them to order; for all the different kinds of beasts scattered themselves abroad ; as ele- phants even now, when imperfectly inured to weapons, flee hither and thither, after having inflicted much cruel damage on their masters. Thus, and with these views, it is possible that they might act. But I am scarcely inclined fo think that they could not originally foresee, and consider in their minds, how genera] and calamitous an evil such warfare would prove to succeeding B. T. 1346-1375. LUCRETIUS. 241 times. But they were willing to adopt 1 this practice, not so much with the hope of conquering, as to cause annoyance to the enemy ; and men who distrusted their numbers, and were without efficient arms, naturally grew desperate, ard were ready to perish themselves, if they might but destroy their op- ponents. The garment of skins, fastened together, existed before the woven dress ; the woven succeeded the discovery of iron ; for by iron weaving is performed. Nor, indeed, of any other mate- rial can instruments of such smoothness a* treadles, spindles, shuttles, and rattling yarn-beams, be produced. And nature obliged men to work in wool before women ; for all the male sex far excel in art, and are much more inge- nious than the female. This state of things continued until the sturdy husbandmen made it a reproach to the workers in wool; making them consent to resign it to the hands of women, and themselves to endure hard labour together with the tillers of the ground, and strengthen their limbs and hands with severe toil. But of sowing and planting, 2 and of grafting, nature, the great producer of all things, was herself the first example and origin. For berries and acorns that fell from the trees, ex- hibited, in the proper season, a crop of seedlings underneath ; from observing which they also ventured to intrust slips to the boughs, and to plant young stocks throughout the fields. They then tried diiferent methods of tilling the kindly soil, and saw wild fruits become improved in their lands by being cherished and indulgently cultivated. And they com- pelled the woods to withdraw daily farther up the mountains, and to give room below for tillage ; so that they might have meadows, lakes, rivulets, corn-fields, and rich vineyards throughout the hills and plains, and that a green tract of olives, marking the ground, might run between other trees, stretching far over the heights, and valleys, and plains ; as you now see all gardens distinguished with varied beauty, 1 But they were willing to adopt, &.] Ver. 1346. Three verses which precede this, and which are evidently spurious or misplaced. I have omitted in the translation. Lachmann has ejected there from his text. 2 But of sowing and planting.] Ver. 1360. At sationis Satif means both sowing and planting. Grafting may be considered of more recent date than Lucretius makes it. 242 LUCRETIUS. B. v. 13761403. which, intersected with rows of dulcet apples, men lay out and adorn, and which they keep planted around with other fruit trees. But to imitate with the mouth the liquid voices of birds * was practised long before men could play melodious tunes, and delight the ear with music. The whistling of the zephyr through the empty reeds first taught the rustics to blow through hollow stalks. Then by degrees they learned the sweet plaintive notes, which the pipe, pressed by the fingers of the players, pours forth ; the pipe, which is now found through all the pathless groves, and woods, and glades, through the solitary haunts, and divine resting-places, 2 of the shepherds. Thus time by degrees suggests every discovery, and skill evolves it into the regions of light and fame. These melodies softened the hearts of those swains, and de- lighted them when they were satisfied with food ; for then every thing affords pleasure. Oftentimes, therefore, stretched upon the soft grass, near a rivulet of water, under the boughs of a high tree, they socially, though with no great wealth, gratified their senses with pleasure, especially when the weather smiled upon them, and the seasons of the year painted the green herbage with flowers. Then jests, and pleasant talk, and agreeable laughter, were wont to be enjoyed; for then the rustic muse had full vigour and influence. Then sportive gaiety prompted them to deck their heads and shoulders with garlands of flowers and leaves, and to stand forth in irregular dances, moving their limbs stiffly, and to stamp on mother earth with heavy foot ; whence arose smiles and jocund laughter, because all these exhibitions had then greater effect, as being new and wonderful. Hence 1 But to imitate voices of birds, $c.] Ver. 1378. He says that the idea of music was taken from the singing of birds, and that of wind instruments from the whistling of the wind among reeds. 1 Divine resting-places.] Ver. 1386. Otiadia. I know not whether Lucretius calls the haunts of the shepherds dia because they were supposed to be frequented by Fauns and other deities, or because they were sub dio; or whether he uses the epithet in some other sense. The commentators give no opinion, except that Creech, in his paraphrase, introduces Pastores otio abundantes, as if he took diva for abundant, numerous. But this acceptation I should be unwilling to adopt. B v. 14041432. LUCRETIUS. 243 to produce various modulations of voice, and to weave tunes, and to run over the reeds with compressed lips, were compensations for icant of sleep, as they watched during the night. From whom, also, the men of the present day, wakeful in nocturnal orgies, have received and maintain the same practices^ and have learned to preserve regularity of numbers ; and yet they do not, even now, enjoy their amusement with greater delight than that which the sylvan sons of earth then experienced. For that gratification which is present, if we have pre- viously known nothing more agreeable, delights us pre-emi- nently, and seems to be superior to every thing else; but any thing better, which is discovered afterwards, blunts and alters our feelings as to all we enjoyed before. Thus dislike of acorns came upon mankind; thus those ancient beds, formed of grass and leaves, were abandoned. Skins, too, and the savage dress, fell into contempt ; a dress of which I can imagine the discovery to have excited such envy, 2 that he who first wore it, possibly died from a treacherous-combination against him ; and that his garment, being torn, with much bloodshed, among those who slew him, was at last spoiled, and rendered incapable of being used. In those days skins, in these gold and purple, disturb the life of men with cares, and harass it with war. In which re- gard, as I think, blame has fallen far more justly on us than on them. For cold tormented the uncovered children of earth, when they were without skins ; but to be destitute of a purple garment, adorned with gold and cumbrous figures, causes no in- convenience to us, provided that we have, instead of it, a com- mon dress that may defend its against the weather. The human race, accordingly, labour perpetually in vain and to no purpose, and consume their life in empty cares ; evidently because they do not know what is the proper limit to acquisi- tion, and how far real pleasure extends : and this ignorance 1 Wakeful in nocturnal orgies, have received and maintain the same practices.] Ver. 1407- Unde etiam vigiles nunc htec accepta tuentur. In these words, as in those immediately preceding, where Lucretius speaks of " compensations for want of sleep," I have followed Wake- field's opinion of the sense. Lambinus and Creech thought that men unable to sleep from care or disease were intended. 2 The discovery to have excited such envy.] Ver. 1418. Intidia tali repertam. 2 244 LUCRETIUS. B. v. 1433-1456 has gradually carried them into a sea of evils, and thorough- ly aroused the mighty tumults of war. But the wakeful and untiring sun and moon, that illumine with their light the vast revolving region of the heaven, taught mankind that the seasons of the year proceed, and that every thing is carried on, by a certain law and in a certain order. They afterwards passed their lives defended with strong fortresses, and the earth, divided and marked out, was culti- vated and peopled. The sea was next covered with ships for the sake of per- fumes. 1 Men had auxiliaries and allies, with settled treaties. The poets now began to hand down great deeds in their poems; letters had only a short time before been discovered. Hence our age cannot trace what previously occurred, except so far as reason gives indications. Ships, and the culture of land, walls of cities, laws, arms, roads, garments, and other things of this kind ; all the bless- ings and all the delights of life ; poems, pictures, and artfully- wrought statues, improving use, 2 and the experience of the active mind, proceeding step by step, taught all mankind gradually to adopt. Thus time by degrees suggests every discovery, and skill evolves it into the regions of light and celebrity. Thus, in the various arts, we see that different inventions proceed from different minds, until they reach the highest point of excel- lence. 1 For the sake of perfumes.] Ver. 1441. Turn mare velivolis (na- vibus sc.) florebat propter adores. This is the reading of Wake- field and his followers, as if trading voyages were made for nothing but perfumes. Lambinus, and his clients, read Turn mare velirolum florebat navibu' pandis. Lachmann corrects, from conjecture, Turn mare velivolis florebat puppibus, et res, $c. I < Improving use.] Ver. 1450. Politic wsiw. " Polibus usus is that which either has polish or produces it." Wakefatd. BOOK VI. ARGUMENT. LUCRBTIUS commences with a panegyric o~ Athens, as the inventress and promoter of useful -and elegant arts, and especially as the birth-place of Epicurus, whom he again extols, ver. 1 42. He then proceeds to treat of meteoric appearances in the heavens, and, lest men should be terrified at thunder, as proceeding from Jupiter, asserts that it arises entirely from natural causes, ver. 43 85. It is produced by the collision, or disruption, or corrasion of clouds, ver. 96 120 ; or from other causes, ver. 121 159. Lightning, he says, is fire forced out of clouds, either by their collision, or by the force of winds, ver. 160 218. Of the nature and origin of the thunderbolt, ver. 219322. Of its swiftness, and that of lightning, and why storms are more prevalent at the equinoxes, ver. 323 378. Ri- dicule of those who attribute the origin and direction of storms to the gods, ver. 379 422. Of the prester, or water-spout, ver. 423 450. Of the production of clouds, ver. 451 494. Of rain, the rain-bow, and other natural phaenomena, ver. 495535. Of earthquakes, ver. 536 607. Of the sea, and why it grows no larger, ver. 608 639. Of the fires of 2Etna, ver. 640712. Of the Nile, and its exundations, ver. 713738. Of the lake Avernus, and the neighbouring region, with remarks on other matters, ver. 739840. Of the temperature of water in wells, and of cer- tain remarkable springs, ver. 841906. Of the magnet, and the causes why iron is attracted towards it, illustrated by many remarks on the na- ture and influence of atoms, and of different substances, one upon another, ver. 9071088. Of the origin and cause of diseases, ver. 10891136 ; with a full description of the plague that depopulated Athens during the Peloponnesian war ver. 1137 1285. 246 LUCRETIUS. B. TI. 1 Si IN early days, Athens, of illustrious name, first communi- cated to suffering mortals the method of producing corn ; Athens, also, first improved life, and established laws ; Athens, moreover, first afforded sweet consolations of existence, when she gave birth to that pre-eminent MAN, endowed with such mighty genius, who once poured forth instruction on all sub- jects from his truth-speaking mouth ; and whose fame, spread abroad of old on account of his discoveries, is raised, since his death, even to the skies. For when he observed that almost all things, which neces- sity requires for subsistence, and by which mankind may render life free from care, 1 are already prepared for them by nature, yet saw that men may abound in wealth, may be crowned with honour and applause, and may have pride in the good fame of their children, but that, notwithstanding, there may be griefs in the heart of each at home, and each may disquiet life with unhappy querulousness of mind, he understood, at once, the cause which compels them to lament with such troublesome complaints ; he perceived that the vessel itself was in fault, and that all good things which were collected and brought into it from abroad, were spoiled by its imperfection within ; he was convinced of this, partly because he saw that it was unsound and perforated, so that it could never by any means be filled ; and partly because he found that it contami- nated with an offensive taste, as it were, all things that it had received within it. He therefore purged the minds of men with the words of truth, and set bounds to desire and fear ; he explained what is the chief good at which we all aim, and showed the way, in a narrow track, by which we may in a straight course arrive at it. And he taught what evil pre- vails every where in human affairs, which flows and arises variously, either from casual accident, or from necessity, ac- cording as nature has appointed ; and he showed from what portals each ought to be met, 2 and proved that mankind re- 1 Render life free from care.] Ver. 11. Vitam consistere tutam. " Consistere is used in an extraordinary sense, for constituere et red- dere." Turneb. Advers. ii. 12, cited by Havercamp. 2 From what portals each ought to be met.] Ver. 32. Qiribus I portis occitrri quoiqiie deceret. " A metaphor from military affairs, in allusion to gates of cities or camps, from which a sally is made, or resistance offered; against the enemy." Lambinus B. vi. 33-30 LUCRETIUS. 247 volve in their breasts, for the most part unnecessarily, the sorrowful tumults of care. For as children tremble, 1 and fear every thing in thick darkness, so we, in the light, fear sometimes things which are not more to be feared than those which children dread, and imagine about to happen, in the dark. This terror of the mind, therefore, it is not the rays of the sun, or the bright arrows of day, that must dispel, but the contemplation of nature and the exercise of reason. For which cause, I shall more carefully proceed to complete, with some further observations, the undertaking which I have in hand. And since I have shown that the regions of the world are mortal, and that the heaven consists of substance generated and perishable, and that whatever things are produced, and must necessarily be produced, within it, are for the most part necessarily dissolved ; attend now to what further remains to be said ; since his friends once more exhort the charioteer to ascend his stately chariot, 2 testifying-by-their-applause, that all things which before were adverse to his course, are now Altered through their gentle favour. But the phcenomena which men observe 3 to occur in the 1 For as children tremble, e.] Ver. 35. See ii. 55 , iii. 87. 2 Since to ascend his stately chariot,