APT""' Y X""X TV T TIONAL f 39 BB m LIBRARY UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO V. AN ESSAY OX THE STAR SPANGLED BANNER NATIONAL SONGS BY STEPHEN SALISBURY, Member cftke America* Antiquarian Society, *e^ Jtc. bcfort tix 9mmcan antuptarian Sortrtg. at fljrir amroal flUtting, dofctt 21, 1872. WITH ADDITIOXAI, HOTES ASD 8OSGS. WORCK8TKR, MAPS. PBIXTKD BT CBARLES HAMILTON. 1873. With the respects of the writer. PRIVATELY PRINTED. THE STAR SPANGLED BANNER AND NATIONAL SONGS. As a slight cloak of propriety, if not of dignity, for a snbject that may be considered of little importance, to which I will invite the attention of the society, for a few minutes, I will offer a familiar quotation from Andrew Fletcher, of Saltonn, a quotation of some value to Fletcher, for it has given him his best hold on the memory of modern times. He writes : " I knew a very wise man who believed that if a man were permitted to make all the ballads, he need not care who should make the laws of a nation." If this should be thought to be exaggeration, it will not be doubted that national songs, in some degree, form and indicate the character of a people, and are there- fore worthy of historical notice. I am not aware that there is more important proof of this power of the Muses than is found in the influence of the song entitled "The Star Spangled Banner" during the struggles for the life of our nation in the last twelve years. In the efforts and suffer- ings of the camp, the battle-field and the prison, and in the discouragements and sacrifices of those who upheld the national arm at home, the untiring repetition of its inspir- ing strains, and the "marching on" of a .more humble and more energetic chorus, kept up the strength and enthusiasm of confident hope. Thus the "Star Spangled Banner" has become a favorite of our people. It is well known that it was written by Francis Scott Key, a young lawyer of Bal- timore, in September, 1814, and it was begun on board of a ship of the British fleet lying near Fort McHenry, to which he had gone to negotiate an exchange of prisoners. To prevent his giving intelligence to his countrymen of the intention to make a combined attack by sea and land on Baltimore, he was detained as a prisoner of war. There he anxiously watched the flag of his country floating over the fort through the day, and in the darkness of the night caught occasional glimpses of it, in the explosion of the shells and rockets by which it was assailed ; and when morning dawned, he saw with thrilling delight that the beautiful ensign still waved over its brave defenders. This scene and the emotions that it excited, he has painted and expressed in this pathetic and inspiring song. The origin of the appropriate tune, that gives strength and deeper feeling to the words, is not so well known. Every one can readily say, that the tune is taken from the old English song, entitled " To Anacreon in Heaven." But I have inquired in vain of the most learned belles lettres scholars and musicians that I know or could approach, for the author of the words or the music, or the date of either. The song as printed in the "Universal Songster," published in Lon- don from 1825 to 1834, has the name of Ralph Tomlinson as the author. Multiplied inquiries and research in all bio- graphies and indexes that I can consult, have not discovered the name ; yet the song has grace, beauty and wit, and is enriched with happy classical ornaments, and it seems to be a thing that could not be disowned or forgotten. It existed to be the model of the song by Robert Treat Paine, Jr., called "Adams and Liberty," at the period when Thomas Moore was first known as a poet, and it is almost worthy of his pen, but it has never been attributed to him. It is commonly called an old English song, but the earliest im- print of it that I have seen, is in my copy of " The Vocal Companion," published in Philadelphia, by Matthew Carey, in 1796. The Nightingale, printed in Boston in 1804, has the words and the music, but not the name of the author. It seems then to be a case in which the best evidence must be obtained from the party on trial, and the song must speak for itself. Its first words are : " To Anacreon in heaven, where he sat in full glee, A few sons of harmony sent their petition," and the last line and the chorus are : " May our club flourish happy, united and free ; And long may the Sons of Anacreon entwine The Myrtle of Venus with Bacchus' Vine." We have here the fact that the song was written for a musical club, called the Sons of Anacreon. Of this club I can find no other mention. With a general resemblance to the poetry of Moore, there are sentences that have not his choice English, as for instance, the line above, "May our club flourish happy, united and free," which is more like the language of the republican cotemporaries of Robert Treat Paine, than the verses of the wits of the earlier time of the first Georges or of Queen Anne, to whom the song has vaguely been attributed. The Historical Magazine, vol. 3, p. 23, states that the tune was originally set to the song " To Anacreon in heaven," by Dr. Arnold. Many notices of Dr. Samuel Arnold, who lived from 1739 to 1802, do not support this statement, though they mention inferior music. The accompaniment is more remarkable than the poetry. Its character is strong and decided, yet it is graceful and flexible, and adapts itself with equal success to the sport of the revellers, to the anxious thoughts of the patriot prisoner, and to the exulting tones of national strength. As an apology for this research of much length and little fruit, it may be remembered that the successful investiga- tion of authorship of subjects for intellectual entertainment is not a waste of time for idle curiosity. The enjoyment of the works of our greatest favorites is increased by a sense of personal gratitude.* * By the kindness of Hon. Charles K. Tuckernian, late U. S. Minister to Greece, a letter from William Chappell, Esq., F. S. A., dated at Heather Down, Ascot, Berkshire, G. B., Jan. 6, 1873, has been obtained, which gives all that can be desired, about the origin of " To Anacreon in heaven" from very high English authority in the history and the art of Music. Mr. Chappell writes that he " made a former correspondent a present of my original copy and retained only a transcript of the heading, which is as follows : ' The Anacreontic Song as sung at the Crown and Anchor Tavern in the Strand, the words by Ralph Tomlinson, Esq., late President of the Society. Price 6d;' with the tune, which was composed by John Stafford Smith. The latter published ' The Anacreontic Song,' harmonized by the author at page 33 ' of A hfth book of canzonets, catches, &c., sprightly and plaintive, * * dedicated by permission to Viscount Dudley and Ward, by John Stafford Smith, gent, of his Majesty's Chapel Royal, author * * and of the Anacreontic and other popular songs.' * * I did not take note of the date of first publication, but the song was sufficiently popular to be pirated in Scotland in 1786, it being included, with the music, in the Musi- cal Miscellany of that year, and again in 1788, in Calliope, or the Musical Mis- cellany, Edinburgh. 1788. 8vo. J. Stafford Smith is said to have been born in Gloucester about 1750. The Anacreontic Club, of which Mr. Tomlinson was first (?) president, was a jovial musical society for singing choral and part-music, catches, canons, and so on. I transcribe a few musical notes at the foot for identification." The replies to the inquiries extensively made for these facts, shew that the above extracts will be read with great interest by scholars and musicians in this country, and the generous courtesy of Mr. Chappell will be appreciated by many who know his name and his works. The Biographical Dictionaries give the time of John Stafford Smith, from about 1750 to 1836, and mention his The song "To Anacreon" is always admired on first ac- quaintance, but it has not gained a place among verses which make men stronger and happier in remembering them. Though it is free from grossness,* it is a bacchana- lian song, and, like its subject, it must be a transient pleas- ure at the best. It is said that in the first flush of popu- larity, its rhythm and music- were used for poetical efforts more short-lived than itself. I do not discover that it was a favorite when Robert Treat Paine, Jr., used its measure in his spirited song, entitled "Adams and Liberty," which was written for and first sung at the anniversary of the Massachusetts Charitable Fire Society in Boston, on June 1, 1798. - Its first words Ye sons of Columbia, who bravely have fought For those rights, which unstained from your sires have descended ; And the energetic chorus For the sons of Columbia will never be slaves, While the earth bears a plant or the sea rolls its waves- eminence as a musical composer; The Free Public Library of Worcester has an odd volume of Calliope, (the second), which does not contain the song. In a subsequent publication, of the substance of his letter in Notes and Que- ries, 4 s. vol. 11, Mr. Chappell adds the interesting statement that the club " is now the Whittington Club; but in the last century it was frequented by such men as Dr. Johnson, Boswell, Sir Joshua Reynolds, and Dr. Percy, especially to sup there." The name "Whittington," commemorates him of the cat, whose obedience to the voice of the chimes, " Turn again, Whittington, thrice Lord Mayor of London," has long been held up to encourage boys to stay at home. Richard Whittington's cat, his inseparable companion and the founder of bis fortune, is a dangerous subject to handle, as Notes and Queries, and other books will show. The easiest way of disposing of the question is to adopt the explanation of an authority free from antiquarian partialities, Sam. Foote, who, in the comedy entitled the " Nabobs," gives an address of Sir Matthew Mite to the Society of Antiquaries, in which he maintains that the Cat was a kind of lighter, in which coal was brought to the London market, and he is sustained by the dictionaries. * The character of the club and the tastes of the time being considered. 8 Will bring to mind its high sentiments and swelling sound, well suited for musical expression and enthusiastic effect. Though it was brought out in a time of great party bitter- ness, and it was exclusively claimed by one of the parties, it has nothing but the language of the broadest patriotism. With all its merits, it was never universally accepted as a national song, and the recent "Library of Poetry and Song," published under the sanction of the honored name of Wil- liam Cullen Bryant, has rescued from oblivion " Sally in our Alley," but has no room for the Sons of Columbia. Some reasons for this failure may be briefly stated. The name of the wise patriot at the head of the government, which was a part of the title of the song, did not recommend it. The broad waves of democracy, which had begun to carry Mr. Jefferson to the highest place, for a time submerged the merits of Mr. Adams and his federal associates, and federal sentiments and federal songs lost their popular pre- eminence. This political movement, though partially un- just, was not wholly injurious, since it severed the last rope that bound our nation to the fast-anchored isle, from which it had been launched. Moreover, there was a felt, though unacknowledged, incongruity between the chorus and the condition of an increasing portion of our inhabitants, and the thoughts and feelings of the song are peculiar to the recent struggle and the escape from national peril ; and the ideas of strength, prosperity and progress are not set forth as they should be in a national song.* *Mr. Paine made other less successful efforts to produce national songs, of which the most worthy of notice is his contribution of a song entitled Spain, set to the music of "To Anacreon," for a Boston festival in honor of the Spanish patriots, on January 24, 1809. The most respected of the 33,000 inhabitants of the good old town honored the occasion with their presence, and were regaled by eight After sixteen years, in which the tune of the Anacreontic song was seldom heard in this country or in Europe, it was applied to the pathetic verses of Mr. Key. A few words may be permitted concerning the questioned right to use this rhythm and music for an American song. Notes and Queries (2d S. V. 6, 429) quotes from "amusing letters from America," this passage. "The air of 'The Star Span- gled Banner,' which our cousins, with their customary im- pudence of assertion, claim as their own, is almost note for note that of the fine old English song, 'When Vulcan forged the bolts of Jove.'" That the song "When Vulcan forged"