mm- Douglas Castle, Drawn and Etched by H. Macbeth-Raebum. JEtiition te Huxe CASTLE DANGEROUS By sir WALTER SCOTT, Bart. asaitl) JntroKuctorg lEssag anU Notes By ANDREW LANG WITH ILLUSTRATIONS BOSTON ESTES AND LAURIAT 1894 CL^-K-4^ -u-U^ EDITION DE LUXE, Limited to One Thousand Copies, N0..2.3T Copyright, 1894, By Estes and Lauriat. A— ^-^^^^^^ /^ TYPOGRAPHY, ELECTROTYPING, AND PRINTING BY JOHN WILSON AND SON, UNIVERSITY PRESS, CAMBRIDGE, U.S.A. TALES OF MY LANDLORD. FOURTH AND LAST SERIES. COLLECTED AND ARRANGED BY JEDEDIAH CLEISHBOTHAM, SCHOOLMASTER AND PARISH-CLERK OF GANDEBCLEUCH. As I stood by yon roofless tower, Where the wa'flower scents the dewy air, Where the howlet mourns in her ivy bower, And tells the midnight moon her care •. The winds were laid, the air was still. The stars they shot along the sky ; The fox was howling on the hill, And the distant echoing glens reply. Robert Burns. M59ayi9 CASTLE DANGEROUS. i;tiitton tie Mxt. LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. Page Douglas Castle Frontispiece The Travelleks 7 The Hunting Feast 94 The Escape 186 The Lady watches the Combat 244 Bannockburn . . 3 293 EDITOK'S INTRODUCTION TO CASTLE DANGEROUS. To criticise '* Castle Dangerous '' is useless, and would be impious. Was never wight so stoutly made But Time and years will overthrow, as Major Bellenden sings. Not many words will suf- ^ce to tell, after Lockhart, the story of this unfortunate romance. Scott, before he began the tale, had suffered one paralytic shock after another. The insults to which he was subjected by the rabble at elections had aggravated his maladies. A *' surgical experiment" was making him feel ^* like the Indian at the torture- stake." In June 1831 Lockhart went to London, on business, and, returning, found that Scott *'had been gradually amending.'' But a morbid activity forbade him to give his brain any repose. He must write, or go mad. He began "Castle Dangerous," based on facts already recorded in his '* Essay on Chivalry," in May or June, r.nd finished it before the end of August. With Ballantynehe had broken — James, too, did '^ap- propinque an end," their tempers and ideas clashed, and Scott, while telling Cadell about the new work, said nothing to his old ally. Ballantyne's criticisms on ^^ Count Robert" had been such as he could not face again. He even thought of giving the book to another printer, but this severity was too much for his genial nature. He feared that he might have forgotten the scenery which he was to describe, and, on July 18, set out with Lockhart for Lanarkshire. They went up X EDITOR'S INTRODUCTION TO Tweed, past Yair, Ashestiel, and Traquair, the beau- tiful familiar places, dull in a sultry day, broken by thunder. The lightning, which he called ''bonny, bonny" when a child, excited him. When they came within view of the dark red lowering walls of Drochel Castle, an unfinished strength of the Regent Morton, Scott could hardly be prevented from stopping the carriage and walking to the place. They pushed on to Biggar, however, where the people turned out and welcomed Sir Walter. ''It was the first time I ever saw him otherwise than annoyed on such an occasion." He seemed, to Lockhart, to be uneasy about his mental condition, setting tasks to his memory. He met two discharged soldiers, or men w^ho called themselves sol- diers, and they blessed him by name. He was touched, and quoted a long passage from Prior : — And he who played the harlequin, After the jest still loads the scene, Unwilling to retire, though weary. On the following day they visited Castle Dangerous, and the Douglas monuments in the deserted church. There lies the e^gjj cross-legged as a Crusader, of the Black Douglas, the friend of Bruce. A little crowd gathered, among them a man who remembered the Butcher Cumberland. Lockhart praises the descrip- tion of the landscape in the novel, and indeed the scene might awaken Scott's smouldering fire, for he was shown the silver case that once held the chivalrous heart of the good Lord James — the heart blazoned on the Douglas shield. Of the castle, only an ivy-clad fragment remained. On their homeward way he re- peated much of Wintoun, Blind Harry, Barbour, and nearly all of Dunbar's poems on the "Deaths of the Makers." Lockhart saw him in the sensitive mood which he once confesses, but ever concealed, when the CASTLE DANGEROUS. a brook or the breeze brought tears to his eyes. He quoted the ballad of Otterbourne — My wound is deep, I fain would sleep. The passion of his life, the love of times gone by, the glory of old houses and '^fights fought long ago '' came upon him. At Milton Lockhart they met Lockhart of Borthwickbrae, an old friend, now smitten by the same malady as Scott himself. *^Each saw his own case glassed in the other's, and neither of their manly hearts could well contain itself as they embraced." Next morning they heard that Borthwickbrae had suf- fered another stroke, and Scott at once set out for home. ^^ I must home to work while it is called to-day : for the night cometh when no man can work.'' So they returned, and the next three weeks were spent on his last published novel. He was to winter abroad, and, the story done, he enjoyed a kind of holiday at last, in his own valley. They would dine under the great tree at Chiefswood, they visited Ettrick and Bemerside, and he entertained a Son of Burns, and Wordsworth. On Sept. 23 he set out for London and the South. On his tour he wrote the unpublished novel ^*The Siege of Malta." His work was not done, but his work for the world's eye was completed. No task remained for him, save the last pages of his Journal, and the intro- duction to ^^ Castle Dangerous," which he sent from Naples, true to the last call of duty. He also, as has been said, wrote *'The Siege of Malta." A draft of the manuscript remains, and one who has read it remarks that it is not destitute of fine passages. On Jan. 26, 1832, Scott notes, in his Journal, that he has good news from Cadell. ^' * Castle Dangerous' and ^ Count Bobert,' neither of whom I deemed sea- worthy, have performed two voyages — that is, each sold about 3400 ... as yet my spell holds fast. " xll EDITOR'S INTRODUCTION TO Yet he * thinks the public mad for passing these two volumes," and calculates what he has ^'on the stocks/' '^ Lady Louisa Stuart" he reckons at £500, probably referring to the unfinished ^^ Private Letters ^' begun before ^^ Nigel.'' He was, apparently, under the mis- conception that this old work was finished, whereas only seventy pages were in type, and it does not seem that he had the rest in manuscript. '^The Knights of Malta " {sic) he estimated at £2500, and put down as much for *^ Reliquiae Trotcosianse, " the descrip- tion of his library and collection of antiquities which he had only begun. He had also conceived a book on the origin of Mdrchen, or popular tales, an account of his Tour, and a book for the Roxburghe Club, a labour of love. The old man in him was unaltered: he dreamed again of buying Faldonside. In fact, illusions were creeping round that noble intellect. His touching hope that his ^^ powers of mind were not to have a different date from those of his body " was not wholly fulfilled. In almost the last lines of poetry which came from his pen, the motto of chap. xiv. of ^^ Castle Dangerous," he says But he that creeps from cradle on to grave, Unskilled save in the velvet course of fortune. Hath missed the discipline of noble hearts. He did not miss the discipline, and his Journal re- mains, a splendid example of constancy and fortitude under every form of trial. Among Sir Walter's lavish gifts to men, the most glorious is his example. Of "Castle Dangerous" it would be impious to speak as if it represented his genius. That declared itself in his emotion as witnessed by Lockhart, but its broken message he could no longer translate into words, or transform into art. Nor is it a grateful task to con- sider the tale pathologically, to remark on the strange CASTLE DANGEROUS. xiii blending of associations which makes him represent his minstrel as a bibliophile and antiquary, and on the weakness shown by such visions as the Knight of the Sepulchre, the burning of the coffins, the one-eyed Ursula. These things were inevitable, pyschologically, in the condition of his brain. He is more like himself in his last hunting-scene, and his account of the keen hunting-passion of the peasants. His intellect, clear and humorous to the last page of his Journal, could no longer grapple with the task of creation. Human respect forbids us to linger over the dying effort made in ** Castle Dangerous.'' Merely by way of being complete, something may be said here about a curious imposture, the so-called posthumous romance of ^^Moredun." A Monsieur E. de Saint-Maurice Cabany told, in 1855, the following tale. He knew a German merchant who bequeathed to him a desk, in which was a collection of Royalist tracts, and a manuscript called '^Moredun, a Tale of the 1210.'' Accompanying the manuscript was a letter (given in fac-simile) addressed to **My dear W. S. " (Paris, 4th November, 1826), and signed ^^W. S.'' The letter is, at least, in a good imitation of Scott's hand. It purported to be addressed to his friend, William Spencer, then ruined, and in Paris. Spencer was asked for a manuscript of Scott's for a friend (the German) : Scott supposes him really to want it for himself. If ever Spencer publishes it, it must be as by W. S., and he must let it be supposed that it is Spencer's own work. Kow the letter, in style as well as in handwriting, is almost beyond the ability of a forger. Every turn, every phrase, all the careless man- ner of it, is Sir Walter's. He certainly was in Paris at the date given, and he certainly breakfasted with Spencer. The letter may be quoted for the satisfaction of the curious. xiv EDITOR'S INTRODUCTION TO Paris, 4th November, 1826. My dear W. S., — I am constrained to make of this note a letter of initials, for I am not quite satisfied with myself in agreeing to write it, and there is no saying into whose hands it may fall. The story which Anne has told me about your daft friend, the foreign monomaniac, is as clearly the case of a man who requires to be cognosced as I ever met with ; but, as it appears to me that she has taken it most ridiculously to heart, we have brought our discussion of it to a conclusion by my con- senting to her doing what you could not be told of until she had received the permission of papa. She has possessed herself, for a long time past, of a tale which I had, at one time, the intention of making the first of a series of such things drawn from the history of Scotland — a notion which I afterward gave up ; for Anne, however, that story has always possessed a great charm, and I allowed her to keep it, because I was under the impression that a mere story, which oSers no particular merits but those of events and a plot, would not appear advantageously among works which had the higher object of painting character — that would be to take a step backward, which would never do — besides, as far as I can recollect, there are a great many anachronisms and freedoms used with persons and places which are not in keeping with the character of historian to which I now aspire. I consider, then, that in authorising my daughter to give you that work as a panacea for the imaginary ills of a foreign monomaniac, I only permit a change of proprietorship. At the same time, in allowing Anne to make a present to you of what is but a trifle after all, I must make a most serious stipulation regarding it — for I tell you candidly that I be- lieve W. S. himself to be the real malade imaginaire — that stipulation is, that if, at any time, you take the fancy of pub- lishing that tale, you will do so with the initials only, and that you will do all that you can in fairness do to countenance the idea that it is a bairn of your ain. I wish I could do something for you personally of some less doubtful character than that of humouring the caprices of a CASTLE DANGEROUS. xv daft man ; but you know how I am placed at present. Be- lieve, however, that you have no more sincere friend than W. S. Cabany deposited his account of the circumstances with the Minister of the Interior, on Nov. 24, 1854. On Nov. 29 Lockhart died. On March 3, 1855, Mr. Skene of Rubislaw, Mr. Gordon (Scott's amanuensis), and a niece of Scott's wrote to the Athenceum^ denying the truth of the story. Cabany's answer was extremely ingenious, and, to be fair, was telling. He remarked that, on Nov. 14, 1814, Ballantyne wrote to Miss Edge- worth, to whom he had sent ^^Waverley," promising ^^ere long'' another novel, ^ describing more ancient manners. " Now the novels which followed ^ ^ Waverley " described more modern manners — they were **Guy Mannering " and *^The Antiquary." ^^Moredun," then, must be what Ballantyne had in his mind. Ca- bany easily detected inconsistencies in the arguments and statements of Mr. Skene and Mr. Gordon, and of the niece. The evidence of the niece was bad enough, careless enough, and, in dates, confused enough, to ruin the value of her testimony. Mr. Gordon asserted that Scott never signed ^^W. S." A letter of his, also, to W. S. (William Scrope) signed ^* W. S." was imme- diately produced. As to the assertion that Scott would not give away a work, he later gave two sermons to Gordon himself (Dec. 28, 1827). That '^Moredun" is not by Scott, that it cannot be by Scott, perhaps no one who tries to read it will deny. But the ingenuity of the introductory letter, the clever- ness of the replies to Skene and Gordon, are perhaps without example in the records of literary forgery. As Sir Walter's niece remarked, *'I cannot think that foreigners alone would have ventured on this." Who was the forger? Andrew Lang, July 1894. INTKODUCTION TO CASTLE DANGEROUS. [The following Introduction to " Castle Dangerous " was forwarded hy Sir Walter Scott from Naples in February 1832, together with some corrections of the text, and notes on localities mentioned in the Novel. The materials for the Introduction must have been collected before he left Scotland, in September 1831; hut in the hurry of preparing for his voyage, he had not been able to arrange them so as to accompany the first edition of this Romance. A feio notes, supplied by the Editor,'^ are placed within brackets.'] The incidents on which the ensuing Novel mainly turns are derived from the ancient Metrical Chronicle of *'The Bruce/' by Archdeacon Barbour, and from *^The History of the Houses of Douglas and Angus," by David Hume of Godscroft ; and are sustained by the immemorial tradition of the western parts of Scot- land. They are so much in consonance with the spirit and manners of the troubled age to which they are referred, that I can see no reason for doubting their be- ing founded in fact : the names, indeed, of numberless localities in the vicinity of Douglas Castle appear to attest, beyond suspicion, many even of the smallest circumstances embraced in the story of Godscroft. 1 [J. G. Lockhart.j h xviii INTRODUCTION TO Among all the associates of Robert the Bruce, in his great enterprise of rescuing Scotland from the power of Edward, the first place is universally conceded to James, the eighth Lord Douglas, to this day venerated by his countrymen as ^^the Good Sir James:" The Gud Schyr James of Douglas, That in his time sa worthy was, That off his price and his bounte. In far landis renownyt was he. Barboue. The Good Sir James, the dreadful blacke Douglas, That in his dayes so wise and worthie was, Wha here, and on the infidels of Spain, Such honour, praise, and triumphs did obtain. Gordon. From the time when the King of England refused to reinstate him, on his return from France, where he had received the education of chivalry, in the extensive possessions of his family, — which had been held for- feited by the exertions of his father, William the Hardy — the young knight of Douglas appears to have embraced the cause of Bruce with enthusiastic ardour, and to have adhered to the fortunes of his sovereign with unwearied fidelity and devotion. *'The Doug- lasse,'' says Hollinshed, ^'was right joyfully received of King Robert, in whose service he faithfully con- tinued, both in peace and war, to his life's end. Though the surname and familie of the Douglasses was in some estimation of nobilitie before those daies, yet the rising thereof to honour chanced through this James Douglasse ; for, by meanes of his advancement, others of that lineage tooke occasion, by their singular manhood and noble prowess, shewed at sundrie times in defence of the realme, to grow to such height in autho- ritie and estimation, that their mightie puissance in mainrent,^ lands, and great possessions, at length was CASTLE DANGEROUS. xix (through suspicion conceived by the kings that suc- ceeded) the cause in part of their ruinous decay." In every narrative of the Scottish war of indepen- dence, a considerable space is devoted to those years of perilous adventure and suffering which were spent by the illustrious friend of Bruce, in harassing the English detachments successively occupying his paternal terri- tory, and in repeated and successful attempts to wrest the formidable fortress of Douglas Castle itself from their possession. In the English, as well as Scotch Chronicles, and in Eymer's ^^Foedera," occur frequent notices of the different officers intrusted by Edward with the keeping of this renowned stronghold ; espe- cially Sir Robert de Clifford, ancestor of the heroic race of the Cliffords, Earls of Cumberland; his lieutenant, Sir Eichard de Thurlewalle (written sometimes Thrus- wall), of Thirwall Castle, on the Tippal, in Northum- berland; and Sir John de Walton, the romantic story of whose love-pledge, to hold the Castle of Douglas for a year and day, or surrender all hope of obtaining his mistress's favour, with the tragic consequences, softened in the Novel, is given at length in Godscroft, and has often been pointed out as one of the affecting passages in the chronicles of chivalry.^ The Author, before he had made much progress in this, probably the last of his Novels, undertook a jour- ney to Douglasdale, for the purpose of examining the remains of the famous Castle, the Kirk of St. Bride of Douglas, the patron saint of that great family, and the various localities alluded to by Godscroft, in his account of the early adventures of Good Sir James ; but though he was fortunate enough to find a zealous and well-informed cicerone in Mr. Thomas Haddow, and 1 [The reader will find both this story, and that of Robert of Paris, in Sir W. Scott's Essay on Chivalry, published in 1818, in the Supplement to the Encyclopcedia Britannica. — Ed.'\ XX INTRODUCTION TO had every assistance from the kindness of Mr. Alex- ander rinlay, the resident chamberlain of his friend, Lord Douglas, the state of his health at the time was so feeble that he found himself incapable of pursuing his researches, as in better days he would have de- lighted to do, and was obliged to be contented with such a cursory view of scenes, in themselves most in- teresting, as could be snatched in a single morning, when any bodily exertion was painful. Mr. Haddow was attentive enough to forward subsequently some notes on the points which the Author had seemed de- sirous of investigating; but these did not reach him until, being obliged to prepare matters for a foreign excursion in quest of health and strength, he had been compelled to bring his work, such as it is, to a conclusion. The remains of the old Castle of Douglas are incon- siderable. They consist indeed of but one ruined tower, standing at a short distance from the modern mansion, which itself is only a fragment of the design on which the Duke of Douglas meant to reconstruct the edifice, after its last accidental destruction by fire.^ 1 [The following notice of Douglas Castle, &c., is from the "Description of the Sheriffdom of Lanark," by William Hamil- ton of Wishaw, written in the beginning of the last century, and printed by the Maitland Club of Glasgow in 1831 : — "Douglass parish, and baronie and lordship, heth very long appertained to the family of Douglass, and continued with the Earles of Douglass untill their fatall forfeiture, anno 1455 ; during which tyme there are many noble and important actions recorded in histories performed by them, by the lords and earls of that great family. It was thereafter given to Douglass, Earl of Anguse, and continued with them untill William, Earle of Anguse, was created Marquess of Douglass, anno 1633; and is now the principal seat of the Marquess of Douglass his family. It is a large baronie and parish, and ane laick patronage ; and the Mar- quess is both titular and patron. He heth there, near to the church, a very considerable great house, called the Castle of Douglass ; and near the church is a fyne village, called the town CASTLE DANGEROUS. xxi His G-race had kept in view the ancient prophecy, that as often as Douglas Castle might be destroyed, it should rise again in enlarged dimensions and improved splendour, and projected a pile of building, which, if it had been completed, would have much exceeded any nobleman's residence then existing in Scotland — as, indeed, what has been finished, amounting to about one eighth part of the plan, is sufficiently extensive for the accommodation of a large establishment, and contains some apartments the dimensions of which are magnificent. The situation is commanding ; and though the Duke's successors have allowed the man- sion to continue as he left it, great expense has been lavished on the environs, which now present a vast sweep of richly undulated woodland, stretching to the borders of the Cairntable mountains, repeatedly men- tioned as the favourite retreat of the great ancestor of the family in the days of his hardship and persecution. There remains at the head of the adjoining bourg, the choir of the ancient church of St. Bride, having be- neath it the vault which was used till lately as the burial-place of this princely race, and only abandoned when their stone and leaden coffins had accumulated, in the course of five or six hundred years, in such a way that it could accommodate no more. Here a silver case, containing the dust of what was once the brave of Douglass, long since erected in a burgh of baronie. It heth ane handsome church, with many ancient monuments and inscrip- tions on the old interments of the Earles of this place. "The water of Douglas runs quyte through the whole length of this parish, and upon either side of the water it is called Douglasdale. It toucheth Clyde towards the north, and is bounded by Lesmahagow to the west, Kyle to the south-west, Crawfurd John and Carmichaell to the south and south-east. It is a pleasant strath, plentiful! in grass and corn, and coall; and the minister is well provided. ** The lands of Heysleside, belonging to Samuel Douglass, has a good house and pleasant seat, close by a wood," &c. — p. 65.] xxS INTRODUCTION TO heart of Good Sir James, is still pointed outj and in the dilapidated choir above appears, though in a sorely ruinous state, the once magnificent tomb of the warrior himself. After detailing the well-known circumstances of Sir James's death in Spain, 20th August, 1330, where he fell, assisting the King of Arragon in an expedition against the Moors, when on his way back to Scotland from Jerusalem, to which he had conveyed the heart of Bruce — the old poet Barbour tells us that — Quhen his men lang had mad murnyn, Thai debowalyt him, and syne Gert scher him swa, that mycht be tane The flesch all haly fra the bane, And the carioune thar in haly place Erdyt, with rycht gret worschip, was. The banys haue thai with thaim tane; And syne ar to thair schippis gane ; Syne to wart Scotland held thair way, And thar ar cummyn in full gret hy. And the banys honorabilly In till the Kyrk off Douglas war Erdyt, with dule and mekill car. Schyr Archebald his sone gert syn Off alabastre, bath fair and fyne, Ordane a tumbe sa richly As it behowyt to swa worthy. The monument is supposed to have been wantonly mutilated and defaced by a detachment of Cromwell's troops, who, as was their custom, converted the kirk of St. Bride of Douglas into a stable for their horses. Enough, however, remains to identify the resting-place of the great Sir James. The ef^gy^ of dark stone, is cross-legged, marking his character as one who had died after performing the pilgrimage to the Holy Sepulchre, and in actual conflict with the infidels of Spain; and the introduction of the heart, adopted as an addition to the old arms of Douglas, in conse- CASTLE DANGEROUS. xxiii quence of the knight's fulfilment of Bruce's dying injunction, appears, when taken in connection with the posture of the figure, to set the question at rest. The monument, in its original state, must have been not inferior in any respect to the best of the same period in Westminster Abbey ; and the curious reader is referred for further particulars of it to ^*The Sepul- chral Antiquities of Great Britain, " by Edward Blore, F.S.A. London, 4to, 1826; where may also be found interesting details of some of the other tombs and effi- gies in the cemetery of the first house of Douglas. As considerable liberties have been taken with the historical incidents on which this novel is founded, it is due to the reader to place before him such extracts from Godscroft and Barbour as may enable him to cor- rect any mis-impression. The passages introduced in the Appendix, from the ancient poem of *