Ex Libris C. K. OGDEN THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES LADY DE ROTHSCHILD , ^/s/r/y //' ■ //<>///■>' //f/s/ ,y '!>/ ' ///f LADY DE ROTHSCHILD Extracts from her Notebooks WITH A Preface by her Daughter CONSTANCE BATTER SEA London ARTHUR L. HUMPHREYS 187 Piccadilly, W. 1912 PREFACE. I have tried to collect and to put into some consecutive form a number of extracts, taken from various authors, often with her own comments, which were amongst my dear mother's papers. These extracts form a valuable index to forty years of reading ! They are occasionally to be found scattered through her diaries, but more generally entered in small unpretentious note-books, which she always kept by her side, where she could transcribe in pen or pencil the passage that struck her fancy. Often the marks of the pencil were faint, or the pen was remiss in its duty, but if the instrument so employed was at times faulty, her own exquisite literary taste was never so. Although, as far as possible, a continuity of dates has been faithfully observed — from I860 to 1907 — for a selection of extracts, still there occurs many a gap in the notes on books during those years, for which it would be difficult to find an explanation other than the fact that some note-books were probably destroyed or lost in the lapse of time. I have every reason to conclude that the passages in prose or verse, that were entered unsigned, and not 1 B r-o «-* v? ■ - - PREFACE. between inverted commas, were by my dear mother's own pen, in addition to those which bear her usual signature : ' L. de R. 1 The little note-books reveal a wide range of reading and a great variety of authors. My mother was not merely a comprehensive, but also a very discriminating reader. Books were indeed her beloved companions, from her earliest youth to within a few months of her death, at the age of eighty-nine, and with them she spent some of her happiest hours. To a great extent they helped to keep her mind fresh and young. She was never alarmed at critical investigations either in Theology or in Science, and eagerly accepted (if she thought them wise) new methods of dealing with philanthropic work and with social questions. Nor was she ever afraid of the principles of a true liberalism. Thus she read with warm interest the newest books, making herself acquainted with the very last results of research in many fields. But this love of critical study did not prevent her from returning again and again, with renewed pleasure and interest, to some of her old and well-read favourites. When quite young she became deeply engrossed in the study of metaphysics, and was laughingly taken to task by an older relative for wasting her time and that of one of her cousins over such useless and ungrateful literature. Many years afterwards (1874) Mr. Matthew Arnold in writing to my mother said : — ' You must read my metaphysics in this last " Con- 2 PREFACE. temporary Vl — my first and last appearance in that field where you, I know, are no stranger. 1 At the age of nineteen, on the eve of her marriage, in March 1840, she drew up the following some- what austere plan for the days of the week, and when, after a time, it had to be discarded, she embarked upon further studies, preparing herself for the superin- tendence of her children's education, and for the many philanthropic schemes that occupied her mind and her heart : — ' Sunday — Without any attempt at order : read as much of new publications, newspapers, magazines as possible. Monday — Household and newspapers ... till £ past 10. A chapter of Locke on the Human understanding .. . „ 11. Drawing ... ... ... „ 1. New publications ... ... „ h past 1. Geography ... „ 3. Italian or German ... . . . „ 4. Tuesday — Household accounts and news- papers ... ... ... „ 12. Drawing ... ... ... „ \ past 1. Letters ... ... „ 4. Wednesday — Household and newspapers „ \ past 10. Locke ... ... ... „ 11. Drawing ... ... ... „ \ past 1 History ... ... . .. „ 3. Ancient Literature . . . „ 4. 3 PREFACE. Thursday — Household and newspapers till | past 10. 1 A )CK • • • • . • • . fl ?? 11. Drawing n \ past 1. Ancient Literature n 3. History n 4. Friday — Household and newspapers ... m J past 10. Locke 11 11. Commentaries 11 1. Italian or German ... 11 4. Leisure hours, occasional intervals between various occupations, to be devoted to reading new publications. - ' I cannot omit to make some mention of my mother's methodical and business-like habits. She never employed a secretary, but, during the long years of her married and widowed life, she carefully kept her accounts in the most perfect and beautiful order, and fulfilled all the duties devolving upon the mistress of a large household in a quiet but very remarkable manner. No mention being made of Saturday on this plan, it would be as well for me to state that my mother loved to keep her Sabbath strictly. Although she could not bear the physical fatigue of a long walk, followed by a lengthy and somewhat tiring service in synagogue, she insisted upon treating the day differently from the other days of the week. All business and ordinary duties were put aside, the carriage was not taken out, and books other than those in daily use were read : my mother, besides her usual Jewish works of devotion, being very fond of Robertson's sermons, of Theodore Parker's and of James Martineau's writings. PREFACE. All through her life she began the day by reading a few verses from the Bible, and the many well-marked passages that I have found are a proof of the care she gave to this study, and of her predilection for the Psalms and for the writings of some of the Prophets. The following words were written after she had made her plan of life : — 4 In order to regulate my conduct rightly, I must diligently study the Word of God, and pray earnestly for the knowledge of my duties and the strength to fulfil them, and be vigilant in constant self-examination. My present duties are to give an example of virtue and piety ; to influence, if possible, the conduct of those around me ; to make my husband as happy as lies in my power, fulfilling his desires and in all things giving way to his wishes ; to employ industry, attention, and judgment in directing those persons and affairs which are under my control. My first object now must no longer be simply to know, but to make use, and the best use, of that which I know ; to advance the happi- ness and comfort of all those around us.'' Severe towards herself as she was indulgent to others, my mother never allowed herself to read a work of fiction until the studies and business of the day were well over, and even then she regarded fiction as a delightful amusement, a sort of dissipation of the mind, of which to taste sparingly. In her early days she read both Italian and German, but as years crept on, the only language, other than English, that attracted her was French. A governess to whom she had been devoted — a native of Geneva, and 5 PREFACE. a most cultivated and charming personality — had early embued her with a taste for the French language, whilst two years spent in Paris at the beginning of her married life, before the upheaval of 1848, when social inter- course was at its pleasantest and brightest, brought her into contact with many distinguished men and women of that period. It was then that she thoroughly enjoyed, amongst other things, the unrivalled performances at the Theatre Francais, the great actress Rachel being at the very height of her fame. To the last she was a constant reader of the Revue des Deux Mondes, delighting in the crisp and lucid style of French prose. Although purely comic literature never could have appealed to her, yet her keen sense of humour made her appreciate much that was delicately humorous in litera- ture, and some works of Dickens stood high in her favour ; she did not care for his sentiment, but enjoyed his fun and his humour. She often spoke with happy pride of her earlv friendship with Mr. Thackeray, and she would read and re-read The Nezvcomes, Pendennis, and Vanity Fair, always rinding fresh interest in their pages. In Pen- dennis there occurs the following beautiful and touching passage, which the great author wrote as a picture of my mother : — ' What one sees symbolised in the Roman churches in the image of the Virgin Mother, with a bosom bleed- ing with love, I think one may witness (and admire the Almighty bounty for) every day. I saw a Jewish lady only yesterday with a child at her knee, and from whose 6 PREFACE. face towards the child there shone a sweetness so angelical that it seemed to form a sort of glory round both. I protest I could have knelt before her too, and adored in her the Divine beneficence in endowing us with the maternal " storge " which began with our race and sanctifies the history of mankind/ The daughter of Mr. Thackeray, a writer herself of much charm and tenderness — Lady Ritchie — was from her very earliest days beloved by my mother, who in another instance transmitted the warm feelings ot friendship she had entertained for a writer of one generation, to his children of the next.* Mr. Matthew Arnold's acquaintance with my mother sprang from their first meeting at the Jews 1 Free School in the East End of London, which Mr. Arnold used to visit in his official capacity of School Inspector. The acquaintance rapidly ripened into friendship, and the happy days of Inspectorship remained unbroken, even when the scene had changed from London to Bucking- hamshire, where Mr. Arnold came regularly during the ' sixties ' to inspect, amongst others, the schools my parents had established in the village of Aston Clinton. In 1863 Mr. Arnold wrote to his mother : ' Lady de Rothschild I am very fond of. 1 And her name constantly appears in the collection of his letters, edited by Mr. G. W. E. Russell. Alluding to a relation of my mother's, he wrote : ' A very remarkable person, * Lucy and Eleanor Arnold, daughters of Mr. and Mrs. Matthew Arnold, married— Lucy, to Mr. Frederick Whitridge of New York, Eleanor, to the late Honble. Armine Wodehouse. and now, the wife of the present Lord Chamberlain, Lord Sandhurst. PREFACE. with a man's power of mind and with great enthusiasm, but, 1 he adds, ' my unapproached favourite is, and will always be, Lady de Rothschild."' As an author, Lord Beaconsfield was nearer to her than as a politician. She had known him in the early days as Mr. Disraeli, when he was a brilliant and most amusing talker ; he often appeared at her mother's hospitable table, and was greatly attracted by the charm of his hostess's young daughter. It was on one of those occasions that the lady he was about to make his wife — Mrs. Wyndham Lewis — was present. The engagement had not been announced, and my mother and her sister, to their infinite amusement, surprised many a nod, wink, and toast given and taken between that happy pair. When the news was made public within the next few days, the two sisters expressed their astonishment that their young and brilliant friend should marry a lady who, in their eyes, seemed to be already quite elderly ; but until the end of their lives both Lord and Lady Beaconsfield (Mr. and Mrs. Disraeli) were, and remained, my dear mother's devoted friends. The very first time that my mother consented to accompany me on a motor drive, was to visit the beautifully situated churchyard at Hughenden — within fourteen miles of Aston Clinton — where she stood beside the grave of her old friend, Lord Beaconsfield. She talked of him and her acquaintance with him in early days to the astonished sexton, who shook his head unbelievingly at the fact that my mother's acquaintance with the great statesman dated back to the years before his marriage. 8 PREFACE. Mr. Gladstone she knew less intimately ; but she keenly enjoyed the two visits that he paid her at Aston Clinton, during the Easter weeks of 1888 and 1 890, when the great statesman was singularly alive to the clearness of her understanding and the quickness of her grasp. She had known Samuel Rogers; she had been intro- duced to Guizot, and had dined by the side of Balzac ; she had sat and listened to Macaulay*, and had enter- tained Bulwer, Tennyson, Browning, Bernal Osborne, Charles Villiers, John Delane, Lord Lyndhurst, Dean Stanley — who mentioned her once in a letter as ' that distinguished daughter of Israel," 1 — Bishop Wilberforce, and his son the present Archdeacon of Westminster, whose name is affectionately mentioned in the diaries, and many others : authors, prelates, statesmen, &c, of the great Victorian era. Indeed, although she was deeply interested in men of letters she often maintained that they gave of their best to their writings. George Eliot's early novels appealed greatly to my mother, Adam Bede and Silas Marner being her special favourites, but unfortunately, the pleasure of a personal acquaintance with that great author had been denied her. On the other hand, she not only claimed acquaint- ance with, but also the friendship of, Mrs. Humphry Ward, whose name, most affectionately mentioned, occurs again and again in the diaries. Frances Power Cobbe attracted her by her strong intellect, her brilliant penmanship, as well as by her breezy humour, whilst my mother was greatly struck by * Sir George Trevelyan, Lord Macaulay's nephew and bio- grapher, was a favourite and frequent visitor at ray mother's house. 9 PREFACE. the courage and steadfastness with which Miss Cobbe fought a desperate and seemingly losing battle against scientific research in the animal world. Through all the years of her life, my mother found constant companionship in her faithful dogs. She had one of these affectionate creatures always with her, and their devotion proved a great solace as the years crept on : to her loving and tender heart vivisection was therefore doubly abhorrent, and she could not bear to dwell upon the painful facts that had been brought to her notice. Responsive as my mother was to the charm of literature, she had a beautiful and refined style of her own, with much originality of thought and grace of diction. She had been repeatedly urged to allow some of her writings to appear in print, but with very few exceptions had always refused to publish them. She wrote two of the chapters that appeared in a book of Essays, called, ' A few words to the Jews by one of themselves, 1 which emanated from the brilliant pen of her elder and only sister* ; also a story that came out in one of the volumes of the Cheap Jewish Library — a publication long extinct — and some other contributions to a little collection of Sabbath Class Addresses — all published without her name. It was her custom to make a list of books in advance that she intended reading, and she generally kept to her purpose, and it was wonderful what she accomplished. I hardly ever saw her without a book * Mrs. Horatio Montefiore. 10 PREFACE. in her hand. But she had not a good verbal memory, so that she never could quote correctly, which caused her much annoyance. How often she wished that she could have beguiled sleepless hours by repeating favourite passages from favourite authors. She used greatly to enjoy reading aloud to us as children, and was also a very good listener: when in after-years her eyesight began to trouble her in the matter of reading small print, I constantly read the Parliamentary speeches in the Times aloud to her, and enjoved her wonderfully discriminating and pertinent remarks. Her judgment was never obscured by prejudice, nor was sh< ever carried away by sentiment or personal interest in the speakers. In the year 1892 my mother spent three weeks with us at the Pleasaunce, Overstrand, our Norfolk home ; there she met daily and in the pleasantest intimacy Lord Morley, or as he then was, Mr. John Morlev. They soon became friends, and it was in answer to one of her questions that Mr. Morley wrote for her his definition of ' Holiness 1 — which appeared later in an article that he published in the Nineteenth Century. At the end of that brief summer holiday, when my mother left us to return to her own home, Mr. Morley, gazing sadly at her accustomed but then empty chair, exclaimed : ' Your house has lost one of its chief charms and attractions."' I venture to quote a few lines from a letter written to me by Lord Morley within a week after my dear mother's death : — 'When we were all at Overstrand nineteen years ago 11 PREFACE. I had a chance that I shall never forget of learning something of her rare gifts and most admirable qualities, her real love of truth and passion for justice, her interest in the things that are worth being in- terested in, her good taste and right judgment in books and the spirit of literature ; her kindly yet firm views of men and women and human life/ My mother was always very cosmopolitan in her tastes ; she loved foreign travel and foreign languages — perhaps the result of having spent six years of her early life, from the age of ten to sixteen (1831-1837) travelling in Germany, Switzerland, and Italy, in the company of her widowed mother, and for the benefit of the health of her sister, to whom she was passion- ately attached and whose death, at a comparatively early age, brought her for the first time face to face with a poignant grief. The only daughter* of this, her only sister, claimed and always held a warm place in my dear mother's affections. Living abroad under very pleasant conditions, at a most impressionable age, she enjoyed many advantages denied to those who lead an entirely insular existence. She made acquaintance with the celebrated pictures of the Continent, and as she had great artistic taste — indeed, she became a very good artist, devoting much time first to portrait and later to flower painting — she took special delight in visiting the foreign churches and galleries. * Helen Montefiore. 12 PREFACE. My mother gave her heart to Italy at a very youthful age, and loved it for the magic of its skies, its language, and its people. Long afterwards, when we were entering the Plains of Lombardy over the Simplon Pass, my mother said she felt as if she were returning home. When a child she took part in some winter festivities at Naples, where one of her relatives had a palace on the Chiaja, and she recalled a theatrical performance given by amateurs, in which Pauline de la Feronnaye — so well known in later life as Mrs. Augustus Craven, the author of Le Recit d\me Sceur — acted most brilliantly, with others of that gifted family. My mother loved beautiful scenery from the days of her childhood onwards, and she remembered, in an astonishing way, places and scenes that had appealed to her in her youth, and that she revisited later. She was particularly fond of the Lake of Geneva, and the Villa Diodati, sacred to the memory of Byron, where she had passed some happy months of her girlhood. She used to linger over the memories of the gay Christmas-times she had spent in Berlin, of the crowded streets, the Christmas-trees standing in every window, and the general spirit of friendliness and good - comradeship amongst the Germans of that date. Yet she longed to put an end to the exile of six years 1 standing and return to her English home. There, in 1837, an intensely happy life awaited her, spent between London and the country, with her mother, a very witty and clever woman, her gifted sister, and two devoted and much-loved brothers, who shared many of her occupations and pleasures. 13 PREFACE. Worth Park, my grandmother's (Mrs. Montefiore's) country home, once an old farmhouse, transformed into a comfortable country residence, was the happy scene of her girlhood life.* It was there that she first showed her vivid interest in the welfare of the labouring classes, in their educa- tional and other needs. In those days schools in the country districts were few and far between ; in fact, in many places they did not exist. The ignorance amongst the rural population being appalling, the two young sisters set themselves a con- genial task in starting and superintending a village school, which they did with the help of a clergyman's widow and her daughters, and which, owing to the fostering care and energy of my mother and my aunt, became a great success. My mother enjoyed herself immensely in teaching the children, and this love of teaching never left her. Thus, many years later, when, as a young married woman, she began to interest her- self in the rapidly-growing Jewish charities of the metropolis, she took a very prominent and active part in the management of the Jews' 1 Free School, of which my father was the very active President. From that time for a period of more than forty years she would most regularly attend the Committee meetings and acquaint herself with all the working of that gigantic institution. Even when she lived during so many months of the year at Aston Clinton, she, who was * My grandfather, the younger brother of Sir Moses Montefiore (Abraham Montefiore by name), died when my mother was a child of three years old. 14 PREFACE. never physically strong, would travel up to and down from London in the dark winter days, taking her ac- customed place at the Committee table, hearing the children repeat their lessons, and encouraging the army of teachers. Meanwhile it had not escaped her attention that the Jewish working girls in the East End of London were often in need of instruction, even of the most elementary order, and it was in their interest that she succeeded in starting evening classes for reading, writing, and arithmetic, in the house of a capable and warm-hearted woman who, with her daughters, gave much of her time to the welfare of her co-religionists.* Mrs. Harris not only supervised the educational classes of the young working girls, but also, with my mother's warm approval, inaugurated for their benefit Sabbath Classes for religious instruction. It was for these audiences that my mother wrote a number of short addresses, which were faithfully read by Mrs. Harris to her weekly congregation. The many excel- lent Clubs for Jewish working girls of to-day, with their long lists of subjects that are dealt with evening after evening, with their singing and dancing classes, their social evenings, and holiday homes, in a great measure owe their existence to these her first attempts at bring- ing a gleam of the spiritual and intellectual joy that illumined her own life into the lives of her less-favoured sisters. * One of Mrs. Harris's daughters, Emily by name, was specially interested in the work initiated by my mother, and to her untiring efforts their lasting success was greatly due. 15 PREFACE. Acquaintance with the Jewish school-children and the Jewish working girls did not end there : my mother, with my father's warm approval, sought them out in their own small tenements, and joined a band of ladies who were beginning to learn the value of personal acquaintance with the poor, and also the difficult lesson of how to bring order and method into charitable work. But her human and religious sympathies were wider than any one form of creed, thus it was not only in London, but also in the country in her Buckingham- shire home that my mother never rested until edu- cational advantages were placed within reach of the village children, and it was entirely owing to the efforts of my parents that excellent schools sprang into existence in the villages of Aston Clinton and of Halton, fully ten years or more before the great educational movement of 1870. The autumn and winter months were in- variably spent at Aston Clinton from 1853 onwards, and there my mother threw herself heart and soul into all that concerned the welfare of the people. Fortu- nately my father also took a very lively and practical interest in village and villagers. Both my parents lived in friendly relationship with many of the neighbouring clergy, and my mother reckoned amongst her most esteemed friends, the rector* who spent twenty-three years of his life at Aston Clinton, and his successor, the present incumbent, j* My sister and I began at an early age to visit the schools of our village, which soon became the object of * The Rev. Thomas Williams. t The Rev. J. R. Cohu. 16 PREFACE. many a morning walk, where two very young teachers might often have been seen solemnly holding their classes, learning probably more than they taught. May I be allowed to say here that from our earliest age my dear mother made us realise that we should learn to take our greatest pleasure in trying to help others to a fuller and happier life ; indeed, we were taught by her example, as well as by her words, that the duties we had set ourselves should not be put on one side for any pleasurable excitement that might come in our way. She spared no pains to make us see life as she saw it, and she never neglected the greatest of all her duties — the education of her children — for any other pursuit, however engrossing it might have been. For nearly forty years my mother was assisted in the furtherance of many philanthropic schemes for the benefit of the village people by a very devoted and most energetic German lady — Miss Molique* by name — well known in the musical world, but who unselfishly gave up a musical career for village work, undertaking the initiation of a Village Library, a Domestic Training Institution, a most successful Evening School for boys, and many other organizations. During all these busy years, my mother possessed the rare quality of being able to combine with her absorbing human interests, her love of literature, in which she found unfailing delight ; her mind was thus attuned to great things, and her standard both in art and authorship was a very high one — only the best satisfied her, and when * Daughter of the celebrated composer and violinist, Bernhard Molique. 17 C PREFACE. she took the pen herself, it was held by a capable and well -practised hand. She was an excellent letter- writer — interesting, humorous, original — but her correspondents were few. To her daughters, when absent from her, she wrote almost daily, and with her two brothers* — both ad- mirable in their power of letter-writing — she freely corresponded in the most charming and intimate manner : also with a beloved cousin and sister-in-law — her namesake and lifelong friend, a woman of rare personal charm and ability — the mother of her niece, Lady Rothschild, whose married and widowed life was spent at Frankfort, f My mother was of a reserved and shy disposition ; it was with difficulty that she could express her deepest feelings, and it is only from her note-books and diaries that some idea may be gained of her spiritual nature. She had no sympathy with any very pronounced doctrine ; she hated the fanaticism of extreme dog- matic belief, and she welcomed liberal thought in religion as in politics. But she could not bear irreverence, and clung with beautiful fidelity to many old customs that belonged to the days of her youth. Her Quaker friends, of whom she had several, paid her, as she always said, the great compliment in telling her that she might really have belonged to the Society of Friends, so constantly was she seen dressed in the * Joseph (the father of Sir Francis Montefiore) and Nathaniel Montefiore, who lived respectively until 1880 and 1883. t Baroness Chai-les de Rothschild, the youngest sister of my father. 18 PREFACE. soft neutral tints in which they delighted, and so un- congenial to her were the excitements and noisy amuse- ments of the world. In fact, as one of her devoted friends, Dr. Kalisch* (to whose daughter she stood in very friendly relationship),! once said : ' She was in the world, but not of it. 1 She was extraordinarily just and fair: generous by nature and equally generous in all her judgments, she had a strong sense of right and wrong. Gentle in manner and in speech, she had, notwithstanding, a very decided personality, that deeply impressed those amongst whom she lived, and who sought and valued her opinion. Young in mind, she was very fond of young people, entered readily into their feelings, loved them for their gaiety, good spirits and enthusiasm. She had a keen sense of humour, and enjoyed bright and witty con- versation. Her sons-in-law, J both gifted with a happy sense of fun and a flow of high spirits, were often struck by her vivacity and ready response. In fact, one of the two, who from his undergraduate days had loved and deeply reverenced her, used laughingly to tease his wife by declaring that she was not as young as her mother, and that those of his friends, who had had the privilege * A distinguished Hebrew scholar and critic of Biblical and Talmudic literature. Died 1885. t Mrs. Hoster. X Lord Battersea (as Cyril Flower) — M.P. for the borough of Brecon from 1880 to 1885 ; M.P. for South Beds, from 1885 to 1892 ; also served in Mr. Gladstone's Government ; died 1907. The Honble. Eliot Yorke, son of the 4th Earl of Hardwicke, equerry to H.R.H. the Duke of Edinburgh; M.P for Cambridgeshire ; died 1878. 19 PREFACE. of being admitted to the home life at Aston Clinton, especially enjoyed the society of one older it might be than they were in years, but full of sympathetic interest in their aims and pursuits. Her presence evoked and never repressed any happy nonsense that brought life and merriment into the party. Amongst the younger generation my mother greatly valued the frequent and ever-welcome visits of many beloved nephews and nieces on both sides of her family. Thus she was warmly attached to Lord Rothschild and his two brothers,* whilst some of her nieces regarded her as a second mother, notably Lady Rothschild and her sisters. In her diary there is a mention of Lady Lindsayf in terms of endearment, whose literary and artistic gifts she held in warm appreciation. For her nephew, Claude Montefiore,^ she entertained feelings of deep affection and high admiration. She also cor- dially welcomed the relations connected by marriage with her daughters ; but it would be invidious, even if it were possible, to enumerate by name all those who claimed her friendship and who responded to her affec- * Alfred and Leopold de Rothschild. t Lady Lindsay, daughter of the Rt. Honble. Henry FitzRoy, and the Honble. Mrs. FitzRoy, a sister of ray father. Mr. FitzRoy, brother of Lord Southampton, served in Lord Palraerston's Government, as Under-Secretary to the Home Office, Chairman of Ways and Means, likewise to the Board of Trade. X The son of Nathaniel Montefiore (my mother's youngest brother), and of his wife Emma Goldsmid. Their eldest son, Leonard, a man of rare promise and much charm, died in 1879 at the early age of 26, deeply regretted by my mother. 20 PREFACE. tionate hospitality. From old days her family had been on the friendliest terms with many members of the great house of Bedford. Lord Charles Russell (1807-1894) was a frequent visitor at Aston Clinton, and in his son, Mr. George Russell, she found a link with those traditions of the past. He Mas her constant visitor in London, and carried on a most charming and original correspondence in prose and in verse with her when she was in the country. As she grew older the circle of her friends increased, and her advent to London brought year after year tried friends and pleasant acquaintances to her door. Indeed, she was the centre of her family ; to both young and old she extended a bright welcome, and no one ever felt that her interests were limited to the past, or that the present had no audible voice for her ear. She had no infirmities of age ; she never lost faith in humanity, nor her hope and belief in a future life and in the goodness of God. She was never bitter or despairing, but, believing in the best, drew forth that which was best in every human being with whom she came in contact. I feel compelled to admit that this short notice, or preface to the ' Extracts,' is in no sense of the word a complete biographical Memoir of my dear mother. It is very difficult for a daughter to write her mother's biography as it should be written, and I fear that, for me, it would be an impossible task. But I have tried, however inadequately, to give some slight picture of her 21 PREFACE. personality, in youth as well as in age, and thus to make the ' Extracts,' with the comments by her own fascinating pen, more living and interesting. I should like to conjure up her portrait as I recall her best in late years, sitting, book in hand, pencil and note-book by her side, in her favourite little blue drawing-room at Aston Clinton. ' It seemed to me a sort of shrine, 1 wrote Lord Rosebery, ' and a centre from which radiated goodness and sympathy.'' From her chair she could see across the lawn, where the venerable yew-tree spreads its heavy branches, and she could watch the many birds, large and small, from the lordly pheasant to the tiny tom-tit, that came hopping up to her windows for their daily food. Then her gaze would travel to an open space, purposely cleared for her in a group of trees, dividing the lawn from the park, where cows and sheep were placidly grazing, and still further on she would get a glimpse of the ' grey, square church tower ' and of ' the red roof of her own village school. 1 A homely scene, indeed, a quiet picture of English country life — a scene, to quote my mother's own words, that ' she had looked on for many a year, that she knew as it were by heart, and yet that always presented itself in some new aspect. 1 Such a landscape as is not un- common, but to her its quiet beauty meant a great deal. It meant home life, in its fullest, deepest, most precious sense ; it also meant village life — that is to say, outside, wider interests. It meant pre-eminently work for others, unselfish, constant work, that only ended when life on earth ended. 22 PREFACE. It will be seen that this book mainly consists of extracts from my mother's favourite authors (some- times merely titles of books), together with comments of her own, to which are added a few short passages from her diaries. (1) A mention of Queen Victoria's Jubilee in 1897 ; and of a visit from King Edward VII., when he was Prince of Wales, in the same year. (2) Of personages connected with statesmanship, literature, and art. (3) Of politics, as showing that my mother retained her liberal sympathies until the very end of her life. (4) Of the Franco-Prussian War, 1870, and the Boer War, 1899-1902, which called forth her expres- sions of grave anxiety and distress. I have also inserted a paragraph about a favourite little dog of my mother's, showing her intense affection for her constant companions. There are many other such passages throughout her diaries, all very touching to those who knew her. Constance Battersea. 1912. 23 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. I860. Michelet's 'Louis XIV.' A curious, but often most unpleasing volume. What a picture of depravity, of bigotry and cruelty is the great and generally considered most glorious reign in the French history ! Neither indecent details of court intrigues, nor horrible accounts of the relentless and savage persecutions of the Protestants, are spared the reader, who arises indignant and sickened by the perusal of the horrible deeds committed under the rule and often by the command of this great monarch. Miehelefs style is eloquent, terse, but sometimes so condensed as to be somewhat confused and difficult to understand. June %8th. Wolff's 'Travels and Adventures.' Dr. Wolff is an honest enthusiast, excessively vain and extraordinarily credulous. His adventures related by himself, in the third person, are extremely amusing. Aston Clinton, September QSrd. 25 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Sainte Marie Madelaine. Par Lacordaire. Very eloquent nonsense. Strange that such a book should be written by such a man in the nineteenth century. Aston Clinton, October. The Arrest of the Five Members by Charles I. in 1641-42. By John Forster. The work of a very prejudiced partisan. A good article upon it in the Quarterly Review. October Z8th. The Professor at the Breakfast Table. By Oliver Wendell Holmes. Bold, quaint, but full of thought. Letters, &c. of Lord Auckland. Personal History of Lord Bacon. By Dixon. The style of the author does not inspire one with much confidence. Too flowery and dramatic and superficial for a calm, historical investigation, but still from his pages it appears to me that Bacon has been hardly judged. Had he not been so great a man, intellectu- ally so far beyond his age, his faults and shortcomings would have been looked upon as merely examples of the difference between our epoch and that in which he lived. A man who not only left such a legacy of wisdom to posterity, but was constantly employed in doing good service to his country, cannot, because he failed in some instances to rise above his contemporaries be called the Meanest of Mankind. January \§th, 1860. 26 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Motley's History of the United Netherlands. Perhaps rather too long and detailed, but very in- teresting. Elisabeth's fame is darkened and Leicester's made rather brighter in these pages. The Eastern Church. Lectures by Arthur Stanley. Great Expectations. By Dickens. The first and last volume written in his best style. Buckle's second volume. Nineteenth volume of ' L'Histoire du Consulat et de PEmpire.' By Thiers. The Early and Middle Ages of England. By Pearson. My Life, and what shall I do with it? Addressed to very independent young and old maids, consequently completely adapted to only a small circle of readers ; but containing many good and useful things. The last words of the book might often be pondered over with advantage : ' Women of wealth, women of talent, women of leisure, what are you doing in God's world for God ? ' Elsie Venner. By Oliver Wendell Holmes. Very clever, though very American. Stanley's Canterbury Sermons. The following extract, taken from the vi. sermon, is a good example of the spirit of liberality which breathes through all the volume : ' Ceremonies, customs, usages change from country to country and from age to age. They cannot be imitated, they cannot be adapted. But 27 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. good and gracious acts of love and of justice and of truth, energy surmounting all difficulties, patience en- during all hardships ; these and the like qualities of the good neighbour of the Parable are always near us, can always be repeated, can always be honoured. " Go " on thy journey, "go" on thy business, "go" home and " do " with all thy might whatsoever of good or true, in times past or times present, at home or abroad, thou hast seen or heard, " go and do likewise." ' Year by year changes gather round us. We shall not be this year as we were last year. If we remain the same the things around us change ; if things around us remain the same, yet we see those around us change, and our relative positions, thoughts, duties, feelings change with them. But one thing changes not, and that is the duty and privilege of keeping the Command- ments of God. If we have kept them before, we can keep them no less now. If the keeping of them, if the striving to keep the Commandments of God has been 'a lantern to our feet and a light to our path,"' in former times, rejoicing the heart and enlightening the eyes, so we may humbly trust that it will be still, whatever changes have befallen us, whatever changes may befall us. — Sermon xiv. Life of Pitt. By Lord Stanhope. CEuvres et Correspondance in^dites d' Alexis de Tocqueville. Deeply interesting are the letters contained in these volumes — displaying constant mental activity and pro- found reflection, with warm, affectionate feeling. 28 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. The one blemish in De TocquevihVs character appears to me to be the contempt with which he looked down upon mankind in general. The reception his books vnet with should have proved to him how many are capable of appreciating true excellence. Though an enemy to all intellectual repute, he often enjoyed the calm tranquillity of Tocqueville. In one of his letters he mentions the happiness he finds in his country retreat, and then says, * Cest encore avoir Fame agitee que de jouir passionnement de la paix. Tel est en ce moment mon cas." 1 1862. Chateaubriand et son Groupe Litteraire. Par Sainte Beuve. Astm aint0Jh ^1^^, Felix Mendelssohn's ' Reisebriefe.' How simple, fresh, childlike, poetical and affectionate must have been the spirit that dictated these letters ! London, May 31. Gravenhurst ; or, Thoughts on Good and Evil. By Smith. A difficult, possibly an insurmountably difficult subject eloquently treated, though perhaps in rather a superficial, or, at least, in two brief a manner. The conclusion at which the author arrives is the satisfactory one, that good and evil are necessary ingredients in the progress and happiness of the world, and that the latter, though constantly changing and diminishing, must always co- exist with what we can understand at present of freedom 29 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. of will, and will ever continue to be the greatest incen- tive to the highest virtues, the noblest deeds and the active energies of mankind. ' I think it well to see that it is by overcoming evil, as well moral evil as natural evil, that we rise in the scale of creation. This very fact convinces us that evil was not brought here otherwise than beneficently — is in fact part of the scheme of a benevolent Creator. This may aid us, too, in supporting manfully the unavoidable, and in combating manfully all remediable evils. He who seeks truth and loves goodness has God upon his side. 1 London, July 27th. Literary Remains of Mrs. Trench. Another example of a good and clever woman being the mother of a distinguished man. The qualities and talents only half developed in the woman, partially concealed perhaps in domestic life or really shorn or clouded by delicate health and the daily round of petty household cares — those qualities and talents reappear in man, and, flourishing in a genial soil, bring forth lasting fruit. Aston Clinton, September \Sth. Fifth volume of Guizot's ' Memoirs.' Interesting as it relates to living characters and to well-known incidents ; but how small do many events now appear, that caused such agitation and labour only twenty years ago. What an immense deal of writing, talking and intriguing about the Syrian question ! England triumphed, but Turkey remained equally weak and tottering. Aston Clinton, September 18th. 30 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Correspondence of Leigh Hunt. A vein of tender and even religious, as well as of poetical feeling, runs through all Hunt's letters. How tender and kind a husband and father they show him to be, how faithful and good a friend ! September 28th. One of the great uses of Art is to teach us how to look into Nature. Here is the same idea much better expressed from the Cornhill Magazine, June 1862 : — 'Moreover the mere physical aspect of things be- comes clearer to many of us in a picture than in the reality. A man who has walked about his fields for twenty years sees them painted by Gainsborough and then begins to understand them. . . . The original, whether in Nature or in Human Nature, is so vaguely great : we want a neat precise translation without too much of that restless, palpitating life, which distracts our senses and makes our thoughts a dream.'' June \st. A song, a song! The dull to rouse, the sad to cheer, To waken smiles, to chase the tear A song, a song ! A song, a song ! Now full of glee, elf-like and wild, Strange measure of some mountain child, A song, a song ! 31 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. A song, a song ! A simple, sweet, old-fashioned ditty That gently pleads for love and pity ; A song, a song ! No song, no song ! That tender voice, that artless lay Are stealing fast my heart away : No song, no song ! L. DE R. Life of Washington Irving. First and second vol- umes, composed principally of his letters. They are the productions of a kind, generous and genial man, and contain indications of the humour and pathos found in his writings, more of the former than of the latter. One must esteem and like the author of those simple yet gracefully penned letters which abound in good and affectionate feelings, but I do not think they give evidence of much power or originality of mind. October 12th. Owen, a Waif. One of the most interesting novels I have read for a long time. The story is very, indeed most, improbable, but the writing is simple and vigorous, the characters are Avell drawn and the lessons conveyed, without any preaching, by the tale itself, are great and pure. October 28th. On The Origin of Species. By Darwin. A theory strange and ingenious with apparently, how- ever, many cogent reasons on its side which fascinate, at least, the unlearned reader. 32 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. We follow the author with interest and pleased surprise whilst he attempts to show how species grow, as it were, out of varieties, the latter becoming more and more distinct by the process of Natural Selection, until, after the lapse of ages, they bear but a faint resemblance to the ancestors from whom they sprang. By inheritance or community of descent is explained the similarity of pattern in members of the same class, the natural system of classification being a genealogical arrangement, and likewise the existence so often met with of rudimentary or useless organs and the resem- blance of the embryos of distinct animals. We are, however, rudely startled when we find that man can form no exception in Darwin's theory, that he can boast no higher parentage than any other Mammalia, and that his mind and reason have merely been developed by the all-powerful effects of Natural Selection. Aston Clinton, October %9tk. Religio Chemici. These Essays by George Wilson are extremely inter- esting, written with much true religious feeling and practical thought. They convey also considerable in- struction in a clear, pleasant manner. 1863. * Let no cry be heard. Crush the escaping groan on the yet quivering lips of the desires thou hast strangled. Uncover not the pale faces of thy departed. Utter not their names aloud. Know thyself and bear to be 33 D LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. unknown. Strike down this beggar heart that prowls for alms and stops men's pity in the public place. Justify the whole endeavour in the perfect deed. Slay thyself and hide the knife. Even so, and as, in large compassion of fond eyes, young graves set grieving, kind nature makes much haste to cast over the hillocks of the recent dead her grassy carpet of the tender green ; so silently and for others' sakes with such a noble haste do thou, too, hide beneath the serenity of a smiling face the sorrow of thine immortal soul ! , — The Ring of Amasis, by Owen Meredith. Aston Clinton. Life of Father Mathew. Life of Burke. Life of William Blake. Seventh and eighth volumes of Froude's ' History.' Less paradoxical and one-sided than his former volumes — beautifully written and full of interest, but some- what too long. His materials, foreign letters, des- patches, &c. not sufficiently digested and made part of the narrative. Hard Cash. By Charles Reade. Full of talent and of absurdity, of beauty and of hideous exaggerations. Enough material for half-a-dozen no\ els. Life of Theodore Parker. Rather too much spun out — the style of the author a bad imitation of that of Parker himself. 34 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. 1864. Perishes, Maximes et Correspondance de Joubert. Still very interesting from the genius, the worth, the nobility, the originality of the subject of the Memoir. He was a great thinker and also great in deeds of beneficence, kindness and mercy. Though his words were often burning, and his indignation and wrath against injustice, fanaticism and intolerance full of bitter sarcasm, there was an immense deal of tenderness in his nature displayed in a variety of ways — in his love for children and his almost passionate fondness for flowers — a nosegay always bloomed upon the table from which he preached. Aston Clinton, September. Histoire Elementaire et Critique de J6sus. Par A. Peyrat. The very opposite of Renan, a sort of French Colenso. Mr. Peyrat displays the same cold, pitiless good sense as the Bishop of Natal, and proves how improbable, nay, how impossible are the various narrations contained in the Gospels. I naturally agree with his view of the New Testament, but is it not strange that the world should owe the greatest strides it has made in civiliza- tion, morality, and, to use one of Parker's words, the humanities of life, to a falsehood and an illusion ? what great truth must not have been wrapped up in those fables. Aston Clinton, September 3Qth. 35 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Broken Light. By Frances Power Cobbe. A disciple of Theodore Parker, Miss Cobbe follows in his track with great power, eloquence and clearness. The following is a sort of resume of her faith : Re- ligious Faith, in its high, true sense, faith in the presence of a Heavenly Father, is a thing which God gives, not in answer to studies and researches, but to prayers and deeds. It is a thing which the clearest mind may lack, and the humblest heart possess in fullest measure. It is a thing which we can only gain by prayer, only keep by obedience. There is no winning it by argument, no preserving it by force of logic in a life of sin. ... Is it not fitting that the highest and divinest of all gifts should be attainable to all God's children, whether learned or ignorant, wise or dull, if only they be upright, good and true of heart ? September 30th. Tractatus Theologico Politicus. By Spinoza. A critical Inquiry into the History, Purpose and Authenticity of the Hebrew Scriptures. This appears to me the fountain-head of all the criticisms on the Bible, the arsenal from which present free-thinkers have taken many of their weapons. Here are some of the conclusions at which Spinoza arrives : — ' We have shown that Scripture does not teach philo- sophy, but piety ; and that the whole contents of the Bible are accommodated to the capacity and precon- ceived opinions of the vulgar As in the nature of things that dogma, which, to one is pious and profit- able, is to another impious and profitless ; therefore are 36 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. all dogmas to be judged by their effects, by the works they produce, by the lives and conversations to which they lead Nor shall I now shrink from specifying the heads of an universal faith, which are also the fundamental dogmas of Scripture. They are these : — There is a Supreme Being, who delights in justice and mercy, whom, all who would be saved, are bound to obey, and whose worship consists in the practice of justice and charity towards our neighbour. 1 Fireside Travels. By Russell Lowell. A quaint, prettily written book, addressed to ' Story ' and somewhat in his style, but more thoughtful and vigorous. November 21th. Lectures on the Science of Language. Second Series. By Max Muller. 'The names given by the early framers of language repose chiefly on wit and fancy — thus " wheat " was called " the white plant " (Sanskrit " sveta, 11 white). In Sanskrit "silver" is counted white and called " Sveta. 11 " Sarit, 11 meaning " goer 11 from " sar 11 = to go, became the name of "river. 11 "Sara" was used for " sap. 11 The Latin " aevum, 11 meaning " going," became the name of "time, age," and its derivative, " aetemus," was made to express " eternity." That on which a thing stands is called its " base," and " basis " in Greek meant no more than going, the ground on which it is safe to walk. The moon was called " luna " from hmus = " the shining ; " the stars " stellse " from Sanskrit " the strewers of light." ' 37 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. 1866. On the Origin of Language. By E. B. Tylor. (F. R.) ' Every one recognizes the fact that certain expressions of face, as well as certain inter jectional sounds, corre- spond to certain feelings, but it is not thus generally recognized that there is a real connection between the expression of the face and the sound which comes from it. The human body is, among other things, an instru- ment for producing vocal sounds, and the different attitudes of mouth, cheeks, &c, which belong to different feelings of the mind, modify the position of the vocal organs, and thereby the sounds uttered. 1 The above might explain many interjectional cries from which various words owe their origin. The old and weary wish for the ' wings of a Dove ' to fly away and be at rest ; the young who are sad and distressed, would rather be carried away by the wings of the swallow to new scenes and sunny climes. To the young there is Hope, to the old only Repose. June 20th. Les Apotres. By Erxest Renan. Ecce Homo. The Philosophical Works of Henry St. John, Viscount Bolingbroke. La Revolution. Par Edgar Qtjinet. Ninth and tenth volumes of Froude's ' History of England.' 38 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. The Gay Science. By Dallas. Always suggestive, and brilliant at times. The ' Gay Science 1 leaves no very clear impression on the mind. According to Mr. Dallas, the aim of Art is pleasure, and the criticism of Art consequently, if it be a Science, the Science of pleasure, but it is just in that Science that he appears to me to be least explicit. 1867. Memoirs of George III. By Jesse. ' Our birth is but a sleep and a forgetting, The soul that rises with us, our life's star Hath had elsewhere its setting, And cometh from afar ; Not in entire forgetfulness, And not in utter nakedness, But trailing clouds of glory do we come From God, who is our home.'' Wordsworth. Adam and the Adamite or the Harmony of Scrip- ture and Ethnology. By Dominick McCausland. Mr. McCausland has made for himself a theory, and, as usual, finds what he looks for in the Bible. In the Scripture account of the Creation and Deluge he sees nothing that conflicts with Science. The Deluge was but a partial flood, and Adam was not the first man, but the first of a new race of men quite distinct from that of the Negro or Mongol already in existence. The Reign of Law. By the Duke of Argyll. 39 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. 1867. The old year was rapidly approaching its end and the bells rang merrily, but the wind mocked their joyous notes and sighed and wailed. At one moment the glad sound reached my ear — the next, it was lost in a dismal chant — the angry shrieking and plaintive sobbing of the wind — prophesying, as it were, wickedness and sor- row, misfortune and disaster. But in the midst of the wild mournful turmoil came again the merry chime ; did it foretell the happy days that awaited us intermingled with many dark and sad ones ? The golden threads that fate was weaving upon a sable ground ? I tried not to hear the wind and only listened to the bells, with a half- superstitious dread of the former — but alas ! the wind was near and around me, making the trees groan and shake by its rough handling — and the bells seemed so far away ! Still the hopeful peal rose ever and anon above the blast, like the voice of human sympathy, or the mercy of our God ! And the raging wind could not completely drown it. For an hour I listened with an aching heart to the war of the wind and the bells, then the storm subsided, and the bells ceased likewise. The overture had been played out, and the New Year began. Aston Clinton, Jammry. There is a light well known to us, for it is the light which visits us at morning and evening, making the day begin and end in beauty, which has the magic power of imparting its own loveliness to all it shines upon. It idealises the commonest things, and the fairest look doubly fair under its soft yet glowing 40 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. radiance ; it turns the dull, grey clouds into gold, stone into marble, it gives a brighter gleam to the jewel and lends a glory to the little wayside flower. How much death resembles this beauty-giving light ! Those it touches with its ice-cold hand lose in an instant their earthly stains and imperfections, and appear to us altogether good and beautiful, and every incident, however trifling, connected with them, is taken from the category of passing events and becomes full of meaning and interest. A halo is thrown around them, they are canonised by death. Whilst here they were poor mortals like ourselves, but death has unfolded their wings, and as, alas ! they soar away from us they be- come transformed not only in the present but in the past. They were angels then and now. Time is like the policeman whose rude office it is to make poor loiterers move on. The houseless wanderer has found a sheltered nook, or a patch of warm sun- light, or only a stone step where he would so willingly sit down and rest were it only for a few moments, but the inexorable policeman cries, ' Move on ; move on. 1 And the stern necessity of ever moving on, of constant change, is likewise the inexorable law of all human beings, of all living things. 1870. Lectures and Philosophical Remains of Professor Ferrier. Institutes of Metaphysic. By Ferrier. Powerfully written and reasoned with great clearness. 41 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. ' Society we must have, but let it be Society and not exchanging news or eating from the same dish. 1 — Society and Solitude, by Emerson. February. We emerge from the Inane, haste stormfully across the astonished earth ; then plunge again into the Inane. . . . But whence, O Heaven, whither? Sense knows not ; Faith knows not ; only that it is through Mystery to Mystery." — Sartor Resartus, by Carlyle. Reading 'The Cloister and the Hearth' and Kingsley's ' Christmas in the West Indies.' Full of beautiful and interesting descriptions of Nature. September 15th. 'The benefits of affection are immense and the one event which never loses its romance is the encounter with superior persons on terms allowing the happiest intercourse. 1 — Society and. Solitude, by Emerson. The country seems strangely quiet considering what is going on abroad ; war more horrible in this en- lightened, civilized age, than it has almost ever shown itself. The Emperor a prisoner ; the Empire a thing of the past, and France a Republic. Much alarmed for our relatives at Paris. September. 1871. Peace seems now about to be concluded ; but, alas ! how long will misery and mourning outlast the war that has occasioned them ! 42 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. ' La saintete de cette vie est dans le travail et dans la peine. 1 — Penseeft, par Boirdaloue. Reading Hawthorne's Note Books. Full of thoughtful and suggestive passages. He had not much knowledge of art; but here and there his deep poetic temperament seemed kindled by some picture or statue, and he would describe them with enthusiasm. The Venus de Medici and Michael Angelo's statue of Lorenzo de Medici appear to have produced more effect upon him than any other work of art. ' What greater thing is there for two human souls than to feel that they are joined for life to strengthen each other in all labours, to rest on each other in all sorrow, to minister to each other in all pain, to be one with each other in silent, unspeakable memories at the moment of the last parting. 1 Adam Bede, by George Eliot. 1872. If you are descending a river with a strong current, a little breeze blowing in a contrary direction will hardly retard the progress of the boat, or be felt by the passengers ; and so in life, if we are much engrossed with one great thought or grief, with an ardent hope or fear, a thousand little ills and pleasures, disappoint- ments and vexations, will pass without affecting us in more than a very slight degree ; the current is speeding us on, and we hardly feel the wind that is playing around us. To the really good man, that current is Faith and trust in all that is good and holy, the love 43 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. of God leading him on to blessed deeds ; but often it is some absorbing sorrow or regret, or maybe a ray of hope, which, though far away, shines still on some distant spot of our earthly horizon. Jidy 91st. Made the acquaintance of Berthold Auerbach ; he was extremely amiable and is very easy to get on with, evidently a vain but kind and generous man ; common- looking, with a stout, short figure, but a fine brow and bright eye. He talked of himself, his works, his friends from monarchs downwards, he repeated his bon-mots and repartees ; but still he seemed interested in others and anxious to give pleasure. Cadenabbia, September. Finished • Deutsche Liebe.' A truly charming little tale, prettily written with some pretty thoughts, but rather thin and shadowy. Bead a pretty story of Auerbaeh's, 'Die Stief- mutter.' 1 Ueber alien Gipfeln 1st Ruh\ In alien Wipfeln Spurest du Kaum einen Hauch ; Die Voglein schweigen im Walde, Warte nur, balde Ruhest du auch ! 1 — Goethe. ' What a blessing it is to mortals, what a kindness of Providence, that life is made so uncertain, that death is thrown in among the possibilities of our being ; that these awful mysteries are thrown around us into which 44 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. we may vanish ! For without it how would it be possible to be heroic ; how should we plod along in common places for ever, never dreaming high things, never risking anything ? 1 By Nathaniel Hawthorne. 1873. Beading ' Memoirs of Baron Bunsen.' A real German, hard-working, yet somewhat mystical ; he was an excellent man, following through his busy, well-filled life the highest and noblest aspirations. In religious matters he tried to combine modern criticism and ancient faith, perfect freedom with the Christian dogma. Many-sided in his views and feelings, he seemed to make friends among the good and great in every camp. March Si-d. Enigmas of Life. By W. R. Greg. Very well written ; result of much thought, but the Enigmas remain Enigmas still. The great riddles, the mysterious perplexities of life are not — apparently cannot be — solved or made clear. Fortunately, there is no diffi- culty in seeing what we are required to do. Though we cannot see God, the path He has marked out for us is visible to us all. Though we cannot know Him, we can read His will and His laws in conscience, history and nature. Literature and Dogma. By Matthew Arnold. A remarkable book, showing, as the author says, the powerful influence of the ' Zeit Geist ' which allows 45 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. him to write so boldly, and to attack without the least reserve the long-received dogmas of religion. Experi- ence and reason are his only guides to faith, and these lead him to recognise an eternal Power that makes for Righteousness — or more fully perhaps — 'the Eternal Power, not ourselves, by which all things fulfil the law of their being."' There is, it appears to me, a want of clearness about the 'Power not ourselves, which makes for righteous- ness 1 — a t times it is spoken of as all we can positively know of the Deity — at times it seems to melt away into a mere tendency, or a system of laws without any lawyer. As such it is not what the Bible appears to teach, to proclaim, the One Holy Spirit to be obeyed, loved and worshipped. Is it not, as presented by the author, too impal- pable and shadowy to be our ' Refuge, our present help in trouble, 1 our Father, our Judge and our Redeemer ? Animals and their Masters. By the Author of ' Friends in Council.' Very pleasant reading, like all the books of Helps. Per- haps somewhat too discursive to leave any very definite impression on the mind — or rather many definite ideas. The author is quite right in what he says about cruelty to animals being generally caused by want of knowledge about them and defective power of imagination— two defects, which should be specially considered, in the education of the people. 46 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Much interested in 'Die Kinder der Welt,' by Auerbach. It is beautifully written, and though a novel with a pur- pose, not in the least dull. There are parts of it rather too much spun out, and it has the fault which all novels have — written to prove either a theory, or to destroy one — that the story is moulded by the author to sub- stantiate his views. Consequently one is always inclined to take up the other side of the question, and instead of enjoying the novel, dispute its truth. In ' Die Kinder der Welt ' it is religious belief of every kind which is attacked — not harshly or angrilv — but calmly and coolly treated as being legendary and imaginative, more or less hurtful to the human race, which has now outgrown the age of fables ! The charac- ters described in ' Die Kinder der Welt ' are with one exception all not only excellent, but generally happy, tho'' there is no Holy One that leads them to righteous- ness — no hope of immortality to gild their hereafter ; their religion is made to appear, if harmless, at least perfectly useless to Mankind. May. Just finished Mrs. Grote's ' Life ' of her Husband. There is a want of tenderness and delicate affection in the writer, but she has given us an interesting Memoir of the Historian, who was as simple and courteous in his man- ner as he was learned and profound. Devoted to his- torical and philosophical studies, he had but little love for the beauties of nature, and was eminently happy when leading the life of a laborious student among his books and a few congenial friends, such as J. S. Mill and Sir G. C. Lewis. July 3rd. 47 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Visitors : — Mr. Story,* Mr. Motley : f both very pleasant as well as very clever — also Mr. Frederick Locker. 1 July 6th, Sunday. Head Lord Houghton's Essay on Walter Savage Landor. Very interesting and well written. Must read again some of his (Landor's) magnificent prose and thought- laden poetry. His love for flowers, which would not allow him to pick them, appears in the following lines : — ' And 'tis and ever was my wish and way, To let all flowers live freely, and all die — Whene'er their genius bids their soul depart — Among their kindred, in their native place. I never pluck the rose, the violet's head Hath shaken with my breath upon its bank, And not reproached me. The tiny sacred cup Of the pure lily hath between my hands Felt safe, unsoiled, nor lost one grain of gold. 1 Finished the first volume of • R6cit d'une Scaur.' § These, indeed, are the darkest of earthly shadows, but they cannot dim the light of hope and love and religious fervency which illumine its pages — a light borrowed possibly from humanly-lighted fires, but God must have * W. W. Story, the well-known American sculptor, also author of Roba di Roma. f John Lothrop Motley, the distinguished author of The Dutch Republic, and the Life and Death of John Barneveldt, &c. % Charming writer of verse, and very pleasant talker, author of London Lyrics. § By Mrs. Augustus Craven. 48 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. given the fuel and have made the flame possible though the igniting spark may not have descended from heaven. In self-forgetting love, in devotion, fervour and aspira- tions towards the Eternal, the Perfect, the Ideal, there must be something Divine, whether they spring from Catholicism, Protestantism, or Judaism. July 19th. Continued 'Le Rdcit d'une Soeur.' One long description of death-beds — not the least wearisome, however, because true, and after all what is there in life that comes home to us so much and interests us all so deeply as death ? August 1st. Reading ' Bath Archives ' and Moscheles' ' Leben.' Both gossipy and amusing books. Moscheles appear.^ in his wife's interesting Memoirs as a thoroughly kind, amiable man, an excellent husband, father and friend. The most interesting parts of the two volumes are those which relate to Mendelssohn — the beaming, tender, graceful genius — Moscheles 1 early pupil and lasting friend. August 6th. Reading ' Life of Sterling,' by Carlyle, which Henry Fitz Roy gave me more than twenty years ago at Brighton. Strange that I should be reading it here for the second time, as a guest of my dear niece Blanche.* . . . Balcarres is certainly very romantic, the old grey buildings, the grand trees, extended view and Italian gardens give it a sort of poetical picturesqueness, which the English places I know do not possess. September, Balcarres. * Lady Lindsay. 49 E LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Bead • Lucian ' in the ' Ancient Classics for English Readers.' A very entertaining little volume. It is curious that writing more than a century after Christ — he was born about a.d. 120 — he should hardly ever allude to Christianity, particularly as in his Dialogues of the Gods and other of his works, he satirises the various systems of philosophy taught at that time. Once he mentions Christians by name, and classes them with Atheists and Epicureans. ... In another place, speaking of Christians, he says : ' You know they still reverence that great man, him that was crucified in Palestine for introducing these new doctrines into the world. 1 October. Read the ' Autobiography of John Stuart Mill.' Extremely interesting. There was much poetry and feeling in the logician and Political Economist ; but I was struck with one strange omission, in his Auto- biography — the man who declared he owed not only his happiness but so much of his mental culture to his wife, and on her account respected and looked up to woman in general, never even mentions the name of his own mother ! Began Adam Smith's ' Wealth of Nations,' which I find very interesting, though occasionally, to my shame, I do not understand him. October 21st. 50 LADY DE ROTHSCHILD. Read the first part of ' Sara Coleridge.' Her letters are charming, full of thought, of clever criticisms, and of sound sense, with occasional poetical descriptions. Finished the second and, I regret to say, last volume of Sara Coleridge's Letters. In the latter part of her life how much broader she becomes in her religious, or rather theological views ! Here is one very liberal confession : — ' My own belief is that the whole logical truth is not in the possession of any one party , (I would substitute or add the word faith), ' that it exists in fragments amongst the several parties and that much of it is yet to be developed. 1 December 4