Law Lib. 
 SB 
 
 25.72 
 St99 
 
 '^t 
 
 
 ^»
 
 From the Library of 
 Professor David Mellinkoff 
 
 Who donated his collection 
 
 TO THE 
 
 UCLA School of Law 
 
 Hugh & Hazel Darling 
 
 Law Library 
 
 August 1999 
 
 "Cleansed of words without reason, much 
 of the language of the law need not be 
 peculiar at all. and better for it." 
 
 The Language of the Law 
 BY David Mellinkoff
 
 V. I O^siH 
 
 ^A^<^^ O 
 
 \ t\^i (i^ v^^JU
 
 ORMODERN 
 
 REPORTS 
 
 Berlin in the now ;^}ot^Suy: />1'- t^»A 
 
 UPPER BENCH cduf T 
 
 AT 
 
 VVESTMINSrER 
 
 i In the bcs^innins; of Hillary Term 2.1 CaroU , and conti-j 
 nued to the end o\ Mkhatlmas Term 165 5. as well on the Cnmi- 
 nall, as on the Pleas fide. 
 
 Moft of which time the late Lord Chief Juftice %oll gave 
 
 the Rule there. 
 
 With neccdary Tables for the ready findingoutand making ule'ofthe 
 matters contained in tlie whole Book. 
 
 And an Addition of the Number Rolls to moft of the re- 
 markable Cafes. 
 
 B» William Style ofth Inner Temple Efquite. 
 
 Mt finguh prcjhn^oitOj precor. 
 
 Nam Genui et proaVos if qud non faimus ipji, 
 Fixea nojlra ^oco. Ovid: Metamoiph. lib. 1 3. 
 
 LONDON, 
 
 Printed by F.L. hrJ^KLce.V.Ta^eman.qMel^aai.^ 
 
 CiAiiamSySind arc to be fold at their fliops in | 
 
 Fleetjlreet. i6^S. \
 
 1^
 
 To the Honourable 
 
 lOHN PARKER! 
 
 One of the 
 
 B A R O N S 
 
 Of his Highnefs the 
 
 LORD PROTECTORS 
 
 C O V R T 
 
 OF THE 
 
 Publique Exchequer: 
 
 JN purfuance cxf what I not long 
 fince intimated in the clofe of the 
 Epiftle Dedicatory prefixed to 
 my Pradical Regifler; and in 
 hopes of as favourable an acceptance of this 
 tender of my refpec5tfull fervice, as you then 
 pleafedto afford my weak endeavours, am 
 I now encouraged to make this my feqond 
 
 humble
 
 The Epijlle Dedicatory, 
 
 Kilmble adrefs.Though this be but a yonger 
 brother, in refpect of its time of production, 
 yet in reference to its firft conception, 
 orowih,6cparts,l may juAIy fay,it far excels 
 the elder biith, and is much more fit to do 
 your Honour, and thePubhque,fervice,and 
 may be(^I conceive)capable ofaslargc,ifnot 
 of a£;reatermeafure of your favour and pro- 
 tection. I will notbetroublefome toyou 
 in relating the pains (Sc time I have taken and 
 fpent in this Collection and Publication,but 
 {lial leave it to your judicious confideration. 
 How great foever they have been I repent 
 me not, but am (^ inmyfelf) abundant- 
 ly fatisfied, and do think it reward enough, 
 that I have thereby gained this opportuni- 
 ty to fliew my continuing humble refpedls 
 to your Honour , and my wiUingnefs to be 
 fome way (erviceable to others, whatever I 
 have been to my felf Q'm that Vocation God 
 hath of his goodnefs been pleafed to place 
 me in) and to give an Accompt to the 
 Worid (a thing, which I hold every good 
 Chriftian is bound to do) of theexpence 
 of my time. 
 
 It may be objedled, that the Prefs hath 
 been very fertile in thisour /\ge, and hath 
 brought forth many, ifnot too many births 
 of this nature. 1 mufl: confefs this Truth; 
 but how legitimate mofl of them are, let the 
 Learned judgetThis I am fure of^there is not 
 
 a
 
 The Epi/lle dedicatory. 
 
 a father alive to own many of them, and 
 ihey fpcak fo plain in the Langu;igeL of 
 Jffjdodj that a knowing-man cannot heiieve-''^'- ^j ^-^-i. 
 they ever fprung from Ifraehti/I) ^Pzrtnts , 
 but by their pronouncing of Stboletb infleed/,,.^ ,. .j ^ 
 oi Skiholethr, may evilly collect of what ex- 
 trad: they are. What I here prefentyou 
 with, is, ("though a Homely, yet) a lawfull 
 ]irae,and 1 dare call it mine ov/n, and that 
 (I believe) I may do with as good a fight as 
 any evermightawoik oftheJjke nature, ha- 
 ving had as little (if notlefs) afsiflance from 
 others in the bringing it forth , as any that 
 have travelled in this kind before me, I am 
 not fo blindly fond , or fo opiniaflre as to 
 think it free from Errors and Mifprifions, I 
 fear there may too many be found in it^ and 
 no wonder, for HunianvmeU err are ^ Ithi^ de- 
 cipi; yet this I do knowingly aver, that I have 
 not (hcrtin) ex propofio or willingly injured 
 any; but have been as ftud'ous and careful! 
 in the penning of thi.^ my CollecTiion to do 
 right ro every perfon concerned, and co 
 make the Truth appear clearly in its native 
 colours,as was pofsiblc at a throngued Bar to 
 do. Nor have i been lefs wanting in my 
 befl endeavours, to prevent and correct the 
 Errors of the Prefs, ( though Imuft ac- 
 knowledge my pains and Cure are not herein 
 fully anlwered) that it might appear in pub- 
 lick
 
 The Efijlle Dedicatory, 
 
 Jick, though not in fo rich a Drefs as to be a 
 Companion for the beft, yet (at leaft^be by 
 your favour fullered to pafs ( astoUerable ) 
 smidft the crowd of a multitude of Editions, 
 cloathed in as ill if not in a worfe and more 
 unbefeeming habit. 
 
 Inner Temple J May . Sir, lam yrurs mofl 
 
 the 1 7 f fe. 1 6 5 8 . ob'i^eJj re/petlivdy 
 
 to/erVeyou 
 
 W I LLi AM Style. 
 
 To
 
 To the IndusiriouSj and Ingenuous T^rofefjor^^ and 
 
 S indent: of the Common La"^! c/Englandj hut more pMrticti' 
 larlyj and ajfetlimatel) to the JJJociates oj the honour able Society 
 ofthelnnet Temple. 
 
 GENTLEMEN. 
 
 FOr a more noble Epitliitc I know not how to give you (the 
 areattft gibcil otmcn on carjh being in trum no more.) 
 Triclc enfuing Reports were at hrii bra Ay taken by mc in 
 the Law-trencii, witiioucany thought of making other ufe 
 ot"thcm,then for my ^k privat latisfadion , And tlicy 
 did for fome time alter lyc'^fo tonfufedly fcatiered in my 
 Note-books, that as they then lay, they were altogether ufelcfTc to 
 ■ any but my ieli, and that not without much cxpencc of time and 
 great trouble, fo that what of them my unhappy memory could not 
 retain, (which was not much)was in a manner loft as wel to my felf, 
 as unto other?; to remedy this inconvenicnce5( if I may fo call it, ) 
 of the lo{fe ot my conltant attendance,& pains tor fo manyyears to- 
 gether takjen at the row uppcrBench.Bar,with very lidc profit cither 
 to others or my felf,than lome fmall improvement ot my knowledge 
 in the praftical partofthe law, and in purfuance of that anticnt 
 Moral Axiomc, Omneager.s aoit propter aliquem fnem, I was encou- 
 raged tocontinue niy travail, and expenteof time in the gathering 
 together , tranfcribing, and putting of them into that order , and 
 method you now behold them , yet as then not having any intent or 
 dehrc to make them publiquc , but only more readily ufetuU to my 
 felf, and futh ot my Friends and Acc]uaiatance as fl^,ould at any 
 timedeilrecobe fatisfied in any thing I wasablc to impart unto 
 them. But this not anfwering the expedation , and importunities 
 offomeotmy necr relations, and many of my incimarc Friends 
 and Acc]uaintance , nor knowing into whofe hands my papers 
 might tall , nor how my felf and others be injured in the 
 publilliing ot them after my deccafc, which I was unccrcain when it 
 might happen , and did beheve it could not be many years off, by 
 realbn of my declining years j but more etpccialiy in r'efped of the 
 weak and crafy con (f itution ot my Body much macerated by iTiarp , 
 and tedious ficknefles, and being willing to leave fome tetkimony 
 behind me,that I have not flighted, or whcly ncgkdfed my calling, 
 but have ever had an honourable elbeemot it,though Ihave hitherto 
 reaped but little oftbat benefit, which too too many do fo eagerly 
 hunt after, but have been doing fomething therein, and have not 
 lived altogether a drone for to many years together in to tjamous a 
 Society amidft lb many learned men, to thediflionour ditrcof , and 
 tomyonereproach-,1 did at laflrelblve(notwithftanding the unavoi- 
 dable cenfuresjwhich 1 was confident I fliould meet wuhal,what e- 
 ver I havcjor could fay to avoid thero,)to give way to this publicati- 
 
 A on
 
 To the Profcflbrs, and Students 
 
 on of thcnijcvcn in this age, wherein moll of the Cafes, and matters 
 herein reported are yet iirefli ( I (appofe ) in the memories of ma- 
 ny, who may eallly trace me where ever I fk-p awry j But I hope 
 to find them not only juft in vindicating of me, in that which I have 
 trucly and faithfully reported , but alio favourable in cenfuring, 
 and palfing by thofe flips and mifprifions they may herein meet 
 withalljcaufed either by the Printers negligence, or my own mif- 
 apprehenfion of the fenfe of the matters, and things delivered and 
 fpoken unto, and the rather, in regard that I have endeavoured as 
 ncer as I could to render things in the fame exprelTions they were 
 firrt uttered , that fo I might as much as might be, avoid the danger 
 ofinjunngofany herein concerned, by putting another (enfc upon 
 them, than what they intenaed ; and this as it was the old way , fo 
 I conceive what ever may be objcited to the contrary, that it is the 
 belV, and clcereft way ot reporting. For thofe, that make it their 
 bull ncfle to cenfure,.and not to read or underfland books, I fliall fay 
 nothing to them, but leave them to abound in their one Icnle if they 
 have any, and to pleafe themfelves with their own phanfics. I 
 have made thefe Reports fpcak En^lifli, not that I believe they will 
 be thereby generally more ufeiull, fori have been always, and 
 yet am of opinion, that that part ot the Common Law which is in 
 Englifli hath only occafioned the making of unquiet fpirits contcn- 
 tioufly knowing , and more apt to offend others , than to defend 
 themfelves J butlliavedone it in obedinece to authority, and to 
 Hop the mouths of fuch of this Englifh age, who though they be as 
 confufcdiy different in their Minds and ludgements , as the builders 
 oi Babel were in their languages, yet do think it vain, if not impious 
 lolpeakorundcrftandmore than their own mother-tongue. Some 
 may peradventure, Notwithltanding thcreafons 1 have formerly 
 offered tor this my publication, be ready to objeft that it was vain, 
 glory, and a tooconfidcnt boldneffc, and high conceiptof mineown 
 abilities that makes me thus appear in publiquej but thofe that 
 know me I believe are of another opinion, and dare clear me of 
 this afpcrfion , and well they may, for thetruth isIhavcaUvayes 
 been, and yet amfo naturally diftrultiulofmy own parts, that I tall 
 far fhort of that neceffary boldnefle which is requifite for every man 
 to be armed withall m the excercifing of publique employments, 
 and what loffe I have fuifered by the vvant of tins, I my felt do bcft 
 know, and is rot unknown to many,fome of whom have out ot their 
 well-wi£hes to me , and others to my difparagcment (as they 
 thought )been pleafcd to take notice of it. If any of the Cafes and 
 matters herein contcined fecm common unto any, and are to infi- 
 pid to pleafe their curious Palates, let them palfe them over : It 
 maybetheymay prove ufeluU toothers, and I doubt not but the 
 molt curious may find many tilings that may give them delight and 
 
 fatisfadion.Andin the farther vindication of thefeReports,Ifhall de- 
 fire all to take notice,that firtt,thefc were moft ot them jtaken in un- 
 fciled rimes, wherein the Law was almoft at a Hand, and therefore 
 
 ic
 
 of the Common Laws o^Ergland. 
 
 u cannot be rcaionably cxpcdcd they ihould be ib (.juick and full oi 
 matter, as thofc that have been gathered when the Laws flowed in 
 a more open, and uninterrupted Chanell , when the Courts of lu- 
 ftice were full fraught with bufinclTe, and were in a more fplendcnt 
 and flourifhing condition than in thcfe latter time? j ^nd next, that 
 this work is not a collcdion only of fomc choice Cafes taken by fe- 
 vcral hands in ail the Courts oiffefimi/jfter; but is only a continued 
 narrative of the Cafes , and proceedings of the new upper Bench 
 Court for I o years together, and taken by one only hand, without 
 the help or afliftancc of any other, during which time I have o- 
 mitted but little, faving when by reafon of fickncffe, I was for a 
 Term or two conftrained to be abfcnt. And the more to encourage 
 all to the perufall of them, I dare affirm that there is much various 
 matter contained in them3& different from what is to be found in o- 
 ther Reports taken in former years, occafioned by the many altera- 
 tion of the face of things, and the changes of government happing 
 at this time,and alfo by reafon of my conftant obferving,inferting , 
 and interweaving of all the remarkable paflages tranfaftedon the 
 Criminal fide, with thofe hapning on the Pleas fide,which in other 
 Reports hath very fparingly at any time , if at all been perfor- 
 med. I have alfo for the Readers greater eafe and benefit , added 
 hereunto three Alphabetical Tables, the firfl containing the names 
 of the feveral Cafcsj a fecond containing the feveral generalHeads , 
 or Titles under which the feveral matters difperfed through the 
 whole book, are properly (figcftedi and the third, and lafk, being a 
 large Table particularly dircding to the Page and Cafe, wherein 
 you may find the fubjed matter methodically ranged under thofe 
 Heads or Titles. And for your further and fuller fatisfa6kion , and 
 making the Cafes the cleerer proof, and morcauthentical authority 
 to be cited and given credit unto, you have the number RoUcs prc- 
 fiixcd to moft of thofe that are remarkable amongft them. 
 I might , and would if I had thought it nccdfiTary have 
 much enlarged thefe Reports , and made the volume fwell to a 
 far greater bulk: But my aim and endeavours have gehc rally been 
 to take the chief points only, andfublfanceof the matters arifing 
 and fpoken unto, and the rational parts of the arguments and autho- 
 rities ufed and urged, to inforcc and prove what was furmifed tO 
 be Law on either fide, and the grounds and authorities upon which 
 the opinions and refolutions of the Court are framed and given ,and 
 to paflc by all the luxuriant flouriChes of wit, and the multiply- 
 ing ofSimilaryCafes to theCafes in queflion,as fcrving more for the 
 mofl part to prove the curious phanfy, & much read'iug of the Ar- 
 guer,than the proof of the points of the cafes in cjueftiou, or the fatis- 
 tadion, or information of the Auditors or Readers ludgmcntjand I 
 have ever(yct with fubmiffion to better Iudgements,)conceived this 
 conciie way oftaking Reports to be farr more beneficial and de- 
 lightful, not only to the Reporter , but alfo to thofe that (hall read 
 
 ihcm
 
 TotheProFcflbrs, and Students of &c, 
 
 them, tlicn tliat long and tedious way, wherein rhc truth is fo ovcr- 
 fliadovved with multiplicity of vvords,that it is very difiicult through 
 thoreClowdstodifcover,and behold lier pcrfeft beauty ib well, as 
 when flic appears bare-faced in iier true and natural complexion. I 
 need not iay^iny thing in commendation of the Common Law^^thcy 
 do fo fHffiLicntly ,and clearly fpeak t'r-eir ou'n worth, not only in our 
 own lanJ,but even through thcChrilUan,if I may not [fay the whole 
 known world. The fruit tiiat every one from him ti^at iits on the 
 Throne, to her that grindcth at tiie Mill, throughout this nation in 
 the tender prefervatioiiof our Religion, Lives, Liberties, and Pro- 
 perties do lowdly proclaim their excellency, and do juftly claim 
 our reverent efteem of them, and their fwcet influence which our 
 Neighbour Nations do partake of from their light and heat, hath 
 purchafed an honourable name, and repute amongll them. Thougli 
 no doubt but other Kingdomes, and Republiqucs have many excel. 
 lent written and eflablilhed Laws futable to the particular confti- 
 tutions ofthc people , andto their ieveral frames of government, 
 and amongft the reft the Civil or imperial Laws, yet t'ney all want 
 many remarkable exccUenLies tiiat are in the Common Laws of 
 England, and the proceedings therein , and amongft the reft to in- 
 ftancc in no more , they are very deficient in this way ufed in our 
 Law for many ages p aft, of reporting, and leaving to pofterity the 
 learned arguments of councel at the Bar , and of tue ^rave and pro- 
 found rcfolutions of the reverend ludgcs in the deciiion of Cafes a- 
 riring,and controverted amongft us^anchhis way how lightly foever 
 it be now cfteemed of by many amongft us,yet is by Strangers much 
 valued,and was heretofore fo much let by amongft us5and thought fo 
 highly advantageous to the publiquc, that the wif dome of this State 
 did then think ht to appoint grave and judicious mcn,encouragcd by 
 an annual ftipend, to attend and perform this task, and therefore I 
 hope that he who hath undertaken this hard labour freely and vo- 
 luntarily in relation to the publicpe good, without hope of reward, 
 is fo far from deferving blame and reproof, that he is rather to be 
 cherifhed and countenanced in thefe his endeavours by thofe in au- 
 thority, andnottobc raflilyand uncharitably calumnicatcd, or 
 cenfurcd by any, but to be favourably interpreted, and received as 
 one that makes it his aim to be accomptedatrue lover of the 
 Common Laws, and really honoureth the profefTion, and Profcf- 
 fors thereof. 
 
 Inner Temple, May 
 the 19th. 1658^ 
 
 Willim Style.
 
 An Alphabetical 
 
 OF THE 
 
 NAMES 
 
 O F THE 
 
 CASES. 
 
 A Pag. 
 
 Sir Maurice Abbots cafe 1 5 ? 1 4 
 
 Abbot and Vaughan 45° 
 
 Adon and Ayrcs 346 
 
 Addon and Hunter 2c6 
 
 Allen and Reeve 88 
 
 Aliens Cafe 2 5? 
 
 Allen and Holdcn 287, 288 
 
 Andrews Cafe 9 
 
 Andrews and Baily 159 
 
 Gount ArondelsCafe 26 
 
 Count Arondel&Shandois cafe 371, 371 
 Archer and Holbidg 185 
 
 Arnold and Floyd 4y3,476 
 
 Sir Anthony Afhly Cooper and St. John 
 
 vid. C, 
 Alhby and Child 384 
 
 A fhtvorih and Sir Tho. Stanley 
 Askwiths cafe 
 Atwood and Monger 
 AtlccanJthc Lady Balcinglafl 
 Avery and Kirton 
 AylctandStellam 
 Aylctand Oates 
 Ailet and Watlefj 
 Ayrcand Sills 
 Ayreand Pimcomb 
 Ayre and Hawkfworth 
 
 B 
 
 BAcon and Raoirey 
 Barnaby andGoodale 
 Bilely and Bafcly 
 Barker and Martyn 
 BarlyandMartyn 
 Barrets cafe 
 A 
 
 5(54 
 
 362 
 378, 379 
 
 475 
 I75'J7<5 
 
 100 
 
 I2I>I25 
 245 
 
 1(^4 
 38Z 
 
 4^0 
 
 1,2 
 
 16 
 
 *P'57 
 20 
 
 «5 
 
 fiikec
 
 An Alphabetical Table. 
 
 Biker an.) tdmoous 
 Bani(krand Wrighc 
 Barlye? cafe 
 Biker andDcnhim 
 Barber and Pomeroy 
 BarncwcUand Uranc 
 Bambury and Balely 
 
 Barmeilon and Gale 
 Bernard and Levic -j 
 Barcock and Tomcloii 
 
 Batisfordand Yaret 
 >Baichcllourand Parfons 
 Baker and Smith 
 Barnard and King 
 Bainron and Checke 
 Baker and Andrews 
 Barjir and Windham 
 Barker and Elmer 
 Banilkrscare 
 Baxters cafe 
 Bankesand Pracc 
 Barker and Welion 
 Baker and Ramley 
 BedWorth and Bietfworih 
 Bealand Wytraa 
 Benskin and fLmck 
 Benner and the 
 
 62,63 
 
 137 
 
 1 90 
 1^^0,161,180,181, 
 182, i5?J, 196,197, 
 
 213 
 
 2 2 7 
 
 ■281,288,373, 
 
 19) 
 
 295,30?, 304 
 
 Bedvvell and Fenwick 
 Bigford and Topfam 
 Bird and Chriiio^ber 
 Bifhop and Fitzhcrbert 
 Boomer and ^'ate 
 Boone and Sheercs 
 Bowes and Brojdhead 
 Bolton and Wills 
 Bowles and Clark 
 Boomer and Cleve 
 Bois and Cranfield 
 Booth and Lambert 
 Bowyerand tantulyar 
 Boyle anJ Scarborow 
 
 306, 307 
 
 353j354'355 
 
 5575358 
 
 3S5 
 
 41J 
 
 405 
 
 35 
 420,421,428 
 
 4^5 
 
 10 
 
 24P 
 
 388 
 
 //undred of /fart lord 
 
 253 
 
 Busrield and Norden 
 Burrel and Lancalire 
 Burcher an I Orchard 
 Bunny worth and Gibbs 
 BlackwcU and Afluon 
 Blackden and //aney 
 Bronze and More 
 Broome md Evering 
 Serj^eant Bradfluw and PrOifler 
 Bruerand Southwell 
 Brooke and Brooke 
 BrcrciOD and Monin;^con 
 Bra^gand Nitingall 
 Browne and Poyncs 
 i>'rook and ^ogg 
 Brooke and Brooke 
 i'rungy and Lee 
 Aryan and Stone 
 /)'iowncand Nclfon 
 i^ryanand Twite 
 ^'rock and Vernon 
 ^fiyhtwell and Robfon 
 i'romefield and Williamfon 
 ^ynion and Trotter 
 /iyronaiKlStoDehowfc 
 
 C 
 
 Bockingand Symons 
 Bond and Marcyn 
 Sir William Bronkers cafe 
 Bnrnet and Bird 
 Burwell and LanciOec 
 Burgesand Dinham 
 Butler and Long 
 Buriallonand /Herbert 
 Bunon and Low 
 BucklionandShurlock 
 
 393) 394 
 2C9 
 
 389 
 
 398 
 
 32 
 79 
 
 ^5> 
 
 214 
 
 22S 
 231 
 
 239 
 
 276,277 
 
 155 
 395. i96, 440, 
 
 441. 442 W43. 444 
 400 
 
 353 
 16 
 
 54 
 
 109 
 
 Ii4>ii5 
 
 117 
 
 155 
 
 212,213,233 
 
 340 
 
 471 
 icp 
 
 349>35o 
 
 419 
 
 50 
 
 220 
 
 428 
 
 8 
 
 45^ 
 
 27,58,65 
 
 61 
 
 "5 
 
 140,141 
 
 147 
 
 1 64, 165 
 
 170,171 
 578 
 
 239 
 
 3»7)3i8 
 
 328 
 
 339>340 
 
 368,369 
 
 407,408 
 
 231 
 
 3*8,329 
 
 e\pelland Alleync 
 Carver and Pierce 
 Caiileand Dynely 
 Cages cale 
 Ca^cand Ol'cby 
 Carcw and Biv/d 
 Cane and Goldirg 
 Cater nnd StartuiC 
 Cane and Pell 
 Cage and Dod 
 Canrrell and Stephens 
 Sir Charls Coor and Plunket 
 Cook and Fincham 
 Cooke and Alleyne 
 Conesby and Fairefax 
 Col ion and ^edloe 
 Corcilli and Cowfye 
 Collins and Page 
 Coles and Sibley 
 Compton and Alleyne 
 Cofwells cafe 
 CoUbnand Kea 
 Cooke and More 
 Sir Anthony Aflilcy 
 
 49 
 66,75 
 
 92, 95 
 129 
 »5^ 
 
 i<57,id8 
 
 169,170,176,177 
 
 217 
 
 329 
 
 233>254 
 30c 
 125 
 
 iS 
 
 20 
 
 25,24 
 
 I 1 S, 1 1 9 
 
 it4- 125 
 
 15^,178 
 
 161 
 
 182 
 
 195 
 
 195 
 
 Cooper and St. 
 
 John
 
 • An Alphabetical Tabic* 
 
 John 
 
 Cowlycand Lockton 
 Coicman and -Blunden 
 Collynstnd Syllys 
 Cottcrel and Thcoballs 
 
 Comport and /^eech 
 Cooks and Chambers 
 Ccnyeand Lawes 
 Curtice and Columbine 
 Cutrwot[h5carc 
 
 Curtodcs aud Oucwell,Newton and Tyd. 
 i78;i79,i8o, 1845 185,191,192 
 Curtodcs and Montague and Lyci»ll 
 
 209, 210 
 Curtodes and White 227 
 
 Ciillodes and Valconbridgs 228 
 
 CuHodes and Mayne and Serjcanc 245 
 
 Curtodcs and Arskott 343 
 
 Curtodcs and the Town. of Colchertcr 
 
 452 
 Cuflodes afld Hall 260 
 
 Curtodcs and Monger 265,^66 
 
 Curtodcs and Jinkes 283 
 
 Cul'odcs and Rivet 2P4 
 
 Curtodcs and the Lord Morley 295 
 
 CuHodesand Tawncyand Norwood 312, 
 
 313- 
 Curtodcs and Howell G win 3 3 ^> 5 ? 7 
 
 362 
 Curtodcs and the Parifh of Stoncham 
 
 366 
 Curtodcs and Toos 
 Curtodesand Martyn 
 Curtodcs and Rickaby 
 
 374 
 
 374,2375 
 
 3<59, 375'376' 
 
 377 
 403 
 
 463 
 
 33 
 41 
 
 Curtodcs and Levingfton 
 Cullycr and lermin 
 ChadlyandStinch 
 Chapel and Drew 
 Checkcs cafe 
 Chambers and Wollafton 78, 84, 85 
 
 Villde Charlton in Kent 14 
 
 Chambers and Floyd 89 
 
 Cheevcrs and Cage 7 1 
 
 Chrirtophcr and How 158 
 
 Chafe and Levering 220 
 
 Child and Guiac 243 
 
 Chapman and Brook 389 
 
 Ch i Id and Sir J ohn Lenthall 330 
 
 Chcefeman and Turner 343 
 
 Childs cafe 424 
 
 Clark and Pew 18 
 
 Cjcment'nn and Mountford 106 
 
 Ciarkscilc .,gj 
 
 Clark and Fitzwilliami 48s 
 
 Crcfwelland Vcmrycs 91 
 
 QefTuand Burgis 296 
 
 Crosltwhait and the Hundred of Lowdon 
 
 318,319 
 CrooLc and Simm 121 
 
 Cremcr and Gurnet: 266,267;263,z69, 
 
 270,271 272 
 Cydill and Spencer 341 
 
 The Hundred of Crondon 47, 
 
 19 
 216 
 
 D 
 
 Davi 1 and Lifter 
 
 Dawkcsand Payton 
 
 Dawkesand Pynder 232 
 
 Davis anJ Ockham 245 
 
 Davis and the Lord Foliott 299, 510 J 
 
 311 
 
 DawkcsandCaveneigh 3475 348 
 
 Davis and Matthews 4)5,4j($ 
 
 Derflcy and Derfley 57 
 Denoirand Oyle 1^6,167,172,173 
 Dell and /''row ne I74)i75,i8i 
 
 Dcwick and /''amber 2c8 
 
 Denton and Hdi'iioa 229 
 
 Dethickscale 233 
 
 Denton and Cakec 247 
 
 Dentons cafe 475 
 
 Dekins and Latham 317, 318 
 
 Dekin and Turner 387 
 
 Deacon and Forcrt 1 14 
 
 Devercuxand Jacklon 477 
 
 Dickcnfon and Prerton 7 
 
 Difon and Barcue 133 
 
 Dilne and Grigfon and ^o!yec 227 
 
 Dod and Eaton 63,64 
 
 Dowlc and Marters 263 
 
 Dod and Herbert 436,459 
 
 Dorman and Snagg 411,412 
 
 Dunch and Smith 13^,146 
 
 Dudecey andColyer 225 
 
 Dudly and ZJorns 32a 
 
 Drinkwater and Pack 297 
 
 Drake and Drake 363,364 
 
 Drake and Whitakcr 24, 2 y. 
 
 Edwards and Fallowes 21a 
 
 Eeles& Lambert 37^^8,54,55,56,73,74 
 Elvott and Blague 28; 
 
 Elrton and Drake 39-3 
 
 Ellis and Tipoin 34,5 
 
 Elzy
 
 An Alphabetical Tabic. 
 
 Elry and Mawdit 
 Kmcrlbn and Uidly, 
 Erhcry and Ernly and Allen 
 Ellon and Manlcy 
 Edward and Scitf 
 Elmes andMarcin 
 
 22C, ill , 226 
 T41, 1^2 Vid7<„. 
 234 
 461 
 448 
 475 
 
 3«7 
 
 357'258 
 57 
 
 285 
 
 F\irfaxandFiirrax 236,237,238 
 
 hanQiaw and Bond 
 Earmtrani Lawrence 
 Eeildcr and lovy 241,242, 
 Finer and JeH'ry 
 FiBCS and Dell 
 Fitton and Richardlon 
 FiOirrand jcftryes 
 Luc ye Foil hrbie scale 
 Fortefcneind Brogravc 
 Firchct ?nd VVoUlon 
 Floyd and Moroan 
 Foriune and Johnlon 
 FowkindBoyl 3435 344i 
 
 Fowk and Prclcoc 
 Fowkand Coplye 
 Fulhams cafe 
 Fox and Swan 
 Fletcher and King 
 Floyd and Morgan 
 Frembling and Clotherbook 
 Frercscale 
 
 Freeborn and Purchafc 
 Frank and Burt 
 Frank and Dixon 
 Freeman and Childerels 
 Freiod and Baker 
 Fianklins cafe 
 
 G 
 
 16? 
 2S6 
 
 38s 
 363 
 8 
 
 3 '3 
 
 5«S 
 348 349 
 
 458 
 
 83^84 
 
 481 
 
 582,383 
 
 3271328 
 
 48,49 
 
 '33 
 
 107 
 
 149 
 
 >53 
 
 299 
 
 388 
 
 'Awdy and Inf,ham 88 
 
 iGallop and Simplon, and Chale 1 1 ■? 
 
 126 
 
 Gardner and Jolly 
 Garret and Blizard 
 Lc Gaycs cafe 
 Garland and Yarrow 
 Gay and Gay 
 Gilbert and Stone 
 Gibbs and Donne 
 Gill tnd Crofs 
 Gilbert and Mardeo 
 Gibbon and Kent 
 Gibbs and Price 
 Giles and Tymberly 
 Giles and Sowthward 
 
 157 
 
 I9i»»93 
 
 464 
 
 322,3i3>326 
 
 258,271 
 
 72 
 
 135 
 
 148 
 
 18? 
 
 212 
 
 231 
 
 283 
 
 38J 
 
 Goffs cafe 
 Gowrs cafe 
 Goodyerand Shaw 
 GollaocandTayler 
 Godwin and Backin 
 Gough and Cann 
 G'ydcandDudenv 
 Greenwocd and Price. 
 Gray »n f Wal>c 
 Graves and Drake 
 Grirtithand Thomas 
 G'.ecnlingand Bawdic 
 Green and How 
 Griblc and Orchard 
 
 H 
 
 234 
 
 261 
 
 298 
 
 3iJ)3»<5 
 330 
 341 
 
 109, no 
 
 159 
 
 199 
 
 334 
 404 
 
 31? 
 164 
 
 ■ \mond and Kingsmill 
 
 2i 
 
 X.JL ^alesand More 
 n^ri and Bucktrinlicr 
 Harris his cafe 
 
 Harwood and Psty 161,161 
 Harris and Gibbons 
 Hamond and Kingfmill 
 Hamondand Ireland 
 Hay ward and Williams 
 Harman and Jacob 
 Hamond and Ward 
 Harding and Freeman 
 Harflop and lohnlon 
 Harris and looker. 
 Hayw.rd and Ducket 
 Hacker and Newborn 
 Hamond and Thornhill 
 Hardrcfs and Prowd 
 
 > 23>2TO 
 
 86 
 
 lOJ 
 
 451 
 ,iC8,i65> 
 
 17Z 
 
 32, 210 
 215 
 
 2 54> 
 
 The Vill of Hardingham aga 
 
 Harley and Mountney 
 
 HcUyar and Cjrace 
 
 /^cllcnaescjfi 
 
 //cyford and Hohion 
 
 Hcii and Green 2 J 8) 259, 
 
 276, 
 
 //card and Read 
 
 Weath and lldall 
 
 //ether and Bowman 
 
 //erbert and Law 
 
 Hcniliawscale 
 
 //enly and Baynton 436 
 
 //ill and //arris 
 
 //ill and Farmer 
 
 //ide and King 
 [ //ill and Bird 
 / ^illandDcchair 
 
 280 
 
 2J6 
 
 287 
 jio 
 
 371 
 40? 
 
 4i3>427 
 476 
 
 465 
 
 inrt Bnfly 
 
 16^ 
 
 4*y 
 9 
 
 II 
 
 136 
 
 260, 27J, 
 
 3i5>3i6 
 
 335 
 
 358 
 
 462 
 
 370 
 
 399 
 
 5437)43« 
 
 134 
 
 29 
 
 io« 
 
 381,38* 
 
 Micks
 
 An Alphabetical Table. 
 
 //icksandjoicc 
 
 Hioos.tnd ^arilbn 
 
 Hogg and Vaughan 
 
 i/olaigh and Chale 74, 
 
 Hcb'.OD and /feyward 
 
 Nooke: and Lamb 
 
 Hchiid and ^oralion 
 
 //obs and SUnchard 
 
 //od^'c sand Jane 
 
 Hoblon and Hadloa 
 
 i/oUingworih and VVheifionV 
 
 i/offs cale 
 
 Homes and Singly 
 
 //odgc scale 
 
 7/owards cafe 
 
 toward and /foward 
 
 //udl'ons'cifc 
 
 //urd and Lenthall 
 
 Hunt and Popham 
 
 i/umc and f/incon 
 
 //udfon and DickinfoO 
 
 /full and Giirnecc 
 
 Hycde and Dell. 
 
 4»3.4H 
 6 
 
 7 J' 78/75? 
 £8 
 96 
 
 122 
 167 
 
 I95>, 200 
 21 2 
 
 124 
 
 20S 
 
 211 
 
 238 
 
 304,305 
 
 416 
 
 64 
 
 I Ay and Gayj or Jay 
 
 jaqucscafe 
 Jennings and Lee. 
 Jcnkinlbn and Porter 
 Jervis and Lucas 
 Jennings and DownJ 
 JcnniugsandLec ijo 
 
 Ingram and Fawfcc 
 Jonjs and Yonguc 
 Jones and Stanly 
 Jones and Jacob 
 Johnlon and^bington 
 Johns and Levinglton 
 Jones and flunden 
 Jones aaJ Graves 
 IbiOD and ^eal 
 lies and Windfor 
 Ireland and Michelbora 
 Izackand Green 
 Jones and Graves 
 
 and Jay, 358, 
 
 274,275 
 
 1535^9,355 
 
 198,199 
 
 187 
 
 345)346 
 
 352 
 
 ) 1515198,199, 
 
 no, 211 
 
 463 
 
 IS 
 
 38 
 142 
 163 
 184 
 
 2CI,206 
 
 421 
 
 165 
 
 419 
 
 171 
 
 <59,7c 
 4*7 
 
 61 
 
 KAleandJofelyo 
 Kenilion and Jones 97 98 
 
 Kcnilion and Cronch 228 
 
 Herman and Johnfon 281, 282,293) 294^ 
 
 KcDCuy unci hiuur 295 296 
 
 KeckwithandMoylc 344,345 
 
 Keightlcyand Nodc« 31 j 
 
 Kemp and Gord 411 
 
 The King and i/o'.land 20,21,40,41,75, 
 76, 84, 90, 94: 95 
 
 The King and Place 
 The King and Marefchall 
 The King and iomcriand 
 Kinpe aod Johnfon 
 The King and //ide 
 The Kit.gandSivjge 
 The King and Apfly 
 
 The King and Page, and /Garwood 
 The King and Cory 
 The King and Symons 
 The King and Andrews 
 
 Kings caic 
 
 The King and Ann Camell 
 
 25,28,29 
 
 29,50 
 
 34 
 
 70,7' 
 60 
 
 85 
 
 85 
 
 85,87 
 
 87 
 91 
 
 lOO 
 
 116 
 
 The Kirg and Sir //enry Spillcr 108, 1 09 
 The King and Dodet Trig 
 
 The King and Bellingham 
 The King and Wood 
 The King and Bray 
 The King and Humphryes 
 The King and Golding 
 King ana Weeden 
 Kitchinmans cafe 
 Kick and Lucas 
 Kimlock and Bamficld ' 
 Knights cafe 
 
 LAngley and Wibord 
 Lamb and Dnft' 
 Lawrence and i/arifon 
 Lamplew and //cvrfon 
 Lance and i>lackmcre 
 
 124>I35, 
 136 
 126 
 
 '45 
 
 147 
 154 
 
 164 
 
 374 
 430 
 
 309,310 
 
 2 
 
 ItO 
 
 21 I, 212 
 
 426 
 
 43S 
 4«53 
 
 The Earl ol Leicellcr and Samfordf 1 5 
 
 Lere and Cholwitch 
 
 Loving aad Gamble 
 
 Ley *nd AnJcrton ' 
 
 Lcvinglion and Crompton 
 
 Leake and Reynolls 
 
 Le Pool and Tryan 
 
 LiddalandLilkr 
 
 Le Grofs and //all ' 
 
 John Lilbornscal;; 
 
 The City of London and Eiiwick 
 
 30,31 
 
 102 
 22S 
 
 359 
 414 
 
 470 
 
 278 
 
 47<5 
 
 96 
 
 3 J' 3$ 
 
 Long and ^ennctc 
 Xodg aiid Weeden 
 Lovell and KDatchford 
 
 35) 3tf>4«'45 
 
 50, 5t 
 
 J 20 
 
 Love-
 
 An Alphabetical Tabic. 
 
 Lovedaiec cafe 
 
 The City of London,ind Le i\oy 
 
 Lvickxr and Palfriman 519,32053*1 
 
 I2p 
 126 
 
 »5> 66 
 466 
 
 481 
 7.8 
 
 3 5° 
 
 Long and Hcbb 
 
 I'heCuy of London, «nd //atton 
 ' Locky'and Dnmiioc 
 
 anJ the Sheriffs of London 
 Lord and MichcU 
 Longs Calc 
 
 London and Wllcocks 
 London and Craven 
 Luskini and Carver 
 LumlcyatidNeviil 
 LuddingcoD and White 
 Lydall and LiUcr 
 Lynifton and Mawricc 
 
 M 
 
 MA.flcrmanscafe 
 Mack and Cubitt 
 Mdthcw and //erle 
 Mayhiicand-^afpool 
 MariinandMiiier 
 Mariliaii and Porter 
 Martin and //eniy 
 MarfliallaadLedfliam 
 Mattel man and Rufl>olm 
 MalVcyand Avibcry 
 Martcrsand VVallis 
 Maynel and MackaHy _ 
 
 Mathcw and the hundred of Godalming, 
 
 427 
 i59)i6o 
 
 ^9h ii'4* ^02» 2°3 
 
 2 
 
 49-50 
 
 65 
 
 104 
 
 483 
 H3 
 232 
 
 246, 282 
 244 
 
 3 6 J, 366- 
 408 
 
 459>4<5o 
 
 Mercer and Rule 
 Meres and French 
 
 Michell and Hepwonh 429,430 
 
 More and Savage ,♦,7. 
 
 MorcficldaudWcbb 3 9' 4© 
 
 Monger and Shattcrion 60, 6 r 
 
 More and Cliplom 7^ 
 
 More and Stone 94 
 
 The Lord Moons cafe 118 
 
 MoggandShute . *23 
 
 The Lord Mounceagles cafe 2 57 
 
 More and the EailRivcri iH 
 
 Morden and Hare 47' 
 
 N 
 
 NAylerand Afb 
 Needier and Gucll 
 Ncvill and Moc 
 Newton and Bailes 
 Nelfon and Tompfon 
 Ncwcon and Tydd, and Ocvvcll 
 
 223 
 
 iz 
 
 59>6o 
 
 120, 121 
 
 142,278 
 
 178 
 
 Newcomin and Leigh 249 
 
 Needier and Guc(t 254?* 5 5 
 
 NewconandGodard 290 
 
 Neve and Croft 35°j3 5^ 
 
 fslcwiTian and Mafly 578 
 
 NcvYion and Osbora 3 87 
 
 Nortonscafe ito 
 
 Norton and Jafon 398,599 
 
 North and j. met 439 
 
 Nulls and Cheney' 5 
 
 O 
 
 OSborns cafe 158 
 
 OrcAvick.and Atncry 128 
 
 Owenandlcvon 274,277 
 Oliph and To-ig 389,390591,392 
 
 OylesandMarcfchalL ' 4i8 
 
 P\inandSkcltro[n 17 
 
 {^aradine and lane 47. 48 
 
 Warmitfcrand Creliy 49,74 
 
 Pay and Paxted 97 
 
 PaynandPredny 234 
 
 Parker andtfook 341 
 
 Page and^rook 401 
 
 Patnclland £rook 417 
 
 P^ge and Parr 43* 
 
 Palcall and Sparinge 198 
 
 Pavvlcy and Lowdall 249, 27 J 
 
 Pciribn and Dawfon 4^ 
 
 Peeling and Ken iii, ria 
 
 Pcndarvis and Dawks 2C5 
 
 '\ Peiic and /I/ablyc i94 
 
 Pcafeand ShrimptoH i6i 
 Peck and Ingram ^263,264,^75 
 
 Peck and Ewre 381 
 
 Pcndarvis and St. Aubili 410,41 1 
 
 Pitcher and Symons 115 
 
 Pilkintonand Zfaglliaw 449 450 
 
 Pimlcy and Kobinfon i2i 
 
 Pickering and ^Sarkley 132 
 
 P.iillips his cMi i6i 
 
 Pickering and Emma i94 
 
 Piiton and Rcy 359 
 
 Pinder and Dawks aja 
 
 Pinchard and Fowk 4ii5 
 
 Phillips andPhillips 420 
 Pitchet and Wollion 
 
 Pliimmer and Sir John Lenchall 475 
 
 Poole and Coply 64 
 
 Popham and //unc j 40, 2 54 
 
 PoynsandFrarscis 181 
 
 Popham and White 231. 
 
 Pow-
 
 An Alphabetical Table. 
 
 Powell and Hopkins ;47 
 
 Port and Midleton 251 
 
 Poynts Mawrice his cafe 3 56 
 
 Porter and Swetman 406,407 
 
 Phi lips his cafe ,162 
 
 Pooly and Markhim 477 
 
 PragncUandGoff 11 ■ 
 
 . Pretlon and Holms 148,1^9 
 
 Preuon aud Morclock 293 
 
 Price and Car 45? 
 
 Prior an.l Ha'e 348 
 
 Price and Goodrick 387 
 
 The Pro:C(flor3Dd Strcercc 415,416 
 The ProtCvSor and Baxter 418 419 
 
 The Proteftor and Ilichardfon 430, 45 1 
 The ProtcAor and C-rtwrighc 431 
 
 The Procector and ^uckner 467,4^* &c. 
 The Protestor and Lowr 432 
 
 The ProtcJ^orand Yaccs 477, 478, &c. 
 The Protestor and Hare 434' 
 
 The ProtCi^orand Summer 450 
 
 The Proteaor and the Vili of Colcheaer 
 44<5,447>448&c. 
 The Protestor and Gunter 448 
 
 The Prorcftor and Norice 454 
 
 TheProtedorandCraford 457,458 
 
 The Proteaor and -SJackwell 461 
 
 Pym and Morgan, vid. Bambury and 
 ^all-!y i6i,&c.' 
 
 Ko'.yer and Langdale 
 Rof? sndLa.vrencc 
 Rook and Smiih 
 Ro",er:?and Doue 
 Roby and Twelves 
 Robinfdn and Walker 
 Roiirgcs and WooiyarJ 
 
 Qi 
 
 kUatcrmans cafe 
 
 R 
 
 R 
 
 Awfon and Bargue 
 
 36> 
 
 Raw andRav/ 
 Raph and Davy 
 RatcliftandDudcny 
 Rawly and Vivers 
 Remington and Kitigerby 
 Reader and Palmer 
 Read and Palmer 
 Sir Tho. Ncvillj cafe 
 Ridley andEmcrfon 141, 142 
 The Earl Rivers and More 
 Ritch and Saunders 
 Countefs Rivers ca(c 2 34>2 5 
 RicotandSt.John 
 Rook and Knight 
 Robinfons calc 
 Roydon and Mecs 
 Roberts and Tucker 
 
 '34 
 
 37jSI.52> 
 81/82,83 
 
 119, 120 
 
 150 
 
 176 
 
 385 
 
 4 
 
 117,118 
 
 106 
 
 141,142 
 
 ,ijjvid.E. 
 
 261, 262 
 
 2)253)*54 
 582 
 
 9 
 69 
 
 79,80 
 
 191 
 
 248 
 263 
 
 273,274 
 5315332, 333'334 
 
 423424 
 239 
 426 
 
 S^\■ig6icl(i 
 Saundtrfon and Martin and Smith 
 Sawyers calc 
 Sawndcifonand Rj-jfm 
 Saunders and Ri;ch 
 SawjerandRu.fcU 
 Sale andWrav 
 Seaman and Edwards 
 Scgar and Dyer * 
 Siacnhamscafc 
 Scoble and Tolye 
 ShertlifFand Timbcrly 
 ShurJey and Semaign 
 Shann and Shann 
 Shayler and Bigg 
 Shann anuBilby 
 ^herecroft and Weeks 
 She pheard and Gray 
 Shcrlocks cafe 
 SkcdlockandLaperc 
 Skete and Clay 
 Sladescafe 
 Smith and Hobfon 
 Sr.iith and Stone 
 Smith and Hancock 
 Smithfon and Wells 
 Smith and Hale 
 Smith and Dunch 
 Smith and Andrews 
 Smith and the Eirl of Dorfcc 
 Smith and Ward 
 Smith and Holyman 
 Snelgrave and Bofvile 
 Somes and Sir John Lenthal^ 
 Sowthcott and Sowthcotc 
 Spitlehoufe and Farmery 
 Spry and Mill 182,183,203,204 
 
 Stoughton and Day 18 
 
 Stents cafe 127 
 
 Sir John Stowels cafe 104 
 
 Stradiingand Borcman l29>i3o 
 
 Stubs and Mauklin 165 
 
 Staples cafe 359,360 
 
 Sir 
 
 12 
 »7 
 
 288, 28P 
 
 • 59? 264 
 
 375 
 
 6i 
 
 31 
 
 341 
 
 102,103 
 
 219 
 
 *55 
 2S'''257>28o 
 
 171 
 
 280 
 
 379 
 445 
 45^.457 
 265 
 125 
 
 138 
 
 • 112, iij 
 
 65 
 
 ■ i37'»38 
 
 141 
 
 139 
 
 139,146 
 
 183,184 
 
 a77 
 
 361 
 
 327 
 
 465 
 
 103, 108 
 
 390
 
 An Alphabetical Tabic. 
 
 Sir Hujiphry S ylc and TuUyc , 286, 
 
 287 
 
 ScarkyandMill 296 
 
 Stroadand Horr.es 3 3^ 
 
 Sraplcj cafe 24^ 
 
 Stcvcnion and Srcward 4=4 
 
 Stavcly andlliithorij 4ii»4i2 
 
 Stephens and Ask 424^4^5 
 
 Wo VrlyStrachye^cafc '*8 
 
 Captain Strecrers calc 4>5 
 
 Siroy»d and Beckvviih 454' 455 
 
 Svran and Fenham ^09,410 
 
 Simons and Leir 72 
 
 Syms and VVilfon 2 14> 2 1 5 
 
 TAnncr and Lawrence 53 
 
 Tayler aid Webb 301,^02-307, 
 308, 309, 319, 38? 
 Terry and Baxter . 3? 
 
 Tench and Cietheroe 59 
 
 Tench and Huhrifon 340 
 
 Theoballs and Newton 307 
 
 Thomas's calc * 461 
 
 Thynandthyn 67,(58,^9,77,78,91,92 
 $8,99,101,143 
 
 Tburlc and Madil'on 
 Tbeobill and Conqiiclt 
 Ti'bns cafe 
 Timbrell and Bullock 
 Tories cafe 
 Toby and Angcll 
 Tompkins and Jour:!en 
 Toplady and Staly 
 TowDl'end and Barker, 
 Tompkins and Clark 
 Toft and Day 
 Torrct and Frampton 
 Tracy and Poole 
 Trctonand Squire 
 Sir //umphry Tracy and Bloom 
 Trundall andTrowcU 
 Trorman and Standarc 
 
 462 
 
 343 
 
 153 
 
 15 
 
 15 
 
 no 
 
 131 
 
 i6y, id6 
 
 338,389,394 
 422 
 
 43i'47'^ 
 
 434,435 
 
 i43>'44 
 
 2 30 
 
 356 
 
 273 
 284>285 
 
 DoiSor Trig and the College of Phyiki 
 
 ans 
 Trcvilian and^elman 
 Trcvanian and Pcnhollow 
 Turner and his Wifes cafe 
 Tucker and C^ofh 
 Turner and Trapes 
 Twig and Roberts 
 Tyler and Johnfon 
 Tyndall anJ //arington 
 
 329) 330 
 400, 401 
 
 452 
 
 47 
 
 288,289 
 
 412 
 
 M5 
 41 
 
 V 
 
 Andicoorscafe 52 
 
 Vaux and Vaux vcrfus Steward 3"d 
 
 Draper 
 Vincent and Furfey 
 Vincent and Wallii 
 Vicciry and Barns 
 Vidian and Fletcher 
 
 157,203 
 
 43'44 
 197 
 
 4IJ 
 
 472 
 
 w 
 
 vv 
 
 AtfonandNorbury 3,201,202 
 
 464 
 
 Ward and Coggin 
 
 Waglialtand Tcmpert 
 Watfonand VVatfon 
 Waineright and Whitley 
 Walker and Alder 
 Waldron and Ward 
 Watfon anJ Scotfon 
 Ware and Chappcl 
 Watts and Dix 
 Watrs and Lord 
 Warry and Bond 
 Willis and BucknaUi9i, 
 VVattsandLowth 
 Wall and Bye 
 Walkcnden and Heycock 
 Weeks and Weeks 
 WeltoD and Plowden 
 ^^cncworch and Wrntworth 
 w^ebbandAriimer 
 AfeldandRumney 
 
 iVc\>b and ^A-aniborn 
 
 28,56 
 
 117 
 
 449 
 121 
 
 186,187 
 
 188,189,204,205 
 
 230 
 
 255 
 
 292,311,312 
 
 341 
 
 352 
 
 173)178, 188 
 24s 
 260 
 418 
 
 ^^ecks his cafe 
 W'eL-fcnand5trudder 
 ^^cbb.-rly and Sir John Lcnthall 
 ^hitchi-rch and Pa-^jt 
 Whitwell and 5horc 
 W'hiileyand Fawfct 
 f^hites cafe 
 P^ite and Thomas 
 ff^ite and //ar wood 
 ;^iteacre and f^illweli 
 ^itcandWolford 
 H^'uc and Finder 
 w^itwelyandPinfent 
 ff'hitehcadandBuckland 
 
 552» 353, 360, 
 361 
 
 37» 
 379 
 4J4 
 
 2 08 
 
 12,13 
 
 17 
 
 58,39 
 138 
 
 27 
 170 
 
 300 
 
 373^ 379.380 
 401,402,405 
 
 ^^ingficld
 
 Wingfield and Sherwood 5 
 
 WilliamlonandHcnly • n 
 
 Willifon and Crow 75 
 
 Pawl Williams and the Cunodes , &c. 244 
 
 Williams and Tyrcr 
 Willi? and Bond 
 Winn and Stcbbins 
 Williamfon and Coleman 
 WiaccandHarby 
 Williamfon and Mead- 
 Winter and Bernard 
 Wtthring and Bilhopfgate Parifll 
 Willis and Bond. 
 Williamfon and NorwUch 
 Wingfield and Valence 
 Wile and Jeoffryes 
 Williams and Poole 
 Wood and Salter 
 Worfcly and Worfely 
 
 A Table. 
 
 . -• 
 
 Wood and Clemence 
 Wood and Holland 
 Wood and Tophara 2i<», 
 
 Wood and Mountney . 
 Wood and Markehara 
 Wood and Gunfton 
 Wroath andElfy 
 Wrijghc and Pinder 
 Wright and Martyn 
 Wrights cafe 
 Wrights cafe 
 
 405 
 
 47 
 200 
 
 207,208 
 
 221 
 260 
 
 3375338 
 
 4i4»4i5 
 4»9 
 460 
 
 53 
 123 
 
 YAce and Batisford 
 VatcsandLynden 
 Yongue and Petit 
 Yokeburft and Skot 
 
 333,i2<J,i5a 
 
 227,234,215, 
 303 
 360 
 
 4"8 
 
 tj6i,4^4, 465 
 
 i<5 
 
 34 
 107 
 
 f^9^ 140 
 
 i95 
 
 47 
 
 439i44o 
 
 V 
 
 Hill
 
 
 HILARY TERM 
 
 21 Gar^ Banc. Reg. 
 
 ^joWWtfon toaspiapeo to fl)C SDrnfraltp, to Prohibition." 
 ftoppjocfleijfiig0tbetc,upon a Contract be* 
 tU)&ntt)e patties fugBCfteo to be maoeupon 
 tfte lanu tDftWn t^e boop of a Count? , ano 
 not upon t^e ^{gt) &ea ; Sinn ttie fnrmife toas 
 penneo t^u0» 3lf ttiere toas anp Contract 
 maoebettoeentfte partfcsCas t^je Ubel fup.- 
 poretb ) it toas maoe upon t^e lano toit^in 
 tfteboopofaCountp, ano not upon tfte ^fglii 
 &ea. %13Z Court ftelo tbis fuggcttion lu, foj Suggcftion.' 
 tfte unrcrtaintp of it, ano ojoereo t|>at it 
 iljoulD be amenoeD anu maoc abfolutc , viz, SCfjat t^e Contract luasmatic 
 upon tbe lano, ^c, ^notbattljctoojoSjiftljereiDas anp Contract maocj, 
 fljoulDbeputout, bccaufetfjepmaocit uncertain tnbet^ict tftcretoaaanp 
 Contract o j no , ano fo bp confcqucnce oio ocftrop tbc tjcrp gronno of tlje 
 furmtfe. 
 
 Barnaby againft Goodale, 
 
 a I Car. Banc, reg. 
 Trin. ai Car. roc, 20 r^ 
 
 A M ?it Of CEtrorfoasbjonglit to rcljcrfc a luDgentcnt gftjcn in an a« Errjr upon a 
 (tion upon tl)C Cafe in tlje Court at Owfc bridge in York, ano tbcfirff Ju<i?«p^"f '" 
 Cttoj afgignco torn in tbc pjotcfs , bctaufc it toas bp fommono ; tofjerc. "^^fhcOie'^ 
 aattje action being an action upon tbe Cafe , tofjulj is in tbc nature of a" 
 SCrefpafg; tl)C ^?o£cfs fijoulo be bp jSttac^cnt, ano SDiftrcfa infinite, ano 
 not bp fummons. HButtofbisittDaflanftocrcobpRoll fnllitc, ttjat lincc 
 10 lacobi tWa manner of pjocccuing ia no (I!;rroj , ano tbat tbat Court Ijatb 
 no poloer to aUiaro a Capiat in an action upon tbc cafe bp tbe Statute of 14 
 H. 7, ttDootber light crccptionolDerc taken to tbe venire, but not inCttca 
 upon. But tbc main erccptton toau to t^e iuogcmcnt, toWcb toag cntrcn 
 tbus, Ideoconiideratum eft per curiam didi Domini Regis, Istjcrcas ( as 
 (t tDas objectCO ) it ougl)t to tiatje been , ideo confideratum ell per eandem 
 
 ys Curiam, 
 
 E'ror. 
 Capias.
 
 Hill. 21 Car, 
 
 Curiam , o j per Curiam prsedidsm. 3nD attl)c firft tbc Coatt fccmcD to 
 cncUnc, tfiat tW fcao a matcrfal eyceptton , fo; tftcfe teafons , viz. bctaufc 
 1 nfei ioiir infctf otCourts ouebt net to tljcto tWnga onlp bp impUcation;but t^cp ougbt 
 Com IS. to fljcVD tljcm OTpjcflp, anu betaufc ftirplufagcc <n fuel) Courtc arc <ll : Sinn 
 laftlp betaufc <nfcrfoat Courts oufebt to bap tbcmfeltcs ftrifllp to t^eft an« 
 tfent fojms , ano not to tiarp from tijem ; pet aftcrtoaro jutjjjcmcnt toao 
 a'firnici) except better tnatterCbonlo be QieUin, noca. 
 
 Maftcrman. •; 
 
 21 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Error upon:* * /p attton Of SDcbt toas b joojjbt io an Infcrlonr (Eourf , upon aniSDbU' 
 
 judf^emciu in _/\pation,to<tbaConi)ttton, fo? tJ^papmcntofaccrtafnfumof moncp 
 
 Dcbiponan at 8 Certain tfmc tljctem trpjctTcD ; but no place teas ItmitcDfn tbc conDl» 
 
 oM.gaaon. t(on fo J tl)c pflpmciit tfjcreof. 3InDgcmcnt teas gfbcn foj tbc piafntfff: 
 
 2Lbc SDcfenoant b jfngs a tojft of Crro j in tbfsCoiirt to rcticrfc tbto ^uogcs 
 
 ment , ano afcisns fo; (Erro; ; 2Lbat betaufc tbcrc appears no place of pap« 
 
 ntent io% tbc moncp in tbc ConDftion of tbc Wonn -, fo tbat bp tbat U cannot 
 
 appear iDbctbcr tbc tanfc of actfon Itetb IcltWn tbe jurfsDfttfon of tbc Court, 
 
 tobcrc tbc action toasbjougbto J not; tbcrcfo?cft fljoulu babe beenmaoc 
 
 appear bp fomc part of tbe IRecoju , tbat tbc monep iras to be pa<D tBftbfn 
 
 .tbcgurioDfttlonoftb^^Court, inbftb is not bcre Done, anotberefoje tbe 
 
 Err<^- 3luBgement crrontons : 2Cbc Court bclD tbts foj crro? , anD ojocrcD tbat 
 
 tbe 31ut)gcmcnt (boulD be rebetfeo , if (anfc tocvc not (bcton to tbctontra- 
 
 rp befoje tbe enb of tbc tctmt 
 
 Knights Cafe, 
 
 21 Car* Banc Reg.' 
 
 • • 
 
 Error upon a A ipsft^ ^^"^ V^^f^ ^38 ttiatie Of ccttafn boufcsfrt York , rcfctbing a 
 Judgement ZJLpearlp rent papablc in London, anofojtbc rent bebino an action of 
 pivcn in an jDfbt ioas b?ougbt iu tbe CitpofYork, ano juogcment tbcreupon giben foj 
 f ^r'Tn'r"^''" *^^ l^laintif : a:bc SDcfenoant brings a tri?it of CBrro j to rcberfc tbfs juDgc 
 went , ano afoigns tlrio Grrors. r. 2Cbat tbc iffuc upon lubftb tbc jungc- 
 mcnt teas gitcn teas not trpable toitbin tbe jurisfiittion of tbc Court, tobcrc 
 tbciiiDgcmrnttxiasgibcnj foj tbc iffuc teas upon tbc papment of rent, 
 liibicb tons parable at London, ano not at York, ano fo papment oj not pap- 
 ment ougbt to be trpeo at London ano not at York. Cbefetcno exception 
 toao to tbc Venire, toblcbtoasdcvicinetoCivitatisgencrallp, ano names 
 not anppariflj in particular tnbcnce tbc jurp fiwulD come: flfno to pjotie 
 tbtstobcagooDcrception, tbe}I5ookof 5 H. 5. toasurgco; but tbe Court 
 DenpcD tbat 3IB00U to be llaiD , ano citeo Gavel ano Gippoes cafe, lojac 
 aoiuogcototbc ccntrarp; tbat de vicineto Civltati* generallp , toitbout 
 naming a pariib in tbcCitp,is gooD: 3i5ut upon tbe firft circcption tbc 
 Court aDtiifcD. 
 
 Watfon 
 
 for lent. 
 
 Vcnne.
 
 HiU. 21 Car. 
 
 VVatfon again ft Nor bury 
 21 Car, Banc, reg. Mich, 
 2oCar,ror, ijtf. 
 
 T7^7 Atfon-b;oattl)t an Si&ion upon t!jc cafe naainft Norburv, fojASionupon 
 V V pjottiting a Commifsfon of 3I6anferupt againa Ijtni, l^'oktan^^-'"-'^ 
 tolbereof tie bjoUc open t)fs &l)op , ano toob.aloap bis gooDs ano e>t)op- 
 twote, tobercbp Ije inas fo otfcrcDUco t|)at f]e loft hw traoe, to f)f3 Damage , 
 &C. snotl)l0 t!)c Dcfcncant pieaos , tbctt tbc plamtfff oto Ijcrctofojc 
 bj{nsW5;3£t<onoftrefpafgfojtI)Elj?eaiiinc open of 1)13 feijop, anO fo; tijc 
 tafefng atoap of t)t3 gooos, ano Ija^ in tftat 0afon rccotcrco Dama= 
 gcs a^ninft l)tm , ano ocmanoa if Ijc fnall not be t^crcbp bartco in t\)ii 3[ct« 
 fon; 0nDtl)atbc ftoulo be batrco tbc Dcfcnoanta CounccU allegco, 
 tljat a rccotcrp in one pcrfonal Slaion is a bat in all pcrfonal Slaims 
 touching tbe fame tfting, ano tljat bctc tlje Action of trcfpafg fojmcrlp 
 bjougftt , ano tbc 0£t(on of tlj: cafe noin bjougljt tecrc petfonal ^aaions', 
 ano tl)at tljcp txjcre botlj bjoag^t foj tljc fame tl)tng, ano tl)Ctefo?e tljc 
 plaintiff ougbt to be batrco ; 3it ttas alfo utgto tbat an Sletion of tljc cafe 
 lies not in tbts cafe, fo; tl)at , to grouno an Action upon t^c cafe , tberc 
 ninftappcat to be malice in t^e partp tfjat ofo tjpfact, anopjcjuoicc to 
 t^c pattp to tDljom tlje fact is Done , but tftcrc appears no malice bete , fo; 
 Icbat tuas Done is faio to b: Done , bp tirtuc o! a Commifoion of IBanbrupt 
 tDbicb ftall be intcn^eo a latofull autljojitp to toarrant t^c fact , ano not 
 gronnoeoupon malice, fotftat malice ano pjejuoiceoo notbotli appear, 
 but onlp Damage , ano tljat alone Ml not fuppojttbts 3ctton,fo; ncitber 
 fo; Damage alone tott^ont malice , no; fo; malice toitbout Damage Ml an 
 Action upon tbe cafe lie, 3i5:jt to tbis it iuas anfiucrcD ( to tobicb tbe Coutt 
 cnclincD ) SCbat tbis ;action upon tbc cafe teas not baougbt fo; tbc fame 
 caufctbattljc action of ttcfpaio teas fojmrrlpbjougbt, fojtbat tuas onlp 
 fo;tbeb;cabingopcnoftbc&bop, ano tailing afeap bis gooos, ano tbe 
 Damages be rccciticotbercbp.. but tbts Action is b;ougbt fo; tbe Damage 
 be futtaineo , bp tbc.lolTe of bis creoit , ano b{no;ancc in '-f 3 traoe tbccebp, 
 caafcD bp tbc S?efcnoants taking ont a <i;ontmirsion of JoanUrupt againft 
 bim, ano bpcolouttt:ctcofb;eaking open bis ^bop ano tahinoc a.^ap bis 
 gooDs , ano fo oifparaging \iim in bis reputation, \ibctebp 'be loft bis 
 traoe; ano tbongb tbebjcaUiitg open of bis &bop, ano tbe taking a= 
 toap bis gooofl be namco in tbis^^ction, as it teas in tljc fo;met Siaion 
 oftrcfpafs, pet it isfautbptoap of31nDucementto tbis ^action upon biS'n<J""m:nr. 
 cafe , ano not to recobcr Damages fo; tbat te;ong, ano ber: being 
 ttoo fetjcrati to;ong3 Done to t\it plaintiff tobfcboo not one ocpcno '-'^■•'""■^ f^''«- 
 apon anotber , tbe plaintiff muft b;ing ttoo fcUerall iiaions fo;'^"- 
 tbcm, ano not jopn tbcm in one taction, bcctufc tbe Damages muft 
 be fc^ctal itbicb are to be tecobetco, but if tbcp bao oepcnoco one upon a= '°>'"^ *^'" 
 notbcrbcmigbt batic fopnco tbcm in one action, ano rccobcrco jopnt°'"" 
 Dammagc6fo; botb: ano befiocs tbcfe tiro actions Differ in tbcir nature loyr.t aama- 
 ttnt from tbc otber , ano tbe tuDgements giben in tbem arc fetjcral, fo; tbc ges. 
 SuDgcmcntinanactionofSErefpafsviet Armis, as tbe firft action teas, 
 isCapiacur, bccaufctbcrc is tbctcupon a fine oitc to tbc iiing, but tbe 
 Suogemcnt in an jSction upon tbc cafe is idco in mifericordra , ano fo 
 
 35 2 tbougb
 
 Hill. 2 1 Car. 
 
 i-ai' n 
 
 tboticl)t{)cpififntffff)at]c3:uDgcmcntl)crcfnliia0rtfon upon tijc cafe, ft 
 cannct be faio Ijc fjat!} Ijao BiuDncmeiit altcaup ; fo j tJjst mult tctntcnccD, 
 nt lead a Jiiugcmciit o' tljc fam: nature, tobtcl) cannot be in t'ofa cafe. iJno 
 tcitljatiD'jicbtacbirctcD, tl;atU"t!)c panitiff flioulo rccotjct Damagcflm 
 tbto action , l)c aoulQ rcco^JctDamaijcs t\t)!ce foj one ano tl)c famc~tl)tng 
 tcMci) is arcafnft JLaln; it is anrucrcu, t??rititi3 not fo? t!;c fame tbtng 
 butclcerlpfojsnotbsr, anoff tcflioulBnotljatcitlisilction be tocrc initij. 
 otitrcmcDpfo; tI)CD:jmagcl)8ruffrefl in tl)C lojfo of t)is Crcuit, anu t^c 
 Damatrc in ijiij JCrace ; foj in tl)c fojnicr Action fje rccoticrco no camacrcis 
 fojtlint, fcjtIjegtirpneticttooUfliatinto tljcit confiDcratton, foj tfjsp 
 Ijao no polt)cr to tnUc anp Damages ijito tl)cit confioetation Inljic^ bap^ 
 pcnco after the gCrcfpafs Done, foj tobicl) tbe Action teas bjougbt, but onlp 
 fojtIjcljjeaUingopcnof t!je feiiop, ano tl)c taUing atcai' of t)is 0oods : 
 anDalt!)oti3f)f)emisbtattbef[rftl)atjeb;ocrebt bis Action upon tljccafe as 
 I)C Ijatft novc Done , pet li3Veas not compellable tijcreto but IjaDfjts (BieaU 
 on to fajirtg either an action tiponfcts cafe, o; an Action of SCrcfpara as 
 ctiOTs" flJonlOrtioftmaUefojliis aoiiantncc, fo?-tl)i3 election of Action belongs 
 to elicrp fnbjcit as his birtb-vtrajt , a:iD Ijcisnot to be IjtiiDjcD from it. 
 /idjouinatur. 
 
 Remington and Kingerby. 
 
 Mich, 1 8 Car, rot. 72f 
 
 Frrir m^ia = "Q Emin^ton gtauts a rent ort of certain ILanDs to Fawne tuitl) a clanfc 
 
 ludftcnicnt in J|[^ Of titftrefs 7 M\^ ^ nomine roenae in tl): Dccafo?, tl^c non papmcnt 
 
 inthc'c'm- thereof, accojDingtothctimcipnrttcD, the rent is bchfno after tljc time 
 
 nionpiea. ' IpmitcD bp tl)e nomine foeiaE. Fawne bjings a tojit Of ^nnuitp in the 
 
 xTommon picas to j ths 0^ reragcs of the annuitp,anD fo j the moncps Due 
 
 upon the nomine iroenae, anD hath ji'Dgement. Remington bjings h^s tujit 
 
 0' C^rroj in this Court tore^crfe this 3iiDgcmcnt,anD 0fsignc2foj Crroj, 
 
 • that the tojit of ilnmiitp ciD not lie foj the nomine poenap, though it iJiD fo j 
 
 the rent . fo; though it teas in the lOotecr , ano (Slcaton of Fawne to charge 
 
 cither the lanD out of UJhifh the rent teas to iffiic tcith the rsnt bchino bp 
 
 Dittrefg, anD fo to mal^c it a rent charge , o; clfc to bjing his tejit of 5Innu= 
 
 itp foj it againft Remington, anD foto charge his petfon ; pet he haD no 
 
 ftich poller foi the nomine rcEn3e,bccaure it teas in the nature of a rent, 
 
 Nomin- "o anDteasnecefrarilptoiffueontonhcHlanD.anDnottobcchargeDupon the 
 
 ix'. perfon ; anD it teas further allegcD that a nomine poenae teas an uncertaiit 
 
 thina a nD cosncs not toithin the §)tatntc of 2 1 H.8 .touching Btotojics as 
 
 a rent charge tothtehich is certain. Another cvception teas.that it appears 
 
 net in the 5RccojD;thatFawne DiD mal.E a gooD DemanD of this nomine pcenx 
 
 upon th? 3LanD out of tehich the rent teas iSning, as he ought to hate Done 
 
 befojc l)e conlD bjiitgan Action fo: it, foj though there Do appear to be a 
 
 DemanD , pet if it appear not to be a legal DemanD it is Null, ano the partp 
 
 Hjalltalic no benefit bp it, aDjonrneD. 
 
 Nuls
 
 Hill- 21 Car. 
 
 Kuls and Cheney 
 2iCar.B,R, 
 
 A^ Slctfon of tl)e cafe teas bjoanljt foj tl^cfc teoj53 , 3! oo acciifc pott Arrcft ciF 
 to be a 5ISIttc^,flnn require pou to be fcarcbcD , ana a 'ocrufct teas' g(= luc'gMr.cnt -n 
 tjciifojt!): plaintiff; tbcDcfmoantmobcs in arrcft of 3«t>3cmcnt tb^ton Jfofc"^' 
 tf)eUio:o0 arc not aflfoii able, bccaufcttfanotaUcrrca tbat tlje partp ac» 
 cufeoijaQDoncanpljurttO'XattcU oj otI)crli)trc, o; l)atl) bao anj? Com* 
 munkattontDitl)tl)cDeviiU ^m fo tl)c Court bclD, bccaufc tS)c; toojog 
 fpohcn DID not b?<n0 tbe JlJartp of lT?l}om tbcp tecrc fpoUcn Mii\m tljc Sta- 
 tute of 1 Jac, concctniiis ©I^ttcb.Craft, 
 
 Wingfield and Sherwood. 
 
 "^ 7 T 7 InoficlJ bjfngs an ;3[tfton of Coljcnant agafuff Sbfrwood W Error upr>n a 
 V V aLcffccfojpecrs, anoDcclarco tljatfjcbaD Cofccnanteo bp fn^iiuprment in 
 Denture tbat bee iuoulD not tcit Doton tnoje tpmber crotofng tipon tbe ^" ^^°" "' 
 lanBsDCimfcDtijanftifflctcntfojnccDfiilanoncceffarp reparations of tbe^°^''"*"* 
 bourcsanDbuiloinas let unto bint; ano foj bjcacb ^ioiants, tbat be ban 
 cutooirmtpmbcrto tbe Mne oftenpounos, anobao conl^crtca tbcm to 
 bis pjoper life; ano upontbia batba tsicroict ano a Sluogcmcnt agatntt 
 bini: iherwood brings a iDjit of Crrojfntljis Court to reticrfctbisSlutig. 
 mcnt , anoafflfgnsfojCrroj, tbat tbete teas tjarrancebcttocen tbe Co« 
 tjenant erpjefTcD fii tbe Icafe , anDtl;cCot3cnantfct fojtb in tbe Dcclara* 
 tion tobereupon tbe bjcatb toas afoigncD , ans fo tbe 3uoament teas not 
 giljen upon a bjcacb of tbe Co'ocnarit cvpjelTcB fn tbe leafe , viz. sCbat 
 I)eftouliJnotcuti3otDnmo;etpmbertbantoa3 nctcffarp fo; reparations; 
 fojbptbis bjcacb tbe plaintiff fuppofctb tbat the JDefensant bao Cot?e« 
 nantcDnottocutooumtpmbcr t*o cniplop to tis oton nfe, tobicb is not 
 tbe Covenant erpjcffcD in tbe Icafe, but anotbcr-. 3nD tboiigb tbe HDc= 
 fcnoantb^Dcut Dotontpmbcr, ano tontjcrten ft to bis oton ufc", tbis trag Covenant. 
 notabjcacboftbeCotJcnantcrpjcffcDtntbc BCnocnturc, cvccpt it be a- 
 t3crreatbatbecut Do\un moje tban teas neccffarp foi reparations , ano 
 coaljcrtcDtttobtaoiBnufe; aiiofoj tbis CDrcojfge 3!"03emeut teas re- 
 tjctfeo, 
 
 Whitwelland^horc. 
 
 Trin,2i,CarKrot, 227. 
 
 Hitwellbiougbtati action of JErcfparo foj affaulttng, beating, 
 ano toounDing bint , agafnft fotot fetjeral perfons: th:cc of tbcm , ,' 1 ""^ . 
 plcaonot guiltp, ano arc fount) gutltp ; ano tbe fourth pleaoa notan^AaTon o" 
 guiltp to part , ano tuCifies foj tbe reft, viz, SCbcluounofng, ano is Tr. iv»iie. 
 founo guiltp as to tbe irounoing onlp , pet tbe tcroict Ivas founo gcncrallp 
 foj tbe ipiaintlff, ano intirc Damages nffclTcD sno luogcmcnt citjcn , ano 
 
 3153 "a 
 
 \V
 
 Several J:- 
 nugf-. 
 
 Hill. 2 1 Car. 
 
 n iDjft of Crroj toas b joucbt , ana tljc CErtoj afetcncD tea© tijat tl)E nama- 
 gcsousftt not to be entire againft all, becaufetljattbe fourth pcrfon irag 
 onlp founu gtjf Up of part of tljc trcfpafa , to toft , tfjc tooanofng, arnj tberc- 
 fo?c as to Uintbc Damages ougljt to liafee been fctjercD, in relation onlp 
 to tlje tDounoing, ano not as ft fs, fo; fo Damages fljoulD be gfbcn ttofcc fo j 
 tl)c fame tftfng. j^frtt againft t^e tijjcc, aiiD tl)cn agafnft tbe foiirtl), 
 Uiljfcl; tbc iDourt srantcD, anu tclicrfco tijc iuDgcmcnt, 
 
 VV^ard and Coggin. 
 
 Pafc. 2» Carirot. 257. 
 
 Erro- upon "V \ 7 ^'^'^ b?fngs an Mion of Debt fn tbe Common pleas agafnff Cog- 
 
 an=aiauof V gin , anD DctlarcB tljat tl)c SDcfcnDant JH confiDcrstfon t<)at ftc 
 
 D.br. tbc^lafpitiff, attfjercqtiettoft^ieSDefenDant, bao folo ccrtafn icares 
 
 toSi.&.DfDafftime ant) piomifctoftfmtljepaiUtff, tftat be luotilD pag 
 
 ftjtti a fum of moncp io% tbem; anD foj non pa^'ment accojDinglp be bjfngs 
 
 bisection, ano batb a merDict anD 31«Dgemcnt. Cbe SDefcnDant bjfitgs 
 
 btstojftofCrrojinthfsCourttorefcerfc tbis 3i"Dgcment. anD afcfgns 
 
 foj dBrro; , Cbat an 0(tfon of Debt Ipes not in tbfs cafe , becaufc tbc Debt 
 
 tDbfcb tbe ©cfenDant pjomifeD to pap , ano fo?. tobftb tbe ^ttfon is 
 
 bjougbt , teas raffcD , anD became a Dutp before tbt paomifc maoe foj 
 
 tbcpapmcntofft, anDfoan^ctfonofDcbtcannotbegtounocDfojft on tbe 
 
 p;omtfe, ^nD tbe 1do?ds fn tbe Declaration do founD mecrtp upon a p;o- 
 
 cafc mffc , upon tobfcb a gooD confiocratfon foj an Action of tbc cafe map be 
 
 gtoimDCD; but not to bjing an 5l£tton of Debt* 
 
 Hogg and Vaughan- 
 
 (If TJ Oggbjings an 3[(tion of tbe Cafe againft Vaughan fo J tbcfe too JDS 
 iJdU'tnt in tlfpofeenofbim, viz. Thou art a perjured Prielt, anDbatba tjerDirt. Jt 
 a.. !.a.onup-iDasmot)£Dfnarrettof3!uDgcmcnt, that tbc Idojos iccrc not actfonable, 
 oniiicCafc. foj tbepfictnlficD no mo?c than that bc \ra3 fojflDOjn ; 315ut tbc Court belo 
 
 tbattbcpmutt be meant, tbat be toaa sailtp of pcrjnrp, fo; tobicfj be 
 
 mtgbt be enDirteo , anotbetefoje toere aafonablc. 
 
 • Mich. 21 Car. 
 
 Aftionupon J. <3ffamcs anD pjomffetbto B. tbat ffB, tofll pap 50l.foC.bfs fon', fobo 
 the cafe upon J^^pag martcD to D.tbc 2Daugbtct of I. at fucb a time , tbatlje totll pap 
 a promr.c. ^ ^^ j ^^ ^ j^^^ SDaugbtct at futb 3 time ; 8, paps tbe ;o I. to C. at tbe 
 time appointcD , I. fails in papment of tbe 100 U acco joins as teas agtaeD; 
 B.Dicsinteftate, anD E.aDminifters, anD bjings an Action upon tbe Cafe 
 againftl; upon tbispjomifemaDetoB.tbeSCettatoj; anD aDjnDgco tbat 
 tbc0£tionDiDtDclUiebptbcaDmfniltratoj, tbougb be ftoulD teccitw no 
 benefit if be Diotecotict. 
 
 Dickenfoo
 
 Mich. 12 Car. 7 
 
 Dickenlbn and Preftoii, 
 
 Mich, 2a Car! Banc. reg» 
 
 Ter. Pafc.2 2Car» rott aji. 
 
 ' It tKHrftof (Etroj tDasfa;ougI)tfapPrcfton, torcterfea 3luBgcmsnf a« Error to re- 
 •AgainaijimatYork; ann afsfgns fo j (Brroj, tbat tljc Vemre teas ^^ ^J^^^^]^"^^^^^' 
 BalUvafua, tuftcrcao ft ongftt to ^at)c been de corpore Comitatas, anO ft ' ' 
 
 cannot appear bp t^c Venire to to'bat place t^e 31BaIptofcli cytenosj ; ano tbe 
 JBalptofcU of tbe Cftp map eictenD futt^ct tban t^c Cftp , ant) upon t^fa tl)e Venirc 
 Conrt aDjuDseO tlJC Venire naught. 
 
 More againft Savage^ 
 2 J Car, Banc, reg.' 
 
 MOre miooto bjfngs an appeal agafnff Savage foj tfte Deatl) of W ^^^^^^^^ 
 ^^uabanD; Savage appears anD Demurs to tfie ojtgfnal U)?ft, ano^nj^^pp^f 
 fljetoafojcaufe, tljatfnoncpartoftlje tojft, fntteao of t^e tnojotunc (t 
 Inas cue , ioWif maoe tibe W.^it fncettafn %o t^fs t^e Council of t^e 0- 
 tftcr part anftoereD, SCIjat ft ougl&t to be amenoeo bp tljc Statute of 14 E. 3; 
 ano tbat t^e Mtft ougbt not foj fo fmall a fault to be abateo ; iBat to tb<s r 
 U teas rcplpcD , tfjattljc Statute toao onlp foj tl^e amenumcnt of mean 
 pjoceffl , anD not of ojfginal Mrft0 ; foj ojfgfnal fai?fts toere not amenoa- 
 ble , becaufc t!)e partp mtgW purc^afe a ncto luaft ff a former tocre naofiljt* 
 31n juttfficatfon of tbe tojit ft toas furtfjrt urgeu , tbat tftc too?D tunc fn tlje 
 iDjftUjasa m&r fojmal Idojd, anDnotoftbefnbftanceoftftc tojft; ano 
 tbat tl)e lt)?ft tooulo be good enougb toftljout ft; ano tberefo^e t^oug^ ft 
 toere mfftaken , ft teas not fo material , ac tljat tl)C tojit fljoulo be tftcrebp 
 abateo; 315uttbeCourtanftDereD,tftatano;fgfnalU)3ft,ff ftbc Defeaffce 
 in fo;m , f abatable , ff ft be not amenoable bp Statute , ano concef beD, 
 tbat bcre ft being fn an appeal , tebcrc Iffcis in queOf on , tbe tojft fs not a« 
 nten cable, tbougl) ft be Defectfbc but fn fojm, ncftbcr bptfje Common JLato. 
 no J bpanp Statute Hatu , noj can t^e partp purclbafe a neiD tD?ft , ad jour- 
 natur ; but afteriDatDo , viz. 9. Feb. 22 Car. tbetojft tuasquafteo foj tbe 
 caufcaifojefafD, ano bccaufe ft ofo not appear tfjat tbe femetofjo bjougbt 
 tbc appeal tuas toffc to tbe partp flafn at tbc tf me inben lie tnac Oafn. 3It 
 Xuas thereupon mobeo tbat t!)c SDefenoant mfgbt be arrafgneo upon tlje 
 Count, tl^ougb tbe isjit teas abateo ; but tt)c Court ^elo be coulo not , be< 
 canfe tbe Count ttiao founoco on ttje b^ft bDJ^fcb teas abateo , ano tbefe 
 booUs toere cfteo , 4 H, <5. 14, ano 1 8 E. 3 . 3 5 . upon bfeto of pjeKoents ^z 
 tuds aftertoaros offc^atgeo. ' 
 
 Luskins and Carver. 
 12 Car. Banc. reg. 
 
 T" ^^e Cafe toaa t^is, Anne Carver maoc Iber laft tof H ano tcCamcnt, anb Proiiibition 
 "*■ mabcs Luskins berCCrcttttoj.batfngbonanotabiiia fn Dftsrs SDioccr« '° ^"^^ ^'^^'^°' 
 >rw; Luskins pjobwtljctofUfn an infcrtoHrSDIoceffl, ano not fntl)eiPJC-fnda''M»nd»- 
 rogatfbe mus.
 
 Hill, 2 2 Car. 
 
 rogatibc Court , asljc oiigbttofjabcoonc, attranget fues foj JLettersof 
 ^omtiutttatton In tljc jpictogatitjc Court, Luskin ocCrco to pjoljc tbe tufll 
 tijcrc, ano tftat t)c map aDnitnlttcr,tf)c Court rcfufctD to aomtt Wmto an^ 
 ntlnlttcrtbcgooDO, crccptftctpaiputfnferurUp to tljc Cfturt to pap all 
 tl)c ILEgattco; i)Ht(fl)c(liallrcfHfc,lBni;grantlLettcr0ofaDmln<aratlbnto 
 t^c (tranger. Luskins motice in tt)fs Court foj a tojit of a Mandamus , to 
 Mtndamus ^^jj^^p^jj tijc pjcrogatitJcCourt to grant Wm tl)C aDmfnittration, acco?D{ng 
 to t^e tetU. Wc Court ruleo tbe otfter partp to ffieU) caufc tU ntxt uap 
 iDftp tftcp OioulD not grant futb atojtt; ann tncrc of clear opinion tljcp 
 jnigt)tDOtt, anoto pjOtJCit ,t^e CountCffC of Barkfhires cafe , Hill. »o 
 
 lac. anD t^e cafe of &t. Burien f n Cornwa 11 toas cf tcD , ano t^c fame JDerm 
 tl^c iDjtt iras granteo accojuinglp. 
 
 Fortcfcuc and Brogravc^ 
 
 aiCar.Banc. Reg, 
 
 An :aion up. Tpi^c plaintiff I) jfiigs an action foj Ijjcacb if Covenant upon a Sdccd, 
 
 (Ml a breach of | j^fjc R[)cfenoant plcaDs 3 pflrol agreement aftcrloaros , in Dlfc^arge of 
 
 ovcnaiu by jfjg fojjngi ^otcnant ; but t\)z Court belD tbc plea not gmD.ano teak tljcfc 
 
 ''Tka Differences, JDljat a parol agreement i)Cfojc a lijeac^ of it, mapfaeDiftbar' 
 
 gcDbp parol, anD fo plcaoeD; after a bjcacft it cannot be pleaocD in nit- 
 
 tbargc U)(tl)Oi;t fattofactlon alfoplcaoeD ; but a "Dtfcljargc map be plcaoeo 
 
 Concord, j^^ ^^^^ ,jp j^^. CoDcitant b? iparol oj bp iBDeco after a bjcaclj , imo toitlj^ 
 
 out fatidf action. 
 
 Broome and EveringJ 
 
 Hill. 2 1 Car. Banc,l\cg» 
 
 Hill. 2 1 Car. rot. 3 54. 
 
 Error to re ' A SuDgemcnt toas gibjn agafntt tbcSEcttatoj of tl)c SOcfenDant , in an 
 
 vd fc 3 ' *■ xVactlon of 2Debt fo j rent , anu tW juDgcmcnt teas retitcD bp a fcire fa- 
 
 judjemcit cias aaainft tbc Crccutoj, anD a tjerDict tl)crcupon, anD a juDgement 
 
 even in » ^ag gj^g„ againft bim in t^c Common picas; upon tljisaiDjitofC'rroj 
 
 Sere jjoas «o ^^^ jjjoug^t in tl)c fcings JlBcncl) to rctcrfc tWs juDgement , anD t^c error 
 
 jud'pc'n'snt in afsfancD toas, t^attl^ctrpal teas infufficicnt.bccaufet&c Venire facias toas 
 
 debt. not KooD , anD is not belpen bp tljc statute of Jeofails , aiiD to pjotc tbis, 
 
 Bayn'ams cafe in tbc 5tl).lilcpojt'toascitcD. llBut Hales anflDcrcDjtbat 
 
 tbe Venire facias being atoarDeDfacfo?c it ougl)t, teas to be accompteD as if 
 
 no Venire !)aD been atoarDeD,?an faio it tuas like to a dedimus to tahc a fine 
 
 before t^e iojft of CotenaatitrucDfojtbtolcbptbcfinc,anDfoconcluDeD, 
 
 y^ tbat it luas bclpeD bp tbe Statute of Jeofails. But the Court took a diffe- 
 
 rencf, tobcre in trutbtbcrctoas no Venire facias at all, anD tobcretfjereia 
 
 Hrror an ill Venire facis as it is Wt, fo J tbougl) it bc as baD as map be , pet being 
 
 J-'' ''■' it is a Venire facias , it is not bclpcD bp tbe statute of jeofails ; but if tberc 
 
 l)aD been none , tl)c statute baD maaetbe trpal gooD toitbout it; anD ttjere. 
 
 upon Dap teas gibcn to fljcto caufe tobp tbo 3«Dgement ftoulD not be alfir* 
 
 mcD, PafcJj, 2 3 Car, t^c JuDgement teas affirmeo. 
 
 A ndrews'
 
 Pafc. 13 Car. p 
 
 Andrews Cafe-^ 
 
 Hill, 22 Car.Banc.Rcg, 
 
 AIRccognfjancc toas acfenoiDleDsco at Serjeants Jnnc In F.'eetftrcet , v^here s • 
 anoDclttjeteDanDcnrollcDat Weftminlier. %\)z Court ^dfl tljat Urefaca.upon 
 teas at t^e cUctfon of tfjc lilecognffee to bjfng ^ia Scire facias cft^ct in i on= > rccogni- 
 don, feticte tbc IRccognf ?ancE teas acfenotolEDgcD, oj fn Midlelex, iilSictc U '^"" ^*" ''« 
 tDasDelitJcrcD ano enroUco: IBiit aDjoutneo. aftettoarD3,viz.Pafc.23 Car,*"""^^'- 
 tite Court ijelD t^at t^e Scire facias ouslit to be tobcre tl)c recognisance 10 ta- 
 ken, anonotVobcreltfarccojoeU; fojtl^crcU bcgfnotofaea JRccojU; but 
 tW being {n tbe Common picaa , it toaa gcoD bot^ iuaps , ano tl)erctip« 
 on tlie pattpliaD ^f0)uDgemcnt» 
 
 Rooke and Knight- 
 si Car. Micb» 
 
 Mich, 22 Car, rot, 381." 
 
 r A BBuogcntent gitien fn tl^c Court at Dy m Church , a Ifmb of one of the Demurrer to 
 x\ Cinque po?t3 toas remofeco fap a certiorari <nto tfte ftinga Benc6; ano ' ^""^ ^"'" 
 
 thereupon <ffucD a Scire facias fo J tlje SDefenoant ,-to fljeto caufc ioljp tbCmentremo 
 
 upon a juJgc- 
 
 pafnMfffljoulD not bate crecutfort upon tl)c juogement; to t^fs tljc" 2De= "eJ ou't'^f'thc 
 fenoant appears ano Demurs , anotahes tbefc efccptfons, i. sn^at it igCinqnePorn 
 not erpjeffeOJBftcrc Dim Church is. 2ly,3|ntf>erctojn of tbe alias certi-!'y c<:"'°f»fi 
 orari , it is faio, ficut prius , ano not ficut alias. 3lp, tljc &^eriff in tfte re- B^nch "^' 
 tojn is not nameo linigW ano IBaronet ; neither ttotft be name himfelf bp 
 bis name of IBaptifm ano Surname : JBat the Court oio oijcr^rule all tbefe 
 f rcspttons^ ano sa\)c juogcment foj tljc plalntif. 
 
 Ai^adionoftheCafeiDasbjougbtfojtherctDojoc, Thou haft ftoirn,^^; ^^^^^ 
 my wood , ano the Court incltncD tbe toojos tocrc attfonable, but not .'he cafc L 
 ifbehaofato, thou hatt ftoll'n mp SCrces , ano it teas tain that a precipe words. 
 tolll lie of a tDooD ; foj it (bail beintenoco of toooDpgjounoj adjourned. Precipe 
 
 Helliar and Grace his VVife. 
 Pafch. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 A inaction upon the Cafe teas b?oughtbp Helliar ano his toffc, upon a ,/^- 
 pjomtfcmaoe unto them, curing the Coverture; ano it teas moUeo. ;heCa'rc"upon 
 (a ticrcict b: tng gitjcn fo? the paintffs)!n arret! of f uDgment,that thcaitfon an Aflun pHc. 
 ought to hatjc been bjougijt in the name of tijc^usbano onlp, ano not bp 
 the hucbant) ano toife ; anoacafctopjot^eittoas titeo out of Dyer, ano 
 upon this exception the juDgementtDacarrcCco till the other thoulo Wto ^'^^^' 
 caufetothccontrarp; Sno in this cafe it toag faio bp the Court, that if an 
 £Dbliption be maue to baron ano feme;that it is the better cpinion.that the ^°^'"'' '^""^ 
 baton map b:fng an action upon this obligatio.i i\i bis oton name onlp, ano 
 not name his U'ife, oj elfe he map at b<s clctttoii bjing the aaion in the 
 name of bimfclf ano bis U)lfc jopntlp, 
 
 <C Betfwortfc
 
 It) Pafch. 2^ Car. 
 
 I; 
 
 Prohibition 
 
 Betfworth and BetRvoith. 
 Pafcb, 8 Mail 2 3 Car. Banc. Reg." 
 
 fSCtoasmotcufojapjoljibftionto tlje pjerogatfbe Court tipon a fur< 
 . mifc tbat tl)c partp cto cnocatiout to barftarof fc one tljat teas legitimate. 
 SBut tl)C otftcr partp anftocrcD , tbattbe formife teas not true , anD urgco , 
 tftattljcfute in tljeip^aerogatilc Court Itiaflonlp, tobetber iLettcrs of aD= 
 Io'tiTp'rTro'n""<ft^3tfoniDcrcbptbcmVDCllsranteD, o}no,ano not concerning ©a- 
 gat.vc Court CarDp as tljc furmifcfsts fojtb, anD tbercfoje DcQres tbc pjobibitlon map 
 not be grantcD ; anufojconfirmationtbereoftbecafetoaaput, tobftbtoas 
 tbis: BetfworthbaDalr<fccalleDBridger,tDbo Dieu; after l^e taUea ano<: 
 tbettotfe calico alfoBridcet.ano Dies (ntcffatc; Bridget tbe fccono toifc 
 tahcs ^Letters of aominiftration of tbe gooos ano cljatcls ofbcr busbano 
 DcccafeOitbe fon of Betfworth fucs in tbc |9j3erogatf bcCoart to repeal tbefc 
 3lctter0of0Dminfttratfon, upon p:etcncc tbat Bridget tbe grtt luifc of 
 Betfworth teas pet lifting. 3in this cafe tbc Court oclibcrcD tbefe politt* 
 jutifdftion , onfl foUototng. i. 2Lbatoneongbtnotto fucfntbcCDcclcBaatcal Court,' 
 to ilBaftaru an iffue , but at tbc Common iLato. 2. Mberc tbe jSDjDfna* 
 Ordinary ^^ ^^^^^ gtanteo Hcttcrs of 0Dminiaration to one tbat ougbt to babe tbem , 
 tbcp ought not to be repcalcDbptbcm. ^ ^^erca futc is in tbc CDcclc- 
 Pfch.bi.-ion finiiicarConrtfojlanDsantgooDsi , apjo^ibitionmap be grantcD 80 to 
 tbelanus; an^tbcpmap pjoteeD tbcrenottoitbftanDing, as totbcgooos. 
 4. SCbatintbisCafeat'tSjcJlBar, ncitbcrJlBaaarDpof tbc ilTue, noj ma» 
 riaae is in qucCtton, as {sTurmifcD , but oulp tbe baliDitp of tbc ILcttcrs of 
 Incidents ^ominfftration , ano tbat tbc otbcr tbings are but as incioent to tbe matter 
 in qucftion. 5 . Cbat iuifc oj uot ioifc is triable at tbc Common ILaiD ; 
 T;y»i but inbetberlaltjfullpmarienlo?. not, is trpable in tbc Spiritual Court; 
 
 6. ■(Mbcre a tbingts trpable in tbe Spiritual Court , ano tbere is aito a 
 matter incioent to it , tubtcb is trpable at tbc Common Hato, tbcre a pjo- 
 Proiiibition l)ibition (ball not be grantcD. 7. 2i:bat a tbing concluocD in tbc Ctclcfiattical 
 Evidence Court toucbinglanDs, cannot be giben in ebtoence in a trpal at Eaiu fo;t. 
 lano. 8. Sf tbe Common ILato Differ from tbe Citil 3LaUj, toucbfng 
 tbclcgalitpoj.nonlcgaUtpofa tbfiig, if tbep toiU pjocceo accojBing to 
 tbcirlLato.a^joblbitionlies, bccatifc tbe Common ^Lato is to be pjcfcre 
 PioKbUien rcD. 2^be rulc Of Court U)as, 2nbata|9:o5ubittonflboulDbcgrantcD,ana 
 tbat tljC otbcr ftoulo Demur upon it; ann fo ft might be ocbatcD tohctljct 
 ap;chibitio«tooulDlicojnot, ano to (tap in tbc Spiritual Court in tljc 
 meantime. ' 
 
 Pafch. 2 3 Car- Eanci Reg. 
 
 O0t bjougbt an Miction upon tbc Cafe againtt I. S. foj pjefcrrfng a bill 
 ofenDictmentagainftbini, fo:ftealing of a spare, ano that tbc 
 ja.'pniKrf in granD 3urp founD an ignoramus , IrbcrcbpljctoasDifcbargeo ; tbc|I)lairt= 
 an jif^i ""rtiffobtainsa aerMctagainfttbcSDefcnDant. SEbcSDefenoant takes tbefc 
 "" '^■'^ ''''^- cvccptions to tbc declaration in 0rrca of Suogcmcnt, i . SCbat it Dotb not 
 appear tbcrcbp , that tbc partp tobo picfcrrcD ttie biu of C-noictment gabc 
 anpcl)i3cncc to tbegranD 3urp touching the bin. 2ip. gt appears not 
 that tbe plaintiff tens bcuno ober to anftoer tbc iTeionp, anD confcqucnt^ 
 Ip teas not mouaeo? pit, ano fo Ije can batje no^ujon: JBut tbc Court 
 
 ttapcD 
 
 An.h of
 
 Pafc; 15 Car, ^ , il 
 
 ffapct) Tljc^SuogcmcntTo another cap upon tfte cvccptfoiis taUcn , aiiD CjiT 
 fapcDtfjat an 3(t(on upon t^: Cafe Ues.fojpjoctidns one to be CnofctcD ,^ ,.„ 
 altt)oust)tl)cparti»l)imfclf Dottnot, anDttjatonemapejIjfbftabiilof CEn- "' "''"^* 
 D{rtmcnttoagranD3C"rrtiitI)out£»atl), ano tljcp map notldtlfianotng grand Jury 
 fine t^c bill , ant) alt^ougl) ft be crtlbUeu upon £)atlj, tfjcp arc not bouno to 
 fino ft , if tl)ep fee caufe to tbe tonttarp , anD t^at in t^e cafe at tlje barr tfcc 
 ^action mfgftt be ao ioell crounDcD upon tbc ftancal , Irbtcl) cteto to tbc 
 partp iDl)o teas CnoictcD , as upon t^e trouble mbtcb mis^t iiatc befallen 
 ijfm bp tcafon of tljc p?cfctrtns tfie bill agafnftftim. , 
 
 Hcllena, 
 Pafc. 23 Car. B, r. 
 
 Aifi Slalon upon tlje Cafe toas bjcugljt fc; tbefc u o;tJ0 , Hellena Is a 
 great Wicch, ano a ClierDfa fouHD fo; tfjc paintiff j Jt toas mo^fj'^J^ i" 
 ijcDtoftap SuDgement , bccaufe tlie toojDs >rcre not 0ctfonable, fo? tftcg "^ fa.onVi.1 
 BfDnotfljeto tljat tl)e pafntiff Ijao bclcftcbeD anp tftfng, oj Done anponthcCafc, 
 tl)fngtbatbjouel)t^crta)ftt)fntftccompaf0 of tl)c Statute i Jac. acafna 
 tSHitcti'Craft : ^uosemcnt tuao hereupon Capeo, 
 
 VVilliamfbnagainft Henley. 
 Pafc. 23 Car, Banc* Reg. 
 Trin, 21 Car. rot. 362. 
 
 Ai^ action of iDebt toas b?ougI)f upon an oblfaatfon , f|je concff ion -'^'"^ °^ . 
 uias, tl)atiftt)c2Dcfcnt)nntDtDfcllt!)etitl)e3 in Ranfom niorctl)atn,h^^';;i'"''" 
 fteOjoulopaptbipafrntiffactjafumofmoncp, butff Ije folo tljemnot,obiie»i «n 
 ttiat tftcn t)c lljDulD DcUter an obltcatfon to tl)C JDIafntfff , fo? tijc papmcnt 
 of a ccttafn fum of monep tljctcin crpjeffco at a certain oap tbercfn UmftcD, 
 am (01 non performance of tlje conoitfon is tfje jaction bjougbt. Stjc 
 plaintiff obtains a merDfct ; tlje JDcrennant mobC0 in Slnttt of Sufigc- 
 jnent , tljat \)t onsl)t to ftatje contjcnf cnt tf me fo j Doing of tl)e tftfngc er- Timr. 
 pjcffeD in tf)C condition, anotljat it appears notbp tljc IRecojD tijat fjc 
 Ijao conljcnicnt time , anOfotbcretanobjcacljoftbE conoition. 315«ttlje 
 Court telB, tljattftctime bcttoccn tlje Bate of tftc oblfaatfon, ano tfte 
 Ijinging of tlje Action tuas a conDenfcnt time, anD tftat t'ftcre being a fe« 
 tono tWng to be per fojmeD in cafe tbcfojmerlDere not Done, tljat tl)cre» 
 fojct^atfojmcrtljingougbttobeDoncinfomcrcaronablctfmc, elcc tljc 
 pattptooulDbetoomncljpjcfuDiceD bp ttsping to bate tfte fccono tl)ing 
 pcrfojmeo, ano tf)crefoje ruleD tljat JuDgemcnt OjouId bccntrcD Uiitljout 
 bcttec mattet (l^onlD be D^ctuco, 
 
 ^ * Savages
 
 1 2 Paic, 1 3 Car. 
 
 Savages Cafe, 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, B,R» 
 
 Err ' upon a Q Avage foas dSiififctcD foj fojcfng, antj pubUfiifns of JLcffcrgof erf* 
 
 ju'siun^nr jj jp^jp jp atiX\\tx moiicp, tiiio Ivas conttacD , nno Siiogcmcnt citcna- 
 
 d'a»cm 'Eainftl)<niupo»W3 0toncon'Crsfon, ano 100 1. fine fct upon l)tm,tt quod 
 
 capiatur. Girccptfons tocrc tahcn to tbis Jucgcmcnt. i. SEljatltcto not 
 
 appear Vnber be reccfteo anp moncp bp tjirttic of tljcfc counterfeit JLettero, 
 
 iioj at teljat time : Bat tljc Court anf'tocteD.tfjattbcfobftancc of tbo of! 
 
 Eiidiftmcnr. fcncc foj tDtjfcl) tc toas CnDtitcD tra0, tl)C forcing ano publifl)ins of tbc 
 
 Hcttcrs!, anonottbccollEafncoftSjemonej'; fo;i tl)oug!) Ijc ban not col. 
 
 IcctcB a pennp , pcttbcCEntiictnirnt iiasgooo. ^ fccono crccption luao, 
 
 tbrittbcCEncictnicntBiD not fap quod Counterfecit falfo : But tfcc Court 
 
 bclotDattbctoojDCounterfecitnctcffarilp implj^cD in it tbc too;D falfo, 
 
 ano fonot material Inbcttct falfo tocrc crp?eircD oj omitteo. jlp. Jt ira s 
 
 objcctcjjjtbattbepartpvcascommittcD bcfojc b^ teas con^ictco ; But to 
 
 Convftion tbfs tbc Court anftoCTCD, tbat be toas committee upon b<s oVo" confefsi. 
 
 on, tobicbf^acoiitictfonin 3LaVD,anDtlj631uDsement U)asbcU)£Ooo,ani) 
 
 aVfirmcD. 
 
 Needier and Giieff. 
 
 Paff ♦ -7 3 Car, Banc. Reg* 
 Entred Trin, 1649. rot. 
 
 NEedler bjings an iJcfion of Cot»cnant agafnff GueR, upon rirtfclM.a^ 
 monaatobicboHCtoastoalloii) fucb a fum of moncp to an umtt 
 l"b, c'.ch of '" ^^^"^^ ' '" *^^ ^"^ Clcrhs £Dfficc bp tbc fljcct , foj clicrp quite of paper be 
 Cov'cna'nr. flioulD Uuitc ill f oppins atio tncrofoing of bill0,anflDErs,&c.a0 luas crpjef- 
 fcDintbcfaiofltticlcs: ano upon tots Needier obtains a tjcroict aaainff 
 Gueft. 3ln flrrcC of SuogemcntBt'oers exceptions toere taken ano ober^ru^ 
 leo , but one toas iiifiCcD upon, tooicb teas tbics tliat tbcrc lr.23 mojc founo 
 in tbebjcacb of tbcCotcnant afsioncD tl;an luas containeo in-tbc Cot?c< 
 tiantitfclf, fo; it toas founo , tbatbebao notpapcofoj 72 (beets laf}icl) 
 luao 5 quire ano a balf.anDfo Damages lucre gibenfo; mo;c tban ougbt 
 Brescii to tc , fc J tbc Colicnaut tons to pap fo mucb tbc quire ano mentions not 
 anpbalf , ano fo> tbfs tbe 3uogemcnt ioas ftapeo: foj tbc Court faio 
 Danagcs. tbst tbc MtiXv VjouId not fupplp a cafus oniifllis to bjiiig it liitbin tbe Cobe» 
 i>urr'}-. nant to g?cunu a bjcatb tbcrcupon,<ibat ctscr tbc intent of tbc partpes irae 
 tbat tuere parties to tbc Articles, 
 
 VVincley and Fawfett- 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, Banc, rcg. 
 
 V.-1 f T d 
 
 Tro. \1\J Hitley bj'ngs an 0(t{on of aCrobcr , anu Conticrfion againtt 
 „(-?]"'' •^ * Fawfett, foj tabing b(s Cattcl faplKap of ciCrcfs, ano felling 
 r$*^" »ctci "' tljcm bp tjtttue of a toarrant of Commfffiloncrs of ^elrcrs fo j not pap. 
 
 m
 
 Pafc. i3Car. 13 
 
 fngofia tap ret bp tJ)cm totoaros tlje rcpatattcn of §jca taalls : tbr. iDc= 
 fEtioant plcaos all tfic fpen'all matter , bp tosp of juaificatton , ti)e ^\mu 
 tiff Dcmurro to tljfs pea, ano upon the ucmurret taUcc tbcfe exceptions to 
 it 1. SCotbcfettincfojtl) office Commtfston, in that ijc niclDS not 
 tl)attl)?ccof tbeCommifsfonerstocrcoftlie quorum. 2Il)C 2d evc^ptton 
 teas , tftat it\ Ijfo |31ea !)c ftaD not Ut fojtl) tljc 0utS)o;ttp of tftc Commifsii 
 oners; Eotbatttjc Court anfiriCTCD ft \Dfl3 not nccctrar)'. glp. SCljat tl;c 
 pea luas but arcumcntatiVe, ir.l)fcl) maiics it naugl-t. 4lj>. 3t appears 
 ttjattberc arcSoc.Slcrcs of ILano iDljfcli arc in tljc ftaiios of tijc fcinr, r.r 
 tctict) are not tarcB as bp lato tljcp ougljt : ano fo tt)e tav i^z uniuft, brcaufc 
 bpttienotturtntToftfjcm, a greater burocn tuas lain upon tftc reft of tl)c 
 3Lano,tl)an ofriafttoualittobe ; anDtbistl.c Court Ijelc a eooo cvccption , 
 anolalD tljnt tl)c iaingo 3Lanto arc tayable fap tl)c Statute. 5lp. Ebc &ta= 
 tutcisnotplcatseDasitougbttdbc. olp 3ti5ott)nGterp;tffc,tl)at Whit- 
 ley in tol)ofc occupation tljeJLanDs are tljat arc tajrco, is t!)c Sfsicnccfo 
 lynfeetftcotoncroftbciLanss, butfjcmap be a mccr ftraiiger, ano 
 not taxable, nojl)is bcafts to be folD. yip. 3t is not fct fojt^, tfjnt I;c 
 llicUjeD l)i3tiarrant,bcfo;cl)cm'0rsineD, asl)eouj?!)tto co: 5ntl)fscafc DiftciTc. 
 tbc Court firft fqiD tlbat one map Difirafn, ano fell tijc Cattcl of t:;c olri:er 
 of tte llano taicco, ojfeisiarsinnec.fo? nonpapmcnttljcreof, but boubtcu ^aic. 
 tubetber a ffranccrs Cattel jniol)t be aittraincD ano foiu : Roll luflice 
 toohtl)crcG-rccptionstotl)cpica. 1. SEftattljepeatifDnot fctfojtljtbc ^^■■*- 
 limits of tftc Commiffiion as it ouabt to do , ano teas tftercfojc ill. zip. 
 3l5e fait) il)e pica oucl)t to l)al3Cfl]CtecD, tlattljjec oftf)e Commifsioncrs 
 tocre of t^c quorum. 3lp. SElatitoiD not appear bp tl)c pica tljat tbc 
 Blanks tarcD, toljcrc tbcDfttretre teas maDc, arc iiit!)intl)c 3Lctcl , to be 
 tajccDbptlje Commifsioncrs. 45p. SCbcSEnvis of tlic lano of fuel) an 
 on^, ani)W3 3fBisnc0,ant)tl;t0{3toogcnaallp cxpjcffcD, anotannot be 
 icVpeD cquallp bp fuel) a tar. 5lp. SEljc plea fcts not fojtl), t^)at tljcrc 
 tnag anp notice giten to W hitley of t^c tav maDC bcfojc tl)c ciftretfc tahen, 
 as tljcre oucl)t to bate been , ano fo? t^cfe rcafons , he corcluocD tl)at tljc 
 pica teas not gooD. Bacon luftice l)c'.o. firft, tljat tljc partpbao irailico Waircr; 
 fcis benefit of tbe pica gifecn Ijtm bp tbc Statute, bp p'caotng fpcciallv , 
 anDb^ounljttomaheroocbtsplca, asljcliatftplcaijcij it, at bis otonpcs 
 till: ^e belt! lifectoife , tbattbcrcourbttobcnotfcccittrnof tbctaj;. ana 
 aDcmanDofit, befojeanp Diftreffc niicbt bctaUen, anD tbat t\)t pica 
 teas ccfcctitc in tbis* jlp. ;Ebat be cannot fell a ftranncrs gooDs foj tH ^°^"^^- 
 tar as Whitley is, fo; ougbt tbat appears in tbc pica. 4lp, i5p tbc Demand 
 picaitappcarSjtbatbcbatbciftrapncoonc iilcrc of iano fo: alltutaj:, 
 lobicbouQbtnottobc, anu upon tbcfcerccptionstbc rule lias foj tbc 2?c-. 
 f cnBant to (beta canfe bcfo?c tbe cnD of tbc SCerm, tebp tbc plaintiff 
 (beijlD not bate 31uD3cmcnt» 
 
 St Maurice Abbct, 
 
 Pafc. 23 Car. Banc, reg. 
 
 Sir Maurice Abbot bat) a Bluljgcmcnf againff one ano t:fc3, .mo tbjcc 
 pears alter Crcciition .is tafecnoutin bis name , upon tbc ^unce^^^"^"^" " 
 merit , tbc Ccurt teas motcu to tacatc tbis 3u!jrrcmcnt . but lu.vm-nr; 
 inoulD not, fo J tbepfaio tbat tbcrc teas no bc!p in tbis cafe, but bi' bjing. '' 
 lnsate;itof Crroj, except tljere can be anp fvatio pjotico in tbc pjoccco. 
 
 C3 fngS Eivor.
 
 14 Pa(c, ijCar.. 
 
 Fia^. tings , anD tben tbe Court toJuTafec o;oct to fj^lptbc partp gricfecD .- Sim 
 thereupon nilcD to cramdic t^c 5lttojncp , ano tt)C pattpcs U)|jetbcr tljcrc 
 toae Due p?occ0Dln£ts oj no^ 
 
 Villde Ghar/eton in K^nr, 
 Pafc. 23 Car. Banc. reg. 
 
 Motion to ' A ^^" ^^^ '^^^"^^ ^^ Charleton fn Kcnr, upon tofjtcl) tl)C Cojoitcr takes 
 
 ciuid. apie- JU^ an <nqucft ,anO returns it Into tlje <ErolDn £)fftcc: upontbts ap;i«= 
 
 fcntmcru andfcntmcnttDasDjaionupintljeCroton £)fftccasainft' t!je ViD.of Charlc= 
 
 lakc o« A- jQj, ^ anD founD , ano thereupon itTucs ircnt out againft tftc Vill t gt teas ' 
 
 mc.ccmcncs. niofccD foj tt>c Vill tol)atc tt)cm DtfcbargcD , 6p rcafon tbat tljc pjcfcnt- 
 
 nicnttDagnotsooD,fojftlDasgrounocD upontbc Statute of 3 H. 7. chap. 
 
 ano fctfl fo;tl) tljat fuel) a pcrfon teas Uf UcD at Charleton, ano tbat tl)c mur» 
 
 Dcrcr act aloap fn tl)c n(al)t , bp iDbicb ft appears t^at tf)C ViU.fg not lpa= 
 
 blc to be amcrccD toftljfn tljc statute : fo? tf)C murtbcrct ounftt to cfcapc 
 
 in tbi cap bp tbe Statute, ano not fn tbe nfgbt, anu foj tbis ft teas quaftco, 
 
 • A'^erccmen.s g^^ j^^ <3merccmcnt3 DlfctjargcD. 
 
 23 Car. Banc. leg. 
 
 Tor niuniinenr^^*^^""^^^^'''"^^^^**'''"^*^ ^" "^^^'^ Of fcfsfons, mane foj tbe 
 
 an order of I becpfng of aliBattaro CbtlD , anDtbcfcofccptfonstDcrc taUrn to tbc 
 
 the Seniors oiDcr: iFfrfttbcoaDcrluas, tbat tbc partp fboulo pap a Incchlp fum foj. 
 
 o( Pcacr,for jfte feecpfna of t^c Cbiio , tobcrcas no fucbojocrcoulo be maoclritboattbc 
 
 Sal'd ' ^rties confent , foj bp tbe statute be fa onlp compellable to fccurc tbc 
 
 |)ari(b , tobcrc tbe Cbflo teas bojn , tbat ft fljouln not be anp cbargc to tbe 
 
 fsarf fb- iJnotber erccpttoir teas, tbat ft appears not tbat tbe Suftfcca bao 
 
 anp potocr , to maUe anp juct at all fn tbe t afc , fo? ft appears not tobere 
 
 tbcCbfloiuasbojn , ano fo ft map be it toas bo;n fn an otber Countp, 
 
 lDberetbcfc3;uftJcc8 \inU no autbo:itp to ^ct anp tbing concerning ft. - 
 
 mpon tbcfe crteptfonsit toas quatbctv. 
 
 F<r a c-rii TT'^e Court toasttiobcB foj a certiorari to tbe Court of Sandwitch, fo 
 1 a.'i to r"""^' 1 remote four Cnotctmcntstberefoj tbooting fn a (3un, ano pulling 
 iv.ovc En<i;a upofapott, becaafc tbe facts, fojtobicb tbe partp toas Cnaicteu, toere 
 nicnts out ofjiotuonetnitbln tbe guristiictton of tbe Court; JSut becaafc Sandwirch 
 onc.tihc irasoncoftbcCinquC'pojts, ano ft bao been a qucftfon bcrctofo?e iobc^ 
 T.qu.-porrs.j^^^ tbfs Court coulD fcnD fucb a iDjft tbttbcr, SLbe rule teas onlp 
 foj cauic to be fteton tobp a certiorari (boulo not be grantco. 
 
 Tory
 
 Pafch. 2 3 Car. 
 
 Tory. 
 
 Pafc,:3 Car.Banc.Reg, 
 
 TOrybjfnasanSctionof Etefpafs, ana falfc tmpjffonmcnt aiTnintt 
 l.S.fimulcumaliis.&c. EfteS^cfenuaut plcaos not guUtp, ano a ™^\^^, 
 'CIcrDfctf0sfticnagafnaftimfojtfte|platn«ff; 3ttea0mofecDtn0rrea of ,„,^ .,ai^„ 
 SdDaement , t^attlb^ neclaratfon toas not gooo, becaufe U Declares a»of Trefp»iie. 
 gafnft I. S. bp name folelp , anu ft ong^t to bate been jopntlp agafntt bfm 
 toftljibe otbers, naming tbem alfo,bccatifc tlje trcfpafs toag jopnt, ano not 
 agafuft I. S. alone ; battbc Court tjelD tbattbe Declaration teas gooD, bc» 
 caufe it teas tcitb a fimul cum, altbotigb tbc pcrfons Incrc not nameo, ano DrciaratJon. 
 faiatbattbis teas tbeconttantcourfe of tlje Common ipleas: i3nD tbatan 
 ejedione firmaeagainft one fimul cum bao been rnlcD to be gooD , anDfo u- Ej aioncfir- 
 fto in tbe Common pleas, altbotjgb bcrctofo:e it batb been aD(uDg= mx. 
 CD to tbe contrary: pet tbe Suogemcnt teas ftaj^eo till tbc otbcr U)oiil5 
 mobe. 
 
 Jones againft Young. 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 Hill. 2 2 Car, rot. iSjy. 
 
 I Ones bjings an Action bfSlffaaltanB 315atterp agafnff Young, Young 
 juftifiesasferljantfoItS. becaufe, tbat Jones came to fiOi in tbc t^^^--^'.l?^^°\Z' 
 raiptfcarpofbisipaftet. SuDgcmcnt teas gitjcn foj tbe SDefcnDant: 21 mciu aeainrt 
 tD?itof €rro;toa3b;ougbt,anD tteo crcepttons taUcn. i. SEbat tebsrc-ihcPUintfr 
 as Young, baD in bis pea oflluftificationentitlcD bis fatter to tbc fcfcc- '« Trcffiiic. 
 ral JDifcarp bp tbe iSings ILcttcrs patents , be bao notlbsten ttiat tbe 
 Jaingtoasreffeooftbis febcral pifcarp jure Coronx, anofoitmigbt be 
 tbcJiingbaDnopotocrtograntit. 2lp. i$c Dotb not fljeto bis ^Letters 
 patents, tobicb be ougbt to DO, becaufe be Dcrfbes a title bp tbcm-, £Ebc '^'^'«- 
 rule teas to ftctocanfe^atntoap ncft tobp tbc JuDgcmcnt (boulD not be 
 tebetfeo, 
 
 T'hc Earl of Lpccfter againft Mrs, Sam ford. 
 
 Pafc»23.Banc. Reg. 
 
 I 
 
 j^ a STtobct anD Conbertion, bjougbt bp tbe Ear! of Leceftcr auafnif Mrs. ^°" '''>;' S. 
 
 Samford fo; certain 3;etocls , tbe SCrobet being laioto be in Kent, but','j'^^."';''.,Ja 
 tfjCilDffringtbcgooDstofcU, being tbc ContierQon of tbcm being m Lon- co.ive.ViLn." 
 don; 3t teas DoubtcD tobcrc tie trpal CjoulD be , ano tbc" Court fapcD, tbat 
 generallp a tranJitojp 0fiion is to be lais tobcrc tbc faa teas Done , pet tbc Vcnitc 
 partpisnot^pcDtolapfttbcrc , butmap lap itinanotbcr Countp,artD 
 tn tbis cafe it teas bclDbp tbe Court, tbat tbe plaintiff mat' b:.tng bis 
 miction tebcrc tbc BCctecls tecrc folo , ano tbat teas in London, as 
 tecll as ill Ken: , tobcrc tbc SCrobcr teas lato,foj p.irt of tijc grouno Ttcvir. 
 of tbe Action to teit tbe ConbcrDion teas in London, tbougb part of it, name* 
 Ip tbe Srobitjtoas laiD to be in Kent, 
 
 Bafdy
 
 vcrfc a luJg 
 nici.c in Noi 
 wicch. 
 
 n6 Pafc. 2 5Car. 
 
 Bafelyand Bafelcy. 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, Banc.Reg, 
 
 AWrft of CErro; toao bjougftt to tdjcrfc a Slntgcmcnt cftcn in N or; 
 ^ ^ ^ witch , ano t!)c Crroj afcfgncD toaa , t^t tljetc dId but fite of tfie 
 
 31«rp empancllco appear at tfte trpal, anu pet a mctntrt toas, gfijen , ano 
 3!uDgcn7cnt thereupon. SEfjc Court fa{o t^at a Cojpojatfon cannot 
 grant a tales, nct'tljcr if tftep tonlo , fiotlj U J)cte appear tlbat tijete 
 Tales. toaa a tales granteo, ano ttjerefojc t£t3crfeo t^e 31«i»gcmcnt, 
 
 Sir William Bronkcr. 
 
 Pafc, J3 Car. Banc.Reg. 
 
 Sir William Bronker toas bjongl)t bcfoje a 'lattice Of peace, upon ait 
 tnfojmation maoc , tljct ^p bao cbeatco one at plap toftb falfc Dke : tijc 
 conim*ittc^i\T 3"'^'^'^ rcqukCB I'im to fino furetfes foj We gooo bcbattoar , ano upon 
 a Uitt.ce of tjtS rcfnfal contmftg btm to pjifon. Sir William Bronker brings bfs habeas 
 peace for corpus t'.i tl)f3 Conrt , anD «pon tf)c retojn tbts otattcr appcar'D , tbc jp;f. 
 refufing to fc^g^ pjaprs bp \}i5 cotmccU to b? DcltDcrco,bccaufe tbcrc appeareo no mat« 
 foT'the'" od ^^"^ iamcimt upon tbe teto?n io^j' be fljoulD be commfttco, but becaufe tbe 
 bchiyiout (daoltx DefircD tfmc to amcnc tbc rctcjn,tl)e Court grantcD It , ann tooulo 
 
 not Dclibcr tbe |3jtfoner,bi:i took bati foj bts appearance, viz. tbe c£arl of 
 Good bchavi. Dover, anDCEarlofChefterfield. 0nDtbc Court tl)cnfafD,tl)at a Bluff* 
 o'-»r- fee of peace cannot fafnD one to tbe gooa bc^atlour upon a general fnfo?= 
 
 mation , oj commit b<m to |0 jffon f"o; tcfnCng to ft no fnrctpcs foj '^is gooD 
 imprKonmcnt beftstfout uponfutli Infojmatfon. 
 
 VVroath arid Elfeye. 
 
 Pafc, tj Car.BancRcg, 
 Hill, 22 Car. rot. 1224, 
 
 Aj^0rttonof2Dcbttoa3b:oug^it agaf:ifi Elfeve an unocr Sbcrfff, 
 bj) Wroath tbc litgl) g>T)CTfff upon a bono gitjcn btm to fabe Win 
 ' '',^ " Ijarmleffe, 6cc.tbc E»cfenDant plcaos tbatlie fcatb latcn btm fjarmleffe, 
 ?biipa"k°"'"to tDfs tbc plaintiff Demurs , ano IjclD a gooQ ocmtirrer, foj be ougbt 
 to babe plcaocD non damnificatus , ano not gnicrallp tbat be batlj 
 fabeo bim bftrmlcirc , foj tbatbc map bo in manp tblims , ano pet 
 tbc plaintiff map be tamnifpco in fome otbcr t bfngBtobcre in be toaa 
 alfo bouno to fabe Ijim tjarinlcEfe. 2Ebe rale teas to fl&ciD caufe toljp 3!«Dg* 
 incnt OjoulD uot be gil^cn Co; tbe plaintiff, 
 
 White
 
 Hill. 2 5 Car. 17 
 
 White. 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, Banc.Rcg, 
 
 AlJuDgcment toao gitcn in an flctfon on tl]c Cafe biottcljt bp an Sttur. ^•''?' '" «■'- 
 ncpfOitljlfctDOjWfpobcn of l)tm;Thomas White is a perjured Knave, j^.*^'"^ '""'i-' 
 and a fuborned Knave, fl MrU of CErrOJ toas bjougllt, ailD OltJCtfl EC- Adl M'i'on"hc 
 ccpHonis taUcn , but tl3c pj/ncipal lucre tltjo, i, S'oat tJjc u-ojos ar^Cjicf^ 
 notteelllart, fojt^cparcaBKflttJctDOjBs, ano fo not poGtitc enoualj to*^or<ib. 
 grouno an Action. 2, '3H)Z too jss arc not iSdtonablc, bccanfc it is not De= 
 clareo, tljat t^cpartpofiobomt^cptocrc fpoUcnlnasj of anp STraotr, 0% 
 baoanpoffice : 15ut Bacon luftice otjer^rnleDaUtbc rrccptions, ant) 0;. 
 ttttz taufe to he ftjctonncrt oap , to^p tbc lucgcmcnt fljoulo not be aifit= ^ 
 tncD. El)C Cafe of one Nicholas ano Webb IragaftCiiiiarOcitcD, teljcrc ^'''^' 
 SuDgcmcnt liias giben in t^c Common picas fo: calling an iltturncf 
 lanabe , toWtl) 3iuogemcnt toag faio to be aftctUjaros affirmed in tl)c 
 i5ingg benclj, 13 Car, Trin, rot, loa, 
 
 Saunderfon and Martin. 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 Trin. 2} Car. rot. 867. 
 
 f A 3!wDScnicnttoa0sibcnfnanacr{onofH)ebtupon an obligation, tOErrorto^e-' 
 ./\petfo?mfucb a pjomtremaDebptl)c£)bli20?,tot^c Obligee ; anoaverfca ludg- 
 Mtit of Cttoj tuas b?oagl)t to tctjerfe tijis 3!ut)qement. SLbe Crroj af= '"'"'^ '" ^^^^ 
 ngncDtnao, tbat tbe bjcacb oftijc p?omifc teas not iuell afBtgneo , foj it 
 tinnot appear Ui^cn t!)is bjcacft of pjomifc iBa0, Bacon luilice %\)e 
 b;eact) of pjomifc is tbcfolc caufe of the Action , ano it appears not to ttc 
 CoMtttJj^cnti;.at iuas, anofojtbia be rctocrfco t^je luDsemcnt, 
 
 Paine and <Skclcrom. 
 
 Hill, 23 Car. rot, 740* 
 
 Aj^aitfionof SDrbt teas bjottc^t upon an obligetion, tlje condition Demurrer to 
 mas, tljatSKeltrcmtljeSDcfcnoanttDitbbis W.iic fijoiilo appear at»P'"m 
 tftc S^arfljals Court , ano foj not appearing accojbing to tbe condition iuas '^'''5 "P°" "> 
 tbe action bjougbt : Skeltrom appears anD plcacs , tljat at tbc time of tfje ° ^•'' ^'"^"' 
 obligation t)e teas folus ec innuptus. 2Eo t^is |plea tljc plaintif? oemurrs. 
 RollcIufticefaiO, t!)i6 |piea teas not tlie fame luitb ne unques loyaimenc • 
 
 accouple,fo? one crtcnDcD to a feme de fafto,artD tfje otljct to a femcdeju. 
 re.JCbc Court tfjen aofeifcD of t!)c |Dlca.but Trin.eij Car.rulco to fteto caufe 
 tomojtoto tobp inogement ftoulo not be giben fo? tl)c plaintiff. 
 
 )E> Stough(oo
 
 1 8 Pafc.ijCar. 
 
 Stoughton and Day. 
 
 Pafc a 3 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Demurrer lit- QToughton an utiDctfljcrlff bjfngs ati SictJonof 2Dcbt agafnft Day one 
 
 on 2 DccUrn- O Of Wa31BaUfif3,upon an obUgatfon toft^ a conoJtfon to fate tljc unoct. 
 
 tioninDrbr.(|^etjffljaf,nl(.(j(.|„epecat{ngofpjocEtrc0, anuotljcr tbfnga contalHCD fn 
 
 KVrT '^•"tbcconnmon, anoafstgnestbcbjeacljoftljcconcWontofac, tliattfttJBaf. 
 
 ^ ' ■ ItffbaDnotCjccuteDfucIjbtstoartantfcntto fttm upon a pjoceac to tjim 
 
 tifrccteD out of tbc Cpcbequct to letjp Iffucs upon certain lanDfi. %o tijfe 
 
 occlaratfon tt)E JDcfcntant Demurs , aiiD fljctoo foj caufe , i, iSCbat tfte 
 
 toartant to b<nt ofrcctco bp tt)c unoctfljctffF, teas maoc out of tbc Countp 
 
 tobetc be teas unDcrfljcriff , anD fo coulD not be fafD bfs toatrant as nnDer= 
 
 ftcdff oftbat Countp. 2. Bjtfs not allegcD.tbat tbe mannonr of Addinfon , 
 
 tpftero be teas bp tiic Warrant to lebp tbe fCfues, fs toftbfn tbcl^nnD?cD 
 
 v/ar^ain. ^xHitxz tl)C JlBadtff batb Btuttsofctfon ; 0ni) tbfs tbe Court belb to be a goob 
 
 crceptfon . ano fato , tbat tbebjcatb afslgneD is not fljetoco to be toftbfn 
 
 tbe CoRUftton of tbe £DbUfiatfon ; betaufetliclBatlp cannot cicecnte apje* 
 
 cept out of tbe ^^unojcD Inbcrc be fs 55a<Uff ; ano SEbcrcupon tbe rule 
 
 toas tbat tbe IDlafntfif Nil capiat per billam, if canfB ioBrcnot ftcton 
 
 Tuesday foUotDtng, 
 
 Cook and Fincham^ 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 For vacating \ 3IaBgement Iras giben foj Cook , npon an fnfojmatfon npon a &ta= 
 
 aWritotEx- x\ tutc, c)cbtbitcD bpbftti on tbe bebalf Of tbelifng ano bfmfclf, tnbere 
 
 ecution. tbe fifng teas to babe ten pouncs of tbe penaltp recobcrco: Cook tabes 
 
 out an Cticecutfon upon tbfs 3iuDgcmcnt , to ictiptbe iKbole fum of monep 
 
 recoberentobfmtfelf ; asappearcoto tbe&etonoarp nponepanifnatfon of 
 
 tbe matter referrcu to bfm. tapon tbfs tbe Court bBln tbe tojft of CEpe-- 
 
 Execurion. cotfon to bc fUi bccaufc f t iDas etitftc foj tbe tobole fum rccobcreo to tbe 
 
 pattp, tobereas i o 1. toas one to tbe 3&fng , ano ojoerco a ncto Wrft of 
 
 Citccntfen,anDtottaptbemonepfn Court, tfll furtbet aobfce of tbe mat» 
 
 ter taben. 
 
 Claik and Pew^ 
 
 Pafc, aj Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 Arrtft of 
 
 AjpattfonofSCrobetanbConberfion teas bjougbt bp Clark, agafnft 
 Pew ano bfs tof fe , ano tbe 3?Ecldratfon teas , tbat tbe gooDs toerc 
 in laion"^ '" fOfn'J ^V t'l^ Baron ano Feme , anotDcrc conbcrteD ad ufum fuum, iDbcrcas 
 onihcc"^^ ft ongbt to be fn tbe plural number, to teft , ad ufum eorum, oj ad u(um of 
 Pew ano bfs tnffe ; fo^asfttoas, ftfuppofeotbe Conbcrlton to be mane 
 onlpbp tbe ^usbano, tobfcb fs contrarp to tbe action ft felf, tobfrb fa 
 bjougbt ngaintt botb, tKpon tbfs 3.abaement teas ffapcD tfll tbe otbet 
 Cboufb motje. 
 
 Long
 
 L 
 
 Pafc. 13 Car^ ^9 
 
 Long and Bennec^ 
 
 23 Car. Banc.Rcg» 
 
 Ongbjfnasan 0c«on upon tljeCafc agaJnft Bennet, anuocclatcs ,mt ^^^^^ ^^ 
 ...jftctooulD notfufictWmto tahe unum AcromliRnitoWcb^Ebaoroloto ,^jj,,^^„j -^ 
 him in fuel) a place, J^ftct a tacrofct fo j tl)C plaintiff, <t toas moijeu tit ,„ Aaion up- 
 ^Itteflofiuoncment, tljat tl)c SDeclaratfon oiigW to l)atiE been unum A^oichcCa'e. 
 crura bofci , anD not ligni, foj tbattoas uncertain. SDlje (Court fsiio , tbep 
 tDOulo^aotifcoftbc exception, bccaufe ft tjoas In an jetton of tfte Cafe Declaration. 
 2Cf)Cfamc2Ccrm3iuDgcmcnt toas gfnen, bccaufe HDamagcs onlp toere' 
 to be recoDcrcD , ano tbc ino jDo ufcD lucre but f noticcmcitts to aefcrfbe tl)e 
 tWng foj tobfcD SBDamagcs onlp luerc DcmanoeD , pet it micljt ^n.\>z 
 betu mo?ep?opcrlp erpjcffeo. 
 
 Barker and Marty a. 
 
 Pirc»23 Car. Banc, Regf 
 
 Tl^e plaintiff bjJngs an S^ctfon of Etefpaffe, antjteclarc0 agarnff tljefj^J^f^^ 
 JDcfcnBant fo} b?ea!jfng Usljoufc, anDtaWngalnap quinque inflru=;n jJ^Aaionof 
 mcnta ferrea , Stngliu, iFctters; ano a terofrt iuas foj tbc ^lafntfff.Trcfpafs. 
 Blttoasmobcofn^rreftof 3uogcment, t^at tlje toojo Inftrumemum is 
 notalBOjotfjatftgnfficsi'ettcrfl; but tbat it {p fo general a toojo tbat U 
 map crpjcffe anp otber t^ing ao iuell , anD tbat tl)c Angdce jopncD jritbit, 
 to interpret toiiat it mcann , cannot fjclp it , bccaufe tfjcrc is a p?opcr 318:= 
 tinU30?DtDl)icl)micl)tanD cunljtto tjaVebecnufCDto crpjetfc IFcttcrs bp. 
 Rolle 3!t!'tttce faiD , tW bp tljc Statute nil plcaQingB ougl)t to be in Latine ^'i"<''"6»' 
 ano et3erp pa'-ticular tbing therein ougbt to be crpjeffeo bp a Hatin too jo , if 
 tbctc be a pjopcr latin iro ?D fo ; it, ns bcrc tljcrc is, ano tbcrcfojc tbc pjo. 
 per JLatin liojD beiitgnot ufeo .. bnt anotbcr lo'oicb cannot flgnific tljc tbfng , 
 tlje AngliceDotbnogooo; but part of tl)c jDcclaration (ball be juogea to 
 be in (EngliQ) , ano fo it cannot be gooo, Sinn juDgemcnt tbcreupon teas 
 fiapeotiUtbe otber fboulD moije. 
 
 Curtice a.nd Columbine^ 
 
 Pafc. 13 , Car. Bine, Reg, 
 Mich, i2Car.rot433f 
 
 Curtice bjiiigs an Action upon tbc Cafe againft Columbine upon an Af- ^^^or to re- 
 futtipritbppavoU, toftno meat, o?inl!, loosing, &c,foj tbc plaintiff, v%rre » ludge- 
 ■jino to tcacb bim tbc tranc of a jncrccr- 2Lbis agreement loas aftcttoaroo mi-cu in an 
 bp confcnt of botb pavtpec put into iajiting, ciipou tbc trpal tbc plain- ^^j^!; "^g" 
 tiff obtcinoaJllerDict upon tbc paroll agreement, ano batb 3;uOacment *" ^"'^ '' 
 tbercupon, SLbc 2DefcnDant fajingc bis 2Clrit of CErro; in tbis vEotirt, anO 
 Slfctfmcs foj Crroj , tbat tbcrc tuas no Affumpfit Dcc^arcDupon, ojpio- 
 l3caftifficient, to toarrant tbc Slcroict ano 5uDaemcnt, becatifc tbatbp 
 rcauctng tbc agreement tolujiting, tbc paroll agreement became iplo 
 faiSotoiOjanoronojaictioncculDbcbjouobtuponit; but it o;:£ijt to bate 
 
 3© 2 been
 
 20 Pafc.2 3^^''' 
 
 been b:ougI)t upon tf)c Agreement crpjtffcD in tljc Dceo, anti t1)c ffTitc oagljt 
 to babe been joi'ncD upon tljat , anu not upon tbc tcrball agrccmcnt,iDf)(tb 
 istioio. 2ni)cnilcofConrt toafitofljciDtaafc tD^p Htioscnrcnt fljoulo not 
 be rctocrfeD. 
 
 Barker and Martin. 
 
 Pdfc.2 3Car.B.R, 
 
 Arrcft of j^ Arker bjfngs an Action of SCrcfpafg fo; an affaiilt anTi Baftcrpncafna 
 
 Tfcr'T"" '" i^Martin , fimulcum , «c. anBhatb a tlcrcirt againC Dtm. %t Ujas 
 
 " ^'' "^^ motcDinarrcftof 3;(jr)gcment,tl)attl)C Action ougbt to fjatc been bjougbt 
 
 patttcularlp , agatrtftt!)C other Crcfpaffojs together toltb tbc SDcfcnOant, 
 
 a?ie not againft tl)e JDcfenoant in pattfcitlar , toftb a general fimul cuni a- 
 
 gainft t?ic reft , lubfcl) f3 uncertain , ano fignifies noting againft tbc rctt , 
 
 anu tbc ratljcr , bccaufe tftc Action tacommenccDbj> bill, ano not b}> o« 
 
 rigfnal; altboiigljitcoalDnotbc gooDtbotigl) it lucre bi> ojigina! : but it 
 
 inaa fain bp Roilc luOice , that it map be tljc plaintiff cotilo not Arrcft tbc 
 
 OifjerSCrelpaffojci, ai;t) tl)nt betoillco it Ubcn be can, ano tljat be map 
 
 TicfriiTc. iDcUpjoctcDagainatbematDiViers times as be can taUctbem, but tbat 
 
 iabcnfosticr be Qjail bate bao fatisfaction foj tbc aCrcfpafa none bim from 
 
 anp one of tbcm, be cannot pjocccDagainttanp oftbeteft; anoittoas 
 
 ttilco tbat 3uDscmcnt fljoulD be entree, 
 
 * 
 
 Cook and Allen. 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 iuJ{.cmcnt A 3!tttigemenf gltenfnantnfctioj Court teas rcfccrfcD In tbis Court , 
 rtvcrfcd be Za bccaufe tbe Venire toac, Venire faciaijjc. anD CiD not fbkb) from 
 ciiifc the Vt-tebat place tbe Venire fljoulo bee, lubicb, bp Rolie luftice, ougbt to batic 
 Hire was i 1. jjpj.,^ cjpjgjfcg at large, it being in an fnferioj Court, anu not Initb an, &c. 
 '"•""'"'^""■^'altbongb tbe ufcoftbc Common picas be to maUc tbe Venire ftojt , toitb 
 
 Co:ninon «„ o 
 
 picas. *"5 ^^' 
 
 Tt\t King and Holland^ 
 
 Entrcd 1 6 Car. 
 Argued Pafc. 2 3 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 An agjiiicntf-p^ccafc tons in effect tbis. Copj'bolo Ivasnirrenujcutol. S.fn 
 vT'itt '^""' ■*■ **""*' tbatHolbnd an Alien, fljoalDtattc tOc pjofita tbcrcof to bis 
 otonufe, ano benefit , upontbisaninquiflftion toas tabcn fo; tbc fctng, 
 ano tbic matter founo: lubcreupon tlje lanos lucre fcifco into tbe ^aings 
 banns, ano upon a trpall concerning tbcfc lanos, n fprcial tueroict teas 
 founn , compjilTng tbe afojefaio matter. 2Ebc cafe teas argueD againft 
 tbcfeingsSEitlc, bpMountague of tbe Middle Temple, anD foj tbe JSings 
 title, bp Hales of.LincoInes Inn, SCbe fubftance of Mountaguct ArgU-- 
 mcnttnas, i. Co conCiDer tbe nature of tbc trult ; ;, Ciyj nature of 
 tbclanoout of toljicbtbe truft iuas raffeo; ano fojtljefirttljebcHi, bc- 
 caufe
 
 Pafc. 23 Car. 21 
 
 * caufc ft teas a truC foj an 0!ten to taae tljc p:oi5ts cftljchino, cnutntlat 
 tbcaUeiiljaD no c53te In tljelano; tl)crcfo;ctl;J lihijjcoulo not bate it, 
 as f)e mf gl)t !:a^B Ijan tl)c InnQ (f tbc ilUen f)ao Ijau anr cttatc in it : ano is 
 faf ti)nt tl)tfl truft u-as a tl)in5 onlp in Sitfon , ano Ucs in p?itftp , ano net 
 to be fcifcD npon bp anctl)£t ; anu MfD a aillcfn luan a parallel pctfoit (tt 
 labj to an Qiicn , i:x rcfpra of purr Ijafina of Janco, anfi lino a Cop(?)o{o brcti 
 furrcnoicD tbii0 fn triift foia •aillelit , tl)ei.o;oPoo:!!Dnctl)a\jG fetfeo ft- 
 anDtI)t3tsbiitatrul!:notCt:cutcD, itljfcbfsmtfjcntiiiacof a ufc at tl)e 
 Common lain , ano not an it is nolo bp tl)C Statute : bcftocs, tbis truft fs 
 talfcD out of Cop^boliD lanus, anD tticrcfoje tljc lifng cannot feife the lanDj 
 toWfb tljc Allien Ijatljnot, fojif l)c fljonlo , tUoLojo of iubom tUc lane is 
 !)clD, U)oulDb5p:c{uDfceD ; anol)CcftcDBeverIyestafC4. rep. 126, ano a 
 cafcfn2?Eliz: Hales on tbcotljcrfiDcitrguco, ti)atti}e l^tns flbnii fjatic 
 the truft, ana laiD tbcfc tluo gjonnco. i , jEljat tftcrc map be a truft raifea 
 upontbcftirrcnBcrofadopji^ol!); anu jlp, tijat tbc f-urrenocr fettles t!)e 
 truft in tb;iSUcn, anocitco u H.4 26. anoIjcfaiotbcretbi'njsVocrccon- 
 fiDcrablc, I. MbetbertftclungftjallljatiEanptbfng, ano tofjat^c (ftall 
 ftatc; 2. ^bctljer &: fi}ill i;al3c a nfc fo j an Silicn at tfjc Common lata , 
 0; a truft; 5. StTi;ctlKtl)c(l)nlll)al)catruttraircQoiitofaurc. iJno foj 
 tftc firft, be latD , ttjat tbe truft irao not a tbing met rip fn 2ttioiT , but an 
 ijercoltament ; ano partlp in poffcfijton. ano cftco Cooks Inftttutcs 469. 
 ano fafo , t^c rcafon toftp an Hlfcn mdp not parcljafc lanos is , becaiifc tfeat 
 tl^isiiiiigDommigbtnotbcfmpotjerdljeotfterebp, bptranfpojttng tbe te« 
 tjcnursoftljelanolntoa fojEtrt Countrp. ano putting a part of it nnocrtbs 
 fubjraion of afojcfnpjfncc, ano t!)e fame rcafon tomes to tlje cafe tit 
 qiicfiion, anotljcrcfojeisnottobc fuffereo; ano ctcrp aifcn t!)at put* 
 cbafctbisfaiotopurc^afctotijcufcoftfjcisfng, anofo Qjall it be in tl)i3 
 cafe , ano altfjougi) a tljfng mecrlp in action is not transferable to a Com* 
 mon perfon , pet is it transfcrrablc to tl)C iisfng -. but tijio cafe is ftrongec 
 fojtl)C?^{ng,fo>l)cre is not at!)ingmc;rlp in Jetton but mireo tuftlj ati 
 intcrcft, ano it is no rcafon, but tijat tljc lata icfjic!) toas maoe to meet 
 iDiil) tt)j fubtfiftp of fuel) alien piircljnfojs , fiioulo take place ftcre ; ano it 
 cannot be fato tt)at tljst lato teas niaoc to giljc rcmcop to tIjD iitng fo: tljat 
 t)c Ijao facfoje , ano a ir^eoffmcnt noia maoe in truft fo j an aitsn is all one 
 tcitb a uf c at tftc Common laiM ; annljctftcDip. jac. tbattrufts maoe to 
 &t. lohn Daccombe of annnftrcs ioi tl)C ILojo Summerfetc attafntcD of 
 2EreafontocrcaojuDgcotobcfo;fcitcD: anol)Cl)clD,tljattI)ereis nooiffe* Daccoirbe, 
 rcnccbcttDEenatruftraifeooutofa Coppbolo ano otijet lanos , ano if Ijc 
 Ijat!) an intcrcft Ijcre in t^c p-.cfitf, t{)c feifurc is gooo, though he hate no in- 
 tereft in the lano , fojtIielanDmaplcfcifco bpthcpjofits^ yH. 5. foj.p. 
 15ut Rolle luftice DcmanOco of Hales, hotothc iiing ftjall be intitleo to the Tide, 
 profits of the lano, tuhcre he is not intitlco to the lano it felf:- ano faio, that 
 the Chanccrp cnnnct compell one to Crccute atruft foj an alien, ch»n«ry 
 ano that a truft teas int'Cntcu onlp to atioio the statute of afco, 
 ano faio , that a truft is not a thing in atfion , but map be ari Trdi. 
 fnl^ctitantc oj a Chatell as the cafe falls cut. aojournco po» 
 Ilea. 
 
 D } Whice
 
 Ple». 
 
 Pafc, 2 3 Car. 
 White and Pynder. 
 
 Pafc. 23 Car, Banc, reg, 
 Mieh. 22 Car, rot -,40.' 
 
 ^^^nJyl^^' f i^ an 0ctton of ilrofeer ano Contcrfion , t^crc tuas a Demurrer jopncu 
 
 ucnce. 1 upon tfee cttoencc ; anDtljercnpontljc Court DirettcD tbc Jnrp to fino 
 Damages fo;tl)e|D;aintiff, If upon tl)c argument of tt)c Demurrer tlje lain 
 ftoulD be aDjuDgcD fo? fjtm , ano tt)cn t!>e partfcs DcCrcD tftc 31urp migbt be 
 DifcIjargeD, ano rcferrcD tbc matter to tl)c ^uDges.to octcrmfnc tl)5 latD 
 upon tl^c ctlcence. 3n tbts cafe Rollc ^ufifce tooU tbfs Difference , to left 
 
 Rcc ui. betlreen pleaotng of a lIctojD, anD ctling a IRccojDin cttoencc to a 
 3[Hrp. 3f It be plcaccD (t muft be fub pede figilii , oj elfc tfjc SaDgcs cannot 
 juDge of (t. ISiit ff ft be gifccn fn cbtoencc, tbougl) It be not fiab pede fi^illi, 
 
 Evidcncf. ttjc Surp map fins It, if tljep tjatic otbcr gooo matter of fnDucemcnt to pjobe 
 ft. flnotlje partpcis in tbfc cafe toere aDbifeD bp tljc Court foj tbcir olnit 
 erpcDftion, toicttijerctobciffucoa venire facias de novo , ano to tuaibe 
 tl)CDcmarrcr upon tbc eblDcnce,becaufc it toas not gooD,noj couId bjing tljc 
 ntalter in qucflion bcfojc tliem tljat tbep migbt Determine it , foj one partp 
 faitbttjereisatojit, anD tbc ot^er faftl) tbcrc is not a Icjit, tobiclj is bare 
 matter of fact, ano not fo; us to Determine but foj a 3urp , ano tl)e Demur- 
 rer ougbt to bavc been toijetljcr t^clBjitbegooDojtD^etljeritbe baD, ana 
 fljoulobabe anmittcD tbat tl)crc loas a lojit tyel quel , anD tljcn Ijao tbe 
 loljolc matter come legallp bcfojc uc , to tott , tD^etfter tlje el3iocncc gibeit 
 to tbc 3urp be fufficirnt to j tbcm to finD a ticrDfct fo j tbc plaintiff upon ttic 
 fffucjopneDojnot, 3l5ut tljc Court Uiill aDbifc. • 
 
 Hamond and Kingfmill, 
 
 1 
 
 Pafc, 23 Cars Banc. Reg, 
 
 A,r<n „f VJJ Amondb;fngs an 0ctioiT upon t!)e cafe againff Kingfmill foj tljcfc 
 
 ludg, irc u JlJ too JDS, fpohcn of l)lm in relation as Ijc is a SuCicc of pcacc,to luit Mr. 
 
 iiianAOjon Hamond DiD put in ofl)io olstt beao tl)cfc toojDs in m examination taUen 
 ^of thtCaieiorijpbfm, viz. I. s. DioCcal ttocntp ll)ecp Of fucl) 3 mans , anD foj fpeabing 
 
 '*"''''' tbcfe otljcr ir!0;D3 of I)im; Hamond was a debauched man, and is not fit to 
 
 bealuiticeof peace , anD Ijat'ia rcrDtct agaiiift tbcDefencant, toijomobes 
 In Slrrrft of 3uDgcmcnt tbat neither tbc fojmcr noj tlje latter teo^Ds tocrc 
 actionable, fo? fo? tbc former too jDs, tljat be DiD of bis oton bcaN'put in 
 tD0j3s into tbc eramlriatton,arc toojcs uncertain, anD Dubious tobat is 
 meant bptbcm, ttibetbcrtbfitbeaDDCDanptlingofbisoton inbcntion, to 
 tbc eramfnntfon irbicb tons not confrffcD bv tbc cjaminant , oj tl;at l)C onlp 
 pnt the fubaaiiceoftbc matter confetTcD into too:Bs ofljig oton cnDifling, 
 ar.o If b; Dio no mojc tbat teas julllfiablc , ano fo it fljall be tal>en b:re ra= 
 
 tbct
 
 Pafc 23 Car. 25 
 
 tfiet tt.an in a too jfc , anc Crafncs conllraaton to grotinu an 2laion npont 
 
 ant) f 0? tl)c fctonD toojUo^to faj> XT,at\)c toao a DeDaiicbcDman, ano not 
 
 tDO jtlJi" to l)c a ^uUke of prarc^tljej' cannot fcc fcancalous. foi ttjcp arc fpo= 
 
 hen of Wm in relation to iDl^at ftc u as in time paff, befo?c ftc toas a 3[nftice 
 
 of peace, ano not as fee iras at tbc time of t!)e fpcaBing, ano it is no 
 
 fcanoall to fap , a man tjstb been ocbaticIjED, fo j it map be l)c is note otbcr. 
 
 leap eg. J5ut foj tftefirft Ido;ds it Irag anflnercB bp ti)2 Conncell on tbc 
 
 ot^er CDC, that tf)cptrcre actionable, foattepmuC be tabcn acto?Dino to 
 
 Common tonflruction , v iz, ttiat be ijau acocu not onlp irojDs of Ws oIdh 
 
 Intention to tJ)c rramination , but tljc matter it fclf eipjeCeo in tljorc 
 
 tDojCfl lubitt) teas not confclTcD fap tfte craminant. ano as to tfte latter 
 
 too? us, it toas anfiucreD tftep tocre alfo Actionable : ano a Cafe tuas cftco 
 
 tj^crc guccrcmciit Iras citcn aoainft tbc SDefenoant fo? Taping of one, t^at 
 
 tc teas a tojrnpt SiiDge. Rolle lufticc teas of opinion , tftat tlje firft tnojos Cafc. 
 
 tecrc actionable, but not tfje fcconD.foj toojBs fait^ be ouglrttobe taben ac- 
 
 tojuing to nfuall, anO Common conftrHCtion,tftong^ t^ep ate not to be ftrai* 
 
 ni:Q,fojotbctliiifcamanmapbcaburcDbprabtilitp, anoQiall bate no re. 
 
 meDp , ano Inogement map be giten l^cre foj tbe firft Ujojds, ano not foj ludgement. 
 
 ttjc fctono , tbe S^amagcs being fctcraU , but if tbe Damages ^aD been fn- 
 
 ttre tbcreifSpDgcmEntcoulDnotbcsiticn fojbotb tbe teoaDs, it cannot 
 
 be gitjcn at all. Bacon luffice mncl) to tbe fame purpofe as Rolle , ano fafD, 
 
 tW tbe fittt iuojDiJ ftall be meant, tbat be aDDeo too jds of bis otnn fntjcntl^ 
 
 on toitbout anp inftruaion of tbe partp, foj oftentimes Dubious tnojDs tbaO 
 
 bctahcnintbetDojfcfcnfe upon confiocration of tbe Circnmftances t^t 
 
 accompanptbem, anDbc teas alfo of opinion tbat tbe fccono toojos iuere 
 
 actionable, ano are as fcanualons as tftc former. BJaDgementtoas gf= 
 
 ten fo; tftc foimet tuojos , ano foj tl^c lattec tlje Contt tDon'tt 
 
 aQt)tre> 
 
 Barrett, 
 
 as Car. Banc,Reg» 
 
 reft of 
 
 AiP action of gCtefpaffe teas b?oagljt foj Digging In Ijis lanD, anb carrp* :^ 
 ing atoap a certain number of loaDs of cartb.anD a taerDict teas fo; tbe iuXVm 
 IDlaintiff. 3t toas motJCD in arreft of BnDgement tijat tbe Declaration in xrefpalv 
 teas incertain , fo j tbe Ctefpaffc is laio to be Done in lano , Iping in Dibera 
 lEotons. alp. 3;tis not fljetocD tobat feinD of foil t])t cartb teas tbat toas 
 carpeo atoap : but botb tbe etccptions toete obct.rnleD , ano 3laDgemcnt 
 tales to be entreo ni{i caufa, ^. 
 
 Conisby and Fairfax. 
 
 Pafc, 23 Car, Banc. Reg» 
 
 A31uDgcmcnt toas giten In an action of ffirefpafs in tbe Contt of Owfe* g^ ^or m 
 bjiogc in York, la toritofCrro; toas biougbt in tbis court to tebctrcvctrtaiud/c. 
 tbe 3uD3ement,manp ej;ception3 not m^ltial at all toete tabc«, ano man? "lem in 
 
 j.Trcrpafle.
 
 VciiilC. 
 
 F 
 
 2 4 Hil. 2 3 Car. 
 
 otbcrs tftat tecrc ?)c!p3iJ bp tftc c!crDl(t;but tbc t^jccT^f €r«ptfone uiccF* 
 1 , 2Et)C jramaccfl lucre Ccdarco to be ad valentiam (juingint. librar. infteaO 
 ofquingent* fo; t!]erc tij no Tiic^ iDOjD as quingint , to cppjcfaanp number, 
 fo:- it" U be meant to crpjcfs i^tftp, it ougbt to be quinqaagint. but quingcn:. 
 fi^n'fiCS 500. 2ll'.2Et)C Venire toae CfrcacD Balivis de Wapentagio , aHjercas 
 tbcrc ja no fut!) too jp, fo? t!je teoro to crpjcfs a CSlapcntaUc is Wapemathi- 
 um,rotbntitonnlittObc de Wapentachio,a:iD not Wapentagio. jlj-SLljC Ve= 
 niref?, Venire facias de b4iva, anD fapcsnot lobat 113nliiDiciv,\D5)tcb(o anter« 
 tafn, ano it cannot be fenoicn, tD'jitljcr it cvtcuBa ano upon tbcfc Gytcptiona 
 tbc ijuDgcmcnt InasrnlcD to be reWrfcDjCvccpt better matter fbcton ^a-- 
 turuaj? foUoiiinS. 
 
 Pafc 23 Car- Banc Reg. 
 
 anEndk?.'"^ V G')cccptions Itjcrc taUeu. i. =|^j (jSinOiacD fo:.ufin5facultatempirto» 
 nient (ox uCwo ris, anO COtl) UOt faj' panis hiimani. 2lp. ^t is fOJ baling panis tricicij-Xng- 
 ihe TraJc oP ]ice, ^^oiifljolQ bjcau, toSjcrcas tt Qgnifieo ohIp bjeaD mauc of CClfjeat, ana 
 a Baker. notWiH^olD bjcHO , foj tJjat map bc mat)c"cf otljcr cojm jlp. jrojba-- 
 
 bing panis Aflfiftoitbout a baft fo; panis Afsifs. tilpon t^cfc ©pccptf ons it 
 
 toss qnadicbt 
 
 Pa(c. 25 Car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 ■\7 J0otx a motion foj qtiafliing anCntifitmcnf agafnft one foj appjcljcnDfns 
 
 ^.rET/ft'^^ * S4imp;{foningbtm,t[;criC-rccpttonstDcrctalvcnto{t.i.3it faprstbat 
 
 .'cnc "fcr 'a'rr. I)e appjcljentieD i (nip?ifoncD tb: partp toitboat a liSarram, tobcrag it oujjbt 
 
 >iRg aiij in.- to bate been abfque aliqua rarionabili cauia/o; in fomcCafc© a man map be 
 
 ;)iiruni!!g one. appjebtnecD ano impji'oncD tuitbont a ^Slarrant , bnt in no Cafe teitbout 
 
 a rcafonabic catife.ilp SEbcCBnoirtmcit ii5,tbat be cio not Ctjcto btm tbe canfc 
 
 tobp be app?-CbcnDcD ano tmpjifonco tbc partp , ano tbat be is not bouno to 
 
 DO, ano vet tbe partp map bclalDfallptmp;ifoneo. jlp. 2Dbe CDnDitt. 
 
 mc'it Dotl) not fap,tbat ')c appjcbcnoco ano impjifonco t'^e aartp falfelp, aa 
 
 it oasbt to babe Done, Ctpon tbefc deceptions it loas quatbco* 
 
 Drake ancJ V^Vhitacre. 
 
 23 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 Hil. 22 Car, Rot, 1518. 
 
 Arcflofjude- A i? )^^'°" "P*^" ^^^ ^^^^ Uasbjougbt, anba tacrbfctfounbfojtbe 
 ir.cnt M) an A |i)laintiff foj tbcfc tiJO^Ds, Margaret vvhitacre (viz. meaning tbc 
 f.aki: I'p.a 3i)iaintifE) did fieal ray Wood, and I will fend her to Bridewell. 3ittoa0 
 
 ti,: csfcior jj^j,<jpg j,, g^^.^j (,f ^nogcment tbat tbctoojus tocte not actionable, foj 
 DoubtfuU ivoios as tbcfe arc ougbt tobetahcninmiiiori fenfu, ano Mood 
 berc map be anoerttooo Canoing Mooo, ano net tidooo tut oolDn, ano fo it 
 f nirtl not be SCbcft but a Strf fpafs : on tl)c otbcr fioe it teas anrtucrco,tbat 
 CSaooD feaH bcrc be unocrttoooGIooo cut col»u,anD not ffcjn:jmr,3ito being 
 f Qupi«9 iyitb tbc tooios Margaoif VVfait. ere IS a SLbfcf, tobtcb arc fcattoa- 
 lous 11.0:03 tbrr iljall be itit£ip?'etcD e quallp fcanDaious,Ayrc 5 Higgin;; W 
 * ' Cafe 
 
 wu;ds.
 
 Pafc. 2 3Car. 25 
 
 C&tc teas cttcD to pjotic it, tobcrc ft toas auiuBgcDtbattlicfe tDojO0,He 
 is a thief and hath ftollcn my Corn, ftiall fcc tlliBCTttooD of (lojncut DoIdit, 
 anDnotftanDmg,anotfter£fojcarcaatonablc. Roli luftice faf , it tnao a 
 ffrongCafctbnt t&c attion ioill Ipc. J^otiiit^ttansing Suogemcnt toag arc* off. 
 ttcD till tijc otljcr ftotJlo mol^r. SZljb lc<i6 acai" motco Trm, 23 Car. ano tljc 
 Court ftclD jtbatttjefirft IrojDs alone tocre actionable, but infteti^cr couplca 
 toft!) tbe otl)cc tbep tocre actionable, ti)e Court teas oiiJtoeo, viz. Bacon 
 a gain ttie 5ction,anD Rolls foj it. 
 
 Pale. 2 5 Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 T ip an action of Crotoer anu ContJcrGon, ann a tierDfct foj tfte ipiaintiff, Atcft cf ludg- 
 -•it tea0 motcDfn arrcft of Juucemcnt t^attticpafnttff Dio Declare fo^ri»cnc ioTro- 
 JBoolis % foj a»tocUf ngs founD n contcrteo, ano Dot^ not QjelD toftat JlBoohs. ^^^^j'^"^'' ^°"' 
 viz. toljetl)cr Englifti, oj Latine,ojtoi)at otftet BlanBaage, m% tol^etftct 
 3LaU) boofea, EXtinitp, ^bpCcS, oj of anpotfter Subject, anobccanfctje 
 tottj not Declare toftat fojt of Stockitigs tljej? loerc, Vobetfter tooUen , too- 
 fteD, 0^ Cltj, fc; JBut tbe Court ot)cr-ruleD t^c Cjrceptiona ann fain , tfeat 
 OlBoohB toerc not tilings of DitJcrs fpecies, be tbcp of to^at ^Language 0?. fnb* speder. 
 ttcttftcpmapbeof, neitbcr tfte fetocfeings, foj toerc tftepfilk, oj tooUcn, 
 0; tooftcD , tliep toere but Stockings , anO fo ruleo 3|uDgemcnt to be 
 cntrcD. 
 
 The King and P lace. 
 
 Pafc, 15 Car,B,R. 
 
 Place toas EdDfctCD before t^C HojD' Finch anO "lattice Crawley foj 
 fpcabing toojos againtt t^e Uueen spotljer of France, tfte toojoo toets fu"°^,'Jfc''„" * 
 tbcfc, The Q.ucen Mother is the Whoreof15abplon,flieisaWhore ande"ven""'o"nan 
 hath hadaBaftard; upon tbfs CnDictment juDgement toasgiten againtt Endiftmcr.t 
 tl)c 2DefenDant, 51 tKJrit of Grroj. toas b;ougt)t in tt)i« Court to retjerCc^°f "°'<i-- 
 tlje iuogemcnt J Cbe ^rrojs afsigneo toere, i. SCftat tlje pjocceDinga up. 
 on this CnDictment toere too fpecDp, ano to illegal; foj t^e toljole pjocccD- 
 ings upon ft inere actcD in one nap. 2 ly. SC^c CEnDf ctment ipcc not, foj It 
 is founoeo upon tt)c Statute of Scandaiuramagnatura, anD^icrecanbcno^""*'''""' 
 fuel) great S»canDal, foj tftat i0 foj taojDs fpofeen ofa peer of the I'^calm,"''^ "''""'• 
 ano the ©ucen i^othcr is not fo. gly. SDfjerc is no Capiator upon tbc Holl, 
 as it ougtjt to fjaUe been , tfte SDefcnDant being not in piifon at tbe time 
 oftbe luDgemcnt gitjen. 4ly. 2Cbe (uogement is tftattheSDefcnDantftall 
 be impjifoneo foj a pear toittjont bail oj mainpjifc, toftereas he oug^t to 
 Uc DelibereD upon paping W iFine. Adjourned to the next Term. 
 
 Pafc. 23 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 AiP action of 2Debt toas bjoagftt upon a iBiu penall , anDatcrfifrtfojAreftofjudp- 
 tfte |0laintiff. Jt teas motjeo in arrett of juDgement , SCftat tl^c '>.cnt in Debt 
 plaintiff hath not IhclrcD, that the SDefenoant ofo not pap ti,e monp "P'"" ^'^^ 
 at the Dap limiteD in the 516ili, but onlp faps, non folvit, &c. »!y. ^e Dc. ^ 
 elates, that the SDefenoant toasbonnotopapfuch a fnm Legaiis monets, 
 anD Dot^ not fap Angliae , but the Court otcc- tjiUD bot^ the eicceptionsj ano 
 tnlCD tl)e jpiaintiff to tabe his JuDgement. 
 
 C Pafc,
 
 Hn.2 3Car^ 
 
 Pafc- 2 3 Car- Banc. Reg. 
 
 Ajpotfon tons mattcbp one Colon agalntt anof^ct ncfgbboar bojoe* 
 rfng SDoton, foj a Mrft to make tftcm rcpaft t\itit fences ; 0nD it 
 to m.kc <hcm tone graiitcD, but ft toas fafo bp tbe Court , tl)at tljc Mrft fo grant, 
 
 keep iiicir CD Qjoulo bc but in tbe nature of a Scire facias rctojnablc (n tl)li5 Court , to 
 Fences. enable t!j m topleaotoit, anDnottotompcUtftcm toDoUiuttiiout being 
 aotnUtcD to plcan. jpottoKljftanBtngtbc opinion of NoySlttojnpdJcneral, 
 ano tl)c olD IRfcojD of Ed. tf)C 203. time pjoDuccD^crctofojc bp Ijim to 
 fttcngt^cnlt Nota, 
 
 Sclie fjcijs. 
 Plc:». 
 
 ^ 
 
 T'rin. 1 3 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 lo «3y Prv A (potion loaomatjc upon an Affidavit to ftavlPJOCSf'* out Of tbis Court 
 <c;\ tMi a Dc /\acratnft tl)c partj' foj a Deodand, bccaufc l)e ban papcD tb?ee pouno foj 
 odic.d. Itto t;)c Inngo ufe to §>ub HDcputp Almonet upon a compoCitfon maDC 
 
 Cc'tlficatc ^^^^ Wm,B3Con Juftice, pjocurc tbe ODcncral 2r>cpntp ^almoner to aPlutOln,' 
 Noiicc. " Icogc It ano pjoturc ^Ijj Certificate to tfte cowrt, foj oftljc S>ub'H)cputg 
 tnc can taiic no ncti'cc. 
 
 Trin. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 To qvnni a!> T'^^sCourttoasmotJCDtoqtiafljaCntiictmentoffojclblccntrpupontljefe 
 
 Hiuiictmcni. -■- ©vtcptions. 1. SCIjcrc Is no aDtttton Of tftc Countp Icftcre tbc part? 
 
 ctfuicibicEn- QjjjciiQ ti)nt maDetl)efojttblecntrp,a3tI)creougl)t to bcbptlic statute of 
 
 Al\itioii ^ ^' 5- ai'O toitbout tljls aoDltlon nopjoccracan faeatoarDcDtooutaalo 
 
 tl)c partp, foj It mutt bc DircctcD unto tljc Countp iBbcreljcoVDCllc. ilp 
 
 gCbcrc Is no Countp crpjeffcD uiJjcrctbc till lies In U)b<clj tl)c fojcctoa? 
 
 cemmlttcD. tmpon tl;cfe exceptions It toasquaOjeD* 
 
 Trin. 23 Car. Banc Reg 
 
 To difcharpe \ ^ (Snutctmcnt tuas pisfcrrco y rears bcfojc, aaalaft Count Arun. 
 
 oi>c cnJ.a^a ,£\del foj rccafancp. 3:t Iras noto motfeo tliat l)c tooulD pleao Confojmt< 
 
 for Rccuiai'tp^ but In rcgarotljat Ijc mtitt plcat) it bp 3 Certificate unucr t^c IjanD ano 
 
 <=y- fcal of tbe 51Bifl)op of tbc SDioccs, anD Blftops ii ere noU) taben aluap bp tbc 
 
 ^^ ^arllamcnt,l)c teas DifablcD to DO It, but fjao a Certificate unDrrtbcljanDfl 
 
 Cji'LS. ^"° ^^^^° °^ *'"^ spinittcr ano- Cburcb^uarDens of tl)c |)arlfl) Uifjcrebc 
 
 DlBClt, upon fl)atl9tcCiifplng bis Confo^mltp, ano tberct!ponitlua3p:ap= 
 
 ED be migbt be DifcbargcD. JBut tbc Court an'.toercD , tbat tbcre is anotbet 
 
 temeDp nitcn bp tbc statute , tobicb be migbt bal^e folloii:eD , tbougb tbe 
 
 fojmer teas tal-.cn ainap , to luit, to conform at tbc ^efsfons , ano it luas ■ 
 
 bis oton fault tbat be batb lott tbat aobantage bp remoljing tbe CEnDtctincnt 
 
 bitber bp Certiorari, auD tbcrcfojc Vuc toill not at pjefent Dcllticr biittj 
 
 but iMlll confiucr of tbc Statute , ano ftap tbe ^loccfu In tlje mean 
 
 timp. 
 
 Trin,
 
 Tfin. 2?- Gar. 
 
 Trin. 2 3 Car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 1%, tons moftcD f o tl)tConrt tli<it tijcre loss ancErcctJtton tmlp ftracD out of ;ufa:"of,'"ouc 
 t^fs Court anolrcturnablc bcrc ttjis 2ncrm,anD tfjat Once it fffiico foitl),t!)C of ihr Cnm- 
 SDefenoant l)aDobtatrrcuan3niun(t(onoutoftl)Cv3:;bancerptottoptl)ccFC-«^y to ft»y 
 tution. 2nbc douTt anftoercD, tijat all t!)c 3!uDacg toerc agrccn that an ^n- "ccuion. 
 junMon out of tbc Ctjanccrp Ipca not after a Sluagcincnt, be tbe Mil put iit 
 bcfojc oj after t!)c 3uDgmcnt (t n:5tter3not,l)ut ff after a 3;iiagcmcnt there 
 be a Mrft of Crroi b:oual)t to reljerfc it, ano pcnoing tftc tSarit an 3u3««' 
 aion be obtainco, Q.. tobctljct it Ipc o; no by the Reporcer. injur.aioo. 
 
 Bnicr and Sowthwell. 
 Trio, 23 Carol. 
 
 ERuer bjouglEit an afifon upon tbe (Dafc upon an AiTumpfit to pap fo maci) '^r''^ -f J"''?- 
 monp fo? Currance folo unto fttm difcomputs ndo fo j four fpontho. %ifz ''^l^^ Tvo"/' 
 SDcfenbant Demurs to tbc SDcclaration fo? tfjc incertatntpoVit, bccaufChTcsfr.''^ 
 it is difcomputando foj fouri^ont^a , ano CfpjcffctI) not fo? ftoiD mucl) be 
 fljoulo Bifcount, auD fo tberc can be no certain baintnajjcs gibcn , ano upot? 
 tbifl it \ija0 ftapcD till t^ept^cr partp mobc. /fo^l-f^- 
 
 Whiteacre and Hill well. 
 
 Trin. 23 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 Hill. 2z Car. rot. ijiS* 
 
 Vpon a^croict ftab foj tl)cpiafntiff in an action upon tfjcCafe foj \Wt -,£-.;on on the 
 iDOJbS Maf^arct Whitacre is a tbict &: hath ftollen my Wood , and i will ^j,,. (or 
 fend her to Bridewell,3;t luas agcin bp t^c pafntiff mobcn fo: Kuogcment, ,vo. ds. 
 becaufc tbc wojus toerc actionable, ano fljall be meant of Cfflooa rut boirm $ 
 not ftanoing; ano it toag faio, tbougi) the firft toojos fljonlo in tbcnifclfecs be 
 Doubtfull, pet arc tijcp mace certain bptbctuojoo tbat arc conplra init?) 
 tl)em. llButBacon JuftiicDcnfcD ft ano fato,tI)at BridtweHioa pjifou fo; 
 Cojrectfort, ano not tlje fe>I',cr{fFs pjifon fo; felons, anotbatoncmapbc 
 . rent tbitbcr altfjougb tbc offence be not !clonp,ano tbat t!;c cutting of CGIooo 
 fianoing is to be puniflicb k itli tobipping, ano fo tfjc partp map be fcnt to 
 Bridewell foj tftat offcKce, aniifaiD,ti)attbclafilto;ti3ar"cerplanat03pof 
 tbe fo?mcr, tbat be meant not tbc factcbargco upontbe plaintiff to be felo- 
 np, but bao not tbc later toojoo been aoneo to rjplain bis meaning, tbe for- 
 mer alone arc clcarlp actionable. 51But Rollluffice bdo tbctoojDsastbcp 
 arc laio to be actionable, ano citeb Hyfords ano Stamps Cafe, Trin. 1 1 lac. & 
 DolemananDYoiings cafe, 5 Car.anD Smith ano Wards Cafe, 21 lac, anO 
 faio 'bat in tl'c Cafe at JBar, tb&t tbc latter toojos lucre cumnlatibc ano 
 notfntcrp:ctatibe, ano ttjat tobere tberc arc ejipjcfrcpjcccocnt iiojosto 
 maheoncaSbief, tbcrcougf)ttob^tiolCHttoo}D0rubftq!lcnt to giiicthcm 
 anotbet intcrpjctation,anD not toojBs U:l)tcl) map (jc tahcu bp implication , 
 astljcpatcintljisCafe, Adjourned. 
 
 ® i VVaf
 
 J^ __ T«n;3 Car. ~ ' 
 
 VVatfon and VVatfon. 
 
 Trin,33. Car.Banc. Regf 
 Hlll.c2Car.roM687» 
 
 /« on of A -^ ^^'°" °^ ^'^'''' ^^^ b?ougftt upon an £)b'{natfon tet'tfj conuftfon to 
 
 Dcbrfornot /iL flaiiD to AH almtD, 2Ll)c SDcfcHDant plcaus HC arbttrcmcnt maoc- 
 
 pcif .rm„, jEfjc ^Dlajntiff rcplpesj , ano fcto fo;tl) tbe aUiatD , ano flfstgno a bjcac!) • 
 
 '•>'-=^"i. tljcSDefcnDontoemuro, anofojcaiifeaiclDS tljat tfje alnara to miccrtafti 
 
 flnDrot finalljo; it is, tl)at one of t!)E parties fljall pap fo much monep to 
 
 tl)c otbcr as ftall be Due fn confcicncc, ano tftat cannot be hnoton I)01d mm\) 
 
 ft map be, auDconfcquentlptlierc is no atoart), but botb parties are at ii- 
 
 A n mccrtjm ]}^xtv to fo to lali) as tl)Ep toerc bcfo jr, ano fo no cno is maoc bctluccn tftcm 
 
 ecod ''°' ^'fcptbeatoatDaccojDing to tbc intent tljcrcof, anotljcfc boolis lixrc citcD a= 
 
 gainfttljealcatD, joEd.4.fol. i.ec4.9H.7'foI. H, 8 Ed.4. fol. 20. Jt 
 
 iDas nilco bp j!)c Court to (Dcto taufc tol)p luogcmcnt ftoiilo not be anainft 
 
 lljC jpiaintlffper nil capiat per billam. 
 
 The King and Placq, 
 Trin 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 Erixr to re- "-p ^z Cafc betlBCcn t!)e King ant) Phce aDjourncD, Pafc' zj Car. tras a- 
 nic'^'^r" .'"'^ * sainmotca, iDl){cl) itas tl}ic: Plpcctoas inaicteo before Finch ano 
 !i'n En'il d'- Crawley SSuCiccs Of £)pcr ani3 2ncrminct , fo j tftcfc toojus fpohen againft 
 mcMt upon tfte ajuccn inotljEt of France, viz. tbc£Uuccnmotl)Ctistl)e ®3l)o?e of Ba« 
 -' ' tariitc faylon, ano is a ttHljoje, ano batb Ijao a JBattarD, ano all t5)c i^cblemcn tl)at 
 damn ^^,{^ j,oj jppj^ i^„f[j j^g ngajnft i)cr , arc lloaucs ano Uafcalls. SCo tl)ia 
 "^'""'- cuDictmcnttbciircfcnDantpIcatJca . ano toao founo guiltpbptlic 3!urp,ana 
 Sutgcmcnt citicn againft bim : tElijcreupon l)C brings bis tOrit of Ctroj^ 
 iutbiflCotirtto rcDcrfc tlje ^uatrement, ano afsigns tljcfc (Srrojfi. i» 
 afainfltljcbcDpcftljcCnDiamentitfcIf, ano tbat Ije ougftt not to be €ti- 
 tirtco foj tljc Uio JDS, bccaufc tl)cp arc neither fpoUen againft tbc (TommDii 
 lain no;i againft anp Statute laVo. 2. Againft tljcpjocccoings upon tl)c 
 6i;2t£tnicnt, n ticlj lucre againft lato , being too fpccop, foi l)c tuaa CnDid:» 
 ED bcfojc Jtifiiccs ot ilDper ano SEcrmincr , ano trfcoin oncoap, Inljcreas 
 tl)creoug!)ttol)alicbecn 15. Daps betfeiirt t!]c pjcfctring of tfte C-noia. 
 nrcnt.anDtbctrpal. 3. SCiic Venire is againft lato, foj tftc Court Dio 
 cl)ufc,trp,anoftto;ctl)E3iurp, tub'tl) ougbt not to be. 4. ipart of tbe 
 Suugement is , tljat tbc SDefencant ftjall be bouno to l)i3 gooo bcljatiiour , 
 lul)icl) cannot be upon fuc!) an Cittiitmcnt as toas befojc tl)2m, 5. SHfje 
 C];nDictmentootI)notrap,tfjattl)c iDOjDs tuere fpoUcn contra pjcem. <5. 
 ir.art of tl)c ?HT?2cntcnt is, fliat be fijall bcTct upon ttjc piHo?p, ano lofe 
 l)?3 cares, \x\}\i\) no lalu Icarrar.ts, but onip to be fct tl)erc to tl)c tieto of tbe 
 impiifo-n-.cn; people, iittlja papcr on f)io Ijeao. 7. ZC'ic guoremrnt is l!)at be llball be 
 fmp?tronct3fo;iapcac toitljout bail , inbfc!) OHg!)t not to be. Ko tbis laft 
 exception t!)c Court anfircreo, tl)c partp migbt be fo committeo ; 5IBut tt.cp 
 fa'D, t{)st t'oc 2ulltccc of £>i'er ano SDcrmincr cannot tr v an (f-noiument tl;c 
 
 fame 
 
 ■ I'cS 
 
 Scsnilo.'i 
 
 Wjgiiaiuni.
 
 Trin.2 3Car. :9 
 
 fame tiap , noj 3«fttce0 of peace at tlje fame ^efefons in toljicb ft JCaa p?c- "^'ya'". 
 ferrcD ; anot^epciteoonc BarnabyesCafcn Car. ano Pridians Cafe, <> 
 Car. 5 23 E. 4.ec Plow.44.115ut t^cp fatDjufitcEs cf Cjj,TOa»' trr an (EnDfd:- 
 mcnt tljc fame Dap; Roll lufticefa{o,tl)c fetngs Ben.tfe Is aCourtof Cpjfn 
 t^eCountpUfecrcttfito, anDtl)crcfo;ctl)cpmaptrp an cnsfcmentcc.mo^^y- 
 ticDfterc out of tl)c fame Cotmtptftc fame Dap , biitnoti'itlje rcmotcDbf-. 
 tftcr out of anotUr Countp, foj (n tCat cafe ft is onlp a Court of £)pcr ano 
 %txminn . 31But Bacon DcnfeQ ft, ano fafD fo teas mp 3Lo;d Cooks opfnf- 
 on, anDtt*trasairofafDtl)at3iifttcc0of£»pcrarD Scrmfnet cannot pjo< 
 cceouponan C-nDfctmcnt it'jicljfsnottal^cnbcfcjctbrmfcitcs, but^'-iftv 
 cfcesofd&aol Deltterp map; ano tfje Court alfoljclD, that tljcjuraroreseledi 
 tryati et jarati bp tl)eCourt,a0ft mull ncccffarflp be ftere unDErftooo,tDas '""^y- ■ 
 fUcpl, fo;tbc3lurpougt)ttobeelcai bp tl)c &beriff out of tfjc Countp ; 
 anDlaftlptfje Court ftclDjtbatlEgallptbcre ouct)t to Ijavc been 15 Oflpes 
 bcttocentf)e<[l;nDfctment,anDtl)etrpal, anofojtljeferearons ojDcrcD to 
 ntbcnotfcetotbcJSfn00§>oHfcftout, 0; Serjeant, to (ftcto cau'c toljp tbe 
 SluDSEment fljoulD not be rctcrfcD» 
 
 Hill and Farmer, 
 
 Trin. 13 Car, Bare. Reg.' 
 Hill. 17 Car, rot, 674* 
 
 vjk j^ 0(tfon of HDebt Iras bjougljt \n tljc Common pleas upon an obltgrs Error i% Dcbc 
 X% tfon i anD a guogement upon a Demurrer teas gitjcn fo j t^e piafntf ff- iip°" >" "bi;- 
 t!)Cpaintiffb?{ng0a©iErftofcrrojfn tbfo Court to re^erfc tlje 3!uDge- S"'°" 
 mentjannafsfgncgfojCBttojtbattlje JSDblfgatfon upon toftfcfj tlje Action 
 toas bjougfit, anD ^uDgement toao gftcn, foa tiofo obUgatton bptfje sta- 
 tute of quinto anD fexto Of Ed. 6- maD^e agafntt burfng of £)fficc0. 315ut Roll 
 JufticeanftoereD, tbat tlbeSuDgcmcntfntbc Common pleas teas gfticn 
 upon a mffpleaDet tticre , anotftcrcfoje pon fijoulo maUe tljat gooD' firft 
 before poumobcrclD matter. iJnD tiicre f0 anctbcr (Erroj alfo in tljc 
 pleaofng, U)l)fcl) itao not toncljeD upon in t\)t Common plcn0,lr!,fclj is tf)f0, 
 firft tlje plea \s of tljc £»{ecc of tfte Delitjcrp, toftfjfn tl)c £)f fice of tijc armo= 
 rp, anD after l)creferr0t!)e plea totbe iD^fice of tlje iSrmojp fefjfcl) fs^-'^'^^'at'''"- 
 another iSDfficc , anD fo tbe EDcclaratfon f0 Donble. SSnotljer cjiceptfon Inas 
 tljat tljC tuojD Armentarius irias ufeD fO? /^ rmatnentarius. More' ay foHOJofng 
 
 teas gfticn to ftciDcaufetctpHuDgemcnt OioulD not bcretjcrfco. 
 
 The King and Marfhall. 
 
 Trio. 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 MAr(liallbjfng0a Mrft of-Ctrroj to retjcrte a 5»BCcm£ntg(tcn a^E.-rorupoa 
 gafnttt)fm uponanCnDfrtmentofbarrntrp, ano tafeco tbcfc creeps >i Fndift- 
 tfons. I . SCtiat it Dotlj not appear fn tlje CnDfrtment, bcfo:c Ujbat Com. ""'"'• 
 mifcfoncro tfjc CnDfamcnt toafl tahen, upon to^fcl) tljc juDgcment teas 
 
 C 3 ciV'cii
 
 50 7rin, 2 3Car. 
 
 gfticn ; ano fo tlje Cnofamcnt ts not gooQ fo j tftc tnccrtafntp of ft, ano con= 
 fequentlptl)e3u^se'ncnttaettoncou3tljat 13 n<tien upontt , foj ft ougljt 
 to appear bp tf)C enDfflment tijat ft toas taken bcfo;ett)c ^utttcce of afcf< 
 fc, 01 Buftices of peatc,oi oftbe 0aol>i3Elftcrp. a. SS^e Snogcmcnt 
 is, quod folvat tantamdenanorumfurnmam, anU fljallfino flirctics fojtftc 
 gooo bcl)3t3four , auD tl)fs ia tatljcr an atoarD tljan a 3;uDgemcnt. So tijfg 
 I d c 1 t Erccptfon Roll lufticc anfiucrcD, f f ft be a gooo o:ocr ft fs a gooo Itiogcmcnt, 
 u gc.ncnt. gj^jjjjjgp,j,gjjgpajtoft^glm,gc^cnt,rct lettfjefefngsCounccll^abc no= 
 tfcc, anDtt)cp?of£nitoj(l)CUjtaurcU)f)ptl)cluDgcmEnt flmilDnot Jjc rc> 
 tKtfco. 
 
 Trin. 2 3 Ca^ Banc. Reg. 
 
 Arrrft 'i "T 7 pQ^ a tctDfci gftcn fn an ejeflione firms ft toas motJCD fn ;g[rrctt of 
 
 jud^cnentm y guogcmcnt, 3110 tl)c crccptfon iia0,tl)at tl)c pioftiffff 11333 cjcttsa dc 
 
 fiimi °'" uno Crof:o, ti'f)fc^ teas faio to be of an unccrtafn fignificatton ; ano bccatifc 
 
 tljc pa'ntfff conccf'ocD the Court Doabtco k.l)ctl)cr an ejcdionc firmae lap of 
 
 aCroft.beourftnotccfcntift, but motcss foj a fpccfal 3[nDgcmcnt foj tbc 
 
 reft of tl)C lantJ contafneo fn tlje iDcclaratfon, ano pjapeo ti)at ijc mfgljt rc» 
 
 leafetljc Damages as to tbe Crofc. Roiieluftice ooubtca Uil)ctbct an e= 
 
 Ejtflione fir- jeAione firnnae l\>ta de uno Crofto , anu-fafD tl)at a iFo?mcDon Ipcs not of a 
 
 «"s-. Croft, but tfjat an afeffe Dotlj,becaufe ft la put fn bfeto to tl)E rccognfto:g,but 
 
 i|..rmedon. g pf-.-jpe ipco not of ft. SEIjc Tulc of Court MS, tf)at tb; iplafntfff CjotilD 
 
 '"■ take a fpecfal Jiiogcmcnt as be oefircD , ano rcleafc t|)C Croft , ano t^c Da» 
 
 magcB to all , ano tljat be Cboulo batie bis Coftes* 
 
 Lerc and Cholwirch" 
 Pafc, 23 Car. Banc, Heg. 
 
 Arrcn-f T Er£ bjfnis an ^ctfOH cf Dcbt tipon an £)bIfgaffon agafi.ff Cfiolwltch; 
 
 imjetmcrt .i> j^ t!)c f onottfoH Of tbc Dblfgatfon U3nG,tbat a certain fiim of moncp Ujoulb 
 
 Obil'Ti^" "" be pafo to tljc plaintiff 40 tsa^'cs aftcrbc flioult) return toffa bis &bip to fiicb 
 apojtofoircbargcfoifrafglt fojbfs&bip, ano fo: non papment <ifco^ 
 rtnglpfstbe action bjougbt ; SCfjcpiaiatfffbatba aeroict , SCbe Defen« 
 Dant motes fn flvrcft of ^iiogemcnt , ano ta'.»cs tbefc crccptions. 7 . 2Cbat 
 tbc alicrmcnt of tbe b;eatbof tbccotiDitfon of tr,c Obligation is not certain, 
 ano tbcrfojc not fooa, foj ft Dotb not a'ocr tbat tbe S>!)ip iuas offcbargeo 
 
 Tf ^'gi.t. of |jj3 ©0003 , 0: tbat tbe 40 oaucs lucre cjpireo befojc tbc montp Deman= 
 DCB ; So tbia Rolle Juftice faio, it is not ufual to pap fraigbt fo : a S>bip , till 
 tbc otoncrs baVie tbcir gooos cciftcreo, but bcre tbe conoftion of tbc bono fs , 
 topaptbemonr)>siBftbfn4oDape3 after b^s return to fucb a pojtof off., 
 cbargc, anoitisnotfntcnocD, tb^t tbe moncp Ojall not be pafotfll ti;e 40 
 Dapcflbcpaft. 2LbE2d.C-rccptfonua3, tbat be ootb not fan tobcvc tbc 
 §>bfplDasunloao:n; So tbts Rolle anflncrco , tijatft Qiall be fntcnoeo 
 tbatfttoasuiilaocnattbcpojtHibcre ft)c nrritJcD, if tbc contrarp be not 
 fijcirn on tbc otber fice. 3lp. S^crc fs nontot ice crpieffeo to be gftjcn of tbc 
 
 Koticf. nnloacfiig of tbc S>hip , anO tUs being a coUatcrall tbing, ano pcnall to tbc 
 Defi:noant, Ic ougbt to batic notice of ft ; So tbfs Rolle fafa, that one par- 
 tpmfc!bta3tc'.ltalicnoticeoftbfsastbeoti}cr,fojtbetljfng to be oone fs 
 
 not 
 
 liitcndmci r.
 
 Trin. 13 Car. 31 
 
 ■not to be none eftljct bp t!je |9lafnt(ff, oj SPcfenuant , anu tfte fffuc fs fotmo 
 ana{ntttl)cDcfEnDant,ti)Ctcfo?c let Wm fljcto caufe Tueiday nert Icl)^ 
 guDgement Qjoulo not be gilien fo; tlje |3lalnt(ff. Afterwards the fame 
 Term ludgement was given accordingly. 
 
 5egar and Dyer, 
 
 Trin. 23 Car. Banc Reg, 
 Mich. 22 Car, rot, 1 3 5, or 13 y 
 
 DYcr bjtnga an 0rtton of SCrotier anu Conticrfioit , in tljc Court at Error ro rc- 
 BriftowagafnftSegar,nnDl)at!)a vEcrDftt, anoa SuoccJticnt agatnftvcrrea ludf- 
 t)(m; Segarbjtngot)tstIRarttoferrojlntl)f3Coutt to tctcrfctbis ^"^SC'^^J^'^j^j J""_ 
 ment, miD Bfslgncs tbcfc Grrojs. i. SCotljcSDrcIarattontobtcl) toas^^.^^^^ °"" 
 of tl)c2Cr6t)cr, anu ConticrCon, de uno pu!io, Anglicc a Colt, tubcrcas TuU ' 
 lusfignJfiEsnotaColt, butp?opctlpapoung^en, ant) l)cncc toe baotbc 
 toojD pullet but in a general acccption of tftctuojD ft map Cgiiific alfo otftct 
 jicung tWngfl, but tfcen ft mutt Ijatjc an aojcctfbc of tbc fpecies iDtjfcl) ft f0to 
 Cgnffie, ojafubftantftjconijcgenftflie fafejofncD Uitl) ft,aa pnilus equi. 
 nus, puUus Afininus 0} Afini ant) t\)t Ifiic , auD ouglt not to be ufcD alone to 
 fignffic a f olt, irii!) an Anglice jopncD to it, as ft fs l]cre. SEbe 2d. QBrtcptfcn 
 teas, tbat ft fs not IbeU fet fojtb, boiu tljc Court teas ftelu U)!)crc tl)c 31ut3ac= 
 went teas gf ben , fojfteuotbnotttjctotljnttljc Court teas ftclo cft^ct bp 
 letters patents, Ojbp pjaefcrfptfon, but faftl) ad curiam tentara tali die coram . . 
 A. D. I, H. fC. a tcrpporecujuscontrariummerooriahominum non exiftit, fC.^'*^ cnptio*. 
 totjftl) cannot be a gooDpjxfcrfptfon,foj a Court cannot be bclD at fuc!) a 
 tap, ano before fuel) partfcalat perfons, ffft be not erpjcffcD to be I'ecnndum 
 confuetudinem. 2Dbc rule Of Court teas to fbcU) caufc Tuesday foilo4ufng 
 iDljp tl)e jHDgement ttjouln not be tebcrfeo, 
 
 } Trini 2 3 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 T^cpafntfff Declares tbattbeSDcfcntjantbaocofccnanfTi) toft!) !)fin,D:murrerup' 
 to pap bfm fo mutb monep as ibc lljoulo crpcno foj rcpafrfng, ano tftt- "" > occiara- 
 ualli^S a febtp foj bint, ano atcrrs t^at lie UnttpcnDct) 300 1. in repairing '^'^"^"J_?^ ^' 
 anD victualling ft, anu tl)at be gate tbc SDefcnoant notice of ft at fuel) a nap , vcnlm'. ^' 
 anu fo? non papment be bjfngs bto 3ctfon of bjeacb of Cotcnant. SCiic De- 
 fendant proteitando tbat tbe piafntiff feao not lafB out 300 1, fn mancr ann 
 fo;m asbe bao ueclareD, uemurs to tbe SDcclatatfon upon tbcfc crceptfons. 
 I.' SEbatttattbeaDeclaratfontoasnotgooD, becanfc be baonot abcrrco 
 a"fpccfallb?catl) of Covenant : 31B«t to tbfs Roll lurticefafo, tbat tbfs tv- 
 teptfon bao been often oter^ruleo, alp. It teas obfeitco, tbat fn tbfs cafe 
 tbe piafntfff fl)oulD babe bjougbt an aictfon of Debt , ano not of£,,,ct;^,„^j. 
 Cotenant. HBut to tbls alfo Roll anftoereo, tbat ft toas tocll cnougb , Aa,on. 
 foj ft fs fn tbe-electfon of tbe plafntfff to b;fng rftbtr an :actfon of Debt, j 
 an actfon of Covenant , ano tljat ft batb been l:cretofo?e qutftfoncD , tobe- 
 tbet an action of S^cbt of d Ipc f n tbfs cafcbut ft Iras ncbcr ooubteo but tbat ^ 
 an action of Cobcnant DfD bcrp t»cll Ife. a tbfio eiccEptfon toas.t^jat tbcre fa '-'• 
 
 no
 
 5* Trin. 3 Or, 
 
 iio rrqticfi allrgcB to pap tljc monp, anD toitftont requcft Ijc tuas not bonnu' 
 Demar.1. *° P'T ^^ SCotbfa Roll anflDCtEO , tbattfte plaintiffs artton luas not an 
 flctiouof SDefatuiftcrcaa>cmantitsncccffarp, but Uisan^aionofdotc. 
 r.ant, ano t^jcrc U is not nceofnllto allege a SDcmano. 
 
 Boomer andPayte. 
 
 Trin. 23 Car. Binc«reg. 
 
 Dtraiirrerup. T)Aytetl)C aominiCratoj of tlje^ooDs ant) Chattels of !. S. bjJngoan 
 on a Dcciara- X attJon Of E^tbt agafnft Boomer, ano Declares, tljat tlie 3nt£ftate bjongljt 
 don in Dcbr. q^^ action Of STctt <n tbeContmon ^Dlcac agajnft tl)?ce . anB bau a3uticrc= 
 ment .iratrft tljcm. anu a Capias aa latisfaciendum agaftiC ttco ef tl)cm U-aa 
 D<retfcDtoBooniertlbc5?Efrncant,l3efngt!)frg)l)CTtffoftl)eComitpU;bcretlje 
 patties lil3ei),to cyctnte, anc that accojcinglp be cio erecutc it bf taftng tbe 
 parties, ano afterliaTBe Dio fuffer tbem to cfcape, ano foj tbis tl)f pinintrtf 
 bjingsbisSfttion. SLo tl)<sl!DcclaTationtl)C plaintiff Demurs. JiButRoU 
 JuftJcc faiD, be fato no tsufe foj ft, foj an Scmiriflratoj map bate an acH= 
 on of SDcbtagainttafeberiffaponanCBftape fufftrcD of a pjifoner oftfe 
 3rtE0atc in bis life time, ana o?DereD tbc SDcfcnoant to (betocauT* 
 SEuefcap nsjt totp tbc plaintiff IboulD not bale 3;nDjcmcnt» 
 
 Dcbr. 
 
 The City of London and Eftwick. 
 Trin. 23 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 For rcftituti- QTepIifn Eflwitk pjapsaTOritof5RrOitntiontobet£lfojebtotbcp]ace 
 on to the ^ofa Common-Courtcl man oftbcCitpoflorcon, tcfngputoutofil 
 Common* ^^ ^^^ ^^^^ ^afoj anD Court of SiDctmcn , ano airotommittcDtoN«w« 
 Counce!-man gate ; tbc ^Tit iscranteD anD tirettcD to tbe Ji.o?D ^aio; anD Court of ^'i 
 of London, tctmcn, tcbo tbcrcopon mafce a lontr retcjn , fctting fo?lb at large tbe cant 
 fcs trhp be teas oe pjiteD ano committto 5 anD tobp b^ ougbt not to be reffo- 
 rcD, tibicl; in b;icf \ras foj tarrpirn bimfelf in a ttimulttious Uap at an cIck 
 ition of Ccmmon=Coantcll-mcn, anD Difiurbing tbc elcftion ; tbis IKeto^ 
 toss TcaD anD fileD,anD tbe Councel tbcreupon p? apcD be migbt be rclto jcc, 
 betaufc tbcrr teas not fuffJcitnt matter CieiECD intbeJRetojn irbp U Ihotila 
 notbcrcOojeo, anDtbefeetteptionstrcTftalrnto tbc9Rcto5n. 1. 2El;at 
 <t trastoogenctal,anDfl)etosnot tobat manner of Di&urbance Eflwitk maDt 
 at tbe Court tbcre tbe election teas. 2lp. partof bismifccmcercut 
 fsfctfo?tb to be claniar<lo&vcciferan<Jo,libitbfli'P treats Vrrp urctrtain 
 anD not p?cper to fet fo?tb a DlCurlarf e. jlp. 3t teas faiD be teas liDDcn 
 to tritbcjato, sno tcfufcD, anD it is rot 0jeirn tcbp be fljoulD uitbD?ati\ 4lp. 
 SLbf tuttom fct fo?tbfo?tbe J.o3DS^ato?anD Court of fllDermentoim^ 
 pjifcn ad placittniisnotcooD, buttbcplbculD bateChetontbatfiicbimpjit 
 fonmert btlcngeo to tbem percorfuetudintni, 0; bptbrCcromon-laU'.." 
 5lp. SEbcp fap, tbat tbep baD ufct to impjifon foj fucb caufes , anD do not 
 IbctD ttbcre tbe cuffomisufcD. <ilp. SCbep fap quxdan) quafi^io crta eiJ 
 toncbing tbeeUctfcnofonetobeaCommonCcnncelman.anDlbcto not
 
 Trin- 2 3 "Car- 35 
 
 ftis abV.itp fo> tf)c place. 7lpra5p tljc inccrtafntp of tlic Rctojn t!jc pain. 
 
 tiff cannot plcao to ft. 81p. 3t <3fatD, tljat to^)cnl)etoagcommanDccto 
 
 00 fojtf) , fje fafo te inoulo not, but it io not fato tljat !)c cio not go fojtft. 
 
 ^Ip. 3;tisfaioti)cttftc€ourtof Contmon^Counctltjmojcutlje Cotienant, 
 
 Mjcreas tljcp ^ate no poVucr fap SDjuinancc of parliament to Do it, SCftc 
 
 aRecoiocr of vIotmccHtoitijtijcCitpDertrco time toamcnotljc lletojnin 
 
 matter of fojm onlp. 2ii\^ faio , tbat tijc plaintiff laas rcmofeeo from 
 
 ^ifl place bv a Court of HccojD, ano tftcrcfojc f)opci) tc Qjoulonotbc 
 
 this leap rcfto:cD, ant) tljnt lie IjaD no lofs bv leina rcmotjco, ano tljercfoae 
 
 ttic Cafe 11333 tlje lcf3 confiucraljlc; ano tubercas it toas objccteo againft \)is 
 
 amcnoins of thelRctojn,tf)at it inas filcD,i fotoo late to moVic foj ft,J^e faio, 
 
 t^atittoas not filcDbpoiOcr of Court, but onlp oincrco tftat Copies migbt 
 
 be taUcn of it foj Council to pcrnfc, ano if fo t!)cn it ia not too late to p;ap 
 
 it map be amenocD, but tljougb it toerc filco l)C conccitJcD t&at in a cafe of tljia 
 
 Importance it migljt be amcnoctjiitmatteroftojmagfomc^ctojngbao 
 
 ieenfojmerlp in tbis Court. Roll luftice anflDercD tijelRfRjticrtottiis 
 
 cffctf, ^OH ougbt to fl)cto fomc caufe upoa lijljicb tl)c partp map i)at)e reme- 
 
 Dp bp a <!ffilritof(i!;rro?,oj otl)criDife,if3ut>eemcntbctDjongfullpgit)cna= Remm 
 
 aaintt !)im,ttitic!)pou babe not Done; ano as to the filing of tftelRetojn, a 
 
 3Rctojn map be fileu citber upon motion of tbc partp , oj bp tl;c rales of tbc ^'^'ng* 
 
 Court , ano it lucre gooo, pou conCocr boU) tbts toag fileo; ano as toucbing 
 
 tbefufpcnlion of tbe partp from bts place, it ougbt not to be perpetual but Sufperfion. 
 
 for a time onlp, ano faio, tbat after filing of a Kctojn, be it upon motion oj 
 
 bp tbc rules of tbc Court, it cannot be amcnoeo. Tuefday next follow- ^"'fn^n'c. 
 
 ing was given by the Court to hear Councel on both parts» /"t^/: 5S*. 
 
 Cliadly and Scinch- 
 
 Trin, jj Car.Banc.Reg. 
 Mich. 2a Car, rot. 5 5d. 
 
 STinch bjougbt an 0rtion upon tbc €a^e upon an AfTumpfit U\ tbc Com* Error to re- 
 mon pieas againft Chjdiy, ano bath a tacroict ano a SuogcmcntStinch vcrfc * ludg- 
 brings a Mrit'ofCBrrorbcrc to rcycrfc tW3I"Dgement , ano afsigns fo; ^"* '" '" ^" 
 Crroj, I. 2:b«t tbere tocre 1 8 rcturnco upon tbc Slurp, ano but ttoo of Jj^" "fj"" '" 
 tbcm trpcD tbc iffue. 2lp. partof SD:clatation togrounotbc AfTumpfic" ^ * 
 Iras in another Countp, ann not \Bitbin tbc 3furifDictfon of tbc Court tobcre 
 the iffuc toastrpeO; and for thefe Errors the ludgemem was reverfed except 
 caak ihould be (hewn to the contrary Thurfday ncxc. 
 
 Trin. 23 Car. Banc. Reg- 
 
 1 2C teas motjcD to quafb an Cnoidment fo j ctctting of a Cottage contrarp 
 
 J to tbc Statute; tbc exception tafecn to it teas, tbat b? crcaco a Cottage Hndiamen" 
 
 fo: habitation , butoin notfapittuasurcDojinbabiteDaBaCottagc. 15atforcreainga 
 
 Bacon Juftice anfiDCrcD, tbattbctjcrp erection Of it is an offcucc againft tbc Cottage. 
 
 Statute, ano tbetefoje the Cncictmcnt DiD bcrp toell purfuMbc toojos of 
 
 tbe Statute, ano tt)etefo;e IdouId uot quatb ft. 
 
 if Wright
 
 Venire Jc no- 
 
 54 7r:n.2 3Car. 
 
 VVright and Pynder. 
 Tfin» 23 Car, Banc. Reg, 
 Mich. 22 Car. rot, 440 antra. 
 
 Op- ion of "T^^c Cafe of Wrir,htannPi-ndcrtoagmot):o a0a{ntol)aiJCt')c3I'J''SC- 
 
 t^cC:>unon I nient of tljs Court. Roll lufticc fan, tbatmatfEtoffact oug^tto'bcn» 
 
 ii-^Val'i'cv'i ^'^^•'^ *" aSDcmurrcr to anClifDcntc^otijcrtofrc t\)t€onxt cannot p?occcD iip^ 
 
 dehcc. " " ' on tl)c 2Dcniurrcr,fo:. tlic 3iti3gc0 cannot trp t!jc matter in fart.fo j tljat lucre 
 
 fo? tl)Z 3if3acs to trf^c tl)3 VcrDttt, irfjtcl) bcloncu to tl)c Snri.' to Do , anD to 
 
 P, ,. toaflje tf)c^r.ttcr in Hair, Uftfcl) tljep fljoulo Qctcrminc , anD Ije fafo, 
 
 «-'i- tjjat (f a rr)ccD be plcaoeo tljc partp muft Qjcto it in xli:ourt,5jut if it be fiiticn 
 
 Evi.^ersce, »" ct'ijCiicc itia iiot ncccffarp to 0)eln it if it can otijcrtoaico be pjoDcD to tlje 
 
 3'Jrp, ano fo is it of a lRcco:o siDrn in cfiocncc.anDcitco one Worfleys 
 
 Cafe 17 lac. Rolls lufticetooU alfo tU)0 otijcrGvccptionstot^c plcauing, 
 
 1 ♦ JCljat tbt? ©0003 mcntioneo in t!)c &cI)cdijIc appear not to be tljs fame 
 
 containco in tije HDJclaration. sip. jlia Eitlc iismaDetotljcJnocnttirc 
 
 bp l)im toI)o bjingstbc Action, ano concUi3CD upon t!)c v. Dole matter tijat 
 
 tl)c SDcmiitrcr tonfj not gootj, ano tljat tberc ongbt to be a Venire facias de 
 
 novo to tvp tlic matter again. Bacon luOicc muclj to tftc fame effect, but 
 
 hi 'm r.t Diftcr'D ii\ tl)iiJ, tbat tl)crc onobt net to be a Venire facias de novo bat faiD, 
 
 ^ ' tbat Sinogcmcnt ciiuftt to be niten againft oncpartp,to luit tijc SD:fencant, 
 
 fo: ill lopnfnn: in Demurrer,',to tbe intent tfte partp t^at is not in fault map 
 
 be uifmiffcD, ano tl)c parties Ijcrc Ijatjc loaibcD tl)c SCrpal per psys bp jopn- 
 
 inn in Demurrer. 15ut Roll anfitcre^i t^at no 3;uogemcnt at all coulD be 
 
 niijcn, foj tot'o parttcsbe in fault, one bp tenojing tlje Demurrer, tljc 
 
 otber bp topnins in it, ano tl)C De cnoant miafet batie cl)ofen ufjetber be 
 
 Ir.oulQ batic iopncDoj no, but migbt tube pjapco tbe 3»3?fmentoftbc 
 
 Co'irt Ubctljcr bi^cutbtto jopn. Slbc Court aotifco to fearcbpiefioer.tg 
 
 foj a Venire facias de novo after a Demurrer upon an cli3cncc,anaif tberc 
 
 te anp, tbep Ijtlo tbat tbe fame Tdxj^ ositjbt to come again, ano not anotfjcr, 
 
 lu ;. Roll fato, if a fpccial tcroid be found infufficicnt, a hcjO V>.T,ire facias 
 
 oagbt to iffue, ano be CalB no 'Oifferencc betlDsen tijat ano tbta 
 
 Cafe, 
 
 Kina and SLwnmerlanJ. 
 
 Trin. 2 3 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 J0 tl)e Cafe of Kin^ ana Sumrncrhnd again mo'oeD, tbe Court belof bat 
 Op-r>!pnt{ Itpc plcaDing of a bargain anU talCtobJdebitomodoirrotulacumrecun* 
 ,).hC lire jjy^; formam itatutiis gooD cnougb, tbougb it benot plcaDco to beinrollco 
 \' caj"pE c( a 1 toitbiii fip montbs , pet rulcD ft ftoulD be niolJCD acain. ZAft fame term 
 •'tMtoiiii.i:: t. 3HDgcmcut u 33 qi\icn, tbat tbe IDlaiutiff nil capiat per bi'hm , bctaufc tbe 
 
 Deca Ujas not l&iQ to be cnrollco, ii«itber iecundumrorm3mftatuti,noj 
 
 uitijia fij; iiJOi'.tbs, but onlp dcbico mode, Voblci) map be an enrollment at 
 
 tbe Commou laty, anono't accojuingto tbs statute. 
 
 The
 
 Trin, 13 Car. ^5 
 
 The City of London and Eftwick- 
 
 Trip, 1 3 Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 Tl^c Coattixjas agafnmo\3eD IntljeCafcbctiDCcntljctCtti' of London a>J-^t 
 ano Eftwick , tljat tbe return of tf)c CUp mtgl)t bsamciiocDaltftousbArgumjnc 
 <t vrcre filcD , bccaufc tftcrc arc pjcCiDcnts tofjcrc it ftatb been oonc Roll 
 
 cji'.cci r.in? 
 
 luftice anfircrcD, tbctcteasnetcrani'amcnDcD after tfjcftlmccbefojcH.'^'^^'''^ °f ' 
 7t!)0. time, gt toao replrco bp tbc Councel, tl)<it tlje return being of tWa ; , /,^",'^°" '" 
 SCerm it migl)t be amcnoeD , foi itrettcD intfjcbzeaaoftbcSaDgec. SBut cuncri- 
 Roll luflicc anfinercD totbio, tljat^ctsof tbc Court remain in tl)eb?eaftian$pi;cf. 
 of tijc Court tbefamc SEcrnT, but not actsofotijerij, ano tberfoic ttfs ^"^'^"'^"'"'• 
 being fo trais not amenoablc, ano faiOjtljat inferiour Courts cannot ameno a 
 pjcrcntmeiit in matter of faa.foj tljat iccrc to alter ttjc ciittom of tl^e courts; 
 ano it Ujac ttjen fain, tljatCnDictments baa been amenoeo after tljc filing 
 of tljent. 3nD 3lDcrman Langhams Cafe toas aKo urcrcD, iuftcre a rctojii 
 of tbe Citp toaa amenaco after it toas filcu , pet t\)h iras rulco not amcno- 
 able. Twifden of Councel toitb tbeCftp argueti that Eftwick ousl)t not 
 to be rcftojen to l)ia place of a Common^Councel=man foj tbefe rcafons* 
 1. iBccaufc it teas not a place of pjofit.auo fo it teas no Damage to Ijim to be 
 remofceo, ano tberefojc !)is fute toasto no p:irpofc. zip, $t is not a place of 
 Cotcrnmcnt, ano fo no Dignitp in it, but it toasa place mccrlp offcrtice 
 ano trouble. 315ut RolllalHce anftereo, tljat a to:it of tcftitutionbao been Rcftii„tjo„, 
 aojuDgeD gooo to rcftoic a Conttable to Ijis place, lobic^ tuas mo:c a place 
 of fctticc ano troub.e tban tl)is. ^Ip. s:i)ere is a niogemcnt agsintt ECtmik 
 in a Court ofKecojD,anDitmuftbeatioiDeocitl)crbpcrrojoj attaint, as 
 t\)Z Statute Dire(t0,ani5 tl)C partie cannot be reffoico bv a mrit of Hrflitu* 
 tion; ano fojtijcobtection tbstt'^cl'leturn is too general, be anftDereQ,tl)at 
 ^m\)iQ to bcgtticu, tbattberetoasaDitturbancemaoebpljim asisfug- 
 acftcD,tbougl)it be not fo plainlp cjpjelTeo as it migiit l-ate been. ;lp, i^crc 
 appears a contempt to tl)e Court , ano fo; tbisbc mapbe fufpcnDeo. jlp^ 
 SEtjc CuttomcistocllpurfueDupontbclDbolc matter taken togctljer. ^Ip. 
 SLbcCuftome is toclllaiDfojtbe commitment ad piacitum, fof it refers to 
 tbe toOjDS fufpcndere vcl amovere,tbat is.citber onc OJ tbe otftct. 5lp.2C!)3 
 tDojD require amounts to a commanabcingfpoUeninaConrtof Iaccoio, 
 ano tbe cifofacping it teas a contempt. Hi les of Council ontbefamenoc 
 atgucD mucl) asTwifden Ijao oone.ano aoocD to it as foUotoctf). i .Xhat tb:re 
 appears u reafonable taufe p:cceDcnt toljp be ftoulo be fu'penDcD, ana tb?n 
 itfollovDSttjep map fufpcjio btm ad libicum. 2lp. SC'ic alleging of tbe ci-- 
 fturbance is not material, foj tbat is not tbe grouno of bis amotion from bi^ 
 place, but onlptl)cint)«ccmeut to it. jlp. Rcquifitus Ojall be unocrttooo 
 requ fitus per cQriam,it being allcgcD to be in Court. 4lp, Recufavit is mo;c 
 tban denegavir, anu implies be CiD not tbe tbfng cnjopnes bfnr, anb fo miabt 
 tDCll be committcD. 5lp. SEbercmapbe caufctogrant a carit of rcCitiitt. 
 on, tbounl) no caufc foj tbe rcffitution: JFoj a common-Councclman of Co^ 
 ventry bao a ^SUrit of rcftitution out of tbis Court,ano pet upon bis fute teas 
 not reftojco. 2Cbc IRccojOcr motjeo foj a longer Dap tofacbearo fo:tbc 
 Citp , bccaufe it tuas a tocigbtp caufc, ano faio tbat no rcffitution coulo b^ 
 maoc, fo J tbe tIEIrit tnas not tecll Dirccteo, ano fo is not tocll crccutcD. STbc 
 paintiffs Councel DeQrcD crpcDition in tbe CaufC; C23bcreiipon Roll faio, 
 fccrc batb been no oelap in tbe bunncrs,buttbe rule is acainarca, ano
 
 3<5 
 
 7rin 23 Car. 
 
 be took ti)rfc crrcpttonsto Hjc llctoin.i.^t appears not bptljc rcto?n tt)at 
 
 tbcpinfnttffisrcjnotcofrombtis place, but onlptftat be ia fufpciiDCD, ana 
 
 tbcntcJJtaptecU bcrcffojcD, anDtt<0 not falD fo; IjoU) long tfmc fjc is fuf- 
 
 pcnoct). 2lp. 3t {3 not faio tl).it l)c fs fufpcnQcu fo; a reafonablu caafc, jip, 
 
 5t <s not fatD tobat tljc aiCtubance teas that l)c maoc fo j iD^fcb l;c ts ftjfpcn- 
 
 Dco. 0ni> fnTt!)cr fafD, that tftcCToiirt oftljcdommon^Coancclfsncta 
 
 E,r„,. Court ofI\cto:o, fojnoCCIrUofGttoj Itcs tbcrcT but isaCourt onlj' 
 
 I'.cfir.iiiicn, OfilDttfC. Biconluffice as Roll, anu fafD ,tlMt EftwickbaDonli'rcmcDp 
 
 to be rctto:co bp a CClrft of KcQItutfon, ano not bp a mrrt of Crroj oj 
 
 /<r//, iji. an Attaint. i^.BjOurncD till Saturoap to fjear Comucl fo; tbc <Z\ti\ 
 
 Rawfon and Bargue, 
 
 Tiin, 2 j Car, Banc. Reg. 
 Hil.iyCar. rot, 904. 
 
 Argument u?-Tj Awfon bjou0l)t an ^ction of Debt agafnCBirguefoj 15 1. upontb; 
 
 on 3 ipcciai J\ statute of 2 Ed. 6. foj fettfng fojtb of 5rttl)cs. 5lnD upon tt)C SCrpal a 
 
 Vc.dictfor fpc^p. tjcrDtcttoasfoiiiiVaftcrctitt&c^iueafonlDao, Iti^ctbcr tbc CCbiircb 
 
 -a'o'VfVsibprcafontbcrcoVtbcSTitbsslDcrcclatmeotDcrcafrcc Cbappcl, ano gf- 
 
 i.iK.n the s,,- ben to Ed. 5b: <3tb . bp tbe ^tatate of i Ed. 6. ano fo offcbargco of Cltbea 
 
 tu cof 1 £J. 0: not. VValksr of Conned toitbtbcp'.atntiff arguco, tbat ft to30not a 
 
 ^- frccCbappcl, brcaufc tbetctoaaacurcof&oulg, ano fotoulD not Oc free 
 
 but pjefentatib: , ano faio tbat tbe too jo free vsasaUjojoofoiCfnaionta 
 
 ttCfnguiO) tbings of Different nature one from anotbcr, asj liber homo is to 
 
 Mtttimuia) a free jnaafromat.imc(it,i^janchfolD, iPianc!;tcncment, ano 
 
 tbcltl-c, ano tltc5 Brafton lib 4.C. 3. 241. l^c UBetotfcDJKmgufCbco 
 
 Cbappcls fnto tb;cefo?t5. i. SDonatfbe. 2lp. pjefcntatibe. jlp. CSlftbout 
 
 cure of&ou!3, anofaio, t-iatCbappelspjcfentatft'etocrcnotsiticntotbe 
 
 fcJn5bptbc»>tatatcof 2Ed. 6.anocitcBNat. brev. 48. snO :jE,4J. 4. 
 
 anotfH. 7. c- j^.ano 5 H. 7. f. 37. ano fafo, tbat it is not toitbtn tbe mcan= 
 inc of tbe fetatiitc of i Ed. d. to gibe Cbappcls pjefentatibcbrcaufcitiij 
 not teitbtn tbe nnfcbief luMcb tbe Statute Icasniaoetopjebent. ano foin- 
 tenos not to gi fee Cbappelc Vuitb cure of &OUI0, ano tbe too?D fne is but no^ 
 niinal, ano Jotb not ina'ac it free if it be not fo otbcriuifcHales fo: tbe Bc- 
 fcnannt arguco, tbat ii teas a free Cbappcll toitbtn tbe Statute of i Ed. 6, 
 |^o;ftrftitt£!cal[cDfo,nncttC)aUbtpicfumcoftis'rigbtlp namco fo. 2lp 
 3tis fofomio to be bp tbe Sinrp , ano to p;o*oc tbat it is a free Cbappcll 
 it is not pjcfciitatil'C, ano 2lp. 3t appears not to be toitbtn tbe Surifoiction 
 oftbciDiOinarp. 5IP. SEbc iSctof i Ed.6.ican acttobicbis gcneralano 
 aibcs all free Cbappels, ano crteaOsasUicUtoCbappelsiubicbarconlp 
 tcpntatilT free Cbapbels as toell as to tbem U)l)!cb are fo inoeeo, rocn as it 
 is of a Cl)aimtcrp,CoHcge . ano an imp:op;iation, as tbe Hooohs are, ano it 
 is a fvcc CbappcU ncbcrtbclcfs it be picfcntatifac ano irttb tbe Ciirc ofS>ouls, 
 fo; a free Cbapp:l mapnotobe tDitbtbccu'COf S>oul0|, altbougb bptbe 
 olo Canon la\D it couh not, nsUiasbcioinClnlds cafe, 'lac. SEbsCbap. 
 pel iritbin t'.icEoirrris a free Cbappcll Donatit0,anDpctittspjcfcnta=: 
 t'Vc ano batb cure of Souls, fo faitb Lvnwood of tbe free Cbappel of St. 
 Mil tiiu. 3t 12 alfo m inteut of tbe Statute, tbat it fl)oulo be fo,fo; a Col- 
 
 lege
 
 Tfin. 25 Car. p S7 
 
 leffc antj a Cfiaunterp tnft]^ cure arc liftUn tfj: Statute, as mapapprar 
 ftp tbe (Erctptlons! oftbc S>tatute of tt)C iFrcc Ctjappcl teftftcurc of feoulom 
 t\,t sue of EelycalleOtbc Chappel of the Sea, ailD tijc beir.Q picfEtitatitie 
 
 SufTex, ano ft map be a Chappel oonatibc bppjcrcrtpt<on,ar!!) pctpjcfra- 
 tatttie. Adjornacur ad proximuni terminum to bear0;!C!3agam, Vid, pofteat 
 
 Barker anj Martyn. 
 
 Trifl. 23 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 T^e cafe faettocm Barker ano Martyn teas actafn motJCD, Uif)iff)U3aB^""°'^T^' 
 b2icflp tbw, an artton of Srcfpafs teas b jouafjt bp Barker aaatnft Mar- pa'"' '" "' 
 iin,\Dl)ctcm be declares , ttjat t!)c HCcfentiant imo bjoUcn M0 i§oure , ano * 
 
 ftaD taUcn atoap quinque inftrumenta ferrea, Anglice fecters. gn atrEft of 
 3;aD)jcmcntErtcpt{onlua0 tafeentotlieSDctlaratfon. tfjat Inftrumenta fer. 
 rea, A nglice fetter?, inas not a eooD crp?efs!on in iattii (as (t ounfjt to be ) 
 of Fettcrj. bccatifc tt)erc toas apjoperlatfit toojo foj Fetters' namelp 
 Corapes, fo tljat it oug^ttofiatebccnqumqueCorapedes, 03 quinque pa- 
 ria Compedum, anUtlot ao ft fs, fo; tijc toojD Inftrumentum to uncertam aito 
 map betifEDtoftgrnftcanptbingclfetoftlj an AngliceaDDentoftaolDellag 
 Fetter?, anD as ft to tl)c plcacfng fs not all fnJLatfn as tl)c Statute cfrctts to 
 aDoiDBarbarffm, ano tljc itojD AnglicetDbenftfspjopcrlp ufcofnaJDe- 
 claratfon f 3 to bclp toojus of art, iu^fclj cannot be erpjeffen tcf tljotit an Ang= 
 lice , anD f 3 not to be ufeo tobcrr tbcrc f 3 a pjopcr iattn tcoao to ftcrnffie tbe 
 tf)tng,asintbfs Cafe tIjcrefs.fJn tbc otbcr fine ft toasfafo, tljat acncral 
 t]0?D3 jnfgbt be gooo in a JQDcclaratf on, anD barbarous toojugfometfrnes 
 anDtfteO Hobarts Reports, 267. anD Ward anD Smiths Cafe, Trip. 4 lac! 
 rot.igoj. Roll luftice , %t fs a IjarD tftfng tomafnt3fntbfsDcclaratfon*r:<:iar»:o.7. 
 fo; ff (tfljottlD be aDmttteD gooo ft tooulD bjing in au 3i5arbarffm in plcao' 
 tngs, anDanp fenfclcfs toojDmfgbtbeufcDteftI) anAnnlice jopnco toftb picadw 
 it.anobcfafDone tDascntfttCDfojuangquandamartemAnglicc ofa Dra. 
 per, anD ft toas aDlnDgcD nauabt, anD fn tljc cafe bcttoccn Tailour anD Ta v 
 lour 9 Car. Ercfpafs.toas bjougbt pro Decern caponibus, Anpiice Caponc,& 
 avibus domefticis, Anglice powltry.anD aDjuDgeD not aooO. pet the rule'of 
 tbc Court toas to argue ft ajjafn &aturDap ncjtt follotofug. 
 
 EelesancJ Lambert. 
 Trin. 23 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Vik, 22 Car. rot, 1646, 
 
 ^Eles'ibjougbf an 0ctfon ofCotjcnant agafnClamberttbe Crecnfojof '^"^^'^^cncf 
 ,^(t MoUon Lambgrt, qnD Declares tljat^lrMoltonLanibsrtDfofnbfs^,*l;,ft"''"' *"
 
 38 Tun. 2 5 Car. 
 
 life time bpfjieiiiDEiittjrc let ccrtafn lanosuntoljfmfoj j»cars, aiio tobc« 
 nantct) tiicrcbi' fojljimaif, l)!S C-vccutoj3,ilomtni(tratoji5,ant> !3'"of(Tn0,tl)at 
 tbc Ecffcc fijoulD not be put out of poffEfflton ot tbc lanuo let bp fttm 
 DiirfnctftcfafDJEcrmi aiiDtljatfincctbcDcatl) of Sir Molton I arabcrt {)fg 
 3Lcfroj,l)clriaoptJt out oi poffcfsion bp tncl) an one , ant) upon ttito be b;fnga 
 f)is Sltton of ^JCoiicnantagatiift tl)C €j;ccuto?. 2Ll)c SDcfcnuant pleaD0, no 
 J^lTcts, upon tijij an iOfiic toao icpncD, anu a fpcttal ClcrDirt ivao fonno, 2Eo 
 tl)l3 cffcft, SIfjat Sir Molton Lan,berc DiD let t^e lanDfl mcntfoncD In tl;c iS>C^ 
 daratfon to Eelcs prour,^tl)at tbcre loao fuel) a Co\3cnant in tljc SDccd prour, 
 ano tbat tljc piahitfff tone put out of poffcfofon of tbc lance proutJCiicpfino 
 UUctoffc, tftat Sir Molton Lambert maoc l)ls ^53tll , anomaDctljc St>cfen= 
 DaritI;fCiCl;>:CCHtOJ, nno DfCDi tftat Sir Molton Lambert bp Ills Icfll gatic 
 manplegacteo of gooes, ano tbat the IDcfcnoant befo?c tbc plaintiff toag 
 p:it out of poffcfssion, cio pap all tljc ^Lcgatlco <n liino, ann tftat bcfiocB ttjofc 
 ILcgacies ijc bao not Sffctis to Dlfcljavgc t^c (lotjcnant. tllpon tbfo cierofct 
 tl)c matter In Halo Vons tins , iibct'ocr tljc Crrcntoj ongbt to bate fo?bo jji 
 tbc papmcnt of tljc ^legacies, ano to Ijatic CTpcctct till tbe cnD of tlfz 2Ccrm 
 Icttotbcpiatntitl, ojttlltt)cCoticnantl)aiJ been bjoljcn, ano fo^ Dofng 
 otOcttDlfc fijOHlo not be cl)argcD to<tbtl)cCot)enant de bonis propriis; oj 
 tol)etl)cr tl)c (Toljcnant not being IjoRen fntliclffc of tl)c2Ccttatoj,no? before 
 tftc ILegacfes palo, tjc l)aB not palo tljc iicgaclcs aa \)c ougljt, ano ftoulo not 
 be freeo from being cljargeo lultb tbc Co^jenant de boni* propriis. ^ipon 
 Decree in Opening oftbc Cafe Rollc IufticefalD,tbat a cccrecln Cbanccrp agalnft an 
 ciui.ccry. C'pccuto?, tbalUnot be fatioficu bcfo je an £DbUgatfon maoc bp tljc SEcttato?, 
 anD become Due after bis Dcatb, Saturday following was fee to here Couiu 
 cell agatHt . 
 
 Jones and Stanley* 
 
 Trin* 23 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 mem m ^^n ^ I ^"^^ bjougbt an action of Debt upon an iDbligation to perfoj m Cobe* 
 Aftion of 1 nants of an gnocnturc agalntt Stanley , ans batb a Qlcrolct agalnft btm; 
 Dcix. Stanley moVEs in ^rrclt of 3iuDgemrnt, anDtalses tbefc crccptlons; r. 
 
 SEbat tbe CPooue Vialuen in tbc 2Dcclaratlon , are not toltljin tbc conoltion of 
 tbe iSDbllgatlon ; 2. SLbcgoocaarenottertainlpfctfojtb U;bat tbcp are, 
 foj tbc 2DeclaratloH la of Dltersparccllsj of olo Cuff; 3. &oinc of tbe tblngs 
 mentloncclntbeiaDecIarationarenotgootje, anufo not to betalueo, foj 
 tbeSDrclaratlonloofpartUionBlnltbintbcboufc, anDof a tbcB, tobfcb arc 
 part of tbe free bolD, antinotgootjo ; upon thefe exceptions thcludgement 
 was arrelkd till the other fhould move it; 
 
 VV^hiceand Thomas- 
 
 Trin, 25 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 Trip. 18 Car. rot. 1400, 
 
 Ft. r to L-f- 
 
 niciit ill Di.bt 
 
 vc. fc a w^- ^^j Hite linns bimrclf,btg ^clrs, erccnto js,ani3 aomlnlfiraf oj3,lii an 
 \\ ^ 
 
 b-o'i-i'tbvan V Y ^©bligation to Thomas fo; tbe papment Of a certain fumm of mo
 
 Trin. 2 3 (Jar. 3^ 
 
 moni' tt n certain nap-, tire nionp fa r.ot pf>ti3 , a ?ii?f cmcnt f« clti^fiiru a= ~ 
 
 satnft White fo:ti)cmonp. White ma^.csl)f0li(ll,?nD makes tfs j^ck et 
 TatD Ws CBFecutoz , ano tjpes leatfrig iaiiss to ucftenD. Wh^e 
 ag^citb;tngsa?KIIrttof errojtorEtcrfe tWiS 3ucffemrnt; gt ii-ao ar- 
 gueo bf tl)c ConnccU of tijc plaintiff in tlje mJrit of Cue? , fijat ilje ^rlt 
 tto Ipr, bccatifc alt^ougft tl)c )3rttottfn tljc fojmcr Stiisccment fcan but a 
 pctfonal miction , pet intti3Cafc,tI)elLanDcfilb£ l^cirniapfcc tl?aiTco br* 
 tl)c3;uDaement,fo;i an elrfit trap be thereupon tel.cn nit to cbarrc its ndr. 
 llanDo 'anJ)tl)ercfo?ett)c3«O0emEntfortcrtis Ijim rs ^^eir as lucU as h:. --. 
 C-^rtutoj, ant) tftcrcfojc it is rcafcti tc ftoulD bjing a Ci^rit of Crroj to rc- 
 tetfetbcluDsctnent, bctanfe l)c map be p?E juDicca bp it. ano a Cafe Excaucr. 
 <n Trin. 29 Eliz. rot. dj I . Ba nc. Reg. tons CitcO,tbat tl]C ll^Cir is p'.ttp to X\)Z 
 3uDgcmcnt, ano tljerefoje (bal? fjate a ^rit of C-rro;, ano Ijc is not mccD ''^""• 
 lptcrr«2Ccnant 13 Fm- »• Ro" Iunice,tI)Etcrr-2ncnant fDlcfijallrotljatc 
 a CCIrit of Crro? upon an crtcnt-.IiJnD In tlic Cafe at tijc larr tl)c ^Kir is not ^^^'"^' 
 pjilip to tije Bluoctcmcnt , ano t!)c CTtcnt is onlp upon lim as tcmaEcnant , 
 ^nc |e is not maac pjitop to tbc Jnogrmciii bp tbc rrtcnt , but after C'rccii. 
 lion be map Ijatc a ^rit of C-rro? , ano be faio , tl)c 315ail cannot bUnrt a B;ii. 
 ^rit of dDrro? upon tijc Sttcgemcnt gibcn agairC tl)e pjircipal , anD tire 
 fame reafon is Ijetc , ano it luiU be tcrp fjaro to mr.iatain t!}tg WixU of Cr- 
 ro?, Adjourned to the next term. 
 
 Terry and Baxter, 
 
 Trin. 2j Car, Banc, Reg, 
 Pafc, 2 3 Car. ror. 394. 
 
 'T- E'''y b;{ngsan0ctionof SDebt upon an AfTumpfit agaiuff Raster, to Dcr 
 
 J ftailn to an 0lDarD. 2El)C SDcfenOant plcaOS nu! arbitrement; tbC plain- u K"'" =n D- 
 
 cmurrer 
 
 notcooD. Rolleluftice an\'tocrcc,iftbcalaar3bct3oiototl)e5 l.atoaroco j^^aij ood 
 tobcpafototbepooj, petitiagoootot'Dcna, fojitispcrfeaastotbc en. i.. tun i^. a 
 ling of all Differences bfttoccntbem Uifticij are fnbmittcD,. and therefore (.""'^ '""d. 
 fiiewcaufe on Monday next, why jadgcment ihould not be riven for the 
 Plaintiff. 
 
 MorefielJ and Webb. 
 
 Trin. 25 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Parc,23 Car, rot#50, 
 
 \T \7 Ebb bjfngs an 0ction upon tljc Cafe againff Morefidd fn tbc pa. Hr-or to re- 
 V V laccCourtat Wcftminiier, anoljat!) a 3;utigcmcnt; Morefidd ^='^- ^ ^"'^i«- 
 bjings a tSHrit of €rroj in tbis Court to rcbcrfc tfjc 3;uoctment,ano ilfsjctns "1",' '" '" 
 tbcfc Crrojs. i . 31t is not flJCiBeQ in tbc SDcdaration ttjat tbc caufe' of the cTfe ^""^ 
 ^'.on Uias infra juriidiaioBem palatii, JBntRolle luflicc anfUiercD, t^at luiisilia'lon 
 
 it
 
 '4° Trin. -^ Or. 
 
 ft teas flictoCD to be infra jurisdi Aionem Curfx , ant) tfjat Icas gooD cnongb 
 Rctorn. fojtbc Court (0 allcgcD to bc bclD bp ILcttcre patents. id. ejcccp' 
 t(on toas , tbat tbctc inao not fifteen capcB foj tbc rcto;n of tfie Venire fa. 
 cias ao tbcrc otiaftt to be ; JBiit to tUs Rolle luQice alfo anftuerco, tljat tftc 
 Court ts^clo bp Jlettcrs patents, aiio tljcrcfojctt map be retojnablc Irftft. 
 
 <n fifteen Dapc0,tl)otiBlj bp tlje Hfual tourfc of tbcCotnmon lain tt cannot And 
 therefore ordered the Plainr.ff m the Writ of Error co fliew better mat- 
 ter, otherwifcludgcmcntftiould be affirmed againfl him. 
 
 Tlie King and Holland. 
 
 Trin, 23 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 tf)c Jtjfnc cannot be fntftlcu to fuel) a ufe, bccaufc it is a tbfiig in piftitp on=: 
 v.c. Ip, anOfitcDtlic&tattitcof jyH.S.ofufCB, anoCooks i.rep. i2j, auD 
 
 faiD, that tbciijfntt cannot be fntitlcD to CoppbolD lahosof an ;aucn mucb 
 Copyhojj. ictrctotbct!'cofCoppbolo!anDiJ;Jf!)C ftoulD, i. SEbc 3Lojd UioulD be 
 vv;'orB fe?onfTcD, iii'.iic!) tbc ISfng ougbt not to do, but to pjotect Ijts fub- 
 Ptouaiun. fpcts, fo; tl)c protection of tljefubfcctfs not onlp matter of bonouj to tlje 
 Tiuft. iifng, but alfo of truft fn tl)c Croton ; alp. ^ firanger is iu?ongcD bp it ; 
 
 ?lp. SEbc CoppbolDcr of tljc^ano; cannot babe remeop foj the tjijurg 
 "''^" tone bfnijfoj be ougbt to fue ii\ tbe ILojDs Court , anb not clfe vobcrc, ana 
 
 Honour. ''^^1^ ^c cannot DO it . ano tljc rule in lato is de minimis non curat lex , ana 
 ft is mud) IctTc ioi tbebonnour of tljc !iing to babe a CoppbolD e(late,toljf£^ 
 fc a bafc tenure. JBut ft map be objcctciJ,tbat if ti;c JSing fba'l not babe tbio 
 tx(e , be fljall be i» a \tio?rc conoition tban a fubject. 2Do tbts it is anftoercD, 
 tbat be fiia 11 be fo in cafcc Inbfcb toucb bio ropaltp, annmap be a Difpa« 
 Copyhrij., ragcmi:nttobfm,Uibicb fnOccD ootb rot ntahe bim in a toojfc conoition 
 tbougbftmapfccmfo.biititfsmojciojbiebonoj, anoa Coppbolo fa an 
 cftatcattbcuflloftbclLojo , anoougbt tobcpjotccteDbptl)eiojD; ana 
 AHfn. the liing cannot be aCenant at \iil\ to anp, aiiD tberefojc cannot fjabc a 
 
 T, uft. Coppbolt) cflatc ; ana an 9licn is not capable of a truft,bccaufc ft ia a thing 
 
 fnilrtionUibtcb an Slim cannot have, ano tbcrcfojc be cannot Derfbc tt 
 from bint. Twisdcn foj the fcing in biis Slrgument confiDcrco , i. tmifz- 
 tbcrtbcliTngcanbalicaufc at the Common lato tobicb fa fo: an 01fcn. 
 2. t?EU)ctber a trttft oiirm from a ufc; fo j the fiift be fnio, that an ;9;fen 
 ^,;^^ mappurtbafc lauos , ano a ufe at tjc Common lato, but be cannot retain 
 
 tI}em,tbcrcfoictl?:!lifngfl)ailb2bctbembpbt3 P.-srcgative , anoa ufc 10 
 notati)iiiginpjil'itp,butfijan53nticnt fnberitnncc at tbc Common lato. 
 a' p. SEbcrcfsnoconfiicenccanncrcij to ccftui queufe, ojtotbeifcoffoj, 
 btitmapbccifpofeoof. 3lp. 2Lbtng0fn pjibftp fn Miction map be gfben 
 to the iiing , anis aufe fo an inberitancefn the nature of a C!<attell» 4lp» 
 51 ufc is grantablc ober , ano therefore map be gibcn to tbc ting , ano tbe 
 mcaniiigot tbc toojD loft, in the Statute, fs to be fntenucD that ft map be 
 ^ loafojtbct)!f{ttult;>offinm'ngfucbrHbtile conticpanccs, ano not that flje 
 Tr.ift. '^-bt lva« icallp loft- 0fio fojatruft itfobutanPtonamegibcntoaufc, 
 
 anc fiiBcntcD toiDpfrauo tbc Statute of ufc0,anD atruft of aCoppbolo is all 
 one toitb anotlicr trtift, foj ft is tbc tnMng of tbc pjofito of the lanD,anD not 
 tljc CUatc in tbc lant), ano tlje M^s ftjall IjatJC ft; ^no to tbat toljfcb fs fafa 
 
 tbat 
 
 lien 
 I'f 
 
 g-t.vr. 
 
 I -vnv.
 
 Trin. 23 Car. j^i 
 
 tl]attbci^<ng cannot be a Coppliolijcr, ft fs not fo cleat; fo; 31 conceftc tlje 
 conttarp: fojafnrrcnDcrofaviCoppljolDtoljtm is £ooD, ano of a ufctoo : 
 anDl)ecUcatl)Creb00feS,9H,6.fol.25. 20 E. j.f.j.n.rep. 91^ Rollelufticc 
 faio , tljat a SCruftce oj cenuy que truft cannot take tfje pjofitss of tbc lano ^'""y i"e 
 but^atljonlptJsremeDpfncquttp.fojtbc CrfiatcmtljelanDts cnlp in tlil''"^'- 
 pprtptniflED; anDtJ)elifnafliallnot!)atictl5ep;cfitsoft!;c lanu upon anou'ibwrv 
 iDntclatop acatnft tDeccfluy queiiie,ojceauy que truft. fJnD iairarttj Lnv & I'qui* 
 Cqnttp oucftt nottobeconfounocD; tftetcfojcfftbel'ifrchaiftcqtittvfoja ■. 
 tl)«ne, t,eono!)t not to rue fojU at tfte Common laui, fofsftfn tbtscafeat 
 tbebar. Adjourned, 
 
 Chapel and Drew; 
 
 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 Hill, ii Car, rot, 92 It 
 
 Ij^ tWs cafe tl)e pattp bcfng attafntco offclonj>,pIeab€5f)t5sr{)artccof ■^xccpt!''" 
 IparDon ano Clafmo, tljercbp tobctcftojcD tobis(!?ooDo ano Cljattcls = P*"^"" ' 
 fojiEitcoto tt)c tetngbp t!)c fclonp ; ano tbc iSucaion \xiag, fotjctljcr astbe '''^'°"-'' 
 parDontoaspennEDbcOjoulDbcrcfiojcooj noc tbeVuojDs oftljcparDon'*"^'"' 
 upon tob<cbtl)C©U£fliongrElD,tocrct!)Cfr, pardonavir,remi(ir, &relax3vir 
 ana it toas ^clo, ttjat Ije tuas not bp tbcfe tiio;D0 to be rcffojco to btj Ooods 
 anti €^attel5?;io; tbe too:D0 do not amount to a &utrenDcr in cafe of a com. 
 TRon pcrfon, muct) Icfo in cafe of tbe iSmcc, ano t!;crc oualjt to Ijabe been the 
 iDOjo reftituit. Roll lufticcfato , HifsJOarDon luasulalDn bp Nov At- 
 torny (©sneral , ann luas toj Ojojt, anu it iDagfatDbpljtintbat tfoi'icbc ''*''"'^' 
 committeo to tl3C<?aolfojoncfclonp, tbe ^uttius mapcnqufrcatiotrp^'''''' 
 t!}c partp foj anotljet f$lojip foj toljicft Ije ma notcommitteo. 
 
 to 
 
 tor 
 
 Tylers Cafe. 
 
 Trin. 23 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 r)cmurrer rd 
 cation 
 
 f A iP ^rtton of 2)cbt ttas bjougftt acatnaTvIeruponan£>bUffattonfo^'"'""' 
 X\ttanD to an atoarQ, ano tlje patntiff DedarcBof an ilrbrtrcmert ' '^■''■" 
 maDc tbciStb. DapofMay(nf«c!)a pear,reaDPtobcDclit3ErcDuptl)cnfne 
 ano ttocntpctl) cap of May in tiic fame peat ; 2Et)c SDcfenoant p!eati0 nul- 
 lum Arbicnum, 2Ebc plaintiff replies, tbat tfjc ^toarD uias maoc bptbc 
 limpire the 2 Stb.of May rcaop to be oelibereo up upon tl)c fame ■> 8tb Dap of 
 May,anDtotl)fa replfcattontbc SDcfcnnsnt Demurs, anD OjcUjs fouaufc 
 tljat tbc plaintiff bao fctfojt!) Double matter, one in bis S^cclara^ion ana 
 tbe otbet in l)is Replication ; foj tbc SiuarD fetfo?tl) in tbeSr^cclaratton 
 anD tbat ret fo:tli in tbelKcplication cannot bcintenDcDtobconeanDtljc 
 fame. 31But Roll luftice anftocrcD , tbat tl)c 3ffue to be trpeo ia not to be 
 taUcn upon tbe oap of tbeilicarD maDc,anD tbercfoic it rcnuiresnoanflrcr ^ 
 anD fo cannot be Double, anD one ounftt not to Demur foj tDcDoiiblcrefa 
 of tbe matter upon a tbing upon icljicb no Sffae can be talien, and ru- 
 led btttcr mattei fhould be (hewn, or elfe ludgemcnt fhould be nivcn for die 
 Plaintiff. 
 
 ^ Hlwick
 
 4^- Trin. ,3 Car. 
 
 Eftwick and the City of London. 
 
 Trin, 23 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 'l**f.^^. "T^ !^c Cafe of Eftwick aiiO the Cicy of London toas again atgciCD bpSef 
 
 Argisment In ■ jeant Glynn fO> tIjC City ; (il |)fg ^rgtimCHt 1)5 ttlltftel) UpOll tl);ccpat- 
 
 ihi; c>fcof tlctilars tDbp Etlwick conlo notbcrcflojcoto .'•,fgplaceofacommon«<Eotjn!^ 
 
 the Writ p'ccUman. «, anbatacommoii^Councclinati map be rcmotco c; fufpcn^ica 
 
 f 'coiv'mor-" ^"'" ^^^ P^^" ^^ plcaftitc bp tl)c cuttottic Of tl)C sZitij. ilp. SDftat l|2 cannot 
 
 c <,un"ci-°'' ^^ rcftojcD bp iLaU). jlp. ipo tcftttutton ran be in t()f3 cafe as U novo ftanos, 
 
 mam pbcr. J?kft, t^c caftottt to rcmo\)c a common^Coiuucbman fc gooo, foiftfirftbc- 
 
 Ktniut.on. tjan bp agrccmcnt,anD fnc!) acnttomc is gooD at tf)c common iair, mnrb 
 
 cuftouie. jj^jijp ^j.j^^ anDUfsnotanunrcafonablccuftomc, alttjougljttmapfccm fo 
 
 prima facie,U(5cas ttlsin tl)ccafe ofa JLojutljat fcffctb tbc Jlantjs of Ijfs 
 
 taUlcfn , ano m tl)C cafe ofaCoppI)olDettl)atfojfeitctI)l)fci (iBftatebp t{)e 
 
 fcllmg of Cfmbcr, :a fccona rcafon (3 , U agrees tpcll uitl) tbc nature 
 
 anu conottfon of tbc office of acommon.Connccl.mantobcfnbiecttotlna 
 
 Tivai. Ctiftomc , ano toe iuiom tljat manp tbtngs ftnll be trpco bp Cu^ 
 
 ftomc, ccntrarp to tfte courfc of tbc common fato. glp. -^Qc fee tftsttlje 
 
 ojtjcr of tl)c |)acliamcnt is a rule to tr|> matters concerning tJjeir i^em« 
 
 bcrs, ano fo it is tierc in tbe Citie to trp tbcic HJcmbers. 4lp. 
 
 3If itfboulo not be fo, itU;oulD pjofccocftructitic to tf)c Citp, bp toafting 
 
 till fuel) an offcnocr mig!)t be remotco bp a courfc iiiHalu, tofttcl) is far 
 
 mojctcDioustljan tills cuitomarp vsap. %o tbcfecono point, Ije fatD , tljat 
 
 bp 3lato tljcrc can be no rcff ftutton to tdis office , ano tftis is pjobeQ bp tt)C 
 
 ijcrp nature of t!)c tiClrit of Kcttttution, Vjliicl) is toreftojet^epartptoa 
 
 frceijolo oj fomc otbcr matter ofp;ofit, neither oftoWcl) can b; in our cafe, 
 
 ano a to;it of Hcflitutionistorcftojeonc toapoffcfsion,tol)crconc map 
 
 notbcrcRojct) bpan ojotnarptDap.nclibct Dotft tbe statute of Maqna char- 
 
 tarrtcno to out cafe : fo; acommon=Couiiccl-mans place is merclp 
 
 nrouuDcr) upontbecuftomeoftijc CItp, ann not upon tl)e Common laU) . 
 
 ano l)C faiDtl)crcaretl);cegrot!n03 foj a tWrtt ofJRcftitution. i.ilcon* 
 
 tempt to the liing. ilp. ilfturt to tbc <!i;ommon:tocaltO. jlp. fparticUlan 
 
 oammagc to fge partp; but none of t^cfe is in our canfc,ano tftcrcfoje ti}ere 
 
 is no caufe fo: a Ctlrtt of IRcftttutlon. SClje cnfc o" §>!r lames Bij^qs !)nlnng 
 
 a ©Elrft of llcQitutiou toas, bccaufc Ije teas ocpjibco of bisHraaeana 
 
 Coi.n bv. 5?recDom,ifree=l)olD,anoour cafeotffcr3fcomtl3etafeofa<i;onfi:ablc, oja 
 
 (hir<hwar. vCfjurcl) tearCcn.o: aup cflfe tftat cau bs ctteO; foj aCfturcl) luarocn {3 anof» 
 
 vv.r.icn. jjfpr iiiTLlatton to tljeCommon Uiealtb fo; tftc cj:-cutionof5;uQ(cc,vi!ierof tl)c 
 
 Common larotaUes notice, ano".iI?ctotfcaConftab!eisatuioton £)fficcrto 
 
 RrcoiJcr. minifter 3ul>tceinrclationtotl)cp;ifaltnuc:foi3it ofaHccoiOerofaCojpo» 
 
 ration, ano fo tt)cp all oiffer from our cafe, j^o; autl)o;(tp to tbts point in 1 7 
 
 lac. but motCO firft i6lac. Warren a COmmon-CounccUman of Coventry 
 
 li as ">cnpco upoii tl)c rcto;n of bis tMrit to be rcCojco, ano our cafe ano rc« 
 
 tojn 13 mo;e fttong agalnft tljc paintiff; ano Burman a Ocntlcman of one 
 
 of tl): 3nnc of Court, being crpclleD,coulo not be rcfiojco bp a CGrtt of l\es 
 
 tlitutfcn, ano latcipacotimon«Counccl=man tons remoljcofo; not taking 
 
 tl)c pjotcltction. jT^o; the t.tro point, vthctljcrupon the cClrititfelf, as 
 
 t!)tscarcf:',tl)CTCcanbcanprfaitiitionmaDe?3 conccitie not, bccaureii 
 
 tc oircacu 10 tl)c ^aio; ano Commonaltp,ano Citizens of tOr Cltp of f.on- 
 
 r. • , don, snofoti^cre is in It a falfe recital of the fufpcnfton; fo; be toas not rc- 
 
 ^"'" ' uioVvO bp t'oc Ci;ij.-ns, ano fothe C£3tit is circaco to parties toho DID not 
 
 the
 
 Trin/2 3Car. ^, 
 
 the tojong , ana fo it fs ffl Dfrcctea , ano ft Differs from t!jc Circctfon of f fic 
 ZSSlxit fn &ft lames Baqs cafc, aut) it otifflit to liaise been fiirctfco to t!)e S>fte- 
 Tiffs oj jpiniftcrg tobo liatic autljojitpto rcttoje Urn, as tJjcp Dio rcmotic 
 f)fm, foj tbc part)' that hatb none no Unonsr ought not to be ptintOjcD oj mo= 
 IcIIcD ; ant) foj the ill oircaion of the liOrit coula not Warren the coaimon- 
 Councel man of Coventry be reftojeo, anothcCojpojation of London ia 
 refponfable foj all particulBt cptfoemcanoura Done Uiithin anp Courts of 
 Sutttcc ioithintfee <Eitt),o> other general spifocmeanours there committcD. MiWemea- 
 Maynard on theothtr fiDcargucD, that tic cafc tuns miftatenasit is fta: routs. 
 nn in theUetojn, fcjit fuppofetb that the party ic remotjco atplcafiirc, 
 ano pet tuppofcth alfo, that there is a caufc to remotsc him,to toit fits refafing 
 to go out,anD erp:ciTcth not that he did not go out,it95 that he inao conrmano^ 
 BD tocooiit, fautthathetoaBrequcficD. 3nDU)herc8fiiti6raiDacomnton= 
 Coancel-mans place io no mojebut toaobife, h-'rc is moic than to 
 aotjifc , fo? he hath a p?tt?ilepc fo j his oitn gooD , ano the goon of the Citp. 
 3lp» %\iz ^rft ia tDCU oirccteo, ano cannot be othcrtoifc foj the partp to 
 Ihatie rcmeDp, ano all ttt IDjcfiocntg arc as this is, ano illDerman Harris his PreCdemt. 
 cafc fs the fame in point irith ttfs , ttherc it teas bp thjce ^uDges rcfolbco, 
 that hcftoulDbcrcflojcDtohis ^iDcrmans place, becaufe it teas a place 
 oflponourastoeilas of JBnrthcn. Rol! Jufticefaio,i. SChat Ihc <IEarit teas. 
 toell irftccteo, sip. Sthat tl3C cuttoiu teas fUrcciteo. 3lp. 3;f ittocre 
 iDCll recitet), pet ft is a tioio cttff om. 4lp. jEhe If^cto^n isnotgooD, 
 foj thcincertainttesofit.viz. inthccaufcsChctocD, tohp the partp'toas re- 
 jnoteiJ , ano thcrcfoje that he ought to be rcttojeo to his place» B^con Ju. 
 ilice to the fame intent, ano faio, that tDhcrcfocberaCommifsioneroj 
 otherperfonhathpotoergibcnto do a thing at his offcrctfon , it is to be mt. 
 DctttooD of louno Difcrctton, anD accojoingto lata, ano that this Court Difcrction. 
 Ijath poUicr to reojcfs things othcrtDtfc Done bp them. The rule was, that ^"■^'''''ftioni 
 the party bereftored, if better matter be not fliewn Tuefday following. 
 
 Trin- 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 1^ an SittfJJn of SCrefpafs fo J digging in his Ground, and carrying away 200 ^^^^^ °f 
 load of foyi, 3t teas motiEDinarrcftof3nogcment,thatft(honlDhat)eV"'^^'"'*"'''* 
 been of fopl indeprovenient. anD tijat an intrnDmcnt cannot mahe it ctooD.'^*^'' 
 Roillunice faiD, ftfctmsagooD exception, foj aoitfs it is too gcncralUe 
 laio. 
 
 Vincent and Furiy. 
 Trin. 13 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 Hil.2 2CanRot, Q» 
 
 V 
 
 Incent bjought an Sctfon of SCrcfpafs againtt Furfy fo j bjeabincc open ^'^^^ '^ 
 2 Chcfts, anD taking jiujap certain Cloaths, ano 3 1. inmonp, anDhattii'/^fp^"^'"
 
 44 7rin, 2 3Car. 
 
 a tacrDfct fo J l)im. %\it SDcfcncaiit motjcs fn 3rrctt of ^uDgcmcnt , am 
 tnUcp tljcfc crcrpttons. i . SEbat tbc 2Dcclarat<on ia too general, fo; it fcto 
 not toiV.) \u!)at tbc dotljc lucre iDbtcli lucre tahcn aVunp, aiio fo t»)c talnc of 
 tbcm cannot be Unoicii as <t oiigbt to be, tljat iDamagcis m<ir be rlgljtlp gf- 
 lif n. 2. 3n tijw one SDcclaratloii tbcrc in an flrttoii of SEtcfpaffe , jopneo 
 lu(tl) an 0rtlon npon tIjcCafc, vrz. tijc JCrcfpaffc foj bjcaUfng open tbc 
 Cl)cft3 ,nno tbc flrtfon of tljc Cafe ioi taUing atoap tl)c doatbce, ano mon j', 
 ip!)lc;;0[ic>)t nottobc, fo; tlnofetopral Actions ought not to bclafofn one 
 SDeclaratton. Wadham Windham of ConnccllkUb tbc plaintiff fa(D it Ipao 
 Uicll cHougb, anu coulo not be otbcruiifc.ano tbe tbing ia tcttainlp cnongb 
 fctfojtb, anotb^lll be interpjCtCO reddendo fingulafin^ulis, viz. tbc fpolia- 
 vit in t'oc Declaration fl)all bate reference to tbc cloatba, anD the cepit to 
 
 Tr •• an* tlic mcn)'. Rollc luftice faio , tbat an Sttiou of SLrotcr , HnD ContJcrCou 
 
 ConvV: iion. fo' Dit?erfl fojtB of linncn bao been aDtnogco gooo. ano 29 E. 3. an flctioit 
 of CrefpntTc 1 j'co fo? beating of bio fcrfcant , anD in Cletheroes cafe, an iTct. 
 
 Ticfj'anc. (on of ECrcfpaffc voao bclo gooo fo; refcuing a pjifoncr from bim ivboin be 
 bao^rrcOcD, ano tbe ^CooUofGrayes Inn b?ougbt an action of SErcfpaffc 
 fo? tahing atoap Mo Itife, per <]uod conforcium amifir, ano it Ujao bclD to be 
 locHbjougbt,b[itiftlKc!oatbointbe(arcat tbe bar bao not been in tbc 
 tbcft,tbc action iDotilD not bate lain; ano be took anotbcr cjrccption.nanres 
 
 inceitaiiit), 'l' tbat tbc JSDcclaration toss fo; tbc bjcaUtug Of acbcfts, anofo it appear0 
 not Uibcrc tbc cloatljs lucre tobcntbcpirere taken, tobctbet fn oneoj in 
 'Jotbof tbcm^ Tile rule was to ftay ludgement till they had fcen the Re« 
 ordi 
 
 Capcll and Allen, 
 
 Trin. c5Car. Banc. Reg, 
 Hill. 12 Car, rot, 639* 
 
 C April bjougbt an action SDcbt npon an AfTurapnt to ftanfi f an afoaru, 
 tbe E'efenoant pleaoeo Nul Arbitremcnr, tbc ?Dlnintiffrrplj'C0, ano 
 
 wL'd' ^" '" fetafojtbtbc arbitrcmcnt, ano tbc bjcacb,tbc BPcfcnoant oemuta, ano 
 fo J caufe fljctog tbat tbc atoaro toas not gooD , bccaufe it toaa maoc but of 
 
 Aw;rd. onc part, fo> it tuas , tbat one of tbc parties Iboitlo do fuclj 
 things crp^cfrco , ano tbat tbc other partp IboulD pap fo; tbe ma. 
 iiing the JlBonDs of feubmifsion, lubicb cannot be alDatDcD, ano fo no« 
 tbfng is atiarDciD foj bim to to , anu the arbitrators cannot atoaro this ,facj 
 
 Suiniiiiion. caofc it is ttot iDtthtn tbc fubmifoion. Rolie luftice held this a good exccps 
 tion , ano faiD ttc Charge fo; mahfng the Injitings is not iuifbfn the 
 ^nbrnifsion , fo; tbe bonus vtjcrc maoc befoje the &ubmifflion , ano it toaa 
 bcltt 1 3 Jac. that tbe tjDojDs fuper prxraiiTis in tbe aVoato VciU not bclp an a- 
 toaro maoe bat of onc part. 
 
 Trin,'
 
 Trin. 25 Car. • 4) 
 
 Trin, 2 3 car- Banc. Reg. 
 
 A 
 
 j^ jactton of 2!)cbt teas bjougljt ttpon a liBono, to perfo jm t!)C Cotic- ^"■'■■J''fcr to 
 ^ , nantsofan^nDcntiircofa 2Dctnifc fo; ^cnra. SEbc J3lafiitlfF sc.'^^jj'J,'''''';^ 
 clarcotljatljcniaDct^clLcaretotbeiDcfcncant tfte 28. uap of May, anDabondtopc- 
 tiat aftctlnatos fcilicet the 27 ,of tfje fame £r5ontb of May , tijc ©efenoant *'>nii covc- 
 bjoUctfjeCotienant. SEotftfa SPeclaration ttjeSDcfcneant bid Dcmurr ,'^»''""f«" 
 bccaufc it appears tijat tbc bjcaclj «s fct fojtl) to be bcfojc tbc Icafc Ocaan, Jj"jJ"i',"''' • 
 toljtcb coulD not be , atiD fo tijcre (0 no caule of action. 315ut to this Bacon in,crpretati- 
 lutlice fa<o, trbcrc tfte poftea anD tftc fcilicet are repugnant (n a Dcco,ag tjerc ons. 
 tftepare, tbc poftea djallbcgooDtoftgnffietftctfrneoftbc Cotcnant b?0' 
 i?en , anOt^C fcilicet ftall be t)0<0. Therefore fhcw caufewhy the Plaintiff 
 ftiould not have ludgeraenu Nota. 
 
 Trin, z^Car Banc Reg. 
 
 A|pjot)ib(tfon toas pjspcD to tl)c Cojpojat(on of Lincoln upon a fug^ For a prohi- 
 gclHon maoe , ano f luojn in tW Court, tljat tljc caufe of Jetton f f a= binon to tUc 
 nplncrearofefntljcbotjpoftbcCountp of Lincoln , ano not Ipttbfn t!)c77°"''°" 
 lurisDtttfon of tbe Cttp of Lincoln. Hales on tbe otljer Coe fafo , tbcp bao 'u,l"Ak>'n' 
 aomtttcD tbe lutf0Dfa<on of tbc Court in tbat tbep ban not plraocD to ft. IBut "lurisJiftio'n. 
 Roll luitice fato , fnfcriotir Courts arc If mfttcD fn tl)cft (urfsofctfons , ann i''^«ii bt'on*. 
 ongljt to be feept fn ojoer bppjobfbftfons ft tbcp crceco , ano ff tbcp pjoccctj P'°"f "^'"g^- 
 fn matters not lrftf)fntbcfc jurfsofctfen tbetr pjoceeofngs are tofo. /.di 
 journed to the next Terra, 
 
 Trin. 2 3 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 Tl^c Court toas mobCD foj a |3;obfbftton to an fnferto j Court , but on ^".'^ * i*^"^'* 
 tbc contrarp part ft teas fat o , tl)at tbcp moUco too late , foa tbep bao T.'^ "<,"' "" 
 aomftteotbejarfsofctfon of tbe Court bpplcaofng, anocftco 9 H, 7. i2.ccuVr 
 anuFitz. jurisdidl. 19. Bacon lufticefafo, ft ffl bcre fn a Court of Com= Admiiiion. 
 moniLatu, anbnotfn tbc fptrftual Court oj^ J3Dmiraltp, anD tberefojc 
 a }0?obfbftton map be bcrc granteDnottoftbftanbfng tbc plcaofng tbcre , but Prohibition. 
 IjaD ft been tbc fpf ritual Courtoj. tbc 0Dmfraltp, ft bao been otberteffc. 
 31ButRollcIafticcfafD,ft teas all one fn tbcfpfrftual Court, oj ;3Dmfraltp 
 as ft fs fn tbfs tafe, ff tbep crccco tbcfr jurfftOfrtfon. i^et ft fs mffcbefbous to luri diaion; 
 grant a pjobf bftf on fn tbfs cafe, foj tbercbp manp Juogcmcnts tcfll be ttop. 
 pcD, SL^crcfo je tbc Court would advife to the next Term, but ftayed oothinr.. 
 
 Trin,
 
 t 
 
 A^ ' Trin. ijCar. 
 
 Trin ->: Car. Banc Res 
 
 T" i^c Court li^acimoticDtl)attl)ctjnt)crC[jcrtffm<gl)t return a Slurp, be 
 Forti.e un- -^ tatjfc tbc fe)!)crf ff, antt Cojoncr iicrc of Mm to the |Bla(nttff , tlic 
 I'c'^'i'rnahuv ^''"'■f thtre!!potiDcmani5ctJlDl)ctl)crtI)cpl)aobjougr,t in tl)c furmiic, ant> 
 Kcp'm.^ '"'■pjotirot1jcpct(grcc,to tDbtcbtbep anftocrco , SDijcp ijaii, tfjctcupon t^icp 
 SiiiP.i fc. Id: re tio to name fomc jatturncps of tlje Countrp, tobUl) teas Done , and 
 IVtij^rtf. tiicrtupon a rule made that they fliouid return the Jury. Nota» 
 
 Trin. =3- Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 I"di'I/I° T ^^^ Contt tras motjcn fox a rule to Cap pjocccofitgc fntlje Court at 
 ^hc o fur It Maidfton fii Kent, bccaufc a fuperiedeas coiilo not be grantco , foj tbat 
 M >ydftr-n. notl)tng erroneous tffiics out of tbfa Court. 115ut tbe Court anfsuereo, tijat 
 bu c.kdcas a fuptrfedcas mial)t Uiell be grantee , ano fo fato Hodsden tbc ^cconoarp , 
 
 altboiiPljnotbfng erroneous be fffutng out of tl}i3 Court , ano Bacon lufticc 
 \vr irs. fa<o tbnt tbc CiHrfts of tbc Court arc as goon , ano of as mucb fojcc as tbc 
 iijics. rules of Court , anDtbercfojc UicitiiUmahcnorulctoftap tljcit pjocecD* 
 
 fngS, but you fliall have a fuperfedeas if you wilU 
 
 Perfon and Dawfon- 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 ArnftcHuJ^- % ^ 0(tfon oftbc Cafc icas bjougbt by> Perfon againtt Dawfon foj 
 Aft on'tl'"' ^^ ^^^^^ toOJtis, ponrgjon inntv-ndo pour §>on Wilii'am,noIea horre,and 
 words ""^ foldhim for ten pounds ; Cbc |31ati'.tiff »}atb a tSlctDfct, tbc SDcfcnDant 
 
 motcDtnarrcftof fuDgcmenttbattbc inojosarenot aatonablc, bccaufc 
 ^'^'^. uiiccrtain, ano tbc innuendo cannot bclptbcm ; ano tbc Hnogcmcnt teas 
 
 V Vujiis. aapco tiil tbc otbcr flioulo motjc. 3it teas aftcrtearDs motjco again . ano tbc 
 
 3uDgCmcnt ftapcO , and this Term ludgemcnt given for the Plaintiff, 
 
 Micfi . 2 5 . Car. Banc, Reg- 
 
 EndftifcnrT^^ Court toas motco to quaft mt Cnofctmcnt npon tbc &tafnte ofu« 
 
 u"un:i"cs\- fnrp. 2nbc erceptfon taljcn teas , tbattttsnot fafo corrupte agrca^ 
 
 nicrt 111111). vie necaccepit, ano fotbc Statute isHOtpurfucD ; Roll luOice fafo , tbattt 
 
 I'm fiuncc, is tbc cojrupt rcccttf H?, ano tbc corrupt contract, upon tob<£b ©nofitmcnts 
 
 arc fraittCD upon tbc olo Statute, viz. 3. Jac. Srcbuttf tbc C-nUfttmcnt 
 
 be frameo npon tbc statute of 2 1 lac. tbcre it ougbt to be upon tbe corrupt 
 
 contract, ano bccaufc tbtsCnDtctmcntfoframcD upon tbc Statute of 2r 
 
 Jac. ano mcntiona not tbc co?rupt contratt, it is not gooD , and therefore let 
 
 i itbequafhed, 
 
 • Yatci
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. 47 
 
 Yates againft Lyndon. 
 Mich* 13 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 MAry Yates b?ongl)t an Action upon t\)e Cafe foj fpcafefngtljcfc toojng Arrtftof juc-g- 
 Ofbet, Mary Yates is a Sorcerer, and a Witch, nndawhice Witch, '"^'^^ '"'^ 
 fhe can witch and unwitch 1 ant) tjatl) a tSlcrCftt. %[c SDcfcnOant niovco „" j" '"'' 
 in^rteftof BEuDgcmcnt tliat m toojco arc net aafoiinbic, Iccaiifc tljccifc' 
 aDlafnt(ff<snotbptl)cfp0abfncoftt)cmb?oucHtoUtimtl)e Statute of ii.sta.u c. 
 J ac. againft ?KHttcl)=craft: 31Bnt Roll luQice coiifctcD,U^I)Ctl)cr t!jr teo;t ^0;= Wuchcuff; 
 ttxtt DtD not bUm tlje ^Dlatntiff iiftljm ttjc Statute. J?ct KuDtrrmctit toaa 
 ftapco till tbc plaintiff fljoiilD mote. Hill, the Came pear it teas niotcQ a- 
 gain , anD the Court aojuDacD Nil capiat per billam, fo j thep hclD the \iojCjj 
 net aaionable. 
 
 Turnetand his Wife. 
 Mich, 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 fnicnt in 
 
 Turner ano hiss Wife b?ot!oht an iJdiontipon the Cafe foj thefe toojtia, Ar-^ift of 
 fpoJJCnofthC Wife, (he is a Witch, and I Will take my oath of it ; S^tie ludgemc 
 
 plafntiffshaDatacrDirt: 2Ehe SDcfcnDant mobes in arreft of Suogcmcnt*' Aftionior 
 that the iDojDo inerc not aatonablc; fo j to fap one is a Mitch , ano to fap no ''"^'^'* 
 tno;c,is not actionable, ano the laft uiojug , 31Ujilltal;e mp oath of it, do 
 not enlarge the fojmct ttOjW. The Court arrelled Judgement till the Pla'in- VVordsi 
 liff (hould move. 
 • 
 
 Paracrine and Jane. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car, Banc. Reg, 
 Hill. 22 Car.ror, 1178, 
 
 PAradine bjought an Action of SDrbt foj rent otic foj lanfi?, let fo j pears \-rument irt 
 unto lane thcSDcfcnuant, ano DcclarccpatticularlphoiD much rent legs ';• be f -t rent 
 Due, anD fojtohattlmc, 2Dhc SDefcnDant pleabs a fprcial |Dlca to this "i'0"» '"'= 
 cffi (t; as to part of the rent f oj tohich the Action is b?onr ht,hc tonfcffcth the ' " >"" • 
 action: 03 to the rcCc he plcaDs, that Prince Rupert an'aiicn, ana an G'= 
 nempoftheteinginbaDcDthclanDbjith an 0rmp, anD tetth oitjcrs ar- 
 meo men Dio enter upon him, anD Dio Djibe alnap hie Catti 11, anD crpc licD 
 him from the lanDs let unto hfmbp the plaintiff, anD Ucptl)fni o:;t that he 
 coiilD not cntop the lanoo foj fnch a time; ano DcmanDs juDj^cment if foj the 
 rmtinciirreo During that time the plaintiff oug!}t tg habcbi^ Action ;• 3i:o 
 this plea the plaintiff Dcmurro, anD fojcaufe faith, that it ii3 neither gooD '^^""''""■'■ 
 in matter no J fojm. Che i.qtisftion Vnag, \ihcthcr a Jicffcc foj pears 
 otifteDbp an 3rmp of Alliens, can pleaD it inlBarr, in an Action of SDcbt-"". 
 b;ousht foi rent Due upon the iLeafC;'janD to thia it irao faio, that this is an "'^^''''• 
 action of SDebt,anD Ipco mecrlp upon the contract bcthjecn the partpcs ano '{^-"a^' 
 fo this collatcrall maticr pleaoeD is nothing to the purpofe, but hao it bren 
 an action of U)aft,if the loafthflD been Done bg Pr. Kup?rr,anD hia feolcicrs, 
 it map be it misht habc been pIcaocD to bar tijc plaintiff, j i p. e. 2 .Brook 
 
 CotJE-
 
 A^ ~ Mich. 2 5 Car. 
 
 Co\3'^nanf47toa3 citco. i;5:rttljc pica uotb not fap,trjitt^earmcomcn 
 Vttl) P^fncc Rupert Uj-rc fllicna ojCBiicmfcsoftljciidig, biJtoiilptl)at 
 L 'my WMlUC Ruperc \ua3 fo. IBilt to tljJs CfCCptiOll Roll luftice anfU3crcD. ti)at 
 
 tbep'ftjall be fo hitciioco <f tl):i''bc W'Slxm^ toftl) toljfct) l)c intiaoco tljs 
 llano, another cvccptfoutoastaUen, tiiat tlje pica ctijcsj no anfiact at 
 ' ■ all foj one £liiartcr3 rent DcmanDCD, lubicl) tncutrco after t!)D time tl)at 
 
 he iunsfe pt out bj.' pjincc Rupert, SLlicComucl foj tljc iDefenoant ttt 
 DcfciKC of tl)c pica, urrtcD tbat it liias not ncccffart> to abcr, tbat t!)c 3lrmp 
 tottljpjtncc Ruperc vocrcfllicno, ann citco ^ H.6, 6i. anDtl)c Conned 
 Rbei tool; a Difference bcttocen an Ciicmp anDaiilcbcl; anotbonn^ in tijetafc 
 
 of a IRcbcllion tbta niisftt not be a gooD pica, pet in cafe of an 3Int)a(ioti 
 KcnicJy. jjp (onciioco it iv.C!5,bccai!fc Ijc coulo bauc no rcmc^p agatnft tlje partp.ano 
 rcfcmb'eBtl)ii5 cafe to cafes of lilic nature citca out of9E. 3.7.40 E. 3 6. 
 YVaftf. & 53 H. 6. 1. anu fala , tljat iobcrc Uiaftc ia none ia tijc Lanos let foj 
 p:av3 b)' one > again Uiljom tl;c %tSu can !)avc no rcmcDp otocr, tljcrc tljc 
 BLcffc foj v^tixa is not tbarseablc foj tbcvuafte, except be be bonno bp a 
 particular Co'ocnant to hcep t!)e JLanDij let Initbont Ujnftc. fllfobptlji 
 =Laiaof l^cafon ttfeemotfteSDefenoant in our cafe ongbt not to becljarsco 
 iDitl) tl)c rent, brciufc l)e co.ilo not cnjop tbat tbat toas let to Ijim, anD it 
 Cvii bw. Inas no fault of btsoLontbatbecoubnot, anotbeCibil lato, anDCanon- 
 can.n. lato.anocpoial iiutbojflDoconfirintbiii, anoD'/er 56. & II A(T. 13. lucr:; 
 M0..1. citcD; ano it Inas faio , tbcrcia no Difference bctloeen aninnunoationano ' 
 lin-.mdation. jjjjg^i',^j,fj3„^ q.^q b'lo t!)C ILnnDc bccn fnrronnDBD bptuatcr , tijclLeffcc 
 ftonlD not ba\3e been cbargeablc foUbs rent anting tbat time, ncitber as 
 31 conccibc fliill be be bcrc. ^:%i conftacr t'.)c nature of tbe rcfcrbatiort, i ©► 
 Kcnr. j^gp J ,g - rcnt{!3nottobcpaiountillitma|>beintcnD:Dt!)nttl)c3leirce 
 
 r.ymciir. ^^^^^^^ ^^^^ tcccitiED tbu pjoftt of tbc tljing foj iubtcb tb: rent ia to be pniD, 
 i7'E 3.81.8 H.4.6.ritz'i. Execution 146. 9 E. ?. »(5, ncftbcr bptbeSB.u* 
 tial lato is tbc HDctcnaar.tcbJrgcablc. ano tb« ILato is tbe Blato of jjiature 
 • ^'^''f K '"■ 83 tocll asj of ip.nions. But Roll luiltce anflcereo 'tbat tbc pica teas 
 inVr." "' not gooD, fo; be liatb not pleaoco tbat the ilrmp lucre aliens ano unUnolnn, 
 Cov'.iunt, as be otigbt to bnuc Done, anD tbe plcaotng tbatittnaahoiHiisexercicus, 
 mnUco not tbc pica mo; c certain tt)anbefo:c, ano if tbc SCenantfo; pears 
 covenant to pap rcnt,tbougb tbc ilanoslct bim be furrounoeD luitb tuatcr,pct 
 l)c i3 cbavgcable loitb tb: rent,mucb moje bcre. riiercfore lee die Plaintiff 
 t^ke hisiudgcment, • 
 
 Fremlingand CliKheibook^ 
 
 Micb, 23 Car, Banc. Reg, 
 
 ,^vc!> of lu.'g- rjRfmlinc; anD bii5 ^^tfc, eyccntrii: of A.B. bjing an 0it{on of SCroljcc 
 
 niciit in Tio- |^a.iDConDerfionagai!iftCluthcrb'jok,fo;©ooDsof tbc Sbcftntojs fotinD, 
 
 vcr ji.JCor- gjiQ contirrtcj h\> tbc Defendant, anoobtainco a Deroictagainftbiin. SEbc 
 
 v.Li.un. nricfcnDant moiieo in aitctt of 31tiogcm:nt, ana tooU tbcfe (Erceptiong. u 
 
 SEb'it tb: S>cclaratto;iloa3of a jopnt poUcfsion of ©ooDscf tbe!l)a3banD 
 
 nno C2Rife, anD oamniacccs arc giben to tbc If)!isb.inD anD t^ife , mbercas 
 
 tbc CJooiDa piopcrlp bilong to tbc saifc onlp as an CErccutrir, an!) not to tbe 
 
 iviicru.n. ^ijgijam, ijno caif:. 2lp. 3tt)otb not fct fojtftDoiuTtnrjfcmc came to tbc pof- 
 
 !r.fv5toitoftbc(!!>ooDi; 515uttotbi-3 Roll luftice anftocrcD. tb^tttbcpoltcf^ 
 
 fionoftbc Cclifc, asGSrrcutrif/ajagalfotbcpoucfsfototbcr^'lJiisbanD, ano 
 
 tl)at tbc oanimages reco'ocrco a^U be to tbc eftatc of tbe 2Ccttatoiir, anQ fo 
 
 map concern tbcin faotb. ano foj t!jc fccono cicccption,tt3ts bcins a poffcf= 
 
 farp
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. .^ 
 
 - -' ^ 49 
 
 fatp aflfottonlp, ft fenotncccOatptoflictDljotDtSepoircrsfonoft^edDoofis 
 
 ]Ba0 gsineo. Stayed till cbe ocher Hiould move ^ 
 
 ParmicerandCrcfljr. 
 Mich, »3 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 PArmiter bjfngs an Sltffon apott tfte cafe apon an Affumpfir, ano Declare©, AreiTof ludg. 
 tJjattljcSDefenDanttnconCDeratfontliat V)Z pafntfff taofoHi ano oe. dentin an 
 UbctcD unto Wm fucft anantbctofpfEcesof&tuffe, t6cE)efeni»antDft)ar='''*^^''''^'"* 
 fume anD pjomKc to tljeJBIafntfff to oeUter onto t)fm t^c talae of t^e fetaffa^""'^^''* 
 In tuci) iafpea of ©atne, Ipfng f n BradgatesCcUat fn London as tljC pafntfff 
 l^oQlo mafee cljotfc of j ano foj not pcrfojmfng tftc fame bjfngs ftfa 9iaU 
 on. 2Dbe paintf ff obtains a DetDict C^e SDefenoant mot)es fn acreS of 
 Bnogement anD'dietDS tbefe canfcs. i, Sl^at tfie pafntfff Dotb not 
 abet fn SfsBDeclatatfon, tbat be maoe anp elcttfon of tbe ppee of Mfne, Averment ■ 
 ano bsfo je fucb elcctfon tbe SDefenoant tnas not bonno to oelf bet tbem , nap 
 ft tuasfmpofflfblcfojbfai to perfojmtbe agreement before fbe electfon.zlp^p, _ 
 SCbe pafntfflf ootb not fet fo jtb , tbat be maoc frts cletfton iDbete tbe Mfne ^'**""'- 
 ipaSjiDbfcbbeoagbttoliatjeoone, becaufe of tbe fnfappo^tablenefs ofti^e 
 commotf tp to be b;tougbt to bfm to mahe bis cbofce« Cbe Coart belo , tbat 
 Ijere ongbt to beafpecfaltequeftmaDctoDelfbertbcHBHines, faecauteftfa Requcft fpe- 
 opon a Contract, anbanattfonofjDebtlfesnotfojtbem, ano tbercupoit cai. 
 arrcSeb tbe Buogement tin tbe pafntffF fl^oulo mote. 2Dbe fame 
 JCctm Slnogcment teas gfben agafnft Vjz pafntfff, Qjjod nil capiat pec 
 billam. 
 
 Mich- 25 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Tag pafntffE bjfngs an 0ctfonoftbe Cafe agafnft tbe SDefcnoant, fojAfftofiujg. 
 fpcabfng tbcfe tuojos agafnft bfm befng a jpinfftct , He is an Adultc= 2?""'" '" ='- 
 rer, Wtiorcmafler , Drunkard, a common Swearer, and a Preacher ofthc°Cafcrr 
 falfe Dodrine. Ebe |9lafntf ff batb a tHctbf ct. SEbc SDefcnoant mobeD fn vords. " 
 atreft of sinogcment tbat tbe Vaojus toete not adfonable, bccanfe tbe matter Words. 
 crpjelTeDbptbemismerclpC-tclefiaftfcal, ano nottrpable at tbe Common JY*'- 
 latD ; ano ft toas fafo, tbat a man map picacb falie Doftrine, ano not be pa. '""«^°^f '«. 
 nffl^eo (0% ft, ff be be not a bencSceo man, ano ft ootb not appear bere, 
 tbat tbe pafntfffbaoanplitfng, ano facSoes, ftfsnotrafobetoasa Preach. ""«»=. 
 er of heretical Dodrine,but Of falfc podrine,tDbfcb iDOjDsarc moje arobf- 
 gtious. The iodgeroenewai flayed till the Plaintiff fhould move. 
 
 Mack and Cubitc • 
 
 Mich. 23 Car, Banc. Reg.' 
 ^^. Pafc.23Car.rot. Q^, 
 
 AreftofluJg- 
 
 MAck bjougbt an jatffon npon tbe cafe agafnft Cabiit foj fpeaWng tbefe ^[^"^' '" '" »- 
 toojDS of bf M , You are a branded Rogue, and have held op your the° clTfe for 
 
 ^ hand words.
 
 PrcfiJent'. 
 
 50 Mich. 23 Car. 
 
 VV>"-<'s. hand at the Bar, and defervc to be hanged, and (hall be hanged . CfjC piaiti' 
 tiff batft a mcx^ldt S^c SD^fenoant motes <n arrrft of gtiDgemcnttbat 
 the teojDa tocrc not aflJonablc , fo; tbcp are all btit ivojos of '^ntamj' atio 
 Df r0racc,anD not of Dam:t:age to tbc pafntlflf. But It toao fr.to', tljnt it baD 
 been aoiaogcD tUat an flttlon oio Ipc foj fapfng one Ijao b:cn cnofctcDof 
 Barratry , tobcrc tbc partp that teas cnoldcD uias atqufttcn , atiD foj 
 raping one toass a Banckrnpt Rogue. 15ut bccaufc Panel of Counccl tofth 
 tbcDcfcnoantfafD, t)C roulDQ)ctDp?caDcntotbattljc toojoo are notacti. 
 enable , tftc <Z oiirt fo;bo?c to gftoc Suogcmcnt, but acnrcu to fee tbcm, ano 
 gaticbfmtimctobjtngtbcmfnanotbcrDap, Panel cftcD tlno p:efiDcnts, 
 but no 3,uO0emcnt fncftljcr. Whereupon ludgcmcnc was given for the 
 Pl-intiff. 
 
 Blackvvell and Afliton* 
 
 Trin, 23 Car. Banc. RegJ 
 
 Ucnuirrcr to C i^^tuet fcbctal perfotts tocrc bouno conjudim anD divifim in an £>b« 
 a sciic ucias " Ugatfon to Bl jckwell,Blackwell Ijatb a guDgment afahift tl)cm,onc Of tbe 
 upon a jujgc- S>efcnDants ofco, Blackwell rues out a Scire facia* agatnft tlje 4. aaD it toas 
 S'^inurrcr ^•^'""tt^D to tbc Scirc facias , betanfconeeftbcD.fenoantoagainftiohoni 
 Abiiciiicn- ibcBiuDffcmcnt upon irbfclj tbc Scire facias loa: grantee, toas oeaD tobcn 
 ttjc Scire fuias iffucD fo;tb 3n tl)io cafeit toas faio, if ttoo be bounn jopntlp 
 in an Obligation , ano an 0cion be bjou5l)t againfl one of tb:m onlp, upon 
 this Obligation tbc SDcfcnoant cannot ocmur, but mac plcao in ilbatc= 
 mcntoftbc Cdvit. 3nDift'ao bcbounl)iopiitipinan£Db!igation, ano one 
 ' of tbcm tpc, auD ttjc Obligee bjinga an Action ofSDcbtagaintt tbc otbcc 
 tbat furtitcs, he mutt in his declaration fctfojtbtbattbc other is ocao. 
 SIhc plaintiff ill the cafe at tbe5i5ar,pcrccibiiig the inclination of the Court 
 Sc;ichci:«.- to l^c tbat the Scire facias toas not gooo, motjcb foj his oton crpeoltlon to 
 tntjc it quaibcD, which was granted. 
 
 ZLodg and Weeden. 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Artfto'iuif,. 'Tl^c plaintiff baings h<s 0£tton upon the Cafe agah, ft the E^efcnDanf, 
 
 inr t in ,„ X g„Q Declares, that the Dcfcntant hao hillcD oit^cra (nfcctco €attel, 
 
 aa.u, upon a„jj hauthJoton out tbcinirarOBojoffaUofthofeCattcl upon thcClofcof 
 
 ' "" • the plaintiff , tohctcbp otbcrs of the plaintiffs (Eattcl tocrc infectco toitb 
 
 tbc murrain, ai«t)iDDpe thereof, anDfl>ctoohotoman|',anD Declares to his 
 
 Dammage lorauch, ano hath ateroict agafnfttbCiDcfcnBant. K\)c E>c- 
 
 fcnoant motea in artett of 3[uDgcment,ant) offers thcfc crtcptions, 1 . 2CU 
 
 S?cclaration is , that tbc plaintiffs Cattcl toerc infcctcu morbo niortali, 
 
 Anglice VLith tbc murrain, tthcrcas there is a pjcpcr i.atfn toojD to crpiefs 
 
 vvoi '^ t'^'^^u'i^ain, namclp lues, tobichowBbtto hate bcenufci), ano not to be 
 
 "'""■ crpjcifcD bp luch uncertain too job as morbus mortalis io, irhich fignifics on» 
 
 Ip a mojtal cifcafc, ano fo might be anp other Difcafe as totU as tbat» ilp. 
 
 %iit JE^cciaration faps that the iSDcfcnuant cio caflc interioria, Anglice the 
 
 intoatos oj offall of the Cattcl, tehetcas that fs not the pjopcr l.at.'n toojo 
 
 fo;
 
 Trin. ijCar. 
 
 f o; ti)cat, but inteftina, 3!?. S,l)e Dsclacatf on Dotb not fet fojt^ toljat Cat*. 
 tcl ttjei' iDctc, noi Ijoto mrniv tftep iccrc, that tljc iDefenoant ban b(Uco,antt 
 ttjjoUjn tl)ctt inluarcs 0: offall on ttjc plaintiffs dofe. Buc the Court 
 overruled all the exceptioi-s, and ordered the Defendant to fliew better uufe 
 why the Plaintiff (hould nc-c have judgement. 
 
 Ravvfbn and Bargue. 
 
 Tiin. 2 j '.Car . Banc, Reg» Vid. antea* 
 
 T^c cafe bettocen Rawfon ano Barque upon tfce fpetfal tacttjfct founn in 
 anar'.fon upon t^c §>tatatcof 2 Ed.^.fojnotfEttfngfojtbofSEUbes/rg""'"" 
 toljcrcfn tftc ^Jueflfon toastobetbertlje Chapel teas a free Cbapel, anD gU p.^chsjei 
 tjen bp tfje &tatnte of : Ed. 6, to ttie fefng j no, teas moteo again, ann at- „r not within 
 aucD bp Maynard tljat ittuas afrcE Ctjapcl gifeen to Edward tl^c 6t^. bp teethe statute of 
 Statute, anD fais, the fittt reafon toao taken from tlje tro jcs of t^z &tatnte» i Ed. 6. 
 •afcccno tcafonfromtljc preamble of tlje^t^ute. 3. t^irD from tbe tea. ^[^^"'':, 
 fon of tlje statute. Sim a fourtlj from t^c meaning of tbe &tatnte. JFittt ^ * 
 
 tl)e intent of tl)e g>tatt]tc tsas to ctanoe Ctiapels of fuperfiition to pious 
 nfcs, ano Doth inteno rcfojmation, anr> net to take atnap tbc Cftapcls t^em= 
 felt!£0, ano foj tbis caui'c^t being toj fo great a gooD, tbc gitatutc ftallbe 
 gcnctaBp <ntcrp?eteD,i i Rep. f , 17, ano tbc too jOs All mannour in the Sta- 
 tute, &c. to mojc oppofe aoiffinttion tbantbeirojDalltanuo, foj tbep 
 atcmo;ccmpbaticalIpnfeD, ilp SCbougb it be parocbial ano ioittj cute of 
 §)ouls,pEt it is not EjcmpteB out of tbe Statute, ano tbis Statute Differs 
 from tbc Statute of 37 H. 8. ianb in cafe of ftee Cbapcls, all ate tefteo in 
 tbe !aing ( be tbcp fupetflitious oj not ) bp tfte fetatute. 3lp. %t is Vctiing, 
 not tDitbin tbc crtcptiono in tbc statute , aun tbercfo?e fs trttft- 
 fn tbc statute , anu be took tbis cifference , tbat SDonojs of CbuKbeSDifferencc." 
 are, Ubere Cburtbes are tonattbc ; anb Jpatrons of Cburtbes are, tobete 
 tbcp arc p?cfentatitc. 2lp. STbe p?eof of tljc contempojarp crpcfition of 
 tbc&tatutetsbcretobeconCDereD,6H.7. 14. i^rae Cbapclsarc oftlro 
 fojts, 7Ed. 3,18. 17 Ed.?. 12. Cooks Lit, 144. 51 iFrec Cbapel map beDiyifion 
 pjefcntatite, ano a Iparift-Cbncrb bonatitc, anDtbeparefoattojDingtODonaiWe. 
 tbc founbation of tbcm at tbc flrff. SI i3ar<Qjd:burtbcannotbea#rtt» 
 Cbapel, but a iFrec-.ebapcl map be a Ipariflj-Cbnrcb, 47 E. 3. 5. 9 E. 3. f-*/'*^: ■ 
 f. 10. ;oEd. 3. anbaCturtb is notaCburtb ifitbatenot JBaptifm, ano * 
 JBurial belonging unto it, Brad. lib. 3. C. 4. 17 E. 3, 5 E. 3. 3 Cbspel map 
 te tiitI)iHaCburcb,anDaCburcbliitbinaCbapcl; ano Capellai8Derib£D^"»^»t'<"'- 
 ftp Rbenanus tbc Citilian, from a Cap oj Covering,ani) fo fs to be atcomptED 
 tno?e fuperflitiou tban Cburtbes arc, becaafc tticit berp name fljciiis tbeit 
 bcriuation to be fupcrftftious. Twifden argucD on tbe tontrarp, tljatit 
 fcas not toitbfntbc statute of J Ed. 6. no? gttcntberebp to tbetoing :ano 
 tbat it is not a iFrec.Cljapel, neitbcr bp tbe Idojds , no j tcitbin tbe intent of 
 tbc fetatute. 2lp. 31f <t be a i^ra.dtapcljpet it is p?cfentatibe, ano toitb- 
 tn tbe Juriftiafon oftbc£)jDinarp. ancfonot aifrcc Cbapeltfojitbatl) 
 no immunitp eitber in rcgato of ^uricbittion oj otberlBifc , ano titcD Cooks 
 J.ittlet on, f. 94. 2E^e Cbapclfl of tbc ISing are all j^rcc- Cbapcls , bccaufe 
 tbcp tbcp are crcmpt from afl SurifDictionoftbc jO?Dinarp,Regifier,4o, 
 41. %i)xe arc tioo fojts of Cbspclo , to toft, i^ra^tonatibcs, 6 H. 7. f. 19. 
 2lp. p jcfcntatitcs. Nat. Br, 3 5 . Cbapcl map be p?cfentatibe bp tbe 
 fotmoationoftt, o;bp matter ex poftfado,22 H.6. f.acr. Si frcontTrca^^., 
 fon topjotjc it to be pjcfentatibe n7ap be from tbc finbfng of t^ Jnrp toboj^" f^a" 
 
 ^ 2 t>at)8 PrcCentatioD.
 
 51 Mich. 2 3 Car. 
 
 ^"^ h!\1)Cfou.ioUfo, anutbctalUngofftotberirapesfiStono piirpofc to alter 
 ition <t, Dy"8i' /5crtftitbcafrc:<!EI)apclUfoprefent3tive, n.rcp.i<o.Cow= 
 
 Caicol'rou'.i. elTit. frcevEtjapc^Lynwood i^p, 150. Grendous(IafC4. rep. 3iiltt(tutfon 
 p{t)es cure of foulcg, 13 H. 4. f. 4. 2El)crc map be a benefice toitl) cute not 
 
 vVjrJt. prc.encative , anofiit bc teUbcurc tftcn it Uiasnot fo; a ftipcrffjtious ufe, 
 q.iD cannot tftcn bc toitbfn tl)c intent of t^c §)tntutc. i. rep. 2 ^ £lnt) fo; tbc ' 
 Ico-.D all,it is not alluam taken gcncrallj'. but rcttrictitoclj'. 2 H. 6. SCo 
 tI)C objection maot to t!)c Uctcict, tljnt it is not found bp toijom it {3 prefcn- 
 
 : ,rui\ ver- tative, 3[anfU}i:r : aCbisJ is afprcial tcrOict, ano it is tljc ctpjefsion of 
 
 •i'*^'' tl)Cl:.y ;:,en> , ano niall bc iatcrpjctcDflccojoing to common acceptation^ 
 
 The riilt of Court war, to argue it againr.be Next Term, becaufe it is a caufe 
 of great cor.fcquencc. 
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 Arr- n of T3 ^'■''" ^"^ jT^cmc b?{ng an ilrtioa of aCrcfpafs of ^ffauU am 3i5aticrp , 
 
 in-fpnncni ill i3 anu Declare of an ailaiilttnij, ano beating of tfjc Jremc, anD Ijaljc a 
 
 3ir.ui;ar,j tcrcict ; t!)c SDcfcnoant moDeg in arrcft of S^iogcmcnt , antifoj caufc 
 
 ''"":'T . fljctos tlMt tbc 315.^ron ano Jl=cmc ouffbt not to iopn in t{)ia Action , tbouglj 
 
 lo^nmR.n a jj^, <3franlt ano iBattcfp Uias DOHCto tl)C i?cmc ptirticuUvlp , but tbat tbe 
 
 JBaroii oitgbt to IjaUc bjougbt tijc 0ction alone, bccaufe tobat cbct oamagcs 
 
 fijoulD bc rcco'jcreo tooulo go to tJjc IBaron onlp , ann citeD p E, 4, f ol, 5 1 ► 
 
 The ludgcment was arreOed till the Plaintiff fliould move, 
 
 Vandicoote. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car, ^anc. Reg. 
 
 A-rcftr-f -f'U^t pafiuiff bjiitgsanactionofSDebtagafnftVandicoote, tljc <3re- 
 D bi'lir.-!,! '"^°5i of l.D.foj tent Due unto him bptbeJCeltatoj in his life time, 
 itfvnfi an Ex- anD h<itt) « tJcrDiit. 2Dhe SDcfcnDant motjco in arrcft of 3iuDgcmcnt , ano 
 1 u or. foj jaafe fljeiua that the Jl)lainttff hao Detlareo that the SDcfcnoant dctinec 
 Dtb i;, t^c et debet lohich ought not to bc, but in the detinct onlp, the Action bctnfl 
 •^cniict aiiJ bjouffht againft him as an (Eicecnto? fo j rent Due in the ^cftatois life , ano 
 "■ citco'smich ano Nichols cafe 7 Car. JBut Wild of Councelltoiththeitaiain- 
 
 tiff faio,it inasgooDcnoiJShirtthc dctinet anDdebet, though it minht habc 
 been ill thC' Dai net oiilp: Hzles on ths contrarp pitt faio it {nng not 
 gooD, fo; it coulD not bc the SDcbt oftbeCrecuto:, t'.jougb bs be to be 
 rliargcD ,anD 'o he cannot bc faio dcbcre , but it is the proper Debt of the 
 SDeftatoj, anD the ©rccutoj map bc faio detinere bccaufe be ought topag 
 it,anDnotbnot.Roli lufticefaiD.tbatitba^bcenaDlitDscD gooD both tea p^s, 
 Evccuois. jj^jj j.^jjj ^ jjjgj c^pccuto;,a cannot inaibc a SCetm tome to them, ano pet' 
 
 thcp cannot bc cbargeDinthc debet ano detinet. 9nD prima facie in tbc 
 tnfc at the bar, the Hction map be bjoiigbt in tbc debet anD dc^inet, Yet put 
 the caufe in the paper , and argue it again. 
 
 Tanner
 
 Mich. 13 Car. 53 
 
 Tanner and Laurence- 
 Mich, 23 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 IT Anner b)fnos an 3tffo« upon tijc dTafc agnfnff Ls wrcnrc, upon m indc:: ^.^(.{^ ^f 
 -* bitatus Affurapfictopapuntoljfm ttoofttlWn20nptcrcfojclJcrpcloat!)'iu.-$icrneiit;n 
 \)t Il)oalD blip fo; tl)C SDcfennant , ano Declares foj fo mnr!) monep one urn »•' ii><)f iiitams 
 to l)tm , ano Ijatb a tetultf 1 t!)c jtDcfcncant mol'cs in arrcft of Juugcment , ^"^"'"^''t. 
 ano (bi:\m foj taufs, i . %l)tit it is not a^crrcD bp ti)C piahUiff , tbnt Ijc Av-rmcnr 
 gatjc anp notice to tbc SDcfcnoant !;oUi marip cloatbs l)e baa bong!)t fo j Wm, koucc. 
 anDfoit i3Hotccrta(nto!)ati3Dt!Ctol)im, SCotbiait toasanflDercD, tbat 
 tlje doatljfl lucre bougin fo j ilje SDcfcnuant Uinifelf , ano I)c map tocrp iticU 
 taUc notice of tl)c number of tbcm , Irttbout anp notice gtten l)im. SI fc« 
 <onD anftptr ita?, tf)at !)erc is a rr qucft fct fojt^ foj t\)t papmcnt of t^e mo= 
 np, ano tbtsimplpes a notice. 31B:it Roll luOice to tWs anftoer rcplpcn , . . 
 that tbc rrqiJCft DotI) nor Implp a notice , ano fo is Twifts dafe , am bcfincs ''^?":«""" 
 tl)E notice otigW not to be bp implication, bat mutt be atcrreo ccrtainlp. Yet 
 let ic be moved again^ 
 
 Midi. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 '-r ^z ^lilatntiff in an Action upon ttje Cafe upon an iRdtbitatus Declares; f\rrc[i of 
 -*- tljat tl)c iDefcnDantinconfioerationofaccrtainnimofmonp, Due to '^"'R'^'"=nt in 
 t^c plaintiff bp tl)c 2D£fenDant , fo j rent bcljinD upon a Icafe foj pears, oio '" •=>'^<j>'f«'is 
 affume, anDp?omifetopaptl]Cfamcnnto^iim at a certain nap, ano ftao'' ""'^'^* 
 notDoneit, anDfojtbisftebjtngsIjiajaction, anobatljatjcrDit, tbc 2Dc= 
 fenDantmotcDinarreftof 3uDgcment, ancfojcaufc ttjevrs tljat tljcre is 
 no confioeration DcclareD to grounfi an Action of tljc Cafe upon,fo j rent is a 
 rcall tl)ing , anD an Action of SDcbt oiigbt to l)aUc been bjotigt)t foj it , ano Coriiacncion 
 not tbis 0ctfon. Roll luflicefaio, tljatljcrcisonlp a confioeration in lain 
 fct fojtl),febicl) is not gooD to toarranttbis action: 31Bnt it map be tftcrcDcb:. 
 tnas fome nclo confiocratton tbnt fpjung from tftc being of tbc rent bcbino 
 tijat Dio groiinb tbis Action, but no futb tbing Dotb appear in tbc sDcclarati- 
 Oli. SCbcrcf03Ctt)e|5laintiff nil capiat per billam , if jaufe be not ftitwn 
 witbini4day£s why he fhould have his ludgtiacci. 
 
 Wood anc3 Salter. 
 
 Mich, 2 3 Car. Banc, Reg. > 
 
 IiP an arrcft of 3tiDsemcnt in au action of SCrefpaffcfoj carrpinc afeapArreftof 
 34 loan of tpmber , 2Clje crception teas, tbat tbe SCpmbcr ig notfaio to luc'scment iii 
 betbelpmbctipfius quercntis, ano fo no caufc of ^tfion. Vpon this Tuipjiie. 
 ludgenieni was arreflcd, 
 
 < • 
 
 ^^ Bennee
 
 54 Mich,2 3^ar. 
 
 Bin net and Bird. 
 
 Michi J3 Car, Banc^ Reg. 
 
 A ft of "D Urnetttic flDmfnffftatoj of i. s. bjtnss an iJctfon upon tfjc Cafe a- 
 
 u,TgM.K.:t in Jj aainftBird , ano Declares agafnttWttiupo" an AffumpfitmaDe bj? tlje 
 
 ,nAa.onup jpcfcjiDaiit to t^c fnteftate,fo} tl)E papniciit of a cettamftimofmonp foja 
 
 ^n ihe Cafe j^atiagc po?tton, at 2 fctcrall Dares of parmciit cqtiallp , ano tijat fo;^ not 
 
 uponapfc- pj,jfpj,„|„gti,cfamcfntbcUfcttmcoftl)ciiitcantc , bebjmgstbfsarttou* 
 
 SCftc piafntiffljat^ a mtiiiA : SCbe SDcfenDant motes in atteft of 31uDge. 
 
 jncnt, ano Ibclus foi caufe , tbatt^cpafnttffDotbnot tocU fct fojtM&e 
 
 granting of tbc letters of aomlmaratton to tiim, fojftcfapcs, tbep toerc 
 
 granteD unto Wm bptljc jarc^^Dcacon of fuc^ a place , ano Dotft not fap loci 
 
 iliiusordinariumnojcuiadminiftratiopertinuit. ilp. JtisfaiD, tftat tl)e- 
 monp toas to be pafo at 2 fctjcrall papmcnts,U)Wcl> amounts to ttoo fcbctal 
 pjomifes , viz. a pjomife to pap tbe firft ten pouno on fnc^j a Dap , 
 anD a pjomife to pap tlje oti)crfum at anotljer Dap to come, ano 
 Dot^ not allege anp parttcuiar requcft maoe bp t^c f ntettate foj tfte firC ten 
 pounD. JBut Bacon luftice oter-ruleD faotb tt)e ejccptf ons , ano faio to t^e 
 
 N tic f^^^'> ^^^^ *^^ '^^ ^^^^ *^^*^ "''^'^'^ "^ ^" ^rt^Deacon being a pubUque £>j. 
 
 oTd'iMry. Df narp , ano tfterefojc ft is not nceofuU to ejpjcffe , tbat tbe letters toerc 
 
 I.ettetsof ad grantCD per Archidiaconum Of fticfj a platC, Ordinarium lilius loci ojcui ad« 
 miniflra.ioiu mininratio pcrtinuit,bHt oHjcrtotfe it toercif t^ep toere granteD toitbin ape- 
 Peculiar. ^yjjg^ jurisDfafon. Therefore he ordered to (hew better matter or elce 
 lud geraent fliould be given for the Plaintiff. 
 
 Ecles and Lambert. 
 
 Mich, 23 Car, BencReg^ 
 
 vidi anteat 
 
 Argument upi 
 on c fpctiall 
 verdift. 
 
 T^t Cafe betlueen Eelei ana Lambert toas again moticD, fobftlj upon a 
 fpecfall tcrDfttfonnD toasfbis; Sir Molton Lambert mafecs a leafeof 
 cettainlanDs toEclcsfoj II pears bpDecD, anD Cotenants foj l)fmfelf, 
 ■ ^is c-):Ecuto?0, aominfffratojs, anD ^afsfgns, that tl)e Icffce Iball pcaccablp, 
 anD qufetip cnjtrp tbe lanDs let, During all the SCerm, the 3leffo? mabcs bfa 
 mif II , anD tbctcbp mahes Lambert tt)c SDefenDant Ijis Cpecuto j, ano Dpes^ 
 ano bp tbe WiiH Ditcrs gooDs in fpecie are DctifeD to fanD?p pcrfons , Lam« 
 berttbe drctntoj Delibersthc gooDsbctjncatheD to the i-cgntecg, Eeles is 
 ontteDoftbelanD6byLS,anDttErcuponbjingsana£tion of Coticnant a- 
 Saiutt Lambert t^ Cjcecnto j , tobo pleaDs fallp abminfftrcD, ST^e qacCf* 
 ontoas,to6ctbertbepapfngof tbcfc legatfes bp the Cjjecutoj toerc a de^ 
 
 De v»ftavir vaftavit , anD fo the e^ecuto J to bc thargcD de bonis propriis to fatfsfie the 
 Covenant bjofeen 0; no, Green of Councfl toftb the pafntfff , argues that 
 It toas a devaRavit nottoftbftanDfngt^at the oetiifetoas of gooDs in fpecicano 
 tljat tbe ©TEcutoj haD onlp DelitiErcD them, bccanfc that the JLcgatecs hao 
 
 piopeitv nopjopettpintbegooDsbeqneathcDfhem,»icfo?ethe€recuto> hao oelfbe- 
 TCD them, no moje than (f thcp hao wMtx been DetifcD , ano citeo i H. e* f.
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. 55 
 
 i^^rano Cooks Lit. III. ano F)C fa(D tijc finDm0oft!)eCojcna!Jtb:o!\CiT 
 1030 noting to tlje parpofcana Ijc fa^o, <t Uaa a Devafiavit, bc<anfc it (IjaU 
 bcfntcntJCD , tbat tJ)cCrccutoj mfstltfenolDoftl)c€oticnant niaocbptljc 
 E;eftatoj, lDl)tcl)bc ttas Uouno alfo to beep, 01 clfcto fatfefic fo; tl)c li?cacJ) 
 ofU, auii tbc tontingcncp toljctljct tftc Covenant looulDbeb;ohciio;no.o^enjn. 
 ntaUcs no Difference in tl)cCafe,fo? <f ft fljoiilD ft IdouId pjoVicmffcIjie^otis fn 
 Dcttriiction of Cot?cnant0, iDbtt!) arc to be accomptcD of as SDcbtcf, Doft. & 
 Scud, lib. 2.C.io.Dyer f.j 24. Hob/. 3 63, 3 97. 315nt ft map be obicctcD, tJiat 
 fftbfsflloulDbea Devaflavit tl)EnBLceacfc6roulonotbcpafo,\ii!<rblro«lD be 
 Dangerous to GrccuJojs, bp reafon of being Ipablc tofutcsfoj tlicm, 21 executors. 
 £.4 f.2 1 .Brook Tit. Procc5,S. lo.SCo ttfs 3 anItDcr, Jtmap be Bangcrous,pet 
 It fs not to tbe ptirpoIe,foj an CBrecuto; fljoulo conOoer of ftjcb Danrers/aiftcn 
 Ije taUcs upon tfm anC£i:«iitojfl)fp,anDtabcnotfccoftl)cnr, atiD tjc fsj not 
 compcUaMc to pap Hegatfes, anotbc 3laititi)lllnotpjctcctbiin,ff Ijc pap 
 tbcrn agafnft linto, Hob. 246. anu ff tljc Court Cfjjififan cnvjcavonr to com- 
 pel him be map fjatje a P;ol)i[)ftfon. glp, 2Cl)c Cpccntoj pcraDlJcnt'ire p.ohibuion. 
 nifgl)ttonccftctl)attl)crclDoiilobe0(rct0 aftettoarDs, anofn tljat confice-- 
 ration cfo pap tfie l.cgacfe0, ano if tlje 5 Rep. Green anuHarifon.' cafe, ano 
 15 lac. Robfon? tafebcobjcctcD, ^snftocr, fbfs Cafe offfcrs ftcmtbcm; 
 foj fterc tfte ©ncCfon is bctteden llegacicc ano JDcbts , ann tljcre betluccn 
 one 2Debt anD another , to iitft . bctlDccn a Debt of a !)fg!)cr nature , anD a 
 SDcbtofalotocc nature. Hales foj tfjc SJefenoant argueo, ti)at ft toasno 
 Devaftavic- i. !^e agras , tbat tl)c ilegatees bate nopjopcrtp in tl)e property, 
 (4D00DS, bp tbe Debifc. alp, Sf tfte Cotienant fjao been bjoUcn ubentftc 
 3LcgacfcsU)erepafo,ftteoiilDl;atic been a Devaftavit. 3IP. ^c bclo, tljat 
 tbc matter fs as hicll fount) iii tftc fpccfal ticrofct, as it mfg!}t !)at3C biien 
 pleaDeo , anD not put at all to t()C 3urp to fino. 2E!)e ©ucfifon ftcrc is, teljc^ 
 t!)cr the aDminfCtration of tljc CDoo^js, bcfo:c tbc Cotjenant bjoUcn, be goon 
 after it is bjoUcn, anD tl-crc is gooD matter bcfojc tl)c Court founD in 
 tlje fpccial tcrDfct, tfjougf) ft mfgljt Ijatie been founD better. JEl)e firft jar« 
 gument 3 infU Djato from tljc nature of tbat, upon tolncl) tbe 0(tfon fs 
 founDes, namclp, tbc Covenant. SLljc iSctfon DepcnDs partlp upon tbe Ditn 
 of Colienant partlp upon tbc bjeacb of it, anD berc is no grouiiD 9f ^aioii 
 at tbe time irljcn tbe aDmfnfftration of tfie (SooDs toas maoc; ano Harifon* 
 cafe cannot be abofoeD : foj a statute is a pjefent oatp, ano ougbt to be Duty. 
 paiofacfojcan£Dbiisatfon.- Robfonscafe i4,& 15 lac. ^nofffsasagra^stir.' 
 able to lair, to papa ILegacp as-aJDcbtuponaCotcnant; anDtbe'niff-°'^''6*''°"- 
 cftfef to tbciLcffec in our cafe fs not fo material, as tbcmifcbfcfmapfacon 
 t!)eG-)cccuto:3 part,jft fanot matcrfaUp obje£tcD,tfjat be mfgbt taljc fccnrftp,securhy 
 foj be cannot compel ft. iFojtbc£Dbjccttontbat oariLatotaUcsnotfccofa 
 3Legacp , 31 anfiner , tbat tbc ILati) taljes notfcc of a Jlcgacp, as to cit?e an 
 intcrctt in it to tbc legatee , alttjougb be map not take ?t itittbout tbc C-rc< fnrcreft 
 cutojs confent. 2lp. 3t taucs notice of it as rcmcDfable bp tbc Jlau) of tbc 
 fcfngDom, tbougb not bp fbe Common4atu : ano tbcrefojc confiocr tbe ^ 
 Statute 21 H.s.of ^Dmfnffiratfons; anDtbeCommonaaiufsKuDgcoftbea^Th",''' 
 Statute, concernfng jaomfnfaratfon, ano nottbc&pfrftuablaiv, Hill. 17 
 lac. Hinron& Buttons Cafe. 2Ebc Common=laUj gftJcsnotarcmeDp foj= 
 a ilegacp, buttbe&pfrftual.Court fsfuppoiteobp tbcCommon-latotoooL^ ^^^ 
 it : anD bp tbe antfcnt Common^aU) tbere toas rcmeop to recover a l.ega> ^ ' ' 
 cp,aRich.3.f. i4.Glanv, lib 6, 7. C.6, 7. anD tbcpolDcr of tbe C-cclcftflaf: 
 tal Court is DerftjcD from tbe Common-latD , auo tbe *£;ommon=lato tofll 
 take notfcc of a compulfarp toap fn tbe CEctleQattfcal- Court to pap allcgacp. 
 ;a[nD tbe papmpnt f n our cafe fs crccutcD , anD noto tbc Lau^ tafecs notfcc of 
 it, bccaufe tbc H)efenDant toas compellable to ft. 3f an CErccutojpjomffcp omifc. 
 to pap a 3lC£acp,an ;9ction upon tbc cafe iof U Ipc againtt bfnt, if be do not
 
 56 Mich. 2 3 Car. 
 
 pap ft. Roll Iii(lice,tftc %t{tato). map Defeat all Cotjcnantsbp ttjfa mcan«; 
 ano Greens tcafon (0 not anfUjctcOjtDhkbis ttic great Doubt fn tljc cafc» 
 3t toao Nefton& Sharp* caff, 38 Eiiz.tbat Icgacfcfloua^t tobcpafDton- 
 Dttfonallp, viz, to bcreftojcD, fftljcdotJcnantfljoulDbcb^oUcn. Wbenyou 
 argue again, argue to this point. Bacon Jufticc tttCD a CafC, 3jEliz» 
 in tbc Crcijcquer, agatnft t^e opinion of Roil, anD faio, iftlicUcsacies 
 fljonlD not be pafD, it migbt be a lofo to tftc Common«tocalt^:fo?itniap 
 be tl)c Coons iifllpcri(I)tDftt»bap<nctl)cin, anDtbcheepingoftbem mag 
 be a cbarcc to tt)e €recatoi, ano no boop fliall ^ate anp benefit of tbem fo^ 
 t^cp map coft mo?c to beep, tijan tbep arc tDOjtb , ano a Devaftavit lieu not 
 
 DevaRavit. sgainft an (EjrccutojofanCErccato?, fo;i tbe Devaftavit of tbc firfl CBmn* 
 toj. Roll luftice, tt)C (lEtclefiaftfcaUlatD ong^t to mahc a pjottiCon againtt 
 
 Prohibition. *^^^^ mifctjieffl, otljcttDtfc 8 p jotjibitfoH lpc0 againft t^mt Appointed to be 
 argued again Tuefday fevennight. 
 
 V Vatfon and VVatfon: 
 
 Mich, 23 Car. Banc. Reg* 
 Hiill.iz Car, rot. 1687, 
 
 Areftof judg- TTTTAtfon bjongbt an 0(tfon of SDcbt opon an £>bll[gat{on agafntt 
 
 menc in Debt V V Watlon, tfte ConOitfOn 1080, tO ftattB tO t^C aiCStD Of tU)0 0rM* 
 upon an Ob- j^gj^jg qj jjf {^g ^U^pjjg^ 2Dl)C ©efenDantpleaDanullara Arbitrium. SCftc 
 
 (h.nd°t"o*° plaintiff replies, t^iattbcBmpfremaoc tljeaaar^. SCije Dcfenoant De- 
 an award, mars, anD Qietos fo^ caafc , tbat tbc i^loarD luas not gooD : fo> it leas in* 
 Award. certain, ano not final on bot^ parts, fo? one partp teas ainarDCD to pap fo 
 mucb monp to t^c ot^er, as in confciencc QjoalD be Dnc, ano no man can fap, 
 tDbat tbat is. 2H)c Court faio, tbeatoatD teas infcnfible. 0nDBjcoa 
 luftice faiD , it toas a taicars 3itoarD. Pulifton of Counccl toitfe t!je plain- 
 tiff titcDt^efeJBoofes to pjotetljcatDatDgooo, 8Ed.4.^ 2.2oEd.4.f. f^ 
 4. iS Ed.4.f. I. Pafc.4 lac. Gofnoli$cafc,6c9H. 7. anD faio , tbefe cafes 
 pjobtD, t^at tDftcrc an intettaintp In an StoarD map be mane certain, tfterc 
 t^e 0U)arD is gooo, ana To it is in our Cafe. ilp. i$t faiD, tbat t^c atoaro 
 here is gmo, nottoltljftanDing it be topapfomucb monp as fljall be Due in 
 ^ (.. Confcience : fo; it (ball be meant as is Due in BLato: fo J 3LaiD ano Confcf* 
 tonic.cn . gn£gajgpnj anD tbe fame. IButRollIufticefaio, t^attfteaioarDDotljnot 
 make a final! Determination sf tbe matters in controbcrfp bettnden t^e par« 
 ties, ano fo it (0 no atoaro. anD Bacon luftice titeo 5 Rep. 2Ebat an Sitbt. 
 trtment ougbt to be certain, anD final, anDt^isatDaiD.toantsbotlttbefe 
 properties; and therefore it not good, 
 
 Fitchct againft Wolfton. 
 
 Micb;2 3Car. 
 
 Demurrer 
 
 o°n Vsti*rc"r.. pltchei taD a 3laDgcment aaalntt I. S. in an action of 2)cbt, I.' S. Dies inte» 
 cias.a^ainft an ^ Sate^ Woifton tabcs oot Hcttcrs of dDminiCtration of t^e <?oods ano 
 Admiaiftta- Cbattels of I. S. f itchet tabes out a Scire facias, toitb a Fieri facias to enquire 
 *°^- . fa.batOooDscfl.S. are in tbc banes of tbC'aDmfnfftratoj.anDfotabetbcm in 
 wi'th aFieti ticccutton opoH ttie 3lwDi5cment, Wolfton, t^eSDefcnoant, appears totbe 
 
 taciat. Scire
 
 Mich. 13 Car. 57 
 
 Scire facias, anDplcai30,ful!p auminfCrco. STfje plaintiff Dcmnrs to tftta || 
 
 ^lea, ano fljciis foj taufc, tl)at in Uic Cafe ti6 fi)ciJlD tiatc plcatj:D non " 
 
 Devaftavit , anD not fuUp acminiftrcD. alp. %i:t plea anftcerB not tfec 
 
 ®Stit. The Court an(v.trcV, aUftrtt) pjctctTfgare onlptomahe tte c!;re« 
 
 cutojg, ojaDmfmttratojstoanflcer, fro tljercfojc fullp aDminiarcD fsFu'iyadmi. 
 
 agooD |Dlea,fojitfsa rccBanfiier, snti it irculfi be cangerons to plcao os"''^'««*' 
 
 tl)cr Iriaicg, "anD Roll Iuft!cefaiD,tl)attti0 being a Scire tacias tcitba Fieri 
 
 facia !;,af tootling to tbenci'jmar.ntr of maUiiig t^c Mrit, it icoulD be can; 
 
 £jCroO0tcplcal3ncn Deva(lavit,ar.t)ittfitli been aOtuUgCD agOOD plea, toNonDeva- 
 
 fap fullp atmfuifirco in R Scire faciss aaair.ft an Crccnto? , but ft te bet =""''• 
 Ut to plcaD nulla bonadevcrcruct ad iranus , luitf) tcWtb te COPlDfatififieNuH, [,on« 
 
 tfe SDcbt fircc tfcc Scire facias ^joog^t. 3Bnt t^fs bcitts a nclD cafe It is fit 
 to be argqec. Therefore let us have Books^ 
 
 Finer and Jeffry. 
 Mich. 23 Car, Banc. Reg.- 
 
 Finer bjfngc an action upon tljc Cafe agafnttjdfry.anD Declares, t&attbCArreft .f 
 2Dcfencant bId affunic ano pjomife nnto ftim, tljat if ^e tDOnlDiudpcmcntin 
 fojbcat to ftic one Ui)o bao atfaultcD i)itn ano beaten Wm, tbat fte*n Aflumpfu. 
 tljc SDefenoant IcoulD pap tljc JJlafntiff as mncb monp as be tnas Dam« 
 nificD tp ttie 0trault ann IBatterp; 2Lf)c plaintiff batb a tjctoitf. SEftc 
 5?Efcncant motjco in arreft of 3uDgement, ano IbelDeD foj caufe, 
 1. SLljat ft cotl) not appear bptbeSDcclaration, tbat tfjc^piainfifffjaoanpccrfiderati- 
 intcnticn to fnc tlje partp fo j t^c fllTauIt ano JBattcrp, ano fo tfje / ffuropfic ''"■ 
 in confiDcratfon, tbat be tooiilti fo?bcar to fuc fo? ft is no conCuetatfon. Up. 
 tec cctb not fct f o?tl), tbat be gave anp notice to tbe SDefenoant, tobat nam- Notice. 
 mages be Ijao fuftafnec bp tljc JPatterp. JBut tbc Court Ijclo, tbat tfje 
 plaintiff natieo not to allege, that be bao an intent to fue tbc partp, foj tbat 
 tbc SDefcnuanttoob notice of, iibentbcAffumFfittras mane : ano fojtbe 
 rcticc tobat csmmcgco tbc plaintiff baDfuflaineD,tbercqacatoperfojm 
 tbc AfTuirpfit implies tbat fofgcicntlp, and fo gave judgement for the 
 Plaintiff. 
 
 Dcrfly and Derfly. • 
 
 Mich, 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 »T" ^jcc arc cnntctccof Confpiracp nnn fo?getp, anDone of tbcm onlpfs Arrefi of 
 -•■ founu guiltp bp tbc 3ititj'. SLbc partp fonno gniltp motico in arrett of iud«racnc 
 jiiogemcnt,anD offcrcD tbcfe Crcepticns. i. SCbc enoictmentis foj a fopnf "po" »n En- 
 fojgcrp, ano fo one onlp cannot be gniltp: but if oncbcacquitteo.allmaft '''^™cntof 
 be acquittcD. 2lp. SCbc enttctmcnt is foi fojgerp, ano caiiCng to fojgc, ^°'5"y- 
 inticb are t\to '"cljcral ano Different acts. J5nt to tbefetbe Court faio nor- 
 thing, ButtmhanotbcrCErccption , namclp, tbat tbc Confpfracpia not Confpirjcy, 
 foimu upon tob'cb tbcCiDiiDictmcntfsgronnDeD, accoioing to tbc Statute, 
 to? 2 arc ncquitteo, ant) fotljcre cannot be a Confpiiacp in tbc tbico pet. 
 fon, nojin anp of tbcm, foj one cannot confpirc alone. 
 
 a Brnet
 
 58 Mich. 2 5 Car. 
 
 Bruer and SowthwelL 
 
 Mich, 23 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Ar. eft of T JfJ tt)is tafc it tons motJCD again in arrcft of 3iioscmcnf , upon tfjc crccpti- 
 iiKiBrmcniin 1 OH fo?nicvlp taUctt, namclj,', tbattljctooiosin tl)c2Dcclarationiiifcoim» 
 an Aftioniiptfng foj fout ^onttjfl tocte tinccttain , auD fo tijcte ic no confiocrattonfoj 
 on anAflmii;- ^jj^, /^^fTumpfir, ano tftrn it i0 but nudum paduuj. Roll luftice faiD, tl)C SDc» 
 Niuiumi'i- claration iu infufficicnt fo; tljc inccrtaintp : foj it cannot be fenoton tobat 
 ftum. f0 nicant br tbc toojo discounting, pet \)e faio, tbat tbougl) part of tl)c Con- 
 
 c.nfidcra- fiDcratlou, upoH lubtcl) tl)c Adumpfu io grouuDcD , bcagainft Jlato; pet if 
 "°"- tl)c otbcr part be gooo, ano it ma)> be Dibioeo, tl?c AfTumpfit ia gooD notlDith« 
 
 CanDing. Yec we ivill liearCounccI on both parts, before the Plaintiff ihall 
 
 haveludgement, Antea, 27 
 
 Golibn and Bedlce. 
 
 Mich, 2 3 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 Entred Mich, 22 Car, ror, 434^ 
 
 Arreft oi'iuJe- /^Oftbn bjougbt flu Mion upon the Cafe upon an Anumpfit againff Bed* 
 
 C 
 
 mcnt.nan t- -^^loc, HnD ficclarcs , that iu confiDcrRtton of fo iHucb monp0, pais bp tbc 
 ftion upon laiaintifftothc SDefcnnant, the iDcfcnDantDiDaffumcanopjontifetoDe. 
 
 ''"'a'.t''^ r''" ' ^^^^^ ^'^ '"^"l' ^^^^^ °f ^''"' ""^^ ''^'" ^* ^"^'' ^ P^^^^> ^"^ ^"^ ""^^ pecfojmins 
 anA.iuniu. |,(g pjoniffe i,e bjjuKg {,(5 c^rtion. SDhc |Dla(ntiff hath 3 ClerQict; SChc 2Dc- 
 
 fcnoant motocD in arrcft of 3Itiogement upon-thefe Cvccptione. i . SChe Be-- 
 
 , jjr.iftio„ claration Doth not fct fojth, that the place irherc the pjomffc toaa maoe Uias 
 
 '" '°"' toithin the JurisDiction of the Court, fehtch ought to hate been, faecaufc ft is 
 
 the grouno of the ^action. Co this Roll JuJliccanfiDcreo, that it Dot&not 
 
 appear, that it is out of thc^urifcictionofthcCourt, anti it ftall not be in- 
 
 tcnoeD to be fo, if it be not allegcD bi' the other partp. SI fcconi) reception 
 
 Re q"cft *"■ *03s, that there is not a fpccial IRcqucft fet fo;th fo; the S?cfenDant tocar- 
 
 tpanolap the ^ap in the place allegcD. glp. 2Ehe plcaoing ic out of Court, 
 
 . fo; ttiant o^ n continuance to the Court, fo; the continuance is not to 
 
 T),uontmu- jjjp Court, biit to fuch fl Dap onlp. 4lp, SChe tElnrDictisinfojmal, ano 
 
 Vcr'i.ft. flielMs no caufeUihpDammages are gilbert. Roll luftice to the firftercepti- 
 
 on faio , that tl)c partp ought to hat»e taUcn aobantage in pleaoing, that the 
 
 ricading. caufe of Action Xnaa out of'thc ^utifoiction of the Court,anD not to mote fuch 
 
 matter in arrctt of JuDgemcnt, fo; it is improper. JBut the Court ru- 
 
 IcD the |)laintiflf to fljelu caufe tohp ^uogement ftjoulD not be arretteo upon 
 
 the thtrO exception,'; Afterward the fame Term judf^ement was given, nil capiu 
 
 per billam,againftthc Plaintiff tor the difcontinuance in the Procefs. 
 
 Tentch
 
 Mich. 23 Car. 55 
 
 Tentch and Cletheroe, 
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car, Bare. Reg* 
 
 Pafc. a* Car, rot. 33 2» 
 
 TEntch bjfngaan Srtton of Coticnant agafnff Cletfieroe,iDccIatC!3,t!)ai Error tore- 
 t%t BDcfcnuant Ijao cotenantco iiftij fjfm to pap fuel) a fnm of monp into ■'=■'' » W<if,c- 
 tbe €rtl)cqiicr at fuc^ atfme, ano fojnotpcrfojmfng tl)fs Coticnant !)c"'^"[^J,"J" 
 bjfngs bifl actlon.SEftc pafntiff tiat!) a tacrDfct,f| a Sungmcnt. Cbc 2)efcn= vcnam" "* 
 oant'bjings Ws Mtit of Crroj, f afcigns foj crroj, tftattftc piatntif IjtiD not 
 fct fojtbfn to^atCountp tftc €j:tl)equct(0,anDc<tC0Hubs l)«i5tafc,Pa"c.« Car. Coun.y. 
 ano a caCc 22 Car.CBanc.SCIjat tlje Countp ie material to be alleacD,bp rca- 
 fonoft^e viHcuue, I E. 4. g.CoGksiflftitut. aio. 21 H, d.f,4. SEfteCoatt 
 ^)clD tljat tlj0 Countp toftere t|)C CjrcbcqpEt teas out:l)t,tobBallcgcD,bc=E«i>'S"e''' 
 catife tbc Crtljcqiict fa tranfitojp, annnotfirt to one place, ano fo ll)cte 
 can be noClenuc.bccaufc It appears not in Icljat Cocintp U 10. And for thij '""'^^ 
 caufe the ludgment was reveried» 
 
 lawyer and RulTell. 
 
 Mich, 23 Car, Banc.Reg, 
 
 i;«iy a v»<^iuiu< ;oi^m. si^civuuaiiv iiiuutuui uiitu ui ^laog^nicnt lOJ ttjCfC i, r" 
 
 rcafona. i , &uc!)belDftcbfng 80 is mentfoncD fn tljc IDedaratfon 10 not pu- word. 
 
 tiilljable bp tbc Statute of 1 lac, foj ft cornea not toftttn anp of tbe vviuh-crafr. 
 
 bjanttjes of tftat statute , nrftljer tbat tobfcb fpeate of ocatb bp ^ffclj« 
 
 craft, no? of tbe otfter b?ancl) ; foj ft is not a^jcrrctj, tijat tbe Coin trac btirt - 
 
 oj ocflropcD bp tbc bcVuftcbfng, auDrotbcpartpianotpumftablc. Bno ft 
 
 lljaU not be fntcnocD to be fo,fo; tbc partp ftall not be punffljcti fan an 'ntcn'-'ment. 
 
 encfctmcnt bp an fntcntfon , ncftfjer ajall be be berc fn tbfa Cafe. Slni3 -In 
 
 iro;Ds ambfguou0 of tbf0 nature, fljau be talienfn mitiori fenfu. Roll lui'ljce 
 
 fafD,tl)attbcfelDO?D0, Thou hafl bewitched my Mothers Milk and Drink fjatJC vv i 
 
 ban abjnDgeD actfonable, ano bercigafcanoaloftbepartp ofMjomtbc " A 
 
 lDO?D0 are fpofecn; ano tbe too? 00 thou haO bejvirchcd implfcs burt ucne to » * 
 
 tbc tbfng bctoitcbcD; ano tbis cafe cfffcrc from an cUbfctment : foj an C'lt' 
 
 Dfctmcnt muC be mojc certain , tijnn tl)cfc toojos ncco to be. i3nt> a tfo. 
 
 lent fntencment aa tcre f0,map b?fng one irftbfn tbc compafa of an ^ctfon. 
 
 Therefore lee thePlaintiff have his ludgemenr, if better matter be not flicwn 
 
 Monday cext. 
 
 Ncvill and Moct. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 ^1FvilIbJougbt an fldton upon the Cafe agnfnflMotr, ano acclarcD.tbaf Arcttcfiu-'g 
 S the SDcfcnoant being fn companp toftb btin Icitb a Coiiflablc, Dfo fpcak "'<^"^ '" ="■ «■ 
 tijua of tbc ipiafntitf to tbc Conftablc, There he is, takchiro,forIcharce ^'7- 7'" 
 
 •a , h ilicCaic for 
 
 wards.
 
 5o Mich.^sCar. 
 
 hi^ with flat felony, "hiiD after fpoUe tftcfe U)o?D3 ofljdnalfo, Mr. Ncvill 
 hatli tnkcn my Sheep with a felonious intent. %])C |)latntfff \)at\) a ticrtlfct; 
 Eljcl^'-'fctiuantmotieotiiatrca of Ktioncmcnt, tljattlje Ibojds arc not attU 
 enable, ano cUjd Poland ano Mafons cafe, Hob, Rep- ant) aOrgco tljcfc rcc- 
 fonoaifo. i. 3ScfaiifctbclD0jDfj lucre fpohen to aConflablcfnpjofcctu 
 tfon of BCnftfcc, Itlifcl) fljall not be taUcn bolo of bp a p;tliatc perron as a par- 
 ticular fnjurp mcar.t to 5)tm. alp. Jt la not fato tt)c VcojDo iccrc fpohen faU 
 Avcrmcnr. j^j & (tiaiitiofe, ac ft otigl)t to Ijatc bccM, 315iit to tl)c fccont) Crccptfon, Roll 
 lufticc fato, 3t '0 not ncccffarptofaPjtljcpttiercfpohcnfaiio&malitiofr, 
 luljcrc tbcp appear to be fcaiioaloua, fo : tbcrc tbc action Itco Vi ctl, tljoiigb ft 
 be not fo crp?cffcD , ano if one charge auotljcr Iwftl) fttfpitton of jf clonp.ano 
 fpcah fuel) \iiojC3 of l)fm, fftl>cpappcarto be malfcfonOpfpol'.cn, an action 
 tcrptoeil lieo. The ruie was for ilicPlamtiffco take his ludgemenc, if bet* 
 ter caufc be not fliewcd to the contrary. 
 
 The King and Hide. 
 
 Mich, 23 Car- Banc, Reg, 
 
 r* sn ■ bUT I*^^ »noi3f d foj tlje qtiaOjintt of an CSnDfctmcut tafecn before Commf ffli* 
 an Ed"amcm JtJ oners of &>c\i}Crc, tobcrcfn l)c teas cnofctEQ fo> a niifancc nuice fn 
 b f.nc Com- tl)c l)iel) \T3ap bprcafon of penning of tuatcr in t\)c Kiijcr, at his jpfu, Uil)cr= 
 niiisioncis of jjp tl)c toatct olier=floiDi!ig t^JIBanhiJDfo annop tlje toap. antJ l)"e took tl)is 
 S:wcrs. crtcption to f.jc CnDiotmcnt , that ft Dfo not fap it toas a natijtablc Hibcr. 
 
 315nttot}}isRoll lurticeanflMcrct), it irao not netctTarp to Tap it Iras nafef' 
 Sewers. gflblc : fo? if it be a common palTagc foj ivatcr it its fufficicnt, ano lice lott&- 
 
 fnthctontifaiJcco;tl)cCoinmf'sioncro.315utRoiliufticetooh another crcepti* 
 
 on to the Cncfctmcnt; 2Ehat ft fcto fo?tl) thiu oticrflotofng of the toter to bs 
 
 i^T^.r amifancc tothchf5hluap,anDfojthis3thcpartplijcnDfctcD,U)hcrcas Com^ 
 
 '^' miroioncrfi of Telstra ha^c no potocr to mcDDlc tufthfuchntifances in the 
 
 lDap,butonlptoithpaffagC0bp Mater. And for this caufe the Endidraenc 
 
 wasquifhed. 
 
 Monger and 5'hacerton. 
 ^ M ch, 23 Car, Bine. Reg, 
 Trin. 2] Car. rot, 5^9, 
 
 A tSIrit of Grro; li-as bjouaht in tljfs Conrt to rctjcrfe a 3:.oDgcmeHt g(- 
 Vudoc- j(L\l3cn in the llBiirroto'.<rotirt of Southwark. anDtljeCrrojafsfgncotoas, 
 ir.crufivcir:., that itx th2 Venire ficias one Of the 2nrp iscaUcO Richardon, anD in the 
 t'lc luu.ow- Habeas Corpora hc io callcQ Richirdfon, Uih.'fh are ttoo feticral names, ano 
 ^u"'iVi\ f° '* (s infcrtaintehat the proper name fs. STo thisthecnounccl ontfte 
 ■ "*"'•'' ^' ■ • other fi3c fato , that thin f.uilt io hcipc?> bp t'gc Statute, ft bciiin after a acr- 
 Vcidft. tict. 315iJt B?con fuftitc faio, h^ Doubtcii iDhcihcr it coulD be hi^lpeo iioio fu 
 this »I^otirt, though it misht hate been helper in the fnfcrioj Court, Inhere 
 tg; action 1353 bjou^tit bp CFamination of it, ano therefore rulco to Iljciij 
 
 taiite 
 
 Emo- to rf-
 
 Mich. 25 Car. 61 
 
 caufetofjpHuDgementfljall not be tctterfcD on Friday nert. It was this 
 Term rcverfed at the Defendants motion for his own expedition. 
 
 Biooke and Brook. 
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Trin, 23 Car. rot. 580* 
 
 BRooke bjincs an SLaion of Debt upon an iDWfgatfon aca<nft o<^*^'»7" "> 
 Brook, tbc comritfon toas , tljat ttje £>bltsoj fljoulo ntaUc an C-ttate',fj"^'_" q^[ 
 «f inftctitaiicc to tbe £)bU0cc fn fncft lanes «t ftitb a nap, anUhgat.on. 
 plate , ano foj not Dofng it, l)c bjings itis attfon. 2H)c Dcfcnoant pleaos 
 tl)atbetDasTcaDi>att()eoap,anDplace,tomaHc tl)c plaintiff an cffatc of 
 inljctttanccinttjcIantJS; SEftcpafntiffBcmutstotljcpIca, anfifojcaufe 
 fijctoo tfjattftcDefenoantDotl) not Qjetotljat be gate notice to tl)C |Dlain' ^o^*«' 
 tiff of l)is being tbcvc. 2Co tbis Roil luftice fafo , it is not ncceffarp to gibe - 
 notice of tbc Dap oj place, jafcconoerccptionlractbat be hao not flietocD ^.^^ 
 tbat be gate tbe plaintiff notice tobat eltate of inheritance be tooulo make mtcsl 
 ^m. 2Eo tbtij Roll luftice fato ,be ought to bate fi}cii)n,tbat be gate notice 
 lubat cftate be taculD mafee bini , ano tbetcfojc let tbe Defendant ihcw 
 cauie why tbe Piain:iiFihould not have ludgcmenc. 
 
 Kale and locelync^ 
 Mich, 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 Trin, 23 Car. rot, 1282, 
 
 KAlebjingsanadionofSJebtacainttlocelynean Crccafoj, ant) De- 
 clares foj tent groiun mic fince tbe Death of the 2:cftatoj, bp tirtitc of ?pi^'i"t'"an° 
 a Icafc fo J peats mace of certain lants bp the plaintiff unto the SLcttato j Exccuto^r In 
 iDbicb pet continues , ano Declares, that tbe Crecntoj debet & detinet, &c. Debt tor icnc 
 2Cbe£DefenDantplcaD3fullpaDm(tiiftrcO, tbe plaintiff Demurs upon tbe^^ °"e''f =- 
 plea; J?0} pleaoing in the debet ano the detinet: Bacon luftice faiOjitf^y'^ ^''"'• 
 teas gooD , ano fo bao been aDjuDgco. Co tobtcb Roll luftice anfujcreo it kxtcmor, 
 bao been aDjuDgeo pro & con, to be cood ano to be bao , ano he faio, that an vvaivcr.' 
 Crecutoj cannot toaitc a SCetm let to the sCcftatoj, fo? be is botmo bp Co. Cuvciianc 
 tenant f holD it , ano faio that the SDcclaration toas gooD in tbe debet ano 
 detinet prima facie ; foj it iftall be intenDCD that the lanD let to the SCclfa. 
 to J is iBojth^s much bp the peat , as the rent that is paio fo j ir,till the con^ 
 trarp be (bcfen , ano then it is rcafon that the Crecnto; be chargcD ; Bacon 
 lufticefaiD, that the Crecutoj map toaitc the poffefsion, if l)CfinD that the 
 rentismojcthantbelanDislDOjtb, otberinifc it map be mifchictotis to 
 bim. Roll luflice faio, that the SDrclaratton nuift be in the detinet ano de- 
 betjOtbcrtoife it toill be mifchictous to the plaintiff, ano faio, that a fpcci= 
 altp (ball be fatisfieo facfo?c a rent rcfcrteo upon a leafe bp oecD . tcbicb Ba. 
 conDenicD, ano it teas faio, that a leafe foj pears fljnirbc affctg in the a^«''- 
 Ijanos of anCrccutoj, although the rent rcfertco be the full taluc of the 
 Hants let bp the leafe. The Defendant was ordered to flievr caufe why 
 ludgement fhould not be given againfl hinit 
 
 31 3 Baker
 
 6i Mich. 2 3 Car. 
 
 Baker againft Edmonds. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car, B, Reg» 
 Hill, taCar.ror, 12?, 
 
 spfciii vcr- |5 Aker bjJtigs an SifXion upon tl^c vEafc agafnff Edmonds , ano Declares, 
 didinjnAft. D tljat toljcrcaa I. S.Ujats IjiDcbtED unto tbcpiafntffffn a certain Uim o£ 
 c Ac" wTctiici '"""P ' ""^ aftertoaros bcfng fo (nocbtco became a SBancUrapt , ano tljat a 
 a vcrd;a Comtfflfon upon tftc fetatatc of JBanUrupt toas taken out bp W m, anu otljct 
 wainrainMhc crcDito^s agafiitt fefm , ann tbat <t Uiao fouiiD ti)at tbe HDcfcntiant leas In* 
 iiiiic ; )nca. m^btcD to tbc 3I5anclirupt,tbc Commtfeloncrs Of tftc fato CommUafon D(i> 
 afsfgn oticr tlje HDcbt of tbcSDefcnoant mcnt(oncD in a certain fcbcmile, a-- 
 mounting to fuel) a fum,iinto tl)c pnlr.tiff.in part of fatlafaaion of tljc 2Dcbt 
 otoing unto lilni bj? tl)c 315nncl;rupt, biP tjirtuc Inbcrcof l)c DcnianDs tl}e fafj 
 JDebtoftl)cSDefencant,tDl)oD{Dairumc, spjomffeto pap t^: fame.ano fo> 
 not perfo jmlng 1)13 pjomifc,f)ebjfngfl Ijio ^rtlon, tbs SDcfenDant plcaos 
 nonAfTumpfit, ano tljercuponaniffuc l«as jopncD , ano a fpccfaU teroict 
 toao founo to ti)c effect, as tl)C plaintiff ban tcclarcu, but tbep futtbcr fint» 
 tbat tlje 2Debts mentfoneo in tlie fdjcDule , auD afalgneo oijcc to tijc plain* 
 tiff ainounteti to fuel) a fum, toljcreas tljep fino that tbe SDcfenoant oiD not 
 • oUje unto tl): iiSanckrupt fo muclj as tbat 2Dcbt afaigneo ia, but a letlc funt. 
 y ^,0 auD upon tl)i5\)crQ(cttl)cquertion teas, irftetber tbe tjcroict oio maintain 
 jHUe ■ tl)ciffue, lrl)tcl) iraa non AlTumpfir.ifit oId , tften tljep ftno (07, tUe SDefcn* 
 Aiiignnienr. Dant.tf not, tl)cn fo: tl)c plaintiff. Bin tbc breaking of tbc Cafe it toao mo= 
 ijeD itDetbcr tbc flfsii^srmcnt tocrc gooD o: no, in rcgaro tbat tbc Commif-- 
 fioncrs ban miftafeen tbc SDcbt , fo j tbc SDcbt afaigneo bp tbcm iuao grca» 
 tct tban tbc iDcbt founo bp tbc 3iurp, ano fo mtgbt be anotbcr SDcbt, iBitt 
 totbis Roll luflice faio,ti)at tlje afstgnmcntiDasnot uioiciallp bcfoje tbcm 
 in qucQion, fo:ifitii)crc,it\BOulD be iuogcDanilUfi3ignmcnt,butbcrcit 
 comcfl not in ifuie but onlp tobctbcr tbc Defendant oio affumc, a«D pjomifc 
 oj no , ant) tbc fpcciall tocroid conclnoco not upon tbc afsignmcnt, but inbe- 
 tbcr tbc fpcciall matter founo uo maintain tbc iffuc oj no, « tbcrfo jc be toag 
 of opinion tbat tbc plaintiff ougbt to babe bis 3I«Dgment. Bacon ludice niU 
 fcrcoin opinion,^ falo.tbat it is Dangerous foj Commifsioners of315anUrupt, 
 CmiiTi:(iio. to a'"s(gn 2)cbts particularlp.3Ebc rule tb?n leas to argue it tbc ncj;t 2Ccrm: 
 ncis, at lubtcb time Ward Of Counccl fo J tbc 2DefenDant argucD, tbat tbc feccQict 
 
 Inas fo J tbcSDcfcnDant fo; tlits rcafoii,viz.l6ccaufc tbe SDcbt lalD t.i tbc ilDc- 
 ciarat(on,anD tbc SDebt fount bp tbc tjaoict arc not tbc fame, ana fo tbc SDc- 
 fenDant did not affume,anDpjomife tbat Inbicb is laio In tbc l!>eclaration , 
 fo: tbcrc is no fuel; SDcbt founo, ann if be fljoulo be dmrgco teitb tbat , be 
 Averment, mtgbt be Doublp cbargcD, foj be map lie again cbargeo fo^ tbc Debt founo bp 
 tbc ttrDict , ano circumttanccs of quantitp, time ana place are aljcrrci) in a 
 K>cclatat{on to mnUctljings certain, ano if tbcp fail tbc SDeclaration ta 
 not gooo , j 8 E. ?. lol. 25. i. rep, 74, Palmers Cafe. alp. lEbc SJcclara^ 
 tion'ictnfufficient, fo;itci:p:cffctbnotiDbat tbe fum is, but faitb, a fum 
 mentioncD in a fcbeoulc of SDcbtB,tobfcb is inccrtain: Roll luftice intet- 
 ruptcD Ward, ano fai?, an tbat pou bate argticn is oat of Do;es, but tbe latt 
 matter toucbfng tbc SDeclaration, anD to tbat Hales of Councell iritb tb? 
 plaintiff faio, tbc SDcclarctiou is gooo anD certain cnougb, foi tb:rc ap* 
 years no otbcr (urn fu tbc fcbcDulc tban is mcntfoncD in tbe jEDcdaratlou. 
 
 BacoQ
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. 63 
 
 B»con Tuftice.2C!)eafsfsntnent i& cf tljc Dcfat of tljfs man Due to tljeBanktuft, 
 ucitmo^e oj be it IcIIe,anDftatl) no reference to tbc accompt, ano recho- 
 nfng bettDcen t!)Bm, ?fo tfte arsfgnraentlBgootutljougbitagrcenot (ntfte 
 fum Mttf tDbat is iuftlp Diie,anD tljc tffue is upon toe A(rurppfit,ano not upon m,e. 
 tl)c jafefgnnient, foj tfte 0rs(gnmcnt ts aomtttco bp tbc SDefenoant, ano fo Adniittjnce: 
 not matcjtal tohctftcr ft be an ^fsfgnmcnt of tlje true fum oj not. Judge* 
 men: was given for the Plaintiff. 
 
 Bruerand Sowihwell. 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. Banc, Reg» 
 
 TI5C piamtfff hi this (Tafcmoticii again foj luogcmcnt , ncttoittttan' ArrcO oj 
 cingtoJjatbaDlcenfojmerlpfpoUcntoarrtftit, fojtljoutTlj tte ^^"'^^ ],"'Sn V^ 
 dircomputandointbclDe£larationbetnfcnfible,pcttl)cri3enoun^tnt!KSD^*'n^i,e'c"ic''' 
 dagition togrounu tbe jattion, anu tljat to tt)e bjcatlj of tlje AfTumpfic afsig= upon an Af- 
 nap:o Bciitcr tlje Currants bouofjt of tbc SDefcncant , ano tfje tuojD Dfr.fu'Hf''^ 
 counting (ball not fturt ft. Bacon luniceiras of tfte fame opftnon. ilBut 
 RoU luftice fafo, all tbe fcargafn is bcvc fet fo?tl) upon trf)fci) tbe Affumpfit AiFu.r.pfir. 
 toas maue , ano if tbe bargain be ill, tbe Afluropfit is not gooo. Hales Coiurztt. 
 of Counccll tnftb tbe piafntfff faio, if part of tbe bargain be in. 
 fcnfible , ano part not, pet a goon Aflumpfit map be grcuncco «p= 
 on tbat part tobfcb is 200D, 315at Roll faio tbe bargain bere is intirc , ano 
 ifpartofitbenot gooDitisallnaugbt: pet bi" faiQ if part of a bargain be 
 gooD, ano part tjoto, pet an ^rtion map be b jougbt upon it. The tule wzs) 
 That ic (houid be argued again on both parts. 
 
 Seaman againft Edwards. • 
 
 Mich. 25 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Trin, a 3 Car, rot. 9 20. 
 
 SEainanb?ing0 an action agafnfi Edwards, ano Declares againft bim as '^'"■"'■7"^" 
 (II;);ccuto J of I. S. ( iDbereas tbe trutb toas, tbat I. S. maoc ^, otbcrs Cv- 'J by an e^- 
 Ecutojs, ano not tbe SDefenoant. ) 2Cb'* SDcfcnoant pleats tbat be is notccutor. 
 tbe fame pcrfon namcD in tbe 'mm. %o tbis plea tbe plaintiff Demurs , I'lca. 
 ano foj caufcfljciDStbat be map be an Crecuto; de ion tort demcrne,tboMgb ^-''""""■• 
 be be not nameo in tbe Will , ano fo map be cbargeablc , ano tbercfoje be 
 ougbttobatiepleaocDneunques^DminittreocomeCrccutoa, ano of tbis 
 opinion toas tbe Court, ano ojocrco tbe i3cfenoant to Ibcto caufc \3iifp 
 31uogemcnt tboulo not be gibcnagatna bim. Judgement was given for the 
 Plaintiff. 
 
 • 
 
 Dod againfi: Eaton. 
 
 Mich, 33 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 DOd bjings an 0ction upon tbe Cafe actainft Eaton fo j fpcaliing tbcfe Px-cp"o^ '<> 
 toojDs of bim, thou haft the French Pox, m JSDifcnDant plcaDs not ' ^^'"' ''"" 
 
 suiltp
 
 ^4 Mich. 2 5 Car. 
 
 aalltp, tbe $atv upon tWs tffac finfi a fpccinll l^cruld , viz .2Cl)at tftc iBDefcn. 
 Oaut l;ati fnfO, thou haft had the French Pox, toiicrcupon tbc SDcfettOantiS 
 CoiintcU fafo, tljnt tljc CI rrcirt uotli not mafntnfn tbc too job laio in tl)c H)c» 
 claration , an'o tbat tbc tc'ojco tt)at arc fotinc hi tbc tictolo arc not aaiona- 
 blc, anDfotbcpafntifftanbatcnoSHDacmcnt, antJCftcoi^ Jac Nut- 
 
 ^^^'''^ combes Cafe, anD tbc tDOjBBfounDarcnotiffuaWe, ano fo tbc terew ia 
 fmpcrfC£t,^o A(T. 4i.Kelway '6.i8 Ed. j.tol. ip.Pafc. sjEli/iBanc. Reg. 
 Dame Ratdiffs Cafe. Dyer &t, lohn Burj^es CafC pjotc tbat tbc tcrDfa ia 
 toofbojt. RollIufticefa{D,lftbctcrcJctbcimpcrfctt,tbcrcmapbc a ncto 
 
 Vcnite dc no- venire facias , anD fo ft <0 agatnC tbc piafntiff , foj be caunot babe Jaoge. 
 
 '"• mcnt. PaDellofCotmccU toitb the plaintiff citcD Osborn, anD Brooks 
 
 Veidia Cafe tbat tbc berufrttoaafoj tbc plaintiff. 315nt Roll luflice falD, tbat 
 
 tbe 3tirp cannot finn a tbing tbat is not toitbin tbc SDctlaration to main-- 
 taiHtbeSDeclaratlon.fo; tbcpotisbtto bolD tbcmfeltcB to tbc iffue, anD 
 tbat tbepbabcnot bete cone , anu tbctcfojc tbc Dcrbltt ia imperfect, ano 
 tbcre mail be a ncto venire facias to trp tbc tffiic again, fo j Sui'Scnicnt can= 
 notbc gitcnupontblc^crclct,foj tbcp do not finDtbat be fpakc not tbc 
 toojDB in tbc S)cclaTation tobicb arc tbc molt material, fo tbat tbc matter is 
 not founo fnllp cnong^ foj uBtopjocecDtoSuts^wcntonc teap ej o||;r. 
 Adjourned. 
 
 Poole againfl: Coply* 
 
 Micb>23tCa. Banc.Reg^ 
 
 Arrcft of D Oole b?f ngs 80 0ctton of Ctcfpaffe againtt Coply , ana batb a bctWtf 
 ludPcmentinX agalnft tbc SDcfcHDant. gttoasmobcD in arrett of faogemcnt tbat 
 Ticfpafic. tbc S)eclatation is incettain, fo; tbc plaintiff DctlarcB tbat tbc SDefcnoant 
 cepitetalportavit decern coria,anglice hides, anD tbc too jO Coria isnnCEt- 
 tain , fo J it map be coria equomra, OJ coria ovium, o; Of anp Otbct Cattcl» 
 %o tbfflRoll luftice faiD , tbat it is tocllenongb, fo? tbc Anglice bao maoe 
 tbc toojD certain, anD it is tbc nfaal manet to pleac it tbas. The Court 
 ordered the Plaintiff fhould have his ludgeroent, if better matter were not 
 Ihewn to the contrary, 
 
 Hull againft Gurnet, 
 Micbt 2 J Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Demurrer up- yj yn jj, j^gg g„ 0(t((,n j,f fgif- fmpjifoumcnt agflintt Gurnet , tbc SDc= 
 
 Xainfairc JljL fcHDant plcaos 3 fpcciall juttification, tbat be tools, ano tmpjifoncD 
 
 inipn'onmem. tbc plaintiff bpbittiic of a CommifsiongrantcD out of tbc Court of tbc 
 
 5lDmiraltp. to EFaminc tbc taking atoap of ^rtain gooDs tibicb tocrc lr.;ac; 
 
 c ft-m fees bp tbc &ca. %o tbis plea tbc piai.ntiff DcmurrcD, anD IbeiccD foj. 
 
 -■'■ ■ caufc; aCbattbcSDcfenDantbatbnotfetfojtbtbcCuffomoftbc aamirall 
 
 Court, tbat tbc firftpjocrCTctbcreof is a Capias, anD fo it appears not, tobc= 
 
 A.iwrahy. tbct bcbatjc pjocccDCD right oj no. alp. 3itDotb not appear tbat tbc mat; 
 
 tcr foj tobicb tbc Commifsion tons grantcD is jparitime , anD otbct matter 
 
 tbcpongbtnottomcDlc toitball. The Rule of Court Wcis to flicw caufe 
 
 why ludgement (hould not be given againft the Defendant upon this plea. 
 
 Smith 
 
 .■^nrllie..
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. 6^ 
 
 Smith again ft Stone. 
 
 Micb. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 SMithb;on5fttatl3[(tfonof2ntCfpaff0agaf.ntt Scone pedibus ambulando, • ,• n^ 
 tbc Defenoant plcans t^ts fpeclall pica In juttlficattoit, viz. Wint tjc toag ,] "'* i},"";!i-l 
 carr peu upon tl)c lanu of tfjc piafntf ff bp fojce , ann tfolencc of ottjero, ano pj,rj pe<jibu$ 
 lDagnottl)cret)oluntarflp,lri^fcbf3 tftcfamcttcfpatrc.fojlr^tcbt^c^latiitif^mbubndo. 
 b jingo 1)13 0£tfon. SCbc piafnt<ff Demurs to t^is plea ; 3in ttis cafe Roll Tieipifc. 
 lofticefafD, tbatUfstbcSCrcfpaffc oft^c pattp tliat catr^'co t^ie SDcfcn-- 
 oant upon tbc lano , ano not tlje Crefpaffe of t!)C SDefcnoant ; as be tftat 
 Djlties mp Cattcl Into another mans lanu ia tJ&eSutefpaffoj agatnU l)tnT,ano 
 not Bi tolio am otQner of tt)e CattclU 
 
 Mathew.againft Herle. 
 
 Mich, 23 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Trim 23 Car, rot, 15 5 4» 
 
 M 
 
 AthewbjougW an aufonoftrefpaircagalnff Herle foj bjcaWng l)f3?nica ".rcf. 
 
 i?ence , anD enttfng tnto ^(0 Clofe, &c. 2Dl)e 2)efcnoant plcaos t^at p^fs quare 
 I, i, toas fetfcD of tlifs lano, iulbctein tb; aCtcfpaire ta fuppofco to be Done , fn chufam {regit 
 fee , ano fo feifeu oto Dcmffe tlje fame foj pears bp Deeo to tbc piafnttff 
 rcfprbing tent , intotjidjoceDlDasaclanfcofrcentrpfoj nonpapmcnt of 
 tbercnt, ano aftcrluarDs mane bfs laft tSHIUin Injttmg, ano opetj ; bp 
 toWcfttDtUftcgatetbcfafblanoin qaa,&c.tot!)eE>cfenDant, anotftat afj 
 let tl)e rent teas bcbtno , ano tfjat 6^ f 0; tbe non papmcnt of tlje rent acco;» 
 Ding to tbe Covenant in tbe Dceo , bp birtuc of tbc claufc of rccntrp oto en- 
 ter into tfjc lanos, inbicb is tbe fame b; cafeing of tbc jFcnce , ano entrp fo j 
 tolitcl} tbe plaintiff bjings bis jetton , anD Demanos ^uogcmcnt if tbe 
 |i)laintiff ousbt to batjc bis 0aton. SCo Jb<s pea tbe |)latnttff Demurs, ano 
 flietDSfojcaufe: SCbatitBotbnotfljctotbattbelearemaoe to tbe |0lain- 
 tiff is a Icafe of tbe lanD, in tobicb tbe SErcfpaffc is fuppofcD to be Done. alp. 
 2Cbc SDcfcnDant Dotb not (bcto tbat be DiD enter into tbc lano bp icatc of tbc Licence. 
 <iBi;ecuto}, tobicbbeounftttobaDeoone ; fojtbougbtbe lano tuas oetJifeo 
 to bfm bp tolU , pet be cannot enter into tbc lano toitbont leatic of tbc Cre- ^""x- 
 tutoj. The Court ordered the Defendant to (hew caufe why ludgement 
 ihould not be given againft him upon his plea. 
 
 and Long^ 
 
 Mich. 13 Car, Banc. Rc2. 
 
 T!^c ^plaintiff bjougbt an action upon tbc Cafe foj tbcfe toojDs fpokcn ^""^^^ '^'^R- 
 ofbtm,Longisamurtherer, and hath bewitched my Child, and was^^"' 'f"^"* *' 
 
 the death of my Child, anD obtcins a bcroid. sCj)e Si>cfcnDant mobes in words. 
 
 U atreS
 
 66 
 
 FcLny. 
 
 Avernicnt. 
 
 ■ — ■ — — f 
 
 Mich. 25 Car. 
 
 arrfft of SluDgcmciit , ano tafecs t!)cfe eiccptiono to the ©cclaratfon. u 
 %\iat it <s not fafo , tftat tbc Cl)Uo teas bcltftcbcD to ocatb. ilp. 5t uotft 
 not ctp:cf0 Uibctlicr tl)c Cl)tlD bctotttbco 11)80 bojnalfbeojnot. Eot^fs 
 tbc Court fafD, tiiat tbc bcidtt^lng of tbcCbilufiJi'^cloiip, tbougljft do 
 not Dpc bp ft. flno to t^c fccono crceptfoti < Sbat tbc Court Uotlj 
 not tahc notfcc of a CWlo <f<t bcDcaD=bo?n, ano tbcp iDfllfntPno ft inag 
 bojn aUbC ; aiiO Roll luftice falD, tbat tbcfc IjdojDB Thou didf} kill my Ma- 
 fters Cook, bat)c been aofiiogcD arttonablc, altbougb tbe plaintiff Dfo not 
 atjcr, tijnt bfs fpaCfcr IjaQ a CooU. Thtrerore let the Plaintiff take his 
 Iudgt;rnenr, if better matter be not (hewn Saturday next. 
 
 Carver againft Pierce. 
 23 Cif. Banc. Reg, 
 
 Arrcftof 
 luJfcmcnt In 
 an aflion for 
 Words 
 
 ChattcJ. 
 
 Felony. 
 
 CA rver b?fnffs tin Sictfon upon tijc Cafe a^cafiitt Pierce foj fpeakfng tftcfc 
 iDOjaa oUjim, Thou art a Thief, for thon hall flollen my Dunf;,anD tatb a 
 tacrDftt. Cbc Sr^cfenoant moVicD in arrcff 0' Kuogcntcnt , that tljc toojoa 
 lucre not actionable : foj ft fa not certain tobctftcrtfte Dung be a Chattel , 
 J part of t\it Jf ree-bolD, ann ff fo, ft cannot be 2Cl)cft to tahc ft, but a £Ercf- 
 fpafa, ano tbcn the Sctfon tofU not Ipc. Bacon Juflice, Dung is a 
 Cbattcl, anomapbcftoDcn, 3I3ut Roll luflice anftocrcD , Dunj^ map be 
 a Chattel, anoft map not be a Chattel ; foj a beap of Dunjj fs a Chattel, 
 bntff it be fpicaa upon the ilano ft fa not, ano fafD, the too?D Thief here fs a. 
 ftfonablc alone, anDthercarenorubfrtiitcntluo:Dato mftfcjatc t^cfojmcc 
 tDOjoa : fo? the flcalfng of Dung fa J^elonpff it be a Chattel. Bacon lu= 
 ftice faio, 3it Doth not appear in this Cafe of lDl)at fealue the Dungtoaa , 
 ant) hoto ©all ft then be fenoton, iuhcthcr ft be j^clonp 0; pctp iLarcenp:' 2Lo 
 thf^ Roll anritjerco, thcVoojoaare fcanoaloua notVoftbftanDfng anuactfo- 
 nablc, though the ttcalfng of tftcDung bcnotiFclonp, The rule was, to 
 move It again Tuefday nex\ 
 
 Micfj. 2sCar. Banc- Reg. 
 
 Error to re- 
 verfc a lud^;- 
 mcnt, for dif. 
 cotuiniiaiicc 
 in the Pro- 
 
 Difcoiitinu- 
 ai.cc. 
 
 ludgcmciit. 
 
 AWidt Of Crro J toaa brought fn thfa Court to rctierfe a 3uogcmcnt gf. 
 ten fn the £Rarflia[a Court, ano the erception taben tDa0,thaf there toaa 
 a Dlfcontf nuance in the pjocefa , ano fo there ought to hate been no Suoge- 
 mcnt, ant) thercfoje the Juogcmcnt gitjcn fs erroneous; ano that there luas 
 a SDifcontfnuancc ft thua appears. SCh" Contfnuancc toas ad proximam 
 Curiam, ano ft appcar0 upon the rcto jn of the Venire facias, that that toas no 
 Court Dap, fojfttoagthctft?cc anDttocntpctf)tapofthc^onth,tohcreaB 
 Friday, on toftfch Dap the Court teas bclD, tuas not the 2 3 Dap, ano fo there 
 fs Crroj fn tftc contfnuancc. Roll luftice fafo, tftcfoamer Continuance 
 tnas to the pt^. nap , ano from tbcnce to the i stfj- anD that fs but fix Dates, 
 anDfoUjantsofthetfmc. Bacon lu(ticf,®ahere there fs a SDffcontfnBance 
 tt)e Court hath no poUicr to afteJuDgcnicnt, ano fothc ^uDgmentfsljcre 
 crtoneouij, ano tljctefoje let (t be teterfcD, nifi caufa, &c. 
 
 Micb,
 
 .\iich. 13 Car. 6"} 
 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 to 
 
 1 
 
 T 
 
 L<jftj[ec f"' ?'car3 ofilanDcbpSJceu, bjfngo an JSctfoit of Cotjenant a- Demurrer 
 tTatnfttl)ci.cffo;, ann Declares, tbattbcllclloj Ijao coticnantcD, t^at»Pti 'nan 
 tie ftoulD peaceablp ann qutctlp cnjop tijc JLaiios let outins tl)c ESerm , am '^'°" °^ ' ' 
 tbat a Stranger entrcD upon Um, ano oiiaco b»m tettfttn tljc %ttm. SDo '^"*"'' 
 tftlo SDcclnrattcn tl)eSDefcnDaut Demurs. Roll ludicefaio, tbat ttje Co^ 
 tenant rn tbts Cafe is fajoiscn, tbougb <t be a &transer tljat cntcrcD anD ou- 
 flcD tfte JLcffce. Walker of Councel tottl) tbe Dcfcnoant tooh tljig Difference, 
 tot)ere a fetrangcr enters upon tbe HclTce ano ootb a Ercfpafs , ano toberc 
 f)e enters ano outs tbe iLeffecjfn ttcfojmcrCafcljefatD, tbe Covenant is Covenant, 
 not bjoben : but in latter ft fs bjoSen. Judgement was given for chc Piaimiff 
 except caufe Ihould b: (hewn Monday ncxr. 
 
 Thynn againft Thynn. 
 
 , -Mich. J 3 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 Hill. 23 Car, rot. idjS, 
 
 HyKD bjougbt an Action of Dotocragainff Thynn, anD I)atb a 3?aij0c<n 
 mcnt bp Default, ano thereupon a caritofC-nquirpiffueDouttotbev-'fe'aiudle; 
 ^bcriff, tobo Delftoerco felKn oftbc Doiucr recoterco, ano rcturneD tbe m^nc inDow- 
 mrit; upon tbis SuDPcment, SEbe DcfcuDant b jings a mrit of Crroj, ano''- 
 afsianstbcfcerro?stntbcHcco?.D. i. 2Ebco;fgtnalOTrtt appears not to p^'",'"- ,• _■ 
 be rcturneDaccojDiiis to tbc Statute : foj tbc pear Dotb not appear ii^en it '''^ ^""•"'"• 
 teas returnto. 2lp. 2Cbc P;oclamatlon maoc bptbe &bcriff. appears 
 not to be toberc tbc lianD Ipec, jlp.SEbc return Dotb not mention tbat tbe ^"'"'"°°'* 
 pjoclamation iuas after tbc Summons, as it ougbt to be, as it is Hob. Re. 
 portf, in Aliens Cafe, 4!?. %t ffl not faiD tbat be Dio make pjoclamntion 
 upon tbc llanD. slp. 3t appears not tljattbi^Pjocl-amation inasintbc pa^ 
 Tiflb tiiberc tbc Summons luas.as tbc Statute cir:£ts. %o tbcfc crccptions 
 Hales of Councel on tbe otfecr fiDc, anfiucrcD. SDo tbs firft , tbat tbc rctojn Kctum. 
 oftbc ojininal tsattt (ball be intenDcD to be in tljc pear of tbe Heign , ano 
 not of tb3 0gc oftbc !iing, tbougb tbe Idojd Reigo be omitteD. sfo tbc fe= 
 cond, tbcJLanDslpcinDiticrsiDariibcs, ano IpjoclamationattbcCburcft 
 ofanp oftbc parifljcs is gooDcnougb. ilp. 3t Dotb not appear, tljat tberc 
 arc Dtbcrs Cijurcbcs inl^ewrSarum tobere tbc proclamation Ujacmaoc. 
 STo tbc third ejctptton, the p joclaraation is faiD to be maoc prout breve po- 
 flulat, anD tbat fball be fuppofcD Dulp Done, ano implies all rcqutiitc tircum- 
 flanccs, anDbc cannot make aiTctbcrreiurn, ano it fsimpofeible tofaco= 
 tbcriralcs SCotbe fourtbjtisnotncccffarptotctojn tl)c place of ttc Sum* 
 mons. anD It is faiD tbatittuasmaDefecundumformiraStatuti, tcbicbfup- 
 plfes tbc rctt. anD to tbis tbe Court fafo, that tbc tuc:D6 fecundum formam 
 Statuti ertcuD far. jflnD Roll lufliccfaio, tbat pjociamation in one placg 
 iBas gooD in all. Holhead of Councel toitb tbe plaintiff, li\ tbc CGritof 
 Crroj pjocecDeD, ano toofe tbcfc cyceptions in tbe Dcmano oftbc IDotocr. 
 I . Ebc DcmanD is gencrallp de redoria, Ubicb is not gooo , foj tbc inccr«Dfman«r. 
 taintp of it; foj tbcrc map be a Reftor of a College, of a ^jotince, f of a iSi.^^'^'^f • 
 
 jI
 
 6 8 Mich/- 3 Car. 
 
 ftjop:tcU, as tocU as of a parfa)-C!)urcb,anD t^crefo^c ft otisljt toljatcbccn 
 de Re<ftoria f cdefiac parochialis dc &c. 1 2 H. 4. f. 19. pi. i. z\v. 2Cf)C DC« 
 mano dccimarum to too general, aiiD not gcna, ano itougl)ttobat>cbEcn<Ie» 
 cimarotngranorum, fccni, &c. fo? tbcDcmanD deomnimodis dccimitquibul- 
 cur.queistOO general, U Rep. Herberts cafe, I. SCotftCfC crccptlons Hales 
 anfUjetcD, tbat a nemanDlnanaritef.DoiDetnecDnottobcfocract aofn 
 otljcr ojfainalGartts: fo; ojfnfnal CQrUoarcnot alterable, but ougbt to 
 anrtoer tlje fo;ms in tljc llcgt'ftcr. So tljc I'econd be fatu , tl)at reftoria fliall 
 be fntcnoco tbe Redory of a Churcb,anD tt)e statute cytcnDo not to tWa .■ bc» 
 Ooes tbe plate of tl)c Hettojp io Dcrcribco,al)tcb mahcs (t ccrtafn cnougi). Eo 
 tl)C third , UfsnotncccffarptocrpjcffltbcStltliES partfcularlp, ano tbcue- 
 manD being oftljeHcctojpUtonip^trctbaU the 2Citl)C0, alfottjcDemanofa 
 de oronimodrs decimis toWcS <3 a general Dcmano, anD cotnp?ifetlj all, ano is 
 notdedecimisonlp, fojtbat mlgftt be inccrtain. Holhead,2:'.)cDemanDi3 
 dereftoria & deomnimodis decimis, tobicl) i0 a CcmanD of onetl)ing tUice, 
 ano t^at ia not tontjenicnt , fo j bp t\\is means tlje partp map rctobcr Dam= 
 mages tVofcc, ano tbc Court Vuill be alfoinbcaglcu bptWs means, ano it 
 matters not tbougl) toe bate not pteaoco to tbts : fo: tljc Court ongbt to 
 
 Notice. taijc notfcc pf (t ^ "bccaufe it to in tlje original mrft. i^cjrt tljerc is no foim 
 In t!)c Count, fo; cum pertinentiis is infojmal , fo; It refers to tlje pariQi, 
 ano nottotl)cSpannour,a7F. 3.f. 86.P1. 3. Halcf, SDbio is but a Variance 
 in fojm, anD is not material, anoalfoit ftaObeintcnoeDtorcfertotbe 
 «pannour, ano not to tl)C parifii. Hoiliead, Sbe ocmant) ia not \ijarranteo 
 bp tl)c Cdrit, fo; tl)c aill ano Ipariflj arc not name? in tbe uSartt , but ate 
 namcD in tbe ocmant), 1 1 Rep. Arondels cafe. Hales,2Cbe oemanD is not de 
 redoria in Tymsbury , but de Tymibury, anD is tbe Denomination of tbc 
 tbinsDemanoeD, anonotoftbc tUll tobetcltlpes.Holhcad, StisnotfafD, 
 
 Tiihc. tDbcrctbeSCitbcocrtenD.anDtbcpmapejtenDtoDiticrBtiltlls, as a .-^aa 
 
 Parifli." rifli map, -.9 E. 3. f. 9, Halet, il5crc is one oemano, ano it induces all tbc 
 SCitbcs. Roll luftice, l^ou baijc SemanDeD tbc llectojp in Tymber, anu not 
 
 Gr«n^ tftc Kcctoip Of Tymber, anD bi' tbc grant of onco cpannour in Dale.no mojr 
 
 of it paffctb tban tubat Dotb Ipcin Dale, ano bete it fljall beintenDCD fs 
 mucb of tbe SEitbcs as are in Tymber. Holhead,^crc is a DemanD of SDoinct 
 of fucb tbtnas tobcrcof Dotocr Ipcs not, viz. 01 a quarry of Stone.*, antiit 
 appears not tbat tbe 'Jiuarrp Iras open in tbc life of bcr !^usbanD; ano if it 
 lrcrc,pct it is improper to DcmanD it bp tbc name of aQuarry.Hales,tbclDojo 
 Quarry is a gooD irioiD,ii tnelUhnoton tobat it means : fo; Qijarrera is an ola 
 
 Dower toebUnoinn kntine teo;s fo; it.ano (1)d is as toell Doioablc of (t as of a s^tm 
 of Coles, anD it (ball be intcnDCD tobcopen.bccaurefljcDemanDsitbp 
 tbat name of a Quany. Holhead.Sbc DemanD oftbc Dotocr is alfoof a il^un« 
 5;ED,oftobtcba CCtoman io not DoUjJiblr, bccaufe it is an entire tbtng, ano 
 cannot be DittoeD, ano tbc DemanD QjouId bate been de tertia parte proficu- 
 orum hundred!. SCo tbis Roll luftice anftoercD tbcn bp pout reafon tbt (IjaD 
 ncter Uecp a Court. Halts, 3t is Itjellenougb DcmanDCD, fo;aDemana 
 daD be of tbctbingitfclf, anDnot oftbcp:ofitsofit, foitbcpjofitstoere 
 not in tbc !^usbanD , but be luas fcifeo of tbe ^5nn2;eD, anD tbc pjofits are 
 at^ingfnccrtafiT. Holbead, EEbe execution of tbe Habere facias fefinamtgt 
 not iDCll orccutcD, fo; bp it ttootbirD parts are afoigncD fo;DotBet, ano 
 tbat is mo;e tban tljc oemanD. Hales, SLbat is but a repetition oftbc tbfng 
 DcmanDCD. Holhead, a tbing not DcmanDCD at all fs afsigncD fo? Dolxicr, 
 \h. ttcfa of i^ranU plcDgc. Hales , Slbat is but an intioent to anotbcc 
 tbing tbat is DcmanDCD, VIZ. tbc li^unDjcD, ano bptbcocmano oftbc I^an- 
 DjcDtbc tielD of if ranb^plcogc is DcmanDCD , ano all otber inciocnts to tbe 
 ^unD;eD. Holhead ^erc is an afcignment alfo of all tenures, ano ftc can- 
 rict bate ^omasc, bccanfe fte fs a ?K.1oman, Halts, &be (6all bate all tc 
 
 nurC0
 
 Mich. 15 Car. 69 
 
 nutes iDbffft ft^ fa capable of,antifo all (liall be imtjerffooD fn tftfs plate, 
 ano no otftcr ibz fljall Ijate. Holhead.SElje ^uDgement is alfo of i s CopfliolDS 
 9 jCenemcntB tol)fcf) latelp tncre «i;opi!}olD!3.Roll lu(1:ice,2!:btg ta gooo enougf), 
 ann toftat iofs ftatie poii bp ft:'Holhead,2D&c iafcfgnmcnt is alfo o"f ttje 3D. part 
 de Copicia & de Straduris>anD;ot&ct too jDs t^crc arc Iclncb arc alfo Incertain, 
 Sim tljctc (s cttoj in tt)C afsfgnment of oammagcs : fo j tfje Datnmages are 
 afeiancD ultra valorem terrae,U)l)fcl) is arafnfttljcfetatntc. Roll Iuf>ice,tl)e 
 Statute fs an aDOltlon oftl)Et3alucanDDt-immagc!?,fojtlic31uogemcnt<g,^^J^^„'f^'' 
 pcrfctt toltftout rctnrmngtbcMrttoftljcDammagcs, anOfoliatbbcenao- 
 juDSCD in t^c Common pleas. Hoihead , ^^crc fsan fUftiggcftfonoftije 
 if erne, fo> fljc riiggeftctb, tljat Jjer ^^usbano DpcD fctfco in'fecof alltfte 
 llanos out of tobltljfljcDcmanBs bcr 2DoU)cr, ano tl)at <s not true, foj ftc 
 SpcD fcffcD of part of tftem in tapl. Jto tbfatbc «ir:ourt fato tW is not mate- 
 rial <f be Dpco fo feffcD , tbat (be ougbt to bate Dolocr. Hoihead, SDammagcs 
 arc gfljcn ultra valorem , Icbitb 3 conccfbc Is not gooD. Roll luftice, 3t is 
 iDClfEnoaBb : tor bammagcs arc gibcn, ant) tljc taluc fartbc Statute, 
 Hoihead, Cljc tctojn Of tbe Elegit is not gooD. Hales, Eljiat fs anotljcc 
 aRecojD, ano appears not notufntbe CDourt. Roll lufllce,i:be Elegtbatbno , 
 
 reference to tbe fojmcr Kccojo. Hoihead, ^\)Ztc iaonc crroj in fact, 
 ano tbat is confeffco bp pout jopning in Demurrer. Roll Juftice, Pou Q.^^^^^^^^tru 
 tnigbtbfl^tDemurrcDfojtbisDou'ilcncrg, foj one cannot afcign an erroj 
 in fart, anD«notbcr crroj in 3Laui in a ^rit of Crroj, foj tbis is Double. 
 Hales, 3t is true, but iuC babe loft tftataobantage, Adjourned to beargned 
 again the next Tcrm» 
 
 Robinfon againfl: 
 
 Mich, 13 Car. Banc. Reg» 
 
 RObinfon fajoogbt an Action of 2:robcr ann ContJcrCon actainft T. B. -^^'/^ °^ . 
 ano batb a UcrDitf. Sbc SDefenoant mobeo fn arrctt of fuDgemcnt, xSf!"^ ' 
 anD flietocD fo: canfr, tbat tfjc SDeclaration teas not gooD, foj tbeJDlain- ' ' 
 tiff amongftotbcr things Declares, that tbe paitttiff bao founD anDcon« 
 Derteo to bio oton ufe unum vtftigium, Anglice a i^ootftool , tobercas it Cg^ 
 nff.e8aiFootftep,o?ap?(nt oftbcfoot, anD not a i?ootCool. sip. acbc 
 Iplaintiff Declares pro decern ponderibus Aeris, meaning ten pounO of Brais, 
 to^creas it fljoulD be ac-is toitb a SDiptbong, foj Aeris is of Ayr, ano not 
 Brafs. 5l5ut this cjception \^-ns ober^r-HcD bp the Court, bccaufc in the tD3i= 
 ting of Court-banD , in inbicb banD SDcclarations are to?itten, tbcrc ate 
 no SDiptbongs ufcD , ano fo the toojD Aeris might as iDCllGgnificBrafs as '"^''^'P- 
 Ayrc. JBut fojtije Otiijet ejrception, judgement was ilaj cd till che Plaintiff coua'ha d 
 fliouldmove. "' ° ■ 
 
 Izack againft Green. 
 
 Mich, 23 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 Izack bjfngs an jatdion upon tbe Cafe in London againft Green/o j calling For a Procc- 
 bcr W horc. Green temobes tbecanfc bp a Habeas corpus into this Court, Jc'^o to iry 
 anDbatba Supc-fedea? to ffap tbe piatntiffspjocacings in London. JIbCL "a'""'" 
 ipiaititiffs Councclmo-bcD fo? a Procedendo , tbat be might pjocaD in Lon- °" ' 
 don, bccawfe tljat in London, bpafpecialCuftom tt)crcan;JlaionDot^lpc
 
 70 Mich. 2 5 Car. 
 
 ■ fo? callfntt a tooman Mfto?c, tbotig^oiit ofTondon it Ipes not , ano titeS 
 
 Pafcal ailD Barbars Cafe 21 lac. to pjobc ft. Bacon Iuftice,2i:t)C cullom Of 
 Londonfstobccertifii'CDtbatVDcmap^tiorc of t^c rcafonablcncffc of it, 
 ano toe arc nnt to ta!»c notice of it upoit a fiirnilfc , anu it fccma tbata pro« 
 Procedendo, cgdendo (IjoulD tiot bctc Ijc gtantED, faccaufctbc matter VDitb icljfcft (6c is 
 ^''""' tl;argcD hp tl)c toojos belong to t'oc Conifancc of tljc Cltitll lato to trp it,ano 
 not to our )LaU',a3 it is 2 H. 4. Roll luOice, Dne map in fomc Cafcfl ^atie 
 anSSctlonattftc^nomnionlau', U)i)cre!)c map bate rcmcDp alfointbcCc- 
 tlertaftff all Court ; foUbc^CommonlalBistobepjctcrrcD, anubp a fpe* 
 cial c'.iftom ag tlje Cafe l)cre is, an Action map be malntaineo tobcrc it Ipca 
 not at tl)c Common lato, anofoluag ttljclos Car. ano ij Car. fltno if 
 tl)crc fijonlo net Oe a procedendo grantcD in tlia Cafe, tbe |3laintiff moulD 
 bs tpru up bptljc habeas corpus, i>ut if it be grantcotlje matter map be trp^ 
 CD, ano npontljat if tl)c31uDScment be erroneous a tojit of Crro; map be 
 ?j;ougl)t in tbc Huftir.gs in London, ano fo all t^c matter map come in queft* 
 ion to be argucc, ano b^ TalD tljat a Charter cannot gitie an Sldion , tofjirb 
 tlje Common lalo allotD3 not, 2uc let the matter reft as it is till we can a- 
 grte. 
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. Banc- Reg, 
 
 r.ction. 
 
 Arrcftot ^ 192 piatntiffbjotigljtljfa Action upon tbe Cafe, foj tfjcfc tDOjOsj, thou 
 luJpemenr in -t rnuttton^rnonper the:f bring home my ftoien hay. 2Et)e IDcfcnOant 
 'n^lfJ'"^^"•'" makes a rpetialuiCffttation,t|)attIjc plaintiff baoftollen a ttjccp, ano up= 
 onthfsiuasaniffuciopnco, anoabcroictfoitte plaintiff, 2Ebc 2Dcfcn- 
 Dant mot)cs in arrctt of Kuogcment tljat tlje declaration inas not gooo; fo j 
 itonlpcljargetljtbeDcfcnoantlDltbfpcaUingof tbe toojos, ano ootb not 
 fap dixit de quercnte , ano tboncb t^ofc IrojDs be in tlje replication, pet tbat 
 maijeo not tbe H>cclaration gooo. R.0II luftice, SCbe Declaration is not gooo, 
 fo J tbe toojoo map be fpol^tn of anp otber boop, as toell as of tbe plaintiff* 
 Bacon luftice agrees hiii:() Roll, ano faio. tbat tbe IdoiO dixit ioas not in 
 tbe Dcclavat'cn , ano fo i\ appears not tobetber tbe JDefcnoant fpoUc , 0?. 
 Ui;it, ojtboti£bt tbeU)o;Ds,anDii.bicbiomo?eiti0notraiD,tbattb: Idojds 
 lucre fpoUcn in tijeptefcncc of anp boop, anotben tbcp cannot be fcanoa^ 
 lons; Roll luft.ce f^iio, one cannot reiopn upon tJDo;Ds,ti)bicb arc not in 
 tbe ^Declaration no? in tbe plea; fojiftbe SDcclaration , ano tbe plea be 
 R'p'.iciiioi). nausbtjtberepUcattOiuannotmaUetbem gooo. The rule of Conrt was 
 nil capiat per billan3,excepi caule (hewn Saturday following. 
 
 , Kinpe again ft lohnfonj 
 Mich 23 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 Pafc, 23 Car. rot. 154, 
 
 F';c; u,''or. a 
 lu('e"r"cnt 11 
 
 A ^rttof€rrojiija3b;ougbttorctcrrca3iiogeOTent gibcninHuil, 
 
 3^^j, • /\ fo; tbefe ©rrojs afsigncD, 1. SEbatoncoftbccontinuantestoasto 
 
 Cu„iiuuii.c a certain cap oftbemontb,toI]Ere it ougbt to be ad proximam curiam; 2, 
 
 21'OC Declaration teas pro fc decern beltii?, Anglicc Cov;s or Whyes, iobtcO 
 
 tcstoo general; fojtbetxiojobcftia map figiufic anp bcaft tobatfoetcr as 
 
 iDCll
 
 MicK. ijCar. 7j 
 
 iDgllasa€oiD» Theludgememwasreverfed except caufe (hewn to the 
 contraryf 
 
 More againft Clipfam. 
 
 ^ 
 
 Mich* 2^ Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 MOre bjfttgsa If^cplctin aaafnft Clipfam , anft Declares of a ^unojca Arpumfnr 
 oves Matrices et vervicesDfftratncD bg Cliplam, Clipiam OCllturfl to "P"-" aR-ep**- 
 tl)clKcplct(nfoitbcfntertatntpofft; foj ft appears not tjotomanp oftJjc^'"- 
 i)iinD jec ftccp DfftrapncD, ano replcljfetj, iccre Mstnces, o: cipcs , ana boin 
 inanp Iccrc vervices, oj Vt)cat!)crs ; Maynard iiioljcs foj ^tiDgcir.Ent in tbc 
 3Rcpletmfojt^c paintfff , ano Ijclo tljat centum oves alone loas gooo,anD 
 certafir, ano tl)C aooftfon Matrices, ano vervices, fljall not mafec an (ncertain- 
 tp, ano t\)t \a^^t of Iflcpletjin cotl) not Ojcto tlje eattcll Dtttraincti parttcular^ '""''*'"'y- 
 Ip, buttbcbclpoftbcpatti', anDtf)e tlelu of tfje S>l)er«ffmaa concurrto 
 fljeVD tD^at Cattcl arc to be oelttereD bp tlje tojit. alp, J^crc is a cooo 
 fffucargumcntattbe,altbouel)ttbenotfo fojmal. 3!p. jniicrefo no mojCr,T- 
 in tbc (true at tbc315ar,tl)an in tbc aboU)?p,fo; all tbe SCcrm is but one oap, f "^* 
 tftct is no of biCon of time in it,i it is Dangerous to make fraaions,iE a§>tatute •^'=""- 
 achnoiBlcogcD in tbc aCcrm relates to tftc firft cap of tb^sncrnt.Hales on t^c „ 
 otberfioeagrceotbat centum oves tDft[)oiit raping anp mo;c bao been cer=Rciatk.n 
 tain enougb, but as t\)t:^ are berc oiaingtnfbcD into Matrices , ? vervices, tbcrc 
 is nocertaintpatall; foj tbc Cattcl in bino are ccmanDco, ano ougbt to 
 be Dclf bercD as tbep are ocmanoeo, fo tbat if tbe oemanD b: incertain tbef c 
 can be no certain ueliberp. alp, SCbe fffiie is ill , ano is not bclpeo bp tbe 
 "beroit; foj i. tbetitlcmabeisnotanrtncrcD. z.SCbctraberrc is onlp to - f»v"^'=- 
 tbc conclufion , ano roisbutbptoapofiitfcrcrtcc,anois not bclpco after ,^ • 
 
 a beroitt ; fo; tbe plea is not anficcrco: fo j tbc toojos fuit ct adhuc eft fefitas "^*' 
 is not gooB , fo; it is not material tobctbcr be locre fcifcD at tbc time of tbc 
 Dittreffe o; no, but tobetber be ucre feifeo at tbc time of tbe rcplebin , ano 
 tbcre is a Diftance bcttoecn tbe rcplebin, ano tbe aboiujp, am tbcre is a pri. 
 m ant) a pofteriusinit. RollIuf>iceraiD,iti3mat)cupintbc rctojn, ano 
 tberc is no Diftinttion of time , ant) if one plcao an ill plea , ano tbc iffu e 
 upon it be founo againS bim , be (ball not take aobantage of bis olcn ill 
 plea , ano if there be a ncgatitc, ano an af firmatibc, tbougb tbc tfftic be not 
 inelUopncD, it is bclpco bp tbc statute of leofaiies, otbcrtoife, if tbcrc be 
 iiptanaffirmatibe,anDancgatibC; fojtbcntbercisnoiffueat all topnco 
 to be bclpco. Bacon luftice, Oves matrices et vervices is ill ; foj tbc &>bcriff 
 Iknotocs not tibat reto jn to maUc j Roll accojos, ano faio , pon babe maoe 
 tbat tobicb teas certain, to be incertain bp tbe fpeclfication pou babe maoe , 
 ano a rcplebin is a ocmano, ano ougbt to be as certain as a precipe. ludge! 
 ment was given againft the Plaintiif m the cafe at the bar, becauie the Declas 
 ration was il!,and uncertain, 
 
 Gilbert
 
 1i Mich. 23 Car. 
 
 Gilbert agaiaft Scone. 
 
 Micb» 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Trin. Zj Car, rot, lyoj. 
 
 Demurrer up. ^^-^nfcert b?onsU an 3ctlon of Etcfpaffc quare claufum frcf;tr,anD taking 
 Trcfpad^ '" ^J "f ^ gclDfng,acainft Stone. 2LI)c SDcfcnoant plcaos tijat ^e fo j feat of 
 Ijfslffe, aiiDii)oiinofnsoftiDCltcarmcDmcrT,to^otb;catncDtot5{ll ^{mtf 
 ftc Dfo not tfjc fatt, tocnt into tl)c ftoufc of tljc plaintiff, «nD tooU tl)c gcloing. 
 %\)c plaintiff DemtirrcD to t^is plca;Roll luiticc, Eljis is no pica to juftific 
 Trcfpidc tbclDcfenoant ; fo; 3 map not do a Crcfpaffc to one fo; feat of tb:cat = 
 nfngflofanotljer, fojbptl)i0mcanotbcpattj>injuteD(l)all l)at3c no fatis- 
 fartion. fo J Y,c cannot ftaljc it of tljc pattp tljat tijjcatncD. Therefore let ibc 
 Plaintiff have his ludgcraent. 
 
 Symons and Low. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc, Rcg» 
 
 Trin. 13 Car. rot. 6 5 o, 
 
 trro' u C Ytnons Wna.a an Action upon the Cafe againtt Low foj fpeakfng tfjefe 
 
 1 Jcgcmcnr * ^ too'Ds of hit, She, innuendo the pia{ntiff,f0 per)ntcD, anD hath a teroict, 
 
 torv/ords. snD 8 luogcment; t^c 2DcfcnDant bjings H tSHtit of C^Etoj to tctetfc this 
 
 Plaint. 3;utigcmcnt , anoafisignsfojcEtroj that the plaint teas entrcD the fame 
 
 Dap "that the too;oc lucre fpol5en,Vrhich VuasfaiD onght not to be .bccanfc the 
 
 Ff jftions. Action ttjoulo bc bjought after the luojDs fpohcn, iohfch Ihall not be intcn. 
 
 ncDtobcifitbcthefamc Dap, bccaufethc J^atoaDmits of no ftaaions of 
 
 timz, tehich UiiU be, if a Dap be Ditioco into fc\3eral patt0,afl it here muft be, 
 
 fo J there muft be one hout fuppofcD tohen the Idojdb tuerc fpobcn , ano a-- 
 
 nothcrhotit iijhen the plaint luas cntteo. ISut Roll luftice faio, it toaa 
 
 lo:U enough, ano ojDcrcD the plaintiff to taUc hct 3;uDgemcnt , if caafe 
 
 were not fhcwn before the end of tne Term , 
 
 Cl\ecvers again ft 
 Mich» 2 3 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 ukc"^ uc.'j' \ 7 Pon a rule of Court to Ihcto caufe tohi' a fcire facias to rcl3t<je a BCuog- 
 V mcntluasnotgooD , 2Lhti3toa0OJftcDfo:caufe,thatitDothnot thcUi 
 i)efojetDhomthe3:uDgcmcntirasgiben,tohtch tos to be tcttbeo bp the 
 fcire facias , ano confcqucntlp there appears no 3;uDgcment to tearran t the 
 icire fncias. 2Eo this Roll luftice anftoercD, that in the Common pleas the 
 £onvfc{0tofetfo?th bcfojc tohom the Sluogemcnt is gi\jrn, but in this 
 Court the toutfc is not fo: 31But hoto tomes the IRccojD hithct :- K'.)C 
 Councell anftoercD , aEljat there \uas a SuDgcment in Canterbury, ana 
 upon that a Wxit of Crro; u-as bjought in this Court, ano the 3;uDgemcnt 
 
 Sc. cfaciis aiftrmcB upon that iKRrit of Crroj, ano then a Scire facias itfucD out here 
 upon the 3:uDgcment againft the bail , ano upon this the bail mot)es upon 
 the rccojD,that there is erro? in the fcire facias . Roll lufticc,2:beJRetojD is 
 iBCllcnoush; 3n a fcire facias it .is rot tequilite to fap Confidcratum efl 
 per curiam. Therefore let the fcire facias ftand. 
 
 Carver
 
 Mich. 2 3 Car. 75 
 
 Carver and Pierce. 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 T©e CarcbettDECn Carver anO Pierce Itjas agafn motiCD bv Hales, lcI)Ct= Arrtft oY 
 (ti tt teas moUeo fotmcrlp <tt arrcft of guDgcment that tljcfe tcojos/'^'i?""'"* 
 Tbouartatheef,andhaftftolen my dung arc not aaionablc: SOjat tl}C°'*"" '• 
 toojDs ate aafonable foj tftcfe reafons. i . 2tbe firft ir ojos ate acttonae 
 blc, ano tlie feconu fao:os ate atcnmulattbe , ano aggravate tfte fo?mct 
 lBo;iJ0, anDDonotmUtgatc tbcm. 2. 3t map be felonp to tteal Dun?, 
 atiD tfte Wolence of tfae toojos do enfo?ce it to be fo fntenucD. Bacon luftice, 
 BfjolDt^at Buogcmentfstofaesi^enfojtbepatntiff , ano foft tras foi 
 tbCfelDOjDSjthouart atheef, andhaftOolen my Corn. Roll luQicetoag of 
 tbc fame opinfoti , ano fato t!)at tbe fccono too jDo ate not tiolcnt enough ta 
 allapthe 8rft too^Ds , ano are not ejcplanatojp , anu bp toap of xnttlgation; 
 fojtt)Ctoo;Dsatenot, for thou haft, but tftcp are, and thou haft ftollen my 
 dung. ludgemen: was given for the Plaintiff, antea* 
 
 Eeles and Lambert. 
 Mich. >5 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 'T'^c Cafe fact tocen Eeles ano Lambert teas again atgiicD bpLatchfo; tljc ^ Araumems 
 •■*' plaintiff, ano bp Twisden fo; the 2D£fcnDant,Larch atgueo to tl)ig cffctt, |',J,''!,"„'^^';'u- 
 SCftat tbe l^cgatec hath no tight in the Icgacp, untill it be ucliteteo unto him ^'^^ 
 Lp tbe Cpecutoi, 2 E. 4 . fol. 1 5 . but if a Icgacp be gihen in th'S manner ) if 3 Legacy. 
 Dpe let mp Cofen hate fach a thing, there the legatee map tabe the Icgacp 
 toithout the helibcrp of the Cpccuto^ , ano a thing tohich cannot be Detjifco Adm.niftratr- 
 cannot be atjminlfltcD. Bradon lib. 2.C. j6. 7 H. 6. oetifc is tioio if thetCg^. 
 be not futficicnt G00D3 facCDes to faticSc the SDcbto of thcSCcftatoj. 2, SLhc Devife. 
 DifpoCtion of the SCeftatoj ought to agree toith the lato of GoD,thc lato of na= 
 tnte, ano the \m of the 3LanD;anD tohcrcag it is objcctcD that there toill be 
 an incontjenience,it the legacies fhall not be paiD, 3 anfuicr, tbc ILato tc« 
 SatDs not this incont}eniencie;]15ut alp. this inconheniencc is none in rcfpect 
 of the inconhcnicncc inill be on the other Cdc if the legacies be paiD, namelp 
 the b?eaking of the Blato of Ood, the i:ato of j^iature, ano of the llano, ano 
 the fncontenienccs fuppofeo arc hclpcu bp theC it?ill ilato , fo j it takes cau- ciution; 
 tion in paping of legacies to rcpap them in fuch accioents as ate in out 
 Cafe. Twifden fo J the 3DefcnDant argueo, that it teas a gooo aominiftra^ 
 tion of thiJ gooQs , ano that there is no affcts in the hanos of the C>:cciito js, 
 ano he agrees that a oetjifc of gooos in t'pecie , ano a oebifc of monp is all 
 onc; but fht3 is not a SDebt , ano fo is not to be paio ; fo j in Suogemcnt o£ 
 ILali), it is p;efumco that the Cotjcnant Hjall not be bjohen , ano that it 
 ftall not be refpccteD in tegaro of the incertaintp tohcthct it (hall be bjohcn 
 oj no, but the liato tafees notice of the ©a:ill,anDit is of tempoyil conufans, 
 2 Rich. 3. n H. 7. f. 12. ano it tabes notice ofalegacic to trp the tight of it, 
 anotooifch'itgeit, anotheC^ecntojhcteis compellable to pap the lega« 
 ctes , ano cannot tcfnCc ft neithet bp the Common lato, noj bp the &piritu« 
 allato; but it isobjcdeo that it is incontjcnicnt that one (hall atoiohis^^""'"^' 
 oton u:o\jenant bphis oton ocWfc. 2lo thiis 3 anftoer. he might haVe Don« 
 ittnhifiiifcbPC<^<ngatoapalll){sgooD3; anoilp. JDheteftall not be In-- 
 tenoeo to be ftauo in the WiiVi , ano there arc mo jc inconveniences of out 
 
 JL pari
 
 "74 Mich. 2 3 Car. 
 
 *^ccaiiiy. 
 
 part (n not papinatbc ILcgacics, tl)ati on tbs<r part bp papfng tljem : foj bp 
 tbfs mcanc, men ftall Ijalic no potocr to offpofc of tljcfc oten Oooos up 
 mill, bp rcafon of Coticnmito fii ILccfcsantj Dacocmaac bptl)cm;ann 
 tbc S>p(rftijal Court cannot coinpcll a iLcgatcc to put in fccurftp fo j ftts jLc- 
 gacp, ao (a furmifco. Adjourned to the nest Term to give ludgeraent, 
 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 T^t Zomt lDa3 moVicij to DcUbcr tbcfr opinion in aCafc fo jmcrlp motjcD 
 toD:rc«n tbc SJncftion toao,'-Dl)ctbcr an iltto:nmcnt maoc bp a?Lctra> foj 
 
 Attornircnt. 
 
 foj 
 f"od or'nc'c pcavs tlj: famc Bap that tbc rent toas Due to be paio upon bis ILcafc to bfm 
 tbatfjaopurcbafcotbcrctjcrftonoftbeJLanD let unto bint, anofo? tobtcbtbe 
 , ^urtbafcr bao bjougbt Ilia flaion, be a nooo iattojnmcnt. Roll luilrcc fafo, 
 tl)atttioagooD0ttojnnientbptbcatiCTmentmaDc, anD bptbc finning of 
 tbc3rurp, ano tbat ^uDgcment ougbt to be foj tbe paintiff. Baconlu- 
 ftite agrcc0, ano fa(D, tbc attornment tball be intenDeo to be bcfoic &utt 
 fet, anu not aCtetloarDS. Therefore let the Plaintiff talie liis ludgemenr. 
 
 Parmiter againft Cieney. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 r iv nr^'5'^ S>cfcnDanfij Countcl upon a foj5:;ertulcofCoiirf toC&ctDcaufc, 
 
 iu%c Z:h offeree fo: caufc tobp tb: plaintiff Ojoulo not babe Juogement. i . 315e= 
 
 n.ouid notbccanfc tbc plaintiff bao not atierrco tbat be oio maUeanpclcaionoftbe 
 
 piveninan ^KJineo tbat tbc iC^cfentiant luas to DcUtier uttto bitti. 2lp. I^cootbnot 
 
 Aft ;on upon jj^,g^^ tbat be gabc tbc SDefcnoantanp notice of bis election, anotbercbc- 
 
 A"vc>m-nT '' <na n ConDition pjcceocnt to be perfo:mco on tbc plaintiffs part, implpcD, 
 
 Not cc. tbc IDefcnDant cannot pcrfojm tbe HBargain, tpftbout notice of tbat pcrfo;- 
 
 RtqLicii. mantc. 2\\\ ^crc is no pootireqncft cxpjcffcDcitbcr in rubflancco; eft* 
 
 tumftancc, fo: fo? tbc ctrcumftancc tbcrc is but tUJo oaics to Do it, in lubicb 
 
 itcannot beiDcUintenDcDitcoultJbcDonc. zip- 3t is faio, beDfonot Deli« 
 
 tier vinurn praedidum, tobicbisaninccrtain implication of a Kcquctt : fo?, 
 
 tbc ItojD deliberare is not a pjopcrtcrm tocrpicfstbc llequctt, anotbe 
 
 terniit ootb not bclp it. Bacon luftice, SEbcre ougbt to be an clcttion bp tbe 
 
 plaintiff, but tbc jDcfcnoant ougbt firft to flicii) tbc tSKincs, anuitUjasof 
 
 bis part to batic appointed tbc time tol)cnb;tooulti0)eU)tbem. Roilluftice, 
 
 SEbe piomifc anD l^cqueft irasatNorwitch, anDittoasftifficicntfojtbc 
 
 plaintiff to mal-.c tbe Kequrft tbcrc : but tbc SDcfcnoant ougbt to nictu tbc 
 
 E'.eftion plaintiff the tiClinco, Voitbout tobtcb tbc plaintiff can mafec no cleaion, 
 
 anDtbcfubftanccoftbcS>££latationt0totbf8<ntcnt, iudgemem was given 
 
 for the Plaintiff. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc. Reg- 
 
 vviiyaPio- T\P tbe nrie of tbJ Court, tbfs nap cau'c iDasofffrcDtobc (b^inntobpa 
 inbinun pjobibitiou (boulD uot bc grantcD to tbc CcdriiafticalCourt.fo; granting 
 
 fhouid not be betters of a^minittration to a Sjiftcr of tbc balf^blooQ , Vobcn tbcrc Inas a 
 g.amcd. i5jotI}cr of tbc iubole^blooD tobo fueD foj tbcm, ano toas DcnpcD.SDbccanfe 
 
 QjetccD
 
 Hill. 2 3 Car. -j^ 
 
 (llclDCD tras, tfcat it isin tljc potocr of tlje £)jD{nari' to grant iaomfn(0ratf^ ~~' 
 
 on, Eitbcr to tbc 55;otl)ctoJtl5:iDt)olc bloo, oj to tljc&fttrroftbeiiair^ 
 
 blooD, at ftts Blcflion, bEcaufe tbcp are tn tqual Decree of fefti to ttj: Jntcffate. j 
 
 And to this tlie Court agreed. 315ut Bacon JullicefafD, tftatfnt^eCafC at tljC 4 
 
 IBat, ^Letters of aominfftratfon are grantco to tbc ^asbam ano ftf^ xhue, 
 
 anofotoone, riz. tljci^uflbanD,iit)ot3 no kin at all to tbc SntcCatc, but a 
 
 ^traneet, anDlfftefurbtbe!)l0®I3ffe, beOjaUbafcaHtfteGooDa, anoall 
 
 tbc kftiDjcD tofll be DcftatiDCD, tol;kb Is not rcnfonablc, ano tb:rcfo:c 
 
 tbc ^ommtCratlon ts not gOOO, And for this reafon a Prohibition was 
 
 granted. 
 
 Mich. 23 Car. Banc. Reg 
 
 I SC Iras motjetj fn arrcft of Suogement , tbat tbc plaintiff tau occiarcu of Arreft of 
 J tbc SCrotJcr 5 ContJctffon,of a retrain number crpjeffeo in tbcSDcdaratton " Jg<^'ntnt in 
 of pietcs panni Ianii,AngIice,ofreD,T'CHoto,ani) blarUCoatij.Ubftbts trccrtain, ^^^'"'"'"'^ 
 anD rannot be ufcD, asitisbcrc,tocrp,:efrcCloatb8OfDtt'Er3tolotir0, fcj^°"'*"°"° 
 panni Janii Cgnifies onlptooUcnCloatbs. 31But Bacon lufticc faio, all is but 
 tDOllcnCloatl],tl)Ougbtbcpbeof Dit)Erscolotir0,ano tbetcfoje it isgooD e- 
 nougb. Hodfdcn tbc ^cconoarp faio , fomctimcs tbe colours arc ufco to 
 be crpieffeo, ano fomctimcs not. Bacon, 3;t to better to erp?cfs tbc Colours 
 tban not, pet it is gooD cnougb toitbout tbc erpjcrsing of tbcm. Therefore lee 
 the Plaintiff take his lud^eraenr, 
 
 Willifon and Crow. 
 Micb* 23 Car. Banc- Regi 
 
 Willifon bjotigbt an action upon tbc Cafe againff Crow,foj fpcalu'.ig Arrcn rfiuJg. 
 tbcfc toojtjs of binn, You arc a bankrupt Skrub anD batb a tJCrDiC; it "enr ,„ ,„ j. 
 luasmotJCD in arrcft of SuDgement, tbat tbc Idojds arc not actionable, bC'*-'*'^" ^'ji^ 
 tanfe tbcp are jaDjcttiUetoojDs, anD fo are not poiititc cnougb to grouno'"""^'- 
 anj9ction. 15nt tbe Court bclD , tb'c^ lucre aaionablr,foj tbc U)o:d Banck- 
 rupt in it fclf teas not an aDic<titc , ano tbc jopning of it toitb Skrub maoc 
 it not fo, but it Qjoulo be unDcrCooo as mtitb as to fap, You arc 3 Skrub, and 
 alio 3 Baockrupt, And judgement was given accordingly. 
 
 The King againft Holland. 
 
 Hill. 23 Car,Bjnc. Reg« 
 
 nri^c Conrt DelibcrcD tbcir opinions in tlje Cafe faefinttn the King anb, , 
 •^ Holland fojmcrlp argucO; ano firff Bacon luftice falD, tbat tbcrc can be."v£"Jn"rVe 
 no 3!«Bgcmeiit,fo:. tbcrc is a mif-trpal in it; fo? firft, tbcrc is no Venire fa- Csfc between 
 cias : anD fcconDlp,tbcre isa Difcontinuancc, bccaufc tbe Venire QjouId beto''^'^ K.ngand 
 tctojn duodecero probes &lc£;ales homines quorum quilibethabet 40 s.lanDs'^'"""^* 
 bp tbc pear at the leaft, f it is cterp tf inborn, bating 4 1. lanDs bv tbc pear, 
 iBbitb is contrarp to tbc Direction of tbc statute. 2Eo tbisRolla'nflucrcD , 
 tbat be bclD tbe Venire to bc gooD,anD fo tbe trpal gooD, fo; if tbc inrp batb 
 ctjcrp oftbcm 41.3 peat in JLanos, be batb 405,^8 pear in i.anD0al leaft, 
 
 H 2. m9
 
 7 6 Hin.2 3 Car. 
 
 ano ntojc, aiio tbcrcfo^c it te a better Jutp, anu moje faffittcnt; ano bp 
 
 tbtB tbC toCrOiCt (ball not ibC tIttatCD, tbougl) ti^C Venire be not quorum quili* 
 bet habet 40 s. per annum ad minus, n0tbe &tatUtCDfrCtt0, aiio Ijccfteo 21 
 lac. PhilpotanorieldcrsCafc to bcfo aDiuDgco;anDbcfaio,t!jat JlanD0fni 
 
 Extent. tijc tjatiis ot a SDviiftcc map be ettcnocD foj tbe lifngs Debt , bnt ttjat ijc did 
 not£ontcft)cbolDtl)ci^tngcan Ijabc CCoppboloaanos tbat arc in ttuttfo: an 
 
 Stiur k\itn CaconlufticejSLtjcCommtfsfoncrotljat founotl^tfilntiHffitfonfouftc 
 
 "^' jstnnbaDnopotocr bptbcftCommifsfon tofchc tbc ILanBs into Hie iitngs 
 ^anbo but onlp to cnrjufrc lubat Lanoo t^c flltcn baO» The Court order- 
 ed tha\ ciufe (hould be fhewn Tuefday following, why the party fliail not be 
 rtftored to his Lands, which were fcifed into the Kings hands by vertue o:thc 
 Inquifuion, Poftca, 
 
 Hill- 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 ACiSrtt of (Erroj toac bjougbt to tebetfc a Jtibgcnicnt afbcn in an SiAU 
 on upon tbc Cafe , upon an AfTumpfir, brought bpttoo atMaydnonin 
 uiyKcmcm"in Kent , ano tl)c CxxQi afcignci) toas, tbat the piafntifs in tljcir Declaration 
 an Aftioii up- Do tap unde dixcrunt quod deteriorati lunt, 8cc. tobetcas it fljOulD bc unde 
 thcCifc. deteriorati funr, anb not dixerunt, &c. foj tbat is poGtibe, anotljeotbct 
 biccrtainiy. ^^^ ^ f^, jj^p ^gj, fj,p ^jjcj, arc DamnlficD , ano be not, ano tbete 
 ''' • can bc no trpal upon futb uncertain 100:03. Roll luflicefaiD, t1)c Uiojog 
 arc not tecU IniO; pet if tberckcrc other loo jos fnffUfent tocrpjcffctbc 
 bammagc tbc plaintiff Ijao rctcibeo it tuonlb be goob cnoagb, buttbcfc 
 tuojos here gobcrn the Icljole fentence ; Therefore ict the Defendant m the 
 Writ of Error confider how he can make the Declaration good. 
 
 The King sgainftv^avage* 
 
 Hill, 23 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 0/5c Savage tens arraignco in tbfj »JDourt upon an Cnufctmcnt of irclonr, 
 anhndift - foj k'H'Og of a VVoiT.jn within tfieV.erpc. SLbe triitbof tbc Cafe tDOS. 
 
 irnni foi' f i- ^e beat and wounded the Womsn at Leine Abby in Kenc,u!jf£bi3 iDttbin tlje 
 
 lony. Verge , but the »2S3oman open nt Scvenock in Kent , tobfc^ ifl out Of tbc 
 
 Verge. %\\z piifoncr pjapco tbc Court l)C migiit babe Walker of tbc inner= 
 Temple afoigncD bi!" foj Comiccl , fo; matter in tab), lubfcb tbc Court 
 nrantc3. Walker foj the pjifoncr, pjai's tbcCnbtrtment mapbcrcaD, 
 tobicb teas oonc accojbinglp; Cdbereupou tjc toot? tbcfc cptcptions to it, 
 1 . Sbat the Cnbiflnicnt botb not Ibeto upon tcbat part of tbc boop particai 
 larlp the ceioman leas Vi ounocb, but itfaitbonlpgencrallp, tbatittoag 
 upon tbc biuDcr parts of bcr HBobp. liy. 31 fapco tijc CSIoman bpeb dc di< 
 verfis plapis, but it Dotl) not ftcu) Of tobat length ano bjcattb tbc toounog 
 toerc, asitoug'ottobo, noj Boti) itfap ofiubfcb cftl)c toounosfbeDpcD 
 
 incaiain;y. Hiio fo It f0 uiKcrtafn , auD cannot be knoton iufjrtbcrtbcCulounDgtoerc-. 
 moital ojno. 3ly- 115p the Statute de ArticuiisfuperChartaj, intijisCafc 
 Itbctc tbc partp toac Irounoeo tuUbin tbeacrgc, ann bpco Uiitbout tbc 
 •JLlcrgc, tbcCo;oncroft!)caerge,anb oftbcCoimtp ougbttojopninta^ 
 lung tbc Jntiuifttion fuper vifum Corpoft , toWtbis not bcrc bone ; but tbc 
 
 ii quifiikv. ijiiquifitfon ii tahcn bp the Co? oner of tbc ciergc onlp. Bacon luftice faio, 
 tbc partp ig faio to bc (lain lubcrc be oiec, not ipbctc be tuag inounficD. Cbc 
 Court ojoercD tbc p?ifoncc to appear a tDceU after , ano in tbc mean time 
 
 to
 
 ___^ Hill. 23 Gar. 77 
 
 togfbcnotfcetotl)e!5tiigs<i;ou!iceloftftc ©rccpttone tafeen to tbe Cnotrt- 
 mcnt , ano Unoto to^ctber tijep totU maintain tfjc Cnoictment ; the fame 
 Term the Endidracnc was ad^'udged not good, and the party was bayled. * 
 
 Thyn againft Thyn. 
 Hill, 23 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Hill,2iCar. rot. idj8, 
 
 Dame Katherme Thyn bjfngs a <K3:rft of Dolncr hi tbe Commonplcas p. , •„ 
 againft &lt lames Thyn, anOftattj a actofct, am aBIuoscmcnt; tbev/'^iofV 
 JjDcfcnDant brings a Wixit of (iI;ttoj to rcDcrfc tl)ig 3!"Bgement in tl)(3 or. 
 Court, anQ afaigns foj Crroj; i. Jn tbe Hctoin maue bp t!]c &l}crtff, fo: ^■'■om. 
 ftc Dotfj ncrtfap, tfjat tbe pjoclamatfort loas maoe atttjc Cljurcb of tijc • 
 %o\an, iD^txc tije gammons toas maoc, anu a S>ummons upon a;ip one ^""="'^"'- 
 part of tl); JlatiD, as ftatb been oblecteD on tbc otljcr Goc, is not goa3, ncttbct 
 Ip tbe tDojog, noj tl)c intent of tbc Statute :fo: tljentbevcojoaint^e 
 Statute lioulD be farplufagc ano folc, t^at partirularlp .Ditcttg Ijoiu it fljoulo 
 be. J3nt) as to tbc £)bjcction,5Lftat a Summons upon one part of t^e ilano ^'^'°" °^ 
 <0gooDinft£tionoflLato,fojtl)ercCofttie3l.ano, SianftDer, Efeat tfjtsisc'"' . 
 not fo iD^crc tfje §>tattitc Dfrctts tbe Summons , ano tljc Idojds fecundum '*'"'"* 
 formam Statuti cannot Ijclp toljerc tfte §>tatute is not QjelncD to bz purfueo, 
 anDfofaft&DyerjSr^atfubftantialirojDsoagftttobcmentfoncD, Hill. 24 
 lac.Hob. PI, i79» Allen anO Walkers Cafe, 2ly. aCfjErE is C-tro:.rntI)cS>e. Demand, 
 niano of tftc BDoiu : r : fo; tl)C ccrtaintp of t^e SCitljcs DcmanocD ougbt to ap- 
 pear, ano ft Dot^ not fo fterc,ii Rep. Harpers (Cafe, f. 25* Sno foj tftat 
 ioljict) is faio in anttoer unto tfjis, 2nbata2)emanDofS)olDcri3 Different 
 from otfter SDemanus, 31 agree it to be trnc , 8. H. 6 5 . pet t!)E tWngs dc 
 manocD in ja^oUjermuftbeccrtainlpDemanoco, n H.y.r.zy. asitislnan 
 aCsife, foj an ^fsifc de uno tenemento is not gooo fo: tljc inccrtaintp, 4 E. Airifc. 
 2. Fitzh, Afsife, 45 1 . Cftoijcrs DemanDeD 0Hai)t to be fljeUjeo particu'larlp; 
 fo is it of a Cojroop, 1 1 E. 3. Fitzh. Dower, {{5. Dyer, f. 84. 7 F. 6. iPafc, 5 
 lac, t^eCountefs of Oxfords Cafe; ono iu^creas tberc liati) this otfFcrcnce 
 i)E£n tafeen betlDcen a SDemanQ of SDttljes in gtor0,an5 of 2Eit^cs appcnoant, 
 ano tljat JCittjcs in gtofs muff beparticularlpDcmanOeo, but it isnotne' 
 (CffarptorjemanoSCithcs appcnoant particularlp , 3ianftocr, SLbis is not 
 fo, fo; tbcitappenoanrpDotltniot maUetfjcmnottobe Demanoco partiru- 
 latlp, no'mojc ttjan if tbcp tocte in grofs, 1 8 E. 2 . Afsife, 377.0 <i:o;ro3p 
 muli be particularlp DemanDeo,anD all tbe iDjcixDents pjotic it, ano it toaa 
 fo bclD, Pafc. 8 Car. rot. 27r.in Bruer anO Drakes cafe in a torit Of Crroj in 
 t^tflilourt, uponajnogementgibcn in Dotocr in tfte Common^pleas, k 
 2d. exception to ttieSDemano of tljeSDoiDcr is t{)is, tbc tSHritofDotocris 
 deraanerio de Imber, anO tbeS^cmanO is OfDolDCC in parochladelmber, 
 ano fo it is larger tban tbc^rit : foj apariAjmapcompjeijcnomanp p,ri(K, 
 lUills.Stat. I H.5,C,y.22 E.^iC.2.Micb. 34Eliz,rot, 1537. Brad anOBu 
 fhops CafcintbeGrcbcquer, Pafc. 38Eliz. Bedel ano Scarborows Cafe in 
 an E^Aionefirroae in this Court. 5t is true, tijat gcncrallpa jJaiift Qjall 
 not be intcnoeo larger tban a mill , if tbe ccntrarp do not appear : but bcrc 
 tbe conttarp oot^appcar bp tbe toojos of tfjc SDemano, Icbicljarc de reftoria 
 dc Imber 8i Tymesbury infra parociiia de Imber, 3? & 4 Phill p &: Mary, Dy- 
 
 aL3 er, 
 
 I
 
 < 
 
 78 Hill. 23 Car- 
 
 ■" " cr. 14J. miD tbc Different penning ano crpjcfflton of tbc2?cmanD istobc 
 
 obfcrtict) : fo} bp tbat U appcaro t^crc is a Difference btttoccn Imber, ano tljc 
 
 ^r»nt- parini of Imber, Grants, Fiezh.Sy. bp pranting a JBannour \nitl) tljc aPP"rtc> 
 
 A itement. ^g„jj>g^ g„ aotoiBfon ioiH pafs, 1 9 E. 2. Tit. brief, tl)C mrit abateD, foj 
 
 *''*""■ tariancc bcttoait tbe (lEHrit anD t!)C «IDonnt» a 4th. CErroj is to atjoio 
 
 t&ccrccutfon, bccati'CoftfteCrroj in fait : foj tbe^^tmDjcoof Warmifter 
 
 Dotb crtcno to Sutton parva tobtcl) is not namcD in tbc ®3rit,anD fo tbc Dam^ 
 
 Dammaees. magcs are giben io% mojc tban is DcmanocD, anD it fliaU not be interpjtteo 
 
 iniciixiinept. ^^ jntenomcnt , anD tbc ii)unD jec is not oemanDCD : fo j tbc Hill relates to 
 
 tbc JLanDanD nottotbc^unDjcD, (5E. 5. 12. 8 Rep. 119. Bonhams Cafe, 
 
 ano p:apB 3uDgement fojtbe plaintiff in tbc tUSrit of Crro;. Maynard 
 
 of Councel with the Defendant defired time to argne , and it was granted, Po« 
 
 fiea. 
 
 Cli a m b ers aga i n ft V VoUafton, 
 
 Hill, 23 Car, Banc. Reg» 
 Mich, 22 Car, rot, 21, 
 
 Dcmuiicrup-/^"<Harober5 bjougbt an ilttion of ^ffault anD 315atterp , anDfalteimpii* 
 
 on the Cu. V^fonmcnt againawoIlafton,WollaftonpleaDsarpecial picaof 3iuftift- 
 
 doiT picadeT '^"°" ' '^P tiirttic of a Cuftom in tbc Citp of London , utjcrebp be bao aa= 
 
 * tbo^tti' to taUe anD imp jifon bim foj cifttirbing an Clcaion of MarDcns of 
 
 a Companp, anD unttll be tooulD p:omirc not toDffftirbfucbCI^lcttfonsaf* 
 
 tertoarDs. 2Co tropica tbc paintlff Demurs, anD taUesthcfcCrccpti* 
 
 Cuftome. ons, I. SCbc Cuffom plcaDcD ifiagainft iLaiD,foj it appcars not tbat tbcrc 
 
 toasanp fittc Dcpcnoing cttber fap IBill, oj CEnoictment , oj otbctUjire^no 
 
 fo tbc Cuftome is againft %a\i\ Star. 25 E, 3. C. y, 25 E. 3. C, 3. anD fo 
 
 teas tbc petition of l^igbt, 3 Car, ^nD tboagb tbc Cuftoms of tbc Citp of 
 
 London arc confirmeD bp &tatutc-Iali), pet illegal Cuftoms arc not confic* 
 
 ludgcraci.t. tnco. 2ly. SCbc BluDgcmcnt is againft ILato, foj bptbE 3IuDgemcntnorc» 
 
 incDp is ^iUn foi tbc offence committcD totbcpartpagalnftlu!!omitfs 
 
 committD , but onlp tbat tbc offcnDoj Ojall be impjifoncD untill be pjomifc 
 
 not to Difturb elections again. 3ly. 2Ebc partp committcD is not tcitbin tlic 
 
 Cuftom bptbeSDcfcnnantsoton fbctoing. 4ly, SCbc Cuftome fetfoif^ 
 
 is not pjofecutcDcfo; tbc commitment is notfejtbc 2i)ifturbance, but be- 
 
 taufe tbc partp toill not p jomife not to Difturb again, 5 iy, SCbe Detenlr* 
 
 on of tbe partp in pjifon is againtt Eato, Hales of Councel with the 
 
 Defendanr, defired time to argue, and the Court defired to have Books. 
 
 Holdigh again ft Chace, 
 
 Hill, 33 Car, Banc. Reg^ 
 
 Pafc, 33 Car. rot, 326, 
 
 -.1 
 
 A fpcciaivcr. Ll01<3iQh bjougbt an action of jEDebt agninft Chace, as an C!;VCCUfo?,'ipon 
 d a upon JrXan £)blfgation maoc to tbc 2Cettato j. 2Ebe SDcfenDant pleaocD non eft 
 Nn„ cfl fx- faaum,ano npon tbi0 pica an 3iffuc inao f opneD,anD a fpccial sicrDict founO; 
 uTT'i-ord "P"" ^^"'' ulcrDict tbc Cafe appcareo to betbis, aUfjc ^cfenoant Chace 
 
 toas
 
 Mich> 2 3 Car. 7^ 
 
 foas boutto in an oWigatfon fo; tfjc papmcnt of a certain fum of moirp onto 
 A. B. ano to I. S. jopntlp. I. S. opus, A. B. futtjitcs . aiitj maUca Hoidigh 
 bfd Crccuto?, ano ores, Holdij^h bjttigs an 0ctton of Debt in Ijts oton name 
 agafntt Chace tl)c SOefcnDanr, anD cetlarcs upon tl;t3 obltaatton maoe to 
 tlje SCcftato:, ant) to 1. S. anD Dott) not abet tl)at tlic 2Ecttato: m furtfbc r. 
 S. 2LJ)eJDefcnt)antplcat)snontil- t'adum, ano tijc qurftion toae toljctljct 
 tbi3 be a gooD pica o; no , ano to pjobc tbat it ta no cooo pica , but tbc^t it pica. 
 teas tl)C ureo of tlje 2?cf enoant. t^c viHounccl fo: tlje |3latnttff citco tliefc 
 bool;0, 5(5H.6.4. 5 5 H.6. fol. 39. 46 E. 3. 7. '4 f. i . foi. 4. tS E. 2. 
 2. anD put tWs cafe. 2CtOO cnfantejopntcnants alien, ano one Dies; snjje 
 furtitjct biingsadumfuit infra aetattm , ant) counts of tbc J^cofmcnt of 
 one of t^cm , ann tliere tfje tigftt toas aojuogcu not to be f cfcreo bv tljc jFes 
 offcment , anD fo tbc tojit gooo , ano in our cafe tfje matter of Variance al= 
 IcgcD goc3totbctojft.anDncttfje0(tion, anoitisnoLo too late foj t!je 
 2DcfenD'a«ittotat5caDt)antagcofit,anDp?8)>cs3Eut>Scmcnt foj tbc plain* 
 tiff. Roil luflice faiD, tbe iiTiie is tobctfjer it be tbc SDcfcnaants dccd oj not, 
 anD toitbout Doubt it is bis ceeo , and thereiore ice him fhew caufe why the 
 Plaintiff fliould not have ludgeraent. 
 
 Boone aoainfi: Sheers- 
 
 Hill. 33, Ba, Reg, 
 Ttin, Jj Car. ror. 288, 
 
 BOone fajougrtjt an action of 2?cbt npon an obligation of 400 I. agafna Demurrer to 
 Sheers, anD Dcclarcij tbat tbe conoition of tbc obligation ioas , tbat tbe * ^'"='- 
 SPcfencant fljonlo mahc fucb a topage tcitlj a S>bfp , anD pap certain mo= 
 npesat bis return, ano otber conoitionsmentionea, ano foj not petfojming 
 tbeconcitionsbebjingsbis aaion. SLbe ©efcncant pleaos in bar tbat 
 tt)c §?b{p Vcas taken in tbc t>opage p«r homines beilicofos, ano DcmanogPica. 
 JnDgemcnt of tbc Action : 2Eo tbis pica tbc plaintiff Dcmurreo, ano fljeto- 
 CD foj caufe tbat tbe plea Dio not gi\je anfiicr to all tbc Declaration. Yard Demurrer, 
 of Conncelliritb tbe SDcfenoantfaio, tbe pica teas cooD; foj tbc plea an= 
 riDcrs tbc tobolc conoition of tbe J5onD, tobicb toas firft to maUc tbc tjopage 
 toitb tbc &btp, ano tben at bis retom to ptrfojm tbc otbcr conDttions , ano 
 being binDjcDin tbc one, be toas not bounD to pctfojm tbe otber. Bacon 
 lufticC, L?t us fee a book to confidcr of, 
 
 Royfton againft Mees. 
 Hill 23 Car, Banc. Reg, 
 
 ROyOon ninUcs a leafe foi pears of certain lanDs fo I. S rcnoiing rent, ^^rfft of 
 tbe Icffce makes btstoill, ano maizes Mees tbe Defcnoant bis ©recti- '"^*K^'"«'it \n 
 toj , anD Dpcs,tbe C^recntoj poffrffctbbimfclf oftberemainDcr of tbc term 
 oftbelanDslct, anD after tbe rent is bebino. Royfton bjings anflttton of 
 2Dcbt aciainft tbc Dcfcnoant, anD Declares againft bim fo; tbc rent fo bebino 
 in tbe debet anD oetinet , anD upon tWs anlcTiic ie jopncD, ano a bcrDia fo> 
 tlic plaintiff, SCbe SDefcnDant moties in arrcft of Juogcmcnt , ano Qictos n. 1 
 fo; canfe tbat tbe Declaration is not gooD, becanfe tbc i?lction bting an 9a. "^ ""^'O"' 
 fun of Debt bjongbt againft tbe DcfcnDant, as an C-rcciitoj,ft ougbt to bate 
 been fn tbc detinet, ano not in tbc debet ano detiner, JSiUVViid of Coun^ 
 
 ecu
 
 8o Mich. 2 3 Car. 
 
 cell tnftl) tljc piafnttf arsncD tf) at flje SDcclaratfon toac gooi> , anu tJje Set, 
 ion iucU biougbt in tlje debet ano detinct , anu citcD Brook title crtiiisuffl>= 
 mcnt J 4' ^"0 tftc comment :5a6,ani) fa(D it ta an i!aion founoeo apoit a Uafe 
 Lp oeco toftic!) loas ?nadc bp tfte 2Dcffatoj, anD cltcD 20 H. 6. i o H.y.fol.jo. 
 aiiD tbat it in tbe conttant fo jm of cljargtng Crccatoje (n fuct) cafes, 14 H, 
 4.fol. 29,Firzh.Tir. refponder,7 E. <>. Dyer «i. 10. rtp. 118. 0nOfafOtftc 
 tJctDid 6atl) fonno U (ti tlje debet anD dccinet toljtc!) Iball be tntcnoco to be 
 tnic,9 Ed. 4. 41 . *7 J3c» Paul and Mordyes Cafe (n tijc Common plcaa, ano 
 7 lac. Smith and Nicholas Cafe, anDpMPCB ^ucgcmcnt fo; tbc plntnttff^ 
 Hales foj tbc SDcfcnnant arciico t^at tfte Declaration fs not gooD. i. l^e 
 fato, tbci^cttonfagooDfntljcdetiner, bccaufc tlje profits of t^elano let, 
 teWcf) arc otjcr aiiD abotjc tt)c rent to be pa<D foj it.refcrtjeo upon tbc leafc, 
 
 Dffcicnc-. fijaUbeonlt'affctsfntljc<!l;j:ecatojo5]anDs. 2. 3t cannot be gooo botl? 
 
 Contrjib. tuaj^ics, ano tl^ESncTm Is fnftfm 33 ?I;rcctito;i, not t^e rent, anotftcrc is a 
 Difference brtiucen contracts Cj:ecuto;j', ano contracts CtectiterijOut ft mag 
 be fafD.tlic rent to be paiD map be mo je tftan the pjofits of tftc lano is \xso:% 
 3!8nftDcr,tW8fl)allnotbep?cfumcoinlalDifitbenotfo(!}etoct). 43 AfT, 
 pi. 23. 16 H 7. fol. X. %\)c action is b?oug!)t foj all tljc rent incurrcD ; 
 tl)crefo?c it ftiall not b~c pjcfnmeo tbat the lano is not Uiojt^ t^e rent that is 
 
 Vcrd.a ^^^^ ^^^ ^^ ' ^"° ^° ^"^ ^^^ ^"^''^ *^ ^^^^ '"^•P notl)fng; fo; a berofct Ojall not 
 ftipplp a netcffarp part of a Declaration omftteo, ano iffjcoUjcstben bene, 
 tains, anD3iconceit3cHargravcsCafctobegooD=lLato, tftotigt) ocnpeo bp 
 tlje Coanccll on tbe otbcr fioc.ano Ijere tl)c p:lbttp of tbc contract is not oc^ 
 tcrmincD, ano fo p?apc3 Juogcment fo; tbc Defcnoant. Roll luf^ice , 31t 
 is foj tbc aotiantagc of tbeCrccuto? to bjingtbeiaafon in tftc detinct; foj 
 tbcn be fl[)iill be cbargeo onlp fo; tbe gooos of tbc aScftatoi , ano not fo'? bis 
 p joper gooos, ano it map be tbc lano is leffc too jtb tban tbe rent, ano tbat 
 tfje partpes bate confenteo t^e Action IbonlD be b joagbt in tbis maner. Ba* 
 con luflice cftCD Pawls CafC Mich. 17 lac. 315ut cnttCti Pafc. rot. 346. SCbat 
 tbc action map be bjougbt in tbc debet ano dctinet, ano if tbe paintiff toill 
 bjing bis action bere in tbe detinec it is not foj pour oifaotantage, ano bt 
 map at bis election bjing ft eitbertoap. RoUiuftice, !^crc ibe tjcroict an- 
 riuers tbe point of tbe ifTiic, ano tbcrefojc is gooo. The Court ruled the 
 Plaintif to take his lud gemeni:? except better caule (hewn to the contrary. 
 
 William againft Tyrer. 
 
 Hill. =3 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Paic. ajCar. rot.224. 
 
 Antft of \7\7 ^'''^"^ biouflbtan action of aCrotirt ano Conberfion againtt Ty 
 
 lu.'gfmcnt in V V rcr foj Certain gooDs Of tbe piatntifftbc piaitttiff batb a tcroict, 
 
 Covenant, jrjjg jjefcnoant moljeo in arreft of Suogcmcnt , ano tooU tbcfe exceptions 
 
 to tbc Declaration, i, 2Cbc plaintiff Declares pro tribus duodenis fill , 
 
 ucciaracion. Anj^lice DofcHS of tbjeaOjtobtcbis inccrtain; fo: it map be tbjce oofcn potmo 
 
 oftb?caD,o; cUcncBoftbjcaDjOjounceBoftbjcao.EotbisitUiasanflECcxD, 
 
 tb at it cannot be otbertoife crpjcffco , ano tbc toojos oofens of tbjcao is u= 
 
 feoamongftSBcrcbants, anotocUhnoton unto tbcm tobat is meant bp 
 
 tbcm. jlp. ^c occlares fo; fo nianp pounts Mulcat, in fieao of Nucum 
 
 Mufcatsrum, Anglicc jphutmcgs. But tbis exception teas mfftaUen, fo; tbe 
 
 r cco;o toas otbertoifc . ano beftocs it toas toitb an Anglice tobicb makes it 
 
 certain. Tlic Court rulc4 ludgctnentto be entred except cauie Ihcwed for 
 
 the Plaintif. 
 
 Raw*
 
 Hill, 2 3 Car. 8i 
 
 Rawfon againft Bargue. 
 
 Hiir.ijCar. Banc, Reg» 
 
 'T' ^c Cafe bcttocen Rawfon anu Bargue being an i^dfon of 2Dcbt i Argument? 
 -^ upon ttie Statute of a E. 6. foj not fftttnc fojtl) of 2L<tt)C0, irbstctn up- w.-cmtr a free 
 on a fpectall tictoW, tljc quettlon teas uljctljer tlje Cljiircl) lucre a free Clja.^'Vi''^' °' "; ' 
 pel gttjcn to tbe iiinot , \omn t\)c Statute of i Ed. 6, teas agatn argueo fap ""^ 'Jinion/ 
 Latch foj tfte plaintiff , anD bp Brown fo> t\fz Dcfcntant , Latches argu= 
 went tuas to this effect, i, ^c fafo, that the i.aiD fapes it io pjcfcntatitje 
 although it be not ; ano sip, 3It is fufficicntlp founo to be a parochial 
 Church, pet it is not material inhcthcr it be fount) fo oj no. j^cpt the tuojDs 
 of the Statute do not cttctio to site Donatives to the toing. ^Ip. 5t is not 
 gttien to t!)c Croton, ano althouah Ujc SDcclatatlon ano bcrtsict be that it is 
 a free Chapell , pctitisnotcomp;ehcnocDasa Ct-apcl p^cfentatibe. Lit- 
 94. aChetoojD free makes a Difttnction of things, ano the partp ought net 
 to confounD ttings, ano a free Cliapcl is altoarcs tRterpicteo foj a Church rrcc ciiapcJ. 
 Donatitie,anD not pjefentatiVe. 2Ehc right inbcfliturc of Churches toas thal- 
 IcngcD from the founoation of tbcm, untill toithin tUs 400 ^ears it teas al= 
 tcreo bp the Common lain ; Scidens l^lttojp of SDithes, fol, 39:. nno "pon 
 that alteration the name of a free Chapel came. Reg.41.3it is faio to be 
 free from ECclcCaQicalljurifDiction. Fi(z. tit. Brief 60. 3 Ed. ^.Fitz. Tit: 
 Aydeduroy 33. 14H. 4, II. 22H. 6, 45. 21 H-d.iy. bp Oanbyejg H. 6. 
 Fitz, grants. ijMat. brev. 33 1. 34. f. 27 E. 3. 84. Cowels interpjetOJ, 
 Tit. free Cljapel. 0no in all Statutes the taojolree Chapel is meant of 
 Conatibes. Stat. 26 H. 8, cap, 3, Stat. 57 H. 8. cap. 4. Stat, i Ed. 6, cap. 14. 
 Regift. 307. 315ntiti3 0bjecteDthatfrceCl;apelscvtcnt) to p:.efentntibCB,p,fn;rtaiior; 
 bccaufe thep are irith cure, Lie. Com. 344. a Donatibe map be parochial, 7 E, Donative 
 3. f, 4i Co this 31 anftoer , Chnrchcs hao cure of fouls, inhen thep tocrc 
 Donatibes. %o the 2d. poi!'t,bp the meaning of the Statute it appears, tljat Tcr urc 
 onlpDonatibCfltoercintrnoco.asthepjcnmblcofitODt!) ceclarc; i3nD aUi-ra.,k- 
 Chapels arc helD in Frarkalmoigne aslEcUasconatit'cs, ap.3foallmap^''""'£"«' 
 be gibcn to the teing bp t!)e fame reafon. SinoWfU objection is that the 
 toDjoCapeilaisfupcrffitious, anOtl)crefoje beingof a uipcrCitlouiS foun» 
 nation it is gibcn to the liing , ano Cowels 3;ntcrp;ctoj is urgeo to pjote 
 the tDOjO to be fo Dcribeo, Co this 3i anfiLCr, that Sir Henry Spelman as 
 learneoan^uthojasCoweli, inhis gioffarp rejects Cowclls Beribation of 
 the too jD Capelia , anO faith that Ca pells is ufco pjomifcuouGp fo; ar,\> up' 
 per cEibcring; Slno t!;ouah t!)c name >Dcre fuptrftittous, pet ttjat mal.cs not 
 the Chapel to be fo ; fo; fo t\}z Church of St, ' ndrew , 0; Sr. Dunrtan , 
 fljoulfj be fuperff itictis , anc giben to the l^fng bp the Statute. Chcrc is a 
 Double picamble of the Statute, 1 . 3 rccitall of anotljer Statute. anD the Prrambie. 
 taUing atoap of other fupcrCitioucufes, ^Djeamblc of the Statute, 37 H. 
 8. 2 2 Ed 4. c?p.7. 8. rep. i37.beaftsofti)ci^o;EttareiiotCr>ttel,* 5. rep. 
 Che marques ofWinchefters Cafe, Com. 204. Chat fomc generals map be 
 tabcn in a rcttjamca f-;ncc, 9 H. 6. 36. ©Hojde of a Statute oucht not to be inrerprcat:- 
 intcrpjetcc to Dcftrop ndturall Suffice. Chcftilealfocfthc9ilDothnoton. 
 fljeto that Donatibes arc onlpintcnDcD, anotheCroUin bath not grantee 
 thfsatoap, 3 7 H. 8. ano fo not DclfropeD them. SDonatttes ufuallp pa£f« acf 
 lap fees.auD the pafsing of them as lap fees alters not the nature of thcCba* 
 pells, anDtl;c,Statutegibcs(ttoihciHinga5 the incsimbertt Ijao it. anOLa .cr 
 
 SB there
 
 8 2 Hiil • 2 5 Car.""" 
 
 tbcte is a fating of tbc nature oFjt fit t!)c statute. 3Itt3 obiettcD, fftat ftc 
 ftatlj not been piCfenteOr.itionelapfu;, SCotljfsHob, 337. in Greens (TafC 
 sites an anflner , ano Poners Cafe 9 Car. in tljc Common picas. anD it is 
 iDcll founol)crcintl)ctetoi(tfo;t|)ci3lafiuiff , aCljatit is not Urftbin the 
 statute. Brown fo: tbc JDcfcnoant in l)ls argument faio, tf)c qucftfon is 
 tol)ct!)ct ft be a free vibapcl, (jf ben bp tljc Statute of i Ed. 6 . ano ». St fs 
 loftbiii tbc loojosoftbcx)tatute J ant zip. 3t fs teftljfn the meaning 0/ 
 tUc&tatiitC; fojtbelDojDjtbcparciimplicicur generalia, ano fo large as 
 £nn be , auD all Cbapcls arc niten bp tbem , ano none cifccpteD. at:D*f)crc 
 I. Cbc nature of a free CtjapcUftitobcconfiDcrcD ; J?oj Cowel be fs 
 c^wcu ^^o^.noxfiitoijzdit^^ fo:bi8boolUuaBconDemiic3bp parliament, anD burnt 
 D vers fonj ci ^'i' crroncous , anD rcanaalou3,fn 4 E, j. 28. Peeter Corbecs Carr,a Ctapcl 
 Chai'cls. iopartofaCburtI), S H.<5 32. jy.Bradon 1^1, i7Ed. 3. 58. 9 Ed. 3. 1 1. 
 tbcfc arc not iuitbfn t!)c S>tatute of 1 t d.6.2lp.2Lljercf6 Capella parocliialis 
 tobicbi3fub(crttotl)EjurifDi£tionofthc£);Dinarp, 14 E.3.Firz,quareimpe» 
 dit 183. L^nw-ood 142.8 Ed. 3 do.Cbe booU of cntrpCS 541. Lonj» quinto 
 26' 3'.i'. CTbauntrp fs tnUcn fo; a «IbaucK 4lp- SI free Cbapcl is 
 nomen comprelicnfivum , anD compicbcnDsmucb, 13 AfT, pi. 2. 15. AIT. pi. 
 8. JEbccffcntialmattcr ofafriC^CbApplistobcfrccfromojtfnarp furir« 
 Birtfon. ano not tobctiGtctbptbe£I)jDinarp,antonccom06rcgnlarlpto 
 a frccCbapclbp tonatton,butbeingin,bcfsfrccfromojDinarp lurifoicti^ 
 on^iS E. 3. Fitz. (cire fac. ] i. 17 E. 3. f. 45- Brook pracrnun. 21, 3ltl)at!) 
 been obiecteD tbat it is pjefcntatitc . ano fo ft is not free; 31 anftocr ft map 
 be frectbaugbitbepjcfcntatite .anofo tbc terolrt flnos ft to be in tbc 
 founoatfon of ft. 2tp 2Cbe pafntiff bjingstbc action as llcctoj of a free 
 Cbapel , ano iwto be fl)all not be fufferco to ocnp bis oion 2Dcclaratfon,3lp, 
 2Cbc aomffsfon. inftitution , anoinouaion implpcs jurisDittion till tbc con- 
 trarp appear, viz.tbatitisafrccCbapel notititbttanotng it be pjcfcnta- 
 titc, 16 E, 3 . Fitz. brief (5^0. j|5onc but tbe iliiig can founo a free Cbapel , 
 , . anoaltbougf)itbcfrecbi'p:efcTiption,pEtitfl)aUbeiiitEnoco tobe at firtt 
 louncaiion. fo fojiiiQeo. inititur. 44. p H. 6. f. 17. 20 E. 3. 56. SLbc liiug bp fomiDa* 
 tion of a free Cbnpcl, map grant tbat it fliall be p jcfcntatitc , ano p: t iubcii 
 tbc partp is In, tb^t ft fi)all be free from tbe furisoiction of tl>c (jDjoinarp . 
 lurTd^a-or ^^^^' ""•'"■■4S. C. Sbbeocanof B.utelinSufl"cxi3p;crcntatitctotbc Wli-- 
 tarageofB-urelbptbcBiftopofChichefter; but Vobcn be is in, be fs free 
 from tbc jurifotction of t!;C £>:0!narp,Davyef Rep. fo. 72. Cooks inftjt. 344» 
 fl lapfc map incur of a free Cb«pcl bp tbc founoation of a free Cbapel,3 j E. 
 g.foJ. 3.i7E.3.fol.5i- 17 E. 3.fol i2.2Elje founoatton of a tbingmapal- 
 tertbcla\i',7 E.3,fo. iS.2CbcolO boolt 316. SLbe effential Difference of a 
 free Cbapel from anotbcr, iijtobefrcc an^ercmpt from tbc jurffoictton 
 Oftbs ilDjDfnarp, 17 E.3.clorerolI in theTower.Seldens book oftithfS44i. 
 regiO. 40, 4 1 . Pafc. 3. ]ac. in tbis iCourt Fachell anO Gaires CafC. 2Lberc 
 arc titers injfts in our books to offcbargc free Cbapcls from tfStations , 
 ano tbcrcfojc ft appears tbep are ercmpt from tbc jQjofnarics Jnrifofrtion. 
 515ut it is objctteD tbat tbc pjcfcntation mahes it pjefentatfte , tbougb it 
 ii3ercnotfobcfo:c. SCbisfsanftocrco, 14E. Fitz- 9 E. 3 i. 27 E. 3r34. 
 3iVfs not tbc pjcfcntation maoc bp tbc pattp, but tbc founoatfon tbat tiiahes 
 it pzcferttatite. alp. 3t is obicctcD tbat it is parocbfal, anD tbcrcfojc fs not 
 free ; 31 anflDcr, ft fs not fo founo altbougb ft be fo clafmco, ano tbougb ft be 
 fo claimco ft matjcs notnf ng to tbc puipofc. Sl^bc parf fij Cb ycb cf sTr. Ma« 
 ryes fn Shrewsbury tuac parocbfal, ano pet gftcnfotbc iiftig bp tbfs &ta. 
 tutC, I' H. 4. Fitz. brev. 807. Hi!; 17. lac. 'n tbiS Court in Grubbam anO 
 G^lcsCafcaDiuogcD, tbataCbapclmapbcfounOeofn a pnrifl) Cburcb, 
 -ano fucb arc gf ten to tbe lung. Dyer 2^7. o Car. Pale, in tbc Common 
 picas Rawlins ano Yaxlyes Cafc. I'-P j^JJj tbc Itjojosoftbc statute tbfs is 
 Molonc of tbc frccCbapclge)jceptfOfntljcStatutc,anDtbcrcfojcft fg tuitb^ 
 
 in
 
 ' Hill. 13 Gar. iJ} 
 
 ill t\ic Statute, ano tftcte appears no tffitatton fn f':c tcrnfrf founo, ana ex. 
 
 ccpcio in non exceptis format regulam. foi Hit mcantng of tbc S»tat. Brook in-rprcttion 
 prebend, i d.io.rep.ii?. 311 parts of a atatutc cjigfttroftanD tccetl)crtf<t 
 map be, ano one part of it ouolit not to Dcftrop anotljct part.generalc didum 
 jjcneraliter eft intelligcnoum ; Slfte erccptfons ot tbc Statute Qjeuj tl)C mea* 
 ni«gofft, 3t<0obtc(ico,tftattl]cbc(ngafrccCl5np'lmal;cgitnot to be 
 fupcrtt(tlotw3 anrU)cr,ff ft be a frccCljapcl bp-Conrmon fntcnnment it is fu= 
 perft<tioa«,but tbougb (( It be not.j-ct It is gibcn bp tbc name of s frccCbapd. 
 ^plbc tjcrclitit toactnUcnfo:afrcc <£l)apel, anutbatitluas felfcD Into 
 tDe iafiigs bancs. Jtberc Is mtitb Itgljt to be bat) in interpietatlon of lateo, 
 bp confultlng toltbtljorc tt)at maoe tb.;m , ano to Unoio Ijoto tl)cp bao Inter* 
 p;etcO tbcmjfo; expofitio coRCcmporanea ef> optima. Plow. 466. Pafc.j y EI. 
 Clar}^ ano Mark 111 tbc Common p'.cas. 3; it be rot a free Chapel, ret 
 being founo fo , It fliall be taken to be fo in reputation , ano rr.oiigb to gj^jc Rspu.-atkn. 
 It to tbe ClOlOn : ^anDtbepiercntatlontoltlsadredonamnve libcram'ca. 
 pellam.anblo not certain, ano fo it Is not a gooD pjefer.tatlon.bicayfc t*^c p^^f ,,j„- 
 jilngtoasnotrlgbtlpenfojmeDluIjatlttoasbcpjcrenteBto.RegiO.foUoj. " "" • 
 19 E. 3 Fitz.quar. imped. ?<5o. ant) fopjapes Jucgcmsntfo J tbc plaintiff. 
 Roll Iui>ice,JLt)ere 10 a Difference tobcre a Cl)ap:ll is founoco toitbin a 
 C\imt\), ap?s fobcre tbc Cbnpel Is parocbfal. B«on luHite bdi) , tijat it 
 ujas gibcn to tbe King bp tbe Statute ; foj it Is founo to be a Cbapel pap- 
 Ing tentbco, anO tbls Statute looks bacfeU.art) to tbe Statute of 37 H g.aiio 
 to tbingo In being , ant tl)e Cbapel teas toftbfn tbat St atute , ano bp It be 
 migbt b^tic fcifco it , ano it Is ulthin tbc too jos, ano intent al'o of tbc Sta- 
 tute of i Ed. (3. ano tbc p?obiro of tbe Statute lljetoa tbe meaning of It , 
 ano Capellae depetidente $, oj Cbapcls of cafe arc not gitcn bp tbe Statute. 
 Roll luftice to tbc fame Eflfcct, ano falDjEEbis Statute of I Ed.<s. toac maoe 
 to fupplp fomctblng omitteo In tbc Statnlc of 37 H. 8. ano It Is plain , tbat 
 Itlfi toitbin tbc toojDs, antj toe tabe no Jearrant to Interpret it otbcrtoffc, 
 Cnce It Dotb not appear tbat It is erccpteo ; alfo It Is not foimo to be a pa= 
 rfflj Cburcb, but tbat tbcp claim It to be fo, ano If it teerc It tooulo not bclp. 
 alp. St mapbepjcfentatlbe, anDpctafrecCbapelaccoaolngtotbcfoun- 
 oatlon, anocnQotomcntofIt, anb a free Cbapel, map become a Cbarc!) 
 bp pjefentatlon of tbcpatroti,but it appcarc not to be fo to us. SCbe pjoblfo 
 oftbc Statute fljctos tbat It toas not tbe Intent of tbe Statute-, to crempt 
 all free Cbapels, but tbofc onip tobicb arc nameD,anD no mojc : jginb tbe ln= 
 tcnt of tbc Statute toas tbat tbc iSIng (ball babe it as a lap tbing , ano be 
 toaa not compellco to pjcfent . ano bcre tb: |i)atron batb taken tbc p:ofits , 
 ano tberc arc nolnbaWtants toitbin tbc |3ariQ), fo; tbc felgro; j' comp:ifctl) 
 all tbc parlO) , anb If tbc King p?cfents bp lapfe toberc be ounl/t to do it pie* 
 no jure, tbc pjcfcntatfon Is not gooo. ^Foj tbcfc reafons, The Judge- 
 ment was given for the Dcfcndanr, if bcucrinatcer be not flKwn before tbe 
 end of the Term, 
 
 Fulham^ 
 
 Hill 13 Car. Banc, Reg." 
 
 FUlhara batJ aBlnDgcmcnt In tbffl Court agalntt 3 DcfcuDants ,tlto of tbe ". sotwitiv 
 ©efenoants bjing a tojit of erro; In parliament. Fulham tbat bao tbe'^'"''"? » 
 juogmcnt mobes tbe Coart,be map babe execution uptn bis juogmcnt t\oul'^'°lX'°'
 
 84 Hill. 2 5 Car. 
 
 toltWtanDfnB tljc Mdt of Crm b jougW f n laatKamcnt, be cnufe tijc llcto jo 
 
 {0 not tocll tcmoDcD, fo j tbc Mrit of Crtoj is net cooo, foj tfte Juogcmcnt 
 
 ffl ngafnfttbja , anothetsarltofCrroj mcntfona btitttoooftbcm. Roll 
 
 iaftice, 3 Doubt pou cannot babccpccntfon, biittbcCarIt ofCrrojmuft 
 
 Ab Jienient. ic abatcD <n parltamcnt , ano tljcn pot! map come bete ann motie ioi ejce» 
 
 Execution, ciitfon , fo J nolD U (0 not fafc to grant (t . Move it in Parliamenc to have it 
 
 abatedjOc move here again at your own adventure. 
 
 The King and Holland. 
 
 Hill, J 3 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 l-or an Amo 
 vcssmsnum 
 toths Clian- 
 ceiy 
 
 IiP tbffl Cafe bctiDccntbcKingano Holland, after ufbcrsargtimentfl at 
 tbe 515ar, ano tbe opinion of the -loart Delitjcrco, SCfje Court Voaa moticD 
 fojan Amovea«roanumto tl)C Cbancerp, tbattbepartp map babe btslLanD 
 Amovcas ont of tbc i^fngs baniJ. The Court anfwered,2rbe3!uDBement (stobe^jlbcn 
 nunum. ^cre , ff tbctc becaufcfo; tbc lafng. <fnotaaafnftWm, ano pou ongbt not 
 to go to tbe Cbanterp. And allthatwecaniayi», that the King (hall not 
 ludgemcnt. ^^^^ jadgement- 
 
 Fiill. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 For 
 
 a 
 
 -or qui(hing *T'i^e Cotirt inas mobeu fo quat&anG-nMrtmcntoffojcf'^lcCSiifrpupon 
 ,n .Lnd:d- -I t^efc €)cccpt(on0. 1 . 2Cbat U Dfo not fap , tbat tbe fojtf ble Gntrp Idss 
 '?*^"'' contra Coronam & dignitatem, but tbfs tbc Court oticr-rulcu. SifCConD 
 
 ejccptfon toas , 2Ei}at(tDotb not QjeU) tbat tbe partp inas fcffcD at tbe tf me 
 untUl tbe SPefcnoantcntrcobpfojcc upon b<m. jlp. tLbc Giiofrtmcnt con« 
 cluDe0, contra formam Statuti, anO ft ougbt to be ftatutorum , fo} tbc Sta- 
 tute Of 8 H.6. upoittobfcbtbfsGtmfctmcnttoframct), relates tootbet&ta* 
 tutes. aCotbta tbc Court fafD, If tbc Cntifamcnt befo itisiW, 4ly. SDbe 
 Endiamcnt. «EnDf ctmcnt faUb, be entreo peateablp ano octatneo toftb fo?ce, anD fucb an 
 enDlctmcnt batb telatfon to tluo S>tatutC0. JTo tbfa it vcao anftocrcD, tbat 
 tbe Statute of 8 H. 6- 10 fuffiticnt to fotmu tbe Cnoirtment tnttbout telatfon 
 tootber &tatute0,fo;tbiaclaufcnpontDbfcbt!;<g enolctmcnt loframcDja 
 a neiDlLaiD, ano batb no relation to p J eccDcnt Statutes, foj Ufsbcrconlp 
 fo;t a fojdble oetepner- Roll Juftice Donbtco oftbfs, foMtlfifalo, tbat tbc 
 Statute of 8 H. 6 fball be aoocD to tbc ncU) Statute. Bacon luftice ulffcrco 
 In opinion ano fafo, tbe Statute of 8 H. 6. toao not maoe to piece up tbe o- 
 tbct StatntCjbnt (0 a neto 3iaiD ag to tblsclaufe. The Court will advife fur- 
 ther. 
 
 Chambers againft VVolladon, 
 
 HilU 23 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 Tl^fs Cafciuao again mobcn ano arguco bp Ward of Councci toftb tbe 
 piainffff. 2Cbe 0(tfon toac aniJctlonof affault ano JSatterp, am* 
 wpcn a ip""'faifj; fmpnfonmcnt. Ebc Dcfcnoant plcaoeo a fpeclal Suftiftcatlon fap bct- 
 "* tuc of tbe Cuttom of tbc Cltp ; iCo toblcb ^niea tbe plaintiff ocmutreo, 
 
 fir
 
 Hill. 13 Car. . ^ 85 - 
 
 firpofntfl toercfpofecnfobpt^epiafntfffsComifcl fn ^fs ardtimcnt. j.^e 
 fa(o, t^e p?otdE!D<ngsasa{nft Chambers tocrc ncfther agreeable to tl)c Com. ^'''^'•'^^'" 
 Mton lato, noj to Magna Charta, anDtl)crefo?ctllcgal, anonotlnatratt* 
 tabic , notlDitl)ffanDfng tl)C Cu0omc plcauco to batfc tbem. jly. %\)c 
 Cnftome ft felf is not tocU purfticB , Bradon,55. 5 Rep. 64. sic 
 I5jng cannot jjtant potoet to a Court tocommft agatntt tljc Common* 
 lato, 0; &tatutc4ato, Ma{;na Charta, 54.43 A[l. PI. j.ano tlicugb one 
 fubtnU b^mfclf to be commftten, fo? a tl}fng fo? itWtl) be <s not£om^subir.;!i.:on. 
 mittablc bp ILato, tMs fubmtfofon is tolo. ^ly, s:f)e Cuftom plcaoeo 
 ta againft Magna Charra , anDCltcrs otbcc &iati!tco,Star. 9 H. 6. cap. y. 
 }jE. 3. Cooks Magn. Chart. f. 16. Brafton,5^4, 355. 43 E. 4. f. 3:. an3(t 
 appears not tbeplcaclngotoerctn J,attn,a3tl)crotinf)ttobe, 36 E. j.ncf ^""'"g'- 
 tbct leas tbeConfeffifon legal, noj entree upon llctojo. jlp.SbeSuogc. , , 
 ment tartes from all otbcr Siiugcmenta fnJLato: fo?tbc Commitment "'6«"'^"'* 
 toag , tbnt be fijoult ttano commtttco imtfll be teoiilo pjomffc tbat be tntll 
 tftturbno mojc; ^no 2ly. untlll tbc Court flioiilDtahc tnrtt)cro;3cr , ano 
 tWsfoagainftlLato, 8 Rep. f. 59. * 'nftir. 5 2« 5'y- SHbc Statute of Rich, 
 3d tonfirmcs not tbc Ctiftom/o? ff ft teas befojc Magna Ctarta ft fs taliett a- 
 luap bv tbat Statute , fo j U is not c jcepteo in ft, Magna Charta cap, 19,29. 
 Mirorof luftice.cap. 5,LongQuint.4o,4i. dly.SCbcCi.ftom jjnottocll 
 puttueu fn tbe lletnrn , fo? tbc £?atb crtcnoa to be obeofcnt to tbc Bay liff, p^jj-.-n 
 3C. fojtbctfmcbcfng, buttbc1Rctnrni)3notro:butit fafo, tbatbcbcobc- 
 DJcnt to gooD 3Lato0, auD tbfo fo not fn tbfe £>atb. ilno tlje IReto?n fs agafntt 
 tbcfr Cuftom, nm 3!iit)ecmcnt fo; tbc Commftment,anQ fo be pjafs Junixt* 
 went foj tbe plaintiff. Roll luftlce fafo , Stbat tbe B/asgcmcnt ano tbc 
 5tlcto:narc contrary : to? tlje ^uBgemcnt Icag , tbat be fball faccommtt= 
 teo , bccaufe be tooulo not pjomffc, not to Dtfturb : ano the licto jn fs , tbat 
 bepjomffetbattc tof U not mfturb. CaulcwastobefhewnwhychePlaincifi' 
 {hould not have ludgeojenc. 
 
 The King and Apfley. 
 
 HilK 25 Car. Banc, Rep, 
 
 f A PneyrcmobeB certain ojoersmabcagainftbimbp tbc Commf'stoners To qnfiior. 
 
 Jl\ of feetocrs fo? Weflmirfler, bp a Certiorari into ttjfs Court. i?nO upon '"" "^' ^om- 
 
 tbc IRetojn tbcfe cyccptfong tocre taken, i. SCbat ftootb not faptbc'l''^'""""'^ 
 
 Commifofon of Seiners teas unoer tbcdrzeat Seal, as ft ongbt to ctpjcrs,"'*""^* 
 
 7 Car. Allen anD Carter, & 5 Car. Rayl anO Mannings Cafe, anU Pafc 14 
 
 Car. Hungatcs Cafe, anu becaufcft f3nctrofctro?tbtbcre can no3;ffucfae 
 
 tahen, tobctbcr tbepbeCommffstoncrso? not. zly. aCbcCommifsfon 
 
 fs not iDCll plcaoeo, fo? ft appears not tbat t6?a of tbcm lucre of tbc quorum, 
 
 actbc atattitc appoints tbere tboulo be. 51^. SCbc 11eto?n fs in englifl),ano 
 
 ft ougbt to be fn Jlatfn. lout to tbfs Roll luflice anfircrco, 2Eb?.t tbe Ke. ^ 
 
 to;nfBgooDnottDitbftantfng,fo?tbcCommffsfon isfnCnglfflj. 4ly. Si ^"°'"" 
 
 ootb not appear, tbat Harti-homlane, toncbing tubitb tbcfr ojocrslcerc 
 
 jitaoe fs IrftbfnVVeftminfter, ano fo ft cannot be tocillmoiBn, irbctbcrft 
 
 loas teftbfn tbcfr potocr. faptjcrtuc of tbcfr Commffsfon to maKcanpo:* 
 
 terstoucbfng tbat place. Hales of Councel fo?tbcCommffsfoncrfl mobeo, 
 
 tbe 31vEto?n mfgbt bcaracnoco. J5at tbe Court anfmereo, 3;t coulc not be, Amcndmenr; 
 
 bccaufe tbc llctojn toas maoc tbc SEcrm bcrojc. And it was ordered, 
 
 that caufe fliould be (hewn Tucfday tollowing, why the Retorn and Proceed' 
 
 ings (hould not be quaflied.
 
 Hill ^3 Car 
 
 The King againft Page and Harwood. 
 
 Hill. 23 Car Banc. PvCg. 
 
 Quft^on upon n-^}tt men Vucrc cnofctcD at an 3fo(fc0 In t^c Countrp fo: jrclonp, fej 
 
 ,Kc s<acii:cif A i.jiKng of 3 mart, tftc Cnotflmcnt toas frsmcD upoti tl)e fetfltutc of I lac. 
 
 Srabb.nt , ^gjjg aaainft feitabWitgjSLbep Vdctc all founD gulltp.l)e tljat Dfo tbc fnfl loas 
 
 '*''"''", conucmiieD, ano CFCfUtco .• but bccaafc tbc Jufttce of afaffc ooubtcD IdI)C> 
 
 Ac'«(r!ry "' ttjet tbc otl)er ttoo toers pitnctples iDltbfn that statute, o? but ilccciro?tC0, 
 
 p r.nc pic. tbcp iBoulo "ot pjocccD to ^uogemciit agaJnft tbcm;©nf)ereupon tbcp tecrc 
 
 /.cceflory. jj^ouobt to tljlo iS^t to bc piocECDco agatiift foi tbc j'^clonp, ano tbc Doubt 
 
 toasjln rcgaro tl)cj' toctc onlp pjcfcnt , ano abetting tbc perfon tbat Dto tbs 
 
 fart ano ufco no 0ct{on totoatostbe oeatlj of tijc partp, Icbetbcr tljcp toctc 
 
 P;intiplco toftWn tbc Statute, oj but flttcffojica. Roll luffice falo, 
 
 cierfy £Ebcp arc Hot pjtntlplcB, but iltccffojf cs, ano ougbt to bate tftefr vTlcrgp : 
 
 foj tbc fetatatc of Stabbing being a penal JlalD, It ftall be taUcn flrlrtlp 
 
 ano not CttentCO to f quitp , ano In Swinertons cafe Brarafton. ■ Barklcy, antt 
 
 lones tlr.(roftl)c3uDgcaoftl)ta<i:ourtDlrctfeotl)e3;«rp- tbe Cafe being 
 
 of tbc fame nature teltb tblo,to fino tbe parties onip accclfojp. 15ut tbe 3u» 
 
 rp In cur <i;afe bate founb tbcm guilt p as pjinctplca, ano 3 Doubt upon tbat, 
 
 Tryai. Inbctbcr tbe SErpal be cooD o; no. Walker of Countel agalntttbe pjlfo- 
 
 mx0M^,xit Statute of Stabbing makes no ncln offence, ano therefore It la 
 
 End dinciit, floubtfull ,U)bebct ft be neceHarp fo j tbe enoictmcnt to cone luDc contra for^ 
 
 mam S:atuti Roil luQice falO. It ougbt to be fo. 53ut Bacon luOice DoubtCO, 
 
 2Ebc Court aDmlttcD tbc palfoners to tbeir Clergp, anD tbcp tocrc burnt In 
 
 tbe banD In tlciD of tbc Court bp tbe l^angman of London, ano tbcp ;ifo. 
 
 ncrs bounD eatb foj t^c otljcr to t^elt gooD bebaWours, and to appear io 
 
 Court tbe next Terra, 
 
 Hales againft More. 
 
 Hill. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 Mich. 23 Car. rot, 332. 
 
 ABluDgcmcnt iuas gltocn In an Infcrlout Court In an Action of ©cbf, 
 anD a" OTrlt of Crroj brought In this Court to rctjcrfc it. Cbe erro;0 
 ucb". afsignco toere, i. SLbc plalntis cntrcD gcncrallp de placito debiti, toblcbla 
 
 Drna nd. uncertain, fo that tbc DefenDant cannot fenoiDtobat la DcmanocD. 2ly. 3n 
 vcni.c. tfaeaiKaTDlngoftbe Venire, It la duodecim, fc. ano Dotbnotfapprobos & 
 lecaies homines. Bacon luftice, Duodecim In tbc Venire, Itltb an &cj0 not 
 oooD In an Snfcrlour Court , but this la In tbc atoarblng of tbe Venire , anD 
 tl)cr£fo?E tjjcll cnougb, but tbe fSrft Is a gooD Crtcption In mp ^uDgement. 
 Therefore let the judgement be fcverfcd, except caufe flicwn to the contrary. 
 
 The King and Corye- 
 
 Jed .0*, Re*' /ifio:eDto tbe KecoaDcra place of tbc CItpof Norwitch, tobtcb tnasrc-- 
 coHcrs piar..tnrncD anD fileo. Hales of Ws Counccl opcnco t^c Keto?n anD cIteD 
 
 Stroods
 
 Hill,i3Car. " 8? 
 
 StroodTWfeT t^ cineTngl)t not to Oe tcmotjeo from anp office icftljout 
 
 fliciDtng aooD caufc tolJ!? ftc (s rcmotico , toljicl) fs not ftcrc Done, but onlp 
 
 a Cuftom fct fojtl), toljcrcbp t!)cp fijcto t^cp Ijati autl)o?Up to elefl: a l^c« 
 
 coaoer foj a peat onlp , ano at tbc cno of tbe pear to elect anotbct , ano tf)at 
 
 bp tertuc of tlits Cuftom, tbcp ban cJjofcn anotljct UecojDcr in tliepartjcs CuRcmc. 
 
 place , be bating ban in a Vobolc pear, tohicb be conccit)c3 to be an ill €u^ 
 
 ffoin. Roll laftice fatQ , 31' Ibis be a tioto Cuftom, none of tbe ttoo Reco j< 
 
 Bcro lucre tocU clC£teD,anD fo Cory cannot be rcftojcD flno Bacon luOice oio 
 
 alfo ooubt, tobctbct anp of tbcni tocrc tocll cbofcn. tt toes faio, tbat tbc 
 
 5Rctojn f3 nottratierfable, but ftiall be taken to be true. Bacon luftice bclD, J"-'"C<:: 
 
 SCbat tbe laetojn teas not gmo, ano pou mnft i;al'c an Alias, tbat toe map ^"o-"- 
 
 babe a better ^liiflijer befojeus : fo; noting can be 8onc upon tbis. But 
 
 the Court enclined, tbat a JRecoiDcr map be clcctco foj one pear. Jt teas 
 
 faio ^ Sf a Cuftom be entire pou cannot make one par^o; it gboo, ano ano- 
 
 tberpart ofitiO. TIic rule was, for the party co take an Alia?, becaufe this ^ , 
 
 Retornis notgood, and itis too late toaitienditjbccaurcic is fikdf ^ > - t n . 
 
 The King and 5ymmons. 
 
 1^ an e-noictment of forcible €ntrp upontbce>tatutcof 8H.^. "J'^ffs J|^j'i,^"^|'^>^'^" 
 Crcrptions tocrc fojmcrlp taken. Roll luftice auftocrcD to tbat, tbat^,'„„;hc"sti. 
 
 tbe ©nDittmetlt OiO not fap , contra Coronam & dipnitatem, it to3S\urllC'tu,cof8H. <f. 
 nougb iDttboat tbofc teojos, ^notbet exception luas notn taken , tbat tbc 
 ©nDictmcnt is ad tunc & ibidem, tubitb io repugnant. 2Ebis Roll luftice o» 
 tjcr-tuleo, but \ft ooubteo tobctbtr tbc CSnDictmcnt ougbt to be contra for= 
 niamStatutorum,ojcontr:i formam Sea tut i asitiiS, bccaufc tbis CDnoiCtmcnt 
 feframcn upon Ditjcts statutes. Bacon IufticecitcDtbe4tb. Rep. tbc Cafe 
 of Appeals, anD faio, ft f0 0ooD as it is contra formaraStaturi.anofaib, tbat 
 a forcible (!£atrp anu SDctcpncr ispantflbablcattbcCommon^laiD. The c mmon h-.v. 
 Court defired to lee Prefidents. Antea, 
 
 Hill- 23 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 MAynsrd ftjctuB fo; caufcltbp a^?obibittonfl)ou!Dnot bcsrantEDto^•'f^P'■ol''- 
 tbc aomftaltp, 2Cbat tbc parties babe motieu tbio matter in tbc^"?^"°|: 
 Common pleas, ano DiotbercjopnilTae upon tbe fame, ano atocrDiapar-^cln^uitlt^ 
 fcD agfainft tbcpjobibitfon, ano a confultation inag tbcrcupon grantco, on grimed. * 
 Ebc Councel on tbc otber Csc makes anotbcr fuagcftion , vz. tbattbe fcn- 
 tcnce fn tbc Court of 0Dmtraltp , inas acainft a pcrfon tbat u-as ocao , ano 
 tbat one of tbc parties tobobao tbc fcntcncc bao rclcafco. STo tbis tbc Court 
 fafo, pou migbt bate plcaccD tbisinttcaomiral Court. Hill of Councel 
 fo; tbc p;ol)ibition faio, it is not material toljat tbc parties bafcc Done in tbc 
 Common-pleas, fo; tbis Court is not bouno bp it. Roll luilice, 3if tbe mat- 
 ter of pour furmifc bcre be trpcD alrcaop intbeCom;non:plcaB, tobp 
 fljoulD pou mobe bere upon tbe fame furmifc. But it is notarbitra»Surmirc. 
 rp to grant a ^;obtbitfon 0; not to grant it, iftbere be caufc to grant it, ^/'"';"7- 
 ano tbc SCrpal in tbc Common^pleas is no conclufion to us, anb if it be mif- ^'"'^'"'""'. 
 tbictous ap is obicdci), to grant a |p;obibition after a Confultation I'roiiibUio^ 
 grantee, tbe parliament map make a llaio to pjcbcnt tl at mffcbicf, foj aij 
 tbc Jlato notois it map be bone; Yet wc will adviie 
 
 Cawdy
 
 && 
 
 Hill. 2} Car. 
 
 Gaudy agi'nft Ingham . 
 
 Hill, 2 3 Car, Banc. Rcg« 
 
 Error upon a 
 Judpfmcnt :- 
 painft an aJ- 
 niiniftrator. 
 Iud|cmenr 
 
 Itatigcment toao gitjcn agafnff an nomfnfttratoji (n an 0flfoit of SDeM 
 bjougbt asatiift btm, fn tijc Common pleasjupon fnllp at)min(ftrcDplca» 
 DetJ , ann a iDjtt of (£tto j iDas ^ere fajotigbt to rcUetfc tftc JuDgmcnt. SLfjc 
 (Ertoj afsfgncD icas, tl)at guuecmcnt irao gttcn foj tbe toljolc ffi)ebt, 
 lubereas tt)C tctoiil founo tt^at ttje SDefcnnant ^ao affeto onlp to tiilcbatge a 
 part of it. 2So tWs tljc Court faio, If U be founo be l)at)e anp affets, BIuDgc^ 
 mcnt mnft be gf ben agatnft l)lm, fo) tUe to^olc Debt upon ^ts falfc pica, but 
 if \)c tatc no atTcts it is otl)ctU){re 
 
 Arrtttof 
 ludfjcmcnt ii 
 an Aftion >^f 
 Covcnanc. 
 
 In aneft of 
 Iudgcnle.^^. 
 
 prebiians. 
 Dcmuner. 
 
 Allen againfl: Reeve 
 
 Hill. 25 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 Mich. Z3 Car. rot, 88. 
 
 Atlen b5tf ngc an 0ct{oii of Covenant againff Reeve, anti bfs inf fe, opoti 
 alcafe evptrco maoc of certain bonfeo Ibp oecQuntotbc luifcdum loja 
 fuir, toberein loas a ^iTobenant to hccp tlje fjoufes in repair During tbe term, 
 I fojb.:eatI) of t!)ti5 Covenant is tbc^rtfonb^ougbt, ann Declares as to one 
 oftbc!;otifC5t!)at it \Da6 burnt bv nca.ligcncc. %^z S^cfcnoants plcaDa 
 fpecial plea to ti)is effect; SCbatttjeboufcUibicb luas burnt tsas not burnt 
 bp negligence, nojlritl) Common fire as tbe plaintiff batb occlarcD, ano 
 as to tbe reft tbcp plcao tljc general iffuc , tbat tbcp loerc in gooo repair at 
 tbe expiration of tbe term; tbe JDlai ntiff batb a fteroict. Nicholas of Coun-- 
 ccl ii)itb tbe plaintiff faio , it contcins a negative preignans ;' foj tberc arc 
 tiiio matters offrco in iifue, one tbat tbe bonfe luasnot burneo bp common 
 fire. 2IV. SLbat it tuas not burneo bp tbe negligence of tbe partp. Roll 
 Iunice,3fit be a negatite preignans, as pou fapitis, pou ougtt to batie 
 oemurreD unto it as to a oouble plea. But lee us fee the book , and flay in 
 the mean time. 
 
 Hobfon againft Hey wood. 
 
 Hill. 23 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 Trin. rot. 791. 
 
 Error to re- T T Qbfon b^fngs 3 .ip^tt of Crro> fn tbis Court to rcbsrfc a 3!ubgcment 
 vcrfc a j^dec- |j^ gj^P„ agaiull bim at Bririow in an Litton of 2Dcbt foj rent , antj af- 
 o"wTn'"n /ft;. KS"s fo J crrojs, tb't tbe fum tiemanocD to be uue fo: rent teas in figure0, 
 o. of Debt . ' ano not in toojoo, as it otigbt to be. alp. 3t is faio, tbat t1)e Surp Afiideinc 
 t;ror. damna foj Aflident damna, 2Ebc Court belD tbcp Itjcte botb material ej:- 
 
 ceptions, ano rcberfeo tbe 31«ogcmcnt, except caufe fhould be fhewn to tne 
 
 contrary Saturday following. 
 
 Cham-
 
 Hill.i3Car. g^ 
 
 Chambers againft Floyd- 
 
 HilUzsCar, Banc, Reg. 
 
 VJDonatnleotTtlje Croton Coe to Iftein caufc toftp an ^ttstc'mtnt cm^e ,«aina 
 fljoulo not fffnc out agaftiattoo3!attfcc0 of peace fo-j not allotomg a iVu.ngcfin 
 certiorar DitectcD to tbem out of t^fa Court to temotjcan enufttmcnt of foj- atu'cwncut. 
 cefble cntrp tabcn at a pjfljate fectsfons befoje tfjcin. SCljc Connect foj 
 tbc31uffkeBarg0D,tl)attbcp baDnottontemncotbcpjoccffc oft^ts Court 
 asfsfurmffeD; fojtlje certiorari ougW to bate been DcUtiercD in open 
 &ef0lon0 of tbe pc ace , ano tljete allotoco ; bat tbfs inas DeUberco at a p ji. Allowance. 
 tjat&Efsfong, anDfotbeptoctcnottoalloto ft. ilp. Cbe pattp totopjo- 
 cnrca ttjc certiorari, ougbt acco jutng to tbe Statute, to pat fn fccuritp, at tbe Certiorari. 
 oeUberp thereof, to pjofecnte, o^ elfe it is not to be allotoeo , bnt t^at tras 
 not Done bere , anD tbercfo jc tbep \ycre not bonno to alloto it: ano the cer» 
 tiorari ts to remote an Cnotctment of fojciblc cntrp;bHt tbc retojii is tbat it 
 toas a peaceable entrp , ano a forcible oetcpner, fo tfiat tijere being no facb Retom 
 CEnoirtment befoje tftem as tbe certiorari mentions, tbep conlD sot make a 
 tetojnaccojWngtotbetDjit, ano tberefoje it is no contempt in tfte 3;uffi-_ 
 ces not to make a return. 2nt>c Court, anftoereo, tbat it is tbe ufual courfc ^°"""'i''* 
 oftfteConrtto maUecertioranes in tbisfojm, anDtberefojetbisi0noct;« 
 mtc; ^biC3unceUsatnfttf)e3|naicesargcD,tbattbiscafei3toftl)tn tbe 
 &tatutc,tbon'-!iit ijjite at a pjibat Versions oft^epeacc, anD tberefoje 
 t^e Saflice • arc h .a'fteTTpt. Roll luftice faio, 3! conteibe tftat tljts is cafus 
 omifTus not pjooiuen fo ? bp tbe statute, anb if fb, tftcn are tljep not in con- cafus oraifius 
 tempt,anDfffomc3infticsiJtafee an ©tioirtment of forcible entrp, otbec * 
 
 3aKtcc0 cantiot gi^c i ettttution upon tljis (!!;nDictment. Bacon lufticc, 2Dbc Reftitution 
 Ja^tatnte is a rcmeuial ILaln, ano made fo} Vsz tate oft^e fabiett, anD 
 ougbttiottobcconttrnEDftrtctlpt anDfaio.tbat a pjibai ^ef^ionois aConftruftion. 
 ^efsions; bat rpruritp ougl) to be put in at tbe quarter ^efsions, foj it C&all 
 ijcintenncD tiiat all tbc 3laftfce0of tlje Countp are tbcre. Roil luftice faiD/"-"^''^' 
 ttiatapiitat Versions ongbt to take fecuritp , anD tbe Cuatctment ongbt 
 to be retojncn tbere; bat tbe certiorari is not gooD.foj it mentions not tbe 
 title of tbc art, pet tbe generall pjatticeoftbcCourtfeemstotoarrant 
 ttasitis. %1ic- ^onrtoJDereDtl)epartp to bate rcttitution, anD tbe con* 
 tempt to be fpareo bp confent of pattpes , if caufe not ihewn to tbe contrary 
 before the end of the Term* 
 
 Hill. 2 5 Car. Banc. Reg 
 
 T!^c Contt toas moteo npon an Aflfidavit fo> a prohibition to the Court For » prohib:- 
 atDoncafter, anD foj an attatthmcnt againft the ^aioj foj rcfuCngtiontothc 
 to^lotoofafo;einplea, tcnojcD bp the SDefennant in an ^action of jDcbt^''""''^''"" 
 bjoagbt againft bimfoj rent foj lants, that Ipe oat of the jurifDictfon of thep'Jfbition 
 Court, ano fojpjocccDing againft him nottofthffanDing the tenoer of the Atuuhment. 
 flea. The prohibition and actatchm^nc were granted if caufc not fliewn to 
 the contrary before the end oi the Ternit 
 
 iP t>i*
 
 po Hill. 2 5 Or. ' 
 
 David againft Lyfter. 
 
 I illf 2 3 Car, Bbdc. Reg, 
 
 [cnd',m r^" T ^^ ^"""^ ^^^ '"^^^'^ ^^ ""^ plflfjitf ff tl)at tfjc SDcftiitJant mfgftt be o; i 
 plead an :fiiu ocTCD toplcaD 811 (ffuflblc plcH, tr!)fcl) fec IjaD Hot DOHC, foj tbc aafon ia 
 bfc pica. an actfon of cjcaione firrax (n toWcb tbc |3lafntfff Ijatb Declarer) , ano 
 
 fl)c SPcfcnoant batb cmparlcD , ano after cmpariantc l)e plcaos t!)at tl)e 
 p]j,, lanDs arc antfent Demean, totjuf) <0 a Dtlatojp pica. Roll luftice, it is a good 
 
 pica after imparlance , for it goesinbarof the Aftionitfelfjand not, in A* 
 
 batementoftheWrit, 
 
 The king and Holland. 
 Hill, 23 Car, Banc. Rfg* 
 
 Sr c °nf for TJ ^" ^"'^'^ ^^'^' ^^^* *" *''*'' ^^^^ fo jmcrlp arguco, reffif utJon oagljt ta 
 rcftiiuiion in XV bc fittcit to t^jc partp, foj tbe fame BluDgement fljall be s^bcn J)crc 
 this Cf urt & toWtIb fljoiilo be gf ten fn Ct)anccrp , ano all tbc lltccojo {0 Ijcre befo jc U0, 
 not in Chan- ano ttjep ftt Cbanccrp cantTot DO anp tbfrtg <n tl&c caufc, foj tljep babe no- 
 lu Joemenr ^'''"S b^foje tbcm, ^no it appcaro to us tljat tbc a?eclaratton toao MaU 
 RcttitlTuon. fiftcnt, ano fotDc cannot gfbc3«Dgcmentfoj tbc pafrtlff; bat agalntt 
 f)fm,notix<tbftano{nstbe <nqinfitfon foimo fojtlie King, Therefore let the 
 party have reRitucion, except caufe (hewed the firR Friday in the next Terror 
 
 Hill. 23 Car. Bant. Reg. 
 
 For aif^harge ^y f^c Coutt luao JiTo^cD to Diftljatgc apjffoHcr bjougbt to tbc 3!Bar , bp 
 ptap,i(oncr. J. g habeas Corpus fommittcD bp tbc Committee of plunDjcD <^fnftter0, 
 ano tbcfe crccpttono trcrc taben to tbe tctojn. 1. SCberc 10 no time orpief* 
 Ctmini.mfnr.rcofjoUj long tbc partpfljallftanDcommfttcD.fo fte fs commftteo lultbout 
 »mttattonoftimc,tob(cbf0notlcgall. ^Ip, ^efocommfttco bp tbc name 
 of c^r- Smith, anDblsnamcofbapttfm is omlttcD,tDbicb oiigbtnot to be, 
 Vpon thele exceptions the Court held the commitment illegal, and difcharged 
 the party. 
 
 Weckes and Weekes, 
 
 Hill. 23 Car, Banc. Reg/' 
 
 Aeainfta ic- T 7 |Don tbc rctojn of a certiorari to remote ojDcr0 mafic bp Commfffifd- 
 tornofouicr-i V Hcrs of S>clucr0, ^t 1030 mobcD tbat tbc rctojtt tDa0 oot gooD.becaufc 
 ncrrd Scw'u'^ Iras not maoc bp tbc pattpes to tobom tbe certiorari inas DtrcileD , fo; it 
 ReVcrn. "^''tta0 DlrcctcD to tftc Commifsioncrs, ann tbc t eto?n is maoc bp tbc Clarfe of 
 Noiicc.*,* tbc &ctocr0.31Bnttbc Court falD tbc rctojnUjasgooDcnotjrTb, fojalltbc re» 
 
 to:.n0 arc fo , ano tbc Claris fg an offif er of U)bom tbc JLayo tafecg notice of , 
 
 anb ft belongs to \iivn to do it. 
 
 Pafe»
 
 Pale. 2 4 Car. 91 
 
 Parci4Car. Banc- Reg, 
 
 AWxit ofCDrroj teaslnottobttorctctfca 3»uO£fcmcnt gftctt fn an fit' Error « re- 
 fEtfoat court f nan action upon tlje cafe, anD tfje Ctroj afsfgncD toasverfea ludgc- 
 tftat tl)C habeas corpus toas not \iK\l Teto:nc3, fo j ft (snot rctojnca to be in mcnt in an ir.- 
 oranibuj fervitum ct executum as tt ougbt to bc , ano an tl)c ufual fojm (a.f'^f^°^<^f urt in 
 Maynara of Councel againft tt)c Miit of Ctro; argucD, t^at ft teas tocU re»'|| the ' caf"'" 
 to?neo notluftbftanofng tftofc uo?ds tocrc omfttco , bccaufc tbc 3urp DfD Retom. 
 appear full, ano no flTucs iuerc loft , anotijejurpljatjc Dap bp t^e roll ,Dayin courr. 
 5 H. 7. 1 4. per HufTcv, and 9 E. 4. 14 ft fs maoc a qucftfon but not rcfolteo. 
 2lp. SLftoucbftbea&lfp petft fsUjlt^fn tbc Statute of 21. lac ano f0 t)cl= 
 pcDbpft.fojtftat&tatutccrtenDstomojetljanCSlTfts, 30 map appear bp 
 tbe Statute, anDtl)eS>tatnfcof iSElix. toucl)fnsojfgfnal ^Tiifts crtcnDai^'"-. 
 to faults of bills , alt!)ousb o;fgfnal ©artts arc onlp namen, foj a bill fa tftc °".?^"''' '*'■'* 
 tome in futftance tofti) a ^rft, fo l;crc tbe Mrft, anupjcceptareof t^c '"''-''• 
 fame fuLftance. 3 Ip. ft is t^c intent of the Statute , anu tijc Statute ftaU 
 be taken bp cquitp,Hili. 1 3. lac. in tljia Court in Gregory and Brookes cafe, 
 tbfsqueflionlnasiQirrcDbutnotrcfoltcD, ant> Hobarco^npes tbe ^tli). re^ 
 po?tt. (5i. tobci^aUj, ano tbcrc fsnopjocecofngspjopcrlp in fuperfout 
 Courts bp plafnt. Roll luflice, SLbe Statute cptcnDs not to point of cquftp 
 In fnfcrfoj Coin-ts, fo; tftcir pjocccDings are not fo regular, aa tl)C pjoccco-- 
 fngsfntbe t)<g^ Courts here at Weflminfter, but thep are bp (bojt notes. 
 Bring Us books and move ic again, 
 
 Crcfwell againft Ventryes. - 
 
 Pafc, 24 Caft Banc, Reg. ■ 
 
 CRefwell bjoufibt an Action npon tlje cafe agafnff Ventryes foj fpcafefng Arreft ofiudg- 
 tbcfe toojos of him ; Thou dldft, and doft receive thief ftollen goods , '^?^^ ,|" '" =' 
 witncfle a featherbed tick in tfiy boufe, and the cloath which thy mans fuit c!j°refTr°"' * 
 was roadc of, and thou kneweft they wcreftollcn. SCfte Plaintiff ^att) words, 
 a terDitf, ttic SDefentjant motes in arrcft of Suogcment that ttjc U)o?D3 arc 
 net actionable, fo? one map rcccite ftollen gooes , anopctnotbeguiltp of 
 i?eionp. Bacon Juf>icc,2i:herccc<tfng of flollcngooDsfs not fclonp ; but 
 tfte rttcfttfng, ano comfo?ting of the iFelon fs iFclonp. The ludgement was r-iony. 
 ftayed till the other fhould move. 
 
 Thynn againft Thynn. 
 Pafc, 24 Car.Banc. Reg. 
 
 'T'Hynn bjfngs an flctfon agafntt Thynn to rcbcrfc a Kuugcmcnt gften fn ^'^^^ '<» f*- 
 
 tbc Common ple?8fn a tojit of Dotoj ; Hales of Councel toitft tl^c "«'''«?' "''R^- 
 2[>efcnoantintfte©arftofS>otDjinanfteerto the cjcceptions fojmcrlp ta/"""'" '""^ 
 benfalo,thatthcrammonB^.raBlriEU enough rcto?neD as it fffjbccaufefttea^summans. 
 mane upon fomc part of the lanQtoitbfn the ail, Lonp quint, E. 4. z H. 4, 
 I?. 39. E. 3.7. 2lp. 3tf0nptnccc(rarptoma{;etec|D?oclamatfon, tol)freproci,n,,.:on 
 tbc fummono fs, foj i^e Statute intencs not to alter tlje courfc of the Wm- 
 
 iP a mons,
 
 Pale. 24 Car 
 
 Demand. 
 
 larexent. 
 
 UjlD'llJnl!. 
 
 mons. 2lp. E^lc Uio jtfi of tl)C fetatntc arc fatlsficB, foj tl)c adtial fummona 
 In one GlUtl0aruinmon3<iitl)coti:.cr SUlls. slp.snbcmcanfngof tijc&ta:; 
 tutc la fatieBer, atiD tljc mtftljcffntcnDcDtoljcratfoficD fap tl)£ statute, 
 Hob. 173. Allen ano Walkers €afc. ^0% t^c 2D, cjccptfon to tl^e JDe.. 
 iitantJ be iJclD Uooo^cnoiislj, fojliiatsarft ofSDotoct ja EDcmano nceo. 
 rtl; not to be fo particular aotiiotbct HlrUo.foJsUfnanafcifc, n E. ?» 
 18. 4?E. 3. 6. 3 Ed.z. Dower, 161. aiiDtbcrca'on (0, b.taufettjeGHffc 
 tjcmariDS not tbe tobole ILano, noj tan batjc tbc CDbarfcrs InWcb concern tbc 
 3ianD to enable I) r to maUc fo pjecifc a HDcmanu aa map be in otbcrSElrita. 
 Sine as to Harpers Cafe tbat<3 obtc(tci3,3 anftDcr,(t agrees not tnftb our 
 <E;arc,Repif>. f-3<5. i<5E'3 F'f^^. Q.j.-ir. Imp. i47.anlJtt Jsccrtafn cnougb, 
 bccaiifc ft {3 of a Kcctojp, ano not of JlCttbcfi in grofs. ?l>'.2!:bc ucmano of 
 %i[\y:ii is furplufacc. ano it tciall one as to fap , tljc IRcctojp cum pcrtincn- 
 tiis. 2C!)cn ag to tbe £)b)ccttort tbat one tbf ng ig t'xfcc DcmanDeD, 31 anf incr, 
 it is not fo , but tjcmanoeti as part of a tbing Dcmanoet) in ttje CJJrit, anD a 
 jeDcKtcniJ in a tOrit of Dotucr iljall not abate tbc <Karft, tbougb one tbing be 
 tiDiccoc'.nanDC3,fojDa!nmagcolball notb0ttofccrecoi)crci!,4E- 3.f. 52. 
 Mitb. 9 lac. IntbeCommon^pleasagreeo fo bp, tbc Vi bole Court; 3In Blu- 
 ets €n{c, 8 Car. ouc tblugtoas tVuicc ncmantcD , ano pet tbc tEHrtt leas 
 not abaten. STo tbc 30. exception, SCbat tbc S^cmano is mo;c large 
 iftai tbD <SIlvit , b caufc a Vmttt map bz larger tljnn a till, ano tbe ffiJemano 
 in V.)C pariflj oi iraberj anriuer,2Ebat t^c taiU anD paviflj Qjafi be intcnoco 
 to be of tbe fame crtcnt,if tbc tontrarp 00 not appear, Cookilit. f. uy. 
 ;ly. jaitbougb tbe parifli map be larger tban tbc mill, pet it map Ipc in tbe 
 t!Hiil,anDtt)ccontrarpDotbnotbcre appear, anD tbeCafeisfo, tbat(t<0 
 Impofjibic tbat tbc pariflj Qjonlo crtcno into another ©m, i. SCbc office 
 of tbc CClrit is to rcftrain tbe IDcmauD, ano tbc Cairit afccrtaino t^c 2Dc- 
 manO, 19E. 3, Fitz. Dower,95.9E.4. f. 16, bp Chock, ilv. SEbcrCisJi: 
 rcftriflion liitUn tbebocpoftlje^emanD , fo j tbe 2Dcmano refers to tbc 
 Wl\it , ano is bomiDcD bp it, 4 1 Eliz. Wook anD Godins Cafe , a fmaU (m^ 
 Impiicition. pitEfliion vuiU maUc a tEliU ano pariflj to b; aU one, anD fo ft is bcrc, 42, 45 
 Eliz. Com. Banc. Hob. 12. CafC Brook auD Spencer, Trin. iglac.ih tbis 
 Court.ror. 50-,. Marks anD Maiks. ^nD as to tbc CBicception taUcntotl>s 
 rrccntfon, tbat Dammagcs are giticn foj mojc tban is oemanDco, 1 . f^crc 
 is no tonfcfsion as It is'fuppofcD on tbc otbcr Coc , tbat tbc i^utiDjco in xte* 
 mano ootb Ipc in anotbcr vHtll. ily. 3t ts impofsiblc fo j oammagcfl to 
 be Pii-cn fo; mo;e of tbc ^unDjcD tban Iprs icitbin tbc mills mcntioncD in 
 tbe"5KIlrit, anD fo are tljcrc no Dammagcs giVcnfo; tbat part of tbc !^?!uu 
 DjcD inbfcb U'co in Sutton parva, as is obji (tcD on tbc otbcr Goc : fo? no mojc 
 (ball be rccoticrcD t^an is contnincDintbeCarit, 9E. ^,6,16, ly* 2Cbc 
 Oacftion tbcvc VDa3,'JLibctbcr it iucrc a pUa to tbc I'SHrtt, »7 E.3. f.44. The 
 Court dtfired to hear another Argument, 
 
 ImpJ. 
 
 Ex:cu:ion, 
 
 CaRle againft Dinefy^ 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 lifnr f.o re- 
 fc fc a ludi.- 
 pictr ill 3\\ a- 
 & i>n uiH)Il 
 
 ll!t CilC. 
 
 Trin. 23 Car. rot. 'oyS, 
 
 C"«A(lle bjfngs a tiKlrftof Crroj to rcterfe a KnBgement gfbcn agafnft 
 ^Ijim i\\ tbc Court at Owfe- bridge in York, fn an Action upott tbe Cafe 
 upon an AfTumpfK; 2Cbc Crroj afsigncD toas, tbat tbcoapoftbcQ^ontbin 
 tol)ltb tbe p.;oni([e tonsmaDcistn iFiffurfs. 2Co tbfs tbe Conned on tber 
 
 Dtbct
 
 _^ Pafc. 24Gar, 93 
 
 otl)cr floe fafa , tftat IjctetofoiC ft IjaD hkn Itzlri to be cBttor rbutnoto Qn« E"or~ 
 the g>catute of leofailcs after a tjerofrt fsnoC-rroj. J5at I. Turner of 
 Conned toitb t^jc p^nfntf ff in t^c EClrft of Crroj fa(a, SCftat ft ia a material 
 exception noU) : foj tl)c AfTumpfit is tbc gronno of tbe Sttfon, ano tbercfoje 
 tl;0 nap muft naoo be material. janotl)eterceptiontDa0,tf)r<ttbE Venire 
 toao Vt-nire facias duodccem, Sec* de Biliva tua ,anDtf)e tJHenutoasfn tlje 
 Ctt)? of York. 3IS:it to tl)iij cjf eption ft toas anf ioercD, tJjat tbc IRecojo ia 
 deCivitatcEbotumin Bsliva tua , ajiDfoitiatodl cnougft ano Of tbis opf» 
 nfon tcaa tbe Court. 315ut tbe Court belo tbcfiraercEptiontobcgooD; 
 whereupon the Countel tor the Defendant in the Writ of Error prayed , the 
 ladgement roiglit be reverfed lor bi» Clyenti difpatcb, and fo it was. 
 
 The King againft Andrews. 
 
 Pafc, 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 ANdrews luafl cnzif cteo foj ^urtber, ano ont^lairco npon tbc Cnbftfment, Arraignment 
 anu talicn upon tbe jSDat laltnp, ano bjoagbt to the Bar, anh Dcmano.^f" " "" *^"'' 
 ED tobat b' conlo fap, tobp 3!uDgcmcnt Ojonlo not be citjen agatntt bim,- i^u'.L"" 
 SCbc =||p;tfoncr faio, be bao bjouobt bi« C53rit of CErroj to reberfc tbc i©ut« " ' 
 IatD?p, anDpjapeDitmfgbtbcalloitico, tobfcb teas sratttCD, ano tbc OTtit 
 reaDbpBroughcontbcS>«onDarpont})cCroto(i<fioe. 2Lbe |)?ironer DcC- 
 reo be migbt balje Walker, Hales, ano Pepei, afoiBnco bfm foj bis Conned, 
 tubicb tbe Court grantcD. 2CbcComicclp:apeDtbcpmig1jtb3tJcaCopp 
 of tbc IRecojD. Roll luftice fafi», that tbc iJJjifoner Umfelf ougbt to ftelo p 
 matter in Hato fo j €xm\ tobicb tbe Counccl oonbteD, IBut tbe Court obet. °^' 
 rnlcD it, pet agteeo, tbflt tbc KctojD (boula be reao unto t\)em , tobftb toao 
 conc; mpon tbc reauing Walker too!^ tbefe erceptions. j. jBCbc pioccfa is 
 not \rcll airarDcOjfoj tbc Capias ia not prxiid. Andrews, ano fo it appear© 
 not iobo teas out-latoeo, ttbetbcr tbe p?ifoner oj anotber of tbe fame nante. 
 2ly. 31t i9 not faio, tbat tbe JBjocefs ia atoarDco bp tbc Court, noj at tobat 
 S>cfsionB it teas atoaroeo. Roil luftice, 3lt ia not nccctTarp , foj it fe re- 
 tojtJCD tbcre. 3 !y. 3t appears not tobat pattp ia ocao , tcbctbcr be tbat 
 luaaftrucbojanotbec. 4ly. 3It Dotb not appear in iubatpartoff&cboDp 
 tbc ^douno ioae giben, no j toitb tobat tneapon. SCbe Court faio, tbat tbcp 
 toill bear tbe iafnga Councel befo je tbep tuoulb concluoe anp tbing. JTbe 
 Couacel mobco, tbat tbe p?ifoner migbt be bapleb , bccanfc it toasfoar^ 
 teen pears ago Cnce be tuas enbiaeo, SEbe Court anftocrcD, till pou are af* 
 Ognco of Counccl upon IRcco jo. we cannot bapl bini at pour pjapcr. jCbcn Biyi. 
 tbe Conned DeCircD a Copp of tbc JRccojO. ad quod non fuie reiponfum, but 
 tbc Court fain to tbc Counccl tabc mo;c time to conffoct of otbcr excepti- 
 ons , fo; if tbcfc Qjall be oberruleo pour Clpcnt fa gone, viz, mutt be hangs 
 eo. At another day he wa« bayled by four perfon$, and bound to profccute 
 his Writ of Error with tffed. 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 ijj Action of SDcbt teas bjougbt npon an £)blfgaf ion foj qoooI.(bc''rrefto! 
 BDefenonnt pleaoa tbat be batipaio tbe monp on fucb a Dap, tDbercas'"*^*^"'"' 
 
 '■-—-■-'•-'-■• - • - ' :nDcbturcri 
 
 A 
 
 tbc trutb of tbcCafc U)a0,ti;at tbcre irao ttoo Daies of papmcnt limitcD in tbc'" o?r 
 SDjUgstior, ano tijc S)efenoant baiJ paio part of tbc morics upcn one of tbe'" '' 
 
 iP i Dotes
 
 Vc:d;a. 
 
 9^ Pafc. 24 Car. 
 
 taicfl of papmcnt , ann t^e rctt apon tijc otftec onp, ano not all nt one cap. 
 %\)t piafnUff tcplfC0 tbat tl)e 2Defcnoant dId not pat) tfjemonp upon tftc 
 nap allcgcD bp tbc ffi)cfcnDant (n Wa pica, ann upon t\)ia an ^ffuc is jopnco, 
 ano a toerolct founo foj tl)C |0la<nt(ff ; ti)z SDefcnoant motjcs tn arrcftof 
 3'.nBement , ano fbcioo fo; taufc , Cbat tbc **iilcrD<ct fs jmp:tfc(t, farcaufe 
 It Dctli not fin^ tljat tl)C SJefcnoant ban ttco Dates of papmcnt , but concluoes 
 tl)at ftc DtD not papt^e monp upon one of tbeoafcs. Koll luilice,3fpoii 
 l)abc two oafcfl of papmcnt to plcao, ano poj telpupon one oap In pour 
 plEaD<ng,anD tffuc fo jopnco upon tl)at,ano ft be founo a?afnft pou,»poa muft 
 Champerty, jjj, i^^^cti bp It. Hales nrgcD, Sljat l)crc w.s a cbampcrtoua agreement, foj 
 tbcrc irac no conCioctatton fojtbe afofanmcnt of tntsiDbligatlonanojit' 
 Dcntnre to tl)C plaintiff, upon toWcl) tlje action IsbjonslJt bpWm. The 
 luJgcmenc was ftayed till the other part ftiould move. 
 
 More againfl vyconc. **' 
 
 Pafc. j4 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 A^ 0ctiiMi of Srcfpafs of affaiilt ano Battcrp , tuau b;ougf)t bp 
 tl)e plaintiff fo? affaulting ano beating, ano tafeing fiig fecrbant fo> 
 JLi'd^went 11. t'vJDO ipontl)3 , per quod fervitium amifit; %\)C SDCfcnOant plcaoo not gufltp, 
 T.dViab; nno ttjerctipon ia an gffuc jopnco , ano a bcroictfojtlje plaintiff. Stfte 
 AHauitan.) jai)efcnDant mobcs in an arrcftofiuoficmcnt, ana foj caufe 0)6103, t^at 
 ^kTa«3v tbc plaintiff batl) not fetfo}tl)l)oto ttjc partp luas Ijia ^erbant, Uibetljct 
 his 'sc> Vint, ae an flppjcntifc, 0; bp retainer, ae Ije ongl)t to tjabc oonc. IBut tbe Court 
 Retainer. faiD, tljat tljc IRctojo fmplics tbatbctoasfeisfecrbant attbctimetDbcti 
 the SCrcfpafs tola Done, ano tbatis cnouglj, ano tbio is theufual fojm 
 of Declaring in tbic action in tfee Common plcaa.ano in tbis Court alfo(ano 
 fo manp oftbc Counccl at tbc 315ar affitntcD ) and therefore lee the Plaintiff 
 take hisludgemenc. 
 
 The King againft Holland. 
 
 Pafc« 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 .,j ^,f ,i>c cannot be giben Ijcrc : foj a juogcmcnt muft be gibai upon tbc IRccojo it 
 
 chincc.y. fflf. 2lp. it tooulD b: inconbcnicnt if it fljoulo be otI)crtDifc,fo? tbe Cbance* 
 
 iucgcmc:it. jv is 3luogc of tftc Jnquifitiott , ano fo there map be luogcment one trap fit 
 
 Chancerp" nno Rnoti)cr itap berc.if tbe JRccojo be not rcmobco bitbcr- ano 
 
 tbcre ifl Difference tobere a tranfcript of a IRccojo is remobeb out of a 
 
 Court tobicb cannot pjoteco upon tbc Ktcojo it fclf, ano toberc ft ie a tran« 
 
 Tranfcnpt. fcript Of 3 Hccojo. upon Vubfcb Kcco jD tbc Court map p?oceeD, as it is in 
 
 our Ca'c, 39 H, (5.6* I4E-4' '-^y- 3lp. 31t appears not to tl)i3 Court 
 
 boiD tbc Commifoion ano BlnqufDition are crccutco, tubetber toell ojnot, 
 
 ano tb'-rcf o?e it cannot inoge of it. Maynard on tbc otbcr Coc p^apes, tbat 
 
 juogemcnt map be gibcn bcre, upon tbc memorandum of tbe l^ccojo fent 
 
 l)itb'cr out of tbc Cb-intcrp fo j ti^tfc rcafonp, i . Ctcrp Court ougbt to gibe 
 
 tingcment ontbsoncfioeoj otbcr ; tberefoac tftbcifiiingmapbabc iuogc- 
 
 metUbcre, tbepattp map alfoba^c judgement, alp. 2C!)e Hecojofsbctc 
 
 in
 
 inttis CcartttTtuallpbpfcnDfny of tfte Memorandum of ft bftbcr, anutftat 
 
 i3 cnougb togfte ftioecincnt upon. jlp.SEbeCftanccrpnnotUo Court as 
 
 to tl)c gfWng of juDgcmcntljcre, ate ask UiErconcCourt,2 4E, j.f. 77. 
 
 4lp. severe {0 a gtouno foi itiogcmcnt to be cfbcn bcrc, ana it cannot be gf = 
 
 ten eirct;ljcte, foj anatcarsfndbancerpfsnoSiuogcment, anofot^cre A«r<r. 
 
 cannot be ttoo fetetal 3luDgement0, one <n Cfjancetp.anu another ^ere, as 
 
 Hales fupporetb; ano in Lathams cafe, tftt llcco?D icas tcmoteD as it is ftcre, 
 
 anc 3iuDgcment gitcn upon it in tljis Coutt, jlp, 2CUc Cftanccrp is not to* 
 
 be Juoge : foj tbe gCratierfc toas there , ano tftc caufc rcmotJCD Ijftbtr, ano 
 
 toe cannot go bach tl]ft!)ct again : io% U Idc flioulD do fo, toe ftotilo ^atje ' * 
 
 3iuDgcnicnt in no Court -, 3if it two been upon a ©cmurtcr in Cljanccrp, ^ 
 
 ttjcn tbere m(gl)t tjatie been a SoDgenient tfjere, but not noto the Caufe is 
 
 remotjED bp 2Crat«crfe,anD apatcnt fljaU not be cojrcttco bp tfje CEnrolmcnt, •' 
 
 but tlje enrollment bp tbc patent unuet &Eal. Hales on t|)e otber fioc faio,' 
 
 SDbat itist^lReco^Qoftbeplea that is tranfmitteo oiitoftlje Cijancerp 
 
 bitfjcr, butnottbeiRecojDoftfjc Slnquiliifion oj Commifsion nponloljtcbit 
 
 is founo , ano Ijolo tben tan tbtic be anp laogemcnt ^ Roll iuftice faio, 
 
 SChat tbeAraoveasmanum is but a confcquence of tfjejiiogemcnt, ano » , 
 
 not tbe SuDgcment it felf, ano toe map .gibe 31uogemcnt toitfjout thenu^r'""" ' 
 
 anquifition againft tl)c i^ing, ano; the, IRccojo is ttanfmittco Ijitber to 
 
 Determine iDiiether tfje Jiing o^ the partp bati) rigbt, ano tl)e Cf)a.icerp can-- 
 
 notintcrmeODle t fo^ bp this means the Courts tDillclaa),tu!)icbU)oulD be 
 
 inconvenient. Bacon lufticefpoUc to tI)C fame effect. Roll lufticeaODeo 
 
 ttjfs , 3f an £Dffice be founo to entitle tf)c fefng in tbcCbanccrp, ano it be 
 
 tranfmitteo bftber, ano it appears to this Court that lijc office is not gooo, 
 
 'ftall not toe giteSlaugemcnt againft tftclitns:' ccrtainlplDcCball. But 
 
 the Court would advife, and defired CO hear the Kings Conncel what they 
 
 cculd fay fox the King, 
 
 Pafc.. 24 Gar. Banc. Reg.' 
 
 Aji action ofSCrcI^afBtoasbjoaghtfojtahingatoapfiibcts parcels of Aneitof 
 jj^onfljolDftuff, ano upon non Gulp, pleaoeo, the plaintiff ban a t)er»i"'P«"'«ntin 
 t)ict, SDhe ©cfcnoant moteo in artcft of SiuDgement, ano fhetocD fo j caufe, T''"^! =»"•> t°r 
 that the SDcclaration teas not gooo, becaufc oibcts toojosin it mere in^Q^odi '"'^ 
 fen0blc, as i . SChc ^plaintiff Declares, fo j tahing atoap unum Lenar, Anglice, 
 a jpat, tohereasLcnat is no too:D tn anp JLangnage to Cgnifie anp thing, ano 
 thetcfojc the Anglice cannot help ft. SCo this the Court anftocrcD , SEhat 
 it fs all one as iffttoctelcftoutofthc SDeclatation , becaufe it Cgnifies 
 nothing tn it, ano fo there isnooammagcsgfbenfojthat thing tehicbitDannmjg«s. 
 Ojoulo 0gnifie. alp. ^e Declares fo; taking aiuaptria fufpendia, Anglice, 
 Pot=hooks,oj Hakes, But the ConrthclD this gooD enough. 3!?. !^eDe= 
 dates foj taUingatoapunum Aduftumferreum , tehith arctlvo aDiectitcs 
 anD ftgnifie nothing. SCo this the Court faio, if thcpfisntScncthtnct,tl)en 
 iioDaotmagesaregibcnfDj ft, and therefore let the Plaincifftakc hisludge» 
 Oient, 
 
 Pifc.
 
 9^ Pafc. 24 Car. . 
 
 Pa(c 24 Car. B^ncReg. 
 
 Vponreat>fngofti)ereto;nofCoUonel Tichbome iLcfutenant of t^ie 
 Tower of London upon an habeas corpus DlrcctcD to ^Im, on the behalf 
 
 fiabcav corpus of John LilborncommfttcDbpojDcr of botHoafC0 of IDarltamcnt fo; bfs 
 
 with pin. contempt to them, Cookof<i;oBncclltolththep?ffonet motjcnfoj^an AlU 
 at babeai corpus tofth a pain, bccaufe the ilicatenant hao onlp teto^neo tbe. 
 
 Aiiat. OTrft; butnotb?onghttheboDpofthepjfroncr. Bacon lufticc , 3|f thete 
 
 be fufficfent matter eicpjcffco fn the tetojn to uctehi the p?f fonet , to tnt^at 
 
 Rctom. parpofefljonlD toe grant an Alias, therefore ff the rctojn be Infuffitfcnt, 
 mobc ponr matter agafnft ft. IBut Roll luftlce fafo, the iLfentenant ongW 
 to mahe hia teto^tn either againtt the jurifoittfon of this Conrt , o» elfe ^e 
 inattb}fn0tbcboDpofthep?tfoncrb<ther, anDltfsfnourpotDcr to fct a 
 
 ^'"^^- fine npon h<m, fo; maUfng an (nfnffictent retojn. Therefore the Court or- 
 
 dered chat he flioald amend his recorn, orelfe they woald grant an Alias 
 with a pain* 
 
 Hocker againft Lamb. 
 
 a4 Cart Banc, Reg« 
 
 Trin«23 Cartrot» 15 pi* 
 
 Errortore- TT Ockcrbjodgfit 8 OTtftof Ctrojftt tbfaCootf agafnfflamb forcbetfe 
 
 vcrfe a ludg- JJj. a BSaogcmcnt gfbcn agafnft hfm, fn the Conrt at Colchefter fn Effex ; 
 
 mencforer- gno afafgns foj CEtto;, 1. SCftat the venirefaatoatDCD larger than tbe 
 
 rirV" "''HJeclaratfon. 2Co thfs Roll luftice fafo,thc OTarb tofthfn Colchefter men- 
 
 Licuconus. tioneDfntheSDcclaratfonfsbntalieuconus; but fn London the t!!2l3arbf0 
 
 Hundred. In the nature ofai^unDjeD,anDfoDfflfcra from thfs Cafe; a fccono e)ccBptf= 
 
 ^'^"^- ontoa0,thatthctfmeoftheAffumpfit,upontohfchthc2ctfonfn tohfch the 
 
 BjuDncmcnttDaagibenUjaafonnDtDfa eicpjetreo fn figures, viz. the tfme 
 
 fojthc oelfbcrp ofthcgooospjomfrcotobcDdfbcreD, aaalfo the tfme of 
 
 the rcqncft fo^ tbe oelf berp of them , as alfo the cofta , ano oamagea ao- 
 
 luDgeo. Vponthefe exceptions cheCourt ordered the Indgeraeat to berc< 
 
 veried except very good caufe (houfd be fhewen to the contury. 
 
 Pafc- 14 Car. Banc. Reg 
 
 For difcharecT ^^ '^'""^ ^^^ ^'^^^^ tobffcharge ftoo pjffoncrs commffteb fo j fnfjrf- 
 of i prifoners tfon Of murthsr, anh bjougbt to the bar bp a habeas corpus rctameo foj 
 at the bjr by tbe fnfufficfentp of the retojn, ano upon ttoo certfficatea offrco to the 
 habeas corpui^tm^t^ Chat the partpcB tuho DiD thc murther , fo;t tohtch thcfe pjffoners 
 
 tuerc commfttcD, tuete Cretntco fo; the fame , ano hao confctfeD that thep 
 Difcharge. Bfoft. JBut Roll Inftice anftocrei5,ff tbcretojnfae touchfug jFeloup, thougft 
 
 ftbefnfafflcfcntUjecannottifCthargethe partpea. SEhe Court tbcrcupen 
 ^'''- toas mobcb, ttjat thcp rafgbt be bafleb, tohfctj teas granteo , and they were 
 
 bailed
 
 Pafc, 24Car, p7 
 
 bailed by four in , >apiccethatthepriloner$fliallappcar at the next aftU 
 f«atBerry inSu, .» 
 
 PayagainftPaxted. 
 Pafc 34 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 'A 
 
 tlSUttt of €troj toas bjouabt to rctjcrfc a Sluogcment Qittn in an in- JcJfc l°]U\f 
 fetfout Court ; 0iiD tbe Ctroj afofgneo toas (n a continuance, tobtcb vent for a d t- 
 
 Iras ad proxiraara curiam, fcil. 16. die, iDbcrcas tbc Court luas not Ijclo tftat '^""' '""»"«. 
 tap , but 26. die. Roll luflice fafo, peraDtcntute t^c fciUcct mag be toto. ^'''°""""- 
 Y« the ludgement wa$ reverfed, antea 
 
 ncf. 
 
 Kenifton againft Jones. 
 Pafc 24 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Mich. 13, Car. rot. 587, 
 
 (A iflSfctfonofSDcbttDasbjottgbttipon an obUcratfon toftb conijftfon to '^•e"'"/ "t . 
 J\ Vtann to an atcatD; tbc SDcfcnOant pleats nullum arbimum; tljc^n-ft'^^'^'f' 
 f0la<nt(ff fets fojttj tfie atearc, aoD afstgns a bjeati), ano upon tbat an i^^az^Li, oITobi^ 
 lo jopneb, ant a fpccfal tjcvtifct fs founo, ano upon tljc fpccfpl tcTOfct 2 rjucC^ ca^n to 
 ions arofc, one upon tbe fubmffsfon, Rnotbcr upon ttc atoart). SLbe j. queft.^'n'i to an 1- 
 <on toafl.libetbcta nitfrecftal oftbeoatcof oneof tljeobUgatJongoffubrnff/o''^- , 
 . fion bp m )atb(tratc?0 fn ttefr alcarD , (ball atotD ttje aiiaro. Philips of conciufior 
 Conner UtDltl)tbE|?lafntffftrguEi>tl)at ft ftoulD not, becaufetbatnoU) tlje 
 patties arc concluBCD bp tbc plea, ano tJ)c tcrofrt fount) upon ft, 2lp, Mlje* 
 tbcT t^B ;arWtrato?0 tate CTceeDCD tlje fubrnftafon; Yc bclo tbcp bao not ; 
 fo? the fitll point be fato, i . lEtat the fubnnfsion tons tbe fiibmlislon of tbc 
 parties, ant tbc mlBaWng of t'r e Slrtftratojg of tbe time tebcn ft tons maoe 
 fs not materlal.no J fljall burt it.foj tbc bono of fubmffsfon Is not iji tbc ciiffo- 
 tip of tbc flrbltratojs^inD fo tbcp nilgtt caflilp niftta'nc tbc Date, becatifc tbcp 
 baoftnottoticlu.Piow.Com.yp, Crckers cafc.jlp.SCbcDate oftbcobliaatf^Djtf 
 on Is not an cllcntlal part of tbc obligation, fojanobliaatfon map bcaooD 
 tbougblt babe no Date,i tberfojc tbc miCafelng of tbc Date Is not mml: mate- 
 rial ; slp.CbcrclsnifficlentcertalMtpoftbcfaono evpjcffco In tbcatoaro. 
 tbougbti)eDatcbemifta!jcn,faboloaDDltlonalDcrcrlptlon of ft fball not a. 
 ■boloa gooB Dcfcrlptlon of ft fct fojtblntbeatoaro.DoufihtyescafcCook 3. 
 rep.i Dyerj 9i ^Ip.SI^be mifrecltal is not in toojDs affjrmatltejbut nieerlp in 
 li30?Ds relatives ip.SLbc clanfe of mlfrccftai refers to tbc occo rctftcD bp tbc 
 prout,tobtcbf3 certain enougb, ano tbc laiB rcjcita ttic mifrecltal aa a tblng 
 impertinent, 6. rep. 36. Dyeru(5. Jfo? tbc f^conD popnt, altbougb tbc fub- 
 mirslonfljoulbbcboiOjpctbptbelffiicjopneotbc fubmlfsion Is confcffco, 
 ano It Is noto contrarp to tbc fubmlfsion to plcau nul award, Dyer 3 2. 2 3,29 
 •H. 8. 2. rep, 4, anb tbe patties In onr cafe do olff ct onlp tubctbct tbcrc be 
 an atoart) oj not , ant> not fcibctber tbcrc be a fubmlfsion o;no. dnn as 
 toncbfng tlic atoaro it fclf, 3 bolo tbit tbc fubmlfsion is not etccracD , foz Avvir j. 
 all matters in Difference betirccn tbc parties are fubmtttco ; but not tfjc 
 bonneof tbe fubmlfsion. 2lp. 3it (ball not be tahen to be allcgcD eypjeflp 
 
 £) of
 
 98 Pafc. ^-4Car ^ 
 
 of t!)c matters onl)' fiibmtttco, nnonot ofotb^rsjftftccontrarp Do not api? 
 pear citbcrbi'tl): plaintiff 0r>Ucfat<ono; totibt of tl)c3«rp. jlp. 311 tl)c 
 ahavt.f0pctfojmiDbcfo:ctljci3(rc!)arneof tlic obUgatfono of fubmffflfoti.' 
 4'.r. JIljc aU-.nrD is at lerft £ooD in part . ano it bring not pcrfo?mcD in tl;ia 
 part tijat is gooD, tbc obligation is fc:fcftco, Cook 10, rep. Kcl. 43.45 Hob, 
 pag. 5<57. N"abv* care,ano fo pjapcs Suogcment fo? tljc plaintiff. Latch foj 
 tijc E^Efcncar.t. i . %\)t ttxnia is not tontrnrt' to tl)e iffue, no? aomifoion 
 in plcaoing, no; out of tbc itiuc, but tcitbin it, foj tlje iffuc is trbctbcr tlje a- 
 toarD be gooo modo et for ma , ano t^.c fnbmtfcion is an cfTf ntial part of tie 
 jainarD, ar.Donfbt to be allegcD in tl)c5lU:arb,otf)crUiifctl)c3U)arDf0 
 not gooo , ano it is l)crc alleagcD in tlje ifTtie aKo, Dyer 2 16. <? H. 7. 3 ano 
 tftc negative l)crc implies notling. knottier qncflion is, tol^ctUr t^e 31arg 
 hatcfounDtljcatDamfct fojtl) in ttjc replication , o; tDbctftcr tftep Ijatje 
 foimDanp3U)arDatall, ano if anp aUjaro be founo , itisfucMn0toaro 
 tD^icl) is not in iffuc in tljc replication , ano fo tbc tcrnict is foj tljc JuDcfcn^ 
 Dant. janu as to tbc jatoaro it fcif, 3 tiolo it toio, i"o; tbe parties fjatc not 
 fubmitteo to t fcc 3\tarD tbat ic maoc , foj ttcrc is no fnbmirsion to tftc ue* 
 termination of mjittcrs ariling bctiucen tl)e time of tftc fcaling of one JBono, 
 ano of tbc otftcr JBonD.ano fo tftc Srbitratojs ftaDc crteeiJCD t^c fubmifsion , 
 fojtbepbatcatoaroeD tomaljerclcafcs at tl)C fcalingbf tl)c laft JlBono, 
 \D\3it^ tomp jifctl) all tljc time bcttorcn t^c fcaling of one 15onD , ano of tfte 
 otft-r. jpeyt, part of tftc ^toarD is not gooo bp ertecDing t^c fabmifsion , 
 ano t^fs maUes all tbc atoaro natigljt, fo j all t^c parts of tbis ;atrarD to fo 
 Depcno one upon anotbcr, tbat if one be naugbt all is naugbt. 0no tbe laS 
 partoftbejaujaroisnangbt , ano fo tbcjaicarD is maoc but on tbe one part 
 (tobfcb cannot be gooo,) fo; if tbc rclcafcbcnot maoc, all Actions bcttuccn 
 tbc parties cannot ceafe accosting to tbc atoato , ano fo tbc flloart) is not 
 final ; ant) tbctc is no tcroict bere foj tbc plaintiff, altbour b tbc tc rDict 
 fboulD not be fo; tbe 2I>cfcnDant,foj it appears not iubctbct tbe ijtb. of a- 
 pril be bcfo?e o> after Eafler,ano fo p;apes Sluogemcnt foj tbe )EDefenDant» 
 Roll lufticefaiDjIftbcrc appears a material tiariance bettocen tbcatnarO 
 ifouct '«^t fo?tb , ano tbe aiuaro pleaoeu, it is ill: ano it is a qncttion tobctbcr toe 
 
 be bouno to taUe notice of tbc jaimanacU, ano tbe fcatt oapes tbcre fct 
 OoUin 0} no> Ic was adjoarned to be argued again che next Terra. 
 
 Thynn againft Thynn. 
 
 Pafc* 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 'Opinion of 
 the Court 
 concerning 
 a rctorn. 
 
 Re torn. 
 
 I/p tbis <rare febftcfn eitcptlons fa- ere fojmcrlp tafeen fo tbc OTrIf cfCt* 
 ro;, aroargucD, Bacon lufticefaio, be bao read otrr tbe fccofe, ano 
 Bcubtct tobctbcr manp of tbc €xxo7s fc;merlp afcignco are rot out of 
 Do;cs,becaufc tbc certiorari is not trell rctojnctbefoje n6,fo; tbeceniora* 
 ri is DiretteO to tbe 1Reco?t)cr, ano it fs retojrco bp tU S>t vutp JRccoiccr in 
 bis oton name. Roll luflice ooubtco alfo, fo; be faio, all tbc olo p;i Uitnta 
 iDCTC againft tb<0 tCt0?n, But if the Writ be dirtdtd to a R» cordcr, w h<. ic 
 cuf^osbreviuni, cc to a Recorder, and hit Deputy, then tbe recotn as it it will ' 
 be good. 
 
 Twifden
 
 Pa{c, 24 Car. 9^ 
 
 T^Wifden of Coaticeltoitb fl)c pafntfff in t^c Writ of Crroj in f^c Error and ex- 
 ■^ Wiltfliire caufe tooktIjcfccrccpUons. SttcfirftcircEpttcntahen toae,"?'""'"'* 
 tftatttjCtJcmanooftticDotoj.tslargctt'bantbe o;ffi<nall mttt, fo^ t^at '."^'^'^ '° ' . 
 t!j0 oemano is of tbc ^DarfO) of Timesbory , anfi tljc mrft (0 of tljc Utll of S''"'"' '" 
 Timesbury, Icljfcl) (s not fo large bp fntcnDincnt as a parfO) , bccaufe tbcrc 
 »nap be citcw Gldls f n one parjflj;anD l)C fa(D,tl]at in fomc cafe a Cffltit fljaU 
 teCrain a DcmanO; in eti)crcnfc3 it fljilll not, nainclp toljcrc tl)ej? cannot 
 flanDtogct^cr,anT)fo ii3itl)crc, 21 E, 4. f, 24. 3 h.^.f. 56. a[feconiicj:cep= 
 tion ii a?, tbat tl)c nature of tl)c titles oemanDeo arc not fct fo jtl), altftoug^ Demand. 
 tiiep be rot in grofs, but apprnoant ag tbep oucftt to be, ann a feme teas not q^^^ 
 Dotoabic at all of titljcfl befo;c tl)c statute of 3 1 H 8. anD a feme is Dotoablc 
 of Common appt nbant,biit not of Common in grofs.a tl)itD cjrception toa0, 
 that SDolii; is rccobcreo of a tbfng not Dotoablc, viz. of a quarrp of ttoncs , 
 fojifn)cftoulDbeDol'jablcofaquarrpotftone0, t^ia IdouId be to tbe oc. 
 flruaion of tbe inl)eritsnce,aKa incccu it is impof0ible,fo; a quarrp of ttoncs 
 cannot be nibiocb bp mctce anb bounbs, Ic^icb muff be if (be fbonlD be cn^^ 
 Dotueb of it. ano alfo if tfte mine, ano quarrp Hjoulo be DitiDED,tbc SLcnant 
 oftljciianD tooulo be pjejncfccoj anb t^at a quarrp cannot be niiirieD, fee 
 Cook»Lit, 164. anD fo teas it abjuugeD 2 lac. upon a reference to tlje 
 3uDgE0. i]5ett, tl^erc is alfo CBrroj in fact, fo j tlje l^unDjeb of Warminiler 
 crtenDdintotlic !^unD?cD of Sutton parva , anbfoiffljebecnBoteCD of tftc^"^''"^** 
 l^unc;cD of Warminfter, Ojc tDill bc enootoeo of tbe tiiirb part of tine i^nn= 
 Djcbs, \dW^ is fojc tban Qje ocmanos bp ber Wiiit of tDotoj. May nard 
 ofCo«nceUtoitbtbcSDcfenDantintbeSQritoferro?faio,as to tbe fum- 
 jnons be bclD tberc is a gooD fummons. ano citco Hob. t jyDalt, f. 8^. Sinn 
 tbere map be DiberspariOjes in one ^iU,asiDcU as biters taills in one 
 parifl) ; 0nD to tlje erception tfjat tftc ucmanb of tfte SDote; in tijc Mrit is 
 5cnctall,\i.t)Ercas it ouebt to be a fpecial bcmanb; be anftDcrEb,tbe oemanQ 
 fnSDotej Differs from otbcr be manba. anb (smojefaboureo in laio; fo;. 
 as SDotoj it felf is faboureo in Jiaiu , fo arc tbe pjocecoings in llatn to re- 
 t0bcrit,6E. 3.45. 16 E. 2.7. 8H. 3. II Ed. 3. 8y. 35 Ed. 3. brev» 4i2« 
 Fitz. Dowr 8 E. 3. Sed. 434. Reg. 39. 2nD as to t^efurplufacte in tbe be. 
 jirano, tbis (ball not abate tbc liZIrit 4 E. 3. 5 2. Fitz. brev.7 1 4. flno tbat tbc •^''"«""=nt. 
 parifb lIioulD crtenoout of tbe clill,isaeojcin intcnDment,ano fljall not be 
 rotahcnaaainttan 3tcrmcnt, ano tobcna Uill,anDaparia)are namcD 
 bp one name, one of tbcm (ball not bcintcnbcD larger tbantljc otbEr,if tbe 
 contrarp be not fijcton. Long quint. Ed.4. f. 20. 0nD be arguco tbat a 
 feme is totoablc Of a quarrp , ano tbat it map be cibiDco bp mctcs ano 
 bounbs, fojitmapbcDitioeb bptbcpjoBts, altbougl) it cannot be oibfccD 
 bp tbe quantitp of tbe tbing. Roll luftice faiD , Bp no manner of plcaoing 
 can one abate a Wixit after 3IuDgcment, ano bote ftoulo it be fo bcrcf 
 Sinn 2 Cafes toerc citeo bp tbe CounccU tljat bis petita ftall not abate 
 a Writ. Mich. 9 lac. Bolftrod and Brooks cafe , and Eafton and Styles cafe 
 Ina^ritofSDotoj. 
 
 Pafc-2 4Car- Banc. Reg, 
 
 Arreft of 
 
 nri^cpaintiffbjonaljtanailionofSrErpaircquare viet armis fo: tcf-i"'^?'"'"" '«• 
 
 -*• cuing cfa^jircncroutofbiijpocrcfefon, ano batbatcrottt actainft tbeV"^^°r"°* 
 
 S^cfcnoant. CUe S^efenbant motes in arreft of Hnbgemf nt , foj tbat tbe 1^2 ioz^' " 
 
 ^? 5|0lain»rercou5.
 
 100 Pale. 24 Or. 
 
 jp!nji'.tfff oufbt to {?atc b^ouoljt t)<0 jetton of jBLrcfpafs upon t^c Cafe, ano 
 not an aafoti otSLtcfpafa quare vi &arfnis. iButRoUluQiceanflrercD, 
 ttjst be m<0l)t bate an flcf on upon tl)e Cafe, oj a SCrcfpafg vi & armit at \iis 
 
 Eua-.on of Elrrtfon, ann Hirrrfcjc tijc cjceptfon fa null. J3notl)Cr crtcptfon inas ta. 
 
 Aa;..n. feen, tliat tbcre tuas 4 pears bcttDCcn tbc time of tbc SCtcfpafs Done, ano tbc 
 timt of bringing tbc 0(tion. Roll luflice anflDcreo, pon fbonlb babe pleaQeo 
 tbfe matter <f pou toonlo bate bao aubantage bp it , trat ft fc to no purpofe 
 to urge ft. ^notbct erceptfon toaa taken, tbattbeSDetlaratfonfapatbatbe 
 toon btm fn bfa poITefaf on out of bfs pofTcrsfon. Buc the Court over^ruled this 
 alio, and ordered the Defendant to (hew better matter why ludgemcot 
 (bouid not be given againft him. 
 
 King againft 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car« Banc. Reg. 
 
 Forai'.rcf- XT' I^g bjoogbt BH flrtfort of tbe Cafc (h London agalnft tbc ©cfCHMiit, 
 dcndo in an J\.foj fpcakfng tbcfe tDOjOs of bet Thou art a Whorc,and Cantrels Whore, 
 adion upon and haft been fo this forty years. SCbc SDefenoant tentobeo tbe Canfefnto 
 moved ourc *^*^ ^°"" ^^ ^ Certiorari ; tbe ^lafntfff mobCD fo; a Procedendo, IBut 
 London. HottfnB 11)80 Done fn ft, fo; tbc Coart tnaa fiftfOCD : foj Bacon luftice belo 
 CiiRomc. tbe tDo;Ds not acttonable. iBat Roll lufticcbelo , tbat bptd'e Cnftomcof 
 London tbep Uietc , tbongb not at tbe Common-laiii. 
 
 Aylect again ft &ellam. 
 
 Pafc, 24 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 Oufcwhy noT^Wf**'" upon a talcotCoattto0)etocaare tobp tbctc IboalDnotbea 
 
 n:w Tryai. ■■• ^tto aCtpal, fafD,tbat ttDO tbfnss toetc allegcD on tbc otbet Qde tbat tbcrc 
 ongbt to be a nebo Crpal. i. %\^i ttoo oftbcHnrojotDcreofbfntotbe 
 pafntfff, anD 2lp.2i:bat tbctc traBnotfccsfbcn to tbc SDcfcnoant ofafg- 
 conD Venire facias, ffio tbc firft Of tobtcb be anf iDcrcD, tbat tfje 3;uro js toetc 
 not ofkfn, ano pjoDoccD an Affidavit fo J pjoof. Roll luftice fntcrcnpteo bfin, 
 anofafo,ftfgnotnotD materf al tobetbet tbep be of bfn o^ no, fo^ tbcSDe- 
 
 chaiien;;;. fcnoant fbonlD bate ta!ten aDtantage of tbat npon bfs cbaUenge at tbeXrpal. 
 
 Advantage. 0nD fo J tbc feconi>,ft mattets not tobctbet be sabe notfcc of tbe fccono Venire 
 o}no : fo^tbetnleaoftbcConrtoonotenjopnbftn togtbenotfce.Maynard 
 of Conncel tuftb tbe Defcnoant urgco, tbat tvno of tbc 3!aro j0 tocrc of bfn, 
 ant p? oDotctb an Affidavit to p5iotc ft, ano fain, tbat tbc Dcfenoant icaa aU 
 fo farpjffco foj toant of notfcc oftbcfccono Venire, Roll luftice fafo , tbe 
 fecono Venire ougbt to be cntrcD bcre , ano if ft toerc not enttco, bote can 
 tbe SDcfcntantbnolDiDbetbetftbcaltetcoojno:' l^ctbcrcfanobjeacbof 
 tbc tulC0 of tbe Coatt, ano fo tbe p?oceecDfngs are faft : fo; tbe Venire map 
 
 Entry ^^ cnttcD, oj ft map not be entreo, ano if ft be not cntreo, tbc partp ma? 
 
 go to tbc 0tto}np, anD procure a Copp of ft before tbe 2Cipal: anotbotigb 
 tbc Venire be not cntteotfll after tbc ;ar0ffe0, tttetDCllcnongb. Therefore 
 let the Piaincifftake hit ludgement. 
 
 Thyn
 
 Pafc't»4Car. loi 
 
 Thynagainft Thyn. 
 
 Pdfc, >4 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 LAtchofCoonccltDUl)tftcpa(n«fffit mm^cit of etrojateuetj again, , ,j„t ;, 
 anci ^elo, i. SCljat t^c nature of tlje aCUljca ccmanDCD fn t^e tKHrft of i^.fwf r. 
 ]EDotocr ongftt to fiatcbccn crpjetfeo, fo> t^c Demano map peraotcntarc tc Dunand. 
 of focb scutes, iD^ereoft^c JFcmc (snot Doicablc. zip. ^^crc t^ctWng 
 ft felf fe ticmaniJeD of tD^kbt^je&ftetfff fsto gfbc poCfefsfon, tbcre tlje SDe- 
 tnanDofftongtjttobccertafn : fojasftf0tna 2>cmanDfn:an EJefiionefira 
 iDae,ojanar8ffe,roou0!)tfttobefna2DemanDfna MtUofSDoluer, Dyer, 
 f. 1 1 6. & 2 J 8. n Rep. Harpers Cafe, Dyer, 83. t^c &crgcantg Cafe, 44 E^ 
 3.5. Cooks Entries, tit. Dower p'ac. 2d. ano t|ouo^ tbcSDemanDbeofall 
 SEft^eo, pet t^cp onglit to be fpecffico, as It tsfn Harpers Cafc; ano foftfs 
 of SCftftes fn grofs, 1 1 Rep. Savills Cafe, Mich. 1 2 lac. Bales anD Hamond fn 
 tbf0 Conrt» 0no as to ti^c Heto;n, a C^apelfs oemantieD, ano BiuDcement Recom. 
 Cftjen fo; ft, ano pet tiie lUetojn ootbnot mentfon ft ; ano ft fs not enoagti 
 to compjffc ft fn otbet inojos, ant) ft fs Doabtfull Irbctber a Cfjapel be a 
 SBCenement o% no : fo j ft fs not a temporal 3;nbctftance, as an aotjoinfon fs, Tcntn-.cat. 
 Dyer, 8j. 3!n fomcCafe tfee Mrft map be general, ano tftc Count fpetfal ; '•'^"f- 
 but t^atfsfDbcret^erefsnota fpecfal fo'.m of Witlt. 2lp. a Chapel fsnot 
 contjepcD fn i?fncs anolRecot)erfes,oj <£ntrie0,bp tbc name of a tenement, 
 no^ fnanp fnofcfal pjoceeofngs, butXenementafnaOjantmapcontafna 
 Chapel, jlp. %\iz particular enumeratfon of otfjer tbfngs, ano tbc omft» 
 tfng of tfte Ctapel mabcs ft III; ano fo tooulo ft be fn a (25;ant bp fut^ an c- 
 numcratfon, Dyer 161. %\)t Cafe of tbe Hamlets, j6 Eliz. £wer & Heydon,. 
 ai &22EIiz. tljelBflftopofNorwitchescafe, 8 Rep. 18. Dodioj Bonhams 
 Cafe, 12 Ed. I. Grants 87. iSDtfter Cfceptfons fte toobto tfje Blnogement 
 ano ejecutfon. jTfrtt to tbc 3laagcmcnt,tftat a ^nnojeo cannot be oelftie^ Hundred. 
 reo bp metes ano bounos : foj a i|nno jeo fs but a 3urf fotctton.ano fs entire. 
 
 7 Ip. 2CIie etecutf on fs f U : (0% a Cotitt of iFranfe^pleoge cannot be of tf oeo 
 bp metes ano bounos, -Cooks Inftit. 32. ano S^otoer Is afsfgnable either bp 
 metes ano bounos, 0^ In common oj In fpectat manner, lib. intrac. i8» 
 
 l^e took alfo deceptions to tbe fecono 3!aogemcnt,tt)at oammages of Djm^agcs. 
 
 tbe tjalue of tljc SCftftes are not to be gltjcn In SDotoer ; ncrt tbe 3nqnlQ= 
 
 tfon ootb notfino, tljat tbc ^^nsbano Opcofclfeooft^eSCItl^es , anot^eti 
 
 fibers can be no Stuogcment gfben foj tl>em, ano tfte opfng fclfco of 
 
 tfte IHertojp, Is no oping felfco oftbedt^es, no; Is t^e oping fclfeo of 
 
 t^e Cbapel, a oping felfeo of ttie Cities appurtenant to It , fo;i tbe Cbapel 
 
 fa but tbe C^apclt^ufe, oj£Djato?p,ii Rep. Harpers Cafe. SCtienfoitftc 
 
 (Ecro; fn faa,tt)eDemariOfsoft^e fanner of Lallington, anotblsectcnos 
 
 out of Lullington, anolt Is not repugnant to tije 11eco;o to afsign t^ls CSr- 
 
 ro; In fact, ano it conlo not l^atie been plcaoeo in abatement of t^eMrlt, 
 
 8 E. 3 . 68. a Nuper obiit rcfcmbles a Mrit of Dower, 7 E. 3 . 28. 7 £• 3 • P'» Nuper obi.- 
 5, 12 AIT, 20.26 E.J. 72. 29 Aff.js. 10 E. 4, ii.9E,4. 3.9E,4. 17- SMi 
 
 fo pjapeot^e SJuOgement mIgW be retcrfeo. It was adjourned to be argued 
 again tbe next Term. 
 
 iD 3 Hill
 
 it>2 Pafc. 24Car. 
 
 HiU againft Bird. 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 Caufe why 1° \ 7 Jpon a tuls of Cotitt to fteii) caufc tobp a pjoWbUfon Hjoulo not be 
 yioiiibition to Y grantcDtotficpjcrogatftc. Larch ftatco the CDafe to be tbfs : i3l man 
 '"•^c Couu^'" ^rc'' fntcttatc, m SDaugWct of tijc JlSiotbet of tt)c ^ntettatc ( bcc i?atbet 
 '" ' bctnj DcaD););ocute3 Letters of iaomfniaratton, anoasonoftbe&iftet 
 
 of tbc ?ntrftatc ftics in tbe pjctogatftc to rcbohc tljc aomfnfQration , o: to 
 l)a\3C Diflribtitton of tbe Ooous; tbc iJomfnf Srato: p:ap0 a p jo?)fbtt(on ; atio 
 hereupon be p;ap3,tt)at cttbcr no p joblfaftton at all (0 to be granteD, j clfe ft 
 p.oiiibition. nttitt bcfpccffll.RoIl Iaafce,E:f)e SDaugbtct oU\)t 515:otbcr,anti tbe J15iotl)cr of 
 tbc e><ftct of tbe gntcttate are in equal Degree of IdnojeQ, anD tbe £)jafnarp 
 A 'minWrati- ^^^^ ^^^^^ aomtnfftratfon to tnbff b be pleafctb- Latch urgco, tbat tl)c aomfn^ 
 ""■ ttratfon teas not yet fctleu: fo j it toao gcantco upon ConD(tion,anD ff tbe iSOs 
 
 Inventory, iniiitftratoj iofUnot b;(nB in an fntjentoji,', tbe £?jDfnarp map alter tbe 
 aomfhlCration, Hales on tbe otbcr Coe p:apo, tbetc map be a general pjo= 
 bititfon cuilibct, &:c. Roll lurtice, %\ic p jobibitton muft be agalnft fome cer= 
 tain p:tfon ; but if oitcrsbatic appcareo to fuc, tbere a Pjobfbttion Ojall be 
 againft all of tbem, ano tl)c 31urffoi:(on of tbe Court cannot be cnlargeo bg 
 tbe agreement of tbepartfes , Hob. Tucker ano Bones Cafe. S^nn an aum u 
 RtvocKcn. I nf Oration cannot be rctoheo, foj tbe not bjtnging in of tbe BIntiento?)? 
 }anD ^ccompt bptbcj^omnfttratoj. The libel was afterwards read, which 
 was to havediftributionofthcGoods,orel(e toreverfcthe Letters of admi* 
 miniflration , and upon this the Court granted to a Prohibition, ifcaufeba 
 rot (hewn upon notice to the contrary , as to the Diftribution, but not gene- 
 • rally. 
 
 Leving againft Gamble. 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 fndpcment in T J?- atrctt of Sutigement ft teas urgCD, tbat tbe Di'daratf on teas fncertafrt; 
 
 Trtfpau. 1 to; tbe plaintiff ^aO OeclateD pro quinquc pecias f^anni, angiicc peUjtet- 
 
 tfOjes, trbcrcas pecias ftanni cfD not fignffie pctotcr.offbes ; fojft 
 mfabt be Spoons, Pot0, oz anpotbetfo:t of pester as Incllas Difljea. 
 ArgUoe void, jg^t tbe Couttcel on tbe otbet fine faio, it inas toell enougb, ano p japeo fo; 
 3uDacmcnt, Roll luftice rafD,tbe Anglice Ojall be tofo, ano tben tbe JLa-- 
 ttnfsgooo, foaitisBDcpieccoof petDtcr, ano it matters nottnbat pieces 
 tbcp be : i^o; ft is ad valentiaoi, tobicb maizes tbe baluc certain cnouglj to tbe 
 3iutp. Therefore let the Plaintiff take his Judgement. 
 
 Scoble againft Tolye, 
 
 Pafc. 34 Car, Banc Reg, 
 
 SCoMe b?fngs an Action ofCrefpafs againft Tolye, foi taking a'jcapWa 
 Cattcl, SLbc refenoant plcaDo tbat tbcplaintifif teas potTeffco of tbe 
 cation in'''" Cattel jopntl? toftb anotber not nameo in tbe IKIltit, ann ucmanDs 5ni)gc- 
 Ticfuaf. :t;cnt Of tbe CJHrft, SC^e piafntfff replies, tbat tbe otbet toftb tobom be teas 
 iopntlp potfcff^D teas ocat) at ttje time of tbe action bjongbti SCtieiSDefen- 
 * ^ ' Dant
 
 Pafc. 24Gar. 103 
 
 Dant DcmntsfojDelap. SCticCouttrnlcoa refpondes oailer. Maynardof 
 Conned inftM^c Plafnttff fato , {ttoaspcrcmptojp; Buc the Court was ^-f^'"Pf<"'y- 
 agaJnft him, aad ordered the Deftniani to plead in chief Saturday toNo"^ 
 jng. 
 
 Hart againft Buckminfter- 
 
 Pafc, 24 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Hill, i3Car>rot. 225. 
 
 HArt bjongbt an Sirtfon of 2D0bt aponatt^DbUgatfonof aool.agafnft f^j ^^^^ 
 Buckrainfter,anDfetsfojtbt^attUeconD{tfon o£ tbc jgDbffgatfon toaa dtm.r.dcd of 
 to t\)i6 cffco,.El^at to^ercasHartl^aDcarrpcDfomanpt^oufanDof Billetji Pc». 
 ano DclfKtco ttcm at Dartford in Kent, fo J t^e nfe of Buckminfterjamount- 
 fng at fo ttiutl)bg tbe tftonfann , to a ftunojeu poano in tfte lDftolc,ff t&erefoje 
 tbe SDcfcnoant Ojoulu pap tbe faio bnno?ED ponno at fuc^ a tfmc anu place, 
 tijat t!jcntI)c£)bHgaffon tobctiofti,o?circto bcftifojcc; ano foj nontpap^ 
 went teas tfte Siatoa b;ougl)t» %\)C SJcfcnDant fapc0 tbat t^e plaintiff 
 tin not catrp ano oeUtec fo manp t^oufann of Billets to Dartford 90 ttie 
 |0laint{ffliaDDcclatcD, anDOcmanDsSaogcmentof tftc0(tfon. 2L^epafn= 
 tiff bp toap of tepUcation oemanos 3IuDgcmcnt(ftbc2DefenDantaaUbc 
 aumitteD to pleaot tifs |pica, to^fcb (0 contrarp to t^e abetment of tlie S>bW 
 Satfon, tD^fcb id W0 oion JBDao, ano Ojall not be cffoppeo t^etebp. SCo tbis Eftopie 
 tbe SPcfcnoant Demnro. Stno tbc Court bclo tbat tbf0 recital in tbe £)bltga. 
 tfon (0 an CEttople to tbe SDcfcnOant to pleao t^e contrarp ; and the rule was, 
 for biro to (hew caufe why ludgemenc Ihould not be given againft him upon 
 his Demurrert 
 
 Southcott againfl Southcott. 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car, Banc, Reg» 
 
 Arreflof 
 
 Southcott bjongbt an 0ft{on upon tftc statute ofaEd.<r. fojnotfettfng 
 fojtt) of ICitbes agalntt Southcott , ano batb a DcrDfa Ebe SDefenoant iudgf,venc m 
 tnobC0 in atreft of 3uDgement, ano Ojetoo tbat tl}e E)eclaratton toao too gs- » n Aa.on for 
 nctal ano f ncettafn : foj (t f foj futb aquant<tpof©jafn, anODotbnot'fet'"^"'':"' 
 mt^ tobatfojtofCJjafn, ano fo it map be foj ©jain not titbcablc. May. ^f "*'',' ^'"• 
 nardof Connccltoitljtbcpaintiff bclo, tbat in tb<0 Cafe the SDcclaration 
 tDa0 tncll enough , altbongb it tooulo not babe been fo in an action of trcf« 
 par0,fojt^at action reqtifrc0mo?ecertaintp, SL ao. Ctccption inaa.tbat 
 ft i0 not faiD tobctbct tbc Cojn toag in ©arbs oj fi>bcat)ca. SCo this Maynird 
 faio, tti0iDcUcnoagbnottoitbttanDtng, fojitfljaU be intenocoonlpoffuc^ 
 CDjafn a0 ia nfuallp pat fn ©atb0. Hales ofConncelliiitbtbe SDefenoant 
 fafo, t^c too;D Grain iDa0 too general a too?D to be ufco, ano no certaiiitp in , 
 It, foj ftei:tcnD0 to spuflarD=fceD,Colc-fccD,lvapc=feeD, fc, ano tbc genus "'"'"'''' 
 ougbt to be cspjcffco , ano it fljall not be intcnoco ofCojnpntindDarba. 
 The Court would advife, but endincd the Declaration was too general, and 
 not good, Poftca; 
 
 Pafc.
 
 104 Pafc. 2 4Car. 
 
 Pafc. 24 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 Trcafon f"?"^ ''^ °'° f" ''^ ^ ""1'' "°t P^csD, ano ff !)c Uictc to plcaD a parDDii foj 2Crca« 
 fon, l)t coulD not do ft, till l)C ^ixrc fir ft cbacgcD toft^ tbc Cnofamcnt. ^no 
 JDortoj Stones cafe, 32 Eliz. toas tUcD , anQ It toaa fato ,t!]at t^oagb In 
 an CnDtttmcnt fo;^ iFclonp, If t^c JO jlfoner rcfufc to plcao Ije is to be pjcffeo; 
 
 Prcrsir ^^^ '" SCrcafon It is not fo, fo; If tl)cp?ffoncrlnDi(tcDof2ntcafon\i;ill 
 '' *"^" not put !)lmfclf npon f)lo2CrpaJ, oj anstoet impcttlncntlp , vJjIc'b Is not an. 
 
 iod^cni:nr. siDcrlng« but nugation, (uogcment (l)aU be gitcn asautQ; bint as tahcn pro 
 
 Pro conufT' conftlTotljat^ciscufltp. 
 
 Pafc- 24 Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 Ai^ action of tl)C Cafe ima bjoneftt agafnft one fo; canfmg fbe plafnfif 
 to be cnotttcD of llebeilion ano iFclonp. SLfjeSDcfcnoantmoUcoiti 
 ftiTn upo'nciK ^'''^^^ °f SuDScmcnt, SHD ftclDB, tijat tbc declaration tuas Inccrtaiii, fo j ft 
 Cafe. fCtS fOJti)an CnOlCtmcnt in quo crimen rebellioms ei impofuit & felonii, 
 
 teWcb toojDs are foincertaln, tljat it appears net toljat tbc plaintiff toas 
 coarscD Ujltl) in tftcCnoictmcnt.anB fo tftcrc conlD ncticr bate been anj,'3IiiDg. 
 jnent sibcn agalnftbtm. MiynarJontbeotbcrfiocfaia, it inas tocllc):« 
 pjeffcD, anocoiilDnotiDcUfaeotbcttolfccrpjcffeotbanitis. Bacon luftice 
 Kcbtiiion. faio, tbcvc map be llebcUlon tcbtcb is not capital, ao Hebclilon in Cbanccs 
 inccnt ion. tp. ISut Roil DiffcrcD in opinion, ano falo, tbe intent of tS)c U'ojus fpoUcn is 
 to be COnfiDCrcO.The rule was, to bring Boois to the Judges. 
 
 Mayhue and Balpool^ 
 
 Tr n» 24 Car Banc. Reg. 
 
 BAfpool biounljt an Action upon tfjc Cafe upon a pjomlfc agalntt May. 
 hue, antJ bntb a ^uDgcment againft bim. £D!ic SDefenDant fajings a Mtii 
 
 trror upin 
 In an Aft 
 
 m jD^u?,anBbntb a ^uDgcment againft bim. £D!ic sbefenDant brings a Miit 
 
 ... Ion of Ctto; in tbis Court to rcoerfc tbeKufgcment , an^afsignsfoiGtro?, 
 
 upon iheCaCc. i ^^ ,g not f^lo Im ttjc iDcclaration , tbat ti)c p; omifc Ujns maoc iDitbin tbe 
 3urifDictioit of tbe Co!;rt. 3!5ut Roll lufticc ansiocreo, tbnt it toas, tbat tbe 
 DcfcnDant toes inucbtcD tunc & ibide.-D , U)bicb fljclDS, tbat \)z became 
 iuurd;a;on. fnocbtco toitbtn tbe lutlfoictlon of tbe Court, ano tbe being InocfatcDtb^re 
 Mumpiic. jg an AfTumpiit in ILain, tljat be ticill pap tbe Debt , ano tbcrcfojc it is not 
 necofnil tofljciDcrpjcflptbatfteOlopjomlfctbcretopapit, sip. 2C!;eVe= 
 nire fs duodccim probos & legales homines, tol)creac ,it llloulD be iiberos, 
 &c. But the Court overruled this exception aifo, anJ affirmed the Iudge» 
 ment exccp: bttttr matter ihould be fliewn, 
 
 Win
 
 Trin, 24Car. 105 
 
 Winn againfl Stebbins 
 
 Trin, 24 Car, Bine Reg* 
 
 VJDon a rule of Conrt foj a rcfhencc to tfjc &e£ontiarp,tDt)ct&cr tljc p3r= whaher » 
 tp,anDt!)e&l3crtff mere <n contempt toilje Court foj tabtng oat offj^J""'"'?"^ 
 Cmutfon , ano erccuttng ft aftcratKHrftofCgrrojbjougljtiipona ^'.\^^- nor. ''""' 
 mcntjfttoasmotjeo ttjatUcmfgftt maUcbfsrepoit, ir^otijcrciipon rcpo> 
 teo to t\)is cfFett • 2Eftat tftcre toas a tojU ot CBrroj bjotigljt upon tbe 3uogc= j^ . 
 ment befoje CEjiccatlon tabcn fojtl) ; but tl^erctoag no notice thereof oftJen " '""^*' 
 to tftc pattp, noi anp Aiperfedeas tahcn fo;tf) to ttap Crcctitton , ano tljete- 
 fojetfjeJDIafnttfmfgbttaheout Crccutfon, notli)US)ftaiiDmg ttje \aiit of "^"""'""^pf. 
 CErro J brought , anu tbat t^crebp be is not tn contempt to t^c Court. Roll 
 lofticefafD.SCbentatfteCEFccuttonnolD toeU crccateo, ano tl)e febctff ts Exccmion. 
 in no fault. Maynard Of Counccl toftlj tbc |Dlalnt<f (n ttie Id jit of (Etroj , 
 tnotjeo tbat tlje Cpccntfon teas atcaroco improvide , ano tl)crcfo}e the 
 Court map rcttojctftepartptof)iggooD0takcnin(2;recution, altljougl) t^c 
 fe^jerf f be not in fault. Roll luftice, SCfje partp ougljt to tafee notice of a re. 
 cipiturupontbclRccojDifitbecntreo, anoiftbcpartptabc out ©rccutfon 
 after tl)E tojit of GErro j fs allotocD, ftc ta in contempt to tbe Court, clfc not , 
 ano ti^e aittojnp ia not bouno to tfeio tbc 3RccojD to^etbcr a in jit of ©rro j 5 . , 
 be bjoiigtjt ; butmaptabcout CBrccntioniftbercbe not a fuperfedeas, oj ^ 
 notice gibcn to tbc partp, SCbcrcfo jc tfterc is no Ijelp Ijcre.foj tl)e pjoceeD« 
 <ngeybatebeenaccoj{)fngtot|iccourreoftbeConrt,foj bp tbe oelf&erp of 
 t&e iDjtt of Crro J to t^c £Dfficet of tfte Conrt,tl)C ^anos of tbe Court are clo= 
 feo. Yet let M fee tbePrcfident that Wood ward hach to ihew, and let ilie 
 Secondary examine it again. 
 
 Trin. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Ai^ jam'on of accompt iuas bjoug^t toutljing tbe frafgftt of a &bip, ano a ^^"^ '^'"^'.f<= f*- 
 JiaDgcment tftat t^c E>cfenDant fljall accompt, ano auDito:s afcign- manu/apms 
 (D.ano ipanncaptojsfouno to appear bcfojetbe51uDttoj0,t&c Court leas 
 inoteo foj a fcire facias agafnlt t^e spanncaptojs, becanfe tbat tbe S>efen< 
 Bant Dio not appear at tbe cap befoje tbe 0uD(tojs afgfgnco , ano feconolp 
 It Inas motjeD tbat tbc Court IdouId afstgne a cap percmpto jp, foj tfje par- „ .. 
 tp to appear bcfojc tbe auoitojs. IBut Roll Inftice fafo , a Dap cannot be J* jifo"?' 
 afsigncD antiU a certificate be maOB to us from tbe ^uoitojg; foj tijep arc 
 trutteD , ann are SInoges of t^e canfe , ano baDe potner to ercufe tbe non- 
 appearance of tbe partp at tlje t)ap,ff t^ep fee caufc , ano to gitie longer cap 
 ojQjo?ter,fojt^e partp to appear an t^cp tbinfe gooo , eno t&ercfoje till . 
 tftcptettifiejnett^ctcanpoHtjatjeaoapafsisnc^noj^ ^cire facias againft ^''" '■'^'"' 
 t^e ^anucapto}0» 
 
 ,fB Cleracnti
 
 io6 Trin. ^4Car 
 
 Clementfon againft Montford 
 
 Trin,24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 Hill. »3 Car, rot, 1493. 
 
 vcrfejhid'te- /\ ont^c^afc bjoiigiitbpan jaomfii(ttrato;i fntfts Court at Efham 
 
 iiieMinan L * jTj^c (j^rrojB afofgucD u ctc, I. 2Lf)c piaftitffF Dot!) not Declare tftat 
 
 aa^cn upon thc nDitilntftratJon U no gtantcD unto fjtnt per loci iliius ordinarium. ilp.SClje 
 
 the cak. JpiaintffF fflltl) hi l)fo ©cclaration, producic litteras Adrainiftrarorias intefta* 
 
 ti,li;l.KrcEs<tfl)ouHibcordinarii,anl)notinteftati. 3!^. iDfte Court cannot 
 
 Capias.. i)p (to p;{()llcgc bctnc an fnfcrfour Court,a!iD tbat but nclDlp crcrtcD. atoaro 
 
 a Capias upon cntrtng tl)5plafnt, aaftia l)crcDonc. ^Ip. 2L^r Court began 
 
 firft to be a Court, but 9 lac anD pet It fs fa(D to be Ijclo per ufum « confue- 
 
 tudinem curiae. Twifdento't!)C i. crccpKOrt faiO, tftat it IB IjclpcD bp tlje 
 
 tcroftf. Roll lufliceaBfeCDl)o\uDotb ft appear tljat EfliamfslDttbfnt^cSDt' 
 
 occf0oftt:c31BiQjop HjatgnuUcotfteiLcttcrsof aDmfmttratfon,fo?<f <t be 
 
 not, tftc iLcttcro arc not tocD grantcB ; fl»ii faiD, tljat fn a ©cdaratfon it 
 
 AdnvniOraiioi {BUotnECCffarptofaptbntiLctteraofiiDniinittrationarc grantet) per loci 
 
 Declaration. I'llius ordinarium, aut cui pertinuit, alt^ougl) tftcp ounl)t to be fo plCaDCD fn a 
 
 ^1". pica fn 55ar. Eo tt)C fccono cjceptfon, Twifden anftDcrcD, tl)at tljc iBOjBs 
 
 mcnttoneo are not necelTarp , ant) tbe SDedaratfon tooulube gooD enough 
 
 iDfttout tbcm , anDtbcrcfojctbcpOiallnotburtft, tljough tljcp be mftta* 
 
 hen , anoffftajoulDbcotftcririre.pettfjeparc bclpcobp tbc u'crDfttj ano 
 
 to tl)C firft crccption !)C fafO, t!)at fbC too jDs fecundnm ufum et confucto4nem 
 
 fliall be tntenDcti to be meant accoiDfng to tijc Laiu, anft not acco?Dfng to 
 
 aucfcnt ufage, as fs urcco fap ttje Councell on tl)e otijcr fioc. The rule was 
 
 that ludgemenc be affirmed except better matter fhould be flhcwn Monday 
 
 next. 
 
 Read againftPiImer. 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 Am«of -p Ead bjinas an aitton upon tl)c Cafe upon an ^fTumpfi-fo ffano to an 
 
 ■nanTai"'.. *^ aWnrD againft Palmer, auo l)atb 3 bciDtct. S:!)C SDcfcnoant mobcs 
 
 iifonihecafr.tnatrettofBinogcmcnt, ano ftjetog tljat tftere icaa an amenamcnt in the 
 
 ccmfitjcratfon , ant tftc p^omtfe after tbc fffuc lopnci;. Twifdcn miftDereo, 
 
 ft 13 not material, tljoufi!) ft be fo, fo} tl>c matter of t^ A flumpfit fs implpeo, 
 
 anD tljc teo;?i5 altered) are fole, anD cfteD 3 7 El. Heydons Cafe, fo j ft is dc et 
 
 Amcrccmcrt. i^uper prffraiflis, toWtt)fmplpes all tl)c wattcr. Roll Iul>ice rafD , \W Wft 
 
 toojDsdcetfuperprafraiftls goc not to tl)e time, but to tf)c matter fubmit. 
 
 ^ £, . teD, anD faiD tl)att&clD0?Dc poilpa, fcilicet ecdem die, upon a contract fn 
 
 T,w"' '" iIatx)ftjaUbcfntenDeDtbctfmeoftl)ctontract,(jiitl}crc(3a IVccf all contract 
 
 fpcciai con- anD collatctal , anD U ougtjt to be ottjcrtoffe tntcnocc, anddtfired to fee 
 
 tisft a book. 
 
 free«
 
 Trin. 24Car. 107 
 
 Freeborn againft Purchafe, 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Hill, 23 Car,roM575; 
 
 FReebornbjousW an action upon t^c Cafe againft Purchafc, anU 00-°!^"""'"° 
 dates tf)attt)eff)efcnDantfnconCDcratfontljat t^e paintfff tao V&i^*n i':,\aion'^ 
 imtoljimrucbafum of moncp,DtoairunJC,anDpjom{reto iopn in tl)C fur- upon the c«fc. 
 tcnoct of certain Coppl)olD iLanos, anotftat foj not performing tWs 
 pjomlfe tje b^inqs ftfs actfon, SCtie SDefcnoant Demurs upon tftc E)cclata. ^^ ^5^ 
 tton , a-.'.D ftctes tbat tftc piaf ntf flf Dot!) not allege t^at be mase anp reqtitft 
 to tfjc SDefcnoant to jopn in tfte furrcnoer, totikl) Ije ugftt to Do , fo? (t luaa 
 notafiuglertcttobeDonebptlFtDcfenDantalone; butbe tuas to jopn in 
 ttieiactloUljaiiotbct, Roll JufticefalD.tbcp^omffe Is <bat fftc SDcfenoant 
 fiian Iopn fn tfte furtcnoet , anD !jc cot'i not fap tbat be Dforequctt b'm to ^'"^^' 
 jopn, tT3t)tcb be HjoulD batoc Done. ^InDbcfiDcs ttie b;eacb<a not toell af- 
 6gneD, for pou babe afsigncD a particular leap boto be IboulD furrenoeti 
 namelpintotbebanD0of2£Cenantsoftbe mannour, Icbereas be oiD af: 
 fame onlp to |opn in a furrenoer, tobfcb map be in Court , or fnto tbe banDs 
 oftbelLorD,asU)eUas{nto tbe banos of tloo SEenants; fo (0 Syms ant> 
 Walkers Cafe, 9 Car, aifo tbe painttff ougbt to Ijabe rbctocD tbat tbete ia 
 fntbapatt(cnlarcuftom<ntbemanonr,tbataCor.pboIo STenant map fur«'^°"«' 
 tenccr into tbe banos of ttoo aCenants of tbe manour, oj clfs fac^) a Cuttom 
 cannot be taken notice of. Therefore lee a nil capiat per billam be encred a- 
 gainft ttie Piainciff« 
 
 Wright againft Martin. 
 
 Trin, 34 Car, Banc, Reg* 
 
 To chauge a 
 
 Tl^c Court toas mobeo to cbangc tbe benuc in m 0(tion foj an efcape, l^^^ ,'"/J^ 
 upon an affidavit' tbat tbe cfcapc toncbing \xjW>) tbe Action toascfcapc. 
 bjougbt loas in anotbec Conntp , anonotintbcCountplcbere tbe jSction LocaJ.' 
 tnasbrougbt. 55ntRoll luftlcefafD, tbat an efcape fn one place is an ef= 
 capeall England obet, anD is not local ; tbcrcfojctbc "Dcnnc is not to be 
 tpeD to one place more tban anotber. Yec let tbe otiicr party (hew caufe 
 why the venae ftioald not be altced, 
 
 Trin- 2 4Car- Bare, Reg. 
 
 'V\ponaruletofl)ciDcauretobp3uDgcment fljonlD not be ffapcp in an an^vcrcaTr^ 
 V SLUion upon the Statute of 2 Ed. 6. for not fctttng fortb of SDitbcs, tbcfc ic.cd in arr'cft 
 crccptionsformcrlp taken toete anfujcrcD, 1, St teas faio tbe Statute [>" ludecmcuc 
 toao mIfrccftcD , for tbe Dap toben tbe parliament began iobercin tbe S>ta> ^"'^^'.^'^^ 
 ttite toas maoe is mtffafeen ; but to tbto it is anfUieceD, tbat tbe Declaration "^""oVi e "" 
 DOtb not fap per Staiutum in Parliamento inchoat. tali die, but in Parliament, e. tor not ic'- 
 tento tall die , anD tbc parliament toas belD bp prorogation tlie Dap tbat it tjrg tortii ut 
 {ament{oncD,tbounbtttocrcnottbenftrtt begun , anD fo tbat fs toell e. y;''=> 
 nougb- CotbcfcconDcrccptton.tbattbc JDcdaratfon Dotl) fap tbat tbc ^"'"'^ 
 plaintiff Uiasprimo die occupatoracpofleaeodem die, £vc. ^0 tbat it ap^ 
 
 P2 pwrg
 
 i68 Trin. 24 Car. 
 
 Proprietor, pears not , tliat be teas proprietor , ann fo tf)C SLdion map not Ipc , foj ftc 
 mapbeoccupatortD^onsfuUp, ano fo not propriecor» 3!t is anriscrcD, tl)at 
 tl)C E^Ltlaration i0, tbatbc iuas tali die pofTeHionatus et ab eodem die occu- 
 pavic , ano Wiia (ball be jtiDgeo o{ a rigbtftill cffate , anti <t is fafo , tbat be 
 igredorecclefiac, aiiD fo be (ball be flltcnOCD proprietor of tbc SCttbeo , If 
 tbccontrarpbcnottbcton. The rule was to (hew better caufe Friday fol» 
 lowing, eife Judgement tor the Plaintiff. 
 
 »S'owthcott againfl Sovvthcorc. 
 
 Trin, 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Excepimrs T/ptbfsCafc fojmctlp mofecD , ano 3!tiogemciit ffapeo tfu tbc pafntlff 
 
 ken to ar "ft ^''"^° '"°^^ • Maynard fo j tbc Hpiaf nt(ff mobcD f oj 3IuDBcment , ano to 
 
 judpemcr.t i„ tbe OTtcptton taUctt OH tftc otbct Ooc, tbat tbt toojD gta(n ufcn (n tbe j©e» 
 
 an aftion tor clatatfon is too gcHCral, ano map crtcno to grafn not tftbcafaU, viz. to rape« 
 
 tithe*. fccDanDcolc-fccD, &c. aflUcUas to tdbcablc , anofo tbe SDcclatation ia 
 
 ' "• (nccrtafn; ^c fa<D it is tucll cnougb, fo; it is fato grain grotoing in fucb a 
 
 fielDbp name, tobicbmafew it certain, 2 rep. lib. inr. 176. id, Coment,f. 
 
 1 6 1 . b. ano fo J tbc VT30JD grain in comon unoctttantJing it is meant fo j to jn, 
 
 anDnotfo}fcED0,tbongbina large exception it map ertcno to fceos alfo. 
 
 Hales on tbe otbcrftocfaio, tbat tbe uio?D grain is incettain, ano Qgnifica 
 
 mojetbancojn, anoalfotbciDOjoGarbxiBtoogcncrall, fo} it map ej* 
 
 tcnotomojetbanfbeafsofCojn, fo;ibnnDlc3ofanp tbfng bouno up map 
 
 be fato to be Garbae, as Uicll as Cojn bouno in (bcafs , ano map cytcno al- 
 
 fo to firain not titbcablc. Roll luftice bclo, tbe toojos in tbe SDeclatation. 
 
 Comon jmcitSeminavit cum granopjopcr cnougb, anotbat bp common conttruction it 
 
 (ball be meant U)itb Co jn, anonottoltbrecos, loCar, Goldfmitlis Cafe, 
 
 Hill. rot. 8 . ano fo J Garbae, it is alfo toell cnougb , foj it (ball be taben 
 
 acco;Ding to common conffru(tion,tDbicbis to rignifteco?n bouno up, ant) 
 
 (ball not be taljcn in tbc large crtcnt of tbc toojo fo? bunoles of anp tbing 
 
 clfc. 0no tbc Jurpbatbtabenrotice of it, foj tbcp babe founo debet, 
 
 itbicb bao tbci' not tbcp coulo not bat)C founo tbe teroict fo. The rule was 
 
 for the Plaintiff CO take his Judgement, if caufe wcrcnot (hewn Friday follow* 
 
 ing. 
 
 ^he King and Sr. Henry Spiller 
 
 Trin. 24Car. anc. Reg, 
 
 For quafbipt "T ^^cCourt luas molico fo J tbc quatbing of otbets CBiiOlctmcnts tobcrcin 
 d vash..d;a- ± Sr. Henry spiller uaocnoicteo (0 J not repairing a b;fDae;tbc cjception 
 "^:";'\'"/j''^to tbe firtt teas, tbat it ootb not fetfo?tb in tobat Countp tbcbjlogetpes, 
 'hirac^' anofo; tbat erccption it teas qtiaibco. anotber CnoictmentUias foi not 
 repairing of Ma^s Bridge ,ano It ootb not IbciB tbat tbc b;iOge is in tbc i^igb* 
 Irap. JButtotbis Roll luflice fato, tbat tbcCDtioictmcntootb fapit is a 
 Common bjioge, ano that fo cnougb, ano ft is nccolclTc to fap it ia in tbe 
 ^igbuap. :anotberc);ccptfonuiastabcn to tbts CBnofctmcnt ; tbat ft ota 
 not (beta tibctbcr tbc bMogc toere a cart bjioge, oj a boife bjfoge, o; a foot 
 bjfoge, 0; tobat otber paffage tuas obcr ft , ano fo; tbat erceptfonltbat (Bn-- 
 ofttment teas quafbeo. %o a tbfro Cnoictmcnt fo? not repafrfng'tbc fame 
 b;iDse,tbiscj:ccptfon teas taKen, viz, %t fapcstbatSr. Henry Spillar toas 
 
 bounft 
 
 g
 
 Tirin. 24 Car. ib9 
 
 bouiiO to tcpaft tl5eb?flJSSratiorie manerii,iDf)fc6 cannot be gooDjbHt (tftoulB ?. 
 
 Lc ratioci tenune reintrii. Roll luftice faid, 3t ougftt to QjCir; tbat Ije is 0tD= 
 
 nerottljeinanout, ano altbougljitDocfpjcirctljatbcfsbounotorcpait it 
 
 ratione raanerii fui, tljat fs butimpUcattontljat \)c (flto repair U, ano mahcs i "piiMuon; 
 
 ft not appear tl)atl)c is poffeffco of tfteman3?,anD upon tbfs cjceptfon teas 
 
 tbfs CnDfctmcnt quaftjeo. SEo a fotirtl) (Enofitment foj not repairing tl)C Addition, 
 
 fame bjiDKC,tl){0 ejception ira0tafeen,tbattl)crc isroaooition of tbc Coun* 
 
 tp.inftcrcSr. Henry SpillarDtoelt,a3tfte &tatutc Directs, ano foj ttts ft 
 
 leas alfo quafljcD. |3ct aftcrtoarofl bccaufe tljere toas no certificate tljat 
 
 tfte bjiogc toas repaireo, tbc Court isouln quaO) none of tftcm , but fato, let 
 
 Wm pleas to tljem : SCbeaDcfenoantsCouncclmotjeDtbatbe migbt pleatt 
 
 buttotiuooftbem, ano tljat p joccffe migbt be fpareD to t^c rcft» Roll 
 
 lufticc, Appear to all, and plead , and proceed m two of therii, and precede 
 
 ihall be flayed to the refl. 
 
 Burrcl and Lancafter- 
 
 Trin. 14 Car, Banc. Reg, 
 
 BUfrell bjougbt an Jetton of SCrcfpaffc quare claufum fregic agafntt Ian* Air.-ft of 
 carter, anD 1)80 a tjcroict; tbc SDcfcnoant tnobco in arrcft of 3IuDgemcnt, ' "''^'"l'"' '"■ 
 ano foj caufe fljciiio tbat tbere is a t?ariancc bettoecn tbe Utiit , ano tbe 3De» rVciaufum"*" 
 claration, fo? tijc to;it is quare claufum fregit in tijc fingular number , ano r epr. 
 tftc paintlff Declares of Ditcrs Clofes ; 3iBut Roll luftice faiD,2i:bat it isas van.nce, 
 tocU enougb, foj ttC too JD claufum is nomen af^gregativum , anD map con- Nomen ag- 
 
 tain manp Clofes , ano fo map tocU enouglj agree toitl) t^c ^Dcclarationt S'^^e"'*""'- 
 And therefore let the Plhintiff take his ludgemenr. 
 
 Glide againfi: Dudenejr. 
 Trin, 24 Car, Bmc, Reg, 
 Pafcw 24Car*ror*42tf» 
 
 Glide bjings an ejeaionc firroxagainff Dudeney in tftc Common picas, Error upon a 
 ano IjatJ) a ^uogemcnt bp Default againft tbe SDefenDant, tobercupon a lucgcmcnc ir> 
 iDjtt of enquirpiffucs out to enquire of tljcSDamagcs, ana befojc tijc te= ^." '^J'^"'"'= 
 to?n tbetrof,tbe H)efenDant bjings a lD?it of Crro?, tbc queftion teas, tube* crm'^n"pica 
 tijer tbe tojit of (Etroj tocre itell bjougbt, in regarD tbat the tourfc of tbe * ' 
 Common pleas is not to make up tlje Siuogment untiu the Ui;it of enquirp 
 be rcto jncD. Roll luflice faiD,t|)at a to?rt of Crro; map be bjougbt bcfojc tljc 
 tD?it of enquirp be retojneo in an ejedione firrax, foj in that action tbC 
 3nogemrnt is compleat at tbc Common BLaln before it be retoancD,fo j tbe g"''^^"'^"'* 
 3nDgcmcnt is but to gain pollefsion , anD fo is ft in a tojft of iDoivtt ; but 
 in an action of SLrcfpaffe b bcre Damages onlp arc to be re cotcrcD^tberc tbc 
 Jnogemcnt is not perfect till tbc to jft of etiquirp is retojneo, no'j can be 
 maDcup bcfojc as in tbis cafe it map, but in regaro tbat bcrc is no compleat 
 3ubgcmcnt entrcD, foj tbcrcis no capiat tcbicb ougbt to be in all Actions 
 quare vi et armisjtljat t|e JSing map bate bis fine tobicb dft be cannot bate 
 
 l?3 ft
 
 Arreft of 
 lu<*gement in 
 AiVjuIc and 
 Battery. 
 Mif-[worn 
 
 no Xrin. 24 Car. 
 
 Fn^ inlic^arfp Bonotpiorat) iiiMsCSTrft ofCnqnfrp, tfjcMrftofcSrrojfa 
 Extcution. b:oi!f;l)t too fooii , ano pou map pjocceo to CFCcntion in tftc Common picas, 
 
 foj ti)C complcat RctojDtfl not ^crc. Therefore advilc what to do in the 
 
 Comnaon-pleas, for icis mikhicvous quacunque via, 
 
 Norton againft 
 
 Trin, 24 C ar. Banc, Reg* 
 
 Norton bjouglit an Sctfon of ananlt ano1Battcrpagafnfftl)Cffi)cfen« 
 Daiit, ano tjao a tcroftt agair.tt !)<m. EbE SDefcnDantmotocDfnat- 
 rrft of guDgentcntjtftat fn tbc Veinre facias one oftbc 3aro?0 toas retojnctt 
 bp tl)C uamc of EJmund, anD it appears bp t^e Poftea, tljat be toaa rtoojn bg 
 tbc name of E' ward, ubfcb cannot be intcnDco to be tbc fame pcifon. Roll 
 Jofticc fato , If tbc Clcrb of tbc flfsf fcs, f n rctarnfng of tbc Poftea babe mff- 
 Amendmcm. ^^^^^ ^^^ mvnc, it map bc amcnDCD bcrc fn Contt bp bis notes, bp tnbfcb be 
 maoe tbc Poftea; and therefore let bim be examined here whether it be a taid 
 take or no, 
 
 Toby againft Angel- 
 
 Trin. 34 Car- Banc Reg. 
 
 TTI^c Court tDaflmobcDfoj a reference fntbfsCan''0 to f be ^ccontarp, 
 -■■ bccaufe tbc futcfcoascommcncei) upon ttooCotrntcr-bontis, toWtbarc 
 bo bcanciUcD. Roll inftice anftoerco, tben tobp Ibonloft be rcfetrcD : (0% 
 pou map p.cao non damnificatus, U tbc ttntb of tbc matter bfe fotbut tbc partp 
 jnap perauticntnrc be DamnfftcD , nottoitbftanDfng tbc JBonDs be canceUeOj 
 ano map.batc gooDcaufc of Sidton, 
 
 For a refe- 
 rence. 
 
 Langly againft Wybord. 
 Trin. 34 Can Banc, Reg, 
 
 Demurrer to T Angly bjougbt an Siniott of SDcM opoii Stt iDblfgaffof! to ffanB to an SI'- 
 
 a Repiicatioi. ^L/trstD agafuft Wybord. SCbc Defcnbant pleabs nullum Arbitrium. JCbc 
 
 in Debtupo, |0ia(ritfff replies, tbattbc3rb(trato?sDft> mafee an ^^rarb, ant) fcts <t fojtb 
 
 "jp^'!S'"''"inhxc verba; SCbc DcfcnDant Dcmutganbfljctos fojcauff, tbat tbc atuattt 
 
 L^d "* "" fs not tocll ret f onb : fo> be iJOtb not IftetD, tbat tbe jatoaro \x as Dclf bcrCD op 
 
 Award'. bp tbE Arbitrators, actojofng to tbc fubmtrston. Roll luftice anfioc* 
 
 rco, tt teas tocll enongb, tbougb <t bc not, a feconb canfc Iras, tbat it is not 
 
 faiD toncbtng tnbat fates tbc atoatD teas matic. Roll Juftice aiiftDcrcD, 
 
 tbcA^xartisfaiOtofacdepriraifsis, anbtbatisgoot) cnoucb. sip. 'E-^t SI- 
 
 loarD is, tbat all fiites Qjall ceafc. Roll lufticc, Ebis is iccll cnougb. 4lp. Subc 
 
 ^rbitrato;s If&^t crcceDeb tbcir fubmifsion. The rule was to bring the Roll 
 
 into Court, and till then the former rule to ftand. Afterwards the Award was 
 
 judged good, and the Plaintiff had his ludgement. 
 
 Trin»
 
 Tiin.2 4Car, m 
 
 Tun, 24 Or. Banc. Reg. 
 
 re- 
 
 c- 
 
 A tK3[rftof(IErrojtDasb:oijaf)ttorc*ocrrc a^mccment cftcn fit an 3I«* Errorro 
 ^L\fcttoiitU:ourt, anBtbcCrrojafotgncotoas, Sftat tljc~plafnt inae cn= ^i^rfeajude 
 trcD bcfojc fiicb an onccpafo;-anDtf)c futctoacccntmucobcfojcanotber f""''"f?"'"' 
 i^afo?,ancittgnota)ctDntl)3t tfjcftrC: ^nfo: lyacrcmo'oca, ano that tlje ' """^ 
 otljcr cpatoj luao latofuUp clcctcn ano ftoo?ti.Roll luRkc fatD,tl;at tl)c Conti- 
 nuances fir Jnfcdoiir Courts ougftt to OjctDtfjemartncr oftftc Conttnuan* ^°"''""*""' 
 CCS, ano it ounljt not to be crpjcffco gcncrallp. l^nn it is not fan tunc mi. 
 jori, teljfcb toonlO^atC maUcftnsojetnccrtafn. I doubt the Venire facias is Tryal. 
 difcontinued, and then there is ro Tryal; therefore it is good to advife» t 
 
 Pragnell againft GofF 
 
 24 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 GOff bjfngs an flctfon upon an Affumpfu againft PragncII , anD batb a Error upon 
 t)ero((t, ano a Buogemcnt agatnfttifin. ac^e IDefcnoant bjfngsa tSHrit » ludgcmcnt 
 of Crroj to rctctfc tbfs Snoctcmcnt. %H Cdfc taas VqIh, Pragnell oto aC- '" ="' '*^'"" 
 fume ano pjomtfcunto Goff, tliat fn conSDcratton tOntGoffUioulomarp^P""^"*^'^ 
 tf)C SDaua^ter of Pragnell, tbatfjciuoalDbcbouncto nioc oijcr tits &bop un. '"'"^ 
 to^tin,anD not ufe^tits SCraoc in Bafingftoke , anD icoulD leno unto bint fiftp 
 pouno , ano foi not performing t^is pjomifc Ijc bao feia 5uDgcmcnt» %\fc 
 €rroj nrsignco teas, tl;at tljcre is a bjeatlj laio cf all tftcp}omife,tel)itbcon= .ffuir.pfir 
 fitts of Dibers parts, ano oncpartofitiaagaintt 3la\D, namelp.tlje^jD.'' ' 
 
 ntifc to be bouno not to ufe bis 2CraDc, ano ret oammagps arc gitjcn cntirc« 
 \v foj all, tubifl) is not goon. Wild on Courtcl on tljc otftcr ftoc faiD,tbat in 
 2 H, 5. urgcDts no 3"t)gcmcntgft)eii, ano in oar Cafe it is not tbat be fljall 
 be bouno not to ufe bfsCraoc senctallp,but onlp in tbcSEotrn of BafingHoke, 
 ano 1}C map nfc it anp mbcrc clfe, ano tbcrcfojc it is not acrsinft Jiato. Roll 
 Iuftice,5f tbc iDojos be gcncral,tbat be Iball rot nft b'sSEraoc in futb a plate 
 InUbout anp confioetatton, tbts is ill : but it is ottjcriuircif t^cre be a conOoe- 
 ratfon,foj a man map fell bis Jlibcrtp t pjfoilcgc foj a c;onfiacratioti,anD it 
 fljall bino bim. The rule i>as to (hew caiife Saturday next why ludgemen: 
 ihould not be afiirmcd. 2Ebis teas aftcrlrarOs mobcD t ofaicflco, tbat part of q,^jj„ 
 tbc Ailutnpfu tuas to turn otcr tbc Ocfanoants Slraoc, ano oammaacs gi= ^'''' 
 
 \3cn fojtbat tDbicbisimpofsiblc. Roll /ufticefaiD,if oammages entire' be gt= 
 ijcn fo: fomc things feitb otbcrs toberoffomc arc imporsiblr,tbc Dammagca 
 fball be oeemco to be uivcn fo;tbofctbatarcpof£ibU,anDUoiototbcrca» 
 The Indgement was affirmed. 
 
 PecHng againft Ken. 
 
 Trin, 24 C«r. Banc. Reg* 
 
 Pafc»Z4Car. rot, 89, D:murrer ro 
 
 • Replicaiion , 
 
 PficUng bjoHo^ an SdioM of 2!>cbt upon an £)blfgation to Cano to an 5i. •" i^'^c 
 Inaro againtt Ken. SLbc SDefcnoant plcaos Nullum Aibitrium. 2Ebc"P^" onobu- 
 |3laintlff replies ano fcts fojtb tbe jatoaro in faee verba, anDafsign8aft''nd1o"ana- 
 
 bjear^-vard.
 
 iiz Tr;n 2 4Car. 
 
 bjcaclj. EC'jc 2D:fcnDant Dcmnrs to t^c UcpUcatfon, ano Vac piafntfff iopng 
 {[ttbcSDcinurrcr. Ctjccaiifccsafsigncofoi t!)C tDcmurcrtocrc, i. 2lo tijc 
 
 .".ni-.d. 0toaro it felf, icbtcb is tbat mfjercas it appears tbat tl)crc leas fir pouno ano 
 a flillUng Due bptbc plaintiff unto ttjeSDcfcnoant; tljc ^rbitratojs Ijaoa- 
 icarocD, tUat tJjc plaintiff ftoulo pap unto tl)C Dcfcnoant fir pouno in fuB 
 fatisfacion thereof :U)fti£l) is Icffctfjaiii tftcpocUnoui'.ciJjjcto be Due, fotljat 
 <t cannot be a fatlofactton, 9 H. 7. f. 1 1. 46 E. 3 f. 7. 2lp. SCtjc iltearD i>3,tljat 
 on2 of tlje parties fljallDclitct Dimifsionem pracdidam, iBijcrcas it ounl)t 
 to be Indcnruraoi dimifsionis : foj ttjcDimifsion is but tl)Cconrcnt of tfjcpac- 
 tp to tl)c Jnocntnte, anDHOt t^c Jnocnturcit fclf,Cooks Inflit. 43 6 5lp» 
 2CIjep aicaro to Dclibcr dimifsionem pracdiSam in tbel^oufc ofa&trangcr, 
 tobicft 0HCl)t not to be: foj tbe pattp mutt commit a trtfpafs to Do ft.if l^e can^ 
 not act Icatc of tbc stranger, tubtci} l)c is not bouno to 00,9 H. 7. 1 (5. 1 8 Ed. 
 ;;. 23 1 9 Ed, 4, 41, SEbc loojDs arc, tbat It QmllbcDcliticrnDat tijci^oufe, 
 • ano in ans at arc all one in grammattcal conttru£tlon,Mich,a3 Car. Coleman 
 
 ano Painters Cafe. 4lp. 2CI)cp atoatD one of tbe parties ftall relcafe tft?de 
 pears rent to tijc otijer , anD tbcrc teas but ttoo pears rent Due , fo ibat it is 
 fmpofsibletobcDone. 5lp. snijepljatjcmaoc tbcirainaroupon atWngnot 
 fubmittcD, viz. t^at tbcre fljoulo be a releafc of all actions tobicb miaftt con- 
 
 Arermcnt. ccrn tftc rent ; anD laftlp, tl)e partp ougl)t to C&eto be Ijat!) perfojmcD tijc SI* 
 hjarD on bis part, \it)icl) beijatbnotnotDonc, 8H.6. 18. Brook Arbitre- 
 menc. Twifdenof Councel ontl)cotl)cr fioc. to tbcfirftdErccptlonfalD, 
 it Is not to tl)c pnrpofe : fo; arbitrators map avoaro a Icffc fum tban is Due, 
 in fatisfactton of it, anotbougl) it be ill, pettlje au'aro is gooD as to fo 
 mucl), irbetcofagooDbjcacblsafsfgncD. SLotbc fcconD l)C anftocrco, t^at 
 tbc tDOjDs dimiisionera prxdiftam tefct to tljc SoDcnturc pleaoco, anD fo tftat 
 is iDCll enough. SCatbc tbirD be falo , tbat tbe aixjaro is tbat tbc 3!nDenture 
 0)311 beDeliticrcDattbci()ouff, anDitislaUjfuUfojbifntogototbc f^oufc, 
 tbougb not into tbc ^oufc of a fetrangcr. 2Eo tbC4tb.beanftoercD', tbat 
 tbc too JDS arc to be unoerft^ooo tbat tlic partp fljall not pap tbc tent, 
 anD not tbat b: fball rcleafc'it. %o tbe fift be falo . tbat tbe toojoa 
 allcgcD are no part of tbe aftbitrement. ana if tbc iDbligation be te« 
 IcafcD it is not material, foj tbc arbltrement is pcrfo?mcD, anD tbe 
 tDOjDs pjemifes reftrain tbc a'-bitrement to tbc S)ubmifQ[on. Sim to 
 tbcfirtb it Is not ncccffarp to fljcm bototbe arbltrement is perfojmcD: 
 fo} if it be not,tbc otbcr partp ^atl) bis temcDp. Roll luftice falo, tbat in 1 2 
 lac. it toas aojuogcD. tbat if an Arbltrement toas foj a tbingto be Done 
 fti 0; at tbe ^oufe of a Stranger, it teas tocU cnougb •• foj it map be intrn- 
 DeD to be Done at tl)c ^oufctoitbout DolngaErefpafs, tbougb not in tbe 
 ^oufc, erccpt tbc contrarp be fljetocD bp tbc pattp. 31" Lynyn ano VVilli= 
 amfon. Hoofs CafC; anD as to tbe toOjDS dirailsionem p aedidam, tbat is alfo 
 toell enougb : fo; it Iball be intenDCD tbe Jnoenturc of oemifc. But let us 
 have Books and move ic again, Jtwai moved again, and another excepti- 
 on taken , that the proraife was releafedj Upon which the Court would ada 
 vifc 
 
 Smith againft Hobfbn. 
 
 Trip, 23 Car. rot, loyS* 
 
 Arcii ti QMith an Sinn ifteeper in Warwick bjougbt an action upon tbe Cafe a* 
 ^"'^Ibn upoW'^a^ntt Hobfon,foj fpeahitrg t^efc toojDs Collonel Egerton had theFrcnch
 
 Trin.24Car. nj 
 
 pox, and hath fet it in the Houfe (meanrng tbc plafntfflfa i^oilfg ) and Wil- 
 liam Smith and his wife (meaning tfje piafnttff nnuljfs CTffc) have ir, 
 and all you. SC^c pafntiff Ijat!) a terofct. SCtp Dcfcnoant motjES fn ar« 
 reft of 35uDgcment, mn foj caufc (itews, ttjat tbc iuo jds arc not attfonable : 
 foj t!)C trojDa arc, tbat Coltoncl Egerton hath fet the French pox in the 
 Houfe, \D\iitit ta impofgflilc : foj tljc ^oufc tonlD not l)a\3e tfjc por, anu tl)e 
 tDOjD0 William Sraith and his Wife have it, fljall not be meant that t!;cp ^a^c 
 tbe pop, bnt tlje ^^oufc, fojtljat tgt^cnci:t;3nfccci)cnttotbctDo;t)s, to 
 toUclj tl)cp ftjall refer. SiiD alfo tol^crc tDOjog arc fpokcn Doubtfallp luljc. 
 t^cr tt)cp be fpobeii true oj faifc, tftep f&all be taUcn to be true ; ana ft map 
 be bcrc the fcDOjtJis arc trnc , ano Sijcn no iSttfon If to fo j fpeabfng of tfjem : 
 alfotbr 315aronani)iFsmcongbttojopnfntf)c ^ctfon, fftftcpbcaofonablc, 'oyn in a. 
 foj tbcp arc fpoUcn to botlj tftcfr p:e ja5tcc,ano the Sctfon fs not to be fa?ought ^'°"- 
 bp tbc ^iiobanD alo.Mc, as ijere ft fa. aifo f ri this Cafe tUc Idojds bcfng fpo< 
 kcnofa|^3arc,thcMtftof(lBnqafrpofSDammaacs muft be tubat SDam« 
 tnaseatg comcto the ^^oufc, tobfch cannot be. Roll luftice,3If an ^adfon be 
 bjoagbtfojluojDs.anDpartorthcmbcaatonafalc, aito part are not, pet ati 
 ^irtfon Ipes fo; tbcm. 0nD fn tbis Cafg tbc ^^uabano alone map bjfng tbc 
 0afonfoj uammagcstobfntfclf , anubemapaftcrUjarDa bjfng another 3- 
 (tfon To; tbc Dammagcanone to bfs SJdffe. 0ni> be bclo tbc tuojoa bcre actfo- 
 nablc, an5 bfo tbc pafntlff talc bt0 3!n5Scm0nt, ffcaufclnerenot (bctDit 
 to tb^ coj'ttatp Saturday folloiufng. ludgement was afterwards given accor* 
 dingly, 
 
 MaifKall againft P orter- 
 HilUag Car.rot. 7d9» 
 
 MArlliall bjfngs an Sctfon of aCtcfpaffl Quare vi & armis foj tafefng a« Demurrer to 
 Ixiap bfs CatteU Cbe E)efenDant plcaoa non Cul. as to tbc vi &ar<a fpeciaipiea 
 mis , ano as to tbe tafefng of tbc Cattcl be pleaDS, tbnt be botigbt tbcm fn a '" Tiefpafs. 
 ^arUctotert. %\]C piafntfff ocmara to tbfa plea, ano tbc ©cf f naant jopns ^"' '' * 
 in tbc SDcmarrcr. Xbe CBixcptton taUcn to tbc pica toas, t!?at tije 2Dcfen< *' ""'' 
 oant Dotb not Ibcto tobat nap tbc ^arkct toaa bcpt, noj lubctb-r ft tocre out 
 of Lent.accorDfng to tbe patent foj tbc beeping of tbc ^avket. Roll luft/c; 
 fafo.tbfsougbttobatiebccnatjcrrcDfntbcpca, ano tbcrcfojetbcpicafs^yj^^^ ^ 
 ItOtgooD. Therefore let the Plaintiff have his lodgement if caufe be not " ™*"'' 
 ftiewn to the contrary. 
 
 Pitcher againft Symonsi 
 
 Trio, 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 hill. 25 Car. rot, 189; 
 
 SYmons bjongbt an actfon npon tbc Cafe uponan Aflfumpfit in tbc Com- nnor to re^ 
 picas agafnft •Pitcher, ano bath a tjctDfct, ano a 3;uDgcmcnt. SCbcSDe- verfeaTudgc 
 fenoant b jougbt a CQlrft of CBrro j bcre to rctjcrfc tbc 31tjDgcmcnt. Cbc (Bz- '"'"''• '" 
 roj afgf giicD toas, that there ujas no ttfuc jopneo bctuiccn tbc parti 38 to the ,, A"s"^°r,;. 
 fate : fOJ ft fs & prxJifius lofepbus fimilitcr, tobcrcaa ft fliOulD bz pra:didus ifiue.'""^' ' 
 Robertrs. Roll luftice tftCD 9 EHz. Dver, anO fafO,ff ft be praediduslxichar- Amendment 
 dus lobcrcft cngbt to be Robertus , it cannot be anicnoco, ijccaafe tijc JiTuc 
 fs altctcD : fcijft fsiopncabettoccnotbcrpartfcs.anbfofaftfntbfnCsfc, 
 But move it again Friday next, Si Dgi-
 
 114 Trin. 24Car. 
 
 Deacon againft Foreft, 
 
 Trin, 34 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 vvhcdicr a Tr\Eacon bjfnas an Slf^ion fn tWfl Court agalntt Foreft. SCfjc SDcfcnUant 
 
 Pica was pc- J_y appcfltc hi MichacImas 2Cetm,anD imparls to Hillary JEcrm, anD bcfo je 
 
 rcmp'oiy, or tbc Dni' of Conttnuanf c plcsDs a pica (n abatement; to tebfcb tlieplafn-- 
 
 In^h^bc' tiff Demurs. Yard of Counccllnttb tl)c plaintiff faiD, be tonccfticotbcpica 
 
 'Kdponi.kt ioas pcrcmptojp to tbc SDcfcnoant , bccaufc it comes after an fmparlancc, 
 
 .luiier. 5 a Cont<nuance,«»nD fo comes in lieu of a pcrcmptojpifoj tbc 5laU) atimits 
 
 rcrcniptory. but otit Dclap.anD tftctcfojc tbc HPefenoant fboulB batic plcancD in Cbtcf,ano 
 
 ''"• not ^jatjlng none it , bis pica (ball be as if it inerc a pica in Cbicf obcr- ru» 
 
 IcD, ano citcD Long Quint, t. 4. f. 139. Roll luftice, |aon cite not tbe 
 
 3IB00U as it is , berc is but a pica in Abatement, anotbe Continuance 
 
 maUcB itnotpercmptojp, 2Ed,4.f. 10. afcconoCDvccpttonicas.tbattbe 
 
 plaintiff batb not ucmurrcD upon tbc pica , but plcaoco to iffuc , ano bcrc 
 
 D^rartu.c isaocpmrturc from tbe general iffuc, 34H. 6,f.8,9.Roll luflice, 2Dbf JlBoiU 
 
 is agalnttpou, foj upon aiSDcmurrcr apieaoilatoii'ffjnotpcrcmptojp : 
 
 but upon an itim jopncD it is. Yard , SCbe oclap of tbc SDcmurrcr maUes it 
 
 pcremptojp, 21 H. d.f'5 j.Roll Iufticc,2Ebe 51BooU titcc is againft pou, anu in 
 
 Difference. 50 E. j.f.io. STbcrc is 3 Diffcrcncc taUcH bctUGEU tbc Dclap Of tbc Court, 
 
 anDtbcDelapoftbepartj?; anDbereisnoDclapintbcpavtp , fojijemisbt 
 
 fiabc been fojcco bp tbc rules of tbc Court tobaftcn tbc pjocecoings, anD tbe 
 
 IBoohof 34H. ^.isagainftpou. 2Cbc pica in abatement ougbt not to bate 
 
 been rcceiticD after imparlance, but if it be rctcitjco, ; a SDcmurrer upon it.it 
 
 PJ'S' cannot be bclpcD ano if one pleao apica after imparlaiicc,trbicb ottght not to 
 
 be pleaDcD; tbc plaintiff map pjap tbe Court to ot3er=rulc It : but If be tiemut 
 
 upon it, be aomits tbat tbcpica map bc;anD one map plcao apiea in 313ar bp 
 
 toap of abatement, Sc e contra. T herefore let the Pcfendant plead in Chief, 
 
 if caufe be not ihewed on Friday to the contrary. 
 
 Burgcs againft Dynliam- 
 
 Trin. 24 C-t. Banc. Reg. 
 Hill. 23 Car, rot. Jipr. 
 Demurrer u;-. "Q Urjjcs bjougbf au 0ctton Of Crcfpafs aaafnff Dynliam fo j f nWng 34 loao 
 
 < n a 
 
 I'lcj ot JDof SEpmbcr. 2Ebc SDefcnoant )ufiifics,tbat be took tb^-^ 2Cpmbcr as a |IDc« 
 luflificatiop. pmp pf J, pu^ticpour to tbe iiing, fo j tbc reparations of ibc i^anfion boufcs 
 oftbeising. SEotbispieaof^uCificatfon, tbe plaintiff Demurs, anofoj. 
 caufe ftcirctb, tbat it Dotb not appear , tbnt tbc Defcnoant bntb anp nutbo- 
 vitp bp tbc Common-laiD, e j bp statute to tafec tbis JCpmber.'fo j tbe Corns 
 CommiiTion. ntl'"sion iublcb gites tbisautbojitpougbttobcrcnctDCtj cbcrpGvi^ontbs, 
 anD it Dotb not appear tbat it inas fo in tbis Cafe, 2 Inftitur. f, 5 45 . 1 E, 4. 
 a, 3 . 2lp. I^c batb not (betDCD tbat tbc ^oufcs lucre in occap Ixiben be toob 
 tbc 2Cpmber,anD be cannot tabe it to maae a Common ftoc!;, to rr^pair tbcm 
 Purveyourj. gftcrlucirD tobcn tbcp IboulD fall toDccap. 3lp. ptirliepours oagbt to pap 
 rcaop monp fo; tbe commoDltiea tbcp takc,anD be Dotb notilljcto in curCafe 
 5batbepaiDrcaDpmonpfo;tbc2r;pmbcr,bptbc b:at. ^6'Ed.3.C.^2.47 Ed.;, 
 f. 8. bHtbp22£d. 3. Tit. Bar. 259. it fccms to be otijcrlDlfc : hut tbc Cafe 
 tbcre Differs from fbis Cafe, foj tbere itteaotbatapt T^cpoun?iiTP tasc 
 ^ojfcs to life foj a time, toitftout paplns monp •• but it lya$ not to rater tbc 
 
 P?opertp»
 
 Tiia. 24 Car. 115 
 
 jjjovcvtp. 4lp- l^e !)at!j not fteiocDtbntfjccnDetJonret) to agree toUbtbe, 
 laiafntfff fo? I)f0 aCfmber, as \)t miobt to Ija'cc Done, Hiii. ; car. rot.scp, '"'^ *• 
 Parker and Scurgens cafe. jlp. 2El)f ptca tfl ftuDlcD ap , atiD <G net plcaDeD 
 partkiilarip ann ufftfnctlp as ft otisl)t to be, fo tljat tljc plaintiff Unoirs not 
 IjolototaUcantirue, loH.j. The rule oi" Court was to hear the other fide 
 Friday nexc, 
 
 Breretofi and Moningron. 
 
 Trin 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 ' A Writ of CBrroj teas bjourjbt to rcljcrfc a Sitiogcincnt gft'cn in m fiife* Error <? re- 
 JLX rfotir Court , anD tljc Crroj afciraco ioacjtljat tljc IDlnint tor-g cntrcD '"'^ * .''"'«=* 
 agafcift Francis, anotljcpjocccottigs lucre agafnft lolin. Roll luHice fafo, 3nij,(^jiour 
 tljat it toas not gooD, fo j a plaint (3 in tbe nnttire of an ojfjiinal tojit , ano courr. 
 tftercfoje itt\)at be erroneous it cannot be IjclpcDtbotigb it be after a tcroirt. I'ljinr. 
 And tliereiorc ftiew cauie Saturday next why the ludgement ftiould not be '^'"endment, 
 reverfcd. 
 
 Gallop againft Symfon. 
 
 Trin, 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 CHafeb?fngoanSirtionof2nrolicran6Cont)ctfion naafnff Ga!Iop, anDErrortore- 
 bic Uiife, anD a ftrangcr, in tl,c <IommcnpIcac, nnDljatbateroitfjano'^rcajudgc-' 
 
 a 31uDgemcnt againft tijem. 2Ebc E>cfcnDant bjings a tojit of Crro j to '"^'"^^ j l"J 
 rctjcrfc tl){0 guDgcmcnt , anc assigns foj Crroj tfeat tbc piaintifT Declares veifio"n, "^ 
 tftattftcgooDs fo J UibictjtljC Action fs bjougbt.venerunt ad urumipforum, 
 VIZ. of tbc J^uflbanD , anD bfs toife, anD tljc flrangcr , tobicU cannot be, foj Dedaratidn. 
 iljep cannot be faio to come to tbc ufc of a jFemc coljcrt. Roll luitice, SLbis 
 is not gooD, foj be ouni)t not to Dcclr.rc tbat tbc gooos came to the ufe of tbc 
 iTeme, but to tlje ufc of tl)C ^usbanD onlp . And therefore re verfetur judici- 
 um,f xcept caufe fhewn to the contrary Saturday ntxc, 
 
 Waincwright and VVhicIy. 
 Trin. 24 Car.Banc. Reg. 
 
 WAinewrightb;cuel)t an 0(tion upon t(je Cafe againft whitly, foj Aired of 
 tljefeiDOjDsrpoUcnofbim; Thouartatheef, and haft broke ray jatlgoTent m 
 CheftiSn be plairtiff batb a ■bcrDictjSrbe SDcfcnDant in arrrft of 3;nDgemcnt ^'''^'O" "pon 
 mbtjestbat tbc toojos arc not actionable. 31But Roll luOice faio, nottoitl)- " 
 ftanDing mp 3Lo;DHobarts opinion, be belDtbc too?Ds are actionable, foj<bc 
 tDO jD anD is cumulntibe, ano aggraliates tbe fojmct too jds, arc not barelp Cumulative. 
 eiplanatojp, anDtbcfubfcqucnttoo;Dsare tiolent, anD map terp toell ^^'^""°'^' 
 ftanO toitlj t^C fojmcr, Therefore let the Plaintiff takehis ludgement. . 
 
 © a The
 
 \\6 Trin. 2 4 Or. 
 
 T'he King and CamcU- 
 
 Trin. : 4 Car. Banc Reg. 
 
 An arra.'gn- 
 
 mcntfir A Nn Camel! cnttcteD flf Southwold in Suffolk foj JTclonj' anu Mftcfj- 
 
 wiich-crafr. x\craft iDss b;oan|)t to the ISar bp an habeas corpus , ane toao here ar» 
 rafgnfo. 2ri;c pjtfoncr ticltrcD Walker foj her Councel. Rollluaicc 
 asUcDb-rfojU^atcanfc anD matter Ojc DID DcGrcCoantcll; Eo to^fcl) tbc 
 pjifoncc mating no anftocr, Roll luAice ttcluco t\\t Cnclctmcnt , ano upon 
 tljat afsfgnea licr Walker fo j bet Comtel , ano gate Wm the nejrt cap to 
 fljcui Ws erccpt(ons agatnft the CnMctmcnt , at tiWchtfmc Walker oe- 
 fircD that the CnDlrtmcnt migtt be tcao , iobfch toas Done , ano upon tbc 
 
 Ep.d:ftai:rt. rcac{ngof<thctool;tbcrec):ccption0. 1. Eothccaptfonuhcrcfn (ttoclc- 
 PJeffeo,thattheCnDfflmcntwaataUen^npcnaceffione, Vobcre <t flioulDbc 
 in plena ceffione.. S^O tbffl Roll anflDCrCD , if the IDOJO pcna be left 
 ont, the (SnDiitmcnt is gooD cnouab tithoiit it , ano tbcrefojc p?.(Tcs oufter. 
 i! fecoiiD exception tons, that the CnDlctmcnt Doth not f;ip that the ^"tttces 
 bcfojCinhomittoagtalJCntoerciufticiariiad pacem tenendara in villa prae. 
 difti , anD then tbcp might babe no pou^.er to fino the CnDictmciit; but tl,f» 
 crteption teacairootcr-rnlcDbp the (Court. iSthirDcrccptionliiafl, 2Ehat 
 the GnDittmcnt to too general, foj it onlp fapcs that the pjifoner pr^dicavic 
 diabolicasarccs, ano Doth not eypjeffe tobat. 3bOttig Roll juQice anfine- 
 rco, tl)at the employing of toichcD fpirits to anp intent tohatfoebcr is iFclo= 
 
 1 cionv. ^^ luithin the Statute , anD the intent tobptbcp toerc emplopeD Is tuell ex-. 
 p; effeD in the CBnDictmcnt , anD if an CnDirtment fail in one part, it map be 
 gooD in another : anDthcrcfoiCtheOnDirtmcntis gooD, anD the pMfoner 
 mutt plcao ; TOlhcrcupon tbcpjIfonerplcaDCD not guiltp. tlpon this Wa!=> 
 kcr molieo the Court that this toas an olD Cnsictmcnt , anD that the p^lfoc 
 net bno been ttDicc acqutttCD upon other CDnDittments of the fame nature ,' 
 ana that tfjis teas p:orecuteD fo? malice, ano pjapcD that the p;ifonct might 
 be bailcD,tehich tons granteo. And flie wsi bailed by her Husband , and by 
 
 Bail. one Z^chary Ba^gs a fufficient Citizen and Fiflimonger of London, andtwo 
 
 otherf, to appear at the next AfTifes to be held for the Connty of Suffolk* 
 
 Trin. 14 Car. Banc. Reg 
 
 To qu m »n nr ^c €mxt tras motjcD to quaOj an GiiDirtment crbtbff cd upon the S>fas 
 ino.amcot ^ ujteofpcrjurpftKingfton upon SCIiamcgfojtiierc cjccptions. 1. Kt 
 upon the S'j.|gj,otcjp;effca'intDhatCountpK!ng{toni3; ano alp. theC^noictmentDoth 
 MKc o( prrji- j,j.{ £ jp,c(fj jjriiii t'nc. partp is pcriureD, fo: it Oictos not in inhat taufe it toaa 
 no? tl-at it irao in giving anp cl'iDcnte upon oath as a ioitnclle in anp canfc, 
 Vpon tbefe exceptions the Endidraent was quafhed.Nota 
 
 Butler, 
 
 ■■y
 
 Tnn.c4Car. 117 
 
 Biicler againft Long. 
 
 Trin» 24 Car* Barx. Reg. 
 Pafc,24Car. rot, 495. 
 
 LOng bjoiiPljt an aatoii of SrcfpatTc nrninft Bucicr fn t!)C €itv of Error ro rr- 
 a«t} !)at!) a vcrotrt nno n 3[aDgcmciit , t!]e SDcfentiant vcrrc 3 judge- 
 bjtnaga toiftofCrro:toret>crfctl)t6 3i«i!gcmc»it,ant) afafnits 10: Crro:,""'"'?^'"''* 
 I. 2Ct)at tl)c ©cclatatton Dotl) not fljctDfn litjat pariO) tettijfn tijc Citpt!jB Ccuj'"'""" 
 CtefpaCfc ivas 3onc, as be ouffjt. 2Co thfs Roll luf>ice arfuicrca , SEI^at ft 
 fljall not be fntcnoeo tftat tl)crc arc moje ^^atiftcg Ipttijin tbcCftp tljan one, i'-«n'ion. 
 crccpt the contrary be fliclBCti. 2lp.EI)CiDctlarattoneO quod cum talis, 
 vizjftc Dcfenoai.t, &c. Inftftl) fa not an crpieffc alicrment that t5)i: ©cfcn. D-daration 
 cant oiD tbc Srcfpaffc ; but ft la ret fo jtij onl v bp irap of cfrcam&ancc tliat rieipafle. 
 Ije DID ft, iDbfcti f3 not gooD, fo; Ijc oug^t to be t^argeo Dfrectlp toftl) ft. Roll 
 lultice, SlIjc fcttf ng fo:tb tbc SErcfpaffe bp a quod cum is not gooD , tfjoualj in 
 another 3afon ft map be gooo. Therefore lee che ludgemcn: be reveried,ex- 
 cept caufe fhewo to the contrary Saturday next. 
 
 Walker and AlJer; 
 
 Trin. 24 Car. Banc, Reg: 
 
 f A Lder!)aDa3"t>5cmcntanDanC2)fettitton agafnff Walker, anD tljcre^ AudiraquereU 
 ,/\ upon i)e tiiaij ta!\Cn , anufnciifteopfn tfjcteftigolBentfj p:ffon. Alder '"i^ onctakea 
 tbe|91afntfff aftcttoatDflconfcnteDt'onttbcHDcfcnoant Walker ajoalocotne ''"'^'^ "p°" 
 tol)<inoutofpjifon tottie !^ojfljoc SCatcrn, irWffj toasout oftfjcKnlc,""' """""" 
 iDftftoiit a ISerpcr J rule of iToiirt-, tf)infetng co maUc fome agreement uftl) 
 Ijfm, SElje JDcfcnDant atcojDfiiglp toent tUtI)cr,but becaufe no agreement 
 conlDbc maoe , SEftepafntfff tattestljcSDefenDant again upon tbe fame 
 €j;ecutfon , ano lapca fefm agafn fn t^c Mnce Wcwcl) , tl)C De= ^^^"J^"* i^^-^ 
 fcnoant tbercupon bjfngs fjfs audita quereU ; /■ nd adjudged by the Court oifchtrge. 
 to be well brought foj tljc (Srecutfon toass DffciiargcD bp tljc pjifoncrs go- 
 ing at large , ano t^icrefo jc tje coulD not be agafn ta{?en upon ft. 
 
 Reader againft Palmer. 
 
 Trin. 14 Car* Banc, Reg, 
 
 REaderb:ougbt an ;artfon upon tbc Cafe agafnff Palmer, anD ljat!)a Arrettof 
 .tcreftf, the SDcfenoantmotco fn arrcft of Suogcmcnttljat tftc plain- '"^g^menc in 
 tfflF«ltcr<'Dt)f3 Declaration fntbetonaocratton of t^epjomffe, anD fn tfte 'f^"^^^^P°^" 
 pjomffc ft felf, after ftcfjaDplcaocD, fotf)att!)erebptl)crame ffftie tolitcf) fejiterirgthe 
 trpeD,f3 not ^ftat to^fcb toaa jopneo. Twifden of Si^ouncell tnftlj tbc piafn* Dcciaratio. 
 tfff fafo, tbat tt); fffne \sas not altcrcD,foj tfic too jos altetco are not materf* 
 altoojDB- Wild ofCouncellii3Jtl)tl)cSDcfenDantfafD, tbcfffue toaa altc- 
 reD bp altcratfon of tbe too?Ds, fo? tbe Sctfon f« bjong5)t upon a fpccfal pjo- 
 affc , anDnotuponap;omffefn 3lnto,agtbc altering of t!)c toojDs Ijabe 
 ntaDctfjcpjomffctobe, anotljcrefo^cft'fs a material alteration. Roll 
 luftice fafo,ftf5amatetfaltWngtt)atfflaltcrcD, anDft ongtt not to be a=j ..j^jn,^ 
 tnenDCD ; ^n actual pjomf re, ano a confiocrattoH contfnufng, caimot be taA**"^^'' 
 
 ■Si 3 few
 
 n8 Trin. 24 Car. 
 
 ilCn to be at anotljCt tlmcT^Hodg and ; Vavifors cafe , 14 lacTBartoiTand 
 Slinrlycs (afc,Mich. 15 Car. And therefore give new rales to plead , and fo 
 proceed according to the courfc to a new tryal* 
 
 V Volverly Scrachy agalnft 
 
 Trin 14 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 X7\ Olverly 5;trachy bjotijjbt an 0(tfonupontl)cCarc againft tl)cDc= 
 
 Don-.urrcr V VfciiDant. ^ Dctlarct),tl)at tDbcrcas fljc toao a toomon of agooD fame, 
 
 upon » ric» g„Q ijoncft rcpntatton, &c. SCljc H)tfcnDajit fpalie t^etc luojog of IJcr , viz, 
 
 lo/(c *!!la " s ^c 's a common Whore, and I will prove her one, by reafon whereof fhe loft 
 
 word"" '^"^ her credit and reputation, and her mariage. 2lI)C SDcfcnOant plcaDCD 
 
 P'ca. that flic tons not Of an Ijorieft rtputaHoit at thctJme itljen be fpaUe tljefc 
 
 li)ojij0ofljcr,a3<s5allcgeD<ntftc JDctlaratfon : Stljc piafnttff Dcmur0 
 
 gcncrvlll' to thfo pica. ludgercent was given for the Plain itf, except 
 
 caaJc fhould be fhewcd Saturday next to the contrary, Antea 
 
 and tbe Lord iMoanc, 
 
 Trin, 24 Car, Bare, Reg. 
 
 „Tg. w, , . ^ . ... _ ., ougbt 
 
 Peer of the not to be fiicD , ano piapC0 foj a fuperitdcas to flap tl)C piocceDtoga, Roll 
 s-i"c.\-dcas Iut>'C' ,pic<iD rotir pjttHtgc, foj upon an aftdavit U)e toUl maUc no rule , o% 
 Vsivikgr. ' Elfc acquaint J the other parfp that be <s a |3cct.oftf)cl1caim, anDftioUUe 
 
 be tolUfojfacartopjocccD thereupon. But you ought not to trouble the 
 
 Court With fuch motions as thefe. 
 
 Cornilli again ft Covvfye. 
 Trin, 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 Trin, 25 Car. ror. I4?4' 
 
 spe.iji ver /^ Ornifh b?ous!)t an attfon of JDcbt agafntt Cowfye an epccutoj, foj ar» 
 
 diftinDibt V^acragcsofrcntincutrcD,part<nthcUfeoftbc 2Dettatoj, ano part in 
 
 for rent a. tbc tfitte of tbc Ctccutoj. SLbcpiaintiffDcclates iipoH 3 leafc maoebp 
 
 ,L»w>ft2n Ex |jjj„ to the llcCatojb)' bio 3nDer.t[jre mace the ftift of May in fiicb a pear, 
 
 ""'"'■ &c.2Ebc2Pcfrn6antplcaDe nil debet, anoiipontlusa fpcciall tjctuia toag 
 
 founD to tbi« effect , %m tbe plaintiff cio upon the firft oap of May,mafee 
 
 the Snoenturc of leafe to tbe SDrflatoj of tbe lanDs let , to ba^c ano to bolD.a 
 
 die datuf , fo? ano During tbe terra of 7 pears, from our J^aop cap iatt patt , 
 
 frombcntcfo;thf"!lpto Tje compleat ano cnoeo, upon tbis teroict, tbe 
 
 nucfiior infilfcD upon bptbeCouncell \Tia3,tebctb£t there be not futba ta. 
 
 "r . riantc betUiccn tbe Icafc, upon U)bicb the plaintiff batb DcclareD, ano the 
 
 *' '^'^'"' leafe fount) in tl)e tjcroict, that tbcp ttjall be fafo to be feberal leafcg, oj tobe- 
 
 tbcritfhnli. be anjtiDgenonc ano the fame leafe. Twifden foj the S)e^ 
 
 fcncant oclo that there isfutb a fjariancc betlueen tbe leafe in tbe SDcclara- 
 
 tion ano tbe leafe founo In tbe tjctoict, tbat tbep cannot be tbe fame , ano 
 
 ' fo
 
 Trill. 24 Car. 119 
 
 fb tbe piafntiff can Ijatje ro Juoccmcnt, ano fte afgct tWs crontio of lalu 
 tftat a DccD fljall be fo cor.ttrticD tbat all parte of it map be miiDe to ffcnD to. 
 getftetifft be pofaiblc tottftoiit fo:ceDcon(iructfon of t^e tDo:DS;but this can- 
 not be \)tu , ant) a ILcffo; map malat a Icafc to begin tnben be pleafrt!),an!) 
 cnD iilj'en fte pleafetb, nottoitljftanDf ng tljc Date of it , ano a Icafc mace to . 
 begin at a Dap patt,Dotb begin in tntcrcft in pjcfcnt, tiiougi) not in compu=,^'"'^^"' 
 tation , ano ^e citeo Mufgraves cafe, Hob. rep. tolicrc ttoo computations arc '''^'"' 
 In a Icafc foj pears, ano one is repugnant to tbe otl)ct, tl)e laft (ball be 
 tcjcctcD. Hales of «roanccllititf)t5)cpatnttfft)elD, tfjnt tbe Icafc facring 
 in point ofintercft from tbeoap of tbc Date, ano tftat t!)cvc is no totfancc , 
 oj tcpugnancp bettBcen tlje leaie mentioncD Ux tije S):claration, ano tijc 
 Icafc fomiD in tbc teroict, ano tbcrcfojc tr,c vcrDict ia fo: the painttff. 
 Roll luftii.e fafD, it iDOulo bc l]arD fo; t)tm to maintain it , ano faiD , tbat in ,, -■ 
 p?efumpttonofiLatr,tobenatt)inGi0tob: Done upon one oar, all tliat nap """P^'""' 
 i0 allotDBD to DO it in foj tbe af oioing of frartions in timc,aibicii tbc J^atn as- i-.sabn'; 
 initS not of, but in cafe of ncccfssitp, Hill. 1 4 J.ic.More and Mulgrave Mich. 
 10 lac. rot. 76 in the Exchequer. Si SDcmifC tl)C 5 of May , bp ^inocnturc 
 oatco tl)C 4 of May, habendum from tljc fcaft of tbe Annunciation Istt patt , 
 fo J 2 1 pears, to bate anD to bolD from tfje Dap of llje Date of t!:cfc p:efento. 
 J5nt tljere arc otbet points in the Cafe at the 25ar to be conlrDcrcD of, foj 
 tfie Action of 2:>Ebt is foj tcnt,part incurreo in time of tljc SEcttato; , ano 
 patt in time of t! e €)iecutoj. ar.D it is in tlje detinet,tDliicb ought not to tjafec ^"""'"^^ 
 becnjbutS conceive that that is h^rc helpcD bpthe tcrtict.pet it is toc;th cen- 
 fioeration : Ano he faio, that an Cjccuto? cannot itait'c a SCcrm if he habc '■' VaUtr, 
 notaffets.bntit&c ftate he map, Another thing ftcre conCoerable is , 
 thattl)e Action is bjdngljt in the detinct, anDtheSDcfcnDantplcaos nil de. 
 bet; |Pct he faiD, that after a tJcrDirt it might be gooD cnouglj, fojit is a 
 SDcbt though the Action bcbjought in the detinet,frin. I oCa'r. 1289. Por* 
 terand larvis Banc. Reg, anD he faiD that the paintiff mk mittaSen !)fg 
 leafe, pet 31 toUl aotjlfe bp rcafon of the opinion in Muigraves cafe, Hob. rep. 
 3it is a Icafc in computation of time, from the fcaling, anoaccojoing to the ' "fe. 
 habendunaalilierpanDfelCnliabend'umsdie datus DclibercD th- licrt Dap '-'"fy ="<* 
 <sgooD,ifUbcmaDebpthepartp ; but itisqticflioneDu-hethcritbcro.if it "'''^"' 
 be maDc bp an Attoinep. An anticnt dccd tpbich cannot be p:ofcco, (hall be 
 fntcnDCDtbbcDclibcreDthclaahouro'tbeDap, tomahegooD the contcp* 
 ancCt Buc 1 will cal<c a liiitle time to advife. 
 
 Rawagainft Raw,. 
 Trin. J4 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 RAw haD a juogcmcnt in an Action of SDebt b?oughf fo j arrcragcs upon £.ror to r- 
 an accorapt in Newcaftle upon Tyne againtt Raw , the DcfenDantverfca ludge- 
 bjonght a IClrit of Grro j to tetcrfc this guDgcmeut. ano afsigneo foi er. "^^"^ '" D'^c 
 ro?, I. 3n the itfuing out of the venire, it is not faiD to bc p-rMsjorcm"''""''""'" 
 pi3edidurovill3cpra:didaf;butperMa)oreingcncrallp. 2lp. Htis'^afD ad rc^rn"^'"**^' 
 CO cognofcendum inftccD of recognofcenduro.3lp.3t is faiD the ^urp a/fidunt VcTifu- 
 daranadepraedid.UihoisnotnamcDbcfo?C,foj itis aHiJunc damna ipfius 
 Kathwinae Carr, tohcrcas fljc tnas befojc calleD Katharine Raw, ar.D fo Da- 
 mages arc gitcn to no certain perfon , fo; tbep hate Different names. Roll 
 luflice faiD, the furname Carr is tooiD , ano it ftall bc tat^cnas if it ijao been Damafes 
 faio ipfius Katharirxonlp, ano tt)at is gooDriionglj, But cxa mine the trani". 
 
 fcript
 
 the Poftea, 
 ComtniGion 
 
 I20 Tria. 24Car. 
 
 ftrfpt br> tijc l^ctojD, totict^ier \\)t U«Jtt faTre co cognofcendum o;liot7foj <f 
 UbcfOjtttonotgooD. 
 
 l.ovcll again ft KnatchforJ. 
 
 Trin. 24 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 Pafc, 24 Car. rot. 348. 
 
 TT" Natchford ^aD a 3|atgcment in t\)t Common=plca0 agafntt Lovell. SD&e 
 
 ve'fc a° "' Jx2:'cfcnDant bjtnge a mrU of (Erro? to rcfectfc t^is BiuDscmcnt. SDfte 
 
 ludecmtnt dgtro; afsfgncD iuas mtbc Hoi>ea,ftitftat ft ia not fafo ttiat t^c ^"ftfcc of ar. 
 
 for Error in fjfc j^fy-Qciato libi,&c. BS ft oug^t tO bc bp tljC fetatUtE, Roll lufricc lafDjtfte 
 
 3;nflfcc Of Sifflffcmap^a\)ea fpccfal Commffflfon to go tftc Cfrtuft alone, 
 
 ano t^n ft muft not be fafo fo , but ff ftbc per formam Scatuti, ft ongbt to be 
 
 affociato (ibi, &c. But the Clark of the Afsife may bring in bis notes by which 
 
 Amendment, he madc the Poftea, and amend it by them : for it it his fault to make the Re« 
 
 torn fo» 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 A iF> 3(tfonof2DebtiBa8bjoagl)tnponan£)blfgaffonfo ftano to an 3- 
 pia.miff /\|i,aro-2i:bcpiafnttffa)ctocD to the Court, tbat tljc atnarD mauc teas 
 co^-\inuc°his' not unoer imn ano fcal, accoaofng totlje rnbmff0fon,anDtbcrcfojc be ban no 
 aaion. caufe of attfon, anDpjapco tbat be mfgbt Dffcontfnue bfs actfon.Roll luftice 
 Difcontinu. gnftocrcD, ft fs fn anfltoaro, anD 3 tofll do notbfng fn f f:bnt f f ft tocrc upon a 
 *""-i jDcbt , ft nif Qbt be tbc SDcbt rcmaf 110, tbongb t^ ;3U)arD be f U, but BiuDge* 
 
 went f0 not DcmanOeOt I will do nothing m it. 
 
 Newton againft Balcs^ 
 
 Trin. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Pafc, 2 4 Car. rot. 183. on 7 8» 
 
 T> Ales ban a Sutgcmcnt agafntt Newton, fn an flctfon upon flje Cafe 
 ve-T.'juTfc- JDupon an AfToinpfit fn tUc Court at Owfe^bridgc fn York. SClje 
 nicminan SDcfcuDant b^fugo a Mtft Of Ctroj to rc\)crretb<s3inDgcmcnt,anDaf. 
 fi.a on on the fi(j„g ti^£fe <£Tro?0, 1 . 3t fs raiD, tftc SDefcnoant toao to Bclfber cettafn com. 
 ^^^''- inoDftf CS ad ratum,f iiltcaD Of fecundum ratum.iBut to tbtaRolHuftice fafDjtbat 
 
 ad ratum f fecundum ratura arc all one f n Cgnf gcatfon. ilp. SCberc fs no tfme 
 fct fojtl) tobcn tl)C pjomf fc teas maoe, foj ft fs fct Doton f n ftgurcg, irbfc^ is 
 alloneasfffttocrenotfcttotonat alU Holl Iuftice,2i::ftelil0to?Dfsnotfo, 
 /icn M'cr, tboug^tbcttanrcrfptbc, tbercfoje tbat map be amenccD. 3!?. SEtjcteare 
 * ttoofctEralpjomffes, anutbcparcbotballegeD. Roll luftlcc , 3ts toell e- 
 nongl).4lp. 2Cbe Venire f s not reto;nED,foj ft fs not retojncD to be in omnibus 
 Kctorn. fervitum & exccutum. JCotbfs the Countel on tbeotftcrliDcanrtoereD, ft ap- 
 pears tbat there fs a pancll retoineo, anD therefore ft fs toell cnongb, thongli 
 tJjof« toojDs be omftteD. Roll lurtice, SClje panel fs not tetojneD, no j anner*
 
 Trin. i4Caf. • izi 
 
 CO aaojirfns tfte fetatotc, ano tlictcfoje Uis no return fnlaiu. There- 
 fore let theludgeraent be reverfed for cbis cadfe, except caufc (hewed to 
 ihc contrary, 
 
 VVatfon again ft Scotfon. 
 
 Trin, J4 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 y7^n a fate faettocen Scotfon ano Watfonfntfte Court of aomftaUp.Todif cent- 
 ^ Scotfon tntttn Mo an £)bUgat(on to Watfon, Watfon bjfngfl an 0tM« nue an jaion. 
 
 peat0, ano puts tr I'apl to tftc ^dton, ano after motMtfte Conrt, tljat Wat» ^^"f''' ^^^ 
 (oa map be ojocreo to pjocao (n t^e 0Dm(raltp npon tWs £Dbl(gatton, ht tt- D'fcha,tc 
 garotlie 15onD tnas giticn tl[ierc , and tijat tlje bapl ticre map be offc^argeD. ' 
 
 Roll Ia(lice,Iwiil notreleafe the bayl : for it is fiied,ai]d it is a Record bere,and Bayl. 
 it isDOtxuidulydone. 
 
 Aylet again ft Oates, 
 
 Trin; 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 Pafc, 24 Car. rot, 3P7. 
 
 A3|ai)semcnt teas gften fn.tlje Common^pleas (n an Platan of affault p 
 ano 315attctp agafnft t^ec. %\}Z 2DcfcnDantbjfnssatI!fflrftofCttoj»er7eaYu*i- 
 to tctcrfe tbia ^acgement, ano afslgnco foj <£tto?, t^at tljc aafon toag menc in af- ' 
 b?oogbt againtttbjec, anDtl)«ttftepallappeareDbp0tto?np, anDpleabeD,''»"'f»n<iB«* 
 ls|icrea«! one of t^em txias an Blnfant loittifn age, ano ongbt to Iiatie pleaoeo ^^'^' 
 bp ftfoOnarofan, ant>tt>at BIuDgemcnt luas cnt(telp gfben agafnff t&em all, 
 tD^ftl) matt be tofD agatntt tbe infant, ano fo It being tntfre (0 tola alfo to 
 tt^ tUio otber SDefenoants. Wild ofCotincel tottli ttie S[>efenDant tn tbe 
 ^tft of CttojatgncD, tbat tbe 3aogementmapberefcerfeoinpatf,viz ludgtmenu . 
 aa to tlie Bnfant, ano pet map ftano gooo agalnS tbeotberSDefenoants: 
 foj t^e Mion mfgbt ftafec ban bjong&tagalnff tbemfetjerallpastocUas 
 jopntlp, 35 H.6.f. 21. 5 Ed, 4. f.7. Roll lafticefafD, Itlsmleocontras • 
 tp, miiztt a Binogment is rctjerfeo fo j an erto j In 3lato agalnft fome of tlie ' 
 
 JDcfcn'oants, It Is teljerfco agatntt all of tjjtm : bat tt feemg to be ot^ettof fe 
 tobere It Is rcterfcn fo j an Crro j In j? act, 5 j H, 6, 2. Hales 1 t^e otl>er Ooe 
 niotjcDto teterfe tbe anogcmcnt tobollp; fojft is an entire^ f.ogement ano Difcominu- 
 cannot be teljetfeo in part onlp t fo^ all tlje SDefenoants a :e eqaailp con^ance. 
 cerneo in tt , ano a tifcontlnnance agatntt one of tftem r£Detfe0tbe 3uDgc= 
 ment agatntt aU oftbem, ano be Dcnpeotbel5oobof5Ed,4. anocltco^ 
 «9Ed. 3.f. ?9- RollIuf>icefafD,lfltfaea3luDgementattbcCommon.laiD, "°'^' 
 o> a 3inogement tabete cofts ate glDcn bp tbe &tatnt0,(f (t be retjerfeo as to 
 one,(t (0 tet)erfeo toalUflno berclg an entire jnogementgltjen fcpt^e Com- 
 inon>lats,anO it cannot be tielpeo. But bring me the Book, PoHea, 
 
 SI Crook
 
 12: 
 
 Error. 
 
 ■ Trin. 24 Car. 
 
 Crook again ft Samm, 
 
 Trin. 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Mich, 23 Car. rot. 311. 
 
 ^ C Amm l;aD a 3 irt'acmcnt fn t!)C Contmoit.plcas upon a Nihil diclr frt an E« 
 
 vcr^Tiud'e- c>)tftione fimx. 2Lt)C SDcfcncaiit bjougbt a tTOrU Of CDnojtorcbcrfctbe 
 mcntinsnE-^uDgement, ano afsfgnco tbc general Crro?. STlje plafntfflf m tijc 
 jca. finis. 3;uDgcmcnt p?apcD It tntsftt be affitmeo, Roll Juilicc Dcmanoeo of 
 l)tm, ff it be aBluBgementuponaNihil dicitljotDcanUbcoftfttsaCcrm:' 
 2!:{)crcfo?c gttoc notice ano mobc agafn. JSiit tl)c Saogcmcnt tg, ideo 
 hiJgcmenr, ^Q^^Qj^afyfn ^o quod jecuperet, anO tljctc toants & defendens capiatur,anD 
 tl)crEfo?c t^c 3«Dgcment <0 erroneous, ano^olncanittljcnbeaffirmcD:' j 
 Car. IntbcCrtbcqucr^Mich. 5lac. rot, 269. Aliens Cafe, 17 Car. Stewarc 
 ano Stewart fn tbe €. ^. ano tbougb U be a 3!anscmcnt bp Default, pet it i& 
 a 3uDgement, but being erroneous U tannot be af flTmeo. Therefore adyiie 
 
 • what you will do. 
 
 Hobait againfl: Borafton- 
 
 Trin. 24 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 )^ an 0rt<on of SDcbt bjongbf upon tlje statute of 2 Ed. <J. fo j not fetffng 
 tojtl) of 2i:<t5)C0,aftcr a t)erDfct3t Inas motco In arreft of SltiDgement, t^at 
 H"up"on" tbc statute luao not Uiell ret iteo : foj tbeparltamcnt began fn tfjc firft peat 
 the Stat. t.f 1 of Ed.6.anD Uia<5 p3orogneD,anD tl)C ^a Ivac mane tbc aetl) ofNovember ano 
 E.I. 6. for roc not t^E fourtl), 30 it IS fct fo jtl) to bc. jTo J p joof Of t\)i5 a Copp oT tbe par- 
 fe.titip forth liamtnt-roll, ano an Affidavit to pjotc tl)c Copp to be true toerc rcau in tijc 
 of jithcs. ^oy^t^ Hales of Counccl on the otbcr ftoc faio, tftat ti)C Copp teas tahen out 
 °^'^' of tbc parliament- Kournal.book onlp ano not out of tbcSClrit fo j pjorogatt- 
 
 on of tl)c parllament,afl It ougftt to bc.RoU luftice faio to tl)c Councel on tlje 
 otbct fioe, AdvKc you how to anlwer this , and let the ludgement ftay in the 
 
 • mean time, antea. 
 
 Pimley againft Robinfbn, 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 r 
 
 Pafc,24Car,rot.47(5, 
 
 Eiror tore- 
 
 R 
 
 Obinfon b?ougtt an Sdlon of STrefpafsagafnftPimpley.fojcntring 
 ^ ^^(nto WsClofe, anBtaUingatoapajparcanu a 3iBjlDlc,lntl)eCountp 
 mt'nr !n xfci" Of York, sno 1)00 3 tjcrolct , auD a 3ut>gement agalnft tfte Drfcnoant. 2Ct)e 
 p,f, V I & a- SDcfentant bjingo a Mrlt of Crroj to retjcrfc this 3iuDgcmcnt, ano arstgns 
 irib \a Vol k. foj cErro J , that the Court Voas fnto to bc hcln on Saturday the ninth of No- 
 vember, ii^creas the Saturday on Uhicl) tl)c <Eourt teas helD.toas not tftc ptfj. 
 El rcr, Bap of Novem'otr, but the ytb. anu fo there is no Court alleged to be i)elD,foj 
 
 on the 9tl). Dap there toas none helD, i H. 7. i i E. 4. i o. Roll luflice , 3It 
 ftoulD f cem thep dIo not look toell Into the 0lmanack, if thep IjaD.thls mif- 
 tahe haD not been. Let the ludgement be reverfed , except caufe be (hewn 
 Monday next, Mogg
 
 Trin, 24 Car. 125, 
 
 * Mogg againft Shute- 
 Trin. 24 Car, Banc. Reg.' 
 Trin. 2 J Car, rot, 2097 
 
 Imogement toas often in an IXdion of JCrefpafsanua^EItUofCtroj^'''''^"? "J- 
 tftcrcupon fa;on^to tctictfe t^s 31uDgc»"cnt/, (anD tftcerro>af3f0ncD^,''J,;^||/'y^f; 
 1030, tW tljc Venire tDaflretumcD bp onctljat teas not S>ljctfff at tftc tttne pafs. 
 of tftc return. %o tW ft teas fafo bp t^c Conned on 4l)C otfter fioc, tl)at 
 tWs matter ougbt not to beafsfgneD fojCrroj, faccaufc ft faagafnfttfte^"'"^- j 
 IRecojo : ontbcotl^EtCDc fttuacfnliifftcDupon, that {)c map afcfgn ft foj 
 ©rroj. Roll lufticefafDjftmap beafsfgncDfojCttoj, butftfs aiSutCton 
 lioto ft ftallbctrpeo: fojftfsnot upon a 3Deinutrer, ann fo tbc mattct fa 
 not bz{0}e U0, 1 1 Car, Smicli ano Smith. And this caufe ought not as it is to 
 have been put ioto the Paper, 
 
 VVorfely againft Worfely- 
 
 Trin. 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Pafc. 44 Car. rot, 489, 
 
 -c T V TOrfely bjought an Sctfonof ^ccontpt agafiia Worfely. %\jt 2Dc« Demurrer 
 V V fcnDant plcaos tbat t^c piafntiff ftanus contfctco upon tf)C S>ta- "P"" ^ ?'<:» 
 tutc ntaoe agafnft aHicufancp, ano Demanos 3Iuogemcnt Si aftjo, SElic |" ^'"^^'j,^'^" 
 pafnttff Demurs upon t^c plea. Wild of Councel tofth tfjc piafntfff fafa, Bar. 
 -tbat iW matter ougljt not to be plcaoeo f n 315at of t^c 0£tfon , but \)c ougljt 
 to toncluDc onlp 31uDgcmcnt if ^c Iftall be anftocrco. SD^c Councel on tfjc 
 ot^et fioc Deftcen tfmc to fpeaU fn ft. Roll luftice, Shew caufe Monday next 
 why ludgeraent ftiall not be given againfl yon 
 
 Trin. 24 Car, Banc- Reg. 
 
 T^c Court teas motjeo foj tlje quafljfng of an Cnufctmcnt npon thc&ta- p ^^ qufhin 
 tutc of 8 Hen. 6, agafnft fojtfblc cnttfea, %\it crccptfon taUcn agafnft an F.?i'dift."^ 
 ft toao tbat t^c CEntif rtmcnt not!) not ffjcto fn tobat Countp tbc fojcfblc (Bn^ menr. 
 trplya0 upon iB^lch the CDnDictmentjDasgrounociJ. Roll lufticc anrtocrco, c<;umy, . 
 if it be within a Liberty, it is not neceflary. * 'o-ny. 
 
 Trin- 24 ("ar- Banc. Reg. 
 
 Tplt5cCourtlBas molJCB totiuaCi) an cn!)fttmcnt ofJDcrfurp agafnft Stephen 
 -*- Burtop,^!)? (iE);ccptfoit0 taken to the C'nofctm^nt to:rc tbcfCji.SCfjc Cn- ,„ Endift""^ 
 ijfamcntfsfafotobctalicnfn plenaSefsionepacis.anDftsothnotappcartohc mm: of pci- 
 tbe €iuartct &eisf one 80 bptfjc statute ft ongljt. 2lp. Jt is fafo,< tbat tUc jury. 
 SDcfcntjant dis;t,&c,amj ootb not Oieto toljerc oj f n totjat plea 13c natjc tf)c c. 
 
 B. 2 tjfDcncc
 
 1 24 Trin- 24 Car. 
 
 tfDcnc8toI)crctrttbcper|nrptoa0CommUtcD. 3!?, HtDotl)notfap,tl>at tb^ 
 JDcfcnCantgabctbccWocncc corruptive, as it ougTit to do. ^\v. SCOcpj^* 
 juDfcc fa not tain to be ad prave damnum of aiij.' boDp , anD fo no boop bcfnS 
 pjcjuDicED bp <t, none oug^t to be cnufaeD fo j ft. Roil luRicc fafo, It ts not 
 cnougl) to fap tl)c Cnofamcnt toao tahcnfn pleaa Ceftionegcncrallp, but 
 ft mutt appear in tr.f)at fecfalono it luas. TJierefore 'let C3u(e be fliewn why 
 it fliould notbequafhed. Bit icac aftcrtoarOoquaflicD, bccanfc ft DfD not 
 fljeto , tljat anp of t^c 3uCfcc0 bcfojc luljom ft Vuas taUcn Uicrc of t|jc Quo. 
 rum, ano not fo} t^e ott)ci; exceptions. ^ 
 
 Howard Sc 
 
 Tr n, 24 Car. Banc- Rtg. 
 
 irror in ii.c A SuDSCi^cnf toas gfbcn f 11 an 0ctton Of Dcbt til tl)f0 Court. 2!:i)cSDc< 
 t xciicqiicr- /\ fcnoant b;ings a ©Urft of €rro j fn tijc Chequer Cfjambcr to retctfc 
 Clumber to ti,jg3;i,3gcmcnt,antircniol3C0t!)cKrco;Dtljitbcr» Ttjcpiafntfffbifngsan 
 Scniciu ilcfon oftDcbtfntNa Court upon tbc3!uDScmcntgf&cnf)erc. SCftcSDefcn^ 
 g^vcn in Deb Dant plcaas in bar of tl)f0 action Nul tic! record, ano upon tbf s tljc plafntiff 
 in this Couir. Demurs, ana tbe Court after motions ano arsumcnt0 on bott) Goes, wns bp 
 ^^'■- tbc plaintiffs Counccl mouco fo; 3|uDgcmcnt fo; bim upon tl)C tDcmurrer. 
 
 , . I5ut Roll luaicean(U3CrcD,3fl'OUtoill5)atJC a Curia advifarevult. poufgall 
 
 u.gcmcnr. jj^^g jj jf „(,(, taUc pour courfc, fojtfjc KccojDfsnotljcrcbcfojcusjThet. 
 tore we can give no ludgement. 
 
 The King againfl: Trigg. 
 
 Trin. :4Car.Bjnc. Reg. 
 
 For quan>;rg TT^^c Coutt iDHS moteo to quafT} a Pjefcntment agamlf Triqgfojnot 
 aniiniiift- | nofnct bcfojc fl fuflfcc cf Pcacc to tauE tljc £)atbofanii5caDbojoto, to 
 m<r,u for nor ^^^^^ ^^^^^ ^^^ ^^^ ^^^^^^^^ gj g jLat.IEftc Crceptfons tahcu aeaintt it icere, 
 
 a Hcaaiwow 1" 2Ef)at it DotI) not appear tftat anp iiotlcc tnas gf'ocn to bfm.to go bcfojc tl)e 
 'lluCfcc. rip. ft appears not tl)"at tbcJInafcEfjaDautbojftptoaDmfmttci; 
 tljE iDatbf For die tirft exception the Prel'cntment was quafhed, 
 
 Collins againfl Page, 
 
 Trii. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Mich. 2Z Car, ro- 269- 
 
 F.rnr to r:- A |)lnfiit tuas CMtrcB itt tljc Court of Plymouth agsfnC P.igc fojtlbjcc- 
 
 "^•^''^ .' ';'"^-' /\fto;e pouuns, ano a pone taken out agnintt bin Coods, ano upon tijis a 
 
 "ponaCu-''0ff3ult, ano tl)crcupon anotbcr poneiffucDoutto attatcl) tbc SDefenoants 
 
 ft<m i.i I'iy <II5ooD3; auD tljc HDcfcnoant, at tb?cc otfjcr Courts futcefsitielp mahcsuc- 
 
 ni.udi. ■ fault , ano upon tljcfourtl) Default Bluogcment toas gifcen againft bfnt; 
 
 5iiabercupon tbe SJcfcnoant bjings aHHrit of (Bnoz in tbis Court to rcDcrfe 
 
 tlic SuDgcmcnt , auD afcfgno fo; €rro?, tftat here is a Juogsmcnt often 
 
 befoje anp appearance, tohicb cannot be, but in tbfs Cafe tbc dDooDs attatcft- 
 
 tcrfeiiu e. cQ arc oiilp fo;feitcD fo; tbe Default maoc bptbcDcfcnDantsnon'appa^ 
 
 ranee. 2Lljc Councel on tl)C otljcr fioc DefircD time to anriucr tbc crccptfon. 
 
 Roll
 
 Trin- '4Car- 
 
 R^Uiufticc, SCfte Cuttont upon totjfcf) tbtc jHUgement is cffcen is not reafo^' 
 nablc. Therefore ifycuanlwer no: the exception Cuefoap tcxr, the ludgec 
 mentfhallbcreverfed. 
 
 vSketeagainftCIay, 
 
 Trin, 24 Car Banc. Reg, . 
 Pafc, J4 Car. rot, 1 3o» 
 
 CLaylnougbtaniartionofsntefpafs againft Skete foj taWng atoapbiflE-romre. 
 gooDs, ano Ijao a tcroict ano a 3iUDiTcmeRt in tbe Common ^aicas, vcrfcaiud^e. 
 2El)e'ED€fcnDaritbjoiie{)tato?ttofG;troj to retcrfc tl)ts luogcmcnt; anO'^ci^ '"Ticf- 
 tbc CErrojs afojgnco ioete to tbe SDcclatattort , bccaafc tt b^D not p:opcr la.- |j\'^| ^^^.^^ 
 ttnctoo;D0tocrp;efrctl)cgooi)S; foj i.ittsfafotfiattljc ^lamctf took a- "' " ' ' * 
 toap decern Velatfiina, AnglicevToifca , totereas Velamina fignifies COtJC- 
 Ttiigsfiencrallp, 2. PilumtsufcofojPileum, tnCEnglifi) aCap. 3. Dcccm 
 CoIores,Angliccif»ecbbant)0. 4.Crura!ia,Anglicc(I?art£r3, 5. ^c Declares 
 dcunoinftrumcnto, Anglice a piate,fo; a3iacb. anotlp- Pro unoopcri= 
 niento, Anglice a IHapl. 31But Roll luftice fatD, tlCfe mutt not be too ctiri- 
 0U8 to ejpjcffe all things in ilattn toojos fn all .jTafes, fo j tt cannot be Done, p^^.^. .^ 
 ano tljctcfoje a Dcfcrtptton toUb an Anglice muafert:e, anofoit map ticre, ' '^'°''' 
 tfjcrcfoje let the Plaintif have his ludgcment, 
 
 Aylecagaiaft Oats, 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Tl^{3 Cafe teas motjcoagafn, anouponbtetooftfjeJSooU Ro/1 luRiccErrorrore- 
 l^'clD , tljat t^e BluDgement inas entire, ano ougbt to be rcijcrfcD fo; tt)e verfc a ji.jg;- 
 lDbole,altl)ou£bitbcgooDinfomepaTtofit' ano l)ecitco Trin. 14 Car, Scu.»'c.iteiuiic, 
 damorc anD Scudamdres Cafe , liiC.r.Gritewel f Morcfieids Cafe, 1 TriP.S^°'^.|',"|'^"' 
 II Car. Eltonhead ano Deerhams Cafe, anOTrin. 7 lac. rot. 565. Bird anu'"]^,' j°, 
 Ormes cafe, ano ^ Rep. Specots Cafe, ano > 5 Car, Dye ano?. tkim Cafe, 
 and upon thefe authorities the judgement wis reverfed, 
 
 5"ir Charls Ccoc againft Plunkec. 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 T^c Conrt teas motcti on tlic part of tijt sDefenoant , tftat tljc piaintif To be dir. 
 bao DcclarcD upon an obligation tuitl) a tonoition , but ban not fct it "''"^'f^^^ "P°" 
 fojtl) in tbc SDcclaration , ano tbcrcfojc cciircD tbat be map citbcr bate Ban"'"" 
 iDpet of it , J elfc tbat tbe JDeclaratfon being imperfect , fo fbat be cannot 
 pleaD , anD be being nolo in pjifon, map otberioffe be fct at large. Roll lu- 
 flice, C23e cannot compclltixpiaintif to fetfojt^tbeconoition of tbc£)b» 
 ligation; but till be botb tbc E>cfeniiant Iball not be compcUco to plcao, ano pj^.,^ 
 let tbc plaintif tbeto caufc upon not ice nitcn to bim , iubp tbc SDcfenoant • 
 fl)all not goe at large upon Common bail, gt teas n!o*jcQ again , ano tbcn ^ 
 Rolllufticefaio, 31f pouarrcftone,ai:ODoenotp;occeco in tb?.ee Eciins, gj,'|]' ■™'°'''' 
 be OUjibt to goc out upon Common JSail, But move it again to morrow, 
 
 3a 3 . , Trio*
 
 12^ Trin. 24 Car. 
 
 Trin^ 24 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 To qiuni an nr ^^ '^oui^t toas motcD to quaO) an enofctmcnt npon tl^e S>tatatc of j 
 
 pnjuiy. Cnafctment faU^, tlje £)atft toas taken before ISaton Atkins ano Serjeant 
 Turner, but ftDotftnot fap tuljcte, viz. tDl)ctt)et<t tocrcat tbc S>:fslon0, 
 OjflfStjCS. 2!y. Sttfaftb tl)e £)atft teas tahcn Coram iufticiariis Domini 
 Regis, biit ftuotbnoteicpjcfstoftat SJuClces tijep toctc. 'he Endiamenc 
 V7as quafhcd for chc firft Exception. 
 
 T'he KingagatnftBellingham. 
 
 Trin 14 Car. Banc. Reg* 
 
 Formovkrati- "o Elljngham toas fnofcteDupon tije&tatiitcof J Eliz. agafnffpctjnrp, ano 
 on ot a fine |jpleaccD j^ot *lI5uUtp, anD tuac founD©urltp, %fie CafctDastbls, BeU 
 upon coiwi- lingham ftaD a pjoccfs DeUbcrcD !){m out of tb: Court of Cffilaroa to fcrbe 
 ju'iT "upon one, tobfcb be d(o acco^omglp ; ano upon tbc return tbcrcof be maoe 
 £)atbtbatbefcrticDtbe|0?ocef3upontbcpartpti)e8tb, Dapoftbc ^ontb, 
 tobercas it teas tbe 9tb. tap but (t appcareD upon eicamtnatlon of tbs mat- 
 ter , tbat tbe ;2Datb toaa not taken maUtfouflp , but onlp raOjlp ; anu upon 
 tbls tbe Court teas motjeDio fct a mo*Deratc Bne. Roll luftice faio , bc« 
 cauCc it teas fo, tbcrcfojc let tbe fine be but 10 1. 
 
 Fine 
 
 Emf t" le- 
 
 Gallop againft Chafe. 
 
 Trin. 24. Car. Banc, Reg. 
 Pafcb. 24. Car. rot. 250. 
 
 T^c Cafe of Chafe ano Gallop teas again mobeo, tobicb teas tijis. Chafe 
 iJJous^t an action of SCrotjer ano ConUcrCon in tbe Common peas a. 
 nKm int^ gainft Gallop ano bis teife , ano a Stranger ; ano DccIarcB tbat tbe Baron 
 vcrand Con- anO iTcmc anO tbe ffrangcr converterunt ad ufum fuum proprium. scbe 
 veifijn. loiatntit bao a Clcroict ano a Jimgcment . %^t SDcfenoant fajinga a Wixit 
 ofCrrojtorcberfetbisSIaDgement, ano afsigng foj (Krroj , tbat the 2De= 
 claration is not gooo , foj it Declares of a ContjcrCon maoc faptbe iFeme to 
 berotenufc, ubftb cannot be, (be feeing a ifcmc Cobert, Roll luftice 
 faio , SClje H>Eclaration ootb intcno , tbat all tbe SDefennants Dio concert 
 
 __...tbcgooD3, tenicb cannot be , foj tbe JFcmc cannot conbcrt tbcm, ano ci= 
 
 Co.ivclfion. tcD Crow ano Bakers cafe i Caroli? 7 H.y.f.j. Therefore let the ludgemcnt 
 bereverfed. 
 
 Tnn- i^.Car. Banc* Reg' 
 
 Por a catia- ■^ ^c Court ixois molJCD foj 3 Certiorari to tcmotic an £);Dcr of Scfcions 
 
 uc. -1 maBc foj t{jc cicftdig of one to be a Conttablc , tbat tbe i!J?Der map be 
 
 confirmeo bcrc, anotijcConCablccompcUcDto be fteojn,» Roll luftice 
 
 an« 
 
 Declaration 
 Feme Covert
 
 Tiin. 24 Car. lit 
 
 anfteercD, ST^at bp grantfnc it tl)c crcctitfon otBliifffcc bptfic ^uOfcea 
 in tbe Counttp tofU be tfttojeo , tljcrcfojc appeal to ttjc JiuttkCB of iJfsfjE, 
 foj toe iDtUnot grant a Certiorari, tmpon tbfc a tDjft inas pjapeo out of 
 tft{0 Court to compell tlje Conttablc to be ficojn , which was granced, M:a Jamu:, 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc, Reg 
 
 Whether s" 
 
 A 3!uD2cmcnt tone aft?cnfntbc Common picas fn an ejcftione firm^writotErr^c 
 quod recuperet,* a to?ft of C-rquup taUen out; but before it teaa txeca^%°°<^- 
 ten ano retojncD tljc SDcfcnoant bjoujjbt a tD?U of Crro j ; anD tJjc qneflfon 
 tDa0iDl)ctf)crtbcto;(tof Crtoj lap o% ro. Turner of Coutucl tcftlj t6e 
 SDcfcnDanttntfjetojftoferrojargucD, tbatftDlDnotlfc,becaufc tl)e D-- 
 riglnal to?ft iBSs not uctermfnec ul^en tljc tojit of €xm ^ras b;cugl)t, ano 
 fotl)c3utigcmcnt teas not perfect oj complcat, ano confcquentlp a injtt 
 cfCrrojcotilDnot bcbjougbttoreticrreft, anotftattljc tejtt is not Betcr« 
 jn{neonojtl)e3!«5gemcnt perfect, fspjotj^ brcanrct&e Sctfon befng an 
 ejedione firraaeljere <s no cofts anD DamagcWounD , no j is tfjere anp habere 
 facias porfeffionemrctojncD, tobfclj arc tbe fruits of tftc juDgcment, ano 
 anDbeciteiJ54H. 8. f. 18. 39H. 8 Fitz, Error 40. ^6 8c 57 Eliz. in tfte 
 CommDnJ0lca0,Year anD PeverellsCafe,? 6 Car.Banc.Reg.25nt Roll lurtice 
 fa(D , Ijerc f0 Ideo corfideraturo ti\ quod recuperet , tobftf} t0 a perfect ^uDgCi 
 ment, bntftbaDnotbccnfoffttjc luDgemcnt hfrti b:cn quod recuperare '"'^S*'"'"'^' 
 debeat, anD U is <n pout potuer tobetfjer pou tofU fjate a \Djit of enquir? 
 ojnot, anDfftfte juogemcnt be affirmeD Ijere upon tbe tojft of C-rtojB cv c'en- 
 ijjougMpoumapbate aiDritofeiiqtifrpl)crcfntl)f0Court. 2C!)cCounccl '!"''/■ 
 thereupon mobeD foj a Certiorari. Roll Iu!lice,Take it but it will doe you no 
 good, for the judgement iswellt 
 
 Stent agalnft 
 
 Trin, 24 Car. Banc.Reg. 
 
 Tent bjengW a" actfon upon flje cafe foj fpsaljfng tlbefc fcanbalouaAncfVof 
 toOjDaofbim, Thouart a pick- pocket RoEue and liaft picked fhv ma- Ji'-'gcmcnt in 
 
 s . _ _ „ 
 
 fters pocket and nil Money- box , and I will prove ir. 2Ef)C piafntif ftao a'"^^'*'*'^ ^""^ 
 tactDfct. scftc SDefcnDant mobco in arreft of jungcment tfcat tbelDejDfl,""^,'™^ 
 are not actionable, fo? tbat tbcp are t© general anb uncertain. *riie ludge- 
 mentwasarrefced till the Plaincifftiouldmove» ' 
 
 Trin. 24. Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 'A CertioraTitoasgrantebonf of this Court to remolic certain enoict- For a j-;/;^^- 
 x\ment0Offojciblecntrie0, iDbereas fn truti) tftcrc tocrc no Gn»i(t= '■-^ '^ to » 
 
 /<i ;. 
 
 ntcnta Of forcible entrp founD againft the partp; upon this a Superfedeas '"''"' 
 toacpjnpcD to fupcrfeDe the Certiorari* Roll luftice, SCbis Certiorari toas 
 gotten bp toap of petb«ntion foj tnljat migtit be Dene , but talvc a Precedent '.''OcccfaUt, 
 dotothejuftices to proceed notwithitanding theXertiorari. 
 
 Triot
 
 128 Trin. 24Cv. 
 
 Trin, 24. Car. Banc. Reg- 
 
 tendani to /A cntioH : %i)z SDefenoant appears ano fmparls , ano after Imparlance 
 picjd in chief *• ■» plcnDs fn abatement of t^e Scire facias , t^at tfte ipialntff ^aD taben 
 j-tccr impar- qq^ g fojmcr Scire facias foj tftc fame caafe , tu^fc^ is pet cepentfng. 3t 
 tDasmoteofojt^epatntff, t^atttie SDcfenoant one^t not to ^leao tt)f0 
 plea fn abatement after imparlance, bat t^at ^e oni^ to pleao tn cl^fer* 
 Roll luAice, Lrc hi'm plead luch a plea as he will abide by wicbin a. week , or 
 elfe let the Plaintif cake bis judgemenCt 
 
 Uricc. 
 
 Trin. 24 Car- Banc. Reg. 
 
 For i stf w- A Coppl^oloer being fneo ffffbte Conrt foj certain lanos, moteD , ttiat 
 ardofacourt /\tbc&tctoarDofftf3 3Lojdb Conrt , to tu^om be ioas a Coppftoloet, 
 [iic cou 'c" "''^^^ ^'^ ojoerea to bjf ng In ttie Conrt-moUs into tWs Coart, tbat bp ttiem 
 Roll*. ' be map be ttie better enableD to Defenuljte title to tlielanDs. JBot Roll la. 
 flicefaio, He canuot be ordered CO dock by this Conrt > therefore we will 
 '^eno ruleinitt 
 
 jiiror 10 rr- 
 
 Trin. 34 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 A ^ attlon of Debt toas faioaght fo j IRent fn t^e Common picas, toljete 
 V, n> a ju 'ge- ^ t^^ plaintif bao a tHerDitf ano a inDgement , ano a Writ of Crcoj ioas 
 mcuinche b^ougbt in tbisCoDrt to rcijerfc tt)<s Blnogement* Cbe C^ro^s aGsigneo 
 Common tocre, I ♦ SCbcrc is an Snoentiirc recitco to be bettoeen tbe plaintif ano 
 pif »5 f.r. tnt. i^hn Barber, tD^creas it IbonlD babe bcfen lohn Barker, Roll luftice anftoe* 
 Miinoimer- ^^^ ^ ^^ ^^^ ^^ j^gj ^^ ^g fenotDtt bp tbe one name, ano the otber , ann them 
 
 it is tDcU enongti- ^feconoCrceptiontDas, BltisfaiD per indenturam (Igc 
 
 nataiD,'anD Doth not fap deliberataiii, ano then it is no Oeeo if it be not oeli* 
 
 . tjereo, SDo^bis Ro" luftice anfincrco , 3f be fap per fadum fuum,it is toeH 
 
 " * cnoagbj n^lBlthftanoing, fo; tbat implies it to be a perfect oeeo. jlp, ^e 
 
 ocdares fo; )ilent of l^onfes in Kenc ftreer, ano oot^ not (beto in toliat pa. 
 
 ritl) Kenc ftreec is. Adjourned. 
 
 Trin» 24 Car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 F'.-a Habeas "Xi^c (Eonrt Irasmotteo foj 8 habcascorpus fo j a pjitoner in t!)e fSings 
 Corpus for a jjocnct) pjlfon, tljat be might be a feitncffc in a caafe to be trpco at the 
 ncrt Hfsifes in Darby Shire, 515ut Roll luftice anftoercO.tBC Ml grant no 
 habeas corpus, fo^ this is bat a trfcfj of the partp himfclf to gain his ILibertp 
 that he map go a hainWng ano hunting this long Vacation. But I have known 
 itgranted for one to be a witnefle at a trial at Yield Hall ; but at the charges , 
 and peril . of the Party, for whom he was to be a witneiTe.if he efcape. 
 
 Mich. 
 
 in.fontv ill 
 t xccutioii
 
 Mich. ?4 Car. j^p 
 
 Mich. 24 c^r- Banc- Reg. 
 
 c 
 
 V pons motion fo J a habeas Corpus fo J one In Crecutlon apon a ftn» For a habeas 
 lence glten arrafnft \)im in tfjc Conrt of t^c aomf raltTP,3t toas faio bp """V"'- <»'■ "" 
 Roniuftice,2i:battfoticbcfucDfntbcaoniltaltpto a.fcntencc,.anD bein'" '^"""''o™ 
 ftxttutim m)on It , ano be bjougbt ^ttljct bp a habeas corpus; If upon tfte tt-. "c^ncVin "he 
 tojn It Dotb not appear t^at tijc Sfomlraltp l^ao not itirtgotctfon of tljc cauf e, Admiralty. 
 bat It appears onlp t^at tbcp bao pjocccDcD to a fcntcncc agalnft t^e rules of 
 tftctr otnn Coott, JDbfs Court tolll not oelltcr tlje ^ jlfoner out of Cre. *PP"'- 
 cntton, fo J Ijc ousl^t to ftatjc maDe Ijfg appeal , bEfo:c ^c toag tafecn In C^z- 
 cntton^ Artd fo is it touching the proceedings in other Courts of equity* 
 
 Cage. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car* Banc. Reg. 
 
 Oi^e Cage toao in (Bttcntion In tfte JSIng© JScncl) upon a BluDgcmcnt ftau j^ v,c«e a 
 agatnft i;<m fo; a ftunujen poano , SDbe plaintiffs ;atto;nep bp frauo fati^faftion 
 iDltfjout tljcconfent of tiis Clpcnt acbnolr'cDgcth fatlsfactton upon tljtsacknowiedg- 
 3aiJgcmcnt,aftEriDarDs t^c attoinep of tljc SDcfenoant iultbout t^econfent^'' "p°" ' 
 of filsClpentacfenovDleogetf) anotljetiuogementfojtbe fame Debt, scftc^"''^*""'"^* 
 palntlffsCounccl moi3eD,tl)at the SDcfennant migftt be In CrccHtion upon 
 ^efitftSuOgement, ano tftat the fatlsfactfon acKnoinltsgeD tftcrenpon 
 ntlgftt be tjacatto. Roll luftice anftocteo , SCfjc ^ttoancp oug^t to' 
 be commltteD fo j acbnotoleoglng the fetono SuDgement tcltl^ont tEIarranf • Ccmmicmcm. 
 JButfterearettoofranoSjOncof eacft fioc, fotftat there Is frauo sratntt 
 trauD, annfo the partpcs ate left to their remeopes one agalnft the other, 
 bat both the attojneps (hall be commtttcDfojt their falfe pjattlce. And we 
 will examine the whole truth of the matter Saturday next* 
 
 againft Loveday. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car* Banc, Reg* 
 
 T" ^e Court toas mobeo upon an affidavit that one of the patois that gahc P""" » ""» 
 •*■ the tjerDlct aaatnft the plaintiff han a ftitc Itxlatouepcnolng at that time ''^'l '^'". 
 luiththepalnttff, ano thcrefoje that the trpal toasnot InoJffer^nt, nno^,'!,;,./,"!;^. 
 thetefoje It toao pjapeo there might be a ncU) trpall. iSut the Court fjio, ..oz md.ftc. ' 
 it could not be , anDasfeeDthepartptDhp he olo not challenge the Bturojicnt. 
 foj this canfe at the trpal, for want of which he had now loft that advan:.^'|^"[rf t. 
 tage. 
 
 Stradling and his wife againft Boreman. 
 
 Mich* 24 Car." anc, Reg, 
 
 STradlin^anhhlBtolfebjoughtanattlonofCrefpalTcof 3ffanlt ano baf^Afcfto? 
 tetp,anDtahtngof aho;re,agafnftBoreman,anti the plaintiffs Declare ad'^^e;"'^'."' "« 
 damnum ip(orum,ano hate a tjcrclct ; the EDefcnoant mohca In arrEflcof[ '';|^|,^^;. 
 3iHDg6mcnt,anD fhcwch foj caufe that ti-,e JSaron ano Jcmc cannot ;opn Inon. 
 
 & thw
 
 I JO Mich- 24 Car. 
 
 ma 0(tfon, bnt onsl^t to b;fnc feterall jSlctione, fo^ tbe tokens Done to eacb 
 toas rcbcraU. The ludgemem was cbereopou ftaycd till the Plaintiff Ihould 
 
 move* 
 
 Mich- 24 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 A^ ;Sf(tioiT upon'tbe Cafe ixae bjoug^t fo^ fpeabtngtbere foojDs, He is 
 gon and dares not (hew himfclf for Dibt, ;ind he is a CanckrDpt,for 
 
 on ihc Cafe, ^^ft Of SlaugEmcnt'tijat tbe toojBs ate not aatonablc, bctanfc tbcp are gene. 
 tal,anDnnccrta{n« But the Court held that all the words taken together 
 . are adionabie, but ftayed the ludgement for a week. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 lurors uwvc | mtojg li)|io appeatBD foj a trpal at t^c 515ar tobfcl^ fcl off fo> inant of a 
 
 for rhcir char- ^ fyH gutf, pjapeD tt)e Coutt tftcp mlgbt ftabe tbcit titjargee , becaafe ttiep 
 
 ^"' came a great tcap, ant> bao attcnucs long fn totom %^t Conrt anCtoereo 
 
 tbcm, tbat ft loae tbek neighbours fault, tobo ofo not appear, tbat tbe ttpal 
 
 toent not on, fo^ botb tbe partpes are reaop , ano if tbe canfe bao been ttp- 
 
 eOt pon £^ onlb babe bao all pour cbargeo. But now wc can order nothing. ' 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 • to \7PonaaRcto?nofacertiorariforcmobcanojDcrof&cr0fon0maDe a- 
 
 Tn-TderTand ▼ gatnC a ^Darlft foj not repairing of a b<Sb trap, Hales of Counccl 
 
 fi„c of stffi- foj tbc laarlfl) toob tWfl ejcccptlon, viz. JLbat tbc fine toas fet upon tbe ^a- 
 
 ons. tifl) toltbont anp p^otetTc ItTutD out againS tbe |i)arl&,onIp apon a certificate 
 
 of oncoftbeHuftfccBoftbepcatemaDeupon bl0 oton t/eto that tbe toap 
 
 toae not rcpatrco , ano fo tbc ^arilb uas conocmneD before tbcp tnere 
 
 beam. 2Lotbf0tbeCourtanrirercD,2Lbata3;nfllceof ipcace map make 
 
 Ccitihcatr. a certificate upon bis otsn bf cto, of tbe tx ant of reparations of a f^lgbtoap, 
 
 bp t^c S)tfitute, SEbcrefo3cb?lnga certificate tbat tbe biapls rc^pafrrD, 
 
 elfe toe falll to nothing, fo? lit muft net be too baftp to obertbJoU) fucb p?e» 
 
 rcntments Isblcb fo much concern tbe pnbllqne goob. And in this cafe if there 
 
 Conviaion. be aconvidJoninlaw,andthcfine hvyed,we cannot belpir, and now you 
 
 Trsv«r». camot iravcrle, for it is too late. 
 
 Sir Anthony Afhley Cooper againftiyt. lohn, 
 Mich, 24 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 • 
 
 A^reftof C^"" Anthony Aflilcy Cooper bjongbt an 0ctfon Of JCrefpaffcnpontbe Cafe 
 )adp.:neni in Ofojfalfefmpjlfonment of bfmagalntt St. John, ano batb a berDW agafntt 
 an^tt.onon ^m; tthsSDttenoanCmotjeo (n artcd of Bjungement , anotabestbis Creep* 
 
 the c.fe, t{p„
 
 Mich. 24 Car. 131 
 
 tto« to rtc JDcclatatfon tljat it toanteD vi et armis toftfcl) oiia!)Tto~^atc bcen^ 
 bccaafc tiflais not a meet Mion apon ifte Cafe ; but in its nature it is an 
 Action of 2Crefpaffc, anDtbcrcfojcJjcougbttobatJCbcctiDerlarcoin tnttb vi 
 
 ^t ai mis. Roll lufticc anfiuCrCD, U)l)at faj' poti to tljC Cafe, quarefr egit fu^ Decr»ratlDn. 
 um mill'daro, Uibicb bat^ been aojuQ(jeb 500D toitljout vi et armis, bs IdcU ac 
 toitft vi et armis i anD in one cafe it fljall be faio to be an action of SLrcfpaffe, 
 viz. toitbttjcviet armis, ano in tbe otber an aaion upon tbc Cafe , viz. 
 loitbout tbc vi et armis ; anD Bacon luftice CtteD tbe 9. rep. The Earl of 
 Shrewsbaryes Cafe. Roll Iiiftice, 3t is a plain Mion upon tb2 Cafe, as it 
 map appear bptcatjing of tbe JRcco;n,foMt is toitb an ct quod cum. Bacon 
 >^r* fnin nnnrannot hafacan Sdfonof snr£fCi?lTnfDifhp h'pnktmr nfntift. 
 
 Ayreagainft Sils. 
 
 Micb. 24 Car. Banc; Re^. 
 
 AYrebjougU an Action upon tbc Cafe againlisils, upon a pjomifc to \rrcft of 
 pap certain arrcrages of rent appearing Due unto Win upon an accompt luJjcmcnt in 
 tnaDefaettoeenbittianut'oeSDsfcnDant: SCbe paintiCf ban a bcmfd:. 2Elje '" ^'^ °? "P" 
 JDcfjJilantmobesinarreaofJuDSCtttent.ano fo; caufc OjeIds, tbat an^"*" "'^* 
 Action upon tbc Cafe Dotb not Ip upon a p jomife to psp rent appearing Dae cife 
 upon accompt, foj tbc rent tuas ouc bp a reall contrait , ann upon tbat tbe 
 plaintiff ban rcmeup toftbout tbe pjamife. SCo tbts tbc Court faio , tbat 
 tbis 3(tion Dot') not Ip coj rent alone Due upon a real contract , but foj tbc 
 rent Uutbotbcrttiings it Dotblpc, yet let the Indgcraent be ftaycd , fojtberc 
 febcrciionetoconfiDeration appearing to grounntbispjomife upon,butonlp 
 tbe olDtonftcerationof l.atufoj tbe papmcntoftbcrcnt.anD upon tbat an 
 aaion of tbc Cnfc Dotb not Ip, fo; it is in tbe realtp. 
 
 Tomkins aga\nft Jourden. 
 
 Micb, 14 Car. Bare, Reg» 
 
 Trin,i4Car, rot.jJfSt 
 
 A tMrit of (Etroj teas bjougbt to rclicrfc a SluDgincnt gib en fn an infcri- ETor to re-' 
 -'^ our Court, n tbcfc CSrrojs toercafsigncD.i.StisfatDiiitbcflileof tbc"^;^'=».'"'^R=- 
 Court tbat tbc Court teas bClD per confuetudinem et literas patences,U)t)icb is an "ntct'iour" 
 not gooD,fo^. tbe Court cannot be l)clD bp botb.RoU Iuftice,2nbi3 is not gooo. court, 
 alp.agatnft tbe iijit of CSrro; it is obiectcD bp tbe otbcr li^e, tbat tbe lujit of 
 Crroj is DlredcD to one, ano is rcto jneo bp anot'ier, foj tbe certiorari jras to 
 ccrfpfiea3luDgcmcnt gibcn bcfo?e tbe £|0aioj,aiDcrmen, anoHecojocr, 
 anD tbc BluDScmcnt certifpcD , is a Suogemcnt gibcn befo jc tbe i^aioj ano 
 tbc aiDermen , ano tbe lilccojoer is left out, fo tbat tbc IIccojd is not rc= 
 mobcD,anatl)entbc SiuDgement cannot be affirnicD. Roll luftice faio, tbc 
 plcaDingisconfufcQ, anD Bacon lufticefalD, pon babe c'jangcD tbe fiile of 
 tbc Coipo^atto n bp pour plcaoingjSlf a Court be bclo bp Ci;ttom,anD after acuftom. 
 patent be purcbafeD to bolo it, ano tbcp bolD it bp tbc patent, tbc Cuttom is 
 gone; but bringusaCopyofthe cert'ficace of theftileofthe Court , and 
 in th« mean time wc will advifc. 
 
 ^ 2 Pi'cSf
 
 13^ Mich. 2 4 Or. 
 
 Pickering again ft Barkley, 
 
 Micb, 14 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 Pafc.24Car. rot, 154. 
 
 Demurrer T)ickfrinp Ijoiif^t nti SJttfon ofCot^cimtit upoii ti cccD Df Cotf nantc (if 
 
 iTan sfti.m -■■ Charter partr,lLljcrcti> ft tnao CotcnanteD \W tljc SDcfcntant (n con-- 
 
 (fcovxnan;. fiDeratfon of accttafn fumofmoni' agrccD tobcpafototftc SDrfcnoant, fo> 
 
 frafg'it of a &»!)(p flioulD maUc fntb a tiopogc, ann Icat all loffes ano caniagc 
 
 ix^Wl) fliotilD befall tl)c S)l)<P, oj qDcnbanolfcBtn l)Er,c):ccptfn0 nip pcrJlis 
 
 oftfjc&ca, anDtcflarcfltljattbcSr'EfenDant baunotpcrfojmcD bfsagrcc 
 
 iiTcnt, ana fojtM3l)c5)?<ng£> Ibis flrtfon, %\)e SDefcnfiant plcaD0, tfjat in 
 
 t!)C mafetne of ftfo topanc upon tl)c feca, tbc gifjlp iras tahcn per quoidam ig« 
 
 noto« hortiines bcllicofos, luljcrf bp IjE Ua0 l)fnD;cB in malihig of tbe topagc 
 
 accojDfngto l:f0 agreement; to tUs pica tl]c patntlff Demurs. SLljequefl^ 
 
 on teas <n rcgarD tljat in tbe Cljarttr partp perl lis of tbc fi> c as toere cvccpt= 
 
 CD, Uil)ctl)cr t|)C talung of tfte S>l)tp bp tlicfe,unhK0Un men of Wtix OjoulD be 
 
 actomptcD a pcrill of tijc S>ca, o^not accojoing to tl^e meaning of S^ti- 
 
 tijants. Twiiden of Conned UiUbt^cpafntiff^elD it CboulD not, ano fo 
 
 tlje plea toas not gooD, ant) tijat tftcr efo? c tbc paintiff ougtt to ftatic 3!nt»g5 
 
 ntcnt, anofaio, tl)iglDagnotaDangeroftl)c&ca . but a Danger upon tbe 
 
 S>ca. 2lp. ^efaiD,t!)cpartp(itmapbc)mig!)t ftatJcpjctjentcDif bp tf- 
 
 eilancp, J bp mailing rcftftancc, ano fo it map bcittoasftis oton fault tl)B 
 
 §>liipiDastaUcn, jlp. 2D^e men of ©Hart tljat tooh t!)c &Ufp toere pcr- 
 
 aDtcnture CDiiglfK) men , ano tljen tbc SDcfcnDant is not to be ercufeo, foj 
 
 ^c map babe bis rcmeDp fo; tobat be is oamnificD ,agafnft tbcm , anD titeo 
 
 35 H, d.f. i.anDpjapcDSuDgemcntfoi tbc plaintiff. Hales of dCoun* 
 
 ccl toftbtbc2?cfcnt)antbclo,tbatto be tahcn ana robbco bp pirates is a! 
 
 Danger of tbe a»ca, ctjcn as tempcftuous Ininos, ano febclfs, ano llocfes are. 
 
 ^110 2lp. Co tbat it is faiaJt^c pirates map be €n glf Qj men, toe arc not able 
 
 tofapoflDljat jiiaitiontbcptocrc, anD tbcrefojc our plea is gooDin tbat 
 
 point alfo, auopjapcoSluDgcmentfo?. tbe3DcfcnDant. Roll luftice faio, 
 
 ft loas not VdcU plcaaca to fap per homines ignores. Bacon luftice faiD, 2Dbe 
 
 SDefcnoant Dotb not fljclu tbat be ano bis &Mp toaa carrpeD per locos in cog- 
 
 pij, nitos, as be tboulD bate fijcton ; but Roll luftice anftaercD, tbat it map be 
 
 tbe S>bip is pet kept upon tbe &ea,faut 31 fuppofc tbat pirates are perils of 
 
 tbe &ca , anD to tbis pnrpofc a certificate of (^ercb ants tuas rcao in Court , 
 
 thattbeplDcrcfocffcemcDamongftfpercbants. ^et tbe Court DeftrcDta 
 
 bate Granly tbc Chaffer of tbe SCrinitp boufc,anD otbet fufficient ipertbants 
 
 to be b?ougljt into tbc Court to fatiefie tbe Court viva voce Friday nc j:t foU 
 
 IcUifng. ludrfment was given this Term ni! capiat ptr billaro;becaHfe the 
 
 iskirgby Fiiatcs are atcoreptcd perils of tl.eSsas. • 
 
 Wood
 
 Mich. 24 Car. 13 j 
 
 Wood againfl: Clcmencc. 
 
 Micb, 24 Car. Banc.Af g. 
 Hill»2»Car.rot. 804. 
 
 Wood bjouclt an 0ctfon of S^ebt upon an DHtgntfon to ffano to 
 an nil atl>> agalnft Clemencc. mt SDefcnDant plwoeo ttat tftc , ,7,7;. 
 5[tbftrato?0 mace no aUiaro : SEbe pafntff rrpUcs ttat tbe tMmpfre maue ward pleaded. 
 anatoatD, anDfcta'tfojtb at large, .SDbc ErfcnDant otmurs, ano fo; 
 taufc (bctDc t'at U appears bp ttjc pleaotng tbat \i)t ^mpfrc teas cbofcn be 
 foje be oiiBbt to bc; fojft appcrirs not tbat tbe 5lrbJtrato?0 tculD not agree 
 tn niabing tije fltoaro , o?tb^ttbrrbao anp polrct to ntat^c an mmpirc. 
 2lp.2Lbe5ltDatDf3maDC fojfatfofattiontotbc iSDtoncrs ano ^arfncrs of 
 tbc febtp, toncernfng tobfib tbe ftibmifsJon teas mabe , ano one of tbcm is 
 tbe J3lc(nt(f (n tbfs Sttton , ano tbep cannot arKtrate tbat tbe monies iBbftft 
 concern one fliall be pain to anotbcr , anb fo all tbe atnarn is naugbt. 0iro 
 bere is nottingarbttrateD concerning John A aon tbe spatter of tbe &bip, 
 hbo io one of tbe parties teitbin tbe fubmifsion. Roll luftice, 3b to tbe 
 Cift (Erccption it is not a material one,as 3 ccnceibc.But give a note of your 
 f xceptions 10 the Ccuncel of the other fide, and bring us Books, Poltea* 
 
 Frere and others again ft 
 
 Mich. 34 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 A Ji Action of 2Dcbt iuas b?o«gbt foj 1 500 l.upon a oeco of Cbarfcrrpartp. ^rreft V 
 
 2Cbc painttf ban a bcroict. 2Cbe SDcfenoant moticu in f rrctt of juDge- judgcm^ent in 
 mcnt. anD offers 1 0? caufe, tbat tbe SDeclaration inas fnftiificient, fo; ftdcbc. 
 appears not bp it tbat tbe jBDefcnoant is inoebteD to tbe paintif , ann tben 
 tbcre is no caufc of jetton ; foj tbe SDeclaration onlp faps, tl:at be is inneb- 
 teD, as it appears, but flietus not boto. Roil luHice faiD,it is bp inoenture, 
 anU locll enougb. Dyer 2, 3 Phil.anD Mar. f. 148. Plowdeni2i. 122. Debt. 
 Buckleys cafe 143. Browninj; anbBeeftonscafc 21 E. 4.f, 29, \jt faiD,eftbCt^°*^"»"^' 
 an action of Debt , 0; an action of Cobenant lies bcre, fo;t it is npon a 
 Cbarter^partp. %eretsnot inoccD a perfect allegation, pet it isiueB e= 
 nougb , foj ft batb ba n ufuallp tbus pUaoco. speak to it again Wcdnefday 
 next. 
 
 Difonagainft Bartue, 
 
 Mich.24 Car. Bano Reg. 
 
 DKon bjotigbt an action of affattlt anb JBatterp.anb tafeing of bis gooos, . 
 againftBattue,anDbaDalllerDict; tbe SDefenoant mobco in ar«ttotiJ'"„°g„t;n 
 31tiDgemcnt , ano fljclDCD foj caiife tbat tbe HDcclaration leas not gooD; foj M'a .u and 
 it is toitba quod cnra, &c. inblcb in an action of trefpafs, vi et armisjfs notBjttei). 
 gooOvfo J it is not a cirect affirmatibctbat tbe SDefrnoant oio tbe SCrcfpafs ; 
 bat it is onlp an implication tbat b^DiD it, but as it is it might babe been 
 goooiftbeactfonbaDbcenanaaionof^refpaircupontbc cafe The Judge- 
 ment was flayed till the Plaint>t'ftioufd move, 
 
 S3 Micbf
 
 IJ4 Tnn.-^C2t' 
 
 Mich- 74 Car. Banc. Reg, 
 
 • 
 
 ?n Tn^Awafd A S**-"" "^ ^^^ ^^^ fajongbt opoii HH Obligation to ttantt to an a- 
 
 vicaded. -/\iDarD. 2^l)C Dcfenoatit plcaDco nullum arbitrlum. 2C!)c plafntfiT.rcc 
 
 pUe0, atiD fcts fo:tl) tbc a^ato, atiD afofgno a bjcacb ; 2Cbe DcfenDant dc^ 
 
 muro; SCftc |3lafnt<ff after Dcniurrct motors tl:c Court, tftat^cmlgtit off. 
 
 tontfiuie bto aafon. SBut ti)E Court fafo, that after a ocmnrrer upon an jar^ 
 
 Dfcontir.u. bftrntioH, ft fs not ufual to uifcontfnuc t^c aafon. But kt nil caput per bil- 
 
 *"'^' lam be entred, if caule be not Ihewed to the contrary* • 
 
 Mich. 24 ("ar. Banc. Reg. 
 
 =nt by A -^ ^^^^^ °^ ^^^^ ^^^ fa joucbt bp iBaron ano iFcme upon an £)bUsa« 
 and • ./itioiimaDetotljci^cmcdumfolafuir, ano tbc Declaratfon feaddam. 
 
 Dcctaraticn. 
 
 Arrefl of 
 
 i'.aion an.. ■» — >>v«i ...---.- --^- ^ , ■ — — — .- 
 
 Fune. nom ipforum; Cftc Jplafntlffa bao a tjcroftt; SCIjc Dcfcnoant motjcs fn arrcff 
 
 of SuDgcment, ano fojcaufcfl)ctDB,tftattbc Declaration fboultj not be ad 
 damnum ipforum, but onlp ad damnum Of tl)C i^UflbanD Onlp I3tlt tI)C Court 
 IjclD tljat tbc Declaration luas toell cnonsl), ano fafo , it ia tftc ufual leap of 
 Declaring in fuc^ 0(tion0," ano tlje tnonp Due upon tbc £Dbligation not being 
 pafD to tlje i^cme toWlcft fbc toas fole, it teas oammagc to ftcrjano note be- 
 ing Cobcrt it is a Dammage to tljc 315aron alfo, ano fo it is ad damnum ipfo^ 
 rum 16E. 4, Therefore let the Plaintiff take his Judgement' 
 
 Quatermans Cafe. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car, Banc. Reg» 
 
 Ar.tientufc of T j^ tl)c Cafc of OHB Qiiaterman, Roll luftice faio, tijat out offiiDulgence 
 p.adc. a''t^-£totbciBapl,it hat!) been tbcufe of later times, tljat jftheJSaploobifng 
 '*'^V ■ in tbe principal bcfo?.ctl)c rcto:n of t^cfecono Scire facias, u hid) Inas taken 
 Dif^arpf. out againft the )15apl , thereupon to offchargc t!}e IBjpl : but anticntlp tt 
 toas not fo , but it leaj tften coantco too late to b jing h<ni in. 
 
 Hill and Harris 
 
 t 
 
 Micft, 24 Car, Banc. Reg» 
 
 Arrefl of li /i action of Debt teas biought againft Dibcrs Crccutojs. 2ohe Defen^ 
 
 judgin.-nt in /\Bantsplc D fullp aDmiiiiflreo, ano upon this an SfTue Icag jopneD, auD 
 
 ^- ,tt;on of g ^j,j.Qjjj fj,j,„o fojt^e plaintiff. 2Dhe iDcfenoants moten in arrcff of 
 
 ExccJioll 3u0ftcmEut, th'it there i5 contrarietp bcttD:crt the i(raciopncD,anDthe 
 
 ticruk founo : fo; th ' action is entire againft a\\ tije C-tccutoig , ano tbe^- 
 
 haa all pleaDcDfullpatiminittreQ, ano upon this tl)Ciirue teas topneo, ana 
 
 Vcrd:ft. jj^, ^crDla finns that fomc of the Gretutojs h^o fuUp aominiftrcD. ano that 
 
 others of thcni haD ©ooDsin their hanOs, Inhereas ths? tiercict Ojoulo hauc 
 
 been thit thcp hao not fuUp aominiftrcO. The ludgeraent was flayed till the 
 
 Plaintiff fliould move. 
 
 Mich,
 
 Mch, 24Car. ijj 
 
 Mich. 24 Car Sane. Reg- 
 
 W|^ a tnlc of Couit to fl&eto caufc tofjp wftUutfon ftoulo not bs giant- JifilfutTon "" 
 * eo npon an ll£nD<ctmcnt of fo;c{ble cnttp, exception ■mas tabcn to t^ Cn-- upon an en- 
 BWmentjtftatftDtD not fap, t|jat tftc jiartpentrcD iljicite & tnanu forti, as t^ie diamcu oi 
 tDOins of tftc fi>tatpte ofrett , ano ft toas faf d, tftat jn a foutble enttp tfjetc ^''"''''« ""y- 
 on^ to be an enttp, e):pal(ion, anooetepnec. Roll ludice fato, tbat t^ete 
 oagljt to be manu forti intbeCnD(<tmcnt,iacto;Dfngtotbc&tatat0,to\|t5 ^"'*'^"^«"f' 
 mngnffl) tbfe WnD of CBnttp from an jofnar^ Crcfpafs bp enttfng (nto ano- 
 t^ers llano , tebfcb is not fo fefolent as a fojccable cnttp is fuppofeb to be. 
 Bat let 1* ^ee che Copy of the Eadid}ment» 
 
 Gibbs againft Dunn. 
 
 Micbt 24 Car, Banc. Reg» 
 
 Glbbs bjougbt an Sttion upon tbe Cafe agafntt Dunn, fej tbefe fcbetal Arrtrt of 
 iDojDs fpo^en of lifm bp tbe SPefenoants Mffe at feberal tfmes, viz. judgement rn 
 
 chouartathietforftealingmycornoutofmy Barn? anO at anotbct tfmc fO} '" aftionup- 
 Capfng thou art a thief, SClje plafntfff batb a fectDftf; SCbe SDefenoant mo- f" '"""f *^' 
 . ten f n arrcft of auogcment, tbat entire bammages toere gf ben foj botb tfjc ° ' " 
 tDOjOS; iDbcrcas t^e firft toojus tocre not adfonafile : fojtlJci'^emcDammages 
 being a jfemc Cobert conlD babe no Cojn of berotnn , fojlttoasbct""''^'- 
 ^sbantjs Coin , ano .fo tbcte conlo be no ffcaling' of bcr Cojn. JBnt ^"""<'™^"^ 
 tbe Court anftoereo, tbat In common Intenbment tbe Cojn Is fjcrs ano 
 ^er ?^usbanD6 Cojn, tbougb In legal conttrudlon It be not fo , ano tbe S>can« 
 balls great, altbougb It appear tbat tbe luojos Ujercfpofeenbpaiferac co« 
 tjert. Therefore let the Plaintiff take bis ludgement, exwpt caufe be Ihcwn to 
 the contrary. ludgemeat was given the lame Term, becaufe the laft words 
 were held CO be accumulative. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. ©anc. Reg. 
 
 •y^e Clarfe of tbe dtrrojs In tbe Common.pleas attenbcb bere npon a rule a ciirk 
 ^ of tbis Conrt,^bcreupon one of tbe Clarbs of tbe Court gabe notice of °f '^e 
 If to tbe Court, anopjapeobemlgbtbebcatD. But the Court anfwered ^ourtough: ..• 
 that Councel ought to more ir,and not he, * [°J ^°^"^ "J • ■= 
 
 T'he King againft Do(9:or Triggj 
 
 I'^^e Court teas mobeo foj Dottoj Trigg to effreafe tbe i?me Into tbe (Bx* 
 
 cbcquec toblcb teas fet upon bim bp tbe-Coutt upon bis conbldlon upon ^:^' 'i'' 
 an Information p^eferreo againft bim upon tbe Statute fojpjartlllng ipbp- 1 pTnt '"* ^* 
 Och In London, \i)ltbout a licence from tbe College of IpbpCclans. Hales of 
 Councel toltb tbe College of pbrSclans mobcs it map not be ettteaten, fo j 
 It Is not neccffarp , ano bcre tbe Suogemcnt Is not onlp fo; tbe iitng : but 
 It (0 lara pro rege.quam pro, &c. anb fo part of tbe 'iflne Dotb belong to tbe n- 
 
 3PUb. Eftreai
 
 i5l 
 
 Eftrear. 
 
 Mich- 24 Car. 
 
 Arrcft of 
 judgment in 
 Trover and 
 ConYC:(ior. 
 
 Dcc!3ration. 
 
 Exceptions to 
 ail a>v;ird. 
 
 ludpfmcnr. 
 Subinifiion, 
 
 &utj|ciJ, attt)fojtl)atpartt!je|iJ5oretutoj map l)at)C apjfljp fecal Jjcteto 
 
 •trtotcr U : kittf ftbctttrcatcDtntotljcetcbcquetbetamiot tljcrc bate it, 
 
 ano fo tc flialUofcbiisrcu'ari}, anotljcrcfojcljc DeGrcDtbei^fDcmtgWbe 
 
 tcfpfteO. Bu: [he Court anfwered, we cannot rcfpite the Kings part, nor the 
 
 other part: for there is an execution out for the whole Fine which cannot be 
 ftayd, 
 
 Heyford againft Hobfon. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car, Banc, Reg* 
 
 HEyford bjoua^t an flttfonof SCrotJcranD ConljetConagafnffHobfon 
 in tl)c Comtifon.pleas fo> takfng ahiap ano contjcrting of o(t)cr3 of b(4 
 ©OOB0 ant) Chattels partlctUarlp nauiCD, ano Ijao a tjcrojrt. SCfje 2DEfe»i- 
 uant motieD in arreft of 3t"D2cmcnt, tljat tbc SDcclaratfon toas nicertafn,fo?. 
 amoncft ottjct things tbe plaintiff in W0 E^ctlaratton Declares foj tf)e ta- 
 iling dc duobus caftoribus, Anglice l5at6,lDl)erca8 caftor is not a p?.opcr taiojb 
 foj a l^at. alp. de uno fervitio argentco, Anglice one filber S)alt, anO 
 t!;cre is nofncb tDCt;t» foja&alt, but tljcte is another pjopcr liattn teojD 
 foj it, viz. falinarium, 3IP, De duobus catenis, Anglice tiDD filter SDiOjWf, 
 tofticl) fs no U.OJD foj a Difl) , mticb lefs a filter Diflj Roll luftice faio, one 
 map DEfcribe a tl}ing in a Declaration, iftljcrebenotapjopertoojDtocic* 
 p;ers it, ant if it be foterccibetttiatttieBiurp map bnolo totalis meant bp 
 it , it is tocll cnougl). But let the Judgement be here be ftayed , for we will 
 advife. 
 
 Wood againft Clemence. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 T^is Cafe fojmerlp ( viz. t^s Cetm) motet ant fpohen to toncWng tfte 
 talitttp of an Stt;atD mate tontbtngtbefraigfttofa&bip, teas again 
 moteD, ano CtccptionstahcntotbE^tuarD. K 2Ei)at t^e atoaro fs repugn 
 nant in it ff If. 0nO2lp. 3t is not final, ant fo not gooD, Stbc Court an^ 
 ftecret , if tbc ^toart be ill, as of pour oirn fljctoing it is,tben pon bate no 
 canfc of0£tton, ant fopou cannot bate gntgemcnt , altljcugb tbcDcfEn* 
 tants bar be not cfooD , ano a fiibmffsion maoc bp one foj blniftlf , ant a= 
 notber , is goot to bint tbe pattp tbat fnbmittet. But move it again, and we 
 will advile io the mean time, Antca, 
 
 Mich. a4 Car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 To qti:(li an 
 cndiftii'cnt of 
 (orcible ci- 
 try. 
 
 EiKl.'ctxent. 
 
 Rcfttution. 
 
 T^e dourt Uas motet to qualb an Gncfctmcnt of fojdble (Entrp after 
 tbe partp encfiteo bno plcaoct, ant a Vcrltct agafiitt bim. Roll luftfcc, 
 tXffc mutt not be fo curious in tbe framing of Gncfctments, astoquafli 
 tljem foj cterp fmall fault, ant in tb<s €afe it luas faio bpWm, tbat 
 if one interrupt a long pcfrcfsiontpfojce, art tbe other regain it tcitb on* 
 tue means, an Cntidment lies not aoairft btm fo? tbis, foj tbis is but vim 
 vi repellcre.ant after a tetcict, ant bcfoje 3;uDgemcnt tpon an Cntittmcnt 
 of forcible entrp, tbe partp oiigbt not to mote foj rjCltutfon,,
 
 Mich. ?4 Car. iJ7 
 
 Banilkr.againft Wright. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 Ji^ a SCtpal at tftc iSar bcttrceuBmiReranD Wright fti an jactfon upon [apj cgg 
 ttjz Statute of 2 Ed. 6. fo? not fetttng fo;tft of SCftbcs, 3;t teas fafD bp tijc from \ubL 
 Court tftat SDttfjcs toljfcl) Ipc not tnftljfn anp ^arfft ate Due to tbe iaifncr, 
 anD tibat BLancs muft be parcel of a pardtj, cttfjer bv pjcfcrfptfon, 0; bp sftt 
 of J0arUamcnt, auD tbat lianoalpmslDftbfn aiFo;cft , ano fntbeljanos 
 of tbe liifng Do not pap 2:<t!)e0, altbougfj tbcp be tottb^n a jaarftlj : but ff tbe Tichcs 
 JLanDs be Qlf afo:cfleD, ano be liiftbin aparfft),tbcpou2bttopap2rftftJ0, 
 fo; tbe<c not papitig SCitbeg bcfng <n tbc banos of tbc Jafng, fa but an tmmu* 
 nttp foj tbat t(mc onlp, 
 
 Mich, 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 zi Baker toaa pjcfentco in a Court liecf foj fclKng JBjeati nnocr tocffibt 
 ■*^tmXi a iF<nc tct aponbfm, ann an action b?on8bt agafnftbfm foj tbte'^l^^ "^ 
 5Ftnc, antj afecrcfrt grtcn agafntt blm. St toaBmot3clJfnarrcaof3!at)SE»inaftbn"f '" 
 mcnt, tbat tbc pjcfcntment upon Uib(f^ tbc jetton icaofounDCDtoaa not » FmcTtaTa 
 gooD.sno fo tbere toaa no grounu of 0(tfon,anD fo tbcrc oiigbt to be no 3;ung= ^<^"" leet. 
 inent. 315ut Roll i office anffcDetcD,tbattbe jetton fa ioi tbe i!mcrcement ^'""^' 
 tobfcb fa a collateral tbtng, anotbepjefentmenttanotnototo be calico fn p""f'""'""' 
 tjucftfon , a ft be onlp atjofoable foj fome fault fn ft : but ft toere otbcrtoffe, ""'""'"'^ 
 tf tbc pjefentiucnt lucre ntteVlp bofo* But (peak again to ic at another 
 
 Mich. 2 4 Car. Sar»c. Reg, 
 
 I^^e Court luaa mobcu foj a Habeas Corpus foj one commfftcD at Nor^ 
 witcb fo; JCtcafon fn fpcaUfng toojoa agafnatbe©uecn, bccaufe Ijc ^"'' * "'''"' 
 coulD not be trpco tbcre. Roll Imtice a^nDere^ be cannot be ennfcteo bcre, mllc\ pJrf 
 crcept tbe faa lucre cone fnMiddlefex, tbcrcfojc aotffe tottb tbe tefnga "" ccmmic/ 
 Counccl, ano p jcfct a 51Bfll of Cnofctment tobcre tbc fact toaa, anD tbcn poo ""^ '°f 
 fliall ba<3C a tisarft ad deliberandum DfrcctcD to tbc place tobcre tbc fact toaa, J'?-5"* 
 anD tbf3 fs at tbcKfnga futc.anD tbe febcnf Ojall be allotocD bis cbargea upon xryii """*' 
 
 iia atcompt, J clfe tbc 3!uftfcco map trp bf m bp tbef r Commffafon of oyor 
 anD terminer^ 
 
 Smkh and Hancock , and others. 
 
 Mich, 14 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 
 SMith bjoughtanfldfonofSCrcfpafa agafnft Hancock anD otbera.fo5ta.F„„ new 
 fefngaujapDftcraparcclaoflRfbbfnfrombfm aCbc fftefcnDants pleao^cryai, bcc.ufe 
 80 bp toap of 3uttfficatton,tbe Cuttomof London agafnft i^aiuhcra, viz.of » miftryai. 
 to taKc atoap Iwrcs from anp tbat folo tbem up anD ootun tlje Streets.
 
 J38 Mich, 24 Car. 
 
 jnijC piafritlfF rcpU'CoTtfjat t^crc toas no fuel) ctiffonT7anD'tiruc teas tafeln 
 upon ft 1 tbctciipon tbc cuttom toas ccrtJfpco bp tbc moutb of tbe Uccojoct, 
 $ a trpal upon it in Londonj a tcroUt fo? tbc SDcfcnDants.Eftcplaintfff moi 
 ucDinarrcftofJuDscmcnt.ttjattttoasamfftrpal, bccaufcU toaa b;fo;c 
 t!)cmtl)atiL'erc«ntcrc(TcD <n tljccaufc, anotberefojcoefircD tbcrc mfgbt 
 be anotljct trpal. Roll Iufticefa<D,<t fa agafnft natural ctjultp, to; one to 
 T 1 be 3uDgc in hfsJ oltin caufc, alt^ougbtbe ottjcr partpaomft it to be fo, aiiD 
 
 '''" ■ tbcrcfojc it io a mittrpall, tljougl) it totre at tijc rcquctt of ttjc plaintiff, be- 
 
 taufc it iijagaintt natural rcafon, 8 E. j.f. 69. s Ed. j.s.pH. y.f. 21.H1I. 
 3 8 Eliz. in the Exchequtr. %\\c pjapcr of tl)c plaintiff cannot Ijclp tbc trp« 
 al, foj tl)C content of tjoti) partpcs cannot cljange t!)c Slato , mucl) Icffc ttjc 
 pjapcr of one of tl)C partpcs. Hales of Counccl liitij ti)c Dcfcnoants argucD 
 t^at it toas not a m<f^trpal!,ant> faio tWs cor ccrns tbon in point of pjftiilcgc 
 cf tfteCftp.ano not mccrlp in point of intcrctt.bcfojc toljom tbc Juogmcnt 
 toas giticn. jlp' 2Cl)c confcnt of tljc partp iiatb barren Ijim of tijc aotian' 
 tage tobicb ot^crtoifc be migbt Ijabc ban. JBut Roil luftice anftocrcD, bcrc 
 i3 point ofintcrcft as toell as point ofpjit!ilcsr,foj part of tbe gooos tatjcii 
 come to tbc benefit of tbc Clip, anntbcrefojetbcp ought not to be tbcic 
 o\rn BluogcB, fo j tbis is againft natural rcafon , ano Co it is a miftrpal. Il5ut 
 tt Dotb not appear bcre^.ubctbcrtbcjpaiojanuaiocrmen be another Coj= 
 pojation oj not , ano Diflinct from the Co;po;ation allcgco, tobicb ccrti- 
 fieDtijiacuaombptbc mouth of tbcUccoioer, ano tbis is tbe folc Doubt 
 tntbcCafCi The Court ordered that there fhouldbe a nev tryal except 
 caufe (hewn to the contrary : Q. whether there (hall bca Repleader, era 
 new venire* 
 
 VV'hice and his wife againft Hacwocci and his wife. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 V/heiVicr a 
 
 writ abated T ^\ 7 Hite ant) l)is toifc bjougbt an flaion upon tbe Cafe fo; flanocrous 
 by death of \\ ujojDs, aijaiuft Harwood auD bis ^ifc; tbrSDefcnoant Dpcs, tbe 
 °"^j^^'j'"''^''jf cmctaUes another ^usbanopcnoing tbe futc. 3t toas moteotbat tbe 
 ftbatcment. tojit toas abatCO.The Court iridincd that becaule the Defendant had by her 
 
 mariage changed her name, therefore the Writ was abated, but :ook time to 
 
 advi(e» 
 
 Slade. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 
 toriuapc- npj^c Court tons motJCD foj 3(Wtigemcnt fojmerU' ttap:D upon a ccrtifi.' 
 
 mcntftaycd -*- tatcmaDebp515aron Arkin$,tiiattbcl3crDictpaircD againft bis opinion, 
 
 upon a i"''g,f^Bacon luftice faio , guDgemcnts bate been arrcfteotn tbe Common pleas, 
 
 ccuifccat. ^^^^^ j.^^jj certificates. Hales of Counccll toitb tbe EDcfenaant pjapeo.tbat 
 
 tbis 3!u5gemcnt might be arreftco, ano t'oattbcre might be anctotrpal, foi 
 
 that it bath been Done bcretofojc in like cafes. 315ut Roll lufti'ce bdo, it 
 
 ought not to be ftapeu, though ft bate been Done in the Common pleas , foi 
 
 """'* it loas too^lrbitrarp to; them to Do f t,anD pou map batie pour attafnt agafrft 
 
 thcSiurp, ano thi^tcfs no other rcmeop in ILato fo J pou ; but it toere gooo 
 
 toajtiifethcpartptofuffcranecDtrpal fo) better fatisfatfon. And lee the 
 
 Defendant take four dayes frora hence to fpeak in arreft of ludgeroent if the 
 
 poftea be brought in, if not, t-hen four dayes from the time it fliall be broughc 
 
 in» 
 
 Andrews
 
 Mich, 2 4 Car. 159 
 
 Andrews againfl: Baiiy. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 \7|Don atrial at tl)e55at facttoccn Andrews ano Baily, uponanejetf.Dcmfationb.- 
 mcntlearetoiicbtnsSirlobnProwds micto lanes. SlttoasCafB, tftat Letters pa- ' 
 a man cannot be a fubiect to ttoo fctrral pjfncca. fltio tftat Ccnifatton bp '"" f° ena- 
 lcttct0 patento no enable tbc partp to purcbafc iLanDp, but not to tn^ctit tijc ''[f ,'° '""'" 
 ILmna ot Wa ancetto j as i^cit at ILato ; J5ut aa a purcljafo? ^c map enjop LhT,;" unds. 
 
 lanD8 0fl)<a;anCCfto?. « Denization. 
 
 Inherharxc. 
 
 Dunch againft Smith and others. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 Hil, 23 Car, rot. 37. • 
 
 Dunch 6?ougbt an action of S)cfat as an Cyecuto j foj arreragcs of a rent omiurrer to 
 charge Due to tljc Ccttatoj, agafntt Smith ann otljers the occnppcrB of ' Dcdaraiior. 
 tl)C HanD, SEhe SDcfcnoantg Demur to the SDcclaration , <ino foj caufe '" ^''"- . 
 iljctD that U Dotb not fet fo jth tohat ettatc the SDcfennants babe in the lanos 
 chargcD toith the rent , anofoU appears not that thep are to pap the rent. 
 Hales ofCouncelltotth the Pafntfffanr'ojcrcD, that it is not neccffarp foj 
 the plaintiff to fet it fcjth, foj be is a firanger to the Cttate, i cannot bnoto 
 lohat Cftatc it is. Roll luftice faiD, gt 00th not appear bp the SDcclaratioti 
 libcther the SDefenoants claim unficr him that grantcD the rent oj no. Buc 
 move it again Saturday nexc. Portea, 
 
 Smith againft Hale. 
 
 Mich, 24 C-r. r anc. Reg. 
 
 SMith bjotjght an Action of SDibt agaiiift Hale foi relit ; SThc Defcnbant o^nurrer to 
 pleaDeDthathetsSCenantanb&erbanttothc iLojD Moone a JLojd of''^7''R'°' 
 the |9atliament , ano p japes his ^rit of pjibilegemapbcallotoen. sche "'"'"'" 
 plaintiff Demurs, 3t teas argucD bp Barton of the miODlc Ermple, that the 
 plea toas ill, foj the berp matter of it fo j the pjibilcge is againft the Com- 
 mon 3LaU', anD alfo againtt the §>tatnte 3LatD,ann foj pjoof citcD i E.r.f.26. 
 2 E. 3. f. 3. 2 Ed. 6. C. 8. Roll luBice anftocreo, pou ought not to argtie gc» ^'^'■'"'''2''* 
 nerallp againft the pjitilcge of ^parliament , fo; pou Unointljat ctcrp 
 Conrt hath its p jibilegc, as this Court alfo hath , thcrcfo je applp pour felf 
 particularlp tothisqueQion, tohethcr a Mrit of paitilcgc belongs to a Admitcara 
 l^arliamentmanrofarasto^pjoterthisiLanDsanD Cftate, ano 3 conccfbc 
 he is fo pjibilcogeD; ano pott babe aomitteo hfs pjflJilcgc bp ponr otpn 
 SDcmarrer. ButwewiUadvife, 
 
 Wright.' 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 plaintiff afcff 
 
 Aiji action ofSDebt toas bjought upon an Obligation to pcrfojm arti. »/^'^<^^^ '"°^ 
 cles ; Sf)e ?D«fenDant plcaoeo Cobcnants pcrfo;mco -. 2:he iplaintiff ,7cw u7ai 
 
 2: J ftao -
 
 ,^0 Mk\\.2/[C2it' 
 
 Ijao a tetDJct, ano after ijctDfa, anu befo?e 3tuDgcment',f)c ntotocD fojTncto 
 trpal . bccaufc ft appcarcD ttiat tl)crc teas no (ffiic jopncD; tljc |Dlafntfff mo* 
 tcDit fo?bti5 0lDncjpctttton,fojl)cfcarcD(fbc fljoulD enter ^tnacmcnt, 
 tljat tl)C SDcfenDant tooulo f)?tng a Mrft of Crro?. Cbe Court anftocrcD, 
 tliattbcrctDaoaperfcrtiffuciopncD; bat tftc plcaDfng f o not gooo, anu <t 
 toao pour oVd" fault to jopn tffuc upon futb a plcaofng, toljcn ['ou infgbt bate 
 CcmurtCD. YedetcheDefendancniewcaufe why be Ihould not content to 
 ^'*'"* a new tryal, and a Repleader* 
 
 Micl^ 24 Car. Banc . Reg, 
 
 T"" ^^'t** TkyTFinorandum on Wednesday the i4offcJovembcr 1648 Henry Roll Ser. 
 Koli fi "fl'w k *-»^ i*'"t 3^ ''^* ^^*" **"^ of the lufiiccs of this Bench took'his place ih 
 hh place. Court as Lord chief luftice o*^ Eng!and,and Twifden moved for a day to plead 
 
 betweev Dunch andSmith being the firft motion that was raade in Court after 
 
 he cook his place. 
 
 Popham againft Hunt. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc, Reg; 
 Mich, asCar* rot, 558. 
 
 bcnuirer to l^Opfiam bjHtgs Htt StttOH of Cotcnant upon an 31nDenf tire agafntt Hunr,> 
 
 a DccUrot.onl tbc SDcfcnDant tcmurs to tbc JDctlaratfon s anotbe pafntlff jopne fni 
 
 in an aa.on of tjjc 2Demurrcr:t!ilpon tfte plcaolng tbc Cafe appcarco to be tbl0,a iFcmc folc 
 
 Covenant. ccUtjcro a ccrtafn futft ofmonghitotbebanosof I. S. anu tbe E^efcnoant 
 
 tbcrcnponCotcnantotoUbtbciFrmctopapunto A.B. 100 I. a peer, fo 
 
 long ao the monp (boulDtontfnuem the ^anuss of I. S. anbejFrme tahcs 
 
 JlBa'ron; 2Lbc bunfijeo pounD per annum fs arrere, SCbc IBavon nrahcs t)(a 
 
 Cicrcuto?, ano tpcs, ano after bffl Dcatb tl)c 100 1. a peer fa bcbtna alfo. 
 
 Covenant Popham the Crctuton, bjfnnc thfs 0ctfon of Co\:cnant,an3 tbc qucKfon toas 
 
 to^ctbcrtbeafliontoasttcllbjoufiht, anu the Court bclD the jetton m 
 
 l|'C,fojtbECotenantDotl) concern tbECBrecutojjbccaafc be rcpicfcntatbe 
 
 ffi:taatoi; btittbcqueftton bcrefalnbctl^erthcrent Due after the Dcatbof 
 
 tbc ^^usb^^nl5 ought to be pafD,BnD boiD U Cball be bnoton tobctber i)Z beoeao 
 
 fo? it (a not fpecfallp allegcD , ant) ff fje be not ocao tbcre (a no canfc of 
 
 Sctfon. Therefore confider of this. 
 
 Bragg againfl Nighcingall; 
 
 Mich, 24 Car, Bane, Reg. 
 
 Trio. 24 Car. rot .601. 
 
 Dfmuire-to T) Rapg bjougW 8" 3ct{on Of Cotienanf agafiitt Nifihtingallupon an 3In. 
 B Dtc'a'^ation Jjoenfire. SCbe SDcfenuant uemura to tl)eH>eclaratfon, HLbe Cafe toaa 
 in an sfticn ^^^^ ^Tije patnttff let bp ^nDcnturc certain boufea fo j DJbera peara to tbe 
 ''''"'"''■ ■'^efennant, anucotcnantcfilDithbtmtorepafrtbc boufea bp futb a Dap 
 E'pjeffctJ in the Snoenture. 2Cbe SDcfcnoant bp the fame Blnocnture cotje-- 
 n'aiitco tof tl) t^c ipiatntlff, tJjat from tljE tf mc tm tl)e jaiafnttff toaa to re- 
 pair
 
 Mich. 24 Car. 141 
 
 paft tbc botifee, unto tfte znn of tfjc SCcrm foj toftfcb tftcp XtcTTmnHenM ~ ^ 
 tooulo luell 1 fufficlcntlp repair, anD leat^e tftem fo repatrcD at tljc cnoof tftc 
 SCcrnt; fo?. not perfo;nhtng oft^fsCotennntjOntbcSDcfCiiiDantspartttje 
 §piaintflf bjoag^t bfs 3ctton.2C{)c caufc fljcmco fo: t\) e Demurrer totfteSDc- 
 claratfonUja0,tftat t!)c |)lafntiff Ijao not fljcfcueotbat be on bts part bau repaf 
 MD tbe Ijoufes accojDing to bis <jrotJcnant,ano fo tbcSDefcnoant fuppofco be 
 toao not bomiD to repair,becaufc b^ tDaO to repair from tbc time tbcplaintiff 
 l)aDtepatrcotbcm,anDnotbcfo;c, anb fo tbcre ia no caufc of 0aion. af- 
 ter otters motions Roll tbfcf luftice faio , SEbat bcrc uas a retipjocal <£o= 
 tjenanttobcperfojmcDoncacbpart, anDaltboiigboneuo not perfo?mtbc q^ ., 
 Covenant on bis part, tbis ootb not ercufc tbc otber partp ; bat be is tpco "■^*' "' 
 to perfojm bis Covenant netertbeleffc, anb if be do not an jClttion Ipcsa- 
 gainftbim, anDbemapbjingbisaftion alfo anainft tbc otbcr tbat firtt 
 bjofee bis Covenant, ano tbcrefoje tbe 0ction Ipecbcre againft tfje JDefcn. 
 oant , anD fo tbc Demurrer is not gooD upon tbe caufe (betoeo. SSut if tbis 
 toerc not a reciprocal Covenant tbetatD tooulD be otbcrtoife, anD citco 
 Hayes and Hayes Cafe 1 1 Car, andSkippon and 1 uca$ his cafe i o Car. JBut 
 Bacon luftice belD tbe contrarp tbat tbe Demurrer inas gcoD, foi tbat it ap= 
 pears tbat it tnas tbc intent of faotb partpcs tbat tljc ipiainttff fljoulD firft 
 repair, anD after tbat tljc ^cfenoant (boulD beep tbe ftoufes in fcpair.The 
 Court would advil'e, 
 
 Smithibn againft V Vcllsi 
 Micb. 24 Car^ Baoc, Reg, 
 
 SMithfon bjongljt an Sttion upon tbe Cafe npon a pjomifc againft Wells, Ja'Tn a!.7a 
 anD Declareo upon a pjomife maDe to fatje tbe paintiflf barmlelTe from ion upon the * 
 fucb an obligation tulbenljcflioulD be tberennto cequireri? jEDbe ©etcnoantcafcupona 
 plcaoeo non Aflumpfit, ano upon tbis a fpccial ternict iuas fouro, viz. gcne-P'^°""^«- 
 rallp tbat tbc 2?efenDant Dio make pjomife to fabc tbe piaiiitiff barmleflc 
 from tbe £)bligation,f tbat be bao not Done it,%\}t qneCion bercupon ti}as> 
 tobet^cr tbe tjerDict baD founo tbc fame pjomife ret fo;tb in tbe SDeclaration 
 bccanfc tbat teas to fabc barmlcffc upon requcft^ but tbc pjomifc in tbc '*''^^"-% 
 terDict mentions no ceqntft to be maDe, butfinos a p^omife generallp to 
 fatjc onet)armleffe» SCbe Court bclo tbat tbcpiai/itiff ougbtto bate 3iuDg« 
 ment, foj tbat it teas tbc fame pjomifc founD tn tbc tcroia , tsbtcb Utas fet 
 fo^tb in tbe SDeclaration, fo; if one p^omife to fate one barmlclTs from a 
 tbing, be tbat maoe tbe pjomife oug^t to do it at bis pcrill toitbouc rcq-t cflf, Rcq^tft, 
 anotbc requeft is not material altbougb tbe pjomifcfapuponrcqticC ; Ctvcnanc. 
 But if he be damnified if I do rccompcnce him upon requeft made, the 
 Covenant is nocbroken. 
 
 Emerfbn againft Ridley, 
 
 Mich. 24 Car, Banc, Reg, 
 Pafc. 24 Car, rot. 400, 
 
 Error upon a 
 ludgement in 
 
 Idley bjongbt an Action of S>ebf upon an £)l)lig^tion againft Emerfon; Debt upon an 
 SCbc Conojtion oftJjCiDbligationUjas, tl)attbc|DefcnDantft)oulDnotO'^''K««»o- 
 
 ^5 put 
 
 R
 
 i42 Mich. 2 4 Car. 
 
 I^nt bis Caftcl upon fuel) a Common bcfo?c atrial ano p?oof , foj tlic 
 Common fljoulo bclfoj the Commoners, auo affifgno a b;cacb. tftatftc 
 DID put on Us Cattd upon tl)c Common bcfoyctbiflCri'aUo; tl)C Commo- 
 ners; upon tl)f 6 an ^ffuc teas iopneu , ano a tjcrofct, anu a Bnngemcnt fo> 
 tlje jaiaintiff. SDt)c JDcfenoant b;(ngfla IMiit of Crroj, ano afsigns foj 
 Crroj, tftat tl]c bjeacf) of tbc ConDn<on afsjgnco Dotb not agree Ujitb tlje 
 ConDftfon of tf)e £)bUgat(on, ano fo tbc aaion bcfng bjougbt upon t^c £)b- 
 Ugatton, ano no bjeatli oftbcConDUfonbcfngrfgbtlpafsigneD, tl)ercap« 
 pears no tatifc of Sidion , ano f o tl}e 3;ui3gcmcnt (a erroneous. )i5nt U Voas 
 fato bj' tl;c Countcl tottl) t^e JDcfcntiar.t, tbat trj'al anu pjoof of a matter fn 
 i _ common fiucnomcnt {sail one, ano fotljcQifft rente aUegeDlBasonlpl3cr« 
 
 "■'"'^"" ■ bal ano not real, ano It (ball be taken to be abjeacftoftbeConDftfon, 
 ano fo tljcrc ia coon tanfe of action, ano tbc Suogcment ttjcreiipon glticn is 
 inell cnougb, Holhcad on Councel on tbc other fioc oenpco (t to be all one 
 in fcnfe, foj tljat a SCrpalmapbe, ano pet tbe ECitle mapnotnotp?obeD, 
 ano tbere map be a Jtiogemcnt upon a Nihil dicit, lubcrc ts noting pjotjea , 
 ano fo toncUiDcD t!jc tuarit of €-rrojDfDlpc, The Court defircdco have 
 Books, Poftea, 
 
 Jones againft Jacob, 
 
 24"Car. BanuReg* 
 
 I Ones a Citijen artU jpciutcrcr of London.b joijgbt anactfon upon ttie Cafe 
 
 an'^faTn"'/" * "^aintt lacob foj tljefc Iriojos fpoUen ot bfm He is gone, and doth hide 
 
 c" t'hc Caff'' himlelf for debr, ani for ought I know he is a Banckrupt. 2Cl)e JDlatntlff batt 
 
 a tjeroict . ano upon tbc jDcfenocnts motion tbe 3iuogemcnt \uas former p 
 
 ttapcD. iCb; plaintiff moties fo: Sticgemcnt notlDltbttanofr.g: fo;tl;at 
 
 tbe tDO?Ds arc a^onafaic. Cbc Court falotbeitojtis are fcanoalous.anD 
 
 bp tbcm be isoffgraceoinbisJEraoe. HaUs of Councel toitb tbc SDcfen^ 
 
 Dant fafD, tbat tbcre tDcreotbcrloojooJrt tbeSDrclaration to'ifcb are not a« 
 
 Djmmage?. ^ j^nablc , ano pet oammages arc gltcn foj botb, tobicb ougbt not to be, anu 
 
 tbcrcfojc no Kuogcment conlD be gften. 2Ebe tDojosfaionottobcatti.: 
 
 * nablc lucre tbcfe, Havcacare, anddonottrutihim, for he will run away 
 
 and pay you nothing. Buc the Courc held, that faoch the words taken togee 
 
 iher are aftionable, and ruled the Plaintiff to have his Judgement for both 
 
 ihcwordsjif better matter be not flicwed. 
 
 Nelfon agaioft Tompfon, 
 
 Mich. 24 Car, Banc, Reg. 
 trin. 24Car, rot, 343. 
 
 Dcmm ,cr tn "Kl Etfonbjougbt an 0(t<on of SPcbt againft Tompfon upon an i©bl<gat<oti 
 rcoica-ion i\ luftb a CouDitfon to fdbe tbc plaintiff batmlefs. SDbe EDefenoant 
 plsaoco nondamnificatus. 2;be plaintiff replpeo ant) (betoco a bjcacb on 
 tbc HDcfenoanto part, tobcrcbp bcvDasoamnifico. 2ni)cSDcfenBantDcmur0 
 to t.;C replication, ano foj caufe fljciuo , tbat tbc bjcacb toag afcigneu to be 
 at Weftnnnfter, anO tiotb not OjclD in iobat Count? WeRmmfTeris. 2CbC 
 Court belD, tbat tbougb Weftmmfter bcaCitp, pet it ougbt tobctbelD« 
 eo in Uibat Countp itlpee, becaufe.itisnotaCountpofitfelf. Therefore 
 
 Dfcominu- advifc what you will do, tor the Aftion is tic to be difcontinued. 
 
 ill I)< b: upon 
 an Obli(:ati 
 on. < 
 
 I'] 
 
 ;ce' 
 
 an(c. 
 
 T|ivn
 
 L 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Uj 
 
 Thyn again ft Thyn. 
 
 Mith, 24 Car Banc. Reg» 
 
 Atch motcD again in tbts cafe, tftat tbc Summons Dotf) not appear upon 
 
 tl&c retojn to be iaell maoe : Soj it is not faio to be mace at tljc (£l)Httl)-- whether 
 
 Do?e, as the Statute Direrts. %o tl)f3 nothing toau aijfiocrcD. 15iit Bacon ^"'" "'°"^ 
 luftice fato , tl)c retojn tuas naugftt foj anorftct rcafoti. ano fo tljerc is no |^^'^ "'"' 
 5Reco;D bcfo je us to pjoccco upon ; in the ESrit of QErro: tlje fault is tbis, 
 
 SDljc Cuftos brevium oufil)t to maUc t^e retojn ftctr , an^ it is mentioneo to 
 be maDcperunumdeputatorumfuorum; toijereasfjioSDcputpbaO noaut^o« Rnorn. 
 ritp to DO it. SCfterefojc pou IjaD bed to ta[;eanctDMntoiCerciorari, 
 ano ccrtlfic tl)e fame matter bpit, anotljistljc Court map grant tijoua^ it 
 betjcrprarc: fojffonctoilla'CignanCiBrroj in a lfl«o;D ano p;ap a Cer- 
 tificate, ano nothing be Done upon it, toe cannot pjocceo. Cor.fider which way 
 you can help dtis faulci 
 
 Tracye againft Pcole 
 
 Mich. a4 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 TRacve bjougbt an action upon tbe Cafe againii Poole upon a pjomife , AimK cf 
 ano tcclares.tbat Poole tlje SDcfcnUant in conftDcration of a mariagc to u <??'wcnt in 
 be !)aD beticecn tbe |Dlaintitrs f on, anD tbc DcfenuantB oaugbtcr, i of fctUng *" *^,'°" "^ 
 fo mutli lano upon bim upon tbc mariagc , ^e oio affumc ano p^omifc tbat o„' , ptV"^' 
 Uiitbin fuel) a time after tfje mariagc ftau , \)e ano t)is S>on Ojoulo be bounD mife. 
 per fcriptum luura debita juris forma iiend.unto tl)C |01aintif,fOj tljC payment 
 fo; joool.foj a mariagc po;tloi?,tafsignstl)ebjcact)tl)attl)cDefenDantf bis 
 fon DiD not become bounn per fcnptum fuurr.Obligatoriumjfoj tbe papment of 
 tbc 3CC0 1, ant) fo J tbis be b;inge bis Action, 2Dbe plaintiff bat) a ncrDict.Cbc 
 SDcfer.Dant in arcft cfjoogmcnt molics tbat ttc b?cacb Inns not Uiell afsign= Btcacb. 
 CD : (oj tbc Afruirpfu tuas.tbat tbe SDefcnoant anc bis &on ftoulD be bouno 
 per fcriptirn fuum debita jurii forma fier.d. anD tl;c b^cacb iff, tbattbcj? 
 UiD not gitJC fccuritp per fcriptum fiiutn Obligatoriuni , tubtcb agrCCS 
 not tcitb tbe Aflumpfit : foj ' tbe SDcfcncant migtt gitjc fccuritp bp a 
 3!uDgement, tobicb is not fcriptum fuum; pet it is debita forma juris fa- 
 dum, upon tbis tbc BiuDgcmcnt teas foj tbat time ftapco, tbougb tbcii 
 Bacon luftice cnclincD , tbat tbe bjescb toag toell afsigncn , bccaufe in torn-- 
 won conftruction it (ball be intenoeo , tbattbcSDefcnoantafrumcDtogitc 
 bis oton ano bis fons bonn fo j fccuritp. Hales of jEounccI toitb tftc |Dlain- 
 tifE at anotbcr Dap moticDfo:3IuDgcmcnt, ajw bclD, tbat tbe bjcacb teas 
 tiieU afcigncD, fo; tbat it erpjcactb tbc fubftance of tbe pjomifc, tbcugb not 
 tbc tjcrp toojDG of it, anD tbis tuas bclD gooD, 7 Car. in Michill ano Cars cafe. 
 2tp. 3if tbe meaning of tbc pjomifc be confiDcrcD, it Uiili appear tljat tbc 2)c« 
 fenDant cno bts&ontocrcto be bounD bp iDbligation 6 Car. Ccurtny ano 
 Gavills Cafe, anD inDceo tbc pjomife cannot be fatisficDbpanpotbcrtoap 
 tban bp an£)bliaation, foj a^uDgmcnt j aStatutc toiU not do it;foj bp tbcm 
 be is not fato to be bounD;anD tf ougb aU tbis be aDmlttcD againft mc,pct it ia 
 noto after a berbict.anD tbc^urp liatjc founo tbe b?cacb Maynard foj tbf £>e« 
 fcnoant argncD,tbat tbc bjcacb teas not tocU afsigncD.fo; tbc bjcacbafsign-- 
 ED tcnDs to a perfonal engagement foj paping tbc 5000 1, ivbicb is r.ot fo £%-. 
 pjctfeD in tbc pjomife , but onlp a general fccuritp to be giten fo; tbe mos 
 nics, anD a rccognifance , ano a juDgcmcnt arc not pjopcrlp fcriptum, as ini 
 j> Car. Goidfmitb anD Sydners Cnfc>anD tlje jDcclaratfcn Dotb not fet fojtl)' 
 
 ttje
 
 14+ Mich- 24 Car. 
 
 t fie Dcatb of &(r Henry Poole bp it)!)om t5)E fcciirltp tnas to be gftjcn , ann fo 
 it tnnnct appear tobctbct be bao a tontciiicnttfmcto oottaflbcougljtto 
 Ijaiic, Pno hcbclD, that tljc tDlalnttff IcaobounDto Dotftcfirft art, viz. to 
 tcnDCT tbc DbUcntfon to He E)cfcnDant, oj clfc be fo not bounu to feal , ano 
 
 K:<)ucP. ccittet ain\ 5no nlfo be ougbt to mahc a particular rcqueft to him to feal ano 
 
 PI ajjrg. DclJtict ft. Halts TEpIpcDtf a mflnplcaDa&tatutc, {t(otriie,tbatbcouabtto 
 Tapper fcriptiim (uum, butplcacinaotigbttobcmojcnlte tbatrtommon par- 
 lance, sip, E:»e llWngof &fr Henry Poole iserpjcffcD, anotljcrc appears 
 time convenient bct\t)ccntbe pjomifc anu t^ctimeofbfoocntbfoi perfo^ 
 mir.gofit. 5!?. 3t ia not neccffarpfoiustotenocr a bono.buttbcotber 
 cucbt to bat)c Done it at blfl oton pctill , fo j it is to be Done at Ws cbarec ano 
 noiatours. Roll CliieflufticebJ^lD, tbat JuDscmcntotigbt to be giben fo; 
 tbc |i)lr.inttflp, anufaio, tbat fo^bc taping oltbcp:omifc ft is not ncccffarp 
 to piirfuc tbc berp Itjojds of tbc p;omifc,but tbc fiibttancc, fo tl;at tbere map 
 appear to tbc»£;oiirt,tb3tt!]crci:3caufe of 3£tfon. 2lp. ^z bdotbat tbcre 
 is no bariancc in tbc fubftancc : fo; tbc intent of tbc parties is to be confioc- 
 rco, Uibicb toasj, to bab: anotber art Bone bp S>fr Henry Poole ano tis &on, 
 per ahquod fcripium , ano not bp a bcrbal pioinifc, ano tnc arc to conCocr if 
 tbc bieacb arsigncD agree to tbis, ano be bclo, tbat tbc pjomffc iufll cjtenD 
 to a Juogcmcnt. 0; a rccognifance : fo; a ^ungcment, statute, 0; llecogs 
 nifance is fcriptum , ano fo; tbe time, tbc 2!>e!cnDant ongbt to babe alicgco, 
 
 Tcndc tbat be bao not conbcnient time, iftbctrutbU'crcfo : but bereootb appear 
 conbEnientt{me,anD it to not neceffarpfo; tbc plaintiff to tenoer tbc £)bli= 
 cation: but tbcDc'cnoantoiigbttoBoit at bf3 oujn perill , ano to pap tbc 
 monp fnconbenicnt time after tbcmariage,anfltl)c otberisnot bouno to De» 
 intc. dmcnt '"^"^ •'•> ""J ^ ^ ^^ ^^ t'jc cbargc to maUe tbe Dbligatfon. Bacon luftice to tbc 
 fame cffcct.anD faio.tbe U3o;t)6 otigbt to be intcnucD of a iDjiting oblfgato;p. 
 
 Time. nccojDingto common fntcnoment.ant) tbc meaning of tbc partfeojaltbougb it 
 
 be not ('o~crp;rffGD,anD it cannot be meant of a p;omtfc bp parol.fo; tbcrc are 
 no pjrQDentsin=ILaU)fo;bcrbalfctiirftic0, but oiilp fo; fecurttfes in Inji- 
 tiiifi:, ano Ibc ir^ojiJ in debita juris forma implies fo mucb, otbcrlDffc bcre 
 iDOulD be onlp oncpjomifc to maUcgoou anotber p;omtrc, Pafccj lac.roc. 
 3(5i.Binc.Re{5.& 21 lac.ipon a <ierft of Gcro; in tbc GtcbcquerAlbamber, 
 tbe former 3[nOffemcRt toas affirmco ano tbc bjcacb bcre afsigncQ meets 
 IsitbtbeAfTumpfir, fo? it is tbat be t)io not become bonno per, K- anDfotbc 
 b?eacb i3 Incll afslgneo. zip. l^erc appears in tbc SDctlaration to be ttoo 
 ^ontbsfojtbc pcrfojming tbcp'jomirf, irbicb in a conbcnient time, ano 
 tbcre Dotb not appear anp bfnbcrancc, anD tbc Dcfcnoant luas bomiD to do 
 it toitbout requctt, anD tbcrefsnoncccfsitpfo; tbc plaintiff to mafec an 
 election of tbc tfme toben be toill babe it Donc.TheCourc bid the Plaintiff take 
 his ludgeiDcnt , except betterraatter were ihewtd on Monday following. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc- Reg- 
 
 l.ld'^^mu.r '-rm Court wasmobcDtoquaai an GnDlctmciit of fojtfblc cntrp. JClje 
 -*^ CvccptioniMas, tbat tbc fo;ciblc cntrp is fain ia to be maee in mefTuj» 
 cium fivetenementum,\ibicbt6incertatn. 16ut Roll Chief luHtce DoubtCD, 
 tDbctlcr tbc circcptlon teas aooo 0; not, becaufcittaasmcfruigmm five te. 
 m mentum , anD tbc too;D MefTusge map be gooD tbougb Tencmen cum be 
 not, But it was quaihed upon another exception. 
 
 The
 
 Mich. 34 Car. 145 
 
 The King againft Wood- 
 Micb. 24Car» Banc. Reg. 
 
 nr^e Court tuasmotJCD to quad) an (Entfctmcnt t^en at a feEfsiona a=Toquj(haA 
 •^ gafnft one Wood fo J getting ti)c lioifeof anotbeWk^nfnto l)fa poffcfsf- £"diair.cnt. 
 on, bg ufins another mana name, nno a falfc toUcn. 2-^!)c Exceptions taken 
 agatnft it toetc, i . SCljc Cnaictinent ootlj not fap tftat it toas contra Stam- 
 tura ; J5ut to tWa tfec Court anflucrcD t^at ft toaa an offence at t\)z Comon 
 ILalD, ano tljc Cnoictmcnt lap at tl)C Common ILoto , anti tljercfojc ft mt^ 
 nottobccvpjellEDtobeeontra formara Statuti, 2lp. 5t Dotl) not ftcto 
 toftattbc falfc token teas, no J fn toftofe name it toas ufco. IBiit Roil cftief 
 ludice tool; anotfjcr rrccption.viz.tljat tl;e enufctmcnt inac tbat tl)C £Dcfcn« 
 oant DfD tbc fact nuper,anctl)atfi5fo general a irojDtljat no anficcr can be 
 gfticn to it And for that it was quafhed. 
 
 Twigg againQ Roberts^ 
 
 Mich, 14 Car. Banc Reg, 
 HiI,22Car,rot,95(5» 
 
 A 
 
 S^ actfon of SDebt tuas bjougfjt agafnff an Crccutoj in Driftow upon a v/rVc' l\Z'e.- 
 Cuftom of conceffic folverc bp f)im to pap a SDebt Dtic bp tl)e Ccllatoj mcnt in Debc 
 upon a (imple contract , ano a tjccofct anoa SuOfsmcnt fo> t^ic patntiff. ^e^''ft j^a 
 %t)c SDefenoant b jougftt atOTrit of CSrro; in tfjfs Court to reticrfc tlje BfaOg.^''.^'^"''"^' 
 ntent , ano tl)e C'rro; afsfgnco iuas, tljat tijc cuflom of b:fng(ng an Siction 
 cf BDcbt upon a concefllt fol vere is not a gooD cuftom, becaufe ft ftlnojcrc tl)c Cuftom. 
 parto to \Bagc bfs ^ILalD, as bp the 5LaVD l)c map 00. Walker of Counccl tofth '^'S" °^*'''' 
 tfteDefenQantfnthc ©attt ofGrrojarcueDitatftirasagooocnaom, be- 
 caufe tftcpartp fs not thcrebp bfnojeo of a trpal , ano there arc cuftomo fn 
 London ithfch are agatnft ihc Common Jlato , aafoj crantplc foj the Re- 
 cojDcv to ai'oc 31ucgemcnt upon an crigcnt. SEhc Court DcGren to fee the 
 booh, ano to hate pjefiocnra bjought them ; ano fafo , Sfafa Cuftom hao 
 been allotocoagafnft the partp thatmaoc tbc contract; but the Doubt in 
 inhethcr it be gooD agafnft an Cjecntoj, fo j a conceffit folverc fg Icithout a- 
 np confioeratfon. AndRollchieflufticefaid, that this cuflom doth break 
 three rules of the Law, 
 
 Barker againil Denham- 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc Reg, 
 Trin, 23 Car, rot. 1 280* 
 
 BArkcr bjonght an ejeftione firmae againft Denham, anD upon not anttf p ^f''^^"'*' "''- ' 
 pleaocD an fffne tnas jopne D, ano thereupon a fpccfal berofa toas'founQ f 'J j" '2 ^' 
 thatfapthcCuftomofthemaiiour,foherEofthc3LanDotnfjucftfontocrchelD,mr.' "' * < 
 aCoppbolDermightfarrenDcchfaCoppholDoutofConrttiTtothe hanoaof 
 ttoocuaomarpCcnanti^, to the ufe of another, ano atthcncvt Court the 
 partp to Itihofcufc the CoppholDtoas fo furrcnt)?eD ufco to be aomittcD, 
 anu Chat there toas fuch a furrcnucc mane here , but that the »artp to' 
 tohofe ufc the Coppfjolo toaa fo furrcnojeu opeo befo je tbe nert dJitirt, ana 
 
 a (0
 
 Dcfce 
 
 Ci;flf in. 
 
 146 A/ich. ^4Car 
 
 fo toaenotacmtttcD. actcquefliontraioteftft'ftcfftcDpfnsbcfojcUs aomlN 
 tancc, fljall be fato to be a CoppftolDct bi' tl)C Ciiftom of ttjc manour oj 
 no. Hales 0rgacD, tljat ftc is not a Coppboloct tettbfn t&c Ctiftom , ano 
 tljeniftliifiCnttom !)lnr)cr not,tl)e ILanDa fliall Dcfceno accojDing to tl)C 
 rulcsoftl)cCommcni,ato,fojfot3ltofaUCopp!)olD JLanus if a fpcdall 
 tiiftom Wnocr not , nnoljcrc i.t'ocuojocottljc Cuftom arc to be conCoc- 
 rcD,ant> jlp, 1)oUjtjM| arc to be C)fpouni)co,antjfortt)f0l)CC!t£D49E. g.f. 
 19. 2jE, 3- : H 4.'P»4. Cuftom fijall be confirncD atcojufng to t^e • 
 Common nppjcljenficn of tbc lay gens, ano a Ctiflom fl)aU be intcrpjctco 
 acfojDtngtothcmoftcfFcctualopcratfonoftI)C JLalr, 3 H'.y. 5. Doft. and 
 Scud. 48. 21H. y.f. 33.44 rfl". f. 10.4H8. Dyer 2S. 3 Dcnpal acnal bpn 
 
 Forfcitur . Copr'ool^ct to pap 1)10 tctit is 8 fo?fctttirr,not an fmplttatftjc ocnpal, lib. in^ 
 trat. "f. 23S'. 3nD bp a fnrrcnDct of a Coppf-jOlD bcfo je aumtttancc t!)c fuu 
 trnojr 5)at^ no real potTcfsjion , ano U}c l)cir of a Cop['l)olDcr bcfo jc Wa aos 
 infttanccboloobptljcCopj'ofbtfiiSiiccfto;, anQ fo tjc batl) title ; but t!)c 
 
 Title. nirrcnocrcc can batie no title bcfo?caomlttar.ce, ano tjccitctj Rawlins ano 
 
 lones his cafc, and Spurlms £afc. furrcnijcr bcfo?e aomittanrc, f» but a 
 a confcnt of tbe partp to part ioit!) tbccflate, but paffit!) it not, anD af- 
 ter atjtiiinlftration it ftoulD fjate no relation to tl)e furrcnDcr. Twifden fo j 
 
 Relation, tfte SDcfcnoant. i . ^z aijrccD tbat a Coppljolocr befojc aomitlancc is not 
 perfect in tic (Eftate ; but pet tljeanmittantcftjall relate to tbe fnrrcnocr, 
 anD botl) (ball be actounteo one entire 0ct, contrarp to otljcr learnings, 
 2I p, SEbc &on is tn bp Dcfccnt,anD tljc Dcfccnt muft be ruleo bp tbe cuftom, 
 anDljcisnotorcallpaCoppboloer , anfl citco Sheliyes cafe , anD pjapet^ 
 3i!tigcment fo j tljc SDcfcnoant. Roll ci>(cf lufticc faio , SCtjis Cafe Differs 
 fromfurrcni);ingfntotbcftanDgof3ncnant0,foMti0 into tbe banco of tbe 
 
 Siirrcm. ©tctoartj out of Court, \Bl;icb is gooD, ant) tbc HLojDs acceptance of t)is rent 
 
 Aum.irion. fg an aoniifaion. 55tit Bacon Doubteo , antj tbcrcfo jc tfte rule Inag foi tbe 
 Cafc to be argucD again t|)cnf);t2ncrm, ano tl)cn bp reafon of CcUncffc 3 
 tuasabfentf But cbat Term held not by reafon of the Kings death. 
 
 Dunch agiinft Smith, 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 A. reft of "pvunch bjotigljt an Action of 3Dcbt as C-jrccutoj foj arteragcs of a rent 
 
 UuifPtnicnc in X-^/ cf)5rgc ouc to tftc SCcftato} agninlf Dunch, an occuppcr of t!ic lanD, out 
 
 DciK bu iii^ht ot to^icb tbe rent leas iSuina, anu batt) a tcruict; 2Cbe SDcf enoant mobcD 
 
 b/an txc.u-jj^jj^^gjjjif^yPjjp^P^j^ ano fo; Caufe fticteco tb2t tbe paintiff ootb not 
 
 ''"'' fljcui anp title that ti)e EDefcnDant bath in tbe llano ; but onlp fapes genc« 
 
 rallp tbat be cntrco fnto the Pianos , ano fo it appears not ttat be is to pap 
 
 tbe rent. STo this tbe Councel on tl)c other. Cue anfUJcrco, tbat the fDlain- 
 
 tiff being but an (IBrecuto j cannot luiote the title, ano tljerefojc is not bouno 
 
 to (hciu a. Roll chief luftice faio, tljcre can be uo 3ii''gEnicnt,fo; tljc JDc 
 
 claration istoogencrall. But Bacon luftice held the Dularation good e- 
 
 nough, Antca. 
 
 Brown
 
 Mich. 24 Gar. 147 
 
 ©rown againftPoyns- 
 
 Mich, 34 Car. Banc, Reg. 
 
 Tj^e Cafe teas tljffl, a man maue u& laft ^<B,ani) maac ttco Cjccntoja, por a prohj- 
 t\)c CDicccutojs upe <n tfte Ufc of tljc SEeftatoj, tlje SEettatej upes ftatfng birwn to re- 
 ttjjo fitters, ti)c clDcft Sitter pjocurEBiiaomfnifftatfon, tlie pounger &f < p"' ^i. »'''";. 
 tt£t mot)e0 fo J a^joWbftlon to repeal tfte aoniftifttratfon, becaufe ttie be'ngi,";JJ^j'j^'j'?^;^ 
 fn equal Degree of bhm ongljt to bate cqaallfljarc of the aomtnfflratfon. Appeal. * 
 But the Court anfwered that a prohibition lies not, for you may appeal if the 
 Adminiftration be not rightly granted. 
 
 Mich' 54 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 r \ JDjoccffe IffueDont oftljfs Court foj a Cart anu ^ojfea tljat tocte To Hay pro- 
 
 io.iand 
 
 jLAtaufe of a mans Death, as a oeooano, 1 2. lac. anD ft'tuas mofteD that "^^J°^ * ^' 
 there hath been a generallparoon bp ^parUament (incethattfme,bplijhfch'" '" 
 oeoDanos Isere parDoneD , ano therefore ft toasp^apeD the p:oce(tc mfght 
 ie ftapeo. l^he Court asfecD tohether there be not an erccptfon of oeoDanos General par- 
 ojthc2ilmoncrBfntcreft(nthe parDon: SCheCouncell anfiBCteo there fs*^""* 
 not ; SChe Court DemanDeDbptehatU)o;Dsfn the parDon arc DcoDanDs par* 
 QoneD ; %%z Conncel anf liiereD bp the generall too ;ds. The Court orde- 
 red thereupon it (hoold be flayed till the Almoner be beard what he cao 
 fay. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 T l^c Court toas motea fo j a habeas Corpus foj one that teas fahcn in€x\ 
 ■^ ccntfon bp the &her(ff, anD toag aftertuarDs fet at Kbcttp, ano aftett^. 
 
 For a habeas 
 _ corpus for one 
 — ;_.-,.-. , -- -- _ — — -„ — j_ , „.._ taken upon 
 
 that tctahen ppon the fame Cicecutfon. The Court anfwered, take it, bat one Executi- 
 you are in the wrong way,for you ought to bring your audita querela. o"- 
 
 Audita quere- 
 
 The King againft Bray, 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 'T^eCoarttDasmohcDtoquafljanCSnDfctmcnt of forcible entri? maoe To quafh an 
 upon a JLeffee foj rears, upon the Statute of 21 lac, SChe ejceptfons ta» Endiamenc 
 ben to ft Ujcre, 1 ; 31t ooth not appear bp the ^nDfttmcnt that the 3Lelfee!^[°'"''''= 
 haD anp tftle to the BLano at the tfmc of the fonccommftteo, foj the fojtefe ^' 
 fuppofeDtobcDoncb^fojcthclcarccommenceD. alp. SEhc Icafe fa fup- 
 pofeDtobealeafefo^fomanppears, if J. s, (hall fo long if be, ano fti^ not 
 atcrrcD that f.S, teas alffecatthctfmeofthefojcfblc cntrj' maoe. RoU-^^rm'nf' '" 
 chfcflufticecfteD the JLaDpMorlycs cafe, that there ought to be a Dfrcct al« 
 legation of the Mfe. Therefore let it be quafhed. 
 
 M » . Tria,
 
 1^8 Mich. 2 4 Car, 
 
 Mich. 24. Car- Banc.Rcg- 
 
 Tofirart, an 'T^^c Cotjrt tPiTS motJCD to qtiaOj anCitufctmcnt of affaiilt ano 3l5attcrp 
 
 K>,dii'i.ucnc J of anoDcrfeeroftljcpot)? yillacde A.<ncFCcnt(ngofbf0oificc-. 2Dt)e tx- 
 
 lawitftlV'tm f cptio"3 1''^^'^" ^° ^^ ^'■'^'^^ '• ^fJ^t tl)crc <s no fuel) officer as an otcrfecr of 
 
 the puoi. "' tbc poo? villac, but ft oagljt to be parochiac ; but ttje Court fato tt iuao tocll c^ 
 
 tioueb, aofttoa0,tljouaI)ftbaDbeEnmojcpjopcrtbcotbcr teaj'. alp. SLijc 
 
 ©noiamcnt fs foj the iaffaulttng.anD bcatfng a Collector fo j tljc pooj fn cre» 
 
 c!it(ng bffl office, totjcrcao tl)crc (s no furl) office appofntco fo j anp one par* 
 
 tfcula't man bp tbe lato, foj tbc Statute is, tftat tbcrc fliall be tico Collect' 
 
 6:0 foj tljC poo; fn e'ocrp partll), anD fo tbe office fu jopnt, ano not fefecral; 
 
 iSut ti)c Court ofcer-rulcDtbtocrccpttonalfo; jlp. StUiants vice Armis. 
 
 Vpoir this excf prion tht Court bid theCouncelraoveit again. 
 
 Gill againft Crofie. 
 
 Mich, 24 Car. Banc.Reg, 
 
 ■^''ft -'"n'r T ^^ plaintiff biougljt an 3ctfon of JDcbt agatntt ttoo as anmfndlra- 
 
 aejinftEx'- ' to?3,uponfullpaDminmrcopleaDcD mic icas fopneo, ano a fpccfall 
 
 cu.ois. " bcrDttt \Bafl foiinu to tbf effect, viz. tbat one of tb: aemfnittratojc bao fullj? 
 
 aBmfnfttrcD , anD tbat tbc other aominlttrato? Ijao affeta. 3it toas urgco 
 
 Vcrdift agafntt tbe 'clcrDfct tbat tl)c fffuc tSjat toas founD fo fmpcrtfnent ano 
 
 ludgcmcm. fmpofstblc; anufotbcrc can be no juogcmcnt gfben upon ft. ISut tbc 
 
 Court anftotrec tbat tbe bcrDfct is gooD, pet ff Juogcmcnt fboulD be gfbcit 
 
 aponft, tbc 3|uDgcmcntU)onlDbcfll, anoNevills and Greenwoods cafe. 
 
 Hill, 7. Car. in the Exchequer, ror. 1 1 89. luaocftCD, anO ft toas fafD tbat 
 
 3luD'gemcntmapbeagafnfttbatCrecuto;U3bo batb aCTcts, ano nil capiat 
 
 per biilam agafnC tbc otbcr tbat batb fuUp aomfnfftrcD. But take ludgc- 
 
 mental your peril. 
 
 Prefton sgainft Holmes- 
 
 Mich, J4 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 Trin, or Mich. 24 Car. rot. 205 J, 
 
 T 7 Pon a fpccial bctoict founu tb2 Cafe fn effect <cas tbia, one fn fee ba= 
 m'on7rpcchi V bfng one &onbp one tenter, anoanotbcr S)onbpafeconDbenter,ii<fl 
 vlrjirtupon fapbfBlaaCiJItll Dctfreallbf3iLanDstobl3tof:cfojUfc, ano after bcroeatl) 
 ■ Will. tol. bfflclDett&on,anDtob(fll^cfr3, anD tbcqucftloninaslDbetbcrtbc S>on 
 fljan taUc tbefe 5LanDs bp tbc oebifc 0; as ^ctr at llalri , anD fo tbc ocbffe 
 tobcofnocffcatomahcbfmcomcto ttclLanoo bp ptircbafr, Cfiriftopher 
 Turner b^lD, tbat tbc Dt\jffe fs \)ofD,bccaufc ft fapes no mo;c tban tbs liaiD 
 faps, fo J f f tbcre baD been no fucb Dctf fe,Tohn i bl0 ^^efre (boulD babe bao tbc 
 3LanD, anDbctftCDPararaourand YardlyesCafein the Comentaries, and 
 ■ Hob.rep.4 Counden and Clarkscafe. 3I5uttt fsobtCCtCD,tbat fn tbis cafc 
 tbeilavi)rpeabsonctbfng,anDtbcDcbfrcanotbertbfng, anD fo tbc Dcbffc 
 fapg not tbc fame tljfng. %o tbIs 3 anfiocr, tljerc (s no Dfffcrcncc concer- 
 ning
 
 Mich. 24 Car. 149 
 
 nfngtljE aItctat(on of tlje Cftate, bctiscen tutiat ttie !Lan3 clrccta , ana tcfjat 
 tlje Dctjffe Dfrcct0, all tlie DlffcTcnce fs fn t^e manner t)cto fefs &>on John fljall 
 come to t!)e Cftate, 3 & 4 Phil. & Mir. Dyer, 154. & 37 El:z» a man 
 fsffcD f n fee bao (ffac ttco Daugbter0, ano ocvifco tlje BLantis to tftcm, ann 
 to tt)cit ^c{M, ano ft toasqucttioncDVDftctl^ert^eptDereSopnt.tcnantg, 
 ano i con«fl3e tftcp arc, ann luljcrc one omits a tWng fn a tontjepantc 
 toljfcl) tbcLato fuppUcg , tl)<s CbaU notljnrt, ano IjctttcDienninqsanD FoU 
 lards Cafe, <5Car. Hales on tinz otl)ec fioc argaeD, ti^nt tbe &o:i tal?cc bp 
 punbafe, ano "Ot bp oefccnt : fojtbeDetirrtsnottotbe Son in pjcfcnt, 
 but after t!)C Drat!) of tbe £:cftato?0 toifc,ano ff be fta?) ttie Unties bp oefccnt, 
 l)C fboti'.B ftntic tijem p?efcntlp. Sttstrnetbcfeonintcbt^a'octaattjcDtbeyv : 
 tafefng tp pntcliafc.anD mfgbt bate taUen bp oefccnt : btit bcrc prima facie be ""''"■ 
 fljan be tntcnoeo to be ir, bp purcbafe,anD not oefcent, fo: bcrc ootb not ac= 
 pear to be anp actual ioaftjer of tljc pKrcljafp, ana tbc §)on Dctl) bcrc as 
 31 f oncef be, tafee bp toap of remaf no cr, ano not bp kap of rctcrfton. Sna ■ 
 as to t^e tjctolct 3 conccfbc ft fs not gooD, foj ft Dotl) not f^cto bote tlje lanus 
 arc hclD, irbetbcr fn Cbftjalrp oj Socage, ano fo ft appears not tobetber ttje 
 SDeftato J bai> polucr to ucbifc all of tbcm o? not , foj if tl)£ p be tielD fn Cl)f= 
 l)alrp, be can Dcljffc but ttoo parts of tbcm.astljc Statute Dfrerts. 2lp. 3t 
 appears not, tbattbeSCcttatoj baofantonc&.onbpbfi3firttii{fc. sip. 3tf3 
 not ttieVDCD, tbat tbc iianes arc parcel oftbe^annoi. 4lp. St Dotbnot 
 appear in tobofc poffcfoton tl^c ILanosare. Roll chief luflicefafo.lLantis 
 tbat arc giten bp taafll (ball b: fntcnuco to be focagc tenure , f f tbc contra- intention 
 tp DO not appear, ano be bclo tbat tbeDct3ffcf6tofD,ar.D tbat ft f snot fntbe 
 jjotDCt of lohn tbc Son, to mnhc tbc clcctfon to taliC bp oefccnt j bp purcbafc 
 atb^splcafate, but^emuftofncccfaftptalJctbeiLanDas tije JLatocfrccts, 
 Itibfcb is bp DcftcntjanD ft fs agafntt a maifm fn ilaUj to gfbe a tbfngto fucb Ma im 
 a perfon to icbom tbc ilaU) gf bcs it, ff ft bao not been fo gfbcn, ? & 4 Phi). "' ' 
 & Ma. Dyer, 114. ano tbcrefojctbc iOlafntffougbt tob^bc Jnogcmcnt; 
 ^no as to tbc berofct be batb pjf mcc poITefcfon , anotbcrefojetftbcotbcr verdifti 
 inafee no title, tbc tjccoict is foj bim, ana gooo cnougb. Bacon laftice to tbc 
 fame intent, viz. tbat tbc !^cir ootb here take bp oefccnt, ano not bp purcbafc, 
 fo; tbis tbc Jlato faps, ano be cannot alter it, ano citco Fofcues Cafe, 4 Car^ 
 anb a Cafe fn 7 Iac» And fo judgement was given for the Plaintif, 
 
 Franck againft Burt and others, 
 
 Mich. 34 Car. Banc. Reg. ■ 
 
 T^c paintlfbjougbtan actfonofCrcfpafsfojbicakfng ofbf3!^oufc,Forco«sfor 
 ano cartpfng atoap bis Oooos, at tbc 2trpal tb: |3lafnttf Uias non fuce. ti'c D^-en. 
 SCbc ipiafntff mobeo, tbat tberctuas errojfntbeSDcclaratfon, anotbcrc. '^*^' "p°" 
 foje tbere coulo babe barn no Jtiogcmcnt, ano pjapg tbat be map be fpareo Z"?"? °r 
 coftB, Roll chief JufticeanfkBcrcD, tbat bcrctofoje ft batb bccnmaocaquc ' " """' 
 ftion,tobetbcr tbe pafntff befng non-fuce, Iboulo papcoCs,but fince tbc Sta-c.(i$. 
 tute of 4 lac. ft fs clear, be ought to pap cotts fo; tbe bcration of tbc Dcfcn- 
 Dant, ano fo it batb ban rulco bcrc, ano pou arc out of Court noin bp being 
 non=fute, anO tbcrcfojcponmuftpapcofts; And therefore except better 
 raatcer be (hewed, let them be paid. 
 
 US 3 Mich.
 
 ijo Mich. 24 Car- 
 
 Mich. 24 Car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 bHo!ur,he T ^^ ^""^^ trasmoijeo foj a JDjoWbltfon to t^c great &cf0fon0 of Car. 
 
 great sefsioi.s * nafvan <n Waie$ to ftopafate<nanEnglifli51BUlof CqnUp erftfWtco 
 
 at cirnaivai. tbctE , to^crcao bp Vfc 515111 <t appears tbcre <0 no matter of €quftp <n tlje 
 
 in waicj. ^f^fg^ but oiilp matter trpablc at t^c JLaiti. Stljc Court anfujcrcD, If tljcp 
 
 p^oceeD tberc a^afnK (Equttp, toe cannot Ijinocr ttiem. severe bias iDont to 
 
 be an agent Ijerc from t^c CommtfstoncrB tijcrc foj us to confer toltb fn 
 
 fucb cafes as tl)cfe, but <t fecms tljerc (s not anp bcrc note. Therefore give 
 
 Prohibition, notice, and let them fliew caufc the next rerni, why a Prohibition fhould not 
 
 be granted. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 H HI "\7Pon*rcatifn!5ofarctojnmar>cbptfte&bcrffsof tfteCUpofNomitch 
 
 asTorVsto V upon a Habeas corpus DfrccteD unto tbcmfoj one Chambers, StVoM 
 
 an ii.tcriout fafo bp tftc Court , tljat it "batb been rulcD, SCfjat upon a Habeas Corpoi 
 
 Ccm t ihouid to an fnfcrfour Court to remote Corpus cum canfa, tfeep ongbt to retojn all 
 
 be rccoi ricd. ^^^f, (gufcs tl)at arc ccpcnofng t^crc concerning tljc partp tfjat fjatft tbe Ha« 
 
 "''^"" beas Corput,(f anp of tbe caufcs ocpcncing be fo; abobc fite pouno of to^fc^ 
 
 tl)cp ougt)t not to bolD iuiea , ano tbertfo;e bccaufc all tl)c caufcs lucre not 
 
 rCtO?neB ^Cre upon tljC retojn of tWs Habeas Corpus, The Conrt held, the 
 
 rctorn was not good, and ordered that it (bould be amended upon pain often 
 
 pounds by Monday next* 
 
 Raph againft Davye, 
 Micb» 24 Car« Banc, Rrg. 
 Arreftof TJ Aph bjongbt an action of tl)c Cafe agafntt Davy fojfpeafefngtbefe 
 
 judocnicnt in XV fcOOjUs of Ijer tO t^B JDlalntlffl mother, viz. Your Daughter, innuendo tfte 
 
 •aiia'^ftionfur |piaf ntlf, is a brazcn faced Whore, and dcfervcs to be hanged, anOfo^fpeak- 
 
 ^''"'^- <ng tljcfcot^crtoojDstOtbcpaintffberfclf, viz. you Huswife are a Thief, 
 
 and have flollen my Porfe, %ftc |pia(ntlf bao a tJcrDltt; 2Lftc 2DcfenDant mo- 
 
 Afcrment. teD In arrcft Of Slungemcntjtbat tfte pialntlf Dotb not atoer, tbat ber ^otbet 
 
 ^ao not anp otbcr SDaugbter bcGocs Ijerfclf , ano fo ft fs uncertain, inbetbcc 
 
 tbe toojos tDcre fpobenofbcrojno. JlBut tlje Court belo, it teas toelle^ 
 
 nongl) toltbont f ucb aterment, becaufe tlje SDeclaratlon te, tW tbe HDcfen- 
 
 oant habens colloquium Of tbe |91afnt(f Dlo fpcah tbciDojOB, ano tljaf 
 
 mafees It certain cnougl^; And therefore bid the plaintiftake her ludge* 
 
 mentt 
 
 Jennings againft Lee^ 
 
 Micht 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 Arrtftof TEnninj^tbjongbt an action of 0ffaultanbJBatterpagatna Lee. CfteSDes 
 iiutpcoicnt in "' fcnoant pleaoa a fpctfal plea, ano iuClfics. 2Dl)e |)lafnt(f replies de inju* 
 s„ -ttionof riafuaDropria,anDupontl)fsan3ffucl3)opncD, ano atjerDlctfomio fojtfte 
 siuoit and |9iafntlf. SCbeSDefenDantmoteDlnarrcftof guDgementjtftat tbcrepllcs- 
 ''*-"^' tlon toas not gooo, betaufe .It anftocrp not t^c fpctlal matter pleaoeo, no j
 
 Mich.24Car, 151 
 
 tahcfi anp tratjcrfc bp an abfque rali caufa as ft otisW to Co, am fo tbcte ts no 
 iffacjopnet), ant) confcqiicntlp tljcrc can be no 31tii)semEtjt. RoUchicflu^ 
 ilice faid , t^at tt)C ttplpfng de injuria fua propria, auo ROt traticrfing abfquc Xravcrfe; 
 tali caufa (s not gmo, foj tl)crc fs not anfltfirmattbeanD ,ancgatft)c, antifo iiiuc 
 tfterc ffl no illtic jogncD, ann tbcrcfojc tbcre can be no fnogcment; ann it fa iccfaiis. " 
 a Dfrcrt Jeofnil.anD it fs not bclpeo bp tbc Clcrofct, fo j ft I3 no trpal, ano not 
 a mfftrpal loljfcl) a ticrufct map bclp. 3f t!)cre be tiuo oj tbjcc tftingc in a 
 SDcclaratfon upon U)l)iclj anftfuemafbciopnco, ifanffftic bcfopneoupon 
 anp ottb^mftfalDclU butticrc isnoflTttctopncoataU : foHbe rcplfcatfoit 
 ootb no mo je but affirm t1)e ibjons Done, as tijc Count Dio. Therefore 
 confider how you can ficlp it. Poflca. laS. %/a. 
 
 V 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Banc, Reg 
 
 Pon tl;e rcatifng ofaccto?nofati:5Irftof pjftjtlcttc crantea fo? one to !;''K?to°n of a 
 be tcftojci) to tbe plsce of an ;aH)crmcn of tbeSIolun of Stafford, Hales Writ of Pii- 
 tooU tIjEfe cjrceptfons totl]C tctojn, i, tbat one caufc fficu:M foj tbe Dff- v'^'^ge. 
 francbiftng tl)c pattpicas , tbatfteljaDtionccontrarpto bisoatf), toijff I) fJ2 Disfranchifc- 
 fnfo teas no fufficfcnt canfe foj tbc Dff-francljffing of tfjcpartp.fojtfteftmcnt. 
 ILettcro patents co not toarrant tt. fccono caufc tcturncD f s , fo j ttjat 
 6e Did not maUc an accompt of fucb monf es, as Ijc ban reccf tiCB fo j t^;e ufc of 
 tbc Citp, ano tl)is concerns not tbc partp as an ^loetman, ano tbcrcfojc bfs 
 ittffoemeanouc fn tfiat office can be no caufc to put tfm ftom bis 
 place of flloctman. 3!?. 3t fa rctojnen foj caufc t!)at bcnfn mff=bc. 
 taije bfmfelf fn bis place tobtlS bcU)as^afo?oftbeCftp,auotbfsa0tbc 
 fo;imct fa no caufc to put bf m from bfs ^locrmans place. fourtb caufc 
 rcturneo fa , fo j fpealif ng contc/nptuous toojos agafnft tbe ^afoj ano 31- 
 Dermcn, viz. Knock your heads together till F come, tnbicb ItJOjos cannot 
 Ic fo rontcmptnotis as to be put out of bfs place foj tbem , fo? tb?p are not Retorn. 
 fo mucbasaaionablc. ^Ip. l^eljelo, tbatffanpoftberccaufC0fingl)',o?aU 
 of tbem togetbct toere fufficfcnt to of f=ftancbifc bf m , pet tbep bate not 
 IbetoeQ tbat tbep bate latufullp remobco tjfm.fo? ft appears not tbat be tnas 
 fauunonen to anftDcranpoftlietbfngsobfcacoagafnftbfm, neftbcrootb 
 It appear, tbat be teas off frnncbffcD bp tbofc tbat ougbt to babe Done ft» 
 The rctorn was ordered to be filed, and time given to anlwer thefc exccpti» 
 ons till tbe next Terra, 
 
 Mich. 24 Cat. Banc. Reg. 
 
 VIDonan AffidavitrcaD.tbattbccaurelrasremobetJbftbctbptbcPlafu. For aPioce- 
 tff, SLbe SPcfcncnnt motjcs fo? a Procederdo, tbat tbc Cor.rt map p?a- J=nJ"- 
 ceeD tubcre tbc Ipfafntff firft b?ongbt bfs iJctton. 31Bnt tbc Court anf tocrca, 
 tbat tbe Plafntff map remote bfa caufc bitbctfap Certiorari, ano upon tbc 
 tcto?n of tbc Certiorari tbc SDcfenDant ougbt to tcnocrbapljanoiftbe 
 Plafntf f tof II not accept of ft a Procedendo map be granteo. 
 
 Wood
 
 ijB Mich- 24 Car. 
 
 Wood againft Clement- 
 Mich. 24 Car, Banc. Reg. 
 
 Arcuments of T ^^ <£afcof VVood SHO Clement fojmctlp fpoben unto, teas agafnmo- 
 coiincci, an,i ^ tJcD ntiu fpoUcn to , fiift bp Twisdcn, tofto argtJCD, t^at t^c iSUjarD fct 
 liic iii.ip.'cs"o. fo?tl)(i3tiof8fojtti)orcafonfli. i. ISccaufcUfg not final, fo>ftatoarD0One 
 I'inicnsfudi- topap mcnpto 1. S. to tbe ulc of anotljct , tottbout fjfij tonfcnt , nno 
 xv'^,''"'^ tl)<a cannot nctcrmfnc tb6 mhtttr fn conttottcrOc, but Dotb beget 
 fates, alp. 3lt <flaga(nft rcafon, tliat t!jc monp Due totljc J0arfnerg 
 HioulQ be papD to anp , but tbe jp-irfncrs t^cmfcltjES , ano'tJjfa te 
 not fubmfttcD, ant) ff ft lucre, petit is fU, fo? tbc iparfncrs incluoc not tl)e 
 (paffor. Maynard bclD, tbat tljE jainarD toao tiofp to tbfsclaufe, ano fo tbcic 
 is no bjeaclj a'sjfgncD, ano confequcntlp tljcre can be no Suoricmcnt gfticn, 
 altljousbfomc otftcr partof tfteillriarDbegcoD, anDficrc tsnottjIngalDarD. 
 £0 conccrnfnglohn Aclacd, tolbofsoncof tbc parties tbatfnbmUtcD to tt)c 
 ^airbftrattorv , ano fo as to the monp \]t batl) no fatJsfattion bp tl)c fltearo, 
 z Rich. 5 . F. 1 (5. Hill ntoticD , tljat tbc airbftratojs batic mane an a^loaro 
 toucbliig a tlifiicnotfubmfttcO: fo; tbeoiffacnccsfubmlttcDaretourbtng 
 t!)C feWp calico tljc Saivadore, ano tljcp Ijate maDc an auaro touching 
 tl)C &l)(p , ano tl]c pjocceo thereof. Hales on tlje otbcr Goc bi lo, tljat lohn 
 Adand fa notpartp to tbcfubmffsfonnomojctban tt)c£j&arfncr0 , anntftit 
 tbc otbcr pnrtfra bate fubjnfttt b bp btm. 2lp, \$t fafo tbcrc fa fcmctbrnga^ 
 u-arDCD fo; lohn Acklan^^, foj bc fo compjffeD toitbfn tlje (parfncrii , ano fo 
 l;c batb fatfafactjon, nno ft be be not fncltiticD, tbcn ft appears not ti]at t!;jrc 
 fa anp Difference toncbfng Win to be arbitrabo, anD bere fa a fopjit truC fo j 
 ail, anD one map taUc upon blm foj all , anD mal!c a Difcljarge fo j nil. Roll 
 chief luflicefaiD, tbe ^arfncrs , auo o'ancrsoftbc&bip arc allpartfeofo 
 t!)c fubmirsion; but the piafntff anoSDcfcnoant in tbfs action arc onlp bouno 
 to perform tbc SiirarD , foj tbep o;ilp cntrcD into bono to Do it. ^no tbe 
 Aw aiJ. Rafter of tbc febfp is tbc cbfcf S^arincr ,anD be cornea in in tbis notiouano fo 
 iijc iltoarD concerns f)i?ti, 7 H. 4. f. 14. 5!lnD if tbc partp bate poiierfap the 
 illrarD citber in Haui j Cqnftp to compcll tbc otb:r to perform it tbe 21- 
 limrD is gooD tbougl) tbc partp be put to bis ^Sction to get it pcrfoimcD. Bas 
 con luOice agrecD luftb R^ll, anD belD JuDgcmcnt ougbt to be ci'jeii foj tbe 
 ^!afiUff,foj tbat all tbc parties arc inclucco icit'oin tbe fubmi'fion.sUbongl; 
 but fomc of tbcm oulp arc bcunD topcrfojm tbc 3U)arD,n!.Dbcf."iotf)at 
 tbc £j,9aftcr oftbc febipis a ^arir.cr. lerman Juflicc faio, lie tiiou!oaD» 
 tffc, bccaufc ft Xvsa a great taufc , but be cncIincD that Juagcmcr.t toas to 
 ibc gfi'cn fo; tbc jpialirtif,becaufet!c fltnnra frcmcD upcntbepIeaDirrrctobe 
 gooD. Crown luftice teas Of tbc famcopiiitMi, auD fafo, tl)at tbc 5pnftcc 
 IMCB e ^arincr, anD tbat there is a truft betirccn all tbe parties. auD a goou 
 TcnicDp fo; tbcm all bp tbe fltoarD. Whereupon the role was, that the Plain* 
 tiffhould have Ju dgttncnt except better nrattcr were fluwn Monday nexr» 
 
 Mich. nCar. Banc. Reg, 
 
 i 
 
 A itft of nr ^^' piJ'intif b;OHgbt an Action upon tlic Cafe upon a pjomffc; %\)t 2Dc- 
 jii.'ptnKm io ■*■■ fciiDaiit picaDjo non AlTumpfir, ans thereupon an iGae iraa io>)nco, ano 
 an ;a:r.niH> a tJcrBict fouuD fo? tbc plaintif, 2Cbc SDcfencantmobcD in arrtfl of 3luDgt 
 on, he Caic J^f>^^t^ anD too(5 crccptiou to tbc fctting fo;t!) of tbc pjomifc, ubicb facia 
 lip.marr;;. ^^.^^ ^^^^^ tljc iEDcfcnDaiit upon a confiocration moving from tbc piaintif, 
 
 DID
 
 Afich, 24 Car. i^) 
 
 «ld affame anu p?om<fe unto tbc plaintii to pap a tzxMn turn of monp/ cni= 
 dam Fountain, ano Icatw out ^fsnamc of baptifm, ano fo (t 10 fnccrtafn 
 iD^o the monp fljoulo be pa(D unto ; oj Icfjctbct ft benovcpafo ox no, ano 
 confequcntlp tnftetftet there be an? caufc of 0ct(on , ano fo tbere can be no 
 31u0gemcnt. lut Roll ch€if luftice anfucreo, the AfTumpfit toas grounoeo Aflumpfir. 
 nponaconCoetatfonpaft, anDpcraDbenturctbe|3lafntff map not fenoln tbe 
 parties <rt);(afan'namc to lt)I]omtt)e monpistobcpaia, tWsb boti) t!]c - 
 J^lafntf f anD SDefcnDant Unoin tfte pcrfon of tljc man VneB cnoua^ There- 
 fore let the Plaintif have his ludgemenc. 
 
 , Frank againft Dixon. 
 Micb. 24 Car, Banc. Rf g. 
 
 FRank b?ou0M an 3(lfon of SCrefpafs agaliitt Dixon foj entrfng fnto '^'^*" °f 
 Wa ?^oa'e,Jino bjeafefng open ^{3 Cl)cff,anD taliins atoap »){s OOOD0. Cfjc !„ 7ft"o "'J^ 
 SDefcnDant pleaeeo a fpccfal piea, viz. tbat fjc ofD ft bp nap of a Bfftrcfs fo;i rtcip}7" " 
 rent one unto ftfm; SCbe ipiafntff rcplpCSde injuria fua propria ablquetali 
 cau& ; upon tbfa an Kffuc loas jopneo, ano a tJcrDfd founo fo; tf)e plafntif. 
 3;t toas motcDac amicus Curiae t6at no Suugemcntcoulo be Ijere gtbcn foj 
 Cottsfojtbe pafntff, becaufc tbc pafnHf^ao niaQcnotftlc tottjcOoooa.Cofls. 
 ano tl)crc Carc0tocrctUeD,44El!i.'Trin, 7lac. Frith ano Blackmans Cafe, 
 anD 5 Car. Davis ano Evans. 315ut Roll chief lufticc anfUjcrcD , tljat be toon- 
 tcrcD iDbp anp boop Ojoulo fo mobe , fo; ft fs agafnft tlje Knoton pjattice of 
 tl)c Court, ano fafotfjatbemuftpapCotts, othcrtotfc there fl)aU()C bcya^ 
 tion toitbout amenw. Therefore lee the Plaintif take hw judgement. 
 
 Tyfbn. 
 
 Mich, 54 Car. B«nc. Reg. 
 ■ i ■■ ■ 
 
 AOTrffofCBttojtoasbjougbttoreberreaguDgcmcnt gfbenfnaii3ctf.F''ror t^ re-' 
 on of Crefpafg, ano ejrccptfon tnas taken to tbe Wiiit of Crroa, fn ttjat '"'= .=■ J'"'^'- 
 U toaa not bjougbt bp tbe fame pcrfon agalntt Inborn tbe inDgcmcnt luas '"^'f'" '" ^"'" 
 gftcn: fo; tbe juDgemcnt toasgfbcn agafntt Evifon, ioftbtbcaooftlonof 
 Gentleman, anO tbe ©Srft of CStroj fa bjougljtbplvifon Yeoman. Roll Addition, 
 chief luftice anttDereo , that Evifon ano Ivifon founoeo but as ons ano tbe 
 fame name, ano foj tbe aBDittono of Yeoman ano Gentleman ft fs not matc« 
 tfaI,tbougb tbep offlfer bcrc- but if ft lucre tbe aooftton of Knigh% j Baroner, 
 there tbe DftfcrcncciDoulo be fometbfng, foj tbat fs maoe part of tbe name, 
 iiiit tbe aOOttions of Yeoraan o^Gentleman ate aoof tfon^ ad placitum* * 
 
 Clitfworth, 
 
 •' ^'^^ = Mith, 24 Car. Banc, Reg, 
 
 Ti^cpiafntlf Declares agafnft tVoo 2DcfenDant0,agaiiitt one of tbcm, foj Error torc- 
 an ^(Tault anD ©atterp, ano agafnft tbeotbcr, fo? taking aiDaptfS'f'''^ M"<f(i:«- 
 ©ooos, anD upon not gufltp plcaDCD the Iplafntff bao a bcroict , ano a tuDgc=|-"^"' '" 'i^" 
 nteiitagainlttbcmbotbtopntlpfojDammagcg, anD tbis toaoafotgncofojt'ry *" "' 
 Erro;^ to reberfc tbe SuDgemcnt. Roll chiefiufticefafo, tbe CSlrtt cannot 
 be b?lpcD, fo; tbe ttoo JDefenoants cannot be iopneo fn one action, bccaufc^'^yn '« »^' 
 tbe SLrcfpaffcs arc of fetjeral natures, ano agafnft fcbctal pcrfons, ano tbe""- 
 
 % parties
 
 154 Mich. 2 4 Or. 
 
 patties cawot pleao to tWflSDctlaratfon. Therefore the Plaintif nil capiat' 
 per biiiam. 
 
 Mich. 2 4 Car. Banc- Reg. 
 
 To quaiiian HTl^c Coiirt toas titobED to qnafli anojDerof&ergfonijmane,tbaf one 
 Older otscf- J- a)OHlD{{ccpl)fflrcpnt2DCtflD,bccanfel)ctaol5cptt)<inftcrctofo;c, anoU 
 '"'"'• totii not fl)ctoeftljcrtf)ntl)cf2!WsI5iiftarD,o?!)f3 lalofullp begotten CljilD. 
 
 The order was quaflKd, becaule not made according to the Statute, 
 
 Mich. 24 car- Banc- Reg. 
 
 Error tore- A tSltU Of (EfW tiia(jbjou8!)tto rcbctfc 8 fuogcmcnt gttjcn irt tljc Coutt 
 
 vcrie a )u jg- /\ at Exeter in an jactfon of SDcbt foj unt. 2Cftc cixois afflffinco Ujcrc, i . 
 
 meiuinD.br.ji^^at tl)C namcs Of tl)C 3!uro?s lucre not retojncD upon t&c panel. 2Cotf)l3 
 
 Reiorn. ^°" chief luftice anfujercD, ft <0 not ncceffarp to retojn tbc<c namca , tbougb 
 
 ft toas ttie olo toap to DO fo. a fecono cytcptf on Vom, tbat tbc Mrit of CEt« 
 
 ro J ffl not tucll tctojncD, foj <t is Dfrcaco to ttjc f^afo; ano IBafllfs of tl]|C Cf- 
 
 tp of Exeter, ano ft fa rctojncu bp t^c spafo j anD ttoo of tbc ii5apUf0, toficrc- 
 
 as ft ftoulDbebpallofttjem. Adjourned to the next Term, 
 
 Micb» 24 Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 ■^° 'i'-""' '" A 5tlctojnofanojwtof3laftfcc3ofpcacc,fojfeeq3frTga 315a(hTrB»Cf)fIir, 
 ces of Ike rcmobcD bitbet bp a Certiorari toas rcao , ano npon tfje reaofng tbe 
 p„„ Court teas motet) to qaafl) tljc ojocr npon tbcfc cyccptfona. i.31tDotbnot 
 appear, tbe ojuct toas maoc bp tUio Bluftfccs of the peace, tobetof one icaa of 
 tbc quorum, alp. 3It totl) not appear tbat tbc 3!«ftfcca bfo fnbabit near tbc 
 place. 3lp. iCbc ojoet ootb not ofrcct boto long tbc partp (ball feecptbe 
 CbllD . as tbc dtatate Dotb Direa ft (boulo. The order was quafhed upon 
 the la ft exception, nt.., • -;;:r;rr' •..!,■-.■ 
 
 The King againft Humphrycs, 
 
 Mich, 24 Car. Banc. Keg. 
 
 Toquafhan T"^ Contt toas mobento qoafljanojoct of ^effifoHS maocat D«tby foj 
 order ofSef- ^atcttts to relfebctbcfc poo J CbtlD?cn, SCbe crccptton tahentoaa 
 fionj . tbat the fetatntc apporfnts tbat tbc Juttcca fn tbc &cfef ons IbaU fct tbc rate 
 
 Drj'utaticn, tbat fg to be pafD fo J tbcfr maintenance , anb tbat the Jtifticcs bcre bate not 
 Done, but babe transferccD tbcfr autbojftp otcr to other gtiCiccs to toft, 
 tubfcb tbep cannot Do, ano fo tl)c ojDct maoc bp tbc other Siifffccs fa not 
 600D, SCbe Court fafo, tbfa fsall oneaaifan ^^rbftrato^ifboulDaibftcate 
 another to make tbc atbfttemcnt,tobfcbfflnoteooo. Therefore let the or- 
 der be quafhed. 
 
 Tlie
 
 Mich.i<J49- i^^ 
 
 The King againft Golding, 
 
 Mich. 24 Car- Banc. Reg. 
 
 qr^c E)efen>»ant fljetoeo foj wafe tofep reftUutton ftoala not be ateatu. „ 
 ^ ED asdntt ^(m upon an Cnotamentof fojclblc cntrp , %m be kill ap- S-;u,7on "* 
 peat annpleaatotbeentilctnicnt. RollchiefiufliceanriDcrcD, rhenycuupon an En. 
 niuft go to tryal the next Terra, and at your own charges. didmcnt ot 
 
 forcible entry, 
 
 Mich, 24. Car. Banc. Reg. 
 
 \7ieont3fetoo£tibc!PatUam0nt1lloUoftbc ^tatuteof 2 Ed. 6. foj pap- 
 ^ mcntoftftbcfl, ano compatfng tt trftb tbe SDeclaratfons in tbe caufea S'Xoueht 
 ijCttoan Bowes an^J Broadhead , anD Bqrrafton anO Herbert , ft tnao fonnO in Court tu 
 tbat tbe statute teas rjebtlprcdteo, nottoUbttanufng tobat bao ban ob|ei examine a 
 tteo, anDtbcTio'-itnallBooUoflpatUamcnt p?ocuccDtotbe contrarp; ano '^''^'*"''°" 
 tbcteapon3!acgemcnttoasgfljenfnbotb cafea, ano tbe doutt faio tbat'^^Rgji^,! 
 tbcptoetctobetulrobptbei^atliamcntlfloU, anD not tbe journal boofe.Parii«m'enc 
 And the fame day, in the Cafe between HBotopct and SCantnlpar , for the Roll, 
 fame reafon, the Court ordered th e Parlianent Roll to be brought in Court ^o""^"*' 
 the next term , to make it appear whether an adjonrnment of Parliament was ^°°^' 
 well reciccci , and would not credit the lournal boo k. 
 
 Mich. 24 Car. Bana Reg, 
 
 PHillips motjeD t^e Court to qnalb an Cnbfttmcnt , foj an affanlt anD ^^ . 
 JlBattcrp mane upon IBaron anD iFcmc, anD foj pullfng Dclcn of tljcnrdlttaient' 
 Ijoufe of t^c JBaron, ano be took tbcfe tjcccpttonst. 1. 2Ebat tbc CD-notament t i aiBuu 
 DtO COntluDC ad damnum ipforum , tobcrcas it ftOUlD be ad damnum of tije *nJ battery. 
 
 aBaron onlp. J5ut tbe Court anftneteo, that tbe CnDidment is goo5, tboag^ 
 tbc tUOjDS ad damnum ipforum be left out. 3 fCCOnD Cjccptfon V0U6 , tbat 
 tbc C-nDictmcnt aotb not flbein tbe time, ano place, tubcn tbe ^aiTault luas 
 commfttcD. 3lp. at is faio imulit anD expalfit in tbc lingular number , Eiidiftmenr. 
 tobeteasft tftoulobeintuleruntanD expulferunt in tbe plural number , be- 
 taufc tbe CnDittmcnt is againft Dltcra , anD fo it if falfe Jiatin. 4lp. STljc p^jf^ Latin 
 CnDictment ufes tbc toojD lignum fo; tbc tpmbcr of tbe boufc , iybcreas it 
 ftoulD be mareroium. Twifden on tbe otbcr CDe anflucrcD, tbat tbc Ciioict. . 
 ment iDas gooD at leaft to tbc ;affanlt ano 15attcrp,tbougb it fail in tl;c otbcr 
 particulars, The Court ordered the Defendants to plead to it , and would 
 not quafh it; 
 
 Mich- 1($4^. Banc. Sup. 
 
 'T'l^eCourtupontbcrcfojnofa &beriff of a rcfcoua maoc, ano rcaD,^ „ 
 ^ luas motcD to quad) it fo j tbefe eitccptionfl taken to it. i . 3t is faio feci' kcUous. * 
 warrantnmmeum ThoraaeTayler , atlDDOtb not fap that Thomas Tayler 
 teas bis ilBapliff. alp. l^e Both not fap fo: tobatcaufc be maoc bis V2af Wamnr. 
 tant , anD fo it appears not tobetbcr it toas latofull 0; not» Vpon thefe ex* 
 ceptiQUs ic was quaihed. 
 
 %2 Mich;
 
 1 56 Mich. 1649, 
 
 Mich. 164^' Banc. (up. 
 
 Vaux and Vaux againft Steward.' 
 
 Arreft tf ^ipon 8 tctofct founu foj ttoo |pia{nt{fFs in an Sltion upon tbc Cafe 
 'udpnv.cnt -n yf ^^qy\ Hii affutnpfit , JEbe SDefeiiDant motoco in fltrrft of 3;nogcmcnt , 
 
 in aftionup- » t^, ,<,,,rn rt'.ptnn that thr. tn^aintiffa nttnhf nnt tn linho to.iM^n ..i «%/» 
 
 n aft.onup- g^^ jq, (jjui-j; fcctos tljat tl)c pa(nt(ffs ottgbtnot to Ijabc topncuiii t^c 
 
 _nan .w^f ^^jj^,,, . i,j,j. £,,,0^1 toljatc bjotigbt fcfeEtal ^ctfoiic. SEbc Cafctoaa tWs, 
 
 loyn in !«!. ti)e fct-cralCattcl Of tl)c tlto piaftttifs IcErc i3(arcpnet);2Cbe SDcfCHDant up' 
 
 on. on totiGDcratton of ten pounos pafo unto l)f m bp tl)c plaOitffs.nfo alTumc ano 
 
 pjomlfc unto tbcm to pjocurc tljc Cattcl to betc^DcUbcrcDtmto tftcm,ano 
 
 • bccaufc tl)cp tocrc not tc^ccUtcrED acojofnelptljcj'fajoiisbttlietrilafon 
 
 rromifc en- fopntlp. Rol! chief lufl cefafOithcpjomffeftcrcis cntfrc,foj tl)cconCDeratfoa 
 
 '■''• is entfrc,anT) fo tl)C 3ctton map be jopntlpibjousbt, Yet let ludgeracnt flay till 
 
 the other move, Poflea, 
 
 Mich. 1649- Banc, (up - 
 
 obfcrvatiorKi T i|i SCtpal bctiticcn Cave ano Osby, fojnotfcttfngfojtbofSCIfbcsat. 
 iipoMa Tryai. J^(0j{)fng to t^c &tatutc Of 2 Ed. d. SCbofE thfngs U)cre DsUtcrcD bp t^c 
 PicfentJ(ion. <i;oatt, I .SCftat tUMnz mappjefenttoaUtfngbpalLettet, butlKoaque- 
 Grcndon. fifonUibctbcttjccanDoftbppatoU. zip. %\fett ought to be tftc tetngaU- 
 cafe, 1 1 Rep. ccntc to Htahc an app?op?fatfon o5a CI)urtl),anD to enootD a tOlfcar. sip. SCftc 
 laipropriati |^(ng caunot Hiahc fuc^ 3 llfcncctDUftout matter oflRccojD, anult ought to 
 !\"- be toftl) a Contiltton to cnDoto aSKtar, anDthecnuolDmcntofthc dkat 
 
 Vicaraic. ^^^ ^^ ^^ ^ Dlftmct (ttfttumcnt from the appjopjiatfon, fo ttiat (t be mane at 
 f^e fame time toljcn the appjopjfatton toao. 
 
 Mich- 1649. Banc. fup. 
 
 , , r T 15 the Cafe of one Wright , brought upon tho statute of !l?uc anu Crp, 
 ,hc fcrvanc 1 RoU chief ludice fafD , that <f a mans fecttjant be robbcD of hfa patters 
 nuy be robbc- (BooDs itt tftt fight o£ hfs pallet, th<« ftall be taUcn fo j a robbfng of tfje ^a- 
 beryofthe fler. 0nt» if one call altiaphfs dDooos to fatjcthem from a llcbber, ano 
 Rubber ^^^ jobber tahe them ujr, ano catrp them aiDap,tSf0 is a robbcrp Done to hf0 
 
 Coles againft Sibfye- 
 
 Mich. 1 64S»' Banc, lap, 
 
 Trin, itf49,rot.i48. 
 
 A Latirat in /^Oles bjoujht an 0£tfon Of SEroljct ano ContcrCon againff Sibfye, 
 
 nature of an v^SChe SDcfcnoant plcaocD the statute of Jlfmftatfon of actions fn bar of 
 
 original. .jjg action, snhe l^lafntff tcpUcs, that he toofe out a Latitat out of thta 
 
 Court againft the S^cfenoant tofthfn the time limftco bp the Statute, tohtch 
 
 pet contfnuea cepenofng. Roll chief lufticc fafo.a Latitat out of this Court fo 
 
 . . fn the nature of an original in the Common plcaa, ano fo hath been altoaies 
 
 0'-'g'"»»- tielo to be. Adjourned. 
 
 Micbt
 
 Mich. 1649. 157 
 
 Mk\\i6^^. Banc.fup. 
 
 T^e Coatt tuag motJcD to quail) Dfters C-nufctmenfs agafntt tljc Bln^a* to qujfii En. 
 tttantS of t!)C patfflies of Shoreditch anD Hackney fit Middlefex, fOJdiftments of 
 
 not repairfns tfte ?^fg^ toapB. Cljc eiccption taken toas, tljat tljc tpatlOics P^^ihcs for 
 ate jopntlp cntifcteD , tijl)crca0 tifzk offcnceg are fcteral, ano alfo not equal, ['^^ h,X"'"^ 
 anO pet botl) fineoalihec TheCourcqua(hcdtheEnd!dment,anddifchar:^gy, 
 eed the iffucs which were not returned, bnt not thofe chat were retorn* 
 ed. 
 
 e. 
 
 Gardner agamft Jolly 
 
 Miclui 649, Banc.fup. 
 
 Pafc I64P, rot. i89f- 
 
 IOllye fajoufebt an action npontbc Cafe agafnft Gardner foj canfing Wm Error torc- 
 to be entWeo ofiTelonpaaacceffarp, fojfuffcrfnga|pj(ronctto efcapcv^rfeajudge- 
 tftat teas contftteo of jFclonp. JCfte |)IafnJHI^5D a tieruftt.anB a juogement? '^^<^^ •« »" »- 
 2Cl)e iBDefenijant b^ougJ&t a Wixit of C-rrojtoret3erfett)is juogement, anD^J°" °" ^^'' 
 tljc crroj afflfgncD leas, tfiat tbc pattp teas cnof ctcn foj a matter toWcl) io but " ^' 
 a SCtefpafs, ano not a iFelonp, ano fo tl^c 2Declatatton ia mtftafecn , ano an 
 jaafon upon tl)e Cafe Ipes not. But the Court anfweted, that the charge of Cafe. 
 the Endiftraent is for Felony, although the matter the party is charged with 
 be not Felony , and a feandal lay upon hiro by it, and therefore the Adion 
 lie^t 
 
 Vaux and Vauxagainft Steward, 
 
 Mich.i649t Eancfup. 
 
 T^^c Cafe betireen Vaux ano Vanx, ant» Steward, toaa agafn motjcu fn at- ^^ [''^ "^ 
 
 tcft of 3fuDgpmcnt. 2C!)c objertfon maoe toas, that tt)c pjomffc maoe a= il\l'^i^on 
 jnountc?5toaiM3Mblep;om<fc,anDtbcrcfojc the patties totohom thepjo=Iipo'n anAf- 
 jn<fc toas maoj ongljt to hatie brought fetjctal ;atf{on0, auD not to liaije <opn- fumi^fit. 
 en fnthc 0ct(on , agthep bate Done, JBut to this H tnas annncrcD bpt^e 
 Cotiticcl on tl)c patntffs pai t, t^at tbc pjemffc is entire , ano is not Double : 
 fo^ tt)e conGoeration oftbcp;iomfre is entire, viz, tbe ten pounotDbicl) mo • 
 tco from tficm topntlp ano rot fctjetallp. Roll chief JuOice bclo . tfjat it is loyiu pro- 
 an cntitc pjomffc, ano a jopnt tonCaeratfon, though tbe Cattcl taUcn toctc '«■'«• 
 Cetjcral, ano tfjctefoje the 0ction mapbcjopnt, ano <i one lap out mo- 
 np fo J a thing affumeti to be Done fo j a tMru pctfon, if it be not Done an 2^ 
 ction Ihall be bjought upon the Affumpfit bp hint trho lapb out t'oc monp;but i^ippon and 
 becanfe a Cafe teas (iteo out of Yelvertons Hepo jts to be againft the opini-^^'"''"''' "^'' 
 on of tljcCoutt.therefojc the Court o;Deico the Conned to b?ing that Cafe, ' '' 
 and m the mean time they would advife.Ancea^ 
 
 ^ 3 ChriHo*
 
 ijS Mich- 16^9. 
 
 Mch, 1649, l^^nc, fuper- 
 
 Chriflopheragainfl How. 
 
 CHriftophcrb?oug^tan3ctfonontl)e Cafe upon an AfTumpfit <ip<nft 
 How an (£%ttatoi , ann DcclarcD upon a pjomffe raaoc bp t^c Ecftatoj, 
 irAitionup'tot'Jcpiaintff, to uelfber certain gooBsfnt^c poffcfoion of ttjc SLcttato?, 
 en the Cafe, unto tljc piafnttt npon requcft, anu becaufe t^c SEcftatoj bao not ncUtiercD 
 t})cm acco:tD<n$lp,tbc piaintif brings b<0 action. 2Et)e pa<nt<f bao a tier* 
 Dtct: SThcSDefcncant niot)ED<narrcftof3;aDgcmcnt, ano fo? catife ftclce, 
 i.SCbattbcbjcacboftbifl pjomtfe ioas in tbc SCcttatojs Ufe time , ano 
 tbeTefo2e tbc 0afon flboulo bat>e been b^oagbt a$a<nfl: b<m , anD I0 not nolo 
 tobcbjongbtagafnfttbe Grccuto?. alp. SDbc Ccffatoj d<o not p?omffe 
 t^at W0 C^ccutojo ttioulD oclltict tbc 30000, but tbat be tooulD oeHter t^em 
 upon rcquclt ; ant) tbecc appears no reqnelt to be maoe to tbe SCeCato^ , as 
 RtqucK. t^etc ougljt to bate been. ^5 lac. Hob. rep. f, 300. Bodwelli Cafe. JBut 
 Roll chief lufticc anftDcreti , %W an C^ecntoj map be cbargcu upon a coU 
 Executor, latgjai pjomtfe , <f tbcre toetea bjeac|> of <t in tbe SCcttatojs Iftc time, anb 
 t)Crcf3agooDrcqtuft,anDgoc0 to all: Therefore let the Plaintif take hit 
 judgeiucnt, except better matter be Ihewed to the contrary. 
 
 and Osborne. 
 
 Mich. 1649. 1 Re-pubt Ang, Banc, fuper* 
 
 Arreft cf T^^ ¥*^alntf f bjoogftt an actfon upon tlje Cafe upon ttoo feberal p?ottil» 
 
 ladgcmcntin fc0 , tbc HDefensjantplcaDcD noD aflampfit , ano upon tbfs an ilTue teas 
 
 sn flftion up- jopncD , ano a tictDta founo fo j tbc iDlafntff. 2Cbc SDcfencant mobeo fji 
 
 on the cafe, attcft of luugcment , anofo^caufe ffietDS, tbattb^rcfsno iffuc jopneo as 
 
 "'• to tljc fcconD pjomffe allcgeD , foj t)C ootb not concluoe toftb petit quod in- 
 
 qui.-aturperpatriam . anD pet tbetcfsa tJctDlct founo uponbotljtl^e pjomf» 
 
 fC0, The ludgeraent was arreftcd till the other fhould move^ 
 
 Mich' 1649. Banc- (iipcr. 
 
 A c f \I ^*'" ^ fpetfal tacttlct tl^e cafe tnas We x SCcnant fo? Ufe , tbe rcmafn^ 
 
 a fi,edai''°" Dei foj Ufc, t^e tcmatntier fn tapl , tlie temafnoer to tbe rfgbt bcfrs of 
 
 %crcift argu- f)imln t^ietcniafnDcr foj life ; tl)c remafnoer man fntapllei3fC0 a fine fn t^e 
 
 ^^- life of tenant foj Ufe; anDtbcqucCton icao, tobctbet bp tl)c Icti'lng of 
 
 tb<0 fine tlic cflate tapl irere uffcontlnueo oj no. 2Co pjotjc tbat tlic tffatc 
 
 tapltJaootfcontfnncD.tbefcJBoobstDereclteD, 1H7. 22. Lit. Cap. Dif« 
 
 ccnts,Se<ft. 34. i4Ed. 3.Fitz. Avowry ny.'sEd, 3. Fitz» grantt 60. 15 
 
 £d. 4 9. 2 Rep. Butlerscafe 65. Cooks Lit. f, 25. Fafcb. 1 3 Car. Hnnj;ates 
 
 Cafe,Banc.Reg. Dyer. 339. Twifden to tbccontrarp argucD, tbat tdc e= 
 
 Catc is not altetcD, ncftljcr to t^ic rfgl)t no? bp leap of Cffoplc, 46 Edward 3 . 
 
 snopic f. 23. janClfopIefuppofctbatbingtobcDonc; anutberefojcfftlje tiling 
 
 betmporfilbletsbicbtsaUegei) bploapofefiople^ttcanbeno cftople. Slno 
 
 oncfljallnotbeconlltneDto Doe tojongbpan fltt tobfcb map be IntctpjCe 
 
 tcD fo , tbat bp It be map Doc no tojong. Brookt j9fa;lDgemcnf Grants 49. 
 
 Roll chief luilice, 2El)C matter tietc I0 not tioto t^e tttates ftall pafs , ana 
 
 IlOtD
 
 Mich. 1649. 15^ 
 
 ftofc tu -mabc iA)tm sets ; but tijp £iuc0<on is upon tljc fojfeUatc : foj "^^'icuurc 
 is Ut<cs t^e fine as of an eSatc in poile.'atotT, ano not ofa rctcrfion in 
 fee ; anc tijfg fs notiipon ti;t rule (n Bredons cafe, 1 j Car. Sir Julius Cxfars 
 cafe ; an acceptaiite of an cttatc, oj an ;attc:nmcnt bp aCcrant fo; life to a 
 ftrang:tc , |0 a fojffcUure, J«rm>n luftice !}clD tijcrc teas no forfeiture. Buc 
 the Court faid the VerdiS was ill fonnd • and therefore ordered it fhould be 
 amended, that the whole matter in Law might cpmc in queflion. Amendmcn:* 
 
 Gray ag^unft Walye 
 
 Mich. i(54P« [Bancfip^ 
 
 ■yvi^Aiye ijjou!^ an SLdiow upontbc Cafe asafntt Gray, foj fpcabfng 
 
 '^ tbcfetoOjDB of ftfm, tlj. lack Waive was quei'lioncd for ftealing ofa ^7 ■ 
 
 gray Mare wuh a imp m her e»r, and hue and cry went out after him , and he i,, ^ftii n up- 
 duritnorlhewnis face hereabouts. 2Lt>e |)latntif JjaD a clCrDfct; snD t^Con the cafe. 
 2>cfcrQnnt mofecD in Sitiett of JuDgcment, ttiat tljc tuojDs Itcrc not adio= 
 nable,;becaufetbepU)ereeencrai8nDancertamtoo?Os, anD it Doth not ap- 
 pear the partp Ujas DamniitcD Ijj' them, no j tolu long ano thcp licrc fpoken. 
 Roll chief lufiice fato, that the pattp \ms D.';famcD bp fpeabing o' t||cm, an9 
 l)c ftatft laiD ft tliat be loft his CrcDit tbcrebp. Therefore le : the Plaintif have 
 ins ludgeraent, exccp: better matter be (hewn. But Nicholas /uftice doabt« 
 cd whether they Wfre^ftionable or nOi And Ask Inftice nihil dixit. 
 
 Mich; 1^49. Banc. fup. 
 
 AiPt^ttojnepoftJjisConrttliatttjastriftbfnage, appearctj f an 0£tton Error agahii 
 propria perlona; anDplraocntoiffuc,anobaD a tcrolrt ano a uiDamcnt i"^ ^'"°'"'y 
 fo J bim ; anu upon ttjia a tojit of Crto j wis bjougljtbere, it bcin^ an erto j appearing 
 Infattj bccanfct&atbeinfliiiirWn age cio not appear p?rgu5rdtanum, no j;i,ofi>jj ^erya- 
 bp bfa :attojncp ; ant ft toas fato, tij -t it is not belpcbbp tbe SJtatate of 31c= "^, being 
 ofailg, ttjoua^ftbcafterucrotct. And thereupon the Court ihyed the Exc-""'i'". 'lo- 
 cution. E'r»r.n/aS. 
 
 A/crcer againft Rule. 
 Mich. «64S>, Banc. fup. . 
 
 'T^eCMirttBas«io1)eo,2CbataiB>itof 0t*aj iBasbjowbtto rebcrfc a For ^s.^pofi- 
 
 5M0gemcnt, ar.otbatfttaaorcceitieaanoallolaco: ano i'.utUwt'oftanO-^yMf&a:- ■" 
 ing tbe ^laintif tb« bat> tbe Juogemcnt ban taijen cut crccntiouianc tb^rc- t'cSment for 
 ution it toaa pjapto fo; a iup«rfedea« teiuperfcoe tbe^rccution, auJ) fo: an '^'^."^^.^'^ c 
 •jattacbmcit againflr the oactp fo j b<s contempt totbas Court. a.iQ it leas rcVa wrir"of " 
 urgeDbptbeConucenbatmofco , 2Sl)at after a,fe3itofG;rro; is tcccibco Error brought 
 anDadoli)Li),tbebatrt0of tbe Court tbatgabe tbe 3tnoscmcnt,are fojcclo» ","«i allowed. 
 ftDfromswntinsoot^rccution, ann that ti)eSDMtof ©rtoj ia ^^ii^^^i^)^'/,l'f^^^cnz 
 Superiedcas, ano citco Dyer »8 3. anD tbercfo?c concluacD, that the Sfuati= ExccmTon?" 
 jonisnottDcUittiicofojtb. Twifden of Comiccl on tbe other iioefaii), that 
 ^eiu;ttof CrrojltasnotDulpptirfuetJ, bccaufe tbe roll laas not matUeo-, 
 anotbcrcfojctbcpartp aiinlK xscU tafec out epecatioit. 35ut Rollchief lu- 
 ftice anfiscrco , t^t tbe ii^it Hjas toclt purftieo, though the roll l«crc not 
 ntarkefl; pctif neitbeitbetoU be markct),nojiioticcstiientotbe 3tto;ncp Ngtice. 
 tm tie btbex; liDc of tbe b;iiig(nc tbe tojit of Crro; , if tbe partp pjocao 
 *o trike Wit cyecntion , it is no contempt to tfe Court : otijeiUiifc tt is 
 
 8
 
 i6o ^ch. 1649. ^_ 
 
 Contfrnpt. acontcmpt; fliiDUistljcBntpof tfjeClctboftljcCrtojBtomarfe tljc roll, 
 Siipojcdiits. anD not tl)e 3ttojneps ; and therefore take a Superfedcas, quia im provide c« 
 raanavir, to ftop execution, 
 
 Pym againft Morgan, alias Bambery and Bafelye- 
 
 Mich. 1649, Banc, fupi 
 
 Hill, 24 Car, rot, io6i, 
 
 Ar£;iimcnt Y j^ ail Ejcfllone firmx bjmigWfo? tftcf^annoj of Caledown, SCIjcSDc. 
 
 vf "diii 10*^311 * fc^iJant plcauis i^ot gutltp ; ano upon ttjts tfte 3urp ftno a fpccfal tctotti 
 
 rjesim'f,,- to t^fa cffctt , SLbat &<r Thomas Morgan toas fcifcD ht fee , amongft otfeet 
 
 w.f. lanDg, of t^c InnDo f n qucftton, anu tliat (n 1 3 Car. f)e mauc a fcttlemcnt of 
 
 tl)cfclanoi3tol)fmrclffo;Ufc,ttjcrcinafnDcrto Ijfo oaugbtct Mary fo; Ufc, 
 
 tl)c rEmatntJEr to tfjc I)cir0of tljc firtt 2Dcnant foj If fc, toitb a poincr of rcbo- 
 
 catton,toalteraUojanp part of tljc fcttlemcnt maoc atanp time outing 
 
 !)fo life : SDbe 'ocrolct finos further, ttjat tl)cte toac an £) jDlnantc of |parUa- 
 
 mcntmaDctntl)cj'carofotJtlLojD, 1^4^, tbat&fr i homa? Morj^an fljoulo 
 
 fojfcft all fefai lanofl anD tftatc \x\)k\) l)c \tas tl)cn felfcD oj poffcffcD of, 03^ 
 
 !)aD been felfeDojpoffcffeDcf iromtljcpeat 1641. anDt!)at ljptljcfamc£Dj=^ 
 
 Dfnance tbe lanoo In queOfon lucre glten to J^r. Pym ; 5 tljat bp tlrtuc of tbe 
 
 falD ^jtif nance be cntrcD? tBas felfeo pro ut; ^tljat £pr, Pym olcD fo feffeo, 
 
 after lofjofc Dcatft tl)cpia{nttfslcffo;,a0 Ijfs l)cfr,cntrcD,({ maac a leafc to tbc 
 
 pialntff.jaftettljat&trTho Morgan DteD.s Mary tljcEiefenoant claiming 
 
 33 tenant in tcmalnDcr fo? life after tbe ueatl) of &ir Thomas Ijcc fatljcr, bg 
 
 "bcrtue of tbc fcttlemcnt mace i ^ Carol, entree Into tOclanDa In qucftlon, 
 
 anotl)cpialnttfa3leff<EOiPymb:lngstbcattlon. lilpontblafpcclal bet- 
 
 Diet, tbe Siueftlon iuaj>,,®!!tt)etl)ct bp tbc £);olnancc of parliament maoe 
 
 nottlUtbcpeat 1645. petltDUlns^acUtotbepear i(54i. tbe rcmalnDerof 
 
 tbclanOslnqacaion,\ub<cbtoasrctlcDi5 ear. being befoictbc mailing of 
 
 ti)c jfiDjtilnancCj ant) alfo bcfo?c tbe time to tobicb tbe S) jDlnance looiis bacit, 
 
 Foi feiturc." bc fojfeltco fap t5)c ^DjiHnancc oj not ;> Larch of Councel toltb tbe a^cfen^ 
 
 DantargueDjEbatlttcasnotfojfclteo; x.3I5ctaufetbat tbe iD^olnance fa 
 
 penal, ann retrofpcdltc j ImUlng bach ; ann tbcrclojc It Is oDloiis fn 3Lato, 
 
 aniJ djail not be largclpfntcrpjcten but asftrictlpasmapbe. 2lp, SCbe 
 
 preamble of t!;c £> jDlnancc fcts fo;tb 2 . tbmg0,ao tbe reafons iubp tbe iDjs 
 
 tlnancc tens mane ; i. 2^t. I'yms ucfcrts, to tobom tijc lanos tocfc gltien ; 
 
 alp, Morgans offences, foj toUcb be tons tbuo punllbcD ; ano fcolb tbefe 
 
 gronnos fo> rnalifng tbe £Djoinancc tan cvteno no fartbct tban to tbe peat 
 
 1641. anDfonottotbetfmcoft!)crcttlfmcntmaoc i?Car. bp &it Tbo* 
 
 masMorgitn; foj tben ncKbcr Of tbcfccaufcsaHegeo tDcrc fnbclng; zip, 
 
 SCbc purtoletD of tbe £> jtlnancc Is Double ; 1 . pimttlbc : alp, tcmuneratlbe, 
 
 I. tbe punltlbe part, tcbfcb concerns tbe piniitblng of fefr Thomas Morgan* 
 
 2lp, tbe rcmuitcratlbc part, concerning tbe rctoarDlng of ipr, Pym; anu tbe 
 
 punltluc part mace In tbe pear 1645. cannot reacb tbe cftatc fetleu upon 
 
 Mary bla Daughter fo long bcfojc, viz. 13 Car. foj ft can reacb no furtbet 
 
 bacU tban to tbe pear 1 64 1 . at tbe moft. to tobtcb tf mc, ano no further, tbe 
 
 £)3Dtnancc Is rctrofpectlte : anD in tbe Statute of 25 H. «. genera* Ujojds 
 
 ofan <3itarcrcKralncD, llBcCiocs, tberclsa Dcmonflratlon In tbe £)?Df- 
 
 natuc, that Kjetrs tbe £)?Dlnancc Dotb not ertcnD to tbe cttate of tbe 2Dcfen' 
 
 Dant, as map appear bp tbe p^ottfoca contelneD in It ; fo j although the cblb 
 
 D;en of Morgan are to bc punfll)CD tolthin the £D jDlnancc bp the fee onD pjo» 
 
 tifoofft.pcttblsertenDsnottofolongtlmcaato 13 Car. tDbcn the eftatB 
 
 tDasfetlcD,b»t onlptotbe ettatc, m it toas In tbe peat i64«. ^no tbcrc* 
 
 foje
 
 Mch, i64p i6\ 
 
 fojepjagCD SIuDgement foj tljC S!>efenDailt. Wadham Windham on f^D 0- 
 t^iet fioe arguco , ttjatt^ccCatc of Morgan, tfjotigl) ft toag fatntobc fctlco 
 13 Car. toas fojfcttcD bp tl)c £D;ofnancE. JSccaufc tbc cOatciuaflnot 
 abfolutelp fetlco at tljat tfme , foj tftere tuas a p joWfo (ti the contcpan ce to 
 teljobe t^e fcttlcmcnt, fo tbatattljcttmcoftljc a)jomancc mau'e tt)cr. 
 Itate liias in &ic Thomas Morgan abfolutelp to Oifpofe off as be plcafc^, anD 
 bp tbc toojDs of tl3C £) jDtnancc Jill Morgans cftatc is paCfeo toftbout anp fa- 
 ttng, anu tljc pjotifocs of t!)c ilDjOfnance do pjotjc, tbat tfte (Etjtlojcn of &(c 
 Thomas Morgan toere EicccptcD ontoftt)e ratfngBmaoctopicfcrtetbcc- 
 ftatcs of otljerfi, 0lfo llSoons atio iFatours bcftoiueD ufc to Oc amp'.p tt, 
 pounDCD,anD tb<s being a HBoon bcftoitcD bp tbc patWament fljall rcccf t)C as 
 large a conftrtictfon as (0 pofsfble. IBcfiocs Morgan iuas a |)apfft, (| tijcrfoje 
 ft map iDcll be fuppofcD^tbat bcintenocD not tbfa foj nnp teal fettlcmcnt,but 
 onlp fap toap of fubtfUtp foj fomcpjtt3atcreafonB:fo; toe hnoU) tljat pa« 
 pifts DO ufc to mabc futb fettlcmcnts as tbf0 toas to p jcfcttje tbem from pc= 
 naltfes oftljelLatD. ianDtbelnojoaoftbc^Djofnancc areaccumHlattfacto 
 conbcp all Morgms cftate, anDtbcrcarenorcffrltftbctoojoo, anoff tbcre 
 Ircre tbep fljoulD be boto bere: fo j tljc Jjftano j of Callidown bcfng tbe iLanoa 
 Inqueftton arc C):p3icflp rltcn bp tbe £>:D<nante. ano as to tbefc JLancs tbe 
 rfgbta ofallmenarcbouno, ano tbcrcfojc If tbcrc VoereafalitneUiroulD 
 be bolD, as It is Cook rep. Alton Woodj Cafe. ^nD anattof JDatliamcnt 
 fometimcs is as a conbepance.foniethnc as a juDgmcnt,anD botb tcales a fa- 
 ting in it is t)o<D ano (riboloits, 1 Rep.4. 3 conDftfonal cftatc j a rfgbt map 
 be fabeo bp Sluogment 0? fine, but not an entire eftatc o? Intercft.ano tbere- Siving. 
 fojc tbe cftateof Mary intbetpano; of Callidown, cannot be fabcDbp anp 
 pjoblfo, ano be tltcD Alton Woods Cafe fo j autbo?<tp fn tbe principal Cafe, 
 t.^1. IBut aomlttlng a general fating bao been gooo to fate Maries eftatc, 
 |)et as tbe toojDs of il)c iD;Dinancc tocrc pcnnco, ber cftatc is not fabcD bp' 
 lt,fo} tbetDo;D3ta>ereputiiitbeiiD:iDmancefo;tbeaDt)antageof Pym, ano 
 nottop?otitDefo}Mary : fojlbc Claims from Thomas Morgan, ano fopiap^ 
 ED 3l«cgcmcnt fo?tbeplaintif. Roll chief lufticefafo,tbat tbepjotffoco 
 in t^ £>;D<nancc are not bolD to all pcrfons,as Windham argueo.fo j Stran- 
 gers arc tlcarlp pjobfi5eD fo j bp tljem. But let the CaCe be argued again Sa<: 
 turday fortnights Poflea. 
 
 Harwcod againft Payee. 
 
 Mich. 1^49 Banc. fup. 
 
 fimredHill, :4Car.rot,78. 
 
 'T^e quWtfon fnCftcb upon in t\]is Cafe toas, iwbetbcr upon a rccobcrp in whedicr 
 -*■ an action of JDcbt agalnft a parfon, tbe aEitbcs be cvtcnDfble bp hle» ,cndbic upon 
 pit. Hales of Counccl iuftb tbepamtlfbclD,tbat tbep arc, bccaafc tbat 7n ricgu. 
 SCltbcsmap be faio to be I^encments, ano the ^arfon batb a iFrce>bolD <it 
 tbcm,aitf)ouahbc bolD tbcni jure Ecclefix. mm Roll chief lurtice falD, tbat ^'H"' 
 a parroitage cannot be C);tenDefl,but tbat tbe SDebt map be IcbpcD out of tbe p 
 jp?ofito ofltbptbc&bcrlf, as ft teas tDont to be Done : foj noijo tbere bt fug """'' 
 no JBfGjops tbe pjoftts cannot be fcqucftrebbp tbe IBflbop of tbe SDfotes , Scqucftration 
 astbepufeOtO be. 315utlerroan ano Nicholas luftices DoubtcO. Ask luftire 
 agrecD toftb Roll , anofafo, tbat bp tbe Common4atD tbe ClergparenoCiergy. 
 moie pjfbtlegcD from paring tbcir Debts, tban 3lap men are. RoH chief lu. 
 fticc fafo, ft batb been bcrctofojc qneftfoneD,\T;bctbcr a Clergp-man be fnb= 
 m to toatcb anb toaro, t^i to contribute to fatisfte fo j a tobbcrp cone irftb^ 
 
 ^. p ■ in
 
 - ■ - , . — . ■ ---ill . 1,1 l—MI I, 
 
 ^6i Mich. 1649- 
 
 in tl)C l^imojcD : but noto ft is no qucffion but tbcp arc fubtect, ano (ball con* 
 ttfbUtC, Adjourned till Saturday to be argued again, Poftea, 
 
 Tyndal and others againft Harington^ 
 
 Mich. 1^49, Banc, fnp, 
 
 Arrtfi of "T Yndal bjotia!)! an actfon of ©cbt agafntt Harington foj atrctagcfl of 
 ju.fRcment in ^ ^0,^ t)uc to btm 33 ILcffcc ofa tilfcaragB, anD upon nil debet p!ca?5ctt, 
 fi'^ll dV" ^^"'^ ^^^ ^" 3^^"^ jopncD. anD a bctQtct founu foj t^c piaintff . Jtbe 2Defcn« 
 anmiWy.*" Dant mobED <n arrcft of Suugcment, tbat an attfon of SDcbt oio not Ipe, but 
 pcbt. " that Ijeoncbttobabebjougbt aMritofjannuttp, becauCc (ttoasfojarre. 
 Annuity, jgggg of an iSnnuftp , lobfcb pet contfnnc0, ano 6 ri. 4. 7. & p H. 6, 94^ 
 toctc CfteH. The ludgemenc was arrefled till the PIaiotifllioutdmove« 
 
 Compton againft Allen. 
 
 Mich 1 6^9f Banc. (ap. 
 
 Entred Trin. 1^49, rot. 348, 
 
 Dcniiirrc. /^"'Ompton b?ou5bt art 0rtfon ofCobenantagafnft Allen WsiLctTccfoj 
 
 upona iMca Vjpearsupon a Cotcnant Of tl)c 3lne0nturc, fbj rtot feeepfiTp; tl)e ^oufe Ict 
 
 in an aflion u„to feint fn tcpalc. %\)t SDcfcnDant plcaijg, tljat tl^ l^oufe tuas burnt bp 
 
 ? '-°^'="*"'- cafualtp. 2Ci)c pialnttf Demurs to tljls pica, ano fo> caufc ftjctoc, tbat t^c 
 
 |91ca U)aBcontrarptotbcSDcfcnBant0crp;cf3Cobcnantbpl)foSDccD, ano 
 
 tbcrcfojc Vras not gooo. Roll chief lufticc falo, tbat a JLcffcc tfiat cobcnanf» 
 
 Covenint ctb to rcpalt, ougbt to DoUlf tftc l^oufc bc bumt, bcU bpncglfgcncCjOj bp 
 
 " "'* otbcrmcano. Therefore letthePlaintif have ludgemcntexceptcaufeftiew- 
 
 ed to the contrary. 
 
 — againft Phillips. 
 
 Mich, i<349< ' anc, fup> 
 
 Arreft of X ^ Sidiou upoH f^c Cafc SjoRs bjougftt agafntt Phillipt fo j fuffcrfng one 
 
 judgement in xYtocfcapc; SDb^ pialuKf ftao 8 bctofrt ; arbc SDcfenoant mobcDinar^ 
 
 an adi. n up- tcft of ^ttttgcrticnt, auO foji caufc fljclDO, tbat the SDcdaratfon luaa (nfuffid* 
 
 on the Cafc.ji^t^ jfoj j. (t flj:lD3, tl)at tbc pattp luas artcftcQ ttjat maoc tb? cfcapc, 
 
 Eicspe. butUDotI)notQ)CU3bpiJrt)iJtpjoccf0ljeU)a0arrcftca. alp, aCbc SDcclara-- 
 
 tfonf(ittb,tbatbeli)asatrcftcDvirtDte Qijerelactnbfcb cannot be : fo^bcta 
 
 arrcftcD bp blrtuc of the Writ, anO not of the pialnt. glp. Ti)t ^ttla- 
 
 tatlon Dotii not OjcId bpvobat aatbojftptbc jDjffon toagf-cpt, outoflcblcfi 
 
 - ^ tbc efcapc tri!3 maoc Roll chief luftice falB, tbai tbcfcconn crccption toaa 
 
 EKapc. niatcrial, anDthcnlftbcpartpbenottoclUrrcttcD, tbcrc can be no efcapc, 
 
 ano fo tbc 0ftfon lpc0 not% Therefore nil capiat per billan), ifcaulc be not 
 
 (hewed ro the contrary. 
 
 lohnfon
 
 Mich.i64p. i6^ 
 
 lohnfon againfl: Abington. 
 
 Mich, 1^49, Bine, fup. 
 
 JOhnfon b;ioagl&t an 0(t{onoftl)eCafcaca<nff Abin^^ton, anT» ucclate*, ^''f'^ °f 
 t^at ttje Dcfcnoant in confioctatton t^at tlje piatntff tooulD DcUtjcr auto '"'^^[^on' '" 
 t^e SDeftttDants &on fatlj iuarcg aa bw &on Qjoulo Defira, DlDalttimeano'n,nAau^r- 
 pjomjfc nnto t^epafntffi6at!)ctooalopaptbepa(iitff fo; tf)cm,anoa-ru. 
 ttxs tftat f)C tjao ocUteteo certain toarcs unto Ws &on, ano t^at tljc 0z(en= 
 oant BID tcftifetopapfojtficm, ano for tWsftel):oug^t Wo Action, 2C^e 
 3)cfcnDant pleaMnonAflumpfit.anDnpontWsanjlIue fo jopneo, ann a 
 Derotct founo foj tbe |3lafntff. SCfte a>efenoant tnotjco in arrcft of jtiuge- 
 mcnt, ano fo j catife ftcios, tijat ft Doth not appear, that the &on of the SDc» Averment 
 fenoant ofo ocfire tbc Goods thatthe|3lafnt<fDclttcrcD onto him, anDfoj 
 U)h<(h ibe b}<ngs hts ;Sl(tfon , ano the AfTumpfK being to pap fo^fuchais h<s 
 &ort IhonlD DcCrc, the SDctlaration ought to fct fo^th an actual ocGrc of the 
 !&on,to hat)E the iDarcaDclitJcreD. IBiit Twifden of Councel toithth: plain* 
 tif anftoereo, that the ocliucrp of the commoDitfea bp the piainttf , ano the 
 acceptance of them bpthe SDefennant implpeo a Defire.ano itianotncccffa^ 
 rp to fljeto an atfnal teftte. lerman luftice faio, there ought at Icaft to be a 
 tjetbal Dcfirc. IBut Roll chief laftice faio, that the acceptance of the toarcs fa 
 an aaual uefire, anu that is mo?c than a tjetbal ocftre, ano it is not necelTa^ ncciara.ioni 
 rp here to affirm the punctual toojw of the pjomifc : but onlp the fubftancc Aiumpfie. 
 of ft. And therefore ietthePlaintifhjvc bii ludgemenc, if better matter be 
 not (hewed, 
 
 Mich- 1^49. Banc- (up- 
 
 TTTZA Iker motjeti to quaflj an cnDfrtment agafnfi the inhabitants of Mile. To quafh an 
 ^ end, tofti)(n the parfflj of Stcbenhoch fo; not repairing the high toapjEnii'Smcnc. 
 ano to take off the iffucs upon a Certificate teao, that the toap teas repairco, 
 ano upon this crccption taUen to the Cnoictment, viz. that the Sinhaijitants 
 of Mile-end toithin the parith of Stebenhoth are cnDi£tcD,ano Mile^end is but 
 ai^amlct toithin a pari0j, ano a ^^amlct tiiithin a Pariflj cannot be chargen 
 to repair a high toap, cjcccptitbcbppjefcriptton, ojfojfomc other fpecial 
 rcafon : fo> of common rightihe tohole PariOj is chargeo tuith ft; ano here is Common 
 no fuch pjefcrfption or particular reafon djetocD in the C-nDictmcnt, ano rithc. 
 therefore it is not gooo. Roll chief lufticeanfiDCtcD, that of common riaht "'s'^ '"'•r' 
 a ^amletfs not fo chargeo, but a bill fs; and therefore let ic be quafhed, bat 
 the ifTues (hall ftand : for few will repair the high way till they be forced. 
 
 Fines againft Dell, 
 Mich^ 1649, Banc, fup. 
 
 pines fajought an action of SDebt upon an Obligation to perfbim certain ^'''^""*'" 
 Cobcnants containro in an Snocntnrc. SChc BDefcnoant pleaoo perfoj. * t'^unon an 
 mance generallp; Ehe Plaintiff Demurs to the pica, ano foj canfe fhctos, obiigKion to 
 that Ditjers Cobenants are compjifco in the SnDcnture, anothatfomcof prform Co- 
 thcm are in the afarmatibe ; ano others of them arc in the i^cgattbc, anovcnant*. 
 tbercfoje a general pleaoing of petfo;mance to all is not fufficfent : fo; as to ^''"• 
 the Cobenants fn the Sffirmatibe hcoughttopleaDarpctialpcrfo?mance, 
 ano to Ojc to hoto he hath pcrfo jmco them. The Court bid the Flaintit take 
 bis JDdgcincot, except caufe be (hewed to the contrary, 
 
 ffi Mich,
 
 i<$4 Mich- 1^9-_ 
 
 For 1 rule to : 
 
 Afich 1649- Banc- fup- 
 
 Tl^e Court toas motco tdat t^cre migl^t be a rnlc of Cotirt fo> t^e partp 
 ackn^wicajc upott fatfofactfoH fflHOc Of a juDgcment obtafncD bp bfm, to acUnoto- 
 fjtiiiaaion. ' icDgc fatfsfactfon. JBut tbe Court uenpco it , ano fafo t^jcrc toas fomc 
 trtcb in tl)C bufincffc ; For no doubt but the party upon receipt of what is due 
 to him will ackncwlege fatitfadion without a rule to compel him, 
 
 Crible againft Orchard. 
 
 Mich. i649»Banc. fup» 
 Entrcd Trin. i(54p, rot» : 30. 
 
 Error upon a 
 
 ORchardb^onQl)t an attton Of Debt agafnil Crible upon an £)bUsatfon, 
 tljeBDefcnuantplcaDEDperrninas; upontWsaniffuctoaa logneo , ano 
 dcbTujion an a mcrolct atiD a Sjaugcment gtbcn in tf)c Court at Barnftaplc foj tfte |6lain- 
 obiigaiion. ^^f^ anouponaMrttofCrrojbjougU tljjEC (iErro;i8 tocrc afslgncD: i, 
 SDbat the E>cclaratfon teas {nfuffidcnt. alp. SCI^c Common Crroj. 3lp. 
 SCftatthc Venire toas not gccD; but thcfc Inerc oljct-rulco. 2no Roll 
 chieflunice upon i^pcr of the Ifleco^iofounD this Crro^, 2Dbat the 3ititp<n 
 Djm>f;es. ffjc atfcfslngof oamagea fap pro miffis & Cuftaoiis, &c, but ooc not not fap 
 ludgc-.ncnt, j.|^jj (cdam cc expenditis, anD fo ft cannot appear foj ichat the coff-s aao Da- 
 mages arc affcffeD, ano fafD, 3t fs true that the juogcmcnt la rfght enttco ; 
 but there fs no tElcrofct to toarrant the 3IuDgemcnt, ano tbcrefoje ft cannot 
 be gooD , anD therefore let it be rctDcrfeDtfcaufe be not Ihelon tot:;eton« 
 trarp. But we will not pronounce it oow except the party defircitfochis 
 own expedition. 
 
 Ayrc againft Pyncomb, 
 Mich, 16^9. Banc. fup. 
 
 AYreb;oagi)tan0(tfon upon the Cafe againttPymcombfojfurchars- 
 ingofa Common, ano fo J trcaoing thcdDjafo: aChe paintff hao a 
 3n"Aft;on up- merD.fct • Slhe 2DefcnDant mobCD ia Strrett of 3luDgcmcMt , SChat an Stfion 
 onthec.fc of the Cafe Doth not lie in this cafe, but an 0roijc, zlp.SChatan Action of 
 for fiircharg- j^tefpafs Doth not lie foj a Commoner foj treating of the <&?af0, jlp, 2Chc 
 ingaCom. 2[;^gfpafg fg aUegcD to bc Dottc in quibuWam pcciis pafturi, anD the quantttg 
 T.W" of them is not (heloeD. Xo the firtt C-jccptton Roll chief luftice anfiucreD , 
 
 TiepfsupoiiSChstthepiafntifmaphatJcanilfdjcojan Sfctton upon the Cafe at his 
 the cafe. Elertton , although h re be a Difturbance of tljc JDlatntffs frceholD , although 
 that the anttcnt boobs fap the contrarp: And thereupon the Court oave 
 Judgement for thePiaintif , except caufe flitWn to the contrary. 
 
 Brook againft Hogg. 
 
 Mich, 1 549. Banc, fup. 
 Hill, 14 Car. rot, 660, 
 
 ludgement in 
 
 '"''fcdTr A Bui'Scmcnt giben in an anion of Debt upon an accotmt in theContt 
 Evminh /r\of Knarcsborough vcas retjerfcD hetc , betanfe t^t Venire facias toaa 
 
 Vcni^
 
 Mich. i^4<7. i5j 
 
 Veuire facias, ^c. to^fc^tn an Blnfctfont Court is not boo , but ft ongljt to \We7 
 fap Venire facias duodecem probos et legales homines de , &c. % fo Cjcpaefs all 
 at large fit too jDs , ani3nottoftMn,&c. Note, Many ludgcmems given in 
 Infcriour Courts have been here reverfed upon the fame exception : But I on« 
 iy mention this for an authority to be cited upon occafion^ 
 
 Ibfon again ft Beale- • 
 
 Mich. ii$49.Banc» fup« 
 
 HilK24Car.rot. 625* 
 
 iBfon bjong^t a OTtft of (Error to retjcrfe a 3lmiffement gf tjen agafnft hfm 
 ■■■foj Beale fnt!)e Court at York, fn an Sidion of SDcbt upon an ilDblfaatfon j^""""" '" ^^^ 
 ^no afsfgneo foj Crrojs, i. acijat ttie partj? Wh not cntttuleo hfmfclf to ''"'" * '".''pf* 
 Vattfon. ilp^StftcfffueffluotiDcUjopncn; fojtfjejaiafntff faftl», ideo' '"""''«'''• 
 ponitieiuperpatriam, tD^Crc l)C OUgljt to fap, petit quod inquiratur per Iliue. 
 patriaiB, glp* l^e concluDcs, to W Damage of U • (i.) fiftp pounog erp?cr< 
 feDfnnumcrfcali^ettcrfi, viz.L, fojfiftp, anoL. foj pounos, fnftcao of°"^'e''' 
 quinquaginti librarum. The Jludgement was reverfed upon the laft Ex- 
 ception > 
 
 Stubs and A/anklyn 
 
 Mich. 1^49. Banc, fup, 
 
 'A Wrffof Crrojtoas bjougl^t to retJcrfc a 31uDgement gftjcn fn t^e Error to rc- 
 
 ** Court at Owfe.bridgefn York, fnan actfonofSDcbtupon an )©blfgatf.'^'^' '•"''?«• 
 
 on, anD the Common Crrpjonlp afsfgnco. 315ut Roll chief luftice upon"**^"' mdebr. 
 
 £)pEr of tbe lilccojD tmfe tbfs crccptfon, ZDhat tftc IReto jo toao ideo prxtep- 
 
 tumeft Vicecomiti, anD ft fs not fafo in Curia , anOfoft Dotbnot appear to 
 
 be tbc IPjotCfs of tfte Court ; And for this Error the iudgeraent wasyeni-c 
 
 reverfed. 
 
 Topladye againft Scalye^ 
 
 Mich, a(549 Banc, fup, 
 Mich* 24 Car, rot, J96. 
 
 TOpladyebjougf)tan0(t{onof2nrcfparsquare claufumfregit &pEdibus 
 ambulando &c.agafnft Stalye ; 2L^e SDcfenoant mahes a fpccfal iallffi* 0"="'""^" 
 catfon , %m tc Dfo enter fntojthe plafntffg Clofc to fcarcli fo? fehap that'oon":? ?!«"' 
 iDcrc ftoUen from bfm. 2Co this ipiea the iplafnttf Dcmurr'o, ano fo: taufci.i xrcfpif., 
 IbEiBS t^at the Juftificatfon fs not goon , fo; ft fs not fafu bp the SDcferiuant 
 tbat tbe ipiafntff bao ttoUcn tbe &heep , 0? tliat be bao anp fufpttfon that lt& 
 banttoBen tbem, oj tbat anp otbcr hau Collcn tbcm f D?ftjcn them upon the 
 ^latntf fs lanD , ano fo baa no colour to tome there to fearcbfo; tbcm, ano 
 tbcJBoofeSOf I7E.4 f, i.andayH. 8.a3.&6E.4.7.&iiH.7. f. 10. &,-.c . 
 22H.8.f. 36,&38E. 3.f. jciuerccfteD. 0notbcr erccptton trao aifp '""'"""o"' 
 tafeen, S^hattbcSDefeniiantDotbnotfaptbattbcdPateoftbc Clofc inhere 
 .becntrcDtoasopen : auotbongbbemapluttfficto fearcb fojbfo&bap fn 
 •^cClofc, pet be cannot jutt(6c tbe b?eabfngoftif0Clofe to Doe ft, SBnt 
 
 33 3 Roll
 
 i66 ^ Mich. 1649. 
 
 Roll chief lufticc oticr^tiilcMWs cj:tcptfon •. atiDfoj t^c matter in Jlato, 
 
 Irbctbcr tl)D SDcfcnoant bao maoc a jjood juflificntton 0? ito. De bclD tbat 
 
 ^c bao not, foj all ttjat Ijc batb aUegcD bp teap of BluftWcatton fa but mattec 
 
 Diftcfs. ofpjffeatcpjofitto bfrnfclf, anotiot foj tljc ptihlfquc gooo ; foj 6c tncnt 
 
 D^migcica- nottbitftettoSnuojappjcbcnDtfecJ^clon, buttolccUfojljfc&ljap; Sinn 
 
 ^•>'»- ifCattclbcftoUcnanDputtntompgtonno, 3lmaptaUetbcm Damagcfea. 
 
 fant. ojb?fii(ja!i S?(t<onof SCrcfpafo agadift tbc otoncr, anD t^c oumcr 
 
 Licence. cannot taUe tfjcm atoap toftbout tljc Kccnfe of tbc pcffcffo j of tljc grotmo , 
 
 fo?ffl)ctnf0bt,bpt^atitican0tbcpofretrojof tbefirouno tooulo be uUbout 
 
 rcmcup fo J tbc namaee tl)c Cattel ftao Done Ijfm : Sinn be fafo , JLfjat toben 
 
 one liati) fufpttfon of anotbct foj fclonp , be ounbt to ftcto tbc taufc of Ws 
 
 Arrcft. fufpftfon , otbcrtDlfc t^: partp fufpeflcD ongljt not to be atrctteD upon It ; 
 
 nnu tontluDCD tl)at tlje patntif ougl)t to !)a\3e 3uDgeincnt. lerman Juftice 
 
 !)clo, that tbe SDefcntiant ougbt to batjc 3!uDgcmcnt , bccaufe a pjftatc <itju» 
 
 rp as tb<s SLrcfpafa f0, ougljt to civc Inap to tbc pubHquc gcDO , viz. tl)c Dtf. 
 
 cotjcrp of iFelonp ; ano berc is a piibUque gmD intcnoco, ano it ougfjt to taUe 
 
 place of ttje pafntffs tnconliiocrable fn|urp. 0nD ftc fa(D tbat one map be 
 
 arrcCcofojJ^elonponlp upon Common fame, (ftljcrc be a fclonp com* 
 
 mtttcD: ;SDtbcrtoircftffltft|)crcbcnoiFclonp Done. Ask JuQice fafo tlje 
 
 Cafe wao batO on botft Coca. Buc the court gave ludgcraent for ihe PJaintif 
 
 except caufefhould be fticwnto the contrary, 
 
 Mich. J (^49. Banc, (up. 
 
 Toqiun. a T-T VTiid moved tbc Court tfjattbcreto^n ofa Habeas Corpus grantco 
 
 Ketornofa V V loa ccrtnin rtotcrs callcij the SDfggcrs that trcrc commlttco bp 
 
 Rtfcous. 3[.,njcc0of =pcaccnponftni)iiigthJ IRfot upon their tfcin mfglt be filco, 
 
 ii hith teas grantcD , upon tchfcb he mobeo that the pjffoners might be iitf« 
 
 tharfteo , but the Court commanuetj the rctojn to be reao , upon the rcan- 
 
 <ng ofit Wild tooh this exception, viz.2Cl;atthcpjlfoncr3 tucrc coiiimfttcD 
 
 contrarp to the Statute of H. 4. c, 7. foj bp that Statute the &her<f ought 
 
 tobcpicfentatthefint)fngof the I'^fot, tohfch toaa not fo here. W;!ker 
 
 hclD that the 3;nttlccoh'i5potoerbp the Statute tofthout the ^^ttUtoen^ 
 
 qufrcofthc3R<ot, anDtocommUthclRlotcrs. 5But Roll chief luflice fafo, 
 
 that there <s no unqnfrp maoc tnthfa carc,foj the Kfot <s fouuDuponthP 
 
 view. tj{c\t) , anD fo there nceos no crqufrp , ant) the Hccojo ought to be maoe up 
 
 Kecord. jjp (jjp tijjQ gutttces that hao the tteU), ano bp the Shcrtf, ano it ia not mane 
 
 bp them aa SuttkCB, but as 3!uDgcB jopncD toUhthe fehcrff bp the Statute, 
 
 $ JufllccB that fino alRtot map cfthcr bjfng fn the IRccojo fn Court propriis 
 
 manibus of thctr olpn acco jD , j map fcno ft fnto Court,a0 thcp hate cone 
 
 here. Ehc piffonero commfttco upon the ftrft l1cco?.o reao ( fo j there toere 
 
 Difchargf . ttoo h^rc rcao f n Court) toere baflco bt«t not of fchargci),although the retojti 
 
 Iras not gcot) , bccaufe the Court fafo ft toao not ufual to of fc^argc pjf ro« 
 
 ner0 at the flrft rcaofns of the cctojnj ifo j the otticr p?<roncr0, The Court 
 
 advifed« 
 
 BendiragainftOylc. 
 
 For a Pro'.i!- Micb. 1 649- Banc. fup. 
 
 bition to the 
 
 hiyo'trirJ"-"'' A i^JohfbfffoniDaspjapetttotheConrtofthe Commf fof oners of poUf« 
 rancc. jl\ cp foj sffutancc Hpott 3 furmlfe tt)at tticp pjocecocD there in tlje trpal 
 
 of
 
 Mich. 1649. 161 
 
 of tt>e ^ffurantc of a mans Hfc,tDWtb iuasfaiD to tc trpafaie at tbc Common A.in.ai.Le. 
 lato, as (t \»as befo; c tbc Statute maDc tljat crcrtco tl^at Court, as map fip= 
 peat bp tbe pjeamble of tl)c Statute. Rollihicf lufticefais, tftatt^c Sffu. 
 tance of tfte Ufe of a man fa not toft Wn tbe Statute of aiTutance, as ttjr SlU ' 
 fniance of a mans life upon tfte burfng of an office; but tbfs cafe to Different, 
 fo» t^e man toftofc Ufe <sl)cre affurco <s going to fca upon ^ertbanta af. 
 fafrs, ano Ws Ufe map be as tocH affureo , as tbe fafe return of t^e fljip be 
 goes fn. But let Councel be heard on botfi fides Wedncfday next ; but wee 
 will ftoy nothing in the interim. Poftea, 
 
 A/ich- 1(^49. Banc. luper. 
 
 Ai^ Slnfojmatfon faascrtfbHeb agafnff tfje 3inbabftants of t\ie SCotan J° *"'"'' " 
 ofBurmingham, foj not repafring Burmingham^b?<oge ; ttoo of tbe vVrdla *^'" 
 2DcfcnDants pleao to itfuc, anDatJcrntct\DasfoHnofojtbeminpaii«. 3f ' ' 
 toasmobcDfojtbeSDefenoants, thati^c. atto?ncp*a5cneral baD mtftahen 
 tbe Cb^iDfan name of one of tbe SDefenoants in bfs rcplfcation ; ano p^apco 
 tbat tbe IRecojD m<gbt be amenoeo bcfojc Bluogemcnt entreo, that tbe Amendment 
 SuDgcmcnt mapnotbcetromousbprcafon oftbfs mtffaUc. aCbc Court 
 anftoeren, BtingaCopy of the Record to u$ to advife upon ; but they faid 
 they did not fee how it could be amended, for that they conceived there was "** 
 noiffue joyned» 
 
 Hobbs againll Blancliard. 
 
 ;■ Mich. 1 549. Banc, fup» 
 
 Pafcb, io Car, rot, aao* 
 
 ntanchard b?ougbt an attfon of aCrefpasfn the Court at Norwitch agafnft 
 
 Hobbs,anDbaDat)etDtiianDajuogcmcnt. SCbeiE^cfcnoant bjougbt a-"">Torf. 
 toilt of CCttoj to tebctre tbe juogcment. 2Cbe rrroj afsjgneo teas , tbat ""^^ ' ^'"'^'- 
 tbe 3Iatp bab not foano tbe fffuc Jopnco ; foj tbc Iffue iopneo fa, de in* p,'s-"' '"" 
 jnria fua propria ablque tali caufa, ant) tbe 3Iurp babe founo not nuiltp Gtnc- 
 rallp. Panel of Councel toftb tbc 2DcfcnDant in tbc \v7tt of Ctroj fafo^tbat 
 tbc lurp bate founo tbe cffett of tbc (true, tbougbtbep bate not founo tbc 
 t)crptoo^DB, ano tbcrcfojc it fs groo cnongb, anObcdtcDFabjan &,;King. • 
 ftonstate, jiEiiz, anb Wingrave & Horaci his cafe 3 Car. CntrcO i Car, 
 rot, 6^2. Roll chief luftice anftoctcD, jBDbat tbc beroitt fouuD tbc fffue ar= 
 gumentattbelp onlp.ano not bitealp ; anb tbcrefojc it is not gmo. lerman Vcrd^# 
 luflicctoas of tbe fame opinion : and the ludgement was rcverfed, except ' 
 
 better caufc flicwn. 
 
 Carew againft Bawd. 
 
 Micfa«j($49. Banc.fap. 
 Trio* 24 Car. rot, 1607. 
 
 Demurrer to 
 
 CArew b;oBgbt an a(tionofttcq)asagafnft BawdCojcntting into We'i'''"?p^",' 
 grounb, ano taferng atoap a tcttain parcel of sCpnOt ffibe j^^fcnoant -^ anVaion 
 
 pleaoeooftrcfpifj.
 
 i68 Mich-i649 
 
 plcaacD tijat Ijc toac fErt)aiit unto tl)e llo:H» Moone, to^ toas a ilojo of t^ 
 |Darlfamcnt,aniJt^atl)ctoDia!)cJEpnnbp!)t3 Commano, ano tlafrng ftia 
 pjttitlEQc aoWa fcttant, not to be implcaDco : totljfcplca tbc piafntff dc= 
 murra, aim foj taiifc ftetos, tljat tbe Dcfcnuant Dot!) not fljcin tl)at be toae 
 
 Privilege. tt)c ILojD Monns iHcnJal fcr\)ant, aiiD attrnulng upon l)<3 pcrfon : ano it map 
 bcijc teas l)lfl Carter oj pioluman, anDftJChfcriDantsjarcnotpjttflcgcD^ 
 Koll chief luflicefafD, S!Ll)cp?(tUcgc<£5 nottlaiiiicDljcre marlp Qa\)is fcr- 
 tant; but l)CHi(I(fiC0l)eTC 80 l)(s rcrbant <n Defence of t)t9 Rafters title to 
 
 Wilvcr, t[)C%\mn, Uil)icl)l)Ct00k bpl)l!)COmmanD» But ler the Defendant plead m 
 
 Chief, and let the Plaincif waive the Demurrer : Orelfc let the Plaintif enter 
 liis fuggeftionupon the roll, thatthe Houlc of Lords ii now difToIved. andfo 
 let them take ilTue and go to tryal : Or elfe let the party plead what he wiU 
 upon record, and we will advife in the mean time. 
 
 Paroch- dq Haidingham verfus Paroch- de Briiley, 
 
 Mich, 1(549. Banc, fup. 
 
 For-qian„.g A _^o;iDerof&crsfonflmaDcfojtbcfetUngof apoj toomanlntbc pat(fii 
 
 Scfl^ sYo'* of Hardirghamliiaa tetnrncDbftbctbp a Certiorari granteo to tbc fato 
 
 the I'vil^e of V^^^^^ «•'•' upoiTttie return tcao, ano opening tiie Anattcr bp Councel , tftc ' 
 
 a Vagiaiic. cafc itiac tl)l0. ^n Inftabftant DUjclUng UjitUn tl)c part(& Of Brifley, c<D f)«re 
 
 a maiD fcruant fo; a pear, ano Co\JcnantcD to gtbc bcr iFo jtp lhtfl(hg0 foj. 
 
 Ijcr toagc0, ano cntertaintD bet Into bis ferbfcc, SCbc main fcrbant fome 
 
 time after fell fichfn bis fcrbfcE; bet jpattcrtbcrcuponturnoijer outofbfa 
 
 fertikr,irUbout gibing bet anptbing : tb^ maiD,fojnecefsttp,lntral3clllnQ 
 
 fromBnfley toiuajD Hardinglumtubctc b^t fr(enD0UbeD, ano ttbere fljc 
 
 ii)aobojn,tDa0fojceD to beg foj relief: lo^ctcupon fljctoaofentas a tiila« 
 
 jjrant to Hardinpham, lubcrc Qjc tuao bo jn. iSLbc tiliU of Hardingham fcno 
 
 bcr bach to Briflcy, fajbcre (be teas cntcttatneDaaaCobcnant ferbantt 
 
 tobcreupoR tbcp of Brifley pjocure an ojDct of fecfstons to fettle bet at Har- 
 
 dingharo. ^be ©ueftlon toaa, ^bctbcr tbt0 luere a gmo ojDer.oj not, fo j 
 
 fctllng ber at Hardmgham accojufng to tbc fetatntc ^ £Dj, lobetber (be 
 
 ougbt to be fetlcD at Briflcy, tDbete (be toaa entcrtatneD a0 a Coijcnant fer-- 
 
 tantanDturneDoutoffcrblcc, ano fojceo to facgg bp tbatmcan0. Roll 
 
 chief luftice fatQ, %W \ftxc fitms to be f '■auDtilcncp In tbe £©.ifti c to make 
 
 Vatranr. bifl fcrl'ant a Zdagrant, tbat fo bc map bc rto Of bcr ', but If one bcgg meat 
 
 ano D?lnfe. foj nctefattp, In pafsing betlrocn one 2DoUm ana anotbcr, 
 
 tbis (0 not begging to mahc one a brggar trlttjin tbc Statute. And there- 
 
 Sctleiiient. ^^""^ the Court ordered that the party fhould be Ictled at l^jfilcp, Where (he 
 
 was entertained for a Covenant fervan:, and not at i^atOingbaitl where fl»e 
 
 was born^ ifcaule were not {liewn to the contrary. 
 
 F'arwo:d againfi: Paty. 
 Mich. KJ49. Banc. fup. 
 
 Argument in "T l^z ctitc bcf Uiffin Harwood fliiD Patye toas agatu fpokcn unto, bp wild 
 rrtfi-jf^jwiie- I ofConnccltoltbtbepiafntif, tobcrclntbc ilflfon faettig an Slaton of 
 .hnT.thcsb 2C|.efpar0fojtaU<ngatoaptobcat,rpc,anDtt)a)D, upon an Elegit tahen out 
 txcen . c. gggj^jj g ^arfort, SCbB HDHCftlon lBa0. caibctbcr SCItbes arc ertcnoible 
 
 npon an Elegit bp tbe statute, 0; not f ano be bclo tbat tbepare not octeii- 
 Extent. Dlblc,firft bp tbc Common lato confirmco bp Mag.Charca tbep arc not crtcn. 
 
 Diblc. CooknponMagaaCbarta, 3.&N,Brev. 227. CltbCS arc marlp
 
 Mich. 1649. ~ ^p 
 
 Spiritual tWngs, ano ercmpt fro:n all l.ap conCocratfon, 1 1 Rep, 14, Pri- ' 
 
 die ann Nappers cafc. Cawdriescafe, 5 Rep. f. ij. 55 H. 5. ^p. tJjjjcre 
 rfjjbto of acitbeearc <n Birpute,tl)C Common ilato IhaM tahe place ; but not 
 
 tol^cre tbc jCftbes tljcmfcltes arc in OifpwtC ; Seldenj Hiftory of Tiihes, cap, 
 14. alp, SCfte Statute of WePmirftcr mabcg no nlteratfon of ttje Common 
 lato In t^f J point, ann non nfage fa a goiD argument to pjotjc <t j foj (f tbep 
 Ijao ban cytcnof blc, ft tnoulD fomitime oj ottjer^iatc been put in pjactfce ; 
 ano bp tlje ctpjcfs tooaoa of tljt Statute of Wcftm!nf>er, tljc 2D. SCftbes are 
 cjceptcD, anotbcpjoccrjufualipbefojctliatDtrcttcototbe JBffijop foj fe* 
 queftration, fs not tahen atoap bp tlje statute of s Ed. 3 . jj. N, Brev. : 6<J. 
 SCftoucft it be a free fjolD, pet is it not toltbln tbc fetatutc ; ano U ft be tolt^^ 
 In tl)cii)ojD0 of tl)e statute, petfsftnottoftfjfntftcmcanfnsofft, as Cook 
 apontbc&tat, ofWeOm. z.totbpjobe, 35 H. 5. jo. 9 E. 2. Clcrcp men 
 anttcntlptDerenotfncluDCD fn general acts of j^arlfamcnts , becaufe tbc 
 Cfturcl> ujas accomptcD as an 3nfant al loapes lefttifn age, ano fo faboureo ciergy 
 anD pjotcctcD bp 3iato» j^cicttbc late flJjofiiance of IparUanrcnt §at6 maoe 
 no alteration f n tbfs cafe > foj tl)c £)jeinance fiJtcRijpD not to punfft tbe 
 iparfons of Cburcftes, altboug!) ft Doe out IBfOjops of tftefr JBfCiopjfcfes ano 
 ofgnftfes. 2nD as to tbe ^Dbjectfon.SCbatff tbe JEltbcsftouln not be bcre 
 ettcnDffale,t|)eretpoulDbcafafler of jufffcc. Hanf^er, %:'^at onr cafc fs 
 out of tbe Common lato, upon tobftbi the rule, tbat ei;trao;Dfnarp courfes 
 are to be taken, ratljcr tfjan tbetc (boulD be a faflet of Jutttce , fs groanDeD, 
 Roll chief luftice fafD, tljat tbere are ttoo ©uctf ons fn tWs cafe, i » Wilt' 
 tber SEftfics arc toftbfn tbe fetatufe ^ alp, ?E3bctbcr no^u t'oat J5f(bops are 
 tabcn atoap bp tbe ^arUamcnt,tbe ^bertts :,Tap Icbp tbe Debt ot ttje Clergp 
 as tbe IBfOjops ufcD to Doe i ano 3 conccftie tbcp map, bp a levari facias, Lev«ri. 
 3But tbe great qucftfon fs, TOIbctbcr tbcEleijic Ipc ;> aino tbe Court fncUnco 
 It DfD. But you will argue it again,therefore we will deUver no opinion in it. ^^'i'^« 
 And the Court clearly held with Mr. &clDen, That Tithes are not due fttte 
 DftfnO; anddireded to fearch prefidents, if a Recognifance had ever been Tithes, 
 extended upon Tithes. 
 
 Cane againft Golding, 
 
 Mich, I ($4.9. Banc, fup» 
 
 CAoe bjongbt an 0ctfon upon tbe cafe agafnft Golding foj Oanb jfng Ws Arrcfi of 
 tftle.bpfpeahfngtbCfe U:OJDS,bfj.His right and title thrreanto is naught, ludpcment In 
 and I have a better title than he, 2Cbe JDlafntff baD abcrDfrt, SCbS JBDrfen*^" idionup- 
 fiantmobcofnarrcft of 3IuDgemcnt, tbat tbe toojDstocrcnotattfonable,"" J^ "/":' 
 Twifden of Counccl toftb tbe pafntff argucD tbat tbe toojDs are attionabU; ,hc piaimifs 
 fo? tbouab tH toojDs fpottcn of tbemfclbcs map not be actionable, pet berc c itic. 
 tbep are aUcgco to be fpolxcn i'alfo et malitiofe, anD tbat tofU mafee tbcm 
 aafonabic, 4? B. 5. f. 33, N. Br. 95. Hob. Rep. Water anD Freeraam Cafe.- 
 ana as to tbe £?bjc(tfon tbat in maoc, tbat tbe SDcclaration is onip quod fait 
 venfimilis vend ere, anD tbat be toas binocrcD bp tbe 'moiDg ; anD tbcrefojc 
 tbere might babe been no bargain maDc, tbotigb tbe iticr?Ds bao not been 
 fpoltcn: SCbc anftocr f 3, SCbat ftistoel! enougb fct fo^tbcoit tS; fo? aU 
 treaties opon Contracts arc but Ui;clp to pjocaeD, aiiD arc not certain till 
 tbe Contracts be raaoc ; but tobicb is moje, ft fs fattbir aUcgco bere , tbat 
 bpreafon of tbe fpeafefngoftbcfctoojosbecoulonotrcccfbe bisSTftbes, 
 tobicbfsanerpicrslors Hales fo? the Dcfcnoantarguco, tbat tbe inojos 
 oftbemiclbcsareiiotattionabU', altbotigSjtbepbcfafoto bcfpohcn fahbej 
 malitiofe, cicccpt a fpctfal Damage be allcgco to come to tbe part? ; fo? fucli 
 
 ^ feojbs
 
 ii70 . Mich. 1649. 
 
 toojOflaatftcfcDffftcfromtoojDstftatatcfpobenoft^ pctfon of a man-. 
 ;9no tbong!) tl)cre be Damage, pet tbcp are not fcanoalous ; fo j the 2?eferT- 
 DanttlahnsatUlcasjiucUafltbepIafntlf: anotbcfapfng t^at tl)c tDOjD0 
 tDcre fpobcn falfo & malitiofc, totl^ not maUc tijem tobc fo fpokctr, no? 
 mahcfl tbem artJonablc, <f t^cp be not fo fn tbemfelbc3» Roll chief lufticc 
 fafo,tl)crconal)ttobcafcanoalanDapartfc«latDama2cfetfojt^; but ft 
 (0 not fo ftere. But move it again Saturday nexr. Poftca» 
 
 Whice againfl: Holford- 
 
 Micbt i649» Banc, fup, 
 
 Trin,i649. rot. 1214, 
 
 Error ro re-" \ XMxit of Cttoj UHS bjottgtt upoH 8 SttDgemcnt Qittti fit m Sbiion of 
 
 vcrfe a jvuipc- j[\ gp^jj^ upon an £>blfgatfon to ttanu to an atuatn, anD tfte ©troj af- 
 
 met ... Debt gg„p^ ^^gg^ j^at t^g arbtttement crceeoeD tbc fubmlfsfon ; foj tl>e fubmff- 
 
 i.gnion" ' ' fiiJ" teas to aano to tlje atoato toncJifng aU matters In Djffctcntc bcttoecii 
 
 tbc partfCB, ano tljc aboaro tuas, tbat tbc parttcs fljall mafee general releafea 
 
 cacb to ot^ei of all Dcmanoo ; ano t^e toojo oemanOB.fo a toojo of a larger 
 
 fignlflcatfon tljan tfec toojo Differences. JBut Roll chief lufti.ce anf tuereo. 
 
 Award '^^^^ ^^^^^ rcleafe be moje large fn toojos, pet it ia am enoogft: fo? It fljall 
 
 be fntcnDCD onlp of all matters In Debate bctluecn t|)c parties , anD if tl^ere 
 
 be otber matters, poti oiigW to tjatie (beton tbcmfn plcaDfng, otbcrtof fe t!)C 
 
 Court toil! not inteno tbere are anp; to tDl)icl) tljc otfter 3I"Dges agrecD, and 
 
 ga^ve judgement for the Plaintif, except better matter ftiould be (hewn. 
 
 Brooke againft Brooke. 
 
 Mich. I ($49. Banc. fup. 
 
 M'ch. 24 Car, rot, 2 87. 
 
 Ejror to t(- "DRook bjOUfibf art Hctfoit Of ttcfpafs quare claufum frcgit,? foj caffng of h(3 
 vcrfc 3 judpe- *-> gjafg juftj) Cattcl, «. flgainft Brooke ; lapon ^ot guiltp pleaoeo, an if- 
 '"V"^ '"i7c '" f"c ^^^ iopneo, anD tb^ ?9laintif bao a tieroict ano a juDgement. SCfte We- 
 dauru?n"fre., fenDant bjougbtatoiftofCErrojtoreberfetbisBItiDgement, ano afsfgnea 
 i". fojCrtoj.tbnttliCiDcclarationUjasfncertain; foi tbe painttf Declares 
 
 of y?caWng bis Clofc, anD eating bis grafs, cum qmbufdam a vcriis, anD Dot!) 
 notfaptehatCattel; anD fo be map recover Damages in this action, ana 
 bjing anotbcr action fo j tbe fame trcfpafs, bccaufe it cannot be fenoton tobat 
 T-irr. CattelDiotbe fojmcr trefpafs, Hdes of Councel toithtbe IDefcnDant, 
 
 A vci mer.t. fgjg (j,,; SDeclaration tag gcoD enongb ; fo?. it is gcoD in fobftancc , altbougb 
 It migbt babe been better fn fo?m, anD ft being after a berDict,tbe incertafntp 
 is bclpeo. SlnD tbe Sr>cfcnDant, if tbe paintif fboulo faiing a ncto action fo? 
 tbis trefpafs, map pleaD bp abcrmcnt that be batb fatlsficD tbe ttcfpafs Don 
 alreaDp,anDaberU)itbtDbatCattel it teas Done. Jcrman luftice faio, tbe 
 bcntts ongbt to be namcD partictilarip ; fo? averia is a large toojD , anD fig' 
 nificscatfclofoivicrsWtiDs; anD it is tm general a too:D to Declare upon. 
 315ut Roll chief IuniceanftDcrcD,iDbcrc tbe tbing it fclfisin DemanD, ano 
 an action is b jougbt fo j ft, as it is fn an action of trobcr ano conbcrCon , tb« 
 tbing ougbt to be particularlp namco ; but bcre tbe action is b?ougbt fo? Da- 
 mages fo? b?eaHing bis Clol^e, ana eating bis grafs. Hno if pou bao De= 
 n.mnrrer OTHtteD to tbe iEE)eclar?»tion, ft bao not been a gcno gJemurtet ; but noU) it fs 
 
 Demurrer. ^^^^^
 
 Mich. 1649. 17! 
 
 aftctamcrm'cttoWctjmaikesttffrongctagamft tl)c SDefcnoant Nicholas- 
 ano Ask jufticcs concutrcD tufttj Roll , To the ludgereenc was alfirmtd. 
 
 Mich, 1(4^. Banc. flip. 
 
 T~^cCuurtlna0mot}CDfojap?ol5fI)fttonfo tfjc 0om{ra'.tp upon a {ux--!^"^ '^'■°\'" 
 ^ mtfc tbat one teas arreftco tijcrc foj rcfcufitg one out of tl)C l)anDD of a A^mi'rluy "^ 
 S^ctfengec of tftc aiomttaltp , toljo itaa taben Op l)fm bv t!)c toarrant of tfje 
 <Doutt,foj a contempt to the Court in a ftite Dcpcnc<ng there bcttrf vt \)im am comcmpr. 
 anottier. Roll chienufticeanfU:icrcD,ff the caiifetDerctnarUfnciDhfch teas 
 i3cpeno<n5,tberc the Court map ejrammc a contempt to the Court (n that 
 caufc, but the? cannot pjockd crjmlnallp agafnft the partp that refcucD 
 Witt that titO the contempt. TliereForc give them notice that they (hew caufe 
 why we fliould not grant a Prohibition. „ . , . 
 
 ■' ° Proh.bition, 
 
 Ireland againft Michelborn. 
 
 Mich. i<J49, Banc. fup. 
 Pntred Mich. 24 Car» ror» 1 1 1. 
 
 IV Jlchelbornbjoughtan miction of SCtcfpafa agafnft Ireland ; quare vi ^""^ '? ■■'• 
 iVJetarmisclaufumfuumfregit, anDfOjUMtjfnGanO bcatfng hfs Cattcl;"^'^'^ ■ 'x^V 
 %\it platntff haD a ^ungement; the SDcfenoant b?ought hfatojft of CErtoj 'pi^\Tii a,- ' 
 tore\jerreth<s31«D0cmcnt. 2Chc CBrtojB afsfgncD tocrc, i. SChat <t ap-mis. 
 
 pears not bp the Continuandohoto long the 2Ctcfpaf0contfnuco.2lp.2Chcrc 
 
 is a tifconttnuance to part of the plea , ann a Departure alfo. Windham in 
 
 anftocc to the firC Crccptfon fato , that ft {0 diverfis diebus et vicibus, ann it °''"''°"''"'^* 
 
 fstofthout anufque, anuthccontfnnancefflbutfn aggrabattonoftheS.ref/""* 
 
 pafs ano the StdfonU felf fg foj the firtt JCrefpafs , toljfch ia the ojfgfnal , 
 
 ano the diverfii diebus et vicibus fiiall bc fntcnticD befojc the 51ctton bjought! 
 
 26 '.6»f. 15.35H. <$.f.4- Hob. rep. 377. antj the partp map toell enough 
 
 atjerr in another 0ct(on bjought fo; this SCrcfpafa that the fDlafntff hatj xc-. 
 
 tot)crcDfo?<t in an actfonfojmcrlp bjought, anofoj the nelu nfswnmcnt 
 
 \ft rafo ft teas but as a neto 2Declaratfon. 315ut the Court bf d the EDcfcnoant 
 
 In the tDjft of (Erroj aotiffe conccrnfng the fcconu occeptfon. Roll chief lu- 
 
 ftice fafD , he beUetcD the cafe cftcD out of.Hobard teas not tocB pjfnteo, but 
 
 fomethfng left out:foj ft hath been rulco that after a tjerDftf ft fc gtco enouglj 
 
 tofap, oiichaofmpjffoncuMmtojalongtfme; but here fo a Blungement 
 
 upon a nihil dicit , tohfchMl alter the Cafe. lerroan ?oftice fafo , "ft teas 
 
 conCocrablc, ano fit to be auuf fcD on. Holhead of Councel tofth ths plafn^ 
 
 tf f f n the tojft of Crro J took another erceptfon, viz. that there teas an flTae 
 
 jopncD as to the beatfng of the Cattel , anu that fs not trpeo noj contfnueo , 
 
 ano pet Damages are gltjcn entftc foj the chafing ano beatfng of the 
 
 Cattel. . • 
 
 ■Z 3 Harrif
 
 i72> Mich- ^^'^9j-_ 
 
 Harris againft Gibbons. 
 
 Mich. t6'i,9> Banc, fup, 
 
 Pafch. 1(549, rot. 303. 
 
 Error tore- /'^Ibbons bjoujjljt ail 0tfion upon tftc Cafc acaJntt Harris upon an A:. 
 
 vrrfe a jddgc- v.jrumprit, 800 DcclntcD tliat t^c SDcfcnDaut , tn tonOoeration tbat tljc 
 
 n>nK in an piatiitif fi'OulD Ict tJiito tljcDcfcnoaiit 8 loootl) in Sturbridge.fair^ofDaffume 
 
 Aai ,n on ti c 5 pjoHiifc to pap tl)c plaliitlf ten pounD fo j tl)C fame, anD to pap ttj: piafntf f 
 
 '^' foj all fticl) ?K3fnc anu Ipopo as ftoulD be fpent (n tl)cl5(Dtb During t^e jTaIr, 
 
 2Cbe |3Iatnttf bao a Cl crotfl ano a Suogcmcnt . 2Ll)C SDefcnoant b jougbt a 
 
 iDjIt of Crro; to retwfc tijfc 3;uDncincnt , ano afotttncD tl)(s Crro; , tljat ft 
 
 BfD not appear iA tljc SDcclatatfon tl)at t^c fait Vuas enueo toben tbc ;a£tlon 
 
 Icao b?oufll)t . antj confctjuentlp ttjat tl]cte toas caiifc of 3£tJon. 315at i wif- 
 
 dcn of Ccunccl toitt) tl)c SDefcnoant in tbc to jit of Ctro j fafD , it fl)aB be in- 
 
 tcnocD it toas cnoeD ; foj tiic ftanoins tl)crc During tftc J^air is tbe caufe of 
 
 brciaratioi). Action. Roll chief luRice tooK anotftcr cjception. JE^at tbc SDeclatatioti 
 
 Ko;ke. ' tjotb notrrpjefc tbat tljcpiaintifgaDe notice l)oto mucb Mine ano ?^op3 
 
 be laio into tbclBootl) During tbciTait, nojtbatbc maoe anp Demano of 
 
 tbcpapmcntofanp fumof inoncp Due, ano fo tbe SDcfenoant couId not 
 
 fenoto boto mncli monep be QjouId pap, ano tbcrcfojc tbc SDcclaration is not 
 
 jrmO, bccaufe it is tro general. Therefore advife whether you will maintain ic 
 
 or no , and becaufe the Councel defired not to be farther heard in ic , the 
 
 ludgement was reveri'ed, 
 
 Id'ich- 16^^. Banc, fup- 
 
 Arrtft of A i? Action ofdolicnantlnasbjouobt upon an 3lnDenfute foj tbc pap- 
 ludgrmcntiu XAmcnt Of 3 ccTtatn fum of moncp at 3 certain time. Ebe SDcfenoant 
 an sttion o{ piraDcDpapmcntattbctimc, anbtipon this an iffuc teas jopnen, anD a 
 Covenant. '^tjerDict fouuD fo? the DcfcnDanf : 2Ebc piaintif motcD in arrcff of 3iuDge« 
 inent,anD aUcgeD fo; caufe tbat tbe S^^uc toas mif.jopneD, becaufe tbc place 
 oftbepapmcnt teas not allegcD, ub^cb is material, anD fo there can be 
 no 3iuDgemcnt, MaynardfojtbeSDefenDantmotJCD foj SuDgement, ana 
 TaiD tbat tbc iCTue tuas tocU iopncD , anD tbat it toas not material to aUege 
 tbc place of papmcnt . becaufe it is a pcrfonal action , ano tbe place flian be 
 fntcnocD tobcrc tbc ^aiow h b:ought , i E-s , f.3 . 0nD bcrc be cannot allege 
 • an immaterial place , anD fo it mutt ncccffarilp be intcnDco to bc'U)bere tbe 
 
 Slttionisbjougbt. Roll chiefluflice,3f PDUiDiUargueitputftin tbe |pa= 
 per. Due there is a difference between finding chc money paid, and the find- 
 ing it not paid, 
 
 • Denoir. againft Oyle. 
 
 Mich, 1 649, Banc. fup» 
 
 For a Prolii- 
 
 CcmVof ^po V^"*" ^ ^'^"^^ fojmcrlp maoe in tbf0 cafc to Ibcto caufe fcbpa pjobibitfon 
 Ik) hi aiiu- IboulD not be granted to tbe CDourt of |9olicp fo j affuranccs Hales opcr 
 r»nce. ncD tbccafc,as fojmcilpbaD ban Done, ano pjapa tijat tbcre map be a 
 
 J0jobf«
 
 Mich- i<^49. 175 
 
 lpjoliib(tioiierantcD,bfcaiifc t!)C partp map Ijabc rcmetp fierc ae tecB as in 
 that Court, ano fo tb(iJ Court cuaftt to be p?cfErrci>;antt!)c contract bcrc 
 Ijatt) no rclatfon to mcrchatiDijing: , ano fo it Dot!) not p;3pcrlp belong to 
 that Court. Serjeant Glyn of Connccl uiftf) t^c JDefennant pjapea that 
 tl)crcmlel)tbcnop:ol)ibttfongrnntcD, bccanfcjt!j3t!)not ban Uno^tn tliat 
 ctjcrfucbapjobibuionuascrantca, anolicrctfteatlje statute mauc fov 
 airurancc0of45 Eliz, anofafotWaCafcitias liift!}{n tbat Statute, a.iu fa 
 to be trpeobptlje Court of poltcp, anotftat tWs cafe Dotlj piopcvlp con- 
 cern mertljanDf jing , anD (a toftljfn bot!) t !C ^Letter ano rcafon of tije llaui. 
 0nD bp tlje iuojDB of tbe polfcp ft appears plafnlp tbat tljc Contract concerns 
 inercfjanDf jfns,i tlje partpougftt not noi» to fuggctt tftc contrarp agflfnft his 
 oUjntoojDfl fn t^e poltcp. Roll chief IuniccfafD,tl)Ctoo:t)s of tlje poltcp 
 arcnotmatcrfal, fo? tbe iDo;t)0 mapbefalfc, ano tbc Contract map bs 
 foj things not toucljfng mcrc!)anof5fns nottoftfjCanofng , ano tbe fntrnt 
 of tftc statute ie foj tbfngs mercbantaWe , ano ff ft appear tbcp be 
 not fo, a pioI)fbftfon ougbt to be grantco. Scrjeanr G!yn rcplpeo, lljat tfte p^^j^ j^; ;^ 
 tjopaBCDEpcnocD upon tbesUfl of tlje partp , tcljofe life toasalTureo bpt^e '°' "'**"' 
 poltcp, annaltljougfttlje partp tDcrefnocbtED, anDtfjcrefajerc fecurftpgf- 
 tjenbpbaflfojftfstjcbt, totl)cfntentbe mfg^t goe tfje topage, pet tWs 
 is tDitl)fn tfte atatutc. Roll chief luftice anficcrcD , SLbfs fs a far 
 fcttb'D conflructfon , ann toe cannot atofo tlie granting of a p?ol[)fbftfon, but 
 6 jatD tl;c fiiggeftfon ano Dclftfer ft on Monday ncrt , ano jopn fffuc ana trp M 
 
 IttWstcrm. SEbeCafcfn tDbicbtfetspjobibftfonUjaBmoteDfojanD gran« ^ 
 
 tcD teas tbfs, Denoir and Oyle tocrc baflcD fo j one Captafn Parr (taitjofe life 
 tuafl affureo bp ttic polfcp ) fn a fute agafntt Wm fn tl)c ilomfraltp bjoagftt AiTuranec; 
 tp one Buftiel foj TOO !. foj frafgbt one bp Parr unto !)fm , anD upoti tbat 
 Parr l)atfnB part fn a plantation fn tbc Barbadoes , ant) a quarter part fn t^e 
 flifptjetDas tomafee bfatiopage, ano Ijfs If fe toa0 affureo bp Denoir ant> 
 OyiciteliotocrcWsi ban. 
 
 Wefton againft Plowden. 
 
 Micb. 1^49' Banc, fop, 
 
 Ror. 505. 
 
 'T'^^c Court tuas motet) fo? time fo? &fr Edmund PJowden tftcSDefcn* ^ . 
 -■- uanttoplcaD, becanfe tl)c pafntff fjao becIarcD againft f)fmfap tl)e pic'^d™* ^° 
 itamc o!&fr Edmund Plowden iinfglit, toftcreaobefc bp Creatfon Count 
 ^alatf ne of Nova Albion, ano t^at is note part of \)is name, ano ic muft aU 
 fo pleao a fpetfal plea. Roll chief luflice anfincrco, l)e is alfo calleo a Count 
 Oflreland,anoneftl)crtbconcno?tl)eotberf0partof Ijfgname, as is fug. 
 gcffeo; ano tberefojeffpoutofll pleao fn Cftfcf tabc a inaks tfmc mo^c 
 fo? ft ; otftertoffc pleao at pour pttfl; fo? a Count J9alatfnc of Nova Albion 
 0? a Count of lreland,ate not aooftfons fn England, 
 
 Aduition, 
 
 Mich 1649. Banc. fiip. 
 
 AiDDt(tfontDasp?ef0nteofo Commffsfonero of fectocrs acafnft oncSr^o? 
 fojobftructfnganabfgablcmfbcr, ano p?apco tSat tbe CommffBio^Commiffio- 
 ttcrstoOHlo remote tl)? obfttuctfon0 J upon tobfct) an jOjoet luas maoc bp ««"'>* scw- 
 
 2 3 iW'
 
 i74 < Mich. 1649, 
 
 tbeCommifeionerstomahcatictD, anDto ccrtige tibe matter to tl^em, 
 nm upon tl)i3 certificate a 3l«rp \ras rcturnco to enquire of tbc ntifance, ann 
 aticrcia VDagn(iicnbptbc3lurpupon0rt<clesp;cfcnteo unto tl)cnt to en= 
 quite of it, a^Ws £)}tct of tl)c Commifsfoncro, ano t^ie pjocauings tl)ctc« 
 upon tocretemotieBbitftetbp a Certiorari ; anotljcfeeircEptions lucre ta- 
 hen upon rcaetng of tfte return, i . SCbat it ootl) not appear bp Icljat ant^o. 
 ritp tlje Commlfsfoncrs DID fit, 2. acije pjefentmcnt maDe toaa not gcoa , 
 foj It (3 fatD tljat anticntlp tlje ritcr toao fo anD fo, ano tl)fs fo tncertafn. 3lp» 
 SEljc pjcfentnicnt is, tljat t^ep hnoUj not tobcn tlje f^fll icaa maoe , toft(clj 
 fo fuppofcD to bt an obttructfon ; anD ft tbe ^lU tocre mate bcponD time of 
 tijeraemojp ofman,tl)c CommifsioncrsljancnopotDetto enquire concern-- 
 tngit. Roll chief lultice, Givenoticc to the Councel for the Coinmiilio* 
 ners of Sewers to anfwer the exceptions CTcDncfDap next. 
 
 Shayleragainft Bigg- 
 Mich. 1649, Banc, fup* 
 Mich, 24 Car. rot. 90. 
 
 w, it of Error r\ Igg bjousbt an action of 2Cro!)er anD Conbetiion of a ?^o jfc , anD 6ao 
 
 ir-i.pht by |< a taerDirtanoa 3!uD0cment, SCf)cbailfo;tiie SDefcnoantin tljcifai- 
 
 ih. bai!. JL> p„ bjoual)t a Iv^it of Grro; to retjctfc tfitg 3«Dsemcnt gibcn agaiiift 
 
 tljc pjittcipal.' 2Cbe Court teas molJcD to abate tl)e tojit: SEbc Coart an- 
 
 ftoereD, IfthctojitofCrrojbcbjougljtHpontbepjiHcfpal SuDgcment it 
 
 oug^t to be abatcD. Sit batft been a queCfon bcrctofoje , U)bet{)cr a tu?it of 
 
 r cErro;b?ougbtnpontt)epjintipal SnDgcmcnt, anD alfo upon t^c ^uDgc- 
 
 ' " ■ ment gitjcn againft tl)c bail togetljet be codd in part, anD ill fo j oti&er part. 
 
 3Eut of later times it tjatb been rulcD tl)at it ougljt to abate foj all. There* 
 
 fore let the party (hew caufe why the writ ftiall not be abated here, 
 
 Mich. i64p- Banc {up. 
 
 For quin.ineT^^ Court toas moljco to quaCb 30 dEnoictmcnf foj a fojciblc dSnfrp,' 
 an Eiui'tt- uport t!}efe (l£rccption0. i. %\)c partp fiat!) maDe no title, :lp. aCfte 
 
 met. CnDfctmcntisnot faiDtobefounDbptl)e3»rp, bat bp tljc Suffices, jlp, 
 
 3t Dotl) not Tap tbat t!)e fo?cc toas contra pacem publlcam , as tfje late Sid of 
 parliament Directs , but contra pacem reipublics. The Court anfwered , 
 it ws$ a foul riot, and defcrved no favour , yet the Endiftnient was quafhed 
 opon the i and 3 exceptions. 
 
 Del! againft Brown- 
 Mich, I C)49. Banc.fup. 
 
 ^" ■ Tl^'^^" bjougbt an Hctfon of Erefpafa againffDell in tbc Common 
 J-^Peas, foj taking atoap tl)jee Coicca, ana hao 31aDgcment,a'- 
 gatnft Urn upon a nihil dicit. acije SDefcnoant b?ougl)t a tnjit of C-tco?*fit 
 tbis Court to reberfe tlje ^nogemcnt, 2Lfte €rro j afsfgneo ioae , tbat fo j 
 
 hnirc <^am» tjj,Qj,f(jjp^Q^jjPj3^jjpyj.|jjg0„p l3aj(,p ijjjijjrcj)^ auD pet entire Damages 
 
 ^''' lucre giben foj tljem all, icljic^ teas not gooD, RqII Chief luflice, This is a 
 
 ludgc-
 
 Mich. \649' 175 
 
 ludgcmcnt upon a Nihil dicir, and fo there is noVerdidto help it. Poftca 
 
 Barber againft Pomcroy. 
 
 Micb« 1649. Banct (up. 
 Entrcd Hill. 24 dr. rot. j jj, or icjjy* 
 
 BArber bjotig^t an 0ct{oii of Debt agalnft Pomeroy fo j artcragcs of tent Arrcd , f 
 Due foj 7. pcato, ano fo? 7. Capons ; tbc JDcfcnonnt pleaocD nil debet; juJpenicnt m 
 upon tb<fl an fffue toass jopnsD, ano a UctDtct foiino fo; tbc piatntif; tlje ]"'^''"^ =f 
 JDefcnDant ntotjcD <n attcft of IiiDgcmcnt, ano toU tbfs crccptton, tbat tbe ^''^ "'"• 
 |9la<nUfof^fsotonfl)eti)fngbaDDemanDCDmojc tbanitascuc, ? foougbt 
 not to fjatjE 31uDgcmcnt. Cbc fJuettton here iras, C<ai)ctl)et the platnttf 
 jnfght not rcUnquffl) tljat part tohfch ia not Due, anb hate tuogement fo j fo „ 
 much ac{0 Due ;> Yard of Councfcl iBtththepahitKhelD that ho mfght„5^„"'^"''^" 
 aaocttcoGodfryescafe, II Rep, f. 55, b. ano Hubbards cafe, 4 Rep, ano' 
 pjapeD foj SluDgemcnt, Twifden of Councel on the other ft'De, pjapeo 
 juDgement mfght not be gitjcn, ano he agreeo the cafes cfteD bp Yard, ano 
 citeo other cafes of the fame nature, uhcretlie pafnttfmap rcleafe part, 
 anD babe 3uDgemcnt foj the rctt. IBut he fafo, that here the thing in entire 
 ano cannot be appojt{oneD,foj then he (hall fallific hfs olnn Vojlt, i Ed.4.34. 
 315ut Roll thief luftice helD, that the reUnquflhing of part is not the falfifping , 
 ofh<sotontD?ft, although the thfng DemanocD be entfic; foj be map aso;"'*";, 
 toeUtelcafe after the tD?itbjOHght, as before; ano there Iras no qucttfon ' 
 
 Ijut he mfght hate releafeD part befoje, anohcma^ releafe tohcre therein 
 antUDemanD, as toell as toherc a DemanD is gmo. jerman luftice hclD, 
 that luDgcmcnt ought not to be gfbcn ; foj^ he faf o, that the reafons of the' 
 cafes citcD, are not UUc to the reafon of thffl cafe ; foj Ijerc the tterDfct is not 
 glben foj the fame fum tohlch is oemanoeo, ano ft ootb appear that here fo 
 an unjuft DemanD, anD it (sWsoton fault : anD if the Defcnoant haD dc- 
 murreD upon the JDcclaration, it VuouId habc been aDiuogcn no gcoD JSDecla^ 
 ration. 115ut Nicholas anD Ask Iuftices,agreeD Inith Roll chief fuRlce, and 
 io judgement was given for the Plaintif, except better matter (hould be fhewn 
 on Saturday next, 
 
 Avery againft Kirton. 
 
 Mich, 1^49, Banc, fup, 
 Mich, 231 Car, rot. 239. 
 
 Kirton biought an Action oftrefpafsagainff Avery, anDDeclareD iipon^"^""^ "P'"' 
 an ejfpinal, fo; impjffoning him till he entrcD into a bono of 600 J, up . J-"^'-^';-"^ '^ 
 on i;5ot gailtp plcaoeD, tbe painti^ haD a bcrDict anD a juoaement. scbc '' *" 
 SDcfenDant bjought a U)?it of Crro?, anD upon the Certiorarlto remote the 
 3K CCOjD, tljc IRccojD teas crrtffieO, anD in nuiio erratum plcaoeD, but the o> 
 rigiiialinthclRcca^^ocertificDVEas, that the 5r>cfcnDant hept the plaituif 
 <fip;<fcntilheentreDfnt0 2.bonD5 of ^00 1, a piece, Vuhcreas the rtnbt 0- 
 riginal hma till be entren into one bonD of 600 1. ttihcrctipon thcpartp 
 brought a nem Unit of CErro?, ano bpthat, hao the true ojiginal ccrtifico', 
 ffihc Councel fojthe SDcfenDantinthelsjitofCrrojfaio, SChat o;iiTin.".l 
 alter ojiginal map as toellbcccrtfacD befojeinnullo eit erratum plcawo. ccrrScatt. 
 
 80
 
 i76 Mich. 1649- 
 
 80 aftcttoat!] ; bnt lieic t^ partrrs arc at ffftic, anot^c firff original is cct< 
 tfficD, ant) ifftic jopnco upon that, ano tbctc cannot be a ti^ ojtnfnal certf. 
 fi:D; anDtl)eo;fofnall)crcootb not agree toitbt!)C otbcr parts of t^c He. 
 co^ii), ano To cannot fuppo^tft, ant) out oUginalccTtfgcDaanDs uft^be 
 5Reco;D, ano bcre is no Certiorari to toananttbc o;l2inal licrc cctttfieo, 
 ano <t is a matedal tarfance, 3 lac. Banc. Reg. Cummins cafe, 9 H. ^ . t.3 8» 
 Pafcb. 1649. Kedpwinscafc. Yard on tbc ot!)cr fioc anflcereo, tf)at noto 
 t^co;if2inalf£)ccTtffiet),anD is before pou in tbis Court, ano pou ongbt to 
 InDge as it is, ano not as it ongbt to be ; anb it is agreeing tsit^ tbe fo^imcr 
 pjoccfs. .3ni» botbtliE ojiginals toerc bcfojc tbc E)cdaration, ano tftc 
 Conrt ibaU take ttjc ricbt original, ano tbc otbct (ball te intenoco foj ano-- 
 tbec caufe. Roll chief lu(>ice fain, 2Ube Certiorari is general, anD not inuc 
 partes pracdiS, bat ttjC certificate is inter partes praedift, SUlU tbe <Ioatt 
 maptahctberiEl)to;igtnalt})atiscertifict),anD tbcjutiscs are not boono 
 bp tI)C plea in nuilo eft erratum tbat is pleaDCD, bat map grant a netn jigf- 
 nal toiit of Crroj, but tlje partp cannot reqaite it, foj be isconclar)eo bp Ws 
 df}%\n>). otonplea; ano it ^eotrcontinuetia original, be map bate a ncto, bat not if 
 Ccftiorasi. ^^ pieao , ano tbc Certiorari is gooD ^ ano \ijeB ccrtifiw, anni tberefoje 
 Jaogcmcnt ougbt to be affirmeo. icrman, Nicholas, ano A-k to tbc fame ef- 
 fect; andfo judgement was affirmed, except better niaccerfhould be (hewed 
 Saturday nexCt 
 
 Ratcliff and Dudeny. 
 
 Mich. 1^49, Banc^fop^ 
 
 Entred Hill, 13 Car, rot, 3^9, 
 
 Aqucftion IT 7^onafpecialDcttiict,tftccaretDa3tbi3, SL leafc ofaboofcanD lanas 
 
 Er ov" » tDasmaoctoIS.fo}99pears,tbcrcmafnoertoiD.fo;99pear3, tiiE 
 
 upon a fpcciai ccmainDcr to A. B. foj 99 pears ; pjotiiDeo, tbat if tbe Icffees Doe not inba. 
 
 vodia. bit in tbe bonfe let During tije tobole term, tbat tben tbe leafe (ball be tioio, 
 
 Stbe queflion bcre tDas,!^olD long tbe leffees trerc boano to inbabit in tbe 
 
 boaic «• ubctbcr fo j tbe fiVft 99 pears :> 0; fo? tbat term, 1 alfo During all tbe 
 
 ipcars in rcmainoet ^ ano lobic^ of tbe lelTees toete to inbabit :> Windham 
 
 ^clD,tbat tbe ttoo grff leCTecs onlp ongbt to inbabit During tbe firlt 99 pears, 
 
 anD no longer, 3Bat Roll chief luftice belD, tbat tbofeintbc remainDct 
 
 toere not bounD to inbabit befojc tbe remainoer falls to tbem ; bat reddcn- 
 
 dendo finguUfiiigulittbep ongbt to inbabit fuccefsitelp one after anotber* 
 
 ;gnDbetoDbanc);ceptiontotbetierD{(t. Cbat tbe leafc being to begin aftet 
 
 tbe Death of one Robert Dudeny, it DiD not finD tbat Robert tuas Deao, ano 
 
 fo it appears not tbat tbe leafe is pet began ; anD fo tberc can be no queffion 
 
 Venire. CirrcD as pet : and thereupon tbe cafe was not argued, but a vjenite faciaa 
 
 De nobo was to iiTue, becaofe the (pecial verdiS was imperfed. 
 
 Cane againftGolding- 
 
 Micb, i64p. Banc, fup, 
 
 opmion of — - ^jg 'jgfg^ foamctlp fpofecn to anD argueo , being an action of tbe "cafe 
 Lponan^a'. ' foj flanDering tbc ipiaintifs titlc, toasnoU) fpokcu to tjp tbe ^uogcs: 
 r.it . f ludge. 2nO firlt bp Roll chief luftice, Ubo belD tbat tbe action Dio not Ipe, altbongb 
 nicnt in *n ft bc alUgeD tbat tbc IroiDs iDEre fpoben f<lfo et malitiofc ; foj tbe l^iaintif 
 Aa;on of the j,j,-j^j J,, jjjg^j a ^^^^^^^ ^^yfg . 35^ j^gt ^^ ^^j^j^t map fupplp, S5ut tbe 
 
 ''^'- * flaintif
 
 Mich. 1649. i-y-y 
 
 ^tiitff ougl)t aifo to I)rtUc (IjcSijcc a rp;tjnl camaje, ti^H: tiatft not doit, 
 aiTD tljfs tlje Ijerofct cannot fappip, 2^^ JDcclaratfon fierc is ica general , 
 upon iD'jfcl) no gcoo ftftje crn be jopnco : auD lie oiinfit to balj; allege B, tliat 
 tJjerc tijas a coinintinfcatton bao bcfojcllj: i-oojoc fpolien toi;c!ji;ig t'jc fxilc cafr ' 
 oftbe lanD3 'ajtjercof t!)C title toao fiaiiDcrco, um tfeat 'jpfpsal-fngof tbcnr, 
 tftcfalcteasbfnDjcD, atiDbccltsoij lac. TucranoB.iilvescaf?, B. R. &ax 
 lac. Dodor Edwards ano Bill;, cafe, an^4Car. Roe anO Harwoods csfe, a 
 Judgement in it in Windfor Court,ani3 rcl>crfco ftctc : ani3 1 1 Jac Sell ait^ 
 Paryes cafe, B. R. lernian lufticeto tl)C fame effect : anD'gs fafQ, t^iat tljcrc 
 oasui to be damnum cc injunaaUcgcotomafntafn tbc SLCicn ; fo:enBlcitlj= 
 out tl)c otber is not euougfj, ano Ijcre Dot!) not appear anj.' oamfrrc, fjcceufe 
 tbcrcappcarcnocommumcatioiioffclimgoftbc laao, Nkhoias ano Ask 
 lullioes of t^c fame opinion ; &o tl^ rule toas, Nil capiat per biiUn?, csctpt 
 better caufe fhewn. Roll luflice fatO, tlj.lt tbcrc 13 digitus Dei (« t^C cafe ; 
 to? t&ctc luao a ffrancc tctofct founD. 
 
 Mich. 1649. -Banc, f.ip. 
 
 Court snlwered, You muft plead your privilege if it be I'u ; for wc cannot take cd. 
 notice cfit upon amotion. Piiviltge. 
 
 Noitcc. 
 
 Ridley an J Cmerron. 
 
 1649. Banc, fup. 
 Pafch* 24 Car. rot. 400, 
 
 J^i 
 
 je cafe bettnccit Ridley ano Emerfon teas again fpoI-;cii unto. Kt Iras '^'?".'^':"t '" 
 infllujitofCJtrojtorcfcerfca Juogcmcntflttcn in m ^(Xion 0: ocbt 'or^ rcvcrfe 
 itpon ail £)blfBation in tfte Common pcac. SCIjc Conoition of tbc £)blt'a lu-isemcnc 
 aatfon teas, ttjat tljz 2DcfenDant (bonlD not put cattcl upon a (Tommoir, ti?. '=> ''^'" upon 
 kanfora Moor, bcfo;ctt)ep?oof ano trpal of tl)e title oftljc Common tocrc'"' o:^;igaii- 
 biD. 2Ct)c Dcfenoant plcaccn, tbat Ijc did not pntfntjis Cattcl. Eftc "" 
 IpiEtntif replfcD, tbat t!)c JDcfcntjant DtDcut tb?tc ^arestljcre bcfoje tfec 
 pjoof oj trpal, ^nerccptiontoag taken, tljat tl)crr{3 tnttaucc bettoeeti 
 tftc lacplication ano Kclopnoer, ano tlje Conoftion of t!)c iDbligation , aoD ^^ j^^,^. 
 foftfs notgooo. Twifdencf Comtcclon t'ocotl)crSioc, Ijclo tfjat it toaci ^''^^ "' 
 cooDcnoiigi)UDtiDttl)aa:;CtnSj becaiifcitisaftcratjcrijict, ano t'jcrc io a 
 gooDiffuc jopntD. Hoihcad on tfte Contrary ftclo it ill ; i. J52cntife tt)c 
 lleplication Dot!) not afaign a b:cacl) oftl)cConoition ofrbc Dbligation. 
 2lp, 5t is faio in tlje Conoition, t)c ffiall not pat Cattcl into onr Common ; 
 ano tl)C IRcplication to, tf)at be did put cattcl into fucb a Common,namins 
 ft, ano ootb not fl)ciDto!)ctet1)c Common ltc3. jlp, SSticrcis Variance be- 
 tiD2cn tbe declaration ano tbe iu^it of erro a 4I)', 2Dtjere is a name mitta' 
 hen, foj in one place it is Ma the u in, ano in anotbcr it ia Math'a?. The Court 
 bid them advile, and br'ng Books to the ludgcsj 
 
 !^H Bruiigye
 
 Pica. 
 
 178 Mich. 1649. 
 
 Brungy againft Lcc* 
 
 Mich, 1^49. Banc. fup. 
 Trin. 1645, rot. '49i» 
 
 Demurrer up- DRungv b2oij0l)t All flctfon Of JCrcfpafBagalnft Lce,fojtaUfngofafl3are 
 on J I'lea in -^aiiD tmpotinDfnc: t)cr tUl tl)c JDlafntff ban papcD 10 1. SCljc JEDcfcnoant 
 1 rcfpaf,. picaDco bp luap of jtufitfitatfoiijtbnt !)C BfD Xiittxain ftcr bp tfrtuc of an ojoct 
 macic bp Commffsfoners of &ctDCts, foj a taj; affcffeo bp tbem upon tbc 
 platnttf. SCbe |Dlafnttf DcmurrcD to tftis pica, ano fljctocu fo? caufc, i . 
 Stbnt it Dotf) not appear, tl;at tftc (lommffsfoncrc toho fmpofca tljc Star 
 ftao atitfto;ftp to do ft, foj ft otigftt to be none bp fip oftftcm, ano ft 
 Dot!) not appear Ijerc, tlMtt^cptoetc mo jcfn number tftan four. ilj*. 3,t 
 Dot5) not appear, t^attljeplDcrcaUoftlicm oftiicQ!iorum,aGtl)ep oiittftt 
 to be. 3lp. SLljcre ootb not appear to be anp fault in tljc plafntff, U)l)p~l)c 
 ftjoulD be tarcD. 4lp. SCtje number of tijc acrcsi of i^anoootb not appear 
 upon U)l)fcl) the iCat teas lapo. sip. gt ootb not appear , tbat tfje l,ani> 
 tarcD Dfa Ipc iDtcbfn tfte Surffofctlon of tfte Commtfsfoncrs. upon thefe Bs-- 
 tcptions the Pica was over-ruled. 
 
 Coles againft Siblye. 
 
 Mich. 1649, Banc, fup. 
 
 Coles b.:ougl)t an 3ctton of aSrotict anti Contjcrtion agafnff ^^ibfyc; STBe 
 SDcfenDant pleaDcfgc statute of Jifimtatton of artfonsfnJBar. SEljc 
 cnion'inT^o piatnttf Tcplpco, tijat Ije tcB out a Latitat fucl) aaCcrmagafnC r!)cS>efen- 
 vcrand Con- Dant foj tljts caufcnoU) ocpcuotng , Inbfcl) icac totljfn ti^etfrncifmUeDbp 
 vcifion. tijc gjtatutc. 2Lo tl)f0 replication tbeHDcfenoantoemurrcD, anofojcaufe 
 fljctijei), tfjat ft toas fncertafn, anD fo no tfftic can be (opnco upon ft : foa ft 
 onlpfapss, tbat ftctooUouta LatitatfucljaEerm, ano Doth not fijeto toljat 
 Dap of the aCcrm he tooU it out, ano fo toe cannot take fffuc upon ft, ano tlic 
 ufual fojm is to fbcto the Dap. Latch mafntafneo the rcpUcatfon, anD faf d, 
 it tvao gooD in matter of fubttancc, ano the Latitat (hall be fntcnocD to fffue 
 Term. fojth t!)c firft Dap of thc ECcmt : fo j all the 2Dcrm fa but one Dap f.i conttru- 
 
 ttfon of the ILato , anD the SDefenoant map tahc a certain fifur, as ft is 
 pleaDcD, Roll chief liiftice anfircrcD, pou ought to hat)c flbelDCD t!ic teflc of 
 Time. the Latitat : foi the time ffl material in this Cafe, viz. to huolDtDhctberit 
 
 luerc fueDfojthluithm thc time erpieffco in the Statute fo; the limitation 
 of a»tionO: 0; tcithout , namelp^iftt.in fir pears 0; no, anD pou might babe 
 maoe it certain bp pourpleaoing ft fpcciallp, JermanDiffcreD in opinion ,- 
 and thereupon the Court took time to advife. Vid. antea, 
 
 Cufl:odes^<Sic. againft the Inhabitants of Ovvtvvell, 
 Tyd. Newton, &c. 
 
 For exrcpti- ». ,- 
 
 ..ns.ndl,,- I-49.BanC.lup, 
 
 fwcrs to 
 
 licni, upon a T 7pon a llctojn rcaD of certain ojDcrs maDcbpCommifef oners of 
 icio. n p Y gjciucrs,igafnll thf inhabitants of Outweii.rcmoDeD hither bp the fa^o 
 jTcTof Sew ^"IjnbitRnts, bp a Certiorari, St^efe exceptions tocretaUen, i." Cftere 
 
 Dcniuircr 
 uptm a rcpli
 
 Mich 164? i-^c) 
 
 Ootl) not appear to beairr atJjonrnmcntof tlicCommffatoiT. IBat totWs "adjournment 
 tbeCouttanfiiiereD,tl)Ptttn:eDci)not. Hales fnfo , tftat ttje cljargc ofte= 
 paratfon ofab;eac!)tnS>cn<trallg, toWcl) f)apppti0 bp fnet)ftabic mcefaftp,- 
 oag^t to be rcpaircn bpttjc teljole llcbcl, ano notbp anp parffcnlar tatll o> 
 petfon. 0no ilp. tt)C cbarne piiobt to be lato tnoffFercntlp : bntbere<ff a 
 patttcolat CnCome of tel^fcft tftc Commffafoncra of ^ctotro mAp tisfee 
 notfce, ano tftcrcfoic t!)e Ccm^-ff-^foncrs arc hottompi'lI'Dtolaptlictai; 
 eqaaflp upon tbe llanos iDftMr. t\)e tUU, fo: tfee dufifomc map be to tftc con^ 
 ttarp, ano pet ftatc a reafonablc conttract^on, anntljfsffltfteCuftotneofCuftome. 
 Marfhland foj ttjefpreDp repair of b;cact)E3 to pietjcntpnblfquc Danger, anD 
 aftcrtoarDs tbc tar ta eqtiallp cfftrtbntCD upoit tbe taHls aoiaccnt. a[«o 
 anImpUcatton fn a IRetojn mauc bp Commifaf oners of feetocrs in goon e^ ^ctorn. 
 nongD. Maynard on tl)c otljet (iDcljclJ), tljat lift Cuftome toaa toellfct 
 fojtl)fojtfte general cfjargcfojtbepicfcnt ncccfoftp, ann aftertoaros tbe 
 particular 3|nl)abftant0 ciiargeo fljall Ijate rcmcopcnr'tna t^c otfter Snbabfj 
 tants to mahc tbcm contribute, as ft toao in SDoctoj Lambs tCafe, t^at toaa 
 flain fn an tapjoar fn London, totjcrc tljc Cftp teas fineo gcncrallp, but tfjc 
 Cftfjcns aftcrto^rrcc! contrfbutctj to tl)C papment of ft : fox all arelpable 
 to tftccftarncbpt!)e Common laio , aiiO ft map be alfo bp t^e p jcfrfptfon. ToEd.j.f.8,9. 
 ff^t Court rcp?otjeDt!)cConnccl,antJfafD, poucugftt not toatguettooof 
 poo atonctfmconti;cfamcli3c, except ft be upon conclufion oCtf^B argu- 
 ments at IBnrfn the cnnfe. Roll chief luftice fpfp, t{)e tar ougbt to" be 
 partfcular, but ft fa not to be lata upon tbe SCotonOjip, ff tfterebenota 
 Coffome foj ft, ano fnctj a Cuftome map be rcarorable, ario ft fs uanger- 
 000 to D:ftrop ft, fo J fear of the pubifque oanger tbat map artfe b^ Do(ng ft. ^ , ^ , 
 janD foi tfte rctojn of f^c Ccmmfj;*foncr0 ft fa not nccc«larp ft fijoulo "'"^'"^ 
 be fo tttict aa our plesDfnga arc. iCl)c Conrt gatie Twifden time tffl 
 ttwt tap fetcn nf gbt to beftcaro on'tfjc otijet 0oe. 5[tlt»l!j(cbff»netotlie 
 ejtceptfon tbat tuas tahcn, that ft appears nov t?iat Lvnn Rej: ' is tDft'gfn tfte 
 IfmftaoftljeCommffsiortfaptfrtuc of lD|(iMfeetarf?mao?; 3;tlre?an- , 
 
 f tPCreB,tbat ft iiotl) appcar.SCo tftc fecono crceptf on tabpn,tf)i»t t?*re is a ncta 
 5Banfe ojtJUall oiucrco to be matic, anD not tlje repaying tftclD, litibtfjfs 
 ia not tofttin tbe Commircfon; $t Iras anftocrcD, djat'tbc mafef'^cof t^e 
 nctD JSanU fs but to ftrengt^cn tlic olD 3Banfe, ano fo fa but a rcpafrfng of an 
 olutDojk, anDnottliemalifngofofaticto. alp. SCfjc t!!J3alU^tobcmaoc 
 fcp confcnt of all tbc 3nliab<tants fntcrcffco fn t>ic benefit, faVclj map accrue 
 bp tbc mahfng of ft. 0s to tbe crceptfon tljnt ft appe area rot tbat Tyd ano 
 Newton arc toftftfn tl)c ^^nnDjeo of Wicsbitch, toucWng Ip^fcb onlp f bfs 
 Commffsfon of feetoers teas granteD; 3t Itias anftcercD, tbat ft itjal' be fo 
 IntcnDco, ano ft fs alfo fo founo. 2Lo the crceptfon, tfjat tl)2 ncic JBanfe teas 
 maoc fn another manner than the oId lEank, anD fo ft fs a net- tocilt , ano 
 ft appears not that the partfCB tareo hatjc anp benefit bp ft; 3t \ra? ^ ifiijc^ 
 rcD, tfcat ft Doth not appear that tbe E) japncrs hatjc Done anp thine fi. fUtit 
 oton benefit in the making tbfslPaniT, noj tocrc anp caureofina':.(;'gthe 
 nctD IBanb. SCo the trteptfon that ft ic not p;eterteo u-here the JBan'a fs; 3t 
 Iras anfttiCTED, ft fs certain enough ftt fo:th fn thcp:cfciitment , ano 
 IDiefentments are not rcqiiireo to be fo pr.ectfc aa other plcaoings arc. JCo 
 the crceptfon tlKJt "yd ano Ncwron ought not to mate th'' i5anfe bet aufe 
 other CotonB ttfc to no ft $t teas anftocreo, tl'at fo? maftfng it fn tlic mSn 
 manner, the other tl iilfi arc not bouno to maitc ft alone, but thofc alfo that 
 retcftc the benefit bp It. JEhcfe rrceptfonsfollotringtoere alfo taken to 
 the lathing of the ?Car. i. SEhat all the JLanos toithin the afUsofNew. 
 ton ano Tyd arcnotthargcD, but fo manp Acres in one, ano fo manp fn a-- 
 MOthct. STo this ft Um3 antinercD, that ft tioth not appear that there tpcrc 
 mo;e 0«res than arc tareo cfthcr fn Tyd oa Newton, ilp JDhe hi'Jh grcunoa 
 anotl)elotogrounDaar»cqnallp tarcD,toWch«s net fuofffctcnt ; fojfome
 
 i^o A/Jch. 1649, 
 
 acrMarcof-anrcatcrtialtictban otI);r3 arc. Co tMs ft teas anftocrcu, 
 tbatfoioufibttlMtootl) appear tbcj,' arc of an cqtial liaUic. 3lp. 2:,|)cp 
 ougfttnottofclltbeoiftrerotaUcn , bccnufctljc ffiimo cfo not bjfngfntbc 
 number of atrec> by t^c £Df8ccr appofntcD by tl)e Commffofoncrs to ooc (t. 
 Jt toaa anf lucrcD,tl)at tl)cp may fell fl)c gooDc, 0? alloto a Hcplctifn : :atiD 
 fcconolp Ijcrc appcaro not to be any Diftrcfo 0: tinpounttfng of tbc CmDa. Ser. 
 jeancBimardontbcotberCoc: i?lrft IjcfaiD , tl)at all tl)c crcrpttona arc 
 not opcncD , ano tl)c firft cvtcption is not anfU3crcD ; foj it appears not 
 i . . by atcrmciit t!)nt tl)C SUUo tarcD arc luitljiii tbc crtent of tbcfr €om 
 ' mffflfon, aott ougbt doc, 2 H. 7. f. 13. J^oj ia tbc fctotio Crccption 
 anfujcrcDj ano altbouBb tbc Counccl mfsbt at tbc finofng oftbcCom= 
 mifofon ba\)c taken it, pet U may be taUcn noto; anoUtanot fl)clu:o 
 bototljcolobanUlDao fnfufficfcnt , no; lobat tbe tbargc U'oiilo be tore- 
 pair it ''. i|5o; <)5 it fljctocD boU) Tyd ano Newton arc in Danger by tbe 
 nnt repairing ano malUng of tbc ncto bank, ailfo rbc Commifaioncrs 
 l)al3c cvftTDCD tbcir antbojity fit evtceofitg tb: anticnt manner of taring foj 
 tbc maintenance of tUs banl^ , ano tbe tar otigbt to be laio accojofng 
 to tbc quality anDtinantity of tbe lanDs, Vobicbarctobe tarcD, ano bcre 
 totb not appear boin many acres arc in tbe fcberal iHiillo, no? lobctber t\)t 
 tar Doe crteno to all, ano tbe gmo laiios ano bao lanoa arc alfo equally tarcD, 
 iieitber ongbt tbcrc to be a nctu tarimpofcD upon one tsiill to cafe anotbcr , 
 \Dbfcb by tbc cuttom ougbt to repair tbc banl; : flno tbey babe alfo maDc a 
 MClD ^Diftccr bcre , tobicb by tb'-^ S>tatutc tbey babe not autbo:ity foj, j babe 
 maDcano;DcrtopuniQ)oncto; rcfufing tbia Office , by oidrcfa of bfa 
 0OJD3, tobicb ougbt not to bc; anDtbcyougbtnottorefufeareplcbfnoftbc 
 Dili refo tahen, ac tbcy babe bcre Done, ano tbc lanDa only tbat arc lyablc to 
 tbc tav arc to be DiftraincD fo; it , anD not tbe goooa of anotber tbat fa not 
 luitbin tbc cptent of tbc Commtfaion, anD upon tbcfccicceptionabc p?ayco 
 tbcp?cfentmcnt migbt Oc quaftco. Roll chief luftice anfacrcD , tic tofll 
 not make all tbe lalutoiDfojfomecrccptiona, tbcrcfojcgibc notice upon 
 tobat crceptiona you iwill ftano upon. Maynard anf incrcD, upon tbefe, i . 
 SCbat tbcrc ougbt not to be fucb a tar laio , becaufc tbc lanoa tarco are not 
 iDitbin tbe C);te'nt of tbc Commifaion ; fo? it appears not tbat tbcy arc toitb* 
 in tbc l^unDjcD of Wisbitch. 2lp, ail tbe 31nbabitanta toftbin all tbc Clilla 
 arcnottarcD ,tol)tcb ougbt to be, becaufc tbcy babe equal benefit, aait ap* 
 jJCarabytbcp;efentm:nt. The Court ordered ic (hould be moved again 
 the next term. ^nD Roll chief luftice asUcD tobp tbC D?ainera OjOUlD not 
 Difcbargetbiscbargc, tnbo babe been tbc caufc of it , anD tbcy reccibe bc- 
 Bffit by tbeir Draining ; anD it fa not fit tbcy ftoulD pjejuDfcc otbera 
 by ft. PoOea. 
 
 Pymm and Morgan , alias Bambery 
 and Balely. 
 
 Mich, I ($49- Banc- fup. 
 
 Arfiimcn: nr^j^ig fafc U)aa again mobcD upoH 8 fpccfal lUcrDfctfnanE/cAionefirmi 
 
 af vcrdift in tubcrcin tbc qucftion U)a0,caibctbcr tbc cftate of Mary Morgan tbat iuaa 
 
 an n jcftione fctlcD 1 5 Car. ia talicn atoay by tbc iD jDinance of ^parliament maDc 1 645 » 
 
 fi.inx. anD tobfcbloouCD back to i64i.tDbicbtoaa after 13 Caroli. St toaa belo 
 
 by tbc Conned tbat argucD againtt tbc iDiDfnancc tbat ft toaa not , bccanfe 
 
 tbc £)jDinancc ia maoc againft a oeaD man. 2ly. SCbc effatc of Morgan 
 
 inaa fojfeitcD to tbe &>tate,anD tbcy out of it doc make an cttatc foj Pyram, 
 
 to{tbrctrorpcctiontotbepcati(54i, ano no furtbcr; anD tbcrjfo?« t^t e. 
 
 ffate
 
 Mich.i64p. i2 
 
 ftatcrctlcDbefo?ct{)attttnct3nottahcnaiDaj': jano if a Statute Ijaftc a 
 ooablc fence , one agatnfi Common 3iiifi<£c, snotbcotljerujitb Common 
 31itftic0, In equal ballancc, itftjallbcmtcrpjctca hi tljc better fence; ano 
 tljatU)ati)atl)beenobjcrteD, tljatt^crctaapctoccofrebocation in tl)c fet- 
 tUmcntta not material; foj Morgan is noVu oeao, iino fo this petfonal 
 polucr fs nolo gone, ano (ball not fjurt tl)e fcttlemcnt. fccono teafon is 
 taken from tbe fcope of tbe £DjDinancc, tobicb confine of tbjec parta: i. 
 2E;()c parUamcntinturcD. alp. Morgan tl)cfl?(fcnDcrpmiifl)co. ^Ip. Pymm 
 tcloatDCD, anDtbe^jDiiianccOjallnotbeftrclcbcDto punffl) Mary, tubo 
 ftatb a particular fntcteft , altbotigbtberc be not an crpr.cfs failing foj bet 
 iiltbeibjtinance, jl H. 7. 4. Plov. Conimenr.487 7Car. Part«randBel« 
 Jingham, anotbattbtsistbs meaning Of tifz £)ji3f!iaiicc map appear, bc= 
 caufctbersmainDcriarcfetbEDtotbc Common^incaltb; ano in ooubtftiU 
 Coiittrurtiona of a>tatutC0 ano i!5;ofnancc3,tbat (ball be tal;cn,Uif){cb mahes i,uerpretaa. 
 all parte of tbe £);Dinance oj §>tatiite ftano together , awtj ftjtb i3 tbc Con^ ,,11, 
 fiructionbcrc in not interrupting tbc cftate of Mar)'. OlBiit (tie objcctcD, 
 tbnt tbc Tifibt of tbc2Daugbtecfl is pjobtDCD fo j if tbcp claim from anofber5ln. 
 ccfto J , ant) not from Morgan tbelr iFatbcr. 3!t iuas anftccrco, tbat tbcrc ia 
 tbe fame rcafon to pjotiiDc fo; Morgans rlfatc tbat lias rigbtip conbcpcD 
 fcombimbefojctbe pear 1641. a0Of attrangcrcfoucribingfromMorpan. 
 StisalfobbjcaeDtbattbeEruftcea fo; Pymm ano tbc Common- Ujealtb 
 ftallbatjc Morgans lanO0, ano tbep (ball not be faio to be fojfitteD. 31 
 triae anflocrcD, tbat tbc 2l(t tiff itbtitcs no mo;c tban is fojfcitcD , iabfcb can 
 be no mojetban Morgan bao at tbat time. 2lp. 2Cbc parliament tool? no 
 notice tbat Morgan Ujagfeij^D in fee Dimple, no; Uibat cftatc be bau, sip. 
 Sifter tbc eftate of Mary Morgan entcD , tbe rctcrfrmrin fee rerurns to 
 Thomas Morgan , fo tbat Mary batb but a particular cCtate , ano tbe ffi)jai- 
 nancemap be fatlsfieotbougb Mary Morgans cftatc be not fojfcitcD ; fo? 
 tbc rebcrtion map be fojfcitcD, anu tbe particular eftate pjcfcrbco, aa 
 Cleres Cafc ia ; ano tbc fating ia not berc repugnant , aa it is objccteo, noi 
 Dcftropea tbc gcnetalitp of tbe i©jDinance, fo; it is bcre fatisfpcD. 0na 
 tbc parliament ootb not tahc notice of tbc conbcpance maoc bp Thomas 
 Morgan, no;ofanp btbct eftate tbait tbat be baoattbc timcoftbcma== 
 ijinBoftbe£D;o(nar(C8j otbcttoifetberctooulobe a great inconbcnience ; 
 but it is ob)£itcD, tbait tbc &ons claiming untier Thomss Morgan arc e^clu^ 
 BCD out of tbc fabing, 3It luas anflt)erco,tbat altbdugbtbep are , pet tbcp 
 arcnot ciccluceiJOutoftbcboDpoftbc 3tt , Dycrzyj.ioEliz. ano bcre tbc 
 crceptins of tbc intcreft of tbe iDaugbtera in tbe fabing batb its cflfcdf, viz, 
 tbc eftate lubicb tbcp babe of Thomas Morgan after 1641. tobfcb ftall be gi- 
 teu bp tii^ £>?oinar.cc , ano not ttjat lolicb tbcp bao befoje , ano fo p;apeD 
 )UOgcmcritfo;tbepiafntif, viz. Mary Morgans Icffcc. Maymrd fo; tbc 
 jDcfcnoant , viz. Pymms bcir faio , SCbat thz 3ctfs tbc rule to mcafurc our 
 cafe bp; ano tbat tbc 0(t cotb tahe abap tbc rigljt of all tl)e CbilD;cn , ano 
 tbat tbe fabing belpa iionc but firangers, ano nottuitbftanoing tbc rccom- 
 penfc rcfctbcD fo; Pymm , if tbc eftate (ball be (bo;t , it ia intenoco of fucb 
 an cftatc not toitbin tbe fabing ; ano tbc cftatc of tbe Cbilojcnisnot toitb' 
 fn tbe fating , ano berc fa not a general gift, but tbcfc lanoa particularip ; 
 ;ano in tW cafe Morgan bao poiDct to rcbofec bis fcttlemcnt , ano fo tlicrc 
 (j no b;eacb maoc bptbc£);Dinancr of Common 3uftice, aa is oblcctco; 
 bccaufc be bao an intcrcft in tbc cftatc, nottoitbttanoing tbe fcttlemcnt. 
 ano all parts of tbe fld ftano tcrp toell berc togetber upon tbe bcff conftru^ 
 dfon of it , acco;oins to tbc maUers intent. 3if 3 grant all mp trcjcs , frutt> 
 trees tDill not pafs; but if 31 ctccpt all mp 5lpple=trccs , all otbcr fruit- 
 trees pafS; ano tbe inbcritancc in Morgan ootb not fatisfic tbc ^a, ano fo 
 J?av'CD3iu02cmentfo;tbc)aDcfcnDant. Roll chief lufticc fatO; ^j. May* 
 
 ^a 3 nard
 
 i82 A/ich-i649 
 
 nard pou m(fta{ic ti)C firft part oftbc £D?D<nancc, fo; Do pou tfjfnft tftat tl^e 
 £>:f<nance lool^g fnrtftcr bach tljan > 64 1 . In otftcr lanue not crp jcffcD ? anD 
 t)cfecmcDtocncltncfo;itbcpiatntff, buttbeotbcrSuDgcafoj tfte SDcfcn- 
 Dant. J5ut t'.jc Court concluDcD tljat <t leas a great cafe, anu Dcfcrbco 
 great fonfiocratfon , ann tijcrcfojc ordered, That it ftiould be argued again 
 the firft Saturday the next Term. 
 
 Aficli. 1649. Banc, fijp- 
 
 c"'* "J"' I^C Court teas raotJCT) upon an Affidavit foj a Habeas Corpui foj one 
 cue comittcd tommfttco fo; fufpftfoH of f clonp, foj uttfins countcrfcft moncp , be- 
 for fiiipi.ion canfc the Snttkcfl tud! not ball Ijim. HoU chief luflice fafo, Jt ia Dangerous 
 ot felony, to temotc fuch a pjffoncr , ano tlxre is a Commffsfon of flDpct anD SCet- 
 Mittimus ^'""^r to trp fncb bffenocrsjano toe ha^c no Copp of theMittimus noto, but 
 It imus. jf pjjy jj^jj^g ^j ^^ ^^jj ^^^^ ^^^^ ^^j^ ^^ ^^ j^ ^j^^ prifoner be bailable , if 
 
 Cafe. the luftice will not bail him,bring your Adionagainft him. 
 
 Cofwell. 
 
 Michf i649tBanc, fop. 
 
 To rtfverfe /^i?^ CofwclI outlaVocD ntotcD to tetjctfe tfte £>atlato>p upon tijcfe jjc- 
 an Outlaw, y.\^ccptf one. 1 . SnftcaB of proxim. thcrcl0 ufeD px. fojan abbjefefatfon of 
 Abbrcviaiicn. ^ ^ ^u^fthout anp DaO). alp. Slnfteao of Infra fcr. tec abb jctJtatlon of infra 
 Icriptam ttiete <0 afcD infra fr« j3nD for thefc exceptions ic was quafhcd. 
 
 Dell and Brown. 
 
 Micbt 1^49, Banc* fup. 
 
 Error uponjTSn tcas mobcD fojntetlp to tcbetfe a ^nosemcnt fn an 9(tfon of 
 lufgement inisCrefpafa foj the lahfng atDapoftljjceCotDes, bctanfetheJSDcclaratf. 
 
 Trefpafs. j,n DOtb ttOt fap ncithct pretii noj ad valentiam ao to ttuo of the Cotor0. Ser- 
 jeant Earl motiCDfOJ 3IuD0cment notlBlttftanttng that ejceptfon, foj he 
 falD It 1080 not neccffarp to cypjcfo cither , ano nrgeu 19 E. a. br. f.g42. 
 anbPa). zoF^d. 3.f, 2. 8 H. 6. reg. 97, b. iBut Roll chief lufticeanftrereo 
 
 Declaration, jchst iubith pou Urge |0 agalnft the reccltJCD opinion; foj If fhep be llbe 
 Cattcl that are taben, It ongbt to be pretii ; bat If oeao, It ought to be ad va. 
 lentiaih. Therefore fhew caufe before the end of the Term why the Judge- 
 ment fliould not be rcverfed* 
 
 Spry againft Mill. 
 
 Mich* i(J49» Banc, fup« 
 
 Pafc. 1549. rot, io8, 
 
 Hrrtir to if- 
 
 vcrfc a judge- QPry bjought a tujlt of C^jroj to teijctfe a Sofgcment glhen agalnff ttim 
 '"».'-id-T'^ vJuponnnihildicittnanartlonofantotjerano ConfccrCon foj a f^ate.ln 
 rTrovrr"andt^p<£^°"i^fat Lancefton In Cornewall , ano thefe (£rroj0 tucrc afsfgneu: 
 Conveifion. I* 3ln tlje JUDQemcnt It t0 falD ideo ad eandum Curiam conndcratum eO; 
 
 Mhcrc*
 
 Mich. 1649. 185 
 
 iDl&ereasft Ol!{t!)tto be per eandemC'uriam» 2lp. 3!t ii recupirarc debeat, 
 iBbcreasftoiigftttobcdebet. 315ut Roll chief luftice anftocrcij . tt;at ta 
 liTcU enougb {it a jaogemcnt upon a nihil dici:. ?lp. 3;n tl)c atoarotng of tljc 
 Venire,<ttSpr3eceptumiuerir. 4lp, gtfgfojtljc StitptO crquirc fn forma 
 praedida. 5lp,2CftE SDefcnsant is not ocmanDeo. SEo tWa Roil chief luftice judoemenr' 
 tain, 2Cftc E>efEnDant DiD appear, ann fo tljat is not matcrfal. dip. 3t is fafo 
 Confideratum fuit, anOtt fllOUlD be Conllderatum eO. Roll chief luflice 
 ra<o, tljat teas a gmD crccption fo; tbc (nccttafntp oftbe toojoa. tElpon tbw, ^'''"• 
 Prenwoodtl)cCouncclontftEotftctOoemot)CD,tl)attI)cKeco:a<3 not tc- 
 
 tnOlJCD ; fojtije Certiorari to rcmotJC ft teas Dfre-ten to tljB f^jfoj auD tbC Certiorari. 
 
 3RecojDcr, anu tfte IRccojd fg retutnco bp tUc ^afo: anD SE)£putp=rEco?DEr. 
 Roll chief luftice fa(D, Sit appears not to us tijat tljc !R ccoincr l)att) potoct to 
 tnabc a SDeputp. Tberefore advife upon ir, and fo will we. Poflca» 
 
 Mich 1649. Banc- fup. 
 
 AlRetojn maoc bp an £Dfficcr of tl)c ^omfralf p foj one f ommftf CD bp 
 tftefr toarrant, tons teao, anfi it tons pjapcD bp Haies of Comucl toitlj ^"^ ''indulge 
 tbc ^jironcr,tl)at t^e rctojn inifiljt be filcD, ant) ibc |5?ffoncr Diftbargeo fo j l^^'^l^Zum 
 t^cfercafons: i.tbepartpinascommitteDfo? tefciiingbimfelf ; anD 2lp,byan officer 
 foj a Contempt fotI)c Court, ano bctaufc be tooulD not finDfaail: anD it'fihc Admi- 
 appears tbattbeirarrantfojbtiJ commitment fs not 200D : fo; be is nof^^'^y* 
 committcD fo; matter aviCng upon tlje S>ca, anD fo tljcp babe no 31urifDicti- 
 om JBut tbc Court biD tbeni pjoceeo upon tbeir pjobtbition , fo; tbcp Bsii. 
 tooulDnotreleafetfjcpjironer. But if you will you may move it again Fri* 
 day nexc, 
 
 Gilbert againft Marden. 
 
 Mich, 1^49. Banc. fup. 
 
 Trin. i<549. rot.942t 
 
 Mrit of CErro; toas b?cugbt to rcmobc a (utigcmcntgitcnfn fbCp 
 k. Common picas In an action upon tbe cafe, mpon opening tije rccoiO, Tjd' em" n°" ^ 
 Twifdentmh exception tljattbctecojD toasnot remo\3eD; foj tbc 3!uDge' the ^Common 
 ntentfntbc Common pleas toasgibm Coram Pctro Phcfanr, ano tbe tojitPi««s. 
 of Crrojtoas to tettifie a rccojD, quod coram vobis rtfide:. The Court a- 
 bated the writ of Error for this exception. Abatement. 
 
 A 
 
 Smith againft Andrews- 
 
 Mich. 1(549, Banc, fnp, 
 
 ANdrews, an attojncp, bjougbt an Action upon the cafe agalnff Smith, Arrtft of 
 fo; fpcahing of tbcfc toojDsagainft btm, He, meaning the Plaintif, UijRcmcnt iri 
 ftirrsupmen to futcs, and promileth, that ifhe recover not for them, he will*'' aftionon 
 lakenofees; and yet in a fure which he fo undertook forme wherein I was 
 overthrown, he took Charges of me, tiUpon not guiltp plcaOED, tbcre Uias 
 a bctDirt anD a (uogcmcnt fo; tbe piafntif, SEbc DcfcnDant bjougbt a tojit 
 of (£tro;, ano fo; caufc it teas IftetocD bp Miynard, ti:nt tberc ate entire Da^ 
 
 itlagcci
 
 i}^4 MiclvjMP^ 
 
 magcfl cf^cn fo? oi{?crD luojcs fpoVxn nt one time , toljcrfof fomc arc 0(tf 6^ 
 nfiblr, anD otljcri? not, U;l)icl) oun{)t not to be ; ana sip, 2Ll)c foojo-j in tixm- 
 fcltcs arc rot actionable ; fo? an ilttojncp map Ok up ircn to futc6, if ttjrtt 
 futes iJC laVofnl ; (icWclJ Roll cbict lunicc ucnpco) 17 Car. Gibfon ano 
 Maintf nincf . Baxter. il'.'.D Dc fafo, tijat an 0tto;ncp map pjofccutc l)ic Clpcnts caufc 
 toiitlwut fee:?, ar.r. pet it is not mafatcitanrc, Trin. 16 ar. Hill anD SsnJs W« 
 Cafe. Hni. s on tl)c otfecr fine IjclB ti)at tfjc luojBo arc Jlctiwtab'.c ; fo;t t!)C 
 itfi JDS fiia;i ! c taUcn in tljc I30 jft fcnfc : ant l^c nlfo ttjcluo tjolo l)C liaD Sit - 
 rcD iipfutcG i.% an unlalofiil manner, viz. bp maliinc ofbargainci iwtJj men 
 nt il^arkcts. Roll cbicf lufticc faio. t?)at fticft toojta ftiall be taUcn mitiori 
 icni'n, nna tirb; is a fjiccial maintcuantc, fo? it is in t!tt cafe of an Slttojaicp , 
 ano tl)erefo?c labottiU; bat ftcrc arrottjcr inojos fpoben to fljclu tl^at \)C 
 fliirco up futcs nnlalufuilp ; anz t^c ftirrt.tg np of fntcs ana anaUing bat- 
 ijainsto loUouitljcm, is in it fclfnnlalDfiiU, anojjrcat iticonbenienfca coc 
 ftrolri bp fuel) manner of p;arti5nfr, ano all tbc Idojds oii35)t to b: talscn tOi^ 
 tjctbcr, ans not civascblp ; foj fo pon map maUc n;ip toojos not actionable, 
 ierman luftice Ijebtljc ioojbij Inere nafonable; bcraufc tljrparca grc t 
 fcanoalyinD trcncbincto oeftrop tbcplaintifs litelibooo ip'.actfce. flno f-.iD, 
 tbat 3ito;ncp3 oufl)! not to po tofliJ.uhcts toflct pjaalcc,! tftc lPo;&6 fpoUcn 
 arctoffictDt^ioa rtirrcrupoffutrs, anbtofljeiDtljatbcUjaoa falfc Deal- 
 er, a;;ti tv.c tooj^s R):tU be taiicn in tbc Common acccptian, anu not owtiori 
 leniu. Nidiolas as lerm n ; a;-t) tl}at tbc I'jojas taUcn togctftir arcattiona- 
 blc. Ask luftice to tbc f>i;nc CfTvit. Whereupon ludgemeni was affirmed, 
 except better matter fliOuW be flic wn Monday nexr, 
 
 Jchns againft Levifton. 
 
 Mich.itf^p. B-nc, fup, 
 
 r 1 vc't oi 1 ^^^^ b Jot??!)t an Slaian of ncbt ajjainft Levifton upon an Affnmpfit tftat 
 
 uiae'cmcntin " tbc Dcfcnbant to3a:i) enter into a imscment unto tljc. piaintif foj 
 
 -.-.■A :ction if-fo mutb montrci as S>ir lohn Hal! mo otnc nnto tbc piaintir". if tbt"- piatntif 
 
 '."-'■Aii-inij-iyoulDtaUc Common bail of !)im tbc Dcfcnuant, if Hall CjoulDbic bcfojc 
 
 '"• fucbaDap,anofoj,notp2rfojmfrtgtbfspjomifctI)c3a(ontoa3fa5ongl|)t;"p= 
 
 on nnn AfTiimpii- {j.caDCD, tljcrc tow an ifftic jopncD, ano a bcroitt founo foj 
 
 tbc plnintif. SL?5c 2DcfcnDant mol'CD in arrctt of 3;«i3gcmcut, ano fljciuctt 
 
 tbnt it 8ot3 -not appear t':;r.t ttjerctoac anp notice cibcnbp tbc pdntif to 
 
 tbc SDcfcncant, bcln mtulj monp toac one to rl)c piafnttf from g»ir John 
 
 Halt, as there o»n!jt to be. Roll chief luftice anflucrcTj^pou DiDnnucrtabc to 
 
 knoly, at tbe time of tbc AiTjmpfir, bolu mntb monp Ijc biD oUic, ano notice 
 
 ianctneccffarp, nnoifft\tJcrc, bcmi(jI)tbabc0oiTCfo§>{tIohnH'allfotcn 
 
 l)im,ai3<jfoit fnallnotonlpbctntcnDcotobcintbc ImoiBlcDcc of tbc S>c« 
 
 fcnoant bimfcif, but tbat be miijbt b^bc alfo luioUile^gc 0; it bp otbcrs. ler= 
 
 raangufltccDcubtcD, but Nicholas ana A'k3!utisc3tDcrc of Roils opinion, 
 
 nnd the Plaintif ordered to cake his Judgement, ifbettermatter were not 
 
 Ihewen, . \ 
 
 CuHodcs Liberut. Sec. againft the inhabitants 
 of Outwell. 
 
 In tlCC. 
 
 F.vctrEOrs 
 
 u .oViaii'i'.'cr Mich, 1649. '"anc, fup. 
 
 <•( C ininiil'.i - 
 
 ct7'a!>dsn- T^'^ '^^''^ -'-"^ again mot)ci3 ; tobJrcin upon a picfcntmcnt mabc ta 
 fv.Jr' 10 1! ciu i Coiumifutoncrs cf ^cujcra, an ojccr U).i3 mabc bn tb?m to rcimburfc 
 
 tlje
 
 Mich- i ^4?. ^i'^^ 
 
 tijc Dtfec-reeticc, fo: monp cypcnccD in tcpafrfng n §>ca iDaC,bp laying atar 
 upon Ditcts iatll0, amoiicll lu^icb Owtweil loas one : DtDcrs crccpttons t)aa ' 
 DccnfojmerlptabcntotljepjcfcntmcntanD ojocr. at tl)i0 time (t teas 
 i.objEflcD,tl)attfjcCom:nifijfo!Krs cannot alter t'oe iifual cuComfo: ma^ 
 Wng tlje tap, as tljcp Ijabc btrc Done .• ano ttjercfojc t\)zit £)}Dcr U not gosD. 
 3lt toae anttoetca, tbat tberc is no cuftom fjer*; pjefcnteo ; but ii tfterc be, 
 pet tfte tai; cannot be lato gi^nctalip upon tbe Mtll, but ciflrfbattbelp; foz 
 cberp one of tbc tnbabttanta Jjatc not an cnnal fbarc of tl)c lano, no; arc all 
 the lanofl of equal £rooDnef0 : JSiiD tf)cr: f0 no cuttom fcj tlje Sltll of 
 Owtweil to apportion tbc tar, fo tbat tbcp ba'uc no autljojitp to Doe it. 
 Windham on tbc Tame Goc faO, tljat tftcrc is no picfcription oj cuffoin Ijcre 
 founo, ano fo tbctai; ougljt to be riilCDbptbc Common i.alD, ano ot^et 
 SEoiBng otigbt tfterebp to be Contttbatojp, lubicl) tcccibe benefit b)» tl)c ma^ 
 feing of t&EbanU ; ano tbc Commffsioncrs of Sctocrsfjabcnotbcrc puc- 
 fiieo tbc uircction of tbc fetatutc of fecuiers as tbep otjgbt to ooc. jano tjctc 
 tbc p^cfcntments upon iLJjicf) tbf^ojoctfojtbetaFiBaggronnccD, uete 
 tnaoebptljjec furies of fcteral^anDjcos, anD tbe bjcacbto be rcpaircD 
 Dotb not appear to be toitftin anp of tl)c l^unojcDs iBbencc tbe Juries rome, 
 as tbe Statute cotb Direct, ncitber is it tl)cUjcof)orotbeinfjabitantoare 
 chargeable, iD^etbcr bp tenure, o; cuttom, ojbolDCirc. Holhead on tfje 
 fame Boe faio, St is not faio botu tfje lanDg are Ipjifalc to t^c tar. t, 3[t iff 
 not fljetoeD in tobat part of tbc poe^SDikc tbe bjeacb bapncD. Maynard on 
 tbe otber ftoc faio, tb.it ttic Commffsion of enquirp fines bp tobat Default tbc 
 bjcacb bappens , but tbep cannot tell bote manp acrcc cberp one bolDs , to 
 cbarge tbem febcral ; ano it map be intenoeo tbat tbep bolo iopntlp, ano it 
 dall be intenoeo tbat tbc lanos are Ipablc to tbe tar bp pzcfcrfptfon , ano it 
 Is not ncceffarp to (beto in iibat place of tbc ipoe'2)tlic tbc bjeacb bappeneo. 
 Roll chief luilice faio, tbc pjefcriptionbctcts toaibeO; foj pou faptbatit 
 tBasnotan inebitablc bjcatb, ano fo pou arc at tbc Common lain, ano not 
 upon a cuCom, ano tb^ntbetar ougbttobcequal, ano accojoingto tbc 
 nnmbecof tbc dcres, ano it is not fo bcre. 0no it appears not tbat tbc 
 bjeacb is toitbin tbe ^unojeos tobcncc tbc 3!nrp came ano fo tbep babe no 
 autbojitp to enquire. Halet faio, tbat tbere is aclaufe tobclp this, foj 
 tbcrc is a potoer in tbe Commifsfonera to cafe tbem tbat babe lD;ong oonc 
 totbem. Roll chief luftice, Ebts toiU not belp, fo; tbc tar ought to be Tax. 
 iDcU ano cquallp laio, acco^oiiig to tbc statute, viz. upon tbe number of tbe 
 0cre0, ano b^rc it is laio upon tbc pecfons of tbc inbabttants. Therefore 
 make a new tax. 
 
 Archer againft Holbidg. 
 
 Mich 1 6'\9, Banc, fup, 
 
 IjP tbffl cafe tbc Action being an Sirtfon b jougbt upon tbc fetatutc of i R. Arreft of 
 j.Cap,3.ano aberoict fo? tbcpiaintif.it teas fojmcrlp mobeo in arrtttof lud^ement in 
 Suogment, tbat the statute teas mifrecitcD; tubEtcupon it luao ojoerco tbc *" '*''" "P' 
 parliament IRoU OjouId bcbjougbtfn Court, tobffb toas nolu Done, ano^"jR "* 
 tcao, ano upon tbe reaoing it appcareo tbat it ^ras mifrccitco ; fo? tbc &ta. 3 . '' ^' 
 tutc toas fo; fufpition of fclonp , ano tbt 2Dcclaratton teas foj felonp : Mifrccitai. 
 tobctcuponit being bclDbp tbe Court to be mifrccitco ia matter o:fub- 
 Sancc, tobcrenpon tbc Action toas gtounocD,* Tfic Courc ordered ami ca* 
 piat per billam. 
 
 B b Mich,'
 
 igi^ Mich. 1649 
 
 3/ich. 1 649. Banc (iipcr. 
 
 For rcniiuti- A i? 3iiD<£tmcnt lofls foono agafntt oiic foj 8 fojciblc ctitrp ; K\)z SDe; 
 on upon »u XA fcnoaiit tratjetfctl) tl)e Slncfctment, atiD enters Ws tratcrre (| plcaDg. 
 Indian cm of 2Cbcpla<nt<f motjeo tbc <Zoint upon a fuggcflion tftat there hao been ofbEra 
 '"■'.^''""""''terDtcts foimo foj tbfalanofoj the pafntff, that tbc palntff iniaht hate 
 '''°"' ttftltutJOn. Bat the Court would not grant reftitution before the tryal, be- 
 caufe the Defendant bad iraverfed and pleaded. 
 
 Mich, 1649^ Banc- fup. 
 
 To dircb3rge*Jl^e Court teas mobro to Dffcbargc tlic fffucfl fct upon the fnbabftants of 
 iHues (or n. t Bridqwatcr, foj not repairing a l^igb \i;ap, anD to qtiaO) the BinDictmcnt, 
 WrTwfs "P^" ^ Certificate that tbc toap Vtiao rcpairco. SCbc Court anflDcreD, tbat 
 Q^iaih. fiirtberpjoccrelboulDbcftapeD, ano tbc iffnco CffcbargeU; But we cannot 
 difcharge the Indidment, ifyou have no exception to take agaujft it. 
 
 Mich. 1649. ^^"^- ^^P- 
 
 Toqiwfh an -T ^0 <T;ourt toafi molicD to quaOiatt 31iii»f£tiiicnt agafnfta llBabet foj. 
 
 for rfiunr rcUingofbjeaoanoer tbeafsifc. SDbc deceptions tocrc, i. SCbat it 
 
 bread under Dotbnot Tap teljat ^fsffc.tobcrcas tbctc bc Ditjcrs afsifcsof bjcaD. 2lp,2C|>e 
 
 the Afliff. 3nDi(tmcnt notb not fljcin lubcrc be folD tbc bjeao, nojtoUibom. Roil 
 
 thcif luiticefaiDtotbcfirftevception, 3;ti0gooD cnotigb to fap be folD tbe 
 
 bjcao contra a fll lam, although it fap not inbat afeifc ; but upon the fecond 
 
 * exception the Indidment was quafhed. 
 
 Earl Rivers againft More. 
 
 Mich. 1(549, Banc. fup. 
 
 Pit iLmcn/ T"^*^ ^^^^ K'ven teas tahdn fap a Latitat antJ commfftcD to the ^arflbal= 
 
 pieaiicd. ■*- fca; SCbc ©arl bpbfa Counccl plcaoco b's p^itilcgc of ^peerage, ano 
 pjapeo be migbt be fct at large. Roll chief lurtice asljeD, !^oto <s tbe plea 
 notu amcnDcD :> fo: pcttcrnap pou pleaoeoin abatement of the to?it, ano 
 notopoupjaptobc Dcltocrctj upon a bare fuggeftion. Wild of Councel 
 
 Capiis. tDftbtbeSDcfcnaantbclD.tbataCapiasDotbnoiDlpc againft an €arl; foj 
 comes dicitur a Comitandorepe, & ceilantereqe ccffat comes, 0nQ DcntUt: 
 rcototbcplf^foj^ii^otoffoim. llollcS'efJufticcfaid, SCbat Carls, ana 
 iBarons arc anticnt titles of tl)c IRcalm. But let him plcao as be Uiill ftano 
 to it, ano aoViifc luell of tbc plea facfoje tbc ISDcmiirrcr jopncD j for we can 
 
 Amendment, ciye leave to amend the pica. 
 
 Ware againfl Chappcll. 
 
 Ml^, 1649, Banc. fup. 
 
 DcmuriTto "T xT 7 Are bjougbt an 3(tion Of S?cbt foMoo. againft Cfiappei, upon m 
 a pica in Cc \\ 3inDcnture of Coticnanto bctucan tbcm, viz. SDhat Ware fljoulo 
 vcnam. ^j,(fp jQQ ^oulcicrSjanobjingtbcm to fucb a pojt,anDtbat Chajipel ftotilD 
 
 fino
 
 Hil.i64p. 18? 
 
 EnoCbfppfnganutfttnalsfojtljcmtotranfpojt t^cm to Gallicia; ano foj, 
 not pjotiofns tbe ft fpp<r g ano tfttwals at ti)c tfmc appofntcu, iras tfje 0ctf > 
 onbjoucljt. 2EljcH)cfciiDantplcaDCD,t^att!cpa<jitff ftaonot ratfcu tfte 
 &oiiltifEr0attl)att<mc; anu to tl)<s plea tl}epla<mif Demurs. Windham 
 cf Conned iritlj tl)c piaintf f, IjclD, tftat t^e SDcfcnoart oug Jt to hate pjotf- 
 DcD tl)C fl)fppin5 ann victual ngafnft tlje time.tftonglj tbc &>oulD(era *aerc not 
 taifcD; foj tf)c not ratling of tljc &oulDfcr0 tan be onlp utgcD bp toap of mf> 
 tfgatfon of samaac0, ano rot pleaDtD (n Bifcljargc of tlje bjcar^ afsigneo. 
 Yard Of Councel to<tb tl)e SDcf cncant, telD tljc plea teas gmtj in barr of tbe 
 jatffon, fo^ tl)e Cotcnantfl of each part bate relation one to tf)cotl)er,anD 
 tbere<0aconbtttonpjecEtientmaDebpt!5ctDO3C0, to fina fljfpplng foj tlje 
 §>ouH)tcr0; fo tljat tfte JBDefenbant teas not to finDftlpplng, crceptt^e"''^*"^"" 
 plalntlf ralfcD tljc §)oulcfcr0,neltl)er (0 1 txt anp notfct glben 00 bote ma« '^°"'''"°''' 
 np&onHiferal)Cl^aDratrED. Roll chief Iunicebclt),t^attberetDa0 nocon' 
 Ditfon p^eccDcnt^ but t^at tijep are tiififntt ant) mutual cotenants , ano t^at 
 tticre map be feVeral actions bjougbt fo? tljcm : anD (t I0 not neccffarp to j^^ ; 
 gfte notice of tbe nnmbcr ot tbe men ratfeo, fo? tbe number I0 hnoton to be °""' 
 yoo» ano tbe time f j t^e Clipping to be reaop, is alfo itnoten bp tbe Cobe. 
 rant0 ; ano pou babe pour rcmebp sgalnft blm (f be talfe not tbe men, ae be 
 %aVi af alnft pou fo? not pjotlDlnn tbe Iblpplrg. lerman anc Nicholas lufti- 
 cet,b£lo agalnft Roll, tljat ttere Is a pjetetcntconbltlon. Atk luftice toao 
 ofRoU tbe CbiefluAices opinion, Nicbolasc^angeb die opinion, anOfo/udg* 
 ment was given for the Plaintif, excepc better matter were (hewn* 
 
 Jenkinfon agaihft Porter. 
 
 Hill. I649, Banc,fup» 
 
 Pafch. 1649, rot. 257. 
 
 nr ^efe CBtr js fn tl^e IRctojo iuere af0lgncD, fo rebctfe a janatmtnt gf« _ 
 A \jcn In tfte Court at York In an action of Bcbt. 1 . SEbat tbe time of t^e vSV?ud« 
 3atgementlcln figures. 2.2Ebc fum retolicrcb Is fn fi£ares. jlp. Vtnirementin debt. 
 fs not gmb, fo? It Is Venire facias duodecim, &c. llblcl' fs not ptD tcltti &n 
 &c. in an (nfcrfonr Court. 4lp» 3lt Dotb not appear tbat ti^e canff of ^action 
 i0 intra jurildidioncro Cnriz. And for chefe errors the judgement wai rc;; 
 »erfed, nifi, &c, ^ • ♦ " 
 
 Wefton againft Plowden. 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc. lHp» 
 
 Mich. »^49, rot. 503, 
 
 'J'^fs cafe fojmetlp fpobcn to, tuas again motjco, tuftlcft teas tftis in effect: ^'" '" '""'"^ 
 
 Wefton bjougbt an Action of Debt agalnff Plowden, upon an ^©bllgatls"^'''']'''" 
 on ofaoooi.fojtbepapmentofioool. SEbe SDefcnBant appears anD im«'™^*'*""' 
 patls, ano after imparlance. pleaDs in Abatement of tbe tujlt, tftat ^e is 
 Carl of Nova Albion In Ireland , anD ougbt to be ImplcaDcD bi' tbat name , 
 and hot bp tljc name of Edmund Plowden Janlgbt : upon tbto plea tbe pain' 
 tlf oemurreD ; i . iBctaufe it tame in after imparlantc.tobcrcas a plea in a» 
 katemcnt of a tojit, ougbt to be pleaneD bcfo?e imparlance. 2lp, jcbe plea Is p'"* 
 ftlbolous ; fo J be pleats tbat be tnas earl of Nova Albion bcfojc be entrca 
 Into tbe bono, toblcb be cannot nolo pleao.foj lie is eftoppcD to plcao fo bpEftoppd. 
 I)l8 oton D&D, toWtl) tettlfico t^c contrarp. Roll chief lufticc faiD, it is a W= 
 
 15 b 2 Iat07«
 
 m Hill. 1649. 
 
 lato^rplca,foil)c(0buta!anfffl)tl)crc,tl)ougl) lie be an (£atl fti Ireland,- 
 ano l)(3 oVon Otlfgatfon Copo Wm from plcaufng as Ijc totb. And there- 
 fore Ice him fhew caulc why he fhall no: plead in chief within a week , other- 
 wife lc:Iudgement be entred, vid.antea, 
 
 Wats and Dix. 
 
 Hil. 1649 Banc. fup. 
 
 JBntred Trin. 24 Car.ror.iy:^. 
 
 A'Riiment A i? ejeAione firmx toas b;ougl)t fo J certain laiiDs (n Lincolne Shire,anB 
 
 upon a fpcc!- .i\.upon Hot sutltp plcaocD, tbcrc toa0 a fpccfal tocroftt founo to t^fs cffctf. 
 
 aivcr^ft In ],s. bcfnsfctfeooftbcllanDsftiqucflfonfni^flemaDca J^coffmcnttbcre* 
 
 r„U °"' "f ^° A- ^ ^"'^ C' I^* ^"^ ^° tl)c(r Ij^cfrc till tljcp ftoulD matsc a 3icafe of t!)8 
 
 fafo ILanDs foj uftocrg pears to certain ufcs, to begin at tljc i^eaft of Philip 
 
 and Jacob ncrt cottimlng ; Ebe jFcoffccs enter, ano make a Icafe fo> 
 
 I'carsof tbcJLanDsto begin from tbc i^eaft of Philip ano lacob nert* 
 
 S:i)c qiicfffoit ina^ irljctljer tftc J^coffcea Ijabj maoe fuel) a ILcafc as 
 
 tljc Dceo of i^coffment Bircct?, ano fo tljc ufca are raifcD tl)cretipon,oj toljcs 
 
 tibcrit fljallbeintcnoEDanotbcr leafc,anD not toatrantco bp tbc jFcoffe 
 
 m cnt, ant fo no ufcs raifcu ; I atch bclo tbat tljc 31 cafe Is not Uiarrantcn bv 
 
 tljeoccDofircoffmcnt, ano tftat tljcrc arc no nfcs raifeo, fo; tbclrojta 
 
 att^JCi^C8a, ano tbc iroiOs from tljc J^caft mahc fcticrnl beglnnlngu 
 
 oftljciLeafc, ano fobcrc is another ILcafemaBe tban tbeneetj tntcnBea. 
 
 2lp. 3t Ib not in effect ano intention tbe Icafc of tljc parties, bccatifc 
 
 it is not maoc accojDing to tljcit Directions, anu fo tberc arc no ufcs 
 
 raifeo, fo J tbc aiitl)o?itp is not piirfaco , woi tbe pjcccocnt concf- 
 
 tion obfertCB , ano fo t^c Icafc batlj anotbct beginning , ano anotbec 
 
 enoing , ana fo it miift be anotbcr ?Lcafe , Fitzh. graunts 63. 5[no here 
 
 is not tbe fame tcbzrfionintcnoeo to tbc partp, viz. Ws &on Watfon, 
 
 fjccatifc it is upon anotber Heafc, ano fo a Different rcbcrfion. 5lno 
 
 aitboagb tbe Jurp might i)abc foano the intent of tbe partp, ano fo 
 
 tijc fame i,eafe, pet t6:p babe not founo it, 2. rep. Crumwells cafe. 
 
 5. rep. EariofRutlaodscafe, anoif tbc3urpfinocbiocncconlp, ano not 
 
 matter of fact, the Court can gibe no 3uogemcnt, 9- rep. Downhams cafe, 
 
 the mcaiiingoftbc partp ougbt to be founo, Oxfords cafe 10. T<p. 11. lac. 
 
 Banc, Rccj. Ifackand Clarkescafr, 3 Hd. 6. B'endloes Reports. 3stO tbcfgs 
 
 rotio point, vix. tobctbcr the ufc (ball rcfiilt to tbe jTcoffo j oi remain in tbc 
 
 i^coffccs, be bdo f bat it ootb rcfult to tbc iFtoffoj;anc remains not in tbc 
 
 JFcoffccs ; i^ oj firft tbcrc inas no other thing intcnoeo to be in tl^c fzGU 
 
 fees tbaft to mauc tbe Icafc gooD . auD that is not here Done, ano Dyer 
 
 ; oc.titco 13 not to this piirpofr ,Sbc intention of tbc parties is not p jebalcnt 
 
 inoirctfing of nfcs, ar.DDy;r3oo- mapbcapplpco to o;ir cafe to oetcr^ 
 
 mfnctbcnfc, 4. rep. 82.Biibersc3fe,Mich. I, 2:3 Eliz. Bendloes Reports 
 
 tbc ufc tC\jertcD : Dyer 1 6 Eliz. Humphrcftons cafe. ;an cflate ought to be 
 
 maoc in convenient timt, othsritjifc tbc nfc (s to rcbcrt out of tbe JFcoffccs 
 
 tot'oc j^eoffo:,acco,:Dingtobf3fitft cffate. 3lp. j^oj tbcqucftion tobc- 
 
 tbcragooocttatcpatfc to Eli7,abcth,anDtbcotbcr3,f)c bdo that tberg oio 
 
 a gooo Cftate patTc cither bp bargain ano fa!e, o: otbetluapes. 3i5ut it is 
 
 gooD bp bargain ano fale, notyDitlttanoingit be upon conRoeration paft, 
 
 tobitb is ro tonftDcratior,anD tbc other coniiDcrattoncrpjctfco to taifc tbc 
 
 ufc butts not,anD here is a gooo cor,fiDeration,Mich.8 lac. Gofman and Ca- 
 
 ringtQn,C,B, EbcrciDasnogooDconflOEration; buta cnrtcfie.is. ano 
 
 14 EliZf
 
 Hilj. 1^49, iHt> 
 
 i4Eliz. Horwoods cafe tftere teas a coot) confiucratton,, alt?]oun{) tljcrc fac 
 no monjcspafo, but lanufoilanD. zip. 3 f<t Doe not pafs bp teapot bar^ 
 gafti ano fate , pet it fliall pafsbp inap of Cotenant to ftano fetfco to tifcs , 
 ano t^c confioctatlon crpjcffco ia nooo to ratfe ttje uUe \ Brdles cafe 7 Rep. % 
 t^fe confioctattong cannot be filcncca bp tlje conQccrattonsof bargain ? falc; 
 no; fljall[t^c intent to pafs it bp \rap of'bargain « falc tjurt it, « if I)C taiic bp 
 toap of ufe, pet it mahes not tbc topntcnancp operate as a tcnantp in Com* 
 mon,f (0 it is t^c fame leafe oeclateo upon, ano not Ditocrs, ano tbcre is no 
 tiiireifin bp t^c entrp of t^c ^cScc at eleaionjfo? tbouKlj be be not E.cffec bp 
 tbe ILeafe intenuco , pet be ia ILeCTee bp tbc one Jleafc 0; tljc otl;cv; fo: ti)C 
 IleafeigmaDceitljEr bptbeiFioffo;, ojbpt!)ci?coffcr, ano fo be p:apcB 
 juogcmcnt fojtbc^Dlaintif. Pannell 5o;tbcSDefcncantpiitti:ec3fcatlar'ec. 
 ano maoc tbefe qucftiong. i . ^bs-tbct bcrc be fttcb a Hcafc as tin firft 
 3;nocntijre Dotb Direct, alp. 31f tbe ufc do not atifc tobcrc tbs cttatc ia. ^Ip. 
 Wbetber tbere be a gcDt> bargain ano fale. zjlp. QClbetbet tbcre be a gooo 
 tonfioeration to mahc a bargain ano fale. jlp. Jftberebe not a goon bar« 
 gain ano fale, tobetljer ittballenurebptoapcf Covenant to ttaiio fcifca 
 to a ufc ; anobcfaio, if all tbcfs points be not foj tbe ^laintif, all iaagainft 
 lim , ano be l)cH) tbat tbe toojos at ano from are all one as to fignifie tbe 
 Intent of tl;e parties. 2Cbc iuoios batie berc an eytraojofnarp fignification, 
 accojoing to time ano place , ano at j in a place arc all one , ano tbe itojo 
 at map be fatisfieo toitb time pjctcoent 0; fubfcqucnt , & qn.cincontinenier 
 Hunt incite dicuntur , et inftans eft indivifibile , anO be oenteo B-'twick . cafc 
 in tbe 5tt). IRcpojt to be laiu. flno berc is no nceo of a fojcco conftruction ; 
 fo^ tbe intent oftbepartp appears bp tbe cafc s rep. pi, iFoj tbe fcronn 
 poihtjff tbe Heafe be not gooo, ano no ufc raifeo, tbcn tobere tbe cffatc of 
 tbclanoisc' ^no be bclotbat it is intbe i^coffces nottoitbttanoinn^, for 
 Ijerctbeufcislimitcs, butnetintbacafefiptitontbcotbcrfioe. Sim bcrc 
 toasafeefimplcDEtetminablc; butit being become impofsiblc, it is a fee 
 abfolnte, irin. iSCar. RolUndBois, anBDyer 300. is miftakcn in puts 
 ting oftbe cafc on tbe otbccfioe: Snoitcannot refult, foj tbcreisnoufe 
 ^erc to refult , bat tbe partp is in bp tbe vEommon ILaU). JCo tbe 3 point.i.f 
 tbe ufc Botb refult , pet tbe eftatc of Hamond binocrs tbe bargain ano falc*; 
 fojbeisatojongooer , bccau'"e tbat tbe fee being octcrmineobp bis bolo. 
 tng otjet be is a iujong Boer ; fant if not, pet bis eitatc is para< 
 mount, iFoj tbe ^tb. be bclo tbat tbe bargain ano falc is not gooo 
 upon tbe conCoeration eppjeffco , becaufc it is not maoc foj mo- 
 nics paio noj fccuteo to be paio. 37 Eliz, Ward ano lamberts 
 tafcC. B. iFoj tbe 5tb. point be bclo^tbit it ootbnot enure as a iCoticnant 
 to ftano feijcD , bccaufebercarcno too?Os of Cobenant. Boyntons cafc. 
 Plow. Comcnt. 301. alp SEberc arc plain tooiDs to fbeio tbe intent of tbe ' 
 
 partp to be againft it , flno alfo actions folloiniiig tberc!:po;T. Foxes Cafe , 
 5 Rep. 15 Car. Pitfieid anO Pierce, B«nc. reg. 17 Eliz. Galiards cafe. 3nO 
 iDbetbcrtbc ufc arifctbo; not, it matters not, if tbe ufe atifctij, Watfonbatb ^^■'^'^ 
 title, if not, Cumberland batb tbe eftate, anofo it is an ill fcofmcnt, ano 
 piapsinogementfo? tbe JDcfenoant. Roll chief lufticefais, tbcre is a Da-- VAriance 
 riancc , ano it cannot be tbe fame leafe ; pet it is a gooo leafe to raifc a ufe, 
 becanfe tbe fcoffo} jopns in it. lerman luOice to tbe fame effect , ano be - 
 bclo tbat tbe trojos ar ano from are all one. Nicholas luftice Oonbteo. Roil ' 
 chieflufticefaio.tbatitisaoittinalcafe ; but tbe partp batb maoe fticb a 
 leafe ano mojc , anoa fcofment maoe habendum a die datus , if tbe ttiUn 
 be not maoe at tbe laftinttant of tbe Dap it is not gooo. The Court ordc-p^^, 
 red it fhould be argued again Tucfday fcvennight following. Poflca. to-'^enc. 
 
 J5b3 HiU,
 
 i^o Hil. 1649. 
 
 Hill. 1649, Banc, fuper. 
 
 VponanC5no{(imcntp;cfcrrcD zaCar.attbc flfcf^cu fa Kent agafntt 
 oncfojcnerofsftiD: Apples, pcara^ ano CljcrrfccframeD upon tl)e 
 iMdf.ci->-nt Statute maac againft cngroffcto of tafctuals , tljc Dcfcnuant plcaoco ano 
 nanAft.m |j,ag fpu^o g.,j>tp , fojmcrip tutgcmEiit trao arrcftcD, ano tftc Conned 
 's-^t" lpo:rft !)eatD. Edward lolinfon of tbc 3nncr SDeraplc pjapeo fo^ SuDflcmcnt fo> 
 rpRi'?.fiii,|^v. tl)c!Seepctscftt)cUbittp, «. tiotUjItljdflnDfngtpljatbaDbcenobletfeDfo^. 
 '^'"»'- mcrlpj anD that upon trcfcrcafono. i. IBccaufct^at Apples, ]^cars ano 
 
 Cherries arc cCltctuals Irttftfn tt)c Statute , ano tbnt bccanfc tbe fetatutc 
 is net to be ab jfDgcD, Ann ttje fetatute of 2 Ed. 6. maoc concetnf ng fraUe» 
 rets cjponnastbfs statute, tbat Apples ano JDcar8,«. are tlllfctuals, fo; 
 t>)c fic\i\kxcx3 are calico fellers of vCltctnals ■, nno foj Boij 1)<b cafe tbat is 
 ob)e(tcotbat Apples are not mfctual, UisnottobemeantofaUro;tt0Ofi)f' 
 (tualin a general acception, ano UiUbont Doubt cngrofsfng of tl^em is en- 
 srofslng at tbe Common ILato , 26 Ehz. 6>alt is no iElfctual per fe , no? is 
 nfeoas tElfctuaUnanpCoantrp; ^ctlttst^erc fafD to be tafctnal, IBot 
 Apples arc tafctual per k , ano Coftermongcts are talleo tafttuallers bg 
 tljetr Charters. Roll chief luftice faio, aCbat 4 lac. Apples toereaojaDgett 
 notafctualB; annaftcruponatojitofCrrojtbfsJtiDgemcnt toas affirm, 
 eo fn tlje Ctcbequer Chamber, anc tberefoje tl)at jnogement is not to be 
 l{£l)tlp paftcD ol3et ; anoiftftcpfljoulDbe aojpDgeo mittnals, tl)c traoe of 
 t^e Coftermongcrs toouln be oeftropeo : ano fo j &alt it is no taidual, bat 
 a pjefertatibc of victual; ano ^ops toas aojuogeD to be no mitfnal, 20 
 laci upon a reference mane to tfte StfDges. i^eitftcr arc Aipples to be ac- 
 tompteo taittnal toitWn tlic fetatutc. lerman luftice DfffercD , ano Niciio- 
 las luftice belD , t^at Apples are micttwl tcftijin tbe Statute , becaufc tbcp 
 are better tftan iFiOi. Ask lufticcijelo , tibat Apples are tlittual , bat 
 not iritlifn tbe Statute , fo? a Statute cannot alter bp teafon of time , but 
 tljc Common JLato map. It was adjourned, 
 
 Barnwell againft Graunt. 
 
 Hitli 1649 Banc.fup. 
 EntrcdTrin, 1649. rot, 7^1. 
 
 T^c Court toas motco fo; tijeir opinion in tbis caufe , to^et^er t\» 
 to:lt of Crroj Dio lie oj not . 3t toas fain tbat a tojit of Crro; is not 
 "^'^^ '/"•£''' like anotbertojft; fo> another to; ft map be afaateo foji one perfon, aim 
 ".mcarc'"'' CanugooDtoanotbet; but if tfte to?it of CBrroj toill not lie , it is abatcoin 
 .found cu hy, all . Hacker anO Wotton Pafcb.34Car. rot. 342. AnD Roll chief Inflice 
 and ohcs aol^co tljc Counfcl ttbat be coulo fap to tbe IBoobs of 2 Ed. 3 , ano 3 Ed. 3* 
 acquitted. p.Mcs fn 3Reco}D map Jopn in a tojit of Crroj , to is it bere , ano an in- 
 F rrcr'"'"'' ton^^ntencc map come to all tbc parties bp tbis juogement , altbongb bat 
 fomc of the parties agafntt fobom tbc action toas commenceo are fountt 
 gufltp, ano otbersareacquftteo, anotberefojetbep map alltoclljopn in 
 tbe to?ft. And therefore let the ludgemenc be reverfed if caufe be not ihewa 
 Wednefday next to the contrary. 
 
 Roberts
 
 Hill 1649 Tc)i 
 
 R oberts againfl Tucker, 
 
 Hjll.i<54p. Banc, fup. 
 
 Pafch, iSCar. roMitf. 
 
 Avi!SIrUofCtto; teas bjougbt to retttfe a Bltiogcment gtben fn tl5C Error to re- 
 CoiirtatBrtdgewatertnan3(t<onof tlje Cafe upon an Afiumpfu to vcrfc a judge- 
 pap fuc!) a fum of monep at tlje SDcfcnDants return out cf Ireland. 2i:fte"'«"'6'^«" '" 
 Court ftelo ttjat BridgewatcrljatljnopotocrtOEnn'.itre of a t^fng Done be- ^" ^jl^'"^^"^' 
 ponD tl)c(r Jur(8D(£tion, ano Ireland ia out of ttjcir |ur(sDJct(on , tobencc tfje °u"mi'iir. 
 partp upon tl)c AfTumpfit traa to return. Latch of Councelioftb tlje SDefen= juriidiaion. 
 Dantfntftetojftof (Brroj fafo,tftat tfjc tojU of Crroj {0 returneD bp tbe 
 ^apoj, ano H>^piitp IRccojocr , ano tbcfr ILcttcrs patents gibe not poiocr R„ujn 
 tbftatieaSDcputplllccojoer, ano tJje tDjt't of CBrroj ia Dircflco Maiori Al- 
 dfrmannit etRfcordatcri, The Court ordered caufe to be (hewn why the qiii'^e<l= 
 Writ of Error fhould not be quaftied, Poftca 
 
 Poynes and Francis. 
 
 Hill, i<>49. Banc. fup. 
 Mich. 24 Car. rot. 22 1. 
 
 ;af0fjee):pjcffcD,ai3Ougl)ttobc. Roll Chief luftice anftocreti, tbfs fs tlje 
 fault of tde Clark of tbcafstj; ; Therefore let him attend and (hew caufe 
 why the Poftea Ihall not be amended. Amendment. 
 
 l-iill. 1645); Banc, (npi 
 
 '^ l^t Court teas moiieb to quafl) an dBrtnfitmcnt fo? a rfotoua cnf rfng fnfo to quad, sn 
 certain lanD, anDcatrp(nsatoap4loaD3of ^ay. SLljc crccptton ta- Endiamcnc / 
 fecn toaa tftat tlje dDnofttment faltb afportavit dao "Carucat. fixni, fnftcao of '"f > f'° • 
 duo Ch re(Sat. fceni. Roll chief luftice anftncrcD, 3if tl)C partp be culpable 
 fojtbecntrpintotfte lano, althoug^^etarricu aioapno^jjap, pcttljeC'ti- 
 DittmentisgooD, tbcrefO?e plead noncul. to all the Endidment, and it may 
 be if it prove not good in all parts it will be naught in all. 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc. fup. 
 
 T^t Cafe of tl)C tulllfl of Newton antJ Tyd conccrnfng the pjcfentments For qusfliing 
 maoctotbeComffsioncToof §>elDPr3 foj tbe l^unD:co of Wijbitch," <:'"c"""=r.ts, 
 artTJtbcirojDcr maoc thereupon toaa again fpoUcnto. Twiiden againft the '"^ °j!i'^'y^-'^ 
 p?efentmcnt faio , 2L!)at it f 3 not a pjefentmrntbp 3!urp, as it ougbt to",grso£Sew. 
 lie fap the statute ; foj tbe Slatp babe onlp polticr to enquire of tbings uitb= cts. 
 fntbe?^unb:cCofWijbitch, ano it ootb not appear that Newton ano Tyd 
 are tritbfn tbat l^nnujcD. 2lp. SCbefubttante of tbe pjefentment is not 
 Coofl; fo; tbe Commtfctoncrs cannot ojocr tW Newton anu Tyd inbftb 
 
 babs
 
 1^1 Mich^4?. 
 
 jjaijc no benefit bptljcrcpaWng of tbcbanhCbaUcontrfbutc to t^e tepars' 
 tfons, »8 E 3. f. 2 2. 3lp. SCbep cannot ojoctto inaitc ancU) toaU not= 
 toftftftanoinsCal lice I){s! opinion fnJ)f 3 rcaDfng upon tbc statute of &clt)- 
 era. 4!^. £l)e2Ca>:t3 not toclllalo,fojtt<0notlaft)upoiiall t\)e JlanDs 
 lolt'ofn Newton ana Tyd, as U ougftt to be cbargcD , tfanp otigbtto be» 
 Holhead anfinctco to tbfo latt c)cccptfon, tbat <t docs not appear tbcrc are 
 mo?e JLanosln Tyd 0; Newton tban ate cbarseo. 0nD Roll chief Iuf>icc 
 fafo.tbatfblDCll cnougb. 2Co tl)C tbfro cyccptfon, Holhead fafo it ia not 
 lDbollpancU)luo?U, anBtbcrcfojetl)cpmapo;Dcrtomal;cft. JCo li)!)icb 
 Rol I chief lufticc aflcntcD , ano falD (t teas fo nottottbftanofng tbc Cafe of 
 tbc lleofEly,fo.itbatiuaflfo;tI)cmaUfngofanttotoo?Ktotallp. SCotlie 
 2d. ©rccptfon l)c rcao tbc toojos of tbc pjcfcntmcnt, bj> tobicb <t appears , 
 ibat bcf aufc tl)c aotenturcra Ijao no iLanoa to be cbargcD , ano ft ia foiino 
 nEteffarptobcrEpaircD,tbattbErefojc(t<stobc rcpafreo bp Newton ano 
 Tyd (0% tbcpjefcnt nctcffeUp. Maynard anflDcreu tbat tbep arc not bountt 
 to rcpak fo; tbc act of a Stranger. Roll chief lufticc anftoerco, Newton $ 
 T;x:s. Tydniaptahe tbcrc rcmeopes agafnft tbc ttrangc aobcntnrera, am it 
 fcems tberc toafl a pjcfent neccfflitp to repair U fo;i publfqiie fafetp. 3jf 
 one be bonnobppjefcrtptton to repair atoall.petto pjcbcnt tbepjefcnt, 
 ano pubUquc Danger, tfec Xommffcioncrs map tar otbcrs to do ft, ano ibc 
 llalD fa jtift tbat fs bete maDebptbeCommffstonera. JBtittbe i. (Brtep= 
 tionfanotanfiiiereD, ano fotbeCommffafoncra babe cjrceeDcD tbcfr an-. 
 tbo;ftp. 2rbcrefojelcttl)ffrbeancUj 3Laiu maDcbptonfert, ano quaJb 
 tbcpjcfcntmcnta , cjrtcpt better matter be fljetoeD. )15ut toe cannot oj- 
 terpou to babe pout monies again.Butfor that take your remedy at Law. 
 
 Garret aoainft Blifard 
 
 Hil, 1649. Bancfup. 
 
 Hil, 24 Car. rot 983. 
 
 Arpuments V J^ott 8 fpctfal tcrDfct founD ftt an cjcafone firni2, JCbe Cafe tDaotbfs, 
 uponaciic (I?;anDmotbcr SCenant foj Iffc, tbc rcmafnDer to tbe i?at!)cr foj If fc, 
 upon a fpcci-tlie rcmafnDer to tbc Son foj life, tbe&onlctipes a fine come ceo, &c, of 
 ai vcrrfift in (jjc ^anD,tbc qucftfon toae tobctber ft be a fojfefture of bia eftatc oj npt. 
 fi"mie'''''"'"' Hales ragucD tbat ft toas a forfeiture, but 3 coulD not berc 5)im toell ; ^e 
 "^*' cftfDtbefe boohs 41 Ed, 3. 1 . 24 F.3.f. To-Pafc. 11. Car. Banc.Reg. Hut« 
 
 ten5reports,Trin, 7 Car, Banc. Reg. anDaDfuDgcDii Car. in King and Ed- 
 wards cafe; Dyer 239. 3nD be fafo tbat a fine fur conifance de droit corae 
 ceo, &c. aa it is ii\ our cafe, fa a iFeoffmcnt upon IRecojD, ano ootb tmplp a 
 3lf bcrp: ano fafo, tl)at a rcmafnosr map be fo jfeitco bp lct)ping facb a fine, 
 ahb concluDCD ft toaa a fo; fcf turc. Wadham Windham on tbe otb^c fioe at» 
 gucDtbatft toaanofojfcftutc; 3nD cfteo Mich. 24 E. 3. andDyer 139. 
 foifciiuie anDlaiDtbf3fojagrounD,tbat\vberca jTco(Tmentini?ecmaDefap a 2Ce- 
 nant fo? IfCc, Dotb Dlfplace anp rcmafnDer, tbat fucb a iFeoffmcnt fa a foj« 
 fciturc, but it fs not fofn tbia Cafe, anDtberefojc ft can be no foj» 
 fcfture. ^fsncnantfojUfeofarcntojJofan aDliolDfonlclipa fine, ft ia 
 afojfcftutc,altbougbtbatnoremainDcrbeD{fplaceD,tbf8 fa tbc great ob« 
 )C£tfon, i^ E.4.f. 1 5 by Littleton , anDtljefine fur conifance de droit fm« 
 pipes a iFcc fimple, 40 Ed. 3. JButtbere a i?ccfimplc realip paffcD toftb 
 tf)ccitatcfojlifc-, HButbcreitpaffecbp Inapofintercft, anD notbpi^ap 
 of cfiopcl, ano tbc Conufcc map conf cCTc ano aboio , anD tbcrefojc {ier c fa 
 iiocttopE!,anDfoitDfffcTafromtbcCafC3,objettced Rich. 2 Eftopel 211, 
 3i5ut it fs oblcctcD, tbat b"? batb taken upon bf m to palTc all tbe eftatc , febicl^ 
 famojctbanbcbat^topaffe, anDtbf3mahcsitafojfeftntP,43 E. 3»f. 12* 
 
 3c
 
 Hil, i64p. 193 
 
 3;tt3 5000 fo; tbc rclJCTfion in i^ce , m\^ net fo: tt)? otbcr cCatc, 37 H. ($. 
 f. 5 , 41 E. ? f. 14- I>P Ttiorpo. St vcas anfiDcrco,t!)at Ijc tjatft not taUrn up- 
 on b^nttcpailc all tbccflatc, but onlptjieotun cftate: gtts objcaru.tljat 
 t!jc fine lopns all tl)c cilst£6toectijcr, anopKrpo?ts tlje parcfiic of t^cm 
 toljolcanD cittftc ; Jt toas anftoerct), tbat tlic fine cot!) not parpojt tlie 
 Entfrccftatr,44 r. %. i. lo.fomucbfliallpr.ffctptbcgncaomaprfabtf'jllp 
 paffc, ana no mo?c, anD fo tt)c cftatc pnffce bp fraction, Cooks Inffir. j.^j" 
 2i;i)c3Laii!Confituc0tl)c effect oftbc fine accojofne: to tl}c intent of tl)c par- 
 ties, anotbattojor.gfljalliiotbeintcntJCijro is ft I}crc; 0nD if tljcre be 
 SCcnant foj life.tbc rcmainccr in tail.tljc rcmafnucr in i'^cc to STenant foi 
 life , if SEcnant foj life letie a fine it is no forfeiture, i o H. 4 f. z. SCcnent 
 fo J life map pjap in apt) of all in t^,ercma(noer, anoljefafD, ti;at in tl)i3 
 cafe iiB no forfeiture no? cttopcl, no J ball) be pntTco tno:c tljan be l:atl),f 
 tljcrc is no iujong bp tt)c fine; but it fljall onlp palls uljat map be paffcB.nno 
 l)t laiD, a fine is a iFeoffmcnt 'dben tl)c tiling to paCfc bp it Ipcs in iiit»crp , 
 ctftcttoffc it is but a grant, «nti ocbcRs no eftatc as a j^coffmcnt Dotl-.jaaa 
 tn Baker and Hackers JTafc in tbfs Court , Bredom Cafe teas Dcnpeo foj 
 .ILatDbpBramfton, Jones, and Barkley, Hob. 5S8, 385?. 3;tiB no DifcontiiUii 
 ante, cnDfucfjcftatefliallfirC paflc, bp tobfctj no ipjong (ball be oonc. 
 SCbcJuiJ^BsougbttobcAftutitoinbEntreafonstofuppojt eftatcs, ancto 
 DcfcnD from injuries, anDU)!)eretbcConufecoft!)cfiiic Ijntb an ictereft 
 to paffc bp it to fatiefic tljc opcratioit of it, fuel) a fine is gooo-ann Dctb no 
 to jong, as it <« in our Cafe. St is obf ectcD, tbat tljerc is a j^a (implc ijere, 
 iut it fo of Ko balue, fo; it if after an eftatc tapi , an2 Qjnll not be affcts in 
 tftc l)?eir ; 3t tuas anftocrco, St is but of little Ijalue, but it batl) mojc tljan 
 a rijj'tjt in it , antifobepjspcDtuDgemcnt for tbc SDcfenoant. Roll chief f°''^f'f"f «• 
 luftice IjclD, it ioas a forfeiture altbougfj tbcre be no cifplacings of cftatcs , 
 hccaufc it puts an cftate in a ftranger, irljo ougbt not to bate i^t, as Brcdors 
 Cafcf0,tobcteoneDotbacUnolt)leDgeanotbct to baftc tbe inberitancc bp 
 tbefinc, tbis is a forfeiture: J5p tbe fine bcrc tbcCbmifor achnolulcDges 
 wore to tbe Conufcc tban be batb , ano be migbt batJC crprcffco in tbe fine 
 ttc eftatc tbat be batb in tbe 3LanD,anD no more, anofo tbcrcis an eftate 
 in potfcfsfon bcre. lerman luOice faio.tbe fine fijaH not be conftruco to no 
 torong; buttbcCafcicofconfcqucnce, tbcrefore be tooulo aDl'ife. Ni- 
 cholas belt) it teas no forfeiture. Asklcasoftbe opinion of tbe cbfef iuttice. 
 Roll chief luHice faiD cftopcls Uiill make forfeitures in manp Cafes. Q> 
 wtiac ludgemcnt was given. 
 
 A/eers againfl: French. 
 
 Hil, 1649 Banc. fup» 
 • Entred Hil, 24 Car* rot, 24. 
 
 Aj^ ejeaione firmae bas brougbt for ejecting fbc painfiff cut of a recto* Arrcfi ol 
 tp , ano Declares of a I cafe tbercof maoc unto bim bp gnoenturcSCbc uidpcmcnc la 
 Paintiff bao a bErD{ct,tbc JDefenDant mobcDin ^nttt of Suogcmcnt, tbat '." tjcaione 
 tbe plaintiff baoDetlarcoo a leafc per Indemuram , ano Dotb not fap inlJJ"^^ • 
 curia prolatam. SDbcCourtanftDftreDjif an SnDenture.be pIcaDro but {,p *""""• 
 toap of inDucement,it is not neccffarp to fap in curia prolatam, othcriDfre if 
 ft be pleaoeo to entitle tbe partp bp it. 2lp, ^t octlares, that tbe JDefen- 
 Dant Dine feet bim out of fucb a clofc, ano Dotb not fap toljerbct it teas pa< 
 Cure or «rrablclanD, nor bote manp 9crcs it teas. Roll chief luftice 
 Caf D, (t (0 not gooD if it be of a clofe of ^Lano, (f be do not gibe (t a name, noj
 
 Dower 
 
 1 94 Hill. 1649. 
 
 Dcclrrc of teljat nature tijc lant) fo. 5!?, I)c Dcrlatcc tl)at tftc SDcfencant 
 electee l)tm «ie uno Crofto, iDlfc!) fs tntcrtaftt. 313ut Roll chief luflicc faiD, 
 ICijat a lp;lt of E>oU'cr anu an flffljfe to<D Uc dc uno Crorco, ano fo liifU an 
 Ejedione firirac, altljotigl) a jf ojmcDon toill not Ue de uno Crotco, And 
 tl.creforelccthc Plaintit take his ludgement, except caufc be ftitwed to the 
 concrary Monday next, Poftea. 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc. fup. 
 
 Entred Trirt 24 Car. C B rot. ioio. 
 
 Error to re- ik ^^ff of Crtoj toss lj?ougi,t to rcticrfc a tutincjncnt gfljcnfn tfjc 
 '''c'^'inT^o' ^^ Common peas tn an Action of Crotcr ano ContJcrDion of nixicra 
 vcV& cou-^'S^^fi'j fc? manpimpjopct u-ojocnrcointljclIDcclaratton tocppjcfis fcticral 
 vcfujji. oftljcni, as I. Argentum fervitium tGufcD to e):p?cfs a (iiltjct S>alt=tellar, 
 iuf)fc!) fa not rrcDD • foj fervitiuniia i.atfn fojfcrtn'tc: Snofn Parker ano 
 Marrvnscafefn tftfiS Cotitt , Inftrumentum ferreura, anglice a ^po;fe-locU, 
 tows IjclD not gcDD, ano 3 !ac. Robotumscafe,Hama,angliceaCrciU)Of3;rort, 
 ItiasaDjimgconaugM; 2ly,?^C Declares deduobus Caftoribu', anglice ttBO 
 l^itS. jlp, De duobus Catems pro patinis, anglice SDffbcs, 4lp, Dc duode< 
 ccmCrinalibusetplaguli?, anglice Coffs anO CrofscloatljS. Ed, Turner 
 pjapcDfoj JtiogcmcntnottDltbttanotngtbcfccjrccptfons t JBctanfg as to 
 tlic I . tfjcre (3 no p;opcr Voeju fo j a filter S)alt=ccUar, anu ft (3 bcrc tocH c» 
 noiigl) DcfcrfbcD bp oftrro toojDs. alp, Cljcrc is no proper Jlatf n luojD foj. 
 !^at6 tailct! SDemp Cnftojs, ano tbcrcfojc it is latofuU to frame l»ojDs,«i fo 
 fo) tl): rctt, being nclu tWngs not Unoton to tfte Romans, there arc no 3Latf!i 
 luojD3fojt()em, $roUio;03 mapbr iatJcnteDlDcUcnougbtocrpjefstfjcm, 
 anD fervitium argentium is here Uiitl) an anglice, anDt^crcfoje ft is a gooD 
 Defcription of ti;c tiling t anUde iriftrumentoligneoCompofito, anglice a 
 cbtecn, IjathbeenaDtnogeogooD, bccaufctbcreisnotapjoper UjojDtocr* 
 pjcff it. 3i5ut tl)c Court Dotibteti of tl)C toojus ufcD fo j Coifs ano Clofe» 
 tlotljCS, farcaufc tticp arc DilJCrs tilings, lerman luftice faiO, argenteum fervi* 
 tium, anglice, a filter Saltcellar, cannot be genu, foj fervitium fs llatine foj, 
 fcrticc. W<M Roll chief luftice faiD, if fervitium Cgnific notl)ing , tlien tl)c 
 3furp gabc no Damages foj tbat, am ttt-n tl)e reft map be gmD. But yec 
 the ludgemer.t was ordered to be rcvcrfed, except caufefhewed, and was then 
 at the prayer of the CounccI pronounced; Ub^Cijifit bCnOtpjapeD, tljC 
 3uDgcU;il!notD0£it, Q:iodjioca, 
 
 Peifeaga^nflMkblye. 
 
 Hill, I 649. Banc, fup, 
 
 Pafch, 1649. rot. 222, 
 
 Errortoic- » Mtit of Crtoj tuas bjougfjt to rctjcrfc 3 juDgemcnf gifcctt at Launcc* 
 iKniuhn'^"' -^ floninan^ctionoftrefpafs upontbe cafe,fo^ tftefe tDojDS', Thefe 
 aftbn'upon Town Weights in Geor^^es pofltifion (meaning t^e plafntif, teljo tDas tlie 
 thccife for Common lrc{glierOftl)C2Coton)aretalle and cofening weights. 2Dt)e i.et« 
 \Yords. ccption luas, tftat berc ioas no Communication IjaD of tbc JDlaintif, but nJe 
 
 Cafe. iDOjPs are onlf fpoUcn concerning tl)c toeig^ts. 2lp.2Cte juogcment is not 
 
 Judgement, tojcu cnttcD ; foj it is faiD to bc gif en ad eandem Curiam, tnftcreas it ougW 
 to bc per eandem Curiaoi , Upon thelf exceptions the ludgcmenc was re 
 vecfed. Colfoa
 
 Hill. 1649. i^^ 
 
 Colfon againft Ree. 
 
 HilUl54?« Banc, fupu 
 Hill, 24 Car, rot, jgi; 
 
 AtiOidt of Crro; tuas bjoagftt to rctcrfc a 3!uogcmcntg<t3enfnf!jCErrortore. 
 Court at Niwcaftle upon Tynf, fnan Artifeof Novel diiTcifin. SL^C vcr'^e a Judge- 
 C-trojaf0fgncDiDag,tftattl)eJplafntffDotb Declare tbat li)i SD^fcnoart d1d'"'="' p''«« '«> 
 t<ffcffc bim de Dno muro lapidco,ant) tbat tlje SDefctiDant l,aii erccteB a ftonfc ' flj'ji^Y^- j^ 
 In tbc place to Wb nufance. SC^c Court anfEereo, The Piaimif ought tofjnce. **' 
 have brought an Aflife of Nufance for this wrong, which becaufc he hath noc 
 done, l<t the judgement be revcrfed. 
 
 Bacisford againft Yate. 
 
 1 ill» 1 549, Banc, fup. 
 
 Pafc. 1649, rot. 289. 
 
 ' A tmtft of erroj teas bjtjugljt to rcijcrfe a luogemcnt gfDen in art 0ct{« Error to re- 
 X\ on of SCrobcr antt ContJcrCon fo; tljefc errojs : i .Jt is fafo of tljc 3!u= vcrfe a judge- 
 to?0 (n cntrfng: of tlje<r tcrtjfct, Dixerunt pro querence : ano alp, 3In tt)c a- '"^"^ givenin 
 toarofiig of the Ventre ft is idco priceptum fuit, tof tij an, &;. anD fo ft fs not c^'vci'to ""** 
 ccrtfttn I bcncc t^e Venire f ffncD, as It ouafet to be. The rule was, the judge; vcni^e'.''°°' 
 nicntnioulabcreverled,ifcaufe werenocftiewnto the contrary, 
 
 Cooke againft More. 
 
 Hill, 1549. Banc, {up. 
 - Trin, i649» rot. 6^5, 
 
 c 
 
 -Or.kf fc jougW an 0dion npon tbe cafe agatnff More upon an Affumpfif,?'^™"^"'' '• 
 -<topapfo:crrtafn barrels of bar, folo aiio DeltUcrcD untobfm fuel) ajft'"'"'!! 
 Dap. 2l p E)ct noant picaos fpcctaUp, that ^c of a not affumc ao tbc |niafn= !n Aflumpfit. 
 tffbatb Declarer. 2lo t^tsplratljepiatntlf Demure, becaufe tl[iat bp t^ug 
 jileaolny the P'pfntff Is tfcD up toa phrllcular Dap : toftctcasbc map gftjc in 
 etJtDcnce foj anp otl^er baft's of beer folD at anp time bcfojc the artfon 
 bzoagljt. The Court ordered caale to be flicwn why the Plaiotif (hould not 
 have judgement upon chic demurrer* 
 
 Banbury againft Bafcly. 
 
 Hill, 1545, Banc, fup. 
 
 Hill, 24. Car. rot. io5j. 
 
 'T^fficafearfttng wpon a fprcfal terDttf fottno in an Eje<aionefiimr .onul^CaVc^' 
 
 touching tljc tftle of the f^rno? of CalHdowne bcfng part of fefr Thomas "n«rning 
 M>rf;anscuf?tct!)attoa6cti;rntoS&r. Pvm bf £>:ofnancc of parliament, 'J^^^'""'"^ 
 aao heretofore arsueo on bot^partSjtoas again fpoUen to : i?itft bp Tmi-^enLu^.^"' 
 
 Cca denPjr 
 
 ym.
 
 j^6>' '" ' Hill. 1649. 
 
 'den, irbo argucD foj tljc piafntff ; toto fafo, tfcc j©ucCfon f0, OTftctljcr tftc 
 cfta'tc fctlco'bp Ss>tt Thomas Morgan bcfojctftc peat 164 1. be jojfdtCDb^ 
 tl)c ;a£t of parliament, antJ tonfcqucntlp itcU gfljcnto^r. Pym, ojno- 
 flni) be faiD,tbc Intent of tijc parlfamcnt in maUfng tWs fla fa fitft to be in-- 
 tcrp?ctcD : ant) be bclu, tbat arcojotiic to tbc act no cftatc paffetb , but fucb 
 cftatcao Morgan bno 1.1 tbe pear 1641. anDnomoje; fojno mancanfoj' 
 fe(t a tbfng tbflt be batb not, but onlp tbat ubicb be batb ; but Morfjan tbcn 
 baonottbi^cCatc: ano tbercfo?e becoulDnotfojfcIt <t. 2lp, 2Dt;ctc is a 
 pjfojitj' of t:flfng tbc cflatc in tbc parliament, anu ncjrt from tbc 
 pnriiamc;'.ttct!;e2CrHftccs, anotbc JErtiftecsran batocnomoje tbati is 
 fojfcitcD to tbc parliament, anotbeeftatefetlcobcfojctbe pear 1 641- is 
 not fojfcftct) to tbe parliament. 3IP, 2Ebc penning of tbc Slct is confiocta. 
 blcjSLbc 2rt faitbali tbc faio lanDp,tbat is all tbc faio lanos tbatMorgan bao 
 in tl)c pear ; 641 . ano not all tbc lanostbat Morgan ciier bao befojc tbat 
 ti:nc,ant>bav)fetlcD; fojtbcp?cceDcnt irojosarctcffraincD bptbe tooiiDB 
 fdbrcquent, AMv^ms cafe, 8 R' p. Dyer 369 ano from tbc preamble of tbc 
 flcttomalic atonltruitfonto punilbfimocentpcrrons, is againft tbe ?Lavu 
 of vE>oti,fS)an,anD jpature, Nichols cafe, f, -598. £)f rcVoarDs ano puniib- 
 ments confift tbc cffencc of Commontocaltb5, ano it toulo not be tbc intent 
 ot tbc parliament to puniib innocent pcrfone, 3 Fd, 4. 2. 2Ehe parliament 
 Ufa not iiitcnn to gibe mojc of Morgans cflatc, tban Vobat be bao 164J. foj. 
 tbcntbcpmicbtgiVic tbat tobicb migbt bccbi£tcD,k.bicbtbcpintemjeo not. 
 SXm iDbereag it is objctteo, tb.'.t tbcrc is a claufc of Kctjocation in Morgans 
 fcttlcment . ano fo tbc cftatc teas not abfolutelp fctlcD ; 3jt is anflDCtcD, 
 SLbat notlijitl)ftan5ing tbis potocr of IRetiocation, tbc cftatc is not gibiti bg 
 tbio 3ct unto Pym ; fojit cannot gibe a polt)cr,7Rep, 13. anbapolBCr can* 
 not be foifcitcD, ana Mary M ugan hat) an intcreft in tbc lano, notiuittftau* 
 ting tbc potocr of llcijocation. Sinti notiBitbftanoing tbcrc is no fating 
 foj Mirv, pet t'lc eftatc is not paiffcD ; fo: M^iry Morgan is not intenoco to 
 be panifbco, Niche's cafe, Com. f. 483, aao fo t:crc nceos ro fabfng foj 
 Ijcr, 14 H. 8. f. i, anD it cannot be intencco bccaufc tbnc ij no fabing fo? 
 bcr, tbat tbcrefojc flic fballfo;fcitbcr cftatc, ano tbc fating is not tbcrc- 
 fcjc iblc ; fo; it batb an operation anotber toap. %\]t fating is not inten- 
 Dct of tbc cftatc of a Collateral auiJtefto; onlp.foj tbio is tbc bcgning o[tl)e 
 qucftion, foj tbc fating fates not apw thing, aiiotbc pcnnit^oftbc toojoa 
 aTcagoinfttl)t3crpofit{on:anDfol)econcluDeD, tbatnotbtng u-asgitcn bp 
 tbc Statute to fpr Pym, but tbc cftatc of Morgan tubicb be bao in tbc peat 
 1(541. anopaapcDiuDgcmcntfojtbcplaintff. Sreel,tbcl1ccojt)crofLon- 
 uon, fo; tbc SDcfenoant, faio, be lioulo onlp anfitcr the argument of Twif- 
 den, bccaufc be baa bcarD no other arguments. jSno firfr be bclo, tbat tbc 
 2) jDinantc reaches all the cflatcs tliat Morgan bao, as tocU bcfoje, as at tbc 
 time i'54i. ano tbe cftatc fetleubpMaroanbefoje 1641. Inas tbc cftatc of 
 Thoma<Morpnn|iit!)c pcar 1641. ilp.Ebc lanos arcctpjcflpnamcD tobicb 
 are gttcn bp tbc statute, ? it is not material wbo batb the cfta Je in tb^m.foj 
 certitado nominis toilic dcmonftrationemj Dowbcy anD Dudingtons cafe , anO 
 Mildmayes cife, i Kcp. Bo fntcrpjct boU) tI)C IdojD others fljaUbcitltCt- 
 pirtcD. Slno here cannot be faio to be anp inttitttce in the parliament. 
 SCbciUucftionbcreis. tSlbctbcr tijc cftatc bcfctlcu bp tbc parliaments? 
 anoifitbcfctlco.itlBoulobcafuppoCtionofiniuaicc, to fuppofc it is not 
 tinhtlp cone. Che ilalu batb inteftcD tbe parliament iritb a polnet to oif* 
 pofcofaillanD8,anOtliercfo:.citcannot bcintentcDinjuftfcc; anb tbe C' 
 fiatc is not in Marv Morgan notluitbftanDing tbc Conttpancs, becanfe 
 there is c. claufc of l^lctocation in it ; foj it is a toio vTontcpancc as to bee 
 cftatc, bp rcafon of the claufc of llctocation, fo: that makes it frauDulcnt. 
 j^no tbe cftateofMary Morgan is not pafTcobp tbe statute, notU)ttbftano> 
 
 Ins
 
 'Hill. 1549. '97 
 
 ing tMt claufc of cttctfonfitthc£):DfMancc, an if o; ait an arc no fatfRg 
 of '•'ti cftatc, aiiD fterc in no cWaion In t!;c cn'c : ano f-crc is ro faWng, ottjct* 
 Ivffc tlicit eCate cannot be fa^co, foj tl)en tf)c lanos are all pafftQ, ^iiD tbe 
 falling CFtcnOO to tl)C lnnD3 OcfccnDCD to tfje CWlOjen of Thomas Morgan, 
 from Collateral i3t;icctto:o, ano not from i bo. Morgan tl)C i^atl;cr; ano as 
 rcafonablc a Conftruflion otigftttobcmaoeofan £):Dinance of ^parlfa- 
 incnta£5tl)fs{0,aij of an act of parliament, ano fo l)C p?ato Sluogemcnt 
 fo J tlje SDcfcnoant. R'tU chief luftice fato ?^ge Dio not Doubt of the polucr 
 of tt)e patUanient <n tbtc cafe, but of tfjeir meaning, it)!)ct!)ct tbcpintenoeo 
 t!)efelanCB(IjoulDbcfojfcitco, ojnot: ilnDtbe £D:t!inance luasmaDc 6p 
 ttjcl^oufeof CommoncU)itl)o:«tanpp;ol^ifoinit, anoxic pjottfotoa© put 
 fnbptl)C^3"fccf5lo?03, anoljccnclirtco tljat Mary M.>rqins cftatc Voaa 
 fatED. SBut Jerman luftice fato, fjc conccioeo that Maries cttate iDao not ra« 
 tJCDjbUt onlp tbC Cftatc of ttcangctS. The Courc was divided, and faid they 
 would confidercill next Term, and then give iudgeraentin this and the Caie 
 or(!5arret and 315lijatD» 
 
 Quire, What lodgement was given in both cafes, for J was not in Court at 
 the day they were fpokeu to again. 
 
 Vincent Rgainft VVallis. 
 
 Hill, 1(549' Banc. fup. 
 Hill, »4 Catt rot. J) (5<5. rot, pocT, 
 
 Ijp a IRcplet^tn foi tifttrafnfng of Cnftcl tljc 2DEfcniiant empatlcu , ano af-- J^ , "J'caTr* 
 tcttDatDsplcaDcDtbattljclanDijarc anticnt SDemefne tDftcrctf)CDiffrefSrcpVv"lfcer 
 toas tafecn , ano to t^is plea tfte piaintif Demucreo, Serjeant Parker fo j imparlance, 
 tftc piatntif , ann agaitift tljc 2Dcmutrcr bclo , tbat tbc pica ia not to be at)« , 
 mittco , bccaufc tljat tl)c partp ball) maoe bia Defence, ano cannot tbetcfo jc '^*'"* 
 aftct\iiarO0plcao to tl)e (urifoiction of tbc Court , ano citco 1 1 H. 4, f, 47* 
 1 2H.7.f.i7 b. Cbat frccbolD onlp iato be fueo foj in anticnt a)cmcfne,0nD 
 alp, ttjc plea it not fuf ficient , fo; it ootb not appear tbat tbc lanos arc bclo 
 of tljc jpano: , but onlp arc parcel of tbc ^anoj, ano futb lanes arc plcao- 
 ablc in otbcr Courts, 3oH.6. Mac. Brev,ii M.4ifcd.3 ?lp,3itisnot faiD 
 tbattbclanocareplcaoablebpOaritofSDjoitClofc, tobicb ougbt to be z 
 H. 7. f. 17. J H.6. f. 146. 4lp-l^ep;cfcrtbe6 that tbc lanos arc not plcaDa=> 
 tie elfctiiberc , tubitbisnottnic , foj in fomc cafes tbep are pleaoablc bete 
 intbtsCourt.Nat. Brev. 19D. anofop?apcD juogcmcnt foj tbc plafntif. 
 Roll chief luftice DcmanocD, Uibp is tljcrc not a fp:cial Demurrer bcrc:- 0f« s^.-ciai De- 
 ter imparlance one map plcao tbat tbc lanos arc anticnt ocmcfne. foj a ■"""". 
 plea of lanos in anticnt SDcmcfnc to tbc jurlioiction of tbc Court Differs 
 from otber picas plcaoeo to tbPluttsoiction of tbc Court. 31t is true tbat 
 parcel ofajpanojofanticnt ocmcfne ia pleaoablc at tbc Common %a\n; 
 but lanos belo of tb^ fpanoj arc pleaoablc in tbc Court of tbc lo jo. Ad< 
 joumed to be heard Tuefday following. aftCrtoatOS it toas mobCD again , 
 ano Roll chief luftice faio , tbat after imparlance tbfs plea is not gooo; be« 
 caufc bp ft bebatbaomfttco tbc jnriaoiction of tbc Court, And therefore Ice 
 ' him fliew caufe why he ihould not plead in chief. 
 
 Cc 3 9i(i
 
 198 Hill. 1649. 
 
 Pafcall againft Sparing. 
 
 Hill i<549, Bancfup* 
 Pafch. 1649. rot. 7J. 
 
 A Wixit of Crro} faasbjotigbt to reterfc aSuDgcmcnt gftcit in att2iaion 
 Tirror ro rf- -'^tn Briftow upotl 8 Conceffit I'olvere faptfjc DcfcilDant. Roll chief lunice 
 vcrfcajuctpc-fafj, t^atan j3(lfonofiDcbtDloiDClllicuponaConceffic folvcre bp tl)e ca. 
 |""conSI c ^°"' °f Brifbow, atlD fo fs (t tn London, 2 8 H. (5. i E. -f- f. 6. flliotbut Cc 
 folvcre. "^ roj affifgJiCQ ioas , tbatUfsfaiotbattbcpattprccotJcrcD tbc Damages per 
 
 Declaration, juntores Compere. tuI)Crca3 tt OUgljt tO bc AflefT.fo J tl)fo fS tI)C pjoper iDO^D; 
 
 but tljfs exception \ras alfo otcr rulco. Latch tootj another Ejrccption*, 
 that there IsantB the iDOjti0 pro raifisetcuftagiis (tithe affefcfns the oama* 
 0C0 ; ano fo It 00th not appear foj tohat the Oamagca aire affcITcD, And 
 Ditwig-i. for this the ludgcraent was reverfed exccpc better naatcerfhewn. 
 
 lennings againftLee. 
 
 Hill, 1649. Bone. fup. /^^^ /^o. J.c 
 
 Whether an /'"^Enning? b?ought an attfon of Strefpals of an afTaulf anc baft crp a- 
 
 iUuc^Jdi'" Vjgafiitt Lee ano h<s totfe ; fo j an nffault ano batterp mane bp the loffc, 
 
 j ^yncd. the ircme plcaoa a fpettal pica of juttificatton , that ft teas in Defence of hec 
 !0ti3banD : 2Che piafntff replies de infuria Tua propria, upon thfs there tuas 
 an tffue (opncD , ano a "bcrDfct fo; the Patntff ; ft toas mo\)CDfnatreft of 
 Snogcment that the fffuc teas nor tocu jopncD , becaufc the rcplftatfon toaj; 
 nctgooD, anofothetferofctnotgooa, aiiDfotherc tan bc no BuDgemcnt. 
 Serjeant Parker pjapsjnDgcmcntfoj the ^Blafntff, fojhc hclDthc rcplfcatf« 
 ontoasgcoD, anDfoagooDSffuciopnco, ano ff there bc not, pet ft is^eU 
 
 iiTur. pen bp the SScrofct, o; elfe bp the S>tatiite of geofaflg , o? If not, pet ft fs at 
 
 Icatt gooD fn part. ^nD the Iffuc here Doth fmplp a negatfbc , althougli 
 there be not a Direct negntfi'c, but an affiritintibc fn the icoj'Js of ft. ani> 
 6 E.'4, i6b.fna UcplcHtii, anD 9H. 5. f- i.b. there arc gcoDiffuesjopn* 
 tD in the affirmatitiE , becaufc thep tmpip a ncgatfbe. Trin. 1 8 Jac. Banc. 
 re^. Aldridfje and Walthalls cafe : anD hctc inaiita onlp a 'Ex.tVatilt; tDhfcfi 
 fabutonlp matter of fo;m. ano not material, alp. SSUe OlerDirt hat^ 
 maDc the fffuc gooD , although it bc not tocll jopnco, 5 H. 7. f, 1 j. 3lp, %t 
 the aerota hclp-3 it not , pet the statute of Scofafls hclpa ft , 5 Rep. Nc 
 c.'ols cafe, 19 Elz. Di':lifon5 I'^epojts, 8 ^' 9 Eliz. Bendlocs llcpojts, 
 ai'D 14 Car. Bmc. Reg. 4lp. 3lf thc§»tatutc bclpnot,pEt it is inell cnoug!), 
 becaufc it ia gooD in part, ant fo: part it fsuxUfouno, ano Damages fljall 
 
 1) n.agrs. be tutciitcs to'bc otticn fo: t!:at tohich fo tDcll founD, 9H.7.f.4. 16 H. 7. 
 f. 16. 10 Uep. J<m.'5aitDOshurn$cafc, 5 f c. Banc. Rep. Bi^rane anD Sel- 
 ling, N'ich. 1 6a9. Deftnond | Oibornahis tafc the vTourt DCnf eD.)RoIi chief 
 
 J . , luiticf fafa , (f thtrc bc a fffuco, anD one fffuc is not tocll jopnco, ano oama* 
 
 p« bc cfl'cn entire, this i>J not gcop, but idll rnalx aU naught, 40 Ed. j.f. 
 40. i81?.c. Aldridn«cafc. 1 6 Uc. lonei ano Gates aojuDgeD , ano he fafa 
 that the material tU ng f s not here put in tffuc, ano fo the iffuc is tmmatcrfaf, 
 
 l^ r,i! aniJ there is a Jeofail , ano th: D&mages being gitcn entire there can be no 
 
 juogemcntcttien. lerman lufticeoio Differ in opinion, ano faio, if tljc 
 E)rtcnDant plcao an finmatcvfal tl-.ing.ano tt)e plafntt: jopn iffuc, ano it be 
 founo fo J him, he (hall batjc juogcincnt ; othcrtoife hhcrc the plea fs partlp 
 material, pattlp (mmaterfal ; fo j there tbc fff-ic curht to bc upon t^e mate- 
 rial
 
 Mich-^Hj?. i^c) 
 
 rfal tljmg, otftertotfc t!)crc can be no juuscmcnt It was adjourned till 
 Thurfdav Tollowing. 
 
 %\iz Cafe toas tl){3 , Sn ilctfott of Manlt ano JBattcrp an^j trotmu^ 
 fnjjUjasbjoug^t; tfec SDefcnoant plcaoo non cul. to tftc tooutttJing, ano 
 (uftifiestbcaffaultanD315atterp fn Defence of Ijet ?^usbanD,m hcepfng 
 poffcfsfon of certain lanD0. %\\t pafntff replteu de injuria fua propria, ana 
 ootl) not ttaticTfe abfque lali caufa. 2Dl)e Juti? finD rntfrc Damages fo j' all , 
 Ivljeteag t!-erc ic not a perfect Iffuc jonieD as to tl)c 0r£auit ano JiBattcrp fo j 
 toantoft^cSCratjerfe, Poftca, z/o. 
 
 HocJgesagainftJanc. 
 
 Hill. I 6^9» Banc, fup» 
 
 Ii^an3rrcaof31iiDsemcntfntl)f3cafe,tl)e qtuttton icas, mi^etbcc an ^'''"''."„'''''* 
 actfon DO He againtt an CEpecHtoj upon a Conceflit iblvere of t^e SCcttatoj ,.'xc?ur'or fu" 
 upon a fpectal cuttom. Roll cliiefJuftice IjelD tbat (t Dotb not , foj tljfoc'onccmr foiv. 
 iuoulD be to cljargc an Cjecuto j fn an 0ct(o!i oi"£D. bt , "jj^ere Ijc map bp tlje ot the Tcn» ' 
 ilatDtoa0el)fa3iaVD, anoan0£t(onof SDcbtlusnot againft an dBpecatoj"''- 
 
 Adjourned, 
 
 Graves againft Drake. 
 
 Hill. '649t Banc, fup, 
 
 Ti^an;a(tfonof2i::rot)cr ano (tonterRon foj Dftcrs parcels of l^otiniolo ^ red of 
 -»auff, anCycepttoniDastaUentotfteSDcclaratlon, bccaufc tbc pialntff lud'^ 
 
 ^..^.u^n itth^,* fhtnira hah nr<rlnrr>h w\m f^v n^.-z-sli:. »ln_l.: _: :: a i- . -r- 
 
 amongftOtljCt things gaD DCClarcO pro fex pircdlis plumbi cinerii Anglice a Trcvcr and 
 |3c\iiter ^ojrfngers : tubcrcastbetDOjOparcellis is uncertain; foj a par- ^°"^'^' '•''"• 
 eel Dotl) conQft of manp tbtngg in number , ano fo fex parcelli cannot be p;o» 
 petlpapplpEDtoCu^ojrlrtgerc, butfflttjaDbanfex peciisftljaD been bet. 
 tcr, tibougti tljat be alfo Incertafn. Hales i)elD it luas all one as if it ftao ban 
 pro feK peciis plumbi Cinerii, Roll chief luftice cnclineo it Iras toell cnoucr^ 
 I)Ccaufe,tbousbtbeU)ojD0arenotfop;opcr, pet tbe Dcfcription is Sood'e! Decia.«ioni 
 nougl). lerraanluniceinasoftbc fame opinion, JlBut Nicholas luftice bClD words. 
 tbat tlje ILatin is not gojD , fojictftcrcbe p?oper Ujojds foj a tWng, tbep 
 ougbt to be ufeo , otljertoffc 55arbarifm toill be inDttceo ; ano circumlocu- 
 tion ongljt not to be ufeo toberc tbcreis a pjopcr 3Latin U)o?o to be IjaD to cjc- 
 prefs a tfting. Ask luflice agreeo toitb Roll tl)c chici luttice : ;anD the Plain, 
 tifwasbid take his ludgeraent, except better matter were ihewn to the coh- 
 trary. 
 
 Hobfbn a3;ainft Hudfon. 
 
 Hil. 1 649 Banc, fup, 
 
 HObfon fa?oagWan 0ction upon tbc cafe againlt Hudfon foj fpeaUing Arrcfiof 
 tbefe iiiOjDS of ber, viz. She went to the Wells to be cured of the French '"''Pf'"'"' '"^ 
 Pox. ■5Hponi;5otgutltppleaDeD,anDat3erDictfonno fo; tbe plaintif, tbe ^." 'j;'"" *'' 
 i^cfcnoant motieo in ^xuSt of auogcmcnt , tbat tbc toojDs are not actio:= 
 
 nable.
 
 zoo Hjl. 1649. ' 
 
 nablc,'b'Caafc tJjcp ate (nartafn Idojdb, ano doc not erpjcia ttjat tfte 
 piatnttfl)aDtbc French Poxattbctfmcof tl)c fpcaUdig of tijcm, ano tbe 
 caufa dicendi ftjall not mal\c tftcnt acttonnblc Shaftoe on tl)c ot!]cr fioc falD 
 Cafe j^ctoo;D6 ate artlonablc;fo;tbcfctoojD3 thou haft been laid of the Pox, batiK 
 
 been atJjuDgeD aaionablc.tDbkb arc not fo fcaimaloms astbefc, Mich. 7 lac» 
 1 hou art a PocRy wliorc , and the Pox hath eaten out the bottom or thy bel- 
 ly tDCtc l)clD aatonable. Roll chief lufticefaio tl)c Ujojcs rrf)ufrcD tonft- 
 Dcvatlon; Luttl)ctoojDi5famto<mp!pt!)attl)c partp did facUcte tbat ftc 
 l)aDtl)cFrciuhPox,elfea]ctooult)not tjatieconcto be ctin-o, ancfo tbci? 
 ate fcanoalous, lerman luftice fat'D, intentions fi]al! not make ttojDc aai- 
 onablc, anDtl)Ctcfo;ct)c contcJteotbcp are not actonable. Nicholas lu- 
 ftice fafo, be concciteD tbcm prima facie to bc actfonablc , fo; Idojub ft)aU be 
 taitcn accojtfng to tb? common (ntcnument , anD an 0rtton on tbe Cafe 
 mapfomcttmcobcfajotJgbtnpontoo^DiS fpokcn bp f mplkatfon ano <ntcrro. 
 gation. A^k luftice tjclD t^ep iBCtc aCtonablc.iJut the Court faid they would 
 adviff.Poftea, 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc ^"P- 
 
 • Tllje Court foas moteo foj tbc qaaCbhtg an CEnnfdmcnt , foj fuffering 
 r°Vnd tt'."^ one to cfcape tbat teas taUcn foj iFelonp ; 3I5tit tbc Coptt Inoulo not 
 fhciit. qtiafl) ittl)ougl)tbeteU:astaufe,buto?DctctitljcjDrfcttDantftoulDplcaDto 
 
 it, bccaufc tt)cp belietjco \)e W componnbeD toitlj t^e ifclom 
 
 VVyac againft Harbyc. 
 
 Hil. 1 649* Banc, fup. 
 Mich, 1649 rot. 426. 
 
 AOTtitofCtto^tuasbjougbt to tcbetfc a 3!tHJgcmcnt giben in tbe 
 CouttatBarneftableinaftactionofSDcbtnponan £Dbligation, SClje 
 vcifca pig (jfrojafsigncD teas, tbat the place allcgcDfo J tbcpapment of tbe monp, 
 n.cnr i " O'l^' f„gj, fj,j (g gut of tftc {utfsDiction of tftc Coutt. Jt ioao anflnereo, tbatic 
 DC B.tr.citi- jg fjjjj, j^ Ijj. at Chitlfchatr.ptonafojefaiD, anoitDolb not appear tobctbet 
 Chitleharapcon be toitbin tbe jutisBittion of the Court, 0; toberc it ia , ano 
 tbercfo;e it (ball bc intcnncD to bc li^itbtn tljc juriooiction. Roll chief lufticc 
 faiD tbc2Dcclarationi0,tbattbe£)bligation \me at Barncftable, ano tbe 
 plea' ia tbat it iv.as at Chichicy lDb<cb is a fo jei'n plea , ano the plea ie not 
 mnn ncitbcr is tbcre anp ccmurrct upon tbe plea; but tbe plea is rece<= 
 tjcD anuDapaiben to ftocaiit, aiiB fo? not fircaring it accojoinglp, a 
 ludgcmenr. jutgcmcntis gibcn againft tbc plaintiff bp Default, tobctcas it ongbt to 
 babebana3uDaemcntnponaiuhildicitfo; inantofa plea, ano be faiD 
 P 7 , alfo, tbat if one plcao an infufficient plea, aitbougb it be a fo?cin plea , it ia 
 ore n pc < ^^^ necelTatp it ftjoulD be fh30?n. The ludgemcnt was ordered to be rever- 
 fed, except caulc flitwed to the contrary. 
 
 Jones
 
 Hil. 1649. 2-0 1 
 
 lones ag^inft Blunden. 
 
 HiU l649» Banc, fup, 
 Mich. J($4p.rot. 34, 
 
 AWSxlt of Ctro J Iras b?oncrt)t to rctcrfc a 3!ucc;emcnf gften in t\)t pa. Error ro r?. 
 late Court at Wcftminrterw an ^ctfon of ^flfjinU nno ISattcrp. SCljc^^^^' « ' .I"'^g«- 
 Cafe V.as t6(0, an actfon iuas fcjougljt fo; an aCTatJlt anti IBatterp in Surry; X"pf:3cT '" 
 SCfte j^efcnoant plcaos a pica ofjuttlficatfonfn Middlcfex: SEljc |)lalnt(ffcouitar 
 teplpeo tljat l)C beat ftfm in Southwark , ( tDl)icl) is in Surrv ) dc injuria fua WcftminKer, 
 propria ab'que tali caufa, anotljis tfftlCtSjas tT^'CtJ fap a 3;urp of MidlefexJO'a". 
 SCtje qucttioj] toastobctfterU inere a goou trpal. The Court would advifc. 
 Pollea.:?^^ 
 
 VVatfonagainft Norbury and oihers. 
 
 Hil. 1649 Banc. fup. 
 
 X 7^ 7 Atfon fajoagbt an Action upon tfte Cafe a^aintt Norbury a Com- Demurrer to 
 
 V w mifflioner upon tbe statute of 315ankrupt anu otl5er0,foj i^^Y^^"'"^-^ „„ 
 Ijcafctngofbts boufe, anotal-ingainaj,' bis gooos upon p?Etmce of tfjc ^J theVafe"" 
 faio Commifsion, tobcrcasbc toas no liSanbriipt , b^; rcafon tobercof be 
 li)ascnipairctiinbis£rcDit,anDl)tnojcDtnl)is2LraDc, ano Declares to fcio 
 Damage, &c. 2i:bc2Defcntiant pUans tbat t^e paintiffljao fccrctofoje 
 bjoucbtanattionofSErcfpaCrcaaatnft bim ioi tbc fame trcfpaffe, ano 
 gooDs tahen, ano ban rccotJcrco Damages againtt.btm. SEo tbts plea 
 tbepalntiffDcmurrcD -, Siid upon tbcceraurrertbenucafon teas tobetbcc 
 tbis plea pleaocD bp tbc SDefcnDant be a gooD plea in abatement of tlje to jit ^.^ ^^^^ 
 of ETCfpaffc, upon tbc Cafe note bjougbtjOj not s> ShnftooICcuritcl toitb ^'"^" ' 
 tbc ^plaintiff argueD tbat tbc plea toao not cooo, becaufc tbc matter in tftls 
 Action upon tbc Cafe,anD tbe matter of tbc fojmct action of SCrefpaffc arc 
 rotalloncjbjutarcfetcral ano tarlous matters, ano tbcrefojcfeberaU 
 actions map b: b;ou£btfo;tbcm, 5. rep, f. 43. Sparies ca(e, Hob. 493. 
 The Earl of Bcdfords Cafe, 4. rep, Siadej cafe, Petty brook I05. 4. rep. F. 4;. 
 Hudfonscafe, iiEd.j. Fitzb.TrefpafTe IC7. zR.j.f". 14, 18 ^. 4. f. 33* 
 20H.7. f.9. 12 E.4.f. ij.Fitzh.cftopchg.y H.4.f. 44^ 0nDttjctar:^ 
 ances bercfacttoecntf)e;actiott upon tbe Cafe, ano tbc Action of STrcfpafs 
 pjobetbattbep arenotallonct ;cino ttiat tberc is a Difference it ii5 plain,- 
 fo; in tbis Action upon tbe Cafe, it is faio tbat tbc DcfcjiDcnt dId enter 
 fnto tbc ipiair.tlffs boufc malitiofe; but In tbc former Action of Ercf« 
 pafs it toao faio.tbat 1}C QiD enter vi et armis, tob'tb '£! a plain Difference sno 
 t)ariancc,8 H. 6.f. jy. Cooks Entries fol. 59. AnD tbc matters p!cpD»:D 
 upon 3Recojo in tbcfe fclieral Actions do not ocflrop one another; but map 
 iDCll IlanD together, Pafc. J Car. Laicon end Barnardsca^e: AnD l;erc tbiS 
 ^action of tbc Cafe is to repair tbc plaintiffs crcDit ; but tbc fojmcr Action 
 toastorecobcrDamagcB, fo; tisgooBs taUen from bim. ^n abduxit of 
 Cattel tolll maintain a cbafing , auD one map therein recover foj tbc cba^ 
 fing, ano tbc talue alfo, fo berc both Actions map Cano toactbcr. Ano 
 tbcte is matter fo? both Actions, ano the matter plcaocD in Bar is but to 
 
 cncreafe the Damages, ano if tbe fpetial matter allegro tnthc Action cf 
 SCrefpafle allcgco in tbe Action upon tbc Cafe ban been letre,pct it is torll 
 cnougb, ano it is but fuqptufage, ano onlp bp uap of insuccment to pjoDc 
 
 ^D tbe
 
 201 
 
 Hill. 1649- 
 
 tlje fcannal , ano t^e JDcfcnuant licrc is not at anp mffcWcf, foj tlie too jus 
 berc arc onlp put U\ agrtatatfon of Dammagcs, 7 H. <5 . f. 34. aiiD fo pjapea 
 jticgcmcntfo? tbe piafntfff. Green of vCounccll toUl) tl)c E^cfcnoant 
 p?apeD t!)C Mrft niigftt be abatcD. JBccaufe 1. here is net anp tWng lafo , 
 tl)at ttjE E>i fenoant latljpofittbclp a(firmcD t\)t plaintiff to be aJBanhrupt* 
 2lp. SLfjcrc arc general Vuo jos in tijc fojmcr iJction,namcl)' aha enormia, 
 tDbicft tDo;03 CO tompjcljeno tljc matter foj lrl)icl)tl)i0 Action is noui 
 bjou2l)t, ano Ije oenpeo the ciffercntes taken bp tl)C Conncell on tljc otbcc 
 fine, anD it Dotb bcrc appear to tlje tTourt.tbat tbe fo jmcr Action of JCrcf- 
 paffc tens bjougttfoitlje fame tbings, ano carnages toere tbcrein giticn 
 fo; tbem,anr) it isa unreafonablc to puniflj one tisicc foj one ano tl^e fame 
 offence, ano tbe averment is gooD,anD cot!) ftctotbatbotb Actions are fo> 
 oncano tbe fametaufe , ancljcbatftrccoticrcD carnages alreacp foj all 
 tbe iuong lie futtaincD , anobcrc is no tcntcrlion allegec in tbc Cafe, 
 nojisitvictarmis, anctbcllaU) bates Double Veratfon , 9 H. 6. f. 54, 
 Brook brev. 397 3 H.7. 4.B''ook btev, 77.3110 camaijcsmigbttDcll enough 
 be retotiercD in tbefirtt5lctton,fo>aUtbc Damages fuftaineo , 19 H.6. f» 
 44. ;anDif tfeis jadionnotobjOHgbt, bac been bjougbt foj calling tbe 
 paintiffiBanhrnpt, tbciHition tooulD bate lien; but not as it is bcrc 
 bjougftt, anD one entire action fljaUnebcr be Dibioeo to put tbcpartp to a 
 coubletjcration, as it is in our cafe, 41 AiT. pi. i(5. Brook brev. 309. 5* rep. 
 Hudfons cafe, anD in tf)C firft action tbe toojcs alia enormia teere piirpofelg 
 put in, tbat all matters toucbing tbat Crefpafs migbt be b?ongbt in quetti= 
 on, to cncreafc tbe Damages, 9 E 4. Brook Trcfp. f. 109. anofoall tbc 
 Damages teererccotJcreD in tbe fo J mer action. Sinn be agrecD Laicons 
 cafe put bpShafto.tbat tbe plaintiff migbt rccotict Damages ns tocll foj 
 tbe taUie of tbe feibecp > as fo? tbe cbaftng oftbcm , anD pjapes tbe Mrit 
 map be abateb. Roll cliief lufticc faio, it is bare to maintain Laicons cafe; 
 foj cepit et abduxit iirtcnDs tbat tbc otoner batb not tbe &bccp again, otbcr- 
 U'ifcit toottlo be if tbe action bnD been foj tbe Djiting of tt:cm onlp. ano 
 Mr. ShsfcobatbtaUcna gooDgroanD,viz. tbat tbc actions arc foj fcfeerall 
 tbings , anD tbe SDcclaration is in part but an inDucement to incrcafe tbe 
 fcanDall , anD to pjotc it, ano tbe Ujojdb alia enormia (ball not be intenD* 
 CD of collateral matter , but of matter ir-cioent to tbc act cone ; anD one 
 anD tbc fame tbing map gibe fclicralcaufcs of action, anDxinc action is 
 not to be confounocB luitbanotbcr action, krman luflice faio, Laicons 
 Cafe teas not Ufectbis Cafe fojtbc tiucffionbercistobethcrtbe plaintiff 
 can rrcotier Damages in tbis feconD action , v.bicbbcbatb bp intenoment 
 tecot)ereD in tbe fojmer action, anobcinclinco tbat it map be fo bcrc, 
 auD tbat ficrc is a reco leering of tbe fame Damages in Dibcrs manners fo j 
 tbe fame tbin?. Nicholas lufticefaiD, be map bjing fetjcrall actions, 
 altbougl) be migbt bat>c jopncD tbem botb in one. Afk luftice faio, 
 Ji:i)atone act map be DitiscD into Dibers actions, ano fo it is bere, 
 anD teeU er.ougb. Roll chief luftice faio , tbe plaintiff in tbis actt. 
 on cannot recover Damages fo; b<s dUooDs, fo tbat tbis action is 
 bjougbt fo; anottcr matter. Therefore plead in chief if caule be not 
 (hewed to the contrary ,ror the Aflion doth well lye, 
 
 Mcers againft French. 
 Hll. 164P, Banc, Reg. 
 
 jude 
 ai ei 
 firm.r. t((,n 
 
 judermcnt ;r)T/;5anejeaionefirnnae, anoateroictfo; tbc plaintiff, Cbe SDefcnoant 
 nn eicfti ne ji motJCD in attcft of JuDgcment, tbat tbere is noccttaintp in tbe SOeclara-
 
 Hin.i64? 205^' 
 
 tfon ticftftcr of tl^c plntc noj of t||C qtrantftp, no} cf t1)c quaUtp of 
 tftc J.ant)to!3CtiectbepafntffftDasctcttci>,fo?ft(Be duobu? Acris Tondr, 
 Anglice^a l)opgrotiuD,tel)fcb ts not toarrantcD bp t!)c?Lat<R,anD fo ft is fnt ct' 
 tafti , anDUfflalfodimifitunumcroftura , anD a price .of ILatiD , atio tljc 
 quant<tpfsnot0):p?0(rcD,fOjftfBpcrefHmationemfive pins five minus & 
 medietatem five unara partem fs alfo tnccrtafn. Twifden aiintcrcD , it Uas 
 certain EnouBb,bccaufe it (BcrpjcffEDbp a certafn name. 315ut Roll chief Dcciar«ioh 
 luftice fa(D, it is 0OOD in grants; but not in a SDcclaration : to? tljcre isre-Gnm. 
 qa(reD mo?e cc.tafntp, arc tfjc Anj;lice Jjere Botb not ijcloit, fo? tbc Angli- 
 cetenottointcrpjcta JLatinnamebptrtfcbitis tallco.' ano tfje five plus 
 five minus fs alfo iU ; but if it ftao been fo manp Sieves per eftiraationem, it 
 I)aD been S00D» Therefore advife beccer of it. Antea» 
 
 Vaux and Vaux again ft Draper. 
 Hill»i<>49» Banc, fupf 
 • Entred Trin, 1649. rot, iio4> 
 
 VAux ant Vaux bjoucbt an action upon tfte Cafe figafnft Draper, upon ^rrcft of 
 a pjomifc, ano ncclarci), t^at tbc ©cfcnoant fn confiocratfon of "^eenncrtin 
 ten poiinos pain bp tbe |9laintif0 unto tljc SPefcnDant, dId a(ranie'"\^'°" "p- 
 anDpjomifc unto tljepiaintifs, to procure certain Cattciof tbc paintifsJpoAa'pro' 
 taben from t^cm bp a t^rti perron, to be reoelitcrcn unto tbcm bp fncb am.ic. 
 time, ano foj not pcrfo?mfng tl)fs p?om{fc tbep b?otiot)t tl^ctr action. tKpon 
 Nonaffumpfit plcaDCD,tt)crcteasanifrHC jopneD, anD a tertfct founu foj . 
 tift IBlaintifs, after t\)ie cafe ban been talcc fpofeen wnto, Cbc EDcfcntiant 
 motcB in arroff of fuopment, tbat tlji^ jattion teas not tDcH biotir.fit lopnt^ fl- 
 ip bp tbe lSlaintffo,but tbat tPcp oug^t to babe bjougljt ttoo federal ;9atono, ^"' * '°"' 
 inTegaTDtbattbcp?omifcuponU)btcbtbe0(tion iras founteu iDng not an 
 entire pjomirr,but teas a fctjcral pjomtfc maDc to cacb of tbc|9taintf fs.SC.bc 
 Councel on tbc otbcr Cocpjapeo fo? Suogement, ano faio t!)c pjomifc \vna 
 fntire,maDctobotb,anDnotfttteral. anofo tbcBlurpbatJCfounoit, tbfcl) 
 ftaU be intcnccD to be true : anti if it Ojoulo not be fo, it tooulo be cifaotan- 
 tagioufl fo? tbe SDefenuant. Hale* faio on tbe otfjcr ftDc, tbat tbc affcropfit 
 tfl rct3eral,anD tbc acts to be tore bp tbc SDcrcnoant to tbc piafntifs arc fe^ 
 tjeral, altbouab tbcsitumpfitfonnDsasaiopnt affumffit. Roll cliief lu. 
 flice faiOjSLbat tbe Confiueratfon gitjcn is entire anD cannot be DfbiD£D,ano 
 tbcre is no inconjjenfence in fopning in tbc jQctfon intW^'cafc; but if one 
 l^an b?ongbt tbe Action alone, it migbt batic been queClonablc. Nicholas 
 ano A$k lufticesof tbc fame opinion. J5ut Jerman luflice Differro , ano 
 faiB, tbat tbep are febcral pjomifes, viz. to celibcr fucb Cattcl rci^erallp to 
 eacb of tbem, as Dio belong p?op:rlp to tbem , ano fo tbere mud be ttoo fe* 
 tcral Actions. But Judgement was given for the Plaiocif, except better mae* 
 tcrlhewedf Antes, 
 
 Spry againft Mill. 
 
 Hill. i(54P, Banc, fup, 
 
 Pa(cb, I^49,rOt. 308f %, • Error to rc- 
 
 N' verrc'a judge- 
 
 1^ a Wixit of erro? bjougbt to tcbetfc a Sluogcmcnt gibcn (.1 a Crobct "?".'nd M,Z' 
 ano ConbCrRon at Launccfton fn Cornwol, npon a nihil dicir, Preftwood vcifion. 
 
 . SDOa ■ motjfD
 
 Qp4 Hill. 1649. 
 
 motet), tljattbcrccojD is not certlfieDjfojUfsrctarncD bponc tobo Itf not 
 Abatement 3"0e<^ t^ctc ; fo J ft f s tctumcD bp tl)c i^.ifo J, ^iDcrmcn , miD HDcputp^rc- 
 co;Dcr,U)l)crcastbctD?ttof(iDtto?U)a3 torctiiniarccojDUcfojctl)ci»a<oj, 
 ailOctmMt, ant) mccojDer, 1 E.y.f. 3. Jordanano Tompkins cafp, i648» 
 Upon this the writ of Error was abated. 
 
 Wats againft Dix, 
 
 Hill. 1(54-9. Banc, fup. ' ' 
 
 Trin, 24. Car< rot. 1529, 
 
 Argument T" ^ffl cafc luafl agafn srgucD.b)) Halts foj tftc piafntif , ano bp Tmtden 
 whcviiera 1 foj t^c SDcfcnoant 5 coulD not bear Hales but fmpcrfcctlp;i:;bercfo?e 
 jcafcwcU 3|omftbi5^rs«mcnt. Twi!den,tbatarguso fojtbe SDcfcnoant, put tbe 
 dire !o'^' cafe bjfcflp tbus. a JFeofmcnttoasmaDcoflanostoI, S.fnfcc, untHbc 
 dircftionof . ftoulD maUc H Icafc Of 2i pcatfe to A. B. from tbe fcaft of Philip ano lacob; 
 DLcai.itiufl.l.S.maltcflalcafcfojzi pears, to begiitat tbe fcaftof Piiilip ano lacob,. 
 ano be bclD tbfs teas a gmo JLcafe, maoc acto jDfng to tbe Dtccctfott of tbe 
 H>BEi>. 2lp,3if<tbenota0ooi>3lcare, pet tbcufcQjall not retjert to tbe 
 iFeoffo J. 3 Ip, ^t belD tbat tbcrc fs neltbct a gmo bargain ano falc, no j Dotf> 
 ittDOjUbptoapofufc. #ojtticfirftpo<ntbebclD,tfftbaDbccnbp uiap of 
 pleaoing, ft bao not been gmo fn purfuancc of tbe Slgrecmcnt : otbertuf fe ft 
 is bcfng founo bp bcrDfct ; but here tbe agreement ano tbe fiitentfon of tbe 
 p3rtfC0f0fattcficD,anotbEtiarf<incefs notconfiocrablc, & de minimis non 
 .curatlex, loIac.Hob. f. i20. 38E.3.f.7. Waftc3T, zip, 3ln tbe 3laDgc« 
 ment ano cttf matfon of men, at ano from arc atcompteo to be all one fn Gg- 
 Jifficatfon. 3n tbe &tat. of 3 2 H. 8. ft fs fo tat;en, ano fn tbe. &tat. of 27 
 H. 8, of enrollments, ano ujojos ftallbc tonttruco accojDfngto common 
 tntcnomcnt. ^nofftbcrcbcatiarfance, pcttbenfercftsfntbe iFcoffees, 
 ano (ball not rctjcrt to tbe iFeoffoj : foj tbe toojo until, fs an ilDberbof 
 tfrflC, Boraftonscafe; &fr Andrew Corbets cafe, 11 Rep. f. S'5» Dyer 300. 
 ? Eliz. Mores Report?, 5 lac. &fr Gu^ Fairfaxtafe : ff tbep maUe not tbe c- 
 ftatc, tbe cftate remafns fn tbcm. Sno ff ft do not remain fn tbe ircofFcc0, 
 pet ft cannot rctjert to tbe jTcoffi) j,foj be batb conbcpco from bf mfelf all tbe 
 cftate tbat be bao, ano ffit return to tb^ i^coffoj, ft fsa offfcfOin, 2 Rep. 
 Butlers cafe; i^.no foj tbe barcaln ano falc, tljat cannot be gmO; fo; bere 
 fsno Confioeratfon, but tbat ipblcb is paft, ano not continuing, tobfcb is no 
 goooConflOeratlon, Plow. Com. 50J, ij Car, Burton ano Sherly. sip, 
 2Ebe Conriocratton,iitb";tc be anp,f0 not mcritojfous, foj'ougbt anp tbfng 
 appears, tbe monies map not be offcbargeotobfcb are lafo out, ano fo tbe 
 2Dcfentant remafns unfatfsfieD,anD fo tberc can be no ConCocratfon, Aliens 
 tafCjjsCar. :;lp,31ftbcDcbtbeolfcbargeo, pet ft cannot raffc a ufe, fop 
 bere fs no monfes, palo but a Debt ; 0no a ufe f s not ralfeo here , bccaufe ft 
 teas tbe fntcnt of tbe parties to pafs tbe lanobp toapof bargafn ano falc, 
 Ed. Foxes cafe, 13 Eliz. Piowd. 1,2,11 Car, Whitfield anO Pierce, rot, 438,. 
 0nD f f one f ntcno to pafs an cttatc out of btmfelf, be map do It citber bp tbe 
 Common laa)o;bpg>tatutclato. Roll chiefJufticc fats JflanOs are palTco 
 fojmoncponljVbeoeeoougbttobeenrolleO; butffitbcfojmoncpanona- 
 F nroi.uTcnt. jjj^^jj affc^(Q„^ (t <53 ^^Q^ nccDfuU to enroll it , but tbe lanos infll pafs toftb« 
 '■ outcnrolmcnt. 0no fo bere tbclanopaffcs one irap oj otber; ano ff tbe 
 
 ufe Itfll rlfc^ll tbe otber points are out of oojes. ano tbcrc fs bere a con* 
 tfnning conCocration to raife a afc. ISut tbe main queftion is tobctbettbe 
 ufe rifetb to tbe iFcoffoj , if not, all tbe otbcr points are gone, ^no be ftelo 
 
 tbat
 
 tbat ^crc teas onlpa mctr matter of trutt,? tijsfntcnt fslToTtbnt tfje iFcof^ ^' 
 
 fees fljall batjc anp tljfng bp tt)c not petfojming tftc trtiff , but tijc iife Cjall 
 fcctotbciFeoffo?. ;anD tljcrc can be no o(ffciQit fn tljc cafe. 2im Ijere 
 fs a material Dfffcrcncc in point of la\D, in t!;c maWng of ttfs Icnfe, foj (t fs Leafe. 
 mace fo J one nap mo?c ttjcn teas agrccD b}» tbc occu , fo j that Icafc tons to 
 begin from tl)e fcaft of Philip anB /acob;<ino tljts Icafc is mane to be bcefn at 
 tl)c"jFeaft of Philip ano lacob. lerman luOice Ijclc , tbat tljc fntcnt of tf)c 
 parttCB is pcrfojmcD , anD tljattftcre fs no material ciffcrcncc , ano l)clD 
 foj tlje SDcfcnuant. Nicholas luftice fafo , text is no performance of tt)e a. 
 grccmcnt, fojJ^UtftcparttcgagrecDnottotljfsEcare, foi ft ia mace foj 
 longer time tbantoaoagrecD; ano be bclo tlat the iifc ftall be to tf)e other 
 parties bp contingencp, anti that tjerc fs no DfOTcfSn- Ask luftice faio, 
 aU the DffficuUp is tobcther the Icafc be mane tsi not ;" ann he hdo it 
 iras a gooD leafc acco joing to the agreement, ano fafo that the fntcnt fo not 
 that the iFeoffccsfliaUhaticanp thing, but that ft ttiall refiilf to the ifcof< 
 foj. Roil chief luftice fafo, the intent ofthcpartfcsfliall not be tmplpcD a^imeBr 
 gainft tftC OfrettruUS of JLato, Nil capiat per Billaranif),&c. 
 
 Pendarvis againfl Dawkcs. ' • 
 
 Hill* id49,Banc,rcg. 
 
 PEndarvis brought an 0ctfon of accompt againtt Dawkes fo j Difcers fums Arrtft of 
 of monp as his receiver 2Dhe SDefcnoant plcaoc thatasto aDcFceptteii luJRcmentip 
 pounosneunqucs receptor; upon this an fffnc Inas jopneo, ano a teroid Accompt. 
 fonnDfojthcpiaintff. Ehe ©cfenoant moDeo in arreft of JuDgement, 
 that it Dothnot appear tDhat ten pountJothcp arc that arc mcnrioncD fn the 
 plea', anufoftisinccrtainiDhEt^rthepbcpartof the monies, foj tohfcft 
 the action fsbjought. Roll chief luftice faio, be onght to hatic erpjcffco 
 lubattcnpountjgitis, fojasitfSjitfsintertain, ano fonotgooD, There= 
 fore take a Dcnire facias De notio , for though the jflue be not well joyned , ^'"""^^ ''^ "**" 
 yet the Declaration is good. 
 
 Cowley again ft Lcdon. 
 
 HilU 1649. Bajic.reg. 
 
 Trin, HCar, rot. p32» 
 
 T0 a tDjff of Crrojt to rc\)crfc a lutjgement gibcn in an miction of Debt np- wnr of Er- • 
 -*onani©biigatfonthecafcVDaBthi0» ^nc iras bonno in an £)bligation r.ir to rcvc'rfc 
 C roj the papmcnt of certain fums of monep ) toajFcme fole, the ^cme ^ '""^R^^'cnt 
 tabcslSaronanDDicB I»S. tafecs out ILcttcrs of Homfnfffratfon of the'"""' inDcbc, 
 GOODS ann Chattels of the iFcme, ano bjf ngs an actfon of SDcbt upon the 
 iDblfgatf on agaf nft the HDbligo j. SLhe iDbligoj plcatjg that bp the r ntcrma=: 
 TfageofthcifcmetbeDebt Due upon the ;©blfgatton became Due to the 
 SBaron, ano Dcmanos Sluogcmcnt ^>i Aftio, 2Co this |Olca the paintif be* •^1!°'''^ '" 
 muts. She Court fafo this JDcbt cue upon the bono became not Due to the "' 
 ^iisbano, fojitis atbingin^ction , ano tbcrcfojetlie plea is not good. 
 
 ^ D 3 lones
 
 106 Mich. 1649 
 
 lonesagainft Blundcn. 
 
 Hillt 1649. Banc, fup, 
 
 Michid49. rot. 34» 
 
 wheriiei a HT ^fg Cflfc fojiitcdp Tpofectt to toas agaftt motcu bp Wild, iBbo Ijclo, 
 
 goodtryai or -» t't)at tit rcgatD tl',at tljc matter triable atifctl^ from ttoo places, atiDfo 
 
 ""• tbs venire map be from botl) places ; petftislDcUenouc^Kttbe from anp 
 
 oft^cm, anotbe Court t)att) I urisDictfon in botti places, anottjerefoje Vnt 
 
 trpalfstocllcnougl)fn tbtscafe. TwifdenontljcotljerODcfafD, tftat ^ere 
 
 are ttoo fffues (11 trpal , ano fo ft fs not toftl)(n tbe 6>tatiite of ^cofaflg > fo> 
 
 tljat fo of fojce onip iMfjcrc one fffue in trpcD. Roll chief luflice anftoeren , 
 
 I)ere are not ttoo ilTucs, fo^ pou ^alie maoe t^em one bp picatifng, ano fo 
 
 ft is toUljfn tl)c statute of Scofafls, ano ftelpeo bp ft . Icrman Juftice to tibe 
 
 ^f"' •. fame fntent : ano fo Nicholas ano Ask lunices. Roll cliief luftice fafo , tljat 
 
 Jeofails. tftcfCrueJsjopncD upon tfte matter arffingfnbotb places, annpctft fstoeu 
 
 cnougb ; fo;t^cp?tncfpal matter toasfn Sc. Clements Danes. Therefore 
 
 let the judgement be affirmed, except better matter be (hewn, Antea. 
 
 Adftone againft Hunter. 
 
 Hill, 1469. Banc fup. 
 Arrcft of A Dfton bjougfet an actfon upon i\^z cafe agafnft Hunter anu fjfs txUf fe foj 
 
 lud(tcnicntin^t|jcfCt0O}DOfpoi^en Of tljC Pafntffbp Hunters toffo , VIZ. Jane Adflon« 
 
 the Caft°" °" ^^^ bewitch my good mar, innuendo her Hbsband. vEIpon i^ot gtjfitp plcaO- 
 BD., anu a tUlcrofct founo fo j tbc piafntff, ft toaa mottco fn iSrrcIt.of (uoge* 
 mcnt tljat tl)c toojos toere too general , ano unccrtafn,to raffe anp fcanoal, 
 ano tl)rrcfo;e an ^ctfon coulo not be bjongljt fo> fpcaljfngof tbcm. Shaftoe 
 ofCounccltoftbtbepafniffljelD tljat tljc toojos are atffonable, becaufc 
 tljcp Declare an 0ct j tbfng Done, ano tljc partp fs fcanualfjco bp tbc toojos, 
 4 rep. Icames Ijia cafc , anB t^c too;DB my good man are toojDfi toell t^noton 
 to Cvpjcfstjcr^^USbanDbp, as 7 lac. tofap, Thou art a healer of Felons, 
 to«0 toell nnBcfftoot) to mean a Concealer of iFclons ; ano ft tljc toojos 
 pood man bc fitccrtafn , pet tljcp arc certain cnouglj to fljcto tljat fomc boop 
 fa bctoftcbcD , foj tljc 0ct oonc fa certaf nip enouglj cj;p;eirci), anc tljc ^lafn= 
 tffffltljercbprcanoalfjcD, anobcQocoftfsaftcra taierotrt, ano bp ft tftcp 
 - arc maoe certain, ano Damages ate gften foj fpeahfng tljem , Mich. 15 
 
 C»fV-. Car.Com.Binc.Srones cafe rot. 2<5.RoIl chief luftice faf9,2n!jcfcteO?D0,Tbou 
 
 haft bewitched a man are actionable, "i ft fs a frantial to fap, One hath killed a 
 man by Wicchcra'r.anO IjC IjelD t^C toOjDS actionable. lerman luftice fafO.tl^ep 
 toulo not bc aiifonablc. becanfe bp tljcm tljerc fa no ad of toftcljtraft cjpjef* 
 feo.Nicholas luftice fafD,tlje too jOs arc not actfonablefo j thou haft bewitched 
 one mzT^ bc fpoUen f n a gooo fence, ? too job arc but tofno , (i fpohrn fn paf« 
 Con fomctfmc?, ano other times fn 5cft 0? mrr\ fm?nt. Ask luftice fafD,tbat 
 
 Arcrmcr.t. tlJC toojto tcno to fcauDal flsttep arcfpoUcH, anb Qjall be ftttcnccD tbat tftc 
 fjallj bctofttfjeo oncbp2Dfatolfcal;art,9nDRoli chief ]uftic£ fafo, 3tf3 not 
 ncccffarptoatcrtoljatactof tKHftclj^craft toag Done. ;anD thefc toojDs, 
 Thou haft bewitched me and my Aunt Ijatic been aOjilDgcD 0(t(onaOlC fn 
 tljfg Court. It was adjourned to be argued again the next terra. 
 
 "" mi
 
 Hill. 1^49. 207 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc fup. 
 
 ^^eCoarttoa0mol3COtoquaCbani©?ijetof a pjiftate ^cfistons of i^^Q°2z*oi*' 
 -"- peace , t^at iuas rcmotjco W\)Zt Up Certiorari. SCtie £D^Der itjag , tljat private Scfn- 
 onefljoalncontdbuteto^nlftftc cbarscto'jjariJst^eUccpJns of a JlBaftatOons ofPcicc. 
 CWlD, bccaufchcDtofufferafeoulDtettogcttlje Cbflo upon t\ft boop of 
 i){0 jpatu fcrtatit. SElje Court fafotbts lias not tnitftfn tt-c Statute of 18 
 ElizranOtljcrefoje let the Order be quafticd, 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc, fuper. 
 
 ApjobibltiontotfteCourtoft^canrnfraltp teas pjapco foj BlnckesJ'fJ^^^PJ^^^' 
 a ClarU of t^s Court fo; Ubellfng agafnft ftfm tJjetc fo j pjofEcutfng a Adrair»ity. 
 matter at tbe Common ILato, tob(cl) t^cp pjeteno to belong to tljcfc Court, 
 anofojstantfnsantnjanttfonagafnft \}im to ttop l)<s pjocecofngs. SCfte 
 Court anftocteo tljcre to no Kbel bere , tl)f s is but a cftatton to appear , zno * 
 
 f0 no 3 n junction agafnlt bim ; but bctaufc upon tl;c cftatton tftcre appcarco 
 to be matter of JOjobtbttlon contafneofnft, A Prohibition was granted,. 
 
 Saunderfbn againft Raifin. 
 
 Hilli 1 549. Banc. fup. 
 
 V|9ona rule f OjeiB caufe tcl^p a Juttgcment OjoultJ not be rct3crfci),J***'^"J' 
 tbc Court Ujas motjeu tftat ttjc 3iloll iBbercfn t^e C-rroj afsf gnco toas En'o'rVaV 
 migbt be amcnocD accojufng to tbej©;<gtnal toWcft is rfgl)t, t^ougl) tJjefigncd. 
 Nifi prius 9RoU be not fo. Holhead ontbc otljcr CoepjapcDtbcrc mfgbt be 
 no amcnomcnt, but tbc 3!uogmcnt rcV£rfcD,fo? {f Jiidcc ment Lc g<tcn upon 
 an crrontous SDctlarat<on,U)b<cl) fs the grouno of tbc adton, as it 10 bcre,ft is 
 notgooD, nojfsamcnijable. aCbc Court anftocreo , tbfiJf^tljc fault of tbe^me 'meat 
 Clarh , tol:o ban tlje original bcfo je btm , tebtcl) io tbc grouno of all , ann ""■ * 
 bp tobicb be ougbt to fojm tbc SDcclaration. iBut tbc matter fs tbat bcrc it 
 fa after a merofd: , annittoUlbe pcrtUousto attaint tbe 3iurp, tbougb it 
 being tbe Claris fault,it be amcnoable. But let it reft till the next terra,and 
 in the mean time we will advifc. 
 
 Williamfbn againft Mead. 
 
 Hill. 1^49. Banc, fup, 
 
 Mich. 1(549, rot. 428. 
 
 ■^ 7 T 7 Illiamfon bjongbt an 0£t{on upon tbe Cafe agaftiff Meade, ant) BC» 
 V V clarcD upon tb?ec AiTumpfus maoe bp tbc SDcfcnoant to tbeJ,7*,J|,t -,. 
 Paintif, tbattbeSDefenoantsfonOjoulDpapfucbarum of moncp to t^c-naftionup 
 ipiaintif foj tjic boaroing teitb Um , irlicn be fljouln be tbcrcunto rcqufrcD ; '^n an Af- 
 npon ronAffumpfit plraDcD,anD a ticroict fo? tbcplatntif,tbc2Defcnoant mo-''""^Ffic- 
 teofnarrcftofSuogcmcnt. SCbattbelpiaintiftiotbnotfljeto tljat be oio 
 require tbc &on to par tbc fnm of moncp , ubicb the SDcfcnosnt cio auumc 
 fljoulobcpalDuponrcqueft; but onlpfaitb that tbc SDcfcnoant licet /spius 
 requifuus non folvit. JEbc SuDgcmcnt toao arreftcD till caufc Oionlo be 
 ftieton to tbc contratp. Ebc fame nap it teas motco a£a(n,nnD tbc Countci 
 
 urfiCB
 
 Rcqucft. 
 
 zo8 Hil. 1649. 
 
 utgcD tftat t\iz teqaeitt teas noTncccffarp to be maue, ano pjapco foj juDge* 
 ntcnt. 15ut Roll Chief luftice anflDcreu, tftat t^fa teas a collateral pjo. 
 tnffc, aiiDtljercfojet^ercqueftniHflbcatetrca to be maoc to tl)C &on» 
 SC^ctcfo je tbc patnttf can ftatie no juogcment , ano fo nil capiat per biilam 
 was ruled to be entred, 
 
 Hudibn. 
 
 Hill. '6A9, Banc, fup. 
 
 For time to T" ^t Court loas ittoticD tl)at tftete toas a fcire facias fffneD out to ccrttfic 
 
 auignEiror:. "^^ Gttojs , anD time toasDECrcD to afsfgn tbcm. IBut t^c Court anfipc. 
 
 rcD, t^cb;fngfngoft!)c\BjftofCrro: la oclnp cnougljj anu tijcrcfojeif 
 
 you have not afligncd the Errors according the rules of the Court, ;tLey ftjil! 
 
 not be now accepted. 
 
 , Dewickagainft Bamber. 
 
 Hilit 1649. Banc. fup» 
 
 Tiut -n Ac nr ^^ ^''*'^* ^^^ moticD upon an Affidavit tbat tbe SDefcnoant mfgW 
 tor'pcy might . pIcaD anD jjoe to ttpal , bccaufct)ts3tto?ncp Ijattj appearcD; anu noto 
 be forced to i)c'faftftbef3not anattojncpoftbfsCourt, anoDot^rcluCc toplcao. Roll 
 plead. jj^jgf luftice anftoCreD , If fte hath appeared, and yet will not plead , enter 
 
 ?'"■ your judgement againft this Clyent , and though he have not appeared, if he 
 
 Appearance. J., ' r. " ' .■ j ■ rr > 
 
 did promile to appear we will rorcc mm to doe it 
 
 Whitchurch againftPagor. 
 
 Hill, 1(54?. Banc, fup. 
 
 Toht rtfto- -y ^ Coutt toas mo1?cB iti tfec bebalf Of Whitchurch aClctfe of tbfsCoart, 
 red 10 a _ I j-jjgj jjj. jj,{g|j{ ijg rctto jco to ffls iDffice in tbe Office of tfte Cuftos brevi. 
 i^'ii.c ci^foi^^'^ff °?^'"'^ f"° ^" 2>:Bcr of tljta Court.otftertoife tfjat he map bate Ubcrtp 
 r.rcviuni ot- to bj<ii0 i}t6 0it(on agarntt the Cuftos brevium. SLljc Comt. anflocrcDjtbat 
 ficc. tbc fp:.ff cr of t^e £)fficc fs anfteerablc fo; all \iie Clerk e , ana batl) potoet 
 
 ot?er tbem , anotijcp arc not iHJfficcrs but mat &er"oant3, ano therefore 
 Rcai-.iititn. tlbcrcfsnorcrticoptobcbaij in 3Lato agafnft htm, but tn Confcrrncc he 
 
 OUglit to TCffoje l)lm. Therefore let him (hew caufe next Ferm why he ftiould 
 
 notbcreOored, 
 
 In Michaelmas Term i654- After divers motions and hearing whst was 
 cbjc-fted on both fides, upon his fubmifiion in Court to Mr, Paget the Mafter 
 ofchcOifice heprorailedto reftore him. 
 
 A/ich 1 649- Banc ■ fup. 
 
 Arrcft of '-J ^c Coutt ioas motjcD ftt 0rrcaof3aO0cinenttfeattbcplafnt<ftoa6i9 
 
 fc/p w 'ir e ^"^^"^^ °^°' ^"^ ^'^^^ P"'' P"^'"'^'^ ""f"' ^^^^^^ "^Sbt not to be i fo> after Ijc 
 per Gujrdi .^3 1 7 pearc pears olD fcc ought to fue pec Aitornacum fuum. 2Ct)e Court an- 
 ruiii, fincreOjtljtsfsnogooDejccptJon, foj(fljcbctotfctnthe?Jgeof 21 pears, ^c 
 
 map fuc pji- guardianura , anD be fa aomlttcD fap ttie Cuurt to ooc fo. And 
 
 therefore let the Plaintif take his Judgement,
 
 Pafc. 1649. 209 
 
 Bigford againft Toplam. 
 
 Pafc»i<J4?. Banc.fup. 
 Micli.i<5-;9ror. 8j, 
 
 AtSarftofetroj tufiis b;ci;at}t to rcbcrfe a %iimmci\t fftcn in an ^,7(c7%T' •' 
 flctfon of SDebt upon an obUgatfon toft^ tbe contttton fo; tbc pnpmcnt n,.^,„ ;„ ..cbr-. 
 ofa certain fum of moncp after tljc return of tftssdjip, to the po:t of Ply- • 
 mouth, snbc Dcfcncant plcaDeo a fpettal pics, to MM) tl)C piafntlff ce= 
 matrco, 1 upon tbts Demurrer tl)c 3 uogemciit teas fittcn foi t^e |piafnt(flF, 
 uponiDljtcfj 3uDgcmenttbetoj(tof(£rroj toas bjougljt. Wadham Wind- 
 bam afcfgncD To j erroj, i. SCljat t!)crc tffuco aponeoutoft^eComtof Ply^' 
 njouth, returnable tbe » of March , ano tbc Defendant ofo not appear tUl 
 tbcSofMarch, anO fo there f0 a Difconthiuance. Hales of Councell on Difomiru- 
 tbeotberQD0,anftoerct),tbattl)ci3la{nttfft)aDacccptcii of a SDetlaration , aiuc. 
 ano fo tbat fault <s belpco. 2Cb': Court anfircrcjj , t^c acceptance of tljc 
 SDEclaratfonOotbnotbelpit: 315uttbeiK.ecojD fs not fo, tbcrcfojc pafles 
 oufter. ^ 2d.(JtccptfonlDas,tbattbcre <)3noba(ltaUcn,fo^{tts crronc- *'' 
 ous faafl , ano fo ftall be accomptco no ba<l. JEbe Court anftocrcD,tl)fs is 
 not material \)trc. Si 3d. Crccptlon toaij. tbat it is fain tbat the plea teas 
 ficlDbcfojctbethenJ^afoj, anD ootb not fijcto that be teas clcctcD. SLbe 
 Court anftDsrcDjit is toeE cnougb as it te, tbougl) it mia^t babe been otbcc- 
 tDife. Icwasadjournedi 
 
 CuflodesIJbeitar. Sec. againft Mountain and Lyda:- 
 
 Pa Tc, 1649, Banc, fup, 
 
 A jp Information toas crWbUciJ bp tiie iattojnep gcncrell againff tbcSDc- ocx.urrer to 
 
 •^^icnuantg fo j engrofctng titers ^crco of Co'.n. SEb- p pleaoco tbat tbep 3 pica t-. an 
 
 Ijaa been. b?retofo;c pjofccutco in the Court of tljc ©rcbrqucr , hho toerc •ntorimn'^n 
 
 acquittcD tbereof. %o tbis plea tbe attojncp general oemurreD, ano thefe ^'" "6''°"''g 
 
 reafons lucre CbelueD irbp tbe plea teas not gcoo. i. 3t is not pleaoco tbat 
 
 tbep lucre acquittco bp jnogement, j upon a bcroict, j upon a fo jmer m^ 
 
 formation ejbtbitcDacainfttbcm. ilp. 3tDotb not appcaj: tbat tbe ©^ 
 
 cbcquecbaD|urisiiictionoftbecaufp» jlp. SLbcrecoulDbcno infojmati= 
 
 on oulp cjbtbfteD, foj it is faio to be tbe 10. of Septeraber,tobicb is cut oftbe 
 
 SCcrm, ano fo tbe Court DID not fit. zip. tbercisnoiffue jopneD,foj tbe 
 
 plaintiff raitb,ponitfe5:<vc iibcrcas it being bpirap of recital, ougbt to 
 
 babe been pofuit ie , ano tbe Ottier faitb. p-'tiit quod inquiratur per patriam. 
 
 jlp acberc is no bcrDict in tt^c Cafe, fo; tbe iCTue is non culp. contra Statu. 
 
 turn, anQ tbe licrotii is non eft culp. )uxta Sta'utum, 4lp. SLbcrc is no juDg- 
 
 ment, fo; it is eat ad pi sefcnf , anB it ougbt to be iret sd tunc. 5 Ip. SEb^rc is no 
 
 alicrmcnt, tbat tbe fitft information Xms foj tbe fame offence, dip. Ebe 
 
 infoimation ougbt to be in tbe fame Countp, bp tbe &tatutc of 2 1* Jac. ano 
 
 tbe IBarons of tbeCrcbequcr are not JuDges bptic Statute, ano fo pjares 
 
 ^tiogcmrntagainfttbeSDcfcnoant. Hales of Councell toitb tbe 2Dcfcn« 
 
 Dantanfloerroto tbe tbiro crccption. SCbst in tbe Crcb qucr tbcrc is a 
 
 Court tbe JO. of September to rcccite informations, aitbougb it be otit of 
 
 tbe aCerm time, flno be faio tberc is a gooo ilTuc iopnco , ano a gooo bee 
 
 ottt, foj tbe toojBs juxca €t contra in tbis place babe one ano tbe fame fence.
 
 xio Pafch. 1649. 
 
 ^nutljcjimgemciitfaalfogooo. nnotlicdtfojmaffon toao focll bjoiinlH 
 <ntl}cCi;cl)Ciincr,»iotUi<tbftan3fi!Ctbc fetatutcof 21 Jac, foj tl;c offence 
 lDa3iiiMidleftxltJl)crct!)c€-):t!)equ£tfs. 0!foff tfje SiiDecmciit be not 
 gooD bprcafon of €rro;, pft it ftail be EtcomptcD nooD,tni tt be atotDcD bp 
 pica: ^nDaU!)Oiic!)it be crroncono, fct \)txz is a cifcont^nuame; foj 
 Micb. 24 Car. v^-t. 1 o bn ttac iljfcf 3uCtcc Of tfte Commons |9lf as . ano not 
 foUfcttcr, 30 t!)C pica ftippofetl). Tlie Court anf*ered , tl)at thcprcmnot 
 taUc notice of tijat: janDl)cre<sno ifftic lopneo, noj anp contiiuianccto 
 part of tbc pica plcaocBbptljcSDcfcnDant, anDtfjeucmurrct ?ocg not to 
 tftc pica, upon tobicJjtbc pattp piitc bfmfclf npon tlje Cotmtrp, ano tijcrc fa 
 no Dcmntrcr to tfeat. SEljc Demurrer ia rcferrcD to tl5C;[aa p!ca,anD not to 
 all, ano fo itcrc is a Difcontinuancc to part, ano tftc firC 3uoncmcnt ia not 
 tjoic,unttllit bcatoiDCDbppIca, ano l)crctl)c fact toss ocnc in tIjeCountp 
 
 yj^';J,^"'^""'tol)crctf)cC-j:cI)rnucrf0, ano fotl)c315aron6arc3ui>?esof it bptbc feta. 
 
 'D7r.'o'ntinu- *"t^ 5 3"^ ^ fi""^ ^^^^ ^^ tciocablc is not tofo, tnitill it be maoe fo bp plcao. 
 
 ;n cc. Inc. 5lnD if i'ou cannot anftecr toe Dircontini!ance,all tljc reft (3 to no ptir- 
 
 Ciy;ior3ri. pofc, tl)Ercfo?c taUctimc to anfiicr ttat. 3tUjagfmD alfo bp the Court, 
 tl)at lljc SDefcnoant map remote an information ct^fbitco againft bim, out 
 of anp Conntp to tljc Courtaat VVeflminaer , notttitliftanoinfl lljc S)ta= 
 
 tUtCt 
 
 Hamond againflKingfrnill. 
 
 Pafci 1 549, Banc. fup» 
 .Ar 'ft of 1^ Araond a ^afiict of peace bjougfet an action upon fljc Cafe againtt 
 
 H 
 
 I V"or" °" tl Kinfifraill, fo? fpeafeing tljefc fetcral ico?ti0 of bim, vJz. Sf)t Hamond 
 didof his own head put into Mores confefCon chat he ftole the Lambs, 0nl> 
 alp. That be was a debauched man, and is not fit tobea lufticeof Peace, 
 tmpon not gtiiltp p!caDcD,ano a ticrsict foj tl^e plaintiff , aCfje JDefcnoant 
 ttiol'CD in 0rrcft of ^uogcmcnt tljat none of tbe Inojts tocre actionable o\ 
 at leaft t!}c laft Idojds arc not , ano fo Hiiogcment cannot be gibcn.jIFoj'tbe 
 firftiBOjtflfter8io,tl)cpooel)ttobetahen in mitiorifenfu, ano tfjcp map 
 Ijatea goooccnftru£tion,\i7,. tbat be framco tfje £onfcf0ion toftfiotjt being 
 IjClpeO bp anp Ot I'Cr boOp. ^nO fo J tbC fCCOnO IdOJDc that he was a dcbanch- 
 cd roan tljcp cannot toucb bis office at tbe pjefent , Mich. 24, &: 2 j. eiiz. C. 
 Banc.i .becaufc tbcp arc fpohen in tbe p?etErperfccttence,?not intbc p?efcnt 
 tcnce. Efte Court faio tbat tbe Itojos, toaa a ocbaucbco man,arc inccrtain 
 iDO JDS. Therefore take lodge mem for the firit words , and nil capiat per 
 billam for the fecond, except caufc fhc wed to the contrary. 
 
 lenningsagainft Lee. 
 
 Pafc, i(549' Banc, fup. ^Zn^ /sn, /^5, y.^ 
 
 Fnr'a rerica-lEnnings faioaobtan 5l£tfon of 0irs«Uano3!Patferpnnaf}iff Lee, SCbe 
 
 <!erbrcr^rc . i SDcfcnoant p'.caDCD non ful. totbe3i5attErp,anopleaC£DafpeciaIi«af« 
 
 an imma.f rbi fif gtiott 30 to tijc SUfault' 3It tpas pjapBD tbcrc migbt be a rcpleaocr gran- 
 
 iflucjoynec'. jeo, becaufe tbeiffuc jopncD f0 immaterial. SEbe Cotintel on tbe ctbcr 
 
 Coepjapcofoj^u'JScnicnt. Wild bclo, tbat there is an 3ffue (opneD,foj, 
 
 tbe IRccojo faitb fo , ano ti;e Hurpbate founo tbe 3ffue , ano if it be ill, « 
 
 Is not bclpeo bp tbe statute , ano fo tberc can be no 3lH0gement. ISLW iffuea 
 
 are not jopnco bp an ejipjcffe affirmative, ano an cjpjeffc ncgatibc , foj ff 
 
 ft be but bp implication it is gooo cnougb. Sin immaterial 3ffae ie not 
 
 b^lpcD
 
 Pafc 1(5 4p 
 
 2 1 y 
 
 belpeD bp tl)c dtatate ; bat an informal! fiTue ie ticlpco , ano ^re tijs tN 
 fu0<0(mmaterfal, 32 Eliz. Lovtlace and Griffin,rot. 934. Trin. 22 Car. 
 CoIe$cafe,rot. 951 Banc. Reg. 23 Car. Moreand Clip!on, anH pjapcg foj 
 8 repleauer. Ser jtanc Parker on tl)c otbet ftoc fa(o, tl)e cafes cfteo tocrc not 
 totbcputpofcaetotlje Cafeattl)c3l5ar, fojfjetetsagooDfffuc lopnco to 
 one tbtng plcaaco, if not to tlie reft. Roll chief luflice tclo, tbat Irbete tberc 
 lsanliiimatcttaUtruc,tl)crcoual)ttoL'eal^epIeaucr,anoft»snottelpeDbp ,, 
 tbe Statute, anDtt)crec8nbeno3[uDgment,fojtl)entattertonotputfn trp« ^^^ "" 
 al, anDfo;tWscaufc,<tlLoulDfacunrcafonablc to gtt?e SuDcement, ano ifofju. 
 tbf0fsanimmatCtfaliffue,Trin. 9Car. encred Mich. 8 Car. ror. 366. Tay»uiuc. 
 ItrandSpark!,anaffirmattl-eantianlmplpeDncaatfbcmabEa gooo (ffuc, 
 tbopjibit be notaneirpjcfs ncgatftc. Thfreforercpleid. 
 
 Hurd againft Lcnthall. 
 
 Hill. 1649. Banc, fup. 
 Entrcd Mi b, 1649. rot, 568. 
 
 Q,icnion up- 
 
 'Wpon a fpecfal tetcfct in an ejtfiione firmy, 2Ebe Cafe upon tbe toojDs of on the wordj 
 ^ a tEClfU Iras tbfs, llanos U?ctc DetJifED to ttajo uaunbters equally to beofa win whe- 
 BitjDcD , ano to tbe &utbttct of tbem, ano to tbe l^cfrs of tbe IBoop of tbe '■'" ' ^°>'"''" 
 ^nrtiVeroftbem. MaynardbelDtbatbcrcfs a jopntcnancp, bccauft "'nancy I'll*"" 
 tberUiffe tbe uEHfU cannot tafee effect in airparts. Hales belo tbat tbcre is common. 
 a tenancp in Common, ann not a jopntensncp, no j anp croffc remainoers. 
 Roll Chief luflice fafD, Ebat t'DE teo?t0 rqnallp to be citiDeo in a ^153111 , 00 ioynten?r,t. 
 make atenancp in Common bpconfituttton, but in a grant it teoulo be 0=^=''^"'''^ 
 tbettoifc J but bete upon tbe entire WiiM it ootb niot appear tbat tbe Hancs ''°°'"'°"* 
 ftjonlD be cifciocD ; but tbat tbere fljoulo be a &urtlber. 3nD tbe Biano 
 teas intenoeo fo; a feturitp fia; a po?tion , ano tbat tbe octifc lljoulD fiano 
 tiUtbemonpcefboulDbepaio. ^noina tISitU tbe leftlso;csofitt)ocr-^.,, 
 plain tbe firft tro?Ds ; but it is not fo in a grant. ^U tbe gucges a- q,!,,,; 
 grecD in opinion faiitb tbctbicf Hufiitc, andludgcmencwasgivenforthe 
 Plaintiffnincaufa, &c. 
 
 Pafc. 1649. Banc. (up. • 
 'Tij^c Court teas mobebfoj a Certiorari, to tbe Eojb s^ama Coi^ ofF-" a«rii6- 
 
 Majors 
 
 tbe Citp of London to remote an infojmation cybibiteD in tbat Court , '"''.° ' 
 
 court. 
 
 agatrft a?IJooDmongerofLondon, grounuet) upon an 2a of Common 
 CounccU. SCbe Court anftocrcD, toe tarnot 00 anp tbing in it, if it OioulD TLondon. 
 beremobcDbitbcr, if it be gronnoco upon an aa of Common Countcl ; but Ccniorati] 
 if tbe 3ct of Common CounceU be agair.ft liato, toe map grant a Certiora' 
 r J. Adjourned till Friday next to hear Counccll on both fides. 
 
 r 
 
 Lamb againft Duff 
 
 I Pafc, 164?, Banc.fup, 
 
 "\7'P«>n an Affidavit tbc Court toas enfojmcD tljat Lamb bab flrrcftcD^"^*'^' 
 Duff after a bcroidfounofo^ Lamb againft b(m, to tbc intent, tbat bc^'"^'"' 
 map babe bim in Cuaoop, tobcn tbc Suogcment is cntrcD againft bfm, ano 
 
 €Z2 fo;
 
 212 
 
 Pafch. 1649. 
 
 foj no otftct canf c.as appears bp ^ts oton confcfefon,? ft toas tbctcfo jc p^ap. 
 
 CD tbc pattp map be fct at large. SC^c Court tnaoc anftoer,tl)at tbfa iuac a 
 
 Crangc ano an trregtilar courfc, ano otiglbt not to be. 3If one tabe out a 
 Cafe. latitat agatnfl: one, anoftabe no caufc of ;actfonagainftb(m,tl)C partp map 
 
 Atcacth nt .l)abCan'3cttonoftt)eCafefOjtt. Take an attachment if he will not d'lU 
 
 charge the pnrty, or elfe let him (hew caufc to Diorrow why he ftiould not 
 
 difcharce him. 
 
 't>' 
 
 Hollingworth againft VVhetftone. 
 
 Paf, J 6^9* Banc^fup. 
 
 Hollingworth bjougbt an 3aton of E^efat upon a Cngic oblfgatton n- 
 aaf nil VVhetftone, 333lje SDcfcnbant pleaueD papmcnt of part of tlje 
 "P^f,\"'^";'f^'f(im,fincc tbe Action bjougl;t, <n JBar of tbe Sctfon. SCo i\]is fDlca tljc 
 «biicit;oi7. ' P'aintff Dcmarrco. SCtc Court anfuicrcbtbc plea teas not pooo (n Bat 
 Bir." of tbc Mioni but fn abatement of tlje ^rft <t bao been gooD. Therefore let 
 
 Absicmcnr, ^jj^ Defen<iant (hew caufe why ludgement fhould not be againft him upon 
 the demurrer. 
 
 Gibbon againft Kent, 
 
 Pafi:h.i<54p, Banc fup, 
 Pafch, 24 Car. rot- 60, 
 
 AMIrUefcSrrojtoaa bjongbt torcberfe a 3lHUgemcia g{l'£?n jn tti 
 Common picas, fn on maim of HDcfat bjougin upon the Statute of 
 
 mcnt tn "c'cb^ 3 Ed. 6. foj tlje not fctttng fojtb of SCttbcs. SCbc Crrojo afofgnco tocre , 
 
 upon ihe su- 1 . SCbat it ootb not appear tbat tbc lanus fotoea do Ipe in tbe |3arf(l^ tbat fi? 
 
 tiucof lE^.^ilaiofntbcSDctlatation. alp. 23bJ|£'lafnt(ffbatl)notint{tlct) tifmfclf icell 
 to l)f3 3i(tfon, foj tt)C statute of 38H. 8. fstafecn atoapbptlje g>tatutc of 
 13 Eliz. 3lp. Stbc statute <!3 not iDCll plcaoco, fo J ft f0plcaDCDtoo gene- 
 rallp, asiD not f n tbc fcts: ral ctrcumttances tbercof, as ft ougbt to be. Stbc 
 Court commanocD t'lc lUccojD to be rcao, ant) upon £)pcr of ft, anfineren, 
 SIfcr.t 2 CburclcoarttcDbptljc statute, arc botb of fpfrftual pjomotton. 
 3no tbc &>tattitc of 1 2 Eliz Dotb not repeal tbc Statute of 3 8 H. 8, But 
 
 J,. I Ut^e party fhew caufe why the ludgement fhould not be reverfcd , and let 
 
 usMabook^ 
 
 Burton agaiRfl Low, 
 
 Pafc. id49,Banc. fup. 
 
 Mich. 16^9, TOU 2Jf 
 
 Dmurier to % ^ 0ctfon Of £Dcbt toss bjougi)t upon a ISonb faKcn b\> a &!)crfff, fo% 
 a pica in 'I'tt ^^ jj^, 2?cff uDsnt to sppcar in Cljantcrp upon an 3ttatcbnient (ffuett 
 "vVonrf ' outtbcnccagafnftUm. SCnc SDcfrntiantplcaDfl tftc Statute of 23 H. 6, 
 2Il)at tl)e &bcttfFoualjt ret total:r JBonooofanp, but in fpccfall cafes, 
 an^ tbat tbto IBonD in toio, bet aufe ft fa tahen agafitft tbc statute. %o 
 tl)i3 pica tbe piafntfff temurrco. SCbc qurflfon irao tobetbcr an ^3- 
 tattijmcnt out of tb? Chancer?, be iDttJjin tlje statute of 23 H. 6^ 
 
 The
 
 Pafch. 1(^45?. 213 
 
 The Court ordered caufe to be (hewn why ludgement fliould not be given 
 for the Plaintif ripon this Demurrer, Ponca, 
 
 Edwards againft Fallowes. 
 
 Pafch. 1 6^9, Banc, (up, 
 
 EDwards bjoug^tan 0(tfon upon tfjc Cafe acafjiff Fallo^cs fo; fpcaU< Arrcft of 
 fns of ti)cretoo?Ds ofb^nt, viz. ©Jtoarcs hith ftolkn my Axe ii^^geimcnc 
 from my Wood Pen, antjfojcaulingWtntobcfaounootjct to tbe £[Juartef l"""^^'"" 
 g>cfi3f on. 3(t toas motjeo in attcft of iaDgcment that tbe toojos sscre not '"° '■ ■ 
 SIctfonable, But the Court held they were adionable , and gave ludgement 
 for the Plaintif , Nificaula, &c. 
 
 Viccarye againft Barny. 
 
 Pafch. i64P, Banc. fup. 
 rot. 1724, 
 
 Viccarye, bcfng a spcrcc t Dp bfs 3LraBe,bjourtbt an Litton upon tfje Cafe ■'^'^''^ °^ 
 agaflltt Barns fo; fpcaUfns tbcfc irojDs of \)im, viz. Thou art a Cuckold, ["/^^Tds? 
 and a Cuckoldly Rafcali , and doll owe more than thcu art worth , and art 
 not able to pay thy debts : tapoil non culp. plcaOCD, am an fffiic topncQ, ano 
 atcrPtctfounDfojtbepiafnttf, it txjac motoeo in Streft ofUiiogcmcnt, 
 tIjattbetBOiDs ate not actionable; foj,fo; tbefirffpart of tbc Ido;03 tbcp 
 are tlcatlpnot actfonable , ano foj tbc latter toojno ttjcp do not faiplp ang 
 tljfftfngftauoo: falCboou, amsfo cannot fmplptjlm to bc'a JBanl;ni?t; fo?. 
 tboi'S^^CDoc Otoe moje tftan be <3 tDOjtb,ann fsnot able topap bffii Qcbt3, 
 yetbemapbeanboncftman, ano b: map bate crcoft ana frienos to fups 
 pO?t btm in bf3 traoc. Apej ano More, Pafch. 15 Car. anO lones anO lacob, 
 4 Car. SCbc Court anftocrcc, bcre is no fraiiti oj ueccfpt <mph'C3, lub^cb Do 
 malieai5.inUtupt toftb<nall tbe Statutes toucbfng JBanUrupts ; ano ff 
 tberebcafpctfallofsallegco, tbe tnojostotll be actfonable, otbcrinffc not, Bank.-upr. 
 But let Judgement ftay till the other fide move, and bring usa book, for the 
 words are worthy confideracion. Poitea. 
 
 Barneftone a^^ainft Gale . 
 
 Pafcb, KJ49, Banc.fup. 
 
 A i^ action of SCtc'pifalcag bjougbt foj cbafing 6f tbe Iplafnttfc l^ogs ; Arrcft of 
 x\tbc2Defcnijantbptoapof)aft(fic3tfonpIcaD0afpcc{3l pica, viz. That .'"Jc^n^f "': 
 he did hunt them with a Dog by the command of his Mafter , becaufe the '" Trcfpaft. 
 Plaintif did put them into his Maftcrs ground to eat the Acorns there. 2CbC 
 
 pafntff rcplpcD tbat bel^ao Common tl;crc -. tdpon tWaan Jtrtic \ma jopn^ 
 ED, ano.a Ucrofctfotmofojtbcplntntff. SCbc Dcfcnoant moljcD (n ar« 
 rcaof3:m3gcmenttipoiitl;<0C):cept{on, tbat tbe pafntff in bw rcpUcatfon ^^P''""""* 
 batb not anftecreD tbe bar , foj be p;cfcrib'"g onlp fo? Common of patltire , 
 anD pannage ia no paCurc, ano fo be bath norfgbt to tbe ilro jnc, ISist 
 RollchiefluiricefafD, Kf tbepbatjr caufe to cat t'jr Ojaffl , tbcp map alfo 
 cattbe0£ojn3tbcrc, fo? tbcp map be on tbe groiinos , ann therefore it fa 
 a gooD juftlficatf Oit, And therefore let the Plaincif have ludgement , except 
 caufe be fDi; wn to the contrary^ 
 
 C-Cj Bolton
 
 2 14 Palch. 1649 
 
 • Bolton againft Wills. 
 
 Pafch. 1 649. Banc, fup. 
 
 A^ action upon tlje <Cafc Inas byotigbt upon an iodietiratus AfTumpfit foj 
 abunDjcDaiiDnfnctp Mcatbers folDbptftepiafnttfuntotbcDcfenD- 
 !.n''Aa"Jn" ur" ^"* at 1 8 c, a §i>bap, inijfcb <n aU amounts to 1 90 !. tiapon an 3trnc topnco , 
 -1 the Cafe ^"'J s dcrofct fo> t^e |0:atnt(f, 3t loaa mobcD in ^rtitt of 3iuiJ0c. 
 upon an Af- mcntt^at tftc SDccUration f0 not Booo , but mfftabes tl)c pjomife,foj tt)e 
 tumifi-, ^catl)crop;omifcDtobcpa<o foj,Donot amount tott>2 f«ni fojtobtcbtbe 
 E)cclcrr.tton fc lafo. anD alfo t!)E tlluc (0 taUcn upon tbe immaterial part 
 oftljcplca, auDtbe matter tDcllplcaoeo ia loaiUcD. 2Cl)c CDourt anfluc- 
 TCD , SLftatmiaaiiingofa SuDgcmcntiflamfttaucof ttjcClark, anoianot 
 Ameiidmcnt. material ; biitl)crctl)e2Dcclarntionitfclfii3miaahcn, ano tljat is mate- 
 rial; fojtbe aaionisgrouaDcDupontljcpjomife in ILalo, upon tl)C falc 
 Declaration, of tljc S>bap, ano not upon anp ncvu Contract , ano bp t!)C falc tl)crc \i;ant« 
 = s. in etierp S>l5ccp to mabc up tbe fum DemanecD , t^ctctoje tftc SDcclara. 
 tion f0 repucrnan t. Nil capiat per billaro, nlfi, &c. 
 
 More againrt the Earl Rivers. ^ 
 
 ( 
 
 Pafch* 1649 Bine, fup, 
 
 Mich. i54p.rot. 588. 
 
 T'jX 7nronofCounceltuitl)Moretl)epaintif, arguctj againff tfje plea 
 
 ea'ir.S' * V V o^pderascplcaacDbptljc earl Rivers, 33 it is plcaoco, ano took 
 
 pica of Peer- t^Jfc Cjiccptions. I. 31t appcaro not fterebp tljc Uctojn bp to^at ^ar. 
 
 age, rant tiie Carl uaascommtttca , ano bjougbt t}itbcr , ano fo be batbjio oap 
 
 tn Court, anofotbcpca tj not q,m, i\v, 31t «3 not IbclBCO bptjirtti'e 
 
 of iB'gat C3arra!it be toas tahen. -.Ip. 2Cbe pica i0, i . 3in abatement of tbe 
 
 IfJit. 2!p. 3inatioioanccoftbea£toftbe3iHDge, ano tbe latter ougbt not 
 
 tobcqucfltonctibi'piea. 3lp. JLbereisno pica, but bare toojos, fojbe 
 
 plcaog tbe Common llato. 4lp. ^^eplcaoo bii5 patent as Carl, onlp bp 
 
 loap of argument- 5 'p. \^z ougbt to fljclD tbe tojit unoer tb: fecal , tcHi- 
 
 fl'ing tbe matter, 8 H. d.f. 9. 6lp.Ebcintcfiitureoftbe CaricomistbeU. 
 
 Dcrpanofr^iftitof tbe GarlDom, anobc batb omittco tbe picaoing the 
 
 Cctcitionics of tbe intjcfting,aiio fo be ootb not flieit tbat be is an C-arl. %p 
 
 Capijs tbe Statute ilaln , viz. of E. 3. a Capias \13a3 gitfcn in Debt, ano before tbat 
 
 a&nmmoiTi5ix)a3tbep.:ocef0. E^be Councel on tbe otber (ioe fato tb^pbao 
 
 Summons tcmurreo to tbcpica , anofli^iuc^tbccaufcof tbetr Demurrer ; but tbe 
 
 Court rcp:oVco i!icm,bccaufctbrpbaDruleo tbe matter in iLain flboulo be 
 
 atguDD at tb; 3Bar to cnfojm tbeit oton 3|uDgcmcnt3. Adjouniatar Poftea, 
 
 5"yms againfl V^Vilfon. 
 
 Pafch. 1 649. Banc, fup. 
 Pafch. 2 5 Car, rot, ijo. 
 
 a iVaT"R:r C YiTJs bjotigbt m atffott upon tbe Cafe upon tbe fetafutc of£ponopo«C0as 
 in an ASb" Osafntt Wilfon. 2EbeS>cfcntjant pleaoco tbe Statute of Umitationa of 
 
 i.ponthcofe. aCtfOnS
 
 Sraru'C of . 
 iim.iauons. 
 
 Parcli.i64p, . 215 
 
 antonfi in J&atol toe jactton to {I;ts^lca,'ti)e piaintff oemurrco. Hales 
 bclD t!)3t tijts action grouiiDgo upon tbc St^'ctsts i3 not toftljin tl;c &tat;itc of 
 limitations of Actions of 21 he. bccanfc.it is net a meet Action on tbe Cafe 
 at t!)c Common 3LaU), but an Action upon tt)e Cafe srounocD tipon tftc &ta= 
 tute of monopolies. 115iitTwifJen!mt{)cot?)ct fioe faio t^at a agonopo:^. 
 Ipisan offence at tbe Common iLatD, fojlrDicl)an iJctionof tbe Cafe DiD """F^^' 
 liebcfojetlje&tatate, anU tljat t^c Statute toaa mace but to inflict a 
 greater panffljmcnt fo; tbc offence, ano fo it is toitbin t^c §)tattitc of lUr\U 
 Utiotts of Actions. Zm iUk tl)c tierj? trojos of tbe §>tat!itc fap, tijat an SLCtU 
 ono fijall be b?otigftt toitbfn ftr pears , ano l)ct!)at faps all lrift!;o'.it limitatf* 
 on, cvcluDcs none, ano bp confcqacnce tljis Jetton ijf not,eFcUt5ci3. 5I}? SCfje 
 cno of tbc Statute of limitations tnas to quiet falcs.ano tljercfojc tij: 
 Statute (Ijall be largelp intcrpjeteo , bccaufe maot fo j fo pHbUi}'.ic a gooo. 
 Adjourned to the nest term to be argued again* 
 
 ?iCch- 1649* Banc fup. 
 
 "\7poitat)cri5fctgii3cnagaina a ^antijcD, t!i;it ions fucD fn an Action imigcncnt in 
 ^ upon tfte Statute of Wincfiefter of f^uc ano Cries, gt tons ntotJCD foj a" Aft^on u;.- 
 tl)c ^unD?cQ in 0rrcft of SluDcremsnt, tfint tftc iguno?cD Iras fue* bp Jgill ,"" '''" ^"- 
 itjbetcas it ougljt to Dabe been fuco bp £>;iflinal. ilBut tfte Court ober=ru- chcftel^^'"' 
 leo tbe C-jceptiort, anofaio tbattbgrcarcmanp ^pjcfiDcnts to p:ote tfjatuiii ' " 
 facljj9ction6mapbecommenccDasU3ellbp3BtUa6bj,'£>3i£fnaU original. 
 
 Pafch. 1649. Banc- fup. 
 
 LFtchmorcmofteo to qnaO) an 3!"qnifition tal»cn agairtt oncutjontljc 
 Statute of Weft. 3. foj tfte tb?oVDing ooten of CEntlofures. HBnt t^e ^° '5"'^" ="* 
 Court antlBcreo, tljal it toas not pjopet to molic tb quaC) tlje JnquiQtfon \^'V.'"'"^ 
 becaufetl)e2DefenDantcame{nHponp?ocefs , ano tbtrefo^clje mutt cit^ct'*^""*^' 
 tratierfe oj pleao to tbe Slnquitttion. Letdimorc replpcD, tftat tl)c Jnqnifiti. 
 on tuas fo uncertain^ tftat tijc SDefcnoant coulo not tell IjoId to plcao to it, ^■"■ 
 'SButtije Court anftoeret), be mtgl)t pleao to tlje Diftringas, And tdac th^^"''"''^- • 
 monies already levied for the offence (hould reft in the Sheri;$ hand until the 
 tryal. 
 
 Hamond againft Ireland. 
 
 Pafch, 1^49. Banc. fup. 
 Hill.1649. rot, 818. 
 
 , Ai reft of 
 
 V|9onatllleta{ctgit)cnfnanEjeaionefirni«, 3lt ir.as motcDin 0rrctt 
 of SuDgement , tljat tbe paintif Declares tbat tfje JDefenoant ejecteo ";'" "' 
 btmexunoCottagio, tnijercas ail Ejcftione firmi lies not of a Cottage , •'"j^T""^'. 
 no mo?e tban a praecipe quod reddat lies of a Cottage, But the Court an' ne fi^mi!^ " 
 {wered,thatanejeamentdothlieof a Cottage, bccaufc tbe DcfcriptlOR of 
 tbe tbing bp tbat name is fufgcient anu certain enougb to Ojcto tljc S^ertf of p -^ 
 tDbat to DeUber tbe poffcfsion of ; pet it toas rain tbat a rccotjcrp lies not of aSmy'' 
 a Cottage. Rethonckano Chapels cafe lo lac. itas cttcD tbat an Ejedioae 
 lies of a Cottage , ano alio a praecipe quod reddat* 
 
 Wood
 
 2i6 Pafc. 1649- 
 
 V Vood againft Topham. 
 
 Pafchi 1649. Banc, fup, 
 
 Arrtft of \7\70odbjoua!)tan 3tffon upon t!ic Cafe agafnftTopham, qusrefilium 
 
 luJgfmcnt in ^ ^ Juum & h^redcm rapuit cc maritavic, anO obtCfneD a tScrofct agattlft 
 
 an aftion up- tljc SPcfcncatit.SIn airrctt of juuncmcnt motJCD foj titc SDcfcnoant, tbcie ep- 
 
 on ihc cafe, ccptfong toctc taliCH agafiift tfjr SDcclaratton. i . 2Ebat it ootft not fap haerc- 
 
 dem apparentctn, but onlp filium & hxredem. alp. 3It DOtft not fap rapuit 
 
 contra voluntatem .♦but'onlp rapuit. glp. 3it DOt^ not fct fojtl) tljat tl)C l)C(c 
 
 toas toJtbtn age. ^p. 3it OotljnotfapCujusmaritafjiumad iprum pertiner» 
 
 5But tl)C latt exception onlp toao {nfifteo upon. Wilmot of Counccl irUlj 
 
 tl)cpa<tUtf, topjcDtjetbatt^at ©jrccptfon Icao not matcrfal , tttcD one 
 
 GraycstsfcPafch. 29 Eliz, Banc. reo.aiiQtIjcJBffikoof 12 H,4 f. i<5. anD 
 
 23 E. a.BrookTit. Trcfpafs4}. JlBin Hales urjjeu tftat ttje latt (Etceptiotl 
 
 Cafe. toas not anf iDcreii» Roil chief luftice fafo , 2Cl)atan ;a(tfon quare filium. 
 
 & baercdcm fuum rapuit iilU Hc,f.ltl30uab tl)cbc(r be of full agc; foj tt)e iFos 
 
 tl)Etftatl)t^emarlaseofl)fsfe»onaltl)ougl)l)cl3al3C no cttate to Ua'oz unto 
 
 ^fm. Adjourned to the next Terra, Poftea, 
 
 Dawkes verfLis Payton. 
 
 Pafch, 1 469, Banc. fup. 
 
 Pafch I i 50. rot. ^06* 
 
 Error brccin A Ji ^ufant bjotio^t an 0(tton ftt tl)f0 Coutt , antJljaT) a lUctDlct ana a 
 
 inrhc Upper ./ 1 3lnoscmcnt , tf}c 2Dcfcnijant bjougbt a tojit of €rroj In t^e fame 
 
 cench upon 3 Courtto retietfe tMs juDgemcnt , anu it toais afofgnco foj CEtroii tljat t^ 
 
 ludg cmei.t 3jnfa«t b?ougI)t W Action in propria perfona , toftctcas be o'.jgbt to Ijatc fu-- 
 
 given there. j.jj p„r puardTanum , ano tbfcfsCSrroj at tl)c Common llalu, ant) fa not 
 
 l)ElpcD b? tbc Statute of ieofadc ; ano it Irao argucD tftat t^c \vnit of CErro?. 
 
 nxs)i be loell b;oual)t In ttjis Court to rctjcrfe a luDgcmcnl gfbcn Ijcre , (f 
 
 tIjcCBrroa arofgncD be matte tin fart, aa it lain this cafe , foj bp fuel) a 
 
 iDj^t of Cuoj tbc judgement of tlje^S^outt fa not calleD in qucCfon, aa it 
 
 Erior. icoulD be if tbc Ctro J afsianeo tocre mattcrin lata; ant) tbefe Walie toerc 
 
 tlteo, viz.7H.6. 28. Dyer 136. Mich. 15, & 26, Eliz. Banc, reg. Hales 
 
 ontbeotbcrftaeatgaeDtljatttjEiijitofCEtrojtJtDnotlie, ^anolje mace z 
 
 qucfiions , i . tdbetbcr tljc tojit of dBcroj ufo lis at alU ilp, 3if it Dia lie 
 
 fnen otbcr SCcrm ; antiljcfafDjtbataDmittingtbetojitofCttoj ootljlte, 
 
 pctitougbt to l3ai3C been bjougbt tbc fame SCcvm tobercin tbe judgement 
 
 ioas gfbcn ; but fo it is not bete, anD tbcrcfo; c it ia not tocli b jougbt : Sinn 
 
 2lp.3ftbe<l!;tro?afsignei)bcCBrroj,petiti3belpet)bp tbe fetatutc of 21 
 
 lac.ofScofails. iButifitbenot, pet tbe €rroj afcigneo bcrc ia not ar- 
 
 fignablE •, fo; it ootb not appear lubctbcr tbc pavtp appcarcD per jiuardianum 
 
 «jnot, fojtbcpattpiaa pjf^ileccD pcrfon. 2Cbe Court anfircreo, toe 
 
 * cannot ImotDtobctbcr tbe partp be iDitbin age 0; of full agc. atiu tbcrcfoje 
 
 fenoto not tbctbcr be ougfjt to appear bp 2tto;np o> bp Ciuatoian ; but fo:i. 
 
 Ctto; fit matter of fact , In a Judgement afben in tbio Court, a lojit of 
 
 CErroj VufH lie berc toell enougb , anD it ia all one tobctbtr tbc tujit be 
 
 bjougbt tbe fame aCerm, j in a;wtber SDcrm, But bring us Books and wc 
 
 willadvile,Poftea. 
 
 Viccarye
 
 Trin. 1550. 217 
 
 Viccirye againft Barnes. 
 
 Pafcb,;i55o, Banc, fup, 
 
 Ajfl iaafort upon tftecafetoasbjouafetbpa ^mcr ajrafnft tfte SDefen- ^^^td'of 
 tcnoant , foj fpeaWns tljcfe toojoo of Mnt, Thou art a Cuckoid, and a i Jdeement in 
 Cuckoldly Rafcal, and art not able to pay thy debts , and art not worth aanAftionup- 
 Groat 2nt)Epa(ntffl)aDa taertfct, ano upon a motfon (n Htrcft of°"'''=Cjrc 
 Juijgcmcnt, tecaufetbe lio;Ds tnerc fitppofco not afljonable, t^e juBjje.'"'^ ''°'*'^* 
 nicnt toas fojmetlp ftapcD till tbc JDlaintf f fljoulo moljc. 0t tbfs cap Pepes 
 fojtbepafntffpjaps foj juogement , bccaufebct)clDt!)ctDo;D0 toere a- 
 rtfonablc , anD cftcn one Brapges Cafe , aDjtiDgco , ano fato tljat tljc plafn* 
 tif ban lalo a fpcctal Damage bp tljc UJOjDff. Windham on tbc other Coc fato , 
 Stbat the plalntff ban not lato anp fpecfal Damage aa Pcpes fuppofctb, but 
 onlp aliegetb a general Damage , namclp, that be bp fpcaMng of the fccojDs 
 loft Ha crcDft, ano coulD not bup toarrs upon truft ao be ufcD to Do bcfoje , 
 but onlp fo J reaop moncp, ano fo tberc can be no ifftie jopncD. lerman /u- 
 fticebelDtbeliJOjOsatttonable, ano alfo Roll the chief luttice, fojbc fafoft 
 toasabtnocrance tob<nitnt,<0 aCraoe to be fo fpohen of, altbougb tbcp 
 bitna, btm not toft^fn tbe Statute of IBanluupt , anD be £<tcD 1 1 Car. lack* 
 fon anD Hewes bt0 cafc, toftcre an 3ttfon tuas bjougbt bp lackfon being a 
 dDjaficr, agalnllHewtSjfOjfajtngofWmThouarta b?ife beggarly Rogue, 
 and art not abie to pay thy debtt. Nicholas Juftice brlD tbc tDOJDS a(tlona< 
 
 ble, but Ask lufticc Doubtco, fojrutbtDojDsmapperflaijenturcbe true, (C 
 tbep be fpohen of a powng i;raDcfman tbat bcgfna toltb Httle, flinD fafD 
 tbat tbc cbfcf queftfon (s tolietDer tbe atcrment of tbe Damage be toell allc- 
 geo ; ano be bclD It tras not, bccaufe It toag fo general tbatno f ITue can be 
 ^orpneouponjt. Roll chief JofticefafOjtbetoojDsarefounDbp tbe ZMeroto 
 to befpokefalloet militiofe, an^tbcrcfojelctthc PJaintifhavc his ludgc* 
 meot except better matcer be (hewed. 
 
 Pafch. 1650. Banc. fup. 
 
 /\iP3!nfojmatfoniDasc)cbfbttcD{ntbfs Court agafnff one foj engrofsfngFor thcDc- 
 ^ -ofl^ap, tbe SJffcnDant appcareD anD plcaDcD to tbe information, tbe^-"'*""'*<> 
 pahutf motico t'nat the SDcfcnoant migljtrbe ojDcrcD to carrp tbe"^ ■" ^"^^'■" 
 tanfe Doton to; be trpcD at tbe flfsijea at big o^trn cbarge* But thcCourtl^wncLr^c " 
 anfvveredchat -hey could make no luch Order, faecaufc tbe ftitc teas not up. denied. 
 on an CnDfamcnt , tobicb ia at tbc futc of tbc Cuftodes , bat uuon an infoj- '"•I'^menr. 
 mation , toWcb is at tbc futc of tbe partp. ' L.fomution. 
 
 Cater ag^inft Srarcute. 
 
 Trin. itfjo. Banc, fup. 
 Hill. I64p« rot, lotj, 
 
 T" ^t ^laf ntif bjongbt an action of SDcbt upon an Obligation fo ffans to D'-n^""" w 
 -■' anatnarD: SCbeSDcfcnDantpleaDeDtbattbcrctDas no auiaro maoe i • 'd^ hT""" 
 JLbcpainttf replica tbat there tpa? an ainarDmaop, anDfctg fojtb ti.era.a^oniiejt'i? 
 toaro, anD afotiTns tbc bjeatb ; iHlpon tbio tbc E^efcnDant D'mnra, ano on ■> (land to 
 fo> caufclietos tbat part oftbeatoarD teas, tbat one of tbc parties fljouio'" "w"**? 
 
 iff mato
 
 2i8 Trin. 1650, 
 
 nrafecfucft a ccncral tclcafc to t!)J otijet as Coantel fljoulo aatjffc, fo fbat 
 
 tbc »Ioiin(cl arc mace ^irbltratoja , in regarQ tljat a juofcfal act fs rcfcrrco 
 
 totbcm, tebici) onoftt not to be ; fojtljc^rbftratojgcanrotflclcgatc tbrfc 
 
 Min^ftc autbojUptoot^cro, anD8E.4. f, lottjascftcBtotbfcpurpofc. 315«t Wild 
 
 Aft rial, on tbc otljcr Odc fato , tljat tbe rcfcrrfng of tl)E maWng of tljc tclcafcB to 
 
 Jujiciai. Countclirastoarrantablc, bccaufctt{3bntamfnfftcrfalart,a:H)nota jw. 
 
 Dfc<al, as ia obiccteo* Roll chief luftice fafo , t!jat tftcrc is no mktal 
 
 tl.fnrclcftfo^^tljcdounceltoijo, butonlra mfnittedal act, anD tfjercfojc 
 
 Itfstocllcnoufib; but U ban been otbcrtoffcljaoit been a jtiDfcfal act , io% 
 
 t!)at l)ao been foj tl)C atbftratojs to Delegate tl)c(c ant!)o?ttp to otbcrs , 
 
 tDftfcb <s not Warrantable , becaufc ft fs contrarp to tlje fubmffslon of tbc 
 
 jjartfcs , but to Delegate a mfnittctlal act fs not contrarp; And with him the 
 
 Court ap.reed, and ordered thePlaintif totakehis ludgeracnt) except better 
 
 matter were fliewn Saturday next* 
 
 Dawkes againft Payton. 
 
 Trin, 1^304 Banc.fup, 
 
 Pafch,i650,rot, 306, 
 
 Error to re. A ^ ;actton iBSS ojDeteD out of tl)c Cl)anccrp to bc ttpeD fn tljfs Court; 
 
 vcrfea judge. jf\?:2a^eteupontbctaufciDa3trpcD, anoa 3]uDgcnicnt upon a mtxnia 
 
 ment in the jj,gg gj^p„ jj,, ^^P ^Dlafntf f, %\)c 2DcfenDant bjfngs a tojft of CErro? bete 
 
 iip'o''."an iffuc *" «^2rfc tbls juosement. 2i:b-^ firtt tiueftfon teas , tobctbcr tt d(d ftifficf. 
 
 <)ircacd out cntlp appear bp tbc IRccojD , lubetbct tbc partp Dfo appear in perfon j bp 
 
 «t tic Chan- (DuarUan, Hales bclDtbat ft DiD not appear, but tbat ft belongs to tbe- 
 
 ccric. otbcr partp to ibclu ft ; fo; be ougljt to babe all tbe IReco jd upon tobftb tbe 
 
 Crto; fj afsigneD, 3 fctono qucCfon teas , tlEIIietbcr tbe Crroj afsfgneD, 
 
 ffftbcCtroj, bcnotbclpcoaftcra y:lerDfctbptbcg>tatuteof2i lac. Hales 
 
 bclD, tbat bolucber tbe partp appeatco , tobeii}er bp dSuarofan, oj fn p?opet 
 
 perfon, ftfsbrlpcDbptbc Statute of 21 lac. ano cannot be afcfgneo bere 
 
 fo; CBrro; , ano tbc U3;ft of Grro; tbatfs b?oucbt fsas toll to rcberfe tbc 
 
 jciDgcment rftjcn bere, as tbe fo;imct juogement gftjen frt C!)ans 
 
 cerp , fcbtcb cannot be , fo; tbfs Court cannot reticrfe tbcir oton 3!uDse* 
 
 ntent, Erccptftbcfoj€rro;fnp;ocef3, lyH. 6. 2.44 7H. e.f- 28. noj 
 
 can tUs Court rctierfe tbcfr oton juDgcmcnt fo; Crro; fn fact , bccanfe ft fs 
 
 fo obcrtb;oir tbefr oton act, pet tbe Cbcp.uer cbambet map Doe ft; pet tber» 
 
 Itfs mo;cpjoper to appeal to tbc patUaincnt; ana be faiD, tbat tbe (Lntea 
 
 ofjRch, j.f. i.anDDyer ly^.citcD, tobcrcfolfceD, babe been fincc Dff. 
 
 putcD, anc fo p;nprD tbe to;ft of Crror mfgbt abate. Roil chief luflice 
 
 fafo, tbat fo; tbc firll matter, tobctber ft appears bp tbe afsfgnmcnt of 
 
 Aopcarsncc t')'^ P'''"^ P 5 V.bctbcr tbc sppcarancc tocre per Guardianum, o;otbertoffe, 
 
 ^^ ' toetotllnot!ma2tncftbct2tto;ncpo;CDiiarDfanfn tbe Cafe, but tbat be 
 
 appcarcD in propria pcrfona , faccaufc notbfngto tbe contrarp appears bp tbe 
 
 I'^ccojD, anpffitbcotbettoffcpouougbtto babe fijeton ft. jgjnD fo; tbe 
 
 °''- matter, tobetber ft be Crro; to appear bp 0tto;ncp, tobcre tbe partp ougbt 
 
 to appear bpbfs Ouarofan , be belD ft teas Crro; , anD tbat ft fo not belp» : 
 
 CD bp tbc gitfltute of 2 1 lac. becaufc ft fsmo;e Dangerous fo;an ^i-fant to 
 
 , - appear in propria perfona,o; per Guaidianum, tban per Attornatum; foj 
 
 agafnft an 0ttoj!icp be map babe remcDp, but not agafnff bfmfclf oj 
 _^ bfsOnarDfnn; anD tnfsfscafusoroifTus out of tbc Statute. BnD as to tbe 
 
 cafus om iru5^^j|.jjjj|j^^ Ubctbcr tbfs Court map rcberfe tbefr oton fuDgcmcnt , b^ belD , 
 tbat tbep map fo; (I2rro;fn matter of fact, as tbe cafe bere fs, tbougbtbep 
 cannot fo; Crro; fn matter in ILato, as teas aDjuDgcD, Mich. 2s. 
 rot. 96, anD Micb, j Jac, fn Watkias anO Giffins cafe , ano ff ft IboulD not be 
 
 fo
 
 TrJn, 1650^ ^19 
 
 fo ftete,tl)cpattpfeoulDbetDftboutrcmct)p, fojljecattfta^c no remcupfn 
 tl)c Ctjcqucr Chamber, ano tljcrc ia no pjeCoent <n JDatUamcnt be to rclf c- 
 tcD t^cre, anu U f0 neftJjEr agafnlt reafon noj anp JRulc of llatufoj tbfs 
 Court to DO <t. tmpon t!)fs tbc Conned motjcu to qaaOj t^e Icjft of (Erroj 
 upon an erccptfon tahcn to ft , 80 ft teas tntxtn f n tl)e IRccojo , but becaufe . , 
 fttoa0butamfr-cntrp,tl)etojftftrclfb£fngtfg^t, the Record was orde- """* 
 
 red to be amended by the Writ, 
 
 Robcrrs and Tucker. 
 
 Tiin. i6jo Banc.fup. 
 Pafch 1 8, Car, rot. 1 1<5. 
 npl^e Court teas motjen to quaCjfliDjft of cDrtoj, becaufc tbe tojff ioas^o ^(i,, 
 
 to remobC a IRccojO coram Majori et Rccordatori, tobcrcag tfjC lilCCOjD Wril of Ec- 
 tCttffiCDiDasalilECOjOcoramMajorietDeputJito recordatori. Roll chief ror. 
 juftice,tl}c IRccojo f0 not tnell rcmotjeo , luDp map pou not l^abe a ncto 
 Certfficatc upon tbc fame iD?ft ;" But tbat cannot bc.ano tftcvcfojc pou 
 muft ftatc a fpccfal to jft DfretfED to remolje the l^ccojo befojc tlie iipafoj 
 anu tliE 2DEputp 'Rtco^ntr ; fo? ff tljcrc be a fpecfal caufe to alter tJje ufual Alteration. : 
 fo jm of a to?tt, tbe CurSto j0 ougbt not to bolu tl)cmrelb£0 to tbe olo pj cC- 
 Dcnts , but ate compilable to alter t'lem ff tbe cafe rrqufte^ Therefore kt Abatement, 
 the writ be abated, and take another Wric, Vid, antea^ 
 
 Shcrtlife againft Tymberlye. 
 
 Trin. 1^504 Banc, (ap. 
 Hill. i(549.rot.438. 
 
 Hertlife bjouglbt 3n ildtOH Of 2Dcbt agafnC Tymberlye upon an ;©blfcra= Den-urrcr to 
 tfon, tbcconoftfontetjcreof toa0, tbattfte BDefenoant ftoulo fnbe t\ic ^ VLi in dtbt 
 
 S _._ ^ „, 
 
 pafntffl)armlcrs from fucba pcrfon,i ftoulo relcafc unto I fm all bfsrfcbtj'P". '" °''' 
 in ccrtafn gooogtSEbeSDcfenoant pleaos tijat be ban fafcco tb: |)lafntff barm= n,^vt bTrmUfs. 
 Icf0, ano bao releafen unto bfm all \}is rfgbt in tbe gooug, ano to tl)f0 plea tbc 
 piatntff Dcmarceo , ano (bctos fo j caufe that tbc EDefcnuant ougl t to bate 
 fiictiieo boto \)t bat) fabeo tbe ^lafntif bacmlefg, bccaufe tbe confttfon iias 
 fn tbe afftrmatfbe. 2Do ubicb tbe Court agreen, becaufc be nngbt balic 
 plcaocoscnerallp fntbcnEgatfte,viz. non dammficatus , ana tbatbao been Mon <hmnifi- 
 gooD , and therefore judgement wis giren againft the Defendant! catui, 
 
 Hobfon againft HuJ/on. 
 
 Ttin. 1650, Bancfup, 
 
 HObfon bjougbt an aciton upon tbe Cafe agafntt Hudfon foj tticfCA-rtftof 
 iDOJDS , Thou wcnteft to the Wells to be cured of the Pox : Ebc ^plaftt: Ja.gc.nent in 
 ttfbaDatacrDtctagafnfttbeJBDcfcnoant , ubomoteufn arrctt ot ^uatrc-^" Adion lor 
 mipt that tbe toojoa tocre not aaionablc, becaufc tbpp tocte tea general ano "*°^'*'- 
 uncertain. lIButRoll chief luftice, ano Nicholas ano Ask :ui>icesbelotbEp 
 tuere artfonablc. 5But Icrman luilice ooubteo, becaufc tbe partp tbat 
 teent to tbe Wells to be cnreo mfgbt lufpcct be bao tbe ^ov tbougli 
 
 iFfi ie
 
 zzo Tri'n. 1650^ 
 
 6e liaO tt^Ctn not, But iudgement was given for the Plaintiff, 
 
 Ellyagginll; Mawdic. 
 
 Trin. 1650. Banc. fup. 
 Pifc, i(5jo, rot, 405. 
 
 ELfyc b;ougl)t an action npon t^c cafe agnfiift Miwdit fo j jrpcalUn0 tl)cre 
 toojDsof^fm; Thou Sirrah art a rogue and a rnn-awayrogae, and didft 
 jiidfif nici t in run away from Oxford, and art a rogue upon Record at Oxford. %\\t ^lafrt« 
 wo/j!'""*" tfffuponnotaiifllpplcaDcD^aoatjetDlct.thc SJcfcnuant moUeD in attcft 
 Df3lat)gcmenttJjatt!)e toojuslDcrc general, anD uncertain, ano not actio- 
 nable tlje Court thereupon ftapeo Snuaemcnt till tf)c plaintiff thoula 
 mote. SChe Plaintiff at another Da J? niotjeabp, Hales of Ijts Councell fo} 
 31iJDgement, tDho faio that the itoojos are actionable, oj at Icatt fomcof 
 them, for thou art a rogue upon 3Rcco;t) are actionable too jos , ano that fa 
 part of the too?D0. SChc Court CF.tliiicD alfo that thcp tocre actionable, yet 
 iDoalO atJtjffc, Poffea, The fame Term Indgeraent was givenfor the Plain* 
 tiff. 
 
 Chafe anci lones agamft Lovcring. 
 
 Trin. 1650, Banc, fup, 
 
 Arrcttof /^HafeanDlontsfajoaehtan Action upon the cafe againtlLovering, upon 
 
 judgement in V^gpjomife mauebp the EDefcnoant to th^ Plaintiffo to pap unto tbcin 
 
 an aftion up- jj^ |^ p^j j,f jjjj ftaisht of 3 e>hip auD foj uot pacing ft the Plaintiffs bjinii; 
 
 uDon a pi'(!- ^^^^"^ actton.taipon non afrumpfit plcaBco thcrc toas an iffue jopneo , ano a 
 
 ni.fc. tereict fotina fo j t')C Plafntiffu. SChe JDefcnoant moljco in arrctt of Siuoge* 
 
 ment, « aUcgeth fo? caufc.thatthe Plaintiffs atcrmcnt in their SDctlaration 
 
 Averment ^^ ^^>^ "°" pnpmcnt of the 84 I. io not coco , fo; It toth not appear b'g tijc a« 
 
 tjernTenttl)attheretoa0anpfraightDucfojthe&hip,oiitof tohich the mo» 
 
 nies toeretobcpaio. Rollchiefluf^ice anftocreo, that the Plaintiff ought to 
 
 liatcafcrret)tV;at there tocre monies tjuc fo?thi: fraight i-f the Ship, o- 
 
 thcni;frc hoto can it be Itnotou tohcther tl^crefae anp monpca Due to be 
 
 paio 9ut of them, therefore the atiermcnt is terp inccrtairt,to tohom Icrman 
 
 Nicholas anD Ask luftices agrceD. Roll ChiefluiliceaDDeD, that it is part 
 
 of the pjomf fe that tljC monp fhall be paio out of the fraight . ano as the a- 
 
 tcrmcnt is; the matter cannot ttanD together , ano here is no Dcmano foi 
 
 the monpcs to b: paio out of the fraight. Therefore againft the Plaintiff 
 
 let there b^a nil capiat per bilfam enired* 
 
 Blackuen againl^ Harvye. 
 
 Tiio, 1^50, Banc, fup. 
 Hill, 1649, rot, 928, 
 
 up 11 9 pi'-a 
 at cr iin;»ai • 
 hnte. 
 
 BLackden brought an 0ction upon the Cafe, upon an indebitatus afTurfp: 
 fit to pap unto him 9 1 upon DcWberp of certain Cloath againft Harvy 
 asC-j;ecuto;ofI,S. SChe JDcfenoant appearcD ano imparlcD', anD after 
 f mparlanccplcaos in abatement of the ©arit, that I, S, maoc other C-jre- 
 
 cutojs
 
 Tritj. £^50. 22.1 
 
 catojs together Vtftl) the SDc" cnoant , tolp oiigbt to !}atc been nameo tntfte 
 Wirit. ELftcpatnt(fftJem;ir0,anc fojtaufcttjetop, i-Sfjattte plafntfff 
 Dotl) not Qjcto iDbat gooois tlje Dcfcnuant aDminfCrco, no; at to^nt tf mc l)c 
 aDmfntftri:Danp,asfteortgI)t, anod. lac Edwards and Foyes cafe teas cftco 
 to pjotjc <t. a fecono caufc of tl)c ocmutrcr toas, tbat tljc pica fn abate* 
 mcntoftfjcMtlticaftErfrnparlancc, \ri)fcb ts not gooD , bccatifc ft is 
 touching a t!)fng fn ti): Dcfcnoants Unotoiegc , ano fo Ijc mfgfet Ijatie plca= 
 DeD (t bcfo?C Imparlance, ag (t is gs H. 6. f. 3d. lerman luQice ablentc Roll 
 anftDCtci), tftat tl)C firft crciptton fo not matetfal;but be fcclo tliat t^e fecono '^''«'="""^' 
 toas a gooo reception , aiiD tijat t^c SDcfcnoant cannot plcao fn abatement 
 after Imparlance , foj fap Us Imparlance \)C i;atfc acinftteD tfje CSHrlt groo.. 
 Therefore plead in cbiefit caufe fae.not flieived to the contrary on Friday next' 
 
 Winter againft Barnard. 
 
 Trin, idjo. Banc. up. 
 
 ■y" iZ^nfcr bjougftt an 0ctfon upon tSe Cafe agafnft Barnard , anti Decla* -^"''* °^ . 
 ^ ^ rcD, tbat upon tlic rumoj tbat a 15attart3 Xbtla teas Oiotenoeo. SCbc ]„ jft"o'n"for 
 SJcfenuant fafo totbe piatntlff, 3 do t'erilp beltetje tljc JlcaftarQ (Itjtlo teas words. 
 tfttnc, nap ft teas tftme J upon not guiltppleaoeo an Wuc iuas jopneo, ano 
 a t)crcfct fount) foj tbe J0!alntfff:3[t tiao moticDfn arrcft of Blucgmcnt tl?at 
 tfjc teojDs arc not actfonable^ao tljcp arc lafD fo; tbat it cctl) not appear tbat 
 t^crc toas a JBaftaro Cfjflo Djotoneo,fo; tfte Declaration fs tljat tbcrc teas 
 onlp a rnmo?,tbat a ji^aSato Ci)tlD teas o^oteneo. I5iit all tDe Court a- 
 gtceD, t^at bp tfte conference fct fojtb fn i^c S>eclaratton> ft Is agtecD tljat 
 tlicrc teas a HBaffara €1)110 , ano ft fs a fcanoal to tbe partp, tobctl):r tljere 
 tocrc a J15aftaro Cbflo 0; no, ano ff tbete toete none , pou ougbt to ftcto 
 it on t!jc Dcfcnoants part. Therefore let the Plaintiff have his ludge^- 
 menu 
 
 El(y againft MawJic. 
 
 1 rin, 1650. Eanc, fup. 
 Pafc. id50» rot. 409» 
 
 Tl^c Cafe of Elfy and Maw dlt teas agafn molicD , tobercfn tljc pafnffff "^"(ft of 
 bao a tcrtjfct agalcC tfjc SDcfrnoant , fn an Sctfon upon tbe Cafe '" '.S'r"="' '" 
 bjowgbtagafnttbfm, fojfpcalifngtljcfc teojos ofbtm; Thou Sirrah arta'^^'jj]"^ ""^ 
 rogue, »nd a runsa way rogue, and didfl runaway at Oxford, and art a rogue 
 upon Record at Oxford; upon a motfon fn atrctt Of ^uugcmcnt , jfuugc- 
 nient teas ttapeottU the plafntfff fl)o:ilQ mote. Hales note motco foj 
 Huogemcnt, becaufetbctoojw are actionable, fojtbcp make tbc plafntfff 
 to be fucb a lHogue as map be cnoicteQ tetthfn tbe statute, ano rccefte 
 coipojal punfQjmcnt ; 3IBut Twifden tenpentt. Rol! chief loflice belD ft 
 toas toftbfn the statute. |0et t!ic Court toonlD atJtffe. Sn this cafe lerman 
 lufticefaid, Chat ff onc fap that anotncr fs fojftoojn tnaCourtof Re. 
 to;D,the teo^Ds are not a(tlonablc;buf ff he fap that he fs fo;f teo?n uponi^c^ 
 cojD, the teojDs arc aflfonable. JlBut Roll chief luftcehclo there teas no 
 Difference betteeen tbc teojos, but tbattftcparc both ;3afonable, Ancea 
 et Podeat 
 
 if f 3 More
 
 ^^ irin. 1649 
 
 More again ft the Earl Rivers. 
 
 Trin» 1 6^0* Banc, fup, 
 
 Mich, 1649, rot. 588. 
 
 F.ni Rivers \M Ore;g[trcffca tbe EarlRivers bg a bill of Midlcfcx fit aplta otlDcbt Cljc 
 o^c touching iVJ earltoaB ttiempon b?otigl)tbcfoje(pr.Iuftice Nicholas to put fn batl, 
 r-'a3ee'°^ ^"^ "°* '"^'"S ablc to put fn fufficfcnt bafl acto?Dfng to tbe courfe of tl)c 
 6 ' Court,toa0commfttcDtotbccutto!jpoftl)ci!parcfc^)alofH)ei^artbalfca,tl^e 
 C!;arlbcfns in cuttoDpbjlngoljlmfelf Into Court bp a habeas corpus, ano 
 t!jcrcplcaDsbf3p.:fW!egcofl3f)jpcetagc,an3 fapcs,tbatl)c ougftt not to 
 bcarrcftcD,auDDcmant)c3;uDgcmcntoftljcta5E[rlt,ano pjapcs to be ulU 
 tJercDj to tijfo tbe plafntfff ucmurrco. Hales of Conned toftft tljc Carl ar« 
 guco to Dfticra points , but 3; couId not bcrc bf m tocU. 315ut tljc main que 
 fiion be inCacD upon irac, toljctljcr tbat bp talUng aluap tbc boufc of J,o jog 
 fn fBarliamcnt, to^crcbp tticfr Doiccann place in ^parliament teas gonc,tl)c 
 fSjiWlegc of liia peerage not to be atreftco fo; SDebt, loaa aKo taUcn atoap, 
 Capias anDf)cargucDtbatitiDa0not,fojberaiD,tl)at at t^e Common ilato, no 
 capiaslJiolpengainffa^eer, anDtl)C§>tatuteofE.3.lDb(cl)gat3ca capias 
 f02 SDebt againft otbcrs.Dionot git)c it againft a JDccr , anD it Dctft ap<« 
 peari)cre tI)attbeH)cfrnDanti£ireaUp an CatI, ano not in nomination 
 onlp , ano IjeciteD 27 H. 8. f, 2a. E-ftercaronsberaiD iubp an Carl fjao 
 tfj" pjiWlcac not to bcarteaeD,are ttoo. %\}C firft io in rcfpcct of ti)c Dtg- 
 nitpofbio perfon, being calico comes a comitando rege ( ns fome babe 
 tfjougbt , ) ano be ia calleu bp tljc ^iing confanguineus nofler, 2Cbc fecono 
 ic in rcfpc£toftl)cpjcfumpt{on of bia futfiticrcp of cftatc in lanDo to be 
 fummoncDbp, ano not bp rcafon of bio place in parliament , foj thep 
 I)abetbep.»it)ilc2c nottobcarrcftco, ao tocU in tbe tmcantp of |S)arlia» 
 mcnta ao Ubcn tbc parliament Dotb fit , ano tbe pjittlegc of parliament 
 is tbat \)c ftjall not bcfuco ; but tbep;i\jilcgc of peerage is , tbat be (ball 
 not be arrcttcD in bifl perron, anufotl;ep are niHiiict p;iV)ilcgcg , ano bp 
 tntiing atoap tbc 5Lo jdc boufc, tl>c fo jmcr pjitillcgc is taUcn atoap, but not 
 tbc latter, ano tbispjitilcgc f anncrcototbcpsrron) notto be arrcffcb, 
 map belong to a psrfon tljat batb not tbc pjiuilegc of par.liament , as fo;. 
 Example uiito CSaiDotocg of peers tobtcb coulo not be arrcttco, ant) pet baa 
 no place in parliament , fo tiiat tbe ejcluDiiig tbcm from tbc parliament 
 Dotb onlp take abiaptbcirpjibilcgc of parliament, ano not tbeir pjiW» 
 lege of peerage, ano NevliU cafe is, tbat tijepjibilegc not to be arrcftcD 
 belcnjjs to tbcm in rcfpcct of tbc oignitp of tbeir pcrfons, 9 Rep. S lops 
 cafe, r iSuD it batb Ijccn a qucftton tobctbcr comes be fo calico a comitando 
 rccc,o; in rcfpcct of tbcir Counties Uj'.jcrcoftbcptocrc Carls, ano 31 ton- 
 ccitjc tbc latter ocriMlon is tb: truer , ano tbcn tbc taWng aiuap tbe Mnz 
 takes not aluap tbeir pjitiilegc , foj tbe Counties remain, alp. Carls 
 babe bp iiitcnomcnt fufficicnt frabolo to cnfco;e tbcm to come in, ano an= 
 ftocr at tbfs oap, ano tbcrcfo:c are not to be arrcftco, ano imp jironmcnt f 
 a mans perfon fo j oebt, toas bat a fuppiimcnt to mahc bim anfioet tobJre 
 be bao not fufficicnt frecbolo, tobfcb inc cannot inteno bcrc, Nar. brev.f.pj. 
 iSno an Carl fbaU be amcrcco btgbcr tban anotbcr man , in rcgaro of tbc 
 pjefumptionofbisfrecbolo.ano Carls arc calico majores Barones in tbis 
 rcfpcct, 7 E. 4 Nevils cafc, nno tbc tofooio of an Carl bao tbc pjitilcge not 
 to be atrctteo.fo; tljc tVoo 'ocrp tcafons t^at t)ct l)u0bano ban iVo teas it of a 
 
 SBti&op
 
 7nn.i6 50. 223 
 
 31BfCbop, ^abbot, ane pjfo; of Enfjland j but otl^ctlrffc it iuaij of a 5B:fliop ' 
 
 tbat ftao a JStOjopMcU out of England 0no tftc late Statute that taUcc a. 
 Inap t^e ISinglp office tiotb not tahe atoap t^cfr names , ano uf^nftf es,noj 
 tfje pjefMntpKon tiint tticp l}at3C freeboifla, ano tberefoje tfjrp arc not to be 
 arrcttco, anotfteft tDfllbcfmce tfteStf, no mojc a fatlcr of ticbt t!)?.n 
 tijcre toa0 bcfo je, ano fo Ije pjapco tftc MIr(t mfcbt be abateo. Roll chief Abatemeuc. 
 3ufticeanfU)crci),poarvi:ipcntougbttol;atcp;apef>tUc tGIrtt mfaftt tiate 
 abateu , befo?e tje uas turneo oVet to tljc iparQjaU *of tbia 
 Court* , fo> tijcn ^c teas in Midiefex toljcre be luas atrcSco ; but 
 
 tlOto it fe too late, fojnoiDbCf0<ncuftodiaMarercall;,anDanpbO5p tbat Declaration; 
 
 Ijatb caufe of jattfon agafr.C bJ'm map Declare agalnC bim. lerman luRice 
 
 fafD, tbat tbc 'Mxit is noiu DctcrramctJ, tobfcb pou pjap to bate abate D , fo 
 
 j»our pjapet la to no purpofe. Roll chief luftice faf d , tbat tbc ofgnftp of 
 
 tbe perfon of an Carl map relate to bim ce be <s peer of tbc |DarUament , 
 
 anDtbcotberp;cfumpttontbJ!t be batb faffictent frcebolg map alfo fafl; 
 
 lutttDotbnot appear t)crebpat)crment tbat be batb not frcebolo, tberc= 
 
 fo?e ft map be a qacftfon tobctbcr tbete Ojal! be intcnoeD a fafler of Ju&fcc, 
 
 fo? leant otirecbolOjtf tbc partpfftonlDnot b'l^'C bccnarrcfteo, auD be a- 
 
 fireeDtbatan C-arlasapcer of^arUamcnt b^oa coablcpjfttlcge, one of 
 
 t)fa perfon to be free from arrctts, tljeotberofbfs Cttatc to be free from^ 5 - 
 
 fute0 , ano be faf d, f f it bat» appcareo bp at)crmcnt tbat tbe partp bau free* ' ** ' 
 
 !)olD, it 1)80 been gooDluitbout Doubt to free btm fromarrctta. itrman 
 
 JufticefaiDbcisnolDfncurtodia,anDtbcSDeclaratioiiagatnft btm is gooD, 
 
 anD noiu it is too late to claim bis pjitilcgc, Nicholas in aU points taas a • 
 
 jaintt tbc p^ifcilcge* Roll chief luftice askcD, tebat fap pou to t'ocm tbat 
 
 l&a^c 2Dcclar?ttons on tbc bp againtt tbe CEarl , fo j certainlp tijep are goon Dceiar .t.-on." 
 
 iDbetbcr beberfgbtlpcommittebojnot, foj tbcp arc not to examine bta 
 
 commitment , and therefore lurely it is now too late to fpeak in abate mens 
 
 of the Writ, 
 
 Nayleragainft Afb. 
 
 Trin, 1050. Banc, fup^ 
 Hill. 13 Car, ror, <5ii» 
 
 NAvlerfa3ongl)t an action upon tbe fetatatc of 5 Eliz» agafnff Afli in ^"^'^ "f" 
 this Court fo J ufing tbe SCraDe of a SD?aper, ano upon not guiitp '"''f'?' "* '^ 
 jjlcaDeDtbcrciDasanitfue jopncD,anDa \3crt)ict founD foj tbe pafntiiF!o'^tVs''a-^ 
 JCbe SDefenDantmot)eoinarrcftof3!uDgcmcnt,ano tooU ttuo erccptionstutc.f ? e'i. 
 to tbe ^plaintiffs 3Dcc!aration. t. SEbat tbe Statute Dotb not name tbc ^r ufing ihe 
 traoc, 2. aCbat it being a popular ;aaion, it ougbt to batjc been fa:oagbt n"^' °^ * 
 In tbe Countptebcrc tbe offence teas committcD, ano not in tbfs Court. "^"^* 
 %o tbe I , exception the Councell on tbe ^DlaintifFs fioe anfiocrcD, tbat tbc 
 traDc is compiifco in tbc meaning of tbc statute, bccaufe it toas a tra'^e u- 
 fcD at tbe time oftbcmafeing of tbc statute. 0nDtotbefeconobcanfluc- 
 rcti ,tbat nottuitbttanoing tbat tbc ojfginal piocctTc itfuco out of tbfs Court, 
 pettbetrpaltbereupontoasintbcCountp tobere tbe offence Inas Done,' 
 ano tbc remcDp tbat tbc Statute intcnos, is maoe ufc of bp tbc trpal being 
 in tbc Countp icbcre tbc offence toas Done. Roll chief luOice anflnerco, 
 ijjCDircctcD pou to fearcb fo j pjeCoents, but pou bate not Bone it. iSiit 3 
 tonccitje tbc Statute is not fatfvfieo , foj itfaps tbat tbe partp Ojail 
 not be compcUcD to appear out of tbc Countp, anD bcrc be is compcllcD /PP""«i;c. 
 anD tbfs is not tjelpeo bp tbe Deroict, to tobfcb t^e Court agrcco. 
 
 Ernely,
 
 2 24 Trin. 16^0- ^____ 
 
 Htncly againft Allen, 
 
 Trin, t^jo, Banc. fup» 
 
 « 
 
 Mich, 1649. rot, 35r» 
 
 "C ^"^'y bjotigbt an 5lafon of SCtotcr ano cont)etfion agafnft Allcn,fo j f a- 
 T«fc7 jJdtc- "^ Wngatoap.anD contjcttfng to !)t3 oton ufc of beta of W0 cooD8,anD Cf)at« 
 iiienc in a tcls, anD amojigft otljers tie Declares foj tbc JECtol-cr ann ContjcrRon de du^ 
 Trover and ccntisponderibns, anglice toafB^t,medicaroenti, anglicc DJtias; t'oc J)laintJflF 
 Conve.hon. jjaa a tctufct, atiD a JuDgcmcrt, ano entire PamaacB gftcn foj all tbe 
 tblnns la<D in t?)c JDcclaratfon. SEljc SDefcnoant bjoiinl)t a ©Srit of crtoj 
 torc't)crfeil)li3 3(«Dffimcnt,anD afsfgnofo? CBrrojjtljat tfjc toojos de du- 
 ccntis ponderibus, anglice tDalgl)t,medicaraenti, anglice Djugg, mcntJOncO iXl 
 ti;c2Dctlaratfonarc<ncertain, anfifotfteDamageo being giDcn intirc foj. 
 alljit Vrasnot goou, Wadharo Windham of CoimtcU toitlj tl)c plaintiff in 
 tl)ctIKIlritof(!r;rro?,ftclt)thctoo;C8tobcinccrtnin, botl)in rcfpert of quan« 
 tit{?,asairointerpc£tofthcqualttpojnaturcof ttje Djugs, foj tbe luojtt 
 pondusmnpOgnifiea pounD, an outtte, a Djam, a fcruplc, 0? anp otb« 
 toafght, fo tbat the Iriaight cannot be fenoitn. Slno the anglice inaight iff as 
 inccrtain as the iLatfn Uio jo pouno, foj Uiatgljt map (Ignifie as manp cfffcs 
 renttoaigbtsaothe JlatinU)o?Dponduimap; But it might hate been o« 
 therluifc, if it has been anglice a Cone, 0} a lucigh , tohich toere toojDs cer» . 
 tainip Unoinn iDhat thep mean ; but here a tcafght of ujugsisnot unoer- 
 ttooD bp the SDJugtters. J9nD fo j the Ido jDs thep fball not be faio to be boio, 
 fo that thstc arc no Damages giben foj them , foj the toojDs are not 
 ItU to the too:Ds duodf cem duodena fili, foj thep are aotectitjc toojDs; but 
 the lT)OjDB hctc are fubtt3ntilic,anDfignifiebp themfclbcs. ^nnthciBOjo 
 tnedicameniurn nlfoisas inccrtain as the other Idojds, ano the anglice 
 Djugs Doto not maUe it moie certain , foj a ojug is of as an incertain fig. 
 nification as the too jD medicaroentum, fo? all Vegetable creatures , ano tx* 
 traalonsout ofthcm, as alfooutof the liuing creatures, maoc ufc of in 
 phpficl?,cithcr bp thcmfclticSjOj clfc compounoco one toith another, arc caU 
 leo Djugs , anD fo he p?apcD the Jutigcmcnt might be rctcrfcD. Maynard 
 on the other fiocfaiD, that the tuojDsjopneDtritl) the anglice tccrc certain 
 enough , fo? pondus Cgnlfics a Icaight, tohich toojD is toell ana commonlp 
 fenoii^namongftthciEDjugfterBhotu mucb it contains, ano he citeo one 
 PennyesCafe, teherc decern ponderibus \rithout an anglice teas hel" gooDj 
 auDoneWardners Cafe II lac. in this Court, /pert fO? the iDO?D medica* 
 (T.cntum bcinglopneD toithananglice.itisagooD iDOjD to E);p?ef0 D?ugg, 
 foiofitfclf itisnoEatintoojDtoGgr.ifieanp certain thing, ano here is 
 no inccrtaintV in the matter, fo?itfmap be brought to a /tertain- 
 tp to the Juries unDcrfiauDing , anD it is not ncceffarp to cjpjcfs tI}C mat- 
 ter like a Scholar, j a philofopher, but onlpas thep arc bnoton bp traocf- 
 menaccojDiiig to common anoerttanDing. ano in an 0aion bjotight a- 
 mongftothcrthing<3,fo?a5iib?arp of JiBoohs, luhichis mo?e iiiccrtain, 
 3luDgement^jiasgitenfo? the plaintiff, ano Melhuis Cafe, toher c the SDc« 
 tinration inter alia toas pro decern ponderibus fcrri, ten tuns Of Siron, !toa0 
 agrccDbCtiuCCn the parties, anD Laurence and Turners Cafe, Mich. 2?. 
 lac. inSLrotier anD Contcrfion, pro tnbus ponderibus lani,toas naught, be- 
 ^ tau'e it toas luithout an anglice. g>crjeant Glin argueo to the fame eflFcrt 
 
 on the fame ttDe, Hales on the othcrCtDe faiOv that notlnithttanoing the an. 
 glice the SDcclsration teas incettaft:. ^nD it is not lifee tl^c cafes de tribu« 
 
 pon«
 
 Trin.1650. ^225 
 
 ponderibuj, Anglice,toefsljts! ofCl'Kfc, oTWaltjC; ffonetocfgbt of <!Li>ktz, 
 3nDtl)Clcojoraedicaracniumi3a0nncertamai3tl}COtl)ctteojQ, fcj tt Cg« 
 nificsDitcrsfpcctefioftftfnKS, ilBut Roll chief luihcefjclDjtbattlje Djtigs 
 lucre toell cjpjcffeD by tt)e toojos Jn tbe E>Ec!aratfon in tljc tulgar ana nfual dc,.]^,^;^,, 
 acceptattoiT of tlje too jdb ; ano fo; t^e teojo weight ft (3 alfo vccU hnoton a- 
 mongftCraDrfmcn. Nicholas luOicefafo, tee mnft not frame nfcettcs to 
 otctftootDjuogemente, ano bcrc fs ccrtafntp cnoitglj (a botfj tfjs toojQsto 
 pjcfct(bJtl)CtWns> ant)«(3lmpofefblctOEj;pjcfstf)8maptIp ano part{cu« 
 larlp. Roll chief luOicefafD, t!)e2>ccIaratfonf3tUjob«nDjc'D tocfgftt, antj 
 ct)Erponehi".oiDSlf)cmcaji(n0ofa!^«no;co. lermaniudicebclD t&c2)cr 
 claratfon certain Enousl»,^anDdtcDacafctol)cre cnc orclarco pro decern 
 doliisfpirituum, Anglice, tcn l^ogfljcaos Of &p(rft0, ano aDJiiDCeO SOOi 
 A$koft!)efanieop(n<on, ano fochcjucigcmenc was affirmed, nifi» ~ 
 
 Dudcnyagaiml Collyer. 
 
 Trin, 1 550, Banc. fup» 
 Hill, aj Car, rot, i$6. 
 
 Dudeny bjoug&t a tojH of Crroi agatnC CoHyer torefcerfca Itioaemenf Error ti -e 
 upon a nihil dicic gttcn aganill f)(m at tbe Court of Barnenable" in an v ifc a ju'dgc- 
 5lctfonofi)£btb?ouat)tiiponan £)bUgatfon, ana atalQne fo;i Crroj, tljat mcnr upon a 
 tJje ConD(tfonoftt)0 51BonD Iras fojtbepnpmc:;t of monepatWotcon Courts '^''''' '^''" '" 
 rey, tcWc!) (0 not iDttl)mtt)c 3lurfaD<rtton of tl)C Court, anofo tix? cannot ob]V«ion '" 
 !)olD plea foj <t at Barneftable , ano tl)c juDgcment toag aiben upon a nihil '^*"''' ' 
 dicit, becanfet^eipica facing fojctn tbc SDefenoant faonln not ftnear it, 
 ijdWii in tWs cafe \it is not bouno to uoc. Roll chief luftice , Sif f t appear 
 ftp tbe SDeclaratf on tbat tl)e moncp toas to be pafo out of tlje 'iurlfotition of 
 tl)cCoart,tl)c3ut)gcmcntf3not gooD, ano ft f« not ncccffarp to flacat '"'•"* 
 ibe piea , f f f t appears upon tbe £)bligat{on t^at tSjc monf ca tocre to be pafo 
 out of tfte jurfsDfctfon ottfte Court , ano ftc plcao papment accojofna to tljc ^'" 
 Conoftfon ; but ff one tofU not ftcear a fo?£fn JDlca icljcrc H ounbt" to ooc ludecmcnr 
 «, tbeipiafntffmap enter juDgcment upon a nihil dici:- fojfutS a fojcfn 
 pea not fU3O3n,f0 no pea upon t^e matter. The ludgcment was rcverfed 
 nifi, &c» 
 
 Ley againfi Andeixon. 
 
 Trin, 1 65 0. Bine, fap^ 
 
 ■ 
 
 Pafch. itfjo. rot, Ji4.i 
 
 LEyb?ougWatD>UofCBtrojtorct3crfeajaogcmentcfbcn fn t!j" Com» Error to re.^i 
 moH peasfoj Andertonfn an jactlon of 2Pcbt upon an £>b'Jcrattou,ano vctfc » judpc- 
 ;af9fgn0 lo% CErroj tijat tljc iDbUgo; fn tljc £)bltgatfon upon Uihfcb the flafc "'"^ '" '''^c 
 ontoa0bjouBbtmaoel)f0iiiffeftfaCj:ccutrfr,anODpcD ano that t'.c iJfe,''"'"" °'" 
 being Crccutrffopco fntcttate ; ano tbat tbc ^lafntf f In tDc 0rtf on tcft ao. ''^"'"• 
 ntfmffratlon of tljc gcooo ano Cljaf telo of tDc feme , ano bjourtijt tljc acrfon 
 jf2Debtuponan£)blfg«tfon, 30 Sominfftratoj to tfte iuffc; toijcrcas m 
 Pafntlfoufibtfirft totetafeenJlettcroof ^lomfr.ffJratfon ue bonis non ,d„,,„i„,„i 
 
 tbc Court agwwj ano falo It <0 a plain fault , ano revcrkd the Judgement 
 
 <^S El/y
 
 226 Trln. 16^*0- 
 
 Elfy againil: Mavvdit. 
 
 Trin. i6jo, Banc.fap. 
 
 ELfy fa?oagl)t an atlfon of flffan't ano IBatterp apfntt Mawdit an ZttoU 
 ny oftljfsCoutt, antil)ts tcffc. %\)z JDefcnoant Mawdit appcateo in 
 Hu-bind propria perfona , anD ftfs Irf fc toaa in cuftodia. anu fo tftc pialntff Dcclatca 
 muft put agafntt tljcm; tl)C queftton bcre toas toljetljcr Mawdit tbc JEDcfcnoant otigftt 
 «"i(^c in^Vfljuit "''^ ^"^ P^'^ tnbaUfo^bfstotfc. BurrelofCoancel Uiitb tljc SDcfcnoatit ar« 
 and baltcry" ' B"^ " > tftat tfec E^Etlsratfon U'as not gooD , bccaufc tljat tlje ^uabano Maw« 
 dit o«2^t to l)atc put fn bafl foj bfs ®3(fc, ano dtco Smith ano Smiths cafe , 
 anDMich,i7 Car,SimonFanfhawscarc,anDDyer jyya.anO Brook title 
 Privilege, J ^3 a^anUprep. Roll chief Iu(]icefa(5 , ^t ougljt to put (rtbaHj 
 Bail. tljcrcfo jc the Plaintif nil capiat per billam,bccaufe his Declaration is not good 
 
 againfl her in Cudodiat 
 
 The Gicy of London againft De roy. , 
 
 Trin. 1650, Banc, fup, 
 
 c»uf£ why 9 T Atch flbelDS foj taufe tobp a procedendo fljonlo not be grantcD to. Lon= 
 a procedendo J^don agafnftDc roy,\il)o upon a trpal agafntt Mm toaacominittco fnLon» 
 etanIed""o don foj nOng tl)c SCtaDc Of 8 U)0?Wng ©olD=fmftl), ano a too;kfng3lclDEl- 
 Lcndon. Icr, not ftatjfng fcttcD as an Sppjcnttfc to tftc aCrane, ano luas b;oug^t ljf< 
 tl)cr bp a Habeas Corpus, i . £Ll)at tftc jDcclaratfon fs founocD upon a 315p» 
 lab. anotliat 31Bplnto<sfoiinDeouponaCuftom, anofftUbcttljeCuIlotti 
 0? IBp'lato be not ccdd fn all patts, tftc a>cclarat(on is natigbt ; ano berc tfte 
 CuCo'mfsfcttfficDfntljs ncgatfte, anBt^fsfaoppofuumin rubjedo , ano 
 By-iaw mccrip toHtratfttoH' «" H ftlf, 8 E. 3 . 77. ano tl)e 315p4ait alfo t^at is cct« 
 tie CO fa not certain , ano It fa alfo unreafonable , foj eticrp ftrohe tljc S)c- 
 fcnoar.t ftrfltEc, f3 tiCng of tfs SEraoe , anofttaiuueafonablcbc fljo'ilo pap 
 fitc pouno fo; eUerp ftroUc. alp. %\it SDcclaratlon fa not applfeo to tbc IBp* 
 laiDupontDftUbftfagrotinoeo, fojtljcoofngofa t^lng one oap fa not u. 
 Cngtoooeft, anotfjeteojoadiverfis vicibus 00 not Ijelp ft, foj t^ep ate 
 notapplpcotobfatBOjUfngaaaietoellct , but to ^fa toojbfng aaadPblo- 
 fniftl)onlp; alfoftootftnotappcarirftofa to ^atie tl)c fojfeftuce foj one 
 tbftopart of the fine fct upon Wm ; ano ft fa not fafo t^at be gafnco l)fa U- 
 tfng bp the 2EraDc o;i falc of the tommooftp lD?ought , ano the toojoa of u« 
 fingftproiucroet profi:uooo not help ft, foHt map be he ufca f t foj hfa 
 •pjftatc tifc, ano that fa to hfa pjofit, though he fell not the commooftp. 
 ^crtftfaunrcafonablethata ftranger an 0lfcn (hall be reSrafneo bpa 
 55p-.lato maoe 4o)icarfiaco, lnhcrrofl;chaQnonotfcc,anothat bpreafon 
 of (nch a ILato he Ihoulo be piinfQjco foj oofng a thfng luhich the ^Common 
 JLatoallotoo, namclptogethfaotonUtjfng. Sitfa alfo fafo, Non cxiftenj 
 iiberhoraoufuseft arte,*fc. toh'th ate tDOjoa tcrp fncertafn ; foj bpthe of» 
 fence foci;pjc{ieocl3erp;appjcntfcE map be punfrtjeo fo:i inojfjfng, foj ait 
 Slppjcntfce f a not Liber homo. M«ynard on the other Ooe cJtco 5 E. z* 
 that a negatf t)c iofth an affirmatfbe f mplpco fa gojo , ano that ft fa cj-clulibe 
 of fetrangcrs, anc fncluSbc of the Cftf jena. ano the offencefa the matter, 
 $ not the tfmc of the ©cfenoatits tiSng the SDraoe , ? ft f a alfo irell oeCgn- 
 co fn all pof nta to ii,hat ufe the fine fa to be pt!t ; ano f f there (jc Crroj thtp 
 ought to b jfna a tojft of (Ertoj , ano to cjrcept to the SDcclaratfon; 0ntt 
 thfa cafe cannot be Ufeenco to an ^ppjcntffea toojfefng, foj &e offes the 
 
 ^ra0£ 
 
 Notice.
 
 TrJn, 16 50i 22 7 
 
 SDtaOC not fo J '^fmfclfbnt!&f0 spatters faencfiU The Court de fired books, 
 and adjourned it till the next Term. 
 
 Cuftodcs liberf . '&c. againft White. 
 
 WHite toasoutlatocufnan^ctfonofCrefpafg, 3it faas mot?eB toToKverfe an 
 reUetfc t!)e £)utlalDJi? , becanfcfnt^cejtgcntft *ra0 utieft, be-- ?u'4^rjon 
 tog put foj an abbjeljiation of utlagatus eft, ano upon tbfs Ofceptfon it toas ' 
 tc^ctfeo* 
 
 Diine againft Grigfoiii 
 
 Trin,i<55o. Banc^fup. 
 Hill» i6'\9>TOt. 98. 
 
 Dlfnebjoug^tan^ttfonofHDcbfttponan ilDblfgatfon agafnft GrIgfon.Demaneraf- 
 tbe conDitton toao foj t^c paptnentof a ccrtafn fum of moncp upon tbc '" »" '""c 
 rcfisnattonofaUtfng, ano a certain annual fum at ttoo papment0, cbe^"^"^ * 
 l^laintifarsfgns a bjcac^ in not paping tucl) a fum at fucl^ a Dap , upon tbia 
 tbeiffuetDaacntrcD, ano after tbeSDcfcnoantDcmara. Roll chief lurticc, 
 SClie SDefenoant is a ^ao.man, ano toe cannot gibe ioogcment againft i„jgfmer.t, 
 ftim , ftap tbcrefo?e till be is rccobcreo*. Yet take your ludgement , nifl ,Errt'r. 
 &c, for the other may bring his writ of Error if he will. Nota, 
 
 Bernard againft Lcvic. 
 
 Triot 1 6 J 0* Banc. Cap* 
 
 BErnard bjongbt a injit of (lEtroj againft Levic to rcbcrfc a gncgemcnt Efo*" '«> •■*- 
 gitcn againft bim in the Common pipas in an aaion upon tbe cafe ioil"l\ hi'an^*" 
 rptahingtbefetoojDBofbtm, Thou JBernaro art a bafe fellow, andAd"on"4>on 
 didft kill thy firft wife. SCbeCrroMfsigncD toas, tbat it DotU not appear the c>re. 
 in tbe ^Declaration tbat tbe ^Dlaintif Iras marico bcfojc. But the Court af- 
 firmed the )udgera£nc,anDfaiD, tbe SDcfenoant Ijatb confeffeDitbpjopnfng 
 ^tTtie non culp,upon tbe toojDs. 
 
 Wood againft Topham. 
 
 Trin. i6$Ot Banc. fup. 
 
 •TTI^is cafe being an 0a{on upon tbe Cafe quarefilium fuum cepit et a^'pj,ortorf 
 I duxit,etmaritavit,tDa6 again motcD , anotbe exception infiftco upou^J,'i^'^a°ujge. 
 Iras, tbat tbe IDlaintif DOtb not fap Cujus maritagium ad ipfum penincr» , cntln an 
 JBut Roll chief luitice faio, tbat it coulD not be otbcritifc intcniscD , but tbat .^-i^n on ihe 
 tbe mariagc belongs to bim , ano it uotb not appear tbat bts &on ioas mari> ^^'=' 
 CO before, ano tbe balne of tbe mariagc is not bere material; fojtl)c mari» 
 age of bis &on belongs unto bim as a parent^ in rcgaro of bio pjotcctton Marble. 
 ano aotjice, lerman DiffcrcD, ano faio , tbat if be lucre niarrco bcto jc. be 
 toas tbcn Pater Familias , ano is out of tbe pjotcction of bis i^atber. i5at^'o«fiion 
 Nicholas ano Ask Slufiices agreeo iritb Roll, ano Roll faio, tbe matter Ijcrc 
 is not tbe lo's of tbe mariagc, foj tbat is but toincreafe tbe Damages , but 
 tbe jSrtion lies onlp, quarecepitet abduxitt /djourned to be argued the 
 next Terra. Antea et Poftca. CD 5 2 Otcf*
 
 -^g Trin. 1650. 
 
 Orefwick againft Armery. 
 Trin^itfjo, Banc.Aip. 
 Mich. 1^49* rot, 354, 
 
 Errortorr. /^Refwick bjcuglit fl tojft Of (Ettoj agafRff Armcry to rctjcrfc a 
 vcrfcajudge vyjiiogcmcntgftcnagafnttbfmfnBnnow, inanadfonof tebt upon a 
 „„nrman ConccfTit folvcrc, accojD<ngtotbCCuaomof t^e C<tp; but the ludgement 
 
 nirnt in an 
 
 Cuftom. 
 
 Aft^onof ^as affirmed, foj t|)eCouttfa(D,an actfon Of Debt \dlllfc bp acuaomupon 
 Dtbr.* aConccflitfoIvcre, but not (Ht bcbjougbtasatnftanGjecutoj, 
 
 Cuftodes Libertat. &;c.^againft Valconbridge. 
 
 Trin, itfyOtBanc.fup, 
 
 To qiuf>i an • T^^ €mxi tofl0 motJCD to quafl) an enuJctment of 0ffault ano IBafterp, 
 Lndiamcrt * 2Et)c CBrcBptfon inag, t{}at ttjE (EoDfctmcnt toflfl tahcn before t^e JaftU 
 ot Aiijuitandtesofa'fifjcanDdUaolDeUlJcrp. anu £>p£t anu SCcrmfncr , ano fo ft ootft 
 Bauciy. ^ot appcat bp tjettue of Uit)at Commffafon tt teas taken* Roll chief luftice, 
 l^c oug^t to IbeiD bp trfrtae of Ujljat Commtfslon partfcularlp (t Inas tafecn, 
 ant) tl!crcro;e lee ic be qoafhed, and a fine of 40 s. fee upon the Clark of the 
 p.^^ Affizes fjr his negligence. 
 
 i 
 
 Bowles againft Glark. 
 
 Trin, 1^50. Banc, fnp, 
 
 TSntDasfljciDCOfojcaufenponariilcofCoatt, tohp a ^joWbUfon fljoulo 
 
 wvy a ?»rr.hi. \ not bc grantcD to tl)c |a?crogatft)c Contt, JEhat fn the lufU ioWth tbe 
 
 biiioti fii°ui<*^:ctogatftieCoutteni)cabourcD to repeal, there tocrc lants gfijcntotlje 
 
 ed twhc Pre- ^'^""^"J- ^'"^ '^""'^^ anftocrcD . jf the ^?erogatfbe hatje potoer to 
 
 icgadve. pjotje a tuill , thcpmapalfo repeal ft bp appeal ; bat If lanosbe DcWfco, 
 
 together liiUh gooDs , thep hate no potoer to repeal ft as to the Intioo, but 
 
 f f thepfhoulot-atje no potoer to repeal f tag to t^e gooDs ft tooulo be mif= 
 
 thfctoufl. 3I3ut th^p halje no authojftp to mahc the oetffc gooD j III , as 
 
 Pr -inbuion. to the lanO0. 3no t'c Court teas at firtt agrcco to grant a pjohfbftfon as 
 
 tothclanQsonlp. 315utaftcru arcs the Court hclD that there couln be no 
 
 fiKh cfftifion maoe of the tofll bp }3johf bftfon , as to ftano gooo fn part, ano 
 
 to bc icpealeD fo^ the rcffj and To would not grant the prohibition, Nota,. 
 
 Kenifton againft Crouch. 
 
 Trin. 1^50, Banc, fup. 
 
 For a rule to np ^t Court iias mohcD that upon a 3!«Dgeincnt gftjcn fn the Common 
 enter juiiRc- I Peas, fincctbcS[athatair?ftoferrojfl)nlibcnofuperfedeas,ato?<t 
 T'lr^a" ^'f ^'^'^°' ^^^ b; ought fn thfs Court, ano the rrcojD remotjctt , but thatbe^ 
 puardenicd penos unOEtcmiineo , ana that the partp hatJ motcD fo; erccntfon fn the 
 ■ Common P'.eas ; but the Clarks refufe to maEic out orcftUfcm, tofthont 
 the rule of this Court, anotb:rcfo;carnle toas pjapcD to them tontate 
 • oat erctutton. 315ut the Court anf toercD, pjocao as the jgirt Dfrctfs , tec 
 
 toill maU« no rule ; But we conceive there it no writ of Error now depend- 
 ing
 
 Trin. [^50. 22.9 
 
 ing, and therefore you may take out execution of Conrl'e, Q, Tamcn, for 11 hxcuiion. 
 was doubced at the Bar. 
 
 Denton againft Harifon. 
 Trin, 1650. Banc, fup, 
 
 DEnton bjoagbt an Stction upon t&c Cafe agafnft Harifon {« London, Tor a Proce- 
 fOJ fpcafetng tftcfe iUOjOS, Thou art a Whore, and my Husbands Whore, '^^"'^"' toLoa- 
 and he doth maintain thee, Klft SOcfenoant remotjcQ tbc caufe {nto t^fa*^""' 
 Court bp a Habeas Corpus , toftcrcupon tfte J9lafntff moticD fo; a proceden= 
 do. Roll chief luftice toas Of opfnfon tljat a procedendo ougftt to be grant* 
 0D, fo?fffta)onlonot,tbcpartpftatl)norcmcDptop;occcD; atioff t^cpDo 
 pjocccofn London, anDtftcittogement be thereupon ctron(ouet, tbe partp 
 grfctjeo map bjfng a tojft of CEtro; fti tljc Huftinges , ann tetcrfe it, Icr- 
 inan lufticefafo. bctcfsatDjongoone, anDtt)cremeBp<0 giten atcojufng 
 to t5je cuftom of tftc Cftp , ano ft <« a gooD cnftont, brcanfe ft is fo j t& - pje. Cuftom. 
 ferbatton of tfje |0eaccof tbcCUp, ano U is tbe cu0om of tbe Cftp 
 totoWpa tlSfjojcmonget, ano to Cart a MtojC; ano tbta map be f^a 
 prounuojreafon tobp an actfon If eg in London foj caUfng of atoomati 
 to^oje tljcrc, ttioug^t ft Doe not If c fn ottiet places. 
 
 Jrin. 1650. Banc.fup. 
 
 V^on an HITuc lopneo , anb a SCrpal tberenpon , a ^acrofet \aae fomttt Th»t ludge- 
 foj tbc plafntff , ano tbe Poftea toas oelfbereo to tbe Clark of tbe ^ ="« ""Rhc 
 juogcmentsto enter tbcjiiDgcment; buttl)?oagl) t^e Clarks neglert ere= '""''' '"""'• 
 tntfon teas taken out , tbe Bjuogcmcnt befiig not cntreo , upon tbfs tbc 
 Court teas mobeo tl)at t^e 3luDgement mfgftt not be entreo, brcaufe ft ludEcraent ; 
 fl)onH) bate been cntreo befojc (Erecutfon fffueo fo?.t^, ano tf)crcfo;c ft teas 
 faggcftcBtbatnoiDtt^oastmlatc, anDpjapeOtofuperfetietfjeCrcciitfon, 
 ij.caufc tbere iijas no juogcmcnt to ttarrant ft. IBut Roll tbc Chief lufticc ^T"'''^"'* 
 anftDcrrb, tbattbfsbcfng but a neglect of tbeClarS, fnogcmcnt mfgbt be 
 iBCfl enougbentreo.tbougbtbeCErctntfon incrc fffueo fojtb, ana bccaufe 
 tbctrpalbcttoeentbcpattfesfsrfgbt, therefore let it beemred. 
 
 Cane againft Pell. 
 Trin, 1^5 0- Banc. fup. 
 
 Arreft of 
 
 CAnebjougbtan0ctfonofSDcbt upontbe&tafutc of z Ed. <5, foi fub- 
 flraafono{tftbe0,agafnftP<-ll, anobatbattTfiftt agafnft tbc 2D^fen-^","ement in 
 Dant: SDbeOefcnBantmobcofnarrcaof JuDgcment, sno tooh an ©pauaion «p- 
 ceptkjntotbepafrttf,a2)eclaratf9n; SCbat ft Bfo not appear bp ft fn toliat .thcScatuie 
 parfflj tbe lanos If e , out of tob'cb tbe tftbcs grcto cue. £)n tbe otbcr fioc ^^' ''^'^"* - 
 U tt,aa fafo.ft appeareo tocU cnougb bp f mplfcatfon; but ff ft Dfo not, ft is not 
 nolB matcrfal, tbere bcfng a bcrufct fn tlje cafe bp inbfch ft fs fjclpeo. Icr- 
 inanIufticefafii,tberef8onlpan fmplfcatfon to fljctjDfn to'^at ^arfflj tbe 
 ianBsUc, anotbatfsnota bfoknt fmplfcatfon ncftber, ano tbcrcfojc ttje 
 jDeclaratfon cannot be goon. IBnt Roll Chief lufticeatiftocreo, Obat f£ 
 tbe pi fnt*f bao onlp fafo . that tbc tfthea bclongeo unto bfrn:- 3no ft fa 
 ibcrc after a ticrDftt , ano tbc Sp^claratfon f a belpco bpft; but ff pou bao oc. DechratioB. 
 . murreo to tbc Dcclaratfon. ftuiotilobatcbcenrulco to be nauabt. 3no 
 K tbc tftbes DO belong to tlje Jplatatf f , iubp map ft not be fmplpco tbat tbcp ^^^^""' 
 
 <25S3 be.
 
 230 Trin- 1649 
 
 bclongtobfmaojpatfonoftfteparfft, anDate of laniis Iptng toftftfn t^e 
 IpartQ) : But let us fee a Book, and fpeak to it again the next Term. 
 
 Robinfbn againft VValker. 
 
 Tritt. 1650, Banc, fup, 
 Pafc, i^jo,rot«25i. 
 
 Demurrer for "^T xT TAIker fajoosftf 311 Slctfon upotl tl)C (Tafc upon 311 indebitatos Af- 
 doubicnef? in V V fumpfit foj tD3tc8 folo. Sl^c SDcftnoatit pleaDco tftc &tatutE Of It' 
 a '«^pi'""^":^ftfltfonsof <3ctfonB{nl5ar. SCijc ipiafntff replpco , tfjat ftc f0 a fpercftant, 
 anDlnasfn Ireland, anDDfo not return ttiente tfll fuclj a tfme, ano actus 
 pjccffelp tut)en , anD t^at toltljln Ot pears after I)fs return l)c bjongJjt tbfs 
 aaton apontt)fsUcplfcatfon, Edc JDcfenoant tcmurreo, ann upon tfte 
 Demurrer 3uDsement teas gJbcn foj tlie |3Ia(ntlf. 2Ebe Defenuant 
 brought a tDjtt of C:ro J to rcterfc tbfs juDgcment.ant) afsfaneo fo j (Erroj, 
 1. 2Lf)at tl)C replication of tbe Iplafntff, upon toftfcfj t^c Demurrer toas )opn« 
 eD, fs Double ; foi 8rtt ^e aBcgetft tbat ^e fs a ipcrc^ant , % fo; ts a perfon 
 out of tl)C Statute of Ifmftattons: Snofeconuipbe lljetos tbal ^c bjougW 
 l)(3 attton to(tl)ln 6 pears after bfs return, to^ft!) fs necDlefs. zlp.^e 
 faftl), Ciiat ^etifD not return fnto England, Irftcreas ttje Statute fs gene- 
 ral, 31f|>e return, anufte map return fnto Wales. iSnt to t^attljc Court 
 anftoereo, tftat to return fnto England, ojfnto Wale?, tuas all one as f o tl)e 
 fntcnt of tbe Statutc/jlp. Etje action toas an 2ctfon upon tfte Cafe, ft tbat 
 actfon (s not mentfoneu fn Ibc Statute, IBat Roll chief luftice fafo , tbfsf 
 is no neto Cafe; foj ft batb been ruleo tljat an Action upon tbe Cafe is tottlj* 
 Cafe. fn tl)e Statute. lermanlufticefaio, tftelDzotjifo of tftc Statute is fnteno- 
 
 eo to be as large as tbe boop of tfte act. Nicholas luflice to tbe fame effect 
 anDfaiDjtbattbetoojDSCterparsmentioneDfntlje act Dotft compjffe fn ft 
 an action upon tfteCafc. J he ludgement was affirmed, mfi. 
 
 Trin. 1650. Banc- fup. 
 
 To q'laf!-. 
 
 A/|iCnt)ictmenttoa3t|uaH)eD, faccanfeft toasraiotobetahcnadgcne= 
 ralem SefTionem Pads Cuftodum libertatis Anglii , tobcre ft OUg^t to 
 be Seflioncm Picis publics, bp Ierra3n lufticc , abfence Roll. 
 
 Treton againft Squire. 
 
 Tiin, 1650. Banc, fup. 
 
 Tohivc* 'y^^c Court teas motcDtbat a p^ffcner fn tl)C ^arflbalfea migljt fjate 
 
 Pi ifoner to ^ If bcrtp fcp rulc of Court to be at a trpal to site bis tcCimonp as a Wit-- 
 
 Kftific at a „pfg ^^ t^j. jgufp. lerman luftice, abfente Roll, anf toerCD , IBjfng bfm tbl- 
 
 * "*'• tbcr bp a Habeas Corpus , but tahe a gmo guaro icitb tj'm , fo: it fljafl be at 
 
 HabeaJCor- pour pcrilff IjE cfcape, anDteftaUbeb;oHgt)ttt)ttt)cr,anDcatrfcD faacfe a< 
 
 fus. gain at pour oton enlarge. 
 
 Gibs
 
 Mich. 1^50. 251 
 
 Gibs aoainft Price. 
 
 Tiin. 1650 Banc fup. 
 
 GlbsaHBamftet of Lincolns Inne bjougftt an action upon tbe cafca=Arrtftof 
 SafnftPricefojrpeabfngt^efetDOjD0Offtfm, William Gibs hachdcalc'"'^P'^n«nf ■'' 
 falfelywith me being his Clyent, and hsth joyned with mine Advcrfary*'" '■^'°" *'"' 
 mponnotguatppleaDCD, tljcreiDSsaniffuejopnED, ano a tacrcfrt often """"'" 
 fo? tfte i^lafntft". SClic SDefcnoant moteD in Slncft of ^rnqtrntnt ttjat tftc 
 tD0?Ds Uicrc not actfonabl0. JBnttftc Court bclo clearlp tl^c iroaos iicte 
 attfonable, ano toetc ojDcifns juDsemem to be entrco foj tljc |31afntff,p j. 
 bHtfaccaufeanottjctcrreptfontBastaUen, SCftattljepafntifDotft not after ' * 
 tl^at be iras afDjactfrcr st tf)e time of tlje bringing of !)ls actfon;anD faccanfe 
 UiDasalfoobjcfteDtftattftcpiamtiftaasnoto fcqucttreo, Jotjercfoje tbc ^^'"-""t. 
 rale toas, tbat t^e IRcco jd oj tbc Poftea ftoulo be fajougbt fnto tbc Court , 
 anotbat Coancel (tioulo agafn be l^taxn, 2:1510 teas ntoticD again , ano 
 Roll chief iulticefalD, SCtjattlje palnttfotigijt toal3Ct!)e<0a|a?actlfcr,foj 
 ije map be a^JlBarretter ano net p?a(tlfe» But ibc Court would advifc» 
 
 Boomer againft Clevc. 
 
 Trin. i^joi Banc, fap, 
 
 Ii^ 1^10 Cafe In artcC of 3iaiiSEment npon a tjerolct giben foj f ^e piatnf If Arreft of 
 fn an Action upon tbe fetat.of Winch, 1 2 E,i. of !^uc ^ Crj>c0,tlje qucffton '"''ptmenr ;n 
 being , teljctfter tbe pialntlf In ^10 SDcclaratlon &ao' minrccltco t^c statute ^" ^^'°'^ "?' 
 ojnot, Roll chief Iafticeto5ktbf0 Difference, tbatffoneb?lng an Action °u re of, "e^ 
 upon a fetatute, anofn l)l02Detlaratton mff^reclte It, In tDojD0 iD^lcft tto cf Hue and 
 to tljegrouno of tlie action, tftougbtberebea laeroldlntbecafc, pet It Cries 
 t0 not ibclpcD ; but fftljcmlf- recital be in U)ojD0it)blcl) Doe not goe to tbe^^"^"'- 
 grounDoftljej9rtlon, U is lielpeo after aetolct bp t^c fetatatc of Se'ieofa;] 
 ofall0. . ' ^' 
 
 Bynion againft Trotter. 
 Michf 1650. Banc, fup, 
 
 BYnionb?oagi&t an Action upon tlje C2jrc againft Trotter foj fpealjing Afreft of 
 t^CfC tOOjOa of ft! nt, He is a Thief, and hstb ftollen my Turnips andiudpcmcnt in 
 my prafs, tHpon a tUcrDlct gitjcn fo j t^c ^pialntif , SCtie SDefenDant mo- an *aion tar 
 tcD fn arteft of Juogcmcnt tljat tftc toojD0 arc not actionable , becaafe tlie '"°"^^- 
 Braf0 mfg^t be grotofng upon tbe gronnD, anD tbe 2nnrnlp0 fn tl^e grounD.^^jC^ 
 ano fo part of tfte iFrecbolD. 215ut Roll chief luflice belD, tl)e Ido jos arc acti- 
 onable , fo;t tbe aEurnfp0 Q)aU be fntenoeD to be puUcD up , ano tbe t^jafs 
 motueDjSt^claftiDOjDsate notcumulatibe. Therefore lee the Defendant 
 fhew caufe why the Plaiouf (hall cot have his ludgemenc. 
 
 Pioder
 
 :^z Mich. 1650, 
 
 Pinder againft Davvkcs. 
 
 Micbt i^sOfBanc.fup, 
 
 Error to re- D^fwlef ''^^'tisbt SH 0(t!on Of JCtcfpafs flgattift Dawkes , aoo Declatw, 
 
 vcrTa'l°uJ|c- X quarc claufuro frcgit contra paccm publicam, et poftci ct palos fuos ibidem 
 
 mcnz in noper tnventos cepit ec afportavit. %[)t piaintff Ijatl) a t3crDla anO a 
 
 Tr^fpafs - jucgemcnt, tfte SDcfcnuant bjfngs a iDjJt of Cttoj to tctctfc tl)c jucac= 
 
 c]u.rc c)au- ^j,.^^^ ^^^^j afsigns foj ©rto}, I » E^at t!)C ICrefpaffl toaa oonc In tbc late 
 
 urn ftgii. luj^ggtjj^j;^ anDtl)crcfojEtUcSD0clatattonQioulDbaticbeen contra pac«m 
 
 Dommi Re gi5,anD not publicam. alp. 2Lf)at t!)c EDcclatatton ta tnttttattt ; 
 
 fo J it appears not tobetljer t^e ipoffs ann |3alc0 tocrc fiiccD to tfte groanD o:^ 
 
 no, noj t)oto manp of tbcm tljcrc toete , ano fo tijc nature of tftc offence 
 
 cannot be ccrtatnli' linolun. IButtbc Court bclo tbat tljc firft crtcptfon 
 
 Iras but a mtftaUc of tljc Clarh , ano fo map be nmctiDco, ano as it is tljcrc 
 
 is no repugnancp in it. Slno as to ttc fctonu , tbc Court ^clo tftat it fljall 
 
 Amendment, jjg jntcncco tfjat tt)e pofts ano pales tDerc not fircD to tl)C grouno ; ano 
 
 } „j there is no neccfsftp to etpjefsBoioRtanppofls ano Ijolu manp pales tt)C 
 
 " " "'" SDefcntant tool?, ano it is not material totictftcr tftep toere fip^o oj not. 
 
 But the Court would advife, and ordered Councel to ipake again to it, 
 
 Popham againft White 
 Mich, i6^0t Banc* iapf 
 
 Exfcpuon to « jtjf^Cctfon of SCrober an CotcrCon Iras brought, tobcrcin tbe plaintit 
 f ^'^^'*^''|.'°"x\Dfclarco pro Afboribus. Twifdenof Councel toltbttic IDcfenoant ar- 
 and convcr-gncDtbattljcSDfclaration teas not gooo, bccaufc a JLrober cannot lie de 
 fiJD. Aiboribus. Rollchief lufticc, be map Declare deArboribus, if ^e Tap ttjat 
 
 I)C Isas poCTciTel) (Icut de Arboribus fuis propriis. JlBut Icrman luAice DOubtCO 
 
 Therefore the Com t would advife, 
 
 Martin againft Hendlye, 
 
 Mich, 1^50, Banc, fup, 
 
 M Artinb;ouabt an Action ofSDebtagainS Hendlye a ^beciffo^ an e- 
 fcapc, ano ban a tHeruirt againtt bim. 2Ebc ©cfcncant mo\\tr\ in 
 an'aal^n oV" ^trcft of Bliiogcmclit, ano toob tbefc crccptions. i . Ebat tljc action toaa 
 Dibtacairft bjougbt tp tbc piaintif as an aominiCrato j, foj tbe efcape, tolicb taas 
 a si.erif for macein tbe life of tbe 31ntcftatconlp. ziy.SCbat tberets no Cnpias iffneo ro 
 an f fcipe. jjj. g>{jj;tjf, %\:,c Coutt anflDcreo , SCbat tbe e>berif cannot taUc au'oan* 
 Advanta|c, ^^^^ ^^ ^^ crronious p?otefB ; but tbe firft erception is goon , foj tbe adion 
 Dcrii ( r; onebt to be b jougbt in tbe Detinet onlp, tbe piaintif being tut an aomlnf- 
 
 Cratoj, U bo recovers not to bis otpnufc. Therefore ilay ludgeraent till 
 
 the Piainlif move. 
 
 Detbick
 
 Mich. 1650. 23^ 
 
 Dechick againfl: 
 
 Micb, 16J0, Banc. fup. 
 
 DEthick motieD fo} a p;ol)<Wt{oii to ttje Sfomtraltp fo j pjcferrfng an For a proiih;- 
 Cnoictmcnt tfterc , toftfcb (3 not toftMntlje Statute touching ttic ilD-^ntothe Ad- 
 inftaltp , ano fo tljcp tatic no jurfscfctfon of the caufc Cftc Court anftD&- j^''»'ty- 
 rco, tljataPjol5fbftionltc0not<ncarecofiFclonp,btU{ftl)cre bcCaufe it Ceuioiar'i"' 
 map be remotjeo bp Certiorari, But wc wul advife, ' '*"' 
 
 Bennecand the Hundred of [hrtford. 
 
 Mich, idjo. Banc. fup. 
 
 T^ a trpal at 31Bat bettoccn t!je iiibabftanta of Hartford ano Bennet aCarp* Evidence by 
 er upon an 0(tfonb;ongbtagafnatl)cmiipontl)c Statute of wincbefter/^"^**' '""='"- 
 fo; a robbcrp commfttco aftWn tliat ipimBjco. upon f)ts fcrbant , %t toas Ej°dtc '"'^' 
 fatobptfte Court, tbattf citbzr oftljcpartfestoatrpaUDcfitctbataJuroj "' '^""' 
 mapcfbecljtocnce offometbtngofbfs oton knotDlcugc, to tbc reft of tljc Exam nniDn. 
 3uroj0, tbattlje Court totlUramfne bfm opcnlp fn Courtnpon ftt's oatb,^''*^'^^»hun- 
 ano l)c oiigW not to be et amfnco in p;f tatc bp tfa companf ons. Sno ft toas ^'|^'J "']" ''= 
 alfo fafo, ttjat i a robbcrp be Done <n crepu(cuio,tbc!^anD?cD (ball not berobLcryoT * 
 cljarpD ; but ff ft be Done bp deer Dap IfgU, tobetber It be bcfo:c &un r{fc where not 
 oj after &on fct, ft f0 all one, foj tbe ^unD?eD ibail be cbarnco fn botb ca- 
 
 Mich. 1649. Banc. fup. 
 
 SErjeant Earl, SI 3!urp bcfng rcaDp at tbe 515ac fo; a trpal , tballengcD tbc 
 arrapfoi toant of ^^unoicocrs. ano Dclttocrco fn tbc cballcnge fnAchiiicneej 
 tDiftfng to WoodwarJ tbe Clark oftbe Court to be rcaQ; JBat tbc Court '■'''' '"'^ 
 fntcrruptcD bfm , anD fafo to tbc Serjeant, pou ougbt firft to rcco ft pout h[,^j "/dofs 
 felffn jprcncb»\ibicbbe atcojofuglpDfo, anBaftcriiaraa Woodward rcao thrnunncr' 
 ftfnilatfn. Twiidenof Councclon tbc otbcrfioc fafo, that tlic tballcngcofit. 
 tiao tal-.cn to no purpofe , fo; tbc 3utp Voao rcturncD bp tbc fecconoarp bp 
 rule ofCourt, anD tl;e1^unD;cDersirerc put out bp tbcconfcntof tbc par. 
 tfes; IBut tb: Court anftcerec, tbat tbc ronfcnt of tbc partfcs tcao to no 
 purpofe to abofo tbc cballcngc , but tbat ft iuas a gooo tballcngc, auo tbcrc Confmr. 
 cannot be a tales granteo upon a tballengc fo; Default of ^^imojeocra , ano challenge. 
 tbcrcfo;e tbc panel Itjao nuafbcD, anD a ncto 3:urp ojDcrcato be rcturncn ^*'<=-'' 
 bp tbe S>bcrfff 3n tbis cafe ft 1030 faio, tbat after tbc firft man of a Jurp 
 ia f toojn, tbc jSrrap cannot be cballcngco. 
 
 CioeaaainftDod. 
 
 Mich. ;<Jjo, Banc, fup, 
 
 •y pon a trpal bcttoen Cape ano Dod toucbfng a Coprboltj ft \xs3 fafo bj» \vh« copy. 
 ^ tbe Court,tbat a CoppbolDcr fo;lffe cannot picfcribc againft bfa ILo;D; iv-.idcr may 
 butaCoppbolDctfnfccmap , fo:bcbatb tbc Coppboln fn tbc nature of P'^^r"^t>= 
 3LanD of fnbcrftancc. flnD alfo tbat ff a Coppbolocr fo; Iffe cut ooton tpm* l^Vj an*!!* 
 bcr trccsjtbc JlojD map take tbcm. SlnD tbat ff an unocr ilcffee fo; pearo what 'nor 
 
 l^b of '
 
 224 Mich. 1650, 
 
 p-"ieuure. Of a Coppljoloct cut Dotoii tpJTtbcr, U OinB Hot bc 8 fojfcUiuc of t^c <topp. 
 ijolDcrs cttatc, 
 
 The CountefTe Rivers. 
 
 Micb* i6$o. Banc, fup. 
 
 T^^ Countcffc Rivers put fn bcrplca of p;(Wlcsc of pccrajtc U\io 
 priviwr of ^ Court, anopjapcDbp&cleant Gim ofljct Couuccl tbat it mfgbt bz 
 iH-craj-c by-arcao, auD allotoco. tUlpou to^fc^ it tofls rcaD Up Woodward Clark 0'^. tbc 
 Cm,;t.f;. Conrt. ilitct VDl)ftb RoU chicf lofticc fa(o , ft ta qucCtonablc tobctlcr a 
 Privilege. Counters ttiaDe fo bp patent onlp foj ftet Ufe bcp;f\jilcgco oj no, tbcrcfoje 
 
 let tjctrcmafnfn the CuftoDp of tbe&^f riff till Saturday, anonot be tut» 
 
 neo otjcr to ttie CuttoDp of tljc jparcfcljall , ano tticn mote <t a0a<tT, 
 
 Poftea, 
 
 Burton againft Low. 
 
 Mich. 1650. Banc, fup. 
 
 Demurrer 
 
 BUrton bjougbt an Sflfon of D:bt acrafntt low,upon a&ljcrfffa bono afbcn 
 ^ „._ bp Low to tbe&bctiff facing arrcftcobpWmbpWrtue of an atfattt- 
 
 s'hc. ifl's" " mcnt Dircttco to l)fm out of tbe Cljancerp, tbc conoitfon of tfte IBono toagi 
 
 lona. t^at t!jc JDEfcnoant flioulo appcaronfucftaDapinCancellariaapud Weft- 
 
 monaftcrium abicui que fuerir,s:f)c SDcfcnoant plcaD0 inJBar tl)c statute of 
 
 36H.<5.tljcpaintiffDcmurrciJtotbi3 plea. Mofeley of Councell Inftlj 
 
 tbc SDefenoant argtiro tfjat tbc IBono upon toWcfttbe 0£tfon toao bjoualjt 
 
 tuaotoio, anoagiiiifftbc Statute. i.JlBccaufctbcpartpfcbounoto ap» 
 
 pear inaCourtjtubtcbionotafirtCoHrt, ano fo incertain , namclp tlje 
 
 CourtofCl^anccrpat WeOminfVer,lDt)crcafltl)cC6anccrp (s a motjcable 
 
 Court, anorotfirtto Weflrainfterojanpotbcrplace. alp. SClie conuftf- 
 
 cnoftlic£?Ll(aatfcni0imporsiblc, fojitfs tbat tljc SDefcnoant fljaD ap. 
 
 pear til t5)c Cbanccrp at VVt ftminfter toljcrcfocter it Kiall be , ano it ia im- 
 
 pofstble Jo J \)im to appear at VVeftminfter, anD at anot!)er place at the fame 
 
 time. 'jlp. SlIjc Bono tjarfcc from tbe fefatute in fome tbingo , ano en« 
 
 jopns rnojc tl-an tfjc Statute rrquircs fn otbcr tbinss. VVilmot on tifz 
 
 otbcr fioc bclD tfjnt tljc IBono is not toitbin tljc Statute , bctaufc tlje Mas 
 
 is rot luftbin tbc fe>tatutc , as teas brio 13 Car. & 7 H. 4. f. 44. 5 rep. 
 
 VVhelpdalescarf,Dyerii9. Roll chief luflice bclD,tbat a 3BonO jjfbcn 
 
 to appear upon an attaftljmcnt out of tbe Cbanccrp is toftbin tbe Statute ; 
 
 but it batb been fjerrtofojc a qurflion Intetber a Serjeant at ^rms of 
 
 Walt^lDrrcltitbiufb: ?s>tamti butitbatbbccnftnccrulcotbatftefs not, 
 
 ariD bete is a material tiariarce in tbe iSono, febicl) makes it tooto, anu neis 
 
 obi/gjuor. tbcrtbe upper IPcncbnoj tbe Cbanccrp arc fijrt Courts, ano tbctefo?e 
 t!jcS>efenDaiitonnbtnottoiJCbounijpjccffclpto appear at VVcfVminfter , 
 
 ^^'['.'i"-' an.DtbcntoaoDcbicuir.qucfuerit is a material Variance, anD maizes tbe 
 jlBononaucbt. lermanlufticetotbefameefFcrt, ano faiP, tbat tbe Cban. 
 tcrpmap fit at anptimeoutoftbcJEermtebentbcp plcafe, anQtbeirnot 
 Gttmc in tbe tHacatfons, is fo j tbe cafe anb conticnicncp of tbe people. Nil 
 capiat ptr biUam n fi,?..c. Antca. 
 
 Paine
 
 Mich . 16 5 0. 2 3 5 
 
 Paine againft Preftny. 
 
 Mich. i6jo. Banc, fup. 
 
 PAine b jottgW an 0ct(on upon tbe cafe agafntt PreHny, fo j fpcafefng f^cfc ^rreft of 
 lDOjD0(toaConftablc)ofbfm ; Take charge of him, and carry him a. judpftncnt In 
 way, for I lay flat Felony to him,anO fo} fpeafefnij tljefc ico?D0 to tfte plain- ^n aaion for 
 tfffWnifelf, I willmakeyouholdupyouhandat the Bart upon not glifltp ^'■'°-'*^- 
 pleaDeDaniCTuctoas jopncD,anDatcrDfttfounDfo;tlje|0la(nttff, 5t teas 
 tnoteDfn arrcftofSltJDgcmentt&attbelDojDsarc not actionable ; but tbc 
 Court ftclo tljcm clarlp adfonablc, and ruled the Plaintiff to take his l.-dge* 
 tnent , except other caufe were Viewed to the contrary Friday following, 
 
 Popham againft White. 
 
 Mich. idjo. Banc. fup. 
 
 "Wpon a ticttiftt founD foj tlje paintfff in a %to^tt f ConberCon, tbc H)c- Arreft of 
 ^ fenoant inSlttttt of 3IuDgmcnt tooU eyccptton to tljcSDctlaratfon becaufe ;«''e""cnt ;n 
 ttic plaintiff ban DcclarcD of a JCtobct 1 ConbcrCondedecemarboribus^^^^'J'^'l^j''^^^"* 
 tobcrastbc ttccs tuete SCpmbcr trees tbat icerc fellec,! fo tbcp arc not IdcU /'a'^"^ yf. 
 EjrpjeffcD, fo; tbe tuojo arbor pjopcrlp Cgnifics a tree tbat grotos , ano not '/ ' 
 
 onecutDoion, accojuing to tbe OlD berfe, Arbor dum crefcit lignum duin 
 crcfcere nefcit,anD fo a SCrobcr cannot be bjotiQbt pro arbore. But Roll chief j^^^,^^ .^ 
 luflice faidjthat they were wtll enough exprefled by theDeclaration,and that Dcfcrip'ian.' 
 they ought not to be too ftriS in fcanning lomc words where the thing is well 
 defcribed. 
 
 Goffs Cafe. 
 
 Mich, 1^50, Banc, fup, 
 
 C"^ LeraentGoff of Greenwitch in Kent, arraigncD of fcloni? atM idiToneA p:rJon far 
 jfnKent, anDtbereronDcmncD, iuasbjotigbtto tbielBar, anu tbcrc^'^'W, ^i^-"- 
 it uas DcmanOcD of bim bp tbc Clar'h on tbc criminal Bcc, tobat be cotUO f^f "J'*^ ^'' 
 raptDbpbcOjoulDnotfuffcrDcatbaccojDingto bis Blaugcment i inbcrcup. "'"^'^ 
 on tlje p jifoncr pleaoco be ban a partjon, ano pjootjceo it , ana it inas reaD 
 opcnlp, tbc pjifoner Imceling on bis Ucces in tbc mean ttmc; after rcaning 
 of it.be teas askcD tobat it ioasbc ucmanocDibcIiDcs of tbcCourt;'be anficc- 
 rcD , tbat be pjapcb Ws parcon migbt be allotocu, tobicb. after lerman luflice 
 ijao maBc a grate fpcccb to eicbojt btm to a better carriage fo j tbc fatiire, 
 tDasiJoncatcojDingli'. 
 
 Wood againft Topham. 
 
 Mich, 1 650, Banc, fup, 
 
 Tl^ecafc bctlBCcn Wood ano Topham being an iSction of SCrcfpaflfr, J^J'J*^^*^^ . 
 quaic fiiium et heredem fuum rapuit et mnritavir, tuas again fpofecn tin» M"l-rva^mi«c 
 to, ancinarreff ofJuogcmcntGrtentooUtbcfccvccptionsto tbeSD-'cU;- liii/m « hc- 
 rstion. I. aCbat it is too fl)ojt,bccaufc tbat after tbc iDOjDsquarefilmai redcm rapui: 
 fuum oiheredero rapuit & raaritavit,tbere OUgbttobatiC been aOOCD cujus mas ^ '"ariwvit. 
 ritagiuro^dipiumpertinct, fO} clfe it appears not tbat tbc plaintiff batft 
 caufe of action, Inflit, f. 30. &: 3 5 El, Child and Towri cafe Banc. Reg. 2lp. 
 
 ^^i Sibe
 
 236 Mich. 165a 
 
 "ICbclBDEclaratfon ootbnot fap fiiium fuam apparentem.toftfcfj ft ouaftt to no, 
 because tb* i^atljcr is aUte. 3!?. Jt ootb not cjp.r.etTe t^c \^tk to be infra 
 atatcra. 4lp» 3t Dotijnot faptbcl^cfr tstllcuftodiafua. 5lp. JtDotljnot 
 fljetD tbat tljc lpc<r toas not marrteo' bfcfoje. 6lp. 3t Dot^ not Qjeto t^at 
 tl)C plaintiffs i^atbcrf 3 DcaD, 12 H.4.f.; i6.Brev.Tir. Trefpjfle, 101 
 Nat. brcv. 141. Reg. 163 Nat. Brev. 140, lo H. 6.f, 44. Sinn ^e fetO. 
 t^at a ST^ccUiration oug^t to be certain ; but tbat fjctc trao no ccrtafntp, bj? 
 , tcafonofttjcfojiticrejccptfons. VVilmoi ontljc otl)crQoc fafotlje Dc* 
 
 Ticrpars'""' tlaratfon teas certain cnou£f),anDaccojt)fng to ttc pjeftoents, ano citco 
 tljcllecitter, f. 88, 89. & j.rep. Ratcliff»cafe.Ro)l cfiietlulhcefalD, 3t<3 
 a SCrcfpntTc to tahe alxjap a mans S>on ano l^rlr,altt)ougl)!]e be not Urftljin 
 age; but If It be another S>on It Is not fo.NichoIas luftke to t^e fame effect; 
 iStit bccaufc tlje Court inag not ftill,^ In rcgaro t^at t !;e Damages glten bp 
 tbc 3iurp tocre crcefjlb0,tl)c Court Deferrco to gibe 5u3geme:it tftat time , 
 ano perfiDaoeD tbe plaintiffs councell to go to a ncio nctotrgaU. An- 
 teactPoftea. 
 
 i/arQiall aga'nft Ledfliam. 
 
 Mich, i6yo. Banc fup» 
 
 Artcft cf \A Arfhall bjopgl^t an Action of Debt as an aomfniffratoj againff led- 
 
 j'adgen^ftt' in IVl (liam, snD obtclns 3 feerolct agafntt t^c ©efenoant. 3t teas moteo 
 
 dcbr by an fo; tl)C Dcfcnoant in arreft of Jaogement , SEljat tbc plaintiff fjao not 
 
 AJm;niflatcr j|jg^jpj„^f2 2]5j£la^at,-Qnbp jj^o^ tfjB Blcttcrs of aomfnfffratfon toerc 
 
 granteu unto l)f m, as l)e otigbt to do, acco jDfng to tljc book6 of ; 6 H. g. 2p» 
 
 & 5 5H.(5, Ebc Court anrircr'cDtftat lie onglit to fjatjc fct ft fojtf), ano 
 
 Iftcrcfoj e t!}e plaintiff mirljt bate Demurrco to tbe E>rtlaratfon ; but ft 
 
 Demurrer ^oto bcfUR after a tierDfct, tftc qucttlon fs, iLa^ctl)Ct tl)at fault be not ^elpeo 
 
 bp ft? And therefore they would advifc. Poflca, 
 
 Wats znd his wife againft Lord. 
 
 Mich, 1 650. Banc, fup, 
 
 Sfn^iu in V V ^^' ^"^ ^^^ ^^^^ b;ougf)t an Sctfon of Crefpaffe of an acfanlt ano 
 anAibJit iSatterp agafntt Lord, ano obtein a tietDict. STIje 2?cfenDant mobeo 
 
 and BiH.ry. fn arreft of 3uDgement, SEfjat tfje Declaratfon toas bptbc USaron ano 
 jFemc, fojanatlaultanDBatterpmaDetotljei^cme, ano tfeep alfo De» 
 dare tbat tftc Defcnoant alia enormia tis intulir, tobfcfi otigbt not to be, foj 
 the lD?ong bcfng but a perfonal toiong Done to tljc pcrfon of tl):i?cme onlp, 
 couiD not be falD to be Done to tfte li^usbanD. To which Roll chief luftice 
 sg'ced. 
 
 Fairefax againft Fairfax. 
 
 Mich, 1 tf JO. Bjnc, fup, 
 
 F.rroi ro re- - T/> a iujft Of Crro? b?ouol)t to rctcrfc a ^uDgcmenf gfticn fn a Imit of 
 
 vtiic a jur.g- 1 rnoiDjtl)efc exceptions toere tahen; i. 2f!}at tlje'ojfgfnal teas not 
 
 i.cmindovvr.^^jj retumeo , foj tf)cfr appears not to be anp return of tftc p?ocla- 
 
 matfon of Wjz fummons , ano thougf) tlje partp bo appear, pet ft inas 
 
 faia tljat ft is not IjjlpeD tljcrcbp. 2lp. SC^cDemanDlsfnccrtafn, 
 
 fo;tt)CDcmanDfs,;e tertia parte dccimarum girbarumin Cotton, anD bp 
 
 ti)f9
 
 A/iCh. i^j°- 257 
 
 tbfsuemanD tbe JSfno of tftc Cttljes oemansta is not maoe ccttafit, foj tlje 
 
 iDojD garba aomits of Dftjcts confttnftfcns , aitnfo Lynwood tbc dttitWait 
 
 lbciDS» jlp. 3tf2notcrpic!reDtol)Cti)crtl]c Dcfcnoant be tcrr.Eenant , 
 
 oj ftelt. 4lp. 2Ct)C DemaunD is ac eciam de rcdoria de Acerftall Malvis,to!3ict) 
 
 bfncertafn, fojitougfttto bede reftoria ecckfis. Roll chief luftice to 
 
 t^c I . exception faiOjt^at tljc appearance of tl)c part ptotllljCtiJ mtfcantfmu''^'''^°n*'n"- 
 
 anc0 of proces , am fo (t ootlj Ijerc, Haies to tl]C 2d. crceptloit faiD , tbat '"'"• 
 
 decimxoarbaruni to certain cnotjgb to coniJiKin tttiTscrftatiofng. .. 2Co tt}e 
 
 3d. deception l)c IjelD (t not ncceffatp to fap de reaon:-. ccckfit, fo: (t mutt 
 
 i)c fo neceffarilp intcnocD* Sftc Court uefiren fo fee faooas, ano fo it luaa 
 
 aufonrncfl. :at another cap tij: cafe toas again moTJea , anti ttjefc fpolien 
 
 to ano afifajCtcD, i . 2ls befo?c tfjat deeimT j;arbarum is certain enotia!) ta 
 
 common fntenotnent. 2lp.5:batiti3notnEceffarp to ejpjcffc tfte fetting 
 
 fojtft of tfte ootoj in tbe titbcs bp ntctcs ano bounu?, fo j trtbc0 cannot be fo 
 
 fctfojtl), anoftisnotccnCanttoufctfiecrpjcfsion per metas ec bundas, 
 
 Latchtoohanotbcr crccptiontliatit toasimpjopctlpcrpjctTeo , foj one to 
 
 rntet into an aotoiufon. 3.m to tt)C ejccptton fo jmcrlp taUcn, Ijc Ijelo 
 
 tljat tlje |D joclamatton of fummons oagbt to tjatje been teturneo , ano tftat 
 
 fault Is not IjelpcDbptbc late Set, becaufcit is matter of fubllance, ano 
 
 not meet matter of fo;m , ano t)e faio tljat appearance of t^e partp Dct^ 
 
 faltjeaDircontinuanceofmeanpioccffcs ; but not of ojfgfnall pjocelTc a0 
 
 tljf0fs, tubicb 13 tbe feerp founoatfcn of tbe Sttion, ano tljat ttjouglj tfje 
 
 Ivant of a fummons be ftelpcD bp tl)c partpcs appearance , pet t^e toant of 
 
 returning tftcrnmmono is not ftelpeobpttiepartpco appearance, ijjert Ije 
 
 Ijclo, asfozmerlp, tbatdecircacgarbarumisincertain , anDtfiattlje nature 
 
 oftbecojn ougftttobcfljetoeD. Rollchief3ufticefaiD,t^attbe not retut- ^<:'"f"« 
 
 inng tlje pjoclamation of fummons is not material, foj tbc fummons fs on* 
 
 Ip to maKe tlje partp appear, ano Ijc Ijatlj appeareo in tfjts cafe , ano tlje late 
 
 act eitenos to it if it toere not gooo liit^ont it. 0no tlje ocmano rf tertiam 
 
 partem garbarum is certain enougb bp common f.^tenoment , but it fecms 
 
 jnoje certain ijerc tljanfo, foj it is tertiam partem garbarum grsnorum 
 
 ix}!)ict) fignifies cojn ; ilno it is not ncceffarp to eypjcfs tftc fctting fojtft of 
 
 tlje Doftij per mctas et bundas, but it is toell as it is tDttl}out toat eipjefcien. 
 
 ano laQlp, 3t is tocll cnougb faio, ingrefTu^ elt into tlje aototofon, altbougfj 
 
 it b: not fo proper an cfpjcfsion as migtt }ja'oc been ufcO; fo? it is gooo e- 
 
 nougb to make t^e partp tenant. lerman luftice to tlje fame cffci, an5 
 
 faiD,tljat if t^erc be ttooSCenants in Common, ano ohc of tljem ope.itisa 
 
 great quettiontotDtbeiDifcaiall bz cnootcco, viz. icljctftcrper metas & 
 
 bundas oj no. 0no fte ooubteo toljcttcr tfte Mrit of erro? Ijerc fajoug^t 
 
 toere gooo oj not, foj itisretojnabic coram cuftodibu'; libertatis, &c. apud 
 
 Wcftraonafterium.ltfjereasasitou^^t to be coram cuftodibus ubicunque, 
 
 fojtljeparenot6j;eDto Weftminfter, Nicholas luftice to tl)C fame effect. 
 
 Roll chief luftice faio it inas a gooO e jrccption tljat lerman tooU to tfjc ^lEIrit Error. 
 
 of erro; 15ut tfte Court teas Ijere at Weftminffer at tt!C return of fljc CTrit, 
 
 ano tlje tKJrit teas maoe bp tbc Cuftodes tljcmfclbcs, ano tlje partpcs Dto 
 
 appear upon it, ano tftercfo?e!)cqueftioneDto^et^er it migbt not be maoc 
 
 gooo fo; tbefe reaf ons. lerman luftice IjelD it coulo not. Koll chief luftice 
 
 faio tbat all tlje Jiatin pjefiOents are agreeable to tbia COrit, ano it tnoulo 
 
 be Dangerous to alter tljem; JBut let t^e curCitojs atteno , ano gitie tbeit ^''"'•''""■ 
 
 reafons tobp t^ep do not alter tbis fojm,ano if tbc CGrit be gooo.ine ttinbo 
 
 the Bluogement fljoulo be affirmeo. Yet we will advife a little cf the writ, 
 
 and whether the demand of dcciraara partem garbarum,wiihout granorum, Lc 
 
 goodornot. Poftea» 
 
 ?^lJ3 Lumlcy
 
 238 Michi6 5C> 
 
 Liimley againft Nevil. 
 
 *" Mich, 1650. Banc, fup. 
 
 F-rror in an Ti^ ^ ^jft of crro J bjougljt tipott a31tiOscmctit gibett fn an e/eftione firmar, 
 
 lubcrc ticias l3t tuao frtfo bp Roll chief luftice, SLftat if tfte tojtt of habere facias poffefii* 
 
 pal flionciii. onem DO contcfn moje ^ctcs of llano tban ate ctpjclTcD In t^eSDeclaratton, 
 
 tftat (t ia erroj. 315tit if t^c g>l)crtfFDo gitie poffcfsfon of moje l.anu tiiania 
 
 COntCineD in the iDjit of habere facias pofTeflionem, an jetton of tl)e cafe 
 
 lies againa tijc feljetiff, j an afsife Ipes foj tlje lano. 31t toas alfo fain, 
 
 Etnr. tljatifaSIuiigcmcnt bcaffirmeDupon a tD?it of 0rro;i in ttje (l£)ccl)eqact 
 
 c .fc. Cljambcr, pet tijcp cannot gtant out execution t^erc ; but it muft be in t^is 
 
 AiFiCc. Court, 
 
 txccutio". 
 
 Hunt againft Popham. 
 
 Mich, i(5jo, Banc, fup. 
 
 The coi'rr not j^ jjjgg ntoticB foj ti^c S^efcncant to Iiatic tftc rule of Court fo j tbc piain« 
 toA\uie"'' lt(ff fobbing in tl)epoftea,tl)at tbc SDcfcnoant map motje in arrcft of 
 where it may BJuOgcWCnt, The Court aniwered they would make no rule, for the De- 
 be given in fendant may give rules in the office to force him to it, and it he Will not bring 
 the office. ij in he is to be nonfuit, 
 Nonfuir. 
 
 Fairefax againft Fairefax. 
 
 Mich. 16 o. Banc, fup= ' 
 
 r »d T" l^c Cafe bcttocen Fairefax anu Fairefax inas motctJ again ^ ano Hales 
 nund in'^dnw'r • '^^'^^^ tftattije Ocmano of DolDj de decimis garbarum inasccrtainenougl), 
 gooj or not. t5)0Ugh it bc not garbarum granoruiP,anD hc citcD tljeKegifter 46.andDycr/, 
 84, anDoneCavendiihescafe, 8, lac. Rollchief lufticetooliaDifFcrcncc.be- 
 tlDcen a Dcmano of 2Dithc3,anD the fuing fo j a recompcncc foj 2Citbe0, up« 
 on t^c Statute of 2 Ed. 6. ano citcn tlic Regift. 1 6s • ano Ijc ijclo tbc ocmanD 
 Ijcre to be gooo, Uiitl) u-homconcutreti t'le otl)Ct 3uDges. Ask lufticc faio , 
 tbat a garbisa frcnch luojo , ano'agnifics anp tljingbouno up into a bun- 
 DlC;biit'b>> Cowtil tl)e CtUllian it ftgnifica Cojn bouno up,anD fo ta the tccjD 
 commoiUp ufcD at t!)c Common iLato. Roll chief luftice faio tiiat a dc» 
 Demand. manti in a p'secipe ought tobc mojc Certain , than it is neceffarpfojaue- 
 mailD in Cotea to be. Latch faio that the irojOS coram nobis apud Weft: 
 monaftcrium is part oc the ttilCOfthe Court, tDhfcb Roll chief Inftice Denp- 
 co, pet he faio it toasuicU enough, bccaufe the Court luas there at the re- 
 turn of the itjjit of CErroj, Co Ichich the other Suogcs agreeo , and the 
 rule was that the ludgcraent (hould be affirmed nifi , &c, antea. 
 
 Mich, 1650. Banc, (up, 
 
 'TT !^e Court iyas molJCD thnt one Inas avreftcD upon a Dap of thanfes-gf^ 
 Moved to dif. -"- tingappointcD bp the parliament, ano that he ^mss fo?ccD to put fii 
 -'lean ar fcono tothc S>')crifff 01 h<s appearance, anDthcrefojc it toas pjapeD that 
 
 the partp arreftcD might he DifchargeD, ano that the bono si^en to the She- 
 riff 
 
 ;c 
 
 a
 
 Mich.iSjo. 239 
 
 t{f mfgbt be DcUfecrcD ap» Roll tfte chief luftice anfiDcrcOjEndift tfic Bji* 
 
 lies that made the Arreft,or bring yopr AAionagainft thcmjf you pleafe, for Difchirgc 
 
 we will aoc difcbarge the party arreted. 
 
 Bois againft Cranfield. 
 
 Mich. 1550. Banc«fup^ 
 
 « I ..V . 
 
 rot, Qc 
 
 BOisHisematojto amotljet bjouslit an 0afon of SDcW upon uftet© Debt upon 
 SJbUaatfonsmaOEtoftfsSLCttatoj. SEbc SDcfcncant plcaoeo t^at ^e"^''^"»obii- 
 DtDpapaleffctfumtftantscipjeffcDfn t(>c£)bltgat(ongto tljc 2EEaa- |\''cu!ion *" 
 tojundng^fsltfc, anotbatbCDiontctpttbcrcofmfuU fatfsfattton of t^e 
 tefo £DbUgatfons. SDo tftfs plea t^e |31atntff Dcmtitrco. Roll Chief luftice 
 nponopenfngtbc matte tfati), tbatt^cqucttfon^ere ia, tobetljet tbc pap- 
 nient, o^ tbc acceptance of tlj: moncp pafo in fatfsfactton be to be tratjetfeo. 
 ;anD^ftelDft Inaa <ntfffcrcnt to traberfecUbcrof tbent; bat be fafo ttp^j^^fp 
 Snas mojE pjopec to jopn fffae upon tbe papment , but the Court would ad^ 
 vife. 31 toas then alfo fafo , that if oncpapmonepfnfatfsfaetfonof an 
 ^©bUgatton, anotlicpartptotD^omUtspafo faith that he tofU recetbe ft 
 fo J another caafe , pet If ibc recetbe <t U Qjall be jpogen to be paio In fatfsfa. sitiif^aion. 
 tffonoftheiDbUgatfon; foj^emnftrccefbeittipon fuel) terms as tljcot^ct payment. 
 tofUpapit, 
 
 Brian againft Stone. 
 
 Mich. 1650, Banc, fnp. 
 
 Stone motjes t^e Court (oj an attachment agafnff Brian ano otber0, f 0} ^°^ an At- 
 that he teas arreftcDbp a Latitat out of thfs Court in the Countp of'*'^^'"'"'* 
 Wilts, an3 thence carrf CD fnto the SCoton of MalSorow, ano there arrefteo 
 Ijp a Serjeant of that 'Eotrn bp aiijftout ofthat Cojpojatfon, aao the 
 paintifp^oceeDs there agafnS htm upon that Vii;it, anonot upon the laci* 
 tat, bp ichfch he toac firft arrefteo , intjch f3 a contempt to thfs Court. The 5^" 'a'^'^Cor- 
 Court ruled the party (hould have an Attachment, nifi, &c, and alfo fhouldpus cum cau- 
 have a Habeas Corpus cum caufa, fa. 
 
 • Mich_ 1650, Banc. flip. 
 
 nri^c5RecojDctofLondonmobcDfoj.the Slnhabftanfct of BIfliopsgate a. p^ , . 
 -■' gafnft one withringes ; toho fo: refufing to fcrbc upon the ^aro mote ^^Vi mJjc- 
 CBnqucft uac fnDfcteti fo j hfs refufal fn London,ant) conbfcteo ano fineo aol. ,ate fine upon 
 tbeSDefenoant being commfttenfo; not papfngfeta fine, remobco hfmfelfonethstfub- 
 ifther bp a Habeas Corpus, butnolD hathfubmftteoljfmfelf toafine, ft toas '"""•* '" * 
 tbcrcfoje pjapcD^cmap be moBcratclpfincD{jere» ThcCourt thereupon '''■"^• 
 fined hini ao !• 
 
 Beal
 
 2^0 Mich. i6|)*o. 
 
 Bcal againft VVyman. 
 
 Mich, 1650. Banc, fup. 
 
 TriBt I f49« rot. 849, 
 
 T 7 IpontljCfctoOjMOfa tnfll , viz. I give and bequeath one half of my 
 
 ^"words oil ^ lands to my wife, and after her death I give all my lands to the heirs 
 
 Will' ' " ' males of any of my Sons, or nfxc of Kin. Latch maDequcftfonfntljE Cafe, 
 
 I, Mftctl)ct t^crc iDcrc a gooD eftate creatco bp tlieft toojaa of tlje tofU, 
 
 alp. OTbctftet tlje cftatc tocte ficftropeo bp the fine IcWcD of t^e lanoa. iFoj 
 
 tl)ei,bcl)Elo,tbatthct)E<r0inalc»ofanpofbi0 ^ono, arc U)0?Da ccrtafn 
 
 ettoagl) to create an cftate; fo?(t<0a« oncac ff ^c hao falo to the hefrst 
 
 mated of aUbf«fon0, tf ttiep ^atc ticirs male0 , o} totboreto^otiabcl^cirs 
 
 male© , anu tbe too?D« , or to the next of Kin , arc alfo ccttatn enoajsh, bd 
 
 fiigJopneDteithtljepjeceDenttoojos, an& fljall be meant to t^e ncpt of 
 
 !6<tT, ani)ttjcfThc<r0niale0, if W fon0 Ijatie no \ftixa malts; iFo? fn a 
 
 MKHfft})creb0too?totoc)tp?er0t^ meaning of the ttcftatoj <tf0 fufflcfa 
 
 cnt enough, tljongh t^e itojM be not apt- SnoljetftcDii Rich, 2. Devife 
 
 27. ana g Rep. 46.anD faJQ,that the cafe fn 30 A(T. pi. 47, te the fame U)ftl> 
 
 «)<0intermiB!s. janD here f0 no contingent rcmafnDcr, but onlpacont<n« 
 
 gent Betjffe, ^ tljerc f0 no nttefoftp fo; a partfcolar cttatc to fpppojt it; fo? ft 
 
 arifcth out of Ibc cffate of thc2Dcbifo?; pet if there teere nreo of a particular. 
 
 cCate here to fnppo?t the rcmr.inDcr,hcre is a particular cftate in the tof fe , 
 
 fcho bp implication of the toiU Doth tafec aU the lanb buringbcr life , aa it is 
 
 13H. 7. JpH, 8. Br.Devife48,Trin. 3 Ed, 6. Bendloes, Plow. Com, 52i, 
 
 WhelpdalescafC,Pafch.25 Ba Com. Ban, SEo the 2 point hcfpahenot, 
 
 fcolDina it not material, HaletofCouncclon the other Cdc belo, that the 
 
 tof fc hao not an cftatc {o^ life in all t\)t lano bp implication of the irill , but 
 
 onlp an cttatc fo? life in a mope tp of the lano, ano fo tt^cre is no particular 
 
 eltatc to fuppojt the continacnt remainDrr,U)f.ich he bclD Iras in tbis cafc; f 
 
 that it i0 not a contingent SDebiica© Latch tirgeo; foj the rcmainQcr here 
 
 t)cpcnt)0bplDapofrcmainDcr, anunot as a contingent JDcbife. Slito he 
 
 helothcSDctifeitfclftobctoiD, aDmittingallthepjcceoent matter alle- 
 
 gcDtobetruc. i. iBccaufc the Dcbifc is uncertain; foj the intent of the 
 
 Bcbifcrooth not appear; fo;itappcar0not tohat heir male fhall habc the 
 
 lano , U)hcthcr the heir male of hio fon, j the heir male of lis ntxt of ^in ; 
 
 foj thetDOjcaarc tisjunctibc; 41 &42Eiiz., Com. Banc, in tl:e Cafe of 
 
 Tavlcrf Sawyer lantj DctJifcD toa S^ano Jffue tpas aiijuDgcD a DotD Dctffc 
 
 foithcircertair.fpofit. 3no he hclo that the intent teas that the heir male 
 
 ot his fon (hotilD inherit bcfo:e the heir male of the nej:t of liin, otherteifc 
 
 tlji further off of ii in fcoiilo hate the lanDbcfoje the nearer of iiin, 0no 
 
 l3C(aiO thatHiil. 1' Car. Rot. iiS8. Com. Banr.inHunt anU Fifhers cafc, 
 
 the cafe at the 5Sar tea0 anjucocti in point. Roll chief luflice fain , 2Ehat 
 
 Intention, thc tiitcntion of thc SCcftatoj here is cceca & iicca, anu fencclcfs, am cannot 
 
 be bnoiDn , ano toe ought not to frame a fence upon the tuojtis of a Wifi, 
 
 ^'''' ichcrc toe cannot finD out the SCeaatojo meaning, krman lui^ice helo, 
 
 that the Dcttfc teas not lioio, but that the Ido;D0 arc to be intcrpjetco as 
 
 thfp map ffant) iDith 3lato, atiD aothc toojos tctll bear. Nicholas luftice 
 
 prm:a facie that tiiCDcbifc is toio , but )'ct it is qucCionable. Ask Juftice 
 
 to the fame intent. Roll chief luflice faio, tijat there io too much luap u- 
 
 fiiallp gitJEn to nmbisnons OCtJffCS. But let it be ar^usd again [he next 
 
 Te-rra. 
 
 Parker
 
 Hill. 1650. 241 
 
 Parker againft Cook. 
 
 Mich, i^yo* Banc. fup» 
 
 HilU 23 Car. rot. 66o^ 
 
 "T^^c^ctfonirasan^ctfonofsntefpafs quare Chufum fregit: Cfte SD^niponsDe 
 ^ fenDantplcnDEoafpcdalplca of jtiQfRcatfon , viz. STftat tijc |)lafntff<i,urrertie" 
 3880 a Coppftolccr to \}is Spanoj , ann t!)at fe? rcfiiffng to appear atiD do ftfg qi^ftion was , 
 fett)kcatftf3Courtbcl)aDfo:fcitcDi^ts Coppfjolu, ano t^at t&erefojg |)e «:.''«iic. a 
 tfo enter. SLftcCafcirjaetlifo, SCfjc SDefcnuant bemg 110:0 of t&c ^3-^°''^^°',''. 
 no;, am liolofnc of ftl0 Court , tlje j0laint(f being Ccnant, ano facing in t^c Tr 001*^^'^' 
 Cotirt, ano tbcre being r qacftfon iclbctfter tlje Court irere legallp tften 
 ftclDojno, ano being acbco tcftc oio appear oj not, l^c anftDereo, Jf it 
 be a legal Court, 3! 00 appear, but if it be not a legal Court J do not appear » 
 acbc qucflion teas , iotJettiCr tbisj be an appearance, oj fuel) a refufal to ap» 
 pcartobcrcbptbeCoppbolDcrPjaH fojfctt Im's CoppbolD, t% not. Latch 
 ft:lDittBa0 no appearance, anDt^attfjcrcfojetfje Coppljolo Inas fojfciteo, 
 anDciteD43 Ed. 3. f. 25. ^noljcfaiD, t^ougb ft be not crpjcffcD bp tbc 
 ^efenDant,tl)at tl)c ipiaintif toaei IcgaUp fummoneD to appear in Court , it 
 JO not material , reclngt)eiuacp?ercnt in Court, ano dId refufe, being dc. 
 manDCD, to appear. <anD tPt tbis teas a fufficient contempt to rnahe a 
 fojfetturr. 5inDl;efaiDtftattl)cl^ejopnDSti3ill; foMt is dixit coroparuir, 
 anolbeDotljnotanriDertotljcffiftallcgcD, viz. SCljat t)c ucnfcD to Do bia 
 futc ano fettjlcc. Wild on t^c ot^er Goc faio, tljat it is no forfeiture ; fo; if 
 tbe Court be Inell belD , tl)cn \)t ootl) appear, as i^ia UiojDs do plainlp manf= 
 ft ft, ano fot^ere is no contempt; ano if ttic Court toetc not tocU ^elo, Ijia 
 net appearing ftall not butt bim, fojljcisnotrcquireo to do it 37 Eliz^ 
 Eft anD Hardinges cafe, anD4rep. 27, Hobard anO Harnonds cafe : 3tHJ 
 ijcfiDes,tl){s cannot ie a Ijolnntarp contempt, bccaufc be Dio appear conDi-- 
 tfonallp, anD Dio not abfolut^lp refufe. Slv.^i tbe llcp'icatf on batl; not en= 
 titlEDpou to a forfeiture' Befbcs it appr^rs not l)cr^ tbat tbe Court toas 
 legallpfummoneD, asitcucbt toDo, no; tbat tbcre teas anp pioclamafi* 
 on maoE foj tljc bolDfng of tljc Court, no; anp notice gttien to tbc SDenants 
 OftbcbolDingoftbcConrt, 58,39Eliz. Binc.Reg.CnfpanD Dyer. Roll 
 chief luftice, sctiscafcbattjDcpcnDcDlong. 3Ct is a barD tbing to mahe aFo'f:«"fc. 
 forfeiture of tbcCoppbolD, iftberciBas a real controbcriis Vgetbec tbe 
 Court kas toell belD oj not ; but if not, anD tbat tl)C tuojog tuere ufcD on^ 
 Ip as a ftjift to atjoio tljc patntifs fute ano fcrbfce , ' it is a forfeiture; 
 for t^c iMorDs arc like garli in a JBox , anD no boDp UnotDS trbat to mahc of 
 tbem. lerman, Nicholas; ano Ask enclincDtbat it toas no forfeiture, Ad- 
 journed to the next tern:. 
 
 Fielder againft Tovy. 
 
 Hill, 1650, Banc, fup, 
 
 Pafch. 1 650. rot, 43 o» 
 
 Fielder brougbt an action of Debt npon a bono gtticn to tbc &Hxi( bp To- n 
 vytbe5DefcuDant,to appear to tbcpiaintif in tbc tapper locncl), to aniD^^cKn 
 Miction tljcre brougbt againft tbe JDcfenoant, %[)t SDcfcnDarit appears, ano u ^on a she- 
 ocmuts to tbe iSDeclatatfon, ano ll&ciDs for caufe, ttjat tlje Worn upn tc'ifc^ f ''^ 1^-"''. 
 
 a* tijc
 
 2 42 Hill. 16 fo. 
 
 tljcpaintif Declares, ano tbc JEDrdaration Do'not agree, foj ttit IpiaintJf 
 Dctlareg pro quadrapim. libris, atio tlje £>bl<gat(on mcntfons , t^at ttjc SDe= 
 fenoant is botmo in quadragcnr. libris. SDJtfrflcarcs licrcput to rcfcm- 
 blCtljls, viz. Maffam ailD lollies cafe, iD^ere fexigint Itias put fo? fcxagint, 
 anD yet l)clD ccdd, a:it) Waters cafe, tol^crc fepcuaginr. tnao put foj feptingem, 
 5lnD Downes anU Hufiics cafe , 1 2 Car. B<jno, Reg- lulierc quingint. duabus 
 libistoao iifeDinftcaoofquinquagint. anurctftelOfrooD, bccaufe (t misftt 
 be an abjci'tatton of quinquagmr. lerman lufticcbelDti^c Declaration not 
 pooD, IccaufetljeconoitfonoftbciDbltgatfonlato ooc a collateral t^tng, 
 ann fo <t cannot appear bp ft tftat Vat fam is In itjljkl) tftc partp fa faounti , as 
 it map toljcre \\)t concftfon fs foj tbe papment of inoncp. Roll chief luiiice 
 
 Declaration, ^gio tl}c JEticlaratlon notpooo , becaufe tl)c ISonD upon tol)fc}) ft f3 grounD* 
 eD Dotl) not toarrant f t,anD tfte mcanfng of tije \ro jd cannot ^lerc be Unoiun, 
 anD f f tbe Contftfon loere not collateral ft tooulo not ^elp ft. Nicholas lu- 
 fliceDfffereo, anDfafo,fttooulDbebarDto make ft no £)blfgatfon foj t\iz 
 mff'iiijftfng of a Inojo , ano tljerefojc ft toerc goooto tearcb pjcfiiDents, foj 
 
 4 It as a confiDcrable cafe. Ask Iufticefafo,t&e meaning fa obfcute, aniJtljfa 
 
 maUf 3 tt)C Dffficultp. Adjourned , Poftca, 
 
 Wcntworrh againft Went worth. 
 
 Hill, 1^5 0. Banc, fup» 
 Mich. 1650, rot, jjr, 
 
 \7 T 7 Entworth b jotigt)t sn Sctf on Of Debt agafnCf Wentworth npon an 
 V £*blfgatfon; %])C Connftf on of ft toas Ws in cff cct,2:i)at ittiereaa 
 tlje Defcncant Ijao granteo an annaitp to tbe pafntff, that tfee Defenoant 
 fljo«lD mate ftn tljcr affurancc to tbe |91af ntf f fo j tljc enlopfng thereof iDitft» 
 fn one month, tobenbefboulobcthcrenntorcqafreD: tilpon a fpetial tier» 
 tfct tftc qucCfon inas from toftat tfme tftc montl) flhouln bcnfn, Vrbetbcr from 
 tl)e Date of tfte £)bl(gatfon,o; from t^etfme of tbcrcqueftto be maoe. Ucch 
 ftcltj ft lljoultj begfn from ttic reqaett , ant> not from tbe Date of tbe ^blfga. 
 tion, bccaurcamontbfromtbattfmefatoo fmall a tfme to do tbe tbfng 
 reqnfrcD , but ff ft IbaU be after tbe rcqttcft ft tofll be a pjopojtfonable tfme 
 fttfo;tbeDol«gft. Roll chief luftice, Slftberebc an inDfffereat con&tu* 
 ctfon,\'?b!tb map be taken ttoo tears:, tec Uifll take ft tbat faap inbkb is 
 inotl rcafcnablc to make tbe iDblfgatfon ffano fn fo;ce , ann me (eime ibc 
 toojoe bcre are plafn,namelp, tbat tbe affuranre Iball be mase tefthfn a 
 montb:aftcrrcqutft, mot after tbe tate of tlicJBono. lertnon luOicr totbe 
 fame effect , ano fafo , tbat altboitgb tbe rcqacff fo; funber affurance Irere 
 not ii ftbfn one n:ontb after tbe Date of tbe bono , pet tbe partp map rcqittrc 
 ft after tbe montb fs cnDf D , anD toftbfn a mortb after fucb reqaett tbe a1ti« 
 ranee fs to be maoe , ano tbe £)blfgatf on (ball be f ntenDcD fo; tbe benefit of 
 JbE ilDblfgo;. Nicholas anD Ask luftices to tbe fame effect , fo judgement 
 ruled for the PlaintifjNifi, &c. 
 
 Child 
 
 Ti tcri rctaii
 
 Hill.. 1650, 243 
 
 Child againftGuiat. 
 Hill 16^0. Banc, (up. 
 Hiil. 1549. rot» 1^3* 
 
 Ij^ an iilrtion upon tbc Cafe upon an Anumpfit mace bp tijc jDcftnuant to''|'a'"Q''l'iJj. 
 paptbe|3lamtlffacEttafnrumofmonc{',atacertainDap. tlipona fpe»fhcr*a%jri- 
 ttall terofa,2Ct)c qucttton loas iDl)cti)cr tljcrc incre a tarlaiicc bcttoeen tljCincc between 
 j)?omifc,anD t^c E'eclatatfon, toUct) qiicttton gtctn from tbe Doubt, totiet^-rhe <*"'»""- 
 t^e Dap ofpapmcnt in tbeAffurapficlbaU be tntcnoeo accojoJne to t^e «>lDp"on^"e on 
 ttUe,ojaccojD{ngtotbcn0lD, foj{f<tU)fte<ntEnoeD one trap tfterc ua0„hichitv»i5 
 notariance, fftbcotbcctcaptfjcrc Iras a Variance. Hales l)clo tCjat tl)ercg,rantc(i. 
 toas no batfarcp, ano tboucij tbcte fljoulo be, pet be falo tbc Jplaiutiff ougU 
 tobateB:uDScment;becaure tbe time in tbie cafe is not material, fo; tbe 
 Debt foj tbe papmcnt irbeteof tbe pjomifc toas mace, appears to be Due up« 
 on an SccomptmaoebttiDccn tbc parties, tLijic?) time ispaft, ano groVus 
 not Due upon tbe AfTumpfir, fo^ tbis is no nels p?.omire in ILalo, anD it is all 
 one bcre as if tbc pjomife baD bcf n fet fojtb that be pjomifco to pap , toben 
 l)c tboulD be tbcrcunto rcquireo. 5lnD Uiberras it batb been objccteo , tbat 
 tbe Debt upon tbe ^ccompt appears to be Due bpttto, anD tbat tbe adioti 
 tbercfo;te ousbt to babe been b?ouQbtagain(l tbembotb, anD not ajjaind 
 one of tbem as it ta bere , be anftoereo, tbat tbe 3ttion map be bjougbt a» 
 gainflfbotb, c?anponeofti;cmattbeclcaionof tbcpartp, ano tbc cuftoni 
 of ipcrcbants makes no Difference in tbc cafe, fo j tbe ilato creates tbc Debt 
 anD mabes botb l|?able, tbousb tbc cuQom gibe eledion to fuc one o^ botb 
 oftbem,anDfooncmapberebe f«eD,fojtbeDcbti8 bp tbe cuttom trans - 
 ferrcD upon one, altbougb it be tbc Debt of botb. anDb^rcfaotb tbe capes, 
 viz acco^Dingto tbeolDltile, anDactojDingtotbe nelo tocrc paH befo;c 
 tbc action bjougbt. Roll chief luflice belD, tbat tbc paintiff ougbt to^««- 
 Ijabc 3uDgcmcnt; but tbat bap Iballbctahen acco?DingtotbcclDBile,ifj^^.^jj^,jjj 
 tbcre be not a fpcciall abcrment to tbc contrarp , anD fo tbcrc is bariance 
 bcttocen tbc plcaDing , anD tbe territt ; but tbis cotb not bntt 
 ^erc, fo^ tbc Action Dotb not fail, altbougb tbe Dap be limitcQ 
 upon tbe eWDence, otbertuife tban it fo in tbc ^Declaration, fo^ 
 tbcDcbtis tbcDutparlftng upon tbc accomptmaoc bcttocen tlx parties ,j;^e 
 ano tbe Dap upon tbe AfTumt fic fo; tbc papmcnt is not material, foj tbc 
 Action lies tbougb no AfTumpfitbaD been maoc, an>) b^re is no nccDof'<a-j»ipro- 
 an actual pjomifc ; JBut if an A fTuinpfit be mace upon a tontract , tl^ere is "'••'■ 
 nopjctcDcnt Dntp, ano fo tbcre is a DifiFcrcncc bcttocen one cafe ano tbc 
 otber. 3nD ff ttoo be founo in arrearages of accompt , bp tbc cuftom of cuftom. 
 jpercbantsonemapbecbargCDtopapaUtbcDcbtastoeUasbotK kiman 
 luflicc as Roll, ano raiD,tbat tolcre tbe cap is part of tbe contract , it ougbt 
 tobeallcgeotobepaflattbctimcoftbe Action bjougbt; but it is not fo 
 bcre, ano alfo botb tbc oapes arc bercpatt. Nicholas to tbe fame purpofc. 
 Roll chief luftice, BIf tbe Action be fpcciallp laio, ano ibc Dap maoe part of 
 ft, tbcre f f tbc plaintiff fail in tbc Dap , bis action alfo fails. Ano if one 
 Declare gencfSHp foj roc 1. upon an indebitatus , ano ft appears upon tbe Cs 
 •bioence, tbat tbe SDefenoant DiDotoctbe plaintiff but 10 1, pet tbc plaintif^'^"''*'"""* 
 fijall recober ; 5But if tbc plaintiff Declare fpcciallp, viz. foj a bo;lc folDw'if/ 
 fo J fo mucb , ano bp tbc cbiocncc it appears be otoco a leffe fum , tbcre tbe 
 plaintiff fball not rccoter.fo; it fban be fntcnoeo anotbcr contract, anO 
 not tbat, upon tobicbtbc Action isbjougbt.and foludgeracnt for the Plaimiff 
 
 31 i 2 nifi
 
 244 ^^^^'* i'^5^- 
 
 nin, &c. Mnynard fpahc again tO it ; But ludgemeac was given for the 
 Plaintiff upon the former reafonsf 
 
 Paul VV^illUms and his wife againft the Cuflodes. 
 
 Hill l<)50, Banc, fup. 
 
 Error 
 
 vc 
 
 PAwl W illiams ant W iDf fc fjno a 3CtiBffcmcnf gfljcii ngafntt tljcm at t'oc 
 ^ff'^*""'^ ^^ Hickes Hall, upon an enDicttncnt fojfpeabingtoojDflagafntt 
 i.i'cnt at thc^ t\)e 3L0JD Fairefax,lDftetcupon tl)ep bjotigfjt a WLtit of Crro;i <n t^fs Court 
 Scriinns for to Tctjcrfc t^c Sluugcment. El)c Cvccpttons taUen toere t^efe, i. SDbat tbc^ 
 fpc.kii.g jiiojccis t!)crc bao not peUjcr to Ijolu pica fora^ojoa fpofecn. %o tbts tbc 
 '^ • Court i-nHucrcD t!)at tftep ftaDcpotocrto l)olD plea foj futb too?D3, becaufe 
 
 tftep tcno to bjeacb of tbc peace , ano tbc fpcaUfng of tl^ent to a great m(fDc« 
 ntenour. SEtjCrcconDCrcCpttontDas.t^ntltia MQ juratores jurati elefti 
 triatiad veritatcmdicuni,5rad4ic€ndumf0lcftout. jlp. 2Cl)ere iffucO out 
 a capias pro fine agafnft tbe parttea , toftcrcss tljerc loao no fine fet upon 
 ti)cm.2EljeCourt to tftat anfircrco tlwt a fine toaa fet. Wild tooU another c);. 
 ccption, viz. tftat t^e cnofctmcnt ougljt not to be jopnt agafnft tluo, fo;. 
 Kndiftmem, loojDsfpobcn bptbem bot^; but fctjeraUcnDf amenta, foj tlje too?Da of 
 one are notjtbe tooxos of tbe otl)cr, tbougb tbep be tlje fame Inojoa j HBuc 
 Cafe. tlje Court anf iBcreD, ttjat a jopnt enufctmcnt icaa gooD enough, alt^ougft a 
 
 jopnt i^ctton of tlje Cafe cannot be b?ougbt againft tioo , fo; Idojdb 
 fpohenbp tljem botft. !^e tooa alfotl)f6(]I;rccption,tt>atitDOt!)not appear 
 tbattbc parties tocretrpeD in tljc Court, fo; it is onlpfaio tftat tbep Incre 
 dudi ad barram.ano t^cn tbat tfjep locrc remoUeo from Hickes Hall to New* 
 gate. SCfte Court anftoereo, that tfte \rojD0 dudi ad barrem tDcre fuffici- 
 cnt , antt it is nceolcfs to fap tijcp tocre trpcD in Court. 0nD tbercfoje tftc 
 ijubole matter refts upon tbe I. ©rceptionjtEbetljcttbc leant of tlje loojoa 
 ad dicendum be CBrroj , anD fo; tljat let ttjc ClarU of tbc peace be bcrc on 
 VVednefdayncvt,ant)tt)enfpeahagaintott,ant)tbcnbp tljc toijole Court 
 tUeCfteptiou toas aDJuogcD gooD..\nd the Clark of the peace wai fined 40 1, 
 
 Mafterman againft Rufholme. 
 
 Hill. l^jo. Banc, fup, 
 
 Pafc, 1650, rot»59^. 
 
 El re r to re - ^,.,-f (,f (j^jroi toas bjougfjt to rdjcrfc a 3IuBgemcnt gitjcn in an 51- 
 
 niVm m "aT' I\ ttfon upott t!)C Cafc upon an Affampfir, to pap cparincra toagcs , tl)e 
 
 Ait....) upon erteptions tafeen toere firft, that the plaint uas foj 10 1, ano tijc SDeclara- 
 
 an Aiitinpfir. |^j,„ {g to the uamagcfl of 20 1, ano fo there is tiariancc bctlucen the plaint , 
 
 ano the SDeclaration. il^cpt the p^omife is laio to be mane the u of May, 
 
 7641 tofertcthetDcfcnoantfojapcar, snu he faith that he fertco him 
 
 from the i. ofMay fojapear.tebcrcaij the i. of May ought to be crcluDCD, 
 
 fo that he ouabt to fap that be ferbeo foj a pcar,from the making of the p?o. 
 
 Va.ia cc mtfc Rollchicf luftice fRiD,that thcrc is tariance bcttueenlhe plsiutvana 
 
 ' the 2)ccl?sration ; butiti0hclpcDbpthcteriJid:,fojtl;at finos that he hath 
 
 fertea a uhoie pear. 515ut ttoo other crceptiono ioErc taljcn at the 31Bar. 
 
 1. 2Dhatthc JDctlaratton iuas pro falore infteeo of Salario. ^ntt alp. 3t is 
 
 fa(j) dcfcrviret fo j defervivit. And upon thefc the Court ordered the Defcn< 
 
 '^'''' dant in the Writ of error to ihtw caufe why the ludgement fhould not be 
 
 reverfed. ,,.„ 
 
 Hill
 
 Hill. i6 50. * 24 ^ 
 
 Hill. 1650. Banc. fup. 
 
 r A iI5 Action upon tfee Cafe isas bjoug^t in London fo} callins a tooman For a Proce- 
 X\\D\}o%t,t)is Defendant reniotjco tbc caafe fnto tli<s ConrJ, toftercupon ^""'° '"'° 
 t&cplatnttffmotJCDfoj a procedendo to trp ft fn London , tuljerc tt»e attf. °"^°"* 
 on teas firft baougbt. l^oll chief Juftice IjclD, t^at a procedendo teas to be 
 grantcD, fo J toe cannot DEtcrmf lie t^jeCuftom; buttfaguogcment begf. 
 ■faenfn London, If tt be crtoneoua, a tojft ofCrtojmapbebjougbtfntfte 
 Huftings to trp tl)? tudom, tftcrcfOje tabe a procedendo nifi caufa oftcnfa fn- 
 erit in contrarium. Aatea* 
 
 Davis agamfl Ockham, • 
 
 Hill, itfjo* Banc, fup» ' \/ 
 
 Micbt i65o,rot,y57, . 
 
 DAvit b?ongbt an aiflfon upon tbc Cafe agafnff Ockhara foj fpcakfng Dtm„rrcj. ^^ 
 tftcfCliOJDBofbfmi; The knive the Apothecary that rcarried ray fifter a pica in an 
 hath poyfoncdmy Vnde, and I will have him taken upagain to hang him. Aftion for 
 %iiz Dcfenoant plcaueo an atco?o bcttofjt Wm, ano tbe pafnttff, tbat '^"^ ''^''^'• 
 mbercag tl)c pamtiff baa cone a aCrefpafo pgafnff fjfm, tfjat one SCrcfpafa 
 ftoalD be fet agatnft tbc otbcr. SEo tbts plea tbe platntiff ocmutrcD , 
 anoTwifdenfaiotbe plea teas not gooD, ano cftco i^ Ed^^.f-'Sp. antt 
 pjapcD BluDgcmcnt foj tbe ^^lafntfff. Latch of Cour.ccU toi'tb tbc SDcfcn- 
 cant fafo tbat tbc 0cco>ii Voaa cpccutcD on tbc SDcfencanta part, ano tijerc- 
 foje map be pleaueo fn JBar. 2Co ib^a Roll chief luftice anItocreD,botoB'r. 
 tabe pou offcljargeD ttje 0cco;t) ^ foj pou Do not fteto ft. Latch toob ep. 
 ccptions to tijc piafnttffa jaDeclaratfon. r.- ?Ebat tU ItojDs fet fo?t!) arc 
 not actionable, fojituotljnoterpjcffl that tbc plaintiff uittinglp popfo. 
 neotbcSDefcnDanta tmnclc, ojthatbccio cpc of tbc popfon, anD citca 
 Hob, rep. 8. Miles and lacobs cafe. anD 275. Fleetwood and Cavcleys cafe. 
 2lp, snijerc i0 no NiommnnicatfonrrpjctfcD in tbe JDedatation to be of 
 tbctiancle, ano it map be fpokcn of another mntlc, anotbe innuendo toil! 
 notbelpit( bEcanfebemapbabcoibcrs^ancleo,, Twifdcn anfl»crcD,tbat 
 It is implpctJ in tbc fence of the toojD0,tl)at lit porfonco \}im fcloniouap,ano 
 fo confcqiicnllp tolttinglp. ilnozlp. l^efaitbthatbc toiU t)a\?cbim cfg. 
 geuup, anDfoitmtiftbcintcnucD tbatbe^pcoof tbe popfon. Roll chief 
 luftice belu tbat tbc too jos arc attionablc. Sinn ilp. SCfjat tbe a)cfenDantg ^f'' 
 plea in 115ar,i3 not gooft, Icrman luftice bclo the plea in J5ar not gooO; but ""^" 
 6e DoubtcD tobetbet tbe SDedaratton teas gooD , foj it Dotb not appear 
 tbctebp,tobctbcttbcpartpDpcDof tbe popfon, anbtbe latter too acabclp 
 it not. Nicholas Juftice, anD Ask luftice agrecD toitb tbe Roll in all , an© 
 tb^tcupon the rule was Indicium Dtfi, Lundi Suivanr. 
 
 Guftodes^ &c againft A/aine and Set jeant. 
 
 HilU x65o» Bancfup, 
 
 Arrctt of 
 
 3!opnt CEnfo jmation teas crb^btf co againtt Main $ Serjeant 2 Jufticcs J),'^JJ,""f^"P* 
 of j|peace,fo J not enquiring of a1R.pot,ano a tcrDict founD agntna them, l"^^,la found, 
 
 31t3» S^^e 
 
 A
 
 Execution 
 
 246 Hill. 1650 
 
 %\itWcimdnlsmo^t in artea^of 31uDgcmcnt7anu bp Hales Ibcto foj 
 tatifctl)attf)Efiifo;mattonongl)tnotto&!ibcb(in (opnt agalnft tl)cm, but 
 febcral, bccaufe t^ctr offences are fctjcralano not jopnt . anoljetc one of 
 t&cm (0 acqattteo , ano fo luogcment cannot be gtben agatnft t^c otftcr ttjat 
 f0 fontit gidltp. Roll chief luflice anftoetcD , SCtjat as an attachment 
 In a pjo^ibttton to fctjetal , fo tlje ercctition bete map be feberal , ano ft Is 
 not matcrinl tbougb one b: acqaftteo , ano tbc otbct fount) gulltp. Icrman, 
 Nicholas, ano Ask luftices to tlje fame purpofe. Jt tnaa tbcn fato, tbat ft fs 
 not nccctrarptbattbencjtSiuafcegoiUpaioulo remote a fo^ce, but all t^c 
 Force ^uftfcco Of tbcCouiitp are bounD to ft : ilno t^efe tDOjos fn tbc statute, 
 
 viz. SCftat tbc 2 ncrt Juttfccs QjaU do it , are put but foj content encp , ano 
 tbe moje fpceop cicecutfon of Sluttfce, Nichola* luftice Doubteo oJ tl)(3. 
 Judicium nif], pro cuflodibus. 
 
 Ailctagainft Watlefs. 
 
 Hill, 1650, Banc, fup, 
 
 Trin 1549, rot. 200, 
 
 Special vcr-T^^" ^'*'''" ^^ Crcfpafs ant) CBjectment, tijcre tnas a fjjccfal bcwfit 
 diainTrcf- ItounD, upott liiblcb tb- csfe fcll out to be ttifs. ^n infant bargafns ano 
 pals and E. fellfl lano , ant) fs toucbcD to toarrantp , ano comes fn upon tbc ^oucber , 
 jcftmcnt. ano tbereupon a common recoterp fs ban , ano upon tbfs tbe qucttf on toa0, 
 iDbetbcr tbf 3 fcc fucb arccoterp, tbat tbe IC'nfant cannot atofo bp Cntrp, 
 Hales belt) ft coulD not be atofoeo , but d(q bfno tbc infant During Ijfs W.i , 
 but 31 coulD not beat bfs tcafons. Wild of Conned on tbc otber Coc argueo, 
 tbat tbe 3!nfant toas not bounu bp tbc recoterp , becaufe as an infant can- 
 not alien bfa lanDs , fo neftber can be fnffet a common tccoterp , anD cftco 
 6 rep, 28. 2lp. ^0 rccojD maoe bp an 3nfantcan bfnD l;fm , ano foj tbfs 
 ftccfteD26Ed.3.Fitz. perqueferv. 24. 4^ E. j.f, 3, 44 E. j.' 10. 9 Ed, 4» 
 38. anDtbougbftbebreveAraicabilc, anD bp confcnt , pctftbfnDsnot,anO 
 pCar. Newporcicarc, tobcrearccoterpfuffcrcD bp a CDuarofan toas ao. 
 juDgeogooD, comes not to our cafe; anofojtbcfntcnDCDtaluefn a rcco« 
 terp, tbatfsnotmaterfaltomaheft bfrtDfng; foj ft fs but a fittfon, ano 
 not a real lvalue, RoIlchieflufUceDcmanDeotibctbcrafinc be not breve 
 P5^^ amicabiie; anD pet befaftttbat tl)at binosan infant until ft be atofocD bp 
 
 E^ror, li)jftof€rroj. anD be fata tbat tbc 3nfantf3 not bounDbere, buttbcquc« 
 
 Kccovtry. ftion fs tobstljcr l)c can abofo tbe recoterp bp CEntrp , oj muft h^ing. a tojit 
 of Crroj to aboia it. ano be belD tbat a rccotcrp fuffcreo bp a ©uarnian fs 
 not gooD , nottcftbOanDfrig tbe opinion fn N^wports cafe. Hales replpco , 
 tbat'tbc recotcrp bcrc f 3 binoing till it be atof oeD bp a to jft of Crroj , ano 
 tbat tbe infant cannot atofD It bp bis ©ntrp, tbougb an infant map abofa 
 aoeeDbpCntrp, altbougbittecnrollED. ano bere appears no confent 
 of tbc parties, ano tbe partp cannot ftciD ft, anD bcrc fs a fojmal juogc- 
 tnent giben , Inbfcb binos till ft be retctfeD bp a txjjtt of dUrroj, Roll chief 
 Eri-.iy. Inltice*!, Sin Jnfant map abofo a matter in paiis by Cntrp , but not a mat« 
 ter of IRccojD , anD bcre fs a p:opcr toap bp tbc lato to atofD ft . namclp bp 
 atojitofCErroj, tDbfcbfsalfo matter of recojD, ano of as bfgb a nature, 
 lerman, Nicholas, anO Ask JuQ JCCS tO tbC famc CffCCt, and fo judgeraent pro 
 Defendente, nifi. 
 
 Powell
 
 ""Hill. 1550. 2 47 
 
 Powell agnnft Hopkins. 
 
 HilU i(J50,Banc»rup. 
 Hill, 23 Car. rot* 787. 
 
 Imogcmeiit teas itftien f n an action of Croijct mr> Conljcrtlon foi tljegrro^j^fe. 
 |3latr.ttf: SCtjcSDefenuambjougfttaluitt of Ccrro;, anut^e Crcfption.ctfca judge- 
 tafeenlvastotbcj&cclaratfon, to^ercftt .t^c piafntfv amons otljec njngsmimiivcnin 
 DCClaveDof a 2Lrot)er de ducentis ponderibus a;ri5,& duccntis ponderibn$*^'^°^'^J^'"** 
 plumb ijAnglice of JBjafsantJ iLcau.ano tljcrc toantsan Anglice fo? tU pom'-""^'' '°"' 
 del ibus , fo It is unccttcifnjtoftat tbc quamitp of ciWat arc. Hno upon t^{8 
 ©ICCcpUon the rule war, that the ludgement fhould be reverfed, nifi, „> c, 
 
 Denton againft Caket. 
 
 Hill. 1650. BaaCtiTup, 
 Trin» i6jo. rot. 150; 
 
 DEntonbjounljf an^ctfon upon tljc Cafe agafntt Cakcc foj fpeaWng Demurrer m 
 tlj.TelBOjDo, He and his fellows have ftollen her (bating fpcccKl Of a'^'^^a,^" 
 ColD Of tfte SOcfcnOantS ) and I do charge him with flac felony ; J5p tcafOrt ^f *" ihc'cafc 
 
 Of tol)fc^ toojos ^c toas taken ano Impjlfoneu, SCtic SDcfcnoant plcaoeo anfgr words. 
 atoatO maoc ( bp &ir John Rivers , auD &ft Nicholas Miller t*xo juttfces Of 
 ipcacc ) betirf en tljc parties In 315at. Twifden of Conned iuftft tlje pialntif 
 falD , tftat t^atoarDDotljnot btno tfce pialntif , foj tl&c aUjarn concerns 
 onlp tl)CfpeaU{tigoftl)cU)ojO0, anDfpcabiS notljfng of tbc Impjlfoincnt: 
 ^nt) 2lp. tbe 5iU)arD is not gooo , fo; tlicrc is not fattsfaulon maoe bp It on 
 lotl) parties. WildofConncelU)ltl)tlje2[)cfenBant bdu, tljat tl>; i):cla» 
 ration ^nas not gooo, anotbattljcrcfojcbcnccoanot to luttlfie t&c plea; 
 fo; tljoupb it ftjoulD be III, pet tlje palntlfcanljate notut)ccinent,anol;c 
 falD tbe SDeclaratlon toas naugljt, faecaufc It allcgeo no Dap to^en, no; place 1 
 
 lT)l)Erc tl)c Dcfcnoant cl^argeD t^e JBlalntlf toltb tl)e fclonp , ano maoc fjint v 
 
 to bclmpjIfoncD. Twifden ansiuerctJtbat tbcre is a place allcgcD , ano 
 tbat tboual) tbcrc toerc none , petit I0 tocH cnouglj fpj part, anu inogc- 
 tncntmapbcglbcnfojtbat. SCotoblcl) Roll chief lufliceagraa. Wild re* 
 plpeo, tbentbc plea Is gooo. IBat tljc Court anstocreu, It is not, anD 
 irbatfap pouto the 0tbttrenient ■' Wild anfirstrcD, It teas gooo, to vibfcb 
 krman ano Ask luftices affei;teD, Roll chief luftice ansiuercD , 3lt lij a be- 
 nefit to tljcparffi); anofo to t!5e£)terrcers of tf)c poo j. Nicholas luftice ' 
 totljc fauic purpofc. Roll chic' luftice falD, t'^at tijc SDeclaratlon lalll.ano 
 tbe pisa alfo , fo; t\)& pica Is enttrc , ano pet goc« i;ot to all tftc mattetaU D'c'^iuon. 
 Icgcafnttjc SDeclaratlon, buttle plea Is onlp to part of tftem, ano tbete- 
 foje If anp part of tbc SDeclaratlon be gooo, jaDgemcnt ougljt to be gftoi 
 againft the SDifcnoantfojtbat part, ant) tljc plea In ISar Is naaolif, fo 
 judgement oughc to be entirely tor the Plaintiff But it is to be confidcrcd con: 
 cerning the damages. ^ 
 
 Ro*
 
 248 Hill. 1650, 
 
 Rofyeragainft Langdale. 
 
 Hill, 1^50, Banc. fup» 
 Pafch, i(550»rot. loOf 
 
 Error to re- TJ Ofycr an Cfccutoj bjougljt 80 ^ctfoit upotitbcCarc upon an AfTumpc 
 
 vcifcajudge. 1\ fu agafnft Langdale a 5Fcme ;aDmtnfftrattf): , ano Declared that tljc 
 
 mrm in an jEjcfcnDant , til conltoetatton tljat \)c inoulo fojOcat futc tmttl fljc ban ta* 
 
 /^'''"'"i''"" J'-j;enoiitlLcttcrflOiaDmtnfftrat<on , Dio affunte ann pjomlfc to pap unto 
 
 aeair?ft^jnTd'b«mttje|Dlafnttf accttatnfum ofmoncpotofnguntobtmbp tlic ^ntcftate. 
 
 niinift:airix. xapon Jffiic iopnsD , anD 8 tulcrDftt anD a Siuogcipcnt foj tbe piafntff, s:t)B 
 
 JPctcnoant bjoucbt a tojlt of (Erroj to rcbcrfc tbe 3»ugcment. Sim Balcf- 
 
 win of bis CountcltooU tbcfc Cicccptfons. i. SCftat tbc ^niafntif baD fct 
 
 fojtbnoconfiocrfltfoninWsSDctlaratfonfojtbc Affumpfic; fo; all tbat ta 
 
 allcgcDts, tbat tbc platntiffboulDfojbear futc till tlic SDcfcnSant baiJtai 
 
 KcnontlLcttcrsofjSIDmhiiftratfon, lubfcblano confiueratlon at all , foj 
 
 tbcS>efenDant\t'a0notlpablctobefucD na ^omfntflratrfic , until ftc ban 
 
 taken out ^Letters of jaomfnlftratt'on , erccpt tbtte lucre a caufc ucpcnclng, 
 
 asbercfenot. BnDb-citcD Hob. rep. Bid well anD Cottons cafe, Xbat it 
 
 tbcTCbcafutccommcnccB, tbougbtljerc benocaufc foj <t,pct fo:bcat- 
 
 Affuropfir. *>«' c t° ft"^ <s a gooB caufe to grounD an AfTumpfit upon, Si fccono CDrccp. 
 
 tfonliastbat tbe Venire facias is not atoavDCD per Curiam, ncc in Curia,. 
 
 Roll chief luflice bclDtbEi, a gooD Crccptfon, foj tbe HDcfcnnant toaa 
 not cbargcablc befojc 5Lettcr0of ^omfmCratfon taken fojtb, ff fljc so not 
 IntermcDlc tottb tbc goous of tbc gntcff ate, anc ft ootb not appear licrc tbat 
 flje BfD , ncltbi^r 13 tbc JDcfcnoant compellable to tal^e fojtb i. e ttcra of 0d» 
 mfnlftratfon , fojtbepniapbegranteototbcnertoffetn if tbe JJDjuinarp 
 plrafetb, aero jtfng as tbe statute ojBafno, lernian, Nicholas, anu Ask 
 luftices to tbc fame intct:t,tbcreupon tbc rule teas revenetur, nifi,dc.3!5iit bc- 
 caufcDjy being ofCounccl on tbc otbcrfiDC tooh fomc ©jccptlons to tbc 
 in?U of dErto J ano tbe rctojn tbc«of, It was adjourned, 
 
 tytaples. 
 Hill, i<550, Banc, fup. 
 
 For a Supcr- 
 frdcas to a 
 Sciic facias. 
 
 Tl^c Court iiias mo^jcn to fupcrfcDe a fcire facias bjougbt bp a pjifonct 
 of tbe f^ar'ilialfea , upon tiic late Sia fo; Bifcbarging of poo j pjtfoncra, 
 bccaufe tbc Certificate of tbc caufc foj lubteb b? toas a pjifonct teas falfc , 
 anDfotbcpjocecDtnagcrronious, fojtbc partptoaatn eKCcntfon foj ITrcf* 
 pafs , tebicb is not Voitbin tbc fetatute matjc fo j tbe pjifoncrs. alp. JBe- 
 caufc tbete Itas no Due notice giten to tbe partp , at tobofe futc be lap in £>;= 
 ccution, 30 tbc Statute uotb Direct tbcrc fboulD. The Court ordered to 
 F Vrig. 1 view the Certificate , and to iile it , otlierwife there fhould be no proceedings 
 Dcmuiicr. upon the fcirc facias, and direfted the party to demur upon the fcfrCfaciaST, 
 if ic be not£Ood , bccaufe the matter alleged cannot be pleaded to ic» 
 
 Cuflodcs,
 
 Hill, 1650. 249 
 
 Cuftodes againft Arskot; 
 
 Hill, 1650, Banc. fup. 
 
 ^^ Aynard molielj tbc Coatt fo j one Arskot tljat inas outlaiDcn fo j muD For thne to 
 i il)£r, am Ibau Icatie to b?in!3 liie to?ft of <£tro j , tljat fje map fjatc loir-- "'" '''•p ' Writ 
 get time to b?{ng ft , bccnttfc t!)C lifng nfcs to (ign t!)c injft , ano tljc parlt= "^ ^'■'■°''- 
 ameiitl;aDnotojDcrcDlol)ofi)aUDo<t noto , ano tijcrcfojc tl;c iltttcjncp 
 dDencral mutt aoWfctoU^tftcparUament about ft, luljfcb cannot fpccoUp 
 fee Done, Thereupon time was granced till the Attorney couid conveniently 
 doitt 
 
 Newcomin againft Leigh. 
 
 HilU 1550, Banc, fup. 
 Pafch, id'o.rot. 5J, 
 
 LEightifoaffun!canDpiomffcantoNewcomin,t!)r.t if ISlewccroin toouiti v.'hether a 
 taUconeLocfojljii5 2Dcbto3,fntl)c room of one Cooper, sno ttouiD 6^°'^ ^''"'"P- 
 fpare Loc untU fucft a ttmc/o; t^e monpp , t^at tfjen be IdouId pap tbc mo- '''• 
 nep to Newcomin, If 1)6 DfD not,anD upon tbts AfTumpfic Newcoroin bjottgW 
 {)t0 jattfon agafntt Leigh. STbc quettton tons tobctbcr tbta toerc a gooOAf. 
 furapfic. janotbc Court l^elolttoaonot, bccaufctt <s a collateral tbfng, 
 anD t)C cotft not fap tbat l^c tofll Difcbarge Cooper , ano fo Newcomin map 
 fue Cooper nottDltbttanctngtbeAffurapfit; JFojlbougbft map be ft teas 
 tbe fntcntfon of tbe partf eo to offcfjarge Cooper, pet ft appears not fo bp tbc 
 iDOjogoftbeAffumpfitfetfo^tb: 3no ft teas tbenfafobp Roll, SEbat ff31 
 
 p:omffctopaptoIohnaDownaH?ebttoljfcb lohnaSciie otoctbto lohn aNuHumpa- 
 Down; tb(0fs nudum pasSum, a^n, '^ " 
 
 Bawiy anclLov\clalL 
 
 Hill. 1650, Banc, fup, 
 
 Pafch, 1 650. rot, 27 j, 
 
 \7 pon a fpecfal betbfrt fn an SJdfon of SDrcfpaffc sm C-jcctmcnt , tbe cafe sptci.! Vcr- 
 ^ fn Effect ioas tbfs. SmanlcffeDof Coppbolo lanos in fa, Dci)ffable=''-'^"P"" ^^^ 
 bpCufiom.DcbfrctbtbcmfntUo manner, I give and bequeath my lands, ^''''Ylj. 
 &c. to my Ion IRfcbarD, during his natural life, and after to the heir of his bo- ul^ "^ '" 
 dy forever. Halesof Counccl iDftl) the |Dlafntif maoetbcfcqueQfono, i. 
 tobetber bp tl;e ixjo?Dg of tbc OTill a iFce-Omplc at tbc Common liato paf.- 
 fctb bccaufc tbere fs an cttatc to Richard foj Iffc, ano after to bfg beft 
 fn tbc Cngular number. anDbcarguentbattbclDOjo bcir fncluoec bcfrsj, 
 bccaufc ft fo Nomen Collcdivum ; ^txt , CSbctber tbc DclnQng tbc 
 lane to Richard foj bfs natural Iffe , ano after to hfs bcfr foj ctcr, 
 maftcs anp offference fn tbc Cafe, ano be bcla ft ofa not, ano faio, 
 tbat Archers cafe tbat fs obtcctcD bp tbc otbcr Ooc Differs miico fro:ii 
 tljfa , foj tbcrc tbe toojos arc rcttrafneo ; foj ft fs Proximo Ha:- 
 redi, ano not Haeredi generallp , as ft fs fn our Cafc; anO tbcrc 
 tbe ttojos neictbeitarcnottoojosofUmftatfon, but of pnrcbafc, ano to 
 
 &!v og.
 
 250 Hill. 1650, 
 
 occfpljct tl)c pcrfon , bat not to Kmft tljc cttatc ; ann fit out cafe if 
 tftcrc ajoiilp not b: a UmUatfcn, Richard fijoulD onlp taUc 
 foj life, tD^tci] ia not tbe intent of tljc Cinai, as map appear bp tljc paflagco, 
 anoclaiirc0oftt. 0no Thomas anoKemiftiet cafe, fnj Car. fntfttg Court 
 inahcs an cno of our Cafe. S^tiWjcx: Dotl) tbc aDBing of tijc U)o jo in perpe* 
 tuummaUcatifffcrrncc<titl)cCafc,fo;tftljetoo?Dol)aDbn?n omfttco, t!)c 
 feme cftnt: b^3 piffco to tbc SLcnaut, Richard ano })\o Cftatc fs not ctilai'= 
 0CD bp tbcin. ali'.SChctDojDOinperpnuum relate to all t!)c Cftate, ant> 
 rot to nnj' partUiilar €ftate, anD fo t^c furrcnocr maoc bp R Hunt iz gmo. 
 ^rvt of all,fuppcff:iictl)nt it be a Umitco Ctftatc, ano a contingent rrmafm 
 Dcr, tijc qtr:(tlon tnfll tbcn bctoljctl'crtl;l3contfn!jentrcmalnDctbc oe- 
 Droj'co 0? no , anD 3 conccf tc It ts,becaufc t!)c particular Coppljolo cftate, 
 h)l)icl) mnft fuppojt tl;<a contingent rcmafnocr lo DcQropcD, ano tlje lialu la 
 the fame In that point in Coppbolo cafes, as It is in ot!)cr cafes at tt)c Com= 
 mon tab), fo j <Ioppl)oltiij arc circacD bp tf)C rulcg of t!)e Common llalu , 
 13 lac.Banc.Reg. 3ti0airobelD,tftattbcrei3tl)cfame rule to fuppojt a 
 contingent rcmalnncr of a Coppboloa's tberc is of iLann at tbc Common 
 Hato. i^cict it is to be conSocreo luftctbcr tljc particular Coppf)olD cftatc , 
 be ertlnguiftjeo 0; not. ^nn it is clar tbat it Is , fo^ tlje cuftomarp Cftatc 
 Is in tl)cl.o;Qliil)ol)at^tl}ci^ctfimplr,tDWcl) cannot botl) ftano together, 
 flnD fo tljcrc is no cftate to fuppoat tU contingent rcmainocr CoppljolD, am 
 confequcntlp all objections arc bptblsanflDctco, i, 2Ct)at tbc furrcnccc 
 ftiallnotoolojong. air. ECbattbefurrcnDcrocftropsnot the Ctiftom.' 
 Turner on tljeotlierfiDcargncD, that onlp an cftatc paffctb ^o Rxhard foj 
 life , ano tbat tbe \t)o?o l^etr Is not a too jo of limitation, to maljc tf)C !Xn* 
 ccfto: take ajf re GmplP, neither fhail tl)c toojo il)clrbc taUcn Coledive 
 Ijcrc but (Ingularicer, ano fo accoioing to tbc common fence, number , ano 
 matter onpht it to be conOrucr.^nD Nowns Colle Ai vc m tlje ftngular nnms 
 bertionotfignifiethcfamc tbins) that thep do in the pUirall number, as 
 map be pjotjeD bp other cramplcs , auD there is no pjopcr name to Ggnlfie 
 one'partlcular !^cir in llato, if the toojD l^cir in the finnular number fljall 
 ItotDoitjShellyescaff, I. Rep. f. 10:. & ooks nliirut. f. 8, i. Rep, Ar* 
 cherscafe. ^no there arc ttoo Jutigcmcnts in the Common pleas In the 
 t?erp point, as K am infoimr o bp the Sttojncp en « our Roe. 3!n a 03111 
 the iiio;D'i5cliIl)all not be taUcuColieaive.biit in the natjral grammati- 
 cnllfence, anonot asa too:Dofait; butitls othcrtelfc taken perchance 
 in cont:!CPancE0,lBh'ch arc tnaoe bp mtn of ^rt, ano IcarncD in the Jlatos, 
 iiihcrcas Inllls arc maoc common'.^ b? lay gents,nnD uitshllfuU in the ILa'o); 
 anD the rnlc la, \W toojDs GjaB be interp:ctcD to malic all the parts of a 
 DrcD in tohifh tbcp are to ftano togcti^cr , anD to bear fence ano to be in tflV, 
 nno cffcctiiai,lihtch cannot be here If the U03D bdr fl)all be talscnCoIleftivc; 
 but map be ff It be taUcn linculariter.Hob.rep.Srukely and Butlers cafc. j]5crt 
 lithctoojDbeirftjoulDbetalicnCol'.eaive, then the (Bftate fo; lifctooula 
 ntcrgc,:?oEl.C.B.Hill.3 lac.CB.HillerandLewis his cafc.5lp.Rich. bath on» 
 Ip an Cftatc fo^ llfc,if it tocre other tolfcthcSCcftatoj toonlo hate othi'rtoifc 
 crp jcffcD it ano he hath inell crpicCfcD an cftate foj life, ano no other Cftatc 
 In bim, 3[f one grant 4. part<5 of his mannoj, it fiiall paffc 4. parts oft. ano 
 not an. i^oi the other popnt the contingent rcmalnoer ig not here Dcftrop- • 
 CD bp the DcftructionoftheCoppholD Cftate, foj Coppho'.o Cftatc-^ Do not 
 aepenB one npon another, as CSatco of ttjc Common ILato Do, anD here is 
 one in effe to talje the Cftatc. another cjucftion he fpoUc to. viz. tjjhethcr 
 a llEffccat luill bef.tg o'.jftcD bp a ffranger can reenter . ano he helD he can- 
 not, foi he hath but ameer right, 38 H.6J. 27-Forrpfcueand Yelvercon, 3. 
 lac.Hanc. Req. rot. 501. C;\rpenrer and Collins. But to tftis Roll chief 
 
 V nrrv luftice, ano Nicholas luftce anftocrcD, that he map enter nottoit!)ftanDing it
 
 Hill. 1650. • 251 
 
 ftatl)bccnftcTctJifo?ccontra1)crtcD,anv) tljc reafon fSjbccattfc \}z Ijat!) tlbc 
 P;fmcrpoffcfsfon.RolUhiefiuftice CHcUncD tfeat tl^c contingent rcmaincct 
 fs not DcfiropcDjbccaufc it aotft not bcre Depcnu upon tl)C particular CCatc; 
 fcut it oug^t to rrpctt till tfj: rcmainccr fenppcn ; ana ^e ronceiVicD tbat tJje 
 iDojD bcir, ano Ijeirs.lccre aii one tierc bv t^c intent ot tbc parties, ano tbe 
 frame of tlje contjcpancc. Ask luQice fato, tbat it is a gooo CEttate of ^te 
 Omple conoitionaD cticnteu in Richard. lermanluilice, JC'nc intent in a 
 ©mill, ifitbenotcontrarptolLato, cngSjttotJCtahcn, anu tljere muft be 
 teojDs to mal;e tfee intent appear, am tbcfc iaojos muE Cano together, ano 
 fljall not be maoe tofo, (\m ^c conccibeo tbc contingent remainoer not ce- 
 flropcD. Adjourneditill the nexc Term. Poftea- 
 
 Port againft Midleton. 
 
 Hill, i<550»Banc.fup. 
 
 AZSUritofCBrrojtoasbjoueftt to rcticrfc a Kuogcmcnt giijcn in an Error toVe- 
 3ction of Debt upon an obligation , ano tljc CErroj inCftcD upon isas ^^^^^^ ^J^^^^ll 
 in tftc entring of t^e 3uDgcment, to^icft teas quod recuperet Debitum funm , 
 ^nDDotbnotrappra:didum. Roll chief luitice anrircrco, tljat t^c Debt Delivery. 
 Is confeffcD bp tlje partp, ano tbe queftion is, toftetljcr t^c ccctJ tuas Dclitc- Efcrow. 
 rcD as an cfcroto 05 not j but it teas oclitjcreo to tfjc pattp ^imfelf , ano 
 tftcrefojccouianotbeocli^crcoasan cfcrolii, Jerman luftice faio, tbat 
 debitum fuutn teitljont pra-difium is not gooD, fo j tl)e icojo prsdidnm is vers 
 bum operativum. Ask luftice as Roil , ano tfecre is tut one Debt , ano tbc impiicKioD. 
 toojD ideo in t^e rcco jo implpes it to be tl^c fame oebt. Nicholas to t^e 
 fame Cffett. The rule was affirnnctur nifi caufa die luna; fequenti. 
 
 Hill, 16 50, Banc. (up. 
 
 Aj]5 aominfffrafo? Ijao a Jucacmcnt againff one to recover a oclt one For a fcire ft- 
 to t^c 3;ntcftate, ano tijen tbc ^ominitttato; opco 3;nteftafe:anD ano • cIjs to revive 
 t^cr toofe out ncto letters of aominiftration de bonis r.on of tl)e firft 3nte« * ju'igcmfn* 
 Oate ,. ano after mofceo tlje Court t^at be migftt Ijatie a fcirc facias to tctitc 5j^7eVcias. 
 tftc guogment obteineo bp tl)c fcjntcr 0DininiOrato?.But the Court anfwe- 
 rcd, that he could not have it; but muft begin a new A Sion, for the debt a- 
 gainft the party. 
 
 Hill. 1(^50. Banc. (up. 
 
 Oijie teas cnalcteo foj fpcaMng tljefe tno^ios againC a ^afo; of a Citp ] 70 quafh an 
 viz, you areaforfwornroan^and have broken your oath. Kales l1T0«endiameiit, 
 teotoquafljtftecnoiflmcnt, bccanfc tbe toojos ^ate no reference to fbc 
 S^aioj in refpect of Ijis office. lermaniufticeanftoereo, tljat tfjcfpcafeing 
 of tbctDOjosfsabjcatl^oftbcgooDbebatiour, anot^ougt)t it fit tljc SDe« 
 fenoant Cbotilo pleao tot^e enoittmcnt, totolbtcl) tbe Court at firS enclf- 
 neo. But afterwards ruled the other party to (hew caufe on Monday follow* 
 ing wby it fliould not be qua(hed» 
 
 f^iii Counters
 
 "252^ Hill. 165a 
 
 The Countefle Rivers cafe. 
 
 Hit. 15)0. Banc« (ap. 
 
 Arguments HT ^t (Eoiintcffc Rivert toas arrcftcn bp a UM of Midlefex , ant) pjapcc fit 
 i.iKhing pri- A Court In' bctCoanccUtftat the ^rft map abate, antitl)ep:cccpt, ano 
 vii'gc ot pec- pjcaijg ^c^ patent, tobcrcbp Qjc inao crcatco a Countcffc, ano fo pl.aoo tbat 
 a.fcncd'/" ftc oug^t not to be arrcftco. Latch of (Touncell affa<nft tfte Counteffe at^ 
 gucD t^atljct patent Ujas not gooD.bccaiifcUtoantsHje Idojdb onnt)cft(- 
 turc , iDticl) arcmatcriall toojua hi tl)c mahfng of an Carl oj Countcffc , 
 foi altftougl) tbe Set of fnDcQfturc map be omIttcD, bccanfc fljc is a toomaii 
 anu flje cannot be gfrt iiftl) a ftoo jd, pet ftc map be cloatljeD \i>it\) a mant'.c, 
 as It (b in tbe I nft. cute?, f. i c. (,m\n fo toas ft in tlie cafe of Am Bullcin tbat 
 foas maoe flf)artt)(onef0 of Wincheftcr bp lung Henry the 8. ano of tl)e 3La= 
 Dp Fioch,maDC Countcffc of Winchellea bpiiing lames, 6 lac. Paich. i. 
 but in tbis Cafe tberc loas a non obflante, to Diipcncc toftb t^e claufe of in< 
 tcftitHre, anu in tl)c ttifcount Barkley« cafe, tbc patent ub^rcbp !)e toao 
 maoe Carl of Nottingham lDasaojuogconaugbt,foj toant of tljfs tlRufc, 
 2ip. 3t tiot^ not appear bp tbc patent, that Oie is mane an CngUlb Coun= 
 tcfs, anDtb:nfl)cbatl)nopjitilegc, 8Ricb. j.Banc.Reg. 704. n E. ^W 
 Banc, re .473. jpeitbetistlicreanprclrtfon to tbc patent to anp place, of 
 tDbiftjflJc is mace a Counters, iFojaltbougbtftc patent be fcalco Initb 
 tlje Cnglifli b?oaD &eal, tjjis ts not matertall, fo j oatlantiO) honours map 
 begranteo bpthcbjoaD&calof trglsnd. 3lp.E[:i)ccaufctl)atIheft)aBhal3c 
 pjiViilege of an (Sngliffj Countcffc is not material, becaufc fljc is not mauc 
 an Cnglilh Countefs , anfi Qjc is no Conntcfs to batjc piiVilcge agafnft tfjc 
 Common Hato, although ftc map ( it map be ) hate her pjibilcgc in point 
 of honour in the jparfhalls Court ano ^cralDo office , bccaufe there is no 
 puOUquc gootJ ano fcrtfcc in maUingher a Counters, 4? E 3. 4.foj being a 
 momanCbe cannot be implopeu in ;arma, o;iotherlBifcfo;thc publique. 
 SJnD an Cmbaffaco j cannot hal^e pjitilcges grantco hint, teh'th co not con= 
 tcrnliimasanCmbaffaooj, Dyer <5o. and u H. 7. rot. 24 C. Banc. SCh- 
 IS/ng cannot grant one to be cpcmptco from artcff ing.as ft fsfii Cook^Mag, 
 Charij Paic. 7 H. 8.rot.(5(5 C.B.fo; thcrcafon of that claufeof Migna char- 
 ta niilii negabiraus itjOiciam. 2EI;B JS'itg cannot grant a &anctusrp to pjo« 
 tcctmcn fromthcarrcttooihtsrubjcct3,29 AfT. 34. Kciw. '50- 5lnD there 
 is no inflancc to be giten of a tcoman mcoc a Counters, that tons etier free 
 anu pjotcttcD from arrctting. 31n the statute of 20 H. (^. C. 9. foj Carls 
 lofties.anD 31 H. 8. to qunlffic Chfiplains, there is no notice taken oCCoun« 
 tcffcs bp creation , but onlp of Coantrffcs Doivagcrs, oj Countcffcs bp DCa 
 fCCnt.Crep. 63. C deRutlandsCafc, ano Ann Builein toas trpcO per pares 
 as fl)c teas iliucen , anb not as fljc Inas spirchionefs of Winchtfter. ano 
 farther the p jibtleges of Carls ano Countcffcs arc noio ertfnct,fo: the caufc 
 oftholcpjitiilcgc0,viz. the toinganohoufc of iiojus arc crtinct , anu 
 gone , anothcpjiViicgc of beingfrce from arrcftcis apjfbilcgc cyecutojp, 
 ano not crccutca. i^cithcr ootlj the fufficfencp of tbcfr poffefsfons onlp 
 gfbcthcmthcpjilM'ccenottobc arrcftro; but their publttiuc fcrl^icce to 
 lhc6>tatc,to!]ich is the final caufc of the pjibilegc, am the other teas but a 
 partfall caufc , ana not the folc caufe. llclicfs toe re papeb bp JtBarons anO 
 Carls, tohcn Cariaoms aiiD Baronies tecre creatro ; but tbep arc not nottj 
 papco ao tbep tarrc then, but accojcfn? to tftc baiuc of the poffcfsions noiu, 
 anb Amercements of Carls ano IBarors toerc eqnalU 2Che njit^ilcgia 
 of Carls aro 515aroi!S toas oerfbetj ojiginallp from 4)Olofcrs . after ft toas 
 certbeD to ^ifbops , ano great CounfcUo^S;, anb fo ft appears) that thcp 
 
 IDE re
 
 JHill. 1650 253 
 
 Irctcpjfbilegcotntefpettof pablfqac frnplcptnenttj, nnonot fap reafon of 
 tbcfr tet)cnttC0. 3U t^c Abbots ano |Djfojg l;at) tIjcpjtMccetiotto bcar« 
 rettcD, pet all Itjcre not ilojosoftlie Ipatltamcnt , 21 E. 3. Mich. jp.Tref. 
 Mich. 7 H.7. pl.7. 31 E. 5 procels. 54. 27H. 8.7. jU.e. 11'. 29 E. 5. f. 
 30. Dyer n 5. 0nD a BluDgemcnt tDftljont a Capiatur toss fn SCrefpafs a- 
 gatntt a 31B{Q[)op, bccaufe tbe tofng teas to bate nofinc, 14 H. 7. 21. SBut 
 It f0 not fo In a tcmpojaU peer , tobere tfjc J^ftig ia to Ijatic a fine. 
 %\)z palWlegcs l)atc fctjcvau cjpicfetons, ann tlje rcafons foj tljc pjt= 
 •bfleges of tftc lap peerage is fullp C):p;cffcD In tbc VExiis lixtatn to 
 tljeot, Rcfjift. 2^(7. 247. RafV. Exigent. Britton 88, 10 H. 4. ij. per 
 Hull. 14 H. <5. 2. per Newton. 39 E. 3. f. 35. Hill. i4Eliz. Dyer 314. 
 3H <5.f. 38. 48E. 3.f. 3. J5 H. 6. 4<5. foj otbcr p?ffctlcgcc tbep are 
 not aBotoablc : ano note alfo all tcmirc0 as tocU as tbc %o«fe 
 of ILojDs fs taljcn atoap bp tbc late SlA ; ano tbougf) ber p:flilcgc Do contf* 
 noe, pet 0)c \)at\) not ta&en tbc rtgbt trap to bate it allotoeo ; fo j the ongbt 
 tobaticfajougbtato;ltoutof tbcCiianccrptobatcft allotocD, anc not to 
 ftabecone U up a tUatojp plea, 8H,6.9&io, ana tbc |I)atent cannot 
 trpb.bctbcta)CbcaCotintcrsojnct, 9rcp. 31 Inft. i6b, drep. 63. ^nh 
 IsfflpmifcbtcfanDmirtrptonicnftieto manp, If ttfs pjlfctlccc fljoulo be 
 allotoeo, anti tbc ticrp matter fpeaksfoj It fflf, anofo be prapco jtiDgc- 
 Mient fo; tbe palntif. Hales of Countcl on tbe other Goe pjapco tbe pjf« 
 Wlerc mfgbt be alloircD , ano be f olloUieo Latch In tbc points of tbfs 3rgu. 
 ntcnt: 0nDfirftbcfaiD,tbattbctbinggrountieDbptbe patent ia onlp'iti 
 creation of tbc Dignitp , anb tberc isno nccD bere of in'orCittire , fo J if tbcrc 
 tocre, tbcn a recital of it fliotilo be alfo ncccffarp, but bccaufc it nccos not , 
 tbcrcfojc it neeos no recital of it in tbc patent. SeldensTit. of honour, f. 
 876. 21 R.2. 2rbcrciBarccitalofan3inbe0iturc, but tl;erc teas no in* 
 tettitute, anofo it teas not material, anoanonobftanteistono ptirpofcto 
 Bifpencctoitbtbe toant offnticCiture, ifittoere ncccffarp, anD tbe rca« 
 fon of tbc maUing tbc ncto patent of tbe 3Lo?d Barkeley leas not fo; tbc 
 toantofti5cClaurcof3lnticfiit«re, fo;tbc3;ntic0{ture is a cercmonp of 
 tb^^craulD6,anDnotcffcntialtotl)ef^onour. anti altbougb tbcrc be no 
 certain place of ocnomination of tbc place of tbc (Earlr-om , pet is t!-,c pa- 
 tent gooti, fo; it map be out or" England , anc pet Cjc map be an ©nglifli 
 Counters nottoitbftantJing , ^lltbcuub 3arrrctbat fojcin bonoiirs map 
 be grantco bp tbc 315;oaD fecal of England ; but bere be fuffjcicrt teojDs to 
 Erpjefs bcr to be an Enolifli Countcft', 1 tbe mott p;oper tbat can be, v iz. tbe 
 patent. Creations of fucb bonoursbalJC been frrquent,if (be tatb alfo a fuf» 
 ficicnt cftate to ruppo;t bet fiignitp -. 3! confefs tbat it is true tbat no petfon 
 can facp;itiilcgeD from jarrrfl- bp grant ; but bere tbc pjililcgcenfucc tbc 
 patent of bcr Countefbip bp Cttflom ano 5LatD, as fnrioent Jo it, STbc litng 
 cannot grant a p;itilcgc to imp;iron, but if Ije grant a Court , tbe potoer to 
 impjifon follotos neceffarilp upon it ; SLnH tbc pji'oilcgc tobfcb tbe JiaU) 
 cites to tbc perfon of a Counters , is tbat u bicb crcmpts bcr from Slxti. ft , 
 as it appears in tbe Cafe of a Coimtefs bp ipariage, ano a Counters bp 
 Creation is mo;c bonourablc tt:an a Counters bp ^ariagc ; ano tbcrcfojc 
 oanbttobabcasbigbpiitilegcsaotbc-otbcr ; ana tbc statute maae eon- 
 cerntng Coiintcffes, tbc toi'oes of Garls ano ilBarons do apprrtain to a 
 Counters crcateD ; fo; tbofc fetatutcs toerc but an affirmance of tbe Com* 
 mon5Lato, anDDiDintroDuccnoneto Biato. SCUs pjitilegc is not tahcii 
 atoap, fo;itatorebpCaComanD bp tljc Common iLatu, ana not from 
 iFoJCincrs, as Larch conceives, anofotbc reafonoftbatcamiot be as be 
 urgeth , but bp tbc pjitilcge of tbe perfon tobicb inoures as torll fcbcn tbcrc 
 fs no parliament, aBl:,bcntberei6, anntbiypiibilcgciiiDtJri.Mgli e, ano 
 not ItUeto a pjibilcgc grantco bp rcafon of cmp'.opincnt. jTo; a Cour.tcfs 
 
 !tiU3 Cotoa-
 
 SDoVoagcr Ijatftno mo^crcaroii to be p?iWlcgeB , in tclatfon to miUtarp cm= 
 plopmcnttftnn a Counters bpCrcatfon, anabp tfte late 5(t no cmplop- 
 ment is talien aitap ; flno fo; tljc Clcrgp tftcpincrc p:{biicn;co from ;ar= 
 rrftg, notbrtaufcof cmplopment, bntbprrafonoflljc cmfiiEncj' of ttcfc 
 pcrCons. Cljerc map be an €atl o j a IBaron bp iMjft o j bp pjcfcrfptton , ano 
 t^crc it ought to be ccrtificD bp torit ; but Ijcrc the tjoncur being bp Creati- 
 on , the patent map be plcaoco to ccrtffieit, as Vocll as if it tocrcrcrti- 
 ficD bp icjtt , ano to picao it thus is the mojc p:opcr teap. ^JBaron o's^ht 
 not to be ftilco Dominus in a \rjit, but bp hfjs ChJiCfian name, ano aoDittort 
 of tonight, if he be one,if he hatie no fpccial name of IBaronp in his Creation. 
 Roll chief lufticeDemanocD , ifonc bc mat)c alBaron, anofaenotcalica to 
 the parliament bp ii!;tt,oj comes tljfthcr bp tofrtue of fome claufe in his pa= 
 tent, fl)aUhebeet:cmpteDfrom;artEtt!' quafi dicsret non. 0nD if one 
 p.iviicge. hcrctofojc i)aD Ijao ttoentp tonights fees, coiilo he hate come to the parlia« 
 went bp rcnfon of them :> ^inDhclottjatthep^ibilcgcisnotaUolDablc, foj 
 (he nefeerhaD reference to the parliament, ojtoDoanpother publiqnc fer=i 
 tJice. lerman, Nicholas, anO Ask Juftices agrceD tcitij Roll Xtt all. Roll- 
 faiD , ?f the toing grant a SCoton to be a JSurrough , the grant gibes it not 
 p?ibilcge to feno a IBurgefs to the parliament , erccpt there be fpccial 
 icojosintbcpatenttotoarrantit; butifhemaUc a Coontp tt is othcr« 
 irifc bp Statute. Adiourned. 
 
 Hay ward againft VVilHams 
 
 Hill liTyo, Bine, fup. 
 
 Hill, 1649. rot, 824. 
 
 wh»thcr i T^c Cafe teas this, JFcmctoasructjasa iT^emefole,butbpthe fur- 
 
 wrftofF-nor I namc of her l^usbano , foe being Cobert 315aron, ano ^uogemcnt 
 
 well bioiigiu. tDas cit)jtn againft her , ano the 5I5aron b;ousht a toait of C'rro j. JDhc qncc 
 
 flionluas, luhcthcrthetojitofC-rrojloaatocUbjoushtbpthcJBnren. 31t 
 
 luas then faio , SChat if a iFeme Cobcrt lebp a fine as a jFeme fole , if het 
 
 3I3aroii Die the Ihall not Defeat it , buttheJBaron map Defeat it During hcc 
 
 isE. 4.40.7. life, Rol 1 chief luRice to the cafe at the JBar faiD, botD tan the 31Baroti 
 
 bjinga lujitof (Erroj here, toho is no partp to the llecojo , ncithep ia 
 
 chargeable bp the juDgemcnt;' But lee us ice books, for the cafe it confidera. 
 
 ble, PoiiQa.^SO. 
 
 Needier and Gueft. 
 
 Hill. 1 6 JO, Banc, fup, 
 
 Trin. '<549.ro£. 5t 
 
 Whether Lx- A ^tit Of (Srroj ii)33 biought in the Chcqner Chamber to rebcrfc s 
 ccutionmiy /\iHtgrmcnt flitcn iu this Cou''t. Ehe queOion toas, b}hether noto, 
 be notwiih- g^cc thelatc 3.A , that a iEOrit of C-troj (ball be no fuperfedeis of ^recuti- 
 WM*^ 'oiVrroi *■" ' ^^'^^ Court map grant ertcution. Roll chief luOice faio, it map , fo?. 
 bccToh't in ^°' othertoife the ^ct is to no purpofe. Latch faio , the iJleco jd is not noln in 
 the Chequer this Court , aiiD thetcfojc thcre catt bc no execution grantco here. Roll 
 Chamber. chief luitice anflcereo , pou hatte confetTcD bp pout pleaoing, namclp bg 
 Exccu::oi, pour SDemiirrer , that the JRecojD is here fo far as to grant execution. 
 SLhercfOje let there be Execution, except caufe be fliewed co the contrary the 
 
 Saturdayr
 
 Hill. 1650, 255 
 
 day the next term. But afterwards the Court Taid , they would not grant it, 
 but laid the party might take cxecntion at his peril. 
 
 and Allsyn. 
 
 Hill» i(55o. Banc, fup* 
 
 A Certiorari 'ii;as tifrcttcD to tlje Countp |9alat{nc of Chefler to remote whcher i 
 a caufc Into tbfs Court. Eftcp mafee afpccfal rctojn, viz. tbat tbeiJ J.^ot'tifr'^ 
 Jwtjejut{sv3<(t<onoftl)ecatjfEs ano tljat tljecEfo;c tt)cp arc net to ccrtfficccumy p^u- 
 it. Serjeant GlynargueiJjt&att^fsrctojn tuns not gooD , (oi t^fs Court tine ct'che- 
 tjat^ juttfiCiction oljcr all tftc Courts fit England In tojita msnoatojp, 34 Aff. ""• 
 7. ip H. (5. 1 2-. SnD an ^ct of parlfament uot^ not tal^.e atuajj ttjc poacr of 
 tWfi Court, ffU run not in tljenegatftic; butfnto^tto rcmcoial ft is notfo 
 general as ft f s fn tl)fs tafc , 5 tlje caufc map be toell enougl) trpeo ficre, not. 
 ixft^aantifn0ftbcconcernfncamattcrtel)fcftarffctbfn tfte Countp |)aia- 
 tfnc, as tl)c Statute 9 Ed. 3 . C. d. fs. 2lp. 3lt appears tbat t^c (^afoj ano 
 CftfjensofCheftcrarcpartfcs, anorotiicpitflltri'lbeftoton caufc, ano 
 ti)fs appears bp tfec HecojD , ano tbfstljcp ought not;to 00, aiH.y.f. 33, 
 lib.AfT, 332. 37 E.s-f. 7.6 lac. C. Banc. anD Smith anU Hancocks cafe, 23 
 Car. Banc Re{^. Koll chief luftice anstocreo , ^f tfte caufc U)crc come to 
 trpaltljfstocre gooDcaufetoremobeft, butftfsnot fo Ijcre. ano ft ap. 
 pears not bptt)crctojntbattl)2 matter of tbcfutcDfo arffc ioftfjfn tijc fu«iurifdiaioni 
 rfsDtrtfon of tl)C Cftp , tofjat Tap pou to tljat r foj tfjcp S) ilic not fteton anp 
 laiife Inbp t!)cp fliouto Ijate jurfsofctfoa. SCtjcrefo jc let tfjem fljeto caufc liC. ^^wro 
 fojc tfte eno of tl)c SCcrm, upon notfcc, tofjp tftcp fljoulo not mafeca rrjai. ' 
 iJEttCtteto?n. RollfafO, the Aftion may be well brought there, although 
 they cannot try it there , for the Original is good. 
 
 Shurlye againft Scmaigp. 
 
 Hill. 1650, BanCifup» 
 
 Tl^e Court teas moteu upon an Affidavit tftat tU)o tojfts of (ijecutfoii por 1 fuper- 
 tocrc crccutcD upon one Blnogement , tljercfoje ft toas pjapcu tfjat t&c fedcas m ah 
 latt crccutfon mf2l)t be rupcrfcDcD , bccaufc tljcrc ought not to be ttoo ere- f^«'-ut'on. 
 cutfons fo J one matter , but inhere the partp fs pjejuBfcco bp Death, oj 3£t 
 of ILaiD, that the partp cannot taUc benefit of the fojmer cjccutfon , 28 H. 
 8. Dyer, ano 13 Eliz. Dyer. Roll chief lufticc, 31f thefirttlujft OfdEfCca- 
 tfonfaercturncoanDfileo, there cannot be a fecono (Evecutfon, otheriuffe ^^='"''<^"' 
 ft fs ff ft be not retojneo ano fileo. Therefore take your Courfe* 
 
 Coleman againfl: Blunden. 
 
 Hill, 1650. Banc. fup. 
 [Mich, I (550. rot, 447, 
 
 Coleman bjougtt an 3(tfon upon the cafe upon an Arfumpllt againft Aiffftof 
 Blunden, ant> hao a \3crDftt agafntt hfm ; Jnarrcttof 3:u5gcment ft^'^/xri"' '" 
 toas motico that ftnoth not appear bp theSDeclaratfon to tohomthc Affumpr on the Cafc''" 
 fit toas maoe , but ft onlp faps fupcr fe afTumpfir, ano upon this erccptfoii 
 The Court ruled a nil capiat per billam. 
 
 Warry
 
 2^6 Pafch. 16^1. 
 
 VVarry again (I Bond. 
 
 Pafch. itf5i,Banc. fup, 
 
 Arrcd of 1% toac mo^cB fn Hrrctt of SaDgBment fit an 0a(on of 2Dcbt bjotiglt tjp= 
 
 lujgcmcnt 1 on an iDblfptfon to ttano to an aioarD, tftat t^c fubmfrBton to ttam to 
 
 ill debt upon tftcillDjrotoasconoittonal, viz. fotl)attbc;atDatD irerc DcHfecrcDiip tbe 
 
 n-^"d"to"an ^7 ^^l' "f f"f'' '' n^onttj : Sino tt appears tbat ttjc action bjouubt is foj not 
 
 Awlrd " pcrfo;ni<n5anatoarDmaDC(fie24Dapof tl)cfam(J ^ontl); fo (t appears 
 
 not uftetbct tftc jaioaro toerc DcUticrcD upon tbc 27Dap,ojno, anDfo 
 
 it map be tbat tl)C conoftion is not bjofecn. Roll chief luftice anstocrcD , tl)c 
 
 qttcftion Is tobetfjcr it be an SLimin befoje the uclitcrins <t up oj no. There* 
 
 Aw:id. tore let the ludgemenc flay till the Plaintifmove , for it is worthy of Confi- 
 
 dcration, 
 
 Harman againftlacob. 
 
 Pafch. 1651, Banc. fup. 
 
 Aruftrf Tjl5anamffof3!utigcmcntuponaticttiictgibenaga(nft an ;aiicn in an 
 Judgement I CEnofctmcnt upon tl)e statute of az H. 8. C. 1 v foj uBng a SErabc , cj;- 
 upoAaiiHn- ccptton \TjaoflrO: tal^ctt , tljat tl)c ©nofrtmcnt Doth not fap that tbc SDcfcn- 
 diftment. cant tDBS bo?n oiit Of t^c polflcr Of the Common*tocaltb , butonlp that !)C 
 
 iuasbojn out of England. SEothts Roll chief luftice ans^ncrcD, if it fap 
 Aicn. thathcis Alieni£;enus,tt)atcuiplj'eo all. 2lp. %\)c Cnoictmcnt Dotft not 
 
 fap that he io Alicnacus extra Angliam, ano this inas helD a gooO (Bp 
 
 ccption. 
 
 vyjrHumphiy Tracy eagainft Bloom. 
 
 Pafch, 165 '. Banc. fup. 
 
 Ar.'ftcf T j^0rrcCof3iU!3SCJttcntupanaacrofctg{ticniiT an Action of iDcbt foi 
 
 iii<i-m:i.t iii J rent upon tltio Icafco , one foj years, ano the otljcrat lutll, 2Chc Crccption 
 
 Debt for f^Yxtn teas that the piaintif Declares upon a oemffc inaDc to the SDcfcnDant 
 
 '"'■ thcvth- ofOdober 1646 at luill,anD fets fo;th that thcHDcfcuDaiithclDthe 
 
 lanes let fcj 2 pears, cnoing at Michaelmas 1648. ariD fo foj tixo pears 
 
 rent behinD he bjiiigs his Action, tohcrcas there cannot be ftich a rent Due 
 
 fojrttth aHLcrm; fo: although tht rent be Due foj the \xI}q\z pear at Mi« 
 
 chatlmas, pet thCtcrm of 2 pcarstsnot cnDeD at Michaelmas, fo? that is 
 
 upon the 29 Dapof SeptembcTjVjheteaslhc 2 pears enD not tftlthe 6of Odoe 
 
 ber follotofng. Rollchief luOiccansii-ercD, thcrcnt fox thcz pe^rs teas 
 
 Kent.' Di;catMchacImas, auD ta'ac all the UiojDs together the 2Dcclaratton is 
 
 gcDD enouch,altho»fih the erp;e'"cion be not to pjcper as it ml^lit Ijatic ban, 
 
 Nicholas anD Ask as Roll , anD fo the rule was judicium nifi. 
 
 Sh'inn and Shann. 
 
 Pafch. 1^5 1. Banc, fup, 
 
 Aitcftof 
 
 lui'RciiKn: ill Q Hann bjought an <3tt(on upon the Cafe upon an Affumpfit againtt Shann, 
 =•' '^-^Vn" "^" 0am D;Clnrc5 , JEt-nt in Confioeration tijat tlje piafattf tooulD furrcnoec 
 
 on anftUiimr- — ' ' ' '- j 
 
 he.
 
 Parc.1651. 257 
 
 to t^e SDefcnoant , atit bfs ^'. fra, a Coppljclo acco jofng to tlic cuflom of tbs 
 manoi, t^eSOefenoantoJoaff-imc anopjomffc unto foe plaintiff to pap 
 onto btitt 500 '• sn" foj •'-t^' ^^ of tWs pjonffe ^c bjougljt Ma Slctton , ano 
 obtcfnB a ^ctDfct agaftiK tlje Defcnoant Cbc SDcfcnCant moVicD in atti ft 
 of 3iuDgcnitnt,anBtoo!aftts3ci:cept{on, viz, t^at tft; conRoeratlon on the 
 ipiafntfffs part teas not perfojmeo, foj tlje conRacration teas, tbat 
 !)c ftjotilD Ttirrcn^er tl)c Coppfjolo to ti)e g^efcnuant. ai^3 ! fg ^ctrs , ano fti; 
 Ijatl) fct fojtl) tl)c ftirrcnDcrto beintotljebanDsofa Copj'ljolo SCcnant of 
 tl)eniflnojtott)cureoftl)ciSDEfcn6ant,tol)<cl)fsnoairrcnoer , until! U tesu,,.e„jg^ 
 pjefentED at tJ)cnc)rt Court , anofo fttafntcrtatn , irftctljct ft fl)au taUc 
 effettojno.. Roll chief iurticer8tO,3It is e|:pjeircD to be fecundutn conlucii 
 tudinem manetii, pet t^s fs not fnlfictcnt, fo J (t (3 not an effectual furrcnDcr 
 antill ft be pjefentcD at t^C Court, Therefore let iudgiraioc Hay till the 
 Plaintiff mo ve. 
 
 Lord Mont-Eagle. 
 
 Pafc, ip 5 r . Banc, fup, 
 
 Tl|ielLojoMonr=EaglctDa0arreffei>b)?abfllofMldlcrey, anofo? toantp , „ 
 ofbatlu^aBturneooljertotbe^arcfcljalof tbfs Court, ano b^ipg fn,cnVa.'tu.'* 
 Cuftodia Marefchalli, tfte |I3lntntfff Dcclarefilagafnft ftfm in SDcbt upon picjd in 
 an obligatfon. SDbe SDcfenoant pleaos bfs peerage, ano pjapeo to be sff» chief. 
 cljargcD, SCfte Court inae motco tljat l)c mfgljt be ojoercn to pleao fn cftfef, '''" dilatory. 
 anDnottl)l0Dtlatojpplca» The Court thereupon ordered that he fhould 
 ihew caule, why he ifhould not plead in chief, and faid hit plea was dilatory j 
 and lb it bad been ruled lately in the cafe of the Earl Rivers, 
 
 Fielder and Tovye. , 
 
 Hill, 1550. Banc, fup, 
 Pafc, idji.rot. 430, 
 
 Fielder bjougW an ^dfpn of Debt upon an obl{ga{fon,t6c SDcCrnoant pjap. Dcmu.ret ti ' 
 ED^pcroftl)el5oni5,*anDupont3feUjtbereof Demurs to tl'.e piafntffF©* Drciaratioa 
 SDeclaratfon , ano foj taufe Ojctes tbat tljc piafnttff occlarco foj quadra. !," fbi; "^•°" 
 gint.librif, ano tlje 515onD ie quadragent libris,.anD fo tfjcrc fs a tarfancc. 2:0 '" '' '^'"""^ 
 tl^fs ft toas anrtncreo bp Green, ttat tbfs fs no material offfcrence, foj ttjc 
 tBOjDs fount! alfhe, ann tbere fs mo je Difference bctirccn dra ane drin tban 
 bettoeen ginta ano genta, 3 betiDccn dra 5 drin ftatl) been liclD no material! 
 tatfance , anD quadragent. fs not utterlpfntertafntjerc.foj cttfjer ftmuft 
 be 40. oj 400. ano tbc conDftion of tbe oblfgatfon crplains tbc fum , ano tlje 
 plaintiff licrc Declares but foj /\o I. ano fo it appears fn t!32 I'^cro jo, ^n 
 O-'bomes cafe odogenta uias foj oSogint. anO pet Ijelo gcoo, ano Hob. 1^, 
 Logards cafc Triqiniat fnftceD of triginji, anD fn Walter anD Pigots cafe Sep« 
 tingent. fs ufeD foJ fepreagent. anD v'ary anD Daves cafe quinquegent. foj 
 quii.quagirt.anD tbefp 1)^ iD no materfall tarfances. latch on tfjc otber fioc 
 fafatbctoojDfntbc JlBono ig unccrtafn , anD tbe conoition haib notbina 
 in ft, to reoute ft to a certain fignfficatfon, anD ff ft m&kc anp crrtafntp fn i^ 
 ftmuft maticftftgniftr4oo 1. anD tben tbc plaintiff hatl) faiico fn bis 2Pc. 
 daralfon, anD Hobarts cafc Differs from tbis, ano as fo; Oiborni cafe it fs 
 tarfou{^prcpo?teD,anDfonot tobc relpeDon. Roll cnie' luilice, ^bat 
 fap pou to reffanra f 5IBut tbc ijucftfon bere is, tofiat fbali be meant bp tbe 
 toojDto^ct^cr^o, 0J4OO' J3nDinFi:z!ie^bcristafC;3»0SCJnent ipas gf- 
 
 3LI tjci!
 
 258 
 
 V.uiince. 
 
 Whether an 
 tftare tail or 
 fee CJniiitic- 
 naJ). 
 
 LiiTiitation. 
 
 Perpetuity, 
 
 CiTe upon a 
 fpfcial vcr- 
 <i!ft in ticf- 
 pai\ and c- 
 jcftment. 
 
 Pa(ch.^6 5 1. 
 
 \3tn upon a Demurrer, t!)<it pent foj gint Inas a material tarfance , ano out 
 cafe <3 all one lutil) tl)at. §( tbc Doubt be toftctljer tt OjoulD be 40, ot 400. 
 l)olD fliaU U3C hnoiu tbe intent of tt)c partpes :> ano if (t be certain it mud i:e 
 unDerttooD 400. nnD t^c Action is bjougftt but fo; 40. 1, 44 Eliz. Mich, rot, 
 * 501. Gray and Davis Cate, Sexf;int. Ujas aojuOgCD tO be a ISonD of 60 I. 
 anD not of 600 i. jSiio tt is tlic gem. ano gint, in all tl)c cafc0 tljat maUeo tbc 
 Difference, janutljc cafe of icifanta comconot to onrcaic,anDfo concluoco 
 iuDgcmciit to be agair.tt ttje ^plaintiff, lermsn Nicholas, ano Ask luftices 
 of the fame opinion. Nicholas luitice falD, t^at falfe iiatin (n a 35onD Dotb 
 not mai^c it naugt)t ; but i)z ^elo t^is loono \ob6 fo;^ 400 i, ano not 40 1. ano 
 it ia not inccrtain fo; tt)c rtrammar ralc.ginta nocat dscem , fed genta numero 
 centuiDjDotl) tolO ^ rc, Aniea. 
 
 Gay again fl Gay. 
 
 Pafc. 165 1. Banc, fup, 
 
 Trin. 1650, rot, 1350, 
 
 \ 7 pon a fpcctall tcrtirt founD in a rcplcWn ; JD&c cafe teas tljio, matt 
 V fetfcDofaCoppftolDl3ojo'jgftC(tgliflj,DetifcDit toH, Ws granotljilD, 
 anD to Ws ^eirs, ano if be ope During tl)c life of i)i£) mother, t^j rcmainoec 
 to H. bis poungcr b;otl)cr,anDlobisl)£tr0. SDbe queftion bcre teas U)ljc« 
 tbcrbcrebcanCttatetailinH.oja fee Cmplc crccatojp. 3f <t be an 
 Cftatc tailjlbcn the Detifc toao faio not gooo, bccanfe ft ia of a CCoppbolo, 
 butifitbea jFefGmple,tl)eniti3a gcoD octjifc. Roll chief lurticc faio, 
 tbata limitation of aninbcritanceaftcran abfolutc fee (imple ia not a 
 aooD limitation, foj tbis tooulo be to maUe a pcrpctnitp , Inbicb tbc 3iato 
 ioill not aamit , but if it be upon a contingent i?ec ample it ia otljctixiife. 
 Adj^urnatur. Poflea. 
 
 Heale sg.iinR Greene. 
 
 Pafc. 165:. Banc, fup. 
 
 t 
 
 Hill. 649 rot. 370, 
 
 T i5 an action of Srcfpafs, ano cjcrtmcntjupon a fpcciaU ^crfiitt founo, tl;c 
 1 cafe PjoDcD to be tbt5. man fci'co 0' a manoj tbnt (jaD oittera Kc- 
 riantfi tljat bclo foj lives bp olD rents oe 'cifctb it to bis lotfe , During ber life, 
 Icitb polutr to let ana fet , anDmahccIrategoutoftbcmJnaB ample ma= 
 ncrastbcCcCatoitninbt, ifbeiDcrcliting. ICb-" qurCions toere maoc 
 bp Latch. I . CJUbctbrt this polwr gibcn ber to fct, anD let, dec, Dotb not 
 alter bet Cflatc foj life in tbc iLanoo DclifcD to ber. ;lp. ^bctbet 
 tbispoto^r ai'scn icr br tbc WiiH, aoDs anp poker to bet cflate fo; life, to 
 ma!-.e cffatcs, ano be bclo fo^. tbs erfJ, tfeat tljc poircr gifeeu ber, DiD not al. 
 tcrbcr Cftatc. 2nD I'.p. tbat it aoDs no polucr unto btcCffatc, bccanfe the 
 daufcintbcCQill, <3 one entire rlaufe, anD not Double ano arcumula. 
 tiuc, anD foOjc can mnt^c no greater Gftate>3,tban ber cftatc fo; life toill 
 bear' 5lnD fo: tbc obt'cction tbnt is maoc. Hbat tben tbc toojDo tbat limit 
 tbcpoiEcr tobcraret)oiD,anfiiDlc. i^eanriL'CreD,tbatitiDnotnece[iarp 
 tbat all the too;Bs in n ^iU fi)OHlD gitie fometl;{ng ,- but fomc Idojds map 
 t)ecrplanato;pofotl>erUJO}D8, ano fo arc tbefe too JD3 Ijcrc , ano pet tbe 
 
 tBOiDa
 
 Palch.. 16 5 1. 259 
 
 ttojDsftcrcmapaoiJ fometftfng to !)ct Cffatc, viz. to enable Ijer to mahc 
 Cftates toftljout impeachment of toafte.Sliio tlje Ilo;D0 fball not be fnteno» 
 ED oftbe tfmeofCDFCCutfonottSe Gttatcs niaoe bp t!)ci^cmc, fo; tljen 
 tijep ate fOle, Hill* i Car. Banc. Reg. Danycl and Vplins cafe. One map 
 Dffpofc an cftate bp Wi'A fo> Ufe, toitl) polrct to maKc (Eftatcs to continue 
 after tljc neat!) of t^e partp tfjat maoc tftcm.JlBut bcrc tbc cftate fs maDconIp 
 out of tl)efntcrcftoftl)c\r.liC,tol)!cbcannotcnoutc after ?ict life, Paf:. 4-^ 
 Eliz. Bible and Dringhoufe, an3 fo piapCG ftlBffCmcnt fo: tl)C piattUtff. 
 Hales foj tlicSDcfcntjant maoc ttjcfe qtieCfo: 0, i .CZHljat poincr toag niljcn bp 
 tlic WMIU 2\v. GiS^et^cr ft tccrc toeU crecutco; ano bcfjclo tr,e feme bcfnQ 
 Ejcccuttlieliatl) bat an Cttatc iox Iffc; 515tit ftetatb a polocr to m.alsc cCatcff, 
 as fljc batb oonc. SCiietc fa no qucftfon but fucb a potocr map be aooeD. 
 SCfte qijcfif on onlp fs f f tlifs poliict be aucco Ijcrc in ctir cafe, anij fjc fata ft 
 teas atiDct) bp tfte crpjcfg too juc of t^e tofll.foj clfc tljofc tooj03 are frito= 
 lotis, ano operate notliinff, Sn Danyel ano Vpiins cafe citeo , Uiftic!) toss 
 BntrcD, 20 lac. Hill. 720. t!)cre is no crpjcfs (Cftate sften to tt)c partp, but 
 a mecr potoct onlp , ano ft toas not bp reafon of tlje too jos aooco, foj tbcp 
 are onlp conjuncttiictoo^cs. ^no lufticeVVridockftclDtljcrctbattbc ftrff 
 toojoc aalic tt)e pouiet; aCftoiigb luftice loncs Differco in opitifotr, ano tljat 
 cafe fo tbe tjcrp fame fett!) ours ; Ctje rcsfon f n out cafe, ffifjat tftc toojos 
 offtc potoet to tbc fcmc,map appear bp tl)c comparing tbis part of tijc Mill 
 tofti) tl)c otbct parts of ft, 3n otber parts of tbc SQill tobctc tbfnss are 
 cct{rcDtoblotoffe,tbcfctooj03l)i:reureDarcnot aatico, anotbat arcues 
 tbat tliE Eeftatoj fntcnocD tbc jTcme moje potocr, tban fn otbec tblnag 
 Dctffeo to ber, ano tbe too jos tccmfeltes being a octiifc of a mano?,p jotcg 
 bptbenaturc of tbctbfnctbattbeSCcftatojfntenoeo to ttfbc potoct to tbc 
 iFcmejtomaUcC-ftatcsoutoftbcmano;, Sno ft cannot be fntcnoeo, 
 tbat tbc toojDs In as ample maner , &c, Do onlp gf^c tbe feme potocr to af- 
 Cgn o\}tv bcr tctm, V jugiian ano Lonjis cafe,24 C.tbc too;03 toere aojuogctt 
 to be toojos to enlarge the potocr of tbc Hcgatde, ano fo arc tbep t}crc.;ana 
 tbc fubfrquentclaufe During tbc tctm of bcr If fc,Tfftratns not tbc potocr, 
 fo J tbcfe toojDs map be eitbtr refcrrco to tbe CEftates to be maoe, 0? to tbc 
 time of mating tbcm.ano bete tbep are referrcD to tbe cvccution of tbepoto* 
 cr,ano tbfs is more fuitable fo tbe intention of tbe partp In ojoinarp rcafon, 
 ano tbep arc aooro to crponno tbc intent, viz. tbat tbc rcmainoer If mitco 0= 
 t3cr fljall not binoer tbe feme, fo; be batb not barreo bcr out, ano batb tmpo= 
 feDtl>{iJtrurtfnbcrasC¥ecntri)c,anoasiiegatce. ilnofoitbc 2d. point 
 bcrc is a gooD execution of tbc potocr, foj ft arifctlj partlp out of Ijcr inte« 
 tcft,anD partlp cut of bet flutbojitp, ano botb map tecll ffano togctbcr,ano 
 tbc Cftate maoc out of bctb is a gooo C5ftatc , 0; if not, tbc Gftatc map be 
 fntcnoco to arffc out of tbc potocr giten bcr to maUc fncb an Cftate, ano 
 notoutofbctfntcrcft, ano tbc jopning of ber oaugbter fs not matertall, 
 tboucb I'O gooo cftate be oerttieo from bcr , anofo be pjarco Suogcmcnt 
 foj tbc JSDcfencant. Roll chief luflice, 3!t is ufual in tbc mtit of Eneiand 
 to malic Cftates foj Iffecs upon tbc olD rent ; but ft is not bcrc erpjeffeo of 
 tobat nature tbfs mano? is, oj tebctbcr it ufco to be let, nno bcrc fa no ltmi« 
 tatfon to let ioi libcs.ilSut bcrc citbcr tbc latter toojos arc iolc. oj clfc tbe 
 y emc batb fucb a potocr, tbat fl)C map ocftrop tbe rcmainoer. ano itO) all 
 not be intcnoco tbat be truftco bis C'tccutrlt , toitb mo:e tban be gabc bcr , 
 ano tlje toojDs of tbc Wiili do not cjp jefs tbat , ano tbe qticftionts bo to it 
 fl)aUbrintcrp:.ctcD. SCbctoojosmapbcfntcrpjctco Cumularive, otbcr- ),""^'''^"*"* 
 toifc the feme batb potoer fo ocftrop tbc rcmainoct, wblcb tooalo be a 1 aro ""' 
 conftriictfon.sno tobicb Nicholas affcntco. Roll chier'flufiie, SCfac intention of 
 tbc2neftato J is not tlccr to gfte tbfs potocr to tbc jFcmc; but if itioio appear 
 to be bis meaning, it mtgbt be otbcrtoifc ; ano bcrc it is in a mm, 5no 
 
 1 1 2 tbe
 
 —I. .. - — . ■ , -t , 
 
 260 Pafch. 1651 
 
 tfje ClcrDfrtfa not tocll DjaUin np , fojtl;c€:arcln{gt)tlbat)c btcnmaBcbct* 
 tcr ; fo? all tfte lano map be in Pcmcfnc foj oiigljt appears bp tl)c 5UrD(ct, 
 Adjourned to be argued again , Poltea, 
 
 Webb ajrainft Wilmer. 
 
 Pafcb, 1(55 I, Banc, fup, 
 Hil), 1550. rot. 309. 
 
 . \7\/^ ^ -^ - --. .- - 
 
 )iir-e'ni:<u,n \ V leafc foj pear0 maoc to Wilmer , 3110 obtalrts 3 tUctDftt. SDbe 
 
 Arrcft . ( . \ 7 \ / Ebb b joualjt an 2ctf on of S>cbt foj tent rcfctbcb bp Wm upon a 
 
 )iiH(>'rn:iu in ^ 
 
 D.bt tor rent 
 
 rcrcrvtrfuv,-, SDEfpntiant moliCD <n ancft of 3!m>!jement, atio allcgeo fojcaufc tljat tbc 
 
 aLcifcfo,'* |9lr.fntlfI)aDabatcDl)fa tojft. SEbe cafe toaa tb<0 , Webb leafctl) ccrtafii 
 
 ycjis. lanDjj to Wilmer fo J pears, tefcrWng a rent, iDUbaclanfcofrc-cntrp foj. 
 
 not patuneiit , i^t rent bcfng bcbaiD , tbc letfoj bjfngs an iJdfon of 
 
 JSDcbt fo; tl)C rent , ano penning tl)c futc re.cntcra <nto tbe lano , ana after 
 
 tbsiLcffeerc= enters. ECbequcflfonberctoas, tuljctbcr tbc iii?ft once aba- 
 
 Rcvivor. tec bp tljc piaintffs cntrp , penotng tbe to?ft, tecre rcbftco bf tlie 2Dcfcn- 
 
 Abaicmcnt. Dant3 re.cntrp. Roll chieflufticebclD ft teas not. Twifden argueo, tbat 
 
 tbe U)?ft is not abateo , but oiilp abatable bp plea , ano fo tbfa matter fa 
 
 not to be offerco to ftap tbe 3iuDgcment , 5 H. 7. f, 47. ano be batb plcaoca 
 
 notbfng fn abatement , but to tbe Siaion onlp , ano bs faia tbat <t noU) being 
 
 after a berofct , ft is belpco bp tbe Statute. Hales on tbe otbcr fioc fafo , 
 
 tbat it Dotbbcrc appear tbat tbe plafntu' batb no caufe of ;^ction, fo;> be toas 
 
 In poffcfsfon toben be b jougbt tbe Cftctment. Roll anstoerco, 3lf one oe* 
 
 Declaration, tlarc baljfng no caufc of ^ctfon, (f tbcrc becaufc aftcrlnarojt is tocU e. 
 
 D.-parturc. not,g{j^ JBut bcrc is 3 Qcparturc, anDtbei.CjcamcntfgnotrebibcDjfoj 
 
 it in purgCD bp tbe re entrp. The rule was nil capiat per billara, nifi. 
 
 The Cuftodes Libertatis^&c. againft Hall. 
 
 Pafcb. KJji.Banc, fap. 
 
 Erroriorc- TTAIIloas enoiflco fo> fo:c£fallfng of SButtcr, ano plcaoeo, ano baD 
 vc.ica jiidg. Xrljuogcmentoiljcnagafnabiiti; lobcrcupon be bjougbt bis toiit ofCr^ 
 n.c-jt u?..n a„ j^, ^ g^j ^ooh tbcfc crceptions. I. Cbat it Dotb not appear tbat tbe €noict» 
 imV; c'luu '"^"^ ^"^^ ^^ *^^ ajuartet Sefsfons, as it ougbt to be bp tbe Statute of 5 
 liig. Ed.6.f0!itisonlpfai0tobe ad geneialcm Scilionem. Roll chief lufticc 
 
 anfmcrcD, ffitbcad gi-neraiemScflionemitmap be intenoeD tbe SJuartcr 
 i-fp.d'P • ^efgionc. ali» 3t Iras objectco tbat tbereie no Caputur atoarOED in tbe 
 ;. .p.. ! '.cat. jj,j,gp,j,p„t^ag tjjfre ougbt to be. l he Court anfwered they would advife. 
 
 VViilisagainftBoncf. 
 
 Pafcb, itfjiiBanclup. 
 Mich. i6yo. rot. 8<j. 
 
 BOnda!T0am{nfffratc?b;o:isbtanS[aion of 2Dcbf in Briflow againtt 
 Willis upon an indebitatus nfTurapfit , anO bao a juoctcmcnt : SLbe 2C»c. 
 mcnc In deb' fc"5ant bjougftt a irjft of Grroj, ano toob tbcfc SErccptions. i. Ebat 
 ■ tbe paintif Declares fo? a tbiug, tbe conufancciBberroflpes out of tbe }u« 
 jiinrcjidion. tisoictjon of tbe Court, fojitis fo? toages to be paio upon tbe performance 
 of a ffilopagetobcmaOcinlocistranrmarinif, Roll chief Jurtice faiO, tbia 
 
 tons
 
 fens a goon Crccptfon , fo j iljej? cannot erqufre at Briftow to^etbcr tbe par= 
 tp Ibatl) petfojmcD bis taopagc o j not. £1)5 2d. Crceptfon teas , that tl)c 
 ^aiafntUDcclarcBttjattbeSDefsnDanttoasfnijebteo to Ijim f n fut6 a fum of 
 itionep , to tEnoer Wm an accompt, 2Ct)E CDcurt anf toercD,tbt0 fsnot gcno, Accompc. 
 foj <n fuclj caf0 an 2lsiioa of accompt lies, ano not an indebitacos aflumpfic,^'-'''- 
 And for thefe caufes the ludgcracnt was reverted, nifii anO pzonotincel) bp If r« 
 man luftice ( at t^c pjaper of tlje ^^csiafntffs Counfel ) in Cnslift , bcfng tl)c 
 firatbatlDacpjonotinceofotntUis Court, accojDtng to tl)e late Sia. foj 
 pjoceeDfngs in iato to be in Engliih, Quod nota* 
 
 Gowr againft 
 
 Pafcb, i5j«. Banc. fup» 
 
 Ii^ 0tr£ft of 3u6gemcntupon a tUcrofct fonntt foj tljc plafnttf, fn a Arrtftof 
 fCroljcr anc Coiiterfton bjongbt bp HBaron ano ftme , fo j gooDs of tbe '"j"^"'/"',^ ^ 
 JFeme dura ipla lola fuit. Sbtjc Circeptlon teas, tbat it ie not orpjcffeo tljat cor.vci'fion" 
 
 tIjCgOODStDerCDEinattDEBbptljEiFcme. KoU chief luftice fatD, tljC DC" Demand. 
 
 manDoftlbciFcmetsgooutofoiinDtljc Srtion, ano U teas tben alfo fafo, Trover, 
 tbat a 2Crot)cr ano dontetfion Ucs fo; gooDs founo ann tonvettco.altfjougl^ 
 tljcpcomca(tcriDatD0totl)el)anD0oftl)cpattpt5at lotttl)em» The Rule 
 viis judicium, nin, 
 
 Pafch. 1651. Banc. fup. 
 
 MEmorandum , The firft rule of this Court made in EngUfh was bctwecri 
 OT^itCand iiebleU;l)Ue. Pafcb. 1651. 
 
 Peafe againft Shrimpton. 
 
 Pafc. KSyi.Banc, fup. 
 
 Hill. 24Car.rot, ipi. 
 
 'Tl^c Court iuas info jmcBbpConnceltftattbe Habeas Corpus aniJi?a(l. 
 -^ pfecc teictc loft , anD tbctefojc {t toas pjapeo tftat tftctc nitgl)t be a ncUi 
 Habeas Corpus , ano t^at tftc olo BaU put (n map be allotoeo bp tfte talc of 
 Court. RollchieflumceanflDCtcD, mahca ncto Habeas Corpus, ano a^^j"^^"" ^'"■- 
 ncto llBaU.pfece; but firtt let Tutt tljc^ttojncp t^at teas Clarfe of tftc JBafla o^jj 
 atteno Ijete to be cramfneo tDbctljer tfje Habea5 Corpus 1 15fitbptecc be loft 
 asisfuggeSeo. 
 
 Ritch againft Sanders, 
 
 Pafcb, 165 1. Banc, fop. 
 Hill. 1649, rot, 758. 
 
 Rltch bjoagtit an Sltffon of SCrefpafsi agafntt Sanders foj taking ainap special ver- 
 1)10 Coin fctfojtftfojtftbcs; uponflTuc lopncoarpetial tiaeroict itas'^i'^inTref- 
 founo, tobcreapon tbc cafe fell out to be upon tbc conCrnflfon of tt)cP'''J°/j^^"'"'' 
 toojosofatofll, toWc^ toere ttjefe , Igivc all my free lands wher€foev«„otiijota 
 
 ill 3 to Will.
 
 2^2 _ Pafch. 1651. 
 
 tomyBroiherSobn&anOCrSandhis heirs, upon condition that he fuffcr 
 my wife to enjov all my Freelands in l)olfojD for life, tftc EcCato; ftatjfnc 
 onlp a po?tfon of tithes; of inbctltnncc tii Holford , ano no lanDo. 2D!)C qnc- 
 flioii \)ext toas, to()cthcr tub po jtfon of tithes fljaU be atcomptco free laiioa 
 tcdhln the intent of the loill, anu fo the Uifc be to hate them onring her life. 
 Twifdenhclo, the titfceoVDCTC not QctjifcD bptliCteiU to the #cme; toj if 
 3DeV<fcmi'fcc:fjmplclanDsto lohn a Stile ano his hcirfl, tithes Do not 
 pafs bp this DCtJifc , foj tithes arc a collateral thins ariftnn ont of lanD , ano 
 notpartofth^ lanDitfclf. 42 Ed. 5. f. 13. 10 lac. Moyieanu Ewers cafe, 
 31 Bliz. Perkins anDHyndes cafe, 3n the Uilll here thcppafc not, foj there 
 Etc no Ujo JDS in th • toiU to DdJifc them, nojcanfcclDOjDshc ro ei:pounD= 
 CD. finDh^vc arc other lanDsDctifcD to fatisfie the uojDs cf the toill. 2L 
 term fo J pears I'athmojcrelction tolano than tithes; ano a term coulo 
 rot have paffeo bp the toojos of the toiU. ijicrt, the fcconD CElaiifc Doth not 
 pafs the tithes , toj there fs no ftich thing as is crpjcffeo in it; btit if ft 
 llionlcpafsto the ir.ifcbf implication, pet it cannot pafs to lohn Sanders 
 thclBjothcr; fo; there arc neither erpjctfe Irojog no? anp itnpH^ation to 
 nel3ife this portion of tithes to him, but the contrarp rather is to be collcctco 
 from the OTiO. Wadham Wmdham on the other GDC anfVrcreD, that the 
 JSCeftatoj calls the tithes in Holrord his free lanDo. 3;t is trnc aencrallp» 
 that bp the Dctifc of lanDs tithe Do not pnfs , but in a trill bp the intent of 
 thcSDetifojtbep map pafs, anDthc tojDlanD incitiDco all real things in 
 tommon intention ano legal confiruction, as Lutrels CaUiSy i Mar- Bro» 
 Tit. Elegit. SnEier'itmapbeof arcnt, ano tithes have a nearer relation 
 to lano than rent bate. ilp. ^ere is an apparent intention to ocWfc the 
 tithes; foylie explains l)ia meaning in his fcconD claufe of tijc OTill, that 
 he intcnDs tithes bp the VbojD laiios, 44 EHz. Com. Banc. Gery agairttt Ge. 
 ry , the qi.tftfon there teas , Inhat paffeo bp the Sxoin rents , Vohctl-cr lanDs 
 paffeD. 2Che IrojDS Ittrc , as to all my lands in iDale 1 ucvife my rcntJ^ &c» 
 nnD here the matter comes fnbp a pjolifo, tohich enlarges the matter, 
 Trin. 3 lac. Ficz.Williamscafc ; £Dne DEtifcD all his gooDo, Sictocls, ano 
 |)latc , cvccptinghislcafcfnC Shcrcit Inas aDjnDgca that all his other 
 JLeafcc paffcD. 4 Ed. 3 . Br. grants 5 1 . another circumlfante in the G2ill 
 cnfo'-ccththisconflrnction, viz, the tuojo whcrefoever, tPhich toojD n- 
 puffcth the intent of the HDetifo; to be fo , othetblfe that tocjD toflt be iaie, 
 anDtonop'irpcfr. Hnb. rep. Smktlv aiiD Butlers cafe: 3^t map alfo appear 
 outoftheboDpoftheltiUll • fo? it appears thcrcbp that his jDaughtct taas 
 pioljiDcD fo; in his Irill bp hir. pcrfonal ca^tc , aiiD that the ii-tcntion teas to 
 tirpofcofhislanDstothc^^cir, anD his (CoppholD InnDc tohicb he hao in 
 H-.lfo- d iDcrc furrcnoaeji at th: time of the maUing of the ^^HII , ano fo the 
 Dclilfecannct refer to them; ano bcCocs this is callpo free lanDs, ivhkl) 
 DiCinPuiflicththem from CoppholD lanoo, anD fo he pjapcD juDgement 
 foi the piaintif. RfWl chief lufnce, SChcre isaCTonDftion anncrcDtothc 
 Condition- Jl>ctiife, that his toifc Qiall cniop this lano.though the toojDs in the CSHtU are 
 rot tierp piopcr to ctpjcfsit ; but ue mull cotiGocr them as ufcD in a OeHfH, 
 anotfnacontcpance. Nicholas lufUcefaiD, the S^etilfojhimfclf calls them 
 frccholDs , anD this DtffinguiCijcth them from CoppholD lanos. Adjourned 
 (ill Saturday foilovving to be argued again. 
 
 Dowfe
 
 Pafch. 1651. 26} 
 
 Dowfe again ft Maftcrs; . 
 Pa(c,id5*.Banc.fap. 
 
 DOwfe bjonsHjt an Mion of SDebt upon an indebicatus AfTumpfit a- D-n-uTfr to 
 gamtt Mafters fo; fite pounD,fn \X)Wi> t&c 2D;fcnDantplcaDco tl)atM'i"inDcb: 
 be D<o ueUtctbflsto tl)epia<nt« totl)(?tjalueof6l.iiiiDfttcfttl)e59la{ntlf''i'"" ';?'^''"'- 
 teas tnocbtED'" to bf m , toWcb blUa tU platntH olo accept fn fuU fa^'t?" ""'^" 
 ttsfaaton; t^c pafntff replpcD proteftandotljatocteasnotinucbtcDtotijc 
 SDcfcnoant, tljat tjc Dfu not rccelbe bfllo to ttjc tialue of 6 1. In fflUs^actfoii : 
 tapontbfaa S>cniur«r toas jopnco. Roll chief ludice fafo, tbe pea of pje, 
 t^c ©efenoant is (11 , foj be Dotl) not tap tbat 50 Dellbrtco tbc HBflls fit fuH 
 fatfgfattfon , but tbat tbe JDlaJnttf recefbco tbcm in ftiU fattsfactfon , tobicft 
 ianotgooD, fojt^cpafnttfsrccetWngoftbe JBtllomtiabe as tiici' vuerc 
 oeUbercD, anO not otbct inaps , anu tftat te not e):p?cIlcD : Therefore let chc 
 Plaintif take bis judgement, niri,&c, 
 
 Rols againft Lawrence. 
 
 Pafch. 1 6ji. Banc, fup. 
 
 ROfs bjotigW an 0£tfon of tbc Cafe agafnff Lawrrnce foj fpcahtng tbcfc Arrea of 
 Welch too JDS of t)tm, viz.De«Iiogue5WillRoItin mudon, U)Wtbarefa!"<'g="if"t 
 Englifti, William Rofs hath forfworn himfcif , upon gffue )opnED, ano a tet- '" '^ ^^"^'^ 
 tiaw tbepiafntlf , tl): SDcfenoant motco fn ;arrctt of Siiocement tbat forwcid"'' 
 tbe toojDs arc notaaionab'.e , as t^cparc rcnojco fn Englifti , ano fo tl)C words Erg. 
 jactfonUesnot. Roll chief luftfce , 3ftbctoojD0 founo fn Welch tbat thci'^'cd. 
 pafntfftoasperjatro , pet ff tl)C ^Dlafntff Do CEnnHO) them fn Enql fh, 
 "toMcbDotbnotamoanttopctturpjfifs fll, ano an aafon Uifll not Uc fojcafr. 
 t^cm, Thereforclet judgeracncbeftayed. 
 
 Peck againft Ingram. 
 
 Pafcb, «55 1. Banc, fup» 
 
 PEck bjougbt an actfon upon tbe Cafe upon an AfTumpfit , anD Declares, Arrcft of 
 tbat tbc Defenoant , fn tonttoeratfoa tbat fijc tbe piafntff IpouId Icate ludpcmcnt 
 Ijer iFatbcrs boufc, anD come to tbc ^oufe of ibe SDefcnoaiU In fuc'o a place , '" '" *'^'°". 
 tfoaffume anD pjomffc unto bet tbat be tooulD marp bcr, ano ti-.at tbcre-uJ°"',nVf"" 
 upon tbe DfDlea\}c bet jFatbersl^onfe, anD Dfo come to tbe SDcfcnoantsrumjfi:. 
 I^oufe , et obtulit fc in maritagium conjungi, anD becaufc b' bao not pcrfoj» 
 meb bfs pjomffe Adio accrevit : tKpon fCfiie fopneo, ano a bcrofct founo fo j 
 tbepafntff, tbe 3?cfenDant mote d fn arreftof Jjuogcmcnt.anDtook €t- 
 ceptfons , tbat tbe ipialntff nfo not Qjeto fn bet SDeclaratfon tobcn (be left 
 bcr JFatbcrtJ ^oafc , ano came to tbe SDefenoanto boufc , no j tbat fi)c oabc 
 bfm anp notfcc tbcreof. WilJ mo^co fo; tuDgcmcnt , nottoftbftanafng tb2 
 Cyccptfon ; fo?, be fafo, tbougb ft be net ci^jjcflp fafa tbat flic gat?c tb? iDc= 
 fcnDant notfcc tobenfljc came to bfsl^oitfi:, ret it fa fafa, quod obrulit fe 
 in maritagiura conjungi^ tobfcb f mplfcs tbc 2?cfcnoant baD notfcc; ano bc= 
 Rnsi berc fs no neeo of notfce ; fo; tbe AduropfK is , tiiat ff (be tofU come 
 to tbe SPcfcnDants boufe be tofll marrp bcr , ano ft fs not fafo that tobcn (be 
 comci$betDUlmaitpbsc, fo t^at Ue fs boiino bp tio p;omfrc to tal^e notice 
 
 at
 
 264 J'^'^^-i^^i; 
 
 — ■ 'cfljcrcomfng. Roll chief lufliceanftocreo, f fall ttjefiDeclaratfon be con* 
 
 ficcrcD togctbct , J)erc f3 n gooo confiocration crpjcffeo ; foj tttia is not like 
 
 to tlje caic of tCrtOCt of moilCp, HnO t^C U'O joa ob;ulit (e in maricag urn con* 
 
 CcnWeraii. jungi fljallbc fntcnocD to tt)e OcfcnDsut Wmfclf , ano tlicn be mnft tiaros 
 
 on. ' batoc notice of bcrcoiufngtbftbcr. Dvesof Counfel loftb tbc S?cfcnoatit 
 
 tool? tWs CiccpKon , tl)at tbc piaf nt jf hi fctt<ng fojtb b^c offer of matiagc 
 Dotb not fap tunc tt ibidem, foe tbcrc (0 ncftbcr plate noj time fct fo;tb» 
 Roll chiet luftice anffcocrcD , ftisaftera tacrDjct, anopoumotjetbfBCE):- 
 
 Advjntsgc. ceptfon too late, anopou bate note lott tbe aotiantage of taljtng <t. 3f 
 tberelJcafuffic<cntnottce,it<atDcU ; <fnot,ft fgnot cooU; foj tbcrc ougbt 
 tobcanottce, fo>fl;eniapcomc toWsboufcfnpitbate, fo teat be cannot 
 
 J. ,. taUcnotkeofberco-nfngtbttbcr. SCbcqueftlononlpfa tb<0, tohetbct no« 
 
 *''"^'^' t<ce be fuffictcntlp ano neceffarflpfmplopcofntbctoojDsobtulitfcinmari- 
 taglura conjuni;i» Curia advilare vulc, Portca» 
 
 King'againft Weeden. 
 
 Pafch. 1(551, Banc, fup, 
 
 Arrcftof 1-^ arteft of 3l«ogcmcnt upott a tHctuftt foyno foj tbe piainUi in an 
 
 lu'ripcmcnt in ' action upon tbe Cafe upon an Affumpfit bjougbt bp an aominifttatoj. , z 
 
 an A<r<ioniip-Crccptfons iDitctaUcn, i,2Lbattbcpiafntff aionotfljctobfs iletters of 
 
 onthcCa/c. aomiiiittration , ano jlp. SLbat tbcrc <0 no gooDconfioetation fct fojtb to 
 
 Srounc tbe AfTumpfu upon: fojlttatbat tbe ffi)cfenDant oio pjomife , tbat 
 
 if tbcpia(nt(ftooulDfo;beartotahcb<0courfc foj tbe monies, be-teoalo 
 
 pap tbcm , toMcb luo;t0 arc uncertain , ann be fljoulo bate faio bis courfe 
 
 <n ilaus ano rotgcncraUpbtacotirfe. Rol! chief luftlcetotbe i anftoereo, 
 
 3!t is not neccllarp bcrc to fljcU) tbe llctters.of acmfniftration, foj tbcp arc 
 
 but inauccmcnts to tbe actior, ano not tbe grouno of it ; ano f o j tb: fecontt 
 
 Confidcra- ctcf ptton tbc conCocratton is ccrtainlp cnougb fct f o;tb . altbougb tbe %ti- 
 
 tion. tine be not terp pjoper. Therefore let the Plaintil' have his Judgement, nifi, 
 
 &:c. 
 
 Sawyer again ft ^u^e\. 
 
 Pafc, i65i,Banc. fup. 
 
 Ar..n of C Awyer bjougbt an action upon the cafe agafnft RufTel , foj tafeing attap 
 
 lu.ipmciitii ^certain CTattcl, anoobtainco a Clcroict againll tbe JDcfcnoant; SDbe 
 
 anjAitcnui- jPcfcnDaiit motcD in arrctt of 3uDgcment , ano took crccption to tbe 
 
 ouihcCafe. pafntife JDcclaration foj tbeinccrtaintp tbcrcof. SCbe pafntif DeclarcD 
 
 of aSLrotir anOConterKon , de ducencis Avcriis, viz bobus, juvencis, Ans 
 
 j;!ice >tcer!, luvencis, AngliceJRunrs, & luvencis, Anglicc Heifers, tobicb ti 
 
 uncertain , anD fo luogcment cannot be giuen, f o j it is uncertain foj tx)bat 
 
 number of cacb of tbe fetccrs, Knnts, ant) Inciters juogement OjouId be gf- 
 
 Avcrnient. ''•''cn Roll chief luftice cncllneD tbat ft fs certain cnougb, anD tbat tbc 
 
 number map be atcrrcD, anO tbe Cattel arc aU of one feinb; yet, The 
 
 Ccurt w/guld advife , afterward ic was ruled, ludicium, nifi» 
 
 Shedlock
 
 Pa fcK. 165 1 •. A6^. 
 
 5hedlcck and La. F ecA F 
 
 Pafct i6ji3anc. fup, 
 ■ Hill* 1650- roc. 1! I. 
 
 Ji^ a rairtt of C-rroj bjougljt to rctjcrfc a Kf'Ogciucnt attjcn in an fnfcrfoj ^^/rf^Vludt- 
 Court , STlje (£rro? afslgnco toais, tfjat tfee B»iiD£cnicr.t to quod recope- n,cnt in aa 
 rare debeaf, tnljErcas f t oagbt to bc recuperarc debet. Ko!l chiet" ludice intcilor 
 
 fappofetl)a3lat)gement, fo^tftcteojueofUare fi judicium redditum fit , Ab,"f„,jn, 
 
 anDfns- lacobifn tfte (EFcUcqucr Cftaiiibct tfje tjcrp cafe teas aojuDgco 
 
 fo. 
 
 rare ucucac, liiynt-aio II wns''>- »« ^ iv..u^/i.iai ^ uvl^vl. --^<i. vi..vi jMnitt m^tn 
 
 anfiDercD,2Cl)atffitbcfo,t&erc{i5no 3!Kt>P'n«»itgffecH,ano fo no ^ritc-urt 
 
 of CErtOj ifC0, therefore kt the writ be abated. jFoj t!)E uXlxit of Ctroj ^"'^^^^^ 
 
 Collins againft Sillye. 
 
 Pafc. 16 J I Bancfuj). 
 Hill. idjOj rot. joit 
 
 Ti^c Cafe tDaflt%f3,lLeffttfoi pears bp fnuctifurc cotjcnanfa toftb fl^e^'^'"""" 
 3Lcffo?,tbatl)cU)flliiotar5fgnot)crtl)clanDlct, noj anp parttbetcof,"^P°^'J),"er 
 tDlt1)out tbe wnfcnt of tijc Heffo j. JEftD JLcffoj Dtirfng tlje term cntera Into itc /or°yearsI 
 part of tftc lantJ let, tbc lieffec.afsfgno otier tlJC tcmafnoct of bfs term in tfte 
 reft of tbe lanD, totbout tlje confcnt of tbe Icffo;, anD t^c ILelTo j t'ocreapon 
 l3?f ngs an 0£t<ott of Cotjcrant agafnft tl^e BLcffee ; tbcqtiettfon Ua5iDlje= 
 tbEt ft DID Ipc ftt regaro tbat tbe Leffoj bau cntteo fnto part of t^e laito. Roll Covenanr; 
 chief lufticeftelD tijat tte Cotcnant toac f ollatcral , snD tbcrefo^c it fa 
 IjjoUcn bptljcar0lgnmcnt,notlDftl)ttanD{ng tftc Leffojs cntrpfnfo part of 
 t^clanD. And the rule was judicium nifi. 
 
 • 
 
 Cuftodes againft Monger. 
 Pafc. I dj I. 
 
 Monger Uja0 cnufctctj foi fojgctng a pjefentraent to a 3iarp in a Court Exceptions 
 IjclD bcfojg Commffstoncrg of fcto: rs, agafnft Monger fo; catting of to ihc fctting 
 I o loaDs of fofl fnto tbc SLbamcs. Cjxcptiona toere tafecn tbat ft ootl) not '°"'' "^ * ?-'- 
 appear bp tftc enofrtmcnt, bp ioftat aiit&o?f tp tbc Court laas belo, iobere tftc ^^'"'^="^' 
 p^efcntment tuaa fotuit). zip. Jtisnotaberceot^atttiepjefcntmento^o 
 pjcfenttljc calling in t'oc fofl to be anp annopance. 3lp. 2:!jec8 Dot^ not 
 appear to be anp pjocefs in tl;e cafe agatnft tbe partp upon tfte p;i£fcntmcnt, 
 SCotbefirttfttsaaanroiercDbpcounccllontbeotberfiQejtbatftid not nc^ 
 celTarp to Qjcto bp tobst autbojftp tbc Court toas bclD, fo j tbeic flutbojltp 
 ia bp 2ia of ^parliament , ano it is a pubUque act to be taUcn notice of.RolI 
 chief luflice anfloercD , Sl^at it is a p^bate SLA maoe fo^ tbe Citp of 
 London,anocon£ErncDtbcIojDipa{o;,tboug&partof ft be publique, fojsntutc 
 part of an 3ct map be pnblique, ano anotljerpartofft p;i!;atc,anDof tbat 
 part \rbicb ia pjibate toe are not bouno to take notice4 it toas Ucre fafo tbat 
 in criminal caufes , Crcojs in pj occeDfnga are not bclpco bp a bcroitt. Roll ^'°'*"* 
 cbiet luft.toobaii Cfccptlwi tbat tfte cnDictmciit iuas onlp contra paccm pub!, uoftii. 
 
 ^ ill toberc- indiamcm^
 
 .66 Pa(c. 1651^^ 
 
 jp^gag at tl)af tfmc tDl)cn ft toag pjcfcrtcD, ft oaetit to Ijatjc been contra 
 pacem nnper domini Regis & contra pacem publicam nunc. Adjourned, 
 
 23 Car in the Kings Bench, 
 
 Pafc, 1650, ror. 414, 
 
 Cremer / cPlantiff )• j> . • 
 Barnec \ < Avowant 5" 
 
 wi-.ttiier a '-»' ^c paftitiff complatrts foj tlie tafefng of Wa Catte'l , to irf t a ^ojfc, 
 ropyhoid e. | <r;olt,anB tl):cc i^atca, tftc >3 of lauuary, n Car. at Chingford ftl t^C 
 [inft by Ihc ^liountp of ElTex tn a tlofc tftcrc calico Pipers down. 
 
 Kinjs Ita'irvg 
 
 ic tor i;fc. ■T"!^c Dcfentant atotos the tabfiig of tfje Cattel in loco quo, &c. as lBaf« 
 Itff unto Thomas Boothbyc, aa Damage feafant fn tbc Clofc afo jefafD , 
 being tbc foil ant) ttc ftce^lo of ttic faio 1 homas Boochby. 
 
 Vpon the pleading, the cafe appeared to be as followeth, 
 
 K3InB Henry tfte 8. bcfiig fcffcD fn $k in tbe tfgbt of Ws CroUin fn tbe 
 maner of Chingford Comitis fntt)eCoiinipof ; Hex, of ttiftftb manont 
 a ccttafn tenement callctJ Lornnjers alias Heriots tcitb tl^c appurtenances, 
 tDhercoftftc faio Clofc calico pipers Down inafl parccll , tobfcl) tene- 
 ment ano Clofc toerc parcell of ti]c faio manour , ano teas tbcn , ann ftao 
 been tfmc out o£ mfno oemf feo , ano cemf fcablc in $tc bp Copp of Court 
 toll, of tbc fato manour,i)fD fauf Id a nelo melTuagc upon tfjc fato 2Ecnemcnt, 
 ano DfD afterlcaros bp hfs iletterfe patents, unDcrtfie great fcai ctant tbe 
 office of deeper , anDfecepfngoftlicfatDmefruage, to lohnGatCjtoj term 
 ofI)fclffc,U)ftf)^nthc l,3nD3, tenements, &.c.tf)cr£to belonging oj aoja- 
 cent , anO Dioalfo bptfte fame ILettcrs patents gibe anD grant unto tfte 
 fafD lohn Gate amongtt otl)er tl)fngs, tbe iianos belongfng to tfte fafo neto 
 buflt ttietTuage , tobcrcof tt)C faio Clofc calleo Pipers down tuas part, foj. 
 SCerm of bfs life, fo j tbe crercfGng of tbe faio officr,\Dftf) an ai/ctmcnt in tl)C 
 plea, tljat bcfoic tftat tfme tljcre teas no furl) office of tlje heepfng of tl)c faftt 
 fjoufc, ano tbat tbe tefng cfD not fenoto, no? teas at tfte time of tijc grant cn- 
 fo;meD,ttjat tl)c fafo SLenement anolLanOg tofjereof ttje faio Clofe tras par « 
 cell Ircrc CopptolD of tbe fatD manour.after tt)e grant maoc to John Gate, 
 asafoaefafD.H.tbeS.DpcD fcifcD of the fafo manour.i of t'.^e rcterfion of tlje 
 fafo £peffnagc ano Clofe after the oeatl^ of John Gate, ano tbercbp £d. the 
 6. became fcf 'ed oftljcm fn Iffec manner , ano from Ed. the 6, thcp came to 
 ©uanVarv. SChcn IobnG»te opes, ano after his Death, Ouan Mary en- 
 ters upon the fafo manonr ano Speffuagc tuhercof the fato Clofc irag a par- 
 ccll , ano aftcrtoarDs bp her iLetters patents unoer her fa?oaD &eal, Dotb 
 grant the £panoar ano rpcffuagc ano p^emifes unto Sufan Tong , ano hcc 
 ticfrs foj c\)er, i^rom Sufan Tongbp mean contepance, the faio ipaiiout 
 S^effaagc ano |Djemffes, came to Humphry White ano h's hefrs, ano after- 
 terUjaros Humphrey White bcfng fcf jeD thereof fn ^k, ofo bp his inocnture 
 ofleafeoemffcthcfaiQC^anourS^efruagcano pjcmffcs to Leigh fo.:i5o, 
 pears, to begin from Mich.,befo2e the mafting of the fnocnture , eftcroara 
 Humphrey White grants ainap the rcbcrCon of the fafo cpanour ^effaagc % 
 pjcmifes to Sir John Branch, aftertoarOS Sir John Branch grants this 
 rct)erlion to Vdall,VdallgrantsfttoBathur(t, ana Bathurft grants ft to 
 Thoraai Boothby the 0nteCoj of Thoraa* Boothby, tohofc JSaflp Ooth here 
 
 mab8
 
 Pafch.i^5t» 2.67 
 
 make tfte aDolDjp. jaiftctteatDs Robert Leigh infjo fjan t^c Icafe of tge ~~ 
 fa(D ^anout ano p jcmffcs as afo?rfato. fox 60 pcaro, DcWfct^ tlje refinne 
 oftWsleafctftenunejpfrct), bpbtslBft^tllann SDcflamcnt unto Robert 
 Leigh ftis §&oti, ano Dpc0,Robcrt Lee tl)e fon being poffelTcD of tbe tcfioue, 0^ 
 remafnccr of tWo JEerm foj 60. pcar0,bp tfttue of tbc fafo QOfll dJd at bts 
 court, belD fo J tbc faio jpanont of Chingford, grant the fafo ^effuage inftft 
 tfte appartcnancea, ano ilanDs tljcrctmto belonging, toftr rcof tljc fato Clofe 
 teas parceU, onto Edmund 1 ee Wo bjotbcr, to tjolD of tbc fame ^anour in 
 iFee, at tfte tof 11 of tfte JLojo bp Copp of Court HoU of tbat spanour , Ed. 
 round Lee teas thereupon aomfttco atcojpfnglp. flffcrU)arD0tl)e!"afij leafe 
 fOJdo, pears maoebp Humphrey White unto Robert Leigh, tftci^aitbct, 
 Bppttes: 0ftctti)arl)s Thomas Boothby,tot)o ban ttjcretcrCon of tbe faio 
 ^anoaranopjemffesasabolJeOlo, cntrcoasfn bis rebcrlion upon tbe 
 raiD^anouranDpjEmifcs.anoDpcDfeifcD tbercof, leading iffucThoraai 
 Boothby^is &on, Thomas Boothby tl)e&on enters into tbe faio ^anont 
 ano pjemifes , ann claims tlje faio ^cffuagc toitb tbc apartcnanccs toitl) 
 tbe lanos tbcreunto belonging, tobctcof tbc Clofc calico Pipers down traa 
 parccll, (finotoasgranteo bp Robert Leigh unto Edmund Leigh bp dopp 
 of Court HoU as afo^efaiD jas parcell of tbe cemaines of tt)e faio ^anour 
 of Chingford, ano Dotb Denp it to bc Coppbolo , ano to ttie intent to ttp 
 tt>etitletbcrcof,Diobpt&c2ibotoantbi3)i5ailffFDittrcin tftc Cattel in ttie 
 faio Clofe, as Damage feafant in bis foil ano irrcebolD. 
 
 SCftiS Cafe teas argncO firttbp Arthur Harris of Lincolnes Idn,tD|>o at- 
 gucD fojtbc plaintiff, viz. be tbatbjougbt tlje repletifn, anD in bis argu^ 
 ment , ^emaoet^egeneraBqueftionintbcCafe tobetobctber tbe clofc 
 callcB Pipers Down in tobitbtbe Diffrefs toas taften, tocre attljc time of tbc 
 BittrefBtabenBcmifcablebpCoppofCourtlRoHjOjtDbetber tbe Cuftom 
 ioas not beSropcD ,ani> be belo it tsas Demifcable, ano tbat tbecuifom tnas 
 not oeSropco, ano betetiponi be maoe four queSions. i. Mbetber 
 t^e grant of tbenetobonfeto &x, John Gate per nomen officii of bccpcc 
 tbeteoftocreagooogrant. 2lp. tSClbetber the iftfng not being enfcjmeo 
 at tbe time oftbc grant, tbat tbebonfetDasCoppbolo tenure, be tnasnot 
 oeceitjeo in bis grant. 3 Ip. ©Hbctber bp tbis grant tbc Cuff om tuas not 
 oettropcD. 4lp- Mbctbet tbe JSings patentee ftatb not the fame pjtbilegc 
 to grant tbis bouie, &c. again bp Copp ofConrtlRoU after tbc oeatb of 
 &r. lohn Gate, 0nD as to tbe i* of tbefe 4. qucttions , be 
 (iteO 8 £.4. by Chock, and 21 E« 4. 79, and Mich. 5 Car. Banc. Reg. Mon- 
 ibns cafe, and Pafc. 14 Car. Banc. Reg. Mefland and Burterfields CafC, and 
 5 Er4.f. 8. and Dyer 269. Savages CafC. SCofbc 2d. qneftionbcbel9,tbat 
 tbcfcingteasnotbcreenfojmcDofbistigbt , anoconfcqucntlpbclDasDc- 
 ceibeo, anotbcrofo^eougbtnottobcpjejuniccDbp bis grant, tobicb bs 
 fitoulo be if be bao not libertp to oemife tbis bonfe again bp Copp of Court 
 5R8l!, after tbe ocatb of &r. lohn Gate, ano be fain tbat tbctc arc ttoo rigbts 
 Intbeteing, njattbeCommonilato, anoilp. acuftomarptigbt, anoof 
 tbisCuttomarptigbtjOjbisjusconcedendi betDaanotenfojmetJ, ano be 
 cite D tbefe boo!?8,3 H. 7. 10. rep.49. 8 H.dijBr. Ayd 45 4,H.6.i<2R. 5. 
 Hunfoj)s Cafe, ano be faio tbat tbc boofe of 5 H. 7. f. i, tobfcb is obicctcD is 
 not to parpofc, foj tbc pjotcftation is not toeB taUen, 19 H. 6. g pjoteHati. 
 on is to fupplp a matter, inbtcb is not fo bcrc. 41 E. 3. Fitzh. proteft. 9. 22 
 H. 6. J7 Br. proteftation6. Plowd. Coraent, Gresbrool-isand Foxes Cafe, 
 and 20 Eliz. Burrell and Holcrofts Cafe* alp. 2Ebc liing is not enfo?mcD 
 fterc in bis grant in matter in ilatD. as be ougbt to br, ano tbcrcfojc ^ie 
 grantlbaU not turn to bispjcjuuicc, i repoi. 18 H. 8. Levels Cafe, 
 Pale. 2 Eliz. Sr.l homas Mores Cafe, I. rep. 1^3. 16. Jac. Needlerscafe; anO 
 Inbcreas it is faio tbat tbc trio^os ex certa fcientia in tbe patent 00 Declare 
 tbat tbe Jiing toas enfojmcD; 3 anfiDcr,tl)attbofc Sdojds co intenD no mo?c 
 
 ^ ni a but
 
 • 52 Pafch. 1651. 
 
 bnttbatt^ctefngtDaijcnfojmcD of matters of fad, ant) not of matters tn 
 
 Hato , ano tljc Bfn?3 grant fljall onlp be tahcn fecundum intcntioneTi ; antJ 
 to^crcasit map bcobjcctcD tl)at bp tlje gramfncoftbeCftatc fo^ifc iintn^r* 
 IohnGate,tbc ctittomtDDeftropeD,31 anftocr,tl)attW«bcfrtgtnt1jcCatc of 
 tljciifng,ftfi3ane):trao?DiiiarpCafc, anD not to be meafarciJ bp o^oinarp 
 rulC0Of\ato. ^no ilp, ilmtcntgrantoareto bcconftrucoas tl)c ?latu 
 tua0attI)attimcl»^entl)cptocrcmaDe,9. rep. 27.6. rep.48. 1 H. 7. aj» 
 14E. s.Fitzb.Scirefaciasas.anDtbci&tngtijnot bouno bp a general tu« 
 ftom ag Common pcrfon0 are, 3 5 H. 6. zp.bpPrifor, 22 Ed, 3, Cljcftfrtg 
 fljaU not pap a ftcrfot upon tbc ptircljafc of bcrfatablc llanOfl , anO toe lljall 
 fiiiD t^at manp majimec of Hato upon fcrfoiia fcannfng of tljcm, are not fo 
 certain tobcrclpction,astl)cparccommonlpl)eloto bz, y, rep. Knighti 
 Cafe, Pafc. 3 Eliz. B. R. Conisby andRisby,Dycr loEliz, anO t!)e patcn^ 
 tec of tbe ilitng f&nll bate tlic fame pjttflegc, tliat ttje ISfng Rjoiila batjc fjau 
 tf !jc Ijat) not grantco tljc ILettero patents , 27 Eliz- Stubs and Ri^fords cafe,; 
 3t anotljct Dap Arthur Harritfpahe again to tI;cpotnt, tljat tlje lifng fjao 
 nolcgaIl<ntenttoccftroptl)CvIDoppj)olo CCatc bp l)io patent, ano tt)cre- 
 fojc ft fijOUlD not be OettropeO, ano tttCO Grotiuj de jure belli et paci?, 345, 
 anottat no fucljtntEnt can appear fntljeluojCB of tl): patent , anDttfci> 7, 
 rep, Inglttields Cafe, and 17 E, 3.f, 19. and Cooks Inftitutet 373, and i» 
 rep, 4(5, and Plow. 33 3 , ano as to tfjc Inft point Ijc argneo , tlint tl)c |JKtcn« 
 tiz of tlje lifng, fljaU be in tfjc fame contt'tion, as to tlie retitfnc tf foe Co* 
 ppbolti(£ttatc,a0tl)Cfetngfl)otilDl)atJCbecntfl)cljaDnotmaDe tliC grant, 
 bccatifetbatt^ciSingftattitbeiFcc, ano be map grant ft as !)c pleafct^j, 
 Dyer 16 Eliz. 337, i, rep. 31. 10 Eliz. Dyer 7(6. 24 fd, 3. Fir?.. Tit. ginrd 
 27. anDnopjtojftpcahbcplcaOcDagafnfttfje iMng, no: ngafr.ft lb'3|93« 
 tcntce, Hi!/ . 30 Eliz. Stubs and Rightwayet Cafe, an Action of accompt a^ 
 gaJnft Crecntois Dotf) Ipc onlp fo; tbe lifng. St (s trnc that pjrrogntfties 
 toff parable, ano annc veo to tijc prrfon of tbc iijf ng, cannot be grnritco atoap 
 IptbclSfng, butpjerogatiticsfeparablcwapbc grantco alvap u H. 4,. 
 Fitzh. guard 8j. %\)z (Bjanteco! tfteCDjantec of t^c i^tnir fbal! hatie tl;c 
 pjerogatfbc of tfjc fctng, bp rcafon of tljc tl}lng grantco bp tfic Isfiig , Brook 
 piaerog.i7. »»H.7. 2, Br. entrecongcable4o. SClictoingmapDtffrefnfoj 
 arentfcch; butnotWodDjantce, bccattfe ft fs a pjerogatfl'e fpecutojp, 
 ano not crecntco, foj fn futljcnfc ft fs otljcrVoapcs ; ano as to tfte obfcrtton 
 tott)ccaurcoftbc Demurrer fetfo?tl),t!)attl]cConcefllt fs not anfircrco . 
 Ijccanfe ft onlp rapes mentionar. cfTe conceflum, 3 l)OlD ft VocU cnoug!) ; but 
 lfftff}OiilDnotbc,pctftf3!iclpcD,fojbotl)partpesoo agree fn the fcttfng 
 fojtb oftljE Hcttcrs patents, 34 Ehz.B R.t-. Hnrr and Smiths cnfc , anO tf)C 
 grant fs confcffcD fn our refopnoer , ano tljougb tbe Demurrer ftonlo not be 
 GOOD, pet tbc^^iolnant cannot t)aDc3uDgrmeut, fo? ftc ftatfj not cntftlco 
 tifmfclf to tfje aafon as appears bp bis grant , fo> ftfs grant fs toio, ano can* 
 not tahC effect, rep. 46. 8. rep. 301, 39 Eliz. in the Chequer Chamber. 
 Wilizxe a.jpanoars arc granteo bp tljc name of one of tbem,tbe grant fonot 
 B80D. ano fn our cafe Thomas Boothbvl)aDnot!:fngfnti)c lanoat tijetfme 
 cf makfng of ttc dccd of Cotjcnant to ttanD feffcD to ufcs ao ft appears bp 
 tftcaboitJantsotonplcaofng, anotbe ^o^a cannot liclp ft, D er m. 
 Clarkt Cafe, Hill.^"! 5 ^ac. entred Trin. 1 5 he. rot. 29. Defmont cafe, ;o H. 
 615, HaIesontl)cotl}ctCtCcargncDfojtl)c ^ai'otoaiit, ano pjapes a re'= 
 turnof the CattelDfOrcpncDi firlf, 6c put tljc Cafe at large, anofic fafo 
 that tt)t plflfntf ff hath not Inell fet fo?tl) the isings grant fn {;fo bar , aiio 
 foftfsaUone,asffftcl)aDnotfctftfoni)atal!,P!owd.5(53,anD!jcl)atl) Dff. 
 putcD tftat tcftfcb toe l!al)c not allegeo, anD tljc fur rcfopiioet fs but arc 
 gumentaft3c,ano not pofitfbc, ano notbtng appears to tbe Court, ano !)c fjatlj 
 qnfte mfftaUen \)is courfe ano toap, JSiit aomfttfng tlje cafc.anQ tl)cpofnts to 
 
 be
 
 Pafch.. 165 1. i^9 
 
 be 30 tf)Bp are mnDc,v!z. i. ©abetter the ncir£)fecc be tocll grantca.bfcatifc 
 tftc toojD Conftituimut fs omftteo. 2.C<iab-t^ct(!)c Brant fo; Iff c bc ecn^. j. 
 OTf)ctf)ct tljc grant of tlje Coppljolo fo? Ufc be a fufpenfioncftljeCoFi'ljolo 
 eftate,ojane);tfngu(Cbmcntof(t,UA(cb'(t5tbegrcat quESfcii in the Cafe, 
 iFojttjci pomt3bolDtbatberc<0aaooDBrantot"t!)jsnctD£)fficc, anu 
 that tfte too JD Conftituimui in not nccctfnrp , bctaufc that tijcre ate fpcttal 
 fas alfo nciDlp gtantco. ilj>, 2C!)ls is not an ©fficc in grofa, confinfna ar.o 
 r^ftlno upon ft felf ; but ft ia a telatfbc Office oi an iniplopmznt <i;ti3cnt ta 
 ti^cfntcrcftof tbeljoufcfiranteo, anntbercfojc t!)e teoio Conftnuimus is 
 nott)ercr.cccffari', Dycrioo- jlp. 3f ftbenotafo:m3l£>rficc, pctfeerc 
 <0 a socQ brant of an employment, toiib^cbarccoia-jrnrcmap be aDCOBj 
 altboucb an ^fsfje cannot be bjongljt (6% it. 3 AfT. Trm. e he Abercro- 
 mies Cafe : 0nD here tbe p jotellatfon that the iSfng teas not fnfo jmco tfjat 
 tbfs teas Copj/bolD lane (ij unncccffarilp allcaco , anotbcttfojcft is not of 
 necefoftg ft ftoiUn be anfitercn ; dno f f ft be not ioeU fet fo;tl) ft fs not mn« 
 terfal. iro j tbe 2 tjiiettfon lufjet&ct tbc i&fnc teas nctef ticQ f n lis grant , be 
 faiD tbat tbe iiifng neet>cD not to tai^c not fee of anp former cSate^, aiio tt;&t 
 tbe statute ejipjeCTctb, tljatftfsnotneccCfarp to mftc t}j£m, 34H. i(. 21. 
 SCO tbe 3 pofnt % ttje chief qucttfon, vuhEthct tbe CoppbolD eftatc be fufpcn:; 
 J)coo?.cj;ttnguffl»ea, bebeloittoaaertingntfljca, ano cftcD Knights tafc. 
 $ Alton woods cafe, ancfafo, thatthcrulcfloftbcCitiillato ought not to 
 be applpeo to the Cotnmon ilato , no j to be cftco to pcrptcr the pjocccafnga 
 thereof, ano tocre tbia in tbe cafe of a Common perfon , tcithout Donbt the 
 CoppholD tllate tooulD be DeftropeD, 20 Eliz. bp Pophsm ano Fenn , ann the 
 MnQ here b'lth tbe iFce fimple, ant) there fano DffTcrcncc bettocen the cafe 
 of the JSfng , ano of a Common perfon in this rcgaru ; a thing totiicb Itill not 
 pafabp tbe l^ingvJtbout notice^ Ml not pafa Vritb notice, ano here is no 
 pjcjnDtce to tbe fetng in not taUing notice tobctbctbp the |9atcnt ttc Cu« 
 Horn to grant CoppbolD eftates be Dcftropeu j not j ann here is a ncccffarp 
 conftqiientc in 3La\o, that the cuftom i<5 ccSropcti, bccaufe the iSing that 
 bautbefcc intbc£p3nojt]atbf«rpcnDeDtbe Coppholo bp Ijis grantf BU 
 the Srgnmcnts ufcD on ttjc other fioc arc to octlrop t^e ikings crnnt , ano 
 the cafes put 130 all Differ from out cafe, ansooftano upan their oton bot- 
 toms: jpoj^lballthcJSingbeintcnBeDtobemff connfantof his panfculat 
 grant, fuch as this is , although be map be in a general grant , Jib. AfT. 21. 
 pi. 19. Palch, 1 2 Car. C. B- Glover ano Edgars cafc, ant) it itoulD uc a great 
 mirtbieflftheCoppholo eftatc (houlD be rcti'ocD. Sis to th; lr.tt point, 
 tDliether the patentee IhflU be in tbefamccontitionas the btng toas, he 
 faio that it ia not mate rial tobethet he be oj no, as to the Cafe inqucftioir, 
 anb reftco upon the ^ qucttion. 31 f the iliing bath frce.toarren in lano, ano 
 grants the lano, ano mentions not tbe toarrcn, pet the Vcarrcn paffctbbp 
 tbe grant •. auO hct» our Slfcotojp ftanos pro confcfTo , bccaufc tijc plains 
 tifbathmaDcnotitIr, grant of a J^anoipei: nomen maneriorum is a 
 gooo grant of the S^nno:, ano here fs a gooo grant, ano if not , pet it is bflp= 
 eobp tbe Statute of 3 &4Phil &Mar»C. 1. 1 H.7. f. 28. ano the Poflea 
 here refers not to the grant of t'rc Copp , ano here is no outtcr allegco , 
 ano if there be , there is Do of (tctQn , but it pafTetb an cttate fo; iDiU bctiiir eii 
 tbe parties. Roll chief lufticc , St luoulo be Dangerous to make the pa- 
 tent tjoio, bccaufe the ISfng took no notice of the Coprholo cCate, ano 
 this point is not fit to be atguco : fl thing not raatcriaUr allegco in pleaotrig 
 fsnotncccffartiptobeanflocreo, anoitisnotncccffarpto crentr fiich coa 
 i©f6cc as this is , fojit ia but an cmplopmcnt. Che great queffion is , 
 tDbetbcr after the oeatbof&r.Iohn Gate, the Coprholo eftatc can bercW- 
 teo oj not in the cafe of tbe iSing. 3t map be Dangerous irhettier it be one 
 Iwp, oj tbe ctljcr, jfls to tbe plcaoing toe teill not maUc it ill , if it map be 
 
 ^m 3 gccof.
 
 i-yo Pafch. 1651 
 
 gOOBi Argue the great point again,for it is a difficult poinf,5nd of great confct 
 
 juencc. lerraanIufticctotl)cfamccffc(t , anucmUneo, tbatttic lafngljatt 
 
 .lotntcnttoDcCtropt^eCopplbolD, ano ^e t)cli> tbat tl^e £>ffice tnas toell 
 
 jfrantcD, bccaiifc tt tras but an (mplopmcnt. Nicholas lufticc (ncUncD, 
 
 :t)at tftc vEoppljolo luaa ocftropco. 0t another nap Wadham Windham at. 
 
 CacD fo; tl)c jDlafnttf ; anD fitft be put t^c cafe at large , am tben fafo, tljat 
 
 5 . 3!t appears bp tbc tcpUcatfou tftat the atiotoant Ijatb no title, a.fec confcf* 
 
 fctbtljattljciaialnttfbatbaSCmc, ©ucen Mary fctfcD of tljc ^anoj of 
 
 ChingfordCoraitis, tobereof Pipers Down tc parcel, grants ft per nomen 
 
 duorum illorum maneriorum, anD ft f0 not atcctcD tt)at llje bao tU)0 ^ano;t0. 
 
 jTfttt, ft is conCoetablc, tobctljct tljc fDatent be gooD bp tljc Common llato, 
 
 alp. ^SHbctbcr, f f not, pet ft be mace gooD bp ttjc statute of H, 8» ann be 
 
 ftclD, i.SEbatfttanot gooD at tbe Common 31 aic, bccaufcft fs fntcrtafti, 
 
 anD toantafuf fief entlDO^Bs, anoberefsan appatent falGtp, fo:t be batb 
 
 tiro ^aiio:tg, anti be grants but one; ana fftbc iSIng batic ttoo i^anoja, 
 
 ano grant tbcm per noraen Manerli , tbffl fs not a gooD grant ; Sia tithes be* 
 
 longf ng to a lUcctojp cannot pafs bp the name of a portion of tf tbes, nettbec 
 
 DO all tl)c Statutes of Confirmation of patents, confirm lefs o> greatet 
 
 talucs grantcD , tbanarc comp?ifeDfntbe3Letter0|9atcnts, 41 Eiiz, Pa- 
 
 fons cafe fn the ©iccbcqucr. pjcfcntatlon to a IRertojp tobete ft ongbt to 
 
 bcadMedietateoiRedorixfsnota gooD p^efcntatfon , 9 rep. Dodingtons 
 
 Cafe, Dyer ; 31. 0n iU grant fs not bclpeD bp tbe Statute, becanfe ft ia 
 
 not namcD. zip. 3 falfc fuggcttionfs not bclpeD bp tbe Statute of 34 H.8. 
 
 3 Car. &fi Hatton Farmers cafc, anD fn out cafe bcre is a mfftaUc of a tbfng, 
 
 anD not of tbe name , fo? ft fs a ^anoj fo:; i^ano;ts , anD fo tbere fs no true 
 
 meaning, anD tbcrefojc ft cannot be belpeo bp tbe fetatute, Pafch. 1 lac, 
 
 rot. 2 1 6. C. B. Dawfon againft Pickei ing, SCbc ^uctn txas fcf fcD of ttoo 
 
 jpanc?0,viz. ofRufhwortb,anDof Dale, anD gtantcD tbe S^anoi of Ru(h«' 
 
 worth, habendum tbe^anoj Of Rufhworth,toitbtbci|)anoj of Dale , afttt 
 
 ft teas belD an ill grant at tbe Common Hals, anonotb^lpcD bp tbe &ta« 
 
 tutc. J5nt it Is obiccteD tbat tbis Spano j map be Unoiun bp tbe name of tiro 
 
 £^anojs , anD fo in our cafe , altbougb tbe i^lng toas fclfeD of one ^ano:^ , 
 
 anD gtantcD tbfs S^anoi habendum per nomen duornm Maneriorum , this (0 
 
 gooD, Mich. 2z H. 6. p!. i6.f. 13, 2to tbis tbe anf tocr is, that ft cannot 
 
 be pieaDeD per nomen iDitbout an atcrment tbat there arc ttoo ^ano}s, a 
 
 Ed.4.f iS.tbelafttafe: 2[:i)eref0 a Difference betineen a fcofment anoa 
 
 relcafc, afeofmcntmapbcplcaDCDpemomentDitbout anabcrmcnt; but 
 
 arclcafecannotbcfoplcaDcD, foj In a fcofment tl)elibcrpopefatec to paf0 
 
 tbelano, 22 H. 6. Hill. f. ^p.pl. 9. 13. anD Dyer, tbe feerfcants Cafe; 
 
 luheretbcreisccrtalntptberenccDsnoaticrmcnt •, butitfsnot fo fn our 
 
 Cafc I H. 7. f. 28. anD It Is a fojcin Intcnomcnt to fuppofe tbat one i|)ano j 
 
 ofChingtordCoraitistballbeUnoiDnbptbc name of tbe ttoo ^anojs of 
 
 Chingford Comitis , anD toe nccDnot plcaobp a nonconccflit, becaufc tbe 
 
 Sfeovtant batb maoe no title , ano fo be can baDe no return , t H, 7. f. 28» 
 
 (5 H 7. t. 6. anD bcre is no ccrtalntp aoocD to maUc it certain bp tbe too jbs 
 
 illorum quod nuptrperquifivimusde,&c. 2Eo the fecottD point , StbC 0« 
 
 tolr-Ttnt batb confcffcD tbe paintlfs t(tlr,fo j be batb confcITeD, tbat te. H. tbe 
 8tb. batb maDe it a CoppbolD , auD If the Copp be gooo, our title Is gooD, 
 astotbenuefifon, tobctbcr toljen a CoppbolD comes to tbe Jfiing, ano be 
 IcafEtb It , this Dotb Rot fo Deftrop tbe CoprbolD , that tobcn tbe leafe fs out 
 ItmapnotfaeCopp^olDagaln. 3bolD, that if a Common petfon leafe a 
 CoppijolD , the CoppbolB is DeCropco ; but It Is not fo tobcre tbe iSIng lca« 
 fctliit, as It loin out cafc, tohtchougbtnottobe meafutcD bp tfas Com» 
 mon rule of 3Lato , foj tbe ilato of tbe Croton oijet-rules tbe Common 
 iLato,anDtbe £.atoofCullom, 22 E. ^^%\)z l^inglsnotbonnDbpCufloni
 
 Pale. 1651. z7 
 
 a0 a common pcrfon f a , 3 5 H. <5. Sbfjc litng ftatjing (Satclftfno iniioo maj? 
 DEftroptljc\Iuftomijjl)lcl)tt!n0U.itU fuel) lanofl pro tempore oti'p, an3 tljs 
 ISfngc grant fljall not enure to a fecoRDarpopsratton, as Knights cafe fa $ 
 anDftetei3nop:c)u2icetoanp pctfon t^at tbs CoppfeolD rCatc ftotilD be 
 rctiteo , bcre tlje conrcoucnce map be re'oercc, ano it is not neceffarp; ano 
 tbercfojctftcleafeof tlcCoppbolD, nctnamir;sit€opp^oi?,is goo5, 33 
 to tl)e £)bjc£tton mncc , tljatttionobcntettotlje Uinq, to matcit <£opp- 
 ftoio again; t5)canriDcrf3, OattttsapjeiuoicctotascaUiapamans pjf= 
 tilegeanoltbcrtp, ifti'cvetcerenocttjcr fnconticnicricc; biit'ijcvciamojc, 
 fojtfteremapbe pjcjactcc bp lofing tbs Ccmmcu, ?c, i^notijc rule, that 
 aCuftcmfflancntiretbtng ano cannot be cppojtfoneo, Ojall notbinotbe 
 5ajng, altf:onnlj<t 00 bino common pcrfcne, eno tbc Statute niskca not 
 tbc arnnt gcD as to tbe rctserCon. SCfcc Ccpp'jcio fa ccmifco, anu pet fliali 
 beccmfrablet)ereaftcr,anDfoit mapbcplcaoco, fo? pleasing follotoa tbc 
 BlatD: SlCuttomfntctruptcDintl)crfKt)tfcgoncfojcticr; but if it be fn- 
 tcrruptco but in part , ft ia not fo,a6 ft is fn tljc cafe cftcD , iBlj.re tlje ims 
 i)atf) CJabclbfnQ lanes, Com. Plovvd, 114. ano fopjaps movement Co; tbc 
 ^laintff. Adjourned. Larch at another cap argucD fo j tir.e ^totoant , sno 
 fafo, tl)at tlje ipiafntif in MsrcfopnDcr ftntl) maQc no title unto Sufan Tong , 
 from tebom f)c claims. %i is objecteo, tl,at bp tbc grant of tfte fla^no; of 
 Chingiord Comicis p:r nomen duorum iliorum maneriorucn , &c. tbat Tong 
 cannot be fntitulco. 3t fs anftoerco tbat tte otber fiuc batb confcBfeo , tbat 
 Tong b?.tb a title , fo j tbsp ucrfl-'e from ber alfo , ant) tbe tciitrarp ootb not 
 appear to tbc Court , ano it being agrccD, tbe Court tciU not make a Doubt 
 of ft. f^emaoc^^Jueflfons, i.^5Hbctbertbe(pano: ofChingfordComU 
 cis patfctb per nomen duorum iliorum maneriorum de, &c. ilp. SObetbcr ff 
 tbegrantbeillftbcaiccDbp Statute, jlp. CCIbctbcr it be bclpcB bp tbe 
 Sterment. JToj tbe i. be belD , tbat bcre fs a gooD grant , ioitbout anp a« 
 Ijetmcnt j afo of tbc Statute; fo j if tbe liing grants tico C^im^s one &all 
 jpaffl , ano e converro,it Q]aU not be fo in tbe Cafe of tbe l5ing , but it fs gcctt 
 in tbe cafe of a Common pcrfon iiitf) an flbermcnt. 'jLj^t grant of tbe £pa. 
 no? of Saperton cum Ripptn fs an til grant foj tbc fnccrtafntp of ft ; but berc 
 is no fucbfncertafntp.berc fo no nf^n noCocr of tbc tbfitg,fo?. tbc irojo nomina 
 requires not a pjoper name ; but it is all one , as if it bao been crpjeffcD bp 
 iDojDs compjcbrncing ft , ano tbc trojo j^anojs 8otb compjcbeno ft, 3Cf 
 tbc tefng grant bfs ttoo acres of ilano Ipfng fn a Common fielo , altbougb 
 but one acre fs to be founo, pet tbc grant fsgooo, ano it is not like to tbe 
 grant ofafpanojiiit'gtbcflototofon, Vibcrctbc!iing batb but a mopctp 
 of tbc aotioto^on , oj a mopetp of tbc S^anoi , fo: tbcipjpetp is not actual 
 in tbe Icbolc , but one fa actiialip in tioo , anufo ft fs toclt nanieo bcrc, zip. 
 ^betbcr ft be gooD , loitbout an alicrment tbat tbelano Uiao fn tbc JLoia 
 Darcv, anObebelDftlDas. Jftbc toe;C3ircregfneralint!;cgrant,al!oC 
 tbem ougbt to be trur, otberluffe notbing tefll paffe bp tbc grant, as Dedmg:: 
 tons cafe is ; but bcre fs n pjoper name to erp?cfs ft,ano tbcrefoie tbc grant 
 is not ocflroT'eD , altbouab tbc latter Dcfcriptfon Co not agree to ft, lo.Rep^ 
 Harpes Cafr.z H.4.' 2,3f tbe iSfng grant all tbc lanDs fn tbc^atcnt anner= 
 £D,bcaring oate in of lune, tbougb t!;c patent bear Date tlic lo of Iuly,pct fa 
 tbc grant gooD ; fojveritajnominis to'ilit errorem demonftrationis ; anO if 
 tbc grant Iboulo not be gooD at tbc Common JLali), pet it fs apoeo bp tbc 
 Statute of 3 & 4 Phil. & Mar. ana here fs a fuB ana a flroug atjcrment fn 
 tbeplcnoing, foifffsManeriiimprxJid-um, anDnot Manerium gencmllp, 
 ano bcrc tsnotonlpapofsfbflftp, but alfo a facilitp foiittopafs, ano ft 
 map be callca jp.ino;, oj J^anoic : ano fn a fcofmcnt a tbtng map paf^ per 
 nomen, bccaulctbattbclftKrppatTctbft , U)bereo;jcp'caD3 per nomen be 
 is to maUc tbc Jplca a£rcc tof tb tbc Hccojo j fpctfaltp , otbcrioifc per no. 
 
 meo
 
 272. 
 
 Pafch. 1651. 
 
 raenlfiaUnotbcpleaDCD, anu Neu-tons cpfnf on ngafnff tbta f0 but a Gttgle. 
 optnfoiT, 3 3 H. 8, Br. Averment 42. 2H)C iDo jD pracdid. matics an atjcrmcnt 
 tntl)cnamcoft6eiFcoffo}, 24 H. 4. 30, 22, H, 6.40. Barton ano Efcott, 
 (J ijcrc <0 alfo a full at)crmcrtt of tb; thing grantcD , « tl)ta is fn grants , 7 E. 
 4.'24.3 3H.6f. 22, i6Aff.2. 24 Aff.d.fo in BLctters patents, Dyer £d.tl)e 
 Serjcantfltafc, anofftWsbcantljojftpftfijfrttljc ttcrp point, Dyer207«. 
 prardid.p'-rnominaisagooDaDiJrmcilt, Palch.y. lac. Rot, 450. B, rc^^ 
 Stonehoule ano Reeds cafc , toftcrc tftcrc toag not fo muci) as a per nomina , 
 bntonlpdeciraasprxdiftanDpetaDiuiigED to l)c a gooD fntUUng, bj,' t^e 
 tDo?tj prcedid, bEtatifc it Ipas liClD a gooo aVierment , altbotiglj it toas not 
 IcD en bp a per nomina , anD tljcrc aBmittcD to be dear if it ban been to(tt) a 
 per nomina, as tftc Cafe Ijcrc io,« fo long is IdcU intitlcD. 2!p. s:fje pain* 
 tifs title istocll atoiccD, anu toe bafc tocU DcftropeD Ijis Copp ; Uiitbout 
 coubttfa Common pctfon bio 5tanteDtl}C Coppbolo foj life, tbe Copp« 
 bolD bat) been tbstcbp ejtinguflbcQ , anc our cafe is not a pjerogatitjecare, 
 foj tbe ^ing to bonno bp tbe Ctiftom cf tbc f^ano; , ana ti;c Cnftom is 
 berecfftropcD, ano tbepjerogatite cannot create tbe Cuflom ancto, ano 
 it is agniift tbc !Sing3 Ipjcrcgatitc to bate tbings ojaton out of tbe 
 l^irg ."teitbont matter of IRccojd ; ano it is pjcjuDice to tbe toing to 
 ftate tbe Cuftom rct!it?cD , fo;t tbe lanus are note mace free, ano 
 fliall netjcr return again to tbc tHlaffalagc. SDbe teings p?crogatibe 
 cralts bim abot»c a Common pcrfon, bnttbiscuttom mabes bim equal 
 toa common perfon, alp. SCbeCuttombere cannot be fuppojtcoj batbcrc 
 Is an abfolutc CTttngmlbmcnt of tbcCoppbolD,fo tbat it cannot be regran- 
 tcD. SCbelaiotoiUccnfirmtUngsncceffarpto tbe grant of tbc !aing in 
 fome cafes tobere it igp:ctuiDicfnl tothc Ijtng, id H. 7. f. 8. NichoJascafe 
 p)owd.489.2EbebingfcircDofnooiiatit3cmaUc0itpjefcntatitie, if be do 
 tut once p?ercnt unto it, fo if be turn an annuitp into a rent cbargc bp ta* 
 feing a oittrcfs : 9nt> tbc nntiire of tbi^ Cuftom bcrc ouebt not to be cramf - 
 neotoitb otbcr Cuftnms , fo; it is mo jc flrict tban in otbcr cafes, foj if it be 
 oncctJtftropeD, itisaltoapsosffropro, ano cannot be fufpenoco, ant)iti« 
 notfojtbeJSing0Dif=ai5tantanctobat)etbe Coppboiu ocflropcD; but it is 
 fo; bis aoiiantagc ana cont?cnicncp , ann fo be pjaps luogement foj tbc 
 fltotpant. Roll chief luRite. SJUtoill come anD reft upon tbe laC point, 
 to; all tbe otbet tbi"gs are aBmittea : SLbe grant is gooD bp tbc per nomen , 
 anD it is onlp nominal, ano ootb not implp tbat tberc are ttooipanojs, 
 nnD it map Itar.D tocll cnoucb feitb rcafon tbat it map be hnotorr per nomen: 
 SEuttbclaCtpcinticconfiOErablCj bccr.clineDtoLatcb. Nicholas lufticeto 
 tbe fame effect, anD tbat ttepraedift is a gooo afcermcnt. sCbe latt point 
 is confiDcrcblf , but prima facie, bcre tbe cultom is not DclIropcD. Ask luftice 
 to tbc fame effect, ana tbat ft appears tb3t tbc iSingintenDeo to grant but 
 oncJSanoj. Roll, tiaeteilltahc time till tbe nert term to fpcait to tbc 
 lalir point, tobiebisonlpDoubtfull, anD to orliber our opinions. lerman 
 luflic, tbe plcncing of tbc partp per nomer.bclps not tbc patent, if it be not 
 cooD in it fclf, Sbc nert SEerm Rnll chief luif ice fo; bimfclf ano tbe reft 
 oftbc3«Dgc0, tei,o be faiD concurr'D in opinion toitb bim, DciifccrcDtb: opi- 
 nion of tbc Court to tbis cfFcct, i. SCbat tbcp lucre agrecD tbat tbe grant 
 oftbci!D(ficsoftbcCuftoDpoftbcbourcisa gooD Icafc fo; life, nottaitb- 
 ftanoing it tuas Copi'bolD, r.no it is not nccclltirp to recite in tl3C grant tbat 
 iticCoppbolD. 2. SEbat after tbc fftatcfo; life is DctermincD , tbc iSing 
 mapgrnrt tbe boufc ant) lano again bpCopp of Court Koll,bccaufc tbe 
 ^ings grants flaall be tal^cn fa'ooureblp, anD not crtcnocD to tlDO indents , 
 Itberc tberc is no ncccfsitp fo; it, as tberc is not bcrc, ano toe are not 
 berc to intcnn a collateral intent, ano fo tl)c CoppbolD is not oellropcO; foj 
 tbc Jiato twacs cars to pjcfcrtc tbc tnberltai:cc of tbe IHtng fo; bis ^urcef- 
 
 fo;0,
 
 __ Parch.i65u 275 
 
 fojs , auiD ft map be a benefit f t^e Bf ng to ftntip ft conf fntie Copp^olu, vizi^ 
 to ^a%c Common , ^c, aiie bia electf on f s alfo DcCtopcD , f f ^c map not ftat« 
 ft CoppllolO, So Iudg€incnt was given for the Plaintif, nifi, 
 
 Pawfey and Lowdall. 
 
 Pafc,i65i.Banc, fup, 
 Pafc* 1650, rot, 275 ♦ 
 
 IjP tl)fs Cafcfojmcrlpargaeo, Roll chief Iuftice,anij Nicholas ano Aikjuj 
 iuftices actecD , tfjattfjeDctjffcoftfjc Coppftolo here fg a Dctjffc to t^jerov/rrr/upoa 
 ^ettsoft!)ci?atfter, ano fo a 5Fce Cmple , anb tljat tUc partp comco notafpeciai Vcr- 
 Jnasapurcfjarcr, ano fojtbiacaufct^juDgcmcnt teas rcijcrfcD, nifi, Sls'^^^ touching 
 totljeotljerpofnt , tDbettifttOcfuttcnoecof aCoppliolD bp a SCcnant fojr^"i!'^id°^ 
 life be jjcdd fn t^fo cafe , t^c Court ocUDcteo no opfnfon , Antea, iand[ ° 
 
 Trundall and Trowell. 
 
 Pafch; i<55i,Banc. fup. • 
 
 Hill, i(55o,roc. 670. 
 
 10 tU6 Cafe ft \saa ^lo tbot Cenant fn antf cnt IDcmefn cannot aftet fm< where ami. 
 parlance plcao antfent BDcmcfn, foj Ijc fjatlj niaoc a full Defence, foj "^ Dememe 
 %c taps Defendit vim etinjuriaraquando, &c, tofjfcf) fmplpcs all tl)e tCft /'""j^f j^' 
 Midr, 2 2 Car, Banc, Reg, Yet it was ruled to be again fpoken to, p ca c . 
 
 Peck againfl Ingram. 
 
 Pafch, 1 65 J. Banc, fup, 
 
 Tl^ Cafe fo?metlpfpoItenfn teas moijcDasafn, am Latch beJo , tftat whether* 
 tlje toojDfl obtulit fe in roaritagium conjungi, toac a gmo notfcc upon t^good notice' 
 Ubole matter , ano tljcrcfoje t^at tt)e action oto toell Ipe. Roil cbief luftice 
 anftDcrco, tftfs fs a perfonal tbfns , ano angJ)t to be offeree to tf)e partp 
 Wmfclf, ott)er1^)ffe ft is no notice , anotftat ootl) not appear ^cre, ano (f 
 tl)Erc ?'e no notfcc fmplpeo, tljcn ttjc 3aion Itc3 not; ano Holme? ano Twifts 
 tafe ifl , tW tbercousbt to be notice fftbe tbfng be to be oonc bp t^e partp 
 tfmfclf, otbcrtoffeffftbetofaeoonebpaffrangcr, fo f0 ft l)cr«; but tlie 
 queCfon onlp f^jff notice be fmplpcD bcre j not;> lerman lufticc fafo, t^etc 
 f0notenocTofmariaeciftlJcotlKrpar^pbcnott6ere. The rule was for ttie 
 Plaintif to take his ludgement, 
 
 Rooke againft Smith. 
 
 Pafch. 465 1, Banc, fup. 
 
 ROokebjottgbt an action upon flOccaCeagafntt Smith fo J fprakfiiG tfjcfe iJ]^^^'/^^ -^ 
 iDOjOa of bim , Thou arta poor fellow, and art not able to pay 2s, injn laTon'up? 
 the pound, and art not able to pay thy debts, <Hpon an BKTae fopneO, anO on xhe Cafe 
 a tJJcrofct foi tbe ^Slafntff , tbcSDcfcnoant motjco in ilrrcft of Slaogcmcnt.fot wqtds. 
 tbat tbe aiojDsarcnot actionable; foj 1. t|je Jplaintff fa not bp tbcra £l)argeD
 
 2,^4 Trin. 1651. 
 
 ^^it{5tlicctrnKBfbcfn^a!l5anUriipt, anu fo t!jrr: fs no partfcnlar loffc to 
 
 htm. ill'. 3t<onotQ)8lucDtl)atti)C pialnUff got l)f5 Itlnnct Op bu^'lns 
 anDfciUng, o;tl):itt)C<0fnDcbtcD, ano u. lac Brook and Clarktcafe', 
 luaadtcD. Twiidenontl)cotI)ctriocanriyctcD,t!)att!ic pafnttffe txctit 
 tcaBi:rpfilrcDbptl)c luojDs, miD bp bic crcoit Ws litdpIjooD i-s ia part 
 ntaintO'ilCD. 5lnDl)C£(ttti ViccaryailO Barnt cafe. Adjourned ro the next 
 Term. Wild aftcrtoarDo inoticD again fo: Jn^prment , bccniifc t!)c vtoioa 
 bc<r.2. fpoljtn of a tvaocfman, fjc coiicct't)?o ttjcin to be actionable. Msynard 
 on tl)c otftcr floe l)cl^ t'ocm not actionabJi ,6ccaufc t&crc ia no pfirtfwlar uac 
 macrc allcgcDto «rolDtctl)C piainti: bp fpcal-ing of tljcm,.inD bcr.iufc tbcre 
 (0 no crime objcctco againft tbc paintift; fo j pobertp is no crime ; but a 
 man map be poo; nm t;onctt at t!)c feme time , anc Ijc citcu ttoo tafcu to 
 ' b£ aDttiBscD, tl)at a particular Damage onrfjt to be nllcgeD. 0r.D (nh tbat 
 tl)cfc Sldions arc net fal-ourcD \a 3LatD , am tl)crcfo?c If tlic trojDo be not 
 tlccrlp Actionable, it tons not rcafon to maUe a fojccD coiiffruaion of tUm 
 to maUc tl)cm fo. jpcrt tfte plaintiff Ijntft not atcrrcD, tf)at Ijc tuaa able 
 top2paUi{3BcbtofojaUt!)Ctl)i!i?3bonefjt; fautonlp of a Debt contracted 
 bptbe buying of tfteS)pl mention cd. Twifdcn oenpco tlj: cafco put Vp 
 Ma^nard of tl)c particular Damage. anDbclD tijc laejiDs artionablc. Roll 
 chief ludice fafo , a man map be a llBanUrnpt , ano pet be Ijoncft, fo? be rtrag 
 
 Avcrmcnr. IjEcomefo bp accijcnt , anonotofpurpofcto Dcccibc bia creoitojs. Jlbut 
 ftcreiononeeo fojtbc plaintiff to fljeVo be ftao a particular loffe bp tlje 
 lro?D3,fo?iti0cnoijali tljat be isgencrallp fcanoalifcD bp tbcm, neither 
 ia it neceffarp foj bim to afaerr, tbat be toao able to pap all iis Debts 
 as Maynard l)att) allCgCD, Therefore let the Plaintiff have his ludgement 
 nifi. Antca. 
 
 Ow en againft Jc von. 
 
 Trin, 1 65 1. Banc. fup. 
 Pafc. 1651. rot, an. 
 
 O Wen bjongbt an Action of the cafe againC levon fo; fpraWng ffjcfe 
 trojBBOf hcr,viz. Thisisthe whore that my man Coweil bfgat aba- 
 Hard oh, and Iptnt all my mony upon, and the quf an hath heen tro long in 
 Towntomyeafe; tEipon an fffuc iopncD, anD a bcrDict fo; tlje plaintiff, 
 Twifdcn fo; thcSDcfcnDant in arrctt of guDgmcnt urgcD that the tDo;Cfl are 
 not actionable , bccaufe there is no fpecial lolle 0; Damage allcagco bp the 
 plaintiff hapning to her bp rcafcn of the lr.o;D04 fafD tliat in one Lighfooi 
 anD Picots cafe ft hacLisn rulcD that an ;action lies not fo; fapirc a ii omatt 
 haoa JEcCarD, anb he citCD alfo Winter anDBarnardscafe.Trin.i 5^0. in 
 this Court. Vpon thefe rcalons ludgreent was flayed till the other iidc fliould 
 move. 
 
 lay againft lay. 
 
 Trin, 1651, Banc, fup» 
 
 Trin, 1650. rot. 1350, 
 
 e'r" qr i^ifl cafe fojmctlp put ano fpofecn to , toas again fpolicn nnfo bp Latch, 
 ''"?■ I tohcrein be mase this qncftion, viz. tchether t'oe limitation to i. anD Ws 
 
 Arrcft.f 
 jutfs^cment in 
 
 wotils. 
 
 Aigoraent in 
 
 a fpccial ve 
 
 t);a touch _^ _ ^. ,^„„. .,, , , ■ - ,._ 
 
 iv.e '^"■'j''''=-\|^efrgtoeregooDo;not^ anoheheiDtttoaonotgooD;fo;bc faio that filc^ 
 word" of a limitation <n cafe of a ftcc^olo (0 tjo(o. ^z confcaeo mt in m cafe of Peil 
 wii. ano
 
 Tiin. 1651. 275 
 
 aiiD Brown 1 7 lac. ror. 44. tijc £0«trarp Uas aaiuDgefi ; but ttjat tfjcre Dfo 
 appear facfj apparent tncoimcnfciuc in it, t'qat upon it ttje vCoui t loao a f ter - 
 luarosottiocD, anozi lac. fntbcfecTteantacafetttoasmaoeaflatquas^e, 
 ano cbcr Once ftljatf) been Disputable, toljetbcr a contmBcru outife be gooo 
 oj not , ano in lacob ano Ttlimgs cafe ft (s not uetcrmincD , ano Hanbury 
 ano Cookrc 11$ cafe is not nojungcD ; but tf ft be, (t is on mp fioc, ano Mich* 
 ^7 & 38,0. B. roc. 1149. SltvijaoaajuDgrDuponfolcmiiarffument nttbe 
 31Bar,ant) on tSjc IBcncl) , cor.trarp to tl)? SuDpirt nt in Pell ano Browns cafe, 
 if lanos be Detitfco to one ano i^ie ][pc<ro , ano <f be ope toftbont tffuc , t.;at 
 tec lano fljall be to anotber, ano I)f5 ^dzs , tftts ii no CEftatc tafl ; fo jIt can= 
 not ttanDteitljtbcrulco of JLatD to De^tfcf ucb an CEftate, foz (t is but a 
 pofcibflftp, anoifftfljoulDbemojCjftmuftbca^Fccuponai^cc, anQ fo 
 apcrpctuit{?,anDitcannotbclinoU)nltiftljfnic{)3t bounostt fliall wio, ti- 
 tftcr tti cafe of pears, oj Ufc, 0% otftcr contingenttes , ano tftc comparifon of 
 Lamports cafc fs not Iffic to tl)to cafe, fo; t5)at inas of a SDcrm , but tW is 
 of a frceljolo , ano a contingent Dcbife of a frecbolD is not goou Once ttic 
 Statute of 3 2, H. 8. and Brook tif. devire, 2 Dyer, 28 H. 8.f. 37. isnotan 0* 
 pinion ag' fnft tbis 3nO thcugl) t!;rre coulo be fuel) a Dctifc of otljcr lanDS, 
 pet Coppgolo lanos cannot be fo Dctireo as tlje cafe is bere , fo? tfterc can- 
 not be To muc!) as a pofsibtlitp of tetcrter , foMbereisno cuffom to loar. 
 rantit,Hi!i, 5. Car. King and I.eyden in tftis Court, anD Dyer 1164, ano 
 H}Ougl)tl)crcmtgtjtbcarel?crtcr,pctbc cannot oebifc ft bp iuin , ano ifljc 
 coulD, pet tjere t^c con bcpance is maoe upbp furrenDer, abmittance , ano 
 6et)ifc,ant) tlje partp ie fjcre in bp tbc furrenocr, ano not bpttje DcDfff jano fo 
 fsa CoppljolDer in bp !Sia ejrecutco , ano not upon tijc contfngcmp, ano ttjc 
 tnfll is bat to Direct ; ano tljougl) all tijis be otftc rloilc, pet tl)C ^plaintiff can« 
 not l)a1)e SiuDgcmcnt , fo j it appears not tljat tlje furrentser is pjefcntcD at 
 anp Court at all, ano fjerc is nothing but a recitall fbmiD. lerman lufticc 
 faio bp tbc Common llaiu ttere ounf)t to be a pjefcntmcnt at tbc nert 
 Court. Roil chief luftice, anD Nicholas luniceSLljcrc is no certain time 
 fojtlicpjefentment; butitisaccojoingtotbeCuflomof the (pano> , fo 
 tljat it be toit, in tfte life of tlj; SCenant.RoIl chief Juftice f«iiD,it la an fnton« 
 tenfence to ocbffc fuel) a contingent Cftatc. Nicholas ooubtco, fo; i}Z faiu 
 ft iooulo djatse manp Itiills, if it mi gl)t not be, ano fo fato Hales. The Court 
 would advife. Hales confcCTeD tftc tjcrOftt toas fmpcrfcrt, but pjapeo ft 
 tnfgfjt be amcnoeo ; ilBut Latch anf toereo ft fs gooo enougft f ; us t^e JDc- 
 fenoants , fo; toe ftatjc p;imer poffcfston. SClje Court anfircrco ft troulD 
 be gooo to Ijabe ft amenoeo , ano not to bate a venire de novo, fo; tljat toiU yg^i^f 
 be cbargcablc ; but ff tbc tcrcfa be imperfect to b;ing tbe matter fn iLato 
 fnaqucftion,U)ecanBranta nctu venire, altbougb it bstb been beretofojc 
 D0ubte0» Tberefocc be advirt;d,fo that it may be argued« Antca^ 
 
 Heal againft Green. 
 
 Trin, 1 (Jj I. Banc. fup. 
 
 Hill. 16^9, rot, 370. 
 
 *T"^e cafc bcttocen Heal ano Green upon a fpecfal tcrofct (ojmfrlp ar-Arjument 
 
 ctuco bp Latch teas again fpoUento, anoargneobp Twifden, ano bCT""^ '^P"'- 
 I>elD~tbat tbe iFcme bao potocr bp tbe ^fll to mabc tbe lcafc,nottoftbCanD=='' "''^'^ ''P- 
 fngtbatC)cbatbbutanC-Catcfo;lffe, ano cftco n Car. Br. Hill, rot.^;; '^1';™* 
 Sio.Iob ano Whites cafe, ano 2 1 IscDanyclanoVgnel, anobcfsfo tbatof, wiii. 
 tfte temafnocr Umftco to tbc oangbter ootb not b«rt , foj ft mnj? tJcrp tocu
 
 276 Trin. 1651. 
 
 CanD teftl) fbc Inill , nm tbe fntcnt of tljc SEcffato j appears upon tJjc Itjljolc 
 to be to g<tc fucb a poloct to ftts tolfc to make tWa Icafc , ano cttcD 8 Car* 
 Pcrd anD Benfams tafc. Sinn there fg a clanfe in t!)C totll that flicuiB tftat 
 tftr jEettato; tfo fiitcnu to aotonncc ftfs Icf fc bp thin ccWfc. iJnu tl)c jFeme 
 fliaUbc<iibptl)cpo\Bcr,tDbt£bfljallmal;ctbccIxateoftl)clcafe gooD, ano 
 it fs not ncccffarp to recite tbc poVDcr,a0 it is bclo in Rogers cafe. Maynard 
 on tl)c other (iDcfafo,bctooulD not Difptitctbc potocr; but berets no fuel) 
 potDcrgiticn to the toifc as It appears bp the crpjelTc toojus oftlietail'i, 
 tohfcfi Dotb onip nefcribc that flic Qjall onip make Cttatcs but foj ijcr life, Oi 
 tbcrtof fc fljc might maUc CBftates in SCaf 1, j in ^te , ann if this fljoulo be 
 the laft part of tbc tK2in, tobich tioth limit.thc remainoer tooiilo be bcftrop- 
 cD, ant) generals in a ©aillfljall not rctoke an cirpjcfs uctife; but thcp 
 ought fo to be conftrueb that all the Mill map ffano together, as Bonhims 
 cafe is 8, rep. Roll chief luftice , 3it is a Difficult thing to fljclp the meaning 
 of the SCcCatoj hert*, bnt the general mutt not Dcftrop the particular DcWfe 
 totohitfjNichoiajlurticeatrcntcD, anD Roll cnclpncD that tljeiFemc t:aa 
 potocrbpthc S53tll to make this Cttate,otbcrU)tfe the toojDs of the Wiill 
 muabciolcanDtjoftJ, ano it mapbetheJSnronintenocotonitic his toffe 
 ruchapotDcr,thatfl3emtghtDtnroptbcrcmaf:iDers, ano othcrtotfc tlicrc 
 cannot be anp conflruflion mane of the Will Ask luiticc DiffercD in opf» 
 nion, ant) faio ft iras anrcafonafale the remainoer ftoulD be ocflropcD.uhlc^ 
 is crpjeflp llmltcD bp the ©Cllfl , ano a viHHill ooth Differ from a confeepance 
 Nicholas TuflicefalDjthat the tBOjosfftall be crpounoeo to fiielD his bountp 
 to bis toifc ; but not to gibe her potner to Dcftrop the rcmainDcr. lerman 
 Iuftice,2Dhercarcei;p;cffetDOjD3,fo?theiFemc,anDthe Daughter ano the 
 ftmz hath a poiner; but not to Deftropthc (iBftatc of the Danghtcr. Curia 
 advifare vult, Antea, 
 
 Booth againft Lambert. 
 
 Trfn, 1 55 1 . Banc, fup. 
 Hill, 164^, rot* 20I, 
 
 Vpon a fpcciall tjetDict upon tl^cfe teojos,viz. I do endow yoa of a third 
 part ofall the landsmyCofen I. S- your husband dyed feifed of. %\i& 
 n>e"n/".7on a flucftion faias lohcther the feme tocre iocH cnDoiucD bp thefe inojOs, be« 
 fpccui vf r. taufc he Doth not far that he enootos her bp metes ano bounDs, Chafe hclo 
 <iia, thcquc- OjciuaanottocllenDotocD, anocitcDS Ed.j.i5.anDfalDth«thcreisinccr« 
 ft.;,n whcthrr ^^^^^^ ^jj^j^ bcgcts DlITention, tohfch ought not to be , anD the thing is not 
 :'fn'eneTor l)crc crtfrc ; but map bc DBbiDeD. jano this is an afsignmcnt of Dotocr, 
 not. tohlch Differs from a oemanD o'' Dotocr, fo j a DcmanD map be general as in 
 
 the cafes of Thyn anD Thyn in this Court, ano of Faircfax ano Fairef ix, ano 
 fo the boob of 8 E. 2. entry congeable ( S ) ^. tohlch fccms to pjOtC the COn* 
 trarp,thatisnot to our cafe, fo;i it Differs from it. Merifield of Councell 
 on the Other CDehelD the feme teas trell enDotocD, anDlagreeo the cafes 
 put bp Chafe, SChat of Common tight a feme ought to be rnDotoeDbp 
 metes anD bounDs , pet fomctimes it is othertDifc , as 3 Eliz. Dyer 27. a 
 feme encofcco in Common. SnD the feme that is to be enDotoeD , ano 
 thcpactptohoistoafoigntheDolDcr, map agra that the Dotocr Ibi^ll be afa 
 ligneD toithotit bounotng it. jr^o j confenfas tollit errorem ; 315ut ijoiucr ad 
 Dower ofiium ecclefii muft be mojc certain, Mich. 4?, & 44 Eliz. Bullock ano 
 
 Finches cafe, Hill. 4 lac. C. B. Roll chief lurtice, ^f Common right a fcmc 
 ought to be enoovueo per metas & bondat, tohctethe ^liertff afsigns Dotoer , 
 
 toho
 
 Trin. 1^51. 277 
 
 tol^o ia an officer o{ tljc ILato, sm ougljt to pjctjent fiicttmb?nnte , anu off. 
 p;jte0,- 315iit<tmap bcaf!3fgncBgener2llpoftI;ctl)(tD partfii fomc cafes ^ conien' 
 anDt&epartpc0 map agree aga{n(t vEoittnionrfgbt, ar.Dtjctc bot^ partpes 
 agrceo to taUc Dotoec in tl)(s ^anor. Jflno t^ougfe Ijcte tl)c termer foj pcara 
 oftfjc lanolDftotaatljfrDpcrfon, bcp?rjut)(cco bp tfjfs afsfgiimcnt, pet 
 ttitc alters not tfte cafe, because it is onlp an cftatc fSj pcara, anD toticfjctf) 
 nofrccbolC, Nicholas an3 Ask lattices as Roll. lerman !uftice,3!fD0U)et be 
 ofatftfropart, it ougbt to bcbpmeteisnnoboimDsgcneraHp; bat if it be 
 of a mopctp it is not fo, 0; if tftc partpcs confent it ftall be otljcrUiifc. Roll 
 If tbe S>^criff afsign Ootocr^ano eo it r.ot per meras .\ bundR? jt ts Crro j , if ^■^'''''■• 
 it migftt Ijatie been to aioignco , ano iuijerc a feme cannot be ento iteo per 
 rnetas & bund as (l)e map enter iDittjout ar0ignment. ludgement was given 
 for the Defendant nifi, &c. 
 
 Smith againll the Earl of Dorler, 
 
 Trin, i6Si» Banc, fup. 
 
 SMith motet) tl&c Court againfftlje Carl of Dorfet, foj an attatcftment Motion for 
 foj Ditturbing of bint in tije poCTcfsion of certain JlanDa. contrarp to tbe ^" »"«'<^!'- 
 rnle of tijis Court, fojtbc plaintiff to Ijatepoffcfsion. SDljc Court anftoe^ "^J;"'/."' '''^" 
 rcDtljatfoj onlp tifturling i)i8 poffcfsion, tl)crc otigbt not to be an attatc&^rufcotCourt 
 mcnt grantcD;but ifl)C be put out of poffer0ioiT,be tljaU bate an attatcljment Attatchmcn:.' 
 SCIjc Councel replpet) tbat t^e partpea cattel tocre D;iten off from tfje lano, 
 tDfjicljtIjcpfoncciteDUiasanouftingoftbcpartpfrombis poffcfston. %o 
 tbia tbc Court anftuercDjtbat tbia rccmcD to be a putting out of poirEr0ion , 
 And tficrefore ordered that theDcfendant (hould ftiew caufe why an attacch< 
 nent (hould not be granted, 
 
 Owen agaiaft Icvon. 
 
 Trin. i65i.Banc, fup, 
 
 Pafc, lijitfOt, 211, 
 
 *T^^{8 cafe fojfflctlpfpohen onto in arrctt of Sluapmsnt , ana tften ffap* ^"^^'"'""' 
 eD,toaa again moteo,ano ^uogment pjapeo foj tbc ipiaintitF bpSerjeant Aft-"* To'" 
 Glyn, tobo arguED tbat tbe tDojD0 lucre aaionablc , becaufc if tbep itece words " 
 true, tbe partp of tobomtbfp arc fpofecnia puniQjable bptbe Statute of 7 
 lac. foitb cojpojal punifljment ann beCoeatbe Idojds incrc fpohen Cncc 
 tbc IPtt&tatute mate actaintt jaoulterp , VobicbDotbaggratatetbe Idojds 
 ano matic tbem mo?e aflionablc. ludgeraent was given for the Plaintiff ni« 
 fi. 3n tbi0 tafe it toaa faio bp tbe Coart,tbat it toaa aDinogeo in one Thec« 
 ker ano Duncombes cafe, tbatatoemanmapbatjcacbiio in 38. toeefes 
 ano tbat a tooman bg colOjO j baro tifage,map go toitb cbilD abote 40 tocefe0' 
 Antea* 
 
 i^ n 3 Neifon
 
 niilr. 
 
 278 Trin. 1651. 
 
 . . Nelfon againft Tomplbn. 
 
 Trin. idji .Banc, fup, 
 
 Trin, a4 Car. rot. 34 ;• ' 
 
 D-m..rrer \n 1^ Elion bjouaftt 811 aflfoit x)f t!)C Cafc agafntt Tomp(on , ano Dfo Declare 
 p.. Aftoni.p- i ^ tbat tl)c SDcfciiDfliit , fnconfiocratfontljattljc pia<ntff tooulotcafcto 
 onihcCafc jjiofcctttc a futc fd liaUj asatnft l)fm, Dfo atfcmc nnu p;om(fE unto tftc 
 uyonaj.io- piatnt<ft!)att)cU)oulD pap unto l)(m 8 l.itljefljargccoffutclDbkHr bao 
 been at, f fo: bjeatl)oftb<flp?omlfe Adioacrevir, 4fetsfojtI)f)fg Damage, 
 2Co tJjfsSDccIaratfon tljc SDcfenoant Demurs <n Lato,i takes tljfe Cjrcpttoir, 
 VIZ. SCiiat there fs? no time no? place fct fo?tf) luberc oi Intjcn Ijc c(d fo jbcac 
 to (lie tl)C EDcfenOant , ao it oiniijt to Oc , bccaufe ft is a tratterfable matter* 
 3i5at Roll chief luUice anfluercD , 3t is not ncccffarp to allege a plate of a 
 negatibc tbing to be Done , viz, to fap tbat fjc Dio not piofecutc tl)C ftitc fa 
 fticbaplatc, o; at fucf) a time , foj bcongbttofurccafc pjofecution fn all 
 places , ano at all times. Therefore let judgement be fticwn tor the Pla!n> 
 tif except better matter be (hewn Friday next.' 
 
 Lyda'e and Lyfter. 
 
 Trin, id5i. Bine, fup. 
 
 Micb, 1 650. rot. 387. 
 
 ^fecmsnt in A /ji Jldion of SJcbt toss bjougljt upoH art £Dblfgation maDc fo a JSif^op 
 b; ujion a /\ahol)is<Commfirarpfojtl)EpapmentofSDcbt3anD ILegacfcs, tbc Sl- 
 Kundic.er- (tioiuias bioijolK b}' an (Jrecutoi, ano juDgcmcnt gfbcn bp SDsfault a. 
 gafnft tl)e 2)cfcnDant , tbc Swogement tuas retcrfeo bpa ?KHrft of Crroj 
 bccaufe tbc Action teas bjougftt fn tbe Debet ano Detintr, tuljcreas ft ougbt 
 toliatoc been bjongljtin t^cDctinet onlp, bccaufe it leas bjoug^t bp an 
 Cvccutoj. 
 
 Saunders ag<iinfl Ritch. 
 
 Trin, K551 Banc, fup. 
 Hill. iC^p,rot. 758. 
 
 I/ii an SlAion of SCrcfpara ann Cicctmcnt upon a fp: tfal tjcrufct foiin^ Klje 
 Cafe fell out to be tbifi. a man bp ids laft CHfnanD SLcttament Defcifeo 
 ri\\ 's'b'i e- all Ms ^iz fimple lano ^til)Crcfoct)er to btclBjotljcr, upon conDitfon ttjat be 
 jtame. t. fuff cr bis kiUc to eniop all bt3 free lanos in Holford During bcv life ; aao tbe 
 jun'fouuDtbattbcSEcftatojbaoonlpapojttonof titbcs in Holford-. 2Lb<5 
 qucCtontoas, ibbctbertbe portion of titbes Dfopafstotbctoffc bptbisoe^ 
 fffc Merifieid bclD, ECbat tbc JIftbcs pafTcD not bp tbc ocljife , bccaufe ti)e 
 lcoj5 lanos cannot cvtenD to titbcs, fojtbat lt)oulo be a terp fojccD con» 
 flrurtion, ano cftcD Trin. 17 lac Banc. Reg. Knight anD Knights cafC, anD 
 Micb. 39 & 40 Eliz. Entrcd 58 Eli?., rot. 269. Yow anD Hardings cafc Banc. 
 Rep. SDbat^oufcsarenotDetjffablcbptbc name of lanDs, anD be fafo , 
 tbat tbe toojD icbJrsfoelJsr makes no Difference, as to maUe ibe tftbe0pafs; 
 
 ano 
 
 I 
 
 D.:b
 
 Trln.1651. 279 
 
 anu tfeOBSl) tl&erc he an f mplftatfon sud an intent in tfjc jSEt Cstojljcrc toOE* 
 Dctifc tJjc tUl]ES, pet tl)at tofll not fcrtje, fctcanfc ti^crc Irants too:Cfl to cj:« 
 p?cf3 tftfs intent , anu tljotinl) tUs be in a triU, ^et tbcxt mutt ijc too jus ufeo 
 to fuppojttljctntentoftbcSteftatoj , fo?. tciliamuHberuIcD I'p toe ruleo 
 OftljeCotnmonlLato. Afhirghurftanil Curtice tjis cafe, Midi. 7 lac. Hob* 
 rep. 34.tl)claft€tttton. Mich. 42 &;43 fliz. Banc. Reg. auetifeof ilanba 
 PTtenDnot to tftbce, fo j titles are not lanDs , btit a mecr coflatcral t^ing to 
 t^em, ant) ^afee no relation to t^cm, Micb. i. Jac. roM92. MiDs ana Hides 
 cafe, B,!nc.Reg. 11 Rep. Bridle anaNapers cafe, f. i3.KTrin. 42 Eiiz. B. 
 Reg. Sherwood anD Winflon ^cli3., ttjnt tttSjes cannot be appenDart tc a 
 jpanoj, I Rep. III. Al'paniescafe, anD ftere arc no^tcojDa in tl'C jajo= 
 Difotopafstljctlttjcs. St ifl true t!)attitl)e0mr'p lie in tenure, anatbat an 
 paction of Debt lies to; tftcm, but tftst is bp tf)£ Statute 1 9 Eliz Dyer L 35^. 
 %ift itojD lanD in a toill Dotl) not cjtent) to titles, anD icirs cuctit not to be 
 Dif.inberitcD bp Doubtfull anD ambiguous toojDs, as it muttbe ijcrc ,if 
 tftcfctitljcoftoulDpafs, j^c);t, as to iljc tcrcia, l)c falo, tlat it 10 not 
 t^erebp founDtbattljcSLeuatojcicDpoffcCTcDoftbctitljes, as it oual)t to 
 Ijabebccn, aaitbatftbccnaisjuDiirD^j EIiz, anofo fje pjaprD juDrcmcnt 
 foj fljc^Iaintif. Maynard of Counfcl Uiitlj tte SDefenDant arj^ico", SEIjat 
 tlje titbcs ciopafsbptlje^illjOtbcriiifcpartof tl)e trClfll mntt be loio, 
 ir!l){ctoucl)tnottobf,ifallpartsmapbcfoconttrucD tip.t tbcp map ttanD 
 toffclftcr, anD^cacrecDttjatlanDD anD titijcs arc DiCina tftinco; but in, 
 Wilis it ia not to be fo muclj confiDcreo kijctber tfje toojcs of tfcrm' bt p:o-' 
 per, but li3T)at teas tbc intent of tlicJEcOato? in tbcm, anDkl3cti:£ttljcp5o 
 Declare tjis meaning oj net; anD^cre bvtoi'ftrurucncftfjcirojoc bpfrce- 
 lanDg inftcritante is meant in oppofltion to Coppftolo lanias, oj terms foi 
 pearc. 2ip. ^erc ia a potititie atTcrtioii of t!)2 Scttato j Jifmfeif , tljat iit U3 
 unDcrCancing Ijc ^an free lanDts in Holford, foj t}C ftaD sio other innDs tljcrc , 
 I? 5 Eliz. Robinfons tafC , rot. 504. Banc. Reg. by a Itill ttnicrg of ere na' 
 ture map paf0 bp toojDs \xii,ich are p:cprr to pafg tl)ingi5 of another nature , 
 44&45 Eliz. for. 125. SlDctifcof lanus anc tenements Vitll pars icafeo 
 fo J pears , if there be no otftcr lanes, to pafs bp tliofc ir c:Db in tie place er- 
 p2effeDintbc?K3ill , anDfopjapcoSucccment foa tJje DefcnDant. Roll Vcdia. 
 thief luftice astcD toftat !)e faiD to tl}C rjrccption, tljat it is nDt foima 
 tftattteEfCatojopeDfeifcDof tte titfjes, toitljotit Doubt ft bao been ill 
 upona STemurrer , tljercfojc feeif routant-.ctljclptt bpttc notes bpu bicb 
 tbctaerDirttoaflDiairnup. ISnt fo? tbe matter in l.atD , mc thinks it is 
 a flrong cafe tljat tbe titljes do pafs , foj iuc arc in tftecafe ot a CCiU, inhere 
 the meaning of tl}cpartp (hall be obrettED, i^it map be founD cut bp anp 
 means, thouglj it cannot tecolletteD ex viTerminis, ano^oti'D it not be 
 to ftcre, part of the iisaili iroulD be boiD , tcirtc:) map not be, if tee can make 
 ft otherteife bp a reafonablc t onflrtiflion. But 3 uiU conQoer of the aer> 
 Diet, anDDoponronfult totth pour notes. lerman Jnrtice ,SEf)e tScrDitt 
 ongl)t to 6nD tbc Dping feifcD, anD till 31 ara fatisficD from the j^otes ^ iriU 
 DEliticr no opinion. Nicholas luflice hclD both the Detifc crooij , ano th;; 
 ^CTDittalfo, but faiD it hao been othErtoife upon a iDemur'rcr. ' Ask la-Dcirarrer 
 ttic: to the fame intent. lerman lufticc, $t is clear that the StcCrtn j inten* 
 BCD to Dctffc the lanDsin Holford , ano it is a gooo dc tife, but if ilj>^ tUcr- 
 Dirt bcfmperfcrtitisfojthcpiatntif, butifotherbifcitisfcj the S»efen, 
 Santt The Court would advife couchin-, the Vcrdid, 
 
 Hay-
 
 Who nny 
 'or if I 
 
 280 Trin. 1651 
 
 Hayward againft VVilliams. 
 
 Trio. i<5ji.Banc. fup. 
 Hill. i649»rot. 8:4» 
 
 Ti^c Cafe toas (l)i0 , a jFcmc toaa faco as a iFemc fole, but bp tbe &ir- 
 tiamc oi'gct ^JlusbanD , ftc bcfngtbc" Cottert. SCfje i?cme appears 
 Mor^wiio BiiD plcaD0,ano 3."DCEnient la g(tcn againft tier, ano tfft UBaron ano jr^eme 
 not. ' iopntnatDj<tofG;rto;i to rctctfc tbici juogcmmt: 2Cbc qucftfon luas , 
 tnSictber tbc iBaron, Vobo toaa a &trangct to tbe Eeco jd, mtgbt jopn in tbe 
 iujfttoretctfctbe JuDgcment :> 3!t teas mottco Dfbcrs tfntee, ano tbc 
 Court aoiifeo , atiDatlsfttbcpfafo, tljat a Stranger to a IRecojD map 
 not bjtng a tojft of CDrro j to retierfc it , but tbat ia onlp tobcrc Ije map babe 
 anotbcrrcmcDptoaboiotbcpjElaDfcc be rstap rcccibe bp it; bat in tWa 
 Cafe tbe loaron batl) no otber rcmcDp. (oi bis Catfc is talicn (n Crccutton, 
 ano bptWo means be ftjaUlofe bet focietp; Andchercfore rcverfetur, oifi. 
 Antes, ^Ty^- 
 ^'hannagainftBilby. 
 
 Trin. i(S$i.Bznc.fup: 
 Hill. i55o,rot. io(5y, 
 
 Arreft of QHinn bjOHO'nt 811 Action npon tb-' Cafe upon a pjomifc agafntt BiJby, 
 
 jadgfmtrnt in i^anT) Dctlarc0 , tbat in coiiGocration tbat tbe plaintif fljoulD furrenoct 
 
 an rtfti'Mi up- a CoprbolD uiito I, s. ano bifibeito, accojofng to tbe Cuftom of tbe ^ano?, 
 
 ontheCi.e tbe JDcfcnoant DiD affumc anopjomffc to pap unto bim looi. anfl tbat be 
 
 p^omife ^io furrcnDcr tbe Coppbolo into tbe banoa of a Cuftomarp Ccnant of tbe 
 
 j;pano J , atfo?Dlng to the Cuftom of tbe i^ano?, to tbe ufc of I. S. ano bfa 
 
 bcira , anc tbat tbe SJcfcnuaHt bao not paio tbe bnnojcD pounD accojDiag to 
 
 bfspjomftc, ano Declares to bi3Damdgc,^c. ciponnon AfTumpfic pleaoca, 
 
 ano Jffuvtbercupon lopnco, a umia teas fotmo foj tbe plaintif, 36 
 
 toas moVeD in arreft of Sn^'gcmtnt bp Latcb of Counccl luttb ttje SDefen* 
 
 oant, tbat tbe tl^cclaration i0 not gooa , i.IBccaufeitDctbnot fet fojtbto 
 
 iDbom tbe p:omife was maoe , ano if it do not appear to be maoe to tbe 
 
 piaintif, it ia nudum p^dum , foj tbepjomifcberc is tbe confiDcratfon» 
 
 xlp, SIbc ConfiDc ratio!', fa Ctecuto?p, ano tbe piaintifDotbnot ftielo 
 
 tbat be batb perfojmeD it, ano tbcn be batb no caufe of 3rtlon ; 2Cbe Confi» 
 
 Deration luaa, tbat tbe plaintlf Iboulo fiirrcjiDer aCoppbolD to I. S. anD W 
 
 bcira, actoi5ing to tbe cuftom of tbe ^anoj; ano be onlp ftjetos tbat be 
 
 DiDrutrcnoertbeCoppbolDintofaebanOflofa Ctiftomarp Xenant, accoj^ 
 
 Ding to {\fi CuEom of t!jc ^ano; , to tbe ufc of I. S. ano bia beira, anD Dotb 
 
 not fl)eiD that tbia furrcnacc toaa p'.efentcD at tb2 ncrt Court. anD fo it ap- 
 
 Suircnder. pcfiraKOttobc 3 QOOQ futrenoer , foj it ia unccrtai-i tnbctbcr it Ibnll bz 
 
 ptcfcntcD oj no, '-no tiU it be picfcntcD it ia imperfect : 2lo iobicb tbe Court 
 
 affentcD, ana rulcD agaiiift tbe plaintif a Nil capiat per Billam , nifi , ?.c. 
 
 Covenant. 3;n tbfa cafe it iuaa faio tbat if a man cobenant to conbcp lanoa, it ougbt 
 
 to be Done at tbe cb^rcc of bim tbat cobenantctb to do it. ercept tbe contra* 
 
 Coi.fiJera- TpbcagrceD ; 0nDtbatif tbcre be a Double confiDcration alleageo foja 
 
 t;on. p:omife, ifoncof tb-'m be gooa, ana tbe otber be not, pet an aaion toill 
 
 lie upon tbe p jomife tbat is fa jolien , to^tcb toaa grounow upon tbefc conC< 
 
 fiocrations, Bac»
 
 Trin. 1651. 2i 
 
 Barcock againftTompfon. 
 
 Trin. 1 65 If Banc, fup, 
 Mich. idjo. rot. 444f 
 
 AWixit of Ctro J toaa bzoujtit bp tlje IBail to tcijetfc a laugcmcnt eJbcn E^ror brcu^hc 
 agafnft ^fm upon a fcire facias,^ tbe Crroj afsfgnco U)as>that tbcrc toas '')' '''^ ^'' '• 
 no Capias taben out agalntttbepjfncipal, atiDt^rrcfojc t\)z (are facias a- 
 gafnft tbc IBafUs not cooo. Hales aiifiDereDjtbat it toas to late to urge 
 tbfBnotofojCrroj j foj tfte juogc|ncni is npon tlno nichiU returnee, ano 
 cttED ai E, 3 . f. 1 3 • Roll chief luiHce fato, t^at tlDO nichils h as muclj as 
 a fcire feci rcturneo , anoUfsnoCrrojtogibe juDgement upon it; but ft 
 DaQ been a gcDD pica upon t^cfcire facias to fapt^atttjereloas no Capias a- pj^, 
 gafnft tfte p;{nc<pal , butnotot^icrctsaSluDscmcnt iucU gfbcn, anD ft fa 
 loo late to afsfgn ft foj Crro?, Buc ihe Coarc adviled, Poftea. 
 
 Kerman againft lohnfon. 
 Trin, i65i,Banc, fc^. 
 Trin. 1649. rot. ij;, 
 
 KErman bjougbtan 51ttfonofErerparsanD(lBjertmentagatnCIohnfon,sptc;aiverdia 
 ano upon a fpetfal 'deroftt fonno tfte Cafe Jnas tbfs. 3 man DcWfcD '" V{-^^' 
 toi.S.WBtDftolecttafc, papfngfcfs Debts ano ILegactes , ano cfco polTcf- "en,/' 
 fco of ©ooDs.ano Chattels , tot^etalucoffibcpounosonlp, anoDpcoairo 
 fetfco fn fee o*f otters lanDs , anotoasfnocbteofoitppounosat tbc time of 
 Ws oeatl). SCftc qucftfon teas , b)l)etbcr t^c lanos paffco bp tbc SDcbffc? 
 Barry of Counccl \ait\i tl)c |3laintlf arguco , tftat tfjc lanos ofo pafs, bccaufc 
 tbat irf Us ougbt to receibe a fabourablc conttructlon ; ^no zip. JDbc intent 
 of tlje Ccftfltoj fs to be confiDerco, tobo bp t!)c toojos all his eftate, ofo mean 
 tocomp;et)enDastccUt)islanoast)te80oDs ano (battels, fo^ tbere is no 
 tcftratnt of tbc too?D0berc , 7 Ed. ^ -.0, SEbe Ido;o eftate is a toojO of 
 large cjitcnt , ano cptcnos as ioell to tbe real as pcrfonal eftate , if it toer c 
 in Cafe of grant . mucb mo>c in tbc cafe of a CTfil. ano tberc is anotljcc 
 tooioufcobere to crplain tbc 2Ccftato;s meaning to be to ocbifc bis lanos 
 aslseUasMs gooos, anotbat is tbc U)o:o All, tobicb comp^cbenos all 
 manner of eftates,\ij{ti)ont exception, j^ertfftbe lano ftioulo not pafs, 
 Ijisoebts ano JLcgatfcs cannot be paio, accojoingtotbc ctp^cfs intent of 
 tbeJCcftatoj , ano tbc intent oftbcpartpouobtto bcfatisfieo, altbougbtnc 
 toojos be not pjoper, bccaufc it is in a tnill , tbougb it migbt be otberluifc in 
 a grant. anoicbercasitisobjecteotbattbcBluriesftnoingoftbe talusof 
 tbe Debts ano llegacics, is to no purpofe , bccaufe tbc Ml cannot be belpeo 
 bp tbc atjcrment of tbc 3itirp. 3 anfiDcr tbat abcrmcnts if tb:p ftano iDttl) 
 tbcVoill, mapbcrcceibcotomafectbc Ceftatojs intent to appear. 3But 
 beftoes tbis is not an abcrmcnt onlp,but a true ftating of tbe Cafc,to tbc in^ 
 tenttofino out tbe SCcftatojB meaning. 5lp. EbcDcltfrcoftliclanoiisnot 
 maoeffirccuto; but2nruftcc,o;DEbifcc,»tbisiBlincc ti)c&tatu!c cfJDctiifcff 
 32 H. 8. 2Lbc 2. qu£Cionis,tDbatcftatttibe2Det)ifcel)atbittlbelanoo7 h^ 
 toncclbe be bfltb jTce Cmple, bccaufe \z batb all tbc €ftntc, tubfcb mnft be 
 tbclargctt, anotbatis J^cc^fimplc. Hob, rep. pi. -So. 2i;bc toojo Itbolc 
 goes bot^ to tbe quantity ano qnalitp of an :ftatc alio, ^no bcrc tbc conCoe- 
 
 iD tatiow
 
 — tattoiTtbatbclato pap all ti3 SDcbts snu JLcgacfec, fa a rooD corfiocratfon 
 
 topaf3tl)cfcc Cniplcof»;f3lanC3, ano tbousb tbcrc ma^» be a furpUifagc 
 aftettbc JDcbtoanDjLcgaclcspalD, tljfotifnDcra noting; fojit is t)is fn-- 
 tenttljatt^ciDct3frccfl)aUftatetl)atfiirplufagc, antifo ^e pja^'CD 3tiD5c- 
 mcnt fojthc |?lffi.tff. TsvifdenfojttieSDtfenoant argtico, tbat cttljct 
 notl)iiiBi>affctbbptt)etKHfU, ojifanp tbfns, tben onlp an tftatc fo: life 
 paffcti). ^^e agreeo tfcat Improper tDo:D0 map fomctfines pais 
 tftfnao, pet fomctf.-nccpjopct toojos lufU not paffe tWngs; viz. if toe 
 fntciit o£-tb; pattp appear to be contrarp, 24 Eiiz, in tftc Carl ofNors 
 tfiumberlandf cafe. % S>ctiifc of all !)f3 Jcicds, Dio not pafs l)ia Collar of 
 «Eirc0 , ano fjis ^etoels anncrco to ftio parliament l\obc0 , ano tlje toojos 
 l^crc are not tftat i)c Dc\3ifct^ all f)i3 eflatc in Ijio lanes , but ^is toljolc eftatc 
 jjcncrallp . anc if t!)C toojosticrc ll)oult pafs tl)c lanua , pet tlje fee Cm. 
 pic paffcti not , but oiilp an eflatc fo: life in tl)c lanno , Icbicft Do pafs ; no j 
 00 t^c teojDs papinc bis Dcbtaanu il cgacics caafc t^jc i?cc.Cmplc to pafa , 
 fojtcrcianoIil^clpIjcDD of anp lofs to tbc Cjrecutoj; foj tftc tooaog arc 
 not, tftat l)C IDall pap all Ijis 2?cbt3 cno Bleaacieg \ anD if lie be an Crecuto;, 
 as tfte contrarp appears not, ftcQiallnot be cljargeD uitlj moje tljan tl)e 
 perfonal eflatc toill Difc^arge. %\iZ too jos do amount to a ConDition , ano 
 (ti3notfounDtbatH)ercatcanpE>£btsoj iLegatics paio, ano fo it is not 
 perfo:mcD, anDtbc^cirmaptoell enter into t^iclanos in qtieffion, fojtfte 
 ConDition b;oken. ilp.SCbcmeroictDotljnotfinDbototljclanDsarcijelD, 
 iBftetber in forage, ojbp!SnigS)tsfErttcc; anD fo it appears not toftctbet 
 tbep tan be DebifeD j no, anD tijep fliall not be intenocD to be Socage lanos, 
 Dver,t". 207. Hill. 32 El. rot. 2. anO Pel! anD Browns cafe, jlp, Jt is not 
 founD tljat the 2Cettatoj DpcD fcifeD of the lanDs, as it ongbt to bate been , 
 Spfciai Vcr--' j,„j, j.^ pigj^icD ^tiDgemcnt fo} tl}e. SDcfenDant. Roll; chief laftice to tbe 
 ^^- fcconDCrccptfontotljc GlerDittanflDercD, tbat in a Special tcrDia it is not 
 
 ncccffarp to fino tobetber lanes be bda in Socage, oj fap tonigbts Sertice , 
 anD be faiD tbat tbe too:Ds in tbe tzaill do gcc to tbc nature ano cyfcnt of the 
 eflatc, as Barry urgco, anD be DoubteD bolD tbe terDitt fljall fupplp tbc ®aill 
 ifitfaeDcfcctitc, fojtbatisonlptomabe tbc intent of tbc OTiH certain. 
 Adjourned co be argued again. Poftea. 
 
 Marfiial againft Ledfham. 
 
 Trin, 1(55*. Banc, liip, 
 
 Arrcft of 
 
 ludecmcntin Tk /| Arflia! Hs 0ominiffratoi bjings an SlctioBof SDcbf foj rcHf i ano up- 
 
 Ditr. J:y| on a 'ctertict fonnD fo; tbc fDlaintif , tbe SDcfenDant motieo in iJrrctt 
 
 ^ ^ ^ "^ / of^nDgcmcnt, anD tafscs crccption , tbat tbc JDIaintif baD not ftclBji bp 
 
 Cv'^-^/'**^.tobomtbelLettcr3Of0DminiffrationlriercgranteDunto bim, as be ougbt 
 
 , / ^►O M C- to 00, bat onlp faps tbat tbc 0Dmi.i{ftration dcbico more commiffa fuif,i5at 
 
 Q^r ft toas anftocrco tbat it is too late to motjc tbfs Crrcption after a dctDict , 
 
 fo J tbe 3iatp batic novo founD tbat t^c 3Dmin(ffrat(on teas Diilp granteD,ant> 
 
 tbelLcttcr0of3Dminittrat{ontoercpjoD«ccDinConrt, anD (bcrcfoje not 
 
 Dcc:»rat;on. /ticceffarptoflielDltbogranteDtbem ; anDitirasfaiD, tbat in aSDecIara* 
 
 tienitisnotnccctrarp to fl)cto bp tof;om l-cttcrs of jaDminiftration are 
 
 grantcD, ojtofaptbcptocrcgrantcDbpbint, Cui pertinuit,oj per loci il- 
 
 jliusOrdinarium : JlBut in a peain 55ar itisotbcrfeifc, fojtbisis not tbc 
 
 rua. I caufc of tbe ;a£tion , anD effect of tbe fate , but to ftcto tbep babe been \xi 
 
 tbc Spiritual Court. Judicium nifi pro quasrcntc t»ag afteriTjatDs gibcn: 
 
 Anew, 
 
 Gilei 
 
 \
 
 Trin,i65i. z?.^ 
 
 Giles againft Tirnberky. * 
 
 Trin, 1 5J i . Banc, fup» 
 
 Mich. idjo. rot. 176. 
 
 ( \ i^Ejeaionefirraaevlet armis me b?OKgl)f in tt)C Common PW8)y',*/,'y'V 
 ^anDaiaogcmEntfiitcnfojtbe jpiafnttf upon a nihil (iicir,anD<n a „,cnt ]„ an^'* 
 tDj<tofCrrojb}Ougl)tfntl)f3Coarttot£terfc tl^c juogement, tlje CBrroj Ejtaionc fu- 
 afefgncD teas in tbe judgement , tDbftftlDas cnttcD tljus, ideo confidera' "'^. 
 turn eft quod recuperet, anDtbetoOjD Capiatur VtSS omfttCD , JrWcb Ollgljt 
 not to be, becaufet^cjattfonfsasnrefpafgvi et armis. Roll chief luQice 
 tain, %t is an <U courfe tbep nfc in tfte Common pica0, to enter tbe juDgc- ^ 
 
 niEntrofn tbfaaaion, fojbptl)f6coutfetl>c|3lafnttffl)aUgafnbii5poffEf3i= '"'^g'™:". 
 on of tl^e lano, ano tfte JDefcnoant cannot b jfng bfs toJit of €rro j until tbe Error. 
 tojit of C-nquirp rctnrneD , ano t^c SoDgement perfetteu, tobttbit map be 
 tDfU ncbctbc; fojlDben tbe paintif batb gotten poffcfsion of tl)c laiios 
 IjetDill little tegatDtbC Damages* Therefore let the judgement be revere 
 fed* Ancea, 
 
 Elyott againft Blague. 
 
 Trim i5$i.BanCf fap* 
 
 ELyott bjougbt an adfon upon tbe Caf£ againft Blague U>i fpeafeing tbefe Arreft c f 
 teOjD0Ofbim,viz.Thou art a Baftard getting Rogue, and hadft a Ba- luJgcment in 
 ftardat£>);fO>0, and art a pocky rogue , and for ought I know thou ^aft ^J'^^^j^ °'' ^''^ 
 filled my Bed full of the French pox, and no luch pocky rogues (hall lie with ""' 
 met mponnotgailtpplcaDen.anoa xacroitt fonno (oi tbe paintif, it 
 toa s motJED in 0ttcft of BinDgement tbat tbe too jts icere not aaionablc, be= 
 canfefome oftbemtDetc aDicclbelp fpofeen , ano otbcrs uncertain, ano 
 fomc of tbcm clcatlp not actionable; 315utTwifdenanftDcreD,tbatiftbc 
 iDOjDstDcre taken togctbct as tbeptoere fpobcn, tbep toete berp fcanoa* 
 loufl ano actionable , anOciteDoneColyersano Lydyers cafe, i Car. %o 
 tDbicbtbc Court agceeD, and ruled tbe Plaintif to take bit judgement czcepe 
 better cauie ihould be (hewn. 
 
 Guftodes againft Ginkes. 
 
 Trin, i65iBanc,fup, 
 
 SErjeant Bernard mobCD to Difcbatge an jSDjDet Of SciTions mane againft To difchttr^e 
 a if eme Cobett, tobecpadDjanocbfloof bets, bccaufc a J^cmc Co« i-^ oracc ot 
 tett toaa not bonnn bp fucb an iSDjocr. Roll chief luftice anftoercD , that ^*'^;°"'-f g . 
 6er It^iisbanu isJbouno to feecp bis toifefi ©tanBcbilD bp tbe Statute ; but in ^^^" ' 
 tcga'rD tbat tbe l^usbanD is not cbargcD bp tbe ;©;tiEt , but tbe Voifc tobo is " 
 cobett is onlp cbatgeo , Therefore lee the Order be qualbed* 
 
 ;© 2 Trot-
 
 284 ^""- *^5li_____ 
 
 Trotman againft Standard. 
 
 Trim 1^51, Banc, fup, 
 
 Trin, 1650. rot, lydSt ' 
 
 spfciii ver- jj^ an Action npon t\it cafe a fpccfal tcrofct Ujas founu.upon Id!)uI) t!)C cafe 
 drtt in an a- ^ jpj| Qj,t ^^ jjg ^^(jj jj^^pp jjcing fcJfcD Of lanD0 (h iFffi, Ufa make a tbar. 
 ftion on liie ^^^ ^^^ feoffment unto tlDo otbets, ano to tbcir iitixe , anu in tbc dccd toao a 
 lettctofi5lttojncptocntct<ntotbelanOD(ntbcnameoftl)c feoffojs, ano 
 make Utjerpano feffin atto?Dlng to tlie effect of tljcoeco, anDUbcrpot UU 
 fin iraamaDctooneoftljriFeoffeeflfaj'tlicattojncpfnttieabrcntc of t^c 
 otljcr i?eoffce. SCljcqneCfon toa!j,lri!)ctl)crf)ctctocreagooD Ifterp ano 
 fc(fin, ojnot :> 2lp. CaHbctJier tftc letter of attojncptoag gooDoj no, (n 
 tegato (t ftao falfc latin <n U, foj tbc letter of jattojncp irao mane bp tlDo , 
 ant) tbe teojDs of it are pro me, & in nomine meo to mahc Uterp U'Wtl) arc 
 trojts of t^crmcular number, tol)erca3 tbcp ought to be of tbc plurall^ 
 Hales a0 to t^e ad. queflionftclD the letter of atto^nep gooo cnougb, bc- 
 caufc tbe aut^ojftp gltcn to the attojncp p?otecDc from both thciFcoffo js, 
 ano therefoje the tD0?D3 fljall be tn tcntieD to be the Idojds of both of them , 
 as fpobcn bp them feterallp. ano he alfo argueD that the letter of attoj. 
 nepltiaBtoelleicccuteDto both the iFcoffce0,bccaufcU toas bp oecD, ano 
 he ttteo I s E. 4 t.i s.anu he fafo, If the Uterp hao been maoe bp the iFeoffoj 
 hfmfelf it hao been gooD toithont qutllfcn , anD there is no Difference ,be- 
 ttoeen that ano our cafe, Occauft it is mnoc accojDing to the effect of the 
 aceo,anD the i^eoffce tuho is p?cfcnt is 0tto;ncpfo; the jTcoffee that is afa« 
 rent to receive libcrp fo; him , ant) the effect of the letter of 3tto?nep is tv- 
 ccutcD,although the iDOjos are not, Cooks Lit. f. j. am Hoxon ano Poles 
 tare, inthebxchtquer,54 Eliz. Boltontcafe, ilittrp maue to the htisbano, 
 itaohcloagooD JLfterptothetDifcalfo. Latch 0' Courcel en the other 
 fioemaucttooqucffions. 1. ^labcthcrhcrc »ia3;a goobauthojitp^ alp. 
 Whether it iDaslDellcrccuteO:' iFoj the firft he argueo, that here teas no 
 anthojitp gitjen to the iltto jncp to enter into the lanus in the name of both 
 the ^f offojs , fo? the toojco arc that he fljoulo enter in nomine raeo,tohich 
 cannot compichcno both of them, the toojos being in the ffngular 
 number , ano he agreeo that JLittrp mace bp the i?eoffo j himself to one , 
 in the name of both hao been gooo •, but here the liter? is bp attojncp, ano 
 an attojnep hath nothing but a bsre autho jitp citcn him, tobicl) ought to be 
 firralp purfucD, cfptciallp it being to paffe aluap an CCatc. \$z alfo took 
 crceptions to the fprcial tercict , ano faio that the trpal upon tohich the ter. 
 DittlDasfouno,lDasD(rfCtcDoutof tleChar.ccrpto clfcotcr a fiauD , ano 
 the terDict finas nothing accojoing to the tircction, ano fo it ought to be 
 fctafiDe,bcfioc3tbetctDictinitfclfi8inccrtain, fo; it is of 300 Sfctcs of 
 lano gencrallp, tDhicb is ir.ctrtain , anu fo the paintiff can hate no ^uogc- 
 ment, fQjthcSDiClarationtoarrantsnottheiJcrtJict , fo?the SDeclaration 
 mentions ^oufcs, ano Cottages, bcSacs the 3 00 acres of lano. zip. SChc 
 tcrDitt tjoth not fino the Date of tbc Jnoenture , ano the 2Citlc to the lano fa 
 to commence a died^tus. Hales anfircrca i.Jt (hallbeintcnoeD the Dap 
 oftheoate. ilp. gtftailtal^ceffcctaftcrthcDcliterp, ifthcrebeno Dap 
 of the Date crpjeffeD. ano to that f vccptf on to the terDict, that tl;ere are 
 not romanp3cre3contefncDinit, as are cvpjcircD in the S>eclarafion ; 
 he anftocreo that the 3iuDgemcnt thall go to all tol ichfs lano in IJno on!p , 
 nno ftall not tytcno to l^onff 0, arto xTottages , ano there appears to be a 
 
 re»
 
 Trin. 155 1. 2^5 
 
 refidaum, 0} fatplufage. RoUch^ef luftice fafo, tljat (t (a fnccrtafn bp t\)e Vcni.a. 
 tctDfct tuftat lanos arc meant , fojtl!crcaTC4oo3crr0of lano, aitD four 
 mettmstg, ano four Cottage0,anD ^o acres of mecoiy in \\): Declaratfoir, 
 ani)fotl&er8appeat0tobearefiduum,bEODe3tl)elanDfoanD fn t1)e beroto, 
 tDftfcftmafscsittobefncertafttte^atfsfounD, 0!iDttjoua!) ft Qjoulobc a 
 icxiia fo J part, ano be uncertain foj tbe reft , alttioug^ tljc plafntfff tofll 
 rcUnqufCb bfs Damages fo; ttic reft, tbis totU not bclp it , fo: tljcrc mutt be 
 ttDoBuDgementfl, ano tfee feetuia fa ill as totbathjfjfcbfafounD, petf)8 
 fjelD tbat ft migbt be gooD toitbout relfnqufOjfng tbe Damages at all, becaufc 
 tbJB berclct fa gooD foj fo manp acres as are fntbe£)eclaratfon, ano ft 
 fljafl be fntenDCD tftat tftc Blntp mfttoob tbc number of tbe acres, ano fnten« 
 DeDbptbebcrDfctnomojctban tfte arcable lano. lerman anD Nicholas 
 luftices DoubtcD fobetbcr tbere be a feerofct at all, bf caufe tlje gurp Ijabc not 
 fonno tbe tljfnss contepncD fn t^c D^claratfon. Koll chief luilice, ano 
 Nicbolaf, mutate opinionc,bclD tbe terDfrt gooo ; but fafD it teoalo bate 
 ban otbertoffc upon a Demurrer , ano it iraa fafo tbat if one Declare fo? 40 
 J. anDtbe bcrDfctfinosioo Ktbeplafntfff map reUnquiflj 60 I. ana bate 
 31uDgement fo J tbe reft. Askluftice faio tbat bio opinion teas, tbatttje 
 terDitt is fncertafn , anOconccibetbtljat tbe Slurp intenoeD all (n tbe 2De« 
 claratfon. The Court took time to advifCf Afcerwards ludgemenc was given 
 for the Plaintiff, 
 
 Fitton againil Richatd(bn. 
 
 Trini55i,Banc,fup» 
 
 •Tl^eCourt toas moteD fo? a pjobffaftfon fo tbe Countp palatine ofForaproh;-- 
 ■■• Chefter, upon a furmffe ttjat tbcp DfD pjoceco fn tbe Court of eqtiftp at ^"'^ "^ '''<= 
 Cheder toucbfng tbe papmcnt of rent refertcD upon a leafc foj pears, tobfct) ^""'/'',^''n' 
 Is a matter trpable at tbe Common Halo , ano not fn a Court of cqnftp, c'." " ' 
 
 Sl^bc Court anftoercDtDeiLfll fee tbe SBill , tobetber tbere be anp matter 
 of equftp laiD in it oj no , foj if tbere be iuc tufUnot grant a pjobibition, ano 
 let us alfo fee fome pjcfitiento if tbere be anp , foj granting of a pjobtbiti* 
 on in fucb cafes. Powis tobo mobeo fo j tbe pjobibition rcp'.pcD , 2Lbat in 
 Cheiler tbepbolDttooCourts, one foa matters of Common iLaln , ano a- 
 notbcr foj matters of equftp , anD fo tbep ougbt to obferte the ijuc p joccco « 
 fnssfneacbCourt,acco}Dfng to tbe nature of tbe caufc, ilp. ECbfs Court 
 of tbe upper I5encb fs tbe fuperfntenDent Court oter all otber Conrts,anD a 
 tojft of (Brroj Ipcs oat of tbfs Court to Chefter , anD bpconfcqiicnce a pjo« 
 ^ibition alfo to rcflrain tbe Court of equftp there, if tbep fljall p jocceo frre' '*• 
 gularlp, 3lp, Cbere tDonlD otbertoffe be a failcr of juftice, fo? tbe Cour J*" 
 ot Cbanterp bcre cannot grant a pjobfbitton , bccaufe tbe matter tbep p}0« 
 ceeDin tberctanomattcrofrquitcNit. brev. f. 44H, I. Cook rep. Cor- 
 bet$ cafe, Hot), rep. cafe 98. Owen and Holts caie. anD tbougb a Injit 
 from bence Dotb not run tbere no? in Wales , pet a pjobfbition fs grantablc 
 to Wales, anDtberefOjctohpnct toCheOcrjMich, 2.1aci B, R a habeas 
 corpus toas grantED to tbe Countp palatine of Durham , ano to Barwirk, 
 anOTrin, 1650, C, B. rot. ipdd.fu Jones and Lcnnjrds cafe a pjobibition 
 InasgranteDtoChef^er. Nicholas luflicecitco a cafe to be aojuogsD fn 
 tbfs Court bp Cook chief luftice tbat ft Infll not Ire de brevi ordinatio ; but 
 fn Wales ft tofll Ip, Hales anficerco, tbat tberr fs moje bcre tban ittattcc 
 ofcquirp, anDtD^itsmanDatojptnilllpe fn all places. Roll chieHuilice 
 fafD tbat Cheftcr batb a Court of upper JBentb , anD tl}Ci> map grant a p;6- 
 ^ibltion tljetc , ano U appears not to us tobctbct tbep totU gract ft oj |,ot, ^''^''''''"o"- 
 
 £Do3 fo
 
 285 Trin. 1651 
 
 fo tftst Inc knotD not itbctbct toe ticca to tnt ermeole. Hales rcplpcD, tl)at 
 cbcrp one is botinn bp tftc Common iLain , anu tbctcfojc \joiits manoato- 
 tp at tfjc Common iiato , U)l)fcbBLncrallp concern men its fubjccta, ano 
 not tonccrnfng pjitatc t!)<ng3. ^n^ i . 3>t io to \ie confiocrce tW Clieften 
 |urtfDloioni0Ccrii3CD from ttjis Court, aiiD fo it <a fuppofco to be fubojDf- 
 nate to <t , ano (3 to be rcgtilatcD bp it. 2lp. tiSabcn tijc matter concerns 
 common rigbt, it is not affirco to Cheftcr , bccaufe ft concerns men aa fub» 
 jctffl at large, 20 lac. Grigs cafe, C. Banc, ano tljffl Court fat in Chcfter in 
 tbc 22 pear of £d i . aa map appear bp tIjc roll , Hill.5 1 .Mich.29.E.3. rot. 
 a habeas corpus iDaa grantcD to Durham, anD tbc Ubcrtp fcffcD Into tl)C 
 MnM banco fo; otfobepfng it , anD tbia Court is tbc confcrtato? of tbc H= 
 bcrtfea of Chefter. Roll chief iufticc cemanCCD, can toe grant apjoWbitf- 
 Pf ohibition. on to tbe Court of equitp fn Ireland ^ 3f tbcre fiio appear to be anp failct 
 of iutticet)ere,li)cU)OulDgrantap7obibftfon ; but tt)crs appears not anp 
 failcr, fo;ftmapbctbepartp mapt-atjcapioljfbitfonfn tftenppcrlBenc^ 
 tljcrc. SCftcrcfojcitisgooDfoj us to fjcar tbc otber partp, and in the 
 mean time we will advife, anD then let uo fee tibe bill in Cbancerp. fn tl)i». 
 cafe Hales faiD tbat a prohibition t)aD been granted to t^c iLo^D ^j(o?9 
 Court of London. 
 
 Style againftTullye, 
 
 Trin, 165 », Banc, fup* 
 
 HilU24.Car,rot. 587. 
 
 Error to re- Q3fr Humphrey ?ty!e bjougbt 3 Icjit Of C'troj to refectfe a guogcmcnt aU 
 vcric a iu<if,- ijticn againft bint in an Action of Debt upon an obligation in tbe Common 
 met in <!ibtpica0fojTullyeanDAaon ©Fccutoisof tbe laftlXJiU anD SCcftamcntof 
 i^Mi*.?"''' one William TuUye. SCbc ca fell as tftiu, &ir Humphrey Style , ana one 
 * '°"' Thomas Brook tDCre iopntlp anD fetJCraUp bouuD unto William Tullye.in ail 
 obligation of i2ol.fojt!)epapmcntof6ol.atacertainDap. iJftcr tlje Dap 
 ofpapment, anDtbcmonp not paio, Thomas Brook maUcabie MiH, ano 
 maUcg Mary Brook bis toffe bis CEtecutrir, ano opes , afterloarns William 
 TullyemabesbisluiU.anD mafees Tullye ano AAon tbe 2?efenoauts in tbe 
 tDjito'CDrrojbiaCBrccutojSjanDDpcs, ano bpWa «Dill be releafes unto 
 Mary Brook all t^e Debts, tobicb Thomas Brook berbusbanD, did otoe nnto 
 i){m at Vt time of bis oeatb. Tullye anD Adon pjobc t'ois Urfll , ano after 
 b jfng an 3ction of Debt againtt &ir Humphrey Style f n tbe Common pleas, 
 'pon tbc obligation of i6o I. &it Fiumphrey Sty ft Dcmnrs to tbe IDcclara- 
 tion, anD fo?caufc(&cto0tbat William Tullye bp bis toilUbaDrelcafcD tf)2 
 H>cbtto Wiry Brooks , anc upon tbta Demurrer luDgcmcnt loas gibcn a- 
 gainC&it Humphrey Style, anD tbcreupon be bjfngs bia tojit ofCgrroj; 
 tobcrcin tl)? nucBion inns, tobetber tbc Debt toas rcleafcD bp tbc u.fll o j no^ 
 Latch of Counccl fo?S)ir Humphrey Style argucD,tbat bete tons an actual 
 tcleafe , anD ^ citco »i E, 4. f, 8. ano a cafe Trin. 10. Car. ano faio tbat a 
 toillamotmtstoarelcafe, altbougbit benot mace of incojpojeal things, 
 anD tbc atrcnt of Mary tbe (Brecntoj ts not necetfarp berc, fo; tbia is not liljc 
 tbc affcnt to tbc accepting of a iLegacic, ano a Debt Due upon an £DbIfga. 
 tion maoe to tbc 2Ccftato; ,ifl not affcts in tbe banoa of an CFecnto; , tmtiU 
 ft be recobcrcD , ano tbis Is maje tban in tbe nature of a ILegacp, ano berc 
 toasagreatpcrronalCBftate, anonootbcrcreoitojs arc DeceitocD bp tbis 
 relcate, anDadevnnavitcannotbc berc fnppofc, 1 9 H.S.Dyer 8 E. 4. f, 
 5.Dy'eri3j),Cranmer5Cafc, anDbcrcisonlpancjconerationof a tbing, 
 i' ano
 
 Trin.1651. 2^."^ 
 
 anD no Donation of anp tbfng bp W-^s releafc, Serjeant Hen. Clark of Coun- 
 cel on tfte ot^cr Qde arsueo,ttjat tUe Debt Ujaa not Kfcbargei) bp tfjc icfll , bc» 
 caufc tWs tcleafe maos bp t^e totU cannot take effea till after tftc ocatb of 
 tbc SCeftatoj.anD fo not at aU,anD fucfj a rclrafc teas rctjobcable bp tbc kc- 
 Cato;Durfngl)<sUfe, anotberefojeftcannctbcfaf^ti^at it teas cljcr an 
 abfolutc tcleafe ,• IBut <f t^fs rcleafc bau been in tljc rcaltp, ft nifgt)t ftu 
 aotentnrc tjatje httn ott)crtof ic ; but it is r ot fo bcre; foj tbc aebt nolo rctto 
 fnt^cCrccutoj, anoitfsa devaftavic (n t^c Cpecutoj to telcafc:ft, foi 
 tftfo is bat a iLcgacte , anDftuiapbetbetcarcDcbtgoiDfng, tobtrfjarc to 
 bepafobefojcHiegacfcs, ano bete ootft not appear to be anp aCTeto in tbc 
 Crccntojs banco, befioestbis ticbt, anolftbcaCcttatoj tooulDba\3erclea« 
 feD(t, be ougbttobafeeconcUbpaDeeo. Roll chief luttice, SQljat (ball 
 tbc Crecuto J Do fn tW cafe:' 3! tonccfue (t fa a ttrong cafe fo j tbe Crccuto? , 
 anti t^at ft is tjerp unrcafonable tbat tbcSCcftato j Qjoulo maUe fucb a Dcbffe, 
 ano fjcre is no confent of Mary tbc Ctecutoj erpjeffec to tbfa rcleafe, be. 
 Cdcs a toUl cannot releafe a tbfng ctcateo fap decd , ano fo cifcbarge Cteof* 
 tOJS» Nicholas 8nD Ask lurticcs ConcuttcD ; JBut lerman luftice 
 toubteo* iFoj a fault fa tbc \siit of CEtto?, ano fmperfectfon in tbc rcto jtt 
 certffpcD,tl)c SltfOgment teas not tbcn affirmcjD* ^ftertoarD g>fr Humphrey 
 Style p jcfcrrcD b<0 WU <n C^ancerp to be rcUfbeo betcfn , aiitj obtcpnco an 
 fnjunttfon tfU bearing ; but uponabcarfngTittbclRollscoulogetno relief; 
 IbutlnasojDereDtopapioo l,o> elfe t^e injunction to be DfCToltieD^ Q» 
 Nota.- 
 
 Hamond againft Ward, 
 
 Triut idjuBanctfup. 
 I»afc,ii5o»rot» 58» 
 
 AJ^ Action of Debt toas bjougW agafntt tbc SDefenDanf, upon an iniiranl Error to re- 
 Computavcrunr,antiatertittani> a Juogement giten agafntt l){m,^"f«» ju-^r- 
 lubetcnponbebjoug^tbistojitofflEtroj, ano afsfgns fo; €rro?. , t^jat tbe ""*"''" ^*^' 
 Miction teas bjongbt agafntt bim fojtcntaBaS^c^antoflano, ano not as J^fXcmpuu- 
 a rcceitcr , ano tbat tbetefoje an atcompt DfD not lp<f^ Roll chief luftice verunr. 
 citco 20 H. 6, tbat tent alone Ipes not in accompt, becanfc rent is a certain 
 tbing, anoitfaalfofntbetealtp; butiftcntbcmiiccD tottb otljcr tbings . 
 an accompt toiU Ipe ; bat bete ft appears tbc adfonis b^ougljt agafntt tbc "°'^^'' 
 SDefenD^nt as a recef bet , ano if one tccef be monp one to mt upon an ob< 
 Ifgatfon, 3! flijall bate cftbcr an 0ctfon of accompt, oj kn Siction of Debt a. °'''^' 
 gafntt bfm , fo ff be recef tc mp tents teftijout mp confent, Tfiereforc Ice 
 the ludgemcnc be iflirmed, 
 
 Alleyn againft Holden. 
 
 Trin. 1^51, Banc, fup. 
 EntredPafc, 1^50, 
 
 Ai^atffonofDcfattDasbjongI)tagafnttan^efr,tol>opleaMrieni perdif- Errortore- 
 cent,! Slnosmcnt U)as gfbcn againft bim upon a nihil dicit , % a tojft of ^^'rc a judg. 
 cnqairp toas atoatuco toftbout t^c pjapct of tbc pattp, anD a fpccfal JuDge. "^'"^ '" ''***' 
 mcnt mtiam giben agafntt tl&ejaD«fcnDant,mpon a tojf t of Crroj bjongbt h^T*^ *" 
 
 to *
 
 'Wiir uf in- 
 
 288 Trin. 16 5^ 
 
 ^tote'bctfctl)fo3;aogcmcnt, It toao alleagco foj erroj,ti3at tbc 5«5gcmcnt 
 ought to taDcbeena general 3uDSemnt , atiD tbetc ought not to ^aDe 
 been a tojltof cnqutrp, eictcpt the pattp ban p?apeD<t , ano to t'ofa tbc 
 Court cncUneD , ano Roll chief luftice fatD, tftat (t <a otbertoffc (11 an ,'actf^ 
 onagamCanCrccHtor, fo; tljcre affcts map be •^ouno, iSt aiiotljcr oop 
 Roll chief luOice fa(D, H tfjc |)r(r plcaD ricns per difcenr , anD if (t Oc a falie 
 plea, a general SJuogcmentoiigl'.ttobcagafnftbfm, ano tt)crc fljaii be no 
 iDjit to er.rjufrc IcfjatlantJs be batl) , anOlt in not neccffarp, ag fterc U fs, to 
 lu g-msnt. ^g^p a fpccfal SuDgcmcnt, tljat tftc jpiafntfff fljall rctoljcr of tljc lanue n<r- 
 ccnBCD,(o; tbe Jtiugement oug^t to be tbat tijc 2DcfcnDantfl boop tir^ goooa 
 be Ipablc , ano half Ijfo lanoa , ano not ao ft Is bcrc a Vojft to enquire , ano 
 finototjatlantisbcbatljbpbfrtcnt, Rtverfet.nifi, 
 
 Earcock againft Tbmpfon. 
 
 Tifn. i6ji,Banc. iup» 
 
 Erro Hi ^'^ ^^^^ ^^^ ^2^*" ^^^^■^^ ^ unto,U)Ucl) tDBs tljtij , aji'^cment \oas gf* 
 
 broupiir by • ^S" <!i tl)C Comon plcao againft tbc pjliufpal toftbout an o;{glnal,| up» 
 ih: Bjii to on tftfs Jtiogment t^cre Iffueo out a fcirc facias againft tbcSBail,! tito nichils 
 vcric a jujg. returneD,anD tbercnpon Sucgtnent toae gitjcn againft ti)c JlBafl,? a tojft of 
 mcnt eivcn (j^j^o} toaa bjougt)t bp tl)C IBall to rctjcrfe tblo guDgmcnt.iant) it loas nolo 
 Jun'cipa!"' argwco bp Hales Of Counccl (o J tl)e iDjit of CBrroj , tftat t^e Sutgmcnt leas 
 crroneou0,bccaufe It being glbcn upon a fcirc facias,U)bltb la a jutsiiial in jir, 
 It ougbt to be gtounoeo npon an original , ano ft not being fo ftcre, (t ia (Et- 
 ro; in fact, altbougl) it be not dDrro J In JLato. SlotbiaftVDacanflBcrca, tbat 
 tlto nichils returneo upon a fclre facias, amount to a fcire feci , anD a )uDg- 
 mcnt gitien tbcrcupon la gooi , anD tl)crcfo?c it la too late nolo to fap, tljat 
 tbe fcire f ici s toaa not toell erecuteO. Brook Sc fac. 96: 28. 1 7 Car. C. B. ' 
 SEo tbfsHales faiD,tberc toaa a Bluogcmcnt againft ua fn tbcCommon plcaa, 
 fotbat toe conlD urge nothing againft tljc Icire facias tb:rc ;but here ine 
 ma^. Roll chief luttice anftocreD, It ia to fome purpofc to mahe up tbc te- 
 co?Dupontbc tU)onichi!F,otterlDfrctbcrclDoulDbcno enoof tbings, ano 
 iu(f c ' tbc guogcment la luell giDcnbptbcBiuDgcB, ano boti? can pou now^ maUe 
 " ^""'"'" cBrrojInltc-anDifpoubcinconDenienccDbptbcSi'Dgemcnt, pouarc not 
 tiror. tDitbontrcmcop , fojpoumapbjlngan Audita querela, ana pou migbt 
 
 baDe pleaocD to tbc fcire facias, nul tiel record , foj It la not matter of fact. 
 Audita qui ^^j therefore (hew better matter why the ludgeraent Jlall not 6e affirmed j 
 and take liberty to bring an Audita querela. Antea* 
 
 Tucker againft Co n\ 
 
 Trin. i6ji Banc.fup* 
 Enrred Trin, 1650, rot» 3 88. 
 
 •i-cijivcr 'T^'''*''^*''^-^*^^'^'''^^'"^^^^"^^''^' foJ iJtttrefnins bfa Cattel. JEbc 
 ^lain»]"' DefctiQantmaSeaconufarreaoiiBallptoI. S. anD upon tbc atoiujp 
 i'ltv.n. tbeffc fell out to be tlila. 3 traccfman,<n tonfioeration of mariage,maD6 
 acontjepanccof tfalanDfltotbeufc ofblmfel^anDofbl'T toffc, ano aftet* 
 toaros becomes a HBancbrupt, ano a tommlfalon of IBanhrupt la taUen 
 out againft bfm , anD tbe lanoa of tbc ilBanUrnpt are folo bp tbc Commlfalo. 
 ncra fo tbe atjotoant tbat toob tbe Dlttref0. %^t queftlon bcrc toaa , tebe- 
 
 tbet
 
 Trin.1651. 289 
 
 foljetl)crtfti0cont)epancemat)cbpt^c 5BanUrnpt of bfs l&nna toaa inftWn 
 tbe statute of frautiulcntcantei.'ancc3o;i not, ano t^e fale matie bp tl)e 
 Commffofoncraofttia lano toctc gooo. Maynard foj t^e piafntff ar* 
 guco , t^at it i0 not loUbtn anp of tl)e statutes of SSanbrnpts. E^^e 2Dsi) 
 bercfsuit^outfrauD; ano fo U (0 not Ui(tl)fn tbc statute; fo^ a Valuable 
 confiocratlon ia onlp cjpjetfeD in tlj: Statute , anB not a contjcpance upon 
 tonCOctatfonofmarfage, asftteas in our tafe* zip. 2nije jFctnc fs but 
 one petfon toftb l)ct l^aabano. 3 Ip. JiBp r omparfng tbc fetatutee togettjct 
 it appears tbattt<ebiife{0 not compjffco toUMn tije Statute of i Iicobi, 
 tX)t)fcb looks bach to ot^;cr Statutes toucMng 315anUrtipt0. foj tftc Irifc fsiuit 
 namcD In tl)c statute of 1 lacobi , but onip d <lo jcn ar.D ot^jcr pcrfona , o« 
 tl)crtoife tlje iDojos oftljc MVlW^ Do enumerate cbflojcn , ano otber per* 
 fonfl,li)otiH)befr(tolou3anD(Dle. Roll chief luftice faJD, t^e Cafe (0 of 
 great confcquencc , ano Crifp ann Pratt cafe Dotb fomcto^jat rcfemblc tbfs* 
 SDfteiLaiDfntenD0a315anferuptU)!)fc^(0ro bp frauB, as luell 80 a IBanU- ^'"'''"P^- 
 tupt U)l;o becomes fo bp ettfoent , ano foj tbfs tanfe ts lie calico an iDffcn- 
 Dctfn tbeatatutc, anDl)crctbepcarofour ilojo i6j7'<stftc ij pear of 
 tbc late lifnpj 5 tbc rccoterp fuff crcjj bp tlie JBanferupt teas tften, anc toftbfti 
 ^alf a pear after tbe rcroterp , tje became a IBanbrupt, fo tbat me 
 tWnfes tbcrc plalnlp appears to be frauo (n tbe Contepance, but p^,,.j ^ 
 t^cfrauo l0noteyp;cffctj in tljc plcaofng, as <t mfgbt tjatje been. %\)i " * ' 
 statute of I lac. <0 fomeh)t:at Doubtfull as 31 concetbe , anoBI do not rdea< 
 np p^obfRon maoe in it againlt tlje Uiife , if frauo do not appear , fo^ ^ere 
 is no baluable confiocrntioti mcntioncD. Nicholas jufticc fafo, it is Doubt* 
 fufl , ptt be conccibcD it Initbfn tbc Statute of i lac.ubicb ougtt to recc ibe a 
 large corftrnction, becaufeit faas maoe foj tfte goon of t^ie Commontuealtb. 
 lerman anO Aik agrcetj Uitb Roll in omnibus. Roll , !^ere tbc matter 
 in Difpute is not in a fpccial tlletbict , but comes in qucfiion npon 
 point of pleaotng , tcbtcl) (ball be taben moS Qrong againS btm tbat pleaos Pieiding. 
 it , ano be Ijatb not evp^ciTco anp Valuable conQocration, as be m{gl}t babe 
 Bone , bp raping in confioeratlon of a pojtion, 0; in recompence of mariage, 
 0; in performance ofilrtlcles mane upon mariage , oj t^at tlje tiife ^ao 
 jopncD in felling fomc part of tbe lano. The Court would advife, but en. 
 dined Judpement ought to be for the Avowant. Afterwards judgement wac 
 given accordingly , for the Court lield the wife ivas within the Statute of i 
 Jac. and che providing for wife and children to be providing for binifcif. 
 
 Ciiapman againfl: Brook. 
 
 Tfin, i<J5i,Binc»fup» 
 Trin» 1^50, rot. aoo. 
 
 Ti^ an ^aion upon the Cafe tbe ^Dlaiotif DcclareD upon a Cuffom of cont« Demurrer m 
 moiling in fncb a place. SClie SDcfenbant oemurreo to tbe 2Dcclaration,» Dcciar»io:i 
 anDfojca«rcft)cli)3tbattbeCuComU)asnot toell laiD; foj tf)e piaintJf'"*"^Jj,^" 
 Declares of a CuSom of commontng , pro averiis , viz- pro equij, bobus ,€-""'* " ^' 
 quabw^etpuiiif, anDtbc tocjt pullis ic Of ah uncertain Ognffication, foj it 
 tnapfJoniiicaCalf, allamb, oi anp otbf r ponng J5caft oj i^oul , ano 23 
 Car. Sep,ar anD Dyeri CCafe teas citcD. JDljc Court belD tbe etccpfion gooo, 
 ano fnfp, tbat it is incertain inbat is meant bp tbe Iroju pullus, aitO faia, tbat 
 iftbcp:cfcripf(onbaD been pro omnibus averiis, it fjoD been gooD, ann tbeprcfaipno.i. 
 vi7,.ll)OulDftatiebfcnboiO; but Ijcre it is onlp pro averiis. therefore, nil 
 capiat per billara» 
 
 |9p Hcwj
 
 2 90 Trin. 1 6 $h _^ 
 
 Newton againft Godard. 
 
 Trin. 1651, Banc, fup. 
 
 Error tore A tSrlt of Ctroj 11)80 bjoug^t to TEtcrfc 8 juDCcmcnt cftjcti (fl anSlil- 
 
 v'crf, a juipe- ;/\onof2Dcbtat Ipfwitch. SLljc Cafe teas tb(3. sntcrctffueo out a Ca- 
 
 lucnt iii'^ck. piasa(Tatnfftl)cp?inc(pal, anna jaogEmcnt toaogfljcn agnfntt Ijfm; ano , 
 
 after iifcire facias iffucD cut agaftifttbcJlSail, anu a juDgcmcnt tb'rcupon 
 
 toas ntben agaJnft tljc JBttil ; EEictt tljc plafntit tahcs out an Crctutfon , 
 
 viz. a'ficri facias agafnft tlje J9?fn£fpal, ano )lBatl,upon botb t{)c juogcmcnta, 
 
 to let)}/ tt)c Debt rccotcrcD upon tbc gooos ano chattels of t^c p:tnclpal ano 
 
 3!5aU , oj ct'tUcr of tljcm. Bt toaa allcgeD t^at tljc cjrccntfon tftuo taltcn out 
 
 toao net good , foj tfjcrc ougt)t to bate been fctjctal crccntfons upon t^ic rc« 
 
 Exccflt.on. Deval jiicgcments , ano not one cycctitfon , ano to t!)(ci tfjc Court agrccD , 
 
 and ordered the Defendant in the writ of Error to flitw caufe why the judgc« 
 
 ment fhould not be rcvcrled, 3n tl)f3 Cafe Roll chief luftice took an C)ctcp= 
 
 Abrcvbtion. t-<on to tljC fcire facias , bftaafctt loas fcire factDftI) a Daft) , tetfc^ mfgljt be 
 
 as ircll fcire faciatis as fcire facias, 
 
 vS'piLclchoule againft Farmeiy. 
 
 Trin, 1 65 1. Banc, (up; 
 
 Hill. 1550, rot. 43, 
 
 Krror to re- * j^ girtfoH of flfcompt irSsbjouaftt agatnft a JTcme Cotert an Hamf- 
 
 vcifea jxi.^-. |/\,,jaratr(t ant) her l)'.:sbano<ntbe Common picng, ano juDgcmcntaf. 
 
 '"n"^aJn'V/ *cn.ngafnC tl)e H^cfcnoants quod compurent. 2LI)Circinc3fco, ano tbc 
 
 A conipt" " l^njJbnnD tjjfnga a to><t of C-rroj in tljis Court to rcbcrfe W-s 3!ucffemcnt» 
 
 Koll chief luff ice !3ClD, tliattl}Cto;ftof Crroj tto not Uc, bccaufc t!)r He* 
 
 to:D cannot be rcmoticD bp (t , fo? tijat tooulo cftturb tl)e piocecDtngs in tlie 
 
 Comnttn picas , ant) tbcpartp tooulo tja'ocRofrnU of Ijia fate, if the lie 
 
 <o:o ftonlD be rrmoDco , noj anp rcmcop to rccofccr X\\z arrears cue unto 
 
 t)fnT; l^ct ti)c£)jf0.{naUsBctcrmfncDbp the SuogemcntgCocn quod com* 
 
 '^ci'cTiaa. putent, anDafcircf;'ciaslicsbptI)nCrcCUtoj,a0tf)Cfarel)Cre<0. lerman 
 
 i.ia-. jj,^ij.gjQtjj(.fa,ij(.lfrC£t, anOtftCDi H. 7, f. 2. Nicholas luflice tofhcfamc 
 
 fntcrit; anofafa. Ijcofonct much rrgaro the IBook of 21 Ed, j, becaufe 
 
 there Pre other iSooksacafnft ft. Asklufficcad idem. Roll cliief loftice 
 
 put thrfc cafes. 3 ju^gcmcr.t toas ai'otw in Dotocr fo: the SDemanoant , 
 
 ano .inolher iu5acinent that fljc fljall rrcotcr her Damagco, and ihfs fcs 
 
 f one (uogcment foj the Damages teas rcfccrfcc Op a to><t of Crroj , becaufe 
 
 flic Dfo not a^jcr that her li^asOano cf co reffeo . f n tohfch cafe Ihc is to hatic 
 
 lu' <m:- iiooaii^ngBB; pct thc firff (uDgcttient fo? the DolDcr flooO uiTCl'erreo, anD 
 
 ^' ' ' Hi!'. 43 Eli7. C. B. fn one Williams anD Whites cafe , fn an fltijon of j3c- 
 
 ccmpt a juogcmcnts tocrc gflcn, ano the fccono toas retjctrco, ano the 
 
 R'.fi Cooo unrcl'CrfCD. In the principle cafe the rule wss judicinro, nifi. 
 
 Wallij 
 
 <
 
 Trin. 1651. 291 
 
 VValis againft Bucknal. 
 
 Trio. i6ji,Banc.fuf>» 
 
 Trin. 1649, ror. 600, 
 
 H 7 ^on a fpctf al tacrtftf t^c cafe fcB mt to be tftb, iDne feffeo of Copp- spccai vcri 
 y ijololanosoffnb r(ta»icemaDealctterofjatta?nep j?uto ttoo jopnt-^f^''*'""* 
 Ip attD fctcrallp , to furteno: r tfte lanaa after bfa ucat^ to ccrtafn afco , u- mj,,'^'" ''' * 
 cojDingto tte Cufiom oUU ^ano^, SL^equcftfon luas, to^ctljer tbte 
 toaBagocDCoffomojno, ElliiofCountelijLltbtfte|9IalnttfatgnED, tl)at 
 ftUjasnotagoooCuftom, bccaafe a Cuffotn oiigbt to be rcafonablc, but 
 tftfs Cufiom (0unteafonable, faccaufcit fa not onlp agafifl a partitulat 
 latD, bat ft fa agafnftttje general rale of lato to paf^s cftates of {iil)erf« 
 fancefnfacft a ^anoj; anoaltljougbpsrtfcularCuftomomapbe againtt 
 puHfqnc fntcrcft pro bono publico , pet tbfs is notbfng to our cafe , fo j tWi* 
 feiiotfojttie publtquegooD , anutfterefojeftfgnot gooo, ilp. janautbo. 
 ritp ougt»t to be coantermanoable , ano to octcrmfne bp tbe ocatb of tt:c 
 partp tbst eftics tbe autbojftp ; but ber$ ft fs not fo , but ft is to contfnwc aU 
 tct bfs Dcatb» i^eyt, no man can gfbe aatftojftp to anotbcr to co a tWng 
 tDbfcb be bfmfelt coulo not do , but bs^tc ft fc otbcrtoffe, ano toe rcfo jc ft fo 
 not gooo. jaifo bp tbe oeatb of tbe Coppbolber tbe Hlato fettles tbe lanDs 
 fntbcbefr, ano an aatbo?ftp cannot tfbett tbcm out of bfmj tbfs fs not 
 Ifbetotbcfnrrenojfi.gofCoppbolDlanDsfntG tbe bancs of tbc Hojd, fo; 
 fntb a farrenoct cannot be rebotscD , bat tbfs autljojftp map be rcbobeo: 
 JB jt tDbfcb fs mojE , tbc aerofdbcre Doth not finotbat tbc ttoo j3ttojncps 
 atccnftomarpSCena-.teoftbc^anoj, butonlp bp leap of recital, iibfcb 
 fenotgooD; fojtbcp ought to babe been foonofoDfrcctlp; noj Dotb ft ap. 
 pc3ttbattbeptnEtecuft"n«arp2Ccnant3 at tbc time of tbc aomfttance of 
 tfcep irtp , n-Mt:i;'i t- tbti ~ anp poffcfefon sr title founD fn tbc ■Dcfenoant , . 
 anofo the ^iJntifl;.-:^;f.igp?fmctpoirer0(on,thc Defenoant fs culpable; 
 Kcfc.;:cr ta ft 'onnD tbat tb? Cuftomarp JCcnant , tubo gatje tUs autbo;ftp, 
 5aD an rflate fn fccSmple fn tbc lanDs , ano ff be bao bat ai cCatc foj Ufe , 
 Ibe coulo not maltc foch a iettct ofSittojncp; neftbetfstbe antboiftp cf. 
 ten toarranteo bp tbt Cuftom , anD To t)c pjapeo iucgeincnt foj tbe pafit- 
 tff. Wilmoc fo; tbe ©efenoant , aBtotheambo;ftp,befafo ttH'.t ft Uias 
 gcDD , ano ofo iDell cnonsbfMrtftic tbe partr tbat gate ft, bccaufeft fs fup« 
 po?tcD teftb a fpecfal Dfrrctfon from tbe partp tbat gaf e ft. i H. 7. 8. ariD tbfa 
 tstbcteafon tbat an (Sjecuto; map fell lanos of tbc IDcftato; after bfs 
 oeatb, viz. bccaafe bff! aofjojftp fs fo rappojfco, 21 E. 4, f. 8, 31 E. 1, 
 Fitz. Grants 45 . 3nc bcre fn our taCc tbe bcft batb negletteo bis aotta'^tage, 
 ano tbcrefoje fbafl not noto bt aomfttcD to take ft. IBtit bcCocs tbu autbo. 
 rftpbcrecf^r.nfgmojet!:rtna bare autbojftp, foj ft fa batUco -itftb tbc 
 tfrcurtiftances of time, perfans, ano of a Zattom , iobfcb fo uot of a fltabt c. 
 Ccem fn 3Lato, ano bp iocb a Cattom trbfcb iff ^erp reafonablc ; fo; ft fs 
 buttocttablctbJ^pfJitp to tffpcfcofbfoolxjn lanos ; ano far mojc atircafo» 
 nable Cuftomstban t^f ^ arc allotocc fn onr lato, as tliat fn Kent fo; an 
 3Irfantof 15 peats of^gc to babe pofecr to fcu bfs lanos ; neftbet fs tbts 
 Cuftom contrarPiO a; ipaoStfbe role of HaU); fo;ft fs bcre to create tbe 
 aatboj'tp to bigin afi^r tbc partfcs oeatb tbat crcateo ft , ano fo ft fs not to 
 oetetmfnetoffbhfsoLatb, fo; tfU tben f t begfns not , ^.no tbe Cuttom bcre 
 fo but to alien lanuj , tofifcb f« no ftrangctblng , ano tbfs Cuftom crtcnos 
 buttoftbfntbcf^ano;, tobttbfstuttoafmalUompafsofgtoanO; ano fo 
 
 i^Pi. . ' tbc
 
 the ptiblt'nnc lo not mtitl) conccrncD (n (t , ann tbc cafe of 1 7 Car, in t^f 
 Court, Bambridgc anD Whaddons cafe Dfffeta from our Cafe ; fo j that toaa 
 not fnppojtco tottl) a cuftome ao tftts fa. ^nu ft ootft appear bp tbc IRcco ju, 
 tijat Dal by tl)c 0ttojne{' <0 a ctiftomarp SDcnant, ano t^c aomifflfon ia alft) 
 founo bptbe clcrOfcttobelecunduniconluetudinemManerii, anO fo tljat is 
 trcUcnongb, ano tbcn one cannot gafn a CoppbolDcftatcbpcfffefQn, ano 
 fo no p;<mcr feffin (tiall be (ntcnocD, as tuas tusco on tbc other fioe , ano ft 
 (0 alfo founo tbat tbe CoppliolDer Idas feffeo. Roll chief luflice , Bit \jM 
 
 Cuftcm. be a haro matter to mafntatn the Cuttom , <f <t be not foano that tbc Co^ 
 bolDcr teas fcf 'eo in fee of tlje CoppbolD lams. alp. 3t ia not Ijcre fountt 
 tbattbelanofiJDcmifablc, accojcfngto the totU of tbc jLojo, anD fo ft 
 map befrcelano, antitbcntbccuflomtotl) not ertcno unto ft, noj is ft 
 founo that the parties to VDbomtljc ^letters of attojnc? tBcrcmaoc toerc 
 
 Diffc fin. CoppbolD SEenants. 0niJthep;fmcrpoffcfBfon tolll mahe a DfffefOn here 
 bp the SDefcnoant , ff the cuDtom be not loeH founo, ano fo Juogcmcnt mutt 
 
 D<:^-c- be foj the pinfiilff. 3nD 3; cannot fee hoto the Cuff om can be gooo , ft be^ 
 
 Sarre dcr ^''5 ^gafnfl the ruUs of ILaiD. Si man cannot oebffe Coppholo lanuo, ana 
 " ■ thfs cafe fs too jfc , but he map futrenosr to the ufe of hia laff JlSim. 31f 
 pou tof 11 not confent to a netn trpal toe tof ll aubf fc , foj It fo a haro cafe, ano 
 mp 5iB; others hatic not been attenDeD tofth iBmfes. Mich. foUotofng Iu(ige» 
 tnenc was given for the Piaintif,nifit Itwasmovcd again , and the Court 
 would advife. Poflea. 
 
 BatcHelouragainft Paribns. 
 
 Trin, 1^5 » Banc, fup* 
 
 Mich, 1^52, rot. 381* 
 
 , T) Atchelour bjfngs a Itjft Of Ctroj to reberfe a Jubgcmcnt gfhcn acrafntt 
 
 vc'r7/a Me ^^m foj ParfoHs <n an 3ctfon of SDebt fu tbc Common picas, ano the 
 
 nicflt 'in 'ac*br. <Etro J afsfgncD toas , tliat there ate ttoo JDcclaratfons fn the JRecojD , one 
 
 in ttc emparlance IR0U, the other in the pea laoll, ano the £);igfnalcet« 
 
 tlftcouponthctojitofCrrojDothnottoarranttbefirttSDcclaratfon, foj it 
 
 Iras fileD after ft, Hales anftDereo, that tbe IRecojD fs gooo enough , ff the 
 
 £);te.fnal Co Tjarrant the laflSI>ctlarat(on,fo? tiis fa the common courfe ufeD 
 
 fji.tfjc Common |D[ea0,a6 the Clarhs tt)erc uo fnfojm mc, j there arc manp 
 
 Cafes Itbc this in the Common peas. Wild of Conncel on the otbet ftoe 
 
 itnftorreo , that this fs a ftrange courfe , fojthep ought ffrft to file the £); 
 
 rfefnal, becaufcftfstbebcginnfnganD gronno^toojU of the fute; ano it 
 
 rot being fo eonc hete, the Suogcmcnt fa gfben tofthout an :©;«2inal, 5 this 
 
 ia a juogcmcnt bp Default , ano the imparlance is part of the fute. Roil 
 
 impatiancf. chief luftice , SLhe^mparlance IRoU fs the piiucipsl part of the fute, ano 
 
 iii.cncnicnc. to confouno tbfngs bpfiitenDment , that the imparlance map be touching a - 
 
 .Ccttioian. nothctfute, isnotgooD, anD it matters not tohat the Cuflom ia in the 
 
 Common peas, if it be againtt llato, ans both IRoUs ought to be certi< 
 
 ftcDbere. lermanlufticead idem. Roll chief luftice, 0H the I'^ecojD in 
 
 the Common ^Blcas, tohfch fa fn the cuftoup of the chief Jufifcc there, ought 
 
 to bccertificD bphfm upon the IRctojn of the MritofCErroj , ano herethc 
 
 gmparlsnce IKoU Is in h'e cuttoop, ano tbercfojte he ought to certffie ft; ano 
 
 ^,ror. if there be tUjoto;its of^rroj, ano one is gooo ano the other naught, 
 
 'ive U ill taUe the bett to affirm the juogcment. SEhe £D jigfnal ought not to 
 
 be fittPD to the 2Declaratfon , but the SPr claratfon to the fl) jfgfnal , becaufe 
 
 !U £):fst.;al is tU fotuioatton of the fute , anD tljcrcfojc the courfe nfcD fn 
 
 m
 
 inn. 1(551. 2,93. 
 
 tbe Common peas fs a p^cpottcrous course, viz. to orclare agafutt tfje Original. 
 JDcfcnoant, ano after to file an ojfcinal asafnft titm, to toarrant i\)C 
 ■BDeclatation.Bt (s fterc ccrtffpcii to be ore 3lRcco?l),aiit) !;oJr tan toe take tbe 
 emparlance II0U to be part of tlielRetozo, it befngnot ccrtpfico toJtbft:" 
 anDiftl)creba tartancc bcttuecn tljc emparlance I'^oll, ano tbe pica HoU, Variar.ee. 
 ft i0 Crtoj, We will advife ; but tec muft not faffcr nc to toapcs , pet toe 
 arelott>,nottoftlfiauD{ng toreterfe SwogemEnts gftcn fn tfte Common 
 pleas. Therefore (hew caufe next term, why the ludgement ftiould not be 
 rtverledt 
 
 Kirman againll lohnfbn. 
 
 Trin, 155 »» Banc fup, 
 
 Ijj^ an ejeftione firms bjongljt bp Kf rman agafitC lohnfon a fpctfal tJerDfct Sp«iai ver~ 
 toas founo , ano upon It tl)e cafe fcU cut to be t^u?, A gating lanes in fee '.*ift >" '" c- 
 fimple.ano alfo gooas ano t^atcls to t^e taiuc of 5 l.onlp tn Tavenock.maoe ^'^'^'^^■^ ''•- 
 flf0 MfU ,anD DcWfeo to W tolfe totum ftatum ibum, viz. l)fg toftclc Cttatc™"^" 
 papfng})fsSDEbt0,anD ILcgacfcs , anoWsJSDcbtsanD Jlegacfcs Dft5 smount 
 totl)ct)altieof4ol. HalesmaDe2qucCfon0, i. Mlbctbcr tl&e lanD0 palTc 
 tot^ctotfebpt^eMttt ojuot. alp. Sftljepoo, tobatcftatcpaffct^olicr 
 fntftc 3Lant)0. iFojtftefirft be argneo- tbat tbe lanD0 no paffe to tbe 
 toffe* 1. IBccaufetbegcncralttpoftbetoojD&DofncluDc tbc lanos, as 
 tocU a0 tbe gooD0 , fojt6ctoojD0are!)t0tol)ole(E;ftatc, fo tbat notWng is 
 ejclufleOjpE. 4<.atcleafeofaU Sidioae^ is bclo a teleafe of all jacttons 
 tbat tbe partpbau<n aU W capacftfe©. 2lp» SCbe ojDfnarp maner of 
 fpacb Dotb ftcto tbat be fntcnocD to Dctffc bts U!nD0, as tocll as bfs gooDs. 
 Richescarc,Mich.45.Eliz. CBanc. ^DctjffeofaUb<3 tents toao belo to 
 (aire ail tbe pattpes lan&0. 0iro tbe fub^tt matter in fact ootb p?obe tbfs 
 tobeW0{ntent, ano altboagb bere is not a collateral atcrmcnt to pjoDe 
 tbe intention , bntacollatsralpjoofto Declare tbe atcttatojs intent, tbts 
 map beaomitteD to afcertain tbe Court of bis meaning , as it is in tt)e cafe 
 ofp?ot)ingana£tof|9arliament. 3!n tbe 5Lojo Cheneys cafe, an abet- 
 ment ttantiing toitba ^ill teas accompteo allotoable, tbougb an a« 
 termentagainftaOTIllbcnot; 31nCooper ano lanes cafe, ^S Eilz. a ce. 
 tifc feigniori puero, tobere tbe ffiettato; bao a &on , ano a SDaugbtcr, toss 
 beloagooiJDeWctotbe&on.altbongbpaerCgnifies a0 toell a SDaugbtec 
 asa&on, ano tbe Pangbtcrtbere lias cloet tban tbe &on, anoHru 8. 
 Car»lnBartIctanDRode$ cafcinB.R.aDebifeofallbislanDsin Dale, if 
 bebaoleafes.as'toeUaslanDSjtbere paffeo not tbe leare0. jFo; tbe 2d. 
 pointbeargueDtbatafceCmplcpaffeD. i. JiBecaufcbtstobolcc^aatcisDe^ 
 Difco , ano tbat is to be applpen as toell to tbe lanDo, as to the goous, alp. 
 JbecanfeintegatDtbattbtreisaconCDerationfojit, totoit tbat tbe toifc 
 fljall pap bis SDcbtfl , ant) Bifcbarge bis iLcgacfcs ,• anu tobcrtas it is obfca:. 
 eD, tbat it is not faio (be (ball ^p all bts SDcfats , 3 anftocr, tbat it (ball be 
 To intenoeo. l^cre is lano ano goo^is mcntioneD, ano not lano onlp, ano ft 
 (sfonhD tbat tbe gooOBonlp arc not fuf fief cnt to pap tbe S^cbts, mn alfo 
 tbe gooDs toere liable to tbe papment of tbe SDebts, toitbout tbis crpjefsion 
 IntbeOTill, anotbetcfojctbelantimuttbeintenDeDto be dcWcd, ano 
 foj tbe terDict ft is not material to SnD tbe lanes to be belD in focage, foj 
 tbep (ball be intcnOM to be fo biH),becaufe ft fs tbe mott anticnt2Ecnurc,to? 
 tobere tbe iato creates a SEcnurc, it (ball be forage 2Ecnurc. alp. 31 anas 
 map pofsiblp be oetifeable , altbouiib tb? p be not belo in focage, fo; if tbcp 
 be ncltbet bclD fap forage, no? tbitjalrp, pet tbcp arc octiffcable, D j cr ? 07. 
 
 I?P3 . nciibc?
 
 294 ^""- *^5^' 
 
 Condition. 
 Li.iiitition 
 
 0eltW i»ii materfal to fitiu t^e Wthte, ano ILegacfes pafD, fo j ft (0 a ton- 
 D(t(on here, an not a Umftatfon, anu tijerc (0 a perfon to tafee aotantage <f 
 the concitfon be bjoUcn,i tWs ia a fpcclal t)crDla,f t^c bjcabfng of tl)c con* 
 Dftion a it ftao b&n b:okcn,tDoalD bate appeareo upon ctfocnce, 5 t^crefojc 
 a ta not neccffarp to atet it,i Jt (5 fn cafe of aj^cc Cmplc.tDbfcb is an Cttatc 
 
 Dtvife. jntcnoeo to continue. Roll chief iumceftclD.tljattlje lanug DfD paffe, foj. 
 fo l)e fafo tbe common nnnerftanofng fmpo;tt3 , ann tbe Uiojos do go to tbc 
 Dalueoftbetflate. i. 3tcomp}cbcnDgtb«tbfn!J',toU)fttl)elanD. alp,, 
 SLftceitentoftbeCftatcgftien, vix. IFeelimple, anDfoUOjaUbe fterefnt- 
 tenoeo, anDtbclDo^nopapfngbfs&EbtsaniJ Hesacfcs ootb cnfojcc tbfft 
 confiructfon , fo^ tl)cp are to be paio p?etcntlp, U)l)fcl) cannot bc,(f tbe lanos 
 paCTe not fn i?ee , ano fo tbe aberment ft fs but tofupplp tbe meanfns of tbe 
 aCcOatoj, ann ttanoa bcrp UieU teftb t^e BZHfU, anbfanot fo collatcrall, 
 asftfflfnCheyncysca'e. iJnbfojtbetcrbfcttbelanDa (ball be fntcnoeo 
 
 Intendment, ^^ j.^, fj^ggc jj^pg 30 bcfng tftc Hiott >i;ommon Cenutc, epcept tbe contra- 
 rp Vicrc (betoeD on tbe otber part , Denliam anDB»kerjcafr,MicJi. 14 EI* 
 cncred Trin. z3.roc. It. 80. anotbetDOjOspapfns bfs Sr>ebt3 , anb ILcga* 
 (te0,areU)O}v)0Ofcond(tton,anD not ofUmitatfon. lerman ad idem, and 
 fafs, Isbcn toe fap a man fs a man of a great <il;ftate, icc mean fK0 €ftatt fn 
 lanO0,a0tDeUa0gooD0. Nlclioiasauo Ask luHices to tbe fame effect; but 
 A^k faiQ be Doubteo of tbe terDf(t,bccanfe no ^egacfes are rouni),ani>tl)f0fs 
 part of tbe cafe, ludicium pro querente nifi, Antea, 
 
 Pickering and Emma. 
 Trin, i^ji, Banc, fop, 
 
 T Mma obtf fncn a 31utgemcnt agaf nft Pickering , anb bao fatfsfatffon up« 
 fcdcM upon t on ft , anu gate a rcleafe to tbe SDcfenoant, pet aftertoarog tahea out a 
 an audiw cspias ad fatiifaciendum agflintt bfm,U5bErEupon bc fa?fng0 Ijf0 Audita que. 
 querela. rela , ano motiC0 tbe Court tbat be map batje a luperlcdeas to tbe capias ad 
 i>ioughc. ^L fatitfaciendum. SLbe Court ocfireo to fcc tbe releafe , ano upon trfetD 
 
 thereof, The rule wa«, that the party fhould proceed in his audita querela ; 
 
 but faiU they would grant no fuperfedeas , becaufe the rekafe was ambigur 
 
 ou»- 
 
 Cuflodes &c. againft Rivctt. 
 
 Trin, i6ji.Banc.fup, • 
 
 Cjufe why "V Po^ ^ '^"^^ Of Court to fbelo canre tobp an attafcbment HjouId not be 
 ar, .^tiaich- ^ ttTantcoaoafr.ftonc,fojp?otcetfngtoatrpalfnanfnfcrfojCourt,not- 
 ni<nt(v.ou!a tcifttfianofng a habeas corpus cfrefleo to remote tbecaufc, 9in Affidavit 
 n ot be g. jj - jjjgg ^jj5,g^ tjjat tjjp pjocccofng to ttpal toaa, bccaofe ft toao fappofcD tbe ha« 
 " ' bea; corpus iBasagafnft tbe statute of 2 1 lac SCbe Court anftoereo, poti 
 
 ougtt to bate rcturneb tblo matter upon pour return ■ ant> not to bate p}0< 
 cecscD ngafnS tbe habeas corpus ; but let tbe &econDarp ctramfne tbe mat- 
 ter, ano tben mote agafn. But it is dangerous CO execute tbe ludgemeocj 
 Rctnr 0. jf jjjg Statu^g be not againft the habeas Corpus. 
 
 The
 
 Mich. 1651. 295 
 
 The Cuftodes againft ir.y Lord Morley. x 
 
 Trin. 1651. Biiic, fup. 
 
 T!^c Court teas motJtD on t!)C facIjalfoftbelLojU Morley foj a Certio-^°f» Ctmo- 
 rarito tcmotc an Cnfiiamcr.t picferrca scafrtt tjfm at tlje ^cfsf-'^'^'y^Jfa-'"' 
 ons of JDeacc at Hicks ^all ppon tfjc Statute aaafnft Ijrariiis of £pafs. £Lf)C.„cm. ,0 
 
 Court anflDcrcu , that they would advile, buttftat tlKl'DlD not fee ^oii) c /. U^-i-<>^- 
 Certiorari coulD be grantcB at tlje pjaper of ttje part? , but t^icp faffi ,/• 9^l^■ At- 
 at t^c p japct of t!)c Counccl fo j tlje @>tate it map be RtantcD. 
 
 Baker againft Smith. 
 
 Trin 1651 » Banc,fup» 
 
 BAkcrbjongljtanflctfonupont^ Cafe aaatV.ff Smith, anD DcclarcD ^ ^rcft of 
 tljat toijcreag tljcrc loag a fpeecl) concerning martagc bcttocen Ijcr tbe luJpemcnt iri 
 piaintif, anD Smith x\yt SDefcnoant, in confiocration t[)at flje tbc |aiatn.'" '^ ''^ "P" 
 ttf lioulo inatrp tl)C Dcfcnoant , tbc ©cfcnoant Dfo affumc ano pjomtfc to "" 'J'\|f If. 
 ftertbcJ-Malntif, that J)e luoulD marrp bcr, ano tUat aftcriuarcg tljc SDc-^rVu. 
 feneant , in conCscratton t^t tbc plaintif UioutD DifcliaTse tbe E>efenoant 
 oftMspjomifc, tl)cSDcfcnoantD(D affumc anopjomifctbat f)e tooulo pap 
 unto bcrtbcpiafntff, attjoufantipounl), sno tl)at Ojc d(d Dtfcbarcrc tbe 
 SDcfenDantofbispjomifeofmartaae; ano pet tlje S^efenoant Jjat) not paia 
 tftc loool. accojatngto^fspjomffc. taponnonafluropfitpleaDeD, anoa 
 teroid: fjouno fo j tlje jDlaintif , 3t teao moteo in Srrcft of Juogement tbat 
 tbeix f3 mention of ttuo pjomifcs in \^z SDeclaratfon, ana tbat it is incertain 
 toU)Wcbp;omifctbc2D:clarationrclatC0. 2lp. 2E!)at tbere is no tempo* 
 ral conKDcration allcgeo , but on'.p a pjoraffe to uiffolbe a Contract of 
 ^ariagc, toblcbioatbrngiUepl, anofono conftQcration. Roil chief lu- 
 itice nnftDcretJ, tbat bcrc is a mutual pjomife mane bp both parties , anD ^^'T'^*- 
 tftcre bate Lcen Dithers acfons of late times bjougljt foj tbiscaufe, ano tbep * ^* 
 IjatebccnaBjuDgeogootJ, ano the engagement to marrp is not mccrlpa 
 a fpirttual matter , ant) t^o Action to not to compel! tlje mariage upon tfte 
 Contract, but to recover DamagcBfo; rot Doing it, anD it is life to a tea* 
 gcr , ano iicre is a temporal lofs, ano tbcrefoje a tempo jal Action Dotb liCf 
 iSutitlDadaDtourncDtiUnertSDermtobeargaeD again, anD tljcn judges 
 ment was given for the Plaintif, fo: tl)e Court i^elD, that the dif-enpagement 
 fliall be intended to the party hiraielf, and here is no need to exprclTc notice 
 given of it, Poltea, 
 
 Kenedy againft Fifl\£r. 
 
 Micii. 1 65 1. Banc. fup» 
 
 KEnedy tcclarcD in an 3ction upon tbc cafe agafnC Fiftier foj fpcafefng whethf r a 
 tbefctro;03 0fWm, he lofl his Feet by the Pox, innuendo tbc Frcnrh picaof prWI- 
 Pox: £LbeDefcntanrDemurreDtotl)cH)cclaration, ano after impadcD, :--?« wasto 
 anD tbcn plcaocD a plea of pjfDilcgc. HaJes DcCrco the opinion of tbe Court, ^^ "'lowe-J. 
 toljetbcr tbis pica tocrc no\u aUotcablc, bccaufe tbe JB00U3 Differeo about it, 
 Koll chief ]uftict anfltjcrcD , tljat the plea is not allolnable , bccaufe there 
 \i but a pjitUege claimeo bp it , ano tt)c iplca goes not to t^c juitroiction o{ 
 
 tlje
 
 fr-^. 
 
 296 Mich. 16 51' 
 
 tlie Coutt , Therefore let the Defendant plead in chief, 
 
 Starkey againft Mill. 
 
 Mich,i6ji.Banc.fup, 
 
 EntredTrin, idji^rot, 170, 
 
 fuTecmcntin C Tarkey bjous^tan actfoH upoH tlic Cafe agafnft Mill upon t'jDO fetetal 
 an Albion up" OAfl'umpfics , ano obtains a tlIlcTD<(t upon bott) , ano entire bamaces are 
 on .nAflump. jjfbcn : 3(t tcaamobeo <n arrcft of iuDgement, tbat one of tlje p;om<rcfl 
 teas not gooo, becaufe tbere loas no conCoeration to grouno (t upon; ant> 
 fo tl)C DamagcB being intire upon botb ttic Affumpfiti,! one fafUngjiiogmcnt 
 cann ot be gitjcn, %}it cafe toas tbis , Sl^be JFatbcr gate bcddb to bis &on, 
 (n conftDcration that tbc &on ftoulDpaptbe ]piaintif in tW action 20 1 3t 
 toag urgcD tbat tbio can be no confiDcratfon fo; tbc piaintif to bjitig bis 
 action, becaufc here ia no Debt Due to bint, but onlp an appointment fo; tbe 
 &on to pap moncp to b^m , inconCtoerationoftbegooDs gibcn b<in bp bis 
 ifatber. 31ButHalesontbeotbErfiDcfaiD,tbatiftbcrcinapbeaDebtbp anp 
 tntencment Due to tbe |01aintif, tbcn tbe Affumpfit is goon, ano bete 
 Is a Debt Due tobim, therefore tbe Aflumpfu is gooo. Roll chief luc 
 ftice belt) , tbat it is gooo as it is , fo; there is a plain Contract , becaufe tbe 
 goons toerc giben foj tbe benefit of tbe paintif, though the Conttact be 
 not bctlueen Urn ano the defendant, ano be map toefl babe an 0aion upon 
 the Cafe , fo; here is a p^omife in ^ato maoe to the paintif , though there 
 benotapjomifeinfact, « there is a Debt here; anbthe Aifainpiit is gooo, 
 lerman anO Atk luQices agteeo, but Nicholas DoubtCO, Bat ludgemcnc was 
 given for ibe Plaiotif, 
 
 Corfidcr*. 
 tion. 
 
 Cafe. 
 
 Crefsic againft Burgis. 
 Mich. 165 1. Banc. fop. 
 
 I>anM£C<. 
 
 Arrcft of 
 
 ludf-emcn; in A jji Sction of SDebt tDasbjonghtopon the fetatute of i Ed.^.foj tithes. 
 Debt upon tx jiipon ml debet pleaDeD,anD a beroict ano Damages giben fo? the plain* 
 '^^Ed'Tt' "^^^^ • *^ ^"^ mobcD in arrcft of 3luDgemcnt that the Damages giben are fo; 
 tithes" " ""^ tithes gro\3jing upon 71 ;acres of lanD,VDi)crea0thepiaintif in hisSDeclaratis 
 on Declares but f 0; tithes grotaiing upon 7 ojScrcs of ^anD,fo that the oama* 
 gea are giticn fo; mo jc than is Declareo fo; , anO contrarp to the Dcmano, 
 %o tWo it Uias anftocrcD , that this is bat the mif»counting of the gurp , ano 
 is not material , becaufe bp the tubole IDeclaration it appears there loas but 
 70 acres, anothisiobutaDefcriptionbptheJarphelDthefeb.ral parcels 
 of lanotoerefoton, viz.toithtohatCo;n. Roll chief luftlcefaia, 2Lbe SDe« 
 (laration is that the SDefenDant tDSs fcffco of 70 acres of arable lano, 
 ano that fomanp acres toere fotoeo toith^hcat, fomanpluith £)at0, 
 To mai.p tPith ^cfltng , fomanp teith 25eans; ano as to the 5 a< 
 creereGDucfotocDU)fth5Barlep, uWcb all amounts to 71 acres; ano ft 
 ought to hate been as to 4 acres reiioue , fo that th<s is but a miscounting; 
 of the Slurp, fo; the Slurp cannot be oeccibeo, fo; the lano is caUeo bnt 70 
 acres in tiicSDedaration, ano no Damage arifeth to anp bp this mfftahe. 
 ECo tobfct) the reft of the Siuogcs agteeo, and judgeracnc was given for the 
 Plaintif , mfu 
 
 Mi-
 
 Mich. 165 1. 297 
 
 • Mich. 1651 Banc. fup. 
 
 Tl^c Court tuas motjEU to rctetfe an £>utlato?p foj tuant of ^lodamai Motion ro re- 
 Hon; tfteqacafontDa0\tftetftct(tmapbc!)onebp0ttojncp, t!jc pactpvcrfeanOuc- 
 Ijfmfclf, bprcaionoffnfirmftpofboijp, facfngnotable to come fn pctfon'^^ry. 
 tapon tjfcto of t^c Statute, Roll chief luflice fato^^e muft come in pctfcn /PP^ence, 
 otftcttDtfc it cannot be Done ; pet tfte Court toonlo aDt){fe, Afterwards ic 
 waJ oversruied, that it could not be revcrfed except he conje in pcrfon» 
 
 Drinkwater againftPack. 
 
 Micb, 1651 BanCf fup» 
 
 DRinkwater bjotigljt an artfon upon an CEfcapc agafnff Pack one of t^e f"'* "^^^ ;„ 
 &l)crifs of London , ano obtatng a taicrofct agafnft Urn, 3t teas mo- jn'faion for 
 t)CD<n3irrcftof3iuogemcnt, tbattljc JBlafntff Dcclateatftat tfte partp loas an eicapc. 
 In tl)e cnftoDp of both tfee S>l)cr(f0, ano pet tfje attfon is bjongl)t agafnft bat 
 one of fqcm, tl)c p;(foncr t Jjat cfcapcD bcfng fn Ludgate, fn tbe cuCoDp of ttie 
 2DcfcnDant Pack. Latch anfinereD , tbat tlje ©rceptton ie not gooo , becaufe 
 in Jlalo tbe p jf oner t^at efcapeo 10 in tl^e cuftoDp of botb ttie ^ijtiiis. Hales 
 on t^e otber Qoe faio , tbat it oott) not appear ttpon t^e Kcco^o, tbat t)e toao 
 Ux tbc CattoftoDp of botb tl)c feberffs , ano it fljall not be fopplpcD bp a fo- 
 tein intenoment, ano tbe partptftaUbcintcnoeDtobcincuftoDp.accojD- 
 Jng to tl)c Caff om of London, anD not bp ttjc Common ILaU), Roll chief 
 Juftice IjelD tbc SDccIaration gooB, fo j tbc'pjifoner toas in cuftotp of botb t&c Declaration. 
 ^bcrifa , alttiougl) t)C teas in t!)C CuttoDp of Pack, anD it ftanD0 toell enough 
 
 toitftttlclilECOjD, anD tt)e JrOjD0 utpracfertur DO ttOt l^Urt tbe atermcnt, Averment. 
 
 anD tbe too JD0 exiftent. incnftodiaioa gooD aticrment , tbat ftetoa0 in cus 
 Coop, as fn an tnoictmcnt, Tunc eKiftens tenementum i0 200D ; anD it is alfo 
 Ijerefoanobp tbe 3 urptbatbctoa0 in cuff oDp; fo:i boto clfe coulD tbepfino 
 fojtbepiaintif. Icrman ad idem: JBut becaufc tbe ttoo otber lunges 
 baD no )15ooh0 Delitjereo tbem , tbcp tooalD DcUbec no opinion tbcn» After- 
 ward ludgement was given for the Plaintif. 
 
 Cottrell and his V^Vife againft Theoballs. 
 
 Micht 1^51 Banc, iup, 
 
 COttretlanDbisMifcb^ongbt an Action upon tbe CalJe apoti an Af.Arrcitor 
 fumpfit againft Theoballs, anoDcclarcD tbat tbcSDcfcnoant, in conG= p^fRcment in 
 Deration tbat tljc plaintff tooulo marrp A. tbat isnoto tbe J01aintif3 totfe ,*^ a,f a""^' 
 DiDafrumeanopjomifctotbepaintiftomaliegooDa ILegacp giDen unto fJ'nJiu. 
 ber bp ber iFatbcr0 Mill , miD tooulD alfo gibe unto bet 40 1. mo?c out of 
 bi0 oton part gitjcn unto bfmbp tbe faio ^ ill, atbcragcof 18 pcaro, an& 
 Dcc'.are0 furtbcr , tbat tbereupon be DiD marrp ber, anD tbat tbe HDcfenoant 
 baDnotperfojmeaUsp^omife, ano fo conclu3e0, to bis Damage fo mucb- 
 tUponnonaflumcfitPlcaDeD , anD a ^crDict foj tbe piaintif, tbe ©cfcn- 
 Dantmot>cDinilrrcftofjuDgemcnt, anD took Dibcr0Crccption0 , but tfje 
 Conrt iiififtcd but upon one of tbcm , anD tbat toas beio material , anD it 
 tDa0tbi0, SEbat tbe ®3ifc DiD bcrelopn in tbe flctfon toitb ber ^^uabano , ^^^jon 
 tobt'cb ibc ouglit not to Do, becaufc tbe pjoinffc teas maoe to t'oc i^usbano 
 onlp, auDfojbis benefit, ano tbe fole confiocration foj tbe p^omifc Dotb 
 
 fH t^ arife
 
 298 Mich. 16 5 1* 
 
 arffe~fronrtbc~fnobanD , namely ftfsmarpfSg'tWlFcmc; 0nD Ba- 
 
 field and Co'lim V,is cafg, ji Cir. anU Cbeefman and Watt cafe 2 3 Car.tof rc 
 iJtcD, aoDRoll chief luftice pat tWfl cafe. 0pjonitfi: toasmaoc tp on: to 
 ai^emcGoVcrt, tftatfflftcvrillpjociircljctl^uobanntolc^ipafinc offnc^j 
 lanoa , t!iat be tuonlD e<bc fjct a rf ojnc futt ; jano jt toas at)ujD?cD ttat tbc 
 JBaroti ap.D ircnc cannot to pnfn an aalon foj b;catb of tbfg pjomf'c ; ano 
 ^ fj J)C falD tbat In tbc cafe at JBar it tras a meet cobcnaiit, anft no outp crevu 
 
 t^crcbi'totljciFcmc, Poflca, 
 
 * 
 Goodyer againft 5ha\v. 
 
 Mich« 165 It Banc, fu pi 
 
 With ifjjo. rot. 655. 
 
 Den n-rcr to /^^Ooiiyer bjouafet an 0£tion of SLrcfpafo fo j an flfTauU nnb HBafterp, ano 
 a pica in :d vJluounofng ot tis &ctt}ant , anDtaUfnc au;ap 12 plate locUc, agafnft 
 Action -f Shaw. SErjcHDefcnDant Shaw pleaocD not culpable to tl)C 3ffaijlt a;iD 15at> 
 Titip.'b. t:tp,anD VuounDins.auDastotbctalUngaUjapoftbclocUsljep'caDcDafpc- 
 tfalplcaof juftifieation, bp tcrtue of betters patents of fnco^pojation 
 grantCD to tbe llOCU-fmitbS of Dutham bp Cucberc 315fi5op of Durham , tibo 
 Sao jura regalia toftbfn tI)?CountppalfitiaC Of Durham, artOtbat bp bct- 
 tuc of tbis Cbartet tbe locks bci:ig not sooo , be as tclaioen of tbe «Iompa< 
 npofitaUctbem. CotbfspicatbcpiaintffDemutrco, ano foj caufcit 
 toasfbcUjeD, that ft appears not bp tbe pieatbattljc iBlack.fmftbs area 
 Cojpo;ationctcatEBbptbci5ffliop . but onlp tbat tbc Cuttoms ufcD a« 
 mongft tbcm in jOjOct to tbc reaulatfng of tbcft JLracc toere confitmeo bp 
 tbc jBiftjop , iDbfcb tJotb not mate tljcin a Cojpoiatlon , plow. f. 199. Lon^ 
 quinc. f. 40, 41. 2IP. 3t Dotb not appear bp tbe «Ibarter tbat tbcp babe a- 
 npautbo;ftp to tal-c atoap III mao: locks ; ano tbercfojc juoacincnt toaa 
 pjapeo fo J tbc plcfntlf. Roll chief lufticc fafD , SLbat t)cre botb not appear 
 Co'puraiion. aup jOjDcrmaDc bp tbc Cojpojatlon to talicatoap tb? ILocks, ano tbcrcs 
 fojc it tuas Done Initbout ii-arraiit,tl.ounb tbc Co:po;atfon bao fucb a potocr; 
 jlBat beGoCs it UiU be 'ocrp bard to jnaiiitain tbe JLocK-fniitbs to be a vro:po- 
 ration, bccaufc tbe 31Bia)3p confinncQ tbcir £) jbcrs. Therefore let the Plains 
 iifhavehisiudg«ment, nifi. 
 
 BiChop aga:nfl Fitzherbert. 
 
 M (h. 1 651, Banc, fup. 
 
 A-rcftrtf T>l{hor>b:ounl)t an fittion upon tbc Cafe agaii^ff Fitzherbert , foj fpcaU- 
 lucp-irei.tin | }i;ig tbcfe toojDij Of btm , thouarta lheee,andbaftftollenHorfes: dp* 
 t'ou'V ""* °" not'gniltp plcaoeu , ano a bcrtifct founu foj tbc piaintif , 3t teas moljeo 
 inarrfttofltjosremcnt, ttiatastbctoojosarelafofntbeSDcclatationtbep 
 are not SI: ionable , fo: it toinccrtain of tobom tbep tocre rpoUcn : 2Cbc 2bc» 
 clarat'Oii teas tbud, 2Lbat tbc SDcfcnOant Collcqumm habcns cum querentc 
 intbcp:Ercnccefotbcr!3, dixir, mssnfngtbe piafntif, Thou arc a Thcef, 
 and h:,fl ffollen Hor'"e';. SLbc Court at tb' firDt molding of tbfsCafecticli^ 
 net) tbc lDo;C3li)CTC actionable , brtaufrftfijallbefatcnocDtbcp lucre fpo« 
 feenoftbcpiaintif, tbougbitbcnotoirettlpfaiofo; 3iio aftcrtoatD it bc« 
 fng moteo agaid , tbe Court ftclo tbc IdojDs tocll CMOugblaiotobcaran 
 0ction, bccaufc upon tljelDbolcUccojt) tbc toozos plafnlp appear to be 
 fpobcn or tbc piaintif, and therefore ludgemeo: was given for him, 
 
 Free-
 
 Mich. i6ji. 29p 
 
 Freeman againil Chilo'erefs. 
 Micbf itfjr.Banc, fup» 
 Entred Trin. i6ji,rot. 45* 
 
 fReeman fa?ougl)t an Sldion upon tlje vEafe agafntt Childerefs foj Tpcafe. Arrea if 
 tngt^cfetUOjDso.'bet, She is a Whore, and iwill prove her a Whore , '"'^'T^'^"' '^ 
 ■ and an arrant Whore* tlpon not gufltp pleaBEt) , antJ a ClerDfa fOOTlO^o/ds """ '°^ 
 
 fo; tl)C plaf nttf , U iuas motcD in atrcft of Suogcmcnt Vjat tfte tco jos are 
 not actionable ,. betaufe tt)cp are but irojos of tijoler, ano fpoken (n pafsfon, 
 tbe juDgcmentattljcfiramottngof Ultiagttajicti,pcttttDas tljcn Doaljtca 
 iD^ctbct tfte tooiOfl ufo not impo jt mo: c in tijcm tljan to fap barclp of a too. 
 man, tttt ie a Id^ojc : I3nt aftccirarog ft bdng aga(n mobcD , Roll chief 
 luflicefafD, tbattbc toojtsUicretoo gcnetaUp fpofecn to be acfonable, 
 anDtbattbcpatebutlDo^OQOf par&(on, ano tijat bcfo;e t\» 0a maD£ a- 
 gafnft 3Dtiltcrp , p:o^fb(ttons bate been grantcD to tlje ^jctogaJfbc Court Pffhibron- 
 foj UbcUfng agntnft petfons , foj calling of luomeniii^ojss, anotftetefoje ' ' '' 
 Hil capiac per Billam,nin. 
 
 Prefton againft Mortlock. 
 
 • likb. i65i,Banc.fup, 
 
 A^ atffon of ffi:tcfpafs iuao bjouytit agafnft 4 ©cfenBants , ano facfo j« 
 a'sHcrDfctoncoftbemDpcD, anu tbe mcx^ia. teas founo agafrfl t^e 
 iBDefenoant : Twifdcn pjapco t^c ^lainttf mtgftt Ijaljc jnugement againtt , . 
 titZ omx tftjec. Roll chief lufticc anftoCteiJ,If yoa will relinqmOi your da. S^n^enr- 
 mages at to ifce perlon thac is. dead , you may have judgcmeiv againft the 
 r«ft, 
 
 Davis againft the Lord Foliot, 
 
 Mich, i<5ji,Banc. fup. 
 
 T!^eCotitt tuas motiea to grant tfte gooo behabtour agafnft t\it iL.Foliot; Motion for 
 b ccaafe he toas enotctco fo? a fo«l 15«ttcrp at tlje fstXsioM fn London '*"= '■'^ ^' 
 aniJ the JBiU toas fount) agatntt Wn, 15ut Roll chief luftice anftocrco . It ^*'".°"'- 
 cannot be granted upon a motion ; bu: you muft prefer Articles againft hira Good beha- 
 here upon Oath , and then you may move for it , and if there appear caufc in v««ui . 
 the Arcickt it (hall be granted, 
 
 iiich. 16 5 1. Banc. flip. 
 
 T ^e Court toasmobet) foj a tD?ft tofluxar one fa the ^Office of a S^afoj,Por « wrkto 
 totohfthhe toasclccteD fo? the 15ojoaghof Trevenoy fn Coruewall , bc.j!||fQ^"^^ JJl^ 
 canfc the olo £pa<o? d(d not ftoear htm fn one time as he ought to do, but oJo ^in oi ot a" 
 at) journ the Court bcfo je it toas Done. Roll chief lufticc anf UjereD , that rowqi, 
 thercianopjefloentto ftoear futh an £)fflcfr, pet.ojDcreo, that notice 
 fhould be given to the Town , and pfefidcnj^ to be brought ioco Ccurt , ifa- 
 ny were to warrant it. 
 
 Si q 2 Wfai t»
 
 — r- ...-' — 
 
 ^oo A/ich. 16 51 . 
 
 Whitw ay again ft Pinfcnt . 
 
 Mich, 1651, Banc, fup. 
 Pale, 165 1, rot. 61. 
 
 a pici in Co- A ^^" ^^^^ ^ ^^^^^ ''^ ^^"^^ ^°^ P'^^'^^ '''? ''^'^°' ^"^ cot)0nanf CD t^at tftc 
 
 vcuai.i*. .z\ %cS(t 1 bis arofgns fljoalD enlop tljcm tntfiig tlje SCerm, t^c BLcffoj 
 macctl)c2DcfcnDant IjlBCSrccpto; ^[ Dpco,2El)cllctrcc afstgna oDet bioSLcrm, 
 a stranger enters upon t^z SlMantz, Vit ^fetgnce tabc0 40 1, in Tatiefa* 
 rtfon foi W0 bcfng cjecteD of tl)e afsfgno?, ano aftctlrarD6 bjinga an actf- 
 on of Coljcnant asa(nft tl)C Cjccpto; of t^c iLcffoj t^c ©cfenoant. 2Cfje 
 E>efenoant plcaoo tt)e acceptance of tlie 40 1, of t^e ^fsigno^ (n fatfsfaafon 
 oftbcto?ongDoneftfm{n3I5aroftl)C0tt(on, ano to tbig plea tbc piafntfflf 
 
 Bar. semnrreQ, Ctje iqucttfon^cre teas, Vobcttiectboadion of Covenant Db 
 
 Ipe againfl t^c fl?efenDant,Cnce t^at the piafntlff tao teceitJcD 40 1, of tta 
 ;3f0fgno; (n fattsfaction. Roll chief ludice fafD,'tbat ^ere ta a Doable Cote> 
 nant, one of t^c ILctro;^, anD t^e ottier of t^e Sfefgno; , anD ttjetefo^e ttie 
 
 ASion V^^^V ^^V ^3^"^ tto" Siaious , anD tbcrcfoje be fs not t)crc barrcD,to bjing 
 tWfl fecono Miction , tboiigb be baljebattcablnifclfbptbc acceptance of tftc 
 40 1. from bringing an 0(tion againQ \iia 0f0(gno; , anD tbe SDcfeaDant 
 ftathnotplcaDCDtl)attbe4ol.iDa0gft)en<nfatfsfactfon of botb'tbc Cot?e» 
 nants » fojtbenitbaDbEcnotbcrtoapEa, lermaniuftlce to t!jc fame effect, 
 SCliat tbepare feteral Covenants, bp fet^eral Dceoo , anD bott) ttje parties 
 are fcterellp faounD , anD fatfsfartfon gfbcn bp one of tbcm,ts nottbc fatis- 
 fattfon of tbc otber, HnD l)c faio if ^icCTcc ioi pcaro afcign oter bis 2Dcrm 
 tbe JLcffo? bating notice tbercof,anD be accept tbe rent from tbe affiignee,be 
 cannot ocmano tbe rent of tbe ILcffec after toaros.pet be map fue otbet Co> 
 tenants conteineD in tbe Icafcagainftbim, as fo? reparations ojt^c Ube. 
 The rule was for the Plaintiff to take his ludgement, nifi, 
 
 Mich. 1651. Banc. fup. 
 
 For* ccti.v QErjeantGlynmoteDfoM certiorari to remotje an cnDftfmcnt of fojci= 
 r»ri torrmovc Oble cntrp tliat teas once befo je temoten bftbcr,anD after fent Doton bp a 
 anendift- procedendo , bccaufc tftr 3 uttices bcloto tcill not grant rcfttttitfon. Roll 
 •"="'• chief luftice anflECrcD, SCbcre io a plea put in , ano in futb cafe it is not nfu- 
 
 al to grant a ccrtlorai i, pet it map be tbat it map be grantcD , t^erefore let 
 the Oihcr fide (hew caufe on Monday next why it ihould not be granted* 
 
 Cantrell againft Stephens 
 
 Mich, 1651. Banc, fup. 
 
 Arreft ot 
 
 CAntrell brought an Action upon tbc cafe againff Stephens foj ttoppfrg 
 uu t .....> ^'^ ^^P *" " ^^"^Oto calleD Madfarook in tbc paiiOj of Redriff in Kent; 
 
 traa'Aftion upon not gufltpplcaocD , ano a tjerDict founD foj tbe plaintiff, 3t teas mo= 
 upon the care tjeD in atrcC of 3uDgement that the plaintiff as iLeffce,to tbc l^aberoafts 
 «oi ftoff ng ers tompanpof London,claimeOtobatoca toapfoj tbem, tobcreas tljcp 
 * **'^ • gating let ti;c lano canuot bate t^w toap , but tbc Blclfa inpoffef&ion. ilp.
 
 Mich. 155 1. ^o 
 
 I 
 
 2D!)C p jefcrfptfoit (0 not rfgfttlp applpeo , fo? it ouaht to be fo; tftcm to ftaM • 
 a iDap pro tenencibus ec occupacnnbus fui^, toNc^fsnot fo t)Cre« Twilden 
 anfU)CT0DU{l)aUbcitUeni)eD2Eciiant0, ano ilDccuppcro to ttjc l^abecoaO): 
 txs, t^ougt) it be not fato fuis Laccb tain tbat a p?ercrfptfon per que eflste 
 f0 0000 man dttfon upon tbeCarr,farcaitfc no lanDtsclafmci), ano Green 
 on tl)C fame Gdc fa<D, tUc cjccptton tahrn luao Ijclpco bp tbc tjcr^ fct. Wild 
 on tb" ott)cr fise fa(D. tbat <t uotl) not a[ pear tljat ttjc SCcnant toto bjfngs 
 tt)e ^ttion, comes ill bp the f^aberoaCtjerg lobo claim tbe toap, ano To \)Z 
 cannot pjr fcrfbe to Ijaljc ft , ano tbc pjcfcrfptlon oug^t to be lah pro tenen» Prcfcription. 
 tibus?c l'ubtcncntibus,tl)Ul) Roll chief Juftice DCnpcD, anO fa(0 ttiat it i6 
 laiatbatttjci^abcruafiierstocrc feifcB iniFtt,& poftca hucufq;, ano fo . 
 tftcp hatje tl)e iTee at tCc ifmc, anc map p jcfcribc ; but it ^&q been better (0% 
 t^cp:irtptobatc{ljetocotbat^etua0t!)cic SEcnant: but it being aftct a 
 tjetoict, tt)equcOion f0 iDbetbcr it be iiotfjclpco, tapon reaoing'tbe URca 
 co?D, Roll chief lufliceobfetbeBjtbatitappeartDnotlDftofc £Dccu'ppcr ano 
 aCenant tl)C plaintiff Iff ; but onlp bp toap of argument ; but faiu tftc que< 
 Cion is WtbEt tbe lieroirt 00 bclp it , ano^eindpneo it oio not, becaufg Verdia. 
 tbejaaionisbjongttbptlicCenant, totjoljatbnotentitlcD ttmfelf to tlje 
 jaaion, fojtjcliatbmaDconlpatitletot^etijapfntbe^abcroaaiers; bat x tie 
 UatljocTilJeDnoOftatcfromtbcmtolbimfelf. ^t another Dap Roll chief 
 lui^ice faio, toe muft not tafee tMngo bp intenomcnt , ano ticre {3 a failer in 
 tbel'erpgistoftbe;actton , fo^tbcpaintiflfbatft not sntitlcD Wmfclf to 
 t^e attion, fo J ftc ftatl) no fntcteft , foj it appears not Ijoto Ije is £)cuppet of 
 tbclano, fojljeDotbnotfapbcisOcupstorfuus, anOas it l)atb laib tJje 
 2)cdaration, tfte Companp ount)t to ^atjc bjougbt tbc Sctton lerman 
 luftice to tftc fame effect , ano faio tbat upon a ocmnrrer it bao been dccrlp 
 naugbt- anotftetjcroirtbercootftnotftclpit.foj no title appears foj t^c 
 |0laintiff, ano t^eberoict cannot gifce^imtftatljc ban not bcfojc. Nicho. [ 
 
 lasano Ask loftices to tl)0 fame effect. Roll, 3!f it bsD been Ocopator fuos, 
 31toabtit teoulDnotmabctl)e2Declarationgooo,becaufcitCljcVP0 not b? 
 totat title i>o The rule was nil capiat per billain, nifi, 
 
 Tayler again ft Web, 
 
 Mich, 16$ I, Banc, fup. 
 Hilt, 1^50, rot, 240, 
 
 Ijlsanejeaionefirmaeaponalcafe fojypcarstfterctoasa fpeeial terofctspec'isiTer. 
 tonno,, ano t^e qticflions in tftc Xafe igrcto upon Hie too;Ds of a TOiB-i^i"*"*- 
 t^attocrefalfc ojtijograp^jp , viz. 3 00 mabe nip Cofen Giles Bridges my^'^'"" *^'" 
 holleAyeareandray Yexecntor, meaning tnp fole^^eit, anO CiEicecntoj,'"** 
 Powit of Counccl toit^ tbc plaintiff bclo, tbat t^c WOAll toas gooo to mahe 
 Giles Bnges tljc Jtcftatojo l^eir ano Crecuto? , notlDitljffanDing tt.c mff- 
 lxi:ift{ngoftl)cli)ojBs,anotbatbptl;e iZHin tije' llano ano perfonal <iBftate 
 paffeo unto bfm, foj be faio, if bp mp Mill 3 mabe one mp l^cir , SCftis 
 IsaoetifetobimofallmpBLanosini^ee, foj tbe Detjifec is put fn loco 
 hacredis.ano fljall bc Iffee an l^eir bp oefccnt, foj ftc is haeres fadas,altbougft 
 Ibebenot hxrcs nacus,Mici]. 31 ^jzEliz. rot. 235 Godfreys Reports, Hob» 
 rep. f, 34- b, Coundffls cafe, Hob. new edition 7 j. Spark againft Burrell, tfte 
 tcrp cafe in pofn t aciuogeo : 7 E. 6. Br. Done 44.'and Devie 48. anO tn tbffl 
 Cafe the JDcbifec baoannuities topap, ano monies foj JLrgacico, lobttb 
 ll)ctoQtt)e intent of t^eSHcQatoj to be, tbat be (ball tjatie bis llanos ana 
 <DooDs y neither (ball tije mifspcUing of tbe too jo ^cir tniit tbc ^ill , foj
 
 50 2 Mich. 165 1. 
 
 t^ intent of tftc Ccttatoj Qjall be follotDcU, i( ft map be bnoton , 80 ft map 
 lDcUbel)crc, Hob. f. 31. 15H.7. f, 12. Cooks Lief. ^23. Dyer 315. 2lp. 
 jptfnamfng fn a Midi (ball not burttbctSJHfll, Dyer 325.21 Rich, 2. Fltzh, 
 devife27.10.rep. 57. 31?. ifalfc }laHnGjallnotDtftropDcctano;plcao« 
 inea, tboQSb it toUl abate tD;it0, a fortiori faire CnglfOi (ball not Dtffrop 
 a 0Slll,9 H. 7. 16. 10. rep. O»bornicafc, Hob. 237, lo. rcp,i33. a.9H.6,jt. 
 a, antj bete is onlp vinum fcriptori»,nnD tl)at cannot ocQrop a t!CI<ll,Hob, f. 
 16 ..Wallverscafe.f. i04,&io4.9.rep.^8.a.Dyer.i7Eliz.f.342.Digbyestafe. 
 Slnotbet rcafcn (0, tbe toojo l^cir is here to jUtcn arcojting to tf)C pionan= 
 dat(on,nnt)rouiiDoftlievio}0,tboug!)<tagrccnotfh Icttera , ano H, tijat 
 fa left out t3 no letter, but an afperate note , anutlielananagefn England 
 " as tt Differs <n time, fo it Differs in place , fo; men fpeah not, nojtojite , 
 CD^ialiO) in all parts of CBnnlauD alide , anDatEQill in latin 0^ grech is a 
 pooo <2iatll toitbin ti)C fetntute , fo tbat it is not ncccffarp fo? a WiiW to be 
 gcooCngUflJ, ano tbcSCcttato? teas bjcD in France, ano coalo neit'jcc 
 Ipjitc noj fpeak gooDCnglifld, anobis ©IHillfotnnrbtl)cratl)cri3tobe 
 fatJOurcD. 3*19 falfeCEnglilbbatt) been allotocD in a IBonb, viz. fertcen 
 fojfctcntccnpounDs, 9. rep, 48.3. nuicbmojc mapitbein a tffilill, ano 
 fo be pjapcD 3;uDgcment fo j tbc plaintiff. Latch foj tbe SDcfcnoant argu= 
 cDtbattbc OaiU toasuotgooD, be conQocreD a. points, t. ^bcn a man 
 raaUesonc WsfoUcaprare nno ^ejrccutoj tobat conftruclion tbc toojDs 
 (ball bate. ilp. ^batC-ttatefscontcpeabptbcm. ;anD firtt be faio tbat 
 HobfrfsCafeciteDbpPowijtoasnottotbcpurpofc. j. Becaufcitfa not 
 tbe pjincipal cafe. 0nD 2lp-3t is bat an opinion tbcrc, ano an ^cir map 
 hz toitboiit lano.anD foj counden ano Claikscafc tbat teas citeo, as it toao 
 urgED, it is to% mcanD not againft me, anDtbcrc can be no autbojitp citeo, 
 tbatifonema^caman bis^eir, tbat bis lanes are tberebp conbepeoto 
 blmin JTccOmple, JBtit in our cafe tberc can be no certain intent of tbc 
 SDcftato; foiuiD out , an!) tbe making of one bis ^eix in France irbcre tbe 
 SCettato J teas b;cD, ace ojDing to tbe Cibfl ILato tbcrc ufeo, Is Wit to mabe 
 bfm bis CErccnto J, anD fo tbe STeftato; migbt mean it» 0nix If one in l;is 
 ^ill fap, 3 mabe one of mp SDaugbtcrs mp ^eir , ano bo not fap of bis 
 Hanos, tbis fliall not Diffnberlt the otbcr SDaugbtcrs , anb if tbcre (boulo be 
 nnp (Ettate conbcpcD bcre, it cannot be but an GCate fo j life. Brook Done 
 44^8 fac. C B. Inkcrfalis cafe, 3IP. 2Dbc ill o?tbogropbp bcre raabcs 
 tbc WClill naugbt, foj a uEHill cannot be maoe goon bp contccturcs, Hob, 
 34. Mich. 25 Car. Robinfons cafe, tt)c 3uC0emcnt \raB rcbcrfcQ foj \xiii- 
 tfngtbciiiOjO AerisinftceD Ofasris toitbabiptbonguc. Trit)»i7Car. C. B* 
 ror. 74. anD in Skirrcc ano Skinners cafe iibii loitb a Dafb Otier put foj iibrif 
 teas aDUJDgcD ill , anp in our cafe bcre are bibers trojos miflii?itten, Sinn 
 fo: tbc tiariation of our CDngliO) Dialert tebfcb is ofaiettcb it ie to no purpofe , 
 bcraufc tbis IniH tons latclp mace 5 tl)EsDiaictt alters not in To fljojt a time, 
 anD tbc ctalctt cf tfjciCountp luberc tbc ?RuIiU teas maDe,viz.Gloctfter Shire 
 agrees rot toitbtbe ^ill. flnb Hill. 6, Car. tbis Will came in Difpntc in 
 tbc Court of InarDs, ano a Decree tbcrc palfco agatnft tbe tiCIill in tbis point. 
 ^^'11. Ebc Court falD, tbe cafe is Doubtful, becaufe tbc MiVi Ootbnot fap, 3 mal-'e 
 
 bimbcirof mpEano, but gene rallcmpbcir anD Crccutoj, but tbcfalfe 
 to;f ting butts not a TOii!, if tbc fficfiatojs mfnb map be founo out, Adjour* 
 ned CO "be argued again. 3oy . 
 
 Wood
 
 Mich, 1^5 1. 3O3 
 
 Wood againlr Topham- 
 
 M ch. i(Jn Banc, fup* 
 
 T 7X /Ood bjoiirfjCan^tttonofSTrifpatTcnpctitftecafc qunre filium & a rtftof 
 
 V \ hijcredem rapuit ec niariravit,so.£<!ifl;Tcphain,iipon not truiltppUa- juf'grmcrt '.n 
 D-B, anDat)EtDfoiafoijno(ojtl)cpnfnilff,tl)0 SDcfrnDcnt nictcQ in at.^nAa.i.n on 
 rcC of ^uogemcnt, anu tahf s tljefe £):ccptiono to tl)c S>ctIarat(on, 1 . Etat ' * "^'' 
 tbc§i3!a(nt(ff DOtt)not fapcujusrnaritagium ad ipfum pettine:. ily. %l)^t 
 JjcDotbnot^apt^attfje^ektoaGlritliln agcj ana Maynard of CdohceI 
 toUft tlK HDcfenDant fcfo tbat tfcc c;ccpt{ons"arc rot to tJjc tD;lt , but tc t^e 
 SDrtlaratfon , ano ttic miction bcfng a SErcfpsiTc to rrcctcr tftc iDamascs, 
 ti)e plaintiff ougbt (0 entitle fjfmfclf to tl)e marfncc fo; tbc !offc U)!)£rcof 
 l)£ itoiilD rccoter Dnmaocp, foj tl}c t3rtr Untap be fcnct ^ctr apparent to 
 ftfni , ant) tl)en (0 no martagc Due tobfm, ano bcre fo a fpccfal SDctlara* 
 t<on, fo; tbe lolTe of tljc mariapc. Roll chiefiuftice anftuerco , tftc <r jUs wiks. 
 arc goon bctljtoapcs, anD fo map tlje SDctlaratfcn be eftljcr tsttb tftofeDcciaraticn, 
 teojDc, 0? toltljoiit tbem , ano fee mafecs not ttje sroimD of Ijfs ^Icttcn , to be 
 tl;at tbe marfage belongcD to blm ; but of Common rinftt It oott) belong toccmmon 
 I)fm, ant) tbc Inojas arc ufcn to be allcseo , onlp to tntrcafc tbc SDamages, light. 
 anD ttjc grounD of tbe SDeclaration is onlp quare filium fuum & Iixredcra ra- 
 puit, anD fo J tljia tljc jSlaintfff oucftt to bate bis 3"Dgcmcnt,fcriTian luftice 
 DiffcrcD,aBDfaiD,tbc plaintiff corbnotOictobe bao anp Damage bp tbe 
 mariagc, lit irrp tcibntbctacbccn !Jiarj;EDlcfc:r,03 trasof full arc % 
 fo no caufc of jgfttion. N cholas luflice as Roi!,ano faio.tbat bp tbc iLalij tbc 
 mariage belongs to tbc iFatbcr, anD ft map pjotc a Diftionour to tbc fami- 
 Iptobatjc tfsfoiitafeenairap, anomarpeDtritbOHt tbe iFatbcrs confent. 
 Ask luflicetotbefamecffCit, and foludgcraent was given for the PlainiifFi 
 nifi. Antea» 
 
 Mich. 165 1. Banc. (u'l^. 
 
 T^t Court teas mobcD to mitigate fines, tl}at lucre to be fct upon rio» Motion to 
 ters tbat inere founo guiltp upon an information crbibiteo againft miiigace 
 tbem , fo J tbc riotous tutting Dokn of irooD. 315ut Wild on tbe otbe'r iioc '^n'=^ '^r iiots. 
 pjapcDtbcrcmigUbcgooD fines fct iipontbcmaccojcingtotbcfaafounD 
 iipon tbe IRf cojD , be caufc it inas a foul riot. SCbc Court anftDCico.tbep 
 arc founoguiltpoftbc riot, anotbcrcfojc tbc fine cannot be Icffc tban tcnF*"*- 
 pounBjjattbelcaftfojtbepjincipaljtbcrebcinsa teroict in tbc cafe, and 
 fo let it be, and ^. marks a piece for the rell. ^01 isc miift pjcfcrbc tbC 
 peace of tbc Coiuitp, 
 
 Baker againftSmicn. ! 
 
 Mich. i<55 1 ♦ Banc, fup, 
 
 T^: cafe of Baker anD Smith fojmcrlp fpoUcn to iuas again ntotcD, anb i" »r,fwcr -6 
 Maynard anflBcrtD tbc crccpUons oflfcrcD in arrcft of 3iuogcmcnt. i.» m^tcr i^'- 
 3t teas objcctcD tbat bcrc teas not a mutual pjomifc fct fojtb bcttocen tbe Jj ?J!,cn^ut 
 partpc0, fojibcrcisno agreement maDcbp tbc ircme, fo?itls onlp faiD, ■' "^ ' • 
 tbatlbeconfontcDtomarrptbcpartp, tobicbisnot a bincing agreement. 
 Sto tbts be anftocTCD.bcic teas a mutual, ano binoing agreement, tboajsbit
 
 304 Mich. 1651J 
 
 be notfoplafnlpcicpjcffcDfniDoatisaijft tnfoftt fiatc been, 5 H. 6, 35,37; 
 jaticrbalpjomlfcmapbcDtft^iatseobp Ibojds, anD fo (t ia tierc, London 
 and ScokescafCjTrin. lo Car. rot. 236. i^cpt it is not ncceffarp ftcre to 
 gfbc notftc of tbc Df fcbargc of tf)c pjomffCjtljoug^jfc tbcrc be notfcc ft fg iucll 
 enoagl), bccaufctbctblngtobcooneupon it, to toft tbc papment of tljc 
 1000 1. Iflccrtafn, ano t!;c Difcbargc fljall be intcnoco to be fn tl)c pjcfcncc of 
 tbc partp to tDljom U ia gtbeti; foj t\)z IDcclaraKon <3 exoneravit ipfum, 
 toWcb (ball not be fntcmjeD (n b«s abfcncc, Pa'cb. 10 Car. Harvy ano Jngiel 
 thorps cafe, anOMUh 8 lac Martin una Wilbif, Hodges anO More, Pafcfi, 
 I Car. Banc. Reg. 7 lac, Bradlyes cafc , J 4 he. Leedly anO Goodrofe* 
 Larch on tbeotbcrfioc argtico , tftat berets no bfnotng p?omfrc on the bc> 
 Wi of the iDoman to marrp luftb tbc Dcfcncant , ano fo tbc oifcbarge of ft 
 tan be no conliDeratfon ; fo j tbfs ia not a rccfpjocal , but a bare acccptatfoit 
 of the pjomffe maoe bp the otbcr ? ano an aaion of the cafe lap not agafntt 
 liertf fl)3!)aDrcfufcDtomarrplDftbtl;cDefEnDant, bccaofcbcrc is no rc» 
 pjomffsfonmaocbpbcr. 2lp. 3t appears not tb't the Dtfcbarcc voag f;i 
 £ont)cnfent tfmc , foHt inas a pears after; but aomfttins tljat to be fo , pet 
 ijercfBnonotfceofti)eDffcbarge, ann tbat fa ncceffarp to be allien, ana ft 
 fljall not be fntennco to be gfben iDitbout fljctfng ft , ioi the* Dcrlaratfon 
 ongbt to be certain, ano bercfsnotnoaccntentfnftthattbercioas anp no- 
 tice gf ben fn bfs pjefence , anofflttoercaitcnfnfjfs abfeiicc, be ougbt to 
 Ijabe notice gifecn bint of bis oifcbargc , elfc boto fljoolo be hnoto ft e 
 anDfttocreunreafonablctoc'oargebfmffbebaD'nonoticc, ano bp a tbfro 
 perfon be cannot recclbc notfcc, as ft is in tbc Cafes put bp £p,:. Maynard 
 on the other fine, gn tbc (Safe of Peck ano Ingram in tbfs Court aof ungco 
 tbnt tbc partp ougbt to babe notice lobcn tbs i^cme left bcr i^atbcrs \$oulc ■ 
 arto came to fucb a place. Koll chief lufticc ftifo, here are ttoopjomifcs, 
 I. S^be i^cmeaffumcD, tbatff tbe ©efencant Iroulo ntarrp bcr , lljc tooulo 
 Confidera- ' confcnt to bf rtt ; aiiD bcrc fs a coiifiDeration , altbougb tbcrc be not an abfo= 
 •'^1 .^ . lute mutual p:omifc, fojftis a pjomffc fn lata, ano tbc iJctfon map be 
 laT'*' '" lain bptoap of conCocratf on, ojbptoap of mutual Contraa. ilp.^er'efs 
 MuTuai cor-''"^ 3 P?'""^f'^^'= •""'"'■<*' awD tbcrc map bcatempojallofs , altbouijli tl;c 
 rrnft. tbfng to bc ooHc , viz.tbcmarfage, bcfpfritual; 3i:i)ti}Ci)ff=cngaacmentof 
 
 Implication, tbc partp Dotb not f mplp notice ; pet tljc oemanD of tbc i oco I, nolc f mpKca 
 ,^. . a cf fcbarge , no j can the partp here take notice of a tbfro perfon, a.no tbcrc^ 
 
 ' *' *^ fojc ft fs neceffarp to gibe bim notice ; fo j tobcrc tbc partp cannot tatc no- 
 tice from anp but tbc partp timfclf, there notice muft be giticn bim.Icrman 
 ]u(>icebclD, bcrc teas a gooD mutual pjomffc to raifc a confiDc ration, ano 
 bp tbc tooios exoneravit ipfum, ft ftjaB be fntcnoco to be to tbc pc-fon. 
 hiinfclf.i tbfs fmplres a nctfcc, cfpecfallp it being after a ticrofrt. Nicholas 
 }n(\. much to the effect as Roll chief luft. but be Doubted toljctbcr ti)c InojDs 
 to implp a perfonal notice, fo j it map be it toaa fn bfs ftbfencc, ana the tcr- 
 Hia mill not help it , ano fo there can be no juogsment. A^k Juffice faio, 
 t)ereU)a0agooDp:omifc, buttheipojos exoneravit ipfum bo not fmplp a' 
 notice , fo the Court was divided, and would advile. 
 
 Hume againfl Hinton. 
 
 Mich. 1 65 1. Banc. ftp. 
 
 Atftof TTUme bjougbt an flictfon upon the Cafe agaiiitt Hinton, anb DccIarcD, 
 jadgrmcnt in ijl li^Ut vibcrcas tbc &on Of tb"- Dcfenoant oio in bis lifetime olne unto 
 .riAfiicnup tbcpiafntifSl. anoopcDintefiatc, tbcpiaintff oio temanQ tbc faio 8!, 
 "" 'n a"r! '^^^^^ SDcfcuoant, being J^otbcr to the iiiteftate ; tobereupon ftc being fa- 
 upon r J- j^ggg^ pj j^j juttnefs of tbe Debt , oio affnmc ano pjomifc unto tbc jaiaintir; 
 
 that
 
 Mich. 1651. > • 
 
 t^at ff ftc tDOulD ff ap (0% tl^e moncp tUl Mich, nert, tftat tljcn llje tooulo pap 
 ft» tajwn non Affuropfu plcaoeo , ano a tjcrtrfct founo fo; tbc pafnttf. tbc 
 S^efenoant ntotjco fn 2trcft of 3;tiDgcmer.t , t^at ftctc uaa no conQoeratfoiT 
 tcstoiinot!^eAfl"umpiuupoH,bccaufcttMa3nottl)eDEbtof tl;c partj> tl;at 
 afTamcD to pap It, ticftljer Uiag flje Crccutojoj aDmin<Cratoj noxcoh* 
 ftquentlp Ipablc anp uiap fap lavo to pap ft , ano tfterefojc an AfTump- 
 ill to pap a remeDflefsi Debt, U tbt ipiafntif tvoulD Sap fo^ ft, 10 no goo^i Af- 
 luropfit, as fn 6 Car, fn t!)f3Court,fn Morgans Cafe, ^n AfTumpfitto 
 pap t^c rent of t^e lanb bclifno , f f t^e partp tooulo fojbcar to DfCtrcfn Cojn 
 fntljeftocbs, toasaDJuDgcDnogooOAfrurapfu, betaufcTtic^Cojn is not 
 Dffircfnable , ant) ft appears not Ijcte tobat perfon tbc &on toas , 0; tsljere 
 ^elftieo, oj tftat be eftljet ftaooj left anp gooDs, ann tljc meet groanti of 
 tfje^ctfonfstl^cpfetpoftfte^otbcr, anonootbet matter, janb fjcte ap» 
 pears no perfon Ifablc to pap tbfs ctfbt, r.eftbcr plafnlp, no? tp fntenDmcnt , 
 ano tbe £)jO!narp fs not chargeable f f no goocs come to bfs banos. 0(to ilp. 
 severe fsnotD no iSDjDfnatp, fojftfstabcnatoapfap tfte Jparlfamcnt , ano 
 9r€p, Bains cafe fs not If kc to tbts cafe, ncftbcrfs lones ano Smiths cafe, 
 Trin. 8Iac. rot. i92.lfbctotW3carc, foj ttjcre toas a perfon Ifablc to be 
 rneo, bnt ft fs not fo ^ere , fo t^at tl)fs is a ftronger cafe, )5ut f f tbere 
 ftoulD be a 0035 conCoeratfon , pctt^eatjermentoftljcpcrfojmanceofft fs 
 not goon, fo J ft fs not rcitafn ijoto be ttapen. Wild foj tbc iplafntf f f)eH),tl;at 
 l^erefs a gmo conftoeratf on , becaufetltiepiafntfffsberebptpeo not to fus 
 anp perfon Uijatfoctjer foj ttc Debt tfll Michaelmas , ano fo ft fs a pjeiuDfcc 
 to bfm to fejbear : SnD ft (ball be f ntenocD bere tbat tfje BIntcCatc ofo leaf c 
 fufficfcnt COOD0 to fatfefie tbe Debt ; ano tbougi) tbere be no £);Dfnarp , pet 
 tbe partp tbat tafeestbegooDs map be fueo, ano tljc Cafe of Homes and 
 Smith tfteo fs foj tbe pafntfffn mp IRepojt , ano tbc /uDgcmcnt fs not 
 ttiere entree fn tbe JRoU, but fn tbe ^atg^nt onlp , ftfs cnfrcQ pro Defen- 
 dentf,ano tbecafe of Hill ano Baily fs fince tbat, ano tbat fs toftft mc , ano fs 
 to be pjeferrcD befoje tbc otfter, bccaufe ft fs a later juogcmcnt. ilp, 2LbE 
 abcrmentfssooofnfnbftancc, altbougliftfcenctfoerpjcfsfn toojDs as ft 
 mfgbt tatjc been, ano ft fs noto after a U c rofit, Sbc <Z ourt fo j tbc firft 
 pofntbclOj JberetDasagooDconCocratfon, fojftfst&at t&e |aiafntff fijaB Confij-ra- 
 fojbearto fuefojtfjemonepsenEraUp, irbtcfjgoesto all the toojlD, anoft "°"' 
 fsnotonlptofojbeartofueapartfcularperfon, but to fojbeac to fuc foj 
 tftc moncp; ano tbf f jbe arancc map be a p?e jnDfce to tbe partp, antr a iofs 
 fn not fufng tf n tbat tfme. 515ut foj tbc latter crceptfon Roll chief luftice 
 fafo , ff tfje bjeac^ be not tocU afsfgneo tl)e terofct tofll not tjrip ft; anti pou Br«ch. 
 fap tbat poo flfapeo fn eppectatfon of tte monep , ann Do not fap abfolutclp 
 tbat ponttapeo. Therefore let us fee a book , and fpeak to the laft point a- Ordinary, 
 gain on Saturday rfe«,* 3" tbfs cafe Roll chief luftice fato , tuterc tbcrcts 
 noboopelfeio befncDfojaDcbt, tljeiSjoinarpfstobcfnco, altboiigb be Dtbt. 
 fs not to be cbargeo , ff be ^atjc no gooDs, ano fn London ft fs ufual to do ft; 
 ano note &fr Nathaniel Brent fs fn place of t^c £??Ofnarp tb;ougbout all 
 England, flfterlcarO judgement was given for the PJaincif , becaufe the coij; 
 fideratioo and the averment were held both good, 
 
 Mich. 165 1. Banc. fup. 
 
 Oi^e Harding toas cnofttCD 1 1 Car. fo; an aiTaalt ano iSatterp ma^se fn r 
 Weflminfter hall, ano t^c partp founogufltp: tbc Cotirt teas moiicDe„''ccri,''2/'' 
 fo J a rnlc to enter juDgement agafnft bfm , becaufe it teas fo long Cncc tbe n.enc ' 
 tiacrofct HBtit tbe Court fafo , f f pon map oo ft bp t^e rules of tbc Court 
 enter ft, foj toe tofll mabc no rule toltljout Ijcarfrtg tbc otber fioc tljctefojc 
 give notice , & ihco move it again, 3Ji C Micb,
 
 2o6 Mich. 1651. 
 
 Mich. 16 5 1. Banc. (up. 
 Dtm r A i^ 0ct{on of Debt toasbjoijcbt upon an £>bUgaf{on of loco 1. fojper' 
 
 A0 aialon of Debt teas bjoucbt upon an £>bUgaf{on of 10 
 tojinanceoftl)eCoticnaina of an 3noentutc, SCfte JS 
 
 a D.ci,r»cion -tl tojiHance Of 11)6 Coticnaiita of an 3noentutc. SCfte JDefenoant ne- 
 ii. o be upo?nturatotbcSDccIatat<on, ano tlje ^fllafnttf jopns fn t?)c S)tmmxtv; anoaf^ 
 » ' ob\fau ntcr rcacfng of tll)c iReco?D , ann tlje (Ejceptfons opcnco, Twifdcn motwo 
 t"i"r:j.m tljc Coiut foa t!)C palrttif , tbattjc misi,t nlffonttntw hia artfon, becaafe 
 D 'co'Hi','.? ^"J"^ ^^^ ^ ^^"'^ '" *^^ '"^'''S U. Roll chief luftice faiD , 3LEt it ttap as ft 
 ana '"""' ta tW0 iCerm, fojtJjfsfafnourDfftretlon, aji&ttfa but a fltp in pltaufng, 
 ano hi t^i m«an time ioc votli aotif fr» 
 
 Barnard againfl; King; 
 
 Mich, 165 1 Banc. fup» , 
 
 Paich, 1651. rot. 467, 
 
 D.miir;trio "T) Amard bjongUan Slitton of SDcbf apon an£Dblfgat(on of 500 I. to 
 
 anpiira.iori pxftanD to an illDarD. Eftc Dcfeuoant plcaoco nullum arbitrium. SLl)c 
 
 io D bt iiponX-'piahitffrcpHcatljattDc tampkcma&ctfteatoatD, ana fets (t fojtb, 
 
 anOb!igi,i n^^„Q^fg|g„f,a|jjcac!): 2Eo tbisj Heplfcatfon the SDcfenuantbcmurrctj, ani>' 
 
 Awaid** '"" {ahcscjfcptfon, tl)attbc|3lafnttffct0fo;tl) tbatttjcjatWtratojg coulo not 
 
 ngrec, ano after tljcp ban ocnicD to make t^c jaujaro, tftc fame nap tbe 
 
 t;iimpfrc mauctljc 3toarD, Latch of Conned iBftb tftc JDcfeiinant fjclo 
 
 ttit3 ^UiarD fct fo;tl)fn the l*li.pltcatton to be naua^t, becaafe ti)8 fabmifst- 
 
 ^ onlnag, ti,atfflbcarbftratoj0fl}aUjwitmflU£t6catDatDtomo?roi»; tlicti 
 
 tbc tamvfrcfljallmaUctbc'ampicaijc; am Icve tbc cimpfragc Is maoe 
 
 upon tlu! fame cnptliattoaojiitsn to tbc ilrbttatojs to nwUc tlje SioarD, 
 
 anD tl)cj? IiaUe the iob^lc Dap bp tbc fubmifoion to raoiic it fn , a«D altbong^ 
 
 tbJp cannot agree to maliC it one part of t'oc uap, tbcp map acrce aftet- 
 
 toatos tiie fame cap to raalic ft, ano tbf*olfscreemcnt Is not a giWi}§ w^ of 
 
 tbctratitbojttp, ano Wood ano Clements cafe, 14 Car, 13 not againfi; tl)icF, 
 
 alp. 3t in not fafD tbat tbc arWtrcracnt iaaa Ddiiserca, jlp. SCbc matter a» 
 
 toatoco is not teUWn tbc fubmifeion , naniclp tbepagincntof tbc rent tx- 
 
 picffco. HaksontbcotljcrGocarrticD.tbat t\fi Umpire migljt uiahc tbe 
 
 ^iraru upon tbat Dap tbat ic fet fojib ; aua tbc ConcUion l;crc ta aU one , 
 
 as if itbaD been faia , if tbc arbitrators matic tbc iJtDarB to mojro-s , ojif 
 
 tbc tampirc maiic tbc StearQ to mojtoiu. Pufcl). 14 1:i% Ba»ry anD Fells cafe. 
 
 ^nDtbCiJOOJDgbcrcPodquim denega(Ttnr,etdercrui0cat is a DtrCit ai;er« 
 
 ment tbat tbc arbitrators coalo not afjtec to maUctb« aujar.D; ajuj arbi* 
 
 tratoja map maUc an alnarD after tbcp ba'nc cboCcu. an Umpire r a«o aU 
 
 tbougbtbc Cimpirc baD polucr to rnahc tbi Umpftasc a nap after tbcp 
 
 maoe it j pet it it be mace facfojc it is a gooD Umpirage , ic tbe 5Lait» per. 
 
 ntit it , anD tbe amplragc bcrc is urcll oclitcrco , foj tbc fubniifsion is not 
 
 tbat it (ball be DclitcrcD to botb parties, butgcncrallptbatit (ball be Delis 
 
 DcrcD , anD tbcrcfojc it iatocll if it briMJU'ocrcDto oitc , it being renDp to be 
 
 telitcrcDtotbeotbcr: HnD fo;tbcpapmciit of tbc rent, altbougb it be 
 
 a future Set , pet bcins matter of- fatisfactlon , It i» goco , altbongti it be 
 
 . jj rr-\ ■ rot cppicffc J in tbe fubmirsfon. RoU chief luiiice faiit, faj tbe laflE jmittct 
 
 ^'^'^' " * tbe tDOjDs ftiper pra-mifQs iTjiiigG tbepapmcnt of tiisrent Idtbtn tb« labmif« 
 
 fon, otbcrtoife tbc a\t arcing of tbe p&pmenttbercofluonla not be gooobp 
 
 tuap of fatiefaaion : 5l5at beta tbc Contwl^evfte in r^j tbe lam» foj tobfrb tbe 
 
 tent
 
 Mich. 1651. 507 
 
 tent fa t« be paitr , ann tl)e matter uotlj not appear fo be out of t!)C fatmtfrsrf' 
 
 on , ana it te not ncccffarp to fttocr tftat t!)c lano toad <rt ConttotcrOiJ. jl?. Averment. 
 
 iFo J tljc D£Ut)erp of tbc Eirnro it ia tocll cnouglj r-* ft f g , foj ft fs not fpEct= 
 
 fieDtoto^omibcffilmpfreCballDelttjcr tftc tawpfraac , alt^otigft ft be tf 
 
 pjcffcDto tDbom tbc ;arbfttato?0 tocrc toDclftct tl)cit ^toato , ff f!)cp ftao 
 
 mane ft, llButtljc mafn qucttfon ^crc l« , ff m tEimpftc coalo mal?c tft; 
 
 tmmpirngcttjstiapfttoaamaae; anofojtljat 31 ftolo^e conic not, bctaafc um/iragf. 
 
 tljc autbojftp gftjcn bj? tbe fubmf fsf on to tbc ^Itbfttatoja teas not ustcrmf- 
 
 11CD to&en tl>c tampfragc toag maoc; ano bp t^c fubmf fgfon ttje atbfttato;« ^wardi 
 
 ^atienoautbojitptomaUcan Ompfrc, fojtticnft ba" been gootj, ano ft 
 
 appears not that tb2 Elmpfre bao concurrent awt^ojftp irftl) tbe iJrbttra- 
 
 tojs; fojftfsnotfafo ff tfce j2lrbftrato;3 mahe no arbftrcmcnt tbcn tftc 
 
 m mpfrc Ojall make ft ; but berc fo a COfiBftfon foj tbe 0rb(tcato?3 f bate 
 
 all t^e Dap p jeccoent to make tbe arbitration fn , ano no toncurtfng pOir.et 
 
 U gf ben to tbe VH mptre tbat oap , foj tbe Sirbf tratojfi bate all of ft to agr* 
 
 in , ano tfll ft fs enoeti tbe 'amptre bat'tj no potecr at all , otbctojffe tbs fuD' 
 
 ntf f0fon tooulo be repunnant in it felf. acbe reft of tbe 3«BgC3 coucurrco 
 
 in ail ;, ano fo tuleo , i fiat tbe Plaincif nil capiac per billam, niii. • 
 
 Tficoba'ls againft Newton. 
 
 Mich. 1 65 r. Banc, fap^ 
 
 O^etoaofueu upon tbe ©fatate of inmates, anD tbe diftringasjurata 
 bate Date on a Sunday, auo out of Ccrnt , anD fo fs erronfous , Cbc 
 que&fon bere teas, totctbsr ft be not bclpto bp tbe statutes of Scofailu , of 
 i8Eliz. anoti lac. RollchieflufticebelD, tbat tbe statutes ertenD not leof*'''.' 
 to penal Hatofl , altbougbft beambfguouflppennco, noj to anp pjoccfTea 
 gtounocD upon tbem, fO} tbe ^jotiffoe):emptotl)e£D;fgfual action, anD bp 
 confeqwcnceallpjoccffcfiiDepcnotng nponttatcejceptso, fo tbat here is noVcnirede 
 good trjal, bat there fhall be a venire dc novo, niJi, novo. 
 
 Tayler and Webb. 
 
 Mich. 1 65 1, Banc, fup^ 
 
 Tl^e Cafe ofTayler ano Webb tobfcbarofe upon a fpecfal Dctufct nport /^r,(;^^^ 
 tbcfc toO}D0 of trail U, viz. I make my Cofen vJUflcg JBjfDge© my foil aycrc j^//upo„ the 
 and yexecutor, toao again motjeo anD argueo bp Hales , ano be maoe t^ace v.ords of a 
 nueCfons. i. ©abctbetanpcCatepatretbbptbetoojDaoftbe toflU alp.wai. 
 31f anp. tobat eftatc paffetb, jlp, ^Klbetber tbe falfe ©jtbograpbp Dotb butt 
 tbe WW, $0% {\)z firft be fafD, tbat bp making one bfs fole bcir bffl lanD paf « 
 fctb to bfm. SCbc toojD bcfr fs to be confiocreD cf tber fn tclatlon to an 3ln> 
 cefto^ , ano fo one cannot mahe one bfs belt , 0; ft map be conftoereo fn tt^ 
 latfon to a tbfng to be fnberftcD , to toft lanos oj tenements, ano fo one 
 map make another bis bsft, anD thus a Cuftom map make one a mans bcfr, 
 a3ftfdfnl5o^ougb<Bnglf(b; ano an accfocnt map tbus alfo make one a 
 mansbefr, asftfs fn tbe»irafcofpoiTeffiofr3Tis,Coundens cafe. Hob. Rep. 
 Cafe 947. 3na here ft fs all one to make one bis bcfr , aiiD to make bini bcfr 
 ofbtslanDO; ano tbe reafwiB arc , iFlrft, tbe toojobefr here cannot bate 
 anp other rclatfon than to tbe SCeftatojs lanos , foj be cannot make bfm bfa 
 bcfrotbertoffe, anD tbe too jDs map be moje reafonahlp fntenOeo fo. ilp. 
 SCljetoojDBtarrpfntUemtbcplafn fntention of tbcBDebifoj, tbat the partv 
 (boulD f)at« Ui UnO0 > altt^ougb t^ too^os ate not tierp proper 
 
 ia 1 2 3 H^
 
 2o8 A/ich. 1651. 
 
 ii H, 7, 3 DcWfc of lanofl to \iis fon after tbc ocatb of Wo feifc, p.iffca art Cr- 
 eate fo; Ufc to tfec te<fc , altftotigb no fuel) CCate toafl crpjcffco in 
 tbe ^lU; fo bcrc, alt^oosl) no rrpjcffe Cffatc of lano be DCljIfcD, 
 fcttl)c2)ct)lfcclbaUI)at)etbclanDobptl)cfntcntoftl)c JDctffoj, jlp. 3n 
 jDinarp fpcccl) , ffonc make ftit!) anoncl)<0?^:<r,ft<3fiitenDBDtl)at i;e 
 g<bC0 ft<m tfs lanos, 8 Car. fn tijc C. B. in Spurt anc Benti tafc. utMUc 
 ofl)(fl<nl)crftancr, tcai3bcli3aDctifcofl)(alatioo,an6rrin, J. lar. in Tcr- 
 ryei cafe, SI oetifc of all bio rents <ii tnpl pnffcD Dfa lanoa.brtaufc in tuU 
 gar acceptance Uffltljc rents of lanofl, nnB<n Pits ano Sands tutt in iW 
 Court, aoctlfeofaU Us frre laiito in Holford ofo patlea pojtfon of 
 2Cft^e0,ani3(ntl)ctafcofoneIohnfon, aocttfeofall big cttatc palico atl 
 tifelanw. Slnotbctcojoccannot bear tt)c fence to mafee hfm Crccuto;, 
 accojtfng to tl)c Cftill Jiaiisaa batb been objectcD, fo;i tl)C CQill fljaU be fn* 
 tcnccoaBtttOjtobeanCngKO) mans ©3jn, anu fo toe loojDtj.ir fn ft 
 fljaH be fntcrp;tteD accojDfng to oucilniu, ann not tlje CftfU iiaiij, ano 
 EbenfntbcCttfUlatDtomabeonetjfsii^rfr oot^ conbep nnto ^im all Wa 
 lanDS, fojljefflbsrcsteftamcntariu?, altljoiipl) not hxres lepitimus. ilnO 
 fn tlifs tKilJll tictc arc ttoo erpjcfcfons, fo; tbc partp fs mace ^tix anu CErc* 
 cuto;, toftfcl) tlDO too;Ds cannot figntfic one tfifng, fo j tbat tooulD be an folc 
 crp^fflfon. 4lp Eftcre are fomc claufes fn tftc ?Kafll , tiDfcl) CbcVo tbc fn« 
 tent of tftc SCeflatoj toas to contjcp tis InnDs , f f ft irerc nceofol to m&he 
 nfeoftljem, i. Eljcre are ftticral annuftfes foj tlje H>ctffcc to pap. 
 2lp. !^eDfreasb(iniDt)eretl)e contcpantes ano afTtirances of bis lanos 
 iDcrc lafD up, iDl;icb plafnlp fljeto f)e meant Ibc fljoulo l)abe t)fa lano. jlp* 
 2Ef)c toojos %cfr ano Cjtcutot arc jopnco togctber, to tielD tbat be gfbes 
 bimaUb<0lant)0anogooD0,elfconeoftbeloo}O0 muQ be fmperfect, ano 
 ineffectual, tolJcl) fball not be fntcnteo. foi 3utf)o?ftp 7 E. 6. Br. dcvifs 
 3 8.bp Deblfing tbat one fe)on fijall be l^ef r to tlje otbcr, it fliall be IntenoeD of 
 lanDa,fofnconttrii£ifonof laiDitOjall be fjcrc fntcnoeD tftat tbe SDctitfo;. 
 inane bin»?^eirofbi0lanD0, Hob. Reports. fn Sparkes ano furnells cafe, 
 William ano Anthony ttiall be cacb otftcra l^efr , ano ft ie not fafo of lano , 
 petaotntgcMbatitlballbcfomeant, ano fo fs ft fn onr cafe, ano ff 3I 
 fjatjc lanosinfccfimpU, anDmaUconcmpbcfr,ftfljall be fntenoeo tbat 
 Ije (ball babe mplanD0fn fee ample, altbongb 31 fap not tbat 31 make bfm 
 l^cfr of mp lanO0. JFoj tbc fccono qucCfon, tbe reafouB befo?e erpiclTeD do 
 alfo (bctD tbst tt)c lanD0 arc paffeo fn j^ce, 80 ft is fn Purnells ano Hamble- 
 tons cafe, fo; tbe toojD^^efrtball relate to tb2 fame Cftate, tbat tbe partp 
 bao f n tbc lano, tcbo malse0 tbe otber bifi !^cfr, 8 lac. Inkerfali caff-iFo; tbe 
 3d point, tobettier bere (ball be anp gooo oebffc at all, bp reafon of tbc falfc 
 CEnglfIb, be fafo ft toaa all one , ano to ao gooo effect aa ff tbc toojog tocre 
 all true Cnglffb, anDncitbertbefncorgrtjftp.nojtbc fnfnfficfcncp of tbc 
 tDO jDfl (ball bart tb^ CHfll, aa ft fa p;ctcno:i). j?o; i . SDHb fa not fn cafe of 
 pleaofng 0; of tDjft0;but fn conbepanc? of lanoa.3;t fa trnctbat fn tbe fo:mct 
 ft Dotb burt/jccaafc tojfta anb pleacfngs m.ip be amenocD,f f tbcp be naugbt; 
 but ft fa fatal fnconbepance0,fo;tbep cannot be amenBCD, aa fn Trotmaa 
 ano Standards cafe, Trin. 1 65 1 . fn tbfe Court ft icas belo tbat fmp;op?f ctp 
 of tDo;D0fl)aU not burt,f{tbtpcan aosnit of a gooo conCtrua(otT. Dcfinet in 
 pifcem mulier formofa luperne. 2lp. Ebia fs in a uQfU, tobicb fa fucb an 
 Inttrimicnt, tbat is much 'aVfjureb in Hata . anBtbcrcfoje to be faboura. 
 blpconflruct). ?lp, SEbiaiaanCnglitb StUfU, nnDaDmft0ofm:icbbarf=! 
 etpofoialceta, ano tbcrrfoje fa not to bccrfticallpfntcrpjetco. jfJcitber 
 arc tbcrc here anp f nfjignfgcant. 0; mffetgnificant tuojoa, aa batb been ob- 
 ^C(tcD,but (trnificant, fo: tbc founb of tbe tooio as ftfs tojftten fa tbc fame 
 aa ff ft bao been rigbtlp fpellco , fo; 0rcr ano l^cfr founo botb aUUc, 2ls 
 fn 3 H. 4. t", 4 Baxter anb B isfter founbCD a.fKe, alp. 3!f tbc iDOJS ^cfc 
 
 migbt
 
 Mich. 165 1. 3^^ 
 
 rnigfeTwccttje an? ot^et fence , pet ft cannot do fo fjerc, bccaufe ttieirc are^ 
 otftettDojoa JopneBto U, to Declare anoQcniect^at tfjc aEcttato; meant 
 i^e(tofft(a3LanD0, anD not tjje element of apje , oja pear, as ^tifbten 
 ttrangelp objccteo , ano irouln p;ot»e a rfofculous cotiflructfon. Osborni 
 cafe 10. rrp, fn ThynscafefnttilaCourtaDcmanoofDolDercle cjpella, al- 
 tbounlj tbe irojD iDCte of Doubtful! cor.ftruafon in it fdf, pet Dp tbc fubjctt 
 ntattctjfttDasftelDtobcmaDecertafticrouc^, fo tlje Vdojd japcare bere 
 ftall rrcclte conttructfon accojDfno to t^e fubjcd matter , anD ti)c tciipUns 
 of U alfo tottb tbc Ujojd i^cicecutoj, tcttcb is alfo falfelp UijUten , CjcUjg tbe 
 JCeftatojs intent, iFojanfU)ettotbemafuobjeafon,viz,tbat in 6 Car, 
 tbcte teas a Decree maoe in tbe Court of toarDa , bp aobfCe of tbc SuOgea , 
 tbat tbffl toag a toto ano fcnccleffe Will, 3i fap tbat t^at Dicrce is not of fo 
 great tuatgbt , as ts a Suogcment gfbcn fn a Court of juDlcaturc at tbc com* 
 won Halo, anDtbistoasbut an opinion DelibereD in Court, Isberetbe 
 3lnDgeg tDcre not BluDgcs , anD tb: Decree tuaamaDc as 3 am cnfojmcD. 
 bccaufe tbep beliebeD tbc ^illtobcnonfcnce,tbc cor.trarp Vr-bcrcof DotbHcir. 
 appear bp mp argoment . 2Cbe Court enclpneo ftronalp tbat tbe STcCato j 
 IntenDeD to mahe tbe SDebifcc ^eir of bis lanes, anotbat tbc Idoids can 
 teccite no otbcr conCruttion, (oj otbcr conffructionsit oulD be berp Crangc, 
 anofo^ceD, anD tbepartp tbat maDetbeMfll, f^tobc conCDcreo as one * 
 
 t^ttoasinopiconfilii , anD alfo tbat toantcD a fcribc, anD bts intent ft ems 
 plain, anDfljallnotbetabenacco^iDinQtotbeCibilllaiD, anD if it (boulD, 
 tbe lBo:tD !^eir tnill as toell e^tcnD to tbe lanDS as goons, Adjouraed co 
 fcc argued again, 3/^ . 
 
 Kymlock againft Bamfi^« 
 
 Mich, 1 55 1. Banc, fup: 
 Mich. 24, Car. roc. 59J, 
 
 KYmlock b?oagbt an Action upon tbe cafe upon an indcbicatus affumpfit ^'" "•■"' '" 
 againft Bamficld,fo; mahing of apparel. SEbc IDefenDant pleaDCD tbat V '"!-'" "^ 
 ^le became bouno in a iBono of 60 1. to tbe plaintiff in fatisfattion of tbc anluebS 
 JBDebt ,anD tbat tbe plaintiff acceptco of it, tbc plaintiff replpcD tbat be Dto atiumpiK. 
 not accept of it,to tbiflteplicatfon tbeSDcfcnoant DcmurrcD,^ fbetus fo j caufe, 
 tbat tbe plaintiff bao tenojco an iCTue upon tbe non acceptance of tblSono, 
 iDbereas it fljonlD batJe been tbat tbe EDcfcnoant non devenit tentus. £nx tbe 
 otbetCDeittDasfaiDtbatitistoellcnoagbjitbatft iyfufficicnt to fap non 
 accepir, anD it is not necclTarp to fap be ccfnfcD tbci cblig^ition, ano tboiigb 
 tbe replication be not gooB, pet tbe plea is alfo naugbl, anD tbercfojc no 
 SuDgcment can be fo j ibc jEDefcnDant. Sbc plea is quod deveniilet tentus, 
 lobcreas it ougbt to be devenit tentuf . 0nD 2lp. M^t (belos not in iubat fum 
 o: place , no j tbat be became bonnD in fatisfaction. Roil chief luflice faiD , 
 tbat bpcntring into JlBonD tbe former contraa is gone, if pou Do not rcfufc 
 (t, anD it is net tufficient to fap pouDiD not accept of tbeJKonD, foj pou 
 tnap pet accept it if pou plcafe , ano tbe partp cannot pleao non eft fadum,^"""'*^' 
 if pou b?ing an Action upon it, until it be abfolntelp rcfufcD , ano tbe con- 
 trad bere is turneo into a SBonD , anD tbc lain Determines the tontraa, ano pica. 
 it is not all one tnitb pleac-ing of tbc acceptance of a b^Jfc in fattsfaafon, j 
 ojanpotbettliingasa collateral fatisfaoion, ano tbc plaintiff ougtt to 
 ibeU) tbat be refnfeD tbc jDbligation, anD ootb pet rcfufc it. ans bcrc is a 
 negative prcipnan$,fo> pou implpbpfaping tbat rouacccptcD not tbc £)b-Nrgiiive 
 Ugation in fati0fa(tion,tbat be gabe pou tbe obligation, anD I'ou mtgbt ijiXiz prciR!>in ,
 
 3io Mich. 1651J 
 
 'fafoTNoiTdevenit tentus , ano fo; tl)D otftct ejfccptlona tftcp arc to no 
 Difcontinu. pnrpofc. And therefore ludgcmenc oughc to be given againft you; but by 
 '"•^^ the ftvour of the Court we can give you leave Co discontinue year 
 
 A(ftion, 
 
 Harding againft Freeman. 
 Mich. i65i«Banc,fap» 
 
 HArding bjoiigbt an Sialon upon t!je Cafe agafr.C Frcemsn , ano oecla- 
 reo agafnat)hn,t;;at tftc ]E>cfcnDant c<d fell unto l)<m a ©clDfng , ano 
 rJdTcmlnti., upon tbc (ale otDrairclpaffirnnintoWm, ttiat tbc 0clD<ng luae Ws oton 
 an Action iiji <I5clojns , BnD ttjat bebjeoWntofaColt, tol)etea0 be bjco l)fm not of a 
 onihccjfc Colt, neither u-aoUl)fsoU3nCDclD<ng, but anotbcr mans CDcluIng, anufo 
 T'u'''r ^''' toncluDcstobfs Damage, waponnotgufltpplcauco, anua tlcvola fonno 
 foj tbc plafntff , tbe SDcfenDant mobco in flrrett of 3uDgcmcnt , i. SLbat 
 in tljie falc of tbc ©clofng , tbc HDefcnoant tjao mate no toarrantp of l)<nt j 
 ano thercfoje tbcugb tbc falc tocrc not gooo, pet tbe iSttfon lice not. alp* 
 SDbc ^latntf f tiotb not octlarc tljat tbc SDefenuant ftnototng tbc (Sciofng to 
 be anotljer mans , cfo affirm btm to be bto oton , ano fo ftere aotl) not ap» 
 pear to be anp frauD tn tl)e fale, Twi'.den anrujeteo, tbat tbc ino j«8 arc fuf« 
 ficient to fmplp a clftcft , tbougb tbep crpicfu not , tfcat ftc Unototag it to be 
 anotbcr mans t>o;fe ufD maUe tljat affirmation , foj tljc toojos arc t:;at be 
 Dfu ft falfo et traudulenter , ano affirmco tbc l^o^fe to be W0 oton. But 
 tbc Court ftppcD the SltiDgcmcnt, fo;tbepfatD,tl)atbercfflno ufrcct affir* 
 matron, but onlp an fntcnomcnt tijat facnter; fecit, yet afterward* judge- 
 ment was given tor the i^intif* r. 
 
 Davis againft the Lord Foliot* 
 
 otaH-irfc. 
 
 Di 
 
 i or i new 
 
 Mich. 1551. Banc, fu p. 
 
 ,Avisb;DtjgI)tanartfonof iI[ra«ltanD3I53ttctp ana tooantfng agafnll 
 
 'the ?i.o;o Foiior, ano bao a licrDfct agatntt b<m , ano a Vojft of cnquJrp 
 
 of Damages, ano upon tlje tojit o:' Gnqufrp 200 1. catnagea toerc founo, SEbc 
 
 writotE.,- |9latnt<f mobcD tfe; vCourt fojanc'ujlDjft, becaufjbp rcafon^of tbe ttU- 
 
 <]uiryctda. fulncffl Of tt)c llurptbc Damagcs l\)crc fourtO toofmaU, Twii'dtnon tlje o» 
 
 ""&«*' tbcrfiocurgcD , tl;at it coulo not be, becaufe tberc inas no mffcarriage 
 
 pjobcD ill execution of tbc Irijit , but it appears to be locll {jrecuteD. RoH 
 
 chief JufticcanftocrcDjtboug!) toe grant not a ncto tojit, fct Ujc can in- 
 
 ^ trcafetbc Damages aponbicto of tl;e loouno . ano bere appears to babe 
 
 Damjgrs in-'v j,0g„ g fguj 15attcrp bv tf)c Dagucr pjoDncco in tbc Court, ano bv tbe partp 
 
 Couu " bimfelf tbat Is toounoco , ano i't is not fit tbat a Inilfntl Blurp fboulo pjcja- 
 
 Dfcctbcpartp, tbcrefojrcitbETConfenttoancUJlDjft, oj clfc b;ing poor 
 
 tiiitiicffcs on botb floes ar.D tie trill bear tlic motion again. SLt anotber Dap 
 
 Wild faiD , t!)e Court cannot tiicrcnfe Damages upon a iDieto of the partp , ff 
 
 be be not maimco , ano bcre is no maiming, but onlp a 313atterp an» 
 
 Uiounttng : JBut tbc Court anfftiercD ibat tbcp tuMtlD aDbifc upon tbat 
 
 point, fojitrnemstbrrcfstbefame reafon fox cncvcafing of Damages In 
 
 botb ca'cs. S!t anotber Dap G etn mobcD foj incrcafc of Damages upon 
 
 tbc Weto , anD urgcD 9 H, 4, f. i . 3 H. 8. 4. 1 o H 4 ano B; et and Middle* 
 
 con- cafe in tbis Court. Twiiden on tbe otbcr Sde confclTcB tbc JBooha 
 
 lucre fo, but bcre tbc 3Batterpii3 not apparent, anotbotoounnis internal, 
 
 ar.arottobcticVDCD bptbe Court. R.0II chief luflice faio, 3 tbings arc 
 
 cor.QDcrablc, i.tobctber tbe Court can fncrcafetljeDnmascs, 2lp. Mbc« 
 
 tbcr
 
 Hill. 1651. jIt 
 
 tbet tVC tooimo be apparent i mw jlp ®a!)ct!)i:c tjje Damages cttjen be too ~ 
 ftnalt?' 2C&e Court upon \3<clu of toe partp, a»6 ofamfnation ofCWtnt- 
 gfofls ano 5iSlitncff;s on botb Gaes upon £)at&, Dfa f oncluDc tljat t!jcp in<!jW 
 fntreafc tbc tamagca , aiiD t^t tl)c tooyno itaa apparent , ano tftat tljc M- 
 tnagealtcrctoofmati, aiiDttjeret"o:e tljrp inctrafED tftcm to 400!. ana 
 fafD ti)ep tooulo not tncrcafe ttjcm mo:c, bctaufe tijep toulo not fn» 
 Huire fnto all tU tkctimffatwca of t!)c fait , as tec Uirp mfjiljt , bat tftcp 
 tljoualjt fitting to cncreafc t^em in fome p;opojtfon,fcttaare tfte offence toas 
 Cteat , ano fnc^ outranioas acts ate not to be flfgtjtJp puniJbcD, 
 
 VVallis againft Bucknal. 
 
 Hill, I (Jj I, Banc, fup* 
 
 V^on a fpcfial tJcrDUt founo \x[. an Ej^cSione fimnae t!>e cafe fell out to be 
 tt)(8: ilCoppftolDcrofmbcrltanceai.i3ea!lettcrof atto;[nepto tlDO SpfcuiVor- 
 jopntlg ano fctterallp to furtenfiet \m Copptjolo lajyiefn iree to certain u- .'^'^> *\ ^- 
 fcs, after l)ta Bcatb , fictojctng to tbc Cuftom of tUe^ano?. Ebe queftion J;J'""« *" 
 niaQcbpHllUafCcuacclto<t{)tl)£piaintffU;8fl, tobetbcr tbe Cnftomtoas " * 
 gooD 0? not:' }{)€ argtwo.tbat \i tons not a nooa Cuflom. 3n M>fr lohn Davis 
 iHepojtsUfafaio, aCnfioin muft be rcafonable , ano a CuCoin ma? be 
 tcafonable, tobcn f t la bui agahiC a partkniat JLatn, ano not a general 
 ILato ; but tbcCiiftoat^tctfeufl to conbeplanOjfaagaJtitt a general iLato, 
 partfcnlar stuff on;s map be agatntt pabUque intereft.probono public bat ff 
 tftcp be Rot, as fr. otir cafe tljc}' arcnot, tljcp are not gooD. ij5c)ct an antljojf- p bono 
 tp pfbcu ou£l)t to be Counterntar.Dable, ano to tsctermfne at tbc aeatb of t^e rubi:cc>. 
 partp; butt5)i3tsnotfo,anotbercfo;citt3 no gooo aiit^jon'tp, 19E. 3.f» 
 5. alp. i^oiie can nttjean antijojttpto anotber to 00 a tbtng tDWcf) fjc conlD 
 not DO bnnfelf ; bnt l)crc (t (s otSjcrVcffe^no tberefoj-e ft fa not a gooD aatbo« 
 rftp. ?lp. 315pt&eocatl)oftf)eCoppbolDertl)elanDsareret!eDfntbefrirj 
 ano tbfs aiitl)o?ltj) gttcn (ball not octift t!;cm, ana t?)fc fa not Ifhe tbc fur- 
 tenojfng of lanoa fnto tbe tanaa of tbe JLojD ; foj a furrcnDer cannot be rc^ 
 bofeeo, butiljfaautOojitpfarcl-oUaWe. i^ert, tbc Clcrofct Dotbnotfino 
 tbattliezflttojnepaarcCuttomarptcnanta, fatitonlpbp tonp of rccftal, 
 tebfcb fa net gooD ; no:^ Dot!) <t appear tbcp toerc cuff orirr.rp tenants , at tbe 
 tfmcoftbcaDmittancc; aaDljercfanotfcuiinanppoircfsfonoj tftU fa tbe 
 SDcfcnoant, anDfotbc ^atntfibat)mgp;inTer poffcfslon, tbc Detfinoant 
 issmltp; rrcitbfrfsftformKtljattbccaComarpCrnant I)aD fecdttuflc fn 
 tlte larTO ; SlnD ff ^c '-.aD but .in cfiate fo: life Ijc'couHj not maUc fuc&»lcttc£ 
 ofattcjtTcp. *airotbcaiitl}o;{tpGfl''cnt0HottoarraMteobj>t;)c «i;ti0'<nf fcfc 
 fojt&. wilmot of Cou.Tccl lufti) tl)c SDefenoant, fafD , SC'iat tbfs au<!jo;tt)> 
 bcre fa fappojteo toftb a fpccial of reef on , tobfcft map furufbc t^e part? that 
 gfbes tt , I H. 7. 8. gno an autbojftp map furbfbe tfte pstif tfjat 
 jtbcB lt;clfe ^oiD can anC'jecutoj fell lanDs bp tlje autbojftp giben wito xm^ 
 at E.4. f. H.jiE, i,Fitzherb. 45. ansae fojtbeljcfr be Ijatb neslecteD Wa 
 aatiai'tagc, ft be fjao anp , ano cannot nofotafec ft: ButbcfiDcs, tbenut^j 
 r(tp ftcrc gf 'ocn is raoje t&an a bare aiitbojftp , foj <t fa backeo \x>\\\ circum* 
 ttancPBoftimeanDpcrfon; anDb^rcfaalfo a Cuttom to fuppojt ft, ano 
 tbtaCuffomfaareafonablcdtitlom, fo; ft fa but to enable a man to Dff. 
 pofc of bta olnn lanDa : ano tbcre are far mo;c anrcafonablc Caaoms tljan 
 tWa allcineo in our latD , aatbeCtiftomof Kent, fojoneof tljc age of 15 
 pcnra to be cnablcD to fell \'A^3 lanDa , anD tbia Cnfrom ie not agatntt aiTp po= 
 fttfbe rule of ILain , foj tbe cuttom fa, to create tbc autbojitp to begin after 
 Wa Dcatb , ano fo it fa not to Determine bp bia oeatb ; fo j till t^)en it begins 
 not \ anD tbe Cuttom Ijcrc (0 but to alien lanes , ir^tcb ia no flrangc tl)ing , 
 
 anD
 
 JI2 
 
 Ctiftom. 
 
 Dcvife. 
 
 Endlftment 
 (or fp caking 
 blifphciuous 
 words. 
 
 Hil)vi65i. 
 
 "anBltlfl n;tcnDcirbut toftfjfn a fmall compifa of '.ana , an^ fo camox be t3C» 
 tp p;cjtiDfcfal to tftc piibUquc. 3nO Bamb idge ano Wh:idd(in!, cafe lyTCar* 
 In tljfs Court , citco on t'.)C otbcr floe Dot!) Differ from tfilo cnfc , loj t ere 
 teas no Cuflom to ruppojt U- ^no ft oot!) appear tjerc bp the Rcco?d, ti,at 
 Dalbytlbe3tto;ncj.' ia a tnflomarp SLenant, ano tftc aomifjfon bcrc ta 
 founii to be fecundum confuetudinem Mancn'i. Sinn one cannot ga(n a Co- 
 ppbolo rftatc bp Diffcffin, ano fo Ijcrccan bcnopjfmer fclftt iiittnocD , ano 
 ft (a fo'irj? tbc «Xoppl)olocr is fcKcD. Roll chief luftict falo, 31 IdUI be ^arD 
 to maintain t^jeCuftom, ifitbenotfoimotbattlicpartp teaafcifeo in fee 
 oftfte"<E;opp!)olDIanD3. iBtit zip. ftignotbcre foiinotSattljc lano isoemfe 
 fable, arcojDfngtotljctoilloftbciLojD, anofo it map be frcclanD, itljcti 
 tljccuftom 00*1) not react) ft. jficltberlsitfotmDt^attbea Sttojncps vuerc 
 Coppbolo SCenanta , anD the pjimcr poffcfaion !)erc teill make a DilTcifin bp 
 tl)c H)efenDant , iftftcCuftombc nottocU fonno, anD tl^cn it (0 foj tbc 
 paintif, anDBlcannotfcefjototbedtiaomcanbegooD, It being againft 
 tfternlC0of iLaVo ; fo; a man cannot Dcbifc a CoppljolD , ano !)crc tljc cafe 
 ie U)o;fe , but ^e m&p Dutrenocr to tbe ufe of bis laS WiiVi ano 2Ccttamcntf 
 3t another Dap Wilmoao tbc Crccptfon taken, 2Lbat it is not founD tbat tbc 
 ttoo;attojnep0ix)ercCenantsoftbc^ano?,fafO;tl)ere is fo mucb tountt 
 asCballmahcthembcp^efumeDto be jCenants of tbe ^ano;t ^ fo; it ii 
 fonno tbattbcpartp is aomittCD fecundum confuccudinem Manerii, toblcft 
 cannot be a gooD aomfttancc iUbcp toerc no^SI^nants. Roll chief iuilice 
 anfloereo, to be aDmitteo fecundum confuetudinem, goes to tbe ;3Dmft< 
 tance , trot to tbc ILcttcr of 0ttojnep ; But we will ad vifc, 0t another oap 
 Twifden pjapcD juDgcmcnt fo; tbe |)laintif , ano inCttcD upon tf)c Crccptf* 
 on tljat tbc tlDO Slttojnepg toerc not founD cuffomarp aCenanto ; fo; one ot 
 tbcm is not mentioneo at all , anD tbe otijer is foutjD fo onlp bp loap of reci- 
 tal, anD fo tbcp t)a\)C not entitleo tijcmfeltcs to tlje Cuff bm , anD tftcn tbe 
 SDcfenDant Ija^ no title. JDlje Court cuIcd to ftiew caufe Saturday folldv/- 
 ing why the Plainttf ftiould not have judgement. _Antca. 
 
 Cuftodes againft Tawny and Norwood. 
 
 IHill. i^juBanc.fup. 
 
 TAwny anD Norwood toerc lofntlpenticteofo; blafpbcmous ino;Ds fc< 
 teraUp fpofeen bp tbem , upon tJje late Statute maoe againft blafpftc- 
 mp, ano toctcconbirteo , tbe parties being rcmoteo bitbcr bp Habeas Cor- 
 pus. 3t teas argcD tbat tbe CDnDictment teas not gooD , bccaufe it Uias 
 lopnt, toberca0tbetDo;Ds being fpoUenbptf)emfcfterallp, tbcp ougbt to 
 bate been cnoictcDfeticrallp; fojtbctoojDsfpokenbponcof tljem cannot 
 befaiotobc tbe Ibojds of tbc otbcr. 15ut Roll chief luftice faiD, SDbC 
 CnDirtment toae gooD cnougb. tbongbit be Jopnt , as it is in tbe cafe of fe- 
 deral perjuries, anD fefecral batteries , tobcrr a jopnt CnDictment Dotfj He, 
 altbongb it DO not fo; fctjeral felonies , ano berc tbe CnDictmcnt fs upon 
 one ano tbe fame Statute , ano fo; one anD tbe fame offence , and there^ 
 fore the judgement given upon it is alfo good, anD it fljall be tahen reddendo^, 
 iinfiula fingalis ( It ) tbe toojDs to cacft of tbem as t^ep fpofee tbewt 
 
 Floyd
 
 Hill. 1651. 31 
 
 > 
 
 Floyd againft Morgan, 
 
 Hill, 1651. Banc, fup, 
 
 ATHrft of CBrrojtDas bjoucbt to rdjerfc a 3:tiB£rrmenf gftm In at! ^, Frmr 'o rc- 
 dfon of SCrcfpafa , foj tah(ng anap cftcrs 50000 , aitB t!)e Crro; U^as ".ifc a ju-'s;- 
 tbattbcretoas the toojofiinftiutricntum tern' ufeDhttftc ©cclaratfotT^io cj;, 'y '" Trcf- 
 JJJCfO OftietB ttfnga, viz dcquodaminOromentoferrijAnglicc^K^ttifeT,;'-, ,^"" 
 &dcquodaminftrumentofcrri, Anglicc a 15;anDfron , ec dequoda{T^HBt|o> s 
 nento ferri, Anglice a s^ajtat , tofectcas there arc pjopcr JLatm iroj?srci m gi:cf. 
 tbcih, f tberfojcarenottobcfouncErtafrilptiErcrfbco. Darcyagainft tl;e 
 to?ft of C-tro>rafD ft tDa0 certain cnoug!: as tbcptDCre cefcrtbcOjjcitcat^e 
 Reg. f.45.anDfafD, ff ft be not tcrtafn in tfte Hatfn urfcrfptfon , pet tie 
 Angliceljclpsft, Roll chief luftce Dcmanoco, tofjat fap pou to tbe Cafe^'^^'P''"'''- 
 of inftrumentum ferri, Anglicc a f^oj feuOCU , aDjuDgeO naijaljt lately fii tljffl 
 places' anu tbcre arc pjopcr iLatfn teo;Dg fo j tbc tiifrtgs pou ocfcrfbr, tu!,fcft 
 fou ougbt to Ijabc iifctj , tbercfoje tbfs befcrfptfon f0 itot gooD ; fo? tobcrc a 
 3Latfittoo;Dficn(ftt0ntanptl5fngs, there an An£;lice<0 pjopcr to be aUDeo 
 to ft, otljcrtoffc not , ano ff tbcre be no Latfn toojD to C);pjef0 a tfjfng , one 
 tnapfnbcnta tciojD, anb fnterpjet ft toftb an Angiice, bat ft fs not fo 
 icrc, t^jcrcfojelcttUejuDgcmcntbcrcbcrrco.nifij&cPonea. 
 
 Kei'ghtley again ft Nodes. 
 
 Hill. i65i.BancJup, 
 Trin. 16^1, rot, S69. 
 
 orc- 
 
 t A OTrftofCrrojtDasbjougbttarcberfe a juog^mcnt fn a SCrcfpafu Erro- . 
 Jrxw er armif at Doncafter, 0nD tl)e Crroj afofgncD Uiao, Stltnt tbev<:f'<=^^--»<> 
 plafntlfDcclarcotbattljc fiDefenoanttoohcertafa Cotes of bf0 out ofthe""^"' '■' ^''^' 
 3uri3Df£tfonoftbcCourt, anubjoutbt tbem Irftfjfn tbe iurfopfofop anD^"'^*'"""" 
 tbereDffporcooftbcmtol)f3on,nufc, 3In tobfcb cafe, fn regam t^at tbcta.'"'* 
 kfng oft!]cCattel,U)bfcbt3tbegrortnt)oftbc0iifon, tnas Urftbotit tbe tn- 
 Tfsofttion of tbc Court . althougl) tbc Dlfpcangof tbcm ioae irfttifn pet tlie 
 Court baO nojurfBDfcffon of tbe canfC, To which Roll chief lofticc agreed 
 ann fafo, ff tbc aafon bao been a STrobcr aim Con'L'crOon ff bao bctn coob ' ^'°''-- 
 bntbcfngaarrefpafsvictarmisfttfinaugbt, anb therefore let the InJee- 
 ment bereverfed.nifi, ^■ 
 
 Cottrell and his Wife againft Thsoballs. 
 
 Hill, 1 65.1. Banc, fup, 
 
 Tl$i3 cafe teas agafn mobeo.? fpoUcn nnto bpTnmcriibo pjapb f uBftmf nf • ■ 
 
 f„ fi:U\^''J''^'i^'.''''^'^ '' ^' conccfbcoftbc action im LKgb .".^er L 
 fcp tljcJ^nsbanD ano mffc , ann to pjobc ft be cftcb tbefc boohs , 59 H. 5; f Ad.on upon 
 45.9H.(5.f,4.Nar.Brev. 131. 28H.8. Dyer f.ai. Pafch. 5 Car. Brown » i'^°'"'''^- 
 «ndFloyd<care,Parc.i3Car.01dham$cafc, anDfafo, K\)nt tbc conQac- 
 ratfenberc DID mobe from botbpartfcs, ano not from tbc ^^ngbano onip 
 2lp.3tt0 not ncceffarp to gfbc tbc JDefcnOant notice tbat bfs toffc br.B st- 
 tafnccitotftc age of 18 pears, attobfcljtfmc be toast to paw tije moncp, 
 
 * f ^ foj
 
 5H. 
 
 Notice. 
 
 Iiifnirg in 
 
 H-U. i6 5 1. 
 
 foj!)cnifgl)ttabciiotfccont!)f!nfclf. Latcit on tfte o'^cr Qie pmpcB tTiaf 
 tl)c iu:)!iemcnt rntebt be atreftcD, brtaur tbe p50.nl c Vtiaj maj,Mott)i: 
 l^asbano onlp , tl)nt tc iBOUlD malic gooD t^i" ILccatp rlvicu to l)f^ uiltcbp 
 tjiriFat^et, anDgftiC4o l.mojctotljc )iBaron anojpcnc , ano tt); \i).\s. 
 banc fa onlp to ftate tbc bcntRt of tl)c pjomffc,ano tlji tonfiur.nto.i, lur.iic* 
 iptbc marl?BC,motcDonlpfromtt)0lt)iobaiio, aiio tbcrc ojc the actfoiHa 
 tobcbjousbtbptt)cl^j0banDonlp,anonotbptbci^iijb<ino ano Wa uitf:, 
 anb tbifl pjomffc ta not llUe a pjomi c maoc to a fcrbant to pap moncp to tlje 
 ufc of bfo fP'ittcr, anb it fa not bcrc laf d tbat tbc pjomtfc teas maoc to botft, 
 aa ft mfefjt babe been , anb ft f 3 not rcafonablc to turn obcr the luf bco pojtf= 
 en, foj tobfcbt^e^J8banbt)at!)maD:|)ct a lopnturetmtotftei^emc; foj 
 rf ft fljoulD babe been fo, tbcU)f[enifg6tt)aberclcafcoft bcfo;c tbe marf- 
 age, anb tbc Cafe cftcbofRippon anb Norton ioaa otbcrtDffc lafo, 37 E-. 
 lir. Banc. Reg. sip. J^crc ouatjt to be notice gfbcn to^cn tl)C iFcme came 
 toljcragcof igpcara; foibcrctbcAflumpritfato malic gooba llcgacp, 
 to1)ftbb.natobe paio to Ijer at ftitb an age , ano^: bugljt to gtac no fee of 
 Ijcrageaabcougbtto ancCtctuto?, ano tWe cafe fa not IfUc aslnbcrconc 
 bfnofltitnifclf fn an £)blfgatlon to pap anctbcr futftafum toljcnije cornea to 
 fucbanagc, anbtt)elcgacpl)CTefato bemabegooofnttjat manner as tt)c 
 Cjrccuto; fa to pap ft. Roll cfiitf luftice fafo , tbat tlje partp fa not bouno 
 to gfbe notice , but t^c otijct mutt tabc notice at Ijfs pcrfl. 3£>ut tbe pio- 
 fflffe fa bcrfc lafo to be raaoc to tftc ^^uafaanb onlp , anb tbougb tbc monep is 
 to be pal D to bot^ . pet ft tooulb be f nconbcnfcnt to f ntftle tlje iTcmc to ft, ano 
 ^ctcfttBastbcfoUpoftbe^uBbanbtojopnbfs "aiit in tbe aictfon, foj ^z 
 mfgbt babe bjougbt ft alone ff be tooulb , loj be batt) aUegeb tbat tbc pjo* . 
 mifc toaa mabe to bfm alcnc , ano tbetefb?e tbc ;attlon fa not UjcH b?ongbt ; 
 ano ft appeata bp tbc SDcclaratfon tbat tbc iFcme \ma of age bcfojc tbc ma. 
 tfagc, ano fo tbc notice fa out of HDooja: 2Cbs reft of tbc Subgea agreeo 
 toitb Roll cbief ludice fn aU , anb fo the Come ruled a nil capiac per Biliacn 
 'oifi. Antca» 
 
 Tc o;!a(h »n 
 tnr a p ivatc 
 Hnojflmcnr, 
 
 For artfc-' 
 JtDCt t"uch- 
 in(> aTitl- 
 P=fs. 
 
 Rcl:rencr. 
 
 Hill. i65iBanci{up* 
 
 T!^e Court tDasmotco to qnaO) an (Enbfctment , becanrc it toaa fo} a 
 pjIbateSCrcfpafa, viz. foj Hopping an antfent tuatcr'tourfc , ano tbc 
 Cnbfctmcnt OOtb not concluOC ad commune nocumemum , but ad prare dam- 
 num , iDbfcb fljctoa ft to be no pnblf que nitrantc. f fobc fa not to be enoftteo^ 
 5i5utRoll chief luOice anfiECTCD , man map be cncfcteo fo> a pjfbate 
 SDrefpafa. but tbc partp bete batb maoc bimfelf no title to tbe toatet-courr^, 
 ano tbcrcfojC let ihc Endidmcnt be quafhcd, 
 
 Gomporc againft Beech. 
 
 HiiK id^i^BancJup. 
 
 TfeeConttto33mobRbontbca)efenbantBbebaU, SCbatbctoafl a bcrp 
 poo> man , anb fn mahfng of a SDftcb fo j anotbcr man , be ban nnVufU 
 IfnglpcommftteoaJErerpafaagafiitttbeplaliittf, fntahfng atoap 2 o> 3 
 tobcclc batrougbo of €artb of tbc ^Dlaintlfa foil, ano tbercfo?e It toaa pjap. 
 CD tbat tbc matter mfgbt be refcrrco to tbc fecconnarp to tar tbc bamagea 
 anb Cofte fo; tbe EEtcfpafa , tobfcbbcitastcaoptopap, «tbattbc pjoccen. 
 Inge mfgbt be (tapcb. ]3ut Roll chief luft ice AnftoeteD , Ic cannot be , but 
 you may confier> the Adioo» 
 
 Hele 

 
 Hill. 1651. 315 
 
 Hele againft Green. 
 
 Hill, i<55i.Banc, fup, 
 
 Tj^anFjefiioHefirmacafprttal cicrofct toagfouno, upontoWtft tftcCafc^ tdiivtr- 
 . fell out to be tljls, a man bifng ILeffc? of a j^anoj foj 199 pears, octj^.^.a man e* 
 (ctb tt)e Ceim to tis ioife fo^ Iffe, luft^ poucr to make Tuc^ eftatcs in as ;oa;onc fi.- 
 ample manner as fteftfmfelfmlgftt bate Done, Dating Ijer Ufe, ano tbc re*"-^. 
 mainocr in SCail to i^is IDaug^tcr, ano Dfes , tt)c jFeme pjoteg ttie WiH ano 
 acccptBOf t^c ?Lcgacp, anDaftctmabCflaJlcafcfoj 99 pears, ano Dfcs, 
 ano tbc Daughter bjfngs an Ejeftione fiTci c acainft t&e ILcffce of tbe iFcmc 
 %\ie que0(on luas, tolietber t^<s Eeafe maoe bpt^eiFemeloereagooo 
 BLcafeeinot. Merifieldarguco, tbattficBlcafcUias not gooD after tlje 
 ueat^ ot tftc J'^cme , bccaufe fljc t)atilng but an cftate foj Ufe, ano tbc Jleafc ^"'^^• 
 ft} 99 peats bcfngDerftjen oat of ft, loften tl): cttafte foj ItteenDs, tbc c- 
 CatcBerltcDoutofftmuftenoalfo. ;an02lp, SlftftciFcmeftaD anppotD- 
 cttoDffpofeofanppartoftbesncrmlongcrtbanfoj^erUfc, bp tt)c fame 
 tcafonOiemig^tbotveoifporeooi'aUofft, Itrtiict) cannot be intenDcD} fo^ 
 t1;eSCcffatojD(Dnotmeantl)at(bc(l)oulD bate potoer to Defirop t^e CBn- 
 tapl maDc npon bfs SDaugbten Sinn as to ttje £)bjcction tDat Hie t)att) Dff- 
 CpofcDofbutpattoftljeSEerm, anotbcrcfoje tiatb not DeftropcD tbc €n- , 
 tapl: Bjanfioer, 3lt matters not iDbatOtcbatb Done , but tobat (bemigbt 
 ftatjcoonfjfoj bptbc fame rcafon tbat flje DtfpofeD of patt fte mfgbt tjatcDff- 
 pofeo of tftc toftoUiSCbe tcft of tlje argamcnt 3 coulo not bcar.Henagc Finch 
 on tbe otbet Qdc argaeo , SCbat tbc llcafc maoe bp tbe iFeme continues 
 aftetbccDeatb, becanfe tbe JFeme bao a polDCtgfben ber to make fucb a 
 ILeafc , anobptettucoftbatpotocr tbe ILeafe contfnacs, fo; tbe potocr 
 g(tcn unto ber relates to ttjc C-ftates to be mafie bp ber , anO not to tbe con« 
 tJnaancc of ber life, 3nD bere tbe fntrnt of tt)C SCeftato j fs to be conOoe. 
 reo , tobfcb toas , tbat bfs tolfe OionlD bate tbe povoer to DUpofe of all tbe 
 SCerm if (be iDonlD , foi^ be trutteo ber toitb (t , becaufe (be Voas b<s ^<fc , 
 ano i^otbcr of bio 2)augbter , to tobom tbe Cntapl teas maoe , ano tbe te- 
 rpfabjca , matter (bctosWs Intent to be fo, ano becaufe tberc Is no otbct 
 potDCT CTp^efleD agafnft tbis In anv otbcr part of tbe MIU, ano tbe too^iDs 
 tbat gibe bet tbis potocr iooulD be lolc ano trifling If tbep (boulo rcceltjc anp 
 otbcr Conttrattlon , t Car. Banc. Heg.Danyel ano Ogleyt cafc , anD Gibs 
 ano Whites cafe , iCar.nojooestbeaOrent of tbe iFeme to tbe Hegacp, 
 to bate tbe 2Dcrm toi life, ocflrop ber potoer to mafec tHates. alp. 
 ^bebatbtDenerecuteotblspotDcr, fo? tbe Biurp bate founo tbat It Is tbe 
 ILcareoftbeiT^eme, 9 lac. Suckham and Hawkins cafe, a potoet giten to 
 an CDjecuto} map be erccoteo bp parts. Roll chief lattice belo , tbe icafe ^^^^^ 
 toas gooo ; fo; a Mill ongbt to be fo intcrpjetcD , tbat all tbe parts of It 
 map ftano togetbet , ano IftbeiFemebcre bate not potoer to mafee tbis 
 ILeafe, tbeClanfeofgltlngbcrtbislLeafc Is (Die , ano tbe meaning Is 
 fo, toltbout Doubt tbe iFcmcbatb tbe folc cftate In iLato In bet, ano tbe 
 potoetgltenbetelsbutatettojlngtoberoftbat, toblcbfbe bao bcfoje bp 
 tbe Hato , ano ber confenting to tbe ILcgacp, Dotb not tahe alpap ber poto- 
 et to mafee CEftates. 5ino tbis llmlteo potoct , ano tbe rcmalnoct to bis 
 oangbtet map 0ano togetbet , fo^t migbt be tbat tbe tcif c tooulo not make 
 fucb a leafe , ano tben tbe oangbter (bonlo bate bao tbe lano in tapl -, but 
 {Cfbeoirpofeoflttbeoaugbtcrlballnotbateit. lerman as Roll, Nicholas 
 luftice bclo, tbat tbe jFcme coulo onip oifpofc of tbe lano During bet life, ano 
 tbat tbe SCeftatojs Intent bp tbe Ujojds toas, tbat tbe i^cmc (boulo not be 
 
 f»t 2 tpeo
 
 3i6 Hill. 1651. 
 
 tpcD to otcupp t!)clajit)fl ftcr f df tJiirfng I er K'c ; but mfgbtBffporf of tbnt. 
 Ask as Nicholas ttintfljetnn cifpofc of tbclanusonlpDurfngbcr Kfc, foj 
 tticpolner <3 onlp gl'jcn otirfng l)cr Ufc , anO tbfa fntcrpctatfoa lufll mafec all 
 parts of tfte zmw fiano tojjctfter, better tftan tbe otljer fntcrp?ctat(on. Mz 
 jJUroed.Aocea. 
 
 Dckins againft Latham. 
 HilK 1651. Bine, fup, 
 
 Entred Hill, aa Car,rot,5?46. 
 
 • 
 
 ^fft^in »!"- T-^ "" eJeAione firnnae a fpctfal licrufrt tons founD,«pon fc!)fcf) tljc Cafe fcl! 
 jiaionc ' 1 out to be tbfo. Oik feifcD of lanos coticnaiitcD to Ictp a fine to tlje ufe 
 fiimx. ofl)finfelf,anDl){3 ii;<fefojUfc,anD after be leafeotftelanoefoj ?i pcars/oj 
 
 3 l.rcnt per annum bp tqiialpojtlon0,anD afttr tbc Deattjof I.S.topapa grofa 
 fum of '25 l.bp trap of fine, papnblcbp 5 1. a pear quartcrlp, toftl) a pjoui^ 
 ro<n tbc 3 m)etitutc,t bat foj Default of papment of tbe tent oj fine, oj foj 
 iuant of rcparatfons,it (boule be latofall foj tbc ILeffoj to te- enter, .flftct 
 tbc iLeffojletipcsafine, atiuafafgnctboticrbfB Intereft fn tbc rcfcctCoiT, 
 STbc qutftfon bete toas, irbetbcr tbc conuftfon of cnttp be ttanofettcD otoct 
 to tbc arcfgnce, bptbettansfcrrfngolJCtoftbctciJCtRon, Halei of courts 
 • tell Irttb tbe (Dlafiitfff belo tbat tbc Icafe pjoccets ftom tlje ^^usbanu onlp, 
 anD rot from tbc 515aton anu i^cme, ano tbc concftfon fo ttanofctrcD oDct, 
 foj tbc tonoftfon tuno fopntlp ao toell totbcfinctcfcttieD, as to tbc tent, 
 ani)<sa3ftU)eteafetietalconD{tfonfnlLato,altbon!!bft be comp;ffeo but 
 fn one claufc, ann not fcbcral claiifcs, ano tbc toncftfon as to tijc rent ia 
 ttanoferrct), tboticb not as to tbc fine, 3" tp E 4. f. 7. SLbc laVo matjeo a 
 fetcral Dfftrfbutfon of one praecipe , ano fo map ft do berc of one conDftfon, 
 anD Rawlins cafe fntbe 3d. rep. cftcoagafnfttbta comes not to tbfs cafe, 
 fojtbetetbeqttcftfonujasoftbcfurpcnftonof aconDftfon ; but bete it fsof 
 tbc ttansfetrfng otiet of a conDUfon. zip, 3if <t be but one conoftfon , pet 
 ItfstDelltransfcrtcDbptbc&tatutcofjiH, 8.c,i4, an c^ffngufCbniEnt 
 in part, ib not ci;tfn6u{(bmcnt of all , altbongb a fufpenCon of patt be a fuf* 
 penfion of all, anD tbe dUjantce of tbe tetcrCon (ball bate aotantagc of tbe 
 conDition, becatifc i . l^c is luitbin tbc tDo:iDs of tbe tonoition as to tbc con< 
 Oltion. alp. SCbc claufc of rc-cntrp is tcitbin tbc toojDs of tbc g>tatate ; 
 ana Knigfici. cafe objcdcD comes not to tijis cafe, fojtberc teas a grant 
 biitofpartoftbcrct'crfion oftbe lanD, tob'cb cafe comes not toitbin tbc 
 fetatute , foj tbc dJjantoj cannot baljc aotantagc bp tbe Statute, tobcte 
 be grants but part of tbc tctJcrRon, anoitisnotliterallp toitbout tbc &ta« 
 tute, anDtbercfojcitistoitbiii tbcfnultpoftt,otbctl2ffcit uoulo be mif- 
 cbieVious to tl}C dDjanto; , anDbcrcisnoDifaDi^antagetotbelLctTee bp tbe 
 ttansfctring of tl)c conDition, fo? tbe fame Statute tbat gites benefit of 
 tbcconDitfon,glt5Cs benefit of tbc Cotjcnants, ano tbe ©jantdc of a tcbcr» 
 Con fljaU bate benefit of a Covenant to be ttansfctrcD , altbougb tbep are 
 entire in U3o;Da at tbe beginning , ano batb one common concUiSon, Wild 
 of Counccl on tbc otbcr fioc , belD tbc conDition to be entire, accojDing to 
 Rawlins cafe, ano goes to papmcnt oftbe rent, anD tbc fine, ano tepatati* 
 ons alfo , anD tbc rctjcrtton being afsigneo toitb inbicb tb2 tent paffctb, tbe 
 conDition is gone alfo to tbe fine, Dyer 709. ano tbis is a ftrongcr cafe 
 than tbatto DcOrop tbc entire con^{tion,bp grant of tbc rctjctlion, 17 El, 
 BriglitminscnrCjC. B 2D!)E fine berc is a fum collateral j ano is not fnci- 
 oent to tbc rc'jcrixon , ano fo tbc conDition is collateral , ano cannot be ap< 
 
 po}ti«
 
 po?tfoncD,y. rep. Spencers cafe, 34 .S.Br.Cov.pj* jlp» SCftc ©fafttte 
 
 of 3 2 H. 8. cannot t)clp U, fo; tftc putWclu of tfje Statute cvplotne tftc large 
 
 p^camblc'oft^e statute, anofbctDStbe intent oftbcmabcrs of U to be, 
 
 fo J fojfcftutea fnct'ocnt to lanos, ann rcUerfions , ano a covenant fs Ijete as 
 
 general as a conoition , ano tb: £>tatiitc cttcnos not to a collateral co\dc« . 
 
 iiant , ann tbctefojs not to a tonoitfon collateral, j 5 H, 6. f, 56. anu t'ac ca. '^'"^"•«"'- 
 
 rc3 put on tl)e otljcr Otic come not to our cafe, ^no as fo j tljc mifcljfef toMcli 
 
 tiiaj? enfiie bp tl)f3 (t matters not , fo? it migl)t bate been pjctjenteo bp pjo= 
 
 tiioencc oi tDe partpeo . ano tijc inccntienienccs iubicb map Ijippen to tbcm 
 
 muft not alter tbe ILato. Roll chief luftice faio, if be rclcal'e tb-: .fine, tbe 
 
 condition toill not ftano as to tbc reft, otbct xifc f t.tlje fine cipfrc bp cffluri- 
 
 on of time, tiM- be rcleafctljc reparations tl):conuitto:: is gone as to tbu 
 
 reft , foj tb' condition bere is enti-'e , ano goes in x\)c Dcttruction of tbe CE- 
 
 Cate, anDitistbeSctoftbclLEffojbinifelftoafoign ouer tbe rc\3crCons 
 
 ano bp tbat all is paffeD atoap tbat is inciuer t to it , ano Op confcq-.jcncc tbc 
 
 condition, lermanluftice DcmanDCD, tlObatiftbc ILcfToj fballpapall tbs 
 
 fine pjefentlp i Roll chief luftice anfuercD, it map be it Vcf U urttrop the 
 
 condition. Nicholas luflice faiD, tbc conoiticn is onions in ilafo ,becaufe it 
 
 fiore h uettruaion of tbe CBCatc. Adjourned to be argued apiin , faccaufc 
 
 ftcloacafc of confcqncncc. 3t anotbec nap ti)c cafe luas motjeo again , 
 
 ano argneo bp Latch fo; tbe plaintiff, tobo mane tbe queOion to be tDbetbcc 
 
 tbe conoltion as it is pcnnco mnp be fetjereo j no , anu faio, tbat as it re- 
 
 fpcctatbercnt.ftlsnotacontitioningrolTe; butasittcrpccts tbe fine, it 
 
 Is a conoition in grolTc , ano a contition tobicb is entire in too jtjs, map bp 
 
 acts of iiato receive Dittributions. tZZUbcretbe penaltp of a conBitton ia 
 
 fntire, tbcrc tbe concition cannot be appojtfonco ; but tbc condition is not 
 
 fo bete , anD tbcrefojc map be appojtioncD, Dyer 306 Knights cafe, 7 H. 7» 
 
 <5. Perkim. 162.7. H. 7 Kelm 60, Dyer 334, Popham in Dumports talc 
 
 is contrarptoDyer,Cook Lit. 203, zip. %i is qucftionablc itbetber tbe 
 
 Statute map bclp tn our cafe,3nij be faiD it Dotb,fo j tbe name of rent is not 
 
 altcreo, no} tbe conoition attcnting upon it, v.oi anp tbing cone to alter tbe 
 
 eirecution of tbe conoition. 3lp. JBp tbc afsignmcnt tbcrcisnoinjurp 
 
 tone to tbe iLcffa , fo? bp it bere is a freeing of a tbing to be ocne , ano 
 
 tbe statute is a fatjoutable statute, ano to be ertenoeo toitb inoiffecaicp. 
 
 Finch ontbcotbctfioeargucomutb to tbc fame effect as be oio fojmcrlp. 
 
 Rollchief lufticefaiOjitisnotncccffarp foj tbe partp to crpjefs boto tbe 
 
 conoition relates to aU, viz. tbere-entrp fojnonpjipment oftberent, 
 
 ano of tbe fine, ano foj not repairing, ano be faio a man cannot bp biff otott 
 
 ^act Ditioe a conoition , fo? toe muft feeep tb:iralc of laiu, inbt'cb is, not to Di= 
 
 tioe a conoition, toblcb goes iit OcCruction of an Cftate , ano t.^its cafe is 
 
 not toitbin tbe fetatnte of 3 2 H. 8 Bll tbc tctt of tbc Huoges concutrco icitb 
 
 Roll, and fo tbe rule was Judicium pro defendence , niH. 
 
 Brown againft Nellbn. 
 
 HilU i6ji,Banc,fup. 
 
 Trih. / 
 
 HilU f »^5orof»8<?7, 
 
 action of Debt upon tbc fetatutc 7 Ed. 6, fo j felling of fof nc fcfiiJ- whether a 
 _ _ out licence, teas fajougbt agnintt 2. Sfocfcncants, tbcp liotb plca?j n'l ludgcmcnr 
 dcfctr,tobcreupon ilTue being (opneo, afpecialteroict toas foimo, vir.e'*'^" ^s»ina 
 tbat as to one ml debet, anotijatastotbcotbct be bao D:.aU)n a pint of ^4° dams 
 
 ^ f 3 tsiae ,vcrc good. 
 
 A
 
 3i2 Hill^i65i. 
 
 iDfitctoftbontHccnte, anDopont^fo.HaogcincnttDao gftcn agafrff ftfm 
 tl)at uao founD culpable, 3t toas qucdioncD ul^ct^ei tl)fs loerc a gooo Iuds* 
 mcnt. 'But Rollcbiei'' iudice cuncludcd ic was a good Iudgemenc,anD Cf- 
 tcD manp cafca aDjnogcDlnpoftittopjobcft , anoonefti partfcular in an 
 actfon upon tijc Statute fo; optiig loftt) Logwood , anD l)e tooh a D<(fen nte 
 bcttoccnanacitongrounocDupona jopnt contract, oj a )opnt tcefpnffc, 
 anD an a(t(onb;otigl)tjopntlp upon a Statute agafplltlio, o; to? a to;t 
 Doncb})ttDO,aatl)fg(supontt)c&tatutc. Jn tftcfitft cafe 5"i>genTnu can- 
 not be siben againtt one ot t^e contra(to}a , in t^c oilta it map. 
 
 Weld againft Rumney. 
 
 Hill. 1 65 1 Banc.fup, 
 
 Hill, 1650, rot, «193, 
 
 Krrorto re- A Cildt of ctto; irao bjougljt to rcbetfc 8 Hluugement cfljcn ftt an 3ctf- 
 
 >cifc ■ jujg- ./ion upon tlJc cafe agafnfttiDOCDrccutojfl, anotfteerroj afstgncD teas 
 
 n^nr in ».. g matter in fact , viz. t^at one of tfte E>efenDanto toao luUtjfn age attfte 
 
 s«K)non 'ntfmcoftbc^rtionbjougbt, anD Dfo appear, anD plcaDbpftta^ttoincp, 
 
 tobcreag be ougbt to bate Done U bp b<a guarDian. Twifdcn fo j tbe ©cfen- 
 
 DantfntbetDiitofQBrrojfafD, tbatit(0notallone to appear toftbln age 
 
 <nl)<iJotonrfgt)t,anD<nanotlcrarfgl)t, ioi tobcrc be appears in W oton 
 
 r{gbt,bcoiinbt to appear bpb(i3gtiaro(an; buttobcrc be appears in auccr 
 
 droJf.as te cotb bcre being an C):ccuto? , b? map appear bp 2tto;nep. ano 
 
 Appearance.. (jteoDraytons cafe 9 Car. JBat Roll chief Juftice DcnpeD tl)B Dlffrrence, 
 
 anD fafo, ft map be tl,at tbc Grccnto j !rap be cbargcD of bfa p:opcr gooD«,aa 
 
 / m cafe be bate tuflflcD tbc SLcffnto js rooDo.anD tbrn it ia not rcafon but be 
 
 fljonlD plcaD bp b<3 guarDlan , ano be (a not toitbfn tbc Statute of 2 1 lac. 
 
 foj tbat statute toaa maoe fo? tbe plaintiff , anD tbta ta in cafe of a SDe- 
 
 fcnDant, tbcrtfoje be (tjonlD babe appcarCD bp bi^ guataian , and therefore 
 
 let the ludgemen: be reverted, nifi. 
 
 Fortune again ft John fon. 
 
 Hill. 1tf51.Banc.fu-. 
 
 Ft an at- T" ^- Coiivt toasj motcD foz an attatbmcnt againtt lobnfon upon an af- 
 
 tvc.mct (or 1 fidavir, that iic 1)30 efcctco one oiit of poffefofon, tbat tuaa put in bp a 
 
 iMi,ui.p<.nc habere facias poffefsionem , ano tbat fn a tjcrp riototw manner, anD batt 
 
 ouc of pciidM jmpjifoncD tbc partp, fo put out of potfcfeion, anD otbcrs. Windham on tbe 
 
 ""■ otbcr fioc bp itiap of anfiocr faio , tbat tbc partp r nmc into tbc lanD bp tjfrtuc 
 
 of an eigne 3ui'iCmfnt,ano an extent upon it. Rollchief luflice anfUiercD, 
 
 here is title againQ title, therefore/ake your c<jurlc inlaw, for we will make 
 
 no rule in it. 
 
 Crofihwayc and the Hundred of Lowdon. 
 
 Hill- idji. Banc. fup. 
 
 Arrefl of *^ 
 
 anAfti'-'n Vi" /^RoRhwayt b:ougbt an 9cttortT;po.i tbf fetatiite of IVinchefter o-f robbc^ 
 <nihesr ft- V^rrea^agafnff tbcl^unDjcDofL()wjun,foj being robbca of i6o\. anD 
 <( w i.ci.ci.. r bao a vcrofct ngainft tbc i^:mDieD. Kt Vuaa mo\jcD in arreft of Hnugcment , 
 far >ob;.cr). j^jjj ^^r. ^jjjoj, j^poj, tjjc gitattitc, oio not Ip fo: tbc partp tbat bjongbt it, 
 
 foil
 
 Hill. 15 J I, ,|9 
 
 foj (t appeare ffeat^e ioae not robbco ; bat tliat the monp tuaa false n oaf of 
 apojtmantle.tDfjft&UiaacarrpciJbptbcpcttbop.anDtbatonlp tbc }31afn- 
 tfffaljanDtoaanpononecnoofthepojtmantlc, fo tbat tfjc poD.bor toaa 
 robbeo ano not t^c plaintin, JBut Roll chief luflice anftocrco there is « k. 
 npqaetttonbnttbattWatoaaarobbcrpoftbepafntifF, atiD (t (a aVonc KSfL 
 80 tobere mp feettjant (a rcbbco in mp pjcfcnce , ano tjcte tbe pcoos IbaU 
 
 be Inued ififi" '"^ ^''^^^^^*'" ' ""^ f*" '^ <^ ^"^' >"<* thcrefoic let Indgcincne 
 
 TaylerandWeb, 
 
 HilUidjiBancfijp. 
 
 t=l^f0cafe fojmetlp argneo at tljc 15at, anobjofeen on tftt 15enc!j , an6''P'*^'»' ^«'"- 
 fomeopfnfonDcUteteD»n<t,U)i«agafnmotieo bp Maynari , ana at '^'^"F°n ft>e 
 gncD bp bfm. ^no be fafo that bp ttje Mill no lano paffctb , bccaufe lanoa Til. ' *" * 
 ate not me.iKoneD in it , ncUbet fa tberc anp ncccOarp f mp:fcat<on , tbat 
 tbe aCeftatoMntenoeD to Debffe bfa lanoa , fo? tt)e ntahfns one bfs ^cft, 
 anb enjopnfng b<m to pap an annuftp ootb not ton'oep tie Icnoa to bfm.ano 
 tbe Mm bot^not rap tbat be mahea bint bia ^eit of bta lanoa , but eene> 
 laBp bfa ^eff, tobfcb bp tbe cf bill iiato map be of goooa ; anb fo; tbe en< 
 Jopnfn0bfmtopapfbeannnftp,tb<3mapbeoutofotl}Ct lanoa in conCoc* 
 latfon of tbe petfonal ettate gf ten unto bfm, 3!n Danyel ano Vblics cafe , 
 agfft maoe bp a iFeme coparcener of bet purpartp of lano, Dfo not con^iep 
 Ibc lanoa fn JFee. gnMarfhes cafe, tbe iFatbetgabc bfa lanoa to bfe tteo 
 &ona to be cqnallp oftfDCD, it toaa aotuDgeD tbcte, tb^t onlp an CESate fo; 
 iffe paircD,anD bete fa notbfng at all crpjeflp oftcn.3in Gilbert ann Withers 
 cafe, Mich, 20 lac. Bit loaa aDiaogcDtbat tbcte ougbt not to be mane fucb a 
 conStuctfon of a tl!2aftt,aa fa not agtcafole to iLato. 0nD tbfafa onlp a losf< 
 cal Wii\i bp tuap of argmticnt , ant) not a gtammatfcal, nno pofttfbe ®n{ll«cin(trua''> 
 Rollchiefluaiceanru)erED,tomakeacontttn(tfonofa®3:faubete tbJ <n or inte" arc- 
 tent of tbe SCefiatO} cannot be bnoU]n,iaintcatiocxca & ficca; but berr al<c<>cion. 
 tbougbtbelDOjoaoftbeMIfllbenotpjopct.pctteemapcoUect t!ic JDctfa- 
 toja meanfng to be, bp makfng of tbe pattp bfa i^cfr, tbat be fljo'ilo bavc bta 
 lanoa, anoitfaafioneaaffbebaDfafDl^efr of bfa lanoe, anobercbenot 
 onlp niakeabfntbfail^efT,bntbfa(!Brecuto}airo, anDtberefo;eff be Cbaa^'^ 
 notba^«l)falanDa,tbeiDojD^eftfamecrlpnngatojp ano to no purpofe, 
 fo % bp bef ng e^ccuto j onlp, be (ball bate tbe goooa, ano aa ft batb been ob< 
 fCttJCO, be fa fn tbfa cafe haercs faSus, tboug^ not nataj. lerman luftice to 
 
 tbe fame eflfc ct , anb fafo tbat tbe toojo l^efr fmplpca tfco tbfnga. i . JEbat 
 te (ball bate tbe lonba. 2lp. SCbat be (ball bate tbcmfni^eeCmple. Ni< 
 cholas ano Ask luOiccs concurred , and To ic was ruled chac ludgement 
 ihould be given for Sir lobn Bridges the Devifce, niO. 
 
 Lockoe againft Palfriman. 
 
 Hill. 1 65 1 Banc, fnp> 
 Hill, i6$i« rot. 1002^ 
 
 ^ponafpctlaltcttfct fonnDfnane'jcaionefirmjc, tbe cafe fell out to'' p"'*'**'^- 
 be tbfa, SCcnant fo j life, tbe tcmafnncr to JlBaror st.t JFcnte, ano tbrfr * ^ ' „ '" ^' 
 i^efta, JBaton anb JFeme fnffet a r£C0t?ctp, SLbc qntttfon fcna, toljetbf t^^ ^x"'' 
 
 tbe ' 
 
 nrj 
 
 V
 
 320 Hill. 1^5 1. . 
 
 t^ ^elTB of tijc ifcmctocrc botjno bp tWff rccdtcrp, fecaofet^e fm9 
 being cotert ft tnao contefbcD Q)C tuao not SCenant to lift prxJpe , betatire 
 It appears not fljc luas tramlneo , aiio fo not^ftig toas rccotjereo from iftti 
 3ttoa0atgaEOtl)nttWsrccoticrpDlDbfiiDtl)e jFemc. i. bccaufeffa preci' 
 pebcbjoacfitagafnttoncto!)obatl) notWng (n tftc fano , tlictojftonlp faa- 
 batablc , Fitx. Tit. Droyt 29. i^^rt an Cftoplc Irf tft rctompencc ejclnats 
 notonlppartfrsaiiDpjftifes, butalfoftranccrc, aflftfs fn Shellyes cafe, 
 ano 3 lac. C.l'.fn Duke ano Smiths cafe, isE.4 f.aS- 3;n43 Ed. 3.f.48» 
 irao tbc firft mciitfon of r^amf nation of a jFcme upon a lIctoDerp, ano fljc 
 HiaUbcfiitcnDEOtobccjamfnrQlEre , ffUbercqtifQtc; fojlKonotfouno 
 llje leas not cyamfneo, anO fit Br; Abridq. recovery in value 27, 23 H. }f. 
 3t ffl bclD tbat a i^cmc Cotcrt ia barrro bp a Common rccobctp , ano tbta 
 ftatb been tbe continual pjactltc Qnte tftat tlmc; ano iuljcteaa It ia objctteo, 
 tbat a colourable rccoticrpootft not bfno a i?cmc Cobcrt, ft fsanftucrcD, 
 tljattWs ffl not a colourable rccobcrp, but a fuollfal matter of Hcro;D , 
 ano is b?ouc^t upon an o?fe;fnal , ano tljere fo an fntcnocD rctompcnce to 
 tftc iFemc, ano to urgetbat there fs noEcnanttbtJjepr.xcipf, faanob* 
 irrtlon lublclj rcacftcs to tljc common pjartlte of affurcnceo , ana tljerefojc 
 not to be aomtttco , ano f n time tbep mfgbt Date countcrplcaoeo tbc tjoucb* 
 tr ; but note t!)cp cannot atcrt tbifl matter agalnfttbc 5Rrco?o,i9 E. j.e- 
 f^ople 9. ana tbougb tbe J^eme be not-eramlnco , pet flje IljaU be bounn bp 
 Ibfs retotcrp, tbougft In a fine It Is otberMfe, ubere tbere Is no rrcompcncc 
 f n talup, as fterc tl;cre is , ano f n a fine tl)e 3uocre ex cffirio Is bouno to tf- 
 amine tbciFemc.but not In a recotJtrp.no; Is tbere anp p:aclco of It fnlalr, 
 13 Ed. 3 ludgement 29. ilpartftlon maoe bp tojit ftall blno a J^emeCo- 
 tert, Ijccaufclbc batba rccompence, fo Is It upon a partition mace upon 
 l!lcco?o In Cbanccrp. flnobptbelBaronsrurlilblngtljei'^emcljcrc, tbe 
 rccompence Dotb not fiirblbc to tbfUBaron, but fljall gototbc^ifrsof tbe 
 i^eme, B^rccovery in value :.i lac. C. B. bcrc Is a reall CUate In tljc 
 JBaron ano i^emc. Habs on tbc otbcr lloe maoe tbe qncfilon to be , iu^c* 
 tber bp a rcroticrp bao Uilicrc tbc j^cn^c being Cctirrt 1:3 rot STcnant to tbc 
 prrcipc,ajell3all be bouno bp lt,anD be f.Uo (Ijc Is not 31ii otbcr cafes tb; part? 
 map be bouno bp cffople, namelr Irberc be migbt bai^c pleaoea to tbc tojlt , 
 J mIgbt bai^c cottntcrplenoeo tbc toucbcr; but b ere tbe J^cmc I3 not fubicct 
 to be aomlttcD to tbefe tbings ,i 7 E. ? .f. ; 7 ano tbe^cmrCotcrt bere.ls net 
 . fo concluDCD bp bcr aDmirston,that Ibe Hjall not be aomlttco to fpeakagafnft 
 tbfsrecobcrp fffljefurbfliebcr baobano, ncftbcr arc beri)?clrsconcluDeo 
 fffl}ci)onotrurtf'oc,aUbougbperaoticuturr nstotbeiTarrantpttrpmaptg 
 fonclnOCO,Jo An.r'-?. 'i £.3 Fitz vrucbcr J43 2E.3.Fitz.eftoplf,246.2^E 3 
 1 3 .ano tbe rccotcrp berc. Is not o-iclp bats, bccaufc tberc fs no terrtcnant. 
 Roll chief luftice fsfo, ft fs not to be qucCtoneo tobctijcr a recofterp bfno a 
 Rtcovsry i^cme , fo: It fs tbc aommon p:ac?lcc. 2!v. Htli'tTOt ncccffnrp to era- 
 txjmina'ion.infnr a i^emeColicrt upon fuffcrlng a rccoVcrp, aItI:oHgbU be a pjuocntf* 
 Averment, all ttfng to CO ft ; faut ff ft be not cone, ft fs not atjrrrablc tbat ft teas not 
 tone; but tbe Cng'.equc(!lon material bcrc.ljltibctbcr tbc i^cmc ba 2Ee« 
 Feme Covert nant to tbc p-acore 01 not , fo tbat the Ojall be cttoppcc to fpcal; agalntt tbc 
 rccotcrp , ano be belo (be uas cffcppeo , foi Qjc lows In tbe rccotierp tiltft 
 !)cr|)u3banD, ano bcrc I3 no Default maacbp tbe iSaron, anonotDtijcrcs. 
 cojD is perfect, ano a t'Jng contrarp to ft ought not to be aljcrreo agafnft It; 
 bntbcfoiettel'leroio'raij perfect Rjcmfnbt bat'e plenoeo , anotbcrecom^ 
 '*• pence fn Baltic bcTCfljaU go to tbe theirs of t'lcj'^eme, ano tbc SCenant foj 
 
 Iffc f3 alfo bouno bp tt-fs rccoticrp,innD tbe j^cmefspartp, ano alfo pjftp to 
 Pmy and thc ffoiTrr . am tlicrcfoie {fltlrlllblnobcr,ltInll! biro ber ^efrs nlfo. 
 P"''^ • 3;f a ffrangcr bao been Eenant to tbe prsc^pe , ano tbe Baron sno if emc 
 
 taro
 
 Hill. 1^5 1, • 321 
 
 !)aD been Votic!jco,tl)ciFcmcl)aB been bouno, anutbfs fs a Ctongct cafe, 
 anD tbfs care map concern manp mcnss cCates , ano t^crefo je fucb recotjc* 
 ttcsarcnottobcqucOtoncd. Tbertforelct the Plaintiff have fiis ludge. 
 mentjnifu 
 
 Hill. 1651 Banc. fup. 
 
 0z Turner anD Marian tecte IBaH fo: one bp tSjcnamcaof Turner an^^e^h^name 
 'Mary , ttc Court toaa motocD tbat tUc name Mary mfglit be raaae Ma«o/'j bjI!. 
 
 rtan. 15at Roll chief lattice anriocccn, let tt)C partp come ano 6nl> ottjecAmcidni-hT. 
 
 IBaU, fo? npon t^c matter ttifs is no Bad. ^aii. 
 
 O 
 
 Hill. 16 51. Banc. fup. • 
 
 A iEtGnDtctmcnt teas remobeDbp a certiorari Into tbis Court, antj tbe^"""' P"^^ 
 Court Uias moteo fo j a procedendo, becaufe no 3l3all teas put fn bere, '^'"''''' 
 Roll thief IuDiceanftiOCreD,Ifno Bailbe put in, you may proceed below 
 without any procedendo* 
 
 Hill. 1651. Banc. fup. 
 
 »T ^c Coutt tea0 motet) to fupcrfcoc an C-recntfon agafnlt onc.quia erro» To ruperfede 
 ■*■ nice , becaufe be toao tahen in Crecutf on , tDbcteas tberc tuaa no De* »" execution. 
 tlaratfon gfben agafnft b<m in tlje SCcrm tfme ac ft ousbt, becaufe t^e pattj^ 
 tosflfncuOodia, anDtbc Dctlaratfon agafnttU^m toas upon t!)C bp, viz» 
 at anotbct mans futc , anu not at bfg at iobofc futc be teas fn culfoDp. Roll 
 chief lufticeanfwercd, if It be a Declaration on the by, it ought to be given 
 in the Term time* 
 
 Hill. 1651. Banc. fup. 
 
 "\7 pon a rule to Cbein caufe tobp an attatcbmcnt Cboulo not be ctantcb a« ', . . 
 ^ gafntt Cox an attojncp of this Court , anD (paloj of Newberry, foj fC- J*^„,* h. 
 fnfngontof€F%cut(onupon ajuosement gfben t^ere, after a tnjlt of CCt-mem. 
 to; bjought, ano allotntiJ there, wild (hctocu fo: caufe that the ^afo? toag 
 enfoimeo bp CounccU, that tbc Kecojo leas not rcmobeo thence , becaufe 
 the iDjlt of Crro; toaa not gooD. This waj allowed for caule , and the for- 
 mer rule difcharged, ^uod nota* 
 
 Hill. 165 1. Banc, fup* 
 
 LEtchmore mobch the C6ntt that the too?D publicae mfgbt be pnt fnfo an j^ ^.„j ^^ 
 CBnufament tubfth luas rcmotco hither bp a certiorari. But the Coort endiament. 
 anlwerffd it could not be ; but becaufe the endidment was of another Terra, AmcDdmcnr. 
 
 the Clark of the peace wai fined at 10 1, for hijcareUffcncffe, and grofTe o» F'"=. 
 verfight* 
 
 Te Fafcb*
 
 322 Pafch. 1652. 
 
 Pafch. 1^5 z» Banc. fup. 
 
 Fort inbeas 'TT^^ecoort faas molJcD foj a habeas corpus, foj one tljat toas commtfteo 
 corpus for -'■ to pjKon bp AH jDCf of&cf0<on8 Of tftc peatc,untUl be fljoulD finD fllfficf. 
 one commit- jnt furctpcs fo?. tljcpgacc , tDl)ctca0l)cl)aDtcnD?eoruTetpcg U)l)ic!) tooulo 
 der of scVr "°t '"^ acccptco ; but CFtraojDftiarp furctpco tocrcrcqiifrco, fticb as Ijc luaa 
 on. oithe not able to p?ocurc. Roll chief lufticeanCtocrcD, a tboufano poiinD bonb 
 pc»cc. mapbcrequfreOjfojtbcUccpfns oftbcpcacc as, tbc cafe map ftantj, viz. 
 
 i>urcty. jftbcpartptobeboutiD be a Dangerows pcrfon. Yec rake a habeas corpus, 
 but be fure you briii^, good luretycs. 
 
 ♦ Pafch. 1652. Banc. flip. 
 
 Wager of A 0^ s^^o" "f ii^W lu^s bjoijsbt attafttlt one foj ^o I. Due foj uftictfl pfea 
 
 Jaw waived Xa ccc of U::ncn cloatb Tolo to tbe Eicfcntiant. SCbc H?cfenDant toao rca« 
 
 andapkapuiupattbcJEarto tDancbfoEaU); but tbe Court being enfojmco tbat tbc 
 
 '"• jaDcfcncants tDtfe tscpt a Ojop , anu ufca to bup anu feUbp bcr busbanog 
 
 pjftUp ano allotnancc , anotbatt!;crcparcsllB of cloatb Inete bougbt bp 
 
 fcet to futnfft bet fljop , ano tbat tbe IDcfennant bcr I;u0bano , altbougb be 
 
 toas a S>ea man , ano mcDlco not in bupfng ano felling of anp of tbe toarcs 
 
 in tb( &bop, pet ila Vtifc cio it bp bis afioUiancei Roil chief lu(lice adftfeft 
 
 tbe SDcfcncant to false bccD b- toagcD not bifl lain, fcj tbat be coulDnot 
 
 to it Uiitb a goot) tonfcicncc , bccaufcbisnllotcance ofblatoifcsbupingtbe 
 
 fcares iDasaUone, as if be bao bougbt tbem btmfelf. ano counfeilco 
 
 blm to plcao, to tobfcb tbe BDcfcnoant confentco, and ihe ley gager 
 
 was waived by confenc of the part)es, and an emparlance given (ill the 
 
 Emparlance. ncXt TcriDt 
 
 Dudley againft Boriii 
 
 Pafc i^52,BaDc, fupf 
 
 T^e (tonrt teas motcD on tbe part of tbe SDcfcncnt tbat in rcgart),tbe 
 plaintiff ban obtcpnco tbe canfc bettneen tbcmto bctfpco at tbcJlBar, 
 fy for coft""' ti^t l^)' tcfojt bc migbt be o:bcreo bp tbe Court, to gibe fccuritp to pap tbe 
 lienyed. tofts, in tafg tbc trpal fljoulo be againtt bim ; 315ut tbe Court tooulo make 
 no futb Tulc-.but faio^if be toill not pap tbc cofts in cafe tbc tjcrofa it againtt 
 bimlje ftall tal^c no benefit bete, aftcrteatos upon it. • 
 
 Garland againft Yarrow. 
 
 Pafc. 1652, Bine. fup. ' ~T 
 
 Hill. i<Jji.rot»i2j)5» 
 
 *T-^e plaintiff bjougbt bis jaafon upon tbe utc aqaind tbe jSOefcrt- 
 hi7 r^tnr "^"^ f°' fpcafelng tbefe fcanoaloua tooxos of btoi, viz you are a kmve , 
 inan Aaion and keep a bawdy houfc ; after a DetDfct foj tbe plaintiflf it teas moiico 
 forwcrds. <n arrcft of 3;uDgement tbat tbe toojos arc not actionable, i, JBc- 
 
 canfe tb^ too^os fpoben are of fpfrftnalconnrance, ano punffbable in tbe 
 
 , eccU(i»
 
 Pafch. 1652. 32.1 
 
 (EtcleCafttcal Court, ano not at ttc Common HaUj. 2lp. SLbcpattpmap 
 bfepallEatcQpl^onfc, ano not hnou U to be fnc^ , anot^cn be fg not pa= 
 nlOjablcfojit, anofo cannot be pjcjuojccDbptbc fpcaking of tftc tooiM. 
 2lp» Cftcre (8 no Statute a5a<nft liccpfng of a IBatoop boufe ao tlje SI>ccla= cafc-, 
 tatfonlapstt, but fo^ beeping of a Common JBatoopljoafe. IBntlerman, 
 Nicholas, ano Atkluftices, ( Roll chief ]uftice being abfent ; ijclD tljat tbe 
 too JDS are axtionablc/o? t^e ftccpfng of jiBaVoDp ^oufc <s an offence pnniflj' 
 able at t^e Common 3Latu, as being a mioDcmeano; ano bjcuc^ of the 
 peace, ano thetefoje ordered judgemenc 10 be entred, except caule (hould 
 be (hewo to the contrary Saturday next. 
 
 Green againft Howi 
 
 Parcb,'^5s,Banc, fup." 
 Entred Hill» ^65 1, rot, 1295,^ 
 
 PAnel motieD foj How tf)c SDefcnuant to atteff juDgcment after a tertfd f '^'^^"^^^^ -^ 
 gifcen againft ftim fo; Green t!)e fSlaintif <n an aaion upon tbe Cafe ^" ^^Tn "iip- 
 Ibjongftt, foj fpcalvf ng tbcfe teojDg of l)ec, viz. You arc a Whore and a.-„thcc.i<: . 
 lade, and a ftrumpetly Whore , and I will prove you a Common Whore; toe woid*. 
 Ijfg (IBpccption teas . tljat tbe toojoo arc not in tbcmfelfces adionable, fo> 
 tbep arc but toojDc of cooler ano heat, anotbcpaintif is not bjougtjt 
 toitftin Danger of tfte late Statute maDe againft tohojcoom, fap tbc fpcafeing 
 of ttjcm , SnD be clteD fo J autbojitp Frcf man and Childers cafC, Trin. 16 5 1 , 
 rot, 45.toberetl)EfclDOjD0,viz. You area Whore, & 1 will prove you an ar- 
 rant Whore, tncrcaOfuDccb not attionatjlc. The rule was to ftay judge- 
 ment till the Plaintif fliould move* 
 
 Baiccck againfl: Torripfon. 
 
 Pafch, 1652. Banc, fup, 
 Mich, 1 6 JO. rot, 444, 
 
 1^ an Audita querela tfte Cafe luas t\)la. Sin Qction of JDebf Iras bjongljt Where an 
 againft the ^Djincipal , anna juogcment upon a nihil dicit obtaineD, but ''"'''" '^"" 
 no capias ad fatiifaciendum iffueD fojtl) aontnft tlim;aftCrVDareo 2 fcirefaciaj ^.i Ball uron 
 iDcretabeiiotit againft tlje JlBail, ano znchils thereupon rcturneD", onblncircnious 
 tbereuponlaDgemcnrlDasgiticn againft tbe IBail, tobo tbercupon bjingsjudgemcnc 
 bis Audita querela, SLbC ^ucftion toaa, iubetber tbe Audita querela DID >B '"f^ '^^ 
 Ue 0% not , in regara tbat tbe fcire facias iffueD fojtb againft tbe 3i5ail bcfo?e P''"''***^* 
 anp capias ad fatiifaciendum ttjastaUen fo?tb upon tbe Juogcmcnt, upon 
 tbe nihil dicit againft tbe pjirttipal. Green of Counccl Uittb tbe SDefenoant 
 t)elO, tbat tbe Audita querela DID not lie, becaufc tbat tbe partp batb otbec 
 tcmeDp to relieve bimfelf, anDtberefo?c tbe Audita querela lies not, foj 
 tbat is gitjcnonlptobere tbe otber partp batb no otberremcDp, 21 E, 3. f« 
 14. Brook Audita qocr. 18. SnD bcfioes bete are ttoo nichilsrctumcD a* 
 gainft tbe partp , tobicb Do amount to a fcire feci , anD fo tbe partp is tcarn* 
 eo, anD tberefoje be comes note too late to bate bis Audita querela, ioi 
 bcrc is as mucb as a luDgementbp Default after an appearance, anD bere 
 Isnorclcafe, anD tberc (s a juDgementcrccuteDanD in fojcc, ano not re. 
 t)erfCD bp tbe ^jincipal, Green and Le Grices cafe , Paich. 39, &(r Francii 
 More* IRepojts, Wild foj tbe paintif bclD , tbat tljc Audita querela Dili 
 
 %t, z Icefl
 
 324 . Parch.i65 i. 
 
 tocTlTf c, bctatifc t^at noTcire facias ou5l)t to Ijatje iVmt ngaftiff t!)c iBafl, bi- 
 fojcacapias adf.itiitaciendumtat^cnfojtlj agaii.ft t^c P;ttu<pal: ;9nt) an 
 Audita querela (o ill tl)c nature Of p futc <n Ct}ancerp , ano fuc partp cornea 
 foon cno.ial) l):rc to be rcUctco , t'f.oush tl)C fcire facias be rcturneo , fo? tftc 
 return tbcrcof fljnll not bar l)jm from l)J3 Audita querela, altljounljU be nolo 
 too late foj Mm to reberfe tfte juogcment bp a tojtt of Crro? , niiD tftc bcofts 
 »i E.3.13 aiioKelw. 33,24- arc <ntl)ct)crppo(nt, 0nDt!)cpartpbpt!)cre» 
 turn ot tl)C I nichils (u not (n Court ; ilno f n Mons JRrpo jto , in Hobs ano 
 Todcaflcrs tafc 38 bliz- ft fs aOjUOgeD tbat an Audita querela OOti) Ifc, Roll 
 chief lufUce, bbcn one fsiBaUfntljC Common |9lcas,l)effl bounD to b?(ng 
 Bail. f n tie boop of tbc pjfnifpal, o; to pap t!)c Debt : ;anD Pomeroys cafe is , t^at 
 
 untU a Capiat be returncD aaafnft ttie pjfncfpal tljc JBafl cannot fojfcit ftfs 
 T,^^^ „; l^ecognUance , fo; tljc non-appearance of tf)c pjfncfpal , fo: tl)C fiUng of 
 f.nccf"'' tl)c Capias fs not fuffitknt . but it muft be returneo. 0nD t^fs Vcao tbe an« 
 Foifcitiue, tfcntcoutfetbcrc, anDtl)C JLalDfobelQto be; but bpufntjc of later times 
 ano out of inonlgcncc (bclticD to tlje JlSafl it ^Rtl) been l)clD fufficicnt fo> 
 t^cSBail to bjfngfntfte p;ifnftpal after tbc rcto?H of t!je Capias , ano noUi 
 attDtijoap, out of greater int)nlgcnceaffo?Dco unto tl)cJ3aiI, it is tocU e- 
 noual) if tt)e iBatl b;iiig in tl)c principal at anp time bcfojc tlje return of t^e 
 fcco'no fcire facias, but aftcritis returncD , tlicn ft fs too late foj bim to 
 Error - biii\Q l)fm in , ant) tbat is tljc rcafon tr)at in fuel) Cafe a tojit of Crro; lfc0 
 notfojtljeJiBailtorEtcrfetbc juDgcmcntagafnfttl)e|Ojttittpal. 3fa fcire 
 facias be b?ougl,t againtt tbr 315ail, anD ^c pleaDs tljat tijc ^ jincipal DpcD be* 
 foje tbe return of tbc Capias againftbim, it fs aojuDgeo to be a gooD plea 
 fojtbclBailtoDifcbarge bimfelf; but to plcao be Dpeo after tbc» return, is 
 "' rot gooD : 0nti it is a gooo plea foj tbc Icail in a fcire facias bjougbt againft 
 
 tjimtofap, tbat no capias tDasreturncDagalnfftbe JDjincipal; ^ud bcrc 
 ie a gooD oifcbarge in ILato agaihtt tbc iBail. But tbe quettion bete fs , 
 tobctbcr tbe return of tbe ttoo NichiU be not a Bar to bim notn , anD tbat 
 Audita que- ^'C batb not tliercfap loll b<s attantage to bjing bis Audita querela , bccaufc 
 reia.' bp tbc rctum tbcreof tbc partpis fuppofcD to bate notice, ano tberefoje a 
 
 iDjit of C-rro; dearlp lies not to retterfe tbis juogement , tljougbit be upon 
 anihildicit. SnDaBtotbat, fnas mucbas tbcpartpbatbnootbcr remc- 
 Dp to bdpbimfelf, ano it is apparent tbat be fs Damnifieo bp an unDue juDg- 
 ment, itisreafonhefljoulobjingbis Audira querela. Barns anD Corbets 
 cafe. SCbe Bail cannot fap tbe ^Djintipal batb paiD tbe monep , (f be bate 
 not an acquittance oj matter of IRccojo to piote it; ano in &tr John Moun. 
 foiTs cafe upon tVoo nichils rcturncD aDjuogeo , tbat tbc partp migbt bate bia 
 Audita querela, and therefore the Plaintif ought to have his /udpemcnr» 
 leiroanlufticeDiffcnteD. But Nichols luftice, abfente Ask, agreeD Icit^ 
 Roll anD faio , tbat foj toant of tbe return of tbc Capias tbc fuogemcnt inaa 
 erronious , anD tbe a (cire facias migbt be rcturncD bcbino tbc parties back, 
 9 tbcrefo jc it coulD not be faiD to be all one, as if tbc partp bao appeart D.foj. 
 if bebao appcarcD tbc Cafe IbouId bate ban otljcrUiife , So ludgement was 
 given for the Plaintif, nifi, &c, 
 
 Pal'ch. 1652. Barc.fup, 
 
 One broi.|,ht Tk yT Emorandum , £Dnc teas bjougbt fnto tbc Court fap tbe S0sxttc\)tAl of 
 bv Habeas j\\ tbC iFlffit , bp tCrtUC of a habeas Corpus DfrCttCD to Wm out of t\)is 
 CorpHsfrotn ^onrt , HuD bccaufe it DiD appear uport UccojD tbat tbc partp teas cbargco 
 mandc"'"'' UiitbDitcrs Dcbts , tobcn bc toas tumeD otcc to tfrc /f Uet, be tow not faf» 
 tcrcD to put in Ball ^zte, but Voas rcmanocD, 
 
 Gof*
 
 Pa(ch.i6 52. •jiS 
 
 Goflage agair.ft Tayler. 
 
 Pafch, 1 dj 2. Banc. fup. 
 Hill»i<Jjo,rot, 117. 
 
 Ij^ an Ejedione firmae upon a ILcafc fo j pears of tS^tSmqt , ano ccttafn ^pf <"•''' •"■•■■ 
 lame In Hatfield Broad-Oak fn tl)e Coiiticp Of Eflex, upon a fpecial ticrDto'^|^^'^"'_ J'^^ 
 founo tbc cafe fell out to be tl)fo, Rich, Frank fe(0CD amonefl ot!)cr ianos ano JcVrJc, i. 
 SEencmentsof t^eJJ&effuagcanDlanDsfnqueflion, upontbematfagcoflbfs 
 ^on Lcventhorp Frank Uitl) Sufjn.Co:tlf,lct<co a fine ot tljG lanDB to tfte ufe 
 of ftfmfcif Durfns bfs oton Ufc, anB tbc life of Leventhorp \)is &on. ano aftec 
 Burfng t^e Iffc of SuTannaCotelc tljc irUc Of Leventhorp,tl;e tema(noct to tl^ 
 nfeoftlje Utlrs to 6c begotten upon tbc bosp ofSufannabp Leventhorp bet 
 l^ngbanD. aCbe quefl<on bcrc teas , tobctbcr tbc toojo betro fljall be fntcn» 
 Sf D tbc bcfrs of Leventhorp anu Suianna \)i3 toffc, oj Inbttber tbc eCatc fljall 
 le fntenoeo to be UmttED to tbe bcfrs of Sufanna onlp , ano tbat Leventhorp 
 fbaUbat}c baielp an eSate fo; lUc in tbe lantie, Ser/eant Giyn of Councel 
 toitb tbe pafntif bdo, STbat Sufanna Cotele batl} an cffate tapl cj;ecntcD ftt 
 tbc lanDs , ano tbat tbe toojo befto (ball relate onlp to tbe bcfrs of Sufanna , 
 ano not to tbc belts of Leventhorp, i.JBccaufc tbatberelfi an eCatc Ifmf^ 
 t£D foj life untoSufanna bp an etp?cf0 Uniftatfon,anD bet befre fljall tafec im- 
 ntctrfatclp after tbe cCatc foj Ufe enoco , ano tbep (boll not tome In as 
 jpnttbafojs. JlBperpjersSEctmBtbcuojD belts fsnotUmiteo to anp pet* 
 fon, bntitfslcfttotbcconCruOfonoftbcJLatD, ano tbat totb applp'ft to 
 Sufanna. as to a petfon to icboni Richard tbat fetlcD tbc lanDs batb ernetXco 
 ntoft affettfon , as appears bp tbe SDreCs Lit. f, d. Seft. 28. ffibcte Is an cjc- 
 pjcffifon of tbc partp to tcbom tbe toojti belts (ball relate, bnt fo Is not bete, 
 anc tbcrefojc tbe cafes Bfffcr. 3!n3 Ed. j.f; ^1,^2. 3;tt3 rulco tbat botb 
 patties bate an ettatc tapl , becaufe tbe cttcte Is Ifmltco to botb , b"t fo ft it 
 not In out cafe , fotbofcboofesarcnot aonfnft mc, $n our cafe, It DotO 
 not appear tbat Richard ulD (ntenn to aobancc tbe ^usbantj of Sufanna, ano 
 tbercfojcftfs not rcafontbattbctooju bcfrs (Ijoulo relate to bfm , but to 
 Sufanna bfs Ictfc orlf^fo J fr. tafc of Uinitiitfcn of ett atcs tbc Intention of tbc 
 partp fs to be conODcnD , anu Dotb Direct tbc matter, ano tbc p?ctcDfng 
 UmltfngoftbccCatctoSuianna, ano not to Leventhorp, cotb (beto tbat tbe 
 jjartpufD mean to pjomote tbc bcfrs of Sufanna. Lit. StS. 37. Dyer 27. SI 
 fccono rcafon fs Djaton from tbc pennfntt of tbc oceo , tobfcb in tbc Umftatf- 
 on of ft cotb cnclfnc meje, tbnt tbe tco;D bcfrs (boulo be applpco to Suianna 
 tban to leventhorp; foj tbcteojDfiupon herfsasmucbastofapof her,anO 
 tben ft fs tbc fame cafe iDftb Littletons cafe. giy. SCbc intention of tbc iDo. 
 noj appears to be futb bp tbe tfrcunittances of tbc entire limitations , kbfcli 
 DofbetottatbcDfo fnteno tbat Leventhorp (boulo not bate fucb an eftatc 
 tobercbpftfboalobEfH bis polrcr to ocp^ttc bis fffuc, anO ttercfoje tbe 
 tro?D bcfts are to be applpco fo Sufanna,anD not toLeverthorp.fo; ff ft (bonis 
 l3c applpco to botb, tbcn Leventhorp mfjjbt DtCrop tbc efiate of tbc fffuc, 
 tontrarptotbcSDonojsfntcnt; ^noiDbereasDyerpp fs objedeo agatrCt 
 me, 31 anftrct, tbat cnfcfs not agafntt mc, fojtbcrc tbc trojs bcfrs fs cjr. 
 pjcflplfmitca to a certain perfon, viz totlieheirsof the 6ody of both of 
 ihem, biitfoitfsnotfnotjrrarc; ano tobcreas Hill. '3 lac. Lane ano Pa- 
 nels cafe fn tbis >i;ourt fs alfo obtecteo agafnft me, 3! anfwt , tJ:at tbat cafe 
 fsfn effect tbc fame cafe luftb Dyer, anotbctiueflionln our cafe came not 
 (noifpute, ^no tbc icill of tbc jDono: fn ocecs f£> to be cbictteo. Lir. 
 
 2Ct 3 '22,
 
 ^z6 • Pafch. 1652. 
 
 22. C.Tayl.i. rep. Shelleytcafe 103. ilJottofUjffantjfng frt fifftS fn tapl 
 tW0 rule l)olD0 not , fo t^at a gift in tapl map be ItmftcD contrarp to tbc rule 
 of tl)e Common ILato. 0tiD 3 nnoto not of anp autftojftp tn pjfnt, 0; to^f- 
 tfnc agafnft mc; but in 1 3 Ed. 3, Fitz. tic variance 81 . tl^cre is an cypjeffe 
 autljojitp foj mc,anD 4 H. 4. Fitx.br.448-iin mp crpcdcncc 3 Ijatjc lutoton 
 tnanpc(latcslimtteDa0ttit0i0inti)c &outl)CTn paTt0,i| i) Id gmD elates 
 tapl,i if it flionlD be otbcrlcifc, manp cttatco Icoulo be fljaUcn.Roll chiet' Iu« 
 fticc.CiHc laljcDclitcrcDoiir opinions bcfoje,aaainft j'ou,viz.tl)atit v. as not 
 tlje meaning; of tbc DonouY,to applp tbc mojO l^eits to tije boop of Sufanna 
 onlp, fo; tW0 conftrncttoit tcouto offer biolente unto t!)C Idojds, as appear* 
 bp Littleton, tol)ointerpxetotbattl)cp arc to be applpco to tftc l^eiro of 
 boti) tl)c partpe0 < anopourreatonisfonnocoupona tojong gtounn , ano 
 cjcpjeflp againft Litletons cafCjanD foj pout fetonu rrafon it 10 of no toaigl)t, 
 fo) tlje tooios ate all one as if ijc bao faio to t^e l^eixe of ti)c ^usbantt ano 
 ioife. begotten upon ttjc toife. 3 Ip. Mie are not to frame a meaninn a- 
 paiiift plain tDo;O0, tobfttj tijcto tbc SDonojs intent to be againftpau. 0no 
 ^'>'- tfte Baron cannot Bat tbe (Ettate tapl as pou fnppofc , foj tbc iFeme fjatb 
 
 an CEffatc fox life , anoiftljcrurijibefl}: map rctjibc tbe remaining ©(tate, 
 ano toe muft not confiocr of incontjeniL-nccs, tobtcb pofsiblp map l)appen a- 
 Satnft tbe c^p^cCTe too>t)0 of tt)e been , anO tbe mnttitnoe of conbcpances 
 matjeintbisntannct, arcofnofouetoaltcttbc ILato, lerman lurtice as 
 Roil , 2EI)at ttjc toojD ^dxa ftall be applpcD to tlje ^cir0 of botlj partpes , 
 bECaufevoluntasdonatorisrecundumforraamchartar expreffa eft obfervan^ 
 da, Nicholas and Atk luftices of the fame opinion. 
 
 Garland againfl Yarrow; 
 
 Pafc.i($52,Banc. fup* * 
 
 AiTtft of 
 
 Tl^ifl tafc being in atrcC o*" Sluugcment ( fojmerlptpoUennnfo; W 
 an ^aion upon tbc cafe fo|itl)crcixo;t>0, you are a knave, and keep a 
 
 an"Aa"on'fo'i'Sawdy hou'e, ira0 again mobcD bp Chriil, Turner, to^obelD tftat t^e 
 
 words. toojO0 arc not actionable, i. IBecaiife tbrpatc of fpititual cognifanccv 
 2lp. 3;ti0not fniotlintlieljeptacommonJlBauiDpboufc. 3lp,b(:rc i0 no 
 fpccial Damage laio, 1 o Car, SCbcfe too joo he is a pimp aoiuogeo not actio* 
 nablc in Lewis ant) V/hittons cafe. 4lp, 31t i0 not allcgcD tbat tc tofl- 
 linglpUcpta JlSatoopljoufe, anotljenbcisnot puniCljablc. Pepes on tije 
 otbcr fiDc ^clo tbe tooios to be actionable , ano citcc Hill, 3 Car, Elfey ano 
 Harifonscafejtiiou art a whore, and a Bawd to thy daughter, and keeps ai 
 Bawdy houfe. totlicb toojDs toctc aDtuogcQ artionablc, 24 H. d. 14,3 8, 39- 
 Eliz.31ntl)cilaDpDarkieystarc,tbcheepingof a JBstobp ftoufe is an of= 
 fence puniftablc at the Common 3Lato , ano tbercfo^c tbe toojDs fpoUcn 
 
 or- ate actionable. Rollchiefluflice, Eo call one totjoje in London is aaio- 
 
 nablc, 0nB tbc lrio:i3o Ijere are actionable, fo j tbc feceping of a JBatobp 
 tjoufe i0 a crime puniOjable at tbc Common ILato, fo: \\)c pattp map be tn- 
 oictcD foj it , ano if ftall be intenoeu to be a common 55atoop Ijoufe, al< 
 
 r.nJiam:nt. tl)ougbttbc not focrpjelTeD, ano tbe plaintiff is rcanonlifetibp tbe fpcaS- 
 fng o'ftbe toOJbg. lerman Nicholas and Ask luiticestocrc of tl)C fame opi- 
 nion, lugdcmcntt was given for the Plaintiff, mfi, 
 
 Snelgrave
 
 PaCch. 1652.. ' 327 
 
 , 5'nclgraveand Bofvile, 
 
 Pafc. i^j;,Banc,iup» 
 
 Mich, Id J I, rot, 20O, 
 
 * 
 
 BOfvilebjoucbtan Sttfonof Debt agafntt Snclgrave, 80 ^£{c unto Us ocb: »gair.a 
 iFatber,npon an £)bUsat<oncntccD Into bpbtm unto tijepnfnttff, tftcanhei. upon, 
 jD.fcnoant plcaB0 riens per dilcent jour del bref, t|K |9Iafnt<ff replpC0, t^at *" tbiigicion. 
 fte ^aolanos bpDefccnt, auoupon t^fsanfffue <3 jopnet), ano t^c Jucp 
 fine ^c Ijao lanos bp orfcent , ano name tticm partkularlp, ano upon tbfs 9 
 3utig0ment fs gfben foj tbc pafntfff in the Common picas, tljat ^e 
 ifljaU tECOtjer f)fa Debt of tl^c lanflBDefccnDCD,aport tbta 3IuDgment a to;ft of 
 ©rrojtDasbjougb'ttiere, anD tl)c CBrroj afsfgncD inao, tftat tijc 3(Utjge- 
 inent OKgbt to babe been ctttien gencrallp agafnft tbe SDcfcnDant , ana not 
 partftularlp of tlje lanos DcfcenDcD. ilp ttic Surp ougftt notto ftalje founo 
 tolbat lanDs partfcularlp tbc ^f fr bac bp Dcfccnt: but gencrallp tbat he bao 
 lanDs bp Defccnt , bccaufc tbe fffiie is general, tobctljcr be baD laiios bp Der« 
 cent J hot , anD tbcrefoje tbc Snfigcment gitjcn upon tbfs <ll tttDitt ts not 
 GOOD. Roll chief luflice , %^t 3!uDgcmcnt Is untoarrantable, to? tb^ tjet= 
 Dfct f£t agafnC tbe flTue jopneo, anD tbc Jtiogemcnt bete otieijt to bate been Vc''//i"r'"' 
 gencrall of aH tbe lanos ano gooDs , ano agafnft tbc prtfon of tbe ^c(r foj " ^ ^ 
 tfs falfc ]plea , anD not partfcular to recover of certafn lanoj, as ft ts bere , 
 foj tbfo fs not fo gooD a guogement fo; tbc JDlaf nttfF,ag tbcgcneral 3uBac- 
 jncnt fs , anD tbfs '^uHQtmtnt map be agafnft tbe |3lafnttffs mfno, fo: 8« 
 tip tbfngDotb appear to tbctonttarp, ano a Ifke 3iuDgemcnt teas retjetfcD ^"°'^- 
 In AUein anD Holdens cafe fntWs Court. lermanNicho'lasandAsk oftljc 
 fame opfnfont And thereupon the ludgemenc was reverfcd, 
 
 Floyd againft Morgan. 
 
 Pafc, i<55:.Banc.fup» 
 
 |^ 
 
 ■ AOTrffofCErrojfoas bjongbt to tctcrfe a gotigcmcntfnan 3tfton of 
 -'^SErerpaffc, foj tat- fngaluap of certain l^oufiiolD fluff, snDtbc Crroj Error to rt- 
 arfifgncDtnaSjtlwt tbe Declaration tnas free rtafn,fojtbat ft toantea latfovcrfca judg- 
 lDO2i)0toc);p;effctbctbfng8,foj tobfcb tbc ^tffoti- teas bjougljt, foj tbe ""•'.» "c!- ^ 
 declaration fs fo? tbc tabfng aluap of quoddam inftrumentum ferri,*ng!ice y,^'^^^^ "" c 
 a grfofron , et quoddem inflrumcntum fcrri Anglice a mojtcr et cf goods? ^ 
 quasdam inftrumcnta ferri Anglice bjantfrons , tcbfcb are IroiDs 
 utterlp incertafn foj tbe gcncralftp of tbem , tobat tbcp map fignffie. 
 Roll chief luftice, s^p 3uDgcmcnt fs tbat tbc Suogcment fs erroneous, foj 
 toe muft not tahc meanings ; faccaufe tne arc bouno up to pjocecD bp tbc 
 rules of tbe Hato, anD S>tatatcs;, anD toe are to confiDcr bere irbcttct tbcrc 
 fcellatfntoojDsfn the SDetlaratton , as tbcrc ought to be fo crpjclTc tbe 
 tijfngs. fojtobttbtbeattionfsbjougbt.anDccTtafnlp tbfs toojD quoddam 
 inftrumentum ferri fs too general to crpjClTe anp tbfng , ano the Anglice aQs 
 Deo to ft tofll not bdp ft ; foj ff the too jd precedent, fn ft felf, be net fit la. 
 tfn to ctpjeffc tbc tbfng tbc Anglice lubfeqacnt fs Iftle to fac rcgarDCD , ano 
 tbcfe too JDS being fnccrtafn tbc SDcclaratfon muft be f ncertafn , ano fo tbc ^"^j'''^'-. 
 SDefcnDant cannot fenototobattoanftoettoft,o>boir'toocfcnobfmrclf as "*"'"»"• 
 bcougbttoDo,tobttbntappjoteberppje|uDftfaltobfm. • lerman laftice, 
 JEbcflTuc cannot be certain, ff the SDctlaratloii. be fnccrtafn, anDbp tbc"^""- 
 
 Common
 
 328 'Pafch. 1652. 
 
 Common %a\o ano fetattitc ILato^our ple-iufnga mntt be^lUtfn, anti timers 
 tljetc arc not clcgantllaKn toojoo to cvpjcffc tMng»,tocmai> tifc tbofc Vd <c!) 
 tftep call barbarous uiojuo'f f tt)cp be UnolDii , fo j tifc mahco a lancuagc » 
 ano iD^erc tbcrc arc nolLatfn \»o;D0,Vdc map topn Vdo j03,ano aoo an A nglicc 
 totljcm, anobcrctl)c2Dcclaratfonfo as Uncertain alfOjfo? tl)c number of 
 tbC tbfngs, ao foi ttje nature of tljcm, fo J ^crc is quaedam inflrumenca fern' , 
 tol)lcb map fign<ecanp number be ttmojco; Icffc, Nicholas ano Ask adi. 
 dem. And fo the ludgcmenc was reverfed, nifi , Antca» 
 
 Brian againft Twite. 
 
 Paf.% 1 6 5 i ♦ Banc, fup. 
 
 Arrc (I of A il^ 3^0" "Pt>" t^c Cafe toas bjoaa^t foj fpcahing tl)cfc toojos of tljc 
 
 lulprmcnt In ^tJ jpia(nt(ff ; you are a whorc, and have plai«l the whoie withfo many 
 
 ail Aftluii for men you cannot number them j ttpon not gufltp plraoeO, ano a terOifl foj, 
 
 yotdi. tlje |9la(ntiff, ft Iras jnobco fn arreft of Slnogemcnt tbat tbc ivojos arc not 
 
 actionable, fojtbcfapfngtbcpartpbaDplafotftz tofjoje arc loojDa fncct. 
 
 tafn, aiiDDonotcnfojceanp 3ctof to!)o?cDomtofacDoncbpbcr ; but ler, 
 
 man luff ce^bfente Roll chief lufticc j;ave ludpemcnt for the Plamtiff, foj |jg 
 
 ff fo tlje toojoa fljoulo beconftrucuto a common fntcnomcnt. 
 
 M «-o for 1^" Court loas motjcn foj ititigcmcnt , upon a tcrDfrt gfben » pear» 
 luTelmcnt f^"^"^ ' ^"'5 tl)c caufc ttapcD t(U note bp m Committee of inbcmpnltp 1 
 
 dciiycJ. butltiuaeoenpco, bccaufcftUjaattjelnftDapoftbcSCctm, Nota, 
 
 . Pafc. 1652. Banc, fup. 
 
 Ceriiorari to TSC toao fljclrco fo? cflufc toljp a certiorari fljoulD not bc granteoto te- 
 lenuvcan 1 moljc an fnofrtmcnt of battcrp,agatnft anatto:ncpof btsCourt.pjEfcrrcD 
 endidiucnt. at 8 fecfofons Of tl)c pcacc fn ttjc Connttp, tbat tbc bfll mag founotbcre, 
 ano tbe partp batb cntrco f nto a rccognf fance tljcrc to go to a trpal tbc nert 
 &cfsfon0. Roll cliief luftice.SCherccoanffance map bs alfo rcmobcD bp 
 fl)C certiorai i , ano lobat Ijart can It bc If tljc enolctment bc rcmotico , ano 
 tljctrralbaoattbcafaffCB, anDffftbcrcmot!CD!>ltljer,lDetofll not qaaOj 
 tljc cp.cfrtmrrt; but tbc partp fljall plcao anb cartpft botDn, ano trp ft at tljc 
 ncvt afaf C0 at fjia olon cijargc, 
 
 Byron againft Sconehowfc. 
 
 Pafch, i6ji Bjnc. fup. 
 
 Trin. i^5i.rot. 1558. 
 
 E^rorto re- A tlMrft Of (Etroa toafl bjoncbttorctcrfea^ubgcmcntsfbcn fn a fei^ 
 
 vcriVa ju.'p-^ofDoajCrfii the Common ^lca0,tl)c €rroj3 afolgnco lucre, tbat tnz 
 
 11 cnt In <io«. 3Eai3gca Df tlje Common IJleaaljaD fct aftoctbc fjcrofct taben bp Default bp 
 
 er ill iiie com j^g ju^gc of afsffc ,faccaufc It ou?l)t not to bal3C been taUcn,but a petite ca« 
 
 men picas. ^^ ^-^ ^^^ j^^.^^g atoarucD, tobcreas tbougfi t^fs tuas a fault fn tbc 3uDgc to 
 
 tahc the ttcrotct ,pct tbffl f a to be amcnoco bp a to;lt of 6rro j, foj tftc S^a^z 
 
 of afoffc, ano tf)c Bluogca of tbe Common pleaa fn this cafe arc but as one 
 
 SuTjgc, Dyer f.194. f.7^. anD bcre fa a toafber of tijc Default.faccaufc tfte cnr. 
 
 qtJCfttoaataUcnattbepjapctoftljcpaTtp.ajH. 8.f» i8, lo H» 7, f. 21;
 
 Trin. 1652. 329 
 
 ^no tbe a^cmattfiant map rclcafc t^c JjcfauU cft!)et cj-p^c^j', j {mplff (tip , 
 3 H. d, f»48. 10 H.y.f. 2 1. 3lp. ^iu <0 a Difconttnuance tcbfcb fa not bclpeo, 
 bccaufB tlbe CEnqaeft fs tahen, bp Default, ano tbc SDcnant bp tl]c Btaogcs ta- 
 fefng aDt(t6 fs out of t^c Coutt.y H.4. f,i4.p'. 1 5 .^^cre is Dap cfben fn Court 
 to tftc SDcntanDant , butnottotbeaCcnant, ano the Budccc cannot aotffe 
 aftertoatos. SlM bcrc tl3e juDgmcnt fs gfbcn upon a Default after a Default , 
 tobcrcastl^c 2d. Default teas t^e fame tap Voftbtbc i.inotat anotl)ctoap< 
 as ft ougl)t to l^aUc bcen.^Haiet en tibc otljcr (idc IjelD tftat tljc juDgment teas 
 rot crronfoup, fo j ^crc (0 no juDfcmcnt, but onlp an aVoarDfng of tbe Cn« 
 que ft, anDffft benotgooD, ftf3Doncbptl)ofct^att)aDnopoircrto Doe it, 
 anDfonotmatcrfal, anDtbeSluDgcBoftbcConflnou place Uat?c a Dfftfnct 
 autl)o?ftp from tbe 3uDgc of t^c nifi prius. jlp. I^cre fs no releafc of tIbeDc* 
 fault noj €nqucft , nojcantftc31uDgeoftt>enifi'priu»tahca releafc of tftc 
 SDcfauU ; foj bp atoarDfng tfte Default t'.;e potocr of tljc 3ItiDae of ttjc nifi pri- 
 ui fs DctcrmfncD: ^m tbc relcafe ougftt to be of t^c Default, upon 
 \dW^ tfte juDgemcnt ftjoulD be cftcn , anD ft fs not fo bere. ^cxi ftcrc f j 
 no Dffcontfnuance , fo; ft fs not neccffarp to gf t?e cap to t^e SDcnant bp tbe 
 Curia advifarc vu!t , fo J tbcn tl)Crc COUlD bc no petite Cape ; 0nD tbC luCge. 
 
 mcnt l)ere fs gooo , f j tljcre f s no ottjcr Dap of Default. Ro li chief luftice, verdia b- 
 
 jKbc BluDge ougbt to batccaUcD Ibc 2Cenant,oj to atoaro a petftc Cape of tl)ea;f>uit. ' 
 
 lanD , ano not to ftatic tnlicn tbe Cnqueft bp Default ; but btre tbc 3uDgc of Petit capc 
 
 ^afcfjeDfo not atoarD a petite Cape. JFojtbc i-Cjrccptfon, SLbc JuDgccf 
 
 tbc nifi prius taD no autbo jftp to tafec tbc terDfct , ano fo tt,at fs cone coram 
 
 Con judtce, snO fotbc nullo habito refptiSuto tbc Crqucft bp tbe 3ui)ge3 
 
 of tbc Common ipicas fs gooD cnougb, anofotbcp map fn tbat Court a«rrror. 
 
 tcarD a petite Cape, ano tbep map alfo aoDf fc, anD tbcre fs no nrcc foj tbem 
 
 togftcacapofcontfrniantc to tbc partp, fo; tbattDeretotaUcatoap tbat 
 
 of tobfcbtbep iDoulD aDtffe , ano tbc ad alium diem fs alfo gnjD, ano fo tbete 
 
 fs no SBrro; fn ttjc juDgcmcnt, Affirmetur nifi. 
 
 Doiflor Trigg againft the College of 
 Phylicians. 
 
 Trin. 1652, Banc, fup^ 
 Hill. i6f i.rot. 114J. 
 
 Aterftof(!Erro;toafl bjougbt to rcbcrfc a fuBgcmcnt often fn tbe Error to re- 
 Common IDlcas fo; tbc College of ^bpftcfans agafnft SDocto; Trigg y„(e a judgs- 
 fn anaafon ofDi:btb;ougbttipontbe iLettcr0|3Gtcnt0,anDS>tat .of 3. H.^'cnt for pra- 
 8.fo; p;actfflngJPbpIicfetottboutlfcencc. SLbc i CrrojafsfgncD teas, tbat"? ''"« •'''J' 
 Itfsfafo tbatquidam WillielmusTripg, anDfoftmapbc fntcnDcD another l^^ "j."'^*"" 
 partp, ano not tbc fame , tcbcrcas ft ougbt to bate been prasdiftu* WiilieU ' '" '' 
 mus Trigg. 35ut to tbfs Roll chief lufticeanflocrcD, tbat tbc partp came 
 fnanopleaDCD , anofobcmuft necDs bc tbe fame partp. 2Lbc 2 Crroj 
 Icaa, tbat tbc 3luDgemcnt leas toholpgftenfo; tbe Jp;eCocnt of tbe Col- 
 lege of |0bpficf arts, tobercss ft ftjoulo babe been gf ben part fo; tbc JDjcfii- 
 oent , ano part fo; tbe tofng. Hales fn mafntenance of tbc iuogcmcnt an- 
 ftDcrco, tbat tbc juDgcmcnt fs to be gfbrn fo; tbc partp tobo b;fngB tbe Mi- 
 on , anD ff tbc adfon bao been b;ougbt bp tbc lUng onlp, 3uogcmcnt 
 0)oulD batf been gflicnfo;bfm onlp, pet tbc moncprecoVercD (ball be of« 
 firfbutcD as tbc statute ofrccta. Koll chief luftice , SCbc liifng map be bet. 
 tet trofteo tbnn a Common 3nfo;mer ; ©o tbc Cafe fs not alfl?c , luberc 
 tbc lafnsbjfngstbc^afon, as iubcrc tbe 3lnfo;mct bjfngs ft , fo; tbe 
 
 HH M fcfng
 
 330 Trin. 1652. 
 
 afngmaprctcftcalltbcmoncpjatiotftc 3!nfojmcrmap l)at)c !)(3 part bp 
 ^etfUon to t^e ISing , anu bcre ncftUcr ttje Knfojmatfon noj tljc Cierofct fa 
 pntfuCD, fojtDat fa tam pro Domino Regequam pro feipfo, &:c, anO !)cre 
 ludgemenr. t!}E Jaugcmcnt loonlpfoj tl)c Jtirojmcr. SCtic tefng map ff fjc tofM.fnc 
 alone ano ^atic3;tiDgenicnt fo; all, f f be begin tifg fate bcfo;c tljc 3nfo;mcr, 
 bat <f be begfn ft aftertnarus, tbe Snfomcr fljall bate \)i9 part. Sim ff tbe 
 ijfngcofnfojmtam rrofeipfo, oflfoj ibcCcBfgc, tbi re tijc College fljnll 
 ^abcftspart. jfojtljcfcrcafonfltbc 3(iH3Scmjnt fa not gooD , Thcrcftre 
 let it be reverfed, nifi, 
 
 ♦ Trin. 16 ji. Banc. fup. 
 
 Tl^cCoutttoaamoUcDtoUacatca latitat tbat fffiieoiont of tbfa Court 
 erronicc, fo} tijat ft toaa maoe teto?nablctl»o oapobefojetbc SEerm 
 L"twltr" Icira^nluftice, Takealuperledeas. 
 
 bUjieifcdcas. 
 
 Godwin againft Batkin. 
 
 Trin, 1 55 2, Banc, fup, 
 . Hill. i<550. rot. 1477. 
 
 •Errct 10 re- 
 vcifc a juJg 
 niciu in an 
 Adion upon 
 a promiie. 
 
 Confideia- 
 tion. 
 Nui'um p;- 
 
 AWixit ef CErroj toaa b?ongbt to tctcrfc a Hiiogcmcht gf ben fn m 0d(* 
 onof^tefpafs upon tbs Cafe fn the Cotirt at Burton upon Trent, 
 tobercfntbcj^lafniffoeclateD, tbattbe SDefcnoant, fn conCoeratfon tbat 
 he tuaa fnoebtcn unto tfte piafntft fn 20 I. ofo affumc ano pjomffc to telffect 
 tfbcrs Cattcl to !. S, totlje nfcof tl;c plafntff , ano fo; non performance 
 oftbfspjomffcbc b?ougbtbf0J3ctton,anDbaDa taecDfctanDaguDgemcnt. 
 But the Judgement was reverfed, betaufc tbc Court b^lD tfjat Ijerc fs HO 
 tonCDeratfoncrpjcffcD tobtcbcan relate to tbc Dffcbargfng of ttic Debt of 
 joLanototticpjomffc fs but nudum padum, ano tbe piaftitff f^x , not* 
 toft!)ftanDfngtbepiomffc,atlfbertptobjfngW3jaafon agafnft tbe jaDcfen» 
 tant foj tbe monep. 
 
 Child againft Sir John Lenthall. 
 
 Trin. 1552. Banc, fup, 
 
 Aj]5 I3[clfonof(£fcapeita3bjougf)tagafnff Sir John Lenthall as sparer, 
 cball of tbJa Court, tobercfntbc |Dlatntff Dcclareti , tbat tDbcrcas h 
 lude'cmcnc \n ^' ^80 fttBcbtcD unto Wm bp ;©blfaatfon fn a ccrtafn fnm of moisep , ano 
 an Aft.ankr teas tbcTCuponbp a latitat outoft!)f0 Court arriCfcD, ano ofo tbcrcupon 
 anckape. putfuSBatl, ano ofo sppcer to tbc ^ttfon, ano tbe pafntff obtafneo a 
 tuogcmcnt agafnft Wm , tobo tberenpon fn offcbarge of bfg 313afl ofo rcnoct 
 ifm'felf to Sir lobn Lenthall frt (Ericutfon , ano that aftertoaroa 
 Sir lohn Lcrthalllliao fuffcreo bfm to efcapc , per quod , &c. to tbfa 
 Dedaratfon Sir lohn Lenthall pleaoeo, ano a acrofctiuaabao ayafnftWm, 
 WilJfn3rrEftof3«ogcmcntta!jCBtbefc Grccptfona to tbc JD^claratforr, 
 I. 3tfaftb that tbc pifncfpalrcnojcobfmfelffnCrecutfon to offcbargebta 
 5i5afl , ano faftb , tt]at aftertnaros be efcnpco , tobcrcbp \)t coulo not bate 
 bf m f n CBrccntfon , to^febfama contraDfiton> to inbat l)z fojmerip fafo. 
 2lp. ^^cfaftbtbatbercnDjeobfmfclfto ibe iparefcball, tobercaa be ought 
 to faptbat^ercnOKOMmfelfto the Court; foj ft fa tbc act oftljc Court 
 tbat tutna ijim otct tt^ tbc ^arcfcbal. Roil chief luftice , !J?c camiot rcn. 
 
 oer
 
 Tnn.1652, 331 
 
 6Ct WmfclftoSirlohnlenthal fitoffcljatgEOf ttslBafl ; foz onlp a 3|aD0eB»H. 
 cantabeanD Dfftljarnc aJlBnU, anunot Sir John Lenthall ; but ftcrc ft (0 
 t^tl)cofD(tfn»i;ourt , anutljcrcfojcfttsiDCilcnonstj ; foj ^e map rcn- 
 DetWmfclfto Sir lohn Lenthall fn Court, ttjoiigfjout of Court Ije cannot, 
 anO tljcrcfoje let the PJaintif have his ludgement, 
 
 Rogers and Dove. 
 
 Trip. i^j2,Banc, fup» 
 Pafcb, i<j52,rot. 354* 
 
 IiP an SLdion of Crotcr ano ContJCrOion foj 3 Cart loans of £)ats , J5ar- Argi-n^f n--; 
 He anD IDeafc, SDljc SDcfcnaant plcaocD a fp; tfal pita to tljfo effect. SEbat"^"" ' p^- 
 tfte lanD tofjcre the aCrofer Voaij fuppo'^eD to be fs s acres of lano Ipfng fn B. ['i^cTtl tL* 
 ano t^at f0 Wttifn the Countp ipalattnc of Chefter.anD t^iat he t)olD0 tie lano jurifd a;on j^f 
 fojtcrm of pears, anD faptcrtuc thereof cfa foto anDtahEthcCojntl)erc«^^»'5Cou:t. 
 upon grotnfng, anD tratetfeth the ConterCon out of the Conntp JDaUatfne, 
 ano atjcrfi that tliere are Courts of SuttfcehelD toUhfn the Conntp JSala- 
 tfnc, fo that 3uIf(CE map there be han , anD faps, that he onttljt to be fuco 
 liittUn the Countp palatine , ano not eUctohcre , anD thercfoje De. 
 inanDs BIuDgemcnt <f h^^ ought to be fueD f n this Ccnrt. 2Eo tf-fs plea the 
 platnttf DemurrcD , ano fhetceo fo: taufc, that the Qctfon being foj a tranG- 
 to?p matter, it map be trpcD out of the Countp |5alatfncasircU aslnfth' 
 fn, although iftttocrefoj a local matter it IdoiiId be othertoffe , anD the 
 partp here hath pUaoeo not gufltp , tch^ch map be trpco nnp Inhere, c ooks 
 Inftit. 2 82.3 nfomc Cafes an £)bUgation bearing Date at Chciler map be 
 fneD fn another place , 19 E. 3. Fitz. Gar. 39. 45 Ed. 3. Fitz, vifne yo.' 9 
 lac. C.B.RichardfonanDMeares, aJBattcrpfnCheftcrtrpablC out of ft, 
 II H. 4. f-40. Cromptonluri'diftionofCourts, f", 213. SCranCtO J p things 
 emergent in the Countp JDalatine of Chefter map be trpco elfc-iDhere, 45 
 E. 3. f. 17. 0nD fo it teas pjapeD the SDcfcntant jnigtt pleaD otjer. Serje- 
 ant Glyn on the otber Qoe hdo , that this plea Inas a gooD pica to the 3nrif « 
 Diction of the Court, i^erc are manp matters of fact confcffcD, anD the mat- 
 tec fn Hato f 3 . tohcther the title of the lanDtoitbfn Chefter JhaB be trpcs 
 out of that turisoictfon, 3" 3 » Ed. 1 . f n the (Srchcqucr ft fs clear thep hat»e 
 conufance of picas. Roll chief luflice to that anstuercD , but it is not that 
 thep ftall be rcmobeo thence; Serjeant Glyn pjoceeDcD anD faio , that alfo 
 upon a reference to 4 ^uDges bp ffiuecn Elizabeth, it teas ccrtificD, that all 
 Actions real anD pcrfonal arifing in Cfiefter are trpable there, ano not elfe» 
 tohere, 21 E,4)Fitz. lurifd. 61,21 H,7.f,23. i H,7.26.ioH.6.i4.aH.4. f, 
 25. 00 to the £)btection, that this is a clear pcrfonal Action, anD tfjcrefojc 
 tranfitojp. i.3]DenpthcanthojitpofCookinh<0 4lnftitutes citco on ttjc 
 other fiDc. ^(.rt the Action here bp the pleaoing of ft fs mabe real , ano 
 then though CookiopfnionfhoulD be ILato, it comes notjhome to our cafe, 
 ano a tranCtojp action map be maoe real bp t^e plcacing of ft, ij H. e. f. i» 
 Hill. 38 £)iz. Banc. (up. Hill, a Car. fn Bclamy anD Bolthorps cafe fn this 
 Court, 6 rep. 14. SI thing is ttpable there tohcre the bell conufance of it 
 mapbfihaD, "H.y. alp. SChcatiermentoftftcpartphcrcis, tfjataUaaf- 
 ona perfonal ano real trithtn Chefter are trpable there, anD this being mat- 
 ter of faa is copfcITeo bp thcSDcmurrcr,9 H.7.Porter j NicIiolU in the CtchC' 
 quer lo; Car. 0nD it looulD be a great incontienience totrp the title of lanDs 
 iping irithfn Chefter out Oi it , fo? fo all canfes real map as tocB be trpeo in 
 fojein Coanties , etcn t^jougti all England , uWth tooulo be ijcrp mifchic- 
 
 tlA u a tou0,
 
 5 52 Trin. 1652^ • 
 
 Try«ii; tonsi ^Rol! chief iufticc, 3f toc can a\jofD It, It Ig not gooo to trp taafco (it 
 fo^cln Countfco ; but bctc poti late bp pour Bcmurrcr confctTco , tbat all 
 caufcfl real ano perfonnl fljall be trpcD tbcrc , ano VDljat fap pou to tljat :• 
 TrjTerfe, 2lp, 3[t lis to bc confiocrto lt)l)Ct!)cr pourSCra'ocrfc be not repugnant to pout 
 Waiver. plta^ fo;poul)atjetDalbcDtl)cpleatotbc)urifolalonoftl)cCoutt, annput 
 '*"«• |)oar felf upon an IfTuc bp t|)c traljcrfe, lu^icl) pou ougbt net to tatc cone ; 
 
 but pou ougbt to tatc rclpco upon pour pica to tl)c jurilBlction of tlie Court, ' 
 foj as tl)C trabcrfc I0 taUcn,untlll a trpall bc l)aD in tbc taufc, toe cannot teB ' 
 tDbetl)cr tbc 2Crot)c r anD ConDcrCon bc Uiltl)ln tijc Countp palatine, 01 out 
 of It, ano tf)f3 la matter of fubffancc, ano tvpnblc, ano tljctefoje It tuoulo bc 
 t)arD to maintain pour pica. ^t. anotlicr cap tl)c cafe teas argucD again , 
 anofirftbpTwifJenfojt^cpalntiff, ano b: took tb?de tljlnga Into conC- 
 Deration, 1, tSIHiictbcr tl)c plea tocrc amccrpleatotbe jurlfolaion. zip. 
 '?32Ibctl)cr It bc mane gooo bp t'oe Demurrer. :;lp. tsatjctljcr tlje tratjcrfc 
 Ijatie not fpolleutbc plea, i. ^cl)clDtl)c plea toas not gooo, becaufe tfje 
 Action la mccrlptranRto?p, anomapbelalolnaupplacc, 2. Mar. Br.trs* 
 verfc 98 J. Cooks Lit. f. 202, ant) tl)c ©cfcncant cannot pleao tbat tfte caufc 
 ofSialonlpealnanp ot^cr place, t^an Inhere ttje plaintiff lapca it, Cook* 
 lurifd.ofCourtaia full autljpjitp In point, Vpiiat ctjeriaobjcaeDagalntt It, 
 30 H. <5. f. 6. 3 flomlt of tl)C juTtfDialon of tljc Countp palatine ; but pet 
 ftmuftnot cntrencftupontlie <rommon3:a\j3,ano3 aomit all t^c booW 
 citeo; but tbcpare of otb^r local mattcra ,ojoftl)ing0 tranOtojp, tobtcft 
 are fircD to Cliciler bp t!^c pleaofng of tl)cm,ani5 Dyer 1 2 j cornea not to out 
 cafe no? croffea tljc cafe of i o. lac 3 . rep, Ridgwaycs cafe, ano l)ere It fl)aU 
 I)c IntcnocD tl)at tljc 3urp map tbcrc Ij't^c bcft conufance of tlje mattet 
 tobcre tbc Action la lalo, ano not clfc-itljcre, altljougb tljc jSJctian do fabout 
 of tbc ILanD. il^oj tlie fcconD matter tbc Demurrer malxca not tbeplca gooo, 
 foj tbe latD fapea it la not gooD , anD tljc partpcs cannot alter ttjc iLato, 
 Burtons cafe, 5, rep. f. 59. 5 H.y, i. 3IP. %\ic tratjcrfc makca not tb* 
 plea gcoD , foj tbc trabcrfe la toaftcD , anD Ije rclpca upon ano* 
 fber matter, 5. Car. rot. 817. Burton ano Cornifli , tbc traberfe 
 ta(5cn, tooU atoap t!)C juttlficatlon bcfojc pleaDeD,fo Dotb (i fterc, 
 anD tfte tratjerfc bcrc is not gooD , becaufe It is In a tranfttojp mat* 
 let. TObrre one jiiCffics a tiling Done , !<■ ougbt to be confcffcD tljat 
 fee DID It, fo ifl)cttat3crfetl)atl)cbatl)notDoncatblngbcrc, (timplpeo ft 
 la Done fomc ttbcrc clfcLatch foj tbc Dcfrncant maDc tbia qncftion, Vobc* 
 tbctupontbcmattcraaltialjcrcplcaDcDJfjcjurlfDictioaof ttifs Court bc 
 taUen aUjap,ano b- b^lD It la, 3it ia tl)c Ijonour of tbfa court to jmaintain tH 
 JurlflCiction of all otljcrCourtaanD tbcrefojc 3 l)op?,lt ia not miobrrccmlns 
 ntc to put It in mInD of tljia bonour t^at bclonga to It, 3 bcllctjc tbat ace 0;= 
 Bfng to t'oe antleiit ilato of the lanD, actiona ougbt not to be laio clfctoberc, 
 tben \T)brrc tbc matter tfeat canfcD tijem cio arifc ,altboug!) t&nt note bp ta- 
 0om It fa groiDU otbcrU. ife. flltboacrb tbc piantiff map fir a tranfitojp act- 
 ion, Itbi^TC be plcafctb In jDlnarp mattcra , pet be cannot Do it tPbcrc tl)e 
 matter arifctb U)ftbln a fpcciall tiiriBDi£tton,a3 tbc cafe bcre la. 3t la not a 
 pooD allegation tbat binos up tbc jurirofctfon of tbis Court , crccpt \Dherc ft 
 appcara tbnt tbe allt gation Is true,t tbc allegation bcre map toell 0anD \tltf) 
 lato.ft bring In tbc Cafe of aCotmtp palatine,tDt)icbt)atb fncb a furlsDictlon 
 fKciocnt to it,» thiij Court Ex Oificio ougbt to taUe notice of tbc Jurta^sfction 
 of tbc Countp.palatine anD tbat tbcp bate autbojitp to bolD plraa,45 Ed.j. 
 f. 10. 50 E. ?. pi. 10. ToH 6. 16. %H abcrment la, that tbe partp re. 
 malna toltbln tbe Jurleolrtion of Chefter, tbat tbcrcmapnot bc Intcno. 
 ED to bc a failcr of juftlce, bp tbc partlea golngout of tec Hurfaolctlon tnbcrc 
 tbe offence toaa Done , 44 & 4 j Eliz. Crifp ano Decro. ipcltljct fa tbc 
 
 plea
 
 Tfin. \6^i. 333 
 
 pleabp t^e ttatetfc become fo tjfffotjgi as to rctafn tfte K'-irlsDfctfon of 
 tW3 Court t^crcbp ; iFoj tbc Coantp JDalatfnc cannot n(t;e np tbcfr Jutfoo^ 
 (t(on to tbfs Court , as antfcnt E>eniEfn Courts, ans otljcr Courts map bp 
 tb«m<!'pleaD<ngOftl)CparttES, fojtbcfrplcaofngts coram noniudice,»oH. 
 6. 13. b 9 H, 7. 13. 45 E, J. f.7,22 E. 4- 2?. 51H.6.11, j^ojDotbtbctrat 
 tcrfe bcre Uiaibc all tbc p:cccticnt mfittcr,bnt ffanoc tofto <t altbougb ft be 
 ntaoc narroiicr bp (t ; bntnotljingiobcrc tond^cOjDyer i<5< ^crcfs anff- 
 fuc In fubffancr, toblcl) fs gooD, altbougU not (n tbc letter , ano tbc ftraf gbt* 
 nfng of (t (ball not buri , ano tbc Court is ncUber fnbcfnlcD, r;o; tbc part? 
 tojongcD bp U, Dyer 3 69 Hob. 1 1 9. Stl)f3 tratcrfc ItnDs not tbc otbcr 
 partp to lopn (ffuc upon U ; bat tbere map be a trabcrfc upon a trabcrfc , 
 anDbc map plcau anotbcr plra, Hob. 1 8. Newmans cafc» Roll chief luOice, 
 3nponrpj«ffrfpttonpouljabcabcrrcD tbat b^ toss an tnbabftant j butpou 
 ftabc not abcrreD tbat tbcp ougbt to tolD plcaof tranOto;p matters , if tb? 
 partp fnbaWt out of tbe jurffoictton , ano berc tbe partp ougbt to be fiJiiittro^ 
 ncD, anti ff be Dtocli out of tbc jurfsDfdfon. tobat rcmcop can be ban arafnft 
 ^{mtbcn, fojbotocanbebcfuinmoncD:' 0nD tye cannot juTjgc of tbc jurlfs 
 tfafon; but bp pour plcaojng, ano bp pour traberfc pou tabe trfppcD npjrvaii. 
 four oton beelo. 2Cbcrca'"on InbptranCtojp actions map be lafo tn anp' 
 Coantp is, bccaufc tbat otbcriilfc juftlcc mfgbt fall, fo; tbc partp map do a 
 faatn one Countp,anDtbcn remote to anotbcr,fobrrc tbc pr.rtp map do 
 Is^ong toitbfn tbe Countp palatine, ano tben gooutofft to aboio tuDice. 
 iSt anotber Dap Wild arguco fo> tbe pialntfff, anD Sdafto fo; tbe SDcfcnD= 
 Dant. Wild bclD tbat tbc pica Vcas i\\, i . %n tbc fnDuccmcnt alp. %t fsj tU 
 tn tbc fnbttance Of It, 3lp. SCbc traberfc is not gooD. 2Ebc fnouccmcnt is 
 ill, becaufe it botb not confers a conberRon; butberc is a general iiTue on* 
 ip plcaoeD, 9 E. 4. 5 . 1 2 £. 4. 1 2. 3t is iU in tbe fubttancc, becau"'e tl;e a- 
 fage plcaoeD is agalnlt ilato, anb tiill caufc a failer of jufffcc, Isbicb ougbt 
 not to be, fo; tbe Hato leabcs no pcrfon to;ongeb toitbout a remeop, 19 E. 
 3,29. Fill. lurifdid. 50 E, 5. pi, 10,44, 45 Eliz, Crifp anOVerols cafe, 
 aR. 3.4. HaridanDFaytonscafc, 24 Car. 48. 2. inftit. 4. Cook jurifdift, 
 2IJ, i4t.4.2j. I^cjt tbc traberrcbatbtoaibcb all tbc matter plcaocD bc- 
 fo;e, ant becaute tbe plea bias gooo bcfo;c, tbere Uias no necefsitp to take 
 It, JO E. 4. 2. ano tbe trabcrfc is alfo too (Iraigbt , fo; ft batb tpcD up tbe 
 matter to Wellington, anD fo be pjapco a rcfp;)ndes ouftcr. Shafto on tbc 0. 
 tber GDC bclD tbe plea gooD, anQ arguco mucb to Cbetcitbe jurifoictton of 
 tbe Conntp JDalatine , anDcftcoCook jurisdiA. f, 21922 E. 4. 34. per coU 
 low, Dyer 1 56. Hill. 8 H. 7. rot. 228- ano bc fafD tbe plea is gooo, tbougb it 
 be not conftncD to tbe inbabitants iottbin Cheftcr, fo; tbere toas no nrcefsi. 
 tp to pleaotbus^ano it bao been enougbtobabepleaoeo genetallp, bccaufc 
 t^fs Court tabes notice of tbc jurifoiaion of Cheftcr, 1 1 Zlich. 2. Fitz. breif. 
 ano tbe plcaofng batb altoapes been in tbis mancr , as map cppccr 
 bp tbe SBoob of entrpes, I E.4. f. 11. ano tbis cnSom bp conSruction of 
 laU), is neceffarilp to erteno to tbe inbabitants Voitbin tbe jurifbiction , z i 
 H. 7, 40. Dyer 46. Raftall 128, 129, tbc pjibilcge of Chefler fol- 
 lows tbe perrons of tbc inbabitants , ano fo tbere can bc no failet 
 of inaice as is obietteo. 0no fo; tbe traberfe, tbougb it be ill,it flliatl do no 
 bnrt in tbis cafe to tabc alsap tbe cuSom , fo; upon tbe entire rcco;D, it ootb 
 appear tbat tbe 0ction Ipcs luitbin tbe lurifDictton , ano if ^uogemcnt 
 be giben bcrc. it is coram non judice, ano to tbc traberfe is no; material, 9 
 H.7. 12. 37 H. 6. f,26.Cook5Maq,Char, cap.347 Mag.Char»C24i. Wcftfn. Not cc. 
 1. C. 3 ^. Brad, 360, Hill. 7 lac. Dymocki cafe in t\)ia Court, Nicholas Iu» 
 fticc anfmrrcD, tbe Siutticcs of tbis Court are not bonno to tabe notice of 
 tbccuflomofChefter.otbcrtDffctbanasitisallegeo, Roll chief luflice, 
 « %\)c matter is tobetbcc bic can take notice of pour cafe, otbctiDifj; tban poa 
 
 "55 b 3 lljatjs
 
 3 34 Trin. 16 5 2. 
 
 ^atc plcaBED ft,aniJ pour plea fg naucljt, »no tbc pattp map uemurr upon fti 
 foj U appears not to^ctftcr tbc cuttom cttcnog to Wellington toftcre tbc tro- 
 tjcr toas, bctaufe tt appears not to^ct^ct Wellington He tottbfn tbe 
 
 Pi„ Countp i)alatfnc of Cheftcr oj no , ano tl)C pea cannot be gooD ia 
 
 part, ano <U in otl)cr part , as Is fuppofco. lerman luftice , 2CI)C 
 JDcclaratJon bcrc (s gooo , ano <f tbc plea be notcooutoanfiDcrfttljcti 
 (tis ill. Nicholas luaice, SE^c pca ts contrarp to laVu ano rcafon, 
 
 .Corfcflion. ano Common fcnce, anotbcrcoucbtnottobeafailcrofjiiaice. Askoftfte 
 fame mfno. Roll chief luftice , CEIe mutt ta'aC all t^e m tter as it is pleao- 
 £0, anolftbcpicabciU, tl)c otftcr partp fijall not bcfaiotoconfcfsanp 
 tWZ' Sinn !jerc poii bate pleaoco a plea fn 315ar , viz. i|iot guiltp, ano poii 
 batjealfolDlcaDcototliclurisDirtfonoftbtsCourt, trtifcb cannot bc^.anD 
 toe are not noli? to cjcamine tbc jtirlottotion , but tl)e plcaofng. Stberefoje , 
 fliew cauie Monday next why you fball not plead in Chief, 
 
 Griffith againft Thomas. 
 
 Trm. i<552,Banc fup» 
 . Mich» i(55i,rot. 340. 
 
 tr^or to re~ 
 
 mem'in'flfb^ A TOrft Of Cttoj foas b?ougljt to tctjcrfc fl Sluogcment gfbcn ia tbe 
 in the c. B. jTV-Common picas in an Siaion of SDebt upon an £DbUgatlon to Cano to 
 anilluaro, anotljcCBrrojsafsfgneDtDerc, i, Ctjat toljcrcaotbc^lriarD 
 toas to pap a certain fumofmoncp, at ojbefojctfte 25 tap of December, 
 tbebjeacfjafsigneois.tljat be paio it not at tfte jj oap. alp. tiabcreas 
 tbcrc are 2 parties of one ftoe , ano one on tbe otbct Coc tbat fubmltteo to 
 tbe airaro, Ebe jatraro is tbat one partp fljall not pjofccutc tbc otbct. 3lw» 
 SCbc Conottion is tbat tbc <3lDarD (ball be maoe tbc 20 oap of fucb a montb, 
 anoftisfctfojtbtbattbc jatDaroUjasmaoebefojc tbe 20 cap, ano ootb 
 not fap tobat oap it teas maoc ; JBut tiie Councel relpco upon tbe i CErccp« 
 Awnd. tion; anO to tbat Larch on tbc otbcrOoeanflDcreo, SCbatlfitbc paio be< 
 fojetbe 25 oap , it is tbcn papco at tbe 25 cap. 2lp. aCbc Conoltion re- 
 quires tbc alcara to be maoctmoertbeir bancs , ano tbc fubfequent al3cr= 
 ntcntistono purpofc, iSlno as to tbc 3 ♦ Alter partium crtcnos to all pat- 
 tics, ano bcCBC0, tbc b?eacb is not afoigncD upon tijat. Roll chief Juftice, 
 Sfit bcpniDbcfo;ct!)CDap, it is paio at t!)c Dap, ano fo tbat is certain 0- 
 ntiugb . 9 H. 7. Snotbcr exception toa& tahcn, tbit tbc conoiticn u^as tbat 
 tbe ^rbitremciit flioulo be put in tojiting bp tbc arbttratojs , anu it is not fo 
 bcrc C);p;cffeo,but onlp gcnerallp tbst it lias put in tojiting.RolI chiefian-» 
 Jtisnottobcncccflarilpunocrftmo tbat it muft be pat in tojitfng bp tbc 
 Arbitrators tbcmreltJCSjSfnotbrr Crccption itas taken tbat berc isanQaU 
 la\u?p after juogcment, 5tbitc is a fault in tbc i]DutlaiDjp,foj In tbc Mrit 
 to tbe &bcrlf it is przcipipimus vobi', iiilff ao of pia^cipiraus vobis,5tbe peat 
 of our ILOJD Is in i^igures, 3nO 2lp. It is fecundum confuetudinem regni 
 Anplijc . tubcreas it teas in tbc time oftbc Papers of tbe llibcrtp of Eng- 
 land, Roll chief luftice, Sftbc tDOjB be prsdpipirauj, tbcn tbcte Is no 
 tommanototbc&berif, fojtbatUjojoCsnlfic^ notbfng, Therefore let tbe 
 Outlawry 6e rcverfed,and jnCgement affirmed. 
 
 » 
 
 Trint
 
 Trin. 1552. ^jj 
 
 Trin. 1651. Banc. (up. 
 
 IJianjaidtonupontficXgfc, tlic ipiafntff Detlarco, tbat in Tuth a ?^(?6' Demurrer to 
 toap tljc Defcnoant Dtggeo a bole , ano tbat bp rcafon of tljst ftolc, ag tje »n evidence, 
 teas ttatelUng tn t!)c toap Inftb l)b OclDfng , Ws ©elofng Ola fall ano burt 
 tiimfelf, to b<0 Damage, it, tiapon not gulltp pleaoeo ,mn fCTuc lopneo at tbe 
 JTrpal, tWoctfocnrctDaatttcntotljelnr)', namrlp, Eftat tf)c ?9!afntlf« 
 ^crtjantiuas Belting Ws {patters Oclomglittljc toap, being loaoen uU|) 
 ilcao , anDtbatbprearonof tbcbolebe fell, %c. SCo tbis eViDrncc it asf 
 ocmurrcD, anDfoicaHfelttoaafljctociJ, SEbatbptUcelhEncc It ncltbcrlo 
 p?oljeotbattberc\i3aBfucbatoap, noj tobat pcifon nlggco t!,e bole , botb 
 tDbfcb are part of tbc Iffnc to be trpcD , ano fo tbe cWoence pjotjcfl ft not, antt 
 tberefojcf0notgooDtofinotbe HHcrolctfo; tbepafntff, as the Jurp bate 
 Done. Roll chief luftice, SCbtiJcWoencelono mojctbaii a fpccfal Sicrofcr, 
 anDftougbttoflnDtbctoap anotb'bolcofggeo , anoaDtbe matter £oniiu« " 
 cing to tbe Iffue , ano tbercfojc It ta not gooo as it ia, Therefore lee thcVcrdi^i 
 Vcrdid be quaftied, and a new Venire awarded. Veniie. 
 
 Heard againft Read 
 
 Trin. idji. Banc, fup, 
 
 1^ m jSctfon upon tbc Cnfe foj too jD0 , tbc Cafe toas me , tbe SDcfcn* . 
 oantbcfngbjougbtbelojcalufllccofipcacctoanrtoer a crime objccco judeement in 
 agafnttbfm, tbc palntif appcarcDasa toltncfa to tcfliffe agalntt bimjn laion for 
 labeteupon tbc SDcfenoant to tocaUen bis 2Ccftlmonp bid fpealt tbcfc toojca wofds. 
 •ftbcpafntffbefojctbeBluKltcof^eace, Thou haft been a contentious 
 man this 30 years, and a Breeder of (trife, and had taken a falfe Oath a* 
 gainfl my Brother and Sifter in a matter of incontinency, and haf> taken zo s» 
 for it, and 1 will ftiew it upon Record. tHpon not gnfltp pleaoeo, anD a 
 tmcrofrt foj tbe fpialntlf , 3t toaa motcBln atreft of UnDgcmc itt , t'bat tbc 
 too^Ds toerc not actfonabic , bccaufc it la not faio tbat be fa periurcD tn anp 
 Court of IRccojo, but, tbat be toll! (bcto ft upon IRccojo, antt 15 Car, 
 Morton and Clapams cafc toaa tItcD ; but on t\)z otbcr fioc it toaa faio , tbat 
 take an tbc too;Da togetbcr tl}cp are actionable, ano Trin. 22 Car. Osborn 
 and Brookes cafc toaa citcD. Roll chief luftice, SCbctoojDaarc faio to be 
 fpobcnfalfo&maliuofc, anDltia not faio in tbc Wecojti tbat tbe pattp 
 fpohc tbem in bla oton Defence , ano It map be tbcp toerc fpokcn bp tbe bp, 
 ano not In tbe juoftfal pjocecoinaa , but It appcarco upon rcooing of tbe Kc«caf< 
 cojD, tbat tfjcp toerc fpohcn to Dlfafalc tbc piaititlfs tiftimonp: wdbcrc- 
 upon Roll chief luftice faio, JCbat tbc action oioaatocu lie in tbia cafc, aa 
 it ootblic fo} enoidtng one falfo et maliiioie , fo;s Cnoiitmenta arc tno^c f a:: 
 tourco in tbc iLato tban pjibate matters bettoccn patties, Thertforc let 
 the Plaintif have hit ludgemenr, niil. 
 
 Cufto^
 
 jr4 Ttin.iS'^ z. 
 
 Gu (lodes againft Howell Gwinn. 
 
 Trin, idja. Banc. fup» 
 
 HOweli Gwinn toas ttiDfctco of pcrf urp , fo j tahfng of a fnlfc £)aH) In m 
 Affi *a vit mane befo?c a flatter of tlje € l)ancerp , ano Voao foanu gaU- 
 ju£g'n.cnt jp^ gttoaflmoljcDftiilrteftof^HDScmcnt, i. Eliat ft Dotlj not appear 
 mem tot pet* li' t^c liC£o:o tl)at tl)C fl)atb maoc luac anp tftfng materfal te t!)c fute De- 
 jury, pcncing (n tftat Court , ann to it is but an crttajuuicfal iDatb , ant» ie not 
 pcrlurp citljcr bp tfte Ctimmon ILaln , o? bp tbc fetatute. 2lp, Kt Dot!) not 
 appear t!)at tfje partp tooU a falfe £iat^, fo; <t appears not ubctfjer tbc spa. 
 Ccr of tljc Cbanccrp tjao anp F^i^ ^"^ to tabc tl)fg £Datl),anD f f tjc ftao not, tften 
 it cannot be pcriurp. Latch enfo?ccD tftc 2 Cvtcptfon , ano fafo , SCfjat a 
 ip3ftcroftbcCi;anccrpt)atl)notpotDCrex Officio to take an £DatIj, anD 
 ■ ttjercfojctbepartpousbttofficlDtbatbctjaopolDcrtotahctbfs £Datl); but 
 IfbcbatftpotoerbeougbtnottotabcftHpontbc l)olp (EttangcUfts , 30 U <g 
 l;ere crpjcffco , but it ougbt to be upon tbc l;olp CEbangclp, foj tb" 
 fojni <S fuper facro fando Evangelic, anD not Evangeliftij. Maynard on 
 tbc otbcr ftoe p?apei) juogcment , anu tbat tb' partp map be finco, ano an. 
 ririercD, tbat UBotbtDcU appear tbat tbe £)atl) irac mace toutbfng tbe 
 caufcfnqticttfon, anotlic encfctmcntfsbcrelafoat tbc Common ILato, 
 ano not upon ttc g>tatute» ijiert <t is not ncceCtarp to tbcto tbat a jpaftet 
 oftbcCbanccrp batb autbo?ttp to tahe an £?atb, foj ft is tbc common 
 courfe anB p:adfcc of tbe Court of Cbanccrp foj tbc i^attero to tahc oatbs, 
 anD tbc Cbanccrp bcfng a Court of JRccojo bcrc , tbfs Court fa bouno to 
 tabe notice of tbc Cuttoms ufco in ft. ^Ip. Che taUfng of tbe Datb upon 
 tbe !^olp CEfeanfclffic , anDtbetaMn?offttipontbc!^o!p Gbnngclp is all 
 onefn effect. Rollchienuftice, 2Lbcmofl: mntcrfal Crcrptfon fs, \tbc- 
 tljcr a Rafter of tbf Cbanccrp batb autbojftp tx Officio to tahe an £Datb, 
 anoccrtafnlpantfenlp be ban rot, ano tbcrcfojcpoufljoulo balccrpjef- 
 fco tbat be bau autbojftp to take an £Datb. at anotbcr cap Hales fafo, tbat 
 ft Dotb IncU appear bp tbc iRecojo , tbat tbc cpaltu r bao autbo jf tp to take tbe 
 o.th. £)atb of tbc pcrfon , ann manp pjcfiocnts are , ao our Cafe is. Roil chief 
 luftice , %\it IpjcftDcntfl are , tbat be batb autbojftp to take an ilDatb prout 
 per Recordum, ?C. but ft ffl not to crpjCffCD bcrc. Nicholas luftice, f^attct 
 Of tbc Cbanccrp of common rfgbt batb no poUjcr to take an £)atb, ano tberc- 
 fo je fn tbfo Cafe pou QjoulD babe plcaoeo p; ccf felp tbat be bao autbojftp, 0- 
 tbertoffc it cannot be gooo. H ilcs at anotbcr nap anftocreo anotbcr CErccp- 
 tfon taken, tbat ft cfo not appear tbat tbc Affidavit fntobfcb tbc falfe £Datb 
 iras maoc , toae filcp, ano tbcn ft irao net upon iRcrojo. ano fo coulo be no 
 perlnrp, ano fafo ft is all one tol)Ctbcrt;;e Affidavit be filcooj not , foj tbc 
 fo^ftoearfng fs bcfoje tbc filfng, « tbc partp tobo takes tbe oatb map cboofc 
 icbctbcrbeUjfllfilcitojno, anotbcrcfo?cftfanotncceirarpf!! tbc plcao* 
 fnctofflp.asitappcarfibptbclRccojD. Greenontbe famcftDC, $t map 
 bctbatftlDasftleo, ano afterlraros taken off from tbcfile , ano tbcn be 
 cannot fap as ft appears bp tbc IRccojo , ano ft Icoulo be mffcbietous f f tbe 
 partp flboulo not be punftb ofo; tbc pcriurp, bccnufetbc Affidavit teas not' 
 filcol Serjeant Glyn on tbc otbcr fioc fafo , tbvit tbc PjcCiDents tobicb are 
 fljeluntopjotietbata jp^ftcrof tbcCbai':£Crpma)'takcan£Datb, arc,tbat 
 tbc partp batb maoc an Affidn it, as ft appears fap tbelRecoio, anotbfa 
 fs not fo plcao:o ^,crc , ann tbcrefojc tbe |02cffDenffl mahc foj us, <Xn 
 Cniifament cannot be at tbc Common }LaU3 fo j pcrfurp fn an Affidavit , ff 
 ftfacnotfilcij, foitbcfilfnjjofitmakcsft a grouno to frame tbe dBnofct.
 
 Trin. 1652. 3^7 
 
 ment upon , ano fo UiHn otfecr ConTto , foj tic flUng of ft effecs polDct to 
 
 tl)C Court to moUc rule©, eno ojoets upon ft. Wild on tljc fame Roc fafo , 
 
 tlbat ft appears not fecre pofitfuclp, tijat tl;c Affidavit luaa maoe fn t^fc taufc 
 
 ullcgcD, bnt onip bp tcap of argument, lolftb fa not gooD. Roll chief luftice, 
 
 3f ft be fn l\}t fame t'u!tntirr,<t O/all be fjitcnDCD to be betlrecn tbc fame par- „ . , 
 
 tfcs : per tarp at tl)c Common JLaln is fr.tf nD8D to be fn fomc Court , ann '^^" ''' 
 
 legal pjof cccfngs, foj of a falfe oat!) ma^c bcfoic us not toutfjfng tbc mat. 
 
 terfnqucftfonbct^j-.c en ttc parties, an cncicment o'pcTjiirpIfcs not, ano ^'"''^'"*"f- 
 
 ft appears not !)crc,tl)attljc Cfjanccrp tcoluiotfcc of tijfg Affidavit, fo:no» 
 
 tbfnc Iras Doirc upon ft, ano tbc Itjojtc ns ft appears fcptbc I'^reojo arc 
 
 matcrfal tuojcs , ano do make up tbe btifmctfe, but t!,ep arc I)crc omfttcD. 
 
 3f ore matic a falfc oatlj, tljc partp fs punfOjable foj ft bp an aafon upon tfcc 
 
 cafc,fn rafc ft be not perjurp, ioi ubfci) be map be enofeteo fo; ft. fl falfe Cafr. 
 
 oatftfs onctI)fnr,ano pcrlurpfs another t'ofng, fo; onefs j«t)fcfal,anD tbe 0= Fjifc Oath. 
 
 tber fa cvtranioff fal. 2nD tbc ilato f nfiics greater punffljmcnt, fo; a falfc 
 
 oatb mace fn a Court of fuftfce, tban if ft be maac clfc^toterc , becaufc of 
 
 tlje p;cfcrt6tfon of juCfte. lerman loHicefafD, tbat perjurp tafees fta 
 
 name frompcrl-crtfngof jnfifec, ano tbercfojc ft fa fntcnocD to be fn a 
 
 Court of jtilifcB . The Court beld theendidrocnt ill, and gaveludgcmcnt a- 
 
 gainft the Cuftodes. Poflca» 
 
 Trin. 1652. Banc. flip. 
 
 Vpon'a rcfojnof tbc Cojonct of an enquctt fount) befo;cf)fm, tljat one 
 ^aBfefllcoanotbsrmanUiftl) a gun bp mifaDtenture, 2Cbe qucflfon ^"^^u'''^,! '''J' 
 Icaatobctbcr tbe partp mfobtplcaotbe general paroon. SLbereupon Roll lhcVn""» 
 chief luflice faf D, f f one fefll another bp Dofng an art inbfcb toaa neeblcfa fo; paraon 
 bfm to CO , ft fa manflaugbtcr , anu fo toas ft aojuogeti fti fefr John Chis Manfliughter 
 chenerstafelatelp.ubohfllcD b'amanbpmffaotcnture fn fcntefng trftft 
 Ijfm ; but (i be bill anotber fn oofng an art tobfcb belongs to bfa callfng, ft fa Patd on. * 
 not manflaugfjter, tfjerefoje men muft b c arp not to Do tfjfnga, tibftb torn 
 cctn tbem not to do. And therefore this Ad is not within the gcntraJj par« 
 don; bucbemuflpurchafehis pardon« 
 
 Williamfonagainft Norvvitch; 
 
 Trin, 1 652. Banc, fu p. ' 
 
 Hill. «65i.rot, 1668. 
 
 J 5 tons inbebtet! to Williamfon tbe piafiitfff bp a confrart,anD to Norwitch 
 t^c JDefenoantuponanoblfgatfon, ano cpca fnteftate, Norwitch fntet- Demurrer to 
 mcolca toftb tbc goooa, Williamfon b;fngB an 9rtfon of tebt agafnft bfm ae ^ p'" '" '^'''^ 
 €rcrHto;oflifsovinto:ong, Norwitch takes I'^ttcra of aomfnittratfon of r^*'""'". 
 m (2JooDo,-anD Cbatcls of I. S. anb tbcn pleaos tbat I. S. toaa fnoebtcD unto feu torrJie. ' 
 *fm bp £)blfgatfon, in tbc fnm of 50 1, ano tbat be bao tafecn out lettcra of inefn. 
 aDminfCratfon of tbeilDooDa ano Cbatcla of I. S. ano bp bfrtuc tljcrcof 
 Dotbrctafn dDooDsanb Cbatcla of I. S. to tbc balae of tbe fafo Debt , ano 
 JbcODea tf;ofe batb nulla bonp, &c. SCo tbfa plea tbc plafntf ff DcmurrcD, ano 
 -itequrfifonberctras tBbetbcrtbc€jxtuto;oft)f0 otonlD;ong,aftcrU)atDs 
 lafefng cut lettcra of aDmfnfftratfon pendente lite, map retafn tbe gooDs of 
 tbc fntcftatc.te fatfofic bta oltn Debt Due upon JBono, 0; ongbt to 
 fatfsfic tbc ^lafntfffa Debt Due bp contrart. 3It teas urgcD tbat be 
 tonlo not pJcao tt^is pUflj ano t&cfc booUa Ujcrc cftcD, 5 , rep, Cowlters cafe , 
 
 %% and •>
 
 35« 
 
 Trin. 1552. 
 
 ano 21 H. 6. f. 8. and 38 Ed. 3. f. 17. ano ft \Dso fafD tftat Wacarcisftronr 
 gcr, bccaufe tljc aDmtn<tttat(on Vdos taUcn pendente lite, 5 . rep, Midletont 
 cafc.i E, 4. 7. Litch on tt)cotl)ci:fjDcl)cH)tl)c plea £5003, atiDagrccoCowl. 
 terstafc 5. rep. ano t^att^c taktne of letters o( aominiffratton (ball not 
 Dcttroptbc)piamtffif0U)',lti but ^ete <o a Icgall at)mini(lTato;t , ant) l)e 
 ini(;t)t bate cctcpneD t^e gooDs if be bao been £3cbt0} but in equal Degree 
 fuitl) tbc otljcr ; butbcia aD:btoj ofa bigljcr nature tliantbcotljcr, foj 
 bis Debt is bp SBonD , anD tt)C others bnt bp contract , ano tbc laiD requires 
 IjioQcbttobcfirftfatiflficD, » H. 4. 21. Comenr. 547. Jfbc bate moje 
 gooDfi t!)an Ujillfattcfieb^mfclf, be ougbt to maUc election tobat gooDjS b& 
 Vcillba^c, ano alter tbcpjopcrtp; biittDbcrcttercarenotmoje jjooDs , it 
 fsnot neceCTarptoDoit. ;3nDtbclaU}a)oulDDolnjong,tf b^Hioulonot be 
 firftfatieftcD, fo} noialieisalatofullaDminiftratoj, ano alfo a creoitoj 
 ofabfgbcrnatnrc tban tbcotbcr, ano becaufc be cannot b;ins an SLdton 
 againSbimfclffo^btsDcbt, tberefo^e be map bp lalo retain tbc gooDs in 
 ratiofaction. 0nD be map fatfefte a Debt upon a fpccialtp, before a Debt Due 
 upon a contract, altbousb a fute toere commcnccD foj tbe Debt Due upon tb^ 
 contract, fo bere lie map retain tbc gooDs. Roll chief luf^ice , iKHbp fljall 
 not bcrctbcaDmtniftration purge tbe tojong tobicbbe DiD as Grccutoj of 
 I)iaou.in iD?ongi' 3t is true InDceD tbat be fliall not abate tbc tojit, bp tabing 
 letters of aomfnlftration; butbcmapplcaDtbiopleainbar of tbe ^flion, 
 Ab.tcmenr. *'"'' ^"^^^ '^ ^°^^ "°^ appear but be is rigbtlp Cpccuto; , toitbout Doubt tbe 
 Bii. ' plcabercplcaDCD,baDbeengooDtoaflranger Inftbout letters of aDitiinf- 
 ttratfon , anD tbc lata fljaU fupplp tbc retainer to b!m bere , anD Jbere is 
 nolDjongtotbcSDcfcnoantiatanotbcrDapit loaa mobeo again, and the 
 Court held cbe plea good , and ordered ludgemcnc for the DcfendanCj 
 nin, 
 
 5cro(Jc againft Homes. 
 
 Trin. 1(552, Banc, fup» 
 Hill, 1651. roc, 9PP. 
 
 Arrett o( Q ^rode bjougbt an Action upon tbc cafe againft Homei , fo j fpeaUing of 
 ju'e-n,cnt In «- ttjc^ctoojDsof bim trt rclatiou Of bJs oificc , be then being Cburcb- 
 an Aaion for loarDcn of St, Clements J3arifllinOxfor</; Thou art a cheating knave, and 
 words. haOcolened thePari(hof4ol, tmponnOtguiltpplcaoeD , anOatJCrDict fOJ^ 
 
 tbc plafnttfT.lt iDJiO mobeD in arrctt.o': 5u:;gir.cnt,tbat tl!C luojos loere not 
 arttoiiablc, becaufcbcrc toaarofpccialloffcailcacobp tbc plaintiff, noj 
 is be-in anp Danger of co;po?al panilbment,bp fpcaUing of tbe toojDs, Pafc 
 10. lac. Hopper ano Baiier. Roll chief lufticeanflDcreo, tbc matter is not 
 fo mucb tbc loffcofbfs office, astbcloffc of bis crcDit in being accomptcD a 
 cheater, at another Dap Crook Senior mobeo fo; Suogemcnt foj tb^ 
 plaintiff, anofaiotbc toojDs are aaionablc , fo; a dburcbKuaroen (a 
 not mecrlp a fpfritual officer, but an officer bp tbc Common iLauj, antt 
 alfo bp tbc Statute, Yarly anD Ellis cafe. Sir Mill s Fleetwoods cafe,Hob.rep, 
 Bray ano Hayncs. Crook Junior on tbc other llOe urgcD tbat tbfs is not an of. 
 ficc of p;ofit,but of trouble ano buroen , anD no fpecial lode is allcgeo* 
 Roll chief luftice. £Dfficer3 tobicb babe no benefit bp tbcir offices babe mo je 
 ncctj to be repairea, if tbcp be fcanoalifcD in tbcirCrecution oftbcm, ano 
 bere t^efcanDalisgrcatlotrc, toan boneft man, ano tobat other remebp 
 c»r= can be babe to repair b<mfelf, but bp bis action on tbe cafc:' Icrman Ni- 
 
 cholas and Ask of tbe (amc opinion. And lo ludgemcnc was given for tbe 
 Plaintiff, nili. Trin.-
 
 Trin. 1652.. 3^59 
 
 Trin. 1652.Banc.rup. 
 
 "W^on an Affidavit tcaofn Court mauebpDftcrspjFoncrflfn tijc upper Motiq^tore- 
 iSciicft-pjffon (icrafnfl Cojorcl Ktycs ap;ffcncr,t!)&t ftc is tcrp tmrulp , move a prifo- 
 «abufctt) tjicfcllOtDprffoncrgjlt InaB mo'oeD Ijc migljt bcremotJcD toNtw- r.eroutcfdie 
 fate; 3l5atRollchietluf)iceanfiLercD.(fl):bc unralp, the ©aolct mutt "PF" ^^"'^^ 
 pat on frons npon Vjim, ano feccp bfm fafclp t!icrc, foj tiJs fo no caufe.foj os ^'j„ " [° je. 
 to rcmotjcftfnr, fo; tjc Ipcs tl;crc unDct inanj; afltons, ano toe maft not rc« r.yed. 
 mote 5fm to another p jtfon. 
 
 Trin. 1652. Banc. flip. " 
 
 T" !^c Court teas motjco tbat tbc partp mtgl)t not babe> trpal at tl^c USat Apairft a tr- 
 -■■ nnttllbcl}aDpafDcott& upon bcfnttnonfutc in a fojmct action foj tftcaiaciiie Bar 
 famelanD0» Roll chief ludice, tie fliali not proceed to another tryal,un- ''" «^^ P*'** 
 till he have paid hiscofts, for by this means we (hall inccuracc raeo to be "f"" * /" 
 vexatious, . co«s. 
 
 Freind againfl Baker. 
 
 [Trin, 1 65 1, Banc, fup, 
 
 "t 7" T 7ild motcD to amcns a llcroju lo^crcin a^ungcmcnt tuaa afbcn For omend- 
 V V <nt!)eCommonpca0,aftertbel'^ccojD teas rcmoVicDbp a tojU of '"«•"'''<> ^e- 
 CBrroj fnto tfte Cftrquct CbattibEr,'l;c fault to te amenDen iras,tbat tbere ia ""^ <i"yed. 
 uap gfbcn otjcr to tbcparttra from EaftcrCcrm to Michaelmas S^ctm.ano 
 fo Trinity SCcrm is left out, Icbitb be conccfbco \vn9 but a mf fpjiaon of tlje 
 Clatb , ano but a mfftontinuancc in gfbfng a iujong tiap to the patties , 2 
 H. 7. n , 2 2 E. 4. 3 . But Roll chief luflice anftocrcD, tljat tbiais t'je act of DTcominu- 
 tbic Court , ano bp pour rcafon pou map sfeip ober 30^4 ECcrms one after *""* 
 anotber, Vnitbout anp continuance. Sfbc gibing of a cap mojc tftan te ne> 
 cEffarp,iBnocif£ontinuancc , but terc toants a cap, iobicb maljcs it nota 
 niiftontinuantCjbutaDifcontinuancc, ann fo Ids it auiuDgco, i Car. at 
 Reading StCtm. Nicholas luflicetitEDai H. 6. f. 16. to bc aDjUCgeB t^at it 
 fsauiftontinuance. Roll chief luftice, 31 mifcontinuance is tcbcrc one 
 pjoccffc is ufeofoj anotber, anDfotbcpjocelTciBmittahcn; but tbis is a 
 Birtontinuance,anti cannot be amcnDct). i^^ojtbis is not upon a tojit of '^°'''"'''"*='"' 
 Crro; out of tbc Common picas as toe fuppofco it to be , ano tbat 
 tbc lRcco?D ban been amenbcn tbcrc,foj tben toe teoulD babe aotifcD tobt- Mifcomin i- 
 tber inc tooulo amcnn it here ; but it is upon a tojit of Crroj b?o«gljt in tbe *"'^'^' 
 Cbcquer Cbambct upon a Suoacmcnt gibcn bcre. 
 
 Brcck againft Vernon. 
 
 Trin. 1 652. Banc fup, 
 
 BRock bjougbt an action of ^cbt againff Vernon as an Crcctitoi npon a 
 fcoGO entree into bp Vernon unto tbc SCiCato: of tbc plaintiff , tbc*7cn?int- 
 JDefcnoantacUnoiBlcogetb tbc bono, but fapcs tbat be gate anotber icbf upon j'^ 
 bono in fatisfactton of tbat S^ouo unto tbc 2CcCato;>,U)b{c^t6eSi:c&ato^ DiOBord. 
 
 %xt act epl
 
 34<> Aiich. i6$2. 
 
 accept of fn fatfafactfon, C^: Court bclD tfjfs pica f B , ano tfjat tbc part? 
 Th"' • A '"'C^t l^s^t^ o^ntutreo upon U , anonecDconot to ftaljc jopncD fffuc, ano 
 a, „"^ '" put ft to tl)e 3arp, fo j ft (0 no goou plea to fan, tdat one m accept of one 
 tb(ng in flftfon, fn fntfssfnctfon of another tl.fng in Action , nno bete the De« 
 tcnoant tjatftconfcffcDtijc Debt , ano ttjcrcfojcftfo plea being (U, 3|uD5C« 
 ntent ougljt to be agafnC ]}im , and luJgcmenc ac another day was given ac« 
 cordingly. 
 
 Suckftcne againft Shmlock. 
 
 Mich. 1653. Bancfup. 
 EntrcdTrin, i<552, rot. 177. 
 
 Error to re- A ^tU ofCrtoj tuag b?ong^t to rctjct'c 8 Juagmentlgftcn (rt l^B Corns 
 
 verfcj j.irfg /imon ^lcaouponan(nfo:matfon,fojr£lifngoftafnetcftl)otitlkcncc, 
 
 rnejt in rhc (onttarp to t^c fetntutc.Cbc C!;rto; afcfgnct) tDns3,tl)nttbe<n!o;matfon tons 
 
 rJcjs'upon an •'^''"S^^ ^" ^^^ <2:oin:t of tljc Common Iplcas, totjfcl) is in tbc Cotintp of Mi. 
 
 jrifomuton dlefcx,tol)ereast!)c offence fa allcgco to be Done at Lambeth fntbe Coun- 
 
 <or (eiiing < ( tp Of Surry, toftlcl) ousl)t not to be, as Davifons cafe fa fn Ho6.rep.RolI chief 
 
 winenuhoutjufticc, ?^otoDovoupjototbf3tobctt.ftbfnt!je&tatutcof 7l=d. (5. 3f tlje 
 
 licence. ^tatutc gftie Itbcrtp to 3uatces o- peace, ano £Dpet ano SCermfner, oj 3(u. 
 
 ftfcca of afaffe to enqufre of tt)i3 offcncc,tt)en an fnfojmatfon cannot be pje. 
 
 f crreo fn a Conntp totjetc tfjc offence toaa not Done , anD tbe mennfng of 
 
 tbe&tatute, 2ilac. fanottoputtbcpartptoitbontrcmeDp, anofftjc can» 
 
 not fue bp tbe Statute of 7 hi.6. f n t^c Countp to!)cre tlje offence toas com« 
 
 mfttcD, tftcn tbia statute of 21 lac. bars bint not to pjcfcr an fnfo?mation 
 
 fnanotbcr Countp. Latch of Counccl againft tbe cnfojmer faiD , tjjat bp 
 
 tbc Statute of 7 Ed. 6,m fafojmatfon Ipcs before SJuftfcco of ^eace, 
 
 oj flfeffc, 0% ©aol Dclitetp. Roll chief luf^ice, 3 Dcnp tbat bp tbc Statute 
 
 of 7 Ed. 6. tbc information coulo not bate ban bjougbt in anp otbet place , 
 
 but fn tlje Courts at Weftminfter , anu tbercfoje tljat ft fs not nccelfarp to 
 
 bjfng ft f n tS)c Countp tobete tbc fact f s Done , notVuftbftanDfng tbc Statute 
 
 of 21 f ac.|,ft fs rcafon ft fljoulD be fo.becaufc tbat no jnrfsDfdfon fs gfbcn bp 
 
 tbe&tat.o'f 2i.Iar.to5uOfcestobEtetbcp baa nopotoer befojc. j9nB tbe 
 
 Court of IRecojD ci:p?cCEDfntbc&t^t.of7Ed.6.fljallbcfntenBcDoneof tbc 
 
 Courts at Weftminiier, anD not a Court of llecojo clfC'toOcrc. Therefore 
 
 (hew caufe why the Judgement (hail not be afl^imed. 
 
 Tench and Hubrifon. 
 
 Micb. t6^ 2, Banc, iup. 
 
 The Courr cf 
 
 the Admirii- r ^tbe Cafe of Tench ano Hubrifon upon a motion foj a piobfbftf on to tbe 
 ty cnnot j j-jj^^j ^f aomfraltp, 31t teas ^clo bp tbc Court, tbat tbe Court of 
 n.i^aliv."'' Somiraltp cannot p;oceeo ctfminaUp agafntt one tbat fsfn contempt to 
 
 tbcCourt. YettheCourtfaid,tbey would here the Civilians if they would 
 
 fpesk in it Saturday followingt 
 
 CydaU
 
 Mich. 1652. 341 
 
 CydaIland^S"pencerand others. 
 
 Mich. I (55 J. Banc, fup, 
 
 Ii^ tliC SDtpal bcttoCCn Cydall antJ Spencer fittU Ot^cr3,{n an Ejeftioncvvhereone 
 firmaett teas fafo bp tbc Court , SCftat ii cnt Bo Dfffclfe me of part of a „iy h»»e e- 
 boufc , anu 3 -am fn pcffcfsf on of t^c reft of (t , 3t <3 at mp clcttf on fcoljctft-c i^a on- 
 3 U»(U aomft m^ fdf out of poacfston of tljeljoafe oj not» 
 
 Long and Hebb and orKers. 
 
 Mich»i6^a»Banc, Tup. 
 
 T^ a JCrpal bettoeen Long ano Hcbb ano otbcra , itiose fafo Ip Roll chfeFTo whac time 
 -llufticc, tbat ILettcrc of jaomfnltttatlon Do relate to tbe tfme of tbenVatifj^"'"*"^"*" 
 of tbe Knteftatc , ano not to tbc time of granting of tbem, aiiu tbcrefojc an '^^^^i '"^^^^ 
 2tmin<ftratoj map bjing an Siaion of SCrcfpafs oj a STrofcer ano ContcrQ. Relation. 
 on foj gffiOs of tbe Unteftate taken bp one bcfojetbc ILctters gtantco unto T'dpaij. 
 Ijim , ot^csjjtrc t|)ere iDoulu be no rcmeop foj tbts tojong Done. Xiovcr. ^ 
 
 Mich. 1652 Banc. fiip. 
 
 T |ge Court toaaraobeo to cbansetbenenuc fti art Action bjougl^t foJvvh 
 an cfcape : JBut Roll chief lufticc fato, ft ougbt not to to be tftangeD, foj Vo"! m!f 
 an efcape la not local but tran(tto;p, foj anefcape in one place is an ercape no: be c:<arg. 
 fn all place0» td. 
 
 Sidenham. 
 
 Mich, 165 2 i Bine, fup.' 
 
 IiPtfteCafe of one Sidenham Roll chief luftice fafo, 3tl)aD been a qnC'^r 
 ftton , miljetbec if one pleao popmcnt at fl oap , Ije (DaB be aDrnftteo af- m,yTa y" 
 ter^atDs to pleao anotlier plca» from his pie*. 
 
 Watts and LoWth, 
 
 ^Micb« 1 65 24 Banc» Tup. 
 
 A^ 2tflon npon tfte Cafe me faiongbt upon DfUeta Affumpfit* , antj a Arrcft of 
 uBLBcDtagibenfoj tbe Iplaintf f. Htloas motjeo fn j^rreft of taege. lud^emenc ic 
 ment t^t tbe 3urp ^au giben mo;c Damages tban toere laio in tbe E)ccia " ft^;°" "P" 
 ration , tubereasl't toaa bat a mif. catting in tbe qu* ic totoattingunr. Roll*/ »"^"^P" 
 chief lufticefaio, ffiljat tbe mif catting is nothing if tbe Dsmagrg gitjen bp "' 
 t6e 3iarp be not moje tbantbc jpiaintif batlj laio {nljfs )BDcclacation» And Verd;a, 
 therefore let him bave bis jad^emcnc, . 
 
 *ir 5 Gougb
 
 34* • Mich. 1652. 
 
 Gongh and Cann. 
 
 Mich, 1^52, Banc, fp, 
 
 Arrcdof T^ 311 0rt(on bjoflgbt foj fl mcfcona, anoatilcrtftffounofojtijc pUfttc 
 
 juJcnrcntn li<f,tl)cfe GycEpMoit tDCtc offctcD tit Bmft of JaDgcmcnt, I . tb^ctcaB ^e 
 
 an Adion fo. fpcaljo of tlj: Hctt Coutt , !)C oott) tiot (l)ciu tD^ctc tl)at ncrt Court Ujaa 
 
 a K;rcou5. ijcitj. 2. SEftctfmcoftfte flrrcft fa not ajelDeu , upon iu^fcfj tbe Hcfcous 
 
 is fuppofcD to be maoc. 3, 3t fo not fljctoco tljat t^e partp rcfcoUjcD teas 
 
 <n ciiCoop of tl)C S>crtcnnt from iibom be teas rcfcotDCD . 4. 3;t is not dieto- 
 
 CD bcfojE iDljom tl)c plaint toas , upon itjbfcl) tl)c ^rrcfl toao maoc, 5, Ctjc 
 
 venire {3 fUatoarbeo, fojUfototbcCojonrrs, toljErc(tougI)ttobetott)C 
 
 otljcr &l)er(f , If one be a h(n to tl)z partp , ano Latch offcrca tijffl C-jrccptf- 
 
 on, ttjattijeSDcclarationfounOflinSCrcfpafo, iD^fcf) 3(t(on ootb not \jcxz 
 
 T.iRi'.n. lie fojtbc partp. JButto tl)at Roll chief luftice anfltiEreo, tbat ft is in 
 
 Ticiiiais. tl)celc£tfonoftl)cpartptobabcanact(on upon tl)C Cafe, 0: an 0(t(on of 
 
 '■ Strcfpafa ; fo j an Sictfon of tbc Cafe j an Sctfon of Crefpafg Ueo at tfjc cle . 
 
 ttton of tbc partp agafnftoncfojtafetngaUiapWoMifc.^nube bemanoco 
 
 tiibetbtrtbctlDO&berffBOfBriftowiDberctbeRcfcouslDas bjougbt toerc 
 
 notonc&berff, ano tobetber tbc venire teas not bclpcu bp tbe statute 
 
 0110 ft Docs nlfo appear tbattbc partp toa0 in cuttoupbpbcrtuc of tbe J9jo. 
 
 ccfj, auDltfsnoiDaftcra ElcrDtct: iSno be fafo, tbat ff one rcfcuc tbc 
 
 partj) iibo f 3 arrettcD at mp futc , becaure tliat after tbc partp f0 arrcftco 3[ 
 
 Rcfcuj. batic an f r.tcrctt In tbc boDp of tbe partp , tbfs llcfcotis f 3 a SCrcfpafu to me, 
 
 foj tobfcbS 'ttflpUicUmafntatn an Action of SCrefpafc. flno lerman lu* 
 
 Pledge. fticefafo , tbat tbe boDp of tbe partp arrcfteu fo; Debt is a plcO0C foj t\)t 
 
 Debt ft fclf, ludgemenc was given for the Plaintif, 
 
 Linifton and Maurice. 
 
 Mich, 16$ J, Banc. fup. 
 
 Air»iuf 'T^eCafciBasfl)f3, flnactfonofErc^pafstoaflbjougbtagafnffa^ar* 
 
 lujgcaicnc in *" fon foj not Ccirrpfn? aicapbts SCftbes fn Due tfme. SLbc SDcfenoant 
 
 9nAai)noi' picaofl tbat tbe piafntlff gate bim :iO' notfce to fetcb atoap Ijis 
 
 Trefpafsfor j^t^eg ; tt]e pafntff repUcss . ttiat be. Dfo gfbe bfm notfce, but 
 
 »\Vrulc^^ Dotb not fljeiD iBbcrc be gaVic bfrti notice , aiio tipon tijfa Crccptfon 
 
 '' judgement Ujas CtapcD : flfiertoarog Bildwin of tbe Sinner JTemplemoti:!! 
 
 foiluDgemcnt, anoallegco tbat tbJ not ailrgfng tbc place toas no (Erroj. 
 
 Nicholas luftice , tobat fap pou to Durdens CafC:- Roll chief Iufticc,2Lberc 
 
 p,,^p arc manp cafes u here tbe place fa not materful, pet ftmuC bcaflcgcofoj. 
 
 tbc 'vLlenue. BIfnOebtbebjoucbtagafnttanCDrccuto;, anobe pieao fuHp 
 
 nomfni DErcD ; iftbc?0lafntf(f replptbatbe batb affcts, be ougbt to allege 
 
 tbe place tobercbvbatbaffct0: 0nD 3 conteffec tbat tbcrc ouebt to be a 
 
 place allcgcD bcrc, tbat a Slurp tobo arc nearcll tbc place , antJ fo map babe 
 
 RtpioJcr, tbe bcftUnotolcDgeoftbc matter, map trp ft, altbougbft map be trpen In 
 
 anntber place; but fftbc trpal bz iH tbe tacrDict fefllnot bslp ft , but tberc 
 
 muft be a ncto trpal , Therefore it were good to replead ai to the place, 
 
 Micb.
 
 Mich. 1^5^' 345 
 
 Mich. 1652. Banc. (up. 
 
 O^ztmk outa Latitat out of tlifs Court ano attrffs ttie pattp , ano te- AttacKmeot 
 fufetb to take ISail of l)jm, bat tarrpeo Wm tnto another Ubcrtp to t'^t abafn.g 
 charge l^fnt tott!) an SLAion t^ete ; tEipon tbfs tec vToutt luag mobca to j ait ^'^ pt""Ue of 
 ^ttacftment, fojabnQngt^cpjoceffcoftMsXoutt, And it was granted, ""='-'^"' ■ 
 nifi, Sccf 
 
 Mich. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 Ti^ a frpal at tbe IBat faetlDecn '" heefman ano Turner aiW otbets fn SCtcf- ^,,j^^ „^ y„. 
 •^pafsanDdBtettment, Roll chief luftice fart, SCIjatfftlicrebc DibcrsdUj;- qu« Exccu- 
 Bcutojs of one ^tll, anooneof tljem rcfufc to pjote tlje ®3il,l)'; map tor ;$ a good 
 pleao ne unqucs Executor, ^no t^jat a M(U in tojUtng mag betetiobeo bg ^^";^j,j^j 
 parol, ano rctj^tcoajjafnbp parol. iv!vivV^°"* 
 
 Theoball and Conqueft^ 
 
 Mich, 1^52. Banc, fup, > 
 
 trio. i<Jj2.rot, T5>99» 
 
 /A JFteta^ettilctfnan ^ctfonofflTrefpafoaniXlElEdmenffttoasmobcB^^^^jj^^ 
 ^ tn 3lrreft o( juogemcnt , tbattbclLeafc tuaa alterco after plcaofng, iJa^eni^, i^ 
 iDn t^e otfter Coe ft Voas motieo fo j Juogeraent. j . IBecaufc tbe Hcafe toaa irefpafj and 
 onlp amenoeo fn matter of fojra , anu not fn fabftance 2lp. llBccaufc bp tbe Ejcamcnt. 
 rule of Court tbe SDefcnnant fa to confcffc tbe Hcafe , ano fo tt fs not mate» 
 rial tobetlier tfte 3Leafe be gooD oj no. IBut Roll chief luftice anffcDercD , 
 tl^at tbe ILeafe iuas amcnoeo (n matter of fnbCtancc . ano ft tbe ILcafe be 
 tefcflfbetoecangftJcnojuDgemcnt, ano bp pour oton flietofng ft fa ntt Amendment, 
 pooo , ano tl^e rule of tbe Court ootlj not bfno tbe SDefcnoant to confeffe tbe r^^^'^l^^' 
 3lcafe otbettcffctbanpou babe maoe ft, and therefore let the judgement be °'- ^ "^ • 
 ftayedf 
 
 Fowke and Boyle. 
 
 Michidji.Banc. fup» 
 Trin. 1652, rot, 460. 
 
 T^c pafntff b5oug!;t an 0ctfon upon tbe Cafe foj fcrfng unto bfm falfc Demurrer to 
 JBfllfl of pubUquc faftb to tbe toalue of 800 1, bnoiufng tbem to be falfc , a oeciantion 
 tDftbanfntenttoDecefbcbfm; SCbe SDefenoant oemura upon tbe SDecla.'n Aftion 
 ration, SfnoBabinptonoftbcBinncrSCcmplc ofTereo tbcfc Crteptfona to"P°"'^"=?*'^' 
 ft. 1. SCbat tbe £);Dfnancc of parliament foj tbe b?fngfng fn of monep % 
 plate fnto GHitdhalI,anD gftfng tbe Commffafonera autbojftp to afbc tbefe 
 bfUa to tbem tbat bjongbt ft fn m rcpapmcnt thereof toftb fntcrctt at 8 U 
 per centum, per annum, tDaamff.rccftcD j fojftfafafo that tbe £)}Dfnance 
 iraamaoe bp both l^oufee of ^DarUament, tobcrcag ft Hjoulo be bp tbe 
 3L0}i)B ano Commona fn parlfament, foj tbe l^oufea arc tbe placca tobere 
 tbcpat,anbcanmaUenoiDjofnanccfl, anobccftcD Mich, 13 Car.Tydalls 
 
 cafe*
 
 Aflch.1652.. 
 
 "cafe 2.2i:i)caiDcnTicnt^atcl^c CommfrsfoncrciarcnottancBljp tftcft 
 
 Chjffltan names, as tljcg ought to be , biitonlpbp tljcfrl&fmamcfl. jlp.jt 
 
 IgnotQjctocDtntDftatraannetttjOlBmetDcrcarfifgncDtoljfnt, but be fap0 
 
 onlp that thrp tocrc afctgncD fn Hue fojm of EatD, totlclj (0 tco pcncrallp ex* 
 
 P'Cffcl),fln»tottji0 hccltCDMcI ,'0 180 BancRei^.GlafsanDGowes tnfc* 
 
 ^0 tJjefc Latch anflDcrcD , SChat the mcmfonfng of tl)c £D?of nance of jpai« 
 
 Uamcnt, anDofthcjaiDcrmcn,(3butbpte8pof<n5utemcnt to tlic Sictton, 
 
 jBiD nottjing to the aroutiD of it , ano tbcrcfojc tftere nceft not be fo puntfual 
 
 a recital as (sfurmlfcD, ntftbct is it ncccfTarp to OictD hototfjc 315lihBU)CTC 
 
 afcfancD, anotrxpare the EDcfcnoants oton iDo?D0, noj <c ft material 
 
 IjoVpt^cmoncptoastobepaiD. Rollchi<f Inttice, SCbc grouno of t^c 0. 
 
 ajont0 the Deceit fnarsfgntng oljcr falfe JIBfHs ,anDaffirmlns tbcm to be 
 
 true, ant) the other matters arc meerlp matters of InDuccment, ano itfco 
 
 inditemrnr. otilp bp Irap Of tcctfal , ant) not matcrfal to thcactfon. Sntj pou hate 
 
 c ,„t.flion. tonfclfcti the Deceit fo; lohicb the Jlctfon is b?onght bp pour general ocmnr- 
 
 ter upon the SDcclaraUon. And therefore Ist judgement be for the PUiniif 
 
 except better matter be ftiewn. Poftea- 
 
 Wood again ft Holland. 
 
 Mich. 1 65 2, Banc, fup. 
 
 Trin, i652,rot, lodi. 
 
 Demurrer ro ^ } ^ 7 Ood bjouttht an 3ttfon of SCrcfpafs ano cBjectmcnf agafnff Hol- 
 
 a KcpVcauo.. \ \ |jnd , JEhc SDcfenoant plcaDg that the |pia(nt(f Dto,D{aJelfe I.S, 
 
 '"] tla" ofthelLanD , anothcn maocaleafcoffttoWm, ano that aftcrtoaraa the 
 
 mc. t Uno Dio ocfteiiD to t^c piafnt(ff,E:hr plafrtfff rrplrrc t[;r.t be \r.as feifco' 
 
 of the lanWjRno tratjerfeo the Diffcifin fuppofco to be mans to I.S.;an» to thfs 
 
 the E>efcnDant Demurs, aoo fo j taufc fljctos that he ouptt to hale tta^Kifea 
 
 thcDcrtent,anDnottheDiffe<Sn. 55nt Roll chief luilice faio, SChat the tra- 
 
 r tiCTftngofthecifrcfanmaltesanenDofaU, anDthcrefojcJsircIltalwn, as 
 
 sJlTn' '' iti ig. the mott material matter, although that the oefccnt mtcbt hat5cu>ell 
 
 Dctctnt. enough been tratCtieC, And therefore let the Plaintif have ludgecienl, 
 
 nifl. 
 
 Reckwitch and Moyle. 
 
 Mich. Idj2, Bine, fup, 
 
 Trin. idjo. rot. 503. 
 
 A writ of tr- \ mxlt of CBrro J toas bjongbt to reljerfc a juogcmcnt gftjcn fit an Sn- 
 
 rorto tcve fe jT^fg^foimCourt . anDthc OTrft of Crroj teas to remote a llecojo, 
 
 ajurt^tmc. t quQj j-oraro vobit refidec de placito in Curia mancriideCu:tingbye, Vobere* 
 
 [TrVur'" asthciRetojDtoas.de placito in Curia CuffodumlibercatisAnglae authori. 
 
 Court. taieParliamentideCurtingbye. anDtherefojcagafnftthc U)?U of Crroi 
 
 ft toasofalecteo, that there teas a t)arfantcb:ttDecn the tojft of Ctroj ano 
 
 tl;c IRccojD , anD thercfo:e that the Irjft of Crroj \me not gooo -, iBut a- 
 
 galnft thf3 teas tftcD Lodge anoGoodalc! Cafe fnthffl Court 2 5 Car. that 
 
 It is not ncteffarp to recUe fn a tojit of Crroj all the irojDa of the Dcfctjpti. 
 
 onofaConrt,anDherethctD:ltfonottoremolica IRccojD out of an in, 
 
 fcriouT Conrt, but the toift of Grroj ia to rctcrre a itiDgcmcnf fti a IRecojD, 
 
 quod coram vobiiicfidet. HaKtanflDCtCD, %^at hcrc (3 a rfght Dcfcrfp. 
 
 ^
 
 Ukhy.'^z, ^ 34S 
 
 ttonof-tbeCouTt , fn ucartt o^tbc place tuyere ft teas ftclu, anu of tl:e 
 puisne of ft, butnottnresarooftftc JLojDof ft, ano t^ctefojc be conccf. 
 tcDftamaterfalobjcflfon, becaufcapart oftbeCfle of t^e Court fgmfCa. ^ 
 
 ben, f not onlp an aonfttonal oefcrfptf on of ft. Roll c'uef luftice anflDcrco,3f Viriar.cCi 
 UbcbutanaDDftfonalaDCftfonojDcrtdptfon, it is Iccll cnono^ aa ft fa; 
 but toe tjjf n fee ijobat batb been Done fn If he (TafCBijeretofoje; but me f.,fnl?.a 
 tbat ft (ball be fntentjcD bcre to be Curia Cuflodum libcmtis hrp\, foj bcrc ft 
 ffl frt a mxit of Crroj tebfcb todl not Ue ft ft be not a Court of Rccoja. 115ut 
 Nicholas anOAjk lufticcsfafD, ^tcannot befntcnDeOaCourt Of l1:cojD , 
 but a Court liFaron, ano fo tbc flflc fmplfcs common fntcntiment. 2Lft6 
 Court aDtlfeo tfU tbcnejtSCtrm. SLbfaCareVDaaaftcrtoarDs motcu b? 
 Latcfe, tobo fato , SCbat bere is no tjarfance bcttceen tbe ^rft ano tbe lie* 
 co;d , altboutfb tbe ?njft be not fo full as ft mlgbt babe been to oefcrfbc tbe 
 SRecojD, ano it fa agreeable to tbe antfent ann ufual pjadfce at thfa cap, ano 
 cfteotbeolDfaoohofCntrpea 171, anofafo. tbatfn Pay tons cafe ti;C IRccojo 
 toas in Curia Domini Regis Ci^itatis, anotbetojftof Crroj toaa in Curit 
 CivitatisGlocertrix, M;ch,i3 Car.Banc. Reg.'ror»5<J9, ^nO all Courts Of 
 3Reco?D are o?fgfnallp tbe iiinga. Hales on tbe otber Qoe falo , tbat tbe 
 tDjftofCtrrojougljttoIbctotDbofctbcCourtfa, ano tbe ratbr, bccaufc ft 
 fa faf D to be Curia Manerii. Wadham Windham, SEbe Kegfttcr fg botb 
 toaps, anubpcfrettfon Of ]parlfamcnt tbe Common ^leas fa ftileo Curia 
 deCorarouni Banco, jloiit bcrctbc HecojD appears to be Curtodura , &c. ■ 
 Civitatis, ano tbe ZSSiUt botb not mcntfon tbat. The Court would advife o 
 the Prefidents. SCbfa cafe fraa again motieo , ano Lodge anc Woodhalls 
 cafe, 2 2 Car. ntgeo , tbat tbe IReturn of tbe Certiorari upon tbe iD?f 1 0; <£c- 
 roj teas not gooD fojtbc tariance fojmcrlp aHegco , but Wadham Wind- 
 ham belD ft goooenougb , anorelpenupon JOjefioentafljetBeotoHern tlje 
 ^econtarp, as tbe Court ban Dfrecteb, Hales on tbe otbct ffoc urgeo tbat 
 tbe tarfancc mace ft not gmD , foj ft cannot be fntenoeo tbe fame 
 Court. Roll chief .uflice, bercfanoofrcaoppoCition betVoccn tbem, to% 
 tbepmapbotb ttano togetbcr, ano tbe tojit of (Erro; fntenosft to be a 
 Court of IRecojD , ano pet ft fa tbe Court of tbe ^anoj alfo, ano tberc» 
 fojeftfagooDfnfubffaticc, De faaoftfatbeCourtoftbeiLojooftbe^an; 
 noj, battfttuaUpanofnofgnftpftfatbeConrtoftbe Mns : but-tbe Ve< 
 nirefsclearlpbftioni^ and therefore Ice the lodgement be reverfed for cbtc 
 ctufe. 
 
 Jervis and Lucas^ 
 
 Mich. i($52. Banc. fup« 
 
 Tl^c Court toSs mobeo foj one lervis , tbat tbe Conrt mfgbf tfcln bfa ^°''^^'f^f 
 toouno, ano fncreafc tbe Damages gfbcn b<m bp tlje 3urp , bccaufc tbcp',^'^^"„oJ^d 
 bao glfecn bim but tirelbc pence;Damagca fo} bfatoonnofng , tobcrcas tbCococreafc 
 parties arm toaa bjofecn, ano be teas fn great Danger ftfu to lofc tbe ufcdsroatcs. 
 of ft, 55ut Roll chief lufticeanftDcreD, ft appears not bp bfs ©cclaratfon 
 tD^,at manner of toonnofngftinas be reccfbeo , as ft ougbt to babe been, 
 ano bote can toe bnoto boto be toaa toounoeD ^ But we will advife, and heac 
 Councel on both fides. Sit anotbet Dap Serjeant Parker mobcO tbc fame 
 matter again, ano cftcD 3 H.4. f.4. anOiS H.4.f. 23. ano Dyer, to pi otic 
 tbe Court mfgbt incrcafc tbe Damages. Twifden anfioereo , Ebat tbc 
 trounofng ougbt to babe been partfcularlp cjpjeffeo fn tbc flJcelaratfon , 
 tbat tbe Court mffibtfuDgc of ft bp tbc 1Reco?o, anD tbc partp fa net to 
 
 PV ' be
 
 346 Micfi. 1(552. 
 
 be trfctocofaptl^c Court upon tljc bate abcrment of tlje pattpmane ai tH 
 515at. %o toWcJ) R-oll chief Inrtice agrccD, nno fafo , boto can it appear to 
 
 Vieif . US tljat be toaa luoanDcD fo as pott aijcr bp tbts Batterp :> fo j It map be be 
 
 * inaa tooanneo Once pour action , ncUbcr can pou note Dtftonttnnc tbc Siai- 
 
 Difcontlnu OH) bccaofe tt |0 attct 8 tcrDlct , fotbatyouarenow without recnedy. 
 
 ancci 
 
 A/ich. i6 5 2. Banc. fup. 
 
 Monon nri^cCourttoafimotjcDfojapjobJbftfontotbc pjerogatfte Cdnrf, br. 
 
 foraProh'- ^ caufctbcpDopjocecD to c)cam<nc taftneffco tbete , to otfpjobc a tofU tbat 
 
 bitio«t.Mhc^ggpj0^et)t^etC2opcataftnce, bp tobttb CSHfUlanoa tocrc Dcbffci>,ano 
 
 PreroRjtive j jjg ignug arc folD , snotbiatbcp Bo to p jctcnt a trpal at ILaiu toucbtnstlre 
 
 title of tbc lanotireaeD ontoftbcCbancerp. Rollchiefluftice anftocrcD, 
 
 ibcp map cramfne tbe p?obatc tbcrc j fo; ['otj babe HfacUpo tfjcre to tabe be. 
 
 nefit of tbe pjobate , ano tbcrcioje tbc otbcv partp map otfpjobe tbe pjobatc 
 
 if be can, as fat aa concerns anpgooDaocbKcDbptb^ lulU, And therefore 
 
 wc will grant no prohibition* 
 
 • Mich. 1652. Banc fup^ 
 
 Motion T ^^ <Co«tt toas mobca fo j tfjc ^Barfftf oners anc S»ffif era of tbc ^arffli 
 to make Sci- ^ of Clarkenwcll , to malje&catiengcrc tbat arc cU(tcDtn tbat pariOi to 
 vergers exe- fcrtctbc £)ffice. Roll chicf lufticeanflDetcD , Stfamarbeltbat tbc Cftp 
 '>ffi'^"' ofLondonDo not looh to tljfs, fej tbep bate potoct bp tbcft fap-latpo to 
 Br-iaw^ waUc men ferte fncb Officca , yet take a mandarauj for tbera to be brought 
 Mandamus, hither to Aicw caufe why they will not execute the Office, 
 
 A^on and Ay res. * 
 
 Mich. 1 65 2. Banc, fup, 
 
 AWitit of CBrroj teas bjougbt to tcbetfe a jnugcmcnf gfben in tbe 
 Common picas fn an Ejedione firm , ano tbc cfro j afefgnco toaa , 
 verfc 3 j Vr" ji^gt t^e jiiogcment loas quod querens recuperet, f ttjc toojOs quod defendens 
 ircnt in the ^^pj j^y^ g^g omfttCB. And upon tbii Exct ption the Court revc'-fed the )udgc» 
 PiTriT.n E- raent , foj tbcp fafu in tb(s intigcmcnt tbtis cntreb tbcrc (s no return of oa- 
 itaioncfi,-- maatfl, nojaCapiatur, anBfotlieConimon.iDraltbistojeneDoftljc fine, 
 "'*• aniTtbcSJcfcnbant barrcDfroinbjtngfnsbfs toMt of CBtro;, 
 
 ludgcmcnt, 
 
 Dawkesand Covencigh. 
 
 Mich. 1(552. Banc, fup. 
 
 Hill. 1650. rot, 653. 
 
 speriii vcr. ^Qvf neigh toasenulctct) m felonp foj b!cak(ng tbc boufc. anb taWng 
 «iain it\ A ^^250!. oatoftbcboofeof Dawkes,anDfounoguilfp,anD teas burnt fti 
 *r"ulre'''^ tbebanD,aftcttoarD3 Dawket bifugsan ^ctfon Of SErcfpnlTc quare clautum 
 r'-ufLmTrc- fregit , aiitJ fo J cattptng alv^p tbe »so 1- ngafnft Covencigh, lubo pleaos not 
 g t. aiifltp , ano tbcrcnpon n fpccf al betotct luas foanu to tbts effect , fbat tbe 
 
 DcfenDant m fclonfouflp bjcab tbc boufe, ano carrp atoap tbe ^50 i. ano 
 voas cnbftteb fo; it, ano itjas fonno S«Htp, ano burnt in tbc banu fo j (t , ano
 
 Mich. 1652. 347 
 
 U upon tbc toljoU matter, &c. 2Hc quiftfon upon tftc Cpctjal tcrtf tt tea© . 
 •HfaftettbcSDEfenCantlrasenDlaco ano foiinfi guHtp, brd burnt <n tl)e 
 t)anD,foj ttfs fnfl at tljc futc of tt)c feccpttis of ttc Kbcrtpcs of EngUn^^ an 
 0(t{on of Krcfpaffc quare claufum tVcgir , ano fo: carrpfng aitap tijc monp, 
 bemafntafnablcbptftepartp, uto toag tljtiB rcfabeo agafnil tbc part? 
 0; no. Latch of Countcl toft!) tbe ^lafntiff bolt), tbat tbc' Sctfon olo tocll 
 L?c, ant) tbat tbc |0lafr.tiff ought to liatic3uDgcincnt, anetbattbtsfp-cfal 
 inattcr founn bp tbc gtirp, Is t[fi bar to tbc iJct(on,fo j tfijc baa been attntntca 
 fojanotbcr iTcionp,it toouionotbafe larvco tbc |D;a(miff from bfu flitfoii, 
 after be bao been offcbcrgcD ; but ctbcrlrUc U ia ti tbc part i> bjfng bfs ZdU 
 on, iDbtlfttbcpartpftanDgattafntct), oj tbcpartpbe.atta(ntctj,pent3fngjbe 
 2afonof2Crcrpaire, 35 Eli2. Wade; rd Prelects cafe in this Court, anD 34 
 Eliz. TrufTels tafc in this Coprr, and 6 Ed. 4, 4, ant) fn out cafc tbe j9aton 
 tpao not biongbt till after tfc partp trpcD -, IBut ft is objcctcD.tbat tbc SCrcf. 
 patrcbc.re(:3b;oHrbtfo; tbc fame lat foi lobfcb tbc pnrtp toa0trpc!), ano 
 tbcrcfojcUtsiunrcaronablctbattbcptl^oulDbccoublp punfQiei) fo: (f. Ko 
 tbte 31 aaf iucr, tfcat ft toaa at tbe partfcs clcflfon at tbc bejjfnnfng citber to 
 cnofttbfnt, ojtob?fngbto:a£tfonof2Crerpairc, HudCons cafe, 4. rep. 43. 
 Sinn bcre tbe partp batb ntaoe no election , fo; tbe partp toas enofcteD at tbe 
 futc of tbe Common CEacaltb,anD not at tbe pjofctutf on 0: tbe partp, ano 
 fo be bafbmaoc no election unttll no lu. Sno ff tbc Sictfon mfgbt not be 
 bjougbt, ffmfgbt p:otc ijerrp mifcbic^joua, fo: tbc partp mfgbt get bimfclf 
 fnaftteo , ano Jo coufcn bfm tbat fa robbeo 0' tbia jnonp, Dyer'5 o. S. rep. 13. 
 ano tbe bfsbnefs of tbc nature of tbc enofctm.ent notb not Djoton t'.c attfon 
 ofSCrefpaffc, altbougbtbatttcaronootbojoirn i?elonp,i R. 3.1. 6H. 7, 
 5. 3ntjaltbougb tbc monicBbcrcttollen be fojfrftco to tbc &tatc, b^ tbe 
 contjfctfon of tbe jFclonp , p:t at Mion of SCrefpafs (pea a. 
 gainft tbc i^elon to caufc btm to rcnocr oamagca pro tanto , altbourb be ^ 
 cannot rccoter tbc monp in fpecie. anu tbe fpccfal berofct ootb not fino , 
 tbat tnv Ebfoencc teas gttien foj tbe plaintiff upon an cnofrtment, but onlp* 
 fo J tbc &tate. ano fo; autbojftp b- citco Markham and Cobs cafc, I Jin. 2 * 
 
 Car. Entrcd i. Car. rot. 112. Roil chief Tuf^icefafO, KliH Juttfcc Dodc* 
 ridg,anD gtiflicc Whitlockbelo,tbat tbc SLrcfpafa IPCS; IButgnftfcc lones Trcfpafle. 
 bclD tbe contrarp,bpcaure if tbe partp robbeo mff.bt batjc bfa election, cftbct 
 toEnDf(ttbci?elon,ojto bjtngbfs action of gLtcfpafa, manp iFeionfes 
 IroulD be fmotbercD, ano tbfa tcoulo p:otc tcrp oangeroue , ano tbougbtbe 
 partp robbeo bao cnoicteo tbc JTelon be mfgbt ijabe bao bis goooa, "oj be 
 mfgbt bat?E bjougbt an appeal againtt bfm,ano fo tbcre fa no Fntonticnfence 
 to bfm, 4 lic. 3!n Hicqins cafc ft iraa aojuogco irbcre an actfon of SLrefpafa 
 teas bjougbt bp tbc ^ucbsnofo; beatfng bfs teffe , bp rcafon tcbercof (be 
 Bpeo,tbat tbc action Ofo not Ipe.becaufc ft toaa iFclonp. lerroan luflice 
 Of ffcrco from. Roll chieflurticcjanofafo, tbat tbc frcontienfcnce on tbc 0= 
 tbcr Coe tooulo be greater tban fs allegco, f f tbc /Felon fljall fo tafee aotjan- 
 tagc of Ms one tojong, ano fn 2 Car. ft toaa bclo tbat tbc actfon ootb Ipc. 
 Roll chief iufticefafo,ff tbc jFcIonbatjc not toflftcD tbc goooa, tobcn be fa 
 bangco tbc partp IbaD batje tcftftutf on j but f f be bate tcattco tbcm , ano 
 batb otbcr goooa bcCballbafecrcCftutfonfn taUic. 515ut let Wild arpueit^'^''"''""' 
 again the next Term. Sccc^ofnglpfttoasaga'nfpottcntoo bp Wild, U)bo 
 arguco tbat tbc actfon of JEteipafs of not Ipc, firtt bccaufc tbc partp ofo not 
 mahcftcflifuteaftertbci?eton,acco:ofngtotbc&tatutc,2i H. 8. tobfcb 
 teas maac to encourage tbc p?orecuto; ; but tbc partp batb not pjofccuteo 
 Ijcrc, ano ft fa an one to tccotjer oamngcs foj tl^e goooa , ano to rccobcr tbe 
 60008 tbcmfcltc^, fo tbat 31 conccfbe tbat fa no offfercncc. ano tbc great 
 (nconfccnfcncctebfcb mfgbt come to tbc Common Oncaltb ff tbc actfon 
 ttoulDlpCjUotbtountcttafl tbc Damage tbat map accrcto to tbe partp, 
 
 |9ps it
 
 J48 Mich. 1652. 
 
 i('ii)t Action Ipc not, Sinn it matters not tljat (t ia fafo tiit aCrefpafs is a of* 
 Cfnct offence from tftc IFelonp, fo^ it is D jotonco fn tbc j^clonp , ano tftcre-* 
 fo;ctl)cpartpcanl;at3enofatl0factfonfo;lt, Mich. 21 lac. Ayers ano Hig= 
 gins cafe,C.B.3 i H 6»l>-. i j.trefpifT.- 41 y.^.IacHigqint anOBuccIurs cafc,B, 
 R.Koll chief luOirc, 2Ll)<fl <3 after a conWflfon,ano fo Ijerc is no fear t^at tl)C 
 i^clon fljall not be trpco ; IBut <f tt \ticre bcfojc coiitictfon tfts aafon inoiilo 
 not Ipe, fo; t:;c Danger tljc jf clon mtgljt not be trpco. ^no tftcrc is no iU' 
 cont)cn<cnce <f t^c fla(on Do Ipc , ano fincc 1)6 toulo not tjai'c bao bi£> rcnre- 
 Dp bcfojc, !)C Qjall not notD lofe jt.anonolptbcr? ia no Dancer of com« 
 pounDfng; fo;tijetojonctbcrcftoft{)c3;uDPCi3 SBtccD toltU Roll, andfo 
 ludgemenc was given for the PlaintiiT. 
 
 Gllisand Tipki. 
 
 • Mich. 1652. fianc, (up, 
 
 Tl})2 Court iuas mo'oc;j tl^at an oiitlatojp mfijljt be J^ffcljargco, bccaufc ft 
 la nolj)par3oncobjitl)c0ctofobHtfo:j,fovnotlt]{tbftanDfngU incre[not 
 ou;i«w 7. " parooncD if it tocre an otitlatiijp after 3lJ«osment,e):cept tbc monpea DUP,fo j 
 ■ tLbfclbtl)cpartpi3 0iitlalDCD,bcpapcototl)cpartp, astlic bcol; oT6H.7.*'.2i. 
 fs, pcto;itlaU);pc3bc'o?c3l!iD0jiJcr.tarc'parooncD, anobcGDcstftc parties 
 IjereDiortibmft toanarbitrement,toucViingti)c matters in oiffcrcricc be. 
 tlDccntbcm,anDan'alaari!f3 maDc. JBiit t!)c Conrt anflDerco.tljat tfte 
 Sci-e f ens outlaiD;p tannot be DifcljargcD tintill tl)c partp l)a\3c bjoiicJjt ftia fcire facias 
 imcic:). upon t^e J?a , ano ft luaer alfo fafD, tftat tftc partp at ItJtjofc futc anotljer is 
 outlalocD, tjatb an fntcrett bp t^e outlatojp, as loeU as i^z ^tate. 
 
 Motion to 
 
 t 
 
 Prior and Hale. 
 
 Micb, i65». Bine, fop. 
 
 A letter of A ^Letter Of attojncpfojoitctoappcartoanSctfonfsgooo cnotisHj? 
 
 Actorncy by / V paroll to fiippojt a SJHBgcmcnt giucn t^crcnpon. JBp Pmient protono* 
 
 pa.ongood taric of ihtCommon Pleas. Nota. 
 
 f (1 lomc in- T^ I 1 o 1 
 
 tern. Fowke and Boyle. 
 
 Mich. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 Demurrer to "T O -vke fajotialjt an 0ctfon upoii t^E cafcasafna Boyle, fojfcHfngof falfc 
 a Df ca-at icn f SitUg of ptibliqnc faittj uMto f)(m, to tfjc talnc of 800 ). tlje iDcfenoant dc« 
 on'ihe^tff" «"""f^io tijeSDctlaratton, nnotoch tijcfc cjccptions to ft. i. STfjat tl)R 
 ojoinancs of parliament, upon tDljfefj thcfc bills of publfquefaftbtocrc 
 grotmoco teas mifrccitcD, fo; it is faiD,to be maoc bp bot'o Jjoufes, toljereas 
 Jtougljtto bcbptbc JLojOg ano Commons. jlp.SEbc aiDcrmen tefto tocrc 
 auti)o;ffcD bp tljc o:t!t::ancc to gi^c thefc bfliij of pabliq.te fatti), arc not na. 
 mcD bp t'oeir CJjiiCtan names , but onlp SlDcrman fuel) a one, naming tljc 
 furnamc. 3!?. 2Ll)crci3 7oI. crpjeffiotobepaio.asfsmentfoncointbe 
 papers, anO it 13 not crpjeffeo at tofcat time c; place,a0 ft oiigbt to fjnte been, 
 16 E.4.f. 3.anOj8H. 6. f. 3, 4lp- ll^crcfsanafsfgnmcntfct fo;tb to 
 bemaocfnoucfojmoflialD; but ootb not (IjcU) fn totjat mancr , 10. lac. 
 Midi. Glafi ano Gowr fn tljts.Court. Larch on tf)e otfeer (toe fafo, tfjat tbe 
 mentioning of tl)c ojoin^nce, ano of t^e aioermen toas but inouccmcnt to 
 tbe ^aion , ano tljcrc is no nctcfsftp to rail tb'^ aioermenTjp their ChjiCf- 
 an'namc0, but as Hjcp arc calico fntl-cOjcfnance; nojfs ftncccCfarp to
 
 Mich. 1652. >^p 
 
 ■fljctototD tfie affifgnment fow maup, aHO tfjcfc toojtjs arc tfie fouj^f tif)g 
 ■jjartp; nojf0itnecDfulltoG)EU)l)oU)tbc minita Incrs to bcpafo. Roll 
 chief Iuftice,2Cl)e caufc of tfje Siaion ta tf)c nefcttt In arsfcnf ng the falfc btlla 
 annafStmfnstljcmtobetruc, ano all t^cottrr matters arc bnt matters inducement, 
 ef fnDnccment , ano bp luap of tccft^, anB not rnatctfal,anD vouftaljc to«- 
 feffeti tfjeoecdtbp pour Demurrer, and thirefore let the Plaintiff have his . 
 Iudpement,n'fi. ^Elpon toljtcft rule Babrngton at anotl;cr Cap mofceD tte 
 matter agafn , ano urgcD ttwtftcre vrac an argfgntnetit of papers mcntfo- 
 ncD, liWtl) co'.ilo not be, fo j tljnt ft is a tftinp in Action, tobtcft fs not afsfcrnai. 
 fclc, noi tan tlje £) jotnance of |Dnr:famcnt (jibe aui!)o?ltp to afofgn a tbfng 
 In Siaion, Roll chief lufticc, SEftc o?Dfnnnce of ^DarUamcnt ootb gf'jc an- ^ ,• 
 tbojftp to afcfgntfte papers. Larch ti;e paper map be afofnnco. Green, '"£"'""'■• 
 SCljc aafon f0 bjougbt foj tljc Deceit grounoeD upon tlje ojcfnante , ano ft 
 (s not ncceffarp foj tfjeiDjDfnance to natre tlje ^llDermensCbMCian names, 
 ana tfjcfe map be true bflls tbougb not fubfcrfbeD, toliftb fs tftc Dccctt Ijcre aU 
 legeo, Twifdcn on \\)Z otber fioc fafO/ tljat tlje atquufttance fs fn nature of 
 a faf U, acco jDfng to the fntent of tl)e £) jDtnance^ foj ft is not onip an atquft- 
 tancc of Dffcftarge , but to recofccr monfcs upon tbem, anD fo tlje SDcfcnDant 
 taHstfjem, anD bp tfte afsfgnment tlje paper fs afsfancD, ano tlic Bctfon 
 isgrounDeDonteeDeteft, anD not upon t^c Statute", ludigemcnc was gi< 
 ven for the Plaintiffs 
 
 Burcher and Orchard. 
 
 Micb» 1(55 J. Banc, fiip* 
 
 ■ . . , Aireftof 
 
 BUrcher bjouglf an Sctfontiponffte Cafe foj tnojos, agafnft Orchard juc-prncntin 
 anDl)fstofff,tl)e3ntpfinDtbattl)c315aron toas gufltp, but tbat t!jc'"''^^"'"°'* 
 i?emc teas not guUtp, Wsdham Windham motjcD fn arreft of gucgc- ^'j^\" ' ° 
 ment, becaufc tbat t\)z Action fs f opnt, ano one of tbcm la founo not eufltp, 
 ano fafo, ft mf filjt ^atc been otftettof fc f f t!jc ifcmc ftaD been fonno gtifltp , 
 anbtl^cilBaronnotgufltp, anDcfteDpEd.^.f. 51. Yard on tl)c otber flee 
 fafo , tbat tbc tcrDfct batb maoc t\)ia r j;ccptfon' gooD , ano «ff tl^c E)cfcn» 
 oantlBOUlD {)at3C taken anp aDtantage of ft, be fljoala batjc 'Dcmurreo 
 to. tl^e a>eclaration. Koli chief luftice Dcnpeo tbc Difference taUcn bi> 
 Windham, ano fafo, f f anp of tftc SDefenDants fpakc tUe too joc ano be founo 
 guiltp, tl^e 3(tton tofll toeUlpc.anDitisallonebcte, as fftbe H^cffnD 
 ants tocte ttoo Crangcrs,tbc ^ttfon befng f opnt; but tfie Doqbt fSjVoijctljer ft 
 bcfng after a iJcrDfct, tftfs matter map be oifereD fn arreft of KuDgemcnt. 
 0t anottjcr Dap Hales motea fo^ 3iuD0cmcnt ano fafo, ft toas all one ff anp 
 of tl)c SDcfenoants be founo gulltp.as ff botb of tftcm tocrc founo ro,anD al- 
 tbougft ft DO appear fap tI)c2Dcclaratfon, tl)at tfjc 3ctfon coulo not be bjougbt 
 iopntlp agalrtft t^cm botft, becaufc ttjc lx;?ongs arc fcljetal, ano note one is 
 foinio guiltp , ana tfjc otbct in arquitteo , ano oamaijcij arc^^ *■^;*''' 
 alrctrco agaiaft one pnlp* 5ltiO note tbc tertict Bat^ maoci tftc "'c ,' i'" 
 JDcclaratiou gooo, otftcrtoffc it f)ao been ff botb bao been founo' "* ■ " 
 guiltp ano entire Damages gifecn againft lotb iopntip, latch on tl[)C 
 ot^icrfitDc faio, tbat tftcrpcaUfng of tl)c tpojos cannot be a lopnt Set, 
 ano tijctcfoje ougbt not to be fo laio in one SDeclaration , foj 
 tbcp arc fcticraU 0£ts, ano fctjcrall offences , as tbc too;os do p;o« 
 ceco from tbcm fetcrallp , ano tbis cafe is not Iffec tbc cafe of a 
 decies tantum, nojtbccafcof a lopnt cnoittmcntagainft ttoo.foja lopnt 
 enofctment (ball be accompteo as rcterail enoictmcnts, ano berc if tbe 
 jfcme baa b«ii founo culpable , pcrcbancc ft migbt batjc ban gooo, 
 brcaufc tbousb tbc tolfe onlp fpcak actionable tcojos , pc^ the 
 
 PV3 ^ftfort
 
 3^6 Mich.i65r. 
 
 ^tttort onstjt to be bjougW agafnft tfte i^usbano anu tftu ^i». 
 Roll chief lufticc, SCbe fi>«laratfon fa not tocB lalo , fo^ tijfa cannot be a 
 jopnt fpeafefnc oftbc toojos bp tl)c l^usbanD aiiD ©a(fe , ano tljcrcfojc tbcp 
 ougbt not to be jopncD in the Xlctlon , ttjctcfojc tbetc otisU to be fc\)f ral 
 juogementfl anu Damages if jontccotJct , vir. ^Dncagafnll tbc l^usbano, 
 another agafrl! tbc Intfe , but beic fa a tetofct fotino toWtb helps ft, ano thfa 
 cafe fs all one toltt) the Cafe of 9 Ed. 4. fo> tl)cre the Dctlaration toaa not 
 gmttaaftfanot here, anbbcrcffl not a tctcfct agafnft both , batonlpaofi- 
 thargc, ano be citet) Rethorick anD ChappcU cafe, loberc an Cjcament 
 terrae&hxredijDfonotUc, pct tberc b»' tdcaCng of Damflgea to tbe beft 
 juogcmcntlDaggfbcnfojtbclanD, ano Ijctc might ba^c been a rclcafc of 
 tamagcfl as to the toffc ff both ban been founo gufltp , but here fn effect fa a 
 juDgcmcntbutasafnfloncofthcEDefenDants. lerman, Nicholas, ano Aik 
 luftices to the fame Cffca , and fo judgement wai given for the 
 Plaintif. 
 
 LiuJdingcon and White". 
 
 Mich, i6ja. Banc, fup, 
 
 Mich. i(55i.rori45 8. 
 
 Demurrer to T uddingtcn b?onght Bti 3rt{on of Dcbt opott 3 bfll agafnft White, the 
 
 apicaindcbi J^gjgfp^Qant plcAoeD, that after the monep became" one, he ano the 
 
 upon. bill, ^jad^tjf Jit, jjp parol fabmft to an atuaro , ano thnt there toaa an atoaro 
 
 mate, thatthclDcfcnoantlhonlopapgl. tothcpiafntff at Cuch a fjoufc, 
 
 ant) thereupon the plaintff tboalo gibe hfm a general releafc , ano accojt- 
 
 Ip he teno jcD the monep , to thfa plea the pafntff oemnrrci , ann fo? caufc 
 
 IhetDca that here t3 a fubmffcfon bp parol! plcnoco after the nap of payment 
 
 crp:circo fn t^c Sofll , toWch fa not gooo, befng bp paroU to offchargc^'a ocbt 
 
 D.fch»rg-. jjjjg ,jp fpecfaltp. JBut Wild anftDercn , here toere other things fubmftteo 
 
 bcfiicflthfa, autJt^atmagmaUethefubmf^8fo^gooIJ. Roil chief luftice. 
 
 Ri£ tec: 3; fee not iuhatauthojftp poo hatiefoj thfa, noj hotoftcanbc, anb 4H. <f. 
 
 f f one be alBarocn bcfojc aaofto?s to actompt , thfa cannot be referreo, ano 
 
 here tooulo be anfn conbenfencetotalicateapabatptrcatebbpbonD -bp 
 
 paroll.thCTCfOjC let the Plaintif have his ludgernent. 
 
 Neve and Crofs. 
 
 Mich, 1652, Banc, fup, 
 
 Arr tt f "KIEvebjoiightaK artfonnponthe ta*"c agatntt Crofs fo: rhargfng hfm 
 
 r.dgcnct in IN totth felon P , anfi canCngatTonttable to carrphfm befojc a guCfccof 
 
 :,. .<;h., up-|3cacc,anbatcftrtnghfmtothe3ulIfccfnthcfeteojb6 > viz. He did come to 
 
 on tlic Cifei my door, and fet a Piftol to my Breft , and demanded money of nie and I 
 
 in nj.urc of a fpj, fafegard ot my life did give him what money he defired. tUpon net gufU 
 
 t- " P'^-^y- tp p'.raTieD , anO a aernfa foa th: pafntff, (t loaa mobco bp Fletcher of 
 
 Lir.colr.s Inn, thfltthe tDojDstDcre not aflfonablc, ans thcrefo:c that the 
 
 ^l6f ntif ought not to habe (uogment , ano that foj thefc rcaPons i , J5e- 
 
 taufe there is but K matter of Ercfpafa aflcgco fn the tooiDa. alp-lChcp 
 
 ^ y arc but argamrntatfbe, anD to not charge the patntifPircmptofthfelonp 
 ant ft map b: the monep DcmcntcD iras tnc to the Dcfentant ant the' 
 3arp hate founo all that tohfch foanos to charge the jrartp tofth fclonp a- 
 
 Safnfi
 
 Mich. 16 52- 351 
 
 gafntt tfje ipiatntf f. Twifden on tl)s otbet Qoe fafo , tijat tftTtoojoToogW 
 to bchben tojjetljet , ano fot^epate attfonable, ano ou3!)t not to be fctie. 
 WD; ;anD tftc groana of tl)c jetton fa foj c!;arc<nc Wm tcft^felonp, ana 
 bjfngfng f)fm befo?c tljc S^atLicc, antifptakfn5tl)etDojO0tbere* Roll chief 
 luOice, 3lftbctoojD3rounDtocbarg.cft(inU)U!)fclonp, tbeSdon tofiilfe, 
 ano toe cannot conceive otl^crtuirc but tftat Ije tuoulD babe robbeb tfte partp , 
 anOtocougfttnottoofblDc tljctoojog, foj tl)(3 luereto atgae a male dUCife. 
 vlfif, ;anD pou mfgW fjabe plcaoeD fpcttallp, j ftabc giben tlie fpccialjnat- 
 tetfttctJfOcnce. lerminlufticelsififctED, but Nicholas ano Ask Jnft'CEB a» 
 gtceO toftlj Roll , and fo judgement was given for the Piaintif, nifi, &c. 
 
 Smith and Ward. 
 Mich, 165 a. Bine, fup- 
 
 1^ an action of Debt upon an iDbUgatf on to ff anb f an atoato , anb a t: r« . « r 
 Dfafojtbepafntif, Ittoasmobcofnatrcaofaubgement tbat^tbe a-i./pcmenr in 
 toaro toae not gooo , i , IBccaufc tjerc Is moncp atoarocD to be palo to 315a- an Adion ot 
 ronanbircmc, ir^cteaa tbc i^emc is no partp to tt}C fabmlfslon, aip. D^brupon an 
 !^cre(0 5ol.atoatDeDtobcpatD, but U l^not eppjeffeb foj toljat, oj tbat P^'l^"'"" '" 
 ttfstobc pafo fnfatfsfattlonofanpttfng* jlp.snbefubmlfofonls of aU ^n Avv'a°d 
 matters fnolflferencc till April 1652* anb rlje aioatD fsoE all matters till 
 December foUotolng. Latch anflijercb, astot^e i (lEFceptton, SE^jat tbe 
 35aron bto fabmit to tbe ^IvarD, as tocll fo; [)ia toffe as fo; bimfelf, and tbe 
 ;3[loarbfstomakean eno of matters to'Jct) Doe concern tbe IBaron ano 
 iFcme. ilp. at la not rcquilJite to fl)c\n \rbp tlje 50 1, is to be pato , pet It 
 <3fl)etocDl)ete, viz. fojt^ccnolug of all Differences. ?lp. Stootbnotap- t 
 
 peat bptbe Jtlecojo t^at anp matter Is auiaroeb but to^at Is fubmitteo. Roll 
 chief luftice, 2Ct)c!^u6banDmapfnbmlt fojbis ®3{fe, anD ^ere Is an ;a, Submiflion. 
 toarbonbotbCocs, analftbe'airarDfae gooDlnpartltlsiucllenougb, noj 
 fsUncceffarptofljetotobptljemoncplstobepalD, foj all Diffcrencrs arc '^'*"'^- 
 to be concluDCD upon papment of tbc moncp, ano tft: rclcafc Is to be maoe 
 after t^ls, therefore Uctbc Plaintif have bis judgetncnr.niii. 
 
 • 
 
 Mich. 1652 Banc. fup. 
 
 T" ©e Court teas mol3CD foj a Certiorari to remobe titers Info jmaf Ions Motion for i 
 ■*■ pjcferreo bp an 3nfo;mcr at t^c Scfolons belo at tbc Guildhall In Lon= Ccniorati. 
 don upon tbc fetatnte of primo lac concerning ILcaf ber. Roll chief luftice, 
 SCbc informations tocrccirWbltcD before tbeSufllccs of peace, but It Is a 
 qucttion tobctbet tbe 2DefcnDant cannot remobc tbem , 3 bellebc tbcre" arc 
 pjefiocnts to pjote be map , otbertotfe the JDefcnuant mfgbt be pjcuiDlcco ; 
 butenfojmustobnttbecourfcfsln t^c Common picas In Itit^ cafes. In 
 the mean time we will advifCf 
 
 Wall
 
 3 5^ Mich. 16 52. 
 
 Wall and his wife againft Bye. 
 Mich, i^ji.BanCtfup^ 
 Pafcb. Id J a. rot, yo, 
 ludgement \n TtEli>5emetit toBS gfteii fo> t!jc paftitffs fn an jactfon upon tlje Cafe 
 
 an Aftion up- ibjougljt fttBriftow foj IWt too?l)0 fpofectt Of t^e Wiitx She is Lews 
 onthcCafc Reads Whore, and he knout's her as well a$ bcr Husband, This ludgement 
 ^"■jfy*""" was reverfed upon a writ ofError brought in this Court, becaufe U Oftt ap- 
 Erior.* P' 8f ''P t^^ l^ctojD tfjat tfte ffiojOfl irctc fpoKcn befo?c the late art maoe a- 
 
 gafnft aDulterp ant) <ncontinencp , before tol^tcl) t(mc fuc^ tsojos l^sD not 
 
 been actionable. 
 
 Jennings and Downs. 
 
 Mich, i652,Banc,fup. 
 
 ,. MrftofCttojtDasbjoojjhttoretJcrfeaiutigcment (ur non fnm in- 
 
 tirirtore- 
 
 Ttin, 1^52, rot, 546. 
 
 vciTmucW a formats Gttjenfntbe Common peas fn an Ejeaioncfirmi. SEftc 
 mcnt upon a" ^xxo% afcfffncD tofls , ttjat {t appearcD bp tbe llccojo tftat the 2Dcclatatfon 
 non fum i,.- Vcafl bcfojc thc |)la4ntff bau anp caiifc of ilttfon. Wild anftoereo 3!t Dot!) 
 foimn^s in not appcat fo , but<f<tDo,tf)cn tDEfaptljattberefaatojonc ojfgfnal cct- 
 fi'w °"' ^'^^^ ' ^"^ te^ P?«P tbat toe map batjc a ncto Certiorari to babe tbe true 0. 
 Ceitioiari. tfgfnal ccrtlficD. Roll chief lurtice, Take it, for it is ia affirmance of a 
 iudgcniene , which ought to be favoured, 
 
 Webb and VValhborn. 
 
 , Mich. I <?5 2, Banc fap, 
 
 "\/ V 7Ebbb3ougbtan5lctfonof2ntefpaf0fojcntr{ngtnto ftffl ftoufeantt 
 
 lu 'etmcnt in ' taldng aUiap Dftjcrs gooOfl agaf lift Wafl-iborn, ano obtafna a tact* 
 
 Ttcipafs '" '" ^'^ agalntt bf'it 3t toaa motcD fti arrcft of jtiogement, ann tbcfc f^xi^V* 
 tfons tafecn to tbe SDcclaratton , i?irft, SCljat tbe JDlaf nttf bao tcclarctt foj 
 tbctakfngatoapof a aCtunli toitb to?<tfng0 , ano Dotb not lljcto tobattbc 
 tDjIttngg Iccrc. %q tbfa Wadharn Windham anftocrcQ , tbat tbe SDcclata* 
 tfontoasgooonottoitbttanning, anDcUeoaCafc abjubgeD, tobcrean 0< 
 (tlontoaa bjong()tfo>taU{ngatoapof ttoo SCrunUo tcftb Cloat^s, anb ft 
 loaa not f^aio tobat Cloatba, anb pet belb gooD : 0nD a Cafe fn 43 Ed, 3,24. 
 Snotber €i;ccptfon ^uastaUcn, SCtjattbe plafntff bcclatcQ fo; tbe taUfng 
 etoapofa great 515eam , &talc0 anb tocfgtita gencrallp, ano (bcto0 not 
 liiliat tecfgbt0. SCO tbf0 Windham anftoercD , that toa0 toell enougb , be- 
 tatife the JlBeam ano tbe §)calc0 ano ^cfgbto Do all go to tbe maUfng up of 
 one ano tbe fame tbfng, ano bat>e all a relation one to tbe otbcr, as art 2£tf« 
 01 of 2nrErpar0 bjOUgllt fO? tbe tabfng atoap de Caruca cum apparatu f0 toell 
 biougbt, ag appears fn tbe olD215ook of CEntrfcc. Latch on tbe otter fine 
 fafo, tbattbcSDeclarattonfsunccrtafn, anbtbat ftfonot If lie tbe cafe of 
 t!iC ECtefpafo de Caruca cum apparatu , lo% tbe Mcfgbt0 arc notbfng tCnOi 
 
 fng to mahe tbe }l5cam perfect , anoft fo aa f ncertafn as to b^fng an j^ctfon 
 
 . fo}
 
 Mich. 1651. 355 
 
 fojtlietaUinBatDa? of fite iDtlus ano i^epij, tn^fcb f)atb bnn ^elo to be 
 
 naught, Htles on ttjc otijct fitc fa(3,t^t ttjerc {0 certaintp enough, becaufe 
 
 it ie sU one to fap a JiBcnm VrttiJ focalcg ano Mcfgbts, toUclj mafees aB fatrt 
 
 onet^ias, aetorci'aSS.am., bcatcs ano ^cfatits , o^ as to rapa&bfp 
 
 lijftb flncrO?0 ano Cable©. Roll chief luftice, ?^oU) tan toe reoacc tbc 
 
 .TOefgbtfl to anp certatntp as tljc jEDcdaratlon fa la(o ^ ano If tbc SDcclara- 'nartaimy. 
 
 tton l;ao not been tDitb tbe U>o;i> and , (t Vronlo not baDebelpco (t, foj ft 
 
 tnap be tbcrc lucre a bunojco totigbto , 0? a tboufano lucfgbts , Sinn tbcre. 
 
 fO}e lee the ludgement be arrened rin, $t, ;Snott)Ct ;9(t(on Of SCrerpafS iuas 
 
 b jougbt bp tl)C fame pattp, itbcrefn be Dcclateo foj tbc tabfng atoap of ttrd Declaration. 
 
 great 3nrunhsIot?5i:&,f[iif of ll{nnctT,tiaootIcn, pctotcr, t amongff otbet 
 
 tt){na0,fo} 4 pair of bcnnfnca. ocai'nft lutftb alfo,c);tf ptfcn luflfl tahrn fn ku 
 
 tctt of 3Iuogcment fo j tbc bicerta(ntp. Roil chief lullice , 3 cjonceftc tbat 
 
 four pafr of bangfngo fo certain cMotigb, *ut bcrc ia no vi et armis mcntloneo 
 
 <n tbe SDcclaratlon, tohcb oisgbt to bcfnatiflctlofiofSCrcrpafg foj, entrfng 
 
 fntob<«boufe, anotahtngbfsgooos , as tbc cafe bcre ts , anntberefojefoj 
 
 tbfs caufe lee the Plaincifniewcaule why a nil capiat per billatn (hall not be 
 
 entred againft hira. PoQea* 
 
 Itoas falD bp Roll chief lurtice, SCbat If one fino mp bcdBb , ana re- ctklor" '''"^ 
 fute to Bc»t)Er tbem to me , an Slaton upon tljc cafe Ites agalrft bint , al- gocd$ found. 
 tt)ousbbc conbert tbemnotto bts oton ur&» 
 
 Bond and Martin,^ 
 
 Mich» id52iBanc« fup» 
 
 S|)f cial plet 
 
 TDOnd bjoiigW an Action of SDcbt upon a IBono gftcn uHtobfm as&ljcrff to to an Mi6<\ 
 *^[a\st !)lm batmlcfs, SEbe SDcfenoant pleaoeD a fpeclal plea, tobfcb amoant* °' ^'^^ "P"" 
 countonottTo?etbantbatbebaofat3eDt)fmbarmlcr3; totbfs Jplea erccpsg^'^j"'* 
 tfon Itjao taken , becaafc be ofo nottbclubotobebaafabco tint batmlcfle. °" * 
 SCottts Wadham Windham antlDercD, gf Itbc tljat be b^tb from time to 
 tfnre fatteo b(m bartnlefa ,' it is tvell enougb> Roll chief luftice , 31t is not 
 fObere , anOtbClCfOJC Uc the Plaintif have judgecDenr, nifi^ 
 
 Mich. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 12n trnifl faiu bp Roll chief loaice, tbat in an 0ctfon of SCrefpafaquareJi^e^av'e".*'' 
 vi et armis , &c. JEbcre ougbt to bc an ejpjefs aberment in tbc SDcclara- mens ought to 
 tionoftbcfojce, anDftousbtnottobccvpjttTeOtoitba wherea$ there was be 
 
 fach a force, Arcmnnr, 
 
 Bayncon and Cheisk. 
 
 MicfaidJji.Bar.c.fup* 
 Trin. ifijitrot, 574, 
 
 BAyntonbjongbtanatfionofjaitconipt agafnftChcck, aabb t«efbet.pi„,o,„ 
 SCbe Cafe in fum iuaa tbis, Baynton ogpoCtcD t\ro bunojco potrnDs AaiondAc- 
 lafD upon a bo jfc.racc tn tbc banos of Cheek , to bc Dclftcrcn to tbc partp compt, 
 tljat IboiilD toln , atcojoing to articles maoc htt\joi%t tbc parties. Baynton 
 hippofiitgbebaotDontbcmonep, oentanDstt of Cheek, tobo ban ocUte- 
 ito ot)cc tbe inoncp to anotbet tDbom be rtippon;D bao toon tbc toagei j and 
 
 2 J tb€
 
 2^. Mich. 165 2. 
 
 tljenionep being not BcUtJcrcD to Biynton, Baynton bjtngs.tWa 3[(t(on a« 
 
 gatnft Cheek ; Cheek t^c Oefcnoant.ao to oncljunojtDpounDsplcaDs, Ne ' 
 unques receptor , npon toWcb plcn l)c toas aomoccD to artompt bcfoic SuDf . 
 •V, to?s, anBbifojctbcauBltojBbeplcatJBinDffcborgcof tl)e actompt, tbat 
 
 t)Z ^atj DElfbercD otjcr tbc ironcp to anotljer tbat toon tbcuiaacr. SEbe 
 Ipiafntffr.plpcD, Ctiattbcrctoac foul plcp ufcD bp tbc otber pattp, (ti 
 tixMns one of tijc bo^fcs tbat ran tl)c race upon tbe jifsofe , toblcb tjoas (onl 
 flap , ano agafnft tbc flrtlclca maoc bcttofrt tbcm , ano fo be ongbt notto 
 |)abe DcUtcrcD tbc moncp. SCbc qucft'on toao ivtctbcr tbts toas a gooo 
 pica In Difcbarge of tbc accontpt bcfojc tbc 0uDitoj3. Roll chief luQice fa(o, 
 SCbe pica luas not gooD . in vcgatotbat tb" SDefcncantteas aBfiiogco to ac- 
 compt,Viibtc!jQotb(inplp tbat tbc moncp toao faMp toonbp tbc platntff. 
 Lacf h on tbc ot'jcr fiioc iiTgcD , tbat tbc rcpUcatfon iras not gooD , but is 
 inip.TtJnent, ann tbcrcfojc tbat tbc |Mn(ntff can babe no Stjoaemcnt 
 tbou£h tr/c plea <nJ5nrb; not goou, but tbat tbcrcotjgbttobea Kcpleao-' 
 et. Sit anotbcr cap Green moljoo fo? tutgemcnt foj tl;c |3lafntlf , anb cf- 
 tcDHijb. iii.Ta'kerscafc, abatanfffuc jopncD upon fmpcrtJncnt matter 
 ta not bclpco bp tbc Statute , anu Kent and H.dls cafe fn Hob. Rep. but bcrc 
 is onlp an fnfo?mal iCfac , tobfcb fs bclpeo bp tbc lillcraict , ac arc Rawden & 
 Tuts cafe, ano Napper and DavrkescafcfnHob. Report?, anO Mich. 2 Car. 
 Giggon and Purchaies cafe, anD falD, that 8t tbc Common Hato a SCrpal 
 upon n Double <ffue teas goot), Brokelfrue3o. 2lp.2Ebtsplcaofti)cSDefen= 
 tantougbttoba^cbccnplcaDCDinbaroftbc 0ctton, ano not in Difcbargc 
 bcfo;ctbC0UDltO?0, I Ed. 5, a.Brook AccomptS^. anO Dyer 195. Hun* 
 perfords cafe. Latch on tbc otbcr GDC fafo , tbat tbc IRepHcatfon f0 <mpcr. 
 feet, anotbattljetacrtJfrtbclpsftnot, tbc SDcfcnoant aUcges tbc ilrtfclea 
 maoc upon tbc taagcr , ano tbc replication fs about flrllifng of tbc l^ojfe, 
 anu anfl-ocrij not tbe matter pleaoeo In S5ar, fo;i tbc Set of tbc IRlDcr, viz. 
 tbc fttllifng oftbcbojfctsnottbcactofBinijtobomaDctbcflrtfclcB, ano 
 bcfioeo bcrc Is no bjeacb of Articles, fo j tbcp Doe not pjoblbltc to ffrlbc tbc 
 i^ojfc, ojtorlDcfoul, accojDlngtotbc JLaiuo of a l^ojfc race, ano tbc 
 iklDcr Dotb not appear to be Bifli bis fecrbant , but a tbtro pcrfon , ano an 
 Action cftbc Cafe llcsjagalntt bint, anD not agafntt Bifh, tobo io% ougbt 
 appears batb Done nothing agalnft tbc flrtlclCB , ano tbc matter fn bar of tbc 
 <accompt l3 toeU plcaocD , ano coulo not be otbcrlrlfc , as tbc Cafe 10 , ana 
 H in toell cnougb , tbcugb It be not plcaocD in bar of tbc Action . foj be conltt 
 not babe plcaocQ ne unques receptor par accompt render , ^ E. 4. 1 <?. Dyec 
 19 H. 6. 5. laisbccoulDnotbabcplcaDCDtbcgencral fffuc, ano giben tbe 
 fpcclal matter in cblDencc;9nD be cannot pleao tbuolnbaroftbcjactf. 
 on of accompt , ano tbcrc is not one book tbat faps otbcrtoffc, 41 E. 3. 3 1 . 
 5H. 5.5. ipH.fi. 5. *i*^.<5,49. >i E. -1.^)7. 5 H. 5. 1. 5 E. 4.41. i E» 
 5.1. i7 H.y.i^.tKIblcbboohsDofljetoftmapbeaBtDcUplcaQcobefoje tbe 
 ^uOitojci, asbcfojc fnbaroftbcflttfon, 14 E. 3. Fitz. Accompt 6S. ji E» 
 4.54 iBpthcfc boohs tclflcompclico to pleao tbcfc matters bcfoje Suof. 
 to;s i ano tbc otbcr boonS are not crpjcflp agamft It -. flno In tbis cafe bcrc 
 is not a bailment purclp to oellbcr ot^cr, but tbcre Is fubfequcnt mattet 
 tob'tb circctfl boto It (ball be oclf bercD otcr , ano tbls matter be mutt plcao. 
 315ut atimlttlng tbe IBar to be IB , If tbc replication be Impertinent, ano tbat 
 ftebatbtonfcffeotbatbcbatbnocaufeof Action , tben It Is fcltb us, antr" 
 tjerc Is no pcrrtner.t matter plcaoeo to abolo tbe matter confeirco,ano fo tbe 
 3uDgcmentougbttobcagalnfltbc ^lalntlf, 3 Report, Ridgewayj Cafe 
 is , SCbat If Impertinent matter be in a rrplfcatlon , toblcb anftners not tbc 
 bar, IHutgemcntougbttobc gibcn agatntt tbe ^Dtalntlf, ano tbc matter 
 confcffcolanotlnbaroftbeactlon ofaccomptaslsobfecteo , 1H.7.1.11 
 H.i. i6. Halcf, sntjc matter of Dcllbcrpmafecs not tbf matter, jEEbefab- 
 
 fequcnt
 
 Mich. 1652. 3 55_ 
 
 ftquent matter Is srounDcnnpontl-cConDftfon inaBc upon t^c miitrv » 
 Dyer 1 69' ano IjctE is m fnfnf 6c(cnt bar,at.O tfje matter of tljs repUcatfon fa 
 gooD, accojDfng to fl)c matter allcsctfnti;e bar , foj tljc iJrtfclco oucbt 
 to be fntcrpjctcD atco jDfng to tljc <ntcntfon of il)c parties , M)k\) teas , tftat 
 titc race ftoalD fee fatrlp toon, iiljicMs not fo Ijcrc , 18 E. 4. 4. matter of 
 Cotenant bp uecD map be DffcljargeD bp fufcfrqaent matter ol fact ; ano t^c 
 ilfocts^crcOjaUnotbcaccomptcD nicer Grangers, fo? tijep are Jntttu- 
 ments maoc bp tlje parties , anc tbcrc Is confiocncc p:it In t!)cm to perform 
 ttie act of Thing, ano tf)elraasfl)all be tbe acts of ttic parties; Sim {)cre Is 
 notljinc; tbetocD in the replication tobtct) Dcftrops tbe Action. Roll chief 
 luftice'^ 3 fpouba^cconfelTeDtfte Articles, ano allcgcD Impertinent mat- 
 ter fnttje replication, tjotocanpoutaheatibantageof anIBbar, ano^to 
 can pou Interpret ttje Intent of ttie articles otbfir\Dl''c tl)aa in crpjcffco bp 
 t\itm^ 0nD tjoto can toe tahc notice ftcrc, tt;at tijerc isas not lair plap in 
 tlje running oftteracc;' ano 3; Doubt of tbebc3^cltcDbpUtcb, foj u^jcreeir, 
 matter map be pleaOEOln 15ar,t|)c partp fliaU not be compelUo to come be* Audi-ors. 
 foje 0aDlto?0,foj tl)»t toere unreafonablc. 3if 3 oellbct gaios to ociltjcc Aecompt. 
 otjcr, ano t^c partp DO It not, be Is acccmptable to me, but If be De'itt«r 
 tljem oticr, be is not , fo; be map pleaot'ols In bar of tije miction, ano fo Is 
 It In tbc Cafe at tbe 55ar , anDpoumlgl)tfjat)e giticn tbc fpeclal matter In 
 eljloence berc bp tt)e meal 0ct , ano tbls plea bere befojc tbe aaoitojs Is Pis*. 
 tl cerlp tolo. snt'C main Doubt bcrc Is, tobetbcr tbere be apparent matt.t 
 to tbe Court to btnoer tbe jpialntllf from bis 3uogement ,3 concclbe tbs 
 Sirtlclcs IbaU be lntcrp?eteD falrlp, ano tbat tbere ougbt not to be fotol plap 
 accojDlngto<rommonlntcnDment,anoltls material to Iftetn tbere toas 
 totol plap In tbe replication, anofo tbe Iffue Is toeU jopneo, and ludge- 
 men c oupht CO be for the Plaintiff, lerman anO Nicholas lullices to Ct)0 
 lame parpofeasRoU. 
 
 ) 
 
 Mich. ij5 5 z.Basc. fup. 
 
 SC tuaa moteo foa Cojonel Baxter, tbat be toas electeo Wgfj ^tcfoaro of ,, . 
 
 tbe3EoirnofColchefter In Effex, ano tberefoje tm tbe Court toonlo ,t,no7a>u' 10 
 grantaraandamastobeOtrecteDtotbc S^ioi tbere to ftoear bim fn thatcoichtii.r 10 
 place. Roll chief luftice.Ifhc be duelyeleded, and he refufe tofwear bini,'"**^ '^e 
 ukcatnaodamas* *^R-' Stewarl 
 
 ihcre, 
 
 iaques. 
 
 Mich. 16$ 2, Banc, Aip« 
 
 Tijtbccafeofonc laqucsfnanactfonof Ctefpafe quare vi cr armi*. fo^ wha.piMa- 
 JtbeentrlngfntoblB 3Lano, at teas talo bp Roll cb.ef luftice, SCbat If in moun.s'^.o 
 an action of aCrcfpafs ri Sc amis fo; cntring Into lano , tbe Dcfenoant "°' g"'"'}- 
 plcaoblsentTpbpWrtaeofa leafc fo^ pcara ,tblo amounts to no moie 
 tbannotgnfltp,anotbE|mafntfffmapocmnrnpont6c pea, ano tbeinit^'"^''"' 
 fo} canfc of oemorrcr, tljatU amounts to no moje* 
 
 *?» Mkhi
 
 Motion for a 
 ccrriorari to 
 
 J 5 g^ _^^^ Mich. 16 52. 
 
 Mich. 1652. Banc.fup. 
 
 here one t^ j^g (gfg (,f jmc Poynci Mawrice ft toao fafo, t^at If one b0 commlttcO (0 
 "dTchrcd tftc upper IBencij p?ffon.foj a mtfocmciiour, nnonotfoj ocbt,onc cannot 
 lir.ft in occUtc againlt \tlm,as againd one <n Cuaodia. 
 
 iftodii. 
 
 Mch. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 T^c CoDtt teas moDcD on tl)C bcbalfdftI)ca)efcniJant,foja ccrtiorac 
 n to remotjc ccrtafn cntifttmenta pjcfcrrcD ngafnft bfm fn London, foj 
 fcllmg of leather, to tljc eno l)c magl)at»canfnDfffcrcnttrpaU,nota;<tl)- 
 d'fimcms"' ftanoFna tbc Statute, U)b(fl) Directs tijat tftc cnDittmcnt Oc pjeferreo in fbc 
 Coantp, \rCTC tbc offence teas commUtcD. Roll chief lufticc , SLtje feita- 
 tuteltasjmaocfojtftecafcoftljc SDefcnoant, ant» tl)crcfo;c be map re- 
 moVieti)ecnDfctmcnt,ot!)eriDffcbc«)allb:tntoojfccafc tban ^c teas be* 
 fojctfte&tatnte, Therefore take a Certiorari, 
 
 Yongue and Petit. 
 
 Mich, 1(551. Banc, fup, 
 
 Parc,i652» rot, lyp. 
 
 Demurrer to^ \7'0n{;ue bjougbt an flcfon of Dcbt agafntt Petit npon an iDbUgatfon ani> 
 « .cpiicanon J Bctlarcg, tftst Uibcrcas at tbc rr queft of tbe SDeicnoant fte UJo become 
 l"Bond "^''" bounD IrttJi a tb<rD pcrfon, foj tbc pnpment of a certain fam of monp unto I, 
 S. at a certain Dap,tbc HDcfenoant became bouno in an jSDblfgatfon to tbe 
 |)lafnt<ff, tbe concitfon Of tDbfcb ilDblf gation Icao, tbat if tljc SDcfcnBant Dio 
 pap tbc monp tmto l. S. at tJ)C Dap limittcD , fo? {sW^ tbc J3laint(fF toas 
 bouno, ano in tbe mean time lIjoulD fate bim barmleffD, tbat tben tbe i£)fa« 
 ligation fljoulD be tjoio , anofojnotpcrrojming tbts condition be bjougbt 
 bf3 Action. 2Ebc S'cfenDant plcaoB that be caufcn tbc partp , toltb tobom 
 tbcpaintfffiuasbounOjtofubmitbtmrclfto J3;ifon, anotbat tbc|9lafn« 
 tiff uiaonotoamnj'fico. 2Dbc ipiafntfflfrcplpceantjticnpecnottbe 315ar; 
 but fapes tbat a latitat Iras fueo oat agatnft bim , anD ttjat be fcarctj to be 
 arretteo , anu upon tbfs replication tbe SDefenoant oemura , ar.o tbcfe c)c« 
 ccptions liocre tnkcn to it. i , 2Cbat be cotb not fap be tooU out a latitat 
 proutpatet perrerordum. alp. 3it tuas tjurftfoneo botu tbc teOjDS in tbe 
 mean time Ojall be unucraooo. iFoj tbc firff crccption Utch b2lD it not 
 Relation, n^gtcria!, anD fo; tbe fcconD bJ belD tbat tbep refer to tbe libole conDitfon, 
 Roll chief luflicefnfo, itignot netcCTarp bcrc to pleaD non damnificatus if 
 Ibe partp be in pjifon , ano tbf toojDo in tbc mean time refer to tbe laft 
 \B02D8 onlp of tl?c conoition; JBut one batb plcaWD an ill plea, anD tbe otbcr 
 batb allcagCD an ill b;cacb , tbcrcfore nil capiat per billam, nifi. Yet we will 
 advife, ' 
 
 Mich. 1652, Banc. fup. 
 
 A0 cnDfctment luas nt'aOicD fo: not repairing a bigbtoap, bccaufe ft DfD 
 "°* f^^ f"'^^ f"*" ^"^^^ P'^'^ ^^ ^^'"^ *?^''" ^^^ ^"P "'^ ^^^^' 
 
 The
 
 Mich. 165 i« 357 
 
 The Maior and Commonalcy of London 
 againfl: Hatton. 
 
 Mich, 1652, Banc. fup. 
 
 'Tl^c S&Aia% ano Commonalty of London fajoucftt an Siaton of Covenant "Demurrer r« 
 egflfnft Hatton,foj not papfng a rent rcfcttcD bp ttcm upon a Irafc f6j Itnt^t" ^'*" 
 pears mace unto i)fm of tbe C^arblers off!cc.2Ll)c S:*cfcnDant plcaceotljat 
 tl)f0 office teas an office of trail rcpofED in tlie C<tpofLondon,anD conlo 
 not be let foj penrSjfnD confcqticnth; tbcrc teas no groiinD of Qatcn.Xo tW 
 plea ttjcplafntJff Demurs. Hales^cto tl)attlifg office map be let fo; pears, 
 becaufc tftc il^afo j anD Commonaltp of London ftatie a Sftc Qmple la tfj e of- 
 fice bp tl^cJr c^artcr.anD tftat tl)cp Ijntje not onip a meer truft rcpofcD fn t'jcm 
 to execute ft. ano ilp. 3[f U coalo not be granteo, pet tiere (3 no fo^feU 
 tare, fojtUsleafefljall be accomptco but a Deputation , anonot a gran- 
 tfngotjer of tbe office, ^nn jlp. %\)z ileffeca coijcnant fijall bar bfm 
 from pleaDfngtljfa plea. Wadham Wmdhampjapco a uap to be IjeatD. 
 Roll cliief Iu(ticc,3t tofU bc barD foj pouto mafntafn tbc UDefcnoanta plea, p*P"t«iort. 
 JFoj lijt^out Doubt tbe (^afoj map maUe a SDcputp to tyecate tfefs office ; *^* 
 35ut terc ^e batb a iFes Qmple fn ft, snD map t^erebp make a leafe of ft, ano 
 tlje ILeffees Covenant tnfll bfno bfm to pap tlje rent. ludicium pro queren- 
 te,nifi. fC, jat anotfjct Dap Wadham Windham put tbe Cafe, anO;ac« 
 gaeD tbat tf)c office of (IDarbler ia not grantable , becaufc t^at tbfs office ia 
 anofficeoftru(trepofeDfnaco:ipo^atfon, anD it fa fo rcpofeo foi tbe pubi 
 IfquegooD, anD tbe office ft felffs not bcftcDfnttejpafo}. ano tbercfojc 
 6c cannot grant ft,altl)ougb be map maUe a £Dcputie to erecatc ft, fo; tfiete 
 tbc^ttsoftbcEDcputfcDoUgbtupontbc jpafterto bc anfujerab'.e fo;^ , 29 
 H.6. 44- Dyer i^g a J^afo} Of a 2LolDn map maHca 2Dcputfc; but be can* 
 not grant ttfa office j mahc a rebcnue of it. Roll chief lufticc, Bit is confis 
 oerablc in rcgarn it ia an office of truff, tubetljer it map be UafeD out , al- 
 tijoug!) t)C map mabe a jDcputp. Thercbrc argue ic again the ncxc Term. 
 
 Baker ind Andrews, 
 
 Mich,»i<552. Banc, fup, 
 Trin. ifijo.roti i45p. 
 
 BAker bjoagbt anactfon 0f3nrcfpar8,quarc vi & armis cUufum rregit,anb tc lurrcr ro 
 foj tafefng bis Cat tcl; tbc SDefcnoant as to the tojce anD arms pleaos > 'cpicarb^ 
 non cui. anD as to tbc reft be luftlfies that the Ca ttcl tuent fn tb^ougb " T'tfcifle 
 the Defect of tbc plafntiffa inclofures; rbe ipiaintiff rcplpcs that fbc Cattcl " '' """'• 
 came in tb:oucb another mans fence into bfs grounojto this replication the 
 )BDefenDantoemurG,ilbc\r6 foj caufc that tljeplaintif Dotb not afSfgn Uibcre 
 tbc place of the other Clbrclpcs,tf)?onghtDbitb the Cattcl camctbjoufib. 
 Yard faio it is notncccITarpto Uiclo icbcre it Ipcs , foz thcpitci tnotfn 
 It here tbc SDsfcnDanl bath allegcD, $ fo the traterfeis tocll taUcn Wadham 
 Windham on the other CDC anfUjcrco, here is a netD afcignmcnt . anD be 
 anf tocrs not the SCrefpafs fo} tobfcb the artfon(8b;ougbt,anD becaufc it is 
 anciDarEtgnmcnt.toemuftgibEanctnanftDCr ; ana tbcrefoje pou muft * 
 fijcin the place tobcrc pour ncio afsignmcnt Ipcs. Roll chief luRice, M^c 
 plcaoa no mo;e but t^at t^e Cattcl came fn at another place, than is plea. 
 
 Z!3 Deo
 
 3$8^ Mich. 1652. 
 
 ttc^, anuftcnccns not flbetotftc place , iiB-jt ftcre t!)c Dcfcnoanto pica fs 
 Pie». "°^ goBD, foj ^c plcaog a pjcfcrfption tobcce it ougl)t to be a cnftom, tbat tfje 
 
 occuppcra of tl)C lano oua^t tomalsc tijc fcntC3,anD t>c ougf)t not to p;;rct(bc 
 <n t Jje pcrfon, IudgemcntforthePliintiff,nifi, 
 
 Mich. 1652. Banc.fup. 
 
 Who » IT) i^Ro'lchtefluOice, 3ftl)crcbcafaijlt(!i a pica fn matter offojm, 
 
 tJkc^a"Va'!i- I J ^"° ^ff '^'^ ^''^'^^ ^3 " foalt alfo f H tljc rcplUwKon , ano tlje ZDetcnoant 
 
 t>ge <.fa fault ^-^ Dtniurd to <t , bat fljcius 110 caiifc Of oem!iTrer,bc fljall taljcnoflODaii. 
 
 in a I'lca. tagc Of t^fs fflult iti tljc rcpUtattott ; but be iil)o Jopng in tgc Dcjnuirct fbufi 
 
 AJvant;gc. take aD^jatitajje oftljc ill pica, anofoluasUaDiuOgcOjParc. i.Car. inthi* 
 
 Court in Prat and I himblethorps cafe, anO l)e ffiio t|)at all faults In plcaoirig 
 
 arc fncnrafale at tbc Common iiaU), ano tbcrcfoie tbofc t|>at are not t)c;pca 
 
 bi' j&tatatca arc left as tlicpiDCte at tDc Common Jlalu, 
 
 Midi. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 Mor 
 
 O j^c teas mane Conftablf bp ojDcr of a Qoartcr fecfsfons, buttle 
 partptcfufcDtofcrDcauorcmot'cij t^c ojocr l)(t!)cr bp Certiorari, 
 ccvoi liar' ' wo^ED to qnafli) tljc o jtcr but tbcCourt IdouId not do it altl;ouab t^er tocre 
 ons. " material crccptkmfl tahcn aga^nft i t , but ojocrco bim to pleao, bccaufe tfttp 
 perceitcD tt)c partp tuas iltibbo^n, ano t^ci> IdouId not iVot ciuourage- 
 ment to fact) perfons. 
 
 Heath ana Vdall^ 
 
 Mich, 165 2. Banc, fup. 
 
 Arrcft of 
 
 HEath aCarpcr bjongbt an Miction of tlieCafc agafnftVdall.ann Declares 
 among otl)cr tbiiigflfojplunoerinsof tfm of vigintifardellas Angiicc 
 inTaiun' '" packs, ano in arrrJl of KuDgementk teas motico tbat t^c iDOjDa vingmti 
 upon ihc cafe fardellas Anglice pacUs is nnccTtain ; IBnt Maynnd argucD that ft migbt be 
 CooD,bccaufetbc Carper coulD not Declare otbcrtoapcs, foj t)C coalo not 
 
 Dcclararicii ''""^ ^"j^* ^^^ *" ^^^ V^tk^ , SnD ftC CftC» CttC Bedingfields CafC, Trin. lo. 
 
 Car. toberc an Action luas bjotjgbt fo> a libjarp of booK0,ano fo} apparcll , 
 anoaDiiiDgcDgooD ; ilButRoll chief lufticefafo, ft coulB not bcgoDfojtbc 
 apparel. Wadham Windfiam on tbc otftcr ftoc hclD tbe toojDB uncertain as 
 tl^cp art, ant faio be ougljt to batjc Cbctoca t^at tl)ep iocre patbg \vit\) gooog, 
 ojbabcOjclccntobatteaafntbcm, fo; a pack is butameafyrc of a tbiiig. 
 Roll chief lufticcanflBcreo, ffftbebHtameafurcofa tbtng, tlicn no Da. 
 mages axi giten foj tbcm,anD tben tbe action is gooD fojtttc rcff ; But we 
 *ill advifir. 0ftcttoaros in tbc fame Ccrm Maynard mol3eD fo; tbc opini- 
 on of tbc Court , anDtbcrcupon tbc Court belD, that tbe vuoaD? arc inccc« 
 tain as tbcp arc, fo j be ongbt to bate crpjcffeo utiat Vnas in tbc packs, and 
 ruled a nil capiat per billain to be entred. 
 
 Icviag(loa
 
 Mich. \6^i. 3 55j 
 
 Lcvingfton and Crompton. 
 Micb. I ($5 2. Banc» (up, 
 
 LEvingifton bjoag^t sn Slction in tftfu Conrt agatntt Crompton, Cljc SPe* Ex«ptioi4j t* 
 fenuant pleaos tliat Ijc fs a Clatb of ttic ClSiancetp, ann t^at all Clartjg ' p ".°'^'"'' 
 of t^c Cljantcrp ougtlt to be fucD fn tbe Ctjanccrp onlp , ano not clfctoljerc, * ' ^"' 
 ano ocmanDa juocemcnt ff fte ougftt to make anp otftct anflDEt in tjifs 
 Coutt, jictoo Cpccptfons tDcre taken to tlje plea , •. ?^e faftl), SCtjat ali 
 ClatbBOf t^e Cbancerp^ate ufen to be futo Intftc Cbanccrp,anD notclfe- 
 iD^ctc, anODotljnotfap, nojanpof tbcmtatfcbccntifcDto be fucD clfc« 
 tBl)ete , anti ttonol^ all of t^cm tatic not been ufco to be fueo clfciubcre, pet 
 tftat tifnuew not bat tUat fome of tbcm Ijabc been fuco elfctotjcre. jlp . ^z 
 plcaD0 tftat be <s a Clath of tbe <li)anterp , ano otigbt to be frnpleatjco in t\)Z 
 Cbancerp ftclo at Weftminner, befojc tbe keepers of tbe Ubcrtp of England, 
 & c. time out of mtno , toMc^ 10 not true. Hales anftoeteo , SCbat tfef s Contt 
 ong^t to take notice oft^cpjitflcgc of Cbancerp, altbongb ft be not tocll No-'<-e- 
 plcaocD; JSiit Roll chief lufticcDcntcDtOattbepongbt to DO it, ano fafo,'^"*'' g«« 
 SLftat ft fs tljcCuftom fo jtbe Clarke of tiieG-j;ct)cqucr,U)bEn tfjep pleao tbcfc 
 p;f tf lege, to b?(ngtl)crco book tDbetefntftefr pjitflcgcs ate tojitten fnto 
 tbcCoptt, anu upon Gg^t of tbcfrpjfbf lege t^etctxiMtten) ftfsnfeoto be 
 aBotocD, but ftfsnotfo of tfte pjftflcges of tlje ot^et Courts , but tfiep 
 jnuft be pleaueD , ano fo bere, And becaufe ic ii not well pleaded here, there^« 
 fore flicw caulc wby yoa (hould noc plead in chief. 
 
 Pitton and Rey. 
 
 Micbv 1 5; t* Banc, fup, ' 
 
 T>ltton appeateb to an flfttfon bjought agafnft Ijfm at tbe fate of Rey , bat \'° p7^°7-. 
 1 no Declaration toas put f n agafntt bfm.tapon an A ffidavit t^t tbeJBDcfen. dcciare'fwe- 
 Dant toas a s^crcbant, fpccDflp to go to fe>ea , gt leas mobeo fo j bfm tbat aiiy. 
 tbe pafntft mfsbt fo?tl)lt<tt) Declare agafntt bfm , tbat tfjerebp be mfgbt of- 
 tea bfs 3ttojr.ep totjat to pleao, ano migbt babe bfs If bertp to be gone. Roll 
 chief Inftice, 15p tbccoorfe of tbc Court bcbatbtf)jaterm0 Ifbertp to De« 
 Clare, buttMsfsaneytraojDfnarpCafc, Therefore let him declare Thurf- 
 daynexc, othcrwifc he fhallnotdeclare till he come back, Noca. 
 
 B 
 
 Mch. 1652. 
 
 p Roll chief luftice ; SI p}it)ate fsttsims of tbc jaeace (0 not^o to H 
 bclofojtbeConntp, • 
 
 Staples Caft. 
 
 Micb. 16$ z. Banc, iup* 
 
 . no 
 ichtnent 
 
 r* A BRalc inas reao on tbe Capftal Coe fo^ Staples a tattict of fDeace of c,ufe wby 
 XlSuflex, tofljctocaufetDbpanattacbmcnt fljonlo not be granfcDa-Auichmem 
 gafnll bfm (0% pjocaofng upon an Cncfdmcnt of fojcfblc entrp , ano finfns»6»inft » lu- 
 tljcpattp, aftctaCcrtiorariUiao DflfbercD untojifrato remote tbe Gnoftt»'^'"'^P"«i 
 
 mtnt
 
 360 Mich. 16 5 i. 
 
 mcnt Into tWs Court , ajto tljcrcupon i: tnaa pjapco tijat (fmfgtt be gtaiii 
 tco, anofefcTho. Styles, ano ©fr lohnSidlcy* cafe 8 CaroiriDaaurBeo, 
 tDbere an ^ttactimcnt U>a0 granteo fti Vtt Ubc cafe, vrild on tt)C otf)cr Qoc 
 pjapcDttmfgljtnotlCijrantct), bccaufc tlje partfcs cnofrteo Dfo not tenocc 
 furctfc0 to p:occcD to a SEtpal npon tljc enDidment.as tl)C &tatatc nfrcdj?. 
 Fine, ano bccaiifc the fine toaa fcf upon tljc pnttfcs bcfo:cthc Ccrciorari U'as dc 
 
 Travcrfj. Ktatgj ^ ano ft ie tn tl>: clettfon of t^c 3uft<ce to Eet a fine upon fi>e partp , 
 "■ anotcfuff toaomrttbcpartPtoWotratcrfc, asfome DO liolo. Roll cbieF 
 
 luiticc, Upon\)(cU)oftbcfo;rctl)e3*tt'tcinapfctafinc upon tbe partp, 
 ano rcfofc to aonrft t%e partp to t)<3 trabcrfc, 0; pica, at Wg pleafarc; but tbc 
 rafcfgnotfotjcrc; anBtn 15 Car. tt teas rcfolbeii, tbat ff a Certiorari bs 
 b?oucbttotl)cfecfsiMfl torcmoucan (EnDfctment of (ojifblc Cntrp pjr. 
 terrr D agatnft Dft^crs pcrfone, if fome of tbcra (oinc in nno ftno farctfcs fo j 
 tbe DamagM.U tB pooo fa^ tfem al ,to rcmobc tbc CCnofflmcnt fo?tbc reft, 
 clfe (t luotilD be mifrbfcbouo fo j tbcm tbat fine tbr furctfce. ano be fatD,tbat 
 <fani>tbttia;bcDoncat apjtbatcfecfofona of peace, ftongt.t to bcrcturiT' 
 EDtoaCitjartCT&efctons, oi tnto tbffl Court, Upoubfctooftbc fojcetbe 
 Error. 3t»ft<rc3 of pcacc are 3laftgcB, antjmapfetafine, anofftfccrcbc CBrroj a 
 
 iDjft of Crro J map be b?ongbt. The rtife wm, that &taplcc be examined Bp« 
 oninrerroi^atories, and make a return ol the Certiorari Monday new, aod 
 chat he reftorc die fiae eo the party » 
 
 Wood and Mountncy. 
 
 _ ., ,., Micb.i^yj. Banc. flip. 
 
 charged by Ti^ tbc Cafe OfVVood aulJ Moumney, Roll chief luftice fatO, STfjat il the 
 ihcdcathof Ipiafntff fn a tojit ot Crvojufebcfojc tbcmattcrbc DctermincD, pet 
 B.ii''''"'''"' ^** ^^^' ^"^^ "°* tbcrcbp DtftbargtD* 
 
 Webb and Wafl\born. 
 
 Hill, 1651, Banc, fup, 
 
 Arrrft of T ^^ 3ct<0N 1)088 an flctfon of SCrobcr antt Conbcrfion fo j Dfbcrs gootts ; 
 ju.igtment in ^Ijc aDcfcHOant plcflCfD ttot gufltp , ano upon fffac ioweD,a Clerofa 
 a Trover and inag founo foj tftc jDlaintlf. 3t toaa mobeo in 3rrca of 3iiDgcincnt tbat tbe 
 CoHvcrfion. |5iatnt(f aiMongft ©tfeer tWugfl featt oedatcb foj a Shrunk uitb tojitingst, 
 leb'cb id uncertain. VVadham Windham foi tbe Dcfcnoant falD, tbc SDc- 
 claratlon io certain cnougb , ano citco a Cafe ubcre an ^dlon luss bjougbt 
 fo^ticoSlLTunhaofCloatbee, anoDotbnotfaplobatCloatbs, ano pctao< 
 ttiogcD gooD. 0notbcr Grrcption teas taUcn , SEbat tbc piafntf f occlarea 
 fo J a great IScant, »calc0, ano GHciJibts, tobicb is alfo incertain. 2Co tbfa 
 Windham anfVDcreo, 3t tea© certain enougb, bccanfe tbep all make but 
 one tWnOjbp rcafon of tbc relation tbep babe one to tbc other ; 0nD in tbe 
 olD 15oo^f Cntriea tue 6tio , t'oat an ;Sctton of SCrefpafo toas b^ougbt pre 
 Cnruca rJnapparatu, anOaoiuDgcO gooO. Latch on tbC Otbcr Coe, as to 
 tbe laft exception faio , 3t io not anrincrco , foj tb; IcojDa arc bcrp incct. 
 tain , ane it is not like tbe cafe of tbe SErefpafa citco , de Caruca cum appa« 
 ratu. fojthc^iSleigbtsgonottotbcpcrfitfingoftbc 15cam, aa tbe appas 
 ratus Dotb of tt;c ^loin , am it is as tintcrtnin «g to b;ing an ^aion foj fifcg 
 i-otho anol^epo, lubicb is not floos. Hales anftoercD, (t fe certain e« 
 nongb, foittisalloneaaifbcbaofaiD, aiBeam, fecalca, antj tlJacigbts, 
 lobtcb in aa certain ao to far, a febip toitb iSncboia anoCablca. Holl 
 chief Juftict , ![?otD can toe reiliite flje OTicjgbta to anp ccrtaintp as tbe De- 
 claration is laiO:' anb if tbc 1oo;d and bao been aoDcoft ioottlD not babe Wv* 
 
 eo,
 
 Hilll.i552. 351 
 
 CO , foj t^ep map be a ftunojeu ca[cfg^ts, j a tfeoufano. Slnot^n €j;ccp« 
 Hon toas taken t^att^e |Blatntiff tn anoti;ec Bdion t^ao tscclarcofo} fout 
 paftofi^ang{n53,toWc?it3ancetta{n:BLjt Roll chief luiTicefajo, Ebat tbat 
 mifiljt fac ioelUnougt) unDcrttooa. Green at atiotftct cap fnfift.D, tt.atfoat 
 ^aft of l)angfng0tstcrp uncertain, bat ffftftau been fafofotir futca ftUB 
 been tDcU;315cf;DC0,tl)c tierp toojD bano^nns fs a coubtfuU iDo;t),fo; (t Qjctcs 
 not VDijctbcr tbc tjangincs tDcrc &tll; oj fe)tu{f, oj tobat clfc tbcp tocre 
 mane of, a0ftougbttobc. ^ealfo tooU an Cjccptfon tbat tbclpiamtifE 
 ftao onl^ tftctocD tbat bete tea's a Denpal am rcfufal to rcttoje tbe gooDs, 
 batnoconfecrdonoftbcmfsOjetoeD. SCotble Hales anftocrco, Jtijat tbe 
 Sfctf on betns an 3ctf on upon tbe Cafe , 3lt is not ncceffarp to fteuj tbe Con« 
 terCon , ant) fo? tbe four paft of tjanefngs it is Ircll cnougb, fo; a pair is a 
 couple tebcatbe Ujojd is ufcs of ocaD tbings, ano not libc a paic of tongues 
 tcbicb mafee but one tbfng no; is it matcifal to erpielTc of ubat tbe bang* 
 fngs arc maBC, as it is net in an action b jougbt fo j oibcrs pair of ftocsinga 
 material to fapjlD^ctbettbcptoere of tb; can, iilfejtDoft.D, oj scoUen, as 
 batb been atijuDgeo , ano tbe tuoj;0 liangings is certain , fo j anp one faiB 
 conceibe tb m to be meant of bangings of a room. Roll cbief luftice, SLbe 
 JSction is an 0aion upon tbe cafe , ano it is not neceffacp to (beto a conber< 
 Oon,fo? tbe action is not bjougbt foj tbe conbertton , ano if it voerc fo,if a 
 r)cmanO,anDaDenpalfaep;olJco,Dotbnottl)i6p:otieaconbcrCon f asanc^fc 
 Action of tbe cafe [pes foj'heeping one out of polTcfsion, altbougb tbe partp ^'°''jf^'„ 
 Dotb enter afterniarosjanD tbe fourpait of bangings is certain enougb,ano it °"^" ' "'"* 
 Is not lifee as tDbcrcilatin too JDS arc mingleotottbCDngUflj in a S)eclara» 
 tion , ano tbe toojos being taben in tbe Cngliflj tonfttnction QjaU be unoct* 
 CodD to be cigbt bangings. i^o; is it material to ej:p:cffe of tobat tbe bang- 
 ings ace maoe « ]Bnt tbe great ooubt is, tsbetbec tbe too;Os be meant of 
 Ibangingsfojarmmojnot, ano 3 fuppofe tbe p cannot be meant of otbec 
 lbangings,tbe toojos being in €nsliib,ano not in!Latin toitb an Anglice, ano 
 31 beiisbc pon cannot 0)eto me anp tbtng elfe, tbat tbe toojos can bp com^ 
 mon intenomcnt iignifie. ludicium nifi. 2Cbe cafe to as again mobeo at a. 
 notbcr cap bp Latch, tobo urgeo tbat four pair of bangings are too jos inccrj 
 tain ; but if it bao been four fnits it bao bsn toeU, fo tijat bcre is a mtfapli^ 
 cation of toojos to erpjetfe tbe tbtng meant , ano be mfgbt as p^opeclp babe 
 faio a fnit of S^boes, oj a fuit of Conies. 3Cf one Tap be batb loQ a banging, 
 tbisisinccttainofttfelf, foj itistbcpjcoicamcnt of fuu$ anonotof fub- 
 ttance,fo}abangingisapoaure, ano tbe too ;o pair makes it mojeincer- 
 tain tban it toas toitbout it. Hales anf toerco, tbat it is certain cnougb, (9i 
 tbe toojD banging is afebbercfubSantibelp, ano not as a participle, ano 
 tbe common ufeoftbetoojo is onlp applicable to tbe bangings of a room, 
 ano tbe four pair fl)flll be unOcSooo cigbt bangings. Roll chief luftice , ^ 
 pairispjopetlptobenoneoftbctbings fo calleo, cannot bepjopcrlp ufeo 
 toitbont tbe otbcr i butpettbctoojosmapbealfounoetftmofo manp cou- 
 ple , ano bere pon cannot inteno tbe too jos to mean fo manp fuits of bang* 
 fngs, ano poumigbtbatjeefpjeffeo pour meaning bp fo manp pieces of 
 bangings, anotbetefoje it feems ooubtfull. lerroan luftice, ^crc tbe 
 toojos DO not eypjcCfe tbe number of tbe tbings, cstbepoo tobcn pon fag 
 a pah of £>)cen oj tbe libe. Nicliolat as lerman , Ask lullice, a pair is in- 
 certain, fo; tbat tjDo;o map be meant mo;e tban ttoo in number , as toben 
 pou fap a pair ofcaros, ano a pair of bangings in fome places is meant a 
 fuit of bangings. Roll chief luilice , 3f itbc fo, tbcn it is niojc inccrtain , 
 tbe too;o bangings map be gooo cnongb ; but bote can tbe nnmbec be 
 bnoton^ Curia adviiarevult. Afterwards the Court moved the Defeodanc 
 to fuffer che Piaintififto amend bis Declaration , and to plead anew , and to 
 coofent to a new (ryall. 
 
 A a a Askwith*
 
 362 Hill.i65i> 
 
 AskwithsCale. 
 HiU, i6j2.Banc,fop, 
 
 Muuon to T" ^c CCotut IraB inotjct) to quail) an joct of fecfafono matje at Durham 
 quiii. an vi- ± agatnft ^ tkwich, fo? not fct\3lng tljc o:fice of a Corttablc , oj fitiDfne 
 
 ^r^otsefu- anotfterablcpcrfonto rcttett)cplarcfojt<m, bcfng eleacD actojofns to 
 lift cuftom of ttjc place \tt)crc l)c Uias clcttcB to fcttjc. SCftc CErccptfon ta» 
 fecn tuas, tftat ft to not QjcUjcd tljat l)c u aa i Icttco at a Court llect, anc tiic 
 &erfi(on0!)a\)cnopoiBrrtocU£taConftablc. Roll chief luftice, ^e is a 
 
 By Law. Conftflblc clcttcD bp a bp.Haii-,^ it fg not nccefTarp tljereflioulD be anp otbcr 
 clcttfon tl)rnacco:Dtngtotl)c tuttom,ant)l)cmiittrct*e(nJ)fsttfrn, oj com 
 
 Cuftcni. tttbntc to t!)c cljargc fo j anot!)cr to fcrtc fo j !)f m, anb tbfs is a gooD cuftom 1 
 nfeo in manp places, ano 3; do fino one mp fclf in mp turn fn one place, ana 
 rtiahe no nfc of mp pjftflege to abofo ft. flnothct crceptfoji icao taken , 
 tbattbccomplafntmaoeoftbepartptoas, tbatftetooulD neftbet fcrbe tbe 
 office, nojtonttfbutefojanotbcrtofcrbeft.anotbe ojoer 13 onlp tbat Ijc 
 tcfufeb to contrf bute anb fo fo not U)arranteb bp tije tuttom , bp tobtcU be 
 tatb an deaf on to fcrtjc oj contribute. Qyafticd, nifi, &c. 
 
 Mill. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 Crcdior ex A ^?*'"o"^'' ^"S" ''J^^C'lt frtto Court ( bp 8 haheas corpus ) ont of tbc 
 aminfd upon "^^ Fleet to tbc fntcnt to turn bfm otcr totbc (Rartbalfca to cbrrgc l)im 
 o«h it his toftb m flctfon brc , tobercupon tbc crcottoj ioas cramfrtco upon W3 oat^ 
 «J<br;wcte lubetbcr tbe ocbt Irns real , foj tcbfc!) be furmtfco tic Ujouia b;in? ¥3 2ctf» 
 "*"• on, ansuponmalifnijoatbtbcrcof t^e J^jffo.itt Urns tnrnea obct accoj- 
 
 bfngip. Nota» 
 
 Smith againft Holyman. 
 
 Hill, 1652, Banc. fup. 
 
 A> reft of I % uias titoVcb fn arrrft of 3;ntcrrnTcnt itr an 0£tfon npon tbe f afc upon an 
 J^"jJ^e""^^J"'"lAnunipfK, anbCyccptfonstafeen. t. 2Ebat tlje SDefenBanta CbjfBfan 
 Fiife'tilgiin. name teas mfftaU en. ;9nD zip. Ebat tbe jurata itjao crroneoue, fojft 
 
 fapcioaplcaof ticpt,fnftcaOofaplcat)fDcbt, and the ludoemcnr was ar. 
 
 refied for dept writitn with a P. it no word/hough it found like debt written 
 
 with aB. 
 
 Cuftodes and Hovvell Gwin. 
 Hill. 16 jj. Banc, fop, 
 
 luafTcnitnc a- TTOwc'l Gwin iBSs bjoucbt to fljc IBar bctnfl contfctco fo^ fo:!pefn5! of a. 
 
 EJinftont XJltccD, ano leas Dcmamjeo inbat b? fO'ilo fap lobp BHwc-^ment 
 
 o.nva;.dof fljoniDiiotbcgfbenanafnftbfm. Boynron of (Tounccl toftb ff>e fJiffonet 
 
 '"^''^"^^ woticn tbe vCourt, tbatfn rcgaro tbere teas an fnfoimat^nn c»f p'^^rtrirp u?. 
 
 pcnofngberc agafnfftb' toftne(rc0,upo!i tnbofeEcllfmon)' ttclDfronertoas 
 
 fontfctco of tbc pcrfurr,ano that tbe ^Daffoncr cotb cnoeattour to m^ceeo 
 
 toit^ all tl)J fpcec tbat fo pofsfblc agafr.C tbein fn tWo tnfojmatfon, tbat tJje 
 
 luDorc^
 
 Hill. 1657! \ 36} 
 
 31ttpgcment map be ffapeo fn tftc mean time agafr.tt Ijfm. Roll chief lufticT 
 anfluereo, ff tljcp be founo gulUp of t:)C per jatp, tljep fljaU be puufOjcD; but 
 we will i^iveludgemcntsgaindyoor Clyen: in tl>e mean t:ir.e, wh clj was 
 done accordingly in thcfe words following, viz. you are convifted of forre- r j 
 , ing a deed, by putting 3 dead mans hand onto ic therefore the Court j^ives'ortoig/" 
 this iudgementagainft you, thatyou arc fined at a hundred pound, and fhall ' 
 Hand on the pillory tuo hours before il.e H«<!i dore, wtih a paper on ycur 
 head flicwmo the nature of your cffencf. Mfmorandum tl)epartpcnt off a 
 ccaD mans Ijait^. nno put a pen, ano a fcnl Ia it, ano fo figncB , ann fcalcD , 
 aiiDDcKbcrcDtljsoccaiilt^tijcocaDftano.anDftDojc t^jst tefatotlje oeco 
 fcalcDanoceUDcreo. 
 
 Mich. 1652 Banc. fup. 
 
 MR-. Lucy Fotherby teas bjoijg!;t U'do Cotirt to bt tarjiEO obcr fnfo tbc A PnTorer 
 i^jrOjalfca out of tbc ^ leet luUlj un tjitcnt to cljarge \)tt tolt!) an 0ct(: '""•'^<* «»"■• 
 on of Debt, ngafnlt tWa ft toaa urgco tbat Ojc toas a |3?(fonEr <n tbcFlecr, 
 commfttcD tbftbct bp an ojoct of tbc Court of Cbancerp, %Bat Roll chief p-ifoner 
 luftice anfujcreD, tbis c?i3ct fa notbtng to bfnOcr b:r turnfng obcr.tf 
 tbc Debt be rcaU, and fo upon proof that the debt was rea!lftiew;stur« 
 ned over* 
 
 Locky and Dumiloe. 
 
 Hill, idj i. Banc. fup. 
 
 Hi!l. i6^Q,toU 146 2, 
 
 't/^onarpftlalfcetDfct{na»eje(aionefirmar,tbccafEfeD out to be ttifs.^P"'^'' "'■ 
 ^ I.S.fcffcooflanOflfn^ecmahcsalcafeoffttoJ.D. atOfflfU, A. b/^'"*''^*' 
 pntotbc2i:enantatCSfUontofpoffcfofon,anD after tbc SCcnant at tISHfll inx.'""'" ' 
 entera, ano tahcs a Icafe at ^fU of btm tbat put \}Un out of poffcfefon , 
 tbc qucflfon tDa6,tobctbcr be fljoulQ bolD tbe lanu b-g tirtae of ftfs fitft Icafc, 
 ojbptfrtucofbfflfccono agreement. SUo tf;fg Roll chief luftice ra(D,ff 
 one make a Icalc at tMill to one, ano be be outteu, anu tbcn enter again ano wm, 
 tafeeanctacftate, tbc Mill is DctctmfncO; but a Oranger cannot oeter- Dctcrminjti- 
 mfne l)le CQatc tifttout W tonfcnt ; but bere be batb oetcrmfnco bfs firft °"- 
 <l5Qatc bp bfs neto contract toftb ti-,c DifTcffoj of ^Is ileffoj. ^nD be f <o, 
 ifiLfbcrp ano &rtQn be maoc upon one Acre 6t lanu fn tbc name of tioo 
 acres, it f0 gmo fo? botb tbc acres, fo> ft ts not ncccffarp tbat tbc partp 
 tbat gftics tbc IfVcrp fljonlo go to all tbc lanu mcntfonci) fn tbc dcbd of JFe. LWery and 
 offment. flnobcairo fafo, tbat ff SLcnant at MIfU cuts Dolrn a tree^**^"* 
 npon tbe lano , tob<tb be ^o\na at Mill, bp tbfa M be bat^i Detetmineb b(s 
 
 mnu 
 
 Drake and Drake. 
 
 HJ|I,i652,Banc. fcp, 
 
 DRakc b?0U5bt an 2L<Hon agafntt Drake foj tbcfc tooiOS, viz. Thou Aiuft of 
 haft preached lyes in the -ulpir; tbc piafntfffbcfng a matter of flrts, '"''p^ncnt 'n 
 ano Incumbent of a iftfng. Wad ham Windham bclD tbc toojus aafona. J^" '\**'"» '"^ 
 lle,becanfctbcpU!CrefpoUcnoftbcplafntfff fn rclatfon to bfspjofcfaf. ""' *- 
 
 a a a 2 on
 
 364 Hill. 16 52^. 
 
 fion, anDc(tcD oik Hinkescafe , tDl)erctI)ereioo;tDg fpohen of t^e plaintiC 
 bcfng a IBjafiet toctc bclD actionable , viz. Thou haft co«ned rac of a Pan» 
 ;ainD (foncfap to anotljcr, Thou haft poifoncd aman, 3lftbcmati bcocao, 
 tbctooj03arcactfoiiablc,altI)oucl) !)c Doe not fap t^at bcDfoit ludfuUp* 
 SCftc Court cntUncD ttjc toojoo arc attlonablc, bccaufe tftcp arc ftanonlonat 
 And the rule was ludicium nili, &c. 
 
 Hill. 1652. Sane, (up- 
 
 Woiion for a ^ 7 \ > AdhaiH Windham motett foj a Certiorari to temobe an C'nt)(tt- 
 r^i^msvc'an'" ^ V mcnt pjcfcttcD agaftlft Oiicfii Newgate. Rollchie/Iuftice, ^C 
 Eiid.anienc. UCO tljCtC fo J mtirDCt , auDfS OlItlairED tljcrcupon , pet tafee a Certiorari 
 
 torcmotietftc3Rcto?o, foj^fofactluas tljc ftabb<ng of a man, ano ttab« 
 r^ l^'-y. bfng is in its nature but fclonp , mn is not murtbcr, altljougb tbe partp can» 
 Muriiur. ,jQf ijg^^ jjjg Clcryp fo J ft , bp reafon of tbc Statute maoc bp fe<ng laracj 
 
 apjiift ^tabbing , elfc bp t^ic Common Jlaiu Ijc mlcu Ijalic Ijao It, 
 
 Afhworth and Sir Tho. Stanley. 
 
 Hill. 1652, Banc, fup^ 
 
 Ancftof T 7pona tilcrt){£tfr{tcn fo?tl)C plafntff fnan EJeftior/e firrax, %t toao 
 '"'R.'^'^""" V movcDln^irrcft of gtiogcmcnt , JEOat tl)E eicrtnterifBlalotobeof 
 'ii'^x ""^ tb;ceri3;irtiagcijoi2i:cncmcnts,anDa£r;oft, toftlcbasto tftc ^:ffua0e3 oj 
 Dimags- SCcnemcntafslnccrtafn. Roll chief Inrtlce, You move too foon,fOJ ft 
 Ejcftionc fir. map bc tftc pafutllf ■till rcleafc tijc oamagcsas to tftc spcffuagcs oj 2Cc« 
 nii«- ncment, ann talse tifs juDgcment onip fo j t!)c toft, ano tljc Action Ucs tocH 
 
 enougJj foj t^at,. 
 
 Hill. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 M-tionto 'ywifdenmoDca to tlffcbRrgC&fr Thomas Revel I attB otljcrs of tbclr re* 
 
 fcgnitan "$" cogntfaticcfl foa t{)c peace fn Ivljfcb thcp ircre boiino tbc laft Mich.ielmat 
 
 otihepcjcc. SCcrm, bccaufe vbe Affidavit uponu.bfcbtbcptnercbounoUjaa onlp totbffl 
 
 Effect , SEljat tftc p jofsciito; goes In fear of fjfa Iffe iu5ien ftc goes fiito fucfj 
 
 parcels of lano, lubcrcae fn ttntb tljofc lanfls are fctlcD upon Sir Thomas 
 
 Kevell bp Decree In Clisnccrp , anc the pjofecutcj bath alfo bjougbt 1 8 fe« 
 
 teral Sections agalnft the JEctiants of the lanDe , ano batb Dcclarco agalnft 
 
 none of tbcm, ar.o there are four />ffidavit« agafnft t\)Z firft Affidavit. 
 
 Green on tbe ot!;cr ftoe falD , that tftepartpfofn Court, anofaps be fsftfll 
 
 tn fear of his life , anD pjaps be map not be DlfcbargcD, 5i5ut bccaufe up. 
 
 Peace, onrcaofngtbc Affidavits ano cramfnfng tbc matter, ft appeareo to tbe 
 
 Court tbattbcp lucre bounD to tbc peace upon malfcc,anD foj tjepatlon, 
 
 they were difcharged. 
 
 Hill. i65Z. Banc. flip. 
 
 Bp Roll chief laff Ice, 2U li)ic\) toapg Of common rfgbt arc tobcrc^ 
 pafrcD bp tbc Jnbsbftanta of tont ?DarfKi fn tobfcb tbc toap Ifco, JBut 
 ffanv?art!sa!arperfonii,fU crchfc anp part of a iuap oz loaftcaD. 
 Jopnfng , b5 tijcrebi' taUcs upon \)im to repair tb3t tobfcb toas fo enclofco. 
 
 Maf. 
 
 Who ought to 
 icpjir High- 
 W5VS M Com- 
 won I'g^i.
 
 ti ill,i6$2, 1_3^5 
 
 rri 
 
 MalTeyand Auhryl 
 
 Hill» idj2,Banc»fup, 
 
 ' A i|i3ctfonof©cbttDa0bjotin^tuponan£)blfffatfonfoffanD to an SL* ji'^cmenr ia 
 
 ./\toarD: 2LbcSDefcnDantplcaDtDttiattt)cjatbltratoj0ma5e no aicatD; q!"[.""':" "* 
 
 2Cljci9a<ntfft0pUeatbattl)e iHlmpfrcmaDean atearDjSnn fcts U fojtt),ftJ,/jV'^"^" 
 
 anti afofgns tlie bjcacb , ano «pon tffuc jopnea, ano a tierofct fo; tJje plafn- w.rd. 
 
 tf f,3;t toas motco fn Sixtttt of jiioccment tbat tftc afof gnmcnt of t^. b jeacb 
 
 toa0 not gooB, fo? tfte fnccrtafntp of (t, foj t^e b?eatt) <0 afsfgnco upon but a 
 
 partoftbeatDaro; foMftebjeact^afsfgncofa, tftat tbc JDcfcnoant ItjotilD 
 
 paptbc iirrcars of tent cue attet tU ptircbafc of certafn lanos; ano ootb 
 
 not fljeiu toljat tl^efe Arrears are, IBtitRoIl chief luftice fa{o, SEfjat tN 
 
 InojDflfince the purchafe thereof fcem to mafectbfc certafn, yet flay till the 
 
 other raovcp, 0t anotl)Cr tap tbe cafe icaa moteD agafn, ano tl)c fame n- 
 
 ceptfon fnOftco upon bp Barry of tbe 3!nncr SDcmple icfco fo?mctlp inoljeo ft. 
 
 Hales belD t^e Crceptfon not gooo , anotbat tlje bjcacb Uiao tuell nfijigticD y 
 
 bccaufetbougbftfeemnnccrtafnofftfclf, pet ft relates to a (bing \3)W\i 
 
 niafecs ft cettafn ; SLs an aujaro foj one to Dclfbcr to anotbct all tbe goota 
 
 In fucb a &l)op iubfcb belongen to bfm.batb been belo to be gooo. 33ut Bar= 
 
 ryanftoerei), SDftat ft fs titterlp fncertafn , anutb ttftctefsnotUng fn tbc 
 
 ;atoarD tobfc^can mahe it ccitnfn, ano bcrc f0 a fouMolD frccrtaintp fn tbe 
 
 ^tcarD. I. 3It cannot be UnoU.n toljat tbefc atrcaro arc tbat are aioarDiD 
 
 to be pafD* zip. 31t appeato not ^p tbe 0toarD foj toijat lanua ti)efc atrers' 
 
 Be0 of rent atoarfieo to be pafa are Due , foj tfjcte ate no lanos mcntf oneo ^ 
 
 butonlptiBolcafe0oflanD. 3lp. 3t appears not bptoljont tbe actetages 
 
 ate one. 4lp, 3it appear© not to inborn tbe arrerages are cue. Roll chief 
 
 luflice , an tl)c matter f0 , tobctbct it appears tbat tbefc arreragrs of rent 
 
 alDaroeo to be paf o toerc fn qucttfon o^ no, anu f t fecrn© tbcp tcere, betanfe 
 
 tbe leafe anti tbe rent tbsrcupon refcrbeo arc both fn qucftfon ; but ft fs not 
 
 certafn tebat tbefc arrears of tent are, ano fo tbe partp tbat f0 atoaro- 
 
 co to pap tbem , cannot tell inbat fum of monpbe fs to pap. lerman 
 
 luftice fafo, be map hnoir,bctaufe be toas %cnmt of tbe lanD. Barry te= 
 
 plpED be cannot bnoVDlBben tbe pnrcbafciDasmaDc, ano tbe atbftrement 
 
 IstbattbepattpCbaUpap all tbe atrears Qnce tbe purcbafe. Cuna advifare 
 
 vult. ^t anotber Dap tbe cafe iBas agafn motico bp Barry , ana cpccptfons 
 
 taUcn tbat tb: b;eacb leas afclgneo upon a tbtng not fubmfttco unto , oi a* 
 
 iDarbcD to be petfo^meo. 0nD fcconolp. 2Dbc aioaro fs fncertafn fn 
 
 wanp tbf ngo. JFfrft, 31 appears not tobat rent toa0 one to be pafo , but 
 
 onlp bp fmplfcatfon,tDbicbf3not gooo. feeconolp, 3it appears not foj^ 
 
 tobat tbe rent f0 Due; no^ jlp. l^olo mucb rent fs Due, ano Sal mons cafe, fn 
 
 tbe s . rep. teas cfteo. ^Ifo ft teas objccteo tbat tbe atoarfi toas not finall , 
 
 ano concluDf ng , ano tbercfoje not gooo : atlfo the atoaro fs untcafonaOle, 
 
 ano foj tbat caufc atfo ft fs not goon , anu be tftcb 2 1 E. 4. f. 40. ano 1 7 E, 
 
 4.^,51. anopiapcDfojtbc ©efenoant tbat juugement mfgbt be ftapco. 
 
 Hales on tbe otbct fine pjapcD foj fuDgcmcnt . 5 fftfo, SEbat the ^rbfttatoja 
 
 fticrc not to a^ccrtafn partfrularlp the rcHt to be pafo, but ft fs fufficfcnt for 
 
 ibcmtomahetbeauarDtoucbfHffalltbccfffcrciiccs bcttoirt tljc partfcs, 
 
 anDanatcrmentmaparccrtafntbcpartfculattbfnns, bcfngtirep arc onljj 
 
 matters of fart , altbougb one map not be aomfttctj bj'an at?cfm«iu to fap"- 
 
 plpanfltoatDfnamattct, tobcrcfn ft Iras fn tbe fnbltancc of ft Dcfcafi'c 
 
 fcefoje. Roll chief luflicc, ^bat ccrtafiitp is tbcte bj> tbe avunro that tbe 
 
 pattr>'
 
 366 .__ Hill. 16 ^1. 
 
 partpfljanenjopaHWarigfttffi tb^ tiro Untes (tt oiffsrcntc bettneen tlje 
 partfC0:' fojtbepapmentoftbcrcnt.lBotbparttcobnotD tebatrcnt fa Due , 
 rcfcrtcDbPtbclcafcs, b:it Ijoiti tan tlicpari)'';.notD irtat t^e arrears arc 
 Awaid. lubfcb arc accretoeo finte tbcpurcbafet" foj {join cm \)z Unoto luljen tftc ptir- 
 tbafc toaa maoc :> ioi ft fa maoe bp a ttrangcr, ano Vtfjat If tl)c ftrangcr icfll 
 not tell t)fm uften t)c maoe ft :• fo tljat mc tljfahs tljc fli-oaro fs nnteafona. 
 ble, anottjcn ft cannot be sooD. The rule was. Nil capiat per iiillam» 
 Nrfi , &c. 
 
 liil). 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 Qutfton in n \$^ qucttton bcfrtg upon a motion fn ^rrctt of juBgcmrnt fn an ^afott 
 Arrcd < ( bjoug^t foj moncp pai3 upon a IBfU of C-rc^angc bjou?l)t bp a Ui?ong 
 
 luJp'mrnrirpgjron , fo to!)om tftc i5ill bcloncrco Hot , anD a fccrofft foj ti)c Defendant, 
 fn a B p" f'^ Twifden faf3 , Eftat ff monzp be pafo to a totong psrfon upon a 3!Bfll of ©r* 
 cxciurgc. cliangc , f f tfte iDjong pcrfon do fljctu tl)2.5!3f ll , bp tfjc CuCom of fperc!)ants 
 
 tlife fs a gooo papmcnt, an^ tfte partp tbat pafo ft fljn'a not be c!).ugeo aaaf.-?, 
 Ctftom W:Id , 3tf3DotibtfulllBl)Ct!)ert!)cCiiCombcfoo?not- 5i5.it Roll chief /u- 
 
 ftice fafo , Ijere is a iJCtDfrt foj tljc CuOom, ano tljcrefoje ft tucrc IdcU ff tte 
 
 pattfco tooulB agrcetoanctDtrpal, butiftbrpVcf Knot, take your judge- 
 
 menr, becaufe the verdid hath fotind it a good cuftom. 
 
 CuRodes againft the Inhabitants of Stcneham 
 in Suffolk. 
 
 Hill, 1 65 2, Banc, fup. 
 
 Mtion tofetHf ^2 3:nl)abftant0o^tftcparfa) of Stcneham fn Suffolk tocrc fnufdei) fo> 
 
 a fi.e nron a tiot rcpafrfttg a ?^fgl):tDap. ann a fecruftt founo agafnft tftcm. SLlje 
 
 coi.viftion f iCcurtfcas moDco tbat a gooo fine map b: fct upon tftem , becaufe tijc toap 
 
 i.-r 'fp^ir :f fgnptpcta^cnoeo, ano a SEratcUcr tbat paffco tftat toap fjatfi loft Ijfa 
 
 ' ^" ""'"• bojfe ante tljc Surpal, bp rcafon tijc leap voas fo b30,ro tljat tbe ?^o?.fe b jabe 
 
 Ws iLcg. Twifden on ttje otftct Boe motjeo tlje fine mfg^t be rcfpftcD , be« 
 
 caufetbcrc Vcasa contett brttoeen tUfJ parfQjamsniiotbcrlDljfcfjoft&eni 
 
 onnfjt of rfgftt to repafr tlje Uiap, ano f n rcgaro tof3 parlft) in bcrp poo j , ano 
 
 laSlp, becaufe tbe i^ap cannot be amenoco until Summer, ano tl)cn ft (ball 
 
 be Done, Roll chief luftice , 2tf)c fine fljall be fct upon pou foj not repaft- 
 
 fng it alreacp , becaufe the tjcrDia founo pou ougl)t to do it, ano t&e Coun- 
 
 1 ft . *^^' ^^^^"^^ '^P P""^ neglect , Therefore take a Diftringas to levy a fine of 
 
 "M'* twenty pounds of tbe Parifhioners for not repairing it. 
 
 Hill. 1651. Banc, flip; 
 
 ^ r ^ 7 Ild mot«eB tbe Court tljat papfng cotts tl)c plaintiff migbt .fjate a 
 
 fhcTiain-'if ^ ^ rule to oifcontiniretfs Miction, becaufe there ieifncb a traticrsno\D 
 
 Ind.rco'n.i..uftafeeittbattb2titleoftb2lano in qucftlon can ncDcr come to be Difputco. 
 
 iiis Afloii, Roll chief Iurtice,33oa mapDotbfsbptbccourfeoftbc Court toitljout mo» 
 
 tfon. tbercfoie luhp mol'c pou fo? it:* IBM ? conccfbc pour rea'on fs , b^- 
 
 taafett-.erefgappremptojprulc of Court upon pou to trp tlje caufe tbfts 
 
 mxt SCerm, ano note pou mote to aljofo lb- contempt pou map fall fnto , 
 
 €on;tn-p!. fojDffohcpfngtLattule.ffpoulboulDnotgotoatrpal. Yet pay good cofts 
 
 and difcoDtinueyour Ad.on. Q.. Nota. 
 
 Hill,
 
 Hill. 1652. }6l 
 
 Hill- 1651- Banc fup. 
 
 Tf^cCoutttoasmolJcDtl^ataiFcmetbattDafl fucn onlp a« an <j)cecti-M.tion.h« 
 txix mtgfttfaecfftbargcDppon puttfng <n Common J5aH. Roll cbief common b.ii 
 lattice. It i» thccommon courfe if there be no fpecial caufe of ASion againft ""'R'^' ^' "" 
 an Execntor, as a Devaftivic, or tbe like, for Common Bail to be ad-"'"'^'** 
 niiiccdt 
 
 Hill. 1652- Bancfup. 
 
 HO Jfden £i)ne of tlje fltto jncpe of tfefs Cotirt , Uws togctfjet tmtb ano- p , , 
 tijct maoc a ILcffeefn an ©jtrtment iLeafe , ana toonlo not grant anpa'rUr"c'"* 
 imparlance to tljc SDcfennant, as tbe tifual courfe fa , bccaafe be is an at- 
 to;nep of tl)<s <Dontt , anuroclatmsbtop^ftflege, tbattbeSD:fEnDantmapp . ., 
 anfUjerWmtbfetcrm, o; elfc be tottt enter )uBjemcnt acafnft btm foj '"^"^'■• 
 loantofaplca. Q.> what was done hereupon* 
 
 Hill. 1652. Bancfup. • 
 
 Ij^tbe cafe ofoneHofftbcCoHrt teas motJCD to confirm a rtile maue be- Motion to 
 ttDcentbc pafntffsattojncpanotbe^DefcnDanta, foja arpal at tbeconS.m* • 
 35ac. Roll chief luftice, let <t be fo, fojfftbe attojnepa agree to rea»'"'«- 
 fonabletbfngs, toe tof II not oppofe t^cm , But the Attorneys ought not toj^^ip 
 make rules of themfdvcs. 
 
 Hill. i652.Bancfup. 
 
 BOynton moDcD foj a SDeerftealer tbat toaa contttfca at tlje fecfaions in Exceptions re 
 London upon an Cnofttmcnt pjefcrreu agafnft bfm upon t^,lateaitar<:tofnot« 
 maDcagafnftftealfngofJDeer, ano rcmobcD bother bp a Habeas Corpa$,^^^''««Cor- 
 tbat;tbe URctojn migbt be filen , ano took tbla CErception , .viz, 2Cbat ft ap. ?"'• 
 pears not <n tubat )DariQ) tbc offence loas committeo , as ft oagbt to ooe. 
 Roil chief luRice , l^erc is a contjfction ano a juogement fn tbe Cafe , ano 
 tbepartpfofnCjcKPtlon, ano tbcrefoje bjfng pout tojft of C^nojfft^c 
 jnogementbeetronfona, fojioeUifllnotobrrtbJoto ft foj a fanlt fn tbe 
 letojn of tbe Habeas Corpus : JBat becaufc ft Dfo appear to tbe Conrt tbat 
 tbepartptDascontfdeobebfnobfabacU, tl^p mo1)eD tbe Conncel toaotoffc 
 ofatoapbotDbemapcomctoafafrtrpalfoj tbe fattefartfon of tbe partp,^"^"^. 
 ano of tbe people; JFojItfaabatDcafe, ano let t^e S^nxQidl tabe ftfmfn 
 tbe mean time, AndwewilUlfoadvire. 
 
 Hill i6j2Banc- fup- 
 
 BY Roll chief luflice. If a fum of money be to be levied upon aCorporati'* 
 on , it may be levied upon the Maior or chief Magillrate , or upon any ""l** f "'] '* 
 perfonbeinga Member of tlK Corporation. Thiswat/pokcnin the Cafe of u'.on a'car 
 cheTownofCoIchefterinEflex. Nota, poraiion. 
 
 HilU
 
 368 Mc)n. 1653. 
 
 Hill. 1652. Bancfup. 
 
 JhTrift- to''rc- T ^^ '^""^^ ^^^ '""^^^ ^^"' ^ ©bctff mfgljt be ojucrcD to rctojn a ZMxlt 
 turn'hiswr'it" uponapatri. 16 Jt RoU chief luitice ailflDCrCD, let him return it, Lutnoc 
 I'ain. ' upon a pair,bccauft l)crc <3 tio Affidavit to pjotjc tftat bc rcftifcD to return ft; 
 Affiiavit. but onlp tl)c fuagcttion ofttjcCouncelattbelBar, 
 
 Siigeftioii. 
 
 Hill. 1652. C.B. 
 
 bfm ftarmUCTi;, be mar DcEcnOttc title, tftfOvIouTttDiU grant (t; but \r<U 
 notcompclltf) piatiitfif toconfclTctljeleafc.cntrp, anoouficr, crcept l)c 
 IdUI be etcfloj bf mfelf ; 31Bnt (t ia not fo in tbe Court of tbc upper JScntb , 
 foj tftere In bot^ cafca ttjcp laiU compel! Wm to confeffc leafc , cntrp, ano 
 OUttCt. Bu: Q.. for I have not kaovvn it fo ruled. 
 • 
 
 HiiI.l652.BaHC.rup. 
 
 Ord«of A ifsojcctof&efsfoitflmaoeat AronJelUn Suriexfoj papfng fo murb 
 
 bdiioni .z\monepU)CcUlptoaparfft),totD3cDsj tl)3 bccptngofa 315aftarD CI)<lo, 
 
 quiihcd, jnag quafljeo, bccaufc tt ofo not appear bp tbe ojocr , that the CtiUo toaa 
 
 bo;n (n t&at parffb to tol)ltt) tf)C moni' toag aUiaroco tabc pa<D, 
 
 Hill. 1652. Banc. fup. 
 
 Mo • T ^"^ Court to5s motjcD to uf ftl)arge tbc plea of not taUfng t^c engage- 
 
 c!;rcharec°th> mcn^,pleaoe3 to a feolofet fn ttjc ^tatcgfcrtfccfn Ireland, upon a tet- 
 
 piea of en- tlfitatc unoer tlje banc ano fcal of an officer i\\ tbe armp tbere, unoct irbofe 
 
 gjjiemcnt. commano be tDa§, tbat be ban taken ft, ano alfo upon a ccrtfficate unoer mp 
 
 Ccrcificjce. Lord General Cromwells banO , anDCoronel WhaieysbanO, tbat tbcp DfD 
 
 bclfetjctl'.cotber certificate irao true. Roll chief luftice anftocreo, we 
 
 cannot help you, for our hands arc tyed op by the Ad, ft om which we muft 
 
 notvary» Nota, 
 
 Hill. 1652. Bancfup. 
 
 Whether one "D O" chief luftice fafo, tbat fec Doubtec iubctber ouc cntideo of pcrjurp 
 endaedof Xv map be batlco , altl)ounbtl)e clarkc o' fbc criminal Coe faio be 
 
 perjufybs ntfobt. Q, 
 bailable. 
 
 Bright well and Robfoi\ 
 
 ' fafch. iCjj.Banc. fup, 
 
 Arrcft of 
 
 judgement in \ j|i Slciion opon tbc catc 1083 bjougbt fo; DeUbetfng fn a falfe note of 
 an Afiionup. jf\gooDP, fo^ Ichfrf) crcifc 1033 1 be pafo frtto tftc officc of crtffe, lubere- 
 on tiK cafe, jjp ^ J «j,gg compelleo to pap 50 1, to bfa Damage, &c, upon not gnflt ji pUaocB 
 
 ant>
 
 anc a ^crcfrf fo: tl)c plafntfff. Green mobw fn attett 0' S'.iorrcmcnt, be- 
 
 caufetbattl)eS?.clarat(onDtDnotfctfo;tbtl)c ^a of |9<ir.f nment , itWcb 
 
 g<tesaiitl)o;ttptotbcc6mmir6foncrflofcrttfe. arojip. 2i:t)c Damage ta 
 
 not coupleo tcUb tbe rratio,no j is it cjjppcffeD bote \)c toaa compclleo to pap • 
 
 tljc 3 o 1, anD tl)e Court is not bounti to talic notice of tbc £)iDinance of lpar« 
 
 liament toucWngt^: ofec:tJ of tijc ejcifc, bicaufc it is rot a general lato. 
 
 JBut Roll chief luftice ani Voer^o, tbat tfte frauo io t'jc grouno of tbe iSctton , 
 
 ann all t^c otf)er matter fct fojtb in tl)c SDcclaratton is but matter of tn* 
 
 Butementto tfte action, ano it is notrcqtiiBtc to be fo punctual in tetting 
 
 tftat fo?tl) aa is furmireD, ano toe arcbouiiDto taUe notice of tbc £):l)i- '""^"""^"^ 
 
 nancc,anDtbejaaionbjougbti3to recover eamagcecaufeobp tlje frano,^"""- '■ 
 
 anuitianomojenccetfarpto fct fojtb au tiiz circumftances occurring in 
 
 acting of tbc frauo. tban fo;i one to fet fo?tb aD pjoceEfca in an ;3ction groun^ 
 
 jjeDnponafrauouientSlnogcmcntobtcpneo againft bim, bptoljictj be ia 
 
 ©amnifiCD. ludtcium nifi, ^c. pro queren;e» 
 
 B 
 
 Pafch. 1653. Banc. fup. 
 
 P Roll chief luftice, 3f one t^itis bouno to tijc ^eace 00 beak J"*^b^,"' 
 bis rccognifancc, be map be cnoictCD upon it.fo; tbia it a ncto ihe Peace 
 offence, 
 
 Pafc. 1653. Banc (up. 
 
 'T^'e Court toao motjeo upon an Affidavit to oifcbatge a pjifonet Motion to 
 ^ bjougljt to tbc 3iBar bp a habeas corpus, bccanfc be inae artcttco on tbc^''5^*'^6'= 
 ^abbatboap. Roll chief luftice, plead this matter to his Adion.that at* " 
 refted you, for we cannot difchirge you upon an alfidavit, 
 
 Cuftodes and Rickaby. 
 
 Pafch 1 65 J. Banc. fup. 
 
 ion CO difi 
 I'ri- 
 
 B IckabycontjictcD Of j^clonpfo J billing a man During tbe tears, ant>wo,io„, 
 bjougbtbitbcrbpahabeascorpuf;mo\3CDbpbiflcoanccllto be Diftbat- chiri^e a . 
 geo upon tbe Set of tbe late general paroon. Roll chief iQftice,3lt appears fontr upon 
 not to U8, tobctber pou are ejccpteo out of it j no. But enter your furmi fe '^^ Rcnerai 
 upon the Roll by the advice of your councell as you will ftand to "^ su,nrfc 
 Poftea. 
 
 B 
 
 Pafch. 16 5 3. Banc. fup. 
 
 p Roll chief luftice, £)ne cannot anftocc foj. an infant as.©uarDfan , who w»y aat 
 either in tbe Cbancerp o; in anp other Court, except be be asigneb ["{"^"gs*" 
 ' oruatoian bp tbe Court, foj if he might that toer c to make bimfelf bis Gwidian. 
 <!Dnaroian, ano that might p:iobe to the Damage of the infant, therefore if Motion. ' 
 oneteiU fuean^nfant.hemuftmotjetbeCoutttoafsign a 0uarDian that p^"***''" '•"T 
 map anftoct foj b<«n ; IBtit an infant map fue per prochcin amy,tljougb Us '"^ "• 
 prochcia amy cannot anftoer fo} bint. 
 
 Sbb • Pafch;
 
 ^7o Pafch.i653._ [ 
 
 Pafcfii 1653. ©anc. fup. 
 
 wbomay bepjjRoncliic'Iaftice, flUftougl) tipoii 8 SErpal, one IdIjo f6 a legatee 
 awitncHt. ^bpa CQUlmapnotbcaomittEDfoj a Ujitncffe to pjoUc tbat toill, ret 
 tieiitap becramfncDnflatoitnetstopjotc a dccd o% other tt)fng , iDljfclj 
 tjatti not relation ta t^e totll, (n refpect of tljc f ntcrcft iDl)f£l) be clatmc fap t^c 
 ^ill. 0nDl)ctt}cnairofdD, t^atDccDoVDcrefnroUco at tftc Common 
 toroiiment. |Lato,fo> tbepjclcrtjatton Of tljem, altbongt) not to pafa anp cflatc, as it 
 tflnotDbptbc&tattrtcofCEntolmcntsmaDc, 4H.7, 
 
 Pafch. 1653. Banc, fup; 
 
 How aJifici nj9 Roll chief Tuflicc, 3f one Diffef feme , anB a fetranger enter upon tljc 
 finis taken ^-'oifrttfo; fo; me , tl)ts CBntrp tabes atoap tfje offfeffin ; ano (fa Copp^ol- 
 e""iv ocrofafe.ino;cntcra3aCommoncr, ittstarigbtoftbc iLo^D, alttiougb 
 
 (t be not bp Ijfa f ommano , no; l)c tiabc anp notice of it. Nota 
 
 Pafch. 1653. Banc. fup. 
 
 Ar.cft of A iR miction tnas bjougbt foj not papfng monfes upon tbc reccfpt of a bill 
 
 iu<iptiticn i < t\ of crcljange atco;Dfng to t^: cuftom of cpcrcbanta , ano upon a berolct 
 
 an Aa no 10 foimo foi the plaintiff it b^as motoeo in arrcft of Suogemcnt , ano tbc ex* 
 
 noa uayiiiR ccptioH tahen liias , that it appears not tobctbcr the ocmano of the jnonp 
 
 II^'*^^^ J;'^'rfueofojtDagacco?DingtothcolDftilc,ojafco?cingto the neU), ano fo it 
 
 ciun^e. is inccrtain tohethcr tbe monp iuas Due, tnhen it uas oemanoeD 0? no , foj 
 
 "' if it toerc DvmanocD acco jDing to t'.ic ntto ftilc it teas not one; but if atcoj» 
 
 Ding to the olo ftflc then it toao Due fo; the ncto Cilc is i o. oapcs bcfojc the 
 
 olo Twifdcn anflDcrcD, it (L)a\\ be acromptco accoioing to the olo ftile, foj 
 
 that is ulEO here in England , ano hJfaiD> If there be ttoo f^crthants t!)at 
 
 hateajopnttraoe, anuonc ofth:macccptabillof(lErchatigc,if be do not 
 
 papit, an Action IpecagainC the other. Roll chief lulhce, 3[f the bill of 
 
 D A (Exchange be acccptcD there is no neccfsitp to allege a ocmanD,anD the Dc« 
 
 '""*" * manD here is not laiD as part of the cuftom, upon tohicMhcjaaton is foun- 
 
 teO, ihercforeletthePlaiotiff liave liisludgtmenc, 
 
 ilerbertanc3 Lane 
 
 
 
 Pafch, 1653, Banc, fup. 
 
 An a of T T Erbert a Cartpct b?ought an anion upon the cafe againft Lane ait 
 
 lid.rmenr i iJTlBnn Uccpcr, fOJgOODsloftoutofthcJnn, viz. certain pack* full oflis 
 
 an Aai.,r. u,' „£„ cloatb and other goods, anD after a bcrcitt fo; the plaintiff (t teas mo= 
 
 01. u.e c;fc. ^j.^ ^„ ajjgjt 0f 3inogcment,that it Dotb not appear bp the 2Declaration,tobat 
 
 fojtof cloathteas inthepacUs.no; of Irhat Dalue the cloatljano gooos lucre, 
 
 r,no fo the SDeclaration is incertain. 3i5'.rt Roil chief lufticeanflDcteD, that 
 
 th: SDeclaration is gooD e!ioug&/Cfpcciallpnotot5crebcinga\?etDktln 
 
 the cafe. 
 
 Hill.
 
 ____^ Pafeh. i6 5 3^_ 371_ 
 
 Palch. 1653, Bane. fup. 
 
 B33 Roll chief luftice, % Certiorari to temoDc a IReto JD ougljf not to be where 1 c«r. 
 matte bat to a hnolDn £)fficer teboJs tjnoiun to babe tbe tuttoop of He. '"^ r; '"^^ 
 toii!0 ant) apon a furmffe tbat be batb fucb a IRecojD fn bfs bano ; ano^j; ^""'* 
 tberefoiC We wiil not upon an iSfftOatft grant a Cettiojarf , but upon a fur- Affidavit. 
 mife made upoa tbe Roll, Surmifc. 
 
 Pafch. 1653. Banc fup. 
 
 C£)ant ArnndcianO mp 3lo}b Chandois, totobott! Count Arundel faaa^^*'lj^'^"'='* 
 feconD fn a Duel being fojmcrip cnofctetj at Surrey 0rsijC0 bcfo?c flay^hter. 
 luftice A^k % luflice Warburton foj tUUfng Mr. Hen, Ccraptor,i founo gntltp 
 onlp of jpanflaucbter , bptbegtanDHnqucfttDerebjouebttolDatto beat* 
 tafgnen fo j ft , ano toerc not aumfttca to be baflco , but toere bclibercD h-. 
 Dct to tbe ^atftal to be bjougbt again at anotbet Dap , Nota. 
 
 Pafch. 1653 Banc. fup. 
 
 IOhnWeek?tDbobao been enbfctcD ano conbfcteo upon tbe statute of PirJonai 
 feing/aines maoeagajnftftabbfng, faefngfojmerlp bjougbt totbfaiBat '"we*!. 
 tfD pleaD tbe general paroon tDb<cb be bao fueo fojtb,anD p:apcD It mtgbt be 
 aUoiuED; 5i5ut tbcn tbe Court faio tbcp Uncfa? not iobetber be toere erteptco 
 out of tbe general paroon 0? not, anD jDcreo bf m to enter bia abcrment up- 
 ontbclkoll, tbatbeisnotcrccptcD, ano tben to appear agafn at anotbet Surmiic en- 
 oap ; attoblcb time be toas b?ongbt agafn , anDtbenbe oeclareo be bao en< c^cd. 
 trcD bfs abcrment, ano p?.oDnccD bfa parDon, ano pjapeo ft mfgbt be aUoio* 
 CD, which after a grave admonition made to him by ^J. 3!uttfce3l8rmani 
 exhortJnghim to repentance and amendment of life, was done, 
 
 Harris and Tookeri 
 
 Pafch, i5j 3, Banc, fop, 
 
 H Arris fajougbt an 3(tfon upon the Cafe agafnft looker foj turning of Arrcflcf 
 an olD mater.courfe from bt0 spill to a fpfU tobicb tbe SDcfcnoant bao |„''|'<{y^'"'J" 
 latclpereficD, auD obtains a acrolct. SEbc Di-'fcnoant motes {\\ iJneft " thc'T-X 
 of JiuDgement, i. 25ccaafeit appears not bp tbeSDeclaratton tobat cCtate tbe 
 paintlf batb in tbe jpfB , fo j be onlp fapa tbat be batb been teifcD of ft. dp. 
 3tisnotfljctoeDfro.nvDbencctbc toaterruna, as it fljoulo be. 3lp. 2Cbe 
 creflf ng of tbe ncto cpiU is not aaionable , but tbe Dfberting of tbe toater to 
 ftiQ Damage, anD tb-rcfoje ougtt not to be Jumbleo togetbcr. Roll chief ^'^*- 
 luftice, St is a Damage to turn tbetoaterontofita antfent conrfc, ano ft 
 Is not nccouill to fap tbat there is a neto £t3fU erccteo. JBut inbat fap pon 
 to tbefirtt Grception , viz.SCbat pou babe not tbetoco tobat cttatc pou babe 
 fntbeSpfll. WildanftoereD,tbepbaD(bctoeDit. Roll chief iuftic'e. Be it 
 foot not the Aftionliei, for what efhtc foever he hath an AiSion of the 
 Cafe will lie, therefore take yoar ladgement. 
 
 JBbb 2 Pafch,
 
 37 2^ Trin. 1 653. 
 
 Pafch* 1653. Banc- (up. 
 
 fn7Man!"'"^ \/f Eraoranduro , This day by Rule o\ Court my Lord .C^janUofa and 
 flaiighter. XVI Count SiruntJcl were ajzain brought to the Bir and arraigned for Man» 
 flicghter. (IbanOofa as Principil, and 0tunDel as acceflary for kilh'ng ^.:» 
 J^enrp Compton in a duel» They coofeffcd the faft , and craved their Clergy 
 and Peerage by the Statute of I Ed. 6. But becaufc the Court doubteJ whe» 
 Clergy. ther the Statute was repealed or not , and in regard the priToncrs were not 
 willing to lie longer in prifon , the Court re.'ufing to bail them , becaufe the 
 faft was notorious , they waived their Peerage , and prayed their Clergy as 
 Commoners of CEngland ; Whereupon the Ordinary was called, who ap- 
 peared , and brought hit Book, which was a fair Latine Pfalter. TheCourc 
 called for the Book , and feeing it to be Latin , commanded him to bring an 
 Englifti Book, which he did. Bat becmfe the Officer was not provided who 
 ftiould have burned the Prifoncrs in the hand, the Court would not then hear 
 them read though the prifoners urged it ; But they were ordered tobeftili 
 in Cuftody till another day , and then to be brought again. 
 
 Trin- 16 5 3' Banc- fup- 
 
 Motion for a *T^wifden motjDi) foja reference to Hem t^e &cconDarp , anu pat tijc 
 
 Jh'"seco7 •'■ cafetobct()<0. 3 Sore facias tffueo fojtt» agafnil ejetntojg , ano 
 
 t^e e on "jije ^^grlfrcturns nulla bona : flfter, upon a fuppofal bp a teftatumj ttja: 
 
 the CErccutojo f)sQ toatteo the gooDs , a ncto fcire facias Mt\) a fieri facias in 
 
 the fame tDj<t <ffneD out, acco;Dingtot&cneU» toap ufcD, ano npon 2 ni- 
 
 chilsrcturneDa juogcmcnttDaaglticnagafnfttbem de bonis propriis, ano 
 
 Aud;tiqueretb'^P''i^f*^'' toerc jiBtcr fummoncD oj hao anp notice ofthcpjocceofnga. 
 
 la. Roll chief iuflicc, 3If poubcconoemneo upon *nichils rcturncii ; tuyere* 
 
 Reference, as pon inere neljer fmnmoneo, pou map help ponr f cities bp an Audita que» 
 
 rda, Bjcicisnoc to be helped upon a reference. 
 
 • 
 
 Trin. 1653. Banc. fup. 
 
 fT**'^ • A ^3"bjoagI)tan9(ltonoftf)CC9rc8gafnttonc fo; cauCng 5(m to be 
 
 J„^a'[;"[,!"/Acnt)tactjfo;CcaIfn5ofa£pare,anDhathatjerD(ct agafnft the Defem 
 
 on (he Ci'.e tJant. %t toas moticD in ^rreft of juDgcment, tftat upon pjefcrrfng of t^e 
 
 JBtUtothegraniSiurp, t^cpfottno an Ignoramus, anDfo there fearepng- 
 
 nancp fti the declaration , iDhith fets fo?tl) that tbe plalntff caafcD htm to 
 
 be enofctco , eno pet faps that an Ij^noramus toaa founo . fo that npon the 
 
 matter (t loao foimo no enotament. Wild on the other Hoc fato , tlje Oc» 
 
 claration fa tocU enough , anuthercfanorepugnancp , fojthc too;Dal6aH 
 
 bctahcnacco;tji'ngtot!)cco!nmonconftrij(tfon. Hiles, SLhctc fa anotl^ec 
 
 Crccptfon . VIZ. SEhat all the p:ocecDfnaa mcntfonco fn the Declaration are 
 
 erpjeffeo to be bcfo je the 3;uogcs aa Commffsfoncrs foj the ©aol oeUterp, 
 
 ano not aa Commf^sfoncra of Dper ano Eermfner. Roll chief luftice, 
 
 mt U)(U f ntcno that the Ciitititment inas bcfo je t'oem as guttfccs of £Dpcr 
 
 Erd;amcr.t. anoSCermfncc , ano fn truth ft fa not materfal befo?c tohat authojftp he 
 
 InaaenDfaeQ ; ano fnthfs cafe the trouble the partp fa pat onto bprcafon of 
 
 this enofctincnt, fa the caufc of hfs bjfngfng this ^fiton, ano not hf^SCrpal 
 
 ^^'' upon ft, anothcrefojcthe authoiftp fa not materfal; no; fa ft materfal 
 
 tDhetherthcenofctmentbcgooDojno, anothetooroa here are to be ton* 
 
 Crueo accojofng to common fntenom&nt , viz, JChat lie teas cnofaeo t^ongft 
 
 the
 
 Trin. 1553 
 
 
 tfte cnDftfntent teas not fonntt , btit an lgnor.imuj , ano fo bp confcqtiencc 
 fn Hato U (fl no CBnolctment upon Uiljfcli re cenlo be trppo to come fn Dan- 
 ger of ^iaUfe HaleimolJcotbatHjppmfgbtamenotfjc E>tc!aratfon , ano 
 
 go to a neto JCrpaK Roll chief Juftice, Ic would be good to do fo, for it Aincndmc 
 ii doubtfull how we (hall cake the matter as it ftaods before us upon the Re- *^"'* 
 
 corrf. 
 
 Trin. i653-Banc.fup^ 
 
 Til^e Contttuafl motjen foj an 0tfojncp of tbe Common |&lea0fbat teas Motion to ai- 
 fneb fn ti)<3 Court to alloU) bfs tojU of p:(^Ucge. 315ut Roll chief luftice ''""' •'^^ ^ttor- 
 WBWm plead his privilege, for wc cannot allow it upon a motion , and his '''>''P"^"gc 
 (hewing of his writ of privilege. mon pici"] 
 
 ■ Whitehead and Buckland 
 
 Trin, i^jj.Bancfup, 
 
 Hill»i6j2, rottitif 
 
 trX/Hiiehead bjougfetWs flrtfon of Ercfpafsagafntt Buckland fo? faKfng Demurrer to 
 ^ ^ ofTifa Cattel, 2Cljea)cfenDantplcaD0tbefefat.oflfmftatfon3of a.a'tpiicjtioa 
 fifonefnIBat, tbcjpiafntffreplpeottjat ftefncbfojtb an i©jfgfnal ioftWnl" Tr«fps6 
 tfte tfme Wmfteo fn tbe Statute-. %o tW repUcatfon t^e SDcfcnuant Demurs, ciuci "^ 
 ano fi)eb)0 foj canfe , i ♦ Cftat l&e fa(tt) be batb fucD out Us £) jfgfnal , bat 
 BOtft not fap pront patet per Recordura , as be ougbt to Do. alp, ^z Dot& 
 not pleaD tbe contfnnances upon tbe IRoU , Maynard anfioercD tbat tbe 
 plcaofngfflgooo, anDtse cannot talse a tratjctfe upon tbcft plea, tobfcb fs 
 rutplnfage , no; fa ft neceffarp fo j ns to Oicto f n our plea all tftc conttnuan' 
 ces ) bat to plcao fo mutb of tbe IRecojD onlp as goes fn 3Bar. Roll chief P'". 
 luflice , The plea is plain , and it is not neceflary to allege the continuances , 
 for here is an apparance, PoOca, 
 
 Sale and Wray. 
 
 Trin. 1653. ^anc.fup, 
 
 "1717 lid mobcD tbe Court tbat tbe SDcfcnbant fn an actfott of Cobcnant Motion that 
 ' ntfgbt be ruleo to fujear bfs plea , bccaufe ft fs a fo jefn ano oflato?p cHe Oefen- 
 |>leajplcaDCD to out tbfs Court of fts 3lurfstfttfon ano to bfnoer a Crpal-, fo j ^»"^ ■"'g'^t 
 $e pleaDs tbat be toas at Lisbon fn Portugal at tbe Dap of tbe papmcnt of tbe *^ '*" P'"' 
 tnoncptob<cbbcbaDtobcnantcDtopap. Roll chief luftice, pon map replp^ . 
 tbat be leas tn England , ano pou nccD not traberfe abfqut hoc tbat be toas '^'^p^ ""o"- 
 f n Portugal. JBut tbe queltfon f s , tobctber tbe plea be fojcfn, ano 3 am f Tra verfe, 
 opfnfon tbat ft fs fojefn , ano ought to be ftoojn. Howell anftocrcD , ft is 
 not fojcfn , fo J ft map be trpcD fn tbe Countp toberc tbe ilttfon fs bjougbt. ^'"« 
 Roll chief luftiee , Lee him fwear his ple« , except betcer matter be 
 (hewn* 
 
 iBbb^ Kicciiia:
 
 374 
 
 Tria.1653. 
 
 Areft<J< 
 j'jdfffncnt 
 an Aition'up 
 on ihc caff. 
 
 ,„v 
 
 £ndiftn)cnr. 
 
 VjriJncf. 
 
 CoaiHiiinicnt. 
 
 Aniendwcnt. 
 
 Kitchinman. 
 
 Trin". l653,Banc,fup, 
 
 pon a tacmict gftjcn fo j tljc pafntff tti an actfon of t^e (tafc bjotJgbt 
 fojpjcfcrrlnsjalBfU of CnDfctment of fclotip agafnff Wm. 3t toas 
 motict) tn flrrcfl of SuDgcnicnt , tbnt ft Vras not lafo in tl)C Dcclaratfon to 
 tc Done rainy, buttljat tbc 2tto?ncp oftbe plafntff ftatb fntcrUnco tl)8 
 tDo?Dulflytiitl)cPoftea. alp. StfanotfaiD ttiattfte Cnufrtment pjcfct- 
 rcDVx)a3litUt5CreDtotbcBranD3[ntp, but to tbc Court, Roll chief JuOice, 
 3it{0 fnfdtobcpicfcrreDmaliciofe, anD it cannot be malidofe fKc^pt it be 
 alfo falflp , ano bcrc is falOp crpjctlctj in tbe beginning of tftc 11pco3D,anD 
 it Is not n'-ccffarp to fap fo tbjongb tbc tcbole Hcfoju, foj tbe U30?Do 
 fnbfcquent are touplcD to tbc pjcceocnt : fllnD a JiSill of Cnoictmcnt is to be 
 Delibcreo to tbc Court , anD tbc grano 3iurp rccc(\3cs it from tbcncc, Iohn= 
 ion, Lancelot took anotbctC-jrccption ,viz. SCbat tbcrc is a variance be- 
 ttoccn tbc Venire anD tbe Diftringas, fOJ in tbC Venire one Of tbc Jurpis 
 tallEDCargcnter, anD in tbC Diftrineas Carpcnccr, Roll chief luftice. 
 Let it be ftayed for rhts fault , And let MlUIams the Sollicitor be committed 
 for enterlining tbe poftca j But upon a voluntary confeflion of the f d, and 
 fubmiilton, the Sollicitor was releafed , and only ordertd to pay the charge 
 for the motions in the Caufe , and tbe j^ottM wa$ ordered to be amended by 
 the Paper book. 
 
 Cuflodes and Troos. 
 
 Motion to 
 Itjy jddfic. 
 ment in i>ct- 
 
 jury. 
 
 Trin. 1653. Banc, fup, 
 
 n 1^2 Court tuas motcD to Cap 3fnDgcmcnt in an cSnDfftmcnf of pcrlnrp 
 ^ foun^agafnfl oncfojpErjtirptnanctioencccit'cnbpbim in an j9ctloii 
 ofSErotcranDCo.ilicrRon. %\)t Crccptfo.i tafectr iiias, t»-at tbe £)atlj 
 is not al3ctrcDto be mace concerning t^e matter in (ffnc in tbe action, 1 fo it 
 cannot be (ucb pet jarp, fo j inbicb an CnDiflment lies. Roil chief luftice , 
 38 tbe Cnofctmcnt grounocD upon tbe &tatiite , ojiott an Cncfctment at 
 tbe Common ILato e SLbc Countc) anftoeteo , 3t is an CnDictmcnt 
 framcD upon tbe fetatutc. Roll chief luflice, 2Li]cniti3 a material c);ccp- 
 tion , but if it baD bctn an CnDittmcnt at tbe Common Halu it looulo batie 
 been othcrtoife , fo; at tbC'Common iLato one map becnoiileDfoj a 
 falfe ilDatb in an Affidavit. Therefore let ludgementltay till thePlaintif 
 I: ove» 
 
 Cuftodes and Martin and Long 
 
 Trin, 1553, Banc, fup, 
 
 T'l^cConrt teas motif ft to fjnaCb ttoo CnDirtmcnfs agafnft Martin and 
 Long, ao ILojDs of tbe ipanoj of Clarkenweil fo; not repafrtng tbe 
 fetoclis anD Cdbipping pott , anD not making of a pounD. SEbc Grccptlon 
 da-re ti leas, t'jattbcmaJjingtbepounotoasnota publtquc tbing, anD tbcrefoje 
 '" ' '"^ ""■ anCnDiamcntlicsnotfojnotDcfnttit. R^'ll chief luilice , Stbat is true, 
 0nD be ttDb anotber Grception , SCftat tbe CEnoittment Dotb not fljcto t'jat 
 Martin and Long arc 3Lo JDS of tbe ilect; ^HDiftbcpbe but JLojDS of tbe 
 
 ^ano} 
 
 Endiftmcrt. 
 Perjury. 
 Fallc Oich, 
 
 Motion to 
 quad) two 
 tndiftmcnt, 
 
 Stocks 
 Wl'.ir'ping
 
 Trin. i^;^.^ y^^ 
 
 (pano?, anDnot3lo;Bsoft!iel.itt, tftcparcnct bounn cf rotrmon dgfct 
 torcpafrttje&tocfeoanD^WppIng pcft, ano tl5ircfo:c tlj: enctctmer.t 
 ntuafi)clo^oiDtl5cparcIjotinDtoDo{t, vu, cftfect 23 JlojcsofttlvJlcet^ 
 0; otljcrtcffe, o; cUc tljs patift <)5 boiinD to do tt. 
 
 Cufloiles and RickabyeJ <" , 
 
 Mich, &c. 1 65:. Banc, fop, 
 
 \j Pon an olD rule of ttifs Court , maoc fittljc begfnnfnsj of tofngCharli.Argumenr* 
 ' SLbc Court to smotjcB to ocUtocrtbcft opinion (ntl)c Cafe of Kickabym lucgc- 
 tbBtbaobccncnDitteijfojmurtlicr, anc tiao obtair.co bia paroon , tofjcttct "^"^ "'''ihef 
 tbc parcon Vsas goo3 anQ to be aUoVccQ, 0: tiiat be ftoulo be trpcD notVuftl)-,^,P*[^°" '^'„ 
 fianDtna bta paroon. Roll chief lulliccanflDcrco, 2E!]!9 Cafe teas arru^'^'ji'oUadr" 
 eo often at t^c JBar b Caroli , toljici) leas Ions agoc, ano faefojc our times, 
 therefor^ let us have books, and ar^ue ic ajjain , for we have vet (:C3rd no Ar- 
 jumencsin the Cafe, itt another Dap bptulc Of Court ttcCafc Voas again 
 motcD,anDarcucD bp Wadham Windham foj tl)c iacpcro, tf)at tbepars 
 Don toas not pood, no; ounjjt to be allotoee , brcaufc bp tlje parDon murtfjcc 
 inaonotparDoncD , ano in bis argument l)C maDe tijcfc cjucttionB , viz i, 
 ^bctijcrtbeiSingcoulD paroon murtbcrbptbe Common i,au'. 2. tabc= 
 tberljemig'tDoitbpttic LaroofOoo. 3. catjetbcrbcmisbtDoit bptbc 
 g>tatute. 4. ^Ubcttier rt)c parson be maoc gooD bp tl)C non obilance irclu< 
 DeDinit. i?ojtbcfirft, tbciitng ex Officio map parDon ipan-flaugbtcc 
 bptb: Common tato, ano in fomc cafes be migbt parDon mnrtbcr , viz. 
 tsabcrc tberc is but onlp malice implpeo m tbc i^urtbercr, but toilfuU mut« 
 tber be conlo not paroon , bctaufe it is againtt tbc ILato of Coo, anD be citCD 
 I 2 H, 8. f. 5. Brudtncll. 3Bp tbc laiO DelitocrCD to Noab, fljCOCiiig of blooD^ Gen.Ycr. 6. 
 luasmaDeuiiparDonablc, anDtbat{i5apcrpetualliato,fe>tat.i3 a. i.e. I, 
 SLbe )&tng map Delegate aDiminiQratton of BInftice to t)is ^iniftero, but not 
 Difpcnfation of mcrcp, 15p tbe fetatute of 1 3 R. 1. c 1 . K\)e iaing teas aD« 
 moniCbcD not to paroon murtbcr fo gcneraHp as be ufeo , but cnacteo, SIbat 
 ff in bis parsons be Dio not C)cp;c(re tbe too^o Murcher, tbe paroon IboulD 
 not beg 000, ano tbe \ro;D Murther is not crp^cGTco in tbis paroon, ano 
 tbcrcfo;citi6notgooD,no:tobcgUolDC3 ,-3 inftit. 236. 8 h. 6.20.9 H.d, 
 8. Kel. pt. j^ojDotb tbc iiing in tliis paroon recite tbc QJnoictment ft fclf. 
 fo; tbcn it map be tt migbt batje altcreo tbc Cafe , but onlp recites tbe fact 
 gcncrallp , ano tbougb tbe U;o:Dfl in tbc parDon be general, anD feem to in- 
 clnDemurtber, pet tbcp cannot make tbe parDon gooD, bccaufc it toants 
 tbe C);p;cf8toD;Ditfelf, viz. Marcher, anD altbougb tbc Cbartcr be not 
 t}oio , pet it cannot be allotocD fo; inant of that tDo;D , no; can ttje general 
 non obitante in tbe paroon oifpcnrc toitb tbe Statute of 13 R. j» fo; an non 
 obf^antes are goD onlp Vubere tbc l^ing takes notice of tbe !Lato tobcreUiitb 
 be Difpcnfitb. anD as to tbe statute of 1 3 R. 3. i^irtt , JBp it tbc )uC 
 potoer of tbe laing is maoe certain , mh ougbt to be Sridlp purfueo- 2!^. 
 SCbat Statute teas maDo of grace, anoasaboone, to tbc people, intobicb 
 tbep ba^c a fpccial intereft , ano is not to be abjisgeo. 5 Ip. St teas maoe 
 fo;tbcmo;efreeaDmini(trationof3;uSice, l;:ftb tcbfcb tbe lling map not 
 Difpcncc, Hob. t. 214. Here jLyfia-^scafc 1 1 Rep. f. 88. 3nD altbougb tb« 
 partpbcrcbcpzofccuteDattbcfuteoftbeiaing, pettbe pzofecution is fo; 
 t^ benefit of tbc people , ano tbeTefo;e tbc )&ing cannot paroon bim, 3 In(t. 
 f. 3;7.anDfobep;apeDtbeparDonmigbtnotbcallotDeD. Halet appoint- 
 CD bp tbc SuDgcs to acgac ad informandum confcienciam , as Windham alfo 
 toas, argtuD fo} Ric^aby, tW tbe parDon \j)sa to be aUotocD , fo; tbc qoe- 
 
 ftion
 
 Trin. 1653. 
 
 ff ion noto {a not iD^etljct tfte patDon be to be granteo ojno. 0nt» zip be 
 IjtlD t^at bcre (3 a 3000 non obftante in tbe parDon to Dif pence inftl) tbe &ta« 
 tMte , ano be arpea tbat murtber at tbe Common 3lam toao pardonable bp 
 otbev iDojDS, as iDcn as bp tbe iuo;o muttbcr, viz. bp tbe toojo i?clonp, 
 anobptbetoojo£Dtatbofamaii,fo;martberts but j?elonp (naWfiboe* 
 era, anO majus et minus nor, variant (pe iem, 4. rep. Ho. fords cafe , ailD t'je 
 Statute of 13 R, 3. ntaUea t!)<a deer, ano tbat Statute fa olfpcnlco 
 tnUb bp tbe non obftante. foi tbat Statute toaa (not maoc to offa* 
 blc tbe Itttng from paroontne murtbcr , but to Direct ano cnfojm 
 tbe litng , ^na toUb ttat tbe totng map offpcnce bp a non ob- 
 ftante, 16 11. ?.Tit. graunt5,34 &5 lac.in this Court, liakers cafe. 3ntt 
 bcrctaa ctfpcnfationbp tbe Statute cfR. 2. tbat tbiomap be faio a par- 
 toM at tbe Common iLalo, foj <t appcaro bp tbe too juo of tbe paroon , tbat 
 tbe IMaq. intenocD tberebi^i to b jcali tbjough tbe Statute, ano to parDon tbe 
 partp tubatctct 4)13 offence tDaff,fo J altbougb tbe non obftante do not eic= 
 pCc tb« toojD murtbcr, pet it is 0ood, fojtberc arc cnnfbaknt toojw to 
 muvt'jcr tn tbe paroon, fo j tbe non obftante to ofipcnce toftball. ^0 ii tbe 
 IfiiS grants a p.irDonnctto(ti.ftanDtng; tbe Statute of Rich. 2. 31tfg nc 
 ceffarp to be referrcD to tbat tlaufe tn tbe Statute, U'bfcb <3 to be Dlfpenfeo 
 tojtball , anD fo fo ft t;crc , foj tbcrefo no otbcr cnD foj tbe iftfng to Dffpcncc 
 toftb tbe Statute 0: R. 2. C. i j.but fo; tbfe claufc, ano befioes here fo a fpc- 
 cfal non obftante, ano not a general, anofoj autbojftpesbc cfteo Stamford 
 loi, pleas otthe Crown, 336. and for prefidents 3 1 Hliz. 4 lac. j lac. d lac. 
 anD manp otbcrs,anD fatD,tbat be founo none agafnft tbem.Roll chiefluftice, 
 ra etc It not fo: tbe pjeftocnto 3: bolo tbcrc Vuoulo be but Kttlc queftfon fn tbe 
 {afeibut fome of tbefc qucQfono bate been ocbatco in fomc time0,i[altboug^ 
 toe cannot (iticttion tbe ]ftfng fo^ granting ftitb parDon0,pet It (0 q'ueSfona- 
 blctobctbcr be map grant tbcmbp tbe ilato ofOoO; but tbe Iblng map 
 Do It In fome cafes, but here I0 a Statute tbat fapcs be (ball not do It, If be 
 Pardon, Donot takenotlceof tbe fact In bloparDou bptbenameofmurtbct.ano bere 
 tg no fucb crpjefslon, but tbe too:tD6 arc general ; If tbe Ifting parDon maturn 
 in fetoltb an non obftante It I0 not gooD ; But let us fee PrefidcntJ , and we 
 will advilc till the next Term. STbc ncrt ECcrm Roll chief luftice in tbc bc« 
 balf of blmfelf.ano tbe otbet Juogcs, oellucreo tbe opinion of tbc Court lit 
 tbi0 cafe to tb<0 effect, IQe arc all of one opinion, anD mp b^otbers babe 
 DcfirGDmctoOclltJcrtbercafong of tb lr0,anD mp opinion. J^lrtt 31 tolll 
 open tbe HccojDjtobicblncifcctlctblo, Rickaby toas cnDiaco at Durham 
 fo^murtbcr.ano tbc cnolrtmenttoaoremotcD Into tbIsCouttbp a certio- 
 rari, anD Rickaby bjougbt bitbcr bp a habeas corpus , anD being DemanDc» 
 tobat tie coulo fap foj blmfclf, iibp be fboulo not be aojuDgeo to Die, be plea- 
 DeD tbc parDon of tbc late tolng, ttblcb parDons tbc Deatb of Curtine In terp 
 general too^Ds ; but tb? parDon Dotb not c)rp;effe tbe toojti 
 murtbcr, anD in bis pica be mentions not tbc Statute of i o Ed. 3 , bp a non 
 obftante, anD t\)(<i I0 fct fo:tb fo? confirmation of bfs plea , anD tbc Statute 
 of 1 s R. i. ie allcgcD tottb a non obftante. SLbC cafe In b;lcf (0, Rickaby 
 ^i\ti otbcrs cnDlctcD fo^ Ullling G<;orge Curtine, anD bjougbt bitbcr pleaDs bl0 
 parDon, as is bcfo jc crpjcffeo. 2El)e quettlon I0, tobctber tbe paroon I0 to be 
 alloivcD ojnot : JEbis cafe batb been toellargucD, anD tbc lihe cafe toltb 
 tbl8 irao netjer calico Into qucfilon, j argucD before tbis, anD tbctcfoje If 
 toe (ball not alloto tbis parson noto ,toc bate better rcafon to mote ns to It 
 tban otbers babe bao to Do tbe contrarp, anD tbcrefo jc toe Qjall fcno blw ftT« 
 to tbc Conntrp to receive 3,utticc tberc foj bis offence, foj toe arc all of one 
 opinion, tbat tbe paroon Is not to be allotocD, anD tbat fo j tbefc reafon0, tbc 
 queftlon bere Is not tobetber tbe !&ing tolll paroon martbec; but Cook faftb, 
 tbe Mni toiil not paroon It, If be iinoto it to be muTtb;r; but tbc fird quettl^ 
 
 on
 
 ^ Triii,i6 53, 377^ 
 
 i)nf0,tDl)etl)prtl)Cl(iigcanfarDonmtitBcruftftoHt a non obftante. zip. 
 ?EIbrWtl>ccan°o<tuU^afpct<al.nonobaaQte. 3!?. ©aj^etfter ftc cart 
 patDon ttbptWs non obft ante <nt!}fB Charter of paroon. ^Ip. ^Jjetbec 
 Rickaby Ijat^plcaDEO tl)is non (.bftante,fo tba^ftc map tahc aDtiantagc of U. 
 jfojtbEfitttpotnttoeiJonotabfolutelp DffallotD tlie parooit; fant toe are 
 toerqufrc Uitj.tDet bctc be muttbct 031 not, ft t&cre be murtbcr, tbat it map 
 be oJfalloiBeD.otljcrtDffc ttat it map be allotoCD. %\)z fetatute laiua tocre 
 mane foj pjcfcitatfon of tbc publftjue peace , ano to tcttrafn patDons foj Miinber. 
 mattl3et,fotbat after t^emaWng of tbe S>tatntEB, martbet conlo not be 
 patooncD teUbout a non obOante fn tl e paroon, tbongO before ft mfgftt bate 
 been parooncofn general too^oeu Zm tbe |3arlfament bat& maoe oftets 
 statutes to rcttrafti parcons, ant) tbat martbet fljoiilD not be fo gene'rallp 
 parDoneDa6bcfo}e.2E.3.4E.^.i4E.5.27E.j.C,-,bptoblcb&tatptC0ftmap 
 appe«r,tbat tbc opfnfon me, tbat tbc Mm conlo not uffpence toftb tbe &ta» 
 tute0 toftb a non obftante, antt tbe cno of all tbcfc fotatntea tBas to enfo jm 
 tht iftfns to cramfne toljctbcr the faa b? fntenDeo to pajDon Ir a0 murtber , 
 anotbatbefbonlonotgrcTntapatoonfo; murtber, toftbont erpjefsfng tbe 
 toojD martber fn tbe parDon. ano tcft!) a non obftante alfo, 22 H, 7. jd^Nombftante. 
 Kelway. 8 H, 6, f. 20. 9 E. 4, f. 1 6. Cook, Pleat of the Crown 2 26, anO fo Difpenfaii'^n. 
 tbe iLatofstoitbont a non obftante. ilp. tEIbctbcr tte ISftigcanparooti 
 murtber toftb a non obftante, toibcre tbe toojo mtirtber fs not c^pjeCfeu. Co ' 
 tbat 3 fap.tbatffft ban been ro,pct tbe parBon to oulB net bate been gooO; 
 foj tbc fetatotc cannot be offpcnfeo Irttb bpa non obft«nte,O0canfc tbe&ta- 
 tntetoaa maoe to reform publfq«eabufc3,foj tbe benefit of tbc Commons 
 TOealtb, 1 1 .rep. 8. Cooks Plcai of the Crown,237.tbe fcfng cannot paroon a 
 common ntifaiicc. 2 1 p. SCbc ftmgbStbbonnpbfmfelfbp erpjeJTe toojos 
 in t!iE&tattJte,anD be cannot of fpcncc to<tb tljcni tottb a non ob.1ante,foj tbcn 
 fucbfetatutcflmaoefojtbeaotiancementof juttfcetooulobctJofD , ano tbc 
 •IRfng cannot paroon S rccognffance fo? fbe peace befo?c ft fg b?oken, ano tljc 
 IKing map btno bfmfclf fn fucb manner bp crp^ffe toojoa, ns mp Lord Bark< 
 le^ei cafe f 0, liif tl) tbe fetatutc of i lac. conccrnfng 3IBf(6ops tbe iSfngcanfiot 
 Dlfpenc e, but toftb tbc &tatatc of i & 1 3 Eiiz. be map. Dodor Harchin. 
 fonscar%Mi£b. 10. lac. C. B, Hob. 103, tbe lifng cannot Of fpencc irftb tbffl 
 statute , becaufe ft teas maoc fo; tlje aotianccraent of Sltifffcc. jFoj tbe 
 tbftDpofnt,tbougt) tbe ISfngmfgbtofrprncc toftb tbe &tatotcbp a non ob- 
 ftente, pet not toftb tb<0 non obftante fntbf0parDon,foj tbc fefng Dotb not 
 tahc notice of tbc offence fn tbe ncn obftante.ano tbc iUfng fs occefDeo fjcrc, 
 tobffbtbelatotoilllrotfufFer, anDbfrcf0a bfcfng of tbe offence from tbe 
 16f ng, tofjfcb te agafnft tbc meaning of tbe fetatnte. 2lp. sCbfa manner 
 ofparDonfrgfsngafnftaU manner of pjettffcfoji too Ibimojeo peara, ano 
 toao neter ufco tfll 2 lac. but onlp fn Spencers cafe, tobfcb iraa carrpco toftb 
 a ftrong tano , ano allotoeo onlp pro fiac vice, 21 Eliz. bp Pophsm tbc iSt- 
 toincpiptbefpfcfalcommano of tbe £!5ucen, anotmtfll 2 lac. foj 200. • 
 
 pears no non obftamc ufeo of tbe fetatute of 1 3 R. 2. but tbf g f g proton up of 
 late pears , ano a Joogc of our oton tfmcsbatb tolo mctbat be batb offaU 
 lotocoft. ?.Inft. 105. ft batb been ufco of late times to maUe a Icafe of 
 . tbe partfca Iffe, v'z. to rcfpfte r rccutfo.i tmtfu tbe tfme of 2 lac. ano tbat al- 
 lotoarcc 31 fo?mcrlp mrr.tfonco pro b^c vice,map be qucttfoneo tobetber ft 
 toerc coot) 02 no. jf 0; tbe fourtb point tbe plcaofng of tbe paroon fa not 
 gooo^ fo; b" batb not pleaoco a non obftante foj tbe paroon of tbe murtfejr, 
 but onlp to offpetire toftb tbc bfnofng to tbc gooo bcbatfonr , ano tbc paroon 
 fa onlp rctftcftto pjotc tbe pica, ano tbcrcfojc ft fa not to be allotoeo. 
 Therefore let the Prifoner ire fine die, and let the matter be inquired in the 
 County where the fad was done. Yet wc will confider whether he (hall be 
 
 Ccc tryed
 
 3/8 Trin. 1653. 
 
 ~ tryeSTn tbTCoanttyor here, in the mean time, M irftiall take care tt your pe- 
 
 tiil thstj'oukcephim jnfalViacufioDJa, 
 
 Ncw/nan and MaiTcy. 
 
 Trin. i<553,Banc. fup, 
 
 Srcch] ver- VT Ewman bjougftt 311 2ct{on Of Dcbt upon an oblfgatfon agafnttMarTey 
 d.ft in debt i\ ag an Cjccuto; ; SCftc SDcfcnoant plcnoo gcncrallp plent adminiftra* 
 ii|.on»noi- y,t_ aiiD after itliic joyncD be gitcfl <n ct'fDcncc a 3uDgemcnt agafnft tbs 
 Efu'ftT ' ffittato; to mahc gooo [,ia pica, upon Uibicft a fpctfal tietDtrt iuaa founo. 
 a./of. ' "' S£¥ qtieftion tbcrtupon toa0, tobctbcr tbia Ju^SCfncnt ma? be gibcn in z* 
 I'ica." tlDencc upon tbe late crcal AatomafntalntbeilTu:, oj tobciljer U ftoalo 
 
 not babe been plcaDCDfpccfallpfn bar of tbe Qstlon. Roll chief Jurticc, 
 SCbc qtullfon fs, ixbctber tbe gfbing tbe 5titi?emrnt fn cbtDcncc can llano 
 toftbbfspU'aof plcneadmiiiiftravit,anD(t feemis ft cannot, foj noS» pou 
 flieto art asmtnfttratfon fn an otbcr leap tljan pou plcaoeo upon a nc'io mat- 
 ter allcgco. Adjourned, ^t anotbcr Dap hales argueo tbat a picne admi- 
 niftravitfaapleafnlBar, altbougl) ft be not a perpetual 31Bar,anD ft fa a 
 general fffac, fitcaufc ft comp?f fetb manv tbfngs tobfclj map be gftien fn cbf. 
 Dcncc, 27 H. 7. 2. 1 1 H. 6, 3 5 • ano ft is CtlcD a general fffae , Br. gen. ilTue 
 91. & Hob, 106 ^ cafe f. 227. anb ft iDoulD be uilfcbfctotia ff ft fl)oulo be o. 
 tbefteffe. Roll chief luftice, 3;f upon tbe general fffue one Qjoulogf be fti 
 rvifscnce non eft faftum, bL'ou'.D ft be goon I- ccrtafnip tbe ^ct fo: tbe general 
 ]([,e f Hue fn ft felf fs mifcijfcboua, ano luc tof U not enlarge ft, ano tSjrc ia not tbe 
 
 general fffae fntcnoeD fn the fetatute, altbougb ft be a common fffue. fo j tbe 
 general ICfucfnteRDeD, ougbt to bz an fTuc pjopcr to tbe Action tbat fa 
 bjougbt, aROtolifcbbcmigbt baVieplcaocDattbcbegfftnfng. ano lobo care 
 Evidence, tell upou tbfs plea ^nbat pou tofll gftc fn cbtocncc , anofotbeplafntiff can 
 • ncber be p;otfocD foj pou at tbe trpal, anu tbcrefojc pou muft relp uaoii 
 
 pour fpecfal plea of pleneadminiftravic, anu not tarp from ftbp tbetofng 
 ncU) matter. Therefore lee the l^laintiff have his ludgemcnt. « 
 
 Atwood and Monger- 
 
 Trin, '6 J ?• Banc, fop, 
 
 f d'.?mcrr J A Twood fajoiigbt an 3ctfon upon tbe cafe agafntt Monger, foj caufiitig a 
 /nAaT'rVs" /j^ffJlfc pjefentment to be maoc agafnft bfmbefojc foe confcrbatoisj of 
 oivuc c.fe. tbclUtJcr of Thames, foj fuffcrfngg.loaDg of cartiitofalifntotbe Hfbcrof 
 Thames, ano obtcfns a bcrofa •, tbe E?cfcnoar.t mobcD fn arrcft of gunge- 
 ^ mcnt tbat ft ootb not appear bp tbe IRecojo tobat autbo^f tp tbe confcrba- 
 
 tojobaatota'aetbcpjefcntmsnt , anufftbcpbatino atitbo:ftp,tbenfttoa3 
 coram non jidice, ant) tbe ^Dlafntfff coulD not be pjCjUDfccD bp ft. Twifden 
 anfioercD ft fa iucll cnougb, tbougb tbefr autbo jftp appears not bp tbe IRe. 
 coju, bccaufc tbep babe autbo?ftp gf ben tbcm bp tbe statute of 15 R« 
 2.C. 9. fcbfclifsagencrallJLato, anbougbttobctaljcnnotfce of? but ft 
 not,pcttbeadfonf"aioellb?ou£ibt,fojft fa tjougbtfoj tbe tcratfon tbe 
 piafntlffteaaputuntobprcafonoftbcpjercntmsnt, ano t!)C otber mat« 
 tec allcgco, fs but bp toap of fnoucemrnt to the 0cffon, 2 Car. fn Dent and 
 Olifescafcfnt' fa court fobilo.ant) tbougb tI;cco;irerb?.to;3 !J.ao no autbo* 
 rftp, pet tbe 2ctfon Ifca fo j tbe malftfoua pjofecatfon, ano fox unfuftlp bep* 
 fag \ilm .ano fo abjaogeb. Trin, id Car, fn tljfa Court fn Damon ano 
 
 Shereraans
 
 Trin. 1653. 379 \ 
 
 Sbcfem^ns tafe. Hales Oil tijc ot^cr fioc ra(3,t!)3t t!)ts Coart (s not boantt 
 to taUc notice, ttfit tl;e ILo jo fjiafo; of London Ijat^ t^fa jurifofctfon of con= 
 fertatojfttp. fojt!jc&tr.tntc\Dl)l£t)ftaOiftl)<mi3n particular JLato totict;. 
 (ng bf 91 on!p, ant) Co not to be taKen notfcc of inttbotit ft tc Hjcuitr, ano tljcn 
 <ft)c|)alicnof«cftaut'.oj(tp al!tl)cp;occcGf:igs afatnft tft: plaintfff are 
 tjofo. Roll chief uiiicc, Sin ^aim upon tlic Ccifc Ifea foj tjfncfng an ap- 
 peal aaainlf one <n tbc Common pu ao , tbocigh U be coram non judicc, bp caf^ 
 teaf0P?oftl3et)cratfonoftbepartp, cn^ foitfsall oneui)ct&er bcrc toerc 
 anpjtnffDta(onoj no, fojtbc {plaf!U;fFfi'p:ciuofcc5 bp tbc tjcratiun , ana 
 t!)e conrcrbcto:s toob upon tlje:n tobnVc autljo;ttp to taitc ttc picfcnt'.nent. 
 0nD3bolDtt)atanJ!Jctfontipontljcca!eli)(Ul]pe, fo;i maUcfotiflp bjfngfnc 
 an aofon aaafnft one teljcrc \). bac ro probable canfc, ano ff fuif) actfono 
 toae iifcD to be bjougbt, tt tooulD octet men from fucJ) mal(tfougcourfc3 as 
 arc to often pat<n p;acticc, 
 
 Sberccrofc and Weekes. 
 
 Trin, »953,Banc,fup» 
 
 SHerecroft bjonttftt an 5ctfon upon tl^c cdfc againtt Weeks , foj fpcafefng Amrt of 
 tt)Cfe IDOJOO of t)Jm; He, meaning the Plaintiff, got Mary Nab with Child ,ludgrmcnt in 
 and the Child is hh, and I have tryed it with a ficve and a pair of fliceres; Jt '" ''^'■'*''^" '°^ 
 toas moiJCD fn arreft of Sltispmcnt, tbat tlje latter toojos are fnfenGble/"' ** 
 anofotljc flcttonnotmatntafnabIC;toUi{jtcf)fttoasanftucrcD,t()at t'lc firft 
 tDO?D0 arc ilctionablc,! ft matters not tboug^ tf)c latter too^Qa be nonfcnte, 
 l)eca«rctbc:^balJe no reference to tftefojmertDOjDs, ana tljcrcfoje (ball be 
 tejcctcD as fertcleffc. JBut feerf cant Barnard on tfte otbcr Coe faf D,tl&c lat- 
 ter toojD0 DO tatc off t^e fo;cc of tfte fojmer iiojUg, as ttie cafe Is 4. rep. f. 
 19. 3lp» 3tf3nttfatDlj£re,tol;cnbegotl)ertoltl)CWl5. i^ojslp. 2Dotfj ^ 
 tje atjer tljat ttiere Vcas anp fiic^ perfon asMary Nab. Roll chief lurtice, SEfte 
 fldion Dot^j tocU Ipe, foj tbc fo jmcr Idojos are pontfbc fcanualons Ujojdo , 
 ano t'ne fubfrqucnt toojos are not matcrfal , ano if tljcp be, tljen tbep arc in 
 tonltrmatfon of tbc fo?mcr,foj U fccms t)c put conftocncc in tbe fiebc ano tie 
 fljeeres, ano tbat mane bimfpeaktftc too ;ds, ana it matters not Uibcttjcr 
 tifl confioentc be true 0; falfe. Therefore ludiciu m nifi proQ.uerente» 
 
 VVeldon and Scrudder. 
 
 Trin, 1653, Banc, fup» 
 
 13Ctoaamobct)fotbc Court tbat tbe plafntfff after be bao obtcpnen aM^*'"""""- 
 tjcroict, ano befojc Sluogement entrcD,opcb, ano pjapcD tbat tb{So7cHcPi 
 
 am' 
 
 mfgbt be entreoupon tbelHolh but the Court denyedic, and faidic could c.tf on the 
 not be. Roll. 
 
 Whitehead and Suckland. 
 
 Trin, 165 3. Banc. flip. 
 
 T|3s cafe of Whitehead anD Buckland Inas agafn fpoken unto, fobtc?! toas Demurrer ro 
 tbfs ; Whitehead bjotigbt an ilctfon of SCrcfpatle bp ojfgfnal u»)tt,foj ' '<=P|.'"'''°" 
 faWngbrsCattchtbc BDcfcnoant pleaocD tbe fetatutc of Umttatfona oforJhui 
 SUdiom in ^at; tbe plaintiff lepHes tbat be tooU fo}tb an o'.igtnal to;lt a- ^ ' 
 
 Ccc2. gafntt
 
 380 Trin. 1655. 
 
 gafntt tbc SDefcnDaut fo j {\}ia SCtcfpara toftWtt t^ic tfmc IfmftcD bp tijc &ta- 
 titte, ano upon tbfo rcplkatfon tbc Dcfcnoant DemtirrcD, aiio foj caufc 
 flicxa, tl)att)CDotl)nota)CU)lDt)atU);ttOcfncD fojtb, as iKougljtto Do, 
 otijcrtoffe <t cannot be hnou-n tobctftet tjc 6c rt0l)tlp tftcrcbp f ntftulcD to t)(3 
 ilttfon 0% no. 2lp. ^c bat?) not fijctocD tljc continnarcco upon bfo pjocccD- 
 jngo , ano fo ft cannot be UnoU)nto!ictl)cr !Ua Action be uffconttnucn oj no , 
 tftat f f ft be \oe map tafee aotantagc tljctcof. 3 Ip. !^c Dotb not fap tbat Ije 
 ^atf) taken out an £>}fg(nal, proucapparet pcrRecordum, asi fje oas'ot to 
 DO , foj toe DO not agree tbc tojft ttat be plcaos be b nb taken out, 4!?. I^c 
 ^jatb concluoeD bfs plea , fo tbat ft amountsi to a ncto afsfgnmcnt , ano bfn- 
 Detc us from objcafng agafnft ft bp toap of rejopnccr, ano be fopns an fCfue 
 ofbfsotonl^caDofamattctnotallcgcDb'foje, anoslp.SLbe^rtfon fs foj 
 a£Ctcfpafsooncfni645. anDpctbcconcUiDcsfttobe contra paceni publi- 
 can), tobfcftbifngfntbclatciStngstfme toulD not be, but oucbt to babe 
 been contra coronam et dignitacem noftrara. Latch on tbc otbcr fiOC fafD, 
 tbat botb pattf cs agree to tbe Djfglnal, ano tbe of fagrccment f 3 onlp f n tbc 
 tfmeoftbcE):ccutfontbcreof, anDftfsnotncccJIarpto fap prouc patet per 
 rtcordum; no; fsftncccITarpto fljetotbccontfrniancEsoftbe pjcccfs , foj 
 tbfs tooulD make tbc IRccojo too long , ano bcrc fs no bfnoerancc but tbep 
 pc» map tcjopn ft tUp bate caufc. Roll chief iuftice, Sstotbe firtt Crccptf* 
 
 tiior, onftfsnotncccffarptofetfojtbtbcpartfcMlarsoftbeUjjft, anDfftbe to?ft 
 
 be not gooD poti map bate a to?ft of Crro j ; ano fo j tbc feconn circcptfon , 
 tbc pica fsgooDtoftbotitCbctofng tbc continuances, anotbcrc fs no fncon- 
 t£nfcncebpnotfcttingtbemfojtb,anD toe tofU fnttno tbat allfs rfglitip 
 Done, bccaufcpoutiabeappcarcD, anDpou arc not bfnojcD from replpfng, 
 tilt map DO ft ff pou tof 11 , ano bate caufc , anD tbe IRccojd bcrc fb:tos tbat 
 joubabc appearcD to tbfs tojft ; but ft fs not gooD to concUiDc tiic pica fupec 
 totamtnateriam as pou babe tone, fojbptbfsbcfsbfnDjeo from replpfng, 
 anD tbcn be batb gooD caufc to ocmur, bccaufc poo bate concluDco bfm, ano 
 tbat fap pou to tbat:" Latch , 2Cbe partp map ftrfhc out tbc too^os Et que=. 
 tens fiiniliter. Roll chief Iuftice , !^c cannot Crfltc out tbat tobfcb belongs 
 Repiicaiiop not to bfm , ano pou cannot go back , anD tbc otbcr (s compellcD to Demur, 
 Dcuiurier'. ' Stbcrcfoje , Nil capiat per Billam nifi , &c, or waive the Demurrer , 
 Poflea* 
 
 Trin. 1652. Banc.fup. 
 
 v'l, , m»v 1 2C teas faio fn tbe care of Homes ano Bingley, tbat aCcnant at tofD map 
 mdc'caicVc 1 matsca Icafcfo; peats to trp a title of lano, anD fo map a Copp. 
 
 totrjatiilc. bOlDer, Q; 
 
 Trin. 1652. Banc.fup. 
 
 Bt3 Roll chief lurtice, Sinattojnep tobobatbtoarrant to appear foj %ls 
 Clpent, mapplcaDfo; bfm toftbout toarrant. 3I5«t tbc Claris fti 
 v!cad«ithoui Court fafD, be map pleaD no otbet pUa toftbout a fpecfal toarrant, bat a noa 
 a f^'f cial war- Jura informatus , ideo Q, 
 
 lant. 
 
 Feck
 
 Trin. 1553' 3^* 
 
 Peck, and Ewre. 
 
 Triflt 1^53, Banc, fup, 
 Pafcb. i6S3,ror, ii6,or !i7» 
 
 AOTdtoTCrroj \ma bioualjt to Tcbrrfc a (uDgcmcnt gftcn ftt a«Eir'>rtore- 
 Safcn of Debt fo^ tent arrcar upon tlDOleafesfo; i'ears, viz, upon a ^'^ ^■»j"''?<- 
 leafcfoj ; pears of!i<bcr« Coppljolo Jianos, anoupona Icafc fo; 3 1 pears ■"'"' '" ^^^^ 
 {oi otbet lan53. Howell afcfang fo; Crroj , i, SEbat the SDctlaratton it '"^'"''* 
 not 0oot), becaife tljat <t is fo j an entire rent rcferbcD foj 2 fevcral terms , 
 to^treaa one of tt)c terms ia erpfre^, f berc cannot be maoc anp appojtton- 
 tnent of t!;e rent , becaufctteppeatsnot tcbfcbof tbclanca are Coppbolo, 
 ano irb'cb arc j'^rec lanes. Roll chief iu!>i«, ^e ougbt to Qjetn tola mutb 
 of tbe lanBg ate Coppbolo, anc bote miitb J^rcctolD Hales , ^ere (0 but 
 one entfrc rent rcfctbeD , anoit fljaH be pato as luell after t&c erpfratton of .- 
 tbc<I;op('bo\Dlanl)saBbefo^c. Roll chief luftice , 2Ebcn foj ixbat term°„ °"""" 
 (ball tbc rent be rcfcrbeo :" foj ftDotb not appear to ns, Therefore yea 
 were beft to difcontinue your action , ocherwife if we give judgement upon 
 the Exception takcn,you may lofe your rent. 
 
 Hill and Dechair, 
 
 Trin, i<5J3,Banc. fup- 
 
 A^ 0ttfon of belt foasbjougbt fo; 5 1. foj fcllfng of ^fnc Itiftbonf 3lf« Arreftcf 
 ccnte , ano a acrtfct Inns fonno fo; tbc piainttf. 3t itiae mobeo in HRemem in 
 Sirreft of guDgcment , SEbat tbc Sldton fs not idcU bjougbt , bccaufc (t is *^ ^*^''°" "^ 
 notbp£);(gtnal,aottoucbttobcbptbcafatatc ofiS Eiiz, Wild on tbe r" V^'ii^"'"^* 
 otber aoc anftoereo, tbat ft is not ncceffa^ to be bp £) jfgfnal , fo j a JSIU of «ine „Xut 
 Mbtaatbfsffl, (3fntbcnatiircofan£>;fg{naltD:<t, ffft fijoulo be otbct. Hccnic. 
 lD<fc tbe Statute tooula be repugnant ; foj tbe Debt Dne bp Statute 
 map be rccoberco fn tbts Court bp Jnfojmatfon , ano tbfs fs tbe 
 nfualpjactkc of tbfs Court. Twifdcn took a Dififcrcncc bctioccn a penal 
 SlfXioVy ano a popular Action ; SL penal iSctfon be fafo map be bp SSill , but 
 not a popular action, 2lp, 3t is not fbctoeo tbat t^c partp teas not U cen^ 
 fcDtofellCSline. jlp.SElie aeroict fines bimsufltp foj felling of 5 pints of 
 Wint bcttoeen fncb a time ano fucb a time , part tobercof toas bcfojc tbe 
 information bjougbt , ano part after tl)c 3;nfo jmatfon bjougljt. SEo tbc a|'"'°°* 
 latt crccption, Roll chief lufticc anftocrcD , SCbe matter (ball relate to tbc " '"'*"'" 
 filing of tbeJlSail, foitben tbe Action trciiinctb,* not befojc. 3i5ut tcbat 
 fap pou to tbc otber CBrception:' Wild , SDbat fs miftaben , foj tbc attton is 
 upon anotlicr bjancb of tbc &tatute.Roll chief laftice, J5p an ojigtnal aaion 
 it is meant in tbc feitatutc tbat tbc offence Hjall not be trpco upon a plaint in 
 an3Inferionr Court,f not to Diff inguiflij it from an Info jmation; foj a Wiiit % 
 JBiU is all one intrfa Court , Stat. 2 R. 3. 2 toll ta not an £)jiginal tojft, 
 but an o:iginal 0£tion , anu it ia tbc common pjaaice to fue in tbis Contt, ^[,"* 
 fn tbis manner But we will advifc. 3t anotbcr bap tbc Court icas mobeo '" 
 foj jnocemcnt . bccaufe tbc action is toell bjougbt, tbougb it be not bjougbt 
 fcp original , ano tbe Cafe urgeo of Winflon agafnft it is not to tbc purpofe , 
 foj tbat Cafe itas rot upon an infojmation, as our Cafe fs, but ft tuag 
 bjougbt bp tbe partt'gricbeo to recover bis treble Damages, ano in tbat cafe 
 t\tt partp Dio not putfne tbe manner of fufng foj tbcm as tbe ^tatnte oirea* 
 
 Ccc 3 «0j
 
 ~~^8i Parch.1653 
 
 go bat tDC Ijatc tjcrc Done It, anoftfstbcconttantpjatffceoftljfflCoatt. 
 
 Twifden anfircrcD , tljat Wmftons cafe fo not anftusreD ; foj tljnt toaa a po« 
 
 polar 3(tfon,ac oat cafe fg. Rollchitt Juaice, E^c qucfifon tjcrc fs, tub' 
 
 tbct tljcrc be an ojfgtnal jetton ojnotupontijc&tatatcofiSEliz. C.j* 
 
 ano 3 fap ft Dotl) not appear ittictbct tl;at Statute meant to out tftis dourt 
 
 ofUsBlurfflOfctfon 0: not , but it ts left at large fn t^v S-tatutc, ano me 
 
 thtnUB It <fl an o;ia<nal jetton, ant) Plats Cafe <s, tljnt an o?fnmal jattton 
 
 lurisdidion. ^ jjp jjp jigjjj ^ -0„jj ^ conccftc tl)C &tatntc fntcncco onlp to c vdnoc fn- 
 
 fctfoat Courta , ano tftc conftant coiirfe <s, tbat tljc partp being in Cuftodia 
 
 Marefcalli 1)6 map be pjocecDco agalnft bp 15f U , ano toe Infll not fuffcr tbfs 
 
 Court to be efcluuco f joni Ua jurisofalon bp obfcnre fcoojog in t^c &ta. 
 
 tUtC Therefore let judgement be for the Plaini i'", nifi, ^c, 
 
 RicotcandSt- lohn. 
 
 Trin, 1655. Banc, fop. 
 
 Mot.on .lut T ^ actfoii of Erc'pafg an Clectmcnt bjongbt bp Ricott againtt St. lohn , 
 the Di^f-n- y t^c (jcoott Vcaa motico fo; a t^fro perfon , tljat \fi. toill fatjc the S)cfenoant 
 TT'^ barmleffl, anopjapg tbatsibinstjimfccuritpfotoDo, tftcSDcfcnoantmap 
 ffird Jf'fon beo;DcrcDbptl)crulcofti)igCoutttopleaoag Ije Ojoulo Dicett Ijim, ano 
 mail diieft. tbat be be not fuffcreo to conf cffc a jnDgcmcnt.Roll chief luOice, 3;t ig out of 
 tl)etoapfo;poutogit)Efucl)fccuritp, {Q\ tijerc pet appears no coUuSon, 
 But > oa (hall be made a party to defend the title, and then move again, 
 
 Trin. i<553. Banc. fup. 
 
 u/i A Tiatbc Cafe of one Clark ft toagfafDbp Roll chief luftice, 2r:baffft!)efub« 
 iT tal?.. in 1 mifsion to an SUnarO be , that tfte ainaro be maoc Or Dapo after tl)C fab. 
 c'uf.vr, whcrt mifgion. the oapof tbe atoato igip betaUen incluftbc ap.n not crtluGbe, fo 
 cxciufive. tjjat if tije atoafo be maoe t^e fame bap on toWc^ tbe fubmtfoion toag , it id 
 
 A.biircmcnr. g gpo^ ^JoatQ. 
 
 Ayre and Hauxefworch. 
 
 Trin, 1655. Banc, fup. 
 
 AY-ebjoaGbtan^ctionofSCrcfpafcagafrift Hauxefwonh foj big Cat- 
 tela Damage fcafantin D. tbc EDefcnaant jutlificg \.n anotbct Countp, 
 ''uuktiT" «"" tratenctft abfque hoc , tljat.bc ig guiltp (n D. o; in anpotbcr place* 
 ' ""^ " Sntje tiucCtonltjasto^ctbcrtbetratjcrtc be uclltalicnoj not. Roll chief luft^ 
 
 r anftocrco, be mull take a tratjerfe as tbig cafe i3,bccaufe tbe uifilfication is 
 nlfccnttnu- ''>C3l * Therefore let the PI intif take nothing by his Bill , for he may not 
 •r'cc!" (Jiicontinuchis AdionbecaufcitisinTrefpafs. Nota. 
 
 Fletcher and King. 
 
 Trin, idj 3, Banc, fup, 
 
 E -orro'c- A mrit of Crto^ toao bjougbt to rcbcrfc a fuDgcmcnf gi^)cn in t^e 
 vcifciju<'ge- l\ Common ^leas in an Action of Debt b;oagI)t upon sn '^fTumpfit to 
 
 "'^.n 'Jn'^Ar f^^* onc^rmlefs, inDifpoQngofccrtaingoo08feifeDbpan£)jact'of tbe 
 E"fi" Commifgioncrsof^abetonfteig i^aB; %\^z jaDcfenoant pleaoco ttiat be
 
 Tfin. 1655 383 
 
 ban faljco ftim ^armcfa ; E^c fSlatnttf rcpIpcB tfjat !)e luag tiamnfgeD , tfte 
 E)cfcnijantu'<opnsbpp;oteC8tfcn, tftat tftcrc teas no 0:D.r of J^abcr- 
 oafljcrol^aB , foj plea faUIj , nondaranificatus, ano npontbis tftepialn- 
 UfDemattcDfntljcComntonipieag, auo ajuogcmcntUjasglticntbcrcup. 
 ontfte SDemurrct fo; tfto piafntlf. %tt tte Uijft of Gtroj !jere tlje Crrot af. 
 figncDtoas, tljattberelopn^ev Is a Departure from t^e pica, ano bcre U 
 Dotl) not appear t^at I jhn Pitcher namcQ iw tl)e repUcatfon fs t^: fame lohn 
 Pitcher t^jat f3 namcDfntljc SDcdaratf on , fo: It te fai3 quidano iobanncs 
 Pitcher , ano not tljc faia 1, Pitcher. Latch fafDj^Lt^fl la not ttiatw£al,U)|ie. 
 tliet ftc be t^2 fame o; no ;:.but upon the entire matter tt ootlj appear t^t 
 bctetbefanicperfon, fojttjcrefsanatJcrmcnta'terlDarDs tbat makes ft 
 To appear , viz, SEtjat ft ts tbe fame perfon ano gooes mcntfoneD in tl}c plea, 
 anDfntbeconDttionmaDeuponDelttJcrpoftbegooDg , ana tt canjiot be 0- 
 tl}CTlDifeunocr(tooD, anottjctrbartanaunlit hot!) in matter ano fn fojm 
 alfo, fo J be is to be faljco ftarwlcfs of goo^g. Hale on tbe otber fiDc makes 
 a Difference betlceen faglng one i. p. anD faplng I. P. ano fagfng of of tiers 
 gooDO, anofaplngof gooDsgciurallp; anDt^tgooBsmcntioneD licrc can- 
 not rilstc to t;ic coccs racnttonco in tiic tonoUton , ano t^ouglj t^c plea be 
 not goon ft matterauot, fo^ tl)c rcplfcation afsignsnot a b^cacti- Roll-chief 
 luftice, 3fpour pleabcnctfiooo,tlj£n tbcSDcclaratfanfsnotanftDercD, HtTrava'fc. 
 mapfacintcnDcotljc fame perfon, petftfsttottocllcrp^etrcDtofap quidam intcndmcnr; 
 I. P. foj ftolB can a traberfe be taken upon an fntcnDment ^ no j Dotl) ft ap- j^"- 
 pear tbsp ar c tijc fame gocoa but bp intcnDment , fo t^at tlje bat fs f U , ane ^°P''"t'°"- 
 ttjc replication alfo. Affirmecor nifi, s c. Nota. 
 
 anJ HccJges, 
 
 Tiin. 1653. Banc. fopi. 
 
 AMrft ofCnoj teas b;oual)t to tctjerfc a laocrement gftjen fjt t^Errorror*- 
 SEotrfh of Newbery in an Action upon tlje statute of 5 Eiiz. bjougW bp '^^^'jj; ' 1^^^^'.' 
 an 3nfojmer foj tiling a Eraoe. not iftiUna. fcvl3CD an app:cnttQ)ip tljcrefn, "n Aftion"up- 
 anD ttoo Grro js tecrc afsigneo , 1. SC^nt t^c action oaatjt not to be b:oucl)t on the StJiurc 
 <ti an inferionr Conrt , but mnft be bjougbt in one of tl)z Courts at Wefts °f s ei.z. 
 minfter. alp. SCljC Venire is nott^OOD, foJ it is onlp pracceplom eft, anD DOtft 
 not rap per curiam as it oug':t to be. Roll chieflufiice , Cftc ^aion ongftt 
 nottobcb;onnl)ttt)erc, fautit ougbttobe bjougbt in fome of tfte Courts 
 ^creanD tijc fecenD is a gooD Ejccption alfo, tljcrcfojcrevcrfctur, nifiAc» 
 
 Aft ion. 
 "v'cniie, 
 
 raylerandVVebbi • 
 
 Trin« i653,13anc.fup. 
 
 TaCtoas tcfolt?eD bp tbe Court, t^at tftcDelibering of a bjctiat of tftc Caffe vvint Aft 
 
 to the 3ntp befojctbe \3erDitt , ano tbeir reaDing it, DiD make tl)e tierDict may make a 
 gtben bp tbem to be tof a, fo j f^c Jurp ougl^t not to ftabe anp otbcr t3;itings Vcra/a void. 
 gitjcn t^em to pzrufc tljan fucb as are cibcn in ebiDence , foj it tooulD be 
 Dangerousifitfl)oulDbcotl)crtoife , ano to confirm tbis, Mich. 31- et 32 
 Eiiz. Metcalfs anD Deans cafe , anD One Viccary anD Farthings cafe lucre U» 
 teD bp Roll chief Iul>ice» 
 
 Aflt:
 
 ^84 Trin. 1653. 
 
 Afliby and Child. 
 
 v: 
 
 Trin. i(5jj,BaHC,fup» 
 
 Mich,i6j». rot, 68<), 
 
 |9on a iDemurrer fit an 0(t{on of Dclt ttje cafe ioas tftte , man D(ea 
 (ntettate, ano a fettangct poffcffct^ Wntfrlf of ttje 3!ntcff atC0 goona af. 
 tct ILettets of aominfftratton uetc grantee to a Ctcofto j of ttie SntcOate, 
 tctio b;(ng0 an jSittf on of Debt againS Vit firangCT (0% t^e oebt one to t)(m by 
 tbc Sntcffatc , as Cjrcctitoj of l)(0 oton \i.?ong. STfte qncttion tnas , 
 to&ctljetfftc Crecfto?bj» tailing tbcilctteraofaDminfftratfonijat) not fnf- 
 penoeo I)f0 ;9(t(on fo;i t^e time tje fijoulo continue to be aomfniQrato^j 
 TwifdentielD tbat ^(s 0afcn fo ftirpenoeo , ano cUeD 8 Rep. &t. Johns cafe , 
 bccanfct^cgooDsoftl)c3inteftatc Cball be affcts in Ws banos, Hob ano 
 Longs cafe ;"anDtl)eipia<nt{f(i3 at no pjcluolce , foj fte map rccobet tfje 
 goo30 bp an 06f on ot Crotcr oj aTtefpafo , 1 2 H. 4. f, 2 1 » Hales on tfte 0= 
 tbccnoe ^:ID tbat t:c 5lcttont«not fnfpenDcO; fo^ tbong^ ^c map bifng 
 SCrefpafs! oj a gnrotier antj Conticrflon fo; tfte goon?, pet tbcp ate not af- 
 fcts tUl tftcp ate tetotJCtcD , ani>a Ctcnito j map bjlng an ;na(on agafnft an 
 Crautojiiefon tort, altbongblLcttersofSiDmfniftratfonbegtanteotoa* 
 notftet . antJ t^c fabfcqnent aomfnfttraHon uotl) not ftifpeno tbe action 
 tDljfcb atcrncD bcfo;e , anobcrccanbcno retainer to fatisfie bimfclf, be. 
 canfe be batb not tlie gooos , ano it is not tbe bare ILetters of aominiStation 
 tf)at cbarrictb tbc aominlttratoj , but tijc atTcts alfo , Com. 7. Bjffctj cafe, 
 2n aafon ot Debt is maintainable bp an aomlniftrato; toljo ^atti not affets. 
 Roll chief iuftice, SLbetels aboobagainfttbat, tbattbcbcirisnotcbarge. 
 able. Hales pnma facie , St fs a gooD plea , otbettoife it tDotilo be mifc^ie* 
 tons , fo J all tbe gooos map be ijuaftco before fjc batb aomfniftration gtati- 
 tcDftim; anot^ongbftemapbjinganactfonofErcfpafsfojtljeflDoiJs, pet 
 be map bjfng bis Action to a.btcl) be teas intitleo bcfoje t^c aunifnittration 
 
 Trover a nd grantcD unto bim. Roll chief Iuftice , 31 is cleat tbe 0Dminiffratoj map 
 
 Convcifioii. bjingaCrotjcr anDConterftonfojtbc gooos, ano bere is bat a rigbtto 
 
 affctointbeaomintttratoi, ano no affet^to charge bfm toftball, ano it 
 
 • toiotilD be mifcbietoas if it (boulo bj otbrttoife ; ano tbe gtanting onto bim 
 
 ILetters of a^minlff ration binoersbim not from b^i'ngingbfs 0ctfon, bc- 
 
 caufc tbe goooa tocrc not tatjcn atoap after tbe aominifttatton grauteo bat 
 
 P P before , ano if tlirp bao hecn tahcn atoap aftertoaros , be migbt bate bao 
 
 o'/br ' a gnrotjcr ano CotirrQnn , oj an 3aion of ?!Lrcfpafs , but in tbc cafe at tbe 
 315a#c nap I'atjc an 3ttion of Debt, ano be cannot Cue bimfcif. therefore 
 
 Sufpcnfion. liisactfonisnotfufpcnoco, ano 'ic cannot retain tbe gooos to fatfsficbim. 
 
 KciaiiKr. ftif,bccatifebebatbnoPooD0, anobemapfuctbebcir bcreifbctoiU, ano 
 b!'fttaUr(ottafecat)tantagcagainft bim bp reafon of tbc aominiff ration, 
 brtanfe be b^'tb no atfcts to retain j fue btmfclf for , ano fo it ia In bia cle- 
 rtion tobat actfon be mill facing , otbertoifc it tooalo be oangcrons , ano toe 
 
 EitSion. j^^ijj fuppojt men in tbeit jnlt aaions. lerman, Nicholas anO Asic ad idenit 
 And lo judgement was given for (he Plaintif, nifw 
 
 Fiftiei
 
 Trin,i653' 385 
 
 Fifl\er and leoffrycs- 
 Tfin, X <5 5 3. Banc, fop, 
 
 Flftier fajotigW an jaaton of ccbt agafnft leoffrycj asCretato: fo another; whjr miy 
 tt)c SDefcnoant (mpatl0, ano after tmparlancc be plcaos tl)at t)c (0 ^J'' ed'aftcr'im-''' 
 mlintttato; cum tcftamento annexo , ano not Cjccuto; , ano ttiat ftc ougtJt parlance. '" 
 to be nameo fo {n tfte iujtt , tott)toplcatbcpia<ntffDemurrco. Roll chief 
 luftice, Cipontlje matter fjeplcao© a mifnofmcr after imparlance, iDtjfttl^.j 
 tl? cannot DO, anotticrefoje lct;he Plaindf have his juJgtmcnt.nifi, &c, **• 
 
 Giles and Southward- 
 
 Trin. 1553. Baoc, iup, 
 
 I/ptW0 cafe Utoasfafobp Roll chief luftice, Sl^atif tbe JDefenDant noz^^,^^^^^ 
 plcao an (nfuffictent bar , ania tijc IpiafntU do jopn fffuc upon U , ano ob» chough the 
 tafn a BaeiDW, tl)C jaiafntifOjaH Ija^e jaoscment t^ougf) tIjc %5ii teas pica m bar 
 notgooD. lioijood. 
 
 Rawley and VivcrS- 
 
 Trin, i653.Banc,fup, 
 
 A tHIrftof (SttojteagbjoaslituponajuDgcmcntsftien in an Sialon ot^"^'^°''- 
 -^SDrcfpafs, quare daufum frcgic , Sec %%z Crro; afsfgncD tras, Vc^^'f-2zu^\r4ll: 
 the piafntff DfD Declare quare claufum fregit , ano fo;. pulHns Doton of his pau quarc 
 home . but DOth not OjC'U) the taluc of bis houfc. Roll chief luftice , 3t fo chmum tre- 
 
 oot ncceSarp , the ^aton being a real attfon. Affirrtictur, nifi, e;r. 
 
 Value. 
 
 Bariar and Windham- 
 
 J 
 
 Trin, 1653. Banc, fup, 
 
 T % toaa hclD bp the Coart that the engagement taken facfojc 2 3luQfcc0 of ^^ 
 -* peace fn Ireland fs tDcUtaUcn,amj that the engagement ought not to \iz p,ge.r*ni is 
 pUaoeDtoanaUcnbojn, anofubjca toanp fojein pjtnce fn amitp ujtth wcUukcn/ 
 England, bccaufe he i0 unoec another obcDiente, ano thereupon the £n- 
 gagemcnc pleaded co fuch an one was dilcharged in cbe Cafe of one SSartac 
 and Mtnohom, 
 
 Trin. 1653- Banc, fup^ 
 
 Oipie tDho toao a toftneffe fnlbc caufc fo j the EDefennant bcfng bafl foj 
 Wm, upon motion to the Court toao taken off from the file, ano a< ^^'''u'"u'^) 
 nothet bail taken tn hfo room in Court upon examination of his fufficicocp . ""' ' " ' 
 
 Now, 
 
 ©50 Trim
 
 386 Trin. 1653. 
 
 Trin. 1653. Banc.fup: 
 
 dIriupcT the T ^^ '^""^^ ^^^ '""^^^ ^^ oJfpanpet t^c piafntff (n an flctfon of Sref- 
 I'h n"if. paffl 3nD Ciectmcnt , fo; t^at ft toas p;otcD bp Affidavit tftat be htao a 
 
 terp tcyatfous pcrfon, foj ftc ^ao been tdifce nonfatc fn tbta Safon, t v^onlD 
 neber pap cofts , j maUc a fufficfcnt ILcffcc able to pap t^cm , ana bao al- 
 fo fcalcD a general relcafctotbcJDefcnoant. Roll chief iuflice, Lethira 
 bedifpaupcrcd, and let him put in an able Lcflee to pay the cofls, or otber» 
 wife he {hall not proceed ui bis AS ion. 
 
 7rin«i 653- Banc- Tup- 
 
 ["'T^nK' "n ^ ^^" ctiief I'jftife , ffifec Halns of Ireland are allotic Idtft tb.c latus 
 jand a"i on^ |"\ ol Enpland , anD 8 tD:.« Of CErroj lies In England to rcticrfc a juogcc 
 Efior. " *-' mcnt gtlJCn in Ireland. 
 
 Trin. 1653. Banc. fup. 
 
 What Is not A SDcclaratfon [ons filcD In the £)ficc aaafnC one f n ctittoDp of t&e f^a= 
 
 gaod notice J\ riTtftal, ano a<roppoftttDaBlcftli)ltbtl)eClarlioftftep?<ron,buttbc 
 
 to a prifoncr pjf foncr 1)30 HO HoHcc ot ft. ^pott tftc pjffoncrs flictofng of tW matter to 
 
 otadtcUra- f^g (t^ouTt , attU reaclttg BH Affidavit tO pjot)e ft , a judgement by a nihil di- 
 
 bm? '^"'^^ '■' obtained againft him was diicharged , and ordered chat the Plaintif (hould 
 
 ludecircnt accept of 3 plea, 
 difcniigcd. 
 
 T'rin. 1653. "Banc. (up. 
 
 'T^c<rourttiiasmot3Ci)tot){rcbargcapi<foncroutoftbc tipper Kenclb 
 f.ncr*'^'' I tbat Uao lafn tbere cticr fince 24 Caroii , upon a juDgemcnt obtatneo a» 
 had lorpgalnflbtmtnanattfonofSDcbt, tobcre ohlp common ball ioafl fileo , ano 
 'npri- bccatifc no f rccutfon teas eter tahcn out upon tbattutigcmcnt, ano tlje 
 
 3Hn<Mtif <;i the CIrtinM Itian iin<n rifinn R r.t i r.ii»>f Inftirp I pr him \\e AiCm 
 
 To difchar 
 a prirnncr 
 
 .''"">. --. ^ "— — -r— - -^ , -'- 
 
 '""• piatntinn tbe 3a(on loas noiD Dcao. Rolicucf luftice, Let him be dif- 
 
 chargcd nlfi caufa (hewed to morrow. Nota. 
 
 Trin. 1(^53, Banc. fup. 
 
 Waiter of Re- "D 1^ Roll chief luftice , fli matter entree upon Hccoati cannotfae alfcreo 
 
 coidnoia;e- Ouiitftout 3 mottort mnijc, ano tftc Confcnt oftt)e Court firtt obtatneo, 
 
 I able » 
 motion 
 Court. 
 
 labie without tboagljtbe^ttojnspg oti bottjCoesconfcnttoit. 
 
 motion to the 
 
 Trin. 1653. Banc ^"P- 
 
 Ti^cConrttDa0mo^eotoqu3D[jan£E)iDlrof feefslons foj one to pap 
 - , 3 s. a toeck to beep a JBattaro Cbflo. Roll chief lufl.ce, Let it be 
 
 {^on"^ "^ 'quaJhcd , foj tfeep cffli mafee no fuel) iD:Der, foz t^e partp map tsecp tbe 
 <!tijllD ^fmfclf, if be Vctll , ano tbcn t)C nceo pap no inoncp to Uecp (t. 
 
 Trin.
 
 B 
 
 Mich. 1^53^ 387 
 
 Trin. 1^53. Banc. fup. 
 
 |0Roll cliier loftice, sCJje tScnac cannot be cliangcD aftet a plea when the 
 pleaocofn abatement of tbc fajjft, mocb lelTe aftet a pUa pleaoeo^*^""* ™»y 
 
 miBar.a. no. be Chang. 
 
 Fanfliaw and 'Bond. 
 
 Mich» 1953, Banc, fupt 
 
 IiptWaCafeff ua0fa<D, SCbat ff a Coppboloct tefnfc to pap n teafona-Ho«, codv 
 bicfincoutobeaomfttcoto tlje Coppbolo, SCtifa fsa fojfettote of lifehoidh forui- 
 fftate ted. 
 
 Dekin and Turner. 
 
 V 
 
 Mich, I £$ 3 , Banc, (ap, 
 
 ^n a motfon fn Strctt of JuDgcment fn an 0ctfon npon t^e Cafe foj Arrefi of 
 ttiefe tDOjDS , ThoH arc a whore, and I will prove it, 3lt toao fafO bp i'"'^""'"^ ^ 
 Roll chief laftice, 2Cbattbe lco?os arc not attfonable, although fpobcn '" ^J*'"" ^"^ 
 fincctbcattmaDcagafnft0opltetp, becaafe thep ate bat irojos of hcat*° 
 anoctjotet, but if a (pedal Damage be lafo bp the (pealsfng of them , a0 per 
 quod maricagiam araifir, o;theUke, thete thep atc actfonable« 
 
 Price and Goodrick- 
 
 Mich, 1653. Banc, fup, 
 
 Tj^thfaCafcfttDflfifafobp Roll chief /uftice, 3lf there bca 9!nijgcmcntwi'<reanAu- 
 -• agafntt thjee , ano one of them fs tahrn fn Ctecutfon, ano be aftettoaroa f"' q""«'» 
 fet at latgc bp the piatatffs tonfent , (f anp of the othet ttoo be aftcttoatDs ' 
 tafecn fn erccntfon upon the fame BJuogement, he map habe an ■ udica qae« Motion. 
 rela , buthc cannot be tclfcbett upon a motton in Coutt , though gronnDco 
 npon an Affidavit- 
 Newton and Osborn. 
 Mich, J 65 3. Banc (Up. 
 
 NEmon bjought an 0ct(on ofCobcnanf agafnftO»born an Crecutoj to whcher jn 
 a iLelTcc foj pC3t0 foj non.papmcnt of tent tcfctbcD upon the leafc^aion cf co- 
 upon th2 general toojos ipfrlDfng ano partnfr fn the leafe j thctc befng no eic« tenant did 
 p^cfs Cobcnant tbcrrfn foj the uapmcrt of tbs rent. EChe queftfon teas , "^ "I "°' '" 
 iDhethetthts flrtfon ofo Ife agafntt the C'tccutoj. Latch atgucD that ftnlOccutor''" ' 
 not lie, bccaufc ft fs a meet Covenant fn IL aiti comp jffco onlp f n the Idojtib 
 pfelDfng ano papfng , nnDnotancrp'-efaCobenant , ano fo onlp bfnoa the 
 2:ettato),b^tnott^c©rmltcJ. iBut Holl chief luftice anftoereD,Chatan 
 0ofon of Cobctiant nothifc agafntt an Ctfcutoj npon a Cobcnant fn ilato.covenmt 
 although h- bcnotnamrD,b(itftf3otber\dfccfanh:ft,foj he fs not botmOEx-ccutor,* 
 bp fntb a Covenant. Sinn the rcfcrtatfon of the rent here Doth feem to be 
 an crp'.cfs Covenant, fojftfothcagiccnicnl cf both pattfca, viz. of the 
 !Lc(ro;{inDlie(ree, lud'iciumnifii S>D9 3 Benskin
 
 ^n Mich. 1653. 
 
 Benskin and Hcrick. 
 
 Micbf i($53, Banc,fup» 
 
 A Plaintiff DEnskin bjoagtt an fldfon of Debt upon nn£)bUsat(onflgafnl!H«rick. 
 
 1 .ft hib mcny •^j^jc SDcfcnoant pleaDD tftat be trnDjcB the monp cue apon tf)c £)bligatf= 
 
 »7if£ T'"* "" "^ ^^^ "^P ^"*' P*"" "^ papmcnt, ano tbat tbc ^lafnttfF rcfufco to recelbe 
 
 VetVia"-* 't- npontbistbc monp toaobjougbtfnto Court bp rule upon tt)C Dcfcn= 
 
 gainft him. tant0 mot<on, tbc ipiaf nt<ff jopns iffne tbat tb: re toac no tenoct ano rcfufal; 
 
 anD upon tbfs a SCrpal icas^ao, anD a tctofct founo foj tbc Defendant, tft.it 
 
 bcDlomahe tcnocr, anu tbat tbcpiafntlff oio tefufc torcccJtoct;c ino. 
 
 np, anu tbcrcupon ttjcDcfenoantmoteo to baljctbt monies out of Court, 
 
 ■Roll chief luftice, The Plaintiff hatli ioft hii mony 1 y thisverdiS, therefore 
 
 PereiT.ptory. '" ^'''" ^^^ ^'"^^^ "''^V ^'^' Defendant (hould not havs them, for it is percmp. 
 
 tory 10 the Plaintiff. 
 
 Franklin. 
 
 Miih, 1^53- Banc, fup. 
 
 Moiion fjr t^ tin Slaltn of iSccompt tbe )Dcfenoanttoaisat)lubri:ciitoac(ompf,ant> 
 Merchants to J[ atiD(to'}0 U)crc affligOLO. X^t Court loas motjco tbat tbcp teoulD «}D6t 
 AudiwrT** af ^° )opn fomc £»crcbant0 to tbc 3tto:ncp« on cftbcr Goc tobclptbcmto 
 fig«cT[o re*, mannage the flccompt.bccaufctbcilttojnepa lucre notsUtlfuH (nfucbba. 
 ctivc jnac- Gncffcfl. Roll cbief luftice, W^e can make no rule for this, butyoa.may by 
 compt. confcnt advife with Merchants to afsift you in drawing up the Accompts, 
 
 Mich: 1653. Banc. flip. 
 
 ^ , tip Roll cbief TuAice , onc tbat batb bcc« bamcb in tbc baMfl foj jFclonp, 
 in h: Lard'" «nap notU)ftbftanOira be a Uftncfcfn a Caufc : foj *jc bin acaparitp ta 
 may be a Wit- pUrcljafc HanDo, T-nD \)iii fault <s purgcD bp \ila puntOjment. 
 
 ncfs. 
 
 Townfend and Barker 
 
 Miclu 1 1:53. Biiv. flip. 
 Tria, j^5-3,rot,743, 
 
 * nf-Ownfcnd bjOHcfttan 0flfonnpoiitl)eCafcaira<nftBirkfr,tbnf ^atibixn 
 
 pdlVmew in " «Copattncr teitb \)im hi tr<i»e,to; fpcahfng tWt iuojes of hfm, You arc a 
 
 31 »^ion fnrcofen»ngKnav<,anddid cofenmeof 1 2ool.atonetime,'>nJ that was in making 
 
 ^tariii. an accotnrt intlw year 1(54^. t£lpon a tcr6<ii fo:tf)c piatntfff, U vuaa mo- 
 
 ijto fn «TTCft of 3fl0crcmcr.t that t^ t»o;Ds arc not fla{Dnablc,bccanfc tijongb 
 
 tbcp be fpofecn of aSCTa»cfman,rct thrp arc not fpoUcn of ijtm tn-rcfcrcntc to 
 
 W0 ELraoc, but Jn rcfercr te to an ^rtompt : ann aitbouc^ bp tcap of rcTjadi« 
 
 on antJ confcqacrtc tbcp map reflect upon iiiobontftr, ret tbr rare not attf- 
 
 onablc,nnB tnonc!) Vis reputation bcf inp.urcn bp fpcnhfng tljsm, pet be can* 
 
 ROt hi onoface fo? cefening <n Ijts Strccc bp reafon of tbem,bccanfc t'ocf 
 
 are fipo'acn of a finfutlar ano particular r;b;«fi% ano not of a general cofcning 
 
 iifccin Ui'J iI^raDc,nnDan aaton upon t^c Cafe Ucsnotfoj toojMtobfcbare 
 
 wtlp franBalous bp toap of reoa.ton, ano If tbetoojDaftoulBbfnDcrt^ 
 
 partp
 
 pattp to get a ^attnct tetc«ftct to traw tofttjWm, pet tjcmapofcfefe ^ 
 
 S^raoe, ano fo cannot be p;e|uttfcei) : no; are tbe too:>os t^at ije c^cateo bfm, 
 . tot tftat ftctotcneo fjfm, frfifc^arcnotof fotfolent aconttractfcin. Wild 
 on tite otiietttocrato, tbat Ijere in a IDartnerfljfp totfcbfanrccffarptotlie 
 o;ffrfngofa2Ltai)e,anotDiti)oatu^d)<t cannotbefotollo;(tcti, ano tbe 
 ;Slccompt <0 IntfDent to all partncrtbfps, ano pjapet fc? Jucgcntf tit. Roll 
 chief luftice , If the Copartnctfhip continued, tl.e words were adion^blc 
 withoor doubt, fo? tftcn tt)cp mntt be fpofecn of Wm <n t!)£ Uap of bfs 2Cra5C: (^ 
 bat here ttcpattncrlftfpbcfngenccomaUcfltftc matter moic c officer able: 
 bnt pet as tt fstl)e ttjojos ate francaloue.ano nraptjtntjcr Wm trom cetKng 
 a partner foj t^)C ttme to comc.ano (t map be l)c cannot mannapc t)ia SEraae 
 toft^out a partner; ano altfjoag^ an jaccompt be ap;ft3atct;,fnF,pcttl)c 
 plafntffff0 oirgracco bp tl>c fpcaKfng of t^c toojos, ano none iodl Deal ioitb 
 a man tbat lofll cofen ^(soU:n j[9artncr ; ano \» e muft cotmtcnattce2rra&« 
 ano JCraffiqae, ano mens creofto ; ano tbc 3ccompt is notfocollatcrr.la 
 t^fiiC to trase 80 Hales objects, aslstbebirfna of a fl)op to trdue (ti, o;t!;e 
 Ube. German lufticead idem, finijfaio, that «ropnrtncT(I)tp fariccetrarv to 
 fa(^?t Straw, an» t^e feccptng of a true Ilicompt in Wyi p;{iic(pal tl^hig be- 
 tween ^rtncrs, Nichola* ano Asklul^icesadidem, judtiium mfi pro 
 qoeretue. 
 
 Biid and Chriflopher. 
 
 Mitbf i^J3„ Bancfup, 
 
 10 tbffl Cafe upon fiibtng of an cWocncc in a Etrcfpafa anD Gicctmrnt. U Ex inpufft- 
 lDasfa(obpRollchi£fJui}icf,tbatif3liocnfeoff l.S. ujt{)ap)ot'ffocon."><'^t "t » 
 tafncT) tn tlje EDeeD,tit>at it ftall be iatofuU fo; me to ratohc tWc IFcoffment, J'^'^^jJ'; , 
 ano aftcrtoarOB 3 Icbp a fine to I. S. of tijcfamc ILano, ttjis fa an ej:tfn« '" ' "' " 
 SHfftment of t^c JD^otUo of tctocatfon. 
 
 Oliv€ and Tong. 
 
 iM'wh, 1653. Bine, fup. 
 Trm. 1651. rot. I^i6. 
 
 Vpon a fpecfal XitttUt in an 0<tioi] of CtcfpafiJ anQGfcament,tlj;^r5<-'»i Ver- 
 Cafcfn eiEc<ttDa0tt)te, )Onc tobofc fetrnamc iDasMiUs fctfcoofOa- -p,^rp"fs'-ni 
 Udfetntj-lanos fn Kent In fee, bp«B laft 52RUI ano Ccffamcnt cdMfetJEj.ancnt'. 
 tbeft LanUBto Elirabcth WfliDaugtjtcr tn tapl, iDttti a p:otfro in tl)c mm, 
 t^t<fW0 K)aagl)ltctlitsbetht)<Dmarponcofl)l3otoa feirnamc that tbcn 
 flic tlKinlD batctbe ILanosfn fee=fimplc. Eliiabetb marlco one iubofe &tr- 
 name toasMill, but commonlp calleD ano bnofaw bpt'gcnamc MilUalfo. 
 TOit qucCfon teas tobctbcr ftic tiao marfco one of fach a &f rname, tebere. 
 bp accojBfng tt t^c pjotKo {n tbctOIUfbelaD a fee Gmplc in ttjc 31 ancc 
 Detffco unto ftcr, 0; ti*et^cr^l0felrnamclbonlD be ercomptco a otttintt 
 name from the SErttatojo, fo that Elizabeih bp tic tKUilt coulo onlp bate an 
 ©Catt in tapl m tbe llanos ocUtfco unto bcr. 3t ioas argueo fiiff, tbat tbc 
 name Mill ano Mills fliall not be fato to be one ano tljc fame name, no 
 mojctbanfffljebaomarfcD one of a clear Dttrerfns Surname <n founo, pet 
 commonlp calleD alfo Mills, coulo fl»c bate been falDtobatcmarfeooneof 
 i)f0 oton fefrname , ano tbc pjotlfo bercfsnota partkiilar pointing out of 
 the oetfon iohom W JDangtJtcr fljoalo marp , but a general Umttatfon 
 *" *^ )DDD 3 Dircflfng
 
 '39O Mich. 165 3- 
 
 •ct«dlng~!jertomaTp one of t)fs oun &<rnanic , ano this oogbt to 
 
 featie been ptmauallp foUo\reo, bctaufe tbc name teas ufco to tnoucc tftc af- 
 fcitfon of tbc SDcWfo; to enlarge tbc cflatc gftjcn bv ^tm. 3f ^c bao octfCco 
 Jjffl ILantJ to bla DaiigMct E. If Ojc OjaU matp a |p;otcttant j an Garl, Hic 
 imitt marp oncttjat is3 tcallpfo, ano not one calleo oj onlp tcputcD fo. 
 jaii:< no totl)C obledion, tftot tftfatonff ruction VdouId mahe contrarfctt' tn 
 tDc tOiU, iD^fcl) <0 not to be aomfttco; tWo tofll not be, it tftc mni be tabcn 
 compofi'tve no tt tepcnneo, 0; together, ano not abftradive anbtaScnto 
 pictcfl ano If (t fljoulo not be IntcnocD tljat fljc Qjonlo marp one tobo in 
 initl) ma eiW name tljcrc tooulo be a tontrantctfon In tfte ©SfB? ano ftcre 
 <3 an empbnfls in tbc too jb Own, iubfcl) muft be meant W0 real name , ano 
 not of a rcputattije name. Roll chieflufticc, 3If a 3;tiro? be rctojnco bp tbe 
 name of Mills ano <o ftoombptbe name of Mill, fljalltWgbeamfttrpal , 
 quafi noni" anO tl)C tUOjOO fouilb alfUe 80 Baxter anO Backfter. J^t an Ot^Ct 
 tap tbe Cafe iras put again Lip H Ales, ano arnueo fo^ tljc jafaf nt<ff , ano be 
 maoc Dfbcrsf pofnts fn tbc Cafe, bnt 3 coulo not toell bear bfm: bat tbc on^ 
 Ip pofntfncaco on teas tbc point fo:merlpfpoben to, ano tbc fnmofbfa 
 ^tranmcnt uaa, tbat V:c arrfntbls Cafcupontbeconaructlonofamin, 
 tobic!) mnft be fa^ourablp taftcn, anotbctjarfatfonberebcttofrtKlilis ano 
 Mill ia rmaU ano fnconftDcrablcto ocfcat an eftatc , fo; <t fo onlp fn tbc tet. 
 wfnatfon of tbc too?o, anO faao lUtlc as tbc Difference bcttoeen Baxter 
 anOBackflcr, o: HaftinganO Haftin^s, 9^-4- 42« •44E''z- Wolyn anO Mo= 
 l^m, oj Pitt ano Pitts, toWtb Differ bnt fn one letter, ano fs not a material 
 tffFerence. 2lp. 3t appcarsj bp tbc tUcrofd: tbat be toaocommonlp calico 
 Mill ano Mills, ano common rcp'.itatfon toe hiioto ootb gibe nameo to tljfnga* 
 :!lr. Stiofounotbat bctoaaUnolnnbponenamc aotoellastbeotbcr, anO 
 tbis toill fatiefic tbc SLcttatojs fntcnt toell cnotigb to carrp tbe ©ffate, 
 4lp. jEbepartpMrnfclftoasltiiolrtntotbcJCcffatoj at tbc time of tbc ma. 
 feins of tl;c ^fll bp tbc name of Mills, aa appcaro fn eigbt fcbcral places of 
 tlie Mill, ano ffone ocbtfc lLanbsanD©ooBa,anDcj:ccptooneltcnre, if 
 tb€Teb:otbcr1learc0tbcpareDct)freo. 5lp. 3lt appears bp tbc OTfll ano 
 tbc tmsrofa.tbat tbc marfage toaa intcnoeo bp tbc jFatber toftb tb<0 Derp 
 porfon tbat is calico Mills, ano a fcttlcmcnt of ilanoamaoeaponit, anoft 
 (ball not be (ntenceo tbat tbc Ecttato; tbongbt tbat tbis marfage toonlo be 
 tiffolbeo ano anotbcr marfage bcbao. flnO tbcoctirc fntbeboopoftbc 
 tiiailiootbnotmal-^ctbcpjotirofntbcenooftbc^rJHm rcpognant, butifit 
 tfa the latt rcpagnancp Iball flano; fo; bcre fsnooepcnoancpoftbclaC 
 p:oviro apon tbi'otbct part of tbc ®n<ll , bnt ft fs a fnbftantioe c lanfc 
 ivbicb rct-ofecs not tbc otbcr , SDocroj ButsCafc, 10 Rep. anotbfslballbc 
 coiintrt)btolafttK3ill,anoitiBtbe mojcflrong, bccanfe ft appears bp tbc 
 tcrp I o:t)B,tb3t ft fs aplainftilttantitcclaafe maoc to Declare tbe ncto 
 f!:tcnt of tbc SCeCatoj, ano ft fball not be fntcnocD tbat tbfs |D?otiffo (ball be 
 applpco to another perron, altbougbtbcrcbeapartfcnlartftlcgitjcntobfm 
 fcp tbc wain, ano tbc Cttatc altereo bp tbc p?otjffo , ano tbc fo?mcr ocWfe 
 fjccrcgateobr'f , Hob. sO.Cafc, Hard in^s Cafe, ano tbc ftrcngtboftbc 
 p:oiifo to batiE one of tbc true name of Mills fa not to bcfntenoeo, fojft 
 appears tbat tbe intent of tbe sneCatojtoas, to bate one ofbfsnamcfnrcc 
 ptitntlon, ano tbis appears bp the fojmcrlfmftatlon in tbc ^111, ano tbe 
 p;oii(lon maoc fn tbe latt pjotffo to pjcferbe bis name , fs no mojc tban 
 that be bao Done bcfojc :anDtl;efojmcr limitation fa as toell foj tbc JTe- 
 Cntojsaotantefcss tbc latter IDjobifo, ano moje , ano bfo intent toaa not 
 tofell tbciLanCB,battop:erertt tbcm, anoitfanomojctofap of my own 
 Sirname, tban to fap of my Srnatrie, noj fs tbC videlicet anptbing to tbC ptir^ 
 pofe. Roll chief luftice, ff tfccquefifon tocrc onlp upon tbc ^?obffo, tberc 
 tooulo be no of fficultp bnt tbat M ill ano Mills (boulo be all onc,ano ft toonl& 
 
 be
 
 Mich. 1653 j^i 
 
 be 0009 in aContiepanceairo, as 31 ruppore,ano if ft isete apparent t^atfje 
 Intcnoet* one ano tbe famepctfon, tbentftelattpjoWfo tooaio be gooo to p,.„;j-^ 
 retJObettje former part of ttjjtilfflfH: but t^c ooabt is, Irftetbet fte (nteno 
 tiie fame perron o;not, becanfc t)e maiies fucb an alteration of tbe Cffate 
 bp tl)e |9;otiro, ant) pat>3 t^efe 100:100 mine own name fn it,bp tobicb tt feems 
 tie (ntenoeo to aobance t)<s olon name, ano ^e f<;cms era(t in it bp tbe great 
 alteration of tbe ©ttatc mane bp tbc ipjotifo in tbe ft ttlcmcnt of tbe ettate. 
 jat another oap tljc Cafe teas again niobeo ano argnzD bp Wadham Wind- 
 ham, t^at Mills $ Mill are bott) one name, ano Differ but in fonno, as Abacock 
 « Habacoci(,<~.ni) t^e tiHerDfct finos tbat bott) tbe names are bis trne 3>irname . 
 tbonc^ it f oulD not be fo inCft:fQiait names,6 Rep.ed.&irnamcs are altcreo 
 bp time ano C::irom of plcccs.ano bcins fo altreo do become true names, as 
 ttie i.ame of Cromwell is note become a trne name, tbougb antientlp tbe 
 name toaa Williams; but 31 agrec,tbatCbiiftian names cannot be altereo 
 bp time, no moje tban tbings can be altcreo from one tbing toanotber. 
 3lp. IBptbe con&cn(tionoftl)e^iU,anDbptbe finding oftbe aerDi(!,tbe 
 names are maoe one name, altbougt) bp tbe SCcffato; t)e toad bnoton bp no 
 otber name tban tbe name of Mills, fbj be is fo calleo, ano tbis anftocrs tb« 
 pjotjifo f n tbe tKHill, tbat be ftoulo be of tis oton &trnamc iiitb tebom bta 
 SDaagbter toas to marp. 4lp. I^cre is a particular oebife maoe toberin 
 tbe boDpoftbc^illoftt)eiLanDB,iftbepfl)oulDnot be oebifeo bere, 8 Rep, 
 
 Claufa {;eneralia nonextenduntadca qu-r lunt rpfcialiterrecitata;anDtbereia 
 
 a Difference bcttoeen a Mill anO a SDccD , foi -all tbe toojostnaJDccoare 
 
 fpoben togetl)er : bat it is not fofna tS{iuii?l)icbfsambulato}p, ano map 
 
 ftabe febcral conttructfons, anD one clatife map controll anotbcr, inftic. 1 1 2. 
 
 ano tbe iDjoWfo bcrc in tbe latt part of tbe OTill controlls tbe fojmcr part of 
 
 tbe Mill, as a Codicil roigbt babe Done, ff tbcre bao been anp , ano tbe bc- 
 
 rp itiOjDB crpaefs tbe parties meaning, i Rep. Porters Cafe , Dyer 255. 3;f 
 
 fn a ©Bill a claufe map receibe a Doubtful! coi Cru(tfon,tl>en a verb's non eft 
 
 recedendum, ro} fljalltbcre be a particular fupplpment of ti^ojDsaoDcD to 
 
 EVponno tt, crccpt to pjebcnt an abfurDitp, tnbtcb mutt not bcaomitteP, 
 
 thongb in a Mill. Msynard on tbe otber iiTje maDettooqueftions. j» 
 
 Mbctbcr Mills anD Mill fijoulo bctntcnOeDtobe one anD tbe fame &ir- 
 
 name.anDfotobetbcSEettatojs&irname. 2lp. Mbctber hiizabethtabc 
 
 tbe iLanos bp tb^ firft claufe fn tbe Mill, 0: bp tbe |D;ob(fo 0? latter claufe. 
 
 foi tbe firft be bclo, tbat Mills anD Mill is not one ano tbe fame &ir-- 
 
 name, becau^e tbe SCcttatojbaD a particular epeto bio oton true feirnamc, 
 
 ano tbe Cafes put of names tbat Differ, pet founn alf fee, no not come to our 
 
 Cafe , becaufe tbcre taas no fucb fpccial epe oj regaro as bere is. zip. &iip- 
 
 pofc tbat bfa true name be Mills, ano tbat be is pjotioco foj particularlp bp" 
 
 tb? Ccftatoj in bio Mill, tbcn tbe pjobffo cannot cttcno tobim, fojtbis 
 
 toonlD be fenfclciTc, ano ft fs as mncb as to make tbe JEeflatoj in one b?eatb 
 
 to fpcaU contraDfttorics , anb ff tuoulo be baro to make fucb conttruflfons of 
 
 fucb tooijatbat Venule argue tbcpartp to be irrational tbat fpahe tbcm,anD 
 
 tbe \DOios fn tb£p?obifo are fn nature of an ejxeptfon fn conftruttfon of Lato, 
 
 I J Ed. I . Fitib. Grants 87, ano Career anD Ringfteeds Cafe is not pet an* 
 
 ftorreO bp tbe otber CDe,Bolton and the Lady Staffords cafe,8 lac.C.B.i.rep. 
 
 MildmayesCafc. SCbetnojDsfna pjobffofna Mfll o> SDeeD map be fup* 
 
 plpeo tof tb otber foojBs, ratber tban to fnterpjet ft fo, ti>at;it fljall contraofd 
 
 tbefo?mcrpctrtottbcMilloj SDeeD tebere ft is, ano bp tbe conltruction 
 
 tbat toe mabe of tbe JOiotJffo all tbeMfll map ffauD togctber,faut bp anotbec 
 
 conttructfon ft cannot«Elizabetb QiaU babe a fpecfal entapl toftid bee l^usbano 
 
 bp tbe Uii claufe, ano pet tte general CCate tapl gfben fn tbe former 
 
 part fltjall Cano; nno Vdb are fn tbe fnterpjetatfon of Mflls to confioer eft - 
 
 camttancesanoconjcctutes, ano tl)cre arc ttoo publfcatfons founofntbio 
 
 Mfn,
 
 39a Mich. 1653. 
 
 teJH, alttjouGfitWflbctlmof appBiic upm UccojB, «rn» fo ftntatmtk 
 
 lUlJgClTliJnt. Roll chief lurtice, Wiare»ll ofoneopinioti,tiiSt iiMigtmcfii 
 ou^ht to bt oivmforttieDebcndairt, 3f tt)C flrtttlanfC h tljc t3HfU tonli. 
 Hue utTcoiittollEO by> tt)c 13,:ot)(fo, tt tafo: tl)eS:?ci"cnoant,lnitif jtfemf* 
 MUC nrt muonirollcD It la fo j tl)E 191a<iUff,ano Ujcljaiti tf)at tbcftrft tlaaA? (« 
 ttotcomrollcD, toi ujeuiinbtnottomaijcanp part of a tKli« ttofii, if aU 
 tljc parte of (t map ttiiiiD toftctbcr , aub tftlJ tnnnot be !Krc If tJje pjostfa 
 
 Rev.cjiioii. Ojoulo rontroB t^c fojincrport, aiiDto mm\c ftti:puatt«nt,lmt (f t%c jpjotrf. 
 focmilottfliiottm)tt)fcfd:mcrpaTtoftl|4 mtMlt infant rcuakc t^a fowncc 
 part, anoff ttffl j|Dji)\)(fo Dao been tflaoc after \%t SEllu , (t i«J$^)t Ijati 
 alt: rctttfic Cafe, batttiatapipcatBnot; ftno U)c uuift toliftt t»ie i^cRit. 
 
 i,itciuio!i. to;dnicai\fiigbptt)C^tU , anBtj'tticKJja (t x^mm be unoerftooo t^at 
 t1)c pjoWfo OjoirtD be Wfo , ano Hie tomnion rcputaiton of NWll ano Milu to 
 be tDc fame name, Wnll notm<jticMilltotjCi5>c SEcltatoie trdtfeftname, 
 ana ttjc Xcftato; (ntenoco l)hj D-iiicDttr Uku marrp C!t« of Ms oi»n rrw*: 
 ^frnaine, atio not one of t)fj rcputatli^e n^itttD , f^iltifsfda tfccUA (>TC| 
 anogot3iTotatfijjWngttitl>c oitsfwarp vAc-s of namco tf>at rowo atftip, 
 aittj ft cannot be fnteftoe'D tliat tl)C Hcaato : ofb '.nean to Dctlrop one part of 
 f)i0 Vofti bp anollKt part. iS aciiirat claurcfn a grant Cjafl not crtcwn to a 
 partftiTlar tWngpjoftfotD ro;iin tic grant, muc!) izftj i^au ft do fo hi a waia. 
 I liereforc lee judgeme'nc be for the DeftncJanc, nifi» 
 
 Mich. 1652 Banc. fup. 
 
 A jji SLUio'A oftljsCafc tD'fi b?ttigi)t Op one tbat hept a afftaafiftrs 
 iJdccmentM -^ftonfc Jo J fpcnlifng ttjcfc Ujoj«3 01 ^Cr, There wm a mnn killed in her 
 ai« Aitijn f, Soulier , and (he concealed the marcher, Clpon a nrtc to Cap ja3(fement 
 wo.at. tfll tbe pafntff (boulQ mote ; Wild mobto fo; Mtogcntcnt, bccaufc fte fjcio 
 tbc taojos to be actfonablc, fii tijat tljcp amount to a ftantial of tfje ^Wntff, 
 Fine. ao iucU aa t!,cp tcnD to caufc l;cr to be fincDtxio impjifoncu. Roll chief 
 
 iiiipiifon- Iu(licc,fefte (Uallnot bcftnco anolmpjifxinco erccpt Cie izceVoz am roftifon 
 '""". the partp that txfileo hmi, bat tijc toojDo arc fcanKalons, ano the Cafe 
 
 tiffferfl from tl)c Cafes pat ontije other floe. TwiiJen foj tlic Dctrnoant 
 urgco , that ft toaa not afjstrc9 that tl)i|)lahitffDfD Iwein of tt)t mtrttlirT. 
 , Roll chief inftice, SCbc iiJojostmplp Ore knetu of the martljer, fo; i;aJB 
 
 clfeconloibebcfaiato concral tt. Bowlftrode fo: tljt JDcfenoant fata , 
 SChatitDotbnot appear bp the Kecojl) that anp man iBao fefBcu in the 
 hotife, nojanpt<!"cU)hcn, no; is ft fafo the SMcnoant fpcttc the teojoa 
 ore 0iX\iC piatnttf , but onlp bp an innuendo. Roll chief iuflire , '3l^ fc»o;Os 
 
 are artfoiiable to fap that thoti half murtbcreo a man, to^Mront atcrrfi'; 
 that he fs kiUcD J but if ft app;ar bp the SDeclatatton that the man toi"? a'-i-ii 
 after the teojDfl fpokcrt,ftif6ott)crta>tfc; Bno here f'ro man be mirthcrco 
 thcfct«n<ngofafarrettrf«gmaKcfltheh)o;ftsthc mo-!e aatonabic, bpfap* 
 fng Itjc conccalcD a muTther, tohcrc there t^as intrnth rrt m irth^r Bonc • 
 But the greatcft houbt here fa . tohctber bccaufc aemftting a mAiM}tt toctc 
 Done, the plafntff fa to be but fineo ano f mpaffoneo fn: t;)c rorccriUru ft , the 
 teojDscanbcaitfonablc; anoSholo the? arcartio»rf»b!c nottofthftaftcfnri, 
 hni.amriv bccHu'c thcp are 'cattUaloua ; auohefafotbat in an iS'trs*(tm':nt , a thing 
 Dcc'atxAm. muft be CtpKffc3 to bc oonc faifoet mahriofe.brcatifcinat ic the ufanlfojm, 
 bat fn a Declaration thofc toojDs arcnotncccffarr, Tlicrefore ie: che Plain* 
 tjffaavc his ludgeraenr, nili. 
 
 Mich,
 
 Mich. 1653. 3^3 
 
 Mich. 1653 Banc. fup. 
 
 IC tuaa ^elo bp tftc Coart tftat a Conttafale cannot be facB out of t!)c Conn« ^ ^'^ b'^r* d 
 tp to^ete^e ta ConCablc foj a tiling oonc bp ^(m in crcctitlon of ^f« j^ffitCj "ut' ot hi'^s "' 
 but fo} otl^ei matters ije map» Coumy. 
 
 Elflon and Drake. 
 
 Mich. I tf J3 . Banc, fup, 
 
 ELfton bjong^t an dafon of SDebt fe^ rent one upon a leafe fo; pears , as Errorco re 
 befng aomlnfflratoj to i. s. ani) Declares fo? rent ouc Cinct t^e Dcatl) of verfe a ju<!fc- 
 tbe f ntettatc , ano ^th a tertte ano a juogemcnt (n tftc Common Ipleag. '!'*"* '" "^'^^ 
 Drake fajlngs Ws twit of (Stroj^cre to rctJcrfctWs tuDgement. %U (tt- '°'""'' 
 ceptfon taben Inas, t^at U ootb not appear bp tl^e 2)ecIaratfon tDliet^cr t^fs 
 rent fneo foj ootb belong to t\)t aomfnfCratoj oi not, fo j be mahes WmfcU 
 no title to It, anD foj ong^t Dotft appear It map belong to tbe tjefr ano not to 
 ibim. Wadhara Windham on ttie ot^cr Ooe 5 EJjfs Is no erccptfon nolo af* 
 tct a CSertid , tint (fit bafi been upon a loDemurrer it iJooalQ tiabc been goo, 
 ant) toe BO not Declare t^attI)e3;nteSate teas feffeD in fee tc^o maDe t\ii 
 teafe, ano fo ft map iselibe nnDerftooo,tt)at^e baDbat alcafe of t^fs lano, 
 iDfoletanniiDer leafetotlieSr^efenDant; ano tgc better conQmctfon (ball 
 be maite fo^ us. H3letbntberameQDefafD,nondetine:ispicaDeD,anDtl)e 
 3!urpbatbfonnDdeciaet^ tsbicb tsoulD be {mpofsiblc if tbjc Bintettatc bat) 
 been feffeo in fee , ano t^ere is a Double fntenDment ttiat tlie rent is refec< 
 Deo upon a Icafe , fo^ it is referteo to Cjtecntors , ano not t^e heir. Msy- 
 nard on tl)e ot^er fioc faio , the TiacrDict helps nothtna, bccanfe the SDecla* 
 ration is naugbt in ftibftapce in out cafe; foj the piaintff thcrcfn bath mace 
 bimfclf no title to the rent , auD all that is in the Declaration to fntitlc him 
 Is cjcpjcffcD but bp ioap of inference 0; conclufion, ano foj the refcrbing 
 the rent to the Crecators , this haD been good if the rent hao groton Due on- 
 ting the time of the Jntettate. The Court moved the partiei , chat by con.^'"'""^*""'^' 
 lent tbe Declaration might be amrnded, paying cofli, and thai a new tryalrcft\' 
 inightbehadby confenc, which was agreed unco, and lb ruled. 
 
 BeJwell and Fenvviek. 
 Micfa. 1655. Banc, fup, 
 
 BEdwellbjought an Slflion upon the cafe agalnflt Fenwick, anb Declares a rcfi o{ 
 that the ©efenoant, in conltoeratlon that tie paintiftuoulD marrp ju^pement in 
 E* ^&itter, he tnonlo gibe his feifter 300 1. fo; her mariagc pojtion,'" ^^'°" ^''•^ 
 Bpon ^9 mart age tDfth her , ano fbjb; each of this pjomife bifnaa his 3='"' promifc. 
 ttion , an* obtains a bcrDfct agafntt the SPefenoant. SEhc Deenoant in 
 Strrcft of Snogcment nrgeD,that the bjeach alsignco intheDcclaration toas 
 not toell afflignem.foj ft recftCD another pjomife than upon tohfch the pain, 
 tif hao DcclareOjfoi he ordares of a pjomlfe maDe to gf'jc 300 1, in mariage 
 to the paintif iBith Ma &f(tcr E. anoheafsignsthe fajcach in not papfng 
 the 3 00 1. unto the jDlaintf f, fo that the bjeach Doth not anfujer the pjomife, 
 fojifthemonrpbejjafDtothcvrffe, tihfthfojoiigljt appears map be, the 
 pjomifc is not baotxcn though Qjc be marpeo, 3i5ut Hales on the other ilDe 
 Md, thatitisauoncasftfsaueaco, anothatitfscqnfbalentan9recip:o. 
 
 Cee c<tl,
 
 394 Mich. 1653. 
 
 tal, anoftcreTfl a refafal to pap t!je monep, afsfgnco foj a b jeacft , antt tW« 
 Is a gooo bjeacft. Roll chief iuOice,3i fuppofc it is all one as if be tjao cps 
 pjcffcDtt)cticrptDOjDsoft!)cp:oir<fc, foj tl;c l^nsbano <6 toalfec tbcac- 
 
 Acnuitrance ' nutttatitc (0% ti)t moncp , anD tftc moncpsarc to be paia onto tbc l^usbano , 
 
 "^ anD tbc actDla Rnos ttiat ti)'p are not patD : ilno <f morvcps be cue to a 
 
 J^cmc upon n Contract dun (ol I 'uit, ano after, ano bcfoje ti)C pnpmcnt 
 
 tbcteof ftcmarrp , tl)emoncpsar£tobcpa(at>tf)v l^iisOano.nnD not tljc 
 
 p raent ^'f" ' ^"^ ^^^ Hioncpo bcrc arc intcnDcD to be paiD fo? a martagc pojtion , 
 jjraent. ^jj^j^jj Qotbpjopcrlp belong totbcbncbano , ano tbrp tocre not to be pafo 
 unto bet befo je tbc mariage , nno tt Is all one In t¥^ vEarc as If t!ie |Dlaln< 
 tlfl)aDfalD,tbattbcSDcfcnBantbaD not palQ tbemoneps to tbc l^usbana 
 t)(tb l)ls Mllfe In marlage : Curia ad idem, The Rule thereupon was, that 
 the Flaintif Ibould take his jud^emenr, nifi, 
 
 ♦ 
 
 Hicks and Joyces 
 
 Mich, »d5 3,Binc. fup, 
 Arreft of A -^ ^^^^^ °^ ^^^ ^^^^ ^^^ b?oncI)t foj tljefcloojDfl , She, meaning t^e 
 
 judgement V, ./ \ HDetcnOant, is a whore, and I willproveit, and her plying place it in 
 an Aftion fuiCheapfide , ?,nd Ihe gets 40 s. a niqht by playing the whore. %t toas tno* 
 words. teBlnatreftof^iiDgcment, t^iat tbe icojDs ate not aalonable, becanfe 
 tftepatebnttDojtsoftbolct, anotjctp genctal Idojds, ano map tccclbc 
 tibers confiructfoits , anDattbcfirftmoblngtbe jnogement teas ttapeo ; 
 but tbe mattet being motjcD again at anotbct oap , Roll chief luftice fala , 
 thattbcrctoojcglmpojt'mojctbnn tbc barccaUfngofatooman Uiljo^e , bp 
 Tcafon of otbct particular cirtnmflanccsfitfoatb to aggratjatettie mattet, 
 anO ti)CtCfo;e lu the Plaintif take her liidgernent. 
 
 Townefend and Barker. 
 
 Mich, 1653. Banc. fup, 
 
 Trin. id53« rot, 74J» 
 
 Arrtft of A^ action upon tbc Cafe tnas bjongbt bp a (X !)urcljtoat&cn of a ^arf (6 , 
 
 judpcmtnt in-'^fojttlcrctoOJtBfpofeenofblnt J Thoudoft make Lowns ( i.e. taxei or 
 
 anaaiontor affeffments ) thy felf, and ma kefV 5 quarters in the year, and dofl cheat and 
 
 '**"''*• cozen the Parifti. 3[t toaa mobcD In ^tuft of Juogcment tijat tbe inoioa 
 
 are not actionable, bccanfctbepare fpofecn ofaCburcbiDarocn.lDblcbtbe 
 
 Common Hato tabes not notice of: ^noilp. Jntbat It Dotl> not appear 
 
 tbeptDCte fpofeenofbl.IT In relation to bis being a Cburcbtoaroen ; But It 
 
 toas anfUjeteo , SCbat a Cbartbtoaroen Is an £)fficcr of aCtuft , anD taken 
 
 notice otbptbe Common 3laU), ano To Isas It aoinogcD In Stroade anD 
 
 Homes bis Cafe In tbis Court, ano tbe \oo%nB mud be IntenoeD to be fpofeen 
 
 of bim In the relation to bis iDffice, fojtbatis Implpeo bp bis making of 
 
 lloiDnsanDbfscoajeninstbclparlQ). The rule was for the Plaintif to have 
 
 hit judgement. 
 
 Mich; 1653. Banc. fup. • 
 
 Fn.rftiient A ^ Ctttildmenf of one cntjfctctjfojtefiiftng to ferbc In tboSDfficc of a 
 quifticd. /ll^caDboiougb tDasquaftjetj, bccanfeltuisnotfljciD tbat ftctoaacbo* 
 A<idicbn. fen to tbe £)fftce , anobecaufetbc partp enbfctco toanteo an aoottloni 
 
 Mich,
 
 cure at a 
 cot. 
 
 Mich, id 53. ^ 39 5 
 
 Mich. 1653. Banc. fup. 
 
 Tfte Contt teas motjeo to Difcftarge one Cullini,tftat faasatrcffcD as ftc ^^ 
 lr«0 attcntfng tDe Court togftctcafmonp (i5amitnt{6ina€satc,l^J,l^X'^^' 
 ano fo; an attachment againtt t^e parties tbat m arrcft l^fnt. German lu. atrendirp; -i . 
 ftice abfcntc Roll chief luftice. Take a Superfedeas , aad let the parties Court a: 
 (hew caufe why an Attachment (hall not be granted againft them that arrefted ^""'^\ 
 
 ,- ' o a Supeifcd 
 
 »""'. Aitadmcrt. 
 
 Hanflop and Johnfbn. 
 Mich, jjjj.Baaofup* 
 
 T^t Court Uiafi mo^en to change tfte tjcnnc fn an E j'efiione firtnx la(D fit to charge 
 London, becaufc t^e JLanDg in ©ucftfon Dfo concern tbel0oojofLon.thcVe,uc m 
 don, ano tberefojc(t teas fnppofcDtbercccalD not bean fnDfffcrentSCrpal^^^^^J'""" 
 fn London, foj bp confeqacncc in tbat it concerns tbe JDm j , ft concerns tfte 
 Indole Cftp» 315at Roll chief luftice anfwered, the Adion is local, audit Aftion local. 
 cannot be removed, except you can draw it from thence by your Pica. Venue. 
 
 Boyle and Scarborough, 
 
 Mich, 1(55 3, Banc, fop* 
 
 Hill. 16$ 1, rot, 22(5, 
 
 Ai^ jSttfon ofSDebttoasbjouabtbp Boyle aftafnC Scarborough, luljcre- Error tnre- 
 fn m piafntfflf bfo Declare, tliat the 3?:tenDant fn conQocratf verieaju^r- 
 on tbattfte plafntfff tnonlD fojbeat to foe fojtt) a ne exeat "gnuralTnri^iJ- ' 
 agafnS tbe E>efenDant0 &on , lobo Dfo otoe unto the )dla(ntf{f fit^e J i^. 
 ^unojeb ponno,t)io alTamc ano p^omife untot!}epUfntffFa certain Tutu 
 of monp eirp^effeo fn tlje SDcclaratfon , upon nonafrumpfitplcaocD, ano 
 a tjeroftt ano a jnogcment gften foj tlje pinfntfff, the IDcfcncaiit bjougt)t 
 a tiUatft of Crro?, ano ft teas afafgnco foj (lI;rroj;2i:bat there appears no 
 confiDcratfon to grouno the pjomtfc upon,$ to no gronno ofilctfon.fo} fte ootli 
 not IbetD tdat be 4aD Done anp thing fn p^ofccuting t^c ^rtt of ne exeat 
 regnnra, anD Rofyer anD Langdales Cafe 1650. fnflfa Court irascftcD, 
 ano Hob, 215. Bedwcll ano Cottons cafe, ano there fs no fuch QHrft fntljc 
 Regifter,a0 a ne exeat rcgnum,anD tl'crefojc there coulD be no fo;br&rancc to 
 fue out fuch a Mrit , buttherefsa Wrfttogfte fecurftp not to 50 out ol 
 tfje IRealm to the publfqiie picfuDfce of the fefnct ano hfs people , ano here is 
 no fuch matter crpjcffeo, but onlp that his «>oii otoco him s 00 I. 5 Nat. Brev. 
 8f, 1180 agrecD; anD ft teas farther objettcDbp Wild tuhoargueo agatnft 
 the SuDgement, that though the conGoeratfon fhoulD be gooo , pet the rcplf- 
 catkin fo not gooD ano fuffiticnt to tpe the fccono tuarit to the firft : fo; ft it 
 not fafo that the fetono Mrft fo pro una ^ eadem caufs, ano fo it is fnccrtaf tr, 
 Br. Trcfpais 85. 9 H. 6, anD there map be fcberal pjomffes maoc fn one Dap-, 
 ano ff the rcplfcation fs gooD, pet the retopnDcr fs not gooo, 1 9 H. 8. 4 ? ■ fo? 
 he onlp aomfts, that he being a tonight is the fame perfon tohich 'uas fuco bp 
 the name of Efquire , Hob. 171. Stukelycs Cafe anDhercfa aluogc- 
 incntbpaNihildicit;anDnoU)arrantoffltto?np. fojftfsfn JLatiii, anofo 
 ft fs nul,ft being ftncc t^c late act maoc fo; the pjocccofngs fn iLalr> to he in 
 
 €CC2 Cii5'
 
 ^9^ , Mich. 1653- 
 
 ^" "~~*CninET^tch~ort'ti:cot^ct fnc piapeo tlfat jtragcnf nt might be affirmeo, 
 anofafo.tliatticrctuajsagoD confiKratfoit to srouiiD ttjcp;omfrc upon, fo; 
 there is a COrft of nc (xeat re^nun-,ano ani' one map movc foj it, aio it Is a 
 benefit to ttje partr, t^it tljf plaintiff itill tojbrar to fwc It fo;tl), am Ije ftao 
 tnufc cnouct) 1 ert to motjc to; tijts CClrit in o;t;cr to rcco^jci m Otbt , ana 
 flltljoKCiJ) it'bc in t5)'; tlfcrctlon ct tDc Islnct , \3i cttj. t fte li,iU gvcnt it oj not, 
 ret Iti'^fo; l)li3l)oi'OJ to ciautit,ariO tbc lUpificr ipj. 134. nno IJnt. joi. 
 mnUc inrutioii of ttts tGttt, Init.r. 130. SLSjcrc is a caution ufcD to be tahcn 
 ofparticsliccnfctJtonobcporiOfecacr, ttjatttjrp tljall paptMr Debts. 2lp» 
 Et)C replication Is coiO, foj itisr.ot nccctfarvtofap, tint tl): fLConDojIut^ 
 nal ftico fo;t:) isfoj tl)C fninc tca'e tl)atttcfojmcr loas, bctaufc it is 
 ill an Action ispon tt)C Cnfcfct fo;tl) at large, Uiiji'b HicIbb verbatim tljat ft 
 is fo: 't'oe fame catifc, ano fo it is plain (n it fclr. alp. 3it is falD. tl;at be 
 facD outtl)C feconD O^itinalprocsuiapracJidii, ivl)!Ci) is a fcjificicnt abets 
 mcnt, if there neccco anp. ano tt?;; tatiarte in t5)c oammacrc is no arsumcnt 
 I'ljat tl)cre is ar.otljcr caufc of Sldtor, £oj Uben tljc fccono £>.:i(;iiial toes 
 fuvD fo?tl),tl)C DPrnmagcs lucic crxreafco bp tljc ciicicafc of tfte time, being 
 a lyi)olc pcft aftctluaras. i^ojt^; tetopnoer, it Is to be coi-.ftoereo,i. 
 U)hai)cttl)cp''TtpbecfioppcD. zip. 3:fnct,u>Utl)tt tbc matter fctfojtU 
 bcctooiD. i?o>tl)efitftl)cl3clo, that l)C is tfioppco bp!)t3tcmminglnfo?= 
 mc'rlp c'acis as ar.C!q'.iirc,an3 being not bjoi:£i)t in in cuHoop.fo jDyer,i 9 ». ' 
 there he aiallt.otplcao another name : bat here tfjfs is not aliegeo asit 
 o'jnht to' be, fo: he o'^«"W to I avc cor.cluDca abique hoc, that he is an CLfquirc, 
 but he hath atfirm:D hdnfclf to be an Crqiiire, bpfapingofp cdiaus^c 
 ano hconahttohateailegcDthis!p:cia«p, viz. that Richard B-mIc iSnigirf, 
 V b'ch fuas'fueo bp the name ot R chard Bi.ile efquirc; ano the JSooU 2 E.4» 
 f - i3 agalnft the other lEoobs, anD the ILato is othcritales, ant) theolo 
 ^ooU of entries, ano other pjefiocntsVuhichare agafntt me, tljcppaf- 
 fco fub filentio auD thclLaiugcnerallp Isngair.atljefepjcQocr.ts.Raftal 
 Crier". S4. 19 H.'d- '. ;6.44' fap,that ftels tttoppeo If he fo come In, anofo 
 fsBr Tit. Defer.ce, 15 N :6.3: H.6. 3. 35 H.6. ano manp cfger IBoohs; 
 anothc51Bool-ofi9H.6.4:j.ur5Ci5ontl)C other floe Is acalntt tljeui; ano 
 thouofahc Qoulonot b: cftopp:D,pcttDc can tattc aDbantagc oftbcfirtt iDjI. 
 oinarfojlt'l8batabatcablcbpt!icC^irr,ormcr, ano is notcbatXD, ano there 
 fa a fla\D In the rejopnner, fo: h= cncht to hate tratjrrfeo that be teas not an 
 Cftiutrc. i!n0 2lp. tbe zrtb- of March is after tbcOjIsinalfuco fojtb, 
 
 Diinmjgcs. 
 
 W. 
 
 cntrp ofttjcmi. 
 
 Warrant of ^tto;ncpbefc:ctlie3a;te, Ton. g lac Morlev ancMoricyiii 
 
 this Coi'tt • iKt. is not t!)e er.trp the izanrrant it fcif , but onlp an cr.trp 
 that be Is £tto?np bp ecintrant.ano fo be p;apco tbcaifirmancc of the iuog- 
 mcnt Roll chiei luiHce , Jf one bjing a mm of loio 1. ano it be abater, 
 arobMnos another mritfojt.c fame ocbt < can ymi cncreafc tlj: oam- 
 maacs acctueo between tb-: f.fft a^^J ;^c f"ono mrit;- Jt cannot be, foj tte 
 f£co"aoi3lnittbCTeVi^lngoftbcfiraciniit.anDnotancj3 Mlrlt; but bete 
 are citcrs points confiocrable, ano fit to be fpohcn unto ?. nc exeat regnum 
 is a fCrit ufiwUp fnco fonh .iltl^ougbtbat o:irl!iaUp it toas onlp ufeo inCa- 
 fes of &tate bufincars. tberefojo the fo;b:aranre tcrucitfojtblsagooo 
 connocration. The Co-ari; advif.-d to cak^ a new Pica to try ctic matter, 
 Pi>flea, 
 
 Mich.
 
 _^___ Mch. 1653. jQ-y 
 
 Mich. 1653. 
 
 A^ CEnDfctmcnt Uja3 p^cfttren agaiuft otic foj tcaoftig tbc IB00U of ^"^ ^"'^*^- 
 Common pjapcr , ano ft toas motoeo to be quaiTjco upon tbfs ejccptf- "!,''"' ^"''^' 
 on, viz. t'jat tt)e Cnolctmciit Dfo not fap tbat Ije reao jt pubUqiiclp : but 
 onlp fa(D, tUat ijc leao <t tJoluntarUp. Anduponcbisitwasquaflicd. 
 
 Mich. 1553. Banc. fup. 
 
 OJlc CaptaJn Streeter tommlttcD bptlje Conned o'&tatc, anobptfec 
 i^atUamcnt , (oj publlflifng feottfona jaampoUtr, to tftcLate^houie pJ'^^^'P- 
 atWeflminfter, toag bjongbtfntoCourtbpa Habeas Corpus, anotljcrc-a H^btaj^"" 
 turn reao ant) pjapcD to f^c fileo bp tfjc JD jf(onet, \x)W^ inas grantcDjiDbcrCs coii-us. 
 upon be p^apeo be miijtit baiic a Copp o( it,li)bicb luaa grantcOi t^cn De p;inp^ 
 eo be migbt be bapleo, but luas oenieD^anDiieloasturneDotieT to thti^iv-. 
 ftjal of tb(0 Xourt, ant) not cemanDco, bccaufe upon fiKng of tbe JRetojn tbc 
 Court Iras ft (fco of tbc IRccojo.ana tbc pjffoner , ano b^ toas oj&creo to 
 be bjousbt again Friday foUolotng, to be bcaro Uibat be coulD fan againft tl;e 
 ](leto}n. 
 
 Farmer and Lawrence. 
 
 • Mich- l<553»Banc.fupt 
 
 "bArmer let a Cbambcr ano a Clofct ItftbOt ft to Lawrence fromfutba * k* , 
 •■^tfmc, to bolo as long as Ibt; ftoulo pleafe,papfng tberetoje pcarip as mucb !!iZLc% ia 
 a3ftfl)OHlobcrcaronablptoonb,anDtMatDasbpparoll; aftertoarCB Farmer ^ft on cf 
 bjongbtan Safonfoj tbetentoftMsCbambct ano Cloftt, ano Ditiarfs'^''-'fof rent. 
 upon tbfs iLcafc,ano aljcrs, tbat (be bclotbcfafo vTbainfaet ano Ciofct 
 fromfacbatfmetofucb atfme, ano tbatfoj tbattt:nc it teas rcafonablp 
 toojtb fo mucb, ano foj not paptng tbat rent be fajongbt his Qaiou , ano ob- 
 tains a tactolttagafnft tbc JDcfcnoant. gt ioas motico fn arrcft o! tuone. 
 iticnt, tbat ft fs allcgcD fn tbc SDcclaratfon tbat OjcbclotbcCbanibcr 3*110 
 Clofct from fucb a tfmc to futb a tfmc , but ft ootb notabcr,tbatf!)cbslDft 
 as long aalbcplcafeo, as tbe agreement teas. Roll chiefJuftice, SEbc olo 
 315oofe3 are, ffSletlLanbtooncfojaslongas iic picafetb. ft ft).iH bcfnrr r •„. 
 tcnocD as long as botbpartfes plcafr, ano bcrS QjaUbcfntenocDttjattbs " '" 
 JCerm teas oetcrmfnco, cicccpt pou bao fljetoeo tbat pou tooulo babe belo 
 tbe Cbamber ano Clofct longcr,ano ff tbe tfmc be oetcrmfnco, pon otjjbt to 
 pap p;cfentlp as mucb ag ft fs rcafonablp U)o?tb , f f no tfmc be crpicfTco fo j 
 tbe papment tbcrcofj ano tbc abcrmcnt ougbt to be on tbc fl) fcnoants . 
 doc , viz to aUcgc tbat tbe pafntfff ofo not fuffcr bet to bolo tbe C -am- ^^""^^"^• 
 bcr ano ClofCt Co long as Qie pleaieo, ludgement was given for tbe l^lain- 
 lifF, nifit 
 
 Mich. 1^53. Banc. fup. 
 
 MEmorandum Colonel JBarbttecO Lieutenant of the Tower of JLonOon, ^y^^y , p,ir„. 
 came into the Court and produced an Order of the Counlel of State, ncr was not" 
 chit he fhould not brinp Jobn ILftbojn to the Bar upon a ^abeas Cojpua di- b -^"eht upon 
 r«ded ro him out of this Court. jjJojbnrp of Counfcl with the Prifoncr' ^"''"^ 
 prayedforan^lfacbabcasCojpustobe diredcd to him. Roil chief /u- ^°'''"'" 
 
 CCC3 fticc.
 
 398 Mich. 16 53- 
 
 ftice, jnakcft,fojnomattcrof3Rcco?o appearo bcfojc m to ^fnoct (t , anD 
 let It be CCtntneO Saturday ncrt , which was chre« days afcert 
 
 Norton ami Ja(bn. 
 
 Mich, 16')$, Banc.fup. 
 Tfin, 1651. rot, 935 < 
 
 ;"<gcnunt m Ti^ att 3.<tton upon tbc Cafe foj cntring into t!)c plafinffs boufc, nni ma. 
 
 a" actio,, oii lu<ngana(raultoponl)(3 2Dau0htct, ano gcttfntt a J5aftarD Ctjtlo upon 
 
 ihcCifc. t>cr,tl)e3latpfounDafpc£(altierD{(t, upon Ini^fcbt be Cafe toaa tl)f0, Nor. 
 tonfojournco fntbeboufcofjafon, anDDarfngblsfojwirnfngtbcrc ti» got 
 !)<3 SDauglitcr toftb Cbtlo ; j^our pears after lafon bjougbtan actfon up- 
 on tbc Cafe aga(nC Norton fojnffaultfng Wa 2Daugl}ter, ano getting bet 
 inftb CbUD , per quod fcrvitium amifit. SDbe queftfon bcre \paa, tDljctbet 
 bccanfc no JJcton ujas bjongbt bp tb: SDaiigbtcr fo; tbc tojong Done to ber 
 I'Jtbm fonr pears , ano tbercbpfijciiasbr.rrcDbp tbe fetattifc of Umftatf- 
 ons or anions to b?<ng ber 5lct<on, lafon tbeiFatbcrm<gbt noin bjfng bis 
 Bctfon upon tbe Cafe foj the Damage Done to bfm bp ttje lofs of bfs SDangb- 
 tcrsfetWte , 0? JboulD be alfo barreobptbc Sitattitc. Powi* argncD, tbat 
 be teas not barrco tbougb tbc SDatigbtet toas , bccanfc tn manp~cafc0 tbc 
 ILaiBgftcsttuoactfcnsfoj one tt:.fng, ano cftcD 19H. 6.45, ^6. a. ano 
 Hill. i649.NorburietcafcaD)uDgcD{ntb<0 Court, anD fafo , tbat tbougfj 
 tbcSCrefpasanotbcacraulttDaflDonctotbcSDaugbter, pet bcre fa a per 
 . quod icrvitium amifit DcclarcD Of, tob'cb Dotb belong to lafon tbe iFatbcr, 
 
 Roll chief luftice, SLbfs i^rtfon IsanBctfon bjougbt foj tbe Damage Done 
 to tbc spatter, ano tbougb tbc fertant tofll rclcafe tbc battcrp, pet tbe 
 fpaOcr map batic an ai!l<onfo} tbc Damage caufcD to bfm bp tbc llBatterp, 
 anoaltbougb tbe BDaugbtcr cannot babe an Sttlon, fjcr i?atbcr map, aU 
 tbotif.bnotfojcntrfngfiitobtsboufc, bccaufe f t tras tnftb bfa leabc, no; 
 fo?atfanltmgbf0 2Daugbtcr,anDgEttfiig bcr uftb tbflD, bccaufe tbfo ts a 
 lc?ong parttcularlp Done to bcr, pet foj tbc lofs of bcr ferbfcc caufco bp tbf0, 
 be map babe an Sialon , but ft ia a pjettp cafe, ano fit to be argucD , tbere. 
 fo jc bjtng uo boobs, anD toe totll aobifc upon it, !3.t anotber oap tbe cafe 
 toas again fpohen unto bp Baldwin of tbc Inner SCcmpIc on tbc 2Dcfcn= 
 tantspart, anDbemaDetbJqucCfonto be, lubctber tbfs be an ^aton of 
 SCrefpafa vi ct armis , oj an 0ctfon upon tbc Cafe totfcb fs bere bjougbt , 
 
 ^^^^ auD be argucD tbat ft fa a JErcfpafTe vi et armis , ano not an 3ctfon upon tbc 
 
 Cafe tobfcbfo bcre bjougbt, ano tttcD Nat. Brcv. 86, & 17 Ed. 3. anD 
 12 H. 4. ano tbc 9 Rep. tbe Carl of Shrewsbury cafc, ano fafo, tbat tbc 
 matter berc allcgco fs not Caufa caufans , but Caufa caufata, anD be agreco 
 tbatonemapbclpableto tftcro batons foj one 2Crcfpafs in Dfbers rc- 
 fpcrts, but bere all tbc matter fsjumblcotogctbcr, ano ft cannot be anja* 
 flfon upon tbc Cafe , fo> the luDgcment ougbt to be quod dcfendens capia* 
 tur,tebftbfa tbe Bluogemcnt fn a Ercfpafs vi ct armis, anD not fn a SCrcfpafa 
 nuon tbc Cafc , Hob. Rep. VVheatly ano Stones Cafc , 3nD altbougb tbe 
 3(tfonconcluDCU)ftbaper quod fervitium amifit, pet ft founoa moic fjl 
 JCrefpaffi t'aan to be anactfon upon tbe cafc ano tbcn be is barrco bp tbc&ta« 
 tutccfUmitatfon0,fo:notb;fngingfttDitbin4 pears, ano berc arc f ntirc 
 Damages alfo gitjen fo:all, 'mbftb ougbt not to be , foi tbc SDcfcnoant 
 luas a fofourncr in tb^ plaintiff boufc , anD bao licence to enter into it, % bp 
 confcqnence ia is not gufltp of tbe vi et armis DcclarcD,of Hob, Andrews anr» 
 
 de
 
 Mich. 1553, 3^9 
 
 delahopc, aiEliz.Dyerj^p. aolac Rhetorick anD Ctiapeh Cafe, anO 
 tljctcfoje noDammagegousljfto batte bccii gibtti fo? t6c domuTi fregir,be= 
 caufc \)t entrco toftb llfccnfe. Roll chief luftice, St map bet^efnttre 
 Dammageg are ai'ozn bp tbc Slurp, fo; tbc trc^paffc, ofU)!]<cl)tbep make 
 Donbt ano refer to t!)C juUBcmcnt of tfte Court, ano i:ot fo? tl)e cntrfng toUt» 
 aLfcenfc t bat if tljc entire fpccfal matter ^ao been fount) ano left to tlje 
 Court, U i&atj been ot&ertoirc. 35ut if tbcp tjao not maoc a Doubt, t^cp 
 m1ff<)t bate founBbtm culpable, anofojooubt ttiat ft is not cooDtofina 
 tl)BOamma0es entire, lecaufc as to tt)c Crcfpafo foz cntrfngvi &armisl^e°^°""'g"' 
 (0 notgufltp. ISut fo J tfje ot&er point tbc caufc of action fa per quod fervi. 
 tium amific, ano foj tbtafje ftatft biougbtitn.ftbfnttetfmclimfteDbptbc 
 statute, fojftisan 0£ti'on upont^cCafc.altljouftljtbe cauiacaufans ist^e 
 vi & armis iD'^fct) is but inouccmcnt to tl)c Siaion , anntbe caufa caufata, ■»•="'' 
 viz. tb^lofsbftb^rerWccfiSt'oJgrounoof tbc aaion. Hales e contra faiD, 
 tbat tbc oammagcs i^aH be applpeo to tbeotbcr matter. RoUchiVfluftice, 
 tbis is t^c fole ©peftfon, Vcftetber tbe oammagea refer to all tl»e 2i;rcrpaf0 
 0; not, ant) upon rcaoing tbe HecojD be faio, tbat It referrcD to aB, ano fo fa vmire. 
 notSOOD, The rale was to fhevv caufc why a new Venire (bould not irtue Ttyil.* 
 forth to try the matter de novo, 
 
 Mich. 1653. Banc.fup. 
 
 T !^e Court teas motjeo to quaflb an ojocr of fecfsfona ma^e foj fbe r , qusfh an 
 committing Of one Wade ano anotber.&urtjcpours o:tbc !^tcb toap, un^ori^sr of Scf- 
 tfU tbep QioulD pap tbc arrerageo of monp coUctteD bp tljem upon tbe &ta« ^^ '"«• 
 tuteof 2 &3. Phil, &Mar.C. 8» foj amcnofng of ^^fob-tDafca, flno ft teas 
 p?apcD t\)t l^jifonera mfgbt be faapleo JLbcfc erceptfons iuerc tahcn bp 
 TwifdenagafnfttbeiDjDcr,firft to ttje Mittimus , in tijat tlje partita toere 
 not contJftteD befo?e tbe Snfticca aa tbepougbt to bate been, 2lp. scbc 
 Mittimus fa repugnant in it felf, foj tbep are committee foj not papinoiof 
 illegal ratcB letfeo ppon tbc IDarfQjfonera > ano iftbep be illegal tbcp are 
 not to be pain, ipejrt tbep are commfttcB fo; not papfng all the monp bp tbem 
 le*ieD, tobercaatbeparcJooeDurtSd.inttie pounnout of ft fo? tbefrpafni 
 lit coUecting of it , ano fo tbep are committco fojmojetbanfanue. Roll 
 chief luftice, The order ij not good, yet leti hem on the other fiJe take time 
 to maintain it if they can, bfcaufc UiaanojDcr fo; repairing oftbef^fgb'fi'^ ^^"^^''^ 
 loap, tubicl) fa fo> tftc goo of tbe Common tor altlj, . " '°"'' 
 
 Henflioe. 
 
 Mich, 1653. Banc.fup, 
 
 f A Writ of dCrro; toaa bjougbttorcfcerfcafuagcmcntinanEiecSioneError tore- 
 X\ firmar; it toaa moteD fo; tbe E)cfenDant in tbe Mrit of Crro j, tbat tbe ' <^' <« ' i"**?'- 
 aRecoju toaa not pet tranfcribcD,anDtbercfojepjapeo be mfcTbtamcnDtbCp7"a'""fi 
 JuDgement bp mabing it recuperet fnfteao of recuperare debet, becanfe it,i,r '""' '' 
 toaa onlp tbe faaltoftbcCtarfeiii mlfentring. Roll chief Iu(licc,2i:bi0 
 la a matter of fubftance, ano toe cannot tell tobetbertbe juagement be final An^endmenr, 
 0; not. Jf it be not final it ought to be recuperare debear: but if ft be '^"'§<^'"«"'- 
 final, It oagbt to be recuperet. Therefore we will make no rule in ir, 
 
 Mich.
 
 E ror to re- 
 verie* jiii'g 
 niciu iu (lie 
 Common 
 
 400 iHill. 1653. 
 
 Mich. 1653. Sane, fupw 
 
 D^"fcan UP Ro" chief luftice , 3tf one mahc a Icafc fo? pears of latin, rcrt- 
 SvTon ir . D;<nB rent, ano after tbe tlcffef pjomtfctlj tbc llcffoj topai'tftc rent, 
 Averiiicni. an 3fl(on \tes upon tW»p?omtrc, tf tlwpjomffe toaa maoc at tbe time of 
 
 tbc IL c afe mane , bpt fn t|je attJon bjonjibt tDJfl pjomlfc matt be c rp^cOg a= 
 
 Ucrreo to be fo, 
 
 locking and Symons. 
 
 Hr:/i ■ J{0^.\f.Q- Hill, 1654. Banc, (up. 
 
 A Writ of CBrro} V]}i0 b^ongbt to rebcrre a luogement efbcn in tte 
 Commmon fdlcao , ano tbe erro; afsigneD teas, t^ttbe ;9a(on tnatf 
 b}onel>t AQahiff ; petfone, one of iDljonttoae tD(tb<n age, anb tbat ti)c^ 
 all appeareo bp attojnep , tobercaabeloitl^fnagcongbt to babe appearea 
 ^'^"'- bpt)<0<I?narDian, ant fo tbe ^uogemcnt toas erronfous as to bint , ann 
 
 tonfcqticntlp to tbe reft bccaufe it toaa a jopnt Juogcment, Roll chief lu^ 
 iudgem:nt. ftjce , %W <s a gooD ciftcptfon , fo? it being a |opnt jnogcntent , if it be 
 naagbt in part , aa tottbout conbt it is, it is naugllt in tbe tobole , And fo ic 
 wat reverfed. 
 
 Hill. 1652. Banc fup, 
 
 T.qujii. on nr )^e Court ioas mobcu to qnnQi an CBnoittment fo;i not repairing 8 
 
 Enciamenc | |^fg^<t))ap. Eb^^ Crception tattcn toas , t^st tbe CEntictment oio (on« 
 
 for not re- (^y^g ^ j^g^ jljg pg^jp jjyg^j tj) ^ppjjj ({ jjp rcafon of bfa tenements , tobici) 
 
 Hiehw^ "^^^ '^'^ ^^ ^^ uncertatn , ano it ouubt to babe fa(a, tbat be , ana all tbofc 
 
 tobofc eftate be batb in tbe SCenements ufca to repair it. ano alp. 3t 
 
 (honlD babe faio , tbat bpteafon of tbe tenure of bis CengmttUs be oagbt 
 
 to repair, ano not bpreafon of bis tenements, ^Vnd upon chefe Exsepciont 
 
 ic watqQaihed. 
 
 Tre\ilianand Wclman. 
 Hil!« 165^, Sane. fap. 
 
 Arrcft ot T^fteviiian bjougbt an Sdion upon tbe Cafe againtt Welman fbj fpcaWng 
 jrtdpement -*■ Of tbefc UlOjOS of btBT, viz. He did put in two Horfes to Colonel ®!ltnD=: 
 tor words fjam , meaning Colanct ?HIIinDbain that wa« Govcrnour of IBjiogetuatcr , 
 and as foon as any warrants came for the prefling of men for the fervice, he 
 acquainted the Cavallier$, by reafon whereof none could be prefled that 
 were fit , and he doth hold <on(>ant corrcfpondency with the Cavalliers. tEp« 
 on BJiTue jopnec , anoa cicvDfctfounofojtbc }3!afiitff, 3it \am mobP?» in 
 arrctt of iubgcment tbat tbe Idojdb tuerc not flttfoiiable , because utttrlp 
 uncertain , either loben Col. windiiam toas Colonel, ano tr.ben tbe l^o^fe^ 
 incre pnt \xk , ant> tbe otber tuo;Ds are as tncertain at} tbcfe. T^'.^X it lose 
 anftDcrcD, tbatifall tbe UJ020a be tahcn together, tbcparcter iianouflii 
 to grotino an aaion , fo> if tbcp be trtie the pinttitif tiirmbp lui! • ('e crpjef» 
 Ip mauc a SDclinqucnt , anD babe bis cttatc fcqtt Itrct) fo> aaberfng ano ar» 
 fifiiiigtbe teing ngalnft tbe iOarliamcnt, aiia ottljls opinion tuas tbe Court, 
 and thereupon the Plaintif had his judi^emcMC. 
 
 Hill;
 
 Hill. 1654. 401 
 
 Hill. 16 54- Banc- fup- 
 
 I jptftc Cafe of one Page anu Crook, Utnagfafi) fap t^e Coart, SCIjat «whom»vU 
 an Action o( S^terpaEs be b;ongl)t aga(nS one toft^ a fimul cum toitti o< wuneflci. 
 ttieto , ff noticing be p}ot)eoasa<nftt^eotl)et0, tl)ep map be ei»m(neo 96 
 tDftneffesinti^ecaufe. 
 
 Whitehead and Buckland^ 
 
 HilUid54- 
 
 x 7\ /Hitehead bjougW an Sctfon of SCtcfpaffl bp £)jfgfnal agafnft ocmurrci to 
 V V Buckland , fo; talUng atoap 400 S>l)ccp, ano 26 iBnllocfeo, tfteaicpiicauon 
 JDefencant pleaDatbe fetatnte of 21 lac. of Ifmitattons of actfona <n ©at ,'" Trcfpafs :-^< 
 tftc glalnttf rcplpeo t^at fte fuco fojt^ an £) jtgfnal U)}<t Inftbfn 6 pcarSjano " """*• 
 tt)att^ep}ocef0 thereupon teas onli' contmnrQ, upon tbts t^c SDefennant 
 oemnrreD , ano fo; canfe (beuis , tbat tbe replication (s not goeo ; fo^ tolien 
 tl^e piaf nt(f fapss f^at ^c foco fojtl5 an ojjgfnal, he ongbt to tanc aDoeo pro- 
 utpatetperRecorduro, U)t)ftlj is omtttco* 2lp. ^t batb not vlcaDco tfte 
 continuances of ^fs pjocef£> upon tbe IReco^D. Maynard anftoereo, t^at 
 t^e tcplfcation is gooD , fo^ toe cannot tahe a traterfe upon tbcfr 
 plea , totf cb is furplufage , anti toe neeo not pleao aU t^e continuances 
 but it i0 fuf Scfent ft lue pleao as muc\3 of tbe llecoiiD as goes in ]5ar. Roll 
 chief Iuftice,2Cbc plea is plain , ant) it is not ncceiTarp to allege tl)c continu. 
 antes , foj bete is an appearance. Sit another nap Maynard fain, tbe plea 
 in JlSar is not gooD , fo; be pKaos an immaterial tWng , foj it matters not 
 ioben tbe ojiginal teas fueo fortb, but be ougbt to plcaD not culpable toitbin 
 0]C pears befoje tbe £Djisinal fueu fojtb. Roll chief luftice , SCblsis tbe a« 
 foal it ap of plcauing , ano it is bat to put pou to a ncto nfefgnment, ano tbe ^'^^' 
 plea is gooD , f oj pou are not tpco up bp it , toj pou arc not foiceo to iopa 
 tlTue . f oj Jou map tnabc a neto afsignment ; but toaite tbe SDemurrcr on 
 one part , ane tbe pleating of tbe Statute on (be otbcr part, anD tafee a 
 neto plea anu go to a trpal , otbertiiifc toe muft gite fuogcment foj tbe 
 paintif. But tlie Court would advjfe. Latch at anotljer Dap faio, tbattbe 
 replication is naugbtfoj the nnccrtaintp, fojitootbnot appear toberc tbe 
 i©jiginaltoasfueDfojtf), nojtbe time toben,fo}itis onlp faiu he i^oft" 
 fojtbaniD?i£i!ialin Michaflmai JLcrm , anu part of Michaelmas SCernt 
 liiap be iuitijin fir pears, ano the otber part map be after tbe ti); pears, ano 
 fo it cannot be tmofentobctbcr it teas fueofostb in Due time oj no, ano be- 
 caufc no place i<5thcfecD there can be no tJlenue. Adjourned to the next 
 term , ^t apotlier tap the «Eare teas mofcD aoaiii, 9 then tbe 2 crccptions 
 taSen, tbatitbfisnotfafoproutpatctper Rfcorc'um , ano ban not fljeten • 
 the continttarcesof thv ptccefs, toerr oVcr-rulco bp t! cConrt; ano then a» 
 notherCrfcptfcntoactaUcntotherrplfcation, that it concluoc!) &- liocpe. 
 tjtquodinquiraturper patriam, Ivbifhisrot gooD, foj it binOcrs tftc Otbct 
 partptorciopn, ano he is tompcUeo cither to topn iifuc, oj to Demur. 
 LatchiinfircrcD , SLhat the partp map not be aomitteo to ta!?c aot-antage of 
 this fault note opon a grncralocnuirrcr , anD be is not tpcD up from rctopn* 
 ing , altbounh an iffuc be offereo him , fo? though the plea be infojmal pet 
 be map pafo otjcr anD relopn , Hob. f, 80. Newman anD Stones cafe, ^ot- 
 iDitWanDing an unncccffarptratCTfc the partp map plcaooUcr, ano is not 
 bciuntitojopnijrue, anotheimpcrtinencpof the plea l\)all remain but onlp 
 
 ifff ia
 
 40Z Hill. 15 5 4- 
 
 ae a blcmfd) in fo^im of t()e plea , ano (ban not be accompfcD a fault fn tbe 
 fubQanccoftt. Sim alp. t^it barfs not gooo, anD tbercfo^c ft matters 
 not tljoiigb tbe repUcatfoti br not gooo , fo; ft fa fmpettfncnt to fct fojtb an 
 £»jfi!;fnal, butljeougbttotiabcplcaDcD gcncrallp tbnt bcvnaanot gufltp 
 Hjftbfn 6 peats before tbe ;©}< B<«al bjongftt , bnt bcre Ije I)atl» fmpcrtfncntlp 
 fctfojtt)ti)Ctfmeofb?fn5ftiStftc0;(g(nal, ano tl)f8 anftocrs not tbc &ta. 
 tutc, ano tfje matter allcgco Dcftrops bffl oton pica, ano bcrc can be no jjcdd 
 3truc jopneo inltljotit Departure from bfs plea , to toft from Ij/s bar, ano 
 tftfs ts not to be fufferco fn pleaufng; ano berc fs ncftljcr certafntp no j con- 
 gruftpfntl)e parts of tbcpleaofng, foj tbe begfnnfng of tbe term fs nncct- 
 tafnlpaHegeo. ilp. It^efljetosnot Inljat Dap of tbc 2Cerm l)c fffueo fojtft 
 ftfs ojfgfnal , btit onlp faps gcncrallp fn Michaelmas SCerm , tobffb fn Cole 
 ano Sibfevs cafe fntbifs Court teas latelpaDjnDgeDnatigbt. Halet on tbe 
 otbtr Cic fafo , tfjattbc barfsgooo , anDt^attbetcplfcatfonfafnfufftcfcnt, 
 becaufc tlje ©efcnDant f s tpcD up bp an f flue , ano f s not fuffcrcD to rcjopn, 
 anD ft fs f nfuffictent fn fubftance , fo^ be l^atb not maoe a proper concluQon, 
 fOjbcou:;bt to ba^C toncluDCO, et hoc paratuseftverificare, anO as ft id 
 ftfsfmpcrtfneiit, anotbe piaf ntf f cannot pafsober to re jopn as Latch fup» 
 pofetb , ano tbf s cafe fs not like ti^e cafe of tbe ttabccte cf teo bp bf m , U>^re 
 be map pafs o\)cr , ft being but fn matter of fojm , but ft fs not fo berc , foj 
 tbe a^ratjers atiers ti)c plea . ano concluDeo not tbe partp as here be fs con- 
 cluDco ,anDcanoonootbertbfngbatDcmaro} jopnfn tbc Sffuc tcnojeO; 
 ^na tbc bar alfo fs gooD ano fufficfent, notltitbttanoing tbe time of tbe 2>iU 
 gfnals iffufng fojtb be allcgcD , altbougb ft tuas in bis elcttfon to babe IlielD« 
 CD tbe tfme, oi not to babe OicUicDft ano btsfbelofng it mabes not tbe plea 
 iDOjfcbut mojecertafn, ano altbougb ft be not tbe trutb of tbc Cafe as be 
 batballegcD ft , 31 Doubt tobetbcr ft (boulD be a Departure foi tbc patntff to 
 replp to a neto ;© jigfnal afsfgneo , ano ft map be tbcrc iDcre ttoo iDjfgf- 
 nals , ano tlje Defendant rclpes upon tb'^ laft £>;ffifnal, ano ff tbc otbet 
 £)jfgf nal be pleaocD be map replp to ft aftettoaros. alp. 0Dmfttfng be can« 
 not D;part, tljfs tofll Doe no bnct , foi tbe plea fs not toojfc foj bfm alttiougb 
 ft be better foj tbe otber. jlp. 3t fs not fncertafn to fap tbat ft flTuco fojtb 
 tn Michaelmas Term , fo> aUtbeSCermfsbutoncDap tn 3laU),-anD ft fa 
 fafDiDbcntbe2netmfaegan,namelptbe2 3 0fOdobcr, anb ff ft be not fo 
 certafnlpevpjeffcDasftougbttobc , pet bp tbe replfcatfon tbfs aobantagc 
 fs loft , ano ft fs not Ifbe to Cole anc Sibfeys cafe cftcD on tbc otber (toe , fo» 
 tbcre voasa fpccfal SDemurret, but bere tbc ©emurrcr fs general, ano tbere 
 ftU»as of tbe partfes oii>n fettfng fojtb- Latch, Jf tbc ^fsfgnment of tbe 
 £)2fgf iial be at bis perfl , f f be fct ft not fojtb rigbt ft f s f U , anD ft fs not toell 
 bcrc'afsfgncD , fo? tbcrc fs ncftbcr time noj place allcgeo tubcn ft fffueo 
 fojtb. Roll chief luftice , 3 concefbc tbe rrplfcatfon fs not gmo , fo? tbc 
 
 Rc,icjtion. partp fcbounDupt'oat be cannot rctopn, butmiiftcftbcr Demur oj iopn fn 
 3ffue\Bftbpou, ano 3 babe not bcaroofpafefngofecrfn tbfs Cafe, as map 
 be cone fit tbe Cafe of a SCraberfe Vnbfcb concluoes not tbe partp , ano bere 
 pou abcr not pour pica as pou ougbt,anD tbe otbcr ougbt to be left at Ubertp 
 
 A.cuiui.t. to vcjopnff be plcafc.tobfcb be cannot Dobercjbut ft fs Doubtful! tobctber tbc 
 pica fiiBar be gooD oj not,becaufc tbcre fs no tfmc ccrtafn allegeo of fffufng 
 o:it tbc £??fgfnal , fojftfs fafo gcncrallp fn Michaelmas SCerm , tobcreas 
 aniDjfgfnalbcarsTefteataDap ccrtafn, ano map fffne fojtb out of tbc 
 
 OTy.,ii jccrm," anDftfsnotlfhea JuDfcial to)ft , ano ft fs iiticfitonablc lobctbct 
 tbfs be matter of fo?m onlp, o? of fubftance , anD me fcems ft fs matter of 
 fubftance to be abcrrco. The Court yvoul d ad vife. 
 
 Sit anotbet Dap tbc date teas agafrt put anofpoken to bpWadbam Wind- 
 bam, tobo, npon putting tbc Cafe iirscD, tbat tbe jEDcfenoant b:tcfctsfojtb 
 
 ano- 
 
 Telle.
 
 Hill. 1653 . 405 
 
 anoth,cc ojisfnal not fet fojt^ bp t\iz fdlafntff, ano t^(0 fs not b^onglbt 
 
 tDitl^ifl tt)e time Umitcs bp tlie Statute; ann upon tbfe ti3C piaintff cejopnS) 
 
 ano Ije tftco Coles aiio SibryesCafc, aiiotnCfteo.t^at t^eSDcfenuantep-M 
 
 fn bat is not scoo tn tb^ matter of fubftancc , to; \)z njeloa no time no^ place 
 
 tDbenl<e6rit('teDro:tbb(s^<-iS<ttal) ano l]c ougbt to djeui loben be tob it 
 
 fo^tb, tbat tbe Court map juDge lobctber it loas Done in sue time'o^ no, as 
 
 tbe Statute requires, ano not to pat tbe CourttomaheenquirptobenitrH.T.f.xfo. 
 
 Iffueo fojtb, ano altijougb it be but furplurage to fljein it, pet noto ba'oing 
 
 taUcn npon bim to OjcId tbe time, l)e ougbt to OjeU) it pjecifclp. Hill 10 lac l Jkcs Lie 
 
 Wcl^byi ano Rookes Cafe in tbis Court, tbemifplcaDtng ofa&tatnteis 
 
 not g(DD,tbougbtbepartpiDa0notbounDtop!caDit, anofoitiaberc, ^no 
 
 tibe replication Dotbusnobarm :fo;tl)ereiano matter in it tb^tma^eoa* 
 
 gerfnlt U0, fo; tbe Court ougbt to juogc upon tbe lotole lUecojo, ano conQoec 
 
 tobo maoe tbe firft fault, ano tbat batb tbe SDcfenoant Done in bis bat, ano 
 
 tbat in matter of fubttance , anObecitcoCarainal Pools Cafe, ano Hob. 
 
 rep. Bafpoole* Cafe, ano pjapeo juoycment foj tbe ^plaintiff. Wild on tbe 
 
 otbet Coc faio. tbat tbe bar is onlp tttious iix io^m, ano fo it bnrts not, ano 
 
 IE fo, tbcn tbe otberpartpbatb loft bis aobantagcofitfap tbe fetatntc, foj 
 
 fte batb not Dcmurrco upon us, but ine batjc ocmurreo upon bim, to tDit,ap« 
 
 on bis replication. Roll chief luftice, 3 am of opinion tbat tbefct* 
 
 ting fojtboftbe£)?iainalbptbeH)cfcnoant, ano conclnoing tbat be fs not 
 
 gniltptottbinC); pears from tbattimc is not gmot but note that is tcaibco 
 
 bp tbe replication, ano is maoc matter of fojm , as it is in V:,c Cafe of a nclD 
 
 arsignment^ano tbe Common bar is nolo out of ooo:t8. 3it bao been gooo to 
 
 lja\je Ojeton tbe pjccife cap of taWng Co?tb tbc£D?igfnal,but it ia not abfolutc- 
 
 Ip nr ccffarp to 00 it, ano tbio is not lil>c ttc mi f-plcaDing of a S^tattite iubicb 
 
 muft be pjccifelppleaoeo ano is matter of fubttance : but tbis is matter of 
 
 fojm onlp , ano beCocs tbis matter is bete tnaftjeo < ano notbing is fljeiccD 
 
 jbp tbe faiaintiff tolifcb can bar iiim of Ijfs action , noj batb tbe 2)e= Demurrer* 
 
 fcnoant plcaocoanptbing to bar bim. 0nDbp tbe replication ponbat)ebin« 
 
 ojeo tbe 2Dcfen8ant to plcao to potr, fo j pou bate concluoco ad patrism, ano 
 
 ftoppeo bim from pjoceeDingfurt!;cr in plcaoing: bat tbe piincfpal matter 
 
 i3, t^at ponbatjetoaiteo tbe matter pleaoco in bar, of tobffb pou migbt 
 
 ftaDctafeenaotjantagc, ano 3 coiueibe tbat be Inbo ocmurc upon matter of 
 
 fojm ougbt to ftjeU) tbe fpccial matter tDberefo;c be Demurs ; but ifit be A<Jv»nM{e. 
 
 toaifteo bp tbe otbcr bp bis rcplpfng, be fball not afterluarDg take notiantagc 
 
 fo J tbe not fljctaiing it, notU)iti)ftariDtng tbe §>tatute, ano oiticrs opinions np^ 
 
 on it, foj tbe Statute enjopnctb to fet fojtb tbe matter of fojm plcacco in- 
 
 fufficientlpt Nil capiat per billam, nid. 
 
 .•'' Hill. 165 5. in the Upper Bench. 
 
 « 
 
 Matter attojncp CDcnctal mobeo tbe Court aftcriffucfonicoiitan To ft«y a 
 CBnoidmcnt picferreo againft S©r0.Lcvingfton,anD tbe SLrpal bciug to Tivai upon 
 be the ncrt Dap , tbat tbe Erpal migbt be aapcD bprnlc of Court, bccaurc*"^"'^'^- 
 tbe Cnoinmcnt is erroneous in manp tbings. ano tbe 2Erpal tbcrcupon toill ■"'"'• 
 be fruitleffc, foj no Juogement can be bao upon it, ano toetnappicfcc 
 a nctD <iBnDictmcnt,-Bno one fault in it ij, tbat tbe ISill iuaafounobpa 
 <I5?anD 3;urp , tobcreof fomc oftbcmtncrc outlatoco lobcn tbcp founo'it. 
 Wild on tbe otber (toe pjapeo tbe SCrpal migbt go on , bccaufc tbe Sffucia 
 jopnco,anD tbe 3i«rpreto?ncD, ano manp tSaitncffca, viz, a btmOKoat 
 Icaft are bjo'ugbt to Colon , fome a great u.ap off, ano arekeptbereata 
 great Cbargc, Roil chief luftice , The Artorney may waive the liTue if he J^'*''"- 
 pleafe though it be joyncd or he may dciruf if he will, thercforcletbim "'"'
 
 404 Hill. i6 54' 
 
 vnvy. raikTwhitcniry he thinki good upon the Roll, for we will make oo rale ia 
 
 Stephcnfon and Steward. 
 
 Hill i6s 4. Upper Bencb, 
 
 STevcnfon Ijoog^t an Zalon of SDcbt agafntt Steward foj rent, ttie JDe- 
 fcnontit plcaucBln abatement of tlje 03 rU tljat befcoaa, (n regacD of mo, 
 viirgeot ['»,"- n<e0 uWilJ ^c ban lent to tee jparllamcnt,piotc(leo bp t^etr fpetlal ojucr 
 i.ament. ftom all artcftfl. Ebe piatntiff replpeo, t^at t^jfa ojDetUwsafterlDaco. 
 tepcalcD bp another general oioer of j|9atUament. Carew arjjeo tljat tbe 
 SDcfeiioantflplea toaa not noto gooo, becaufetfteparUaracnt being of (ToU 
 fecD,tl)e(ro?oersareofnotojce; anopjareo luogemcnt fojtljc plaintiff. 
 Roll chief iuftice, ^ftfteplcauasgooD U)t)cn It uiafl pleaoeo , poaraalon 
 Abjce nenr Waft «batc, ano pou muft begfn again : fo j tt)c plea I0 bat ia abatcment,ani> 
 I'crcmpiory. iwt pctcmpto?? to t^? part?; and therefore lecthcWric abace. 
 
 Hill. 1654. upper Bench. 
 
 whtre may RP ^0^^ '^'^^ luftice, 3f an flttlen of55attetpbp£)j<s(nalbcB8afnft 
 be a new o- ttoo, ano one comes in upon tbc Criscnt, tberc map be a neto ^©jfgfnal 
 riginai. bjoogbt agalnft ttjc otbct toltb a Simul cum, ano ttofe tobo are Voaftwo map 
 be GaitneffefltntbeCaare.anotlMalanfaalpjaalcc : but ttjofe tobo are oe* 
 Witr.efj. j^gjj.Q agajntt ij,(t^ a Simol com cannot Iw ?©ftncae«. 
 
 GrcenlinganJ Bavvdit. 
 
 Hill. 1654. Upper Bench, 
 
 Ar eft of •^Reenl ng b;oasbt an 0dlon apon tbe Cafe agafntt Bawdit , ann oec la- 
 ju^menc in vJreo, tljat tbe Defenoant in conftocratfon tbnt tftc plafntlfif tooulo marp 
 an Aftion fuel) a iC[oman,D(D atfume auD pjomlfe t^at upan btfl mitlarc t)f£b bct, ^ 
 upon .nAf- 'ojoulD pap tbe plaintiff 50 1. ano iDoulo alfo gftjc unto blm pc/irlp one 
 '""'rfi'- fitWnof CggeaanDaaitcbofKaconoarlnstbclffc of ttc piafatlff; ana 
 apon a Nihil dicit tbe plaintiff obtafna a SiiDgemcnt, ano upon aCSJrltof 
 Cntjnlrp 6f onmmacea ejecutiO. great Bammagca tocre foanD foj tbe 
 plaintiff. 3tIi)aamo\3eDlnarr£flof3;ui)gcmcnt, i. Z.\>,at ttootb not ap- 
 pear fo; U)bntb:cncb of pjomtfc tbe Action lebjoti^ib^, tobetber foj tbe 
 not paptng tb- 50 1. 0^ not paplngtbeCggeaano JSaton. alp. Zt ienot 
 atjerret) in teliat pear tbe 2>efenDant iraa to begin to pap tbcCggeaano 
 jpacon. £Co tbia R- II chief Joftice aHfijjerco, tb« ft QjaH be fntcnue!) to be. 
 inwndmenc. gfn toftWn the peat n£)ct after tbe fflarlagB flbaU take effect. s^V- 3it taaa 
 Etccptco agnf atf, tbat (t atflb not appzar foj bote manp peara tbe ©ngea ano 
 JJaconUcreunpalD, anotbep^omlfctoaft maae anno ifi^7.'nttiittitWirit 
 ofCnciiilrptDascrccuteD anno 1653. SBat Roll chief Iuftice otjer.ruleo 
 tbe Crctptlona. ano to tbelaC anftoereo, tbe HecoiD ia hoc ofque, ana 
 fo ft is ce;tatn snoujb. Therefore let the Plaiontfbavc his lodgement, 
 
 Oifl, CvC, 
 
 HiU
 
 Hill. 1654. __ _ _____^^ 
 
 Hill. 1654 Upper Bench. 
 
 1i^ tljE Cafe of one BaniOer tD^ete t^e SMon teao an SctfiJnofBDebtJ^'"*'.'''"?^' 
 biou&it asatnttanCEtecuto?, Roll chief Jufticf, fajo, SCtjat riens inttr„7rot '««»*- 
 inaiaes pleaDeo bp an (trccuto% is an afftrmatfbe plea <n fabftantc ,ivc. 
 tftougt) ft founD fomctbing in tl)C ncgattbe , foj ft is in effect tbe fame tett^ 
 plene adrainiftravit , ano fiicb plea muft be at)citc6 , ano fjc put t^a oiffc^Av-rmcir 
 tence , viz. lo^ece an Sfftie (0 joj^neo up npon. a nccatite pica tuitt bnt anp ' ' ' 
 teplicatfon , ft is not nccefTsTptoatettbeplea, b:<t iftbcre be a teplication 
 it mud be ateiteo. 
 
 Hay ward and Ducket- 
 Hill, 1 554. Banc* fupi 
 Pafch.i<55 3»roMp5, 
 
 Hkywtvi bjoog^t an jatffon npon t^ Cafe agatnff Ducket tbat iraa ^rrcft cr 
 Cicecato:tto anotbct, ano Declares, tljat tobereas tbc SLcfltatoj ufoiudpcment in 
 otocontatbc^lafntfffncljafnraofmoncp, totjicbtbe pafntif oft inicno'"'^"""' "?' 
 tftfoctbeSDcfenoant fi>j,tbe SDefcnoant Dio affame ano p?omifc to tfje""* P'^""''- 
 5plaf ntf r, tftat if l)C tDOulo fojbcar to fuc bf m fo j tbc monep , ano inonla fufs 
 fee bim to go into tbc Country, be ttonlo pap tljc monep, ano foj bjcacb of 
 tftis pjomffe fje bjongbt bis 3afon , ano obtains a tjcroia. 3it teas mobco 
 f n attett of Binogcmcnt, tbat tbcre appears no conGoetation in tbe Dctlara* 
 tiontogroanotbcpjontifenpon, tobcrcbp to make tlie a>efcnDant Irable 
 topapt&emoncptoWcftbcpjomtfeDtopap,{ojitootl) m>t appear tbat be 
 feCrecntO}, ano Rofyer anb Lanpdalrs cafe. Anno xeio. in tl^fc Coart toatf 
 citco. JCotbisittDasanftocreDbptbeCoiincelontbe other fiac, srbat a 
 goob confioeratfon ootb appear tocU enongb, foj loben be faftb tbat be 
 toaotofojbeartofaebfntasCrccotoj , it ©all be inrenoeo tbat be toaa 
 Cpccutoj attbctfmetobenl-ei&onlDfofojbear to fue hhn , atio tbc pjo- 
 mffe fs fo lafo , Plow. 1 a8. Rolf chief luftice , SCo Tap tbat 3 vcili fojbeac 
 tofneoneasCic£cato>,fsnotanatfirmancctbatb3isCDi:ccato> , ^no tbcre 
 tDBs fticb a cafe as tbfs ruleo in the CpcbcJiuer ; ano it is no mo;e , nap not 
 fomucbasifbcbabfafOjtbatbeUjoulDnotfucbiniat air. iudgement pro 
 Defeodencc, niil,. 
 
 B 
 
 Bill. 1654. Banc.fup. 
 p Roll chief lurtice, 31n an ;3ctfon npon tbc cafc vittarmis, jt is not 
 
 Where oh: 
 not 
 
 mcceffarp to concloBc contra pacem publicam , but in an 0ttion of aCref- nccd^* 
 pafs quatevi ct atmij , tbe concluQon muff be contra pacem publicam. condude'eon- 
 
 Hili. 1654 Upper Bench. f"''^'"'"- 
 
 BI^Rollchiefloi^ice, afpccfalCaplpfsboanotofbetDbiBtDarranttOvvh r 
 tbe partp tobom be is to ^rrctt , otbcrtoife tbc partp to be arrcftco is ,m>a\hcn lit 
 nottpcotoobcpbfm.tntbeianotboimo to (hcto bis toarrant to awjrranc 
 stranger, bnt a bnoton 1Bapl|^ fs not bcnno to f&eU) bid Warrant to 
 anp, 
 
 if f f 3 HU/.
 
 406 >Hill. 16 54' 
 
 a^4.A<roJ.Q. Hill. i654.Upper Bench. 
 
 WhJtVVritff 
 
 Error 
 
 iseToj pl^ Roll chief luftice, 3tfan amojt bcb?oucbt flgafnff tl);ce, anB one 
 
 ' JDof tfccm fg an Jnfant , ano tl)cp all appear bp lattoincp, anu an entire 
 
 SuDgemciit ie n<\)cn agafnft tbcni all , ano tl)ci> all jopn fn a lojft of Crto? 
 
 torc\)crrctW0§tiDgemciit, tWoVDjlttclucu b)0U3ftt, foj tftc luogcmcnt 
 
 ludecment to'"' crronfooa , bccaufc U <s an cntfrc f nogcmcnt , fo; as; to the 3nfant (t 
 
 ^ ■ -cannot be gooo, 5fott<3naaBt)ttotl)crca,anDljccfteDoncByrescafe5?Iac. 
 
 <ntt)e point. 
 
 Porter and Swecnam. 
 
 Hill. K554. Upper Bench, 
 Trin, 1(55 3, rot, 72 3. 
 
 Eiror tfi re- 
 
 AOTtU Of Ctro J teas bjought to tctetfc a Juogemcnt gften npon a 
 nonium informatuslntlje Common picas in an action of Covenant 
 mcntup"nV bjougbtuponaJLeafefojpcarafojnotpaping tljc rent referlJCD , ano not 
 non fum in- rcpaltijig , ano tbffl tuag agattift an Crecutrf); of the afoignee of tbe iLeCTe^ 
 d7bt7'r'"nr ^•'^ I'cara, ano U toaa bjoiijiht as to the non-papment of the rent np- 
 t or ""f-pj^t^g^jjpjQjplgHjjnganopaptng, annnotuponaneppjcfsCoDcnant, ano 
 fo^t^atthetDO^ttspiclDinganDpapfngarcbut a Col^cnant in llalo, ano 
 onlp an luiplpEO Covenant, ant> arlfeth but from a pcrfonal Cobcnant,ana 
 not upon a real contract, as Latch helo, iDhoargncofo} the plalntlf fn the 
 tDjit of Crroj , SE'.icrefo je he falo the action of Covenant coulD not ftcre Ue 
 agaiiift thcCrccattir, asalrarrantpin iLato blnos onlp the partp, ano 
 notpjifcies, as Spencers cafe is, Dyensy. alp. die iDlaintiftnthe actf* 
 pnooth not Declare that the 3Dcfenoant teas maoc Ctccutrii; , ano if (he be 
 but fiSrccutri); de (on tort demefne, (he is not UablC to this action, Wadharo 
 Windham on the other fioc helo , th^t the too'^os ptdoing ano paptng in the 
 ILcafe ate an cvpjcrcf Covenant, ano the 3^ ton here is fo; rent become ar* 
 rearinthet(meofti3C(fj:cc«tri);, ano this Covenant being a Covenant 
 tohich maUcB the rent papafale ratione terrac , it 00th concern her, ano an ^i- 
 ccutrirdefontortisbountJtopapthcrent. Roll chief luilicc , take time 
 to anfiaer both €rccptton0,btit 3 conceitjc at p:efcnt , that the Vco jDs pielo* 
 fng ano papingare an crpjcfsCo^jenant, fo: if thep tocre not . iuhat re* 
 Covcr.anr. wcop clfc iroulothcrc be to tecoter the rent :■ foj if (he be a tiffeifo?, nef. 
 therocbtnoj Covenant toill lie agatnft her. at another cap Windham ar- 
 gucDtl;att'rc action teas toell brought, becaufc this is an crpjefs Cotje» 
 liant , ano not a Covenant in iLalD. jlp. 3;t is not material to CbeU) hoio 
 (he is vc^vi^z C!;j;ecntri)c ; ant) fo? the firft this mttft be an erpiefs Co'jenant, 
 becaufc itigbpSnocnttire, although the irojoColJcnant be not erpjefTei), 
 fojthatirojDisnotatoojDofart, anofonoteffential to the confiituting 
 of a Covenant, Dyer 5 7. 27 E. 4. f, 6, . ano fo? the fctonD it is toeU fet 
 f ojth that the is mace Crecutrir , foi it is faio Jhc entrcu as an ©tcculrir. 
 sh'.fehehat") acmtttcohcrfclftobe Crccutrfrbpplraoing. Latch on the 
 other Sdc helo , 2Ehat here is onlp a Cotcnant in Halo , an^fois the boob 
 in Dyer citED bp Windham , ano the Crccutrtr (3 not bouno here , becaufe 
 it is agaiiift the afcignceoi a SCerm , ano the terp teojos doc (hcb) that 
 Icrcis no crpacfs Cotjenant, fo; the too^tg pieloing ana paping arc not the 
 toojDB of the JLcffcc , but onlp bp conftrnction of Hato , but are the Iro jDS 
 ctthc icfToj cnjopningthc Jletfectopaptherent, Roll chief Iuftice,?^otD
 
 Hill. 1^54' 407 
 
 pjotjc poatftat tWa aofon Ifcanot ajrafnfl an afsJgitcc f latcb Jrtc raft of 
 Overton % lidncv p?obe0 it, fo J It p?otPa tbat Debt lfc»not ', ano bp tonfe. 
 qucncc Covenant Ueb not. Sinn (0 J tl)e fccono matter , tbe SDefcnoant (0 
 not intttlco to t^c Icafe in p;f bttp , btcaufe it ia not QieUieD ttiat i^c ia maoe 
 fBretutxlv , ano To djc (l;aU be taken but as an CicecatTfi^of ber oton lo^ong, 
 ano fo ia not cbargcablc , bccaiUe fl)C batb no pjftitp of eSate bat bp ^ec en* 
 ttp , nojisitanptoberectcrmcntfoncDtbatanpcanbc Cmattfi; de fon 
 tore ef a SCecm. zlp.^^ cannot be a^Cetmo;, but (t)c muft be a SDitfefferefa, 
 fo^ (be cannot apportion jcr otnnts^otig. ;lp. &1}C cannot mabca tftle 
 totlicSCctmbpftcrcntrp, ncit mapbctipaquceHate, ano tbercfoje iiia 
 agaiiift teafon tbat Gis (hall be a ZTermoj , ano tbeie is no auttK)}itp againft 
 t\fl9 , Palcb- 25 Btiz in tbiavTourt. Kinp and Surges in Mores ]flepO}t0 
 Dyer 254. ^ponajSDemutTcr, aDjubgco tbat it t»as not to be (betoeD t)ols 
 one teas €(:ecuto;.Roll chief Iuflicc,^it)at fap pou to tbe j^b)e(tton,ti)at tlie 
 ;9aion io b^ougbt agaitiO: \mi aa an e);cc"ti^<i: . anb pou appear ant> pleao , 
 ant) To aomit pour feU to be an CBrecutrir ^ Sno 3 bolD tbat bcre is an er- 
 pjcfs ^otienant , fo;tbci3o;ib0arc tbe iigreement o( bot^ parties to t^e 
 Snoenture , anotticn tbeCr^cuto^tistbargeable bp tbem , ann it is not 
 libetotbeCarcof aE>emife, anb there is no fit(Ferencc berc betlseen a 
 Cotenant in lain*, anoan crpjcfs Cobenant, bctaufe it is tontbing a 
 tbiagtebtcbariretb from tbe land, anbrotbeBretgnce isbouno bp it, ano 
 tbfs Cafe is not lil-^e tbe cafe citcD out of Dyer, fo^bete tbeeSate tsasoe^ 
 termineo, but bcrc it tontinucs. Sinb as to tbe laft point, 3 tonceite pri- 
 ma facie , tbat (be (liaU be accomptcDa true Crccutrir .• ano pou bp pleao. 
 IngbateaDmittcDit; anoifonfftnterasan dEirecuto? upcn a 2Ceim, be 
 map bate tbe SCcrm if tbe other tstUaomtt him to be a SCermo:^, ann he 
 iJiaHnot be accomptea a IDilTeiro; to the liefTo^ , ant to Srangers he CbaD 
 beacconiptcD an (Ejcecuto? in iato , if thep bjtng atfions againft him, 
 ano tbe SCccm Qjall be aiTets in bis hattos ; SLa tf one teccibe mp rents Vrith- 
 outmptonltut. 3 map charge him asmprctcfbcr, oj mafec Wm a DlBrcfc^'^"'' 
 fojntmp election. Cutia ad idem, and fo tbe Judgemenc was alfirnned^ 
 JButaftcrlsarbs it VDasmoteo again, anbthe U)?itof Crro^ toas qaathcD 
 (02 a tariance bettoirt itaribtbe IRccojb, fo; tbe Kcco^fi ie againtt the 
 areijfus , and the to;it of Crro; is to rcmobc a ^Rcco^o againft the ^fsfg* 
 nee. i^oitca, 
 
 Bromc field anci Sir lohn Williamfbn. 
 
 Hill, i6J4-^3nc,fup. 
 Mich, idji.rot. 353. 
 
 B 
 
 Rnni«{icld bjouplit an Action of fi?cbt upon an iDWffatfon to pcrfojm 
 the Col3cnantfi of a J. cafe fo? pears againft feir lohr Williarafon , tbe°"""^J'^^;^° 
 SDcfcnDantpleaDeDtlathcbabprrfojmcDtbe CoVerarts, ttc Plain- f„'j^b" pen' 
 tifrtplpcB, anafet^fojthabiracb, ano upon this the SDcfenoant Demur- an obiijati- 
 tcD , ant) upon the SDcmurrcr tbe Cafe ttas tWa : 3 iieafe leas mane fojon. 
 one pear , the fLeCTce toiiehants fo; him ano hfe flfsigns to pap the rent, fo 
 long as be aiio thcp (baS hat)e the pofTcf!^ion of the thing let ; the ^LcflTee af« 
 figns oVicr bia 2CcrnT , the SCcrm evpircs, the Jlfaignrc continues tbepoffef- 
 fion after the SCerm ejpirco',. ano foj rent bcbino bp the jflfsignee after the 
 crptrntionoftheSCcrm, theliellip;t b;fngs the Sldion , anb tbe queQion 
 waa tX'hcther here be futh an flfcignce that the flttion UiH lie again(f,oj not, 
 Roll chieflufl, bclo,that though here be not an afoiemt.flrialp.actojDingto Afji^nes. 
 the rales DfJ.aip. pet that he (haU be nccompteo fachan^rsigneeasistocovcnanV. 
 
 fee*
 
 4o8 ' ^I'^J- *^54- 
 
 petfojm tijc Cotjnantfl tnaoc bettoc en tbe parties , anoralcdtheDefcn-, 
 daaccoHiew Canfejvby the PlaintifHiould not have judgerocnc NoUt 
 
 Wood and Markham. 
 
 Hill. 1 <5j4, Banc. fup. 
 
 Forn rcniiu-T7|9onaftE)e<5ionefirin«bjongt>t, ant) a JCtpal tlicrcupon t)ai), a Taet« 
 
 tion after an \r D((t iuflc toono fo J tftc piaftitff; bat npoH an agreement mace bettD^n 
 
 habere <aci3. tftc pafiittf ano tljc jSr^cfEnuant , tt)c SDcfcnoant toas to Ijolo tbc lano tcco* 
 
 rxecutcd"" *^f «^'' t^^ tcmafnDct of bfs SCcrm to come, ano accojofng to tbfs agreement 
 
 be l)£lD <t fo? 2 pears , but aftcrtDarti0, befo:c W term crpfrcD.tftc J^laJnttf 
 
 tafecs ont an habere facias pofleflionem.anD ercf utCB <t. Serj.Brrnard mobeo 
 
 fo; tbe SDefenoant npon tb<6 matter IbctDeD to tlie Court , Xbat tbe SDe- 
 
 . . fcnnantnfnbthatjearulcfojreflftatton. JBot Roll chief luftice anftoe- 
 
 Reftituiion. ^pjj It cannot be, but yea mufl have your Aftion upon the Cafe againft the 
 
 Caff.- Plaintif for not performing his agreement , fo? tbe Sift feems to betincon' 
 
 fcfonablc. 
 
 Matters and VVallis. 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc, fop. 
 Pafcb. 1552.rot.58ii 
 
 c \ OTjftof<Bttojixra6biougl)tfntb<0 Cotirt to tetjerfe a Btabgcment 
 
 veifcVjuTee- /\gttEntn the Common ipieasfn an aafon Of Crcfpafs quare vi ec ar- 
 
 mcnrin Trcf-mii , ano tbc CBttoj afcfgncD toas, tbat tbc SCrcfpafa is tontlaDeo to be 
 
 P>fs quirc vi contta pacem, &c. bat DOtti not fap publicam, Twifden anftoereo , tbat (t 
 
 c( jrmis. jg jjjjg cnougb . becaafe tbe aafon tDaBtommenCO bp £);fgfnal , bnt if It 
 
 fcau been bpHBIil It teoulDljatoc been otbertolfe. Roll chief lufticc, 3tis tbe 
 
 ufe In tbe Common ^Blcas to make fntb l^o^t recitals , bat In tbe beginning 
 
 of the IRccojDbcteltlsrecltcDatlarge, anblffttuerenot rcclteoat large 
 
 Reciui. It iDoalD not bc gooD ; bot foj tbc matter It felf It is matter of fubffance , 
 
 ant) gencraUpltoagbtto beccnclaoeotobecontra pacem publicam, pet It 
 
 Is goon bete as It Is fo? tbe teafons before allegeo, Affirmctur judicium 
 
 nifi, &c. 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 • o ci "T 7\7Ildmot)eDagalnfta6>berlf< tbatbcmapnot be aumlttcB to file 
 arcluVnof'a^ V V tbc rctojn Of a tujlt Pltetfco to blm , becaofe an 9dfon upon tbe 
 wri"""'° CafclsDepcnBfngagalnftbtm fo? not returning tbistojit, anolfbcfljoulD 
 notD be aomltteD to file tbc retarn , be tDoalb tberebp abate our jetton. 
 Roll chief luftice, 3Eftbe tD?lt benotfileo, It (ban not bcfilcD till the Court 
 bemo'jEO; bnt be cannot file It as cf this Eerm, tbongb be (botilo file It 
 ro?tbe return of tb:to?lt, (asltfeems)lslonsCncepaft, bntiftbeicto^n 
 be aUf aop fileo pou mobe too late. 
 
 Swan
 
 Hill. 1554* 409 
 
 5wan and Fenham. 
 
 Trin, i65o» rot, 1072. 
 
 1^ an 0(tion of SHtepafs am CBjcttment a fpccial '^exXiia toao fonnD, ano sptciai ver- 
 (nUtl5f3Ctittom,viz."2[;!3att^c£)tDncr0 of^^oufesfntbcSColDn of New. d^^ ■" T.ef- 
 Caftle in fecGmplc mspDctjffetbembpparoU, but not SEcnantalntapl,?'^''"'^^- 
 ano ft teas furtbet founo , tljat tbc Ecttatoj toaefetfeo oftftcJ^oufEBtn^ "'" 
 qacIKon <n fee taplfn potTefBton , atiD of tbe remaftiDtt of ttjcm in fce- 
 fimplc, ana fc fcffco cb octlfc tbcm bp paroll, SElje qpcllton tnao , tcljc. 
 tbi^ttbte oet(fctDn0tDatTanteot)ptl)C<£nSom. Sbafco arsneo, tijat t^t 
 Cnfiom Dfo not l]:aTratit tb<£> setiifc, becaufe Cnffoms are nottobcenlar- 
 geo bp tonCriiflfon, but arc to be taben llrfctlp , ano actojDing to t^c Icttc r, 
 bccanfe tbep run in cb?iogemcntoftt)cCommon=latD, ano To are not to 
 be fatoureD, 9 E. j.f. 38. iiH.4,f. 33. 5 H. d. f. 51, ^crt bere are fin< 
 material Uio^ts foano in t^e ^ercia , to; if it be t^e Cuttom fo^ SHenant in 
 fee-Qmple to ocfcife.pct tljis C):tEnDs not to tenant in tapl,27 H.d.r. 5 t»i E. 4. 
 f. 34. ant) a oetife of rent to be iffuing ont of ttefe l^oufesia notgooo tsitfjfn 
 t^e Cuftom, alttoun^ tbatarcntcott)foUoti] tbe nature tft^e llano, 21 
 AiTil. pi. 78. 26 H, S. 5 4. 3.t is true, Cook in \)i0 Littleton, f» 1 1 1 . faftb, tbat 
 one map oetife a rent in remainoer^but J ocnp tbis,fo? t^c authorities of tU 
 SStcbs are againtt \iim. Sin effate in remainoet is not j^ITets , no; can be 
 oetJifcD, 3 H. 7. f. 13,24, a conDitiongocstoanGflatc-tapl, not to a fee. 
 fimple in rcmainozr, <5 Rep. f. 35. ^noljereis butapotoer of anCI;ttate. 
 ano not an (Effate in po(rcfsion,lJt. feet. 137. ^no t^e finoing l^re t^t 
 tiie. %tnmt in tapl oio Die U;itbcut tiiuc is not material, fo; t^is conlo rot be 
 Unoton at tbc time of tftc oetifc , ano iteoetife takes its effect in ttjc time 
 of tftC SDctlfo; , 27 H. 8. Dyer 4 j. s Eliz. Dyer, Biihops Cafe, l Rep, Ar- 
 chers Cafe, {.(6, 2lp. ^ere is no CuCom founo to intitle tlje part? : fo j 
 a SEotun cannot bate a Cuffom as it is bcre fotmoy t^oug^ a HBojoag^ map, 
 3 2Ar«. 178 anOtiiisisnotfounDto beanantientUill,7H. 6. Dyer, 22 H. 
 6,Fitzh. prasfcript. 47. j^Eji t^c CDi'ftom is not foimD,tftat JBurgers mak 
 uetifeasit oug^ttobc. Turnerlohn on t^eotl;crOoc^eto.tt)atro4H| 
 Cttate Botb pafs by tlje C23UI, ano it matters not Irtist Cffatc paffetlj, atW 
 t\)C £)b ners of l^oufcs in our Cafcfliall bcinicnOtD to be S^rnants in fce= 
 fimple, ano it is not ncceffarp tbat tl)cp be tenants in fee in pofTefsion, 
 Perkins Oetifcs, Plcwd. 262. Dyer 22. 23Eliz, 371, p. 5. anD the Cnflom 
 Ijere founo is no moje,bot an o?Dtnarp Cuflom common to otl)er Ibojougb?, 
 ano it fball net be intenoeo a rpecialCuftom,)anD t^isxafe map be refcmbleo 
 to Cafes upon Hjc Statute of 32, & 33 H. 8. fo? oetiling of ilanos, lo 
 Rep.f, Si.Trin. 34EI1Z. Bfc^lds Cafe tljcrecitCD. anO 35 Eliz. Howards 
 Cafe,ui)itbpjotc,tl)atrc1<CTlons mapbeDetifeD. Nat. brev. 199. a. Per. 
 kins 2>ctifcB,PI. 2 4o.istl)etjErpCafein qiicftion , anb tfte Cafes put on 
 tbeotftcrfiOEcomenot tooiiT Cafe, Roll ciiief luflice. Sltisnotncccffa- 
 rpinafpctial t!:ierD!£ttobefop?ctifea3inpleai>ing,butfomctl)ingmrrp be Srcciaiver- 
 fupplpCD, ano tbc tertjfc tjatt) fount) ttjat ije toaa £)iBncr, anO tfjat tftc £)ton-. d^^. 
 er map Dctifc . ano tbc Cunomie,tl!i!tcteTp£)tencr in feeOmplemapDC* 
 tife, ano tfiP CiiCom ffiall go to llnno ■ ano bolDs to rclcrftons as locll as to 
 lanoo in potTcfskn. ;at anotbcr nap it Uias arguco, tbat tbe Dctifc luas not 
 gcDOjfoj tt e toojD Owners cannot cytenoto all fojts of £DiBnEr8, foj it er- 
 tenDs not loan 3nfant ^Dtcncr of ftub !&oufc3 : foj tjt cannot oetife, 
 
 <I*gS ' " tbSre- 

 
 lO 
 
 Hill. 1654. 
 
 tbctefojc tl)C toojDB mutt rcccfbc a Umfteo conttrnctlon, anD tbcrefoje 3 
 contcitc tljc U)o;iD Owner cjitenos onlp to an abfoltitc SEcnant f n fee fimple, 
 anD not to:a retetGoncr in fcc: fo; a Cnttom mutt, actiatb bccnTato, be 
 tahcn ttrfctip, 1 2 E. 4, f. 3. 21 E. 4J. 24. alp. 3n truK conftructfon t\)ts 
 £)ltiner in fcc in rcmafntcr (ball not be fafo £)toj!cr , but tbcffi:cnant<n 
 tapU8J3DU)ncr,anDfobcrc<0notiDU)ncr ex VI termini, jlp, iljjcrctsbuta 
 pofeibaitp of f.' example in 4(m, VoWif is not grantablc 0; DcbffablCj'i Ed. 4.- 
 i« ano tljc Statute of Weftm. 2D. ftclps not to tlje CuCom : fo;i tftat feta- 
 tate <0 toWnJ memo?p of man, 26 h. s- f. 4. 32 Aff. Pl.28. flnoupon 
 tftc tjcrp finoing of tftc tctofttft cannot be goiD, foj bp tfte tactDftt no title it 
 founo foj tfje 2DcfenDant. Latch on t^c otbet fioe tjclD , tbat bcre is a Qcon 
 Dctffe tnatrantcD bp t^c Cnftom, foj bctc is an Cftatc tottbfn the bcrp let- 
 tet of tbc Cnftom, fo j fte (0 trne £Diunet of tljc ^^oufc in fce;fimple,altt)ougb 
 ItbcnotinpjcfcntpoffifBfcnjfojbcbat^fecfimplc fntt, ano tjat^itto bfs 
 oUin benefit in fuel) an (Eftatc as it <0, ano t^e tspjD Owner fs a general 
 tuojD, anDcompjcbcnDctballmannerof ^DtDncrfljfps. 2lp. 3t fotoftbfn 
 ijt)c reafon of t^cCuftom, foj it intcnDot^c fame benefit to £)tDner0 In 
 retjcrtton as it Dot^ to £>)]:iner:0 in polTefoion, anD ia inDiiferent untQ all (^c 
 Cates. J3nD altbousb a Cnftom fljallbetahenftrliilp, pet it ftiall alfo be 
 taben reafonablp, as ^aWng rcfpect to tbe benefit of tljc partp, ano 
 tftctc can be noreafon allegeDtobeagalnfttblsDetilfe; 2c H. 8.4. fltre- 
 mainocr in fcc ftjall 00 accojDing to tbcCuftom, tohct^et bp t^c Cuflom 
 3lanD0fnfceftiallgo,tbc Cuttomfliall go to aU tbings iffulng out of tbe 
 3lanD,anD foto all (iSatcs in tl)e ilanD , Dyer MS.anD^creio mo^etban 
 a pofoibilitp DctifcD, 4 & 5 Phil.&: Mar. Benloes.Blt ie raleD,tbat a fce=fimplc 
 tppttxant cballgototbc poungeft &on bp tbcCuftom,tDberc tljc Cuftont 
 tuas, tbat t^c pioungeft &on flionlo Ijntic tljc ILanDoof toblcfjblflilnceftoj 
 opcD fcifeb ; anD ss to tbc ClctDia bcrc lo a gmD title founD 10 j tlie SDefen. 
 Dant. Roil chief luftice , %^e tjcrDict I0 Impctfcrt , fo j tbe ©jcctment i0 ac 
 gainft JBaron anD i^emc, ano tbc i^cmc io founD €|crto} bp tbc feetDlct, ano 
 Venire iic notftlngisfounD conccmlng tbe315aron,tlbcrcfoje pou nuift ftabcaVenirede 
 novo. novo , if pou totll not agree toameno t^e tmerDict arcojDing pto tt)e note0, 
 
 If tbe notes toill tuarrant It. Afterwards a Venire de novo wai awarded 
 by confentf 
 
 # 
 
 Pcndarvis and Saint Aubin. 
 
 HiIi.i6S4.Banc,fup» 
 
 Plei before 
 
 Auditors, 
 
 Trin,r653. rot. 723. 
 
 T/p an Action of accompt tbc 2DrfcnDantplcaD0 nennqucs receptor, upon 
 -* tbl0 an 3ffue tnas topncD, ano an imprrfcrt terDirt founD, auD tbcrcupon a 
 Venire de novo iDas.alratDCD, anD tbc 3nrp f/^\^p foj tbc plaintiff, aiiD tbe 
 H)efcnoantaDtuDgebtoaccomptbefojeSIuDlto?0. SCbe 2PcfcnDant plcaos 
 befoje tbe ancitois, tbat be bao oelibereD otiar part of tbc monies. STo 
 tbifl tbc ipialntiff Demurs, anD;fl)rlno fojtanfe tbat tbis pcaiscontrarp 
 to tbc JaerDlct, fo; tbat is, tbat be fljoulD actompt foj all, anD berebe luoulo 
 accompt but fo? part onlp. . Windham fo? tbc plaintiff argncD, tbat 
 tbis cannot be a gooD plea befoje auDltojs in Dlfcbarge of tbe accompt , but 
 Itgoesinbarof tbc accompt. Dyer 196. 4t E. 3.f. 3T.22H.d. 25, anoin 
 Boynton anD Cheeks Cafe latclp in tbifl Court focb a i^lea teas aOluDncD 
 mt eoBO. ;9nD It tootilt) be micl^fetious if it Dbonlo be otbcrtcifr, in refcrting 
 
 fircb 
 
 «»
 
 Hill. 1654. 4ti 
 
 fucft matter to be trpeo again. Twifdcn on tijc otfjer Coe faf d <t fs a gmD 
 plea befoje auDfto?0,tofap,tl)at^cretcftJCD tljemonfcBto CElttcroticr.ano 
 tbere are four opfnfons fn tbc IBoolis ftotD tl)<0 matter fljoulD be plcaoeO; /o 
 E. 3* Br, Ace 80. IjclD , tljat tbfspca Ispleaoafalc befoje ;atiQaoj0, ano 
 tbta pleafofnoffcbargeoftbcjafcompt, onDtl)crefo?e pleaoablc befojc 0u= 
 
 BJtOJS, 12 H. 4. 18. i3nt)(tl Bjyncon anO Cheeks (TafC cftCD , tljC juDgC* 
 
 ntent toao not g<t)rn upon tbfa pofnt. Roll chief luftice , SCbe llBrnks gene^ 
 rallparE,tbattb(splcat6mbaroftl);arcompt : but bcrc pourplea of oc^pic. 
 Utjcrp obcr, ftatl) maoe (t a plea in bar, anQ (t luoulo be mtfcljtetoua to plead 3ir," 
 it noto , foj tW0 tioulD caufe one ano tbe fame fffuc to be ttokc trpco, ano 
 tljcn tfecre map be conttarp 2»EtDfiJ0,lDft(tf) iroulo be (nconUcnient. There* 
 fore Itt judgemeiu be for the Plaintiff. 
 
 6'tavely at^d Ulichorp. 
 
 Hill* 1^54 Banc.fup. 
 
 A0 ^Aion of SDcbt luao b;ougl)t upon tlje statute of 2 Ed. (5. (0% not fef- Arrt , f 
 tfng fojtb of 2rU!)e3-,anii a aierDfctlBaagitiEn foj tbc patnttfF. 3:t U)a0ii"^e'mert in 
 mobeo in nrrcft of luogemcnt t^at tlje Statute Vcas mff ric(teD,»"'^''"."'^°' 
 bccaufe it \sae not fafotl)e pacltamcnt in tobicb it icao maoc tuaa tclD,'^"/^,,^;^!^^!,, 
 bp pjojogation , as in trutft it teas. But Latch anftocrco, tfiat itionot 
 mif.recitcD,fo; it is true that tbe parlioincnt teas bdo, tipon ti'.c ptlj.of No« . 
 vember, aaUjcl)atieaUcgeD,tIjougt)iDEl)al3e not cypjcffco it to be Ijela bp ^"^'■*' 
 pjorogation , ano iuc tonceitc it is not neceffatp to crpjefo it to be fo ftelD, 
 foj tlje |D?c(iocnt0 arccontrarp, as in Cooks Entry, tit. Prohibition. Roil 
 chief luUice, SC^e fBarliamcnt is not faiD to be.bcgun anubelD, butonlpto 
 be ftclD, ano tljerefoje it is Uiell enouglj. ludgcmen: was [,ivcn for the 
 Plaintiff, nifu Pofte'a, 
 
 Dormanand vS'nag, 
 
 HiIUi6$4. Banc, fupf 
 
 ' A ^ 2rtion npon tlje Cafe tnas b jouglit upon ttoo piomifcs , viz. to pap Arrcn cf 
 \l\ fo muchmonp upon a certain oap : ano ilp. to fatjetbe plaintiff barm= )''<'g-'"<:n- in 
 Icfs, nc mpon ilTue iopneo ano a tjcroict fonno foj the |tnainttff,it tuaa mo= '" •^^°'^. 
 tjco in arrcft of f uogement, that the plaintiff oio not lljebo ho\u the UDefcn- J'omi'frs" 
 Bant hath not fabco the plaintiff harmlefo, but onlpfapcsgcneraUp that 
 he oio not fahchimbarmlcfs, snofohe map bjing another iilctton fojthc 
 fame thing. SThe Court luas then of opinion that it iDaonotgmD tofap 
 generallp, that the SDefenoant oio not fate f;im harmlefs, but be ought to 
 IhciB in tohat particular ; as if 3 affumeano pjoipifctoonetoeibcbimaU 
 the monp in mppurfr,? mutt CbetD holu much monp Vona in ir,ano abc r that 
 3 gate it htm.0t another Dap &crgcant Clark uiobco foj tuDgcmrnt,uhotii 
 Latch feconocD, ano faio, here i0 a gma bjeach afaigneo : foj it is that he paio 
 not the monp foj tohich the plaintiff iuao touno toith him at fuch a oap , ac = 
 £0 joins to his pjomifc. Twnden on the other (ioc faio , that the confiocratioii 
 {3 to pap the ufurp foj the monp foj tohfchthe pialntif tons bouno itith the 
 SDefcnoant, tohich is not a gooD conftoeration, foj it is againft the Common» 
 into to let monp foj ufurp, ano fo it toasaojuogco 2 Car.anot'oe Statutes do 
 but toUerate the tahing of ufurp ioj monies, alp. ^erc isno timcofthe 
 conCoeration fet fojth- Latch, Che ufurp hcrcisnomojctban thcsta. 
 tiite alletos, ano fo it is a gooo conftoeration, Alleyn, 2Ehe pjomtfc uccla- 
 
 dUggi ■ tcv
 
 41 i Hill. 1654. 
 
 teonponf^Donble, i.topapmonp. alp. 2Do Tatie |)atmlcr0 , ano tliebeacli 
 
 ^^P (0 affltgncD gencrallp, ano not pattkalarlpaaUoug^ttobc. Roll chief 
 
 *'' lattice, 3iftloob;ieac^e0bear6fgneD, ani) tbcone tocU afsisncD, annttiz 
 
 ot^er not, pet tbc ;a(t<on Uc0 tocll enougt) : bnt Jbcrcisbutoneb^cacb aC- 
 
 CgncD, viz. tbe non papmcnt of t^c monpattljcDap. 0nDfojtt)cotl^cc 
 
 Confidcration "'^^'^^'^ 31 l)olD <t a gooD coh&Dctatfon to afftimB to fabc one ftarmUfa from 
 
 paping of CUiirp, ano tbc ufurp Ijcrc cicpjeffcD <0 latofuU bp tbc Statute, 
 
 ano fo ft ^ati) been refollj^Dftncc 2 Car. and therefore let judgement be for 
 
 be Plaintiff, nifu 
 
 Turner and Trapes. ; 
 
 Hill, 1654, BarK, fup. 
 
 Motion to ai T ^'^" l»?oual)t an adon of SDebf upon a tecognffante in-t!je ^Dcftfbagg. 
 icr a i"ica in * ^Ctjc SDcfcntjant pjapcD oyer of tbc ConDltfon tbete, anD bao <t, after- 
 the P<:ttibag£- luarDfl l)c f^etDB tl)f0 Hiattct to tbfs Court, ano pjaps, in rcgarD be bao miU 
 office. tafeen l)<0 plea,tbat be map repleao* Roll chief iuftice, CW0 cannot be 
 
 grantcD upon motion bere, fo^fftbc ffTuc be jopneo (n tbc ipett(bagg. pou 
 
 ntpft trp ft, we can make no rule but by confem. 
 
 • 
 
 Hill. 1654 Banc. fup. 
 
 Topieadfpe V'V^''''®" Windham motjco fo; bf^Clpcnt, ffjat bemfgbf bateUbcrfp 
 ciaiiy. to pleat) fpccfallp in an action of SCrcfpafa ano CEiectmcnt, ano not 
 
 gcncrallp not gniltp. Roll chief Iuftice, iFojtBbat taufC:' Windham, 
 JBecanfe tberc batb been matter glbcn in ctjioence at a fo?mct Crpal, 
 tobicb ongbt not to bate been. Roll chief Iuftice, pjofCED accojioing to tbc 
 conrfe oftbc^Conrt , tftbc otbct tolll not content pon fljall not plcaft 
 fpcciallp , yet let him Ihew caufe why you may not plead fpecially. 
 
 Barker and Elnner. 
 
 Hill. 1654, Banc, fup, 
 
 wheiher » HT !^e Cafe 1080 tb{0,one Of tbe gufticcs Of ^foi^e falling ftcfe , anbopfng 
 
 Mif-tryaior | at Chclmesford in EiTcx , tbc iJfflifCB lucre aDjourncQ to Brentwood in 
 
 ^'°- tbe fame Countp; aftctlrarDs, ano before tbc fitting at Brentwood tbe other 
 
 3nDcefcllfick, ano opeo at London , ano a nciu CommiTaion iffncofo^tl; 
 
 to autbo^iife another 3^Mg.t to fit at Brentford •acco;tDing to the aojourn* 
 
 ment, ano there a EErpal toac hao upon the olo lurata rctojneo bcfoje the o» 
 
 tbet 3!tit)gcs, SChc queftiou teas, tobctbcr this tocre not a miCtrpal , inures 
 
 garo there teas not a n^iD Siurp reto?ncD; SLhe Cafe teas Diticrs times mo- 
 
 tjcD, ant) the Court 'tool; time to aatiifc : but at length Roll chief Iuftice 
 
 Mir-tryjI. delivered the opinion ofthc Court, that this Wat not a mif.tryal, faecaufctbe 
 
 Death of the 31ufticc0 luao not material to mal?e it boio , fo; tbe Snfticeo arc 
 not namen in the lurata: btittbcCaufeisjrFpjcffeD generallptobctrj'eD - 
 bp tl)c 3Ii!flfces. 0no be faio, that he helti it fo j a rulc,tbat if a CiarU miOen^ 
 Amr!,7n?rnr t^"^ ^ thing Bfual ttt mattet of fo jm,iti0to be amcnoeo ,♦ Out thc.crroj of tbe 
 SltiDge map not beamcnDco, anDheciteotbefei3jPfiDent0, Mich. ijCar. 
 Sawyer anOHortons CafC ill tl)(0 Coutt, ailOHill, 15 Car. Belth anD Fates 
 
 cafe fnt pis Coart. 
 
 Hiil. 
 
 Atncndmcnr,
 
 Hill. 1(^54' _4*5_ 
 
 Hill. 1654- Banc.fup. 
 
 A^ action of 0(raultaniJ5i5attcrp iraa bjougW agafnft ttno, one of Motion to 
 t^cm plcaos^fs pjitJkgcofparUantcnt, nnntljeottjernoncul.SCbeftnktoneDe- 
 pafntlf motcD tbc Court that ^e mim tttfbe tlim oat of tfje ffJctlatatton *"«*»"' °« 
 tobobaoplcaDeDtljcp^fwflcBe, anDm<gl)t p?oteeD agafnft tlje ot^t ^"IP^Lion. 
 Bus: the Court would Qiske no rule, but bid the Plaintifprocccdashe pleal- 
 ed at bis own peril, 
 
 Hill. 1654. ©anc. (iip. 
 
 Ojpc Cock ioas commfttet) bp tftc Coutt fo j oeUterfng a IBUl of Midle* Commitment 
 lex to arreft one ao be toas comfng to tl)e Conrt about bta occaCons.tor comcmpc 
 bHttna0p?0fentlpteleafeD, paping t^e fees ano Dffcbatgtng tbe pattp ar.^^'^^ ^°""' 
 rcftED, ano t&c JBatlff toas rep joteD, but not commUteo, becaafe ^e fafo 
 6c t5neU) not that tbc pattp ban anp buGncfg fn Court , anD ftat tje attcftcD 
 Wmontoft^e!^aUt Nota, 
 
 Hacker and Newborn. 
 
 Hill, 1653, Banc, fup» 
 
 1% tuas fbeiDCD to tftc Court tbat tbe pafntff Ijao berctofoje liaD a ftpal to n»y pro- 
 attbelBarfojtbefamctUng, fojublcbbe nolo b?<ng0 W adion, anD ceedings tai 
 tljat ft tocnt tben againtt bfm , bnt be batb \?M pet papcD tbe SDefenoant Wa "J' p*'/ '" 
 coft0, anD nolii bjfnga a nciu action; Jt toas tberefojc pjapcD tbat 6e map ^^'q"^" 
 pap the Coftg tajcD fn tl)e fojmcr action befojc be be fuffctea to pjoteco tn 
 tifsartfon. Roll cl)i€fIuftice,Let itbcforuledt 
 
 Higgs and Hairifoni 
 
 Hill, Id 54. Banc, fup, 
 Mich* idyf, rot. 429, 
 
 HlfgsbjingS an action of SCrcrpafCquare claurum fregit agafnft HarrU demurrer to' 
 fon an attojncp of tbe Common picas. SEbc Dcfcnuant plcans bis i pica of pru 
 pjftflegc bp an attojncp , ann to tbisplca tbe plaintif ocmnrteo ; tbe que* v.ie^cby an 
 fifonUjastobcibcrbcmapplcaotbfflpleabpattojnep , oj ougbt to plcan ^""^"'^y* 
 it in proper perlon, latch argUED , SChatb-Ougljt not to plcaD ft bp at- 
 tojncp , foj tbfc pica is not a pica to tbe turioDiction of tbe Cotirt , bat it is 
 onlp a p?apcr to tbe Court , anti be mfglit bate Done ft ore tenus, anD pleaD« 
 fnnitbp attojncp bis pica cannot be cntrcD, foj tbcn-tbc plea of pjitflegc 
 iPonlobcDfftroprB inmaUingtjim to ntfcnt), Ctierp one bp tbe Common 
 ILatDwigbttoapppe.irinperfon, ann tbcrc is no Statute, l^ato noj ufagc 
 tlj.it autbojifctb an attojnep to mate an attojncp to DemanDbfapjftiflegc. 
 ; Ip, 3;t is againft tljc Dignitp of tbio Court tbat be IboulD be aomftteD to 00 
 U. sip. IBpmaUfngofan attojnep be Dcftrops tf)C tierp reafon tobp be 
 claf ms bfs pjftjilcge, tubicl) fs to be fparco of bis attcnoance. toWcb be nceos 
 notff bcmaUcan attotncp, anoWsmafefngof an attorucp bcrc fs a ge- 
 neral toarrant to oefcno otbct caufcs as tucll as tbf3 , anD t^5 Cafe of an 
 
 © g g 3 Cffofgti
 
 414 Hill. 1654. 
 
 ~ Cffotgnobjetteomabeefo^me, iDbfttjfsbutto pjap an crcafe, anci after 
 
 an attojncp mane one cannot caft an cffofgn , except ft be ujtjcrc tbc Slttoi-- 
 nep cannot anftoer, 4 Ed. 3. 34. anDtbetetano autbojitp canbcCbcUieD 
 tbat be map mahc an iJttojncp . 315at on tbc contrary piirt there arc manp 
 pSicBDcntfl tobcrc Sttojncpis batoc pjapco tbclr p:<Wlcge tn pcrfon, ano tbcfc 
 tncrccmefljotUD matte tbc ILatofntbiB Cafe, Dyer 35 H. Ststbecppjcfij 
 
 Attorney. ffl!"^ j »oH.6. ja. The Court adviled, Htanotbcc Dap Roll chief luftice 
 fafO, That the opinion of the Court was , that an Attorney may plead his 
 privilege by an Attorney , ano tbcre ffl no fncontcnJcnce foUoUs bp Dcfnn; ft^ 
 butftfotrtictbelpjEftQcntcarefaotbtoapfl, ano ft is not contrarp to anp 
 tljtng b^ bath Done, ano ft map be be (sCcI^, 0; batb buCncfs fn ano- 
 tber Conrt, tobcrc be fiJ nctcffarflp to attcno. Therefore let his plea be aU 
 lowed, nifi, 
 
 Leake and Reynolds. 
 • Hill, 1^54. Bjnc.fup. 
 
 Spcciiiver- y take fejoiigbt an0£tfon Of SDcbt npott an flDblfgatfon againff Reynolds, 
 
 d.a in debt _L2t^g BDcfenoant pleaog non eft fadam , tbc ^wp upon fffuc (opncD fino 
 
 upon a bond, g fpj.£jai ^cto((t totDfs cffcct , Mat tbc plafntjfo ©cclaratfon fa npon an 
 
 £Dblfgatfoni)atcDtbe24Dapoftbemontb, anotbep fino tbat tbc £)blig.i- 
 
 tfontoagfealcDanDDcUbcrcDtbeajDapoftbc montb, bnt bears Date tbc 
 
 24 Dap, anD tobctber tbto IljnU be accomptcD tbc fame Stblf gallon upon 
 
 iEbfcbtbcplaintifDcclarcsojnot, fs left to tbc Court to Detcrmfne* Green 
 
 fojtbcpafntiffafo, tb-ittbtacafcfo tbe fame Ir.ftb Goddards cafe, ano 
 
 tbere ft inas aoiuogcD a gooo cccd , i 2 H <5 f. i . Dyer 247. anD fn tbe eno 
 
 of Goddards ca^c tljc cafe fn pofnt to antuDgco. Roll chief Juftice , SCbfa fa 
 
 Pi^'- a plea f n SBar, ano not in abatement, tbctcfo jc take your judgcmerit. 
 
 Hill. i6j4- Upper Bench. 
 
 Bp Roll chief luflice , 3foncbatbcolour of tftlc to lano, an 0ctfoti of 
 tbe Cafe tofU not Ue agafnft bfm fojfapfng, 3 babe better title to 
 ;';;ir"'^' tbe lanotDanpou, tbougb bf0 tftlc be not fo gooo as tbc otbera title is, 
 Noca, ^ 
 
 VViogfield and Valence. 
 
 Hill. i<J54.Banc,fup, 
 
 Hill, i550,roM409. 
 
 For nftiuii-T Afch mobcD to babc rcttltutfonof mottfcs out of tl)c bJinDsof a S>bcrff, 
 on of monif J |_ ^^jjjj jjp ^gt, leVjfcD upon an erccutfon taken out of UAq Conrt , bccaufe 
 ImS ^''*"' •' '^""^^ f''?^'' erronfounp , fo j bcfojc tbe CErcctJtfon tahcn f jtb tbc SDcfen. 
 Daiitbjoug()tbf3to?ft of Crroj fn tbc Cbcqtjcr Cbamber to rebcrfe tbe 
 taogement, anntfac I'lccojD tDSsrciitobcDtbftbcr, ano altbougb tbc late 
 statute fap , tbat a iojft of Gtroj Ojall be no luperfedcas to ttap cicccutfon , 
 pet tbr Hcco:i5 being rcmobeo into tbc Grclicquer Cbamber , no erccutfcn 
 can be granteo oat 'gcre, foi bcrc fs no Hcco;D to iijarrant It. Roll chief lufl-, 
 SEbe cafe bcfng mobeo agafn af anotbcr Dap, tfll toben tbe Court toonlD ao. 
 bffe,fafo,2Cbc KciOjDfa rcmobcD bp a lojft of Crroj fn tbc (i!;i;cbcqtiet 
 
 Cbam«
 
 Hill. 1654. 415 
 
 Cbatnbet , ano is not iioto before tis, no? teas at t^c time toben tde Creca- 
 Hon IffacD fojtj), ano tWs befng after a Vcrufd ano a lucgcmcnt tjje toitt'of ^,irgf,i^P 
 cErroMsnofupetledcas, anD fo ft fa m<fcWet)0U8 bott) tnapa, bnt boto cansuperftdew 
 toe belp ft :> yet take a fupzrfcDeas qufa crronftc to fuperfede the execution , 
 for it was ill awarded, andcake the moneys out of the Sherifs hands* Noia» 
 
 T'he Protcclor and Captain Streeter, 
 
 Hill. i(554,Banc. fup. 
 
 C0pta{n Streeter toas bjOUfbt fr»Coutt bp habeas Corpus, anO upon tbi^of delivery 
 return tcao ano filcD , ftnppcargtbatbe xuaecommftteD bp an jSDjwc^^" Prifoner 
 of parUament, fo^pHblfOifngftanDaloiw ano fcD(tfou0 booUa. Twifden^^^'^HTbeiT 
 niobci) tbat tbe pjffoncr mfgbt be bafico, becaufc Hat t|| IparUamcnt fscorpus. 
 note DfffoltcD , ano bp tonfequencc tbc iflDjocr bp tobfcb bnras commfttcD , 
 <0of nofojee. ^?. :9tto?nep (Dcncral on tbe ot4;er Coc urgeo , tbattb'c 
 parlfament toa0 not of irolt)ec,but onlp tte ntcetfng of tbofc perfons (n |£>ar- 
 Ifamcnt toae tfffoll'eo , fo? tbe^arlfament bp tbcantfent ilain fa to be Cs 
 tjerppear, folbattbfs fa bat fn effect an aufonrnment, ant not a offfola^ 
 tfon, ano beCoe0,tbfs matter fojivtfcb tie piffencrftanDs commftteo can- 
 not be bcrc f nqufrco of , ano fo tbe canfc of bfs tommftment fljall be fntenOs 
 eotobegooo, ano tbe parliament map commfttoftbont flbetufngtbecaufe 
 of tbe tommftment, anotbfs commftmcnt mapbefnojDer to bfaSCrpal, 
 ano tbe pjffoncr fs not liftljotit remeop , fojbemapapplp bfmfclf to tb^ 
 fup?cme ^atboMtp , to totom tbe |darlfament bate rcCgneB tbcfr potoer. 
 Twiidcn foj tbe pjffoncr tonfelTea , tbat tbfaCourt cannot be Snoge of tbe 
 |0arlfament ; but tUs £D;Dcr bp Ui'ofcb be fa commftteo offfera from an Slit 
 of fdarUament , fo;tbtafatempo;arp,anDOeterinfnetb ; ano altbougbtbe 
 autbojftpofpailfamcntccafetbnct, petapartfcalar|parlfamcnt map be 
 Dfffolbeo, aatbfaVcaa. Wadham Windham, ^ben a |3arl. faofffolbiD, 
 tbe p;oc«;Dfnga tberc are octermfncD. Flowrdews cafe i H, 7, tbe iLatfne 
 cafe , ano tbe JDarUfanolDOfffoltei), ano not aojoarncD, nno a |0arlfa- 
 ment oftfolteo fa not Ifhe tbe Courts of guff fee bere fn tbe tOl acatfon tf me. 
 Wild, 2Cbf3 cafe fs not IfUc to tbe tafcirbcrctbfa Court rcmannowi a pjf:. 
 foncr commftteo bp tbe iparlfamcnt fitting tbe parliament, fo; tbe pjffo- 
 ncr bere fa coram Protedore txbo map Oclfbcr Ijfm. Caprain Streeter, $02- 
 flttojnep labours to afpcrfc me ; but Cjctoa no catifc oj crime foj mp com- 
 mitment , ano 3 am b^re bcfo?e tbe |3jot£ctoj fn bis olcn Court. Attor- 
 ney General, ^nlptbe pcrfonaanoticfrconiicntfon fa cftroltco, but not 
 tbe Court, no mojetbantbfa Court fa. bp tic ocmife of tbeJ^ing, 0; fntbe 
 tiaacatfontfmc, ano 3 muft refer it to tjjc Court boU) far pon ItifH intcr- 
 mcoole in tbis csfc , rno tbfa £)jDcr bp Vrbffb'be ftanca committeo map bt 
 bis jnogement tbere , ano tijen be cannot be oeliberco ; ano 3 fenoto no oif= 
 fercncc faettoeen an £)?Der ano an £Djtinance of iparliamrnt, ano tbe 
 ftamp ano autbo jftp of p;!rliamcnt is upon this jocr ; ano ft tbe pjifonera 
 C^fcl fap true,tbcnbc inap bnne an Action of falfe inipjifonment agairtt 
 bi0<Sao(er. Twiiden . f^.refsno jSDjoer of tbe |0arliamentrc(urncD,but 
 ft erpjcfTcfb that be \j-ae committeo bp tbe fepcakcr bp tcrtuc of an :©:ocr 
 oftbcp.nlianrcnt. Roli chief luUice, »!Il2c cramfnc net tlje £)jocr0 of 
 parliament; bnttbequcnionfa Irbctber tbe £)jocr ootb noto continue, order of 
 ano 3 conrcftc ft fa oetermfnco hp the oifToluticn of tbe parlfamcnt , ano Pariiwrcnr, 
 fo tboulo ft batjc tone bp pjojogatior. of tbe parliament , brraufc tberc re a-D'^'uimi''". 
 notber fecfoion , ano toe can juogc no ctbcrtoifc of £Djoer0 of parliamcHt, 
 butbptbctoojB3ottbcm. Aikiuftice, Hfone tbat fa committee bp £)j- 
 
 .■'•'*."k--.
 
 '~^ _ Hill..i654. 
 
 jjft of IJarUamcnt cannot be ocUtcren until another parUament, t|>e pco- 
 
 pUfl Ubertp IrlU be loft, fo? tfecrc map not «?e a parUament in manp peara^ 
 Roll chief luftice, ilneto parliamrnt l)3tb not reference to tljcolD, but ([ 
 fg a netD Court treatco upon nclo fetimnionB, ano irbp map not tbe |0jtro. 
 OCT be balleo toabout tbefe Dffpute0 .' altlongb be map applp bJmfclf cire= 
 tibetc; But the Court would advile, bccaufetbep pcrccJbeD tbcpjffonct 
 ttubboan- jatanotbcr l>ap,^(Jr. Actornev>"pon tbc pjtfoncra appearance a« 
 pain upon b<s Habea* Corpus fajD , tbat be bao no mo jc to fap tban tobat be 
 bano^mcrlpoffercD, onlpbe aoociJ tbat It lias a tenoct ano a Icaufng 
 tafe, anDtbcrefojetobevceUaDtJfeoof. Roll chief lufticc , iFojtbcflira 
 
 Return. part Of tbe return, 3 conccffee <t too genial , foj it Dotb not appear fn tobat 
 tbe bmba arc fcanoaloufl , fo; the pubUfljing tobcreof be toaa comm{ttcD» 
 
 Order. alp. 3 toncclbe tbat tbe £>iDct of jbarKam^nt ccafetb toUb tbe parUament, 
 
 tobicb ta Diffolbe^j aa^n ^;iDer of oric&ciafonofparUamcntenDa fcftb 
 
 mttee tbc fecfston , aj#(0 not UUc an 00, tobkb continues after tbe idarUament; 
 
 ' ' anOflU Committees mapebpojDcr of JDarlfament DO ceafebp ofOblbtngof 
 
 tbe parliament , but tbofc tobicb are mane bp 3ct of parliament Doe contf. 
 
 nue aftcrtoarus ; ano tbisinoitioual parliament being Diffolbeo , tbcp can 
 
 B I note mate no turtber ojuec , anu fo tbc p^ifoner map Ife perpctuallp f jt pjf. 
 
 *' * fon, ant be batbalrcaop lain long in pjlfon, anD tbcrefoje it ia reafon t)e 
 
 IboulD be bf ilcD. SLbc pjifoncr toaa aomonifbCD to be quiet,anD not bence- 
 fojtb to Oifturb tbe fetate. The prifoner was ordered to bring iuretiet to be 
 bound in s oo I. for his appearance here tbe next Terra , and Dc DC Die in HU 
 em until S^h ^ttojnep will proceed againft him, if he will proceed at ail. 
 
 Hudfon andDickenfon. 
 
 Hill, 16 J4. Banc, fup. 
 
 , »T-^e Court toaa mobcDon tbc bebalf of tbc piafntif , tbat a Nil capiat 
 N,ic"pi7t per -*- pcrbiilam map bc entrcD againtt bint foj ocpeDition In an jaaion of 
 Biiiam for ex- iCrefpafafoj tailing atoapbiaCattcl, toberein be bao obtaincD a metoitt, 
 pedition. bccaufe be ban DeclareD fo; taking atoap 6 ^ares anD Colts , ano DiD not 
 
 (bcto boto manp ipaics, ano boto manp Colts pattfculaclp. Roll chief lu> 
 
 ftice , Let a Nil capiat pet Billam be encrcd. 
 
 Pinchard and Fowke. 
 
 Hill. 1654. anc. fup. 
 
 • 
 
 Prnchardbjougbt an Action upon tbe Cafe againft Fowke, upon an Af- 
 lumpfu , anD Declares, tbat tbc ©cfrnoant , in conBocration tbat tbe 
 an Aai^nup-'piainttftooulDfojbeattopjotcftalBiUofCrcbangcD^aton upon tbe J3[)e» 
 on an Af- feuoant, tbat be tooalo pap tbe monepa tobcn be IbonlD nert come to ]^- 
 fumpfic. jjon . ^no upon an glTuc lopneD, ano a aerDict fotuiD foj tbe piaintfWit 
 toas mobcD tn arrcft of 3luDgcment,tbat bctc is no conCDcration fet fojtb to 
 grounD tbe pjomife upon ; fo? be Dotb not fbeto tbat be tame to London , 
 but fljctoa tbat be DpeD at Plymouth, ano came not to London. Roll chief 
 C^nfidera- juQice, Ebc toming to London ia allcgcD to no ptirpofc, fo? tbc papmcnt of 
 Jj°J)' tbc moncp vraa a Dntp,ano tbe monic6 to be paiD tecrc rcceibeo beponn &ca, 
 
 anDioiaaDutp, auDmaoca goo3 confioccation , tbercfo?e let the Plaintit' 
 cake bit ludgemenc, 
 
 Pafcb.
 
 Trin. 1654^ 4*7 
 
 Pafc. 1654. Banc (up. 
 
 1% toas fafo bp t^e Contt tftat toften an 3Info jmcr ftat^ atfattjcD Bfs SiaU a good pie» 
 on (n a Court, another BInfojmer cannot fnfoxmfo;itfte fame tl)(nB,anD»i!»'f'ft«n in 
 If lie 00, tt'ii agooDplea fnJBartot^c fccono Slnfojnrtt, tljat an (nfoj- ^°^'""- 
 tnatf on ie oeit ^nof ng againlt ^im ioi t^e fame tt)f ng. NotSf 
 
 B 
 
 Trin. 1654- Banc- fup. 
 
 p Roll chief lufttce, 21 JBafUfofa Ubcrtp Iwtft tetarn of tD2ft0, awn How a re- 
 t^cicfojie a tefcons maoe from Mm mnS be eicp^effeo to be ont of ^fs ^<^""' '' ("^ be 
 banjjs , but a tefcous maue from tbe fefterffa IBaUff mttft be cppjeffeo B''''[f "^'^• 
 
 tobeoutoftbet)anD0ott^e&t)cr(rd]5aUif , fo^t^e 15a(Ur ia bnt tbe&^e< 
 tffofeiDant. 
 
 P atncU and Brooke. 
 
 Ttin, 1^54. Banr.fup^ 
 
 T'^c Contt \sw moteo npon an Affidavit to Cap (Erecatfon apon a f tiBge . j- 
 ■^ mtnt gttjcn foj an aomfnltttato? , becaofe tbe iLcttcr© of aDmfnfffra- cut S 
 
 exc- 
 
 lion tuetc tepealeo bcfojc tftc (nngcmcnt enttco. Roll chief laftice , JCftc a judgereenc. 
 Matter comee not legaBpfnqnElHon before no, poamatt bjfng pont au- Auduaque-' 
 dint querela, yet let ^etn the Secondary examine it, f^h. 
 
 Trin. 1654, Banc. flip. 
 
 nr ^e Conrt iuaa motjco foj a to?<t of Diftringas agafnft tbe 3Inf>afaffant0 f nww- 
 .J- ofa SEoton In Hummgtonfbire , foj t^jotofng fn of bante of tbc €atl of caTsLinft 
 Bedfords in ^{0 DjalncO lanD0. Roll chief luftice , Take it , but at the re- 1- habuants of 
 torn of the writ the Inhabitants may plead to you , notwithftanding 0i)P the ' ^^^n. 
 late Kingi Atturncy would not have fuffered it. Nota. '''«»• 
 
 and the Sherifs of London 
 • Trio,i654. Banc. fup» 
 
 Ai^jacrton upon tbe Cafe tDa0bjongbt agafnff tbe &1jet{f0 of London Moved that 
 fo J not retnrnf ng a fieri facias : %i}z 2DcfenDant0 plcau not guHtp, ano che Defen. 
 a^nrptnaoretntneototrptbettrne , ano after tbe SDefcnnanto files tbe<'*nc$mgiK 
 tetnrn of tbe Scire facias. Wadham Windham mobeb , tbat tt)e fiDefcn**'''*'^ *?''"'* 
 D8nt0 mtght toaftc tljefr general plea of not gnfltp , ano mfgbt pleao fpe- '''• 
 tlalip, viz. achat tbcpbaoerecatcotbetojft. Rollchiefluftjce, You have 
 pleaded already , and it is jn our power whether we will fuflFcr you to alter ''"'^"'^"^'"'' 
 your plea or not, and we will not doe it without the Plaintif will confent, 
 therefore make the beft of that plea you have pleaded upon your tryal. 
 
 ^^^ Oylet'
 
 4i8 Tr in. 1654. 
 
 « ■ ~ 
 
 Oyles andMaifliall. 
 
 Trin,'id54'Bauc, fup* 
 
 Ag«ir ft grji- \7 \7lld upon a talc to fljcto taafc toljp a p joWblUon fljotilo uot be cranS 
 tii.^a I'roh.- »^ V pjj ^Qjijj, ([jouttof IDolkpofaffurantefn London, flictosfoj canfe, 
 Co°rl 'ou'o- ^^^^ ^^^ E^cfcnoant bao plcaocD tbctc , ann tftc piafntfff ban rcplreo . ana 
 iic7ot aSu- '^ ttjat tbc caufc ujaa tcaop fo j SErpal, ano tbat tbc pjtntfpal matter \joa0 fit to 
 raiicc. bctrpeotberc, anotbepbauantbojUytotrplt. Roll chief luftice, SJftbep 
 
 „. bate SurlfDfctfon of tbcpjtntfpal njatter, tbep batjc alfoSmlfofrtfonofall 
 Tr'yaJ ""' mattctB inctDitit tbcrEtmto, anDtbcptnap trpthemaccoaofngtotbetourfe 
 
 of tbcfr iaU), fo tbatttbcnottonttarp to tbc Common-lato. Therefore 
 
 dilcharge the former rule. 
 
 Trin. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 Bp Roll chief lunice, ^fno pattfctilatpcrfott bp Cattom be bouiro 
 to r-pafr a feca^toaH to^cretn a bjcacb is maoc , tbc tobolc JLctJCl ate 
 
 Who ofcoiTi- 
 
 nion r'plit aic 
 
 rotcp^ir a bopnO to DO ft. 
 
 Sea-wall. 
 
 Trin. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 Coipus 
 
 How a Will Y^^Joit cWdchcc gfbcn in a SCrpal at tbc 5Bat bettoccn &fr lohn Bridges, 
 maybcievo- / ,-,^0 llip ILojD Chandois,ft iDfla fafo bp Roll chief laf^ice, tbat oncmap 
 
 ''^''- tctjobc a MIfll in tojftlns bp |0aroll, ano map tctrfte it agam bp J^a- 
 
 roU. 
 
 Trin. 1654 Banc. Tup. 
 
 For a Habeas T ^^ Court toas tttotJCD foj 8 Habcfli Corpus fo} one oirt.laiDCB in fclonp, 
 I bccaijfc be cannot be trpcD tbere tnbcte tbc fclonp teas tone, nntfB tbe 
 £)utlato;p be rctctfeJ). 315pt ft tuaspjapco foi tbc ^a^otcctoj tbat a Ha= 
 bea< Corpus map not be gtanteo , becaufc tbc pjtfonct ftanog tommfttco 
 foj tf beta felonf CB anO rapc0. Roll chief luflicc, He fhall bebroughthi* 
 ther by a Habeat Corpus toreverfe the Outlawry, but wc will remand bim 
 to be tryed where he is, 
 
 Trin. 1654- Banc, fup, 
 
 Thit one "Tl^P Court loas motJCD fo; one bjonjtbt out of Wales bp a Habeas Cor* 
 mi(.h.. be bay- 1 pus, tbat tjc map bc baplcD, becaufc tbcp babe no ©aoUoelf bcrp tbere. 
 led. Roll chief luOice , Jt tocrc gooD a Quo warranto toerc bjougbt agafnft 
 
 Quo warran- ^^^^ fj,j ^Pj „g„g t^c^ pjftflcgCS Dulp. Let the Prifoner be bound to an- 
 "'• iwer bis offence «t the nc« /^ (Tifes, 
 
 The Prote(5lor and Bixter. 
 
 Eiror to re- Trin. i^j^. Banc. fup. 
 
 vcifc an Out. 
 
 i».v y 'nftio-^^j^c Baxter cntfcteD upon fufpftfon ofll^obbcrp tras out lairco upon 
 cd'o'bcai-^ v.* tbc Cncf.-tment , ano taken upon tbe fl)utlato2p, ano commftteo to 
 lowed. F'^^t
 
 Trin. i6 54« 419 
 
 Fimbury.<I5aol ; aftertoarOfl fjcbjfncsaOTtitof CBttojto ret)etfctl)e£)tjf« 
 latojp, ano obtafna a Habeas Corpti tctcbjouafttbft?jertop;oficutct)te 
 tKJtitofGrtot, ant) upon tlierEtojn thereof iDasL;;oac.bt to tbeSBat, cno 
 pjapes toftatJEbtatarU ofCrroj nlioiDCD , ano toJ^atEiIoanftlafslsncD 
 \)tm, ano t^at t)e map ^ate a Copp ot tbe IReco^o, anQ tba t l^e map be bapU 
 ED5 ano ^etoohttooc):ccptfor0totl;e£)iitlatoip, I. 3L&at be toaa f n pjf« 
 Ton at tbe t<me ^e toaa out-latDco, ano bncio notbtng of ttie £)ntIatD?p, ilp, 
 SCljat tbe cbargc aaafntt Wm fa tm general, ano tftcrcfg no boDppjofctntes 
 agafnS t)im, ano p^apeo t)c map go toft!) bfs l^eepet to ^fs Connrell. Roll 
 cbie/luftice, You cannot be bailed, nor have a Copy of the Record, i but Bail. 
 yoD (hall have Coanlell aftigned you, but you tnuH be remanded. Copy. 
 
 lies and VVindlbr. 
 
 Trin, 1 654. Banc, fup. 
 
 Trin, 1653. rot. 36«» 
 
 A ^RSrft of CEttoi iDHfl bjonjrtit to tcbcrfe a ^oogcment gftren bp Oefanltin Error to re. 
 -^ tbc Common-iaicas fn an flctfon of 3Eroter ano Contjetfion.ano tbe Et« ve.fe a judge- 
 toj afafgncD tDa0,tbat tbeiPlafnttff l;aD ocdareo fo j tiro pfecea of Cloatiano '"«"' •" Tro- 
 Dfo notejpjcratDljetftertliepfcDcre Ifnncnoj tooBen cloat^:But the wcep^^fSjenby 
 sion was over* ruled, and the judgement affirmed, nifi. *" ^* 
 
 Bunniworch and Gibbs. 
 
 Trin, 1654. Banc, fup, 
 
 Mich. 165 3. rot. 50. 
 
 A OTtft Of Cnoj tDHB bjodg^t to retjetfe a Blnogcmjnt gf ben fn tbe Coptt ^""^ '? "- 
 -^at Peterborough fn an actfon npon tbe Cafe npon a piomffc,tDbcrcfn tbe ^^'^\ 'J'^tK 
 pafntfff DcclarcD, tftat fn conOocratfon tbattbe Dcfenoant baa recefbeOa^nupon"' 
 5 1. tD^c^ toaa one bp tbe |0lafntfff onto t^e SDefenoant upon an accompt an Aflun:)piit. 
 maoe np betltfjt tbem at fiicb a tfme,tbc Dcfcntant ofo alTamc ann pjomffe 
 to t^e ^lafntfff to pap unto bfm a certafn fum of monp tobcn tbe £>2fcnoant 
 (IjaU ret np an 0potbccarfeB Ojopfn Peterborough, ff tbe JSlafntfff be tben lf» 
 tfng tftere. SLbe erroj afafgnco iuaa, tliat t)cre fa no conODcratfon lafo fn 
 tbe JDctlaratfon to gronno tbe paomffe npon : fo j tbe confiDeratfon fa tbe re- 
 ceipt of fibe po unDa,\rbf cb toaa bf a oton monp.foj f t tnaa one to bf m upon tbe 
 acccompt.ano tbfacan be no gmo conGoeratfon.lBut Rollchief luftice anfinc: 
 reo totbfa,tbat alfttle conQDeratfontoflirctt)etogrounDapjomffcnpon,*^°'>fi<'"«ion 
 ano ft map be tbe piafntf ff tooulo not bate attmotDleDgco fo mucb aa j 1. to 
 iatic been oue oporr tlje 2ccompt,ff tbeSDefcnuant tooulo not babe maoe tbfs 
 pjomifc. SI fEcono rueptfon toaa tat;en that tbe pafntfffootb not abet, tbat 
 iu!)cn the jDcfcnDcnt fet nptbcapotbecarfeafljopfn Pcrerboroogb tbat be ^vf rmenr," 
 iraa KWng tbcre Roll chef luftice, 2Cbfefeagoooerteptfon,fojtbcfa» 
 tent of tt)3 pfatntfff appears to be , tbat be tooulo not batcanotbetofbfa 
 Oton Xraoe f n tbe Eoton to leffcn bfa ttaofng, Therefore le: the ludgcraent 
 f>e revelled, niii. 
 
 ^^z tori
 
 420_ Trin. 16 54- 
 
 Lord andMicViell. 
 
 Trin. 1554. Banc. fup. 
 Trin. i63 3.rot. 35S. 
 
 ^'T^ZZ'c A ^'^'^ ofCtwtDaBbJoagljttorEtcrfealaDgementefbcnupoiiaNi. 
 
 mem by a Ni- i\m dicit fti tbc Commonplcas in an ^alon upon tljc CCafe upon an Af, 
 
 hii dicic in an fumpfit; tfte conOocratfoH teas lafs, tt)3t (fttje JplafntffflDoulofojbcarto 
 
 aa.on upon fue t^c E^ef CHoant, t^at tDen tbe SDefcnoant tooulo pap fntl^ a fum of rnonp* 
 
 an Aflumpdr. j^^^ crrojs toerc afafgncD to retictfe the judgement, r. ffifiat ittjcrcaa 
 
 tbc confiiocratfon <0 lafo gcncrallp/.tt)at(ftt)C plaintiff IftoulD fojbcarto 
 
 fne tfteHDcfent)ant,b:tDoalD paptbemonp; t^e pafnUff l)atl) not aljct« 
 
 TeDttfflconfioetatfon, but fatt!) infaSotbatbeDfofoibeartofijetfU /une, 
 
 tnbfcl) cannot bctbc fametonfiDcratlon. jlp. e;1)2 CSJrft of Gnqufrpfj 
 
 fa<D to be cnqnfteo ofbp tmclbclatofuU men fntljc Countp, toljercaaU 
 
 fljoulD be of tl)c Countp. fojtbcjutojsf"'} oag^t appears map beofano- 
 
 «v,.n, t^cr Conntp, ant H)cn <t cannot be icelU Roll chief luflice , SCbta (a bat an 
 
 '"''"'■ " Inquctt of £Dffitc, but pou babe not al3errcDt!)econQDeratfon aspoaougbt 
 
 to bate oonc, ant)t|j<9 <0Ctroj. Thercrore let the InJgement bcrever* 
 
 fcd,nifi, &c, 
 
 Phillips and Phillips. 
 
 Trio, 1^54. Banc, fup. 
 
 Error to re- • ^,.{t j,f (gfjoj ^13 bjougbt to reberfc a lungemcnf gften in tl^e 
 *='''=*^J'^^^^^'' /\ Court at Newport In an aaton npontbeCafe fo> tbcfc toojos, Thou 
 aTo"n fjr*" *' art* a whorcfon Bankrupt=Rogue, ant) tbep toerc lafiJ to be fpokcn of a jFar. 
 word>, met. Cbc crro jfl afsfgneo tucrc. r . SCbat ft ootb not appear bp tbc Dcclaratf- 
 on tbat tbe piaf ntfff gets bfa Utifng bp bupfng ano f ellfng. ano ilp. Jt ap- 
 pears not tbat tbc toojos mere fpottcn of bfmfn relation to btapjofefsfon. 
 And upon thele Exceptions the judgement was reverfed, * 
 
 Bancks and Pra'. 
 
 Trin. 1654, Banc. Cup. 
 
 Hill, 1^5?. rot, C03, 
 
 Error t-- re- » cffltft of CEcroj toas bjoogbt to rctetfe ajingcmcnt gfticn in tfts 
 vcrfc a judg'. /\ Common pi cBfl foj an attojnp fn an action upon tbe Cafe , groanneo 
 "aTon ".p'"p jipon a P'-omffe tbat tftc Dcfcnoant tooulo pnp bfm fucb fcc3 m Ojoulo groto 
 Piomifc. Due to bint ag an atto jnp in piofccntlng fucb a fe>-ttc fo: btm fn tbc Com- 
 mon pleas, «>nD fojpjorecutfnganotbcr futefojbiminClianccrpasbia&oI^ 
 lfcito;.2::be Crrois afsfgncti toerc i Xljat be uotb not Ojcto partfcularlp boto 
 be !;atb laf 5 out tbe monp, but oiilp erpjeffctb it gcncralUp,tbat be bao crpen« 
 tie5,ano tb:rc toas oue unto bfm fucb a fum of monp. 2lp. SLb: Ipiom/fe 
 <3, tbat tbe Defc.noant tooulo pap bfm tbz fees fo long aa beOjonlocontf- 
 nue to be bio atto?np ano to pjofccute foi bim,anii ft ootb not appear tbat be 
 conffnueotobcbis attojnp, anDtop:ofecutcfo:bitn During tbc futc, mn 
 to mafee tbe firfi ctccptfon gooo Took ano ^it Tno. Walfioghatni Cafe latc= 
 
 4.
 
 Trin.1'^54- 4.y_ 
 
 Ip aujuDcBD inafl urgeD, 5But as to tbat crccptfon Roll cliiefiunicenn- 
 
 ftoercDjiKsnotnecctrarp to fljcto pattfctilarlp fioto tfte monp became Due, 
 
 ano teas crpcnDcD,fo> tb<0 tooulD mafee tijc 2Detlaratfon ten long,- ano tljonaft 
 
 t^c plaintiff, as batl) bcenobtcdco, fljoulo bjfng anott)cr 2ctfoti fojtfte 
 
 fame tt)fng, pet poo map plcaDtWa rctotitrpfn bar gene rallpagafna^fm. 
 
 ^ntj as to tl)c fccono erccptf on (t Ojall be fnti noco be tontfntJCD to be l)(s 2t. ',''" ''? ^*''* 
 
 tojnp, (f ft appcarsasft Dotft,t!)at bepjofctutcofoibfrn. Therefore fbew ''""*''™"^' 
 
 cau'e Friday next why the judgerocnc fliould not be affiimed, Puflea* 
 
 Ketnp and Gcrd. 
 
 Tr in. 1654. Banc, fup/ 
 Hill, i6j3.ror, 840. 
 
 Ajp flctfon npcntfje^Eafetoasbjongbtbptbeipafoj anbCommonaltp D^n^urrcr to 
 of tbe JEotnn of Lyfcard in Cornwall agafnft Gord foj not grfnofng at a Declaration 
 tbefr common Jplll, %\)t SDefcnoart Demurs to t!je BDctlaratlon. ano'"'" ^^ion 
 Wad ban) Windham fo J tbe JDcfenDant iirgcD , that theCuffomfanotiDCli"i-°"''i<= 
 aUegeD upon tohicl) the ^flfon teas grounceD. i?oj firtt ft (snot fljeuicD that eH^V"'""' 
 the l^oufe toherc the SDcfcnoant fnhabftcth , anobp rcafon tohcreofftfs m.I].'"^ "* 
 fuppofeDheouBhttogrfnDatthe SpfUfshclDofthefpafojanDCommonaltp. 
 2lp. StfsnottbclticDjthatthcfJJntojanoCommonaltp are bounotorepafr 
 the S^fll, anD DO conftantip hcep (SjfnDers ano iloaocrs, 3m fo^the 
 firtt, thfs Cnftomc ought to beaffijceo, bj^ rcafon of the tenure of the ?^ouff, 
 0% in refprrt oftheCojngrotDfng upon the grounDtifcDtDith the ^oufe.ano 
 it fs not p?oper to fap, a man fs bouno to grfnD bp rrafon of hfs ^^onfr,8 Rep. 
 Farmers cafC.f. 125. Hob. Harding anD Greens caft, jp Ed. j. Fttzh.Afh 
 519' i^oj the fcconD, thfs grinDfugatthei^fllfsaperfonal fcrbfte, nnoff 
 the jpafoj ano Commonaltp be not bouno to rcpafrtheipfli-, anotofino 
 dD jfnocrs ano Hoaoers, then there fs not quid pro quo, ano the Cuffom tufll 
 be nnrcafonablc , anoamcet oppjefsfon, 22 Aft. PI. 58. Latch on thco. 
 thcr 0De fafo, here fa a gooD Cuftom aflegeo , anp f t fs not neceiTarp to fheto 
 anp tenure fnthfs ^(tfon, bcfng but an Slction upon the Cafe, ano not 
 a Seda ad molendinum , anDfo fs ft ajrreeD fn Harding ana Greens Cafe, 
 5lnD fn 9 lac. Hill, rot. 69i , an j9dfon ttas bjought fo? thfs trrp Canfc, ano 
 the Cuftom toasthcn allotocD to be gmo. Rolkhief Juftice, 3; bclfclje thfs fs 
 a gooD Cuttom,anD the Cojpo?atfon fs bouno to rcpafr the ^fll , ano there Cuftom. 
 can be no pjefuofce foj the partp to grfnD here, ano the Cuftom hath been al. 
 rcaDp trpcD ano founo gOOO, Therefore let the FJaintiff have his ludgemenr, 
 nifi, &f ♦ 
 
 lonesandGravcj. 
 
 Tfin, K554, Banc, fup, 
 
 Ijfl the Cafe of one lones ano Graven, Sf foas fafo bv Roll chief luftice, ^vherc 
 athat ff nWdt of Cot)enant be bjonght agafnft tl);cc,ant) one of them Dfe, w. .t i. ab». 
 the ?X3r1t fs abatcD onlp to hfm;but fs not abateo to the rtft,bnt onip abates "J, ^vhcrc .c 
 able ; but Latch fortment that ft fs abatcD to all, Q., '^ »baicabic. 
 
 ^^^3 temp*
 
 42Z 'frin. 1^54. 
 
 Tompkins and Clark. 
 
 Trin. 1^54. Banc, fup* 
 
 Error ort A ©Ht't «>f Ctto> ioM bjougljt fo teterfc a jnogement QiHn In tbc 
 vcrfeV^ti'gc-x\<!CourtatNewcafllruponTyne, <nan flflfon upontfteCafc foj t^efe 
 trcnrinan too}D0 , He, mcatiins t|)e jpiatntff, is a bafe beggarly Rafcal, and ha cb coze* 
 aftion for ppj (hg parliamenc a hundred times,and deferves to ride on the wooden horfe, 
 '^°"^'' ftanding on the Sand hill. SCftc CjCCptfonfl tDEtC, t^at X\)C iuo JCS arc tlOt 
 
 actionable, fo;tbcpia(ntf[isatnolor0o^oamase bp fpcahins of tbem, 
 noMstbetebp enoangerei) of bis life , o^to be ptinifben cojpo^allF- ^^v* 
 SCbc Isojos arc not Tato to be Tpoben of tbc |piaint<f , no^ to tbc p[afnt(f» 
 31^. 2Ct)e Venire t0 not tDelliffneD, Roll chief iudice, Revecfecur, nifi, &c» 
 
 5tavley and Ulithorp. 
 
 Trin, i^$4> ^itic, fap. 
 
 P ■ . T Atcb mobeD again foj^jnogementtntlifscaCefojmerlprpoken to, not* 
 
 uxJm,nTn L^tD<tbttanDtns tbc erceptJon (natteo upon bp Shaftoe after tlje Coprt Ijaa 
 
 aaion on the DcKbereo fomc opinion , viz. tbat ft toaanot etrpjctTeo tfiat tbe parliament 
 
 Siatucc of i \30a9 ()elD bp prorogation , becanfe ft ts not necelTarp ft QionlD be To cn>ref< 
 
 Ed.^.conccn-fgj,^ jlp. jCbc Safon tsbcte bjongbt upon tbe fecono bjancb of tbe &ta- 
 
 wg lithe.. tntc,toWcb f0, tbat aU perfona OjaH fct fojtb tijeir tftbco, ano tbc toojo fub. 
 
 jea is onlp mentioneo in tliz 6rtt clanfe. Mavnard on tbe fame Qoc faio , 
 
 tbat this mif recital , fittbcamif-recital, affirms tbc fetatate, anb it fa 
 
 not a falfc recital, ano tbercfojc it Dotb not burt. Roll chief luftice, 3itfa 
 
 Rcciuis. not gooQ to mabcfncb rccitalo of &tatate0in a SDeclaration , nor tooalb 31 
 
 |)abe anp recital mabc bercaftcr more than is ncceffarp for tbc gift of 
 
 tbe iSction. Shaftoe itiQftcD upon it , %^at tbe mif recital here is a 
 
 materfal Crceptton ^ for ti)e recital f0 not true ; for ft fs not aU one to fap 
 
 tije&nb|c(toftbe!&fng, anb to fap tbc Subject of tbe ti)cn Mmt foi tbe 
 
 former l])ort>0goe to tbe poUftichcapacitp of tbe J^ing as &ing< anb tbe 
 
 latter toorbs go to tbe natnral capacitp of bis particular perfon. Roll chief 
 
 luilice, SBtJt ubatfappouto that tobftb is faio on tbc otbcr liDc, SLbat 
 
 tbe Action is brought npon tbc fccont) clanfe of tbe statute , tobfcb is , tbat 
 
 all pcrfons fball fct fortb t^efr titbeo , anb not upon tbe firft Ciattfe, 
 
 tDbicb fpcahs of all &ub)eas of tbe l^ing: ^nb tbc recital bcrc is not 
 
 material to the Slttion. 31t is true , bcrc is a mif recital , ano if tbc 3ctf. 
 
 ontDerebroagbtupontbcfitil Claufeoftbc Sitatutc, fttoonlDnotbcgooo, 
 
 but ft t0 not fo bete. Therefore let the Plaintif have his iudgement, nifi, 
 
 Antca, 
 
 Tim. 16 54. Banc. fup. 
 
 For an At- "1 ^c Coott tuas mobcD for an attacbment agaf nft tbe &berif of f^tafford. 
 
 tachment. * (hire , for making a frttjolous return of a Habeas Corpus , viz. SCbat tbe 
 Committee for poor prifoners ban orbereb, ^ fijoulb not bring tbc boop 
 till tbep bai) confulteb icftb tbe ilora cbfef Huftfce, Roll chiei luftice, Take 
 an Alias habeas Corpus, with a pain of 80 1. 
 
 Rovye
 
 t^^-^A: 51"^ *^54. 4^; 
 
 Roby and Twelve^i 
 
 I 
 
 Trin, 1654. Banc.fup» 
 Trin, 1552, rot. 502; 
 
 Ii^ a fppcfal ticrDfrf fn an bjcflione firma?, ft tDa0 founu, tfjat there toas^speciai v«r<. 
 cuftom toftbfii tl)c jpanojof Caltle Dunninftton , tljat anp <CoppbolDetd a in,n t- 
 of ttjat ipanoj map maUe a to;ft(nc in tbc nature ot a ilcttcr of Sittojnep to jcftionc fic- 
 tffioCoppljolDEtfloftJjcfame^anoj, to furrenner tils Copptjolo after jtjfsmi. 
 oeatb. E^cqucfifon toa0,tibctbcrtbf3lca0 a fooD cuffom oj not. AU 
 ley n argneo foj tlje ctittom, tfeat it tuas a gooD cuffont; btcaiifc fmft cuffoms 
 arcnottobcgotcmcQbpt^ErtilcooftljcCommoniLatD, batbptbe rulc0 
 of natural rcafon, anoarcconficcrable fn tliemfcltce , ano fucb cnffonig 
 mapriftrafnt^e Common l,a\D, ann tlje Common llato Dot b to Derate 
 tbcm. 0nD tbffl cuftom tbat c(tiC0 potDcr to make t!)fa furrenDEt after tbc 
 Copp!)olDer0t)eatb,fonot unrcafonablc , foj tbc potoer a(ticn f3notcoun= 
 tcrmanOEDbpbtsDEfitb, romojctlananflttojntpto rcftrafncnbj'Uomas 
 flcr0 Dcatb to act tn ttie caufe* 3nc in Butler ano Bakers tafc , bp t\3t oelf- 
 tjerpofaDcct) after tbeceatb of tbc partp, tbc eltate map pafa bp jattoj- 
 nep, anofoaltbonobbcrebebutabarcpoUicrcttJcn, pet ft (atDellerccns 
 tco, notuftlftanofnQbfooeatotbatnatieft. jlp. ILbfs ILcttct of flttoj- 
 nepuraanotconntermanfiablcbptbe Coppboloer btmfclf mirfng 0t0 Iffe, 
 ano tberefoje ft (ball not be conntcrmanoeo bp bf0 ocatb , ano tbougb ft bat> 
 been toufitetnianoable During b<6lffe, pet ft being not countcrmanoeo bp 
 b<m(nl)i0Ute, ^fsccatb fball not conntcrmanB ft, anu tbe cnttom ootb 
 Crengtbcn tbffl poluer. i!iej:t,tb<0tul!-om<0notcontraDlttojp, foj bere fs 
 no 5lttojnep maoe, bnc a iDjftfng mane fn tbe nature 0? a 'ILette'r 
 of attojnep , ano a potocr to furrcnter often bp ft , ano ft fs no 
 mo?c tban foj one Coppboloer to futrenocr foj anotber, tebftbf0 ufual, ano 
 fnCookspRep. f. 76. a Coppboloer fa taflco an flttojnep; alfoCoppbolD 
 cftatccaremaoc bprulfoms, anotbercfojc ftitbcuOoms U}b(f b arc to con* 
 ftrmclfateBarcfobefatJonrcofn Hail), altbougljtbcpco Differ from coti- 
 tjepanccB of i ftateg at tbc Common iLa to , ano tbfa tnCom I0 not onlp refi« 
 fonablc, but tontjenf ;nt alfo foj tbe pafcfng of Coppbolo rffatf 0. 0nn tbts 
 tuftom enlargc0 tbe potoer of altenatfona , ano futb tu0om0 balie gcncraU 
 Ipbecnaumltteogcoo, tbongb tlffercnt from tbe Common ?Lato; 0nti 
 lubcnaculfomfobccomca JLatoftfs'ocrpoangcrouflto alter ft , ano tbc 
 Doing of ft tooulo otcrttnoto manp t ftatco. Ellis Soll'citor General on tbc 
 otbcr Ctocarguco, SLbat tbccuflomtsnot gooD, brcsufc ft 10 agalnft tbc 
 rulco'. lata, 2rbatanautbojftpcftirn(boulD'"nrfjli?c tbe partp tbat gabc 
 ft, auoacuffomcannotftrcngtbenlt, fo:a cuffom ouglt to be reafoiia- 
 ble, anO agreeing to tbc nature of tbe tbfiig U'bitb «t concerns, otbcrtolfe 
 ft cannot be gooD , fo; Ra ioeftfoimaliscpuuconluctuclinis. Dalifons Rep, ' 
 32. I Inflir. ^.59. anutblacaufe cannot be reafonablc, becaufc It cannot 
 gftjc an autbojftp to anotber to do fucb a thing foj bf m after bto oeatb, tcblcb 
 be coulD not DO During bfg life ; 3nD this cuftom ootb purelp Deft rop tbe na* 
 turcot tbc Common ?l?) to, anotbercfoje cannot be gooD;9nD It Is agalnft 
 tbc f crp nature of an autbo;ltp to furifttc , ano fo confequentlp It I0 agalnO: 
 tbc nature cf tic tbfng, Dyer 357. loE, 3, f. 5. iH Rep. Vynyers cafe. 
 SLbc pnrtp In bto life time might balic rcDokco tffa autbojttp, ano tbercfo:e 
 bf3DeatbDotbrct?ol^elt ; ano bp the ncatb or tbc Coppboloer the Coppbola 
 fs Df fccnarD , anD cannot be furrcnD^eo bp a ocao man , ano here tuaa na 
 
 In-
 
 Copyholt". 
 
 424 Mich. 1654. 
 
 fncoadon'of tl)c tfiatccftbcpartptftatfeitcaD, anuKfjolotftcrc^safifffc. 
 
 rercc betWrt a tofD ant) an auttojftp ; flno alfo Ucrc tl)c BLcttet of 0tto>. 
 nf r (a not purfuant to tl)C tuftom, anu t^ercfojf <t ie a Dofn Utttct of 0tto?. 
 refiielac. rot. 5 30. Greenwood and Onflaestafc Cufloms arc to bc taken 
 Cdalp , ano to be fo purfucD , anDUfanotfobtte, fo> bcre fa an aoDttlon 
 10 the ctiftom , anu tWa maUea all Vofo. Roll chief lufticc , Coppftoloa are 
 imublcDbptbccullomaoftbei^nnoj, ano, inc tWnha, Ijere (a Utile 6iffe» 
 tentc bcttDfrtt fnrtcnDjIns fnto tbc bantia of anotbcr Coppbolocr , to mahe 
 a furrenDEt foj Wnt , anD tWo cafe, ano tftc Variances arc not fo conCocrablc 
 as to mahe ft tKifo tjcre. Tlie Court would advife, 0t another Dap t^e 
 lafctoaa again put, ann tbc Court BeUberco tljclr opfnfon , tbattbc caSont 
 toasaoot); ant) Roll ihief luflice falD, t^at fbe Dtatb of t^c partp oot^ 
 not rct?obe t^ls to?ttfng maue In t^c nature of a ILetter of jatto?nep , foj U 
 faflrengtfjncDbi'tbccuflom, anD ft Is not Ube an ojtfnarp letter of jat. 
 to^ncp tD^fcb bcromc t^oio bp t^e ticati) of t)fm tliat tnat)e ft , fo} Ws cuflont 
 fa a ILatD, ano tt)e ant^o^ftp bcre furbtties, as an Crecnto^ map fell tf)e 
 SCcftato^slanss , ft be be fmpotoercD to Do ft bp tfie tDfll , anD t^tttftu the 
 Caflcni is good, and let the Piaintif have judgement, nifi, &c. 
 
 Child . 
 
 Cuftom 
 Revocation. 
 
 Authority, 
 ixccutor. 
 
 Trin, 1 ^54* Banc, fup. 
 
 :- A i^ 0(tfon upon ti)e statute of $ Eliz, toas b^ongi^t fo) nGng a 2I^raDe 
 )aant mij.ht jf^ not bating ferteo an 0pp^cntfCbfp fn ft Serjeant Fletcher motjco tbat 
 
 Tl-.it the De- 
 fc, 
 
 n-i pietrf to ti)c SDcfenoant mf gW not be compeBeD to plcaD , becaufc l&c oog^t not to be 
 facDoutoftbeConntptobcreftenfetbtfjeCraDe, Roll chief luftice, pjo- 
 ceeD arcojDfns to llato , anD pleao tbfs matter , 0^ mote ft fn arreS ^ 
 
 ihc Aft ion. 
 
 Rule4 
 
 ^oDgement , foj we will make no rale. 
 
 Trin. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 Bp Roll chief luftfce , an flttfon npon t&e cafe Botb not ifc agafnff one 
 fo; caufuig another to beenDfaeD fo; a Ercfpafs , bat fo; caalingonc 
 Cafe he: ond to be cnoftteD fo; a tfjfng inbltft Dcferfces co;po;al panllbment , 0; a 
 where not. f Wng toWcl) founDs fn fcanDal of t^e partp enofflsD, an action npon t^e cafe 
 tofU \lt, Noca, 
 
 Stevens again ft Ask. 
 
 Mich. 1654. Banc. ftp. 
 
 C Tephent bjoogftf an flctfon upon the cafe agafnft Ask fo; tWt toojDs , 
 Aft.on on the ^ .j.jj^y gj.j g common Baftard- bearing Whore , and hadft two Baftards by 
 a Bnrcber, and I will prove it- tSlpon not gufltp picaDeD, anD a tierDfct 
 foimDfo;tbci9iafntlf, Twifdenmotjeo fn jarrcft of Haogement tbat tbe 
 f rft tBO;D0, viz. 1 hou art a common Ba(lardbearing Whorcare not actlona* 
 
 Cafe for 
 words. 
 Artcft of 
 ju'^erment. 
 
 /!'!'). aiye 
 words. 
 
 blc, bccauretbepareaDjEctft)etDo;D0,anDarcnotpoOtft)C; 0nD fo;tbeo» 
 tftci irio;D0 tbcp are not aflfonablc , becaofc tbcp toere fpoben of a JFeme 
 Cotjert, tobo cannot batie a IBaftarD. tapon tbia tbe juogcment toas arre« 
 aeDtfBtbenejtSCcrm, anD tbcn Wild motJCD fo; judgement, fo; tbat I^e 
 concefteD that the U)o;ds tabcn togetber are aalonablc , ano cftco Owen 
 elevens rate aDjnageDfntWsCoart to p?otje ft. RolIchi?floftice, 3f f6c 
 
 tDEce
 
 Mich. 1654. ^z^ 
 
 teete martfeo at t^e time of t^e too^os rpoben (be coulo not (labe a IBaffatD; ~ 
 
 but pet to^p (fioalD not tlic ino joa be atffonable , fo j tbc Ujojds purport tbat 
 flbetDasnotmaricDtobenlbeiiaotbelBaSarDs, anb ttie Blnrp ^at^ fonno 
 fO} i^Z JBlatntfft Therefore let her cake her judgement, nifi. 
 
 Barker and Wefton, 
 
 Mich, i654t Banc, Alp. 
 
 ^ ^e Contt toae moteo tbat t^e bail to an 0(tfon mfstit be DifcbargeD.be: "^o <i:rcharg« 
 -*- tanrct^epbabnotobjongbtfntbepjtncfpat, anDittDaebatoneoapaf*^'''- 
 tcrtbe return of t^ctD?(t. 3IE>ut Koli chief laftice anftoerco, that it may 
 not be , becaufe they cooie in upon the return of the fecond ^(le factao, 
 
 Harvey and Mountncy. 
 Mich. 1654, 'anc. fup, 
 
 10. tW8 Cafe tbe Sctfoit being a JCrcrpafs anb (Sjetfrncnt , anb t!je tftU ' 
 concerning Hugh Audley of tbe Snncr STemple , tbe E>efenDant teas bp 
 rule of Court, at the trpal ,iDticb teas to beat ttc bar,to appear anD confefa 
 tbe leafe, cnttp, anb outter, ann to ftano upon the title onlp, pet at tbe trpal Piaintif non- 
 betooulD not appear, upon tobicb tbe ^MaintiftDas non-fate, anu pet ttje '^"" '"'' >" 
 jjoDgement teas foj tbc ipiaintif upon tbe rule , anb be teas ojocrcb 1,1^"'*"' 
 to pap tbe 3lurp. Nota. 
 
 VValkendenand Haycock. 
 
 Mich. 1 654, Banc. fup. 
 
 \7 |0onamerbictgibcnfojtbe|piaintifin anjaaion upon tbe tafc fojAaion upon 
 tbefe tDOjDs fpobcn of a ^IDcner in London, viz. Thou art in a break- ihc ofe tot 
 ing ^nd decayed condition , ana I will prove it, and if you queftion me, I will ^vord>. 
 prove it to your difgracc. Twifden niOtJCD foj juDgcmcnt fo? tbC J9laintif , 
 bccaufcbc bclotbe toojbs arc adionablc; fo? bptbefpcabingoftbcmtbc 
 piaintifisDifsractcinbiapjofcfsion; foj in common unbctftanuing tbc 
 too;D0 amount to as much as if be ban faio tbat t!jc partp is a IBanferupt.ano 
 It is fa aberrcD in tbc IRccojo , anb founb bp tbc 3;urp , anb be ttteb Mich. 
 151 Tayler and Keil'ers cafe , anD Smith and Rookes cafe 24 Car. Wild 
 on tbc otbcr fiDe faio, tbat tbc toojos are not actionable , fojtbep are aoje- AJj«a;vc 
 <titJCU)o?os,anDofaninccrtalnttgr(fitation, foj tbc tDOjBs map as toell"*"'*^' 
 tneantbatl;eisb;!oi)eo;buiff in bis boop, as tbat tie is a S5anhrnpt 0% 
 bjofeen in bis cttatc ; ano tbcre is ho abermcnt tbat tbc toojos inere fpoben 
 in tl)c bearing of ttaocfmcn , anti tbotigb tbcp iDcrc. pcttbcpmapnottcno 
 to b(o Difgracc , fo j a Craocfman map be in a occaping conoition, in rcfpett 
 of uibat be batl) fojmetlp been , an.D pet babe flock cnougb left to traoc 
 libithall. 2tbc Court tbcncrclihco tbat tbe toojbs toere actionable, but 
 fo; tbat time gave no luDgcmcnt; but the cafe being moved again the fame lu^gcmett. 
 Term, judgement was given tor the Piaintif, 
 
 m Law.
 
 426 
 
 Mich. 1654. 
 
 Afiton upon 
 ihe Csfcloc 
 breach of 
 tittft. 
 
 Whether a 
 Warrant of 
 Attorney 
 determined. 
 
 Judgement. 
 
 Lawrence and HarrifonJ 
 Mich, 1 6;4« Banc. Tap. 
 
 Ai^ 0(t(on npon ttie Care ioas bjongbt bp Lawrence acatnftHarifon 
 ^ia attojnp foj DcUticrlng a Fieri facias agatnftljfm.ln tbefutc tobctefn 
 |ieiDa0;atto;nepfo7b<ni,totbeti;inBei=&t)CTfff, anopjocnrtng ittobeefe* 
 cntcD againft Mni) conttarp to tt)e truft upofeu tntifm. ^Slponnot-goUtp 
 pUaoeD, ano a MzxiAa fottno fo) tbe j^tatnttfF, 3t toae mote d in attcft of 
 laDgement fo; tlje SDefenoant bp Windham , fil^bat tbere appears not in tbe 
 ikeco^D to be anp (ombinatfon bettoeen tbe BDefenoant ano tbe |0laintiff0 
 aoberfarp againft biflClpent. anofonobjcacliof tiqtt appeata togrouno 
 tbe jSction upon. 2lp. I^ere being a Inogement in t^e Cafe, tbe Tnte in 
 lubicb be tsas entCTtaineo to be jStttojnp ie enDcb,ano conrcqncntip tbe tinft 
 xcporeo in tint is DeteimineD, ano fo no b:ieacborit , to?bcisnolotif< 
 cbareeo frotn being Sltto^nep, anb tbe |)laintiffs abetting tbe tontrarp fiot^ 
 not altet tbel^ato, ano befioco, tbiobclibeTp oftbe Fieri facias ia in pnrra< 
 anceef lattice, Isbicbfincetbattte Tote ioenoco cannot be caUeD a bjcacti 
 ofttnflt. Roll chief luOice, ISnt pou DiD not onlp Delibct tbe t^rit againft 
 I^OQC ClpenttotbemnbeT&beriif: but oiD alfo p^ocnre it to be crecutcb 
 againlt \)im,U!bicb Ibelofii tt)crc teas a combination againft bim. %\)e onlp 
 qaefifonis^tDbetbertbe tlKlQatrantof 0tto:ncp be Determincbbp tbe |ai)ge« 
 ment gfben in t|ie fate tobetein ^e toae retaineOj ano 3 conceite it is not.fo^ 
 tbe fate is notbetermineo.fo^tbe^ttojnepaftettbe jnogement iotobe 
 caUeb to fap tsbp tfiete Ibonlo not erecotion be maoe oat againff bis CIpent, 
 anb I)e (0 ttnfieDtooefcnbbfs^lpcntasfat as be can from tbe ei^ecution* 
 Tbercforc Ice the PlalncifFhavc his judgcmenr, oifi, &c. 
 
 Adion of the 
 Cafe for 
 
 Roungs and Woodyard. 
 Mich» te^^-'Buncfap* 
 
 ROnngi a iFattnct fn tbe Conntrp b}ongbt an 0£tioH upon tbe Cafe 
 againft Woodyard foj fpcabing tbefe toojMi of bim, Ycu are a Bepgar, 
 words agamu gnda BancKruptly Fellow, and it every one had his owr,you are not worth a 
 aMrm r. q^^^^^ ^cTgcant Fletcher motjcb (n arrlftofjoDgemcnttbattbelBojitf 
 are not abfolnte anb poGtibe Ico^u , bnt are fpohen abjctritelp, anoalfo 
 tbcparenotfpobenofaq^etcbant, o^ofonetbatgetsliis libing bf bnpins 
 anb felling , ano fo are not fcanoalons : fo;^ a iFarmer cannot be a ]l5anb' 
 rnpt, anobere is no bammage to tbe partp bp tbe fpeahtngoftbcm. Roll 
 Ftrticuiar ^^^^^ JD(lice,2Cbongl)if appear not tbat tbe piaintiif is aSEraocrman , pet 
 dammage. |)ere appears to be a partfcalar tianimagc to bim bp tbe fpeaUfrgoftbR 
 Isojbs, viz. t^at bp reafon of tbe fpeahing of tbem be teas Bircrcoiteo Isitt) 
 bis Hanblo^ib, anb bis BLanblo?b tab gibcn bim tnarning to be gone ont of 
 (is iFarm, anb it matters not tbongb tbe Idojdb generallp conltocreD arc 
 not aitionable. Therefore ihcw cauU Saturday ncxc v\ hy tbe Plaintiff il^all 
 not have his jadgetnent. 
 
 lonef
 
 Mch,v^54 _4i7 
 
 lent s and Graves. 
 
 Micli.i^j4.Barc. fup, 
 
 1 .\.\ . 
 
 r a j^ 3(tfon upon tlic Cafe inae bjo'.iE?)t bp lonrs agafntt Graves foj en- Aaion upon 
 XVtrfrtg upon t!)c poffefsfon of n SCcrm, after Ije Ijao rccoUcteo ft bp a feet- 'he .^*f« ''^'^ 
 tfct gftjcn fo3iWm. '»apon notguUtr plcaBeo, ano « tcrofct fo: tbe pla(ti/,"" p^^^j/j^^ 
 tfff , U Inas motjcD fn artcft of juogcmcnt, t^at tfte J9lafnt(ff t)atft not fljeto« oi a Tinn. 
 CD tfjat tbere toaoanpSCcrmcontfnufngfn ^fm at tfjc ttme of tlje Defcn- 
 tantg entrp fiito tfte HanD, fo; ttjouglj tftc SCernt mfg^t^ate a contfnnance 
 at tb2 tfmc of tbe tecotjcrp, »ct <t map be cnDco at fnc tf mc of ttje ipiafntfffa 
 cntrp <iito tl)c iLanu. alp. 'jt fa not erpjclteiitoftentlje entrp teas, anofo 
 ft appears not inbetbcr ft hme bcfo? e o j after tbe rccoterp , fo t!)at ft cannot 
 be hnoton, tobctbet tbc |i)la(ntfff Ijatb canfe of Sflfon oj not. Latch alfo 
 Boobtco , itbetljet tljfB hfno of attfon ooo^t to be (n tWs Cafe oj not , ano 
 tDl)etf)er be ougbt not to babe bioogM an Stctfon of SCrefpalTc , ano not an 0- • 
 dfon upon tbe Cafe. Rolklnefluiiice, !^: map b:fitgan actfonnpontfteEieftinn of 
 Cafe, oj an action ofaCrefpafTeatbfso'irnelectfon. Wild ontbe otfjecAaion. 
 fioe bclD , tbat tbe laDcclaratfon Irae gcoo cnougb, fojbp ft tbere appears 
 to be gtJOD caafc of attfon, fo?, tbe tfme of tl)c cntrp fs ejpjicCteD, viz. tftat ft 
 tDaa after tbe tecoberp. 2lp. 2Lbe cntrp fs founb to be vi & armii, 
 tol)fcftfmplfe0annn!atDfnll cntrp ano fo tl)e Siirp ba^e founD ft to be, viz 'mpHryroo. 
 tfjat tc is pat ont of bfs poffcf^fon recotcreo. Roll chief luftice, Cboag^ ^J' a p"offef. 
 tbe IDlafntfff ban no tftlc, pet be ban a poffefafon. ano ft fa actfonablc fo^ tbc don aaion. 
 SDefenOant to Offtarb l^tm» Therefore lee the Plaintiff have his ludgement, able. 
 niH; &c. 
 
 iVIathew and the Hundred of Godatming 
 in Surrey.' 
 
 Micb« 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 tJ? a Carriers man OJ &onconfpfretorobbfm, anoaccojbfnglpooft,tbeAaion upon 
 ■Icartfcr net befng p?fbp to ft^ 2Lbe Carrier map bjfng an ^ctfon agafnft '^« Srjn.fe of 
 tbe^^umijci), npontbe &tatnte of Wmchefter foi tbfsrobberp, I'nttbfs^^^!'^^''/}^^ 
 confpfracp map be nrgeD fn mfttlgatfon of Dammagcs. Per Roll chief lu- 'red' ' """ 
 ftice, 3n a SDrpal at tbe IBar, bcttocen one Mathew, and the Hundred of Go» Mitigation of 
 dalming in Surrey^ dammjges. 
 
 Hacker and Newborn, a SuOfex Caufe. 
 
 Mich. I ^54. Banc. fup. 
 
 IJF a span mahc bfs ^fH fn tfu fefcfencfs , bp tljeotjcr.fmpojtanfngofWhatniaiibe 
 bfsOTffe, to tbeeno be map bequfet, tbfs ftali be fafo to beaMfll*^''''f>' 
 maOEbpconttrafnt, ano fljall not be a gooD OTfll. IBp Roll chief luftice,"""^" '""• 
 3In a SErpal at t{>c JBarfnttcCafcofonc Hacker ano Newborn, Mich* 
 
 1654. 
 
 jffi Brooge
 
 428 TO"' *^54- 
 
 Bronge and More. 
 
 Micht 16^4* Banc, fup^ 
 
 eft of \A ^^^'^ 6>olUtftoj general motjco fn artell of juBgemcnt in a teplctfn, 
 
 ju"ccment inlVianD took tbcfE ejrccptfono to tbe at)oU)jp. i» SCtat tl)e pattp ofo 
 
 a Replevin, atoto t()c tatiing of t()e CattelDantmagc fcarantinaCommon,lD^CTet>e 
 
 t)ao Common, ano oot^ not Qich) t^at be i)at^ Common fo^tisCnttelle* 
 
 tant ano conctiant. ilp, ^t oot^ notlbeb), tbat be loas oampnifico 
 
 bp tbe Cattel tbat toeie t)<fttcpneD Dammage^fcafant , ano it map be tbcrs 
 
 iJoaetommonenougbfo^Mmnottoftbttantiingtbe otber Cattel DiftcepncD 
 
 wh 'ft r ^'■^ tbwe, ano fo be inas not oampnlfico bp tbcfr being tberc» Roll 
 
 i,^"i,'''^'ia,' chief luftice anflDCtcD.lf one tobo batb no rlgbt to Common do pat W Cat* 
 
 ouc averment tel upoH tbe Common , \it tbbo is a Commoner map taUc tbc Cattel tarn* 
 
 ot daaimngcs. mage-fcafant upon tbe Common, ano Utonotnecetlarpfojbimtoatjcr, 
 
 t^H bebatboammagebptbem, fo^ be batb an fntereft toMcb ootb autbojife 
 
 intereft. |,(n, {q tcmoDe tbc nufance, bat be mutt matsc a JCUle to tbe Common, ano 
 
 Title by im- '^ ^^ ^^'^^ ^^^^ '^ ^^''^ ^^^ ^P ImpUcatlon , (t Is toell enongb : fo^t is noto 
 
 plication. belpeo bp tbe tetdld , and you have pafled over yonr advantage bynotdc 
 
 murring to him. 
 
 Mich. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 A D ^ , Tip Roll chief luftice , jBDceD map be fraaonlent la part , anD gmb fn 
 in pirt ^^^nd patt,ano fo iJe faio (t bao been attjuogeo in tbe Cafe of one iydal 
 fraudukm i.i of tbe Middle- Temple* 
 pjrc. 
 
 B^nks and Pratt. 
 
 Trin. id54.BaQC, fup* 
 
 Hill, i^jg^rot. 603. 
 
 PRatt bjongbt an Action npon tbe Cafe agafnff Banks upon anAumpfic, 
 to pap blm fncb fccfl as (boulo be Due tmto bf m as b(3 3itto jncjT fn pjo- 
 c^fe by"an" ' fecutlng 8 fntc foj blm fn tbe Commonrplcas, ano fucb raonfcfi as be ftotilo 
 Aitotncy forlapont fn rollfcftfng a fute fo^ bfm fn tbi^ Cbancerp, ano upon non^afTumpnc 
 fees and foil, plcaDCO, a ZMcrDfd Uias gfben fo j tbe |3laftitj(f, ano a juDgcmciit tbcrcupon. 
 "^'''fg. SLbc SDcfcnoant bjongbt a ^r(t of erro? fn tbfs Court , ano nfofgns ioi tr- 
 roj, tbat tbe |0lafntffE DfonotfljttDpartfcularlptDbat fums ofmonpbebfltt 
 lafDontfoai)fm,no; toijobombe tiaopafDft.asbe ougbtto do, ano Tooke 
 ano S)fr Thomas Walfinghams cafe fntl)f0 Court teas cftcD to p?ot)C ft. ilp. 
 SCbe A ffumpfi t tras tbat be tboulD pap bfm b's fees, fo long as be fljoulD con* 
 tfnuc to be bfs 3tto?np, 5 ft appears not tbat be contf tiucD to be Ma iJtto jnp 
 fn !be futetobcrcfn be fuppofctb be pjofctutcD fo? bfm.JlBut fo? tbe firft cjcccp* 
 A pf nerai tfou Roll chief lufticc fsfD , tbat ft fs not neccffarp to fet Dolnn partfcularlp, 
 Declaration tbe {c^txtA fums of moup be bao lafo ont,fo2 tbfs mfgbt mahe tbe SDedara* 
 %■ od. tfon teofous, anD ff the piafntlff (bonlD ( as ft fs objcttcDbc map ') fajfng a* 
 
 notbcr 2(tfort foi fomc part of tbe monfcorcco^jcrcafn this fute, pon map 
 pleaD tbfs retotjerp gencrallp fn bar of fucb 3rtfon. S!nD as to tbe jd. creep, 
 tfon ft fljall be f ntenoeo, tbat be DfD continue to be bfs i3ttojnep if ft appears, 
 intenv5cn. gg ft Dotb, tbst bc pjofccuteo foj Ijfm, 2Cbe cafc toas mo\)fcD again tbe ncrt 
 
 SCerm,
 
 Hill. 1554, 4?p 
 
 SDetm, ano tbc fojmct cjccptf ong onlp (nCfteo upon. But Roll chi«f laftice ' ",'fpcment > 
 ovcr»ruled the exceptions, and affirmed the ludg«inent, Antca. afhuncd. 
 
 Mich. r6 54. Banc. fup. 
 
 T^z Contt t3a0mot)CD, tW tteo tljat Inere baplfojone fnan0rtfoiiTodian« 
 m<gftt bcDlftljaTgcD atiD ttoo otfteraacccptcD of,l)ecanfe t^e pattp teas to^'^'^ e*)''^ 
 ejiattifne tljem a0 WHtmWez in tlje Caure, which was granted upon con- 
 fent of the parties. j 
 
 VVife and Jeffrycs. 
 
 HilU i<»54. Banc, fup^ 
 
 Mich. i654TOt, Q. 
 
 ■y'V^'^ " ^"^^ ^eutaiit anu a IBahcr (n London bjopght an gtrtoa uk)- Aaion for 
 ' ^ upon t^e Cafe aca<nft leffryes foj fpcaWng tjcfe tDOjO0 of Wm, viz. words 
 Thou art a broken fellow, and hafl cheated nie of 200 U ^pon a tfitDlit fo^ brought by a 
 t^ patottf It toas tnoteofnatrrttofjtiDncmcnt^t^attbetDojMatenotJf^"'^"'**"* 
 afllonabU, bccaafc tbc iuojDsarca&jEfllfeclgfpokcn, anDatcnotpofitltjeAdYeQWc 
 too^iMf, noj of a certain fignfficatfon, foj t^ep map be meant tbat be toas words, 
 bjoben (n bis boDp, anu not in b<0 cftatc, SBut Wild anfujereo , tbat i* 
 SLbe vi:o;O0 ate fpphen of a SCtabefman , tsbicb map l^c a )5atii;rnpt; ano 
 2lp. I^ece i0 an atermejit tbat tbeU)o?fi0iDere meant to Qgnifie tbattbe 
 piaintif Iras a 35anhrupt, anD beGoea bete (0 a betbiit fo^ tbe |pia(ntif. 
 Green fcplpeo, tl;atit cotb rot appeattbat tbetoo^cslDcre fpofcen of bint - 
 {n telation to W%x&u o} p^ofefoion, anbtofap, thatthon haft cheated 
 roe, iscte aT>jttt>aeo not aafonablo in HIUs cafe, 2 Car. ano in one lohnc 
 fons cafe. Roll chief lultice , 3 Do not astce tbe Cafe of » Car. tilcD, but to 
 the Cafe in qncQion, tafae aDtbe iDO^Dstogctbetaotbepatelaiotbepim* 
 pip be i0 bjofeen in bis SCraoe, anD tbe tDojD cheated enfo?cetbtbi0fenre,' 
 ano tbe U)O)D0 ate tetp fcanoalous, anD tbe abetmcnt,anD tbe tfetDiit mabeo , . 
 ft mo je fttons- Therefore judicium pro querente, nifi, &c. gemenr. 
 
 Fowkes and Copfye. 
 
 Hill. 1654. 
 
 1% teas faiDin this Cafe, tbat if tberc be titcre fajeatbcs ofanatDato,One breach 
 pon map afsign l)«t one oftbcm{nan;9aionb?oiigbtfojb?eacboftbe°f »" ^'^"^ 
 
 iatoatD, air.gnablf. 
 
 Michill and Hep worth . 
 Hill. 1654. Banc, fup, 
 Trin. i654.rot»7i7. 
 
 A Writ of Crro? toaobjotiehtto tcbctrc a juUgcmcnteibenintbeErrorin 
 Commonpleao in anattionofsnrefpafo fojanaffauU, ano taMng ludgeBem 
 atoap of tbe l&lafntifo <I5ooD0, anD amonga otbcr fo> tafetng atoap of ®Irf-'" Ticfpafs^
 
 450 _^ Hill. 1654. 
 
 tfngs , ano tino Crtojis ioecc nr^fgneo, i . %VM Wjt ^cclaratfon Ivag tDftb 
 uod cum ^ ^^^^ cum,\nl)lcb toae fafo (0 not gooD (n an aictfon of BCtefpafa. 2 . SCI^at tfte 
 no? good in !Pla<ntlf DID Hot fct fojtb Ui^at tbe iDjltfngo VDcrc Voljlcb tuetc tahcn aUjap ; 
 in Ticfpifs. bnt t^c 6rft eicccptfon uao onlp relpeo upon , ano to tbat Roll chief lufticr, 
 otherwifc in anftocrcD , SCtjatifttic action iDcrc an flrtfon of SLrcfp^fa npon tlje cafe, 
 Trefpafs on tljong^j U iDCtc toitb 3 VI et amis, tt m<nbt be gooo Ui<H) a quod cum , bnt t^ 
 the caie. ^jjj^^ ^cxtis a mect action of 2CrBfpaf0 vi et armis, Therefore fiiew caufc 
 why the lodgement (ball not be reverfed. 
 
 Kirk and Lucas. 
 
 Hill, 1654. Banc, fop. 
 
 Hill, 1653, rot. 579. 
 
 What fiiaii be T/" ^'"*' •'J^^C^'t >" actlott of actontpf HgalnC Lacaf, t^e SDcfenbant Lucas 
 
 a good plea in J\>pleaD0 ne unquei receptor, ant) upontb<0 BKTne t^etc toas a tcrolct fo; 
 
 anaccompr tbe|plalntlf , tbat tbc jaDcienDant Qjallatcompt, tobereapon auolto^a bc« 
 
 before Aud^ fug affllgncD , be plcat)0 bcfoje tbcm fn tlfcbatge of tbc atcompt . tbat be 
 
 '°"- rctefteo tbe tttoncp of tbe )piainttf to oelfbcr otet, ano acco^olnglp it bai» 
 
 belitcrcti tt o\}CT ; 2;beqtic(tfontoa0lt)!ietbCTtb{0pleapIcai)eo bcfo;e tbe 
 
 anDtto?0 Iraa a gooD pica <n Dircbargc of tbe actompt. Twifdcn faiD , 3it 
 
 leas not a gooo plea In tlfcbargc of tbe 0cconipt befo je tbe anotto^s , bat 
 
 it bat) been a gooD plea In bar of tbe action , ano bere It I0 not (bcUieo tbat 
 
 tbere \aas anp Direction glt^en to pap tbe monep otcr. Roll chief lufiice , 
 
 3lfbepleaDtbatlttoa0palobpb(6confcntltf0agooopleabefo;te tbe anof^ 
 
 to}0 , ano tbl0 <0 a gooo plea In bar If tbe monep be palo accojolnglp, There* 
 
 ludgtmcnt. fore take your judgement, nili. 
 
 The Protc^or againft Richardfon. 
 
 Hill, 15 J4. Banc, fup. 
 
 AiII2IHrltof(iBfrojtDa0b;tongbt bp Ricbardfon to reberfe a labgement 
 luu cue. gitjcn againft bim , being bp pjofefslon a ECapict , upon an fnfojma- 
 
 uponTn In— tfon Of eitto)tlon ej-blbtteo agafnft blin at Oxford , at tbe af0<?e0 tbere , fo j 
 formation toi taking oto^e moncp of one tbat bouno blmfelf apprentice iitt b blm, tban bp 
 Extortion. jLalD be ongbt ; anotbeCErrojafolgncD ua?, tbat tbe 3!oW«8 of arslje 
 bate no poiricr to Determine offcnceaof tbis nature, ano Metcaitt cafe ir 
 R«p.tra0 argeo, anotbe&tatuteof 22H. 8. C. s.anbaSH. 8. C. 5.1Bnt 
 Crook Seipnior anftDcrcD, Chat as tbepatc Jufilccoof £)pet anostctml. 
 net tbep batie poicer fap tbclr CommlfBfon to Determine offences of this na- 
 tare, ano It (ball be Intenoeo tbep pjoceedcd bere bp tirtue of tbat Com- 
 mlfelon , ano In 7 Ehz. In Dyer It I0 a quaere tobctber tbe statute be meant 
 Certainty is Of tbc Court0 at Weftrrtinftcr, 01 no , ano It tDoulo bc Incontienlcnt If tbe 
 requiicd. 3iufi{ce0 (boalD not cnqulce of futb offences at tbe afsljes, ano be citco 
 Grcgories cafe , anc Cook* gtirlsolctlona of Courts ■. to pjobe tbep babe an* 
 tbojitp Roll chief luftice , JBut ft appears not here bp bertue of toblcb of 
 tbelr Commlfslons pon babe trpco tbe offence ; but pou fcabe |umbleo tbe 
 Commlfslonstogctbcrlntbcl'^ecojD, ano tbep bate not autbojitp bpaH 
 tbelr Commlfslons ; ano beftoectberelsanotbet fault In tbe tuogcmcnt, 
 fojItlsnotfalDltlsconfioereobptbeOrourt, but onlpft Isconfioerro. !B5p 
 Ibe i^tatnte of 2 2 H. 8. tbe JuCkes of afsljc bp t?ertnE of tbclr CommiisU 
 
 on
 
 y»ll- »^54 431 
 
 onof;©petaaoSCetmlnec,bat)epoiDecto trptjftcti olltnttt , K t^cf bt 
 not ttttxatntn to ccttaf n Conrta; but fo? tbc ceaCons gfo^efato > Shew caufc 
 why the ludgemenc ftiould ooc be reverfed' 
 
 Protedor and Gartwright- 
 Hill. 1654, Baacfup. 
 
 ]9ClDa0moteDonff)ebct)alfofCartvvric;bttf)atl^e mfgttf liate aUotsance For aiiow. 
 -■ •f W0 l^lca confeffeD bp fp;. attoincp general pleaneo to a quo Wtrran- »"<:<: of » p'«* 
 tob?ongl)t (0? tftc ^jotcttoj aBa<na l)fm foj cettafn Hbettfee toWtft ^e?''^''''"*'''' 
 tlaJmcotottWntljeflpanojofOflinfihainfa Nottinghamfliire; tfte ®fceptf=geneur"'^' 
 on to tbe plea tnaa, ttiat ^edafmeo t^c dfe^^e of Mfne , to totiicl^ ft toas 
 anftocrcD, tbatUfgfntcnBeoonlpoftbcmeafotcflfoj^tne, anot^t tl)e 
 fdlea ^aD be^n reao ano craminco bp luQic Aik. Roll chief lufticc, Lee 
 JnftiiccAik examine ic again. 
 
 Toft and Daye. 
 
 Hill. 1654, Banc. fup. "' ' 
 
 Trin. 1 65 j. rot. 547. 
 
 AMtJt Of ettoj foas bjoagW to teftetfe a |a«gemcnt gftjcn fn an actl- c ^or to r? 
 on upon tbe Cafe b?ongtjt agalntt a febcdf fo j tctto?fng of goons taben verfe a iudlt* 
 fn ©fcntf on to tbe part? from tBbom t^p toctc taken , ano fo j enoo jfing of ment in m a- 
 mUa bona apon tbe tD?ltof €yctnticn, ano DcKtnfng otct tbe tB;tt^'"""P°" 
 fo eiwo jfcD to tfte neto febcr<f W« &atceffoj. SC^e <£tto?0 afsfgneo tocrc'^^ ^*^'" 
 tbelie. } . 3t (• notXafo <n tt)e Sleco^ Vtat i)e tetnrneo nulla bona , but on- 
 If tt>at te enoo^rea nulla bona apon tiie ts^it. i\f, $t is fafo tbat \)t ttiU 
 t»Tpo tbe tojft tbns enBo^fco to tj^e neti) feftcrff , bnt Botft not ftcto tfjat tt>e 
 tD;ft tpae oeUbcrcD otct bp Blnsentore beticirt t^e neio &t)erf f ano ^c elD , 
 to be tetnrncD bp Wm. 5 ly. 3t appears not tnljetbet t|>cre toctc anp return 
 at all mane of tbe tojft bp tftc neto feberff oj t^e olo. 0no 4lp. SLbc ^ttfoit 
 fsnotlafofntbeCounti'lBbereUonBbtto be, fojft ie neftbcr b?ougbt fn 
 tfte Countp tobctc tbe tojft toag fntiojfco.noj toberc ft teas Dclftcreo abet. 
 Latch anrtoereo , tbattbc attfontoa«b?ougbt foj rcvUelfterfng tbe gooDs 
 taken fn ejccntfon back agafn to tbe partp , ano not foj tbe cnoojCng ofi^^'^e'^'f s 
 tbe twft, ano oelf berfng ft otct to tbe nctp feberf f. But the ludgcment was'*"'^""- 
 reverfed, nifi, &c, Poftea. 
 
 Porter andSwecnam. 
 
 Hill, t6^4> Banc, fup. 
 Trin, itfj4. rot. 393» 
 
 1^ tbf i Cafe npoH « tejft of Crro j b jougbt upon a Inigemenf gften upon 
 an 3tffon of Covenant foj not papfng of rent rcfcrbco upon a ILcafc foj tenant" 
 peats bpjnccntutc, Sfter tbe optnfon of tbe Court teas oclfterco tbatEVprefJco- 
 ^toojDepfclDfngano papfng fn tbe Snocntnrc maoc an etpjcfs Cobc-vcnanr. 
 nant, ano tocrc not a bate Covenant In JLato, anotbat an attfon of Co,'^'^'''^°^^"°^ 
 tenant DID U)cUl(e upon tbein, tbe to^u of Crroj toas qnal^co foj a ocfttf^udgime'n^f^
 
 43' 
 
 Hill.i6 54j 
 
 tn It , ann a ncto fcpjlt of CEtto; bjoagljt , aiio tl)cteapon tlje | aogcmertt toas 
 aflafn pjapeo to be affitmcD , which wt$ done, nifi,&c. Nora. Antca* 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 H-beas Cor- -T" i^c CooTt toas moDcD fo? a Habeas Corpus to tcmotje a Pjffonet in 
 pus. I MorthamptonCDaol, t^at teas contrfttcD of felonp, anobao been burnt 
 
 JDtbcbani), upon an Affidavit tbattbcOaolcrufcDblmbarDlp. 3But Roil 
 '."'!"*"'y"p'„ chief lafticeanftoetCD, that it could not be, but they might either endift 
 the Sfc. »h« Gaoler,or bring an Aftionagainft him. 
 
 Hill. 1654- Banc- fup- 
 
 For a new 
 Tiyal. 
 
 TK^e Court toae mobeo upon an Affidavit (tn a neto tr^l ,' becaufe tt^e 
 3[urpVcere not kept togetbertfUtbepl^D gfben tbefc beroia, as t^i» 
 ougbttobe. 315ut RoMchiefluaiceanftocreD, tbfsfflamffDemeanoj , pet 
 Thr lu'ics t^e betDfctis a gooD bcroict nottoitbttanoing , pet Uie tuUltjear the Councel 
 miidcmcanor ou bot^ Qoes before toe conclnoe anp tbfng : The fame Term ludgement was 
 Ipoiis noi the oiven, upon another motion made for a new Tryal. 
 
 Vcrdift, fc ' f . •» 
 
 TUc Protedor and Lowr. 
 Hill, 1654; Banc, fup. 
 
 Toquafh an 
 Endiftmeiit. 
 
 D Arton motett to quaflj an Gnofamcnt pjefctreo agafnH Lowr at tftc SIT- 
 ^fl^es at Cornwall, to J fpeahfng of fcanoalouo too job agafntt the parlta- 
 mcnt ; 'SDiZ Cixeptton taken toae , tbat it ofo not appear fn tiie Cnoictment 
 that the patUament toag fitting at tbc time tobcn tbc lnoiOfii incre fpoUen. 
 JBut Roll chief lufiiceanftnercD, 3 1 appears not to ub but that tbc ^arlia* 
 Uenied. ^^^^ ^^g Otting at tbe time ; ano peraobentare it toill be maoe appear at 
 tbe trpal. Therefore plead, and go to tryal , and then move in Arreft of 
 judgement if you have any thing to raovei 
 
 > • 
 
 Page and Parr. 
 
 • - 
 
 Hill. I654. Banc. fup. 
 Trjn. i<5y4i rot, 1(587. , 
 
 Covenant fjAge bjougbt Btt flcion Of Cotjcnant upon a Cobcnant confclncu in an 
 
 upon an In- | jnDenturc of a ocmife fo; pcara , foj tbe not paping tbe rent referbcD 
 
 dcn.uie. bp tbc Binoentnre , accosting to tl)cCotenant. JEbe SDefenuant pleaoa in 
 
 bartbattbePaintifcntrcDintopartof tbc lano Dcmifeo bcfoje tbe rent 
 
 Due, fojtBWtbtbcSafontDafl bjougbt, ano fo ban fufpenoco Wb rent: 
 
 SLbc pialntif replpro, tbc H^rfcnMntoiDrC' enter , anofo teas poffclIenaB 
 
 Su'"ptiifion <y in i)i6 fojmer cftatc , ano to tbia replication tbe SDcfenoant DcmurrcD , ano 
 
 "■" ■ to), cauftbe fi)etDct),tb<it liere toas no confefBion ano aboioance, o^ traterfe 
 
 of the plea in tar. Roll chief iuf>ice,?^atcpouflieli!cot!iat be continueofn 
 
 poffcfinion until tbe rent greto Due J ioi pon ought to tbtintbat be cntrett 
 
 ano toaBpoITctreDantil after tbe rcnt'Dap, but bere pon babe onlp faio tbat 
 
 N! rji'ijt rerjje jjjag poffcffeo in b<S fojimcr rigljt, Therefore nil capiat per Billara , 
 
 HiiL
 
 HilL i654- ____^ ^31 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 
 •\7 pon an Affidavit teao In Court, tftat aol. colls ioeirc tarco upon a^''^' 'ft'''"j 
 ^ non-futcfn an artfon of Crcfpafaano ejectment bjouebt to tfte 3i5at,'i,-'(j5^i^P*"* 
 anD tljat tlie ^lafntff ftao not papcDtbcm, no? toas to be fotmu , ano pet^ap f^,,mer h&i- 
 1»! ougl)t anotBet iattton fo: x\)c fame lantr, 2Ct)e Court teas motJCD tbat tftc on. 
 SDefcnoant mfgljt not be taleo to plcao to tftiafeconQ Action, unt<lt^e 
 JDlafntff bao paf o tfte toffs tareo npon ttie former non fute, ano tftat anotftct 
 pafnttf mfgftt be nameo , oj tftat fecurftp mf gftt be gf ten to pap tlje cotts 
 ff tbe paintft flionlD be nonftite sgafn. The rak was to fhew caufe why ic Shew caufe, 
 (houldnotbefo* ' ^^^--i 
 
 -. Hill. 1654. Sane. fiip. 
 
 DArcy moteo t^af an Cnbfttment of Michaelmas SCerm laff mfgftt be a« 
 menOcD in t&c Caption. J5ut Roll chief luftke, anftocrcD , It cannot JnS/n*" 
 beifitbcofthelaftTcrm, but had it been an endidment of this Term it of a forme" 
 might bave been amended. Term <lcmc«|> 
 
 Hill 1654- iBanc.fup* 
 
 IT fee Conrt Irag motcu to qaaOj an <2nuf ctmcnt for cnftfna fo jcf blp apon ^^ -„,(}, „ 
 ■*■ aSCenantfojpearg, agatntt tfte Statute of 2 1 lacobi, ano tfte (iEi:tcptl« Endiament. 
 on teas, tbat t^e CEnoictmcnt ootft not fap tbat ftc entren manu fortU Roll 
 chief lattice anftnetco, SL^e Statute fg onlp , tftat <f one enter bp fojce; 
 ano tfte toojos manu forti arc not eitpjcffcD fn ttie SlCt , Therefore move it a* 
 gain if you will* 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc fiip. 
 
 A Habeas Corpus cum caufa teas grantCU fo J Elizabeth Bsyne, to tbc {n»ro Hifchirje 
 ''■ ^tent to tbargc her lotth an 0(tfon , ano upon the return thereof (he toas ^ ptifoncr 
 tommttteoto the l^arefchal. Wild motjeo that Qje mfgfit be Dffchargeo , "'"rf "7' ''^ 
 bccaufe the return ofthe Habeas Corpus fserronfous. iSut Roll chief I*chaj * 
 fticeanftDereOjltcouldnotbe; tohcrcuponhc motjeo fo? another Habeas For i habeas 
 CorpasfojheradfubjicienduratobcDfrecteDto tfte ^arcIJchal , which wis<=°^v^^»i 
 granted, fubjicicndum. 
 
 Hill. i6 54,Banc.rup. 
 
 T^l^c Court bias mohctt to qnaOi an Cnufctment pjeferrco agafnff one foj To quj(h aa 
 pjaaffing IpWCck, not being sWlfnll fn the pjofefsfon , ano not haWng Endiftment 
 a ILfcenfeto pjattkc from the College of phlBcfans. JCbc C-rceptfon0p,''?'t*'''''h 
 tners, i.2Lhatno(iBnD(amcntatthe Common liato lies foj the offencCoutiiccnrc 
 fuppofeDtobecommnteo, fo; (t is not an offence agafnft the Common 
 BLato , ano 2lp, an Cnofctment upon the Statute Itta not , ano To no Cnofcts 
 ment lies , And upoa chefe Exceptions ic was quafhedt
 
 454 Hill. 1654' 
 
 The Protedor and Hart. 
 
 Hili> i6^^,'&ir\c,{up. 
 
 Tofem»nd a •^^e Hart commUtcD to tt)E ©atcbourc appcarcBiti Coiirt upon t^ tC 
 piifoner ap- ^Jtujg of 8 Habeas Corpus gtantCD (oj Will , anonpon tbcpjapct of bio 
 pearing upon ^p„,,(gj ^^g tctuttt ira0 fllcD , upott toWt^ (t U)a0 HioticD Oil b<0 I>cl)alf tftat 
 CorpuT, and Mc m<ctt bc rcmanocB to ttic JSeepct of t^ie <I!?atcl)oure , ano not tarneo obct 
 turned over, to tljc ipatcfcbal , to tl)c <ntcnt to ffttjc ^ffl fces , but the Court laid it could 
 Denied. „(,( \^ ^ bccaufe upon fiUng of tt)e return tbere oug'bt to be cntreo apon U a 
 Commitcicur tot^cCJ^arefc^al, lo^crcbi.' be becomes ^tspjffoncr. 
 
 Torret and Frarapton. 
 Hill, i6j4»Banc.rup» 
 Trin. i6S3«tot. «78. 
 
 SpeciaT rrr. •* 7^on s fpecfal mcroftt tbe Cafe toae tbfs , man oetffetb b<8 lanos to 
 d,a upon a Y tjjg jpffp foj ijct Ufe , tbc rcmafnoat to A. B. ano C, anu tbcft bcfra re- 
 ^"'^''' fpecftoclp fo; ctjer, SCbc qarff fon teas tobetbcr A. B. ano C. torrcjopnt 
 tenants, o> tcnantfl in common. Serjeant TwifJcn IjclD, tbat tjjep tocre 
 Whether jognt tenants, ano tbat tbfs taf« BlfFcrs from Radcliffs cafe, ann cftco 
 joym-tenancy yj-^^^^ j^jj. ^^ j|jj ^ ^^p^ ^^^ g OTlfllmutt be flcBr ano tonfpfcuotjfl , but fo 
 
 In common'' ** <flnotberc , ano bere Is no enforcement bp tbcfe toojog rcfpembelp , ano 
 tijep to relate to tbeperfons, anonottotbe lanes bcqucatbco, anD a Co- 
 tenant maoe bp tb?ee rcfpcfltbclp fs a Jopnt Cobenant, ano not a febe- 
 tal Covenant, anDtbctoojo refpectftclpbatb relatfon to t^c furtfbojfljip 
 tobkb map bappcn bctlrfrt tbe par«co , ani) a oebffc to one ano b<0 bcft is a 
 fee=Cmple. Latch , jFoj tbe E)efcnDant bclD , that tjere fs a tenancp (n: 
 Common, anflnotajopnttcnantp, foj tbe (Mate oi-gbt to be Uiljole out, 
 eftbcr a tenancp f n Common, o j tobole out, a Jopnt tenancp, ano tWs of ne= 
 cef0<tp; foj tijcre cannot be a jopnt tenancp foj life , ano fcberal inberf. 
 tancc0intl)cremainDcr, ano Littletons grounfipjoljeotbio to be fo. Sim 
 alp. St {0 againft all conltruction to be otbertoffc , as tbc tnojo refpectfuelp 
 iS berc placeo , ano Ratclifs cafe , \30W\i is not fo Crong a cafe a0 tbi0 cafe 
 pjoljes it to be ""o , ano altbougb tbc u o?o rcfpcdlbelp map fomctimcs 
 mafec aDiftributionofbeirfbiPf asbatbijeenobjctteD, viz. offctieralbeir< 
 l5iftribution 0,jpg. pp^ ^g^g thc placing of tbc Inojo rcfpcrtiticip (ijcltis it camrot be fo.ano 
 othc!t(hip. tbisafingoftbctoojoianotopcratite, butiDlc,ifbcrcfboulDbe ajopnttCs 
 nancp, fo: tbc la\n faps ac mucb, tbonyb tbc tDO?t» rcfpectltclp tere left 
 out, ano tbE tooio toonlo be tbr mojc iDle in crplicating a tbfng fo cbtfous 
 to common unorrftancing. ano no \uap0 Donbtfull , ano tbcrcfoje toe can. 
 not tbfnh btittbattbefeertraojoinarptoojOflDo entojcc an ertraojoinarp 
 tonftru'iion, antinota common one , anu an iolc application; ano this 
 comes not toitbin the rule objccteofo; tbc ccrtaintr, foj ttjis icojo b«tb a 
 Operative pjopET meaning to maUe a feteral Dittribution , inbici) mabes it certain t> 
 *'"^''*- nougb,? tftc teo?D l& ufeo l.crc abfoUitelp, f fljall be fo taken in 3 Car. laques 
 
 ano Thorowgoods cafe in tbe Common pleas, tbe tDo?D equaHp laas tafien 
 operatiticlp, ano not in common conCrnction, anoinLewin anoDods cafe 
 fn tbe Common pleas, ^dano 37 Eiiz.tbeiDojocnuallptDasftclo bp ttoo 
 JuDgcs to mafee a jopnt temincp , ano not a tenancp in common; ana 
 tntbts Court alfo tbe 3iuD5Cs tocrc DitjfDco at tbe firft; but aftertoaros 
 
 Pop, 
 
 ■tJi
 
 Hill. 1654 435 
 
 Pophamc|)angcDl)(0op<nJon, anD U feao atjaoaeD a tenant? in common, 
 anu p.ftertoarDa a tojft of C-rro; toas bjougljt in ttje Crcljcqucr Ccambcr , • 
 anotijcrctbc juDsementVoaaaffitmco. Pafch.^i Ehz.B. r.rot. 27^. aifo 
 tbe fubjca matter berc la apt to tcceftjc a tenantp in common, ^crc be<ns (n« 
 tenoetiapjotifftonfojcbilDjen, ann tljdr febcral poffctftf co , iDbfclj a fur- 
 tibojOjip irotilD Df ttrop , J7 H. 8. Bro, Devife 29. anD tbe bcrp {ntcnt of tlje 
 SPeWoj appeatain tfic ulH to be as 3 bavc argueo. Roll chkl luftice, 3 
 lJolr)l)crcf0atcnantp(ncommon,anDtl)nt(tftatfgoc tbjougbout, ano fgWordj nnrto 
 not to be tJtfDCD, aiiDtljc intent of ttcDcbffo; appears (nttjc tutU t^at elic. ""^ cMifirufd 
 rp one OjaU bate Ijfa part, ano tbcfr Ijetrs , to? bete ie a pjotifion mane to j ,7,""'" '''*" 
 Ctnojcn , ant> tlje toojo refprttfbelp toonlo be <Dlr, (f another conftrucffon ' * 
 ftoulDbcmaoe, anoUjoulDCjjnlfienomojetbanVDljattbc lata fa<D U)ftft"!"''P'^n^ent 
 oat<t. Askani3Ncwclij;atcadidem, anDNewdigatetUcD Dyer 3 ^ Hum-j^'^^ ''^''"* 
 lyes cafe , fo judgement was given for the Plaimif , nifi» 
 
 5^hepheard and Gray. 
 
 ^■iilK i6S4' Banc fup. 
 ' Trin. «^54,r, Cjx, 
 
 AtJ^rft of Ctm teas bjougbt to retjerfc a jnogcment gfben fn an Sl<tU^"°' '" 
 on upon t&eC8fe<ntbe Court at Doncaftcr, ano tbe Crroj afsjgneo fj^f c"r"''°" 
 iDa0fntbejuDgement,tDWcfjtoa0entteDtbas, anbtbefafoshepheard, to' **' 
 toft tbeSDefenoantjUjaU be Inmercp of W.Gray, totofttbepaftitff. Roll 
 chief luftice, SDWs < crronfoua , foj be ougbt not to be in mercp oftbc 
 IPlafntf f, bet «Jf tbC ^tate , Therefore let the judgement be rcverfed* Reverfcd 
 
 Lamplew and Hewfon. 
 Hillt 1654. Banc, fup, 
 '"A JFter a tjctbto fn an Siaton npon tbe Cafe bjongbt fo j tbefe feojua , Amft of 
 
 XXviz.l was never aTraytor to the State as you have beentgt toas mobCO 1"^" *aTm 'lor 
 arrcft of Biuogement bp Turner fo j tbe incettafntp of tbc SDcclaratfon , (oi^^ids . 
 tbat it appear0 not tbercfap tbat tbe toojoa tocre fpohen of tbc Jplafntff ,j) j 
 totbeJpia(nt<f, anDbecaufeftisnotfafotbattbetoojos tocre fpoben falfo 
 etmaiitiofe. Shafto Of Councel on tbe otijet Coe anftoereo, tbat U ap. 
 pear0tbe toojii0 tocre fpoben upon conference betU;fj:t tbe partfeo, ano 
 tbcrebpDotb appear a fnfflcfentatjcrmcnt , tb::t tbc toojD0 toere fpohen of 
 tlit JDIafntff. Roll chiefluftice , Stbe ©eclaratfon fmplfe0 tbat tbe toojDS 
 toere fpoben falfo et raalitiofe,i tber ntetia not an cj:p;ef0 abermcnt tbat tbep ,^ , j 
 toere fo fpoken.aa tbere ongbt to be in an enoitfment, anb tbioSDeclarationvcrmcni 
 is lain ttoo pcat0 after tbc toojD0 tocte fpoken , Therefore take your ludgc- gooj. 
 tacnt except better matter be fbewn. iudgemenr; 
 
 Hill. 1654- Banc- fup, 
 
 Ajf ojefn plea, tob'cb fs to out tb^Contt of tbc 3nrfflDictfon in tbc canfe To fweir a 
 bcpenofng ongbt to be ftoojn to be trnc , p; cUc is not to be allotoeo bp wrcin pica, 
 tbe Court. SoruledbytbeCourtf 
 
 lifeba Dod
 
 4^6 Trin. 1654. 
 
 Dod and Herbert. 
 
 Hill, i6)4» B'lf- fup» 
 Trin. itfjj. rot. Q. 
 
 • 
 
 oSSn'r FXO'* bjousbt an aufon of SDcbtagafntt Gregory Herbert an attojnp 
 
 ftand lo an ' J-V of tWs <Cotut tipoH an £»bUgat<on to ftano to an aaaro. EDbe SDe- 
 
 Awaid. fenoant plcaD0 no Sluiato maoc. SLljcpiafntlf tcpUeoaiio fctsfojtbtlje 
 
 jatoam, Iv^kb tuas , ttjat tic HDcfcnDsnt fi)oalo pap unto ttie paintiC 
 
 loo I, at ttoo fcbctal Dates of papmcnt, ano afsfgno tbc b;cncf) tn not papfna 
 
 tb8 100 1. acco jDfnclp. 3Co tijfs tcplicatfon ttjc SDcfcnuant Dcmnro, ano tbc 
 
 cyccptfon taken toas, tftat tt Dotb not appear <ii tbe 0tDatD, tbat tl)c aiuaro 
 
 fa retfpjocal : but that in onlp maoc on one part. 3it fs true bp tbc allcgatfoii 
 
 In fbe pleaufng ft cotb appear : but tW Ijclpa (t not , foj ft ougtit to appear 
 
 Award de & ^" ^^'^ flujaro <t fclf. Roll chief Juftice, tl)c iliuarD app:ars to be maocxle & 
 
 fuper pvi.r.if- fupfr pr2mifris,anD tbat map ftelp<t.ll5uHbc|)lafntff batbnot tocU affl<gncD 
 
 fi». tbe bjcacb, foj tftc bjcac^fsnot afefgnco upon a gooopart of tlje aiDarD,foj 
 
 Breach not ^^gjg jg „o (gufg fet io;tb (u tljc fltoarD U)'.)p tlje a>efenDant fboulo pap tlje 
 
 wciJ ai..g.icd j^^j^ Therefore nil capiat per billam,niri,&c. 
 
 Hcnly and Baynton. 
 
 Tcifl. I6j4 Banc.fup, 
 
 Trin; 1654. rot. '3^4» 
 
 A reft of TJEnly biouo^t an Action upon tl^c Cafe aga{nffg>(t Edward B'aynton^ 
 
 in Aftion up- tlfOJ fpcaWng of tbcfe toOjDS of bfm, viz. You have coufencd the State of 
 
 rhe c»fe for 20000 1, and I will prove it, for you have received five and twenty thou- 
 
 words. fand pounds profits of the OfRce,'and not compounded for it, and have foiffed 
 
 in words into the order for your compofition, 0ftct a tetDfct founO foj tfte 
 
 pafntff , ft toas motieofn atreff of 3laDgemEnt,tbat tljc tuojua as t^ep are 
 
 lafo fntbeSDeclatatton ate not aaf enable: fojtbepafntlfootb not cntftle 
 
 Winfclf totbe£Dfficc, but onlp toelct)cnpattooftbe pjoRta oftf)ea>fficc, 
 
 anfi fobc cannot be fcanDaUjcD bp tbc toojoa as an £)r{icer,8 Hob. 267,168. 
 
 &fr Miles Fleetswoods catctoaacfteD, anoHob. 76. Bray ano Humes cafe, 
 
 ant> 4 lac. Cars anD Rans cafe, ann Hill, 14 lac. Snails cafe, anD2ol<c» 
 
 Curie anD Tucks cafc. dp. ©crc fa no atjcrmcnt tbat Whitwick ourfng U)ftofe 
 
 life tjc cUima tftc office toaa aUtie loljcn tljc ino jDa toctc fpohcn , ano f f be 
 
 toere Deao tben be toaa no offltct. Sinn tbc fubfcq-.tcnt teojoa do quaUflc 
 
 tbc fo jmct part of the toojDa. foj tbc rccciblng of tfcc monp ta not an offence 
 
 0; tofcnfng of tbc &tatc, 1 4 lac. Godard auo Gilberts cafc f n tljc Common* 
 
 infenfibie plcaa , anD fo; tb^ UiojD foiling ft fa anfnfcnfiblciDOjD, anDtl)crcfoj» 
 
 wjrJ. cannot be actionable, anD tbepiafnttfootb not ater, tbatbebfonotfoittfti 
 
 „ . too jDB Into tbffl o?Dcr, but onlp fapca , be Dio not foitt fn too joa fnto anp oj^ 
 
 where no" •>"• ^"^ tljougb tbc toojDfl tocTC acttonablp, pet at tbc tfme tobcn tbc Action 
 
 danimjgc;. toaa bjougbt Henlv Vena parooncD bp tbe Act of £DbUtfon ff be bap Done ft, 
 
 ano fo coulD not be DamntficD bp tbc SDcfenDanta fpcakfng tbc tv.o;D£E 
 
 Iftbeptoetcttuc, anD fono :9£tfon Ifca, fo; no Dammagca coulobcrcco- 
 
 tEtCD,Hob, S2. 294- Chuddington anD VVilkinscafC, i E. j- ?• 12 Eliz. 
 
 Bartons cafc, 20 Aff. Pi. 7. 6 Rep. 13. J6 lac. Series cafc. ShaftoOrttb" fame 
 
 fiDC utgcD,tbat It appcara not bp tbc Declaration tbat Henly iiiaa an £)fficir, 
 
 oj iljat &f t Edward Baynton feneto btni to be fo, anD fo bcre fa an til {nDucc= 
 
 mcnt
 
 Trin. I554'. ^ 4j7_ 
 
 ment, sno &(t Miles Fleetwoods cafe (a, tijat fjcoug^t to bnoto tftat ftc 
 
 teas an £)ffif er, ano tl)eretljeuo?O0toercpoat(tic annccttafn, butfotbep 
 
 BtcnotJjere) noj core late to l;{i5£)fffcc atiDtftc tDo:osarctobetonftta« 
 
 coafltftcplpetogcttjer, ano fo fomc of tbem are of a tcrp ambigitouflconi 
 
 Ittactfon anu unccttafn, ani) otbcrg of tficm arc fnfer.Oble, ano on atjerment 
 
 tannot mahe renfelcfs toojoa to befcnfe. flnofntlbecarc of Curie ano 
 
 Tuck, 20 lac. no juogr ment tuas cter gfticn, art) pet that toaa flronger t^att 
 
 our cafe. 3it ixjas alfo urgeo bp Powis on the fame Qoe, tt)at ft appears not 
 
 lljat ttemoupfpofeen of Dfo belong to the &tatc, oj teas to be compounOeo 
 
 foj , fo? ft map be Ijc reccfbcD tt)E monies befo?c fte Iras a SDelfnqtient, atio 
 
 tftM Ije teas not to tompounDfojtl)cm,Hob. p?, BradftiawanDWalken 
 
 cafe cfteo, fecrgeant Twifden foj tljc jipiafntff bclo the uojtis to be aafon' 
 
 able, ant) cfteo S Car. Culme ano Denhi m<! cafe. Uj^c re ft iDao aoitiDgeD, tbnt 
 
 to fap a man teas a cofening Knave arc attfonablelro job, ano \6 lac. &(t 
 
 William BrunkertCafC, anD Hiil. 1651 Strode anO Homes cafe fcl tbfs 
 
 Court, antt Trin. 1653* Townefend ano Barkers cafe ; anD fn ttjfs Cafe (s 
 
 an (nftancfng iDbercfn t^e piafntif bat^ cofenco iDbfcb maUes ft mo?e plafn, 
 
 ano ft fs alfo aggrat^ateo bp fapfng be hao cofeneo, tl)e &tate, fo? f)c ftati) 
 
 tbcrebp fncenftD tbe &tateagafnftil)e5aiafntff; ano tbc toojoa fntfeem* 
 
 fcltieB •refcanoalousanopjetnoftfalaifo, foj If fte Ijat^ not compounoea 
 
 I)ef0no£)fficcr, bat M^ loll Uf0£)fficc,befnglpable to be fequettrEO , ano 
 
 tbe toojos bere. fball be taken in fenfu compofito, ano not fn fenfu divifo, fo> Senfus com- 
 
 t^ep are pofitftie too jos, 8 Car«Redwood 3 Smiths cafe,8nD tfte laft toojos are 1^°''/"' V .. 
 
 onlp fpofcen to fnftancetl)cCaureofrpeabfngoft!)pfo?mer , anoftfsnot " ' 
 
 material toftcfbcr tljcp be actfonableo?not, but tlje meaning oftfjetoojo 
 
 foil>ing(arotfoDoubtfttll, btitfs bcrptocU tsnoton, nno fijall bcintenoeo 
 
 tbat l)c bao falfclp put fn toojos fnto tfte ojoer, ano fo tbep arc fcanoalous as 
 
 IrcUafl the former, 5 Car. AlleynsCa''c. j9nD tljere fs no neccfcftpfjcre 
 
 to auet tbc If fe of VVhitwick as fs objcaco on tbc otber fioc , foj tl)c £Dfffce 
 
 foasfoj tbe IffeofHenly ano VVhitwick, ano tl)c furtftcr oftbem, ano ff 
 
 tbe afeermcnt toerc neceffarp fn fomc Cafes, pet l}ere ft fs not, brca«fe 
 
 Whitwick fs an ;©fficer upon lilecojo fn tlfsCoftjrt, tofjerc tbeflafonf* 
 
 bjonebt , ano fcen to be alf fee bcrc fn Court; ano bcaocs , tbc Statute 
 
 of 21 lac. toonlo bdp tWs ff rcco rrqufrco, ft bcfng afteratJCtofcHano 
 
 not npon a Demurrer; ano beOloes.bcre fs an aterment, tbat be bath not 
 
 fofffeo toojDP fnto tblsojoerfn effect, fo? be batb atcrrcc, tbat bebaibnot 
 
 foftleo lro?os Into anpojoer, ano fotonfrqucntlp not fnto tl)fo, 2 RTj.f. 7. 
 
 laH. 7. f. 23. 3nD tbc 3ct of obUtfontatb not parooneotbfs offence, asfs 
 
 alfo obictf CO , ano tbougb ft Iboulo, pet ft muft be plcflceo,tbnt tbe pattp map 
 
 appear not to be ejrccptco ont offt, asmanpare, ano tbc Jtirp bate bcrc 
 
 founo foj tbc piafntff, ano foft tball bcfntcnoeotbatbcfsontoftbei'ct, 
 
 ano be ougbt to batscafcerrcoft befoje, oj bate gftcn ft fn eWocncc, ano 
 
 fo be piapeo jnogement foj tbe ^aiafntff. Roll chief luftice , j-on miflahc 
 
 tbe erccptfon, fo; tbcp fap ibat ^r. Hcniy fsparoonco bp tbe Act, ano focan^ 
 
 iiotbconmnlficobptbetoojDslftbcf here true, anofotbcp arenotactfona= 
 
 ble. Twildfn, IBptbcIt plcaofng ft appears not, tbat i^r. Henlyfs toft Wit 
 
 tbe parOon,fo; there are manp pcrfons rrccptco out of ft. Roll <hicf lufticc, 
 
 ISutffttbcfo pctif tbctoojogoonotrclatetoWmas an p;(iccr tbcp ate 
 
 notadfonablc. Wild, SDbetoojosarcfpofecn fntentfonaHpfit rclatfonto 
 
 bis Office. Roll chief luftice , %}c toas not an Officer at the time of tbc 
 
 toojDB fpot^cn, fojbcvas frqutflreo, ano'tben tobatfranoaltantbcpbc to 
 
 bfm. Wild, PEbc Jurp batb fonno tbat be teas oamnlficO, tbongb tbe toojog 
 
 tocre true. SCbcffrft qurlHon bcrc fa , trbctbcr tbc toojos, as t'bcp arc lata, 
 
 rclatetobl8fi)fficc,fojbcfBnotan£?fficer, no; can tbc0£tfonbcb;otigl;t 
 
 bp (jiai asbcfsfOjutittblsfsnotmucbtotbcpurpofc: but tbc occcftalle= 
 
 tohhj SCO
 
 43 8 Hill. 16 54- 
 
 gco to b: Done to tlje &tatc tljargcD upon Mm ta tbe caufc of tftc SiAion, ano 
 (t (0 fafo tftat be occcltoco the 6)tatc <n Wa compoftHon, foj Ijfafine , ana foi 
 f oftting iDojDg <nto tbc ojocr, ano (f be roftteD not anp \)uojDg (nto anp ojoct 
 
 Averment, tbcn fcc D(D tt not fnto tbfiJ. ^M tbcrc fa no neeo to atocr Whitwicks If fc, foj 
 be cotilonotrrccitoc tbepjcfitfl oftljc £)fficcffWhitwick irercocaD, ano 
 tb^rcfojcbcfljallbefntentJCDtobealf'dc-, anD tbcre DotbDammagcarifcto 
 tbcpafntffbptljefpeakfnsof tbclDo;Da,fo;be(fl <n Danger tbetcb^offc- 
 qticftratfon bpfiicbfofftfnsoftl)cVDOjD3 ; ano in tb^ common unOcrHnnO' 
 Ing'Of tbe Ujojds t Ijcp tball be taben to be meant of falQfpfng of tbe Commft. 
 tccfl oiDct, anD one man ougbt not to flanoer anotbet ; ano fap tbat pou bao 
 not notfccoftbciDiotnancetoiiciinalDbfcbbc fflflanocrcD, ft lanott^c 
 purpofe,fo; pou ougbt to take notice of tb: £);Df nance. Newdigare lumte, 
 . to tbs fame effect, tbat tbe toojoa are aafonablc. fo j as tbcp are lafo,H[;n!y fj 
 bjougbt tbctbp iDftbtn tbe compafo of &cn'ieftratfon,anD tbe toojDa U\ tbcm« 
 fclbco are actionable, Uccaufc tbcp fntlance in tebat tbfng be cofcnco 
 tbe &tatc, anotbelubrcquenttoojDs do not (jualffietbefojmcr, but ag^ 
 gratiate tbe matter , ano 3 conccfue ft not ncceffarp to aber Whitwicks 
 
 tor fhc'i'llir. I'f^' ^^^ 'f 'f ''^'i ft fs ab£rtCD bcrc J and (o judgement was given for the 
 
 lift; Plainiif, nifi, &c. 
 
 North and lames. 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc. fup» 
 
 Trin. i<)Ji. ror,i<J(55, 
 
 Error to re- \ CTrft Of erroj loas bjougbt to reUcrfe a jaDgcmcnt gftco ftt att Sctfon 
 
 verfe a judfc j[\ of SLrefpafB fn tbe Commotvplcas rnpon a Demurrer, tbe erro j afsfgn* 
 
 ment in T.ef eBjjjaa^ tbat tbere tocreDffcontfnuances in tbe pjoccfa. ano ft tDao fljetocD 
 
 DHconiinn •>? Howell Of CounceU toftb tbe IDefenoant (n tbe Wixit of erroj tbat 
 
 ances. tbfs fs belpeD bp tbe late Statute, tobfcbfapes, tliat no GSrftofcrroj 
 
 fljan flap crecutfon , anD 3;uDgemcnts upon £>emarrcrs , as tbfs fs, ate 
 
 tottbfn tbe fetatutc. Roll chief lurtice , 315p pour rcafon a Mrft of erroj. 
 
 tofllnot nob) Ipe to j anp tbfn^.SCbe biantb of tbe Statute fs to be fntcnOcD of 
 
 matter fnfojmonlp, but tbfsfs matter of fubftance nottoftbftanofng tbe 
 
 bjancb of tbe Statnte allcscD, Therefore let the judgement be reverfed, 
 
 nifi, &c, 
 
 Reverfed. 
 
 Yokehurft againft 5cotc. 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc. fup. 
 Hill. 165 3. rot. 3 J. 
 
 Debt i;pon \7^''^'^°'^ bjoucbt an 0ttfon of SDebt upon an £)bUgatfonaa;atnft Scor, 
 
 anObiipiti- 1 tbeEDcfcnDantpleaDcDnoneft fadura. aponthfs a fpccfal fecrofct teas 
 
 on, and a fpe. f oanD , tobcrcfn tbe qucflton teas, \i)betbcr ftluasbfsSDccoojno, becaufe 
 
 ciai verdia. t(,g -©bifgatfon loao, tbat be teas bouno fn ccntem libris fnfteao of centum 
 
 libris. Green fo; tbe ^latntff belD ft a gooD IBononotUiftbRanofngtbfa 
 
 Faifc Ofcho- mfftaUc,bctaufc cencemDotbfounD If he centum, anD be cfteo manp Cafes 
 
 graphy. f o p;ot3e , tbat mfMo^tfug of toojDs fn an £)blfgatfon Qjall not bart ft, as 
 
 Hob. 34. TriRintat. foj trigioti , anD feff^nti foj fexcenti anD Of- 
 
 bornstafe, fewcnteen foj fevtntcen , jH.^.f.j, anOPinder andTugges 
 
 cafe
 
 Hili. 1654. 4^^ 
 
 cafe in tljfa Coutf. ano 2 Car. Davis 6(3 Cafe, ano t6e Jorp fn oar cafe ~ 
 
 fiate foanu tftat tftc ©efcnoant ofo fc al anu DeUtiEr tbe bono rg Ms ^(t ano 
 JDfleD.Roll chief Justice ^Z^z tonOfHon of tt)C bono Dotb fet ft fojt^ to Oc i c o|, 
 tD^erefn ttjc JDcfenoant became I'omio , therefore flicw caufe chc next rerm 
 why the Plaintif (hould not have judgement, Juc^gtmenr. 
 
 Cooks and Chambers. 
 
 Hill. 1654. Banc, fap, 
 
 COoks motcD fo*a|9jol)fbftfontotljepjeroBatfbc Coptt foj p jocecD^ Fof » PfoHi- 
 fng agafnft btmtbcrcbp trap of attacbmcnt foj not obepfngtbeSDe.^'*'"" '".'''* 
 •cree of tbat Court. Etie Cafe toas tbfa,Cooki an0 Chambers befngin fntc courT'"'* 
 fn tbe ^;erogat(be Court ioi Hetterg of abtninfff ratten of ttie Coooe ano 
 Cbattels of one tbat opeo fntcffate,3t laft tbep agreeo bp confcnt, tbat 
 Cooks upon pnttfng fn bono to pcrfojm tbe Decree of tbe fDjerogattbe 
 Conrt,tont()ing tbe Difiribution oftbeSntcfiateacftatetbonlD babet^eao< 
 mfnffttatfon grantcn unto bf m fobereapon be nin enter fnto bono , ano ^9 
 ttie ILetterBofaomfnfCratfongrantePuntobfm, ano aftertoaroattje Court 
 maoe an o^oec 0; Decree tljat be (boulo Diffribute t^e efiate in fuc^ano fac^ 
 manner, ano fo^not-perfo^mfngoftbis Decree Chambers p^oceeoo agafnH 
 i)(m fn tlje JDjerogatf be Court bp U)ap of jattacfemcnt. 3t loas argco a- 
 gafnft tbe ^;olb<bftion tbat tbfs Courtis note abfolntc bp tbe late &tatute» 
 ano tbat tbcrc is no appeal from ft, ano tbat tbe Decree maoe boas maoe bp 
 confentsf tbe parties, ano tberefo^eittcasnoreafon to grant a )djot)ibitfs 
 Oil to ^fnoer tbat Court from footing tbe partp to perfojm tbe Decree, Ser- 
 geant Twifden anflcereo, tbat tbe confentoftbe parties cannot gibe a 3a- 
 riofction to tbat Court bcbitb tbep bao not before. Roll chief lufticc, ^at 
 fs true, but bp confent pcraouenture it map be as it is berc, but tbep cannot 
 compel! tbem to confent, ano tbep babe no autbojttp gibentbcm bptbe 
 late statute, but tbep babe onlptbciroloautbojitp, ano it toonio be Dan< 
 gcrous to out tbe olo, ano bcre is a Decree maoe bp confent of botb parties t AdrviniRn-] 
 but bring us Preiidcnis where a Prohibition hath been granted after anadmi-^'°" by con-- 
 niftration granted by confent as this is, 3t another Oap Latch mobeo again ^*"'' 
 fo; tbe pjobibition , ano faio, tbat tbe attatbmcnt teas grantee bepono tbe 
 Conoition of tbe IBono giben in Court . ano tbep ijabe no potner to atoaro 
 ft.nottDit^OancfngtbcDiaribntionoftbf clfate be not maoe accojDfng to 
 tbe bono, fo: tbe iDjofrnncc of paliamcnt gibes tftcm no futb auttojiftp. 
 sip. 2Ebcp cannot o;iDerfucb a Dfttribution of tbe eSate, nottsitbfianoing 
 our confent, foi our confent tnas, tbat tbe clear eftate onlp (bonlo beDi< 
 IlriluteD, anonottl'ic tvbole cttate . ano \vc babe ftr puiiDcnts bere to 
 p;toVe tbat tbep ougbt to p;>oceeD upon tbe 15ono, ano not as tbep babe Done, 
 ItDecoulobabebjougbtabunojeototbcfame parpofeiftDC ba5> tljougbtit 
 neeOfuU;!anD tbrir glting of uo t!;e aomtnfttration upon tbe bono giben botb 
 ab;iDgc tbcm from maUing anp o^oer to D<0rlbute tbe cffate , 0; to p^ockd 
 bp attacbmcnt, anoSlaynyescafe, Hob. f. 85. ano Tucker ano Loans cafe, 
 Hob. i9(.tcerccftco. WildontbcotbcrQocagreco tbe boolis citeo, but 
 faiD, bcre is tl;e confent of the parties , tbat tbe aomfnlffration Oioalo be as 
 ft is bcre, ano tfcat agreement tias bcfojc tbe aominittration granteo. 
 Roll chief luOice , Will you confent to brirg an Adion upon the Bond, and 
 waive the prohibition. A nfwer to this to morrow, ^t anotber D«p ft toa0 No Auach* 
 mpbeDagafn, ano tbcn Roll chief Juftice anftocrco , Proceed upon the'"enf. 
 Bond , tor they cannot grant an attachment for not performing the decree, aU 
 though it was made by coqfcnt. Wild replpcO , CbiS being a ]©CCCW tXaDC
 
 440 Hill. 1654. 
 
 Prohibition 
 
 bpconfent, HjepftatefnbmfttcDtolt. ano Hit attacbment ia granteb ftj 
 DffobcDicncc to tl)c Court tobomaoctfjc octree, ann tbe late £);ti<nancc 
 cotb gff c tbcm potocr to commit fucb ao fljall Df fobep tbe uccrccfl ano ojDcrs 
 of tl;c Court. Roil chief lu(Hcc, appear, ano pleao to tt, ano trp tbcfc 
 po\uer tt?atU)ap , 3 b.Ucbetbatff partfcalDfUconrcnttbataomfnifttatfoit 
 ftjaU be graiitcD in truft , it mnp be fo granteo , altbongb it be not in tbc lu 
 fnaliuap, cno as tl)c statute Ootbcfrcct, buttbctahinsoftljc £)blfgatioii 
 7°m'c7.'"" ties tl)cm lip to tl)at tcmcop, ano tljcp cannot pjoceeobptoap ofattn£lj= 
 ' mcnt , Therefore take a prohibicion as to the actachment, and appear 10 it, 
 and try the raattett 
 
 Boyle and Scarborough. 
 
 Hili. 1 65 5. Banc. tup. 
 
 Hill. 52. r,295. 
 
 Aftion MPoa QCarborough biongbt a« million upon tbc cafe Ux tbe Common picas a« 
 
 theCifr up. Ogainft Boyle, upon a pjomifc, tbatitbcrcas bis fon William oiootocuni 
 
 onapioniKe tO •Scarborough 500 I, anD Scarborough OiQ intcnOtofuca ne exeat regnurn 
 
 ond jujRc- agafnS btm, to bfnocr bim from going out of England till be mijjbt tccabcc 
 
 Dcnmrer"' '^^^ ^^^^' ^^v'' ^''^ H^^fcnuant Dio pjomifc that if ^e looulD fo?beat to 
 
 an'd mTof fuB Oiit 811 ne exeat regnum againtt bis fo" William , bc toOulD pap tbc Debt; 
 
 Error, ore- tUlpon tbis Sflioo tftc pialntif obtaino a juogcmcnt upon a Demurrer. 
 
 vcifc it. aaJbcreupon Bovle bjingsa tojit of Crro? to tcbcrfc tbis luogcmcnt, SLbe 
 
 pleaDtng in tbc Common pleas iiiastbns, tbe SDefcnbant in tbc action in 
 
 tbt Common picas iras fnco bv tbc name of of Robert Boyle ©fq; tDbo aps 
 
 pears ano plcaos tbc 3»tatnte of limitations of Actions of 21 iac, SCbe 
 
 paintifrepUcstbatbc took out an £>:igfnal againft bim ititbin 6 peats 
 
 out oftbcCbantcrpbp tbc name of Robert Bovle Cfq; ano outlatoco bim 
 
 npon tbat £Djiginal, ann tbat aftcrlraros tbc SDcfenoant Boyle came in ano 
 
 rcberfeO tbc ilDatlaUijp, tbc SDcfcnoant rciopna ano faps proteftando, tbat 
 
 betooknotoutfucbanojigtnallritbirrd pears, fojplcafaps, tbatbeinaa 
 
 a iSnigftt at tbc time of tbc ^jiginalfucofojtb, t5)e pnintif fnr.re- 
 
 lopns tbat be came in ano reberfco tbc ^Dutlalojp upon tbat £)3isitial , foj. 
 
 toant of proclamation, bptbe name of Robert Boyle ©fqufre, gCbc H)efcn- 
 
 DantbploapofKcbuttcrrapB, tbat be teas a iltnigbt at tbe time of tbe 
 
 £intlato:prcbcrrcD ; tbcplaintifbp toapoffur-rebutttcrfaps, bcrebet- 
 
 feo tbe oatlatojpbp tbe name of Robert Boyle CEfq; upon tbis tbe SDcfena 
 
 Dant oemurrco, ano upon tbc Demurrer tacgcmcnt teas giben foj tbc 
 
 |3lafnttf, ano npon tbis tbc U-.jit of CBrrojtvasbjongbt in tbis Court, STbe 
 
 CorfiJerjii- ^f^djg afgfgncD tocrc, 1 . 2Cbat bcrc toas no gooo conftocration foj tbia 
 
 a'pn mX." P?omife , fo J tberc is no grouno of action Oictoco againft tbe fon , noj that 
 
 i^c bao been at anpcbargc in tb' pjofecuting anp artion againft bim, ano Ro. 
 
 fyer anO Langdales cafe 1 6^0. in tbis Court , ano Bed well and Cottons cafe 
 
 fum"*' "^'^ ^°^' ^ '^ ^^^ ^^^^^ '• ^"^ ^^^' *''^" '^ "* ' "''' ''^'^^ ^^ ^" "^ *^^^^ regnum iti 
 ''"""' tbe ikegifter ; but onlp a tojit to gibe fccuritp not to go out of tbc lUealtn 
 
 totbcpubliqMcp:ciut)iccoftbc^SinganD bi3 people; ano bcrc is no fucb 
 
 matter but onlp tbat be otocb <f 00 i. anD tbcrcfo:c be IdouId fuc out tbe injit, 
 
 • ano tbougb tbe conftocration Cboulo be gooo, pet is not tbe p laintifs rcpU« 
 
 cation goto to tpe tbc fcconotojitro tbe firft, fojbcDotb not fap tbat tbc 
 
 recono is pro una et eadem caufa , anO fo it is inccrtain , Brook Trefpafj 
 
 85. 9 H. 5. ano tberc mapbefeberalpjomifesmaocbcrcinoncDap, anoic 
 
 Rejoyadcr. tjje wplUatloH begooD,pcttlje tcjopnoct (s gooo, 19 H. s. 43. 1$e onlp 
 
 ao.
 
 Hill. 1655 441 
 
 iBBmfta tbat fte bcfng alSnf a!)t <3 t^e fame pcrfon tn^ifcf) toas fueo fap tfte name 
 of an Cfqufre , Hob. 1 7 1 Stukelyes cafc. Znn ftcte ia a |uDgement bp a ni. 
 hildicif, anonoiijatraritof attojnep, fojftfflfnlatfnc, to^fcbbcfngfincewarrartof 
 ttjc3ctfoa3UlDpjoceEDms3tobcfrt CngUQ), fs notgooD, ano fo it tDagAtoimy. 
 pjarcB t(;e lu^gement mffiftt be rcticrreo* Latch on toe otber Qoc paapco 
 to affum tfje tnogemciit , ann be argucD , i , SEjjat bere ioas a gooD conQoe= 
 ration to gtounQ tbc pjomirc upon, fo; tbfs tDjft of ne exeat reghum map be 
 fucD fo jtb bp anp one, t feerc is a benefit to tlje partpfn t|)c fojbearfng to fuc 
 ttfojtb, atiD berc <s gooD c.itjfe to motic fo; tbfainjU, ano ft fsfntbcoff- 
 cretfonoftbe tefng to grant it ojnot, but ft concerns Wm (n Ws ftonoat 
 to grant ft> Regift. ipj, 19-;. Brit. 182. Cooks inftit. 1 50. SCftercfflcantfoii 
 to be taken of petfous KccnfcD to go bcpono §>cag, tUat tbep pap tbc(r Debts, 
 alp. 2Cl]c reputation fsgooo, anDftfonotnecefTarpto abet tljat tfee fccono Arermenr. 
 £>;f gfnal luae fo; ttie r^ime caufe ■, firft, becaufe it f s fn an action upon t^e 
 cafe , ane is fet fo;tl) at large, tobfcb ffietne verbatim tbat ft ia fo; tbe fame 
 caufc, anofaplafnfnftfclf; anoilp.ftfs fafotbatbefuen out tlje fecont» 
 iDjfgfnalprocoufaprsdifta, toWci) is a fufficicnt abcrmcnt, ff an abet- 
 ment be necelTarp , anDtljetntfancefntfje Damages argnes not tbat t^erc 
 <s another canfe of flrtfon, fozlKbcn tbe fcconD £D;(g(nal inas fncofojtb, 
 tbc Damages lucre fncrcalcDbpfncrcafe of time, it being a pear after tt)C 
 fuingfojt^oftbefirft ; iFojfljercjopnDcriti/to be conCoercD, i.TOlje- 
 tber tbe partp be eCtoppcD tbno to pleaD. 2lp. 3lf be be not, pet tn&etbcr tbe Eftoppci. 
 matter fet fojtb be gooD. jFoj tbe i. 31 bolobe is cftoppeD bp coming in 
 gratis as an ©fquire, to fap tljat be teas a fcnigbt , ano be not being bjoagbt 
 fncuftoDp, Dyeri9;.s:berebefl)aUpleaDnootbctnamc; bnt b?rc be bat6 
 not allegeD it as be onght , fo; be ougbt to conclnoe abfque hoc tbat ^: toas 
 an Cfquire, ano be batb affirmcD bimfclf to be an Cfqutre fap fapfng & prac« 
 diftus, &c. bat t]e ougbt to batJC allcgco fpcciallp tbat Robert Boyle tonfgbt, 
 tobo VxjasfucDbp tbc name of Robert Boyle Cfqaite: anoiE 4. f. j. is a- 
 gainfttbeofcr boohs. anDtbelalDisotbertoffc. 3tis true tbat tbe olo 
 book of entries, SJCftle SDrcfpafs, ano fome otber JDjeCoents tobicb pafTeD 
 fubfiientioareagainftme, but tbe llaU) genctaHp is againU tbofe ]^;eQ< 
 aents, asR3ftalentriesbrief54. 19H.6. 1,35, 44, tcb^cft fap , ft bc come 
 fnbciscttoppeD, Br. Tit. Deff. 15 &16. giH. 6, 3. 3 j H. 6. anD man? 
 otberloobs, anotbcbooUof ipH- 6.4 3,\ib<cbi8objeacDon tbeotbecOoe 
 IsagaiaCtbem, anoDyer,?. <;8. IBut tbougb be tocte not eftoppeo, pet toe 
 map taUc aotantage 0? tbe firtt £); jginai U);it , fo; (t is bat abatable bp tbe 
 mifnofmcr, anDfonotabateti ; antfUrcfa aflatointbercjopnoer, fo; be 
 Bogbt to batie tratictfcD tbnt be ioas not an (Efqnire, kbfcb be batb not Done. Abltabie 
 alp. SCbc 26 of March is after tbe ojiginal fueo fo;tb, ano fo it is uncertain Xravcrrci 
 fnrefpectoftimc, tDbcnbctoasalanigbt, Plow. 27. bp Morgan, 7H.7. 
 5, janDtbctoarrantof^ttojncpisgooD, tboagbitbcin JLatine, ano if it 
 tecre in CngliQ) it toonlD be erronious , fo; tbe entrp is material , ano tbc 
 conftant p;actfcet3nottoentcrtbctoarrantbefo;ctbe iffue, Trin. 8 lac.^'^"^' 
 Morley ano Morley in tbfs Court , anD bcre is not tbc entrp of tbe toarrant 
 itfclf, buttbcCntrpiatbatbcis^ttojnep bp Warrant. Roll chief lu- 
 flice, 3foneb;ingato;itof looohanDitbeabateo, ano tben be b;fng a* 
 notbertoJit fo; toe fame ocbt, map be incrcafe tbe Damages accriicD be-j^^^^ r , 
 tteiicttbcflrft\u;itanDtbr fcconD => Certainlp no, fo; tfte fccono lujit tedTmiJs'! 
 buttbcrenctoingoftbcfirftlDiit, aiiDisnotanctDtojit; Bat here aredii 
 vers points confiderable, therefore (peak again to it, IBut a ne exeat reg- 
 num is ufnallp fneD fo;tb fn fiicb cafeo as tbis , altbougb tbat jigirtallp tbis ^1"°^*"** 
 Uijit Iras onlp iifeD in bafmclTcB tobicb tonternco the &tate, anD not in p.:i. 
 tatecafcsi anD tbe forbearance to fnc it is a gooD conQoctation togrouno 
 an j^ction upon. 0t anotbct Dap ttje Cafc teas again put bp CbriiV.Turner, 
 
 mi ano
 
 44 i 
 
 Coiiftticiati- 
 on. 
 
 flgrecD 
 
 Averment. 
 
 tftjpp'e. 
 
 Wrlmfincr 
 plcaicd. 
 
 Implication. 
 Coi.fidera- 
 
 Kcplica'iin 
 
 Avrimcnc. 
 
 Csufc of 
 ACliur. 
 
 Mifiiofmc; 
 Eftoppel. 
 
 Apparancf. 
 
 Entry. 
 
 Hill. 165 5. 
 
 "«iiDl)cp;apci)tbe)uD3£metitm(al)tbcrel3crfcD, mrtin bis argument tit 
 mace tlicic qucQiono. i. t!ini)ctl)cr tftcrc be n goot) confiocratton to laifc 
 apjomife, antbcJjclDtljcrc is not, brcaufc ft Dot^ not appear tUat t|je 
 jplaftUtf IjaD aiig cailfc of 0(tfon. Nat, Brev, 85. A. a ne exeat rfgnuni is at 
 ^E ftite of tfjc Sfiig, ano not at tbc futc of a common perfoji ; ano Ubercag 
 ftffiobjcaeotljattibetefngmnpttapnr.poncfromgotng bcpono fecaa, 3 
 anfiuct anp tljat t;e cannot ftap one foj ctcrp canfc , but foj a canfe toljfclj 
 concerns tlje &tate; ano <f tbcrc Ircre tn our cafe a gooD caufe to fuc out ttjfg 
 toift, tljcngramentb.tVtitpttbeparHconotto fucftonUs not a gooo a- 
 aramrnt, Hoi. 154. Dyer ipd.Ctierp one map go out oftbe Isfngoom 
 at fcfa pleafurc. 1 !p. ^crc is no aljerment tbat botl) ttic £)}fgfnal0 tocrc 
 fucDfo:.tbfo?cneanotbe fame caufe, altbougb tbattbep agree Uterallp, 
 Hob. Rtp.Fofierand lacKlonscafc. 3IP <^cref0 no gooD abermcnf , be> 
 catifc it cannot be tbetcbp luioton foj Vnbat caufe tbc laft £)i<2ltial iDag fueo 
 fojtii , Cook InO. i, 20. 4lp. SLbougb tbcrc be an abermcnt, pet (t ts tJoJD 
 bp tbc partfMi oton a)eir'fng,45 E. 3 . y. 2 1 H.7. 24. j9nD our cafe oiffcre from 
 tbc cafe of I o lib. Aft objcacD, foj tbere tbc atcrment toaa tbc BDcfcnoants 
 aDcrmeia, but berc It <0tbc|Dlafntff0.flirotbet)amage0(ntbcfira£)jf. 
 Clnal , anD tbc Damage© tn tbc fccont) j©?<Bfnal to tfffcr , ttWfb ougbt 
 not to be j but tbcp flJoulD agree, otbertolfc tbc £)jfgfnal0 (ball not be 
 pjefumeotobebotboftbenffojoiicanntbcfame caufe, 6 Rep. Spencers 
 cafe, 12 H-y.'!'.? H.6.9 janotbcpartpftjaUnotbccftoppcDbctc, to fap 
 tbat be tuas a Itnigbt , ano this mifnofmecis locll pleaQeo , fo^ tbcce are 
 but tu.;o iccj'c toplcao mffnofmer , antt -toe bate pleaoeo it one of tbofc 
 Juapfl, Co.tKs Entrie* 689, 690, Tit. Outlawries, Raflal brief 6o8» Tit» 
 Treipaft 6'o.ariD tbe pjefiocnt0 of i E. 4.3. ano 21 H. 7. ace tnitb uo , tbat 
 be ftaH not be cKoppcu , aiio be plcaua not crpjeflp tbat be isas an CBfcjuf re, 
 butonlpbpUraponmpUcatfoit. Serjeant Twiidcn on tbc otbcr OfDcpjapo 
 fo J (uogcmcnt , ana V,t argucD, i . Ebat berc ie a gooD conflorratfon , fo j be 
 to fntUleu to bate tb<B to;tt bpFitz.Nor. Brev.ss.toberclttafafoanp pet» 
 fon map mnt?c a fstrmtfc to bate tbfa to?ft , fo^ ft conDucesto tbe benefit of 
 tbc piamt<f , nnu ot tbe Dcfcnoant alfo , ano tbe MnQ map bfatucr anp one 
 from going beronO &ea . 9 Car, Meads cale, 18 lac. C, B, Hall and Wollers 
 cafecitcbbpHobsrttobeaDmBgcD, 43 &44 Eliz.Rippon and North, alp, 
 2Ll)C IRepHrat'on ffi cooo notUittljltanoing the €^b|ettfcn acafi'ff ft tbat bcre 
 i0 not an a'oermcnt , tbat tbe frcona iDjtgfnal U foj tbc fame caufe ao tbe 
 firft tnas , foj U ta !«ot nctelTarp to mahe facb «n atjermcnt , be- 
 caufe tbat tbfs is a fpecfal partfctHar Sctfon , ano not a general 
 aafon , pet berc ia an atcrment i( ft be ttrceffarp, SCbtmlp. 
 Il^crc to uo tarfancc though tbc Dammages noc niffct , foj tbc irjong 
 Dtine fopjpperlp tbc caufe of the flctfon', anD lottbcoammagccfuffcreDbp 
 tbe it';on0,anD tbe crcrcafc of tfmc bat5) maoe the onmsg C0to encrcafe,;anD 
 fo to Differ', 36 H. 8. f. 6. In a feccnti ceUfcerancc, Hill. S Car. entrco 5 Car, 
 in iW Court, tbifl point toaa rcfoibeD in Thcophilui Finch ano Laws cafc; 
 ana tbc jplfno'mi't obicrtcaia not material, fo;i be fa eftoppel) topleaoft, 
 bccaufc be app- arii ,: atis hv tl)c name of b'q;i not upon tbc &bf tf fa rctojn , 
 Dyer 193. ')c muff i^c aDmittcD to bv the fame perfon , ano fo ia tCoppeo to 
 fap t\]t contrnrj', t9 H.d.t.dj. tticBookof 19 H. 6.f, 43.(0notagafnft 
 iij^.ioj fbvre tbe pr.rtp came tnnpoH tbe reto;noftbe&berif,anDrottoUm« 
 tartip as be ootb bete Slfo the trarrant of attojnp entreo in CSiiglifb 
 botD no '.>nrt notluitbttnnoing tbc objection that aD pleaofnga oagbt to bate 
 ban in ilitin at tbc time cf tbc gftfng of tbc toarrant fo j a toarrant of 2iu 
 to jnp ma)' be entreo at anp ttmc.bccaufe tbcrc is no piccifc time Dfrcctcofoj 
 tbcer.trtngotit,!! E. j.f.i. 24 £.7.^,62,15 H7.f.i4.4Ed.4.f.i ^Star. 32H. 
 8, €.3.8 toatrant of 0tto?np entreo at anp tfme prnefng tbe pira fa gooo, i at 
 
 tbe
 
 Hill. 1^5 5 445 
 
 tlJenfme oftbccntdngofft bptbelate Statute It oitgftt to be fiiCrglfff). 
 Roll chieflufticemutataopmionefato, l)c map; cnctcafe t)(g eammases bPr„crcjreof 
 bfs fccono 0ctfon, otbcrlctfc <t luoulo be unrcnfouablc , foj l)c bat!) been te- djmm.-gei. 
 lapco ttoentp pearobptljc £Dutlalt)?poftbE2Dcf£nDant. 3no berc (0 alfo a 
 pooD confiDcratlon to grouno tU actfon , viz. tbe foibearancc to fiic out tbte cor fidcration 
 tI<L1r(t of ne exeat regnum, fo? it <3 beneficial to tbc SDefcncart, cno It la foj 
 Ifjc iSlnge &ono J to grant It, ano tbe psrtp bp forbearing to fne It , Is fteto 
 of trouble , bi? not being ItapeD in England to be fucD bf re. ano bere Is no 
 nccD of an aj^crmcnt, foj It appears t^at botbtbs? £);(Cfnals tocrefucD,\vermenri 
 fojtb foj one ano tbc fame catife, JlBut tbc queOlon fs, toiicbfng tbe manner 
 of tbe plcaolng, ixbttter be be not cCcppeD to fap tbat be f3aii5nigbt,i;:ft^pie. 
 ano not an (Efqulre, anu 31 fee no rcafon Uibpbc Ibotito bccttoppcDto fap' 
 fo,notU)ltbftanDlngbls boluntarp coming fn to rebcrfe tbc£)utla\i3?p. foj 
 fee coMco (rt to fabe bimfelffromarrcfltng, anD tbe Iplngunoetan^Dat. 
 lairjp, anD It itioulo be mlfcblc^ous If be do It not, an^ tahe all tbc pica c^r.ftruaion. 
 togctbcr, mctbln{j0 It (0 goo, ano tbeEntrplnC-ngUODIcfgooTj', fo?ltl« 
 to affirm a jungcmcnt, ano being goou faotb toalcs, toe vilU ta[;e tbat loblct) 
 maUca tb& jaogcment gooD. Yet let it be argued again. Stanotbct oaptbe 
 Cafe toas put again , ano arguco bp Sergeant Giyn tbat tbe juogcment toag 
 notgcoo, anofirttbeaomltteo, tbat bete laagmotonCDeratlontogrounoconfidcratioo 
 tbe Action upon. ilp. !^e maoc qtiettlon tcbctber tbcrc be a gooo abcrmcnt Avcrmcm. 
 toticljing tbc going bcpono Sea, ano toncbing tbc ftnn, ano be fafo , ti;at tbe 
 uiogcmcntglbcn In tbe Common plca0 teas fo:L tbc rcafon tbat be came (11 
 to rcbcrfe tbe ^DutlatDjp bptbcnamcofdDfquIre, ano tb<0 IsbpCffopIctEdopic.' 
 JBut 31 f onccfbe It Is no (Bftopic, fo j JSnIgbt fs part of bis name , ano fo tbc 
 jgDutlaiiijplsnotgooo, 2dH. ^.tberclsnoCBffoplc maoc bp tbe inojoprx. 
 did* Bat If ft be an (Moplc , pet ' tbc pialntlf relics not upon It in bis 
 plea, but upon otbcr matter, ano tbat foj tbcfe reafono , i . JBccaufc tbc 
 coarfe of pleasing Is gcncrallpfo InrcbctRngof £)atlatDjleg.a0ltl0berc,iMeading. 
 ano fo fs tbc old book or'Entries, altbougb fomc IpjcGoents rSn tbe otbcc 
 loap, ano In tbc Common^plcas It batb been aoiuogeD gooo as It la bcrc 
 plcaoco , anD bs map tocll aber, tbat be fs not tbc fame petjon. alp. (B- 
 ftople0 arc tahcn ftrlrtlp agalnft bim tbat pleaos tb^m, ano are not fabotirco 
 in JLato, anD fliali not be tberfoje tabe;) bp Implication. Cooks lit.f. 15 j.B.but impi cition. 
 iftbcrefboulobeanCftoplebcrc, (t mtift be bp Implication onlp, anotbere 
 oiigfct not to be an Gffoplc agalntt an C-ftople in tbc fame Hcro?D, as It 
 Iroula alfo be bete, fo j be map as lucU be cftoppcD to fap tbat be Is a llnlgbt, 
 as to fap tbat be (0 an Cfqulre. j]5ctt tljc plalntlfs contlufioji Is not gcoo, conciufion. 
 fo? be rc!lc0 not upon tbe Cffoplc, anD a gooD plea lultb an 111 ccnclufion fs 
 not 0000, 1 8 H.(5. f,33. 1 1 Rrp. Rawlins cafC. Roll cliicf luftice, fl9ai5C3 bc not 
 tbe concluD'on upon tbe IRccojC:' let It bz reao.upon tbc rcaolng It be fafD,t!;at 
 lie relics not on tbc conclnfton ano fo tbe (Eftoplc Is relpcD upon. Sergeant 
 T wif Jen,3|n ourfenrncbntter toe rclp upon tbc Cft ople,altbougb luc do It not 
 fnourretopnocr,anDfoltlsgooD. Ser;:ennc Glyn, IButpoH DonctconcluDc 
 uponlb:5RccojD,foUJIt,\i3bctbcrpoufl)aUberccelbcD agalnft tbe RccojD, 
 as pon ougbttooo, 2; H. 6. f. 26. Roll chiefluflice, BltlslncffcafalDfo, 
 tbongb It be not In crpjcftc IrojDo. Finch Hen:cc on tbc other fioc arguco In . 
 affirmarcc of tbe tnogcmcnt, ano falo, tbc queftlon Is, Irbctbcr bf? cc!;nmlng 
 (nbp tbc name ofCEfqulrctoteberfctbPfl)iitlatii?p Qjall not be a;i Cttoplc naopV. 
 to bIm to fap aftcrUiarDs tbat be tons a ISnlgbt, anu 3 conccltie It Is, tscaufc 
 be tbnt comes In gratis to rcbcrfe an iDatlato?p AmU not plcao {pifnofmc r, Mfnofmcr. 
 6 E. 4. f. 9. be irbo comco In gratis Is not pjcjuoltco If bebc nctallotocj t^ia 
 plea, but It Is otbcrtilfeff be come In upon pjoccfs to rctcrfc It. alp. 3t 
 fs Icffe mIftblcbouB to Dcnp tbc pica of jpffnofmcr , tban to allotu ft tob^rc It 
 tsnotallotoablP,tbepUaDinsoftbc fpifnofmerlftt bc not true jnapfnbcgle 
 
 mi 2 tbe
 
 444 ^ Hill. 165 5. 
 
 ^rte Contf, 10 E. 4. 1 «. 1 1 E. 4. f. 6, 19 H. 6. f. 8. JCtfcte are 4 bfwaof 
 
 4 Mifnc fmcr jpffnofmcr , to tnit , mtrnofmet of tbe Cft?lft<an name. ilp. S>t t\jz 
 &frnamc, jlp. £Jf aooitfonof lD;iofef0fon 4lp. a)f aoDftfon of place, 
 ano in none oft^cmXiiau mirnofmer bepUaoeDtobete tlpc partp comes (n 
 grati$,Br.Mi(no(mer 48.& ^ E.4.S. 27 H. 8. f. i« 1 5 H.6. Stacham pi. Error, 
 Dyer ipi-ji E.4.f- 8.Fitzh.tit.Mirnofmer8.39H. d. i E.4.anDa3tljCC«re»- 
 
 Eftopic bete (b b'' tscftoppeD to pleao mffnormcr bp reberflng of t^c 2)ntlato;p 
 tD^<ct)i0amatteTof)Reco;iD, ano bpit^ic ^att)confiTmet)t]ignamctobcro, 
 i9H.<s. f. 1. yEd. 4. f. I, ait^ougtit]e m(gt)t pleaD S^ifnobncrff became 
 fn bp a Cepi , pet t^cce be map alfo pleao anotl}cc toap fpecialip 
 ff be tDill , ano it toiU be goon iilfo, 19 H. 6. f. i. i^o; ^atb be bete 
 lelpeo apon bis l^lea of ^ifnofmer , bnt upon tbe toant of |@}o> 
 tlamatioiT, ano be rebetreo tbe £)nTlatD;p bp tbe nameofCfqutcr, ano 
 pet note 6e irfll fap tbat be ioafl a fen<Bbt, toblcbte nnrcafonablc , 34H.6» 
 Fitzh. Protcft, 7, ano tbtB le nn allegation contra fadumfuum propriutr. 
 
 OiiEina; ^tc(6 a fccono ojtgfnal , ano tbat is a gooo fl)?(g(nal tuttbfn tbe&ta- 
 tnte; ano ft appears, tbat tbfs fccono £)j<glnal <b agalnft tfjc fame pattp, 
 ano fo be acbnoiDlcogctb bp tbe IRccojD, bptoblcbtbe Court map be afcct- 
 tafneo, tbat be teas tbe fame pecfon, ano b<s J^ooftion mffmameo ^all 00 no 
 bart. 0nD tbe fccono ;^}fgtnal is gooo as tbe Court batb agrceo upon o> 
 penfngoftbcCafc. RoUchief luftire, be rctocrfetb tbe iDutlaUijp asati 
 Cfqnire, ano aftectsaros fapcs be is a )knigbt. ^e map come in toftbont 
 
 Outlaw y |0?occB to reberfc tbe ^utlatojp> lobcre bis perfon 0; eftatc is enoangereo 
 bpft, 39E, 3Jn2Debt,38E. 3. but be cannot pleao i^lfnofmcr, petbemap 
 p?otcft tbatbelsalftnfgbt, ano fatje btmfcif tn anotbcc fuic tobicbmapbe 
 bjougbt agafnC b<»n. SfbebaOcplcaoEorfgbtpouagrce, ttat bcisnote- 
 ftoppeobece, ano it appears tbat be is tbe fame pcrfon, ano comes in gracic 
 
 Q^. bptbisname^petftisnoeftople. 0no tbe feconc£):fgfnalf3gciD, fo?it 
 
 ^ ^ appears tbat be is tbe fame perfon, ano tbat bp tbe ©tatutc , nottoitbOanoing 
 
 tbe badancl. ano be map come fn gratis tDitboutpjoces, ano take aoban< 
 tage oftbcerro?. But argue again to the point, ivbctbcnb'*- map Ijfng a 
 fecono £5^igfnal bp tbe fetatute. Sit anotber oap ft Iras arcuco again, but 
 3 conlD not bear , but 33 H. 6. f. 1 9. & 50. v.as citeo , tbat tberc ougbt to 
 
 Muuai E- be a mutual Cttople, viz. on tbe part of tbe Iplafntif , ano of tbe part of tbe 
 
 ftopie, SDcfenoant. Roll chief luftice , 3t appears to be one ano tbe fame partp, 
 
 ano toe mult maintain actions againft ibc fetatnte of iLimitations, faecaufc 
 
 1.1H rrtent ^P tljat fetatutc tbe benefit Of tbc Hatois taUen atoap tn part. Therefore 
 
 affirmed. Ut thc Judgement be affirmed. 
 
 Hill. 1655. Banc. fup. 
 
 To fti«w 
 
 ^^ Eraorandum the two Sherifs of iLonOon appeared in Court, in their 
 1 proper perfoniupon a rule of Court to fbevv caufe why they did not 
 execution rot grant out execution upon a judgement given in their Court, or elfe to make a 
 done. lufficicniretornof a Ccrtiojarfdirc&ed to theiTjbecaufc they had made three 
 
 Shaift ' infufficient retorns. Upon this, their retorn now made was read , the cfFtd 
 whereof was, that there is^no fuch judgement as the Writ mentioneth to 
 Vitw of the malie out execution upon, IRjollcbief 3uttfce,This is a good retorn,asit now is. 
 Record. and if thetetornbefalfe^ you may take your remedy againft them forma* 
 icing a falfe retorn. Upon this thc Councel prayed tliat the party might have 
 a Copy ofcheludgement out of chc Sherifs Office. IRoUcbief Suttfee, You 
 may have a fight of the Record, and ifthey will not fuffcr you to have it, you 
 may have your remedy againfl them. SCbe rule tDQS, tbat tbC partp (bonlo 
 
 ^beaCoppoftbe llecojo 
 
 Pafc.
 
 PafcH. 1 6 5 5» 445 
 
 Pafch. r6 5 5. Banc. fup. 
 
 TZJDonamotfonfojanctuSCrpalBronnMD upon an Affidavit, Roll cbiefpor a new 
 ^ lurtice fafo, JCfeat K tfecre be a SCrpal ano a tctofct gltjen opon ft, iBCfte rryai. 
 fame Iffne cannot be trpco agafn bp t^c fame Jarp, altljoogft ttje Ctjancetp J;y*l °f "» 
 00 ojoct facft aatrpal, bat ii ttete be a mitttpal ttic pattp malt mot)e tftc o"^^^ , 
 Coatt tuyere t^e ;3(tion ioas commenceo fo; a Venire dc novo to rnmmon a cLancery. 
 
 nCtoliUtp. Now. Vcn.rc de 
 
 novo. 
 
 The Protc<5tor and Brufter. 
 
 Pafc, 1655 » Banc, fup, 
 
 CArew npon a rale to OieiD caufe icijp an atf aci^ment tboxAn not IttaeS^i^^^ why nb 
 fojt|>agalnCCommfr0(onersof&etDet0fnSDfrork fo> fcttfnga ^Ine^"'^"*"'' 
 opon one fo; not obepfng t^cf c owners, after a Certiorari toas Dclfijereo nnto 
 tftem to remote t^je ojoers maue agafnft t^jc partp fn contempt of ttjfsConrt, 
 fbetueo fo^ canfe , tftat tbe iFlne fet itas foj offofaepfng a neto £)joer of 
 tftefrg maoc agaf nft tfte partp after tlje Certiorari teas tetojneo, ano not fo j Certiorjri. 
 tlfobe^tng tfte £>}itxB temotieo fap tftc Certiorari,anD fo it me no contempt 
 to tftfs Ctratt, Roll chief luftice, SCIje Certiorari Dot|> not temotJC tfee 
 Commifsfon of detocrs, ano tberefojet&epmapp;oceeDapantl^eCom< 
 mffafon nottotttiftanmng l^c Certiorari, Therefore let no'Atuchment if« 
 fue agaiod them. 
 
 Pafch. 165 5- Banc. fup. 
 
 T" l^e Court tnao motjeD toqaalbarrto?nofrcrcoH0, t^etefconfer bcfngR'«i!r»of« 
 ^ inConrt, ^tlpon tb<scrccptfon, viz. that tbe dEnolttmcnt feta fojtl)^^'.'^ cfufti^ 
 tl)at tlj2 partp refcoacD teas arrcftcu on oj about tfte fonrt^ Dap of February /"''""• 
 ano rapes not cettafnip iD^en, and upon this it was quaihed, * 
 
 • 
 
 Pafc. 1655. Banc. fup. 
 
 T 
 
 ^z Court toae motco upon an Affidavit foj an attachment agafnft ^°' '" ^^' 
 four t^at tucrc ferl3E0 u.ttft a Subpxra out of ttfe Court to appear as "''''""^"'' 
 tRSftnctrcs fo? t^c ^jotctto? at a 2rTraltipon8n<I£nt)f£tmentof|berjurp, 
 ano DfT not appear, tobcrebp tbc SErpal coulo not go on. The rule was, that 
 an Attacbmcnt ftjould iffue forth except caufc fhewcd to the contrary. Granted nC 
 Nota. 
 
 Pafc. 1655. ^^^^ ^P- 
 
 Vpcn eWocncE slfcen in a 2ttpal at the IBar in a SCrefpafs ano ei ett. Evidence to 
 mentbetUifrt'-^oodionandlones, 3it toa0 rafD,SDiiat one map ftot »)"')■• 
 fijcto in Etf<DEncc to a 3urp an Infpeximus of a JDcen fnroHcB in Cl)anccrp,<f 
 it be not a ceco of bargain % fale cnrollcQ tl)cre,foj if ft be a deed of feofment, 
 tbe partp muft Ojeln the HDecD it f£lf, foj tftc infpeximus te no matter of IRc ' Matter ef Re- 
 COJD. ISiitbp Roll chief luftice, Chounl) the infpeximus be tbc iofpeximus5^f<^. 
 oftbeCnrolniiEnt, anDnotoftbcSDccoItfclf, pctifitbcan anttcnt 2)«p ' 
 It map be gftjen in eljiDencc. 3t teas tten alfo faio , tftat if it do not ap. 
 pcarbp^cfabjfckofaSDflfDtljatlanosaretoparBtticrebpbp toap of feof.Fiofoicnr. 
 
 S' 1 1 3 mint
 
 44^ P^^cb. 1655. 
 
 "ic. nient pet tljc lanu map pafa bp toap of afe , tf tbcrc be a fufficfcnt conuDcra- 
 
 t<onryp;c(rcD<ntl)CiD^Dtoraffcaure. 5t Vnaa alfo tijcn fafo , tftat <fa 
 
 Indenture. SDffiD DO tuntljuo , 2Lt)ffl'3[nDcntutc maoc , tDl)crcao<n trutft tlje SDaeo fa 
 
 Deed Poll. nottnocntcD, pt map tljfsjSDcco operate as a SDcco Jpoll. 3t teas Ijtjc- . 
 
 toifcfaftj, tbatffonc maUeatoUintarpconbepancc upon tonSoctatton of 
 
 Bjdfcc of natural affcctfon, aiio I0 not at tliat tfmc fnocbteo unto anp , noj be in trea« 
 
 tiaud. tpUftMnp fo: tbcfale of tbe lanes, fuel) contepance Ijatl) no bailee of 
 
 frauo , but otbcrUiifc ft fa If Ijc be InocbtcD oi in trcatpfoj falc of tl)e lanna. 
 
 v,iunury 3;t Icac tljcn aifo fafo, tftat a tolnntarp Affidavit maoe bcfoje a i^nftct 
 
 Aftijavit. of tlje Chancer? cannot be gftcn tn cVfocncc at a SCrpaU 
 
 t'arch..i<55 5. Banc. fup. 
 
 Trcf afs and T^ ^ '^^^^^ ^^ ^^^ ^^"^ ^" ^ '^^'"'^ bcttoccrt Brvers ano Lake fit an 0ctfo{i of 
 ■■tjcamcm. * aCrcfpaffl foj cutting ooton ano tarrping atoap tomo , ant) tbc Defcnoant. 
 juntfpfng aoadommonetfojcaotjcra, Stioaafafo, 2Cftatffanant<ent 
 N Cut ^""'^Sc totjtcftbao Common be fallen ooirn , ano anotbcr Cottage ia cre- 
 ComnTon'by ' ^^^ '" ^bc placc U)J)cre tbc olD Cottage ttootj ; ttts f s no ne\jD Cottage , but 
 picfctiptUn. ft map claim common as an autlcnt Cottage bp pjcfcrfptlon. Noca» 
 
 Timbrell and Bullock. 
 
 Pafcb»i(?yjt 
 
 f TiliaSCrpalatiSatlnalCrcrpafDantj CEjcctmentbetiDeen Timbrell ano 
 
 Hi'cftmc ""'l*i"'iof*t'tloa8fafo, tlmttomakca tufpcnfion of tent refcrtien npon a 
 
 SiifpcniYon of ^^'^^^ ft"^ pears ,. tbc ILelToj muft out tbc JLctfcc of part of tbe tl)fng let at 
 
 rent. Icaft, auo tjolD ifUn ouftlll after tbc oap on lubfcl) t!)c tent Is maoe papable 
 
 Kei.t levivcd. bp tl)c Icafc , ano If tl)E ILcffee re enters tbc tent Is rc\jlt£D. 3!t Ujaa alfo 
 
 tbeu falD bp Roll chief luftice , STIjat Ifoneftatjealeaf^ foj pcarsof lanubp 
 
 E> ccD , ant) During tbc term tbe ilelTcc accepts to IjdId t^e lanos foji a leCTec 
 
 S'jnender of ^^^^ bg^patol , t\)lis Is 3 futrcnDct Of tbc Hcafe bp S)ecD. 3t Inas tften al» 
 
 Lcaie. fo fafo, If tl)cre be a leafe foj pears reno jins rent at a Dap, Uiitf) a claofe of 
 
 tC'Cntrp fo? not papment ; 5' tbc lleffo j Do enter into parf cf tbe lanos let 
 
 bcfojctbeDapofpapmcnt , anoattl)'^ Dap ticmakcsaDcmanooftberent; 
 
 jJiottoltbttanDing this Demano.ano a non papment of tbc rent foUotos t^erea 
 
 Avoidance ofupon, tDbereupontbc ilrffo J re-enters, ptt(haUnottl)tgre.rntrpmafeCtt)C 
 
 a Lc*fc. Ileafc bolo, foj tbe rent tuas fufpcnocD at tbc time of tlje DcmanD, 
 
 The Protestor and che Town o I ColcKefter. 
 
 1*afcb, 1 6) s Banc, fup, * 
 
 R^mrnof » T) Ernardiflon being rcmobo from bfs F.ecoaDcrs place of tl)c ECotim 6f 
 Writ ofri-fti- l~\ Colchefter In ElTex bp tljc IBai'lffs aoD Common fiTouiiccl of tl)e faia 
 r-ition.r, l^^Q.j^^^ p:np:Dfoiljl3lt):ltofrcttttutlon totb2 385al[|f3 aiD Common 
 pUcc Counccl tbercof to be rcftoreD , ano tjattj It , ano up6n tbe return tbep fet 
 
 foitbtbccaufesiDbptbrpremotieDbim, anoiobpbeo-jgbtnot to be reftO"^ 
 reo, Uibicbtocre to tbl^ cffcrt. i^lrft, tbat be being HccoiDet of tbat 
 SCoton, at a quarter feefslons bclo tbcrc before bim ano otbzrs, one Good- 
 all tDas enDlcteofo? baiofng ttoo Uil^cd, anDcont)f(teD tbercof, aop pjapea 
 
 Ijte
 
 WoClcrgp, nno tDa3DcnfcDftbpBernardiftontbel^eco:Der,am)tDa0c«N 
 Demnct) to d<c,5 tDacrcpjf ctjeo,? after at cnotber&cfsjons belOjtljere be uao 
 notluttbftaiir)fngftfgfo?mcr luogcmcntnDmftteDtobfsClcrgp. a.SHiatbe 
 mglettcD to fit at t^c publtquc fecfoiong of t^e peace , tDljkb ougbt to babe 
 been bclo fo; tftat EoUin,uftCTfap ttjc feefflfons conlo not be IjclD. 3 . J^c maoe 
 one Mb 2Dcpntj) , iDbotoasnotan utter JlBadttcr,a0 be cugbt to be, ano 
 contractcD voitb U(m fo j 40 1. a pear to evccute tl's placr, 4lp, J^c ncgleaeo 
 fojalonctfmetofitfnCourt, iDbercbp taufcsTeaop foj trpal coulD not 
 ftCtrpCDinDClapofBIafffce, Larch of Councel fo: Bernarcifton totftcfirtt 
 cpciptlonanftoercD, SLbat tbougfj \)e feao pjocceoeo erronjouflp to oenp 
 tftcClcrcp to Goodalljpct tbfs being not Done aalje toaslIlrfo;Der,but as be 
 toac one amongft otbcrs of tbc <IDomm(fsfoncr0 of j©pcr % ffiermfncr, tob(c& 
 ©ommffcion toae bat to cncnrc fo j a pear, $ toas a ufttfntt potuer from ttje Diair.a 
 3Rf cojccrs poliu r, j.inas crcctitcD bp bfm together toftb otber Comm<fc{o« s'"**"- 
 ncr0, (t tons no caufc to remove blin. SCo tbei2 be anffcocreD, tbat tbcre Dot^j 
 uot appear bp tbe return tbat anp boDp rccc jtjeo anp pjcjuDfce bp bfenot UU I'rcju Jke. 
 tfng (!i Court to bolD tbc &crsfon0 , noj tbfit tbcre toao anp caufe to bolD a 
 |&crsfon0,ani> tbc&efefons tubicb tbcp fiippofc lua0 appofnteo to be belD toaa 
 an f Itc gal appofntment of tbem , fo^t appeare not to be appofnteo bp tbofe 
 tbat bao aiitbojUp to appoint, 0? to bolu tbem, anu fo no fault appears in tbe Amhoriiy. 
 3Ref o?oct foj notboloing tbem. 3lp.2]:bc 3uflfcco arc mff nameo, foj tbep 
 are callcDtbe BuQfcpo of tbc JlBojouLib, a!bcrca0 <t fljoulD be tbc Juftfcea of ^'''*''^'""' 
 tbe Iftfng. 4V* t^ere ootb not appear to be anp appointment at all of anp 
 quarter &er0(on0, annrotberccanbeno^aultfo^ not bolDing tbem,- ano 
 ft (0 not nercffarp (ao ft is fiigrtcftca) f j bfm to mahc an utter JBarflfer bf0 
 JDcpntp , but fapfng be lDa0 not a fit pcrfon to be Ida EDeputp is too general ^'P^'y ^«- 
 an accufatfon , foj tbep ougbt to Ojcto fn toftat \jc inao fnfuffltf ent , neftber clilui ac- 
 DotbblscontrattfngVultbblmfojmonepto ej-ccute tbe place foj bfnr, anp cufation. 
 Isaps concern tbe co;po;atfon, no;f0lt maiuminfe, but 10 onlp pnnfflia> ^^''"'" ^ ^<^i 
 blebptbc&tatuteot 5£d.6. anQ a0 to tbc not trpfngof tbe fCTuctit lopncD 
 lntbat<rourt,attbeDap0tbBptoerctobctrleo upon , tbf0 fa no caufe to 
 tiepjftic bim 01 bf0 place , Vobfcb fa a frcebolo , foj fclB &tetDarD0 of Cojpo. Freehold. 
 ratfono no otbericffe tban be batb Done , fo; tiiep ufuaUp Sap tfll tbep bate 
 a competent number ofcaufeo to trp before tbep lofU ftt to trp tbem, ano 
 tbcre appearo to be but 5 caufe0untrpcD,tDbicb fa no great number, ncftbcc 
 Ootb fl appear tbat be bao anp notice tbat tbefe fite lucre rcaop fo;i trpal, Notice, 
 ano fo berc cannot bcfo great an offence a0 f0 fuppofco , anO be cfteo Se- 
 maigns cafe pRfp. 5jt.noj Dotbftnppinrtbat anp trpal inao offappofnteo 
 bpbtcabfcnce, fo?ftappear0nott atn.ipiffuc iDa0 jopnco fn anp of tbe 
 caufco, oj anp toarnfng gtbcn foj trpnl ouring tbe time tbat f0 furmffco foj 
 b'm to neglect to Qtfn Court; 0no bcrtDC0 , tboagb tbefc locre faffilcfent 
 crfmcp foj to Dcpjfbcbim of bf0 place, pet tbep babe not pjoceeoeo agafntt 
 bfm m a legaltoap , fo;beiDa0ncijercaMeDtoanflDCC tbe crimes objcctco uueai pro 
 .ag<'.(t.ft bfm, but fs oepjftwo iiiftbout bearfngbf0 Defence, tobfcb fa fllcgal , cccd ng. 
 80 fefr lacncB Bapgs cafe f0. Roll chief luftice , be OOgbt tO be bearO Icbat Ocicncf. 
 bccoulofapfojbfmfelf, clfc boto coulo ft be fmoton \ijbctber tberc toerc 
 jult caufc to remote bfm 0; no, anoft fo tierp bato to oepjfbe one of bfa 
 frecbolotaitbout bearing bIm. 3t anotbcr oap fecr leant Twifden moteo 
 tbc Court foj tbJfr opfnfon, tubctbcr Bemar difton ougbt to be reSojcO oj 
 no, ano anfiBcreo tbc crceptfono fo:mcrlpta(ienmucbtotbc effcaa0 Latch 
 bao oonc. OTbcrcupou Roll chcr lufticc fafo , pou ougbt to babe conbcn< 
 teDbimbcfo;cponp(itl)fmont,tobear\o1;atercure be coulo make fo; bfa 
 abfcnce , otbcrtoffc bo\D coulo pou fenoto to'jctber f}C hao fnft caufc oj not foj 
 bfo abfcnce, ihccefore It him be reftored except canfe be fhewed to the '^*'^°'«<l>n'fi> 
 contrary Saturday next, Poftca» ^''^• 
 
 Edc
 
 448 
 
 Pafch. 1655. 
 
 Tryalin 
 Trelpifsand 
 Ejcftmenc. 
 Jury fuffc eJ 
 to drink ac 
 the Bar. 
 
 Fetfting of 
 luiies. 
 
 Fur a r.crt 
 tryal. 
 Death ol a 
 
 Wit lid's. 
 
 AA cf God. 
 
 Ntw tryal 
 paying cofts. 
 
 Edwards and ^'tiff. 
 
 Pafch. 1655. Banc fup» 
 
 MEmorandura, Vpon a tryal at the Bar in a Trcfpafi and EjeSment be- 
 tween CotoatDB Plaintif, and fetlff Defendant, the evidence being long 
 andthe Weathctbot, the Jury dtfircd they might have drink, which the 
 Court granted , but faid they ftiooild have it ac the Bar, whereupon drink 
 wasfent for for them , and they drunk it there before they went out to con- 
 fider of the evidence. lloU c^lcf Suftkc did then reprove the Attorneys 
 and Soliicitors for the great charges they ufed to put their Clyents to, in 
 feafting the Jury, and ordered diatthenccfortli nomorethon 3 $,4d. (hould 
 be allowed to any luryman to pay for his dinner, Nota* 
 
 Pafch . 1 6 5 5 . Banc. fup. 
 
 \; ipon an AfRdavit reao in Court, tbat a matetial toftnefTe fn tbc eanfe 
 tbat lias fcttjto tDftft a fubpoena to gJtjc Ifis teftfmonp at tl)e ttpal, ano 
 opcD before tbe trpal : 2Cbc Court teas tnotieD on t\)e SDefcnoants pait fo^ 
 anehitrpal, but t^e paint(f oppofcDft, mnc^ fnCOIns upon tlifa, ttiat 
 tfterctoaanomifcartlagc on hfa part: ^Ijetcnpon Roll chief luftite an-- 
 ftoercD, tiere ia ttie ^ct of C3od in the Cafe, toijicti cannot be ttUtten, sno tW 
 ttpal is final to the SDefenoant , %^tittoit if the Plaintif will not confent to 
 takehiicoitt, andgoetoanewtryal, we will not be baity to give judge* 
 ment, but will advife upon it. 
 
 The Protedor and Gunter. 
 
 Pafch. i6js. Banc, fup* 
 
 ToquaOi iWo T ^^ ^^^^^ ^^^ motjeD to qnaCb ttoo CEnoictmentfl foj continning of par* 
 Endiftments. *- pjcfturcs in tftc Ijijjb luap , ano it teas urgeo bp titie Conncel tbat t^ere 
 \otit4 (Enoittments pjefcrreo agsiiitt ^is Clpent, ttoo fo^ erecting t^e 
 pntpjcftures, ano tbc other ttso fo^ tbe continuing of tbent , ano upon a trp< 
 al tue tocrc founo not guiltp of tbe erecting tbem.ano tbercfoje tne cannot be 
 guiltp of ttte continuing of them , ano be tooU this exception to the caption of 
 tbe €nDictmcnts,viz. %Mt it is faio tbat tbe Cnbictmentd toere p^eferreo at 
 tbc Sefsions belt) at Eail-Grinfteed in the Conntp of Suffex , tobercit ougbt 
 tobatoebcenattbcfecfsions of t^e peace belo at Eaft-Grinfteed foj the 
 Coantp of Suifex. Roll chief lufticennftocreD, |0ou map be guiltp fo> con. 
 tinuing of that \xiWif anotbcr d(d erect . ano not pou , but if tbc ercaing ano 
 continuance be mcntioncD in one ano tbe fame Cncictment pon cannot be- 
 guiltp. But plead to them, for no fuch thing appears in the Record, but 
 only that you kept the Highway flopped, but fays not who flopped it. 
 
 Denied. 
 
 Pafch. 165 5. Banc. fup. 
 
 Tl^e Court tnas mobeb to quail) an C^nnictmcnt jS^ronnbeo upon t^e ^ta- 
 tnteof 5 Eliz»pjcferreDagaiiiaonefojnCngtl;e Crane of a 2)japet, 
 Endiftment, ttot bating f.tbeo 33 an Slppiientifc in that SCraoe, accojuing to tbe &ta= 
 tnte, upon tbefc 2 (Srceptions , i. 3t is faio be ufco the SCraDe in tbe peat 
 i^ j.anb Dot!) not fap t^e pear of out il ojo. zlp.'it is not faio tljat tt»e 3urp 
 
 teas
 
 'Fafcfi.i6 55« 449 
 
 iDastetarneo, tiojto^cncctftcp tocrc, anDbotfterceptfonstoerefjelDgooo 
 
 bp Roll chiefluftice , and the Endidmenc was thereupon quaflbed, Qu»(hed. 
 
 iparch. i65 5.Banc fup^ 
 
 T^^cCoarttoasjmotetJfoqtiaCjanenDfctmcnt aaaintt one Peers, fo> l^^^^^l^ 
 rpeal.fug p?ot)ol-.tns language to onc,contrarp to t\}t Idte £);Dfnantc of up"on thc'or- 
 tlje 3Lo;d |p;otECto;i ano ftfa Countcl, upon tt)efe €ircept(on0. 1 . Jt (sfafo dm^ncc a- 
 t^c CnDlctmcnt teas at tbe fecfcfons lielD at A, ano ootft not fap tn tobat e''"^ Duds. 
 Coontp. zip. 3t to fa(Dbpan£)jDfnanceof t^e p;ot£ttoj maoe facft a 
 Dap, anUDotb not fap<nt^at cafe pjobioeo. And upon chefe Exception! itQi«afhed. 
 was qaaflicdt 
 
 ^afch. 165 5- Sane. flip. 
 
 nr l^eContt traflittotjeo foj a tales to a Northumberland 3urp returnable For a tales, 
 
 tB<8 SCerm , becaufe but 8 of tbe panel rctnrncD dId app:ar. JBat Roll 
 chief laftice anftucteo , Take it returnable in Michaelmas Terra next, but Return of a 
 this Term you cannot have icv calcs. 
 
 VValdron and Ward. 
 
 Pafch,i554«Bancfup. 
 
 Ii^atrpalattl&ebatfactiBCcnWaldron pafntff, ano Ward ©cfcnftant, Tryai at Bir: 
 £)ne$p3.ConyeaCoantcllctattbc313atiDas eiraminci) upon bfa Bati}^ Counceiier 
 to pjotje the tcatft of &lr rhom^Conye. M^jetenpon Serjeant May nard '^,'1^': ^." 
 nrgeo to fjai-e l)f :n cramlncD on tbe otber part , as a tcftnefs fn fomc mat- mz^cffc " * 
 tcrstDbrrcofbcbaobeenmaoepjitipasofCounrcltntljecaufe. ISutRoll 
 chief luftice anftueteD , ^l fsnotboanDto mafee anftoet foj tWngs iDWc^Not toa.r 
 map Df fdofc tfte fcctets of W Clpcnts canfc, mt tljetcupon he was f orborn dofe a ci'yl 
 to be examined. cncscaufe. 
 
 (Pilkinton andBagfhaw. 
 
 PBfch,.i5j4. Banc. fup+ 
 
 V/'IPon a ttpal to be ^ao at tbe ISar befujcen Pilkington anO Bagfhaw, t^e .j-tvai „ t. ■. 
 pafntUteoulo not put in bis mit tftat the trpal mfgbt goc on ; Wi\3txZ: bJ. ' 
 upon Roll chief luaice Wd t^c Crper to caB tbe 3ttojnep of tbe plafnttf to 
 appear, ann to bjfng <n the tDjtt upon pain of 20 1. ano fa<D,tbat U Ijc bjoasbt^'*'" of" '. 
 ft not In be (bonlO be put out of tbC IRoU. Serjeant Maynard motJED, tbat If A""f"=y put 
 bebjougbtnotfntbetDjtttbattbe Iplalntff mfgbt be callen non futc upon^KoiL 
 tbc IRccojD , tublcb Roll chief luftice anftDcrefl mfgbt toeU be , becaufe the Non'fute up- 
 parties bate Dap in Court bptbc1ilcco?DojlIlofl; aftertoarog tbe &oUlcf»o°cheRecoi(i. 
 to% tubo ban tbe tojit bjougbt It In; pet Roll chief luifice falD, There 
 (hall, noiwichOanding the writ be brought in, be zo I, fine fet upon bim for 
 bis trifling with theCourtt 
 
 spmm The
 
 4 "JO 
 
 Pafch. 165 "J. 
 
 The Piotedor and 5umner. 
 
 Pafch, 1^54. Banc, fup» 
 
 To bail a nrl C, Erj^ ^nt Bernard inotCD tbat Sumner that appcarct) fii Court upon ljf0 ha- 
 foner dcnie.i "^''^as corpjs DtrCCtCD tO tl)C liocpctof Northampton ©aol itliQlt bc tallCO, 
 
 'fojtijntljaumsWUcDtVrio men upon tfte li^igfttoap tljc Jtirp Ijan founo It 
 
 span'flaugbtcrledefcndfndo, Koll chiet luflice anftocrcD , %[)z Juries 
 
 tonclufton ta contrarp to tbctr pjcmifco. Therefore let the priloner be fent to 
 
 T. yal. ipojtljamptonGaol whence he came,yet that naay not be,for the (ad was done 
 
 Writ aJ rfc'- m jpctctljojougb, and therefore he cannot be trycd at j^O^tljampton, there- 
 
 picndun'. fore let him be Icntto pctctbojounl) Gaol wiiha writaDrCCipfcnDtlrtl to the 
 
 Gaoler thereto tal;e charge of bim. 
 
 •Piikington verkis BagOiaw. . 
 
 Pafch, i65),Banc, fup. 
 
 T/Iia2Lrj'nlatt!)c5I5arlna Sttefpafs ano G-fcrtmcnt Orttofrt Pilkinfjton 
 ■^;)nd Bagfliaw , tl)c qucftfon bcfngit)fictbetCoppl)olDlanOg map be cntafU 
 CD bp tbc tufiom of tl)c ^inoj, 3t tuns fa(D that If S^cnant in tafl , ano tbc 
 <fruct:itaflofCoppbolDlanDsfntatl|opnfnaftjrrcnDcrfn a Court JBaton 
 oftlievEoppbolDlanDo, thattbfeKanotancftopcl, foj it ougbt to be by fine 
 ojDccQfncenteD. flno Roll chief lufticefafo, tbat Coppbolo lanDs fntafl 
 arc not toitlfn tbc &tat«tc of Weftm. 2. but ft Is a Cuftomarp entail ilbe In 
 Its nature to anotijrr entail, ano fad) an cftatcmuft be tochco bp fine, o> 
 bpfomeotbcrctiftomarptoap. 3ttoa3alfofatDbpl)lm,tb3t If Copies of 
 CourHRollsbelbcVDCOto pjotjc a Ciifiomarp cftatc, tbccnjopnmentof 
 -futftcftatcomuftalfobcpjotetJ, otbertDlfctbcpjooflsnot gooD, 3t toaa 
 • alfo falD upon t'e etilDcrcc,SEl)at a felfare bp tbello jo maoc ofCopp^olo en^ 
 talleD lanDs witbin tbc fpano j of Wiikefidd in Yoi kfliire is In tbc natatc of 
 a recolicrp to Deck tbe entail, anD that tbc manner of Doing It la citbet foj. 
 tbe CoppiiolDcr to let bis CoppbolD fo; mojc pears tban be ougbt , j to re* 
 fnfetotobfsfctbfcc, anDtbcntbcHojo fclfea tbclanos foj a fojfelture, 
 ano grants It to anotbcr bp tl)c tonfcnt of tbc Coppbolocr tbat maoc tbe fo> 
 felturc. 3!t toas tbcn alfo falo bp Roil chief luftice , tbat a Cuttom cannot 
 bcuracDfojatblngtbatbaoltsbcctrmlng Dncc Rich, tbe i. If a Heco?t» 
 can be fqctocD to tbc tontrnrp. 3t luas alfo falD bp btm tbat a common re. 
 to'ocrp fup' ofetb a rccompcncc In lialue to all pcrfons Irbo loft tbc cftatc bp 
 tbe rctotcrp. ^e falD alfo tbat be concclticD tbat tbcre coulD be no fucb 
 Coftom to cut off entails of Coppbolo lanos bp tbc fojfelture ana 
 fclfureoftbcJLojD, foj bis felfurc upon tbe forfeiture Dcftrops tbe Copp- 
 bolD cftatebp tbe Common iLalu, fojItlslntbel-ojDs eledfon after tbe 
 fclfurelDbctbcrbe tiill grant tbc cftatc again o: no , ano poii do not pjotoe 
 tbat tbc Cuftom bfnos b(m to It. Nota. 
 
 TrcrpiRard 
 Ejcftmeni. 
 
 Ettopfl. 
 t'opyl'.old 
 Jands ill (•!'. 
 Cuttonury 
 er.tji!. 
 Fine. 
 
 Siarc enjoy- 
 ed. 
 
 Scifure of C( 
 pyhold land.' 
 
 Cuftoni. 
 
 Common re- 
 covery. 
 Rccompenfc 
 iji valur,' 
 Curt m.' 
 Copyhold dc' 
 llioyed. 
 
 Harris
 
 Pafch.1655* 45 i 
 
 « — ■■ - - — 
 
 Harris and 
 
 Pafcb,i65T«Binc,fup, 
 
 T"|^cCoprttoasmol30a{nt5]e Cafe of one Harm, fljat t!jE tntrv of ajj -JIJ"? *" 
 -^ {nogcmcntttoeltie pea r0 pall mfffinbcamcnDett npon tfje !Roll/ Batmenr. ' 
 Roll chiicf mftice anftseteo , it cannot be after fo long time paft. Denied. 
 
 Pafch. i^5 5.Banc. fup. 
 
 V^on a tojft of Ctto; bjoagfet to'retjetfe a fine letf eo bp an Slrtfanf be. ^*y '° '"- 
 f ng a |«^cm0 Coljert. SCbe Court toaa motjeo foj a oap to bjing in t^je ['"^ *" ^"* 
 pattp tbat Ictfeo tlje ine to be infjiectcD bp tf)c Court , to^fcfj toaa granteo, 
 ono at t^eoapfljeiDaabjousbttntotfj: Court, anotfciDcD, ano ttoo toft= 
 ncffea oepofeB tftat Oje toaa tottWn age at t^e tfme of tl)e fine leWco, taW^ ^""J T'^ 
 toaa entteo apon t^c Ifloll , ttpon iDtrfcfj tlje 3lffqe toaa ttpcD* '"' ^''"* 
 
 Pafch. 16 5 J Banc. Cup. 
 
 TCtoas fafo bp Roll chief luftice , El&at ff tfjere be ttoo Sfnfmen fn equal Euaion; 
 -» Degree of bfno^eo to tbc gntcttate , tt fa fn ti^e elcitfon of t^e £) jofnarp to 
 toWctj of t^em $e afll grant JLetteraof ^aomfntftratfont 
 
 •Pafc^. 1655. Banc. fup. 
 
 ^ ^ntlatojp toaa reterfeo, bccaafe tlje place to^ere tljc Connfp outlawry re^ 
 Court toaa ^elo fa not Cbetoeo In t^e fccundo exaftuj, verfcd. 
 
 A 
 
 Pafch. 1655- Bailc. fup. 
 
 tC toaa motCB tbat tbcrc toad a jutjgemcnt gftcn f n tbe Common peaa, t° **f™ • 
 
 •^ ano thereupon tfteSDefenuantbjoagfjt Wa fojft of (Jrro; to tcterfc tlje |;';!f *™'eJ "or 
 
 JttOgem6nt{ntW0ConTt,antiCnccpcnDfngt&eto?ft of Grroj t\)c partfca depending. ' 
 
 toere agraco , ano t^crefo?e t^cp ocCrco tbc inogement mfgl)t be affirmco', 
 
 betaufctljat otfjertotfe fatfafactfon of tfic fuogcment cannot be acknotoleo* 
 
 geo upon t^c1iloB,becanfet!je Court of Common pcaatocrc fojdofcD to 
 
 BO anp tl)lnf farther upon tfte Jnogement gffecn tl)erc bp rcafon of tfic tojft Denied. , 
 
 Of€rroj, J6tJt Roll chief luftice anftoereB , It cannot be, foj ponfljctp 
 
 itocaBfetoftp.tocfljouto affirm tljelnugement, anotl)ctcfoje we will make 
 
 no rule in it, but enter fatfafactfon upon tIjeKoU ff pon totll at pour otoit 
 
 pertl. 
 
 •Pafch. 1655. Banc- fup. 
 
 ISTtoPsfafobpRoU diieflufticctljatan Sctfon npon t!)e cafe tofH Ife a-Aaionuponi 
 gafntt one ttiat b?tnga tcratfoua actfons agafntt anotlier, o: fo; enfrfna of'*" ^'^* '"^ • 
 atffona of a great talue, to fojC£ fjfa aoberfarpto put in great bafl,to?jcte 58 vexition. 
 i)attibutfmaUcanreof;9(tion. Noca. / 
 
 ^mmi Trt^
 
 4^2 Pafch. i6$5- 
 
 ' Trevanian and 'Penhollow. 
 
 Trin. itfjj, 
 
 Pka to in 'TRcvauian bjoogftt an 3ctfon apon tbc cafe acainS Penhollow foj I|?eafe- 
 
 and art faUe f orfworn. SLbc ISDefenDant pleaDs tbat tl)e pia<nt(f ^ai> agtoeii 
 
 to accept of 3 Suggs of i^cct from Wm fn ratisfactlon. S^be pafntff 6c« 
 
 Demurrer. niutTCD to tl)c plca,anD fo} caufc ftclDs tijat ft Dotb not appear tbat Hie tjjjce 
 
 ludgcment. ^UCS" Of IBect jBCtc {)a<D oj tEnD^cD bp tlje a?efcnijant ; ano npon tWs ep 
 
 Ceptfon judgement was given for the Piaincif, &c. 
 
 MEmorandum, Trinity Terra 165 5 beginning the 1 5 of June being Fri» 
 day %attke 30b late alone in the Court of the Vpper Bench , being 
 then the foleIud(jc there, Thclate Lord t^lcf 3nft<ce IRoll having furren* 
 dred hii Patent the Tucfdayfeventghc before, being the ; of lane, at I was 
 enformedt 
 
 MEmorandam, Afterwards the fahnc day 3Ioi)n ©Ipn his Highneds the 
 Lord Proteftor$ Serjeant at Law took bit place of Lord chief lufVicc of 
 CnglanD in this Court, and the Lord ILifle one of the Lords CommiGioncrs 
 of the great Seal of(l!;nglanO made a Speech unto him, according to tbeCu- 
 (lom , and &er)eant ^tof foen moved for a tryal at the Bar the next Michael* 
 mas Term, which was granted, nifi, &c. 
 
 • 
 
 The 'Procedor and the Town of Colchcfter. 
 
 Pafch. and Trin» 1655. BanCtfop; 
 
 VJBon a Mandamus to tljclBafUfs of Colchefter to rcffoje Bernardifton 
 . c.u. M ., - *" t^^ JRecojDcrfl plate of t^at 2i:oiDn,apon m tcttirn tftc pccrtffito tbc 
 
 Mtndilru 'i< caufcB fo> remotjfng Um , ano tohp be ougbt not to be rettojeo. 1. SChat 
 thcTo»<'n.f oneGoodallbefngciiDictcD upon the fetatute foj batfng ttoo tofbea, antt 
 CoU-heftcr. contlctcn thereof D(Dp;apt)fsClcrgp, ano teas refufeo Itbp Bernardiflon, 
 ano U)a0 concemncD to Die , ano after at another ^efsiona he aomfttcD bint 
 to bis Clergp , ano fo be loaij burnt f n the bano. zip. 2Cbat be negUcteo to 
 Ctattbe&cf0(on6, itbctebptbe&efafons fojtbeSLolonconlo not bebclo 
 outp aatbcp ongbt to bate been. 3IP. 2bbat be appofntro a Dcputp iR.Ct 
 cojoet to ctetntc bis place fo; bfm,\ubo Ujas not an utter JBaircfter,anD con- 
 tracted toftti bfnt fo; 40 1. per annum. 4lp. Xbatb^ neglecteo tp bolo Conttd 
 Irbercbptanfeecoulonot fcc trfeo, to the pjcjuoice of manp. Latch of 
 CouncBl toft^ Bsrnardifton to tbc firft taufc anftoetcD , SCbat altbougb ft 
 toaa an Ctro; fn BIuDgement to ncnp the CUrgp tobcrc ft Hjoulo babe been 
 grnrteo ; pettlifslraonotcommfttcDnsbetoaglRccoiDerof tbc Coton, 
 but ea a Commfrdfoner of Oyer ano Terminer , tobfcb tuaa to en« 
 Dure but fo; a pear, ano tens a offtfntt potacr from bfs poloct as be toas He- 
 cojner, aiio cpecnteo bp t)fm, Itftbotherdommifsfoncrstbat lucre jopneo 
 toftb bfm f n Commtfsfon. SCo the fccono be aufu'crco, that bere ootb not 
 appear to be anp p;ejaDfcc to anp bp bis not bclDfng tbc iD^fsfons , no; tbat 
 tbere loap any canfe to bc!D tbr«. ano befJocs, Itcotb appear, tbat tbe 
 *** I^ef0<on0 tobcre be ncgleaco to fit toerenot legallpappofntco to bebclo, 
 
 ti>% t^sv toetc appofnteo bp tbcm tbat tab no aiitbo;ftp to do ft, viz.
 
 Pafch. 1655. 453 
 
 bp Vit cpaioj aiiD IBapIffg, {xtlitnas t^cp ouc^t to be appofnteo bp 
 tbe^aio;, IBapUfs.sz^oUcco^ocr; ano ncpt tbe Bufifcesatemfr nameo, 
 fo? ti)tp are calico tbcSuftfceo of ttc IBoioiirlj, Irljercag ttjep ougbt to be 
 CElIcu tl)c 5iiClcc0 of tJ)C iamg. 4!?. ^^erE cotb not appear anpappofnt= 
 mcRtat alioftbefEitiavtct ferfsfons; E^otbe jD.be anfi^cteo, ttjatftts 
 not necrSarp tbat b~ fljou'.o appofnt a JBatrcfter to bcSDcpntpHccojnrr, 
 ano to fap fbat be toaa not fit to be Dcputp IRecojoet fs too general a 
 cbargc. tut ft oucbt to be IbciixD fn itbat be toas unfit . anu bfs contraafng 
 toftb bfm {0? raoiiptonccrnsnottbeCopojatfon, neftberfsft maluminfe, 
 bttt is cr.lp punffljable bp tbc Statute of 5 Ed. 6. Sinn as to tbc laft, viz, 
 tf0 nrclcdfi.r; to^trp tbc tffi:co fopneo at tte oafcc appotntcD ft fa not a crfme 
 matcrtnl to c cpjttc Vim of bf o free tolo, ano feto fetctoaros 00 otbcrtnafeo, 
 foi tbcp 00 ufuallp ffap tftl tbep bafe a competent nnmber of Caufcs to 
 ttp, befo;8 tbcp irUf Ct ; ano berc are bat Of caafes allcgcD to be antrpeo, 
 ano one of tbcmtoao not trpablefntbat place, nojfsftabcrreo, tbatbeban 
 notfcc Qiben b(ni of anp iSate tobetrpeo, ano fo tbe offence is tbe ltt9i 
 % Rep. Seraaiones cafc , no? ootb <t appear, tbat anp trpal toasi olfappofnteo 
 bp btsabfcnce, fo; <t appears not tbat tbcretnas anp fffuea )opncD, ojanp 
 toatnfng gfben foj trpal fn anp of tbe daufcg Dnrfng tbe tfme allcgen, 
 &»berefn(tf0fafDbeoiofo:bearto fittotrptbem. iiattlp, bere fgnotnS 
 tnap of p^oceeofng to ocp;ifte b(m of b<9 place tbongb bem<gbtbeDcp?f- 
 teo, fo;i be toas nebcr futnmoneo to appear to anftoct tbe matters objectcD 
 againft b<m, as be ougbt to bate been, ano fo ta Cook fnS^fr James Eaggs 
 cafe. Sergeant Giyn on tbe fame fioc fnfiSco onlp npon tbe laft matter ur- 
 geo bp Litch , tob<cb be fafo iccnt tb;otigb tbc lobole Cafe. Roll chief Ju= 
 fticc, ^t onsbt to bate been bearo, boaietfccanftfcebnotDntDbetbertbep 
 |a& itiftccnfe to remote bfmo;^ not, anoitfoterpbarotooep^fteoneofbfd 
 freebolo iBftbout bcarfnp hfm mahc b's ocferce. SDbe Coart teas motett 
 at aiiotbec oapfojtbt^ropdifon, ano tbcn Sergeant Twifden cnocatoiireo 
 to anfircr fome ctccptions tahen totbercto^nbp Windham, ano to mat;e 
 gem tbe c);ceptton0 tahcn agafnS Bernardidon, mucb to tbe fame effect as 
 fojmcrlp. Whertupon Roll chief Juftice ar.ftoer£0,pon cofbt tobatecon- 
 tjcntco biui bcfo:c poo bao pptbfm ont, tbat pon mfgljt bate bearO tobat tv 
 cufe be ronlD maHe fo; bis abfence, elfe bo to can ft be UnoU)n,\iibetbcr be bat) 
 a jnflcaufeof abfcnceotnot. Thcrebre let b m bercftored, nifi,&c. 3tano- iuJgemtnr 
 tberoap, being fn Trinity SCcrm i65 5.&ergeantMaynard Cbctocofojcaafeniii. 
 tDbpbcoiigbtnottobercltojcD, 1. jlljat bebclonottbeCConrtsoulp, but 
 filD abfent blmfelf loj fij;tcen montbs3, toftbont anp caufe,to tbc enoangcrfng 
 of tbc foifeftarc of tbc Cbatter of 5be STcten, ano fafo, tbat ft" an £)rficcr of 
 BRccoio 00 toilfullp ano loltbont caufc abfent blaifclf from b's £>lfice, ft fa a 
 fbjfclfure tbcrcof, fojbpfoootngtbeCbarter f0fojfcfteD,anDbire fs no Forfeiture of 
 fappoCtfon 0? anp ctcufe. ilp.- 2Ebereto:n fs gooo, tbougb no notice Iras m office, 
 gttcn blm, fo J be ougbt to tabe notfcc of blmfelf as be Is an £)fficcr of tbat 
 Court, ano enola him tbep cannot, ano If bis offence be true dc fafto tbep 
 map put blm outofblsplace, asa^aflermappututDapbls&ertant, ano 
 tbfs tbcfr Cbartcr U.arrants tbcm to 00 Twiidcn on ttje fame fioe fafo, 
 be batb contractcD luify anctbcr foi bis place , ano fo fs offableo bp tbc Sta- 
 tute. Wild , ^c coulD not uc bere contenteo, foj It fs crpjcflp fafo , tbat 
 be tocnttounUroUji places. Glyn chief lufticc,2Ebc mafnbaCncfslnCfteD 
 on teas bis ?bfctice but bere teas ro notice nftcntoblm, anopouougbt 
 not to pjoceeo agatr.Ct Mm, ano iicter bear blm,tbougb tbc crime obietteo a- 
 galnft blm be true,fo? It map be be irns ficb oi bao fome otbcr (uft ercufe fo; 
 bis abfence, ano be ougbtalfoto bcb^arDtoalltbc otbir crimes objccteo 
 agalnft blm. Therefore let him be reRored, nifi, &c. to morrow, lu.igement 
 
 , • nfi. 
 
 spmms Howard
 
 454__ Trin. 165 5. 
 
 Howard and Howard. 
 
 Trin. 1655. Banc. fup. 
 
 I'cerate pic - \Ji P ^'"3'^ [joward bciog tflUcM bp a Latitat out Of tl)fs Coutt appeatea 
 
 Jed, ' iVl"Pontl)c Dap oftbctctojnoftt)c©ar{tiii Court, ano pleaDcD Ws p;<. 
 
 Wlegc of PiitasEj ano ucmaiios In juDgcmcnt of tljc 2Eldt, anu tljcreupon 
 
 to be DUc^argcD. PowisofCouncclagafntt^fmmotcD, tbatbemigbt put 
 
 ^*^'; ^ (n fpc£<al bapl. ClynchicfIuflicc,You ought to demur to his Plea, tor hen 
 
 cii urrer. ^^^ ^^^ CuftODfa, and therefore be need not put in bayl, Nota» 
 
 The Protedorand Norrice. 
 
 Trin. idjj.Banc, fup. 
 
 To difchirgc K'Orrice bcftig tommfttcotopjffoiifoi fpcakfngtDojDs agafntt tbe ^at* 
 
 a Piifoncr J^\j lament in tbc pear 1650. toastbcreupon cnufctcD , ano toaaconWcteo 
 
 "robhvion ^"° S"*° ^^°^- ^""^ o;DcteDtolp£(np;{fontuit<U!)C£oulD fino &urettca 
 
 foi W« gmo bctjabfout ; aftertoarosbcVoasbjounW Into Court bpDcttuc of 
 
 a Habeas Corpus, ano b(3 Counccl mo'tttD on Ijts behalf that tje mtght be off- 
 
 t^argcD, becaufe 1)2 'imflparDoncDfaptlje^ctofiiDbUbion. 31 u.a3urgco 
 
 againft t^s fo; t^c ^;otctto;, ti)at he map be a perron erceptcD ont of tbs 
 
 Surmhc. jSltf , ono tbetefoje oagbt not upon this furmlfc to be oeUbetcD, Glyn 
 
 chief iufticc, 3it Doth not appear tousthatbclflnotcrceptcD , ano t^ete* 
 
 foie toe cannot DcUbct Woi. 2Lhcrcupon (t tDasir.o\jcDfojthep;<fonet 
 
 Certiorari, foj a Certiorari to rcttiobc the lA^cojt) httbcr, tohcrcbp hcttant)3con^<ctr3, 
 
 tilt. y. tbat bfc m(0l;t enter the fuggeCton upon tt, that Ijc is patDoneo bp tbe ^tt. 
 
 Glyn chief luilice, Takeitt 
 
 Wcbberly and >S"!r John Lenchall. 
 
 ff 
 
 Trin, 1655. Banc, fup. 
 
 Motion a. 'T^^^c Courf fosfl motteo fo: W(bber!y agafnff &fr lohn Lenthall , tbat 
 
 giinft Sir A tohrrcas he be<ng a p-Jfcncr in the OpperlBcnci) pjffon fo: SDcbt, 
 
 tiuH fo?dc- ^"^ &a^<ng agreco tofth hfs Crcoftois tone tffchargeo bp them, pet S)(r lohn 
 
 taininj; a Lenthall DfD Ucep bfm pjffoncr tHI be OjoulO paphfm Aflion mony. Glyn 
 
 Prifoncrdif- chief I'uftice, |9ou hate ttoorcmcDfcsagafnft&fr lohn Lenthall fojthte, fo;. 
 
 charged. either pou map bjfng pour Qttlon of falfc fmp:(ronment aaat.ifl hfm, oj pou 
 
 Falfe"impr1-" ^^^ '^""^'^ ^^" f"' ^^'^t^^^**'"' Yet let Sir'Sobu Oiew caufe why he ftiouli 
 
 fo.imenr. Dot d'fthargc him paying his Fees. 
 
 Endictmcnr. 
 
 Scrowd and Kcckwich. 
 
 Trin,*j<J55, Banc, fup, 
 
 Mich. i653,rot« 119, 
 
 AudlcaqiiCiC-QTrowd b?,OU£bt diX Audita quereii agaftltt Keckwith; SCfjC Cafe teas 
 
 '». ■ i^JtU^a, Strowd atbnotolcBgeD a Suogcment 1 7 Car. foj 2000 1. upon tDtifcfu 
 
 3ut)gement an Eleqit toag tahcn fojth agafnft Strowds lanoo in tbe Co jntp 
 
 of B, ano lanoa tJjereapon toerc fotino ano crtcnDjB , ano ocUbctcD to the 
 
 Co«
 
 Pafch. 11^55. 455 
 
 Conafee , ano tbe Elegit filen , aim t^c lanos enjopcD accojofnglp fojCi; 
 pears, tften tfte Conu'"EE c<es3 anD mafecs ^{a toffe Crecatrfj:, tobo tabes oat 
 a Scire facias upon tbc JuDgmcitt foj 2000 I. Dfrcdco tbc S)l)erff ot tljc (Zoixn-- 
 tp of C. being another Couiitp.a.tc upon tiooNichilstctojncD ^atbJuDg- 
 ntent anD epecutfon agafnft Strowd foi ftje fame SDebt, Uubo tljercupon 
 bjfngs bfa Audita querela. Wadham Wmdb3ml)t'l0, tljat tI)C Audita que- 
 rela 'ofD Ipe, ano cftcft 15 H 7. 7. &L Q,.f.4o. ano fafo tftfs teas an 
 fl'iCgalpjocccDfngasatnftStrowd, becaufc tftat after an Elegit cicctutCD no 
 ottjer crecutfen Ues, but toberc tljere tjatb been no cjetntfon of lanos fn tbc g ec • 
 fame Cotmtpo; in another upon tbcfirft Elegit, but6crc(3lanDfouno,ano ^ """"" 
 tbe Elegit filCD,anDtbelar,Ds5cn|opeD, 1 8 E. 12. Fitzh. tit. Execution 240, ^^'^g'tfodi. 
 Dyer 1 5a an Elegit map be pjapcD to Dfbers Counties. Glyn chier luftice, ^7" ^°"'^'" 
 %\it Cafe is atJiuDgeD fn Hcbards llepo^ts, tfjat one cannot fjatjc an Elegit N^EiceTt af 
 after a fojmcr Elegit, if lanng be tbcrebpfouno, anntbe Elegit filcD. Tbercfr ^nHcgir. 
 fore (hew caufc why judgement fhall not be given for the Plaintif, luJgcment. 
 
 Price and Cair. 
 
 HilK i6J4.Banc, fup. 
 
 PRice bjongbt an 0ftlon npon t^e Cafe againff Carr (0% fpcaking tbefe ^''^^ °^ 
 too JDS Ofl}cr, A pox upon you for a Welih whore, for thou wenteftinto ^^''la'^oT '" 
 the Coan-ry and emptiedft thy Cask of a Baftard. 3ftcr a fecrtif £t foj tfte fhe Cafc fo" 
 pialntif it toas motet) in arrEff.cf guDcemcut, t'M tbe fo?met toojDs .vords. 
 videlicet, tbc f plug fljc teas a VVelfli Whore arc rot atffonable, bt» 
 tanfc no Action Ipes attfjc Common lata foj calling a Uioman ^bo?e, 
 ano tbe laft toojDs arc uncertain too?,03, anD Icfs actionable* rhe 
 Judgement was then ft.iyeJ till the Plaintif fhould move, SlSbcreupon 
 at anot*ict nap tlj: piaintif mobco foj luDgcmcnt , ano a €a{cin 17 lac» 
 fn tbis Court toas citeo, ano 41 Eliz. Wheeler ann AbigaU cafc.anD it teas 
 urgcD, tljat tbc too;Ds fljall be interpjctcD atcojsing to common intention 
 ano unocrttanoing of tbe bearers, anofbaUbcaciuoeco berpfcanoalctw. 
 Wild on tbe otbcr (lac "^alDjtbcp arc frlnolous tuojss anD not to be reuarocn, 
 fpj tbep 00 not fap poCtitcIp Ojc Is a tisabo je, noj ttat tbe bao a i3attari),but 
 tbe toojos are of a tcrp uncertain meaning, fo; ft appears not tol:cn tbc 
 iDOjos tocre fpofecn , oj toben fte ii-.cnt into tbc Countrp, no? is tbcre anp 
 abetment tobat is meant bp tijc tcojos. Glyn chief inflice, j^Jolo 
 Cncc tbc 3ct, tbc calling of a tooman Mboic, ano faping (be bao a ^^°['^* »^'«": 
 JBattaro toiH bear an action, ano bere arc toojos certain cnougb"* * 
 to 6v a particular ^canoal upon tbe partp , bp application of tbe 
 iDOjDs, ano tbep are maoc moje tban general toojos oj too?Dsofbfat 
 ano pafsion . foj tbcre is a general application of tbcm , ano a fuf- 
 ficicnt auerment, ano foj tbe time of fpcabing tbem toe toill not 
 pjefume tbep tocrc fpokcn four pears Snce, toblcb toas bcfojc tbe late 
 statute maoc agafnft ^Oultcrp, Therefore let the Plaintif have her ^^'^g""="-» 
 ludgement. 
 
 Davis and Matthews. 
 
 . Pafcbt 155;. Banc, fup* 
 
 '~r^z Cafe toas tbts, snberc being a controlicrfic In tbc JpJcrogatibeRondpat in 
 
 Court bettoeen ti;c OTIcoto of one tbat olco Inteftate, ano one of tbe in= Huc in the 
 f«ftatC0 ncjt Klnojco, tebolbonlo batie Jlcttcrs ol jaominlff ration of tbc'' "^i!«ive 
 
 eoios^'"^^-
 
 45^ Trin.1655. 
 
 goooB ano «Il)attcls oC t^e Sntcttatc, 3it teaa at Icngtlj agrceo bctfajijt tftc 
 
 patties, tl)attl)cu<DO\i)ft)oiUcifiatic iLettcrs of aDnifnlttratfoii, ano tijat 
 tl)Cteupon lt)E ttjoulD enter into SBono in tbc pjcrogatibe £)face , to make 
 ancqualDlttributtonoftljcgootisanocftattclaoftbe intcftate amongtt lji» 
 UiiiDjeD , Vubcrcopon ILtttcrs of ^DminiQration U)crc tommittcD unto f)cr t 
 ano ftcafta\uarD3 entree into bono accojoinglp , ano foj not pcrfojming 
 t^e conoltton ot tbc bono in making an equal oiftribiitfon of tfjc cftate.tlje 
 Prohib.tion. i,o„Q ijjag put tn fute in tl)c picrogatiVje Court , upon luljkb a prohibition 
 toaapjaie") ansa rule thereupon inaoefojiijc E^efenDant to (tjeU) caufe 
 totjpitftoulDnet bcflrantco,an3att^cDapit iDasofferco foj taufc tbat 
 tl)cre ougbt to be no pjoWbition, bccaufe tD^ecc an nomfnillration ia grant- 
 CD to ore unto U3!)om tbe ©iDinarp is not bounD bp tbe Statute to grant it , 
 as tt tain tbis cafe, tberetl)e£D?oinarpmaptakeabono oftftepartp. toitb 
 conoition to make an equal ciftributionof tbe gooos; but otfjertoife it is 
 iD&crclLettfersofaDmfniftrationarcgranteDto one to tol)oin bp ttie Sta- 
 tute tt)cp oual)t to be granteo, ano one Sharp »nd sympfan? cafe 14 lac toaa 
 Ordinary. ((tcD, auo Hob. i9i,£);i ti)C ot()erfioe it luas urge9tl)attl)c £)jDinarpl)atl| 
 no autliojitp to take fuel) a bonu for flje equal offtribution of tbe gooas , ano 
 tbe Difference put on tbe otl)cr fine toas Dcnico , ano it luaa faio, tbat tuben 
 tbe £)jDtnarpbati) once com.'inttcD tbe ilettcro of jaomiiiiaration to tbe 
 P)v»er ticicr- pattp , btspotoer (s tben DetcrmfncD , ano be cannot grant Letters of Sin- 
 "''"■'='^- . miftv^'tion upon ConDltfon. Giynchief luftice,2Lbc taking of tbe 3IBonD fa 
 o^u'on coi aaaintttbcstatutc, fojtl)3ti3ffeougbttobep;cfctrcD befojc tbe neit of 
 di"ion. ""' tbe Iiin.notVuitbftanDing tbe §jtatute,anD fo is tbe common pjattfcc , cj- 
 ccpttbcrcbeafpcctalcaufefojtbeconttarp, astot^cretbe toife batb ban a 
 „ ,... ■ foimerp?otition mace foj bet bp-bct busbano, &c, Ttierefore I« there 
 gtanied. be 3 prohibition, nilu 
 
 Trin. 1 6 5 5 • Banc. fup. 
 
 To difcharge 
 a Guardiau. 
 
 *7 ^z Court fcoas mo\)eD on t^c behalf of an Infant f Df fcbargc a 0«arbf-' 
 
 ^ an afgfgncD bp tbe Court, toitb an intent to make Richard Somers Sit- 
 
 lojncp of this Court OuarDian in bis room , ano tbat tbe fojmcr fn» 
 
 infpeftion fpeCton map be DiftbargcD , anD tbat tbe infant map b? nolo {nfpeaeD a- 
 
 ' cafn, lecaufetobcntbefojmerinrpeflfontoasanDtbcdDuarofanafsfgneD, 
 
 tberetcasnoaafonDepenDing in Court againtt tbe 3nfant. Glyn chief 
 
 loftice, Lee ic be fo for the caufe you have allegpd, and give notice of it to 
 
 the former Guardian 
 
 Sherlock. 
 
 Trin. i(555.Banc. fup. 
 
 rot. 1320, OF '3J5» 
 
 Oj^eSherelocka WlDotDoftbe^Daifil) of Earth in Suflcx, anBInfanf, 
 b?onabt tojit of C-rrojtoret)crfe a fine IcticD bp ber of bet lanoa 
 verfc'a rinT lubilft fljcUjas 8 Cotjcrt HBaron, ano tbe Court toas moteo tbat Ojc miglt 
 ftatcaCDuarDianafsigncDbertopiofccutcfojbcr, anD tbat flje migbt be Uu 
 T nfpcaion. fpcrtcD bp tbe Court , ano tbat tbe infpcrtion might be recoiDCD ; ftnD tbcrc 
 toas an Affidavit maDc bp one in Court, tbat be kncto tbe infant tobo teas 
 tbcre pjefcnt , ano tbe time of ber fairtb ano baptising, nuD ftooje tbe times 
 piECffelp; tbcCbutcbboU teas alfo pjoouccD.in Court, ano p;oteD bg 
 
 ;©attj ,
 
 Trin.1655. 457 
 
 i&«t6 , toftetefn tfte time of ber bapfijtiig Uiaa cntreo , anD tljat ftc toaa tlje " 
 
 fame petfon upon to^ict) flie Ijao bp bet oton clettton Atrwood an attojneg 
 of tbfsCoutt afsignco fo; bcr Guarofan, ann tbc Affidavits toere ojocreu bp Guardian af- 
 tbe Court to be tccojwo , ano tbc infpcaion to be entrcD , ano a Icire facias %ncd. 
 aU)atocDaga(nfttljc!>e<rt tnciy. 
 
 TheTrotedorand CraFoid^ 
 
 .Titn, 1655. Banc, fup. ^_ 
 
 'W JSon a return of a Mandamus DfrcrtcD to tbc a?ittcr ann iFeBofco 6tA Mmdamut 
 Gonvile ano Cayui ColUDcc fn Cambridge, to rcCojc one to an"° "^""'^"''e 
 tatbera place of a i^ rcc=rcbool f 11 Cambridge, of \s:,kii tbep are bfCtcta, Kt '? "" "''" " 
 loas ejiceptcD agati.tt ft , tbattb^pljaDnotftetocotbattbcpbaa anp autbo«F'rec'!f"hooi 
 rttp to oepjftjc tbe pattp of bis place ; ilno 2lp. 3t ooti) not appsar tbat tbep and the k-' 
 gabebtnt anp notice of tbeftpjocceofnos agafnft btm, tobetebp be mtgbt '""^ ""^ «- 
 pjcpatctooefcnDbimfclf. Serjeant Tw fjen maoc qatftfon tobetber a"P5J'^"V° ■'• 
 Mandamus DtoUc in tbi0 cafe, betaufe a&cbooImatt:rBplacefa a tempojal ^oticc"^' 
 £).fice, ano an iiaion at tb; Slab) Iks fo? tbc partp to recobcr <t, ano tbere« Aaion « 
 fo^ettfeamaaMandanaus, tobfcb feast erttaojoinarp conrfe oiigbt not to Law. 
 be grantcD , ano be tfteo 8 AfT. ano ©ft lames Bags cafe, am Dyer 209. ano txtraordin*- 
 faiB ft (0 not Ube an £Dffite Icftbout fee. latch on tbc otbct fioc anftocrco '^ '"'''^** 
 2Ebe Mandamus is aUolccD 8lrcaDp,anD tbe legalttp of ft is not noto to be eif- 
 putco , ano &it lames Bags cafe in not repugnant to t'bfs cafe ^ fo; tbfd is a 
 jjublfquc office, ano not a pjttiate , ant tcnos macb to tbe publfque gcoo, ano office puf - 
 la Ifbc to tbe cafe of an jaiDetman, 01 #reeman of a Cojpo?atfon, oj a 1 quc.pfiv^cc. 
 5^cUoiDofaCoUege» Glynchicfiuftice, 3 Mandamus to rcttojc one to 
 a CburcbtDatocns place batb been aojuugcD geoo. 3t fa tru: tbat fo j a pjf* 
 tate office a tojft of reflftutfon Dotb not Ife , but f f tbc publfque be concern- 
 CD fn tbe office ft Dotb He ; ano tbougb ft be an office toftb a fee belongfng to 
 (t , that mafeco no nfffercnce ; foj a Kecojocra plate fa an office Ujftb a fee, 
 ann pet a tojft of rtttftutfon Uca foj ft ; JlBut ft appeara berc tbat tbe' 
 fetboolmaaer batb mucb abufcu bf mfclf , ano tbcrcfojc we will adviie. Sit Z^'l-o^ '^'^' 
 anotbcr cap tbfa cafe toaa mofeco agafn . ano tbcn Glyn chiefiuflice fafo , 3 office°"":rh 
 Dpubt tobetbcr a Mandamus Dotb lie fn tbfa cafe, fo;t ft Ifea not foj etcrp jnd niduut a 
 tahfng atoap of a mana frecbolo , aa fn tbc cafes of a toecpcr of a iparb, o% ^,"- , 
 a&tetoarotbfpof aCourtlBaroii. Wild qucftfoneoto Vobom tbc Manda- Fr^h"'-]"" 
 mus coulD be bcre ofrectcD , fo? be fafo tbat tbe j^aftcr ano i^eUotoa are no '" '° ' 
 Co?po;atfon; ano be cftcD Boremans cafe of tbe ^ioole fiCcmplc, tobo corporation 
 pjapeo a Mandamus to be tefiojct to tbat focfctp, tobcrc ft inaa belD tbat tbe ' "»«» "t 
 Snnca of Court are not Co?po?atfon3,bHt onlp tolnntarp focfetfea. Larch ^""^ ^y^"^- 
 on tbe otbcrfioe fafo tbat ft luaaterp pjopcr to bate a Mandamns in tbfs'"^^"*^'*''"' 
 cafe, fo; ft fa a publfque office, ano not a p;f\}ate, aa a igcepcra place of 
 a^Dark, ojafetetnaroaplaceofa jpanojarc; anoa&tcUjaro of a Court '"^''^''''■'*^''"« 
 Jlcct fa a publfque £)ffic:r: ;anO tbfa Court batb lurfaofflfon^to rcfojm all 
 orfetianccB of tbfa nature, anotofeecp otbct lutfaoicttona fn gooa ojoer , 
 tbat tbep 00 not fntrencb one upon anotbcr ,f bcre fa no Offiter to lobom tbe 
 partp rtiap appeal , ano ft toere tjerp unrcafonablc to leate bf>n Uftbout 
 temepp, ano Mandamuffei bate been gtantco foj placco of Icfaconfc- 
 quence tbantbfa aafn Paich, 2 Car. a Mandamus toaa grantco to rcftojc 
 one to tbe place of a SCovon Clarh , ubfcb fa a pjftatc office , ano 19 lac. a 
 Mandamus toaa gtanteo to reftoje one to a common ClarKe place of a afU, 
 ano s Car, ano 18 Car, to reftojc tbe partfea to parfUj Clarbo placea. 
 0no Utbe plats be publfque tbfa Court totli not Icatc tbc partp to feck bfa 
 
 i?nn ' rcOTf'
 
 4^S^ '^rin- 1655. 
 
 mntop at lUito , anu 3!i»ctman Pflwickscafe fa tocU knofem, telio toa» 
 rrCo?rD to tlje place ofa Common Courcel man of London, auo here tbc 
 
 iinpioyment partp^afi mi imploptitent foi Mo Uic,tliotirfe^cbatJC nota free^lD (n U, 
 
 foe lite. ano tljEtc is a fctlco picfit accrumg to btm , ano fo pjapea ft; vti^.x be rc- 
 ttojcD. Wild on tbc otljcr fine ftclD,tl)at a Mand arnns IfcB not irt tb<d cafe , 
 anofafo , tbJo caic Differs frointbc cafes put on tbc otljcr &DC; foj t^c 
 fecbmlmafter, tl)Oiigbl)el)at)cafrcel)olo, pctU(6 bat durante bencplacito. 
 
 Durante be- g^^ ^^ ^^ ^^^ j^yd^ ,,0 ^^ ^^ ^^gn a frrttant , anu in all tbc cafes pat on tbe o. 
 
 nephoto. jijp^fj^p the pab'.fquefsmojecoiitcrncDtbantntWs cafe 11H.4, f. 47, a 
 fethoolmaft^r batbnofrctljolDaBSkrecnthctelielo, anu <t is notltUe the 
 
 churchwar- cafc Of 8 Cl)attl)lDatDcn , toblc^ <fl an £)f ficc that the common Hato takes 
 
 ''"■ notfre of , 1 2 H 7. anu a SCeton ClarU Is a pubUquc officer of the SCoton , 
 
 ano Borcmam cafc fsherpUbc to this ; anDtbcolficeofa hlgfj fetcuiarD is 
 a publtqne office, anofofsa&tcvraroof aileet, ano one map putairapa 
 fettant rctatnco fo j his life , anu fo map the fechmlmatter here be tlfchats 
 gcu , ano this ^chcol f a pjlljatc School, anD <s not a Cojpojatfon as Weft. 
 niiniVer fechcoUa. Glyn chief lufticc, bpthc fame ralEthat the &thoolma- 
 tter fljonlo be rettojeo map eher fechollar claim to be rrftojeo , anD 3 con- 
 tcltoc the HlQtois map remoljc thr spatter of tl.c School, If he obferte not 
 the rales fo? gotrrnmcntof the fetbool, anc ft fcems as rcafonaWc fojj. 
 them to turn out the S^ iftcrs, as to rcceltjc them Into the plate. But let the 
 whole matter be referred to t lie Juftice* of tdeAffize, one of whom, viz. my 
 
 Refcirtnce Lord chief Inftice St. lolin , it the Chancellor of the VnivcrfityofCam* 
 BiiDge, where the School is, 
 
 Fowkc and Prefcott. 
 
 Trin, i^jj, Banc»fup: 
 
 FOwke bjonght an 0dfon upon the cafc upon a pjotrtffe agaf nft Prefcott, 
 SChc Cafe teas this, Prefcottbcfng a Coachman DfD bp carelefs Djlbfng 
 „■ ntt.on'ii'i;'- of hfs CoBch b?caU 3 pipe of tDJne of Fo wkes <jDhfch lap fn the ftrcct , tohcrc- 
 oo iht cjie bp much ot the tnfnc ran ont, anD toaa loft : Fowke appjehenDs the Coach* 
 uponapio- man, toho thereupon pjomffeto thatffhcU)OulDfojbeartofuel,fm fojthe 
 ""^'' tefnc' tbatheltioulopflpbfmas much as he hao DamnlficD bfm, anD fo> 
 
 b;ieachoftbfsp;omffeheb;iing6hfs 0ctfon, ano obtafns a tcrDfct agafnft 
 the BDcfenDant. 3t\r)a6 moKDfnarrcttof tuDgemcnt, i.SLhatthcpiafn* 
 tff bao not a\jerrcD hoir much the tofne teas toojti that taasfpUt , ano fo he 
 Avcrnunr. ^^^j^ ^^^ ^^^^ ^jjg^ fatfsfactfon to malie the piafntf f fo? ft , fo; he fenoiD0 
 Rcqucft. not the toalue. zip. ^nc Doth not appear to be anp reqncft maoc foj the 
 fattsfactfon bp the piatr.tlf. Serjeant Twiiden anftoertD , l>crc Doth ap» 
 pear to be an apparent Damage , ano he hath not fatfefiiO the Damage ice 
 bal3C laiDfnourSDcclaratfon, nojhatbtheSDcfcnDant pleaoeD anp tenoet 
 Tender of a.> Of Damaoco at all , anD the 3"rphat3C founo the Damages, ilp. ©He fnp 
 iTi>ee>. that toe hate fo:bo?n to fue hfm , anD thfs fnipUes no fatfsfaalon maDe at 
 
 iTipiicatior. tijg jfnte of the ^flfon bjought. Alleyne on the other fine , SChc JOlafntffo 
 ^"''""« SDcclaratfon Doth not f ntftlc hfm to the ^ctfon, anD the finofng of the 3Iurp 
 cannot mahe thts gooD. Gljn chief luftice, JBotb partfcs DfD fee the 
 tn<re, anD theE»ff£nDantfsbonnDtotafrenotfcc of the Damage, ano the 
 pafntfffsnotbounDtogfbchfmnotfce, ano the 31«rp hath ntaoe ft cet- 
 lui^gcmenr. {g(„^ xiiercfore let the Plainrif have bij judgement, 
 
 Ood 
 
 Avieftof 
 ju g mcnf 
 an
 
 D 
 
 Dod and Herbert 
 
 TrJn» 1^5 5.' Banc, fup, 
 
 Od bjftngbt an 3(tfo»i "of SDcbt upon an £Dblfgat{on to ttanotoan «» Demurrer ih 
 __ toarD, againft Herbert, t!)cE)EfencantpleaDea nil debet, ano upon a'i'b-up"" *n 
 JDcmutter tbcfc cvccpttona tectc taben to tbc ainaro, ir bp <t fljoulo not be i?;^ j^,"'°^ '° 
 gooD : I . SCbat berc {0 1 00 1. aUjaroeu to be pala to tbe partp , ann ft Dotb ward. 
 not appear tbat It fs to be pafo unto btm in fdttafactfon of tbc tojong cones.ti.iadion, 
 untobtm. alp. l^erctsSl. ojocreotobepafo foj tbarccg ano cj:pcncca,<^'i>'P"- 
 tob(cb tbfng fs not fubmtttctj unto bp tbc parties, ano fo no 3 voarD ougbt to '^" cuji'^^jlo. 
 be maoc foj tbcm. glp. SCbc Sictfon bere Is ntcerlp grotinocD tipan tbc SI- Utj. 
 VuarD, ano tbcrcfoje tbc atoarD ougbt to babe been b:.ou{;i)t Into Court, 
 ioblcb Is not none fo; ougbt appears bcrc. Wild on tbc otbcr floe anfujereo, 
 tbat upon tbc penning of tbc irbolcatoaro, It appears tbat tbc 100 1, fs to 
 bcpapo fo: tbc to;ong Done to tbc partp bptbe fpeaUIng of tbc fcanoalous 
 toojDS, anDtbeaUjarDfafttfOjtbtobcmaDcdeec fupcr prxmiflis, tDt,fcbDc& fuper 
 malicflftgooB, asmp Lord chid luftice Rolls opinion iuac upon tbc firftpr*""fl>s. 
 opening 0'. the 3ilcco;D , «nt) fo toas Burbidges cafe 16 Car. 3nt) as Jo tbe 
 fccono Crceptfon b bclD, tbat tbc 8 I. atoaroeo to be papco fo; cbargcs teas 
 IrftWn t:)c fubmlfslon , fojtbc Sfrbftatojs tabc poSncr to alloln cbarges; 
 flno as to tbc latt eixcptlon,bc falo ft Is not ncceffarp to pjotiucc tbe filnaro 
 fn Court. Giyn chief luftice, 3t Isto belntenDeo tbattbe 100 1. Is to bcpalD^"^'"'^'""'^' 
 fo; tbc tD;ongDone , ano tbc 81 fo; cofts 1:3 as luell Icltbln tbe fubmllolon as 
 tbeotbcr, anDtbcairiarofsretltco, anoftlsfafo to be maoc dc et fuper 
 pramiills. 2Cbe onlp tjnf B<cn fs, tobctbcr tbc :aii}aro eugbt to be p;oDuteD In 
 Court , anD 31 conccttc It is not neteJTarp to do It . altbotigb be mull plcao 
 tbc ilttarD fn tp;ftlng , fo; tbc aafonfs not b;oufibt upon tbe atoaro, but 
 upon tbc fubmf fsf on, fo;tbc0toarDl3buttbcfnDuccment , ano tbe Court, 
 batbnotbfngtoDotoltbtbcaiuaro, battofee tobctbcrit be fn iDjttfng o> f^^^j'JJ^^^^^^^ 
 no; il=o:aH)eeo,tbatmulf 31 corfefs, be p;oi!uceD fn Court, tbat tbc ""'■"'"*'"• 
 Court map juuge tobctbcr It bho tbc partp 0; not , ano pou pour fclbcs 
 l)abebcrefEtfo;tbtbc;3teari3lnpourpleaDfng, But fpeak toic ar another 
 dsy, at feblci^ time tbc cafe belnc onlp pat, Glv" chief luflice falD, If an 
 ^flfonofocbt be bjongbt upon an Obligation, tbc £t)blfgatf on ""^^f to be ^|^'.'^"^^* ^^ 
 pioDuceo, anD fn all otber cafes tobcrctbtngs cannot be Dcmanneo but bp ^j|j"j^y"!.j_ * 
 jDccD ; otbertDffc fs ft,ff tbcp map be Bcmnnoro cttber bp 2Dcci),o; vftbout 
 
 nicoc. 
 
 SDecD; but here fs no £?cco In tljc cafe , fo; an ;arbttrcmcnt unocr fral Is no 
 SDccD, f tbc arbftremcnt map be maoc iDltbout a SDeco, « }bcrefo;c It Ij not ^."i^',;^ 
 necc(rarptofaep;oDuccDfnCourt , fojftfsbut a tojftlng unDcr bano ano'wiiting 
 real, ludicium Difi pro quertuce, lu i^cment 
 
 nifi. 
 
 Maynelland Mackaliye. 
 
 Trirt. 1^55. Banc. fup. 
 
 MAvnelIb;ougbt'an Action upon tbe Cafe agafnli Mackaliye, ant) t)c.^'■rfft>f 
 clarcD, SEbatiDbcrcaobebaoanlntcntto enter an flctfonagafnft tbe '""?'"'"' '" 
 SDcfcnoant, anotoarrcftblmatfiitba time, tbcDcfenoar.tln confiDcra.*;'^^^';'°J|^"f' 
 tlontbat tbcplafntiftoonlDfo^bcartoarrcftblmat tbat time dId pjomffCuponapro- 
 tbatbetooulo putfnbatltoblmatanptfmc after tobcn be Qjall enter bfs "'re 
 aafon agalnftbfm.ano fo; b;eacb of tbfspjomlfc be b;lngsbl3 Action, tlpoit 
 nonalTumplitplcaDeD, ano abcrDf.rfo;tbe piaintif, ft toas mol^cD fn Ac 
 
 i^nn 2 rcK
 
 c 
 
 ^60 ^""- »^5 5. 
 
 rcfl of fucgcment, ?Dbat ft Is not fafo tioto long tijc paf nf if fliouln fojbcat 
 to atrtfl t^c SDcfenDant , ano ft map be foj fo Ifttlc tfmc ttjat ft tolll not be 
 CorGdera- ^ ^^^^ conCoetatfoii to gronno tJje p^omffc. JBut ft teas anftDcrcD, tftat ft 
 ^^^^■at^on. fd UjcU cnoneb, foj tbc DEclatatfonpatfueg tl^ toojua of tftc agreement be. 
 Kcafonabie tlDCCH tfte pattfcfl, ant) cannot bc bettct ocpjeffeD. Glyn chief luftice, 3tf9 
 conftiiiaion. g gjijij, tonfiOEtatfon , ano toe mutt mabe reafonablctonftruafonof tooiM, 
 ) udgcmcm. g];;^g^(pje !„ the Plaintif havc his judgement. 
 
 Abbott and Vaughan. 
 
 Trin. 165J. Banc, fup» 
 Pafch. igyy.rot. 557. 
 
 Error upon a A ^bott bjougM Hit adion npoH tlje cafe agafnff Vaughan rniD W toffe, 
 judgement in /\foj tDojDo fpohen ot t^e plafntffbp tfte SDcfenUants tuffe, ano npon 
 n Aajonup not gutltp pUaijeD ano at)aD<ctfonnDfo?tbepafntff , ano a )ntgement 
 on the cafe j^jjgopoti gftoen , upon 3 lujft of ffitto? bjoufltjt tlrfa Cfteptfon teas tabeir, 
 
 tijat tbc terDfd foano tfte irf fc onlp gnfUp , ano pet tftc laugement tuaa gf- 
 ten agafnft JBaron ano iFcme , utjicb Vcas nrget to be Crroj , but 9 E. 4» 
 teas tftcD on tfte ot^ier Ooe , tbat tbe fnogemcnt fe tocU gften. Glyn 
 chief luftice, SDbe 3nrp ^fee fount) tbe tuffe gnfltp , ann fo tl)C SDeclata. 
 tfon fs tcne » ano ttietcfoje juftcaufeof Adion, and the judgement well 
 given* 
 
 Williams and Probe. 
 
 Trin.idyy, Banc, fup, 
 
 n of \/\ 7 ''''a"* bjoagW an 0ctfon npon t^e cafe foj fpcafefng tljcfc toojoa 
 
 judfement \n V V Offtet , viz, Thou art a Whore, and I will prove thee a Whore, 
 
 an Aftion tor and thou baft made my houk a Bawdy houfe. flftcr a tcrOfft ft teas motct» 
 
 words. In 3rreft of f uogemcnt tftat tJic too jos are not attfonablc . bccatife tbcp 00 
 
 not f mplp tbat (be bao plapeo tbc Icbo^e bet felf, tboiigb (be t)ao maoe tbe 
 
 |Dlaf ntf f0 t)onfc a XBateop boufc. Jbut Glyn chief luftice anflttereo , 3f toe 
 
 tabe all tbe toojDstogetljcr astbcp arc lafo tl^cp arc aflfonablc , foj tbrp 
 
 Particular ap- gjg partfcnlsr appUcable toojoa , rclatfng to t^e partfcs plapfns tijc to^oje ; 
 
 pi.cabie Therefore let her have her judgement. 
 
 word*. ' " 
 
 ludgcmenc. 
 
 Bacon and Ramfey. 
 
 Trin. ifijj.Banc. fupi- 
 
 ForaBarre- Ht^C Coutt toas WOtJCO fO} Bacon 8 IBatteffCt Of Grays Inne tbatbe 
 
 fttr (or his ^ rofgbt bat3E bfs pjfbflegc to lap an 3(tfon tranfttoj p fn Middlefcx, toberc. 
 
 privilege to gg (t Itas lafO fn Northumberland , anO Franklin anO S)fr William Butjers 
 
 !*y^:* j^^'"" cafe , ano Btre ano lonet^fs cafe Of tfte Middle Temple trerccfttD topjobe 
 
 inMid iccx. ttiatalBarrcffcrongbttobatc thfs p;fbflcge , that tob^te anp tranOtojp 
 
 aafoii is bjonght agafr.ft bim, be map bate ft lafo fn Middlefex , tufjerefoc- 
 
 tct tbe f aufc of 3ctfon toaa. TheCourtadvifcd, anoorCrcotof^tbcpjc 
 
 Ooentfl citeo, 2t anotljcr oap it tDSs motjeo again, ano npon tbe pjefioento 
 
 Granted. p}00nced , It was ordered to Uy the venue io MiddkUx accordingly. 
 
 The
 
 The ?rote<aor and Blackwell. 
 Trin. 1655. Bine, f up. 
 
 n ^e Court toas mot}co fo ^ n meliu} inquirendom to be Dircctcli to tl^e Co- ^^r a meiiuit 
 -"^ ronec of Middlefcx to enquire of tobat gmtifl one Toomi t^t feangco Wm. »'qu»rcndum. 
 fdfofoofe poffeffcD of, bccanfe tbe gnqnifitfon tcturneo DfD onip fino tbe 
 00011^ ^c luas poffefTea of in London, Glyn chief lufcice, You may have a mc« 
 (iusinqoin-ndum , it being for the Protedor, if the pradite of the Court will 
 allow ic , but U mutt bc DftcctcD to tbe &l)et{f , bccanfe t^e Co?onct \fnt^ J'""^- 
 Done bis office alreaop, ano batb notbing note to 00 UiUblt* coroner. 
 
 Efton and Manley; 
 
 Trin, i<Js5.Banc, fup, 
 
 -|[SC toaa motjji) In Strctt of iuogcment in an fllctfon of Debt upon an ;©b- 
 l.ltgatton , tbat tbc i©bUgat(on upon tob(cb tbe j9ct(on tnag bjosgbt toas fo; Semem in 
 tb:pai>inEtitofiool. atiDtbepiatiittf Declares foj 80 1 anofotbc SDccla. debt upon an 
 ration barf eg from tbc bono. alp. 3It i9 fafD tbat tbe attfon tnao entreo <n obligation. 
 tbc fame Counter , iDbercas tberc liaa no mention of anp Counter bcfoje , 
 neftl;ercotbit appear tijat tbc Counter is a Court. Glyn chief luftice an- 
 ficcrco , tbe firft erception is to no purpofe , ano foi tbe feconD it is but an 
 epccptfon to a furplufagc , tobicb mfgbt babe been left oat of tbe 2Dcclaratf= surpiufai*. 
 on , ano it is alfo alter a «HetDi(t, Therefore lee tbe Piaintit have his ludgcmem. 
 judgement, 
 
 Thomas and 
 Mich. 1655, Bare, fup. 
 
 'T ?^e cafe tuas tb{0 , oncpjomffcD to tbc i^atbcr, tbat fn tonffbcratfon Arreft of 
 
 tbatfjetooalDfurrcKCcra CoppbolD to tbe E^efencant, tbat tbe 2Dc- K*^'"^"" '" 
 fenpant UioulD nfbe mito bis ttro caugbtcrs jo I, a pfete , ano after a 53et- on a'^'rTmi'fe' 
 main an action upon tbc cafe bjougbtbp one of bia Daugbters foj bjeacti" * P^""'"- 
 oftbispjemife, StloasmobcDlnjarrcttof luDgement , tbat tbc |dlafnt(f 
 t\aD DcclareD upon a f opnt p^omifc maoe irbtcb concemeD anotber iDf tb the 
 ^iabitff , anD pet tbc ;actfon fs bjougbt bat bp one of tbem , tobereas ti^t^^ '°.'^"' P"* 
 ouQbt tobatic lopnco in tbc Action. 31But Glyn chief lufticc anftDcreo, that'"' '' 
 tbc parties babe DfSfnctfntcrclts, ano fo anp one of tbem mapbjlng an 
 Bctlon. Turner Tf plpcD, JTbc SDcclaratfon mentions tbc p^omlfe to be a ^iftirft intc- 
 jornt pjomlfe. Glyn chief luftice, JButtbe ILatDDctbDiaingutO) tbe fntr. * 
 rctt , tbourfb tbc SDedaratfon be general. Serjeant Bernard , ?^ere ought 
 to bc a fcbcral j9ctlon , anD fobatb it been latelp aoluDgcD In tbc Common Diftit a on of 
 pleas: But it iDasanfUicreo, that tbc Action is brought but foj one tlocntp l*J' ^ 
 pouno Due to one of the JEDaucbters , and fo jadgeraeqt for the Plaintif, " S"""*** 
 Bifi,:<vc, 
 
 jann J Wood
 
 46i Mich. 16,55. 
 
 Wood and Gunfton. 
 
 Mich. 1655- Banc, fup» 
 
 NoAaion<orjiPfl2Ctpalat513ar(nati3dfonupontbe cafe fo;i IDOJD0 bcftoecn Wood 
 
 (candaious *|0la<nt<f, fltiD Gunfton Defcnoant, %t toas fafo b)) Glyn chief luftice, 
 
 wo: Js. 2i;ijat ita Counccllcr fpcaU fcanoalons tDOjDs agatnft one in oefcriofng Ws 
 
 Clpcnt0 catife , an ^aion Dotb not lie agafift btm fo; To Doing, fo; it ia bis 
 
 Dntp to fpcak fo; i)iB dClpcnt, ano it ll)aU lie intenocD to be fpoken accojoing 
 
 to bis Cl£>cnt0 inttnictiono, 
 
 Hecheranii Bowman. 
 
 Mich, 1655. Banc fup. 
 
 ir.ftiumentinTiPatrpalatJBar bcttoecnHether ano Bowman in SCrcfpafa ano (tied- 
 law. -^tnentitUiasraiDbptbe Court, Cbat tbe iLo^o of a Coppboplo ia iiut an 
 
 Admflron"' BlnttramcnttoaDmfttbcCoppbolDcr, ano ougbt to auinit bim aceojofng 
 '^"' to tbc fnrrcnocr, 0? otbcrioifc the aomittance ia not gooD» 
 
 • Thiirlcand Madilbn. 
 
 Mich. 1655. Banc, fup. 
 
 Enrolment of | JF' ^ Ctpal at tbc JBat bcttoan Thurle anu Madifon , 3!t toaa TafD bp Glyn 
 a Deed. -^chief luOice , that if Ditjcrs pcrfpno Do real a 2DecD,ani) but o.ie of tbem aca 
 
 ftnoiolcDge tbcSDita, anotbcJIDaois tbcrcupon entollco, t\}ia is a gooo 
 Evidence ^ntoUmcjit Voitliin tl;c Statute , ano map be gitjcn in ctifnencc as a SDceo 
 
 enroUco, at a2CtpaU 31t toas tljcn alfo faio, that if a dccd erpjefs a 
 Confijera- conSoetatlon Of moHcp upon tbc putcbafc maocbp tbc 2[>cco , pettbfai iano 
 tion. pjoof upon a trpal, tbat ttje monico cppjcffco ioctc paio, but it muft be pjo- 
 
 •bCD bp tDitncffc0, 
 
 Copy proved. \ yi Emorandum, Sbat upon the fame SCrpal an 0ct of iparliamcnt pjo« 
 IVjDnccD in point foj tbc felling of £)dinqucnt0cftatC0, loas fuiojn to 
 (ate been cramineo bp tbe iparliamtnt IRoU , ano ti;at it toas a trae Copp 
 befo;e it icao reao in cbiocncc. N»ia. 
 
 VVood and Giir>fton. 
 
 Mi:h. 1655, 
 
 Memoran- \ > P^n a motion fo; a ncfo trpal bcttoKn Wood ano Gundon , npon a 
 dum, V fuppolition of cvccfsibe Damages gioenbp tbc 31urp in an Sctior/ npoti 
 
 Ncwityai foitbctafetrpeoattbc55atfo>lBO}D0, vi/. CaUtngtbcpaintifSCraptoj, $c. 
 mi'cairiage 1500 1. bcidg tbc Damagcs giticH , 3t tDfls faio bp Glyn chief Juftxe, tbatif 
 of tiK lury. j^p ^jjy^j j,Q bclictc that tbe Blurp gabc tbcir ticrnict againft tbeir Direction 
 giben onto tbcm , tbc Court map grant a neto Crpal. a nd a new Tryal 
 wasgronted in chis Cafe afcer a full dgbace had by Councell on both iides* 
 
 Cul-
 
 _____^ Mich. 1^55. j^6^ 
 
 CuUiar and lermin. 
 Mich. 16^5. BanoCap. 
 
 CUlliar bjoagbt an actfonupont^Cafcaponapjomlfe, anDDcclarei>,ArrtJi of 
 tftat tfteCcftatojoftticSDEfcntJantfnconCDeratfon, tftattbe ^afntff ludpcmenc 
 tnotJlu marp fncft a Moman D(Dp2oni<fetftatl)ch.oulDlgatic Wm^)alfWs"P°"•P'^"'• 
 C5ftatc at W ueatl) , ano thereupon ^0 Dfo marp t^e partp , ann pet be tfo ""'*• 
 not leate bfm ^alf ftfs cftate at b<a ucatft. tapon a tercfct fonnu foj tbe 
 idlafntff, ft toa0mot)cD<nattcftof)uDgement, t^at t^e fiDeclatatfon teas 
 not gooo , (o^ tobetcas tfie p jomtfc toaa, tljat tf]c Defenoant fljoalD Uatje 
 ftlm fjalf of an Wa cfiatc, tDlrfctj mf gbt be fntetiDeo bot& of W real anu alfo of 
 if0 pctfonal Cftate, antt of anp cfiatc fnreterfion, aBlDCUasofancftatefn 
 poJTcfBfon, tbe plafntf:' onlp faps, tbattbeSCtttatojDfeotDOjtbsoooUn 
 poffcfsfon, anDtbatbcufDnotlfatfcfttmljalf of tftat cfiatc, ano it map be 
 llE left t)'m part of W0 teal cfiatc , o% ettatc <n retJcrCon to tbe fall 
 taluc of balf t)fo tr^o^o cfiatc. 3i5;it Glyn chiefluftice DJfallotoCDt^e 
 ejxeptfon , and gave judgemenc for the Plaintif. j 
 
 Lance and Blackmore. 
 Mich. 1 65 J, Banc, fap» 
 Hill. 1654, roMpi. 
 
 LA nee an ©rectif o;b?otigbt an aidf on upon f be Cafe agafnft Blackmore, Arrcft cf 
 ano DcclatcD, tbat <ti conllDcratlon ttiat tftc ICcfiatoi^ tBOPlD fpfifet tic judgement in 
 SDefcnoantto cnjop futb a Clofcoflano, tbe jBDcfcnoant Dio airumeano>'^A^'°""P' 
 pjomlfc to pap 5 J J. a peat fo; tbe rent thereof fo j fo long time as be QionlD ''" '''" *-'^' 
 cnjoptt, ano fo; fomntb tent Due fojUfojfolongtfmc (n tbe SCcffatojs "^°" * ^'^°' 
 Wfettme, ano foj fo raucb rent Dae fincc bfa neatb be bjfngs tbe attfon. 
 tapon non affumpiit plcaDCD, a t)crol(t toas foanD fo? tbe |3lafntlf j ano cn= 
 tfre Dammages gfljcn* 3t Ujas moiJCD fnattcftofSaDgemcnt, i, Subat 
 an atffon of tbc Ca:^e ootb not l(e, Ufaefng fojtbenonrpapmcntofrcnt, 
 tD',<cb folio -B tt)c nature of tbe lano , ana Dotbfoant) tn the rcaltp, foj tobftb 
 a pcrfonal action Ilea not. alp, l^crc Dotb not appear bp tbe SDcclaratlon ^'^'fo"' ^^^ 
 to be anp confiDcratfon to gronno tb: pjomlfc upon, fo? tbc £?eclaratlon ts corfid«ari 
 f bat If tbe Ccfiato? In ber life time tooulo permit tbe JuDcfenuant to en|op ' 
 tbc Clofe, tbcn . w» ano It Is not atcrrcD, tbat tbe SCcftato j oio f n bet life Avcf ment. ' 
 tliiefaffet tbc 2DefenDant to cnfop tbe Clofc. GIvnchief Innice,3fap?o» 
 mife be maoc totbeaCettatojjtJjcCrecutojmapbatjeanaafon,' aooftfsKxccucor 
 a gmo confioeratlon as to blm , foj tbc crecato j la rcpjcfcntatitc of tbc Xz-. 
 ttato?. ano 2lp. An Adion upon the Cafe will not lieforrentuponapro.promife in 
 mile in law, buc upon 3 fpecialpromifeof the party to pay it, as our Calc is Law, Special. 
 
 Ingram and Fawfet. 
 
 Mich, i655,Baoc»lup, 
 
 Ii^ tbfa Cafe It toaa raft bp Glyn chief luftice, SChatffanaDmfnlffratojA''"^'"''^''*'^ 
 bilns an action agalnlt an aDmfntCrato?,lt la not ntccffarp foj tbe J9laln.ho"w" ^^^^^ 
 
 tlffttator.
 
 4^4 Mich. 1655. 
 
 — " ^(Tto (b2tD bp to^om tbdcttereof aiDmfnffttatfon tocrccrantcDantotbc 
 SDcfenoant , but be muftQjeirbpvuljomtbeUttctsof aommfftratfontDere 
 QrnnteD to Ijtmfclf to cntttlc himfclf to tbc flaion, fcj If ft appear not 
 to tt)c Court tliatlicU^DminiQiato;, be cannot fac bp tbat name. 
 
 Hnw far fpe 
 
 Mich. 16) 5. Banc. fiip. 
 
 I3C toaa fafo bp Wild , ano agrccu bp VVhitwick one of tbe ^affcra of tbe 
 Clppcr 515:ncl):officc, tbat ff an flttomp Do appear fo^ one jnt^c Upper 
 ivjbic ('-r ^he ^ciicl), t fpccOl bapWs ctttrcD foibfo c ipcnt.to tbat i^ctfon,tbat tbat Bapi (u 
 i>i licijiii. „ot boinia to flanti 3i5apl to all ctbcr iSirtlona tbat Qjall be Mclarco (n agafntt 
 tbe pattp upon tl;c bp. buttbc3ttojnpfojbfin <3boimt»to appear foj bim 
 in all fwtb ;:ictlon0, ano to put Jti Common bapl. 
 
 WagRaffand TempeR. 
 
 Mith \'^s 5. Banc, fop, 
 
 nfo-nfa.on \^ '^'^^ fato bp Glyn chief luftice upon cWocnce gibwifnaCrpaUttbs 
 wi.h a(o'tci-l315.«, bettoeeti VVapftaff aiio Tempeft, tbat \i tenant fo>Ufct)ole\)pa 
 lu c ofaih- -jftne oftbelanMbctsfofeffcaof. to^icrcbp be fljoiilo fojfcitljfatftatc. 
 iU(c u) 1. pet (f be <n tbe rcmairTJcr toill topn luitb tbe SDcnant foj Ufc fn Dcdariiig tbe 
 uf0o,tbf3{5aD(fpcnfat(ontoJtbtbefo?fctturc. 
 
 and LeGay 
 Mich. !655.Binc, fup. 
 
 For i riinr ,0 T !^: Court teas cnfojmco , tbat fn an action of jactompt bjoogbt tbcre 
 
 sccomp. b- I toao a DfiDfct, tbat tbe Dcfcnoant (bouloatcomptfacfojcauDttojs, 
 
 foic Auditors. g„jj tijat 3uDltojfliDercafi3finca, anDtbepnrtfestocrc notobcfojctbeSUi' 
 
 t)fto:g,ano tbereupon ft iitaa mobca on tbe SDcfcnoants part, tbat tbfs Court- 
 
 iDOulD erant b<m ttme to accompt, fo j tbe reafons alieceo. 3i5:it Wild an- 
 
 flDCTCD, tbat It Iras not pjopcr tomofeebere, fojtbc SuoUojsare nolo 
 
 3Itiacc9 of tbe matter, ano map gfbctime Utbepfeecaufe. SCotobfcb 
 
 ^" b ThV" ^'V" chieflunice agreed, ant) fdO, tbe auDttejs are ?u*ees bp tbe fetatulc, 
 
 i?aiute. «nd therefore move before tliem, ".ni trouble not us with it. 
 
 Sergeant Brad iiiaw and PrO(5ter. 
 
 Mich. icjS-Banc, fup, 
 
 ^n'ant>w'.'" [ /^^bC Cafc Of ^crgcailt Bra.-'fh w an^ Spr. Prober of GraysJnnc. %i load 
 p"rrof the fafo, tbatacballcncetotbcarrapfsnoJpartoftiicllccojD. but ougbt to 
 Kccoid. be tctermhico lobetb^t ft be cooo 0? rotbptbcSaoec, befojetrbomtbe 
 trpal of tbe Caufc 0ioulD ba^ci»ccn, ff tbe cbalicngebao not been tatjert; 
 B) whom to ^^^ ^^ ^^^^ jj jjpgj^ ^yjgjj jjpijj^ fcrloug ao^jffc in tbe,Comtnon=plcas : ano it 
 
 ncd"'^'"" tias tbcn Ifkchiffc fafo, fftberebeaocmiirrcrtoa tbaUcngcat tijeafaffe©, 
 Dniiurrcr <o tbe ^uOffc of arsffc mapDctcrmfnc ft tb:re, oj oticr<rulc ft, oj aDjournft 
 a challenge. ^^ (,5 ^garu at anotbCT tfmc. 
 
 Somes
 
 Mich. j6 5 5 . ^^^ 
 
 • Somes and Sir John Lenthall. 
 
 Mich, i<r5j.Banc.fup, 
 
 T^e Coatf teas enfojmeu t^3t an ^aittn of JSDcbt teeg fojtncrlp bjoogljt For Sir loha 
 agafnH &{t John Lenchall, an5 tbnt tt)cre teas Jti^gcmcnt, ano an cje i-cnrbaii ihc 
 ctttfom thereupon tafeentnitagafnffbf in, but ttjatftcabconoeoMmfelf.tbat ^^"'''^'"V '" 
 
 be coalo not be tafeen, anb tljcrefoje ft toag pjapsD ( 
 
 exccutjoo. 
 
 licet of tl)f3 Court ttiat tbc Court teoulD oioer bfm to appear bere, tbatbe in en 
 
 n 
 
 ip- 
 
 map be eoitiinftteo fn crccutfon to'tbe ^berlf of Mid jlcfex. 3I5ut Glyn chief 
 lattice anftocrcDjf&lcIohnLentliall DO appear fterc, ano poupiap j^oiiti 
 netutfon , toe can commit Wm to no otbet pjtfon bnt tbc ip.uCbalfea, foj 
 tbat fs tbe p;(fon of tljfs Court, ano to commft \)i\n to tljat p;ifoii af tolncb be 
 (0 t!)e iSapcr, toftljout fecurfng tbc JDjffoncrs tbere, bcfojetoe 3jo(t,fetU 
 be m efcape in laio of aa tbe pjtfonetg. Thcpcfore let Sir Sofjn fhew 
 caafe why htf fltonJd not piy the Debr, for it is neith«r for bis o*n credit, nor 
 the honor of this Court, that he ftiould not fatiifie bis Debts, 
 
 Hardrcs andProwd. 
 
 Mich. i£ $ j« Bine, Tap. ^ 
 
 HArdrcs b}oug|>tan 0(tfon upon tbe Cc-ft agafnC Prowd, anb btflavcn, Arrcd cf 
 tbat iBbcte§0 te at tbc fnflancc ano requcft of tbcSDcfenoant itm tahw i^Jgcmem i 
 pafns to reconcile Dfflfcrenccs bettuijt tbc SDefennant ano J.s. ano otbet0, tbc '" '^'°1 "p 
 SDefenDint Dfo aiTamc ano pjomfte unto tjje iplafntff to pap unto bim loo /, l"„'^^l ^^l^'^ 
 at a certain nap, aiio fo; no.t paptng tbs monp accojoinglp'be b}ing0 fjfs 3.- m^c ' ^ °' 
 ttfon. ane upon non-ailumpfit plcaoco, anB a tetDfct fount) foj tljc JDIaiH' 
 tff. Sbe ©efcnnant mo^e!) fi! arrcft of 3;ui>ccment, i. Ebat tcre fa no 
 conftoeration fct fujtFj in ti)z Declaration to croiiiiDtbcpjomifc upon fo> 
 ft f0 onlp fafD , that in conGoctatfon tbat tftc =|pi5intif bao tafeen pain?' ?c. 
 ^c ofD pjomife, 5c. ano tbis is a conCottation crccnteo, ano not fufiUcient to cor.fijcrjcion 
 gtoano a pjcmifcupon, antjone Hunt ano Diers cafe iDafltiteDfojpjoof.^^"""^''- 
 2lp. i^e:iOtbnota)ctotob^np3fnsbcbat?)tafeen, ant) fo ft cannot be fenotoii 
 tobct^et bis pains inete ftfficient to Gtouno tbe p:.omtfe nppn.«!p. tes 
 fape^ytbat be too& pafna to tecomfic Differences bctlpirt tfjex)cfcnaant,ant> 
 i. S. ano others, ant) Dotb not Qitvo tcbo tbefc otbcrs Ujetr. Ebc ttoo latt ey- 
 ceptioro iDEie oliertulcD toitbout fpeahing to; ana rotlicBrUWildan' 
 Itocrct,tbat litn iuaaa continmng conttDcration, tbougb tbe pains tabencomiruine 
 tocrepaft, fo? it is faia be tcofetbc pains at tbefntfa:/cc ant) requcft of tbe^''^'fi'^cran«n. 
 laiaintlf G!yn chief luftice, It is as you fay, for here is more than a volun. Voluntary 
 tary Curt* fie, upon which no confideration for a promife can be grounded for cunefic. 
 the pains here were undertaken at the inftance of the Piaintif, HuDfcium 
 nfC, iC 
 
 Mich. i<55 5^ Banc. flip. 
 
 Bp Glyn chief lufltce, Jf one come fnupon tbc (Spfgcnt bJMaap aa- whsre one 
 pear fap bis attojnr, butifbecomc in upon the £I>ntlaU)jpljemuttap-'"'y *m«" 
 peat iu b's pjopct pcrfon, ano notbpbi3a;tto;np, ano fo istbeconttant ''l'^"'"'"'^' 
 pjaafce of tSe Common pUas, ano of tbfs Court alfo. Nota, "here not. 
 
 ^"0 Lon.
 
 a6'^ Micfi.1655. 
 
 London and VVjlcocks. 
 
 Mich. 1655. Banc fup, 
 
 Arrtft of T Ondon bjoaglit an action of SCrefpafa agafntt VVilcocks inter alia , fo^ 
 
 judfiemcm in l_jtaUfng ajiD tarrpJog atoap 40 loaoo of Co?n <n tfie fetrato. tlpon a 
 
 Trcfpafs. tjctottt founo foi tbE |Dlafnif f, U toaB moVieo fn arteft of SuQgcnient tbat tlje 
 
 SDctlaratfon tons ancertaln, fojtbe|0la(ntff ftao orclatcD foj4oloaDaof 
 
 Cojn fn tl)E fetratD, ant) n ootb not appear, totctljet tbcp be !^o?fc loaoi 
 
 oj Cart- loaofli, o? tnbat otber loacs of Co?n tbep are. J5ot Glyn chief luflice 
 
 anflDCtcD , that ft fs tocM cnougtJ e^pjeffeo , fo; ft bcfns of Cojnfntfte 
 
 &trato, ft (ball be fntenneo Catt-loaos , and therefore let the Plaintif have 
 
 Jut'gemeiu. Lis ludgeiTicnt. 
 
 Q, 3f tfte actfon ^D been lafb fntljcCoqnfpofCornwell 
 . tobere ft f ufual to carrp Co^n fn tbc &tralB apon I^o^fes 
 tobctbet tbe jBDeclaratfon tpoulo ^\iz been goon, 
 
 • 
 
 Wood and Gunfton. 
 
 ^ Mich, 1 65 J' Banc J'up* 
 
 • 
 
 For 9 new XjSJOaii bjougbt an 3ttfon apon tbe Cafe agafnttGunftonfo^fpeafe* 
 
 tryai in an a- ^ ^ fng Of fcattDalona Idojw Of bfot /anD amongft otbcr toojoofojcaU 
 
 aionofTref. ijng bfttt Traytor , anD obtepno at3cri)(aagafnlfbfmattbcl5ar,tDbErefit 
 
 pifsfor j^p jy^P gg^g i5oo!;fiamiragc0. Upon tbe fuppoOtlon tbat tbe cam-- 
 
 **"! '■ tnagea tocre cyccfaffec, ano tbat tbe 3urp Dfi> fatjout ibc pafntff, tbe 
 
 ji^CfenOant moteO foj a neto trpal. JBut Sergeant Maynard oppofeD ft , 
 
 anu fafD tbat after a tcroftt tbe partfalftp of tbe 3arp ought not to be qucftf . 
 
 oneo, noj fa tbere anp^?tfit)entB<:ojftfnour JBtnhaoftbcHatD, anoft 
 
 IcoulD be of oangeroua confequcnce f f ft fljoulD be fuffercD, ano tbe grEatncr0 
 
 of tbe Dammageagftencanbenocaafcfojanetotrpal, bHtfffttticre,tte 
 
 Dammagcfl arc not berc ercefflfbe, fftbc toojUflfpohcnbc toellconQDereD, 
 
 fo; tbcp tcno to tabe atoap tbe jpiafntffs Eflate,anD bfa Iffc. VVindbam on 
 
 tbe otglc floe pjeffeo fo> a netotrpal, anofafoft toaaapacbcDboOnefa, 
 
 clfetberetoulD not bate been fo great tiammagea, anti tbe Court batb potD» 
 
 cr f n cytraojDtnarp cafca, fucb aa tbfa f 0, 1 grant a n etc trpaU Glyn chief 
 
 Difcie.ion of Juftice, 3t fa fn tbe offcrctfon of tte Court fn fome cafca to grant a neto 
 
 the Coutt. trpal , but tbfa mutt be a juDfcfal , ano not an arbftrarp offcrctfon , anoft 
 
 Diirrctionju-jg frequent fn our IBooba fo> tbe Court to taUc notfreofrnffrarfagEBof 
 
 dcs^i, Aibi- ^j,,.jgg ^ an5 to grant neto trpala upon tbcm, ano ft fa (03 ibc peoples 
 
 The Coutc benefit tbat ft CboulD befo fo; aBlurp map fomctfmcc bp fnufrca ueal- 
 
 not 10 be in <nga bc motjeo to Due irftb one partp,ani) not to be fnDffFcrent bettofyt tbem, 
 
 •ended par- ^jyj ft tannot bC fofntenUCD Of tftc CouTt ; wherefore let there be anew try- 
 "*'• 3\ the next Term , and the Defcmlanc (hall pay lull Cofts, and juagcrocnt to 
 
 be upon this Verdid toftand for fccurity to pay what (hall be recovered up- 
 Granted, on the ne»t verdi(S, 
 
 the
 
 Mich. 16 S 5' 467 
 
 The Protedtor and Buckner. 
 
 Micli» 165 J, Banc, Tup* 
 
 BUckner tnas etiDfdcD apon tfte fetatatc of i Iac» maocagafnft&taWjfrrgSprciai ver- 
 attftc Snttfce i^allfnt^eOld baily fojWUfngof Horwood, ann apo«<^'^ "p°n *n 
 tijc eWoence gftieiifo; t^ ^Djotectoj, tije gurp foano a fpccfal bcrD(d, icl)k^ ^"diamcnt 
 Iras to tWs effect, viz. t&at Horwood awn atiotber man iDttftfjfm camefnto^fj^tutj^of , 
 tl^e loDgfng of Buckner bcfns tn Drury^lane, anD toben tl)cp Ujctc cotnc into Ijc. a^ JuR 
 t^c lotjgfng , tbat ott>zt man tob Doton a ftoojo in tbe §>cabbatD tu^ctj ijung *^^bb;i.g. 
 tbcre, anD ftoo atttjc 2E)cdj 0ftl)cCijambctiD<tt)tl)l3&iB0j0unD;aton<n 
 1^(0 bano , ano kept tbe 2Doo j to bdep Buckner from gofng oat t(H tljcp mtq^ 
 b?(ng a 3i5aUff to arreft Buckner foj a Debt tobfcb be olocD Horwood, 
 iDtjereapon upon fome offcoacfe betioeen Buckner ano Horwood, Buckner 
 tahcs a Dagger out of tjfs pocket, ano ffabg Horwood ano bfiic bttn , ano 
 toljetljcr tWa toas IcfttjOi tbe fetatute of fetabfaJngtuaflDoubteDfaptbe^n* 
 rp. mpon toWcb Buckner 1030 (ommUtcD to Newgate, anD after tbe JSoop 
 anB tbe Caafc teas rcmobeo fnto tbfs Conrt bp a Habeas Corpus ano a Cer= 
 tiorsri, anD argueD Diters limes at tbe J5ar anD at laft on tbe ISencb; 
 anofitttAithuf Harris efLincolrs Inn openeo tbclRecojD, anDonlppattijd 
 qucttton, ano tbcn on tbe bcbalf of tbe ^liiontt it teas motieo, tbat be mfgbt 
 ftabe a Copp of tbe IRccojB , ano Cotincel afatgnco btm facb as be DEfirco. 
 tDb<cb tbe Conrt gtantco, tben tttoaspjapeobc nttgbtbebapleo, battbat 
 tbB Court UjonlD not grant , bnt turnco b<m otjct to tijc ^arcfcall, ano aatie 
 sap fo^ tbe 10iotetto?0councclto be bearo ; at toWcb cap Twifdcn fo; tbe 
 |0jote(io? maDc tbfs qntttfon, itbetber Buckner Inag to, babe Ms Clcrop<ri 
 tbis cafe, o; ixjcre ocbarrcD bptbe Statute oj not, ano be fafo, tbteqace'ioii 
 fljonlo not bat)e been ma«c bp tbe 3larp as tbep babe Done npon tbe fpccfal 
 merDitt, bat tbe Court ougbt to babe maoe ft, fo? tbe 3nrp areonfpto 
 p:o(i£D upon matter 0^ fact, ano not upon matter in ?i5lD, ano bcncgucD 
 t^t be ougbt not to babe bis Clergy, fo; fbe Statute of i lac, ootb 
 not create tbe offence, but Icabes ft to tbe Common talD, ann onlptakesa* 
 toap tbe Clcrgp from tbe partp tbatcommftsft;ai)Dtopjobethf0, 1. jtfs 
 not itiftMn tbe iDOjDs of tbe Statute, onD »lp. ftfsnottoftWntbS meanfng 
 of tbe Statute, ncftbcr fn ftspicamble, no? fntbc boep, oj fn tbcpjobffo 
 tbcreof, foj Buckner tuac not firftOrook, no? baDbeatuEaponojatonaj 
 gainit Wm,8ltbongb 're toaakeptapifroncrfnbfs Cbambcr, tob^cb luas 
 not a conCDcrafale but a flfgJit pjobocatfon Ot bfm to mobc bint to fo (odi a 
 taa. ano tDftlifn tbe boDp of fbe 0ct, tbere are no acta crpjeHeD. but bai-fn? 
 atoeaponoisivinagafnftbfmjrij befngfirl* Crack, anD tbfs fnumeratfcn of 
 tbe aas crtluoes b!' otbr r , as ft fo.fn tbe §)tatute of #fne0. ^no fit tb? feta* 
 tntP iBbftlJ tabes atoap Clcrerp. aifo tbercafonof ^LatBretjHfreotoallolo 
 tbe Clergp to one tbat fsfirft ttrfcfecn; butbercfsno fuccrcaf;'?, ar.otbe 
 partp mfc'bt babe baDbfsrcmeop agafnC Horwondfo; com liitng into hfs 
 Cbamber ano fmpjffonfng of bfm bp an actfon of Crcfpafs ; ano tlic babfncj 
 a tnrapon DTaaniuaSa rcafonfo^tbeotbct to DcfenDbfmfeli. FincbHe^- 
 nage foj tb« |9?froner argueo.tbat tbe pjffoner teas onlp gufltp of felonp at 
 Ibe Common la>j a^) fs not lof tbfn tbe Statute bp tobfcb bfs Clergp lioulo 
 to be taken atoap. i^ojfirfttbe&tatdtefstobcifberaUpfntcrpjctcD, be-r 
 canfe ft famaseinreftrafntoftbeCommon.tatD, anDfttuasmaaconlptOon^'"^ *"" 
 p;cbent fetecs bctbofrt tbe EnpliHi anD tbe Scotifh-j^atfon, vobfcb tocre tbcit 
 apt to b?raUfoitbi anD tbe quarrel bete toas not a ojunkcnanDraDDen 
 qnattel, but aaco npon Dettberatfon , anD beic Isanaffaalt fo great nfco 
 
 jD 2 a.
 
 468 . _,^^^^:^^ 5 5. 
 
 agafnff tbcpjffoncr, t^at ftamountstoaffriitfngofWrtt, 43 E 3. f. 41.42 
 E 3. f.7. aiiDtbctmpjIfonmcntof blmismojc tftan an affault, anoicte 
 (sfontiDafoufblcentrpfatoWsCljamber , ann tljc fcnufna foj a 3!5ai- 
 Uf, anD tU flnnElng at b'c Ctiambi r too; Irttb a fUjojc fn tbc parties ijanD, 
 tboug^notojaim, to^kljfanomncbfncffcaasfftt bao bccnojalun , ano 
 j^Car. tbrClcrgpiiasallotocDto t'oio pcrfoua tljat a(Dc9 anD afettleD a 
 tWro petfon fnttabbfngofa fourth man, anotlmt bicanfctfjc Clergpfljall 
 imcndmen- not bc tafern atpapbp Intcnoments. Glynchitfluftice, Ehe Statute Ijatti 
 not ban. fo fatourablp tonflrucD ajs ^ath been argnco , foj bcrc is no ttroab, 
 no? iDcapon Djaton fo? l)<s p?cf£nt DEfcrcc,a0 tbc Statute iutenDs; ano ttab. 
 bingtoUljaCobntiopfpc , ano tettl) a l^alberD Ijatl) ban aDtuDgcuto be 
 flabbfrg\i;<tl'.<»ti)c statute, ano tljc fetatiitc Drtl) rot fap brfng flrftaf. 
 raulteD,a0ttf3cafE<o,butfitftttr(clJcn , ano 3 tonceltenottl'stttierearc 
 anpUOjt0<ntt)CS>tatiitPtbatli<UbEepsoaoutof<t. Day was given over 
 to the mxt Term SiX \xW\> unptliCfpctial tcrcfit teas agafn rrpcateo bp 
 Serjeant Maynard, rrt Iptimlt tDSsargncD foj tl)cp?ffoner, tljat be lias 
 not to<tl)fn t! c Statute of 1 Uc of ftabbfng , bccanfe firft ftcrc Ujais 
 an unlavrfuM <mp;<roi-.(ng of Eufkner (n Ws oton Cbamfcer, ano tWs 
 conlonotlietoitljoutanatranlt, ncft ttifs fetatntc fa not to be Ifterallp fn« 
 tetpjctco , fo? (f tfecre be 0ctB of tctto; nfcD agafntt one , altbougb a irca* 
 ponberotDjaiDii, {Ct be ts not to<tb<n tbc fetatutcaltbounbbel;<U ano- 
 tber , fo? tbc taking up of a CanolcflfcU to Hxtkt anotbcr batb been aojuDg* 
 CD a toeapcn D?atr!n , arc be tftco Patye ann Horwoods cafe, ann an ibe pct- 
 • fons that tame (nto b<o Cbambcr iicre Ercfpaffoja , ann one of tbem ta- 
 bfng tbc flt)o?D (n b<6 t)a»D bovr toulo It be fenoton tobat mifcblef mfgbt bate 
 been tone tuftb ft , Cooks cafe 14 Caroli , £Dne map Do a latofuH act bpun* 
 latofnH means , ano altlioagb Buckner ofo lU pet fs be not toftbfn tbe feta. 
 tutc, Arthnr Harris on tbe otbcr fioc arguet) tbat tbc act teas ttabbfng tcftb* 
 Jn tbc fetattrte , anDonfteDtbepjffoncrofbfeClcrgp, anutbatbc is toftb^ 
 In tbc meaning ans ts o?dc of tbc Statute. Ebe Statute fntcnDco to p?e* 
 tent tbc hIBIng of men fuDOcnlp , tiibftb Is tbc too?a of all otbet kining, foj 
 ItlsaslttDerctotettropnotonlptbeboDp, buteten to bill boop ano foul 
 alfo, ant)tbetefo?etbonobtbcStatntcbe penal, pctftlsnotto befatou' 
 rablp Interp? eteD, It being maoc fo? tbe peace ano quirt of tbe i^atlon. ffibe 
 felBlnglfl tbc matter afmcD at In tbc Statute, ano It matters not intttbct 
 tbc partp be hIBCD tcltba iFautbeon 0? a "jpfftol, as Williamt cafe tuas, tbat 
 felUcD atiotherbptb?o\ifnga 2Cflrlo?0 d^rofr at bfm, arm he ia not iiltbln 
 tbc fating of tbc Statute tbonr I3 fee i- as rCculteo , ano tt e oibcr ftcoo iiltb 
 tbcflro?ulntbcfcabbarDln ttfltanB, 56,37 Eli?. Hargersnd M- Ims cafe 
 In tbc drcb'. qucr Cbambcr , SC«-e ti^ojts of tbc Statute are, not being firll 
 ftrook, but an atraultfsnotaftrltitng, anDfobclsontoftbc ietttr of tbe 
 Statute, ant>bcretDEsnoiicaponi);atiin, fo?tbt ftrojDtossIn tbc fcab* 
 fcarD, trblcblcromojetbanaflElf fna.mnrs tanD,Stat. 5 E.6, C 4. anl» 
 ft Is llfee to a pittol uncctfet , sno If tbc fUcjc bat) been t)?au n ft tronlo not 
 bate alterco tbe cafe, btcaufc It tors rot In Hr rwoods bann, tcbo Iras Ilaln, 
 butlnanotbcrs, ano pou cannot rrtrnu tbe Statute furtbcr. Glyn chief 
 luftice, OTfBpoubatcltargucl)*arpmo?c :> Firch, i^o. Glynchleflu. 
 •flice, 3battcton0rlcrcDoftbctI:UTtftf,ar.tltonfuit^l)•U)^tbt^c StatDtr,ani> 
 attffcatcftb aU tbc Suogcs. sro tbcr are of'mfnc cptrfon. STbfs fe a ccoO 
 llato, ant) to be Interp? ctcD Briflip, pet 3 bolu tbc p?H|ner ia net teftbfn ft ; 
 fo? tbc fcopc of tbe Statute sppears'fcp tbc pjean'ble, ttc boBp, arc fating 
 of It, Ubftb DO an confirm mpcpfnfon : fppfirftreafcinfe, tetaufe $ finD 
 tbat tbc Intent of tbe Statute Is anafr.ftfnDccntifBfrg, butbere teas not a 
 fatDenfellifng, ano tbc Statute tabes not atrap tbe CIcrppfrcm all man* 
 netof^anflaugbtec, anDberetcasa^rerpafsanDanlmipjKncment satn 
 
 flgflimi
 
 Micb.i''"5 5' 465» 
 
 agafnffftcpjffonfr before tjcfefUcoHorwood, anofotljcart toig not fuu* 
 Benlpconc alp. EbcboBpoftljcaitf.emgtomeait, tbattljere ortgbt^o 
 be malice <tit!)C cafe, anaUootb not tntcno tne Cbonlo llfcb to tbe Hcrp 
 -toojDoofit; anDbcrctbcpartpflaiiimtgbtbatc fojfeen the Danger, ano 
 xefenoco bititfeU. j'.j' 3Lbepio\3ifo cpccpts D<bcta partfralars out of tbe 
 iLajj, anDtl)etoo:a.-.aifns(conlpfn tbeprovifo, fotbat tb'rc h pjo'^ftt- 
 on msoc boiu tee fe>fflttite fljall be tntcrp^cteu , viz. 2Lb<it it mtift be HiDOeii 
 fefUing, Irbfc./fenotfobvre, fo:t'Ke fcpjo^iocatfons, ahOtt-ne (ntcTl>e- 
 nientbctUnrttbemanotbettabblng, a;iDtb OcrDfttfinosno pjaEtoncrtbco 
 nta'.fcc ; -ana tr>e &t?tutc ertenos to no otUr Wtlfng bp tbe provilo. Jflno If 
 one be afTanltijO bp 2Lbccbcfl toWcb batic no f\iioiD D jatoir , anb tbe partp af. 
 } Biiltitj fi.ib? one of tbe 2Si ccVC0, be fa not loftbfn tbe latent of tbe &tatiite, 
 aUbougbt»cbclBftb'ntbetDo>D0of<t, o?tf one be alTaultco fn t)ts bO'fe, 
 anD t ,c flfaulto} batb no Ucapon Djaton , ano one ot tbe aUauU' 
 to:iabcC)ot, pcttbepariMalTaultcDlo not VDltbfn tbe fetatiite, 15 Car, In 
 Dsvy ana Wiili.ims cafe (tUjasc'iDjujgcDbpaU tbe Jaogea tbat betb'itbfU 
 leo anotbct bp tbioifefng -i l^atnmct at bfm tnaa not toftbbi tbe Statute, be^ 
 taufs tbete lD2s a p:eccD<!Tg pjotocatlonofbtm* ano I tir.oaffanlt atbfro 
 pcrfon , anu one of ti cm ftrfije tbe tbito pcrfon, ano tbe tbfro perfon bflls 
 the otber tbat Dfb not DfrifeE bfur, 3 t>o not conceive be fs ^tiftbfn tbe ferat j'c, 
 f 07 tt i£ tbe affault of botb,ani) (ball alfo be aoiutigeD tbe ftrtking of but 1. A k 
 Juftice belD be tprs tDitbin tbe Statute, bccau e<t Isas not nnlaipfill to 
 comctoarrcftbint , anobrctoaiinouicaponDjatun, and f.. it wm ar^f iir= 
 ned to another day. ^t tofifcb Cap Buckner Irao again b;oug' t to tt.r IB ir , 
 A.k Juflice ripcatfl tbe ipetial tjeroia , imaoc tbe quefllon b-bctbcr tb-e tad 
 lof Buckner be toitbin tbe fetatatc of i lac.enattcD againl* Oabbing,aiiO tjc ac- 
 gncD tbat it teas, ano tbat Backner'coulo not babe bis Clirgp bcca.-ifc tbe 
 &tatatc (ball be taken bcncficiallp foi tbe CommoniDPaltb, ano not f oi rbe 
 . pMfoner, lobo is a pacticnlar pcifon, ano tbt intent of tbe statute is to ta e 
 ainaptbeClergpfojConie fclonp; i^citbcrbp tbe common ilalo, no; bp 
 tbeiiaiDOfCooistbcreClcrgpgi^jenfoj billing -a man, ano it tuaa tbe 
 |j)oplIb potocr tbat introoucco tbe Clergp to be gitjen fo: ij^anflaugbt r, ano 
 alfo fo} murtbet , in Diminution of tbe Common ILaln, ano of regal potocr, 
 pea, ano of the Lain of <Soo alfo, ano if a tooman bill one (be Ojall not babe 
 ber Clergp batbcbangco, tobfcb tbcU'S tbat bp tbe Common iLalu tbe 
 Clergp \ona not gibcn fo; C^anflaugbter. SnO bp tbe SLalo of (Doo 3; fino 
 no Difference bctluan^artbcr ano jpanflc^ugbter, fo;i it mahcs no Biffc- 
 Tcnce brttDern>iotb!ccDanocolDbla>D, aslseoonoiuDfttinguidi; anoebe- 
 rp tuoiD in tbe §>tatutc me tbinbs ootb take atoap tlie Clergp bp toap of ar- 
 gument, ctjenfrom tbe title of tbe 2d: to tbe ticrpeno of it, anobcreisa 
 great fin to be puni(bco, ano crcat incont'enicnccs tooulo foloto to aomit ot 
 tbeClcrgpinfucbcafcsastbtais, ano berc tons a fuooen killing sa tbe 
 att crpjelTctb , fo?it taasooneiBitbaDagguUbicbtoaBnot fen, but fuo- 
 ftcnlpOja^Tjnoutofapoctiet, ano no i capon tsag-ojatDn ngalnft bim, foj 
 tbe p:o^of "tions allegro , tbep c ansiot amount to tbe oiatoing of a toeapon, 
 02 fucb a p;ot)ocatfoa ae tbe Statute fntcnoo , fo; all tbe acts Done bp Hor« 
 wood amountco but to a SCrefpafs, ano cannot be fucb a p^otocation as 
 fcoulo-caure Buckner to fear lis cratb , foj no violence iras uico to bis pcr« 
 fonbpftriling.ojOjalDingofatoeapon. oj otber tnaps, ano tbe fcnoing 
 foi JBailifa to arrcft bimcannct be fucb a p:oTtccatfon as tbe Statute in-- 
 t.noo,tobicbiatoput tbe partp in frsr of fain life, ano tbe partp bnctu 
 tbat Horwood came toitb an intent onlp to arrcft blm , anO not to Uill iiim , 
 nojofo tbe partp flatn 00 anp tbfng agafrft Buckner topjoboUe bint; ano 
 tberctsbppjefumptionof ilatoapiepcnrcomalfcei.tBuckner to Mil Hor« 
 wood, lDl)icb is feen bp bis fuooen manner of (tabbing bint, ano Davye 
 
 ;^oo 3 ano
 
 \- 
 
 ^'J^ ' Mich. 165 5*. ^ 
 
 "anVWilliams cafe dtgcB cm t^c otl^er Cue ia not U^xt to tWa cafe. 31 grant it 
 cwie kill aSLljicf fuoocnlp It I9 not bjftWn tbe &tattitc,fo j fwclj feflUng toas nc« 
 t)ct Intenueo to be pjctcntco bp ft. 2Ct)c loo jtt too joa one man can gftie a. 
 nolftctarenotaCutfitfcntp^oDocatfon \DWn tftc fetatate.fo; fpeaHfng of 
 tDojosDotijmucl) Differ from DjalDing of a tocapon: i^oj is t^fa a UUlfng 
 fc dctendendo , J bp midfojtunc , but a kflKng at tbc Common Hain , ano 
 fo t|)e Clcrgp la taken atcapfaptbc&tatute, anottjofe ofSirj;ant« inne 
 InFlectftrcet , amongft tubom are Bafkly anD Fofter, anoRoll , tobo Ijalie 
 been BSuogea, ate of mp opfnfoit Glyn chief luftice belu ft not toftWn tftc 
 statute, l)c argupD long mucb to tbc effect aa fojmerlp , but baWng taken 
 co'.o 3 coalD not offtinrtlp bear bfm , Adjourned. SDWe Cafe toaa agafn au 
 gneD Trin. idjrf. to cnfo;m lufticc Warburton tobo Icaa callcB to tbat 
 315cncb , after ttje fojmer arguments ano opfnfon of tbc Court oeUtjerco 
 
 * mac^ to tftc fame manner as fo?merlp, IBp Finch foj tbe pjffoner, ano 
 Baldwin foj tbc PjOtettoj , anD tbcrcupon mp Lord chief lufVice Gfyn , anO 
 iuftice WirburtonUjcrc ofoplnfonagafnft luihce A'k, ano fo jnogcment 
 inaa gtbcn fo j ttje p jffonct , tbat tbe Ilabbfng toaa not toftbfn tbe fetatntc , 
 but loab onlp fclotip at tbe Common ILaio, anotbe p}ifonet toaaaomittcD 
 10 Ws Clcrgp, anD burnt fn tlje bano atcojDfnglp. 
 
 VVilliarafon and Coleman. 
 
 Mich. 1655. Banc. ffjp. 
 
 iuon "fT-jponcbfocnccgHJenlnanjactfonof EDrefpaffli bcttD&n WiHiamfon ano 
 P*''- * Colemin at tbcJ5at',3It Ujaa fafo bp Glyn chief Juftice. tbat tf one 
 malsc a tftcb, 01 raffc np a ban!; to bfnocr rap Voap to mp Common , J map 
 juttfflc tljc tb joVDfng of ft Doton, ano tbe fillf ng of ft ap». 
 
 Mich. 1655. . 
 
 Bp Glyn chief luftice, 3lf aiFcme bjfngatojft of ootoct, anorccober, 
 anotbcSDcfenMntDfc, tljefemeftall fjabc (jer oamagea agafntt tfte 
 2Dcir=2DcnantB, 
 
 Micli. 1655.; 
 
 Error qMod \ OTfrft Of Crtoj quod coram vQbis refidet f 3 inbcn a tojft Of Crroj ffl 
 c< tain vobis /\bjongt)t to rcterfc a fuugcment gftjcn fn t'oc Common picas, oi otbcc 
 lefidet, w;iar ^Contt tobcre tbe IRecojD toaa fojmcrlp rcma\3cD f nto tbe Court of tbe <ilp- 
 "i^- per llBer(Cl),ano bp rcafon of tbe Deatbof tbe partp , oj foi fome otbcr caufes 
 
 rcfto unDetctmfneo , bp reafon of tbe abatement of ttie fojmec tojft of 
 
 (Stto?. 
 
 Le pool and Tryan: 
 
 Mich, I (Jy J .Banc. (op. 
 
 . . \ 7 r 7 I'd moiJCD foj a piobfbftfon to tlje Court of aomlraltp to dsig a 
 
 bition''ro°,he V w trpal tbcrc f n a 2Crobcr ano Conberfion , in uj'.jfcb tbep pjocaencD 
 
 admiralty, upoii 3 pjcter.cc that tbc ccDOg fn queftt^n to'erc taken upon tbe !^fgb &ea , 
 
 ano t'.'atbptbelate act tbep babe cjclufibcpoiDct in all fucb cafea, tDbfcft 
 
 luftfi 
 ill Trefp 
 
 Dimages in 
 Dowcr. 
 
 lanotfo. Glyn chief Jaftice, 3t toaa refolbCD fn Cremers ano Cokely, 
 cafe % fo aotuDgcD, ttiat t^ep ^abc no facl) potoet , Therefore take a prohibi 
 tion.nifi, &c, Mor 
 
 es
 
 u 
 
 Mich. 1655,^^ 47 £ . 
 
 Morden and Harr.. 
 
 Mich. 16 J5" Banc, fup. 
 
 Ordeii bjougl)t an action of Debt npon an £)bHgat<on to Cano to an 
 'r atuaro aoa(nft Hare, tllpon nil debcr pleaDcD, ano a tjerofct foj tfjc Juj emwt in 
 ^lafrtttf , ft toafl mot); 6 fn flrrctt of inDgrmcnt , ano tfte cjtceptfon taUen ncbf up'o'n »IL 
 tDa0, tbflt tlieaiDarD tone tnaDC bat of one part, ano To not binDfng to aQ obligation <o 
 t&epartfcafiibmlttfng. Hbctafc Idab tftfo, j©nc Stephens anD Body on'^.»"'it°»n a- 
 onc part , ano Hart on tbc otbcr part fiibinfttco to ttantj to tbe ^toato. SDbe ''''"'^" 
 SlrbftratoisaisatDCD tbat Body fljaulD pap a certain (um of moncp onto 
 Hart (it fatfafartfon fo? tbe olflFcrencca bctaljt Body ano Stephens on tbe one 
 part,anD Hart on tb^otbJ^r part, lub<cblon3ob)eaei>(oaltinotbe ga)D,fc^ 
 tbe moncp paio bp one coulo not be in fntlsfattton fo^ anotbcc, ano fo !be 0- 
 ioarti (snot mane to concltiDc all tbe parties fubmftting^ fo^ Scephent Uias 
 notconccrneoinit, anatbeaiuaroislvitbanhaquod, inbicb ortgbttobe 
 a general atoarD,anti incline a 1! partlc0, anDtberefojcifitbc tJoiDinpart 
 (t i0 toiD in all. Wut Grern on tbe otbcr iloe anflsereD , tbongb tbe atoaro 
 C^oiilb be naugbt (11 part, pet it map be gooo as to Body tbat paio tbe monep, 
 anD tl)c moneps ongtjt to be rcccfbcD as tbcp ate pafo , anD tbat Is fo j Body 
 anDStcph.ns, and map be iDCll in fatisfattlonfojbotb oftbem. Httoasal* 
 fo urgpo bp Howell on tbe fame Coe, tbat it appears tbat Body anb Stephem 
 arc partners, anDtbisiiUlmaltcanenDoftbcmattEc ,foj tbcn tbe monep 
 paio bp one oftbem map fatioftc fo? tbe otber, Glyn chief luftice, l^ereis Award in 
 agooD atoarDbettDdentlvoof tbe parties tbat fnbmitteo, bnt tbere ap-.part. 
 peara notbjng to be atoarDCD as to Stephens , tbe tbiro patcp, foj ft Dotb not • 
 Jippjar tbat be can tahc anp benefit bp tbe atoaro of tbe monep to be paiD bp ludcement 
 Body, o?tbatitcanb.anpfatlsfa(tionfojbfm,butonlpfoj Body* Iudge=for iheOe- 
 ment for the Defendant, nifi. &:c, lendant 
 
 Susfield and Norden. 
 
 Mich. 16 Jj. Banc, fup, 
 
 AMjftofdJrrojtoasbjougbtbpBusfteidagaintt Nordon to tetjcrfe agrjor tore " 
 (utjgcmcntgitjcnintbeCourtfpilftatpof Kippon in an attfon nponvcrfea jud^e- 
 nn indebitatus aftumpiitfoHnaresfolD, ttiberefn tbere befng a ioDgement i":'<c upon an 
 gf*;cn^n:afntttbep?fncipal, a icire f dcias iCTueo out againfttbc IBail , ano a ''"'''"'•^"^ 
 juogcmcnt luas tbcreupon baD againft bim, tbe bail thereupon bifngs a 'f " b*"?/ ''' 
 tojf t ot QErroj to rcberfe botb tbefe foDgements , ano afsigns fo j Ctro?, tbat ' '" 
 tbarcluasnoiffue jopnrD in tbe (Irft juDgement, ano tbat being erronious, 
 ano b-'f 15 tbe grouno npoji to^lcb tbe fcire facias Dio fffuc fojtb , tobereapon ^■''' "J.*"?"' 
 ticfeconDtiiogementMjasgibcn ,tbe fecono jaogcment cannot be gooi. p"ncipii 
 Giyi chieTuftice, JButtbepJfncfpal juDgement ougbt Jo be tcbcrfeo bp ju/^cmctir. 
 tbe pjiiKf psl, anD not bp tbe bail, ana tbetefoje the writ of Error it not well The writ abi- 
 brouj^hc by ttie bail, therefore let it abate. *•'• 
 
 Mi*
 
 f — — — _—— — ^ ~ ■- ■ ■ ■ ■ >■■■ 
 
 ^-ya Mich. 1655. 
 
 V^idian and Fletcher. 
 
 Mich»i6}$.Banc. fap^ 
 
 s- fjcia l^ponT)lctocfaii3nCairtbjoiigl)tfirtoConrttofaefnfpcctciJ, tr&ol)aoDa« 
 f .r "a 'lnt»pi ting cotjcrtutc lopnco iBttl) IjJt busbanu in letjptng a fine of bet lanDs flje 
 
 j^. event, tpngbptbc Court aojuDgeotDttWii age, to^creupon a fcire facias iSucn out 
 f ,c levcj j^ ({j3 E^crt'ttnatitfl '^l)o came fn anopleaoco tbat fljc toas of full age at tljc 
 .uii.gCo- .j(^g(,ftt)CfinclciiicD, tiponltlilcljpliatffuetoagiopncD, ano atrpalUiaa 
 ''""' '^' 1)86 at t!)e afot?c« , anuaacrofitfoj ticpiafntif, tol)onoto came In Court 
 anopjapeu foa luogcinent upon tbe ttlcroftt. Glyn chief Jufticc; 2Ebc 
 hiynotto ^otittteto juoscoftfte 3nfaiicp, ano not t!)c 3urp, ano ttjerefoje pou 
 c, i.iUr.cy. jj3^cnotp,p(ccDeDoulp, but 11)0 pjocccBtngfl DO tto ftutt , fojloejuDgcac 
 Fine rcvcrk J. IMS toitljm agC , Therefore let the fine be reverfed, mfi, &c. Noca. 
 
 and the hundred of Crondcri. 
 
 Mith. 165 J.Banc.fup* 
 
 Arrtftof 
 
 judprmcnrin fc j^ ^cifon of JEtcfpafs upoH tl)C trfc toas bjougftt agafntt tl)e ^uttfijett 
 
 an Aai. n u, - J;\ gf Crondon (n Hacnpftii cupon ttic fi>tat. of Winchefter,bp one tijat toas 
 
 o"huc .*!d ' '^°''^^^ toltlj<n tbc tianDjcD , i upon m trpal a teroto paffeo foj tfje pialntJf , 
 
 Cy<s " SttoasmoticDont^cbcb.Tit of tl)c J^rnajco in jjrrrtt of juDgcmcnt. i, 
 
 Cafc.'^ SCbattbeJDlaintJfbaDmtaakcn Ijfo aafon, foj totjcrcas tje tjati) bjougbt a 
 
 StJtuic. general 0afon of SCrcfpafg upon the cafe, l)^ oogftt to ftabe bjouoljt art 
 
 ^(tfonuponth: Statute, zip. ^c occlarCGtb'itftc trokbtfl Oatb bcfojc I. 
 
 S.aS'.ifttccofpcaccfnttieCountp, irbcrcas it OjoulB be fc; tbe Countp» 
 
 3lp. i^c batf) not cirpjcffeo tbat be tcnfe f)to £)atft bcfojc a 3uftfce afeigneD to 
 
 ijEcp tbe peace. 4lv,£Dbcrt{0nofffueropncD. 5lp.!^efaUb tbat tje tooft 
 
 l)ls£)atb 20 caps, but Dotb not fap ncrt bcfojc, a0 tbe Statute ofrect0» 
 
 Windham OH tbc otbcr Goe anf isercD to tbe firtt Crccptton , tbat it fs ufual 
 
 of latter times to Declare (n an aalon upon tbo Cafe gcncrallp, jCo tbe 
 
 TcconD be fata ft fs no erccptfon, fo; a Blafifcc or JDeace {3 not an Officer af. 
 
 BrcDtoa place. Serjeant Twifd^n, 35utUDotb not appear tbat pou tto^ 
 
 pour £)atb2oonp6bcfo?c pour £);!gfral fueo out. Glyn chief luftice, 
 
 kbat appears VDrilenongb upon tbe lRC(£o;D. 315ut tljc \xiiit bete fa man 
 
 VitU.un. paction Upon tbc cafe general! p, jpsttteccclarcahianilatonapontbe cafe 
 
 upon tbeS'tfltute,tob<tb<fl not all one.ai ft fo tbcSDeclf.ratfcn tarfcg from (be 
 
 trjft , fo} nn flctfon upon tbe Cafe upon tbe fetetutc is an ejrtraojofnarp 
 
 actfon upon tbc cafe , but 3 belfctjc it is toen cnoucb, noticitbairoinu, it be- 
 
 '^- '"•^ (ng after a u ecoirt , nns not being a material \3ar|ancc, but a bare recital , 
 
 judgement. ^ j^j^pj.-jjj.j i^^ ^^ piancit take hit judgement. 
 
 Conye and Lawes. 
 
 Mich, 1655. ^ancfup. 
 
 Hill. i655.rot*25i ?♦ 
 
 vcilc a )u<ie'- 
 
 incnc In an T Awcs bjouftbt an SciOH upou tbc csfc againft Conye upon an indebita- 
 A^.i'nupon JL^tusailuraplituponanaccompt, tbc 5?cfenDant plsaoco non affumpfit. 
 
 l:t:oi to re- 
 verie a judf
 
 Mich.i655' 4.73 
 
 ami opon fffue fopnce, afpzdal tcrcfctiDaofouiiDfojt^c^IafntffTartD^ 
 tuogemcnt g<t);n fojWm, tipon t!)c fpcclal fecrufct tbccaa appearcotobe 
 t^fo.t^c j|iJla(nt(f I aw5 mar(co a f^emc unto tobom monfcsirerc okifngiiutn 
 folatuif, anDtbeiBaron, ano tljcDcbtouomctoanaccomptfojt^smonp, 
 tl)c 2Dcbtoj befra four.D (n firrcrc pjcmlfetl) tijc JBaron to pap fjfm tbc monp 
 Due upon tlje accompt at a ccrtfi<ii Dap, ? fo j not pcrfo; mlng, ibfs pjomffe tfte 
 JDlafntffb^oupbtWs 2ctfon. apon t^e to;ft ofcrrojb;ougt)t<ttoasurgeD, 
 tftat tlje plafnt(f t»io not UkId boto tbc monks became cue to the \oife , ant 
 tbat tbc accompt ofa not alter tbc vEafc, ano Hcrndcn ant) Palmers cafe, 
 Hob. 88.uascftcDtobcliljetl)fccare, ano Done ano Thorns cafc,24 Car* 
 in tt)(6 Court ioas alfo cftcD , am 20 H. 6. f. jo. b. Wild on tbe otjjcc Coc 
 fafo tbat tbe ^Declaration <3truc, anD t^e tcrcfct contra jfaa <tnot, foj 
 bp th0 marfage tbc Debt ie Due to tlje^usbsno, aiiDtt)crcfoje bcougbtto 
 b;fng tbe 5lit(on, anot^c cafe Dfffirs from Hobarts cafe: Glyn chief Iu» 
 nice, H. barts cafe f0 not U [jc tl)(3 ft Is true tbc accompt 'Iters not tbe na- 
 ture oft^c:3ctfon, but bcrc t^e tierDld fitiDa tftat tljcre tDaaafpccfal pjo- Special pro- 
 mifc maoe to pap the monies to tbc l^usbanD, anD tbere map be an actual ■"''i^* 
 pjcmffe In an infimui computaverunc,alt^ougb tlje latD Dotft create a pjomlfe 
 iD^ere a fpcclal p;omlfe Is not (&eU)CD,anD ^ecc Is a DlSlnct Dap fo; papment 
 of tbe monp allcacD, nno tljc conCoeratfon fs gcoo, foj ft Is a Debt Due -^"''p'"''*'" 
 to tt)c l^u0bano,anD be map rcleafelt , ano tfje Doubt maDe bptbe'^"^'" 
 3urp Is, Ynbabcr tbe 0ctlon be toell bjongljt bptfje i^jsbano slone 
 o> not. at anott)cr Dap Green urgeo , tbat tcre Dotft not appear 
 a confiDcratlon foj tbe fpscfal p;omlfe , ano tftcn ft can be taken 
 but fo} a pjomlfe in iLaiu , anD upon fuel) a pzomffe tbe Sictfon Pro^ife !n 
 cannot Ipe , fo> tbe Debt Is Due to tbe hilfe nottoftbttanatng tbe marlage. '*'*• 
 Wild anfttcreo, tbe accompt Is gooD to tbe JBaron to grounDtbcpjomlfc 
 upon, ano be cfteD Partridge* Cafe, ano tbe pjomlfe bete to pap tbe monp af 
 a Dap Is a fp^ clal pjomlfc anD not crcatcD bp tbe iLauu , ano.tbls makes tbe 
 conCottatlon gcoo, ano tbe SDeclaratlon Is true, foj It Is the f^asbanas Debt, 
 ano tbe tierolct confirms It , ano If tbe toffe op tbe aomfnt tlratlon belongs to 
 tbe i^usbanD , tublcb pjctics ft Is bfs Debt, ano tbe Inift of crroj Is not gooD, 
 anDfotbclRccojDlsnotrcmotjeo, tbeiDjftofetrojfs DircctcD totbeipal- 
 oj anD &bcrlfs of Lincoln , anD tbe Court Is falD to be belD bcfo:e tbe &bc« 
 Tifs onlp. Glyn chief luftice, 2tbe nature of tbe Debt I0 not cbangcDbp tbe tJebt chjn- 
 accompt, no'mojc tban tbe accompting toltb anCrccutoj, but a fpecfal s'^'^- 
 pjomtfc map alter tbe Debt: ^ftcrclaa p;omffe maDctotbc i^uobanc, ano 
 ^e batb b lougbt tbe action aa if tbe Dcfcnoant tpcre InDcbteo to l;lm, pet be 
 ie not InaebteDtoblmgcncrallp, but rubmodo,tl5. jurenxoris, SLbcrefe 
 anotbcr point In tbe Cafe, 3 conceive berc Is caufe of action, but tobetbcr it 
 be applicable to make ftafpccfal Debt Is tbe qucttlon. But the writ of error ^^)5'']J'^"'*^ 
 is naught, therefore let it be quafhed. quaihtd. 
 
 Arnold anci Floyd. 
 
 Mich, »fi55. Banc, fup, 
 
 ARnold a JlBjuet bjounbt an action of Debt upon a 55onD fopcrfojm » „ ( 
 articles agafna Floyd bis Clark. Cbe iffcrt of one of tbJ articles iadgernVnc 
 tras,tbat tbe SDcfcnoant tljoulD ocUtcr toceklp fucb aie anD 15ccr as fljoulo .n debt upon 
 be Delf pcrco unto bf m to fucb Cuftomera as be bao In bis cbargc, 4 to r. cclbe »" obiip»u- 
 tbe monies of fucb Cultomcrs as toerc Due f oj tbe fame, ano tbe crcffc,anD ""/° Fe:form 
 fljoulD accompt ctjerp Saturday tcffiklp nnto tbe plalntif foj ftKb monies as"'"^ '*' 
 %z Ibonlo uwiiz fo; tbe fame, fo: b?eacb oi Cofienant tbe ipialntie 
 
 IPPP af«
 
 •certain 
 
 474 Mich. 1655. ~ 
 
 afsigno tijat tfte SDcfciwant Din not accompt Ittitti ti<m fo; fuel) monf es as be 
 1)33 retetticD upon Saturday tlje 26tli. ofluly 1654* anofoj tt)fol)c bjfngfl 
 Wfl 0£tfcin. tUlpon fffuc Jopncu, anD a tjcrofa founn fo j ;tUe ipiahitif, (t inaa 
 inoljco fn atreft of jiiogcmcnt, tftat tlje bjeact) toas nnccttalnlp allcgco, be* 
 f aiife tftc piafnttf Dotlj not QjelD, that tt)e SDefcneant bao anp Cuftomcre fii 
 tjfs cljargc, oj Uibo tbcp lucre, j tbat be bao oclf betcD i!lc 0; 315ccr to t!icm, 
 oj t ctcftcD« np monp of tljcm Giyn chief luftice , SCftc cftar(](c is too gene* 
 rallp fct fo:th, foj pou ougbt to Ijatoc OjctncD luftat monfcs be batb rrcd'oeo, 
 nno tijat ft teas of t Dofc Cuftomcro f n l)fo charge, fo j t!;c ^Dlafntff mav hatje 
 ''■'^^' fcticral XlnrUOjano fome dittomcia map bcfii t^JCtjargc of one Clarli.ana 
 
 M iprPieat ^°'"^ (titiiccbargc of an otl)cr,rotl)attbc charge .ffl not certain. Therefore 
 
 ^; I cjpi.i p, let Nil capiat per billam be entred for the Defcndanc, 
 
 iliiii. 
 
 ToFc and Day. 
 
 Mich, 1555, Uppjr Bench* 
 
 irnrtnrc- A iji ^ctfoii Of 2Defat tuas .b;ou5l)t (n tljc Common picas, ano a 
 vcife a ju,ip,' /Xtuojjcmcnt gtbcn foj tlj: piafnttf, toho tljcrctipon taUes out etecutfon, 
 mem i.jna viz. a Fieri facias , anD Delfljcrstttotlje&berffo ofNorwircb, teboeretateo 
 ^1' c"ca"rrtor *^ ''i' Icvpfiig tbc Debt upon tl)c ccDfl ann chattels of tljc JDcfcnoant , after 
 m.kin^ <a. \x^ic[) {\)z &!)rrlf3 Iticrc Dlfcharreo tftcfr ^fficp,janD ncU) §>l)crffg clecteDfti 
 i.Lc return 0! t^cfr plflccs. Mljereupon the o'd fehcrffs reoeUbcrcD to the partp the DeeDa 
 ' Writ. tahcn in crcciitton, bp tcrtuc of the Fieri facias, anD cnDojfcD nulla bona np« 
 on the to?<t of Fieri facias . anD DelfttercD ft fo cnDojfcD tinto the ncto &he« 
 rffs, anD fo: maUfngof tlifsrctojn an 0ctfon upon thcCafiMijaB bjonght 
 in the Common pleas agafntt the ttoo oId &hcr(f3, ano a fuDgcmcnt obtain* 
 PTJ agaJnftthcm; tohctc.ipon a to;ft ofcrrojlnashcrebjoachttorctjetre 
 thfo tiiogcmciih, ano thsfccfcrptfonsltjcrc taken, 1. Chat the plafntlf 
 fn hf3 E>cclaratlon fn hts flctfon upon the Cafe 00th notfap, that thcolo 
 Rrr .ni. &!)Crif3 Df 1 rPtojn nulla bona , but onlp that tl)Cp DfD cnDOjfe nulla bona up- 
 on tbc tojft, tohlc^ fs not a rctojn. anD fo the ^ctfon cannot Ipc foj a falfc re- 
 tojn. nip. ^: fapei^ that the olD fehcrlfs DcUtjcrcD the tojft thus enOoifcD to 
 the ncltt,but 00th not fap that thep Dfo Delffacr ft to be vcto?ncD,viz, bp 3InDen« 
 '...rfcniiir ; tiTC; as the u'e fs. jlp. 3t Doth not ?».';pear luhcthcr there tocrc anp retojn of 
 t'ocraft maoe cither bp the olD&'-crffs o: the neto.4lp.2Chc flcffon is brought 
 in a tojon? Co^ntp, fo: ft fa not bjought in t!)C Countp ^jn^iztz the cnDojfe* 
 ment ano DcU'oerp ol)cr of the to:ft Vons Latch of counccl on the other Goe 
 anfioercD, that the ;2lctfon tons brought fo j DcUberfng the gooDs bach again 
 to the 2>;iiJnDant after theph^D tnkcn them bp tjcrtiic of a Fieri facias, ano 
 not foj the cnDojfemcnt maoe upon the tojft. The rulewastoreverfethe 
 ]U(3gemrn', tx;epc caufc fliewtd co the con-rarv. ^t another Dap the Court 
 toas mo'jco to afSrinthc fuDgcmciit, ano theconncel on the other Cocfn* 
 fitted upon the foimcr ctccptfons to retjrrfc the )uogcmcnt. Glyn chief 
 luflice canfco the Urcojo to be reaD, ano upon Oyer thereof faio, 31 conceive 
 it is Vnell , anoaccojofngtothecourfcfnthatUinD, fo; the olD Sherifsto 
 ira'.jc t'e r:to;n, anD to DcUtjer the to:it oticr bj^^nDcnturetothenelo 
 fe>vjcrfrp,anDhcretoalfon bcrDfctfnthc Cafe, anD a rctojnfsnotpjopetlg 
 a rctom until! ft be filcD here, pet it is the rctojn of the &hcrif in the Conn- 
 tp iDhSiC he is &hcrif. Shew caufe upon n\3cice why the judgement ought not 
 tobc rcverfed. Ancea. Q., 
 
 Den: 
 
 N'cnu:
 
 Mich, ift' 5 5 47 5 
 
 Denton. 
 Mich. 1^55' Banc, Tup, 
 
 A0 ttittt Of tbe puidifttte &efetong mace apafnS one Denton foj ((^e To quanta 
 feffiping of affiaftaro cl)flo Vdrs ^cmotJcD (nto fbisJi^ourt bp aCertiorarl, ^"""^'^ ^' '« 
 ano tbe partpalfo uboiDagcommittcD to Aih bury- gaol fojaffobep^nfit^fio^"'^^*^' 
 o?OEr,U)a0 b?oast)t (nto Contt upon a H abeas Corpus gratiteo unto Wm, ano ""'' 
 npon t!iercat)fnsoftl)erctojnoftl)eH beasCorpu;, tl^fscrccptfoniraBta- 
 hen to tl)e rctojn. that H appears bp t\fz rctojn tftat ti:e o;dct mace fo; Den- 
 ton to U&p t^e SBattatD c^ilo toaa maoe bp tt)e Bluftfcee at tbe ^uatter &er> 
 fions, ano tbat foj not obepfnatWo ojoctibetDaacommftteo totbeOaolbp 
 tlDO Sufffces at a pjftiatc feefsfonBOf tbc peatc, tDfjercas tbe ^uttfces of tbe 
 £!iuarter ^efsfons t)ao no autbo;<tp bp t^e Statute to ma lie Tucb an o>- 
 net , fo} ft oasbt to bate bxn mace tp tbe ntr^t tU30 BJnftfces of peace to f be 
 place tDbere tbe SBaftaro toasbojn. Sinn to tbfs Giyn chief lufllce agreeo, 
 but tDonlo not releafe tbc pjffonct tf II be toas bouno obet toftb 5000 bapl to 
 tt;c nc);t €inatter Versions fo; tbe Conntp of Buckingham, toappeattbetc 
 ano to anfluet tbe fad. 
 
 ♦ 
 
 Att Lee and the Lady BaUinglas, 
 Mich. i^;5.Banc. fop^ 
 
 T^^e Contt teas moben on tbe 2Dcfen!)ant« bebaIf,tbattbetctDa8aaTo difchrge 
 Action upon tbe Cafcbjongbt agafnC JBaton anb ifeme , anD tbe a feme covert 
 JFeme bao appearco , but tbe IBaton UjouId not , ano tbat tbe piafntffa "p°" common 
 0ttojnep ttooD to babe fpecfal bapl fo> bet, tobtcb Ibe toula not pjo: ^'y'* 
 cure, ann tberefojcfttoaapjapco, tbat (bemfobtbc uclibfreouponcom^ 
 
 mon bapl. JSut Glyn chief luftice anftocretJ, if there be caufe to have fpecial Denied. 
 bayl tbe w^ife inuft lyein Pnfon, ontill the Husband appear and put Ui bay! for 
 bcr, for (he cannot put in bay I for herfdf being Covert Baron. 
 
 Elmes and Miirtyn, 
 
 Micb. 1655. Banc, fup. 
 
 nr^c Court tnag mobeojoj tbe piafntfftbatfnrefpcct tbat tbe 2Defcn=i^or "me to 
 -■■ Dant bao put fn a fpecfal pica, anOpIcaBCDa bcrp long ^Itoaro , tcbfcb "^J"""' •" ' 
 mabc tbe pica betp long , tbat tbercfojc be mfgbt babetfmccrantcDnnto'' * 
 Wm bp tbe Court to Demur to tbfs plea. Cut Glyn chief luftPce anfteereo, 
 you need not have time to demur to che Plea, for you may do [that prcfcntly: Denied. 
 but ifyoudefire time to rejoyn in refpedt of the length of ibe Plea, you (hall ^'^°^°''"' 
 have it. 
 
 F lummer and Sir John Lenchall. 
 
 Mich 1655. Banc. fop. 
 
 I an aafott of cfcapc agafnC &ft John Lcnthall tbe i^^arcfcball oflbe^''^" '-="" 
 jpatOjalfca of t^jfn Comrt , anb bao tberenpon a jwogement ano an wcotl. hu oftcc. 
 
 ^e piifntff ftetDco to tbe^Comt bp bfBCo«tttdtbafbebaDb:oH?bt''"° P"fSir 
 
 "sir John Lcnthall tbe i^^arcfcball of tbe' ' 
 J tbereapon a juogement ano an mcntf* [
 
 476 Mich. 1^5 5- 
 
 Tn'asafnftUin, buttbat&lr iQhntfjotiel) as being ^artball be otigftt as an 
 £).ficcr of tbfo Court DaUp to atteno tftc Contt, cfDpctncbettbclcfgab. 
 lent blinfcf , fo tbat tlje JDlafntf f coiilo not tahe bfm upon tbc erecution, ano 
 tbat If l)C iDcrc p jcfcnt Ijc Doubtco , iutictbcr be mfgbt tahc bfm , fo j fear ft 
 tDOuio be an cfcapc of tl)c pjifonera commltteo to t)<in, ano tbetefojc pjap- 
 cD tljat S>(c John Lenthall m<gt)t bcput otit ofWs plfcc Of ^arcfcall,tbat 
 fo be mJgbt take b<ni tn Cjecutton. C.lyn chief Juftice, TIii$isverymifchi«= 
 ^j.jfj VOU-, lee Sir 3obn ibcw caufe Friday next why hcftiould nocpaythemo' 
 
 nie$, 
 
 Le Grofs and Hall. 
 
 Mich» 1^55. Banc, fup, 
 
 Tn rtvc fc al5P ^ ^jit (if Ctvoj bjonjjbt in tbis CTonrttotctctfcajutigcmentBtbert 
 ju.'p Mirnc 'tn an 3ct<on of Debt SLbc SDcfciiDanto Cotinccl fn tl;ciu;ftofCtro> 
 for txi-idiii- moljcD , tbat tbe Court tnoulD TCtocrfc tbejuDgement bccaufc tbcp con= 
 *"'■ cclocD ft Voao trroneonc, fo: tbc<r oton crpcoftfon, tbat tbcp mffibt bjfng a 
 
 neiD aafon. G!yn chief luftice, |9on bate not pet confcCfeo tbe crroj upon 
 ti)c lReco?o, neftbet batocpouplcaoeo innulloeff erratum, as pou ougbt 
 Dei le.i for tQ jjQ gj^jj tjjgtpfojg YQy move too foonto have the ludgemcntrcver* 
 
 inovngo, ,^j 
 luuii. 
 
 Hamond and T'hoinhill. 
 
 Mich, l6J5.Banc, fup. 
 
 vvh<ti-cr gj- T ^ *^^ ^^^^ "^ °"^ Haraond am Thonhill Inattcrpafsjauo ejectment 
 veikm^i-iasio ItrpeD at tbe 315ar, upon tbe ctjoence glben ftlBasaffirmcDbpSergeinc 
 luid by chi- Twifden, tbat vHJatJclhfnD lanD0 tbougb tbcp bcbelobpiinfsbt'rettkctc* 
 vai.ybcdc nurc. mfrbt be all Di;t3ffeo bp mil\ bptbccuttouiot Kent, Q.fo;otbct 
 viieab-e. CouncclDoubtcDofft, 
 
 Arnold and Floyd. 
 
 Wich. 1655. Banc. fup. 
 
 T10fs Cafe fojmerlp fpoUcnunto, anD after a Nil capiat per billara,nifi, 
 &c. ojoereD to be entren agafnft tbe plafntfttoafi again fpoUcnunto, 
 ano tbe Cafe put, ano tbe eyceptlonfojincrlptaUcn tbat tb- piafntff baote* 
 tlarcDofagEneralretcitifngof monpoffucbaiiD fiicbCuttomcrij, ano baa 
 not attomptco fo; tbem, tobercas ttjc iSrtfc'.cs fo j bjeatb of tobicb tbe 3lat- 
 onfo bjougbt 00 crpjcfs tbat be IboulD accompt foa fucb moiifcg ao be Qioulu 
 ttcefticoftbeCuftomets.tobfcbtocrcfabfscbargc onlp. IBitt Green an- 
 ficereo, tbat tbougb ft toaa not fo crpictrco, pet ft fljoulo be fntcnocD tbat be 
 fca^ notatconiptcDfoj all fucb monies aa be baorcccttjcD of tb^ Cutlomcre 
 fn bis cbargc . anoastoanotbeteicccpttontobicbUjasalfofojmerlpta&en, 
 VIZ. t!;at tbe piaintff baU not fbstocD tobat monies bebnorcccitco. foj 
 tobicb tlje IDcfenDant baonotcctomuteo, ano fo be tuieU) not tobat anftoer 
 to gf t»e, Green anftoereo, tbat tbe piaintif is not bounD to fljeto it p?ecf fe- 
 Ip fo; be cannot telt inbat tbe IDefcnnant baa tcceftieo, ano tobat not , but 
 tbe SDcfenoant ootb bnoto it \deU encugb. Glyn chief lurtice , 3f /Donbt of 
 tbat, fo} tbe piaintif muft fenoto tbat tbe SDcfenoant batb tctcitjco fomc mo- 
 nies
 
 Mich. 15 5 5- 47^ 
 
 'ii!c0tof){cl)'[)eftatl)notaccomptcDfo?, otljErtoffc tfjere is rto taiife of adfort, ^ 
 
 ant) tljongl) ft be not ncccffarp foj pontoQjctoalltbcpartkulatfamat^B 
 SDcfenuant ftatt) rcccften ano not accomptea fo j, pet poa muft Etpjcfa fome 
 fani tDf tl) to&lil) to cfjarge Mm luUftall, ano tfterefo?e ao to tftfe cjceptfon, 3 
 tbfnk (t material , onu tfte £Dct!arat(on ia too general to tfjarge tijc E)efen. 
 tant bp, fo J tofeat iffuc can be jopiieo upon t\its ^ foj berc ootlj not appear to 
 i)c anpbjc«tl)ofttcartfclcfl , btit onlp bp fmpUcatton t^atfte ^jatljrcce^ 
 Vtn fome monies nnarcoimfco foj,anD an fffuc rannot be ttpcD upon a 
 p:cfiimpt<on. Crctn pjapen Icatctoofftontfntic tbejactfon J5at Wildp'^7' 
 on t!)e otl)cr Coc fatti It ougljt net to be, becaufc tftc actfon (0 bjotigftt agafntt '" "'"P"""* 
 a 6>nrctp onlp tW inac bouno foj tlje JPcfenoant tbat fje ftoulo pcrfojm 
 SIrttclco. Glyn chief luftice, Jf Ije Do Difcontfnuctfjc Sflfon, fccbatbno^'^""""": 
 furtfic r tcmeop analr.fl tbc E>eteniiant. But fhcw caufe why he fliould not *""' 
 appear upon the Artittts, and Co pay fo much at jc ftiall be tcund that he Is 
 dampnificd by breach of them, and chen.be (hail difconcinur, 
 
 Dcvercux and Jacklbri; 
 Mich. i(55j,Banc«fap. 
 Hill, 1^54, ror, 835. 
 
 AWrft of CBrto; iuaa bjousbt to rctcrfc a jtrtgemcnf gften fn an j^. Error to re; 
 flfon of SDebt, ann tfte erteptfoti tafeentoas, fftat tbepafnt<fljao''"'"J"'*J!'- 
 bjongbt b<0 Siaion foj 14 I. ano be occlarea of a SDebt cue tobfmfoj""'"' mdebt. 
 toatea folo bp b<ni unto tbe SDcfcnbant , icbtcb bp bfs oton ftetolng 
 come but to ttoeltic potmo. Glyn chief luftice, K conccftje U is not 
 fiooD foi tbc tjatfance, ano tbercfo;elettheIudgemencbereverfe<i,nifi/*'''*"«. 
 
 gfC^ . 'Reverfed. 
 
 Pooly and Maikham. 
 
 Mich i65 5.Banc, fup, 
 
 T" ^e Court \rao motcu tbat tbc fecconoarp mfgbt retojnaJurpttponForthe sc- 
 Affidavit tbat tbe ipiaintiftn afojmcrtrpal bcttocen tbe partfea baD^ndary to 
 feaftcD four of tbc 31nrp,anD bao alio feafteo fome oftbeSlurp tbat arc'"""' ^"T- 
 rcto jneo upon tbfa trpaU Glyn chief luftice , Let the FreehoJderj book be 
 brought to the Secondary , and let him retornaiury. Grcnrcd, 
 
 The Protedot and the Town ofKingftonupon 
 Thames^ 
 
 Yates his Cafe and others* 
 
 Mich, i5sJ. BanCflup, 
 
 v; Ates ano four 0; fite otbcr pcrfona, irrccmen of tbc SCoton of Kin^jfton "["^ of'!|Vr'i; 
 f upon Thames,befng oiflfrancVffcD bp tbc I5aplff0,«.of tbatCo?po?atfon,of Rcftiimion 
 ntotcD fo; alDjUofreftftutfontobcrcftojeoto tbclrfrccoomfl ano places 'o Frtemcnf 
 In tbat SCotDit , ano bao ft grantco , tobfcb to jf t toau accojofnglp oltetteo to p'"^*' '" 
 tb« JBmm, %t, of tbatCo?pojatfon,it)botbctenponOomafec reto:n oftbe,^^''f|;^""„"P' 
 
 iPPP3 to?ft,'
 
 478 Mich. 16 55. 
 
 tojft, ani) tbcrcfn fet fojtl) at large tljcrc Charter ano pMtiflcgeaoftlje 
 SLoton , ano tbccaufc ott|ieDf0fTanct)(rcmcnt of Y^tei am t^c otljcre , and 
 ttMtotus iDtii? t^ep toere not to be reffo^teo. 0nD bp t!)c rctojn tbe matter 
 of tact foj tuWcft tftrp lucre Dtsftaartifec appeareo to br tn fubffantc t|}(g,viz» 
 t^at t^crc leas a Dfffcrcncc amongtt tbofc of tt)C Co?po;tatfon abont maUiiig 
 an0tto?npoftticfrCoatt, at a Court bciD fo;ti)8SLolon,t^fittbcrc \o&0 
 libe to be a tumcilt ano appear about tbfs matter ; tobcrcnpon tbe BapUfs 
 ttwt belD tlje Cotirt Dfo aofonra ttie Conrt, ano commanocoaUp.rfons 
 tberc to Depart, anotbentbcp lujtbtbc reft that \tcrc of tbcfrpattptocnt a- 
 toap. IBut tbc otbcr parties on tbe contrarpQoe, totieteofY'rcsanDt^c 
 reft tbat mere Diofrane^fcDlnercn partttapeDtt(n<ntbe2^olon']l^aU, ano 
 (alb, tbc Court toao not offfoltco, ano DfonifirmtbrptoereaCourt, ant> 
 D<D tbcrupon maljc ofbers o^ocro o; acta of Court,anD canfco tbetn to be en» 
 trcD in tbe Court booh tobere ali tbe oxntrs ufeo to be entreo VLo tbfs reto^n 
 manp crccptf ono tocre talscn, ano firftbp Serjeant Twifden, i. SCbat bete 
 teas no fufficfcnt matter of fact rctojnco to be Done bp Yates ano the otberOt 
 to caufe tbem to be cfsfrancbifcD. zip. Ebat tbe rctojn tfo not fl)etD, tbat 
 tbe Cuttoms of tbefr Co^poiiatfon Dfb toarrant tbemtoDfsfranccifean? 
 fo; fucb offencee, o? ofo Qjeto tUat anp petfon bao at anp time been otsfrans 
 tbtfcD fo J fucb offences, 3 Ip. fiCbe rcto;n mentfona tbat tbe ptrtona btr= 
 francbifcDbaubjokentbelroatbaag jTrecmcn of tbe Colon , but ootb not 
 fet fo?tb tbfa oatb at large as it ousbt to be. 4lp. aEbep do not Qjeto in tbe 
 rctojn tbat tbep bao anp autbo;itp to bolo tbat Court tobicb tbep otf. 
 rolbcD, no> before ^bom it loa^s belQ. 5lp. Bit ia not (bettieo in tbe 
 retojn tbat Yate* ano tbs otbcra toere at aU conbentcD to anftoet tbefr offeti« 
 cca, anb To tbep ate conoemncD toitbout bearincoftbem, tobicbiaiBe^ 
 gal. STo tbcfc erccptiona Green of Councel tomainfain tbe rctojtt 
 HiaDC tbfa anttDcr, fo; tbe firtt be faio , t!)ere ootb appear a fufficfent fact to 
 be Doncjbp Yates ano tbe reft tocauretbcmtobcDi3francbffeD,viz. tbeft 
 tumultuoua going into tbe Court, ano ftapingtberc after it iDaaBitTolbeD, 
 anD making of joera, ano entring tbem into tbe IBooH, ano citeo &it lames 
 Bags cafe, tbat tbia tbcir fact toaa a corrupting tbe ojoera of tbe Coion. jFo j 
 tbereconDtbereto;nDotbruf6cfentip crp^cfa, tbat bp tbeir Cuftoma tbe^ 
 map remotje pcrfona from tbeir placeo in tbe Cojpoiation foj fucb offences, 
 Removcahic. foi tbs rcto?n faitb, tbat perfons bate been from time to time remobcable, 
 tobicb iaafloneaaifftbao faio, tbep babe been remobeb. jlp. litis not 
 neteffarp to fet fo jtb tbe itbole oatb of a iFrccmsn, ano bere ia a« mncb ot 
 tbe oatb mention ea as fa neeofull to Ojevu tbat tbe oatb toas broken bp 
 tbem. 4lp. 3t is (betoeo in tbe reto^n, tbat tbe Court Isas belo accojofng to 
 tbt^ir CuSomes , ano (0 it (ball be intenoeo to be a gooo Court , ano rigbtip 
 belo , ano it neeos not to be erpjeffeo befoje Inborn it toaa belo. 5IP. 3t 
 is erpjcffeo tbat t^ep toere conbcnteo, ano tbat tbep baoalfo notice of tbe 
 Diffolution of tbe Court, Mr, Attorney General on tbe fame fioe faiO, 
 l^ere is caufe to oisfrancbife tbe parties; fo; bere appears bp tbeir fact to be 
 Opyjofition cia fctting up of gobernment agninftgobermncnt, ano tbiss fa corrupting of 
 R. vet lime in. gotcmmcnt, ano oone bp hnotoing pcrfons tbat tocllunocTflanotbcCa« 
 ftomeoftbeSCoiun, tobicb makes tbeir crimes tbe greater, ano it is better 
 retojneo , tbat fucb pcrfons arc remobeable, tban to fap tbep batie been rc- 
 mobeo, ano bere is moje tban an opfiifon of one of tbe parties agcrnft tbe 0* 
 pinon of tbe otbers, fo» tbep babe reouceo tbcir opinion into m Set to oifturb 
 tbe gobcrnment. ^r. !ileco?Der of 1 ondon on tbe fame fine fain, tbat here 
 is a fact Done to craoicate tbe tobolc gobcrnmcnt of tb-2Co ton, for Doing 
 tobeteof tbe parties juftlp oeferbe to be olsfrancbifeo , ano tbeir entrfng of 
 ojocrs into tbe 1Regtfter>foookisa corrupting of tbe Cuffoma of t^eSDoton, 
 auOtenO0totftcfubbcrtionoftbeCojpojation,anobccftcO28 H, 8, Malc- 
 
 verers
 
 Mich. 1655. 
 
 v«rer5 casein Dyer. Alleyn oti t^e fame Qoc, f^etc fa faffitfgnt canfc IfteteeO' 
 ia t!)e teto?n to turn tftc partfcs out of ibeft cfftccs , unto toljfcb t^ep pjap 
 to be rcftojcD {f tftercfljoulonot appear Mttitnt ntattw to niehmcWe 
 tftem. Roll l»l)o teljen t^fa caC. iraa firft mofcco tuas chieFInftice. fafo, ftcte 
 ii3 one Groves ttiat pjaps to bc|cfto?eo,concernfng irftom t\)e retojn ftctD0 
 no cattfe at all toljpbe toasrewotocD, but oniptljatftctDaocnofttcoofiTe.^' """f °^ 
 lonpjiuWcijfsnotafuffictentcauf, fo}t)smai> be ciiDftfeo falfclp, ano U mem." 
 Bot'6 not app:ac that anp t.;(ns l)Hti) been aa pet Done upon tijc (Enofctment, 
 ano pet t^ep allege tftfa ioi caufc irbp tbep tofll not r. ttoic bf in , anu f f pon 
 Ijatie no caufc to rcntoUc ftfm, tbcn be (s miniillp rcmotjcD, ano ougbt to be 
 tctto?e9, ano tljfs caufe poii ba\)c OjctDCD, fucft as ft fs. was after tbat ^e inas 
 temoteo,anDrocoulobenocaufeofl^fgtemot3al. 315ut fo; tbe reft tberc fa • 
 no qiieftion but tftatb^rc fa a bfgft contempt, ano juft caufc to ofsfrancbire 
 tfte partfcs,fo}ljerefaniojct!)anan opfnfon, asftatbbeen urgcofoj tbcrn, 
 fo^ tbcre fa an ^ct of a l)f gb nature tcntitng to ebcrt all government in ^fn< 
 Djfng tbc pjocccDfnga of 3I«ftfcc , ano ibe pjofit ano tnellfarc of tbc 
 CotDn, anD a greater offence of tbfs nature cannot be fmagfneo, ano 
 tbcrefoic foj t^c matter tberc fa caufc to ofafrancbffc tbem. JBut 
 rte queftfon fa , tobetbcr tlje retojn bz gooo , ano aa to tbat 31 con* 
 ccftie ft not ncccffeirp to fet fojtft tl)8 toljolc £)atb , oj to atjcr tbe 
 flDcarlng of tfte attojncp» But tbe rctojn ougbt to bate been , tbat 
 bp tbcfr Cuttome tbep bate ufea to rcmotie perfona foj fucb offencea, Hive ufcJto 
 ano not to fap tbep arc remoftcable , ano of tbfs 31 Doubt ano Infll aoijffe. '««>°vc. 
 0t anotbcr Dap Latch ofCouncclfo J Yates argco ttiat tbe rctojn luae not 
 gooD , fo J tbep batjc not Cbelon anp SLa. oone to rcmotjc anp perfon foj mft- 
 oemeanoja, accojofngtotbecuftom, aatbcpbab: aUcgeo ft; foj tbe re- 
 turn fapa onlp tbat fucb partfea batie been remotafalc, ano tbfa fa enlp a 
 pofafbflftpofanatt, anoftappearanotbotDtbcpare rcmotiafale , eftbcr bp pofsjbiiit, of 
 tbcfr Cuftom. o% bp tbcfr Cbarter , ano confcquentlp berc fa no grouno foj an Aa, 
 tbcfr reraotjal returneo , Pafch. ^3 Eliz. C» B, apotcntfalCuttomrcturneo 
 ianotgcDD, pofli:& potuifletaDjuogconot gooo fn S>ft William Hattonsf*"'"'''' """ 
 cafe , ano 2 1 lac. ufus fuit bclo naugbt. ^no a0 to tbe £>b)c(tfon tbat ft fa ' "oT "^^ 
 not neceffarp to return tbcfr potncr torcmo'oe , becaufc It fa a tbf ng fncf oent 
 unto tbctr Co?pojatfon , 3lanftDcrtbrpbabcrctnrneD a potoer, but babe 
 not maoc ft goon bp tbe return. Mag Cfiart. 2 5. ano to tbe ^Dbjcctfon tbat 
 a return nccoctb not to be fo fojmal aa a pleaofng , ano tftat tberefojc ff 
 Ibcf r poiner Do appear upon tbe tobolc return ft fa gooo enougb , 31 anf tocr, 
 tbat tbep batie fafleo fn tbe bcrp matter of tbef r pjefcrfptfon , ano not fn tbe 
 fojm onlp , ano tbep muft ccrtffie n gooo caufc of tbcfr remotal , tbat tbe 
 CourtmapfuDgcefft ; anoaatotbatUjbfcbfBobtccteD, tbat tbefr Cbar» 
 tcr fa a Ijcrpantient Cbarter, ano tbercfoje cannot be pleaoeo , 31 anftoer, charter piea- 
 tbattbcpmapgfbeftfn etfoence, ano alfo a Cbarter maoc tfmc out ofiedandnot* 
 mfno map be pleaoeo aa an olo oeco map , altbougb pou cannot plcao tbat ft K'^^" '" 'cvi- 
 InaamaoetfmeoutofmfriD. Serjeant Twifden on tbe fame {foe , 3U ca-*^'""- 
 fiomsj ougbt to be allcgco fn h6to , 9 Car. Fletcher ano Bagnals cafe, Licitum 
 fuic fo: a Londoner to afc anp traoc bp tbe cuftom of London aojuogco to 
 be fU pleaoeo, ano tbougb ft map be gojo fn ait eljfocnce , pet ft fa not goio 
 fn a return, Alleyn on tbe otbcr Coc fafo , tbat tbe return fa gooo fn tbe 
 ,returnfug of tbe cuftom, tbongb ft tnoulo baUc been fll fn tbe .pleaofng, pjcj.iin- 
 iBbfcb f'J ftrfcter tban a return neco to be, ano berc fa matter cnoagft return. Rccom 
 ; CD to rcmotjc tbe partfc3,anD tbe Vobolc cuffoma neco not to be rcturncD,ano 
 tbe fnfo jmalftp of tbe return ftjall not make ft f 0, fo j tbfs Court fa to j uogc 
 oftbc matter of fact rsturneo, anofota Giles Bags ano Wagoners cafe, ano 
 tbep bate returnee a cuftom to remote, ano bp confequcnce fomc bate been 
 wmoteo , o> cUe t\)z return fa falfe, tDbfcb fs'not to be pjcrumco. Wind- 
 ham,
 
 480- Mich. 1655. 
 
 ham , C£t)erp tnftomlBp?cfumcD bp tbe Hatn to IjaVe a latoftill bCBinnfnjr, 
 ano ftiall be intcnoco manp tf mcu to be bp anttcnt Cftnrtet , namdi', fo> 
 foci) tl)tnai5 aoar»not to be clatmcD toitbout a Cbnrtcr , but (f tbcp map be 
 Antitnt Chir clalmco UiUl)out a Charter it flwH be tntcnDCD ottjcrtolfc. iJti anttcnt Cbnt* 
 ter tct Dotb not lofc itfl fojtc bp not bchm toiifirmco (n Eyre, aa Latch batbfajo, 
 
 54 H. 6. ano iberc map be a pjcfcriptton to: tblngo ubfcb bate ncbcr been 
 a£tet),(fit began bp Charter, 22 E./J.t. 9. Green on tbc fame fioc Ebc toc» 
 rp Uiojoo of the rcto jn Do enfojte that pcrfonu tjabe b(tn tcmotjco, Glyn 
 chief luOice , % Ua\7C no booUs DcUtJcrco me tn this cafe ; jano thfo Creep* 
 tton Itao molJcD the UiQ SLerm , ano it <a trrp Doubtful! to me , ano mp 
 JlojD Roll iDOulD not oclttocr l)is opinion , 3 toulD toiftj the boftnefa might 
 • be compofcD foj the peace of the Cojpo:ntion. 2Co fap that the lanoa habc 
 been Demifeo ano Dcmilablc, thetoojoa ftall be taken DitttibuUtic. IBat 
 me fccms hetc is no mattet of tact rcturnetj foj rrmobing of anp. Sit ano» 
 thct Dap t!ic cafe toas fpoUen to again, ano agai.iH the retain it inas oreept" 
 so as fo jmrrip , that the Colur. hao not bp the return (ntitlcD thcmfelljee to 
 Prefrtipiion gj^p potocr to rcraotc the parties , fo j here is a p:cfcrtption onip in fieri ano 
 "* "'■ not infafloreturreD, viz.aLhatfuch pcrfons hate btcn accuftomeo to be 
 teniobable, ano it Doth not fap th^P hate ban remotco, anb thcfc cafcg, 
 viz, 70 E. 4, anD Mich. 7 Car. Flowers cafe, anD Mcli.p Car. Fletcher anO 
 Bagftiaws cafe, ano Skipwiths cafe, 25 Eliz. C. B. toerc citcD bp Wild on 
 Counccl fo; Yate?. Windham on tbc other Qoc as fb?merlp Diftfnguifteo 
 bettoirt a pleaoing, anD a return , tnhtch nccDsnot be fo fojmal ao a plcao* 
 ing, but QjallbetatjengooDtoa common (ntent, ano faio that Wagoners 
 cafe, tohich Voas as this is . uas aDjuogcD to be IctU upon gooD aobicc , ano 
 sui.fljncc. thcfubliantcofthcpjcfcriptfoniatocUfetfojthinthereturn, ano the foj- 
 nialitr is not to be much ttooD upon, j regarDeo. lievn on the fame Ooe 
 faiD, that tlje rule in W'a{;oners cafe comes home to this. Glyn chief lus 
 f\icc, SLbcrcisan fldfon npon the cafe b)ong^,t^pYaret fojthis matter, 
 . anD if it be founo fo? hint tne toill rcttojc him,bc the tctutn as it toill. Cu- 
 ftom is the main hinge upon tohich all Diofrancbifcmcnts do mobe ,. ano if 
 that be not tecU aUcgeo, it Hill be haro foj tl5C Diafranchifcment. Try youc 
 caufe this Terni,otherwi(e wc will deliver our opinions upon the return. Sit a« 
 nothcr Dap the Court teas motiea ""oj their opinion upon the rcturn,?3p Yates 
 his Councel,tohethcr it *aia3 gooo oj not.Cdiierupon Glyn chief iuf>. anftoe- 
 tcD, 3:t tocre geo^ pou tooulo agree as the Court hath aatiifeD ,- JBut Once 
 pou u>m not toe toill cibc our f uDgcment , fo j the caufe hath DcpcnDcD long* 
 CMircofdif- 3nDftTft3lconcet\)ct'hatherci3gooD caufe to DtofrancWfc the parties foji 
 (rjnchiff. cntring of ojDcrs maoc bp a pjetcnDCD Court, tehich fit truth teas no 
 luenr. Court" fo J thcft cntrv of fticb oiDcrs is tcrp p jc juDicfal to the cojpo jatioir, 
 
 anD is to the ill example of others, toDitturb the gobernmcnt. 35ut Cu- 
 flom is the main caufe of Disfranchtfing anp pcrfon , f 0: bp the Diofranchifc«= 
 mcntthc partp lofesljisftectolD, tchfcti is no fmall lofs, anc thcrcfojc 
 not to be put inpjacticc but upon tjcrp gooD toarraht ; f pet fn fomc cafes fo^ 
 the aDtancemcnt of government one map be put out of his f rccholo Without 
 alccalpjoceeoingagainftthcpartp, as &>it lame; Bags cafe is. But there 
 muft be a Cuttom oi a fetatotc to toarrant (t. IBut here appears no fucfj 
 Ciiflom upon the return , foj tl)c tcturn is that fo: fiich offences the parties 
 taijeufc-otobercmotiablcanDDirchargcablc, tohich is meerlpimaglnarp, 
 Thinp in fieri anD a thing fn fieri, anouot in fafto , oj in ufagc, ano fo it is as a Deao 
 i'<t'''(»ft<^' thing in the feoniblvhichnctjcrhao birth, fo> pou hafte not nictoco that it 
 ti^as at anp time put in pjacicc ^ 0: batic maDc anp oircrt affirmance of the 
 CuCom , as all Cuttom& nfc to be plcaDcD. au Cnffoms fmplpttno 
 • p nbi tbinas, to Vntt, a thing pofsiblc to be Done , ano that ftje thing hath ome- 
 and III' "'' t^oi^s been Done, ano fo arc all out i^lcasfnsci , anfi the return ought to 
 
 tiabe
 
 Tf in. 16 5 5 . 48 1 
 
 batje in ft certafntf enongJb tofnfo^m tl^e Conrt of t|ie mattet Tetameo , al« 
 t^onot) <t (0 not Tcqafreo t^ep (boalt) be To p;iecire as pleaofngs ottg^t to be , Raum ihouid 
 fo; bot() tiie Court ano t^e pattp mutt abioe bp t^e return , ant> ft Is to be ac< be certain. 
 bnololeoeso 30 true. 3In Wagoners cafe cfteo , 3lt teas touc^eo lobet^ec 
 t^ Cnttom tbere 10x0 toell atleseD , ano concernfng t^e CnSomo of Lon- 
 don alfo , tobfcb Do Differ from btder toftoma, t^ep bcfng conftrmeo bp 
 Statute, anD tbere t^ep allege a fpecfal act of Common Councel bp Cu- 
 Com ) ano a Statute alfo to enable tbem to do as ttiep Dfo. 3 ^lot conflDe> 
 reo toell of tbe return , ano 3H>olDtfte return to be naugbt, ano tl)ercfoje'"f«'"^f' 
 let himbereflored. Ask I uftice concurreD fn opinion. 2Cbe Conrt toas 
 molieD to retto^e t^e rett, totio toere4fn number , becanfe all tliefr cafes 
 toetcaUUe. Glyn chiet luftke , Lee thcra be reftorcd aifo,niri,&c, Rcrtored. 
 
 London and Craven^ 
 
 Trin» idj j* 
 irot. 44* 
 
 London anD Craven cntreb into articles bp SnDcntnre bcftofrt tfjcm, 
 toftcrefn London Dfo article to pap 1 10 1. at a certain Dap to come unto ,^,7'ment in 
 Craven, % Craven DfD artfcle tftat upon tfte receipt of tbe 1 1 o I. unto fjfm from ;„ ^ai .n of 
 London , tbat be toonlD sf^e unto London an acquittance fo;t tbe no 1. anD Covenant tr.r 
 tDonlD alfo enter Into an £Dblfgatfon of 400 1. unto London to fate bfm ''r<»<^^ «' ^^' 
 Ijarmlefs from all claims toWcbttJonlD be maDe unto certain lanDs In tbe""^^" 
 poffefsfonoftbefafD London, fnpnrfnance of tbefe Srtfcles London DotQ 
 tenoertbeiio UuntoCravenatt^eDaplfmfteDfn tfje artfcles, but Cra- 
 ven cefufetf) to rccclfee tbe r 10 1. of London, anD to gfUe Wm an acqufttance, 
 ano alfo to enter Into t^e bono of 400 1. Ililberenpon London brings tm SI- 
 (tfon of Cotienant agafnff Craven fo^ b^eacb of tbe ^rtfcles , ano afsfgns 
 t^e b^eacb to be, tbat ^e Dfo not gfte tllm an acqufttance fo^ tbe no U no^ 
 enter fntotbe bono of4ool.acco;Dfng to tde^rtfcles, anD upon ftTne lopn< 
 <D a terofct toas fonno fo; tbe pialntff* 3t toad mobeo bp tbe DefenDant 
 fnarreftof 31aDgcment, SEbat berefsno bjeac^ of Covenant fljeiDeo bp 
 tfje ^lafntff , foj tbe SDeclaratlon fs tbat tbe SDefcnoant upon tfjc papmcnf 
 of tbe 1 1 o I.toas to gfbt tfje acqulttantc.anO enter into tbc bono of 4oel. ano 
 (ere fs no papment, but onlp a tenoer ano a refofal of tbe 1 10 U ntentfoneo, 
 anD ft teas fn tbe SDefenDants eledfon, cltber to refufe tbe 1 1 o 1. ano to gf te 
 no acqufttance,noj enter fnto ttie bono of 400 1. 0; clfc to rcccfbe ft, ano gfte 
 tbe acqufttance , ano enter fnto tbe bono , ano fo bis cefufal fs no b;cacb of 
 Cotjcnant. £)n tbe otbcr floe ft teas urgeb tbat ft toas not fn tbe aJcfcn- 
 oants Clettfon to rccefte tbe 1 1 o 1, o^ to refufe It , but be toas bouno bp tbe 
 artlcleotoreceffeetbeiioLanOtofiftetbe acqufttance, ano enter fnto tbc 
 bono of 400 1. Glyn chiefluftice,!^eref0 a Covenant grounoeo upon 0rtf. 
 cles fnoenteD,ano ft f0 tbe mutual Covenant of botb tbe partf e0,fo tbat be la 
 bounD bp tbc 0rtfcUs to rccef be tbe 1 1 o I. at tbe Dap If mf teo , $ it fs not in 
 bf0 potoer Gitber to rccetbe ft, 0; to refufe ft, as batb been obi ecteo, % tbe S)e' 
 fenoantbaoremeBpbpt^eflrtfclcs to recover t^e no I. ff ft bao not becn^*"'"'' ^'"■ 
 papeoattbcDap, anotberefojebefsbounoto recefbe ft, ano to gibe an ''"*"'• 
 acqufttance fo; ft , ano to enter fnto tbe bono of 400 1. ano toe mutt make a 
 Teafonableconttructfonoftbetoo^iDsortbepartfes, But we will advife. Sit 
 anotljer Dap tbe cafe toas agafn put, ano tbe opfnfon of tbe Court ocOreo, 
 3no Glyn chief luftice tbcrcupon fafo , bere fs no bjeacb of CotJcnant aUe* 
 SCO to gronno tlie action upon, fo» tbe artfdes erp}ef0 , tbat upon tbe re* 
 
 €i q q cefpt
 
 48^i 7rin;i 65 5. ^ 
 
 itfpt of tbt no'. tbe ZDtffnDfiitt tooalt) pfftc the a(qttff!anrc , ahV^hKtfif/ 
 to bouD , nno tljc bjcatU aUcnco is, tbat tlic pialntff tcnojco tbe 1 1 o I. at 
 tl)c Dap, aoD tfic E)cf cittjant refufeo to reccfDc ft ,aniJ ftatb not fealee t!)c nc 
 qulttanct . tica citicn tl)e bono of 400 1, ano ft map be (t trna the f ntftnt of tfte 
 patKes, ti)at(ttlioiil8bcttit^cclcd:fonof.tI)cDefenDaiit cftbct to rcceftjc 
 tfts 1 10 lut; not to tcseibe tt, ano tt)c ^ainfnttf (0 not p*c juDfceo bj> tbc SDc* 
 fenHantfenottctclninfiofk; fojUljcfljoulofuefojtljeiiol. tlje |9faf»it{f 
 map plena thfotcnDcianorcfufalflgadttt t)(m, ano tljat tofll be luDgco a 
 papmcnt , ano icljcn be fuds poii for the 1 1 o I. poii rttap fuc l)fm fo j tbc ac= 
 qufttatttc ano tt)C bonu, Ai-k, 3 Uabc not a bcok, but 3 t'Jiik tfjc tafc fs a0 
 U liatt) bren put, ano l)^ re la no Cotcnant tl)at the JDffenttant (honlD tccclbe 
 N.l cjpUc t^^ »»^ ^* ^* '^'^ "^^^ ^'^'" ''*'^^ ^°^''^*^ ' '^'' '^^P'*^ P*-'"^ Billsra, nifi , 
 
 Clark and Fitzvvilliams. 
 
 Arrcft of A ili ^ittfoiiof JCtotcr ano ConVcrfion teas bjonc!)t bp Chrk agafnft 
 
 hi.igcmf in in /\f itiwiHigriis fo> ottiets gcDD0anD boufl)oloftaff,anoamongft tbetctt 11)6 
 
 »J'"y"^plafntifoetlareoofaSCro\3eraitD<i;oi)crfionof6 2Can3, flftcc a tacrofct 
 
 covcfiun. j^^ jjjg piatntutt Iras moteo (ti arrcft of ^aogement , tftat t^e SDctlata- 
 
 , , . , tfon tuia uncertain ,• fo J U cannot be fenoluti Icbnt fs* meant bp 
 
 A iorfs- 6 2:;an0, ano upoiitWotl)c tuogcmcnt Inas ftapcD ttU tiie JJIafiitlf ftouio 
 
 mote, ©atjctcupon Serjeant Twiiderijat aitotbet Dap motecD foj juoge- 
 
 ment ,anD fate tljc SDetlaratfon toas gooo enough, fo? <t (s fenoton tbat t^e 6 
 
 a^unoate HBjckietB ^acffclfi, oj dfc tbcp Cgnffic noting, ano tften no 
 
 DamagCB are ciben foj tljcm, accojotng to Osborns cafe, ano tbe cafe 
 
 to^cretbejactloiiViasprovigintiulniifiiCteaD of olmis. Windham on tfte 
 
 otljcr fine fa(o , tbata 2nHn(0amcaftirc,.aMp tocU Imoton fo to be, ana 
 
 pouougbttofljctocertafnlpof tobat poti doc DcmanD tfte quantUp of Gp 
 
 JEunc, anD it cannot be faio tftat tfteliraCtmo QjaU fignffic nothing , as Ser« 
 
 jeant Twifden fuppotctli , foj tjetc tljc ItJOjDS are fub£tanttt3C, anD Cgnifte bp 
 
 tfeemfclljec , aito not aojccitjc , ano Osborns cafe tftcD toaa aojaogcD upon 
 
 another rcafcn j fo^fulcruro lefti fignifico a BcotteaD, ano tftc Anglice 
 
 toWcb teas aooeo, viz, Curtams and Valence toctc a mccr aoDitfoi! , ano no 
 
 part of tlje JDcclaration. anDbefioeotijeptocrefnEnglinitoWcl) oug^t not 
 
 to bate been. Glyn chief luDice, 2D!)c Conrt tjatb oelitereo tijeit opfnfonr 
 
 alrcaop, SCbatftlsfnc^rtainluljattbepaintlf tjotbmcanbp tfte trojss 6 
 
 SLuns, fo;ti)iocafciiJnotli!;ctberafe5pur, inftcrc a tbfng is mentioncD, 
 
 iBWc^Dot^rtgRific noting, foitbcreoamngeu cannot be gfben toi fucft a 
 
 tbing, fojtijc toojD SEun Dotb fignifie ciijcra tljingo, but it ia inccrtaiti 
 
 n;i capiat toftatit Dotl) (igntfic bere, ano t^crcfojc Nil capiat per billam , Ask Iu« 
 
 iii(i. nice ad idem. 
 
 Fox and Swain. 
 
 Mich. 1^5). Banc. fnp. 
 
 10 a Crpal at tfjc IBar irt a Crcfpafs ano Cfectmcn'f bstlDfrt Fox piafntff 
 ano Swf«nn S^cfcnDant exception \vas tattcn againtt a tDitncfs tbat iraa 
 n^cfl-r ' " ' pjoouteo to pjotc tbc lca'"c of ciectmcnt , brcaufcbcf)aD tbc inbcrftaiice 
 in the lanDg let, bat it Inas urgcD bp the € ouncel on the plaintffs Coc, tbat 
 tbcJDefcnoant DID claim unDcttbe fame pcrfoiitbat tbe jpiaintif oio, ano 
 
 tberenpon
 
 'fin. 16 55' 42^ 
 
 thereupon ttetDftncfBirasaumfttco to be ftDOjn, anufn fl)fs cafe ft toaa 
 alfo fafo tljat f f ILcffee foj pcara do cotjcnant fcoUl) t&e JLeffo j not to afcfgn 0^ a Devife u 
 uer I)f0 SCerm tof ttiout t'oe JLeffojc confcnt in tojftfng , ano 00 aftettoarCB not an aflign- 
 iottliout foc^ confcnt cefcife tUc SEcrm to j. s. tl)<3 fs not a bjcacft of t|je Co- menc. 
 tenant, ioi a netiife ts not a leafe. 3!t toas alfo fafo, t^at f f a leafe fo j pears 
 bcfojfciteD, anDtfterentfoMlje lanD let be aftctlnarDs rrccjbcD bp t'jeLcafe forfeit* 
 iLeCfoj J bp Ws atfcnt, tijc Icafe ie maoc ccod again bp iW M of tlje 5Lcf=cd rcviveJ. 
 fo J , anD tlje fo jfettarc is Dffpenfco toUftaU, Nota, 
 
 Mich. 1655- Banc. fup. 
 
 Vipon Articles crtfbftcoftttWs Court asajntt one Alwin an 3ttojncp Attorney con- 
 oftbls Court fojfalfep:actfce ano iSarratrp, ano pjotoco agatnft ftim v.acd upon 
 bp otters Affidavits icao in Cctirt,3!"Dgcment loajs pjonouncco acafnC b<nt Articles, tur- 
 faptl>eConrt,tl)atbettioulDbepntoatoftt,eHofloftb2ilttojnepo, anibc^^^^ '•^" '''' 
 fincD50 I. aiiD ttjrncDotcrtb';3Bar,ancftani)comniftteD. iftc iDafitiirncD "' 
 obec tte JBat accojoinglp at t^sCSlea e«D of tljeJBar bp tbc SLipftaffs of t^e 
 Contt' 
 
 Martyn and A/iller. 
 
 Micb, 16) y. Bine, fap» 
 
 Tl^cre Incte tine federal caufes trpeo bettofyt Martyn paintff, anbArrcttof 
 Miller SDefenoant , anot&crenpon tterc teere ttoo venires, ano ttoo judgement 
 Diftringaffes taken out, anDfaptfteni«aaf;coftbe&^er(f a to?ong Dinrin^"?"" *" f'^- 
 gastoasfileototlje Venire, viz.tbattDttc^ fljonlD bate been fileo to tbe'°'°^'^"** 
 Venire in tbcfirataufe, toasfileoto tbc Venire fn tlje fccono caufc, anD 
 tbfs ioas moteo in 0rt£ft of Huogcment. Glynchief luflice, SEbisia aoif 
 tljetetDasno Diftringas, ano iatljerefojel^elpcDfap tlje §»tatntc0 of 3eos 
 fails, btttifitlBercan eironions Diftrirgas it coiil^ not be bclpco, ano 
 ^crc inas a gooo iffne jopneo , ano a gmo trpal of tbat iffne , ano it toas bnt 
 tbe mittabc of tbc Sberif, ano map be amcnoco bp tahing off tbc tojong Di- 
 ftringas from tbe Venire,ano filing tbe rigbt Diflringas in t^e room of it, and No Rule. 
 therefore this is no caufc toarrefl judgement. 
 
 FINIS;
 
 An Alphabetical 
 
 TABLE 
 
 OF THE 
 
 SEVE%AL HEADS 
 
 Contained in the following 
 
 T A B L e: 
 
 ABatement i 
 
 Abreriation 2 
 
 Aftion 3 
 
 Acccrtbry vid. Principal 4 
 
 Accompc 5 
 
 Acquittance 6 
 
 Addition 7 
 
 Adjournment S 
 
 AtimininratiooandAdminiftrators 9 
 
 Admiilion *o 
 
 Admiralty H 
 
 /ffidavic 12 
 
 Alien 1 3 
 
 Amend menc I4 
 
 Amercement 15 
 
 Amoveasmanum i5 
 
 Annuity 17 
 
 Apparance 18 
 
 Appeal ip 
 
 Appendant and Appurtenant ao 
 
 Arraijjnment 21 
 
 Arbitrator 22 
 
 Arbitrary 25 
 
 Arreft 24 
 ^ccftonudgeraents, t'lVtladgemcots 2; 
 
 Affets 
 
 Affife 
 
 Aflignmeni 
 
 Affumpfit f »W, Promife 
 
 Attachment 
 
 Attaint 
 
 Attorney and Attornment 
 
 Audita querela 
 
 Auditor vid. Arbitrator 
 
 Averment 
 
 Authority 
 
 Antient demefne 
 
 Award or Arbitration 
 
 i 
 
 BAnkrupt 
 Baron and Feme 
 Bargain and Sale 
 Baftard 
 
 Beggar */W, Vagrant 
 Bay! 
 Bailif 
 
 Breach vti, Promife 
 By'lawv('<^. Law. 
 
 Rrr 
 
 3(? 
 
 27 
 
 a? 
 
 30 
 31 
 32 
 3J 
 34 
 35 
 36 
 
 37 
 38 
 
 t 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 4 
 5 
 <^ 
 
 7 
 S 
 
 9
 
 An 
 
 Alphabetical Tabltr. 
 
 
 — . 
 
 
 1 Difcharge 
 
 \6 
 
 c 
 
 
 1 
 
 Difcontinuance 
 Difcretion 
 
 J? 
 iS 
 
 £ 'Apias 
 VjLafe 
 
 
 1 j 
 
 Difcription 
 
 'P 
 
 
 2 ' Dt«franchi(eraent 
 
 ao 
 
 Ccrcificacc 
 
 
 3 DifD.'nfation 
 
 21 
 
 Certainty and Incertainty 
 
 
 4 
 
 DiflcirorandDifTeifin. 
 
 itf 
 
 Certiorari 
 
 
 5 
 
 Diftref* 
 
 l» 
 
 Ceftuy que ufe 
 
 
 6 
 
 Dtftringas 
 
 »3 
 
 Champtrrty 
 
 
 7 
 
 Deftrudion vii, Extingaiftiraent 
 
 24 
 
 Challenge 
 
 
 S 
 
 Donative , 
 
 25 
 
 Chancery 
 
 
 9 
 
 Dower 
 
 ^6 
 
 Chappel 
 
 
 lO 
 
 
 , 
 
 Charges 
 
 
 II 
 
 E 
 
 
 Chattel 
 
 
 IS 
 
 •i .^ 
 
 
 Clergy 
 
 
 »3 
 
 V" leftione firmac 
 JHEIeaion 
 
 i 
 
 Common and Commoner 
 
 
 H 
 
 2 
 
 Comraiflionj and CommifTioneri 
 
 M 
 
 Elegit 
 
 ^ 
 
 Commitment vU. Imprifonraent 
 
 16 
 
 Enaidment 
 
 4 
 
 Common right W. right 
 
 
 ,»7 
 
 Engagement 
 
 s 
 
 Confeflion 
 
 
 «8 
 
 Engrofiing * 
 
 6 
 
 Coodition 
 
 
 19 
 
 ■ Jr.quiry 
 
 7 
 
 Confefiion 
 
 
 26 
 
 Enrollment t^ 
 
 8 
 
 Confent 
 
 
 21 
 
 iquity y 
 Error 
 
 9 
 
 Confideration 
 
 10 
 
 Confpiracy 
 
 
 43 
 
 Efcape 
 
 Hi 
 
 ConfituSion 
 
 
 34 
 
 Eftople 
 
 12' 
 
 Contempt 
 
 
 25 
 
 Eftreate, 
 
 13 
 
 Continuance 
 
 
 26 
 
 Evidence 
 
 J4 
 
 Contrad 
 
 
 a? 
 
 EKamination 
 
 IJ 
 
 Copyhold and Copyholder 
 
 
 >8 
 
 Executor 
 
 \6 
 
 Copy 
 
 
 2P 
 
 Execu'ion 
 
 17 
 
 Corporation 
 
 
 30 
 
 Expofuion w»J. Interpretation 
 
 18 
 
 Cofts 
 
 
 3' 
 
 Extent 
 
 19 
 
 Covenant 
 
 
 32 
 
 Extioguifhraent 
 
 20 
 
 Courts 
 
 
 33 
 
 
 
 Cnftom 
 
 
 34 
 
 F 
 
 
 D 
 
 
 
 ,pEefimple 
 ^ Felony 
 
 I 
 
 A 
 
 
 
 ■ a 
 
 T^Amages 
 
 XJ Datet/»JTyme 
 
 
 I 
 
 -Fecfmcnts 
 
 3 
 
 
 2 
 
 Feme vtd. Baron and Ferae 
 
 4 
 
 Declaration 
 
 
 3 
 
 Filing 
 
 5 
 
 Decree 
 
 
 4 
 
 fine 
 
 6 
 
 Deed 
 
 
 5 
 
 Forfeiture 
 
 7 
 
 Delivery vid^ Deed 
 
 
 6 
 
 Forgery 
 
 8 
 
 Demand 
 
 
 7 
 
 Formedon 
 
 9 
 
 Demurrer 
 
 
 8 
 
 FraSion vii, Tyrae 
 
 10 
 
 Denilon and Dcnifation 
 
 
 9 
 
 i Franktenement 
 
 «r 
 
 Di'pri'ture 
 
 
 10 
 
 Fraud 
 
 11 
 
 Depopulation 
 
 
 II 
 
 *-n 
 
 
 Devaftavit 
 
 
 12 
 
 G 
 
 
 Devife 
 
 
 >3 
 
 
 
 Debt 
 Descent 
 
 
 14 
 
 1 Y'^AoIet/tV.Pfifon 
 j ^ VJ Good behaviour 
 
 1 
 
 '2 
 Grant
 
 ' 
 
 An 
 
 Alphabetical Table. 
 
 
 Grant 
 
 
 
 ? 
 
 Local and Tranfitory 
 
 9 
 
 Guardian 
 
 
 
 4 
 
 M 
 
 
 H 
 
 
 
 
 ■Jk yl Aintenance 
 iVX Mandamus 
 
 1 
 
 T_T Abcas Corpus 
 iTl Habere facias pol 
 
 
 
 a 
 
 i 
 
 TeHionem 
 
 a 
 
 Manflaoghter 
 
 z 
 
 Heir 
 
 
 
 3 
 
 Mariage 
 
 4 
 
 High way vii. way 
 
 
 
 4 
 
 Maxirae 
 
 5 
 
 Homage 
 
 
 
 5 
 
 Melius inquirendnni 
 
 ^ 
 
 Honour 
 
 
 
 6 
 
 Merger 
 
 Mifcontlnuance vtd, Procefs 
 
 7 
 8 
 
 I 
 
 
 
 
 Mondrans de droic 
 
 9 
 
 
 
 
 Motion 
 
 lO 
 
 
 
 
 
 Murcher i, 
 
 H 
 
 IEofails 
 Imparlance 
 Implication 
 Imprifonmcnc 
 Impropriation 
 Infant 
 Information 
 Inheritance 
 InjunSioa 
 InquiHtion 
 Intendment 
 Interefl 
 Interpretation 
 Iflbe 
 Iffues 
 
 ludgcment 
 
 lurifdidion viL Courts 
 lary 
 
 lattice of Peace •&»</» Peace 
 laftiBcation 
 
 K 
 
 Ing 
 
 LAtitat 
 Law 
 Legacy 
 Lcafe 
 
 Levari facias vU. Execatioo» 
 Licenfe 
 livery 
 Limicatioo 
 
 I 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 4 
 5 
 6 
 
 7 
 
 8 
 
 9 
 
 lo 
 
 la 
 
 13 
 14 
 ij 
 \6 
 
 "7 
 18 
 
 19 
 20 
 
 I 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 4 
 5 
 <S 
 
 7 
 8 
 
 N 
 
 NEgative preignans 
 Ne exeat regnum 
 Nomine p cenae 
 Non obfiante 
 Non fute 
 Notice 
 
 Nudum paAum 
 Nafance 
 
 o 
 
 OAth vii. Affidavit 
 Obligation f »W, Deed 
 Offences 
 Office 
 Order 
 
 Ordinance of Parliament •j'»W,Parll 
 
 Ordinary 
 
 Original ^ 
 
 Outlawry 
 
 Oufting 
 
 I. 
 
 1, 
 
 2 
 
 5 
 
 4 
 
 5 
 
 6 
 
 7 
 
 I 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 5 
 
 ament 6 
 
 7 
 8 
 
 9 
 
 «0 
 
 PAin 
 I 
 
 Payne fort et dare or preffine 
 Payment 
 Panelw</»Iury 
 Pardon 
 Parifli 
 Parliament 
 Ftroll 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 5 
 
 i ^ 
 7 
 8
 
 
 An Alphabetical Table. 
 
 
 Party and Privy 
 
 9 RefcoQs 
 
 —" 
 
 Patent and Patentee 
 
 10 
 
 Rent 
 
 13 
 
 Pauptr 
 
 II 
 
 ReftitucioQ 
 
 >4 
 
 Peace 
 
 ii 
 
 Retainer 
 
 '4 
 
 Peer and Peerage 
 
 »3 
 
 Retorn 
 
 15 
 16 
 
 Peremptory 
 
 H 
 
 Reverfal 
 
 Perjury 
 
 15 
 
 Reviver « 
 
 17 
 18 
 
 Perpetuity 
 
 16 
 
 Revocation 
 
 Place 
 Plaint 
 
 »7 
 
 IS 
 
 Right 
 
 Robbi-ry 
 
 Rule 
 
 19 
 20 
 
 Plea and Pleading 
 
 IP 
 
 21 
 
 Poflefsion 
 
 20 
 
 
 2» 
 
 Pojiea 
 
 21 
 
 s 
 
 
 Precipe 
 
 22 
 
 V 
 
 
 Vrerogit'we v(d> King 
 
 H 
 
 CAlc 
 OSatisfadion 
 
 . -, 
 
 I'refcription 
 
 »4 
 
 I 
 
 Prtfentaticm 
 
 25 
 
 Saving 
 
 % 
 
 Pfffemment 
 
 26 
 
 Scandalui*! Ma?nattim 
 
 3 
 
 Principle and Ajceflbry 
 
 27 
 
 Scire facias 
 
 4 
 
 Prifon and Priloner 
 
 28 
 
 J 
 
 Security 
 
 S 
 
 Privilege 
 
 '9 
 
 Seiiure 
 
 6 
 
 ProcetittiJo 
 
 30 
 
 Sequeftration 
 
 7 
 S 
 
 Proceedings 
 
 3« 
 
 Settlement 
 
 Procefs 
 
 32 
 
 Sewers 
 
 9 
 
 Proclamation 
 
 33 
 
 Statutes 
 
 10 
 
 Proof 
 
 34 
 
 Subraifsion 
 
 It! 
 
 Prohibition 
 
 3V 
 
 Sureties 
 
 12 
 
 Promife 
 
 36 
 
 1 Suggeflion 
 
 15 
 
 Property 
 
 37 
 
 Sutcs 
 
 14 
 
 Protedion 
 
 3S 
 
 Summons 
 
 15 
 
 Proteftation 
 Purcbafe 
 
 39 
 40 
 
 SuperfcJeat 
 Superdition 
 
 16 
 
 . 17 
 18 
 
 
 
 Supply 
 
 ^Uaftiing of EndidmentsandOrderr, 
 
 Surmife W,Suggeftion 
 
 Surplufage 
 
 Surrender 
 
 20 
 
 21 
 
 ^ &c, wi/, Endidments, 
 
 Orders, &c. 
 
 Sufpcnfion 
 
 22 
 23 
 
 Qvo vyArrAnto 
 
 I 
 
 2 
 
 i- 
 
 - i/ 
 
 R 
 
 
 'j-Ales 
 
 ■^ Tayl vtd, Fee-tayl 
 Tax 
 
 Tenant and Tenancy 
 Tenement 
 
 r- - ■ 
 1 
 
 T> Ecital 
 
 X\. Recognifance 
 
 Record 
 
 * 1 
 
 3 
 
 2 
 
 3 
 
 4 
 
 Recovery 
 
 4 
 
 Tender 
 
 5 
 
 Reculanc 
 
 4 
 
 Terra 
 
 <; 
 
 Reference 
 
 1^ 
 
 5 
 
 Tenure 
 
 7 
 
 Rcjoynder 
 
 6 
 
 Tithes 
 
 8 
 
 Rcia:ion 
 
 7 
 
 Title 
 
 P 
 
 Re'eafe 
 
 / 
 8 
 
 Transferring 
 
 10 
 
 Repeal r^W, Statute. 
 Repleader 
 
 9 
 10 
 
 Tranfitoryz/U Local 
 Traverfc 
 
 II 
 
 12 
 
 Replication 
 Rtqueft 
 
 12 
 
 Treafon 
 Tre'pa($ 
 
 15 
 
 Trover 
 
 "■ 
 

 
 ' 
 
 
 An 
 
 Alphabetical Table. 
 
 
 Trover 
 
 
 
 16 , Ufe 
 
 ti 
 
 Trytl 
 
 
 
 17 
 
 UtlawryW. Outlawry 
 
 1» 
 
 Trnft 
 
 
 
 18 
 
 
 
 Tyme 
 
 
 
 I? 
 
 W 
 
 
 ^ 
 
 V 
 
 
 
 ■yyAgerofLaWM'/. Law 
 
 1 
 
 "V/ Agrant oi 
 ^ Value 
 
 •Beggar 
 
 
 I 
 2 
 
 ^ Waiver 
 Warrant 
 
 2 
 * a 
 
 Variance 
 
 
 
 3 
 
 Warren 
 
 3 
 
 Vtnire and VcODC 
 
 
 4 
 
 Waft* 
 
 4 
 
 Vcrdia 
 
 
 
 5 
 
 Wayci 
 
 % 
 
 Verting 
 
 
 
 « 
 
 Will 
 
 6 
 
 Viccarage 
 
 
 
 7 
 
 Witchcraft 
 
 7 
 
 ViduaU 
 
 
 
 8 
 
 Witnen 
 
 9 
 
 View 
 
 • 
 
 • 
 
 9 
 
 Words 
 
 
 Void 
 
 
 
 19 
 
 Writ 
 
 9 
 to 
 
 iff 
 
 ;. 07 no
 
 r.'.n 
 
 v/ 
 
 w^9 
 
 «>.' 
 
 A» J^dvertifementtothe ^I^aderin explanation of the 
 method ohferyedin the T'ahle following, 
 
 BEpleafed to take notice the Table following generally refers 
 to the pages in the Book, whicfi you arc dircded unto by the 
 firft figures ; and the Letter C fet after thole figures refers you to the 
 number of the Cafes contained in that page , that is to fay the firft, 
 fecond, third, &c. Cafe j but if the Gafc begin on one fide, and go 
 on to another, you arc dire<5ted to that page and Cafe where the 
 Cafe begins, and for your greater cafe you may find moft of the 
 matters you are to lookforexprcffedinthc Margcnt to that Cafe , 
 whether you are direded , but if you do not you fhall be fure to 
 find it in fome part ot the Cafe. 
 
 A
 
 A large 
 
 TABLE 
 
 OF ALL THE 
 
 SEVERAL MATTERS 
 
 Contained in the whole 
 
 BOO K. 
 
 Alphabetically digefted under proper and particular 
 
 heads, agreeing to the various matters 
 
 therein contained. 
 
 Abatement. 
 
 X7T7Hcrc a writ of Error is abitible; 
 \^\ \ and where Doc^ but may be a- 
 
 mcnded p. 7.C. 2. p.78 
 Where one may plead aa abatement of 
 the Yvrir, and where not. W. writ 
 
 a t/fbrtviAtkn 
 
 What abreviations are gcod , tnd what 
 noti 82 C. 2. 227 C. 2. 250 
 
 ■ i\ 
 
 
 ■t< 
 
 5 (yfllion 
 
 Fcrwhatcaufesan A(3ioc upon the cafe 
 will lie,and for what nor, p.-^.vi-iCzi'c. 
 
 Where an Ac^tlon may be "joynt , and 
 where rhere mu(t he leveral anions, 
 p. 3. 15 J i54>i-<5C.i.i^7C. 2.190 
 C. 2. 203 C. I. 297 C. ?.4Xi C. 2. 
 
 Where one may have his clertion oti&i- 
 on, and the reafon of it, p. 4. 19 C*4. 
 p. 31 C. 2.99, 100.542 C. 1.347. 
 
 Where an ai^ion of the cafe lies for word* 
 and where not, WCafe 
 Where Baron and Feme are to joyn in 
 an aaiop, and where not, p. 9 €.4.0. 
 
 52 C.I. H2, 115. I2P C. 4. 215, 
 
 314. -^ ' 3J 
 
 Where an aaion of Trelpafs lies , and 
 where notyvid. Trefpafs, 
 
 Where
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 where one is well incitlcd lo an Aftion 
 and where not, 107, 108 , 300, 301, 
 393 C. 2.401,401, 461 C. 3. 47a, 
 
 473- 
 Where an Ailion maybe dilcontinuedby 
 
 the Court, where not , i 20 C. 2. 1 34 
 
 C.1.477. 
 Where one may (lead in bar of an Afti- 
 
 on, and where noc, and what, and what 
 
 not, 428c. 3. 
 Where election of aflion lies -. and where 
 
 not, 131 C. 2, 1^40.3. 287 C. 1.384, 
 
 427 C.I. 
 Where divers aftions may be brought for 
 
 one thing, and where not, 201 , 202 5 
 
 300 C. 1.398, 399. 
 Where adions arc to be liiJ , and where 
 
 not,46oC. 3. 
 What actions are barred by the Statute of 
 
 liiritationsofadions, 21 /^^.aodvvhai 
 
 not , 214, 215 , 388, 389 , 401 , 
 
 402. 
 Where an i&ioa is well comnlenccd, and 
 
 whcrenot, 215C. I. 223 C. i. 301, 
 
 331 > 532, &c. 349, 350 , 381 C, 
 
 2. 383 C.I. 393 C 1.424C. I. 
 Where an aftion lies upon a Statute, and 
 
 where not 3 1 S, 3 19,424c. 1.427 C.2. 
 
 4*57, 468, &c. 
 By what ads an aition may be fufpended 
 
 and by whatnot, 384. 
 
 4 tyfccejfoyy, vid. Princlfal, 
 
 5 jiccomft. 
 
 Where an t8ion of accompt lies, and 
 where noe> 160, i^i , 287 C. i. 353, 
 
 3 54) 3 5!' 407- 
 What plea is good before auditors in an 
 accompt, and what not, 353, 354, 3 55, 
 4'oC. 1.43 oC. 1. 
 
 6 yic<]u'itttttict. 
 
 What acquittance is well given, and what 
 not, 394. 
 
 7 Aiditieni, 
 
 VVhere an addition is to be given to the 
 party, and where it needs noc, p« 26 
 C.3.P.19, 151 C. 2. ?94C. 3. 
 
 What are additions to be given to the 
 party, and what not> 173. G. i . 
 
 AdvMtnge, 
 
 Where one (ball take advantage of a thiig 
 and where not, p. 71. 100 C. 2. 129 
 
 c. 3.232 c.3.358 C.I. 403. 
 
 8 Adjournment. 
 
 \Vhetc an adjournment ij nccc(rary,and 
 where not, 179. 
 
 <j Adminifirathn and AdtuiniflrMor, 
 
 What A(ftions an Admmiftrator may. 
 
 btino and what not. p. 6 C. 3f 341 C. 
 
 2,384. 
 Where letters of Adminiflration may be 
 
 repealed, and where not. p. 10. C. i. 
 
 102 C. I. 
 How letters of Adminiflration ought to 
 
 beplcaded.54C.i.236G. 1.28a Ci. 
 46j C. 3 
 What arc good pleas for an Adminiftra- 
 
 tor,anJ whatnot. p. 56, 57, 
 Whit locters ot Adtninittration are good, 
 
 and what not. p. 74, 75. 102 C. i. 
 
 439,440.451 C. 3. 456. 
 What things may be adminiftred, what 
 
 not.p. 73C. 2» 
 
 \o Aimirahy, 
 
 What proceedings in the Admiralty are 
 good, and what not. 170 C. 1. 340 
 
 C. I. 
 
 I 2 -i^ffidavit. 
 
 What things the Court will grant upon an 
 Affidavit, and what not, 371 C. i. 
 387 C.4. 417 C. 3. 
 
 What Affidavit is g»od > *nd whit not. 
 446. • V 
 
 I 5 Alye». 
 
 What thing! an Alyen may have , and 
 whatnot, p. 20, 21,40, 41. 
 
 1 /^ Amtndvfeut^'fT^f: Jff'/' 
 
 Where amendments may be made in 
 
 w/its, proceffcs, and pleadings , and 
 
 where not. p. 7 C. 2. p. 31, 33*P'3''- 
 
 p. 85
 
 A Table. 
 
 p. S5. C.i.p. 96. C. !. iio.C. 2.1 13. 
 - C. s. p. ii5'C. 1. 1 1(5, 117, 1 20. C. I . 
 167. C. 1. 1 86. C. 4. 191. C. 2. 207. 
 C. 3. 31 ?• C. I. 218. 252.C. 1. ?3I. 
 C. I. 5. 339.C. ?. 373, ; 74. C. 1.386. 
 05.299.0.2.412.0.3.413. C. I. 
 417. C. 5.43 3. C. 2.451.0,1.483.0.2. 
 
 15 Am€rcement. 
 
 VVhat isgoodcaiife toclifcharge Amerce- 
 ments, and vvliat not. 14.C. 1. 
 
 j6. /imovtAs mannm. 
 
 Where an tyimovc^i manum lyes , and 
 where no:. 84,^.1- 
 
 17 Anmity, 
 
 Where a writ of Annuity lies , and Nvh:re 
 00c. \6i,C. I. 
 
 18 A^^arance. 
 
 Where the Court will compell the party 
 to appear, and where not. 207. C. 
 2. 
 VVhere one may appear by an Attorney, 
 
 and whercnot. 46S.C4 3. 
 VVhat is a good apparance, and what 
 not. 218. ^'.2.241. jit'w C. li 4oOiC. 
 
 19 AppeaU 
 
 In whar cafes an Appeal from one Jnrif- 
 diflion to another lies, and where not. 
 p. 129. C 1. 147. C. 1. 
 
 VVherc an appeal of Robbery, &c.lies, 
 and where not. 347. 
 
 %o jiffendant and AffurtenAKt. 
 
 VVhat things (hall be faid Appendant, 
 and whatnot. 279. 
 
 21 Arraigtimtnt, 
 
 VVhere an arraignment may be, anj 
 whercnot. p. 7.C. 2 
 
 . ( 
 1 2 Arbttraters. 
 
 The power of an Arbitrator, p.ioj, ^. 2. 
 
 VVhac Arbitrators may do , and what 
 not. 217,218. 
 
 2 3 Arbitrary. . 
 
 VVhat things are arbitrary, and what not. 
 78.0.2. 
 
 24 Arrefi. 
 
 VVhere one may be arrefled, and where 
 not. 166. 222, 223,405.0.4. 
 
 25 Arreft of JudgcmtntsJ \ id. Judge- 
 ments. 
 
 iS Afets. 
 
 VVhat (hall be AITets inihchaodsofan 
 Executor or AdminiHraror , and what 
 nor.p. d:.^. 2. 384, 407. 
 
 ij Ajiifti 
 
 • 
 For what things an Afsifc lies, for what 
 nor. p. ;o. C. 2. P.77.C. I. 164. C. 3. 
 194, 195- C. T. 238. C. t,269. 
 Ot what mitiers Juliices of Afjifcmay 
 take notice, and of what nor. 430. 
 C 2. 
 
 28 Afslgftment and Ajsignee. 
 
 VVhat fliall be a good afsignment of a 
 Debt or other thing , and what nor. 
 p. 62.63,349. 
 
 Who (hall be laid an Afsigqjc, and who 
 not. 407. C. I. 
 
 29 Afumpfc\id.Prcmife. 
 
 30 Attachmentt 
 
 Where an attathment lies', and where 
 not. p. 84. C. I, 2. 211, 212. C. 3.239. 
 C. 2. 277. C' I. 3 1 8. C. 2. 321. C' 4. 
 243.^.1.359,360,395.0.1.422.^.3. 
 439) 44o>445-0.2.4. 
 
 31 Atta'iKt. 
 
 VVhere and for what caufej an attiini lies* 
 and where and whatnot. 138,0. 2. 
 
 Ttt 
 
 3 2i t/ft
 
 A Table. 
 
 3 1 Attorney and Actornmenti 
 
 What is a good attornment, and what 
 
 not, p. 74 C. I, J84, 28?. 
 What letter or warrant of Attorney is 
 
 good, and what not. j8 j, 185,491,191, 
 
 348 C. 1. 413,4:4.4:6c. I. 441. 
 What pleas an Attorney miy plead , and 
 
 whatnot 380C. 2. 
 VVhat things may be done by an Attorney, 
 
 and what not.zdyC.i. 367 C.3.386.C, 
 
 5.4i3C,4. 4»dC. I. 
 
 33 Audita querelM, 
 
 Where an Audita q Mere U Met, sad where 
 not. p, 117 C, 2. 149 C, 3. 288 C. I, 
 3»3.3»4>372C.2-387C,4.4i7C 3. 
 4T4»45J» 
 
 34 Auditor vid. Arbitrator,^. 
 
 The power of an Aadiror , p, 105 C. 2.' 
 4<54 C, 3» 
 
 35 Averment, 
 
 What averment is good , and what not. 
 
 p. 30,31. p, 39, : 81 C« 2. 3P3 C. I, 
 
 297 C. 2. 30S:307j353C'»'440, 44t, 
 
 &c. 
 Where an averment is ncceflary, and 
 
 wherenor, p. 49C, «. 50 C. i. 53 C*. 
 
 I. p. 59,60,6a, 66,74 C. 2. p, 107 C. 
 
 I. Mi, 112,1 '3 C. 2. 147 ^' 4» ^5° 
 
 C.- 3, 163 C. 1.206C 2.220 C, 2, 
 
 231 C. ^( 270, 274, 3*0. 371 ^' 3» ^ 
 
 397 C. 3,400 c. 1.405 C, I. 419 C. I 
 
 2,42oC.i,4i7C. i,4j8. 135 C 2, I 
 
 441. 
 
 3 6 Authority. 
 
 What is a good authority Co do a thing , 
 •nd whatnot, 291, 19 », 3 1 1, 3 1 2,3 36, 
 
 337» I 
 
 ^J hfititnt demefn, 1 6 5<>;/. 
 
 Where antteni demefn may be pleaded , ! Where Bail is graniable , and where not. 
 andwherenot.6o9C,i,i'K/,plea,. j p.63C.i.ii6C.i.i25C.3.i66C,i.324C,T, 
 
 j 36SC, 5.371C. l;.37:C, I. 397 C,2. 
 
 ' 4 '5, 4'8C 5. 418,419^450^1, 
 ' Where Bail is to be given,and where noti 
 
 and 
 
 3 8 Award er Arbitrament, 
 
 What ftiall be faid a good award , and 
 whatnot, p. 28 C, i. p, 44C, i,p, ^c 
 C.I. 97,98. p. no C. 3, HI, 112, 
 133 C. I.i5»^«i'i78 C. I. 217,219, 
 256 C.I. 3o6,307,J34C. 1.35 i.c» 
 I 365, 3^6, 382^,1,436 C, I.4J6, 
 &c. 45 2 ( .1, 459 C. 1. 471 C. I, 
 
 What breach of an award is well afsigoed, 
 and what not. 4'? ^- 3* 436 C j. 
 
 B 
 
 1 BanckrMpt, 
 
 By what ads a man is made a Bankrupt. 
 
 213 C. 2. 289. 
 What ads done by one that afterwards 
 
 becomes bankrupt is good , and what 
 
 not, 288,289, 
 
 2 Baren and Feme, 
 
 What things (hall bind a Feme Covert, 
 whatnot. 254 c. i. 310, qii. 
 
 Where the Baron and Feme ought to 
 joyninan adion or doing any other 
 thing , and where not.2 97 C. 3. 
 
 3 Bargain and Sale, 
 
 What ftiall be faid a good bargain and 
 fate, and what not, 204, 205, 28S7 
 289* 
 
 4 Bayard. 
 
 VVherea Child may be faid to be a ba* 
 ftard, and where not, 277 C, 2, 
 
 5 BflS,"^ vid, vagrant.
 
 A Table. 
 
 and! what bayU 226, C,i. 261, C4 3» 
 
 jri. C. I. }ri. tJ.l. ^51, . I. ^6^,C 1.47J. 
 C. I. 47f- C t. 
 
 Where the bayl may be difchargeJ, and 
 
 where not , and huw. p. izi. C. i. J34 C. j, 
 
 3*4, 33O' 33'j3«'^-'-- I.38T.<-^5.4iS ^'.i- 
 419. C. I. 
 
 VVbat adions do lye for tliebayl, and j 
 what againft the bayl, and what not, | 
 
 How far bayl is lyable for the principle. 
 
 In what manner a Baylif is to execute pro- 
 ceiTes direded Co biiDtp, 18 C.i.^O)< 
 
 8 Breach vid. Primift% 
 
 What breach of covenant or pronnife is 
 well afsigned, and what not, p. 1 07. C« 
 1. 393. C, 3. 
 
 p 57- id* vid. Z.'rt*'*. 
 
 What By-Law is good, whatnot, and 
 where it binds, and where not, 227, 
 362. C. i» 
 
 I Cafiasl 
 
 Where aad by what Courts a Capias may 
 be granted , and where not. p. 1.186. 
 C.4. 
 
 Where a Cafiat lyes, and whcte not.322, 
 aaj. 
 
 2» Cafe. 
 
 Where an adion upon the. Cafe lies for 
 words, and where not. p. 5.C.i.p,<$.C, 
 
 2.P- II* C, *.p,I7.C.l.p,22,2 3,p.24, 
 
 ay, i7.C.3,p,46.C,3.47.C.i,j.49.C.2. 
 p.4P,jo.p,s8,C.2.5j»,do,53,<54,d5)<5<5.' 
 <5'S.C. *,70.70»C,i.7J;C,2'P'9itC.2'' 
 lOOt 
 
 Where an adion on the Cafelyei for 
 words,&: where not.p. 1 13,113,1 1 5.0,3, 
 118, C, 1,127. C.2.p.i3o.C.i.p.i35,C,2. 
 142.0.1,150.0.3. 159.0^1.169.170,17^, 
 •77) '83, 184.194.0,2. i99,:oo,206.C. 2, 
 
 110.0.1.213.0,1. 217,C.I.2'9 0.1,220.0. 
 
 I. 311. C. i,s. 227,0. 3. 229 O, 
 
 i-a3r,0,l. :3i,C.3, 3 j. C.i,245.C,i,2. 
 
 247.0, 5'.C.2.273.C.4.274.C,i,a74 
 
 C, J2, 285. r.2, 29j.r.3 298,C.a.299. 
 
 C.i.304,305,5 12,323,3 23.C.i.3i6,C,(. 
 
 3i8.C.i.3 3y.0.3.338.C,i.35o,3ji,352. 
 
 C ,1. 353, 364. 3 79. > . ).387.0,^388, 
 
 389, 383, C, 1. 394. ( , I. «. a. 4o6,(, ,4. 
 
 4'4' <^ .2.420, c .i,422.C.!.424.C.3. 
 
 42?* 0.3. 426. C. 2.429.0.2.435.0,2. 
 
 43M37j45 '-0.1.455.' .».4(Jo.C,3. 
 Where an adion upon the cafe lies upon 
 
 a proraifeand where not.p. 5.C,i.p.3. p. 
 
 53.0.2. p. 55,57-'^->.p',«52,(5j,i3i.C, 
 • I. 141 C. 1.143, 142, •jB.Ci. 162. C,(. 
 
 203, C.r.2i3.C.i.243,348.C.i.25<5, 157* 
 
 261, C, 3, a<J4.C,2, 273, C, j,a7J* 
 
 C.I. aSi. C. X i^y.C.i 196.0, i.ifj, 
 »98, 303, 304, 305, J9^. 3J(S, 4(0. C. I- 
 40J, C. t. 411, 41J., 41^. C. 1. 419. C. i. 
 41". C. 3. 440, C.I. 463. C. ». 47»,473, 
 
 84r. C. I. 
 
 Where an adion upon the cafe lies in na* 
 
 ture of a conrpiracy,& where not, p, io,ir, 
 
 157c. 2,372 c.5,4o8.c.i.424c.2,432.c,i; 
 
 Where an adion of Trefpafs upon the 
 
 Oafc lyes, and where not, 99, 100, 
 
 131, 86:. O. 3, 1^4,0,3.169,170, 
 
 i8i,0,,20i 20a,iia, 114, 2i5,»i^^ 
 
 0. r. 227« 0.4.230.0,1,238,0,1. 
 244. 0. 1, 310, C. 1,335.0. 1.341.C. 
 
 1, 343«C.4» 348.349, 35^>370' C. 3, 
 4.371. 0. 4- 378.0.3,398, 399,42i« 
 C, 1. 4a<5. 0» 1 . 437. 0.1. 43 1 .0,1,45 1 . 
 C» 6, ^63, 0, 2, 47a. 0. 2,474, C, 
 U 
 
 What is a $;ood Plea in bar to an adion 
 
 upon the Cafe, and what not, 345,C,a, 
 
 347, 0. 2, 
 Where an adior»>on the Cafe lies upon an 
 
 Inedbitatut Aj^Hmffic^ and where not. 
 
 160, i^i. 
 
 3 Certificate. 
 
 What is a good Certificate, wbae not;' 
 130. 0. 3, 131, 0. 3, 137, 138. '75> 
 175,183,292,0, 3,368,0.4. 
 
 4, Certaintj end lucertMHtjl 
 
 iV-
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 5 Certiorari. 
 
 where nor. p. 86. C. j. 364. C. 1.37*' 
 
 C. i.457,468.&c. 
 
 In Avhit things chc C'crgv are pri.ilcgcd-, 
 in wliat not. 151, 152, i<58, 169. 
 
 In what cafes a Certiorari lies , and in 
 what nor. p. 9. C, 2. p. 14. C, 3. 125 
 125,127 C.3.14J.C,;. 151.C. J, 210, 
 211. C. 2. 133. C. 1.195.0.1.300, I 
 C. 2. 328. C. 3.3^1. C.2. 35*. C. 2, Who mjv claim Co:"ninon, andwhonott 
 
 Common ar.d Qjmtr.oner, 
 
 IV clai 
 436. C.I. 
 
 356. C a. 364. C. I. 37 I.e. I ♦454 
 C 2. I 
 
 What Certiorari is well granted, and j J-^C^mmifsioH a':dCjmmifsto»ers. 
 what not. 8y. C. 1,176, 371. C.i 
 
 6 Cefiuj qt4t ufe^ 
 
 7» Champerty. 
 
 What (hall be Champerty, what not, 9h 
 94. 
 
 ^Challengt^ 
 
 What ii good caafe of Challenge to 
 a Jury or Juror. 100. C, 2. 1 19, C, 
 3»i?3»C.3. 
 
 How ihe array is to be challenged, and 
 
 how nor. 233, C. 3. 
 How a challenge to the array is to be try- 
 
 cdj and how not. 4(54. C . 4. 
 
 9 Ckar.cery. 
 
 What things the Chancery may compcU 
 to be donC) and what not. p. 2 1 . 
 
 I o Cb-tftl ^nd ^hurch. 
 
 Of Churches andChapcls and their fcve- 
 ral natures, and the realonstliereoL p. 
 36> 37. p- s^) 52. 8') 82> 83. 212. 
 
 C. 2. 
 
 1 1 Charges. 
 
 Where Jurors or other pcrfonr, fliall have 
 ihcircharges,v\herenor. 13S.C. 2,137. 
 
 I 2 Chattels, 
 
 What things fliall be faidtobechattclr, 
 and what no:.p. Sd.C.i. 
 
 13 Clergf. 
 
 Where the Clergy is to be granted, and ' 385. C, 5.417.C, 5 
 
 J 
 
 Of what things Commifsioners ofSew; 
 
 crs miy take conulsoceoGand of what 
 
 not. p. 59. C. i.'z/'d.Sewcrr. 
 What thini;s Commifsioners of Bankrnpc 
 
 miv do, aud what nor. p. 6i, ibS^ 
 
 289.; 
 
 I 5 Commnrnent, 
 
 Whatisagood Cammitmenr, and what 
 
 nor. p. 90. C. 3.434.C.i.4'5s C.i. vid. 
 
 Imprjlonment. 
 
 For tvhat offences the Court will commit 
 
 one, and tor what nor. i 2P. C. 2. 374. 
 
 C.I. 413. C. 2.483. C. 1. 
 
 1 6 Common right, Jee Right. 
 
 1 7 Confefuov. 
 
 Where one ought to confefs and avoid, 
 ortravcrlC5crwhcrenct.43 2. C.4. 
 
 I 8 Co^ditiofi. 
 
 What fliall (be faid a Condition ^ and 
 
 whatnot. 294. 
 Where a Condition fliall be faid to b: 
 
 entire, an J where not. 3 16, 317. 
 Where a Condition is transferrable to a» 
 
 noiher^and where not. 316, 317. 
 
 19 Confefrion. 
 
 VVhat things one fnall be faid to have 
 conteiied by pleading , and what not« 
 334>343-C.3. 
 
 lO.Confent. 
 
 VVhat confent ofpanies is good to alter 
 things and what not. 233. C. 3.^77* 
 
 Con-
 
 A Table. 
 
 2 1 Conftderat'ian, 
 
 I 
 
 29 Cop J. 
 
 What fliall be a good confideration to 
 ground a ^romilc upoojand whiCnoc, 
 vtd. Promilc. 
 
 2 2 Co»fptrat;j, 
 
 Whac fliall be laid to be a confpiracy, and 
 what not. p. 57. C. 2. 
 
 ■i^.Co*iftrHnionk 
 
 24 Contempt. 
 
 What fliall be faid a contempt of rhi- 
 Court, and what not* p. 89 C. i.p. 105 
 C. 1. 159^ 160.241. 
 
 25 Continuance vid. D'fcontinMAtice. 
 
 Where Procclfes fliall be faid to be well 
 continued) and where not. 11 1 C. i. 
 528, 529. 
 
 Where continuances arc to be pleaded^ 
 and where not. 37 j C. 2.401, 403. 
 
 26 Contra^. 
 
 27 Convi^ioH. 
 
 What fliall be faid a good conviilioD , 
 whac not. p. 12 C. i. 
 
 28 CopyhoUand Copyholder ^ 
 
 What fliall be a good furrcndcr of a Copy- 
 hold, whac DOC. p. 107 C. 1. 1453 14<5. 
 25(5,2575 275-C. 1.450C. 2. 
 
 By what Ads a Copyhold may be forfei- 
 ted, by what not. 5 87 C.i. 
 
 What Ads a Copyholder may dr, and 
 whatnot. 5 80 C.I. 
 
 By what Ads a Copyhold -eftatc maybe 
 dcUroyed. 4-50 C 2. 
 
 Who fliall be laid a Copyholder, and who 
 not. 145,146. 
 
 Of Copyholds cntay!cJ.450C. 2. 
 
 What copy ofa Deed, Record, &c. ij au- 
 
 thentica! , and what not. 1 22. C. 2. 
 Where the Court will grant a copy ot Re- 
 cor 1, &rc. where no:. 397 C. 2.418, 419, 
 444 C- '• 
 
 10 Corporation. 
 
 Where a Corporation ij well created^ 
 
 and where nor. 298 C. i. 
 How to levy mony upon a corporation. 
 567 C. 5. - 
 
 S^Cofi/. 
 
 Where cofts arc to be paid, and where 
 
 DCC.149C.1. 153C.1.366C.3. 4f3 
 C 3. " 
 
 3 2 Covenant. 
 
 For what an aftionofCovenant lyes, for 
 wbatnot, and where. p.67C.i.73,74. 
 140 C. 2.140, 141. i62C.2.i86,i87. 
 
 265C.2.357C.i.387C.5.p.3iC.2.37, 
 
 3 8.54,55, 56.300 C.i.4o6,4C7. 407 C, 
 
 I.431C.3. 481. 
 What fliall be laid a breach of'Covcnantj 
 
 and what not. 483. 
 VVhat fliall be a good plea in bar of an x- 
 
 ftion of Covenant, and whatnot, p. 67 
 
 C i.p.86C.2.p.i3 2C.i.]62C.2.i87, 
 
 3 57 C.I. 406 407,43 2 C.4. 
 VVhat is a good Covenant in faft, and 
 
 whac but a Covenant in law. 406,407. 
 
 431 C. 3. 
 
 Comcell. 
 
 Where the Court will afsign Councell' 
 and where ^101^41 8, 419. 
 
 33 Cotfts, 
 
 How infcriour Courts ought to proceed, 
 and how not. p. 1,2. 171 C 1. 191 C 
 3. 340C. 1. 418C. 1.459,440. 
 The caulc ot Acftion muft lye wi:hiache 
 JuriK i^icion of the Court where ir is 
 tryed.p. 2.313 C.2. 
 Where one may fue inthcEcdcfiaftical 
 Court, and W'herc coi.p. lo.C- 1 . 
 Uuu ^here
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 Where ihc Ji.rildiaion oi a Court lliiU 
 befaid to be admiitedj an.i where nor. 
 
 p. 45^.3- , , 
 
 Whit Ads the Court may do, and uhat 
 
 not. 3 loC. I. 
 
 What Juiidiilion the C^^urtof ihellnper 
 bench hi.h^arKi whit 1101.255 C.1.3B1, 
 
 Whit auihoricy is good to hold a Court, 
 what not. p. 51 C. 1.477,478. Ckc. 
 
 What Courts arc tixt, and what not. 234 
 C. a. 
 
 Jiirifdifiion" of Coi'rtsi"'<^' ^It*!. 
 
 What ^ourt is a Court of Record , and 
 what nor. p. 35, 36. * 
 
 Where a Deed or other writing is robe 
 
 produced in Courr, and wh>-'rc not. 459 
 C. I . 
 VVhjc JurifJiaion the Court of Acicni- 
 ralty haib, and what not. 470 C. 4. 
 
 34Cuflomc. 
 
 What (T^all be fai I a good Cunom , and 
 
 what not.4j,43 p.ySC. v.i)4 85>87. 
 
 1 24,; 25,1 37,1 j8,i45 C.^.\'}9'^■^9 C- 
 
 I.;43,i5)i,2$?i.3i 1, 3 1 2.262 6.1.3(56 
 
 C. i.409>4io.4jiC'.i.4i3,424) 45° 
 
 C. 2. 
 A^Vberc and how a Cuflom onp^ht to be 
 
 let forth, D. 64 jf. 2. 421 C.I. 477, 
 
 &c. 
 By what A<f\saCul:omm3yheexting«iflv 
 
 ed,and by what not. i ; i Cr.i66,z6i, 
 
 j68,a6s» 270,2715272,273. 
 How a ^ ultom is to be expouiKicd , 145, 
 
 146,409,410,476^.2. 
 
 D 
 
 I Damage!, 
 
 Whercdanoai-.esooghtto be given icve 
 rally, and vv here joy ncly.p.ig. 56 C 3- 
 135 C. 2. 1 74 C.J. ipSC. i. 
 
 Where dirnagisrhall be laid to he well 
 oivcD, and wherenot.pag. I 2 C. 2. p. 
 2^,24. F-48. 49- P-'69. p. 78- 92. 
 iiiC. 2. 119, t !<>• 135 C. 2. 164C. 
 2,198c. 2.214c. I. 296C. 2. 341 
 
 c.s. 398,399.478c. 2. 
 
 How ditniges lluU be found u^ 00 a dt- 
 
 murrer to an evidence, pag. 2aC. i. 
 Where damages n-iall be recovered, and 
 
 aj^aind whom. 470 C- 2. 
 Whdrc damai^es may be rckalcd , and 
 
 where no: . 1 7 5 C, 1 . 299 C a. 
 VVh.rc particnlar damages are to be al- 
 
 icagcd, where net. 275, 274. C. 1.426 
 
 C.2. 
 
 Vvh re psrt cfdimi^.c! gi\enmay be rc- 
 iirquifi-.ed , and lud^tment given for 
 rherei;.i85. 
 
 Where the coert may increale ihe dama- 
 ges given tiy ihclery , and where nor. 
 2IC, 2 I. 345, 546.4-1 1. 
 
 Whatmav he a!!eagc:d in mitigation of 
 damages and whatnp;. 427 C. 2. 
 
 2 Diite vid. Time. 
 
 3 Dtclaration , 
 
 Where a Declaration ought to be joynt , 
 and where it i<; goo ' t^ainll one with t 
 JinjfflcpfmJ-ic. p. I ). C. 1 .p.20 C. T, 
 
 Whit Declaration is good, and what not. 
 p. 18 C. 3. p. 19 C. ij », J. 18 C. ». p, j7 e. 
 l.p. 4J,44, 45 C.l.p. 50,51, J5 C. 3. p. 70 
 C. I, p.75 C. I. p. 7?>83. 94<^-»- P- ioi> 
 loi C. z. 3, 104 C:. »j }. p. 106 C. 1. p. 
 107 C, 1. 1090.1.115 C.I. 117. 118,119.114, 
 iij, i»(;C J.I18C. <.ijo, ijt. 133 c. I. 
 z, 3. 154 C. 1. 13< C 1. 139 C. z. 14^ C. r. 
 170, 17 1, 171 C. I. 176, 177, i8i C. 3. 18^. 
 I 87. 195, «94, 154 C. I- >99 C. I. zoi, 101 » 
 103. 114 C. 1, 113. ii3 C. I. 114,115, iig 
 C. I. "<?, 117, i>9 C. 3 Z3»C. z. 135 C. I. 
 ^. 136 C. 1. 1. 141 C. ^, »43 C. z. Z47 C. z. 
 Z55C. J. 156 C. }. i57j »f8. ztfo C. I. i^j 
 C. 3. ztf4; C. i 174, 181 C. z. 191, rq;, 197 
 C. z. 198 C. 1. 5C0, ?oi. 333c. I. 31} C. I. 
 3iT>3i8 337'5J8, 341-343 C. 4.348,349. 
 3?o> 351. 353. 556 C. I. 3i8 C. 3.J60, 
 3^1. 3«8, 369- 370 C. 3. 4. 371 C. J. ;8i C. 
 1.385C. z 386C. 3.j8t C. T. 593 C. z, 
 397 C. 3. 464 C. 3. 4)8C. 1. 411 C. t. 414. 
 C.i.4'SC. I. 410, 4ij, 411 C. z. 4i8C, 3. 
 419,43°. 45T C. 1. 4TSC.I. 4.59. 460, 4^1 
 C. z. 4^3 C. I. 4(f<5 C. I. 471 C. i. 473, 474 
 474 C. 1.476 C. 3. 1770.1,481 C. I 
 
 4 Decree. 
 
 How far a decree in Chancery i? ro be fa- 
 tisfied, and wher," not . p. 3 6'. 
 
 •^Tteei
 
 AT^le. 
 
 ^Detd. 
 
 How a deed rr;Ul\ bq pleaded , and how 
 
 given ir evidence, p. ;4C i.C-a. 
 What wri:ingniall be laid to be a dec f', 
 
 and what not. 45 ?• 
 What is a good deed, and nhat nor. p. 
 
 97C. 1.428C. a.462C. ;. 
 How deeds iTjall belaid lo operate, and 
 
 ho.vnot.445,44^' 
 W^ete a deed i? to be enrolled , and 
 
 where cor. vid. Enroltmenr. 
 What delivery of a deed is good, and 
 
 whacDor. 251 C. 2. 
 
 6 Delivery vid. Deed. 
 
 9 Denifon Diffavot, 
 
 7 Demand. 
 
 ^hat is a good demand of a rent , nomine 
 fosa£ or othcrihing. p. /\.t6^6-[y 68, 69. 
 77,78.86 C. 2. 5>3.99,ici 236, 237, 
 
 238C.3- 
 Where a demand is neceirary , and where 
 itisnof. p. 1 51 C.i.p, 32. 172 C.I. 
 aaoC.2.37oC3. 
 
 8 Demurrer. 
 
 What is good caufcof demurrer to a de- 
 claration, plea, &c.what not. p.6i C.I. 
 2.64C. 2.65c. 1.67 C. 1.P.72C. I. 
 i88C.2.p. iToC. 3. 113 C. 1.114 , 
 115, 124 C. I. 139 C. 2.3. 140, 141, 
 142c. 2. 170C.2.178C. I. 2. 187, 
 188, 195 C. 3. 197 C. I. 205 C. 2. 
 2c9,2io,2ia C. 3. 2ii) C.3. 220, 
 
 3 21, 2 22, 223 , 239 C.3. 230 C. 1. 
 434C.2.236C.I. 2.239C. I. 242 
 
 C 2.245 C. 2.248 C. 2. 57, 258 
 262 C.i. 287 C. 1. 288C.1. 289, 286, 
 387,289, 298 C 1.300 C.T. 309 C. 
 i.3^i>&c. 3 3SC. 1. 343 C. 4- 344 
 C.i.348>349, 350 C. I, 355 C. 2. 
 
 - 356C. 2. 373 C. 2.579, 380, 382, 
 383,385C.i.403,432C.4. 
 
 •YVhacfliiallbeiaidagood demurrer, and 
 what not. p. 22 C. i.p. 34 C. i.p. 41 
 C. 2. P.50C. 1. 118C. I. 163 C. 3. 
 401, 402,403 C. I. 407 C. 1.410 C. 
 1.413 C.4.45 2C.I. 452 c. I. 45p 
 C I, 
 
 What things a denifoti may have , and 
 what not.i79C.i. 
 
 1 o Deptrture. 
 
 Where fniU be faid to be a departure, and 
 where nor. 260 C. '. 
 
 1 1 Depucnloif. 
 
 Where one may make a deputation , and 
 where noc.ijil C. 4. 217 , 218, 357 
 C.i. 
 
 I 2 Dev^fiavit, 
 
 W'hat fliall be faid a devafiavir, and what 
 not. p. 54) 5 S' 5<5y 286, 287. 
 
 1 3 Ijev'fe. 
 
 Where and what devife is good, and 
 whcrenot.p. 73 C. 2.148, 149,240, 
 261,262,274,275,278, 279, 281 , 
 282,292,293,294, 311, 312, 4C9, 
 410,476 C. 2. 
 
 14 Deht. 
 
 Where an aflionoi debt lies, and where 
 not, ind for whom. p. 6* C. i . p. 3 1 C. 
 2- p. 132 C. 2. P.53C. 2. 162 C. 
 
 1. 198 C.I. 199 C.I.2C5C. 2.228C. 
 
 I. 2340.2.279,286, 287, 287 C.I. 
 
 305,307c. 2. 407 C. I. 
 Whit is a good plea in bar of an ai^ion of 
 
 dcbt» and whatnot, p. 47, 48, 56. 57. 
 
 P.79C. 1.93.94, 105 C.I. I 24 C.I. 
 
 205, 134 C. 2. 2J9C. 1.263 C. I. 
 
 286, 287, 339,340,550c. I. 353 C. 
 
 i.356C.2.37«C.i. * 
 
 Where an Aaioa of debt may be brought 
 
 in the dchet^ where in the detmet, and 
 
 where in the debet and Jatinct. p. 52 G 
 
 2,p.6iC. a. p. 79, 80,119,232c. 3. 
 288 C.I. . 
 
 In what order debts ought to be paid. p< 
 55.?. 61 C. a., 337, 3 jg. 
 
 1 5 Bifcent, 
 
 \ Where one (hall be laid to be entitled to 
 
 laodt
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 lands by diiccnt, and where not. 148. 
 149. 
 
 16 Di{char^e. 
 
 Where a prifoner may be difcharged-and 
 
 where nor. 96,97) I 19C I. 166 C. 2. 
 
 18? C. I. ih'6C.4.2 I I J 212,222,223. 
 
 238 C. 5. 369C. 1. 395 C. J. 418 
 
 C.4. 
 Where bail maybe diichargcd, and where 
 Doi.v'd. bail. 
 
 1 6 Dijfeifer and D'JfeiJitit 
 
 Whomay be a dilVeiforj ar>d who nor. 
 
 407 C. 
 
 T -J DifcartinsaKcet 
 
 Where proccflcs fliall be faid tobc dif- | 
 
 continued, and where nor. P.58C.2. 
 
 p. 70,71 ,97 C. 2. Ill C.i.t22 C. 3. 
 
 171 C. 2. 2C9 C.I. 209, 210, 339 
 
 C. 3. 
 By what i$t.% an eflate tayl (hall be dii- 
 
 concinucd, by what not. 192, 193, 
 
 vid. Fee tayl. 
 Where an adlioflmay be difcontmucd , 
 
 where not.p.i 20 C 2.134C.1.142C.2. 
 
 306 C.I. 309 C. i.34'5.3<56C.3.382 
 
 C.3.477. 
 
 I 8 D'fcreiion. 
 
 i9Defcriptio». 
 
 When thirg? fhall be laid to be wcUdc- 
 icribcd, and whcnnot.p.^ 5 C. I. 125 
 C.1.136C. I. 194 C. I. 199 C. 2. 
 235C. 2.313C. I. 
 
 ao. Disfra»chije»fei.t. 
 
 por whatcaufcs oncmaydisfranchife, and 
 for what not. 151 C.i.44<5'447> 448, 
 &c. 
 
 Wh»t difpenfations are good, and what 
 oor.SJS) &c.3755&c.4(54.C.2. 
 
 22 Dtftreff. 
 
 In wharcaicsadinrefsmay berakcn, and 
 in what not, pag. 13.166C.428. C. 
 I. 
 
 Vv'hcrc adidrcfsmay be lold, and where 
 not. p. 13.C. I. 
 
 23 Bcjiringas. 
 
 In what cafes a Dflrin^as lies , and where 
 not. 366 C. 2.417 (..4. 
 
 24'Z)//?r«i?»o»vid. Extinguish' 
 menf, 
 
 25 Djnative, 
 
 -^ Dower, 
 
 How Dower ouoht to be demanded , and 
 
 ofwhit.67,68,69.92j99. 194. 238C.3. 
 
 176' C. I. 
 What al'signment of Dower is good, and 
 
 v^hat nor.p.67j68,69. 23^5 237.276, 
 
 J77- 
 Where there needs 00 afsignmenc 9f 
 
 Dower. 277. 
 
 E. 
 
 I Ejellione firmx. 
 
 For what thing? an Ejenioni firms, lye J, 
 and for what cot. p. 30 C. 1. and ia 
 what cafes. 160, 161. 194.21$. C.3. 
 364 C. 2. 
 
 2 ElSion, 
 
 Where one may have election of adion; 
 
 vid. Aaion. 546, 347) 348, 384, 
 Where anelcdion isneccliary,aDd where 
 
 nct.p.49C. !• 338. 
 Where 01 e n-.ay have an cledion^Sc where 
 
 not. p. 80.149. 341 C. 1.450C. 2.4J1 
 
 C. 3.481 C.I. 
 
 3. Elegit. 
 
 Where an EU^tt lyes? and where not, and 
 
 a*
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 agatnli whom, and againlt wUotnnoc. 
 
 4 Endi^lment. 
 
 How a bill of Endii^menc is to be prefer 
 
 red> p. 1 1. C. I. p,4(5^,C.4. 175 C. 5. 
 
 ;74C. . 
 
 for whar thing's an endiiftmeuc lyes, ard 
 
 :or w-hai nof . p. i z. C> i . p. 2 5 C.2.P.3 3 
 
 ^. 2.::44C.). ;56 6.3.145 Ci .iPo'c.i. 
 
 258 C. 5. 25 r C.J. 3 I 20.1.514^.1.326 
 
 r'i-??^'.U7> 365?C-. I.J74 C2., 3.3P4 
 C. 3.397C. i.45iC".i.4]jCs.454C. 
 
 3- 
 Tor what caufes and tau'is anendiiSl menr 
 
 maybe q"inicd, for what not. p. 24 C, 
 
 1, 1. p. ijT C. 1. p. itf.C.j.p.ij, 30.P.33 C.z.p. 
 
 46 C. ^. p.T9C.i.p.6oC.i.p.7(5.C.i.p.84.C.i. 
 
 p. 87 C, 1.108,109,115 C.I, 1.113 C.3,4. 1x6 
 
 C. t. i3?C. i.i3(J C.3.T44C.i,r4v C.1.147C 
 
 4. i48C.i.iyyC.3.ij7C.i.i63.C.j.i74 C. z. 
 
 186 6.1,3.191 C.3.ii8 C.1.130 C.X.144 C.I. 156 
 
 C.i.ifiy f, 1.3 14 C.i.'j^g 6.3.3^7 C.4. 374.(..i. 
 
 374 C.1,3.394 C.3. 397. C. I. 400 C.3. 431 C, 3. 
 
 433 ^- 3- 4J3 '^.J 44^ C. 3, 4.448 C.3,449.C.i, 
 VVnere ao cndictmenc may be amended, 
 where not.4(5j.C. 2. 
 In what manner endiflmenrsonoht to be 
 
 prcccecfedm.p. 28C.2.2'i7C. 2. 
 What cndiftmenr is good, and what not. 
 
 244 C. 1.3 12 C.t.37«C. 3. 382 C. I. 
 The diftercnce between an Endidtnjent 
 
 and arlifortnationi 217 C. 2. 
 Where the Court will nrr quafh an er- 
 roneous Endidmenr.ioo C 2, 
 
 Entry. 
 
 Where anentry into Lands i<;lawfiill, 4nd 
 
 where not. p.55 C. a 2+<5C.i.2)0, a^i* 
 To whit intent entrncs into land Hull op- 
 
 Derate .-nd to whit D0C.3 70 C- 2- 
 VVhac ihirgsmay bcentrcdu onKecord, 
 
 anJwhatnor. 379c. J'4 )3.4o4.45i C- 
 2 454 <^- 2- 457. - 
 Ot the entry cfProccfs, and where it is 
 
 oec i^ary ; and where not. joo C.2. 395, 
 
 441, &c. 
 
 5 Engagement, 
 
 VVh re tlic plea ofrbe ef>gi?,emtnt may 
 ^ be difcharged, and where not. 568. 
 
 6 Ettgrojsing, 
 
 EttqH ij. 
 
 Where a writ of enquiry lies , and where 
 not. 2889 uoC. I. 
 
 8 EnrollnnKt, 
 
 \ How an enrollment of a Deed fhall be 
 
 pleaded. p. 34 C. 2. 
 Several enrollments o^DcedS) and their 
 
 operation.'. 370 C. i. 
 Where it is necellary to enroll a Deed, 
 
 and where nor. 104. 
 Whi re a Deed is faid to be well enrolled, 
 
 and where not. 462 C. 3 . 
 
 ^ 9 Equity. 
 
 Where there fliall be faid to be equity, 
 
 and where not. 41. 
 Law and equity not to be confoundedr 
 p. 41. 
 
 I o Error. 
 
 » 
 
 What may be ar^igned for error, and what 
 
 nor. p. 60, 61, 69, 381 C i.70, 71. p. 
 
 72C.2.8(5C.2. 9i,P2396C.2.97C. 
 
 I. 115 C. 2. 121,1220.1.131 C.2. 
 
 145 C.2. 15M54, 1 T7'^. 2.164.0 
 
 2- ^64;':if 5C.2.167C. 2. 170 C. i. 
 
 174C. 2. 187C. 2. p. 16. C. 2. p. 
 
 17 C. i.p. 19C. 2. p.40, 59C.1. 12a 
 
 C. I. 2i8C. 2. 
 ^'^hcre variance b: vvixt one part of a 
 
 pleading, and another nart of it makes 
 
 error, where not. p. 5 C. 2- 
 Erjor caiifcd by giving dam.-nages intire 
 
 where they oiight to beleveral.o, 56 
 
 C.3. 
 W here awriroferror lies, and where nor, 
 
 jnd for whom, and for whom not. p. 
 
 IJ C. I. p. 2j c. i.p. 18,19. p. 38,39,4100.1. 
 
 p. 1°. C. 1, 60 61. p. 66. C. I. 67, 68, 69, 
 
 8fi C. 1. p, 106 C. 1. 1 09, no, 1 1 J C. ». 1 17 
 
 C. I. 119, no C.J. no, III, 111 C. 3. 114, 
 
 ixf, 116 C. J. 117 C I. 118 C. 5. 141, 141, 
 
 r?4. C. 1. 1^9 C. 1, 170, 171 C. 1. 172 C. I. 
 
 174 C. 1. isi C. 3. C. 4, 183, 1S4, 187 .€. 
 
 I. 19" C. 2. 191 C. 1. 1?4. C. 1, 1. 1 9< C t. 
 
 19« C. X. 100 C. 1. loi C. 1. 109 C. I. »ii,C. 
 
 1. 116 C. I.XI8C. 1. 114C. I. ixjC. I I. 
 
 117 C. J. X18 C. 1. 130 C. 1. 131 C.I. 138 C. 
 
 1. 144 C, 1. 146 C. I. X47 C. I. 148 C. I. 
 
 i?lC. 1.1J4C. I. ttfoC. X, ?.x6fC. i.iSo. 
 
 t. I. »83C.i.»8f C. I, 186. C.I. X87 C.I. 
 Xxx 288
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 i88 r. 1.190 O I. »9oC. 1. 191. f. I. Jij c, 
 I. jij C. i. 318 C. I. 317 f. i.p. JiTC «, 
 
 p. J 17. 318. 3^8' 3»?' 3»9» 3?°- 3 J" ^- »-J3* 
 54') c. I. 546 c. J. 3^ c. i 3«o, 381 C. 4 
 383 C. i.?8?C. ^ 386C. I. ;93C. 1. 3j)5, 
 396, 400 C. 1. 406 C. /. 410 C. I, i. 410 c. 
 3. 413. C. 1.4:8 C. 3. 419, 43° C- ^Ai^ C.l, 
 43? C. 1.458 (.. I 44^^ C-.1.46CC.I.474, 475 
 477 (•■. ». 
 
 How errors ought fo be afiigned and pro» 
 fecuted. 93 C, i. 100, i j9,i6o, 208Q 
 1.419 C. I. 
 
 Who may bring a writ of error, and who 
 
 not. 47t C 2. 
 
 What writ of error is good, and what not. 
 153 C. 3. 174C.I. «7S, i7<5. i8j C» 
 2. 190 C, 2, 191 C'. :o3 C. 2, ii6 
 C.J. 129C. 1.265 C' i.344.345,407> 
 471 C 2.46?. 
 
 What a writ of error ijuod coram vobii re 
 fidet is. 470 C. 3. 
 
 Who may joyn in a writ of error, and who 
 not, 406 C, I. 
 
 .1 
 
 1 1 Efc»ft. 
 
 Where an Aflion ofEfcapelies.and where 
 
 not. 162 C, 3. 330C. 3 
 What will make an Efcape, and what not. 
 
 46 J C 1.475,476. 
 
 I 2 Efioplt, 
 
 What (hallbcaneftople, and what not. 
 103 C. i, 158 C. 3. 187 C. 2.192 C.I.396, 
 441,450 c. 2. 
 
 1 3 Efireat, 
 
 Where a finemayberefpiied and not t-- 
 ftreated , and where not, M<i, Fine, 
 
 t/^ Evidence. 
 
 What things may be given in evidence up; 
 on a tryalat Law, and whatnot. p. 10 
 C.I. 378 C. 1.445 C. 5.450 C, z.^62 
 
 C.3» 4.479. 
 What (hall be a good evidence to prove 
 
 the iflue, and what not. 3 3 5 C. 1. 3 83 C, 
 
 2. 
 In what manner things are to be given irj 
 
 evidence, p. 22C. u p. 34 C. J. 233. C 
 
 2. 
 
 15 Examinatien. 
 
 What Examination is good, and what not» 
 233 C. 2, 
 
 16 Executor^ 
 
 Where an Executor (hall be charged^* fe. 
 
 nit frofriis , and where not, p, 5<}, 55 
 56. 
 What pleas an Executor may plead, what 
 
 not. p. 5f^, 57, c^C. 2. 337'338,243 
 
 C.2, 378C, 1.40V C, I. 
 What Adions in Executor mjy have, 
 
 and 'whatnot, 140 C.i. 2 86, 287,463 C. 
 
 a> 
 What adions ttiay be brought againflan 
 
 Executor, and what not.15 8 C. 1.199 C. 
 
 2. 228 C. I. 290C. 2. 387C.5,4o6, 
 
 407» 
 
 17 Executiati". 
 
 Where an execution may beiacire,and 
 where not.p, i8C,2.2poC.t, 
 
 VVhcre one may have execution upon a 
 judgement, and where not. 83,84.228, 
 a 9, 338 C.I. 246, 254,255,465 C. 
 I. 
 
 Upon vvhjt grounds an execution may be 
 flayed, and upon what not. 417,438 C. 
 I, 
 
 What execution is good , and what not, 
 
 100. p. 10 5 C.M(55,229C.2.25jC.2» 
 
 290C, 1.3210.3.414,415. 
 What is a good difcharge of an execution, 
 and what not.p.u7 C . :. 
 
 18 ExpefitioM vid. Interfrttatiottt 
 
 39 Exient, 
 
 What things are extendible, whatnot, p, 
 75, 161,162,168,169. 
 
 20 ExtiMguifhrrtentt 
 
 By what Ads an Eflate or other thing may 
 be extingnithed, by what not. 349, 250^ 
 15 '> 266, 267 , &c. 389 C. I, ^
 
 A Table. 
 
 ■% 
 
 I Fee fimple And Fee tn'l. 
 
 By whac ads a fee tail may be difcontinu- 
 ed, by whatnot. 158, iJ9, ipzj ip?* 
 
 What ftnll be faid an eftate in fee firaple, 
 and what not, 249, 250, 25 i, 278 C, 
 a. 273 C. I. 2811 282,4340, I. 
 
 What (hall bea fee tail, and what not. 
 278C. 2. 3»5,32^,45oC,2, 
 
 2 Feloiiy. 
 
 VVbat things are Felony, and what not. 
 p. 66. and C.a.p.ysC, i.p 9i C.i, 
 11 dC I. 364 C.I* f' 
 
 VVhereoncmay bearrefted for Felony, 
 
 . where not, 166. 
 
 3 Teofment 
 
 What is a good feofmcnt, and what not. 
 189,193. 
 
 4 Feme vid. Baron andFeme, 
 
 5 Filiig vidi frociffe 
 
 Wbat things IT ay be filed, and wbeo, and 
 how.pag. 33, 292, 293, 336, 337, 3i 
 408 C. 3. 
 
 6 Fine, 
 
 ^hcre the Court may ttnpore a fine , and 
 where not. p. 9<5 C. i. 12? Ci 2.228, 
 239 C, 3. 244 C.I. 303 Cj. 321 C, 5. 
 449^.4,485 C. 1, 
 
 Where and by whom a fine is Well impo» 
 fed, and where and hy cvh .ns not, p, 
 130 C. 3. 3J9, 360, 5dd C. 2, 382 
 C, I. 
 
 Where a fine may be refpited , and not c« 
 ftreated, and where not, 135, 135, j^jj 
 
 C.. 2. 
 
 Whec a fine levyed of lands, &c. is good 
 and (hall bind, where not. 3^6 C. i. 254 
 
 C, 1.472 C. I, 
 
 r 
 
 7 Forfciturel 
 
 What (hall be a forfeiture of a Copyhold, 
 or other eOate. J4(S , ,48, 149, u5o, 
 i<5i,i52, 19;, 19^,195, 197,233 C. 
 4«a4'> 1870,2,4460,2.453, 
 
 By what ads a forfeiture may be difpen« 
 fcdwith, 464 C, 2.483, 
 
 8 Fcrferjt 
 
 The form of a judgement given upon a 
 convidion of forgery and perjury. 36 3, 
 
 5 Formedon, 
 
 For what things a Formedon lies, for what 
 notip. 30 C. 2. 
 
 loFraaitnvii^Time', 
 
 1 1 Franktenemtnt or Freehold. 
 
 What (hall be faid a freehold, and what 
 not. 161 ♦ 
 
 1 2 Frand. 
 
 WhatconveyanceAallbc accompted m 
 be fraudulent, and what not. 288 289 
 428 C. 2. ^<\6. * * 
 
 1 Gaoi \ld, Prifon. 
 
 2 Goodbehavionrt 
 
 Where one may b:- bound to the good be- 
 haviour, and where not. p. i«5 C. 2. :9S» 
 
 3 Gr4nt4 
 
 What things (hall paffe by a grant, and 
 
 what not. p.68. p. 78. 203, 
 How the words in a grant (bail be inter. 
 
 preted. 2 1 1 C, i. 
 What grams are good,and what not. a^2, 
 
 i66^
 
 ATaWe^ 
 
 ^ GMtdlan, 
 
 ^^ Ady be a Gtiardi'ati fo an InfdUr, and 
 fiow to be au horifed > and who not. 
 369 C. 4 45<5C. ^. 
 
 Howand wticrc a guardiaa may be aif> 
 chrged,456C. t, 
 
 H 
 
 1 liaheas corpus. 
 
 Where a habeas carpnt lies, and where not 
 ._ 1-28 C. 4. 173. C, J. 147 C. 3.. 
 182 C, I. 230C. 3.i39C,2, a6tC, 3. 
 
 28^,286,3* c.i, 397^.1.397,398, 
 
 4i8C'.4.432C, i»43j C.4» 
 
 z Habtrt fusias ft^fffimcnti 
 
 ^\\&t'9it\toi habere factas pfijfe/jtuneru is 
 good, and what nor, 238 C.i. 
 
 t|\/herea man (hall be faid to be an beir, 
 and where not, 307, 308, 309* 
 
 ^ Highiv.iy vid.rvaj/ 
 
 5 liomJ'e, 
 
 6 Htnours, 
 
 Of the creation of honours and privile- 
 ges belonging to them. 252, 253, 234, 
 372 C 1.452 C, I. 1 
 
 2 Imparlance^ 
 
 Where an imparlance may be granted,' 
 where not. 36? C, 2. 
 
 3 Implication, 
 
 VVhere a thtBgmay be fupplyed by im* 
 plication.and where not, 53C, 1. 351 
 C. 2. 428 C.I, 
 
 4 Impri/oHmerttt 
 
 For what caufes one naay be imprifoned, 
 and for what not, p, 16 C 2. 382 C. i, 
 
 VVhcre an adion of falTe imprifonmenc 
 Hei, and where not 454 C. 3, 
 
 VVhat ftiall be faid a lawfull imprifon* 
 ment,and whatnot, p. 900,3.35? C.i. 
 
 5 Improprhtiaa. 
 
 J 
 
 I Jeifdilf, 
 
 VVhat thing? and faulcs in pleading are 
 helped by the Statute of Jeofails, p. 70 
 C. I. •yii Star, 151,206 C i, 218 C 2. 
 
 215C, I, 
 
 6 J ft fan t. 
 
 What afts ofan infant are good, and what 
 
 not. 1 2 1 C, 1, 208 C, 4. 3 1 8 C. I. 47a 
 
 C.I, 
 How an Infant may fue, and be fued , and 
 
 how not, 3 69 C, 4. 400 C. 2, 
 VVhat ads (bail bind an Infant, and what 
 
 not. 246 C. ;, 
 Infpedion of an Infant, 451 C. a« 4S*^» 
 
 4575 472 C.I. 
 
 7 Information, 
 
 The difference between an information, 
 andanendiSraent. 217C. a. 
 
 For what things an information lyes, and 
 for what not,and where and where not, 
 217 C. 2. J45, 246,417 c. i-43oC. 2, 
 
 In what Courts an information is to be 
 preferred, and in what not, 340 C. i. 
 
 8 Inheritance, 
 
 Who may inherit lands, and who not. 139 
 C,i. 
 
 9 InJM»Uiott, 
 
 ■ji^ '^ 
 
 VVhercaninjunSionoutof the Chance. 
 ry is not to be admitted to ftay pro- 
 ceed-
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 ceedingiatchecormnon Law« p»27G 
 
 to ^nqnifili«n. 
 
 VVhatfhaU beagoodinquinnon, what 
 , not, p. 40,41 ♦?» 75 C. a, 
 VVbcre an inquUicion may 1 e quafhed , 
 and where not. 285 C. 2, 
 
 1 1 Intindment 
 
 Where things (lull be fiipplyed by ir- 
 Ccndmcnt, and vn here not. p. 50, 31- 43 
 C. 1. 58 C. 2. p. 59 C. 2. p. 78, 119, 
 
 149,2055260 C.2. 292 C. !• 29\, 
 
 294, 404 C. 3.421, 428 -C. 3. ^(>6 
 C. I. 
 
 1 2 Interejh. 
 
 Where one fliall be faidtohave ati inte 
 rciHn a thing, and where not* 348 C. 
 1.428C.1. 
 
 1 3 Interfretathn. 
 
 How words fhall be interpreted , vid. 
 words. 
 
 How Statutes and Ordinances fhall be in- 
 icrpret6d,z'/<^. Siaiutes and Ordinan- 
 ces. 
 
 l^If 
 
 Ht. 
 
 What (Viall be faid a good iHae, and what 
 not.p.70. iij C.I. 151, 172 C. 2. 
 198C. 2.210, 211 , 239 C. 1. 378 
 C.I. 
 
 How the general ilTue is ro be taken up- 
 on the meal ^&.. 37S C. i. 
 
 Where one may joyn iiiue,and where not. 
 401,401,477. 
 
 Where the Court will di.'charge iflncs, 
 where not. 1 57 C. i. 1 86 C. 2. 
 
 16 luigtmtnt. 
 
 How lodgements ought to be enrred. r. 
 s.^ i.a.io8C.2. 229C. 2.aci C2.283 
 C. 1. 399 c. 2.1 30 C. 2. 
 
 UiiTticiKc between a iudgcmcot in ad 
 aiHon ot trclpils vt ct tirmis ^ and a 
 judgement in an a<Jiion upon rhe cafe , 
 and the rearonofic.p. 3. 
 
 Where a juJgemcnt may not be aifirmtd. 
 45 1 C. 5. 
 
 ForNvhatcsurc; judp,errent<: may b** ar- 
 icflcd, ani for what not. p. it C. x. 19 C. I. 
 p. 38 C. 1 p. 58 C. I. p. 64 C. u p. 69 C. I*. 
 p. 7^ C. 1, 1. p. 80 C. 1.93,94, 9jC. I. lotf 
 C. ». 108 C. I. 117, n8,i»9,iJo, 131, ijj 
 C. 5. 134C. 1,4. 136C, 1. 1J8C. I. 146 C" 
 I. 150. C. 3. ijo, 151, iji, ,J3, ,jj c, ,. 
 156 C T, 158 C.z.ij<)C.i.i6iC.i.i<iC.3. 
 i«3 C. I. I«9-I70,i7i. 0.1.194,19^,103 C."t. 
 ic6 C. X. 108C. 4.117 C. 1,119 C 3.1370.1, • 
 i(Ar C. 3. 135 C. I , X. 161 C. I. 1^3 C, X, x«3 
 C. 3. 1154 C, I, 1. 173 C.. 4. 274 C. I. 177 
 C. 1. xSo C. 1. i8j C. i . 19^ C, I. z9($ C. X. 
 X97 C. 1.197 C. 3.198 C. 1,19) C. I. jio 
 €.3.303 C. 1,3,304, 30J, 310 c. t. 338 C. 
 1.341 C.i. 349,3To. 3ji, 35^358^.3.560, 
 3<;i, 3*1 C. 3. 3«4 C. X, 365, 3*6 C. i. 
 3i58, 3^9, J70C. 3. 371 C. 4. 171 C. 3. 374 
 C, X. 378, 37.'), 379 C. I. 381 C. I. 387 C, 3. 
 388, 389, 39} e. 3.394 C. 1, 3. 397 C. 3. 
 =198, 39?, 400 C. 4. 404 C. 3. 405 C. i. 4U 
 C I. 411 C. 1. 416 C. 1. 414 C. }. 415 C, 3. 
 416 C. X. 417 C.I. 418 C.I. 419 C.X.435 C.»^ 
 4?<, 437. 438, 455 C, I. 458 C. 1.459. 4«S 
 4(foC. X. 461 C.x, 3.463 C. 1, X. 4«j C X. 
 466 C. 1.47I C.I, 471 C 1.473,474-474 C.I. 
 481 C. 1. 481 C. 1.48} C. X. 
 
 Y\^hit maitersiray be moved in arrcfl of 
 Iiidgment,and what not. r. 58Ci2.99, 
 100, 1 02 C. 2. 102 C. 2. 1C9 C. 2.105 
 C.I. 184 C. I. 185 C. I. 207 C.J. 
 213C. t,2,3. 215 C. 3. ai6 C. I. 
 
 219 C. 3. 220 C. I, 2, 22lC.I,2, 
 
 223 C.I. 231 C.I.23JC. 2.232C. 
 
 3.245,246 255C.3.256 C.2. 256 
 
 C. 3.260C. I. 25)6 C, 1. 322 C. 4. 
 
 323C.1.326C.1, 328C.1. 230C. 3. 
 335 C. 2, 536 C, I. 
 
 where ludgemen^may be given in part 
 
 only, and where nor. p. 22,23,175 c, 
 
 1. 210 C. 1. 147 C. 2.34JC. 5'.342 
 
 Where no Iudgenr,enc can be given, p. 34 
 C. 1. 75^76, 9cC. 2. 1 24 C.I. 136C* 
 
 2. 227 C. 2. 343 C. 3. 
 
 What ludgrmcDt is well given, and whit 
 cot. D. 29, 30. p. 69. p. 84 C. I. 84, 85, 
 ii8C.i.94,95,ioi,ic4 C. i. 109, 
 110,121 C. 2. 122 C.I. 124, 125 
 C.2.127C.1. 148 C. 2. 164 C. 2. 
 l6^ C.2.)94C. 2.200C.2. 225 c. 
 1.225 C. 2.285, 288 C. i. 292 Ct. 
 316C.1.327C. 1.329, 330, 346 C. 
 3.38J.C.2. 386C.5. 4C0 C. 2. 406
 
 Arabic. 
 
 ,.iji6C. 1.415 C.2 435C I. 
 VVIxrc ;* Judpen-.ent may bercvcrfedin 
 
 part only, and where not. p. 12 1 C, a. 
 Judgemnc agsinft f.n Attorney for falfe 
 
 praAice. ^9,% C. i. 
 Where the t oui;lit to bea fpecial judpe- 
 
 ment, and whtrenot. iSy.rbS, 2^9 C, 
 
 2. 
 VVbereand forwhatslarfgenient maybe 
 
 rcveffcd by a wnt o: Error, and where 
 
 not. 2»7 C,i.:9oC,2.47i C. 2.476 C. 
 
 17 JurifdiRien vid. Couriit 
 
 What lurifdlftion lufticfs ofAlsife, and 
 Oj:r «nd Terminer have, and what not. 
 4}oC, 2. 
 
 18 /«7. 
 
 Where one may try a caufe twice , and 
 
 where not, p. 34 C. i. 232 C. 3, 445 
 
 C, u 
 Where the panel of the lury may be 
 
 qaaD'cd.snd where not, 2^3 C, 3. 
 Of what matters & lury may enquire , and 
 
 ofwhai nor.472 C.i. 
 What ihinj^". the Juiy may do by leave oF 
 
 theCou:!.44SC.i, 
 
 Where the Sherif (hall no: retorn the 
 lury.477C.2, 
 
 19 lufiiccef Peace vid. Peace, 
 
 10 jMJitficatior), 
 
 What (hall be raid's gijod lurtification by 
 
 wayof plea, "^'W, Pica, 
 YVhat thin(;s one miy joftific the doing j 
 
 of, and of what not. 4 o V. , 1, 
 
 K 
 
 King, 
 
 Of the duty of a King. 40. 
 
 Of the Kings Prerogative, and whit privi- 
 leges he may hare thereby, and what 
 not.p.4o,4'»J<56 2<57,&c-375 .316^x77, 
 
 V Vhat the King miy grant, ^nd what not, 
 
 25 2,266. 267, &c. 3755?7^,577' 
 What granti of the King are good , and 
 
 what not. z66, 267, &c. 
 What things theKmg (hall bcfaid tobc 
 
 ' intitled untOi and what not vid, Title, 
 
 I Lai It at. 
 
 The nature of a Latitat. 156 C, 4. 
 
 2 L/iw, 
 
 Of what things the law takes notice of, 
 and ofwhstnot, p, 55. 
 
 The Laws in Ireland the fame with the 
 Laws in E»gUnti, ^S6C,2. 
 
 What things arc recoverable at the Cora* 
 monlaw, and whatnot, vid. Recove- 
 ry. 
 
 VVhcre wager of Law lief, and for«vn»m, 
 and where not, ipp C. 1. 3 21 C. a. 
 
 What By 'law is good, and who it binds,' 
 and who, and wbatnor,t/r(i. By- taw. 
 
 5 Ltgacj. 
 
 VVhere and in what orders Legacies are 
 to be paid, and where not. p, 37, 38. p. 
 
 i\Leafi, 
 
 From what time a Leafe for years (hall be 
 laid to begin. 118, iip, 188, iSc?, 204, 
 205. 
 What (hall be faid a good Leafe at willj 
 
 and what not. 397 C. 5 . 
 What (hall be (aid a good Leafe.and what 
 not. 188,189, Jo4,ao5,3i5,3i<5,5J7 G.t, 
 380C.1 383, 
 By what Ads a Leafe at will may be deter* 
 mined or forfeited, and by what not,36j 
 C.j,<i4<jC,2. 
 
 f Le:
 
 A Table. 
 
 5 L'.vari facias vid. ExecHtieK, 
 
 Where a Lev-irifjcias Wcsy andot'what; 
 and where not. 69. 
 
 6 Licence, 
 
 Where onemuR il-.cw a Licence for doing 
 ot a iliipv;i and where- ic needs no;. r. 
 6jC. i. "siC. 2. 166. 
 
 What fiull be fjiJ a good Licence, and 
 wha;co[. 156C. 2. 
 
 1 L'tvcrj and S:i^n. 
 
 Whit Livery and Seifin is good, and what 
 1)01.119.204,285,3630.2. 
 
 8 Limitatiot:. 
 
 What fhall be agoodlinnitaiionofan E- 
 llace,and what not. 140, 274 C. 2.294, 
 
 9 Locxland Tranjitory. 
 
 What Aflions and things are local, and 
 what traufuory. p. 107 C. 2. 
 
 M 
 
 1 UVIaii.tenance^ 
 
 What fball be laid Maintenance, and what 
 not. 1 84* 
 
 2 <^l*>:dtUK«S> 
 
 In what cafes a writ of c3'^'"«^'»«jlies> 
 and in whit nor. p.7,8C. 5. 799 C. 
 4. 546C.2. j55C.i.45i>452, 453> 
 457. 45^' 
 
 3 (^lanjlaugbter, \ 
 
 What fiiiU be (aid Mtnflaughicr, and 
 whatnot.537*G^ i* 
 
 4 M-iriage, 
 
 To whom the Mariage of perfons belong?, 
 and to whom not, 237 C.4. 
 
 5 L^-tllus intjuireridum. 
 
 Where a Afe/iitt imjuirindHm lies, and 
 where not. 4$ I C. i. 
 
 4 Maxime, , 
 
 Maximes of Law are not 10 be broken. 
 149. 
 
 6 (^lerger. 
 
 Where a tWngmaybe faid to be merged 
 in another thing. 347, 548, 
 
 7 MifcoHtlnuxnce vid. Proceft, 
 
 8 MonfirAnce delfaits, c^f . 
 
 Where Deed?, Letters Patents arc to be 
 produced in Court , and where not. p. 
 IS C. 2.164. C. I. 
 
 • A 
 
 9 Mctitn. ■" 
 
 Whit Motions are tobemade inGpnrri 
 and what not . 1 ^ 5 C. 3 . 3 86 C. J. 
 
 What things the Court will rake rretice 
 of upon a Motion , and what nor. 1 77 
 f. 1.373 C.I. 387 C.4.464f.3. 
 
 10 Murthtr. 
 
 What fballbe laid Vforthcr, and vriitt not." 
 564C. I. - • J 
 
 ..■UjUA^ 
 
 N 
 
 .i .- 
 
 -dw -.n"i 
 
 1 T^e^^tive fregnans. 
 
 Where a plea conteynes x negative preg. 
 nam and where not. p. 66 C,2- 309 Cii« 
 
 I Ne exeat regMttm. 
 Where a ^<f f.vMf rf^»«»» lie;>and where 
 
 HOC
 
 A Table. 
 
 not. 395, 39<5, 440, &c. 
 
 2 limine paite. 
 
 The nature of a 7iominefce>"t, and how it 
 is to be demanded and recovered, p. 
 4- 
 
 3 No» ohjlame. 
 
 How ^» obflAntei fliall bc taken to inure> 
 and how not. 575, &c. 
 
 4 Nonfnu, 
 
 Where the party fhall be *'on futc , and 
 where not. 1380. 3.449 C.4. 
 
 5 Notice. 
 
 Where notice ought to be given of a thing) 
 and where It needs noo and what is a 
 good notice, and whit not. p. i 5 C. i. 
 p. 30, 31. p. 53 C.I. p. 57 C.i.p.6i C.I. 
 P.74C.2. 1C0C.2.172 C.i.ii^4C. I. 
 '87,163 c. 5. 273 C.3.1PJ C. 2. 303 
 C.3. 213, ai4,342C. a.386C. 3.438 
 C. I. 
 
 Of what Officers the Court of the Upper 
 Bench willtakcnotice of, and of what 
 not. p. 26 C. 2. p. S4 C i.PoC.j.p.pS, 
 456457'4s8. 
 
 Of what things the £'ourt will take no- 
 tice of, and of what nor, and how. p.70, 
 
 ,. 465^.2. 331,332,333,334,359^. I. 
 368,369,378.379. 
 
 6 Nudnm failum. 
 
 V Vhat fliall be faid to bc T^udum paClum, 
 and what not. p. jSCi. 249^. 2. 330 
 
 7 Nuj Ar.ee. 
 
 For what an Ar5i(e of Nufanccliei, for 
 what not. >95 C. i- 
 
 J Odtth vid. %>4§inv'H , 
 
 what Oath fliallbc laid perjiiry,vvhat nor, 
 z/»^. Perjury. 
 
 3 Obligation. 
 
 How a breach of the Condition of an 
 Obligaiion ought to be afsigncd,?. 1 8 
 C. I. 
 
 What i{ a good Obligation, what not. p. 
 28C.1.P.97 ^.1.21 2 C.3.234C.2.241 
 
 c.i. 277, 278,438 r. 2. 
 
 3 Off ernes. 
 
 What are offences at the Common law, 
 what not. p. 87 C.I. 2 1 5, 323,316 c:, 
 
 ^■: 
 
 t.l 
 
 I. 
 
 4 Office and Officers, 
 
 What Office Hiall be well granted, what 
 nor.2'56, 267)&c. 
 
 What Offices and Officers the Common- 
 law tak' snot ice of,and what noc.3 38C. 
 1.3940.2.457,458. 
 
 What offices may beexccurcJ by a De- 
 puty, and what not. 3 57 C.I. 
 
 5 Older. 
 
 For what caufcs orders of Scfsious, 
 and other orders may be quaflied, and 
 for what not. p. 14 C. 2.P.85.C.1.130 
 C. 3. IS4C. 1,3,4.168c. 1.173, i74t 
 184,185, i>>i, 192,207c. I. 283 C. 
 3.362 C.i>368 C.3. 385 C.6. 399C.I . 
 475 C.I.; 
 
 V Vhere the Court will not qualh errone- 
 ous orders. 358 C. 2. 
 
 VVhat Ordcrrthc Upper Bench will take 
 notice o*^,ind whatnot. 363 C. 1 . 41 5, 
 416,^45 C.I. 
 
 6 Ordinance of Parliament 
 vid. Parliament. 
 
 ■ 7 Ordinary 
 
 What Aftions lye againft the Ordinary, 
 and in what cafcSjand where not. 305. 
 
 VVhat things the Ordinary niay do> and 
 whatnot.4Ji ^.3.45<5. 
 
 8 Origi.^
 
 A Table. 
 
 8 Original vid* writ. 
 
 When an original writ ought to be filec'. 
 292, 2!?3. 
 
 Where one may have a nevv original vvri'j 
 and where no:. 404 C. 2. 
 
 9 Onttitwry. 
 
 Whar outlawry is good, an i what nor. p. 
 
 93 C. 1. 182 C. 2. 227c- 1. 297 C. I- 
 • 3J4C.1. 418,419,451 C.4. 
 How an outlawry ought to be teverfcd. 
 
 297 C.I. 548 C. I. 
 
 1 o Orvfiing. 
 
 What rhallbefaidan oufting one out of 
 poiTdlion, and whatnot, 277 C. i. 
 
 P 
 
 1 Paint 
 
 Where the Court will enjoyn a thing up- 
 on a pain, and where not. 368 C. i. 
 449 C. 4. 
 
 2 Vtyn fort et Aurtytr freffing. 
 
 Where prefling is ufed , and where not. 
 104 C.I. 
 
 3 Paymerit. 
 
 What fhallbefaida good payment, and 
 whatnot. 366 C. i. 393 C. j. 482. 
 
 What fluU b- a good proof of payment of 
 mony, and what not. 462 C. 3. 
 
 4 Pantl vid. lurj. 
 
 % Pardon, 
 
 How X pardon fliall be cooftrued. p. 43 C. 
 i-375>376, 377. 
 
 How a pardon is to be pleaded , and al- 
 lowed. 235 C. 3.337 C, i. 369 C. 2. 
 371C.3. 
 
 Z 
 
 What things arc pardoned by a general 
 pardon , and what not. 147 C. 2. 348 
 
 V>« I • 
 
 What pardon fhall be faid to be good, and 
 whatnot. 375,37(5, 377, 
 
 6 Parijl?. 
 
 of a Parifn, and of what ic confifls, and of 
 its extent, p, 77578, 9i> 1 37 C. i. 
 
 7 Parliament, 
 
 How anordinance of Parliament is to be 
 interpreted. i<5o, 161, 195, 196,197. 
 
 When orders and ordinances of Parlia- 
 ment fhall be faid to be in force, and 
 when not. 41 5,416. 
 
 8 Parell. 
 
 What things may be done by Parol!, what 
 not. 343 C 2. 
 
 Pariy aniPrivj.' 
 
 Where one fhall be faid to be party or 
 privy,and where not.39. 
 
 I o Patent and Patentee, 
 
 What the Kings Patentee may do by vir- 
 tue of his Patent, and what not, 246 , 
 247> &c. 
 
 1 I Pauper. 
 
 For what caufes one fuing in forwa paw 
 peris fhall be difpanpcrcd , and where 
 not. 386C. I. 
 
 I a Peace. 
 
 What things luftices of peace may do, and 
 what nor. i6<5 C. 1. 244 C. i. 24S, 
 246, 3*2C. 1.359,350, 475 C.t. 
 
 Whar things done fliall be faid a breach 
 of the peace, and what not.3 23. 
 
 Peer and Peerage y'ld. lontur. 
 
 Where Peerage (hall be allowed, and 
 where nor. 372 C.I, 
 
 z« 
 
 H
 
 A Table. 
 
 1 4 Peremftarj vid. Ple^t, 
 
 VVhat pleas arc pcrcmptory,ind what nor. 
 3880.1.4040,1. 
 
 75 Peru/. 
 
 VVhat oaih fluUbc faid to be pet jury, and 
 whatnot. 336,357,374c. z. 
 
 The maner of g'ning Iiidgemcnt upon a 
 conviition for perjury. 362,363. 
 
 16 Popduhy. 
 
 What is laid a perpetuity , and what nor. 
 278. 
 
 1 7 Place. 
 
 Where it is necefTary to allege a place, 
 and where it is not. p. z6C. 3. p. 59 C. 
 I.I42C.2.. ijiC.z. 287C. I. 341 
 C. 2. 3 57,3 5?- 
 
 1 8 Plaint. 
 
 What is a good plaint, and wfnc not, and 
 its nature, p. 86 C. 2. 1 1 5 C 1 . 
 
 19 V let and Pleading. 
 
 Wharoleiisgood in dilcharge rf a Co- 
 venants and what not. p. 8 C, 2. 163 
 
 C.3. „, ^ 
 
 What plea n qnod to julUfie a diHrefle ta- 
 ken, and wl.at rot, p. 13 <^. !• 17^' 
 
 C.I. 
 
 A Plea th.t is too general IS not good. p. 
 
 T6C.3-p.wC.3--'^C.2. 
 Where and wh.sn one may pL-ad to the 
 jurisdidion,whac not. . 97 C. r . 351 , 
 
 '.What plea ind pleadings are "ood , and 
 
 what erroncou'. p. 19 C. i. p. 37 C- '• /' ^^' 
 57,<;4C.x. p.78.79P. 9'^C. i. p. 9« *-• »• 
 
 c\ii8C.t.if9C.x.<^5C. 5.1^7,163, 
 177 C. 1. 178 C. t,i. 187, i88, I9J <-■ 3- 
 
 197 C l.tOiC. I.20<JC. I.Z09, XtO, 114 
 
 C. z. -iSC. 1. iio, xiijiti, »ij,i»< *-■ '• 
 141, i45 C- i.*?*,!^?' iy4'i"-C-'-^70, 
 175 C I '•S*^- ^^S'^^- ^ -88 C.I. z89, 
 a9?C. ;.'i93C. i.^ooC. I, 309C. I. J14, 
 
 401,403. W.i.40f C.3.4' 8C.i.4i'>C'.4ti 
 C. 1. 415 C. 4. 430 C- J.443J&C. 451 C. I. 
 
 What IS a j^ood piea in debt, vid. dcbtt 
 VVhat in TrelpalV, W. Trefpar?. 
 VVhat in covenant. r/f^.coienanr. 
 VVhat inTreliulson ihecale, w</.carc. 
 VVhat in adtion upon a promife, W. pro* 
 
 mile. 
 VVhat in accompt, vid. accompr. 
 For what catl'es one may demur to a plea, 
 
 and tor what not, W. demurrer. 
 VVhireone may plead fpecially , and 
 
 where not. 41 2 C, 2. 417 C. 5. 
 of what things one may take advantage 
 
 by pleading, and what not. p. J8 C. 2. 
 
 p. 324 403,479. 
 
 V Vhere ore may plead by way of juftifi- 
 cation, and where not. 470C. i. 
 
 VVhat pleas an Attorny may plead , and 
 what nor. 380 C. i. 
 
 V Vhat pleas are to be allowed, what nor. 
 431 C. r. 
 
 Where onemay plead his privilege, and 
 where nor, and how. 222, 223, 257 
 C. 1.295 C 3. 359 C. I. z/i<i. privi- 
 lege. 
 
 Where a pica is to be fworn, and where 
 not. 215 €.1.3730.3,4550.5. 
 
 Where one may vary fiom his pica , apd 
 wherenot. 341 O.4, 
 
 V Vhere one fliall not be compelled to 
 plead. 433 C.\. 
 
 VVhat is a good plea in bar ofthcAftioD, 
 and what in abatement of the writ, and 
 what not. 90 0. i. 114 C. 1. 123 0. 2. 
 187, 188, 212C. I. 2 2 1, 252, 253 , 
 254, 338,4040.1.410^.4140.1, 
 417 C.I. 43 1. 
 
 VVhat plea is forein, and whatnot. 373 
 C.3.435C.3. 
 
 VVhat plea is peremptory , what nor. 
 102, 103, 1 14 0. I. 388 C. 1. 404 
 
 zoPoff^efioH. 
 
 How a poffclTion ought to be fee forth in 
 
 pleading. p. 48,49. 
 VVhat (hall he (aid a putting out of pof- 
 
 fellion, and what not. 277 C, i. 
 VVhere and who fliall be laid to be in 
 
 poitellioD of a tbingj and vvbo not. 3 1 8> 
 
 319, 34iC. 1. 
 
 21.
 
 A Table. 
 
 Wbat po^ta is good, and what erroneousi 
 
 120CtI. 
 
 22 Precipe, 
 
 Where and for what a praecipe quad reddat 
 lies, and where and for what not.p, 9 C, 
 J, p, 30C. 2. 
 
 23 Prerog.ttwe vidi King. 
 
 Where a I'ubjeft may take advantage of 
 the Kings Prerogative, where not, ^67, 
 268, &c. 
 
 24 Prefcrlption, 
 
 What is a good prefcriptior, what not p. , 
 31 C, 1.233 C. 4,289, 300, 301 J 44<5 I 
 C.I. 
 
 Where a prefcription is well alleged, and 1 
 where not, 477, &c» I 
 
 a 5 Prefentation, 
 
 ;What prefentation (hall he good,and wJiat 
 not.p* 83,156 C.», 370. 
 
 26 Prtfentntentt 
 
 yVhat prefcp'raent is good, and what 
 not.p, 14 C. I. '. 24 C. 2. p. 130 C 3 . 
 173 €♦ 2.I9I, f92,27y» 
 
 27 Prheipaland iccefory^ 
 
 Where one fiiall be '^lid to be principal , 
 andwhercbutaccefTory. p. 86 C i. 
 
 Prifon and Prifoner vid. Bail and difcharge. 
 
 Where a Prifoner may be difcbarged, 
 and where not, 90 97, '^9 C 1.238 
 C f. 369 C. . 369 C. 3. 386C. 4. 
 395 C.I. 4»8C. 4.433 C. 1.454 C«'» 
 3. 475 C. 1 , 47 J C. 2. t-fi*. difcharge. 
 
 VVherca Prifoner may be bailed , and 
 where not . r)6^ 9'j-,^66 C^i, vtd, bail. 
 
 yVherea Prifonei may be removed, and 
 wherenot. J39, 3(?7 r. 2. 563C, i* 
 397 C. 2. 434 C. 1 . 4 JO C. I » 
 
 29 Privilege, 
 
 V Vbcre a writ of priv-Iegc lieir, and where 
 not, and for whoni.andfor whom not. 
 139C. 3.23-fd. 
 
 VVhereone may claim or plead a privl« 
 Ifge, and where not. 167,1-^8 214 c, 
 2. 222.223, 234 C.I, 252, 253, jj4, 
 ^95 C.3.373C.1.413 C, 1.454C. I, 
 460 C,3.t)»d'Plea. 
 
 The priviltge of the Clergy, vid. Clergy,' 
 
 The privilege of Peers, t//^. Honour^ 
 
 30 Ptcctdindv. 
 
 Where A proudiudoUe^^ and where not^ 
 p, 69,70. p. 100 C. I, 127 C, J. 151 
 C. 2.226,227, 229 c. 1.345 C'.i.3 2| 
 C, z. ' . " 
 
 3 I Trcceidingt^ 
 
 What proceedings of fourts are good.and 
 what not. p. 45 C, 2. p, 91 C.i, '125 
 C. J. 
 
 Where I he Court will flay proceedings,' 
 
 and where nor. 41 3 C. 3. 
 How 10 proceed in an endidment, and 
 
 howinan informatioD. :j7C.a. 
 
 3 1 Process vid* FiUng^ 
 
 For what things proceHe may iflue out of 
 the upper Bench Ccurr,tor what not.p, 
 26 C, 7. 
 
 What retorn of procefs is good, and what 
 not. p, 330 C.I. 
 
 ProcefTc how to be diredf J. p. 26 C. 5, 
 
 Wh ere procefles fbali be faid to be difcon. 
 tinued.and wherenot. p. 58 v., 2, p, 
 66 , 2. p. 70>7h9;C. i.p. Ill C.I, 
 '22 C, 3.209 C, J. 210, 5:;9C, 3. 
 
 Where procefTes (hall be .^aid to mifcohti.' 
 nue,and wherenot,237,339C.3, 
 
 Where the Court may Jilcontinue pro- 
 cefles, where nor. 306. 
 
 Where proc.fle mav be flayed, and where 
 not, 147 C. 2, 18) C, 2, 
 
 33 Frac/amatio^t 
 
 ■What proclaraarion is good, what not.'9r,' 
 S>2. 237» 
 
 '^
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 l^ Proof. 
 
 WhatfliaUbeaccomprcd a good proof of 
 of an Ad of Parliament or other mat- 
 ter cf ha. 155 C. 1.462 C. 3,4. 
 
 35 
 
 Frobibiiion. 
 
 Where ^ Prohibition tothe Prerogaiive 
 Court or other Court may be granted, 
 and where not. p .10. C i.r.55 56 74^ 
 75. S7 C.i.ioiC.n47C.i.228C.3. 
 299c. 1, 346C. 1.439 440,45 5-. 45^- 
 
 Where a Prohibition lyes toan interiour 
 Court or Jurifdiition, anJ where nor. 
 p.45C.:.<f5 C 3.89C.2.150C. 1.166, 
 107,170 C.i.i 7 2,17 5'i 83 C.2.207 C. 
 2. 235 C. i.285,i86;4i8C. i.fyoC. 
 4. 
 
 3 6 Prom'fe* 
 
 How a bru'ch of promife mufi be afsigncd, 
 
 \\ 17 c. i.p. 107 C. I. 
 Hew one mil it declare in an Albion for a 
 breach of promilc, whereapromiieby 
 paroll is reduced into writing, p. 19, 
 20, 
 What IS a "ood confideraiion to ground 
 a promife upon, and what not. 5 7 C.i. 
 p.58C.t.p.63 C.i.r3i C. I. 248C. 1. 
 264C. I. 280 C. 2. 295 C.2. 296 C.i . 
 303 C. 3.5C4> 305> 33<^C.z. 395,396, 
 411 C.2.440C. i.459>4<5o 47 2,47 3• 
 Whcre a promife may be i^idiobedif- 
 
 charged , and where not. 303 C. 3. 
 What is a good oromife to .;round an A- 
 <^tion upon the Cafe, ind what not.;\ 63 
 C. i.p.;o4C.3.iii C.2.i5 2,i5 5,i57 
 C.J. 249 C.I. 291 C.3.303 e.g. 304, 
 305, 330C.2.40S C. 2> 416 C. :. 419 
 C.2 420C.1. 440C. i.459j4^0'f'55 
 
 C.2. 472,473- , , 
 
 Where a promile fl^all be faid to be joynt, 
 an i where feveral. 23 C. i. 
 
 What is a good plea indifcharge ofa pro- 
 mife, and what not. 309 C. 1. 
 
 37 Fropert/. 
 
 Where one (Kail be faiJ to have t proper- 
 ty in a thing, and where not. p.54 C. 1. 
 55)73.74. 
 
 Where one may alter the property of 1 
 thing, and where. 338. 
 
 3 8 ProtcElion. 
 
 of a Proteflion, and the benefit of 1:, p. 
 
 40. 
 Where and from whom ProreAion is due, 
 
 and where nor , and to whom, and to 
 
 whonot. 227 C. 4. 
 
 39 Frottfttuiev, 
 
 Of thcDature ofa Prote^ation , and what 
 is agood Protelfation , and what nor, 
 and where it lies, and where not. 266, 
 267> &c. 
 
 40 Pmchafe. 
 
 Who may be faid a Purchafcr , ani who 
 
 noi. 1 ;9C.i.273 C.i. 
 Who may purchafc lands, and who not. 
 
 388 C. 3. 
 V Vho niall be faid to be intitled to lands 
 
 by purchale, and who not. 148, 14$). 
 
 Q-, 
 
 1 Qjmfhing of Endi^ments, Order s^ 
 drcndt ^ndiilmtnts^ Orders, &c% 
 
 2 Quo WarratHe. 
 
 For what a Quo Htfranto lycSj and for 
 what not.418 C. 5. 
 
 R 
 
 1 Recital. 
 
 Whit Recital Hiall be good, and what not. 
 p.107,108, 185 C.I. 344)34J>4o8C. 
 2. 411 C.i.42i,C. 2. 
 
 2 Re-
 
 A Table. 
 
 2 Recogtii^anct. 
 
 Where a Recognifance may be difchar- 
 gcdjand vyhcrcnoc.364 C. j. 
 
 5 %jcord. 
 
 How a Record is co be pleaded, and how 
 
 given tn evidence.! 2 C. i . 
 What is matter tf Record , v\ hat nor.4^4 
 
 C. 4. 
 Where one may have view of a Record, 
 
 aha where not.444 C 1. 
 Where a Record may be amended , and 
 
 wherenoi. x"V. Amcndmcnr. 
 
 4 Recovery. 
 
 Whit thing? are recoverable at the Com- 
 mon-law, and what nor. p. 55. 
 
 Of what things a Recovery lies , ando' 
 what not. 215 C.5.450C. 2. 
 
 Where a Recovery {hall be good , and 
 where not. 246 C.I. 319, 320,321. 
 
 Bfcufant, 
 
 Hovyt a Recufant ought to conform fincc 
 Bifliops taken away. 36 C. 4. 
 
 5 Reference. 
 
 Where the Court will make a reference, 
 and where not. 1 10, C. 2. 214 C. a. 
 372 C, 2. 
 
 6 %ejojnder. 
 
 Upon what a Re joynder ought to be, and 
 
 upon what not. p.70 C. i . 
 Where one may re oyn and where not. 
 
 40i,8(c.44oC. I. 
 
 7 Relation. 
 
 How and to what time things fhall be 
 ■ ("aid to relate,and to what not. 341 C.3. 
 3 5(5C.2.38iC.2. 
 
 8 Releafe. 
 
 What Releafe is good and what 1101.17$ 
 C. \, i8<5, 287,'f73. 
 
 9 Repeal vid. Statute. 
 
 What thing? may be repealed , and what 
 not. 228 C. 5. 
 
 10 Repleader. 
 
 VVherfe there ought to be a Repledcr> 
 and where not. 2 1 0,2 1 1,41 2 C.i, 
 
 I I Replication, 
 
 VVhat Replication is good,jnd what nor. 
 P.41C.2. "loC. 3.309C.1.356C. 2. 
 373 C. 3. 379' 3 So, 396,401:4025432 
 C.4. 440C. I. 
 
 I 2 Retjueft. 
 
 Where afpccial Requcll is nece(l"ary,and 
 where ir is noc.49 C.i .p. 54 C. i .p.74 C, 
 2. 107 C. t. 141 C. 1 -1 43,144.207 c. 
 4. 45 8 C. I. 
 
 VVhat iliall be faid a good Rcqueft, and 
 whatnot. 138c. i. 
 
 I 3 RefcoUSi 
 
 For what caufes a writ of Refcous may be 
 quallicd} for what not. 1 5 5 C4. 4 1 7 C. 
 2. 
 
 14 Reptution. 
 
 In what cafes a Reftituticnlyes, and in 
 wharnot.p. 35.0,41 C. i. 0.42,43, 87, 
 88.r. 89.^.',p.9oC.2.i36 ^-S-iSiC. 
 1 .1 5 5 C. 1 . 186 C1.208 C.3.347,4oS C. 
 I-4H, 4i5>44'5C. 3«452;4s3»4y7» 
 458.477547^j&c- 
 
 1 4 Rent. 
 
 Where a Rent fhall be fufpcndcd, and 
 where not. ^. 2. 
 
 15 Retainer. 
 
 Where a Retainer of Goods doth lye 
 and where not. 338, 584, 
 
 laaa 
 
 1 6 Rettm '
 
 A Table. 
 
 16 Siiorf. vid. Procejfe^ 
 
 VVhat Rerorn o'^Procefs is'',ood , and 
 whatnor.p.^i,^?.p.^5.?6.p.39 4Mi> 
 4j,67,6t;,69 77,7?,S4.85.;.S5C.i. 
 
 89C.i,9oC.7,-t Pi f'- »-9^ ^■' •• P- 98 
 C.I.I 20,121,145^.2.150^.2. I 51 C.I. 
 1^4^. T<j<;r.4 17^.174,17^ '79- 
 180, 191 C !.203,io4,236,2i7,x55 C 
 1. 294C.2.^3oC.t. 34^,415, 4»5,Hi 
 C. 2.444 <^' i.445C.?.446C. 3.452> 
 45?. 457,458,474^.1.475^,1.4771 
 478, ^c. 
 Where ProcefTcs (hill be retornei in an 
 exiraof liinary way, 3r.d vv.tere not. p 45 
 
 C.T. 
 
 Where a Jury may be retorn«6 by the Se 
 ccndary,acd not by the Sberif , 477 <^" 
 
 2. 
 
 2t Rohhtrjt 
 
 What fhall befaid a Robbery, and what 
 not, andofwhom.iy6 €,3.318, 319. 
 
 2 2 RnU, 
 
 What Rules the Court will make, and 
 
 W!l.ll n't. i(;4 t , 1. ily c. t.ir3 C. 4, 158 
 C a J 5 C.i.^tS C.i.jii C.3.?i8 C. I. 35J t.i. 
 5<'7 '. 3. 3<^* '^'.i.jKi C. t 388C. 1. 405, 404, 
 4I1 C. 1,1. 413 c. I. 414 C. I. 451 C. 5. 4<54 
 C.J. 
 
 How far a rule of Court will bind, and 
 where nor. 343 C13, 
 
 \6 Rpt, 
 
 What enquiry and finding of a Ryot is 
 good, and what not. 166 C.!. 
 
 17 Rivcrfal, 
 
 For what faults an Outlawry nnyhere» 
 verled, and for w'.iat not, 227 C. 2.418, 
 
 419- 
 Wiiere a Fine levyid may be rcverfcd, 47 2 
 
 C. t. vid. Fine. 
 
 18 Rcv'tvert 
 
 How ihinq? may be revived and bow not, 
 4i8C.3.4'^^^<-". 2«483' 
 
 19 Revoc-ititn, 
 
 What is a good Rtvocation.and what not. 
 4i8(^.3'4-4' 
 
 2 Right, 
 
 What things belong to one of Common 
 
 right, and whar not. 3(^3. 
 Where perfons are bourvd to do thln^sof 
 
 Common righr, 2nd where not. ^6^Q. 
 
 4 574,375.41 8 C, 2, 
 
 1 Sate. 
 
 2 Sati.'faUion'. 
 
 What fhall be nccompted a goodSatiifafti' 
 on to plead in bar of an Adion ofTrcf- 
 pafs,^ what not.p,20.C.i.vid. 7rf/^a/i-, 
 
 What. Debts ought by Law to be firft fatif* 
 fiedjz^ (!/. Debt, 
 
 What fhatr be accorapted a good fatisfa* 
 dion of a Debt, &c, 239 C , 2, 
 
 5 Saving. 
 
 To what intent a favingin StatutCf,Ordi5 
 nances of Parliament ,»&:c. (hall inure; 
 160, 161, 
 
 4 Scanddlum Jiiagnatuntt 
 
 5 Scire facias. 
 
 In what place a Sc'tri facia* ought to be 
 
 brought, p, 9, C. I, 
 For what Caufes a Sciri fan s may be 
 
 brought, and for what nor. p, a6 C, i .p, 
 
 50C. I. p. 1 05 C. 2. 251 C. 2. 290 C. 2* 
 
 348C.i.45<5,4)7, 
 VVbat Pica is gooA 10 1 Scire facias, ztii 
 
 what not, fiV. Plea, 
 What Scire fac as Kgooi, and what not. 
 
 p.72 C,3,2j;oC« 1. 
 
 6Se>
 
 A Table. 
 
 6 Stcnritj* 
 
 Where one may take fecurity , and where 
 not. p. 55, P«7J,74. p« 89 C. !♦ 
 
 Where fecurity (hall be put in for doing of 
 aching, and where not, p« 322 C, 3, 
 433^»i^ 
 
 7 Seifure, 
 
 2, 438C.i. 4(57,4(58, &c. 
 
 \i SiibmilfieK, 
 
 What is a good fubmifsicn, and what not^ 
 85, 136 C. a. 30(5, 307, 351 C.t. 
 
 13 Sftreti.'s. 
 
 '4 Suggtfiion or Surmi/e, 
 
 Ofwhat things, and where a feifure may 
 
 be made, and of what not, p, 75. 233 A Tugfjcnion to grocnd a prohibition up 
 C.4, 
 
 8 Se(]:tfflratio«i 
 What things are fequcftrable, & by whom. 
 
 I6*yl62, 169, 
 
 p Setltmintt 
 
 What fetlement of poor people is good, 
 and what not, 168 C, i, 
 
 I o Severs, 
 
 on rauft be pofitive, and not argumen- 
 tative, p. I. 
 VVhere there ought to be a fuggeftion, or 
 furmife made, and where not. 371C. 
 I, 
 
 15 S^tfi, 
 
 1 6 Summons, 
 
 What fl-iall be a good fommons, artd 
 
 what not.p.67.68,dp,77,7S, 51, 92, 99, 
 143 C,u * 
 
 Ofwhat things CommifTioncrs of Sewers , 
 
 may takeconulanceof, andofwLatnct. ) i-] Su^erfcdeas, 
 
 p. 6i C. «. 
 What Coir.mifTioners of Sewers may do, ^ In what cafes a fp.ferftAeas h'es and in 
 
 and what not, 178, \'J9, 180, 1S4, 
 185,191,192,4450,3, I 
 
 i 
 II Statutes. 
 
 What Statutes arc repealed,and whatnot. 
 
 212C. 2. 
 Where an aftion may be brought upon a ' 
 
 Statute, and where not. vid, Aftion. 
 What adions are barred by the-.tatute of 
 
 liraitations.of 2 1 Jac,and what xioi,-jid, 
 
 Aftion, 
 
 whntnor.46C. ;.p.„8C,2.,59 ,60 
 «77C.:.M«C.3 255C. 2.254 C,,; 
 321C. 3,330c. 1.3950.1.415. 
 
 1% Snfer§it:on, 
 
 What ftiili be faiJ a fupjr.litious nfe, end 
 whatnot, 3f,37,5', J 2. ^»V. Ufe.'p.gr 
 82,83, 
 
 19 Supply. 
 
 What faults in pleadings are helped by the \ What things the Law muft funj Ir and 
 Statute of jeofails, and what not. p. 8; I whatnot, p. 12 C, 2, J > ana 
 
 C. 2- p. 63 (55. p, 7i.p, 91 C. I, ii.) 
 C. «. i5i,i;;9 C 2, 170C. 2-i74,i75> 
 
 198 C, 2. 206 C, I, aio, 211, 2. 8C. 2, 
 23^, C, i,23jC. 2. 256 C. I. 2d5 r, 2, 
 307C, 1,401, &c. 438 C.J. 47: C, 2. 
 483 C. 2. 
 How Statutes (hall be interpreted, p. Si, 
 8:, 83 . 84 C, 2. p. 9 1 C. 1. 180. p, 181 , 
 182,190c, t. 195, )9<5, 197, 230 C. I. 
 3S9, 307 C. 1. 33 5 &c. 381, 58s, 430 C, 
 
 20 Sitrfnife vid. Sufgeflion, 
 
 21 Surplftfagf^ 
 
 22 Sttrrender, 
 
 What
 
 A Table. 
 
 what words amount unco a furrend'-r,and 
 
 what not. 4> ^ ♦ !♦ 
 What fliall be- a good furrendcr of a copy- 
 hold, or otber eftate, and what not. 
 a8o C, 2. 29h ^9h 4^*5 ^' '* "^^^ 
 
 Ct2, 
 
 aj Sitffi»f'o»> 
 
 VVhat (hall be a good fufpenfion from an 
 office or other thing. p« 3 J> 3^ 
 
 9 Tithes, 
 
 yVhere a taUs taay be granted , and 
 where not. p. \6 C, <♦ 233 C« 3» 44? 
 
 C, 2. 
 
 CTajlsM.Ftttajl. 
 
 3 TrtAT, 
 
 VVhatisalawfulltax,and what not. p. 
 n,t4 138", 139 » »8o, I8j, 191 , 
 
 4 Ttnant and Te*""''!* 
 
 VVhit (hall be faid a tenancy in common, 
 and what a joymcnancy. »ii ^ «2,434, 
 
 435. 
 
 5 Tenement t 
 
 VVhat (hall be faid to be a tenement, and 
 whatnot. «<5i, 162. 
 
 6 Tender, 
 
 •J Term, 
 
 8 Tenure, 
 
 VVhat things may be faid to lye in tenure, 
 and whatnot. i79» 
 
 Where tithes arc to be paid , and where 
 I not, and to whom. p. 157 C, I. 
 
 1 o Title, 
 
 VVhere in pleading one oughttoftiew a- 
 
 nothers title to a thing and where not. 
 
 .5C.Z. 
 VVhac things the Kmg (l)all be inticled to, 
 
 and what nor. p. 20,21,40, 41, $1,52, 
 
 p.75,8',82,33. 
 Where one ought co entitle himfelf to a 
 
 thing, and where not. 395 C. a- 42<>. 
 
 C. ». 
 
 n Transferring. 
 
 Where and by what adt a thing fliali be 
 faid to be transferred to another , and 
 where not. ii6,i\-j, 
 
 I 2 Tranfiterj vid. Ltcai^ 
 
 1 3 Traverfe, 
 
 VVhat chings are traverfable , and what 
 
 not. p. 87,139 Ci. 
 Where it is neceflary to take a traverfe , 
 
 and where not, 150, iti, i98j 199, 373 
 
 C.:?.3S:C. 3.432C.4. 
 VVhat traverle is well taken, and what 
 
 not 332i34u.C. 1.382 C, 3. 
 
 14 Treafon, 
 
 How and when Judgement (hall be given 
 in high treafon. 104 C. 1, 
 
 15 Trtrptfft, 
 
 How to declare in adion of trefpaffe vi et 
 armit, p. 20 C. 1, 408 C. a. 
 
 Where an aftion of trefpaflc lies vi et art 
 mis, and where not, and for what, and 
 for what not. 4^ 44. p. 94C, i. 9<? , 
 100, 16(5,^-3 5 C. 4. 51? C. 2. 541 C 
 2, 342 C. I. 34^ 347, 34S, 357, 
 
 VVhat h a pood plea in bir of an adioa 
 
 oftrefparie, and what nor. p. (55 C. i , 
 
 I 2» p. 7i C. !. 112 C. a.idj, 166, 201 , 
 
 302,
 
 A Table. 
 
 202, 213 C. 3. 313 C. 2. 34(5)3475 
 348, 355 c. 2. 
 Where an Aftion of Trclpafs upon the 
 Czic\icS}Vid, Cafe. 
 
 1 6 Trover, 
 
 Where an A(ftion of Trover and Comer- 
 (ion lyes, and where not. 44, 23 5 C. 2. 
 261 C. 2. 3 I 3 C. 2.341 C.2. 3(51)1 84, 
 
 482 C> !• 
 
 1 1 Trjal. 
 
 Where an Aiftion is to be tryed, and 
 
 where not. p. 2.p.io.C.i.i9i C.1.331, 
 
 532, &c. 4(5oC- 3. 
 Where one may Jbe hindred from a Tryal, 
 
 and where not. 339 C.2 . 403 C. i. 
 Where the Court will grant a new Tryal, 
 
 and where not. 448 C. 2.462 C. 5.466 
 
 C. 1. 
 
 What Tryal is good, and what not. p, 3 3 
 C. i.p. 34C.i.42C.:.p.75C.i. 86 C. 
 1. 110C.2.111 C. 1. 129 C. 5.1 37 C. 
 3, 4' 139) 140' 191 C I. 201 ^. I. 
 2c6 C.I. 342C.2;4i2C3.43oC.2. 
 43 2^-''34SC-i. 
 
 i%Trttfl^ 
 
 of what things a Trull may bC) and of 
 
 what not. p. 2 s • 
 What a Truli is, and why it was invented. 
 
 p. 21,40" 
 
 What things a Truflee, or ceftuy quetruft^ 
 may do) and what not. p. 41, 
 
 19 Time. 
 
 The Law allows convenient time to do a 
 
 thing, p.i I C.2. 143, 144. 
 Where the time for doing or not doing a 
 
 thing \i to be fet forth, and where ii is 
 
 not neceff»ry, 17C. 2. 178C.2.243. 
 Where fra«flion of cime is allowable, and 
 
 where pot. p. 72 c. 1. 1 1 9. 
 How time for doing of a thing is to be 
 
 comr"ted. 170C. 3.581 C.i. 
 Where ttie Court will allow time to do a 
 
 thing, where not. 208 Cti .249 C. 1.47 5 
 
 C.3, 
 
 Who {liaii be fiid 
 who nor, 168 C. i. 
 
 ^ 
 
 1 flagrant or Beggar, 
 to be 
 
 a'Vagranr, 
 
 2 f^alue. 
 
 3 FArranee. 
 
 What variance in 'pleading makes error, 
 and what not. p.5 C. 2.p.io9C.2.\i8, 
 ii9, 141, 142,177 C.2.i88,i 89,243,244 
 C.2. 277.278.344)345,374 C. 1.378 
 C. 1.472 C. 2.477c. I. 
 
 4 Vinire or Venue. 
 
 Whence the Venue ought to be upon 
 Tryal ot an Action, p. 2. p. 7.C. i.p." 
 15 C. 3.341 C. 3.393 G. 1.4'^oC. 
 3. ■ 
 
 Wi>atK^*i>*isgoodiand whatnot, p. 8.C. 
 2.p. 20.C. 2.p. 2 3s24. p. 28,29.p. 34 
 C. i.p.6o,6i.p.86C. 2. p. 96 C.2. 107 
 C. :. 1 1 1 C. I. 1 19, 1 20, 164, 165. 
 16) C. 2. 195 C. 2. ^SjC. I. 
 
 where there may be a ye>:ire de novo, and 
 where not. p.g 3, 64, 176 C.i- 205 C. 1. 
 275) 307 C. 1. 335 C. I. 399, 410, 
 C.I. 445 C.I, 
 
 where the Venue may be changed) and 
 where not. 387 C. i.395C,2. 
 
 5 rerd;tt. 
 
 Where ayerdia is well giv^n^ and where 
 nor.p.6 r ,62,63,54,9 5 .94,1 ^4 c. 4.141 
 C I. 148 C. 2. 167 C. 2.176 C.i. 188) 
 279^3I i)3i2.527C.i. 328,329,385 
 C. 2.432 C.2.450C. i.46oC. I. 
 
 What things in pleading may be helped 
 by a Verdifl, and what not.p.80, 115 C. 
 2.i7o.i7i>i76'i77'iPSC.2.229C.3v 
 231 C. 2. 236 C.I. 265 C.2. 3C1, 307 
 C. 1.^2 C. I. 349C.i.37oC.4,46i 
 C. 2.472 C. 2. 
 
 What Ipccial Verdidl isgood, and what 
 not. 282,284,285,3350.1,409,410. 
 Bbbb eVepng"
 
 A Tabic. 
 
 6 Vefling. 
 7 ViccArage, 
 
 What things are accompted Viftuals, and 
 whatnot. 190C. i- 
 
 9 Vierf, 
 
 What things maybe done upon a View? 
 and what not. id^C. i. 346)451 C. 2. 
 472 C.I". 
 
 1 o Vo'ii, 
 
 What is void) and what voidable. 209, 
 
 210. 
 
 What (liall be faid a (uperftitious ufe, and 
 what nor. 36, 57, 51, 525 81, 82, 8^. 
 
 Where a ufc Oiall be faid 10 be well railed, 
 and where not. 188,189, ao4> 205. 
 
 1 1 Uilxsvrj-, vid. Omlarvry^ 
 
 w 
 
 I PVager of Law, fee Law. 
 
 2 WMv'er. 
 
 Where a thing may be waivcd.where not. 
 p. 5iC. 2.61 C. 2. 119,403 C.I. 417 
 C.J. 
 
 a If Arrant, 
 
 Where aVVarrantistobefbewed, and 
 where it needs not to be. 405 C. 4. 
 
 VVhen a VVarrant of Attorney fhall be 
 determined, and when not. 426 C. i . 
 
 3 fVarren, 
 
 4 pra/fe. 
 
 V Vhat is a good plea in bar of an Adion of 
 Warte, and what not. 48. 
 
 $ fVajes. 
 
 VVhooughtto repair High-wayeS) and 
 whonot. 163C. 2. 364C.4. 
 
 How t Will fhall be interpreted 211 C. 
 
 I. 240, 249>*5o> 251, 258, 559.160, 
 
 261,262,275,27(5,278,279,295,194, 
 
 301, 302, 307,308,309,316,317, 319 
 
 C. 1. 3890.2.409,410,434,435. 
 What dull be faid i good will, and what 
 
 nor. 240, 427C. 3, 
 Where a Will may be repealed, and 
 
 where nor. 228 C. 3. 
 How a Will may be proved, and hownor. 
 
 37cC. I. 
 How a Will may be revoked, and how 
 
 revived, and how nor. 343 C. 2. 418 
 
 C.3. 
 What A&s a Tenant at will may do, 
 
 whatnot. 380 ^. 2. 
 
 fyhcb craft. 
 
 What is Witch-craft within the Statute 
 of 1 J<if. and whatnot. p.59C. 2, 
 
 8 fVitnefs. 
 
 Who is a good witncrs,and who not. 3 70 
 C.i.388C.3.4<^«C«i'404C. 2.481 
 
 C. 2. 
 Who may be examined as a witnefs, and 
 who not , and upon what matters. 449 
 C. 3.t'«i.TriaI. 
 
 9 mrdr. 
 
 How words which are doubtful! (hall be 
 conftrued. p. 22,23, 24)25,27^.2, 3. 
 
 p. 3 1
 
 A Table. 
 
 p. 31 C. I. 41 C. I, 45, 44 C. I. 59 C. t. 6i C. 
 1. p. ^9 C.I. p. 7JC.I. p. go. C. i.8i,8i, 8J. 
 p. 106 C. 1, ». 108 C. I. Ill, II J C. J. i88> 
 l8jj 194 C. I. I9J C. t. 199, zoo, loj, 104, 
 aOj,ii4, ii^ijf C, I. ij7,ij8C. 3.140,141, 
 j4t t. I. 149, ijo, If I, 177, 178, 1J8, if9, 
 j_go, itfi, 151, 179, i8t C. 1. 301, joi, 307 , 
 308, 309,3190. 1.3x5,316, 35tfC. 1. 358 c. 
 3. 3^0} 36i> 3^15 389 C. 1.407,410, 447 C. 1. 
 4J4>43 J f ■ 3- 4jtf> 457, 438. C.t. 4^0. 
 
 How words arc to be ulcd in pleading, 
 p. 37' ?^7' 3^8,481 C- I- 
 
 Where words fhall be adjudged void. 45 
 C.I. 102 C. 2.334C.1. 
 
 loW'/if. 
 
 Where a writ fliall be faid to be well di- 
 rcdcd) and where not. 42, 4 J, 2 37. 
 
 To whom writs arc to be direcled , to 
 whom nor. 461 . 
 
 Where one may plead in abatement ofa 
 
 wnr, and where not. p. 50C. i.p. 84, 
 
 99, 201,202, i6Q(^. 1., -3 8, 404^1. 
 
 4*1 C. 2. 
 Where a writ is to be abatedjand where 
 
 bucabiteible.42 1 C.2.44I. 
 For what caufis a writ fhali be abated, and 
 
 for what noc.p j,i 38 C. 1 .190 C.1.19C. 
 
 I.^OJ C.I.204,2l8C.I.22I,2 2 3,237, 
 
 260, 265 C. I, 303 C. 1.407,421 C- 
 
 2. 
 Wh^re a writ of A'ie exe^t regmm lye?jind 
 
 where nor. 440 &c. 
 Where a writ of crquiry ofdammages lie?, 
 
 and where not. i 27 C. i . 288, vid. En« 
 
 quiry. 
 Wiicre the ancient forms of wiitsmay be 
 
 altrcd, and where nor. 2 1 8 C. 1. 
 Wiien an Original writ ought to be filed. 
 
 292,293. 
 Where one may have a newOriginal writ) 
 
 and where ooc. 404 C. 2. 
 
 To 
 
 ^.1
 
 To the Reader* 
 
 B Efhafei to (ake notice th^tmtyvithjianding mj more than ordinary care in CorrcUing 
 , he I'rejfe-, thtfe tnfmng Erratacs have haf^cnei in the Printing, hut masj ■ cf them are 
 but literal, ^ndatier not the [enje-, and for the others I hope pu will pardon theW) and corre^ 
 them I? J the Errata as yott meet with them. 
 
 ERRATA. 
 
 P Age 10. ). f . for Barker, read Barlye p.76. r. for Bcndirj r. Denoir. p. 104, »of. r. 104, lof. 
 p. 108. r. Paget for Psgott. p. 8. 1. 3. r. facias for facis. p. 8.1. laft but one and Jaft, r. revcrfed , 
 for affirmed, p. if. I. 8. r. if;ainft, ior again, p. iC.l. iX. r. (or to Sub-dcimty, to the Sub-deputy. 
 p. 17. ). T,t. r. for at Bar, at tlic Bar. p. 48. J. ly. r. againft.for again, p. 75. 1. ly. r. him, for hinn. 
 p. 106. C. 1. in the raargent put out Ameicenient. p. 166. r. Dcnoyr, for Bendir. p. 171. 1. z^. r; 
 bail, (or bailed. p.iSj. 1. 17. r. ce:tifie, for reft fie. p. 9S. J. 11. r. Icniijnj,s, for Gennings. p, nj. 
 C. 3. r. Barmcftonc, for B-irnefton. p. ^l6. 1. 4j.r. and not to,t or and to. p. 228. C, 4. in the mar- 
 gene, r. to have EKCcu'ion, infteed of to have ludgcment. p. 243 I. x J. r, but that the, for but that. 
 p. Z49. ). C. 3. in the title, 1. Pawfye,for Bawlye. p. 258. r. lay and lay, f r Gay and Gay. p. x6n'. 
 1. 13. r. implyed, for imployed. p. itf j. :, C. in ihe title, r. Skedlock, for Shedlock. p. 170. 1. j y , 
 16. r. (he, for he. p. iSf. i'. nmrata, tor mutate, p. 194.). i. for an, r. and. p. 199. l.iy. r. Defendants. 
 p. 306. 1. 16. r. replication, p. 311. 1. 19. r. publico, p. 32^. 1. j. r. Sufanna.for page 324. r. 33^. p. 
 344 111 the mjrger:t,for inditcment r. inducement, p. 34^. 1. 10. for common by intendment, r. by 
 C6mnion intendment, p. 348. r. Tippin, for Pippin, p. 549. I. ifi. r. acquittance , for acquuirtance. 
 p. 353. 1. 19. r. it, for 1. p. 371. 1. 8. for to bar, r. to the bar. p. 374. for Troos, r. Too?, p. 388. after 
 Newton and O shorn, r. Tiin. itfyj.ror. 1780, p. 409.for Fcnham, r. Fenwick. p.398. !• ii. r. aftion, 
 fofajtion. p.410.1. 4S.For Boynton, r. Baynton. p. 413. 1. 39. for caule, r. cuflom. p. 432.1,19. 
 fo"" was fitting, r. was not (itcir.g. p. 440. 1. z. for of of, r. of. p. 44^. 1, 9. for fidavir, r. Affidavit, p. 
 447 .1. 13. for ttd, r. to. p. 448. 1. 8. for thou, r. then, p. 4^1. 1. laft, for gronted, r. granred. p. 477. 
 for lackibn, r. lohnfon. p. 474. 1. 18. for deeds, r. goods, p. 180. 1. 9. for books r. book, and J. Ii, 
 r. that lands, for chat the lands, p. 481, 482, 483. in the head of the page, for Trin. t. Mich.
 
 • •
 
 m.-y\'\^ 
 
 -2»
 
 uc SOUTHERN REGIONAL ueaw^FjWjJ^^^ 
 b 001120126 6
 
 *A »^