?/vl - noo UNCLASSIFIED UNCLASSIFIED ORNL-1700 Subject Category: PHYSICS UNITED STATES ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION EFFECT OF RADIATION ON THE DIELECTRIC CONSTANT AND ATTENUATION OF TWO COAXIAL CABLES By R. A. Weeks D. Binder March 19, 1954 Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge, Tennessee Technical Information Service, Oak Ridge, Tennessee Date Declassified: February 23, 1955. This report was prepared asa scientific account of Govern- ment-sponsored work. Neither the United States, nor the Com- mission, nor any person acting on behalf of the Commission makes any warranty or representation, express or implied, with respect to the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of the in- formation contained in this report, or that the use of any infor- mation, apparatus, method, or process disclosed in this report may not infringe privately owned rights. The Commission assumes no liability with respect to the use of, or from damages resulting from the use of, any information, apparatus, method, or process disclosed in this report. This report has been reproduced directly from the best available copy. Issuance of this document does not constitute authority for declassification of classified material of the same or similar content and title by the same authors. Printed in USA, Price 20 cents. Available from the Office of Technical Services, Department of Commerce, Wash- ington 25, D. C. GPD B2Z900 - 1 OML-1700 Contract No. W-7405-eng-26 SOLID STATE DIVISION EFFECT OF RADIATION ON THE DIELECTRIC CONSTANT AND ATTENUATION OF TWO COAXIAL CABLES R. A. Weeks and D. Binder ABSTRACT Measurements have been made on radiation induced changes in the phase constant and attenuation of two coaxial cables while being irradiated. The measurements were made in the region of four megacycles. At this frequency the change in dielectric constant was (1.4 + 0.4) f> for both dielectrics after roughly 2 x 10^° nvt. The change in attenuation was (9 + 2) "jo for polyethylene and within the range of error for teflon. The phase constant and attenuation were found by measuring the input impedance of an open-ended length of cable in the neighborhood of its quarter -wave frequency. Assuming a uniform cable dielectric and no other variables the input impedance has a minimum at this frequency. From the minimum the attenuation and phase con- stant are found. March 19, 1954 Oak Ridge National Laboratory operated by Carbide and Carbon Chemicals Company A Division of Union Carbide and Carbon Corporation Post Office Box P Oak Ridge, Tennessee xix Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2012 with funding from University of Florida, George A. Smathers Libraries with support from LYRASIS and the Sloan Foundation http://archive.org/details/effectofradiatio3043oakr EFFECT OF RADIATION ON THE DIELECTRIC CONSTANT AND ATTENUATION OF WO COAXIAL CABLES R. A. Weeks and D. Binder Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee Introduction Plastic dielectrics in the form of coaxial cables are often used in and around radiation sources. Many of the physical properties of such plastics have been studied*' ' as a function of irradiation in neutron and gamma ray sources. It is of some interest to extend these studies to the effect of radiation on certain electrical properties, dielectric constant and attenuation, of importance in high frequency applications. Experimental Method An accurate technique of measuring relative changes in the dielectric con- stant and attenuation in coaxial cables during irradiation has been devised. With this technique and the theory developed below, it was possible to determine changes in the relative value of the attenuation and specific dielectric constant, e', with an error less than 2% and 0.1$ respectively. Two types of coaxial cable have been inserted in the ORNL graphite reactor and measurements of attenuation and e 1 have been made during irradiation. One of the cables was type RG-ll/U with a polyethylene dielectric. The other cable was a high voltage cable with a teflon dielectric. Its characteristic impedance, Z , was approximately 50 ohms. The latter cable was irradiated for approximately 700 hours (Fig. II) and the RG-ll/U for approximately 900 hours in a flux of 9.2 x 10 11 thermal neutrons (Fig. III). The observed e' increased about 1% for both (1) 0. Sisman, C. D. Bopp, "Physical Properties of Irradiated Plastics", ORNL-928 Refer to Bibliography for other reports. - 1 - - 2 - cables. The observed attenuation of the teflon cable showed little change during the period of irradiation. The observed change in attenuation of the SG-ll/U cable was approximately 5>%* The measurements were made in the region of four megacycles. Theory of Measurement The equations pertinent to the technique are developed below. The input impedance of a transmission line of length X is Z( /) coshY,/ k z o sinh Y./ (1) Z^ « Z z(/ ) sinhYi f Z cosh yj where Zj^ = input impedance Z(/) = impedance of load Z * characteristic impedance V = propagation constant For low loss lines Y« C*+ i/3 <*■ - attenuation per unit length /3 = cu f/7c Ld « frequency in radians per second P ■ permability ^ ■ 1 (for dielectrics of interest here) ^- - dielectric constant (2) George C. Southworth, "Principles and Applications of Waveguide Transmission". p. 39-72, 1950, D. Van No strand Co. (3) G. G. Montgomery, et al, "Principles of Microwave Circuits", p. 67, 19U3 McGraw Hill. - 3 - For an open ended line, Z{$ )» Z , equation (1) becomes (2) Z^ * Z cothy/ Then if ^ s JL^L , n . x, 2 , 3, ... equation (2) becomes (3) Zin ■ Z tanh */ At the quarter-wave frequency, n » 1 where c is the velocity of light, Vh is the angular quarter-wave frequency, f is the length of the line, e is the dielectric constant of free space, and e' is the specific dielectric constant. Equation (2) can be written (6) p& , I fe e ~ 2 *' ( cos 2 ^ - 1 s^ 2/8/ ) ^° 1 - e- 2 (cos 2/5/ -i sin 2/3/ ) When (7) 2/S/s^ A 9, 4© « 7/ and retaining only first order terms equation (6) becomes (8) ha z ac/i L&1 The absolute magnitude is and when A © e (10) |f * *' - h - At the quarter wave frequency the magnitude of t? — goes through a minimum. By plotting \'^ u ^\ versus frequency, one can find both the attenuation and the quarter-wave frequency. A curve drawn from equation (9) is compared with ob- served values of hf 111 / in Figure IV. The agreement between observed and calculated values of z i J1 is quite good. The value of &■!( used in the equation z o was that found from the minimum in the experimental datajC-f ■ 0.016°. Apparatus A block diagram of the circuit used to measure lir" 1 / is shown in Figure I-A. The procedure of the experiment was set up so that h^— / could be found from two voltages that were easily measured. In Fig. I-B the signal generator is treated as a Thevenin voltage source^'. With the terminals open the potential across them is (11) V ■ V X where V, = Thevenin voltage. With the cable attached to the generator terminals the Thevenin voltage is increased until the potential across the terminals is the same as that in equation (11). Then (12) V * i Z^ where i ■ current, and the new Thevenin voltage is (13) V 2 = i (Z g f Zin) where Zg is the generator impedance. Substituting i = ^r ^ equation (13), we have for the input impedance v l Z g C 11 *) Z in ■ v 2 -\ At the quarter i^ave frequency (lit) becomes (15) Z tanhot/ a y My (U) George C. Southworth, "Principles and Applications of Waveguide Transmission p. 26, 19!?0, D. Van Nostrand Co. -5 - If the generator impedance is matched to the characteristic impedance of the cable, Z - Z , tanned « <*/ , then (16) «/ v. 1 v 2 -Vx All that is necessary is to measure Vi and V2 in the region of %/),• In- the signal generator used in these measurements, a General Radio 60^-B, a calibrated attenuator preceding the output terminal was used to measure the relative magni- tudes of V]_ and V?. ^ ie signal generator impedance was matched to the cable by a series resistor of appropriate value. The incidental shunting capacitance was negligible at the frequencies used. The value of the series impedance matching resistor was found by measuring the impedance of the generator and the character- istic impedance of the cable. Since the cable impedance was larger than the generator impedance for both cables, the matching resistance was in series with the generator impedance. The cathode follower, receiver, and VTVM shown in Fig. 1A were used to set the voltage V at a constant value. This was done by modulat- ing the output of the signal generator; a small fraction of the r-f signal being passed by the cathode follower to the receiver, a National HRO-60, the modula- tion component then going to the VTVM. A cathode follower was used because of its high input impedance, approximately 100 megohms. The deflection of the VTVM was kept constant for the conditions of cable connected and disconnected by varying the calibrated attenuator of the signal generator. The frequency was measured by the receiver tuning condenser of the HRO-60 which had been calibrated. The advantages of this method of measuring relative changes in e* and attenuation are: a) with one measurement the relative magnitudes of e' and -attenuation can be determined with an accuracy not achievable by other methods^ b) instruments and personnel can be shielded from the radiation source dur?^" - 6 - irradiation of cable, c) measurements can be made during irradiation, and d) standard instruments can be used. The major disadvantages are: a) the cable is not uniformly irradiated, and b) there is a temperature gradient along the length of the cable. However, the conditions of irradiation are similar to those that would exist if the cables were used in and around a radiation source. Cable Measurements Using the above method changes in e' andof/in two coaxial cables have been measured during irradiation in the ORNL graphite reactor. The cables were inserted in Hole B of this reactor and the measurements made over a period of approximately 700 hours (approx. 1.6 x lCr-° nvt) for one cable and 900 hours (approx. 2,1 x 10-'-" nvt) for the other. The one irradiated for the 700 hour period had teflon as the dielectric, the other had polyethylene. The results for the two cables are shown in Figs. II and III. It can be seen from these figures that the effect of radiation on the "measured e' " is small, the total observed change for both cables is approximately 1% of the initial value. The change in e 1 is proportional to twice the change in Hj/i i.e., (17) -A*' - £-J& vu The "measured pCf " for the teflon cable exhibited changes that were not outside the range of error for theperiod or irradiation. The polyethylene cable had a total change in the "measuredo(/ " of approximately 9%, In order to determine whether there were transient effects resulting from variations in the flux around the cable measurements were made during the weekly shutdowns of the reactor. These were then compared to measurements made just prior to shutdown and just after start-up. In the teflon cable no significant change in e' and e*/ could be detected between the reactor-on and reactor-off -■? - conditions. In the HG-ll/O cable there were observable differences in the value of e' but none in &H between the two conditions . These differences were much smaller than the total change in e' for the period of irradiation. The change in e' for the two conditions seems to be correlated with the change in the temperature of the irradiated section of the cable. This temperature effect can be seen by comparing adjacent points on the f ^ /, graph, Fig. Ill, for which there was a change in the average temperature of the irradiated section of the cable. The changes in e' are of the same sign as the changes in average temperature . The average temperature is the average of the temperature of the pile inlet air and outlet air. The air coolant flowed through the channel in which the cables lay, the inlet air being at one end of the cable and the outlet air at the other. Hence the average of the inlet and outlet air temperatures is an approximate measure of the average temperature of the cable. At full pile power the difference between inlet and outlet air temperature was approximately 70°C. The reason for speaking of "measured e' " and"measured © = a. it « * vl U m f r — E 1 ® 1 r r □ / ENGTH OF CABLE, 1 1 .92(±0.05 ) meters HERMAL FLUX IN ABSENCE OF CABLE, » 9. FMPFRATIJRF IS AVFRARF OF INI FT AND / a G | ■ '- | • * 0/ " D K la — e _) h - 1- — n o o o UJ or o UJ x u_ o CD UJ _) o X Q UJ S O < = or o QT u- ^~ UJ _l 00 < 3 U_ UJ r- < u_ o a Q or o r- O < UJ or UJ H X 0. < or o O O O O O O O O O O CD 00 K to if) w _i < L x < or h- 2 UJ L ] > \ < > 2 LU 2 LU X U. _l 1- 1- 1 X UJ O LO o o o o o m oo o "*. T H h- O LU < > LU _l rr O a LU Ll H o X a CL < rr Q o _i ->