, LioKAK Y STATE PLANT BOARD December 1945 2-678 Onite'd States Department of Agriculture Agricultural Research Administration Bureau of Entomology and Plant Quarantine INSECTICIDAL ACTION CF ORGANIC HALOGEN COMPOUNDS — A COMPARISON OF SELECTED LITERATURE REFERENCES By C. V. Bowen and H . L. Haller Division of Insecticide Investigations Interest in organic compounds containing halogens as insecticides has been stimulated recently by the widespread publicity given to DDT (l-trichloro-2,2-bie(£-chloropnenyl)ethane) (2, 1£, 17); by the effec- tiveness $p a soil disinfectant in pineapple fields of a mixture con- taining 1,3-dichloropropylene and 1,2-dichloropropane, the commercial product of which has been called D-D ^ and by 1,2, 3,^,5, 6-hexachloro- cyclohexane, a new British insecticide (20, 1). Dichloropropane was first tested as an insecticide 20 years ago Tl3) an d was shown to have limited value as a fumigant. DDT is of especial interest because of its high residual toxicity, and D-D because as a byproduct in the chlor- ination %f hydrocarbons it is available at a comparatively low cost. 1 ,2,3,^,5,6-Hexachlorocyclohexane, or benzene hexachloride as it is commonly called, was discovered to have insecticidal properties in 19^2, land early in 194-3 * ne gamma isomer was reported to be more toxic to some insects than DDT. D-D, DDT, and benzene hexachloride represent but a small percentage of the total number of halogen- containing compounds that have been tested against a wide variety of insects. Because of the great interest shown in these three products, it appeared worth while to assemble the toxicity data of some other halogen-containing compounds, and to observe the effect of the introduction of one or more halogens into an organic compound on its insecticidal properties. For this purpose publications containing the results of tests with a large number of organic halogen compounds 2/ were selected. Grain Weevils Neifert et al. (lj) studied the fumigating action of more than 100 volatile organic compounds against grain weevils. Of the 3^ organic halogen compounds, 9 were more toxic than carbon disulfide to the rice weevil ( Sitophilus oryza (L.)). The most effective bromide tested was ethylene bromide, which at a concentration of only 0.5 percent killed 100 percent of the weevils (S. oryza (L.), S. granarius (L. ) , and Tribollum spp.). The order of toxicity of the other bromides was bromoform; n^-butyl, ethyl, allyl, n-propyl, and benzyl bromides; and bromobenzene. Epichloro- hydrin, trichloroethane, sym- tetrachloroethane . propylene dichloride, and — The names of the chemical compounds are given as they appear in the literature cited. - 2 - a mixture of o- and p_-dichlorobenzenes at concentrations of 2 percent or less gave 100 percent mortality. gym-Pi chloromethyl ether had an efficiency comparable to that of carton disulfide; chloromethyl ether was about half as efficient. Epichlorohydrin, the most toxic substance tested, at a concentration of only 0.09 percent killed 100 percent of S. oryza . Other chlorides showed toxicity in the following order: Monochlorobenzene , p_-dichlorobenzene , tetrachloroethylene, methylene chloride, carbon tetrachloride, chloroform, acetylene dichloride, trichloro- ethylene, ethylidene chloride, and isopropyl chl<5ride. The bromides in general were more effective than the corresponding chlorides. n-Butyl iodide, the only iodine compound tested, at a concentration of 0.8 percent killed all the weevils. Boark and Cotton (l6) reported further on the toxicity of 303 ali- phatic halogen compounds tested as fumigants in the presence of wheat against the rice weevil. The most effective of these compounds, together with the minimum lethal dosages, are listed below. Milligrams Milligrams per liter per liter tert-Butyl bromide *2U tert-Butyl chloride 3* Epichlorohydrin 2-Chloroethyl acetate H7 2-Chloroethyl ether <2U Carbon tetrabromide 60 2-Bromoethyl ethyl ether*27 Isobutyl iodide 6U Allyl bromide <2g sec-Butyl iodide 6U 2-Bromoethyl acetate Isopropyl iodide 6g Methyl bromoacetate '<30 Methyl chloroacetate 73 Ethyl bromoacetate < 30 n-Propyl bromide gl n-Propyl iodide 035 Ethyl 1-bromopropionate gu Allyl iodide <37 Ethylene dibromide 87 Ethyl iodide <39 Propylene chlorohydrin 89 Methyl iodide and para isomers of the chloro-, bromo-, and iodoacetanilides. Cupples, Yust, and Hiley (J) reported on $asts with more than 300 compounds as possible substitutes for hydrocyanic acid in the fumi- gation of California red scale ( Aonidiella aurantii (Mask.)). Of the 89 organic halogen compounds, 79 showed only slight or no toxicity, 7 moderate toxicity, and 3 decided toxicity. Twenty-four cases of related compounds showing the relative toxicity with change in halogen content are indicated as follows: n-Octane = Cyclohexane ■ Benzene = Methylene chloride » Methyl bromide = sym -Dichloroethylene Fluorobenzene = Benzyl chloride = Ether = Nitrome thane « Ethyl acetate «* n-Propyl acetate = Benzyl acetate = 2-Bromooctane Bromo cyclohexane p_-Dichlorobenzene Chloroform = Carbon tetrachloride Methylene bromide ~* Bromoform 'Trichloroethylene > Tetraehloroethyleras p_-Fluorochlorobenzene p_-Fluorobromobenzene Benzo trichloride £-Bromobenzyl chloride beta-Bromoethyl ethyl ether Chloropicrin Bromopicrin Ethyl bromoacetate beta-Bromoethyl acetate beta-Bromopropyl acetate gamma-Bromopropyl acetate Benzyl chloroacetate Fourteen compounds showed no change in toxicity with increase of halogen content, three showed a decrease, and six an increase in toxicity. Goldfish In toxicity tests of halogenated phenols against goldfish, 0-ers- dorff and Smith 10, 11 ) found that the most pronounced differences between the iodophenols and the chloro- and bromophenols are as follows: (1) Each iodophenol is more toxic than the corresponding compound con- taining chlorine or bromine. (2) The ortho and meta compounds have changed places, however, in the order of toxicity so that the latter is the least toxic of the iodophenolsi (3) The para compound has a pro- nouncedly greater toxicity than its least toxic isomer, it being five times as toxic in the case of the iodophenols as compared with one and one-half times for the bromo- and chloro- phenols. Conclusions The dissimilarity of treatment and the wide variety of compounds - 7 - tested in the entomological investigations reported make • the drawing of conclusions difficult. It is apparent, however, that the introduction of halogen into an organic compound may increase, decrease, or have no effect on the insecticidal value, and that the effect on toxicity obtained "by the introduction of one of the halogens is no indication of the effect likely, to "be obtained by the introduction of a different halogen. - 8 - Table 1. — Effect of halogen substitution on effectiveness of compounds as furaigants for wheat against the rice weevil Compound : Minimum lethal dosage Weevils killed after 2^ hours Milligrams per liter Percent Methyl formate 39 100 Methyl chloroformate 198 100 Ethyl formate 72 100 Ethyl chloroformate 251 100 Chloroethyl chloroformate hso 100 n-Propyl formate 12 100 n-Propyl chloroformate 5^2 20 gamraa-Chloropropyl chloroformate 600 10 Isopropyl formate 53 100 I 8 op ropy 1 chloroformate 5U0 70 n- Butyl formate 109 100 n- Butyl chloroformate 539 Isobutyl formate 35 100 Isobutyl chloroformate 520 20 Isoamyl formate 70 100 Isoamyl chloroformate 512 Q Chloromethyl ether 532 sym-Di chl or ome thyl ether 658! 100 Diethyl ether 357 10 be ta-Bromo ethyl ethyl .ether 27 100 alpha, beta- Di chloroethyl ether 188 100 beta,beta-Dichloroethyl ether 2k 100 Acetone 396 100 Chl oroac© tone 110 100* Acetic acid 500 Chloroacetic acid Chloroacetyl chloride lk& Dichloroaeetyl chloride 780 Trichloroacetyl chloride 815 Ethyl acetate 180 100 2-Bromoethyl acetate 30 100 2-Chloroethyl acetate U7 100 Ethyl bromoacetate 30 100 Ethyl chloroacetate 93 100 Ethyl di chloroacetate 256 100 Ethyl trichloroacetate 692 100 Ethyl alcohol 790 UO Ethylene chlorohydrin 2U2 100 Ethylene bromohydrin 337 100 n-Propyl alcohol *K>2 60 Propylene chlorohydrin 89 100 - 9 - Table 2. — Toxicity tests against mosquito larvae, showing parent compound and halogen derivatives k » k • Toxicity Compound : Concentration ; Mortality in : compared : : 16 hour a : > • vlth parent P.p,m, Pe rcen t Biphenyl 10 p-Bromobiphenyl 3»3 51 p-Chlorohiphenyl 5 8U *" p-Iodehiphenyl 10 66. £,U«~Bichlor©Mphenyl 100 65 "* l*,U«-Di'bromo'biph6iiyl 100 "* U,h«-Diiodohiphenyl 100 "* Dihenisofuran 5 60 2- Chlorodioen2,ofuraa 5 5^ 2-Kitrodihezizofuraa 100 3- Chloro-7-nitrediDen2ofuran 100 = 2-Hitroaniline 100 54 2-Chloro-U-nitroaniline 20 98 * U-Ac©tyldiphen/lamine 100 5-ChloroacetyIdlphsnylamine 100 H3 ** l-Phenylaso-2-naphthol 100 1- (2,5-Dichlorophenyla«o)-2-naphthol 100 « Phenetole l/ 100 **1 ~Di chl rob enz ene 9» 96 40 95 £-Dibrostobenz ene 20 52 - L» — X/A 1UUU UOUS QUO lis* 40 m- Chl r oni t roben z ene 100 100 ml 0-> Chl or oni t ro benz ene IC'J 100 - tv-CIi! npfinl t i*riT"»ftrsy en ft 1/ iiA 3,4-Dichloronitrcbenzene cU 85 91 m-Bromoni trobenz ene Ho If - o_~Bromoni trobenz ene Pj-Bromonitrobensene 5 N8 aa-Iodoni trobenz ene 20 96 0— Tod. oni trohenzene 98 pj-Iodonitrobenzene 100 Pj-Icdoeoni trobenz ene 1/ 100 5 5 100 m-?fitrophenyliodochlo«?-idj .1/ 20 18 20 £-11 1 r ophenyl i do chl ri d< 100 7 36 p^-Thlocyanobromobenzen© ! 2 97 96 p-Thiocyanoiodobenzene lj 2 93 9g 2,4-Dinitrochlorobenzene 20 96 99 2,4-Dinitrobromobenzene J 20 98 99 l/ Data from Bushland and King (U) , ■ « a u ai » CO rH <♦» h P.* o ® 43 •«* 4» d 4» «d * 2*2 d »« «h £ § c O «H «d CO PS O 8 rH CD 4» to © o -»-> 03 U o % 4» rH t( CD <0 W 43 9 o I o o to 4* o o o oJ I cm • • • irv cvj »h GO CM CM • • CO rH CD CT> ON a O N CO o €| 8 8 - 11 - i i ; i i t i CM O • • J* OJ o M 2 u 8 I*- 0*\ H OH • • 4* K> o a~\ o CM to I ON I mone 8 em sophenone ct»k\ CD 8 N 8 o N CO CD •§ s ° CO «H d P CO I 43 - g P< - 12 e o i h m & P. 43 c (3 o ♦» ♦» CD 3 & O r-l » +> •H O «H X o ♦» (3 o ♦> o to 60 S3 o o vo o o €tf • • • • V o 1 1 ? o o * er 1 ITS X o 4» O o o S3 • • • • O o o o o CD u *> 43 •r* (0 iH o « rH (1 4» • 13 p 43 P< ft (0 ft «H 43 O e o u « ol g & & o • • © 43 43 43 P. O* Pi "H "H 43 43 O O O O • ft «H 43 O a o 43 P I t ft * ! •H Xi 43 P, rH r-f 2 35 & & O Q • 43 •O" a> +» o a> «H J* M M 4* 0| - 13 - Literature Cited ANONYMOUS. 19^5. Hew Briti'sh insecticide. Soap and Sanit. Chem. 21(5): 103. ANNAND, P. N., and Bureau Staff. 19^. Teste conducted by the Bureau of Entomology and Plant Quarantine to appraise the usefulness of DDT as an insecticide. Jour. Econ. Ent. (51 Scientific Notes) 37: 125-159- BUSHLAND, R. C. I9U0. Toxicity of some organic compounds to young screwworms. Jour. Econ. Ent. 33 : 669-676. — —- . • and KING, w . T. I9U3. Laboratory tests with organic compounds as larvicidee for Culex quinquefasclatus Say. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant Quar. E-585, 15 PP. [Processed.] CARTER, W. 19^3» A, promising new soil amendment and disinfectant. Science 97: 383-381+. 00LMAN, V. I9U3. Tests of chemical compounds against fabric insects. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant Quar. E-592, 12 pp. [Processed.] CDPPLES, H. L., YUST, H. P., and HILEY, J. 1936. Tests of possible substitutes for hydrocyanic acid In fumigation of -California red scale. Jour. Econ. Int. 29: 6ll-6l8. TIKI, D. X. , SMITH, L. VIVIAN, D. L., and CLABORN, H. V. I938. Toxicity tests with synthetic organic compounds against cullcine mosquito larvae. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant $iar. E-U25, 3^ pp. [Processed.] OERSDOEFT, W. A., and SMITH, L. I. I9U0. Effect of introduction of the halogens into the phenol molecule on toxicity to gold- fish. I. Monochlorphenols. Amer. Jour. Phara. 112: 197-20U. — , and SMITH, L. E. 19*10. Effect of introduction of the halogen into the phenol molecule on toxicity to goldfish. II. Mono- bromophenols. Amer. Jour, Pharm. 112: 316-322. — -- — , and SMITH, L. S. I9U0. Effect of introduction of the halogen into the phenol molecule on toxicity to goldfish. III. Mono- iodophenols. Amer. Jour. Pharm. 112: 389-39U. McALISTXR, L. C. , and VAN LEXUWXN, S. R. 1930. Laboratory tests of miscellaneous chemicals against the codling moth. Jour. Econ. Ent. 23: 907-922. NEITERT, I. 1., COOK, P. C. , HO ARK, R. C. , TONKIN, W. H., BACK, E. A., and COTTON, R. T. 1§25« Fumigation against grain weevils with various volatile organic compounds. U. S. Dept. Agr. Dept. Bui. I3I3, Uo pp. - 14 (lU) QUESTS! , D. D. , GERTLER, S. I., SMITH, L. E. , and VIVIAN, D. L. 1941. Laboratory and field teats of toxicity of some organic compounds to European corn "borer. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant Quar. E-557, 17 PP. [Processed.] (15) ROARK, R. C. 194U. A list of publications on 2 2-bis(parachloro- phenyl)-l,l,l-trichloroethane (called DDT) from I87U to April 30, 19UU, inclusive. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant $iar. (Unnumbered) , 12 pp. [Processed.] (16) , and COTTON, R. T. 1930. Tests of various aliphatic compounds as fumigants. U. S. Dept. Agr. Tech. Bui. 162, 52 pp. (17) , and Mc'INDOO, S. E. I9UU. A digest of the literature on DDT through April 30, I9UU. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant Quar. E-63I, 53 PP» [Processed.] (18) SIEG-LER, E. H. , MUNGER, P., and SMITH, L. S. I939. Toxicity to the codling moth larva of derivatives of benzene containing halogen and nitro groups. Jour. Econ. Ent. "}2: 129-131* (19) f MUNGER, P., and SMITH, L. E. 1939. Toxicity of certain organic insecticides to codling moth larvae in laboratory tests. U. S. Dept. Agr. Cir. 523, 10 pp. (20) SLADE, R. A. I9U5. A new British insecticide. Chem. Trade Jour. and Chem. TSngin. Il6: 2T9-281. (21) TATTEBSFIELD, P., and ROBERTS, A. W. R. 1920. The influence of chemical constitution on the toxicity of organic compounds to wireworms. Jour. Agr. Sci. 10: 199-232. (22) WIESMANN, R. I9U3. Eine neue Methode der Bekampfung der Pliegenplagen in Stallen. Anz. f. Schadling sic. 19(1) : 5-8. (A translation by Carlo Zeimet was printed under the title "Fly Control in Stables" in Soap and Sanit. Chem. 19(12): 117, 119, 1^3. 19^3). *