^(\Cf\L-M\ ^ NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR AERONAUTICS WARTIME REPORT ORIGINALLY ISSUED Octo'ber 19^1 as Advance Restricted Report DEVELOPMENT OF COVLIHG FOE LCWG-NOSE M3?-C00LED ENGINE M THE KACA FULL-SCALE WIND TDMEL By Abe Sllverstein and Eugene R. Guryanslsy Langley Memorial Aeronautical Laboratory Langley Field, Va. UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA DOCUMENTS DEPARTMENT 120 MARSTON SCIENCE LIBRARY P.O. BOX 117011 GAINESVILLE. FL 32611-7011 USA NACA WASHINGTON NACA WARTIME REPORTS are reprints of papers originally issued to provide rapid distribution of advance research results to an authorized group requiring them for the war effort. They were pre- viously held under a security status but are now unclassified. Some of these reports were not tech- nically edited. All have been reproduced without change in order to expedite general distribution. L - 2Ul \%"l 1 0\H^ o 3S6)5 ' ^7 31\lC-II\:Z IN THS EACii FULL-SCALE WIllD TUIJNEL By Ate Silverstein and Bn^-ene H. Gr-ij.r--ansk:y IKTROrUCTIOK An investigation of co-A'lir.gs for long-nose radial engines l:a s l"een made on the Ci.rtiss XP-42 airplane in tne FaC \ full-scale vfind tunnel. The XF-42 airplane is providei with a Fratt Sc '.Thitney ?.-l&c0-31 en^-ir.e, which has a propeller s.iaft and tearing housing that is 2C incl'es icnger ti;2.n the stared,- re short-nose engine cf the same series » Tr.is fcrTrard tistension of the -nropeller en- ahles the use of ftiselage nose sna-^es of higher fineness ratio than are possible rith the olnnter short-nose en- gine. In tha original C'-rtiss Co"nT,any design of the Xp-42 airplane the pointed f-.sela,-^e nose y:bs used (fig. 1) and sharp-edge scco-os rer:^ addid at t^.e bottcn and top of the corling for the engine- co ol ing and tne carburetor- air inlets. Flight tests shoved i>, e high sr^eed of the airplane to be co".i-^ara bl e rith, bnt not s'apericr to, that of the I'-Sd, T«'hic-i is a ciiuilar airrlane ^ith a short- nose eng: ne and a conventional KaCa celling installation. Inspection of the covling scoops disclosed so\;rces of drag, the existence of which rare substantiated by pre- liminary I'ACa flight measurements. These tests shored tha.t the engine cooling air enter-^d the lo^er scoop at abou.t half the airrlane flight velocit^^ and that the kinetic e n e r gy of this flow r a s d i s s i-c a t e d by the s ha tx> change in the air-flow direction at the rear of the scoop and. by the expansion fror.; the smai! area ahead of the engine. '^3ee fij scoop area to large 2.) The existence of a large internal energy loss due to the cooling-air flo^^ was establis.ied and experience led to the belie'" tnat a f~i.rther subscantial external drag wou.ld be add-ed by the flow over txie sharp scoop edges. The full-scale tu..nel investigation was ti^en instiiS'ated for the rV'.r~ose of Ie-d rovi n.; the original scjox; co'~ii:ig or developing an efficient cowl o: another type. •°'a' Tne wind-tunnel program included an initial investi- ■ ion of the original F- 42 cowling, wnich was follo'^ed "by tests of several modified arrangements v;ith iniproved scoops. The general v.nsat i sf ac to ry eerod"namic charac- teristics of all the con'lings with scoop inlets led to the development of the annular high-velocity inlet coal- ing. Since it ras tl.e pv.Tpose of the wind- tunnel i^^vesti- gi.atiOi. to develop an o-ctir.mm covlin^i; that could he later constructed for fli.:ht tests, the various cc^'line- -oaram- eters, such as inlet velocity ratio, exit area, etc., were studied in consideraole detail. This cowling has teen constnctec! and is c'^rrently undergoing flight tests on the F-43 airplane. Tne res'^Tlts of tne flight investi- gation will be reported at a later date. METHOD AUD AFFASATUS The iTACA full-scale wind-tunnel halance equi-pment used for tne force inet?. surenent s is described in reference 1. Tne method of mounting the airplane on the br.lance is shown in figure 1. The sr;ecial tec.'Uiique and apparatus used for the monentun measurements are described in ref- erence 2. Static-pressure ceasur ement s vere obtained either by the use of static orifices or l/l 5-inch diam- eter s ta.t ic-p r es r.ur e tubes mounted near the airrlana sur- faces. Tne air flo"/ through the engine cQv,'lin^ r.as meas- ured by total-pressure and sta t ic-pre r sur e tubes placed in tne diffii.sers aneyd of t"ne en{^ine baffles, and in the CO wl or t let s . KssuLis a:^td discus 3 lors ^Li^i^-?-l._ikll~l2 _cp_wl vnj2.«- -A photograph of the instal- lation of t;.e original scoop coriing on the Xp-42 airplane is shovTn in figure 1; a s; Sealed 0.0192 0.0203 Smooth with original acoop - :^ > \A3 Standard 167 0.0232 0.0243 0.0040 16,100 0.69 Cowl 1 Sealed 0.0209 0.0220 0. 0017 - ^~~^^==i.^^ 5/S 67 .0212 .0226 .0023 6,970 0.15 - aj > 3A 7/8 98 8,810 10,280 .19 .23 ' ===^ Sealed 311 oooler open .0210 .0224 .0021 Oowl 1 modified >T r~-^-> Sealed 5/8 Sooopa sealed 0.0194 .0196 0.0209 .0209 0. 0006 .0006 - C3 > 5/8 J/"* Scoops open It n 63 .0206 .0208 .0221 .0224 .0018 .0021 7,330 a23 7/8 5/8 II n 98 65 .0210 .0211 .0225 .0224 .0022 .0021 10,900 9,160 .3'* .28 Duct atralghtened. expansion reduced. 7/8 Same aa 5/8 91 .021b .0227 .0024 12,700 .39 Oowl 2 Sealed 0.0200 0.0215 0.0012 Spinner A - ~~~--^ 5/8 70 .0213 .0225 .0022 12,050 0.32 ^ 3/"^ 7S 13,750 .36 ^ 7/S 98 .0216 .0209 .0230 .0222 .0027 .0019 17,000 .44 5/8 («) 63 .0201* .0218 .0015 12,040 .31 Sealed Nose aealed * .0192 .0206 .0003 n Bottom e)tlt open ^ 72 .0198 .0214 .0011 9,940 ,26 " Modified bottom exlt^ 91 .0199 .0214 .0011 12,800 .33 . " Modified bottom exlt^ upper Inlet sealed. 91 .0199 .0212 .0009 13,550 .35 Partial 5/8 Modified bottom exit* 136 .0202 .0216 .0013 . 5/8 Bottom aealed * "^5 8,150 .21 " 7/8 II n a 63 12,100 .32 » 1-1/U n n a 90 .0209 .0224 .0021 18,600 .49 Oowl 2 modified Spinner B t~ ) Sealed Partial 5/« Modified bottom * 91 131 0.0199 .0204 0.0209 .0215 0.0006 .0012 13,870 21,l40 0.55 .83 \- — ^^ Cowl flap gear reraoved and smooth exit Installed. Baaed on smooth condition with original scoop off; landing gear fairing reraoved; control surfaces unsealed; and antenna on. MCA Figs. 1,14 ^ ' ' F HiKci 5. ■fz: Figure 1.- Ths XP-42 airplane in the standard condition, 'I' Figure 14.- Tlie XP-42 airplane in the smcoth condition with cowl 2 modified and smooth cowl flaps. NACA Figs. 2,10 k Q^ c, k n O <0 *3 On c <^ MCA FigB. 3,4 Figure 3.- The XP-42 airplane in the completely smooth condition Tnoijnted in the full-scale tunnel. a-xiCvxe 4.- The XP-42 airplane in the smooth condition with covd 1 and original cowl flaps. NACA F,'q.-5 u ''Xl KUCA rigs. 6, 17 o 1 i ' V^ ^-- - * &■ I 3 (y/p//M ~J3SnjJip J.O IU3D-J3d 'SUOI^OfS^ ID3l.f-i3/l MCA Figs. I ,'d, Figure 7.- The XP-42 airplane in the smooth condition with cowl 1 modified and original cov>l flaps. Fi£-'are S.- The XF-42 airplane in the scocth condition with ccv/1 2, spinner A, and original co\vl flaps. NACA Fig. 12 to 1 --; — • -; t>J rsl n~ ■53- <* IT) Ol 3 o o H ■ — ■ l:^i ri v;)^ IT) O mcA Fife. 11 ^ !**»■ ^"V >i Ml ■ ^ • 1 L 'JI^^H 1 sssill a (a) Bottom outlet (t) Modified bottom outlet Figure 11.- Cowl outlet on XP-42 airplane. MACA /■Ks ir.!3 .2 A 6 .fl 1.0 Fi^or& /2.- Pressure, disi-ribut/on over -/-op of ^p/nn^r A if/i-Z-h /n/ef ve/oaify raf/a (^ O..?, V? .2 .4 .6 .8 I.O fi^iint;/3.' Pressure di.^rt-//>i i-^/^.. ) utcv- ru;.' o/ ^>/jiiiiici /) wii^i /n/i'/- vrlacr/y id/i- '//(.4Q. N/'i,.4 Figs. I5,IG f-igurr IS- Prc-^^ure d/.-^^r/i^u^/on uver /op o/ ^p/ririfyr S w//h /n/e.i Vc/oci/^y ra-/-/:- ^-r.SS. P/9 .6-rs C .2 .4 e .k I.O figure X.-Z^re^sut-a di^f' buf'On ever -f-ap of jp'nner B <^if/i '.n'e- /efoci^/ t-nfic '/V- I ^l I I 1 i ^ si I i ^' 'I ; i ,' / / ii ..z .'■' ■-/- •' ;-. w (1) > o o c: 11 n "::» -P\ o > u o -p (/. -p {T- 13 s- ot ; J-. JJ •^ D. CJ MS Is' -J "J »o Cj w. ■* ^J» 5° 1 yf Ik: ^J f: ^1 ^ u, u> <«J b" ^1 1 r / 1 'f 1 1 / / / ' / OA///^ .yo 3sap ^^'Ot'^l 1 • i 1 1 // \ I I > ■ o o J ^' UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 3 1262 08106 479 1 UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA DOCUMENTS DEPARTMENT 120 MARSTON SCIENCE LIBRARY P.O. BOX 117011 GAINESVILLE, FL 32611-701 1 USA Wf