LIBRARY STATE PLANT BOARD February 1950 E-794 United States Department of Agriculture Agricultural Research Administration Bureau of Entomology and Plant Quarantine TESTS WITH ACR YLONITRILE - CARBON TETRACHLORIDE AND HYDROGEN CYANIDE AS FUMIGANTS FOR INSECTS IN CIGARETTE TOBACCOS By C. O. Bare and Joseph N. Tenhet Division of Truck Crop and Garden Insect Investigations Flue-cured and Turkish tobaccos are attacked in storage by two in- sect pests, the cigarette beetle (Lasioderma serricorne F.) and the tobacco moth (Ephestia elutella Hbn.). A new commercial fumigant has been developed which is composed of acrylonitrile and carbon tetrachloride (50-50 by volume). With material supplied by the manufacturers and in cooperation with several tobacco companies, tests have been made to compare this fumigant with hydrogen cyanide. Atmospheric Fumigation Laboratory tests. --Replicated laboratory tests were made in 33-cubic- foot chambers, at atmospheric pressure and 70°-82° F., and the exposure period was 72 hours. The toxicity of acrylonitrile -carbon tetrachloride to large unprotected larvae of the cigarette beetle and the tobacco moth was roughly comparable to that of hydrogen cyanide. Against large larvae of the tobacco moth hydrogen cyanide was the more effective at very low dosages. At 2 or 3 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet the new fumigant seemed to be slightly more effective; but 4 ounces of hydrogen cyanide killed all moth larvae, whereas 6 ounces of acrylonitrile- carbon tetra- chloride was required for a complete kill (table 1). It will be noted that 3| to 4 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet of the new fumigant killed all unpro- tected cigarette beetle larvae. In other replicated laboratory tests at summer temperatures (70°- 95° F.) approximately 28 ounces of acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride per 1,000 cubic feet with a 48-hour exposure or 32 ounces with a 24-hour exposure killed all cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches in bales of Turkish tobacco (table 2). - 2 - m £ CD £ o o > o cd 1 G O 3 g O 0) cd a; -»-> 73 C cd 0) 73 C a rt > u cd o 6 o o o o H 42 0> cd bo •rH u 73 •r-t (U o •H -C o "S a o > a c CD tut) o 73 0) 73 •rH •H pC >H O o "5 o O » M « g 3 o o O - o CD O on - cd ^ o S Q a CO CD CD 00 eg CD O CO 00 CO CO CO o o CD CO 00 o o CM o m o CO o o o o o o o o m 00 (CO CO o o t-h CM CO -In CO CD - 3 - o o o O co -C +-> a 73 73 CD h-> 03 O •rH 73 C CD CJ Sh 0) -a 03 o 0) a, ^ rc to o g Q a o m CO o o r- Sh CD s 03 o +-> o o <4H rQ a i CO 00 03 a co CD H-> 73 CD H-> nj O •rH . — I a CD PS CD O O CO CO o o o o CO CO CO CO o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o to •rH r^ Jh o 73 o 73 CO tJ< N CM CO CM CO o LO CO I o o I> H-> 03 Sh CD s o3 rC o Hr3 o o I a •rH rQ u o o o in 03 £ 10 CD -t-> 73 CD +-> 03 CJ •rH r— I a CD rH C CD O "tf CD CM O CO t> O N CO CO O CO > CO O CO CO CO O CO CO CO o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o 73 CD rH cj I o o CD 73 73 3 tfl •rH rH CM CO CO CM t> THH -r^ O O CO CM CM CM CO 10 CD CD > 73 CD +-> 03 CJ •rH i — I a CD u H-> CO CD H - 4 - Tests in commercial chambers .-- Tests were conducted in 5,000- cubic-foot atmospheric chambers to determine the effectiveness of this fumigant under semicommercial conditions. As would be expected, it was found that the gas did not penetrate hogsheads of flue- cured tobacco sc readily as it did the less dense bales of Turkish tobacco. These tests were made at temperatures of 70°-85° F. A 16-inch oscillating electric fan was operated in the chamber for 1 to 2 hours at the beginning of each test to prevent stratification of the gas. A 72-hour exposure gave better penetration of hogsheads of tobacco than a 48-hour exposure. With a 72-hour exposure a dosage of 20 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet gave com- plete kill of cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches in bales of Turkish tobacco. However, at no dosage or exposure was complete kill obtained to such depths in hogsheads of flue-cured tobacco. A dosage of 32 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet with a 72-hour exposure gave a mortality of cigarette beetle larvae of 72 percent at 9 inches in hogsheads of tobacco, as compared with 36 percent at the same dosage of gas but with a 48-hour exposure. Tests in warehouses .- -In 1947 and 1948 three large warehouses of flue-cured tobacco in hogsheads were fumigated with acrylonitrile-carbon tetrachloride. Two of them had a capacity of 280,000 cubic feet, and one of 600,000 cubic feet. In all fumigations the exposure period was 72 hours and the temperature range was 65°- 90° F. Electric fans were operated for the first 4 to 5 hours to prevent stratification of the gas. By means of an air compressor the gas was introduced into the buildings through copper tubing permanently installed for fumigation. The acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride mixture was in high pressure cylinders of the type used for hydrogen cyanide, and was under carbon dioxide pressure. However, air pressure was required to force the furnigant into the building. The mortality of test insects used in these experiments is shown in table 3. In the first warehouse the dosage was inadequate, and in this and in the second warehouse some unknown factor reduced the effectiveness of the fumigant. Perhaps the sheet-metal buildings were not so tight as they were thought to be, or possibly the cinder floors were more absorptive than was anticipated for a gas heavier than air. Nevertheless, the penetration of the gas in these tests was superior to that obtained with hydrogen cyanide, in previous tests under similar conditions. In the third warehouse, a brick building with concrete floors, the penetration of the gas and the mortality of test insects at depths of 5 to 9 inches, above 90 percent at a 9-inch depth, were the best ever observed in warehouse fumigation of flue-cured tobacco in hogsheads. The effectiveness of fumigation in the third warehouse is further confirmed by the weekly catches in suction light traps. Little build-up of insect population was noted 3 months after fumigation with acryloni- trile-carbon tetrachloride. In contrast, the average catch per trap - 5 - from six other comparable warehouses fumigated at about the same time with 16 ounces of hydrogen cyanide per 1,000 cubic feet showed a much greater increase in tobacco moth population late in the summer. Unfortunately for the experiment, the initial cigarette beetle population in the warehouses fumigated with hydrogen cyanide was not appreciable. The insect populations of these warehouses are shown in table 4. Vacuum Fumigation Laboratory tests.--Tests were made at reduced pressure to determine the minimum dosage of acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride that would kill all cigarette beetle larvae in bales of Turkish tobacco. These tests were conducted in a 33- cubic-foot steel chamber in which the air was exhausted to a pressure of 28 to 29.6 inches of mercury. The exposure period was 3 hours, and temperatures ranged from 70° to 86° F. By means of the customary steel test spikes (2), large larvae of the cigarette beetle were placed in bales of Turkish tobacco (approximately 140 pounds each) at depths of 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 inches. Dosages tested were from 8 to 32 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet. All tests were replicated five times. Table 5 shows that under the conditions of these tests the minimum dosage which could be depended upon to produce 100 percent mortality was 20 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet. Tests in commercial chambers.- -A series of tests in commercial vacuum fumigation chambers of 1,082 cubic feet each was conducted in the fall of 1946. Bales of Turkish tobacco and hogsheads of flue-cured tobacco were fumigated in vacuum under commercial conditions. The chambers were evacuated to a pressure of 28.5 to 29 inches of mercury. The exposure period was 4 hours and the temperatures were below 70° F. As shown in table 5, a dosage of 48 ounces of acrylonitrile- carbon tetra- chloride per 1,000 cubic feet killed all cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches in bales of Turkish tobacco. However, a dosage of 64 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet was necessary to kill all larvae to the same depth in hogsheads of flue-cured tobacco. In another series of tests in the same vacuum chambers in 1947, acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride was approximately equivalent to hydrogen cyanide in effectiveness. At tobacco temperatures of 42°-57° F. and air temperatures of 31°-64°, a dosage of 2\ pounds of acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride, with an exposure of 4 hours, killed all cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches in bales of Turkish tobacco. However, in a third series of tests under similar conditions, except at somewhat lower tobacco temperatures (29°-57°), an occasional larva survived dosages up to 4 pounds of acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride per 1,000 cubic feet. - 6 - ee ar o o tte i cd . — 1 •rH o OJ cd Sh o +j -(-> •i-l TUO 0 m CJ . — i to >> 0) Sh a ojq cj o !h $h 03 03 r— 1 £1 ■*-> T3 «*-! •r-i CD too O £ >» ed C -*-> •iH 03 «— < -»-> Sh cfl cd to -t-> •rH U 0) O § -t-> i OJ i a •a T3 CD +-> 03 a •r-i O £ +-> c 0) o Sh CD cj o CD ■*-> a CJ Sh -(-> c tO CU o •1-1 OJ to CD X! CJ C CO cd CJ c •l-l m to CJ c •rH oo CJ C 0) CO bjo a a3 o to c O 3 Q O CJ to o CD Sh cd to CM m 00 CO in CO CO 0) 6 cu CJ Jh C/3 CO CM Sh 0 0 Sh CD T3 C •rH CJ OO CD OO CD m CO m o 73 O CM CM CM oj oj OJ o o o o (0 , Sh o Sh o O CD in t CM CJ Sh o CJ Sh CD O OO - 7 - Table 4. --Average numbers of tobacco moths and cigarette beetles caught per suction light trap in a warehouse fumigated with acrylonitrile-carbon tetrachloride and in six warehouses fumigated with hydrogen cyanide. Wilson, N. C, and Portsmouth, Va., 1948 Tobacco moths Cigarette beetles Week ending Acrylonitrile- carbon tetra- chloride Hydrogen cyanide Acrylonitrile- carbon tetra- chloride Hydrogen cyanide May 18 26 176 515 95 151 40 76 0 0 Ti i n r* %J Ullfc; i i 8 15 22 29 619 355 Fumigated 301/ -J/ 135 184 143 Fumigated 2 108 93 Fumigated .11 0 0 0 Fumigated 0 July 6 13 20 27 7 147 30 69 10 20 45 86 27 172 J. 1 Ci 18 36 0 0 0 3 Aug. 3 10 17 23 30 117 155 129 211 204 172 278 225 749 760 47 63 162 125 209 8 10 2 0 0 Sept. 6 13 20 222 241 264 718 1,642 Fumigated 268 282 160 0 0 Fumigated 1/ Through a mistake this warehouse was sprayed once with pyrethrum in oil. - 8 - CO o o o co X! o to X! -t-> a CD -a cd H-> co o •r-l -a c co -t-> •rH r-H cO H-> Sh O g d a> o s-, tf-H O a G 6 OX) CO o cO to bJO •rH o O o Q b o f-fH 3 to o a x 10 rH CD rQ s CO X a f» u o H-J CO in o X! CO CO CD r-H CO X! O CJ o CO X! o -r-> XI to •rH r* S-t CO CO t- (M CD CM O O O O O CO o o o o o o o o o o o c- o o o o o t> O 05 O O O CO O CT> O O O r- o r- o + O o o o o o o iH O 0) O o o oo o o o o o m m m m io m t> CD CM CO CO I> t> O CO t— CO I I I I I I o o o co cm m O C- t— I> t- c- CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CM CO O CM r-t rH CM CM CO to ■u CD X3 B CO x a I— I CO •rH u rH CD b B o u CO CD r-l CO rQ o CJ o CO X o H-> XI CO •rH r* u o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o CO «0 o to o yjj r-H rH E CO \j O ■ — i TO r-H • rH O" Ph CD a o /— < £ o o I— 1 o c •iH c_> CO -a CO CD si CO OjO o X c •rH O O CJ CO rO o CO H— * CO 1 0) 1— 1 h lO O CD 3 tJ* t}< CO CO tF tF LO CD 01 o o 02 0 0 o o o o o o O 00 o O Oi o o o o o o o o o o o o o T— 1 Tjl CO CO c- co i CD CO H m ^ ^ ^ 00 CO in cd -9 - Effect of Acrylonitrile-Carbon Tetrachloride on Tobacco Repeated tests were made to discover any possible effect of this fumigant on flue-cured tobacco or on Turkish tobacco. Samples of fumigated and unfumigated tobacco of the same grade were submitted to leaf -tobacco experts. No effect upon the aroma, taste, or appearance of the tobacco was noted. Immediately after fumigation a very faint odor could sometimes be detected, but it vanished in less than 24 hours. A chemical analysis was made for residues of acrylonitrile on fumigated tobacco. The only method known of making such analysis was to pass heated air over the tobacco and then analyze the air for free nitrogen. Tobacco contains so much free nitrogen that the figures obtained were meaningless . Effect of Acrylonitrile-Carbon Tetrachloride on Equipment Acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride is corrosive to certain materials. Iron corrodes quickly; hence it is not satisfactory to use plain iron pipes or containers. Galvanized iron and tinned iron stand up satisfactorily for short periods. RUBBER TUBING CANNOT BE USED, AS ACRYLO- NITRILE QUICKLY POLYMERIZES AND DESTROYS RUBBER. Stainless steel tubing is most satisfactory for use in vacuum or atmospheric chambers. Copper tubing has been used, with little or no evidence of corrosion after 3 years. However, regardless of the fumigant used, great care should be taken to blow out the piping system thoroughly afterwards. Apparently it is the liquid fumigant that is corrosive, not the vapor phase. A compressor that had been in constant use for over a year in connection with acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride fumigation of tobacco was dismantled for repairs in the winter of 1948-49. Careful examina- tion of all parts showed no corrosion of the steel. Although the acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride mixture is not so volatile as most fumigants and can be shipped in regular galvanized- iron or tin drums, THE VAPOR EVOLVING FROM THIS MIXTURE IS POISONOUS AND THE MIXTURE MUST BE HANDLED ACCORDINGLY. Summary In extensive tests with atmospheric and vacuum fumigation a 50-50 mixture of acrylonitrile-carbon tetrachloride, was found to be a satis- factory fumigant for cigarette-type tobaccos. In laboratory tests at atmospheric pressure, it was as effective as hydrogen cyanide against cigarette beetle larvae, but less effective against tobacco moth larvae. It showed unusual penetration, yet it aired - 10 - out rapidly. No injury to tobacco was noted. In commercial atmospheric chambers at summer temperatures a dosage of 20 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet, with an exposure of 72 hours, gave complete kill of cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches in bales of Turkish tobacco. In hogs- heads of flue -cured tobacco a dosage of 32 ounces with the same exposure gave 100 percent mortality of cigarette beetle larvae at a depth of 3 inches, 99 percent at 5 inches, 86 percent at 7 inches, and 72 percent at 9 inches. In large warehouses of flue-cured tobacco in hogsheads a dosage of approximately 40 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet, with an exposure of 72 hours, gave excellent results against cigarette beetle larvae. In other warehouses fumigation with hydrogen cyanide at 16 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet was less effective against the tobacco moth. In small vacuum chambers in the laboratory the minimum dosage of acrylonitrile- carbon tetrachloride to give complete kill of cigarette beetle larvae in bales of Turkish tobacco was 20 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet, with a 3 -hour exposure and temperature of 73°- 8 2° In vacuum fumigation in commercial chambers at temperatures above 60° F., a dosage of 48 ounces of acrylonitrile-carbon tetrachloride per 1,000 cubic feet, with an exposure of 4 hours, gave complete kill of cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches in bales of Turkish tobacco. However, at lower temperatures (29°-50°) 64 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet did not give complete mortality in all tests. In hogsheads of flue- cured tobacco at summer temperatures, 64 ounces per 1,000 cubic feet, with an exposure of 4 hours, gave complete mortality of cigarette beetle larvae to a depth of 9 inches. No effect of acrylonitrile-carbon tetrachloride upon the aroma, taste, or appearance of flue-cured or Turkish tobacco was noted. In a study of the effect of acrylonitrile-carbon tetrachloride on different materials, it was found that stainless steel is most satisfactory for use in vacuum or atmospheric chambers; copper showed little or nc corrosion after 3 years; galvanized iron and tinned iron stand up for short periods; but plain iron is not satisfactory. Rubber tubing cannot be used. Literature Cited (1) Reed, W. D., and Vinzant, J. P. 1942. Control of insects attacking stored tobacco and tobacco products. U. S. Dept. Agr. Cir. 635, 40 pp., illus. (2) , Livingstone, E. M., and Morrill, A. W., Jr. 1936. Apparatus for placing test lots of insects within parcels of stored tobacco during fumigation experiments. U. S. Bur. Ent. and Plant Quar. ET-83, 3 pp., illus. /Processed]/