University of Illinois Library. 
 Reference department. 
 
 BIBLIOGRAPHY ON THE RECALL OF JUDGES 
 Prepared November, 1912. 
 
I 
 
University of Ill ir: is Library. )*' 
 Reference department. 
 
 BIBLIOGRAPHY ON THE RECALL OF JUDGES. 
 Prepared November, 1912, 
 
 Question:- Resolved* That the recall cf state and local 
 judges by popular vote is desirable, 
 
 NOTE:- This bibliography is limited to material not in 
 eluded in -the U. S. Library of Congress list. 
 
 Bibliegraphies. 
 
 321.4 
 
 qC33r 
 
 Central debating league. 
 
 The recall (excluding judges). 1912. p,04-38, 
 
 301.4 
 1192 i 
 
 Pol,sci. 
 
 Munro, William Bennett, ed. 
 
 The'initiative, referendum and recall, 
 p.342-48. 
 
 1912. 
 
 ©lo,5 Reeder, Charles Welle. 
 
 BU The reca’1 of public officials, A select list of 
 
 April, 1912. references. (Bulletin of bibliography. April, 
 
 1912, 7:5-2). 
 
 345 
 W7 5 
 
 v. 12 
 
 Schaffner, Margaret Anna, 
 
 The recall. 19c?. (Wisconsin free library 
 ccmmission. Comj>arative leg!s1ation bulletin, no.12). 
 
 ol6.3214 U. S. Library of Congress, 
 
 qUn3a Select list of references on the initiative, 
 
 referendum and recall. 1912. 
 
 • ■ - • ; a - t, 
 
 Note:- The current numbers of the American political science 
 review, Equity series, the National municipal review, and 
 the Public should be consulted for information concerning 
 the spread of the recall movement, 
 
 GENERAL, 
 
 342.73 
 Ae3a 
 Pc 1.sci. 
 
 3-42.72 
 
 G62e 
 
 Pol.soi. 
 
 Ashley, Roscoe Lewie. 
 
 The recall, 
 191o, p. 3o). 
 
 BOOKS. 
 
 (see his American government. 
 
 
 Gcodnovv, Frank J. 
 
 Constitutionality of political reform. (see 
 hio Social reform and the Constitution. 1911. 
 p.224, 226-28). 
 
• .... ; 
 
 . /• 
 
 • V .''- 1 ;• 
 
 •• s r 1 ! t 
 
 .faz&rti, ■ -it 
 
 "T'> y>t£& . vinXJ 
 
 Gn 
 
 ••I 
 
 . m t 
 
 , ■» "i t Y&Ym t / • - K ; 
 
 :ti2 \o tins*.* eiJ ’ . -yl • a.;I -: r>. ■> i j.-,uG 
 
 o i'M j h * x $ frc v ■ i’s* I 
 
 y\ * ,*> .'*■ 
 
 '•* *4> ° t, 
 
 - . ' ' ■ - - ; 
 
 », * *> ... . __ ' -■ 
 
 *ws*3a' j y io y- i.?J 
 
 11 /J 
 
 fit I:3iH rl< 
 
 ■< M 
 
 ■•‘M 
 
 , •-. • : , • -y; o■ .■■: :>• 
 
 "'i* 
 
 v. < 
 
 4 AX 
 
 . J 
 
 .3 j Ac eel £*ri£ir?<3 
 ■ X , ! t ■ 03 i i £X [: ,;• I f 0 X y ) f .a. : 5X ."j £i? 
 
 1- .1 
 
 V# 
 
 c- 
 
 
 Iv.* Ov fc* 
 
 sV- 
 
 _,r* 
 
 .SJS«I 
 
 ' ' £ J 
 
 . i S5J 
 
 % " Af ?• % fr >Jt 
 
 
 ’'I 
 
 ' V. v • 
 li • >*i. ‘v 
 
 ' AtfW'Ai 
 
 •» r • V 
 
 * i i i. .... - 
 
 -jv. i J.A>rxy • 1 Jilts*n 
 
 tU'iqk ,vrfYo ni1-,lf?ra) 
 
 ' o r> 
 
 
 u 
 
 r.T 
 
 7 - . " 
 
 , 
 
 .s *««'•.>*f ts>* .SX£I , Xx-r xA 
 
 ■S £:» f 
 
 * 
 
 ' i ?$ 
 
 ;-Ar> fcjii 
 
 * V * S1 * $ ■ lilt : f .i I: ■ 3 0 l ev £■'■ ■ z r i.Xj 0 t ■' ' 13 ■::, ZXy'iO 0 
 
 X7- '■ t Of i *. Y 0 t% £T i 3 np s 0 XW ) 
 
 .:■ ' .T ...A . ‘ 
 
 .XI ':'T .' riT 
 
 a^s 
 
 •Y# 
 
 d ‘yW 
 
 ^ .v 
 
 ■+ < • 
 
 -■ 
 
 . *; ?~ 
 
 r~ 
 
 t , -- »• '' -0 V < x. -xnj ,• 4»X,;€/j£o 
 
 i-j in YYrvuAs-'-v? i 0 t £ > { 5-^ a x^r r ^ r - 
 
 .siex p f i " ■ ■ ” —.... 
 
 xfl 
 
 j* A'/^D ;y T 
 
 £ihb tY.i/ba«.Y/al ft*x 
 
 -•: . 
 
 ? * * V ^ X if i; ' 1 ^ ^I J&nO i *t .SE ft , r £j t i». t i T Y.3 V V • i ;..S >9 ,’ 7 s^ 
 
 Y r ? • £Jl^OACXi IT; i.to-v/xo" Xii‘ tol hB^IuUfiOO oY bXu-oYu OiX.-.Y.YT 
 
 . J . •■ 0filX-v ■ I i ,■ • Y'■■•• ■ •. x Y > r,;.f! y q:,• YdX 
 
 / 
 
 '9 
 
 
 . T '• vxo 
 
 
 . a ? ‘i :;. vea ;;• » XT - • A Jt ;> Y A J 
 
 *& ■ ■■ jJ -■ A'X '• x V -. £Y « 
 
 «X ’ ,:, 7 X. « fT 
 
 . 
 
 
 
 ■ -.1 
 
 jS6!2?. 
 YY . I O' 
 
 > 8 ) 
 
 
 XGj. 
 
 I /?! t c • 
 
 f. Vo t*l 1 
 
 • - - ’ •', . . ": • 
 
 * Cl * ' -• ;/-% ■•. 
 
 ■• ^ ^ ^ Y* » »•- ^ ,• 
 
 o.aXooG 
 
 * ^ ■ 
 
 
 al.f 
 
 *ii£ ■.: . i. 
 
 I 
 
347.o6 
 IL 
 
 1912 
 
 Illinois state bar association. 
 
 Result of vote on the recall, (see its Pro¬ 
 ceedings, 1912. v. 36 , p.375). 
 
 352,o7731 Lissner, Meyer. 
 
 C493 The recall in operation.(in Los Angeles). 
 v.4 (Chicago city club bulletin. 25 April, 1911. 
 Pol.sci. 4:7o). 
 
 32o Lcs Angeles, Cal. Charter. 
 
 KISr Section of the charter of Los Angeles providing for 
 
 the recall. (Kaye, P.L. Readings in civil government 
 
 191o. p.526-27). 
 
 342.73 Ohio. State library, Columbus. 
 
 0h3d Digest of state constitutions. 1912. p.127- 
 
 128, 145-51). 
 
 The recall, (American year book, 191o. 1911. p,151 
 
 152). 
 
 (American yearbook, 1911. 1912, 
 
 p.167-68, 184). 
 
 (New international yearbook, 1911. 
 1912. p.72-7 3, 236, 785-86). 
 
 342 . 73 
 Sm6 
 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Smith, J, Allen, 
 
 The recall, 
 ment. 19o7. 
 
 (see his Spirit of American govern- 
 p,351). 
 
 328,7 31 IT. 
 
 Uii34 
 
 v.48, Pt.2 
 
 S, Congress, 
 
 H.J. Resolution 227, Proposing an amendment to the 
 Constitution of the United States making the federal 
 judiciary elective and subject to recall. (Congres¬ 
 sional record. 62d Cong. 2d seas, 24 January, 1912. 
 v.48, Pt.2, p.1361). 
 
 328.731 - 
 
 Un34 S.J. Resolution 13o proposing an amendment to the 
 
 5 Aug.1912 Constitution providing that judges of the inferior 
 
 courts shall be subject to recall. (Congressional 
 
 record. 62d Cong. 2d sess. 5 August, 1912, 
 
 48:lo962. Unbound edition). 
 
3 
 
 
 
 -0 'I*! ■ (bn) 
 
 r f i L t 
 
 i . *. V * 
 
 / J r> v . .. r. £ V 
 
 , • - • . d *. - • v 
 
 ClQi$B£00&&& a 
 
 ,-; .J. ' «r ~ £.-> ■* A TT *t / • 't t • f 
 
 a * ->r 
 
 J.'*d3 3 
 
 ,£ fjl ^ 
 
 saaita 
 
 >ai I11 
 
 V . 
 
 'K 
 
 JI 
 
 ( 3$, 
 
 f-aS 
 
 ac J r r) 
 
 I E X t I.;-i:i& - 
 
 # %SV#M . XOil 
 
 , ig| t.t'i'•■ ill ix^oa 
 XtsIIirdJf dvlb yrHc 
 
 <?£0 
 
 i Oil , i-J < 
 
 , a 0 d i r. rlO . C jt-D t e s j. £ - 5 n *- a c ^ 
 
 ,.- 5£ ^nA ,oI lo aid 1« soidoaS 
 
 -iOi ^nx.bx voiq so a.$s 
 ,j n e ca r i © v>y:> X xy x o rt i s>- i i - : b t>n , 
 
 ? X 1 « - 
 
 J? : ~-3Sc.q sClr.l 
 
 v&r 
 
 \ t> I . cf 
 
 . >1QL 
 
 :- f -7 r ..0 ,.Y r .a -X. ill ad£d3 
 
 »aaox^J.ti.tBaoo ».d 
 
 , l i.*'• ’i 
 
 j X .10 
 
 ?. ,v-a 
 r,£dO 
 
 -iai.q . ax 
 
 ,ti 
 
 i 0 Q d T£> o v n X: 0 IT •:■» 
 
 «A) 
 
 ,1Ifdot aiT 
 
 .{aai 
 
 . -a X 
 
 if [ .ioocSdLF&Y n^^xio^A) 
 
 .{a,I t ae-d la; 
 
 riex t Sxnottearatai *»K) ■ 
 
 . , ■ ■ ■ 
 
 •xzievog 
 
 • ii ) 
 
 . { Xdd ,q 
 
 , a e 1 1 - k 
 . 11 x 091 ©XT 
 ,do€I 
 
 t d t i ff'3 
 
 , da&«i 
 
 , & idC 
 
 ,io© .Jo<J 
 
 
 61 
 
 id od drt?fvb'j -v •..;o‘:cb ," •.J' 3 ’ 1V4- r -.^ 
 
 1 . liBoe o* fo*t tfs &U srldoal* ytxxox^ u 
 
 .jtjoee bS .s«oO b£B ..bi'oosn. X£ao.r.^ 
 
 -©©’x^noO} 
 
 C MS' T ir»- 
 
 , ■ j. <5 A . * *• 
 
 ( CdX :: ,q t .* , • 
 
 u tev.soo 
 ,:..tq , X‘.v 
 
 arid ud XnembnemF an 
 
 xoi iX. ;X ed.; ; ' 
 
 l£3OXS33%£fi0«3 ) 
 
 . -X I t .i v:;(jA 
 
 • t j ;•) — r cj X i •t’ 1 3* f .- f X• oa'H . ■•> *3 
 
 buf dxxiJ aniJbc v o t ■•, :ioIdr ■ x-1 ^no' 
 
 fi J"T Cfv 
 
 X od dosr->'i.' i ad Il/de 
 
 [jfB !,x' J .;tn ;0 5•'••£;a .t^ooe'! 
 
 : 
 
 L c . 3SE 
 
3 
 
 * 311,4 Wilcox, Delos F. 
 
 W64g Majority rule- The initiative, the referendum and the 
 
 i Pol,sci. recall combined, (see his Government bv all the people. 
 
 - 1913, p,131-313), 
 
 a 
 
 •ml 
 
 *321.4 ' --- 
 
 *64g The reoi'll. (see his Government by all the people. 
 
 Pol,ci, 1912. -.199-' 27). 
 
 • pal * * i.n&„ I'tily 12 ; 2 -.a- < -i 1 
 
 PER TOPICALS, 
 
 3c5 
 
 PU 
 
 14 June,1912 
 Pol. sci. 
 
 Aivi »cry recall for federal judges. (Public. 14 ^une, 
 
 1:.L . l-:5 r '3-54). ' 
 
 ® v ' ' *5* MO% hfe t ,* ib‘ 12. X ! 9L»9~c‘ 11 - 
 
 352.05 Defects in the recall. (Pacific municipalitiee. 5o March, 
 
 PA 1212. 36:139). 
 
 3o March,1312 
 
 Delaying statehood and the veto of judges. (Review of reviews 
 
 Sept amber, 1311. 44;264-66). 
 
 •1 l . , , V . ji . ^ i. 
 
 « ‘ ’ • • - _ ’ ' • •- ' > A-'r ' \y{ f i- 
 
 3o5 Direct legislation in Texas. (Public. 23 Fobruarjr, 1312. 
 
 PU ' 1:1 o-Sl). 
 
 23 Feb, 1812 
 Pol,sci. 
 
 Law Eddy, Arthur. 
 
 The recall of Juigse. (Ghicago Segal news, 
 
 6 April, 1912. 44:274-76). 
 
 3o5 Flection re ts-Jinicial recall, (Public, 15 November, 
 
 PU 1912. 15: lo6c). 
 
 15 Nov,1918 
 Pol,sci. 
 
 320.5 Extension of the recall in Arizona, (Equity series, 
 
 v, E October, 1913. 14:153-58). 
 
 ' Oct.1812 
 Pol.eci. 
 
 3o5 Initiit.ive, referendum and recall in Taras. (Pi c, 
 
 PU 29 March, 1912. 15:299). 
 
 . 29 Mirch, 1912 
 
 Pci.sci, 
 
 * 3o5 The judicial recall in Arizona. (Public. 3 May, 1912. 
 
 PU “ 15:419). 
 
 3U2ay, 1912 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 32o.5 
 
 E 
 
« 
 
 . ■ . < J. - " t / DC nr 
 
 9rfJ ibiijii mbn^ts'i t\y cm Li ,o-/l arff -a ten fl'■■•'). o£*M‘ 
 
 • is i qo •■•• q * i * X ; ♦. v d #n n •" >; t-■.* ■ a : - n 
 
 s) ' . .-.'V; ifr-J ; 
 
 / '; i t ** ■ or . is • r 
 
 b 3H,3? 
 
 ' C'' ,r .■* 
 
 : .i .? it • ! r x. ; .v »T'v;> r ’ a in 
 
 £i>Dtt i1Sf¥ 
 
 .-v ; -■••■!.- 
 
 .aiLi 
 
 »» 
 
 . : or. , 
 
 . ’, r a d J' , t ■" q 
 
 I v/ * ft? v * « **f * .L .* I? ; J 
 
 t& a'- 'rc ? ££#op? •vyo-ilvt-A 
 
 A - X: ■/ ». . I 
 
 uq 
 
 *1 
 
 . o . f > t T 
 
 at 
 
 .axi / L . : n * -a .- fr’M -: c l) , Vli-sea. ' ! .' hi * ,* n;• '*cCl i'o-,: dS 
 
 A n . :.'•{; ;rx 
 
 •'fgi ...- 
 
 w * „ •rf - j, ^ A f -»• w 
 
 © % 9 i* V9 r X ^ 0 W *' l V 3 ft} 
 
 fc, x& : i ■ .< - . <• >t< 
 
 . )S;># 
 
 USX *T^rfsnaT- td 
 
 f 
 
 X ^ 
 
 fiXoC? 
 
 » ••’ , l': Line.: :>% C-4 , a C .oT) 
 
 . 5 »* 3? n r. no i .f * f : :> a i j a ©i M 
 
 , ? X - -o X: r 
 
 
 SiCX.idt L. 
 
 '♦ ; ' . ■:' ' c ' 
 
 .W D(l i'%&■'■' 
 
 K vi' 
 
 ' t0 £ C/.ost tffiT 
 
 ,sxer t lLiqA D 
 
 
 
 t 'ixc'inw^I 01 
 
 , • . 
 
 ♦XX.foor L' iviiuX f -Qj'y&&i noiiC’5/3 
 , (o9ol:$1 
 
 ... ro f 
 
 4 -''j .C • ■ v 
 
 , v tf 
 
 trq 
 
 'SJQ£,V0« d£ 
 
 , i Of , .’ . 7 
 
 y.tia , } ,rn i?.rti. -:i f T? no 7 e !.t a noi xv$> ~. C 
 
 • (-<! —i X : > / . - •'. ■<■ X t 'V, ;• *5 4 oC X 
 
 CU t, da: 
 
 .art au<l} 
 
 
 f 1 np f ■* ff 
 
 • J - ■ * • ,J 
 
 , 2 ! r 1 i XI.i'0 91 .'r.ni «wf :ai 9*1 a*c t or i t a i i t a X 
 
 . ( : !l . -i^X * .loxr” .; 
 
 <?oE 
 
 rrq 
 
 .19X f rfoTj M ‘, l . 
 
 a?! 
 
 .ai ;jl 
 
 *1 S 
 
 .ot; .vq) 
 
 , tZfy&tc A :,.t Xlx 3^*1 X/;ioX>'0; sit 
 
 } »> «U - < * «• 
 
 do 6 
 
 trq 
 
 * H 
 
 t- th ■ f .%,a 
 -v > J l • * A i 
 
 .0.0 
 
 *c 
 
4 
 
 32o.5 King, George Judson. 
 
 E Arizona replies to President Tift, (Equity 
 
 April, 1912 series. April, 1212. 14:54-55). 
 
 Poltsci. 
 
 352.05 Locke, William J. 
 
 PA . A review of the city charters adopted in California 
 
 31 July, 1912 during the past two years, with com/pen to. (Pacific 
 
 municipalities. 31 July, 1912. 20:337, 339-41). 
 
 352,o5 Mason, Edward F. 
 
 NA Learning tc use the recall, (National municipal 
 
 Oct.1912 review. October, 1912. 1:659-61), 
 
 Pol. aci. 
 
 32o.5 
 
 E 
 
 Oct.1912 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Present status of the state wide recall in the United States, 
 (Equity series, October, 1912, 14:15o-53). 
 
 ■ davvjb bar s. s ood x oij . 0 uly a*.', 11. t, is*, 
 
 Happard, William E, 
 
 The initiative, referendum and recall in Switzer¬ 
 land. (Annals of the American academy of political 
 
 and social science. September, 1912. 43:126-27, 
 
 129, 134-35). 
 
 i : : ■ . ■ 3; •. ' ic r i '' ' *. 
 
 Law Sohroeder, Theodore. 
 
 Social justice and the courts. (Yale law 
 
 journal. November, 1912. 22:25-29). 
 
 3o5 Smith, Joe, 
 
 PU The recall in Seattle. (Public. 17 Febru- 
 
 v, 14 ary, 1911. 14:151-53). 
 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 3o5 - 
 
 PIT The recall in Tacoma, (Public. 26 May, 
 
 v. 14 ’-1911. 14:4 3d— 89), 
 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Still bombarding the judiciary. (Current literature. 
 
 March, 1913. 52:355-58). 
 
?iiup3) 
 
 ,nc aJiu'C ©£ r *■■ •* 
 
 ; f ’ 
 
 i£ r 
 
 JL m <!» 
 
 n: : 
 
 .* * *** 
 «-r 
 
 V 
 
 %?.* 
 
 f f.' £ A 
 
 ., * r 
 
 • « i .v 
 
 # T» V ■ £ 1 1 ■ t tf.'S'Orf ^ 
 
 » lf< « _• I . t-,-,- . J ;|:| ■ :i"> r-fto erf# to- KiW't ‘ . „ rnf , -.., V 
 
 jin «Vfat ?^- ^ 0 rfjt* or# #«q *•'# ai3X *' tm >%* 
 
 onto&V • ” .,K,T fi - £8 ■ 
 
 ,x Li; l"' « 1 ‘ 5B U 
 
 c » *. _,’,r \ f f £.;«- s «i*r <•» -f f' ‘QTr. tj 0'$ SttlJtn*? 
 
 . • : ' • ' 
 
 .v 0 l^d’X 
 
 ES , rJ „ ^i.,0 s -. «i I If,os? efel* •#*#• erf# *•«$»*• * n6BSiq 
 
 < 
 
 m 
 
 Is L.toO 
 
 * .: 
 
 , r. :.q 
 
 t '■> r' 
 
 • i»C 
 't 
 
 .UCI :«C 
 
 , I OJ , i. ’ 
 
 .••X ,forc'?q»a 
 
 -«.t*r8 ni X£*®** b«* mt****t*r f *ri >*»*"* ««* f 
 
 t , t s. ~ v yr-M•) }" ft &0 L%&Wh 0U# A0 <> A '••■ iA.&J *’ 
 
 . 
 
 ;V -- '■•{• -'■' ••*. VJ ‘ « • ■-■ i ,9 
 
 9 it 
 
 .e-.ot-ifdT ,T&i jorrfeE 
 
 ■ ' '' 
 
 -3..: ;, . .lex t v>- «voH 
 
 
 w/-JC 
 
 
 
 > i 
 
 . o if. £ jj*5 } 
 
 ,eo!. , K *a 
 
 rci ilBbteZ- ®r- T 
 f—>_r a: ; I .ii5i , a? -• 
 
 So .■ 
 
 th 
 
 £ I* v 
 
 i: o e .: a-i 
 
 ■> «v 
 
 t *i A '* 
 
 :£s 
 
 . c i i ■ 
 
 .JMlOOiST .1 
 
 o??x odT 
 
 .(es- 4a X 
 
 r 
 
 -• \ v • . 
 
 TTH 
 ?v f . •' 
 
 , I r . •: . • 
 
 -; 
 
 (X ^n®nu^) 
 
 \ 1 "*■ 
 
 .-liUitHJt 9(11 ili#3 
 
 . . . •X .rforeM 
 
 
3 " 
 
 32o, 6 
 AM 
 v. 8 
 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 FAVORABLE. 
 
 BOOKS. 
 
 Croly, Herbert. 
 
 State political reorganisation. (American 
 political science association. Proceedings, 1911, 
 
 v. 8 , p, 133). 
 
 AM 
 
 Feb.1912 
 Supplement 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Same in American political science review. 
 February, 1912. Supplement, p.133. 
 
 34?. 06 
 IL 
 
 1912 
 
 Goodwin, Clarence N. 
 
 The recall of judges, 
 sociation. Proceedings, 1912. 
 
 (Illinois state bar as- 
 v.36, p.243-45). 
 
 Ref,desk Manahan, James. 
 
 The recall of judges. Address before the Minnesota 
 state bar association, July 19, 1911, (U. S. 
 
 62d Cong. 2d sess. Senate. Doc.941). 
 
 32o,6 
 AM 
 v.e 
 
 Pol.sci, 
 
 32o, 5 
 AM 
 
 Feb, 1912 
 Supplement 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Ref,desk Taylor, C. F. 
 
 A glaring error in certain Senate documents oppo 
 sing popular government, (U. S. 62d Cong. 2d sess. 
 Senate. Doc.651). 
 
 Rowell, Chester H. 
 
 ’ Remarks on Mr. Herbert Croly*s paper on State poli¬ 
 tical reorganization. (American political science 
 
 association. Proceedings, 1911, v. 8 , p,148-5o). 
 
 Saije article in American political science 
 review. February, 1912, Supplement. p,148-5o. 
 
 347,o6 
 
 IL 
 
 v.36 
 
 Law 
 
 Wanamaker, R. M. 
 
 Addresses on the recall of judges. (Illinois 
 
 state bar association. Proceedings, 1912. v.36, p.174- 
 
 189, 251-58). 
 
 Part of same in Chicago legal news, 18 May^ 1912. 
 44:321-24. 
 
 Law 
 
 Part of same in Central law journal. 
 75:28-33. 
 
 12 July, 
 
# 3J5TAHOVAt 
 
 .8X003 
 
 3 ,oS£ 
 MA 
 8.t 
 .ios .103 
 
 3 ,o££ 
 alk 
 
 siex.cf83 
 
 InefnaXqqnS 
 
 .xas ,Xo3 
 
 M 90H8TBXO t nxwbooX) 3o.?££ 
 -Ofi tjscT slBls aioniXXl) .assbuQ lo XXbost ed? JI 
 
 .\cM>~££S t q ,3£.v .oX0X , agrtx baa oortS .no i .lexooo 3X01 
 
 ,a9flUBt» t xi£rfj6aBM d89b,lofi 
 
 x.loasnniM aril snored aaaxbbA .asg&ut 1o IIsoqt sxlT 
 
 .3) ,IX9X , 8X YIxjL ,noi\+6iooas£ x£d aljsls 
 
 . CXAO.ocCI ,9d£n9'3 .8898 bS .gnoO bS6 
 
 .JlSdlsH 4 yXO‘i0 
 
 aBoxx9mA) .noil; si'a^Toes -ffioxliXoq al&J8 
 ..vXOI t s§nib99ooi3 ,aoxl£i:cos8.8 eonaioa Xjeoilxloq 
 
 . (££ X . q < 8. v 
 
 .V79XVST sonsioa XBoxliXoq aBoxTemA ai 
 
 • £SX.q .Jtnome Cqqxf3 .SX9X , y^ 6 ^^ 9 ^ 
 
 •H 13^89(10 , XXswoH 3 ,oS£ 
 
 *i!oq .18 ao X9q£q e 1 yXonD l-xoa'ieH ,tM no * 1U 
 
 son9xoe Xb oi 1 xXoq aBoxx&mA) .aoilBsx nB^xosi Xsoxl 8.v 
 
 * (oS-SAI ,q ,8.v ,XXGX ,agflibaaooxq .nox IsiooaBB .xos.Xo^ 
 
 ©cnoxoa XBoxliXoq nfioixemA nx eXoilxB 9 $.cS c ,o3 £ 
 
 .□3-8AX .q .InsmsXqqtxS ,SX0X t yxELfXde^ .w sivez MA 
 
 sxex .cf9 r ii 
 
 JaemeXqqi/S 
 .i: os .X08 
 
 .0 t xoXyBT desb.leH 
 
 -oqqo alnamnoob elBnoS niBliso nx ioxts gfiixeXg A 
 
 »8.".98 bS ,§ao0 bS3 ,8 .IT) .Inoamnavos xeXt/qoq gnxe 
 
 .(XS3.ooG .slnnefi 
 
 ,M .H t i95fBSL£n£W 3o, ?A£ 
 
 vionilllj , 33 gbufc lo XIboot sal no aasasxbbA JI 
 
 t 85.v .3X6X t asnxb9900Tq .no xlBxooaaB xbo alBle 3£.v 
 
 ,(85-ias , 08 X 
 
 ,8X01 81 ,awan Xb^oX ogjsox;f0 nx 9 itubs 1o 1xb8 wbJ 
 
 ,*S-XS5:^ 
 
 ,XBnxxro(; tcjsI XBilnsO nx smxsa lo ,lx£q ;?£,J 
 
 .££-32:5? .310X 
 
 ,yX^ SX 
 
6 
 
 3q 5 Quotations from Aante in Public. 
 
 PU 15:^11. 
 
 3 May, 1913 . 
 
 Pol. ec i, 
 
 PERIODICALS, 
 
 3o5 Another reason for the recall of judges. 
 
 PU 9 February, 1912. 15:124). 
 
 9 Feb. 1912 
 Pci - sol. 
 
 3 May, 1912. 
 
 (Public. 
 
 3o5 
 
 PU 
 v. 14 
 Pol.3Ci, 
 
 Barkley, R. W, 
 
 A significant parallel, 
 b r, 1911. Ii:lc69-7c). 
 
 (Public. c o Qcto- 
 
 3o5 
 
 PU 
 
 3 April, 1912 j 
 P ol,eci. 
 
 Behcl 1 the bench. 
 
 (Pub;io. 
 
 5 April, 1912. 
 
 lb: 316 
 
 > # • u 
 
 Bourne, Jonathan. 
 
 Functions of the initiative, referendum and recall, 
 (Annals of the American academy of political and social 
 science. September, 1912, 43:3-16). 
 
 3c5 
 
 Bryan before 
 
 PU 
 
 131 
 
 22 March, 
 
 1912 15: 
 
 Pol.oci. 
 
 Catlett, Frol 
 
 (Public, 
 
 22 March, 1912. 
 
 f YViV-1 i a 
 
 arch. 
 
 Working of the recall in Seattle. (Annals of 
 the American academy of ucliticul and social science. 
 September, ISIS. 43:327*36). 
 
 Checks an', balances. ' (Independent, 
 ? o: 1 c? 5-7 C). 
 
 18 May, 1911. 
 
 i 
 
 V 
 
 3c 5 
 
 ptr 
 
 V, 14 
 
 Pol,sc i. 
 
 
 Dutton, J. W. 
 
 American origin of the recall, 
 r. August, 1911, 14:826-27 ). 
 
 Experiments in democracy. 
 
 3:831-32). 
 
 (Outlook. 
 
 (Public, 
 
 15 August, 19o8. 
 
 Part oi eame in Larne-d, J. N. History for ready 
 
 reference. 
 
 191c. 
 
 y.7, p.559-6o. 
 
 
3 
 
 
 ...18' t y• -■* s 
 
 . 
 
 , ft? 
 
 o aoc 
 
 uq 
 
 s 
 
 , £ *Jii , I J*t 
 
 *■' f Id ir f I 5 
 
 1 
 
 : c * 
 
 ♦ do?, 
 
 0t 
 
 ,:i 'M .cf>s 8 
 
 , )" j; r ‘- 
 
 -d toQ od .oiXv^) 
 
 aj ; 
 
 ,*? ,s ^^liijisC 
 
 , X s? i I**&g -tn arc r 1’ AS ‘ 4 A 
 
 at ?*T 
 
 IH 
 
 30- : 
 
 si -.‘a 
 
 <0 
 
 ..CISC ,1 <S 
 
 .ilon J 9 At fc.Xotf®S 
 
 V • - 5 " 
 
 M .7 
 
 •a>s 
 
 ,XiT:qA ;.: 
 
 # j . i o<7 
 
 10L ,^'r-TUOa 
 
 J I « , 
 
 X • !■ H i X 3 - V ' . ;, /'■ - * V '" Z . 
 
 „{ -I~C i • -> '• * ■ .1 8 X . 1 «dl‘-i , v-».. . ^ -•' •* v - 
 
 s 
 
 -ric'i i'd 5»X t rn aco I*?r XtoU^nod o 
 
 # £i. !-li , r; • 3 1 „ •>.': fed .'' - M *./ r l ) 
 
 aryi?- 
 
 r- f 
 
 <* i- JL 
 
 * . *• ' f 
 
 f * A- 
 
 sxer 
 
 
 ,i tsIti-O 
 
 •t-, ..iwtaA) .s.£*S;a»e X XX«'-9" »•« " 5 <> . ,, 
 
 , WJ i M iitinoe bn* tJiSimr.? -:a i»l «i f< U*«* a:.f 
 
 V- * . . • -j . • 
 
 dOC 
 
 Tfl 
 
 f(OTt-.I? ^ ci 
 
 « v,'i ?*X 
 
 J n-> t-asqcbrl) 
 
 .». £-1 x.' X to * s £'' *rfO 
 
 ( .v/lio-’ 
 
 .?>? f^in) 
 
 , ' vdl : " v 
 
 ,T ,T* ti (0.<v'uXI 
 
 ,Xl£09? i Xtf Xe ai»i <0 
 
 ,(v -D*8: ■■ ■ . - '• t ? 
 
 $q r i wt jto6 ai a$«esui$ X*^ 
 
 , r - • : ' 
 
 . uooim 
 
 V' .» 
 
 tw 
 
 • 1 .v 
 
 ..to: .1 r < 
 
 vSwi o:ot M tH ^ t X>d£ii.^T n : • . “ ^ 
 
 v o0—8$- '* q W , ■ IUX .oojii 1 ifufli 
 
7 
 
 352.05 
 * HA 
 
 April, 1012 
 Pol. sci. 
 
 A 
 
 l 
 
 Gilbertscn,H. 8, 
 
 Conservative -lapecte of the recall. 
 
 (Kat ion- i 1 mu t- i u i ? 1 1 re v i ca. April, 1912* 
 
 is: o4-li). 
 
 Tbs recall - it.-, provisions and significance. 
 (Annals of the American academy of political and 
 social soiene*.. Sept nber, 1312, 43:216- 
 
 326). 
 
 Gu t h r i, ©, Ge or ge W, 
 
 Tie initiative, reforen&um and recall. (Annals 
 • pf the American academy of political and social science 
 September, 131,, ' 43:17-31). 
 
 352.00 
 
 M 
 
 Oct.1912 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Haynes, John R, 
 
 The actual workings of the initiative, referendum 
 and recall. (National municipal review. October 
 
 1912. 1:586-6 oh). 
 
 The houte-cloaning in Loa Angeles, 
 I960. ' 31:757-58), 
 
 (Ou11ock. 3 Ap r11, 
 
 3o5 Johns n, H. W. 
 
 PU Speech before the Ohio Constitutioral convention, 
 
 9 March, 1312 February 29 , 1912. Quot’d lens. (Public. 
 
 Pol * eel. . $ March, 1912. 15:22 5 - 26 ). 
 
 3o5 The judicial recall and Mr. Roosevelt, (Public, 
 
 PU ' 15 March, 1912. 15:243*44). 
 
 15 March, 1912 
 Pol,sci. 
 
 JUD. 
 
 The recall of judges, (Outlook. 16 March, 
 
 1913. Ioo;6o6-c7). 
 
 Lav Morrill, Donald L. 
 
 The recall of judges and judicial decisions. y 
 
 (Chicago legal neva. 6 April, 1912. 44:376). 
 
 32o. 5 The recall in national poZM.ioss. (Equity series, 
 
 r 191o. 12:132-33). 
 
 v. 12 
 
 Pol,sci. 
 

 ,3 JB 4 <v 0 
 
 , 1 t/ioea a;i \o s)t? *r - * J* 
 
 r e,- -jA , ' 
 
 • ,J - * .- .{ Ci- o :x 
 
 r 4W> M» *•*- »• < 
 
 .aofltfo>; iwii® - v " "' ** ~ 1 [ Ai x r - t ., x 
 
 I,U :■: ■-.. ■ . V.. lato*•*•«* V !•> P#****# 
 
 •a I&tS * . -- t 1 toSn * 3 q •-■£ 
 
 .&rn$10-- I ^ loo a 
 
 »v < ’ •* -* 
 
 ‘ O • * Ovj 
 
 Aii 
 
 £1CI «1 i:i ;A. 
 
 . iot: , •' v i 
 
 JF 4;tort) t #I:rrffr*j6 
 
 vZmiik) '*' , * 
 
 , 
 
 * . 
 
 xuiai’ioisx 1 sviJoJ ‘ i ii o<-f f ^ u ' : * ' ! f ““ h 
 
 . 
 
 * { ...••( .1 .-0 J 1 
 
 .It"-... k C 
 
 
 > 1 4 
 
 *►« _ ft '"f ¥' 
 
 r «•'<.> 4 i ' jt -*v 
 
 A'a 
 
 *\ .. X . * 'oO 
 * £o.: . lo'1 
 
 , C \ 
 
 ,.je C^vcA •■■ ■•■i fi£ * *.< •:» •• - - o;c 4 oriT 
 
 ( -■ /-' 3 I 
 
 . 
 
 If TT r 
 
 • ■ ■ •»* t 
 
 i to Vrf* 
 
 
 
 :-;I , ; 
 
 ♦• * • * 
 
 . '•:;. 0X « 
 
 Z*t 
 
 ij* 
 
 s-u 
 
 ■+t 
 
 , Ion 
 
 «i* 
 
 siL qh* 1) .ttavana&n .iM tz* llsot-x * trT '££ 
 
 " ‘ ^ ■■■ ■ ’1 
 
 t io: .lo^ 
 
 ♦ coa ML te ,sjilT 
 
 ' S' : >; 0 0 l . '" X 
 
 dcmtf '.'< I . Iqo^irO) 
 
 f tvf* 
 
 , v 
 
 .(.'• : . . »••'»* 3 
 
 lo crIV . 
 
 , 6vJ. '*$>i o- coX .0) 
 
 '■Mi. 
 
 I 
 
 
 . s04tIXoq X/ -\Q ■ /-M fl t t XJi6c t tt^T 
 
 .0 ' 
 
 • 4 •* *‘ 
 
 r. L , / 
 
 . .*: o * 
 

 The recall of judges. 
 
 1cc:522-25), 
 
 (Outlook. 
 
 9 March, 1912. 
 
 3o5 
 
 PU 
 v, 14 
 
 Pollsci. 
 
 14:146-47). 
 
 {Public. 
 
 17 February, 1913. 
 
 3o5 
 
 PU 
 v. 14 
 
 14:817-18). 
 
 (Public. 
 
 11 August, 1911. 
 
 Pol.sci. 
 
 Roosevelt, Theodore. 
 
 The right of the people tc rule. (Outlook. 
 
 23 Mrch, 1913. loo:633). 
 
 Snow, A3pheus Henry. 
 
 The position of the judiciary in the United States. 
 (Annals of the American academy of political and social 
 science. September, 1' 12. 43:286-31o). 
 
 3o5 Stockton, Lewis. 
 
 PU Direct legislation and the recall. (Public, 
 
 8 March, 1913 8 March, 1913. 15:231-33). 
 
 Pol.sci, 
 
 32o.5 Taylcr, C, F. 
 
 E Direct legislation record. (Equity series. 
 
 April, 1912 April, 1912. 14:56-7 3). 
 
 Pol,sci. 
 
 Law Wilkins, F. B. 
 
 Recall of the Judges. (Chicago legal news. 
 
 11 November, 1911, 44 :1 c6-o8). 
 
 OPPOSED. 
 
 BOOKS. 
 
 347.cS 
 
 AM 
 v. 36 
 
 American bar association. 
 
 Resolution concerning the recall of fudges, 
 (aee its Proceedings, 1911. v,36, p.51). 
 
 Ref,desk Brown, Rome G. ' * 
 
 The judicial recall a fatiicy repugnant to courti 
 
 tutional government, (U. S. 62 Ceng. 2d sesa. 
 
 Senate. Doc.892). 
 
 Same in Annals of the American academy of politi¬ 
 cal and social science. September, 1912. 43:239-77. 
 
. .119X * oo - : M O 
 
 . 
 
 ;to IJVr-'X 0 f 
 
 ,(0—OddJooX 
 
 
 • USX «T*i' 7£ 
 
 six.: jO{ 
 
 .fVv-MAU M 
 
 ro£ 
 
 IN 
 M .V 
 
 ♦ irih ilcN 
 
 . - i t i t ic ii^ .A ; i 
 
 , 0i* I :} 
 
 
 rOC 
 
 M 
 
 Oi ,v 
 
 . i:»S . lO'i 
 
 iooi'jhuG} 
 
 # -‘W 
 
 , •> it .to »d? , :t X e- to e oo ft 
 
 o.f tj fqovq ;,o erf'f 
 
 .(£ 200 Jt 
 
 . x ix t ;ti, : iu 
 
 y' :' < H - £f«%li f r # J.i ri r* ;> 
 
 ■ 
 
 tUE. ifcxnioq to e&vir&ttLA odi io b trank) 
 
 • o~ v d: c • , i* [ , *vd s ’ f'-.i.r ,- 
 
 ♦ Of f i 
 
 dot 
 
 rt .d; *■? Jf t r:ot:l vO; ! '' 
 
 • 0- - ay .i ^ .!; ;l b IT • 1 j ?: ( Ji ■ C tfC91 : a -J<T 
 
 4 1 * 1 - ■ •<! $ did I 8 
 
 . iod, ico 
 
 .aos-see xflufil) 
 
 .0 , djivvT <i , . 
 
 ,fdid03i aoitfJCXnifcoJ josita 3 
 
 —'-n; rAi , 'ii. dJL t ii'.t’fA ai QI . Xxt .{A 
 
 ♦ £o«, £:•'* 
 
 $ ’$ ^ fv | tJ f j -" 
 
 •*** a **a*'X 03 * >iJO) ,e© 3 bif| »d.t to xxioaH 
 
 * v • k 5 -• f o X :; •> , L 10 [ t :, odm ovoM I £ 
 
 .0 
 
 .81008 
 
 
 . _ . » ,r ' 1 Xv r .. 0-.. 0 \£ ‘Xx.d fXJSQ/ TO *11A 
 
 : , •,, 7 . 1 it! . ... rt; ? 2teo~0 :. 1 i to,.) 
 
 : ;c; , r ». ; 
 
 m 
 
 OS ,v 
 
 .. . : . ■ 
 
 - )Jo , 
 
 .»«*e •• .dr 0 :-a ,3 ,U) 
 
 it or. , ;sk 
 
 * ■, .- 
 
 ■f ' . Oi'v*; , ; ; j i ;d 
 
 r^J 1 ^ 10 atfj 'to eXmirA at o^a 
 
 — . • >. x. . tor k H.V o .1 _ . ... 
 
347. o6 
 
 AM 
 v. 36 
 
 Ref,desk 
 
 347.06 
 
 IL 
 
 1912 
 
 Ref,desk 
 
 Ref.desk 
 
 §§§4 731 
 
 v, 48, Pt.3 
 
 Ref.desk. 
 
 Ref,desk 
 
 Ref, desk 
 
 Farrar, Edgar H, 
 
 Address before the American bar association, 
 (see its Proceedings, 1911. v.36, p.231-32). 
 
 Same in Chicago legal news. 
 
 44:61). 
 
 3o September, 1911. 
 
 Haze It on, John H. 
 
 The recall of judges. (U, S. 62d Cong, 
 
 2d sess. Senate. Doc.723). 
 
 Illinois state bar association. 
 
 Discussion on the recall of judges. (see its 
 
 Proceedings, 1912. v.36, p,234-42, 245-48). 
 
 Lodge, Henry Caoot. 
 
 The compulsory initiative and referendum and the 
 recall of judges. An address delivered at Princeton 
 university^ March 8,'1912, (U, S. 62d Cong, 
 
 2d sess. Senate. Doc, 4c6). 
 
 Staffer!, Wendell Phillips. 
 
 The new despotism. Address before the New York 
 county lawyers 1 association, February 17, 1912, 
 
 (U£ S. 62d Cong. 2d sess. Senate. Doc.344). 
 
 Part of same in Congressional reeofid. G2d Congress 
 2a sess. 26 February, 1912. v.48, Pt .3 
 
 p.2595-96. 
 
 Taft, William H. 
 
 Address at Concord, N.H. March IS, 1912. p.9-11 
 
 (U. 8. 62d Cong. 3d sess. Senate. Doc.522), 
 
 Address to the General court of the Legislature 
 of Massachusetts, March, 18, 1913. p.6-7. 
 
 (U. S. 62d Cong, 2d sess. Senate. Doc,451). 
 
 The judiciary and progress. Address at Toledo, 
 Ohio March 8, 1912. (U. S. 62d Cong. 2d sess. 
 
 Senate. Doc. 4o8). 
 
 Quotations from above in Outlook. 23 March, 
 1912. loc:6o4*. 
 
e 
 
 . ao s 1 jb i oo sen usd a bq i ivir.A s a ;f 
 
 i. •'. t .. ’ jb“ i t;>: 
 
 ie; ti A 
 
 , \ ±&~l£ J.q t .'-o ,v .IIGI * . 4 i, saoo'i : c-ivtx o&s) 
 
 r> r > T* 
 
 MA 
 
 3c . v 
 
 . IXUX < I- • ‘J.tt•■• * _ si>3 0G 
 
 * 
 
 . (X3: ;■-•> 
 
 <o n ^ n * 0 p tt 1 
 
 ,H a lc L ,no*l«*j it 
 . ■ : ' ." . ‘ ■ V “ ! V 
 
 At "V..-Y-. t?. ,bs9» t:i 
 
 lao.l ,'. vH 
 
 otfi o&r,} 
 
 . cr.■ 1 di ; oo $? jb i i <J s.f jlX a <• i oni £ I 
 
 .ee$;;.vr to IIjbost e;l+ ao no ietauoeAd 
 
 (- ' I—c Js G . ■ J , q . 1 
 
 4!- o r 
 
 I t «;g ai.be 3 oos*! 
 
 «PO , V. G 
 
 TT 
 
 5X31 
 
 * X yd bO y i a »H * 0 s &o I 
 
 srfX JbriB flttffc/taisTtei Jbns ©trxiBi Xinl y • oaluqifloo et?T 
 aojfecuir'l 3x jbeietllsb esaaJhb* a A :pf lo IXBoot 
 
 * -o'’ x: , r ) _ .. ’X > f t■; • ^ ‘:o~ v!■ , 
 
 ^ tt 
 
 , ■ ->C! „ v -x-, ' .. 
 
 iyoi .IsH 
 
 . ag i IX t d3 i X e l f * t i t ' '•; 1 £ &S 
 
 Ayo'i * ©£ $ 'it 07 0 loci’ eaeT.Jb.bA ,m?.i to Ljaeb «-;ea or IT 
 
 i J . .. 1 " 
 
 • (£: .: .C‘0'1. ,etx ioO . ^0 i . ,8 1U) 
 
 ^f;S£ . "ioG 
 
 aaeT^xxoO fca . 
 
 . b,iio o s % £ 1-470 i a *, 313 ao ^ ri ' n ' J: s ' ^ 
 
 
 + ty r*Cf 
 
 . . r i a a a o-S 
 
 c>3811.0 
 
 i G Y * i?S V 
 
 C. • 1 t 
 
 XI- 
 
 r> r 
 
 •»V *A. 
 
 . {:.:', 5. 00(1 
 
 rfcrx.J »HJi t . f --iootfaoD fc-aopibA 
 
 # e*aa<-8 .4 : 0 c l.. , act.- b;c .3 *U) 
 
 .H Xlixnv .r:xT J8S. .loH 
 
 .Jl^XaxgsJ ad* to *.a;oo X jBien#£ oj sfeoibbA 
 
 • 3 .c; ,c i.SI j-I £ n0 fid t i**a4i/l?«ta bM 1 o 
 
 . .31100 b>:0 .8 .V) 
 
 -- it . j ,1c H 
 
 .ic ' .0; CT .e*»-no2 . a... 
 
 t oJbaXoT tt- 
 .aoaa b;l 
 
 saexbi A .eeoT^QTCj bru: y r x sdT 
 
 • ' - SJ . _ . 
 
 , ■ > .OcG . 3 - 1 .: r- ■.. 8 
 
 - -- ©j . 1 ^- 
 
 d ot.«M 
 
 Vj-14 
 
 . • : • > -j? X * 0 0 n i 0 v > <X & ftio t 1 a iio i * 0 * q rip 
 
 4 # . i» 
 
 . .••. ) o X 
 
 . 4 1 ■ i 
 
lo 
 
 Ref.desk 
 
 Thom, Alfred p. 
 
 The pending revolution. Address before the Ala¬ 
 bama state bar association July IS, 1912, (U, S. 
 
 G2 Cong. 3d eeaa. Senate. Doc.683), 
 
 Ref.desk 
 
 U. S, Rouse of representatives. Committee on territories. 
 
 Admission cf Rew Mexico and Arizona. Report to 
 accompany H.J. Res.156, August 19. 1911. (62d 
 
 Cong. 1st sesa. House, Report,162). 
 
 Ref,desk 
 
 Constitutions of Re^ Mexico and Arizona. Report to 
 accompany H.J.Res.14, May 15, 1911. (62d Cong. 
 
 1st seas. Hcuae. Report 33), 
 
 347.oG 
 
 IL 
 
 191s 
 
 Wilkerson, James H. 
 
 Argument against the recall of judges. (Illi¬ 
 
 nois state bar association. Proceedings, 1912, 
 v.3G, p.l9o-2o3). 
 
 Law 
 
 Same ir. Chicago legal ne»e. 18 May, 1912, 
 
 44:214, 326-28, 
 
 Ref.desk 
 
 Young, N. 0. 
 
 Shall we change our plan of government? (IT. S. 
 
 62 Cong, 5:1 sese, Senate, Doc.865). 
 
 • 
 
 PERIODICALS. 
 
 Ford, Henry Jones, 
 
 Direct legislation and the recall . (Annals cf 
 
 the American academy of po itical and social science, 
 September, 1915. ' 43:65-77). 
 
 law 
 
 Coating, John F, 
 
 Judicial recall. (Chicago legal news. 
 
 6 April, 1912, 44:277-78). 
 
 Law 
 
 Gibbons, John. 
 
 The legal aspect cf the recall. (Chicago legal 
 
 news. 15 June, 1912. 44:359). 
 
 Law 
 
 Hornblower, William B. 
 
 Independence of the judiciary the safeguard of 
 free institutions. (Yale law journal. November, 
 
 1316. 22:1-16). 
 
Oi. 
 
 - ** 4. p 
 
 •* i 4 
 
 '2 
 
 
 *rt-+ 
 
 * 
 
 ©to i aj Qztoxibk ,rt 
 
 •*XC?X ^ 1 1 - X vlt/T, an/" sioo/eu 
 , (.1 -■' . oc<; ,o .•* -:e r v 
 
 / , in y T 
 
 Juiovot tiatJfyoq bJT 
 
 JUU v 
 
 f 
 
 K ^ i' 1 4 n r 
 
 «*•- - • <> .J 
 
 :, .uucO S5 
 
 , 1 © R 
 
 , r + X -Si X r~^./!? ®«*Jii*ai©0 i?; o,* ..-I to eotfdH .8 
 
 © t .tTO Sf* 
 ; jg) 
 
 ^ V* V/ 
 
 fi *J*i* A tais odJxoM *efc to noiBcXf^A 
 ' Xj - ~ V i JaitHsA t dZI.AeP[ J..JT Yte: ^ 0Cj: ,. 
 . \ h:; i . : 10 ; 9h t e -j H ,t£.f • oO 
 
 .tr 
 
 . 
 
 ~ J .t xoxrh .i'.TDSi'iit fc.rt; ooix.eM to . -o ■),,+/ 1 Lr .~ * 
 
 ™>v » ^ \ .. . ... ^ ' 'Mdi liAii./j 
 
 . ioO : ,d) 
 
 * Air r t *x v— « f .o ur., ., 
 
 X iU-'lffiOOOx 
 
 ’ ’ *• r 
 
 v * , '■■ , o • *<r, : > r 
 
 
 0* i 
 
 
 ’ Uei .aoitets'o*** w s -,i 8 *; „ 
 
 - ~ £.■«.< ,v 
 
 a i 
 
 for 
 
 ,.u.u <r , ? .r ^ . : ; j ai 
 
 >3:<o t * 
 
 W*J 
 
 ■ tJ) Y nr £,■; 
 
 i f "■ -i. rfk -- 
 
 ^ t -;UiOO v .-sTu • 
 
 • ’ ■ *■ * 1 ~ t . - o 
 
 «3j*x>ir n;rq 
 
 r io so iia-iig 
 
 . 
 
 K 1 
 
 to o r^.raA) 
 
 i': i - 
 
 u 
 
 “0 8 
 
 ,• ,. *••- ro;.j X;7 ? ri , i ;0 
 
 -' t * *0.«xia 
 
 ?3j.° n:oX-it.^A on J 
 
 
 1 • #••,• i. 
 
 
 I3H 
 
 
 •«»••«« X-eseX ojt o i.':0} 
 
 . (B ■’• 
 
 ♦ * -iOt trtOr'i 
 
 • i Cjfp;;-i U itii.ifT, 
 
 . ."• r" ■ , *, a * . .. 
 
 ’ ,IU * ■ i • • ■ X i i isqn _ 
 
 i4 
 
 u<s«o.f 
 
 » . J. i .' ;•. ”, pi f 
 
 • ■ 
 
 # ' - s * 
 
 ft it ft f* 
 
 * * . X >. / k? 
 
 J;' • ' 
 
 * • -■ : ‘ T • ^ ■ • * j • ’ 
 
 . xO 
 
 
 tXXJUjfctxa. si? off/ 
 
 < - ©Qf^ovoll . t t,X Di ) 
 
 .€ .suriillW t xe^olonToH 
 
 to oooeoao^o^ol 
 
 • » ^ 0 j f f i $ t $ c y i © 11 
 
 . 4 0 i 
 
 ( ’j — J * ■ ;■ 
 
 » \ ' - • v'i 
 
 Vf.i 
 
11 
 
 Improving the judiciary. 
 
 a/ . n. r : n \ 
 
 ~r .e • i ; , ' 
 
 (Nation, 
 
 7 March, 1913, 
 
 Law 
 
 Judicial deauotis© and the recall. (Chicago legal news, 
 
 31 October, 1911. 44:87-88). 
 
 Law 
 
 Lewis, J. G. W. 
 
 Recall of the judges, (Chicago legal nawa, 
 
 11 November, 1911, 44:lc8-ll). 
 
 MeCay, Bruce B. 
 
 The judicial recall. 
 
 84:15-21). 
 
 (Century. May, 1912. 
 
 Maxey, Edwin. 
 
 The recall of the judges. 
 September, 1912. 48:2S4-3o8), 
 
 (Forum, 
 
 Metcalf, James A. 
 
 Dangers that kurk in the recall of the judiciary. 
 (Annals of the American academy cf political and 
 social science, September, 1913, 43:278-85), 
 
 Lac Recall of judges. (Green bag. April, 1911. 
 
 23:214). 
 
 Referendum; not recall. (Independent. 83 May, 1818, 
 72:1186—87). 
 
 Law Seymour, C, B. 
 
 The'recall from the standpoint of Kentucky legal 
 historv. (Yale law journal, March, 1912. 
 
 21:373-82). 
 
 What of the recall? ' (Review of reviews. April, 1912 
 
 45:395-96). 
 
V. 
 
 L t 
 
 ’ SjXX ? . • i j/lf) 
 
 i 
 
 . 7 
 
 r '• ; v f C "i’ ' • r v vi •■ r 
 
 V / <*•! _ k ,* ..•“*■ ** 
 
 • . i . 1 
 
 i * t« X - : ,h a I a# £■ oilO) rr*,. 
 
 .{ ~ ; a : ■ v ■«»£ 
 
 *il o i i.r'G 
 
 ■ t'rza 
 
 vo JtrfO} 
 
 .(a. 
 
 • C4 '8*®t )0 
 
 • . 
 
 txj»09#r 
 
 • .. 7 Jrt 5^<51* Xi 
 
 . 
 
 t Y&a’ 
 
 ,T?,/*aaO) 
 
 . £ Xkjoo 
 
 r r ,- >K •‘ 5 ®» wf 2 ,Y«OoM 
 
 XY£Mb;j^ oift 
 
 •» ■ i. r £ v 
 
 „ ! „ A >C .04 • & < * 
 
 ♦ ■v v >; r ■ ' y r 
 
 ♦ « ’ZSiiwr ft •; 
 
 V • i’ 
 
 • 3ds lo XX*0*1 . v , . V. . , 
 
 teottuoq *0 * &d * ^nr,Q 
 
 £;.w ' .;.: , •*'***• M , !* <\ /t-~ nl \ 
 
 • . nrlw r? t v., 4 j» . •• * ~-nnA/ 
 
 -' .00:'.' : ' •",: - 
 
 **•* X.. JL *' 
 
 • XX C: X . £ l t t '• 4 . . 
 
 1 fr***0) 
 
 , • -A r • * jr • 
 
 *' ’X < ?.• 11 £ j 
 
 •■*<’-s :•■ .slnrj r,-. ,.., 
 
 ' 7»^' ' -?r i^SISUfl 
 
 ' •: f.T • • •“,■• -, C • V ,.. . 
 
 c f J v , - T| ' 5 -J-l-UiX. .f. !>■■<•( ~ . , , v •». r r » i .^YS 1 
 
 ... • v 5 ' 171 IIr.003 
 
 u ^yrosalfi 
 
 * ( S’.' - x V "; i <: 
 
 i ex 
 
 4 XXiqi 
 
 '1 '• V - J a) 
 
 Slf ' + ^rtt 
 
 * • :r;-'