'JL' THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LIBRARY 35Z B875 V.5 i rr i ntTm B arnmiHi o rn^fi'(i jfiolaiq ^rfj jf.d) aiofiinlffi iU i A' Qf the w^r, and the ilate of the finances, ■^-"'^■'I'liad no other wifti than to engage the atten-. ' ; tidn of thisxountry to the dangers with which \:A ii^^ is threatened b)r the prefect lyftem of pro- ^ fiifion in' th-;:..iin:BJib ^i ,nOill.. ■ "pofe Md\ »f[)|rif V' T-'^^r''^ ^" :jHJ io .li.'W '^'J■^A\ ft-M(« ^ ^ -r V0 m •4- »»V O •►- O a^c^ »'0>UW' (-> T o vr (?\ YijJ:,i -noiifirn innobi\j\>f. yiih hnn. . >/jifl oJ nobiqlui ^m svoiq vino ion tySWi.'t, i^jl.on ');;: r:>''>->> r. 'to "orr'nui^ocf Qfl) In ;t O o r^ •* 't (4 ;il '►•3 >- n c: <5z;o O 1^ CN O ON O ON O O 1 ro\o r^ CO O O »o \C »r^>0 00 O O - »»i Hi »»1 O OO •^ O f^ 'O ro ^ e» o> ©N OO VO ro "_^ O •*■ fvi CN >0 -. OO CTv O "^ CO ** rr "^ ^ 1 1 1 1 f I i I i } I f I i t • ( I • I I • <»6 <»o 00 o " ^ «-^ r*- _ ro O ro <-l in c> t^vc M y^jr. ^C" "J t^ M OO t~- CO — o ^ 'J rj_ rr, vo CT> to cT vo » »r^ o- M r-1 m CO ^ , •^ftl t4 t« t^ VO N 1^ O CO t- 'J- M vn U-, O *-^oo o 1 1 i t^ ^ \^ C^ O^. OS t^ r*. r* •i- 0\ r> loo t/^ vr, r^ ay oo o oo o ^ <- ro Lo vo o ■^ - ■+ <-0 t^ u- ov M rj- SO t^OO OD •O O lO «< ro^ 1-1 cr. o Ht ll fO H '*•{» 'J-*^ M C^ «^ ro o •-• M 1- 00 t^ 00 o -J ■*^ C^ (D 'J- o »o O CVOO r^o ro OO t~, ^ ■-4 *^ ro G\ r^ vD « N -I- t^ t^ f^ O CTN 1-1 oo \0 - -^ e va *^{yj «-- iv r^ •^ *-» r^ J I M {4 ( '2 ) In forming thefe ftatements, I have fal- lowed the method adopted by Mr. Grey, in his mafterly and unanfvverable fpeech to the Houfe of Commons on the loth of March laft, and it appears from them that the ex- pences of the firft three years of the prefent war are more than double thofe of the fame term in the American war, and very nearly one half greater than even thofe of the firft three years of the American and French war. But the moft remarkable circumftance attend- ing this unprecedented expenditure is the great proportion of it which has been incur- red without the previous confent of Parlia- ment. In the year 1782 a committee was appointed, of which I believe the prefent Chancellor of the Exchequer was one, to examine the public accounts of the kingdom, and in the report of that committee it is ob- ferved, ** that the enormous amount of the ** extraordinarics incurred without the con- *' fent of Parliament is an abufe of the moft ** alarming nature, enabling Minifters to de- ,** ceive the nation, by keeping back the ** great expences of the war, and concealing ** thereby the extent of its engagements.*' When this report was delivered, the extraor- dinarics ih three years had amounted to ele- ven millions and a half, and in five years to twenty-lix millions nearly — an expenditure moft enormoufly extravagant, and well de- ferving the cenfure pronounced againft it. But in fpite of that cenfure, and even under aa ( '3 ) :\n adminlflration compofed of fome of thofe very perfons who formed the committee, the cxtraordinaries of the prefent war, exceeding all the profiilion of former times, have amounted, in three years only, to imore than thirty-one millions /* In whatever manner, therefore, the comparifon be made, whether from the elHmates, or from the cxtraordina- ries, whether during the firfl: three years of the American, or during the firft three years of the French and American war, the truth of my former aflertion is equally confirmed, ** that the expence of the prefent is unpa- ** ralleled even among the mofl exfrava- * Some idea may be formed of the rapid progrefs of this evil, from the following comparifon of the extraordinaries of the army : In King William''^ war, which lafted nine years, £. they amounted to - - 1,200,000 In Queen Ann's war, which lafted eleven years, they amounted to - - a,ooo,ooo In George the Second's firft war, which lafted nine years, they amounted to - 3,500,000 In the firft three years of the war of 1755 they amounted to - - - 2,434,893 In the firft three years of the American war they amounted to - - 5,215,990 In the whole 35 years — 14>350>S83 In three years of the prefent war they have amounted to . . - 14,509,314 A fum exceeding their amount during 35 years of former wars, by 150,000/. Nay, from the 15th of November to the 3 1 ft' of December laft, a period of about _/£r I'^eeksy they amounted to 1,101,000/. which almoft equals their whole amovmt during n'me years of King Williaiiv'i war. C 3 ** gant (14 ) " gant wars that ever defolated this coun- ♦' try." The principal juftiiication of the prefent enormous expenditure is founded on the ftu- pendoOs magnitude of our exertions in this war, which are reprefented fo far to furpafs thofe of any former war, as to lead us even to admire the frugality of Minivers in having been able to u^iCieafe our forc*:^ in a proportion fo much greater than our expences. Without entering into an examination of the effeds of our exertions, particularly in the laft campaign, I fhall beg leave, in order to prove what little fupport thefe afTertions derive from fad:, to tranfcribe a minijierial ftatemcnt of the naval and military force employed during the fame periods in this and the former war, Com- ( >5 ) « •■•-CO CO Th «/-i &> o »- « o O o « vn ui O »»i 'T * •/^ «~ — I ^ fe-3 " 3 «^ ooo o "^ ^i^ j: r/) OV ■-< ^ CO °.S r^'*- r» > a^ !S J oo c^ O r^ Qh p« rt to ^■S > w^ s o r^ 4-'^ 0S t^ t^ «^ < «« 1-1 M ►" 5; «=; ^Si b •»s o e; "rt OO Cv ^ o ^ o •-- '4- bo S_ u-i <~» O oo o > 15 O *il O ^ ••^ N "-, > C« •< CO % § •£ • o o S " '^ "^ Vi-1 O g o fc o i-i s ^ ^ Ctf CO j/~. -£ •< EU , , S TO ^ O o J- t^ «». ta. M M '^co^ V vo m (VI ^ o ■^ »^ c> i-o O in •o c; •^oo <> 0^ O 1-^ r^^N u-^ I--0 ro H <-l ro ■rh c « M M M M ^ ■4- MOM r^ rt oo eo O O S- 5 - 1 -o « ^ a »j .2 * ~ ^ ( '6 ) It appears from tliefe ftatements that, al- though the war eflabhlliment during the lafl three years has been proved to exceed in ex- pence the fame eftabhfliment during the firfl three years of the French and American war, by more than twenty milhons, only nine ihips of the line, and on the whole num- ber of every defcription, only three fhips have been annually employed in the one cafe more than in the other ; but that in the army, on the contrary, the number of men employed, {q far from exceeding, appear to have been annually about 7000 fewer in the prefent than they were in the former war. The enormity of our expenditure, therefore, does not pro- ceed from any fuperiority in our exertions, and is even aggravated by the very ftatements which are intended to juftify it. In regard to the importance of our conquers, I have only to obferve, that the fettlements of our Allies, for whom we were faid originally to engage in the war, can hardly be reckoned in that number; and as to any other conquefts they certainly afford a very inadequate com- penfation for the lofs of blood and treafure by which they have been acquired, admitting even that a country, whofe pofleffions are al- ready much too extenlive for its decreafing population, could derive any real advantage from an addition to its foreign territories. If however, we boaft of our conquefts, it be- hoves us alfo to look on the other fide of the •account, and in this cafe I am afraid we fhaU 4 have k '7 ) have but little caufe for triumph. When wc behold our enemies, exclufive of N/ce and Savoy and fome of the finefl provinces of the German Empire, in the full pofTeffion of the Netherlands and Holland, by which we are excluded from every port, from Embden to Bilboa, we can derive but little confolation from regarding our new poffeflions on the other fide of the globe ; or from the refled:ion of having expended above Q7ie hundred fnilliom in acquiring them. ' SEC- ( i8 ) SECTION II. On the Debt Incurred by the War, and on the prefent Amount of the National Debt, IN ftating the amount of the unfunded debt in my former account* at fixteen millions, I did it on the fuppofition that the war would end with the enfuing campaign, and that the probable expences, which could not imme- diately ceafe, would be more than equal to fo much of that debt as had been incurred pre- vious to hoftilities. But further information has proved this ftatement to have been under- rated. The navy debt, inftead of five millions, at w^hich it was then taken, appears to have been increafed by the war, on the 3 1 ft of De- cember laft, to the following amount. Whole debt on the 31(1 of December, 179^ - 10,788,984 Sums received from grants of 1796, and applied to theferviceof the year 1795 - i5S4^"'?75^ Vote of credit for 1795 " " ^7^>373 12,507,115 Deduft the debt on the 3 1 ft of December, 179a 2j74Sj99i Increafe of the navy debt " 9,761,124 * Fads, p. 8. The ( '9 ) The more accurate amount, therefore, of the unfunded debt incurred by this war, will be, £■ Navy debt on the 31ft of December, 1795 9,761,124 Ordnance debt on do. - - 210,194. Increafe of Exchequer bills - - 500,000 Expe(5led increafe of the Navy debt above the efti- mates in 1796, and faid to be provided for in the two lail: loans - - - 4,000,000* Allow for expences which cannot immediately ceafe with the war, the very moderate fum of 5, 50o,ooof Whole increafe 1 9,9 7 1 ,3 1 8 From thefe ftatemcnts it appears that the debt incurred by the prefent war, including feventy-eight millions which have been funded J cannot be lefs than ninety-eight mil- lions ; fuppofing, againfl: all probability, that the Emperor*s loan will not be ultimately paid by this country, and that fufficient provilion has been made in the two budgets of the pre- fent feffion for the whole expenditure of the year. The prefent Miniftry claim to themfelves much credit from having provided for the ex- traordinaries of every preceding year in the fupplies of the following year, fo as to pre- vent that accumulation of the unfunded debt, * Of this fum there were 2,822,389/. expended on the 5th of April laft. It is not probable, therefore, that the provifion in this cafe will be fjfficient to pay half the extraordinary ex- penditure during tiie prefent year. f This fum is allosved in a mlmjienal pamphlet, and is moft piobably much belov/ the truth. \ % Facts, p. 7. D which ( ^o ) which had grown to fuch an enormous mag- nitude in the American war.— But the expen- diture of the laft three years, and {tit fee and loan in the prefent year, are not only in dirc(ft oppofition to any claims of this kind, but prove that there never was a time in which they could have been urged with Icfs propriety. So great has been the difference between the fupplies and the real expenditure, that it is impoffible, from the mere knowledge of the one, to form the moil diflant idea of the other. In every department the arrears are enormous beyond all precedent. In the navy particu- larly (which has often been felecfled as the moft ilriking objedt of mifmanagement in former adminiftrations) the evil has acquired its greateft force. At the end of the third year of the French and American war, the unfunded debt in that department amounted to the fum of 10,372,6:28/. At the end of the third year of the prefent war it amounted to 12,507,1 15/.— Or, if a deduction be made ot the debt which exifted at the commence- ment of each of thofe wars, the accumulation in the former will appear to have been 6,369,055/. while in the latter it has fwelled to 9,761,124/.! It is with very little reafon, therefore, that the advantage of going to market iL'itb ready money, rather than with promiffory notes at a coniiderable difcount, is pointed out as one of the good confequences of preventing the floating debt from accumu- lating in an irregular manner.— Whenever this hypo- ( ^' ) hypothefis fhall be carried into effed, I have no doubt but that its truth will be fully efta- blilhed by experience. Sohttle regard, how- ever, has been paid to it for the laft three years, and (o far has tlie contrary practice been purfued of going to market wtth&ut ready money, that the floating debt has endangered commercial credit by its magnitude, and ren- dered a new loan neceflary to prevent worfe coniequcnces. If it could be proved that neither exchequer bills at a difcount 'of five and a half per cent, navy bills at a difcount of lix per cent, nor bills dated at Hamburgh and drawn in London, came within the defcription of promiflbry notes, it might perhaps be allowed that the expences of the. war had been difcharged as foon as they were incurred ; but as this is known to be impoihble, and my bufinefs is only withy^^^, I Ihall leave all theories of finance to thofe who have more leifure to at- tend to them. Whether taxes have been provided in the fupplies of the foregoing years for paying the intereft of the navy debt when it ihall be funded, or whether no fuch proviiion has been made, it is certain that hitherto no intereft can have been paid on more than twelve mil- lions and a half of this- debt ; and therefore, that it lupplies were granted for this purpole,, they have been dire(^fed to other channels, and mud be made up hereafter by new fupplies. It is true, that in opening every budget, except D 2 the ( « ) \htjirft of the prefent feflion, Mr. Pitt under- took to provide not only for the intereft of the navy debt then exilling, but alfo for the intereft of its probable increafe during the courfe of the enfuing year. Thus in the budget of 1794, he appropriated taxes for one mil- lion of navy debt to be contracted in the courfe of that year. In the budget of February 1795, he ftated the increafe of the navy debt to have been, on the preceding Chrillmas, 3,594,000/. fo that in addition to the million which he had provided for 1794, it became neceifary to make proviiion for a further furu of 2,594,000/. and as the increafe of the navy m the year 1795 would probably keep pace with its increafe in 1794, taxes were propofed in that year to pay the intereft of ;i, 594, 000/. and 3,594,000/. making toge- ther 6,188,000. Of this fum 1,609,898/. were funded in the five per cents, fo that the unfunded debt to be provided for in February 1795 was 5,478,102/. In December 1795 the navy debt appears to have been 12,507, 115/. Dedudting 5,478,102/. which are faid to have been provided for in the preceding February, from this fum, there remained in December a further furn of 7,029,013/. to be provided for by new taxes in this year. It is now pro-, pofed to fuqd live millions of this debt,* * It was propofed, at the beginning of the feflion, to provide for the intereft of this fum by an annual lottery. But that mo-. r(z( injlitution is referved for fome further exigencies of the war. and ( -3 ) and to make provifion for a further increafe, during the courfe of the prefent year, of four milhons. But if the navy debt accumulates at the fame rate as it has done in the year 1795, he ought, inltead of four millions, to have provided for nine millions. * Reafoning, therefore, from pali: experience the in^77 Probable arrears of the army, not yet brought to account, which may be eftimated at leaft at - • - - 3,500,000 /.22,862,85i If this film be added to the funded debt, the whole will amount to three hundred and iixty millions nearly, which is as much as the national debt was ftated to be in my former trad:, with the Emperor^s loan included. It follows, therefore, that if any errors were committed in that publication, they were fuch as ought to have fecured to me the approba- tion, and not the cenfure of the Miniftry ; for, by leiTening the amount of the debt, I muft have contributed in fome degree to dif- pel thofe gloomy apprehenfions which are fo unjuftly entertained in regard to the expenca * It IS now propofed to fund a part of this debt, together •with three millions and a half of Exchequer bills and /our mil* lions of the balance due to the Bank. This will increafe the funded and lefTen the unfunded debt. But as the meafure has not yet received the fandion of Parliament, I have thought it beft to continue the accounts of thefe debts vsx their prefent ftatc of ( 27 ) of the war — a war glorious beyond all former example, not only m the number of its vic- tories, but ** in having extended our com- •* merce fo far beyond its utmofl limits in the ** moll flourilhing times of peace, as to have ** already fhed immortal honours on the name *• of Pitt!''* * The ajfertion may be found in one of the miniflerial pamphlets; the proof is perhaps referved for the next publica- cion of the fame kind. 1 SEC-? ( 28 ) SECTION III. On the Loatii of the prefent War. MY chief objecflions to the loans of the prefent war arofe from their having ieen made, for the moft part, in the three per cents, rather than in a flock bearing a higher interefl, by which means the capital of the debt was increafed unnecefiarily. In juflifica- tion of this prad:ice the miniilerial writers feem to have recourfe to an opinion '* That * the Interejl is the only circumftance to be * attended to in borrowing money, that the * expences of a war mean only the fums * which have been adually fpent in it, and * that the creation of a needlefs capital is a * matter of perfed: indifference, lince it can- * not be conlidered as forming any addition * to the amount of the public debts.*' — Leaving Mr. Pitt's adherents to reconcile thefe politions with his former fentiments on the fubje(^,* 1 fliall only obferve, that at this * See my Review of Dr. Price^s Writings, page 19, &c.— but more particularly the debate on Lord j^o/in Cavendijh's bud- getin the year 1783. In his oppontion to that budget, Mr. Pitt reprobates in the llrongeft terms the plan of borrowing in the thrte per ceuts^ and infifts that the only method of con- ducing loans lb as to haften the operations of compound in- Tereft in paying off the national 4ebt, is to borrow in the Jive per cents. — See the Parliamentary Regiiler, publiflaed by Mr. Debiett, Vol. VIII. ( 29 ) moment the capital, which has been borrowed in the prefent war at fixty-three, is redeeming at fixty-fix per cent, and that in the year 1792, the capital which had been borrowed in the American war at fifty-four and a half, was re- deemed at ninety- fix per cent, that is, for every 100/. received in that war, the public were paying in 179:: about 175/. So long, there- fore, as the adherents of the Minifler boafl: of his exertions in providing for the difcharge of the national debt, fo long will the excefs of the capital, above the money actually re- ceived, form a very eirential part of the ex- pences of the war. But when he has ceafed to make this provision, and confidcrs every addition to the debt as a perpetual burden upon the country, they may then, and not till then, recur to the opinions of thofe ftatefmen who borrowed upon this principle, for a jufti- fication of his conducft. The minifterial defence of the laft loan * I do not underftand. It feems to be founded on the fuppolition that it would have been impoffible to prevail upon the contractors for the loan to accept a ftock which bore a high intereft, or in other words, which did not form a capital one halj greater than the fum which they advanced. It cannot be denied that the loan-mongers arc pretty corredl in their ideas of the value of a large capital; and though the national debt, * 1 mean the loan in December laft. E Z 3I> ( 3° ) in the opinion of tlie minifterial writers, may not be increafed by funding in the three per cents, it is evident that the better judgment of thofc perfons teaches them to j:egard their pro- perty as confiderably increafed by this circum-i fiance. Without entering into any further compu- tations on this loan, it will be fuflicient to re- mark, that it has borne a premium of ten, and even twelve per cent, and therefore that the terms, which on eighteen millions give a pro- fit to the lenders of 1,800,000/. mull be highly injurious to the public. Thefe terms have, no doubt, been rendered more profitable to the fubfcribers, by the King's Meflage to Parliament, after the bargain was fettled j and by the refolution of the Commif- lioners to purchafe in \.\iq four per cent s . before it was fettled. But thefe are meafures which have not hitherto been fatisfadtorily explamed. They happened, indeed, to be well-tuned for the lenders; — perhaps a little fo refight* might have made them equally fo for the borrower, — It is attempted to account for the latter of thofe meafures by reprefenting it to have been adopted in conlcquence of the impolTi- bility of purchaiing three per cent, confuls in the month of November, becaufe the books of thofe annuities were fliut at that time. * — This explanation can by rso m.eans be admit- * See Mr. Francis's Speech in the Houfe of Commons, on Friday, Feb. 26, 1796, page 15. Debrett's Debates, Vol. XLIII, ted; ( 31 ) ted ; for it is highly improbable that a cir- cumftance which had recurred twenty times within the hill ten years, fhould not have fooner impeded the operations of the Com- miflioners, and induced them to adopt a Simi- lar condu<^. SEC- ( 3^ ) SECTION IV. On the Sinking Fund. THE plan which was adopted by Mr. Pitiy in the year 1786, for redeeming the na- tional debt I have already proved, * not only to be a prodiidiion oi Dr. Price, mutilated and rendered impotent by injudicious altera- tion, but alfo that it was the weakelt of three plans which had been propofed for the pur- pofc, and communicated by him in confe- quence of repeated apphcation from Mr. Pitt on that iubjed:. Thefe are fads which can be no more denied, than that the Minifter af- fumed the whole merit of the meafure to him- felf, without ever mentionmg the name, much lefs the fervices of Dr. Price. His adherents, improving on the (ileiice cf the Minifter, have attempted to depreciate thofe fervices, and by this means to difcharge him from every obli- gation on their account. The application of a million annually in the purchafe of flock is, certainly, " No new invention or difcovery.'* But was Dr. Price ever fo abfurd as to fup- pofe that he had made fuch adifcovery ? His plans, it is true, like all other effedual plans, were founded on the operations of compound * Review of Dr. Price's Writings, chap. ii. inte- { 33 ) intereflj but they were not valuable merely on this account. They had other merit to recommend them, and this Mr. Pitt him- felf has fufficiently proved, by adopting the weakell of them in preference to one of his own, which, on the reprefentations of Dr. Price, he had been induced to abandon as flill more weaic and ineft'edf ual. * The principal objed:ion to the two ftrongei' plans of Dr. Price arofe from the additional taxes which they would require, to the amount of 600,000/. per ann. in the courle of five years. This deterred Mr. Pitt from diflin- guifliing his adminiftration by adopting either of them ; and although he thought it impro- per, and even imprad:icable, to increafe the taxes at that time about iio^oool. per ann, for iive years, he foon after found it expedient, in a much Ihorter term, to increafe them for other purpofes about 800,000/. per ann. Nay, Vv'ithin the laft three years the Minifter,, who in 1786 Ihrunk from the addition of 600,000/. per. ann. to the taxes, has had tlie refolution to increafe them above four mil- lions, and, if the prei'ent fy ftem fhould con- tinue two or three years longer, he muft have the flili bolder reiblution to increafe them as many millions more. The prefent plan for difcharging the public debts, which was enfeebled at the time of its firfl eftablilhment by injudicious reflridtions, * See my Review of Dr. PrzWs Writings, page 19, S:c. I I have ( 34 ) 1 have already fhewn to be flill further en- feebled, by invariably confining its operations to the redemption of the three ^^r cents.* In the firll feven years, the ftock purchafed by the Commiffioners amounted to 10,109,400/. which afforded a free revenue of 303,282/. According to Dr. Price\ calculations^ 4,076,572/. ought to have been purchafed in the three per cents, and 5,038,133/. in the four per cents, which would have given a free revenue of 323,762/. ; fo that in this fhort time above 20,000/. per ann. has been loft to the fund, in adtlition to the much greater lofs which it has fuftained by the neglect of ex- changing the ioMxper cents, into three per cents ^ when the price of the former was fo nearly equal to that of the latter. -f- In regard to Mr. P///'s meafure of pro- viding an additional fum of i/. per cent, on the capital of every new loan, I have already explained its operations in difcharging the debt, and proved how much they are im- peded by nis method of borrowing in the three per cents.\ I have no wiih to do in- juflice to Mr. Fht\ meafures, or in the leaft degree to diminilh thofe wimortal honours^ which he has acquired by his adminiftration; but I muil acknowledge, whatever may be the opinion of his adherents, that I have yet to be convinced that this meafure deferves * Fa^ls, Sea. V. f lb. p. 37. X lb. Appejnd. p. 47. § See Not. f , page 19. ho^ ( 3S ) honour. Though the principle is old, the provifion, when applied to the national debt, is, I believe, the work of the prefent Chan- celloi^f the Exchequer, and by this provil'on he has certainly fo far made the finkirg fund his oivn. But it was the glory of Dr. Price^s finking fund to be founded upon a fyftcm of peace, by applying the favings derived from. the lapfe of the temporary annuities, and from an ceconomical expenditure of the pub- lic money, to the real extinction of the debt. In afiirting his plans by additional taxes he meant to infpire the nation with confidence, from the vigour with which they operated at their outfet. By thus infpiring confidence, at a period when it was moft wanted, he hoped to fecure a continuance of thofe peaceful ex- ertions, in order effecftually to deliver the kingdom from its incumbrances and its dan- gers. On the contrary, Mr. Pitt's finking fund is founded upon a fyftem of war. In- flead of reducing, it feems calculated only with greater facility, to increafe the national debt. Additional taxes are annually laid, not for the falutary purpofe of giving vigour to the plan by accelerating its operations at the outfet, but for the pernicious purpofe of giv- ing vigour to new loans, and of leading the nation to fuppofe that the fafler its debts are accumulating, the fooner they will be extin- guilhed. The greater amount of the fums appropriated to fuch a finking fund, only proves the growing incumbrances of the na- F tion i ( 36 ) tion ; fo that when it is boafted that Mr. Pitt has already made an addition to his fink- ing fund of 770,000/. /^r ann. the public in this triumph have to regret, that within the lafl: three years the capital of the funded debt has been increafedy^i'^«/y-y^T;^« millions. II the prcfent expenditure continues, neither the minifterial exultation nor the public re- gret are likely to be lefTened, until the evil, which grows one hundred times fafler than the remedy, Ihall have acquired that force which no .delufion can withftand, and at laft overwhelm both the lender and the borrower in one common ruin. Such are the operations of Mr. P///*s fink- ing fund, nor fhall I conteil with him for the honour of its invention. I feel but little fatis- fadion in contemplating its eflPefts, or behold- ing the fleady perfeverance with which it is carried into execution. If the national debt is to be difcharged by the afliftance of fuch a plan, I am certain that the purpofe will be ef- teded by a much more fummary procefs, than the tedious accumulations of compound intereih 1 cannot conclude this Section without no- ticing the many wretched inlinuations with which the minifterial writers are continually endeavouring to deface the memory of Dr. Price. In themfelves they are utterly con- temptible ; but when proceeding from the ad- herents of Mr. Pitty they certainly do very little honour to bis adminiltration. He fhould q re- ( 37 ) iecolIe57? 405»57^ Nett produce of the taxes impofed in the laft three years — 2,422,783 Whole produce of the permanent revenue — — — 15,48?, 310 Deficirncy — — — — — — . — 1,492,690 16,974,000 If to this fum be added the annual defi- ciency in the land and malt tax, amounting to 250,000/. the intereft paid to the Bank for ca(h advanced (which in Chrillmas lafl ex- ceeded eleven millions), the intereft paid on the unfunded navy debt, &c. &c. I think the computation will be very moderate which makes the difference between the expenditure and the income to be no more than two mil- lions. But it will appear from the following statement that this is by no means likely to be the whole deficiency. PR'E- ( 4« ) (9 ao O O o »^ o c o »- oo O 0_ P NO (Too r^NC o o "^ o o - o o_ »^ o o O "^ O Q i 1 1-2 1 II I J I. ^ 5 £ „ ~3 "-5 c > J^ o S " E £■£ ^-= a. u > i ■ c I. >, ' g « rt > n V ^ «: ?• c j; •_ -^ c ^ "^ ^ i2 " "^ S "*" tj y fe ■ -3 ^ -r *^rr o •■ S -^' g 1= +-+ •^ 5 ^ O" : 3 rt .. C CI "a _„ « ° 5-! W -T3 ^ »- = Ji s^ g o S o Ji h e Si ii ii <« ii . p «t ^ 4< « o ~~_ '^ 4; -f: -T3 s 3 7- ^ ^ .2 „ c " " ^ .ti « r: ?! r; o "^ 4* ° '^ ■^ "^^"^ E "a E ^ = 1 1 ^ ^ c 5 : S:g «^ 1^ "2 c-:2 < SO < o w OS O vr, O O - - o o f^ ■^ o o «^ iC cT »?i 00 N o t^ LOiO ro « ^ O p v2 "I Ie'^^.s o c -"^ S t! o •- •£ ^ " .£ " -3 vl^ «3 >> ** g y oo «j fco *5 to c o g -a •;^ n J c^ !o £ S .S « -a *? 2 t -g d ^ ^ " V- a. o ■— S "O j> o :j) t»> "^ In — 4 0< rt > C S — L= O. rt = O ^"^ = 8 '^ ■z E Z " '^ ^ ^ -r. 2 rt :e -s ns c 1= j: " K. *: " y - _c ^• _ — N V Ov O F. .^ a. 2 §-w. .E 3 "^ .3 -^ ^ o -a *J -3 '-• •— o 4> C ■ *^ "5 "3. c £.£ -2 S S g« E-o. ^2 3 ( 42 ) If to this deficiency of 2,661,948/. be added the fiim of 200,000/. which has been annually voted for the finking fund, and alfo the intereft ufually paid to the Bank for the funis which are C(;nllantly advanced by them on the credit of the land and malt tax, and on other fecurities, the expenditure, fuppofing the war even to terminate with the prefent campaign, will exceed the revenue on the ordinary peace ellablilliment by the fum of three millions nearly. But this is not the whole of the evil which is to be apprehended. Should the taxes fall in the fam.e proportion at the clofe of this war> as they fell at the clofe of the j^mcrican war, the deficiency will be augmented by the further fum of 2,890,000/.* Suppofing it, however, to be augmented by only half this fum, ftill it will be neceffary to impofe new taxes to the amount of more than four millions and a half, in order to place the revenue in the fame fitu- * During the American wra-, the expenditure in any one year never exceeded the fum of 2.i,690,ooo/.§ nor the perma- nent taxes the fum of io,i78,oo/.t At the clofe of that war, the revenue, exclufive of the deficiency in the land and malt tax, fell fliort 1,318,800/4' In the prefent war, the expendi- ture of the jaft year appears to have been 31,181,000/. and the amount of the permanent taxes 15,4.81,000/. If the re- venue therefore be duninifhed at the clofe of this war in pro- portion to the excefs of the expenditure, and alfo to the excefs of the permanent taxes above what they were in the American war, the deficiency will be found to amount to 2,890,000/. nearly^ § Dr. Price's Sratc of the Public Debts in 17S3. Sedl. 3. page 13. + Dr. FnVf's Poftfcript to the above pamphlet, page 10. ♦ Ibid, ation. ( 43 ) ation, with regard to the expenditure, as It was before the commencement of the war. — ■ With this profped: before us, and at the very moment when an application is made for a third loan within fourteen months, which completes an addition to the public debts of forty-three millions and a half, we are alTured that *' we fhall go out of this war in a better '* ftate than we went into it.'* It is undoubt- edly very wrong, and I can honeRly fay the farthefb from my intentions, either to alarm the nation, or to increafe the pride and info- lence of the enemy by aggravating the ac- count of our finances. But is it lefs dan- gerous or lefs criminal to purfue the contrary courfe ? — To allure the nation into a fyflem of perpetual expence by prefenting falfe views of its profperity — and to divert its attention from the precipice towards which it is im- pelled, by pointing out the gulph into which its enemies are plunging ? SEC- ( 44 ) SECTION VI. On the general State of the Nation, TF the aflertions of the miniflerial writers be •*■ well founded, we have very little reafon to regret the addition of one hundred millions to the debt, or the growing preffure of the public burdens. '* The progrefs of national im- '* provement has continued without interrup- *' tion— The foundations of general credit •* have remained unfliaken.— The taxes are ** produd:ive.— Trade increafes. — Buildings ** multiply. *r — And the mafs of national pro- *' perty accumulates to fuch a degree, as to ** dillinguilh the prefent war above the moll *' flourilhing years of peace •" fo that we are almoft led to with it may be continued merely for the fake of promoting the welfare and happinefs of the country. But are they feri-, ous in all this idle declamation and triumph ? Is it poliible that they fhould gravely repre* fent the revenue to be productive, when the amount of the old ta^es has decreafed, within t I fuppofe bqrracks ^re inclu^led in the number. the ( 45 ) the fliort term of three years, * above one mil- lion and a quarter, and when it is even con- flantly becoming more deficient in proportion as new taxes are impofed, and the public dif- trefs is aggravated by the continuance of the war ? With equal reafon is the nation congratu- lated at this time on the improving ftate of its commerce, when the trade of the country is known to have diminiflied fo dreadfully as to oblige thoufands of its manufacturers, tor want of employ, to enter into the army and navy, in order to preferve themfelves from llarving. Much flrefs has been laid on the in- creafed amount of the exports and imports during the war. But furely very little can be inferred in fuch a feafon from this circum- l1:ance. Nay, the flightelf attention muil con- vince us that it is merely artificial, and has arifen principally from the war itfelf. The cloathing and provilions for our fleets and armies. — The naval flores imported. — The millions of gold coin, and the other fupplies which have been exported for our fubiidized Allies on the Continent, will eafily account for any increafe of this kind, and, fo far £• * In the year 1792 the produce of the per- manent taxes was - - 14,354,000 In the year 1795 the produce of the fame taxes wa. . ... 13,0-8,527 Difference » 1,295,473 G -41. from ( 46 ) from being beneficial, prove it to' be highly injurious to the welfare ot the country. * In the year 1788, when we were reprelented to be at the height of our profperity, the exports and imports amounted only to ^6,151,000/. while the cuftoms produced 3,767,000/. In the year 1795, the exports and imports are flated to amount to 49,447,000/. and thofe very cuftoms have produced only 3,247,000/. fo that the one is increafed above ibirUen mil- lions^ while the other is dimimjhed 520,000/. / Leaving thefe contradictions to be reconciled by thole who are mjore interefted than myfelf in deceiving the nation, I fhall even admit the annual average of the exports, during the lall three years to be, according to the moft exag- gerated ftatements, 24,800,000/. and the an- nual average of the imports to be 21 ,200,000 /. fo that the whole may amount to forty-fix millions. Suppofing now, againll all com- mon fenfe and probability, that the imports and exports are equally advantageous to the country, and that a profit is made upon each o^ ^ity per cenL In this cafe, which is ex- travagant in the higheft degree, the profits of all our foreign trade will amount to- twenty- * The fiidden increafe of the exports from 20,394,180/. in 1793, 1026,748,083/. in 1794, and 1027,270,000/. in 179J, fiiihciently ])roves it to have arifeu from the war; and this is further contirmed by the circumftance of thofe exports having increafed principally, in the laft two years, to Germany, while tliey have even decreafed to Portugal, Spain, the btreights, TurKey, the Briuili Continental Colonies^ and the Britiih Weft indies. 2 three ( 47 ) three millions. — And yet even thefe profits, when compared with the fums to be in future raifed by taxes,* will be no more than fuffi- cient to pay the ordinary cxpences of a peace eftablidiment in this kingdom. If it could be proved that national property increafes in proportion as taxes multiply, what encouragement might not be derived trom the profpedf before us ? The adherents of adminif- tration might then triumph with good reafon in our growing profperity, and war be jufl:ly reprefented as more beneficial to a country than the mofi; fiourilhing years of peace. But it has hitherto been found from experience, that the addition of every new tax is fo lar a diminution of the general mafs of wealth, and inftead of increanng the property, that it al- ways aggravates the didrefs oi a country. In Great Britain, particularly, every perlbn in the leail acquainted with its prcfent, compared with its former flate, muit be convinced of this fad:. In confequence of increaied taxa- tion provifions necellarily become dearer, and in this kingdom they have rifen fo m.uch higher in proportion tiian the price ot labour, as to render it impoffible for the poor at pre- fent to maintain themfclves and families by their wages. This has produced a growing diffrefs among them, and notv.'ithibmding their number is diminilhing, the poor-rates at this moment are four times greater than they * See page 4 1 . were ( 48 ) were at the Revolution. Whatever appear- ance of fplendor, therefore, the Capital may difplay, the great bulk of the nation is dread- fully impoverilhed ; and every new war, by increafing the difference between the articles and the means of fubfiftence, aggravates this evil in difcouraging marriage or promoting emigration, and in either cafe accelerating a depopulation which has been gradually going on for the lafi: century. Were an opinion to be formed of the na- tional profperity from a few inftances of over- grown merchants and capitalifts in the prin- cipal towns, we might perhaps be led to con- clude, that at no former time had it ever . attained its prcient height. But this is a ■wretched deluiion. The commerce, like the agriculture of the country, is continually en- grolTed into fewer hands, and we are haften- ing into that flate which knows only of two claffes of men— the very rich, and the very poor. By drawing the capital into one point, which was accuftomed to diverge a thoufand ways and afford fubfiflence for as many fa- milies of moderate fortune, the effed; in that point is certainly more fplendid in appearance, but in reality it is much more injurious to the public. It is alfo a melancholy truth that from the enormous magnitude of the national debt, a great part of the traffic confifts of fpecula- tions in the funds;— a traffic productive of no good to the community, which, by con- vertmg commerce into a lyffem of gambling, changes ( 49 ) cliangcs the merchant into a capitalifl, who employs his money, not in enriching his country by laudable enterprize and induftry, but in adding to its diftrefs by trading in loans and contradis. To the other evils which have been occa- fioned by the prefent war, mufl be added the very fevere fhock which it has given to the commercial credit of the country. So enor- mous have been the expences — fo far have they furpafTed all the eftimates of the Miniller, and all the provifions which have been made for them by Parliament, that, excluiive of the ar- rears in the army, the navy, the ordnance, and every other department, to the amount of many millions, * recourfe has been had to the paper credit of the Bank, to fuch an unprece- dented deo^ree, as to oblige the Dire«5tors to reduce and almoft entirely to defifl from their ufual difcounts in fupport of the trade of the country. This fingle circumftance produced a fcarcity of cafh and a diftrefs in all mercin- tile negociations which threatened the whole nation with the woril confequences, and a fe- * In a pamphlet which is ftated to be the fubftance of Lord Auckland^ fpeech in the Houfe of Lords, on the 2d of May, it is gravely aflerted, that there were at that time neither "out- ftanding debts and demands," nor " floating and unfunded debt" of any kind; although, in the fame pamphlet, it is al- lowed that the unprovided Navy debt was 2,300,000/. and th,it the balance due to the Bank, including five millions propofed to be funded, amounted to more than eleven millions: but as it is highly improbable that Lord Auckland fliould himfelf have written fuch a book, I do not wiih to hurt his feelings hy noticing it as bis publication, cond ( 50 ) cond loan, amounting to fcven millions and a half, became necefTaiy within three months of another loan ot eighteen millions, in order to dilcharge the arrears at the Bank, and to en- able them, by recurring to their former dif- counts, in fome meafure to reftore the totter- ing foundations of commercial credit. If, however, the expenditure continues as it has begun in this year, the evil will return, and the remedy mufl: foon be repeated. But a credit which is fo often deprelled by the pub- lic exigencies, and which requires the fre- quent repetition of fuch remedies for its fup- port, is not likely to be long able to maintain itfelf, much lefs to afford ground for that mi- nifterial triumph on its ftability which has of late been difplayed with fo little regard to truth or decencv. It mufl:, no doubt, afford great confolation, in the midil of the dangers and diflrefs to which we are expofed from accumulating debts and taxes, to be informed, that by abo- lifliing one hundred and forty-four offices in the Treafury, and fubftituting threefcore others in their flead,* a faving has been pro- duced which (if the grant had not been ante- dated three years) would have been rather more than fufficient to pay Mr. Burke's laji penfion. Let it, however, be remembered, that the merit even of this oeconomy is un- * This is dated in the Treafury pamphlet to which I have 5tlready alluded in the prefeut work.— See note, p. 1 9. juftly { 51 ) jufrly afcribed to the prefent minlilry ; for the abolition of the offices was for the moft part effedled by the Marquis of hanfdown in the year 1782, and the principal fhare which they appear to have had in the alterations, has been to fubilitute other offices in lieu of them, and by this means to reduce a faving of 10,900/. to the very moderate fum of 2,700/. a year. With equal truth and juftice are the offices fuppreffied under the civil lift attri- buted to their care and management, rather than to the well-known operations of Mr. Burke*s, bill. But while fo much zeal is dif- played in recounting the offices which have been fuppreffed, it would not have been amils at the lame time to have added to the cata- logue the numerous and very expenfive places which have alfo been created by the prefent adminiflration.* Had this been done, it would * In this catalogue may be included the following places: Board ff Comptrol^ for" the management of the affairs of the Eaft Indies; confifting of a Prefideut and two Commiilioners, who receive 5000/. a Secretary, who receives 1000/. per ann, — Under Secretary — Counfel — Solicitor — Affiftant Solicitor — Chief Clerk— twelve other Clerks — Precis Writer — Ailiftant ditto — Accomptant — four jVIedengers — Houfekeeper — and Chamber-keeper; the emoluments of whofe appointments are not acc"urately knowm. Third Secretary of State^ with an Under Secretary, Chief Clerk, Clerks, Office-keepers, IMelTengers, &c. 'Tranfpcrt Board, confifting of five Commiifioners, who re- ceive 1000/. a year each. Secretary, two Clerks, fix Alliftant Clerks, Office-keeper, Houfe-keeper, two Meffengers, and a Porter, whofe emoluinents are not known. H Bai' ( 5^ ) would have been found that their plan or ceconomy has much the ikme tendency to re- lieve the n.ition of its burdens, as the Chan-^ cellor of the Exchequer's finking fund has to pay off the pubHc debts, which are annually increafing one hundred times failer than they are difchargcd. — But it is needlefs to expatiate On a fubject fo unprofitable. If ,the favings and frugality of Minifters are the only auxi- liaries we can call to our aid, it may well be fcud that our fituation is forlorn and defperate. The prefent is indeed a momentous period; and all the abilities and virtue of the nation are neceflary to extricate us from our diffi- culties. But while millions are added an* Barrack EJiahliJJpnent^ by which are created feventy-five places from 70/. to 700/. per ann. Foreign Minijlers, liich as, a Mmifter to the Swifs Cantons, five or fix Secretaries of Legation, &c. In the Exctfc, a Chairman and DeputyS Chairman - I with additional fala- In the Cujiomsy a Chairman and Deputy j ries. Chainnan • - J In the Foft Office^ a Comptroller and Surveyor General, TravelHng Surveyor, Deputy Clerks, &:c. &c. In the Secretary of State's Office, many additional appoint- ments of Clerks, &c. and the falariet. of the Under Secreta- ries are advanced 500/. a year each. In Scotland^ additional falaries have been given to the Judges and Sheriffs. To thefe may be added the New Boards of Agriculture* and Is'aval Architecture; the Telegraph appointments — the addi- tional places in every department of the revenue, in confe- quence of the new taxes vvhicii have lately been impofed, to- getlier with an immenfe multitude of other offices which my con- fined knowledge prevents me from enumerating. * The Secretary and onder Sccr .tary to this board rcetive a falary. TJ>c commjffionei s I believe for the moll part officiate grntuitcnnj'. 2 mial Ijr ( 53 ) nually to the public burdens, while every new campaign, diftinguifhed principally for the enormity of its expence and the length- ened profped: of the war, deflroys every hope of checking the evil in its progrefs, it will be in vain to attempt our relief. With an ordinary peace eftablilhment, already equal to the rental of all the landed property, and even exceeding the profits of the whole foreign trade of the kingdom, if the nation fliould continue to acquiefce in that fyftem of pro- fuiion, which at prefent exhaufts our re- fources with fuch tremendous rapidity, I do not believe that any effort of virtue or ability will be fufficient to fave us from ruin. FINIS. imiwuwHuii liwywHH