THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LIBRARY ^875 v5j W''^ ^i'-V'"' msm^^ BANKING. REASONS IN SUPPORT OF A RILL, FOR RENDERING COUNTRY BANKERS' CIRCULATION INVARIABLE, AND CONVERTIBLE INTO A METALLIC CURRENCY, AXD dfor (©rantms %mntt^ to (JtfiartertDi 9SanRi5* MOST RESPECTFULLY ADDRESSED TO THE RIGHT HON. LORD ALTHORP, CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER, AND CHAIRMAN OF THE SECRET COMMITTEE, APPOINTED BY THE HOUSE OF COMMONS IN SESSION 1832, " To Inquire into the Expediency of Renewing the Charter of tlie Bank of England, and to Enquire into tlie " System on which Banks of Issue in England and Wales are conducted." By WILLIAM BROWNE, Esq. TO WHICH ARE ADDED, TABLES, THE ADVANTAGE WHICH THE BANK OF ENGLAND ENJOYED OVliR COUNTRY BANKRRS ON THE SCORE OF DUTY;— THE LOSS SUSTAINED BY THE REVENUE ON SEVEN TEARS' BANK OF ENGLAND CIRCULATION : THE BANK MODE OF COMPUTING THE DUTY ; A COMPARI.SON AND RESULT OF WITHDRAWING THE SMALL NOTES, .\XD THE EFFECT OF THE COMPOSITION ACT, 9 GEO. IV. CAP 23, FOR FOUR YEA US PRIOR TO AND FOLLOWING THE PANIC OF 1 82o ; ■"HE PROPORTION THE SMALL NOTES BORE TO THE LARGE, and Till: DUTY LOST THEREBY; AND '^ Balnttcc S^htet ot the iSattit of Cnglnn^ PUBLISHED AUG. 10, 1832. LONDON : ] HATCHETT AND SON, PICCADILLY; F. WILSON AND J. CHAPPEL, ROYAL EXCHANGE; J. R. KENNETT, GREAT QUEEN-STREET, LINCOLN'S INN FIELDS. Printed by Joseph Roger ton, I'J, Old Botwell Cotirf, i i 1832. »t " Every syllable issued by the Governoi- of the Bank is a direct appeal to the people of England, " against the continance of the Bank Charter, for a Single Day ! The Public Safety must not be *' lost sight of, for the claims of any class of individuals. We ask, ought twenty-four Merchants, (we '* believe the Secret Committee of the Bank does not exceed three,) to possess the power of raising or " depressing prices ; of extending or contracting Private Credit; o{ driving gold from England; or " forcing it suddenly back again ; of advancing t© the King's Ministers what sum they please ; of " managing the business of the Bank, upon the ' Principles of a Politcal Concern V We affirm, that " no power so awful, was ever before lodged in the hands of any Corporation, that has yet existed in " in a Free Country ?"-^Times. TO THE RIGHT HON. LORD ALTHORP, CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER, AND CHAIRMAN OF THE SECRET COMMITTIE TO ENQUIRE INTO THE EXPEDIENCY OF RENEWING THE CHARTER OF THE BANK OF ENGLAND, &C. &C. My Lord, Having had the honour to suhmit to the Lords of the Treasury, " A Plan for the Regulation of Country Bank- ers," but more especially the mode by wliich the extent of the Paper Circulation of the United Kingdom, could be accurately and speedily ascertained, (which suggestions have partially been incorporated in the Act of the 9 Geo. 4, cap. 23, which enables Bankers to compound i'or stamps,) I am encouraged to address your Lordship, and most respectfully to submit to the consideration of His Majesty's JNIinisters, the following reasons for estaV lishing a New Currency, by yrhich the Bank Note circu- lation might be placed on an invariable and solid basis, and immediately convertible into a JNIetaDic Currency] at least, during such a period, that no restriction be imposed on the Bank of England. My plan will also combine the means of/ enabling the Lords of the Treasury to ascertain the extent of the Bank Note circulation of the United Kingdom,j(distinguishing the circulation of Ireland and Scotland, from that of England), at anytime when required, within the short space of 10 or It days. Tliis will afford a protection to the lower classes against severe loss to which tliey are exposed, and who have no possible means of guarding themselves against loss, or the option of refu- sal. It will be tlie means of restoring confidenceto the agri- cultural, manufacturing, and commercial districts; it will facilitate tlie means of collecting the taxes, and of increas- ing the Revenue, to an amount, 1 will not here venture to state, and which miglit be improved in proportion to the increased circul.ition, independent of collateral advan- tages, such as duty on paj)er, postages, &c. &c., besides securing to the aid of Government, the resources of the country, in case of war, or any other emergency. It would be presumptuous in any individual to intrude on your Lordshii), tlieories not founded in practical expe- rience. The principle on which I have framed the measures I have now the honor to propose, is, — the establisliment of Chartered Banks, which have been recognised by tlie most eminent financiers and statesmen of modern tinms and have, in some degree, been tried, and proved of vita' importance and advantage to tin? agricultural, ninnufac turing, and trading interests of Scotland, where no com . plaint of distress is heard, whilst England is over/ whelmed. j It is admitted that the Country Banking System forffis a most imi>ortant and essential ])art of commercial econo- my, and that it has been the jnedium of very extensive pecuniary transactions throughout the country, on which depended the. prosperity of the state ; and without which, the public revenue could not have been collected, as I am prepared to shew from accjuired experience as late Deputy Receiver-General ft)r Somersetsliire ; which appointtnent I held for ;"> years prior to the close of the late war, and b 3-ears subsequent thereto. During that period I collected and paid into the Exchequer upwards of £2,447,000, and without tlie co-operation of country bankers it could not have been collected, or the quarterly payments ma.^. regularly into the Exchequer, either during the war ... since. I cannot elucidate the advantages of the measure now proposed, without alludins^ to some of the causes which led to the withdrawal of the small Notes from circulation, in April, 1829, instead of deferring that measure, as origi- nally intended, until 1833,— which was no doubt accele- rated by the exclusive privilege and monopoly of the Bank of England. The irresponsibility of the Directors of this establish- ment for their conduct, and non-liability to any control- ing power, proves a serious evil, inasmuch, as under any circumstances of public distress, real or artificial, tlie Directors uniformly work it to the advantage of the Bank of England Company, and to the injury of tli public ; for instance, during the Panic in December, 182.5, Bank Stock, shortly before, had been as high as 233 per cent. ; on the day when Sir Peter Pole and Co.'s house suspended payment, it was banged down below 200 per cent., and so remained some time reduced in price, hut not in value, during which large sales were eflected, occasioned by tlie unavoidable distress brought upon Country Bankers by their measures. To these uncontrolled jiroceedings must be attributed the greatest part, if not the whole of the distress, biink- ruptcv, and ruin, brouglit on die country, from which (as the numerous jietitions to the Legislature manifestly proves) it lias never recovered. JMany of tlie most resi>ectnble and wealthy Banking- houses, during Uiis j>aiiic, were driven to the Ga- zette. I believe 177 were reported in Parliament to have suspended papieiit, (which must necessarily have occasioned great I'.efalcation in the public re- Wenue;) of this number, few have paid less than /17s. r.d. in the pound, many 209., and a considerible 'number resumed their busmess, whilst some have paid oft and wound up their ra,... >mii, aS-the reduc.-d luiinber ot annual licenses shows. So .nironglv did the conduct ot the Bank Directors openite on the minds of Country r,ank.TS, that tliev av now living in dremi of the tepe- tition of these disastrous rc^sults, wh.-never it may suit li.e interest of these P.ank Directors to r-sort to it. uli.er.H, in self-defence, are compelled to act with the utmost cir- cumspection, c...isc.,uentfy to limit their letelv, and, if adopted by His JIajesty's Government, I pledge my veracity to ascertain most aocu- ratelv the Country Bank circulation ; in no other way than that which I have proposed, can the extent of the Bank Note circulation of England, Irehmd, and Scotland, be correctly ascertained. The amount of capital which I propose to be raised by the Chartered Banks in England and Wales, allowing one for each county, with collateral branches established in populous districts and cities, I estimate at 6 millions ; that sum is considered a sufficient capital, being about 10 per cent on the real property, as assessed under Schedule A, in 181.5. Each county, it is presumed, would sub- scribe its respective quotas on that scale. The total amount of which was £52,000,000. This 10 per cent, would amount to £5,200,000 To which I would add for extra capital viz. Bristol, Manchester, and JNIanuiacturing Counties 800,000 IMaking £6,000,000 as appears detailed in Schedule A, annexed to the pro- posed Bill. The Chancellor of the Exchequer, at the time before referred to, (3rd .Tune, 1828) estimated the Country circu- lation at £15,400,000: this included 2,400,000 small Notes. Supposing 10 per cent to be subscribed on the esti- mated value of the real estates in England and Wales, say £5,200,000, and allowing each Chartered Bank to issue paper for three times more tlian the subscribed capital, it would produce a circulating currenc}'' of £15,600,000 ; and this may be considered a fair ratio to estimate tlie amount required, to which I would add, for the extra capital of £800,000, which by 3 would give, say £2,400,000, making together 18 millions. I estimate £6,000,000 more will be added to the circu- lating medium, being the amount of deposits to which extent Notes might be issued. This would make £24,000,000 to the i/.sc of the Manvfiictttret; Afiriculturht , tind Trtuler, and I think this would be equal to the sum required to carry on the operations of the country as re- gards Local Hank Paper. I reckon, of tliis sum, the JJankers would employ i or 5-8ths in Bank Chartered Excheriuer Bills, (to be created) say 12 millions for (£ ), I propose should be required to be vested in Government Security, which should ncvtT fluctuate in real value, the (jovernment being always bound to pay tlie amount originally received, viz. at par., and for all taxes and revenue of every description ; after a given date, these Bills might be paid to, and received bv Receivers or Collectors of Excise or Customs, and lleceiver-Gcne- ral of Taxes. The Bank Chartered Exchequer Bills to bear an inter- est of lit' reasons the repeal of the 9 Geo. IV, c. 23, and allow lliaikers to pay as formerly : but pass an Act to ascertain the extent of the Country Bank Note circulation. I also beg to refer to the evidence taken by the Com- mittee of Secrecy, in .March, 1797, as aftbrding ample jiroof, particularly that of William Boyd, Esq., p. 'ib and ?)9. And also to tin- Resolutions of a Committee of Merchants on the suhjict of discounts, in the ajipendix, p. 115. Also to tl)f lu'ports printed by order of the House of Commons in lii-'6. A certain portion of the intended capital it is proposed shall be invested in Govi'rnment Securities for tlie benefit of the Public, not to be alienated. The amount vested in L.vchequer Bills would enable Government to be- less dependent on the Bank of Eng- land, and thus create a controuliog influence which they do not now possess. The Bank might be ctuJipcTfrrHo-nfeftto- the inforust on the Debt owing by Govorniiient, from 3 per cent, to 'l\ per cent., and thus stive upwards uf £73,000 per annum, and save also £;',.'< >,(iOO i>er annum for management, wliicli the i\ew Bank >vould do gratuitously. It would bring aboii^ 52 Chartered Country I'anWs to the aid of Government, to who-n it mitjht look for sup- port in case of need, iiu-ad of (as in Mr- !'»" s time) to only one Chartered Bink. It will identify the National Currency willi the na- tional credit, as Govemmeat will, to a certain eiunt. t>« their Jebtors. It %v...il.l, in ca.se of w«r, place the means and rri^urrr.. of the country at the service, and under the protection o! Ciovernnuriit. It will give the Ministers periodically a knowlcdfe ol the state of the afl^airs of the (han.red Banks, or, on an emergency, similar to tlnit occasioned by the Uank <.i \ 6 England in February, 1797, the Goverment could with safety, extend protection to a/i, without exclusion — with- out risk —the benefits would alike extend to the whole commercial establishments of the United Kingdom, while it would unite the Government, the landed and monied interest, in one indissoluble bond, and in war, defeat the expectations of an invading- army. The plan I propose for adoption will prevent another Restriction Act from becoming necessary, by the confi- dence placed in Chartered Banks, which otherwise must inevitably be the case if the present system of Bank mo- nopoly is allowed to exist, and Branch Banks, as now con- stituted, are not suppressed ; for if the Bank of England should be called on to pay specie, small notes must again be resorted to, and the tragedies of 1793, 1797, 1804, 1810, 1816, and 1825-26, will be, to a certain extent, re- acted ; for the Directors of the Bank of England will never be satisfied until they are in possession of the whole circu- lation of the country. It will prevent large quantities of gold from being hoarded, which is the invariable effect of panic ; to this was attributed the drain on Country Banks in 1797, and the subsequent years above stated^'and consequently and ultimately on the Bank of England. The proposed mea- sure will operate advantageously on subscribers to the Chartered Banks, particularly on merchants in maritime districts, who will instruct their captains and agents to bring bullion to the country, seeing it is an article of mer- chandise ; that it can be used as a deposit and valued upon immediately. Merchants will import, when the Bank of England will not ; it will thus prove a feeder to the Bank, as the Customs, Excise and Taxes, will, more or less, be paid in the precious metals. The Merchant will not depend on the Bank of England for discount; it will prevent alarm and distrust, and induce timid persons to hold notes, instead of converting them into gold. It will compel the Bank of England to pursue a diffe- rent line in conducting their fiiture business from that adopted since 1795, particularly as to the quantity of dis- counts, as the many Chartered Banks will afford facilities for discount, and give a circulating medium adequate to any increase in price of corn and cattle, or other mer- chandize. The Merchant and Manufacturers might always rely for accommodation by discount, as the value of a certain portion of the Export and Import trade require, which is both reasonable and necessary, and this may be afforded without risk. As to the proposed Chartered Bank Exchequer Bills, they should be made payable to order or in blank, as at pre- sent, but in case of alarm and distrust by an Order in Council, they, on emergency, (of which the Government would be the sole judges) should be ordered to be circu- lated, to supply the place of withdrawn Chartered Bank Notes. After a while, the principle of Banking, and operations of trade, would gradually restore the Note cir- culation, and Chartered Exchequer Bills would find their way to the Bank again. _ Should small Notes oe lound Hereafter to be expedient and necessary. Government might guarantee the value by a stamp impression on the face of each Note, being in- demnified by deposit of Chartered Exchequer Bills. Provision should be made for a Chartered Banking Company in London, to transact the business of the Coun- try Banks, as it would be desirable that the specie which would be useless in the Country Banks, should be de- posited in the London Bank ; a large quantity of super- fluous specie would be collected by these means, and which should be returned if netessity required it. The frauds by Fauntleroy, — the constant mis-applica- tion of partnership funds by ,private partners, — against which the laws afford no protection, suggests that it would be imsafe to be without such a constituted Bank in Lon- don. The last London Bankeifi who failed, Messrs. Fry's and Chapman, were debtors to the Public upwards of £400,000 ; they were £130,000 minus to the Bank credi- tors, although each partner professed he had a surplus private estate. Three Country Bankers are reported to have proved £170,000 on their estate, vis. one for £90,000, another for £45,000/, and a third for £35,000. liemming- ham, Stephenson and Co., the month after f\iiled for £425,000 ; and, as reported, the London Life Assurance Company suffered to the extent of £39,000 stock, and £12,000 cash balance. The private deficiencies of Ste- phenson were immense. The failures of these two Banks affected 47 other Country Banks, who kept cash accounts with them, and sustained heavy losses. And the recent failure of Sir T. Duckworth, Sir J. Moreland, and Co.'s Bank, affords lulditional reasons for Legislative interference. The stoppage of six or seven London Banking Houses by the Bank of England, and which produced the panic through the country in December, 1825-26, caused the suspension of payment of 177 Banks ; thus upwards of 220 houses were involved in the short space of three years. The Scotch and Irish Chartered Banks are evidence of the utility of Joint Stock Companies. And by a recent report of the 2d Annual Meeting of the Huddersfield Banking Company, it appears the capital is £100,000, and the subscribed capital £50,000 and they divided 6 per cent. The Commercial Bank of Scotland, established in 1810, subscribed a capital of £600,000, and they have divided from six to eight per cent. ; its stock is at 50 per cent, pre- mium, and its capital is accumulating by a reserved fund. ^The Bank of Scotland and Royal Bank Stock, the Capital is £1,500,000, bears from 90 to 140 per cent, premium. The British Linen Company commenced with £100,000, by its profits accumulating, or further subscription, the capital doubled ; it has now a reserved fund amounting to £300,000. It has a charter, and £1,500,000 capital, and bears a premium of 200 per cent. In Ireland, the Provincial Irish Bank derived much benefit from private Banks, at starting many of them ap- plied for agencies, the capital subscribed was £2,000,000, viz., 20,000 shares of £100 each, and the Government showed every readiness to co-operate in the measure. The capital paid in, amounts to £500,000. The Bank of Ireland was established in 1783, with a capital of £600,000, four per cent, stock. In 1804, its capital was £1,500,000; it has since added considerably to its original capital by bonuses. The Bank of England possessed a capital in 1816, of £11,686,800 ; it paid 10 per cent, dividend during the war, and about the 23rd of May, 1816, declared a bonus of 25 per cent., amounting to three millions, which was added to the capital, making it now £14,686,800 ; it divides 8 per cent., and bears a premium of £99 to £lO() per cent., but lately fell to 85 prem. The late Lord Liverpool is reported to have said in the House of Lords, 17th of February, 1826, in reference to the Bank of England Charter and Country Bank Note Acts, " That the present system of Banking Laws in this country was the most absurd that ever was invented ; it was in the teeth of all sound policy and common sense ; there was one or two systems founded upon reason and good policy, which might be adopted by Banks ; let them liave a system of condition or security, so that the public had a chance of being secure. In America one of these systems was acted upon. In INIassachussetts, they had twelve chartered Banks, and no others allowed ; the mo- ment either was unable to pay their notes in specie, it was dis-chartered. The other system was one of entire liability, on which respectable Banks should be established, composed of a number of wealthy individuals, or founded on the principles of Joint Stock Companies. If Chartered Banks were established, tliey would immediatelv absorb the whole circulation of the country, by either of tljese means security would be obtained." The Marquis of Lansdowne is reported also to have expressed his conviction of the necessity of a sound cir- culation ; the convertibility of paper into cash should be immediate, that the check to improper issues of paper might be resorted to without delay. The lesson of the past three years, taught the necessity of placing the entire currency on a broad metallic basis. He approved of the measures of Lord Liverpool, the protection of tlie poor classes should be a primary object. He hoped Banking would be put on a more practical footing. He hoped tlie Bank of England would not resist such alteration in its charter, as without affecting its own rights, would substi- tute a sound and secure system of Uanking, for an un- sound and dangerous one. He bad no doubt on reflection sucli would be tlie policy of the Bank and Parliament, that in any alteration in the Bank charter, it would be enabled to license Chartered Banks through the country, the condition of whose charter of limited respoitsibilitij being the annual publication of their accounts, all persons would tlien have an opportunity of constant examination into the affairs of tlie parties whom they trusted, and the country would have the best system of Banking which commercial secu- rity could desire. The Earl of Lauderdale said he could not find six men, or more, who were ready to embark their whole property with the chance of dividing it to their last shilling, in case of failure. Lords Ellenborough, Bexley, and other Noble Lords, are reported to have concurred in these sentiments, and tlie late Lord Redesdale brought in a Bill, making it felony in a private Banker abstracting the Bank funds toliis own use, and a misdemeaiKirin any clerk assisting therein, but it did not pass the Lords, I'urliament iiaving been prorogued. In conclusion, I can confidently assert, that tlie measures I propose to submit to the consideration of bis iMajesty's JNlinisters, if carried into execution, will, in a sliort time, establish an invariablt '.md convertible Bank note circulation, as far as it is practicable or necessary, of from oO to (>0 millions, and a revenue derivable tlierefrom, of from £.>00,00() to .£iiOO,000 per annum ; a permanent Loan to Government o( V2 millions or upwards ; a gua- rantee to the poor against all losses from failure of Banks, which will be impossilili', while rents and profits will be restored to their natural maximum, and a stimulus will thus be given to tlie energies of every class of the com- munity in the country. Soliciting your Lordship's atten- tion to the annexed TaMcs, I have the honour to remain, mj' Lord, Your Lordship's most obedient Servant, London, } WILLUM BROWNE. . -:» August,1832.i^? /(/^.,^,,r^^.^^^ > /* •'■' ^ — ^ POSTCRIPT. Since the foregoing letter was sent to press, a portion of the evidence taken by the Committee on the Bank of England Charter has been published. In the " Account of Coin and Bullion in the Fossessio7i of the Bank," it ap- pears that on the 24th of Dec. 1825 (the week of the panic) the liabilities of the Bank, including circulation 20 millions, amounted to £32,403,000 — its securities to £35,378,000, of which only £426,000 was in Coin, and £601,000 in Bullion ; and this was nine days after the meeting of the Merchants and Bankers at tiie Mansion House, where it was resolved, " To icith- hold draivin^ on the Bank for Balances, and to paii in all the Gold tiiey could collect." We also find, notwithstand- ing this great efl^ort, that on the 28th Feb. 1826, the Coin in the Bank was only Xn, 043, 000, and its Bullion £1,415,000. Their circulation was #25.000,000 on 26lh Feb. 1826. " Coin" is a term for " .Specie," in whicii only the Bank of England notes could be paid ; Bullion is an article of exportable merchandize, not applicable to the payment of Bank notes, any more than the Country Bankers' acres of land, which on such emer- gency is an unconvertible property, and although worth £100 per acre, would not pay his five pound note when demanded. The " account," referred to above, also proves, that as the Bank securities increased, in the same ratio did its liabilities ; this latter consisted of notes sent into circu- lation, and all vvhich securities for liabilities were pro- ductive of Interest, minus only the interest lost on their Coin and Bullion, wliirli are not " breeding" commodi- ties, clearly demonstrating an rinjustijiable principle of avarice, disgraceful to the character of a Banker. The view taken by the Public Press, being confirmatory of the foregoing statement, I have annexed a few extracts at the end, highly interestincr, particularly to Bankers. W. B. BALANCE SHEET OF THE AFFAIRS OF THE BANK OF ENGLAND. Dr, the Bank of Ent'lnnd. Bank Capital (.£14,686,800) lent to Oovernmcnt. To Bank Circulation, viz. : — Bank Notes anil Post Bills issued ^20.000,000 Balance due to Deposit Account 6,ooii,oo0 .£26,000,000 Ditto due to Public Department? and Pulilic Bodies 1,150,000 Total Debits 27,1.50,000 •Surplus of Profit* (undivided) 2,«50,(iO0 ^£■30,000,000 Contra. Cr. By value of .585.740/. per Annum Pension Annuities expiring 5th April, 1867, at 18J vcars' purchase ... .£1 1 .Ofli'.flOO Exchequer Bills ' 4,000,000 Ditto, issued to cover Deficiencies of Public Revenue 5.oo(l.o00 Bills Discounted l.odo.WiO Loans to Public Companies, Corporations, &c 1,500,000 Mortgages 1, 400.000 Cash and Bullion 6,000,000 Aug. 10, 1832. ^.30 000.000 ANNUAL DIVIDEND OR PROFIT AMOUNT OF THE BANK OF ENGLAND. Payments mai>k nv the Bank. 1. To Dividend Annuallv paid on the Capital Stock, viz. 8/. per cent, on il.OSC.SlKl/ £1.174,000 2. J^alarics, Pension".., Clerks, and House Expi'nces, loss by Koigeries. &o. &c 203,000 3. Composition paid to (."vernment in lieu of Stamp Duty '""W • • w*^* ■ i.4'i;.o(>o Balance, being iUri»u» Annual Profit -"•^'^ .£1,467.000 Reckiits 1. Three per Com. i. ■reived Rnniially from Govern- mentonlheCapiinl iVi,--'- •^""•®"<* 2. Pour per Cent, on elcTen millions invested In Pen- ^^^^ ^^^ sion Annuity • ■ ■ ; 'iii'ooo 3. Interest on tive niiilinns Excliei|OtT unit -„',,«, 4. Ditto ..n I).-nci.n.y Bills • ••;• • ' -^^ 5. Jlonev received from Ocnornmcnt for .Managemeni of thi- Pol)!!"- Bebt *in'iKM> 6. Discount received on BUI* of Kxchange *^-""" 7. Interests on .Mortgages ;,"":, t- Ao'ivm 8. Do. on I,<.Bn. to Public Companies Corpor»tlon.,«cc. 60.000 9. Ditto on lKinn« for short pcri'd* • ' X1.4';7.0 •» 8 An account of the Annual Circulation of Country Bankers in England, and the amount of Duty paid by them for seven years, viz. — from 1819 to 1825, both inclusive; also the Annual Amount of the Bank of England Circulation, and the duty paid by them for the same period, showing the loss Government sustained by the Bank Charter, comparing the Duty compounded for in liea of Stamps, with the Duties paid for Stamps by Country Bankers. Years. Circulation of country bankers, as certaiu'dfrom the returns Notes stamped. 1819 20 21 22 23 24 25 of try £ 4465092 3493901 443S548 4293164 4479448 6274069 8755309 Duty paid at the stamp of- fice by coun- bankers. The duty paid perl 000/. was equal to the following rates. £ s. d, 64754 54238 69252 64124 67303 95267 121976 4 frac Total of 7 years. 36199531 536918 103 12 6 £ s. d. 14 10 15 10 15 12 14 18 6 15 14 3 6 13 18 6 Account ofj the excess of\ \duty paid by| Jcountrybank- |ers, as com- ipared with the Bank of Eng- land. Account of the excess of duty paid on cciuntry cir- culation over that of the Bank of Eng- land. The Bank of England only pay a compo-l sition of 3,500Z. per million, that is 3L 10s. per 1,000/., with six months credit, while the fractions under 500,000/. are not subject to any duty ; yet country bankers pay to the very pound, and before their notes are deli- vered from the Stamp Office. £ 11 12 12 11 11 10 10 13 10 8 79 2 6 £ s. d. 49505 42-221 54085 49423 51900 73901 91967 413002 Theave-") ragefor7 Ul71361 years is J To which add the amount of bankers' licences per annum The Annual Amount of Reve- nue paidby country bankers for the 7 years as above is Duty. Average per lOOOZ. £ s. d. 76702 26000 102702 £ s. d. 14 16 5 10 20 6 N.B. The advantages derived by the re-"^ venue on country bankers' notes and li- | cences on a circulation of only 5171000Z. )■ per annum, beyond what was paid by the j Bank of England for the same amount isj For the 7 years, no less than .£ Average ol excess. Average ex- cess. jf s. d. 11 6 01 Licence to be added. 59000/ per an. 26000/peran. Total excess. 85000/. 85,000 413,000 per annum. Years. Circulation of the Bank of England, from Returns made to Par liament. Annual Duty, paid as com- position is 3,500/. per million, or 70s.per 1000/, and 6 months credit. The duty paid per 1000/. is 3/. 10s. Od Country Bankers would have paid on this circulation at 3/. 10s. Od. per 1000/., the following sums. Supposing the Bank of England to have been charged to the Duty paid by Country Bankers for Stamps, the following would have been the result. The Increase duty at 11/. 6s. Od. Total of Du- ties payable by Country JBankers. 1819 20 21 22 23 24 25 24697000 23692000 19632000 17772000 20500000 18500000 lf£>OOSc»- 143793000 The Average circula- tion of the Bank of England for 7 Years, was 20542000 £ s. d 85750 82250 68250 61250 71750 64750 ■5550S £ S. d. 3 10 3 10 3 10 3 10 3 10 3 10 3 10 £ 86439 82922 68712 62202 71750 64 "750 66500 £ 271667 284304 237547 203044 235750 197487 198075 . d £ 358106 367226 306259 265246 307500 262237 264575 s. d 500500 The Average of annual du ty paid for these 7 years, was 71500/. 503275 1627874 2131149 Deduct for Composition actually paid by the Bank of 1 ,„ England on their Circulation for 7 Years J" ^""'^OO The Loss of Revenue during these 7 Years, as com- pared with the Duties which Country Bankers would have paid, and if chartered Banks are estab- ■ ' ■■ "" — — -s-jg" ' " lished, I estimate they will, hereafter, pay is To which must be added the Annual sum paid by the Country Bankers for their Licences, say 26000/. per Annum for 7 Years J Thus the Government, by the Bank Charter, suffered a Total loss of Revenue for 7 Years, estimated at 1,812,649 The Annual Loss showed by the above scale is. . 232,949/. Ditto. Annual Licences 26,000/. 1,630,649 182,000 The Aggregate Annual Loss to the Revenue is .f 258,949 o K^ A copy of the above Calculations was sent to each Member of the Secret Committee on the Bauk Charter, 23d July, 1832. An Account of the Average Amount of Circulation on a 3-qrs, Calculation, on which the Bank of Kiigland paid Composition in lit u of ^^tanip Duties, from Weekly Keturiis, from 9th April, 18-25, to 5th April, 182H. The amount of C'ompositioii naiii by the Bank of Kngland under 55 Geo. ad, cap. 184, is £3,500 per million. Description of Notes, ave- rage for the Year 1827. Bank Notes Bank Post Bills Bills drawn by the Branch j Banks J Total. . . . Amount of Circula- tion. 19,178,582 8 2,122,405 10 16,530 3 d. 14 iT 2^ 21,317,5is Fraction. Total amount of Composition .\ccording to the rate of Duty paid byCoun try Bankers, as illustrated in the annexed account, the Averaece for 7 ytiirs being 14Z. 16s. Od. per 1000/., it would have amounted to Which occasioned a loss of Revenne on this single year of Duty paid to Revenue. the ■£. s. 66,125 4 7,317 15 56 19 d. 7i 6 '1 73,500 315,491 12 241,991 12 The following results are deduced from the foregoing statements and estimates on a seven years average: — That the Country Bankers' circulation was at that period about one-fourth of that of the Bank of England. That the Country Circulation paid a duty on 5,171,000/. annually of no less than 20/. 6s. per 1,000, amounting to 102,700/. per annum, while the Bank of England, on a circulation of 20,542,000/., paid only 3/. 10s. per 1,000 ; amounting only to 71,500/. per annum, which, according to this estimate, is about 570/. to 575/. for every 100/. paid by the Bank of England, or equal to 5,000/. to 5,700/. for every 1,000/. paid by the Bank. That displacing Country Bankers and substituting Bank of England Branch Banks, was an injudicious monopoly, whereby the Revenue was diminished in proportion to the extent of that measure, by diminishing the circulating medium, at that time so highly productive to the Revenue, while the Bank of England was comparatively unproductive. That the same beneficial results to the Revenue and to the country arising from Country Banking Circulation cannot be secured unless the Legislature extend to England the same advantages which they have afforded to Scotland and Ireland, and that Chartered Banks be established, unlimited in number and restricted in responsibility, with a "well secured one- pound note circulation, and returns made to Government either monthly or quarterly on oath, as may be required. COUNTRY BANK NOTES. Comparison and Results shewing the Loss of Duty by the withdrawal of Small Notes, and the operation of tlie Ac^ of thp 9th Geo. W ., c. ^.S, callt'd the Composition Act. .£ s. d. £ 8. d. In 1822, 23, 24, 25— The amount of duty paid on Notes Stamped was 348,673 3 The total nominal value of notes stamped 1 ___-. _„ (This was preceding the panic of 1825,26, in 1822-23-24-25 was ^ .i.J,»ui,yyu which occasioned, first, the London Ban- kers, and, consequently, the Country Ban- kers, to stop payment.) In 1826, 27, 28, 29— The amount of duty paid was only 113,550 19 4 The total nominal value of notes stamped 1 _ ^,„ „,, iu 1826-27-28-29 was / ».o' /,"/■* " The loss in duty on these four years is. .. . -i'235,122 11 And during this period the amount of notes issued w as less than the four for- mer years by 14,184,916 Aga'nst this loss of Duty, £4,268 12s. Od., is the amount estimated to be receivtil under 9 Geo. IV., c. 23, taking the Duty to he on £1,219,629, at 7s. per cent. ; but as these amounts include A'o/c* ami liill** of Exchange, which are not distinguished iu the account sent to the Stamp Office, and as only 3s. 6d. per cent, is cli:irgeable on Bills of Kxchange, while 7s. is chargeable on Notes, it is impossible to arrive at the actual Duty paid mi e:u-li, or to ascertain what pro- portion, re-issuable Notes bears to the Bills of Exchange. In the next returns to I'arliamcnt, it would be advisable to have this objection removed. X 8. d. Comparison and results — In 1S25, the amount of re-issuable Notes was 8,755,309/., the l iity pa id there- on for one year was ' r?"'. . r. '21 ,«)7fi 19 O For the /e;ur succeeding years, viz., 1826, 27, 28, 29, the amount was 9,617,074/., aud tin Duty paid was 1 13,550 19 4 The Notes issued being only 862,765/. excess on four years, while the Duty was less by 8,425 19 8 Giving the advantage of the whole Duty on Bills of Exchange as above 4,268 3 The Duty on Bankers Notes for four years, viz., 1826, 27, 28, 29, was less productive than the Duty received for 1825, by the sum of. 4,157 16 8 While the Circulating Medium is lessened in this period, as above stated. 14,184,91"/., of which n very considerable portion would have rrniaiiird out, for the use of Tradi-rx, the Bunk of iMitrlaud Direr'ors li.ive now reduced their cir- culation to about 16,000,000/., which during the above-named four years, averaged about iy,o00,000/. 10 n Account shewing tbe different proportion* of Country H-.ink Notes issued iroiu the iitump Office, and circulated in Ens-land as compared with the nominul aggregate amount of Notes Stamped for the Country Bankers' Circula- lation Also the proportions of Duty paid on the different classes of Notes as compared with the aggregate amount of Duty so paid, the whole being for seven years immediately precedmg the panic of 18'2d, 26, viz., from amount of T)uty so p 1819 to lfs'i.5, both inclusive 'Ihe proportion of 1/. and 21 notes stamped for Country Hankers, as compared with the aggregate amount is sued ; also the duty paid thereon. Years. 1S19 1820 1821 1822 1823 182-i 1825 Propor- tion of Notes Stampt. Propor- tion of Duty Paid. 3-7ths. i i 3-7ths. 4-9ths. 5-8ths. 4-7ths. 3-5ths. 2-3rds. 2-3rds. 5-8ths. 5-8ths. 5-8ths. 7-13ths. Notes above ll. & 2Z.,&Duty Paid thereon. Propor- tion of Notes Stampt. Propor- tion of Duty Paid. 4-7ths. i 4-7ths. 5-9ths. :?-8ths. 3-7ths. 2-5ths. l-3rd. l-3rd. 3-8ths. 3-8ths. 3-8ths. 6-13ths, Notes consisting of 1/., 2/., and 5/., and Duty Paid thereon, Propor- tion of Notes Stampt. 7-lOths 3-4ths. 4-5ths. 3-4ths. 3-4ths. 3-4ths. 3-4ths. Propor- tion of Duty Paid. 6-7ths. 9-lOths. 9-lOths 7-Sths. 7-8ths. 7-8ths. 5-6ths. Notes above the value of One 2l., and 5?., viz lOl. & upwards and Duty Paid thereon. Propor- tion of Notes Stampt. 3-lOths, l-4th. l-5th. l-4th. l-4th. l-4th. l-4th. Propor- tion of Duty Paid. l-7th. 1-lOth. 1-lOth. l-8th. l-8th. l-8th. l-6th. Copies of Returns made from the Stamp Office to Parlia- ment for the Years 1819 to 1825, The aggregate nominal amount of Country Notes Stampt 4,465,092 3,493,901 4,438,548 4,293,164 4,479,448 6,274,069 8,755,309 .£36,199,531 Nominal amount of Notes Stamped in se- ven Years. The aggregate amount of Duty Paid on Notes Stampt. 64,754 54,238 69,252 64,124 67,303 95,267 121,976 Fraction 4 .i536,9i8 Duty actually Paid on Notes Stamped in se- ven Years. EXTRACT FROM " GUARDIAN AND PUBLIC LEDGER." " By the evidence, now undergoing the process of being j)rinted, a most extraordinary exposition is given of the financial operations of the Bank and the govern- ment, which led to the panic in 1825, and the sup- pression of small notes in 1826. Lord Liverpool, it will be recollected, was prime minister at that period, and the present illustrious Lord Goderich Chancellor of the Exchequer. When the panic had worked its devastation, every one was anxious to learn what had caused it. The ministerial explanalion was at length given, and it amounted to this, namely, that undue speculation had been encouraged, and the cvrrency de- ranged, by the artful and dishonest practices of the country bankers. This was a grave and serious charge, which many persons believed to be well founded ; and as a proof that ministers wished the public to adopt their belief, they instantly consigned the offending parties to ruin. The majority survived the blow thus aimed at their credit ; but upwards of a hundred less prepared, were compelled to stop patjment, encounter the dishonour, and bear with the calumny, although many of them were in possession of property and securities equal to forty shillings in the pound. ' ♦ The country bankers indignantly denied the charge, retaliated upon the government, boldly accused his Majesty's ministers of being the sole authors of the paiiic.and, in order to est^^tJ.'^'^ t^ii-Charge, demanded an inquiry into the affairs o\ the Bank of England. From that time to this, it has only been a war of o\n nion — the evidence could not be procured— ( hy tbe fluctuating issues of the Bank of England, h /iWoduced a general feeling of the otal insecuiity and liaiird of all mercantile, manu- facturing, and agricultuijif transactions. Capital lies dormant for want of confiti^ncc in its distribution. No care, no judgment, no precaution, has lH?en able to guard against the sudden ilepreciitions and losses resulting from a fluctuating amount of the circulating medium, of tii« sudden increase or diminution of which no one has been able to form even a conjecture. Hence has arisen the general stagnation of every brancU of trade, the deaith of employment, and the inadequate wages of labor. A financial cholera has been j)aralyzing all the operations of industry, and has kept the body politic in a slate of un- ceasing and terrible convulsion. A A 12 EXTRACT FROM "THE MARK LANE EXPRESS'" CORRESPONDENT, AGRICOL^. In Mr. Palmer's evidence, we have the reluctant admis- sion of what every writer of common sense has constantly insisted upon, namely — that the alternate contractions and expansions of the Bank issues, have always produced a corresponding depression and rise in prices. The most important question we meet with touching this part of the subject, is the following : " Must not the alterations which take place in your extension or contraction of your circulation, keep the prices in this country in a state of constant change and revolution 1" Answer — " If there be frequent contractions and expansions, there inay be frequent fluctuations of prices." J/" there be — much mis- chief (as well as virtue) in an if. Now, if Mr. Palmer's mind be not made up as to this point, and that he still lacks conviction of the Bank of England having been one of the great auxiliary causes (Peel's Bill of course being the primary one) I beg to refer him to the first four, (as well as several subsequent numbers) of your journal, in which I have demonstrated, from authority which defies contradiction, that from the middle of last century to the first quarter of the present, the frequent contraction of the bank issues always brought with it national calamity, while the subsequent expansion has invariably produced a con- trary effect. But in Mr. Ward's evidence there is one question, the reply to which is extremely valuable, as establishing this position in reference to Agriculture. Mr. Ward is re- minded of the decision of the Government in 1822 — that sunless year in the farmer's calendar — when an additional 4,000,000 of bank notes were put into circulation with a view to revive speculation and restore the prosj)erity of the country ; and is asked whether he did not consider that by such an increase much good effects would result ? Mr. Ward says — " I recollect distinctly many of the circum- stances referred to. Government had at that time received many complaints relating to the agricultural distress, and the depression of prices ; and I think the price of wheat was at one time as low as 37s., [per quarter], the average for the year was as low as about 43s. My own opinion is, that whatever circumstances were in operation, one if the most unfavorable circumstances that occasioned the low prices, was the very low state of the aggregate currency of the coun- try. I stated in my former examination, that the amount of country notes which had been at 20,000,000, had be- come reduced in one year to 16,000,000, and had been then reduced to 11,000,000 ; and by the year 1821, it had been reduced to 7,000,000 sterling: the consequence was, that not only prices were low, but that a disinclination to transact business, and a great deal of positive evil existed ; and I think the agriculturists had a clear right to complain of that circumstance. I think Government had a clear right to restore the pi-ices, in some degree to relieve them from that depression, and I do not know any other means by which it could be done, than by giving them at least as good a currency, as full a currency, as was legitimate in connexion with the laws relating to currency. When the season of 1822 arrived, I think it was a very wise measure to try to stimulate prices ; I believe that mode- rate speculation itself 's^a.^od ratlier than an evil ; but that the difficulty is in re^Jil'r w§ tl^e degree. If persons, when once speculation isseta^-going, carry it to a prepos- terous extent, they must iikel the consequences of it ; but 1 do consider it beneficial tt w'le country that there should be a certain degree of enteipirise ; and there was a great want of what I should call pi legitimate degree of enter- prise at that period, and a depression of price in conse- quence, of which I think tbs parties were entitled to ask for relief." Now I am aware it has been asserted by some, that the country bankers, by the largo reductions occasionally made in their circulation, mainly contributed to the ruinous depression in prices, and consequent pressure on industry, which have occurred at different periods. But, in order to see how far this imputation is sustainable, let us, for a moment, contemplate the situation of this class of traders at particular epochs, and I tbink we shall discover that they were not deserving of the reproach. | Witliout going farther back, it may sufllice to state, tliat by the 55th Geo. 111., c. 6, one pound notes had been continued until 25th March, 1826 ; that by the 56th Geo. III., c. 21, (1816,) one-pound notes were allowed to circulate " until two years after the resumption of cash pay- ments by the Bank of England ;" and by the 3d Geo. IV., c. 70, the circulation of one-pound notes was continued until the 5th of January, 1833. Now, the country bankers, relying on the good f'aitli of Parliament, tnd on tlie avowed intentions of his Majesty's Government, namely, that the 5th of January, 1833, would he the final period for the circulation of one-)iound notes, made their arrange- ments accordingly. This, be it remembered, was the state of the law until the end of 1825. Country bankers, of course, continued to issue one-pound notes in their respective districts, as the trade of those districts required, always keeping in view the period (January, 1833), when, according to Act of Parliament, they were no longer to be issued. But in February, 1826, to the great dismay and surprise of the provincial bankers — His Majesty's Ministers announced it to be their intention to shorten the period for issuing one- pound notes, from 1833 to 1829 ! Country bankers were in no way consulted upon this occasion. No Parlia- mentary inquiry was entered upon to ascertain whether the waiits of the public would be interfeied with, or the regular employment of the people interrupted by such a sudden alteration— or whether a supply of gold could be ensured equal to the amount of notes to be withdrawn in England and Wales. , The period of 1829, however, being thus fixed upon by his Majesty's ministers, those country bankers who had not a sufficient quantity of stamps by them to keep up their issues until that period, applied to the Stamp Office for the needful supply. But here an unexpected impediment was raised against their applica- tion. His Majesty's ministers, by an official letter ad- dressed to the Commissioners of Stamps, forbade them to issue any stamps for one-pound notes to any country banker whatsoever ; thus anticipating, on their own responsibility, the prohibition intended to be included in their Act of Parliament. By this extraordinary proceeding, country bankers were severally placed in different relative situations. Those who had by them a sufficient stock of stamps, were en- abled to prepare to issue one-pound notes until 1829 — whilst those who had relied upon the law of tlie land as it previously stood, to procure, as occasion might require, the needful supply of stamps were disabled from making any further issues ; at the same time the New Act of Parlia- ment made it lawful for all country bankers mdiscrjminate- ly to continue the issuuig of one-pound notes until 1829. ihe nnural consequence of thus "tampering with the currency," and the harsh proceedings of these ministers was, to precipitate thepayment of one-pound notes, and in- deed notes of all amounts. But what rendered this state of things more oppressive to the country banker was, the culpable negligence of the Government in not ensuring an adequate supply of gold to be given in exchange for the notes thus driven in upon their respective issuers. Nay, it is notorious to all connected with banking busi- ness at that period, that when some of the country bank- ers who were possessed of the most ample funds in Bank of England notes, applied to the Bank of England for gold in exchange for them, they were informed that the Di- rectors had nM gold enough to take them up ! The Bank Directors, moreover, informed the London bankers of their inability to pay all their notes in gold, and requested that country bankers might be prevailed upon to take small bank notes into the country, and not press them for gold. All this, be it remembered, was passing at the very time when the law required the Bank Directors equally with the country bankers to pay all their notes in gold on demand. I'he country bankers exercised the most honor- able forbearance towards the Bank of England, and took their small notes instead of gold. Printed by Joseph Rogerson, Old Boswell Court, London. ■•.•' -v ■ : ,, /'; >