r 
 
1 
 
MEMOIR 
 
 OF 
 
 GEORGE LIVER MOEE. 
 
 PREPARED AGREEABLY TO A RESOLUTION 
 
 MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL SOCIETY 
 
 By CHARLES DEANE. 
 
 CAMBRIDGE: 
 
 PRESS OF JOHN WILSON AND SON. 
 
 1869. 
 
MEMOIR 
 
 OF 
 
 GEOEGE LIYEEMOEE. 
 
 George Livermore, the son of Deacon Nathaniel and Eliza- 
 beth (Gleason) Livermore, was born in that part of Cambridge 
 called Cambridgeport, in Massachusetts, on the 10th of July, 
 1809. He was a descendant of John Livermore, who came 
 from Ipswich in England, in 1634, and settled in Watertown 
 in this State. 
 
 Mr. Livermore attended the public and private schools at 
 Cambridgeport until he was fourteen years of age, pursuing, 
 in addition to the common English course, some of the pre- 
 paratory studies for admission to college. In a brief auto- 
 biographical sketch written during his last sickness, he says : 
 " Among my school-mates at the private school was Oliver 
 Wendell Holmes, now so widely known as the charming poet 
 and prose-writer. The humorous scene described in ' The 
 Autocrat of the Breakfast Table,' concerning 'the Leghorn 
 Hat,' the ' Port Chuck,' and ' the Race,' is as vivid to my 
 memory as if it took place yesterday." * 
 
 * In some remarks by our associate, Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes, at a meeting 
 of the Society after Mr. Livermoi'e's death, he speaks of this private school, and 
 refers to some of those who attended it while he was there. Richard H. Dana, Jr., and 
 Margaret Fuller were of the number. "The boys," he says, " were rather a fighting 
 set; and our champion, a nephew of the most celebrated of American painters, had 
 
 BURTON HIST. COLLECTION 
 DETROIT 
 
 EXCHANOE DUPLICATE 
 
4 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 His constitution being feeble, and his health not good, it 
 was thought best that he should abandon the idea of a college 
 education, and follow some more active calling. Accordingly, 
 at the age of fourteen he left school, and went into the store 
 of his older brothers, Isaac and Marshall Livermore, mer- 
 chants, at Cambridgeport. After this period the only school 
 advantages he enjoyed were a course of exercises in English 
 and Latin during two terms at the Deerfield Academy, in 
 1827-28. 
 
 From the time of entering the store, his leisure hours 
 were always spent in reading and study ; and all the money 
 he could earn was saved for the purchase of books. He thus 
 refers to this period of his life. 
 
 "A great mauy valuable and standard works were published in a 
 cheajD form, and thus came within the reach of persons of small means. 
 I was sometimes allowed an evening to go to Boston and attend the 
 book auctions ; and I felt proud and happy when I came home with 
 two or three volumes, costing from twenty-five to thirty cents each. 
 At these book auctions there was sold, almost every time I was present, 
 a thick octavo edition of Shakespeare, with rather coarse wood-cuts. 
 The price generally obtained was not far from three dollars. I had read 
 the ' Merchant of Venice,' from a borrowed volume of Shakespeare, and 
 I thought that an author who could write like that was w^orth owning 
 entire. I saved my money, therefore, till I had three dollars, and went 
 to Boston, hoping that a copy of my coveted author might be put up, 
 and sold within my means. I was not disappointed. After waiting an 
 hour, the auctioneer put up a copy of Shakespeare. The bidding began 
 at two dollars and fifty cents, and advanced five cents till it reached 
 two dollars and ninety cents, when it was knocked down, and the name 
 of the purchaser was called for. I had bid two dollars and ninety cents, 
 but another bidder gave his name. I claimed the book, as I had fairly 
 
 at least two regular pitched battles with outside fellows, who challenged the preten- 
 sions of the gentlemen of the ' Academy.' George Livermore came among this rather 
 rough crowd, the mildest and quietest of boys, — slight, almost feminine in aspect, 
 quite alien to all such doings. I do not remember him as conspicuous in any 
 active play, still less as ever quarrelling with anybody. He was a lamb-like creature, 
 who made us all feel kindly to him, — this I can remember, and his looks, so delicate 
 and gentle." 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 5 
 
 made the bid ; and I called out to the auctioneer that I had bid $2.90 
 too. 'Ah,' said he, ' if you bid $2.92, the book is yours, as you are the 
 highest bidder.' I had no disposition to quibble about his pun, but 
 gladly paid two dollars and ninety-two cents, and hurried home with 
 my big book under my arm, a prouder and happier boy than I had ever 
 been before. This was the Shakespeare which I first read. I marked 
 the favorite passages which most impressed me, and noted the pages 
 on which they occurred, on the fly-leaf at the end of the volume. I 
 kept the volume for many years, when, wishing to own an English 
 edition with notes, and not feeling able to keep both, I had tlie folly 
 to exchange it. Many a time have I regretted this. I would, it' I 
 could, have bought it back, and given for it its weight in gold." 
 
 When quite a young man, he became much interested in the 
 character and history of the merchant-scholar, William Roscoe, 
 the first account of whom he read in Irving's Sketch-Book." 
 
 " I was much pleased," he says, " to find that a man in active busi- 
 ness, without a college education, had accomplished so much in litera- 
 ture, science, and statesmanship. Roscoe seemed to me to be a model 
 which one might well strive to imitate, at however humble a distance. 
 My respect for the abilities, attainments, and character of this remark- 
 able man increased with my knowledge of the works he published. 
 His life, written by his son, has always been a favorite biography with 
 me ; and I have bouglit a large number of copies to present to young 
 friends. When I visited England in 1845, I sought out the principal 
 places connected with his name, and had the good fortune to become 
 personally acquainted with many of his friends and descendants." 
 
 In 1829 Mr. Livermore went to Waltham as a salesman in 
 a dry-goods store,"' where he remained a year, when, a 
 smarter young man offering his services," he returned to 
 Cambridge. A change having taken place in his brothers' 
 business, he entered the shop of his father, who was a soap- 
 manufacturer, and went to work making fancy soap and 
 wash-balls." All his earnings, except what he needed for 
 his clothes, he passed over to his father, who was in strait- 
 ened circumstances. His father had given him a silver 
 watch which cost ten dollars. 
 
 2 
 
6 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 "On the day I was twenty-one years old," he writes, "wishing in 
 some way to signalize my majority, I asked my father for a dollar, and 
 took a trip in tlie steamboat to Nahant. The fare was thirty-seven 
 and a half cents each way, leaving me but twenty-five cents for other 
 expenses. I could not, of course, get a dinner at any public house with 
 this sum ; but I managed to find a grocery store, where I got ninepence 
 worth of gingerbread and crackers, and a glass of lemonade for six 
 cents, which I regarded as a good dinner, and came home with six 
 cents in my pocket. This was my start in life." 
 
 Two months later, the person in whose shop at Waltbam he 
 had served as salesman, called upon him, and urged him to 
 return into his employ, saying that the young man who had 
 succeeded him did not please the customers as well as he 
 had done, and offering him increased pay. The invitation 
 was accepted, and Waltham once more became his place of 
 residence. The following spring, his employer, Mr. Smith, 
 proposed to him to take the business and conduct it on his 
 own account for two years, offering fair terms. 
 
 " I hesitated at first," says Mr. Livermore, " about assuming such a 
 responsibility ; but my friends advised me not to let so favorable an 
 opportunity slip, and on the first of April, 1831, I put up my sign, and 
 commenced business on my own account. My brother Isaac lent me 
 one thousand dollars as capital to pay Mr. Smith in part for his goods. 
 At the end of the two years I returned the one thousand dollars, with 
 interest, and had earned nearly twice as much more for my own cap- 
 ital with which to begin business elsewhere. I was sorry to give up 
 so good a business, but Mr Smith needed and had a right to the store ; 
 and I retired from the scene of my first business experience and success 
 as gracefully as I could. 
 
 "The agent of the Waltham factories, learning that I was to resign 
 to Mr. Smith the business I had received fi-om him, suggested that I 
 should take the 'factory store,' wiiich was better located than his, and 
 thus retain my own customers. This would have injured Mr. Smith 
 seriously. I did not think it would be honorable in me to encroach 
 upon his privileges, and I promptly declined the oiler." 
 
 Mr. Livermore's religious nature was warm and earnest, 
 and bad been early developed under the most favorable cir- 
 cumstances beneath the paternal roof. Although suffering 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 7 
 
 much from poor health, his religious views were cheerful. 
 During his residence in Waltham, he boarded with a lady 
 of eminent piety, who had a high regard for him. 
 
 " Her religion," he writes, " was after the pattern of the strictest Cal- 
 vinism. As she loved me, she wished to save my soul ; and no argu- 
 ments which she and her minister and friends could bring were kept 
 back. I had, however, thought and read a good deal on the subject of 
 religion, and had examined the evidences for and against the particular 
 form of faith vv^hich is called ' Orthodoxy.' The result of my investiga- 
 tions was to convince me that the grounds of true religion are very 
 simple ; viz., to love the Lord our God with all our heart, and our 
 neighbor as ourself My sister Eliza (now the wife of the Rev. Mr. 
 Stebbins) did more than any one else to encourage my religious inqui- 
 ries and to fix my religious principles. The year in which I attained 
 my majority, I, with her, made an open profession of my faith, and 
 united with the church where my parents worshipped, where my father 
 was deacon, and where I had been a Sunday-school scholar since I was 
 five years old. I have always regarded this act of consecration with 
 satisfaction; 'not as though I had already attained, either were already 
 perfect,' but as a means of fixing my mind and directing my thoughts 
 to the higher and spiritual wants of my nature. My dear mother had 
 taught me a large number of hymns, which I shall never forget, and 
 some of which I repeat every day and night." 
 
 In the interval between relinquishing his business at Wal- 
 tham and entering into new engagements, as he had rarely 
 been away from home, and never beyond the limits of this 
 State, he made a visit to Maine, which was followed by a jour- 
 ney to New York, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Washington. 
 On his return, he went to West Point and Saratoga. Of his 
 visit to Maine he says, — 
 
 " In the spring of 1833, soon after I left Waltham, I went, by sail- 
 ing packet, to Bangor. I had never been out of the State before. The 
 voyage was rather rough and I was sea-sick ; but it was a new experience 
 to me, and I enjoyed the novelty. I went to Old Town, where there 
 was, on the island of Orono, an Indian settlement. These Indians are 
 Roman Catholics. They have a church and a Catholic priest on the 
 island. The church is a rude structure, and I desired to see the inte- 
 
8 
 
 MEMOIR OP GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 rior. The priest told me I could do tliis by calling on the deacon, who 
 had the keys, and giving him a small compensation for his trouble. He 
 pointed out the wigwam where the deacon lived, and I went there and 
 made known my wishes to a fat squaw, who stood at the entrance. 
 ' You want to see church,' said she. ' How much you give ? ' Wish- 
 ing to be liberal, I said, ' Half-dollar,' being twice the sum the priest 
 had named as the customary fee. She grumbled out, ' Deacon not at 
 home.' Supposing that I should have to go again to accomplish my 
 purpose, I started to return, when the squaw called out, ' You give a 
 dollar, and the deacon is at home.' I readily produced my dollar, and 
 my tawny guide came out with the keys and showed me the church." 
 
 During his visit to Washington, he called upon President 
 Jackson, and was surprised to find that hard and tyrannical 
 ruler so gentle and affable in private conversation." He also 
 spent a day at Mount Vernon, with the greatest interest and 
 satisfaction. 
 
 Some attempts about this time to form a mercantile con- 
 nection failed, but in 1834 he established himself in Boston, 
 in the shoe and leather business. This led him at times to 
 visit other cities, and to be absent from home for weeks and 
 months together. But however pressing his engagements, 
 his thoughts always reverted fondl}^ to the paternal hearth, 
 and to his Sunday school, which through life claimed his 
 warmest interest and affection. 
 
 In a letter to a younger brother from New York, dated 22d 
 September, 1834, occurs this passage: — 
 
 " Young never uttered a truer sentiment than this : ' We take no 
 note of time but from its loss.' You are just at the age when time is of 
 immense value. Improve every moment ; but do not consider time 
 lost, if spent in profitable conversation, — or even sometimes in silence. 
 There are other ways of improving the mind than reading books ; read 
 men, read the volume of Nature ; read everything you see ; but when 
 you take a printed volume, bestow on it your whole attention, and read 
 it through before you commence anything else. You are just arriv- 
 ing at an age when you will feel the worth of information on almost 
 any subject. In a few weeks you will be called to act for yourself in 
 life. I believe you have long since determined to act in all things from 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 9 
 
 principle, not from caprice, oi- the impulse of the moment. Let purity 
 of purpose be your pole-star through life, and you will not live in vain. 
 The time will come when all will find their proper place in the world. 
 . . . We have, as a family, cause to be grateful that our escutcheon 
 is not marred by one dishonorable blot. Let us strive to increase its 
 lustre. . . . 
 
 Be a valuable member of society, no matter how humble may be 
 your occupation for a few years. Remember Roger Sherman was 
 called from the cobbler's bench to assist in drafting the Declaration of 
 Independence." 
 
 In the winter of 1834-5 he went to the South and West, 
 spending some weeks in New Orleans. In a little memorandum- 
 book kept by him at this time, we find that on the 15th of 
 February he " heard Rev. Mr. Clapp preach in the morning,'' 
 and in the afternoon attended the meeting of the slaves at 
 the Methodist Church." A few evenings after he attended 
 a meeting of colored persons about to emigrate to Liberia. 
 Gloster Simpson, formerly a slave, and recently from Liberia, 
 spoke in favor of tlie colony. All who were about to emi- 
 grate formed themselves into a Temperance Society." For 
 further information respecting this colonization scheme, he 
 calls the next day on this Gloster Simpson from Liberia. 
 
 He returned home from New Orleans by way of the Missis- 
 sippi and the Ohio Rivers, and arriving at Louisville spent 
 the Sunday there, March 15th. He attended the Sunday 
 school of the Rev. Mr. Clarke's Society " (James Freeman 
 Clarke, D. D., now of Boston). " The wdiole number of schol- 
 ars," he says, " is at present about fifty. Mr. Clarke preached 
 in the morning on the education of children." 
 
 Mr. Livermore's love of books increased with the increase 
 of his means: indeed, it outran his means, which were 3^et 
 small. His tastes craved for, and were formed upon, the best 
 models : the authors with whom he communed were of the 
 highest order, not only as regards purity and elevation of 
 sentiment, but elegance of style. His pure mind rejected 
 everything coarse or irreverent. He had a great horror of 
 
10 
 
 MEMOIR OP GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 the very presence of books of a demoralizing tendency, — a 
 feeling which led him to discard from his collection a copy 
 of Byron, as he did not wish so impure a book in his library. 
 
 His poetic faculty was large, and showed itself not only 
 in a love for the best poets, but in the composition of some 
 exquisite verses. Within a few years of the period of which 
 we are now speaking, he wrote two dedication-hymns, a num- 
 ber of hymns addressed to Sunday-school children, some 
 verses suggested by the Scripture passage, And Jesus 
 called a little child unto him," &c. Other pieces were en- 
 titled, ''The Negro Missionary," ''The Blind Harper and his 
 Boy in Rogers's Italy," and some verses " To my Sister on her 
 Wedding-Day." These subjects of his Muse are here enumer- 
 ated for the purpose of showing how largely religious ideas 
 and sentiments possessed his mind at this time. Many of 
 these verses are excellent as poetry, and probably have never 
 been published, unless upon the cards of his Sunday scholars. 
 To a valued friend in the Divinity School, who had already 
 dedicated himself to the cause of Sunday schools and phil- 
 anthropic labors among the poor, he presented a copy of the 
 " Sunday-School Guide," written by his pastor, the Rev. A. 
 B. Muzzey, on a blank leaf of which was inscribed this 
 sonnet : — 
 
 " TO R. C. W. * 
 
 " Self-consecrated to the cause of truth, 
 Wedded to charity by tenderest ties, 
 Thou art a Guide to many a wandering youth, 
 Directing upward their inquiring eyes. 
 Happy the chosen path thy feet pursue ! 
 The work our Lord began, 'tis thine to do. 
 To bless the little ones, — preach to the poor, 
 Lead the lone pilgrim to the heavenly door. 
 And bid him enter freely, — heal the blind 
 By pouring light celestial on the mind, — 
 Comfort the mourning, — bind the broken heart, 
 And give the balm religious joys impart : 
 These are the duties that your path attend ; 
 God bless your efforts evermore, my friend ! g. l. 
 
 " December 10th, 1837." 
 
 * Waterston. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 11 
 
 In the year 1838, Mr. Livermore and an older brother, Isaac 
 Livermore, formed a copartnership in business as wool-mer- 
 chants, — an arrangement which was favorable to the culti- 
 vation of his literary tastes, as the larger share of the 
 responsibilities of the business would be assumed by the 
 senior partner, who would regard with an indulgent eye the 
 favorite pursuits of the junior. 
 
 About this time Mr. Livermore began to keep a diary, 
 which he continued to the year of his death. The volume 
 for 1838 opens with a dedication to his favorite sister; and 
 at the head of the first page is copied the following stanza : — 
 
 " Thus far the Lord hath led me on, 
 Thus far I make his mercy known ; 
 And while I walk this desert land, 
 New blessings shall new praise command." 
 
 This daily record shows the development of his tastes and 
 the subjects which took the strongest hold upon him, whether 
 of a moral, religious, or political nature. We see what books 
 he read, and what were his opinions of different authors. He 
 had one of the most active of minds, and the most sensitive 
 of natures. His interest in the parish, in the Sunday school, 
 in the Lyceum, in the political meetings of his ward, <fec., never 
 flagged. He was a constant attendant at church, and for 
 years always recorded the text from which the clergyman 
 preached, and often gave an account of the discourse. The 
 sessions of the Sunday school and the teachers' meetings 
 were also duly noticed in his diary. Through life he had a 
 great reverence for sacred things — for the Scriptures and the 
 ordinances of religion. He had a horror of metaphysics, and 
 all those philosophies which tended, as he thought, to scep- 
 ticism. His mind was more poetic and aesthetic than logical, 
 and he was much disturbed by the discussions on Tran- 
 scendentalism," when they first appeared here. He attended 
 a course of lectures by Mr. Emerson, whose doctrines, so fixr 
 as he understood them, much disquieted him. But, with the 
 
12 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 utmost simplicity, he says, that on leaving the lecture-room 
 he is unable to recall any definite and well-connected ideas 
 in the lectures of the Concord philosopher. 
 
 He is found this year deeply engaged in reading his favor- 
 ite author, Roscoe. Gray, Coleridge, Wordsworth, Miss Edge- 
 worth, and Dickens also had charms for him; and the gentle 
 Charles Lamb he loved as an elder brother. 
 
 His love of Nature, and particularly of flowers, was a 
 striking trait in him. Under the date of Dec. 8, 1838, he 
 says he received a fine bunch of larch from his sister, in 
 Leominster, for which he felt very grateful. " There is noth- 
 ing which gives me more pleasure than these little tokens of 
 affection. I had rather see an old broken brown pitcher, filled 
 with natural flowers or foliage, than the most curiously wrought 
 alabaster vase, with only artificial flowers. My love for flowers 
 and plants has become almost a passion, — I believe an inno- 
 cent one." This love continued through life : in the season of 
 flowers, he was rarely seen on his way to the city without a 
 bunch of them in his hand ; and he frequently distributed 
 them among the poor city children that he met, to whom 
 they were luxuries indeed : he w^ould, if he could, have 
 strewn flowers in the pathway of every living creature. 
 These flowers were cultivated on his own grounds, and many 
 of them were of rare varieties, and of exquisite beauty. 
 Their fragrance fitly symbolized the aroma of his beautiful 
 life. 
 
 We find him now attending Channing's lecture on Self- 
 Culture, and paying the expenses of a young man in college. 
 He is interested in Mr. Gurley and the Colonization Society, 
 and feels that the Abolitionists are misrepresenting its pur- 
 poses. With Elliott Cresson, the advocate of Colonization, he 
 is holding a correspondence. 
 
 In a memorandum of expenses this year, one half the 
 amount is put down to necessary expenses, " board and cloth- 
 ing," about one quarter to the account of books," and the 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 13 
 
 remainder to charity and presents." The library he had col- 
 lected at this time was comparatively small. In an entry 
 made September 6th, he says he had to work hard that day, 
 and felt annoyed by it, as he had five or six new books he 
 was very desirous of reading. " I moved mv books into a new 
 secretary, or bookcase, and find they make quite a show. 
 It seems I have about two hundred volumes of good books ; 
 once this would have seemed quite a library ; now I only be- 
 gin to see how many books I want. On one thing I am deter- 
 mined, — that is, to buy no more trash ; what works I do 
 have shall be of good editions. I love literature too well 
 and prize books too highly to have a good author in a mean 
 dress." 
 
 One day an old gentleman reproved him for being always 
 found with a book in his hand ; telling him it was " a bad 
 sign for a merchant to read in his counting-room ; and he was 
 " abashed " by it. 
 
 Mr. Livermore's reading, up to this time, seems to have 
 been somewhat miscellaneous ; that is to say, he appears to 
 have made no subject a specialty. His range of authors had 
 been wide, and, as we have already observed, of the best 
 selection. He thus laid such a foundation in a general knowl- 
 edge of English literature, as well fitted him for those more 
 special studies which we shall soon see him entering upon, 
 and which he pursued with such ardor through life. He was 
 always interested in the study of the Scriptures, and in the 
 great themes which they suggest ; and his duties as a Sunday- 
 school teacher naturally offered a constant inducement to the 
 pursuit of these studies. But now we fijad him (21st Novem- 
 ber, 1838) buying a copy of Coverdale's Bible. It was proba- 
 bly a reprint by Bagster, issued this year. 
 
 On the 1st of October, 1839, Mr. Livermore was married to 
 Miss Elizabeth Cunningham Odiorne, of Cambridgeport, — a 
 connection which opened a new field for the exercise of his 
 warm and generous nature. In him the domestic virtues had 
 
 3 
 
14 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 a rare growth, and no one could be more fortunate in the cir- 
 cumstances which througli life tended to hallow the marriage 
 relation. 
 
 He is developing a taste, at this time, for our local his- 
 tory, and appears to have kept a Record-Book of matters 
 connected with the annals of his native town. We find him, 
 in the early part of 1841, owning twenty-six volumes of the 
 Historical Society's Collections, almost an entire set, — and 
 Winthrop's History of New England, and all the Family and 
 Classical Libraries. ^' Every day I go to Burnham's and 
 Drake's and other bookstores, to see something new ; I must 
 form a resolution to keep away," as he has yet a number of 
 books unread, — but he fears he will be unable to abide by it 
 for any length of time. 
 
 The "Life of Josiah Quincy, Jr.," the ante-Revolutionary 
 patriot, he reads with great interest. " It is an account of 
 one who lived long, though he died young." 
 
 Mr. Livermore always felt a deep interest in whatever was 
 going on around him. On the 29th of January, 1842, he was 
 present in the saloon of the Tremont Theatre, on the occasion 
 of the presentation of a piece of plate to Captain Hewitt, by 
 the passengers of the steamship Britannia," as a testimonial 
 of his skill in the management of his ship during a violent 
 storm. He there saw Charles Dickens, one of the passengers 
 in that ship, who made the presentation speech, and whose 
 appearance disappointed him. " My idea," he says, " of the 
 author of Oliver Twist and dear little Nell was quite too 
 spiritual to be realized in any human form." 
 
 In his business experience, now and through life, there 
 were, at times, days and months of doubt and anxiety, when 
 it seemed difficult to see through the dark clouds which over- 
 spread the financial prospect. He had a high sense of mer- 
 cantile honor ; but he was never ambitious of being a rich 
 man. Amidst all his anxieties, his books, next to his family, 
 were his never-failing solace. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 15 
 
 He was gradually adding to his store of Biblical works, as 
 opportunities and means favored their acquisition. On the 
 3d of March, 1842, he saw on sale, at Little and Brown's, a 
 copy of Eliot's Indian Bible, the price of which was twenty- 
 five dollars. He could not think of buying it, but his brother 
 bought it and generously presented it to him. Copies of the 
 same book have since been sold for more than a thousand dol- 
 lars. On the 30th of June he visits the library of Harvard 
 College, and finds Mr. Sibley very attentive and obliging 
 showing him many old volumes which make his ^' eyes open 
 very wide." The next month he visits, probably for the first 
 time, the rooms of the American Antiquarian Society at 
 Worcester, and receives polite attention from Mr. Haven, 
 the librarian of that institution, — subsequently one of Mr. 
 Livermore's most intimate friends. 
 
 In the early part of 1843, the library of the Rev. Thaddeus 
 M. Harris, D.D., was sold at auction, in Boston, and Mr. Liv- 
 ermore was tempted to buy some of the " antiques " in that 
 collection. Among the books sold, he speaks of a copy of 
 Eliot's Indian Bible, which brought thirty-nine dollars. 
 
 In February of this year he evinces his growing interest 
 in those studies which through life were a specialty with 
 him by writing an article on this Indian Bible for the " Chris- 
 tian World," a religious newspaper, edited by George G. 
 Channing. He afterwards suggests to the editor the devo- 
 tion of a certain part of his paper to Sunday schools, and 
 agrees to furnish something to that department for a month. 
 
 He is reading with intense dehght the Reminiscences of 
 Thomas Frognall Dibdin. ^' I love him," he says. He is also 
 reading that author's ^'^des Althorpianae." 
 
 He now engages to assist a young man to pursue his 
 studies for the ministry : a case where the principal charge 
 would be borne by him. 
 
 Strange to say, for the first time, he this year (March 10) 
 visited the library of the Boston Athengeum. Probably he then 
 
16 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE, 
 
 little thought that in a few years he would be chosen one of 
 the Trustees of that institution, the Chairman of its Library 
 Committee, and then its Vice-President, and regarded as one 
 of its most efficient and influential managers. 
 
 On the 29th of March we find him attending the meeting 
 of the Massachusetts Historical Society at the First Church 
 in Chauncy Place, where he hears the second Centennial Dis- 
 course of John Quincy Adams, on the Formation of the New- 
 England Confederacy^ of 1643. 
 
 About this time was started a curious Biblical question, 
 which Mr. Livermore and the late President of the Historical 
 Society, the Hon. James Savage, were much interested in 
 solving. In September of this year, the Rev. Rufus P. 
 Stebbins delivered a Centennial Discourse before the First 
 Congregational Society at Leominster, in the course of which 
 he had occasion to mention the Rogers family residing in that 
 town, who claimed to be descended from the first Marian 
 martyr. He referred, also, to an old copy of the Bible in the 
 possession of a member of the family in Lunenburg, which, 
 according to tradition, once belonged to the Martyr himself: 
 indeed, it was said to have been the identical copy which 
 he carried to the stake ; and it now bears upon its leaves the 
 marks of fire. The titlepage having disappeared from the 
 volume, its date could not readily be ascertained. But what 
 was supposed to be the monogram of the old printer, Cawood, 
 was found upon the book ; and it was stated on respectable 
 authority that Cawood printed but one edition of the Bible, 
 namely, in 1549, six years before the Martyr's death. All this 
 was therefore consistent with the tradition that the book had 
 belonged to Rogers, and was now in the possession of a de- 
 scendant. 
 
 Previously to publishing his discourse, Mr. Stebbins ap- 
 plied to Mr. Livermore for information on this subject. Mr. 
 Livermore showed from unquestionable authority, that Ca- 
 wood printed a number of editions of the Bible after 1555, 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 17 
 
 the year of the Martyr's death ; and therefore, in the absence 
 of more definite information, which he could not then furnish, 
 as to the precise edition of the Lunenburg Bible, it must 
 remain doubtful whether the Martyr could have owned that 
 copy. Yet as Cawood was said to have printed one edition 
 before Rogers's death, he felt that the probabilities favored the 
 family tradition. 
 
 The investigation of the subject, however, did not end here. 
 Mr. Savage's interest in the matter centred principally on 
 the genealogical question as to the descent of the Rogerses 
 in this country (those Avho came from Nathaniel, of Ipswich, 
 Mass.) from the Marian Martyr. He had no faith in the 
 tradition, and was curious to know whether the Lunenburg 
 Bible furnished any link in the chain of evidence. A frag- 
 ment of that Bible was therefore procured by Mr. Livermorc, 
 and sent to his correspondent, Mr. Henry Stevens, in London, 
 who, with Mr. George Offer, the editor of Bagster's reprint 
 of Tyndale's New Testament, diligently compared it with 
 copies of Cawood's editions of known date, when it was clearly 
 ascertained that the Lunenburg copy was of the edition of 
 1561, six years after the Martyr's death. A sheet of the 
 Bible of that date was subsequently sent by Mr. Offer to this 
 country, and a careful collation being instituted with the 
 Lunenburg copy, the conclusions arrived at in London were 
 abundantly confirmed. Later investigations into the genea- 
 logical question, both in this country and in England, have 
 shown the improbability of the tradition that John Rogers, 
 of Dedham, England, (the father of Nathaniel, of Ipswich, 
 Mass.), was a grandson of the Marian Martyr. 
 
 In November of this year, the Biblical library of the Rev. 
 Dr. Homer, of Newton, was placed on sale at Messrs. Little 
 and Brown's ; and Mr. Livermore bought from it a number of 
 copies of rare editions of the Bible. Among them was a copy 
 of the Genevan version, presented by Admiral Sir Isaac Coffin 
 to Dr. Homer, and supposed by its former owners to have 
 
18 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LTVERMORE. 
 
 been the identical copy presented by the printer to Queen 
 Elizabeth, — also the Bible which formerly belonged to Adam 
 Winthrop, the father of the first Governor Winthrop. This gave 
 further impetus to his studies in this direction. The library 
 of the Duke of Sussex was sold the next year. This collec- 
 tion was rich in rare copies of the Bible, some of which were 
 purchased by Mr. Livermore. Further rarities were subse- 
 quently added to his collection from the library of the late 
 Dr. Hawtrey, Provost of Eton, — among which may be no- 
 ticed ail Evangelistarium, for the use of the Church, written 
 on parchment, and supposed to be of a date as early as the 
 eighth century. From these sources he laid the foundation 
 of that large collection of Biblical works which his library now 
 contains. But his time was not wholl}^ spent, as it often is 
 with book collectors, in amassing books : he was a careful 
 student of them.^ 
 
 In December of this year, Mr. Livermore visited the Rev. 
 Thomas Robbins, D. D., then living at Mattapoiset, in Roch- 
 ester, Mass., to inspect his valuable collection of old Bibles. 
 Dr. Robbins afterwards removed to Connecticut, and became 
 Secretary of the Historical Society of that State, leaving to it 
 his library. 
 
 He now makes the acquaintance of some who were after- 
 wards his associates in this Society, including Mr. Longfellow, 
 Mr. Hillard, and Mr. Norton. Mr. Hillard recalls his early 
 friendship for Mr. Livermore in some touching remarks made 
 before this Society at the meeting following his death, which 
 were printed in the volume of Proceedings." Mr. Water- 
 ston was an earlier friend ; Mr. Livermore showing much in- 
 terest in his library, and adding to it, from time to time, some 
 curious volume. With Mr. Ticknor he formed an early acquaint- 
 ance. In the third edition of his History of Spanish Litera- 
 
 * It should be stated tluit Mr. Livermore could read neither Hebrew nor Greek, though 
 his Biblical collection contained some books in these languages. In early life he 
 acquired some knowledge of Latin, which was of service to him in later years. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 19 
 
 ture/' Mr. Ticknor acknowledges his indebtedness for the cor- 
 rection of an error of Navarrete — in referring to the eigli- 
 teentk Psalm, as containing the prophecy appropriated by 
 Columbus to himself, instead of the nineteenth^ as stated in 
 the Giustiniani Polyglott Psalter of 1516 — to his friend^ 
 
 George Livermore, of Cambridge, who has in his precious 
 library," says Mr. Ticknor, a copy of the Giustiniani Poly- 
 glott, which, when he pointed out tlie error to me, I did not 
 own." (vol. i. p. 188.) 
 
 Between our former associate, the late Rev. Alexander 
 Young, and Mr. Livermore, there existed the warmest friend- 
 ship. They had many literary affinities. Dr. Young was a 
 ripe scholar, and had the tastes and sympathies of an an- 
 tiquary. He had a true Dibdin eye for a good book, and the 
 rare art of handling a volume properly, which few persons 
 possess. He knew how to open a book without breaking its 
 back, and to turn over its leaves so that its owner would not 
 tremble while it was in his hand. There is a knack in all 
 this, known only to the true lover of books, — to him who 
 reverences not merely the author, or the author's thoughts, 
 but the concrete object before him. You never would see 
 him taking up a noble volume, clothed in Bedford's best 
 Levant, and in . his best style, and, balancing it on one hand, 
 allow one of the covers to swing at an angle of ninety de- 
 grees, endangering the joint on which it hung; nor find him 
 leaning on an open page, crumpling the virgin leaves, and 
 making " dog's ears " of the corners. 
 
 Dr. Young had a great love for such an author, for in- 
 stance, as Coryat, the great foot-traveller, the Odcombian 
 Leggestretcher," as he styled himself, and would read with de- 
 light his Crudities hastily gobled vp in Five Moneths Trauells 
 in France, Sauoy, Italy," &c., <fec. With what rare pleasure 
 have we heard him read the passage in this quaint writer, 
 where, in describing the wines of Venice, he says that the 
 " Lagryme di Christo ... is so toothsome and delectable to 
 
20 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 the taste, that a certain stranger, being newly come to the 
 citie, and tasting of this pleasant wine, was so affected there- 
 with, that I heard he vttered this speech out of a passionate 
 humour : 0 Domine, Bomine, cur non lachrymasti in regionibus 
 nostris? " 
 
 Izaac Walton, too, was an author after his own heart ; and the 
 bit of philosophy contained in his quaint praise -of the straw- 
 berry Dr. Young always thought inimitable, and would cite 
 the passage with gout : " Indeed, my good scholar, we may 
 say of angling as Dr. Boteler said of strawberries, ' Doubtless 
 God could have made a better berry, but doubtless God never 
 did."' But Dr. Young's great book was BoswelPs Johnson, 
 which he used to say a person should read through once a year. 
 His " Library of Old English Prose Writers " reveals the 
 well of English undefiled " from wdiich lie drew ; and his 
 " Chronicles of the Pilgrims " and Chronicles of Massachu- 
 setts " show his thorough knowledge of the early history of 
 his native State."^* 
 
 Another friend, afterwards a member of this Society, was 
 Edward A. Crowninshield. He was a true gentleman, a man 
 of elegant manners and of a refined and cultivated taste. He 
 was an ardent lover of books, and had one of the rarest libra- 
 ries of old English literature in this part of the country. He 
 had the first edition of Chaucer, the first edition of Shake- 
 speare's and of Milton's Poems, ^' The Schoolmaster," by Roger 
 Ascham, Coryat's Crudities " of the edition of 1611, &c. 
 His library was also quite rich in early American history 
 and biography. Seated in his elegant room, with all its lux- 
 urious appointments, surrounded by his Strawberry Hills," 
 his " Lee Priories," and his " Dibdins " (all of which told 
 
 * Dr. Young died on the lOtli of March, 1854. Hiiloss was deeply felt by his friends. 
 In a note dated lUh April, Mr. Livermore writes: "Thanks for your kind note 
 of yestcrda}'-, and for the perusal of that of Crowninshield. I do not wonder that he 
 feels so deeply the loss of Dr. Young. For many years, ' we three ' met daily at Little 
 and Brown's. I cannot realize that I shall see his face no more on earth. I think 
 every day he will call and see me." 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIYERMORE. 
 
 21 
 
 you that their owner regarded the art of bookbinding as one 
 of the fine arts), he would remind you of some of the pict- 
 ures of Horace Walpole.* 
 
 Mr. Livermore and these two friends, for years, met almost 
 daily, at noon, at the book-store of Messrs. Little and Brown, 
 and there held sweet converse among the noble volumes 
 which surrounded them. No one, it may here be observed, 
 had a greater love of humor, or had more of fun and frolic in 
 his nature, than Mr. Livermore himself; and when the proper 
 time came for its display, it had free course. These meetings 
 were choice occasions. Books, of course, were the chief theme ; 
 but the conversation took a wide range, and there were free 
 discussions upon whatever topics of interest came up. As has 
 been seen, few were more fond of anecdote, or could tell a 
 better story, than Dr. Young. His wit and humor had the 
 true flavor, like the bouquet of choice wine. At one time Cot- 
 ton Mather was the subject of remark. Some one said that 
 he was born out of time ; that, unhappily, he lived at a transi- 
 tion period in the colony, when clergymen were losing the 
 influence and authority which had so long been conceded to 
 them ; and this wounded his vanity. " An influence and au- 
 thority,^^ replied Dr. Young, in quiet irony, assuming an air of 
 gravity and importance, " which the clergy at the present day 
 are rapidl}^ recovering." 
 
 The eccentricities of Mr. Dowse, of whom the members of 
 the Society are constantly reminded by the speaking picture 
 of him in the Dowse Library, would now and then be the 
 subject of pleasant remark. How many volumes have 
 
 * Mr. Crowninshield died on the 21st of February, 1859. Mr. Livermore thus writes 
 on the same day: — Poor Crowninshield is gone ! He was as well as usual yesterday 
 afternoon ; but in the evening, whilst coughing, he was seized with a severe hemorrhage 
 of the lungs, fainted, and passed away! We little thought, whilst speaking of him on 
 Friday as one of the Standing Committee for next year, that before we met again he 
 would be numbered with the dead. I loved him deeply, and I cannot but mourn his 
 loss, though I feel that a merciful Providence has saved him from much suffering by 
 thus suddenly and gently relieving him from his pains." 
 
 4 
 
22 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 you in your collection ? " was a question often put to him by 
 impertinent curiosity. ^' Never counted them/' was the quick 
 and decisive reply. 
 
 Not infrequently two or three other friends would make 
 their way into this charmed circle ; and the cheery presence 
 of Mr. James Brown, who loved good books not merely 
 because he dealt in them, was always a benediction. 
 
 Sometimes the late John Overton Choules, D. D., whose 
 rotund figure always recalled a well-remembered line of 
 Thomson's, would appear amongst this company of biblio- 
 philists. The Doctor was a great lover of books, and was 
 thoroughly orthodox in his tastes. He used to say, that " old 
 books and old wine " were fit companions. He edited some 
 of the writings of others, but his labors in this field were not 
 always regarded with favor by scholars. He never would 
 acknowledge a suspicion of the authorship of the scathing 
 criticism which appeared in the Christian Examiner," for 
 January, 1845, on his edition of NeaPs " History of the Puri- 
 tans," published by the Harpers the year before ; and used, 
 in apparent simplicity, to ask Mr. Livermore, " who he thought 
 could have written it." 
 
 In March, 1845, we find Mr. Livermore making corrections 
 for the new edition of Grahame's "History of the United 
 States," published this year, under the supervision of Presi- 
 dent Quincy. He calls upon Mr. Quincy, who thanks him 
 for the service rendered, and promises to acknowledge it in 
 the Preface. This was the beginning of their acquaintance, 
 and each continued to entertain the highest regard for the 
 character of the other. Mr. Livermore had an almost romantic 
 admiration for the heroic qualities of Mr. Quinc}^. Every 
 summer or autumn, for ten or twelve of the last years of the 
 life of the venerable patriot, Mr. Livermore, in company with 
 the writer of this notice, paid a visit to the family mansion in 
 Quincy, where a warm welcome always awaited him. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 23 
 
 This year Mr. Livermore visited Europe, with his friend, 
 Mr. James Brown, sailing on the 1st of April. He was 
 furnished with letters from Mr. Sparks, Mr. Ticknor, and 
 other well-known gentlemen. His journal, in the form of let- 
 ters to his family, would make a most interesting volume, and 
 is worthy of being printed entire. He did not follow the 
 beaten track of the tourist. He made the acquaintance of 
 many eminent men, and visited many famous libraries, inspect- 
 ing, as time permitted, the curious books and manuscripts 
 which they contained. 
 
 The first object he would seek, on his arrival at Liverpool, 
 would be some memorial of Roscoe. Under date of the 13th 
 of April he writes : — 
 
 " My first visit in the Old World was to the grave of Roscoe. From 
 my childhood, when I read in the ' Sketch-Book ' Irving's glowing 
 account of Roscoe, I have felt a deep interest in everything relating 
 to him. I have never read any works of biography or history with 
 more pleasure and profit than his ' Lorenzo de Medici ' and ' Leo 
 X.' The beautiful style of the composition, the fine taste, correct 
 views, and pure principles, which are so prominent in tliese volumes, 
 quite fascinated me with the author ; and since reading his Life by his 
 son, ten or twelve years ago, I have had for his character the most 
 profound respect and enthusiastic admiration. He was a ripe scholar, 
 a pure patriot, and a liberal, humble, consistent Christian. Though 
 engaged in the active duties and cares of business, he found time to 
 cultivate a taste for literature, science, and the fine arts ; and, in each 
 department, the world has been benefited by his published works. His 
 friends in Liverpool have shown in various ways their respect for his 
 memory. Roscoe's grave is in a remote corner of the burying-ground 
 connected with the Unitarian Chapel in Renshaw Street. I was dis- 
 appointed not to find a monument here. There is nothing but a plain 
 horizontal slab to mark the place of the family tomb. There is no 
 inscription, but the names and ages of those who are buried beneath, 
 with the date of their birth and death." 
 
 Of course he did not fail to see the full length statue of 
 Roscoe by Chantrey, in the Royal Institution. 
 
 Through letters from his friend, Mr. Charles Sumner, Mr. 
 
24 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 Livermore became acquainted with members and friends of 
 the Roscoe family in Liverpool, and afterwards in London, 
 from whom he received the most flattering attentions. A 
 dinner-party was made for him at Liverpool, at which he saw 
 many of the descendants of Roscoe, who had been invited 
 especially to meet him. Mr. Robert Roscoe, residing in Lon- 
 don, called on him, invited him to his house, and gave him 
 several memorials of his father, including a letter relating to 
 his edition of Pope, a volume of poetry translated from the 
 Italian, and a beautiful crystal miniature head of him in has- 
 relief. 
 
 While in London, Mr. Livermore visited the great bibli- 
 ographer, Thomas Frognall Dibdin, whose writings he had 
 so thoroughly studied, and from whom he received a most 
 hearty welcome. Dibdin was surprised to find that so many 
 persons in this country were interested in his writings. 
 Seizing Mr. Livermore's hands, he said, — My dear sir, I see 
 you are a genuine bibliomaniac. I thank you for coming to 
 see me. I will point out to you such treasures in books as 
 will delight your heart. You must go with me to Mr. Gren- 
 ville's library; and I will give you an introduction to Oxford, 
 Althorp, and other places, where you will see such books as 
 you have never beheld before." ^ 
 
 His account of a visit to the poet Rogers, on the 25th of 
 April, in company with Mr. Brown, we give entire : — 
 
 " Mr. Rogers lives at 22, St. James's Place. The entrance is in a very 
 quiet and retired situation, but the windows in the parlors and drawing- 
 room command a fine view of St. James's Park. We sent in our 
 cards to Mr. Rogers, and were at once very cordially received. He 
 made many inquiries about affairs in our country, and then invited us 
 to his library and parlor, where we saw treasures in books and paint- 
 
 * Dibdin subsequently proposed to give a dinner-party to Mr. Livermore, -sWiere he 
 could meet some distinguished bibliographers, and kindred spirits; but Mr. Livermore 
 was obliged, by reason of pressing engagements, to excuse himself, and decline the 
 honor. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 25 
 
 ings which were of themselves worth a long journey to see. Whilst 
 we were there, Mr. Wordsworth came in, and we were introduced to 
 him. To see the author of ' The Excursion ' and the author of ' The 
 Pleasures of Memory ' together, to take them both by the hand and 
 listen to their conversation, was surely ' glory enough ' for one day. 
 The personal appearance of the two poets is quite unlike. Rogers is 
 over eighty years old, yet not enfeebled by age. His manners are 
 gentle and graceful, his countenance mild and delicate, and his voice 
 sweet and remarkably pleasing. Wordsworth is eight or ten years 
 younger. He is nearly a head taller than Rogers, and looks quite as 
 old ; what little hair remains on his head is quite gray. His manners 
 are rough, his voice loud, his conversation very rapid and vehement ; 
 his whole soul seems to be thrown into the subject before him. When 
 he is silent, he looks just like the engraved portrait in his Poems. I 
 should have known him from the resemblance. But when he talks, the 
 quiet and gentle look that the engraving indicates is gone. Perhaps 
 he was unusually excited to-day ; for he has come to London to be pre- 
 sented for the first time to Her Majesty, the Queen, as Poet-Laureate. 
 He must appear in full court dress, and wear a sword, an unusual 
 thing for him. Well, we were introduced by Mr. Rogers, to the 
 Laureate, as from America. His first words were, ' Gentlemen, are 
 you from Pennsylvania ? ' We knew why he asked : he is deeply 
 interested in the credit of that State, being the holder of its bonds, on 
 which the interest had not been promptly paid ; and the odious and 
 shameful doctrine of repudiation was probably associated in his mind 
 with that State and its citizens. So I j^romptly answered, — ' No, from 
 Boston in New England, where repudiation finds no favor with the 
 people.' — ' Do you think Pennsylvania will pay her debts ? ' — ' Yes,' I 
 replied, ' undoubtedly, principal and interest.' — ' So do I,' said Words- 
 worth : ' I have always thought so. I hold a large amount of State 
 securities ; and some of my friends, too, are large holders. I have 
 always advised them not to sacrifice them ; and I am glad to hear that we 
 shall not be likely to lose.' T was glad enough to get through with this 
 unpleasant matter of repudiation so well. He asked several questions 
 about our country ; inquired if I knew Professor Ticknor ; when I left 
 home ; how long I proposed to stay ; and what route I intended to take. 
 But before I could answer half his questions, he said, ' I suppose you will 
 do as your countrymen generally do, when they come here, — hurry 
 through some of the most remarkable places in England by railway, and 
 then be off to Italy to see paintings, and to Germany to see the great 
 
26 
 
 MEMOIR OP GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 metaphysicians : for my part, I think we have paintings and works of 
 art in England, enough to interest one for years ; and if you want to 
 puzzle your brain with the metaphysics of the Germans, you can buy 
 their works cheaji enough.' When I told him that I was to be absent 
 only three or four months from home, and that all but a fortnight of it 
 would be passed in England, he said I had decided wisely. ' Come to 
 Rydal Mount,' said he, ' and I will show you some beautiful scenery, 
 well worth a little trouble to view.' Mr. Wordsworth left the house 
 before we did. Mr. Rogers gave us so cordial and pressing an invita- 
 tion to breakfast with him next Monday [the 28th of April], that 
 we unhesitatingly accepted. . . . 
 
 " Breakfasted with Samuel Rogers the poet. This delightful old 
 gentleman had invited Mr. Brown and me to come this morning, and 
 he received us very cordially. It was a great privilege to sit beside 
 him and listen to his anecdotes, and talk with him about the authors of 
 England, with whom he had been so long on terras of the closest friend- 
 ship and intimacy. Mr. Rogers has never been married. He does the 
 honors of the table with ease and grate. There were numerous 
 little choice dishes, which he gave an account of, as they were served 
 up, giving us the history of each. He is constantly receiving presents 
 from some of his numerous friends. This morning he had plovers' eggs 
 served up on sea-weed, a present from the South of France ; oranges 
 from Malta, whose fragrance and beauty surpassed any thing of the kind 
 I had ever seen; sweetmeats from Turkey, marmalade from Scotland, 
 and Dutch bread. Mr. Rogers spoke very freely of his contemporaries. 
 Coleridge was an intimate friend. He was a remarkable man in con- 
 versation, but had a bad temper. He did not live with his wife for 
 many years before he died. He spoke warmly of Roscoe, with whom 
 he was acquainted. Byron, Southey, and Campbell were frequent 
 visitors at Rogers's : I wish I could remember a tithe of what he said 
 about them. Rogers has always felt a deep interest in our country. 
 His father was a warm friend of the Colonies at the time of the Revolu- 
 tion. When the news came to London of the Battle of Lexington, he 
 sent for his tailor, and ordered a suit of black. On the tailor asking 
 if he had lost any friend, he answered, — ' Yes, many dear American 
 friends at the Battle of Lexington ; and I shall w^ear black for them as 
 long as I live.' 
 
 " Rogers said that in 1790 (I think it was, perhaps, 1791 or 2) he was 
 one of a dinner-party of twelve at Paris, — nine of whom, within a year 
 or two, died a violent death ! He spoke of our American authors. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 27. 
 
 < 
 
 Washington Irving was of course at the head of our prose-writers, 
 Bryant, at the head of the poets. Halleck was held high in his esteem. 
 He said nothing of Dana the poet, but spoke in the highest terms of 
 the work of K. H. Dana, Jr., ' Two Years before the Mast.' Mr. 
 Rogers's house is a perfect museum of curiosities, yet all arranged in 
 good taste. He has some exquisitely beautiful paintings, originals by 
 the Old Masters. Besides some of the choice works of Sir Joshua Rey- 
 nolds and Sir Thomas Lawrence, I saw the original bust of Pope, by 
 Roubilliac, which Flaxman told Rogers his father had seen more than a 
 century ago in the studio of the artist. Among the autographs were a 
 letter of Dr. Franklin to Washington, and one from Washington to 
 Alexander Hamilton. I saw the original drawings from which the 
 engravings were taken in the ' Poems ' and ' Italy.' In the library were 
 some hook rarities, — the first Aldus, the first edition of the ' Faerie 
 Queene,' and the first edition of ' Paradise Lost ' ; but the chief orna- 
 ment of the library was a little certificate neatly framed and hung 
 upon the wall, which is nothing less than the original contract of 
 Milton with his printer for the copyright of ' Paradise Lost.' 
 
 " Mr. Rogers inquired particularly what places we had visited in Lon- 
 don, and gave us a memorandum of those worth seeing on account of 
 their historical associations. We left him between eleven and twelve 
 o'clock, having had one of the most interesting and delightful visits 
 imaginable." 
 
 Mr. Livermore also visited Sir Thomas Grenville, and saw 
 his magnificeDt library, which has since been transferred to 
 the British Museum, and now forms one of the greatest at- 
 tractions of that institution. In the British Museum he saw 
 many Biblical rarities, which gave new inspiration to his in- 
 terest in the history of the early publication of the Scriptures, 
 and in general bibliography. 
 
 His visits to Oxford, to Cambridge, and to Althorp, where 
 he saw the unrivalled collection of Earl Spencer, made more 
 famous by the description in Dibdin's luxurious volumes, are 
 all eloquently set forth in his journal. 
 
 Mr. Everett was at this time our minister in London ; and 
 he was very attentive in affording Mr. Livermore, by means 
 
.28 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 of letters and in other ways, every facility for accomplishing 
 the objects of his tour."^ 
 
 The gay city of Paris had fewer attractions for Mr. Liver- 
 more. He could not speak the language, nor could he 
 become reconciled to the apparent desecration of the Sabb'ath, 
 in the open shops and places of amusement. The brilliant 
 spectacles which everywhere arrest the eye of the stranger 
 in that city were not unobserved by him, and were elo- 
 quently described in his letters to his family ; but every- 
 thing was foreign to his principles, and to his tastes. 
 England had the greater charm for him, and in after life 
 he derived the highest satisfaction from the recollection 
 of this visit to the mother country. He arrived home, on 
 the 3d of July, after an absence of about three months. 
 The last thing before embarking at Liverpool, he says, — "I 
 went to the grave of Roscoe, and brought away a sprig of 
 sweetbrier and some ivy leaves." 
 
 The previous year he had ordered from Liverpool two or 
 three copies of the bust of Roscoe, in plaster. They could 
 not then be obtained in this country. One of them was placed 
 in the vestibule of his house, where it has since stood. One 
 was presented to Harvard College, and it now stands in Gore 
 Hall. When the committee of the Historical Society were fit- 
 ting up a room to receive Mr. Dowse's library, and were plac- 
 ing busts of distinguished authors over the bookcases, Mr. 
 Livermore requested that a bust of Roscoe might be of the 
 number. 
 
 Mr. Livermore was deeply interested in the cause of learn- 
 ing; and the College in his neighborhood was as dear to him 
 as though he had passed the four years as an undergraduate 
 
 * While in London, Mr. Livermore had the opportunity, through his friend Mr. 
 Brown, of seeing the rare privnte collections of books and manuscripts, belonging to the 
 eminent booksellers, Mr. Pickering and Mr. Murray; and he describes them at length. 
 
 Among the Americans whom lie was constantly in the habit of meeting in London 
 were the late Rev. Henry Colman and Dr. Samuel Parkman; also our present associate, 
 Mr. Saltonstall. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 29 
 
 within her walls, and could call her Jlma Mater. He was 
 now chosen by the Board of Overseers a member of the Library 
 Committee, and continued to hold that position, by annual 
 election, till his death ; being most of the time the Secretary 
 of the Committee. When in England, he had formed the 
 acquaintance of Mr. Everett ; and he regarded it as most 
 fortunate for Harvard College when that eminent scholar was 
 called to its Presidency. He was present at the inauguration 
 services, which took place on the 30th of April, 1846, and 
 under this date thus writes in his diary : — 
 
 " It was a great day for Cambridge, for Harvard University, for the 
 cause of literature and learning in our country. The inauguration of 
 Edward Everett as President of Harvard University was an event to 
 fill every heart with joy ; i.e., every heart that beats with the love of ex- 
 cellence and talent. There was a large audience at the church, every 
 seat and stand was occupied, and four times as many would have been 
 present, if the building could have held them. I was very fortunate in 
 having a comfortable place during all the exercises at the church. As 
 a member of the Examining Committee on the Library, the place ap- 
 pointed me in the procession was just after the Overseers ; and I had a 
 seat on the platform at the church, and a good place at the table for 
 dinner. E. A. Crowninshield was my companion in the procession and 
 at dinner ; I found him by appointment at Owen's, before the procession 
 was formed. We went to the Library at a little past ten o'clock, and at 
 eleven the procession started. The services at the church were all of a 
 high order. They were as follows — Introductory prayer, by Rev. James 
 Walker, D. D. ; address and delivery of the College charter, seal, and 
 keys, by His Excellency, George N. Briggs ; reply to the Governor, by 
 the President elect ; a Latin oration, by George M. Lane, of Cambridge- 
 port ; hymn, by Rev. Dr. Flint ; and then an elegant, profound, and in- 
 imitable address by the President. I had often heard Mr. Everett 
 before, but I believe that of to-day surpassed all his previous productions. 
 Lane's performance was very creditable, and the Governor's marked 
 by his usual good sense and propriety. There were many distinguished 
 persons present ; when Daniel Webster came forward on the platform, 
 he was greeted by tremendous applause."* The services at church were 
 
 * The sudden appearance of Mr. Webster on the platform on tliis occasion (in the 
 First Parish Church), approaching from behind, at the entrance through tlie pulpit, and 
 
 5 
 
30 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVr]RMORE. 
 
 over a little before two o'clock ; at half past two the procession re- 
 formed at Gore Hall, and proceeded to Harvard Hall for dinner. 
 About five hundred and fifty sat down to the table. My neighbors were 
 Crowninshield, Hillard, Bowen, Ellis, and Bowditch. 
 
 " Mr. Everett presided v^ith great dignity and grace at the table. A 
 blessing was asked by the Rev. Dr. Sharp, and thanks returned by the 
 Rev. Dr. Woods, President of Bowdoin College. Speeches were made by 
 President Everett, Ex-President Quincy, Daniel Webster, a humorous 
 poem by Dr. O. W. Holmes, speeches by R. C. Winthrop, J. Quincy, 
 Jr., President Hitchcock of Amherst, and Professor Silliman of Yale Col- 
 lege, and George S. Hillard of Boston. At half past five o'clock the 
 company left the hall. Mr. Everett invited all to visit him at his 
 house." 
 
 The " Cambridge Chronicle," a weekly newspaper, Avas 
 started in Cambridgeport in 1846 ; and Mr. Livermore, partly 
 to assist the proprietor, and partly to aid in securing a good 
 local paper, was a frequent contributor to its columns. He 
 was a graceful and forcible writer ; his opinions on whatever 
 subject were never doubtfully expressed, and his historical 
 investigations were thorough and exhaustive. Many of the 
 
 the reception given to him, are thus described by our associate, Mr. Dana, in his 
 " Address on the Life and Services of Edward Everett," delivered before tlie muni- 
 cipal authorities and citizens of Cambridge, Feb. 22, 1865. 
 
 " On this occasion, there was an occurrence which put suddenly to the severest test the 
 equanimity and ready resources of Mr. Everett. The day and place were his, and his only. 
 The crowded assembly, waited for his word. He rose, and advanced to the front of the 
 platform, and was received with gratifying applause. As he was about to begin, the 
 applause received a sudden and marked acceleration, and rose higher and higher into 
 a tumult of cheers. Mr. Everett felt that something more than his welcome had 
 caused this; and turning, he saw, just at that opening behind your seat, Mr. Mayor, 
 the majestic presence of Mr. Webster! The reception of Mr. Webster had additional 
 force given to it from the fact that he had just returned from his conflict in Congress 
 with Cliarles Jared Ingersoll, who had made an attack on his character, and that this his 
 first appearance among us since was altogether unexpected. I had heard Mr. Everett's 
 readiness of resource called in question. I looked — all must have looked — to see how 
 he would meet this embarrassment. He turned again to the audience, cast his eyes 
 slowly round the assembly, with a look of the utmost gratification seemed to gather 
 their applause in his arms, and, turning about, to lay it ministerially at the feet 
 of Mr. Webster, said to him, as I remember, ' I wish, Sir, that I could at once assert 
 the authority that has just been conferred upon me, and, aucloritate mild commissd 
 declare to tlie audience, exptctatur oratio in lingua vernnculd a Webster. But I suppose, 
 Sk', your convenience and the arrangements made by others, render it expedient that I 
 should speak myself, — at least, at first.' " 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 31 
 
 book-notices which appeared in this journal for a number of 
 years, were from his pen. 
 
 On Monday the 6th of December, 1847, the Hon. R. C. Win- 
 throp took the chair as Speaker of the House of Representatives 
 of the United States, to which office he had just been elected ; 
 and in the course of his speech on that occasion, he made 
 use of the following language : May I not reasonably 
 implore, with something more than common fervency, upon 
 your labors and upon my own, the blessing of that Almighty 
 Power, whose recorded attribute it is, that ' He maketh men 
 to be of one mind in a house Supposing the concluding 
 
 words to be Scriptural, many asked where they were to be 
 found. The newspapers of New York and Boston inquired 
 the Speaker's authority for the apt quotation, — some asserting 
 that it was not in the Bible at all, and not a few learned 
 divines being greatly puzzled. It was finally found to have 
 been taken from the Psalter. In an article contributed to 
 the " Cambridge Chronicle,'' of the 23d of December, Mr. 
 Livermore explained that the passage in the Received Version 
 (Psalm Ixviii. 6), which reads ^' God setteth the solitary in 
 families," is rendered in the Book of Common Prayer as 
 given by Mr. Winthrop, " Grod maketh men to be of one 
 mind in a house." It is from the Coverdale version of 
 1535, and appears there in Psalm Ixvii. It is substantially 
 according to the Cranmer Bible, to which the Psalter in 
 the Prayer-Book generally conforms. Mr. Winthrop took 
 the passage cited from the Prayer-Book, his eye happening 
 to rest upon it the day before at church. In the article re- 
 ferred to, Mr. Livermore gave ten several versions of this 
 passage. 
 
 A good illustration of the accuracy and minuteness of his 
 knowledge of the various editions of the Scriptures is shown 
 in some papers which he communicated to the " Boston 
 Daily Advertiser," of July 12th, and Oct. 19th, 1849, in reply 
 
 * Addresses and Speeches, Boston, 1852, p. 610. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 to Bishop Chase, of Illinois, who had brought the charge 
 against Cromwell and the Puritans of having corrupted the 
 sacred text. The allegation was, that Cromwell, having su- 
 preme power, had authorized the change of the word we " — in 
 Acts vi. 3, relating to the appointment of the seven deacons — 
 to " ye," in order to favor the views of the Independents. The 
 Bishop indulged in many other loose statements, by no means 
 creditable either to his knowledge or to his taste. Among 
 other things, he said that the ^' Cambridge Platform of 1648 
 was based upon this noted error." Mr. Livermore, in reply to 
 the Bishop, in the papers referred to, show^ed, by respectable 
 Episcopalian authority, that the edition of the Bible in which 
 this error first appeared was printed in 1638, while Laud and 
 Charles were ascendant in Church and State, — and that the 
 next edition known to contain it was printed after the Restora- 
 tion. It was simply a typographical error. 
 
 In the " Cambridge Chronicle " of the 5th of April, 1849, he 
 commenced a series of eight articles on the New-England 
 Primer, which were published over the signature of The 
 Antiquary." Those papers were afterwards gathered into a 
 thin volume (of which twelve copies only were issued as gifts 
 to friends), with this title: The Origin, History, and Char- 
 acter of the New-England Primer." They showed much 
 research and curious learning, and attracted considerable at- 
 tention. This Society has one of these twelve copies in its 
 Library. 
 
 Among the minor questions discussed in these papers on 
 the New-England Primer was one concerning the number of 
 John Rogers's children. The equivocal statement of the 
 Primer, that there were nine small children and one at the 
 breast," was disputed by Mr. Livermore, who contended that 
 the number of the Martyr's children at the time of his death 
 was eleven — citing Fox, the martyrologist, for his authority. 
 His positions were assailed by some humorous communica- 
 tions in the '^Boston Transcript," of July 16th and 24th,- to 
 which he replied. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 33 
 
 While a member of the School Committee, Mr. Livermore 
 contributed to the Chronicle " an interesting article on the 
 Public Schools in Cambridge," going back to Master Ea- 
 ton's Flogging School/' and citing the early colonial laws on 
 the subject of schools in Massachusetts. This article was 
 copied into the ^' Common-School Journal" for Aug. 1, 1848. 
 The next year he prepared and printed " A Brief Account 
 of the Dana-Hill Public Schools, Cambridge, 1849." 
 
 A collection of books which formerly belonged to Washing- 
 ton was offered for sale this year, and was bought by a num- 
 ber of gentlemen, and presented to the Boston Atheuceum. 
 Mr. Livermore was not only one of the subscribers to the fund 
 for the purchase of these books, but he was one of a few 
 persons who labored persistently for the securing of this 
 treasure.* Subsequently, as a trustee of Mr. Dowse's estate, 
 he communicated to the " Athenseum " the sum of one thou- 
 sand dollars to defray the expense of a catalogue for this 
 collection, and for increasing it. Everything relating to the 
 history and character of Washington had an interest for Mr. 
 Livermore. His noble library contains many memorials of the 
 Father of his Country: and among the latest accessions to 
 it, not many weeks before his decease, were several sermons 
 preached on the death of Washington, of whicli he already 
 possessed over one hundred. 
 
 In November, 1849, Mr. Livermore was elected a member 
 of this Society ; and a most valuable member did he prove, 
 laboring for its welfare, in season and out of season, to the 
 last. Tlie first volume of Proceedings " was issued under 
 his superintending care, assisted by his friend and associate 
 on the Committee of Publication, the Rev. Chandler Bobbins, 
 D. D. He continued a member of that Committee till his 
 death ; and was also for a number of years a most influential 
 member of the Standing Committee. Other important ser- 
 
 * See Quincy's Historj- of the Boston Atlieiifeiim, p. 187, for a description of these 
 books. 
 
34 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE, 
 
 vices which he rendered the Society will be noticed farther 
 on. The American Antiquarian Society had, the month be- 
 fore, enrolled him among its members. 
 
 The " Christian Examiner " for November, this year, con- 
 tained an article by Mr. Livermore, written at the request of 
 Dr. Ellis, one of the editors of that journal, on the " Publication 
 and Circulation of the Scriptures"; being a review of the Rev. 
 W. P. Strickland's " History of the American Bible Society." 
 This paper gave abundant evidence of his large information on 
 the subject of the translation and circulation of the Bible ; 
 and contains a strong protest against " the absurd attempt " 
 to adapt a version of the Scriptures to the capacities of the 
 ignorant and almost barbarous races, which was made by 
 the British and Foreign Bible Society when they printed a 
 translation of the New Testament for the English negroes in 
 Surinam : — 
 
 " These negroes," he says, " have no distinct language ; but speak 
 what is called ' talkee-talkee,' a strange lingo, compounded of original 
 African words, of clipped and softened English words, and of vio- 
 lently treated Portuguese words. Their missionaries, the Moravians, 
 instead of attempting to teach the negroes pure English or Dutch, 
 recommended and urged the Bible Society to print an edition of the 
 New Testament from a manuscript version which had long been in 
 use at Surinam, in the abommahle patois spoken by the slaves. Great 
 benefit, ii was predicted, would result to the missionaries and their con- 
 verts from the undertaking, though the Society brought upon itself smart 
 censures and much ridicule for the seemingly irreverent and ludicrous 
 character of the volume which they published. It was very elegantly 
 printed in octavo form, large type, in London, in 1829. Nearly all 
 the copies were transmitted to the people for whose use they were 
 prepared, and their arrival and distribution among the negroes caused 
 great excitement. A very few copies were retained in England, as 
 bibliographical and philological curiosities, and they have now become 
 very scarce. One of them was recently offered to the public, in 
 London, at the sale of the library of the late Duke of Sussex, and was 
 sold for three pounds ten shillings. Its original cost could not liave 
 exceeded two or three shillings. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 35 
 
 " We have a copy of this extraordinary volume of gibberish before 
 us, and have looked it over for the purpose of finding a specimen which 
 shall have in it nothing more offensive than what characterizes the 
 whole of the work. The reader may form some just idea of what 
 specimens might be selected, when he is told that the word virgin is 
 rendered, in this version, " wan njoe wendje." 
 
 " We will take a few verses from the benedictions, Matt. v. : — 
 
 " * 1. Ma teh Jesus si da piple, a go na wan bergi tappo, a go sidom, en dem 
 
 discipel va hem kom klossibei na hem. 
 " * 2. En a hoppo hem moefFe, a leri dem, a takki : 
 
 " * 3. Boenne heddi va dem, dissi de poti na hatti : bikasi Gadokondre do 
 vo dem. 
 
 "*4. Boenne heddi va dem, dissi de sari na hatti: bikasi hatti va dem sa 
 kom-e.* 
 
 " Which we may venture to translate half-way back again into 
 English, as follows : — 
 
 " ' 1. But when Jesus see the people, he go after one mountain-top, he go sit 
 
 down, and them disciple for him come close by after him. 
 " ' 2. And he open him moutli, and learn them, and talk : 
 " ' 3. Good is it for them, these the pretty in heart, because God's country is 
 for them. 
 
 " ' 4. Good is it for them, these the sorry in heart, because heart for them so 
 cheery.' " 
 
 In a letter to John Allan, of New York, the disting-uished 
 antiquary, in December of this year, Mr. Livermore expressed 
 his intention of printing, for private distribution, some Remi- 
 niscences of a too short, but very pleasant acquaintance with 
 Thomas Frognall Dibdin." This purpose, however, was never 
 fulfilled. 
 
 In the " North-American Review," for July, 1850, Mr. Liv- 
 ermore contributed an article on Public Libraries, contain- 
 ing a large amount of curious and valuable information 
 qn the subject, both as regards this country and Europe. 
 The scheme of international exchanges of books, inaugurated 
 by M. Vattemare, was also discussed. Mr. Livermore had 
 no confidence in M. Vattemare, and regarded his scheme as 
 visionary. The great subject of a catalogue, which had just 
 
36 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 before agitated the minds of the trustees of the British 
 Museum, is dwelt upon ; and the conflicting views drawn out 
 by the examining committees of Parliament laid before 
 the reader. Two of the books reviewed in this article were 
 the " Report from the Select Committee on Public Libra- 
 ries," and the Report of the Commissioners appointed to 
 inquire into the Constitution and Government of the British 
 Museum." 
 
 A few months afterwards, a volume of Chambers's " Papers 
 for the People " was issued in Edinburgh, containing a paper 
 on Public Libraries," which was made up from Mr. Liver- 
 more's article, a former article from the North American," 
 written by our Corresponding Member, Professor George 
 Washington Greene, and a third paper from another source, — 
 no acknowledgment whatever being made by the Edinburgh 
 publishers. 
 
 This year Mr. Livermore was elected a trustee of the 
 State Library ; and while a member of this board, he had an 
 opportunity of testing M. Vattemare's system of exchanges. 
 His views as to the benefit accruing to the State therefrom 
 were briefly expressed a few years later in the " History of 
 the State Library," drawn up by the Librarian, and prefixed 
 to the Catalogue published in 1858. 
 
 In 1850, Harvard College conferred upon him the honorary 
 degree of Master of Arts ; and, the same year, he was elected 
 a member of the Phi Beta Kappa Society. 
 
 Mr. Livermore's library at this time had become a most 
 valuable one ; and his thorough habits of investigation had 
 made him an authority on those subjects that specially 
 engaged his thoughts. A paper on ^' Libraries in Boston 
 and its Vicinity," in the " Bibliotheca Sacra," for January, 
 1850, contains a notice of Mr. Livermore's collection, and 
 mentions many of its rare works. His library was then 
 estimated to comprise " about three thousand volumes." It 
 was largely increased during the fifteen years following. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 37 
 
 In the early part of the year 1851, there appeared in the 
 " New- York Evening Post/' under the signature of Friar 
 Lupin/' a series of articles commenting on the manner in 
 which Mr. Sparks had edited the Writings of Washington. He 
 was charged with not being faithful to the original text 
 of Washington's letters. The charge was based on a com- 
 parison of some of the letters as printed by Mr. Sparks with 
 the same letters as published by Mr. William B. Reed, 
 of Philadelphia, from the originals in his possession. In 
 the ^' Cambridge Chronicle," of the 20th of February of that 
 year, Mr. Livermore came out with an article in defence of 
 Mr. Sparks, quoting largely from his Preface to Washington's 
 Writings, to show the plan on which he had prepared 
 that work. The matter assumed graver proportions when 
 the charges of the writer in the " New- York Evening Post " 
 were adopted by Lord Mahon, who accused Mr. Sparks of 
 " tampering with the truth of History." ^ 
 
 In the Christian Examiner," for July, 1851, appeared an 
 article from Mr. Livermore's pen, entitled " John Wycliffe 
 and the first English Bible " ; which no one can read without 
 seeing how thoroughly Mr. Livermore's mind was possessed 
 of all the curious learning appertaining to a full understand- 
 ing of the subject. 
 
 Mr. Livermore was now becoming well known to our schol- 
 ars, as a man of large acquirements in certain departments of 
 learning ; and his simple, frank, and winning manners caused 
 his acquaintance to be sought by those who sympathized with 
 his tastes, or who desired to profit by his intimate knowledge 
 of books, or by his words of counsel. He numbered among 
 his correspondents many eminent scholars and bibliographers, 
 both in this country and in England. Among these may be 
 mentioned Francis Fry, F. S. A., of Cotham, Bristol, the edi- 
 
 * An excellent treatment of this whole question, in defence of the editor of Wash- 
 ington's Writings, may be seen in the Memoir of Mr. Sparks by our associate, Dr. Ellis, 
 in this volume, at pages 261-267. 
 
 6 
 
38 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 tor of the elegant new edition, printed in 1862 in facsimile, 
 of Tyndale's New Testament of 1526, in the library of the 
 Baptist College in Bristol. Mr. Fry was the editor of other 
 book rarities, and usually had a few copies struck off on parch- 
 ment or vellum for private distribution. 
 
 The late Rev. Christopher Anderson, D. D., of Edinburgh, 
 author of the Annals /of the English Bible," London, 1845, 
 was also a valued correspondent. Mr. Livermore formed his 
 acquaintance while in London. 
 
 With the lamented Professor Jewett, formerly Librarian 
 of the Smithsonian Institute in Washington, and more recently 
 of the Boston Public Library, Mr. Livermore held the most 
 agreeable relations. At the time of the controversy respect- 
 ing the distribution of the income of the Smithsonian fund, 
 Mr. Livermore entered warmly into the question, sympathiz- 
 ing entirely with Professor Jewett and his friends, and using 
 all his influence to prevent what he considered a perversion 
 of the trust. 
 
 Of the late George Washington Parke Custis, the adopted 
 son of General Washington, who lived at Arlington House," 
 near Alexandria, Ya., Mr. Livermore was a frequent corre- 
 spondent, as he had been his guest."^ Mr. Custis was a gran- 
 diloquent old man, but warm-hearted and hospitable to all 
 who visited the shades of Arlington," where were treasured 
 with care many interesting memorials of his illustrious rela- 
 tive. His Recollections and Private Memoirs of Washing- 
 ton " was a posthumous publication. 
 
 About this time he is found applying his accurate learning 
 to the correction of what he regarded as some singular errors 
 of Mr. Bancroft, relative to the publication of the Scriptures 
 in this country before the American Revolution. His crit- 
 
 * Others, eminent book-collectors, who were also intellij;ent bibhographers, might 
 be named, by whom the memory of iMr. Livermore will always be held dear. Mr. James 
 Lenox, of New York; Mr. John Carter Brown and Mr. John Russell Bartlett, of 
 Providence; Mr. George Brinley and Mr. J. Hammond Trumbull, of Hartford, — were 
 among his valued friends and correspondents. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 39 
 
 icism appeared in the " Boston Daily Advertiser/' of the 
 18th of January, 1853, and relates to some statements in 
 Chapter XII. Volume Y. of the first edition of Bancroft's 
 History of the United States." In subsequent issues of 
 that volume, large alterations in the foot note will be found at 
 this place. 
 
 Mr. Livermore's health was almost always poor. He 
 suffered greatly from headache all his life. ^' I wonder," he 
 would say, " if blockheads ever ache." He remarks that 
 he has seen somewhere that disease is a crime ; and, if it is 
 so, he must be the greatest of sinners. In 1850, he was so ill 
 that he contemplated a long voyage. But he had an elastic 
 spirit, and he commonly soon recovered from his attacks of 
 illness, — at least, he was enabled to resume his usual avo- 
 cations. 
 
 In the pohtical affairs of his State and of the Nation he 
 was always deeply interested. But he never sought, nor 
 would he have accepted, office. He was decided in his 
 views ; his opinions were convictions ; and he was sometimes 
 a little impatient, and not always tolerant, of the opinions of 
 those who differed from him. He did not reflect at the mo- 
 ment that the dissent of others from him was the exact 
 measure of his dissent from others. But he was simple, con- 
 scientious, and constantly striving for the truth. 
 
 He was ever opposed to the system of slavery in this 
 country, and particularly to its extension ; but, up to this time, 
 he was equally opposed to the spirit and policy of the Abolition- 
 ists. He felt that the vehement denunciations in which they 
 indulged did more harm than good to the cause, and that a 
 way would be opened by Providence for the peaceable set- 
 tlement of this agitating question ; and when Mr. Webster 
 delivered his Seventh of March Speech " in the Senate 
 of the United States, which fell " like a wet sheet " upon 
 New England, it met Mr. Livermore's approval. Subse- 
 quently, his views on the subject underwent a change. He 
 
40 
 
 MEMOIR OP GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 began to feel that the South, banded together as one man, 
 were determined to force tlieir peciiHar institution upon the 
 National domain ; that, by stifling freedom of debate in the 
 National Legislature,"^' by the repeal of ordinances enacted for 
 the protection of freedom, by securing decisions in the Su- 
 preme Court hostile to liberty, and by other acts of a similar 
 character, they were, with the aid of their Northern allies, 
 rapidly extending their power in the government, and would 
 soon bring the whole North under their corrupting influence. 
 He then felt that the only hope for freedom was in the union 
 of all manly hearts in an equally firm stand against slavery. 
 As he felt, so he acted. 
 
 During a business tour which he made, in 1852, to the 
 West, Mr. Livermore visited Blennerhassett's Island, in the 
 Ohio River, concerning which, with other matters, he writes 
 as follows : — 
 
 " Parkersburg, Va., May 21,1852. 
 
 " My dear D , — I wish you had been with me here in " Old 
 
 Virginny " this pleasant day, and we would have rambled together over 
 the beautiful island made forever memorable as the scene of Burr's 
 and Blennerhassett's conspiracy, and by the eloquence of Wirt made 
 classic as well as historic ground. It lies in the Ohio just below the 
 river Kanawha, and between Parkersburg, Va., and Belpre, Ohio. I 
 hired a boatman to take me in his skiff to the island, and can say from 
 actual observation, that neither eloquence nor poetry can magnify the 
 beauties of the situation beyond the reality. But few of the relics of 
 improvements by its former owner now remain. The house was 
 destroyed by fire between forty and fifty years ago. The garden is 
 literally all grown over with thorns. I cut a stick for a cane on the 
 
 * The attack upon the Massachusetts Senator, in the Capitol at Washington, on the 
 22d of May, 1856, caused a deep feeling at tlie North among all political parties. Up 
 to this time Mr. Livermore had called himself a "Webster Whig," and had uniformly 
 voted against his relative, Mr. Burlingame, whenever he had been a candidate for any 
 political office. But novf he caused to be printed, at his own expense, the speech of 
 Mr. Burlingame, made in the House of Representatives in Washington on the 21st of 
 June, in " Defence of Massachusetts"; and, in some extra copies, inserted a " Prefa- 
 tory Note," not signed, wlierein he expresses his conviction that the time had arrived 
 when " consistency to long cherished principles requir. s that the Conservative utter 
 and defend the old doctrine of our illustrious statesman, — 'Liberty and Union, now 
 and forever, one and inseparable.' " Later events only intensified his convictions. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 41 
 
 spot, and gathered a few shells and pebbles from the beach, to bring 
 home as mementoes of the visit ; and I left the place with sad reflections 
 on the misfortune and folly of those who leave the luxury of a quiet 
 home for the ambitious purpose of political power. 
 
 " It is now the third week of my absence from home, and another 
 week will elapse before I can return. This lias been the first day that 
 has not been devoted almost exclusively to business. I was detained 
 here, waiting for a steamboat to take me up the river, and improved the 
 leisure by a visit to Blennerhassett's Island. 
 
 " I procured a copy of ' Uncle Tom's Cabin ' on my way, and have 
 read it with jireat interest. I agree with you entirely that it is a work 
 of great power, as well as of perfect fairness. It must do much good. 
 The subject of slavery needs only to be presented in a spirit of candor 
 and intelligence like this, to bring all who are truly desirous of promot- 
 ing freedom to common ground. I wish I could circulate ten thou- 
 sand copies of ' Uncle Tom,' in the Old Dominion, where chivalry and 
 slavery have wrought such a potent spell, and almost reduced to beg- 
 gary a people possessed of some of the greatest natural advantages of 
 any in our fair country. 
 
 " Remember everything that occurs during my absence, and come 
 and tell me all when I get home. You can, better than almost any 
 one else, make up the loss which I always feel when deprived of the 
 genial influences of Boston and Cambridge society. 
 
 " Yours faithfully, 
 
 " George Livermore." 
 
 Mr. Livermore was continually adding to his store of 
 Biblical works, and often found occasion to make use of his 
 cui'ious and accurate learning in this department of bibli- 
 ography. At the annual meeting of the Massachusetts Bible 
 Society, in May, 1854, his Excellency, Governor Washburn, 
 made an address, in the course of which he referred to 
 the influence of the Bible upon CromwelPs soldiers. In 
 the army," he said, " every man had a Bible in his knapsack, 
 and daily read it, and sang the praises of God ; and the 
 result was the like of what has been seen in the history of 
 Puritanism." In an article in the Cambridge Chronicle," of 
 the 20th of June, Mr. Livermore quoted this passage from the 
 Governor's speech, saying it was substantially correct, but 
 
42 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 not literally so ; that, if Cromwell's soldiers carried the Bible 
 in their knapsacks, it was not the whole Bible ; that The 
 Soldiers' Pocket Bible " consisted of appropriate selections 
 from the Scriptures, printed in pamphlet form, and was gen- 
 erally buttoned between the coat and waistcoat, next to the 
 heart, — proving, perhaps, sometimes, a defence from the 
 weapons of the enemies of their bodies, as well as from the 
 Wicked One who sought to subdue their souls." He remarked, 
 that but few copies of this curious Bible had been preserved, 
 and that probably the copy he possessed was the only one in 
 the country. He then gives a brief description of it. He had 
 had it some years, having received it from his friend Mr. 
 Crowninshield, to whom it had been sent from London. The 
 book was afterwards reprinted by Mr. Livermore. 
 
 To afford some idea of the character of Mr. Livermore's 
 library at this time, the following description of it is given. 
 It was written by Mr. Livermore himself, by request."^ 
 
 " Nearly a quarter part of the entire collection consists of Bibles 
 and Biblical works, in various languages, versions and forms, from the 
 ancient Hebrew manuscript roll, to the most modern translation of our 
 own times. 
 
 " Among the manuscripts of interest is The Pentateuch, carefully writ- 
 ten on thirty-six skins of parchment, and measuring fifty-eight feet in 
 length, and one foot in breadth. This fine apograph is rolled upon a 
 pair of handles, and enclosed in an embroidered silk cover. It was 
 formerly used in a Jewish synagogue, and is a good specimen of an 
 ancient volume, or rolled book. 
 
 " Two copies of the Bible entire, in the Latin Vulgate version, written 
 by monks in the Middle Ages upon the most delicate vellum, are elabo- 
 rately illuminated with beautiful initial letters, figures, and miniatures. 
 They are of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. Each was, perhaps, the 
 work of a whole life. 
 
 " To these may be added an Evangelistarium, or selections from the 
 Gospels, for the use of the church, written on parchment in the eighth 
 
 * It should be stated here, that Mr. Livermore was largely indebted to our country- 
 man and Corresponding Member, Mr. Henry Stevens, of London, for assistance in pro- 
 curing many of the valuable books contained in his library. His correspondence with 
 tliis eminent bibliographer must have covered a period of nearly twenty years. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 43 
 
 century, seven hundred years before the invention of printing, one of 
 the oldest books, if not the oldest, in this country. It was obtained at 
 the sale of the library of the Rev. Dr. Hawtrey, Provost of Eton. 
 
 " The Book of Job, a metrical version, by George Sandys, is supposed 
 to be the original autograph copy of the author. It was formerly in 
 the library of the late Duke of Sussex, and is particularly described by 
 Dr. Pettigrew, in the ' Bibliotheca Sussexiana.' 
 
 " Next in order to the manuscripts is the BIBLIA PAU- 
 PERUM, a block book, or series of wood-cuts, representing Scripture 
 subjects, with a few lines of text coarsely engraved upon the same page. 
 The precise date is not known, but bibliographers are generally agreed 
 in the opinion that it was printed as early as the year 1440. 
 
 " There is in this library a fragment of the celebrated M A Z A R I N 
 BIBLE, the first hook ever 'printed. Although the date does not ap- 
 pear, this work is well known to have been the first that issued from 
 the press of Gutenberg, and to have been completed in the year 1455. 
 Mr. L. has also the New Testament printed by Faust in 1462, being 
 the first in which the date is given, and quite a number of Bibles pub- 
 lished within the first half-century from the invention of printing. 
 Servetus's Bible, published in Lyons, 1542, is a very rare work. The 
 entire edition was ordered to be burnt, by the Roman Catholic authori- 
 ties, on account of the supposed heretical sentiments contained in tlie 
 preface and in some of the notes. The author, in 1553, shared the 
 same fate with his Bible. He was burned alive for heresy ; and as 
 many of the Bibles as could then" be found were used to kindle the 
 wood at the time of his martyrdom. But very few copies escaped the 
 flames, and there is probably no other in this country. 
 
 " Cromwell's Soldiers' Pocket Bible, of which only one other copy is 
 known to be extant, is a great curiosity. It consists of selections from 
 the Sci iptures, published in 1643, for the use of the army during tlie 
 civil wars. Here are copies of both editions of Eliot's Indian Bible, — 
 the first containing the rare dclication to King Charles IL, of wliich 
 only twenty copies were printed ; and a perfect copy of the Commentary 
 of Nicholas de Lyra, beautifully printed in black letter, in 1483, being 
 the first work of the kind ever published. 
 
 " Of English versions, Mr. L. has all the editions of Wyclif, several 
 of Coverdale, Tyndale, Cranmer, the Genevan, the Bishops, the Douay, 
 and the most remarkable editions of our present authorized version, 
 from the first black-letter folio of 1611 to the recent revision of the 
 American Bible Society. 
 
44 
 
 MEMOIR OP GEORGE LTVERMORE. 
 
 " A splendid unique large-paper copy of Reeves's Bible, with several 
 hundred original v^^ater-color illustrations, by Harris, of London, and a 
 New Testament printed entirely in letters of gold, were added to the 
 collection on account of their beauty as works of art. 
 
 " A special interest attaches to some copies of the Scriptures in Mr. 
 Livermore's library, on account of their former ownership. The Venice 
 edition of the Latin Vulgate, 1478, was once the property of the un- 
 fortunate Pope Pius VL, and has his arms stamped upon the covers. 
 On the same shelf stands Melancthon's own copy of the Bible, with 
 numerous notes on the margins in the handwriting of the Reformer. A 
 copy of the Geneva version, presented by Admiral Sir Isaac Coffin to 
 the late Rev. Dr. Homer, of Newton (from whose library it was pur- 
 chased), was supposed by its former owners to have been the identical 
 copy presented by the printer to Queen Elizabeth. The royal arms 
 can still be traced on the covers. It was printed in 1576. But the 
 Bible of Adam Winthrop, of Groton, England, the father of the first 
 Governor of Massachusetts, is more highly prized by the present pro- 
 prietor. 
 
 " A manuscript Koran, brought many years ago from Turkey, by 
 Edward Wortley Montagu, and the Book of Mormon, with the auto- 
 graph of Joseph Smith, possess an interest of a different kind. 
 
 " Mr. L. has, in a large portfolio, THE LORD'S PRAYER 
 in more than eight hundred languages and dialects. This remarkable 
 work was printed at the Imperial Office, in Vienna, and exhibited, as 
 the contribution of the Emperor of Austria, at the World's Fair in 
 London. Only a few copies were allowed to be sold. 
 
 "It maybe mentioned that the only two New-England subscribers to 
 Halliwell's magnificent edition of Shakespeare, now publishing in Eng- 
 land, in twenty folio volumes, and limited to one hundred and fifty 
 copies, are near neighbors to eacli other, — Mr. Hosmer and Mr. 
 Livermore. 
 
 " Mr. Livermore has from his boyhood been much interested in the 
 subject of general bibliography ; and he has collected a considerable 
 number of the best works on this subject, including typographical an- 
 tiquities, and accounts of the most celebrated public and private libra- 
 ries. In this department may be found nearly all the publications of 
 Dibdin, several of them presentation copies from the author; works 
 from the presses of Gutenberg, Faust, Caxton, Wynken de Worde, 
 Pynson, Baskerville, Stephen Daye, the first American printer. Dr. 
 Franklin, and nearly all the most famous printers in Europe and 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 45 
 
 America; also privately printed books from Strawberry Hill, Lee 
 Priory, the Roxburghe and other clubs. We might mention many 
 other curious and rare volumes. The larger part of this library consists 
 of standard works of English literature, history, biography, poetry, &c., 
 &c., — the best editions of the best authors." * 
 
 It may here be observed, that, after this brief and neces- 
 sarily inadequate description of his library was written in 
 1855, Mr. Livermore made large additions to it, not only of 
 Biblical works, but of works of history and of general biblio- 
 graphy. Everything which would illustrate the history of 
 printing, from the earliest period, interested him. He refers, 
 we have seen, to a fragment of the celebrated Mazarin Bible 
 which his library contained, — " the first book ever printed " on 
 movable types. Three years before his death, he purchased 
 a beautiful copy of the original edition of Coverdale's Bible, 
 printed in 1535, the first edition of the entire Bible in English. 
 It cost him one hundred and forty pounds. 
 
 A worthy Tribute to the Memory of James Johnson," " a 
 merchant of the old school," was contributed by Mr. Liver- 
 more to the " Boston Daily Advertiser," of May 4th, 1855. 
 A few copies of the " Tribute " were subsequently reprinted 
 by the friends of the deceased, for private distribution. 
 
 This year Mr. Livermore was elected a member of the 
 
 American Academy of Arts and Sciences," and he was 
 treasurer of that institution at the time of his death. 
 
 Many of Mr. Livermore's associates will recall with pleas- 
 ure the meeting of the Historical Society at his house on the 
 evening of the 26th of June, 1856. It was in the season of 
 strawberries ; and the prolific gardens of his neighbor, Mr. 
 Hovey, the well-known horticulturist, furnished for the oc- 
 casion a most abundant supply of his choicest varieties of 
 that delicate fruit. The luscious ^' seedling " which bears his 
 name, and other rival descriptions of Cambridge growth, 
 looked as if they had each been prepared for the eye of the 
 
 * See "A Glance at Private Libraries," by Luther Farnliam, Boston, 1855. 
 
 7 
 
46 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 expert, as candidates for a prize. It was, indeed, a " Straw- 
 berry Festival.''^ 
 
 Mr. Livermore's love of flowers did not desert him at this 
 time ] and the charming floral adornments which here met 
 the eye were an eloquent commentary on his exquisite taste, 
 which was not confined to books alone. 
 
 Mr. Savage, then late President of the Society, and now its 
 senior member, was not able to be present; but, as a delicate 
 compliment to his venerated friend, Mr. Livermore caused the 
 portrait of him, then recently painted by Wight for the So- 
 ciety's cabinet, to be brought to his house and hung on the 
 wall of the room in which the business meeting Avas held. 
 This served as a pleasant reminder of one whose membership 
 dates back to the year 1813, and who had for fourteen years 
 so faithfully served the Society as its chief officer. 
 
 As a part of the business of this meeting, " Mr. Livermore 
 produced a trunk containing a large collection of manuscripts 
 formerly belonging to the Hon. Judge Davis, and more re- 
 cently to Isaac P. Davis, Esq., late associates of the Society ; 
 which, in compliance with the expressed wish of the latter, 
 had been committed to Mr. Livermore's charge by Mrs. Davis 
 and the Hon. William Sturgis, executor, to be examined and 
 assorted, previously to their being deposited in the library of 
 the Society. Mr. Livermore stated that he had partially ex- 
 amined the papers, and found some of them to be of great 
 value." t They were referred to a committee, of which he was 
 chairman, to be arranged for the library according to the 
 views of the donor. The volume of Davis Papers " now 
 in the cabinet, comprises this collection. 
 
 -* For the purpose of illustrating Mr. Livermore's thoughtful care in little things, 
 which, indeed, make up the staple of every man's life, we will here recall the circum- 
 stance, that there was enclosed in the notice of this meeting, to each member, a beauti- 
 fully printed card, which served not only as a " free pass " over the railway, from " Bow- 
 doin Square" to his house on "Dana Hill," but conveyed the information that the 
 ' Business Meeting " would be held " at half-past seven o'clock. Strawberries at 
 nine o'clock. Cars return at ten o'clock." 
 
 t See Proceedings Massachusetts Historical Society for June, 1856, pp. 96, 97. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 47 
 
 This meeting at Mr. Livermore's, the first of a few rural 
 gatherings of the members as a society, is one of the pleas- 
 ant things to recall. The recollection of it revives the pic- 
 ture of one in whom the graces of purity, sweetness, re- 
 finement, gentleness, and disinterestedness,'^ to use the 
 felicitous language of Mr. Hillard respecting him, were .mar- 
 vellously combined, — in the midst of his books and of his 
 flowers, extending his warm and unstinted hospitality to his 
 associates around him. The silver cord by which he was 
 bound to us is loosed, but the sweet memories of the occa- 
 sion will ever remain ; 
 
 " The scent of the roses will hang round it still." 
 
 Thomas Dowse, the leather-dresser of Cambridgeport, the 
 collector of the magnificent Library, estimated to have cost 
 over forty thousand dollars, was a near neighbor and friend 
 of Mr. Livermore. He was a bachelor, of a quiet, retiring 
 disposition, somewhat odd withal, and he admitted few to 
 his intimacy. Mr. Livermore's warm-hearted disinterested- 
 ness won his confidence, and his love and knowledge of 
 books made him a most desirable companion. As old age 
 grew upon Mr. Dowse, and his infirmities increased, Mr. 
 Livermore made it a point to visit him almost daily. The 
 morning after the meeting of the Historical Society at his 
 house, Mr. Livermore called on Mr Dowse, taking with him 
 a dish of strawberries. The conversation naturally turned 
 on the subject of the meeting the evening before, and Mr. 
 Dowse was much interested in the account he received of it. 
 This led him to make further inquiries respecting the Society, 
 with many of whose members he was already well acquainted. 
 Soon afterwards Mr. Dowse asked Mr. Livermore if he thought 
 the Society would accept of his library. He received en- 
 couragement that they would. He then desired to see a plan 
 of their building, and the rooms which they occupied ; and 
 when he had fully decided to offer his library to the accept- 
 
48 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIYERMORE. 
 
 ance of the Society, Mr. Livermore conferred with the Presi- 
 dent, and the matter was soon consummated. The account of 
 the Special Meeting at which the announcement of the gift 
 was made, and of that which was held on the transfer of the 
 books to the rooms of the Society, after the decease of Mr. 
 Dowse, the following year, are related in the " Proceedings 
 for August, 1856, and April, 1857.^- 
 
 Mr. Livermore and Mr. Eben. Dale were appointed execu- 
 tors and trustees under Mr. Dowse's will. By this instru- 
 ment a considerable sum was left to the trustees, to dispose 
 of according to their judgment, under certain general instruc- 
 tions. The charge for fitting up the room now known as 
 ^' The Dowse Library of the Massachusetts Historical Society," 
 amounting to about three thousand dollars, was defrayed by 
 the trustees, who in addition gave the Society ten thousand 
 dollars as a fund, the income of which was to be devoted to 
 the care and administration of the library. 
 
 The trustees contributed also a fund of ten thousand dollars 
 for the establishment, in Cambridge, of a Dowse Listitute," 
 
 * Mr. Dowse had had many plans for the disposition of his library, but he could 
 decide on nothing. When Mr. Quincy was President of the College, a proposal Avas 
 made by him to Mr. Dowse, that, if he would present his library to that institution, a 
 fire-proof building should be constructed to receive it, and other provisions made for 
 its safe-keeping for ever; but ;nothing came of it. In September, 1853, early in 
 the Presidency of Dr. Walker, Mr. Dowse's health seemed to be failing, and he felt 
 anxious about his library, being at a loss what disposition to make of it, when Mr. 
 Livermore, on his behalf, informally conferred with Dr. Walker as to the probability 
 of the College consenting to receive it, if it should be offered, on the terms intimated: 
 namely, that a sepai-ate fire-proof building should be erected for it, that none of the 
 volumes should be taken from it, &c. Dr. Walker, of course, had no authority, of him- 
 self, to accept or to decline such an offer, had it been made; and he had no wish to 
 divert such a gift from the College: but he saw that the terms suggested would involve 
 a serious expense to the Corporation, without an equivalent. He, however, assured Mr. 
 Livermore, that, without doubt, if the library should be presented to the College, 
 arrangements would be made to give it a place by itself in Gore Hall. 
 
 There seemed at one time to be danger that this collection of books would come to 
 the hammer. Mr. Dowse once offered to give it to Mr. Livermore, who, of course, 
 declined it. Mr. Dowse finally proposed, as stated in the text, to place his libi-ary in 
 the custody of the Society of which his friend, Mr. Livermore, was a prominent mem- 
 ber. This suggestion was warmly seconded by Mr. Livermore, and to him is the Histori- 
 cal Society largely indebted for the final disposition made of this noble library. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 49 
 
 for public lectures, &c. This sum was paid over to the city 
 of Cambridge, which, in return, agreed to pay annually, for- 
 ever, to the trustees of the Institute, six hundred dollars. 
 
 Mr. Dowse's fine collection of paintings in water-colors was 
 given to the Boston Athenasum, of which institution Mr. Liv- 
 ermore was a trustee. 
 
 It will not require a reference to the records of the Soci- 
 ety, to recall a similar meeting of the members to that just de- 
 scribed, which, two years after, was held, by invitation of Mr. 
 Longfellow, at his house in Cambridge, — the house which was 
 for nine months the residence and headquarters of Washing- 
 ton. The meeting was summoned in the afternoon of the 
 17th of June, the anniversary of the battle of Bunker Hill. 
 Mr. Livermore was chairman of the Standing Committee this 
 year, and he used every means, in co-operation with the other 
 officers of the Society, to make this meeting worthy of the 
 occasion. On the notices issued to the members he caused to 
 be printed a wood-cut impression of the ancient mansion 
 where the meeting was to be held. The following character- 
 istic note was received from him a few days before the meet- 
 ing:— 
 
 " Wednesday Morning, June 9tli. 
 
 " Dear D , — Thinking that you might like to preserve a tmt- 
 
 ed copy of the notice of our grand meeting to be held on the 17th, I 
 send you one of each shade. The regular Society's notice is printed ou 
 white paper, but half a dozen or more of a ' fancy ' character were 
 struck off to be sent to the ' Saints.' . . . The meeting is likely to be 
 the most interesting one ever held by the Society. 
 
 " Yours ever affectionately." 
 
 Mr. Livermore's fondest expectations concerning the meet- 
 ing at Mr. Longfellow's were fully realized. There were 
 present, among others, Mr. Everett, Judge Shaw, Mr. Adams, 
 Mr. Willard, Mr. Richard Frothingham, Mr. Paige, and Dr. 
 Ellis, who severally addressed the meeting. The President, 
 Mr. Winthrop, called the meeting to order at half-past five 
 
50 
 
 MEMOIR -OF GEORGE LIVERMORE; 
 
 o'clock, and in bis opening remarks alluded to the occasion 
 and the place, and also to the circumstances under which 
 General Washington assumed the command of the American 
 army in 1775. " None could have entered this venerable 
 mansion," he said, " without recaUing the words which the ac- 
 complished host once addressed to a child, but which are no less 
 adapted to stir the feelings of full-grown men: — 
 
 " ' Once, all ! once, within these walls, 
 One whom memory oft recalls, 
 The Father of his Country, dwelt ; 
 And yonder meadows, broad and damp, 
 The fires of the besieging camp 
 Encircled with a burning belt. 
 Up and down these echoing stairs. 
 Heavy with the weight of cares. 
 Sounded his majestic tread : 
 Yes, within this very room 
 Sat he in those hours of gloom. 
 Weary both in heart and head.' " 
 
 All his remarks were excellent, as were those of the mem- 
 bers who followed him. During the evening Mr. Livermore 
 exhibited several most interesting relics associated with 
 Washington and his times ; and Mr. Everett, who at Mr. Liv- 
 ermore's request had drawn up a statement relative to the 
 preparation and delivery of his celebrated discourse " On the 
 Character of Washington," submitted that statement to the 
 meeting. After the business was over, the invitation of the 
 host to partake of strawberries and cream was not declined ; 
 and every one present felt that he had good reason to remem- 
 ber " the 17th of June," 1858. 
 
 In 1859 Mr. Livermore was elected a member of the 
 Executive Committee of the " American Unitarian Associa- 
 tion," and he almost invariably attended its monthly meetings. 
 In 1864 he was elected Yice-President of the Association, 
 a position which he held at his death. Besides giving his 
 active personal services, he was a liberal contributor to its 
 funds. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 51 
 
 On the 30th of April, 1860, we find him collecting the snb- 
 scriptions, which he had before solicited, for the " Quincy 
 statue," as the treasurer wishes to remit the first instalment, 
 of two thousand dollars, by the next Wednesday's steamer. 
 This refers to the statue of President Quincy by Story, yet 
 in the studio of the artist in Rome. 
 
 The copy of the " Soldiers' Pocket Bible " belonging to Mr. 
 Livermore, has been already referred to. It was very rare ; only 
 one other copy was known to exist, and that was in the British 
 Museum. He had for some time thought of reprinting it for 
 distribution among his friends, — " for the saints," as he used 
 playfully to style those for whom he designed the few copies 
 of any work privately got up by him. In 1861, Mr. Hough- 
 ton, of the Riverside Press, printed for him one hundred 
 copies, in fac-siinile. He at the same time had ten copies 
 printed on parchment, three on vellum, and two on India 
 paper."^ It came from the press about the 1st of June. 
 The American Tract Society, in both its branches, thinking 
 it would serve a useful purpose as a religious manual for 
 the soldiers in our army, reprinted it in large numbers as a 
 tract. How extensively it was circulated among the soldiers, 
 and how much good it accomplished, we have no means 
 of knowing. The book, in the original, is a 12mo, or 16mo, 
 of 16 pages. It is made up of passages from the Bible, or 
 rather from the Old Testament, — there being but two cita- 
 tions from the New Testament. Those passages in which 
 God's chosen people are referred to as fighting God's enemies 
 are introduced. Cromwell's soldiers no doubt felt, as did the 
 Jews, that they were the Lord's elect" ; and this little volume 
 may have served to nerve them to the conflict. It may well 
 be doubted if such a tract would better the condition of our 
 soldiers at this day, either morally or mentally ; or improve 
 them as fighting men. Its chief value now must be historical. 
 
 * Through Mr. Livermore the attention of Mr. Francis Fry had been called to the 
 Soldiers' Pocket Bible," and he had an edition in facsimile printed in England, in 
 
52 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 In 18G2 a reprint of the " Bay Psalm Book/' consisting of 
 fifty copies, on laid paper, was executed by Mr. Houghton, 
 for Charles B. Richardson, a bookseller in New York. Mr. 
 Livermore's name appears on the list of subscribers for one 
 of the fifty copies. But he secured, also, one copy to be 
 struck off on parchment, — the only one printed. There were 
 at the same time five copies printed on India paper, of which 
 Mr. Livermore's library contains one. 
 
 The proof-sheets of this reprint of the Bay Psalm Book " 
 were revised and corrected by our associate, Mayor Shurt- 
 leff, Avho, in his introduction to the volume, says, — " In the 
 reproduction of this quaint volume, every word, every letter, 
 and indeed every point, has been sedulously collated with a 
 perfect impression of the original work struck at Cambridge 
 in the year 1640." 
 
 At the annual meeting of the American Antiquarian Society, 
 at Worcester, in October, 1864, Mr. Livermore read the report 
 of the Council. The principal theme dwelt upon in this 
 paper was suggested by the recent decease of Mr. Quincy. 
 He gave an analysis of Mr. Quincy's writings, and endeavored 
 to show that each of his works had been the product of his 
 personal experience in the active duties in which he had been 
 engaged through life. It was an admirably conceived and 
 an admirably written paper. A few copies of the remarks 
 commemorative of Mr. Quincy were struck off separately from 
 the pamphlet of " Proceedings," for private distribution. 
 
 And here we are reminded that, from the time Mr. Liver- 
 more was elected a member of our sister society at Worcester, 
 he rarely failed to attend its meetings, whether held in that 
 city or in Boston. Nothing but the most imperative engage- 
 ments ever kept him away from the annual meetings, which 
 are always held in Worcester. The ride through that beau- 
 
 1862, from the only other original copy known, that in the British Museum. He also, 
 the same year, reproduced in facsimile an edition of *' The Christian Soldier's Penny 
 Bible," from a copy of the original edition in his possession, dated London, 1693, — 
 a little manual of sixteen pages. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 53 
 
 tiful part of the State, with his associates, the Boston mem- 
 bers, in that season of the year when the foliage puts on its 
 brilliant and varied hue, could not fail to have an attraction 
 for him in itself. Then the warm greeting he was sure to 
 receive at " Antiquarian Hall," from the grave and reverend 
 seigniors there assembled, including always Governor Lin- 
 coln and Judge Barton, — ^' not dead, but gone before " ; then 
 the mental repast served up to the meeting in the Report of 
 the Council, of which the Librarian's Report — invariably so 
 rich in curious learning, and keen and wholesome criticism — 
 always forms a part ; and, finally, the elegant hospitality of 
 the President of the Society : to share all this, was a rare 
 treat to our friend ; and the 21st of October was a red-letter 
 day in Mr. Livermore's calendar. 
 
 In November, 1864, Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes delivered 
 a lecture before the " Dowse Institute " in Cambridge, entitled 
 New England's Master-Key " ; in the course of which he 
 endeavored to show what had been accomplished by those 
 who had devoted their literary labors to one special object ; 
 and he instanced among others, as illustrating the truth of his 
 remark, George Livermore. 
 
 Reference was made to Mr. Livermore's copartnership with 
 his brother Isaac, in 1838. The older brother retired from 
 the business in 1846 ; and Mr. Livermore, for the five fol- 
 lowing years, continued on in company with a nephew. After 
 remaining alone about a year, he was, in 1852, invited to a 
 partnership in the Boston branch of the extensive wool busi- 
 ness of Aaron Erickson, of Rochester, N. Y., which subsisted 
 until 1857, when the firm of " Livermore & Morse " was 
 formed, which was dissolved only by his death. 
 
 Mr. Livermore took pride in his calling as a merchant, and 
 for many years devoted his best energies during the hours 
 of business to its demands. He was conservative and cautious 
 in his business views, and was uneasy under large pecuniary 
 responsibilities ; preferring small gains with corresponding 
 
 8 
 
54 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 safety to the pursuit of larger acquisitions with the usual at- 
 tendant risks. He had the satisfaction through life of always 
 meeting his engagements. 
 
 The financial storm which swept over the country in the 
 autumn of 1857, prostrating almost everything before it, was 
 of fearful portent to our friend. He felt that all he had 
 was gone, and that the only thing left was to maintain his 
 mercantile honor and credit, which was done. The speedy 
 recurrence, three years later, of a similar crisis, occasioned 
 by the breaking out of the Rebellion, was another trial, which 
 taxed the highest energies of every merchant who had accept- 
 ances to meet, or notes to pay. But when the government 
 began to call out the troops, which had to be clothed and fed 
 and provided with all the equipments of war, such a demand 
 was made upon the raw material and industry of the country, 
 that, with the added influence of the suspension of specie 
 payments, and consequent appreciation of merchandise, all 
 embarrassments were removed, and, in the next few years, 
 large fortunes were realized by many. Mr. Livermore 
 shared in this success ; and, during the war, acquired an 
 amount of property such as previously he had been a 
 stranger to. 
 
 On the actual breaking out of the Rebellion, Mr. Livermore 
 threw himself into the cause of the Union with all his charac- 
 teristic energy and zeal. With him there was no temporizing, 
 no " good Lord " and " good Devil." His trumpet gave no 
 uncertain sound. He attended recruiting-meetings, joined a 
 "Home Guard," and drilled and marched for miles, at times, 
 with a musket on his shoulder, which, with his frail and 
 delicate frame, was almost like bearing his cross. As his 
 means enabled him, he gave freely ; and, throughout the 
 war, he poured out his money like water for the cause. 
 
 * In the second year of the war, when it was proposed to raise a fund for the relief 
 of the families of the soldiers of Cambridge, the following letter from Mr. Livermore 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 55 
 
 As he could not go to the field, he considered himself bound 
 to do in other ways all that lay in his power to maintain the 
 integrity of the Union. One of his sons was in the army, but 
 that did not absolve him from duty. During the twelve 
 months which preceded his death he spent for public objects 
 and for private charities nearly twenty-five thousand dollars. 
 
 Not content with all this, when the discussion arose whether 
 the government should accept colored troops, and there were 
 strong doubts even among the most loyal as to its expediency, 
 he prepared with great labor, and published at great expense, a 
 work of over two hundred pages, which he entitled " An His- 
 torical Research respecting the Opinions of the Founders of 
 the Republic, on Negroes as Slaves, as Citizens, and as Sol- 
 diers." The substance of this work was read before this Soci- 
 ety at a stated meeting, 14th August, 1862 ; and the President 
 of the Society, Mr. Wiuthrop, has since said of it, that it would 
 alone have been " enough to secure for him a reputation 
 which any of us might envy." His purpose was to show 
 
 was read to a meeting of citizens held for the consideration of this subject at the City- 
 Hall:— 
 
 " Dana Hill, Aug. 9, 1862. 
 
 " Hon. J. M. S. Williams. 
 
 "My DEAR Sir, — I cannot be present with you, in person, this evening, as 1 had in- 
 tended, but you need not be told that my heart is with you. The more I reflect on the 
 subject of the proposed fund of twenty-five thousand dollars for the relief of the families 
 of the soldiers, by the way of insurance on their lives, and in the other manner suggested in 
 the circular of the Committee, the more I am convinced of the merit and excellence of the 
 plan ; and I ask you to alter my subscription from five hundred dollars to one thousand 
 dollars. To save the Committee the trouble of collecting this amount, I now enclose a 
 United-States Treasury-note for the sum, with interest at seven and three-tenths per 
 cent. I have been much gratified at the readiness of our citizens to respond to this 
 call. The whole sum of twenty -five thousand dollars will be made up, I am sure, in a 
 few days, if it is not secured at the meeting this evening. When this subscription is 
 full, we must all be ready for something else. Until the war is over, we must dedicate 
 our time, our money, our lives, — and, what may be dearer to us than any of these, our 
 brothers and sons, — to the service of our country. When we are thoroughly aroused 
 to the value of the liberty we are defending, we shall feel that no sacrifice is too great 
 for us to make in its behalf. And when we rise to this point of patriotism, God will 
 surely crown our cause with complete success. 
 
 " I am, very truly, yours, 
 
 " George Livermore." 
 
56 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 that the patriots of the Revolution regarded the negro as a 
 man, capable of bearing arms, and of being a citizen ; and 
 he saw no reason why he should not be allowed to do his part, 
 side by side with his white brother, in upholding the flag of 
 his country. 
 
 " Among the agencies which swayed the public mind at 
 that time," says a distinguished civilian, this publication 
 cannot be forgotten." Attorney-General Bates acknowledged 
 his obligation to it in making up his opinions on the status of 
 the negro ; and " it is within my own knowledge," says Sen- 
 ator Sumner, that it interested President Lincoln much. The 
 President expressed a desire to consult it while he was pre- 
 paring the final Proclamation of Emancipation ; * and, as his 
 own copy was mislaid, he requested me to send him mine, 
 which I did." f 
 
 This work was issued in five different editions, in a most 
 luxurious style ; fifty copies of two of the editions having 
 been printed on " large paper." The most of the copies were 
 distributed gratuitously. The whole cost of this work, some 
 three or four thousand dollars, was borne by Mr. Livermore ' 
 himself. A pamphlet of eight pages of extracts from it was 
 published soon after, in Philadelphia, by Henry C. Baird, en- 
 titled " George Washington and General Jackson on Negro 
 Soldiers," of which over one hundred thousand copies were 
 printed. J 
 
 While declining all oflScial positions, Mr. Livermore was in 
 frequent correspondence with leading politicians and states- 
 men, and with some of them maintained the most intimate 
 and confidential relations. 
 
 * The pen with which Mr. Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation was 
 presented to Mr. Livermore by the President, and was treasured among his cherished 
 memorials. 
 
 t See notice of " The Death of George Livermore," in the " Boston Daily Adver- 
 tiser," Sept. 2, 1865. 
 
 J In 1864, there was issued from the "Riverside Press" of Mr. Houghton the first 
 volume of a new edition of "The Federalist," edited by Mr. Henry B. Dawson, of 
 Morrisania, N. Y., and dedicated to Mr. Livermore in warm and flattering terms. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 57 
 
 The following extract of a letter from Mr. Livermore, dated 
 March 30th, 1863, written in reply to one addressed to him, 
 containing a memorial of a young gentleman of rare culture 
 and social position, who enlisted in the army as a common 
 soldier, and lost his life in the service, shows the same devo- 
 tion to the cause of his country, — a devotion which con- 
 tinued to the last. 
 
 " I never had the pleasure of a personal acquaintance with Mr. 
 
 H but I knew of his talents, his genius, his patriotism, and his 
 
 general worth. I honor his memory more than any poor words at my 
 command can express. I should value more the honorable record of 
 such a life, brief though it might be, than the showier demonstrations 
 which begin and end with po]3ular applause. This wicked war, con- 
 ceived in sin and slavery, and waged for the destruction of national 
 liberty, — how costly are the sacrifices which it demands ! You and I, 
 my dear friend, will yet have to make still greater offerings for our 
 country, before the strife is ended. But nothing we have or are can be 
 too much to bestow, be it all our means, our friends, our children, and 
 our own lives, if we can redeem our nation, and establish it on the sure 
 foundation of Justice and Liberty. The nation will be saved, and will 
 rise from its degradation and sorrow. But we must suffer more before 
 the glorious day shall dawn." 
 
 Mr. Livermore's constitution, as has been already stated, 
 was feeble, and his health was poor through life. But he 
 had a strong will, which carried him through difficulties from 
 which many of more robust constitutions would have shrunk. 
 During the winter of 1864-65, his health seemed feebler 
 than usual. The issues of the war, now rapidly culminating, 
 affected him intensely ;• and as the spring opened, bringing 
 with it the joyful events of the downfall of Richmond and 
 the capture of Lee, so soon followed by the terrible tragedy 
 of the death of President Lincoln, his delicate organization 
 received a shock almost beyond what it could bear. 
 
 * This was Francis Custis Hopkinson, of the Class of 1859 of Harvard College. 
 He was a member of the Fortj^-fourth Massachusetts Infantr3\ See " Harvard Memorial 
 Biographies," ii. 21. 
 
58 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 A few days after the assassination at Washington, he attend- 
 ed a meeting of the Historical Society, and in some remarks 
 relative to that event enjoined upon the members the duty of 
 self-consecration, anew, to the service of their country. He 
 was deeply affected, and spoke with intense feeling. 
 
 At the following meeting, in May, he was likewise present. 
 In the latter part of that month he went to West Point on 
 a brief visit to his son. On Wednesday, the 24th, having 
 returned, he writes from his residence on Dana Hill, — "I 
 came home from West Point on Monday with a lame leg, 
 which is likely to keep me a prisoner in my house for some 
 time ; otherwise, I should call and see you." * 
 
 He seemed to be getting better during the few weeks fol- 
 lowing, and received the visits of some of his friends. He 
 was much interested in the Eulogy on President Lincoln, 
 pronounced by his friend, Mr. Sumner, on the 1st of June, 
 at the Music Hall, a copy of which in print was furnished 
 him on the day of its delivery, — the Eulogy having been 
 delivered by Mr. Sumner from the printed sheets. But 
 towards the last of June, he had a relapse from which he 
 never recovered. On the 28th of July he writes, — "I feel 
 more comfortable this morning than I have done since my 
 last relapse, four weeks ago ; and although confined to 
 my bed, and only allowed to read a little each day, and 
 forbidden to see company, I manage to maintain my faith 
 and patience thus far. The doctor does not dream that I 
 write. I would not ask his permission, for fear of being 
 denied. I have a curious and convenient table, which 
 projects over my bed; and I can, whilst reclining, use 
 my pen a few moments each day very comfortably. I thank 
 you for your kind note of the 15th. It is nearly ten weeks, 
 now, since I have been shut out from the active duties of 
 life, and a word from a friend is cheering. Although the 
 
 * His infirmity proved to be phlebitis, or inflammation of the veins. 
 
MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 59 
 
 doctors say I must not see company, there is hardly a day 
 when I should not see you for a few moments if you called, 
 and I should be blest by the sight." During a brief inter- 
 view with him, three days after this, though pale and much 
 emaciated, he seemed in most excellent spirits. He was full 
 of hope and of gratitude. He probably then had not given up 
 all thoughts of recovery, and of being restored to his friends 
 and the active duties of life. But it was otherwise ordered. 
 Three days before his death he was attacked with paralysis, 
 and he died on the 30th of August. 
 
 In this notice of Mr. Livermore, the purpose has not been 
 to pronounce a eulogy upon him, but to state some of the 
 principal facts of his life, agreeably to the custom followed 
 by the Historical Society in the Memoirs of its deceased 
 members. The estimation in which Mr. Livermore was held 
 in the community, — and, indeed, by all who knew him, — 
 and the great loss sustained in his death, were attempted 
 to be expressed, at the first meeting of the Society follow- 
 ing that event, in remarks by the President and some of the 
 associate members, which were published in the " Proceed- 
 ings." Other societies and associations with which he was 
 connected bore a united and willing testimony to his great 
 worth. Reference may also be made to an admirable dis- 
 course, entitled " The Consecrated Life," preached to the 
 Cambridgeport Parish, on the 3d of September, 1865, by 
 the pastor, the Rev. Henry C. Badger ; likewise to the elo- 
 quent and appreciative sermon, entitled " The Public Duty 
 of a Private Citizen," preached in the South Congregational 
 Church, Boston, on the same Sunday, by our associate, the 
 Rev. Edward E.Hale. An interesting article in the ''At- 
 lantic Monthly" for November, 1865, entitled '' The Visible 
 
 * A beautiful tribute to the moral and religious traits of Mr. Livermore's character 
 Avas at this time paid by his friend, our associate, Mr. Folsom, — now himself prostrated 
 on a bed of sickness, — in the form of a letter to Admiral Farragut, which was read at 
 the meeting, and printed in the " Proceedings." 
 
60 
 
 MEMOIR OF GEORGE LIVERMORE. 
 
 and Invisible in Libraries," written by Mrs. Waterston, con- 
 tains the following passage in reference to our friend and 
 to his exquisite library : — 
 
 "The sileut library of George Livermore speaks eloquently of 
 him. That collection, gathered with a love which increased as years 
 advanced, includes ancient copies of the Bible of rarest value. His 
 hfe was a book, written over with good deeds and pure thoughts, illu- 
 minated by holy aspirations. That volume is closed, but the spirit 
 which rendered it precious is not withdrawn : living in many hearts, 
 it will continue to be a cherished presence in the world, the home, 
 and the library." * 
 
 Nothing could be added, were it desired, to these tributes 
 to our loved and lamented associate. 
 
 Mr. Livermore left three sons, his only children : the eld- 
 est, Frank, now a physician, settled in Paris in the practice 
 of his profession ; the second, William Roscoe, a graduate of 
 West Point, in high standing, connected with the engineer 
 department of the United-States Army; the third, Charles 
 Cunningham, residing with his mother in Cambridge. 
 
 * Mr. Livermore's residence was on the corner of Dana and Main Streets, on " Dana 
 Hill," just within the limits of " Old Cannbridoe," where he lived for nearly twenty-five 
 years. A few years before his death he built an addition to his house, of a library- 
 room, for the better accommodation of his books. It is a charming apartment, and 
 everything remains just as he left it. By his will, his library was bequeathed to his 
 wife. 
 
i