rOSTER THE CONTINUATION SCHOOL Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2016 https://archive.org/details/continuationschoOOfost THE CONTINUATION SCHOOL BY ISAAC OWEN FOSTER B.S. University of Illinois, 1921 THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE IN EDUCATION IN THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS, 1922 URBANA, ILLINOIS r ' .V '"•■f ’ 1 y ' ■', .'V ■ - • •- •.■■4si>MM 'if- A i vlOOJDa VtOLTATJ/lTVIOD 3HT ii • ' t ': ' ■' V 'I'f ■ 0 'i® I *\l •. •.'■■•'. '*’'' ^' ■ '■ '0* A. s «•-. V'Vti __ r .-’ ♦/.' 7.V ■* '’u. ' ■■' ■ TJi ; -'-■ . f S' '• . >•■».'’ '‘ 'iiv , ’ ■*•■ ■■ i-'l-iS ,J •“ * .'‘''S i : . i V*'. '. "; . •* \ Ml W. *"' 1 / ... I .- . . - v'^ '■ ■ :' 10 m U '■' ^ .fcfi . - ' . , ; 4^''' -fV'. 7* -f *v ■ ;r •■' ■ i iww 0 .. ' '!?:'*«. if JgMB >,■ r-' mv .V v-'V- . 1 ^ ■ ijuit A^ym% ytt, . 'i w>ii’A*7i;)UM' VL) ^ta' aaa Aar-i.' sm- nut , , ■ rn««a.’’/iivjftr ' n.wpi’: 'to ' , :• ittfM 8 JIOV 5 U.IT ' a *' .*'V\’.>-'<^ , :: ;■’!«* .yT ■ rn'fC 3 a.’’/?v|^' Fv - ^ .,:.::...ll .:' V <^'4 '' ."'KSr : . - %0<: ^ M =ii University of Illinois Library Manuscript Theses Unpublished theses submitted for the Master's r deposited in the University 0 llinois Library are open for inspection, but are to be used only with due regard to the rights of the aut ors. Bibliographical references may be noted, but passages may be copied only with permission of the authors, and proper credit must be given in sub- sequent written or published work. Extensive copy- ing or publication of the thesis in whole or in part consent of the Dean of the Graduate School of the University ot Illinois. This Thesis by . . - has been used by the following persons, whose signa- tures attest their acceptance of the above restric- tions. A Library which borrows this thesis for use bv Its patrons is expected to secure the signature of each user. NAME AND ADDRESS DATE TT?TTT-tTP ) 92 ^ Fell UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS THE GRADUATE SCHOOL -192-2- 1 HEREBY RECOMMEND THAT THE THESIS PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION BY Xsajic Owen j'oster ENTITLED jUie^Gxmt-inuatio 21- School BE ACCEPTED AS FULFILLING THIS PART OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF^llas ter., oT Science in Education Recommendation concurred in* Committee on Final Examination* Required for doctor’s degree but not for master’s , .iiii (itf’m. Vif ■:' I fiiovriaai YT:aH3viJ>?u JOOHOe HTAa<1A>»ri 3;HT '.■■ -r ; DT :5clxrt,, ,' V , ‘ V I , |, ' ■ nmwl^.a) j , ' ' '^- ' j . I'^.t l;v.‘ -V ■ V ■ ‘ W h 33 •’ ',. ipM-''’"' . , - V' ' .%'y ,i .^!).y- 'y ■' ■ , <: J, *nlriifd^ifaa lOMJiil. I .^‘ A"' j^' if S^' $ b' - ».. 1 a" ■ • :'■ 'J ■ • \\ ■ ■■*-.- . • '•'^■. ■' ».. .., .. . — K ». j;^. ,- •■■• “Sl^;.. ■ , i ]ii*?i nAy*;'l ■ f imw^ a'‘V> ■ i ' ,. ,,rti i>TV < . M -' " '-t, ■' rf* ' .’LhS !?®''i"'''.. .,i ■ •'^H ;\r. ■’ ■"■'•*V'^':;lii {K . „ ,M.:: .-i; fij CONTENTS Chapter Page I. The Basis of The Study .... l II. A Brief Survey of The Continuation School Movement 36 III. Some Factors in Organization and Administration 59 IV. Retrospect and Prospect .... 105 Appendix I. Provisions of Part-Time Compulsory Education Laws 115 II. Funds Available under The Smith-Hughes Act . 116 List of Works Consulted: The Bibliography . . n? THE CONTINUATION SCHOOL Chapter I The Basis of The Study Education an Evolutionary Process Modern education is a labyrinth of serious problems which are becoming constantly more complex and which are continually increasing at a tremendous rate. Many of the problems of yesterday are more difficult today, and many of them have undergone such a change that the educator of a century ago would hardly recognize them now. This crucial situation is caused primarily by a more complex society which needs larger and more thorough facilities for its accomodation, and this need has been the chief factor in making the school system of the United States much larger and more complicated than it was a few decades ago. Since society has made new and larger demands on educational authorities many new problems gradually have been added to the old mass of educational difficulties which are the school man's heritage. One of these problems which is both new and old is the continuation school, an institution some- what aged in idea and experiment but new in possibilities, as this thesis will endeavor to show in the following chapters. Purposeful activity is a practical expression of the motives and ideals of individuals either separately or •W A-fc r, -X JtfttjC 1- . t- ■r ■■ V • ' '^v 'Ysa*— ' • f.' ' ’''■'^A-'^L\,'i^ % 'V MKlTOfcaU''^' ’ * •'Vr^SP WJh ■ r >'T-^~ M ’ ,<• r fi ' /■^l02!8F-I’t^ ■' ’ ’ />»'Sir *1itit'‘ L X ■ -jif? ^'!i: v^.i rj ‘ ' ■' * v.i , ■' . V' ^ rt , ' ** vi \ - ■'Jt V-; ,. %'i » ■' 'Li*'< sS;: ■f‘- 6, . J '- ■ tj/ulM *'’»Wrrf<»i.-- •• ,^’''rAOyre v*^' • ' ■'. V- ‘■•‘ . . ' ' ‘ *!*? r-y'/i'’*'’ ir‘* * 4. •’• '? ‘ ''-/»L . :. ;-4'ta,:, iirt;- ■ ..-to*?' fiX ^orr^Jf^f^VU ■> -V-' '' •Irff.Oft^' v^^V l|^, '-Mi . < ^7* Jr' ' ^ ' '• •’ • ^ iii-: '!'»• . ‘ ' ' '. ■ •■ ''' ' I ^ t ' ' ' ^ ‘ ^ ^ .'WjiSMHE ‘ a' 4idlt..'£i ,1. 1 .J, , ,, J'l • - 2 - collectively, and the continuous change of problems in the school is due largely to the change of these motives and ideals which frequently themselves become modified in the light of experiment and consideration from various angles. Evidence of this appears in abundance if a careful study is made of such somewhat supplementary factors of education as its aims and its curricula as these have existed at various stages in the history of the world. Hence, three illustrations are in- corporated at this point to substantiate this contention: First, the Spartan held the militaristic ideal of a perfect and paramount state brought about by the physical efficiency of the individuals who composed the state, and his education included ball-playing, dancing, running, jumping, discus-hurling, javelin-throwing, and wrestling, while little attention was paid to intellectual training.^ Secondly, the Roman looked upon the orator as being the ideal man of culture and refine- ment for his state, and to accomplish this aim rhetorical schools were established which included a very broad curriculim and afforded training in those subjects that were believed to be necessary for or accessory to the making of a man of eloquence and power .^Thirdly, the aim of present-day education has been expressed by Bagley and has been accepted by educators as "social efficiency"* hence, in order to make the individual socially efficient the curricula of the public schools include vocational, social, physical, and aesthetic training, 1 Graves, Frank P., A Student's History of Education, 11-12. 2 Ibid., 38. - 3 - These examples illustrate the truth that social evolution has been going on in the educational phases of human endeavor by being given expression in the purposes and curricula of the school. Further, they are representative of a legion of others which show equally well that education is an evolutionary process, a series 6f activities, which constantly change in terms of their purposes. The Continuation School Idea Out of this evolutionary process all phases of modern education have emerged and they center in the public school as the chief agency. For many years the public school has attempted to educate the children of our republic. It has been criticized often and severely; yet its good results never can be estimated. Its defects which are many have been magnified as it has raced with the development Of democracy. In order to remedy some of its most striking: defects many reforms which were the results of some more or less far-sighted ideas have been undertaken and some of them have been successfully realized. One of these evolutionary problems, however, that has not been completely realized is the desire to place an education within the reach of every individual regardless of his social or economic status. Since this problem cannot be solved by the traditional public school alone and since the continuation school, if properly organized and administered, has many ‘ possibilities in this direction the term, "continuation idea", has been selected to denote the ideal of placing an education within the reach of those people who have not been educated acceptably by the regular public school and who have severed their student - 4 - connections with this institution. One of the important steps towards the realization of the continuation idea was undertaken when an organized effort was begun for the purpose of keeping children in school until they were prepared for their particular work in life. As a result compulsory attendance laws were enacted and more or less enforced, but these did not prove to be a panacea for all the evils of the illiterate and unprepared portion of the people because the public school did not train for any particular work in life and because the children were not required to attend long enough to learn certain trades and professions. Another step towards the realization of this ideal was the movement against child labor which during the present century swept over practically every section of the United States. Both federal and local statutes were enacted and as a result many children who were forced out of employment turned back to the public school. Since that movement began, in some states, such as Illinois, the standards have been raised in order that the children might receive as much real schooling as possible before entering industry, A third movement toward the continuation idea was the establishment of voluntary evening schools both for adults and for minors. Through this agency an opportunity to obtain an education was made possible for a large number of people who previously had had no such opportunity offered to them. This kind of continuation education is without the province of this thesis except as is sheds light on the realization of the continuation idea. I - 5 - In the fourth place, the movement for continuation education began to receive more and more stress in an effort to reach those who were in employment and whom the compulsory attendance and child labor laws did not affect. This movement was an effort to realize the continuation idea, the offering of educational facilities and advantages to all who oared to profit by them. The carrying out of this idea began with the younger members of society and is proceeding towards the older. When the idea shall be realized fully the adult worker may receive instruction in the public school at public expense at evenings or during his leisure (and frequently, perhaps, during the regular working day) . But will the realization of the continuation idea make everybody socially efficient? Certainly not, but it will open the doors of opportunity to a large number of people who under the present scheme lack such opportunities for educational advancement. In this way Americans democracy will tend to be- come more equitable in opportunity and its people will tend to be more socially efficient. This work already has been begun. An important link in the chain was forged when during the last decade the Congress of the United States enacted the Smith— Hughes Law, but before taking up the history of the movement the limits of the term with which we deal are necessary: Hence, the dis- cussion of the conception of the continuation school is now in order. The Continuation School Defined Sneddon says that "a continuation school should be de- fined to include only schools on which attendance is compulsory for a minimum of a stated number of hours per week within the I ordinary working day of young persons employed gainfully." ^ The chief objection to this definition is the compulsory require- ment. Beyond question at the present time compulsory attendance is necessary for the highest efficiency either in the traditional elementary school or in the continuation school; however, either would still remain a school without the compulsory requirement. It would still serve those people who would take advantage of its educational facilities. Hence, this idea is unnecessary in the exact definition of the continuation school, Taylor defines the continuation school as "a school for persons engaged in useful employment, which gives instruction supplementary to such employment. This statement is not acceptable because it has only an industrial significance. The industrial phase is very important; but it, alone, is too narrow. It forms only a part of the truth and not the "whole truth."' Cooley declares that the continuation school is any institution that devotes itself to the further education of "young people who have outgrown the elementary school." ^ Neither this statement nor its context points out why the author of it considers the transition to have taken place when the pupil has outgrown the elementary school. According to this statement the high school, the university, and any other school above the eighth grade (or ninth grade in some few cases) would be a continuation school. Then why not say that the elementary school is a continuation school because it continues the de- velopment of the pupil above the kindergarten? Why limit the 3 Sneddon, David, Vocational Education, 333, 4 Taylor, Joseph S., A Handbook for Vocational Education, 86-87. 5 Cooley, Edwin G., Vocational Education in Europe, 82. '^^ ■ F jrli-.. *.^>4 Nf (i^C' ai ^ Y&iie.". • ;*»i^:.';rKl-*4A .»4.' 'J'^- \(t« ^ : V • .J: '-^‘ ! » j ■’'• , f -i . * >f*! 6 a 4 ^pti 3 l;f 'ifc* ^ * i‘ '* '^? ' ■ ■^- ■■■Hf.. t i. C.O!i^j . 'fit I > jam (is a, a > ■ . ■* i ^ ^ :» j ' * ■> . ^<'1 A” lu^ rt oxie^ . ofi t i ** ■• i# . y ' ;t jy i^*" mu ^ ^ M-' .' r j^r .'^■' ' ''^ ■ ' ' » *" ' lii?' * ’^ 1 ^’ -' 4 fqgi;i!^ M^'' I si 't ' ! -R! • •f.'i* ’ vV* ■-*. J«j i ^fV 31 u :,Vi5i».' _ c '.\ ;3ei'e»,.Jr.C. r .. .-..oci-L J^j5:w;.i .,>%o iii^ >1 . . U ‘ \ ... ,• )4 • ^ f I ■ ' . ^ • ; f- -v .". . ■;•; ■ ..*■>, ^.^.F;;,.,, ^ '‘■^51 'te*'"' 88 Si .’•*.\v^' ^'.r' ■ '/T » .lf .L ‘ ^ ' (;t. -r. 0 .at -r^i? 'S'/ .: ^ n W* 1 ' ► ''■ •' 4 i-' '■ ■ '--‘‘ usually minors, who are gainfully employed and who are not attending the regular day school. A distinguishing feature of this institution is that it is a part-time school. The pupil works part of the time and attends the continuation school part of the time, the major amount of the said time being spent usually at his work. Hence, the name, part-time school , is very frequently used instead of the term, continuation school. The continuation school, as it is used in this discussion, does not coincide with the continuation idea. The latter is broader and more comprehensive than the former. It is an ideal which stands before the educational world, while the former is the substance of the institution which is gradually evolving from the traditional public school towards the realization of the continuation idea. The possible future progress of the continuation school towards this end will be discussed in a later chapter of this thesis. For the present, however, it is better to concentrate on the social conditions underlying its justification; then, the growth of the continuation idea ajid the continuation school itself will be noticed; later, the question of administration and organization will be dealt with; and finally, a more detailed discussion of ideal conditions will be appreciated to a fuller extent. » 9 <» Arguments for The Continuation School For a number of years many people have been interested in the continuation idea and a start in the accomplishment of this ideal has been made in the institution called the continuation or part-time school or classes. Chapter II will show the gradiial growth in this phase of educational evolution. The interest, however, which has been manifested and which is still so intense is the result of a complexity of situations: „|^irst^ the prevalence of illiteracy is in itself a con- dition of such moment as to convince the fair-minded individual that a serious defect exists in the heart of America's population and that as a result some remedy must be sought. Be- fore the entrance of the United States into the Great War com- paratively few people were aware of the amount of illiteracy that existed within its confines; indeed, little attention wa:s paid to this problem except by experts in the field of sociology who recognized the dangers resultant from such widespread illiteracy. The illiterate population according to Towne, in 1910 was over five and one-half million; this means that approximately eight per cent of the people of the United States could neither read nor write.® Ellwood pointed out the relation of illiteracy to crime and suggested a remedy which fore- shadowed the continuation school. He said, "^The prison census for 1910 showed that 12.8 per cent of the prisoners were illiterate, while only 8,2 per cent of the general population fifteen years of age or over were illiterate; and of the major offenders a still higher per cent were illiterate. The defects 8. Towne, E.T., Social Problems, 31. t -lo- in our educational conditions which especially favor the de- velopment of crime are chiefly: lack of facilities for industrial education, lack of physical education, and lack of specific moral instruction.*'® The operation of the Selective Service Act during the Great War brought forth many startling revelations, and one of these was the fact that illiteracy was more prevalent than it was thought to have been. Out of the first two million men chosen about ten per cent of them were illiterates.^^ This dis- covery of a cosmopolitan condition formed the core for the dis- cussion of many sociological and educational bodies which were concerned with the prevention of illiteracy. Really a great deal was said but considerably less was done. The percentage of illiteracy, however, is not constant in the various states of the union. The male percentage reaches from 1.7 in Iowa to 38 in Louisiana. Thirteen states have a per- centage higher than 10. The female percentage extends from 1.4 in Oregon to 30,1 in Louisiana. Of the native whites who have native parentage the numbers vary from .3 per cent in Wyoming, Washington, South Dakota, and North Dakota to 15.5 per cent in Nev/ Mexico; while of the native whites of foreign or mixed parentage the figures begin at .3 per cent in Idaho and Washing- ton and extend to 11,6 per cent in Texas, Of the foreign born whites, however, the percentage varies from 4.8 in Washington to 31.5 in Arizona. The State that has the lowest negro illiteracy is again Washington with 4,3 per cent while the 9 Ellwood, C.A. , Sociology and Modern Social Problems, 338-339. 10 Literary Digest, (Editorial) January 11, 1919. \ » m. 'j f i f ^ I I I I . t.* li I i li/l ; I I • 7 .■ a^\ • fe 7 'I i ^ ^ ■ ^ • r*. c / i - 11 - number rapidly advances to the alarming figure of 48.4 per cent in Louisisuia. The percentage of illiterate males of voting age in Washington and Nebraska is 3.4 while the percentage of the same class in Louisiana reaches to 38.6.^^ What is the meaning of this long array of statistics? It has several meanings, such as that in some states and sections of the United States the illiteracy is alarmingly high, that the traditional public school is not preparing a vast nmber of citizens for social efficiency, and that something must be done. In the further discussion of the continuation school reference again will be made to its effectiveness as an agent in improving conditions both at home and abroad, Seco ndJ^yy the public school as it is traditionally organized and administered is unable to give to "all the children of all the people" the fundamentals which educators agree they should have. The foregoing statistics corroborate this point, but further light may be thrown upon the situation (l) by finding out what those fundamentals are and (3) by making a more detailed study of the number of pupils who fall by the way- side before these aims have been accomplished. The Committee on The Reorganization of Secondary Education of the National Ed^-cational Association summarized the objectives of education in a very satisfactory manner, Inglis, Bobbitt, and others have set up similar objectives, A consensus of opinion seems to agree that the citizens of today should be healthy, that they should have a command of the fundamental 11 Bureau of Domestic and Foreign Commerce, Statistical Abstract of The United States, 1930, 69, . '' c 3 ? i‘x c V .* >' i^vibi ■ ‘ ''**■'>■; ■ . r ,• < , '“ -hi,* '■h' % m. ■ V' iitj-J'-f zn»k ' . >l?i^-' . &' A- •• ''i i • *'"v ’ ' ' •■ ,' *'■:■■ - • ' ■' ;i ^ *’i f ' ' P ^ ' ./ 'ii ^ lin^Xo t.' 0 iAf . : V- '■ * ' ■*' - ..-*3 •■■,•■ ■>';*]-* ' '■'■« 'H' oail '- 1 ■ i . > 5 ‘ 'Jiftoi « : 4 ;: 24 1 W . >•■' -J .’-V . . 4 */,^ ';V ■', ^ 1 ( 1,4 *^c JiittiiiiiW Jbifr’, ««»!, 4 i ^.‘.Jfi- ' ‘ ' ' .' . ■■ ' -'t' C "<'*'• V ..».]■•'■ . ‘ V -".f: .' • L ' J h~ •i^/. ItOiAtj . .3 • D .t iMctt k .1 idj^ d. tH ‘ 4 t : r i-« .’ './ ■ ;'■** ,' ' - ■: ^ 'V-' ■’:; '5 ' • ■^ . ,. . I ' ' V P' ■ '■ • '• ■ ‘^'4 ■' i- *' ^ 4 -'f' 1 j ^ f t f^.'' . "'^J. -r ^' aafti;: ^f; I', fW^rf ;/ ' 1 . 6 ' ib^hKja ic ^U'J ft *ij^'dc ;.'^©r t tc ^ '■■' '•■’■'•/ ,f; .' 'r ■;■/•• ,vi ■-■;.• v.Vijpj -I f }•» ■/< ••■■^ • • ... i>tT . . il'nf tini. ’ I . ■ •i^i»'Avy . /y ^rvi'A.A I*" i » ’ 'J- r : r it ' ‘"v^ ' '■ .: ' , "■«# -t ?■•; ; ■■ ,*fti ■ • jtfWGwi’i,' i ■ ■ nfs ^ ■*',* 4 ik.i*T 4 %**..• !«.v ••;/'/■ . C.""; V , 'T, . ■ ;•■ . -v.oa i iQ r:5’-. ' ‘ ' ' ■ ‘” "::i* ;.vS%«M " . '*■''' I - 12 - processes, that they should attain a worthy home membership, that they should be vocationally efficient, that they should have high ideals of the obligations and duties of citizenship, that they should know how to use their leisure time in a profit- able way, and that they should be of good moral character. In 1913 Ayres called our attention to the fact that about twenty-six per cent of all pupils entering school did not finish the eighth grade and that about ninety-four per cent did not finish high school. More recent investigations have revealed the fact that elimination is still very high, even though pupils tend to remain in school longer than formerly. The Commissioner of Education about the middle of the last decade estimated that of every one thousand pupils who entered the first grade in 1906-1907, about 11,7 per cent would graduate from high school and 1,5 per cent would gradmte from college. The status of elimination in different communities is not constant, but of course this should be inferred from a knowledge of the status of illiteracy which is partially caused by elimination. Naturally pupils in Cleveland, Ohio, remain in school longer than pupils in New Orleans, Louisiana. Bonner states that 17.8 per cent of the pupils of school age are not enrolled in school and that 44 per cent of the entire school term in 1918 was wasted be- cause of lack of attendance.^® 12 Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 35, 1918. 13 Ayres, Leonard P., Laggards in Otar Schools, 14 ff. 14 Hill, David S., An Introduction to Vocational Education, 74-76 15 Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 11, 1921, 6 et 15-18, V ■r ' , ■?-i l n'tol -r.r i • • » Off Jj f| 'I 1 ( \ 0 t 1 .'■ ■ A" "‘■y<;i;\!‘i •"JV . '4' ii H j " ' ' 4 ■t ,K^{9r- 4,‘ J ITOV"'" ^'■J! JL o/r . •■' > ^ ;•■'■- >•*..*• M »’)«rYV V*/ <* > ^ ¥. i ': . '■ ■ I -i o., ell :;!;.* *>tVi I - • 1 “ V , ^ '«.' t ■■■•.'■<.£ fci- . • t • ■-i-om -13- Why do so many pupils leave school at such an early age with so little preparation for living? The answers to this question are multitudinous and only a few of the most Important reasons are incorporated in this discussion, (l) The limited range of instruction offered in the higher grades of the elementary school and in many of the secondary schools certainly is a factor to be taken into consideration, in any argument for more thorough education. The schools are gradually adjusting themselves in this regard through such agencies as the junior high school and the introduction of vocational studies. (3) The' failure of some communities to provide suitable facilities for the education of their children prevents many of them from obtaining a more thorough education. Such communities existed in abundance a few years ago but the number is gradually being lessened through legislation and equalization of opportunity and costs. Nevertheless many districts today contribute to elimination by their failure to provide the necessary facilities for their young people. (3) Aniother reason for much elimination is the failure of the school to demonstrate its worth to the pupil and to his parents when lucrative jobs are available. This is especially true in an industrial community such as the automobile manufacturing districts of Michigan. Obviously this cause of elimination is inseparable from (4) the desire to obtain spending money. The lure of the fruition of employment very frequently draws the child from school into industry. In many communities an instinctive appeal requires his work in order that he may not be isolated socially from his fellows -14- beoause they have spending money and he does not. (5) The failure of a pupil in school oftentimes tends to antagonize him against the institution. The repetition of the grade is without interest. Tardiness and absence result and the latter is likely to become perpetual, (6) Economic pressure either real or imaginary is, perhaps, the greatest single cause of elimination , Ayres found that about 20 per cent of the children who in the elementary schools of six large cities left school did so be- cause of this reason alone while over one-third of the children who left the high schools of the same cities did so for the sole purpose of going to work.^® Economic distress is a social evil that cannot be eradicated. It always will remain a cause for elimination unless legal relief can be obtained in such sufficiency that the pupil and the people who are dependent partially or wholly upon him will be able to live without his support. If the eliminated pupil is followed into industry his short-comings cannot but be noticed. His needs show the import- ance of the continuation school. Why not force him back into the traditional school and compel him to remedy hie deficiencies? Such an idea is absolutely preposterous. If he belongs to the last group mentioned above, often he must either work, starve, or become a public charge, and he can choose only the former. If he belongs to one of the other groups his presence in school, if he is forced to be there, is often a menace to the discipline and progress of the school. Give him an alternative whose function is to educate him while he works is the argument ad- vanced by the exponents of the continuation school, 16 Ayres, Leonard P., Laggards in Our Schools, 100 ff. » ' »»r it w'W '< ffct. «.'• ;''•. Cai-^Diite i]K tvf' ItltoliH u ^ ...:iL ■ .»)r .arif i ..* jirT’ >f :.r.‘ ■) td i ■;. S(rt 4 . t r'f. 4C; V* (tt '. '1 . i * •> i/iStfv* it^ ' « Tf 't>i‘ji|i- V' .-Vi i ,. y". • ' < ■ < ■ 'j* '^1 ' w fiX’.‘- .‘r’vv.iiQ j/'' ■« iU ifwViW^'’ • \r* 'n-^ ‘ • 'QKM :i li ..jij •V kV/ t oso;?' ; y':t ■ •’ r ^ t -. : t iia ' '■ ' -I: ^ • X Jit> , v'rr;^- ,;? r V -r,' ■ ^ ' /*■'■ . . ^ “W . • <'•■■ ■ . Jk3fJI j/A OC . . ^ I 3 <{.rjfi,g ^.OJ'.XW^Z X.ci *V ,^:T •, , ’ /- . V/ ;• - /**ir ,’ ** ' 4 , *>’*• »*•/ '^' •■ > ■ '"’ ., ^' ’ ■ '^ ^^'r.. ? ,*‘' ... •;. . /"'■ ”7^ '* " *.;;^ ©isp; t4 as.- ' '' ’xa?.v ''^>. O'": :jai'X 5 ^/ " ■■ i' - .r/, ^ ' * L, .. . evtf vA. ^par^r-' ^ ^ je^C •: •f:- ^ ■ ,r ' 8 . 19 ^ . /' , ‘:'i / J . ■<:;' •■• ■ t :'■ , I . .. , , ■■■" .W' 4 '■ 7 i ‘ .... L •'. A A . s' i ■..•t •■. i^A-ii'. .«».. -ipctiU Wix-'iii - 1 .'• .' ■ M • # ' . - J* I, ''X WM h, 'tid . ( 'SAT.iV > 'Jb(i»i-‘^V-il.:’ '.;.■ • jiJr lidliuAll. -15- Since the eliminated child has not been educated adequiately he is unable to secure the most promising industrial positions. Hence, he must accept whatever position he can get, a job which the better trained have refused and which has little or no possibilities for the future. He must bdgln at the bottom of the great industrial ladder and must stay there unless further education is provided for him. Very frequently he drifts about from one "blind-alley "job to another and seldom attains his dwarfed ambition. Hill made an investigation which is valuable in this connection: "Twenty-five cases selected by the writer at random from among more than a thousand boys under fifteen years of age, have records of from four or five jobs during the first year out of school. These young boys stated the jobs they had already tried and also their preference or 'ambition*. E,g., Bov A: Errand boy, plumber's helper, office boy, in grocery, -ambit ion, bookkeeper; Bov B : Wagon boy, office boy, clerk for soap company, 17 office boy, -ambition, civil engineer; Etc." The oases cited above are representative of a legion of others which show the hapless wanderings of children who ought to be in school. Mays suggests that only about twenty-five in every four thousand of these unprepared children hold one job longer than two years.^® The great tragedy lies not so much in their inability to progress but in the fact that there is not r sufficient opportunity given for them to learn how to progress and become self-supporting so that they will become an asset 17 Hill, David, S., An Introduction to Vocational Education, 80-81. 18 Mays, A.B., Lecture on Continuation School Pupils. -16- rather than a liability to the community in their later years. In this work the continuation school can be of a great service, Kerschensteiner showed that in Munich it really was of much value in this capacity. He g'ave statistics showing that in 1890 about 1000 of the eighth class boys went into "blin^.-alley” jobs, while in 1698 after the continuation school was in oper- ation only 250 went the same road, and in 1908 only 50 entered the "blind-alley” trades. T hirdly, the prevalence of poverty and pauperism makes a more urgent demand for better educational results not only in America, but throughout the world as well. Towne says, "For the country as a whole, and for years of average prosperity, probably as fair an estimate as we can make is that about 15 per cent of all the people are living in poverty. This would make the number in the United States today about fifteen million, including of course the five million dependent upon some form of public re- lief." In speaking of the causes of poverty Ellwood correctly asserts, "Defects in our educational system are certainly pro- ductive of poverty. Ignorant and illiterate persons are much more liable to become dependent. In particular the lack Of industrial training in our public schools is a prolific cause of dependence in our complex industrial civilization."’^^ The continuation school offers abundant opportunity for the education of the worker along industrial lines after he has become engaged in industrial pursuits. It is an institution limited to the education of this large group of people and it 19 Best, R.H., and Ogden, C.K., The Problem of The Continuation School, 29-30, 20 Towne, E.T., Social Problems, 289. 21 Ellwood, C.A., Sociology and Modern Social Problems, 309. -17- is peculiarly adapted to the performance of this vital work. No claim is made that the continuation school will blot out poverty and pauperism because many factors enter into the production of these social evils. Many cases are purely patho- logical and can be treated on no other basis; and such a case is outside the province of the continuation school which is an agency destined to contribute a large share to minimizing these evils by assisting in destroying the causes for their existence. Fotirthly, the extent of poor health and physical in- capacity shows that instruction in preventive and corrective measures should not be limited to the elementary school but that it should be continued even after the worker has entered upon his vocation. The Selective Service Act operating in the Great War revealed the fact that about fifty per cent of Americans best manhood were unfit pnysically to serve their coiintry,^^ Since a large part of these physical disabilities could have been prevented if attempted in time the continuation school has a function in this respect. It can educate along preventive and remedial lines in regard to disease and accidents. Inasmuch as the mortality rate of young children and adults over forty-five years of age is so much higher than that of those people who come under the provisions of the Selective Service Act the findings of these results are likely to be too low for the entire population of the United States. 22 U.S. Surgeon General's Office, Defects found in Drafted Men, 1920, 29 et 73. 23 Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce, Statistical Abstract of The United States, 1920, 80-81. TV|i.», i f' '• ’-f 'A.V ^ ^ BMW - ■ - V ' ‘ 0 - 'i T t/i 3 ,. __ _ '•/ }\ -I: . . , * ■ ..;/■)■ V ■’ r^^f. ‘ -.n. € 'I ; r--<;r .T^- ’*•> ^.'i, /i 3 ) n V :: ■ v v t ' t- ■ Su V M ,irfX -'“If' ■. I , ■ii«.-;‘ i-ijit • a-wyin:* ?.'flfi r^.iO'ji' v " / "”5 *‘J -r I ' ’^.C i ktYXfQ '6'.^ ’ X-*i i vko^i ■- ■ • ' - ' f ^ li.’ ot ^t!s^’‘ , ' ■ ’ '. ,,* '• ' ' ■ '. .. .- 'Ji>- , ... ’ *-• ■■ '^- ‘ ■-■’ .• MA^ . . -. jf.; v^icrr. »iO , 3 ■’■' V ' '-I ' ‘ • ' '^ ■ " ■ ' V' f V • *i ■' ■ ^ TtJfiaT- iyif (W"' • '^4 Iffi • i> ‘ '.jV, P^' lo ;tf.f!:» 'll' ;.'t^‘'n C\70«® 'l^'j^itfifvt't. ■•j.^f"'. t.t^: ,. sai “» ri-ai-S'" . ■• ■■.■/-■"■■vr'. -.in ‘ ■ ‘ ■ . ' -ui Cli lA - .*i X ■ 4iit. .>^a f»*r ' « iii? f f 3[ ^fr, t •:' ■■ ■• 'V'^' ' >'■ ..ij.'i#* K 0 1 ■ J ■■‘'^0 HV-4H'; A/v*;. .*■: >f ! '1 ’ ;' ; f‘'’ ■ '^. 'X ^ Ail * ■■'iot; ’'nt :. '* ./ 4‘-iV' •’'■!< ^-•'--.#,1^'^^ 10 -Atii^ i' ' > • "" • "* '•...’ gK '•*■ • ■•- i Vv JO' ’.0- ^ " ' ■• mM -^^»^»^.i» | i»»V; ,«y) | |J>^ l ^ ' ■^l»v» ti;''li>. >N '' '. I ’.' IM >/•'''' > '. I ' .’L< ■.. ' i k' ,*' >•'■. . . ^ , I 'V -18- The workers in industry should know how to avoid accidents whose numbers are appallingly high. At least thirty-five thousand workmen are killed and two million are injured in industrial accidents annually. An estimate states that at least one-half of these accidents can be avoided if proper instructions are given to the laboring population.^"^ The experience of the writer in the coal mining district of the Middle West shows that any instruction as to dangerous parts of the mines, such as "old works"' that have been bratticed off, is only casual. Explosions occur as a result of gas ignition in such districts. The $62, 500,000 and the man power that could be saved by such prevention would go far to- wards financing the continuation schools which among other agencies would teach prevention and employ corrective measures wherever needed. F lfthl a&i the inability of the common people to adjust them- selves when a transfer of jobs is made is an argument for some kind of specific instruction whereby the worker can learn the job at the time when he is employed at it. This maladjustment of workers is especially noticeable during a period of financial and labor depression. The crisis of 1931 is highly illustrative in this connection. Nearly every metropolitan newspaper spoke often and at length of the serious condition and at the same time printed advertisements of "HELP WANTED", Certainly none would accuse the newspapers of inconsistency in their actions. The trouble lies in the fact that industry is so highly specialized that the task of transferring from one job to another is usually very difficult and if the industrial concern does not teach its 24 Towns, E, T., Social Problems, -356. - 19 - new employees, with few exceptions they must learn for them- selves. Very frequently the joh or trade oannot be mastered alone; or in a short time. Hence, the laborer who is idle cannot in many oases even obtain the position. Yet there exist a great many .jobs and trades which can be learned in a short time if instruction is available while work is being done. Various firms are too small to profitably main- tain a training school for their employees and very frequently they have vacancies which can be filled by many persons if some way were provided for their learning how to perform the duties of the particular job or trade. Again the continuation school has an urgent duty to perform. It is valiiable in this respect not only in periods of depression and in oases of seasonal fluctuations in the demand for labor, but also in irregular oases of emplpyment in sundry industries. It cannot eliminate but it can lessen the great \inemployment evil, ^xthly , the passage of the Lever Act and of the Sedition Acts during the late struggle with the Central Powers was an action which in ipso recognized the necessity of education for democracy. Perhaps one of the principal reasons for the passage of these laws as well as of some others was the enormous immigration of the "newer type", which came is such large numbers prior to the outbreak of the European conflict, and which is coming again as fast as is permissible. These people most of whom are uneducated collect in some sections of the large cities and settle in communities in the smaller ones until nearly every industrial center of importance has Its "’Italy", "'Austria? and other communal epithets. If these people are to become American - 20 - they must be taught Americanism, The continuation school can be of vital assistance in this great movement for Americanization. It is true that in its present form the continuation school reaches the adults more indirectly than directly, but the reaching of the young immigrants and of the immigrants' children who are between the ages of fourteen and eighteen is notably worthwhile, Americanization is not limited to immigrants alone: neither should it be under present conditions. The continuation school can be of service among many native-born Aflierioans, "Really to Vs Americanize America we must reach the native-born and the immigrant, the adult and the child in school; and incidentally our task of Americanizing the newcomer will be rendered com- paratively easy if we can but succeed first in Americanizing ourselves, The gradual extension of the suffrage implies a wider use of it , No other agency, perhaps, will have a better chance to teach the adolescent in industry his rights and duties toward his neighbor, community, state, and nation than the con- tinuation school, because it has an opportunity to reach a great number of people who have not learned the fundamental principles of democracy elsewhere. Indeed, civic instruction occupies an important place in the curriculum of the continuation school, Seveifthly, education for leisure time is a problem whose importance is becoming widely recognized. Pound says, "Education for leisure, under the conditions of automatic production, is education for life What is the first requirement for the right use of leisure 7 Self-restraint Need for self-restraint increases in proportion to affluence ... .It follows that knowledge, Mahoney, J.J., "Training Teachers for Americanization", Bureau of Education Bulletin No. 12, 192Q,. 14. - 21 - as the chief restraining influence in the youthful mind, is the substitute that education must establish in place of the set of controls which formerly resulted from the young man’s poverty or fear of poverty,"'^® Pound proceeds to point out that the child should be taught thrift, ideas of law, history, literature, science, art, and music because they give a meaning to life and an inspiration to leisure. ^Finally, there should be a complete system of continuation schools wherein those who desire to use their labor-bought leisure, by securing further instruction could be accomodated on their own time. All graduates presumably will have been so far inoculated with the intellectual virus that th&j will go on improving their minds at lei sure « to some extent thus demonstrating on a wide scale that education is not a matter of youth, but of life,*^^ Qonsiderable credit is due the public schools for what they have done for the cultural growth ef America* but observation shows that much still remains to be done* Many (people do not know the joys of a life of intellectual appreciation^ they remain out- side the realms of good music, literature, dramatics, painting and sculpture. The "’jazz”, yellow literature, the public dance, movies, gambling, chewing gum, and red lemonade have strong attractions which should be eliminated or at least controlled. This can be done only by means of a positive program. Since the class of people to whom these lighter attractions most appeal are those who have not learned self-restraint, several agencies should be set to work to teach them to control their appetites, passions, and desires. T^e children between the ages of fourteen and eighteen who are forming ideals of conduct which are lasting, 26 Pound, Arthur, "The Iron Man", Atlantic Monthly, Oct . 1921. 438-A49* 27 Ibid., 441. * s^u ; , ■ - 'li rf 4 . '’l Jjk’'’ 'vj.lj kr 'r- «i • 1 . --fc i • ^ » V ‘ ( -. V uOi I i' !T, r't \i ■; ^ „■'' ■■' :■ ■■.X ',: >:?i*jLT^®-T<5, rts ■ . ;. i '♦ * \ vD.' . * 10*5 •’ XC'O '*':■*• ’t. » ! .'*'■ ^ •>.?- .. t > /.; 'i'. ,r*iu V ♦Jl -• ■ j .‘i : : 'lii <*’Jf.M_ !• ’ i , WJV, ■ r i ', f i L» 3jdi f 1 r* i... -.j* .''-y;/-.: ;v < -■ ii'-'ii8 • .•fi ■ ■ ■ \ V ,*■» I . l» V * .t- i: ';:, , 6 ‘,i'^ M;,^ v \ ' i ■ ' '. . V.: ^-'T • ^ - , t' 4 , ",.<. I ’ itr. : V. . . - • 4 ■ria_ ; k k‘ ■ir 'H 'r, lx: •* If 'f k *< i '\ fv ; < 4 . ,f • J , .‘■ct 4 r' . cr .n I a; - 22 - should have positive programs placed before them. No agency is better fitted to reach that part of these youngsters who have severed relations with the regular day school and have entered industry than the continuation school. The crusade must be begun before long and the continuation school must be considered as one of the agencies whose aid can be utilized. S ightl y, the problem of the conservation of the natural resources of the United States in the last few years has attained a position of much prominence. The federal government has carried through a magnificent program for the continuous conservation of certain forests and timber reserves. It also has reclaimed vast tracts of land by great irrigation projects and has made a wider acreage possible by the drainage of certain marsh lands. Only the beginning has been made; the federal and state governments must go still further. They owe a duty to the future generations of this great republic to conserve the other natural resources which so abundantly bless its vast domain. The conservation of peat, petroleum, natural gas, the metals, and their products is a more difficult problem. If exploitations in these products should continue at the same rate as at present for one hundred and fifty years the supply would almost, if not completely, be exhausted.^® Such luxuries as pleasure-riding, superfluous lighting, and waste orf fuel, either directly or indirectly, should be checked by volimtary action. The continuation school promises to have a prominent part in this program due to the fact that it reaches a class which does not have a knowledge of the consequences of such waste and exploitation, or if they do who take the attitude of Louis XV of France, "After us, the deluge."^ 28 Towns, E.T., Social Problems, 322. - 23 - Ninethly, obedience to oommon social principles which have been app'r^ed by society is an ideal which is fundamental to a democracy as well as to any other social organization. If the ethical is the Ideal aspect of behavior certainly public opinion must be enlightened. The continuation school has a tremendous advantage of many other institutions as an agency for inculc&ting morality. It reaches a great multitude that hardly can be reached in any other manner, some of whom belong either to the immoral class or the unmoral class. Perhaps at the critical period of life the right kind of moral instructions would save to society many lives of usefulness as well as large economic returns and money that as a result of law-breaking would be expended for re- proof and reformation. If the great hypothesis that moral development depends to a large extent upon intellectual growth is true, it logically follows that society must have the maximum of education in order to possess the highest ethics, other things being equal or approximately so. Then if intellectual growth and education are synonymous the continuation school is justifiable on purely intelleot\ial grounds because it can give to many adolescent workers education that they will not get unless they get it in the continuation school or in some substitute for it. The social studies offer abundant opportunity for the teaching of obedience both to civil and to moral laws, not as pure abstractions but as real truths existing in a social environment. No argument is advanced in this thesis that the primary function of the continuation school is to teach religion, but this institution can aid materially in giving proper ideals of 24 - conduct, be they either ethical or religious. Neither do the promoters of the continuation school claim that it is a panacea for the social evils that have been mentioned in the foregoing pages, nor that it will cure any one of them. Nevertheless it is peculiarly fitted to reach many people who hardly can be reached throng any other source. As this institution exists today it can do much to improve the efficiency of the social group. As it should exist when it shall be fully grown, it will have an opportunity to reach nearly every home in the land and to assist the intellectual group as well as that group which it now serves so successfully where it is established. Arguments against The Continuation School Refuted The opponents of the continuation school claim that its existence will be an excuse for certain pupils* leaving the traditional school sooner than they otherwise would do. Their parents may be led to believe that their children oan profit from the continuation school as much as from the older schools; and therefore, they will encourage attendance at the continuation school when, if it did not exist, they would not consent to their children* s leaving school. Hence, instead of adding to the social efficiency of the nation the continuation school would be de- tracting from it. In order to test the validity of this argument which, if true, would seriously handicap the growth of this institution and lessen its efficiency the author made a rather wide inquiry into this matter in Illinois, The results were sur- prising because the principals in every case testified that no r i. .. .• %V m.^. 'V.. ; ■'- ' (•* '■’: '. ■ / . .' ’ t ’ '•/i* rtti^idi ■■•i rv-A4'v..n$'-’aXi Rv''’'. ; • ' 7 ''’ "r •». Vt ^ ,‘l.r n 0 ’ 0 cfO’Xj^ J-|' • i V - Ia. i ,9^(' Z w f <• 7 / >» ’ ij^ wa iWv. ^n 4 s;w T|£J. .ei 0 ^«<;rj£J t :- V ,. rr, } , ;ii ^ Jt i 1 R ■♦X -?i i.« V - ilio * .•■ •. >''v^ . ./-a;. ■ ' ■’ .. * ■ vj' . •' -m,! •# xjpiff • ri; .c>i-^t -ii .'. ■ ■ >• ■■ ' .-'if A O ^ I ; twui ^^7 ^ - T"'^' t YX w, C-c / W ; O .' 'i<^ ijll s <* .• s •:' ), ^r,',)o«vo,a. vU, tf& 4 ^ liwr^ '■7 ‘‘^‘' •-’ •= « „■ ’ f' ^ .. - '■''’‘-'f '’llfi*y 5 S ' ‘H '■ ' 'rT’> / .■” ' ' 'L iC .' .i J 7tS£/ -StlfOOj^V '•f^:,_u ff' Yoiai , i . : yk >4 j ' ■■ , „•■ ^ i ^ taco 6i/fA^^ sJt .s.' '«BP| ; | Jfn:a ^rt»' ft, xx:u..^r .c,tii y i. y ' ' ' '/ , '■ : ' * '''''-. Wit ’’■’ < f ' "r ; ; 4 pn ‘©a ^ I.C»SS?i ■ - 4 *^' -i-r ;. Xdj.' ■? *' rj..- . - > ... -^ ) .J^. '.V ". , •■ -p"./ .*,-•, tV-V' • -'' ( ‘ <’■ i “*». i'<*. VV- r..j £^t^x »c ‘vi’infe , iix ■-t. r~ • ■ ! ' 5 '- ^«W "[ y | g j g f < i( ^ i j i m ' VJ ,■' . 1 1 f!lL' :j^iAL‘\i I, ,»!■- . - 25 - such a case had ever oome to their knowledge in their respective schools. On the other hand they stated that they knew of several instances where the continuation school was the means that had led a goodly number of pupils who had left the regular schools, back into that institution which they had so willingly or re- luctantly left not many days or months previously. In the second place, the argument is advanced that the continuation school will increase the tax rate materially. This argument cannot wholly be refuted but it can be answered partially in that the children between the ages of fourteen and eighteen who are in industry are entitled to have as much money spent on their education per capita in proportion to the restilts obtained as the children who regularly or irregularly attend the elementary or the high schools. Again, much of the work done by the pupils can be placed on a production basis so that the returns of it will be a means for the partial support of the institution. A part of the seemingly high cost is eliminated frequently by the inaugur- ation of certain continuation schools in the plants of industrial concerns, as is done in the packing industry of Chicago. In such cases usually the corporation furnishes the rooms, equipment, and supplies while the local district is required to furnish a part or all of the teaching corps (. and occasionally some or all of the equipment and supplies) . As a safeguard in the interest of the public the schools thus established are usually made a part of the local school system subject to its inspection and direction. The maintenance of both of the above objections at the same time is inconsistent since the former presupposes that the pupils are drawn from the regular school while the latter assumes 1 - 26 - that very few are thus obtained or that the per capita cost in the continuation school is far more than it is in the elementary and high schools. It may be true that some pupils will be drawn from the all-day schools as a result of the establishment of continuation schools and it certainly is true that the expense of the continuation schools must be met. However, the added ex- pense will result more from the entrance of pupils who are not in school at all than from those who transfer from the all-day schools. If the opposite were the case, the continuation school could not be justified. Some increase in expenses will result and public taxation will be used in most oases to pay the bills, even though the amount required for this purpose is considerably less than that required to maintain the regular schools. This is a practical situation. If the people want the continuation school are they willing to pay for it? In the third place an argument can well be advanced that such a curriculum in the junior and senior high schools, as some few of the advocates of this objection favor, would accomplish the same results as the continuation school and at a less expense. Such an innovation does not differ from the con- tinuation school. Both have the same aims and employ like means in accomplishing them. Since the organization of the continuation school differs so widely in different cities the upshot of the whole argument is that the opponents who advance this argument are advancing the continuation school idea and are contending for a principle that the author lays down in a following chapter.^ K fourth argument against the continuation school is that teachers who are properly qualified cannot be obtained. There 29 Infra, 106 ff . ft - 27 - is some truth in this eirgument. At the present time the demand for teachers with the requisites necessary for success in the continuation school has not been created sufficiently. It is axiomatic that such a supply will never exist until such a demand has been made. A similar argument was advanced in California against the bill which provided that a year of ad- vanced work beyond the bachelor* s degree should be a requisite^ for high school certification, but the bill became a law and during the Great War when other states were needing high school teachers, California was supplied pretty adequately. Two reasons were primarily responsible for this situation; In the first place teachers were imported from other states; and in the second place more teaching timber was attracted because of the resultant better conditions. Certainly the economic laws of supply and demand must be taken into consideration in the dis- cussion of this problem. Since the history of the continuation school movement shows that its adoption has been gradual the problem of teacher shortage is less acute than it would be if the movement became instantly cosmopolitan. When all factors are weighed and the balance is struck, if the fact is kept in mind that our normal schools and universities can train men and women who desire a career in this field, the problem becomes far less serious. Another argument which is advanced against the con- tinuation school again refers to the teacher situation* A con- tention is made that this institution will draw the best teachers- from the elementary and high schools. This is true to a certain extent and, perhaps, it should not be lamented as much as seems ■■ "tvr’rh^f^: IV ■' V'"' ’ I I - 1 »»• •- -vs- J . ' I ti .'. • fit fiftf'i? f>>nCi\ ut <> l '- V. >* A ^ ’fe: Ottfrpcv;;, 7:^> Xiqt- ’i ■• ,C'\ ’ ' •'• ' ;' .',‘j ' ‘ ‘ ti&S, a \£,t'f tO> «, ■ V • ‘ ..■ V‘t • • "«•■' yiifii' ^V5{a7i 4 '«- ' ^' fw * '«X #4.' !ro! xl i iilH ® ■, :ims» i %n ipcx ‘ CO fticj f' A ■:*«1l''1// ■■'GSjy’AOi^.p ■ X:r('OiW(J| ’ ' ; •'■ ■' ^ ^ , ' ’' , ■' f‘ I - ' ■ '■ ' 'YA. titf IlC A '. #1rfd4' j /< P ^ rtVl t’ ♦ > L'LSA>> r f{ i.lJK 9 f ■« ■'* , ; V ■ *; ;.' "■■ ' ■ .'. ’ ■ ■■■ .-it t J.Wij JUIu-fcxPfc .i^ • V . •:. ■ • .Cl, • ,% ' •,:.y ■' : . -‘i ~ , -• ’■ at t-: xi»r; ’£^-i »;, %l V t (fOnsikcf ■ iJCf^r 1 ' ' ■. 4 Vi " ' • ' 4 ...■-. ■.', -3' . • '■'V 4 hv aldtq ffrp XW?ii^k|5. tii^y r- ■( . v- 4 |xat al'^‘tt.p¥ 4 ?p r. ; CMifi af^f.i 5 ’< "’ .■ PlttWjtJ^'.’ ' ' lSi!8 ‘.:iv.1 *&#,X . .r.? M . -V) - -rnr. bocairM' i^:l iifjilSif vf- • V',1 ‘ ^' ' '"'V * 'p>%> -x'iOTi. ’4 ♦nvrxO'Aif^tt xiii^Aiy ■ 4 '■ u "’> ■■ ’ vr '-■ "' '■ ,r : << IrXVi 'W Pd ^ ffipdiS X J 41 Xi • i(. _ - . ' ,;.' ^', ’"»i ■ -/•’)i'(F ■' ' ■ ' .:«^*Ph-/j4w ;««■ ^ciu. i. ildi A«>r^r r’-:-. f. . ■ ■ ■* ■' ■ .' ^ V ** ' ‘ ’ r^'T 7 *»V ^ lw.lL/. T.— ’»<— " *■ » ** " »')y ? "' V- 'e/ji . «^ 1 ^ f'Ki, ',. iri' - 28 - to be the case. The adolescent in the continuation school needs a superior type of teacher just as much as, if not more than, the adolescent in the junior and senior high schools. The with- drawal of some of the best teachers from the latter schools will make a greater demand for more superior teachers in these institutions. As a result better conditions are likely to follow and this means that better timber will be attracted into the common schools. Every teacher should work where she can do the greatest service and it is the problem of the administration to effect this condition. This objection seems to be so closely connected with the preceding one that the remedy in the former will apply equally well to the latter. An argument which was expounded a few years ago but which seems to have much less weight today is that the con- tinuation school creates class distinctions and makes more marked those classes which already have been created. The ex- perience of Germany was cited as proof but little consideration was given to the basic educational plan provided by that c'ountry. The experience of the American system, on the contrary,, tends to show that the pupil has really more liberty in the choice of a vocation if he attend a continuation school than if he pursue the regular course in the traditional schools. This is true because the latter usually prepares for college while the former prepares for an immediate vocational career as well as for the responsibilities of citizenship. It tends to prevent the pupil from falling into the "Iblind alley"' class and to make out of him a citizen worthy of his community. -29- Pttxhaps the greatest argument against the continuation school is the fact that funds are not available at the present time and that the legislators are afraid to take a stand for any movement that can be construed as financially dangerous to their constituents. This condition has been a great stumbling block in the way of the progress of this institution. The lament- 30 able experience of Illinois bears witness to this fact. Perhaps the best answer that has been given to this objection is that taxation more nearly equalized would provide for the support of the continuation school without material injury to the other educational institutions or to the public. Except some readjustment takes place it seems that the only hope for the success of an universal acceptance of this institution lies in the legislators of the various states whom only time and experience must convince. The Function of The Continuation School In its broadest sense, the continuation school should give the pupil whatever instruction he needs to make him socially efficient. This much may have been inferred already from the foregoing discussion of the needs that justify the existence of this very important institution. It is an agency designed to educate the pupils who attend it while they are employed and at the same time to induce them to seek more education. The problem of continuing the education of the pupil is very closely related to the problem of making him socially efficient. Few people are likely to deny the fact that the juvenile worker who comes from the traditional public school 30 Infra, 51 et ff. 1 I - 30 - at the age of fourteen ought to have more education. Seldom does he have a command of the fundamental principles that are necessary for a complete life, because he has attained only a part of those educational objectives which society deems necessary for success. Hence, he is in need of further education and it is the function of the continuation school to furnish it to him in such substance and quantity as he most needs and desires. It trains the worker to do his task better if his interests lie in the field in which he is employed. Frequently, it shows him that he has the ability to advance to a higher position for which it continues to prepare him. In either cas«p it has a specific function to perform by increasing his fund of general knowledge. This .modern educational institution intends to educate the young workers in industry under public direction and at public expense. The training usually being general as well as specific does not produce a stereotyped product, a worker who cannot transfer from one field to another, as does that of the average privately owned schools which are con- ducted solely by large industrial corporations. This assures the pupil of an equal industrial opportunity in the sense that his training will not make him wholly dependent on some great industrial firm or set of corporations. The continuation school is designed to give the youth who has left school because of economic pressure further education. Unless elimination which results from pecuniary necessity shall be ended by legislation which shall provide for the family or for at least the child and for those people who are dependent -31- upon him for support and which shall provide a fund that will sustain life during the time required for the completion of his elementary and preferably his secondary school work some in- stitution must be utilized which will enable him to earn a livelihood and at the same time contribute to the support of those persons who are dependent upon him during the time that he is obtaining an acceptable education. In this respect the continuation school serves a rather unique purpose. Dewey thinks that one of the real values of any education is the effect that it produces on the subject by causing him to advance further into the educational realm. If this is a true criterion of the value of an educatioml institution certainly the continuation school must rank very high. In the first place the pupils continue their educational advancement in the continuation school which is not infinitely separated from the school of life. Then pursuing the zeal which has been developed further in their stay in the continuation school, sometimes ohey enter the technical school, specialize in some important line of work, and become citizens who are valuable assets to their communities. A large mmber of these pupils are shown the value of a liberal education and their own possibilities. As a result, they often enter the full-day school with a better knowledge of what industrial life is and with a determination to prepare themselves for their station in society. Hence through the agency of the continuation school many people re- ceive an education much higher than they would have received had 31 Dewey, John, Democracy and Education, 62. 32 Supra, 25. - 32 « it not been for their connection with this very valuable in- st itution. The specific functions which the continuation people claim for their institution are: that the pupils are taught how to better perform the tasks which they have to do in the industrial world, if their positions are commensurate with their abilities; that many are led into and prepared for higher positions, if the ones in which they are employed are incommen- surate with their abilities; that a large number of pupils are led back into the full-time schools; and that all are better prepared for their stations in this great democratic society. Summary and Conclusion All education is an evolutionary process which is determined by the thoughts and feelings of society. A widespread opinion has been current for a long time that everybody should have an equalized educational opportunity. The desire to makie this opportunity accessible to those people who have left the school and entered into industry may be called the "continuation idea.*” However, the realization of it is far in the future, but the continuation school which generally is limited to juvenile workers is one step in advance towards the realization of the "continuation idea’,"' even though this school is embryotic in form. This institution has been variouly defined; as it is here used in a narrow sense it is a school that during working hours provides education for persons, usually minors, who are gainfully employed and who are not attending the regular day- school. It is a part-time school. 1 - 33 - The prevalence of illiteracy, the enormous elimination from the traditional public schools, the large amount of poverty and pauperism, the universal extent of ppor health and physical incapacity, the general lack of efficiency among workers, the widespread need of civic, and social education, the cosmopolitan misuse of leisure time, the ecumenical need for conservation of natural and human resources, the deficiency in the moral con- duct of many citizens justify the existence of an institution that will educate the industrial population along the lines of right living and social efficiency. The continuation school is peculiarly fitted to assist in the prevention and elimination of many common social evils as well as to prepare for industrial success, despite the attacks made upon it by its enemies who argue that it would tend to increase elimination, that it would materially increase the tax rate, that the functions claimed for it can be accomplished as well in the schools that now exist, that properly qualified teachers cannot be obtained, that the now existing schools would be harmed by the transfer of their best teachers to the continuation school, that it would promote class distinctions and thereby be undemocratic, and that funds for its maintenance are not available and cannot be obtained. This long train of argument against the continuation school seems to be partly refuted from theoretical considerations and the experience of those communities that have inaugurated a scheme of continuation education apparently throws the weight of evidence on the side of this institution. -34- Selected Bibliography. XAYres, Leonard P., Laggards in Our Schools Best, R. H. and Ogden, C,K.,The Problem of the Continuation School. Briggs, Thomas H., The Junior High School Bureau of Domestic and Foreign Commerce, Statistical Abstract of The United States, 1920 (See United States, etc.) Bureau of Education Bulletin No, 35, 1918, Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education (See United States, etc.) Bureau of Education Bulletin No, 5, 1921, Part-Time Education of Various Types (See United States, etc.) Cooley, Edwin G,, Public Continuation Schools, /Cooley, Edwin G., Vocational Education in Europe 'f.Dewey, John, Democracy and Education Editorial in Literary Digest, Jan. 11, 1919 "'What The Draft Revealed" Ellwood, C,A,, Sociology and Modern Social Problems ■/Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bulletin No, 19, 1918, Part-Time Trade and Industrial Education Graves, Frank P,, A' Student’s History of Education ^Hill, David S., An Introduction to Vocational Education Lutz, R,R,, Wage Earning and Education '‘Mahoney, J.J., Training Teacher for Americanization, Bureau of Education Bulletin, No, 12, 1920 Mays, A,B,, Lectures on Continuation School Pupils^ Miller, H.A, , The School and The Immigrant Pound, Arthur, in Atlantic Monthly Oct., 1921, "The Iron Man" . '■ * 1 * • r i i i :n t ' •*<' '■ i-’H'l'it' t !■ 1 , 'n;i: L -.. tr A VV •v K' - *'? . r. It •* i. :'A ■ i 4 - ’.‘ !. ' 1 /■ I - 35 - ^ Sneddon, David, Vocational Education i^Taylor, Joseph S., A Handbook for Vocational Education Towne, E,T,, Social Problems United States, Sxirgeon General *s Office, Defects Found in Drafted Men. t Chapter II A Brief Survey of The Continuation School Movement The German Continuation School The history of the continuation movement in Germany may be traced back to the Sunday Schools of the sixteenth century,^ In these institutions instruction in church catechism, reading, and writing was given to pupils after they had left the elementary schools as well as to those pupils who were unable to attend o the regular elementary schools.*^ Sunday gohool attendance be«> came compulsory in V/urtemburg in 1739 and in Bavaria in 1803. In the latter stats a certificate stating that the candidate had completed his course in the Sunday School was a prerequisite to marriage. Frequently education of this sort in this in- stitution was all that a young man was able to obtain, because of the fact that his domestic duties made attendance at the week-day school impossible. However, due to the lack of school facilities and properly trained teachers the laws were not strictly enforced. In Saxony from 1835 to 1859 the enforcement of compulsory attendance laws was fairly successful, but the growing universality of elementary education put a temporary end to this early form of continuation school.^ Some ten years later, the movement was revived, "Under the terms of the »Regulat ior of Industry*' of 1869, employers were compelled to allow their 1 Cooley, E.G., Vocational Education in Europe, 78. 2 Sadler, M.E., Continuation Schools in England and Elsewhere, 520, 3. Ibid.., 521. • '/'i ■ ■ 'i''" ■ > i. j C ' ’J •.''t- ' ' ■ -I' .. .{: \-, ' 1 : ^ I . , r / ^ - X :: . t i .. ■: »>r>r p. • ^ ■’ ri .f.i- V* > 1 fl, jL :i |fc 1: ', ..,‘f,qii I '7 1. J. t J ‘.5 •I'. <;..>. C>* ' jr, •;, , .-vM 1 '.'>»V5' ; ^■' H>; - »i ' ,.:ri J.nir . I '. CX • . Aa . i ' .’Ti/- ■•S' »;rl ^ VI ■ ■■ vt£ il 4 /..-..S "I vi>i. • ■'. '■■''■ -.r ■ , •' V . - V# */ « L- '. ,h'] 'i.i/ii( mILai 'nt ij -37- workmen under eighteen years of age to attend a recognised continuation school, and the communes were empowered to frame bye-laws making attendance at such schools obligatory on all workmen under eighteen!T^ Under the influence of the Society for The Extension of Popular Education schools were quickly established; especially was this true in the larger cities. So great was the movement that the success of Germany in the Franco-Prussian wer was attributed to some extent to 5 the success of the new continuation schools of the Fatherland. The continuance of the German Empire’s rapid growth seemed to depend on its ability to keep pace with the industrial de- velopment of England, but this result was accomplished largely through the teaching of trades in the continuation schools. The outcome made the continuation school a popular institution and caused it to experience an unprecedented growth. By 1900 this institution was accepted as a matter of fact and was permissibly legalized by imperial edict while under the leader- ship of such men as Kerschensteiner the present system was given form,® Kerschensteiner took the position that the primary schools could not effectively educate for citizenship since the child*'s experiences were too limited at the time of his in- struction there, that at the age of fourteen systematic education stopped at the point where the moral control of the boy was most difficult, and that the continuation school was the appropriate 4 Ibid, 523. 5 Ibid, 522 . 6 Sadler, M.E., Continuation Schools in England and Elsewhere, 520-5241 Monroe, P., Cyclopedia of Education, ("See '"Continuation Schools"). -38- institution to bridge the gap between the time when the boy left the primary school and the time when he entered military 7 service * Since that time and largely through the efforts of Kerschensteiner the continuation school in Germany has grown to be a highly specialized institution*® A little reflective thinking about the significance of the statistics contained in the following quotation will give the reader some idea of the enormous importance of the continuation school in Germany some ten years ago: "'A't the close of 1911 Germany possessed about 3,300 industrial continuation schools, of which nearly 3,000 were under obligatory ordinance. The number of pupils was approximately 550,000, The commercial continuation schools not included in the foregoing totals numbered at the same time 7,700 of which only 80 were not under obligatory regulations. The number of pupils in the commercial schools was in round nijmber .90;^ 000 boys and 12,000 girls. Agricultural continuation schools are very numerous in Prussia, Bavaria, and Alsace- Lorraine, For all Germany the number was 1,700 obligatory and 3,500 optional. They comprise together about 84,000 pupils. In addition to the continuation schools having a vocational pur- pose, there were in Germany at the close of 1911, 16,000 continuation schools for general instruction, attended by 350,000 boys and 250,000 girls. The foregoing statistics do not include the continuation schools of an industrial character for young women; since, as a rule, these have not been brought 7 Kerschensteiner, Georg, Education for Citizenship. 8 Henderson, E,..F,,A Short History of Germany, 535-541. -39- under obligatory orders, it is difficult to secure exact sta- tistics relating to them. The reports indicate, however, that great interest is taken in the domestic training of young women in the Grand Duchy of Baden and in Alsace-Lorraine. As a general rule the continuation schools are supported by the communes, with the aid of chambers of commerce, commercial societies, trades unions, etc. The annual expenditure of the schools of this order is estimated at 22,000,000 marks ($5,236,000); of this total the communes supply 10,500,000 marks, the State 6,500,000, and the employers and pupils in the way of fees 4,500,000. The balance is met by voluntary sub- scriptions. The communes also furnish housing, light, heat, etc., for the schools.”® The Great War which changed the government of Germany from a monarchy to a republic abolished class distinction so far as nobility of birth was concerned. However, since the aristocracy during the old regime had never attended the con- tinuation schools and since this did not materially increase the population of the lower classes, the burden on the school was not appreciably augmented. In fact the assumption seems to be justified that due to the decrease of the birth rate during the war the number of people to be served in the present decade will be no larger than the number served in the past decade. But on the other hand, those people who are served must be so well served that industrial Germany may be cpickly reconstructed. Hence, this will mean that more industrial edu- cation must be introduced to meet the needs of the people. 9 Report of The Commissioner of Education, 1913, I, 818. r ‘ ) I li I /I f I 1 I I 1 i I i I f ) ( - 40 - Both handicrafts and mechanical arts must be taught. This will mean, probably, that the work of the continuation schools will become more highly specialized and that more general education will be introduced as Germany becomes restored to a normal con- dition, As the law stands at the present time all pupils who leave the elementary school at the age of fourteen still have to supplement their education in the part-time school. Hence, the continuation school is one of the vital parts of Germany’s edu- cat ion. The Continuation School of England The Sunday School movement in England may be mentioned as one of the first steps towards the realization of the continuation idea. Sadler divides the history of the ’’overlapping series of ef- forts for further education” into four main divisions. The period from about 1780 to 1833 when the first parlia- mentary vote for the purpose of education was taken extends through a very important part of the Industrial Revolution and the fight for political reform. The idea was given expression through charitable instruction in religion, and this phase was soon followed by night instruction provided by certain benevo- lent textile employers as well as by ministers of the Church of England. Self-supporting schools were then established, and in these such young men as George Stephenson, the pioneer in the modern railway movement, learned how .to read about topics of their own special interests. 10 Sandiford, Peter, ” E ^ .it'f ■>.*» •' ‘ » hi .. j ^ » .^i ■•U -. : v"!}*T- p- ■ ’■ ^ . '.‘li^r'tJ'UVi.'S V* ,)! •' ;V r r t j. .'.' -42- the synthetic view of national education, which is the dis- tinctive mark of the period, has been a convergence of thought upon the problem of the continuation school" as the term is 15 used in this thesis. In England only a few years ago the most widely known form of continuation education was the Evening Continuation Schobl which functioned both in urban centers and in rural communities,^® This institution, however, seems to be a survival of practices from the time when the working days were very long and when continued instruction was given only at the close of the working day. The continuation school as it is defined in this thesis is of very recent date in England. The Education Bill of 1917 for England and Wales inaugurated a national ceunpaign for part-time schools which were to be similar to the American 17 institution with which the writer is dealing. This is shown by Mr. Fisher* s speech which was made at the time when he in- troduced the bill into Parliament. He said, "The school attend- ance provision amounts to this: That young persons who are not undergoing full-time instruction will be liberated from in- dustrial toil for the equivalent of three one-half days a week during forty weeks* t’-vo half-days to be spent in school while one will be half holiday. Under the terms of the bill the local authorities are compelled to consult industrial and other interests and to establish >a variety cf types of schools, 15 Ibid., 13. 16 Ibid., Chaps. II to VI. 17 Federal Board for Vocational Education Bulletin No. 19, 1918, 22 et 48-49. V.' ,^V: :Jl V- .. ' ‘ ■ \ ■ ‘"'']l P ;\, t i-.\i J ,rri-y?^ Alfc'j i* ',■:, ■' — \ y • ■;• • ' ' ’ ’ . ■ d, . f Mttfa .-^C-. :\V rcoc*- 4 t’ '.. ■ • ■ V'*' " ’■’* ' •■■, ,v ■ ‘ - ’^1 " . -* V ^ : V r vf> . ^v.v i i A 4 '%y|fr‘: I •' ; ' • ...^ , . ' .IP^-'*' -*i( ' '*-,• ' *’ f ' . ■ » ' 1 ■' vO.' ..,&■• :>it t^W«lv'4V':'< '■ •.■;p . .,■ - ‘s Vi/ ? w '■ -• 1 . n.'-.prvt .-rttf .ft .'aid . ■ '■ * ^ ; , V , ^ - ffXyjC’ . . V ,,,':kv".' 3 :v , 4~»ij 'f***'^ *■«? -f-H »#t>« ?»|» *; <«S : ' jf. . -. ■(•-/'■ '‘‘ ''h-44swv. .iu^^*'BS. .«:. '"J' V * '•/ -V'' vJ 4 a^' 5 'pjy**, 'i a J. /' , '^ <■ ^ ^ , ' . .; .;■ ^ - .^ . 'T * > ■ ■ ■■’^.0 • ■ .* . : :'-:yj^x ,.;vvf 4 ^,i:,t>f)px/ 'i .;a. -/,’i> tJ*!'!*, iVj^J A> • vi*y ^jj^', 'ii- [W'4-,,, ''''a? J, r"ij y*'.''k \. .'. ■' .vjmBV.V /iJtfay.U .»4t*-f.'.i -43- The schools are to continue the general education on the foundations of the public elementary schools, and to give it an additional vocational bias with the aim to produce good citizens. Are 8 hours a week for 4 weeks sufficient? Having regard to the practical objections that it would be difficult to provide teachers of ability, that it would require large expenditures and a disturbance in the labor market, I came to the conclusion that 8 hours per week would be the practical starting point. At the same time I should not like it to go abroad that I gave the period of 8 hours a week as an ideal. Young people should be regarded as subjects of education and not as parts of the industrial machine. The bill makes pro- visions for the extension of hours at some later time. Industrial efficiency will be increased and the employers will get their return in the development of the character of the people. The only objection to the bill came from one member who believed that the proposals for raising the school age would not be approved by the people who had to obey the law," This bill afterwards was withdrawn, but a modified form of it subsequently was introduced. It provided for compulsory day attendance at continuation schools from the age of fourteen to the age of eighteen, This was an endeavor to establish a continuation school that would provide for general education, that would provide for vocational and civic efficiency, that would not consider the pupil as merely a cog in the great industrial machine, that would be manned by teachers who were 18 London Times, Education Supplement, August 16, 1917. 19 Editorial, Journal of Education, London, Sept., 1917, 507. Federal Board for Vocational Education Bulletin Ho. 19,1918,22. sn .. »» •( ' ■ i ' >(.:^VljM 3 ij. .; c^.., . 1 ,^ •■’’ . '. ■ V ' ',.' ,;>'■" T> v;:' ■ ■ ■ 1 V . :" • ■« vVlJj^ U/V%k - ; 4 ' ivr -, •,- L J^t^ Un 6 HlPi^ *i :U- -• ■':.•» \<‘.«i 3 t,' u.ii *it:/c'‘i?': ifi.- .. \ IL »*»ti/W. IPMI ,.- . * ■• ,^' ■“*■. ■ s' ■'" 'I Vxi.»,n;Vi - : 'iiJ/w ,^^♦K^(i>l >ci i'%,-.;;oWj > . ■' -t V S''*' *y'' xopjjf'^- i ^:'if^: tViiitflfct?- ■ '■ ■'•■ ' ' JLj ''v'‘ ‘■'■^^ '! ■ ''' ■ '*’( .ri-j^^O' . '. ' . j lilC V'">iJi.'i^i-< > 'Vi ,'£: * ’ y -’t oJtvHpir^ --<: ♦hifop***- si' il’ &/‘lv O}' *' -.’* ■■ i - ■ ■ ' . ■ ’ '■ ■■ / -W ,( fciiitf &4*6 i J3i b;; X*»4|t^ »i^‘HLafvL*A» ^ 9dT * ' . < /*• ' . ■ ' * ■■' s .Ti n itirt'tf : $.a Vii4it?X ':t nr -foci •»fi^ Oit »oojii 5 nei 5 jp: #=j T ^ ■ ' _ ‘ ',5ftUaiuier^Ct4 tot 0 l ./ n ■ ' , .'^•^ '''" *'J-.'I 3 W *'■. '• ' ' ' ' -\ i'li v^^Jjaoi/p (^1 , xcstoritx^ Otis jtciars;.-- a^pit^«ii3^ •E’ ’» '•' '> * ©V X .0 iJ&Xit'lo/if ?ico oifoit ^XXHir .^Xocis66. M#' 'ii33:, ©tsitoiq' ,', '■ ‘ ■•" :, .'-^-^x..'-' ■•.#' .‘tv X. • ' ■•'■^■'■|r^'W/^r| : ’T'' • ,, , ,, ^4 Of rCoXfiii Vxi ,2SGX‘ ©•" It xfir^©i'Cx< » al, . ^ioortoe lociS^ibo^i^,^ it' +^,;. ', 'a. ‘■'‘ ’ •■ '♦'■ ,r’ " ’V ;, ' -^ • 'J.'\ ,V^- >*■’ '’ti •./R « • *■*• vV'^;- «*-- ■■•1 . ,,; ,. ..'’*■ ' "I'n^, hi' 'V [k , '_ ,-/ ; lui :^,tl »,£x\ls^i frX isicfj'. iiffCi!n, bjUijk^Z i I'’ lni<6i o>ii ©^ijf<5,v YTX,i.aiq,-i4^it-©X tr .ua > )K;',„;r' '■■ ' ''-mim '■ ' aiSvi '‘*'' w ‘ • .vm 'itluZ- '^,:>. Xi-/ttPcX. # •• vOfi ^ptc i ■ fe'ii ^ t ‘ ■«> fVU.'v:. Ov - . - Jr’’ iT ' i ;. iJ: ■ Y ' ■- -■ xD ; ..0 •■;iT r' ‘ o 4 t ■* « X - r ■ • ; t Yi , . . - A '■ .';>! ; '■•>{: „ lT t .; y' ’'7 A 0 < iwjifi. X •. -^ y I «,* ' (♦■' PS - 47 - ‘X't employer, the trade union and the teacher." Since the Swiss systems of education differ so materially, this state has been 32 called aptly "the educational laborotory of Europe." it is sufficient to say that the continuation school is accepted 33 very widely by this great democratic people. Vajlous types of part-time schools are found also in Italy, Holland, Austria, and Scandinavia^^ As a rule they resemble the German system in such particulajs as organization, content, v methods and aims, but since they have had little or no effect on the American institution perhaps the greatest value that they have for the United States is that they reflect the cosmopolitan view of how other nations feel concerning the cont inuati oon school! The American Mov e ment The philanthropic spirit which expressed itself so strongly across the Atlantic put the continuation idea before the people of America at a very early date in colonial history. Its expression, as in England and elsewhere, was voiced in the Sunday School movement although the same idea had been expressed partially by such other movements as that for apprenticeship education in Virginia.^® The former, however, was more aggressive. It undertook the publication and furnishing of various books at a very low rate because it thought them necessary for effective 36 Sunday School Instruction. 31 32 33 34 35 36 ibid. , 575. ibid. , 574. ibid. , 574 . Cooley E.G. , Vocational Education in Europe, 276-313> Sadler, M.E., Continuation Schools in England and Elsewhere, 483-513. Leonard R.S., "One Promotional Aspect of The Smith-Hughes Act" in Educational Administration and Supervision, Dec. 1920,492. Graves, Frank P., A Student *s History of Education - 48 - The development of the public school system to a large extent made unnecessary the Sunday School as well as several other philanthropic societies which were trying to bring into practice their conceptions of the continuation idea* A distinct step in the direction of the continuation school was the Pestalozzi-Feiienburg system. It was introduced into the United States during the third decade of the nineteenth century in order to enable students to earn their way through college. It enjoyed a prosperous growth in How England and the Middle States. Under this system the increments from a student *8 manual labor were applied on his expenses while he was in college* A plan somewhat similar to this was adopted in our own century in 1906 by the College of Engineering in the University of Cincinnati, This indicates a movement in the working out of the continuation idea even beyond the usual continuation school?® ^ The American continuation school may be said to have been born when in 1901 the Board of Education of the City of Chicago established a continuation class for the education of apprentices of the Mason’s and Bricklayer’s Associations* In 1902 at the re- quest of the Bricklayer's Union and the Masons’ and Bricklayers’ Association the School was continued and its attendance was 39 increased materially* Other cities, such as Boston and Hew York, experienced similar situations and established local continuation schools* 37 Graves, Frank P*, A history of Education in Modern Times, 160-16< 38 Jones, A.J., "The Continuation School in The United States" in Bureau of Education Bulletin Ho* 1, 1907, 135-26i . 39 Ibid., 134-125. -49- They were only experiments but they paved the way for the first comprehensive state system in America. Hence, the history of each experiment is of little importance for the purpose of this study. In 1909 Senator Fairchild introduced into the state legislature of Wisconsin a joint resolution which created a commission to investigate the basis of education in that state. The commission was provided for and was ready to report to the legislature in 1911, The result of its findings influenced that body to pass a law which established a system of con- tinuation schools, A State Board of Industrial Education for the control of sts.te aid was provided for and placed under the direction of the state superintendent. Local boards of education in districts with a population of 5,000 or more were required to appoint a board of education whose duty was to provide for and maintain a system of continuation schools. This board was to be composed of two employers, two employees, and the 40 superintendent of schools. All children between the ages of fourteen and sixteen who were employed were required to attend school for at least four hours per week In 1913 "Pennsylvania enacted a law that required the attendance of all children between 14 and 18" for eight hours per week if they were em- ployed. Employment in this case was not construed to mean work on the farm or domestic service in the house. Other states 40 Miles, H.E., "Wisconsin Legislation Governing Industrial and Continuation Education," in Bulletin of Wisconsin State Board of Indust iral Education# 8. 41 Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 55, 1920, 19. 42 Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 5, 1921, 21, r s ■■ n ' ' •’ 1 1 , ■* ■?'; ' ' I ' * ^ V ^ ^ <4i> I ij-l i■ 1 : 5 '' ' ; 1 ^/. . ' C.I. i . 4 ‘iu-. 4 s- ..' . ..V ‘ ‘ ^ ^ k\. » I ■■ ’V. . ' . V > i' •* ''Mvlf ' ' 3 jP . 7^ ' rtb/ •/ hr . n ' ’ t V; , •> ' -;T.v ij ■,’' A <, . Si,^ ,' ’ * '. ' ^ 7 '■ * ' i' i. ' ■ I ' "ti- . . -rt'b ■’ •' .;■ s- '‘U ‘ ^’ ' J»' 4 i . A * ■ ■ i’ i *-^t £: r -i' .^ 4 '^ ‘ '- ■■ V ' ' V,' 'v''. ' , i " ' ■ • I mu ■ . ‘T' i ^ ■. h ^ jt-^. : >r :>i': ■/.■-, :P,v ;iy>< .'Uo . ■ ::^ i ' '^■'*'•'’ (2 - ii^‘ r'"' yii- l'%M2 f ' -- I- «;*tr w I ' ''*1 i>'^ / . Jf.,-) X » llPt’y ^ ■•■■■ A--»/ Tfi i ji bi/si. .'tfiiit ■ 3 'i,'..iieir “ r. ‘/%:t 4 i i’liinirirty '' ^ * A i‘;iA. fl - v:>if.3i\y i\i vt' I- ■ ^ IX .- 4 ).«fc) * -'i * ? ty.» ^■'^- 1 ,''*''' 'V'V ' ■' ' ■ / **** l\'f ■■ ‘ '< I /^T#| " *■'■ '»'« ■■■■ •iM^“ i ' ' 'W ', 7«4 I • ^ Jr * I • ' '^ I 7 j- I, V I-..' ., w ■ • KS^; .Ika'^i .ii'i -50~ quickly fell in line as soon as the Great War was over; at the present time nearly half of the states of the Union have con- tinuation school systems and compulsory attendance laws,^^ In fact the Great War was instrumental in bringing about con- tinuation legislation because it taught the states that pro- blems really existed. As a result the Smith-Hughes Act was 44 passed which offered aid to the continuation school. During 1919 and 1920 seventeen states adopted state-wide continuation school policies. The pace set in those years, however, was not kept up probably for several reasons: In the first place the continuation school systems that had been established had not been able to do in one or two years what the traditional schools had failed to do in a century; in the second place as the states in time receded from the startling revelations of the war they tended to forget the defects of their citizens; and in the third place the objections discussed above"^^ v/ere vital factors in retarding action. It may have been, too, that some of the states were afraid of getting into the difficulty that Illinois experienced in its endeavor to establish a state-wide system of continuation education. A discussion of this experience is included to show the difficulties that beset legislation and to show by example how the continuation school began in practically every state that has adopted a system of continuation education.'^^ 43 Appendix I . 44 Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bulletin No. 19, 1918, 42-43. 45 Supra, 24 bt ff. 46 Impression gained by the author in his study of the origin of this institution. -51- The Experlenoe of Illinola The continuation activities in Chicago in 1901 and 1302 have been referred to already, In the same city during the next year a part-time class in carpentry was organized. The results of the Chicago experiment and of the Wisconsin plan were so successful that in 1912 Moline established a trade- extension class. Just at that time the popularity of the German continuation school was rather wide-spread and en- deavors were made to attain similar results. These experiments proved very successful and by 1918 Alton, Galesburg, Peoria, Rockford, and Springfield had established part-time schools or classes. There were 2,516 pupils enrolled and the time of 48 46 teachers was required for their instruction. The agency which materially furthered the growth Of the continuation school in Illinois and in many other states was the federal subsidy provided for by the Smith-Hughes Act.^^ Considerable pressure was brought to bear on the legislature of 191 '5 when the Cob ley bill was before that body. Due to the fact that it provided for dual control and that it was thought to be too German in character it was defeated after a bitter fight, although speakers from Wisconsin and elsewhere were imported to defend the movement and outside forces were brought to bear upon the bill for its defeat, one. of which was the stand taken by Superintendent Cary. He showed that the Wisconsin system 47 Supra, 48. 48 Proceedings of The High School Conference, Illinois, 1918, 95-96. 49 Infra, 88-90. m’r, ;jf\'‘;-^r^ !/, ' iiii'Uii. 2 a.iit^'i 5 .'t'M' ■i9l\ }'^^‘j;Tli *’ " ' a'T oil) -. Jwri'.i 4 *,i- ' v Q-.'f . -M >" 4 ;‘ 4 WT| ^ ^y .* < S to-: : •’7' ' -‘'V/dn'' **' ’■ ' ’’. 'i '" ‘ir ■ ' ' *V’ *} % •'>*/ 1 ^' >Jai»i;i^Vif #5 -novifi^j t -.‘HP t ^ . vX • •; ' t'J ‘ ‘ •' l»’U 9 lwUr«f V : i*r': p t. tq 1 ' ^, . i . : ■ ■ h; • i L‘r''^ .' ■■*'• ; ;v.'- . , • r^; ♦ ■• •' 0 ,'' ’ , . !. ■ V». v.^i’. «' 4 . > ./;.H^*?-. ••.’■HSl''^ ..ri >iii| jt t^iT i rX X' '|F - !‘^'jrVkli3f ' '^"\| 'V ' ‘■;'*’v' J • ^' ■ •* ■' ‘j ''■ J '■ i q* 5 >- '‘.Ji • ? \‘C W't :^ ■ */ ■ " . . .-. V. 1'. i' ■ V J;, ur4i>; f4i4' «i'» fXA® !?I*^ow if>'' '•X. Vu'.‘.’^\ A' '■ ..>/# 4 . ^ .C'.-A .- • . ■■•.%?. V> '.J. '.'fl -Xv* , .•' • . jS I • '.■.<• <.,■. ' . f i 7 ®?!^''.:-; •; .. . - a; ^ .Ra'V*-®!? ' >• • ., "Vi'’ <^' 7 .'‘M-%-i|p^^ ''%"- y tf ’ • •^’ • • ■ ^‘iSHttU • ■/V',-: ••'■. ’VAAklW li-t. c ''‘S*** ''„■ i f7 ‘, n t - 52 ' was not like the one proposed in the Cooley hill and that the same forces were at work in his state to replace the associate 50 control by dual control. The bill was defeated but the move- ment for a system of continuation schools did not stop there. A like result, 1917, was accomplished by the legislature’s tabling the bill.^^ The next legislature, in 1919, passed the con- tinuation school bill by a vote almost unanimous: 84 to 1 in the House and 35 to 0 in the Senate. The series of laws which included and gave color to this law have been analyzed in the following way:- The first law accepted the provisions of the Federal Vocational Education Act and created machinery to take ad- vantage of it. The second important measure was embodied as a part of the omnibus bill and appropriated from the state treasury ^400,439.97 in order to match an equal amount pro- vided for by the Smith-Hughes Act, The third enactment amended the compulsory attendance law and provided that in districts where continuation schools were established already, all children in empl03mient between the ages of fourteen and sixteen should attend these continuation schools for at least eight hours per week. The final law which was important in this connection provided that all districts that had twenty or more minors between the ages of fourteen and sixteen who were not in attendance in the full-time schools must establish part-time schools. Attendance was made compulsory for at least 50 Educational Press Bulletin, June 1916, 2. 51 Journal of The House of Representatives, Illinois, 1917, 971, 52 Ibid., 1919, 770; Senate Journal, Illinois, See Index. -53- eight hours per week and for at least thirty-six weeks annually. The sessions had to be held between the hours of eight in the morning and five in the afternoon, excepting Saturday after- noons and Sundays, The age limits were to be changed in 1922 to include children between the ages of fourteen and seventeen, and in 1923 to include the children between the ages of fourteen and eighteen, if the children were not attending the regular schools. These laws seemed very good but the pressing question of the hour was how was the local district, which was taxed to its limit and which hardly could maintain its schools as they were, going to meet the situation. The legislature appropriated no funds for these local districts to provide additional facilities to meet '.the situation and as a result the men who most desired such a law had either to remain neutral, to oppose it or to persuade the legislators to give them powers to obtain the necessary funds. The legislators however failed to provide means for the carrying out of this mammoth project. Hence, the law was amended and this action practically killed its effectiveness so far as its original purpose was concerned. State Superintendent of Public Instruction, Blair, said of this situation, "The group of earnest zealous persons who formulated and fe,vored such a plan was forced to postpone the compulsory establishment of these continuation schools for at least nine months after its passage. During the last two years the matter has been discussed up and down State. Boards of 53 University of Illinois Bulletin, XVII, 19-24. F I * I ‘ . * ^ \' ” ‘ ‘ * )^' ' ' jyj ' ' ■ * ' 'f "'' it. i{ . -,A< ^fi,if\ ,' 4 h'laf fit -.A, t- a*--^ ,ti>v.l4i^J \ i| ‘ ■ V. ■' ■ ' ;'■ ' • j^nj ?(f' It s,, ■<.* . f , /fc-2 <.' c^' >( It (rV‘ ■ ^ ^ I* *j . ¥ * 'S i i (Uito‘ cf ^:tT(, ir:j'£ : t •>f, ■ ■ n f ;-'|l . ' i T? U < Sv»T DXil|b; t OKI-. . .:m> ' . •' .#:, ... f::^ » > ;’#.»* iulff .'wnt-' V ■■'• « k'vj — F ,/' /■' ' ■:' 'm^fw'i / #-i ® . •■’■ «- '-i f\’j4-' 1^ .IjjM IwAris '“.N.'jS "»-'• I);/ .rf. . ‘ , . , , V if '•' ' C; ' )"'’ "■ V ■ rr ’ ■'. ■ ^ "A 'vr^. ■' • ;... k%^cv. .> •.*.>. v' ' -.4^':, •;-'>’> . . v,'V:a Titftf*' V.?»l , ,;f. .' Wiiff v't'"' .• “I • * ■ • ■ ’ii. »V:.' ~s- ■ f . ■ ■ ■ % " 3 t}i' i >^1 X rf a?r ' qi} si: ft ■' -.iA (»; ‘a: ■ :% t . « -iJJi-VO'. 17 ^^, 'P >'i ijif. ^ , ‘3j I f. t ' h^mhm . . ' ^ ♦•/•<’ • . ' .» i ,‘c- V ' 4 ' ^ i-g ' * ■> ' ' ' !pi ^ V.’- ' " ^ “ - ■ . . ■ . y : C- 6«01 y ■■*'1 -VtA i ■ ' -'• ■L.i', J V - '.;v/'jLi:m^ , V" , ... . r. ' ' (/*'■ , . 'K :-^’ . , V"*- , ’ ''*v s •.’^•^li 41ifl !• ■», 1 .J TYr7«5^.t^ lit. •Mhaut -54- education, city superintendents, and high school principals saw that it was going to add considerably to the expenses of operating their schools. In many oases the districts were running behind their current revenues. Unless the Legislature would give a greatly Increased distributive fund and a greatly increased tax rate, these boards and school officers were un- willing to take on an additional form of school work whose cost they could not accurately forecast. It is probably true that they greatly exaggerated the addition to their budget which would be entailed by establishing and maintaining these schools, but the fact that they could see no way of getting any increase forced them to seek further postponement of the compulsory continuation law. At the beginning of the session it was hoped by all that were interested in the welfare of boys and girls between the ages of fourteen and sixteen who Sre now in employment, that the amendment adopted would postpone the compulsory feature Only two years. It was believed that by that time the increased distributive fund and the increased tax rate would have con- vinced the boards that they could undertake the work. It appeared, however, that the districts were so much alarmed over the possible increase in their expenses should they be forced to establish continuation schools that their efforts soon took the form of striking out of the present law every word of its compulsory provisions. As the law now stands, any district which desires to, may establish part-time continuation schools. In such districts the children in employment between the ages of fourteen and eighteen will be compelled to attend. 54 Educational Press Bulletin, July 1921, 4. ■ ‘ 'Jfr- ' ' 1 . ai i 1 '/<<] ^nwri*** .K*l-Uv- ft' „ iSWP 'w./; - '■’r -j^*: > *«! .' K , v'-s' V 'in; ‘v''-''' I. I ■’’I' m \ 4 v < ^ ^ ; 4 1 V fi.t vj ipilfgtrj tf4i^L '''^ ‘ •'» /t ) * 4 ->o; ’ ‘ *1 ^ , r ^ iN! : tt'J .t ^'*.o.-?'t> >4 i . «..• _ y * ' J; ’■, y ^i?p 5 ^ Ti 'i ■ . '■i* ' / \^' j ' '/ t ^ ' ■ .,\•^^ 'fi ^ f'.' 'i^i»r>rf#\i‘kcP ■- '.:.fi[A 'J (f> ' ^.. Ac ■ . O !a * ‘•■^’ ' k“' * ^ ' ^kV/L'*’* ' ' f ' r^ vr*u^,:f.v-K^ '■ ■” ’rf*’ fife' '■■' '•'^^>'i, i l' v^' s|w<;^.^' r . rit hd,^ * ' '. jM- \| ' iii:' M * ‘ !' '•' ■';. , _. ■'t' “' ' •>' %. v: »!• W i r? .i»i^/^ i‘.; A 9 t - x ■ •>■ ''■'v ' ■ ^ ' .... ' ■■■. M >>0 -*' ’ . . ■ - ,i' > 4 -^ ., 1 ■’' '"fe' . .vo.y,- w;-*# ';i. •t#^j'V . if . ' t Of'S, < *illi9 V TK‘ K’’^ " / V :,;,i ,u X i»U'< 4^4 >-^ o J; ‘ti'iii*' aMto roll W '^- '7 '• 7 ' ’ ■• :>,J\\i'l : 'Z ■' il;^' '■:V'^^.:^_, 1 , „' «£;,'■■.» niX Xwfo*.v’i^ ^itilSAiaK SW "<<•' a^»f«; yyniifc A;' \ :■ yi#i' 'i^ ' ■•'.■iw , ■ ■ <" '.a ,^'h ' ',,v' *' '‘" ‘ -'‘*H 'tj ifr .‘filSi, ‘ .-. ,.fe . ■" 4fiar*!»iit ,cu'!r%wpi ;?•■, ■ r- 'J ■'. .'f-.'«i: • ,■ ,.',!ic^ fi, ..T • ■ ; o‘ . ^ I A ./‘ '. ’fiJ 9 ai 5»r ■ ■ ',‘> 0 . ., Ww; ■ V r: .r * ^ ^ ^ ; A I t'fljt* . ' 1 a||ti' -*5 ^ , 'r ^-... .. ■' . *v--' . j-:' •■'* (t , , >. ■, ' V r. " t -"T jy?i '3 « di?i: :?l ‘ 14 ^- q « » » '•.. a « ■ >C' '■, .' "V ;*-!«■ ■',' . 'trtv '., ■ ,. ' ',v,^ "■- '‘ ' ’"'■ '■’■.'^(’'i^^' ' ' ’ '■ ■ .s* .- . ■ i . Tl« 4.!^^ Ft: % M U' T: ' » ^ /•4.. • . 1 ' TV '^5lC r.liflJ^ * .. ” -K*> - j .tf* " I ' W.w» ■ ■:x-';».’^‘'> '■ ■’ ■ '» > -«•♦ '.>(» I- , .1 ■'^'' ' ,-v \.:;,f — -J ■ F, ■(^w ^ tt 4 'T A ■ ■;: , ■" ■•■! '-i-.xjijM( :' i:'jtmii... ji,;. '?, ' '...:: fl,'-' f -58- London Times, Educational Supplement, August 16, 1917 Miles, H. E., "Wisconsin Legislation Governing Industrial and Continuation Education" A Bulletin of The Wisconsin State Board of Industrial Education, Monroe, Paul, Cyclopedia of Education, Proceedings of High School Conference, Illinois, 1918 Report of The Commissioner of Education, I, 1913 Sadler, M.E,, Continuation Schools in England and Elsewhere Sandiford, Peter, "Education in New Germany? Survey, January 17, 1920. School and Society, January 17, 1920 Senate Journal, Illinois, 1919 Senate Journal, Illinois, 1921 Stewart, J.J., "The New Continuation School," Journal of Education and The School World, February, 1921 University of Illinois Bulletin, Vol. XVII No. 2, 1919, "Industrial Education" Chapter III Some Factors in Organization and Administration Types of Continuation Schools At the present time in the United States at least three forms of continuation education are generally accepted} Each has a specific purpose to perform and is organized and administer- ed as the local superintendent thinks best, being subject to what- ever state regulations may exist. Since state control is very lax, there exists a great lack of uniformity in any type of the continuation school. The first type to be mentioned is the general continu- ation school. Due to the ease of establishing this kind of con- tinuation work as well as to the ease of maintaining it, this type of continuation school is most prevalent. Its specific function is to continue the education of the pupil along general lines. The instruction is intended to begin at the place where the instruction in the all-day schools ends and to furnish the pupils with solid foundations upon which can be built vocational superstructures and lives of social usefulness. This school is designed to continue the education of the pupils in such funda- mental subjects as reading, arithmetic, writing, and citizenship to whatever extent is necessary in order that they may pursue their vocations and occupy positions which are acceptable and 1 Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bulletin No. 19, 1918, 33-24. - 60 - profitable to society. ^ The second type of continuation school is the trade preparatory school. The function of this school is more highly specialized than that of the general continuation school because it is designed to prepare its pupils for Various trades or voca- tions, It is the kind of institution that assists pupils to rise from the "blind-alley job" to better positions by teaching them how to do some work whose future is more inviting and more in ac- cord with their natural abilities. In this type of school an elevator boy may learn the machinis'fr’s trade or a paper carrier may learn stenography or bookkeeping. Here most of the trades may be taught and the chief limitations on the individual* s learning any trade are that it may not be offered because of a lack of a demand for it or that the individual may be incapable of mx storing it . The third type of continuation school is the trade extension school. This school has the function of teaching the pupils how to do more efficiently zhe work at which they are em- ployed; it is designed to prepare them to advance to higher positions in the vocations upon which they have entered. This type of institution has been deemed so valuable to their interests that many large industrial conoerns such as the iiational Cash Register Company and the Western Electric Company conduct trade extension schools. Some schools of this type are privately owned and controlled while others are managed under the direct control of the public school officials. Four of the seven continuation schools of the city of Chicago are located in the plants of the -61- great packing industries. This means that these particular schools are teaching the children employed in their plants how to do the various jobs of the packing industry. An objection that is raised to the practice of carrying on continuation schools of this type in the buildings of the great corporations is that the respective industrial concerns dominate the schools and that as a result the education given is of such a kind that it can be a- dapted only to their own systems. Hence, the pupils can not orient themselves into new situations in case they lose their jobs; thus the purpose of the continuation school of this type is baffled. On the other hand, other people argue that public supervision and control certainly are able to take care of :lie situation and mini- mize, if not eradicate, such dangers. Doubtless without public oversight the argument of the former group is valid, but with public supervision and administration the argument of the latter group seems to be well founded. The Continuation Class One advance in continuation work is that of considering the class, and not the school in every case, as a unit for this kind of instruction. In fact, the term, continuation class, should be used more often. Certain communities have possibilities for the class, but when they think of a school as being made up of a large n^jimber of clashes, the continuation school seems an im- possibility. If a small district has a small number of children in industry, a number large enough to justify a separate class in the regular school, certainly the public school should maintain 2 Cooley, E. G., "Some Chicago Continuation Schools,” School Life, January 15,1920, 15. -62- a continuation school for them. The term, class, might not seem impossible to the sraail-town board of education when perhaps the term, school, might frighten them so much that they would give little attention to the project. Only a few or just one subject might be offered,- a subject that would pretty fully meet the needs of the group of pupils. Some districts are maintaining classes in only one or in just a few subjects.^ As a result of this practice the terms, continuation school and continuation class, are used often interchangeably. \ Its Relation to The Elementary School In most cases the elementary school prepares the pupil for his further education whether it be in the traditional secon- dary or in the continuation school. For his entrance into the traditional secondary school certain standards are held to very religiously in may cases, but for his entrance into the continu- ation school no scholastic minimum requirements have been estab- lished definitely, gome pupils are found in the continuation school who have had very little formal schooling while others have attended school as much as eleven years. The determination of entrance requirements along scholastic lines is a very diffi- cult problem because one of the fundamental purposes of the in- stitution is very likely to be defeated. A safer policy to pur- sue is to adapt the instruction to the pupil in the continuation school even though he may never have learned to read, write, or even^ cipher, provided that the child is normal or approximately so. 3 Board for Vocational Hducat^on, Illinois, Bulletin No. 30, 1921, •:%« V'' /■ ^ ■'■ "'Xr' v; . .1 . .■ t'l «« . ‘ '> , .■ , ' iX 7i' ' ''^ J ^i dj ■ '< <'• ' r> . I'^i 'f '> * -it ft n .• • o.’ ^lLii ! ‘Vfi >t . * ' f » .*! f y ■X ‘ i AJ '■ I S--*^ Jf'VV'«;;d.r s^qo . • ^e-tO'U* no,n««4-'?. frX^rVij t'.'”' •' ••; ;v‘X' •'■'vMII i f-->.'i' Jvfij -c •* ■■•'*';■- • im? "■^ ^‘ ' - w ,' • ^ ■ ’■• ^ ■ JVnT/'J- ill ' ' *■ ’’ I ^ 'I I •• ' ; . 4 II " r i-i,- ..^ jj ■>. , . * ,-...■ , ■■ ijff ' ' X’ iT'^MflW ■ -.il* ■r!i " '\' f • 'T^mi ' 'Xfo^r- \^^h!h 0' 'f B ^'^■;. ‘ifi ’ ^ ^ .- ;vB-v\U,-: , .1, x ' ^.' ..• , L A'^i'": i. ;*.i ■ k^.'ax: ftv''^-ta.t .t- ■ t>,t ■- ^n>^;4 * i • f " . .' - ’^'-^'-mi :’ ■' ' '" siMaiaaTiit"' /;,, , ;:■.• ’' ■' ^ - -.ilv^lK^. ‘ ../f " '~''W 'iit'i.r. '- >n>A'4 * i '''; ^ j,;.. ■>■■• A' .,”. ;A: * . ’; •"';■■ ::rP- ^U‘ Vf ■'< '■*' . . ' ■ -i .. . J ■ '- ■’■■■, ■■■.• V'V# . ■■. 'X''' ■'■■^"Ji j**r . ', '''"■ »^ ^ . ' ■:.-. ■. ■"' ^ ’■■'• '• ■• .k-"> . . .' * V-.- /«'■■■' -'ii .. V'... i.'.s i ,. . ..-■ /•:'... .h'»t, '- 4'jt35ciiv '»«Al ^>*1,1" •*.Xr-'.(X .4 > .. f.! V 1 .w-.ie'?vi ii il«mj!;..'vK' ^ flrw i'tf.-iqk'. t . "I iiviA •< T’ ' f ) ■: i i ‘4^ ^ * ■''■ . •■'a ‘ ”_ ’'J. ■ "ifJi; I ’ ' ^' ■' C .' ' S^M fi.lr '-i^'i'-.v M^Hr^4iTiivA tat *.' ’t . i • p V ■* It ^ ^'isl . i 1l ' ■ > ^* m ••f 1 ^ 'Tf) M Xw3?i £j t t Sttflif J' ••' "* . < pf ■ -y »•• fc 0^ rf .. . jjif •? • B . r .fie, i , ■' ■ ,y .'I .;(. » •' ». vli f»f ,. ;i'o ti->iK « . ^/v.- icy w ,fi^r ••.-1 :•;. \^tr .1 !,|i‘f eu,v i4 flylti .;" "• x$f •« V, i-i . ■ . i.-i ^ ^ “ ■ ■« * •‘It ■•'.■ » ’.s-f ^of^ ^ -Iff I :,.»v -(>8l / ' f it f^!T. ' W A^"." g'A , ■ V.'' f^/!'. ■ ..•-" ' uni'll ^ > ■■ -rvi' '4iCf F \ * 5' WT^' i\ --Vlr. ; /' . •' n '/ W.S. ,, - s d ■ ■'* #^v “'' > . » t-'*: ■ .' \> K:Jarfy0X‘ -. ;*^ ', i.^’3 ^ ; -jC ;t • w -w«. i „ ,,. ^ j . . . r. ‘ .4 ' '■ ’■"? ' / " *).„ •>'• <- •*' '■ ,' '. ■ V" '% .^'v .r-' . ,. V.” i-‘rtfi-.’ ■ J... io»« . ' i' vV'»<. /j'.'.jil!^ -tl' ^4-^wji vfpmw " lJUl'Mi! i*i ft' > ' ^ f >***^r5ars:^t>wrr35prj - 70 - means the ability to move more freely and without deference to cus- tom is worthy of consideration. Public school administrators do respect tradition to such an extent that sometimes where the "unit plan of control" exists, the supervisor of continuation education may be unable to carry out his program because the traditional a- mount of Latin or mathematics must be required whether the child does or does not need it. This hostility to the work of the con- tinuation school may come from the superintendent himself or from other administrative officers with whom the director must deal. If the principal of the high school in which the continuation group is located is adverse to the continuation school, he may im- pede its efficiency by not giving it permission to exercise its rights, as in the use of certain rooms or equipment. Those who favor the "unit plan of control" answer this argument by declaring that any principal or other officer who will not cooperate ought to be removed. They are answered in turn by being asked, "What would be done if the superintendent were adverse to the continuation work and if the board of education did not realize the proper relations contended for?" The former reply that if such a case were to be found an appeal to the people would be necessary, but that such a case could hardly be found. If the argument is carried to the ex- treme, it is evident that an injustice may exist, one that could not be avoided under the "unit plan of control." The "dual plan of control" is denounced on the grounds that segregation of the two systems tends to destroy an important: purpose of the continuation school, the leading of pupils back in- to the all-day schools; that the great social advantage of asso- ciation with the mass of pupils of all classes is denied: that un- I - 71 - justifiable expenses are incurred in the erection of new buildings and in obtaining equipment, much of which expense is a duplication; and that the ”dual plan of control” does not always mean public control which is considered more beneficial than private control. The objection that seems to the author to be most valid is that a separate control is no more justifiable for continuation work than for eighth grade work, or for vocational stidies than for civic studies. The third plan of control is the "associate plan of con- trol" which is in force in Wisconsin at the present time. This plan provides for serai-independence, yet semi-dependence. The continu- ation board of education is appointed by the local board of educa- tion and must consist of two employers, two employees, and the local superintendent of schools. Its advocates claim that under this plan the board members have more interest in the work because of their nearness to it, that they select better teachers, that they are not bound by tradition, that dissatisfaction because of differ- ent salaries in the different systems is eliminated, that the Q two systems are linked together by the same superintendent: These arguments are answered in various ways by opponents from both systems. Some say that the mere personnel of the board makes the superintendent choose to vote -either wi^h the conservative or with the radical group in nearly every case, thus causing embarrassing relations because each class that is represented tends to look af- ter class interests rather than public interests; that this plan does not insure better teachers because the superintendent should nominate all teachers and in doing so is likely to show no partial- 9 State Board of Industrial Educat:. on, Wisconsin, Biennial Reoort, 1914, 25^27. mV- . jlf;i ,;, ^."l^./'^i *si"ft *Vf; I ■-'tt ■s/^7.^ '**.' '/ - >. ■.‘7»^iB| •'.' ’V? ■'; t'i ■■■■■'PI ;. :*^y■■.•)? . ■.. i.'L jt'teb _ .. Lk . . A> ' TMiur!\ k : tr > ■ o 'i'''S h'u f-i Sf^ Ht ■' V r>iW'Mf4 • ''■ ■ll im' > ■ ' r* Ail ■ ^ jH.- * y ■ I** ' -fc. I ’■ i iis^' . I Vi« t * .!f ■' ;• . ''i; ■' !<^^] i * • ♦ . ■ *J^i )jf. V- ■ f r r47tr;^4|^t1^ ^ V‘i:_ ... „ ^ Jfp 1 1 r'-y-’' r< ' ' ' '■’y ' 'y "' > t 'tsr-.') « ■ ^^4 i - ■ i'* ' V ^ '™HI ^ ■ V,-’ (, :.*iKtjn4^Si,, . £o 3('%J ♦'* ^^'31 >% ^‘r?3xcr?ir- M .‘il \ * \ 4 J it cot .i V . .. itci ^ * 'm, r^TV\f. iv, ra^ 14 . *''' '4 '■‘,'^ 1 ™.' ■ y «“.' *. j. yv. ' ' ■ * ^ ‘f.tT’iY ' '•'^‘ •V ^ ^ VJ . . rit. bAf' , a t*!-^'^''‘W :„f ' ‘ .'v' PfA-y' .'. ' ' ': -.f '''‘ 5 t‘‘^ fe 'Ai i ).g r , ’A' Sp, 4 ;.n >' ^ 44^ ' ' ' 14 ^ {? ff ■ ■ •:'•■■. ' . . >1 »■> ■’ , y: rt<«>4 , ,, , 1 '■'**’’ '■■ r'V’,'' ./'. ^ ivva' ' tfeiV ■ ’ ^ („y' ;. * ..; 4 v .’ X# ,’H' ' ^ •■ ^ r^rnnj^.- ' ''r.. . ifSi ,'.l.. ■■'' ■ ,'.l''. j fctffe’' ..S'’' M '.J t ... \\> '■ ' . ' v’«r ’" ' 't, .*. ■ { • P • ^ ’■ '-WM' . - ■■ 'i r ,' 3 i ' ) Ql^jir-: *; 5 "-''**t' '•# i' 'i* ,:.j7 - ■ ■ ' y t^'.i >.j?]^* !. ;■ W . . j‘- ( ... -y j I 'A *■'■/' 5.'! '••i'.V; ;.?v.i! '%.An4gUlHi^ i>‘ wfi ' *lii; *^v K*-'. ,'f'<‘if>.0f V ^-.f' ' . VOji^. '♦ • • ■*' ' A < A)»ri;;Y 4 ..n'ijftu - 76 - will be required to leave their tasks during the time when usual- ly they have been at work. Adverse employers must be convinced that the school will add to t’re efficiency of the children whom they employ. Where automatic or semi-automatic machines are be- ing used, the task will be difficult perhaps. However, if the employers can be induced to investigate what other employers who have tried the continuation school think of it, they very likely at least will give it a trial. Some such people become enthusi- astic supporters of the plan when a thorough trial has been given. Humanitarian ism, as a century ago, may be called into action and become a potent force in inducing employers to support the move- ment during the time when it is on trial. In order to accomplish successful results it becomes imperative that the man at the helm be a man of brains and action. The support of civic, commercial, rotary, and Kiwanis clubs was mentioned above in connection with the campaign. Their aids still should be continued, because they can do much to in- still the spirit of cooperative fellowship, especially among mem- bers of their own orders. Fraternities, both sec'-et and non- secret, oan render valua'^^'le aid in such a campaign. Churches by means of their pastors and other leaders can add force to, and instill a spirit of sympathy for this movement in many cases. Organizations of influential ladies are a valuable asset in a cam- paign for cooperation because they often have both the energy and time that is necessary for the propagation of such movements. Of course the local situations will determine just what organisations should be enlisted in this work. If success io the goal to be attained no organization whose influence might be a detriment ' c > 1 I . « » ♦ 1 ^ 4 / I 1 <• i.'H ■m - 77 - should have an active part in the csjupaign for cooperation. One hundred per cent efficiency hardly ever will be attained in such a campaign; this movement , like most other great movements will have some opposition. Hence, its limits are not clearly defined. The preliminary survey that was made by the campaign director usually should not be accepted as final, unless mjore thorough work was done than was suggested above. But why was it not made in sufficient detail in the first place? There is no objection to this procedure so far as the writer is concerned; in fact there would be some distinct advantages for the director to have a complete survey made at the beginning, but on the other ha- d the expense involved and the time required to do the work would be so great that many administrators v/ould not justify it when the reality of the school’s being established is a matter of doubt. In some cases if enough time were taken for an absolutely accurate survey at the beginning of the campaign, the most aus- picious time fo:-’ its launching might pass before the survey could be completed. Yet definite f cts to present in tre campaign might in other cases help to make the campaign a success. The facts obtained in this survey may differ from com- munity to community. They include such items as the number of children of continuation school age who are in emplo3'-ment , the number of juvenile vacancies and positions in tl^ community, the kinds of work at which th children are engaged, the age of t^^e children, their appa ent interests, their home conditions, the industries of their ov;n community and of adjacent communities, and the probable future of such industries. From each list of conditions which the supervisor has deter"- ined he will likely ob- ■.itUSMUKXi h; ^ ^ \> ‘ ■ *v I'*. it6- ; ■'‘''^'’3 ■.■'•. ‘ " ,'* ' .' ’ ' ’ /.v..:fj; • ' ./'V’i; 1 ;^fWD»F . ' •• ? ■I • f * s, ■•'t ':■; , ■Si ' 1* ' ’'■.J\'A ' ,■ : • , »ti/v<. ' ,XI(« »’4jjfe'. ''T':-.' ■I!-''' ■ l;j'c*'f« '■ <■* f ■ ■ ■■ IV '-T’'.' ..< Kv.< 1 * [v V »( . - !^. <> .‘V4ll«/i ■ t f' ' . i£ll h. r , ..^r' '^vi^r " -■.•■ ' I A; .V- ■ ; 1A 4 J'i !■') :'f/', -i'^*-i .•••-' j^, „.-v », '■ y-'fjtJ.; ■/? ‘. /:-. ,’-+.V; JVv« *■; ■*; ''■ ■'«■*'' V :, ■' '> A,.;, :' ' ' :, ' . > ififc *-i Ti ii yv || .,u«' ■ ;!*« J«> » V V* 1 -M' ■ ’ ■■»■,>■ . f il;'* ®|jfi.|:J %v5,(9?U: ? ,»?!# '■ -r V W&. | M | ' ,_, 'f' ' f- / ' '' *^ ^ cVai \{^\ -vt ^4^ Is^ ■ «,;* is#' r /4?ir ■; A'k«'A;v/iV’ ' .i^MtBUr'- i‘“‘ ■' ‘ ‘•is . •-, .. r;' * r/-‘ . ' •?* /i7>i i 'i • ‘..«- Vi--r ■v*!gj^'' j.,':; S .M JA : A., ,' . ; 'Aj^’:„'., ^, ■' . .".'*^^V,,)ffl .;,■ V f ^ ■■■ >J:4'%KS^*Al4£|f »i;:rrt K^r ff*:? •'Jsi'!.-- a: ^ ■ V. f «f^r 1^' l'. :'-A. ’Af*" .'' •vl ‘ 7 ,'"' a ' t! rt* ,' ay>gV > - 78 - tain results that .vill aid materially in the conduct of this in- stitution. All of the data that have been obtained in this sur- vey should be tabulated carefully and preserved for future use. If certain conditions have been discovered accurately in the first survey, no need for duplication exists. All material should be studied carefully because the conclusions dra'/m from it may render invaluable aid in providing for the highes’t efficiency of the school What Type of Class or School Should Be Established? The ans7/er to this question should be derived from the facts which the survey has furnished. If the survey shows that a large number of prospective pupils are engaged in certain occupa- tions which have a promising future and with 7/hich the abilities of these pupils are commensurate with the work they are doing or expect to do, a trade extension class or school should be started which will provide instruction in those trades or occupations where the demand is greatest, providing that other factors do not make the plan inadvisable. If on the otheT hand, the survey ee- veals that a large number of pupils are employed at jobs whose future ')ffers little or no opportunity for advancement and ths-t they are unprepared to do any other job of importance, a trade preparatory class or school should be established to meet their needs. If the survey shows that due to a lack of general educa- tion several pupils are handicapped and unable to advance higher in industry, a general continuation school or class shouH be start- ed for them. Hence, it is possible that all three types of continu- ation education will be offered in the same building and under the same management. If all three types are needed and funds are not PkS' 'V. i.' V. '..4. vS® 'a-*'* '''■ ’ ■ f’^'V i. ■ ,•. f^i,' 'i<‘.'i’ ,u ’’N# , ' ..1 JfSjS r }A ifv./' -k; -••?'.*■. 'ifi « f. I I . i«»w . i *•^1 1 • -n r. < ' ■ * 5 ^; ■ ' ■■ V -,*-*«.> s.*: ' c- : - ' li .s, * ■ i ■t : ■ •»"’:1 ^"T^* •■ '. ■ ■'•?WSi * . ^ ■'’*>‘' 'V-^'> ' > '’^‘ '* ^i- . '* ' ■ ' '"„ .■<■■■ ' V-' ii’ ' ‘ ir.i'ti '’V, :A . ' :-%'V v.%-('.^'i||'^w -' ■ i' »-'^‘.'*.v’'' ' ^ '■ ■ jr ■■ '3 " 4 ^ ' : ■ ‘“js' "i ’■ — ^S'fc i'- • ' -■> '■ '•'“ ' % • ‘V. ■^' ! . :M ' '‘f ,■''•**.« V’/'VWU/ ' 'jr/'-lO r " iz ■ N'f . .>-», ra. . . j ■ , ^ ., ,, ', ■j*-v,^.,'«i '. 'i i ■ A" '’'■ii' '■ ^ ' ■ ' L. ' . ' '/’W«C ■ ^ ;''^i’V ■■'>>' ”'‘v py»raEn ■ ^ ^ V ^4 nx;K) ii 4 l ^'W ')!■■( ,'J^, ' '^'l^.' ■ ' ' ' ■’•''■ vfll •’ ' ft'' , I ... A iM' . -IBr"® ;v^ , te' ■' '■: " ' ' ‘ ^ - 79 - available to conduct them, then the type :r t 3 »'pes must be chosen which will serve the most pupils, othei factors being equal. One of the greatest problems arises in the case where the survey re- veals only a small number of pupils who are eligible to attend. An illustration of a class which was orgcuiized not on the basic principle of purpose is worth while at this point: The class was composed of about "30 boys between fourteen and sixteen years of age who were required to return to the school sight hours each week. There were two cotton glove cutters, two cigsr fac- tory workers, three machinist apprentices, four errand boys, and six delivery boys, the remainder being occupied in twelve miscel- laneous occupations. The technical instruction included two hours of machine shop drawing, and two hours of machine shop mathematics, while the four hours of academic instruction included English, spelling, geography, history, and physical training. It was said that the employers felt justified in giving the boys the time to return to school, because the technical instruction made them more efficient in their factory work. As a matter of fact, the technical instruction was related to the work of but three of the whole group, and even v/ith these, the lack of coordination be- tween shop problems and school ins '.ruction, made the v/ork entirely academic. The city was large enough so that youths with similar needs could have been enrolled in separate classes, thus making 12 the instruction purposeful." If this city had not been large enough for such a division, what logically should have been done? Perhaps the entire time should have been spent in general continu- 12 Ibid., 27. f- -80- ation work until the general needs of the pupils were satisfied, if the survey showed that they needed more education of a general type. No hard and fast rule can be determined because the indi- vidual needs of each pupil are not known in the case just cited. In some cases the establishment of a continuation school is not advisable at all. If the sentiment of the community is one of opposition, if sufficient funds cannot be obtained, if adequate equipment cannot be procured, and if competent teachers cannot be employed, the wisdom of its establishment is question- able. If the enrollment is very small, perhaps the gene'’’al con- tinuation class should be started first and the other types of work can be added as necessity demands. Where Should Continuation Classes Meet? This is a disputed question but one which all adminis- trators who establish continuation schools or classes are forced to answer. In 1S18 the Federal Board for Vocational Education issued the following statement: ’’Classes should be formed where- ever most convenient, is school, store, factory, or shop, and shall not be confined to educational buildings. In 1921 a re- port of the Commission on The Reorganization of Secondary Education, appointed by the National Educational Association contained, these statements in its summary of recommendations: ’’That in cities and towns having only one high school, the continuation group be located in that high school” and ’’That in cities having more than one high school, the continuation group be located in that school or in those schools, whose location is favorable, instead of 13 Ibid., 27. -81- establishing separate continuation schools. The vievTpoint of the comiriiSLion meets with the ap- proval of the author so far as the theoretical situation is con- cerned, but when such conditions exist as an over-crowded con- dition or a lack of neaessary funds’ in the high school, the estab- lishment of continuation classes in the stores, factories, and other places of employment is appropriate and their existence there is warranted until a situation is brought about by which the continu-ction classes or school may be incorporated into the 15 comprehensive high school. However, su di factors as the time situation are important questions that must be taken into account before the latter practice is determined upon. In considering this question as well as the other policies of the continuation school common sense must be the gtiide even though it contradict some theoretical principle. Types of Organization How can the continuation school be organized so that it will allow pupils to perform their tasks and yet attend school? This is another question which every continuation school adminis- trator should be able to answer and one which, if answered proper- ly, will eliminate one of the common complaints against the con- tinuation school: i, e. that it is not adapted to the employers' convenience. Several types of organization have been tried and have proved successful, a few of which have been included in this discussion. Sometimes a combination of types is necessary to accomodate all workers and employers. 14 Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 5, 1921, 19. 15 Infra, 106 et ff. * \ ■» ‘ j‘ K' • i '„i‘ B *' '•/ : %i : > . ■• ; i' 'i t'.4 < i • I ♦' i H' f - 82 - The ”off-tirae plan” has "been received with much satis- faction by a number of industrial establishments. This plan al- lows the pupils to take time from the regular working day to at- tend the continuation school. Most of the employers in Spring- field, Illinois, give the pupils not only the time to attend the Qontinualion school eight hours per week, but they also pay them for the time during which they are in attendance at this insti- tution. As a rule whsreever such a plan is adopted, the daily schedule of the pupils is adjusted so that the pupil may attend at the time or the times which will least inconvenience the em- ployer. ^For instance, let us assume that Monday morning and Wednesday afternoon are times when little business is being done in some industry where children are employed who are attending the continuation school. If the pupils are required to attend eight hours per week, the schedule is eo arranged that the pu- pils from this particular concern can attend four of the eight hours on Monday morning, doing half of their work then, and four hours on Wednesday afternoon, doing the other half at that time. Some industries find this plan most convenient because of the fact that certain hours in their business are regularly dull. But other industries do not have regular hours during which time business is at a low stage, and they are unable to . spare the children from the machines at any stated time. As typical of this kind of industry attention is called to the textile industry which is a means of earning a livelihood for thousands of child- ren in the South. In order to keep the mills running and yet to give the children a chance to improve themselves educationally four methods are used for the instruction of the juvenile workers: ■ 33 - (l) A small number of "spare hands" are employed who act as substitutes for the children during the time that they are undergoing instruction. This means that the force of juvenile workers must be increased by about one-sixth. Some em- ployers object to this type of substitution because of the extra expense, but if the working force is not increased out of pro- portion and the children are not paid for the time during which instruction is being given little additional expense is necessary. (S) Some firms want to use the "flying squadron"' as a substitution in order that their mills may keep running. These firms employ extra hands who go from room to room to relieve the workers for an hour or so each day or half-day. The time of relief may be less than an hour. While each pupil is resting he spends his time in the cont iniiat ion school if it is located in the factory or adjacent to it. This method implies that the process of manufacture is "speeded up"' to the maximum and that the children are rushed to such an extent that rest periods are necessary for the maintenance of the health of the workers, (3) Another method used in the "Off-time Plan" is the doubling up" method. This implies that the pupils have regular times for instruction and that during these times other persons do their work in addition to their own. A miller who normally runs one sacking machine will be required to run that of his neighbor also. If he is accustomed to run two machines he may be required to run three; and thereby the employer suffers only a small loss. Many industries, however, are organized in such a way as to make this plan impracticable. -84- (4) In some factories that employ child labor the "sur- plus plan" is used. The several departments have more machines than is necessary to keep the next department aioove supplied with material. If these machines are run at full capacity a surplus will accumulate. Then the children are required to attend the continuation school until the department just above has "caught up"' when they return to the factory and begin to accumulate another surplus. The Unity Cotton Mills at Lagrange, Georgia, uses this plan very successfully. Another plan that has met with much approval is the alternate plan. This plan of part-time continuation education was made famous by the College of Engineering of the University of Cincinnati. In such an arrangement the pupil works for a definite period of time and then attends school for another definite period which usually is equal in length to the former. The period used in the University of Cincinnati was a week. This experiment proved so successful that sich schools as the Fichburg School in Massachusetts are using it at the present time. At Spartanburg, South Carolina the textile industries use this plan very successfully. A shorter period could be used just as well. The Pacolet Manufacturing Company of New Holland, Georgia is using the half-day period.^"^ The "Cff-season or Shut-down Plan" is esjecially adapted to certain industries and seasonal trades. The brick- layers and masons of Chicago early showed the value of this plan. They encouraged their apprentices to attend this school during the time when they were unable to work steadily because 16 Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bullet in No. 30, 1919 17 Ibid., 38 - 85 - of climatic conditions. Coal miners could profitably require their prentices to attend a continuation school during the periodic striJces that occur at the expiration of their agree- ments with the operators and during the frequent shut-downs that occur for miscellaneous reasons. Establishments sometime i are forced to close because of a multiplicity of reasons during which periods a continuation school could be operated which would fulfill the legal requirements and give valuable contin- uation instruction en masse. The "P reemployment or Vestibule School” is a school usually located in the manufacturing plant or industrial estab- lishment and its business is to teach the pupil how to do the task for which he is hired. It performs this function before the child is permitted to enter employment, or at least it pre- pares him to do the job in a creditable manner before he is allowed to attempt it. Under this plan an expert milling machine operator teaches several students who expect to operate milling machines until they become proficient in that work. John L. Patterson, manager of the Rosemary manufacturing Company of Roanoke Rapids, North Carolina, after having the vestibule scheme in operation for quite a while, said, "These teachers devote their time to showing the new operatives assigned to them how to do the work properly. We of course pay the teachers as much, in fact slightly more, for doing this work than they were able to make before. The results we are getting from this system are very gratifying and we confidently believe that satisfactory operatives can be developed in this way within half of the time, or possibly one-third of - 86 - the time, that they can be if placed with weavers or spinners with a full job on their hands, and no especial incentive *:o properly teach the inexperienced ones." He had selected his teachers from the best experts in his plant, and his corps consisted of "two teachers from each of the three weave rooms, and one teacher each from each of the three spinning rooms, making nine in all."^® The administrator must familiarize himself thoroughly with the types of organization that have been used successfully and with any other that might be adaptable to his own situation. The basis for his decision as to which plan or plans best suit his own system will be the data obtained in the surveys and the information which he obtains from consultation with the heads of the various industrial establishments. The daily schedule will be relatively easy to adjust under any of the above plans except the "Off-time" plan which in one of its forms will likely be used for some of the classes. Hence, the discussion of it is in order. The Daily Schedule of The Qff-Time Plan The schedule of classes is of considerable importance in any school. No state makes full provisions regarding the program but it may set the time limits per week and occasionally per class. In general, state authorities provide a list of subjects which they recommend to be taught, but the lists are usually elastic and considerable freedom is allowed especially in the vocational subjects. The Boston Continuation School has a flexible schedule which in this particular meets the needs in that city.^^ The State Supervisor of Industrial Education for Illinois advises the use of the following schedule which is a modification of the one 18 Ibid., 33. 19 Vocational Summary, June, 1919, 36. ,^;'„v. , ,,>v: f : ■ ^r-r ‘ ''■•,h> V ’ V • 4 if'® ' '■ ^ ' ' . ' ■ '• 'i' ■ .'i.'^" ■ .1 '•§' £l f"' ''"' ■'■ ’'’ * ' tiy ' *'’ '*' ■ - ' ■ • - ■I'Vjiir;) .% e# S.!,, ' f ^..' " ilSsi 4.| M * vV , ; ,' ik^ni t.^iikm let? r- ' ■ i{r_-j» r 41 ( ’ 'F:S '' • v* ‘mTwP^ * I . F- »' 44' i" V ‘i#: ri tv ^ ^ .■••->■ ■■»•(« MiMpr- i-;ja ^,'.' ''.'Vv/v’ m -J- , . *■ •‘'tWV ; < .V- \t c 10^A. i ' X^t 2 I ' y |k v_ , ' A 'sf. i*i> ' :''t f-’^ < y kiM^i At' :» t , 1 ' 4-'ii V ■ . ‘ ^ 'T''' ■'' ■ ■ ■' '^.i ' .' *,*i ' ,' _ '7 ,fdt D*A I it V"' ■:,"' V. ■■ /' ', '.t' i >i'\ r'M . r.!'^ ^'' '''*W;' :VV :: v..:.v.n4Si:‘^ * .rUfcit: ' \^., }§ 'y '4 ^ ,.4J V.,- ■ I V. t }' ^ vT •v54of;5#i.4» 'V ' ''Wit* ;-t'j.JS''^'®^;>*:';^^ .. 'i. ,. ‘'’ ■■■* •-■«-.<' ■. ’“W LJ.>. •: ■'J-.'. . :. '.A.:A>.-.. ravHll'' . ..' if'.viS ,., 1 „■ \ ^ *V;' Hi y 1^^' ' '^*1 ■ - '■ iT'- \i.i./'.‘M4 ~ 1 ' ' i <*0 'Uttvk iv'w- H v'y, , f ' -''"i*" '■"»;<; “i'n a«i J ayi.j|?t!' ’ - .'. ■ ‘L ■v;.‘ ■„ .■'■>* ,\, ::" '■V'.',,",'. . '.V. :■ k'F' * r. aJk * i^'i,:jfc,tA CT ' ■' "' ' '.’■^ '-■<*'. i’ 'f'"' ' ■'**'' i|g^j|?^'j.-,it.-. .-»(.; «6tmr ,.'-.v. ^ .ii' i' |?’ ' ;_ „ . _ < ' ' ■ !■ r . .yi»mj ' * .'lU * ^ ® ■ il .■ ■>. ■ J»!*' Llkiiy^'.V . i ".. -87- Evans used in Boston: Time Monday Tuesday Wednesday I'hursdav Friday 8:C0- 9:00 a E c F a 9:;00-10:00 b d b 10:00-11:00 c F b E 0 11:00-1B:00 d a d 1:00-3 :00 2:00- 3:00 E b F d E a c 3:00- 4:00 4:00- 5:00 F d E a F c b If in the above schedule a,b,c, and d represent courses offered, such as general continuation or theoretical vocational courses but not laboratory or shop subjects, the reader can see that the pupil might attend school Monday morning at which time he would study these subjects. If likewise E and F represent shop or laborotory subjects it is evident too that the pupil might supplement his work with these subjects on Monday afternoon, Tuesday morning, Wednesday afternoon, Thursday morning, or Friday afternoon. Since the above schedule is arranged for a school having only one teacher it is clear that with two teachers and a little readjustment of the schedule any half-day combination can be made. With four teachers any two-hour arrangement can be worked out and with more than four teachers a great number of possibilities exists. The one teacher progrsm, however, is des- igned to accomodate most of the practical situations that require only one teacher. If more than five teachers are employed in the con- tinuation school and if the above schedule plan is used a bulky arrangement results, because a separate schedule must be made for each teacher. A single schedule cannot be made because of the irregularity of the hours of attendance of any particular pupil. - 88 - Hence, it is better to arrange for each day a schedule having a separate program that differs from the one in use on Monday, A schedule for Monday and Thursday is given below for a school that has nine teachers. In this schedule the assumption is made that each teacher teaches eight hours daily which should not be the case Schedule for Monday and Thursday Time Mr, A Miss B ,Miss C Mr ,i) Mr. E Mr .F Miss G MissH. Myl 8: CO- 9:00, a c A T ‘ i 1 1 e J “9":UD^1U:TO a d c r 1 f f h ii 10:C0-il:U0' b c B TN H 1 e J . J\ b d iJ 0 1 f h T:D0-”2TUU a d A ri TP j g ^ ■ t'' ' 'J:0U- T:UU| b c A 0 1 1 ^ 1 3:00- TiUU a d B r* UL J. e . K' 4:00- 5:o0 b- a JJ _J £ J] With such a schedule only from one to five programs are necessary and they can be mimeographed easily on a single page. In this respect this type of schedule is more convenient than the one suggested for the one-teacher continuation school. How The Continuation School Is Financed In most European states the continuation school is not wholly supported by public taxation, although some portion of its cost may be defrayed by public taxes; in fact public taxation raises only a small part of the funds which are regularly applied to this kind of education. However, in the United States just the opposite is true. Usually the entire school is supported by public taxation either directly of indirectly. Until 1917 the local districts of the American states that had authorized continuation schools almost invariably levied taxes for the complete support of these schools. In that year, however, the Smith-Hughes Act was I' V ';tri . ' - - I' “■ ' ■ .-€ ^ ' '■■ u , ' i|.j , . •' '■ ■■ '• ' \ * ■ n \ rz i}rfr ' : v; ,» . •. « r i. rllt '' f i k -89- approved and since 1918 federal aid has been given annually for that continuation education which meets the approval of the Federal Board for Vocational Education in those states which have accepted the provisions of the act. The Smith-Hughes Act provided that definite appropriations should be made as shown in Appendix II and required ”that at least one-third of the sum appropriated to any state for salaries of teachers of trade, home economics, and industrial subjects shall, if expended, be applied to part-time schools or classes for workers over fourteen years of age who have entered upon employ- ment,"^^ Any state had a right to accept this proffered aid pro- viding that it matched the federal money dollar for dollar with stats or local funds or with both. The act provided also for the creation of machinery for its execution and for experiment along lines for which it had planned appropriations. The final executive power was vested in the Federal Board for Vocational Education, but the state administration was delegated to state Boards for Vocational Education. This offer from the federal government gave a sudden im- petus to the continuation school movement,, since in 1917-1918 ^188,666.67 were available from federal authorities for part-time work. This siraount was to increase materially until in 1925-1926 and annually thereafter the amount given by the federal government for this ’work alone would be $1,016,665.57, Since this sum must be matched by state or local funds or by both, the minimum amount available at that time will be $2,033,333.34. Some states match the amount allot ed to them and make the combined fund 20 Smith-Hughes Act, Section 11. 21 See Appendix II, -90- available to the local community providing that it matches dollar for dollar the portion which it uses. This does not mean, however, that only one-third of the amount allotted to the trade, home economic, and industrial subjects shall be spent for part-time work. In fact, ”it would be entirely permissible under the act for much more than one-third of the fund to be used for part-time t raining”’, Federal aid is given only for purposes of instruction. The local community or state must provide the buildings and equip- ment. In order to do this a second method is sometimes used which is met by public taxation, use of bonds. Direct taxation provides the funds to match the stats and federal money, providing the school is doing work under the provisions of the Smith-Hughes Act. In case the work is not in accordance with the Smith-Hughes pro- visions the expense is usually met in its entirety by direct taxation. Endowments and bequests are seldom given to continuation schools at the present time, although in earlier days such in- stitutions as the Williamson Free School for Mechanical Trades began their work as a result of gifts of certain benevolent persons who had deep interests in the younger generat ion,^^ The Continuation School Pupil Since the continuation school pupil in so many ways is the secondary school pupil and since the latter has been dealt with so fully by many prominent writers in the educational field, only casual notice will be given this subject in an effort to point out how the continuation school pupil differs from the pupil 22 Federal Board for Vocational Education Bulletin No, 19, 1918, 30 23 Hill, David S., Introduction to Vocationa. Education, 143 ^ . I w ' i - 91 - of the Junior and senior high schools. In the first place as a rule the pupil in the continuation school has a less fortunate home environment than the pupil in the latter institutions. Sometimes by his parents he is persuaded to enter industryj at other times by force of economic circum- stances he is required to leave the all-day school and enter in- dustry. Premature persuasion or coercion naturally causes many children to miss much of the school v7ork which society deems fundamental to efficiency. Hence, the continuation school child has a school education usually inferior to that of the all-day school child of his own age. In the second place the boy or girl who attends the part- time school has missed much of the social experience which the other boy or girl has gotten through constant contact with other pupils in the all-day school. The training obtained from the meet- ing of children of all classes, the results of matching minds constantly for five days per week, and the influence which the teachers have in this constant contact can be duplicated in very few places. Much of this the child in the part-time school has missed, but on the other hand he has obtained an industrial out- look on life far superior to that which the child in the regular schools has. He has met men and women of business capacity and in dealing with them certainly a great deal of education has been obtained. These experiences plus the hard life of many of the con- tinuation school children give them a better appreciation of industrial values to which the continuation school mast add enough social contact as well as civic and vocational education to make I I ^-^^- ■*'"i-^V--i r — rV' r ^ >-jwJ.. w«w iiii t m ^.« r j mi a^' '■ '’ - • ■ '7 ' ' ■ ^ ^ ai; t i £f ,t BEe?c i:■r^^KtQ, ■ ,i■ 7' -^ ■-'' •X ■ ->w WJWj 8L. ^ ^ : :. .. , *-'i’ ' -t ^W^SSr ' 'i ' y*''' ■ ' * '' '^ - -“ViS sH "T"' ' ' ,fgV Io64t.% ] .: t.r'Oi-.m'-oi^ - £r|%v’'tci orfr «X v* ••'» sfi.. ' •>-• ■. ‘ '-• - „■ '■ ' "*V" '-'tSI/v '■■"*, . -■- » ' ■ ■ '-'.‘'..V ■ ■'■ I ■w» ■■ ' 1 9 ii M < *Ki; t 'M'I*; • v ♦cn^ » V4-«#^tera t- - # - n • m ’ .,,vr-.-v 4^^.t^v JF!»te!>.:4W it!?' ; mP^' ' ' ■'•'<“ ■ ■■' •■ ' ' . .• '‘ . \i.y‘ i4W‘. X .-i- ••* ’* 30^ - .>.i •A'*'^Jli • Xa^ a' '.*;ia A^ ft' ’ St'-’ f^'ii.» tfjM%»2u*'^i i ‘*i£'^ ' ;* •k. i *k -i" 'f _•> "i' T' ■ - .:fii'.y< ' 'Xf -' ii'ti J i'Syii "i: - 92 - these children more socially efficient. While the teacher in the continuation school will be unable to capitalize social experiences to the same extent as the teacher in the all-day schools, she will be able to use industrial situations to a much better advantage. The Classification of Pupils When the pupils enter the continuation school nothing some- times is knov7n about their specific needs, interests, problems, and capacities. Without a knowledge of these necessities classi- fication hardly can be made with a high degree of accuracy. If however, these things can be learned from conversation with the public school authorities, parents, and employers, a tentative classification can be made pending results obtained from that arrangement. When results show that improper classification has been made a change can be effected. Assuming, however, that no knowledge of the pupils is at hand a very good method to follow is outlined in the following discussion: A class in general industries or what the Springfield, Illinois, authorities call a ’’reservoir class” is formed. Every pupil about whom information necessary for proper classification is lacking or who is undecided as to the trade or occupation which he expects to enter is put in this class. The purpose of this class is to give general information about the different industries and about the capacities that are necessary for making a success in each. At the same time pupils are given the privilege of visiting the different rooms where special vocations are being taught. They are at liberty to try their hands at any of the machines under the direction of the teachers of the school to v/hom they have been assigned for this particular work. Their interests ^*1 I ' ; i id^ ra r Ji0 m’’t^tli^ '9 ic. t *^:i'Si:-,r::j£‘‘t!^^ D< * .•, -Xr.^ io<.*-Uw"i|--iii ; K' 4«r''f doi- ••*’ <^tir.'ni luctfc^-. c* j. * ^ ^ C7. i' %■ I. i, ,jfii ;.t ,i i^'i^.:;'' jW 8 "; ' ’ -♦t® ^ ' '*^*- ffl ■ j' vt" j ’■''' .* ■ ' ft iStt qfi!V!is'' iiufev i/'r vi ,v” ^ \ ^ 5 i ,■ ' vj&feaiij ■■' M, -•^., '■ ^ '‘’\i^- ;-‘m; i' ;■ ' *jXC- *■ < ' '■<' ' 'vi# ^ «iOfV ^ 4 '• ' V I I : H'r-v ;:t^« '-,#? aa&. ‘' )T »,V' .’Ifcl '■ r vF^^/''" . :uS; a*w^> f i'.Va . ^iii-4- .Ml tM - 93 - are soon discernible by their desire to stay in the room and at the work which especially interests them. Then, they are allowed to enter the technical classes and receive instruction in those vocations if their abilities physically and mentally tend to show that they are capable of making a success in those lines of work. Otherwise they are discouraged from entering those callings. Of course pathological cases should not be under the jurisdiction of the continuation school and when they are they must receive special attention. After the child has chosen his major vocation situations are created to show him what general education is necessary for the accomplishment of his aims. If he wants to be a carpenter and needs to know long division a situation will be created in which the knowledge of long division is absolutely necessary for the accomplishment of ;his aims. All classes should be formed to meet the needs of the pupils who should not be taught subject-matter which they already know. Time does not permit and neither is such an action a credit to an educational institution. Another way used to classify pupils is by the "cycle method By this plan every pupil with a few exceptions is required to spend a certain time in a class which teaches him certain things about every vocation that is offered in the particular school. He may spend five days learning some fundamentals about auto-mechanics and the same time learning about each of the other trades that are taught. In one school in Illinois children between fourteen and sixteen ^end all their time in just this kind of work and between sixteen and eighteen they specialize in some particular trade. If the first method is used, it becomes evident that -■ A ■ ' ■ , 1 ^<}T ;■ V-' ; eti •V'?' fif .-r &tiJi ■ ^ * >'ir? ■ ^ '.i'’ ' ■',>* ** V j"^!* '■^’ - '-I ,'*'■*'■5 j, •tl^-' %*■ 't' ^ ' '' '• •' »v{r > ^ M yaTjcP ^^ P: ^t*: . .r '*• ? ?ij a 'V.7 , . i X^/<31 V-' ''. ' ' :>!'■ '■' ry . A- , t S‘-. . i‘T . "K' , .»J*><;4t/ U'^if ^ o: ■t ->4C iEH '* Y - i' ^ -I ^ ■ *> trvjoi v" •'' ;. ’Vii:' ***a I f 41 ^. ^ i *• ^■^': ^4' ^ . Y > -39 ' II f> -i.t;., f < * i ' DS W ■ " ■ V ,^. .,-t; ^ »,- I- { n . '• ft ;)kr’^;■v J#jr* i «^ %-’i a|^ *•> ^ ^*'5' ?ii^ -i f, iAr'Vfe.' • 4v*‘ X**' ’U «. 'Ulj'o ♦‘t .Js:qlA*i«4i.v •Viil ’* "' >’i' ■•. A-"' '^'' 'A ':i>.j ;». .a . , . ^ •■■^... «k 36 ® 2 E:^ .ii9 a !*5]fji'l -94- classes necessarily must be small. In fact, certain classes may have as lov7 as from one to three pupile in them. Eight or ten pupils is supposed make a good sized class; it is thought to be 21 expedient that no class should have more than twenty pupile in it. What use have intelligence tests in the classification of continuation school pupils? They have the sa^^ie general use as in the regular all-day schools. Such tests should be given for the purpose of obtaining an index of the pupils* mental capacity in order that they may be guided rightly and be pushed to the maximum of their abilities. Some group test, such as the Otis, should be given first, and this should be followed in doubtful cases by some individual test or tests, such as the Stanford Revision of the Binet-Simon Tests in order to check and balance the results of the first test. Educational achievement tests sometimes may be used to find out whether the pupil has attained a high enough degree of pro- ficiency to pursue his vocation without further education in the general subjects, such as reading and arithmetic. Such tests as Monroe* s Standardized Silent Reading Tests and the Courtis Arithmetic Tests seem worthy of mention in this connection. Perhaps before long certain very reliable standards will be available which can be used as a minimum achievement requirement for the general cont iniiation subjects. At present no such trustv;orthy data is available but their determination would be a great contribution to the educational field. The Curriculum Behavior depends considerably upon imitation. The fact is 21 Federal Board for Vocational Education, Illinois, Bulletin No. 13 1920,13, r* • ■'s.'.y -r «fc.Trtit"nnr«i< W oilifii II .. ’ •'•" r'-1iiA ' .* ■ ft»K* sff> i ^>h: \ Mil i- ’ c ■ •«. i r,//*** >>\r« bf.‘-j,- ■¥* fc^ u gy i 8.,‘^jtv/ i>'r iA* ’!^r 3 V'. X- iri^ - Men, j-v 5. .• •4^^1t.e i,- <♦; »; ‘.^ v.■V-' ^ :^.r . •: • ] , ' ^ "■ ... .4 Ifff ra4^ f. j H ‘.‘ • N.i« /iii *r^ r.‘ 'VV.-y;' ■' * ‘•j 41#'iWLf,i '■ v:tt4dt4wc'‘' .' .i:,lC*r-lf '‘o' . . ff, >• * ....". .nViu'7 .f• 'ii' i’^SISBBMIS '5 '^ . i ' -. "'<■ . ^ «-T.< i Ilk! ' .' Wiu K ■'^9^5 ''VAl M^feW '* mitia-.'o.t ; , t* ,' ^'i ’ • ■ / 1 / V ' idi'-iiMBlSIf ' ^ ^ j> ■; -0 *‘ li , •, I'e i ■ fc -1 tf .t.T jg p’ ■ . ‘-r.ivv • tl J 4'<^‘ ' f V- ’ .rii’iif'ito J| y :, /TO I'^X :: J \jp; ■■ *' • X“ ' 4 ' 1^ ^. ' il^wr t,«4 . .r.-’ c.* ’ rtl/ ,; ••;, '.'ll ,. \' ♦ ‘ X.® l3ff liVi ' d j;?!ri:5 . 0 /.' ■ ' ■- '■ 2 . -I' " /’• 7. '• 'A ’V V ilf v,<®. jiB-' .* j ■» ».. '*'. ' uBQ' aitfAi'* ’ •'^4 . tV '-j /. . KAIl- '. l'..‘.;'.i '. ‘ -l' ' ' -r, .-1 '....'-at'. hmA - 95 ' very noticeable in the ciirricula of the continuation school. When a continuation school is first established the curriculum of some other school is adopted usually in toto or in a some- what modified form. Both federal and state boards for vocational education give suggestive courses of study which frequently have been taken from the existing schools of some cities and which have come to the attention of these boards. In many instances this practice is not to be cond.^mned because if the supervisor of a system is not an expert curriculum builder certainly he had better adopt a curriculum that has proved successful some- where than to risk his ability to construct an absolutely new curriculum. When some curriculum is copied, however, trouble may be brewing because it may have the same fallacies in it, that drove the boy from the all-day school. In one school that the writer visited he found a class in auto-mechanics busy tearing down and assembling an old oar which could not be forced to run, the only automobile in the shop. This activity, the teacher said was the major problem of the course. As a result, a general lack of interest pervaded the entire class. The class just re- ferred to was in sharp contrast to another in the same subject at another school which the writer visited. The problem was making broken cars run, one of the same nature as the garage man has to meet. Its solution was accomplished when the break was adequately repaired. The work was on the project basis and much interest pervaded the entire class. The positive classroom activity of both pupils and teacher showed that the work was on the right basis, the meeting of a need. In other the i^' . a S\ 3A' „... :‘/>'5C < wA,./ Xitv^idt. 'Mfa^v 143(4 * ’SmU^' < ■■' ' ‘ ■ i fS’; :^";^t^^W*-’ 'Si ■I .M'i,f rr ^ v : . . •■-•,x?<»i 4 rrfi ■ ’ " • » J . ■' • */ ';s( t^>' /j . >t^1iTr-7v . '■ '^■'’ ', ' "' , '» :cec ‘■t'VJ-V j ■ '•• 'v>-? :■*# t. V '3 \- -.fit .■••/! I, ■ X 8.4 Wilzi/tv'irffil'.ii •»il|M7 .•' '. '’fv ' ..■ xvv, ' K > .;,yt «♦ 'n *»,•' -'tfr' I [' '♦ 1- .•*ra I ^ ^ ■: ••' - .,: , ' -^^Ari ■■ sf if' 'A ■■■*•. •.•.‘•••*yp''"'«^“ *>■ ' 'W,1 •■ -. ■ I'.Ait? vp ‘"J %x; ■•W'j , V fvV^ r; , .. - ’ tf. ■ \ x<* ■ ^ ’»-? *i ^ ' ',4'’’' Jl‘ ' ' ■ -!a>' ’'■ f li'iv ' L.ff %.. ■§ , 'vt>'A '■ri'.'t’jji^ ■ ^uj f ^*V. ■3 *' l «. ■ I, '■/•■ lA ki n -' '.vfc^* ^i -J’l, ^ . . , . ^'7 P 7; ■ ' ' ^' 1, ■ ■’ ■■ Av ■„ .4V tfisi'-f" MJt' ' - '■' ■ -f '’‘-'I '■‘■•"^^'it'-jkl’ ' "w- 'r''': ' '’it® ''' « ».l-;'|'wW t ..* i. < , ■' ■•* ;t i r 4 • I I ('- - 97 - age who think that they would like to become carpenters they are placed under the instruction of a practical carpenter. If at the end of a reasonably long period of time they are still of the same mind, the carpenter is paid an annual salary to instruct them. Such instruction is under the supervision of the continua- tion school authorities and is for as many hours weekly as they may determine. The carpenter in order to profit from the result of this trial experience must make the work interesting and profitable to the boys. The great difficulty in the working out of the plan is the finding of an artisan who is competent to teach the trade. He may be a good carpenter and at the same time be a poor teacher. As a result, the "^try-out course” in carpentry in one community might be a total failure while in another community it might be a success. Hence, it is clear that this method is not absolutely satisfactory in determining every trade that should go into the continuation school. The Equipment of The Continuation School The equipment that the continuation school should possess depends upon the courses that are being offered. Each course may contain phases that require tools which are peculiarly fitted for particular jobts. Since different teachers may use different tools for the accomplishment of the same result, the administrator should solicit the advice of 'his teachers as to what tools they need. The latter, however, will have a tendency to request many tools that are not absolutely necessary for the course. The budget system is recommended in order that each •i*. . 4 . l: . ti ., . ,, T. f ■■, : ^ ' • \ , 'v?t i . ’ .' ',' 1 • •••-- I ' ' s' ,• , ■yt < 4^ n 4 ., •'>••>-- a I.- > » ^ 1 4 i »*''**’ vl'-i;;. i‘ :. 'f 1 ’ ■ 'Vv - . ' ■ I • '■■'i ;.i^ I . r 'I H » .-' n » . ■ # M; ^ . ■ t;i.v 7'v*- ■■ iTT' I .. ■ , ^ >: ■‘ 'i f, 4i . ! ' j , ; / / ' '/■> ■ «i Arr%-iS :,i - 98 - department may spend its allotment most wisely. Tet some prac- tical objections to the budget present themselves. In fact each department feels that it must spend all of the funds that are alloted to it when equipment is n'^eded to a greater extent in other departments. This cannot be wholly eliminated but if the supervisor keeps a firm hand on what is being done and uses a flexible budget part of the difficulty will be obviated. On the other hand if the administration is to hold every teacher strictly responsible for the work that is being done under his supervision, proper equipment must be furnished. The ability to properly equip a continuation school should be con- sidered well before its establishment. If working tools cannot be supplied to the teachers, the wisdom of the establishment of a continuation school is questionable. Compulsory Attendance The value of compulsory attendance at the continuation school hardly can be questioned. Its arguments rest on much tie same arguments as those for compulsory attendance at the regular Q'dl^^s.y schools and like the traditional public school its en-~ forcement is vital to the highest efficiency of the institution because pupils, in general, cannot advance with their fellow- pupils when their attendance is checkered, if they have no other means of obtaining instruction. Since most fathers and mothers are unable to instruct their children along technical lines other than the one in which they have specialized, (provided that they have specialized), attendance at the continuation school is necessary for the continuation school pupil in order that he may advance rapidly and regularly. r r r *4 L •' <■ I • ( [ ,V ■’ ■ ^ i«:<' 9tfV,-l>'-^. ■ MVltlit'in Ut . . V; , it»WwB< tf . y I L * -• ^ ‘ . I '■•. «i I • I * > . f ^ p. Q’^51^' Xi*t4 ^il^X)' & .•.•<) J L ^vuV^T^f *• * ' .■iSvta 1»-' ji v.oAco-' ^*- ’ '■‘5 V'1 ^ I • '?■ •■■' -'i#^ ^ V4P V'-r’if ^j^f.-T-'i tn- / Cv'v tn.*? t II . • ;t ■ ■ .’ ,’ ' • '■ • .■ \\!>n . ' ' ' • ' . ■■ ::j4t \ 1 •■' i ! ’ i ■i* ' '^.>!^ '• I'y / ' f '■■ , , . •' i > . ': iMmin *■• Vr ;'<^ »' .■■ "';V ■-■.iP'y ■■$■ 7- !V^’r?: .’■' -V'^f , % \JAj,yy:S lUnjt ■ iiicc .i .•V > *.'• jr j ir V' . '' ''^'^ '/- r i . . . . ^ ‘ i. ^ rJ^jJfi.lb . -‘^ j .k .1 i^lr ^Av4. ik.n L'. .' Pl^nBA^^Il _>. ][^»Ai' M i4 . kjijiii ^Bl.4 ... A M x > >jv . mm i .» j* «a < V.V V li » ■' .r ‘fLlt .T .'.it -99- The movement for compulsory continuation education was early espoused hy certain German cities, and it gradually became more widespread until by the middle of the last decade in about four-fiffhs of the states attendance for boys v;as compulsory up to the ages of sixteen, seventeen or eighteen, while for girls attendance was compulsory up to the ages of fifteen or sixteen. In the United States, however, no difference is made between the sexes in compulsory requirements. Compulsory attendance in America has been referred to already. At the present time a decided movement is going on to establish a definite mlnimuirn age require- ment which is to be uniform in .all the states. It seems that the "■minimum number of hours of attendance in continuation classes should be not less than eight hours a week for each week that the high school is in session, or a requirement of not less than 330 hours per year distributed over a reasonably long period of time during the year,"' according to a recent study. The same commission recommended that the attendance be made compulsory up to the age of eighteen unless the pupil has completed his secondary school work. Methods of Securing Attendance ^ The methods of securing attendance that are in use in the all-day schools may be used with excellent success in the continuation school. The new methods of instruction per se interest the pupils in what they are doing and the subject-matter with which they deal is closely connected with the work that they 23 Sadler, M.E., Continuation Schools in England and Elsewhere, 518-519, 24 Supra,50 et Appendix I . 25 Bureau of Education Bulletin No, 5, 1921, 19, - 100 - are doing or expect to do in industry. The teachers are vital instruments in giving the continuation school an especial interest for the pupil. Their personal magnetism, example, and interest in the lives of the pupil give the continuation school consider- able prestige sunong the juvenile workers who are attending it. The most important leverage on the compulsion of atten- dance, perhaps, is the activity which should be connected with every continuation school, of assisting the pupils to obtain jobs and to advance them to better ones. Principals of continua- tion schools almost universally agree that due to this one activity they are able to win and hold the confidence of the children who come under their influence. No other school has such an opportunity coming at the critical period of the life of its pupils and every pupil realizes that if he is to obtain the best job he must be on the friendliest terms with the con- tinuation school,. Various members of the faculty visit him at his regular duties, find out how he is getting on, sympathize with him in ^is adversities, encourage his good endeavors, and have heart to heart talks with his employers. Such exertions win his confidence and often he will show that he merits the confidence and interest shown in his favor. The oomp'alsory attendance law is always necessary when the school goes into operation if results are expected soon, but after it is running smoothly compulsory attendance will have to be enforced in few cases. Failure to attend the continuation school usually means for the pupil dismissal from his job, if the employers cooperate loyally with the school authorities. It means also the revocation of his working permit and the return -lo;- to the all-day school in many oases, depending of course upon statutory requirements. In addition it usually means the im- position of a fine upon both the employer and the parent. This has a tendency to insure attendance thereafter. The Teaching Staff Reference already has been made to the supervisor of continuation education. The same type of person is needed for principal where the continuation school is not a part of a com- prehensive high school, but principals with experience less broad may make successes if they are working \inder the firm hand of a competent supervisor. The teachers of the various subjects form the fountain of the vitality of the school. In many cases the success of the institution depends upon them more than upon any other single f actor. The Federal Board for Vocational Education recommends that ”If it is weaving that is to be taught the best weaver in the mill should be sought for teaching purposes; if the subject under consideration is loom fixing, the most expert loom fixer should become the instructor, and similarly throughout the rnill?^® It is reasonable to expect that educational authorities will take exceptions to the fitbove quoted statements because the most expert artisan is sometimes the poorest teacher. Vaughan says that the carpenter instead of teaching the boys how to build the house builds it for them. He contends that teachers who know how to teach should learn the trades and jobs and become teachers 26 Supra, 74 et ff. 27 Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bulletin No .30, 1919, 16. 28 Ibid, 17. 29 Vaughn, S.J., Lectures on Vocational Education. , . 'At, i iX* 1 ■ '.' .• V , ■ 'iS'' !■ ' * , ' 1* '•• .'•■■ .' 'V ' ‘1^ V«t 1 ^ . ■ ''l' < : w '. ' *; n'v I l' ‘ ■ M. ‘ .L, V V' . . ' ■ /. ^ '».» , y^ii >-•■ k-i ; * j 1 '■ ni’/ . . . ‘ 1 ' ' '■ '■/■' ■.' fV ♦ • . . . * » i-'. ' ■'■ c .' '. '. ‘kl' : , .. . ■ ,-' - f (t (.* ' in.' ",< ■ / ;,-.yrctr' ■ . , -'V ■ . / ■ - ■ * V 'J „ '.1 ^ - 102 - of them rather than have expert workmen become teachers. At the present time, however, both plans are employed and excellent teachers of both types are now found in the continuation school. Some states have adopted tentative minimum requirements for license to teach in the continuation school. The standards set for teachers of general continuation subjects are usually higher than those set for teachers of the trade extension or trade preparatory subjects. This condition exists primarily be- cause of the greater availability of teachers of the general continuation subjects. Illinois requires at least graduation from the eighth grade for the latter and two years of education beyond the high school for the former?^ At the present time, perhaps, these standards are too low, but exceptions to ideal standards must be made when the supply of properly qualified teachers is limited, as was the condition during the Great War when the Stats Board for Vocational Education in Illinois made its ruling. In many places the regular high school teachers con- duct the major portion of the continuation work, although the advisability of this practice is questioned by some school men. Vocational Guidance A necessary adjunct to the continuation school is the Bureau of Vocational Guidance, At the head of this bureau usually is the principal of the school or a teacher who seems to the principal to be properly qioalified for this position. In the largest continuation schools which are not operated by some industry a director of vocational guidance may be found. The duties of this officer in either case are to place the pupils in 30 Board for Vocational Education, Illinois, Bulletin No. 13. 1920 pp. 18-19. - 103 - positions to which they are best adapted, to watch their work, and if they deserve the honor to advise their promotion to better positions when the opportunity presents itself. It is his duty to give them some instruction which will lead them to the trades that best suit their capacities and abilities. Perhaps, too often, this officer has so many burdens placed upon him that he cannot do justice to this particular office, and even when the duties of vocational guidance become too heavy for him proper assistance is not supplied. Perhaps here is one of the inefficient parts of the continuation school as it exists today. Summary For the purpose of meeting different situations three types of continuation schools or classes are used widely: general continuation, trade preparatory, and trade extension. The relation between these schools and the regular schools depends upon state laws and local conditions. When a continuation school becomes a reality in any community the daily schedule and other units of organization should be arranged to best meet the needs of the community. In order that this may be done, the federal government has seen fit to aid the states in financing the continuation school by means of subsidies provided by the Smith-Hughes Act. Yet the major expense in most cases must be borne by the local unit . Compulsory attendance laws have been enacted in order to force the unwilling child to take advantage of this institution; yet other agencies seem to be just as effective in many cases. after the pupil has been in attendance for a short time. One of the foremost of these agencies is the power exerted by the Bureau for Vocational Guidance through its placement department. «* l' \ I i i i i -104- Seleoted Biblio^rafthy Bawden, William T., ”The Relation of The Elementary School to Sub- sequent Industrial Education," National Educational Asso- ciation Proceedings, 1912, 912 ff. Board for Vocational Education, State of Illinois, Bulletin No. 13, 1920, "Day Continuation Schools " Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 5, 1921, "Part-Time Education of Various Types'.* (See United States, etc.) Cooley, Edwin G., "Some Chicago Continuation Schools," School Life, January 15, 1920. Course of Study for The Common Schools of Illinois, Sixth General Revision, Sixth Year Arithmetic Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bulletin No, 30, 1919, "Evening and Part-Time Schools in The Textile Industry of The Southern States" Federal Board for Vocational Education, Bulletin No. 19, 1918, "Part-Time Trade and Industrial Education" Hill, David S., Introduction to Vocational Education Hurd, H. B., Revised Statutes, Illinois, 1919 Sadler, M. E., Continuation Schools in England and Elsewhere Smith-Hughes Law, Sections 3 and 11 Vaughn, S. J., Lectures on Vocational Education Vocational Summary, June 1919. Wisconsin, State Board for Vocational Education, Biennial Report, 1914, 25 ff. i yw i — ' ‘ V ■•’ ■*• •*■ ■ ' ■ •• • V. .* ‘‘A' / p 'v' -':■ , ■T '■ t ■ •■. ■ ^- ' : ,: ' 'h l^i»V ' ■ ^1 ' ' 'V W6k UfA '' ;>* Itvii P ^ ^ ■ •*t'-' ■'■ " ' '' '” '■ t . V ^ ^ K :.« ■> X ': r , .» « . - M, X, ' i"JLl ' ' ■'■■■^ 'I^'' '* X',.. :%’ '"'.',1 «;/■/. y'-' X-, '■ n .• L • ' ifl.-'a 7;r d«aao3 -i S "^r;' JUB , ,. ; . ' :-^4 (,,X ■■ ^ .■ W • y::i';^5V,%^- ^ 0 : A’gPif ' ***^* ' *• * ‘ . ** ,, ^ * ' < *1-^ ^ j f I ‘ 'te; iiit -lo v'Pl o'"^ XC^ ,PzMp€i^l4tobtiV' dfi . ■, v:.: "t:;-!5,i'W^’ ' ■ , '■* .(MS*.;# .,'«‘?^ '0i$'^ i-V.ix-*i lYftXXMaa J iF.i-'a* V' ,' CJT, • ' - ■« '■•■ "li . .m:;- ■■, - .- ■ ' ^ ' ’■' V, I W*'’ ' Wl' '' ' — ’ ' ■> 'MW ' ' - • -5-V ,A'*t . y.. '.’> ".i - , r* . VL. Hr?# «it ■" ^ mior ' ' ' !■• -if .1 ’*»' 9^ \ w Jb . ^ -i*.. , t ' '■ n Chapter IV % Retrospect and P’rospect The American Social Situation Needs Improvement "The prevalence of illiteracy, the elimination from the traditional public schools, the large amount of poverty and pauperism, the universal extent of poor health and physical incapacity, the general lack of efficiency among workers, the widespread need of civic and social education, the cosmopolitan misuse of leisure time, and the ecumenical need for conservation of natural and human resources" present a social problem that is extremely complex and hard to remedy, Ko panacea ever has been found for all of these evils. However, many agencies have been tried and the positive conclusion that has been reached is that only 31 aid has been found, Students of the problem point out that every available agency should be sought for the purpose of improving the social conditions of America, Continuation Education Aids in This Movement In this great movement to produce a better social environment, old agencies are being brought into action and new agencies are being created to meet the demand. One of these agencies that may be of much value in this movement is the continuation school which is especially adapted to reach 1 Supra, 33 . i-j 1 ■ ir « I r 106 - the boys and girls from fourteen to eighteen years of age who have left the all-day schools and have begun careers in the industrial world. At many points along the way, in the dis- cussion of this institution various objections arise, but for each objection there seems t:: be an opposing affirmative argu- ment. Anong the strongest arguments for the continuation school is the historical witness that this institution has been tried repeatedly and has proved succe.-sful enough in nearly every instance to be retained. This recommendation shows that the part-time school is an institution that is helping to meet the social situations that exist in various communities. When all of the objections to the continua 13 on school on the one hand and all of the arguments fo^^ the con- ■feinuation school on the other hand have been summed up and a tentative balance has been struck, it appears to the writer that the verdict must be rendered in favor of this institution. It is a means of partially securing the realization of a high ideal, the equity of educational opportunity for all America. Continuation Education in The Comprehensive High Rohool Perhaps the greatest efficiency in continuation edu- cation can be obtained. by substituting in many cases for the continuation school, as it is herein portrayed, continuation classes in the regular high schools. This conclusion has been reached after a careful survey of the following conditions and after a careful consideration of the following arguments: First, the local high schools are usually equiciped with the best educational facilities that the community can i ,9 i j 1 -107- afford. Usually the number of pupils vvho attend the continuation school, where state-wide continuation school systems exist, is not large enough to cause a duplication of all the expensive equipment and buildings which are used only a fraction of the regular day. Also under the present scheme some of the equip- ment that has been purchased for the continuation schools is idle part of the time. If these two institutions were brought together, provision could be made to eliminate some of the waste of time that occurs because of the fact that the building and equipment are _ idle several minutes almost daily. Hence, the cost to the community in making provision for buildings and equipment would be lessened by making this combination. This will hold true for the teaching staff also. An added advan- tage that is worth mentioning is that the pupils who attend the continuation school might feel that the school is worth more because of its auperior advantages. This feeling would also tend to affect the parents in the same manner. Secondly, ”the sense of social solidarity and of loyalty to the whole community will be developed among all 2 pupils of high school age." Certainly physically, mentally, and chronologically continuation school pupils are not of elementary school age.^ The social instinct is calling and should be answered by the appropriate group, children of like ages. Such an arrangement tends to give a social solidarity 2 Bureau of Education Bulletin No. 5, 1921, 17, 3 Inglis, Alexander, Principles of Secondary Education, Chapters I-III. » <■1 •K V I t.. . •■ • ifc ■ *V-< • X t\- : ■ *' fv I ! I , W'iC’'.'. I ' I 'M , 'kt ....', ' • »-'y '.(/: \(J ;.•• •?.Ti, f. rtry« !..,•. 4/;t '■3 ..';i '■ ; av 'W ^ f V li.J '! \ . '''.A;, '''“^' ■ Xf %' :> ■ ' ‘ ■ ■ ' i i '■ ■ , . ' , '. _ L •••♦<. v« J K ': : >. "i - ■ : .*1 : ■<'»>!•* 1 C' C "•♦ ■.v 4 . ‘ ^'r^l ■ ■ . .» i> ■ '■, •• ' ^M, ,S I' . r V,. - 108 - to tile community and to eliminate the possible elements of class education which the continuation school frequently has b=en ac- cused of fostering. Thirdly, "the varying needs of continuation school pupils can be met more adequately in the larger organization with its varied facilities."^ The interests, needs, and problems of the pupil are of primary importance in effective teaching. If these are not consulted, waste ensues and the educational objectives are apt to be lost sight of. If a pupil’s chief interest is in the field of salesmanship ^ the endeavor of school authorities to teach him one of the mechanical trades will likely be crowned with little or no success. Yet, the average continuation school is rather limited in the scope of its curriculum, and the pupil in many cases is forced to choose a trade with which he at the beginning is dissatisfied. How- ever if the continuation school were an integral part of the regular high school, the money that could be saved and invested in increased educational facilities would tend to eliminate this condition to some degree, Foiirthly, "the comprehensive high school will be stimu- lated to serve the needs of all pupils of high school age" who are now in industry. Under the present plan industrial edu- cation may be slighted because the assumption is made that the pupils who take advantage of it soon are to enter industry or a special industrial school. Since nearly every city is in more or less financial difficulties this condition is accepted and sometimes little is done tj improve conditions, 4 Bureau of Education Bulletin No. 5, 1921 17 5 Ibid., 17. * * -109- Fifthly, the incorporation cf the continuation school as an integral part of the comprehensive hi^h school will react favorably on both institutions in that it will make those people whose children attend the continuation school more sympathetic towards the needs of the high school. At the same time this fusion will tend to cause other people who at the present stage of evolution of this institution are skeptical towards it to place their approval upon it because they are converted to the high school idea. Hence, the "community will be stimulated in gaining a broad conception of the function of the high school and consequently will give it greater financial and moral sup- port . j •X Sixthly, the function of leading pupils back to the regular schools can be realised better if the continuation work is made a part of the comprehensive high school. The association with the regular high school pupils exerts an influence that tends to promote harmony between the two groups; and conversely, the lack of association tends to create a gulf between the two. As a result, the transfer is ^ accomplished with some difficulty. Perhaps this is true in fewer cases under the present arrangement than under the proposed plan. The comir^unity of interests even beyond the social, that are interrelated offers a means for a closer harmony between the two groups. The giving of high school credit for acceptable part-time work will be assured and the pupil will recognize that his endeavors are being recognized. Hence, ne will feel that his efforts are bringing him nearer to high school graduation and perhaps to college entrance than under the 6 Ibid,, 17. M ' 'f Ifl i:* >■ *■ V ,1 .' vV * f'O^ - ^ ,..c .'^ ^ ,v, ■■ '^r I ^ '. ■ ’.rsca^: ri’^. ' ' lUi' ? * * A A d I. ; V :y .• !.• ' '^5t rJr<„_ ■>y!r;R’ , ( I rr 4 i.’ "V" •. ; , ■• w^m- ■ •V'.’ iv'l '.*' 1 . ' i .'.{' ’ ■ • , 1 ' ' ■ * • t • A ■■(, ■ W'^ ' ' ' ‘ ' li».J ■ 5 ,, . , , , ,^ ; ,y»( , 'Xu ■ ^ ■ '. ' C. , '-■*< '•' ■ ■ . ■ ' * ; ■ ■ 'i ' ■ ** '>,‘1 ,1 . )■• ' >J'A ■'. 'j’’ii 1 '■•.1' . (, (> _ . , * ,; V ' \i " ' :;/. f. •' ^ ;.' y-iVi'V ' 7 ' . ■ ■■ U : . ■ ... - ... • -,.:ii,‘' ?; : ' ' '” ^ •■ ■ '''.-■ ;'■ , ' ; ■ ; 'r v.'.^ . > ,' ' ; ■ '1 :• A-;.. ■ ' , V', ■ i-r.'f 1 I ! IdiL; 'tft' - 110 - present plan. In short, the contention is maintained that the continu- ation school in many cases cease to exist as a separate institu- tion as soon as is practicable and that trade preparatory, trade extension, and general continuation courses be included in every high school curriculum where a sufficient demand exists. The accompanying diagram shows the proposed relation of the con- tinuation school to the other work of the secondary school as well as the relation of voluntary education to the life of the adult in his social environment. When the plan shall have been I carried out successfully, the continuation idea will not be far in advance of the then existing system of continuation education. The Proposed Organization The diagram on the following page is thus explained: After the pupil completes the work of the elementary school he regularly passes into the high school and not into a separate continuation school even though he may enter industry. In case he does enter industry during his six years in the elementary school he automatically passes into the continuation department of the regular high school. After he graduates from high school he may continue his formal education by going on to college but if he desires to pursue his chosen vocation he may continue his eiucati on along general or technical lines at public expense, provided that a demand sufficiently large exists to justify the offering of the desired courses. Continuation education should be compulsory through the high school or until the age of eight- een has been attained. Thereafter it should be voluntary for the -C'iJr .;f: -rW ■ ", ■;r V ' t.v' ' ' Ml' :; f ; .* ;»ai <•• « !• J?}( ■ ■ - '^A t*. ■ ’h ' ■ ■ - J' U' ■ tarnmnlarM, ' V " i«. . .I’C. roe;Hf ^,‘i nv ;'to \S hr,ci ‘ < ';f1 . < ■ '’ i ^*'*f4!SWP^s^> #;■€) w - 1 1 C'^occ.e. ' ' 'J, . ■ ;■ .' ■ , • , ’ " ^ '‘!^V .7 . - . . . • „, ', .1 •’* • ^.V '‘X%’ it4 :fl ,.. O'. 1 '_W ,; ^ . ^ y i .p-t' <( ^a>wwt«lg4 ^ .t^ ,.ft;'.:rv-:-Sj;fe^£-*..(.- la '-t- , V . "■ ''' ■"'■■ ' '.r' ^■T_,£!U^0(" f '^' jlrC,.,v'''''''.!^S!| V*'' . ,, ,. ., 9>i,: iljpi'nJI ifeil'V'SSi|<’s<«l*l';, i'ofV'ti' rtci Jf jifu ,<. Jatift '■ *' •• ' '■■ -''i-yj' , ''« * ’ ' ’ '/J i ' „ 1 ■ ' -^ • ' <^y^' ■’’,' '' . W' ' '"'i ,v e.v a.itftfV'1^ ‘rcti,. •! • ■3/,';. '•W.1 .i 4 A o'" •*■;.- .’ ‘Itfx* . ' ,■ •'■'“■'/•■' . , %■ I .i.‘*.^^iLr« U j'> . '1 . 1' O '.'I. :;:' U / c U ^ 41 .Xo c> 3 #:■ ' •',* V.. Ti ' ‘ ' j ‘■■' e:;- , ‘Vtt^ ^ ^4 tt b ■•* .. f'.f'lC.^ ■ ■*" ■ «5,^ |^'^-(" "' ' ■ V,'.4*i‘“ ’ ' ! 'If- ’■' ■■ 'it'" ^ 'I lb. '.C ^ Hif a' ■ ■ ft • '“*- ./-V- ' . '' . • ; fe'v^ J . ■; , % A ■ h, ' I V- y i ‘ ■ >U\4iy, ■ I.'-:'-; ’ ™ ' ■‘'' V '■"■ ' i(J. .y^ i^r;- ■ ;.f;-;,,J^.:'t^»u-' { ' ^ » jl4 ^ ^ t. i j «-l «A J) ’’ f.w'**. ’ . ■ . . lii ' ,; il . ^ '■ ■' '■' ■ - - i V'. ' •# 'J ■'•'""‘T . A', ,^- I ^'-'^ rk*'^ K ■ U A Wh^J L , '‘T ■:-Jl lixi •y ! A*"! } « . f .'■•■I ' Vb ;e •i ^ > ■=o— «r— * -?? o R tJ ' ^U»ney\hi r Y S i/k 9t)l -113- great mass of the populalion; but perhaps those people who are not acquainted with American principles should be excepted from this arbitrary rule which may change as the years go by just as the compulsory age limits have done. The Vocational Guidance Provision "The success of the plans for part-time education will depend to no small measure upon the inauguration of an effective and comprehensive plan of vocational guidance,"'^ Whether or not the plan suggested in this chapter is accepted, it remains true that continuation school pupils have had little or no vocational guidance} they have fallen into the jobs that offer the highest initial pay and have taken little thought for the future. If Miles's estimate that 87 per cent of the children of continuation school age enter the "blind-alley" jobs is correct, there is no doubt that these unfortunate children need both educational and vocational guidance.® In the comprehensive high school there should be in- corporated a bureau of vocational guidance which may have control of the educational guidance as well. A report of the Commission os' The Reorganization of Secondary Education of The National Educational Association outlines ^ pretty definite program for such a department. It should assist the child to guide himself through educational career amd tt should place the worker of the Continuation Department in positions to which he is adapted. 7 Ibid., 13. 8 Ibid., 13. - 113 - The Service of The Future Continuation School Since the continuation school exists in an evolutionary- social environment that is constantly changing and since this institution itself is a result of this evolution, further growth may be expected. Perhaps the time will, come when every state in the Union w'ill have a well organized system of continuation edu- cation, schools at which working children will be compelled to attend until they have become eighteen years of age or until they haire graduated from high school. If such state-wide systems shall be inaugurated universally, SQuity of educational oppor- tunity will be materially furthered. Hence, it follows that the younger generation will tend to becoime more socially efficient. But this is only part of the story. The state owes a duty to the adult who has been imable to obtain an education. Through the enlargement of the conception of the continuation school, as the term is here used, the continuation school may fulfill tts obligation by offering to him that educational opportunity which perhaps he has never had. It may do more than this. It may give the college graduate a chance to con- tinue his studies at home under state guidance at state expense. When the child must continue his educational growth and the adult may have the chance to continue his in an institution provided oy the state, the realization of the continuation idea will be accomplished. Then continuation education will be in a better position to assist in improving the social conditions of America. » k M '' i -114- Selected Bitoliog:raphy Briggs, Thomas S., The Junior High School Bureau of Education Bulletin No. 5, 1931, "Part-Time Education of Various Types" (See United States) Dewey, John, Democracy and Education Inglis, Alexander, Principles of Secondary Education Johnston, Charles Hughes and Others, The Modern High School I I A \ ■I 1 I } I -115- APPENDIX I Provisions of Part-Time Compulsory Education Laws* State Law in ef- fect Minimum number of minors re- quired to establish classes Age of requir- ed at- tend- ance Hours of re- quirdd attends ance per week 1919 15 14-16 5 1920 12(1) 14-18 4 1921 14-18 8 1919 15 14-16 8 1920 200(2) 14-16 4 1921 50(3) 14-18 8 1919 25 14-16 4 1919 15 14-18 4 1919 15 14-16 8 1919 15 14-18 4 1920 20 14-16 6 1919 15 14-16 b 1920 20(4) 14-18 4^8 1919 20 16-18 ^ ^ 1919 15(5) 14-18 5 1915 20 14-16 8 1919 15 14-18 4 1920 15(6) 14-18 4 1921 (4) 1 14-18 8-20 Length of the school year Arizona California Illinois Iowa Massachusetts Michigan Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Jersey New Mexico New York Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Utah Wash ington Wisconsin 150 hours As public Do/ Do . Do . Do. Do. Do. 144 hfeurs As public 36 weeks 150 hours As public 144 hours As public Do. 144 hours As public 8 months school school scho'l school school Exrlana *( 1 ) ^11 (3 (4) it ions: High school districts having 50 or more puoils must es- tablish part-time classss. Referendum law adopted by all towns except one. Establishment of schools is compulsory only in school districts having a population of 5,000 or more. Establishment required only in cities of over 5,000. Attendance upon evening school may be substituted. Districts may organize schools upon written requests of twenty-five residents. ♦ This table was taken by the author from Federal Board for Vo- cational Education Bulletin No. 55, 1920, page 8; it has been revised to June 1, 1922, so far as'material lould bfoMainlS r».- -■ ■V*' ^ Y ,t f- » M- *•!• * , I V'- , ’ ' • ' - " t. .'ft ,. ■ _ • t ■ * ■. I f); •*'•♦ t«.*4 ■♦ VW V ‘ , V Si- '■!- :'■*-« “.V, . .’■ < ’ X’''' ' y '■ ' A ■ : i \ r. 1 1 / A:-. '4 O' ■ 4 *". ./< ; : ■'■ " . . ♦ ■ 'i. ;ki. •!- • » . vM« O/ ■ I ■»-Jv > • 4^’ •f.*v.‘' Z • ,r - vM/C . .’I'T "Av-.p ■' ^ ■\ . ■■f t , •t ff* ,. ■• -f '\v ' 'i’ov- .. •• '■- "'Vj'..;':*, , - V if. . : l-‘. ' 't o ..,- ■ ' . • / • ■•■ • --M ■ '*^4- ••<■ . , W f- A*'*'''.'- ; s~ f ■•!v^.‘ ■ I '■ . - *• *-'vy ••■;• V'-’r '■-■'V ' ■ \ '■>< , ‘-*(1 ’ Vy\ 0 * 1 . V* J' '.'5 *’''..!^v ' ■*■ :r ^ I' i .>'.W V ; ■ ■ ^ ..^ . • . - . . ' ’- *\ •<•■■(* -••■.' ; .-.■ >» ’tf . V / ••♦ . ' )*. ,-- A ■ ■ ' 1 •-'■'HI' ' •■ o 'U'** ^ '''' /■' V ' )rA' ■ ■-;- 'a!;-. „ - . ,.,. ♦,j-.. <* .•.yj’. V V ' '5:''^ A .■r^.■■'i^i Ik * Ijf.’; .*i.'>' "v ^ ‘ 4 ^' r T • ’ • ■', ' v .' •'**< 4 -;V . . -f!' \- }. :' '^f.. 1 -' ••■;••* .Jt :^;;X . . *;;.::5'- /,!#. , .., u _.A , •- ---- .-.j.--r.t,.~ ' A, ' • *, V. • . i.- . ■ ^ •■' r<' - '■' ' ."■• , . '•' ■ i'-' ••'■( ^'».' ■■ .; •«, - <>■'.(■ . •■ 5*,»», <..■*'.• . ' ' ■ ■ '■•• . .■ ,-••"•» j^AiL , ■ 1 ,. ■,...-*;> •' 'V'-. rs ♦ > ;•• . ■--;■ (V; ' '7K' '• ?'* ■’■ " '■ ; ••■-..??" J'; /a ‘-I . ;i'-^ ■ . r'. ’■• ■ t ■■' .-f ‘. « R .», i^VVi ^••». 4 ' ■'. ■^■, ;V«. V. .'* ■ ,• i \ - •■ ^ ^vi'- f . . r'l; '*•' ■- VV ' ' •* j *»■$?-•-.■ r-'- A... . flii 'A' -K ■• yf ."• :"^ • */•••'•’■ '■■ *-i •o.^ : /■ -'fe; * fl *. •i;;.l'-i',l..V, ' V-,*',. . . *r, ■■/ .-, :■ ’1 V '■ ' ;Sr Jijf V'rrf • .‘• VilK -h '•■'■./ I I) y. ' \i) .• ' ■' ty. . , •’. . V «-■■ •■• • •*. V/n-i ' ■ tVs • “i' ' y ' - y ;• f,,- ,< .r ,.- < ' - ■ ■ :x • ' ‘{^ ■ . '-i-, ■ '^ . «" ■ V*, ^ / si ' /-i- ■’ ’A ) ■'■ '.* 4 ' . -, ■ tv'^' >■ • V. y’tf.j V- ■ V‘ '4 • ■ r * . *« -( ' % '-f. a ■ ’^1 IK", ■iv; o;i Vr-W7, . . : , , H ,- ■ : >. V-, ' '■ L ' .' ifidl I ‘ > It i ■iw.V.'T’*' a'/ „'A^JUi 4 K ( uirti -116- APPENDIX II Minimun amount available from the State Board for Vocational Edu- cation because of the Smith— Hughes Act, for part-time work for workers over 14 years of age, by years * Fiscal year ending June 30- Minimum amount available for partirtirae schools and classes Federal money: " Total federal and state or local money one-third of appropriation for trade, home economics, and industrial sub- St e or local money; to match federal appro- priation 1917- 18 1918- 19 1919- 20 1920- 21 1921- 22 1922- 23 1923- 24 1924- 25 1925- 26 1926 - on 1377,333.34 530, 666* 66 689,333.34 852,000.00 1, G16, 666, 66 1.181.333.34 1.346.000. 00 1.704.000. 00 2.033.333.34 2,033^333.34 jects |1S8, 666. 67 265.333.33 344. 666. 67 426.000. 00 508.333.33 590.666.67 673.000. 00 852.000. 00 1.016. 666.67 1. 016.6 66.67 $188,666.67 265.333.33 344.666.67 426. 000. 00 508.333.33 590.666.67 673.000. 00 852.000. 00 1,016,666.67 1,016,366,37 T Board for Yo°3-tional Education Bulletin No. 19 i y I K ij ^ -117- Works Consulted; The Bibliography Ale'xandsr, W. M,, ”The Factory As A Continuation School,” Proceed- ings of The New York Teachers' Association, 1909, Index University of New York, Albany. ' Alltucker, Margaret M., Coordination in Part-Time Education, Uni- versity of California, Berkeley, 1921. Alsberg, Elsa, "Education of The Imrrigrant," Proceedings of The National Educational Association, 1916, 786-792, Washington. Anderson, Lewis F., "Beginnings in Industrial Education," School and Society, 13:1-9, January 1, 1921. Ayres, Leonard P., Laggards in Our Schools, Charities Publication Commission, New York, 1909. Bagley, W. C., "The Unit versus The Dual System of Vocational Edu- cation," Educational Bimonthly, 9:191-199, February, 1915. Ball, F. B., "Industrial Training in Continuation Schools," Proceed- ings of The Pennsylvania State Educational Association, 1910, Index, Pennsylvania State Journal, Lancaster. Bazeley, E. T., "Two Experiments in Voluntary Continuation Education Journal of Experimental Pedagogy, 6:20-26 and 82-89, March and June, 1921, Bawden, William T., "The Relation of The Elementary School to Sub- sequent Industrial Education," Proceedings of The National EducaHonal Association, 1912, 907-915, Washington. Bawden, William T., Vocational Education, United States Bureau of Education Bulletin No. 25, 1919, Government Printing Office, Washington, Beloit, Wisconsin, Annual Report of The Industrial, Continuation, Commercial, and Evening Schools, 1912-13 and 1913-14 Board of Education. ^ Bennett, Charles A., "The Boston Continuation School," Manual Training Magazine, 21:329-333, June, 1920. Best, R. H. , and Ogden, C. K., The Problem of The Continuation School, King and Son, London, 1914. Blair, Francis G., "Amendment to The Continuation School Law " Educat ional Press Bulletin, July, 1921. Blair, Francis G., "Part-Time Education," Educational Press Bul- letin, June, 1922. -118- Blewett, Ben, ’’The Education of The Adult Immigrant,” Proceedings of The National Educational Association, 1915. 439-445 Washington. ' Board for Vocational Education, Illinois, Annual Reports: 1920 and 1921, Springfield. Board for Vocational Education, Illinois, Day Continuation Schools Bulletin No. 13, 1920, Springfield. * Bonner, H. R., Statistics of State School Systems, 1917-18 United States Bureau of Education, Bulletin No. 11, 1920, Govern- ment Printing Office, Washington. Briggs, Thomas S., The Junior High School, Houghton Mifflin, Boston, Brown, John F., The American High School, Macmillan, New York, 1917. Callahan, John, "Part-Time Vocational Education," Pr@ceedings of The National Educational Association, 1019, 272-275 Wash- ington. ' Carris, Lewis H., "Administration of Compulsory Part-Time Laws " Vocational Summary, 2:22-27, June, 1919. ' Carris, Lewis H., "The Significance of A State-Wide Continuation School Law," Proceedings of The National Society for The - Promotion of Education, 1917, 118-120, New York. Cary, C. ?., "Danger Ahead:-Unity of The Educational System Threat- ened," Journal of Education, 85:120-121, February 1, 1917. Case, M. Elizabeth, "An Adventure in Education," New Republic 13: 209-211, December 22, 1917. * Clark, Ruth S., "The Continuation School," Survey, 45: 541-542 January 8, 1921. • ' Cole, Carlos M., "The Denver Opportunity School," Chicago School Journal, 3:'10-13, September, 1920. Colgrove, F.P., "The Part-Time Continuation School," Proceedings of The National Educational Association, 1919, 619-621 Washington. ' Commercial Club of Chicago, Vocational Schools for Illinois, Com- mercial Club, Chicago, 1915. "Compulsory^ Continuation Schools in New York," School and Society 10:516-517, November 1, 1919. Connelley, C. B., "The Place of The Corporation and The Continuation Journal of The National Educational Association, 1:412-417, January, 1917. <4J»i. • '■»’%r. ' ■ j- ri '' t--, . i- 5d*.-. .^, ' - ■"'■'f, , ,;,1, i* ' ^ , l' t ' ■ ’ ' * ' ' I IX . J " ,.^,.:t^o^;f-,-t:'; X>i4w " w. , : ,JC^®I •'.. ..7^ .. '■' As ' - ^ t.r; ,ncJW^ox-*^ X^ttikin^a^ ta'i-ut-^oaj - ' .’ v^-nfiUt':i^ .£X .d*: olUdIv f ",a’: ' : >“ '■ ■'. ".v‘^' 'a-' ' ‘f, ' ' ' '\ ,*■ ' 7 ’'i \ tf'f '■'■A^i’'l ■,-K,\ ' -,?5 i), ' .' Al ’^''V, ,.C*^V ''. ., .-.S;, c J^ ,1 , ■ ,: i*y" ..';'••<• ■• ■•• •; ,- ■’-■■' .^ **■ "* “/ ' ' ■•i, .■,-') -, .V K‘ V.,.5*t»>: ' .' » •-''. . V ;t. I i •, ■' /! .. ; W ’ ■ ■» ; .;• ^ -* ■ ^■■Jfirj V fa -A "' 5b>‘w^‘ii 0 ^'i X ” i . -I «^o,^ ' .»d? XC:^^ X- ,.*^-**— «...•»'! V ^aT.‘ n,y*Jn!*. .1.^ ■ -^ ^ * t^aiooe ■ •b.it^ha «:$r*'W'' ^^.-.fi '•’ " ' ‘.j , xX'^' '* ' *4. 4i"Xsi>^i4^, ^ . 'X*--v‘ii.;;>C ^ ^ti.-0':io '|K . V :'■ ■"'■ \ , ' "V’ vc, :/v \'' >, A.* . y , ' . ^ - " .'*;m X'nrfn.f.p^C ,£',SS-J^0i^ . % ^ i - ", •, ,,^i . '^, '■ -1-, ' ™ r^ 'i* ,.♦ 'f/ *■ ' fct- '■.a.Jt.v c.' 4o'!^ofii>rct^eM#'^l!>0'i■n^^ 1. " ' '■ ^' '> , :'\li-i >.:v ■ V,.-’ iiftO* ■^4 ’.iWC" i li i’ife '’l^ ■*- fiT'JlP' XJ I ft tr^ :’itoS'5 h ■ *'!■* ■■ ; ■' .ei';-,.: ,I :A}■' 3a^'yo^'■ ,j-C^Ui I '' . ' V"/ *' ”‘'v Ali- rf''' Ji'i "** ' ^ """' ' -'’. ; ® ' •■ ' .•■" ^ Vi '’ < ' '^i ^ wf ' LT! ‘ fLr I -119- "Continuation Schools in Denmark," The Times (London), Educational Supplement, 421-432, August 21, 1919. Cooley, Edwin G.,"The Continuation School," American School Board Journal, 45:11-59, Aup'ust, 1912. Cooley, Edwin G., VCont inuation Schools, " Proceedings of The Nation- al Educational Association, 1915, 1203-1207, Washington. Cooley, Edwin G., "The Need for Vocational Schools," Educational Review, 44:433-450, December, 1912, Cooley, Edwin G., "The Part-Time School," School and Society 3: 843-847, June 10, 1916. ^ Cooley, Edwin G., "Public Continuation Schools," Journal of The National Educational Association, 1912, 1203-1207, Washing- ton . Cooley, Edwin G. , "Some Chicago Continuation Schools," School Life 4:1, January 15, 1920. " Cooley, Edwin G., Vocational Education in Europe, Commercial Club of Chicago, 1912. Cooley, R. L., "Apprenticeship and Continuation Schools of Milwau- Proceedings of The National Educational association, 1914, 614-618, Washington. Cooley, L , "The Problem of The Continuation School," Proceedings of The National Educational Association, 1919 275-279 Washington. ' Cooley, R. L., "Schools and Continuation Schools," Industrial Arts Magazine, 2:49-54, August 1914. Course of Study for The Common Schools of Illinois, Sixth General Revision, C. M. Parker, Taylorville, 1916. Cubberley, Ellwood P,, Public School Administration, Houghton Mif- flin, Boston, 1916. Dean, A. D., "State-Wide Compulsory Continuation Education," Pro- ceedings of The National Society for The Promotion of In— dustrial Education, 1913, 40-54, Manual Arts Press, Peoria. Illinois. ' ' Dewey, John, Democracy and Education, Macmillan, yew York, 1916. Douglas, Paul H. American Apprenticeship and Industrial Education. Columbia University, New York, 1921. Douglas, Paul H., "Apprenticeship and fts Relation to Industrial Education," Pedagogical Semiaary, 25:65-74, March, 1918. Dyer, Walter A., "A Whole-Hearted Half-Tim.e School," World's Work 28:452-460, August, 1914. * >r tl' - *1 1 f ' ; f • t “t < .I'JT , I :‘.er"' ' * . '■ .r.^.v tjj;- ,-'':»ri 'o /I .A..^ :*' * ^., / *. .Oj ■ - . < ■ ' ';j '^0 '. >' ' 1 ' ^ j ^ V •', ■' ' ' *r ' ; ' '• K :. *■ : '■ >*■ f ‘r ' ' A/ ■• •*. . ^ - ^ A \ . . •• • (a •o.v'frj-'l (f. ' « «> '■ , :<■ i? : • 1 : y. ^ U j T 'v • i' • \ '. ' ''a. w ■ 'iT» • jV . ’ , *f d ' ' )1 ‘ » ' -■ e*fi^ { -;i'’ ’! ■ '. 'Z' ’,t :;.r r - , ■ « r»" ' '. 1"' :'• i T ,K, . .. . : ,i„ ' 1 • » ' 1 ‘ ' ■ I ’ ' ' ’ • ' < * A ' ■ ; ; .■ . \v ' ' ', ' ■ i ■ . 6;'v2 'tt: ‘.':-^'}J ■ A . ' A , " y <1 «*f I. '■> ofi •,■ . . wvT >1 • .* ' Vti. »> £ n A ' I - - * .