THE ROMANTIC ELEMENTS IN THE LIFE AND WORKS OF JEAN JACQUES ROUSSEAU BY MARGARET EBERT JFOLEY A. B. Ohio Wesleyan University, 1919 THESIS Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS 1921 m\ UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS THE GRADUATE SCHOOL 191 I HEREBY RECOMMEND THAT THE THESIS PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION BY . Margaret Ebert Foley ENTITLED in t he Life and Works of Jean Ja cques Rousseau BE ACCEPTED AS FULFILLING THIS PART OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF faster of Arts In Charge of Thesis Head of Department Recommendation concurred in* Committee on Final Examination* ^Required for doctor’s degree but not for master’s CV'G'C JL Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2015 https://archive.org/details/romanticelementsOOfole Table of Contents. Chap. page. I Introduction 1 II Classic and Romantic 3 III Early Years (1712-1728) 7 IV Youth and Wanderings 15 V Life at Chambery and Charmettes (1732-1741) ... 29 VI Paris (1741-1756) 32 VII L'Kermitage and Mont Louis (1756-1762) 39 VIII Last Years and Death (1762-1778) . 51 IX Conclusion . 55 T Chapter I INTRODUCTION Before pointing out the romantic elements in Rousseau, which is the aim in writing this thesis, we shall begin by giv- ing a short account of the beginnings of Romanticism as a move- ment, which had as its leader Jean Jacques Rousseau; the causes for this movement and the conditions leading up to it. This will naturally involve us in a discussion of the eternal con- flict between Classicism and Romanticism. In this discussion some consideration will be given to the exact meaning of the terms Classic and Romantic. Keeping the definitions of Romanticism in mind, we shall then point out the romantic elements in Rousseau, which consti- tute the germs of the romantic ideas and ideals to be found later in the Romantic School at the time of Victor Hugo. If an author be an objective writer his works can be criticized or analyzed apart from his personality, although this is not the best of meth- ods. In the case of Rousseau, however, a method of this sort is impossible. Rousseau, is the most subjective of writers. His works are so closely bound up with the events of his life and the emotional responses to these events that they cannot be separated one from the other. Going back to one of our definitions of ro- mantic style, we find it to be a self-reflection of the author- subjectivity. Since self— ref lection is one of the features of romantic style and since we are dealing with the romantic elements in one, who is characterized as the father of the French romantic style, we shall not be able to overlook the events of Rousseau’s % 2 life} for it is the emotional responses to these events which are reflected in his writings* Certain things made deep impressions on him and caused deep emotions, which had an outlet in his writ- ings. To understand these outlets, we must first understand the causes for them. In short, had Rousseau never lived a romantic life, we should have no romantic writings from him. Thus the ro- mantic elements will be pointed out not in his works alone but in his works as they are linked up with his life. In undertaking to give an account of Rousseau's life, we have made more use of his Confessions than any other biography. Histories or biographies are most likely to be objective and im- personal,. whereas confessions such as those of Rousseau, the out- pourings of his inmost thoughts and desires, are more subjective and, from the nature of the case, better suit our purpose in deal- ing with romantic elements. 3 Chapter II CLASSIC AND ROMANTIC. The word Classic is derived from the Latin c lassicus , which in the singular means "relating to one of the classes of Roman citizens*" In the plural classici we have the meaning citi- zens of the first class. By extension classici scriptores indi- cates writers of the first class. The word classical applied to literature today may mean the best of a particular kind of writing. To the European mind however the Classics have meant the litera- ture of Greece and Rome. It is with the latter conception of the term that w.e shall deal here., for the former is but a popular use of it. Since it in no way implies the opposite of Romanticism, it will have no place in this definition, for we are dealing with Clas- sicism only as it concerns Romanticism. Modern Classicism had its beginning with the Renaissance. The Renaissance brought about a desire for an intelligent study and imitation of antiquity. From this study of the ancients there grew up a great love of form and of conformity to rules. To write as Plato or Cicero was the ambition of all writers of this time. Most of them were concerned only with imitating the style, not wishing to go into antique thought. Some, however, went so far as to imi- tate ideas and even philosophy of the ancients. The Classic School, as an outgrowth of this, began in France with la Pl^iade, which aimed to found French literature on Greek and Latin., Ronsard and his disciples were desirous ol trans- planting the antique forms on French soil and imitating them in the French language. From the middle of the sixteenth through the 4 eighteenth century France was largely under classical rule. The seventeenth century, however, was the only truly classical epoch. At this time there was real comprehension of the classical spirit. The brilliant spirit of the Renaissance was felt at this time, but toward the end of the century we begin to see the formal side dom- inating. That is to say, the imitation and close adherence to rule was slowly smothering the classical spirit. We see evidences of this as early as 1674 in Boileau’s Art Foetique . He tells us to give much attention to form. To attain perfection the author must rewrite constantly. Three out of every four words should be erased after they have been written.. His theory of literary art is best shown in the following quotations: Quelque sujet qu'on traite ou plaisant ou sublime, Que toujours le bon sens s’accorde avec la rime. Aimez done la raison: Que toujours vos Merits Empruntent d’elle seule et leur lustre et leur prix, Hatez-vous lentement ; et sans perdre courage, Vingt fois sur le metier remettez votre ouvrage . Polissez-le sans cesse et le repolissez, Ajoutez quelque fois, et souvent effacez,^) To sum up what we need to remember about Classic, we may say that it consists in love of form and in. the following of rules, hence conventionality and formality; but with true classic spirit, (1) Boileau, Art Poetique, Vol. II, page 286 (2) ib., page 288. (3) ib., page 305. 5 the style being only a means to attain an end. The Classic is the clear, the orderly and the definite; it appeals to reason, seeks pro- portions and harmony. A Classicist may have the most intense pas- sions, but delights in controlling them. His satisfaction is in self control, poise, calmness. The Classicism of the eighteenth century, known as Pseudo-Classicism, differs from that of the truly Classic period of the seventeenth century in emphasizing solely the imitative elements. The brilliant spirit of the Renaissance, which was still present in the seventeenth century and which we see beginning to die av/ay at the time of Soileau, had its death blow in the eighteenth century. The Romantic movement was not so clear cut as the Classic. Classicism is as clear and definite as its individual traits, where- as Romanticism is as vague and indefinite as its traits. Romantic elements have been present in all literatures in all ages, many ro- mantic elements being found even in the Classic writers. There were romantic wri tings among the Greeks and Romans, and classical tenden- cies in the Middle Ages. The' Odyssey was more romantic than the Ilia it being in fact a romance rather than a hero-epic. Throughout Frenc literature we find different authors in different periods showing ro- mantic tendencies, and even in the eighteenth century, Prevost in his Manon Lescaut was treating passions of love with some tendency toward melancholy. But lacking the emotional temperament to back his out- pourings, these did not ring true.. With Rousseau the romantic ele- ments were assembled and for the first time took form in a movement. This movement which, in its beginnings, was simply a reaction against eighteenth century Classicism, was successful for two reasons. First society was ready for it. As we have said eighteenth century literature 6 had become somewhat stilted. By this time society was probably tired of such polished works as were produced, and was reacting to them unconsciously, waiting for something to appear to cause a con- scious reaction. Second, Rousseau with a true romantic temperament came on the stage at just the proper time to start this reaction- He appeared with the idea that the world is organized for the joy of all individuals, and set out to prove it. With his emotional disposition to back him, he started out by portraying passions in so true and sincere a manner and with such depth of feeling that he awoke in society the slumbering romantic traits. It was such an awakening that writers continued to folloWjin his foot-steps^ for a century afterward. Thus we see how powerful was Rousseau in being able to head a movement. We do not exaggerate in the least when we call him the father of French Romanticism. The word romantic indicates tendencies opposite to those of the Classic in Art.. The Romantic is the vague, the indefinite - It is a dim longing, a reaching out for something vague and unde- termined. It appeals to the imagination to the exclusion of reason. It has no regard for proportion, seeks suggestion rather than clear and full expression, melody rather than harmony, the individual rather than the typical. It is abnormal rather than normal, morbid rather than healthy. The ego also plays a large part in Romanticism. Other elements are, a love of solitude connected with love of naturej and uncontrolled emotions, of which the most characteristic is mel- ancholy, at times becoming a feeling of despair. Last but not least, it is a reactionary spirit. That is, reaction to that which has gone before. It is in this last that Rousseau figures primarily. 7 Chapter III EARLY YEARS (1712-1728) . Jean Jacques Rousseau, son of Isaac and Suzanne Rousseau, was born June 28, 1712. We get a first romantic touch by using Rousseau’s own words concerning his entrance into this world. "Je coutai la vie a ma mere et ma naissance fut le premier de mes mal- heurs.^' He was born we ak and sickly and had to be nursed with the utmost care in order that his life might be saved. This tender care was given him by an Aunt, who was devoted to him during his early years. As regards the sources of the traits of character, which we are to see appear in Rousseau as he grows from childhood to manhood, we may say that his mother is described to us as being pretty and somewhat coquettish, but without strongly marked characteristics which appear later in Rousseau. His father on the other hand exer- cised a great influence over him. Not only did he hand down certain traits but created an atmosphere in which they would naturally thrive Isaac Rousseau, the father, was highly emotional, irritable and in- clined to be quarrelsome, had a very restless disposition, lofty am- bitions, but no strength of character, no patience or perseverance to help him realize them. He was always shirking responsibility. One pronounced fault of his was always to desert the matter in hand, when on the eve of success, and pass on to something new r and unex- plored. Money went as fast as he could earn it. These traits just enumerated were handed down almost in their entirety to Jean Jacques.. (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, page 7 . 8 As to the atmosphere, which the father created, we have first of all his emotional side in the presence of his son. He seemed to take great joy in weeping, often arranging sorrowful settings in order that he might indulge in this pleasure. A favorite means of doing this was to speak with Jean Jacques about the latter's mother, and as Jean Jacques tells us, the conversation was always accompanied by showers of tears. It was such a common occurrence that in his boyish mind the mention of his mother's name came to be connected with his fa- ther's tears. Quani il me disait Jean-Jacques, parlons de ta mere, je lui disais, He bieni. Mon pere nous allons done pleurer; et ce mot seul lui tirait deja des larrnes. CD Rousseau's early childhood was spent almost entirely with his aunt and father. He never went to school and had no companion his own age. It was probably because of his lack of companions and his close association with older people that he was a precocious child. We find him at the age of seven not only reading novels but, what is more remarkable, seeming to understand them. However . marvel- ous this novel reading may seem, it was very dangerous for one so young. Rousseau thereby gained a knowledge of passions at too early an age. His senses were stimulated before his intelligence or rea- soning was strong enough to hold them in balance. Thus this boy, frail in body and developed beyond his years in mind, was early swept (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, page 6. s in a tide of emotion. Needless to say he was affected both physi- cally and mentally. As regards the mental side there grew up from this reading strange, distorted notions of life, which make them- selves felt later. His father did not seem to realize the harm this extensive romantic reading could do. Instead of forbidding him this sort of reading and turning his boyish curiosity into other and safer channels, he used to read and discuss these books with him. Rousseau tells us how they used to take turns reading night after night, and how their enthusiasm would grow sometimes to such an ex- tent that they would read on with no regard for the passing hours, until with the chirping of the birds they would suddenly realize that morning had come.. Then the father, for an instant probably, feeling his responsibility would say, "Let us go to bed. I am more of a child than you."^-^ This early life in the home was a very happjr and care free one for the boy. The extremely sensitive nature of Rousseau is shown at this early stage, demanding that he be in harmon 3 ^ with his surroundings. This life with his father, aunt and nurse satisfied the demand. He loved them and was loved and cared for tenderly by them. That was all that was necessary for happi- ness says Rousseau.. He was a very clever child and his father and aunt were quick to see it. They responded, as all doting parents respond to the clever child, by petting him and overlooking his faults. While these two people were being the kindest to Jean Jac- ques they were unconsciously doing him the most harm. He was al- ways allowed to do as he liked, was never taught self-denial and (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, page 8.. 10 scarcely knew the meaning of a scolding. If some attempt at disci- pline was made he usually thwarted it by some childish cleverness for which he was complimented as in the following case: / / / Un soir . . . etant condamne pour quelque espieglerie a m f aller coucher sans souper et passant par la cuisine je vis et flairai le roti tournant a la broche. On etait autour du feu: il fallut en passant galuer tout le monde . Quand la ronde fut faite, lorgnant du coin de 1‘oeil ce r3ti qui avait si bonne mine et qui sentait si bon, je ne pus m'abstenir de lui faire aussi la reverence, et de lua dire, d' un ton piteux, Adieu, roti. Cette saillie de naivete parut si plaisante, qu r on me fit rester a souper. ^ The intended scolding thus ended always in a petting, and the fault which it was meant to correct went on grov/ing and develop- ing unhindered. This pleasant home life was suddenly interrupted when Isaac was forced to leave the country on account of a serious quarrel. He left his son, then ten years of age, in the care of Gabriel Bernard, an uncle of the boy. This uncle placed Jean Jac- ques together with his own son, in the home of a minister named Lambercier. This minister lived with his unmarried sister at Bos- sey, a village near Geneva. Here the two boys devoted themselves to study, and in spare moments worked in the garden and enjoyed other O outdoor activities. The countryside was a novelty to Rousseau. Here was born his passionate love for nature and the joys to be de- rived from the simple country life. The following quotation shows what an impression his surroundings at Bossey made on him. (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, page 46. 11 La campagne etait pour moi si nouvelle, que je ne pouvais me lasser d’en jouir. Je pris pour elle un gout si vif, qu*il n'a jamais pu s’eteindre. ( 1 ) Rousseau and his cousin spent two years in the home of M. Lambercier. At the end of that time an incident occurred which, says Rousseau, made further stay impossible * He was accused one day of a fault which he had not committed and for which he was severely punished. This seems to have made a deep impression on him. To his boyish mind, this unjust treatment at the hands of those he had loved took the proportions of a tragedy- It put an end to his childish existence so he says. His innocent faith in people was (3; shattered, and in its place was a sullen pessimism. He no longer took pleasure in his outdoor sports. His time was now spent nurs- ing his grievances. His reaction was not the reaction of a normal child but that of an abnormally emotional person for whom trifles assume immense proportions. From then on life was so unbearable at Bossey that he returned to the home of his uncle. Rousseau tried to prove that this was a turning point in his life; that his disposition was changed entirely by this episode at Bossey. He says that until then he had had an innocent child* s outlook on life. Everything was ideal, he had a simple trust in everyone and knew nothing about the ways of life or man. When we take into account his early novel-reading, through which he learned (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, page 16 (2) ib., Partie 1, Livre 1, page 25 (3) ib. , Partie 1, Livre 1, page 28 . . , 12 much about people and life, and add to this his own account of the awakening of his sensuality at Bossey, we feel that he did not have the serene naive childhood he would have us believe. Rousseau’ s whole life, as v/e shall see, was influenced by his environment in both his good and bad traits. Previous to the episode at Bossey, his surroundings had been calm and peaceful; he had reacted accord- ingly by being happy and showing a calmness and gentleness of spir- it. Kis unjust treatment at the hands of M. Lambercier served only as a stimulus to bring out some of the bad traits which had up to this point lain dormant. After leaving Bossey he was apprenticed by his uncle to an engraver, Abel Ducommum. This man had a very violent temper and was brutal in his treatment of Jean Jacques. Here we observe to a greater extent the kind of response we get when Rousseau is out of harmony with his surroundings. In this new position he became lazy, grew restless and careless, lost all self-respect and even stooped to stealing and lying. He soon learned that his childish clever- ness, which had saved him from many scoldings, was of no use with this hard master. Thus he was forced to endure all his scoldings and beatings and became, because of them, sullen and vicious. His only joy was in secretly reading licentious books which he got from a circulating library.. These stimulated his already aroused pas- sions, and things went from bad to worse. In reading these books he always put himself in the place of the characters and mentally acted out their parts. From this early practice came later his (1) Confessions, Fartie 1, Livre 1, p. 19, 20, 21, 22, 25. 13 ability to portray emotions realistically. He was absorbed so en- tirely in his book world that he longed to get away by himself from all material surroundings and live in the world of his imagination. During the years of his apprenticeship his childish gentleness and sensitiveness passed away making place for some of the traits which, developed arid acted on later, classify him as a Romanticist. In the following words he gives evidence of these romantic elements. J’atteignis ainsi ma seizieme annee, inquiet , mecontent de tout et de moi , sans gout de mon etat, sans plaisirs de mon age, devore' de d^sirs dont j'ignorais l'objet, pleurant sans sujet de larnes, soupirant sans savoir de quoi , enfin caressant tendrement « A mes chimeres faute de rien voir autour de moi qui les valut.^-^ Every Sunday evening Rousseau and his companions used to take walks outside the city walls. The gates closed at a certain time in the evening. Twice Rousseau was locked out and forced to spend the night outside the city. On his return home next morning he was cruelly treated by his master, who threatened to punish him even more severely should the event take place a third time. When Jean Jacques was locked out the third time, he spent the night in great anxiety and fear and when morning came he had not the courage to return home to the punishment which he knew awaited him. So, when his companions took the road to the city, he went in the oppo- site direction, resolved never to return to his master. Rousseau justified this step and its consequences by put- ting the entire burden on fate. He would have spent a peaceful (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, page 61. 14 life, would have been good, industrious, persevering, all the things which he was not, had he fallen into the hands of a better Master. Avant de m'abandonner a la fatalite de rna destinee, qu’on me permette de tourner un moment les yeux sur celle qui m'attendait naturellement si j'etais tombe dans- les rnains d’un meilleur rnaitre. Rien n'etait plus convenable a mon humeur, ni plus propre a me rendre heureux, que l’etat tranquille et obscur d'un bon artisan..^ . ..J’aurais passe dans le sein de rna religion, de ma patrie, de ma famille, et de rnes amis, une vie paisible et douce, telle qu'il la fallait si mon caractere, dans 1 1 unif orrni te, d’un travail de mon gout et d'une societe selon mon coeur. (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 1, p. 64, 65 / 15 Chapter IV YOUTH AND WANDERINGS * The grief and anxiety which Jean Jacques experienced as he saw the gates closing gave way to happiness and content as he went on his way, feeling himself far from the dreaded master. Now he was master of himself, free to wander where he wished* Libre et maftre de moi-meme, je croyais pouvoir tout faire, atteindre a tout: . . . J 1 entraisjavec securite' dans la.. vaste espace du monde ; mon merite allait le remplir, a chaque pas j'allais trouver des festins, des tresors, des aventures, des amis prets a me servir . . . Rousseau was in his element here* Many of his romantic traits were having full play in his imagination and were growing and ripening with each step^ preparing for a day when they should burst forth in definite form. For several days he wandered about aimlessly, begging meals here and there from the peasants. He finally came to a little village, Confignon, near Geneva. There he met M. de Pontverre, a priest, who took him in and kept him over night. Rousseau was greatly influenced by this priest, who set out to convert him. Be- fore the evening was over this boy, who had been brought up on pro- doctrineSj testant^ signified his willingness to adopt the Catholic religion. As regards this sudden change J. Jacques says, n M. de Pontverre was so splendid a host that I could not oppose him.“ Whether his action was due to being flattered that the (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 2, p. 66. 16 priest should engage him in such deep conversation or to timidity, fearing to displease the priest by opposing him, we cannot sayj but in either case his action shows clearly the beginning of his insta- bility of character, his wavering tendencies. Jean Jacques says he never really meant to change his religion, that he only made a temporary decision to satisfy the pries but the latter, taking advantage of this opportunity sent him to Mme . de Warens, a recent convert at Annecy, before he should have a chance to change again. On his arrival at Annecy he found Mme. de Warens not old as he had expected, but a charming young woman of twenty eight who received him very kindly. This reception by such a pretty woman added to the fact that she too was a recent convert, appealed to the romantic boy. Whatever doubts and regrets he had had, at changing his religion, no doubt left him when he found him- self in her presence. At any rate he made no outward objection and at her suggestion, went to a monastery at Turin where he should re- ceive the training necessary for becoming a Catholic. Once instal- led in the monastery, away from the flattering remarks of the priest and the charming presence of Mme. de Warens, Rousseau began to regret what he had done. His stay at Turin was unhappy. At the end of several months he was received into the Church, after which he was dismissed from the monastery and again put out into the world. His first move was to secure a position as servant to the Comtesse de Vercellis. Here he was not happy, complaining that he was treated as an inferior. With his ideal system he could not seem to understand why the Comtesse should never take him into her confidence, never treat him as an equal. Soon after his arrival she died and during the confusion, which followed in the household, Rousseau stole a 17 little ribbon which struck his fancy. The crime in itself w as not so disgraceful had he not, upon being accused, laid the blame on a young servant girl. The remorse following this crime was ever pres- ent in his mind throughout his life, the thoughts of i t always caus- ing great emotion. He rehearsed the details of it over and over and like the incident at Bossey each time it assumed greater proportions He seems to find a kind of morbid fascination in picturing the re- sults it may have brought to the girl. He speaks of the great dan- ger to which he exposed her. Qui sait, a sonilge, ou le decouragement de 1* innocence Here he is creating a dramatic effect, just as his father had done before him, for the sake of arousing his own emotions. He next went into the service of the Comte de Gouvon. In this household he was treated very kindly and shown every con- sideration- He was on the point of obtaining a settled position as secretary and confidential servant when his restlessness again as- serted itself and caused him to move on. His insatiable thirst for freedom and his desire for novelty were upon him again. In vain he tells us that all he wished was to have a peaceful habitation and steady occupation. We see him too often rebelling against routine of any sort to accept this statement. He seems happy only when free from all restraint and sense of duty. To be wandering about care- free with but a few francs in his pocket not knowing whence his next meal would come, constituted for him a pleasant existence. (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 2, p. 130. 18 Thoughts of Mm©. de Warens came to him at this time and, desirous of seeing her again, he went back to Annecy. She appeared to be very glad to see him and received him into her household. He entered into this new life with a content hitherto unknown to him.. A tender intimacy grew up between the two. He used to call Ivlme. de Warens Maman, she called him Petit. He regarded her as a mother and had the reverence of a son for her. Theirs was an ideal rela- tionship says Rousseau. His world was a world of ideals and it was only when living in this world that he approached a state of hap- piness. Life at Annecy fulfilled his ideals to a certain extent. He was happy and content because of it. Mme, de Warens seemed to care very much for him but at times she seemed to gro w tired of his shiftless ways and wished that he would do something for himself, assume some responsibility. With this in mind she placed him in a seminary where he could follow some definite line of work. She was disappointed in this, however, for he was dissatisfied there and soon returned to her. After this he took a few music lessons of a M. Nicoloz but his lessons soon came to an end for M. Nicoloz was ob- liged to leave Annecy. At Mine, de Waren's request Rousseau accom- panied him. He went as far as Lyons then abandoned his Master and rushed back to Annecy only to find that in his absence Mine, de War- ens had gone to Paris leaving no word of explanation or information concerning her whereabouts in Paris. This was a sad home-coming for Rousseau. He spent days hanging around Annecy in the hopes of her return or of receiving some word from her. In spite of his disap- pointment at Ivlme. de Waren's absence, he managed to enjoy himself. He was care-free, therefore happy. He idled his time awajr by wand- ering about either in the company of Mile. Merceret, the chamber— U i'J . 19 maid of Mine, de Warens, or in solitude, enjoying the beauties of Nature. He was so delighted at seeing the sun rise one morning that, as he says, he could not refrain from writing about it. L'aurore un Matin me parut si bellej que m'^tant habille* precipitamment je me hatai de gagner la campagne pour voir lever le soleil. Je goutai ce plaisir dans tout son charme ; ... La terre, dans sa plus grande parure, e^tait couverte d' herbe et de fleurs; les rossignols, presque a la fin de leur ramage, semblaient se plaire \ le renforcer; tous les oiseaux, faisant en concert leurs adieux au printemps, chantaient la naissance d'un beau jour d'ete . . . To be so impressed by a spring morning as to be able to describe it in detail years later is a sure proof of a sensitive, romantic nature. It cherishes things indef ini telyj whereas the calm nature, without ernoti on ; soon forgets, although it may have enjoyed intense^ for the moment. Emotion is the force which drives things into the memory, causing them to be retained. Days passed and still no word, from Mme.de Warens. Mile. Merceret decided to go home to her father. Rousseau accompanied her to her home at Fribourg and went on from there to Nyon, a short dis- tance away, where his father was located. The reunion, says Rous- seau was a very touching one. They embraced and shed tears of ( 2 ) joy, too overcome with emotion to speak. Rousseau's emotion in this case seems to have been an outward show and not deepseated. After all these years of separation we would expect to see him settle (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 206. (2) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 223. ' ' 20 down with his father and continue the happy home life which he re- gretted having missed* but to our surprise he bids his father good- bjre the same day and with very little reluctance starts out on his way.. There was now no reason why he should go back to Annecy, ! and having no definite place to go he wandered about until he came to Lausanne.. His funds were low by this time, so he was forced to do something to earn a living. The idea of giving music lessons came to him and he set out to do this although he knew very little about music.- To carry out his plans he assumed the name of Vaussore and established himself at Lausanne as music teacher and composer. His work brought him in contact with a certain M. de Treytorens, a great music lover who used to give concerts at his home. Rousseau was very much impressed by him and wishing to please him promised to render one of his own compositions at Treytoren's next concert. As usual he is not thinking of consequences but plunges boldly in in the hopes of gaining favor in the eyes of his new acquaintance. It is onl^r wher the first moments of excitement are over that he begins to think of the magnitude of the thing he has done. To prepare for this concert Rousseau worked fifteen days on his composition, growing more uneasy as the time for its execution drew near. At last the night arrived and as is to be expected his composition was a miserable failure. Quoi qu’oneut pm penser de mon prltendu talent, l'effet fut pire que tout ce qu’on semblait attendre. Les musiciens etouf- faient de rire ; les auditeurs ouvraient de grands yeux et auraient bien voulu fermer les oreilles. . . J*eus la .Constance d*aller tou- jours mon train, suant, il est vrai , a grosses gouttes, mais retenu 21 par la honte , n l csant m'enfuir et tout planter la. CD Such is the trick the romantic temperament plays on its possessor, pulling and drawing him into precarious situations, then departing abruptly and leaving him to flounder about and suffer alone in his predicament. The possessor of this temperament lives con- tinually in the land of dreams. Unfortunately for hirn, however, there is always the awakening. As regards this incident of the con- cert, Rousseau probably pictured himself as being a wonderful com- poser, dreaming that his composition would be successful, that he would be complimented by great men and petted by charming women. But he awoke, in the depths of despair finding himself not the com- plimented hero but the town fool. Days of extreme melancholy for Rousseau followed this humiliating episode. It may be that he has something of this in mind when he has his hero in La NouvelleHe- loise say with such depth of feeling: Oh Julie, what a fatal present from heaven is an emotional soul. One who has received it must prepare for sorrow on earth. After this failure his pupils withdrew, and people shunned him or poked fun at him. He was without friends in his distress and had only his imagination to turn to for comfort. He spent hours in solitude dreaming about Mine, de Warens and wondering if he should see her again. Her birthplacej Vevey, was not far from Lausanne, and one day Rousseau conceived the idea of going there for consolation.. He would seek comfort in inhabiting her country, in passing the (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 229 22 streets where she had passed, before the houses where she had lived. To reach Vevey it was necessary to travel for two or three days along Lake Geneva. On the way Rousseau gave himself up completely to the melancholy which had been pursuing him since the night of the con- cert- But it was a different kind of melancholy; where it had been grief mixed with bitterness, shame and remorse it now became calm and resigned. In the former Rousseau suffered keenly, in the latter he found keen enjoyment. That is to say he discovered the pleasure to be derived from being miserable. In the former his tears came from bitterness and despair, in the latter he wept for the sheer joy of weeping- In the following passage we see Rousseau's enjoyment and love of the beautiful in Nature. His ddlight, however, is not in the scene alone but in the effect produced by it. L ''Aspect du lac de Geneve et de ses admirables co^tes eut toujours a mes yeux un attrait particulier que je ne saurais ex- pliquer, et qui ne tient pas seuleinent a la beaute 1 2 ^ du spectacle, rnais a je ne sais quoi de plus interessant qui m'affecte et m' attendrit^) Quand 1' ardent desir de cette vie heureuse et douce qui me fuit et pour laquelle j t etais ne vient enflammer mon imagination, c'est toujours au pays de Yaud, pres du lac, dans des campagnes charmantes, qu'elle se fixe. II me faut absolument un verger au bord de ce lac, et non pas d'un autre; il me faut un ami sur, une femme aimable, une vache , et un petit bateau. Je ne joutrai d'un bonheur parfait sur la terre que quand j'aurai tout cela. (1) Confessions, Fartie 1, Livre 4, p. 233 (2) ib., Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 234 23 And again concerning his return from Vevey we get a des- cription of the effect of the Lake on Rousseau. Dans ce voyage de Vevey, je me livrais, en suivant ce beau rivage, a la plus douce melancolie: mon coeur s'elancait avec ardeur a mille felicites innocentes; je m' attendri ssai s , je soupirais et pleurais comme un enfant. Combi en de fois, m'arretant pour pleurer a mon aise, assis sur une grosse pierre, je me suis amuse a voir tomber rues larmes dans l'eau. CD These impressions are interesting and important^ for this is a scene which remains longest in Rousseau's memory and which ap- pears later in La Nouvelle Heloise . From Lausanne he went to Ueufchatel where he again attempt- ed to teach music. This time he was more successful, for he was beginning to understand music and have a taste for it. He was only moderately happy at Neufch&tel. As he says, "an ordinary man would have been contented, but my restless heart demanded other things." He hated to be hemmed in in the city and longed to get into the open country where he could dream at leisure. Les dimanches et les jours ou j'etais libre, j'allais courir les campagnes et les bois des environs, toujours errant, r£- vant, soupirant; et quand j'etais une fois sorti de la ville, je n'y rentrais plus que le soir.^g) One evening on returning from one of his walks, Rousseau stopped to rest at a little inn at Boudry. There he met an old man (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 23.4 (2) ib., Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 236 24 in Greek costume, w ho told a story to the effect that he was travel- ing through Europe collecting money for the restoration of the Holy Sepulchre Anything out of the ordinary always appealed to Rous- seau, and this was not without its appeal. He was immediately drawn toward this old man. The two ate dinner together and became friends Rousseau was so impressed with the idea of restoring the Holy Se- pulchre that he volunteered his services as secretary and prepared to leave Neufchatel. Here again is a proof of Rousseau's impetuous nature. He is too ready to take everyone at his word and becomes so filled with enthusiasm for future possibilities that he complete- ly forgets the present* The two started off on their mission, traveling through Fribourg, Berne and Soleure. The ambition to reach Jerusalem was never realized, for at Soleure Rousseau's companion was arrested for fraud. The French ambassador realizing that Rousseau had been a tool, pardoned him and offered to start him on the right path by sending him to Paris. There he was to enter the service of one of the am- bassador's friends* Rousseau accepted immediately for it had long been his desire to see Paris, the city of his dreams where all am- bitions are realized and a state of happiness attained. He set out enthusiastically for Paris but on arriving there he was doomed to disappointment* Here again the ideal turned suddenly into the real. In the following we get his first impres- sion of Paris not as his dream city but as a disagreeable reality* En entrant par le faubourg Saint-Marc eau, je ne vis que de petites rues sales et puantes, de vilaines Maisons Noires, 1'air de la mal-proprete 7 , de la pauvrete^ des mendiantes, des charretiers, . ' . , ' 25 des ravaudeuses, des crieuses de tisane et de vieux chapeaux. Tout cela me frappa d’abord a tel point, que tout ce que j'ai vu depuis \ Paris de magnificence r^ele n' a pu detruire cette premiere impres- s i on . ^ -j ^ He was neither pleased with his surroundings at Paris nor his occupation; accordingly, as we should expect from his tem- perament, he left immediately. He had learned that Mme . de Warens was no longer living at Paris. Thinking she had gone back to Annecy, Rousseau decided to go there to join her. He started out on this journey on foot. He had very little money and would have to endure what to the aver- age man would be the greatest hardships; to Rousseau, however, these hardships were merely pleasant adventures. He went along from day to day free from worry or care. It mattered not to him how long the journey was, provided he eventually reached Annecy. In the meantime he would enjoy nature and entertain himself by his thoughts and dreams which he says were abundant when he was in solitude. r t / Jamais je n f ai tant pense, tant existe tant vecu, tant et4 moi , si j‘ose ainsi dire, que dans ces voyages que j’ai faits seul et a pied. . .La vue de la campagne, la succession des as- pects agreables, le grand air, la bonne sante que je gagne en mar- chant, . . . 1 1 eloignement de tout ce qui me fait sentir ma de— pendance de tout ce qui me rappelle a ma situation, tout cela de- gage mon anie, me donne une plus grande audace de penser, me jette en quelque sorte dans l'immensite des etres pour les combiner, les (1) Confessions, Partiel, Livre 4, p. 245. ■ ■ . . 26 One day as Rousseau was walking along he lost his way and wandered about for hours until he came to a peasant's hut.. He en- tered and asked for food. The peasant offered him nothing but coarse bread and milk, but later, becoming interested in him and convinced that he was not spying, went to the cellar and brought out meat, wine and other good foods. This surprised Rousseau, who upon ques- tioning the peasant learned that he pretended poverty and kept his food hidden to escape paying duties and taxes on it. It was to his advantage to be dying of hunger. Rousseau was greatly impressed by this episode. This man, sensitive to his surroundings, did not fail to respond here. He put himself wholly in the position of the peas- ant , suffering and revolting as much as the latter^ Rousseau was struck forcibly by the umyjustness of this treatment and as he went on his way again he meditated and pondered over the question of this injustice, — Why should the peasant be mistreated and kept in con- stant fear of being punished? The thoughts of this burdened the liberty-loving Rousseau. The following shows the impression it made on him, — such a strong impression that it remained alive in his mem- ory for years and finally took form in L es Discourg. sui I'inegalite . Ce fut la le germe de cette haine inextinguible qui se developpa depuis dans mon coeur contre les vexations qu'eprouve le Sialheureux peuple et contre les oppresseurs. Cet homme, quoique ais£, n’osait manger le pain qu'il avait gagne a la sueur de son front, et ne pouvait eviter sa ruine , qu'en montrant la rneme ndsere (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 250 27 qui rlgnait autour de lui . Je sortis de la maison . . . deplorant le sort de ces belles contrees a qui la nature n'a prodigue ses dons que pour en faire la proie des barbares publicains . Upon reaching Annecy he found that Lime, de Warens had moved, to Chamb^ry. Rousseau had scarcely any money left but was de- termined to reach Chamb^ry. Before he arrived there his money gave out entirely and he was forced to spend his nights in the open. But instead of complaining about this he says it is his most beautiful adventure.. He gives us a striking description of one night thus spent and we see that he is. not exaggerating when he tells us he really enjoyed this life of a vagabond. Je me souviens meme d* avoir passe une nuit delicieuse hors de la ville. Des jardins eleves en terrasse bordaient le chem- j_n du cote oppose. II avait fait trks-chand ce jour- la, la soiree etait charmante ; la rosle humectait l r herbe fletrie; point de vent, une nuit tranquille; l'air etait frais sans etre froid; le soleil, aprls son coucher, avait laisse dans le ciel des vapeurs rouges dont la reflexion rendait l'eau couleur de rose; les arbres des terrasses etaient charges de rossigno]s qui se repondaient de l’un a 1* autre, je me promenais dans une sorte d’extase, livrant rnes sens et mon cosur a la jouissance de tout cela . . . absorbe 7 dans ma douce reverie, je prolongeai fort avant dans la nuit ma promenade, / sans m'apercevoir que j'etais las . . . Je me couchai voluptueuse- ment sur la tablette d’une esp^ce de niche ou de fausse porte enfonci s dans un mur de terrasse; le ciel de mon lit etait forme par les tetes des arbres; un rossignol etait precisement au-dessus de moi : Je (1) Confessions, Fartie 1, Livre 4, p. 253. 28 ra'endormis a son chant; mon sommeil fut doux, mon r4veil le fut davantage. II etait grand jour: Ivies yeux, en s'ouvrant, virent l'eau, la verdure, un paysage admirable. . , J'etais de si bonne humeur, que j'allais chantant tout le long du chemin. ^ In the following we get a description which shows another romantic trait, — not only the love of nautre but the love of the rugged in nature. La vie ambulant est celle qu'il me. faut. Faire route a pied par un beau temps, dans un beau pays, sans etre pressd, et avoir pour terme de ma course un ©bjet agreable ; voila de toutes les manilres de vivre celle qui est le plus de mon gout. Jamais pays de plaine , quelque beau qu'il fut, ne parut tel a mes yeux. II me faut des torrents, des rochers, des sapins, des bois noirs, des montagnes, des chemins raboteux a monter et a descendre, des preci- pices a mes cotes qui me fassent bien peur.^g) (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 260 (2) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 4, p. 266. Chapter V LIFE AT CHAMBERY AND CHARMETTES (1732-1741). After many days of wandering he finally arrived at Cham- bery and was received by Mme . de Warens, who was delighted to see him again. Rousseau's restless desires were satisfied for a time, and he settled down into a calm, peaceful life with Mme. de Warens, which lasted eight or nine years. During this time he was clerk of the surveys, and music teacher. At the beginning of his stay an incident occurred which affected his whole life at Chambery, an in- cident not important in Itself but as it involves a later consider- ation of a similar incident in La Nouvelle Heloise . Mme. de Warens had living at her home a young botanist named Claud Anet, with whom she had the most intimate relations. She offered Rousseau the same privileges which he accepted. The strange thing to be noticed here is that she continued in her former manner with Claude Anet without provoking the least sign of jealousy in Rousseau^ In fact he goes into detail in a very frank way about the life of these three people. He tells how they all lived happily under one roof without thinking of being jealous. All their wishes, cares and hearts were in com- mon About the third year of his stay at Chambery he was tem- porarily blinded by an accident and had a serious illness because of it- Mme. de Warens nursed him carefully and brought him safely through it but he was only a shadow of his former self, weak;, ner- vous and melancholy. The old house in which they lived was a gloomy (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 5, p. 312 30 sort and it had its effect on the nervous, irritable invalid. Ke didn’t gain strength as he should and was becoming more and more melancholy. The sight of the city oppressed him and he yearned to be out in the country. Mme . de Warens, to humor him rented a beauti- ful country place just outside the city. They took possession of this place, known as Les Charmettes, in the fall of 1736. Rousseau was delighted as soon as he saw it. His sadness passed away in an instant and his old care-free, lighthearted spirit returned and with it his sensitiveness to beauty which had been repressed for some time. In speaking of "Les Charmettes" he says — J'etais transport^ le premier jour que nous y couchames. 0 Mamanl dis-je a cette chere amie en l'embrassant et l’inondant de larmes d' attendrissement et de joie, ce sejour est celui de bonheur et de cl* innocence . Ici commence le court bonheur de me vie; ici viennent les paisibles mais rapides moments qui m’ ont donne le droit de dire que j l 2 ai vecu. . . . Je me levais avec le soleil, et j'etais heureux; je me promenais et j’etais heureux; Je voyais Maman et j’etais heureux; ... Je parcourais les bois, les coteaux, j’errais dans les vallons, je lisais, j'etais oisif, je travaillais au jardin, je cueillais les fruits . . . et le bonheur me suiivait part out., Here hex had nature, freedom, idleness, everything that suited his disposition. To use his own words, "I did what I wished, 1 was what I wanted to be." (1) Confessions, Partie 1, Livre 5, p. 3.4S (2) ib., Partie 1, Livre 6, p. 351 31 This happy and care free existence was unexpectedly inter- rupted. Rousseau had a sudden attack of what he diagnosed as heart trouble. Upon being persuaded by Mine, de Warens, he went to Mont- pellier for a consultation. In a short time he felt much improved and hastened back to Les Charmettes hoping to take up his happy life where he had left it, but to his surprise and chagrin he found that in his absence Lime, de Warens had filled his place with a young man named Wintzenried. She pretended to be glad to have Rousseau back home again, but he detected a change in her manner, a coldness and indifference formerly foreign to her.. When she proposed another three-fold relationship he declined. He tried to. stay on at Les Charmettes; tried to bury his grief in his books and in solitude; but the presence of Wintzenried and the changed attitude of Lime, de Warens were more than he could endure and he felt forced to leave. For a year he tutored in a private household then returned to Les Charmettes, hoping that Lime de Waren's infatuation for Wintzenried would have worn off and that he, Rousseau, would be in favor again. Such was not the case and after a short period of grief, Rousseau set out for Paris. In this circumstance Rousseau shows another strange trait of character. Without doubt he suffered much because of this break with Lime, de Warens, but his sorrow, although extreme, was only mo- mentary. After the break with her he indulged in violent spells of grief and despair followed by melancholy then suddenly without warn- ing he rises up, shakes the burden off his shoulders and as though nothing had happened, starts for Paris, making plans and dreaming dreams for the future. 32 Chapter VI PARIS (1741-1756) . In 1741 Rousseau reached Paris with little money in his pocket but full of ambition and dreams of success.. This success he hoped to obtain t hrough Narcisse, a comedy, and through a new sys- tem of musical notation. Ke went to live in Hotel St. Quentin in Paris- It was located in an undesirable part of the city and was very unattractive in itself, but none of this could affect Rousseau now for he. was too busy living in the future, in his imagination, to be concerned with the present. Everjrthing depended on his new sys- tem of music, the success of which he did not doubt for an instant. It was, however, a complete failure. Rousseau was disappointed over the outcome of it, but never doubted his own ability. He said, by way of consoling himself, that the decision on it was just because of the fact that those who passed judgment didn't know enough about music to appreciate anything of value. Rousseau's temperament and care-free attitude, aided by his egotism, helped him over many dis- appointments. As we have said, he is overcome for an instant but never fails to rise again and to attempt with zeal some new activity. The remarkable thing is that he never seems to weary or be discour- aged over his past failures; he never feels that they are a result of his inability but rather that they are brought about by fate. About the time his system of musical notation failed, Rous- seau- met a Jesuit named Castel who advised him to try his success with women. Castel explained how influential they were and how much could be gained by courting their favor. 33 Rousseau fell in with this plan and presented letters of introduction to three influential ladies who succeeded in getting for him a position as secretary to the Comte de Montaigu in Venice- As usual Rousseau did not find the position to his liking. He could not get along with the Comte, who was a man of quick temper arid dis- agreeable disposition and who refused to treat Rousseau as an equal. He very soon abandoned this position and went back to Paris full of disgust for the nobility and resentment toward them. On his return to Paris he found that the Hotel St. Quentin had fallen into the hands of new people, who were very rough and vulgar and offended Rousseau's aesthetic sensibilities. Only one among them showed any refinement; this was the maid of the new landlady, Therese Le Vas— seur- She stood out in contrast to the others and Rousseau was im- mediately drawn to her. He had had several affairs since his break with Mine . de Warens b.ut they were affairs only. Not since his de- parture from Les Charmettes had he felt toward any woman as he had toward Mme . de Warens. He now felt the need of just such a relation- ship and thought he saw in Therese his need fulfilled. ^ He pick- ed her out because she was quiet, refined, ignorant and inferior to him- He wished some one who would depend on him entirely, follow out his wishes to the letter, care for him and be sensitive enough to reflect his moods. He found just these things in Therese. She was very ignorant, never being able to tell the months of the year or even to tell time by the clock. In talking she always used the wrong words; but what did that matter if she could sit and weep with him (1) Confessions, Partie 2, Livre 7, p. 90 34 over the reading of some mournful selection or go into ecstasy with him over the contemplation of a beautiful landscape. Their emotional natures were in harmony. Rousseau never married her and never led her to expect that he would marry her.. In fact in making the bargain he told her frank- ly what their relationship was to be. Je lui declarai d'avance que je ne 1 ‘ abandonnerai s ni ne l’lpou- serais jamais. ^ That he should refuse to marry Therese when he had the intention of living with her always and being loyal to her, is strange; but it fits in with all his other bizarre notions. He was happy with her* She gratified his desires and supplied domestic peace, which was all that was essential to him. No marriage was needed for that. To live with an inferior is one thing, to marry her is another. Prob- ably had he married her he would have noticed her faults and would have complained of her ignorance. He accepted from a mistress what he might have found disgusting in a wife. Then too the problem of responsibility very likely arose in his mind. Marriage was binding and Rousseau in no way wished to be bound not even to a woman he loved. Closely allied to this shirking of responsibility was another much more serious. Rousseau tells us that, in all, five children were born of this union and that one by one they v/ere disposed of in an orphan asylum. With the birth of the first child Rousseau per- suaded Therese that it was the thing to do to save her honor. ( 2 ) (1) Confessions, Partie 2, Livre 7, p. 89 (2) ib., Partie 2, Livre 7, p. 111. . . 35 Later he justified his act by saying, — . . En livrant ines enfants a l'education publique, faute de pouvoir qes elever moi-mene, en les destinant a devenir ouvriers et paysans, plutot qu' aventuriers et coureurs de fortunes, je crus faire un acte de citoyen et de p^re ; et je me regardai comme un rnembre de la r£- publique de Platon. / Such was the author of the Erni 1 e , that well known treatise on education, in which Rousseau, the unnatural father in reality, idealizes a situation in which the child is brought up altogether under the guidance of its parents. This gives added proof that Rous- seau lived completely in the imagination. He was continually pic- turing to himself what he would like to be and how he would act in certain circumstances.. In his imagination he was a success as a man, lover and father; in reality he was a miserable failure. In the Emile some of Rousseau's own early influences take form. He is un- doubtedly thinking of his own haphazard education, his early novel reading and the harmful knowledge derived from it when he says, "Ed- ucation should be purely negative from the j^ears of five to twelve." Nothing should be given the child which is bejrond his comprehension. The period of innocent childhood should be prolonged and not pushed into manhood before the proper time. From this he goes into his pet theory that it is inherent in the child to be good and that the corruption of society does him harm. Therefore he must be carafully educated to ward off these evil influences.. The Emile is usually considered as an intellectual piece (1) Confessions, Partie 2, Livre 8, p. 133. 36 of work, being a product of the reason only. But after making a careful study of Rousseau's life we can show that the points he makes in the Smile are simply the results of some past experience accompanied by emotion. This work is also subjective, Rousseau being felt throughout. We therefore include it in our discussion of the romantic. His theory that all nature is good, that it is in- herent in us to be good until we are polluted by ci vilization, is an- other romantic touch. By this he implies that nature is God, civil- ization is man and as man becomes more civilized he gets farther from God. It was in the summer of 1749 that an incident occurred which suddenly made Rousseau famous*. His friend Diderot had been publishing certain of his opinions on matters of morals and religi- on, and for this reason he was arrested and confined in the chateau at Vincennes. Friends were permitted to visit him and Rousseau was one of these. He used to go almost dail 3 ^ carrying with him parts of unfinished works for Diderot to read. One day as he was on his , way to Vincennes he happened to read in the Me r cure de France an an- nouncement of the question proposed for a prize essay by the Academy of Dijon.. The influence of the Progress of the Arts and Sciences upon Morality. A sudden inspiration came to him. One idea after an- oth er took form and almost overwhelmed him. He was so overcome with emotion that he had to sit down under a tree to recover. He says he passed a half hour in such agitation, that without realizing that he was weeping, he had moistened the whole front of his vest with tears* He hurried on to Vincennes and told Diderot what had happen- ed. The latter urged him to write on the subject. Rousseau took the side that society was becoming corrupt through the Arts and 37 Sciences, or to make it more general, through civilization. He at- tacked this subject with much sincerity and great depth of feeling. All his pent up emotions were for the first time finding an outlet in real expressions. Intoxicated with this inspiration he went deep- er and deeper into the subject making somewhat rash statements, car- rying his views to extremes, But it was this very boldness and orig- inality in his writings which attracted the attention of the Dijon Academy to him, won for him the prize and made him one of the most popular men in Paris- Rousseau' s next work was his Pi scours sur 1 'infealit^ the theme of which is an enlargement of that of his first Pi scours . Once having started pouring out his thoughts he could not repress them and they continued to flow gaining force as they went. ■Very likely as he wrote, thoughts of past events, which had impress- ed him, c ame to an< ^ demanded expression; his servitude with Abel Ducommum, his being treated as an inferior at the home of the comtesse de Vercellis, his misery in the service of the comte de Montaigu, and especially the impressions which he received the day the peasant told him how the poor suffered at the hands of those higher up. In this Pi scours he is still complaining against civili- zation but his remarks are directed to those high up in the society, which constitutes civilization. In this work he starts by giving a detailed account of primitive man. In the age of primitive man there did not exist any inequality. All enjoyed and partook of com- mon pleasures. Rousseau says that wrong began with private property; gradually one individual acquired more than his fellows and with this acquisition came power. From this, civilization built up little by \ 38 little bringing with it unhappiness and useless strivings. This would never have happened could man have remained in his primitive state. As he was writing this he became so imbued with the ideas that he was setting forth that in his imagination he began to live ! in the past with primitive man and to enjoy his peaceful existence. These imaginary pictures of peace aroused in him an even greater hatred of the city than he had had before, and he conceived the Idea of publicly denouncing society and living the simple life; to con- form his life as nearly as possible to the things he had been preach- ing. Kis first step was to give up fancy dress discard his watch, lay aside his fine linen and in their place to put on very simple attire and live simply. He was not able to do this in Paris, where he was the center of attraction, so he moved from there to a place near Montmorency in a pretty little cottage known as L'Hermitage, / which was given him by an old friend, Lime. d’Epinay. He w as over- joyed to be once more in the quiet of the county and away from the mad rush and corruption of the city. 39 Chapter VII L ‘HERMITAGE AND MONT LOUIS (1756-1762) . Rousseau took up his abode at L‘Hermitage in April 1756. Although it was quite cold, he says the violets and spring flowers were beginning to bloom and the sight of them filled him with peace and calm. He spent the first days exploring his surroundings and speaks of the delight they brought him. Enfin tous mes voeux sont accompli s. Mon premier soin fut de me IDvrer a 1* impression des objets champetres dont j'etais en- tour£. . . . il ^i»eut pas un sentier, pas un taillis, pas un bos- quet, pas un reduit autour de ma demeure, que je n’eusse parcouru.. . ^ He tells us that from time to time he had visited the country homes of the rich ; but these places failed to appeal to him or to satisfjr him. The nature was a cultivated nature, too keenly did he feel the hand of man in the symmetrical, formal gardens. He long- ed to be surrounded by rugged nature in some lonely spot where only the hand of God could be felt. To the former he reacted to a great extent, not being able to be inspired by it or even to enjoy it; in the latter the irregular, rugged aspects of nature suited his moods and inspired him with romantic thoughts. A classicist might be in- spired in a symmetrical, garden, a romanticist never. I 1 Hermitage was just the place Rousseau needed as a stimulus to his romantic traits. He says of it: Plus j ‘examinais cette charmante retraite plus je la sen- (1) Confessions, Partie 2, Livre 9, p. 207 ' r ' . . . 40 tais faite pour moi. Ce lieu^ solitaire plutot que sauvage, me trans- portait en idee au bout du monde . II avait de ces beautes touchantes qu'on ne ttrouve gu&re aupres des villes.^-jj . . He benefited by this life both physically and mentally. He grew stronger in body, calmer in mind. Away from the city he be- gan to lose the bitterness he had felt for society; and for weeks his life was one of calmness and contentment. His days were spent rambling about through the woods, sometimes alone, sometimes with Therese who continued to reflect his moods. Happiness and content seemed, however, to be always shorWlived for Rousseau. A disappoint ment always followed his periods of happiness. He was never able to steer a middle course, he was either on the heights or in the depths. His trouble at l^Hermitage came in the person of Mme . Le Vasseur, mother of Therese who, while accepting the hospitality of Rousseau and pretending friendship for him, was doing all in her power to turn her daughter against him. At this time Rousseau began to de- tect a change in Therese* s attitude.- She began to have an aversion for him. Rousseau was all too conscious of this growing estrange- ment and bitterly* complained of it. Now that her affection for him was altered, she was no longer his emotional companion and he found that outside of her emotional nature there was nothing of interest in her character. For the first time he noticed her faults, her lack of wit and intelligence and he began to tire of the very ignorance he had so desired in her.. Rousseau was oppressed by this turn in affairs and again (1) Confessions, Parti© 2, Livre 9. p. 207 . . . . . . 41 sought comfort in solitude and in his imagination. He used to spend entire days wandering about in the woods and meditating. His thought turned to the past and his imagination surrounded him with the forms of all the women he had loved. He became forgetful of the present and lived completely in the imagination with these dream creatures. Each one of these he reviewed and analyzed, stopping longest with Lime, de Warens and Therese. But as he meditated on his past love affairs he realized that something had been lacking, for in none of them had he been really satisfied. The longing for complete satis- faction still remained with him.. He felt in need of loving and be- ing loved by a woman who would understand him completely and give him such happiness in love that the longing in his heart would be quieted. He complained that he had never yet found a woman who coulc do this. Mme . de Warens and Therese had done much for him, but they had been able neither to give nor to inspire the type of ideal love for which he yearned. Comment se pouvait-il qu'avec une ame nature llement ex- pansive, pour qui vivre c'etait aimer, je n'eusse pas trouv^ jusqu'a- lors un ami tout a moi un veritable ami, moi qui me sentais si bien fait pour l'^etre. Comment se pouvait-il qu'avec des sens si combus- tibles, avec un coeur tout p£tri d'amour je n'eusse pas du moins une fois brule de sa flamrne pour un objet determine? Devore du besoin d' aimer, sans jamais 1' avoir pu bien satisfaire; je me voyai s attein— dre aux portes de la vieillesse, et mourir sans avoir vecu. Ces re- flexions tristes, mais attendri ssantes me faisaient replier sur moi- meme avec un regret qui n'etait pas sans douceur. II me semblait que la destinee me devait quelque chose qu’elle ne m'avait pas donne . A'quoi bon m' avoir fait na^tre avec des facultes exquises, pour le s - 42 laisser jus qu'a la fin sans eraploi? Le sentiment de mon prix in- terne en me dormant celui de cette injustice m’en dedommageait en quelque sorte, et me faisait verser des larmes que j'aimais a laisser couler . He was disappointed at not having found any evidences of the ideal love in real life. Since he couldn’t experience it, he determined to enjoy it in the imagination. Thus he surrounded him- self with imaginary persons whom he made to look and act as he will- ed. At first this was somewhat objective, that is to say, Rousseau stood on the side directing his personages, but with a sentimentalist such as he was a method of this sort was not possible for long. He soon became affected by the emotions he put in his dream people. He could no longer be an outsider, so he entered into the imaginary play, identifying himself with his hero, putting traits of some of his friends in his other characters, putting them in situations sim- ilar to some in his own life and finally laying the scene in Switz- erland, at Vevey, on Lake Geneva, where he had spent such melancholy days. Thus the picture became completely subjective and was pervad- ed with Rousseau's emotional experiences both past and present, with even a few yearnings in the future. In the following quotation we have his own account of his dream characters. Je me figurai 1 ’ amour^ 1' ami tie , les deux idoles de mon c oeur, sous les plus ravissantes images. Je me plus a les orner de tous les Charmes du sexe que j'avais toujours adore. J'imaginai deux amies. . . Je les douai de deux caracteres analogues, mais different?; de deux figuresj Non pas parfaites, mais de mon gout, qu'animaient li Ul C°nfe ssions, Partie 2. Livre 9. -p. 244. 43 bienveillance et la sensibilite. Je fis l'une brune et l'autre blonde, I'une vive et l'autre douce, fune sage et l'autre faible; mais d'une si touchante faiblesse, que la vertu semblait y gagner. Je donnai a l'une des deux un amant dont l'autre fut la tendre arnie, et merne quei- que chose de plus; mais je n'admis ni rivalite, ni querelles, ni jalousie . . . l^pris de raes deux charmants modules, je m' identifiai s avec 1' amant et l'arni le plus qu'il m'etais possible; mais je le fis aimable et jeune, lui dormant au surplus les vertus et les defauts que je me sentais. ( 1 ) At first, he did not conceive of the idea of writing a novel; but, with his dreaming, his passion increased to such an ex- tent that it had to have an outlet. It was then that he began to write down what had been dwelling in his imagination.. This was the beginning of l a Nouyelle Heloise . During the winter that followed he wrote tt wo parts of it. With the coming of spring an incident oc- curred which had a marked effect on Rousseau and incidentally on his / work. Mine . d'Houdetot, a sister in law of Mme. d'Epinay, paid him a visit. Mme. d'Houdetot was married, to a man of disagreeable temper- ament, who neglected his wife for another woman and did not care in the least when she formed a liaison with M.. de St. Lambert. She was now living at Eaubonne, a short distance from 1' Hermit age. It was in the absence of her husband, and lover, when she was very lonely, that she had the idea of making a visit to Rousseau, whom she had once met in Paris* After this first visit she came again. Both enjoyed walk- (1) Confessions, Part 2, Livre 1, p.251 • . ■ . . 44 ing, and spent many happy hours together strolling around the woods, Jean Jacques fell madly in love with her; she played the game, pre- tending to be ill love with him but never for an instant did her real affection turn from St. Lambert. During a period of nine months Rousseau and Mme . d'Houdetot met every day secretly in the woods, and spent hours there. Mme. d'Houdetot now began to realize the magni- tude of Rousseau's passion; that as a lover he wished the privileges of a lover. Not having any deep love for him, her problem was to save herself and spare his feelings to the best of her ability. She thought of a plan which she put in action. She wrote to Rousseau commenting on the beauty of their friendship, which she said, nothing should mar.- She told him that she loved St - Lambert but considered Rousseau her best friend and wished to keep him so. Should he be carried away by his passion he would bring her great unhappiness and their beautiful friendship would be ruined. Shortly after this St. Lambert returned. She confessed to him her relations with Rousseau. Ke forgave her and for her sake even pretended friendship for Rous- seau. The three met several times after this, but the friendship soon broke up. I As we remember, Rousseau was writing la Nouvelle Keloise when he first met Mme . d'Houdetot. His writing did not cease during his love affair, but was greatly intensified by it. Rousseau now put into his work not the passions felt for dream personages but an absorbing passion for a real woman. This woman had come to be em- bodied in his dream heroine, Julie, as Rousseau the real lover was embodied in his hero St. Freux. Thus Rousseau had a double passion for the real and for the ideal, the one intensifying the other. * - v >« . •- . 45 The plot of la Nouvelle Heloise is a simple one. — St. Preux is a tutor to Julie, daughter of baron d'^tange. St. Preux falls madly in love with Julie, but does not know that his love is returned. He writes letters to her of his passion, and begs her to send him away as he cannot stand being near her without speaking of his love. Finally, in a letter she confesses her love for him. Un- known to her parents this mutual passion increases, until, acting on a sudden impulse, Julie yields to her passion. Then follows a per- I iod of bitterness and remorse for her, in which St. Preux tries to i i console her by telling her she has given herself for love and that is as it should be. The real nature of their relations is still un- known to the parents, but they realize that St. Preux wishes to marry Julie. The baron is very angry, and forbids Julie to see her lover again. St. Preux gees to Paris. Letters full of grief and despair at parting are then written. Julie's mother discovers the letters; realizing the true nature of the relations which have existed between Julie and St. Preux, she receives such a shock that she dies soon after.- Shortly after this Julie is seriously ill with small-pox- St. Preux in a frenzy rushes to her bedside and catches the disease; but both recover. Then Julie accepts a suitor, M„ de Wolmar, whom her father proposes. She does not love him and intends to be faith- ful to St. Preux only, but at the altar she is taken with a religi- ous fervor and solemnly swears to herself to remain faithful to her marriage vows and to give herself entirely to the fulfillment of her new duties as the wife of M- de Colmar. Six years pass in which St. Preux spends the life of a wanderer; Julie spends the calm life of a married woman doing her household tasks and caring for her children. St. Freux then returns . . 46 from. his wanderings. Julie tells Wolmar all about the past, and he, having the utmost faith in her writes to St. Preux asking him to come to their home to live. St. Preux accepts. When he realizes the generosity of Wolmar and the confidence he has in the tv/o former lovers, St. Preux determines to be worthy of this confidence. Then follows a struggle for the lovers. Both are pursued by memories. To further show the confidence he has placed in them, Wolmar goes away for a time leaving them alone. In this period oo* Preux almost gives in to his passion, but Julie restrains him. With the return of Wolmar the danger passes, and the three again live happily under one roof. So the story goes on until it is brought to a close by an accident which causes the death of Julie. One of her children falls into the lake. Julie saves him but dies from the shock and exposure . La Nouvelle Heloise is the most important romantic work of Rousseau.. Here all his romantic traits are seen in full develop- ment. The whole work is filled with his own emotional experiences; the emotions of the characters being his own emotions, the events being a repetition of some of the events of his life. This strange idea of having Julie, St. Preux and Wolmar live together peacefully and happily comes from an early experience, when Mme . de Warens, Claude Anet and Rousseau lived just such a life; and, again, from the idea of Mme. d'Houdetot, St. Lambert and himself in such a re- lationship. When he makes Julie so faithful to duty that she over- comes her passion for St. Preux, we see Rousseau's experience with Mme. d'Houdetot, when at her request he controls his passion in or- der to preserve their friendship. Some of the romantic traits, out- side of subjectivity, which are clearly shown, are unbridled emo— ' . . . _ 47 tion, passionate love, sentimentality, melancholy, tears and despair; and throughout the whole production we see Rousseau’s great love of nature and his ability to bring nature into harmony with the emotions. In the following passages we have good examples of unbridled passions, overwhelming grief and sentimentality. The first is the . anger of baron d’Etange on finding that his daughter loves her tutor. II remarqua ma contenance basse, eperdue, humili^e, in- dices de mes remords. S' il n'en tira pas la consequence de ma faute, il en tira celle de mon amour; et pour m’en faire plus de honte, il en outragea l’objet en des termes si odieux et si m£pri sants que je ne pu . . . le laisser poursuivre sans 1 ' interrompre . . . Au nom du ciel, lui dis-je, daignez vous apaiser; jamais un homme digne de tant d' injures ne sera dangereux pour moi . A 1’ instant mon p^re, qui crut sentir un reproche \ travers ces mots, et dont la fureur n'attendait qu'un pretexte, s’elan^a sur ta pauvre amie: (Julie) pour la premiere fois de ma vie je rejus un soufflet qui ne fut pas le seul ; et , se livrant a son transport avec une violence €gale a celle qu’il lui avait coatee, il me maltraita sans management, quoique ma m&re se fut jet&e entre deux, m'e.ut couverte de son corps, et eut repu quelques-uns des coups qui m’etaient portes. En reculant pour les eviter, je fis un faux pas, je tombai, et mon visage alia donner contre le pied d'une table qui me fit saigner. The following passage is a good example of unbridled emo- tion and romantic grief. It occurs where St. Preux has been forced to leave Julie. (1) La Nouvelle Heloise, Partie 1, Lettre 63, p. 245. . . . . 48 J»ai vu 1* insense se Jeter a genoux au milieu de 1‘escalier, en baiser mi lie fois les marches, et M. d’Orbe pouvoir h. peine l‘ar- racher de cette froide pierre qu'il pressait de son corps, de la tete, st des bras, en poussant de longs g£mi ssement s . ^ ^ When St. Preux goes to the bedside of Julie, who is very ill, we get a romantic illustration of emotion, grief and sentimental- ity. II te vit, et se tut; il l’avait promis: mais quel silence! [1 se jeta a genoux; il baisait tes rideaux en sanglotant ; il elevait les mains et les yeux; il poussait de sourds ge mi ssement s ;’ il avait peine a contenir sa douleur et ses cris. Sans le voir, tu sortis nachinalement une de tes mains; il s'en saisit avec une espece de fureur; les baisers de feu qu’il appliquait sur cette main malade b ’ evei llerent mieux que le bruit et la voix de tout ce qui t'environ— lait '(2) The most beautiful and most romantic touch in la Nouvelle leloi se is the following nature description. In the absence of LI. de Wolmar, Julie and St. Freux walk along the lake and re-visit scenes loved by both of them. L’occasion de visiter ce lieu si cheri dans une saison plus agreable, et avec celle dont 1' image l'habitait jadis avec moi , fut le motif secret de ma promenade. Je me faisais un plaisir de lui nontrer d'anciens monumens d’une passion si constante et si malheur- ause . Nous y parvinmes aprbs une heure de marche par des sentiers (1) La Nouvelle Reloise, Partie 1, Lettre 65, p. 265. (2) La Nouvelle Heloise, Partie 3, Lettre 14, p. 487, 488. . . .. . 49 tortueux et frais, qui , montant insensiblement entre les arbres et les rochers, n’avaient rien de plus incommode que la longueur du chemin. En approchant et reconnai ssant mes anciens renseignements , je fus A \ pret a me trouver mal ; rnai s je me surmontai , je cachai mon trouble, et nous arrivames. Ce lieu solitaire formait un r^duit sauvage et de- sert, mais plain de ces sortes de beautes qui ne plaisent qu'aux ames sensibles, et paraissent horribles aux autres. Un torrent forme' par la fonte des neiges roulait a vingt pas de nous une eau bourbeuse, et charriait avec bruit du limon, du sable et des pierres. Derri^re nous une chaine de rochers inaccessibles separait l'esplanade o"u nous etions de cette partie des Alpes qu‘on nomine les Glacieres, parce que d ( enormes sommets de glaces qui s’ accroissent incessament les couv- rent depuis le commencement du monde... Des forests de noirs sapins nous ornbragea-i ent tristement a droite. Un grand bois de chdne >■ Scribners, 1908. Hudson, Wm. Rousseau and Naturalism in Life and Thought. New York, Scribner, 1903, MacDonald, F. J. U. Rousseau, a new criticism. 2 vols. New York, Putman, 1906. Macdonald, F. Studies in the France of Voltaire and Rousseau. London, Unto/ln, 1895. Morley, J. Rousseau. 2 vols. London, Chapman, 1891. Nisard,' D. Iiistoire de la Langue et de la Litterature Fran^aise. 8 vols. Paris, Colin, 1909. Texte, J. J. J. Rousseau et les origines du Cosmopoli- ✓ t anisine Litteraire. Paris, Hachette, 1895. Wright, C.. H. A History of French Literature. New York, Oxford Univ. Press, 1912, . . I \ ' * - ■r