THE HYDROLYSIS OF TERTIARY ARSENATES BY HAROLD BYRON JOHNS THESIS FOR THE DEGREE OF BACHELOR OF SCIENCE TN CHEMICAL ENGINEERING COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS AND SCIENCES UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS 1922 I fl'V' t I ■kh m ?r 'V'.ff W) YHAin >Ttin^^Ui r.iia'mmiu » ■'■ * < .A’ ■* f ■. > ., . Tfv;t ••-,.? -/O 't'* . ■ •* _ ‘ ■ . ■>! N <-.f * .-;. U#': 5#: !>, i<> j* * i • * ^ >)'*'. ■■♦ f; I .':! i. JA,n ,-»^r . •>i i/a‘ , 1 ? j ■ • , , •', f '.B* ,♦ • \. ■ A • ’ • ' • • Y' *# *- - • ^ > iH :*} : feV '-'.' ■ * Rj'^V'frU' ■ • ■ ■ 1 ' ‘ /*'»%" ■/• 'lA ?i r / i •>" V >.-a. 'i. 9 v\; '•ifi ' ■, 'iN'/ MSr ■Jd • tV. kV .'C' Pil i ,* V A ' i '."••• .w WiW'ik /922 T6 2 UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS . - PS.J 1 92 s . THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE THESIS PREPARED UNDER MY SUPERVISION BY lA _ _£ YHPJ0-. A oJins ENTITLED _ c_f_X©_rtJ.axy__Ar_aejaaJLes^ IS APPROVED BY ME AS FULFILLING THIS PART OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF a.QLe LQC--QL-Cjiii3xg-Q-ia-Siiei'iiC-aI--KrLg1 ne r r i . n fr Instructor in Charge Approved *_t_ ' HEAD OF DEPARTMENT OF -r —ao[lvk.(j!av;^ tf3 '3 » « •■ aihft &- N- j-*I: «t», V»_ . - - • t 1 'jiy'./ w ”. -*i!tT JH IHI ijO TKa«I eiHT D/I JurijLO’^ M 31': ’/pJTiHAt^t ■■ "'- I , ^ ? 4 ; "T'l ^‘. _-V * ■ J "^-^£ * ' JLil'.i. -•- id H4fM;>'iJ;l \H . «r i • - *. •S -> 1 . ‘ ■-.'#. /'i^.u ‘ '■’' ur \\ • r • •- « ^ VJ =, K •• r? .^J. 4 - ,^,!4 cV ^V> •• t ■ • ‘JJIS - -: - - T -- ^ ' Y » : 5AJ-5 f >1 A'B iD^titfixi ’r6' .hi -:i^ Co) ^ ^ , * ' liU* - — *Wi.-, XW)i *5»: X: bI>? X«^0/^C B\ ■ ( t" , t f\, 1 . I. Introduction. (a). Facts suggesting the problem. Lead arsenate has been used as an insecticide for several years. On account of the increased cost of manufacture, how- ever, manufacturers have recently directed their attentions to the manufacture of a substitute, calcium arsenate, which can be produced for about one half the cost of the lead arsenate. Calcium arsenate is now being manufactured in large quan- tities and is used in the south, principally for the destruc- tion of the cotton boll worm and, to a lesser extent, for the tobacco worm, Colorado potato beetle, and the codling moth. It has been conclusively demonstrated that these two arsenates are equal in toxic value and killing power. There is one great disadvantage in the use calcium arsen- ate as an insecticide in that, even though the product may be free from water soluble arsenic when it leaves the factory, it very often has an appreciable of water soluble arsenic when it reaches the consumer. This water soluble arsenic burns the foliage of plants and since it cannot be removed, large amounts of the insecticide are returned and cause a great loss to the manufacturer. Another disadvantage is that many batches are spoiled in preparation because of the difficulty of properly controlling the conditions of formation. At; V V ■ '•(tr- 'n. I * > r; ^ ' . 4 „ * ., f ' ” ' h. 4 i 'R ’to'. 4 :r ■ i ,- ^ ti« 5 >-‘J "*' 3 fij 5 r ‘ vj ..' ,r ; ■j ' I I’f j : ' m'^ ■ > T . '(^ ■* ', #«. fvs^AX, 'tci v‘i '00 '.'lUft . U ' ■: - 'I**; ^ -f-if£rt pji'siif t’ uu^/i*i uiiswa i'Wfitfi'j>,w( 1 1 •>.*jm»rt’i(!'9»'i!'XsJ)fr .• < it- ' ■« ,, ' , .„ --I /i ' ^'.-I\».' - -I 1 .J i, i#J rfi'l «tf>«)flbio<.| 0 Vx‘#ii|- ■iT».^^’^r.JK'trn<^p rr»#v^^’irXo 4 i^ . V w; • I ;tf • J I tH «L‘ 4 aV f *. i !><• . • - ' '- >^. > ’ '. M • A '•-A -rv tj i* #< • ‘ «a ?5 ^!^,\tTl 'O ff!.^ '«t' r-4^-0'iVbAaXt w7<^x»'^£s fa ’ ■ - ' ' •’ ■■■’ , .’ "’ ’i . ■' -‘’ *n JT^ ti^*iV! -'■‘^- i' ’ •■ i'a’.A'rJ' a6X4(ii^‘ -t k * ,.««5 dri/ ct'vti-l H > 5 far-r 5 X;^t 5 |f'U^f0<5ti)r<% ■ r^^;' * ' • '> ^ .-.-■! ttfr' >t-f ,ai*Viti !,’ t /1 '?'fc ,r,ff l?i . “ -■ uJ J.0 / 'M I'illt f. * j' ^ ' * >■ ■ *s ' » V ' ’ ^ ■ «' . • •'• ; 1 ' I*' !' . ivfi' s,Qot .a’ vocii . ■>> ' ’ * ' ■ " ^4 .T . -ii /..?'. *!?•• . . ■ -■" v-.,;,-,_ Vvf ?; ' [ -■ - -lie .:m I iiilfflUitii ilL nil .M»'!. ■«ri.;iafi»B- -Sr 'f« '. >:(*, ■* Oil I-. '.'i* d3i'.|! 2 . (b ) , Review of the literature. Reedy and Haag (l) found that the presence of such impu- rities as HaCl or FeSO^ seemed to catalyze the formation of wa- ter soluble AS 2 O 5 , Exposure to air and carbon dioxide had sim- ilar effects . De Toni ( 2 ) recently prepared colloidal tri -calcium phos- phate by adding slowly and with constant stirring, nearly boil- ing N Na^PO^ solution, largely diluted, to an equal volume of hot N GaGlg, which also had been largely diluted and had been mixed with the desired quantity of gelatin as protective col- loid. He found that cold solutions react slowly and remain clear for a long time. By adding the phosphate to the calcium chloride an excess of Ga ions is assured and the formation of tri -calcium phosphate* Gelatin gives a precipitate with the sodium phosphate and is therefore added to the calcium chloride. De Toni prepared the Na^PO^ solution by adding the calculated amount of NaOH to a solution of Ha 2 HP 04 , diluting to normal and then carefully protecting from the air. By varying the concen- trations he found that to make colloidal solutions containing 2.068, 3.102, 4.137 g. Ga 3 (P 04)2 in 1000 cc. none of which would show a precipitate, there were required, respectively, 9.5, 17.0, and 27.5 g. of gelatin. He found that gum arabic, blood serum, and starch may be used as protective colloids, but sugar and caramel do not give colloidal tri -calcium phosphate. 3. (c). Statement of the* problem. Since there is a possibility that a precipitate in col- loidal form would not be so apt to hydrolyse, the purpose of this research was first, to try to prepare colloidal tri-calcium arsenate; second, if this colloid is obtained, to study its sta- bility and ionization; and third, to study the stability and ion- ization of other tertiary arsenates. II . Theoretical . (a). Effect of colloidal dispersion on the tox- icity of an insecticide. Burton (3) found that the average diameter of the colloid- al particles of gold, silver, and platinum range from 0.2 to 0.6 micron and other colloids are known to have particles that are only one millimicron in diameter. These particles are therefore much smaller than the particles of an ordinary precipitate which is in suspension. Hence, since we have increased solution and smaller particles, the toxicity of an insecticide should be in- creased when it is in a colloidal form. (b ) . Permanence of suspension. ciiy'iyKpyy'iJ f Tfhen peptized, colloids remain suspended or disbursed for an indefinite period of time. On the other hand certain sus- pensions are often settled within a few hours. (c). Protective effects against weathering. If a colloidal solution of tri-calcium arsenate could be used, it would not only have an increased toxicity, but it would also tend to gelatinize on the foliage of the plant on which it 4. is sprayed. This gelatinous form would not be so easily washed off by the rain and would therefore materially reduce the num- ber of sprayings necessary each year. It might be thought that this gelatinous coating would cover the pores of the leaves and in this way interfere with the respiration and transpiration of the leaves. However, sprays are not often applied so heavily but what the liquid collects in tiny droplets instead of form- ing a solid coating. Ill . Experimental, (a). Preparation of the colloid. A calculated amount of KOH solution was added to a solu- tion of KH 2 AsO^ to form K^AsO^ solution. This solution was fil- tered and diluted to 3N, A solution of GaOlg was made up, fil- tered, and diluted to N. Five cc. of the 3N potassium arsenate solution were dil- uted to 500 cc. and 15 cc. of the N. calcium chloride solution were diluted to 500 cc. Seventeen g. of gelatin were added to the calcium chloride solution and with both solutions near boil- ing, the arsenate solution was added slowly to the calcium chlor- ide and gelatin solution. The stirring was continued for a few moments after the KjAsO^ solution had been added. This gave a solution or suspension which was white by reflected light and yellowish color by transmitted light. This solution gelatinized after standing about 20 hours. When diluted with two parts of water, it gave a clear, water white solution, which did not ’gel- atinize and which remained clear for several days . An increased 5 . amount of gelatin made a more viscous jelly. When the solutions were heated to about the melting point of gelatin ( 40 ® G.), in- stead of 100 ® G. the product appeared to be the same as was ob- tained in the other case. Ga(N03)2 was tried in place of the GaGl2 but the jelly did not seem to remain viscous quite as well. An attempt was also made to make the colloidal Ga3(As04)2 by dropping H^asO^ into a paste of Ga(0H)2 similar to the method recommended by Reedy and Haag (l). The gelatin was dissolved in the arsenic acid. This method proved unsuccessful because the gelatin seemed to slow the reaction too much. Even when the so- lution was made distinctly acid (phenolphthalein ) , by the time the upper part of the solution had gelatinized, the lower part would be decidedly colored, showing that the OH ions were again in excess . It was thought at first that this formation of OH ions indicated that hydrolysis was taking place but the fact that only a fraction of the calculated amount of arsenic acid was necessary to make the solution acid seems to show rather conclusively that it was the slowness of the reaction which caused the phenomena. The above concentrations give a 0.015 H solution of Ga^- (As 0^)2 or 0.995 g. of tri-calcium arsenate per liter. (b). Preparation of other arsenates. Galculated amounts of the K^AsO^ solution were added to solutions of AgNOs, Pb (1103)2, and Gu(N03)2 to form Ag3As04, Pb3(As04)2, and Gu3(As04)2 respectively. In each case the prod- uct was filtered, thoroughly washed, and then dried on a clay plate. Each product was kept in a stoppered sample bottle. •is,. - n r -%'W ^ :s ' 'fc 1 - .-j ’ ' ‘I , ' <3 •■' t* 1 3 ^ ' - (. *- '' j* <“ ( . ;v* y« V ^ - ■ r. . <■. «■' .-i,» 4 „..- y.!*.{«r't J'ectf- ■.'•> tir)4ii tix^* -R ^ ->r t ’. .W ^ T,- ■■■:'. 'Ill' ‘'’' • .uC.t ■ ■ ' ■.''' _•■'■ ■•' .» /•;!•:-. J..-\.:'>^.. ?lfera •iC'.) 4 |h'i 0 Jf 4 jm vt i< 'uT> ‘ 1^' ■ ■ ■-■■£•■ «i ' <■'■■ w* s.r»rrtl'£*>A^'i :>Ji"Vferj^^/ * i*i^’ • .*• Ji' i,. ,‘; i • *' ' ' ;gi Mrtj 4 ■<;.•> ffe; I® *■ .. Bl_ ■■ ,. i'vi' ‘ ■ 4 -.''« i'wl’ot>,r^■I^'#^£'r . iv) ‘ - *■ ■ ■' i!#V ' ; rTh- -IF' '« : yvf ■ — J * ■' .'/T' * - ■ • - -vtl-, '^I.-TTV 4 fc' » '^!L' , 54-1 * ‘ 'k.‘ :'i j'A I • K >-% .'.Ji wi. r 1 ^ 1 ' i. V _ji ■ r' ' . !iv ♦U^‘*.- V l■■>^f:■r{viAJf^ * •/’t* . . . ^“S:' c ..»fpcv .9 f ■ ' ^g> iIh' < "'. i ‘ vt -a '. /v^l^rXcu .. ^ -V * * ti* ‘ ■ 1 "’ V ■: 'r' ■jwW' ' . ' ' -'■ •' II**' '*-T*® _ . . '.II -.. . ..• ,r. ».. •>• - vi • ', w*;’ '. • .1>.I ■ . - Ai-v . V ■‘S •..»•' •■ *• ,, . Lri<* _» • .. ^^,,1 •^ ' i. '“■ *.» ’'■ I #'■ .1 ‘> , ■' ■■ *u '* • ‘ ''“i ■ L ' m' , ' rK -k 1 *^ 0 : 0 .t Cf'no icf *5 TV ■ *■' I. «. ■-, ..•.:'^M 7'V :^4-' •■? ,.r I. p- M «as^* - '■■■“l.-#* 4 * 'H*®::' '* k:' i. 6 • (c). Determination of the solubilities of the arsenates . The solubilities of the arsenates were determined by meas- uring their electromotive forces, when used as ’half cells with silver electrodes, and then calculating the ion concentrations from 'the equation: E = 0.0585 log G’/C" The half cells (used against N/10 Gal.) were: Ag/AgjAsO^/SN Kl'iOj Ag/aggAsO^/Pb^ (AsO^ )2/3N KiJOj Ag/Ag^AsO^/GuglAsO^)^^^ KHO^ Ag/Agj^AsO^/Gol. Ga5(AsO^)g/3N KNO^ The setup used was the ordinary one consisting of a stor- age battery, potentiometer box, variable resistance, galvanom- eter, and standard cell. Gonsidering E’ as the potentiometer reading and using a N/io AgGl cell as a reference, the above equation becomes: E' - .0474 r .0585 log G (AgCl )/C ( Ag 3 As 04 ) z .0585 log(A^)AgGl - ^0585 log (A^)Ag'^As 04 The concentration of Ag ions in n/ 10 AgGl is 1.94 x lO”*^ and after substituting this value in the equation, it becomes: E’ - .0474 « .0585 log 1.94 x 10”^ - .0585 log (Aj)Ag 3 As 04 E’ : .0474 + .0585 log 1.94 x 10"^' - .0585 log (Ag)Ag^AsO^ Whitby ( 4 ) found that the solubility of Ag^As 04 was 8.5 X 10“^ g. per 100 g. of solution. This is equal to 8.5 x 10"^ g. per liter of solution. Ghanging this to moles it becom.es: 7 8.5 X 10"^/462,6 = 1.839 x 10“5 = (ASO 4 ) 1.839 X 10-3 X 3 = 5.517 x 10“5 = {A$) Hence : (Ag)^ X (Aio”) r (5.517 X 10“^)^ x (1.839 x 10 - 5 ) : 308 X 10-20 Therefore: (Ag) r 308 X 10“^ V (AsO^) Substituting, the equation becomes: E’ = .0474 + .0585 log 1.94 x 10 -S --.0585 x log 308 X 10-20/ (ASO4) E’ = ,0474 + .0585 log 1.94 x 10“- - .0585 x log 308 X 10"^^ + .0585 log (ASO 4 ) Combining the terms which are constant for this work, the equation becomes : E' = constant -** .0585 log (As5”) = 0.67905 + 0.0585 log (ASO 4 ) Log (AsOJ) = (E» - 0.67905.) 0.0585 The following readings were made: No. 1. Silver arsenate (to try and check Whitby's results). No. 2 . Copper arsenate. No. 3. Lead arsenate. No. 4. Apiece of gelatin from a Colloidal calcium arsenate solution several days old. (Made from Ca(N 03 )g). No. 5. Some colloidal calcium arsenate which had been made from calcium nitrate'} but had been diluted with tv^o parts of wa- ter and therefore had never gelatinized. The above readings were taken after the cell had been made 1 1 8 . up for at least 24 hours . No. 6. Colloidal oalcium arsenate made iiith CaCl 2 . This reading was taken immediately after the gelatinous colloid had been put in the cell. No. 7. No. 6 after standing for 72 hours. No. 8. Same as No. 6 but made with Ga(NO„Oo instead of o ^ G aC Ig • No. 9. No. 8 after standing for 72 hours. Results • Reading No. Re ading (Volts ; (AsO” ) 1. 0.1820 3.185 X 10“^ 2. 0.1828 3.295 X 10“^ 3. 0.1933 5.000 X 10"^ 4. 0.1155 2.330 X 10-10 5. 0 . 12 15 2,955 X 10-10 6. 0.0716 4.100 X 10"^^ 7. 0.0325 8.890 X 10”^^ 8. 0.1566 1.172 X 10“^ 9. 0.1425 6.720 X 10’^^ IV. Summary . Calculating from the solubility given by Whitby (4), read- ing NO. 1 should give the concentration of the AsO^ ions as 1.84 X 10”^ instead of 3.185 x 10“^. This difference makes the accuracy of the other figures rather doubtful. Even though the figures may not be quite ac- curate, however, the 7 / seem to show that the copper and lead ar- f i tt I : .■ ' 'r-' C f ■ i 9 senates are a little more soluble than the silver arsenate; that colloidal calcium arsenate, especially when prepared with GaCl2, is even more insoluble than the silver arsenate; and that none of these arsenates h^T'drolyses to any appreciable extent. 10 . V. Bibliography . (1) . J. Ind . & iilng. Chem. 13, #11, p. 1038 (Nov. 1921) (2) . Koll. Zeit. 28, 145-8 (1921). (3) . Phil. Mag. U., 425 (1906). ( 4 ) . Zeit. Anorg. Chem. 67,107 .