v;n mil im mV n \ it >m.n 1 1 t V*. I » ) l H I ) H l ll 1 1 « :l I >1 » II II I '< > I n i ill 1,1 11 III) 11 1 111 HI M U II ,1 l II 11 11 1 miimmmim.mimMmii : • — : * • • • • it mm \ i i I I i h It I t r > ) 1 1 . i 1 l > m 1 i m m m . j . y > t . > i , r. i it > n 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 m t n 1 1 > * w n u i 1 1 , \ > i * ; i i it i *. s t u 'i i v i i » i i \ •. m n i 1 1 i ‘iMA'AHM 1 M, HHAM OJ Mam > > M M ' MAMAM, >AM, M M,‘ >AM MAMAM M minimum. mm.ntmiiniimiimiimim'inmwmni OF THE U N I VERS I T Y Of ILLINOIS 385.4 At53r I * ♦ f I , l f \ i ii Dwckirk rElmirrv fens- Wraclvc,/fa .AovAurqh ft r>s hen- fruit A t W/u/eshtir' ' ■ ■ 1 • r : - 1 • - ■ ■ / - ■ • ' . . • - ■ 1 « lln «' .. i<« ’ / ’.-if; J. * S \ -f» K . ■ 'V • ?'’ 1 • 1 v - ■ y,r v- :v ■ * - r ■ * .. „ \ .. . ’>• . ■ . - .. w . .. i .. .v ■ • v. Wyoming Valley. Penn* New York, January 7th, 1853. To Stephen Whitney, Hon. J. Phillips Ph(enix, 0. B. Conant, Lyman Denison, Amos R. Eno, Henry R. Remsen, New York. Gouverneur Morris, Morrisania. Hon. D. S. Gregory, Jersey City. Adam Lee, Rahway, N. J. John Acken, New Brunswick, N. J. Wm. Coxe Dusenbery, North Orange, N. J. Wm. Redmond, South Orange, N. J. F. S. Lathrop, Madison, N. J, John P. Jackson, Joel W. Condit, Beach Yanderpool, John S. Darcy, Hon. Wm. Wright, J. C. Garthwaite, Edwin Van Antwerp, Newark, N. J. W. N. Wood, Morristown, N. J. Edward Lindsley, Beaumont. Jona. J. Slocum, W. J. Woodward, Geo. P. Steele, Chas. Denison, H. M. Fuller, Wilkesbarre, Pa. Gentlemen : — Having been requested by you, to examine the country, between the Wyoming Valley, at Wilkesbarre* and the Delaware River, at the Water Gap, with a view of ascertaining the feasibility and probable expense of constructing a Railroad between these points, as well as the prospect of business for the road when built, I have the honor to report that my examination has resulted in finding a practical line, which will not encounter more than ordi- nary difficulties incidental to mountainous countiies. The line examined commences at Wilkesbarre, and ascends the slope of the mountain, passing over Laurel Brook to Mill Creek, and ascends through the valleys of Mill and Panther Creeks, to the summit near Panther Mountain, a distance of eighteen miles, with a grade not exceeding sixty feet to the mile. From this point, to the top of Pocono Mountain, crossing the Lehigh Valley, a distance of seventeen miles, I think, a line can be obtained with level and light descending grades. * The North Branch Canal, connecting with the New York Public Works and extending to the Chesapeake Bay, passes through Wilkesbarre. G A line was recently run from the top of Pocono Mountain to the Water Gap, twenty-three miles, by Mr. Foster, who reports that a good line can be had, with a grade descending seventy-five feet to the mile, for nine miles, (with a probability of reducing it to sixty,) and the remaining fourteen miles easy descending grades. • I fully concur with Mr. Foster. The whole length of the line will be about fifty-six miles. A first-class railroad can be built and equipped on the line described for two and a quarter millions of dollars. From the foregoing description of the line, it will be seen that after ascending the first eighteen miles from Wilkesbarre, the grades will be either level or descending to the Water Gap, and in the di- rection of the heaviest trade. The limit of the capacity of the Road after reaching the summit would oe fixed by the power of the engine to haul back the empty cars'. We may set down the load for a twenty ton engine at four hundred tons, and should the Belvidere & Delaware Railroad be ex- tended to connect at the Water Gap, the same load may be carried to Bordentown on tide water. The connection with this road, would form a continuous line of railroad from Wilkesbarre to Philadelphia, of one hundred and sixty miles in length. The Morris and Essex Railroad now being extended to the Water Gap, would form a continuous line with the proposed road from Wilkesbarre to New York of one hundred and forty miles in length, with the highest grades, ascending east, (with one exception,) of forty feet to the mile.* Over this road a twenty ton engine would haul two hundred tons, and coal would be delivered on ship board at Jersey city, at all seasons, by the same car upon which it was loaded at the mines, in twelve hours, instead of 'fifteen days, the time now occupied in sending it by way of the Lehigh or Hudson and Delaware Canals, which are closed three months in the year. Although the proposed railroad will carry a large amount of coal and timber, it is probable a considerable part of the profits will arise from passengers and merchandise, as well as lime, from the counties of Sussex and Warren, in New Jersey, for building and agricultural purposes, there being no limestone in the vicinity of Wilkesbarre. gee correspondence at close of Report, page 11. 7 Tlie county of Luzerne has a population of sixty thousand, most of which is within a few miles of Wilkesbarre. The borough of Wilkesbarre has four thousand inhabitants. Kingston, Wyoming, Forty-fort, Plymouth, Frenchville, Huntsville, Leahman’s Corners, Franklin-centre, on the west side of the Susque- hanna — Nauticoke and Pittston, on the east, are thriving and mostly manufacturing villages in the immediate vicinity. There are now running, connecting with lines to Philadelphia and New York, five daily stages, carrying on an average fifty passengers each way. As the railroad would furnish the shortest route to both cities, it is safe to calculate by the new and more ample accommo- dation which the railroad itself would furnish, that the travel would increase at once to one hundred each way, per day. • Fifteen miles of the proposed road would pass through one of the finest timber regions within the same distance from New York. The forest there contains the best of building materials, ship spars, birds eye maple, black walnut, &c., and the timber trade would be an important item in the revenues of the Company. During the past year there has been mined and sent to market from the neighborhood of Wilkesbarre, including the Pennsylvania Coal Mines at Pittston, one million tons of coal — while the coal business, froih the want of facility of transportation, may be said to be scarcely begun, although the coal of the Wyoming Valley is ac- knowledged to be the best fuel of its kind brought to market, and commands the highest price. The coal appears to be inexhaustable, for twelve 'miles the face of the mountain is one continuous bed. The strata are larger and can be worked with greater facility than any other in this country, one vein in the Baltimore mine near Wilkesbarre being twenty-four feet in thickness of pure coal. Within the last four years, the Pennsylvania Coal Company have built a Gravity Railroad, fifty miles in length, from Pittston to Hawley, on the Delaware & Hudson Canal, ten miles below Ilones- dale, and during the last year have sent four hundred thousand tons of coal to market — they bringing none but their own coal — the re- 8 suit is, that all others, except the Wilkesbarre Company, who send theirs over the White Haven inclined plane road, are obliged to seek a market at the mouth of the Susquehanna river. The increase in consumption of Anthracite coal, from the year 1820, the period of its first use, to 1850, inclusive, stated at each successive five years, to show the progressive increase, will appear by the following statement : There was brought to market in 1820, - - - 365 tons. do do 1825, - - 34,583 u do do 1830, - - 174,734 u do do 1835, - - 560,758 u do do 1840, - - 865,444 u do do 1845, - 2,023,052 u do do 1850, about 3,200,000 u do do 1852, “ 5,000,000 u The preceding is but a faint index of the magnitude to which the coal interest of Pennsylvania is to reach, and the avenues for the transportation of the coal to market will have a corresponding im- portance ; and those Railroads which have this resource to rely upon, in addition to other trade naturally flowing to them, by the growth of the country and an increasing travelling population, cannot fail to be productive to their owners. I The cost of transporting coal on the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, is ascertained to be seven-eighths of a cent per mile. There is one grade on this road as high as eighty feet to the mile, and a number reaching above fifty feet. It will be safe to assume this as the cost of transporting coal from Wilkesbarre to Jersey City, over roads of lower grades. Then the cost of carrying a ton of coal over the roads w'ould be one dollar and twenty-two and a half cents. Coal is mined and delivered in the cars at Wilkesbarre for one dol- lar per ton. The actual cost of a ton of coal, at Jersey City, would be two dollars twenty- two and half cents, so that coal, sold at three dollars and eighty-seven and half cents, would leave a profit to the roads of one dollar and sixty-five cents per ton. It is ascertained, from practical experience, that eighty cents per mile will cover the cost of running a train of cars. A twenty ton 9 engine will draw up a sixty foot grade, one hundred and thirty-three tons. To make up a train of four hundred tons at the summit, the engine would have to travel. over the road six times — one hundred and eight miles ; from the summit to the Water Gap, twice over the road — seventy-six miles ; making the whole distance travelled, in transporting four hundred tons over the road, one hundred and eighty-four miles, which at eighty cents per mile would cost one hundred and forty-seven dollars and twenty cents, about thirty- seven cents per ton. Now suppose five trains were run daily, there would be, calculating for three hundred working days in the year, six hundred thousand of tons carried over the road, at a cost of two hundred and twenty-eight thousand dollars, and that the Company charge two cents per ton, per mile — that is one dollar and twelve cents per ton — six hundred thousand of tons will amount to six hundred and seventy-two thousand dollars, leaving a profit of four hundred and forty thousand dollars, or nearly twenty per cent, on the capital required ; and this too, without taking into consider- ation the passengers and timber, or back freight. It is shown by the above calculation that a ton of coal can be de- livered at a profit, at the Delaware Water Gap, eighty-four miles from New York, for - - - - - - $2 12 Coal costs at Manch Chunk - - - - - 225 “ “ “ Pottsville, 205 From the Water Gap the coal can be taken direct to New York by way of the Morris & Essex Railroad, or by the Belvidere & Delaware Railroad, fifty-two miles, to the head of the Delaware & Raritan Canal feeder, where it can be shipped into sea going vessels carrying two hundred tons. The price charged for transporting a ton of coal from Pottsville to New York, 180 miles, is $2 40, and from Mauch Chunk, 140 miles, $2 30|. Considering the road built, to Wilkesbarre, a glance at the accom- panying map will show that it is the most direct route to the great Lakes, and I am assured by gentlemen perfectly acquainted with the country, that a good locomotive route can be had from Wilkesbarre to Williamsport, by way of Shick-Shiny, Huntington, and Fishing Creeks, and that the distance will be less than seventy miles. 2 10 From Williamsport to Erie, a railroad is in the com-se of con- struction. The city of Erie, in the State of Pennsyl vania, is admitted to be one of the best harbors on the Lakes. It ig a proper point to base a calculation, as here the various railroads diverge. 1st. — fhe New York & Erie Route : From Erie to State line, 19 miles. “ State line to Dunkirk, 28 “ “ Dunkirk to New York, - 460 “ 507 “ 2d. — Buffalo & Albany Route : From Erie to State line, 1 9 miles. “ State line to Buffalo, 69 “ “ Buffalo to Albany, - . 328 “ u Albany to New York, 144 “ 560 “ 3d. — By way of Easton <& N. J. Central Railroad : From Erie to Williamsport, 240 miles. “ Williamsport to Tamaqua, 90 “ “ Tamaqua to Easton, - 60 “ “ Easton to Elizabethport, - 64 “ “ Elizabethport to New York, 14 “ 468 “ 4th. — By way of Wilkesbarre : From Erie to Williamsport, 240 miles. “ Williamsport to Wilkesbarre, o “ Wilkesbarre to Water Gap, 56 “ “ Water Gap to New York, 84 “ 450 “ It will be seen that the proposed route will he eighteen miles shorter than by way of the third route ; one hundred and ten shorter than the second ; and fifty-seven shorter than the first. At Williamsport the road would connect with a railroad extending to Elmira, and thence to Niagara, with a branch to Sodus Bay and Oswego. 11 The importance of the work may be brought before the public in two distinct aspects ; one with a view to the great enhancement in the real estate in Wilkesbarre, and along the line of the road, which I believe would exceed materially the whole cost of the work; and the other regarding it merely as an investment for capitalists. Either, in my judgment, is sufficient to justify the immediate construction of the road. * The enterprise is now submitted to your consideration, as entirely feasible, and one that is fully believed will afford a lgige return for the capital required for its construction. , Respectfully, &c., J. W. ALLEN, Civil Engineer. New York, February 1, 1853. J. B. Bassinger, Esq., Engineer of Morris d Essex Railroad , N. J. My Dear Sir : — Having heard from a reliable source that certain persons are doing all they can to create an impression that the grades upon your road are so heavy, as to effectually prevent it ever being used for the transportation of coal from the mines near Wilkes- barre, Pa., to this city, you will very much oblige me, and confer a favor upon the many friends of the enterprise in which I am now engaged, (the constructing of the Delaware, Lehigh & Wyo- ming Valley Railroad,) by giving the facts respecting the grades upon your road, and whatever improvements are contemplated by your Company, with permission to insert the same in the pamphlet now preparing for private circulation. Faithfully your friend, WM. COXE DUSENBERY. 12 Engineer’s Office, M. &c * railroad authorized by special act of Assembly, or any part thereof, or any edifice, device, property or work or any part thereof or any machinery, engine, car, imple- ment or utensil, erected, owned or used by such company, in pursuance of this act, he, she or they so offending, shall forfeit and* pay to such company, three times the actual damage so sustained, to be sued for and recovered 30 Penalty for mis demeanor. Proviso. Statement affairs, &c. Public high- ways. with full costs, before any tribunal having cognizance thereof, by action in the name and for the use of the company. Section 16. That if any person or persons shall wilfully and maliciously remove or destroy any part of the road, property, buildings or other works, belonging to such company, or place designedly and with evil in- tent, any obstruction on the line of such railroad, so as to jeopard the safety or endanger the lives of persons traveling on or over the same, such person or persons so offending, shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor, and shall on conviction be imprisoned in the county jail or penitentiary, at the discretion of the court, for a term not more than three years : Provided, That nothing here- in contained shall prevent the company from pursuing any other appropriate remedy at law in such cases. Section 17. That at each annual meeting of the stockholders of any such company, the president and managers of the preceeding year, shall exhibit to them a full and complete statement of the affairs and proceed- ings of the company for such year, with all such mat- ters as shall be necessary to convey to the stockholders a full knowledge” of the condition and affairs of the company ; and the said president and directors of every such company, shall whenever required, furnish to the legislature, or either branch thereof, a full and authentic report of their affairs and transactions, or such informa- tion relating thereto, as may be demanded of them. Section 18. That upon the completion of any rail- road authorized as aforesaid, the same shall be esteemed a public highway, for the conveyance of passengers, and the transportation of freight, subject to such rules and regulations, in relation to the same, and to the size and construction of wheels, cars, and carriages, the weight of loads/and all other matters and things connected with 31 the use of said railroad, as the president and directors may prescribe and direct: Provided, That the said com- Proviso, pany shall have the exclusive control of the motive power, and may from time to time establish, demand and receive such rates of toll, or other compensation, for the use of such road and of said motive power, and for the conveyance of passengers, the transportation of mer- chandize and commodities, and the cars or other vehi- cles containing the same, or otherwise passing over or on the said railroad, as to the president and directors shall seem reasonable : Provided, however, nevertheless, Proviso. That said rates of toll and motive power charges, so to be established, demanded or received, when the cars used for such conveyance or transportation, are owned or fur- nished by others, shall not exceed two and one half cents To n # per mile for each passenger, three cents per mile for each ton of two thousand pounds of freight, three cents per mile for each passenger or baggage car, and two cents per mile for each burden or freight car, every four wheels being computed a car ; and in the transportation of passengers, no charge shall be made to exceed three cents per mile for through passengers, and three and a half cents per mile for way passengers. Section 1 9. That if any company incorporated as Commence, aforesaid, shall not commence the construction of their pietion of road’, proposed railroad within three years, and complete and open the same for use, with at least one track, within the term prescribed by the special act authorizing the same, or if after completion, the said railroad shall be suffered to go into decay, and be impassable for the term of two years, then this charter shall be null and void, except so far as to compel the said company to make reparation for damages. Section 20. That if any company incorporated as Reservation, aforesaid, shall at any time misuse or abuse any of the privileges granted by this act, or by the special act of 32 Proviso. incorporation, the Legislature may revoke, all and singu- lar the rights and privileges so granted to such company ; and the Legislature hereby reserves the power to resume, alter or amend any charter granted under this act, and take for public use any road constructed in pursuance of such charter : Provided, That in resuming, altering, or amending said charters, no injustice shall be done to the corporators, and that in taking such roads for public use, full compensation shall be made to the stockholders. WILLIAM F. PACKER, Speaker of the House of Representatives. GEORGE DARSIE, Speaker of the Senate. APPROVED — - The nineteenth day of February , one thousand eight hundred and forty^nine. WM. F. JOHNSTON. 33 (A SUPPLEMENT,) To the Act Incorporating the Pennsylvania Coal Company, “ Section 2d. That in all cases where the parties cannot agree on the amount of damages claimed, either for lands or materials, the company shall tender a bond with sufficient security to the party claiming the damages, the condition of which shall be that the company will pay or cause to be paid, such amount of damages as the party shall be entitled to receive, after the same shall have been agreed upon by the parties, or assessed under the act to which this is a supplement : Provided , That in case the party or parties claiming damages refuse to accept the bond as tendered by the company, the company shall in every such case present their bond to the Court of Common Pleas of the proper county, and if the court approve of the security, shall direct the same to be filed for the benefit of those to whom it is given ; which bond shall be answerable as all other debts for the amount of damages assessed, if the same be not paid in a reasonable time after such assessment: And provided further , That upon the filing of such bonds it shall be lawful for the President, Directors and company, or any of their agents, to enter upon any land which they shall deem necessary for the construction of said road, either by the making of any excavation or embankment, or for the purpose of searching for earth, stone or gravel.” 5 34 % Beaumont, Luzerne Co., Penn., January 15 th, 1853. Wm. Coxe Dusenbery, Esq., Dear Sir : — Agreeably to your request, we proceed to give you all the information we have within our knowledge, in regard to the Timber Lands in this section, and the cost of manufacturing Lumber. We stated to you in our last conversation, when recently in your city, that we believed there was from two hundred and fifty to three hundred million feet of all kinds of timber and lumber that would go to market over a railroad passing through the country where it is contemplated the route from Wilkesbarre to the Delaware Water Gap will pass. In conversing with others, we find that it will ex- ceed that amount. We have made our estimate by taking three miles wide on each side of the Road, commencing east of Tobyhan- nah River and going west fifteen miles to Shiney Mountain, but we have good reason to know that lumber will be brought a much greater distance to the Road. We believe a great part of the tim- ber lands lying in the three miles, can be purchased at from one to six dollars per acre, according to the quality, quantity, and variety of the timber growing on the same. The cost of saw mills will be about two thousand dollars for each saw, and each saw will manu- facture from eight hundred thousand to a million feet of lumber in a year. Water power is more uncertain than steam, as to quantity, as they are subject to drought in summer and frost in winter, whereas a steam mill will average twelve hundred thousand feet a year for each saw. The average cost of cutting the timber, and sawing and delivering on the line of railroad, we do not think will exceed three dollars and seventy-five cents, or four dollars, the thousand feet, (that is, after the steam saw mills are erected, which can be located in the woods, to favor the hauling of the timber, and the delivery of the lumber to the railroad.) The cost of transportation, Mr. Bassinger (the Engi- neer of the Morris & Essex Railroad,) informed us, would be from three to four cents per thousand feet per mile. The cost of the land, which is covered with pine, spruce, hemlock, beech, birch, maple, white ash, and cherry, with the manufacturing into lumber, we think, 35 will average twelve dollars per thousand feet, delivered in the market. Now allowing for erection of mills, the cost of manufacturing the lumber, and transportation to market, at the above average, there will be a profit of from five to eight dollars per thousand feet. The amount that will be realized will be in proportion to the quantity of lands purchased. There is no timber, in any quantity, so near New York or Phila delphia, as this, which will give it a higher rate of profit than can be obtained from any other place where timber lands can be pur- chased. A large proportion of these lands, now covered with timber, will be worth as much, or more, after the timber is cut off, for farming purposes, than they are now. Mr. Isaac Lewis, living near the con- templated route, on the Lehigh River, last spring planted potatoes on a piece of new ground, by digging holes here and there among the stumps and logs, without manure, and raised a fine crop, which is a proof of the quality of the soil. We believe we have given all the information you desired, and as near the facts as it will be possible to arrive at ; any further informa- tion, however, that you may want, we will cheerfully give, to the best of our knowledge, at any time. Respectfully yours, Ac., EDWARD LINDSLEY, A. LEWIS. APPENDIX During the summer of 1850, some triends in this city, whose attention was drawn to this great enterprise, employed Wm. F. Roberts, Esq., a well-known practised geologist, to examine some lands upon or very near the contemplated line of road, to ascertain if there was any coal upon them. Here is his REPORT. Wilkesbarre, Pa., June 20th, 1850. To John Alstyne, Esq., 1 Simeon Draper, Esq. >• of New York. Wm. Coxe Dusenbery, Esq., ) Gentlemen : In compliance with your request, I at once proceed to submit my Report upon the Western portion of the third tier of Lots in Pittston Township, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, the result of two examinations — the first in the fall of 1839, the second in the spring of 1850, by Wm. F. Roberts, Practical Geologist and Engineer of Mines. The examinations above referred to, of a part of the third tier of lots, lying between the waters of Mill creek, a tributary of the Sus- quehanna, on the division line between the townships of Pittston and Wilkesbarre, and the waters of Miller’s Creek, a tributary of the Lackawanna, was made for the purpose of ascertaining the Geologi- cal value of these lands for Anthracite coal, and the facts and con- clusions arrived at are as follows : The boundary of the coal formation (the conglomerate rock on which the coal veins repose,) crops out on the summit of the moun- tain at the point of intersection of the north-western and north- eastern lines of Pittston certified Township, a short distance south- east from the intersection of the south-western line of Wilkes- barre Township, on the knoll of the mountain north-east of the gap 37 of Mill Creek. The course of the mountain, and the general range of the outcrop of the coal veins from Mill Creek gap in an east- wardly direction, diverges gradually from the line of Pittston Town- ship, and consequently the distance is continually increasing east- wardly, between the range of the outcrop of coal veins and the Township line of Pittston, and thus the third tier of lots command the lowermost veins of the formation, (which are the largest and produce the best coal,) and those in the third tier are nearer to the surface than they are at the RivA, and better adapted for economical mining. It was formerly considered, and indeed is at the present time as- serted, by some persons, that the third tier of lots in Pittston Town- ship are of very little value for coal. They are, and always have been, what may be termed “ run down,” by parties interested in the lands and mines Contiguous to the river, who hold the opinion that no other land contains coal except that in which they are interested ; thus the prejudice of these persons has done much to prevent the purchase of land in the third tier of lots, and for this reason, and this alone, the third tier of lots are valued by their respective owners (except in one or two instances,) at so low a price in comparison to that which is now being asked, and for which lots are now being sold at in the second tier, which lots are really not so valuable for mining purposes, as the third tier, and there is question if they con- tain as much available coal. The lots in Pittston Township are divided into four tiers, by lines drawn pretty much in the same direction as the line of the coal strata. The lots are generally divided into narrow strips, which cross the measures at right angles to the range of the outcrop of the coal veins. These lots were divided previous to the discovery of coal in that section, and narrow strips were made for the purpose of giving to each lot-holder an equal proportion of mountain with bottom land. In making purchases for mining operations, it is very necessary to secure several of these narrow lots connected together, to get a sufficient workable distance on the range of coal veins, which is not easily accomplished ; in some places it is impossible, in conse- quence of the different and various ownerships. The lots therefore, to which this Report refers, are not only valuable as coal lands, but 6 38 they are likewise valuable, and very advantageously situated for mining, as a connected body of lands. The lots in Pittston Town- ship, as I before stated, are divided into four parts — the river tier — the first tier — the second tier — and the third tier. The prejudicial opinions are not merely confined to a depreciation of the value of the third tier of lots in Pittston Township, by the owners of the front or River lots, but these opinions exist and are much used to depreciate the value of^sach others coal property in that section. Each owner considers himself to possess the best coal tract, and should one property-holder develope a vein of coal on his es- tate which had not been opened on his neighbor’s, it was then cer- tain that he possessed that vein to himself, and that his neighbor, who had not troubled himself to open, it, did not possess it at all, although the Geological evidence was as strong as could be that the vein went through his neighbor’s estate and beyond it. It is true that these prejudices are not so strong as they formerly were, and every new developement has a tendency to weaken them, and to prove the great regularity of the coal strata through the Wy- oming coal field. As development after development is made in the river and first and second tiers of lots, each tending in some measure to give value to the third tier, the eyes of the more intelli- gent miners and operators in that coal region, are being favorably turned to the third tier, and many of them, even now, without fur- ther developments in that tier, are coming out boldly and asserting that the third tier of lots are really valuable coal lands, and the owners of these lands are waking up to their value. The fourteen feet vein of coal in the vicinity of Pittston makes several angles or abrupt curves, dipping and rising alternately several times in the river and first tier, and a short time since a develop- ment w r as made at Mr. Benedict’s mine, near the division line between the second and third tier of lots, completely upsetting' the theory that heretofore existed, that the fourteen feet vein of coal was confined to the neighborhood of Pittston, and did not exist in the second tier. The discovery was the proving, by Mr. Benedict’s oper- ations, that the fourteen feet vein of coal folded over and dipped underneath the tract in the second tier, back or south of his mine. In consequence of this discovery, Mr. Benedict purchased the tract in the second tier at about 100 dollars per acre. The fourteen feet vein of coal forms a basin underneath the second tier, and rises, making an outcrop on the side of the mountain in the third tier. It will require a deep shaft to work the fourteen feet vein of coal in the second tier. A bore hole was put down by Col. Wright and Company, in the tract next west of Mr. Benedict’s pur- chase, to a depth of about 160 feet, which did not reach the four- teen feet vein, and from the measures in which the bore was discon- tinued, it is presumed that the bore hole must be continued much deeper before it would reach the fourteen feet vein of coal, conse- quently this vein cannot be mined in the second tier without the construction of expensive pumps to draw the coal to the surface, while the same vein in the third tier will be above water level, and the coal could be mined with great facility, and without the addi- tional cost of pumping the water, or winding the coal to the surface. The advantages of the third tier of lots in Pittston Township, as regards the facilities for mining the coal, are unequalled in that sec- tion. Tfyey command the lower series of veins of the Anthracite formation of Wyoming Valley, and these crop out on the side of the mountain, and consequently these lots command an abundunce of coal above water level, and that of the purest and best quality. These coal veins may be opened and worked from the gaps of Mill Creek, without incurring the enormous expense of driving tunnels across the strata, through rock, or sinking of shafts, or slopes, to obtain workable breasts. The veins of coal may be entered at once from the gaps, and by continuing in the vein a water level roadway, great breasts of coal would be gained which could be mined and delivered on the surface at very cheap rates. The distance from the proposed sites for mining operations in that portion of the third tier of lots to which this report refers, to the place selected for the shipment of the coal, is not more than two miles — an easy down-hill grade. Taking into consideration this fact, together with the superior situation of the coal veins for mining above water level, the third tier of lots are actually far more valua- 40 ble than those of the second tier, or even those of the first, or the front tier, which are close upon the banks of the Canal, because in the first place, the veins underlaying the fourteen feet vein of coal, and even in many places on the River lots, are all below water level, and the twenty-eight feet vein of coal, so celebrated for its purity, is at great depth below the 'surface, at the River ; even the fourteen feet vein, in most places where it is worked in the River lots, is ap- proached either by a tunnel, slope, or shaft, constructed at great cost. In the river and first tier of lots, the coal veins are much contorted, and as I before stated, make several abrupt axis and narrow basins, and where these contortions exist, the facilities for mining are retarded, and the coal strata is much more liable to fault than it is where the axis are farther from each other. In the mountain range of coal strata of the third tier of lots to which this Report refers, these contortions do not exist, for the coal veins after basining under the second tier, crop out on the side of the mountain in the third tier ; and these crops are well delineated on the surface, in a regular unbroken line from Mill Stream Gap to Miller’s Stream. In the river and first and' second tiers of lots are impediments to mining operations, in the shape of sand banks and gravel mounds, caused by the change of the course of the waters of the Susque- hanna and its tributaries, making their way through the valley for ages past. These do not exist in the third tier of lots in Pittston Township. Another advantage which the third tier of lots has over the river and first tiers, is its growth of timber, which for mining purposes is abundant in that tier. Time must come, and that before long, when timber land in the valley of the Wyoming, contiguous to the mines, will be worth more than coal land is worth at the present time. The lots in the third tier in Pittston Township, it must be borne in mind, are admirably situated for market. The river lots cer- tainly, at the present time, have the advantage of being close to the line of the Pennsylvania canal, so far as regards the contiguity of the mines to navigation for shipment of the coal when raised. The 41 advantage thus gained is about the distance of two miles of railroad of an easy down-hill grade. But as regards the future improve- ments, such as those now under contemplation, to connect New York market with the Wyoming coal region by a continuous line of railway through the State of New Jersey, thereby opening out the great and invaluable primitive iron ore region of that State, and connecting it with the Anthracite coal field of Wyoming, the third tier of lots in Pittston Township will have every advantage over the river tier, and first and second tiers. The amount of coal in the twenty -eight feet vein alone, being as it is the bottom vein of the coal formation of Wyoming, and conse- quently the general range of its ontcrop is near the summit of the mountain which bounds the coal formation, ranging along the third tier of lots, is very great in quantity within the boundary of these lots. Millions of tons of the finest description of coal are com- manded by these lots above water level. Several other workable veins overlie the twenty-eight feet vein, between it and the fourteen feet vein, all of which, the third tier of lots herein referred to, command to a great extent. No reason can be shown why the third tier of lots in Pittston Township are not of more value, and will not yield a greater profit per ton upon the coal mined, than the river lots or the first tier. For my own part, I consider that portion of the third tier of lots in Pittston Township, referred to in this Report, taking into considera- tion all the circumstances herein named, as regards their situation for mining, their marketable advantages, and the quantity and quality of the coal therein contained, of equal value to any body of land of the same area in the Wyoming Valley. Lots have sold on the river tier for $2p0 to $300 per acre ; in the first tier, $150 to $200 ; in the second, $100 to $200 ; and in the third tier they are valued at only about $60 per acre. All of which is respectfully submitted by Yours, very truly, W. F. ROBERTS, Practical Geologist and Engineer of Mines . 42 The foregoing Report was published , and produced the following notice : — New York, Ogt. 19th, 1850. Sir : — You are respectfully invited to attend a meeting to be held at the office of Messrs. Dumont & Hosack, No. 11 Wall street, on The 2 2d inst., at 2 o’clock P.M., to take into consideration a connec- tion, by Railroad, of the Coal Fields of Lackawanna Valley with this city, being in the direct line from this city to Elmira, in this State, via Morris & Essex Railroad, N. J., with a saving in distance of eighty miles. It is believed that Coal, by this route, can be delivered in this city at $3.50 per ton. It is particularly adapted for Steamers. Respectfully yours, NATH’L P. HOSACK, WM. COXE DUSENBERY, J. P. BASSINGER, Engineer of Morris & Essex Railroad , A 7 *. J. The meeting was attended by some of our well-known citizens, and the following proceedings were had thereon : — Pursuant to notice, a meeting was held at the rooms of Messrs. Du- mont & Hosack, No. 11 Wall street, New York, on Tuesday, the 22d day of October, 1850, “ for the purpose of taking into consideration a connection, by Railroad, of the Coal Fields of the Lackawanna Valley with this city, via the Morris & Essex Railroad, N. J.” The meeting being called to order, James Depeyster Ogden, Esq., was unanimously called to the chair, and N. P. Hosack, Esq., was appointed Secretary. The Chairman briefly stated the objects of the call for this meet- ing, with the additional remark, that he considered the time propi- tious for this important undertaking, with the request, if there was any gentleman present 4 who could explain fully the advantages of this improvement, that he would do so. Mr. Dusenbery then stated, that he had been acquainted with this project for the past twelve years : that he considered it the most important improvement leading to New York : that untoward cir- cumstances had kept it back, but now that the Morris & Essex Rail- road had determined to extend their road to the Delaware Water 43 Gap, the greatest difficulty would be removed, as the connection with this city would be complete. Twelve years since, the only chance to have made this work available, was to build, at great ex- pense, a canal from the Water Gap, to Easton, Pa., a distance of some thirty-five miles, and then no nearer to New York ; but now, by the Morris & Essex Railroad, they could avail themselves of it, and also of the Morris Canal, at Hackettstown, where the road crossed the same, and have the advantage of both these improve- ments. Again, the Central Railroad, of New Jersey, is rapidly urg- ing forward that road to Phillipsburg, opposite Easton, and which work will soon be completed, and will there connect with our road at the Gap, via the Trenton & Belvidere Railroad, which is now in progress, and nearly completed to Lambertsville, fourteen miles above Trenton. These four improvements would require at least five hun- dred thousand tons of coal, which would be an important item for this road ; and when it is taken into consideration that this forty-two miles of railroad add another link towards the completion of the air line from New York to Elmira, we must be convinced of its increased importance. Cast your eye over the map of New Jersey and Penn- sylvania, and this will be at once perceived ; and when we calculate the distance of each road forming this line, we find a saving of over eighty miles in our favor, as follows : First, the Morris & Essex Rail- road, from Jersey City to the Water Gap, is about ninety miles, then the length of our road is forty-five miles, that of the Susquehanna Road, from the mouth of the Lackawanna to Elmira, is sixty-five miles, making a total of two hundred miles; while between the same places, via the New York & Erie Railroad, the distance is put down at two hundred and eighty-three miles. Thus much for its importance. Now one word for its revenue. The coal in the Lackawanna Valley is now acknowledged, on all: hands, to be the purest and best fuel of its kind brought to this mar- ket. A large portion of the land in this valley is owned by the Delaware & Hudson Canal Company, and others, who are interested with them. From good authority we learn that this Company have expended upon their works, and for purchases of lands, upwards of eight millions of dollars. This certainly shows their confidence in the results from coal alone. Being owners of all the outlets for con- veying coal from thence to New York, (excepting the expensive road 44 to Whitehaven, 26 miles, where it connects with the Lehigh Canal, distant from New York over two hundred miles,) but a small oppor- tunity is afforded for other companies and individuals to compete with them ; and the result is, that all the others seek a market at the mouth of the Susquehanna river, which route is too long and expensive to afford any profit on the coal. The formation of our road would give other companies and individuals just the oppor- tunity they are desirous of obtaining ; and there is no doubt that they will generously interest themselves in carrying out our plans. Independent of the coal, the contemplated road passes through one of the finest timber regions within the same distance from New York. The forests there contain the best of ship and building tim- ber ; ship spars of extra length, of the finest spruce pine ; rare woods, such as birds-eye maple, black walnut, wild cherry, &c., &c. The cost of the superstructure would be considerably lessened by this fact, and it is worthy of consideration. In conclusion, the Legget’s Gap Road is now building, and will be completed within the next year. This road would run from Harri- son, where the great Lackawanna Iron Works are located, to the great bend on the Susquehanna river, and by building our road, would connect with the New York & Erie Railroad at that place. These are the most prominent points touching this undertaking. Mr. Dusenbery concluded by offering the following resolution : — “ Resolved, That a Committee of twelve be appointed by the chair, to prepare and present to our capitalists, and others, such statements respecting this enterprise, as may induce them to become interested with us.” Whereupon the following gentlemen were appointed such com- mittee : — Hon. William Wright, Beach Vanderpool, and John P. Jackson, Esqs., of Newark, N. J. ; Hon. D. S. Gregory, of Jersey City ; Robert Schuyler, Amos R. Eno, Nathaniel P. Hosack, John A. C. Gray, William B. Draper, and William Coxe Dusenbery, of New York ; to which, on motion, were added James DePeyster Og- den and Doct. J. Kearney Rogers, also of New York. On motion, this Committee were empowered to fill vacancies and to add to their number, and to call the next meeting. Whereupon this meeting adjourned. [Attest^ N. P. Hosack, Secretary. * ■ . ' . . ♦ ■ ‘ ' ^ ■ ' v ....... : i :■ ... - v , **. ■ . ■ ■ ‘}'V, \