>32-6 |ff653f . A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP w m '.P%. «Mk! COMPLIMENTS OF X E. Hi ROLLINS & SONS BOSTON CHICAGO . DENVER SAN FRANCI8C0 ' 1 "V • V ; „>*?.*■ Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2017 with funding from University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign Alternates https://archive.org/details/financialcourtshOOroll \ A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP OR A PLEA FOR CONSE RVATIVE INVESTMENTS BY Frank W. Rollins B OSTON NATHAN SAWYER & SON, PRINTERS No. 41 Pearl St., cor. Franklin 1906 Copyright, 1808 , by E. H. Rollins & Sons, C 0 w\w\erce avVyivaS Sh op» PREFACE. One of our stenographers said to me one day, “Why don’t you get up a book or pamphlet which would be of some service to women in making investments? Put it in plain, understandable lan¬ guage, avoiding technical terms. You have no idea how ignorant many women are of the names and very rudiments of things.” I knew from experience that she was right, and I have tried to carry out the idea. In a life insur¬ ance circular I recently saw the following statement, which I do not vouch for, but it is undoubtedly approximately true : “But three men out of every one hundred acquire a competency by the age of sixty-five, and three out of every five who have so acquired a competency by that time of life lose it between the ages of seventy and seventy-five. Nine women out of every ten lose their money if it is not placed in trust.” This statement is pretty sweeping and would be hard to prove, but if only approximately true, it gives me a reason for offering this little pamphlet. A•H-K' 33 £,,£> "K&53f A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. CHAPTER I. When James Allen died, he left his two daughters a small but comfortable home and fifty thousand dollars of life insurance. He had been a quiet, taciturn man, taking no one, not even his own daughters, into his confidence. Not until he was buried and his will was read, did any one have the slightest idea of his posses¬ sions. He had held the position of Clerk of the United States Circuit Court for forty years and had lived com¬ fortably, educated his daughters and performed his duty as a good citizen. His wife had died four years before him. It now appeared that he had adopted early in life the idea of living close to his income, saving enough each year to pay his life insurance premiums, and relying on the insurance to take care of his family when he should be gone, — rather a dangerous, but not unusual, policy. He had never discussed business at home, and his daughters were absolutely ignorant of the first princi- 6 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. pies of finance. They had received the usual common school education and were now well advanced toward middle life, Hannah being forty-two and Mary, thirty- two. When the first shock of the unexpected death was overcome and they found themselves thrown wholly upon their own resources they were staggered by the weight of the responsibility. It is true they had a comfortable home and a modest fortune, but they were entirely without male kith or kin. There was no man, no near relative, they could go to for advice, and, with the instinctive dread of New England women of expos¬ ing their affairs to outsiders, they hesitated to take any one into their confidence. It was the evening following the funeral, and the two sisters in their new black gowns were seated in the little, lonely sitting-room, reading their father’s last will and testament, which was very brief, and left all he possessed to them jointly. ‘ ‘ I never had the slightest idea of how much father had,” said Hannah, staring into space. “Nor I,” said Mary; “we always had enough, but we lived very economically, so I suppose we can go on all right.” “Yes, but you must remember we don’t have father’s salary any more.” A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 7 “ That’s true; I never thought of that. Can we live on what he left ? ” And an anxious look came over the face of the younger woman. “We must. It isn’t as though we were young and could go out and teach or become stenographers. We are almost too old to begin now, and it doesn’t look, Mary, as though either of us would get married.” A sad little laugh followed the words and the quick tears sprang to the gentle eyes of the younger sister. The word “ spinster” was indelibly stamped on both their good, honest, kindly faces and they knew the world would pass them by for fresher and more brilliant ones. It was only one more of the sad little home tragedies of hope deferred and at last surrendered and merged into gentle resignation; a loss to some man and to the world, for such women make the best wives and mothers. “Well, dear, there are worse things than being single,” said Mary. “I suppose so, but I can’t quite see what, some¬ times,” straining the long, slender fingers together in her lap. ‘ ‘ Why, look around at the unhappy homes you know.” “Yes, dear, but they have lived, at any rate. They know or knew the joys as well as the sorrows of life, while we — well, we are two old maids ! ” 8 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. “ Oh, well, we can have some fun, too. Let’s cheer up and decide what we are going to do. What’s the next move?” said the younger woman, poking the fire vigorously as if it were an adversary. Hannah, somewhat ashamed of her self-exposure, wiped her eyes and glanced at the will again. 44 One thing we don’t have to worry about,—we have a good home with no mortgage on it. Father had a horror of mortgages. I heard him say once that a man with a mortgage on his house was a slave.” “ But how long can we live on $50,000 ? How much shall we spend a year ? How many years are we likely to live ? What shall we do if we live longer than the money lasts? ” These questions rolled out in a torrent and it was plain that the younger sister had more to follow. 4 ‘Wait, wait, Mary, one at a time. I don’t know much about it, but I suppose it’s like this,—father has left us this $50,000 and it’s clear that he thought it was enough for us to live on the rest of our lives. He was a careful, prudent man, and that’s the idea and intent of his will and his provision for us. You seem to think we are going to take this $50,000 and bury it in the cellar, and when we want a new gown just go down and dig out a ten dollar bill and buy it, and so on till it is all gone.” A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 9 46 Well, I must confess that was about my concep¬ tion of it, dear.” “ We must live on the income of it,” said Hannah proudly. “ We must not touch the principal.” “Yes,” gasped Mary, “but how do you get the income? Who pays it and what for? What is income, anyway?” “We ought to be ashamed to be so ignorant, but how is a girl who never handled over $25 at one time in her life, and who never even heard money matters discussed at home, to know anything about it? Why, the income, I suppose, is what you get from your investments.” “But how do you make investments? Where do you go?” “I don’t know. Some bank, I suppose. Oh, I know, the magazines are full of things. Don’t you remember? You’ve seen them hundreds of times. I always read them, they look so attractive. Let’s see,” reaching for one of the popular magazines and hur¬ riedly turning the multitudinous pages of advertising matter at the back. “ Here’s one ; just listen : 6 100 per cent, profit; send us $100 and in six months we guarantee to return you your money and $100 additional.’ Just think of that! Why, we could put in the whole $50,000 and double our money.” 10 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. “ My ! that would be fine; but do you suppose it is true ? Is it safe ? ” “They guarantee it.” 4 4 But who are 6 they ’ ? ” “Here’s another: ‘Banking by mail, 6 per cent, compounded annually. Sums of any size received. The Union Trust Company of L-.’ That sounds more reasonable. Don’t you think 100 per cent, seems pretty large? Here’s another: 4 The K. T. Oil Company — 300 per cent, profits ; no risk; stock in $10 shares. Send for prospectus.’” “Well, it seems easy enough to invest, doesn’t it? Such a magazine wouldn’t publish those advertisements unless the people were honest, would it?” “I don’t know,” said Hannah despondently; “we are always reading in the papers about the failures of companies and about bunco schemes. How is one to know? Oh, I wish we had a brother or an uncle or a man of some kind. It’s pretty hard for two lone women with absolutely no knowledge to do the right thing. And just suppose we should do the wrong thing and lose part or all of our money. Do you realize what that might mean? Did you ever see a poor-farm, Mary? Did you ever go into one? Did you ever inhale the pauper smell? Oh, it makes me sick to think of it.” A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 11 “We mustn’t make the mistake, then, dear; we must go to some one who does know, some one we can trust. We must study these things and know some¬ thing about them. Come,” said the younger girl bravely, “we will put a good face on this. We have the average amount of brains and we can learn what is right. Don’t give way,” getting up and putting her arm around her sister protectingly. ‘ ‘ But to whom can we go ? ” “ Well, there’s Mr. Asquith at the bank.” “ Oh, you know what a mean, secretive old man he is ; I wouldn’t trust him.” “Mr. Appleton, the president of the street rail¬ way.” “ He’s too rich and grand to bother with our affairs.” * ‘ I know — Mr. Stanley, that new lawyer who came here from Boston for his health last year. They said he was in the banking business once.” “Would you dare to go to him, dear? He seems to be a splendid man. I like his eyes and his good, aquiline nose and his square jaw. He looks truthful. But why should he bother about our poor affairs ? ” “ I think he would take an interest,” replied Mary, getting behind her sister to hide a telltale blush. “ You know I met him at Mrs. Coleman’s tea and have seen him once or twice at the Golf Club since.” 12 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. ‘ ‘ Have you ? I didn’t know you had met him; you never mentioned it to me.” ‘ ‘ I forgot, dear. Shall we go to see him to¬ morrow? ” “ If you think he would advise us. I can’t think of any one else and he does look honest.” The next afternoon the two sisters timidly entered the office of Mr. Edward A. Stanley and were pleas¬ antly received by that gentleman. Mr. Stanley, while educated for the bar, had spent most of his life in the banking business; but, having made a modest fortune and finding that his nerves were giving way, he gave up his business in Boston and moved to S-, where he played at practicing law, but really spent most of his time on the golf links. These two women had, with feminine instinct, made a correct estimate of his character. He was distinctly honest. He was also a man of wide knowledge, broad experience and excel¬ lent judgment. It was very fortunate for them that they fell into such good hands. He was old enough to have had experience, yet not so old as to have lost the vigor and virility of youth. It did not take them long to state their case, the talking being done by the elder sister, Mary remaining strangely silent and distrait but very attentive. It A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 13 was, of course, a very simple matter, but Stanley saw at once that what they wanted was not simply to be told what to put their money into but that they needed instruction. They were as ignorant of finance as a toad is of skating, so he said: “I am going to speak very plainly to you, and do what I would do for my own sisters, if I had any.” 4 ‘Oh, will you? That’s just what we want!” exclaimed Hannah. ‘ ‘ I could very easily invest your money for you at reasonable rates of interest, and safely, but, left alone as you are, you ought to know something about finan¬ cial matters. You ought not to be left to the mercy of every ‘ get-rich-quick ’ advertisement, every chance promoter who comes along with a tongue as smooth as an axle newly oiled. You ought to know at least the rudiments of finance; you ought to have the weapons of defence and know how to use them. Now, I’ll tell you what I will do. I’m not a very busy man. I have just enough to do in taking care of my own property and my small practice to keep me from going to seed mentally, while I devote the most of my time to golf and other important matters. I will undertake to teach you what you ought to know. I will put my time against the enjoyment of your society and there will be no charge. Let us start fairly and understand 14 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. each other. I know you and your kind well enough to understand you would accept no gratuity at my hands, but I am thoroughly in earnest when I say I shall enjoy doing it, and that it will not interfere with any of my work or plans.” He spoke earnestly to Hannah, but out of the corner of his eye glanced at Mary. Again, that blush. For the first time the younger sister spoke: “I don’t see, Mr. Stanley, how we could allow you to do it for nothing.” “Oh, but, Mary,” broke in Hannah, “he says he will enjoy it. I am sure it is most kind, Mr. Stanley, and we shall be only too glad to accept.” “All right,” exclaimed Stanley, looking rather triumphantly at the demure face on his right. “ When shall we begin? We must go at it methodically and begin at the beginning. Let me think,” looking down at his desk for several moments, evidently turning something over in his mind. “You won’t want to come to my office every day; suppose I call at the house evenings and we have lessons there ? ” Now both sisters blushed and it was Hannah’s turn to be embarrassed. “ Why, of course, if you don’t think” — “All right. That’s settled,” exclaimed Stanley, without giving her time to voice her fears. He knew A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 15 what was passing through her mind and how she was saying to herself, ‘ 4 What will the neighbors say ? ” and so forth. “ I’ll call to-morrow at eight.” A cheerful fire welcomed Mr. Stanley the next evening and it was difficult to determine whether it was the warmth from the hearth or something else that made the cheeks of the sisters glow. They looked almost pretty as they received their guest. At first they were a little embarrassed, but he soon put them at their ease by taking up the subject in a plain, matter- of-fact way. ‘ ‘ I’m going to assume that you are absolutely ignorant on the subject of finance and investments, although, of course, much that I tell you will be an old story; and that reminds me of an incident in my business. “We received a letter one day from a woman living in an interior country town, asking for a circular describing a certain bond on a western city. Thinking that the woman wished to make a purchase we imme¬ diately started one of our salesmen off to see her. It was necessary for him to travel some hours on the cars and then drive about five miles into the country. On arriving at the house he found the woman hanging 16 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. out clothes. He stated to her he came from our house, and that we had received a letter inquiring about a cer¬ tain bond, and that he was there to tell her about it. She replied: 6 Oh ! I did not want to buy any bond, but I used to live in that town, and I thought I would like to see your circular to see whether the town had improved any.’ 66 Not knowing what you do know, I will begin at the beginning and you can absorb as much as you need. Here are some blank books and pencils, and I wish you would make notes as I go along, for I shall examine you very severely. You know this is a real school,” he added, with a quaint, winsome smile. “ MONEY. 4 6 In order to invest, you must have money. Money is a commodity which represents value or has value itself. Theoretically, you can’t get money without giving an equivalent for it, either in labor, land, merchandise, or something of recognized value. The money you have inherited was earned by your father by a lifetime of labor. Now money, like human beings, must work to get the best out of itself. If you bury your money in the ground, you get nothing out of it beyond the miser’s feeling of possession. Therefore, as soon as one accumulates any surplus A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 17 beyond what he needs to feed and clothe himself, he tries to set it at work for him and that, of course, is the secret of all wealth, the magic but simple process by which nearly all the great fortunes have been cre¬ ated ; not only does the man work to earn more money, but the surplus of his previous earnings toils for him, resting neither day nor night, for interest goes on days and nights, Sundays and holidays, three hundred and sixty-five and one-quarter days in the year. There is no seventh day of rest for interest, no Fourth of July, no Labor Day ; it toils and moils eternally. “ ‘But what is interest?’ you may ask. It is the wages of your money, if you look upon it as a laborer. It is what some person is willing to pay you for the use of it. We will imagine a man has discovered some new way of making cotton cloth. He has a valuable idea, but no money. He hears that you have $50,000. He comes to you and says : ‘ If I had your $50,000 I could put up a small mill and make cloth in my new way, and I could make $25,000 a year over and above all expenses. If you will let me have your $50,000 I will pay you 6 per cent, a year for it, and in a few years I shall have earned enough to pay you back the $50,000.’ Now you can figure that out easily: 6 per cent, on $50,000 is $3,000; deducting $3,000, which he would pay you annually for interest, 18 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. or for the use of your money, would leave him $22,000, net annual profit, which he could put away to repay your principal; or he could, in turn, set that amount to work again by enlarging his mill or investing it. Have I made it clear to you what interest is?” “Yes, I see that clearly,” answered Hannah, who had made an occasional note, while Mary had simply glanced at the speaker’s face shyly once in a while f saying nothing. “We have seen what money is,” he went on, “ and that to get the best out of it we must make it work for us. That is all very simple and elementary and something that everybody probably knows; but right here the real trouble begins. What kind of work shall our money do for us? How shall this useful servant be employed? What can it be trusted to do safely? Whom can we trust to employ it? These are questions as old as the world and as fresh as the newly risen sun. As soon as one has earned a dollar of surplus these questions begin to arise and they last as long as there is a 4 shot in the locker.’ Some learn what to do by long, sad and costly experience, some are taught by prudent advisers, some know by intui¬ tion, but the great mass never learn at all, and the world is full of human ghouls who live by preying on A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 19 the ignorance of the great mass who never learn. All these advertisements which you see so attractively dis¬ played in the papers and magazines, promising 10, 20, 30 or 100 per cent, profit, are the webs spread to catch the gullible human fly. Doubtless you have already been reading them and have thought of doubling your money in a year. Isn’t it so ? ” The sisters smiled guiltily and assented. “I thought so. Hence these lessons. To the financier it is simply incomprehensible that people should be drawn into such transparent swindles, but he forgets that finance is his trade, that he knows it root and branch, while to the average man, and espe¬ cially to the average woman, it is a sealed book, as incomprehensible as the mechanism of a fine watch to a five-year-old child.” “But, Mr. Stanley,” said Mary, “would a high- class magazine publish fraudulent things of that kind ? ” “ Some of them do. There are very few which dis¬ criminate. Most of the newspapers and magazines will publish any advertisement not prohibited by law. The cheaper magazines, which have an enormous circu¬ lation, claim that they refuse many advertisements promising impossible dividends, but the daily papers all over the country take about everything, exercising care only to herd the legitimate banking houses 20 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. together and apart from the illegitimate, leaving the latter in a limbo by themselves. If you were to remonstrate with the papers and magazines for taking such advertisements, they would tell you that they do not have time to examine into the merits of every scheme which is brought to them, and that they are not in business for their health.” “Some of these attractive advertisements are by banks,” exclaimed Hannah. “ Surely a bank ought to be honest and safe.” “ Yes, and that is why so many people are misled. That word 4 bank 9 is worked to death and made to cover all sorts of things. There are banks and banks. Any one can hang out a sign — bank — but it is not necessarily a legitimate bank, what you would under¬ stand as a bank. Ignorant people, and our newly arrived immigrants, especially, are misled by this use of the word bank. Such people have no way of dis¬ criminating ; to them a bank is a bank, and I suppose they think they are all under government control, as they are in some foreign countries. In running through the popular magazines I find many banks advertising high rates of interest. Such institutions should be carefully avoided. Sound and honestly managed banking institutions do not need to advertise high rates, in fact, do not pay high rates; and the ones A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 21 which appear in the advertising columns are probably organized for the benefit of the promoters and not for the depositors. You may scan the papers in vain for an advertisement of our old and well-established savings banks. There are some good trust companies that advertise, but they do not offer fancy rates of interest. 66 1 am not surprised that very intelligent people are frequently caught by these advertisements. They are shrewdly and speciously drawn and are most seductive to people with small incomes. Many people are drawn into these schemes because they are ashamed to go to some man who is posted in such matters and ask about their real standing. In their hearts they know that there is something questionable, and they hesitate to expose their credulity. I have in my hand the adver¬ tisement of a company which states that it pays 5 per cent., and one of the attractive features which it holds out is that you can withdraw your money at any time. Now any financier will tell you that it is impossible for a bank to safely invest money and agree to pay 5 per cent, upon it, and, at the same time, allow the depositor to withdraw without notice. The very strongest trust companies only allow 2 to 3 per cert, on such deposits. 46 Another advertisement which I have here offers a 6 per cent, bond upon real estate. Such an adver- 22 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. tisement should put one upon his inquiry, for the reason that you can get all the money you want in nearly every well-populated section of this country at 5 per cent., and in many sections of the country at even lower rates. You must remember that if these companies advertise to pay 6 per cent., they must be earning a great deal more than 6 per cent., in order to pay their expenses and make a profit for themselves. Therefore, they must be charging the borrower over 7 per cent, for the use of the money. This clearly indicates a dangerous and speculative investment. “ I do not wish to give the impression that because a bank or a company advertises it is necessarily unsound; I merely wish to state that very few good banks do advertise, and that the ones which advertise high rates are the ones to be carefully examined before a deposit is made with them.” “ I have been very much attracted,” said Mary, “ by the advertisements of the wireless telegraph. I don’t see why that shouldn’t prove a great invention and be very profitable.” “So it may,” said Mr. Stanley; “but it is yet largely in the experimental stage. It has not been reduced to a business basis. The original promoters of great enterprises and the first stockholders rarely make money. Once in a great while they are enor- A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 23 mously successful, as in the case of the telephone, but, as a rule, two or three sets of stockholders have to be wiped out before a great invention is placed upon a sound commercial basis. I should say that the stock of new inventions or industrial enterprises would not be classed as a safe investment for women. I am free to admit that the wireless telegraph is fascinating and attractive. There is a certain romantic interest in having your money in such a weird and uncanny thing as the wireless. “1 am very anxious that you should not misunder¬ stand my general remarks on advertising. I am only trying to lay down some general principles for your guidance. I do not wish you to think that the mere fact that a bank or trust company or a corporation advertises lays it open to suspicion, for I am a great believer in advertising, and the papers contain many perfectly legitimate advertisements. Nearly every reputable bond house in the country advertises its bonds. They do not, however, offer 6, 7, 8 and 10 per cent, returns on the money. The thing to look out for is the company or bank advertising excessive and improbable rates. A bank which offers 4 per cent, interest is well within the lines of safety; but one which offers 5 per cent, and over should be inves¬ tigated. A little practice will enable you to differen- 24 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. tiate very readily between a sound and an unsound company. Any financier could go through a news¬ paper or a magazine and blue pencil the unsound adver¬ tisements as fast as he could run his eye over them.” 46 1 know a man who made $100,000 in one month in mining stocks,” said Hannah, somewhat irrelevantly. “Yes, there are many such instances, and I have heard of men making money at Monte Carlo and on horse racing; but that is not investment — that is gambling, and it is not a proper business for women. Mining, as mining, is a perfectly legitimate business* and, properly conducted by a man who understands it, is sometimes very profitable. The same may be said of the oil business, but women situated as you are cannot possibly know anything about mining or the oil business or have any means of investigating it. Such stocks are so speculative, so dangerous, so uncertain, that no man who is square and honest would think for a moment of investing trust funds in them. A really first grade mine, or oil well, is seized by men on the spot, and does not have to advertise to find a pur¬ chaser. The country is full of shrewd men with an abundance of money, perfectly familiar with mining and kindred ventures, who are ready to take up every good mine or oil well that appears. I am not prepared to say that good mines and good wells are not some- A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 25 times sold by advertisement, but it is a rare occur¬ rence. There is but one road for the trustee who handles the funds of women and children, and that is the road of absolute safety. Mines and oil wells do not lie along that road. ‘‘There is one thing that many newspapers and some magazines do, which it seems to me is very rep¬ rehensible and very dangerous, and of course exceed¬ ingly misleading, and that is the publication as reading matter of paid advertisements. It is utterly impos¬ sible for those who are not familiar with newspapers to recognize the difference between this reading matter, which is a paid-for advertisement, and bona fide news matter. In fact, the whole intent of it is to deceive. The practiced advertiser or newspaper man can detect this kind of an advertisement, but a woman never would know the difference, and she would get the impression that what she was reading was the opinion of the paper itself or of its correspondent. This is a matter which ought to be regulated by law in some way. No reputable newspaper or magazine ought to countenance such advertising. ‘ ‘ Most of the big metropolitan newspapers indicate paid reading notices by stars or by the word ‘ adv.’ at the end of the article paid for. But, outside of these big metropolitan papers, most journals have a price 26 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. for pure reading matter, which they do not distinguish in any way, and, even when the three stars or the word 6 adv.’ is used, the ordinary reader does not at once understand the meaning of these printer’s marks.” For an hour more the two sisters plied him with questions, which he answered clearly and simply; and then he took his departure, promising to come again the next Tuesday evening. After he had gone, it took two hours more for those he left behind to get sufficiently calmed down and talked out to go to bed. They decided that it had been a very instructive and delightful visit. A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 27 CHAPTER n. On the following Tuesday Stanley arrived promptly, bringing with him a bouquet of handsome American Beauties. After a brief review of what he had gone over before, in order to see that they had it clearly in mind, he said : “ I am going to take up with you this evening the possibilities in the way of good investments. We will go through the entire list first, and then look them over in detail. Here they are : “You may invest your money in government bonds. “ You may invest it in land or real estate ; and by real estate I include houses, blocks, etc. “You may invest it in mortgages on real estate. “ You may invest it in municipal bonds. “You may invest it in railway bonds. “You may invest it in public service corporation bonds. “You may invest it in stocks. “ You may invest it in bank stocks. “ This covers pretty well the list of possible invest¬ ments. Now, to describe more clearly these various 28 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. forms of investments I must at the start make clear to you the meaning of the names of those different things. “WHAT IS A MORTGAGE? “If you owned a piece of land or a house, — say this house we are in, — and you needed a sum of money, you could go to a savings bank and they would lend you a certain sum upon it, — taking what is called a mortgage upon the house and lot, to secure themselves against loss. The way they would go about it is as follows: 6 ‘ They would first visit the property and make up their minds what it is worth, or what it would bring if they had to sell it to get their money back. Let us say that they valued it at $5,000. They would prob¬ ably tell you that they would loan you 60 per cent, of its value, or $3,000. You see they keep well within the lines of safety, and leave a good margin of 40 per cent, of the supposed value to take care of any possible shrinkage or change in values. Having agreed on the sum, they would draw up a note, or promise to pay, at a certain stated time (one, two or five years, according to your wishes), providing in the note that you should pay the bank every six months a stated sum as interest. A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 29 6 6 Then they would draw up a formidable legal docu¬ ment known as a mortgage, by which you really trans¬ fer your property to the bank, for when you have once signed it, you can’t sell your property, nor give it away, except subject to the mortgage. Now what happens? The bank hands over to you $3,000 in money, or a check for it. Time goes on and every six months you must go to the bank and pay them $75 (I am supposing the rate of interest to have been agreed upon as 5 per cent.), which is what the bank gets for the use of its money. At the end of five years, or for whatever time the money was loaned to you, you must go to the bank and pay them back the $3,000. When you do this the bank will execute what is known as a release of the mortgage (in other words, cancel it), and hand it back to you, together with your note duly canceled. The bank has its money back and you have your house free and clear of all encumbrance. During this period, however, you will have paid the bank the sum of $750 for the use of the money. The dictionary describes a mortgage as ‘ a grant (of land, houses or other immovable property) as security for money lent or contracted to be paid, or other obligation, on condition that if the obligation be discharged according to the contract, the grant shall be void, otherwise it shall remain in full 30 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. force,’ but I have tried to make it clearer by an object lesson.” 44 But what is to prevent one from going to another bank and getting another mortgage and more money?” asked Mary. 4 4 1 should have explained that when the bank made the mortgage, they at once took it to the county recorder’s office and had it recorded; and this effec¬ tually prevents another first mortgage on the same property. 44 WHAT IS A BOND? 44 A bond is a promise to pay. It may be issued by a town, city, county, state or the government, in which case the faith and credit of the municipality* state or government is pledged for the payment; or it may be issued by a corporation, like a railroad, an electric light company or a mill, in which case it is generally secured by a mortgage, but not neces¬ sarily so, for there are debenture bonds which fre¬ quently have no specific security behind them on which you can levy. It is usually a promise to pay a sum of money (say $1,000) at a certain stated time, with an agreement to pay the interest every six months. For convenience there are attached to the bond little oblong notes, or promises to pay, for the amount of each six months’ interest, so that all you have to do A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 31 when the six months rolls around is to cut off one of these little so-called coupons and present it to your bank, which will collect it for you. “WHAT ARE REGISTERED BONDS? “The bonds we have been describing are what are known as coupon bonds. But there is a form known as registered bonds. Coupon and registered bonds differ in two ways. “The coupon bond is negotiable, that is, you can transfer it to another person simply by handing it to him, and his title is perfect, and he can collect the principal and interest as well as you can. “ The registered bond is worth nothing to any one but the person to whom it is issued, for the name of the person is entered in a register with the number of the bond (for each bond is numbered) and the name is also written in the face of the bond, so that no one else can collect it. Instead of there being coupons for you to cut off, the treasurer of the town or company issuing has to send you a check every six months for your interest; as a matter of fact they are not much used by individuals, or at least, coupon bonds are vastly more popular. “ A bond is sometimes described as 4 an endorsement under seal,’ and the dictionary says a bond 4 is a certifi- 32 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. cate of ownership of a specified portion of a capital debt due by a government, a city, a railroad or other corporation to individual holders, and usually bearing a fixed rate of interest.’ These descriptions would not mean much to you, however. 44 WHAT IS A NOTE? 4 6 A note is simply a promise to pay a certain sum of money. There are many kinds. For instance : “ Single name notes, which are simply the promise to pay of one person, or a corporation. “Notes with endorsements, which are notes of some person or corporation upon which another writes his name as endorser, or promisor to pay if the maker of the note does not. “Notes secured by collateral, —that is, the maker of the note deposits with the one loaning the money certain bonds or stocks or other valuable property as security. “Notes may be made payable at a specified date, say six months or a year from the date of making, or may be payable at either the pleasure of the lender or borrower, in which case they are called demand loans, or call loans. “Notes may have the rate of interest specified (and this is generally the case in time loans), or the rate A FINANCIAL COUBTSHIP. 33 may be governed by the current market rate for money, which is generally the rule in demand loans. Of course, a note may also be secured by a mortgage, as I told you earlier in the evening. “WHAT IS STOCK? “ In order to tell you what stock is, I must first tell you what a corporation is; for without corporations there would be no stock. Corporations are a crea¬ tion of modern times. They are a means of associ¬ ating a number of people together in some common business or enterprise. Formerly this was done by means of partnerships ; but as business grew and com¬ merce enlarged and spread, it was found that great enterprises were too large for a few people, and to gather vast numbers into a partnership was impracti¬ cable. There was also the dangerous feature that in a partnership every partner was liable for all the debts of the enterprise. To overcome these obstacles cor¬ porations were devised. They are the creation of the state and are subject to its laws. If a few men want to engage in some business (manufacturing, we will say) that requires large capital, they go to the legisla¬ ture and apply for a charter for a corporation, naming the incorporators, or men who ask for the charter, and stating the kind of business they propose to carry on. 34 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. Generally they have no trouble and a charter is given them to organize a corporation with a certain amount of capital divided into so many shares (usually of $100 each) to do a certain kind of business in a certain state or town. Having this charter, they call together all the men interested and organize a company or a corporation and elect officers, etc. They then vote to issue a certain amount of stock. Let us say, for instance, that the capital stock is to be $100,000. They will vote to issue 1,000 shares of $100 each. They will then take as many shares as they want and offer the rest for sale. If you had a thousand dollars and believed in the enterprise you could buy ten shares, and on the payment of the money they would give you a certificate stating that you were the owner of ten shares of the capital stock of the - Manufacturing Company. If the company proved to be a success and earned a profit, they would send you once or twice a year a check for your proportion of the net earnings. You see you would be the owner of one one-hundredth of the property. If the stock was all taken and fully paid for, you would be secure from any suits for the debts of the company; and that is one of the advantages of a corporation over a partnership. It is very necessary in buying stock to know whether it is fully paid and non-assessable.” A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 35 ‘ ‘ What do you mean by fully paid and non-assess- able? I don’t think I understand that,” said Hannah. “Well, take the manufacturing company which I spoke of a few moments since. Under the laws of most states, if all the stock was sold and paid for at $100 per share, the various subscribers would not be liable for any of the debts of the company. If the corporation was not successful and ran into debt, the only recourse the creditors would have would be to take the mill or whatever property the company had. They could not ask you as a stockholder to pay any of the debts. All you would lose would be what you had invested in the stock; but if all the stock had not been sold and paid for, they could sue you individually and make you pay as much of the debt as you had the means. In other words, one of the real purposes of a corporation is defeated and it practically becomes a partnership with individual liability. Is that clear?” “I think so.” “Furthermore, in some states there is a law which makes every stockholder in a corporation liable for the amount of his stock and as much more. This is known as double liabilitv and, while it is a mighty fine thing for the creditors of a corporation, it be¬ hooves one to examine the affairs of a company he is investing in pretty carefully and also to watch it 36 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. continually. Under our National Bank Act the stock in all national banks has a double liability; therefore, if you own stock in a national bank and it fails, the government can call upon you to pay $100 in cash for every $100 you had in stock.” “ Good gracious, I shouldn’t think any one would want to own stocks ! ” exclaimed Mary. “Perhaps it sounds more dangerous than it is,” said Mr. Stanley, with a smile, “ but I never advise women to buy stocks anyway. There are too many possibilities. “Now I think I have given you all you can digest this evening without mental dyspepsia, and I suggest that Miss Mary play that piece of Chopin’s that I see on the piano.” With some blushing and hesitation Mary was induced to play; and so the second evening closed to the evident satisfaction of all. A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 37 CHAPTER m. When Mr. Stanley next called he took up his lessons where he had left off and went on as follows : “WHAT IS A DEBENTURE? “You will occasionally hear of a debenture, although it is a term used much more abroad than in the United States. It is rather a hard thing to define, as it is used to cover several kinds of securities; but generally it is a simple coupon bond or note, a simple promise to pay, without special security behind it. It is put in the form of a bond and has the rather high-sounding name of debenture to catch the unwary, but you always want to know what it is secured upon. ‘ ‘ There are debentures which are secured by mort¬ gages, and also by collateral, but the word is used very broadly and is likely to lead to misapprehension and a poor investment. * ‘ I have now pretty well covered the names of the tools financiers work with. There are, of course, many variations, many sub-titles, many offshoots. Having explained briefly the meaning of the terms, we 38 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. will try to learn something of the character and value of these securities and investments as investments; and bear in mind that I am talking all the time about investments, permanent places for money for the purpose of getting a steady income, and not specula¬ tion with possible large losses (as well as gains) and long lapses in dividends. “GOVERNMENT BONDS. “To most people absolute safety is summed up in these two words. Whenever a promoter wants to impress a greenhorn with his goods he says they are as safe as a government bond. That is the last word. In a way he is right, for, if our government bonds are not good our other securities are likely to have a checkered career, but it does not necessarily follow, for the government might have a costly war and run up an enormous debt, which would depreciate its bonds heavily, while state, county and city bonds, etc., might not be affected. You will find the bonds of many foreign countries selling at much less than par, while municipal and corporate debts in those coun¬ tries are at a premium. Personally, I am not a great believer in government bonds as an investment for the small investor. They fluctuate tremendously at times, as, for instance, the bonds of Russia and Japan during A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 39 the late war, and our own bonds at the time of the trouble with England about Venezuela in 1895 — our government issues declined from four to ten points. Then, too, you cannot sue a government and are entirely at its mercy. ‘ ‘ In the case of this country our government holds a unique position, for our debt is small, our resources great; but it is not altogether the smallness of the debt nor the greatness of our resources that makes our bonds sell at such high prices. It is the fact that our national banking system is largely based on the bonds of the government. That is, if a national bank wants to issue notes or bank bills it has to go into the market and buy government bonds and lodge them with the United States Treasurer as security. This makes a tremendous and fictitious demand for them and forces the price above their normal value. They are really out of the reach of all but the very rich, to whom the question of income is not material. At the present time the various government issues are selling as follows, and you can see how little the income is from them : “The 2 per cent, bonds redeemable in 1930 will net, at 103, 1.85 per cent, per annum. “The 3 per cent, bonds due in 1918 will net, at 102J, 1.80 per cent, per annum. 40 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. “ The 4 per cent, bonds due in 1907 will net, at 103£, 1.75 per cent, per annum. The 4 per cent, bonds due in 1925 will net, at 130, 2.05 per cent, per annum. “You will notice that only one of them will pay you 2 per cent, per annum. Therefore, if you put your whole property into them you would get an income of considerably less than $1,000. “One ought to say in favor of government bonds that they can be turned into cash ‘ at the drop of a hat,’ that they can always be used as collateral, and that they are non-taxable. I should say that our government bonds were the luxury of investment, the pate de foie gras of the world of wealth. To the average man (or woman) who lives on his income they are not attractive.” “ Mr. Stanley, what is premium?” asked Mary. “ That is a term that puzzles many people. I think I explained to you what par value, or face value, is. In stocks the par or face value is usually $100 (though it may be $5 or $10, or any amount established when the corporation is formed). In bonds it is usually $1,000 (sometimes $500 or even $100). Now, the price of bonds and stocks is regulated by the laws of demand and supply, just as sugar, coffee or any other thing of value. The price indicates the demand for, or the scarcity of, or the value in the public mind. If A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 41 the bonds are scarce and hard to get and thought well of, the price will advance and they will sell for more than their par value, —that is, a $1,000 bond may sell at $1,020. The $20, or excess above the par value, is called premium (a word derived, it is said, from two Latin words — ‘ primo ’ and ‘ yum-yum ’ — the latter word expressing the satisfaction one feels at having his bonds sell above par).” “ You had best be careful how you put any jokes in your lessons,” laughed Hannah. “ We are so ignorant we may take the joke in earnest.” ‘ ‘ I have no fear. But, to go on; if, for any reason, the bonds are not popular, or bear too low a rate of interest, or are not in demand, the price may sink below the par or face value; for instance, a $1,000 bond might sell at $980. The $20 loss in this case is called discount. So you see if bonds or stocks sell above their established par value they are said to be selling at a premium ; if below, at a discount.” “Is it safe,” asked Hannah, “ to buy a bond that is selling at a discount? ” “ I find,” said Mr. Stanley, “ that there is a preva¬ lent feeling amongst women and those who are igno¬ rant of financial affairs that if a bond is selling at a discount, that is, below par, there must be something wrong with it. Now while it is true that the market 42 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. price of a security fixes, in a certain way, its value and the estimation which the general public put upon it, it is frequently true that the market price is not a sure criterion as to its value. As I have said in some previous part of my talk, it is largely a question of supply and demand. It is frequently the case that bonds are brought out and offered to the public in large amounts running up into the millions. Now it takes some time to distribute such an issue of bonds as that and get it into the hands of the final holders, who are the investors. The first purchasers are generally bond houses or brokers, who act as middlemen and distributers and gradually sell the issue to investors. During this period of distribution there are necessarily a great many of the bonds on the market, offered by various houses and people, and this has a tendency to keep the price of the bonds down, so that a very good bond may sometimes sell at quite a discount. After the bonds have become distributed and taken off the market they generally begin to rise, gradually approach par and may go to a considerable premium. It is rather unusual for a new issue to sell at a premium unless it is some very high-grade, well-known bond. ‘ * Another factor which governs the price is the rate of interest which the bond bears. A corporation naturally wishes to place its loans, particularly if they A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 43 are to run a long term of years, at as low a rate as possible, and instead of selling a 5 per cent, bond at par, they will very often offer a 4 per cent, bond at a discount, preferring to pay the discount in order to get a 4 per cent, rate of interest for a long period of years rather than to place the loan at par and pay 5 per cent, for a long period of years. “It is quite often the case that a new issue of bonds, even bearing as high a rate of interest as 5 per cent., will sell at a discount when first brought out because the security is not well known. A great many issues of very good 5 per cent, bonds are being offered nowadays on water power companies, inter- urban railways, electric light plants and other public service corporations, and many of these issues are brought out at from 95 to 98. This price appears very low for a sound 5 per cent, bond, and of course each case must be carefully investigated, but it does not necessarily argue that the investment is unsound because it is sold at less than par. In course of time as the bonds are distributed and become better known the price generally advances to par and even higher. “ REAL ESTATE. “You often hear people say that there is nothing safer than a piece of good real estate,—it can’t run 44 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. away. That is a fallacy. It is true and untrue. As a matter of fact, there is nothing more uncertain, more changeable, more tricky than real estate. It takes a very wise and far-seeing man to invest in it judi¬ ciously. While it cannot run away its value can, and frequently does. 64 Enormous fortunes have been made in real estate* are being made every day, — see the Astor fortune, for example, — but the first Astor happened to get right in the way of a great city and was made rich in spite of himself. You hear of those great fortunes* but you don’t hear of the thousands who bought in the wrong place or wrong direction. I don’t mean to decry real estate as an investment, for I believe in it, but it takes a mighty astute man to figure out the lines of growth in this ever-changing country. “Fifty or seventy-five years ago you would have said nothing could be safer than a good New England farm, at which time land was selling at from $25 to $100 an acre. To-day you can buy all you want at from $5 to $20. Thirty or forty years ago there were certain streets in staid old Boston with great brown- stone houses, imposing and dignified, worth from $50,000 to $100,000 each, and one would have said they were the best of security. What could change that splendid locality? Presto ! it became the fashion A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 45 to live on the Back Bay. Those splendid homes are to-day cheap boarding houses with Chinese laundries in the basements. What would they bring? $15,000? $20,000 ? Perhaps. 4 ‘ Real estate is as capricious as a young girl in her first season. A change of fashion, a new street car line, an elevated road, a hundred things absolutely unforeseen, and the value goes up or down 50 per cent, in a night. Take, for instance, nearly every large city except New York, where the conditions are exceptional on account of the fact that the city is built on an island, and watch the effect of the great ten, fifteen and twenty-story buildings now going up on the old four and five-story buildings looked upon with pride as evidence of wealth and prosperity a few years ago. Some one will say, ‘Yes, but think of how many have made fortunes by unexpected rises in value of real estate!’ True, but what I am trying to make clear is that there is a tremendous element of luck to be considered in real estate investments and that the ordinary investor hasn’t the skill nor experience to deal in it. If you can get a man of skill and ripe judgment, who has watched the ebb and flow of traffic and is not influenced by his own investments, you may do well, but my advice to the beginner is to let it alone or go slowly. 46 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. “MORTGAGES. “A mortgage, if properly made, is generally a safe investment, but many of the difficulties which surround investment in real estate also spring up when you try to buy a mortgage. It requires careful study and delicate weighing of the probabilities. This is par¬ ticularly so in the case of small mortgages which must of necessity be placed on residence or outlying prop¬ erty. Of course a mortgage on inside business prop¬ erty at not over 60 per cent, of its supposed value rarely goes wrong. These mortgages are generally in sums of $25,000 and upward, and are out of the reach of people like yourselves. If you wanted to buy a mortgage you would go to some real estate dealer or person who places mortgages and he would show you a list, some on dwellings, some on board¬ ing houses, some on apartments, some on unoccupied land, etc. 4 ‘ To begin with, you would want to cut out the loans on unoccupied land unless the margin of security was very large. There is no income from such prop¬ erty and in case you have to foreclose the mortgage and take the property you get no income and have to pay heavy taxes. Small stores in the suburbs are more or less dangerous, as they frequently are unsuc- A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 47 cessful. Apartments are fickle and they may become very unpopular if they happen to get in a few unde¬ sirable tenants. The most desirable small loan is to some respectable man on his own home. The only trouble is that such loans are hard to get and generally go to the savings banks at comparatively low rates. The banks are always on the lookout for such loans. Many of the loans on the market are on apartment houses and single houses cheaply built by speculators to sell land. Be careful of them. Also beware of loans on mills or manufacturing plants. They are all right so long as the business is profitable, but if failure comes or they are swallowed up by a trust the security is bad. A mill out of commission brings but a fraction of its cost as a rule. Never lend on personal property or stocks of goods, for you cannot watch your security. It sometimes takes wings. As a rule, never lend to friends. They too often expect to pay only in friend¬ ship, and when they become your debtors they cease to be even friends. ‘ ‘ In taking a mortgage two things are to be studied carefully, —the moral risk and the value of the security. By the moral risk I mean the character of the bor¬ rower, for even if the security proves poor, and yet the borrower is a man of character, he will work his fingers to the bone to pay you.” 48 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. ‘‘One of my friends,” said Hannah, “told me she had placed some money in the West on a farm mortgage at 7 per cent. Are those safe?” “Why, a mortgage in the West is just like a mortgage in the East, or anywhere else. It depends upon the property mortgaged and the local conditions. If you can go and examine the property yourself, or can send some one who knows his business, it is safe enough, but each case must be settled by itself and stand on its own bottom. You can’t say as a general thing western mortgages are good any more than you can say eastern mortgages are good. I should want to know a lot about a man’s character and ability and knowledge before I allowed him to place money on mortgages for me where I could not see the property. Twenty years ago there was a perfect craze in the East for buying western farm and town mortgages. Hundreds of millions were loaned on them at very high rates; the loans were in many cases carelessly made, and there was widespread trouble and much loss. Since then the West has grown rich and has money to loan. You can’t loan money in the good sections of the West at much higher rates than you get here,—that is, the prevailing rate here is 5 per cent; in the West it is 6, but after you have paid your agent and your expenses of examination, etc., A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 49 you can’t net more than 5 per cent. At whatever rate a western mortgage is offered here, remember that the western agent is charging the farmer at least 1 per cent, more for his profit. So, if you are offered a western mortgage to pay you 6 per cent., you may be sure the farmer himself is paying 7 or 8 per cent. Now, if the farmer has good security he does not have to pay such rates in the West to-day. They have too much money there ready to be loaned at more reasonable rates. To sum it up, the same rules apply to western mortgages as to eastern,—reasonable rates of interest and a personal examination of the property. “MUNICIPAL BONDS. 4 4 In order to make myself clear I must first define the word 4 municipal,’ for I don’t suppose you have a very clear idea of it, have you?” The sisters reluctantly confessed that they thought it had something to do with a city, but were not quite sure. “For convenience and for local self-government the state is subdivided into counties, cities, towns and schoul districts. There are also what is known as water precincts, fire precincts, park districts, etc. As a rule, school districts, precincts, etc., are subdivisions of a city or a town, though in some states each county 50 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. is divided into several school districts. These various subdivisions of the state are created by the state and get their charters from the legislature. They are, therefore, purely arbitrary creations of the state and are known generally as municipalities. A municipal bond, therefore, is a bond issued by a municipality, that is, a county, city, town, precinct or district.” “ But,” said Hannah, “ why do towns have to issue bonds? I thought they raised their money by taxes. What do we pay taxes for? ” 64 Well,” replied Mr. Stanley, 44 they do raise a great deal of it that way, but sometimes, for unusual expenditures, they borrow the money by issuing bonds payable at some future date. For instance, you remember that this town put in a system of water works last summer. The cost of it was $150,000. Now, if they had raised the whole of that sum this year by levying a tax for the entire amount it would have nearly bankrupted the whole town. Your share of it would have made a large hole in your income. Instead of that, the town issued a bond or its promise to pay, bearing interest at 4 per cent, per annum. These bonds become due in instalments of $15,000 a year for ten years. That is, each year for the next ten years the town will levy a tax amounting to enough money to pay the annual interest on the loan A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 51 at 4 per cent, and the $15,000 instalment. At the end of ten years the debt will all be paid and the town will own the water works free and clear. “ Sometimes towns adopt the policy of letting the next generation pay a share of the civic improvements, and make the bonds payable thirty, forty or fifty years hence; but the best practice is to pay them inside of twenty years.” “How do they go to work to issue bonds?” ven¬ tured Mary timidly. “Why, you know a town in New England is run by a set of three men known as selectmen. If it is decided to issue bonds, these men will put a paragraph in the call for the annual town meeting, stating that one of the things to be considered is the question of issuing $150,000 of bonds to build water works. When the town meeting occurs, some one will intro¬ duce a resolution that the town bond itself in the sum of $150,000 to build water works, specifying the rate of interest the bonds are to bear, the length of time they are to run, and how they are to be sold. After more or less discussion the resolution is adopted, and then the selectmen go to work and get the bonds printed or lithographed, and publish a notice in the papers that on such a day, at such an hour, they will receive bids for the bonds. The dealers in bonds see- 52 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. ing this notice send in their sealed bids. They are opened and the bonds awarded to the highest bidder. Then the dealer who gets the bonds sells them to people like you or to the savings banks, adding some¬ thing to the price he paid for them for his profit. After the bonds are issued, the town has to levy a tax each year sufficient in amount to pay the interest on the whole amount, and to provide for the part of the principal sum which becomes due. In this way the bonds are gradually called in and retired. Of course, it would be cheaper for the town to levy a tax to pay the whole amount in one year, but the people would not submit to it. 4 6 Now, there are all kinds of municipal bonds and there is quite a difference in their value. There are WATER BONDS, SCHOOL BONDS, COURT HOUSE BONDS, FUNDING BONDS, CITY HALL BONDS and SEWER BONDS, the purposes of which are all sufficiently indicated by their names. These bonds are all for good purposes and the credit of the whole town is usually pledged for their payment; but there are certain classes of bonds which do not stand as well, and which I advise you to let alone. There are what are known as special assessment bonds; that is, instead of being paid directly by a tax on all property in the town, they are paid by a tax on a special part of the town. For A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 53 instance, if you wanted to have the road in front of your place macadamized, you might get the town to do it, but they would issue bonds payable by a tax against the abutting property. Thus, only the people directly benefited or the people whose property fronted on the road would be taxed. You can readily see that the security is not as good, and, as a matter of fact, the people so taxed frequently rebel. Lawsuits follow, and the payment of the bond is involved. It is a safe rule never to buy a special assessment bond. Always inquire whether the property of the whole town is pledged. 64 Another class to be avoided is bonus bonds, which I am glad to say are not very common. To illustrate : It sometimes happens that a town wants to induce some manufacturing concern to locate within its borders. The manufacturing company says it will come if the town will supply a mill. The town goes to work and issues bonds for the purpose. These bonds are nearly always declared illegal if they get into the courts. Another unsafe bond is what is known as a railroad aid bond, which is very similar to a bonus bond. We will suppose it is proposed to run a railroad somewhere near the town. The promoters say to the officers of the town, 6 We will come through your place if you will give us a certain sum of money/ 54 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. To raise this sum the town issues bonds and gives the proceeds to the promoters. There have been many cases where the road was never built, and the people, feeling defrauded, repudiated the bonds. “I heard a good story once about an issue of rail¬ road aid bonds in a western territory. 4 6 A certain county voted to issue a block of railroad aid bonds in order to get a railroad built through the county. These bonds were going to be given to the contractor, one half of the issue when the road was half completed, and the other half when the whole road was done. The contractor completed the first half of the road, and then called upon the county com¬ missioners to go over it and inspect it, which they did. They then delivered him half the issue of bonds. The contractor then quietly pulled up all the rails on the first half of the road, laid them down on the last half of the road, and then took the commissioners over the last half of the road, and got the rest of the bonds. It is quite probable the commissioners were in collu¬ sion with the contractor. In any event, the people of the county later on discovered the fraud, and threat¬ ened to repudiate the bonds. The contractor said if they repudiated the bonds he would pull up the track. The county did repudiate the bonds, and the con¬ tractor pulled up the tracks and ties, took them to California, and built another road with them. A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 55 “Years afterwards the territory, in order to clear up the financial situation of some of the counties and cities, made a large issue of bonds to refund the outstanding debts of the various municipalities. In other words, people holding the county and city bonds were allowed to exchange them for the territorial bonds. The original contractor for the road in ques¬ tion, hearing of this, went to work and bought up these old defaulted bonds at something like ten cents on the dollar, went to the territorial officers, and exchanged them for the territorial bonds, which he afterwards sold at par. ‘ ‘ I am informed that this is an actual occurrence and that the story is absolutely true. It seems almost incredible, but it shows what loose methods prevailed in the earlier days. Such a thing would be impossible at this time. Such bonds are rarely issued now, but thirty years ago they were very common in the West and the South, and resulted in large losses. ‘ ‘ To sum up : If you are going to buy a municipal bond, see that it is the obligation of the whole munici¬ pality, whether it is a county, city, town, water dis¬ trict, school district, or fire precinct. See that the object for which they are issued is something which will benefit all the people alike and is one in which all are interested,—such purposes as water, schools, 56 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. sewers, court house, city hall, parks, cemeteries, etc. A refunding or a funding bond is generally safe, for it refunds a debt which has stood the test of time ; but it is well in buying a refunding bond to ask the purpose of the original issue, to see that it was not a special assessment, bonus or railroad aid bond. “A municipal bond may be either coupon or registered; that is, it may be payable to bearer and have coupons attached, which you cut off every six months and collect through your bank, and this is the usual form; or it may be a registered bond made out in the name of the owner and the interest will be sent by the town treasurer every six months by check. Registered bonds are, of course, safer in case of fire or robbery, but are a nuisance if you want to sell them or use them as collateral. With the present abundance of good safe deposit vaults where you can have a perfectly safe place for your securities for $5 or $10 per annum, there is no need of registered bonds. Every one should have a box in a safety vault even for one’s private papers, such as insurance policies, wills, deeds, etc. It is the cheapest kind of insurance and the mental relief is worth the price. Never keep valuable papers or securities in the house. I have known of many cases where people kept thousands of dollars of securities in old teapots, hair-covered trunks, under A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 57 carpets and between mattresses. Every now and then a house burns down and all the precious savings go up in smoke.” 6 ‘Mr. Stanley, I am following you very well, I think, but will you explain to us what would happen if a town refused to pay its bonds when due?” asked Hannah. “ Certainly,” replied the lawyer; “ if the town did not pay, or defaulted, as we say, you would employ an attorney and he would apply to the court for a man¬ damus— which is a legal phrase for an order — to compel the selectmen to levy a tax to pay the bonds. The case would come up for trial in due course, and if the court decided your claim was valid it would issue a mandamus (or order) to the selectmen to levy a tax sufficient in amount to pay your bonds and the interest.” 66 Supposing the selectmen refused to do it?” said Mary timidly. “That rarely occurs; but if it did, the selectmen would be guilty of contempt of court, and the judge would have them arrested, fined and sent to jail. No, if you get a mandamus you will get your money. “ One great advantage of a municipal bond is that it is practically a first mortgage on all the property in the town, for taxes have to be paid before any- 58 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. thing else. They are a lien on the property and a cloud on the title until paid, and the property can be seized and sold if not paid. It does not matter whether the tax was levied after the property was mortgaged, even. They are a prior lien ahead of all other claims.” * ‘ I don’t understand what you mean when you speak of net return,” said Hannah. ‘ ‘ Many people are at a loss to understand what is meant when you tell them a bond will net so much, or a certain per cent. I will try and explain this. “If you buy a 6 per cent. $1,000 bond at par you pay just $1,000 for it, and, of course, your return is $60 per annum, or 6 per cent.; but if you pay a premium for the bond, you are investing more than $1,000, while your income remains still $60. Now, $60 is 6 per cent, of $1,000, but if you should pay, we will say, a premium of 5 per cent., or $1,050 for the bond, your $60 would not be 6 per cent, upon $1,050. You have invested more money to get the 6 per cent, than when you pay par for the security. “ Now, the question is, at just what rate of interest have you invested your money. To arrive at this, you divide the amount of income which you receive by the amount that you pay for the bond. In this A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 59 case you would divide $60 by $1,050 and the result would be: $1,050)$60.0000(.0571 + 52 50 7 500 7 350 1500 1050 450 or a little less than 5| per cent, per annum. This is the net result of the investment, so that, when any¬ body says the bond will net so much, he means that this is the net return on the money invested. “If the bond is sold below par, the problem is figured out in the same way. “In actual practice, all financial houses use a set of carefully prepared tables, just as they do for figuring interest, not relying upon the lead pencil or the mathe¬ matics of any clerk. “As a matter of fact, the above method of com¬ putation should only be applied to stocks, which do not mature at any specified time, but in the case of bonds, which mature at a certain date, the strictly accurate method of computation is rather complicated; too much so for the average person to figure, and the only safe way is to use tables prepared for that 60 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. purpose. The method I have suggested will do roughly, and is accurate as far as stocks are con¬ cerned, but not for bonds maturing at a fixed date. “ The question of how long the bond has to run enters into the computation, and, if one has much of this sort of work to do, it is advisable to have a set of these tables (which can be readily procured) at hand, as they tell at a glance just what any bond bearing any rate of interest will net at any given price, if you know the length of time the security has to run. “STATE BONDS. “ This is a subject I can deal with very briefly, for the best state bonds sell so high they, like govern¬ ment bonds, are out of the reach of most people. If they are issued by a good state with a high standard of honor, they are a very high-class security, and sell at a price to net from 3 to 3 1-2 per cent. During the War of the Rebellion, Massachusetts met all its obli¬ gations in gold, even when gold was selling at a stu¬ pendous premium, while many of the southern states, overwhelmed with debt, repudiated. The great out about a state bond is that, under the constitution, you cannot sue a sovereign state, so that if a state declines to pay, you are powerless. Therefore, if you buy a state bond, choose your state with care. Nearly all A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 61 the states, I am happy to say, are now on a sound financial basis, and there is small risk. Still, I prefer a good municipal to either a state or a government bond. “ STOCKS. “This is a tremendous subject, and can only be treated in a very general way. I have already told you that a certificate of stock simply represents your ownership of such a proportion of the capital stock of a corporation. In case there is a debt upon the com¬ pany, such as bonds, a mortgage, or floating debt (so-called), the stock represents the equity over and above said debt. If the company is successful, your share of the net earnings is sent you at regular periods in the form of checks. “Stocks have a great attraction for many people, particularly for women. They see them rise rapidly at times, they hear of great fortunes being made in them, etc. It is true that such fortunes are made, but they are made by the big plungers and speculators and not by the little, inexperienced dabblers. Great fortunes are made and lost, and thousands of little fortunes are swept away annually. If the small investor con¬ fined himself to the high-grade dividend-paying stocks (and did not buy them on a margin), he would not run much risk ; but this is seldom the case. He is attracted 62 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. by the promise of big dividends and buys a stock because it looks cheap and a great rise is predicted ; and the gamblers in Wall Street get his little all. If one buys the best stocks, they do not pay a much larger income than conservative bonds, indeed, they sell on somewhat the same basis ; but even these so-called gilt-edged stocks are subject at times to manipulation and rapid changes in price. These changes need not worry the careful holder who has bought and paid for his stock. So long as the divi¬ dends come regularly and the property is kept up it does not matter much. I am referring now to the best railroad stocks, such as Pennsylvania; New York Central; New York, New Haven and Hartford ; Pullman Car Company, and others. “ There is still another line of stocks which attract many on account of their large dividends. I refer to the INDUSTRIAL SHARES : SUGAR, STEEL, SMELTING, etc. There are hundreds, but these are the most prominent. The best of them are semi-conservative, but hardly the thing for a woman. 64 Great fortunes have been made in mining stocks, — gold, silver, copper, lead and iron; but the chances of a woman hitting the right one are as uncertain as of her hitting a bull’s eye with a stone. She had better pass them by. Women are the easy prey for the mining shark with a salted mine to sell. A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 63 ‘ ‘ To sum up the stock question : My advice would be either to buy the most expensive, most conservative, best-established stocks, like those named, or let stocks alone. Perhaps the safest course for a woman is to confine herself to bonds and mortgages. She stands less risk of loss, for she is nearer the bottom of things. While she will not share in the great advances, she does not take the risk of the big losses.” “How would you rate investments, Mr. Stanley, — in what order?” said Hannah. “ About as follows for a woman : “ 1st. Municipal Bonds. “ 2d. First Mortgage Corporation Bonds. “3d. Real Estate Mortgages. “ 4th. Government Bonds. “ 5th. State Bonds. “ 6th. High-grade Stocks. “ It requires very little skill or judgment to buy the first, for they may be said to be generally safe. The courts of the country have very carefully guarded the credit of our municipalities, and where they are offered by a reputable bond house, which has made a proper examination, such as most of them make, you are very safe in their purchase. The second (first mortgage corporation bonds) requires more care and a study of 64 A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. the property mortgaged. They should not be bought of any but first-class houses, and you should know that the property is not over-mortgaged, that the corporation is a sound one, and that its earnings are sufficient to pay its operating expenses, the interest on its bonds, and a fair margin over. The character of the business in which the corporation is engaged is also well worth considering. The third requires the skill and experience of a good real estate man. The fourth requires no skill, simply money. The fifth calls for a study of the present debt and past history of the state. The sixth requires careful study of the corporation, and the advice of an honest broker.” In this pleasant and instructive manner the weeks sped by. Two evenings of each week our lawyer- financier was sure to be found at the Allen homestead. The acquaintance ripened into intimacy and then into warm friendship. The lessons continued, interspersed with an occasional examination and music. At last the subject of finance as a reason for calling was exhausted, for the sisters had really mastered the subject, or at least knew enough so that there was no fear of their losing their money. When it became evident that they needed no more training, he began to read to them from his favorite authors. Of course the neighbors shook their heads, looked knowingly at A FINANCIAL COURTSHIP. 65 each other and said, “Well, did you ever?” etc., but Mr. Stanley pursued the even tenor of his way undisturbed. One morning in June, Mary came up behind her sister’s chair so that the older girl could not see her face and said: “Hannah, do you remember the day after father died when we were wishing we had some man in the family to whom we could go for advice ? ” “ Yes, very well.” “We’re going to have one.” “Mary, what do you mean?” and Hannah sprang to her feet and looked at her sister. One glance at the glistening eyes and flushed cheeks told the story; she threw her arms around Mary’s neck, and there was sobbing with the little half-articulated cries and kisses that women love. POSTSCRIPTUM When I had finished this little story, some friend who glanced it over said, “ Well, what did they finally put their money into ? ” I think this is a fair question, and I will tell you confidentially what they did. The reason I did not include it in the story was because New England women hate to have any one know about their affairs. With Mr. Stanley’s advice, they invested their money as follows: They placed $2,000 in the local savings banks ($1,000 in each) at 3£ per cent, per annum, in order that they might have a little money at hand in case of urgent need. $5,000 was placed on a local mortgage at 5 per cent., upon property well known to all of them. $5,000 was placed in City of Chicago, Ill., 4 per cent, bonds at a price to net 3.80 per cent, per annum. $5,000 was placed in the 4 per cent, bonds of their town at a price to net 3.65 per cent, per annum. $5,000 was placed in the 3J per cent, bonds of the City of New York at par, netting 3J per cent, per annum. POSTSCRIPT UM. 67 $5,000 was placed in the 4£ per cent, bonds of a Washington school district at a price to net 4£ per cent, per annum. $5,000 was placed in the 4£ per cent, bonds of a Colorado school district at a price to net 4J per cent, per annum. $5,000 was placed in the 5 per cent, first mortgage bonds of an electric light and gas company of one of our large western cities, at par, netting 5 per cent, per annum. $5,000 was placed in the 5 percent, first mortgage bonds of a strong interurban electric railway at par, netting 5 per cent, per annum. $2,000 was placed in the 3 per cent, bonds of the United States government at a price to net 1.90 per cent, per annum. $5,000 was placed in the 5 per cent, bonds of the Chicago Junction Railways & Union Stock Yards of Chicago at a price to net 4 per cent, per annum. I have listed the whole investment in a little table below, where it will be perhaps more clearly under¬ stood. You will see that the investments are distrib¬ uted over deposits in savings banks, first mortgages on real estate, municipal bonds, school bonds, first mort¬ gage corporation bonds and United States government bonds. The total amount invested was $49,974, leav- 68 POSTSCRIPTUM. ing a small balance of cash in their hands. The total income from the investment per annum was $2,155, or an average of about 4J per cent, upon their principal. Two girls, living quietly at home, ought to be able to save money on this income, and thus add to their principal. The United States government bonds were included in the $50,000 purchase more as a matter of sentiment, for they could have invested their money to pay much better, but the sisters thought, as a matter of patriotism, they would like to have a few of the government bonds. Par valine. Rate. Cost. Income. $2,000 Deposited in banks, 34 % $2,000 $70 5,000 Mortgage, 3% 5,000 250 5,000 City of Chicago, Ill., bonds, 4% 5,100 200 5,000 Local bonds, 4 % 5,125 200 5,000 City of New York, 34 % 5,000 175 5,000 A Washington school district, 44 % 5,162 225 5,000 A Colorado school district, 44 % 5,137 225 5,000 A western electric light and gas co., 3% 5,000 250 5,000 An interurban railway 5% bond, 5% 5,000 250 2,000 United States government, 3% 2,050 60 5,000 Chic. Junct. Rys. & Union Stock Yds., 5% 5,400 250 $49,000 $49,974 $2,155 Average income about 4.25%.