tifnr!!*;'-;'r-c;.f>. --^^^ THE PRIVATE JOURNAL OF AARON BURR, DURING HIS RESIDENCE OF FOUR YEARS IN EUROPE; WITH SELECTIONS FROM HIS CORRESPONDENCE. EDITED BY MATTHEW L. DAVIS, AUTHOR OF " MEMOIRS OF AARON BURR," &C. IN TWO VOLUMES. V O L. I. NEW-YORK: HARPER & BROTHERS, CLIFF-STREET. 18 38. Entered, according to Act of Congress, in the year 1838, by MjTTHEW L. Davis in the Clerk's Office of the Southern Diat.'ict oi iVew Vtiik. VALE I PREFACE. Thf. following brief correspondence requires no explana tion. The incident referred to merits record. It would have been related in his Memoirs if Colonel Burr had not forbidden its publication without accompanying evidence of the fact. That evidence has but recently been procured by the editor of these volumes, and it is now given. TO THE REV. GARDNER SPRING. Rev. Sir — There is an anecdote respecting Colonel Burr, worthy, in my opinion, a place on the page of our revolu tionary history. I should have published it if I had pos sessed any other evidence of its correctness than what was derived from Colonel Burr's own statement ; but, without I could obtain that evidence, it was his wish that I should sup press it in the Memoirs of his Life that I was preparing for publication. I refer to the manner in which the body of General Montgomery (after his fall on the moming of the 31st December, 1775) was rescued from the British troops and conveyed to the American camp. Your father, the late Rev. Samuel Spring, accompanied General Arnold in his perilous expedition through the wil derness in the autumn of 177-5. On the fatal morning refer red to he was with the arniy on the Plains of Abram, and witnessed the melancholy result of the attack upon Quebec. May I be permitted to ask you, Rev. Sir, whether he did at any time inform you how the body of General Montgomery came into the possession of the American troops ? If yea, A2 IV PREFACE. when did he make the communication ? And under what circumstances ? I am unwilling to give you much trouble ; but as the incident relates to a most interesting crisis in the history of our revolutionary struggles, you will, I trust, par don me when I add that any details which you may be pleased to give will confei a favour on. Rev. Sir, Yours respectfully, M. L. Davis. RET. GARDNER SPRING TO M. L. DAVIS. New-York, Brick-church Chapel, October 24, 1838. G. Spring's compliments to Mr. Davis, with a hasty reply lo his note of yesteriay. The facts in relation to my venerable father's interview with Colonel Burr are just as I stated them to you at Sara toga. The last visit my father made me, he expressed a great anxiety to see Colonel Burr. I objected, and told him Burr had lost caste, and it was reputable neither to him nor myself to call on him. For two or three days he relinquished the design of ma king the call. But on an afternoon just before he left us, he said to me, " My son, I must see Burr before I leave the city. I went through the woods with him under Arnold. I stood by his side on the Plains of Abram, and I have not seen him since the morning on which Montgomery fell. It was a heavy snowstorm. Montgomery had fallen. The British troops were advancing towards the dead body ; and little Burr was hastening from the fire of the enemy, up to his knees in snow, with Montgomery's body on his shoul ders ! Do you wonder I wish to see him ?" I conducted my father to Col. Burr's office, and we sub sequently spent part of an evening together at my house in Beekraan-street. My father was a volunteer chaplain un der Arnold, and, being friends at college, he and Burr were much together during that fearful campaign. G. Spring. PREFACE. V In presenting to the public the ensuing Journal of the late Aaron Burr, the editor is not aware that he is, in the least d'Ogree, violating the wishes of its author, far less that he is infringing any of the restrictions of proper reserve. The journal was originally, indeed, intended only for Mrs. Alston, the daughter of Col. Burr. But, after the lamented death of this lady, the journal was carefully preserved by her father, and committed, with his correspondence, to the edi tor, with unlimited license of publication. It may, then, be truly said that it is published with the assent of its author ; and it is believed to be sufficiently curious, and indicative of the character of an extraordinary man, to warrant its pub lication from general considerations. The journal, it will be seen, changes its character during its progress. At first it seems to have been merely a few careless and rough notes of his travels ; but it gradually became more expanded and minute, as time grew heavy on his hands, until, especially during his residence in Paris and his second sojourn in England, it became a faithful tran script of his daily life. There are chasms in the journal which the editor has been unable, in any extent, to supply from the contempo raneous correspondence of the author; and these deficiencies are the more to be regretted, as the periods of time of which the record is thus omitted are those which would have been highly interesting to the reader. The first serious omission will be found in the commencement of his diary, when he first arrived in England, ardent in his plans of engaging the British government in the emancipation of Mexico from Spain, and when his negotiations with the ministry were frequent, and not without hope. The second chasm occurs when, having been compulsorily detaiiied in Paris for more than a year, deserted by almost every friend, without letters, and almost without hope of release, he was unexpectedly relieved by the Duke of Bassano. How this successful and efTective interference was obtained, we are not informed by VI PREFACE. his diary. It was undoubtedly through the aid of Denon, the celebrated traveller. We know, from other sources, that the conduct of the Duke of Bassano was most generous ; not limited to what alone Col. Burr had, for more than a year, in vain requested, a relaxation of the tyrannical refusal of his passports, but accompanied by a loan of money, which enabled him to leave France free from debt, except to his noble and disinterested benefactor. This was, however, the only occurrence during his long stay in Paris which called for gratitude. From the moment of his arrival in France to his departure in the Vigilant, he experienced from the government unmitigated discountenance and severity, and from Frenchmen utter neglect and inhospitality. He whose life, from the time he had first been their companion in arms (as he remarked in his memorial to Napoleon), had been de voted to kindness and hospitality to Frenchmen ! Besides the hiatus in the journal above alluded to, the editor deems it proper to state that he has suppressed cer tain parts. As the journal is now shown, it will probably surprise the reader that a father should write and preserve such a record for his daughter. It must be remembered, however, that the perfect unreservedness with which the author of the diary wrote to his daughter was part of the system, be it erroneous or not, on which her education and their intercourse had been conducted. It was his theory, as will partly appear from the journal itself, that female edu cation should in no respect differ from that of young men ; and that, between parent and child, there should be the same frankness and candour of demeanour and conversation as be tween two friends of equal age. The theory may have been most unfounded ; and yet he may be excused for adhering to it, when he saw before him, produced by it, or in spite of it, such a model of purity, intelligence, and loveliness as Theodosia Burr Alston. The editor anticipates criticisms on the journal for its ab sence of political and general remark, and the apparently PREFACE. Vll unimportant incidents which it records. By some it will, perhaps, be thought that it exhibits only laborious trifling, " operose nihil agendo." There are some considerations which may be submitted to obviate such remarks. Il is very evident, in the first place, that the absence of all political observations in this journal is the result of systematic reso lution. The journal, in its early and careless stages, and in free and constitutional England, had been seized by order of the ministry ; and on the Continent, from Mr. Burr's arrival in Hamburgh till his embarcation from the Holder, he must have been daily and hourly sensible of the all-pervading vigilance and power of the French police. The journal shows, by its very reserve, not that its author did not ob serve, but that he knew too well that Napoleon was em peror, and Fouche had but just ceased to be his minister. It should also be borne in mind that the diary was in tended only as a memorandum for conversation with his daughter on his return to America. He repeatedly mentions this in his notes. The idea of publication certainly never occurred to him. If in its later portions it became more like a regular narrative, it was because the periods it then re cords were those in which his detention in France by the government, and in England by absolute want of money, left him no occupation and no amusement but that of writing to that beloved daughter, who, during her four years' absence from his society, seems lo have been scarcely one moment absent from his thoughts. Why, then, it may be asked, is this journal published ? Because, unless the editor deceives himself, unambitious as it is, it will amuse the reader ; because it illustrates the character of a distinguished man, whose influence has been felt in his country's fortunes, and whose name will live in her history ; and because the character illustrated is amia ble, interesting, and not without instruction to the observer. This man of dark intrigue and remorseless design, as it has pleased politicians and reviewers, clerical and lay, to repre- VIU PREFACE. sent him, is here shown in an artless auto-biographic narra tive, which could not he feigned, to have been one of the most amiable and playful of men ; like the little children whom he so remarkably and characteristically loved, he was pleased with the slightest incidents,-lively and happy in the humblest circumstances, and incapable of harbouring a last ing resentment. Few of the readers of this journal will peruse the cold-blooded insults and injuries which he re ceived in France from the representatives of the United States without feeling a more intense indignation than seems to have been excited in him who was the sufferer by them. And in the uncomplaining constancy and unabating cheerfulness under the most trying circumstances, which never for a moment forsook him during his long and dreary detention in miserable lodgings in Paris, without a friend or correspondent, and with only indefinite restrictions and pri vations in prospect ; nor in his obscure garret in London, with impending starvation before him. Let those who may object to the absence of philosophic remark in the following pages answer whether, in such exhibitions of temper and control of mind, there was not the highest and most admira ble philosophy ? THE EDITOR. New-York, November 15, 1838. PRIVATE JOURNAL, &c. On the 5lh of August, 1807, the trial of Colonel Burr for treason commenced at Richmond, Virginia, Judge Marshall presiding. On the 1st of September the jury returned a verdict of not guilty. On the 9th of September another jury was empannelled to try him on an indictment for mis demeanor. In this case, as in the former, the jury pro nounced a verdict of not guilty. Colonel Burr remained in Richmond until the month of December, making preparatory arrangements for a voyage to England, with the view of inducing the British ministry to aid him in his project of revolutionizing Mexico. As early as the 8th of October, 1807, he stated to Blennerhassett that " he was preparing to go to England ; that the time was now auspicious for him," &c.* During February and March, 1808, Colonel Burr was in Baltimore, and from thence came to the city of New-York in April. Here he remained for a few days incognito. He then passed over to the country-seat of the late Peter Kem- ble, Esq., in the neighbourhood of Belleville, New-Jersey. In the latter part of May he returned to New- York, and remained at the house of a friend until his departure for England, via Halifax, in the British packet. His last inter view with his daughter Theodosia was on the evening of his embarcation, at the house of Mrs. Pollock. They never again met. On the 1st of June, 1808, he commences keeping a diary. It consisted at first of a very few and brief memoranda, but gradually swelled into a copious narrative of his life. It is * See Memoirs of Aaron Burr, vol. ii., page 398. A 3 10 PRIVATE JOURNAL to be regretted that the earlier period of his European trav els, when sanguine of success in his schemes, and when he was unremitted in his negotiations, or attempts to negotiate with the British ministry, is the least minutely recorded. Chasms of days and weeks occur in his early memoranda ; and, where he has left any written record, it is very concise and obscure. The best mode of supplying these deficien cies will be to give, in connexion with what is found of his diary, such letters as he preserved copies of, particularly those to his daughter, Theodosia B. Alston. It must be borne in mind, that at the time the journal com mences he was in the city of New- York or its vicinity, en gaged in preparations for his journey, and preserving a strict incognito. The letters, &c., referred to will make it stri kingly appear how great importance he attached to this in cognito, and the pains he took, particularly on his departure from and on his return to America, to shroud himself in mystery. Doubtless this partly proceeded from the love of concealment which formed so marked a trait in his charac ter, and was not required to the extent to which he carried it by the circumstances of his situation ; but it is equally certain that, at the time when the following journal com menced, he would have been greatly embarrassed had his plans or even his residence been known. Extracts from Letters to Theodosia. Dates not given. Supposed to he previous to \st June, 1808. That we may not clash in our communications, I submit to your perusal a letter just written lo H. N. Seal and for ward it. It is probable that he would, within a few months, have known of the friend there spoken of, and it was, there fore, best to let it come from me or you. The water con veyance is to be preferred, and if to Charleston, under cover to Charles Kershaw, with a line. Another parcel of papers is herewith sent, for the pur poses before mentioned of former deposiies. OP AARON BURR. 11 H. has sounded his friend, and, finding all right, has put him in full communion. This circumstance, the longer knowledge of the slate of your health, and the receipt of three letters for important personages, indemnify me for my share of the vexation, and the loss of time and money on a late occasion. Perhaps more good may arise from it. Did you talk to E. W. L. about C. ? What course will he take ? He (E. W. L.) must co-operate wiih us, or great mischief may ensue. Your parcel, written yesterday, with a note acknowledg ing the receipt of mine, has come in at two P. M. I shall not commit violence on Miss G. nor a burglary on the house of her uncle. The letter will be sent with a written mes sage containing my address. After which, I stand on the defensive. The newspaper which you intended to enclose was for gotten. Have no apprehension about the orders I may draw on you. Ask Dr. Eustis his charge, and say that you will forward it to Mr. Alston. Don't waste the money or his labour by reserve or concealment. I don't think he will take any thing. English papers, this day arrived, say that Mr. Armstrong had been ordered to leave Paris, and had arrived in London, intimating thereby a war between France and the United States, which I believe to be all a stock-jobbing lie. I have paid S. his dollar, and will pay you twelve. Be assured that the one hundred and sixty barrels of rice will arrive in the Mary Ann, subject to your orders ; and then you'll be rich. J. K. B. is a young gentleman of great fortune, of no oc cupation, of good character and connexions, and of great civility of manner. I do not know either P. or P. even by reputation. No doubt, however, they would be very suita ble acquaintances. Inquire when on the spot. I always " turn over" — " nocturna versate manu." la PRIVATE JOURNAL The afFection of the nerves arises wholly from the disease, and can only be cured by removing those diseases. All nervous medicines, unless for momentary relief, are quack ery and nonsense. The spring waters of Ballston or Sara toga are the best ; the only tonic which performs at once the double cure. Have faith, and you shall be saved ; but not without good works — meaning, thereby, the persevering use of means. Heighho ! news just come in that the packet does not go till Thursday. Things seem to be well arranged. All attempts at interview must be abandoned for this night, at least. To-morrow we will see. The depositions of Bayard and Smith* may be shown without any reserve. There is no delicacy connected with them. Be sure you get the right ones ; not their first depo sitions, unless, indeed, both sets be shown or published to gether ; but that would be too voluminous. There is no ob jection even to the publication. It is a mere point of policy. If published, it ought to be accompanied by remarks from Aristides.i Talk to him of it. Your old young beau and swain, J. V. N. Y., could do it, either in prose or verse. Mr. G., who negotiates with C, says he is now all milk and honey. The affronted neighbours can be appeased at any time in half a minute. It is not now worth while ; make no efibrt, except for X. The S.'s are fools by inherit ance of five generations. What you say about changes is very true. The wonder is that you did not discover it sooner. What courteous friends ! I wish yoU two hundred miles off; and you, in revenge, wish me three thousand miles off — " Leplus loin, le plus serreT You may make H. prescribe a sea voyage. I should feel confident of everything — " te numine." What a long letter. I wish you were off. A. Burr. * See Memoirs of A. Burr, vol. ii., page 122. t The late Judge WiUiam P. Van Ness. OP AARON BURR. 13 TO THEODOSIA. Order Dr. Hosack to be with you this evening. I forgot to remind you of Anabelle Shedden. You ought, in one line to E. A., to acknowledge the interest she has taken in the question of tutor. You may also say that Bab., having been formally and earnestly applied to, both by you and me, you cannot, with propriety, apply to another. Acknowledge, also, that the defects of his character form no serious ob jection to his office of tutor to A. B. A., and that his knowl edge of the Spanish language more than atones for many defects. If you should be directed to write to Julien, sign Mary Anne Meville, and let him know that you are the daughter of George Meville. I never travel without giving to my confidential servant or attendant directions for the disposition of my papers, clothes, &c., in case of sudden death. Do you the same. Sam will be your agent, and F. your depository. My letters to you will be often in a strange handwriting, and with various signatures. Sometimes feminine. Godwin's Enquirer. His life of Chaucer, also, has much on language. It is, indeed, rather a history of the English language than of the poet. Make your list of books, or rather of subjects. If you should have a newspaper containing a letter from B. to Gov. Williams, February, 1807, send it to me; but don't hunt for it yourself. Tell Sam to engage the carriage for this evening. I do not yet know the hour or place of meeting. You will hear before nine. My baggage will go in the packet, myself in the schooner. Ask Mrs. P., with suitable apologies, to write her friend H. a line to the following effect : " My friend, Mr. Edwards, who has a letter of introduc tion from me to you, has sent part of his baggage to your care ; lest it might arrive before him, be pleased to take charge of it till his arrival." 14 PRIVATE JOURNAL What is the Christian name of Mrs. P. ? I send you a letter of R. R., that you may see the goodness of herself and cousin. How are you ? A. Burr. TO THEODOSIA. There is dignity and fortitude in your letter. Need it be added that I am charmed with it ? We had come to the same conclusion by sympathy. A long letter was sent in quest of you a few minutes "ago. It will, probably, not find you till late. C. has just come in. I rejoice to see him. T.'s letter shall be reviewed and returned to-morrow. The swelling is a mere indication of the weak and slug gish stale of the vessels. One week at Saratoga will carry it off. I think your departure should not be deferred more than one day, so that you may hear, &c. Conjecture may carry me with you. A. Burr. TO THEODOSIA. My dear T., the weather is so inauspicious that I tremble at the thought of the enterprise you are about to undertake. If the " turn" is such as I suppose, a cold night prove fatal. Let us hazard nothing for the gratification of our feelings. You will have yet some hours to make minutes or notes of all you have to say or ask. That you may be more in the way of sending to me, suppose you should go and pass the day at Robert Swartwoul's ; no, there again you might be exposed during the transit. Stay at home, and write and send Sam as your postboy. If we should not meet to-day, I shall write something, in which I shall speak of you in the third person, under the name of Anne, and will be designated by H — n. Express to Mrs. P., if you can, all my gratitude and afFection. Tell me something more of Miss Grattan — her age and pretensions. Is she daughter, or any way related to the Irish orator ? Since writing the above the weather has become clear. OP AARON BURR. 15 I submit the propriety of your expedition to yourself and O. ; but if the " turn" be as I hope, there will be hazard, and there ought to be none. A. Burr. TO THEODOSIA. " Tuesday night ;'' and why did you not write me on Wednesday morning ? The captain's I ihink safer than L. I will be there at ten. You may go when and how he and you may agree, and with or without your little girl. I have for some time been apprehensive that you had rheumatic affections. The symptoms you describe may be of that character, but more probably are some of that infi nite variety of spasmodic and nervous affections which are the invariable companions of extreme debility ; whichever it may be, the waters will cure ; for every species of rheu matism, they are infallible. Before leaving town, which ought not to be till Friday, write E. W. L., requesting that he would call now and then on Saltus, to know and advise you when any remit tance may be received for you, and how to draw for it. We shall have only one hour together. You say that my note by T. was received,