YALE UNIVERSI1 9002 05366 7953 15% YALE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY The Athletic Games and their Effect on Greek Art A LECTURE DELIVERED IN THE SHEFFIELD SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL MECHANICS' COORSE NEW HAVEN, FEBRUARY 1 7, 1 893 BY J. M. HOPPIN ProlesBor of the History of Art in Tale University THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART. The chief interest attached to the athletic games of the Greeks is the influence they had to foster the heroic spirit, proving not only that it was a heroic nation that established them, but that .they tended to make the nation heroic. The heroic element shows itself very early iri Greek art and literature, yet is hardly ever without certain childish features and accompaniments that are, indeed, to be found in the sagas of all Oriental races, Indian, Hebrew and Ara bian, as well as Greek, and which is an evidence of the simplicity of the poems of earlier nations. Even the Homeric heroes, as critics have noted, exhibit traits of weakness, and they were not all of them anxious to go to the big wars and tried hard to bribe Agamemnon to except them from military service, the wily Odysseus feigning madness to escape the draft; but his device was detected and he finally joined the army with an effective contingent. When the Trojans got among the ships of the allies, the Greeks cried like children because they fancied that they were fated to destruction; and this sensitiveness in regard to death, which the heroes nevertheless fearlessly met, is manifested in the scene where the inspired horses of Achilles, shedding tears as if human, foretold his early doom. The heroic Greek character was crystalized in the strong Doric race and type; but, singularly enough for a Greek, Xenophaiies of Colophon, the founder of the Eleatic school of philosophy, decries heroic quali- THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND ties and the athletic games; and he says: "Whoever wins in a foot race, boxing, wrestling or chariot race, receives all kinds of honors, precedence at festivals, a purse of money and public support. This is his reward, even if the horses have done it. Yet he is of less valor than I; my wisdom is better than the strength of horses or men. All this is foolish; it is not proper to prefer strength to wisdom. Of what use is all this physical skill? It secures no better govern ment, and the delight of winning a contest is a brief one, in no way helping to fill the granaries of a city." The vigorous life which sprung up after the first Persian wars gave an additional impulse to the ath letic games, as tending to keep alive the heroic spirit that had been kindled in the strife of a small but free people against innumerable foes combined by a cohe sive rather than organic unity, and urged to a com pelled valor, whereas the heroic spirit is bred from a deeper race-principle; as, for example, Sir Philip Sid ney was a courtier and poet, spending much of his time in composing euphuistic phrases and ' ' rustical roundelays ' ' in praise of Queen Elizabeth, and yet he lived a perfectly heroic life ; and Gen. Gordon, it is said, was more like a quiet citizen than a soldier in appearance and habits, who, nevertheless, was a hero if such ever existed ; but the Greeks found one of the chief means of nourishing and perpetuating this spirit in the agonistic games, recognizing the truth that all strength comes through struggle. The great athletic games were held every four years at Olympia in Elis, during the month of the sacred truce, and they constituted, perhaps, more than any thing else, the symbol and realization of Hellenic unity. THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 5 The wonderful scene which presented itself to the eye at one of those great Olympic festivals, was that of a whole nation met for an inspiring and joyful purpose; and it offered just "that mixture of uniformity and variety most stimulating to the observant faculties of a man of genius," who, at the same time if he sought to communicate his impressions or to act upon this mingled audience — composed of such diverse charac ters — soldiers, legislators, orators, writers, poets, sailors, wealthy men and vine dressers, princes and demagogues — he was forced to shake off what was peculiar to himself and to his little town and com- munit}', and to put forth matters' in harmony with the feelings of all, and in this /way mutual interest and competition was'excited, and thehuman element came into Greek life' and. drama, and was the most important feature of Greek art and the secret of its expression, variety and power. In the vast crowd of spectators brought together from every part of Greece and her remotest colonies — from swarthy African Cyrene to the borders of snowy Scythia — do you think that the artist was not there ? Do you think that he neglected such an opportunity to study human nature ? And the contests themselves were not confined to simple athletism, but were combined with philoso phy, history, the drama, music and sculpture; and the wreaths of wild parsley, olive and pine showed the essentially heroic character of the games appeal ing to an ideal motive, while the combats of youths in the palizstra, stimulated by ancestral heroic tradi tion, served to build up a splendid manhood; and yet after a time, and almost of necessity, there came about a degeneration of the sports, and the professional athlete made his appearance on the scene, who was THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND not regarded with the highest respect, since the Greeks did not glory in mere brawn and muscle. The forms represented in Greek heroic sculpture prove that they were not of men who made a busi ness of being athletes, but of the noblest youth; there is in them the light and grace of something more than physical power, for, though the statues of Greek athletes betoken a marvelous development of physical strength, compared with which Michael Angelo's mod els were porters and draymen, they manifest muscular force combined with fineness of proportion, and a beauty and nobility that show the sincere but uncon scious enthusiasm for honorable things which belongs to a youth who might have gone from the most excit ing race that strained every nerve, or the most violent wrestling match, to sit at the feet of Plato. Yet it is to be noticed, as proving the finer charac ter or training of the Greeks, that even in the profes sional athlete and gladiator of later Roman times, the Greeks still showed the touch of a superior race, as illustrated in what Plutarch relates of the sanguinary athletic exhibitions in his day, that at the last ban quet which was commonly given to those who were about to die, while Roman and Thracian gladiators gave way to excessive feasting, the Greeks spent the precious moments in taking leave of their families and giving advice to those who would hear them no more. Athletic training in Greece, it should be remarked, aimed at the development of power combined with harmony of action; and the athlete exercised himself not only in the arena but in the choruses of singing and processional dances, that induced rhythmic grace, and for this purpose music of the flute, harp and lyre contributed to bring his nature into agreement with THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART musical measure and tone, which, combined with the study of rhetoric and philosophy, produced, in its best examples, the result of the heroic spirit, beauti ful action and noble thought. The life evidenced the training, and there are, indeed, relations that nature has established between the body and mind, a myste rious interdependence of the faculties, that cannot be overlooked if broad and healthful intellectual results are to be sought for, so that even the reign of intellect - ualism is a short one which neglects those bodily con ditions under which it can only exist at its best ; and I think, therefore, that the gymnastic training in our universities might derive, through the study of Greek sculpture and the methods and discipline of the Greek gymnasia, much valuable aid, and that, by this, the athletic training of the university would tend to become more earnestly practiced and more gener ally diffused, and it would be regarded as an element of education, or as forming a part of that culture which would modify and enlarge the whole system. In order rightly to understand the Greek athletic games and their influence on art, we must go behind the games to the gymnasia. The gymnasia (from gumnos, naked) were the local training schools for the great games; but the gymnasia belonged to the sys tem of education of which Greek philosophy, lit erature and • art formed the consummate flower. Education was held to be the most important of the state's functions, so that Aristotle laid down the principle that the state was justly compelled to assume its control, and that any occupation, art or science which rendered the body or soul of the free man less fit for the practice of virtue, should be pro hibited as vulgar; wherefore all arts and occupations that have an influence to deform the body or the mind THE A THLETIC GAMES AND were not only not to be encouraged, but forbidden ; since it must be confessed, that the Greeks, for free citizens of democratic communities, were, in many respects, rank aristocrats, and they held a lower opinion of honest work than we do, or than is just and right, esteeming manual labor fit only for slaves, which sentiment, with other similar ideas, finally brought about the overthrow of Athens and Greece; but should we judge this bright and noble nation too harshly, and refuse to learn from them what was really beautiful in their life and example ? And (to make a little digression from our theme) the mention of work recalls an odd episode that Oscar Wilde once related in a lecture given in New Haven many years ago, of Mr. Ruskin's heading a company of Oxford students to dig a new road in the neighbor hood of the university, showing that the great art- teacher and his scholars were not afraid of soiling their hands by work; and, in the same lecture, some here may remember, with me, that the speaker prom ised to give the statue of an athlete to Yale ; and perhaps it would be a good thing to remind the dis tinguished gentleman of his promise, so that a copy of the ' Apoxyomenos, ' or of some other fine statue, might be set up in the vestibule of our gymnasium. Aristotle likewise said that ' ' gymnastic exercises tended to infuse courage, while drawing and art were fitted to make pupils judges of the beautiful ; for to be always seeking the useful does not become free souls." The gymnasia might be called the universities of Greece, and they exerted a direct influence on the art of Greece, because there was in them just this ming ling of the physical and intellectual; and springing as they did from the needs of the state to train young THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 9 men for civic virtue and for war, that demanded the best disciplined strength (as in those warring com munities to exist was to contend), it came about in a natural way that the whole man received discipline, and even the highest, for these contests had a higher side, because, since they were held to be instituted by heroes and demi-gods, no one could contend in the games who had disgraced himself by a dishonorable act or been guilty of sacrilege. The games were, in fact, a part of popular education, and formed, as it were, its summit ; and education was not a creature of accident, fashion or custom, since the Greeks believed in compulsory education, and thought that it could not be left to loose ends; for Greek edu cation, whatever it was, was not superficial; and while it doubtless had its faults, it was founded on a philosophical basis, or on the nurture of the soul as a living organism that was contained in a body which needed careful training. The passions were to be regulated but not repressed; and even in nature, the higher element, the spirit, was to be cultivated; and this cultivation of the spirit was the work of the gym nasium, as Plato remarked, that a man could be best judged by the manner in which he bore himself in the gymnasium — meaning probably his patience, self- collectedness and courage. The true object was self- training. This was that hard element {res severa) of human nature, which, if rightly nourished, becomes bravery, but if exclusively encouraged, degenerates into brutality. Then followed the culture of the imagination and tastes, and, above all, of the rational soul, which needs philosophy. The three great divisions of Greek education were "Gymnastic," "Music," and "Philosophy;" and io THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND ' ' Gymnastic ' ' was by no means considered to be the least of these, for though it was bodily training it was not to end in the body but the soul, in a spiritual discipline which made a man hardy, self-centred, gifted with andreia (manliness), another name for the perfection of all the powers, and the full development of mind and body. This made the heroic man. It was inward more than outward, but it was the outward in combination with the spirit and acting upon it. At first gymnastic exercises were held wherever there was convenient open ground; but as they acquired more importance the state provided places and erected buildings, and as these required room, the gymnasium usually covered a large area; and Athens had three such great training schools — the Kynosarges, the I^ykeion and the Akademeia, of which the last, situated in a dell and surrounded by a grove was a resort of the best citizens. Indeed, the spaces devoted to the gymnasia were of such size that the whole arms-bearing population of the city could exercise in them. In the special building, or gymna sium proper, parts of it were used for dressing rooms, and for anointing the body with oil and sanding it, and for cleansing the body with the ' strigil;' and other chambers were employed for cold and hot baths, fires and lodgings. To these were added porticoes for the assemblage and conversation of the Ephebi, colon nades and halls, walks, gardens and copses of trees; and, as the gymnasium was dedicated to some divinity, altars, statues and religious symbolic adornments were not wanting. The exercises of the Greek gymnasium were quite simple when compared with the modern elaborate sys tem, or, we might say, with that of our own complete and noble gymnasium, and consisted, originally, ol THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART n the Pentathlon, or five contests — to which the horse race and other contests were afterwards added. The Pentathlon, in a word, was made up of the combined exercises of running, leaping, throwing the javelin, casting the diskos and wrestling with boxing; though running or the foot race {diaulos) in which the stadium was traversed twice, seems to have been the principal of the sports, and the Greeks carried it to an astonishing pitch of perfection. The course was usually of deep sand, where the foot took no firm hold, and the runners were naked, but sometimes were armed in complete armor, or, it might be, with shield and helm only. ' ' The length of a long course was 24 stadia (about three miles), and that the runners who were trained for special emergencies were of extraordinary speed and endurance is shown by the story of the Plataean Euchidas, who on being sent after the battle of Sala- mis to fetch fire from Apollo's altar, made in one day the distance between Platsea and Delphi and back — a thousand stadia (about 100 miles) — but the exertion cost him his life." The exercise of leaping, both the high and distant leap, was practiced by the simple spring of the mus cles, though sometimes weights {halteres) were held in the hand and swung to gi-ve impetus. The javelin sport consisted in the flinging of a light lance covered with a thong to make it revolve, and both accuracy and distance were striven for. Casting the diskos was of very ancient date, as Homer teaches. The diskos was a heavy circular plate of bronze or iron, about eight inches in diameter, which was grasped by the whole hand, and swung round to give it a rotary motion. Before the throw it was carried in the left hand so as not to tire the THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND right ; and both positions are illustrated in the two well-known statues of the Diskoboloi. Wrestling was developed to an art; and the victory did not depend on strength alone; there were rules, sleights and advantages of various kinds in which the wrestler was instructed, so that scientific skill not seldom bore off the prize from sheer strength, as was magnificently illustrated in modern athletism, I may be excused for saying, by the last boat race at New Dondon between Yale and Harvard. If gymnastics were universal in Greece so also was the enthusiasm felt in these contests, which were regarded as national affairs, and at which every free man of Hellenic blood had a birthright to be present and to participate in them. I ask you to consider what an immense effect these games must have had on the art of sculpture, and what a concentration of popular sentiment was brought to bear on them. That the sculptor made use of the study of the nude of which the games afforded oppor tunity, numberless Greek statues and bas-reliefs of heroes, fighters and victors testify, in which there is a force, a technique, a close imitation of nature, a free dom of composition, a truth without exaggeration or violence in the rendering of the muscular system, a beauty springing from full and exact knowledge, which could only come from daily, yearly, life-long sight and study, and an actual mingling in the con tests themselves where every power was tried, every muscle developed and every energetic and beautiful attitude that the human frame is capable of, was pre sented in more bald and varied forms than in Michael Angelo's famous cartoon of the " Battle of Pisa." I fear we can never have such sculptors again, certainly not without a revival of a system similar to that which THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 13 produced them; though, indeed, it is said that in the wrestling matches on the village green in Cumber- landshire, England, fine models for the sculptor may yet be found, because athletic sports have been kept up for centuries by a hardy mountaineer race. But our sculptors copy from the Greeks while their sculp tors copied from nature; and they had models as nearly perfect as humanity, perhaps, ever afforded. Eooked at artistically, the main effect of the public games upon sculpture was in the opportunity presented for artistic study of the human form; and I have translated a short passage bearing on this from the French of Duval on ' art-anatomy.' " There would seem to be," he says, " a contradic tion between these two facts, viz : that while Greek artists have on their part shown in their works the most vigorous anatomical exactitude, on the other hand neither they nor their contemporaries, the phy sicians, studied anatomy by dissection. But this con tradiction disappears when one examines the con ditions whereby artists were permitted to have incessantly under their eyes the human form in move ment, which set them to analyze these forms, and to acquire, through the mechanism of their active changes, empirical ideas as precise as those demanded to-day by the scientific study of physiology. The artist was privileged to study his model before exercising, while anointing himself; then during the course, or leap, which showed the muscles of the lower limbs; then at the play of the diskos which brought in relief the contractions of the great deltoid muscles of the shoulder; and during the wrestle, which success ively, according to the numberless variety of efforts, threw into play all the muscular system. Why need we be astonished that when antique life was given up, J4 THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND images deprived of the movement of life, and that sat isfied the religious sentiment only, succeeded those reproductions of the man in action, those statues which inspire the beholder with the force and beauty drawn from the living plastique of the Greek gym nast ? In point of fact, the decadence of the art of sculpture proceeds parallel with the abandonment of gymnastic exercises; later, in the Middle Ages, art returns to the producing of sculptures without living force, which however, express the mystic aspirations of the epoch, but have nothing in common with the real representation of the human form well developed and active." It is a valuable idea for the student of art to obtain that Greek sculpture was a genuine product of the national mind, and that it had an object which called it into being and dignified it ; that it was to set forth real deeds, and was commemorative of actual struggle and caught the breath of popular life. A statue was not made, as nowadays, to be put in a palace or museum and admired as a work of art, but it carved a man in full life, as like him as could be and be beautiful, and bade it live with the spirit which in spired him and his act. Thus alone sculpture could be great and have a purpose which was vital, nay, religious, springing from man's deepest impulse. Greek sculpture was stimulated by the athletic games, not only from the fact that artists had a chance to study the human frame and compare form with form, thus idealizing the forms of gods who pre sented the sum of perfection, but that the greatest sculptors were employed to make statues of victors to be placed in the Altis, or sacred enclosure of Olympia, which, totally lost sight of for noo years, has been laid bare by recent excavations, so that we can now THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 15 trace with perfect accuracy the topography of the Olympian palcestra and stadium themselves. The public games gave a raison d'etre to sculpture and a practical aim to artistic effort, and, combined with the motive of religious cult, this influence wrought mightily on the various schools of sculp ture. The custom of commemorating successful ath letes by setting up statues to them, arose about 600 B. C, and signs of progress appear as early as the 50th Olympiad (544); but when the usage became more general of thus dedicating the statues to vic tors, sculptors were obliged to study their subjects carefully, since an accurate resemblance to all parts of the body was demanded, and this led the way to the vigorous marbles of ^Egina, the breathing statues of Myron, and the ideal forms of Pheidias. It was building on nature and knowledge which is art's inexorable condition of progress; and many of the statues we are now so familiar with in the European galleries were probably these very statues of athletes that were erected in the consecrated places. The immense antiquity of the games, which, tradi tion says, were instituted by the Idaean Herakles, is evinced by pictures painted on vases of extreme antiq- ity representing wrestling matches ; and the influence of the athletic sports on archaic Greek sculpture is seen in the combats carved on the tympana of the old Doric temple of iEgina, older than the Parthenon, and that are of the purely heroic type. The people of the island of iEgina were renowned athletes. In the forty-five odes of Pindar which have reached us, there are but four odes commemorative of victors in the games from her own city of Thebes, four from Agri- gentum, two from Athens, and still fewer from other cities whose praises he celebrates, while he sings of 1 6 THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND eleven who belonged to ^Egina; and the first victor honored by a statue in the Altis of Olympia, was an iEginetan. These JEginetan groups represent real fighters, forms taken directly from the palcsstra, cor rect in physique, regular in movement, of terrible because disciplined energy, yet wanting the grace, life and poetic touch of Pheidian sculpture. It was the realistic period of sculpture,' but was on the way to something higher. Herakles, the heroic ideal of the Greeks, as repre sented in the familiar statue of what is called the ' Farnese Hercules ' now at the Naples Museum, is a noble, but unnaturally exaggerated, example of the school of heroic art, which, in the Grasco-Roman time, had lost its idealism and gloried in enormous exuberance of muscular development to express utmost physical force. The so-called ' Apoxyomenos ' is an older and more simply natural statue of very easy attitude, being a marble copy of the bronze original by Eysippos, and now stands in the Braccio Nuovo of the Vatican. It illustrates the use of the ' strigil ' after the athletic contest, and it is a trivial but curious fact, that among the remaining evidences of Alexander's re mote conquests, the use of the ' strigil ' for cleansing the body of oil and sand still survives in India ; for the Greeks carried their athletism everywhere, to India, Syria, Egypt, Spain ; and Pausanias said that a Greek city could be told at once by its palcestra. The ' Diskobolos, ' the work of Myron, was cele brated even in antiquity — Eucian wrote of it : ' ' You speak of the diskos-thrower, who stoops pre paratory to the throw, with the face towards the hands holding the disc, and with one leg bent, as though he meant to rise again after the throw." This THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 17 sculpture is now in the Palazzo Massimi at Rome, and its original was, also, probably of bronze. It has a vig orous swing as if the whole force was thrown into it, while .the beauty and manly modesty of the face show one bred to hardship yet retaining the sweetness of youth. The 'Diskobolos in repose,' sometimes ascribed to Alkamenes, illustrates what I said of the athlete's holding the diskos in the left hand when at rest. The so-called ' Fighting Gladiator, ' by Agasias of Ephesos, giving the whole stretch of a powerful human frame, is really an athlete in the games con tending as an armed hoplite, probably against a horse man, and may have been one of these public statues of victors. The group too of the 'Wrestlers,' is a splendid fruit of the effect of the public games on sculpture ; and its anatomy will bear the most scientific criti cism. All scientists say that the free range of move ment of the shoulder is one of the most striking and beautiful arrangements of the human form, so that the arm can be moved around in every direction through space ; and when we examine this carving, we can have no doubt that the physical fact, or con trivance, of bone and muscle in the shoulder, has been closely studied by the artist. We see in this sculpture-piece that subtle quality, or device, sometimes employed with great effect in the most thoughtful art — of suspense — or of suspended action. In the mov?ment of the figures and the ex pression of the faces, there is a prolongation of the action after the moment of the act seized upon has really ceased, and we feel that it is by no means certain that he who now has the upper hand will have it at the end ; when his determined antagonist who has evi dently bated no jot or tittle of courage will haue pain- THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND fully regained his equality of position, or may even suddenly turn the tables on his somewhat more youth ful rival. The ' Borghese Achilles ' of the Eouvre, represents the hero as athlete, nude though wearing a helm, and resting from combat, with a melancholy expression as if thinking of his great grief and loss. The sculpture of the 'Diadumenos,' after Poly kleitos, represents a young athlete binding the fillet of victory on his fore head, with a placid expression. It is the pahnam non sine pulvere, but with a lofty peace that fills his soul. By way of comparison, or it might be said, contrast, I would mention one or two modern sculptures of ath letes, such as the ' boxers ' of Canova, or the story of Creugas and Damoxenos. While these have un doubted vigor, they are results of study rather than of nature, and are barbarians, absolute savages, when compared with the Greek. The simple nobility of youth, the repose in the midst of action, the classic facial expression of a high type of race, the even health and unconquerable spirit of the young Greek ,athlete — in fact the heroic element which is chiefly spiritual— is not in them. The harmonious pose of body and mind is absent, and, in their place, only agitating passions. The gladiator ' Spartacus ' of the Eouvre, by the French sculptor, Barrias, is spirited but too academic to be great, and lacks the freedom and nature of the antique. Taken as a whole, one of the most charming, shin ing, and admirable ancient statues of a Greek athlete is the ' Hermes of the Vatican, ' carved as a runner resting himself, while the trunk of the*palm on which he leans signifies that he has conquered in the race. The mirror-like polish of the statue is retained. It shows, in its natural force and grace, that the Greeks THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 19 studied the living body before putting it into the marble, thus lending it life without affectation, and repose without weariness. Take for another example the wonderful fragment of the ' Belvedere torso ' which Michel Angelo called his ' master,' and its anatomy, the magnificent arch of the chest, the great hollow of the pelvis and the mighty legs, could only have been produced by an artist who knew the human form thoroughly by a life-long study in the arena. In its pathetically broken condition, what veritable flesh and blood, what breathing powerful life ! The Greeks regarded the public games in a peculiar light, for they were looked upon as an inheritance from the immortals, since a perfect human body was, in some sense, the most sacred of objects, enshrining the soul as in a temple, and associating it with the divine. To contend in the games was a religious aspiration, a lofty endeavor, a striving for the perfect, even as antiquity, or the best antiquity, was full of the idea of struggle, of bringing forth the perfect through contention ; and we can probably have no con ception of the earnestness thrown into these games when a nation was looking on, when it was some times the whole aim of a life to conquer, when it was a religious consecration. The fine statue now in Ber lin of the "Praying Boy" has been supposed by some to be that of a youth consecrating himself to the gods before or after the Olympic games. The relation then of the athletic games to the art of sculpture was mainly three fold: 1. They kept alive the heroic spirit. 2. They brought to the front the best artists to carve iconic statues of victors erected in the sacred enclosures. 3. They gave opportunity for constant and accurate 20 THE ATHLETIC GAMES AND study of the human form in every attitude, j^nd of the most perfect specimens of the human body developed by training and under circumstances that tended to ennoble rather than debase it; since athletic discipline was one part of the system of physical, intellectual and religious education. In view of what has been said of the athletic system under the Greeks, and its importance in many ways, I venture to remark that modern athletism, especially at the university, might be also regarded from many interesting points of view other than the training of the physical powers for athletic contest and com petition, although this is a great object, and I doubt if the athletic system could be maintained without it as was demonstrated by the Greeks themselves in the games, bringing young men up to a high' pitch of physical power and skill, and making them ready to contend for the prize with any foe however formidable; but that, with this, it should fit in with the training of other powers, and not aim at the discipline of the body only, but of the soul, in order to give it its fullest efficiency in our university life. The best period of athletic practice among the Greeks before its degeneration in the Alexandrian and Roman days, was when a great deal was still left to nature, when it was a real joy and inspiration to contend in the games, as well as a hard struggle, when it was healthy sport and had not yet became a rigid system of overtraining and sheer muscularity but continued to be a means of healthier, happier and more beautiful life. This rare combination of athletics and art in Greece meant a great deal, and was a most happy and pregnant circumstance. The close con nection that existed between the agonistic games and sculpture, though at first sight there would seem to THEIR EFFECT ON GREEK ART 21 be no connection between them, brought into the games the aesthetic, and, I might say, the poetic, element, and gave to them a higher meaning and glory. The Greek's genuine love of the beautiful and his earnest conception of the state, and its demand upon him for the best he could give it, for all the power of body and mind he was capable of, ennobled everything he did. The Greek sought instinctively the ideal, the perfect, development. Beauty with him was no mere sentiment, but was another name for perfection. His line of beauty was a line of strength. He understood, as far as he went, the working prin ciples of a true education, which aspired not to knowledge merely, but to culture, and that belonged not to the few highly trained men, but to the entire educational system, serving the purposes both of liv ing and art, and tending to create a healthy nature and heroic spirit in the best youth of the land.