w. > JOB. NEW TRANSLATION OF THE BOOK OF JOB ¦WITH AN INTRODUCTION, NOTES CHIEFLY EXPLANATORY-. Bt GEORGE R. NOYES. D. D., Hakcoce Fbof. 07 Heobew, etc., ind Dzxtsb Leotubeb i« Hasvabd University. muti astirtton. CAEEFULLT BE-VISED. BOSTON: JAMES MUNEOE AND COMPANT. Entered according to act of Congress in the year 1861 by Geobob B.. Notes, In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the District of Massachusetts. CAUBBTDOE : MILES & DILLINGHAM, Pfintera and Steteptypers. TO FREDERIC HUIDEKOPER, OF MEADVILLE, PA., THIS VOLrME IS DEDICATED, IN TOKEN OF THE ESTEEM AND FEIENDSHIP OF GEORGE R. NOYES. PREFACE. In this third edition of the New Translation of the hook of Job, of 'which the first appeared about thirty-four years ago, I have carefully revised the -whole, re-examin ing -with special attention the more obscure and difficult passages, availing myself of wliatever light has been thrown upon them by recent Biblical scholars, such as Ewald, Hirzel, Heihgstedt, Schlottmann, Conant, Renan, and others. When I differ from any of them on any important passage, it is after a deliberate examination of the reasons for their view of it. I have added some notes, altered others, and modified some of the language of the Introduction. It is pleasant to find a very prevalent coincidence between my views, in respect to various points both in the Introduction and the Translation, and those of the distinguished French orientalist, M. Renan, the most recent translator of Job. The principal point on which his opinion dififers from mine, viz., the genuineness of the speech of Elihu, is of no great importance. Whether this speech be an interpolation or not, it is highly im- fvii] vm probable that on questionable internal grounds it will ever be separated from the rest of the poem. I had made an arrangement to publish a re-vised edition ofthe New Translation ofthe Hebrew Prophets in con nection with the present work. But the death of the late Mr. Munroe has caused it to be given up. I take the liberty, therefore, to mention that I have carefully revised the New Translation of the Hebrew Prophets, made a considerable addition to the notes, and written a new and enlarged Introduction, containing an essay on the Pro phetic dispensation among the Hebrews, including the Messianic predictions, in which I have aimed to leave no important question unanswered. Though necessarily com pressed, I hope it will be found sufficiently comprehensive and complete to be a guide to such as have a desire to know the truth in relation to a difficult subject, upon which no satisfactory treatise exists in the English lan guage. Whenever any publisher will undertake the printing of the work, the manuscript will be ready. Cambridge, June 26, 1861. INTRODUCTION. I'HE work, which it is the design of the present volume to illustrate, is in many respects one of the most remarkable pro ductions of any age or country. It is, without doubt, in its general plan, as well as in the rhythmical construction and high poetic character of its language, a work of art. Deep thought and long continued study must have been united with genius in its production. Yet has it, in a much higher degree than most compositions, the freshness of an unstudied effusion of the soul of the author ; a soul full of the sublimest conceptions of the Parent of nature and his glorious works, and of true and deep sympathy with all that is great and amiable in the character, and affecting in thS condition, of man. The imagination of the author seems to have ranged freely through every part of the universe, and to have enriched itself from almost every depart ment of nature and of art. \'Ciether he attempt to describe the residence of Him " who maintaineth peace in his high places," or " the land of darkness and the shadow of death," the passions and pursuits of man, or the nature and features of the animal creation, the phenomena of the air and the heavens, or the dark operations of the miner, he is ever familiar with his subject, and seems to tell us what our eyes have seen and our ears have heard. And not more remarkable are the richness and vigor of his imagination than his power in representing the deep emotions and the tender affections of the soul. Admirable, too, in a poem of so high antiquity, is the skill with which he makes all the delineations of the human heart and all the descriptions of external nature subservient to the illustration of one important moral subject; thus uniting the attributes of the poet and 1 [11 2 INTRODUCTION. philosopher. It is true, that we miss the perfection of Grecian art in the structure of this work ; and his plan required him to set forth the general workings of the human heart, rather than to delineate the nicer shades of human character. It was in. harmony with the ethical nature of the composition, that his characters should make speeches, rather than converse. Yet no one can fail to perceive the unity of design which pervades the work, and the adaptation of the various parts to its completion. The first place among the Hebrew poets has usually been as signed to Isaiah. But in what respect the Great Unknown, the author of the book of Job, can be regarded as inferior to any Hebrew poet, or any other poet, unless perhaps we except Shak speare, I am at a loss to conceive. In comprehensiveness of thought, and richness and strength of imagination, he seems to me to be unsurpassed, and in depth and tenderness of feeling incomparable, when we consider that female loveliness con stitutes no part of the interest of the work. Almost every Christian poet has felt his influence in respect both to thought and expression. But to delineate the excellences and beauties of the book of Job is a task far beyond my capacity. They must be understood and felt, rather than described. There has been much discussion in former times, in regard to the particular department of poetry and literature, under which the book of Job should be classed. Undue importance has, without doubt, been attached to this question ; a,nd the scope and spirit of the work have in a degree been lost sight of, in the eagerness to establish its claim to a particular name, or its place in a particular department of poetical composition. The truth is, that there is nothing that bears an exact resemblance to it in Grecian, Roman, or modern literature. It has something in common not only with different forms of composition, but with different departments of literature. Those, who have given it the appellation of an epic poem, have applied to it a term the least suited to its character, and the most unjust to its claims, as a work of art. They have made unimportant circumstances in regard to its form of raore consequence than its substantial INTRODUCTION. 3 character, spirit, and design. Nothing can be more evident than the fact, that to excite interest in the personal fortunes of Job, as the hero of a poem, was not the principal design of the writer. Still less was it his design to unfold characteristic traits in the other personages introduced into the work. Some, it is true, have discovered, as they supposed, striking characteristic traits in Eliphaz the Temanite, Bildad the Shuhite, and Zophar the Naamathite, and have pointed out the different degrees of severity which they exhibited towards their friend in his dis tress. It appears to me that these writers have drawn largely upon their own imaginations to make out their representations. There is, no doubt, some diversity in the manner and substance of the discourses of the friends of Job. The author may have put the longest and best speeches into the mouth of an inhaibitant of a city so famous for its wisdom as Teman ¦* ; and to young Elihu, whom some regard as an interloper, thrtist into the place he occupies by a later writer than the author, he certainly assigns the language ofa young man who has made rather an extravagant estimate of his abilities and his consequence. But I seek in vain for evidence that the author made it a principal object to excite an interest in the actions or characters of the personages whom he introduces. There is more plausibility in the views of those who have re garded and named the book of Job a dramatic poem. For, un doubtedly, the character of Job has a tragic interest, and reminds one of the most interesting characters of Grecian tragedy, suffer ing by the will of the Gods, or the necessities of Fate, especially the Prometheus Vinctus of .^Bschylus. In regard to its form, there is something resembling dialogue, and something which bears a distant resemblance to a prologue and epilogue. The author has also skilfully introduced into various parts of the work hints having reference to the final issue of the fortunes of Job, similar to those which occur in the best of the Greek tragedies, such as the CEdipus Tyrannus. See ch. viii. 6, 7; xvi. 19 ; xix. 25, &c., compared with ch. xiii. Still, to give the name of a drama * Jer. xlix. 7. 4 INTRODUCTION. or a tragedy to this production is to give it a name from what is incidental to it, rather than from its pervading spirit and prominent design. In fact to call it a poem of any kind fails to suggest the characteristic feature of the work, though it contains poetry, which, perhaps, has never been surpassed. If we have regard to the main design, the substance and spirit of the work, we shall refer it to the department of moral or religious philosophy. It contains the moral or religious philosophy of the time when it was produced. It is rather a philosophical religious discussion in a poetical form, than an epic poem or a drama. It is more nearly allied to the Essay on Man than to Paradise Lost, or Prometheus Vinctus. It is the effusion of the mind and heart of the author upon a moral sub ject which has agitated the human bosom in every age. Still, the author was a poet, as well as a religious philosopher. In the mode of presenting the subject to his readers, he aimed, like other poets, to move the human feelings by exhibitions of passion and scenes of distress, and to please the taste by the sublime flights of his imagination. He aimed to give the highest interest to his subject by clothing his thoughts in the loftiest language of poetry, and arranging them in the measured rhythm which is one of the characteristics of Hebrew poetry. It might be interesting to analyze the pure religious doctrines, which the author held, and with wonderful liberality for one of his nation ascribed to Arabians, but this we must leave to the attentive reader of the book. It seems particularly remarkable that the author should ascribe Divine inspiration to Eliphaz the Temanite. The special subject of this unique production is the ways of Providence in regard to the distribution of good and evil in the world, in connexion with the doctrine of a righteous retribution in the present life, such as seemed to be contained in the Jewish religion. It sets forth the struggle between faith in the perfect government of God, or in a righteous retribution in the present life, and the various doubts excited in the soul of man, by what it feels or sees of human misery, and by what it knows of the INTRODUCTION. 5 prosperity of the contemners of God. These doubts the author expresses in strong and irreverent language from the lips of Job ; while the received doctrine of retribution, which pervades the Jewish religion, is maintained and reiterated from the personages introduced as the friends of Job. The subject is one which comes home to men's business and bosoms. Even under the light of Christianity, perhaps there are few who have not in peculiar seasons felt the strife between faith in the perfect government of God, and the various feelings excited in the mind by what they have experienced or witnessed of human suffering. The pains of the innocent, of those who cannot discern their right hand from their left hand, the pro tracted calamities which are often the lot of the righteous, and the prosperity which often crowns the designs of the wicked, have at times excited wonder, perplexity, and doubt in almost every thinking mind. We, as Christians, silence our doubts, and confirm our faith, by what experience teaches us of the general wisdom and benevolence of the Creator, by the con sideration that affliction comes from the same merciful hand which is the source of all the good that we have ever enjoyed, by the perception of the moral and religious influences of ad versity, and especially by the hope of the joy in a better world set before those who endure to the end. The Apostle could say, for the consolation of himself and his fellow-sufferers, " For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared 'with the glory which shall be revealed in us." And every Christian knows that the Captain of his Salvation ascended to his throne of glory from the ignominious cross. The cross is the great source of the Christian's consolation. But let us suppose ourselves to be deprived of those sources of consolation which are peculiar to a disciple of Christ, and we may conceive of the state of mind of the author of the book of Job, upon whom the sun of righteousness had never dawned. Is it strange that the soul of a pious Jew, who lived before " life and immortality were brought to light through the gospel," should have been agitated by the conflict between such a faith 1* 6 INTRODUCTION. in retribution as his religion seemed to require, and the doubts and murmurings excited by what he felt and saw of the calami ties of the righteous, and witnessed of the prosperity of the wicked ? One of the most enlightened of the Romans, when called to mourn the early loss of the children of his hopes, was led, as he says, almost " to accuse the gods, and to exclaim that no providence governed the world." An Arabic poet, quoted by Dr. Pococke,* writes : Qaot intelleotu prsestantes in angustias rediguntur ! Et summe stolidos invenies prospere agentes ! Hoc est quod auimos perplexos relinquit, Et egregie doctos Sadducseos reddit. How many wise men are reduced to distress ! How many fools ¦will you find in prosperity ! It is this that leaves the mind iu perplexity. And raakes Sadducees of very learned men. We think that many have stated too strongly the argument for the immortality of the soul, drawn from the apparent in equalities of the present state. To maintain that there is little or no retribution in this part of the Creator's dominions appears to me not the best way of proving that there will be a perfect one in another part of them. But the sentiments referred to may serve to illustrate the mental condition of a pious man of exalted genius, who appears to have had no conception, or at least no belief, of a state after death that was desirable in comparison with the present life. In Ps. Ixxiii. we have the thoughts which passed through the raind of another upon the same subject : Yet my feet almost gave way ; My steps had well nigh slipped; For I was envious of the profane. When I saw the prosperity of the 'wicked, &c. Ps. xxxvii. may also be considered as being upon the same * Not. in Port. Mos. C. vli. Opp. p. 214, INTRODUCTION. 7 subject, and in fact, the book of Ecclesiastes, though a more skeptical spirit seems to pervade the latter than either of those psalms, or the book of Job. Such being the subject which filled the mind of the author of Job, the question arises, how he has treated it, or what he aimed to accomplish in regard to it. That, in his own view, he had solved all the difficulties which embarrass the human un derstanding in regard to it is not very probable. But that he proposed to establish some truths in relation to it, as well as to inculcate the duty of entire submission to God, and unreserved faith in him, is, I think, clear. I do not believe, with De Wette, that he means to leave the subject an utter mystery, and merely to bring man to a helpless consciousness of his ignorance. The most prominent part of the author's design is, indeed, to enforce the duty of unqualified submission to the will of God, and of reverential faith amid all the difficulties, which perplex the understanding. A part of it is, also, to illustrate the truth, that moral character is not to be inferred from outward condition ; that afflictions are designed as the trial of piety, and that they lead in the end to higher good than would otherwise be obtained, and thus to assert eternal providence, and justify the ways of God to man. And while he enforces the duty of entire submission to God, he also plainly intimates that unfounded censures and un kind treatment of a friend in distress are more offensive to the Deity than those expressions of impatience which affliction may wring from the lips of the pious. The author aims to show that, in the distribution of good and evil in the world, God is sometimes influenced by reasons which raan can neither discover nor comprehend, and not solely by the merit or demerit of his creatures ; that the righteous are often afflicted, and the wicked prospered ; but that this course of providence is perfectly consistent with wisdom, justice, and goodness in the Deity, though man is unable to discern the reasons of it ; that afflictions are often intended as the trials of piety and the means of moral improvement ; that man is an in competent judge of the divine dispensations ; that it is his duty. 8 INTRODUCTION. instead of rashly daring to penetrate, or to censure, the counsels of his Creator, to submit to his 'will, to reverence his "character, and to obey his laws ; and that the end will prove the wisdom as well as the obligation of such submission, reverence, and obedience. In this view, I have taken the whole book, as we now have it, to be genuine. I think this supposition is attended with the fewest difficulties. Those who discard the speech of Elihu, the twenty-eighth chapter, and part of the twenty-seventh, and the prose introduction and conclusion, must give, of course, an ac count of it somewhat different. In order to accomplish the design, or express the views, which I have exhibited, in such a manner that his work should possess the highest interest for his readers, the author employs a form of composition resembling that of the drama. He brings forward a personage, celebrated probably in the traditions of his country as distinguished for the excellence of his character, and the vicissitudes through which he had passed. In the delineation of the character and fortunes, of this personage, he uses the liberty of a poet in stating everything in extremes, or painting everything in the broadest colors, that he might thus the better illustrate the moral truth, and accomplish the moral purpose, which he had in view. He introduces to the reader an inhabitant of the land of Uz, in the northern part of Arabia, equally distinguished by his piety and his prosperity. He was pronounced by the Searcher of hearts an upright and good man ; and he was suiTounded by a happy family, and was the most wealthy of all the inhabi tants of the East. If virtue and piety could in any case be a security against ca lamity, then must Job's prosperity have been lasting. Who ever had more reason for expecting continued prosperity, the favor of men, and the smiles of providence ? " But when he looked for good, evil came." A single day produces a complete reverse in his condition, and reduces him from the height of INTRODUCTION. 9 prosperity to the lowest depths of misery. He is stripped of his possessions. His children, a numerous family, for whom he had never forgotten to offer to God a morning sacrifice, are buried under the ruins of their houses, which a hurricane levels 'with the ground ; and finally he is affiicted, in his own person, with a most loathsome and dangerous disease. Thus the best man in the world has become the most miserable man in the world. The reader is made acquainted in the outset with the cause of the aflBictions of Job. At an assembly of the sons of God, or the inhabitants of heaven, in the presence of the Governor of the world, an evil spirit, Satan, the adversary in the court of heaven, had come, on his return from an excursion over the earth to present himself, or to stand in readiness to receive the com mands of God. Jehovah puts the question to Satan, whether he had taken notice of the model of human excellence exhibited in the character of his servant Job, and sets forth the praise of the good man in terms so emphatic, as to excite the envy and ill-will of that suspicious accuser of his brethren. Satan in timates that selfishness is the sole motive of Job's obedience ; that it was ¦with views of profit, and not from sentiments of reverence toward God, that he paid him an outward service ; that if Jehovah should take away the possessions of him whom he believed so faithful, he would at once renounce his service. " Doth Job fear God for nought?" To establish the truth of what he had said in commendation of his servant, Jehovah is represented as giving permission to Satan to put the piety of Job to the test, by taking away at once all his possessions and all his children. But the evil spirit gains no triumph. Job re mains true to his allegiance. He sins not even with his lips. There is yet another assembly of the heavenly spirits, and here the hateful spirit, the disbeliever in human virtue, will have it, that it is love of life, the dearest of all possessions to man, which retains Job in his allegiance. Satan therefore is repre sented as ha'wng permission to take from Job all that can be called life, except the mere consciousness of existence, and the 10 INTRODUCTION. ability to express his sentiments, in the condition to whic'n he is reduced, by the infliction of a most loathsome disease. And yet this good man, in this lowest point of depression, is repre sented as remaining patient so long, that when his wife, whom Satan appears to have spared to him for no good purpose, tempt ed him to renounce his allegiance to God, he calmly answers, " Shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil ?" Thus far, he did not sin with his lips. But when the fame of Job's sufferings had spread abroad, and had drawn around him a company of his friends, who had left their distant homes to sympathize with him in his calamities, he is represented as giving vehement utterance to his long repress ed impatience, and pouring oul his complaints and doubts in rash language, with which the reader is prepared to sympathize, only by the account which has been given of the cause of his afflictions in the introductory chapters. But the friends of Job, who, of course, are not acquainted with the cause of his sufferings in the occurrences of the heavenly assembly, are thrown into amazement at the condition in which they find their friend, and the expressions uttered by him, whom they had heretofore looked upon as a wise and good man. They are silent while they witness only his dreadful sufferings ; but when they hear the vehement and rash complaints which are extorted from him by the severity of his distress, they refrain no longer from expressing their sentiments respecting the cause of his calamities. Thus commences a discussion respecting the causes of human sufferings between Job and his friends. They are represented as holding the doctrine of a strict and perfect retribution in the present life ; as maintaining that misery al ways implies guilt ; and hence, instead of bringing him comfort and consolation, they accuse him of having merited his misfor tunes by secret wickedness. They exhort him to repentance, as if he were a great sinner, suffering the just punishment of his crimes. Job repels their insinuations with indignation, and firmly maintains his innocence. He knows not why he suffers. He INTRODUCTION. 11 complains of severe treatment, and asserts that God afflicts equally the righteous and the wicked. His friends are offended at his sentiments, and undertake to vindicate the conduct of the Deity towards him. They repeat with greater asperity their charges of wickedness and impiety, and even go so far as to accuse him of particular crimes. But the more they press their accusations, the more confident is he in his assertions of his in nocence, or of the justice of his cause. He avows his conviction that God will one day manifest himself as the vindicator of his character. He appeals to him, as the witness of his sincerity ; denies the constancy, and even the frequency of his judgments upon wdcked men, and boldly asks for an opportunity of plead ing his cause with his Creator, confident that he should be ac quitted before any righteous tribunal. His friends are reduced to silence, Bildad closing their remarks by a few general maxims respecting the greatness of God and the frailty of man, and Zophar not undertaking to say anything. The spirit of Job is somewhat softened by their silence, and he retracts some of the sentiments, which, in the anguish of his spirit, and the heat of controversy, he had inconsiderately uttered. " He proceeds with calm confidence, like a lion among his defeated enemies." He shows that he could speak of the perfections of God, and express all that was true in their positions, in a better style than any of them. He now admits, what before he seemed to deny, that wicked men are often 'visited by severe punishment. But from his main position he does not retreat, that misery is not always the consequence of wickedness, and that God has a hidden wisdom in regard to the distribution of happiness and misery, which it is impossible for man to fathom. He then proceeds, with a melting pathos, to describe his present, in contrast with his former condition, and to give a most beautiful picture of his character and life, very pardonable in one of whom the reader knows what has been said by the Governor of the world before the angels of heaven. From this he is led to renewed protestations of his innocence, and of his desire to have his cause tried before the tribunal of his Creator. 12 INTRODUCTION. In this stage of the discussion, a new disputant is brought for ward, probably for the purpose of expressing some thoughts of the author on the design of afflictions, and for the purpose of forming a contrast, in respect to style and manner, with the manifestation of the Deity which follows. Elihu is represented as a young man coming forward with an air of great confidence, though in words he ascribes the burden, with which his breast was laboring, to the inspiration of God. " Like most inspired men of the same sort, he is assuming, bold, and supercilious." He does, indeed, bring forward some thoughts on the moral in fluence of afflictions which had not been uttered by the friends of Job, maintaining that, though they may not be the punish ment of past offences, nor evidence of guilt, they may operate as preventives of those sins which the best of men sometimes commit, and as a salutary discipline, for the correction of those faults of which a man may be unconscious, until his attention is awakened by adversity. Thus he gives a more rational con jecture than the three friends of Job, in regard to the precise cause of his afflictions, but does not give the true account of it, as it is stated in the introductory chapters. He is also as far from solving the great problem of evil in the world as any of the preceding speakers. No one thinks it worth while to reply to Elihu. Human wisdom, the learned wisdom of age, and the unbiass ed genius of youth have now been exhausted upon the subject. At length, therefore, the Supreme Being himself is represented as speaking from the midst of a tempest, and putting an end to the controversy ; the dignity of his introduction being rendered more impressive by the self-confident egotism with which Elihu had entered into the contest. ¦* * "How vast the difiference," says Herder, " between the words of Jehovah and the language of Elihu ! It is but the feeble, prolix babbling of a child, in comparison with the brief and majestic tones of thunder in which the Creator speaks. He disputes not, but produces a succession of living pictures ; surrounds, astonishes, and overwhelms the faculties of Job with the objects of his inanimate and animated creation." INTRODUCTION. 13 The Creator decides the controversy in favor of Job. Jehovah does not, however, condescend to explain or vindicate to him the ways of his providence ; but with overpowering force con vinces him of his inability to fathom the divine counsels, de monstrates the necessity of faith in a wisdom which he cannot comprehend, produces in him a sense of his weakness and igno rance, and leads him to profound repentance on account of the rashness of his language; and thus prepares the way for the final vindication of his faithful servant. Ina strain of sublime irony he requests him, who had spoken with such confidence and boldness of the ways of God, to give an explanation of some of the phenomena which were constantly presented to his view ; of the nature and structure of the earth, the sea, the light, and the animal kingdom. If he were unable to explain any of the common phenomena of nature, how could he expect to compre hend the secret counsels and moral government of the Author of nature .' But having shown the. reasonableness of entire confidence in his unsearchable wisdom, and submission to his darkest dis pensations, the Supreme Judge does decide the controversy in favor of Job. He declares that he had spoken that which was right, that is, in maintaining that his misery was not the con sequence of his guilt, or that character is not to be inferred from external condition ; and that the friends of Job had not spoken that which was right, in condemning him as a wicked man on account of his misery, or in maintaining that suffering always implies guilt. The cause of Job's afflictions has already been communicated to the reader in the introductory chapters, namely, that they were appointed as a temporary trial of his virtue, in order to vindicate the judgment of Jehovah concern ing him, and to prove against all gainsayers the disinterestedness of his piety. Finally, Jehovah bestows upon Job double the prosperity which distinguished him before his aifliction, and thus compensates him for the calamities he had suffered, thereby showing, for the consolation of all who endure affliction, that the end of the good man will .show his