'f/

¦a hIP

YALE
UNIVERSITY LIBRARY

ESSAYS

ON

TheBook OF Proverbs.

BY
(a.) S. SeklES,
(b.) Granville Ross Pike.

PHILADELPHIA:
Publishesl by tbe Young Mten's Hebre-w
A.ssocia.tion. 1888.

ESSAYS

ON

The Book of Proverbs.

BY

(a.) S. Sekles,
(b.) Granville Ross Pike.

PHILADELPHIA:
F*ublisheci by tbe Young Men's Hebre^w
A.ssociation. 1888.

PREFACE.

In the summer of 1886 the Board of Managers of the Young Men's
Hebrew Association of Philadelphia, desiring to encourage the study of
Hebrew Literature, issued the following circular, which was widely dis
tributed in such quarters from which it was thought a response might
be elicited :
The Young Men's Hebrew Association of Philadelphia offers a
Prize of Fifty (50) Dollars for the best Essay submitted on the following
topic :
The Principles of Ethics in the Sayings Contained in the Book of
Proverbs, with an Inquiry into the Social Conditions
which They Reflect.
The judges of the Essays will be :
Dr. M. Jastrow, Philadelphia.
Dr. G. Gottheil, New York.
Dr. B. Felsenthal, Chicago.
The Committee has adopted the following rules :
I. The competition is open to all.
2. Every Essay submitted must be written in English, and must be
originally prepared for this competition.
3. Essays must be written on one side of the paper only.
4. Essays must be sent to Dr. M. Jastrow, 925 North Eighth
Street, Philadelphia, on or before April i, 1887.
5. Each Essay must be signed with an assumed name. A sealed
envelope endorsed with the assumed name, and containing the true
name of the writer, must accompany the Essay.

6. The successful Essay shall become the property of the Associa
tion, which may, in its discretion and at its own expense, publish the
same. A number of Essays were submitted to the judges, who, after a
careful consideration, reported to the Board of Managers of the Associ
ation that in their judgment the Essay of Mr. S. Sekles, of New York,
was entitled to the prize, and recommended that honorable mention be
made of the Essay of the Rev. Granville Ross Pike, of Clayville, New
York! The report of the judges having been confirmed by the Board,
the award was duly made in accordance therewith.

The Ethics of Mishle.

BY S. SEKLES.

A book highly praised but little read, greatly esteemed but
little known, is Mishle, the Book of Proverbs, one of the Holy
Scriptures. It is a collection of works of several writers, most, if
not all, of whom lived during the First Hebrew Commonwealth,
and has for its main purpose the manners and proprieties, the
rules and requirements of social and practical life. The Book
of Proverbs was always looked upon with great favor, and was
highly esteemed by our ancient Rabbis. They saw in proverbs
a main support of the precepts of the Torah. ' ' Do not despise
the Mashai (proverb), for it contributes to the understanding of
the Torah ' ' (Mtdrash Rabbah to Shir Hashirini). They illus
trated this assertion by numerous similes, among others, by com
paring the proverb to a candle, which, though of insignificant
value, may be the means whereby a great treasure may be dis
covered. One of the greatest thinkers of the second century.
Bar Kappora, even asserted, that one sentence of Mishle, namely,
' ' In all thy ways acknowledge God, and He shall direct thy
paths ¦' (III. 6), comprises the very essence of the laws of the
Torah {B'reshith Rabbah, section 63). The different authors
seem to have written exclusively for that large body of the people
who formed the middle classes, the farmer, the mechanic, and the
small merchant, while they rarely addressed the judges, the
wealthy, and never the priests or government officers. They
occupied themselves more with the life of the individual than that
of the community, so that it should become a family book, a
Vade mecutn for the house. This peculiar feature of Mishle
manifests a prominent trait of the Jewish spirit in contradistinc
tion to the entire literature of the ancient world. Among other
nations the individual received consideration only as a part of the
political body. The totality alone was thought worthy of account
and report ; the individual disappeared. The Hebrews, on the
other hand, devoted careful consideration to the individual and
the family life.
We can only notice here that this characteristic contributed
to the salvation of the people, when their state and their religious
institutions were destroyed.

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

The compilers of Mishle avoided all rnetaphysical investi
gations and speculations, and did not indulge in abstract problems,
but when they accidentally touched them, expressed their views
in short, concise sentences.
They sought to deduce from the thoughts of other Biblical
books, moral and religious principles which should be universal
and applicable wherever man lived. Though sacrifice, for ex
ample, is alluded to once or twice, no importance is attached to
the ritual system. The ideas around which prophecy revolves,
such as the kingdom of God, of a chosen people, of a Messiah,
and the like, are entirely absent. The distinction between " Israel "
and the ' ' nations ' ' has no place.
It would be, however, too hasty a conclusion to suppose any
antagonism between the compilers of Afiskle and either the priests
or prophets. The proverbs are entirely within the circle of revealed reli
gion, as is evident from the fact that all the ethical rules contained
therein are in conformity with the Law, and moreover repeatedly
refer to the Law. To the sacrifices they referred as follows :
Honor the Lord from thy earnings.
And with the first fruit of all thine increase, (iii. 9.)
A high appreciation of prophecy is expressed in the sentence,
Without vision the people perish,
And he that keepeth the Law, happy be he. (xxix. 18.)
Virtues, however, like courage, patriotism, self-sacrifice, and
public spirit, which form the military type, and overshadowed all
other sentiments in other nations, are not touched upon ; only
amiable traits, like benevolence, charity, love, reverence, which are
closely connected with religion and a moral life, are prominently
and impressively taught.
It was not until a later period than the time of the composition
of Mishle, when formidable empires sprang up around Palestine, and
the danger of destruction grew imminent, that military virtues be
came a necessity. When courage, patriotism, and self-sacrifice were
needed for the preservation of independence, the Hebrews assumed
these virtues, as is fully proved by history.
The leading idea oi Mishle is, that the divine wisdom, grace,
and love are the fundamental causes of all being. This is no
where more strongly expressed than in the sublime speech
which the ancient author puts in the mouth of eternal wisdom.
(Ch. viii.)
"The true wisdom is the knowledge of the will of God,"
that is the recognition of the divine wisdom revealed in Nature
and in the events of life. True wisdom includes all the spiritual

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

and moral accomplishments of men, piety and skill, justice and
discretion. Of the attributes of God the proverbialists especially pro
nounce :
I. His omnipresence :
The eyes of the Lord are in every place.
Beholding the evil and the good.* (xv. 3.)
2. His omniscience :
Sheol and destruction are before the Lord,
How much more then the hearts of the children of men? (xv. 11.)
3. His providence :
A man's heart deviseth his way.
But the Lord directeth his steps, (xvi. 9.)
4. His infinite wisdom :
The Lord has with wisdom formed the earth,
And with understanding established the heavens, (iii. 19.)
5. His infinite justice :
Six things doth the Lord hate.
Seven are an abomination unto him.
A proud look, a lying tongue ;
And hands that shed innocent blood ;
A heart that deviseth wicked plans ;
Feet that are swift in running to mischief;
A false witness speaking lies.
And he that soweth discord among brethren, (vi. 16-20.)
6. His infinite goodness :
That thy trust may be in the Lord,
I have made known to thee this day. (xxii. 19.)
The difficult probleni^how to reconcile the providence of God
with the free will of man is not directly touched by our moralists.
They accepted as an axiom that man is subject to the providence
of God, but at the same time retains his free will.

* Rabbi Isaac Aboab makes the interesting remark that the verb
Tsaphah, to behold, to penetrate with one's eyes, gives to this sentence
the meaning that God understands the hypocrisy of persons, who de
ceive men, but whose thoughts are known to Him alone.

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

He that is slow to anger is better than the mighty.
And he that ruleth his spirit, than he that taketh a city.
 (xvi. 32.)
Duties of Man.
As the main purpose o{ Mishle was to gather the most precious
ethical doctrines of Israel, which appeal to man's reason and
heart, we find there only such duties referred to as contribute
directly to his justice, love, and moral purity, and are pre-emi
nently a matter of conscience.
The fear of God is repeatedly expressed as the highest prin
ciple of religion, in fact as religion itself. The Hebrew expression
for fear of God, Yirath Adonai, does not mean as much apprehen
sion of incurring God's wrath as the respectful reverence for His
will, and the eager desire to fulfill His commands. Only in that
sense could they say.
The fear of God is the beginning of knowledge (i. 7) ; it is the
fountain of life. (xiv. 27.)
Besides the fear of God our moralists pronounce trust in God
as essential to a pure, moral life.
Thy trust may be in the Lord (xxii. 19) ;
He that putteth his trust in the Lord shall prosper., (xxviii. 25.)
The chief duty of man towards himself is beautifully and con
cisely expressed :
Keep thy heart with all diligence.
For out of it are the issues of life. (iv. 23.)
It is the heart with its emotions which requires rational con
trol, and by directing it towards all that is good, noble, and pure,
man secures perfection of mind and body.
In order to attain temporal happiness by perfecting and
guarding a sound body, the following four virtues are urgently
and repeatedly recommended : temperance, contentment, industry,
and chastity. The most beautiful admonitions against intemperance issued
from one of our moralists :
Who hath woe ? who hath sorrow ?
Who hath contentions ? who hath complaints ?
Who hath wounds without cause ?
Who hath his eyes darkened ?
They that tarry long at the wine.
They that go to seek mixed wine.

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

Be not tempted by the red wine,
When it formeth pearls in the cup.
And smoothly glideth down.
At the last it biteth like a serpent,
Andstingeth like a viper, (xxiii. 29-32.)
Nevertheless our moralists did not oppose the moderate use
of wine, and agreed with the Psalmists, ' ' That wine cheers the
heart of man," and recommend the drinking of it to cheer those
in distress. Give strong wine unto him who is ready to perish,
And wine to those that be of heavy heart.
Let him drink and forget his sufferings,
And remember his misery no more. (xxxi. 6-7.)
Our moralists fully appreciated that satisfaction of mind which
is acquired by faith in God, and gives contentment to the soul.
Better is little with the fear of the Lord,
Than great treasure and troubles therewith, (xv. 16.)
The ancient Hebrews were an industrious people ; labor
was highly esteemed, and, therefore, repeatedly recommended :
Go to the ant, thou sluggard,
Consider her ways and be wise.
She hath no guide, overseer, or ruler,
Provideth her meat in summer,
And gathereth her food in the harvest.
How long wilt thou sleep, O sluggard ?
When wilt thou arise out of thy sleep ?
Yet a little sleep, a litde slumber,
A little folding of the hands to sleep.
So shall thy poverty come as a traveler.
And thy want as an armed man. (vi. 6-1 1.)
The hand of the diligent shall bear rule.
But the slothful shall be under tribute, (xii. 24.)
Love not sleep, lest thou come to poverty.
Open thine eyes and thou shalt be satisfied with bread, (xx. 13.)
The maxims in reference to the observance of chastity are
among the most beautiful passages of the Holy Scriptures.
When man is in distress, suffering from the adversities of
life, when misfortune pursues him, can better consolation and en
couragement to patience and hope be found than in the following
sayings ?

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

My son, despise not the chastening of the Lord,
Neither be weary of his correction.
For whom the Lord loveth he correcteth.
Even as a father the son in whom he delighteth. (iii. 11-12.)
The proverbialists recommend truthfulness, contentment, and
a cheerful disposition.
Lying lips are abomination to the Lord,
But they that deal truly are his delight, (xii. 22.)
Better is little with the fear of the Lord,
Than great treasure and trouble therewith, (xv. 16.)
A merry heart giveth good health.
But a broken spirit drieth the bones, (xvii. 22.)
While among other ancient nations such military virtues as
courage, self-sacrifice, and patriotism secured to a citizen a lofty
reputation, among the Hebrews it was piety, benevolence, and
charity, which gave a man a good name, and our proverbialists
recommended :
A good name rather is chosen than great riches,
And loving favor rather than silver and gold. (xxii. i.)
If the Torah mentions in praise of the greatest man that ever
lived, Moses, that he was meek, we may expect that meekness
and modesty were especially appreciated and inculcated in the
Proverbs. Modesty was looked upon as the source of the fear of God,
and the indirect cause of riches, honor, and happiness.
In the wake of meekness are the fear of the Lord,
Riches, honor and happiness, (xxii 4.)
On the contrary, conceit was repeatedly condemned, as for
instance :
Pride goes before destruction.
And a haughty spirit before the fall. (xvi. 18.)

Duties towards our Fellow-Men.
The chief duties of man to his fellow-men are concisely and
emphatically expressed in the Scriptural precept, ' ' Thou shalt
love thy neighbor as thyself." This precept implies positive and
negative duties. The latter comprise prohibitions to injure our
neighbor in his property, in reputation, or in peace of mind, and

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

may be expressed as the duty of justice. The positive duties are
those that have for their foundations m,ercy, and impel us to those
amiable duties, — benevolence, sympathy, and charity.
These duties enjoined on us by the divine precept are beauti
fully expresssed by our moralists :
He that pursueth righteousness and mercy,
Findeth happiness, righteousness and honor, (xxi. 21.)
While this maxim comprises all our duties to our fellow-men,
there are numerous others which refer to particular duties and
especially to truthfulness and charity, of which we select :
Withhold not good from them to whom it is due,
When it is in thy power to do it.
Say not unto thy neighbor, Go, and come again.
And to-morrow I will give, when thou hast it by thee.
Devise not evil against thy neighbor.
Seeing he dwelleth securely by thee. (iii. 27-29.)
Strive not with a man without cause.
If he have done thee no harm. (iii. 30. )¦
Whoso stoppeth his ears at the cry of the poor,
He also shall cry himself, but shall not be heard, (xxi. 13.)
He that oppresseth the poor reproacheth his Maker :
But he that honoreth him hath mercy on the poor. (xiv. 31.)
A special characteristic of Mishle is shown in the recom
mendation concerning the treatment of enemies. This is another
proof of the sublime ethical character prevailing among the
Hebrews, inspired by their conceptions of God. Search the
books of the ancient nations, decipher the inscriptions of the
Assyrians and Babylonians for maxims like the following :
If thine enemy be hungry give him bread to eat.
And if he be thirsty, give him water to drink.
For thou shalt heap coals of fire upon his head,
And the Lord shall reward thee. (xxv. 21.)
Rejoice not when thine enemy falleth,
And let not thine heart be glad when he stumbleth. (xxiv. 17.)
In accordance with the general principles of morals are
numerous maxims recommending prudence and discretion in
social intercourse, all founded on the purest ethical basis.
It must be noticed that neither mixed marriages nor garnbling
are touched upon, an evident proof that they were unknown in the
times of the authors of Mishle.

77y.fi' ETHICS OF MISHLE.

Social Conditions of the Hebrews.
While the prophets of Israel inveighed against the oppres
sions practised by the ruling powers and the corruption of the
judges, the moralists of Mishle addressed themselves to the
middle classes, and in their maxims and sayings reflect the social
conditions of that large portion of the nation better than does any
other part of the Bible.
Through the whole period of the first Commonwealth there
existed a large class of farmers and tradesmen, who in the pursuit
of their calling, although more or less affected by revolutions and
wars, continued in the even tenor of their way, preserving the
traditional ceremonies and customs, and' keeping afar from the
depraved influence of court life.
Out of the midst of the farmers the first prophet, the rustic
and eloquent Amos, arose, whose speeches contain some of the
most perfect specimens of sublime thought that are found in any
language. Heiwas only a herdsman, and his prophecies abound
in illustrations drawn from husbandry and the scenes of rural life.
The people must have acquired a high degree of culture
when such a man, a shepherd, could deliver such well set
speeches, and could be understood and appreciated by his
hearers. We may assume that these patriots and God-inspired men,
who composed or collected the most precious fruits of the wisdom
of Israel, who were recognized under the pious king Hezekiah, as
the men of Hezekiah (xxv. i), and are mentioned by Isaiah
as my disciples (Isaiah viii. i6), lived among the laboring
classes, stood afar from the depraved influence of the ruling
powers, and considered it their task to preserve the sacred spark
of religion and pure morals among these classes, and to guard
them from decline. Thanks to their efforts, the Hebrew farmer
never sank down to the low grade of ignorant peasants of other
countries, who, excluded from all education, were mere workers
of the soil, standing not much higher than their domestic animals.
The land offered them inexhaustible sources of wealth. No
part of Judea was waste, very little was occupied by unprofitable
wood ; the more fertile hills were cultivated in artificial terraces,
others were adorned with orchards of fruit trees ; the more rocky
and barren districts were covered with vineyards. The climate
was healthy and the seasons regular. Grain of all kinds — wheat,
barley, millet, and other sorts — grew in abundance ; the wheat
commonly yielded thirty for one. Besides the wine and olive,
the almond, the date, figs of many kinds, the orange, the pome
granate, and many other fruit trees flourished in the greatest
luxuriance. Great quantities of honey were collected. Thus the

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE. 13
farmer dwelt, according to the picturesque language of the
country, each under his own vine or his own fig-tree, and could
proudly say with the Shunammite, "I dwell among mine own
people" (II. Kings iv. 1,3) ; I have no favors to ask from the
king or his captains.
Besides the farmers there were many skilled mechanics in the
country. There were masons (Masger) especially engaged in the
erection of forts (II. Kings, xiv. 14), sculptors (Hosea xiii. 2),
workers of mosaics, and of other trades. There were separate
villages and districts occupied by the families of Yokim, .of the
tribe of Judah, engaged in manufacturing pottery, near Jerusalem
(I. Chronicles iv. 22, 23). Not far from them lived the families
of Ashbia, who wrought fine linen, a very fine tissue, hardly
differing from our modern shirting.*
The wealth acquired by the diligence of the husbandman,
by the industry of the skilled mechanic, and by the energy of the
merchant, produced a certain opulence in all classes, that promoted
a higher education and a general knowledge of reading and
writing. The people were surrounded with a poetical, spiritual
atmosphere. They listened to the fiery eloquence of the proph
ets, they sang the sublime poetry of the Psalmists, and recited the
wise maxims of the moralists. Everything contributed towards
raising them to a higher sphere.
Among such a nation the industrious were respected, and
the slothful appeared despicable :
I went by the field of the slothful.
And by the vineyard of the man lacking understanding ;
And lo, it was all grown with thorns.
And netties covered the face thereof,
The stone wall thereof was broken down,
Then I saw and considered it well,
I looked upon it and received instruction.
Yet a little sleep, a little slumber,
A littie folding of the hands to sleep,
So shall thy poverty come as a wayfarer.
And thy want as an armed man. (xxiv. 30,34.)
Be thou diligent to know the condition of thy flocks,
And look well to thy herds.
The lambs are for tl^y clothing.
The young goats pay for the work on the field,

* According to an obscure passage in I. Kings x. 28, as translated
by the Revised Version and explained by Kimchi, Solomon mtroduced
the linen yarn from Egypt into Palestine.

14 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.
Goats' milk will supply thy food and the food of thy household,
And maintenance for thy maidens, (xxvii. 23, 26, 27.)
Mechanics also were encouraged to diligence :
Wealth gotten by vanity shall be diminished.
But he that gathereth by labor shall increase, (xiii. 11.)
He that is slothful in his work
Is brother to him that is a great waster, (xviii. 9.)
There can be no doubt that the people not only listened to
the wise sayings, but also lived in accordance with the ethical
principles communicated to them.
The Hebrew nation were of a cheerful, merry disposition,
indulging in singing, playing, music, and dances. For " to sing "
they had four different expressions, while "to dance" could be
expressed in four or five different ways. An evident proof that
these amusements were appreciated in Judea. Playing was even
ascribed to Wisdom, which exclaims :
I was by him, his favorite,
Playihg always before him.
Playing in his dominion,
My delights were with the sons of men. (viii. 30, 31.)
The concourse of both sexes was not restricted. Young men
and girls joined in merry dances directed by a timbrel, especially
at weddings, harvest feasts, and vintage. The young men assem
bled in wine rooms and sang there to the sound of the tabrets.
It even seems that they had regular clubs.

Family Life.

The happy family life, which, through all generations of which
we possess a more exact account, was the glory and the pride of
the Jews, undoubtedly also prevailed among the ancient Hebrews,
when in possession of their pwn land. This family life was rooted ,
in their traditions and in their religion, and we may even assert
was one of the chief pillars for the preservation of the Jewish re
ligion from entire destruction. This view appears to be expressed
in the Talmud, where it is asserted, " Through the piety of the
women Israel was redeemed from Egypt." {Sofa, 11.) While in
the outside world men were enticed to follow idols, assume
strange manners and to imitate foreign costumes, in the home,
at the family hearth, the good time-honored customs of the patri
archal times were retained, and the Hebrew women watched over
the observance of the accustomed ceremonies. The position

 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE. 15
assigned to women was a highly honorable one, and to a certain
degree independent, as appears by the entire Jewish literature
and most prominently by Proverbs.
If nothing else would appear concerning the mothers of Israel
in the whole Bible but the passage.
My son, hear the instruction of thy father, and forsake
not the law of thy mother.
For they shall be an ornament of grace unto thy head.
And chains about thy neck (i. 8, 9).
it would speak volumes for the exalted position they occu
pied in the family. The moralist does not speak of an excep
tional case, but in general of the mother, who had a large share in
the education of the children and would only exercise that great
influence upon them, which is so highly recommended by the
quoted passage, when she possessed the moral and ethical knowl
edge necessary in the education of children.
We can, therefore, not be surprised when, to prove the high
position of mothers in Israel, such women as Deborah and Abigail
appear even as leaders of men, and the daughters of Zelophchad
plead in person in defence of their rights before Moses. We may
even recommend the witty Achsa to the attention of our readers,
whose history is very little known, although twice related in the
Bible. (Joshua xv. 16 ; Judges i. 15.)
Achsa, the daughter of the rich Caleb, prince of the tribe of
Judah, had to marry her cousin Othniel, who, according to tradi
tion, was a scholar, hence a poor man. Othniel, the younger son
of Caleb's brother, displayed his valor in seizing Kirjath Sepher,
a fortified city, and was rewarded for his exploit by the hand of
Achsa. He was brave, when the hand of his fair cousin was to be
won, but lost his courage when his betrothed requested him to
ask for a dowry. There she herself interfered. She addressed
her father in an ambiguous way, " Give me Beracha (both " bless
ings ' ' and " springs ' ' in Hebrew), for thou hast given me a South
{barren) country " (referring to the poverty of her betrothed). The
father granted his witty daughter a very liberal gift.
The Biblical history has very little to say about Hebrew girls,
for in ancient Palestine they married at an early age, and there
was very little time left for courtship with its difficulties, intrigues
and romantic events, that fill modern novels, and alas ! actual
life. Marriage was looked upon as a holy institution ordered by
divine precept.
The happy marriage of young people is beautifully con
ceived by our moralists :
Rejoice with the wife of thy youth.
Lovely as a hind, pleasant as a roe ;

1 6 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.
Let her embraces satisfy thee continually.
Let her love delight thee for all time to come. (v. i8.)
Her very presence was a blessing to the household, when
she fulfilled her duties :
A woman of worth is a crown to her husband,
A corrupt one is a rottenness.in the bones, (xii. 4.)
The liberty and independence enjoyed by the women were
however often misused, and quarrels in the house were the conse
quence. A contentious wife is a dripping roof, (xxvii. 15.)
It is better to dwell in a corner of a house-top
Than with a brawling wife in a wide house, (xxi. 9.)
It is better to dwell in the wilderness,
Than with a contentious, fretful woman, (xxi. 19.)
The thirty-first chapter of Proverbs (from 10-^31), contains
the praise and describes the properties of a good wife. This de
scription of an ideal matron evinces the practical sense of the
Israelite, which decidedly differs from the romantic, exaggerated
adoration of woman, viewing her from a sentimental aspect.
Herein Israelites differed from the Greeks, who in the woman
only admired plastic beauty and sensuous graces.
Not that the Hebrew had no perception of .the graces of
woman, but in a moral code he appreciates a capable, diligent
housewife, who cares for the comforts of her husband, and who
watches over her household.

Education.

Among a people where marriage was regarded as a holy in
stitution, the family hearth became a temple, with father and
mother as priests ; every child formed another link in the chain of
love that connected them. They rejoiced in the prosperity of
their children : My son, if thy heart be wise,
My heart shall rejoice, even mine, (xxiii. 15.)
Both parents co-operated in the important duty of educating
their children, and especially the mother laid the foundation for
their future development. They were left under the care of their
mothers and received from them their first instruction. Common
schools were unknown. As they advanced in age, the father had
to exercise his paternal authority and care. The authors of

™^ ^Z^^^ O/^ MISHLE. 17

Mishle were believers in corporal punishment, a view still main
tained by some prominent modern educators.
Chasten thy son while there is hope.
Let not thy soul have pity for his crying, (xix. 18.)
Folly is bound in the heart of the child, .
But the rod of correction ahall drive it far from him. (xxii. 15.)
He that spareth his rod hateth his son.
But he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes, (xiii. 24.)
The rod and reproof give wisdom,
A child left to himself bringeth his mother to shame, (xxix. 1 5.)
Higher schools were established under the supervision of the
prophets, to train young men to become expounders of the law,
and to preserve the religion of the fathers. Such schools already
existed under Samuel (I. Sam. xix. 20), and also in the time of
Elijah (II. Kings ii. 5). It is also probable, that Huldah, the
prophetess, dwelt in a college, as Mishna is translated in the R.
V. and explained by some commentators. (II. Ch. xxxiv. 22.)
An important principle for education is laid down in the
sentence :
Train up the child according to his abilities.
And when he is old he will not go astray, (xxii. 6.)
This principle is of the highest importance, and only when
he regards the abilities and inclinations of the pupil can the edu
cator expect full success to attend his efforts.

Luxury and Toilets of the Hebrew Women.
The republican simplicity which existed during the time be
fore there were kings in Israel made room for increasing wealth,
and all its advantages and defects, with the formation of the king
dom, and especially during the reigns of David and Solomon.
Then arose two distinct classes, the rich and the poor, and the
state of society was thereby considerably modified. During the
reigns of David and Solomon the Hebrews engaged in commer
cial undertakings, and the products of Egypt, Arabia, and India
were brought to Palestine. With the growth in wealth, luxury
also increased. Not only the royal palace, but also the houses of
the wealthy were built of brown cedar decorated in gold, silver,
and bronze. The women rested on beds decked with coverings

* We take here Derech in the same sense as in Gen. vi. 12, "the
natural inclinations."

1 8 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

of tapestry, surrounded by an enormous quantity of perfumes
(vi. i6, 17). The fragrance of Arabia had to be imported in
bulk. What abundance of boxes, vases, and botties !
To mention some of the toilet requirements of the Hebrew
ladies, we would speak of the neat cases filled with dry henna
leaves, and will remark, that bunches of henna blossoms, on ac
count of their beauty of form and their scent, were worn on the
breast. (Solomon's Song i. 13.)
We also meet with Stibium, nothing else than antimony,
which had to be transported a great distance to reach Palestine.
In the Proverbs we meet with myrrh, aloe and cinnamon (vii. 17)
as perfumes, all three brought from distant lands.
Did those ladies of antiquity wear many ornaments ?
The moralists of Mishle, who wrote mostly for the middle
classes, made no complaint about too much luxury of our ances
tors, a decisive proof that the former republican simplicity had yet
great hold among the agricultural people. Of chains, crowns, and
other ornaments, our moralists only speak in connection with wis
dom and teachings of parents.
The prophet Isaiah has so much the more to censure, and
enumerates the following parts of dresses and garnishes : Anklets,
worn as feet or ankle decorations, wherewith women made a tink
ling sound in walking ; little suns and moons as medals, for
necklaces ; ear-drops, bracelets, veils, turbans ; stepchains,
attached to the ankle of each foot, to compel the bearer to
take short, mincing steps ; girdles, smelling bottles, amulets ;
finger, ear, and nose rings ; cloaks, money purses, mirrors of
polished metal, and a few more articles about whose character
we are in the dark (Is. iii. 19). We even doubt whether the
eloquent prophet knew all the names of the female toilet. A
moralist of Mishle takes occasion to speak of golden nose rings,
but only in the nose of the swine.
As a nose-ring of gold in a swine's snout,
So is a fair woman without discernment, (xi. 22.)
Commerce.
The Hebrews, during the reign of the judges, were a poor,
agricultural people. They received their first impulse to com
mercial enterprises from King Solomon. That wise king intro
duced commerce with the neighboring nations, and joined
the Phoenicians in navigation, At that period the Baby
lonians and Assyrians carried on a large inland commerce, in
which Palestine was included. Well constructed highroads
through the desert joined Syria and Palestine with Babylon, forti
fied stations protected the merchants against the nomadic tribes of

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE. 19

Arabia, cities surrounded by walls served as resting places and
magazines, and in properly situated places wells were built that
provided abundant water for travelers and their beasts. These
roads of the caravans may even be traced to this day. The
great commercial road which crossed Galilee, from the Jacob's
bridge to Capernaum, joined Ptolemais with Damascus, while
another through Sebaste, the capital of Samaria, near Dothain
(where Joseph was sold), passed by Beth-El to Egypt. The
great caravan road to the east of the Dead Sea, along the moun
tains of Seir, touched Jericho, and that city became an important
place for the Arabian and Egyptian trade.
Palestine, situated between Assyria, Babylonia, and Egypt,
became a connecting link for these highly developed countries,
and necessarily participated in the lively commerce then carried
on between them and Phoenicia and Arabia. Such a commerce
brought many strangers to the country, and as stated in Chronicles
(ii. 2, 17), at the time of Solomon 153, 600 Gentiles resided in
Jerusalem. Riches poured into the country from the mines, from
taxes and tributes.
The Hebrews in the time of Solomon also joined the Phoeni
cians in navigation, and brought from Arabia gold and silver,
ivory, apes, and peacocks.
From that time the Hebrews did not withdraw from the com
merce of the world, but more or less partook in it. Our moralists
in speaking of the industrious matron say :
She is like the merchant's ships.
She brings her food from afar (xxxi. 14) ;
a simile which could only suggest itself in connection with a
people engaged in commerce.
Uzziah, King of Judah, an excellent, prosperous monarch,
attempted to imitate Solomon, arid had also great ships on the
sea. (Is. ii. 16.) The wealth of the country increased to such
dimensions that Uzziah developed an expenditure not
even known in the time of Solomon. He had a winter palace
and a summer palace, and houses of ivory. (Amos iii. 15.)
Luxury was exorbitant among the ruling classes. Our moralists,
however, left the admonitions of these wealthy people and the
merchant princes, with their vices, to the eloquent prophets, and
directed their teachings merely to the petty dealers.
It is naught, it is naught, saith the buyer.
When he is gone his way, then he boasteth. (xx. 14.)
A false balance is abomination unto the Lord,
But a just weight is his delight, (xi. i.)

20 ¦ THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

The Principle^ of Ethics in the Sayings Contained in
THE Book of Proverbs, with an Inquiry into the
Social Conditions which they Reflect.

BY GRANVILLE R. PIKE.

A people's proverbs reveal its inmost thought. They give
insight into both processes and principles. This is the form
naturally assumed by early and unconventional expression, before
literature grows self-conscious and the spontaneous utterance of
general conviction hardens into prescribed formulas. Every
nation, therefore, hoary Egypt, ice-bound Finland, or China by
her Yellow Sea, boasts a wealth of this minted wisdom peculiar
to itself. " Each holding much in common with all, the gnomic
literature of every land still reveals the specific ethnic features of
its birthplace, whether the aesthetic intellectualism of Greece, the
military and legal bias of Rome, the vivacity of Gallic, the gravity
of Teutonic, or the energy of Anglo-Saxon" character.
This elliptical, sententious method of speech flourishes best,
however, in the fertile fancy and contemplative habit of the Orient.
Arabia, India, Persia, Judea, display their mental history and
criteria of conduct in a mass of proverbial lore commensurate
with the length and grandeur of their national life. Least among
these ancient peoples in many ways, it is apparent from a com
parison of the practical ethics abbreviated and current in these
sayings that in moral elevation, — the final test of greatness, —
Israel excels them all. Among her sacred writings this "wis
dom " literature holds a conspicuous place. It is the subjective
side of the Theocracy. The historical and prophetic portions are,
in the main, objective. They set forth what God did in the pro
cess of training his people and their outward response. But these
" wisdom " books show the effect of such training upon Jewish
intellect and heart and conscience.
Especially does this divine influence reappear in the language
and daily life and human relations in the Book of Proverbs. Its
ethical principles, therefore, are grounded on God himself. This
differentiates them at once, not in degree only, but in kind, from
all systems based upon statute,* spiritual sovereignty of ances-

rlatO, Ue LegtbuS, lib. X.. Kupta eKaara eTcat yLyvofleya tc'kvjj Kal Tots

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

tors,* or that no-morality of expediency against which all Hebrew
literature is a protest.
In seeking the Hebrew method of determining man's com
plex duty, there emerge three mighty key-words as pillars which
bear up the whole moral fabric. They occur grouped together
as early as the third verse of the prologue, in the common version,
righteousness, judgment, equity. pns looks God-ward, and
means a righteousness that is such by reason of its harmony with
the divine character, or absolute right. BiJK'a, resting upon
the idea of judging, comes to mean the judgmeftt reached, or the
act of rendering justice, hence statute, law, that which is lawful,
just. While necessarily involving social relations, it goes beyond
what is simply equitable between man and man, and must con
form also to the stricter demands of supreme justice. Dntyn,
on the contrary, is a word reflexive in its very nature. With the
rooP-idea of straightforwardness, it signifies that which is right,
rectus, hence undeviating rectitude of purpose, integrity. What
ever is intrinsically right, lawful in operation, and upright in mo
tive is comprehended under these three nouns, and by them all
human transactions are brought directly to the bar of God. The
extent to which this conception was woven into Jewish thought
is shown by the occurrence of the first of these words no less than
seventy times within the small compass of this book, and each
of the others appears more than a third as often. About these
principles, accountabihty to God, mutual obligation, and personal
probity, a large portion of the sayings crystallize. In them, there
fore, without tedious examination of their specific applications,
we find the cardinal points from which, as astronomers determine
an orbit, we may trace the entire circumference where duty touches
life. Every action under an ethical system is inevitably affected by
the character of its sanction. Intelligent estimate of conduct be
comes possible only in response to the inquiry, to what is the
ultimate appeal ? Over the Delphic portals, as their profoundest
precept, the Greeks inscribed know thyself. At the opening
of this collection of maxims, professedly relating mainly to worldly
prudence, intellectual keenness, and business morality, the He
brews, with deeper insight, wrote fear of jehovah, beginning
OF knowledge. When it is remembered that by " Fear " they
meant not terror, but intelligent, reverential awe, and how com
prehensive also was their notion of a knowledge or wisdom

* Chinese Classics, Pan-King, "I think 'of my ancestors, who are
now the spiritual sovereigns. * * * » Were I to err in my government,
my high sovereign would send down on me a great punishment for my
crime." Legge's Trans.

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.

based upon this pious attitude of mind and heart, including within
it practically the whole rule of personal duty, it will readily be
seen how far-reaching is the principle here announced.
It embraces alike the most ordinary and the most exalted
callings and occasions. It lays a restraining hand upon the laborer,
demanding that he regard the life of his beast (12: 10), and incites
the student to the utmost strife after wisdom, that he may under
stand righteousness, and judgment, and equity, yea, every good
path (2 : 9).
Over this wide space between prosaic practice and highest
soaring theory, consciousness of a sovereign's eye, watchful and
supreme, casts a dignity for which we search other literatures in
vain.
Although thou sayest. Behold, we knew not this :
Doth not he that weigheth hearts consider it ?
Yea he that guardeth thy soul doth kriow ;
And he will render to every m.an according to his work. (24 : 12.)
And again with even stronger emphasis.
The Under-world and Destruction are before fehovah.
How much m,ore then the hearts of the children of men. (15: 11.)
With so vivid a sense of the divine omniscience, a recogni
tion of the duty of sincere worship was inevitable. Hence such
sentiments as
The sacrifice of the wicked is the abomination of fehovah ;
But the prayer of the upright is his delight. (15: 8.)
fehovah is far from the wicked;
But he heareth the prayers of the righteous. (15: 29.)
In the face of such stern discrimination between the
true and the false, there is little wonder that the code of Israel
found no place for that class whose breed is yet far from extinct.
who would confound all moral distinctions.
He that saith unto the wicked, Thou art righteous ;
Peoples shall curse him, nations shall abhor him. (24 : 24.)
Not only will he bring down upon himself the execrations of
humanity, whose moral sense is outraged, but
He that justifieth the wicked, and he that condemneth the righteous,
Both of them alike are an abomination of fehovah. (17 : 15.)
They did not, however, overlook the supplementary truth
that mere lip-service or decorous performance of devotional rites
was but a part, and the lesser part, of fitting worship. We seem

THE ETHICS OF MISHLE. 23

to hear the echo of Samuel's indignant answer to Saul, (r Sam.
15 : 22), and an anticipation of Isaiah's burden (Is. i : 11-17), in
To do justice and judgment
Is more acceptable to fehovah than sacrifice. (21 : 3.)
With such impressions of God's oversight and of the sincere
life which alone received his favor, it was natural that the posses
sion of this should be reckoned chief among treasures. Conse
quently we are told.
Better is little with the fear of fehovah.
Than great treasure and trouble therewith. (15 : 16.)
Still more apparent is the spring of honest dealing in,
Better is a little with righteousness.
Than large revemies with injustice. (16: 8.)
What better antidote to the avarice which besets most hearts
and all commercial peoples, and is a chief canker in our body
politic to-day, than this knowledge that it is the Eternal God
who strikes the final balance in the ledger !
The Israelite, conscious of his integrity, has, moreover, in
this ever-present Judge a refuge from the destruction which over
takes the wicked, since whatever storms beat about him
The name of fehovah is a strong tower :
7 he righteous runneth into it and is safe. (18 : 10. )
Hence it is that
He that walketh uprightly, walketh surely,
and The root of the righteous shall never be moved.
It were easy to follow the ramifications of this sense of per
sonal accountability which underlay all Hebrew life, striking its
roots deep into every department of activity, demanding that
. body, intellect, will, and heart render homage to Jehovah. But
we address ourselves instead to tracing the influence of the na
tion's creed upon its social relations.
For deeds, after all, express genuine convictions. The same
principles, as we soon discover, run through all this range of
duties. It is still Jehovah who guards the paths of judgment.
(2 : 8.) In the field of general ethics, worthy to stand at the head of
all precepts, is this : Say not, 1 will do so to him as he hath done
tome: I will render to the man according to his work. (24: 29.)
This surpasses that ancient maxim of Confucius, What ye would
not that men should do to you, that do ye not to them, inasmuch

24 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.
as the Chinese injunction is merely negative, forbidding only the
initiative in evil, while the Jew is enjoined to suffer injury in patience
and trust in him who saith, Vengeance is mine, I will repay. If
revenge is so strongly prohibited, much more the more obvious
sins against life and liberty. The reason urged for not joining
the robber bands, described i: 10-19, is that they make haste to
shed blood. Among the six things hated of Jehovah (6: 16-19)
are hands that shed innocent blood, and a malicious person who
causeth the upright to err, shall fall into his own pit. Property
rights are guarded by warnings against theft, robbery, monopoly,
cheating. Especially is stress laid upon fair dealing between
man and man, and the strictest honesty required :
A just balance and scales are fehovah' s.
All thf' weights of the bag are his work. (16 : 11.)
What a revolution must be wrought in the commercial
morality of any modern people, in order to render universally
acceptable such a sentiment as.
Balances of deceit are the abomination of fehovah ;
But a just weight is his delight !
Because lying lips are the abomination of fehovah, the
Hebrew theory of right tolerated no slander ; and a false witness
was a maul, and a sword,, and a sharp arrow. On the other hand
the cultivation of a charitable disposition was regarded as of prime
importance. If thine enemy be hungry, give him bread to eat;
arid if he be thirsty, give him water to drink.
* * * * fehovah shall reward thee. (25:21.) Particu-
larly, there was required kindness to the poor, who were counted
wards of the Almighty ; He that oppresseth the poor reproacheth
his Maker; But he that hath mercy on the needy honoreth him.
(14 : 31.) The righteous taketh knowledge of the cause of the
poor. (29 : 7.)
It is obvious that these and many similar passages teach a
philanthropy as genuine and, because founded directly upon God,
more enduring than the boasted Altruism at present so fashion
able in certain circles. Perhaps, however, no better gauge of a
people's morals can be found than the relative position of the
family. When lax views concerning that prevail, the whole social
fabric is unsound. Israel is conspicuous in history for the sacred
ness with which she invested the marriage relation : Whoso find
eth a wife, findeth a good thing, and obtaineth favor of fehovah.
(18 : 22.) No warnings are more frequent or solemn than those
against matrimonial infidelity. Parental responsibilities, and the
reciprocal duties of children are emphasized repeatedly, and

 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE. 25
we need not stop to illustrate them, for the sufficient reason that
these maxims are already in everybody's mouth.
Exploring the still subtier sources of conduct as manifested
by the individual, we trace these also to this common fountain of
all the rest. He who walketh in his integrity, feareth the Lord.
(14: 2.)
How thoroughly the conviction that, to those on God's side,
all things work together for good, was imbedded in Jewish
.thought, may be seen in such profound conceptions as, the wicked
is a ransom, for the righteous ;
And the treacherous comet h in the room of the upright (21 :
18), or, The wealth of the sinner is laid up for the righteous.
(13: 22). That the prevalence of such sentiments was not a
substitute for personal exertion, but an incentive to it, even a
cursory examination makes abundantly evident. Feeling them
selves God-kept, they felt more than selfish interest in keeping
themselves. It was a religious duty as well.
Since the primal command, " In the sweat of thy face shalt
thou eat bread," a fundamental element of this self-conservation
is industry. It emulates. In Proverbs, the God-given instinct of
the ant, which Provideth her food in the summer. (6 : 8. ) It
preserves from the fate of the slothful, who shall come under
tribute. (12: 24.) It is a defence against the j/r(?«^ »/a« arwzsif
of Poverty (24 : 34), and raises the diligent to the fellowship of
kings (22: 29). Closely allied, too, with zeal in getting, is
economy in use, and frugality in spending ; He that loveth wine
and oil shall not be rich. (21: 17.)
The educational scheme of the Hebrews contemplated culti
vation of the intellect, but not alone nor as an end in itself. The
spiritual was to be cultivated through the intellect. This thought
sounds like the ever-recurring keynote of a symphony through
out Proverbs. Consequently, wherever we find a suggestion of
mental culture, almost invariably it is mentioned as simply the
gateway to moral enlightenment. Thus the outcome of seeking
knowledge as silver {2: 4), is that thou shalt understand the fear
of the Lord, and find the knowledge of God. As might be ex
pected from such fundamental principles, we find great emphasis
put upon development of the moral nature: Keep thy heart with
all diligence ; For out of it are the issues of life. (16 : 19.) The
impossibility of such keeping, without practicing the elementary
virtue of self-restraint, is acknowledged in such sentiments as :
Whosoever is deceived by wine is not wise (20: i) ; He that
curbs his own spirit excels the military conqueror (16: 32) ; and
he that is beguiled by the blandishments of the courtesan is void
of understanding (7 : 7). Guided by such principles, and watch
ful in their application.

26 THE ETHICS OF MISHLE.
The path of the righteous is as the dawning light.
That shineth more and more unto the perfect day. (4 : 18.)
As the traveler, pausing on a country's border, lingers a little
to call before him its varied features and diverse scenes, and
blend them all into a single characteristic picture which he may
carry with him while hastening on to other lands, so may we
profitably turn now a short backward glance upon the territory
thus rapidly traversed, while we inquire what are the social condi
tions of the region of our sojourn. It is no easy life to portray
upon a single canvass. There have passed before us the hunter
and the husbandman ; the soldier and the statesman ; the man of
high estate and the brother of low degree. We have passed among
the lowing herds, the ripening vintage, and the busy mart, through
mirthful and through serious hours. But through them all the
Hebrew has been grave and earnest, like Isaac in the fields at even
tide. Life, with him, is a reality, with an impartial Judge to mark
his good or ill. Consequently these Proverbs which show us the
innermost thought, the feelings, reasonings, and moral impulses of
Hebrew society, show us at the same time a people whom it is
impossible not to respect. Their close communion with Jehovah and
constant life in his sight elevated the mind and disciplined the judg
ment of the whole people. Hence the phenomenon, without a
parallel, of a nation in which such sentiments and sayings could
become current coin. To speak, in a single word, the volume to
which this exhibit of Israel's social condition through her Prov
erbs invites, the social condition of -the originators may fairly be
assumed to be in many points akin to that of a nation largely'
moulded by these sayings^Scotland.

YALE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY

3 9002 08844 7538