MtyGG YALE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY WORD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT BY- MARVIN R. VINCENT, D.D. BAI-DWIN PROFESSOR OF SACRED LITERATURE IN UNION THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY, NEW VORK VOLUME IV. THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES THE EPISTLE TO THE GALATIANS THE PASTORAL EPISTLES THE EPISTLE TO THE HEBREWS NEW YORK CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS 1903 COPYRIGHT, 1900, BY CHARLES, SCRIBNER'S SONS THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES ABBREVIATIONS, ETC. A. v. Authorised Version of 1611. Apoc. Apocalypse. Cit. Cited. Citn. Citation. Class. Greek and Koman classical authors. Comm. Commentary. Comp. Compare. Const. Construe, = Equivalent to. f . and ff. Following. LXX. Septuagint Version of the Old Testament. For the sake of brevity the Apocryphal books are included under this sign. The numbers of the Psalms when cited from the LXX are given according to the enumeration of the LXX, and not of the EngUsh Bible. Lit. Literally. O. T. : N. T. Old Testament: New Testament. Bend. Bender. Kev. Revised Version of the New Testament, 1881. Kev. T. Revisers' Text of the New Testament. T. B. Textus Receptus. Vulg. Vulgate or Latin Translation of the New Testament. P". The word or phrase occurs only in Paul's vfritlngs. op. The word or phrase does not occur in Paul's writings. "LXX. The word or phrase does not occur in the Septuagint. "Class. The word or phrase does not occur in classical writers. N. T.o. The word or phrase occurs in the New Testament only here. Past". The word or phrase occurs only in the Pastoral Epistles. Pasts. Pastoral Epistles. "Past. The word or phrase does not occur in the Pastoral Epistles. THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES. INTRODUCTION. THE FIRST EPISTLE. Thessalonica was situated on the Thermaic Gulf, a fine harbour, affording anchorage for large ships directly in front of the city.* The situation commanded the trade of the Macedonian waters, and was connected inland with the plain of the Axius, one of the great levels of Macedonia, and with the plain of the Strymon, by a pass across the peninsula of Chalcidice. It was the chief station on the Via Egnatia, the great Roman road which ran from Dyrrhachium through Epirus, Macedonia, and Thrace to Byzantium. In Paul's day it was a free city, the capital of the whole province and the most populous of its towns. Its extensive trade with all parts of the world accounts in part for the rapid spread of the news of the success of the gospel (1 Th. i. 8). The population consisted of the original Graeco- Macedonian inhabitants, mixed with many Romans and some Jews. The same heathen deities were worshipped as in other Graeco-Roman communities, and the worship of the Cabeiri had been introduced from Samothrace.f Paul's first visit; to Thessalonica is related in Acts xvii. ; and the account must be filled out, as far as possible, by means * " Medio flexu litoris." Pliny, H. N. iv. 10. t The Cabeiri were Pelasgic deities worshipped in the islands between Euboea and the Hellespont, on the adjacent coasts of Asia Minor, and at Thebes and Andania in Greece. They were four in number, answering to Demeter, Persephone, Hades, and Hermes in the Greek mythology. Through out the Bomau period of Greek history the Cabeiric mysteries were held only seeond to the Eleusinian, and many Bomans of high position were initiated. 3 4 INTRODUCTION TO THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES. of the references in the two letters. From the Acts it appears that he remained only three weeks ; but the first Epistle indicates that a large and flourishing church had been formed, chiefly of Gentiles (i. 8, 9) ; and from this, and from the facts that the PhUippians, twice during his stay, sent him pecuniary aid (Philip, iv. 16), and that he labored for his own support, his visit would seem to have befen longer. According to the narrative in Acts, he secured some con verts from among the Jews, but more from the pious Greeks or Proselytes, and many prominent women. Nothing is said of his labours among the heathen. The author of the Acts has, apparently, recorded the least important part of his work, which was evidently begun, according to his usual practice, in the synagogue. The principal part of it, however, was not done in the synagogue. The cause of Paul's departure from Thessalonica was a persecution instigated by the Jews, who used the vulgar pagan rabble as their instruments. Most of the Christian converts were from the better classes, and the Politarchs were not dis posed to interfere actively. But the riot was a serious matter. A powerful, dangerous, lasting sentiment was aroused in the class which fostered it (see ch. ii. 14). The charge against Paul was that of treason against the Emperor, and the Poli tarchs were forced to take active measures lest they should incur the charge of condoning treason. Their course was the mildest for which they could find precedent. The accused were bound over to keep the peace, and as security was exacted from Jason and the leading Christians of Thessa lonica, it implied that they were under obligation to prevent Paul from coming to the city again. Paul, after his departure, was distressed, lest his converts, who had b^en only partially instructed, might faU from their faith. He had twice made the attempt to revisit them, but m vain. He had sent Timothy to inquire into their condition and to estabhsh and comfort them (iii. 2). Timothy had now rejomed him at Corinth, and the information which he brought called forth the first letter. The letter, though official, is not stiff nor condescending. INTRODUCTION TO THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES. 5 It reveals a quick, intelligent sympathy with the burdens and sufferings of the church, and a full appreciation of their patience and fidelity. They are the subject of the Apostle's thoughts, wishes, and prayers ; they are his joy and his crown. The tone of the Epistle, while peculiarly affectionate, is never theless decided, and exacting in moral demand. It has nothing of the legal or ecclesiastical character. It is pervaded, in parts, with the tension and anxiety of the interval between Paul's departure from Thessalonica and the reception of Timothy's report. Timothy's news had been substantially good. The church had remained true to the faith against all assaults. But a degree of mistrust had arisen concerning the sincerity of Paul's interest for the church, which must have come from the outside. Accordingly in the second chapter he takes on an apologetic tone. Some lack of religious steadfastness among the members has made itself evident, and some signs of not fully appreciating the relations of their faith to Christian morality. There has arisen a tendency to assume that the second coming of Christ is close at hand, and that all old relations and duties are therefore done away. On the other hand, an opposite tendency has shown itself, a reaction against the enthusiasm evoked by the expectation of the parousia, which calls for the admonitions, " Quench not the spirit : despise not prophesyings : prove all things : hold fast that which is good." Mistakes have become current respect ing the lot of such Christians as may die before the Lord's coming. There is a possible hint of strained relations with the church-superintendents (v. 12-15) and of occasions given to the enemies of Christianity for malicious criticism (iv. 12). But the main objects of the letter are, to strengthen the bond between the writer and the chureh, to detach the church from the errors and abominations of heathen life, and to correct misunderstandings and give comfort as regards the dead ill Christ. The language of the letter is simple, taking on a rhetoiical character only in certain isolated passages (ii. 19 f. ; iii. 8 f.). It is not without picturesqueness (i. 8, 9; ii. 1, 6, 16, 17, 19, iii. 3, 8, 11; iv. 1, 6, 12; v. 2, 3, 5, 8, l9). There is an 6 INTRODUCTION TO THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES. occasional tendency to amplification (i. 2 f., 8; ii. 11, 13: iii. 2, 7, 9, 10; v. 1, 3, 5, 23, etc.), and to round off the ends ,pf sentences with adverbial phrases (i. 5, 6; ii. 2, 16, 17; iii. 3, 9, etc.). There is to be noted the frequent introduction of expressions which recognise the knowledge and remem brance of the writer's correspondents, as wa^w? otBare even as ye hnow: also the forms of adjuration and comparison (ii. 5, 10 ; iii. 6). A certain ruggedness and lack of symmetry in the structure of sentences appears at times (i. 2 ff., 8 ; ii. 10 ff., 17 f., 19 f.; iv. 1 f., 3 ff.). The vocabulary is relatively small. Repetitions and similarities of expression occur. There are no citations from the Old Testament, and no use of apocryphal writings can be shown. The mode of expression is thoroughly Pauline. The character of the Epistle does not lead us to expect many of the technical terms of the Pauline dogmatic; but such as we do find are Pauline, as e/cXoiy^ election ; Ka'kelv to call ; ajioi saints ; dyiaa-iMi; sanctification ; fiT) eiSdrei rov Beov not knowing (rod. There are also to be noted the characteristic play of words (ii. 4) ; paradox (i. 6) ; mixed metaphor (v. 5), and antithesis of prepositions (i. 5 j iv. 7; ii. 3, etc.). There are relatively few hapaxlegomena, some peculiar uses of words common in the New Testament; possibly a dozen words and modes of expression which appear only in the deutero-Pauline writings, and a few which are almost exclusively confined to the writings of Luke and the Epistle to the Hebrews. The authenticity of the Epistle is generally conceded. It has been assailed by Baur, Steck, Holsten, and Loman. THE SECOND EPISTLE. The authenticity and genuineness of this Epistle have been challenged since the beginning of the present century.* Its integrity has also been questioned on the assumed ground of a combination of a genuine Pauline epistle with interpo lated matter (P. W. Schmidt). It has been ascribed to * J. E. C. Schmidt, DeWette, Kern, Baur, Hilgenfeld, Pfieiderer, Weiz sacker, Loman, Holtzmann, Schmiedel. INTRODUCTION TO THE THESSALONIAN EPISTLES. 7 Timothy. Attempts have also been made to prove that it was earlier in date than the first Epistle (Ewald, Baur, Davidson) ; but there seems to be, on the whole, no suf ficient reason for refusing it a place among the genuine Pauline Epistles. The external testimony in its favor is ancient and good, while the resemblances in manner and phraseology to the other Pauline writings cannot be evaded. The vocabulary is Pauline. The list of non-Pauline words is small and not important. As distinguished from all other Pauline letters, the two Thessalonian epistles exhibit a striking relationship, extending to sequences of thought, articulation of sentences, and peculiar expressions and usages. In not a few cases, the same subjects are treated with almost the same words.* Both letters have an eschato logical drift ; both exhibit, without specially emphasising it, the writer's apostolic consciousness ; both- treat moral ques tions from the religious point of view.f The second Epistle appears to have been written some months after the first, because of some later information received by Paul, who was probably still in Corinth. The circumstances of the church were substantially the same, although there appears to have been a growth in faith and charity (i. 3, 4) ; but the idea of the imminent second coming of the Lord had assumed such proportions as to cause restlessness and impatience, and a measure of social dis(organisation and fanaticism. A spurious epistle in Paul's name, announcing the immediate advent of the Lord, appears to have been circulated (ii. 2). The main design of this second letter is to correct false views concerning the second advent, and to rebuke the idleness and disorder into which some of the Thessalonian Christians had fallen. * Comp., for instance, 2 Th. i. 1-7 ; ii. 13-17 ; iii. 1, 3, 12, and 1 Th. i. 3, 4f., 6, 7 ; ii. 13, 15, 16; iii. 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. t THe authenticity of the 2d Epistle is defended by Jowett, Godet, Weiss, Lunemann, Schenkel, Reuss, Bleek, Kenan, Salmon, Klopper, Jiilicher, Bornemann, Zahn, McGiffert. COMMENTARIES, ETC., ON THE THESSALONIAN LETTERS.* GERMAN. W. Bornemann. In the Meyer Series. 6th ed. Die Thessalo- nicherhriefe, 1894. P. W. Schmiedel, in the Hand-Gommentar zwm Neuen Testa'ment, by Holtzmann, Lipsius, Schmiedel, and Von Soden, 1893. P. Schmid, Der erste Thessalonicherbrief 'neu erklart, with Excursus on 2d Epistle, 1885. F. Zimmer, Der Text der Thessalonicherbriefe, etc. Textual Apparatus and Commen tary, 1893. ENGLISH. J. B. Lightfoot, both Epistles, in Notes on Epistles of St. Paul from. Unpublished Commentaries, 1895. C. J. Ellicott, A Critical and Orammatical Commentary on St. Paul's Epistles to the Thessa lonians. B. Jowett, TJie Epistles of St. Paul to the Thessalonians, Galatians and Bomans. Translation and Com'mentary, 3d ed. 1894. J. Eadie, A Commentary on the Greek Text of the Epistles of Paul to the Thessalonians, 1877. J. Hutchison, Lectures, chiefly Expository, on Paul's 1st and 2d Epistles to the Thessaloni ans, 1883. J. B. Lightfoot, Biblical, Essays, chs. VL, VII. G. G. Findlay, in Camb'Hdge Bible for Schools. J. Denney, in Eiq)osi- tor's Bible. On Macedonia, L. Heuzey and H. Daumet, Mission ArcMolo- gique de Mac&doine, 1876. Account of the expedition under the auspices of Napoleon III. for the exploration of Macedonia. M. E. Vincent, Philippians and Philemon, Introduction. Interna tional Commentary, 1897. » No attempt is made to present an exhaustive catalogue of the Literature. 8 THE FIEST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. CHAPTER L 1. The address of the first Epistle is shorter than that of any of the Pauline letters. In the other Epistles Paul either indicates the contents of the letter, or adds details concern ing the writer or his correspondents, or amplifies the apos tolic greeting. The names of Silvanus and Timothy are added to that of Paul as the senders of the letter. They were with him at Corinth when it was written (Acts xviii. 5; 2 Cor. i. 19). They had assisted him in the foundation of the Thessalonian Church (Acts xvi. 1-3; xvii. 4, 10, 14). Paul's official title " Apostle " is omitted in the addresses of both Epistles, although in 1 Th. ii. 6 he uses cnroa-roXoi apostles, including Silvanus and Timothy under that title. The title appears in all the other Epistles except Philippians and Philemon. The reason for its omission in every case appears to have been the intimate and affectionate character of his relations with the parties addressed, which rendered an appeal to his apostolic authority unnecessary. Paul does not confine the name of apostle to the twelve.* Silvanus. The Silas of the Acts, where alone the form 2tXas occurs. By Paul always "EiXovavoi;, of which SiXa? is a contraction, as Aou/ea? from AovKavo^. Similar contract ions occur in Class., as 'AXefa? for 'A\€^avBpo irarpl Kal KVpuoa 'Itjo-oO Hpicrra in God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ, 1 Th. i. 1 ; comp. 2 Th. i. 1. In both Hebrew andN. T. usage, iKKX-rj- tria implies a community based on a special religious idea, and established in a special way; In N. T. it is also used in 12 WORD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. 1 a narrower sense, of a single church, or of a church confined to a single place. So Rom. xvi. 5, etc. In God the Father, etc. Const, with the church, and comp. 2 Th. i. 1. The phrase "the church in God" is pecul iar to the Thessalonian Epistles. Elsewhere "of God" (1 Cor. X. 32; xi. 16, 22; xv. 9, etc.); "of the saints" (1 Cor. xiv. 33). Lightfoot suggests that the word iKKXrj aia can scarcely have been stamped with so definite a Christian meaning in the minds of these recent and early converts as to render the addition "in God the Father," etc., superfluous. Grace to you and peace (j(dpi'i viuv Kal elprjvrj^. In Romans, 1st and 2d Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Phi lippians, the salutation is, Crrace to you and peace from Crod our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ : Colossians omits the last five words of this : 2 Thessalonians omits our before Father. On the union of the Greek and Jewish forms of salutation, see on 1 Cor. i. 3. 2. We give thanks {evxapiaroijuev'). According to Paul's habit, a thanksgiving follows the salutation, commonly with the verb evxapiareiv, as here; but in 2d Corinthians and Ephes ians, evXoyrjro'; 6 0e6<{ blessed be God. The thanksgiving is omitted only in Galatians. The verb evxapiareiv occurs only in later Greek, and there but rarely. In LXX only in Apocr. See Judith viii. 25 ; 2 Macc. i. 11 ; x. 7 ; 3 Macc. vii. 16. In the N. T. Epistles, P"- Originally to do a good turn; hence, to return a favour. The meaning to give thanks is late. The kindred noun evxapiaria giving of thanks, is found often in Paul. As a designation of the Lord's Supper (Ilucharisf) it is not found in the N. T. Perhaps the earliest instance of its use in that sense is in Ignatius. See Philad. iv. ; Smyrn. vi., viii. ; Eph. xiii. Comp. Just. Mart. Apol. i., 64, 65. In we give thanks, it is not easy to decide whether Paul uses we as plural, or in the sense of J. Rom. iii. 9 seems to Ch. I.] THE FIRST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 18 be a clear case of the latter usage. In 1 Th. iii. 1, 2, ijvBoK'Tjaafiev we thoiight it good, and i'jrefj.yjra/iev we sent, can, apparently, refer only to Paul ; and similarly, in 1 Th. iii. 6, TTjBos ^/tas unto us, can hardly include Silvanus who came with Timothy (comp. iii. 5). But it is significant that, in the Epis tles which are written in Paul's name alone (Romans, Gala tians, Ephesians), only I is used, unless we except Gal. i. 8, which is doubtful. Paul and Timothy appear jointly as cor respondents in Philippians, but the first person predominates throughout the letter. The same is true of 1st Corinthians, where Paul and Sosthenes are associated in the address, but the singular pronoun is used almost throughout. (See iv. 10-13 ; ix. 4, 5, 25, 26). In Colossians Paul and Timothy appear in the address. The plural prevails to i. 23, and alternates with the singular throughout the remainder. The alternations in 2d Corinthians are very bewildering. On the whole, I think that occasional instances of the epistolary plural must be granted. It is not, however, Paul's habitual usage. We is often employed as in ordinary corre spondence or argument, where the writer or speaker associates himself with his readers or hearers. Abundant illustrations of this may be seen in Rom. vi. and viii. ; but in other cases, when Paul speaks in the plural, he usually associates his fellow-ministers, mentally, with himself.* Making mention (^fiveiav Troiovfievoi). For the phrase see Rom. i. 9 ; Eph. i. 16 ; Philem. 4. Always in connection with prayer. In the sense of remember it appears in LXX, Job xiv. 13. In Ps. cxi. 4, to make a memorial. See further, on without ceasing, ver. 3. in my prayers (eVi). When engaged in offering my prayers. 'EttI here blends the local with the temporal sense. Prayers (^Trpoaevx&v'). The more general term, and limited to prayer to God ; while SeijaK petitionary prayer, supplica- * The discussion in detail may be found in Bomemann's Thessalonicher briefe, p. 37 f. and p. 53. See also Spitta, Urchristenthum, p. 120 f., and Lightfoot, Notes on Epistles of St. Paul, p. 22. 14 WORD STUDIBS IN THE NEW TtSSTAH^^'^' ^^^' ^' tion, may be addressed to man. Paul alone associates the two words. See Philip, iv. 6 ; Eph. vi. 18. I^ classical Greek the word does not occur in the sense of prayer. It is found in later Greek, meaning a place for prayer, in which sense it appears in Acts xvi. 13, 16. It signified either a synagogue, or an open praying-place outside of a city.* 3. Without ceasing (aliaXeirtrWi) . P°. In LXX see 1 Macc. xii. 11 ; 2 Macc. iii. 26 ; ix. 4 ; xiii. 12 ; xv. 7 ; 3 Macc. vi. 33. Should be construed with making mention, not with remembering, as A. V. and Rev. The salutations of Paul reproduce ordinary conventional forms of greeting. Thus the familiar Greek greeting x'^'-P^'-^ ^^ joyf'ul, hail, Welcome, appears in X'^/'*' grace. This was perceived by Theodore of Mopsuestia (350-428 a.d.), who, in his com mentary on Ephesians, says that in the preface to that letter Paul does very much as we do when we say " So and so to So and so, greeting " (6 helva rm Seivi xai/>eti'). Deissmann gives some interesting parallels from ancient papyri. For instance, a letter dated 172 B.C., from an Egyptian lady to her brother or husband : " Isias to her brother Hephaestion, greeting (xaipeiv^. If you are well, and other things happen as you would wish, it would be in accordance with my constant prayer to the gods. I myself am well, and the boy ; and all at home make constant remembrance of you." Comp. Rom. i. 9 ; Eph. i. 16 ; Philem. 4. Again : " Ammohios fo his sister Tachnumi, abundant greeting (ra irXeiara x«4'"'')" Before all things, I pray that you may be in health ; aiid each day I make the act of worship for you." In these * There has been some dispute as to whether it vyas applied to a syna gogue, but the usage of Josephus and Philo seems decisive in favour of that meaning. See Jos. Vita, 54 ; Juvenal, Sat. III. 296 ; Schurer, The Je-wish People in the Time of Jesus Christ, Div. IL, Vol. IL, p. 73 ; Wendt, Apostel- geschichte, on Aots xvi. 13. An inscription preserved in the Berlin Egyptian Museum testifies to the meaning synagogue as early as the third century b.c. Zenobia and Vaballath, about 270 a.d., decree the restoration of an inscrip-' tion on a synagogue, as follows : Boo-iXeJs HToXe/iaros 'Eiep-yirris rijv Trpoo-euxV A(Tv\ov King Ptolemy Euergetes [decrees'] that the place of pra'yer [fee] on as-ylum. See Deissmann, Neue Bibelstudien, p. 49. Ch. I.] THB FIRST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 15 specimens the conventional salutations in correspondence include the general greeting (xaifeii') and the statement that prayer is made for the correspondent's welfare ; and the words constant and daily are attached to the act of prayer. It is further to be noticed that many passages of Paul's Epistles give evidence of having been shaped by expressions in letters received by him from the parties he is addressing. In his answer he gives them back their own words, as is common in correspondence. Thus, making men tion of you and remembering your work, etc., together with the statement that Timothy reports that you have a good remem- hrance of us (ch. iii. 6), all together suggest that Paul had before him, when writing to the Thessalonians, a letter which Timothy had brought from them. Other instances will be noted as they occur.* Work — labour — patience (epyov — kottov — vTroiJ,ovrj<;'). "Epyov work, may mean either the act, the simple trans action, or the process of dealing with anything, or the result -of the dealing, — as a book or a picture is called a work. K0V09 labour, from Koirreiv to strike or hew; hence, laborious, painful exertion. "Tiro/juovrj patience, patient endurance and faithful persistence in toil and suffering. See on 2 Pet. i. 6 ; Jas. V. 7. The genitives, of faith, love, hope, mark the gen erating principles of the work and labour and patience, which set their stamp upon each ; thus, work which springs iroTCi faith, and is characteristic of faith. The phrase patience -of hope is found only here ; but see Rom. v. 4 ; viii. 25 ; XV. 4 ; 1 Cor. xiii. 7 ; Heb. vii. 11, 12. For virofiovrj in LXX, see 1 Chron. xxix. 15 ; Job xiv. 19 ; Ps. ix. 18 ; xxxviii. 7 ; Jer. xiv. 8. We have here the great triad of Christian graces, corresponding to 1 Cor. xiii. Hope is prominent throughout the two Epistles. The triad appears, 1 Th. V. 8 ; Gal. v. 5, 6 ; 1 Cor. xiii. 13 ; Eph. iv. 2-5 ; * See an interesting article by J. Eendel Harris, Expositor, Vol. IV. , No. III., 1898, "A Study in Letter- writing." Also an article by Walter Lock, {Expositor, Vol. IL, No. I., 1897, "1 Corinthians viii. 1-9. A Suggestion." 16 WORD STUDrSS IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. I. CoL i. 4, 5; Heb. x. 22-24; 1 Pet. i. 21-22. Comp. 1 Th. ii. 9 ; V. 8 ; 2 Th. iii. 5, 8 ; 1 Cor. xv. 10, 58 ; 2 Cor. xi. 27 ; Apoc. ii. 2. In our Lord, etc. (rov Kvpiov). Lit. of our Lord. For a similar use of the genitive, see J. v. 42 ; 1 J. ii. 5, 15 ; Acts ix. 31 ; Rom. i. 5 ; iii. 18, 22, 26, etc. Connect with hope only. Before our God and Father. Const, with remembering, and comp. ch. ii. 19; iii. 9. 4. Election of God. Incorrect. Const, of or by (wtto) God with beloved. 'EKXoyij election, in N. T., mostly by Paul. Elsewhere only Acts ix. 15, and 2 Pet. i. 10. This, and the kindred words, iKXeyeiv to choose, and iKXeKro's chosen or elect, are used of God's selection of men or agencies for special missions or attainments ; but neither here nor else where in the N. T. is there any warrant for the revolting doctrine that God has predestined a definite number of man kind to eternal life, and the rest to eternal destruction.* The sense in this passage appears to be defined by the suc ceeding context. The Thessalonians had been chosen to be members of the Christian church, and their conduct had justified the choice. See vv. 5-10. 5. For (on'). Incorrect. Rend, how that. It is explana tory of your election. For similar usage see 1 Cor. i. 26. Our gospel. The gospel as preached by Paul and his colleagues. Comp. Rom. ii. 16 ; xvi. 25 ; Gal. i. 11 ; ii. 2 ; 1 Th. ii. 4. My gospel is sometimes used in connection with an emphasis upon some particular feature of the gospel, as in Rom. ii. 16, where Paul is speaking of the judgment of the world by Christ; or in Rom. xvi. 25, where he is refer. ring to the extension of the messianic kingdom to the Gen^ tiles. • See the note in Vol. III., p. 133 ff. Ch. I.] THE FIRST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 17 In word (iv Xdytp). The gospel did not appeal to them as mere eloquent and learned discourse. In power (iv Bvvajjxi). Power of spiritual persuasion and conviction : not power as displayed in miracles, at least not principally, although miraculous demonstrations may be included. Paul rarely alludes to his power of working miracles. Assurance ('irXrjpoopia') . Assured persuasion of the preacher that the message was divine. The word not in pre- Christian Greek writers, nor in LXX. Only in one other passage in Paul, Col. ii. 2. See Heb. vi. 11 ; x. 22. We were (iyevrjOrjiiev'). More correctly, we shewed or proved ourselves. 6. Followers (fiifiijraV). More literally and better, imi tators. Only once outside of Paul's writings, Heb. vi. 12. Comp. 1 Th. iii. 9 ; 2 Th. iii. 7 ; 1 Cor. iv. 16 ; xi. 1 ; Gal. iv. 12 ; Philip, iii. 17 ; iv. 9. And of the Lord. Guarding against any possible impu tation of self-assertion or conceit. Comp. 1 Cor. xi. 1. Tribulation (0'Xiyjrei). See on Matt. xjii. 21. Referring • especially to persecutions at the hands of the Jews (Acts xvii. 5ff.), which probably continued after Paul's departure from Thessalonica. 7. An ensample (rvirov). See on 1 Pet. v. 3. Macedonia and Achaia. Shortly after 146 B.C., all Greece south of Macedonia and Epirus was formed into a Roman province under the name of Achaia, and Macedonia with Epirus into another province called Macedonia. 8. Hath sounded forth (i^'nxvrai}. N. T.". LXX Joel iii. 14; Sir. xl. 13, of thunder; 3 Macc?. iii. 2, of a report. It means a loud, unmistakable proclamation. VOL. IV. — 2 18 WORD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. I. The word of the Lord (6 Xoyo^ rov Kvpiov). The phrase in Paul only in these Epistles. Comp. 2 Th. iii. 1 ; iv. 15. Comparatively frequent in Acts. Paul has X6yo<; Oeov or rov deov word of God, eight times, and Xoyos rov xP^°"rov word of the Christ, once. Col. iii. 16. The meaning here is the gospel, regarded either as the message proceeding from the Lord, or concerning him. It is the evayyeXiov 6eov the gospel of God: see ch. ii. 2, 8, 9; Rom. i. 1; xv. 16; 2 Cor. xi. 7. As Professor Sanday remarks on Rom. i. 1, " it is probably a mistake in these cases to restrict the force of the genitive to one particular aspect: all aspects are included in which the gospel is in any way related to God and Christ." In every place. A rhetorical exaggeration, signifying the whole known world. It is explained by the extensive commercial relations of Thessalonica. Comp. Rom. i. 8 ; Col. i. 6, 23 ; 2 Cor. ii. 14. Is spread abroad a^eXijXvOev). Lit. and better, Aas ^owe forth. * 9. They themselves shew (avroi airay yeXXovaiv). They themselves in contrast with we, ver. 8. We need not speak of anything : they themselves volunteer testimony to your faith. Shew, more correctly announce or report. -f * Much discussion has arisen as to the proper connection of this passage. As punctuated and rendered in A.V. and Rev. the sequence is irregular. There is a clear antithesis between dXV but and oi ii,6vov not only ; and the sentence, if regular, would have closed with in every place. As it is, a new subject and predicate (^your faith — has gone forth') is introduced with in every place. The simplest and best solution of the difficulty is to accept the irregular construction as characteristically Pauline. Others place a colon after of the Lord, and begin a new clause with not only. t Dr. J. Rendel Harris offers as a conjectural reading (l7ro77^X6Te ye report, taking the passage as an exact parallel to ch. ii. 1, ye know that our entrance ¦was not in vain. He thinks that thus a reference would be shown to a letter from the Thessalonians to Paul, and that the difBculty would be relieved which grows out of the improbability of a newly founded church exerting so extensive an influence. Expositor, Vol. IV., No. III., 1898. Ch. I.] THE FIRST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 19 Entering in (eiaoBov). Comp. ch. ii. 1. The thought of ver. 5 is resumed. The repetition of the word in ch. ii. 1, and of in vain in ch. iii. 5, may point to expressions in a letter of the Thessalonians. Unto you (irpb<;'). The preposition combines with the sense of direction that of relation and intercourse. Comp. Matt. xiii. 56 ; Mk. ix. 16 ; J. i. 1 ; Acts iii. 25 ; Col. iv. 5 ; Heb. ix. 20. Ye turned unto God (iirearpe-^are irpb<; rov deov). Comp. Acts xiv. 15. The exact phrase only here. The verb is common in LXX, with both Kvpiov Lord and deov God. Idols. See on 1 Cor. viii. 3. The word would indicate that the majority of the converts were heathen and not Jews. Living and true (^avn Kal aXrj6ivS>). The only instance in N. T. of this collocation. It does not occur in O. T. For aXrjdivo<; genuine, see on J. i. 9 ; iv. 37 ; vii. 28. Mostly in the Johannine writings. 10. To wait for (avafieveiv). N. T.°. Several times in LXX, as Job ii. 9 ; vii. 2 ; Isa. lix. 11. Paul's usual word is aireKBexofiai : see Rom. viii. 19, 23, 25 ; 1 Cor. i. 7 ; Philip, iii. 20. From heaven (e« r&v ovpav&v). Lit. from the heavens. Comp. 1 Cor. xv. 47 ; 1 Th. iv. 16 ; 2 Th. i. 7. Paul uses the unclassical plural much oftener than the singular. Although the Hebrew equivalent has no singular, the sin gular is almost universal in LXX, the plural occurring mostly in the Psalms. Ovpavos is from a Sanscrit word meaning to cover or encompass. The Hebrew shamayim sig nifies height, high district, the upper regions. Similarly we have in N. T. e'l' iryjriaroK in the highest (places). Matt. xxi. 9; L. ii. 14 : iv ui^ijXot? in the high (places), Heb. i. 3. Paul's usage is evidently coloured by the Rabbinical conception of 20 WORD STUDIES IN THB NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. U a series of heavens : see 2 Cor. xii. 2 ; Eph. iv. 10. Some Jewish teachers held that there were seven heavens,* others three. The idea of a series of heavens appears in patristic writings, in Thomas Aquinas's doctrine of the celestial hie rarchies, and in Dionysius the Areopagite. Through the scholastic theologians it passed into Dante's Paradiso with its nine heavens, f The words to await his Son from heaven strike the keynote of this Epistle. Jesus which delivered (^Irjaovv rbv pv6fievov). More cor rectly, delivereth. See on Matt. i. 21. 'VveaOai to deliver, mostly in Paul. Lit. to draw to one's self. Almost invaria bly with the specification of some evil or danger or enemy. SwfetK to save is often used in a similar sense, of deliverance from disease, from sin, or from divine wrath: see Matt. i. 21; Mk. vi. 56 ; L. viii. 36 ; Acts ii. 40 ; Rom. v. 9 : but aml^eiv is a larger and more comprehensive term, including not only deliverance from sin and death, but investment with all the privileges and rewards of the new life in Christ. The wrath to come (t^? opyrj'i ttJ? ipxofJievrjv). Lit. the wrath which is coming. The wrath, absolutely, of the wrath of God, as Rom. v. 9 ; xii. 19 ; 1 Th. ii. 16. Sometimes for the punishment which wrath inflicts, as Rom. xii. 4 ; Eph. V. 6 ; Col. iii. 6. See on J. iii. 36. The phrase wrath to come is found in Matt. iii. 7 ; L. iii. 7. Coming does not necessarily imply the thought of speedy or imminent approach, but the general tone of the Epistle points in that direction. CHAPTER II. 1. Was not in vain (oi Kevrj yiyovev). More accurately, hath not proved vain. Kevrj is empty. Maraia, also rendered vain, is fruitless. * See Stanley's condensation of Wetstein, in Com. on Corinthians, on 2 Cor. xii. 2. t See B. F. Westcott, Religious Thought in the TTest. Ch. n.] THE PIRST EPISTLE TO THB THESSALONIANS. 21 2. Having suffered before (irpoira66vre<;). N. T.'^. Although we had suffered. Having been shamefully entreated (v^piadevrev). Comp. Matt. xxii. 6 ; L. xviii. 32 ; Acts xiv. 5. This may have been added because irpoira66vre<; alone might denote the experience of something good; but it is more probably intended as an expansion and illustration of that word. Paul's sensitiveness to personal indignity appears in the nar rative in Acts xvi., which gives the historical explanation of the two words. It appears frequently in 2d Corinthians. As ye know (KadoK oiBare). One of the many character istic expressions of these Epistles which indicate community of experience and sentiment on the part of Paul and his readers. See 1 Th. i. 5, 8 ; ii. 1, 5, 10, 11 ; iii. 3, 4, 12 ; iv. 1, 2, 6, 11 ; V. 1, 11 ; 2 Th. ii. 16; iii. 1, 2.* Philippi. See Acts xvi. 19-40 ; Philip. 1, 30. We waxed bold (iirapprjataad^da). Only once elsewhere In Paul, Eph. vi. 20. Frequent in Acts. Always in N. T. in connection with speaking. Derived from irav every, and prjai<; speaking. Hence irapp'rjaia boldness, bold speaking out of every word. The noun is very often used adverbially, as irapprjaia boldly or openly, Mk. viii. 32 ; see also J. xviii. 20. In Acts always jiera irapp7jaia<; with boldness, comp. Heb. iv. 16. 'Ev irapprjaia in boldness, J. vii. 4 ; xvi. 29 ; Eph. vi. 19 ; Philip, i. 20. Both the verb and the noun are found in LXX. See Lev. xxvi. 13 ; Prov. x. 10 ; Wisd. V. 1 ; 1 Macc. iv. 18 ; Sir. vi. 11. In our God (iv rqi dea> •^/j.&v). Const, with we waxed bold. Their boldness was not mere natural courage, but was inspired by God. There is a slight emphasis on our God, as * Dr. Harris says that the expression must be understood here in the sense "ye have admitted in your letter," or "ye have testified." I do not think that this can be shown. It looks a little like a piece of special pleading. 22 WORD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. 11. contrasted with the idols from which they had turned (ch, i. 9). The phrase only here in N. T. Gospel of God (evayyeXiov rov deov). For the phrase see Mk. i. 14 ; Rom. i. 1 ; xv. 16 ; 2 Cor. xi. 7 ; 1 Th. ii. 8, 9 ; 1 Pet. iv. 17. It points to the monotheistic character of the gospel. In much contention (iv rroXX^ ay&vi). Better conflict. Comp. Col. ii. 1 ; Philip, i. 27 ; 1 Tim. vi. 12 ; Heb. xii. 1. 'Aya>v originally of a contest in the arena ; but it is used of any struggle, outward or inward. 3. Exhortation (irapdKXriai<;). See on L. vi. 24 and 1 Cor. xiv. 3. Exhortation or counsel is Paul's usual sense. Of deceit (e'/c irXavrj's). Better, of error. It may imply deceit as accompanying or causing error, but it does not occur in the sense of deceit. Our exhortation did not pro ceed from any false teaching which we had ourselves received. We were guided by " the spirit of truth " ; see 1 J. iv. 6, and comp. 2 Pet. i. 16. Of uncleanness (ef aKadapaia is explained by some as report or rumour. Common report did not charge us with being flatterers. This meaning is admissible, but the other is simpler. Paul says that they had not descended to flattery in order to make the gospel acceptable. They had not flattered men's self-com placency so as to blind them to their need of the radical work which the gospel demands. Cloke of covetousness (irpodaei irXeove^ia<;). For irpo- (fiaaii see on J. xv. 22. Properly pretext : irpo before, (fsdait a word or saying. Others, less probably, from irpoaiveiv to 24 WORD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. D. cause to shine forth or before. Paul means that he had not used his apostolic office to disguise or conceal avaricious designs. God is witness (deo<; jidprvs). Comp. Rom. i. 9 ; 2 Cor. i. 23 ; Philip, i. 8 ; 1 Th. ii. 10. God or the Lord is witness is a common O. T. formula: see Gen. xxxi. 44, 50 ; 1 Sam. xii. 5, 6 ; xx. 23, 42 ; Wisd. i. 6. For testimony to his con duct, he appeals to the Thessalonians (as ye know) : for testi mony to his motives, he appeals to God. Comp. ver. 10, where there is the double appeal. 6. Of men (ef avdpmirwv). To extract gloijfrom men. When we might have been burdensome (Bwdjxevoi iv fidpei elvai). Lit. being able to be in weight. The phrase iv fidpei in weight is unique in N. T., and does not occur in LXX. The better rendering here is to be in authority. Paul means that his position as an apostle would have warranted him in asserting authority or standing on his dignity, which he did not do. Bapo? weight, in the sense of influence, is found in late Greek. Paul's Epistles were called weighty (^apelai), 2 Cor. x. 10 : others explain as referring to the apostolic right to exact pecuniary support.* 7. Gentle (^Triot). This reading is adopted by Tischen dorf, Weiss, and the Rev. T. Westcott and Hort read v^irioi babes. This gives a stronger and bolder image, and . one which falls in better with the course of thought, in which Paul is asserting his innocence of guile and flattery, and not of harshness. « This interpretation is urged on the ground that iwipap^aat, ver. 9, and 2 Th. iii. 8, Kore/SipTjira, 2 Cor. xii. 16, and d/3op^, 2 Cor. xi. 9, all refer to pecuniary support. Accordingly these words are connected with covetous ness, ver. 5. But they are separated from xXeowefto by a new idea, seeking glory, with which their connection is immediate. Moreover, it is unlikely that Paul would have attached the idea of covetousness to a rightful claim for support. Our explanation is further favoured by the contrasted iT^Trtot, ver. 7. Ch. II.] THB FIRST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 25 Among you (iv jieaw vfi&v). Better, and more literally, in the midst of you, which implies more intimate intercourse than among you. Comp. L. xxii. 27. Nurse (rpot^o?). N. T.°- In Class, sometimes of a mother, and so probably here. See Gal. iv. 19. Cherisheth (ddXirrj). F°. Here and Eph. v. 29. The verb originally means to warm. See LXX, Deut. xxii. 6. Her own children. Note the inversion of metaphor. Paul is first the babe, then the nurse or mother. For similar instances see ch. v. 2, 4 ; 2 Cor. iii. 13-16 ; Rom. vii. 1 ff. See Introduction to 2 Cor., Vol. III., p. xix. 8. Being affectionately desirous (ojieipofievoi). N. T.°. Once in LXX, Job iii. 21. The figure of the nursing mother is continued. She is not satisfied with nursing the child, but interests herself affectionately in all that concerns it. We were willing (rjlBoKovjiev). Better, we were pleased. Imperfect tense : we continued to entertain and manifest our affectionate solicitude. The verb occasionally in later Greek, and often in LXX. In N. T. it is used of God's decrees, as L. xii. 32 ; 1 Cor. i. 21 ; Gal. i. 15 ; CoL i. 19 ; and of the free determination and plans of men, as Rom. xv. 26 ; 2 Cor. V. 8 ; 1 Th. iii. 1. Souls (i/rw;!^;a?). Better lives. See on Rom. xi. 3 ; 1 Cor. XV. 45 ; Mk. xii. 30. 9. Labour — travail (/coVoj/ — fioxdov). The two words are associated in 2 Cor. xi. 27;. 2 Th. iii. 8. Moxdo'i travail, P°. Frequent in LXX. KoVo? emphasises fatigue, jioxda hard- Because we would not be chargeable (irpm rb firj iiri- §aprjaai). Incorrect. Rend, that we might not burden. Put you to expense for our support. Comp. 2 Th. iii. 8. 26 WORD STUDIES IN THB NBW TESTAMENT. [Ch. II. 10. Holily — justly — unblameably (oo-t'ca? — StKoia)? — a/ie'jLirr(o. evKXeiav crown of renown. The Thessalonians were "a chaplet of victory of which Paul might justly make his boast in the day of the Lord" (Ellicott). For are(j)avo<; see on Apoc. iv. 4. Coming (irapovaia). See on Matt. xxiv. 3, and on eVt- v 'Irjaov (Xpiarov), 1 Gov. i. 8 ; 2 Cor. i 14. These expressions refer to a definite time when the Lord is expected to appear, and Paul expects this appearance soon. Attempts to evade this by referring such expressions to the day of death, or to the advance toward perfection after death untU the final judgment, are forced, and are shaped by dogmatic conceptions of the nature of Biblical inspiration.* In the O. T. the phrase day of the Lord denotes a time in which God wiU conspicuously manifest his power and goodness or his penal justice. See Isa. u. 12; Ezek. xiu. 5 ; Joel i. 15 ; u. 11 ; and comp. Rom. ii. 6 The whole class of phrases is rare in N. T- outside of Paul'r Epistles. As a thief (w? KXeirrrji). Comp. Matt. xxiv. 43; L. ai; 39 ; 2 Pet. iii. 10 ; Apoc. xvi. 15, and see on Apoc. iii. S. In the night (iv WKri). The ancient ehurch held that the advent was to be expected at night, on an Easter eve. This gave rise to the custom of vigils. Jerome, on Matt. xxv. 6, says : " It is a tradition of the Jews that Messiah wiU come at midnight, after the likeness of that season in Egypt when the Passover was celebrated, and the Destroyer came, and the Lord passed over the dwelUngs. I think that this idea was perpetuated in the apostolic custom, that, on the day of vigUs, at the Pascha, it was not aUowed to dismiss the people before midnight, siuce they 3spected the advent of Christ." It is noteworthy how many of the gospel lessons on watch- f tdness are associated with the night and a visit by night* See Matt. xxiv. 43 ; xxv. 1-13 ; Mk. x?" 35 ? L. xii. 85, 38 r xvu. 34 ; xU. 20. 3. When they shall say. The prediotioii is thrown inw dramatic form. * See B. Jowett, " On the belief of the Comii^of OhiJSbJn tiie Apostolica! Age," in Commentary on the Epistles of Paid. Ch.V.] THB EIRST EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 45 Cometh upon (iiriararai). See L. xxi. 34, 36. Often in N. T. of aperson coming suddenly upon another ; as L. ii. 9 ; xxiv. 4 ; Acts iv. 1 ; xii. 7. Travail (mBlv). Birth-throe. Only here in its literal sense. Elsewhere as a strong figure of sorrow or pain. See Matt. xxiv. 8 ; Mk. xUi. 8 ; Acts ii. 24. For the figure in O. T. see Isa. xiii. 6-8 ; xxxvii. 3 ; Mic. iv. 9 ; Hos. xiii. 3 ; Jer. xiu. 21. Shall not escape (oi jirj iK^vycoaiv). A. V. misses the force of the double negative. They shall in no wise escape. 4. Overtake (KaraXd^trj) . See on comprehended, J. i. 5. A thief (KXeirrrj';). Tischendorf, Weiss, and Rev. T. retain this reading. Westcott and Hort read KXeirra<; thieves, but with KXeirrrj<; in margin. The weight of textual evidence is in favour of the singular. 5. Ye are all. In the text yap for should be inserted after irdvre'i all. Ye are not in darkness for ye are sons of light. Children of light (wtot (fxoro'i). More correctly, sons of Ught. See on Mk. iii. 17, and comp. L. xvi. 8 ; J. xii. 36 ; Eph. V. 8 ; Col. i. 12. The Christian condition is habitually associated in N. T. with light : see Matt. v. 14, 16 ; J. iii. 21 ; viii. 12 ; Acts xxvi. 18 ; 1 Pet. ii. 9 ; 1 J. i. 7. The contrary condition with darkness : see J. iii. 19, 20 ; Eph. v. 8 ; 1 Pet. U. 9 ; Matt. iv. 16 ; vi. 23, etc. Of the night — of darkness (j'wkto? — aKorovi). The genitive marks an advance of thought from iv aKorei in darkness, ver. 4. 'Ev indicates the element in which one is. The genitive, of darkness, points to nature and origin. To belong to darkness is more than to be in darkness. 6. Others (ot Xoiiroi). The rest, as ch. iv. 13. 46 WORD STUDLES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch.V. Let US watch (yprjyop&p^v). See on Mk. xiii. 35, and comp. Eph. V. 14. Be sober (vrj^wp.ev). Primarily in a physical sense, as opposed to excess in drink, but passing into the ethical sense of calm, collected, circumspect. Alert wakefulness and cahn assurance wiU prevent their being surprised and confused by the Lord's coming, as by a thief in the night. 7. Be drunken (fj.edvaK6p.evoi). Lit. who are made drunk or get drunk. See on J. ii. 10. In N. T. always of intoxi cation. In LXX, the Heb. shekar strong drink is several times rendered by p.edvapa ; Judg. xui. 4, 7; 1 Sam. i. 11, 15. 8. Putting on (ivBvadp.evoi). The son of day clothes himself for the day's work or battle. The same association of ideas as in vv. 6, 8, is found in Rom. xUi. 12-14 ; Apoc. xvi. 15 ; 1 Pet. i. 13. Comp. LXX, Bar. v. 2. Breastplate — helmet. Comp. Eph. vi. 14. The figures are not original with Paul. See Isa. Ux. 17 ; Wisd. v. 18, 19. Notice that only defensive armour is mentioned, in accordance with the darkness and uncertainty of the last time ; and that the fundamental elements of Christian char acter, faith, hope, and love, are brought forward again as in ch. i. 3 ; 1 Cor. xiii. 13. For the figure of the armed soldier, comp. also Rom. xiii. 12 ; 2 Cor. x. 4. 9. For (on). Special emphasis is laid on the hope of salvation. The exhortation to put it on is enforced by the fact that God's appointment is to salvation and not to wrath. To obtain (et? irepiiroirjaiv). More Uterally, unto the ob taining. See on Eph. i. 14. In three out of five instances in N. T. the word clearly means acquiring or obtaining. In Eph. i. 14 and 1 Pet. ii. 9, it is sometimes rendered possession (so Rev.). But in Ephesians the meaning is redemption or acquisition, or redemption which will give possession ; and in Ch.V.] the PIRST EPISTLB TO THE THESSALONIANS. 47 1st Peter a people for acquisition. The meaning here is that we might obtain. Comp. LXX, Mal. iii. 17. 10. Who died. Frequently the resurrection is coupled with the death of Christ by Paul, as ch. iv. 14 ; Philip, iii. 10 ; Col. ii. 12 ; iii. 1-4. Not so here ; but the thought of resurrection is supplied in live together with him. Wake or sleep. Whether we are alive or dead at Christ's appearing. Comp. Rom. xiv. 9. Yiadei)Beiv in N. T. always literaUy of sleep, except here, and possibly Eph. v. 14. In Mk. V. 39 ; L. viii. 52, it is contrasted with death. In LXX in the sense of death, Ps. Ixxxvii. 5 ; Dan. xii. 2 ; 2 Sam. vu. 12. 11. Comfort (irapaKaXelre). Rev. renders exhort; but ¦comfort suits better the general drift of the passage, and cor responds with ch. iv. 18. There is some force in Bome mann's suggestion that the two meanings may be combined. Exhort each other to be of good heart. Edify (o'lKoBopelre). Lit. build up. See on Acts xx. 32. The metaphorical sense habitually in Paul. See 1 Cor. viu. 1, 10 ; X. 23 ; xiv. 4 ; Eph. u. 20. In O. T. mostly in the literal sense. See however LXX, Ruth iv. 11 ; Ps. xxvii. 5 ; Ixxxviii. 2 ; Jer. xxxi. 4. 12. Know (elBevai). See on ch. iv. 4. Recognise them for what they are, and as entitled to respect because of their ofiice. Comp. iiriyivaaKere acknowledge, 1 Cor. xvi. 18 ; and iyvmadrji takest knowledge, LXX, Ps. cxliii. 3. Ignatius, Smyrn. ix., has iiriaKoirov elBevai to know the bishop, to appre ciate and honor him. Are over (irpoiarapevovs). Lit. who are placed before you. See on Rom. xii. 8. Used of superintendents of households, 1 Tim. iii. 4, 5, 12 : of the ruling of elders of the church, 1 Tim. V. 17. It does not indicate a particular ecclesiastical 48 WORD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch.V. office, but is used functionally. The ecclesiastical nomencla ture of the PauUne Epistles is unsettled, corresponding with the fact that the primitive church was not a homogeneous body throughout Christendom. The primitive Pauline church consisted of a number of separate fraternities which were self-governing. The recognition of those who ministered to the congregations depended on the free choice of their mem bers. See for instance 1 Cor. xvi. 15, 16. The congrega tion exercised discipline and gave judgment : 1 Cor. v. 3-5 ; 2 Cor. u. 6, 7 ; vu. 11, 12 ; Gal. vi. 1. Admonish (vovderovvra^). Only iu Acts and Paul. See on Acts XX. 31, and comp. ver. 14 ; Rom. xv. 14 ; 1 Cor. iv. 14 ; Col. i. 28. 13. Esteem (rjyeiadai). Primarily to lead, which is the only sense in the Gospels and Acts, except Acts xxvi. 2, in a speech of Paul. To lead the mind through a reasoning pro cess to a conclusion, and so to think, to estimate. Only in this sense by Paul, Peter, and James. See 2 Cor. ix. 5 ; PhUip. U. 3 ; Jas. i. 2 ; 2 Pet. iii. 9. In both senses in Hebrews. See X. 29 ; xiii. 7. Very highly in love. Const, very highly with esteem. In love qualifies both words.* For their work's sake (Bid rb epyov avr&v). Their esteem for their superintendents is not to rest only on personal attachment or respect for their position, but on inteUigent and sympathetic appreciation of their work. It is a good and much-needed lesson for the modern congregation no less than for the Thessalonian church- 14. Them that are unruly (tou? dTo'/ETow?). N. T.°. The A.V. is more vigorous and less stilted than Rev. disorderly. From a not and rdaaeiv draw up or arrange. Those who are * Others join in love with esteem as forming one conception ; but the phrase riyeiXoy6'i). Lit. in a fire of flame. Comp. 1 Cor. i. 13 ; 2 Pet. iii. 7. Taking vengeance (BiB6vro? eKBiKrjaiv). Lit. giving or rendering. Vengeance is an unfortunate rendering, as imply ing, in popular usage, personal vindictiveness. See on 2 Cor. vii. 11. It is the full awarding of justice to all parties. On them that know not God — obey not the gospel (rok prj elBoai debv — rol'i prj viraKoiiovaiv rip evayyeXim). To know God is to know him as the one, true God as distinguished 56 WORD STUDIES IN THB NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch.L from false gods ; to know his will, his hoUness, his hatred of sin, and his saving intent toward mankind. Two words are used of such knowledge, elBevai and yivmaKeiv. Both are appUed to the heathen and to Christians, and both are used of the Jews' knowledge of God. 'EiBevai, of heathen. Gal. iv. 8 ; 1 Th. iv. 5 ; 2 Th. i. 8. TivaaKeiv, of heathen, Rom. i. 21 ; 1 Cor. i. 21. 'EiBevai, of Christ and Christians, J. vii. 29 ; viU. 19, 55 ; xiv. 7. Tiv&aKeiv, of Christ and Christians, Gal. iv. 9 ; 1 J. u. 13, 14 ; iv. 6, 7, 8; J. x. 15 ; xvii. 3. In John, yiv&aKeiv of Jews who do not know the Father, J. xvi. 3 ; vui. 55 : eiBevai, J. vU. 28 ; vUi. 19 ; xv. 21. The two are combined, J. i. 26 ; vii. 27 ; viU. 55 ; 2 Cor. v. 16. A dis tinction is asserted between yivdtaKeiv as knowledge grounded in personal experience, apprehension of external impressions — and elBevai purely mental perception in contrast with con jecture or knowledge derived from others. There are doubt less passages which bear out this distinction (see on J. ii. 24), but it is impossible to carry it rigidly through the N. T. In the two classes, — those who know not God and those who obeyjiot the gospel, — it is not probable that Paul has in mind a distinction between Jews and Gentiles. The Jews were not ignorant of God, yet they are described by John as not knowing him. The Gentiles are described by Paul as knowing God, but as refusing to glorify him as God (Rom. i. 21). Paul rather describes here the subjects of God's judgment as one class, but under different aspects. 9. Shall be punished (BiKrjvriaovaiv). The verb (N. T.°) means to pay or render. Lit. shall pay penalty. Everlasting destruction (SXedpov alcoviov). The phrase nowhere else in N. T. In LXX, 4 Macc. x. 15. Rev. prop erly, eternal destruction. It is to be carefully noted that eternal and everlasting are not synonymous. See additional note at the end of this chapter. From the presence (aTro irpoadnrov). Or face. 'Airb from has simply the sense of separation. Not from the time of the Ch. I.] THB SECOND EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 57 Lord's appearing, nor by reason of the glory of his presence. Ylpoawirov is variously translated in A. V. Mostly /ace : also presence. Acts iii. 13, 19 ; v. 41 : person, Matt. xxii. 16 ; L. XX. 21 ; Gal. ii. 6 : appearance, 2 Cor. v. 12 ; x. 1 : fash ion, Jas. i. 11. The formula aTro irpoawirov or tou irpoawirov occurs Acts iii. 19 ; v. 41 ; vii. 45 ; Apoc. vi. 16 ; xii. 14 ; XX. 11. In LXX, Gen. ui. 8 ; iv. 14, 16 ; Ex. xiv. 25, and frequently. Glory of his power (Sofij? tij? t'o-^uo? avroD). For glory see on 1 Th. ii. 12. 'laxv? power, not often in Paul. It is indwelling power put forth or embodied, either aggressively or as an obstacle to resistance : physical power organised or working under individual direction. An army and a fortress are both iax^pb?. The power inhering in the magistrate, which is put forth in laws or judicial decisions, is iaxixi, and makes the edicts iax^pd valid and hard to resist. AvvapK is the indwelling power which comes to manifestation in laxb^- The precise phrase used here does not appear elsewhere in N. T. In LXX, Isa. U. 10, 19, 21. The power (BijyapK) and glory of God are associated in Matt. xxiv. 30 ; Mk. xiii. 26 ; L. xxi. 27 ; Apoc. iv. 11 ; xix. 1. Comp. Kpdroi tt)? So'^ij? avrov strength of his glory. Col. i. 11. 10. To be glorified (ivBo^aadfjvai). Only here and ver. 12 in N. T. Repeatedly in LXX. See Ex. xiv. 4, 17; Isa. xlv. 26. oClass. 11. Wherefore (et? 8). Better, to which end. Comp. Col. i. 29. The end is, " that ye may be counted worthy of the kingdom of God," ver. 5. The same thought is continued in ver. 11. Count — worthy (ct^iwajf). Comp. 1 Tim. v. 17; Heb. Ui. 3 ; X. 29. Your calling (tjj? KX'rjaewi). Including both the act and the end of the Christian calling. Comp. Philip, iii. 14; 1 Th. u. 12 ; Eph. iv. 1. 58 WORD STUDIES IN THB NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. I. All the good pleasure of his goodness (irdaav evBodav dyadwavvrji). Wrong. Paul does not mean all the goodness which God is pleased to bestow, but the delight of the Thessa lonians in goodness. He prays that God may perfect their pleasure in goodness. So Weizsacker, die Freude an allem Guten. The Rev. desire for eiiBoKiav is infelicitous, and lacks support. 'Ayadwavvrj goodness (P**. see on Rom. iU. 12) is never predicated of God in N. T. In LXX, see Neh. ix. 25, 35. 'EvSoKia good pleasure, delight, is a purely Biblical word. As related to one's self, it means contentment, satisfaction: see Sir. xxix. 23 ; Ps. of Sol. ui. 4 ; xvi. 12. As related to others, good will, benevolence. L. x. 21; Eph. i. 5, 9; Philip. i. 15 ; U. 13 ; Ps. of Sol. viU. 39. 12. The name (to ovopa). In no case where it is joined with Jesus, or Christ, or Lord Jesus, does it mean the title or dignity.* Paul follows O. T. usage, according to which the name of the Lord is often used for all that the name covers ; so that the name of the Lord = the Lord himself. Additional Note on oXedpov alwviov eternal destruction, 2 Th. I. 9. 'Akov, transliterated aeon, is a period of time of longer or shorter dura tion, having a beginning and an end, and complete in itself. Aristotle (¦Trepi mpavmi, i. 9, 15) says : " The period which includes the whole time of each one's life is called the aeon of each one." Hence it often means the life of a man, as in Homer, where one's life (aiw) is said to leave him or to consume away (II. v. 685 ; Od. v. 160). It is not, however, limited to human life; it signifies any period in the course of events, as the period or age before Christ; the period of the millennium; the mytho logical period before the beginnings of hi.story. The word has not " a stationary and mechanical value" (De Quincey). It does not mean a period of a fixed length for aU cases. There are as many aeons as entities, the respective durations of which are fixed by the normal conditions of the several entities. There is one aeon of a human life, another of the iife of a nation, another of a crow's life, another of an oak's life. The length of the aeon depends on the subject to which it is attached. * As Lightfoot on Philip, ii. 9. Ch. I.] THE SECOND EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 69 It is sometimes translated world; world representing a period or a series of periods of time. See Matt. xii. 32 ; xiii. 40, 49 ; L. i. 70 ; 1 Cor. i. 20; ii. 6 ; Eph. i; 21. Similarly ol aicSves the worlds, the universe, the aggregate of the ages or periods, and their contents which are included in the duration of the world. 1 Cor. ii. 7 ; x. 11 ; Heb. i. 2 ; ix. 26 ; xi. 3. The word always carries the notion of time, and not of eternity. It always means a period of time. Otherwise it would be impossible to account for the plural, or for such qualifying expressions as this age, or the age to come. It does not mean something endless or everlasting. To deduce that meaning from its relation to det is absurd ; for, apart frora the fact that the meaning of a word is not definitely fixed by its deriva tion, det does not signify endless duration. When the writer of the Pastoral Epistles quotes the saying ttat the Cretans are always (det) liars (Tit. i. 12), he surely does not mean that the Cretans will go on lying to all eternity. See also Acts vii. 51 ; 2 Cor. iv. 11 ; vi. 10 ; Heb. iii. 10 ; 1. Pet. - iii. 15. 'Aet means habitually or continuaUy within the limit of the subject's life. In our colloquial dialect everlastingly is used in the same way. " The boy is everlastingly tormenting me to buy him a drum." In the New Testament the history of the world is conceived as devel oped through a succession of aeons. A series of such aeons precedes the introduction of- a new series inaugurated by the Christian dispensation, and the end of the world and the second coming of Christ are to mark the beginning of another series. See Eph. iii. 11. Paul contemplates aeons before and after the Christian era. Eph. i. 21 ; ii. 7 ; iii. 9, 21 ; 1 Cor. X. 11 ; comp. Heb. ix. 26. He includes the series of aeons in one great aeon, 6 atciv tS)v alu>va>v the aeon ofthe aeons (Eph. iii. 21) ; and the author of the Epistle to the Hebrews describes the throne of God as enduring unto the aeon of the aeons (Heb. i. 8). The plural is also used, aeons of the aeons, signifying all the successive periods which make up the sum total of the ages collectively. Rom. xvi. 27; Gal. i. 5 ; Philip, iv. 20, etc. This plural phrase is applied by Paul to God only. The adjective aiiiivto; in like manner carries the idea of time. Neither the noun nor the adjective, in themselves, carry the sense of endless or everlasting. They may acquire that sense by their connotation, as, on the other hand, diSios, which means everlasting, has its meaning limited to a given point of time in Jude 6. 'Aiwioi means enduring through or pertain ing to a period of time. Both the noun and the adjective are applied to limited periods. Thus the phrase eis tov alwva, habitually rendered for ever, is often used of duration which is limited in the very nature of the case. See, for a few out of many instances, LXX, Ex. xxi. 6 ; xxix. 9 ; xxxii. 13 ; Josh. xiv. 9 ; 1 Sam. viii. 13 ; Lev. xxv. 46 ; Deut. xv. 17 ; 1 Chron. xxviii. 4. See also Matt. xxi. 19 ; J. xiii. 8 ; 1 Cor. viii. 13. The same is true of aiiavioi. Out of 150 instances in LXX, four-fifths imply limited duration. For a few instances see Gen. xlviii. 4; Num. x. 8; XV. 15 ; Prov. xxii. 28 ; Jonah ii. 6 ; Hab. iii. 6 ; Isa. Lxi. 17. Words which are habitually applied to things temporal or material can- 60 WOBD STUDIES IN THE NBW TESTAMENT. [Ch. L not carry in theraselves the sense of endlessness. Even when applied to God, we are not forced to render attovtos everlasting. Of course the life of God is endless ; but the question is whether, in describing God as atmvtos, it was intended to describe the duration of his being, or whether some different and larger idea was not contemplated. That God lives longer than men, and lives on everlastingly, and has lived everlastingly, are, no doubt, great and significant facts ; yet they are not the dominant or the most impressive facts in God's relations to time. God's eternity does not stand merely or chiefly for a scale of length. It is not primarily a mathe matical but a moral fact. The relations of God to time include and imply far more than the bare fact of endless continuance. They carry with them the fact that God transcends time ; works on different principles and on a vaster scale than the wisdom of time provides ; oversteps the conditions and the motives of time ; marshals the successive aeons from a point ouf> side of time, on lines which run out into his own measureless cycles,, and for sublime moral ends which the creature of threescore and ten years cannot grasp and does not even suspect. There is a word for everlasting if that idea is demanded. That dtSios occurs rarely in the New Testament and in LXX does not prove that its place was taken by alwuy;. It rather goes to show that less importance was attached to the bare idea of everlastingness than later theological thought has given it. Paul uses the word once, in Rom. i. 20, where he speaks of " the everlasting power and divinity of God." In Rom. xvi. 26 he speaks of the eternal God (rav alamiav O^ov) ; but that he does not raean the everlasting God is perfectly clear from the context. He has said that " the mystery " has been kept in silence in times eternal (xpovoi^ almviov;), by which he does not mean everlasting times, but the successive aeons which elapsed before Christ was proclaimed. God therefore is described as the God ofthe aeons, the God who pervaded and controUed those periods before the incarnation. To the same effect is the title o /8ao-tXeus t£v aldn/iisv the King of ihe aeons, applied to God in 1 Tim. i. 17 ; Apoc. xv. 3 ; comp. Tob. xiii. 6, 10. The phrase irpo xpovm/ altoviuyv before eternal times (2 Tim. i. 9 ; Tit. i. 2), cannot mean before everlasting times. To say that God bestowed grace on men, or promised them eternal life before endless times, would be absurd. The meaning is of old, as L. i. 70. The grace and the promise were given in time, but far back in the ages, before the times of reckoning the aeons. Zwij alutvioi eternal life, which occurs 42 times in N. T., but not in LXX, is not endless life, but life pertaining to a certain age or aeon, or continuing during that aeon. I repeat, life may be endless. The life in union with Christ is endless, but the fact is not expressed by atuvtos. Ko- Aao-is alivuK, rendered everlasting punishment (Matt. xxv. 46), is the pun ishment peculiar to an aeon other than that in which Christ is speaking. In some cases Ifinj alutvuK does not refer specificaUy to the Ufe beyond time, but rather to the aeon or dispensation of Messiah which succeeds the legal dispensation. See Matt. xix. 16 ; J. v. 39. John says that ^tmj oIwuk is Ch. I.] THE SECOND EPISTLE TO THE THESSALONIANS. 61 the present possession of those who believe on the Son of God, J. iii. 36 ; V. 24; vi. 47, 54. The Father's commandment is ^wrj atwvtos, J. xii. 50; to know the only true God and Jesus Christ is ^wrj aitavioi, J. xvii. 3. Bishop Westcott very justly says, commenting upon the terms used by John to describe life under different aspects : ." In considering these phrases it is necessary to premise that in spiritual things we must guard against all conclusions which rest upon the notions of succession and duration. ' Eternal life ' is that whieh St. Paul speaks of as 17 ovrais ^mj ihe life which is life indeed, and ¦}) ^unj tov Oeov the life of God. It is not an end less dm'ation of being in time, but being of which time is not a measure. We have indeed no powers to grasp the idea except through forms and images of sense. These must be used, but we must not transfer them as realities to another order." * Thus, while aldtvio's carries the idea of time, though not of endlessness, there belongs to it also, more or less, a sense of quality. Its character is ethical rather than mathematical. The deepest significance of the Ufe beyond time lies, not in endlessness, but in the moral quality of the aeon into which the Ufe passes. It is comparatively unimportant whether or not, the rich fool, when his soul was required of him (L. xii. 20), entered upon a state that was endless. The principal, the tremendous fact, as Christ unmistakably puts it, was that, in the new aeon, the motives, the aims, the conditions, the successes and awards of time counted for nothing. In time, his barns and their contents were everytMng; the soul was nothing. In the new Ufe the soul was first and everything, and the barns and storehouses nothing. The bliss of the sanctified does not consist pri marily in its endlessness, but in the nobler moral conditions of the new aeon, — the years of the holy and eternal God. Duration is a secondary idea. When it enters it enters as an accompaniment and outgrowth of moral conditions. In the present passage it is urged that oXeOpov destruction points to an unchangeable, irremediable, and endless condition. If this be true, if oXeOpos is extinction, then the passage teaches the annihilation of the wicked, in which case the adjective attuvtos is superfluous, since extinction is flnal, and excludes the idea of duration. But oXedpos does not always mean destruction or extinction. Take the kindred verb airoXXvpi to destroy, pui an end to, or in the middle voice, to be lost, to perish. Peter says, " the world being deluged with water, perished " (aTriHiXero, 2 Pet. iii. 6) ; but the world did not become extinct, it was renewed. In Heb. i. 11, 12, quoted from Ps. cii., we read concerning the heavens and the earth as compared with the eternity of God, "they shall perish" (dTroXoSvTat). But the perishing is only preparatory to change and renewal. " They shall be changed " (dXAay^o-ovrai). Comp. Isa. li. 6, 16 ; Ixv. 17; Ixvi. 22 ; 2 Pet. iii. 13 ; Apoc. xxi. 1. Similarly, " the Son of man came to save that which was lost " (d7roA.(«Aos), L. xix. 10. Jesus charged his apostles to go * The Epistles of St, John, p. 205. 62 WOBD STUDIES IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. [Ch. H to the lost (a-TToXaXoTo) sheep of the house of Israel, Matt. x. 6, comp. XV. 24. " He that shall lose (a-TroXearf) his life for my sake shaU find it," Matt. xvi. 25. Comp. L. xv. 6, 9, 82.' In this passage the word destruction is quaUfied. It is "destruction from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power," at his second coming, in the new aeon. In other words, it is the severance, at a given point of time, of those who obey not the gospel from the presence and the glory of Christ. 'Atoii/tos may therefore describe this severance as continuing during the millennial aeon between Christ's coming and the final judgment ; as being for the wicked prolonged throughout that aeon and characteristic of it, — or it may describe the severance as characteris ing or enduring through a period or aeon succeeding the final judgment, the extent of which period is not defined. In neither case is oimvuK to be interpreted as everlasting or endless. CHAPTER IL 1. By the coming (i/Tre/o). More correctly touching. Comp. Rom. ix. 27; 2 Cor. i. 8. 'Tirep never inN. T. in a formula of swearing. Gathering together (iiriawaywyrji). Only here and Heb. X. 25. The verb iiriavvdyeiv is used, as the noun here, of the Lord's gathering together his elect at his coming. See Matt. xxiv. 31; Mk. xiii. 27; comp. 2 Macc. U. 7. 2. Shaken (aaXevd-tjvai). From adXo'i the tossing or swell of the sea. See L. xxi. 25. Comp. Matt. xi. 7; xxiv. 29; Acts iv. 31; Heb. xU. 26. In mind (dirb rov vob'i). More correctly, /rom your mind. Nov? signifies the judgment, sober sense. Comp. 1 Cor. xiv. 15, and see on Rom. vii. 23. They are to " keep their heads " under the temptation to fanatical extravagances concerning the Lord's appearing. Be troubled (dpoeladai). From dpo